Dubai Statement 18Dez10(2)

2
MANNTECH Fassadenbefahrsysteme GmbH ' Mmesmannsrasse 5 ' D-82291Mmendorf To whom it may concern Telephone +49(0)8145 999- 100 Telefax +49 (0) 8145 999 -222 e-mail [email protected] FASSADEN BEFAH RSYS'I ma n ntech Mmesmmstrasse 5 82291 MamendorflGemmy 18ft December 2010 Yom reference/ your message of Om referenc Dept,/Participmt Manntech statement for our Business Partners and Customers regarding the accident in Dubai on 30th November 2010 On Tuesday evening, 30th November 2010 we received the following news from Dubai: Two facade workers of Indian nationality, whilst working at a considerable height on the exterior fagade of the Burj Dubai Plot 12 building for the firm Multiform, tragically fell to their deaths. This greatly shocked us and we feel the deepest sympathy and sorrow for the workers and their families. Manntech immediately sent a third party inspector to Dubai GÜD. Presently, a detailed investi- gation is ongoing. However, we would like to give all our business partners and customers the information we do have regarding this situation in Dubai and how we are proceeding. It will take some time to provide final clarification of the full causes of this incident. The chain of parties involved is very long and includes the BMU manufacturer (Manntech), one of our special- ist suppliers (hydraulic cylinders), our local partner, the customer, the company operating the BMU and local authorities. We have delivered a total of four static crane-type BMUs to the Burj Dubai Plots 12 and 13. Each BMU is equipped with a telescopic mast and telescopic jib (a.k.a. boom or arm). These machines have been in use since August 2010 for the purposes of facade installation at the customer's re- quest. Manntech's local partner handed over the machines for temporary use during the construc- tion phase, and with explicit operating restrictions regarding the use of the BMUs for the proposed construction application. Initial information received from the site is that one BMU had a failure within an already replaced hydraulic cylinder operating the telescopic mast. We still have to establish the fulI circumstances leading up to this component failure. However, it resulted in the telescopic mast suddenly retract- ing vertically into itself, causing the jib to drop by approximately 3 meters. Mmging Didor Edch Dinkls H€dqM6: Mmendorf Cmty Coü Muich: HRB 127884 USt-IdNr D8185996338 Telephme Telefd: e-roil: IffiI: +49(0)8145-994 Banksincem&y: +49(0)8145-99-2s Sparfta*Fffiqfeldbnk AeoutNo-1428515 So(Cod€7m53070 ex?o(@,lwt6hd€ Hwovercinsbak, Olching Atroünt No. 87400557 So( Code 70O 202 70 lütp://wv.lffi€h.de ßN BIC DE4070053070m01428515 BYLADEMIFFB DEr5 7002 0270 0087 4005 s7 TTYWDEW Certified according to DIN ISO 9001

Transcript of Dubai Statement 18Dez10(2)

MANNTECH Fassadenbefahrsysteme GmbH ' Mmesmannsrasse 5 ' D-82291Mmendorf

To whom it may concern

Telephone +49(0)8145 999- 100

Telefax +49 (0) 8145 999 -222e-mail [email protected]

FASSADEN BEFAH RSYS'I

ma n ntech

Mmesmmstrasse 5

82291 MamendorflGemmy

18ft December 2010

Yom reference/your message of

Om referencDept,/Participmt

Manntech statement for our Business Partners and Customers regarding theaccident in Dubai on 30th November 2010

On Tuesday evening, 30th November 2010 we received the following news from Dubai:

Two facade workers of Indian nationality, whilst working at a considerable height on the exteriorfagade of the Burj Dubai Plot 12 building for the firm Multiform, tragically fell to their deaths.This greatly shocked us and we feel the deepest sympathy and sorrow for the workers and theirfamilies.

Manntech immediately sent a third party inspector to Dubai GÜD. Presently, a detailed investi-gation is ongoing. However, we would like to give all our business partners and customers theinformation we do have regarding this situation in Dubai and how we are proceeding.

It will take some time to provide final clarification of the full causes of this incident. The chain ofparties involved is very long and includes the BMU manufacturer (Manntech), one of our special-ist suppliers (hydraulic cylinders), our local partner, the customer, the company operating theBMU and local authorities.

We have delivered a total of four static crane-type BMUs to the Burj Dubai Plots 12 and 13. EachBMU is equipped with a telescopic mast and telescopic jib (a.k.a. boom or arm). These machineshave been in use since August 2010 for the purposes of facade installation at the customer's re-quest. Manntech's local partner handed over the machines for temporary use during the construc-tion phase, and with explicit operating restrictions regarding the use of the BMUs for the proposed

construction application.

Initial information received from the site is that one BMU had a failure within an already replacedhydraulic cylinder operating the telescopic mast. We still have to establish the fulI circumstancesleading up to this component failure. However, it resulted in the telescopic mast suddenly retract-ing vertically into itself, causing the jib to drop by approximately 3 meters.

Mmging Didor Edch Dinkls

H€dqM6: MmendorfCmty Coü Muich: HRB 127884

USt-IdNr D8185996338

TelephmeTelefd:e-roil:IffiI:

+49(0)8145-994 Banksincem&y:+49(0)8145-99-2s Sparfta*Fffiqfeldbnk AeoutNo-1428515 So(Cod€7m53070ex?o(@,lwt6hd€ Hwovercinsbak, Olching Atroünt No. 87400557 So( Code 70O 202 70lütp://wv.lffi€h.de

ßN BICDE4070053070m01428515 BYLADEMIFFBDEr5 7002 0270 0087 4005 s7 TTYWDEW

Certified according to DIN ISO 9001

FASSADEN BEFAH RSYST

ma n ntech

The telescopic jib was fully telescoped out and at its maximum reach dimension of 20 meters.

The telescopic jib absorbed the impact forces and remained in place. However the slewing head

connection at the end of the jib appears to have failed as the vertical movement of the combined

inner telescoping mast, telescoping jib, counterweight, slewing head and gondola came to an in-stant stop by hitting the outer telescoping mast and main frame of the BMU.

As a precautionary measure, all BMU's with double action cylinders from the same specialist sup-

plier will be taken out of service until the final results of the investigation and thorough examina-

tion are received. This will be carried out by an independent institute as soon as we receive fullclearance to proceed from the local authorities.

There are just two further installations worldwide where components from the same specialistsupplier have been used in the BMU design and production. No BMUs supplied to your market

include components from this specialist supplier.

The BMUs MANNTECH, (formerly Mannesmann) products are very robust and are designed and

constructed according to all valid Industry Standards (Machinery Directive, harmonized European

Standard Norms e.g. EN 1808, local standards if requested) and are certified by the German Tech-nical Supervision Authority according to DIN/EN/ISO 9001. An immediate review of all our doc-

uments (type testing documents, structural analysis, calculations, purchasing documents, workshop test report) showed no breaches of the relevant standards and codes. Each Manntech Machineis fully engineered and assembled in our factory, then tested in accordance with Manntech ISOtesting procedure. After testing it is disassembled for delivery to site.

We are still very proud of our company's continuous safety record of almost 60 years of age. Priorto this accident we have supplied almost 8,000 fagade access systems all over the world, and have

no record of such an incident with one of our BMUs. We credit this safety record to our interna-

tionally recognized approach to high quality product design and manufacturing standards.

Please be assured that whatever circumstances may be established following the investigation ofthis incident, we remain highly motivated and committed to our product quality and safety aware-

ness. We will continue to further improve and optimize our standards in design, safety and qualityas we have been doing for many years.

We look forward to receiving your continued trust and ongoing successful cooperation and sup-

c"uManaging Director

Fassadenbefahrsysteme GmbH