dwc - Highly Commended - InternuntiaArmstrong Foundation (cancer research), or the ‘Make Poverty...

3
1. INTRODUCTION In January 2007 a poll carried out by the British Medical Journal found that sanitation was the greatest medical milestone of the last century and a half. 1 Although enhanced sanitation and hygiene methods and facilities have improved and saved the lives of millions in the developed world, many in the developing world have not benefited from such advances. 1.9 million children will die from diarrhoeal related diseases (e.g. cholera, dysentery and typhoid) this year. 2 Of the all the child deaths in the world 18% of them are due to diarrhoeal diseases. 3 Inadequate and unsafe water, poor sanitation, and unsafe hygiene practices are the main causes of diarrhea. Intestinal worms infect about 10% of the population of the developing world. Intestinal parasitic infections can lead to malnutrition, anaemia and stunted growth. 4 There is also emerging evidence linking better hand-washing practices with reduced incidence of acute respiratory infections. 2 Traditionally, resources have been focused on water supply, but now providers have realised that a holistic approach is needed, integrating water supply, improved sanitation and improved hygiene. Research has shown that improved water quality alone can reduce incidences of childhood diarrhoea by 15-20%, the safe disposal of children’s faeces leads to a reduction of nearly 40% and better hygiene through hand washing and safe food handling reduces it by 35%. 5 During the UNICEF/IRC roundtable meeting of experts and decision makers in Oxford in 2005 it was noted that: ‘Interventions that focus on improving hygiene practices seem to have the greatest impact’ 6 Good hygiene practices are simple and you don’t have to understand germ theory to implement them and save lives. Experience from UNICEF has shown that informed and motivated children are powerful advocates for improved hygiene in the home. 2 Children are the people most at risk but are also the most powerful advocates for improved hygiene. This proposal suggests a simple plan to help educate and motivate children in improved hygiene. Could educating and motivating children to improve hygiene practice become one of the medical milestones of the 21 st century? 2. THE IDEA There is a need to educate children in good hygiene practices. A key to success is to make this exciting for children, something that will engage them. In recent years the rubber, charity wrist band has been used to raise money and awareness for a range of charities. At its peak a majority of young people were wearing a wrist band supporting some cause or another. Examples are the yellow ‘Livestrong’ wrist band which raises money for the Lance Armstrong Foundation (cancer research), or the ‘Make Poverty History’ white band. These wrist bands became a meaningful but sought-after and fashionable accessory. We propose to use the wrist band concept primarily to educate and motivate children in the developing world in good hygiene practice and as a spin off idea, to raise awareness and funds in the UK by selling them to the general public. The basis of the idea is that the WaterAid Bands will have four very distinct symbols representing four key, basic hygiene messages. Children in countries where this is introduced will be given the opportunity to learn what each symbol stands for. When a child can recognise the symbols and memorise and demonstrate practice of the four messages they will be given a WaterAid Band. This idea is based on the grounds that the WaterAid Bands will be highly attractive to children, they will want one and do what is required to get one. Moreover, ‘earning’ a WaterAid Band through the demonstration of key understandings and skills will help instil the concept that hygiene knowledge and practice is important and has value. The WaterAid Bands will have four very simple symbols (see below). Associated with each symbol will be a key hygiene practise (see below). These hygiene messages are transferable across gender, culture, religion and language. Handwashing with soap and water after going to the toilet and before eating. Wearing shoes in latrines. Washing face and hands regularly with clean water. Using a sanitary latrine instead of going to the toilet in the bush. The bands are aimed predominantly at children, as these are the people most at risk from diarrhoeal diseases, but that is not the only reason. As stated in the introduction children are powerful advocates of improved hygiene. Children are generally sociable and come into contact with many people and across cultural and gender boundaries. Not only will the children learn life-saving hygiene practices for themselves but, on earning the WaterAid Band, they will be told that they are now advocates for good hygiene and should be encouraged to tell others what the symbols mean and to look out for others practicing them. Traditionally hygiene education has come in the form of organised set times for learning in schools and community groups. One of the advantages of the WaterAid Band concept is that this education can take place informally - anywhere kids are playing with each other, walking to the shops or at home – reaching even those children who may not be enrolled in formal schooling. Anywhere the child goes there is an opportunity to pass on the message of good hygiene practice with these highly portable and durable WaterAid Bands. This concept reinvents the approach to hygiene education, takes it out of class rooms and into everyday lives. The bands are hard-wearing, waterproof and can be worn at all times. They are also rubber and non-absorbent, so are no more unhygienic than human skin. Another important advantage is that illiteracy is not a barrier to learning through this process – the symbols will be simple and easily recognisable. The symbols are also transferable to urban settings and rural settings, as well as not being restricted by language. Although hygiene and sanitation practices are specific to particular contexts, the core principles represented on the WaterAid Bands are relevant to the majority of developing countries. 3. Project Implementation Our idea is for the educational wristbands to form the incentive for children to learn about safe personal hygiene practices. The field-level implementation of this project is extremely important if the potential impact of the WaterAid Bands is to be maximised. One of the benefits of our idea is its simplicity and therefore how transferable it is as it can be applied within many different contexts. However, we believe, for the bands to be fully effective one must ensure a number of practices are in place. One of the important features of our proposal is the target audience for the scheme is children. Previous hygiene education studies have focused on educating the mothers and measuring the outcome in children. 7 However, given that children are the population group most at risk from poor hygiene practices, and their potential as powerful drivers for change, we believe a scheme aiming hygiene education at children would be very effective. We propose that the bands will only be distributed to children once they have completed a relevant curriculum. This is to ensure that the message the bands are putting across is fully understood before they are handed out. It is envisaged that the bands would act as both a prize for demonstrating commitment and understanding of the knowledge and skills within the curriculum as well as an incentive for other children to seek out the knowledge and complete the course. The exact make-up of the syllabus will be dependent on the location of the project, with it being possible to tailor it to suit the specific issues of the area. Because of this the project can be implemented in both rural and urban settings and is not restricted by religious/cultural sensitivities. Another exciting aspect of our proposal is that it enables and encourages pier-to-pier learning amongst children. Various studies have been undertaken that highlight the effectiveness of carefully implemented pier-pier learning, as children are far more receptive to new ideas if they are delivered out side formal educational settings and when disseminated by their contemporaries. 8 Once the bands have been distributed to children who have completed the course, other children will enquire how they got them and the main messages of the hygiene education course will be passed on. The scheme could even be set up to reward children who can prove they are carrying out the things they have learned (perhaps by showing clean hands or keeping a diary) or have encouraged other children to join the programme. This reward may consist of an additional band to indicate that the child has achieved the next level. Again, once a child has received an additional band, this will encourage other children to follow suit and develop their knowledge of hygiene education. As with all development projects, family and community involvement is a key driver in ensuring the success and sustainability of the scheme. The benefit of our proposal is that it does not require expensive materials or huge numbers of foreign development workers to ensure its success. The syllabus can be prepared, using a modification of a generic document, to make it specific for each community. This can be achieved by consulting with the relevant community leaders and asking them how they believe sanitation/hygiene can be improved within their community. This ensures the community feels ownership of the project and addresses their specific needs. 4. Pilot Scheme In order to determine the effectiveness, and determine the most suitable implementation techniques of our proposal, a pilot scheme could be set up. This could take the form of trial bands being made up and the project being implemented as previously described. It could be trialed in both an urban and rural settings and at this stage the different requirements for the core syllabuses could be assessed. Once the scheme has been in operation for a set period of time the incidences of diarrhoea and other water borne disease could be compared with the pre-project levels. The comparison of this data could then be used, along with monitoring and evaluation studies on the implementation techniques used in the pilots, to form a set of best practice guidelines for the implementation of the project on a lager scale. 5. Project Development The main focus of this proposal, effective hygiene education for children, can be developed further to broaden the scope of the project. One way of doing this would be to introduce additional bands to recognise different levels of hygiene education. An example of this is to introduce a band highlighting important aspects of family hygiene, for example: Keeping water pots covered when they are not in use. Going to the toilet at a safe distance from water sources that are used for drinking, cooking or other household purposes. Washing fruit and vegetables before cutting, keeping cooked food covered and utensils off the ground. This could be followed by a band to recognise the wearer has completed a further course in the importance of community hygiene. The award of these bands would be similar to the first wristband but could also be dependent on the children demonstrating they have passed on the information they have learnt. For example, for children to achieve the community wristband they would have to become a ‘community hygiene officer’ responsible for promoting safe hygiene practices within their communities. Examples of key community hygiene issues are: drinking water from protected sources like handpumps or protected wells, rather than rivers or ponds. Ensuring animals are kept away from houses, water sources and latrines. Making drainage channels or soakpits to take wastewater away from wells and homes. Another aspect of the scheme that could be developed is to use the bands for fund raising within the UK. This could take the form of WaterAid selling the bands on their website. 6. The case study This case study looks at the implementation of a hygiene programme in post war Afghanistan. 9 In 2001 the Ministry of Public Health (MoPH) estimated that more than 50% of hospital beds were occupied by patients suffering from waterborne and related diseases. There were no sewerage systems in any cities, even in the capital Kabul. Public awareness about hygiene was low. Before the 1980s, hygiene education was in the school curriculum, and government programmes included health education in all clinics, hospitals and in other gathering places. Health inspectors regularly visited schools, and were responsible for hygiene messages. Literacy was low in rural areas, but higher than today’s literacy rates in urban areas (literacy in men 46% in women 16%). In 2001 the problems identified were high levels of diarrhoeal disease, provision of water and sanitation without good information on their use, little information on existing hygiene education materials and delivery. There was also a lack of consensus (and potential confusion) on the best messages for good hygiene in Afghanistan. The policy for hygiene education included basic messages, produced through a consultative process and aimed at programme planners and managers in the water, health, education and community development sectors, in both urban and rural areas. The hygiene messages would focus narrowly on the prevention of oral-faecal transmission of disease, and on the promotion of a few (rather than many) healthy behaviours consistent with local custom. Afghanistan is an Islamic country in which the law of Islam is applicable in all daily private and public activities. In Islam, hygiene is an important religious obligation. Religious leaders in Afghanistan support hygiene messages and have a crucial role in educating and leading changes to improve health and hygiene practices. Important gender issues identified were that women are the main hygiene educators in the family and that female educators are needed to reach women in the community. It was also found that men and women have highly segregated lives. Children can mix up to the age of about 9, after which girls and boys are segregated. Therefore identifying segregated channels for communicating hygiene messages is vital in this situation. It was concluded that all hygiene programmes in Afghanistan should plan for men to pass messages to men and boys, and women to pass messages to women and girls (our concept would work in the opposite direction, getting girls to educate women and boys men). There was also a lack of trained personnel and in this situation and joint coordinated action is vital. WaterAid Band Potential in Afghanistan As literacy is low in rural and urban Afghanistan the WaterAid Band, with four messages would be an effective method of passing on basic hygiene messages as simple symbols are used. In Afghanistan literacy is especially low amongst females, this further emphasis the need for symbols as women are the predominant communicators of good hygiene practice. The idea is that once somebody learns what the symbols stand for, they do not need any literature and they can carry this message around with them wherever they go (play, school, home) and pass on the message to their peers and others. Their friends will ask ‘what is the band for and how do I get one’. In Afghanistan hygiene education was focused on adults, our concept proposes using children as the main channel for passing on the message of hygiene. Children up to a certain age can cross many of the barriers that we put in place that may hinder communication e.g. gender, religious, cultural. As children come into contact with many different types of people and are generally sociable they are in a good position to pass on hygiene messages. It was identified that resources were low for trainers in Afghanistan. Using children and the wrist bands is a very low cost way to spread the messages of good hygiene practices across whole communities. The case study found that using the existing religious authorities was a good way of integrating hygiene messages. The WaterAid Band Project could be introduced in the places where people gather and from places that people respect, depending on the location. The key to the wrist bands is that it is simple. There are only four basic messages with symbols representing simple practices. This can be implemented quickly and may therefore also be of use in emergency relief situations, when hygiene conditions can be extremely poor. (Endnotes) 1 Sarah Boseley. (2006) Sanitation rated the greatest medical advance in 150 years, The Guardian, 19/01/2007. 2 UNICEF water, sanitation and hygiene strategies for 2006-2015, Economic and Social Council/UNICEF, 23/01/2006. 3 Rehydration Project [Internet] Available From: <http://rehydrate.org/diarrhoea/index.html> [Accessed 21/01/2007]. 4 WaterAid Statistics [Internet] Available From: <www.wateraid.org.uk/uk/what_we_do/statistics/default.asp> [Accessed 21/01/2007]. 5 Esrey, S.A., Potash, J.B., Roberts, L., Shiff, C. Effects of improved water supply and sanitation on ascariasis, diarrhoea, dracunculiasis, hookworm infection, schistosomiasis, and trachoma. Bull. WHO 69(5): 609-621. 1991. 6 UNICEF/IRC Roundtable Meeting on Water, Sanitation and Hygiene Education for Schools. 2005. Oxford. pp. 9. 7 Fewtrell, Kaufmann, Kay et al, Water, sanitation, and hygiene interventions to reduce diarrhoea in less developed countries: a systematic review and meta-analysis, The Lancet, Vol. 5, Jan 2005. 8 Peer Education and HIV/AIDS: Concepts, uses and challenges (1999, UNICEF) 9 Hygiene Education for Afganistan – People and systems for water, sanitation and health, Eng S Najibullah Masoumyar, Dr A G Dost, N Ruck and Dr K Wilson, WEDEC (27 th WEDEC Conference), 2001.

Transcript of dwc - Highly Commended - InternuntiaArmstrong Foundation (cancer research), or the ‘Make Poverty...

Page 1: dwc - Highly Commended - InternuntiaArmstrong Foundation (cancer research), or the ‘Make Poverty History’ white band. These wrist bands became a meaningful but sought-after and

1. INTRODUCTION

In January 2007 a poll carried out by the British Medical Journal found that sanitation was the greatest medical milestone of the last century and a half.1

Although enhanced sanitation and hygiene methods and facilities have improved and saved the lives of millions in the developed world, many in the developing world have not benefited from such advances.

1.9 million children will die from diarrhoeal related diseases (e.g. cholera, dysentery and typhoid) this year.2 Of the all the child deaths in the world 18% of them are due to diarrhoeal diseases.3 Inadequate and unsafe water, poor sanitation, and unsafe hygiene practices are the main causes of diarrhea.

Intestinal worms infect about 10% of the population of the developing world. Intestinal parasitic infections can lead to malnutrition, anaemia and stunted growth.4 There is also emerging evidence linking better hand-washing practices with reduced incidence of acute respiratory infections.2

Traditionally, resources have been focused on water supply, but now providers have realised that a holistic approach is needed, integrating water supply, improved sanitation and improved hygiene.

Research has shown that improved water quality alone can reduce incidences of childhood diarrhoea by 15-20%, the safe disposal of children’s faeces leads to a reduction of nearly 40% and better hygiene through hand washing and safe food handling reduces it by 35%.5 During the UNICEF/IRC roundtable meeting of experts and decision makers in Oxford in 2005 it was noted that:

‘Interventions that focus on improving hygiene practices seem to have the greatest impact’6

Good hygiene practices are simple and you don’t have to understand germ theory to implement them and save lives.

Experience from UNICEF has shown that informed and motivated children are powerful advocates for improved hygiene in the home.2

Children are the people most at risk but are also the most powerful advocates for improved hygiene.

This proposal suggests a simple plan to help educate and motivate children in improved hygiene.

Could educating and motivating children to improve hygiene practice become one of the medical milestones of the 21st century?

2. THE IDEA

There is a need to educate children in good hygiene practices. A key to success is to make this exciting for children, something that will engage them.

In recent years the rubber, charity wrist band has been used to raise money and awareness for a range of charities. At its peak a majority of young people were wearing a wrist band supporting some cause or another. Examples are the yellow ‘Livestrong’ wrist band which raises money for the Lance Armstrong Foundation (cancer research), or the ‘Make Poverty History’ white band. These wrist bands became a meaningful but sought-after and fashionable accessory.

We propose to use the wrist band concept primarily to educate and motivate children in the developing world in good hygiene practice and as a spin off idea, to raise awareness and funds in the UK by selling them to the general public.

The basis of the idea is that the WaterAid Bands will have four very distinct symbols representing four key, basic hygiene messages. Children in countries where this is introduced will be given the opportunity to learn what each symbol stands for. When a child can recognise the symbols and memorise and demonstrate practice of the four messages they will be given a WaterAid Band. This idea is based on the grounds that the WaterAid Bands will be highly attractive to children, they will want one and do what is required to get one. Moreover, ‘earning’ a WaterAid Band through the demonstration of key understandings and skills will help instil the concept that hygiene knowledge and practice is important and has value.

The WaterAid Bands will have four very simple symbols (see below). Associated with each symbol will be a key hygiene practise (see below). These hygiene messages are transferable across gender, culture, religion and language.

• Handwashing with soap and water after going to the toilet and before eating.

• Wearing shoes in latrines.

• Washing face and hands regularly with clean water.

• Using a sanitary latrine instead of going to the toilet in the bush.

The bands are aimed predominantly at children, as these are the people most at risk from diarrhoeal diseases, but that is not the only reason. As stated in the introduction children are powerful advocates of improved hygiene. Children are generally sociable and come into contact with many people and across cultural and gender boundaries. Not only will the children learn life-saving hygiene practices for themselves but, on earning the WaterAid Band, they will be told that they are now advocates for good hygiene and should be encouraged to tell others what the symbols mean and to look out for others practicing them.

Traditionally hygiene education has come in the form of organised set times for learning in schools and community groups. One of the advantages of the WaterAid Band concept is that this education can take place informally - anywhere kids are playing with each other, walking to the shops or at home – reaching even those children who may not be enrolled in formal schooling. Anywhere the child goes there is an opportunity to pass on the message of good hygiene practice with these highly portable

and durable WaterAid Bands. This concept reinvents the approach to hygiene education, takes it out of class rooms and into everyday lives. The bands are hard-wearing, waterproof and can be worn at all times. They are also rubber and non-absorbent, so are no more unhygienic than human skin.

Another important advantage is that illiteracy is not a barrier to learning through this process – the symbols will be simple and easily recognisable. The symbols are also transferable to urban settings and rural settings, as well as not being restricted by language. Although hygiene and sanitation practices are specific to particular contexts, the core principles represented on the WaterAid Bands are relevant to the majority of developing countries.

3. Project Implementation

Our idea is for the educational wristbands to form the incentive for children to learn about safe personal hygiene practices.

The field-level implementation of this project is extremely important if the potential impact of the WaterAid Bands is to be maximised. One of the benefits of our idea is its simplicity and therefore how transferable it is as it can be applied within many different contexts. However, we believe, for the bands to be fully effective one must ensure a number of practices are in place.

One of the important features of our proposal is the target audience for the scheme is children. Previous hygiene education studies have focused on educating the mothers and measuring the outcome in children.7 However, given that children are the population group most at risk from poor hygiene practices, and their potential as powerful drivers for change, we believe a scheme aiming hygiene education at children would be very effective.

We propose that the bands will only be distributed to children once they have completed a relevant curriculum. This is to ensure that the message the bands are putting across is fully understood before they are handed out. It is envisaged that the bands would act as both a prize for demonstrating commitment and understanding of the knowledge and skills within the curriculum as well as an incentive for other children to seek out the knowledge and complete the course. The exact make-up of the syllabus will be dependent on the location of the project, with it being possible to

tailor it to suit the specific issues of the area. Because of this the project can be implemented in both rural and urban settings and is not restricted by religious/cultural sensitivities.

Another exciting aspect of our proposal is that it enables and encourages pier-to-pier learning amongst children. Various studies have been undertaken that highlight the effectiveness of carefully implemented pier-pier learning, as children are far more receptive to new ideas if they are delivered out side formal educational settings and when disseminated by their contemporaries.8 Once the bands have been distributed to children who have completed the course, other children will enquire how they got them and the main messages of the hygiene education course will be passed on. The scheme could even be set up to reward children who can prove they are carrying out the things they have learned (perhaps by showing clean hands or keeping a diary) or have encouraged other children to join the programme. This reward may consist of an additional band to indicate that the child has achieved the next level. Again, once a child has received an additional band, this will encourage other children to follow suit and develop their knowledge of hygiene education.

As with all development projects, family and community involvement is a key driver in ensuring the

success and sustainability of the scheme. The benefit of our proposal is that it does not require expensive materials or huge numbers of foreign development workers to ensure its success. The syllabus can be prepared, using a modification of a generic document, to make it specific for each community. This can be achieved by consulting with the relevant community leaders and asking them how they believe sanitation/hygiene can be improved within their community. This ensures the community feels ownership of the project and addresses their specific needs.

4. Pilot Scheme

In order to determine the effectiveness, and determine the most suitable implementation techniques of our proposal, a pilot scheme could be set up. This could take the form of trial bands being made up and the project being implemented as previously described. It could be trialed in both an urban and rural settings and at this stage the different requirements for the core syllabuses could be assessed. Once the scheme has been in operation for a set period of time the incidences of diarrhoea and other water borne disease could be compared with the pre-project levels. The comparison of this data could then be used, along with monitoring and evaluation studies on the implementation techniques used in the pilots, to form a set of best practice guidelines for the implementation of the project on a lager scale.

5. Project Development

The main focus of this proposal, effective hygiene education for children, can be developed further to broaden the scope of the project. One way of doing this would be to introduce additional bands to

recognise different levels of hygiene education. An example of this is to introduce a band highlighting important aspects of family hygiene, for example:

• Keeping water pots covered when they are not in use.

• Going to the toilet at a safe distance from water sources that are used for drinking, cooking or other household purposes.

• Washing fruit and vegetables before cutting, keeping cooked food covered and utensils off the ground.

This could be followed by a band to recognise the wearer has completed a further course in the importance of community hygiene. The award of these bands would be similar to the first wristband but could also be dependent on the children demonstrating they have passed on the information they

have learnt. For example, for children to achieve the community wristband they would have to become a ‘community hygiene officer’responsible for promoting safe hygiene practices within their communities. Examples of key community hygiene issues are:

• drinking water from protected sources like handpumps or protected wells, rather than rivers or ponds.

• Ensuring animals are kept away from houses, water sources and latrines.

• Making drainage channels or soakpits to take wastewater away from wells and homes.

Another aspect of the scheme that could be developed is to use the bands for fund raising within the UK. This could take the form of WaterAid selling the bands on their website.

6. The case study

This case study looks at the implementation of a hygiene programme in post war Afghanistan.9

In 2001 the Ministry of Public Health (MoPH) estimated that more than 50% of hospital beds were occupied by patients suffering from waterborne and related diseases. There were no sewerage systems in any cities, even in the capital Kabul. Public awareness about hygiene was low.

Before the 1980s, hygiene education was in the school curriculum, and government programmes included health education in all clinics, hospitals and in other gathering places. Health inspectors regularly visited schools, and were responsible for hygiene messages. Literacy was low in rural areas, but higher than today’s literacy rates in urban areas (literacy in men 46% in women 16%).

In 2001 the problems identified were high levels of diarrhoeal disease, provision of water and sanitation without good information on their use, little information on existing hygiene education materials and delivery. There was also a lack of consensus (and potential confusion) on the best messages for good hygiene in Afghanistan.

The policy for hygiene education included basic messages, produced through a consultative process and aimed at programme planners and managers in the water, health, education and community development sectors, in both urban and rural areas. The hygiene messages would focus narrowly on the prevention of oral-faecal transmission of disease, and on the promotion of a few (rather than many) healthy behaviours consistent with local custom.

Afghanistan is an Islamic country in which the law of Islam is applicable in all daily private and public activities. In Islam, hygiene is an important religious obligation. Religious leaders in Afghanistan support hygiene messages and have a crucial role in educating and leading changes to improve health and hygiene practices.

Important gender issues identified were that women are the main hygiene educators in the family and that female educators are needed to reach women in the community. It was also found that men and women have highly segregated lives. Children can mix up to the age of about 9, after which girls and boys are segregated. Therefore identifying segregated channels for communicating hygiene messages is vital in this situation.

It was concluded that all hygiene programmes in Afghanistan should plan for men to pass messages to men and boys, and women to pass messages to women and girls (our concept would work in the opposite direction, getting girls to educate women and boys men). There was also a lack of trained personnel and in this situation and joint coordinated action is vital.

WaterAid Band Potential in Afghanistan

As literacy is low in rural and urban Afghanistan the WaterAid Band, with four messages would be an effective method of passing on basic hygiene messages as simple symbols are used. In Afghanistan literacy is especially low amongst females, this further emphasis the need for symbols as women are the predominant communicators of good hygiene practice.

The idea is that once somebody learns what the symbols stand for, they do not need any literature and they can carry this message around with them wherever they go (play, school, home) and pass on the message to their peers and others. Their friends will ask ‘what is the band for and how do I get one’.

In Afghanistan hygiene education was focused on adults, our concept proposes using children as the main channel for passing on the message of hygiene. Children up to a certain age can cross many of the barriers that we put in place that may hinder communication e.g. gender, religious, cultural. As children come into contact with many different types of people and are generally sociable they are in a good position to pass on hygiene messages.

It was identified that resources were low for trainers in Afghanistan. Using children and the wrist bands is a very low cost way to spread the messages of good hygiene practices across whole communities.

The case study found that using the existing religious authorities was a good way of integrating hygiene messages. The WaterAid Band Project could be introduced in the places where people gather and from places that people respect, depending on the location.

The key to the wrist bands is that it is simple. There are only four basic messages with symbols representing simple practices. This can be implemented quickly and may therefore also be of use in emergency relief situations, when hygiene conditions can be extremely poor.

(Endnotes)1 Sarah Boseley. (2006) Sanitation rated the greatest medical advance in 150 years, The Guardian, 19/01/2007. 2 UNICEF water, sanitation and hygiene strategies for 2006-2015, Economic and Social Council/UNICEF, 23/01/2006. 3 Rehydration Project [Internet] Available From: <http://rehydrate.org/diarrhoea/index.html> [Accessed 21/01/2007]. 4 WaterAid Statistics [Internet] Available From:

<www.wateraid.org.uk/uk/what_we_do/statistics/default.asp> [Accessed 21/01/2007]. 5 Esrey, S.A., Potash, J.B., Roberts, L., Shiff, C. Effects of improved water supply and sanitation on ascariasis, diarrhoea, dracunculiasis, hookworm infection, schistosomiasis, and trachoma. Bull. WHO 69(5): 609-621. 1991. 6 UNICEF/IRC Roundtable Meeting on Water, Sanitation and Hygiene Education for Schools. 2005. Oxford. pp. 9. 7 Fewtrell, Kaufmann, Kay et al, Water, sanitation, and hygiene interventions to reduce diarrhoea in less developed countries: a systematic review and meta-analysis, The Lancet, Vol. 5, Jan 2005. 8 Peer Education and HIV/AIDS: Concepts, uses and challenges (1999, UNICEF) 9 Hygiene Education for Afganistan – People and systems for water, sanitation and health, Eng S Najibullah Masoumyar, Dr A G Dost, N Ruck and Dr K

Wilson, WEDEC (27th WEDEC Conference), 2001.

Page 2: dwc - Highly Commended - InternuntiaArmstrong Foundation (cancer research), or the ‘Make Poverty History’ white band. These wrist bands became a meaningful but sought-after and
Page 3: dwc - Highly Commended - InternuntiaArmstrong Foundation (cancer research), or the ‘Make Poverty History’ white band. These wrist bands became a meaningful but sought-after and

Po

rta

ble

Ph

ase

Ch

an

ge

Incu

ba

tor

De

sig

n C

on

cep

t

By

usi

ng

a p

ha

se c

ha

ng

e m

ate

ria

l, th

e n

ee

d f

or

ele

ctri

city

ca

n b

e e

limin

ate

d.

Pro

du

ce r

ou

gh

ly 6

00

gra

ms

of

sod

ium

ace

tate

so

luti

on

wit

h a

fre

ezi

ng

te

mp

era

ture

of

44

.5°C

. T

his

ca

n b

e a

chie

ved

usi

ng

a r

ati

o o

f a

pp

roxi

ma

tely

10

pa

rts

sod

ium

ace

tate

to

9

pa

rts

dis

tille

d w

ate

r.

Se

al

in a

vin

yl b

ag

wit

h a

n a

ctiv

ato

r d

isc

(se

e U

K p

ate

nt

no

. 4,0

77

,39

0)

to f

orm

a h

ea

t p

ack

.

Th

e e

xact

sh

ap

e o

f th

e v

inyl

ba

g s

ho

uld

be

su

ita

ble

fo

r th

is a

pp

lica

tio

n.

Wa

rm h

ea

t p

ack

in

bo

ilin

g w

ate

r u

nti

l so

luti

on

is

en

tire

ly m

elt

ed

he

nce

sto

rin

g t

he

la

ten

t

he

at.

Th

en

allo

w t

o s

up

erc

oo

l do

wn

to

ro

om

te

mp

era

ture

.

En

clo

se h

ea

t p

ack

wit

hin

wid

e m

ou

th t

he

rmo

s fl

ask

ca

pa

ble

of

ho

usi

ng

bo

th t

he

he

at

pa

ck

an

d a

sta

ck o

f 2

0 p

etr

i dis

he

s.

Wh

en

in

cub

ati

on

is

req

uir

ed

act

iva

te f

ree

zin

g p

roce

ss w

ith

in h

ea

t p

ack

, w

hic

h w

ill r

ais

e

tem

pe

ratu

re w

ith

in f

lask

to

44

.5°C

an

d m

ain

tain

te

mp

era

ture

fo

r 1

8 h

ou

r p

eri

od

.

Aft

er

incu

ba

tio

n r

em

ove

he

at

pa

ck a

nd

bo

il to

me

lt s

od

ium

ace

tate

so

luti

on

re

ad

y fo

r n

ex

t

incu

ba

tio

n c

ycle

.

Ba

sic

Pri

nci

ple

s

La

ten

t h

ea

t is

re

lea

sed

du

rin

g t

he

ph

ase

ch

an

ge

fro

m l

iqu

id t

o s

olid

. D

uri

ng

th

is t

ran

siti

on

the

en

erg

y lib

era

ted

will

in e

ffe

ct k

ee

p t

he

su

bst

an

ces

tem

pe

ratu

re c

on

sta

nt.

Su

pe

rco

olin

g r

efe

rs t

o a

sta

ble

liq

uid

s’ t

em

pe

ratu

re d

rop

pin

g b

elo

w i

ts f

ree

zin

g p

oin

t

wit

ho

ut

solid

ifyi

ng

. If

a c

ryst

al i

s fo

rme

d in

th

e s

up

erc

oo

led

liq

uid

it w

ill t

rig

ge

r so

lidif

ica

tio

n

of

the

en

tire

vo

lum

e.

Th

e c

om

bin

ati

on

of

the

se e

ffe

cts

me

an

s th

at

sup

erc

oo

led

so

diu

m a

ceta

te s

olu

tio

n c

an

be

trig

ge

red

to

so

lidif

y w

he

n r

eq

uir

ed

. T

his

in

tu

rn w

ill r

ais

e t

he

so

luti

on

’s t

em

pe

ratu

re t

o i

ts

fre

ezi

ng

po

int

an

d r

em

ain

th

ere

un

til i

t h

as

solid

ifie

d e

nti

rely

.

Ste

rilis

ati

on

Str

ate

gy

By

exa

min

ing

th

e e

nti

re f

iltra

tio

n p

roce

ss w

e w

ere

ab

le t

o a

sse

ss w

he

re c

on

tam

ina

tio

n c

ou

ld

occ

ur.

Ou

r p

roto

typ

e d

esi

gn

att

em

pts

to

sim

plif

y th

e p

roce

ss a

nd

en

sure

th

at

on

ly t

he

ap

pro

pri

ate

co

mp

on

en

ts o

f a

pp

ara

tus

rem

ain

ste

rile

.

Rig

oro

us

test

ing

of

ou

r p

roto

typ

e p

rove

d t

ha

t b

act

eri

al

con

tam

ina

tio

n o

f co

mp

on

en

ts

sup

po

rtin

g t

he

me

mb

ran

e d

oe

s n

ot

aff

ect

re

sult

s; t

he

refo

re t

he

on

ly i

tem

s th

at

ne

ed

ste

rilis

ati

on

are

th

ose

to

uch

ing

th

e t

op

su

rfa

ce o

f th

e m

em

bra

ne

.

Th

e s

imp

lifie

d d

esi

gn

su

gg

est

ed

be

low

wo

uld

on

ly r

eq

uir

e t

he

be

ak

er

wit

h a

40

mm

ho

le in

the

ba

se t

o b

e s

teri

lise

d b

etw

ee

n t

est

s.

Be

ak

ers

ca

n b

e p

re-s

teri

lise

d a

nd

sta

cke

d w

ith

on

e

use

d p

er

test

. T

his

wo

uld

ad

d li

ttle

ad

dit

ion

al w

eig

ht

an

d t

ak

e u

p o

nly

a f

ract

ion

mo

re s

pa

ce.

Me

mb

ran

e F

iltra

tio

n A

pp

ara

tus

Be

ne

fits

We

no

w f

ind

th

e in

cub

ato

r to

be

sm

all

an

d li

gh

t w

eig

ht.

Fu

rth

erm

ore

it d

oe

s n

ot

req

uir

e a

ny

ele

ctri

city

fo

r o

pe

rati

on

or

ind

ee

d a

t a

ny

tim

e.

Th

e r

ev

ise

d f

iltra

tio

n a

pp

ara

tus

is a

lso

lig

hte

r

an

d r

eq

uir

es

less

tim

e t

o p

rep

are

pri

ma

rily

du

e t

o r

ed

uct

ion

of

ste

rilis

ati

on

re

qu

ire

d.

Th

e

en

tire

kit

co

uld

be

use

d r

em

ote

ly f

or

a m

ult

iple

te

sts,

re

qu

irin

g li

ttle

ba

se c

am

p p

rep

ara

tio

ns.

Bo

th f

iltra

tio

n a

pp

ara

tus

an

d i

ncu

ba

tor

are

mo

re s

imp

ly m

an

ufa

ctu

red

wit

h h

op

es

tha

t

fab

rica

tio

n c

ou

ld b

e d

on

e lo

cally

.

Tem

p.

Tim

e

Ele

vate

d

La

ten

t H

ea

t R

ele

ase

44

.5°C

Am

bie

nt

Su

pe

rco

olin

gS

olid

ific

ati

on

Init

iate

d

Fre

ezi

ng

Te

mp

.

Th

erm

os

Fla

sk

So

diu

m A

ceta

te H

ea

t P

ack

Sta

ck o

f P

etr

i Dis

he

s

For

the

me

mb

ran

e fi

ltra

tio

n t

est

to

be

acc

ura

te e

very

ca

re m

ust

be

ta

ke

n t

o a

void

co

nta

min

a-

tio

n a

t a

ny

sta

ge

. S

tain

less

ste

el c

om

po

ne

nts

are

cu

rre

ntl

y in

volv

ed

in t

he

pro

cess

, ho

we

ver,

the

y a

re h

eav

y a

nd

exp

en

sive

, re

qu

irin

g a

len

gth

y s

teri

liza

tio

n p

roce

du

re b

etw

ee

n t

est

s. T

his

red

uce

s th

e s

uit

ab

ility

of

an

y p

ort

ab

le k

it f

or

use

in d

eve

lop

ing

co

un

trie

s.

Po

rta

ble

Wa

ter

Qu

alit

y Te

st K

itB

iolo

gic

ally

co

nta

min

ate

d w

ate

r is

a c

om

mo

n c

au

se o

f d

ise

ase

in

de

velo

pin

g c

ou

ntr

ies.

In

vest

iga

-

tio

n i

nto

th

e n

um

be

r o

f fa

eca

l co

lifo

rms

pre

sen

t in

a w

ate

r so

urc

e c

an

act

as

an

est

ima

te o

f p

ath

o-

ge

ns

pre

sen

t. R

ath

er

tha

n s

ea

rch

ing

fo

r sp

eci

fic

pa

tho

ge

ns,

in

dic

ato

r o

rga

nis

ms

can

pro

vid

e a

n

est

ima

te t

o t

he

leve

l of

con

tam

ina

tio

n.

Esc

he

rich

ia C

oli

(E. C

oli)

is a

ke

y in

dic

ato

r o

rga

nis

m b

eca

use

it is

ab

un

da

nt

in m

am

ma

lian

fa

ece

s a

nd

ha

s si

mila

r su

rviv

al c

ha

ract

eri

stic

s to

pa

tho

ge

nic

org

an

ism

s.

Me

mb

ran

e F

iltra

tio

n i

s a

n e

sta

blis

he

d m

eth

od

fo

r d

ete

rmin

ing

th

e l

eve

l o

f E

. Co

li p

rese

nt.

Cu

rre

nt

ap

plic

ati

on

s o

f th

is m

eth

od

are

mo

re s

uit

ed

to

a l

ab

ora

tory

en

vir

on

me

nt;

ho

we

ver,

the

su

gg

est

ed

ap

pro

ach

is a

pp

lica

ble

to

use

in r

em

ote

loca

tio

ns.

Au

tocl

ava

ble

Be

ak

er

Filt

er

Me

mb

ran

e

Wir

e M

esh

Va

cuu

m C

ha

mb

er

Ru

bb

er

Se

al

Plu

ng

er

Sim

plif

ied

Te

chn

iqu

e

Pla

ce f

ilte

r m

em

bra

ne

on

wir

e m

esh

wit

h s

teri

le t

we

eze

rs

Cla

mp

into

pla

ce b

y in

sert

ing

ste

rile

be

ak

er,

form

ing

a s

ea

l

Po

ur

kn

ow

n v

olu

me

into

be

ak

er

Pu

ll d

ow

n p

lun

ge

r fo

rcin

g w

ate

r th

rou

gh

me

mb

ran

e in

to v

acu

um

ch

am

be

r

Re

mo

ve b

ea

ke

r

Re

ad

y p

etr

i dis

h w

ith

nu

trie

nt

pa

d

Pla

ce f

ilte

r in

to p

etr

i dis

h w

ith

ste

rile

tw

ee

zers

Dis

card

filt

ere

d s

am

ple

Dry

to

p o

f va

cuu

m c

ha

mb

er

an

d w

ire

me

sh

Re

pe

at

the

pro

cess

wit

h n

ew

ste

rile

be

ak

er

Ste

rilis

e t

we

eze

rs u

sin

g li

gh

ter

fla

me

Min

ima

l On

-Sit

e S

teri

lisa

tio

n is

re

qu

ire

d

Cu

rre

nt

wa

ter

qu

alit

y te

st k

its

req

uir

e h

eav

y e

qu

ipm

en

t; t

he

bu

lk o

f w

hic

h is

th

e in

cub

ato

r.

Th

is o

fte

n r

eq

uir

es

ex

ten

de

d p

eri

od

s o

f re

cha

rgin

g a

nd

a c

on

ne

ctio

n t

o t

he

ma

ins.

In

rem

ote

loca

tio

ns

ele

ctri

city

su

pp

ly is

oft

en

inte

rmit

ten

t o

r e

nti

rely

ab

sen

t. A

s a

re

sult

th

ese

kit

s re

ma

in u

nu

sab

le d

esp

ite

th

eir

ne

cess

ity.

Re

sea

rch

an

d D

eve

lop

me

nt

Giv

en

th

at

fae

cal

colif

orm

s a

re k

ille

d a

t 8

2°C

it

is s

ug

ge

ste

d t

ha

t th

e b

ea

ke

rs c

ou

ld b

e

ste

rilis

ed

by

sub

me

rsio

n i

n b

oili

ng

wa

ter

for

an

ap

pro

pri

ate

du

rati

on

fu

rth

er

red

uci

ng

th

e

ne

ed

fo

r a

ba

se o

f o

pe

rati

on

s m

ore

co

mp

lica

ted

th

an

a c

am

p f

ire

.

Ea

rly

exp

eri

me

nts

pe

rfo

rme

d s

ug

ge

st a

n i

ncu

ba

tor

may

re

ma

in e

ffe

ctiv

e d

esp

ite

a w

ide

r

vari

ati

on

of

incu

ba

tio

n t

em

pe

ratu

re.

Th

is c

ou

ld h

elp

alle

via

te n

ee

d f

or

such

str

ing

en

t

con

tro

ls o

n e

nv

iro

nm

en

t a

nd

ma

ke

de

sig

n e

asi

er.

Furt

he

r p

roto

typ

ing

mu

st b

e c

arr

ied

ou

t to

en

sure

all

incu

ba

tio

n r

eq

uir

em

en

ts a

re m

et.

Va

ria

ble

s in

clu

de

ph

ase

ch

an

ge

su

bst

an

ce u

sed

an

d t

he

str

ate

gic

sh

ap

e o

f th

e v

inyl

b

ag

infl

ue

nci

ng

so

lidif

ica

tio

n p

roce

ss.

Me

mb

ran

e F

iltra

tio

n

Filt

er

kn

ow

n v

olu

me

th

rou

gh

me

mb

ran

e

Th

e fi

lte

r m

em

bra

ne

ha

s a

po

re d

iam

ete

r o

f 0.4

m, w

hic

h is

sm

all

en

ou

gh

to

tra

p t

he

E. C

oli

pre

sen

t.

Th

is f

ilte

r m

em

bra

ne

sh

ou

ld t

he

n b

e p

lace

d i

nto

a p

etr

i d

ish

on

to

p o

f a

pa

d s

oa

ke

d i

n n

utr

ien

t. I

t

sho

uld

th

en

be

left

to

acc

lima

tise

fo

r o

ne

ho

ur.

Incu

ba

te a

t 4

4.5

°C f

or

16

-18

ho

urs

Bo

th n

utr

ien

t a

nd

in

cub

ati

on

te

mp

era

ture

pro

vid

e f

avo

ura

ble

co

nd

itio

ns

for

the

gro

wth

of

fae

cal

colif

orm

s.

Aft

er

the

in

cub

ati

on

pe

rio

d r

em

ove

th

e f

ilte

r m

em

bra

ne

an

d c

ou

nt

the

nu

mb

er

of

colo

nie

s. E

ach

re

pre

sen

ts o

ne

fa

eca

l co

lifo

rm in

th

e o

rig

ina

l sa

mp

le.

Cu

rre

nt

Re

cog

nis

ed

Pro

ced

ure

5 m

ain

co

mp

on

en

ts,

mo

stly

sta

inle

ss s

tee

l w

ith

so

me

pla

stic

an

d r

ub

be

r

Co

mp

lex

ste

rilis

ati

on

pro

cess

in

volv

ing

th

e

inco

mp

lete

co

mb

ust

ion

of m

eth

an

ol t

ak

es

at

lea

st 1

5 m

inu

tes

be

twe

en

ea

ch t

est

Nu

mb

er

of

test

s p

er

day

se

vere

ly r

est

rict

ed

b

y st

eri

lisa

tio

n t

ime

:

20

sa

mp

les

tak

e m

inim

um

5 h

ou

rs

Ou

r S

yste

m

3 m

ain

pla

stic

co

mp

on

en

ts

No

ste

rilis

ati

on

re

qu

ire

d b

etw

ee

n t

est

s

Nu

mb

er

of

test

s p

er

day

on

ly r

est

rict

ed

by

in

cub

ato

r ca

pa

city

:

20

sa

mp

les

tak

e m

inim

um

of

1 h

ou

r

(th

is is

no

t in

clu

din

g s

ett

ing

up

tim

e a

nd

tim

e f

or

trav

elli

ng

be

twe

en

te

sts)