DRC Capstone Presentation 4-24 ConDev

38
Impact of Interventions on Child Malnutrition and Youth Unemployment in Eastern Congo Skyler Barlow . David Hobson . Brandon Pichanick . Diego Pinzon Cait Stadler . Julie Swensen . Gabriel Vander Hey Faculty Advisor: Dr. Kishore Gawande

description

 

Transcript of DRC Capstone Presentation 4-24 ConDev

Page 1: DRC Capstone Presentation 4-24 ConDev

Impact of Interventions on Child Malnutrition and Youth Unemployment in

Eastern CongoSkyler Barlow . David Hobson . Brandon Pichanick . Diego Pinzon

Cait Stadler . Julie Swensen . Gabriel Vander Hey

Faculty Advisor: Dr. Kishore Gawande

Page 2: DRC Capstone Presentation 4-24 ConDev

Roadmap• Background• Partners and Pre-Survey• Project 1: CEFADES• Project 2: Nutrition• Conclusion• Questions

Page 3: DRC Capstone Presentation 4-24 ConDev

The Democratic Republic of the Congo

Page 4: DRC Capstone Presentation 4-24 ConDev

Conflict in North Kivu• Crossroads for armed groups

• Butembo population

• Stability of Butembo

Page 5: DRC Capstone Presentation 4-24 ConDev

Client & Partner Background• Client: The Conflict & Development Lab• Partner: The Universite Catholique du Graben

– Students will be co-authors– CEFADES & Giorgio Cerruto Therapeutic Nutrition Center

Page 6: DRC Capstone Presentation 4-24 ConDev

Pre-Survey• Gavin Finnegan

• Purpose– Train enumerators– Identify potential

weaknesses of the surveys

Page 7: DRC Capstone Presentation 4-24 ConDev

Project I: CEFADESYouth Employment

Page 8: DRC Capstone Presentation 4-24 ConDev

What is CEFADES?

• Youth Vocational Program• Focused on the Disenfranchised• 594 since 2009

– 30% female• Skill Training

– mechanics, carpentry, masonry, dressmaking, hairdressing, culinary arts, etc...

Page 9: DRC Capstone Presentation 4-24 ConDev

CEFADES Research Questions

•Does employment increase?

•Does income increase?

Page 10: DRC Capstone Presentation 4-24 ConDev

CEFADES Survey

Page 11: DRC Capstone Presentation 4-24 ConDev

CEFADES Methodology• Comparison of Control and Treatment• OLS regression on income• Comparison of Control and Treatment• Probit regression on working status• Child soldier regressions

Cait Stadler
Having methodology as the title of the slide, then as a bullet is redundant
Page 12: DRC Capstone Presentation 4-24 ConDev

Employment ImpactThe Proportion of Populations Working vs Unemployed

Page 13: DRC Capstone Presentation 4-24 ConDev

Employment ImpactDependent Variable: Working Status

Page 14: DRC Capstone Presentation 4-24 ConDev

Income ImpactAverage Monthly Income in Dollars

Cait Stadler
Capitalize Mean of Dollars
Page 15: DRC Capstone Presentation 4-24 ConDev

Income ImpactDependent Variable: Log of Monthly Income

Page 16: DRC Capstone Presentation 4-24 ConDev

Dependent Variable: Log of Monthly Income

Page 17: DRC Capstone Presentation 4-24 ConDev

Bottom Line• Research Questions

– Does employment increase?Yes

– Does income increase?Yes

• Limitations– Post-Treatment Survey

Ideal: Panel Data– Non-Randomized Treatment

Page 18: DRC Capstone Presentation 4-24 ConDev

Project II: Nutrition

Page 19: DRC Capstone Presentation 4-24 ConDev

Setting the Stage

Source: Eastern Congo Initiative

Page 20: DRC Capstone Presentation 4-24 ConDev

Nutrition Research Questions

• What is the prevalence of child malnutrition in the Bunyuka Parish?

• In comparison to the control, does the treatment positively affect the nutritional status of children?

Page 21: DRC Capstone Presentation 4-24 ConDev

Nutrition Methodology

• Control Study– WHO Standardized Measurements

• Average Treatment on the Treated (ATT)– Independent Variable: Nutritional Therapy– Dependent Variables: Height-for-Age (HFA), Weight-for-Age (WFA)

Page 22: DRC Capstone Presentation 4-24 ConDev

Nutrition Control Survey

Page 23: DRC Capstone Presentation 4-24 ConDev

Nutrition Treatment Survey

Page 24: DRC Capstone Presentation 4-24 ConDev

Nutrition Sample

Untreated Group• 714 households surveyed• 1,750 children measured

Treatment Group• 215 households surveyed• 351 children measured

Page 25: DRC Capstone Presentation 4-24 ConDev

io

Prevalence of MalnutritionControl Sample

Comparison of Below Average WHO Outcomes w/ Above Average Bunyuka Outcomes

Page 26: DRC Capstone Presentation 4-24 ConDev

Selection on Observables• Self-Reported Nutritional Status• Education Levels• Distance to Health Center• Nutritional Preferences• Age • Ethnicity/Language• Cost of Treatment

Page 27: DRC Capstone Presentation 4-24 ConDev

Quartile Treatment Effect

Page 28: DRC Capstone Presentation 4-24 ConDev

Average Treatment Effect

Page 29: DRC Capstone Presentation 4-24 ConDev

Bottom Line

• Research QuestionsWhat is the prevalence of child malnutrition in Bunyuka Parish?

Very prevalentIn comparison to the control, does the treatment positively affect the nutritional status of children?

Yes, but it is best for children under 3 years• Limitations

–Not a perfect control–Post-treatment survey only

Page 30: DRC Capstone Presentation 4-24 ConDev

CONCLUSION

Page 31: DRC Capstone Presentation 4-24 ConDev

Conclusion

CEFADES•Positively impacts youth•Confirms training effectiveness•Contradicts child soldier literature•Unique program for this part of the world

Page 32: DRC Capstone Presentation 4-24 ConDev

Conclusion

Nutrition• Context• Survey Mechanics• Findings–Rural health outcomes–Observable costs to treatment–Ideal age range for treatment

Page 33: DRC Capstone Presentation 4-24 ConDev

Conclusion

Client•Program evaluation capabilities

Field of Conflict & Development•Research capabilities

Page 34: DRC Capstone Presentation 4-24 ConDev

Questions

Skyler Barlow | David HobsonBrandon Pichanick | Diego Pinzon

Cait Stadler | Julie Swensen | Gabriel Vander Hey

Page 35: DRC Capstone Presentation 4-24 ConDev

CEFADES Selection Process

1 - Program Psychologist

2 - NGO’s and Government

3 - Parents

4 - Advertisement in Churches

Page 36: DRC Capstone Presentation 4-24 ConDev

Survey

Key Factors Measured

1 - Demographics

2 - Income

3 - Health

4 - Spillover Effects

Page 37: DRC Capstone Presentation 4-24 ConDev

Survey: By Gender Comparison

Page 38: DRC Capstone Presentation 4-24 ConDev

CEFADES - PSM results