Dr. RUCHI DHAR - 52.172.27.147:8080
Transcript of Dr. RUCHI DHAR - 52.172.27.147:8080
ldquoA STUDY ON THE MORBIDITY PATTERN AND HEALTH SEEKING
BEHAVIOUR AMONG THE GERIATRIC POPULATION IN THE URBAN FIELD
PRACTICE AREA OF JJM MEDICAL COLLEGE DAVANGERErdquo Submitted by
Dr RUCHI DHAR
MBBS
Dissertation submitted to the
Rajiv Gandhi University of Health Sciences Bangalore Karnataka
In partial fulfillment of the requirement for the degree of
DOCTOR OF
MEDICINE IN
COMMUNITY MEDICINE
Under the guidance of
Dr VIDYA GS MD
Professor
DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY MEDICINE
JJM MEDICAL COLLEGE DAVANGERE
2015-2018
i
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
This work is dedicated to my beloved Mother Usha Dhar and Father
Ramesh Kumar Dhar without whom I would not be where I am today
I would like to make a special mention here of my brother Romil Dhar
For supporting me all the way and believing in me
I take this opportunity to extend my gratitude and sincere thanks to all those who
have helped me in completing this dissertation
I am thankful to all participants who were part of the study for their kind co-operation
It is with this sense of heartfelt gratitude and appreciation that I would like to express
my sincere thanks to my revered guide and teacher Dr Vidya G S MD Professor
Department of Community medicine J JM Medical College Davangere for having
rendered encouragement and valuable suggestions during the course of this study Her
patience keen interest in the progress of my research work and readiness with which
she entered into discussion has been instrumental in the successful completion of my
dissertation work
I would also like to express my sincere gratitude to Dr Balu P S MD Professor and
Head Department of Community Medicine JJMMC for his valuable advice
constant guidance and inspiration during my study course
vi
LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS USED (in alphabetical order)
APD - Acid Peptic Disease
AYUSH- Ayurveda Yoga Unani Siddha and Homeopathy
BMI - Body Mass Index
CAD - Coronary Artery Disease
CVD - Cardiovascular Diseases
ENT - Ear Nose Throat
GIT - Gastrointestinal Tract
HBM- Health Belief Model
HSB- Health Seeking Behviour
ICD - International Classification of Diseases
ICMR- Indian Council of Medical Research
MI - Myocardial Infarction
NCOP- National Council for Older Persons
viii
NCD- Non Communicable Disease
NCsrC- National Council for Senior Citizens
NGO - Non -Governmental Organization
NPOP- National Policy for Older Persons
RMP- Registered Medical Practitioner
SDGs ndash Sustainable Development Goals
SES - Socio-Economic Status
TB ndash Tuberculosis
TPB- Theory of Planned Behaviour
TRA- Theory of Reasoned Action
UN - United Nations
UHTC- Urban Health Training center
URTI- Upper Respiratory Tract Infection
WHO - World Health organization
ix
LIST OF TABLES
Table No
Title Page No
1 Percentage share of elderly population (aged 60 years and above) in
total population by sex in India
6
2 Size of elderly population (aged 60+) and their share in total
population in major states of India in 2011
7
3 List of areas covered under the UHTC of JJM Medical College
Davangere
29
4 WHO Categorization of Body Mass index (BMI) for Asians 34
5 JNC VII Classification of Blood pressure 35
6 Socio-economic status (SES)- As per modified BG Prasad
Classification
37
7 Age and sex wise distribution of the study subjects 39
8 Distribution of the study subjects based on religion 40
9 Distribution of the study subjects based on Educational status 41
10 Distribution of the study subjects based on occupation 42
11
Distribution of the study subjects based on socio-economic status
(Modified BG Prasad classification 2016)
43
12 Distribution of the study subjects based on their marital status 44
13 Distribution of the study subjects based on the type of family 45
14 Distribution of morbidity pattern of the study subjects based on ICD
10 classification of diseases
47
xiii
15
Distribution of the study subjects based on morbidity of the
Musculoskeletal system
49
16
Distribution of the study subjects based on morbidity of the eye
and adnexa
50
17 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the oral cavity 51
18
Distribution of study subjects based on endocrine nutritional and
metabolic disorders
52
19 Distribution of the study subject based on disease of the circulatory
system
53
20 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the respiratory
system
54
21
Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the digestive
system
55
22
Distribution the study subjects based on disease of the Skin and
subcutaneous tissue
56
23 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the ear 57
24
Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the
genitourinary system
58
25
Distribution of the study subjects based on diseases of the Nervous
system
59
26 Association between morbidity pattern of the study subjects and
their age group
60
xiv
27
Association between morbidity pattern of the study subjects and
their occupation
62
28
Association between morbidity pattern of the study subjects and
their religion
64
29 Reasons cited by the study subjects for not seeking healthcare in
case of an illness
67
30 Distribution of the study subjects based on the type of health facility
visited
68
31 Association between gender and health care seeking behavior of the
study subjects
69
32 Association between educational status and health care seeking
behaviour of the study subjects
70
33 Distribution of study subjects according to frequency of visits to a
health care facility
71
xv
LIST OF FIGURES
Figure No
Title Page No
1 Proportion of elderly in the Indian population by age groups
1961-2001
6
2 Pathophysiology of health issues in geriatrics 10
3 Predicting health behaviour with social cognition models 13
4 Health belief model components and linkages 15
5 Maps showing the location of Davangere district and the
area where the UHTC is located
27
6 Map showing the Urban field practice area of JJM medical college
28
7 Age and sex wise distribution of the study subjects 39
8 Distribution of the study subjects based on religion 40
9 Distribution of the study subjects based on Educational status 41
10 Distribution of study subjects based on their occupation 42
11
Distribution of study subjects based on their occupation
43
12 Distribution of the study subjects based on their marital status 44
13 Distribution of the study subjects based on the type of family 45
14 Distribution of the study subjects based on the BMI 46
15 Distribution of morbidity pattern of the study subjects based on
ICD 10 classification of diseases
48
16 Distribution of the study subjects based on the visit to health
facility in case of an illness
66
xvi
ABSTRACT Background
According to census 2011 the elderly population aged 60 years and above account for 8
of total population and is projected to rise to 124 by the year 2026 Health status is an
important factor that has a significant impact on quality of life The elderly are one of the
most vulnerable and high risk groups in terms of health status and their health seeking
behaviour is crucial in any society
Objectives
1 To study the morbidity pattern among the geriatric population in the urban field
practice area of JJM Medical college Davangere
2 To assess the health seeking behaviour of the elderly residing in the study area
Methods It was a community based cross sectional study which was conducted in the urban field
practice area of JJM Medical College Davangere The total study subjects were 440
individuals aged 60 years and above Data was collected using a predesigned pre-tested
and semi- structured questionnaire Height weight and blood pressure were measured
and recorded Data was analyzed by using MS Excel and Open-Epi Info software
version 22 Statistical test employed was chi-square and Fishers exact test x
Results and Conclusion
In our study it was found that the majority of the subjects (368) were in the age group
of 60-64 years 525 were illiterate 511 were unemployed and 49 belonged to class
IV socio economic status The study revealed that the some of the common morbidities
among the geriatric subjects were the disorders of the musculoskeletal system (714)
eye and adnexa (497) oral cavity (329) endocrine nutritional and metabolic
disorders (329)etc some disorders like cataract dental caries constipation and
increased frequency of micturition were more common among males whereas disease
like anemia and hypertension were more common among females A significant
association was found between some of the morbidities and socio demographic
determinants like age occupation and religion
Any degree of formal schooling was found to be associated with better health seeking
behavior Majority of the subjects (58) visited a Government health facility in case of
an illness and the main reason that was stated for not visiting a health facility was that
they suffered from mild discomfort (444) and did not consider it necessary to visit a
health facility
Key words Geriatric urban behaviour morbidity
xi
Introduction
INTRODUCTION
ldquoA STUDY ON THE MORBIDITY PATTERN AND HEALTH SEEKING BEHAVIOUR AMONG THE GERIATRIC POPULATION IN THE URBAN FIELD
PRACTICE AREA OF JJM MEDICAL COLLEGE DAVANGERErdquo
All countries of the world are experiencing population ageing Ageing is a result of
decreasing mortality and most importantly declining fertility The global share of older
people (aged 60 years and above) has increased from 92 per cent in 1990 to 117 in
2013 and will continue to grow as a proportion of the world population reaches 211 by
20501
The lsquoNational Policy for Older Personsrsquo was adopted by the Government of India in
January 1999 and it defines a lsquosenior citizenrsquo or lsquoelderlyrsquo as a person who is aged 60 years
or above Ageing is a progressive process associated with declines in structure and
function impaired maintenance and repair systems increased susceptibility to disease and
death2
In 2015 Worldwide there were 901 million people aged 60 years or over It is
projected that their number will grow to 14 billion in 2030 which is the target date for the
SDGs and to 21 billion by 2050 There will be growth in the number of older persons aged
60 years and above between 2015 and 2030 This increase is projected to be especially
significant global phenomenon and virtually every country in the world will experience a
substantial increase including the less developed regions3 The increased life expectancy has
led to challenges in health care management The elderly suffer from various diseases which
include non-communicable disease (NCDs) like diabetes hypertension coronary heart
disease and other disorders like osteoarthritis stroke dementia osteoporosis cancer
1
Introduction enlarged prostate depression and cataract related blindness In the coming years there will
be a phenomenal growth in the population of the elderly while the family size will reduce
The disintegration of the joint family and women moving out of the household has led to the
absence of traditional caregivers for the elderly who are already a vulnerable group4
The most common cause of health problems in the old aged people is chronic diseases
Most of these problems can be prevented or delayed by engaging in healthy behaviours
Even in the advanced years of life physical activity and good nutrition can have
effective benefits on health and well-being Many health problems of old age can be
effectively managed if they are detected early enough5 The National Policy for Older
Persons was announced by the Government of India in the year 1999 The Constitution of
India under Article 41 mandates the well-being of senior citizens ldquoThe state shall
within the limits of its economic capacity and development make effective provision
for securing the right to public assistance in case of old aged peoplerdquo 6
National Council for Older Persons (NCOP) has been reconstituted and renamed as
National Council for Senior Citizens (NCSrC) in order to have a definite structure and also
regional balancing the NCOP advises the Central and State Governments on a broad range
of issues related to welfare of senior citizens and enhancement of their quality of life The
NCSrc meets at least twice a year7 The elderly suffer from multiple medical as well as
psychological problems There has already been some pioneering work on the elderly in
India but a lot more remains to be done There is an urgent need to pay attention
towards the medical and socio-economic problems that are being faced by the elderly
people in India and thus formulate strategies to bring about an improvement in their
quality of life8 The Health seeking behaviour is influenced by various factors which
include the individual self diseases and the availability and accessibility of health
2
services It is important to have knowledge regarding the health seeking behaviour of
individuals for designing health care policies and programmes so that all the possible
difficulties with early diagnosis and effective treatment can be identified and appropriate
interventions can be implemented9 As already stated the elderly are a vulnerable group as
there are psychological as well as physiological changes with increasing age and it is
difficult to cope up with the problems of ageing Some of the most common problems in old
age are cardiovascular problems arthritis respiratory problems blood pressure and so on
Therefore the study of the health status of elderly morbid conditions perceptions about
it is important to note and the health care of the elderly becomes very important since they
are more prone to illness than young people and are also more prone to domestic and other
accidents Their health and treatment seeking behaviour are most important for the
formulation of welfare programmes of the country 10
Hence this study was taken up in the urban field practice area of JJM Medical College
Davangere to assess the morbidity pattern and health seeking behaviour of the geriatric
subjects
3
Objectives
OBJECTIVES
1 To study the morbidity pattern among the geriatric population in the urban field
practice area of JJM Medical college Davangere
2 To assess the health seeking behaviour of the elderly residing in the study area
4
Review of literature
vii
REVIEW OF LITERATURE
1 Definition Geriatrics or clinical gerontology Is the term used for the care of the aged 11 The United Nations uses 60 years and above to refer to older people the same is also used
by demographers However in many developed countries the age of 65 is used as the
reference point for older persons 12
Elderly are classified in to 3 groups 13
Young old Persons in the age group of 60 years to 74 years
Old old Persons in the age group of 75 years to 84 years
Oldest old Persons above the age of 85 yrs
2 Demography of the ageing population in India
The UN defines a country as ldquoAgeingrdquo or ldquoGreying Nationrdquo where the
proportion of people over 60 reaches 7 percent to total population By 2011 India has
exceeded that proportion (80 percent) and is expected to reach 126 percent in 2025
The Indian population has increased from 361 million in 1951 to 1027 billion in 2001
and further to 121 billion in 2011 Simultaneously the number of older people has
increased from 19 million (ie 4 percent of total population) to 77 million and
further to roughly 93 million (ie 75 percent of the total) during the same time
span 14
5
Review of literature
Figure1 proportion of elderly in the Indian population by age groups 1961-2001 14
Table 1 Percentage share of elderly population (aged 60 years and above) in total
population by sex in India 15
Years Male Female Total Rural Urban
1961 55 58 56 58 47
1971 59 60 60 62 50
1981 64 66 65 68 54
1991 67 68 68 71 57
2001 71 78 75 77 67
2011 77 84 80 81 79
2004-05 69 75 72 73 70
2007-08 73 77 75 76 72
6
Review of literature
The rise in population of males was more modest from 55 percent to 71 percent while for
females there had been a steep rise from 58 percent to 78 percent during five decadal
Censuses from 1961 to 2001 In 2011 the elderly population accounted for 80 percent of
total population For males it was marginally lower at 77 percent while for females it was
84 percent According to NSSO surveys the proportion of elderly population in rural areas
was 73 percent during 2004-05 and increased up to 76 percent in 2007-08 While on the
other hand in urban areas the proportion of elderly population rose from 70 percent to 72
percent during the corresponding period It has been observed that the percentage share of
elderly to total population remained higher in rural areas than in urban areas15
Table2 Size of elderly population (aged 60+) and their share in total population in major states of India in 201115
All India and selected major states
Proportion of elderly in total population of State
Male Female Total Andhra Pradesh 83 94 88 Bihar 72 67 70 Gujarat 76 90 83 Haryana 66 76 71 Himachal Pradesh 104 103 104 Karnataka 79 89 84 Kerala 118 133 126 Madhya Pradesh 68 74 71 Maharashtra 88 97 93 Orissa 91 95 93 Punjab 91 100 95 Rajasthan 66 79 72 Tamil Nadu 102 109 105 Uttar Pradesh 66 71 68 West Bengal 82 82 82 All India 77 84 80
7
Review of literature
3 MORBIDITY PATTERN AMONG THE ELDERLY
Physiological Decline and Consequences of increasing age
Ageing i s a process of decline in biological functions affecting most physical
Systems The following systems are affected by ageing
(a) Atrophy of the Taste Buds and Loss of Teeth
With the increasing age the taste buds of the tongue get atrophied and as a result the
preference for food alters significantly There is also a considerable loss of teeth causing
difficulties in chewing food
(b) Changes in the Gastrointestinal Tract
As the age advances the walls of the intestine get atrophied and the motility is
markedly reduced (lazy intestine) The digestive enzymes secreted by the intestine are
also reduced Hence the partly digested food stays in the intestine for a longer period
As a result the common complaint of the elderly person is gas formation (flatulence)
and constipation
(c) Respiratory System
As the age advance there is progressive fibrosis of the lungs leading to reduced
oxygenation of the lungs and breathing difficulties
(d) Kidney and genitourinary System
The kidneys get smaller in size and the power of the kidneys to filter out the unwanted
waste products from the body is diminished The total amount of urine becomes less in
old age and thus the waste products are not adequately excreted from the body
8
Review of literature
(e) Urinary Bladder
Urinary bladder gets smaller in size due to shrinkage and as a result the accumulation
of urine even of a small amount leads to an urge for urination With increase in age
the valve in the bladder which controls the exit of urine from the bladder to urethra
gets atrophied and weak Involuntary leakage of urine occurs in case the bladder is full
or due to increase of pressure on bladder on sneezing or even on laughing a condition
known as urinary incontinence Incontinence is a common complaint of elder females
(f) Heart and Circulatory System
The blood vessels get rigid and quite often the vessel walls become rough with the
deposition of solid matters consisting mostly of cholesterol The heart muscles get weaker
and power to send blood throughout the body through the circulatory system gets less and
less powerful The most dangerous effect on heart is coronary heart disease especially
coronary thrombosis
(g) Muscular system
The muscles in the body get gradually atrophied with ageing and especially those
small muscles which are necessary for quick reflex action The elderly person can quite
be capable of working like a normal person and can undertake activities which require
big muscles of legs and arms But when it comes to quick movement which needs small
muscles for quick reflex movements these functions are impaired causing accidents
like slipping on wet floor of the bathroom
(h) Brain
With ageing the size of the brain gets smaller and the weight also becomes less This
however does not interfere with the function of the brain However in general the brain
cells and its fibers which carry impulses from brain to the system and upwards get
9
Review of literature
degenerated The most glaring manifestation of ageing affecting the brain is
forgetfulness and in simple terms it is inability of brain to recall the past experience
However this is common in all elderly persons
(i ) Bones
The bones become porous and fragile as age advances especially in elderly females This
condition is known as osteoporosis and leads to sustaining of fractures even after a minor
fall16
Figure 2 pathophysiology of health issues in geriatrics17
The common disease that the geriatric population suffers from are type 2 diabetes
coronary heart disease hypertension stroke chronic obstructive pulmonary disease
10
Review of literature
Alzheimerrsquos disease osteoarthritis osteoporosis prostatic hypertrophy cataracts macular
degeneration cancer etc and at the same time they are vulnerable to infections involving
respiratory (including TB) urinary and digestive tract17
In India the elderly people suffer from dual medical problems ie communicable and
nonndash communicable diseases There is also impairment of special sensory functions like
vision and hearing A decline in immunity and age-related physiological changes leads to
an increased burden of communicable diseases in the elderly A report by Indian Council
of Medical Research (ICMR) on the chronic morbidity profile in the elderly states that
hearing impairment is the most common morbidity followed by visual impairment
However different studies show varied results in the morbidity pattern18
Major chronic conditions affecting older people worldwide 19
Cardiovascular diseases (such as coronary heart disease) Diabetes Mellitus
Hypertension Stroke Cancer
Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease
Musculoskeletal conditions (such as arthritis and osteoporosis)
Mental health conditions (mostly dementia and depression)
Blindness and visual impairment
11
Review of literature
Health seeking behaviour
1 Definition
There is no common definition agreed upon by sociologists in any sociology literature
Different definitions may be used in different studies despite referring to the same activity
Sociology and literature assume that health seeking behaviour is influenced by the various
factors which include individual self or the individual diseases present and also the
availability and accessibility of health services Being dependent on these determinants and
their interactions it can be said that health care seeking behaviour is a very complex
outcome of various factors which operate at individual family and community level20
Health Seeking Behavior (HSB) refers to decision or an action taken by an individual to
maintain attain or regain good health and to prevent illness The decisions which are
made encompasses all available health care options like visiting a public or private and
modern or traditional health facility self-medication and use of home remedies or not to
utilize the available health services etc
Determining the health care seeking behavior is very important to provide a need
based health care services to the population Visiting official channels in a formally
recognized health care system has been considered as the desired Health seeking behaviour
Health seeking behavior is influenced by multiple factors including availability quality and
price of services and also social groups health views residences and personal features of the
users Peoplersquos choice of health care differs in socio demographic socio-economic and
cultural compositions and this has an effect on their health seeking behavior Urban dwellers
are generally believed to be open to new ideas and willing to try certain things on a trial and
error basis21
12
Review of literature
Health seeking behaviours two approaches
(a) Health seeking behaviours utilization of the system
This approach focuses on the actions which are taken to rectify perceived ill health and
the type of health care facility which is utilized by the people There is data which
suggests that the people visit more traditional healers and unofficial medical channels
this should be prevented and the emphasis s h o u l d b e on encouraging people to opt
first for the official channels
(b) Health seeking behaviours the process of illness response
This approach considers the factors which enable or prevent people from making
healthy choices either i n their lifestyle behaviours or use of medical care and
treatment22
Figure 3 Predicting health behaviour with social cognition models 22
13
Review of literature
2 Health belief Model of health seeking behaviour
Since lsquoHealth seekingrsquo is a conditioned behaviour any attempt which is made to
encourage people to seek health care definitely requires an understanding of their
motivation for such behaviour Only through a deeper understanding of the intricate
factors shaping behavioural practices can health promotion programmes and or
interventions successfully be introduced into the realities of the peoplersquos lives to bring
about changes in health behaviour
Behaviour change theories and models such as the Health Belief Model (HBM)
Theory of Reasoned Action (TRA) Theory of Planned Behaviour (TPB) and the
Trans theoretical model have been widely applied in public health in an attempt to
explain or predict health seeking behaviours Their use enables identification and
understanding of peoplersquos health-seeking behaviour beyond their knowledge attitudes
and practices
HBM is a health specific behavioural cognitive model This model is based on the
idea that people are more likely to change their behaviour and adhere to treatments
if they have the following perceptions (i) have a perception that they are at risk of
contracting the disease (perceived susceptibility) (ii) perception that the disease
might have an unfavorable outcome (perceived severity) (iii) perceive that the
proposed health behaviour to be both effective and practical (perceived benefits)
(iv) perceive the barriers to adopting the behaviour to be minimal (perceived
barriers)(v) perceive themselves to have the ability of applying and practicing the
specific behaviour proposed (perceived self-efficacy) and (vi) they have the cues
for motivating their actions such as internal cues (pain symptoms past experiences)
or external cues (advice from friends relatives and mass media campaigns) (cues to
14
Review of literature
action) The specificity of the HBM to health has made it suitable for use in
understanding and explaining the behaviour as well as health outcomes and this may also
explain its wider use in public health2 3
Figure 4 Health belief model components and linkages 23
3 Factors influencing health seeking behaviour
The factors affecting the health seeking behaviours are seen in various contexts which
include physical socio-economic cultural and political factors Therefore the utilization of
a health care system whether public or private formal or non- formal may depend on socio-
demographic factors social structures level of education cultural beliefs and practices and
some other factors like gender discrimination status of women economic and political
systems environmental conditions and the disease pattern and health care system itself also
have an impact on the health seeking behaviour24
15
Review of literature
REVIEW OF RELATED STUDIES
A study done by Sanjay Polisetty and Madhavi Seepana (2017) on the morbidity profile
of elderly individuals in urban Visakhapatnam revealed that of the 270 study participants
about 996 suffered from either some form of acute or chronic morbidity More than 70
of individuals suffered from eye problems of which most common problem was cataract
seen in 60 About 304 had difficulties in chewing and 256 had difficulty in hearing
Hypertension was present in 49 of individuals and 742 of Diabetics were also found to
be hypertensive25
A study done by Swapnil Jain et al (2016) on Morbidity pattern among geriatric
population in urban field practice area of a district in Maharashtra revealed 653 suffered
from hearing impairment 62 were anemic 462 had hypertension 423 had joint
pain 41 had dental problems 38 7 had cataract and 318 had chronic bronchitis It
was seen that 81 of the subjects had multiple morbidities 26
A study done by Rajat Das Gupta et al (2016) in an urban area of Bangladesh on Morbidity
pattern and health-seeking behavior among the senior citizens revealed that of the 384 study
participants 968 were suffering from at least one medical problem The commonest was
musculoskeletal problems in 8411 followed by eye problems in 8125 It was found that
all the respondents sought treatment for their health problems 33 respondents went to
Government hospitals to seek medical help 6927 respondents took prescribed
medications and 567 were satisfied with their treatment 27
16
Review of literature
A study done by Md Alam Naushad et al (2016) on Morbidity pattern and health
seeking behavior in elderly population of Raipur City Chhattisgarh revealed that the
prevalence of morbidity among elderly was 9531 Out of total morbid population some
chronic illness was present in 7049 Gastro intestinal system was involved in 8262
followed by eye in 7983 and Cardiovascular system in 5245 It was found that 3552
of the subjects sought treatment from private registered practitioners 28
A study done by Sribas Goswami and Manjari Sahai (2016) in Raipur city on Morbidity
Pattern in elderly Population revealed that out of total study population of 640 elderly
subjects 610 (9531) suffered from some morbidity Prevalence among females was
9892 whereas among males it was 9026 Out of various agencies 3552 subjects
were utilizing private facility followed by 2785 who were utilizing Government agency
2631 visited quacks and 1030 were taking treatment from other source 29
A study done by Harsh Bardhan et al (2016) on the Morbidity profile of elderly population
in Ghaziabad district revealed that in geriatric population 5008 suffered from
musculoskeletal problems 5877 had dental problems and impairment of vision was seen
in 5561 The overall prevalence of diabetes and heart disease were 10 and 122
respectively 236 subjects reported the problem of loneliness and depression
forgetfulness was also reported by 3296 As far as treatment seeking behavior is
concerned approach of elderly is quite different for different morbidities The main source
of treatment for morbidities such as hypertension respiratory urinary GIT-related and
musculoskeletal problems was quacks 30
17
Review of literature
A study done by Mohammad Maharoof et al (2016) on the health problems among
the aged in Urban Aligarh UP revealed that of the 225 study subjects 782 had cataract
followed by depression in 356 refractive error in 276 loco-motor problem in 213
and hearing loss in 138 The prevalence of hearing loss was significantly related to gender
as it was higher among females with 181 compared to males in whom it was 6931
A study done by Gowri Shankar and Bhayalaxmi Sidenur (2016) on morbidity of
elderly residing in an urban area of Bagalkot revealed that the most common morbidity was
Cataract seen in 2875 followed by musculoskeletal problems in 2813 and 2313
were known hypertensive Both diabetes mellitus and hypertension was observed in 10 of
the study subjects32
A study done by Leena Rahul Salunkhe (2015) on socio-demographic profile of old
age people living in urban amp urban slum areas in Maharashtra Karad revealed that 504
and 42 elderly suffered from arthritis in an urban area and a slum respectively Number of
diabetics were higher in urban (14) than urban slum (35) 301 of subjects from urban
area suffered from hypertension compared to 161 from urban slums Upper Respiratory
Infections was more in slum dwellers (196) than people residing in urban area (7) Acid
peptic diseases were found in 168 study subjects in urban area and 154 in slum area 33
In a study done by Warbhe Priyanka A and Warbhe Rupesh (2015) on morbidity
profile health seeking behaviour and home environment survey of the elderly in an urban
slum community it was found that 941 had 1-3 morbidities 41 had 4-6 morbidities
373 gave a history of fall and 314 had history of fracture 136 subjects had been
18
Review of literature
operated for cataract 168 had undergone a procedure for fracture and10 had undergone
a dental procedure 542 went to Urban health center (UHC) and Government hospitals for
treatment and 786 received both allopathic and Ayurvedic treatment34
A study done by Man Mohan Gupta et al (2015) on Assessment of Clinico-
socioeconomic status and health-care support among the elderly people aged older than 60
years in urban population of Bhopal revealed that 353 subjects received treatment for
their morbidities from the Government hospitals whereas 267 from private
clinichospital About 653 study subjects presented with complaints and morbidity The
common morbidities which were found in the subjects were fatigue (487) backache
(353) Obesity (393) and hypertension (247)35
In a study done by Shilpa Shaukaiah et al (2015) on prevalence of morbidity pattern
among geriatric age group in an urban slum of Mumbai it was found that body ache was the
most commonly reported symptom by 290 followed by visual problems in 2318 joint
pain in 2181 indigestion in 2045 and backache in 2045 subjects36
A study done by Shubha Davalagi B et al (2015) on morbidity psycho-social profile and
health seeking behavior of the elderly population in urban slums of Davangere City revealed
that the most common morbidity which was present in the study subjects was
musculoskeletal problems in 46 psychosocial problems were present in 31 and
respiratory problems in 23 Majority of the elderly (56) utilized government
institutions for treatment of chronic disease and 47 for treatment of acute disease The
elderly population had financial constraints and lack of accessibility in seeking health care37
19
Review of literature
A study done by Vandana Nikumb et al ( 2015) on morbidity Profile among Geriatric
Population in an Urban Area of Navi Mumbai revealed that 9312 elderly were morbid and
with increasing age the number of morbidities was found to be increasing In this study it
was found that the most common morbidity was psychosocial problems which include
stress which was present in 594 subjects followed by musculoskeletal problems in
556 and eye problems like diminished vision mostly due to cataract in 463
Hypertension dental problems respiratory problems ENT problems (hearing impairment)
and endocrine disorders like diabetes accounted for 281 219 119 106 and10
respectively38
A study done by Vishnoi BR et al (2015) on Morbidity Profile of Elderly in Urban
Slum of Udaipur Rajasthan revealed that 61 of the study subjects had impaired vision
followed by 25 who had hypertension 1533 suffered from insomnia 1467 had
anemia and 14 suffered from gastrointestinal problems The condition of females was
worse compared to males39
In a study done by L Subedhi and RB Sah (2015) on the health status of geriatric age
group in Chitwan district of Nepal it was found that of the 300 study subjects 44 had
Ophthalmic problems 43 had GIT problems 33 had CVS problems 23 had ENT
problems 1567 had metabolic disorders and 533 had mental disorders The study
highlighted a high prevalence of morbidity and health related problems in the geriatric age
group40
20
Review of literature
A study done by Sofia Noor et al (2015) on health status of geriatric population in slums
of Rourkela revealed that the morbidities among the elderly that were found to be significant
were hypertension decreased visual acuity urinary problems and insomnia Apart from
systemic morbidities 91 of the elderly also complained of fragility which includes
complex physiological deterioration and unexplained weight loss41
In a study conducted by VM Sarode (2014) on Chronic Diseases Related to Ageing and
Disease Prevention in Slums in Mumbai it was found that there were highly significant
disorders among aged women related to Skin lesion and super infection Untreated bacterial
pharyngitis acute rheumatic fever while disorders among aged men were related to
hypertension Illicit drug use diabetes and asthma It was found that 49 of elderly males
and 45 of elderly females had not sought any treatment for their illness Of the people who
had sought treatment 93 elderly males and 92 of elderly females had taken treatment
from Government hospital42
A study conducted by Sanjeev Kumar Barman et al (2014) on morbidity profile of
geriatric population in an urban slum of Kishnganj Bihar revealed that the prevalence of
anemia cataract and hypertension were quite high 6375 6125 and 5063
respectively Loss of income amp occupation along with a feeling of neglect from the family
members were the common problems among the elderly It was also found that morbidities
like arthritis loss of teeth amp dental caries along with depression had a significant association
with sex age amp educational status of the study subjects43
21
Review of literature
A study done by Khadervali Nagoor et al (2014) on the health status of elderly
population in an urban area of Kadapa revealed that out of the 200 elderly persons studied
Visual problem due to cataract and refractive errors were present in 72 of the study
subjects followed by pain in joints in 595 gastrointestinal problems in 46 and dental
problems in 44 Other morbidities were hypertension in 42 genitourinary problems in
25 dermatological problems in 235 and psychological problems in 1644
A study done by Kakkar R et al (2013) on morbidity profile among geriatric population
in District Dehradun revealed that the working geriatric group was healthy as compared to
those who were retired Hypertension was the commonest morbidity among all age groups
In the age group of 60-70 years the following morbidities were seen hypertension (306)
followed by diabetes (153) arthritis (14) CVS morbidities (14) cataract (96) and
BPH (83) Among 71-80 years age group Hypertension (287) followed by arthritis
(167) cataract (157) Diabetes (111) BPH (111) and CVS morbidities (93)45
In a study done by Bhawalkar JS et al (2013) on morbidity profile among geriatric
population in an urban area of Pune it was found that Musculoskeletal disorder was the
most common (4331) followed by eye problems (3722) and hypertension (137)It
was seen that 43 elderly population had some health problem but only 8 visited the
health facilities Among them 6 visited private practitioners and only 18 went to
municipal hospitals It was found that only 2322 elderly were taking any medications and
the most commonly used drug was anti-inflammatory drugs 2323 followed by
antihypertensive drugs 136746
22
Review of literature
A study conducted by Deepak Sharma et al (2013) on morbidity pattern and health-
seeking behavior of aged population residing in Shimla revealed that the following
morbidities were present in the study subjects hypertension was the commonest (56)
followed by Musculoskeletal problems (535) Dental problems (27) cataract (23)
anemia (15) and acid peptic disease (175) 658 of the subjects were seeking
treatment for their health problems Majority of the older people preferred allopathic
medicine (812) followed by Ayurvedic medicines (113) and homeopathic medicine
(73) for their health problems Most of the older persons preferred going to a
CHCGovernment hospital for treatment for their illness There was considerable use of
over-the-counter drug by125 of the people 47
A study done by JP Singh et al (2013) on Geriatric morbidity profile in an urban slum of
Nagpur central India revealed that the most common morbidity identified in the study
population was anemia (9650) followed by hypertension (345) arthritis (3225)
cataract (21) and diabetes (1775) More than 2 morbidities were present in 325 of
the study subjects followed by four morbidities in 3125 and two morbidities in 23548
A study conducted by RP Thakur et al (2013) on the health problems of the elderly in
central India revealed that among the elderly residing in the urban areas 384 of the urban
elderly had both dental problems and arthritis followed by anemia in 348 hypertension in
266 cataract in 252 and diabetes mellitus in 157 The prevalence of self-reported
depression was 672 among the urban female elderly when compared to 397 among the
urban females49
23
Review of literature
A study done by Mrinal Ranjan Srivastav et al (2013) on Morbidity Status and its
Social determinants among elderly population of Lucknow revealed that the most common
morbidity among the urban population was eye problems which affected 516 males and
67 females followed by CVS problems in 363 males and 395 females and GIT
problems in 315males and 382 females50
A study done by Shraddha K et al (2012) on morbidity pattern among elderly in urban
population of Mysore revealed that out of the 526 study subjects 486 suffered from the
disease of the eye and adnexa followed by 384 who suffered from endocrine and
metabolic disorders 331 suffered from the disease of the circulatory system 323 had
disease of the oral cavity and salivary glands and 302 had disease of the musculoskeletal
system 51
A study done by Vimala Thomas et al (2012) on morbidity profile and health seeking
behaviour of the elderly in urban slums of Hyderabad revealed that hypertension was the
most common morbidity in 469 followed by Arthritis in 302 Diabetes in 265
respiratory problems in 243 and Cataract in 21 For out-patient treatment 472 visited
private sectors 303 Government facility 25 RMP and 06 AYUSH clinics For in-
patient treatment 198 visited private institutions 16 visited Government institutions
while 642 did not visit either52
24
Review of literature
A study done by Soe Moe et al (2012) on health seeking behaviour of elderly in
Myanmar revealed that 35 of the male elderly perceived that they were having good
health status whereas 229 of them perceived having a poor health status 343 of female
elderly perceived that they were having good health status while 24 of them perceived
having a poor health About 49 of the elderly went to rural health center for treatment
followed by 33 who went to private practitioners 15 visited hospitals and 3 went to
more than one place for treatment53
A study done by Dharamvir Ranjan Bharati et al (2011) in Puducherry revealed that in
the urban areas about 707 of the study subjects had anemia followed by 537 who had
visual impairment and hypertension and 532 suffered from diabetes mellitus It was seen
that On univariate analysis the risk of diabetes mellitus was significantly higher among
elderly from urban areas than that among elderly from rural areas and significantly lower
risk in elderly from below poverty line than in those belonging to normal (not below poverty
line)54
A study done by Rajashree Bhat et al (2011) on the morbidity pattern among the elderly
population in Ahmedabad revealed that most common morbidity of elderly was the
problems of loco-motor system (486) followed by vision (427) and hypertension
(344) In this study only 37 of elderly had psychosocial problems55
A study done by Krishnamachari Srinivasan et al (2010) in an urban area of Bangalore
revealed that 494 subjects had hypertension 323 had diabetes 281 had arthritis
279 suffered from Genitourinary and cardiovascular disease It was observed that about
25
Review of literature
49 of the respondents made less than three physician visits and 13 were hospitalized for
health related problems during the past one year 56
A study done by Kajal Srivastava et al (2010) on the morbidity pattern of the elderly in
urban Agra revealed that 9529 of the elderly were morbid in the slum areas The most
common morbidity which was seen among the elderly people residing in urban slums was
anemia which was seen in 3843 followed by cataract in 298 arthritis in 2431 and
hearing impairments in 2157The system wise distribution of the morbidity pattern
showed the most common systemic involvement was visual disorders 5216 followed by
musculoskeletal system 4784 and the gastrointestinal system 4314 The number of
morbidities was found to be increasing with age and this association with age was
statistically significant57
A study done by Abdullah Ladha et al (2009) on the health seeking behaviour of elderly
population in a poor-urban community of Karachi Pakistan revealed that 164 of the
elderly people were Diabetic and 301 had Hypertension The Common symptoms that
prompted elderly of to seek health care were fever (612) generalized body aches (434)
and cough (404) About 614 responders reported factors which deterred them from
seeking health care out of which 62 reported financial constraint as the commonest factor
Deterrence from seeking health care was associated with illiteracy and living alone58
26
Methodology METHODOLOGY
The study was conducted in the urban field practice area of JJM Medical college
Davangere The city of Davangere is situated in the central part of Karnataka state
265 km north of the state capital Bengaluru along the national highway number 4
Figure 5 Maps showing the location of Davangere district and the area where the
UHTC is located
27
Methodology
Figure 6 Map showing the Urban field practice area of JJM medical college
28
Methodology
Table 3 List of areas covered under the UHTC of JJM Medical
College Davangere
Areas covered Total population Bethur road 1374 Hedge nagar 1213 Mehboob nagar 3042 Mustafa nagar A 2093 B D layout A 1084 Mustafa nagar B 1127 Mahavir nagar 930 Muddabovi colony 1094 Maganhalli 1221 Tippu nagar 968 B D layout B 1717 Batti layout 1080
STUDY AREA The study was conducted in the urban field practice area of JJM
Medical College Davangere which consists of 12 areas with a total population of
16943
STUDY DESIGN Cross sectional study
STUDY POPULATION Persons aged 60 years and above
Total Population Covered 16943
29
Methodology
INCLUSION CRITERIA subjects aged 60 years and above living in the study area
for more than one year duration
EXCLUSION CRITERIA Subjects who we r e no t w i l l i ng t o pa r t i c ipa t e i n
t he s t udy
STUDY PERIOD 1 year from 1st December 2015 to 30th November 2016
SAMPLE SIZE As quoted by Manmohan Gupta et al 35 in the studies done in various
parts of India the prevalence of morbidity in the geriatric population ranges from 31-80
Considering the prevalence of morbidity to be about 50 in the geriatric population at 95
confidence level and allowable error of 10 and a non -response rate of 10 sample size
was calculated to be 440 using the formula
n=4pq L2
n= sample size
4= factor to achieve 95 level of confidence
p= prevalence of morbidities ie 50
q= 100- p ie 100-50 = 50
L= permissible error in the estimate of ldquoprdquo (10 of p)
n = 4 x 50 x 50 = 400
5 x 5
After calculating a non-response rate of 10 a sample size of 440 was calculated
30
Methodology
A community based cross sectional study was conducted in the urban field practice
area of JJM Medical College Davangere The Urban field practice area has a total
population of 16943 and there are 12 areas in urban field practice area of JJM Medical
College Davangere
The Study was conducted by probability proportionate sampling The sample size for each
area was derived from the formula
1198991 =119875119900119901119906119897119886119905119894119900119899 119894119899 119890119886119888ℎ 119886119903119890119886
119879119900119905119886119897 119875119900119901119906119897119886119905119894119900119899119883 119878119886119898119901119897119890 119878119894119911119890
Example 1st area has a population of 1374 so
1198991 =1374
16943119883 440 = 36
Therefore 36 elderly subjects were selected by house to house visit from 1st area Same
procedure was applied for other areas until the desired sample size of 440 was reached
MATERIALS USED FOR DATA COLLECTION
The following tools were used for data collection
Semi-structured predesigned and pre-tested questionnaire
Portable bathroom weighing machine
Stretch- resistant measuring tape
Mercury Sphygmomanometer
Others - stethoscope torch tuning fork knee hammer
ICD-10 for system wise classification of disease59
31
Methodology METHOD OF COLLECTION OF DATA After establishing rapport with the family
and explaining the data collection procedure in the local language an informed verbal
consent was obtained from each individual and data was collected using a
Predesigned semi structured questionnaire by Interview method The questionnaire
comprised of the following information socio-demographic data of the study subjects
information regarding the morbidity pattern and health seeking behaviour If there were
more than one elderly subjects in the same household then all were included
The study subjects were asked about any ho illness (communicable or non-
communicable) which they were suffering from Upon a positive response the subjects were
further asked to specify the type(s) and duration of morbidities that they were suffering
from eg heart disease diabetes gastrointestinal diseases respiratory disease etc Some
were unable to understand or answer questions due to illness In such cases help was sought
from the family members Based on the self-reported symptoms information from
hospital records and clinical examination the prevalence of different morbidities among the
study subjects was assessed The Information about the health seeking behaviour was
sought by asking the study subjects about their visits to a health facility in case of an illness
and also the type of health facility visited ( Government private or quacks )
DATA ENTRY AND ANALYSIS Data was entered and analyzed using MS Excel and
Open Epi Info version 2260 Both descriptive and inferential statistics were used Subjectrsquos
baseline characteristics were presented as frequencies and percentages Categorical
variables between the groups were compared using Chi square test and Fisherrsquos exact
test Fisherrsquos exact test was used when more than 20 cells had expected value lt 5 and any
one of the cells had expected value lt 1 All statistical analysis was carried out at 5 level
of significance and p value lt005 was considered as significant
32
Methodology ETHICAL CLEARANCE
Ethical clearance was obtained before conducting the study from the Ethical Committee of
JJM Medical college Davangere [ANNEXURE III] During the study verbal
informed consent was taken from the study subjects Assurance was given that the
confidentiality concerning their information will be maintained
Clinical Examination included
(a) General physical examination
(b) Anthropometric measurements like height and weight
(c) Systemic examination
(d) Measurement of Blood pressure
(e) Eye examination by torch and Snellenrsquos (E chart)61
(f) Hearing assessment by Rinnersquos test Webberlsquos and Absolute bone conduction
test using tuning fork 62
Parameters used in our study
Height Height was measured with a standard non-stretchable measuring tape to the
nearest 01 cm in standing position (without footwear standing upright with the
back against the wall heels together and eyes directed forward)
33
Methodology Weight Weight was measured with minimal clothing and respecting the modesty of the
individual without footwear using a calibrated standard bathroom weighing scale to the
nearest 05 kg
Body Mass Index (BMI) Using weight (in Kg) and height (in meter2) BMI was calculated by applying the formula
Body Mass Index= Weight (kg) Height (m2)
The BMI cut off values for Asians as recommended by the WHO was used in our study
Table 4 WHO Categorization of Body Mass index (BMI) for Asians 63
Measurement of Blood pressure Procedure Blood pressure was measured in the left arm in a sitting posture with the subject in a
relaxed state Standardized mercury sphygmomanometer with adult size cuff was used
The first appearance of (phase 1 of Korotkoff sounds) sound was used to define
Systolic Blood Pressure (SBP) The disappearance of sound (phase 5) was used to
define Diastolic Blood Pressure (DBP) Two readings were taken five minutes apart and
the average of the two readings was taken as the final blood pressure reading A person
was considered to be a hypertensive if he she was already diagnosed case of
hypertension and or on treatment or with a current SBP of ge 140 mm Hg or DBP ge 90 mm
Hg (JNC VII criteria)64
BODY MASS INDEX INFERENCE
lt 185 underweight
185 to 229 kg m2 Normal
23 to 249 kg m2 Overweight
ge 25 kg m2 Obese
34
Methodology
Table 5 JNC VII Classification of Blood pressure 65
BP Classification Systolic Blood Pressure Diastolic Blood Pressure
Normal lt120 lt 80
Pre Hypertension 120 ndash 139 or 80 ndash 89 Stage 1 Hypertension 140 ndash 159 or 90 ndash 99 Stage 2 Hypertension ge 160 or ge 100
Anaemia was detected by pallor of conjunctiva tongue and nails and was confirmed by
doing haemoglobin estimation using sahlirsquos hemogobinometer66
The cut off for the diagnosis of anaemia was done based on WHO classification67
Diabetes - self reported cases of diabetes were considered as diabetics for the study
STUDY VARIABLES
1 AGE - subjects aged 60 years and above were taken up for the study Age was
recorded to the nearest complete years as stated by the respondent
2 GENDER Both males and females were taken up for the study
3 EDUCATIONAL STATUS 68
i Illiterate -A person who could not read or write
ii Primary School - studied up to 4th standard
iii Higher primary- studied between 5th and 7th standard
iv Secondary school -studied between 8th and 10th standard v Intermediate- studied between 11th or 12 th standard or diploma
vi Graduate - obtained graduate degree
vii Post Graduate- obtained post graduate degree
35
Methodology
4 OCCUPATION STATUS69
i Unskilled worker
Labourer domestic servants casual worker peon sweeper porter washer-man others
(vegetable vendor)
ii Semi-skilled worker
Factory worker agriculture laborers shoemaker potters others (security guard shop
helper canteen helper
iii Skilled
Artisan clerk foreman supervisor carpenter tailor mechanic electrician railway guard
painter modeler smiths baker driver shop assistant petty trader constable soldier
linesman pointsman potter barber others (tinkering printer receptionist salesman
welder cook mason postman plumber agarbatti worker)
iv semi-professional
Teacher pharmacist social worker owner of a small business farmer others (computer
programmer Govt employee nurse)
V Professional
Doctor engineer principal lawyer Military officer senior executive business
proprietor writer scientist large employer director university professor police
officer others (horse rider)
(vi) Unemployed Presently not working retired homemakers
36
Methodology 5 SOCIO ECONOMIC STATUS
Table 6 Socio-economic status (SES)- As per modified BG Prasad Classification70
5 TYPE OF FAMILY 71
Joint Family ndash It is type of family grouping in which a number of married couples and
their children live together in the same household All the men are related by blood
and women of household are their wives unmarried girls and widows of family kinsmen
Nuclear Family - It consist of married couple and their children while they are still
regarded as dependents
Three generation family - It is a family where representatives of three generation are
living together Young married couples continue to stay with their parents and have
their own children as well
Socio-economic
status
Prasadrsquos classification
1961(Per capita income in
Rupees per month)
Modified BG Prasad classification-
updated for May 2016 ((per
capita income in Rupees per
month)
I 100 and above 6261 and above
II 50-99 3099-6260
III 30-49 1835-3098
IV 15-29 949-1834
V Below 15 lt948
37
SAMPLE SIZE ESTIMATION
SAMPLE SIZE As quoted by Manmohan Gupta et al 35 in the studies done in various
parts of India the prevalence of morbidity in the geriatric population ranges from 31-80
Considering the prevalence of morbidity to be about 50 in the geriatric population at 95
confidence level and allowable error of 10 and a non -response rate of 10 sample size
was calculated to be 440 using the formula
n=4pq L2
n= sample size
4= factor to achieve 95 level of confidence
p= prevalence of morbidities ie 50
q= 100- p ie 100-50 = 50
L= permissible error in the estimate of ldquoprdquo (10 of p)
n = 4 x 50 x 50 = 400
5 x 5
After calculating a non-response rate of 10 a sample size of 440 was calculated
A community based cross sectional study was conducted in the urban field practice area of
JJM Medical College Davangere The Urban field practice area has a total population of
16943 and there are 12 areas in urban field practice area of JJM Medical College
Davangere
The Study was conducted by probability proportionate sampling The sample size for each area
was derived from the formula
1198991 =119875119900119901119906119897119886119905119894119900119899 119894119899 119890119886119888ℎ 119886119903119890119886
119879119900119905119886119897 119875119900119901119906119897119886119905119894119900119899119883 119878119886119898119901119897119890 119878119894119911119890
Example 1st area has a population of 1374 so
1198991 =1374
16943119883 440 = 36
Therefore 36 elderly subjects were selected by house to house visit from 1st area Same
procedure was applied for other areas until the desired sample size of 440 was reached
Results
RESULTS
The results are presented under the following headings
I Socio-demographic characteristics of study subjects
II Prevalence of morbidities among the study subjects
III Details of health seeking behavior of the study subjects
38
Results
ISocio-demographic characteristics of the study subjects
Table 7 Age and sex wise distribution of the study subjects
Figure 7 Age and sex wise distribution of the study subjects
In the present study Out of 440 study subjects majority 162(368) were in the age group
of 60-64 Years followed by 109 (247) in the age group of 65-69 Years 99 (225) were
in the age group of 70-74 Years and 35 (8) were more than or equal to 80 years of age
Majority of the subjects were males 260 (59) and 180 (41) were females The mean age
of the study population was 6745 plusmn 655 Years
354 254 262
88 42
389
239 172
67 133
0102030405060708090
100
60-64 65-69 70-74 75-79 ge80
Perc
enta
ge
Age in years
Males
Females
Age group (in years)
Males Females Total
Percentage () Frequency
(n=260) Percentage ()
Frequency (n=180)
Percentage ()
60-64 92 354 70 389 162 368
65-69 66 254 43 239 109 247
70-74 68 262 31 172 99 225
75-79 23 88 12 67 35 80
ge80 11 42 24 133 35 80
Total 260 100 180 100 440 100
39
Results
Table 8 Distribution of the study subjects based on religion
Religion Frequency (n=440) Percentage ()
Hindu 188 427
Muslim 252 573
Total 440 100
Figure 8 Distribution of the study subjects based on religion
In the present study it was found that the majority of the study subject belonged to Muslim
religion 252 (573) followed by Hindus 188 (427)
0102030405060708090
100
Hindu Muslim
427
573
Perc
enta
ge
Religion of the study subjects
40
Results
Table 9 Distribution of the study subjects based on Educational status
Education Frequency (n=440) Percentage ()
Illiterate 231 525
Primary school 121 275
Higher primary 38 86
Secondary School 30 68
Intermediate 6 14
Graduate 14 32
Total 440 100
Figure 9 Distribution of the study subjects based on Educational status
In the present study it was found that the Majority of the study subjects were illiterate
231(525) 121(275) had completed education up to primary school 30(68) had
completed education up to secondary school and only 14(32) were graduates
525
275
86 68
14 32
0102030405060708090
100
Perc
enta
ge
Educational status of study subjects
41
Results Table 10 Distribution of the study subjects based on occupation
Occupation Frequency (n=440) Percentage ()
Semi-professional 2 05
Skilled worker 45 102
Semi-skilled worker 68 155
Unskilled worker 100 227
Unemployed 225 511
Total 440 100
Figure 10 Distribution of study subjects based on their occupation
In our study it was found that the majority of the study subjects 225 (511) were
unemployed followed by 100 (227) who were unskilled workers 68 (155) were semi-
skilled workers and 45 (102) were skilled workers
0102030405060708090
100
05 102 155 227
511
Perc
enta
ge
Occupation of the study subjects
42
Results Table 11 Distribution of the study subjects based on socio-economic status (Modified
BG Prasad classification 2016)
Figure 11 Distribution of the study subjects based on their socio-economic status
In our study majority of the subjects 215 (49) belonged to Class IV Socioeconomic status
followed by 115 (26) who belonged to class III and 56 (13) who belonged to class II
SES (according to Modified BG Prasad Classification 2016)
Class II 13
Class III 26
Class IV 49
Class V 12
Socio-economic status Frequency (n=440) Percentage ()
Class I 0 0
Class II 56 13
Class III 115 26
Class IV 215 49
Class V 54 12
Total 440 100
43
Results
Table 12 Distribution of the study subjects based on their marital status
Marital status Frequency (n=440) Percentage ()
Unmarried 2 05
Married 323 734
Widowwidower 115 261
Total 440 100
Figure 12 Distribution of the study subjects based on their marital status
In our study it was found that majority of the study subjects 323(734) were married
followed by 115(261) who were widowed and only 2 (05) were unmarried
0102030405060708090
100
Unmarried married Widowwidower
05
734
261 Perc
enta
ge
44
Results
Table 13 Distribution of the study subjects based on the type of family
Type of family Frequency (n=440) Percentage ()
Nuclear family 163 37
Joint family 93 21
Three generation family 184 42
Total 440 100
Figure 13 Distribution of the study subjects based on the type of family
In the present study it was found that majority of the study subjects 184 (42) lived in a
three generation family followed by 163 (37) who lived in a nuclear family and 93(21)
who lived in a Joint family
Nuclear family 37
Joint family 21
Three generation
family 42
45
Results
II Prevalence of morbidities among the study subjects
Figure 14 Distribution of the study subjects based on the BMI
In the present study it was found that out of 440 study subjects 198 (45) had a normal
BMI followed by 132 (30) who were overweight 66 (15) were obese and only 44
(10) were underweight
under weight 10
Normal 45
Overweight 30
Obese 15
46
Results
Table 14 Distribution of morbidity pattern of the study subjects based on ICD 10
classification of diseases
System involved ICD 10
Males (n=260)
Females (n=180)
Total (n=440)
No No No
Diseases of musculoskeletal system (M00 ndash M99)
184 707 130 722 314 714
Diseases of the eye and adnexa (H00 ndash H59)
139 534 80 444 219 497
Diseases of oral cavityamp salivary glands (K00 ndash K14)
90 346 64 355 154 35
Endocrine nutritional amp metabolic diseases (E00 ndash
E90)
70 269 75 417 145 329
Diseases of circulatory system (I00 ndash I99)
64 246 73 405 137 311
Diseases of respiratory system(J00 ndash J99)
64 246 37 206 101 23
Diseases of digestive system (K00 ndash K93)
57 219 30 166 87 198
Diseases of skin amp subcutaneous tissue (L00 ndash
L99)
38 146 20 111 58 132
Diseases of the ear and mastoid process (H60 ndashH95)
39 15 18 10 57 13
Diseases of genitourinary system (N00 ndash N99)
22 85 7 39 29 66
Diseases of nervous system (G00 ndash G99)
6 23 5 28 11 25
Note Total number could not be given as many subjects had multiple disorders
47
Results
Figure 15 Distribution of morbidity pattern of the study subjects based on ICD 10
classification of diseases
In the present study it was found that the majority of the subjects 314 (714) suffered
from the disorders of the musculoskeletal system followed by 219 (497) who suffered
from the disease of the eye and adnexa154 (35) suffered from the disease of the oral
cavity 145 (329) suffered from endocrine nutritional and metabolic disorders137
(311) suffered from the disease of the circulatory system 101 (229) suffered from the
disease of the respiratory system 87(198) suffered from the disease of the digestive
system 58 (132) suffered from disease of the skin 57 (13) suffered from the disease of
the ear 29 (66) suffered from the disease of the genitourinary system and only 11( 25 )
suffered from the disease of the nervous system
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
714
497
35 329 311 229
198 132 13 66
25
perc
enta
ge
48
Results
Table 15 Distribution of the study subjects based on morbidity of the musculoskeletal
system
Musculoskeletal
Disease
Males
(n=260)
Females
(n=180)
Total
(n= 440)
Statistical
Value
Knee joint pain
52 (20)
30 (167)
82 (186)
X2 = 0779
df = 1
p=03773
Back ache
30 (115)
35 (194)
65 (148) X2 = 528
df = 1
p = 0021
Joint pain (other than
knee joint pain)
52(20)
35(194)
87(198)
X2 =00206
df=1
p =0885
Non-specific aches
and pain
50(192)
30(167)
80(182)
X2=0470
df=1
p = 0492
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses
In the present study it was found that the most common morbidity of musculoskeletal
system was pain of the joints (other than the knee joint) found in 87 (198) of the subjects
followed by knee joint pain in 82 ( 186) and non-specific pains and aches were found in
80 (182) of the subjects It was found that back ache was more common in females
35(194) compared to males 30 (115) and this difference was found to be statistically
significant
49
Results
Table 16 Distribution of the study subjects based on morbidity of the eye and adnexa
Diseases of the
eye and
adnexa
Males
(n=260)
Females
(n=180)
Total
(n= 440)
Statistical
value
Cataract
112(43)
60(333)
172(391)
X2 = 4241
df=1
p = 0039
Refractive error
20(77)
14(78)
34(77)
X2= 0001
df=1
p = 0973
Others (conjunctivitis
pterygium glaucoma etc)
7(27)
6(33)
13(29)
X2=0152
df=1
p = 0696
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses
In the present study it was found that the most common morbidity of the eye was cataract
found in 172 (391) of the subjects It was more common in males 112 (43) compared to
females 60 (333) and this difference was found to be statistically significant The other
morbidities present were refractive error found in 34 (77) subjects and others which
includes conjunctivitis pterygium glaucoma etc found in 13 (29 ) subjects
50
Results
Table 17 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the oral cavity
Diseases of the
oral cavity
Males
(n =260 )
Females
(n =180 )
Total
(n = 440)
Statistical
value
Stained teeth
22 (84)
18 (10)
40 (91)
X2 =0304
df=1
p = 0581
Missing teeth
40 (154)
38 (211)
78 (177)
X2= 239
df= 1
p=0122
Caries
28 (108)
8 (44)
36 (82)
X2= 566
df= 1
p=0017
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses
In the present study it was found that the most common morbidity of the oral cavity was
missing teeth found in 78 (177 ) of the subjects followed by stained teeth found in 40
(91) of the subjects and dental caries in 36 (82) of the subjects Dental caries were
more common in males 28 (108) compared to females 8(44) and this difference was
found to be statistically significant
51
Results
Table 18 Distribution of study subjects based on endocrine nutritional and metabolic
disorders
Disorders Males
(n =260 )
Females
(n =180)
Total
(n = 440)
Statistical value
Diabetes mellitus
45 (173)
37 (206)
82 (186)
X2 = 0739
df= 1
p = 0389
Anemia
24 (92)
35 (194)
59 (134)
X2= 955
df = 1
p = 0001
Thyroid disorders
1(04)
3 (17)
4 (09)
p= 0309
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
The present study revealed that the most common disorder of the endocrine system was
diabetes mellitus found in 82 (186) of the subjects followed by the nutritional disorder of
anemia found in 59 (134) of the subjects It was seen that anemia was more common
among females 35 (194) compared to males 24 (92) This difference was found to be
statistically significant Disorders of the thyroid gland were found in 4 (09) of the subjects
being more common in females 3(17) compared to males 1 (04)
52
Results
Table 19 Distribution of the study subject based on disease of the circulatory system
Diseases of
circulatory
system
Males
(n=260 )
Females
(n =180)
Total
(n = 440)
Statistical
value
Hypertension
62 (238)
71 (394)
133 (302)
X2= 1227
df= 1
p = 0000
CAD MI
Arrhythmias
2 (08)
2 (11)
4 (09)
p =100
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
In our study it was found that the most common disease of the circulatory system was
hypertension which was found in 133 (302 ) of the subjects it was more common in
females 71 (394) compared to males 62 (239) and this difference was found to be
statistically significant The other disorders of the circulatory system were CAD MI
arrhythmias which were found only in 4 (09) of the study subjects
53
Results
Table 20 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the respiratory system
Disorders of
Respiratory
System
Males
(n=260)
Females
(n=180)
Total
(n=440)
Statistical
value
Bronchial asthma
3 (12)
3 (17)
6 (14)
p =0692
URTI
45 (173)
27 (15)
72 (164)
X2= 0413
df = 1
p = 0520
Acute Bronchitis
12 (46)
7 (39)
19 (43)
X2= 0135
df = 1
p = 0712
Pulmonary TB
4 (15)
0(00)
4 (09)
p =0148
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
Our study revealed that the most common disease of the respiratory system was URTI
(upper respiratory tract infection) found in 72 (164) subjects followed by acute bronchitis
in 19 (43 ) bronchial asthma in 6 (14) and pulmonary TB in only in 4 (09 ) subjects
Pulmonary TB was found in 4 (15) of the males whereas no females had TB however
this difference was not found to be statistically significant
54
Results
Table 21 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the digestive system
Disorders of
Gastrointestinal
system
Males
(n = 260)
Females
(n = 180)
Total
(n = 440)
Statistical value
Constipation
21(8)
6 (33)
27(61)
X2 =4155
df =1
p =0041
Gastritis
24 (92)
18 (10)
42(95)
X2= 0072
df = 1
p =0787
Bleeding per
rectum 3(12) 2(11) 5(11)
p =100
Others (Pain
abdomen
anorexia
indigestion)
9(35)
4 (22)
13 (3)
X2=0569
df =1
p=0450
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
Our study revealed that the most common disorder of the gastrointestinal system was
gastritis found in 42 (95) subjects followed by constipation in 27 ( 61) others which
include pain abdomen anorexia indigestion was found in 13 (3) and bleeding per rectum
was seen in 5 (11) It was seen that constipation was more common among males 21(8)
compared to females 6 (33) which was found to be statistically significant
55
Results
Table 22 Distribution the study subjects based on disease of the Skin and
subcutaneous tissue
Disorders of skin and
subcutaneous tissue
Males ( n = 260)
Females (n = 180)
Total (n = 440)
Statistical
value
Itching
19(73)
2(11)
21(48)
X2 =896
df=1
p = 0002
Scaling 6 (23)
3 (17)
9 (2)
p =0743
Pigmentation
5(19)
4 (22)
9 (2)
p =100
Dryness
8 (31)
11 (61)
19(43)
X2= 237
df = 1
p = 0123 Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
In the present study it was found that the most common disease of the skin was itching
which was present in 21 (48) of the study subjects followed by dryness in 19 (43) and 9
(2) of the subjects had scaling and pigmentation It was seen that itching was more
common among males 19 (73) compared to females 2 (11) and this difference was
found to be statistically significant
56
Results
Table 23 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the ear
Disease of the ear
Males
(n= 260)
Females
(n = 180)
Total
(n = 440) Statistical value
Hearing impairment
33 (126)
16 (89)
49 (111)
X2 =155
df =1
p =0212
Ear discharge
3 (12)
1 (06)
4(09)
p =0647
Tinnitus
3 (12)
1 (06)
4 (09)
p =0647
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
In the present study it was observed that hearing impairment was the most common
morbidity of the ear found in 49 (111) of the subjects though it was more common
among males 33 (126) compared to females 16 (89) the difference was not found to be
statistically significant The other disorders which affected the ear were ear discharge and
tinnitus both present in 4 (09) of the subjects
57
Results
Table 24 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the genitourinary
system
Disorders of
genitourinary system
Male
(n = 260)
Female
(n = 180)
Total
(n=440)
Statistical value
Burning micturition
2 (077)
2 (11)
4 (09)
p=100
Increased frequency of
micturition
20(77) 5(28) 25(57)
X2= 4794
df =1
p =0028 Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
In our study it was observed that the most common morbidity affecting the genitourinary
system was increased frequency of micturition in 25 (57) of the subjects followed by
burning micturition in 4 (09) of the study subjects Increased frequency of micturition was
more common among males 20 (77) compared to females 5 (28) and this difference
was found to be statistically significant
58
Results
Table 25 Distribution of the study subjects based on diseases of the Nervous system
Disease of the
nervous system Males
(n = 260)
Females
(n = 180)
Total
(n = 440)
p value
Memory loss
2 (77)
2 (11)
4 (09)
100
Stroke
2 (77)
0 (00)
2 (05)
0515
Neuritis
2 (77)
3 (17)
5 (11)
0652
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
Our study revealed that the most common disorder of the nervous system was neuritis seen
in 5 (11) of the subjects followed by memory loss in 4 (09) and stroke in 2 (05 ) of
the subjects It was observed that 2 (0 77) of males had suffered a stroke whereas none of
the females had suffered from stroke however this difference was not found to be
statistically significant
59
Results
Table 26 Association between morbidity pattern of the study subjects and their age
group
System involved 60-69Yrs
(n = 271)
70-79Yrs
(n = 134)
gt 80Yrs
(n = 35)
Total
( n = 440)
Statistical
value
Musculoskeletal
System
195 (72)
94 (70)
25 (710)
314 (714) X2= 0143
df = 2 p = 0930
Eye amp adnexa
125 (461)
69 (515)
25 (714)
219 (497) X2= 8166
df = 2 p = 0016
Oral cavity amp salivary gland
56 (207)
68 (507)
30 (857)
154 (350) X2= 7865
df = 2 p lt 00001
Endocrine nutritional amp
metabolic diseases
91 (335)
47 (35)
7 (200)
145 (329) X2= 297
df = 2 p = 0225
Circulatory
system
87 (321)
40 (298)
10 (285)
137 (311) X2= 0328
df = 2 p = 0848
Respiratory
system
64 (236)
31 (231)
6 (171)
101 (23) X2= 0738
df = 2 p = 0691
Digestive system
52 (191)
28 (210)
7 (200)
87 (191) X2= 0166
df = 2 p = 0 920
Skin and subcutaneous
tissue
43 (159)
13 (97)
2 (57)
58 (132) X2= 4831
df = 2 p = 0089
Ear amp mastoid process
27 (99)
20 (149)
10 (285)
57 (13) X2= 1018
d= 2 p = 0006
Genitourinary
system
20 (74)
8 (59)
1 (29)
29 (66) X2= 1151
df = 2 p = 0562
Nervous system
5 (18)
4 (29)
2 (57)
11 (25)
p = 0418
Figure in parenthesis indicates percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
60
Results
Table 26 shows the association between the morbidity pattern and age group of the study
subjects It is observed that the disease of the eye and adnexa increase with increasing age
and are more common in individuals above 80 years of age (714) compared to
individuals in the age group of 60-69 years (461) and 70-79 years (515) This
difference was found to be statistically significant The disease of the oral cavity were also
more common in the subjects aged 80 years and above (857) compared to individuals in
the age group of 70-79 years (507) and 60-69 years (207) this difference was also
found to be statistically significant Significant association was also found between
increasing age and disease of the ear 285 subjects aged 80 years and above suffered from
disease of the ear followed by 149 in the age group of 60-69 years and 99 in the age
group of 60-69 years
61
Results Table 27 Association between morbidity pattern of the study subjects and their
occupation
System involved Employed (n=215)
Unemployed (n=225)
Total (n=440)
Statistical value
Musculoskeletal
system
171 (795) 143 (635) 314 (714) X2 =1374 df=1
p=00002
Eye and adnexa 108 (502) 111(493) 219(497) X2= 0035 df=1
p= 0850
Oral cavityamp
salivary glands
76 (353) 78 (347) 154 (35) X2=0022 df=1
p=0880
Endocrine
nutritional amp
metabolic
disease
75 (348) 70 (311) 145 (329) X2=0708 df=1
p=0400
circulatory
system
58 (269) 79 (351) 137 (311) X2=3393 df=1
p=0065
Respiratory
system
49 (227) 52 (231) 101 (23) X2=0006 df=1
p=09363
Digestive system 45 (21) 42 (187) 87 (198) X2=0125 df=1
p=0723
Skin
subcutaneous
tissue
38 (176) 20 (88) 58 (132) X2=741 df=1
p=0006
Ear and mastoid
process
31 (144) 26 (115) 57 (13) X2=0799 df=1
p=0371
Genitourinary
system
16 (74) 13 (57) 29 (66) X2=0494 df=1
p=0481
Nervous system
2 (093) 9 (4) 11 (25) X2=425 df=1
p=0039 Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses
62
Results
Table 27 shows the association between the morbidity pattern and occupation of the study
subjects It was observed that musculoskeletal disorders were more common among the
subjects who are employed (795) compared to those who are not employed (635) and
this difference was found to be statistically significant A significant association was also
seen between the disorders of the skin and subcutaneous tissue 176 subjects who are
employed suffered from the disease of the skin and subcutaneous tissue compared to 88
who were unemployed The diseases of the nervous system were more common among
those who were unemployed (4) compared to those who were employed (093) this
difference was also found to be statistically significant
63
Results Table 28 Association between morbidity pattern of the study subjects and their
religion
System involved Hindu
(n=188)
Muslim
(n=252)
Total
(n=440)
Statistical value
Musculoskeletal system 138 (73) 176 (698) 314 (714)
X2=0668 df=1
p=0413
Eye and adnexa 100 (531) 119 (472) 219 (497) X2=1535 df=1
p= 0215
Oral cavityamp salivary glands 73 (388) 81 (321) 154 (35)
X2=211 df=1
p=0145
Endocrine nutritional amp metabolic diseases
53 (2819) 92 (365) 145 (329) X2=3371 df=1
p=0066
circulatory system 58 (269) 79 (351) 137 (311)
X2=3393 df=1
p=0065
Respiratory system
33 (176) 68 (269) 101 (229)
X2=5415 df= 1
p=0019
Digestive system 27 (144) 60 (238) 87 (198) X2=6059 df=1
p=0013
Skin subcutaneous tissue
31 (164) 27 (107) 58 (132) X2=3138 df=1
p=00765
Ear and mastoid process
28 (149) 29 (115) 57 (129) X2=1095 df=1
p=0297
Genitourinary system
16 (85) 13 (52) 29 (66) X2=1965 df=1
p=0161
Nervous system
4 (21) 7 (28) 11(25) p=0764
Figure in parenthesis indicates percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
64
Results
Table 28 shows the association between the morbidity pattern of the study subjects and their
religion In our study it was observed that the disorders of the digestive system were more
common among Muslims (238) compared to Hindus (144) this difference was found
to be statistically significant Also the disorders of the respiratory system were more
common among Muslims (269) compared to Hindus (176) This difference was also
found to be statistically significant Some of the diseases were more common among Hindus
which include the disease of the eye and adnexa (531) oral cavity (388) ear (149)
skin and subcutaneous tissue (164) and genitourinary system (85) but it was not found
to be statistically significant
65
Results
III HEATLTH SEEKING BEHAVIOR OF THE STUDY SUBJECTS
Figure16 Distribution of the study subjects based on the visit to health facility in case
of an illness
In our study it was found that that out of 440 study subjects 395(898) visited a health
facility in case of an illness whereas 45(102) did not visit any health facility in case of an
illness
898
102
health facility visitednot visited
66
Results
Table 29 Reasons cited by the study subjects for not seeking healthcare in case of an
illness
In the present study it was found that the most common reason stated by the 45 study
subjects for not seeking health care in case of an illness was that it was a mil 20 (444)
followed by lack of money stated by12 (267) the other reasons stated were no one to
accompany 7 (156) and lack of faith in health care 6 (133)
Reasons cited for not
seeking health care
Frequency (n=45)
Percentage ()
Mild discomfort 20 444
Lack of money 12 267
Lack of faith in
healthcare
6 133
No one to accompany 7 156
Total 45 100
67
Results
Table 30 Distribution of the study subjects based on the type of health facility visited
It was observed that out of 395 subjects who visited health care facility in case of an illness
229(58) Visited government hospitals 160 (405) visited private practitioners hospitals
and 6 (15) visited quacks More number of males (622) visited government hospitals
compared to females (513)
Type of health facility visited
Males
(n=241)
Females
(n=154)
Total
(n=395)
No No No
Government hospital 150 622 79 513 229 58
Private practitionershospitals 87 361 73 474 160 405
Quacks 4 17 2 13 6 15
Total 241 100 154 100 395 100
68
Results
Table 31 Association between gender and health seeking behaviour of the study
subjects
Whether visited
health facility
in case of illness
Sex
Total
n ()
p value Male
n ()
Female
n ()
Yes 241 (927) 154 (856) 395 (898) 00151
No 19 (106) 26 (144) 45 (102)
Total 260 (59) 180 (41) 440 (100)
x2=5901 df =1
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
It was observed that more number of males visited a health care facility in case of an illness
241(927) whereas only 154(856) females visited a health facility in case of an illness
This difference was found to be statistically significant
69
Results
Table 32 Association between educational status and health seeking
behaviour of the study subjects
Whether visited Health facility in case of illness
p value
Educational status(n) Yes () No ()
0000
Illiterate (231) 194 (84) 37 (16)
Primary school (121) 115 (95) 6 (49)
Higher primary (38) 37 (974) 1 (26)
Secondary school (30) 29 (967) 1 (33)
Intermediate (6) 6 (100) 0(00)
Graduate (14) 14 (100) 0(00)
Total(440) 395 (898) 45(102)
Fisherrsquos exact test
In the present study it was found that 84 of the study subjects who were illiterate visited a
health facility in case of an illness whereas 16 did not visit a health facility in case of an
illness 967 of the subjects with education up to secondary school visited the health
facility and 100 of the subjects who studied up to intermediate and with a graduate degree
visited the health facility in case of an illness This difference was found to be statistically
significant
70
Results
Table 33 Distribution of study subjects according to frequency of visits to a health care facility
Frequency of visits to a health care facility
Frequency
(n=395)
Percentage
Once a month 207 524
Once in 3 months 99 251
Once in 6 months 79 20
Once in a year 10 25
Total 395 100
In the present study it was found that out of 395 study subjects who visited a health care
facility in case of an illness 207 (524) visited a health facility every month followed by
99 (251) who visited once in 3 months 79(20) once in 6 months and 10 25 visited
the health facility once in a year
71
Discussion
DISCUSSION
I Socio-demographic characteristics
Our study was done in the urban field practice area of JJM Medical College Davangere
among 440 geriatric subjects our study aimed at assessing the morbidity pattern and health
seeking behaviour of the geriatric population in the study area
In the present study Out of 440 study subjects majority 162(368) were in the age
group of 60-64 Years followed by 109 (247) in the age group of 65-69 Years 99 (225)
in the age group of 70-74 Years and 8 were more than or equal to 80 years of age [Table
7] This was similar to a study conducted by Prakash Boraingaiah et al 72 in which majority
of the elderly (346) belongs to age group 60-64 years followed by age group 75 years and
above (259)
In our study it was also seen that 59 of the study subjects were males and 41 were
females This was similar to a study conducted by Mohan Gupta et al 35 where 573
subjects were males and 427were females Our findings were contrary to a study
conducted by Md Alam Naushad et al 28 where 598 subjects were females and 402
were males
In the present study it was found that the majority of the study subject belonged to
Muslim religion 252 (573) followed by Hindus 188 (427) there were no study subjects
who belonged to other religions like Christian Jain Sikhs etc [Table 8] similar findings
were seen in a study conducted by Mrinal Ranjan Srivastav et al 50 in which 52 of the
subjects were Muslims
72
Discussion
In the present study it was found that the Majority of the study subjects were illiterate
525 whereas 275 had completed education up to primary school 82 had completed
education up to secondary school and only 32 were graduates [Table 9] These findings
were similar to a study done by Shraddha K et al 51in which 504 of the study subjects
were illiterate
In our study it was found that the majority of the study subjects 511 were unemployed
followed by 227 who were unskilled workers 155 were semi-skilled workers and
about 105 were skilled workers [Table 10] These findings were similar to a study done
by Rajat Das Gupta et al27 al in which 481 of the study subjects were not working
In our study majority of the subjects 49 belonged to Class IV Socioeconomic status
followed by 26 who belonged to class III and 13 who belonged to class II (according to
Modified BG Prasad Classification 2016) [Table 11] Similar findings were found in a study
conducted by Sribas Goswami and Manjari Sahai 29 in which majority of the study subjects
belonged to class IV socio economic status
In our study it was found that the majority of the study subjects 734 were married
followed by 261 who were widowed and only 05 were unmarried [Table 12] These
findings were similar to a study done by L subedhi and RB Sah 40 in which 663 of the
subjects were married 322 were widowed and 07 were unmarried
In the present study it was found that majority of the study subjects 42 lived in a three
generation family followed by 37 who lived in a nuclear family and 21 who lived in a
Joint family [Table 13] These findings were similar to a study done by Swapnil Jain et al 26
in which the majority (47) of the study subjects lived in a three generation family
73
Discussion
II Prevalence of morbidities among the study subjects
In the present study it was found that majority of the subjects 45 had a normal BMI
followed by 30 who were overweight about 15 were obese and only10 were
underweight [Figure 14] Similar findings were reported in a study conducted by Khadervali
Nagoor et al 44 in which 49 subjects had a normal BMI In a study done by Vimala
Thomas et al 52 272 of the subjects were obese which was higher than the present study
In the present study it was found that the majority of the subjects suffered from the
disorders of the musculoskeletal system (714) eye and adnexa (497) oral cavity
(311) respiratory system (229) digestive system (198)disease of the skin
(132)ear(13)genitourinary system (66) nervous system (25) [Table14] Similar
findings were seen in a study done by Rajashree Bhat et al 55 in which most common
morbidity of elderly was the problems of loco-motor system (486) followed by vision
(427) CVS disorders (344) respiratory system (202) and disease of ear (179)In
this study though the prevalence of loco-motor system disorders (486) was highest
compared to other disorders it was lesser compared to our study (714) In a study done by
L subedhi and RB Sah 40 it was found that 44 had eye problems 43 had gastrointestinal
problems 33 had CVS problems and 23 had ENT problems In this study the prevalence
of gastrointestinal disorders was much higher compared to our study
In the present study joint pain (including the knee joint) was most common disorder of the
musculoskeletal system seen in 40 of the males compared to 384 in females [Table 15]
whereas in a study done by Swapnil Jain et al 26 it was found that 472 males and 528
females suffered from joint pains This could be attributed to the fact that in our study
majority of the study subjects were males
74
Discussion
In the present study it was found that the most common morbidity of the eye was cataract
found in 39 of the subjects It was more common in males 43 compared to females
333 [ Table 16]These findings were similar to a study done by Shraddha K et al 51 in
which the overall prevalence of cataract was 302 of which 42 males and 358
females had cataract
In the present study it was found that the most common morbidity of the oral cavity was
missing teeth found in 177 of the subjects [Table 17] it was similar to the findings of a
study conducted by JP Singh et al 48 in which 1475 subjects were edentulous
The present study revealed that the most common disorder of the endocrine system was
diabetes mellitus found in 186 of the subjects followed by the nutritional disorder of
anemia found in 134 of the subjects It was seen that anemia was more common among
females 194 compared to males 92 [Table 18] Kakkar R et al 45 reported similar
findings with prevalence of diabetes mellitus as 153 In a study done by Deepak Sharma
et al 47 anemia was present in 15 of the subjects 97 males and 21 females were
anemic which was similar to our study
In our study it was found that the most common disease of the circulatory system was
hypertension which was found in 302 of the subjects it was more common in females
394 compared to males 239 and this difference was found to be statistically significant
[Table 19] A study by L Subedhi and RB Sah 40 reported that the prevalence of
hypertension was more among females (333) compared to males (30) which was
statistically significant
75
Discussion
In our study the most common morbidity of the respiratory system was upper respiratory
tract infection (163) [Table20] it was similar to the study done by Leena Rahul
Salunke33 where it was reported to be 196
In our study the most common disorder of the digestive system was gastritis (95)
[Table 21] similar to the findings of JP Singh et al 48 (35) contrary to this L subedhi
and RB Sah 40 reported a high prevalence of gastritis (39) This difference could be
attributed to the difference in the interpretation of symptoms for the diagnosis of gastritis
In our study the most common disorder of the skin was itching (48) [ Table 22] which
was similar to the findings reported by JP Singh et al 48 in which 225 subjects suffered
from itching
In our study the most common disorder of the ear was impaired hearing (111) [Table
23] similar to a study by Vandana Nikumb et al 38 in which 106 subjects suffered from
hearing impairment
In our study it was observed that the most common morbidity affecting the
genitourinary system was increased frequency of micturition (57) [Table 24]
L subedhi and RB Sah40 found in their study that 143 subjects suffered from increased
frequency of micturition which was higher compared to our study
Our study revealed that 25 subjects suffered from the disorders of the nervous
system [Table 25] similar to a study conducted by Vandana Nikumb et al 38 in which
13 of the Subjects suffered from the disorders of the nervous system whereas in a
study conducted by Shilpa Shaukaiah et al36 it was found that 66 of the subjects
suffered from the disorders of the nervous system which was higher than our study
76
Discussion
It is observed that the disease of the eye and adnexa increased with increasing age and were
more common in individuals above 80 years of age (714) The disease of the oral cavity
were also more common in the subjects aged 80 years and above (857) and 285
subjects aged 80 years and above suffered from disease of the ear A significant association
was found between age and these morbidities [Table 26] Similar results were found in a
study done by Swapnil Jain et al 26 in which cataract hearing impairment and dental
problems were significantly associated with the age of the study subjects
In our study a significant association was found between occupation and the disorders of
the musculoskeletal system skin and the nervous system Disorders of the musculoskeletal
system were more common among employed subjects (795) compared to unemployed
(635) 176 subjects who were employed suffered from the disease of the skin and
subcutaneous tissue compared to 88 who were unemployed Diseases of the nervous
system were more common among those who were unemployed (4) compared to those
who were employed (093) [Table 27]
A study done by Kakkar R et al45 found that there was a significant association between the
employment status and the morbidities of the CVS arthritis and cataract CVS morbidity
was more common among those not working (164) compared to those working (36)
Arthritis was also more common among not working (212) compared to those working
(55) and cataract was also more common among those not working (175) compared to
those working (55)
77
Discussion
In our study it was observed that there was a significant association between religion and
disorders of the digestive system and respiratory system The disorders of the digestive
system were more common among Muslims (238) compared to Hindus (144) Also the
disorders of the respiratory system were more common among Muslims (269) compared
to Hindus (176) [Table 28] In a study conducted by Mrinal Ranjan Srivastav et al 50 it
was found that there was significant association between religion and the morbidities of the
genitourinary system in the urban areas The problems of the genitourinary system were
more common among Hindus (26) compared to Muslims (96)
III HEATLTH SEEKING BEHAVIOR OF THE STUDY SUBJECTS
In our study it was found that that (898) study subjects visited a health facility in case
of an illness whereas 102 did not visit any health facility in case of an illness[Figure 16]
Similar findings were seen in a study conducted by Vimala Thomas et al 52 where it was
found that 716 subjects visited a health facility Contrary to our findings a study
conducted by Bhawalkar JS et al46 showed that only 81 subjects visited a health facility in
case of an illness whereas 919 did not visit any health facility
In the present study it was found that the most common reason stated by study subjects
for not seeking health care in case of an illness was that it was a mild discomfort (444)
followed by lack of money stated by (267) other reasons stated were no one to
accompany (156) and lack of faith in health care (133) [Table 29] In a study
conducted by Deepak Sharma et al 47 it was found that the most common reasons for not
seeking health care were the following disease due to age (496) health services too far
(191) lack of money (6) no body to take to hospital (35)
78
Discussion
It was observed that out of 395 subjects who visited health care facility in case of an illness
58 Visited government hospitals 362 visited private practitioners hospitals and 15
visited quacks [Table 30] similar results were found in a study conducted by Deepak Sharma
et al 47 in which 607 went to Government hospitals 267 consulted private practitioners
and 126 took over the counter drugs In another study conducted by Rajat Das Gupta et al
27 it was found that 33 visited Government hospitals 25 visited private hospitals 6
visited private practitioners
It was observed that more number of males (927) visited a health care facility in case of
an illness whereas only 856 females visited a health facility in case of an illness [Table
31] In a study done by Man Mohan Gupta et al 35 it was found that 672 females and
651 males visited a health facility in case of illness
In the present study it was found that 848 of the study subjects who were illiterate
visited a health facility in case of an illness whereas 152 did not visit a health facility in
case of an illness A significant association was found between educational status and
gender [Table 32] In a study done by Deepak Sharma et al 47 it was found that Gender
literacy income and marital status were not found to be significantly related to health-
seeking behaviour
In the present study it was found that 524 subjects visited a health facility every month
followed by 251 who visited a health facility once in 3 months 20once in 6 months
and 25 visited a health facility once in a year[ Table 33] In a study conducted by Rajat
Das Gupta et al 27 it was found that majority of the subjects (2943) visited a health
facility once a year followed by 2813 who visited a health facility once in three months
79
Conclusion
CONCLUSION
The study revealed that some of the common morbidities among the geriatric subjects were
the disorders of the musculoskeletal system followed by the disease of the eye and adnexa
oral cavity endocrine nutritional and metabolic disorders etc some disorders like cataract
dental caries constipation and increased frequency of micturition were more common
among males whereas disease like anemia and hypertension were more common among
females A significant association was found between some of the morbidities and socio
demographic determinants like age occupation and religion
Any degree of formal schooling was found to be associated with better health seeking
behavior Majority of the subjects visited a Government health facility in case of an illness
and the main reason that was stated for not visiting a health facility was that they suffered
from mild discomfort and did not consider it necessary to visit a health facility
80
Summary
SUMMARY
Our study was done in the urban field practice area of JJM Medical College Davangere
among 440 geriatric subjects our study aimed at assessing the morbidity pattern and health
seeking behaviour of the geriatric population in the study area
The results of our study are as follows
ISocio-demographic characteristics of the study subjects
In the present study 368 subjects were in the age group of 60-64 Years
59 of the subjects were males and 41 were females
573 subjects were Muslims whereas 427 were Hindus
Majority of the subjects were illiterate (525) whereas 275 had completed
education up to primary school
It was found that the majority of the study subjects (511) were unemployed
49 subjects belonged to Class IV Socioeconomic status according to Modified BG
Prasad Classification
734 of the subjects were married
42 of the people lived in a three generation family
II Prevalence of morbidities among the study subjects
Majority of the subjects (45) had a normal BMI followed 30who were
overweight
Majority 714 subjects suffered from the disorders of the musculoskeletal system
followed by 497 who suffered from the disease of the eye and adnexa35
suffered from the disease of the oral cavity 329 suffered from endocrine
nutritional and metabolic disorders and 311 suffered from the disease of the
circulatory system 229 suffered from the disease of the respiratory system198
81
Summary
suffered from the disease of the digestive system132 suffered from disease of the
skin13 suffered from the disease of the ear66 suffered from the disease of the
genitourinary system and 25 suffered from the disease of the nervous system
The most common morbidity of musculoskeletal system was pain of the joints (other
than the knee joint) found in 198 of the subjectsBack ache was more common in
females 231 compared to males 163 and this difference was found to be
statistically significant
cataract found in 39 of the subjects It was more common in males 43 compared
to females 333 and this difference was found to be statistically significant
Missing teeth were found in 177 of the subjects Dental caries were more
common in males 108 compared to females 44 and this difference was found to
be statistically significant
Diabetes mellitus found in 186 of the subjects followed by the nutritional disorder
of anemia found in 134 of the subjects anemia was more common among females
194 compared to males 92 This difference was found to be statistically
significant
Hypertension which was found in 302 of the subjects it was more common in
females 394 compared to males 239 and this difference was found to be
statistically significant
upper respiratory tract infection) found in 163 subjects followed by acute
bronchitis in 43 bronchial asthma in 14 and pulmonary TB in only 09
Gastritis was found in 95 subjects followed by constipation in 61 Among
males (81) had constipation compared to females(03)
Most common disease of the skin was itching which was present in 48 of the
study subjects followed by dryness in 43
82
Summary
Hearing impairment was found in 111 of the subjects
Increased frequency of micturition was found in 57 of the subjects followed by
burning micturition in 09 of the study subjects Increased frequency of
micturition was more among males 77 compared to females in whom it was 28
and this difference was found to be statistically significant
The most common disorder of the nervous system was neuritis seen in 11 of the
subjects followed by memory loss in 09 and stroke in 05 of the subjects
A significant association was found between increasing age and the morbidities of
the eye ear and the oral cavity
Significant association was found between occupation and the disorders of the
musculoskeletal system skin and the nervous system Disorders of the
musculoskeletal system were more common among employed subjects (795)
compared to unemployed (635) 176 subjects who were employed suffered
from the disease of the skin and subcutaneous tissue compared to 88 who were
unemployed Diseases of the nervous system were more common among those who
were unemployed (4) compared to those who were employed (093)
It was observed that the disorders of the digestive system were more common
among Muslims (238) compared to Hindus (144) this difference was found to
be statistically significant Also the disorders of the respiratory system were more
common among Muslims (269) compared to Hindus (176) This difference
was also found to be statistically significant
83
Summary
III HEATLTH SEEKING BEHAVIOR OF THE STUDY SUBJECTS
In our study 898 subjects visited a health facility in case of an illness whereas
102 did not
The most common reason stated by study subjects for not seeking health care in case
of an illness was that it was a mild discomfort (444) followed by lack of money
stated by (267) the other reasons stated were no one to accompany (156) and
lack of faith in health care (133)
It was observed that 58 subjects Visited Government hospitals 362 visited
private practitioners hospitals and 15 visited quacks
Majority of males (927) visited a health care facility in case of an illness whereas
only 856 females visited a health facility in case of an illness This difference was
found to be statistically significant
A significant association was found between the educational status and health
seeking behaviour Majority of the educated subjects visited a health facility in case
of an illness compared to those who were illiterate
It was found that 524 subjects visited a health facility every month followed by
251 who visited a health facility once in 3 months 20once in 6 months and
25 visited a health facility once in a year
84
Limitations
LIMITATIONS
1 Many of the responses were subjective and there were no records to verify them
2 Some of the morbidities were diagnosed only by clinical examination and could not be
confirmed by performing diagnostic tests due to high cost and time constraints
3 This study was done in the urban field practice area which consisted of a closed
community hence the results cannot be generalized to the entire population of the area
85
Recommendations
RECOMMENDATIONS
1 Health education should be given to the geriatric people regarding the common health
problems associated with ageing and preventive care should be provided to the elderly
2 Geriatric clinics should be set up at the primary health care level which provide regular
screening and health check-ups
3 There should also be a provision to provide domiciliary care by specialists qualified in
geriatrics
4 The family members and the care givers of the elderly should be educated about the
common health problems of the elderly and also about the need for regular health check-ups
and emotional support
5 The majority of the geriatric population is out of work force they are suffering from
many morbidities and are totally dependent on others even for their health needs Hence the
Government should increase the pension of the elderly and provide them quality healthcare
free of cost
6 There is also a need for public private partnership to improve the quality of health
services for the geriatric people More number of NGOs should work towards improving the
health and the quality of life of the elderly
86
References
REFERENCES
1 United Nations Department of Economic and Social affairs Population Division
World population ageing 2013 Available from URL
wwwunorgendevelopmentpopulationageingWorldPopulationAgeing2013
[Accessed on 17-7-2016]
2 Khan S and Itrat M Current Issues in Geriatric Health Care in India-A Review J Community Med Health Care 2016 1(1) 1-3
3 United Nations Department of Economic and Social Affairs Population Division
World Population Ageing 2015 ndash Highlights Available from URL
wwwunorgendevelopmentdesapopulationpdfageingWPA2015_Reportpdf
[Accessed on 272017]
4 State of elderly in India 2014 Help age India Available from URL
httpswwwhelpageindiaorgimagespdfstate-elderly-india-2014pdf [Accessed on
1082017]
5 World Health Organization World report on ageing and health 2015Available
from URL wwwwhointageingeventsworld-report-2015-launchen [Accessed on
1272017]
6 National policy for Senior citizens March 2011Ministry of Social Justice and
welfare Govt of India Available from URL
socialjusticenicinwritereaddataUploadFilednpscpdf [Accessed on 482017]
87
References
7 Elderly in India Profile and programmes 2016Govt of India Ministry of statistics
and programme implementation Central Statistics Office Available from URL
wwwmopsigovin [ Accessed on 1442017]
8 Saxena V Kandpal SD Gael D Bansal S Health status of elderly community
based study Indian Journal of Community Health2012 Oct-Dec24(4)269-74
9 Shah T Patel M Shah V Health care seeking behaviour of urban and rural
community in Ahmedabad district Int J Med Sci Public Health20132908-11
10 Sahoo H Mishra NR Health Status Morbidity Pattern and Treatment Seeking
Behaviour among Elderly in India Evidence from 60th round of National Sample
Survey Data Learning community 2011 Dec 2(3) 341-55
11 Park K Parkrsquos Textbook of Preventive and social medicine 24 th ed Jabalpur MS
Banarsidas Bhanot Publishers2017631
12 UNFPA- state of World Population 2011Chapter 1 setting the scene 19-31
Available from URL httpswwwunfpaorgsitesdefaultfilesresource-
pdfUNFPA-Report-Chapter1pd [Accessed on 1082017]
13 Lal S Adarsh Pankaj Textbook of community Medicine 4th ed CBS publishers and
distributors PvtLtd2011732
14 Census of India 2001 Registrar General And Census Commissioner India
Available from URL httpwwwcensusindiagovinCensus[Accessed on
7102015]
15 SRS bulletin October 2012 Registar General of India New Delhi Available from
URL censusindiagovinvital_statisticsSRS_BulletinsSRS_Bulletin-
October_2012[Acessed on 7102015]
88
References
16 Bagchi K Healthy ageing Health and Population-Perspectives and Issues 2000
23(1)11-16
17 Salagre SB The Association of Physicians of India Chapter 177 Health Issues in
Geriatrics Available from URL
wwwapiindiaorgmedicine_update_2013chap177pd [ Accessed on 282017]
18 Ingle GK Nath A Geriatric Health in India Concerns and Solutions Indian Journal
of Community Medicine 2008 33(4)214-18
19 World Health Organization Active Ageing a policy framework 2002 Available
from httpwhqlibdocwhointhq2002who_nmh_nph_028pdf [Accessed on
1062017]
20 Inche Zainal Abidin S Sutan R Shamsuddin K Prevalence and determinants of
appropriate health seeking behaviour among known diabetics Results from a
community-based survey Advances in Epidemiology 2014 Nov 20141-6
21 Begashaw B Tessema F Gesesew HA Health Care Seeking behavior in Southwest
Ethiopia Plos one 2016 Sep 11(9)e0161014
22 MacKian S Health systems development Manchester University of Manchester
2003 A review of health seeking behavior problems and prospects
23 Metta EO Health-seeking behaviour among adults in the context of the
epidemiological transition in Southeastern Tanzania A focus on malaria and
diabetes [Groningen] University of Groningen 2016 228 Available from URL
httpswwwrugnlresearchportalfiles28737720Chapter_7pdf [Accessed on
1272017]
24 Adhikari D Rijal D Factors affecting health seeking behaviour of senior citizens of
Dharan Journal of Nobel Medical College 2015 Sep 4(1)57-63
25 Polisetty S Seepana M Morbidity profile of elderly individuals in urban
Visakhapatnam Int J Community Med Public Health 2017 4(2)2558-63
89
References
26 Jain S Kaware AC Doibale MK Shaikh S Radhey BK Mathurkar MP Morbidity
pattern among geriatric population in urban field practice area of district of
Maharashtra a cross sectional study Int J Community Med Public Health 2016
3(2)523-29
27 Gupta RD Loha A Roy S Morbidity pattern and health-seeking behaviour among
the senior citizens in a selected urban area of Bangladesh A cross-sectional study
South East Asia Journal of Public Health 2016 Jul 5(2)43-49
28 Naushad MA Verma N Bhawnani D Jain M Anand T Umate LV Morbidity
pattern and health seeking behaviour in elderly population of Raipur City
Chhattisgarh India Indian Journal of Community Health2016 Sep 28(3)236-41
29 Goswami S Sahai M A Study of Morbidity Pattern in Elderly Population European
Researcher Series A 2016103(2)119-28
30 Bardhan H Dixit AM Agarwal R Jain PK Gupta S Shukla SK Morbidity profile
of elderly population in Ghaziabad district a cross-sectional study Int J Med Sci
Public Health 2016 5(6)1098-1102
31 Maroof M Ahmad A Khalique N Ansari MA Health problems among the aged A
community based study from urban Aligarh Uttar Pradesh India Int J Community
Med Public Health 2016 Feb 3(4)944-47
32 Shankar G Sidenur B A morbidity study of elderly residing in urban field practice
area of SN medical college Bagalkot National Journal of research in community
medicine 2016 Oct-Dec 4(5) 229-34
90
References
33 Salunkhe LR Socio-demographic profile of old age people living in urban amp urban
slum areas in Maharashtra Karad A comparative study J of Evidence based Med
and Hlthcare 2015 Feb 2(5) 513-21
34 Warbhe P Rupesh W Morbidity profile health seeking behaviour and home
environment survey for adaptive measures in geriatric population-Urban community
study International Journal of Medical Research amp Health Sciences 2015 4(4)778-
82
35 Gupta M Borle AL Chhari N Gupta S Assessment of clinico-socioeconomic
status and health-care support among the elderly people aged older than 60 years in
urban population of Bhopal Central India Int J Med Sci Public Health 2015
4558-64
36 Sahukaiah S Shenoy A Vijayakumar BC An epidemiological study of prevalence
of morbidity patterns among geriatric age group in an urban slum of Mumbai Int J
Med Sci Public Health 2015 Jul 4(7)883-87
37 Shubha Davalagi B Angadi N Mahabalaraju DK Morbidity psycho-social profile
and health seeking behaviour of the elderly population in urban slums of Davangere
City India Int J Res Med Sci 2015 Nov 3(11)3288-91
38 Nikumb V Patankar F Behera A A Study of Morbidity Profile among Geriatric
Population in an Urban Area Sch J App Med Sci 2015 3(3)1365-69
91
References
39 Vishnoi BR Solanki SL Singhal G Meharda B Mishra N Morbidity profile of
elderly in urban slum of Udaipur Rajasthan Int J Oral Health Med Res 2015 May
2(1)9-12
40 Subedi L Sah RB Study of the health status of geriatric age group in Chitwan
district of Nepal Journal of Chitwan Medical College 2015 Mar 5(1)11-17
41 Noor S Krishnababu G Prasad KV Health status of Geriatric population in slums
of Rourkela Young Innovative Journal of Medical and Health Science 2015 May
5(3) 92-94
42 Sarode VM Chronic Diseases Related to Aging and Disease Prevention in Slums in
Mumbai Journal of Aging Science 2014 Jan 2 (1)1-6
43 Barman SK Lata K Ram R Ghosh N Sarker G Shahnawaz K A study of
morbidity profile of geriatric population in an urban community of Kishanganj
Bihar India Global Journal of Medicine and Public Health GJMEDPH 2014 3(1)
1-7
44 Nagoor K Srikanth BA Dudekula R Satna K Comparative study of health status
among slum and non-slum elderly population in Kadapa Region South India
Journal of Evolution of Medical and Dental Sciences 2014 Feb 3(5)1298-308
45 Kakkar R Aggarwal P Kandpal SD Bansal SK An Epidemiological study to assess
morbidity profile among geriatric population in District Dehradun Indian Journal of
Community Health 2013 May 25(1)39-44
46 Bhawalkar JS Dhone AB Jethani S Singru S Jadhav SL Adyanthaya S A study of
morbidity profile among geriatric population in an urban area J Evol Med Dent Sci
2013 Sep 9 36(2)6963-7
92
References
47 Sharma D Mazta SR Parashar A Morbidity pattern and health-seeking behaviour of
aged population residing in Shimla hills of north India A cross-sectional study
Journal of family medicine and primary care 2013 Apr2(2)188
48 Singh JP Singh S Kasturwar NB Hassan A Geriatric morbidity profile in an urban
slum Central India Indian Journal of Community Health 2013 Aug 25(2)164-70
49 Thakur RP Banerjee A Nikumb VB Health Problems among the Elderly A Cross
Sectional Study Annals of medical and health sciences research 2013 3(1)19-25
50 Mrinal RS Beena S Pratibha G Pankaj B Srivastava JP Atul B Morbidity Status
and Its Social Determinants among Elderly Population of Lucknow District India
Sch J App Med Sci 2013 1(6)758-64
51 Shraddha K Prashantha B Prakash B Study on morbidity pattern among elderly in
urban population of Mysore Karnataka India International Journal of Medicine and
Biomedical Research 2012 1(3)215-23
52 Thomas V Lavanya KM Morbidity profile and health seeking behaviour of the
elderly in urban slums of Hyderabad Andhra Pradesh India- A cross sectional study
International Journal of Current Research and Review 2012 Oct 1 4(19)174-80
53 Moe S Tha K Naing DK Htike MM Health seeking behaviour of elderly in
Myanmar International Journal of Collaborative Research on Internal Medicine and
Public Health 2012 4(8)1538-44
93
References
54 Bharati DR Pal R Rekha R Yamuna TV Kar S Radjou AN Ageing in
Puducherry South India An overview of morbidity profile Journal of pharmacy amp
bio allied sciences 2011 Oct 3(4)537
55 Bhatt R Gadhvi MS Sonaliya KN Solanki A Nayak H An epidemiological study
of the morbidity pattern among the elderly population in Ahmedabad Gujarat
National Journal of community medicine 2011 Jul 2(2)233-36
56 Srinivasan Krishnamachari Vaz Mario Thomas Tinku Prevalence of health related
disability among community dwelling urban elderly from middle socioeconomic
strata in Bangaluru India Indian Journal of Medical Research 2010 Apr 131(4)
515-21
57 Srivastava K Gupta SC Kaushal SK Chaturvedi M Morbidity profile of elderly a
cross sectional study of urban Agra Indian Journal of Community Health 2010 Jun
22(1)51-55
58 Ladha A Khan R Malik A Khan S Khan B Khan I et al The health seeking
behaviour of elderly population in a poor-urban community of Karachi Pakistan
Journal of the Pakistan Medical Association2009 Feb 59(2) 89-92
59 WHO ICD-10 version 2010 Geneva World Health Organization Available from
URL appswhointclassificationsicd10browse2010en [Accessed on 772017]
60 OpenEpi22OpenEpi (free) download Windows version Available from URL
enfreedownloadmanagerorgWindows-PCOpenEpi-FREEhtml
61 Tandon R Sinhota Parsonrsquos disease of the eye 22edNew Delhi Elsevier 98-100
62 Dhingra P L Dhingra S Disease of ear nose and throat and head and neck surgery
6th ed New Delhi Elsevier 201422
94
References
63 Aziz N Kallur SD Nirmalan PK Implications of the revised consensus body mass
indices for Asian Indians on clinical obstetric practice Journal of clinical and
diagnostic research 2014 May 8(5)OC01
64 Chobanion AV Bakris GL Black HR The seventh report of the joint national
committee on prevention detection evaluation and treatment of high blood pressure
the JNC 7 report JAMA 2003 2892560-72
65 The Seventh Report of the Joint National Committee on Prevention Detection
Evaluation and Treatment of High Blood Pressure (JNC 7) The GuidelinesUS
Department of Health and Human Services National Heart Lung and Blood
Institute Available at URL
httpswwwnhlbinihgovfilesdocsguidelinesjnc7fullpdf [ Accessed on
1282017]
66 Firkin F Chestman C Penington D Rush B De Gruchyrsquos clinical Hematology in
medical practice 5th edition New Delhi Blackwell science Ltd1989 32-47
67 Report of WHO consultation Nutritional Anaemias Geneva Switzerland World
Health Organization TRS-405 1968 Available from URL
whqlibdocwhointtrsWHO_TRS_405pdf [Accessed on 1282017]
68 National Family Health survey (NFHS-4) 2015-16 India Mumbai IIPS
2016Available from URL httpwwwnfhsindiaorg [Accessed on 4072017]
69 The Minimum Wages Act 1948 Ministry of Labour and Employment Government
of India Available from URL httplabourgovincontentinnerpagewagesphp
[Accessed on 1082017]
70 Khairnar M Wadgave U Shimpi P Updated BG Prasad socioeconomic
classification for 2016 Journal of Indian Association of Public Health Dentistry
2016 Oct 1 14(4)469
95
References
71 Tiwari P Tiwari S Mastering practicals community medicine 1st ed New Delhi
India Wolters Kluwer PvtLtd2013161-67
72 Boralingaiah P Bettappa P Kashyap S Prevalence of Psycho-Social Problems
among Elderly in Urban Population of Mysore City Karnataka India Indian journal
of psychological medicine 2012 Oct 34(4)360
96
PATIENT CONSENT FORM JJM MEDICAL COLLEGE DAVANGERE
DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY MEDICINE I the undersigned hereby give my consent
for investigations carried upon me I am satisfied with the information given about this
Clinical study titled ldquoA STUDY ON THE MORBIDITY PATTERN AND HEALTH
SEEKING BEHAVIOR AMONG THE GERIATRIC POULATION IN THE
URBAN FIELD PRACTICE AREA OF JJM MEDICAL COLLEGE
DAVANGERErdquo ldquoconducted by Dr RUCHI DHAR under the guidance of Dr VIDYA
GS Associate Professor I have been informed and explained the risks involved and I
hereby voluntarily and Unconditionally give my consent without any fear or pressure in
mentally sound and conscious state to participate in this study
DATE PATIENTrsquoS SIGNATURE
eEacuteeEacuteJA ordfEacuteEcirczAgravearingQAtildeAiAgraveAuml ordfAgraveAumlordmAacutelaquozAacutearingregAiAgraveAuml zAacuteordfAgravetUEacutegEacute
ryenAacutemiumlethordfEacuteAumlAmiumlDyensiumlPAgraveordfAgraveAumlAumlaringcurrenn ordfEacuteAumlrsup1poundiuml
ordfEacuteEcirczAgravearingQAtildeAiAgraveAumlvAgraveyenAacutecedilAgraveuEacuteUEacuteMbrvbaragraveUEacute yenAgravevAgraveaelig F PEacutefrac14AgraveUEacute cedilAgraveraquo ordfAgraveiAacutergAgraveAumlordfAgrave poundAacutepoundAgraveAuml CAzAgravegEacute
poundAgravepoundAgraveszlig
ordfEacuteEcirczAgravearingQAtildeAiAgraveAumlvAgraveyenAacutecedilAgraveuEacute ordmAacuteUAgraveAElig plusmnAgravecedilAgraveUcircccedilaQvEacuteigraveUEacuteAzAgraveAuml poundAgravepoundAgraveszligMbrvbaragraveUEacuteAiAgraveAumlpoundAgraveAumlszlig
cedilAgraveAEligasup1gAgraveAumlvEacuteUcircAtildepoundEacute J cedilAgraveOumlr Dyensiuml zAgrave ordfEacuteAEligcopyethrn yenAacutearinglpoundiumleth CAqiuml ordmEacutemacriumlUcirc sup1AtildeQAUiuml copyordmEacuteAtildelaquoAiAgraveAumlgiuml Dyensiuml zAgrave fjAiAgraveiAacutenaeligPiuml yenEacuteAEligAtildeyenAgraveAumlaringmacrEacuteAtildemicroAgravepoundiuml Epoundiuml zAgrave Csectethpoundiuml brvbarAtildemacriumlOslash yenAacuteaeligoumlaringQOumlAtildecediliuml JjAiAgraveAuml Dyensiuml ddordfAgraveAumlAuml ordfEacuteEcirczAgravearingQAtildeAiAgraveAuml ordfAgraveAumlordmAacutelaquozAacutearingregAiAgraveAuml zAacuteordfAgravetUEacutegEacute JAsect sup2AtildeparaethPEacuteAiAgraveAumlrAiAgraveAumldegegrave yenAgravejAtildePEacuteeumlUEacute Mfrac14AgraveyenAgravercedilAgraveAumlordfAgrave ordfEacuteEcirczAgravearinggAacutezAgrave qAacute|| gAgraveAumla zAgravesAgravegAgrave ordfAgraveAumlvAgraveAumlUcirc qAacute|| laquozAacutearing fJcediliumlordfAgraveiAacuteUAgraveethzAgraveplusmnAgraveethPAgravegAacutezAgrave yenEacuteAEligaeligAtildeyensEacutecedilAgravegiuml
EordfAgravegAgraveAuml poundAgravepoundAgraveUEacute F vAgraveyenAacutecedilAgraveuEacuteUEacute Mfrac14AgraveyenAgraveqAgraveAumlordfAgrave ordfAgraveAumlAumlpoundAgraveszlig yenAgraveaeligwAiEacuteAEligAzAgraveAuml
CAplusmnAgraveUAgravefrac14AgravepoundAgraveAumlszlig CxAgraveethordfAacuteUAgraveAumlordfAgraveAvEacute wfrac12sup1gAgraveAumlvAacuteUcircgEacuteDzAgraveYacutejAzAgrave poundAacutepoundAgraveAuml poundAgravepoundAgraveszlig
ordfAgraveAumlpoundAgravecedilAacutegEacute AiAgraveiAacuteordfAgraveAringzEacuteAtilde umlsAgraveAiAgraveAuml ordfAgraveAumlvAgraveAumlUcirc AiAgraveiAacutegAgrave MvAacuteUcircAiAgraveAumllaquoregegravezEacute poundAacutepoundAgraveAuml
vAgraveyenAacutecedilAgraveuEacute aQvEacuteigraveUEacuteAEligfrac14AgraveyenAgraveqAgraveregAuml MbrvbaragraveUEacuteAiAgraveAumlpoundAgraveAumlszlig cedilAgraveAEligasup1gAgraveAumlvEacuteUcircAtildepoundEacute
centpoundAacuteAPAgrave gEacuteAEligAtildeVAi
Annexures
ANNEXURE ndashIII
104
Annexures
PROFORMA
I General information
1 NAME
2 AGE
3 GENDER (a) Male (b) Female
4 MARITAL STATUS (a) Unmarried (b) Married (c) Widow Widower
(d) Divorced separated
5 LIVING ARRANGEMENT (a) with spouse (b) Spouse and children
(c) Children only (d) living alone (e) others
6 RELIGION (a) Hindu (b) Muslim (c) Christian (d) Others
7 ADDRESS
8 EDUCATION (a) illiterate (b) Primary school (c) higher primary
(d) secondary school (e)PUC diploma (e) Graduate (f) Postgraduate
9 OCCUPATION (a) professional (b) semi- professional (c) skilled worker
(d) Semi ndashskilled worker (e) unskilled worker (f) unemployed
10 CONTACT NUMBER
11 TYPE OF FAMILY (a) Joint (b) Nuclear (C) three generation
12 TOTAL NUMBER OF FAMILY MEMBERS
13 TOTAL FAMILY INCOME
14 PER CAPITA FAMILY INCOME
15 SOCIO ECONOMIC STATUS (Modified BG Prasad classification) I IIIIIIVV
16 DIET (a) Vegetarian (b) Mixed
17 Sleep (a) Disturbed if yes reason ______________ (b) Not disturbed
18 Bowel Regular Irregular
19 Bladder Regular Irregular
97
Annexures
20 HABITS (a) betel nut (b) tobacco (c) alcohol (d) smoking (e) others
If any of the habits present Duration (since when) _________
Frequency of consumption day_______
IIAssessment of morbidity based on history
1 Whether suffering from any chronic illness like (a) Type 2 DM (b) Hypertension
(c) Bronchial Asthma (d) TB (e) others
2 Whether suffering from cataract currently (a) Yes (b) No
3 Whether operated for cataract (a) Yes (b) No If Yes duration since operation____
4 MUSCULOSKELETAL SYSTEM
Whether the following symptoms are present
(a) Backache (b) Joint pain (c) restricted joint movements (d) pain in calves
(e) Others_________
5 RESPIRATORY SYSTEM
(a) Productive cough (b) non-productive cough (c) nasal discharge (d) breathlessness (e)
sore throat (f) sneezing
6 CARDIOVASCULAR SYSTEM
(a) Palpitations (b) chest pain (c) breathlessness
7 GASTROINTESTINAL SYSTEM
(a) Pain abdomen (b) lose stools (c) constipation (d) flatulence (e) heart burn
(f) Bleeding per rectum
8 EYE AND ADNEXA
(a) Watering (b) diminution of vision (c) redness
9 EAR
(a) Discharge (b) decreased hearing (c) Tinnitus
10 SKIN
(a) Itching (b) skin eruptions (c) scaling (d) pigmentation
98
Annexures
11 GENITO URINARY SYSTEM
(a) Burning micturition (b) increased frequency of micturition
12 GENERAL SYMPTOMS
(a) Fatigue (b) headache (c) fever
13 ANY OTHER COMPLAINTS (a) burning feet (b) swelling in groin
(c) Memory loss (d) insomnia
III Assessment of health seeking behaviour
1 Do you visit a health facility in case of illness (a) Yes (b) No
If yes how much time do you take to visit a health facility an case of an illness
(a) Within 24 hours (b) 24-48 hours (c) more than 48 hours
2 Which type of health facility do you visit
(a) Govt hospital (b) Private practitioners (c) over the counter drugs (e) quacks
Mention the reason for visiting the particular health facility______________________
3 Whether taking regular treatment after diagnosis ________________
If No mention the reason_______________________
4 Whether following the instructions given by the treating doctor
(a) Yes (b) no
5 cost of treatment per month in case of chronic disease
(a) lt100 (b) 100-200 (c) 200-300 (d) 300 and above
6 Person bearing the cost of treatment
(a) Self (b) spouse (c) son (d) daughter (d) outside help
7 Duration to reach the health facility
(a) less than 3o minutes (b) 30 minutes or more
8 Whether going for regular check -ups (a) Yes (b) No
If Yes duration between the check-ups_______
99
Annexures
9 Whether following self- care practices in case of chronic disease like diabetes and hypertension
(a) Yes (b) No
10 In case of healthy individuals whether getting screening tests done (a) Yes (b) No
11 Whether following any dietary modifications (a) yes (b) No
12 Whether any family member accompanies you to the health facility
If yes who (a) Son (b) daughter (c) spouse (d) others
11 Whether the family supports in following specific diet advised by the doctor
(a) Yes (b) No
12 whether family members help in reminding to take regular medication
(a) Yes (b) No
IV Physical examination
1 Personal hygiene status
S NO COMPONENT CONDITION REMARKS
1 Hair
2 Teeth
3 Bath
4 Clothes
5 Washing hand before
eating food
6 Washing hands with soap
and water after ablution
7 Nails
8 Foot wear
Remarks personal hygiene status Good fair poor
100
Annexures
2 MEASUREMENTS
(a) Weight (in Kg) ______ (b) Height (in cm) _____ (c) BMI ______
(d) Waist circumference______ (e) Hip circumference ___________
(f) Waist hip ratio_________
3 GENERAL PHYSICAL EXAMINATION
Pallor Icterus Cyanosis clubbing lymphadenopathy Oedema
Pulse rate Temp Blood Pressure
Respiratory rate
20 Examination of
Eye Oral cavity Ear
Nose Throat
SYSTEMIC EXAMINATION
Cardiovascular system Respiratory system
Per abdomen Central Nervous system
101
MASTER CHART
Annexures
ANNEXURES
International Classification of Diseases (10th Revision)
I Certain infectious and parasitic diseases (A00-B99)
II Neoplasms (C00-D48)
III Diseases of blood and blood forming organs and certain disorders
involving the immune mechanisms (D50-D89)
IV Endocrine nutritional and metabolic diseases (E00-E90)
V Mental and behavioural disorders (F00-F99)
VI Diseases of the nervous system (G00-G99)
VII Diseases of the eye and adnexa (H00-H59)
VIII Diseases of the ear and mastoid process ( H60-H95)
IX Diseases of the circulatory system (I00-I99)
X Diseases of the respiratory system ( J00-J99)
XI Diseases of the digestive system (K00-K93)
XII Diseases of the skin and subcutaneous tissue ( L00-L99)
XIII Diseases of the musculoskeletal system and connective tissue
(M00-M99)
XIV Diseases of the genitourinary system ( N00-N99)
XV Pregnancy childbirth and purperium (O00-O99)
XVI Certain conditions originating in perinatal period (P00-P96)
XVII Congenital malformations deformations and chromosomal
XVIII (S00-T98)
XIX External causes of morbidity and mortality (V01-Y98)
102
Annexures
XX Injury poisoning and certain other consequences of external causes
(S00-T98)
XXI Factors influencing health status and contact with health services
(Z00-Z99)
XXII Codes for special purpose
103
Annexures
105
Annexures
106
Annexures
107
Annexures
PHOTOS
Picture 1 Showing the investigator interviewing the study subject
Picture 2 Showing the investigator interacting with the study subject
108
Annexures
Picture 3 Showing the investigator recording the Blood pressure of the study subject
Picture 4 Showing the investigator auscultating the study subject
109
Annexures
110
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
This work is dedicated to my beloved Mother Usha Dhar and Father
Ramesh Kumar Dhar without whom I would not be where I am today
I would like to make a special mention here of my brother Romil Dhar
For supporting me all the way and believing in me
I take this opportunity to extend my gratitude and sincere thanks to all those who
have helped me in completing this dissertation
I am thankful to all participants who were part of the study for their kind co-operation
It is with this sense of heartfelt gratitude and appreciation that I would like to express
my sincere thanks to my revered guide and teacher Dr Vidya G S MD Professor
Department of Community medicine J JM Medical College Davangere for having
rendered encouragement and valuable suggestions during the course of this study Her
patience keen interest in the progress of my research work and readiness with which
she entered into discussion has been instrumental in the successful completion of my
dissertation work
I would also like to express my sincere gratitude to Dr Balu P S MD Professor and
Head Department of Community Medicine JJMMC for his valuable advice
constant guidance and inspiration during my study course
vi
LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS USED (in alphabetical order)
APD - Acid Peptic Disease
AYUSH- Ayurveda Yoga Unani Siddha and Homeopathy
BMI - Body Mass Index
CAD - Coronary Artery Disease
CVD - Cardiovascular Diseases
ENT - Ear Nose Throat
GIT - Gastrointestinal Tract
HBM- Health Belief Model
HSB- Health Seeking Behviour
ICD - International Classification of Diseases
ICMR- Indian Council of Medical Research
MI - Myocardial Infarction
NCOP- National Council for Older Persons
viii
NCD- Non Communicable Disease
NCsrC- National Council for Senior Citizens
NGO - Non -Governmental Organization
NPOP- National Policy for Older Persons
RMP- Registered Medical Practitioner
SDGs ndash Sustainable Development Goals
SES - Socio-Economic Status
TB ndash Tuberculosis
TPB- Theory of Planned Behaviour
TRA- Theory of Reasoned Action
UN - United Nations
UHTC- Urban Health Training center
URTI- Upper Respiratory Tract Infection
WHO - World Health organization
ix
LIST OF TABLES
Table No
Title Page No
1 Percentage share of elderly population (aged 60 years and above) in
total population by sex in India
6
2 Size of elderly population (aged 60+) and their share in total
population in major states of India in 2011
7
3 List of areas covered under the UHTC of JJM Medical College
Davangere
29
4 WHO Categorization of Body Mass index (BMI) for Asians 34
5 JNC VII Classification of Blood pressure 35
6 Socio-economic status (SES)- As per modified BG Prasad
Classification
37
7 Age and sex wise distribution of the study subjects 39
8 Distribution of the study subjects based on religion 40
9 Distribution of the study subjects based on Educational status 41
10 Distribution of the study subjects based on occupation 42
11
Distribution of the study subjects based on socio-economic status
(Modified BG Prasad classification 2016)
43
12 Distribution of the study subjects based on their marital status 44
13 Distribution of the study subjects based on the type of family 45
14 Distribution of morbidity pattern of the study subjects based on ICD
10 classification of diseases
47
xiii
15
Distribution of the study subjects based on morbidity of the
Musculoskeletal system
49
16
Distribution of the study subjects based on morbidity of the eye
and adnexa
50
17 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the oral cavity 51
18
Distribution of study subjects based on endocrine nutritional and
metabolic disorders
52
19 Distribution of the study subject based on disease of the circulatory
system
53
20 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the respiratory
system
54
21
Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the digestive
system
55
22
Distribution the study subjects based on disease of the Skin and
subcutaneous tissue
56
23 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the ear 57
24
Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the
genitourinary system
58
25
Distribution of the study subjects based on diseases of the Nervous
system
59
26 Association between morbidity pattern of the study subjects and
their age group
60
xiv
27
Association between morbidity pattern of the study subjects and
their occupation
62
28
Association between morbidity pattern of the study subjects and
their religion
64
29 Reasons cited by the study subjects for not seeking healthcare in
case of an illness
67
30 Distribution of the study subjects based on the type of health facility
visited
68
31 Association between gender and health care seeking behavior of the
study subjects
69
32 Association between educational status and health care seeking
behaviour of the study subjects
70
33 Distribution of study subjects according to frequency of visits to a
health care facility
71
xv
LIST OF FIGURES
Figure No
Title Page No
1 Proportion of elderly in the Indian population by age groups
1961-2001
6
2 Pathophysiology of health issues in geriatrics 10
3 Predicting health behaviour with social cognition models 13
4 Health belief model components and linkages 15
5 Maps showing the location of Davangere district and the
area where the UHTC is located
27
6 Map showing the Urban field practice area of JJM medical college
28
7 Age and sex wise distribution of the study subjects 39
8 Distribution of the study subjects based on religion 40
9 Distribution of the study subjects based on Educational status 41
10 Distribution of study subjects based on their occupation 42
11
Distribution of study subjects based on their occupation
43
12 Distribution of the study subjects based on their marital status 44
13 Distribution of the study subjects based on the type of family 45
14 Distribution of the study subjects based on the BMI 46
15 Distribution of morbidity pattern of the study subjects based on
ICD 10 classification of diseases
48
16 Distribution of the study subjects based on the visit to health
facility in case of an illness
66
xvi
ABSTRACT Background
According to census 2011 the elderly population aged 60 years and above account for 8
of total population and is projected to rise to 124 by the year 2026 Health status is an
important factor that has a significant impact on quality of life The elderly are one of the
most vulnerable and high risk groups in terms of health status and their health seeking
behaviour is crucial in any society
Objectives
1 To study the morbidity pattern among the geriatric population in the urban field
practice area of JJM Medical college Davangere
2 To assess the health seeking behaviour of the elderly residing in the study area
Methods It was a community based cross sectional study which was conducted in the urban field
practice area of JJM Medical College Davangere The total study subjects were 440
individuals aged 60 years and above Data was collected using a predesigned pre-tested
and semi- structured questionnaire Height weight and blood pressure were measured
and recorded Data was analyzed by using MS Excel and Open-Epi Info software
version 22 Statistical test employed was chi-square and Fishers exact test x
Results and Conclusion
In our study it was found that the majority of the subjects (368) were in the age group
of 60-64 years 525 were illiterate 511 were unemployed and 49 belonged to class
IV socio economic status The study revealed that the some of the common morbidities
among the geriatric subjects were the disorders of the musculoskeletal system (714)
eye and adnexa (497) oral cavity (329) endocrine nutritional and metabolic
disorders (329)etc some disorders like cataract dental caries constipation and
increased frequency of micturition were more common among males whereas disease
like anemia and hypertension were more common among females A significant
association was found between some of the morbidities and socio demographic
determinants like age occupation and religion
Any degree of formal schooling was found to be associated with better health seeking
behavior Majority of the subjects (58) visited a Government health facility in case of
an illness and the main reason that was stated for not visiting a health facility was that
they suffered from mild discomfort (444) and did not consider it necessary to visit a
health facility
Key words Geriatric urban behaviour morbidity
xi
Introduction
INTRODUCTION
ldquoA STUDY ON THE MORBIDITY PATTERN AND HEALTH SEEKING BEHAVIOUR AMONG THE GERIATRIC POPULATION IN THE URBAN FIELD
PRACTICE AREA OF JJM MEDICAL COLLEGE DAVANGERErdquo
All countries of the world are experiencing population ageing Ageing is a result of
decreasing mortality and most importantly declining fertility The global share of older
people (aged 60 years and above) has increased from 92 per cent in 1990 to 117 in
2013 and will continue to grow as a proportion of the world population reaches 211 by
20501
The lsquoNational Policy for Older Personsrsquo was adopted by the Government of India in
January 1999 and it defines a lsquosenior citizenrsquo or lsquoelderlyrsquo as a person who is aged 60 years
or above Ageing is a progressive process associated with declines in structure and
function impaired maintenance and repair systems increased susceptibility to disease and
death2
In 2015 Worldwide there were 901 million people aged 60 years or over It is
projected that their number will grow to 14 billion in 2030 which is the target date for the
SDGs and to 21 billion by 2050 There will be growth in the number of older persons aged
60 years and above between 2015 and 2030 This increase is projected to be especially
significant global phenomenon and virtually every country in the world will experience a
substantial increase including the less developed regions3 The increased life expectancy has
led to challenges in health care management The elderly suffer from various diseases which
include non-communicable disease (NCDs) like diabetes hypertension coronary heart
disease and other disorders like osteoarthritis stroke dementia osteoporosis cancer
1
Introduction enlarged prostate depression and cataract related blindness In the coming years there will
be a phenomenal growth in the population of the elderly while the family size will reduce
The disintegration of the joint family and women moving out of the household has led to the
absence of traditional caregivers for the elderly who are already a vulnerable group4
The most common cause of health problems in the old aged people is chronic diseases
Most of these problems can be prevented or delayed by engaging in healthy behaviours
Even in the advanced years of life physical activity and good nutrition can have
effective benefits on health and well-being Many health problems of old age can be
effectively managed if they are detected early enough5 The National Policy for Older
Persons was announced by the Government of India in the year 1999 The Constitution of
India under Article 41 mandates the well-being of senior citizens ldquoThe state shall
within the limits of its economic capacity and development make effective provision
for securing the right to public assistance in case of old aged peoplerdquo 6
National Council for Older Persons (NCOP) has been reconstituted and renamed as
National Council for Senior Citizens (NCSrC) in order to have a definite structure and also
regional balancing the NCOP advises the Central and State Governments on a broad range
of issues related to welfare of senior citizens and enhancement of their quality of life The
NCSrc meets at least twice a year7 The elderly suffer from multiple medical as well as
psychological problems There has already been some pioneering work on the elderly in
India but a lot more remains to be done There is an urgent need to pay attention
towards the medical and socio-economic problems that are being faced by the elderly
people in India and thus formulate strategies to bring about an improvement in their
quality of life8 The Health seeking behaviour is influenced by various factors which
include the individual self diseases and the availability and accessibility of health
2
services It is important to have knowledge regarding the health seeking behaviour of
individuals for designing health care policies and programmes so that all the possible
difficulties with early diagnosis and effective treatment can be identified and appropriate
interventions can be implemented9 As already stated the elderly are a vulnerable group as
there are psychological as well as physiological changes with increasing age and it is
difficult to cope up with the problems of ageing Some of the most common problems in old
age are cardiovascular problems arthritis respiratory problems blood pressure and so on
Therefore the study of the health status of elderly morbid conditions perceptions about
it is important to note and the health care of the elderly becomes very important since they
are more prone to illness than young people and are also more prone to domestic and other
accidents Their health and treatment seeking behaviour are most important for the
formulation of welfare programmes of the country 10
Hence this study was taken up in the urban field practice area of JJM Medical College
Davangere to assess the morbidity pattern and health seeking behaviour of the geriatric
subjects
3
Objectives
OBJECTIVES
1 To study the morbidity pattern among the geriatric population in the urban field
practice area of JJM Medical college Davangere
2 To assess the health seeking behaviour of the elderly residing in the study area
4
Review of literature
vii
REVIEW OF LITERATURE
1 Definition Geriatrics or clinical gerontology Is the term used for the care of the aged 11 The United Nations uses 60 years and above to refer to older people the same is also used
by demographers However in many developed countries the age of 65 is used as the
reference point for older persons 12
Elderly are classified in to 3 groups 13
Young old Persons in the age group of 60 years to 74 years
Old old Persons in the age group of 75 years to 84 years
Oldest old Persons above the age of 85 yrs
2 Demography of the ageing population in India
The UN defines a country as ldquoAgeingrdquo or ldquoGreying Nationrdquo where the
proportion of people over 60 reaches 7 percent to total population By 2011 India has
exceeded that proportion (80 percent) and is expected to reach 126 percent in 2025
The Indian population has increased from 361 million in 1951 to 1027 billion in 2001
and further to 121 billion in 2011 Simultaneously the number of older people has
increased from 19 million (ie 4 percent of total population) to 77 million and
further to roughly 93 million (ie 75 percent of the total) during the same time
span 14
5
Review of literature
Figure1 proportion of elderly in the Indian population by age groups 1961-2001 14
Table 1 Percentage share of elderly population (aged 60 years and above) in total
population by sex in India 15
Years Male Female Total Rural Urban
1961 55 58 56 58 47
1971 59 60 60 62 50
1981 64 66 65 68 54
1991 67 68 68 71 57
2001 71 78 75 77 67
2011 77 84 80 81 79
2004-05 69 75 72 73 70
2007-08 73 77 75 76 72
6
Review of literature
The rise in population of males was more modest from 55 percent to 71 percent while for
females there had been a steep rise from 58 percent to 78 percent during five decadal
Censuses from 1961 to 2001 In 2011 the elderly population accounted for 80 percent of
total population For males it was marginally lower at 77 percent while for females it was
84 percent According to NSSO surveys the proportion of elderly population in rural areas
was 73 percent during 2004-05 and increased up to 76 percent in 2007-08 While on the
other hand in urban areas the proportion of elderly population rose from 70 percent to 72
percent during the corresponding period It has been observed that the percentage share of
elderly to total population remained higher in rural areas than in urban areas15
Table2 Size of elderly population (aged 60+) and their share in total population in major states of India in 201115
All India and selected major states
Proportion of elderly in total population of State
Male Female Total Andhra Pradesh 83 94 88 Bihar 72 67 70 Gujarat 76 90 83 Haryana 66 76 71 Himachal Pradesh 104 103 104 Karnataka 79 89 84 Kerala 118 133 126 Madhya Pradesh 68 74 71 Maharashtra 88 97 93 Orissa 91 95 93 Punjab 91 100 95 Rajasthan 66 79 72 Tamil Nadu 102 109 105 Uttar Pradesh 66 71 68 West Bengal 82 82 82 All India 77 84 80
7
Review of literature
3 MORBIDITY PATTERN AMONG THE ELDERLY
Physiological Decline and Consequences of increasing age
Ageing i s a process of decline in biological functions affecting most physical
Systems The following systems are affected by ageing
(a) Atrophy of the Taste Buds and Loss of Teeth
With the increasing age the taste buds of the tongue get atrophied and as a result the
preference for food alters significantly There is also a considerable loss of teeth causing
difficulties in chewing food
(b) Changes in the Gastrointestinal Tract
As the age advances the walls of the intestine get atrophied and the motility is
markedly reduced (lazy intestine) The digestive enzymes secreted by the intestine are
also reduced Hence the partly digested food stays in the intestine for a longer period
As a result the common complaint of the elderly person is gas formation (flatulence)
and constipation
(c) Respiratory System
As the age advance there is progressive fibrosis of the lungs leading to reduced
oxygenation of the lungs and breathing difficulties
(d) Kidney and genitourinary System
The kidneys get smaller in size and the power of the kidneys to filter out the unwanted
waste products from the body is diminished The total amount of urine becomes less in
old age and thus the waste products are not adequately excreted from the body
8
Review of literature
(e) Urinary Bladder
Urinary bladder gets smaller in size due to shrinkage and as a result the accumulation
of urine even of a small amount leads to an urge for urination With increase in age
the valve in the bladder which controls the exit of urine from the bladder to urethra
gets atrophied and weak Involuntary leakage of urine occurs in case the bladder is full
or due to increase of pressure on bladder on sneezing or even on laughing a condition
known as urinary incontinence Incontinence is a common complaint of elder females
(f) Heart and Circulatory System
The blood vessels get rigid and quite often the vessel walls become rough with the
deposition of solid matters consisting mostly of cholesterol The heart muscles get weaker
and power to send blood throughout the body through the circulatory system gets less and
less powerful The most dangerous effect on heart is coronary heart disease especially
coronary thrombosis
(g) Muscular system
The muscles in the body get gradually atrophied with ageing and especially those
small muscles which are necessary for quick reflex action The elderly person can quite
be capable of working like a normal person and can undertake activities which require
big muscles of legs and arms But when it comes to quick movement which needs small
muscles for quick reflex movements these functions are impaired causing accidents
like slipping on wet floor of the bathroom
(h) Brain
With ageing the size of the brain gets smaller and the weight also becomes less This
however does not interfere with the function of the brain However in general the brain
cells and its fibers which carry impulses from brain to the system and upwards get
9
Review of literature
degenerated The most glaring manifestation of ageing affecting the brain is
forgetfulness and in simple terms it is inability of brain to recall the past experience
However this is common in all elderly persons
(i ) Bones
The bones become porous and fragile as age advances especially in elderly females This
condition is known as osteoporosis and leads to sustaining of fractures even after a minor
fall16
Figure 2 pathophysiology of health issues in geriatrics17
The common disease that the geriatric population suffers from are type 2 diabetes
coronary heart disease hypertension stroke chronic obstructive pulmonary disease
10
Review of literature
Alzheimerrsquos disease osteoarthritis osteoporosis prostatic hypertrophy cataracts macular
degeneration cancer etc and at the same time they are vulnerable to infections involving
respiratory (including TB) urinary and digestive tract17
In India the elderly people suffer from dual medical problems ie communicable and
nonndash communicable diseases There is also impairment of special sensory functions like
vision and hearing A decline in immunity and age-related physiological changes leads to
an increased burden of communicable diseases in the elderly A report by Indian Council
of Medical Research (ICMR) on the chronic morbidity profile in the elderly states that
hearing impairment is the most common morbidity followed by visual impairment
However different studies show varied results in the morbidity pattern18
Major chronic conditions affecting older people worldwide 19
Cardiovascular diseases (such as coronary heart disease) Diabetes Mellitus
Hypertension Stroke Cancer
Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease
Musculoskeletal conditions (such as arthritis and osteoporosis)
Mental health conditions (mostly dementia and depression)
Blindness and visual impairment
11
Review of literature
Health seeking behaviour
1 Definition
There is no common definition agreed upon by sociologists in any sociology literature
Different definitions may be used in different studies despite referring to the same activity
Sociology and literature assume that health seeking behaviour is influenced by the various
factors which include individual self or the individual diseases present and also the
availability and accessibility of health services Being dependent on these determinants and
their interactions it can be said that health care seeking behaviour is a very complex
outcome of various factors which operate at individual family and community level20
Health Seeking Behavior (HSB) refers to decision or an action taken by an individual to
maintain attain or regain good health and to prevent illness The decisions which are
made encompasses all available health care options like visiting a public or private and
modern or traditional health facility self-medication and use of home remedies or not to
utilize the available health services etc
Determining the health care seeking behavior is very important to provide a need
based health care services to the population Visiting official channels in a formally
recognized health care system has been considered as the desired Health seeking behaviour
Health seeking behavior is influenced by multiple factors including availability quality and
price of services and also social groups health views residences and personal features of the
users Peoplersquos choice of health care differs in socio demographic socio-economic and
cultural compositions and this has an effect on their health seeking behavior Urban dwellers
are generally believed to be open to new ideas and willing to try certain things on a trial and
error basis21
12
Review of literature
Health seeking behaviours two approaches
(a) Health seeking behaviours utilization of the system
This approach focuses on the actions which are taken to rectify perceived ill health and
the type of health care facility which is utilized by the people There is data which
suggests that the people visit more traditional healers and unofficial medical channels
this should be prevented and the emphasis s h o u l d b e on encouraging people to opt
first for the official channels
(b) Health seeking behaviours the process of illness response
This approach considers the factors which enable or prevent people from making
healthy choices either i n their lifestyle behaviours or use of medical care and
treatment22
Figure 3 Predicting health behaviour with social cognition models 22
13
Review of literature
2 Health belief Model of health seeking behaviour
Since lsquoHealth seekingrsquo is a conditioned behaviour any attempt which is made to
encourage people to seek health care definitely requires an understanding of their
motivation for such behaviour Only through a deeper understanding of the intricate
factors shaping behavioural practices can health promotion programmes and or
interventions successfully be introduced into the realities of the peoplersquos lives to bring
about changes in health behaviour
Behaviour change theories and models such as the Health Belief Model (HBM)
Theory of Reasoned Action (TRA) Theory of Planned Behaviour (TPB) and the
Trans theoretical model have been widely applied in public health in an attempt to
explain or predict health seeking behaviours Their use enables identification and
understanding of peoplersquos health-seeking behaviour beyond their knowledge attitudes
and practices
HBM is a health specific behavioural cognitive model This model is based on the
idea that people are more likely to change their behaviour and adhere to treatments
if they have the following perceptions (i) have a perception that they are at risk of
contracting the disease (perceived susceptibility) (ii) perception that the disease
might have an unfavorable outcome (perceived severity) (iii) perceive that the
proposed health behaviour to be both effective and practical (perceived benefits)
(iv) perceive the barriers to adopting the behaviour to be minimal (perceived
barriers)(v) perceive themselves to have the ability of applying and practicing the
specific behaviour proposed (perceived self-efficacy) and (vi) they have the cues
for motivating their actions such as internal cues (pain symptoms past experiences)
or external cues (advice from friends relatives and mass media campaigns) (cues to
14
Review of literature
action) The specificity of the HBM to health has made it suitable for use in
understanding and explaining the behaviour as well as health outcomes and this may also
explain its wider use in public health2 3
Figure 4 Health belief model components and linkages 23
3 Factors influencing health seeking behaviour
The factors affecting the health seeking behaviours are seen in various contexts which
include physical socio-economic cultural and political factors Therefore the utilization of
a health care system whether public or private formal or non- formal may depend on socio-
demographic factors social structures level of education cultural beliefs and practices and
some other factors like gender discrimination status of women economic and political
systems environmental conditions and the disease pattern and health care system itself also
have an impact on the health seeking behaviour24
15
Review of literature
REVIEW OF RELATED STUDIES
A study done by Sanjay Polisetty and Madhavi Seepana (2017) on the morbidity profile
of elderly individuals in urban Visakhapatnam revealed that of the 270 study participants
about 996 suffered from either some form of acute or chronic morbidity More than 70
of individuals suffered from eye problems of which most common problem was cataract
seen in 60 About 304 had difficulties in chewing and 256 had difficulty in hearing
Hypertension was present in 49 of individuals and 742 of Diabetics were also found to
be hypertensive25
A study done by Swapnil Jain et al (2016) on Morbidity pattern among geriatric
population in urban field practice area of a district in Maharashtra revealed 653 suffered
from hearing impairment 62 were anemic 462 had hypertension 423 had joint
pain 41 had dental problems 38 7 had cataract and 318 had chronic bronchitis It
was seen that 81 of the subjects had multiple morbidities 26
A study done by Rajat Das Gupta et al (2016) in an urban area of Bangladesh on Morbidity
pattern and health-seeking behavior among the senior citizens revealed that of the 384 study
participants 968 were suffering from at least one medical problem The commonest was
musculoskeletal problems in 8411 followed by eye problems in 8125 It was found that
all the respondents sought treatment for their health problems 33 respondents went to
Government hospitals to seek medical help 6927 respondents took prescribed
medications and 567 were satisfied with their treatment 27
16
Review of literature
A study done by Md Alam Naushad et al (2016) on Morbidity pattern and health
seeking behavior in elderly population of Raipur City Chhattisgarh revealed that the
prevalence of morbidity among elderly was 9531 Out of total morbid population some
chronic illness was present in 7049 Gastro intestinal system was involved in 8262
followed by eye in 7983 and Cardiovascular system in 5245 It was found that 3552
of the subjects sought treatment from private registered practitioners 28
A study done by Sribas Goswami and Manjari Sahai (2016) in Raipur city on Morbidity
Pattern in elderly Population revealed that out of total study population of 640 elderly
subjects 610 (9531) suffered from some morbidity Prevalence among females was
9892 whereas among males it was 9026 Out of various agencies 3552 subjects
were utilizing private facility followed by 2785 who were utilizing Government agency
2631 visited quacks and 1030 were taking treatment from other source 29
A study done by Harsh Bardhan et al (2016) on the Morbidity profile of elderly population
in Ghaziabad district revealed that in geriatric population 5008 suffered from
musculoskeletal problems 5877 had dental problems and impairment of vision was seen
in 5561 The overall prevalence of diabetes and heart disease were 10 and 122
respectively 236 subjects reported the problem of loneliness and depression
forgetfulness was also reported by 3296 As far as treatment seeking behavior is
concerned approach of elderly is quite different for different morbidities The main source
of treatment for morbidities such as hypertension respiratory urinary GIT-related and
musculoskeletal problems was quacks 30
17
Review of literature
A study done by Mohammad Maharoof et al (2016) on the health problems among
the aged in Urban Aligarh UP revealed that of the 225 study subjects 782 had cataract
followed by depression in 356 refractive error in 276 loco-motor problem in 213
and hearing loss in 138 The prevalence of hearing loss was significantly related to gender
as it was higher among females with 181 compared to males in whom it was 6931
A study done by Gowri Shankar and Bhayalaxmi Sidenur (2016) on morbidity of
elderly residing in an urban area of Bagalkot revealed that the most common morbidity was
Cataract seen in 2875 followed by musculoskeletal problems in 2813 and 2313
were known hypertensive Both diabetes mellitus and hypertension was observed in 10 of
the study subjects32
A study done by Leena Rahul Salunkhe (2015) on socio-demographic profile of old
age people living in urban amp urban slum areas in Maharashtra Karad revealed that 504
and 42 elderly suffered from arthritis in an urban area and a slum respectively Number of
diabetics were higher in urban (14) than urban slum (35) 301 of subjects from urban
area suffered from hypertension compared to 161 from urban slums Upper Respiratory
Infections was more in slum dwellers (196) than people residing in urban area (7) Acid
peptic diseases were found in 168 study subjects in urban area and 154 in slum area 33
In a study done by Warbhe Priyanka A and Warbhe Rupesh (2015) on morbidity
profile health seeking behaviour and home environment survey of the elderly in an urban
slum community it was found that 941 had 1-3 morbidities 41 had 4-6 morbidities
373 gave a history of fall and 314 had history of fracture 136 subjects had been
18
Review of literature
operated for cataract 168 had undergone a procedure for fracture and10 had undergone
a dental procedure 542 went to Urban health center (UHC) and Government hospitals for
treatment and 786 received both allopathic and Ayurvedic treatment34
A study done by Man Mohan Gupta et al (2015) on Assessment of Clinico-
socioeconomic status and health-care support among the elderly people aged older than 60
years in urban population of Bhopal revealed that 353 subjects received treatment for
their morbidities from the Government hospitals whereas 267 from private
clinichospital About 653 study subjects presented with complaints and morbidity The
common morbidities which were found in the subjects were fatigue (487) backache
(353) Obesity (393) and hypertension (247)35
In a study done by Shilpa Shaukaiah et al (2015) on prevalence of morbidity pattern
among geriatric age group in an urban slum of Mumbai it was found that body ache was the
most commonly reported symptom by 290 followed by visual problems in 2318 joint
pain in 2181 indigestion in 2045 and backache in 2045 subjects36
A study done by Shubha Davalagi B et al (2015) on morbidity psycho-social profile and
health seeking behavior of the elderly population in urban slums of Davangere City revealed
that the most common morbidity which was present in the study subjects was
musculoskeletal problems in 46 psychosocial problems were present in 31 and
respiratory problems in 23 Majority of the elderly (56) utilized government
institutions for treatment of chronic disease and 47 for treatment of acute disease The
elderly population had financial constraints and lack of accessibility in seeking health care37
19
Review of literature
A study done by Vandana Nikumb et al ( 2015) on morbidity Profile among Geriatric
Population in an Urban Area of Navi Mumbai revealed that 9312 elderly were morbid and
with increasing age the number of morbidities was found to be increasing In this study it
was found that the most common morbidity was psychosocial problems which include
stress which was present in 594 subjects followed by musculoskeletal problems in
556 and eye problems like diminished vision mostly due to cataract in 463
Hypertension dental problems respiratory problems ENT problems (hearing impairment)
and endocrine disorders like diabetes accounted for 281 219 119 106 and10
respectively38
A study done by Vishnoi BR et al (2015) on Morbidity Profile of Elderly in Urban
Slum of Udaipur Rajasthan revealed that 61 of the study subjects had impaired vision
followed by 25 who had hypertension 1533 suffered from insomnia 1467 had
anemia and 14 suffered from gastrointestinal problems The condition of females was
worse compared to males39
In a study done by L Subedhi and RB Sah (2015) on the health status of geriatric age
group in Chitwan district of Nepal it was found that of the 300 study subjects 44 had
Ophthalmic problems 43 had GIT problems 33 had CVS problems 23 had ENT
problems 1567 had metabolic disorders and 533 had mental disorders The study
highlighted a high prevalence of morbidity and health related problems in the geriatric age
group40
20
Review of literature
A study done by Sofia Noor et al (2015) on health status of geriatric population in slums
of Rourkela revealed that the morbidities among the elderly that were found to be significant
were hypertension decreased visual acuity urinary problems and insomnia Apart from
systemic morbidities 91 of the elderly also complained of fragility which includes
complex physiological deterioration and unexplained weight loss41
In a study conducted by VM Sarode (2014) on Chronic Diseases Related to Ageing and
Disease Prevention in Slums in Mumbai it was found that there were highly significant
disorders among aged women related to Skin lesion and super infection Untreated bacterial
pharyngitis acute rheumatic fever while disorders among aged men were related to
hypertension Illicit drug use diabetes and asthma It was found that 49 of elderly males
and 45 of elderly females had not sought any treatment for their illness Of the people who
had sought treatment 93 elderly males and 92 of elderly females had taken treatment
from Government hospital42
A study conducted by Sanjeev Kumar Barman et al (2014) on morbidity profile of
geriatric population in an urban slum of Kishnganj Bihar revealed that the prevalence of
anemia cataract and hypertension were quite high 6375 6125 and 5063
respectively Loss of income amp occupation along with a feeling of neglect from the family
members were the common problems among the elderly It was also found that morbidities
like arthritis loss of teeth amp dental caries along with depression had a significant association
with sex age amp educational status of the study subjects43
21
Review of literature
A study done by Khadervali Nagoor et al (2014) on the health status of elderly
population in an urban area of Kadapa revealed that out of the 200 elderly persons studied
Visual problem due to cataract and refractive errors were present in 72 of the study
subjects followed by pain in joints in 595 gastrointestinal problems in 46 and dental
problems in 44 Other morbidities were hypertension in 42 genitourinary problems in
25 dermatological problems in 235 and psychological problems in 1644
A study done by Kakkar R et al (2013) on morbidity profile among geriatric population
in District Dehradun revealed that the working geriatric group was healthy as compared to
those who were retired Hypertension was the commonest morbidity among all age groups
In the age group of 60-70 years the following morbidities were seen hypertension (306)
followed by diabetes (153) arthritis (14) CVS morbidities (14) cataract (96) and
BPH (83) Among 71-80 years age group Hypertension (287) followed by arthritis
(167) cataract (157) Diabetes (111) BPH (111) and CVS morbidities (93)45
In a study done by Bhawalkar JS et al (2013) on morbidity profile among geriatric
population in an urban area of Pune it was found that Musculoskeletal disorder was the
most common (4331) followed by eye problems (3722) and hypertension (137)It
was seen that 43 elderly population had some health problem but only 8 visited the
health facilities Among them 6 visited private practitioners and only 18 went to
municipal hospitals It was found that only 2322 elderly were taking any medications and
the most commonly used drug was anti-inflammatory drugs 2323 followed by
antihypertensive drugs 136746
22
Review of literature
A study conducted by Deepak Sharma et al (2013) on morbidity pattern and health-
seeking behavior of aged population residing in Shimla revealed that the following
morbidities were present in the study subjects hypertension was the commonest (56)
followed by Musculoskeletal problems (535) Dental problems (27) cataract (23)
anemia (15) and acid peptic disease (175) 658 of the subjects were seeking
treatment for their health problems Majority of the older people preferred allopathic
medicine (812) followed by Ayurvedic medicines (113) and homeopathic medicine
(73) for their health problems Most of the older persons preferred going to a
CHCGovernment hospital for treatment for their illness There was considerable use of
over-the-counter drug by125 of the people 47
A study done by JP Singh et al (2013) on Geriatric morbidity profile in an urban slum of
Nagpur central India revealed that the most common morbidity identified in the study
population was anemia (9650) followed by hypertension (345) arthritis (3225)
cataract (21) and diabetes (1775) More than 2 morbidities were present in 325 of
the study subjects followed by four morbidities in 3125 and two morbidities in 23548
A study conducted by RP Thakur et al (2013) on the health problems of the elderly in
central India revealed that among the elderly residing in the urban areas 384 of the urban
elderly had both dental problems and arthritis followed by anemia in 348 hypertension in
266 cataract in 252 and diabetes mellitus in 157 The prevalence of self-reported
depression was 672 among the urban female elderly when compared to 397 among the
urban females49
23
Review of literature
A study done by Mrinal Ranjan Srivastav et al (2013) on Morbidity Status and its
Social determinants among elderly population of Lucknow revealed that the most common
morbidity among the urban population was eye problems which affected 516 males and
67 females followed by CVS problems in 363 males and 395 females and GIT
problems in 315males and 382 females50
A study done by Shraddha K et al (2012) on morbidity pattern among elderly in urban
population of Mysore revealed that out of the 526 study subjects 486 suffered from the
disease of the eye and adnexa followed by 384 who suffered from endocrine and
metabolic disorders 331 suffered from the disease of the circulatory system 323 had
disease of the oral cavity and salivary glands and 302 had disease of the musculoskeletal
system 51
A study done by Vimala Thomas et al (2012) on morbidity profile and health seeking
behaviour of the elderly in urban slums of Hyderabad revealed that hypertension was the
most common morbidity in 469 followed by Arthritis in 302 Diabetes in 265
respiratory problems in 243 and Cataract in 21 For out-patient treatment 472 visited
private sectors 303 Government facility 25 RMP and 06 AYUSH clinics For in-
patient treatment 198 visited private institutions 16 visited Government institutions
while 642 did not visit either52
24
Review of literature
A study done by Soe Moe et al (2012) on health seeking behaviour of elderly in
Myanmar revealed that 35 of the male elderly perceived that they were having good
health status whereas 229 of them perceived having a poor health status 343 of female
elderly perceived that they were having good health status while 24 of them perceived
having a poor health About 49 of the elderly went to rural health center for treatment
followed by 33 who went to private practitioners 15 visited hospitals and 3 went to
more than one place for treatment53
A study done by Dharamvir Ranjan Bharati et al (2011) in Puducherry revealed that in
the urban areas about 707 of the study subjects had anemia followed by 537 who had
visual impairment and hypertension and 532 suffered from diabetes mellitus It was seen
that On univariate analysis the risk of diabetes mellitus was significantly higher among
elderly from urban areas than that among elderly from rural areas and significantly lower
risk in elderly from below poverty line than in those belonging to normal (not below poverty
line)54
A study done by Rajashree Bhat et al (2011) on the morbidity pattern among the elderly
population in Ahmedabad revealed that most common morbidity of elderly was the
problems of loco-motor system (486) followed by vision (427) and hypertension
(344) In this study only 37 of elderly had psychosocial problems55
A study done by Krishnamachari Srinivasan et al (2010) in an urban area of Bangalore
revealed that 494 subjects had hypertension 323 had diabetes 281 had arthritis
279 suffered from Genitourinary and cardiovascular disease It was observed that about
25
Review of literature
49 of the respondents made less than three physician visits and 13 were hospitalized for
health related problems during the past one year 56
A study done by Kajal Srivastava et al (2010) on the morbidity pattern of the elderly in
urban Agra revealed that 9529 of the elderly were morbid in the slum areas The most
common morbidity which was seen among the elderly people residing in urban slums was
anemia which was seen in 3843 followed by cataract in 298 arthritis in 2431 and
hearing impairments in 2157The system wise distribution of the morbidity pattern
showed the most common systemic involvement was visual disorders 5216 followed by
musculoskeletal system 4784 and the gastrointestinal system 4314 The number of
morbidities was found to be increasing with age and this association with age was
statistically significant57
A study done by Abdullah Ladha et al (2009) on the health seeking behaviour of elderly
population in a poor-urban community of Karachi Pakistan revealed that 164 of the
elderly people were Diabetic and 301 had Hypertension The Common symptoms that
prompted elderly of to seek health care were fever (612) generalized body aches (434)
and cough (404) About 614 responders reported factors which deterred them from
seeking health care out of which 62 reported financial constraint as the commonest factor
Deterrence from seeking health care was associated with illiteracy and living alone58
26
Methodology METHODOLOGY
The study was conducted in the urban field practice area of JJM Medical college
Davangere The city of Davangere is situated in the central part of Karnataka state
265 km north of the state capital Bengaluru along the national highway number 4
Figure 5 Maps showing the location of Davangere district and the area where the
UHTC is located
27
Methodology
Figure 6 Map showing the Urban field practice area of JJM medical college
28
Methodology
Table 3 List of areas covered under the UHTC of JJM Medical
College Davangere
Areas covered Total population Bethur road 1374 Hedge nagar 1213 Mehboob nagar 3042 Mustafa nagar A 2093 B D layout A 1084 Mustafa nagar B 1127 Mahavir nagar 930 Muddabovi colony 1094 Maganhalli 1221 Tippu nagar 968 B D layout B 1717 Batti layout 1080
STUDY AREA The study was conducted in the urban field practice area of JJM
Medical College Davangere which consists of 12 areas with a total population of
16943
STUDY DESIGN Cross sectional study
STUDY POPULATION Persons aged 60 years and above
Total Population Covered 16943
29
Methodology
INCLUSION CRITERIA subjects aged 60 years and above living in the study area
for more than one year duration
EXCLUSION CRITERIA Subjects who we r e no t w i l l i ng t o pa r t i c ipa t e i n
t he s t udy
STUDY PERIOD 1 year from 1st December 2015 to 30th November 2016
SAMPLE SIZE As quoted by Manmohan Gupta et al 35 in the studies done in various
parts of India the prevalence of morbidity in the geriatric population ranges from 31-80
Considering the prevalence of morbidity to be about 50 in the geriatric population at 95
confidence level and allowable error of 10 and a non -response rate of 10 sample size
was calculated to be 440 using the formula
n=4pq L2
n= sample size
4= factor to achieve 95 level of confidence
p= prevalence of morbidities ie 50
q= 100- p ie 100-50 = 50
L= permissible error in the estimate of ldquoprdquo (10 of p)
n = 4 x 50 x 50 = 400
5 x 5
After calculating a non-response rate of 10 a sample size of 440 was calculated
30
Methodology
A community based cross sectional study was conducted in the urban field practice
area of JJM Medical College Davangere The Urban field practice area has a total
population of 16943 and there are 12 areas in urban field practice area of JJM Medical
College Davangere
The Study was conducted by probability proportionate sampling The sample size for each
area was derived from the formula
1198991 =119875119900119901119906119897119886119905119894119900119899 119894119899 119890119886119888ℎ 119886119903119890119886
119879119900119905119886119897 119875119900119901119906119897119886119905119894119900119899119883 119878119886119898119901119897119890 119878119894119911119890
Example 1st area has a population of 1374 so
1198991 =1374
16943119883 440 = 36
Therefore 36 elderly subjects were selected by house to house visit from 1st area Same
procedure was applied for other areas until the desired sample size of 440 was reached
MATERIALS USED FOR DATA COLLECTION
The following tools were used for data collection
Semi-structured predesigned and pre-tested questionnaire
Portable bathroom weighing machine
Stretch- resistant measuring tape
Mercury Sphygmomanometer
Others - stethoscope torch tuning fork knee hammer
ICD-10 for system wise classification of disease59
31
Methodology METHOD OF COLLECTION OF DATA After establishing rapport with the family
and explaining the data collection procedure in the local language an informed verbal
consent was obtained from each individual and data was collected using a
Predesigned semi structured questionnaire by Interview method The questionnaire
comprised of the following information socio-demographic data of the study subjects
information regarding the morbidity pattern and health seeking behaviour If there were
more than one elderly subjects in the same household then all were included
The study subjects were asked about any ho illness (communicable or non-
communicable) which they were suffering from Upon a positive response the subjects were
further asked to specify the type(s) and duration of morbidities that they were suffering
from eg heart disease diabetes gastrointestinal diseases respiratory disease etc Some
were unable to understand or answer questions due to illness In such cases help was sought
from the family members Based on the self-reported symptoms information from
hospital records and clinical examination the prevalence of different morbidities among the
study subjects was assessed The Information about the health seeking behaviour was
sought by asking the study subjects about their visits to a health facility in case of an illness
and also the type of health facility visited ( Government private or quacks )
DATA ENTRY AND ANALYSIS Data was entered and analyzed using MS Excel and
Open Epi Info version 2260 Both descriptive and inferential statistics were used Subjectrsquos
baseline characteristics were presented as frequencies and percentages Categorical
variables between the groups were compared using Chi square test and Fisherrsquos exact
test Fisherrsquos exact test was used when more than 20 cells had expected value lt 5 and any
one of the cells had expected value lt 1 All statistical analysis was carried out at 5 level
of significance and p value lt005 was considered as significant
32
Methodology ETHICAL CLEARANCE
Ethical clearance was obtained before conducting the study from the Ethical Committee of
JJM Medical college Davangere [ANNEXURE III] During the study verbal
informed consent was taken from the study subjects Assurance was given that the
confidentiality concerning their information will be maintained
Clinical Examination included
(a) General physical examination
(b) Anthropometric measurements like height and weight
(c) Systemic examination
(d) Measurement of Blood pressure
(e) Eye examination by torch and Snellenrsquos (E chart)61
(f) Hearing assessment by Rinnersquos test Webberlsquos and Absolute bone conduction
test using tuning fork 62
Parameters used in our study
Height Height was measured with a standard non-stretchable measuring tape to the
nearest 01 cm in standing position (without footwear standing upright with the
back against the wall heels together and eyes directed forward)
33
Methodology Weight Weight was measured with minimal clothing and respecting the modesty of the
individual without footwear using a calibrated standard bathroom weighing scale to the
nearest 05 kg
Body Mass Index (BMI) Using weight (in Kg) and height (in meter2) BMI was calculated by applying the formula
Body Mass Index= Weight (kg) Height (m2)
The BMI cut off values for Asians as recommended by the WHO was used in our study
Table 4 WHO Categorization of Body Mass index (BMI) for Asians 63
Measurement of Blood pressure Procedure Blood pressure was measured in the left arm in a sitting posture with the subject in a
relaxed state Standardized mercury sphygmomanometer with adult size cuff was used
The first appearance of (phase 1 of Korotkoff sounds) sound was used to define
Systolic Blood Pressure (SBP) The disappearance of sound (phase 5) was used to
define Diastolic Blood Pressure (DBP) Two readings were taken five minutes apart and
the average of the two readings was taken as the final blood pressure reading A person
was considered to be a hypertensive if he she was already diagnosed case of
hypertension and or on treatment or with a current SBP of ge 140 mm Hg or DBP ge 90 mm
Hg (JNC VII criteria)64
BODY MASS INDEX INFERENCE
lt 185 underweight
185 to 229 kg m2 Normal
23 to 249 kg m2 Overweight
ge 25 kg m2 Obese
34
Methodology
Table 5 JNC VII Classification of Blood pressure 65
BP Classification Systolic Blood Pressure Diastolic Blood Pressure
Normal lt120 lt 80
Pre Hypertension 120 ndash 139 or 80 ndash 89 Stage 1 Hypertension 140 ndash 159 or 90 ndash 99 Stage 2 Hypertension ge 160 or ge 100
Anaemia was detected by pallor of conjunctiva tongue and nails and was confirmed by
doing haemoglobin estimation using sahlirsquos hemogobinometer66
The cut off for the diagnosis of anaemia was done based on WHO classification67
Diabetes - self reported cases of diabetes were considered as diabetics for the study
STUDY VARIABLES
1 AGE - subjects aged 60 years and above were taken up for the study Age was
recorded to the nearest complete years as stated by the respondent
2 GENDER Both males and females were taken up for the study
3 EDUCATIONAL STATUS 68
i Illiterate -A person who could not read or write
ii Primary School - studied up to 4th standard
iii Higher primary- studied between 5th and 7th standard
iv Secondary school -studied between 8th and 10th standard v Intermediate- studied between 11th or 12 th standard or diploma
vi Graduate - obtained graduate degree
vii Post Graduate- obtained post graduate degree
35
Methodology
4 OCCUPATION STATUS69
i Unskilled worker
Labourer domestic servants casual worker peon sweeper porter washer-man others
(vegetable vendor)
ii Semi-skilled worker
Factory worker agriculture laborers shoemaker potters others (security guard shop
helper canteen helper
iii Skilled
Artisan clerk foreman supervisor carpenter tailor mechanic electrician railway guard
painter modeler smiths baker driver shop assistant petty trader constable soldier
linesman pointsman potter barber others (tinkering printer receptionist salesman
welder cook mason postman plumber agarbatti worker)
iv semi-professional
Teacher pharmacist social worker owner of a small business farmer others (computer
programmer Govt employee nurse)
V Professional
Doctor engineer principal lawyer Military officer senior executive business
proprietor writer scientist large employer director university professor police
officer others (horse rider)
(vi) Unemployed Presently not working retired homemakers
36
Methodology 5 SOCIO ECONOMIC STATUS
Table 6 Socio-economic status (SES)- As per modified BG Prasad Classification70
5 TYPE OF FAMILY 71
Joint Family ndash It is type of family grouping in which a number of married couples and
their children live together in the same household All the men are related by blood
and women of household are their wives unmarried girls and widows of family kinsmen
Nuclear Family - It consist of married couple and their children while they are still
regarded as dependents
Three generation family - It is a family where representatives of three generation are
living together Young married couples continue to stay with their parents and have
their own children as well
Socio-economic
status
Prasadrsquos classification
1961(Per capita income in
Rupees per month)
Modified BG Prasad classification-
updated for May 2016 ((per
capita income in Rupees per
month)
I 100 and above 6261 and above
II 50-99 3099-6260
III 30-49 1835-3098
IV 15-29 949-1834
V Below 15 lt948
37
SAMPLE SIZE ESTIMATION
SAMPLE SIZE As quoted by Manmohan Gupta et al 35 in the studies done in various
parts of India the prevalence of morbidity in the geriatric population ranges from 31-80
Considering the prevalence of morbidity to be about 50 in the geriatric population at 95
confidence level and allowable error of 10 and a non -response rate of 10 sample size
was calculated to be 440 using the formula
n=4pq L2
n= sample size
4= factor to achieve 95 level of confidence
p= prevalence of morbidities ie 50
q= 100- p ie 100-50 = 50
L= permissible error in the estimate of ldquoprdquo (10 of p)
n = 4 x 50 x 50 = 400
5 x 5
After calculating a non-response rate of 10 a sample size of 440 was calculated
A community based cross sectional study was conducted in the urban field practice area of
JJM Medical College Davangere The Urban field practice area has a total population of
16943 and there are 12 areas in urban field practice area of JJM Medical College
Davangere
The Study was conducted by probability proportionate sampling The sample size for each area
was derived from the formula
1198991 =119875119900119901119906119897119886119905119894119900119899 119894119899 119890119886119888ℎ 119886119903119890119886
119879119900119905119886119897 119875119900119901119906119897119886119905119894119900119899119883 119878119886119898119901119897119890 119878119894119911119890
Example 1st area has a population of 1374 so
1198991 =1374
16943119883 440 = 36
Therefore 36 elderly subjects were selected by house to house visit from 1st area Same
procedure was applied for other areas until the desired sample size of 440 was reached
Results
RESULTS
The results are presented under the following headings
I Socio-demographic characteristics of study subjects
II Prevalence of morbidities among the study subjects
III Details of health seeking behavior of the study subjects
38
Results
ISocio-demographic characteristics of the study subjects
Table 7 Age and sex wise distribution of the study subjects
Figure 7 Age and sex wise distribution of the study subjects
In the present study Out of 440 study subjects majority 162(368) were in the age group
of 60-64 Years followed by 109 (247) in the age group of 65-69 Years 99 (225) were
in the age group of 70-74 Years and 35 (8) were more than or equal to 80 years of age
Majority of the subjects were males 260 (59) and 180 (41) were females The mean age
of the study population was 6745 plusmn 655 Years
354 254 262
88 42
389
239 172
67 133
0102030405060708090
100
60-64 65-69 70-74 75-79 ge80
Perc
enta
ge
Age in years
Males
Females
Age group (in years)
Males Females Total
Percentage () Frequency
(n=260) Percentage ()
Frequency (n=180)
Percentage ()
60-64 92 354 70 389 162 368
65-69 66 254 43 239 109 247
70-74 68 262 31 172 99 225
75-79 23 88 12 67 35 80
ge80 11 42 24 133 35 80
Total 260 100 180 100 440 100
39
Results
Table 8 Distribution of the study subjects based on religion
Religion Frequency (n=440) Percentage ()
Hindu 188 427
Muslim 252 573
Total 440 100
Figure 8 Distribution of the study subjects based on religion
In the present study it was found that the majority of the study subject belonged to Muslim
religion 252 (573) followed by Hindus 188 (427)
0102030405060708090
100
Hindu Muslim
427
573
Perc
enta
ge
Religion of the study subjects
40
Results
Table 9 Distribution of the study subjects based on Educational status
Education Frequency (n=440) Percentage ()
Illiterate 231 525
Primary school 121 275
Higher primary 38 86
Secondary School 30 68
Intermediate 6 14
Graduate 14 32
Total 440 100
Figure 9 Distribution of the study subjects based on Educational status
In the present study it was found that the Majority of the study subjects were illiterate
231(525) 121(275) had completed education up to primary school 30(68) had
completed education up to secondary school and only 14(32) were graduates
525
275
86 68
14 32
0102030405060708090
100
Perc
enta
ge
Educational status of study subjects
41
Results Table 10 Distribution of the study subjects based on occupation
Occupation Frequency (n=440) Percentage ()
Semi-professional 2 05
Skilled worker 45 102
Semi-skilled worker 68 155
Unskilled worker 100 227
Unemployed 225 511
Total 440 100
Figure 10 Distribution of study subjects based on their occupation
In our study it was found that the majority of the study subjects 225 (511) were
unemployed followed by 100 (227) who were unskilled workers 68 (155) were semi-
skilled workers and 45 (102) were skilled workers
0102030405060708090
100
05 102 155 227
511
Perc
enta
ge
Occupation of the study subjects
42
Results Table 11 Distribution of the study subjects based on socio-economic status (Modified
BG Prasad classification 2016)
Figure 11 Distribution of the study subjects based on their socio-economic status
In our study majority of the subjects 215 (49) belonged to Class IV Socioeconomic status
followed by 115 (26) who belonged to class III and 56 (13) who belonged to class II
SES (according to Modified BG Prasad Classification 2016)
Class II 13
Class III 26
Class IV 49
Class V 12
Socio-economic status Frequency (n=440) Percentage ()
Class I 0 0
Class II 56 13
Class III 115 26
Class IV 215 49
Class V 54 12
Total 440 100
43
Results
Table 12 Distribution of the study subjects based on their marital status
Marital status Frequency (n=440) Percentage ()
Unmarried 2 05
Married 323 734
Widowwidower 115 261
Total 440 100
Figure 12 Distribution of the study subjects based on their marital status
In our study it was found that majority of the study subjects 323(734) were married
followed by 115(261) who were widowed and only 2 (05) were unmarried
0102030405060708090
100
Unmarried married Widowwidower
05
734
261 Perc
enta
ge
44
Results
Table 13 Distribution of the study subjects based on the type of family
Type of family Frequency (n=440) Percentage ()
Nuclear family 163 37
Joint family 93 21
Three generation family 184 42
Total 440 100
Figure 13 Distribution of the study subjects based on the type of family
In the present study it was found that majority of the study subjects 184 (42) lived in a
three generation family followed by 163 (37) who lived in a nuclear family and 93(21)
who lived in a Joint family
Nuclear family 37
Joint family 21
Three generation
family 42
45
Results
II Prevalence of morbidities among the study subjects
Figure 14 Distribution of the study subjects based on the BMI
In the present study it was found that out of 440 study subjects 198 (45) had a normal
BMI followed by 132 (30) who were overweight 66 (15) were obese and only 44
(10) were underweight
under weight 10
Normal 45
Overweight 30
Obese 15
46
Results
Table 14 Distribution of morbidity pattern of the study subjects based on ICD 10
classification of diseases
System involved ICD 10
Males (n=260)
Females (n=180)
Total (n=440)
No No No
Diseases of musculoskeletal system (M00 ndash M99)
184 707 130 722 314 714
Diseases of the eye and adnexa (H00 ndash H59)
139 534 80 444 219 497
Diseases of oral cavityamp salivary glands (K00 ndash K14)
90 346 64 355 154 35
Endocrine nutritional amp metabolic diseases (E00 ndash
E90)
70 269 75 417 145 329
Diseases of circulatory system (I00 ndash I99)
64 246 73 405 137 311
Diseases of respiratory system(J00 ndash J99)
64 246 37 206 101 23
Diseases of digestive system (K00 ndash K93)
57 219 30 166 87 198
Diseases of skin amp subcutaneous tissue (L00 ndash
L99)
38 146 20 111 58 132
Diseases of the ear and mastoid process (H60 ndashH95)
39 15 18 10 57 13
Diseases of genitourinary system (N00 ndash N99)
22 85 7 39 29 66
Diseases of nervous system (G00 ndash G99)
6 23 5 28 11 25
Note Total number could not be given as many subjects had multiple disorders
47
Results
Figure 15 Distribution of morbidity pattern of the study subjects based on ICD 10
classification of diseases
In the present study it was found that the majority of the subjects 314 (714) suffered
from the disorders of the musculoskeletal system followed by 219 (497) who suffered
from the disease of the eye and adnexa154 (35) suffered from the disease of the oral
cavity 145 (329) suffered from endocrine nutritional and metabolic disorders137
(311) suffered from the disease of the circulatory system 101 (229) suffered from the
disease of the respiratory system 87(198) suffered from the disease of the digestive
system 58 (132) suffered from disease of the skin 57 (13) suffered from the disease of
the ear 29 (66) suffered from the disease of the genitourinary system and only 11( 25 )
suffered from the disease of the nervous system
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
714
497
35 329 311 229
198 132 13 66
25
perc
enta
ge
48
Results
Table 15 Distribution of the study subjects based on morbidity of the musculoskeletal
system
Musculoskeletal
Disease
Males
(n=260)
Females
(n=180)
Total
(n= 440)
Statistical
Value
Knee joint pain
52 (20)
30 (167)
82 (186)
X2 = 0779
df = 1
p=03773
Back ache
30 (115)
35 (194)
65 (148) X2 = 528
df = 1
p = 0021
Joint pain (other than
knee joint pain)
52(20)
35(194)
87(198)
X2 =00206
df=1
p =0885
Non-specific aches
and pain
50(192)
30(167)
80(182)
X2=0470
df=1
p = 0492
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses
In the present study it was found that the most common morbidity of musculoskeletal
system was pain of the joints (other than the knee joint) found in 87 (198) of the subjects
followed by knee joint pain in 82 ( 186) and non-specific pains and aches were found in
80 (182) of the subjects It was found that back ache was more common in females
35(194) compared to males 30 (115) and this difference was found to be statistically
significant
49
Results
Table 16 Distribution of the study subjects based on morbidity of the eye and adnexa
Diseases of the
eye and
adnexa
Males
(n=260)
Females
(n=180)
Total
(n= 440)
Statistical
value
Cataract
112(43)
60(333)
172(391)
X2 = 4241
df=1
p = 0039
Refractive error
20(77)
14(78)
34(77)
X2= 0001
df=1
p = 0973
Others (conjunctivitis
pterygium glaucoma etc)
7(27)
6(33)
13(29)
X2=0152
df=1
p = 0696
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses
In the present study it was found that the most common morbidity of the eye was cataract
found in 172 (391) of the subjects It was more common in males 112 (43) compared to
females 60 (333) and this difference was found to be statistically significant The other
morbidities present were refractive error found in 34 (77) subjects and others which
includes conjunctivitis pterygium glaucoma etc found in 13 (29 ) subjects
50
Results
Table 17 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the oral cavity
Diseases of the
oral cavity
Males
(n =260 )
Females
(n =180 )
Total
(n = 440)
Statistical
value
Stained teeth
22 (84)
18 (10)
40 (91)
X2 =0304
df=1
p = 0581
Missing teeth
40 (154)
38 (211)
78 (177)
X2= 239
df= 1
p=0122
Caries
28 (108)
8 (44)
36 (82)
X2= 566
df= 1
p=0017
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses
In the present study it was found that the most common morbidity of the oral cavity was
missing teeth found in 78 (177 ) of the subjects followed by stained teeth found in 40
(91) of the subjects and dental caries in 36 (82) of the subjects Dental caries were
more common in males 28 (108) compared to females 8(44) and this difference was
found to be statistically significant
51
Results
Table 18 Distribution of study subjects based on endocrine nutritional and metabolic
disorders
Disorders Males
(n =260 )
Females
(n =180)
Total
(n = 440)
Statistical value
Diabetes mellitus
45 (173)
37 (206)
82 (186)
X2 = 0739
df= 1
p = 0389
Anemia
24 (92)
35 (194)
59 (134)
X2= 955
df = 1
p = 0001
Thyroid disorders
1(04)
3 (17)
4 (09)
p= 0309
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
The present study revealed that the most common disorder of the endocrine system was
diabetes mellitus found in 82 (186) of the subjects followed by the nutritional disorder of
anemia found in 59 (134) of the subjects It was seen that anemia was more common
among females 35 (194) compared to males 24 (92) This difference was found to be
statistically significant Disorders of the thyroid gland were found in 4 (09) of the subjects
being more common in females 3(17) compared to males 1 (04)
52
Results
Table 19 Distribution of the study subject based on disease of the circulatory system
Diseases of
circulatory
system
Males
(n=260 )
Females
(n =180)
Total
(n = 440)
Statistical
value
Hypertension
62 (238)
71 (394)
133 (302)
X2= 1227
df= 1
p = 0000
CAD MI
Arrhythmias
2 (08)
2 (11)
4 (09)
p =100
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
In our study it was found that the most common disease of the circulatory system was
hypertension which was found in 133 (302 ) of the subjects it was more common in
females 71 (394) compared to males 62 (239) and this difference was found to be
statistically significant The other disorders of the circulatory system were CAD MI
arrhythmias which were found only in 4 (09) of the study subjects
53
Results
Table 20 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the respiratory system
Disorders of
Respiratory
System
Males
(n=260)
Females
(n=180)
Total
(n=440)
Statistical
value
Bronchial asthma
3 (12)
3 (17)
6 (14)
p =0692
URTI
45 (173)
27 (15)
72 (164)
X2= 0413
df = 1
p = 0520
Acute Bronchitis
12 (46)
7 (39)
19 (43)
X2= 0135
df = 1
p = 0712
Pulmonary TB
4 (15)
0(00)
4 (09)
p =0148
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
Our study revealed that the most common disease of the respiratory system was URTI
(upper respiratory tract infection) found in 72 (164) subjects followed by acute bronchitis
in 19 (43 ) bronchial asthma in 6 (14) and pulmonary TB in only in 4 (09 ) subjects
Pulmonary TB was found in 4 (15) of the males whereas no females had TB however
this difference was not found to be statistically significant
54
Results
Table 21 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the digestive system
Disorders of
Gastrointestinal
system
Males
(n = 260)
Females
(n = 180)
Total
(n = 440)
Statistical value
Constipation
21(8)
6 (33)
27(61)
X2 =4155
df =1
p =0041
Gastritis
24 (92)
18 (10)
42(95)
X2= 0072
df = 1
p =0787
Bleeding per
rectum 3(12) 2(11) 5(11)
p =100
Others (Pain
abdomen
anorexia
indigestion)
9(35)
4 (22)
13 (3)
X2=0569
df =1
p=0450
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
Our study revealed that the most common disorder of the gastrointestinal system was
gastritis found in 42 (95) subjects followed by constipation in 27 ( 61) others which
include pain abdomen anorexia indigestion was found in 13 (3) and bleeding per rectum
was seen in 5 (11) It was seen that constipation was more common among males 21(8)
compared to females 6 (33) which was found to be statistically significant
55
Results
Table 22 Distribution the study subjects based on disease of the Skin and
subcutaneous tissue
Disorders of skin and
subcutaneous tissue
Males ( n = 260)
Females (n = 180)
Total (n = 440)
Statistical
value
Itching
19(73)
2(11)
21(48)
X2 =896
df=1
p = 0002
Scaling 6 (23)
3 (17)
9 (2)
p =0743
Pigmentation
5(19)
4 (22)
9 (2)
p =100
Dryness
8 (31)
11 (61)
19(43)
X2= 237
df = 1
p = 0123 Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
In the present study it was found that the most common disease of the skin was itching
which was present in 21 (48) of the study subjects followed by dryness in 19 (43) and 9
(2) of the subjects had scaling and pigmentation It was seen that itching was more
common among males 19 (73) compared to females 2 (11) and this difference was
found to be statistically significant
56
Results
Table 23 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the ear
Disease of the ear
Males
(n= 260)
Females
(n = 180)
Total
(n = 440) Statistical value
Hearing impairment
33 (126)
16 (89)
49 (111)
X2 =155
df =1
p =0212
Ear discharge
3 (12)
1 (06)
4(09)
p =0647
Tinnitus
3 (12)
1 (06)
4 (09)
p =0647
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
In the present study it was observed that hearing impairment was the most common
morbidity of the ear found in 49 (111) of the subjects though it was more common
among males 33 (126) compared to females 16 (89) the difference was not found to be
statistically significant The other disorders which affected the ear were ear discharge and
tinnitus both present in 4 (09) of the subjects
57
Results
Table 24 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the genitourinary
system
Disorders of
genitourinary system
Male
(n = 260)
Female
(n = 180)
Total
(n=440)
Statistical value
Burning micturition
2 (077)
2 (11)
4 (09)
p=100
Increased frequency of
micturition
20(77) 5(28) 25(57)
X2= 4794
df =1
p =0028 Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
In our study it was observed that the most common morbidity affecting the genitourinary
system was increased frequency of micturition in 25 (57) of the subjects followed by
burning micturition in 4 (09) of the study subjects Increased frequency of micturition was
more common among males 20 (77) compared to females 5 (28) and this difference
was found to be statistically significant
58
Results
Table 25 Distribution of the study subjects based on diseases of the Nervous system
Disease of the
nervous system Males
(n = 260)
Females
(n = 180)
Total
(n = 440)
p value
Memory loss
2 (77)
2 (11)
4 (09)
100
Stroke
2 (77)
0 (00)
2 (05)
0515
Neuritis
2 (77)
3 (17)
5 (11)
0652
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
Our study revealed that the most common disorder of the nervous system was neuritis seen
in 5 (11) of the subjects followed by memory loss in 4 (09) and stroke in 2 (05 ) of
the subjects It was observed that 2 (0 77) of males had suffered a stroke whereas none of
the females had suffered from stroke however this difference was not found to be
statistically significant
59
Results
Table 26 Association between morbidity pattern of the study subjects and their age
group
System involved 60-69Yrs
(n = 271)
70-79Yrs
(n = 134)
gt 80Yrs
(n = 35)
Total
( n = 440)
Statistical
value
Musculoskeletal
System
195 (72)
94 (70)
25 (710)
314 (714) X2= 0143
df = 2 p = 0930
Eye amp adnexa
125 (461)
69 (515)
25 (714)
219 (497) X2= 8166
df = 2 p = 0016
Oral cavity amp salivary gland
56 (207)
68 (507)
30 (857)
154 (350) X2= 7865
df = 2 p lt 00001
Endocrine nutritional amp
metabolic diseases
91 (335)
47 (35)
7 (200)
145 (329) X2= 297
df = 2 p = 0225
Circulatory
system
87 (321)
40 (298)
10 (285)
137 (311) X2= 0328
df = 2 p = 0848
Respiratory
system
64 (236)
31 (231)
6 (171)
101 (23) X2= 0738
df = 2 p = 0691
Digestive system
52 (191)
28 (210)
7 (200)
87 (191) X2= 0166
df = 2 p = 0 920
Skin and subcutaneous
tissue
43 (159)
13 (97)
2 (57)
58 (132) X2= 4831
df = 2 p = 0089
Ear amp mastoid process
27 (99)
20 (149)
10 (285)
57 (13) X2= 1018
d= 2 p = 0006
Genitourinary
system
20 (74)
8 (59)
1 (29)
29 (66) X2= 1151
df = 2 p = 0562
Nervous system
5 (18)
4 (29)
2 (57)
11 (25)
p = 0418
Figure in parenthesis indicates percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
60
Results
Table 26 shows the association between the morbidity pattern and age group of the study
subjects It is observed that the disease of the eye and adnexa increase with increasing age
and are more common in individuals above 80 years of age (714) compared to
individuals in the age group of 60-69 years (461) and 70-79 years (515) This
difference was found to be statistically significant The disease of the oral cavity were also
more common in the subjects aged 80 years and above (857) compared to individuals in
the age group of 70-79 years (507) and 60-69 years (207) this difference was also
found to be statistically significant Significant association was also found between
increasing age and disease of the ear 285 subjects aged 80 years and above suffered from
disease of the ear followed by 149 in the age group of 60-69 years and 99 in the age
group of 60-69 years
61
Results Table 27 Association between morbidity pattern of the study subjects and their
occupation
System involved Employed (n=215)
Unemployed (n=225)
Total (n=440)
Statistical value
Musculoskeletal
system
171 (795) 143 (635) 314 (714) X2 =1374 df=1
p=00002
Eye and adnexa 108 (502) 111(493) 219(497) X2= 0035 df=1
p= 0850
Oral cavityamp
salivary glands
76 (353) 78 (347) 154 (35) X2=0022 df=1
p=0880
Endocrine
nutritional amp
metabolic
disease
75 (348) 70 (311) 145 (329) X2=0708 df=1
p=0400
circulatory
system
58 (269) 79 (351) 137 (311) X2=3393 df=1
p=0065
Respiratory
system
49 (227) 52 (231) 101 (23) X2=0006 df=1
p=09363
Digestive system 45 (21) 42 (187) 87 (198) X2=0125 df=1
p=0723
Skin
subcutaneous
tissue
38 (176) 20 (88) 58 (132) X2=741 df=1
p=0006
Ear and mastoid
process
31 (144) 26 (115) 57 (13) X2=0799 df=1
p=0371
Genitourinary
system
16 (74) 13 (57) 29 (66) X2=0494 df=1
p=0481
Nervous system
2 (093) 9 (4) 11 (25) X2=425 df=1
p=0039 Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses
62
Results
Table 27 shows the association between the morbidity pattern and occupation of the study
subjects It was observed that musculoskeletal disorders were more common among the
subjects who are employed (795) compared to those who are not employed (635) and
this difference was found to be statistically significant A significant association was also
seen between the disorders of the skin and subcutaneous tissue 176 subjects who are
employed suffered from the disease of the skin and subcutaneous tissue compared to 88
who were unemployed The diseases of the nervous system were more common among
those who were unemployed (4) compared to those who were employed (093) this
difference was also found to be statistically significant
63
Results Table 28 Association between morbidity pattern of the study subjects and their
religion
System involved Hindu
(n=188)
Muslim
(n=252)
Total
(n=440)
Statistical value
Musculoskeletal system 138 (73) 176 (698) 314 (714)
X2=0668 df=1
p=0413
Eye and adnexa 100 (531) 119 (472) 219 (497) X2=1535 df=1
p= 0215
Oral cavityamp salivary glands 73 (388) 81 (321) 154 (35)
X2=211 df=1
p=0145
Endocrine nutritional amp metabolic diseases
53 (2819) 92 (365) 145 (329) X2=3371 df=1
p=0066
circulatory system 58 (269) 79 (351) 137 (311)
X2=3393 df=1
p=0065
Respiratory system
33 (176) 68 (269) 101 (229)
X2=5415 df= 1
p=0019
Digestive system 27 (144) 60 (238) 87 (198) X2=6059 df=1
p=0013
Skin subcutaneous tissue
31 (164) 27 (107) 58 (132) X2=3138 df=1
p=00765
Ear and mastoid process
28 (149) 29 (115) 57 (129) X2=1095 df=1
p=0297
Genitourinary system
16 (85) 13 (52) 29 (66) X2=1965 df=1
p=0161
Nervous system
4 (21) 7 (28) 11(25) p=0764
Figure in parenthesis indicates percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
64
Results
Table 28 shows the association between the morbidity pattern of the study subjects and their
religion In our study it was observed that the disorders of the digestive system were more
common among Muslims (238) compared to Hindus (144) this difference was found
to be statistically significant Also the disorders of the respiratory system were more
common among Muslims (269) compared to Hindus (176) This difference was also
found to be statistically significant Some of the diseases were more common among Hindus
which include the disease of the eye and adnexa (531) oral cavity (388) ear (149)
skin and subcutaneous tissue (164) and genitourinary system (85) but it was not found
to be statistically significant
65
Results
III HEATLTH SEEKING BEHAVIOR OF THE STUDY SUBJECTS
Figure16 Distribution of the study subjects based on the visit to health facility in case
of an illness
In our study it was found that that out of 440 study subjects 395(898) visited a health
facility in case of an illness whereas 45(102) did not visit any health facility in case of an
illness
898
102
health facility visitednot visited
66
Results
Table 29 Reasons cited by the study subjects for not seeking healthcare in case of an
illness
In the present study it was found that the most common reason stated by the 45 study
subjects for not seeking health care in case of an illness was that it was a mil 20 (444)
followed by lack of money stated by12 (267) the other reasons stated were no one to
accompany 7 (156) and lack of faith in health care 6 (133)
Reasons cited for not
seeking health care
Frequency (n=45)
Percentage ()
Mild discomfort 20 444
Lack of money 12 267
Lack of faith in
healthcare
6 133
No one to accompany 7 156
Total 45 100
67
Results
Table 30 Distribution of the study subjects based on the type of health facility visited
It was observed that out of 395 subjects who visited health care facility in case of an illness
229(58) Visited government hospitals 160 (405) visited private practitioners hospitals
and 6 (15) visited quacks More number of males (622) visited government hospitals
compared to females (513)
Type of health facility visited
Males
(n=241)
Females
(n=154)
Total
(n=395)
No No No
Government hospital 150 622 79 513 229 58
Private practitionershospitals 87 361 73 474 160 405
Quacks 4 17 2 13 6 15
Total 241 100 154 100 395 100
68
Results
Table 31 Association between gender and health seeking behaviour of the study
subjects
Whether visited
health facility
in case of illness
Sex
Total
n ()
p value Male
n ()
Female
n ()
Yes 241 (927) 154 (856) 395 (898) 00151
No 19 (106) 26 (144) 45 (102)
Total 260 (59) 180 (41) 440 (100)
x2=5901 df =1
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
It was observed that more number of males visited a health care facility in case of an illness
241(927) whereas only 154(856) females visited a health facility in case of an illness
This difference was found to be statistically significant
69
Results
Table 32 Association between educational status and health seeking
behaviour of the study subjects
Whether visited Health facility in case of illness
p value
Educational status(n) Yes () No ()
0000
Illiterate (231) 194 (84) 37 (16)
Primary school (121) 115 (95) 6 (49)
Higher primary (38) 37 (974) 1 (26)
Secondary school (30) 29 (967) 1 (33)
Intermediate (6) 6 (100) 0(00)
Graduate (14) 14 (100) 0(00)
Total(440) 395 (898) 45(102)
Fisherrsquos exact test
In the present study it was found that 84 of the study subjects who were illiterate visited a
health facility in case of an illness whereas 16 did not visit a health facility in case of an
illness 967 of the subjects with education up to secondary school visited the health
facility and 100 of the subjects who studied up to intermediate and with a graduate degree
visited the health facility in case of an illness This difference was found to be statistically
significant
70
Results
Table 33 Distribution of study subjects according to frequency of visits to a health care facility
Frequency of visits to a health care facility
Frequency
(n=395)
Percentage
Once a month 207 524
Once in 3 months 99 251
Once in 6 months 79 20
Once in a year 10 25
Total 395 100
In the present study it was found that out of 395 study subjects who visited a health care
facility in case of an illness 207 (524) visited a health facility every month followed by
99 (251) who visited once in 3 months 79(20) once in 6 months and 10 25 visited
the health facility once in a year
71
Discussion
DISCUSSION
I Socio-demographic characteristics
Our study was done in the urban field practice area of JJM Medical College Davangere
among 440 geriatric subjects our study aimed at assessing the morbidity pattern and health
seeking behaviour of the geriatric population in the study area
In the present study Out of 440 study subjects majority 162(368) were in the age
group of 60-64 Years followed by 109 (247) in the age group of 65-69 Years 99 (225)
in the age group of 70-74 Years and 8 were more than or equal to 80 years of age [Table
7] This was similar to a study conducted by Prakash Boraingaiah et al 72 in which majority
of the elderly (346) belongs to age group 60-64 years followed by age group 75 years and
above (259)
In our study it was also seen that 59 of the study subjects were males and 41 were
females This was similar to a study conducted by Mohan Gupta et al 35 where 573
subjects were males and 427were females Our findings were contrary to a study
conducted by Md Alam Naushad et al 28 where 598 subjects were females and 402
were males
In the present study it was found that the majority of the study subject belonged to
Muslim religion 252 (573) followed by Hindus 188 (427) there were no study subjects
who belonged to other religions like Christian Jain Sikhs etc [Table 8] similar findings
were seen in a study conducted by Mrinal Ranjan Srivastav et al 50 in which 52 of the
subjects were Muslims
72
Discussion
In the present study it was found that the Majority of the study subjects were illiterate
525 whereas 275 had completed education up to primary school 82 had completed
education up to secondary school and only 32 were graduates [Table 9] These findings
were similar to a study done by Shraddha K et al 51in which 504 of the study subjects
were illiterate
In our study it was found that the majority of the study subjects 511 were unemployed
followed by 227 who were unskilled workers 155 were semi-skilled workers and
about 105 were skilled workers [Table 10] These findings were similar to a study done
by Rajat Das Gupta et al27 al in which 481 of the study subjects were not working
In our study majority of the subjects 49 belonged to Class IV Socioeconomic status
followed by 26 who belonged to class III and 13 who belonged to class II (according to
Modified BG Prasad Classification 2016) [Table 11] Similar findings were found in a study
conducted by Sribas Goswami and Manjari Sahai 29 in which majority of the study subjects
belonged to class IV socio economic status
In our study it was found that the majority of the study subjects 734 were married
followed by 261 who were widowed and only 05 were unmarried [Table 12] These
findings were similar to a study done by L subedhi and RB Sah 40 in which 663 of the
subjects were married 322 were widowed and 07 were unmarried
In the present study it was found that majority of the study subjects 42 lived in a three
generation family followed by 37 who lived in a nuclear family and 21 who lived in a
Joint family [Table 13] These findings were similar to a study done by Swapnil Jain et al 26
in which the majority (47) of the study subjects lived in a three generation family
73
Discussion
II Prevalence of morbidities among the study subjects
In the present study it was found that majority of the subjects 45 had a normal BMI
followed by 30 who were overweight about 15 were obese and only10 were
underweight [Figure 14] Similar findings were reported in a study conducted by Khadervali
Nagoor et al 44 in which 49 subjects had a normal BMI In a study done by Vimala
Thomas et al 52 272 of the subjects were obese which was higher than the present study
In the present study it was found that the majority of the subjects suffered from the
disorders of the musculoskeletal system (714) eye and adnexa (497) oral cavity
(311) respiratory system (229) digestive system (198)disease of the skin
(132)ear(13)genitourinary system (66) nervous system (25) [Table14] Similar
findings were seen in a study done by Rajashree Bhat et al 55 in which most common
morbidity of elderly was the problems of loco-motor system (486) followed by vision
(427) CVS disorders (344) respiratory system (202) and disease of ear (179)In
this study though the prevalence of loco-motor system disorders (486) was highest
compared to other disorders it was lesser compared to our study (714) In a study done by
L subedhi and RB Sah 40 it was found that 44 had eye problems 43 had gastrointestinal
problems 33 had CVS problems and 23 had ENT problems In this study the prevalence
of gastrointestinal disorders was much higher compared to our study
In the present study joint pain (including the knee joint) was most common disorder of the
musculoskeletal system seen in 40 of the males compared to 384 in females [Table 15]
whereas in a study done by Swapnil Jain et al 26 it was found that 472 males and 528
females suffered from joint pains This could be attributed to the fact that in our study
majority of the study subjects were males
74
Discussion
In the present study it was found that the most common morbidity of the eye was cataract
found in 39 of the subjects It was more common in males 43 compared to females
333 [ Table 16]These findings were similar to a study done by Shraddha K et al 51 in
which the overall prevalence of cataract was 302 of which 42 males and 358
females had cataract
In the present study it was found that the most common morbidity of the oral cavity was
missing teeth found in 177 of the subjects [Table 17] it was similar to the findings of a
study conducted by JP Singh et al 48 in which 1475 subjects were edentulous
The present study revealed that the most common disorder of the endocrine system was
diabetes mellitus found in 186 of the subjects followed by the nutritional disorder of
anemia found in 134 of the subjects It was seen that anemia was more common among
females 194 compared to males 92 [Table 18] Kakkar R et al 45 reported similar
findings with prevalence of diabetes mellitus as 153 In a study done by Deepak Sharma
et al 47 anemia was present in 15 of the subjects 97 males and 21 females were
anemic which was similar to our study
In our study it was found that the most common disease of the circulatory system was
hypertension which was found in 302 of the subjects it was more common in females
394 compared to males 239 and this difference was found to be statistically significant
[Table 19] A study by L Subedhi and RB Sah 40 reported that the prevalence of
hypertension was more among females (333) compared to males (30) which was
statistically significant
75
Discussion
In our study the most common morbidity of the respiratory system was upper respiratory
tract infection (163) [Table20] it was similar to the study done by Leena Rahul
Salunke33 where it was reported to be 196
In our study the most common disorder of the digestive system was gastritis (95)
[Table 21] similar to the findings of JP Singh et al 48 (35) contrary to this L subedhi
and RB Sah 40 reported a high prevalence of gastritis (39) This difference could be
attributed to the difference in the interpretation of symptoms for the diagnosis of gastritis
In our study the most common disorder of the skin was itching (48) [ Table 22] which
was similar to the findings reported by JP Singh et al 48 in which 225 subjects suffered
from itching
In our study the most common disorder of the ear was impaired hearing (111) [Table
23] similar to a study by Vandana Nikumb et al 38 in which 106 subjects suffered from
hearing impairment
In our study it was observed that the most common morbidity affecting the
genitourinary system was increased frequency of micturition (57) [Table 24]
L subedhi and RB Sah40 found in their study that 143 subjects suffered from increased
frequency of micturition which was higher compared to our study
Our study revealed that 25 subjects suffered from the disorders of the nervous
system [Table 25] similar to a study conducted by Vandana Nikumb et al 38 in which
13 of the Subjects suffered from the disorders of the nervous system whereas in a
study conducted by Shilpa Shaukaiah et al36 it was found that 66 of the subjects
suffered from the disorders of the nervous system which was higher than our study
76
Discussion
It is observed that the disease of the eye and adnexa increased with increasing age and were
more common in individuals above 80 years of age (714) The disease of the oral cavity
were also more common in the subjects aged 80 years and above (857) and 285
subjects aged 80 years and above suffered from disease of the ear A significant association
was found between age and these morbidities [Table 26] Similar results were found in a
study done by Swapnil Jain et al 26 in which cataract hearing impairment and dental
problems were significantly associated with the age of the study subjects
In our study a significant association was found between occupation and the disorders of
the musculoskeletal system skin and the nervous system Disorders of the musculoskeletal
system were more common among employed subjects (795) compared to unemployed
(635) 176 subjects who were employed suffered from the disease of the skin and
subcutaneous tissue compared to 88 who were unemployed Diseases of the nervous
system were more common among those who were unemployed (4) compared to those
who were employed (093) [Table 27]
A study done by Kakkar R et al45 found that there was a significant association between the
employment status and the morbidities of the CVS arthritis and cataract CVS morbidity
was more common among those not working (164) compared to those working (36)
Arthritis was also more common among not working (212) compared to those working
(55) and cataract was also more common among those not working (175) compared to
those working (55)
77
Discussion
In our study it was observed that there was a significant association between religion and
disorders of the digestive system and respiratory system The disorders of the digestive
system were more common among Muslims (238) compared to Hindus (144) Also the
disorders of the respiratory system were more common among Muslims (269) compared
to Hindus (176) [Table 28] In a study conducted by Mrinal Ranjan Srivastav et al 50 it
was found that there was significant association between religion and the morbidities of the
genitourinary system in the urban areas The problems of the genitourinary system were
more common among Hindus (26) compared to Muslims (96)
III HEATLTH SEEKING BEHAVIOR OF THE STUDY SUBJECTS
In our study it was found that that (898) study subjects visited a health facility in case
of an illness whereas 102 did not visit any health facility in case of an illness[Figure 16]
Similar findings were seen in a study conducted by Vimala Thomas et al 52 where it was
found that 716 subjects visited a health facility Contrary to our findings a study
conducted by Bhawalkar JS et al46 showed that only 81 subjects visited a health facility in
case of an illness whereas 919 did not visit any health facility
In the present study it was found that the most common reason stated by study subjects
for not seeking health care in case of an illness was that it was a mild discomfort (444)
followed by lack of money stated by (267) other reasons stated were no one to
accompany (156) and lack of faith in health care (133) [Table 29] In a study
conducted by Deepak Sharma et al 47 it was found that the most common reasons for not
seeking health care were the following disease due to age (496) health services too far
(191) lack of money (6) no body to take to hospital (35)
78
Discussion
It was observed that out of 395 subjects who visited health care facility in case of an illness
58 Visited government hospitals 362 visited private practitioners hospitals and 15
visited quacks [Table 30] similar results were found in a study conducted by Deepak Sharma
et al 47 in which 607 went to Government hospitals 267 consulted private practitioners
and 126 took over the counter drugs In another study conducted by Rajat Das Gupta et al
27 it was found that 33 visited Government hospitals 25 visited private hospitals 6
visited private practitioners
It was observed that more number of males (927) visited a health care facility in case of
an illness whereas only 856 females visited a health facility in case of an illness [Table
31] In a study done by Man Mohan Gupta et al 35 it was found that 672 females and
651 males visited a health facility in case of illness
In the present study it was found that 848 of the study subjects who were illiterate
visited a health facility in case of an illness whereas 152 did not visit a health facility in
case of an illness A significant association was found between educational status and
gender [Table 32] In a study done by Deepak Sharma et al 47 it was found that Gender
literacy income and marital status were not found to be significantly related to health-
seeking behaviour
In the present study it was found that 524 subjects visited a health facility every month
followed by 251 who visited a health facility once in 3 months 20once in 6 months
and 25 visited a health facility once in a year[ Table 33] In a study conducted by Rajat
Das Gupta et al 27 it was found that majority of the subjects (2943) visited a health
facility once a year followed by 2813 who visited a health facility once in three months
79
Conclusion
CONCLUSION
The study revealed that some of the common morbidities among the geriatric subjects were
the disorders of the musculoskeletal system followed by the disease of the eye and adnexa
oral cavity endocrine nutritional and metabolic disorders etc some disorders like cataract
dental caries constipation and increased frequency of micturition were more common
among males whereas disease like anemia and hypertension were more common among
females A significant association was found between some of the morbidities and socio
demographic determinants like age occupation and religion
Any degree of formal schooling was found to be associated with better health seeking
behavior Majority of the subjects visited a Government health facility in case of an illness
and the main reason that was stated for not visiting a health facility was that they suffered
from mild discomfort and did not consider it necessary to visit a health facility
80
Summary
SUMMARY
Our study was done in the urban field practice area of JJM Medical College Davangere
among 440 geriatric subjects our study aimed at assessing the morbidity pattern and health
seeking behaviour of the geriatric population in the study area
The results of our study are as follows
ISocio-demographic characteristics of the study subjects
In the present study 368 subjects were in the age group of 60-64 Years
59 of the subjects were males and 41 were females
573 subjects were Muslims whereas 427 were Hindus
Majority of the subjects were illiterate (525) whereas 275 had completed
education up to primary school
It was found that the majority of the study subjects (511) were unemployed
49 subjects belonged to Class IV Socioeconomic status according to Modified BG
Prasad Classification
734 of the subjects were married
42 of the people lived in a three generation family
II Prevalence of morbidities among the study subjects
Majority of the subjects (45) had a normal BMI followed 30who were
overweight
Majority 714 subjects suffered from the disorders of the musculoskeletal system
followed by 497 who suffered from the disease of the eye and adnexa35
suffered from the disease of the oral cavity 329 suffered from endocrine
nutritional and metabolic disorders and 311 suffered from the disease of the
circulatory system 229 suffered from the disease of the respiratory system198
81
Summary
suffered from the disease of the digestive system132 suffered from disease of the
skin13 suffered from the disease of the ear66 suffered from the disease of the
genitourinary system and 25 suffered from the disease of the nervous system
The most common morbidity of musculoskeletal system was pain of the joints (other
than the knee joint) found in 198 of the subjectsBack ache was more common in
females 231 compared to males 163 and this difference was found to be
statistically significant
cataract found in 39 of the subjects It was more common in males 43 compared
to females 333 and this difference was found to be statistically significant
Missing teeth were found in 177 of the subjects Dental caries were more
common in males 108 compared to females 44 and this difference was found to
be statistically significant
Diabetes mellitus found in 186 of the subjects followed by the nutritional disorder
of anemia found in 134 of the subjects anemia was more common among females
194 compared to males 92 This difference was found to be statistically
significant
Hypertension which was found in 302 of the subjects it was more common in
females 394 compared to males 239 and this difference was found to be
statistically significant
upper respiratory tract infection) found in 163 subjects followed by acute
bronchitis in 43 bronchial asthma in 14 and pulmonary TB in only 09
Gastritis was found in 95 subjects followed by constipation in 61 Among
males (81) had constipation compared to females(03)
Most common disease of the skin was itching which was present in 48 of the
study subjects followed by dryness in 43
82
Summary
Hearing impairment was found in 111 of the subjects
Increased frequency of micturition was found in 57 of the subjects followed by
burning micturition in 09 of the study subjects Increased frequency of
micturition was more among males 77 compared to females in whom it was 28
and this difference was found to be statistically significant
The most common disorder of the nervous system was neuritis seen in 11 of the
subjects followed by memory loss in 09 and stroke in 05 of the subjects
A significant association was found between increasing age and the morbidities of
the eye ear and the oral cavity
Significant association was found between occupation and the disorders of the
musculoskeletal system skin and the nervous system Disorders of the
musculoskeletal system were more common among employed subjects (795)
compared to unemployed (635) 176 subjects who were employed suffered
from the disease of the skin and subcutaneous tissue compared to 88 who were
unemployed Diseases of the nervous system were more common among those who
were unemployed (4) compared to those who were employed (093)
It was observed that the disorders of the digestive system were more common
among Muslims (238) compared to Hindus (144) this difference was found to
be statistically significant Also the disorders of the respiratory system were more
common among Muslims (269) compared to Hindus (176) This difference
was also found to be statistically significant
83
Summary
III HEATLTH SEEKING BEHAVIOR OF THE STUDY SUBJECTS
In our study 898 subjects visited a health facility in case of an illness whereas
102 did not
The most common reason stated by study subjects for not seeking health care in case
of an illness was that it was a mild discomfort (444) followed by lack of money
stated by (267) the other reasons stated were no one to accompany (156) and
lack of faith in health care (133)
It was observed that 58 subjects Visited Government hospitals 362 visited
private practitioners hospitals and 15 visited quacks
Majority of males (927) visited a health care facility in case of an illness whereas
only 856 females visited a health facility in case of an illness This difference was
found to be statistically significant
A significant association was found between the educational status and health
seeking behaviour Majority of the educated subjects visited a health facility in case
of an illness compared to those who were illiterate
It was found that 524 subjects visited a health facility every month followed by
251 who visited a health facility once in 3 months 20once in 6 months and
25 visited a health facility once in a year
84
Limitations
LIMITATIONS
1 Many of the responses were subjective and there were no records to verify them
2 Some of the morbidities were diagnosed only by clinical examination and could not be
confirmed by performing diagnostic tests due to high cost and time constraints
3 This study was done in the urban field practice area which consisted of a closed
community hence the results cannot be generalized to the entire population of the area
85
Recommendations
RECOMMENDATIONS
1 Health education should be given to the geriatric people regarding the common health
problems associated with ageing and preventive care should be provided to the elderly
2 Geriatric clinics should be set up at the primary health care level which provide regular
screening and health check-ups
3 There should also be a provision to provide domiciliary care by specialists qualified in
geriatrics
4 The family members and the care givers of the elderly should be educated about the
common health problems of the elderly and also about the need for regular health check-ups
and emotional support
5 The majority of the geriatric population is out of work force they are suffering from
many morbidities and are totally dependent on others even for their health needs Hence the
Government should increase the pension of the elderly and provide them quality healthcare
free of cost
6 There is also a need for public private partnership to improve the quality of health
services for the geriatric people More number of NGOs should work towards improving the
health and the quality of life of the elderly
86
References
REFERENCES
1 United Nations Department of Economic and Social affairs Population Division
World population ageing 2013 Available from URL
wwwunorgendevelopmentpopulationageingWorldPopulationAgeing2013
[Accessed on 17-7-2016]
2 Khan S and Itrat M Current Issues in Geriatric Health Care in India-A Review J Community Med Health Care 2016 1(1) 1-3
3 United Nations Department of Economic and Social Affairs Population Division
World Population Ageing 2015 ndash Highlights Available from URL
wwwunorgendevelopmentdesapopulationpdfageingWPA2015_Reportpdf
[Accessed on 272017]
4 State of elderly in India 2014 Help age India Available from URL
httpswwwhelpageindiaorgimagespdfstate-elderly-india-2014pdf [Accessed on
1082017]
5 World Health Organization World report on ageing and health 2015Available
from URL wwwwhointageingeventsworld-report-2015-launchen [Accessed on
1272017]
6 National policy for Senior citizens March 2011Ministry of Social Justice and
welfare Govt of India Available from URL
socialjusticenicinwritereaddataUploadFilednpscpdf [Accessed on 482017]
87
References
7 Elderly in India Profile and programmes 2016Govt of India Ministry of statistics
and programme implementation Central Statistics Office Available from URL
wwwmopsigovin [ Accessed on 1442017]
8 Saxena V Kandpal SD Gael D Bansal S Health status of elderly community
based study Indian Journal of Community Health2012 Oct-Dec24(4)269-74
9 Shah T Patel M Shah V Health care seeking behaviour of urban and rural
community in Ahmedabad district Int J Med Sci Public Health20132908-11
10 Sahoo H Mishra NR Health Status Morbidity Pattern and Treatment Seeking
Behaviour among Elderly in India Evidence from 60th round of National Sample
Survey Data Learning community 2011 Dec 2(3) 341-55
11 Park K Parkrsquos Textbook of Preventive and social medicine 24 th ed Jabalpur MS
Banarsidas Bhanot Publishers2017631
12 UNFPA- state of World Population 2011Chapter 1 setting the scene 19-31
Available from URL httpswwwunfpaorgsitesdefaultfilesresource-
pdfUNFPA-Report-Chapter1pd [Accessed on 1082017]
13 Lal S Adarsh Pankaj Textbook of community Medicine 4th ed CBS publishers and
distributors PvtLtd2011732
14 Census of India 2001 Registrar General And Census Commissioner India
Available from URL httpwwwcensusindiagovinCensus[Accessed on
7102015]
15 SRS bulletin October 2012 Registar General of India New Delhi Available from
URL censusindiagovinvital_statisticsSRS_BulletinsSRS_Bulletin-
October_2012[Acessed on 7102015]
88
References
16 Bagchi K Healthy ageing Health and Population-Perspectives and Issues 2000
23(1)11-16
17 Salagre SB The Association of Physicians of India Chapter 177 Health Issues in
Geriatrics Available from URL
wwwapiindiaorgmedicine_update_2013chap177pd [ Accessed on 282017]
18 Ingle GK Nath A Geriatric Health in India Concerns and Solutions Indian Journal
of Community Medicine 2008 33(4)214-18
19 World Health Organization Active Ageing a policy framework 2002 Available
from httpwhqlibdocwhointhq2002who_nmh_nph_028pdf [Accessed on
1062017]
20 Inche Zainal Abidin S Sutan R Shamsuddin K Prevalence and determinants of
appropriate health seeking behaviour among known diabetics Results from a
community-based survey Advances in Epidemiology 2014 Nov 20141-6
21 Begashaw B Tessema F Gesesew HA Health Care Seeking behavior in Southwest
Ethiopia Plos one 2016 Sep 11(9)e0161014
22 MacKian S Health systems development Manchester University of Manchester
2003 A review of health seeking behavior problems and prospects
23 Metta EO Health-seeking behaviour among adults in the context of the
epidemiological transition in Southeastern Tanzania A focus on malaria and
diabetes [Groningen] University of Groningen 2016 228 Available from URL
httpswwwrugnlresearchportalfiles28737720Chapter_7pdf [Accessed on
1272017]
24 Adhikari D Rijal D Factors affecting health seeking behaviour of senior citizens of
Dharan Journal of Nobel Medical College 2015 Sep 4(1)57-63
25 Polisetty S Seepana M Morbidity profile of elderly individuals in urban
Visakhapatnam Int J Community Med Public Health 2017 4(2)2558-63
89
References
26 Jain S Kaware AC Doibale MK Shaikh S Radhey BK Mathurkar MP Morbidity
pattern among geriatric population in urban field practice area of district of
Maharashtra a cross sectional study Int J Community Med Public Health 2016
3(2)523-29
27 Gupta RD Loha A Roy S Morbidity pattern and health-seeking behaviour among
the senior citizens in a selected urban area of Bangladesh A cross-sectional study
South East Asia Journal of Public Health 2016 Jul 5(2)43-49
28 Naushad MA Verma N Bhawnani D Jain M Anand T Umate LV Morbidity
pattern and health seeking behaviour in elderly population of Raipur City
Chhattisgarh India Indian Journal of Community Health2016 Sep 28(3)236-41
29 Goswami S Sahai M A Study of Morbidity Pattern in Elderly Population European
Researcher Series A 2016103(2)119-28
30 Bardhan H Dixit AM Agarwal R Jain PK Gupta S Shukla SK Morbidity profile
of elderly population in Ghaziabad district a cross-sectional study Int J Med Sci
Public Health 2016 5(6)1098-1102
31 Maroof M Ahmad A Khalique N Ansari MA Health problems among the aged A
community based study from urban Aligarh Uttar Pradesh India Int J Community
Med Public Health 2016 Feb 3(4)944-47
32 Shankar G Sidenur B A morbidity study of elderly residing in urban field practice
area of SN medical college Bagalkot National Journal of research in community
medicine 2016 Oct-Dec 4(5) 229-34
90
References
33 Salunkhe LR Socio-demographic profile of old age people living in urban amp urban
slum areas in Maharashtra Karad A comparative study J of Evidence based Med
and Hlthcare 2015 Feb 2(5) 513-21
34 Warbhe P Rupesh W Morbidity profile health seeking behaviour and home
environment survey for adaptive measures in geriatric population-Urban community
study International Journal of Medical Research amp Health Sciences 2015 4(4)778-
82
35 Gupta M Borle AL Chhari N Gupta S Assessment of clinico-socioeconomic
status and health-care support among the elderly people aged older than 60 years in
urban population of Bhopal Central India Int J Med Sci Public Health 2015
4558-64
36 Sahukaiah S Shenoy A Vijayakumar BC An epidemiological study of prevalence
of morbidity patterns among geriatric age group in an urban slum of Mumbai Int J
Med Sci Public Health 2015 Jul 4(7)883-87
37 Shubha Davalagi B Angadi N Mahabalaraju DK Morbidity psycho-social profile
and health seeking behaviour of the elderly population in urban slums of Davangere
City India Int J Res Med Sci 2015 Nov 3(11)3288-91
38 Nikumb V Patankar F Behera A A Study of Morbidity Profile among Geriatric
Population in an Urban Area Sch J App Med Sci 2015 3(3)1365-69
91
References
39 Vishnoi BR Solanki SL Singhal G Meharda B Mishra N Morbidity profile of
elderly in urban slum of Udaipur Rajasthan Int J Oral Health Med Res 2015 May
2(1)9-12
40 Subedi L Sah RB Study of the health status of geriatric age group in Chitwan
district of Nepal Journal of Chitwan Medical College 2015 Mar 5(1)11-17
41 Noor S Krishnababu G Prasad KV Health status of Geriatric population in slums
of Rourkela Young Innovative Journal of Medical and Health Science 2015 May
5(3) 92-94
42 Sarode VM Chronic Diseases Related to Aging and Disease Prevention in Slums in
Mumbai Journal of Aging Science 2014 Jan 2 (1)1-6
43 Barman SK Lata K Ram R Ghosh N Sarker G Shahnawaz K A study of
morbidity profile of geriatric population in an urban community of Kishanganj
Bihar India Global Journal of Medicine and Public Health GJMEDPH 2014 3(1)
1-7
44 Nagoor K Srikanth BA Dudekula R Satna K Comparative study of health status
among slum and non-slum elderly population in Kadapa Region South India
Journal of Evolution of Medical and Dental Sciences 2014 Feb 3(5)1298-308
45 Kakkar R Aggarwal P Kandpal SD Bansal SK An Epidemiological study to assess
morbidity profile among geriatric population in District Dehradun Indian Journal of
Community Health 2013 May 25(1)39-44
46 Bhawalkar JS Dhone AB Jethani S Singru S Jadhav SL Adyanthaya S A study of
morbidity profile among geriatric population in an urban area J Evol Med Dent Sci
2013 Sep 9 36(2)6963-7
92
References
47 Sharma D Mazta SR Parashar A Morbidity pattern and health-seeking behaviour of
aged population residing in Shimla hills of north India A cross-sectional study
Journal of family medicine and primary care 2013 Apr2(2)188
48 Singh JP Singh S Kasturwar NB Hassan A Geriatric morbidity profile in an urban
slum Central India Indian Journal of Community Health 2013 Aug 25(2)164-70
49 Thakur RP Banerjee A Nikumb VB Health Problems among the Elderly A Cross
Sectional Study Annals of medical and health sciences research 2013 3(1)19-25
50 Mrinal RS Beena S Pratibha G Pankaj B Srivastava JP Atul B Morbidity Status
and Its Social Determinants among Elderly Population of Lucknow District India
Sch J App Med Sci 2013 1(6)758-64
51 Shraddha K Prashantha B Prakash B Study on morbidity pattern among elderly in
urban population of Mysore Karnataka India International Journal of Medicine and
Biomedical Research 2012 1(3)215-23
52 Thomas V Lavanya KM Morbidity profile and health seeking behaviour of the
elderly in urban slums of Hyderabad Andhra Pradesh India- A cross sectional study
International Journal of Current Research and Review 2012 Oct 1 4(19)174-80
53 Moe S Tha K Naing DK Htike MM Health seeking behaviour of elderly in
Myanmar International Journal of Collaborative Research on Internal Medicine and
Public Health 2012 4(8)1538-44
93
References
54 Bharati DR Pal R Rekha R Yamuna TV Kar S Radjou AN Ageing in
Puducherry South India An overview of morbidity profile Journal of pharmacy amp
bio allied sciences 2011 Oct 3(4)537
55 Bhatt R Gadhvi MS Sonaliya KN Solanki A Nayak H An epidemiological study
of the morbidity pattern among the elderly population in Ahmedabad Gujarat
National Journal of community medicine 2011 Jul 2(2)233-36
56 Srinivasan Krishnamachari Vaz Mario Thomas Tinku Prevalence of health related
disability among community dwelling urban elderly from middle socioeconomic
strata in Bangaluru India Indian Journal of Medical Research 2010 Apr 131(4)
515-21
57 Srivastava K Gupta SC Kaushal SK Chaturvedi M Morbidity profile of elderly a
cross sectional study of urban Agra Indian Journal of Community Health 2010 Jun
22(1)51-55
58 Ladha A Khan R Malik A Khan S Khan B Khan I et al The health seeking
behaviour of elderly population in a poor-urban community of Karachi Pakistan
Journal of the Pakistan Medical Association2009 Feb 59(2) 89-92
59 WHO ICD-10 version 2010 Geneva World Health Organization Available from
URL appswhointclassificationsicd10browse2010en [Accessed on 772017]
60 OpenEpi22OpenEpi (free) download Windows version Available from URL
enfreedownloadmanagerorgWindows-PCOpenEpi-FREEhtml
61 Tandon R Sinhota Parsonrsquos disease of the eye 22edNew Delhi Elsevier 98-100
62 Dhingra P L Dhingra S Disease of ear nose and throat and head and neck surgery
6th ed New Delhi Elsevier 201422
94
References
63 Aziz N Kallur SD Nirmalan PK Implications of the revised consensus body mass
indices for Asian Indians on clinical obstetric practice Journal of clinical and
diagnostic research 2014 May 8(5)OC01
64 Chobanion AV Bakris GL Black HR The seventh report of the joint national
committee on prevention detection evaluation and treatment of high blood pressure
the JNC 7 report JAMA 2003 2892560-72
65 The Seventh Report of the Joint National Committee on Prevention Detection
Evaluation and Treatment of High Blood Pressure (JNC 7) The GuidelinesUS
Department of Health and Human Services National Heart Lung and Blood
Institute Available at URL
httpswwwnhlbinihgovfilesdocsguidelinesjnc7fullpdf [ Accessed on
1282017]
66 Firkin F Chestman C Penington D Rush B De Gruchyrsquos clinical Hematology in
medical practice 5th edition New Delhi Blackwell science Ltd1989 32-47
67 Report of WHO consultation Nutritional Anaemias Geneva Switzerland World
Health Organization TRS-405 1968 Available from URL
whqlibdocwhointtrsWHO_TRS_405pdf [Accessed on 1282017]
68 National Family Health survey (NFHS-4) 2015-16 India Mumbai IIPS
2016Available from URL httpwwwnfhsindiaorg [Accessed on 4072017]
69 The Minimum Wages Act 1948 Ministry of Labour and Employment Government
of India Available from URL httplabourgovincontentinnerpagewagesphp
[Accessed on 1082017]
70 Khairnar M Wadgave U Shimpi P Updated BG Prasad socioeconomic
classification for 2016 Journal of Indian Association of Public Health Dentistry
2016 Oct 1 14(4)469
95
References
71 Tiwari P Tiwari S Mastering practicals community medicine 1st ed New Delhi
India Wolters Kluwer PvtLtd2013161-67
72 Boralingaiah P Bettappa P Kashyap S Prevalence of Psycho-Social Problems
among Elderly in Urban Population of Mysore City Karnataka India Indian journal
of psychological medicine 2012 Oct 34(4)360
96
PATIENT CONSENT FORM JJM MEDICAL COLLEGE DAVANGERE
DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY MEDICINE I the undersigned hereby give my consent
for investigations carried upon me I am satisfied with the information given about this
Clinical study titled ldquoA STUDY ON THE MORBIDITY PATTERN AND HEALTH
SEEKING BEHAVIOR AMONG THE GERIATRIC POULATION IN THE
URBAN FIELD PRACTICE AREA OF JJM MEDICAL COLLEGE
DAVANGERErdquo ldquoconducted by Dr RUCHI DHAR under the guidance of Dr VIDYA
GS Associate Professor I have been informed and explained the risks involved and I
hereby voluntarily and Unconditionally give my consent without any fear or pressure in
mentally sound and conscious state to participate in this study
DATE PATIENTrsquoS SIGNATURE
eEacuteeEacuteJA ordfEacuteEcirczAgravearingQAtildeAiAgraveAuml ordfAgraveAumlordmAacutelaquozAacutearingregAiAgraveAuml zAacuteordfAgravetUEacutegEacute
ryenAacutemiumlethordfEacuteAumlAmiumlDyensiumlPAgraveordfAgraveAumlAumlaringcurrenn ordfEacuteAumlrsup1poundiuml
ordfEacuteEcirczAgravearingQAtildeAiAgraveAumlvAgraveyenAacutecedilAgraveuEacuteUEacuteMbrvbaragraveUEacute yenAgravevAgraveaelig F PEacutefrac14AgraveUEacute cedilAgraveraquo ordfAgraveiAacutergAgraveAumlordfAgrave poundAacutepoundAgraveAuml CAzAgravegEacute
poundAgravepoundAgraveszlig
ordfEacuteEcirczAgravearingQAtildeAiAgraveAumlvAgraveyenAacutecedilAgraveuEacute ordmAacuteUAgraveAElig plusmnAgravecedilAgraveUcircccedilaQvEacuteigraveUEacuteAzAgraveAuml poundAgravepoundAgraveszligMbrvbaragraveUEacuteAiAgraveAumlpoundAgraveAumlszlig
cedilAgraveAEligasup1gAgraveAumlvEacuteUcircAtildepoundEacute J cedilAgraveOumlr Dyensiuml zAgrave ordfEacuteAEligcopyethrn yenAacutearinglpoundiumleth CAqiuml ordmEacutemacriumlUcirc sup1AtildeQAUiuml copyordmEacuteAtildelaquoAiAgraveAumlgiuml Dyensiuml zAgrave fjAiAgraveiAacutenaeligPiuml yenEacuteAEligAtildeyenAgraveAumlaringmacrEacuteAtildemicroAgravepoundiuml Epoundiuml zAgrave Csectethpoundiuml brvbarAtildemacriumlOslash yenAacuteaeligoumlaringQOumlAtildecediliuml JjAiAgraveAuml Dyensiuml ddordfAgraveAumlAuml ordfEacuteEcirczAgravearingQAtildeAiAgraveAuml ordfAgraveAumlordmAacutelaquozAacutearingregAiAgraveAuml zAacuteordfAgravetUEacutegEacute JAsect sup2AtildeparaethPEacuteAiAgraveAumlrAiAgraveAumldegegrave yenAgravejAtildePEacuteeumlUEacute Mfrac14AgraveyenAgravercedilAgraveAumlordfAgrave ordfEacuteEcirczAgravearinggAacutezAgrave qAacute|| gAgraveAumla zAgravesAgravegAgrave ordfAgraveAumlvAgraveAumlUcirc qAacute|| laquozAacutearing fJcediliumlordfAgraveiAacuteUAgraveethzAgraveplusmnAgraveethPAgravegAacutezAgrave yenEacuteAEligaeligAtildeyensEacutecedilAgravegiuml
EordfAgravegAgraveAuml poundAgravepoundAgraveUEacute F vAgraveyenAacutecedilAgraveuEacuteUEacute Mfrac14AgraveyenAgraveqAgraveAumlordfAgrave ordfAgraveAumlAumlpoundAgraveszlig yenAgraveaeligwAiEacuteAEligAzAgraveAuml
CAplusmnAgraveUAgravefrac14AgravepoundAgraveAumlszlig CxAgraveethordfAacuteUAgraveAumlordfAgraveAvEacute wfrac12sup1gAgraveAumlvAacuteUcircgEacuteDzAgraveYacutejAzAgrave poundAacutepoundAgraveAuml poundAgravepoundAgraveszlig
ordfAgraveAumlpoundAgravecedilAacutegEacute AiAgraveiAacuteordfAgraveAringzEacuteAtilde umlsAgraveAiAgraveAuml ordfAgraveAumlvAgraveAumlUcirc AiAgraveiAacutegAgrave MvAacuteUcircAiAgraveAumllaquoregegravezEacute poundAacutepoundAgraveAuml
vAgraveyenAacutecedilAgraveuEacute aQvEacuteigraveUEacuteAEligfrac14AgraveyenAgraveqAgraveregAuml MbrvbaragraveUEacuteAiAgraveAumlpoundAgraveAumlszlig cedilAgraveAEligasup1gAgraveAumlvEacuteUcircAtildepoundEacute
centpoundAacuteAPAgrave gEacuteAEligAtildeVAi
Annexures
ANNEXURE ndashIII
104
Annexures
PROFORMA
I General information
1 NAME
2 AGE
3 GENDER (a) Male (b) Female
4 MARITAL STATUS (a) Unmarried (b) Married (c) Widow Widower
(d) Divorced separated
5 LIVING ARRANGEMENT (a) with spouse (b) Spouse and children
(c) Children only (d) living alone (e) others
6 RELIGION (a) Hindu (b) Muslim (c) Christian (d) Others
7 ADDRESS
8 EDUCATION (a) illiterate (b) Primary school (c) higher primary
(d) secondary school (e)PUC diploma (e) Graduate (f) Postgraduate
9 OCCUPATION (a) professional (b) semi- professional (c) skilled worker
(d) Semi ndashskilled worker (e) unskilled worker (f) unemployed
10 CONTACT NUMBER
11 TYPE OF FAMILY (a) Joint (b) Nuclear (C) three generation
12 TOTAL NUMBER OF FAMILY MEMBERS
13 TOTAL FAMILY INCOME
14 PER CAPITA FAMILY INCOME
15 SOCIO ECONOMIC STATUS (Modified BG Prasad classification) I IIIIIIVV
16 DIET (a) Vegetarian (b) Mixed
17 Sleep (a) Disturbed if yes reason ______________ (b) Not disturbed
18 Bowel Regular Irregular
19 Bladder Regular Irregular
97
Annexures
20 HABITS (a) betel nut (b) tobacco (c) alcohol (d) smoking (e) others
If any of the habits present Duration (since when) _________
Frequency of consumption day_______
IIAssessment of morbidity based on history
1 Whether suffering from any chronic illness like (a) Type 2 DM (b) Hypertension
(c) Bronchial Asthma (d) TB (e) others
2 Whether suffering from cataract currently (a) Yes (b) No
3 Whether operated for cataract (a) Yes (b) No If Yes duration since operation____
4 MUSCULOSKELETAL SYSTEM
Whether the following symptoms are present
(a) Backache (b) Joint pain (c) restricted joint movements (d) pain in calves
(e) Others_________
5 RESPIRATORY SYSTEM
(a) Productive cough (b) non-productive cough (c) nasal discharge (d) breathlessness (e)
sore throat (f) sneezing
6 CARDIOVASCULAR SYSTEM
(a) Palpitations (b) chest pain (c) breathlessness
7 GASTROINTESTINAL SYSTEM
(a) Pain abdomen (b) lose stools (c) constipation (d) flatulence (e) heart burn
(f) Bleeding per rectum
8 EYE AND ADNEXA
(a) Watering (b) diminution of vision (c) redness
9 EAR
(a) Discharge (b) decreased hearing (c) Tinnitus
10 SKIN
(a) Itching (b) skin eruptions (c) scaling (d) pigmentation
98
Annexures
11 GENITO URINARY SYSTEM
(a) Burning micturition (b) increased frequency of micturition
12 GENERAL SYMPTOMS
(a) Fatigue (b) headache (c) fever
13 ANY OTHER COMPLAINTS (a) burning feet (b) swelling in groin
(c) Memory loss (d) insomnia
III Assessment of health seeking behaviour
1 Do you visit a health facility in case of illness (a) Yes (b) No
If yes how much time do you take to visit a health facility an case of an illness
(a) Within 24 hours (b) 24-48 hours (c) more than 48 hours
2 Which type of health facility do you visit
(a) Govt hospital (b) Private practitioners (c) over the counter drugs (e) quacks
Mention the reason for visiting the particular health facility______________________
3 Whether taking regular treatment after diagnosis ________________
If No mention the reason_______________________
4 Whether following the instructions given by the treating doctor
(a) Yes (b) no
5 cost of treatment per month in case of chronic disease
(a) lt100 (b) 100-200 (c) 200-300 (d) 300 and above
6 Person bearing the cost of treatment
(a) Self (b) spouse (c) son (d) daughter (d) outside help
7 Duration to reach the health facility
(a) less than 3o minutes (b) 30 minutes or more
8 Whether going for regular check -ups (a) Yes (b) No
If Yes duration between the check-ups_______
99
Annexures
9 Whether following self- care practices in case of chronic disease like diabetes and hypertension
(a) Yes (b) No
10 In case of healthy individuals whether getting screening tests done (a) Yes (b) No
11 Whether following any dietary modifications (a) yes (b) No
12 Whether any family member accompanies you to the health facility
If yes who (a) Son (b) daughter (c) spouse (d) others
11 Whether the family supports in following specific diet advised by the doctor
(a) Yes (b) No
12 whether family members help in reminding to take regular medication
(a) Yes (b) No
IV Physical examination
1 Personal hygiene status
S NO COMPONENT CONDITION REMARKS
1 Hair
2 Teeth
3 Bath
4 Clothes
5 Washing hand before
eating food
6 Washing hands with soap
and water after ablution
7 Nails
8 Foot wear
Remarks personal hygiene status Good fair poor
100
Annexures
2 MEASUREMENTS
(a) Weight (in Kg) ______ (b) Height (in cm) _____ (c) BMI ______
(d) Waist circumference______ (e) Hip circumference ___________
(f) Waist hip ratio_________
3 GENERAL PHYSICAL EXAMINATION
Pallor Icterus Cyanosis clubbing lymphadenopathy Oedema
Pulse rate Temp Blood Pressure
Respiratory rate
20 Examination of
Eye Oral cavity Ear
Nose Throat
SYSTEMIC EXAMINATION
Cardiovascular system Respiratory system
Per abdomen Central Nervous system
101
MASTER CHART
Annexures
ANNEXURES
International Classification of Diseases (10th Revision)
I Certain infectious and parasitic diseases (A00-B99)
II Neoplasms (C00-D48)
III Diseases of blood and blood forming organs and certain disorders
involving the immune mechanisms (D50-D89)
IV Endocrine nutritional and metabolic diseases (E00-E90)
V Mental and behavioural disorders (F00-F99)
VI Diseases of the nervous system (G00-G99)
VII Diseases of the eye and adnexa (H00-H59)
VIII Diseases of the ear and mastoid process ( H60-H95)
IX Diseases of the circulatory system (I00-I99)
X Diseases of the respiratory system ( J00-J99)
XI Diseases of the digestive system (K00-K93)
XII Diseases of the skin and subcutaneous tissue ( L00-L99)
XIII Diseases of the musculoskeletal system and connective tissue
(M00-M99)
XIV Diseases of the genitourinary system ( N00-N99)
XV Pregnancy childbirth and purperium (O00-O99)
XVI Certain conditions originating in perinatal period (P00-P96)
XVII Congenital malformations deformations and chromosomal
XVIII (S00-T98)
XIX External causes of morbidity and mortality (V01-Y98)
102
Annexures
XX Injury poisoning and certain other consequences of external causes
(S00-T98)
XXI Factors influencing health status and contact with health services
(Z00-Z99)
XXII Codes for special purpose
103
Annexures
105
Annexures
106
Annexures
107
Annexures
PHOTOS
Picture 1 Showing the investigator interviewing the study subject
Picture 2 Showing the investigator interacting with the study subject
108
Annexures
Picture 3 Showing the investigator recording the Blood pressure of the study subject
Picture 4 Showing the investigator auscultating the study subject
109
Annexures
110
LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS USED (in alphabetical order)
APD - Acid Peptic Disease
AYUSH- Ayurveda Yoga Unani Siddha and Homeopathy
BMI - Body Mass Index
CAD - Coronary Artery Disease
CVD - Cardiovascular Diseases
ENT - Ear Nose Throat
GIT - Gastrointestinal Tract
HBM- Health Belief Model
HSB- Health Seeking Behviour
ICD - International Classification of Diseases
ICMR- Indian Council of Medical Research
MI - Myocardial Infarction
NCOP- National Council for Older Persons
viii
NCD- Non Communicable Disease
NCsrC- National Council for Senior Citizens
NGO - Non -Governmental Organization
NPOP- National Policy for Older Persons
RMP- Registered Medical Practitioner
SDGs ndash Sustainable Development Goals
SES - Socio-Economic Status
TB ndash Tuberculosis
TPB- Theory of Planned Behaviour
TRA- Theory of Reasoned Action
UN - United Nations
UHTC- Urban Health Training center
URTI- Upper Respiratory Tract Infection
WHO - World Health organization
ix
LIST OF TABLES
Table No
Title Page No
1 Percentage share of elderly population (aged 60 years and above) in
total population by sex in India
6
2 Size of elderly population (aged 60+) and their share in total
population in major states of India in 2011
7
3 List of areas covered under the UHTC of JJM Medical College
Davangere
29
4 WHO Categorization of Body Mass index (BMI) for Asians 34
5 JNC VII Classification of Blood pressure 35
6 Socio-economic status (SES)- As per modified BG Prasad
Classification
37
7 Age and sex wise distribution of the study subjects 39
8 Distribution of the study subjects based on religion 40
9 Distribution of the study subjects based on Educational status 41
10 Distribution of the study subjects based on occupation 42
11
Distribution of the study subjects based on socio-economic status
(Modified BG Prasad classification 2016)
43
12 Distribution of the study subjects based on their marital status 44
13 Distribution of the study subjects based on the type of family 45
14 Distribution of morbidity pattern of the study subjects based on ICD
10 classification of diseases
47
xiii
15
Distribution of the study subjects based on morbidity of the
Musculoskeletal system
49
16
Distribution of the study subjects based on morbidity of the eye
and adnexa
50
17 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the oral cavity 51
18
Distribution of study subjects based on endocrine nutritional and
metabolic disorders
52
19 Distribution of the study subject based on disease of the circulatory
system
53
20 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the respiratory
system
54
21
Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the digestive
system
55
22
Distribution the study subjects based on disease of the Skin and
subcutaneous tissue
56
23 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the ear 57
24
Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the
genitourinary system
58
25
Distribution of the study subjects based on diseases of the Nervous
system
59
26 Association between morbidity pattern of the study subjects and
their age group
60
xiv
27
Association between morbidity pattern of the study subjects and
their occupation
62
28
Association between morbidity pattern of the study subjects and
their religion
64
29 Reasons cited by the study subjects for not seeking healthcare in
case of an illness
67
30 Distribution of the study subjects based on the type of health facility
visited
68
31 Association between gender and health care seeking behavior of the
study subjects
69
32 Association between educational status and health care seeking
behaviour of the study subjects
70
33 Distribution of study subjects according to frequency of visits to a
health care facility
71
xv
LIST OF FIGURES
Figure No
Title Page No
1 Proportion of elderly in the Indian population by age groups
1961-2001
6
2 Pathophysiology of health issues in geriatrics 10
3 Predicting health behaviour with social cognition models 13
4 Health belief model components and linkages 15
5 Maps showing the location of Davangere district and the
area where the UHTC is located
27
6 Map showing the Urban field practice area of JJM medical college
28
7 Age and sex wise distribution of the study subjects 39
8 Distribution of the study subjects based on religion 40
9 Distribution of the study subjects based on Educational status 41
10 Distribution of study subjects based on their occupation 42
11
Distribution of study subjects based on their occupation
43
12 Distribution of the study subjects based on their marital status 44
13 Distribution of the study subjects based on the type of family 45
14 Distribution of the study subjects based on the BMI 46
15 Distribution of morbidity pattern of the study subjects based on
ICD 10 classification of diseases
48
16 Distribution of the study subjects based on the visit to health
facility in case of an illness
66
xvi
ABSTRACT Background
According to census 2011 the elderly population aged 60 years and above account for 8
of total population and is projected to rise to 124 by the year 2026 Health status is an
important factor that has a significant impact on quality of life The elderly are one of the
most vulnerable and high risk groups in terms of health status and their health seeking
behaviour is crucial in any society
Objectives
1 To study the morbidity pattern among the geriatric population in the urban field
practice area of JJM Medical college Davangere
2 To assess the health seeking behaviour of the elderly residing in the study area
Methods It was a community based cross sectional study which was conducted in the urban field
practice area of JJM Medical College Davangere The total study subjects were 440
individuals aged 60 years and above Data was collected using a predesigned pre-tested
and semi- structured questionnaire Height weight and blood pressure were measured
and recorded Data was analyzed by using MS Excel and Open-Epi Info software
version 22 Statistical test employed was chi-square and Fishers exact test x
Results and Conclusion
In our study it was found that the majority of the subjects (368) were in the age group
of 60-64 years 525 were illiterate 511 were unemployed and 49 belonged to class
IV socio economic status The study revealed that the some of the common morbidities
among the geriatric subjects were the disorders of the musculoskeletal system (714)
eye and adnexa (497) oral cavity (329) endocrine nutritional and metabolic
disorders (329)etc some disorders like cataract dental caries constipation and
increased frequency of micturition were more common among males whereas disease
like anemia and hypertension were more common among females A significant
association was found between some of the morbidities and socio demographic
determinants like age occupation and religion
Any degree of formal schooling was found to be associated with better health seeking
behavior Majority of the subjects (58) visited a Government health facility in case of
an illness and the main reason that was stated for not visiting a health facility was that
they suffered from mild discomfort (444) and did not consider it necessary to visit a
health facility
Key words Geriatric urban behaviour morbidity
xi
Introduction
INTRODUCTION
ldquoA STUDY ON THE MORBIDITY PATTERN AND HEALTH SEEKING BEHAVIOUR AMONG THE GERIATRIC POPULATION IN THE URBAN FIELD
PRACTICE AREA OF JJM MEDICAL COLLEGE DAVANGERErdquo
All countries of the world are experiencing population ageing Ageing is a result of
decreasing mortality and most importantly declining fertility The global share of older
people (aged 60 years and above) has increased from 92 per cent in 1990 to 117 in
2013 and will continue to grow as a proportion of the world population reaches 211 by
20501
The lsquoNational Policy for Older Personsrsquo was adopted by the Government of India in
January 1999 and it defines a lsquosenior citizenrsquo or lsquoelderlyrsquo as a person who is aged 60 years
or above Ageing is a progressive process associated with declines in structure and
function impaired maintenance and repair systems increased susceptibility to disease and
death2
In 2015 Worldwide there were 901 million people aged 60 years or over It is
projected that their number will grow to 14 billion in 2030 which is the target date for the
SDGs and to 21 billion by 2050 There will be growth in the number of older persons aged
60 years and above between 2015 and 2030 This increase is projected to be especially
significant global phenomenon and virtually every country in the world will experience a
substantial increase including the less developed regions3 The increased life expectancy has
led to challenges in health care management The elderly suffer from various diseases which
include non-communicable disease (NCDs) like diabetes hypertension coronary heart
disease and other disorders like osteoarthritis stroke dementia osteoporosis cancer
1
Introduction enlarged prostate depression and cataract related blindness In the coming years there will
be a phenomenal growth in the population of the elderly while the family size will reduce
The disintegration of the joint family and women moving out of the household has led to the
absence of traditional caregivers for the elderly who are already a vulnerable group4
The most common cause of health problems in the old aged people is chronic diseases
Most of these problems can be prevented or delayed by engaging in healthy behaviours
Even in the advanced years of life physical activity and good nutrition can have
effective benefits on health and well-being Many health problems of old age can be
effectively managed if they are detected early enough5 The National Policy for Older
Persons was announced by the Government of India in the year 1999 The Constitution of
India under Article 41 mandates the well-being of senior citizens ldquoThe state shall
within the limits of its economic capacity and development make effective provision
for securing the right to public assistance in case of old aged peoplerdquo 6
National Council for Older Persons (NCOP) has been reconstituted and renamed as
National Council for Senior Citizens (NCSrC) in order to have a definite structure and also
regional balancing the NCOP advises the Central and State Governments on a broad range
of issues related to welfare of senior citizens and enhancement of their quality of life The
NCSrc meets at least twice a year7 The elderly suffer from multiple medical as well as
psychological problems There has already been some pioneering work on the elderly in
India but a lot more remains to be done There is an urgent need to pay attention
towards the medical and socio-economic problems that are being faced by the elderly
people in India and thus formulate strategies to bring about an improvement in their
quality of life8 The Health seeking behaviour is influenced by various factors which
include the individual self diseases and the availability and accessibility of health
2
services It is important to have knowledge regarding the health seeking behaviour of
individuals for designing health care policies and programmes so that all the possible
difficulties with early diagnosis and effective treatment can be identified and appropriate
interventions can be implemented9 As already stated the elderly are a vulnerable group as
there are psychological as well as physiological changes with increasing age and it is
difficult to cope up with the problems of ageing Some of the most common problems in old
age are cardiovascular problems arthritis respiratory problems blood pressure and so on
Therefore the study of the health status of elderly morbid conditions perceptions about
it is important to note and the health care of the elderly becomes very important since they
are more prone to illness than young people and are also more prone to domestic and other
accidents Their health and treatment seeking behaviour are most important for the
formulation of welfare programmes of the country 10
Hence this study was taken up in the urban field practice area of JJM Medical College
Davangere to assess the morbidity pattern and health seeking behaviour of the geriatric
subjects
3
Objectives
OBJECTIVES
1 To study the morbidity pattern among the geriatric population in the urban field
practice area of JJM Medical college Davangere
2 To assess the health seeking behaviour of the elderly residing in the study area
4
Review of literature
vii
REVIEW OF LITERATURE
1 Definition Geriatrics or clinical gerontology Is the term used for the care of the aged 11 The United Nations uses 60 years and above to refer to older people the same is also used
by demographers However in many developed countries the age of 65 is used as the
reference point for older persons 12
Elderly are classified in to 3 groups 13
Young old Persons in the age group of 60 years to 74 years
Old old Persons in the age group of 75 years to 84 years
Oldest old Persons above the age of 85 yrs
2 Demography of the ageing population in India
The UN defines a country as ldquoAgeingrdquo or ldquoGreying Nationrdquo where the
proportion of people over 60 reaches 7 percent to total population By 2011 India has
exceeded that proportion (80 percent) and is expected to reach 126 percent in 2025
The Indian population has increased from 361 million in 1951 to 1027 billion in 2001
and further to 121 billion in 2011 Simultaneously the number of older people has
increased from 19 million (ie 4 percent of total population) to 77 million and
further to roughly 93 million (ie 75 percent of the total) during the same time
span 14
5
Review of literature
Figure1 proportion of elderly in the Indian population by age groups 1961-2001 14
Table 1 Percentage share of elderly population (aged 60 years and above) in total
population by sex in India 15
Years Male Female Total Rural Urban
1961 55 58 56 58 47
1971 59 60 60 62 50
1981 64 66 65 68 54
1991 67 68 68 71 57
2001 71 78 75 77 67
2011 77 84 80 81 79
2004-05 69 75 72 73 70
2007-08 73 77 75 76 72
6
Review of literature
The rise in population of males was more modest from 55 percent to 71 percent while for
females there had been a steep rise from 58 percent to 78 percent during five decadal
Censuses from 1961 to 2001 In 2011 the elderly population accounted for 80 percent of
total population For males it was marginally lower at 77 percent while for females it was
84 percent According to NSSO surveys the proportion of elderly population in rural areas
was 73 percent during 2004-05 and increased up to 76 percent in 2007-08 While on the
other hand in urban areas the proportion of elderly population rose from 70 percent to 72
percent during the corresponding period It has been observed that the percentage share of
elderly to total population remained higher in rural areas than in urban areas15
Table2 Size of elderly population (aged 60+) and their share in total population in major states of India in 201115
All India and selected major states
Proportion of elderly in total population of State
Male Female Total Andhra Pradesh 83 94 88 Bihar 72 67 70 Gujarat 76 90 83 Haryana 66 76 71 Himachal Pradesh 104 103 104 Karnataka 79 89 84 Kerala 118 133 126 Madhya Pradesh 68 74 71 Maharashtra 88 97 93 Orissa 91 95 93 Punjab 91 100 95 Rajasthan 66 79 72 Tamil Nadu 102 109 105 Uttar Pradesh 66 71 68 West Bengal 82 82 82 All India 77 84 80
7
Review of literature
3 MORBIDITY PATTERN AMONG THE ELDERLY
Physiological Decline and Consequences of increasing age
Ageing i s a process of decline in biological functions affecting most physical
Systems The following systems are affected by ageing
(a) Atrophy of the Taste Buds and Loss of Teeth
With the increasing age the taste buds of the tongue get atrophied and as a result the
preference for food alters significantly There is also a considerable loss of teeth causing
difficulties in chewing food
(b) Changes in the Gastrointestinal Tract
As the age advances the walls of the intestine get atrophied and the motility is
markedly reduced (lazy intestine) The digestive enzymes secreted by the intestine are
also reduced Hence the partly digested food stays in the intestine for a longer period
As a result the common complaint of the elderly person is gas formation (flatulence)
and constipation
(c) Respiratory System
As the age advance there is progressive fibrosis of the lungs leading to reduced
oxygenation of the lungs and breathing difficulties
(d) Kidney and genitourinary System
The kidneys get smaller in size and the power of the kidneys to filter out the unwanted
waste products from the body is diminished The total amount of urine becomes less in
old age and thus the waste products are not adequately excreted from the body
8
Review of literature
(e) Urinary Bladder
Urinary bladder gets smaller in size due to shrinkage and as a result the accumulation
of urine even of a small amount leads to an urge for urination With increase in age
the valve in the bladder which controls the exit of urine from the bladder to urethra
gets atrophied and weak Involuntary leakage of urine occurs in case the bladder is full
or due to increase of pressure on bladder on sneezing or even on laughing a condition
known as urinary incontinence Incontinence is a common complaint of elder females
(f) Heart and Circulatory System
The blood vessels get rigid and quite often the vessel walls become rough with the
deposition of solid matters consisting mostly of cholesterol The heart muscles get weaker
and power to send blood throughout the body through the circulatory system gets less and
less powerful The most dangerous effect on heart is coronary heart disease especially
coronary thrombosis
(g) Muscular system
The muscles in the body get gradually atrophied with ageing and especially those
small muscles which are necessary for quick reflex action The elderly person can quite
be capable of working like a normal person and can undertake activities which require
big muscles of legs and arms But when it comes to quick movement which needs small
muscles for quick reflex movements these functions are impaired causing accidents
like slipping on wet floor of the bathroom
(h) Brain
With ageing the size of the brain gets smaller and the weight also becomes less This
however does not interfere with the function of the brain However in general the brain
cells and its fibers which carry impulses from brain to the system and upwards get
9
Review of literature
degenerated The most glaring manifestation of ageing affecting the brain is
forgetfulness and in simple terms it is inability of brain to recall the past experience
However this is common in all elderly persons
(i ) Bones
The bones become porous and fragile as age advances especially in elderly females This
condition is known as osteoporosis and leads to sustaining of fractures even after a minor
fall16
Figure 2 pathophysiology of health issues in geriatrics17
The common disease that the geriatric population suffers from are type 2 diabetes
coronary heart disease hypertension stroke chronic obstructive pulmonary disease
10
Review of literature
Alzheimerrsquos disease osteoarthritis osteoporosis prostatic hypertrophy cataracts macular
degeneration cancer etc and at the same time they are vulnerable to infections involving
respiratory (including TB) urinary and digestive tract17
In India the elderly people suffer from dual medical problems ie communicable and
nonndash communicable diseases There is also impairment of special sensory functions like
vision and hearing A decline in immunity and age-related physiological changes leads to
an increased burden of communicable diseases in the elderly A report by Indian Council
of Medical Research (ICMR) on the chronic morbidity profile in the elderly states that
hearing impairment is the most common morbidity followed by visual impairment
However different studies show varied results in the morbidity pattern18
Major chronic conditions affecting older people worldwide 19
Cardiovascular diseases (such as coronary heart disease) Diabetes Mellitus
Hypertension Stroke Cancer
Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease
Musculoskeletal conditions (such as arthritis and osteoporosis)
Mental health conditions (mostly dementia and depression)
Blindness and visual impairment
11
Review of literature
Health seeking behaviour
1 Definition
There is no common definition agreed upon by sociologists in any sociology literature
Different definitions may be used in different studies despite referring to the same activity
Sociology and literature assume that health seeking behaviour is influenced by the various
factors which include individual self or the individual diseases present and also the
availability and accessibility of health services Being dependent on these determinants and
their interactions it can be said that health care seeking behaviour is a very complex
outcome of various factors which operate at individual family and community level20
Health Seeking Behavior (HSB) refers to decision or an action taken by an individual to
maintain attain or regain good health and to prevent illness The decisions which are
made encompasses all available health care options like visiting a public or private and
modern or traditional health facility self-medication and use of home remedies or not to
utilize the available health services etc
Determining the health care seeking behavior is very important to provide a need
based health care services to the population Visiting official channels in a formally
recognized health care system has been considered as the desired Health seeking behaviour
Health seeking behavior is influenced by multiple factors including availability quality and
price of services and also social groups health views residences and personal features of the
users Peoplersquos choice of health care differs in socio demographic socio-economic and
cultural compositions and this has an effect on their health seeking behavior Urban dwellers
are generally believed to be open to new ideas and willing to try certain things on a trial and
error basis21
12
Review of literature
Health seeking behaviours two approaches
(a) Health seeking behaviours utilization of the system
This approach focuses on the actions which are taken to rectify perceived ill health and
the type of health care facility which is utilized by the people There is data which
suggests that the people visit more traditional healers and unofficial medical channels
this should be prevented and the emphasis s h o u l d b e on encouraging people to opt
first for the official channels
(b) Health seeking behaviours the process of illness response
This approach considers the factors which enable or prevent people from making
healthy choices either i n their lifestyle behaviours or use of medical care and
treatment22
Figure 3 Predicting health behaviour with social cognition models 22
13
Review of literature
2 Health belief Model of health seeking behaviour
Since lsquoHealth seekingrsquo is a conditioned behaviour any attempt which is made to
encourage people to seek health care definitely requires an understanding of their
motivation for such behaviour Only through a deeper understanding of the intricate
factors shaping behavioural practices can health promotion programmes and or
interventions successfully be introduced into the realities of the peoplersquos lives to bring
about changes in health behaviour
Behaviour change theories and models such as the Health Belief Model (HBM)
Theory of Reasoned Action (TRA) Theory of Planned Behaviour (TPB) and the
Trans theoretical model have been widely applied in public health in an attempt to
explain or predict health seeking behaviours Their use enables identification and
understanding of peoplersquos health-seeking behaviour beyond their knowledge attitudes
and practices
HBM is a health specific behavioural cognitive model This model is based on the
idea that people are more likely to change their behaviour and adhere to treatments
if they have the following perceptions (i) have a perception that they are at risk of
contracting the disease (perceived susceptibility) (ii) perception that the disease
might have an unfavorable outcome (perceived severity) (iii) perceive that the
proposed health behaviour to be both effective and practical (perceived benefits)
(iv) perceive the barriers to adopting the behaviour to be minimal (perceived
barriers)(v) perceive themselves to have the ability of applying and practicing the
specific behaviour proposed (perceived self-efficacy) and (vi) they have the cues
for motivating their actions such as internal cues (pain symptoms past experiences)
or external cues (advice from friends relatives and mass media campaigns) (cues to
14
Review of literature
action) The specificity of the HBM to health has made it suitable for use in
understanding and explaining the behaviour as well as health outcomes and this may also
explain its wider use in public health2 3
Figure 4 Health belief model components and linkages 23
3 Factors influencing health seeking behaviour
The factors affecting the health seeking behaviours are seen in various contexts which
include physical socio-economic cultural and political factors Therefore the utilization of
a health care system whether public or private formal or non- formal may depend on socio-
demographic factors social structures level of education cultural beliefs and practices and
some other factors like gender discrimination status of women economic and political
systems environmental conditions and the disease pattern and health care system itself also
have an impact on the health seeking behaviour24
15
Review of literature
REVIEW OF RELATED STUDIES
A study done by Sanjay Polisetty and Madhavi Seepana (2017) on the morbidity profile
of elderly individuals in urban Visakhapatnam revealed that of the 270 study participants
about 996 suffered from either some form of acute or chronic morbidity More than 70
of individuals suffered from eye problems of which most common problem was cataract
seen in 60 About 304 had difficulties in chewing and 256 had difficulty in hearing
Hypertension was present in 49 of individuals and 742 of Diabetics were also found to
be hypertensive25
A study done by Swapnil Jain et al (2016) on Morbidity pattern among geriatric
population in urban field practice area of a district in Maharashtra revealed 653 suffered
from hearing impairment 62 were anemic 462 had hypertension 423 had joint
pain 41 had dental problems 38 7 had cataract and 318 had chronic bronchitis It
was seen that 81 of the subjects had multiple morbidities 26
A study done by Rajat Das Gupta et al (2016) in an urban area of Bangladesh on Morbidity
pattern and health-seeking behavior among the senior citizens revealed that of the 384 study
participants 968 were suffering from at least one medical problem The commonest was
musculoskeletal problems in 8411 followed by eye problems in 8125 It was found that
all the respondents sought treatment for their health problems 33 respondents went to
Government hospitals to seek medical help 6927 respondents took prescribed
medications and 567 were satisfied with their treatment 27
16
Review of literature
A study done by Md Alam Naushad et al (2016) on Morbidity pattern and health
seeking behavior in elderly population of Raipur City Chhattisgarh revealed that the
prevalence of morbidity among elderly was 9531 Out of total morbid population some
chronic illness was present in 7049 Gastro intestinal system was involved in 8262
followed by eye in 7983 and Cardiovascular system in 5245 It was found that 3552
of the subjects sought treatment from private registered practitioners 28
A study done by Sribas Goswami and Manjari Sahai (2016) in Raipur city on Morbidity
Pattern in elderly Population revealed that out of total study population of 640 elderly
subjects 610 (9531) suffered from some morbidity Prevalence among females was
9892 whereas among males it was 9026 Out of various agencies 3552 subjects
were utilizing private facility followed by 2785 who were utilizing Government agency
2631 visited quacks and 1030 were taking treatment from other source 29
A study done by Harsh Bardhan et al (2016) on the Morbidity profile of elderly population
in Ghaziabad district revealed that in geriatric population 5008 suffered from
musculoskeletal problems 5877 had dental problems and impairment of vision was seen
in 5561 The overall prevalence of diabetes and heart disease were 10 and 122
respectively 236 subjects reported the problem of loneliness and depression
forgetfulness was also reported by 3296 As far as treatment seeking behavior is
concerned approach of elderly is quite different for different morbidities The main source
of treatment for morbidities such as hypertension respiratory urinary GIT-related and
musculoskeletal problems was quacks 30
17
Review of literature
A study done by Mohammad Maharoof et al (2016) on the health problems among
the aged in Urban Aligarh UP revealed that of the 225 study subjects 782 had cataract
followed by depression in 356 refractive error in 276 loco-motor problem in 213
and hearing loss in 138 The prevalence of hearing loss was significantly related to gender
as it was higher among females with 181 compared to males in whom it was 6931
A study done by Gowri Shankar and Bhayalaxmi Sidenur (2016) on morbidity of
elderly residing in an urban area of Bagalkot revealed that the most common morbidity was
Cataract seen in 2875 followed by musculoskeletal problems in 2813 and 2313
were known hypertensive Both diabetes mellitus and hypertension was observed in 10 of
the study subjects32
A study done by Leena Rahul Salunkhe (2015) on socio-demographic profile of old
age people living in urban amp urban slum areas in Maharashtra Karad revealed that 504
and 42 elderly suffered from arthritis in an urban area and a slum respectively Number of
diabetics were higher in urban (14) than urban slum (35) 301 of subjects from urban
area suffered from hypertension compared to 161 from urban slums Upper Respiratory
Infections was more in slum dwellers (196) than people residing in urban area (7) Acid
peptic diseases were found in 168 study subjects in urban area and 154 in slum area 33
In a study done by Warbhe Priyanka A and Warbhe Rupesh (2015) on morbidity
profile health seeking behaviour and home environment survey of the elderly in an urban
slum community it was found that 941 had 1-3 morbidities 41 had 4-6 morbidities
373 gave a history of fall and 314 had history of fracture 136 subjects had been
18
Review of literature
operated for cataract 168 had undergone a procedure for fracture and10 had undergone
a dental procedure 542 went to Urban health center (UHC) and Government hospitals for
treatment and 786 received both allopathic and Ayurvedic treatment34
A study done by Man Mohan Gupta et al (2015) on Assessment of Clinico-
socioeconomic status and health-care support among the elderly people aged older than 60
years in urban population of Bhopal revealed that 353 subjects received treatment for
their morbidities from the Government hospitals whereas 267 from private
clinichospital About 653 study subjects presented with complaints and morbidity The
common morbidities which were found in the subjects were fatigue (487) backache
(353) Obesity (393) and hypertension (247)35
In a study done by Shilpa Shaukaiah et al (2015) on prevalence of morbidity pattern
among geriatric age group in an urban slum of Mumbai it was found that body ache was the
most commonly reported symptom by 290 followed by visual problems in 2318 joint
pain in 2181 indigestion in 2045 and backache in 2045 subjects36
A study done by Shubha Davalagi B et al (2015) on morbidity psycho-social profile and
health seeking behavior of the elderly population in urban slums of Davangere City revealed
that the most common morbidity which was present in the study subjects was
musculoskeletal problems in 46 psychosocial problems were present in 31 and
respiratory problems in 23 Majority of the elderly (56) utilized government
institutions for treatment of chronic disease and 47 for treatment of acute disease The
elderly population had financial constraints and lack of accessibility in seeking health care37
19
Review of literature
A study done by Vandana Nikumb et al ( 2015) on morbidity Profile among Geriatric
Population in an Urban Area of Navi Mumbai revealed that 9312 elderly were morbid and
with increasing age the number of morbidities was found to be increasing In this study it
was found that the most common morbidity was psychosocial problems which include
stress which was present in 594 subjects followed by musculoskeletal problems in
556 and eye problems like diminished vision mostly due to cataract in 463
Hypertension dental problems respiratory problems ENT problems (hearing impairment)
and endocrine disorders like diabetes accounted for 281 219 119 106 and10
respectively38
A study done by Vishnoi BR et al (2015) on Morbidity Profile of Elderly in Urban
Slum of Udaipur Rajasthan revealed that 61 of the study subjects had impaired vision
followed by 25 who had hypertension 1533 suffered from insomnia 1467 had
anemia and 14 suffered from gastrointestinal problems The condition of females was
worse compared to males39
In a study done by L Subedhi and RB Sah (2015) on the health status of geriatric age
group in Chitwan district of Nepal it was found that of the 300 study subjects 44 had
Ophthalmic problems 43 had GIT problems 33 had CVS problems 23 had ENT
problems 1567 had metabolic disorders and 533 had mental disorders The study
highlighted a high prevalence of morbidity and health related problems in the geriatric age
group40
20
Review of literature
A study done by Sofia Noor et al (2015) on health status of geriatric population in slums
of Rourkela revealed that the morbidities among the elderly that were found to be significant
were hypertension decreased visual acuity urinary problems and insomnia Apart from
systemic morbidities 91 of the elderly also complained of fragility which includes
complex physiological deterioration and unexplained weight loss41
In a study conducted by VM Sarode (2014) on Chronic Diseases Related to Ageing and
Disease Prevention in Slums in Mumbai it was found that there were highly significant
disorders among aged women related to Skin lesion and super infection Untreated bacterial
pharyngitis acute rheumatic fever while disorders among aged men were related to
hypertension Illicit drug use diabetes and asthma It was found that 49 of elderly males
and 45 of elderly females had not sought any treatment for their illness Of the people who
had sought treatment 93 elderly males and 92 of elderly females had taken treatment
from Government hospital42
A study conducted by Sanjeev Kumar Barman et al (2014) on morbidity profile of
geriatric population in an urban slum of Kishnganj Bihar revealed that the prevalence of
anemia cataract and hypertension were quite high 6375 6125 and 5063
respectively Loss of income amp occupation along with a feeling of neglect from the family
members were the common problems among the elderly It was also found that morbidities
like arthritis loss of teeth amp dental caries along with depression had a significant association
with sex age amp educational status of the study subjects43
21
Review of literature
A study done by Khadervali Nagoor et al (2014) on the health status of elderly
population in an urban area of Kadapa revealed that out of the 200 elderly persons studied
Visual problem due to cataract and refractive errors were present in 72 of the study
subjects followed by pain in joints in 595 gastrointestinal problems in 46 and dental
problems in 44 Other morbidities were hypertension in 42 genitourinary problems in
25 dermatological problems in 235 and psychological problems in 1644
A study done by Kakkar R et al (2013) on morbidity profile among geriatric population
in District Dehradun revealed that the working geriatric group was healthy as compared to
those who were retired Hypertension was the commonest morbidity among all age groups
In the age group of 60-70 years the following morbidities were seen hypertension (306)
followed by diabetes (153) arthritis (14) CVS morbidities (14) cataract (96) and
BPH (83) Among 71-80 years age group Hypertension (287) followed by arthritis
(167) cataract (157) Diabetes (111) BPH (111) and CVS morbidities (93)45
In a study done by Bhawalkar JS et al (2013) on morbidity profile among geriatric
population in an urban area of Pune it was found that Musculoskeletal disorder was the
most common (4331) followed by eye problems (3722) and hypertension (137)It
was seen that 43 elderly population had some health problem but only 8 visited the
health facilities Among them 6 visited private practitioners and only 18 went to
municipal hospitals It was found that only 2322 elderly were taking any medications and
the most commonly used drug was anti-inflammatory drugs 2323 followed by
antihypertensive drugs 136746
22
Review of literature
A study conducted by Deepak Sharma et al (2013) on morbidity pattern and health-
seeking behavior of aged population residing in Shimla revealed that the following
morbidities were present in the study subjects hypertension was the commonest (56)
followed by Musculoskeletal problems (535) Dental problems (27) cataract (23)
anemia (15) and acid peptic disease (175) 658 of the subjects were seeking
treatment for their health problems Majority of the older people preferred allopathic
medicine (812) followed by Ayurvedic medicines (113) and homeopathic medicine
(73) for their health problems Most of the older persons preferred going to a
CHCGovernment hospital for treatment for their illness There was considerable use of
over-the-counter drug by125 of the people 47
A study done by JP Singh et al (2013) on Geriatric morbidity profile in an urban slum of
Nagpur central India revealed that the most common morbidity identified in the study
population was anemia (9650) followed by hypertension (345) arthritis (3225)
cataract (21) and diabetes (1775) More than 2 morbidities were present in 325 of
the study subjects followed by four morbidities in 3125 and two morbidities in 23548
A study conducted by RP Thakur et al (2013) on the health problems of the elderly in
central India revealed that among the elderly residing in the urban areas 384 of the urban
elderly had both dental problems and arthritis followed by anemia in 348 hypertension in
266 cataract in 252 and diabetes mellitus in 157 The prevalence of self-reported
depression was 672 among the urban female elderly when compared to 397 among the
urban females49
23
Review of literature
A study done by Mrinal Ranjan Srivastav et al (2013) on Morbidity Status and its
Social determinants among elderly population of Lucknow revealed that the most common
morbidity among the urban population was eye problems which affected 516 males and
67 females followed by CVS problems in 363 males and 395 females and GIT
problems in 315males and 382 females50
A study done by Shraddha K et al (2012) on morbidity pattern among elderly in urban
population of Mysore revealed that out of the 526 study subjects 486 suffered from the
disease of the eye and adnexa followed by 384 who suffered from endocrine and
metabolic disorders 331 suffered from the disease of the circulatory system 323 had
disease of the oral cavity and salivary glands and 302 had disease of the musculoskeletal
system 51
A study done by Vimala Thomas et al (2012) on morbidity profile and health seeking
behaviour of the elderly in urban slums of Hyderabad revealed that hypertension was the
most common morbidity in 469 followed by Arthritis in 302 Diabetes in 265
respiratory problems in 243 and Cataract in 21 For out-patient treatment 472 visited
private sectors 303 Government facility 25 RMP and 06 AYUSH clinics For in-
patient treatment 198 visited private institutions 16 visited Government institutions
while 642 did not visit either52
24
Review of literature
A study done by Soe Moe et al (2012) on health seeking behaviour of elderly in
Myanmar revealed that 35 of the male elderly perceived that they were having good
health status whereas 229 of them perceived having a poor health status 343 of female
elderly perceived that they were having good health status while 24 of them perceived
having a poor health About 49 of the elderly went to rural health center for treatment
followed by 33 who went to private practitioners 15 visited hospitals and 3 went to
more than one place for treatment53
A study done by Dharamvir Ranjan Bharati et al (2011) in Puducherry revealed that in
the urban areas about 707 of the study subjects had anemia followed by 537 who had
visual impairment and hypertension and 532 suffered from diabetes mellitus It was seen
that On univariate analysis the risk of diabetes mellitus was significantly higher among
elderly from urban areas than that among elderly from rural areas and significantly lower
risk in elderly from below poverty line than in those belonging to normal (not below poverty
line)54
A study done by Rajashree Bhat et al (2011) on the morbidity pattern among the elderly
population in Ahmedabad revealed that most common morbidity of elderly was the
problems of loco-motor system (486) followed by vision (427) and hypertension
(344) In this study only 37 of elderly had psychosocial problems55
A study done by Krishnamachari Srinivasan et al (2010) in an urban area of Bangalore
revealed that 494 subjects had hypertension 323 had diabetes 281 had arthritis
279 suffered from Genitourinary and cardiovascular disease It was observed that about
25
Review of literature
49 of the respondents made less than three physician visits and 13 were hospitalized for
health related problems during the past one year 56
A study done by Kajal Srivastava et al (2010) on the morbidity pattern of the elderly in
urban Agra revealed that 9529 of the elderly were morbid in the slum areas The most
common morbidity which was seen among the elderly people residing in urban slums was
anemia which was seen in 3843 followed by cataract in 298 arthritis in 2431 and
hearing impairments in 2157The system wise distribution of the morbidity pattern
showed the most common systemic involvement was visual disorders 5216 followed by
musculoskeletal system 4784 and the gastrointestinal system 4314 The number of
morbidities was found to be increasing with age and this association with age was
statistically significant57
A study done by Abdullah Ladha et al (2009) on the health seeking behaviour of elderly
population in a poor-urban community of Karachi Pakistan revealed that 164 of the
elderly people were Diabetic and 301 had Hypertension The Common symptoms that
prompted elderly of to seek health care were fever (612) generalized body aches (434)
and cough (404) About 614 responders reported factors which deterred them from
seeking health care out of which 62 reported financial constraint as the commonest factor
Deterrence from seeking health care was associated with illiteracy and living alone58
26
Methodology METHODOLOGY
The study was conducted in the urban field practice area of JJM Medical college
Davangere The city of Davangere is situated in the central part of Karnataka state
265 km north of the state capital Bengaluru along the national highway number 4
Figure 5 Maps showing the location of Davangere district and the area where the
UHTC is located
27
Methodology
Figure 6 Map showing the Urban field practice area of JJM medical college
28
Methodology
Table 3 List of areas covered under the UHTC of JJM Medical
College Davangere
Areas covered Total population Bethur road 1374 Hedge nagar 1213 Mehboob nagar 3042 Mustafa nagar A 2093 B D layout A 1084 Mustafa nagar B 1127 Mahavir nagar 930 Muddabovi colony 1094 Maganhalli 1221 Tippu nagar 968 B D layout B 1717 Batti layout 1080
STUDY AREA The study was conducted in the urban field practice area of JJM
Medical College Davangere which consists of 12 areas with a total population of
16943
STUDY DESIGN Cross sectional study
STUDY POPULATION Persons aged 60 years and above
Total Population Covered 16943
29
Methodology
INCLUSION CRITERIA subjects aged 60 years and above living in the study area
for more than one year duration
EXCLUSION CRITERIA Subjects who we r e no t w i l l i ng t o pa r t i c ipa t e i n
t he s t udy
STUDY PERIOD 1 year from 1st December 2015 to 30th November 2016
SAMPLE SIZE As quoted by Manmohan Gupta et al 35 in the studies done in various
parts of India the prevalence of morbidity in the geriatric population ranges from 31-80
Considering the prevalence of morbidity to be about 50 in the geriatric population at 95
confidence level and allowable error of 10 and a non -response rate of 10 sample size
was calculated to be 440 using the formula
n=4pq L2
n= sample size
4= factor to achieve 95 level of confidence
p= prevalence of morbidities ie 50
q= 100- p ie 100-50 = 50
L= permissible error in the estimate of ldquoprdquo (10 of p)
n = 4 x 50 x 50 = 400
5 x 5
After calculating a non-response rate of 10 a sample size of 440 was calculated
30
Methodology
A community based cross sectional study was conducted in the urban field practice
area of JJM Medical College Davangere The Urban field practice area has a total
population of 16943 and there are 12 areas in urban field practice area of JJM Medical
College Davangere
The Study was conducted by probability proportionate sampling The sample size for each
area was derived from the formula
1198991 =119875119900119901119906119897119886119905119894119900119899 119894119899 119890119886119888ℎ 119886119903119890119886
119879119900119905119886119897 119875119900119901119906119897119886119905119894119900119899119883 119878119886119898119901119897119890 119878119894119911119890
Example 1st area has a population of 1374 so
1198991 =1374
16943119883 440 = 36
Therefore 36 elderly subjects were selected by house to house visit from 1st area Same
procedure was applied for other areas until the desired sample size of 440 was reached
MATERIALS USED FOR DATA COLLECTION
The following tools were used for data collection
Semi-structured predesigned and pre-tested questionnaire
Portable bathroom weighing machine
Stretch- resistant measuring tape
Mercury Sphygmomanometer
Others - stethoscope torch tuning fork knee hammer
ICD-10 for system wise classification of disease59
31
Methodology METHOD OF COLLECTION OF DATA After establishing rapport with the family
and explaining the data collection procedure in the local language an informed verbal
consent was obtained from each individual and data was collected using a
Predesigned semi structured questionnaire by Interview method The questionnaire
comprised of the following information socio-demographic data of the study subjects
information regarding the morbidity pattern and health seeking behaviour If there were
more than one elderly subjects in the same household then all were included
The study subjects were asked about any ho illness (communicable or non-
communicable) which they were suffering from Upon a positive response the subjects were
further asked to specify the type(s) and duration of morbidities that they were suffering
from eg heart disease diabetes gastrointestinal diseases respiratory disease etc Some
were unable to understand or answer questions due to illness In such cases help was sought
from the family members Based on the self-reported symptoms information from
hospital records and clinical examination the prevalence of different morbidities among the
study subjects was assessed The Information about the health seeking behaviour was
sought by asking the study subjects about their visits to a health facility in case of an illness
and also the type of health facility visited ( Government private or quacks )
DATA ENTRY AND ANALYSIS Data was entered and analyzed using MS Excel and
Open Epi Info version 2260 Both descriptive and inferential statistics were used Subjectrsquos
baseline characteristics were presented as frequencies and percentages Categorical
variables between the groups were compared using Chi square test and Fisherrsquos exact
test Fisherrsquos exact test was used when more than 20 cells had expected value lt 5 and any
one of the cells had expected value lt 1 All statistical analysis was carried out at 5 level
of significance and p value lt005 was considered as significant
32
Methodology ETHICAL CLEARANCE
Ethical clearance was obtained before conducting the study from the Ethical Committee of
JJM Medical college Davangere [ANNEXURE III] During the study verbal
informed consent was taken from the study subjects Assurance was given that the
confidentiality concerning their information will be maintained
Clinical Examination included
(a) General physical examination
(b) Anthropometric measurements like height and weight
(c) Systemic examination
(d) Measurement of Blood pressure
(e) Eye examination by torch and Snellenrsquos (E chart)61
(f) Hearing assessment by Rinnersquos test Webberlsquos and Absolute bone conduction
test using tuning fork 62
Parameters used in our study
Height Height was measured with a standard non-stretchable measuring tape to the
nearest 01 cm in standing position (without footwear standing upright with the
back against the wall heels together and eyes directed forward)
33
Methodology Weight Weight was measured with minimal clothing and respecting the modesty of the
individual without footwear using a calibrated standard bathroom weighing scale to the
nearest 05 kg
Body Mass Index (BMI) Using weight (in Kg) and height (in meter2) BMI was calculated by applying the formula
Body Mass Index= Weight (kg) Height (m2)
The BMI cut off values for Asians as recommended by the WHO was used in our study
Table 4 WHO Categorization of Body Mass index (BMI) for Asians 63
Measurement of Blood pressure Procedure Blood pressure was measured in the left arm in a sitting posture with the subject in a
relaxed state Standardized mercury sphygmomanometer with adult size cuff was used
The first appearance of (phase 1 of Korotkoff sounds) sound was used to define
Systolic Blood Pressure (SBP) The disappearance of sound (phase 5) was used to
define Diastolic Blood Pressure (DBP) Two readings were taken five minutes apart and
the average of the two readings was taken as the final blood pressure reading A person
was considered to be a hypertensive if he she was already diagnosed case of
hypertension and or on treatment or with a current SBP of ge 140 mm Hg or DBP ge 90 mm
Hg (JNC VII criteria)64
BODY MASS INDEX INFERENCE
lt 185 underweight
185 to 229 kg m2 Normal
23 to 249 kg m2 Overweight
ge 25 kg m2 Obese
34
Methodology
Table 5 JNC VII Classification of Blood pressure 65
BP Classification Systolic Blood Pressure Diastolic Blood Pressure
Normal lt120 lt 80
Pre Hypertension 120 ndash 139 or 80 ndash 89 Stage 1 Hypertension 140 ndash 159 or 90 ndash 99 Stage 2 Hypertension ge 160 or ge 100
Anaemia was detected by pallor of conjunctiva tongue and nails and was confirmed by
doing haemoglobin estimation using sahlirsquos hemogobinometer66
The cut off for the diagnosis of anaemia was done based on WHO classification67
Diabetes - self reported cases of diabetes were considered as diabetics for the study
STUDY VARIABLES
1 AGE - subjects aged 60 years and above were taken up for the study Age was
recorded to the nearest complete years as stated by the respondent
2 GENDER Both males and females were taken up for the study
3 EDUCATIONAL STATUS 68
i Illiterate -A person who could not read or write
ii Primary School - studied up to 4th standard
iii Higher primary- studied between 5th and 7th standard
iv Secondary school -studied between 8th and 10th standard v Intermediate- studied between 11th or 12 th standard or diploma
vi Graduate - obtained graduate degree
vii Post Graduate- obtained post graduate degree
35
Methodology
4 OCCUPATION STATUS69
i Unskilled worker
Labourer domestic servants casual worker peon sweeper porter washer-man others
(vegetable vendor)
ii Semi-skilled worker
Factory worker agriculture laborers shoemaker potters others (security guard shop
helper canteen helper
iii Skilled
Artisan clerk foreman supervisor carpenter tailor mechanic electrician railway guard
painter modeler smiths baker driver shop assistant petty trader constable soldier
linesman pointsman potter barber others (tinkering printer receptionist salesman
welder cook mason postman plumber agarbatti worker)
iv semi-professional
Teacher pharmacist social worker owner of a small business farmer others (computer
programmer Govt employee nurse)
V Professional
Doctor engineer principal lawyer Military officer senior executive business
proprietor writer scientist large employer director university professor police
officer others (horse rider)
(vi) Unemployed Presently not working retired homemakers
36
Methodology 5 SOCIO ECONOMIC STATUS
Table 6 Socio-economic status (SES)- As per modified BG Prasad Classification70
5 TYPE OF FAMILY 71
Joint Family ndash It is type of family grouping in which a number of married couples and
their children live together in the same household All the men are related by blood
and women of household are their wives unmarried girls and widows of family kinsmen
Nuclear Family - It consist of married couple and their children while they are still
regarded as dependents
Three generation family - It is a family where representatives of three generation are
living together Young married couples continue to stay with their parents and have
their own children as well
Socio-economic
status
Prasadrsquos classification
1961(Per capita income in
Rupees per month)
Modified BG Prasad classification-
updated for May 2016 ((per
capita income in Rupees per
month)
I 100 and above 6261 and above
II 50-99 3099-6260
III 30-49 1835-3098
IV 15-29 949-1834
V Below 15 lt948
37
SAMPLE SIZE ESTIMATION
SAMPLE SIZE As quoted by Manmohan Gupta et al 35 in the studies done in various
parts of India the prevalence of morbidity in the geriatric population ranges from 31-80
Considering the prevalence of morbidity to be about 50 in the geriatric population at 95
confidence level and allowable error of 10 and a non -response rate of 10 sample size
was calculated to be 440 using the formula
n=4pq L2
n= sample size
4= factor to achieve 95 level of confidence
p= prevalence of morbidities ie 50
q= 100- p ie 100-50 = 50
L= permissible error in the estimate of ldquoprdquo (10 of p)
n = 4 x 50 x 50 = 400
5 x 5
After calculating a non-response rate of 10 a sample size of 440 was calculated
A community based cross sectional study was conducted in the urban field practice area of
JJM Medical College Davangere The Urban field practice area has a total population of
16943 and there are 12 areas in urban field practice area of JJM Medical College
Davangere
The Study was conducted by probability proportionate sampling The sample size for each area
was derived from the formula
1198991 =119875119900119901119906119897119886119905119894119900119899 119894119899 119890119886119888ℎ 119886119903119890119886
119879119900119905119886119897 119875119900119901119906119897119886119905119894119900119899119883 119878119886119898119901119897119890 119878119894119911119890
Example 1st area has a population of 1374 so
1198991 =1374
16943119883 440 = 36
Therefore 36 elderly subjects were selected by house to house visit from 1st area Same
procedure was applied for other areas until the desired sample size of 440 was reached
Results
RESULTS
The results are presented under the following headings
I Socio-demographic characteristics of study subjects
II Prevalence of morbidities among the study subjects
III Details of health seeking behavior of the study subjects
38
Results
ISocio-demographic characteristics of the study subjects
Table 7 Age and sex wise distribution of the study subjects
Figure 7 Age and sex wise distribution of the study subjects
In the present study Out of 440 study subjects majority 162(368) were in the age group
of 60-64 Years followed by 109 (247) in the age group of 65-69 Years 99 (225) were
in the age group of 70-74 Years and 35 (8) were more than or equal to 80 years of age
Majority of the subjects were males 260 (59) and 180 (41) were females The mean age
of the study population was 6745 plusmn 655 Years
354 254 262
88 42
389
239 172
67 133
0102030405060708090
100
60-64 65-69 70-74 75-79 ge80
Perc
enta
ge
Age in years
Males
Females
Age group (in years)
Males Females Total
Percentage () Frequency
(n=260) Percentage ()
Frequency (n=180)
Percentage ()
60-64 92 354 70 389 162 368
65-69 66 254 43 239 109 247
70-74 68 262 31 172 99 225
75-79 23 88 12 67 35 80
ge80 11 42 24 133 35 80
Total 260 100 180 100 440 100
39
Results
Table 8 Distribution of the study subjects based on religion
Religion Frequency (n=440) Percentage ()
Hindu 188 427
Muslim 252 573
Total 440 100
Figure 8 Distribution of the study subjects based on religion
In the present study it was found that the majority of the study subject belonged to Muslim
religion 252 (573) followed by Hindus 188 (427)
0102030405060708090
100
Hindu Muslim
427
573
Perc
enta
ge
Religion of the study subjects
40
Results
Table 9 Distribution of the study subjects based on Educational status
Education Frequency (n=440) Percentage ()
Illiterate 231 525
Primary school 121 275
Higher primary 38 86
Secondary School 30 68
Intermediate 6 14
Graduate 14 32
Total 440 100
Figure 9 Distribution of the study subjects based on Educational status
In the present study it was found that the Majority of the study subjects were illiterate
231(525) 121(275) had completed education up to primary school 30(68) had
completed education up to secondary school and only 14(32) were graduates
525
275
86 68
14 32
0102030405060708090
100
Perc
enta
ge
Educational status of study subjects
41
Results Table 10 Distribution of the study subjects based on occupation
Occupation Frequency (n=440) Percentage ()
Semi-professional 2 05
Skilled worker 45 102
Semi-skilled worker 68 155
Unskilled worker 100 227
Unemployed 225 511
Total 440 100
Figure 10 Distribution of study subjects based on their occupation
In our study it was found that the majority of the study subjects 225 (511) were
unemployed followed by 100 (227) who were unskilled workers 68 (155) were semi-
skilled workers and 45 (102) were skilled workers
0102030405060708090
100
05 102 155 227
511
Perc
enta
ge
Occupation of the study subjects
42
Results Table 11 Distribution of the study subjects based on socio-economic status (Modified
BG Prasad classification 2016)
Figure 11 Distribution of the study subjects based on their socio-economic status
In our study majority of the subjects 215 (49) belonged to Class IV Socioeconomic status
followed by 115 (26) who belonged to class III and 56 (13) who belonged to class II
SES (according to Modified BG Prasad Classification 2016)
Class II 13
Class III 26
Class IV 49
Class V 12
Socio-economic status Frequency (n=440) Percentage ()
Class I 0 0
Class II 56 13
Class III 115 26
Class IV 215 49
Class V 54 12
Total 440 100
43
Results
Table 12 Distribution of the study subjects based on their marital status
Marital status Frequency (n=440) Percentage ()
Unmarried 2 05
Married 323 734
Widowwidower 115 261
Total 440 100
Figure 12 Distribution of the study subjects based on their marital status
In our study it was found that majority of the study subjects 323(734) were married
followed by 115(261) who were widowed and only 2 (05) were unmarried
0102030405060708090
100
Unmarried married Widowwidower
05
734
261 Perc
enta
ge
44
Results
Table 13 Distribution of the study subjects based on the type of family
Type of family Frequency (n=440) Percentage ()
Nuclear family 163 37
Joint family 93 21
Three generation family 184 42
Total 440 100
Figure 13 Distribution of the study subjects based on the type of family
In the present study it was found that majority of the study subjects 184 (42) lived in a
three generation family followed by 163 (37) who lived in a nuclear family and 93(21)
who lived in a Joint family
Nuclear family 37
Joint family 21
Three generation
family 42
45
Results
II Prevalence of morbidities among the study subjects
Figure 14 Distribution of the study subjects based on the BMI
In the present study it was found that out of 440 study subjects 198 (45) had a normal
BMI followed by 132 (30) who were overweight 66 (15) were obese and only 44
(10) were underweight
under weight 10
Normal 45
Overweight 30
Obese 15
46
Results
Table 14 Distribution of morbidity pattern of the study subjects based on ICD 10
classification of diseases
System involved ICD 10
Males (n=260)
Females (n=180)
Total (n=440)
No No No
Diseases of musculoskeletal system (M00 ndash M99)
184 707 130 722 314 714
Diseases of the eye and adnexa (H00 ndash H59)
139 534 80 444 219 497
Diseases of oral cavityamp salivary glands (K00 ndash K14)
90 346 64 355 154 35
Endocrine nutritional amp metabolic diseases (E00 ndash
E90)
70 269 75 417 145 329
Diseases of circulatory system (I00 ndash I99)
64 246 73 405 137 311
Diseases of respiratory system(J00 ndash J99)
64 246 37 206 101 23
Diseases of digestive system (K00 ndash K93)
57 219 30 166 87 198
Diseases of skin amp subcutaneous tissue (L00 ndash
L99)
38 146 20 111 58 132
Diseases of the ear and mastoid process (H60 ndashH95)
39 15 18 10 57 13
Diseases of genitourinary system (N00 ndash N99)
22 85 7 39 29 66
Diseases of nervous system (G00 ndash G99)
6 23 5 28 11 25
Note Total number could not be given as many subjects had multiple disorders
47
Results
Figure 15 Distribution of morbidity pattern of the study subjects based on ICD 10
classification of diseases
In the present study it was found that the majority of the subjects 314 (714) suffered
from the disorders of the musculoskeletal system followed by 219 (497) who suffered
from the disease of the eye and adnexa154 (35) suffered from the disease of the oral
cavity 145 (329) suffered from endocrine nutritional and metabolic disorders137
(311) suffered from the disease of the circulatory system 101 (229) suffered from the
disease of the respiratory system 87(198) suffered from the disease of the digestive
system 58 (132) suffered from disease of the skin 57 (13) suffered from the disease of
the ear 29 (66) suffered from the disease of the genitourinary system and only 11( 25 )
suffered from the disease of the nervous system
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
714
497
35 329 311 229
198 132 13 66
25
perc
enta
ge
48
Results
Table 15 Distribution of the study subjects based on morbidity of the musculoskeletal
system
Musculoskeletal
Disease
Males
(n=260)
Females
(n=180)
Total
(n= 440)
Statistical
Value
Knee joint pain
52 (20)
30 (167)
82 (186)
X2 = 0779
df = 1
p=03773
Back ache
30 (115)
35 (194)
65 (148) X2 = 528
df = 1
p = 0021
Joint pain (other than
knee joint pain)
52(20)
35(194)
87(198)
X2 =00206
df=1
p =0885
Non-specific aches
and pain
50(192)
30(167)
80(182)
X2=0470
df=1
p = 0492
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses
In the present study it was found that the most common morbidity of musculoskeletal
system was pain of the joints (other than the knee joint) found in 87 (198) of the subjects
followed by knee joint pain in 82 ( 186) and non-specific pains and aches were found in
80 (182) of the subjects It was found that back ache was more common in females
35(194) compared to males 30 (115) and this difference was found to be statistically
significant
49
Results
Table 16 Distribution of the study subjects based on morbidity of the eye and adnexa
Diseases of the
eye and
adnexa
Males
(n=260)
Females
(n=180)
Total
(n= 440)
Statistical
value
Cataract
112(43)
60(333)
172(391)
X2 = 4241
df=1
p = 0039
Refractive error
20(77)
14(78)
34(77)
X2= 0001
df=1
p = 0973
Others (conjunctivitis
pterygium glaucoma etc)
7(27)
6(33)
13(29)
X2=0152
df=1
p = 0696
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses
In the present study it was found that the most common morbidity of the eye was cataract
found in 172 (391) of the subjects It was more common in males 112 (43) compared to
females 60 (333) and this difference was found to be statistically significant The other
morbidities present were refractive error found in 34 (77) subjects and others which
includes conjunctivitis pterygium glaucoma etc found in 13 (29 ) subjects
50
Results
Table 17 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the oral cavity
Diseases of the
oral cavity
Males
(n =260 )
Females
(n =180 )
Total
(n = 440)
Statistical
value
Stained teeth
22 (84)
18 (10)
40 (91)
X2 =0304
df=1
p = 0581
Missing teeth
40 (154)
38 (211)
78 (177)
X2= 239
df= 1
p=0122
Caries
28 (108)
8 (44)
36 (82)
X2= 566
df= 1
p=0017
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses
In the present study it was found that the most common morbidity of the oral cavity was
missing teeth found in 78 (177 ) of the subjects followed by stained teeth found in 40
(91) of the subjects and dental caries in 36 (82) of the subjects Dental caries were
more common in males 28 (108) compared to females 8(44) and this difference was
found to be statistically significant
51
Results
Table 18 Distribution of study subjects based on endocrine nutritional and metabolic
disorders
Disorders Males
(n =260 )
Females
(n =180)
Total
(n = 440)
Statistical value
Diabetes mellitus
45 (173)
37 (206)
82 (186)
X2 = 0739
df= 1
p = 0389
Anemia
24 (92)
35 (194)
59 (134)
X2= 955
df = 1
p = 0001
Thyroid disorders
1(04)
3 (17)
4 (09)
p= 0309
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
The present study revealed that the most common disorder of the endocrine system was
diabetes mellitus found in 82 (186) of the subjects followed by the nutritional disorder of
anemia found in 59 (134) of the subjects It was seen that anemia was more common
among females 35 (194) compared to males 24 (92) This difference was found to be
statistically significant Disorders of the thyroid gland were found in 4 (09) of the subjects
being more common in females 3(17) compared to males 1 (04)
52
Results
Table 19 Distribution of the study subject based on disease of the circulatory system
Diseases of
circulatory
system
Males
(n=260 )
Females
(n =180)
Total
(n = 440)
Statistical
value
Hypertension
62 (238)
71 (394)
133 (302)
X2= 1227
df= 1
p = 0000
CAD MI
Arrhythmias
2 (08)
2 (11)
4 (09)
p =100
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
In our study it was found that the most common disease of the circulatory system was
hypertension which was found in 133 (302 ) of the subjects it was more common in
females 71 (394) compared to males 62 (239) and this difference was found to be
statistically significant The other disorders of the circulatory system were CAD MI
arrhythmias which were found only in 4 (09) of the study subjects
53
Results
Table 20 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the respiratory system
Disorders of
Respiratory
System
Males
(n=260)
Females
(n=180)
Total
(n=440)
Statistical
value
Bronchial asthma
3 (12)
3 (17)
6 (14)
p =0692
URTI
45 (173)
27 (15)
72 (164)
X2= 0413
df = 1
p = 0520
Acute Bronchitis
12 (46)
7 (39)
19 (43)
X2= 0135
df = 1
p = 0712
Pulmonary TB
4 (15)
0(00)
4 (09)
p =0148
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
Our study revealed that the most common disease of the respiratory system was URTI
(upper respiratory tract infection) found in 72 (164) subjects followed by acute bronchitis
in 19 (43 ) bronchial asthma in 6 (14) and pulmonary TB in only in 4 (09 ) subjects
Pulmonary TB was found in 4 (15) of the males whereas no females had TB however
this difference was not found to be statistically significant
54
Results
Table 21 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the digestive system
Disorders of
Gastrointestinal
system
Males
(n = 260)
Females
(n = 180)
Total
(n = 440)
Statistical value
Constipation
21(8)
6 (33)
27(61)
X2 =4155
df =1
p =0041
Gastritis
24 (92)
18 (10)
42(95)
X2= 0072
df = 1
p =0787
Bleeding per
rectum 3(12) 2(11) 5(11)
p =100
Others (Pain
abdomen
anorexia
indigestion)
9(35)
4 (22)
13 (3)
X2=0569
df =1
p=0450
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
Our study revealed that the most common disorder of the gastrointestinal system was
gastritis found in 42 (95) subjects followed by constipation in 27 ( 61) others which
include pain abdomen anorexia indigestion was found in 13 (3) and bleeding per rectum
was seen in 5 (11) It was seen that constipation was more common among males 21(8)
compared to females 6 (33) which was found to be statistically significant
55
Results
Table 22 Distribution the study subjects based on disease of the Skin and
subcutaneous tissue
Disorders of skin and
subcutaneous tissue
Males ( n = 260)
Females (n = 180)
Total (n = 440)
Statistical
value
Itching
19(73)
2(11)
21(48)
X2 =896
df=1
p = 0002
Scaling 6 (23)
3 (17)
9 (2)
p =0743
Pigmentation
5(19)
4 (22)
9 (2)
p =100
Dryness
8 (31)
11 (61)
19(43)
X2= 237
df = 1
p = 0123 Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
In the present study it was found that the most common disease of the skin was itching
which was present in 21 (48) of the study subjects followed by dryness in 19 (43) and 9
(2) of the subjects had scaling and pigmentation It was seen that itching was more
common among males 19 (73) compared to females 2 (11) and this difference was
found to be statistically significant
56
Results
Table 23 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the ear
Disease of the ear
Males
(n= 260)
Females
(n = 180)
Total
(n = 440) Statistical value
Hearing impairment
33 (126)
16 (89)
49 (111)
X2 =155
df =1
p =0212
Ear discharge
3 (12)
1 (06)
4(09)
p =0647
Tinnitus
3 (12)
1 (06)
4 (09)
p =0647
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
In the present study it was observed that hearing impairment was the most common
morbidity of the ear found in 49 (111) of the subjects though it was more common
among males 33 (126) compared to females 16 (89) the difference was not found to be
statistically significant The other disorders which affected the ear were ear discharge and
tinnitus both present in 4 (09) of the subjects
57
Results
Table 24 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the genitourinary
system
Disorders of
genitourinary system
Male
(n = 260)
Female
(n = 180)
Total
(n=440)
Statistical value
Burning micturition
2 (077)
2 (11)
4 (09)
p=100
Increased frequency of
micturition
20(77) 5(28) 25(57)
X2= 4794
df =1
p =0028 Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
In our study it was observed that the most common morbidity affecting the genitourinary
system was increased frequency of micturition in 25 (57) of the subjects followed by
burning micturition in 4 (09) of the study subjects Increased frequency of micturition was
more common among males 20 (77) compared to females 5 (28) and this difference
was found to be statistically significant
58
Results
Table 25 Distribution of the study subjects based on diseases of the Nervous system
Disease of the
nervous system Males
(n = 260)
Females
(n = 180)
Total
(n = 440)
p value
Memory loss
2 (77)
2 (11)
4 (09)
100
Stroke
2 (77)
0 (00)
2 (05)
0515
Neuritis
2 (77)
3 (17)
5 (11)
0652
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
Our study revealed that the most common disorder of the nervous system was neuritis seen
in 5 (11) of the subjects followed by memory loss in 4 (09) and stroke in 2 (05 ) of
the subjects It was observed that 2 (0 77) of males had suffered a stroke whereas none of
the females had suffered from stroke however this difference was not found to be
statistically significant
59
Results
Table 26 Association between morbidity pattern of the study subjects and their age
group
System involved 60-69Yrs
(n = 271)
70-79Yrs
(n = 134)
gt 80Yrs
(n = 35)
Total
( n = 440)
Statistical
value
Musculoskeletal
System
195 (72)
94 (70)
25 (710)
314 (714) X2= 0143
df = 2 p = 0930
Eye amp adnexa
125 (461)
69 (515)
25 (714)
219 (497) X2= 8166
df = 2 p = 0016
Oral cavity amp salivary gland
56 (207)
68 (507)
30 (857)
154 (350) X2= 7865
df = 2 p lt 00001
Endocrine nutritional amp
metabolic diseases
91 (335)
47 (35)
7 (200)
145 (329) X2= 297
df = 2 p = 0225
Circulatory
system
87 (321)
40 (298)
10 (285)
137 (311) X2= 0328
df = 2 p = 0848
Respiratory
system
64 (236)
31 (231)
6 (171)
101 (23) X2= 0738
df = 2 p = 0691
Digestive system
52 (191)
28 (210)
7 (200)
87 (191) X2= 0166
df = 2 p = 0 920
Skin and subcutaneous
tissue
43 (159)
13 (97)
2 (57)
58 (132) X2= 4831
df = 2 p = 0089
Ear amp mastoid process
27 (99)
20 (149)
10 (285)
57 (13) X2= 1018
d= 2 p = 0006
Genitourinary
system
20 (74)
8 (59)
1 (29)
29 (66) X2= 1151
df = 2 p = 0562
Nervous system
5 (18)
4 (29)
2 (57)
11 (25)
p = 0418
Figure in parenthesis indicates percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
60
Results
Table 26 shows the association between the morbidity pattern and age group of the study
subjects It is observed that the disease of the eye and adnexa increase with increasing age
and are more common in individuals above 80 years of age (714) compared to
individuals in the age group of 60-69 years (461) and 70-79 years (515) This
difference was found to be statistically significant The disease of the oral cavity were also
more common in the subjects aged 80 years and above (857) compared to individuals in
the age group of 70-79 years (507) and 60-69 years (207) this difference was also
found to be statistically significant Significant association was also found between
increasing age and disease of the ear 285 subjects aged 80 years and above suffered from
disease of the ear followed by 149 in the age group of 60-69 years and 99 in the age
group of 60-69 years
61
Results Table 27 Association between morbidity pattern of the study subjects and their
occupation
System involved Employed (n=215)
Unemployed (n=225)
Total (n=440)
Statistical value
Musculoskeletal
system
171 (795) 143 (635) 314 (714) X2 =1374 df=1
p=00002
Eye and adnexa 108 (502) 111(493) 219(497) X2= 0035 df=1
p= 0850
Oral cavityamp
salivary glands
76 (353) 78 (347) 154 (35) X2=0022 df=1
p=0880
Endocrine
nutritional amp
metabolic
disease
75 (348) 70 (311) 145 (329) X2=0708 df=1
p=0400
circulatory
system
58 (269) 79 (351) 137 (311) X2=3393 df=1
p=0065
Respiratory
system
49 (227) 52 (231) 101 (23) X2=0006 df=1
p=09363
Digestive system 45 (21) 42 (187) 87 (198) X2=0125 df=1
p=0723
Skin
subcutaneous
tissue
38 (176) 20 (88) 58 (132) X2=741 df=1
p=0006
Ear and mastoid
process
31 (144) 26 (115) 57 (13) X2=0799 df=1
p=0371
Genitourinary
system
16 (74) 13 (57) 29 (66) X2=0494 df=1
p=0481
Nervous system
2 (093) 9 (4) 11 (25) X2=425 df=1
p=0039 Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses
62
Results
Table 27 shows the association between the morbidity pattern and occupation of the study
subjects It was observed that musculoskeletal disorders were more common among the
subjects who are employed (795) compared to those who are not employed (635) and
this difference was found to be statistically significant A significant association was also
seen between the disorders of the skin and subcutaneous tissue 176 subjects who are
employed suffered from the disease of the skin and subcutaneous tissue compared to 88
who were unemployed The diseases of the nervous system were more common among
those who were unemployed (4) compared to those who were employed (093) this
difference was also found to be statistically significant
63
Results Table 28 Association between morbidity pattern of the study subjects and their
religion
System involved Hindu
(n=188)
Muslim
(n=252)
Total
(n=440)
Statistical value
Musculoskeletal system 138 (73) 176 (698) 314 (714)
X2=0668 df=1
p=0413
Eye and adnexa 100 (531) 119 (472) 219 (497) X2=1535 df=1
p= 0215
Oral cavityamp salivary glands 73 (388) 81 (321) 154 (35)
X2=211 df=1
p=0145
Endocrine nutritional amp metabolic diseases
53 (2819) 92 (365) 145 (329) X2=3371 df=1
p=0066
circulatory system 58 (269) 79 (351) 137 (311)
X2=3393 df=1
p=0065
Respiratory system
33 (176) 68 (269) 101 (229)
X2=5415 df= 1
p=0019
Digestive system 27 (144) 60 (238) 87 (198) X2=6059 df=1
p=0013
Skin subcutaneous tissue
31 (164) 27 (107) 58 (132) X2=3138 df=1
p=00765
Ear and mastoid process
28 (149) 29 (115) 57 (129) X2=1095 df=1
p=0297
Genitourinary system
16 (85) 13 (52) 29 (66) X2=1965 df=1
p=0161
Nervous system
4 (21) 7 (28) 11(25) p=0764
Figure in parenthesis indicates percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
64
Results
Table 28 shows the association between the morbidity pattern of the study subjects and their
religion In our study it was observed that the disorders of the digestive system were more
common among Muslims (238) compared to Hindus (144) this difference was found
to be statistically significant Also the disorders of the respiratory system were more
common among Muslims (269) compared to Hindus (176) This difference was also
found to be statistically significant Some of the diseases were more common among Hindus
which include the disease of the eye and adnexa (531) oral cavity (388) ear (149)
skin and subcutaneous tissue (164) and genitourinary system (85) but it was not found
to be statistically significant
65
Results
III HEATLTH SEEKING BEHAVIOR OF THE STUDY SUBJECTS
Figure16 Distribution of the study subjects based on the visit to health facility in case
of an illness
In our study it was found that that out of 440 study subjects 395(898) visited a health
facility in case of an illness whereas 45(102) did not visit any health facility in case of an
illness
898
102
health facility visitednot visited
66
Results
Table 29 Reasons cited by the study subjects for not seeking healthcare in case of an
illness
In the present study it was found that the most common reason stated by the 45 study
subjects for not seeking health care in case of an illness was that it was a mil 20 (444)
followed by lack of money stated by12 (267) the other reasons stated were no one to
accompany 7 (156) and lack of faith in health care 6 (133)
Reasons cited for not
seeking health care
Frequency (n=45)
Percentage ()
Mild discomfort 20 444
Lack of money 12 267
Lack of faith in
healthcare
6 133
No one to accompany 7 156
Total 45 100
67
Results
Table 30 Distribution of the study subjects based on the type of health facility visited
It was observed that out of 395 subjects who visited health care facility in case of an illness
229(58) Visited government hospitals 160 (405) visited private practitioners hospitals
and 6 (15) visited quacks More number of males (622) visited government hospitals
compared to females (513)
Type of health facility visited
Males
(n=241)
Females
(n=154)
Total
(n=395)
No No No
Government hospital 150 622 79 513 229 58
Private practitionershospitals 87 361 73 474 160 405
Quacks 4 17 2 13 6 15
Total 241 100 154 100 395 100
68
Results
Table 31 Association between gender and health seeking behaviour of the study
subjects
Whether visited
health facility
in case of illness
Sex
Total
n ()
p value Male
n ()
Female
n ()
Yes 241 (927) 154 (856) 395 (898) 00151
No 19 (106) 26 (144) 45 (102)
Total 260 (59) 180 (41) 440 (100)
x2=5901 df =1
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
It was observed that more number of males visited a health care facility in case of an illness
241(927) whereas only 154(856) females visited a health facility in case of an illness
This difference was found to be statistically significant
69
Results
Table 32 Association between educational status and health seeking
behaviour of the study subjects
Whether visited Health facility in case of illness
p value
Educational status(n) Yes () No ()
0000
Illiterate (231) 194 (84) 37 (16)
Primary school (121) 115 (95) 6 (49)
Higher primary (38) 37 (974) 1 (26)
Secondary school (30) 29 (967) 1 (33)
Intermediate (6) 6 (100) 0(00)
Graduate (14) 14 (100) 0(00)
Total(440) 395 (898) 45(102)
Fisherrsquos exact test
In the present study it was found that 84 of the study subjects who were illiterate visited a
health facility in case of an illness whereas 16 did not visit a health facility in case of an
illness 967 of the subjects with education up to secondary school visited the health
facility and 100 of the subjects who studied up to intermediate and with a graduate degree
visited the health facility in case of an illness This difference was found to be statistically
significant
70
Results
Table 33 Distribution of study subjects according to frequency of visits to a health care facility
Frequency of visits to a health care facility
Frequency
(n=395)
Percentage
Once a month 207 524
Once in 3 months 99 251
Once in 6 months 79 20
Once in a year 10 25
Total 395 100
In the present study it was found that out of 395 study subjects who visited a health care
facility in case of an illness 207 (524) visited a health facility every month followed by
99 (251) who visited once in 3 months 79(20) once in 6 months and 10 25 visited
the health facility once in a year
71
Discussion
DISCUSSION
I Socio-demographic characteristics
Our study was done in the urban field practice area of JJM Medical College Davangere
among 440 geriatric subjects our study aimed at assessing the morbidity pattern and health
seeking behaviour of the geriatric population in the study area
In the present study Out of 440 study subjects majority 162(368) were in the age
group of 60-64 Years followed by 109 (247) in the age group of 65-69 Years 99 (225)
in the age group of 70-74 Years and 8 were more than or equal to 80 years of age [Table
7] This was similar to a study conducted by Prakash Boraingaiah et al 72 in which majority
of the elderly (346) belongs to age group 60-64 years followed by age group 75 years and
above (259)
In our study it was also seen that 59 of the study subjects were males and 41 were
females This was similar to a study conducted by Mohan Gupta et al 35 where 573
subjects were males and 427were females Our findings were contrary to a study
conducted by Md Alam Naushad et al 28 where 598 subjects were females and 402
were males
In the present study it was found that the majority of the study subject belonged to
Muslim religion 252 (573) followed by Hindus 188 (427) there were no study subjects
who belonged to other religions like Christian Jain Sikhs etc [Table 8] similar findings
were seen in a study conducted by Mrinal Ranjan Srivastav et al 50 in which 52 of the
subjects were Muslims
72
Discussion
In the present study it was found that the Majority of the study subjects were illiterate
525 whereas 275 had completed education up to primary school 82 had completed
education up to secondary school and only 32 were graduates [Table 9] These findings
were similar to a study done by Shraddha K et al 51in which 504 of the study subjects
were illiterate
In our study it was found that the majority of the study subjects 511 were unemployed
followed by 227 who were unskilled workers 155 were semi-skilled workers and
about 105 were skilled workers [Table 10] These findings were similar to a study done
by Rajat Das Gupta et al27 al in which 481 of the study subjects were not working
In our study majority of the subjects 49 belonged to Class IV Socioeconomic status
followed by 26 who belonged to class III and 13 who belonged to class II (according to
Modified BG Prasad Classification 2016) [Table 11] Similar findings were found in a study
conducted by Sribas Goswami and Manjari Sahai 29 in which majority of the study subjects
belonged to class IV socio economic status
In our study it was found that the majority of the study subjects 734 were married
followed by 261 who were widowed and only 05 were unmarried [Table 12] These
findings were similar to a study done by L subedhi and RB Sah 40 in which 663 of the
subjects were married 322 were widowed and 07 were unmarried
In the present study it was found that majority of the study subjects 42 lived in a three
generation family followed by 37 who lived in a nuclear family and 21 who lived in a
Joint family [Table 13] These findings were similar to a study done by Swapnil Jain et al 26
in which the majority (47) of the study subjects lived in a three generation family
73
Discussion
II Prevalence of morbidities among the study subjects
In the present study it was found that majority of the subjects 45 had a normal BMI
followed by 30 who were overweight about 15 were obese and only10 were
underweight [Figure 14] Similar findings were reported in a study conducted by Khadervali
Nagoor et al 44 in which 49 subjects had a normal BMI In a study done by Vimala
Thomas et al 52 272 of the subjects were obese which was higher than the present study
In the present study it was found that the majority of the subjects suffered from the
disorders of the musculoskeletal system (714) eye and adnexa (497) oral cavity
(311) respiratory system (229) digestive system (198)disease of the skin
(132)ear(13)genitourinary system (66) nervous system (25) [Table14] Similar
findings were seen in a study done by Rajashree Bhat et al 55 in which most common
morbidity of elderly was the problems of loco-motor system (486) followed by vision
(427) CVS disorders (344) respiratory system (202) and disease of ear (179)In
this study though the prevalence of loco-motor system disorders (486) was highest
compared to other disorders it was lesser compared to our study (714) In a study done by
L subedhi and RB Sah 40 it was found that 44 had eye problems 43 had gastrointestinal
problems 33 had CVS problems and 23 had ENT problems In this study the prevalence
of gastrointestinal disorders was much higher compared to our study
In the present study joint pain (including the knee joint) was most common disorder of the
musculoskeletal system seen in 40 of the males compared to 384 in females [Table 15]
whereas in a study done by Swapnil Jain et al 26 it was found that 472 males and 528
females suffered from joint pains This could be attributed to the fact that in our study
majority of the study subjects were males
74
Discussion
In the present study it was found that the most common morbidity of the eye was cataract
found in 39 of the subjects It was more common in males 43 compared to females
333 [ Table 16]These findings were similar to a study done by Shraddha K et al 51 in
which the overall prevalence of cataract was 302 of which 42 males and 358
females had cataract
In the present study it was found that the most common morbidity of the oral cavity was
missing teeth found in 177 of the subjects [Table 17] it was similar to the findings of a
study conducted by JP Singh et al 48 in which 1475 subjects were edentulous
The present study revealed that the most common disorder of the endocrine system was
diabetes mellitus found in 186 of the subjects followed by the nutritional disorder of
anemia found in 134 of the subjects It was seen that anemia was more common among
females 194 compared to males 92 [Table 18] Kakkar R et al 45 reported similar
findings with prevalence of diabetes mellitus as 153 In a study done by Deepak Sharma
et al 47 anemia was present in 15 of the subjects 97 males and 21 females were
anemic which was similar to our study
In our study it was found that the most common disease of the circulatory system was
hypertension which was found in 302 of the subjects it was more common in females
394 compared to males 239 and this difference was found to be statistically significant
[Table 19] A study by L Subedhi and RB Sah 40 reported that the prevalence of
hypertension was more among females (333) compared to males (30) which was
statistically significant
75
Discussion
In our study the most common morbidity of the respiratory system was upper respiratory
tract infection (163) [Table20] it was similar to the study done by Leena Rahul
Salunke33 where it was reported to be 196
In our study the most common disorder of the digestive system was gastritis (95)
[Table 21] similar to the findings of JP Singh et al 48 (35) contrary to this L subedhi
and RB Sah 40 reported a high prevalence of gastritis (39) This difference could be
attributed to the difference in the interpretation of symptoms for the diagnosis of gastritis
In our study the most common disorder of the skin was itching (48) [ Table 22] which
was similar to the findings reported by JP Singh et al 48 in which 225 subjects suffered
from itching
In our study the most common disorder of the ear was impaired hearing (111) [Table
23] similar to a study by Vandana Nikumb et al 38 in which 106 subjects suffered from
hearing impairment
In our study it was observed that the most common morbidity affecting the
genitourinary system was increased frequency of micturition (57) [Table 24]
L subedhi and RB Sah40 found in their study that 143 subjects suffered from increased
frequency of micturition which was higher compared to our study
Our study revealed that 25 subjects suffered from the disorders of the nervous
system [Table 25] similar to a study conducted by Vandana Nikumb et al 38 in which
13 of the Subjects suffered from the disorders of the nervous system whereas in a
study conducted by Shilpa Shaukaiah et al36 it was found that 66 of the subjects
suffered from the disorders of the nervous system which was higher than our study
76
Discussion
It is observed that the disease of the eye and adnexa increased with increasing age and were
more common in individuals above 80 years of age (714) The disease of the oral cavity
were also more common in the subjects aged 80 years and above (857) and 285
subjects aged 80 years and above suffered from disease of the ear A significant association
was found between age and these morbidities [Table 26] Similar results were found in a
study done by Swapnil Jain et al 26 in which cataract hearing impairment and dental
problems were significantly associated with the age of the study subjects
In our study a significant association was found between occupation and the disorders of
the musculoskeletal system skin and the nervous system Disorders of the musculoskeletal
system were more common among employed subjects (795) compared to unemployed
(635) 176 subjects who were employed suffered from the disease of the skin and
subcutaneous tissue compared to 88 who were unemployed Diseases of the nervous
system were more common among those who were unemployed (4) compared to those
who were employed (093) [Table 27]
A study done by Kakkar R et al45 found that there was a significant association between the
employment status and the morbidities of the CVS arthritis and cataract CVS morbidity
was more common among those not working (164) compared to those working (36)
Arthritis was also more common among not working (212) compared to those working
(55) and cataract was also more common among those not working (175) compared to
those working (55)
77
Discussion
In our study it was observed that there was a significant association between religion and
disorders of the digestive system and respiratory system The disorders of the digestive
system were more common among Muslims (238) compared to Hindus (144) Also the
disorders of the respiratory system were more common among Muslims (269) compared
to Hindus (176) [Table 28] In a study conducted by Mrinal Ranjan Srivastav et al 50 it
was found that there was significant association between religion and the morbidities of the
genitourinary system in the urban areas The problems of the genitourinary system were
more common among Hindus (26) compared to Muslims (96)
III HEATLTH SEEKING BEHAVIOR OF THE STUDY SUBJECTS
In our study it was found that that (898) study subjects visited a health facility in case
of an illness whereas 102 did not visit any health facility in case of an illness[Figure 16]
Similar findings were seen in a study conducted by Vimala Thomas et al 52 where it was
found that 716 subjects visited a health facility Contrary to our findings a study
conducted by Bhawalkar JS et al46 showed that only 81 subjects visited a health facility in
case of an illness whereas 919 did not visit any health facility
In the present study it was found that the most common reason stated by study subjects
for not seeking health care in case of an illness was that it was a mild discomfort (444)
followed by lack of money stated by (267) other reasons stated were no one to
accompany (156) and lack of faith in health care (133) [Table 29] In a study
conducted by Deepak Sharma et al 47 it was found that the most common reasons for not
seeking health care were the following disease due to age (496) health services too far
(191) lack of money (6) no body to take to hospital (35)
78
Discussion
It was observed that out of 395 subjects who visited health care facility in case of an illness
58 Visited government hospitals 362 visited private practitioners hospitals and 15
visited quacks [Table 30] similar results were found in a study conducted by Deepak Sharma
et al 47 in which 607 went to Government hospitals 267 consulted private practitioners
and 126 took over the counter drugs In another study conducted by Rajat Das Gupta et al
27 it was found that 33 visited Government hospitals 25 visited private hospitals 6
visited private practitioners
It was observed that more number of males (927) visited a health care facility in case of
an illness whereas only 856 females visited a health facility in case of an illness [Table
31] In a study done by Man Mohan Gupta et al 35 it was found that 672 females and
651 males visited a health facility in case of illness
In the present study it was found that 848 of the study subjects who were illiterate
visited a health facility in case of an illness whereas 152 did not visit a health facility in
case of an illness A significant association was found between educational status and
gender [Table 32] In a study done by Deepak Sharma et al 47 it was found that Gender
literacy income and marital status were not found to be significantly related to health-
seeking behaviour
In the present study it was found that 524 subjects visited a health facility every month
followed by 251 who visited a health facility once in 3 months 20once in 6 months
and 25 visited a health facility once in a year[ Table 33] In a study conducted by Rajat
Das Gupta et al 27 it was found that majority of the subjects (2943) visited a health
facility once a year followed by 2813 who visited a health facility once in three months
79
Conclusion
CONCLUSION
The study revealed that some of the common morbidities among the geriatric subjects were
the disorders of the musculoskeletal system followed by the disease of the eye and adnexa
oral cavity endocrine nutritional and metabolic disorders etc some disorders like cataract
dental caries constipation and increased frequency of micturition were more common
among males whereas disease like anemia and hypertension were more common among
females A significant association was found between some of the morbidities and socio
demographic determinants like age occupation and religion
Any degree of formal schooling was found to be associated with better health seeking
behavior Majority of the subjects visited a Government health facility in case of an illness
and the main reason that was stated for not visiting a health facility was that they suffered
from mild discomfort and did not consider it necessary to visit a health facility
80
Summary
SUMMARY
Our study was done in the urban field practice area of JJM Medical College Davangere
among 440 geriatric subjects our study aimed at assessing the morbidity pattern and health
seeking behaviour of the geriatric population in the study area
The results of our study are as follows
ISocio-demographic characteristics of the study subjects
In the present study 368 subjects were in the age group of 60-64 Years
59 of the subjects were males and 41 were females
573 subjects were Muslims whereas 427 were Hindus
Majority of the subjects were illiterate (525) whereas 275 had completed
education up to primary school
It was found that the majority of the study subjects (511) were unemployed
49 subjects belonged to Class IV Socioeconomic status according to Modified BG
Prasad Classification
734 of the subjects were married
42 of the people lived in a three generation family
II Prevalence of morbidities among the study subjects
Majority of the subjects (45) had a normal BMI followed 30who were
overweight
Majority 714 subjects suffered from the disorders of the musculoskeletal system
followed by 497 who suffered from the disease of the eye and adnexa35
suffered from the disease of the oral cavity 329 suffered from endocrine
nutritional and metabolic disorders and 311 suffered from the disease of the
circulatory system 229 suffered from the disease of the respiratory system198
81
Summary
suffered from the disease of the digestive system132 suffered from disease of the
skin13 suffered from the disease of the ear66 suffered from the disease of the
genitourinary system and 25 suffered from the disease of the nervous system
The most common morbidity of musculoskeletal system was pain of the joints (other
than the knee joint) found in 198 of the subjectsBack ache was more common in
females 231 compared to males 163 and this difference was found to be
statistically significant
cataract found in 39 of the subjects It was more common in males 43 compared
to females 333 and this difference was found to be statistically significant
Missing teeth were found in 177 of the subjects Dental caries were more
common in males 108 compared to females 44 and this difference was found to
be statistically significant
Diabetes mellitus found in 186 of the subjects followed by the nutritional disorder
of anemia found in 134 of the subjects anemia was more common among females
194 compared to males 92 This difference was found to be statistically
significant
Hypertension which was found in 302 of the subjects it was more common in
females 394 compared to males 239 and this difference was found to be
statistically significant
upper respiratory tract infection) found in 163 subjects followed by acute
bronchitis in 43 bronchial asthma in 14 and pulmonary TB in only 09
Gastritis was found in 95 subjects followed by constipation in 61 Among
males (81) had constipation compared to females(03)
Most common disease of the skin was itching which was present in 48 of the
study subjects followed by dryness in 43
82
Summary
Hearing impairment was found in 111 of the subjects
Increased frequency of micturition was found in 57 of the subjects followed by
burning micturition in 09 of the study subjects Increased frequency of
micturition was more among males 77 compared to females in whom it was 28
and this difference was found to be statistically significant
The most common disorder of the nervous system was neuritis seen in 11 of the
subjects followed by memory loss in 09 and stroke in 05 of the subjects
A significant association was found between increasing age and the morbidities of
the eye ear and the oral cavity
Significant association was found between occupation and the disorders of the
musculoskeletal system skin and the nervous system Disorders of the
musculoskeletal system were more common among employed subjects (795)
compared to unemployed (635) 176 subjects who were employed suffered
from the disease of the skin and subcutaneous tissue compared to 88 who were
unemployed Diseases of the nervous system were more common among those who
were unemployed (4) compared to those who were employed (093)
It was observed that the disorders of the digestive system were more common
among Muslims (238) compared to Hindus (144) this difference was found to
be statistically significant Also the disorders of the respiratory system were more
common among Muslims (269) compared to Hindus (176) This difference
was also found to be statistically significant
83
Summary
III HEATLTH SEEKING BEHAVIOR OF THE STUDY SUBJECTS
In our study 898 subjects visited a health facility in case of an illness whereas
102 did not
The most common reason stated by study subjects for not seeking health care in case
of an illness was that it was a mild discomfort (444) followed by lack of money
stated by (267) the other reasons stated were no one to accompany (156) and
lack of faith in health care (133)
It was observed that 58 subjects Visited Government hospitals 362 visited
private practitioners hospitals and 15 visited quacks
Majority of males (927) visited a health care facility in case of an illness whereas
only 856 females visited a health facility in case of an illness This difference was
found to be statistically significant
A significant association was found between the educational status and health
seeking behaviour Majority of the educated subjects visited a health facility in case
of an illness compared to those who were illiterate
It was found that 524 subjects visited a health facility every month followed by
251 who visited a health facility once in 3 months 20once in 6 months and
25 visited a health facility once in a year
84
Limitations
LIMITATIONS
1 Many of the responses were subjective and there were no records to verify them
2 Some of the morbidities were diagnosed only by clinical examination and could not be
confirmed by performing diagnostic tests due to high cost and time constraints
3 This study was done in the urban field practice area which consisted of a closed
community hence the results cannot be generalized to the entire population of the area
85
Recommendations
RECOMMENDATIONS
1 Health education should be given to the geriatric people regarding the common health
problems associated with ageing and preventive care should be provided to the elderly
2 Geriatric clinics should be set up at the primary health care level which provide regular
screening and health check-ups
3 There should also be a provision to provide domiciliary care by specialists qualified in
geriatrics
4 The family members and the care givers of the elderly should be educated about the
common health problems of the elderly and also about the need for regular health check-ups
and emotional support
5 The majority of the geriatric population is out of work force they are suffering from
many morbidities and are totally dependent on others even for their health needs Hence the
Government should increase the pension of the elderly and provide them quality healthcare
free of cost
6 There is also a need for public private partnership to improve the quality of health
services for the geriatric people More number of NGOs should work towards improving the
health and the quality of life of the elderly
86
References
REFERENCES
1 United Nations Department of Economic and Social affairs Population Division
World population ageing 2013 Available from URL
wwwunorgendevelopmentpopulationageingWorldPopulationAgeing2013
[Accessed on 17-7-2016]
2 Khan S and Itrat M Current Issues in Geriatric Health Care in India-A Review J Community Med Health Care 2016 1(1) 1-3
3 United Nations Department of Economic and Social Affairs Population Division
World Population Ageing 2015 ndash Highlights Available from URL
wwwunorgendevelopmentdesapopulationpdfageingWPA2015_Reportpdf
[Accessed on 272017]
4 State of elderly in India 2014 Help age India Available from URL
httpswwwhelpageindiaorgimagespdfstate-elderly-india-2014pdf [Accessed on
1082017]
5 World Health Organization World report on ageing and health 2015Available
from URL wwwwhointageingeventsworld-report-2015-launchen [Accessed on
1272017]
6 National policy for Senior citizens March 2011Ministry of Social Justice and
welfare Govt of India Available from URL
socialjusticenicinwritereaddataUploadFilednpscpdf [Accessed on 482017]
87
References
7 Elderly in India Profile and programmes 2016Govt of India Ministry of statistics
and programme implementation Central Statistics Office Available from URL
wwwmopsigovin [ Accessed on 1442017]
8 Saxena V Kandpal SD Gael D Bansal S Health status of elderly community
based study Indian Journal of Community Health2012 Oct-Dec24(4)269-74
9 Shah T Patel M Shah V Health care seeking behaviour of urban and rural
community in Ahmedabad district Int J Med Sci Public Health20132908-11
10 Sahoo H Mishra NR Health Status Morbidity Pattern and Treatment Seeking
Behaviour among Elderly in India Evidence from 60th round of National Sample
Survey Data Learning community 2011 Dec 2(3) 341-55
11 Park K Parkrsquos Textbook of Preventive and social medicine 24 th ed Jabalpur MS
Banarsidas Bhanot Publishers2017631
12 UNFPA- state of World Population 2011Chapter 1 setting the scene 19-31
Available from URL httpswwwunfpaorgsitesdefaultfilesresource-
pdfUNFPA-Report-Chapter1pd [Accessed on 1082017]
13 Lal S Adarsh Pankaj Textbook of community Medicine 4th ed CBS publishers and
distributors PvtLtd2011732
14 Census of India 2001 Registrar General And Census Commissioner India
Available from URL httpwwwcensusindiagovinCensus[Accessed on
7102015]
15 SRS bulletin October 2012 Registar General of India New Delhi Available from
URL censusindiagovinvital_statisticsSRS_BulletinsSRS_Bulletin-
October_2012[Acessed on 7102015]
88
References
16 Bagchi K Healthy ageing Health and Population-Perspectives and Issues 2000
23(1)11-16
17 Salagre SB The Association of Physicians of India Chapter 177 Health Issues in
Geriatrics Available from URL
wwwapiindiaorgmedicine_update_2013chap177pd [ Accessed on 282017]
18 Ingle GK Nath A Geriatric Health in India Concerns and Solutions Indian Journal
of Community Medicine 2008 33(4)214-18
19 World Health Organization Active Ageing a policy framework 2002 Available
from httpwhqlibdocwhointhq2002who_nmh_nph_028pdf [Accessed on
1062017]
20 Inche Zainal Abidin S Sutan R Shamsuddin K Prevalence and determinants of
appropriate health seeking behaviour among known diabetics Results from a
community-based survey Advances in Epidemiology 2014 Nov 20141-6
21 Begashaw B Tessema F Gesesew HA Health Care Seeking behavior in Southwest
Ethiopia Plos one 2016 Sep 11(9)e0161014
22 MacKian S Health systems development Manchester University of Manchester
2003 A review of health seeking behavior problems and prospects
23 Metta EO Health-seeking behaviour among adults in the context of the
epidemiological transition in Southeastern Tanzania A focus on malaria and
diabetes [Groningen] University of Groningen 2016 228 Available from URL
httpswwwrugnlresearchportalfiles28737720Chapter_7pdf [Accessed on
1272017]
24 Adhikari D Rijal D Factors affecting health seeking behaviour of senior citizens of
Dharan Journal of Nobel Medical College 2015 Sep 4(1)57-63
25 Polisetty S Seepana M Morbidity profile of elderly individuals in urban
Visakhapatnam Int J Community Med Public Health 2017 4(2)2558-63
89
References
26 Jain S Kaware AC Doibale MK Shaikh S Radhey BK Mathurkar MP Morbidity
pattern among geriatric population in urban field practice area of district of
Maharashtra a cross sectional study Int J Community Med Public Health 2016
3(2)523-29
27 Gupta RD Loha A Roy S Morbidity pattern and health-seeking behaviour among
the senior citizens in a selected urban area of Bangladesh A cross-sectional study
South East Asia Journal of Public Health 2016 Jul 5(2)43-49
28 Naushad MA Verma N Bhawnani D Jain M Anand T Umate LV Morbidity
pattern and health seeking behaviour in elderly population of Raipur City
Chhattisgarh India Indian Journal of Community Health2016 Sep 28(3)236-41
29 Goswami S Sahai M A Study of Morbidity Pattern in Elderly Population European
Researcher Series A 2016103(2)119-28
30 Bardhan H Dixit AM Agarwal R Jain PK Gupta S Shukla SK Morbidity profile
of elderly population in Ghaziabad district a cross-sectional study Int J Med Sci
Public Health 2016 5(6)1098-1102
31 Maroof M Ahmad A Khalique N Ansari MA Health problems among the aged A
community based study from urban Aligarh Uttar Pradesh India Int J Community
Med Public Health 2016 Feb 3(4)944-47
32 Shankar G Sidenur B A morbidity study of elderly residing in urban field practice
area of SN medical college Bagalkot National Journal of research in community
medicine 2016 Oct-Dec 4(5) 229-34
90
References
33 Salunkhe LR Socio-demographic profile of old age people living in urban amp urban
slum areas in Maharashtra Karad A comparative study J of Evidence based Med
and Hlthcare 2015 Feb 2(5) 513-21
34 Warbhe P Rupesh W Morbidity profile health seeking behaviour and home
environment survey for adaptive measures in geriatric population-Urban community
study International Journal of Medical Research amp Health Sciences 2015 4(4)778-
82
35 Gupta M Borle AL Chhari N Gupta S Assessment of clinico-socioeconomic
status and health-care support among the elderly people aged older than 60 years in
urban population of Bhopal Central India Int J Med Sci Public Health 2015
4558-64
36 Sahukaiah S Shenoy A Vijayakumar BC An epidemiological study of prevalence
of morbidity patterns among geriatric age group in an urban slum of Mumbai Int J
Med Sci Public Health 2015 Jul 4(7)883-87
37 Shubha Davalagi B Angadi N Mahabalaraju DK Morbidity psycho-social profile
and health seeking behaviour of the elderly population in urban slums of Davangere
City India Int J Res Med Sci 2015 Nov 3(11)3288-91
38 Nikumb V Patankar F Behera A A Study of Morbidity Profile among Geriatric
Population in an Urban Area Sch J App Med Sci 2015 3(3)1365-69
91
References
39 Vishnoi BR Solanki SL Singhal G Meharda B Mishra N Morbidity profile of
elderly in urban slum of Udaipur Rajasthan Int J Oral Health Med Res 2015 May
2(1)9-12
40 Subedi L Sah RB Study of the health status of geriatric age group in Chitwan
district of Nepal Journal of Chitwan Medical College 2015 Mar 5(1)11-17
41 Noor S Krishnababu G Prasad KV Health status of Geriatric population in slums
of Rourkela Young Innovative Journal of Medical and Health Science 2015 May
5(3) 92-94
42 Sarode VM Chronic Diseases Related to Aging and Disease Prevention in Slums in
Mumbai Journal of Aging Science 2014 Jan 2 (1)1-6
43 Barman SK Lata K Ram R Ghosh N Sarker G Shahnawaz K A study of
morbidity profile of geriatric population in an urban community of Kishanganj
Bihar India Global Journal of Medicine and Public Health GJMEDPH 2014 3(1)
1-7
44 Nagoor K Srikanth BA Dudekula R Satna K Comparative study of health status
among slum and non-slum elderly population in Kadapa Region South India
Journal of Evolution of Medical and Dental Sciences 2014 Feb 3(5)1298-308
45 Kakkar R Aggarwal P Kandpal SD Bansal SK An Epidemiological study to assess
morbidity profile among geriatric population in District Dehradun Indian Journal of
Community Health 2013 May 25(1)39-44
46 Bhawalkar JS Dhone AB Jethani S Singru S Jadhav SL Adyanthaya S A study of
morbidity profile among geriatric population in an urban area J Evol Med Dent Sci
2013 Sep 9 36(2)6963-7
92
References
47 Sharma D Mazta SR Parashar A Morbidity pattern and health-seeking behaviour of
aged population residing in Shimla hills of north India A cross-sectional study
Journal of family medicine and primary care 2013 Apr2(2)188
48 Singh JP Singh S Kasturwar NB Hassan A Geriatric morbidity profile in an urban
slum Central India Indian Journal of Community Health 2013 Aug 25(2)164-70
49 Thakur RP Banerjee A Nikumb VB Health Problems among the Elderly A Cross
Sectional Study Annals of medical and health sciences research 2013 3(1)19-25
50 Mrinal RS Beena S Pratibha G Pankaj B Srivastava JP Atul B Morbidity Status
and Its Social Determinants among Elderly Population of Lucknow District India
Sch J App Med Sci 2013 1(6)758-64
51 Shraddha K Prashantha B Prakash B Study on morbidity pattern among elderly in
urban population of Mysore Karnataka India International Journal of Medicine and
Biomedical Research 2012 1(3)215-23
52 Thomas V Lavanya KM Morbidity profile and health seeking behaviour of the
elderly in urban slums of Hyderabad Andhra Pradesh India- A cross sectional study
International Journal of Current Research and Review 2012 Oct 1 4(19)174-80
53 Moe S Tha K Naing DK Htike MM Health seeking behaviour of elderly in
Myanmar International Journal of Collaborative Research on Internal Medicine and
Public Health 2012 4(8)1538-44
93
References
54 Bharati DR Pal R Rekha R Yamuna TV Kar S Radjou AN Ageing in
Puducherry South India An overview of morbidity profile Journal of pharmacy amp
bio allied sciences 2011 Oct 3(4)537
55 Bhatt R Gadhvi MS Sonaliya KN Solanki A Nayak H An epidemiological study
of the morbidity pattern among the elderly population in Ahmedabad Gujarat
National Journal of community medicine 2011 Jul 2(2)233-36
56 Srinivasan Krishnamachari Vaz Mario Thomas Tinku Prevalence of health related
disability among community dwelling urban elderly from middle socioeconomic
strata in Bangaluru India Indian Journal of Medical Research 2010 Apr 131(4)
515-21
57 Srivastava K Gupta SC Kaushal SK Chaturvedi M Morbidity profile of elderly a
cross sectional study of urban Agra Indian Journal of Community Health 2010 Jun
22(1)51-55
58 Ladha A Khan R Malik A Khan S Khan B Khan I et al The health seeking
behaviour of elderly population in a poor-urban community of Karachi Pakistan
Journal of the Pakistan Medical Association2009 Feb 59(2) 89-92
59 WHO ICD-10 version 2010 Geneva World Health Organization Available from
URL appswhointclassificationsicd10browse2010en [Accessed on 772017]
60 OpenEpi22OpenEpi (free) download Windows version Available from URL
enfreedownloadmanagerorgWindows-PCOpenEpi-FREEhtml
61 Tandon R Sinhota Parsonrsquos disease of the eye 22edNew Delhi Elsevier 98-100
62 Dhingra P L Dhingra S Disease of ear nose and throat and head and neck surgery
6th ed New Delhi Elsevier 201422
94
References
63 Aziz N Kallur SD Nirmalan PK Implications of the revised consensus body mass
indices for Asian Indians on clinical obstetric practice Journal of clinical and
diagnostic research 2014 May 8(5)OC01
64 Chobanion AV Bakris GL Black HR The seventh report of the joint national
committee on prevention detection evaluation and treatment of high blood pressure
the JNC 7 report JAMA 2003 2892560-72
65 The Seventh Report of the Joint National Committee on Prevention Detection
Evaluation and Treatment of High Blood Pressure (JNC 7) The GuidelinesUS
Department of Health and Human Services National Heart Lung and Blood
Institute Available at URL
httpswwwnhlbinihgovfilesdocsguidelinesjnc7fullpdf [ Accessed on
1282017]
66 Firkin F Chestman C Penington D Rush B De Gruchyrsquos clinical Hematology in
medical practice 5th edition New Delhi Blackwell science Ltd1989 32-47
67 Report of WHO consultation Nutritional Anaemias Geneva Switzerland World
Health Organization TRS-405 1968 Available from URL
whqlibdocwhointtrsWHO_TRS_405pdf [Accessed on 1282017]
68 National Family Health survey (NFHS-4) 2015-16 India Mumbai IIPS
2016Available from URL httpwwwnfhsindiaorg [Accessed on 4072017]
69 The Minimum Wages Act 1948 Ministry of Labour and Employment Government
of India Available from URL httplabourgovincontentinnerpagewagesphp
[Accessed on 1082017]
70 Khairnar M Wadgave U Shimpi P Updated BG Prasad socioeconomic
classification for 2016 Journal of Indian Association of Public Health Dentistry
2016 Oct 1 14(4)469
95
References
71 Tiwari P Tiwari S Mastering practicals community medicine 1st ed New Delhi
India Wolters Kluwer PvtLtd2013161-67
72 Boralingaiah P Bettappa P Kashyap S Prevalence of Psycho-Social Problems
among Elderly in Urban Population of Mysore City Karnataka India Indian journal
of psychological medicine 2012 Oct 34(4)360
96
PATIENT CONSENT FORM JJM MEDICAL COLLEGE DAVANGERE
DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY MEDICINE I the undersigned hereby give my consent
for investigations carried upon me I am satisfied with the information given about this
Clinical study titled ldquoA STUDY ON THE MORBIDITY PATTERN AND HEALTH
SEEKING BEHAVIOR AMONG THE GERIATRIC POULATION IN THE
URBAN FIELD PRACTICE AREA OF JJM MEDICAL COLLEGE
DAVANGERErdquo ldquoconducted by Dr RUCHI DHAR under the guidance of Dr VIDYA
GS Associate Professor I have been informed and explained the risks involved and I
hereby voluntarily and Unconditionally give my consent without any fear or pressure in
mentally sound and conscious state to participate in this study
DATE PATIENTrsquoS SIGNATURE
eEacuteeEacuteJA ordfEacuteEcirczAgravearingQAtildeAiAgraveAuml ordfAgraveAumlordmAacutelaquozAacutearingregAiAgraveAuml zAacuteordfAgravetUEacutegEacute
ryenAacutemiumlethordfEacuteAumlAmiumlDyensiumlPAgraveordfAgraveAumlAumlaringcurrenn ordfEacuteAumlrsup1poundiuml
ordfEacuteEcirczAgravearingQAtildeAiAgraveAumlvAgraveyenAacutecedilAgraveuEacuteUEacuteMbrvbaragraveUEacute yenAgravevAgraveaelig F PEacutefrac14AgraveUEacute cedilAgraveraquo ordfAgraveiAacutergAgraveAumlordfAgrave poundAacutepoundAgraveAuml CAzAgravegEacute
poundAgravepoundAgraveszlig
ordfEacuteEcirczAgravearingQAtildeAiAgraveAumlvAgraveyenAacutecedilAgraveuEacute ordmAacuteUAgraveAElig plusmnAgravecedilAgraveUcircccedilaQvEacuteigraveUEacuteAzAgraveAuml poundAgravepoundAgraveszligMbrvbaragraveUEacuteAiAgraveAumlpoundAgraveAumlszlig
cedilAgraveAEligasup1gAgraveAumlvEacuteUcircAtildepoundEacute J cedilAgraveOumlr Dyensiuml zAgrave ordfEacuteAEligcopyethrn yenAacutearinglpoundiumleth CAqiuml ordmEacutemacriumlUcirc sup1AtildeQAUiuml copyordmEacuteAtildelaquoAiAgraveAumlgiuml Dyensiuml zAgrave fjAiAgraveiAacutenaeligPiuml yenEacuteAEligAtildeyenAgraveAumlaringmacrEacuteAtildemicroAgravepoundiuml Epoundiuml zAgrave Csectethpoundiuml brvbarAtildemacriumlOslash yenAacuteaeligoumlaringQOumlAtildecediliuml JjAiAgraveAuml Dyensiuml ddordfAgraveAumlAuml ordfEacuteEcirczAgravearingQAtildeAiAgraveAuml ordfAgraveAumlordmAacutelaquozAacutearingregAiAgraveAuml zAacuteordfAgravetUEacutegEacute JAsect sup2AtildeparaethPEacuteAiAgraveAumlrAiAgraveAumldegegrave yenAgravejAtildePEacuteeumlUEacute Mfrac14AgraveyenAgravercedilAgraveAumlordfAgrave ordfEacuteEcirczAgravearinggAacutezAgrave qAacute|| gAgraveAumla zAgravesAgravegAgrave ordfAgraveAumlvAgraveAumlUcirc qAacute|| laquozAacutearing fJcediliumlordfAgraveiAacuteUAgraveethzAgraveplusmnAgraveethPAgravegAacutezAgrave yenEacuteAEligaeligAtildeyensEacutecedilAgravegiuml
EordfAgravegAgraveAuml poundAgravepoundAgraveUEacute F vAgraveyenAacutecedilAgraveuEacuteUEacute Mfrac14AgraveyenAgraveqAgraveAumlordfAgrave ordfAgraveAumlAumlpoundAgraveszlig yenAgraveaeligwAiEacuteAEligAzAgraveAuml
CAplusmnAgraveUAgravefrac14AgravepoundAgraveAumlszlig CxAgraveethordfAacuteUAgraveAumlordfAgraveAvEacute wfrac12sup1gAgraveAumlvAacuteUcircgEacuteDzAgraveYacutejAzAgrave poundAacutepoundAgraveAuml poundAgravepoundAgraveszlig
ordfAgraveAumlpoundAgravecedilAacutegEacute AiAgraveiAacuteordfAgraveAringzEacuteAtilde umlsAgraveAiAgraveAuml ordfAgraveAumlvAgraveAumlUcirc AiAgraveiAacutegAgrave MvAacuteUcircAiAgraveAumllaquoregegravezEacute poundAacutepoundAgraveAuml
vAgraveyenAacutecedilAgraveuEacute aQvEacuteigraveUEacuteAEligfrac14AgraveyenAgraveqAgraveregAuml MbrvbaragraveUEacuteAiAgraveAumlpoundAgraveAumlszlig cedilAgraveAEligasup1gAgraveAumlvEacuteUcircAtildepoundEacute
centpoundAacuteAPAgrave gEacuteAEligAtildeVAi
Annexures
ANNEXURE ndashIII
104
Annexures
PROFORMA
I General information
1 NAME
2 AGE
3 GENDER (a) Male (b) Female
4 MARITAL STATUS (a) Unmarried (b) Married (c) Widow Widower
(d) Divorced separated
5 LIVING ARRANGEMENT (a) with spouse (b) Spouse and children
(c) Children only (d) living alone (e) others
6 RELIGION (a) Hindu (b) Muslim (c) Christian (d) Others
7 ADDRESS
8 EDUCATION (a) illiterate (b) Primary school (c) higher primary
(d) secondary school (e)PUC diploma (e) Graduate (f) Postgraduate
9 OCCUPATION (a) professional (b) semi- professional (c) skilled worker
(d) Semi ndashskilled worker (e) unskilled worker (f) unemployed
10 CONTACT NUMBER
11 TYPE OF FAMILY (a) Joint (b) Nuclear (C) three generation
12 TOTAL NUMBER OF FAMILY MEMBERS
13 TOTAL FAMILY INCOME
14 PER CAPITA FAMILY INCOME
15 SOCIO ECONOMIC STATUS (Modified BG Prasad classification) I IIIIIIVV
16 DIET (a) Vegetarian (b) Mixed
17 Sleep (a) Disturbed if yes reason ______________ (b) Not disturbed
18 Bowel Regular Irregular
19 Bladder Regular Irregular
97
Annexures
20 HABITS (a) betel nut (b) tobacco (c) alcohol (d) smoking (e) others
If any of the habits present Duration (since when) _________
Frequency of consumption day_______
IIAssessment of morbidity based on history
1 Whether suffering from any chronic illness like (a) Type 2 DM (b) Hypertension
(c) Bronchial Asthma (d) TB (e) others
2 Whether suffering from cataract currently (a) Yes (b) No
3 Whether operated for cataract (a) Yes (b) No If Yes duration since operation____
4 MUSCULOSKELETAL SYSTEM
Whether the following symptoms are present
(a) Backache (b) Joint pain (c) restricted joint movements (d) pain in calves
(e) Others_________
5 RESPIRATORY SYSTEM
(a) Productive cough (b) non-productive cough (c) nasal discharge (d) breathlessness (e)
sore throat (f) sneezing
6 CARDIOVASCULAR SYSTEM
(a) Palpitations (b) chest pain (c) breathlessness
7 GASTROINTESTINAL SYSTEM
(a) Pain abdomen (b) lose stools (c) constipation (d) flatulence (e) heart burn
(f) Bleeding per rectum
8 EYE AND ADNEXA
(a) Watering (b) diminution of vision (c) redness
9 EAR
(a) Discharge (b) decreased hearing (c) Tinnitus
10 SKIN
(a) Itching (b) skin eruptions (c) scaling (d) pigmentation
98
Annexures
11 GENITO URINARY SYSTEM
(a) Burning micturition (b) increased frequency of micturition
12 GENERAL SYMPTOMS
(a) Fatigue (b) headache (c) fever
13 ANY OTHER COMPLAINTS (a) burning feet (b) swelling in groin
(c) Memory loss (d) insomnia
III Assessment of health seeking behaviour
1 Do you visit a health facility in case of illness (a) Yes (b) No
If yes how much time do you take to visit a health facility an case of an illness
(a) Within 24 hours (b) 24-48 hours (c) more than 48 hours
2 Which type of health facility do you visit
(a) Govt hospital (b) Private practitioners (c) over the counter drugs (e) quacks
Mention the reason for visiting the particular health facility______________________
3 Whether taking regular treatment after diagnosis ________________
If No mention the reason_______________________
4 Whether following the instructions given by the treating doctor
(a) Yes (b) no
5 cost of treatment per month in case of chronic disease
(a) lt100 (b) 100-200 (c) 200-300 (d) 300 and above
6 Person bearing the cost of treatment
(a) Self (b) spouse (c) son (d) daughter (d) outside help
7 Duration to reach the health facility
(a) less than 3o minutes (b) 30 minutes or more
8 Whether going for regular check -ups (a) Yes (b) No
If Yes duration between the check-ups_______
99
Annexures
9 Whether following self- care practices in case of chronic disease like diabetes and hypertension
(a) Yes (b) No
10 In case of healthy individuals whether getting screening tests done (a) Yes (b) No
11 Whether following any dietary modifications (a) yes (b) No
12 Whether any family member accompanies you to the health facility
If yes who (a) Son (b) daughter (c) spouse (d) others
11 Whether the family supports in following specific diet advised by the doctor
(a) Yes (b) No
12 whether family members help in reminding to take regular medication
(a) Yes (b) No
IV Physical examination
1 Personal hygiene status
S NO COMPONENT CONDITION REMARKS
1 Hair
2 Teeth
3 Bath
4 Clothes
5 Washing hand before
eating food
6 Washing hands with soap
and water after ablution
7 Nails
8 Foot wear
Remarks personal hygiene status Good fair poor
100
Annexures
2 MEASUREMENTS
(a) Weight (in Kg) ______ (b) Height (in cm) _____ (c) BMI ______
(d) Waist circumference______ (e) Hip circumference ___________
(f) Waist hip ratio_________
3 GENERAL PHYSICAL EXAMINATION
Pallor Icterus Cyanosis clubbing lymphadenopathy Oedema
Pulse rate Temp Blood Pressure
Respiratory rate
20 Examination of
Eye Oral cavity Ear
Nose Throat
SYSTEMIC EXAMINATION
Cardiovascular system Respiratory system
Per abdomen Central Nervous system
101
MASTER CHART
Annexures
ANNEXURES
International Classification of Diseases (10th Revision)
I Certain infectious and parasitic diseases (A00-B99)
II Neoplasms (C00-D48)
III Diseases of blood and blood forming organs and certain disorders
involving the immune mechanisms (D50-D89)
IV Endocrine nutritional and metabolic diseases (E00-E90)
V Mental and behavioural disorders (F00-F99)
VI Diseases of the nervous system (G00-G99)
VII Diseases of the eye and adnexa (H00-H59)
VIII Diseases of the ear and mastoid process ( H60-H95)
IX Diseases of the circulatory system (I00-I99)
X Diseases of the respiratory system ( J00-J99)
XI Diseases of the digestive system (K00-K93)
XII Diseases of the skin and subcutaneous tissue ( L00-L99)
XIII Diseases of the musculoskeletal system and connective tissue
(M00-M99)
XIV Diseases of the genitourinary system ( N00-N99)
XV Pregnancy childbirth and purperium (O00-O99)
XVI Certain conditions originating in perinatal period (P00-P96)
XVII Congenital malformations deformations and chromosomal
XVIII (S00-T98)
XIX External causes of morbidity and mortality (V01-Y98)
102
Annexures
XX Injury poisoning and certain other consequences of external causes
(S00-T98)
XXI Factors influencing health status and contact with health services
(Z00-Z99)
XXII Codes for special purpose
103
Annexures
105
Annexures
106
Annexures
107
Annexures
PHOTOS
Picture 1 Showing the investigator interviewing the study subject
Picture 2 Showing the investigator interacting with the study subject
108
Annexures
Picture 3 Showing the investigator recording the Blood pressure of the study subject
Picture 4 Showing the investigator auscultating the study subject
109
Annexures
110
NCD- Non Communicable Disease
NCsrC- National Council for Senior Citizens
NGO - Non -Governmental Organization
NPOP- National Policy for Older Persons
RMP- Registered Medical Practitioner
SDGs ndash Sustainable Development Goals
SES - Socio-Economic Status
TB ndash Tuberculosis
TPB- Theory of Planned Behaviour
TRA- Theory of Reasoned Action
UN - United Nations
UHTC- Urban Health Training center
URTI- Upper Respiratory Tract Infection
WHO - World Health organization
ix
LIST OF TABLES
Table No
Title Page No
1 Percentage share of elderly population (aged 60 years and above) in
total population by sex in India
6
2 Size of elderly population (aged 60+) and their share in total
population in major states of India in 2011
7
3 List of areas covered under the UHTC of JJM Medical College
Davangere
29
4 WHO Categorization of Body Mass index (BMI) for Asians 34
5 JNC VII Classification of Blood pressure 35
6 Socio-economic status (SES)- As per modified BG Prasad
Classification
37
7 Age and sex wise distribution of the study subjects 39
8 Distribution of the study subjects based on religion 40
9 Distribution of the study subjects based on Educational status 41
10 Distribution of the study subjects based on occupation 42
11
Distribution of the study subjects based on socio-economic status
(Modified BG Prasad classification 2016)
43
12 Distribution of the study subjects based on their marital status 44
13 Distribution of the study subjects based on the type of family 45
14 Distribution of morbidity pattern of the study subjects based on ICD
10 classification of diseases
47
xiii
15
Distribution of the study subjects based on morbidity of the
Musculoskeletal system
49
16
Distribution of the study subjects based on morbidity of the eye
and adnexa
50
17 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the oral cavity 51
18
Distribution of study subjects based on endocrine nutritional and
metabolic disorders
52
19 Distribution of the study subject based on disease of the circulatory
system
53
20 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the respiratory
system
54
21
Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the digestive
system
55
22
Distribution the study subjects based on disease of the Skin and
subcutaneous tissue
56
23 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the ear 57
24
Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the
genitourinary system
58
25
Distribution of the study subjects based on diseases of the Nervous
system
59
26 Association between morbidity pattern of the study subjects and
their age group
60
xiv
27
Association between morbidity pattern of the study subjects and
their occupation
62
28
Association between morbidity pattern of the study subjects and
their religion
64
29 Reasons cited by the study subjects for not seeking healthcare in
case of an illness
67
30 Distribution of the study subjects based on the type of health facility
visited
68
31 Association between gender and health care seeking behavior of the
study subjects
69
32 Association between educational status and health care seeking
behaviour of the study subjects
70
33 Distribution of study subjects according to frequency of visits to a
health care facility
71
xv
LIST OF FIGURES
Figure No
Title Page No
1 Proportion of elderly in the Indian population by age groups
1961-2001
6
2 Pathophysiology of health issues in geriatrics 10
3 Predicting health behaviour with social cognition models 13
4 Health belief model components and linkages 15
5 Maps showing the location of Davangere district and the
area where the UHTC is located
27
6 Map showing the Urban field practice area of JJM medical college
28
7 Age and sex wise distribution of the study subjects 39
8 Distribution of the study subjects based on religion 40
9 Distribution of the study subjects based on Educational status 41
10 Distribution of study subjects based on their occupation 42
11
Distribution of study subjects based on their occupation
43
12 Distribution of the study subjects based on their marital status 44
13 Distribution of the study subjects based on the type of family 45
14 Distribution of the study subjects based on the BMI 46
15 Distribution of morbidity pattern of the study subjects based on
ICD 10 classification of diseases
48
16 Distribution of the study subjects based on the visit to health
facility in case of an illness
66
xvi
ABSTRACT Background
According to census 2011 the elderly population aged 60 years and above account for 8
of total population and is projected to rise to 124 by the year 2026 Health status is an
important factor that has a significant impact on quality of life The elderly are one of the
most vulnerable and high risk groups in terms of health status and their health seeking
behaviour is crucial in any society
Objectives
1 To study the morbidity pattern among the geriatric population in the urban field
practice area of JJM Medical college Davangere
2 To assess the health seeking behaviour of the elderly residing in the study area
Methods It was a community based cross sectional study which was conducted in the urban field
practice area of JJM Medical College Davangere The total study subjects were 440
individuals aged 60 years and above Data was collected using a predesigned pre-tested
and semi- structured questionnaire Height weight and blood pressure were measured
and recorded Data was analyzed by using MS Excel and Open-Epi Info software
version 22 Statistical test employed was chi-square and Fishers exact test x
Results and Conclusion
In our study it was found that the majority of the subjects (368) were in the age group
of 60-64 years 525 were illiterate 511 were unemployed and 49 belonged to class
IV socio economic status The study revealed that the some of the common morbidities
among the geriatric subjects were the disorders of the musculoskeletal system (714)
eye and adnexa (497) oral cavity (329) endocrine nutritional and metabolic
disorders (329)etc some disorders like cataract dental caries constipation and
increased frequency of micturition were more common among males whereas disease
like anemia and hypertension were more common among females A significant
association was found between some of the morbidities and socio demographic
determinants like age occupation and religion
Any degree of formal schooling was found to be associated with better health seeking
behavior Majority of the subjects (58) visited a Government health facility in case of
an illness and the main reason that was stated for not visiting a health facility was that
they suffered from mild discomfort (444) and did not consider it necessary to visit a
health facility
Key words Geriatric urban behaviour morbidity
xi
Introduction
INTRODUCTION
ldquoA STUDY ON THE MORBIDITY PATTERN AND HEALTH SEEKING BEHAVIOUR AMONG THE GERIATRIC POPULATION IN THE URBAN FIELD
PRACTICE AREA OF JJM MEDICAL COLLEGE DAVANGERErdquo
All countries of the world are experiencing population ageing Ageing is a result of
decreasing mortality and most importantly declining fertility The global share of older
people (aged 60 years and above) has increased from 92 per cent in 1990 to 117 in
2013 and will continue to grow as a proportion of the world population reaches 211 by
20501
The lsquoNational Policy for Older Personsrsquo was adopted by the Government of India in
January 1999 and it defines a lsquosenior citizenrsquo or lsquoelderlyrsquo as a person who is aged 60 years
or above Ageing is a progressive process associated with declines in structure and
function impaired maintenance and repair systems increased susceptibility to disease and
death2
In 2015 Worldwide there were 901 million people aged 60 years or over It is
projected that their number will grow to 14 billion in 2030 which is the target date for the
SDGs and to 21 billion by 2050 There will be growth in the number of older persons aged
60 years and above between 2015 and 2030 This increase is projected to be especially
significant global phenomenon and virtually every country in the world will experience a
substantial increase including the less developed regions3 The increased life expectancy has
led to challenges in health care management The elderly suffer from various diseases which
include non-communicable disease (NCDs) like diabetes hypertension coronary heart
disease and other disorders like osteoarthritis stroke dementia osteoporosis cancer
1
Introduction enlarged prostate depression and cataract related blindness In the coming years there will
be a phenomenal growth in the population of the elderly while the family size will reduce
The disintegration of the joint family and women moving out of the household has led to the
absence of traditional caregivers for the elderly who are already a vulnerable group4
The most common cause of health problems in the old aged people is chronic diseases
Most of these problems can be prevented or delayed by engaging in healthy behaviours
Even in the advanced years of life physical activity and good nutrition can have
effective benefits on health and well-being Many health problems of old age can be
effectively managed if they are detected early enough5 The National Policy for Older
Persons was announced by the Government of India in the year 1999 The Constitution of
India under Article 41 mandates the well-being of senior citizens ldquoThe state shall
within the limits of its economic capacity and development make effective provision
for securing the right to public assistance in case of old aged peoplerdquo 6
National Council for Older Persons (NCOP) has been reconstituted and renamed as
National Council for Senior Citizens (NCSrC) in order to have a definite structure and also
regional balancing the NCOP advises the Central and State Governments on a broad range
of issues related to welfare of senior citizens and enhancement of their quality of life The
NCSrc meets at least twice a year7 The elderly suffer from multiple medical as well as
psychological problems There has already been some pioneering work on the elderly in
India but a lot more remains to be done There is an urgent need to pay attention
towards the medical and socio-economic problems that are being faced by the elderly
people in India and thus formulate strategies to bring about an improvement in their
quality of life8 The Health seeking behaviour is influenced by various factors which
include the individual self diseases and the availability and accessibility of health
2
services It is important to have knowledge regarding the health seeking behaviour of
individuals for designing health care policies and programmes so that all the possible
difficulties with early diagnosis and effective treatment can be identified and appropriate
interventions can be implemented9 As already stated the elderly are a vulnerable group as
there are psychological as well as physiological changes with increasing age and it is
difficult to cope up with the problems of ageing Some of the most common problems in old
age are cardiovascular problems arthritis respiratory problems blood pressure and so on
Therefore the study of the health status of elderly morbid conditions perceptions about
it is important to note and the health care of the elderly becomes very important since they
are more prone to illness than young people and are also more prone to domestic and other
accidents Their health and treatment seeking behaviour are most important for the
formulation of welfare programmes of the country 10
Hence this study was taken up in the urban field practice area of JJM Medical College
Davangere to assess the morbidity pattern and health seeking behaviour of the geriatric
subjects
3
Objectives
OBJECTIVES
1 To study the morbidity pattern among the geriatric population in the urban field
practice area of JJM Medical college Davangere
2 To assess the health seeking behaviour of the elderly residing in the study area
4
Review of literature
vii
REVIEW OF LITERATURE
1 Definition Geriatrics or clinical gerontology Is the term used for the care of the aged 11 The United Nations uses 60 years and above to refer to older people the same is also used
by demographers However in many developed countries the age of 65 is used as the
reference point for older persons 12
Elderly are classified in to 3 groups 13
Young old Persons in the age group of 60 years to 74 years
Old old Persons in the age group of 75 years to 84 years
Oldest old Persons above the age of 85 yrs
2 Demography of the ageing population in India
The UN defines a country as ldquoAgeingrdquo or ldquoGreying Nationrdquo where the
proportion of people over 60 reaches 7 percent to total population By 2011 India has
exceeded that proportion (80 percent) and is expected to reach 126 percent in 2025
The Indian population has increased from 361 million in 1951 to 1027 billion in 2001
and further to 121 billion in 2011 Simultaneously the number of older people has
increased from 19 million (ie 4 percent of total population) to 77 million and
further to roughly 93 million (ie 75 percent of the total) during the same time
span 14
5
Review of literature
Figure1 proportion of elderly in the Indian population by age groups 1961-2001 14
Table 1 Percentage share of elderly population (aged 60 years and above) in total
population by sex in India 15
Years Male Female Total Rural Urban
1961 55 58 56 58 47
1971 59 60 60 62 50
1981 64 66 65 68 54
1991 67 68 68 71 57
2001 71 78 75 77 67
2011 77 84 80 81 79
2004-05 69 75 72 73 70
2007-08 73 77 75 76 72
6
Review of literature
The rise in population of males was more modest from 55 percent to 71 percent while for
females there had been a steep rise from 58 percent to 78 percent during five decadal
Censuses from 1961 to 2001 In 2011 the elderly population accounted for 80 percent of
total population For males it was marginally lower at 77 percent while for females it was
84 percent According to NSSO surveys the proportion of elderly population in rural areas
was 73 percent during 2004-05 and increased up to 76 percent in 2007-08 While on the
other hand in urban areas the proportion of elderly population rose from 70 percent to 72
percent during the corresponding period It has been observed that the percentage share of
elderly to total population remained higher in rural areas than in urban areas15
Table2 Size of elderly population (aged 60+) and their share in total population in major states of India in 201115
All India and selected major states
Proportion of elderly in total population of State
Male Female Total Andhra Pradesh 83 94 88 Bihar 72 67 70 Gujarat 76 90 83 Haryana 66 76 71 Himachal Pradesh 104 103 104 Karnataka 79 89 84 Kerala 118 133 126 Madhya Pradesh 68 74 71 Maharashtra 88 97 93 Orissa 91 95 93 Punjab 91 100 95 Rajasthan 66 79 72 Tamil Nadu 102 109 105 Uttar Pradesh 66 71 68 West Bengal 82 82 82 All India 77 84 80
7
Review of literature
3 MORBIDITY PATTERN AMONG THE ELDERLY
Physiological Decline and Consequences of increasing age
Ageing i s a process of decline in biological functions affecting most physical
Systems The following systems are affected by ageing
(a) Atrophy of the Taste Buds and Loss of Teeth
With the increasing age the taste buds of the tongue get atrophied and as a result the
preference for food alters significantly There is also a considerable loss of teeth causing
difficulties in chewing food
(b) Changes in the Gastrointestinal Tract
As the age advances the walls of the intestine get atrophied and the motility is
markedly reduced (lazy intestine) The digestive enzymes secreted by the intestine are
also reduced Hence the partly digested food stays in the intestine for a longer period
As a result the common complaint of the elderly person is gas formation (flatulence)
and constipation
(c) Respiratory System
As the age advance there is progressive fibrosis of the lungs leading to reduced
oxygenation of the lungs and breathing difficulties
(d) Kidney and genitourinary System
The kidneys get smaller in size and the power of the kidneys to filter out the unwanted
waste products from the body is diminished The total amount of urine becomes less in
old age and thus the waste products are not adequately excreted from the body
8
Review of literature
(e) Urinary Bladder
Urinary bladder gets smaller in size due to shrinkage and as a result the accumulation
of urine even of a small amount leads to an urge for urination With increase in age
the valve in the bladder which controls the exit of urine from the bladder to urethra
gets atrophied and weak Involuntary leakage of urine occurs in case the bladder is full
or due to increase of pressure on bladder on sneezing or even on laughing a condition
known as urinary incontinence Incontinence is a common complaint of elder females
(f) Heart and Circulatory System
The blood vessels get rigid and quite often the vessel walls become rough with the
deposition of solid matters consisting mostly of cholesterol The heart muscles get weaker
and power to send blood throughout the body through the circulatory system gets less and
less powerful The most dangerous effect on heart is coronary heart disease especially
coronary thrombosis
(g) Muscular system
The muscles in the body get gradually atrophied with ageing and especially those
small muscles which are necessary for quick reflex action The elderly person can quite
be capable of working like a normal person and can undertake activities which require
big muscles of legs and arms But when it comes to quick movement which needs small
muscles for quick reflex movements these functions are impaired causing accidents
like slipping on wet floor of the bathroom
(h) Brain
With ageing the size of the brain gets smaller and the weight also becomes less This
however does not interfere with the function of the brain However in general the brain
cells and its fibers which carry impulses from brain to the system and upwards get
9
Review of literature
degenerated The most glaring manifestation of ageing affecting the brain is
forgetfulness and in simple terms it is inability of brain to recall the past experience
However this is common in all elderly persons
(i ) Bones
The bones become porous and fragile as age advances especially in elderly females This
condition is known as osteoporosis and leads to sustaining of fractures even after a minor
fall16
Figure 2 pathophysiology of health issues in geriatrics17
The common disease that the geriatric population suffers from are type 2 diabetes
coronary heart disease hypertension stroke chronic obstructive pulmonary disease
10
Review of literature
Alzheimerrsquos disease osteoarthritis osteoporosis prostatic hypertrophy cataracts macular
degeneration cancer etc and at the same time they are vulnerable to infections involving
respiratory (including TB) urinary and digestive tract17
In India the elderly people suffer from dual medical problems ie communicable and
nonndash communicable diseases There is also impairment of special sensory functions like
vision and hearing A decline in immunity and age-related physiological changes leads to
an increased burden of communicable diseases in the elderly A report by Indian Council
of Medical Research (ICMR) on the chronic morbidity profile in the elderly states that
hearing impairment is the most common morbidity followed by visual impairment
However different studies show varied results in the morbidity pattern18
Major chronic conditions affecting older people worldwide 19
Cardiovascular diseases (such as coronary heart disease) Diabetes Mellitus
Hypertension Stroke Cancer
Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease
Musculoskeletal conditions (such as arthritis and osteoporosis)
Mental health conditions (mostly dementia and depression)
Blindness and visual impairment
11
Review of literature
Health seeking behaviour
1 Definition
There is no common definition agreed upon by sociologists in any sociology literature
Different definitions may be used in different studies despite referring to the same activity
Sociology and literature assume that health seeking behaviour is influenced by the various
factors which include individual self or the individual diseases present and also the
availability and accessibility of health services Being dependent on these determinants and
their interactions it can be said that health care seeking behaviour is a very complex
outcome of various factors which operate at individual family and community level20
Health Seeking Behavior (HSB) refers to decision or an action taken by an individual to
maintain attain or regain good health and to prevent illness The decisions which are
made encompasses all available health care options like visiting a public or private and
modern or traditional health facility self-medication and use of home remedies or not to
utilize the available health services etc
Determining the health care seeking behavior is very important to provide a need
based health care services to the population Visiting official channels in a formally
recognized health care system has been considered as the desired Health seeking behaviour
Health seeking behavior is influenced by multiple factors including availability quality and
price of services and also social groups health views residences and personal features of the
users Peoplersquos choice of health care differs in socio demographic socio-economic and
cultural compositions and this has an effect on their health seeking behavior Urban dwellers
are generally believed to be open to new ideas and willing to try certain things on a trial and
error basis21
12
Review of literature
Health seeking behaviours two approaches
(a) Health seeking behaviours utilization of the system
This approach focuses on the actions which are taken to rectify perceived ill health and
the type of health care facility which is utilized by the people There is data which
suggests that the people visit more traditional healers and unofficial medical channels
this should be prevented and the emphasis s h o u l d b e on encouraging people to opt
first for the official channels
(b) Health seeking behaviours the process of illness response
This approach considers the factors which enable or prevent people from making
healthy choices either i n their lifestyle behaviours or use of medical care and
treatment22
Figure 3 Predicting health behaviour with social cognition models 22
13
Review of literature
2 Health belief Model of health seeking behaviour
Since lsquoHealth seekingrsquo is a conditioned behaviour any attempt which is made to
encourage people to seek health care definitely requires an understanding of their
motivation for such behaviour Only through a deeper understanding of the intricate
factors shaping behavioural practices can health promotion programmes and or
interventions successfully be introduced into the realities of the peoplersquos lives to bring
about changes in health behaviour
Behaviour change theories and models such as the Health Belief Model (HBM)
Theory of Reasoned Action (TRA) Theory of Planned Behaviour (TPB) and the
Trans theoretical model have been widely applied in public health in an attempt to
explain or predict health seeking behaviours Their use enables identification and
understanding of peoplersquos health-seeking behaviour beyond their knowledge attitudes
and practices
HBM is a health specific behavioural cognitive model This model is based on the
idea that people are more likely to change their behaviour and adhere to treatments
if they have the following perceptions (i) have a perception that they are at risk of
contracting the disease (perceived susceptibility) (ii) perception that the disease
might have an unfavorable outcome (perceived severity) (iii) perceive that the
proposed health behaviour to be both effective and practical (perceived benefits)
(iv) perceive the barriers to adopting the behaviour to be minimal (perceived
barriers)(v) perceive themselves to have the ability of applying and practicing the
specific behaviour proposed (perceived self-efficacy) and (vi) they have the cues
for motivating their actions such as internal cues (pain symptoms past experiences)
or external cues (advice from friends relatives and mass media campaigns) (cues to
14
Review of literature
action) The specificity of the HBM to health has made it suitable for use in
understanding and explaining the behaviour as well as health outcomes and this may also
explain its wider use in public health2 3
Figure 4 Health belief model components and linkages 23
3 Factors influencing health seeking behaviour
The factors affecting the health seeking behaviours are seen in various contexts which
include physical socio-economic cultural and political factors Therefore the utilization of
a health care system whether public or private formal or non- formal may depend on socio-
demographic factors social structures level of education cultural beliefs and practices and
some other factors like gender discrimination status of women economic and political
systems environmental conditions and the disease pattern and health care system itself also
have an impact on the health seeking behaviour24
15
Review of literature
REVIEW OF RELATED STUDIES
A study done by Sanjay Polisetty and Madhavi Seepana (2017) on the morbidity profile
of elderly individuals in urban Visakhapatnam revealed that of the 270 study participants
about 996 suffered from either some form of acute or chronic morbidity More than 70
of individuals suffered from eye problems of which most common problem was cataract
seen in 60 About 304 had difficulties in chewing and 256 had difficulty in hearing
Hypertension was present in 49 of individuals and 742 of Diabetics were also found to
be hypertensive25
A study done by Swapnil Jain et al (2016) on Morbidity pattern among geriatric
population in urban field practice area of a district in Maharashtra revealed 653 suffered
from hearing impairment 62 were anemic 462 had hypertension 423 had joint
pain 41 had dental problems 38 7 had cataract and 318 had chronic bronchitis It
was seen that 81 of the subjects had multiple morbidities 26
A study done by Rajat Das Gupta et al (2016) in an urban area of Bangladesh on Morbidity
pattern and health-seeking behavior among the senior citizens revealed that of the 384 study
participants 968 were suffering from at least one medical problem The commonest was
musculoskeletal problems in 8411 followed by eye problems in 8125 It was found that
all the respondents sought treatment for their health problems 33 respondents went to
Government hospitals to seek medical help 6927 respondents took prescribed
medications and 567 were satisfied with their treatment 27
16
Review of literature
A study done by Md Alam Naushad et al (2016) on Morbidity pattern and health
seeking behavior in elderly population of Raipur City Chhattisgarh revealed that the
prevalence of morbidity among elderly was 9531 Out of total morbid population some
chronic illness was present in 7049 Gastro intestinal system was involved in 8262
followed by eye in 7983 and Cardiovascular system in 5245 It was found that 3552
of the subjects sought treatment from private registered practitioners 28
A study done by Sribas Goswami and Manjari Sahai (2016) in Raipur city on Morbidity
Pattern in elderly Population revealed that out of total study population of 640 elderly
subjects 610 (9531) suffered from some morbidity Prevalence among females was
9892 whereas among males it was 9026 Out of various agencies 3552 subjects
were utilizing private facility followed by 2785 who were utilizing Government agency
2631 visited quacks and 1030 were taking treatment from other source 29
A study done by Harsh Bardhan et al (2016) on the Morbidity profile of elderly population
in Ghaziabad district revealed that in geriatric population 5008 suffered from
musculoskeletal problems 5877 had dental problems and impairment of vision was seen
in 5561 The overall prevalence of diabetes and heart disease were 10 and 122
respectively 236 subjects reported the problem of loneliness and depression
forgetfulness was also reported by 3296 As far as treatment seeking behavior is
concerned approach of elderly is quite different for different morbidities The main source
of treatment for morbidities such as hypertension respiratory urinary GIT-related and
musculoskeletal problems was quacks 30
17
Review of literature
A study done by Mohammad Maharoof et al (2016) on the health problems among
the aged in Urban Aligarh UP revealed that of the 225 study subjects 782 had cataract
followed by depression in 356 refractive error in 276 loco-motor problem in 213
and hearing loss in 138 The prevalence of hearing loss was significantly related to gender
as it was higher among females with 181 compared to males in whom it was 6931
A study done by Gowri Shankar and Bhayalaxmi Sidenur (2016) on morbidity of
elderly residing in an urban area of Bagalkot revealed that the most common morbidity was
Cataract seen in 2875 followed by musculoskeletal problems in 2813 and 2313
were known hypertensive Both diabetes mellitus and hypertension was observed in 10 of
the study subjects32
A study done by Leena Rahul Salunkhe (2015) on socio-demographic profile of old
age people living in urban amp urban slum areas in Maharashtra Karad revealed that 504
and 42 elderly suffered from arthritis in an urban area and a slum respectively Number of
diabetics were higher in urban (14) than urban slum (35) 301 of subjects from urban
area suffered from hypertension compared to 161 from urban slums Upper Respiratory
Infections was more in slum dwellers (196) than people residing in urban area (7) Acid
peptic diseases were found in 168 study subjects in urban area and 154 in slum area 33
In a study done by Warbhe Priyanka A and Warbhe Rupesh (2015) on morbidity
profile health seeking behaviour and home environment survey of the elderly in an urban
slum community it was found that 941 had 1-3 morbidities 41 had 4-6 morbidities
373 gave a history of fall and 314 had history of fracture 136 subjects had been
18
Review of literature
operated for cataract 168 had undergone a procedure for fracture and10 had undergone
a dental procedure 542 went to Urban health center (UHC) and Government hospitals for
treatment and 786 received both allopathic and Ayurvedic treatment34
A study done by Man Mohan Gupta et al (2015) on Assessment of Clinico-
socioeconomic status and health-care support among the elderly people aged older than 60
years in urban population of Bhopal revealed that 353 subjects received treatment for
their morbidities from the Government hospitals whereas 267 from private
clinichospital About 653 study subjects presented with complaints and morbidity The
common morbidities which were found in the subjects were fatigue (487) backache
(353) Obesity (393) and hypertension (247)35
In a study done by Shilpa Shaukaiah et al (2015) on prevalence of morbidity pattern
among geriatric age group in an urban slum of Mumbai it was found that body ache was the
most commonly reported symptom by 290 followed by visual problems in 2318 joint
pain in 2181 indigestion in 2045 and backache in 2045 subjects36
A study done by Shubha Davalagi B et al (2015) on morbidity psycho-social profile and
health seeking behavior of the elderly population in urban slums of Davangere City revealed
that the most common morbidity which was present in the study subjects was
musculoskeletal problems in 46 psychosocial problems were present in 31 and
respiratory problems in 23 Majority of the elderly (56) utilized government
institutions for treatment of chronic disease and 47 for treatment of acute disease The
elderly population had financial constraints and lack of accessibility in seeking health care37
19
Review of literature
A study done by Vandana Nikumb et al ( 2015) on morbidity Profile among Geriatric
Population in an Urban Area of Navi Mumbai revealed that 9312 elderly were morbid and
with increasing age the number of morbidities was found to be increasing In this study it
was found that the most common morbidity was psychosocial problems which include
stress which was present in 594 subjects followed by musculoskeletal problems in
556 and eye problems like diminished vision mostly due to cataract in 463
Hypertension dental problems respiratory problems ENT problems (hearing impairment)
and endocrine disorders like diabetes accounted for 281 219 119 106 and10
respectively38
A study done by Vishnoi BR et al (2015) on Morbidity Profile of Elderly in Urban
Slum of Udaipur Rajasthan revealed that 61 of the study subjects had impaired vision
followed by 25 who had hypertension 1533 suffered from insomnia 1467 had
anemia and 14 suffered from gastrointestinal problems The condition of females was
worse compared to males39
In a study done by L Subedhi and RB Sah (2015) on the health status of geriatric age
group in Chitwan district of Nepal it was found that of the 300 study subjects 44 had
Ophthalmic problems 43 had GIT problems 33 had CVS problems 23 had ENT
problems 1567 had metabolic disorders and 533 had mental disorders The study
highlighted a high prevalence of morbidity and health related problems in the geriatric age
group40
20
Review of literature
A study done by Sofia Noor et al (2015) on health status of geriatric population in slums
of Rourkela revealed that the morbidities among the elderly that were found to be significant
were hypertension decreased visual acuity urinary problems and insomnia Apart from
systemic morbidities 91 of the elderly also complained of fragility which includes
complex physiological deterioration and unexplained weight loss41
In a study conducted by VM Sarode (2014) on Chronic Diseases Related to Ageing and
Disease Prevention in Slums in Mumbai it was found that there were highly significant
disorders among aged women related to Skin lesion and super infection Untreated bacterial
pharyngitis acute rheumatic fever while disorders among aged men were related to
hypertension Illicit drug use diabetes and asthma It was found that 49 of elderly males
and 45 of elderly females had not sought any treatment for their illness Of the people who
had sought treatment 93 elderly males and 92 of elderly females had taken treatment
from Government hospital42
A study conducted by Sanjeev Kumar Barman et al (2014) on morbidity profile of
geriatric population in an urban slum of Kishnganj Bihar revealed that the prevalence of
anemia cataract and hypertension were quite high 6375 6125 and 5063
respectively Loss of income amp occupation along with a feeling of neglect from the family
members were the common problems among the elderly It was also found that morbidities
like arthritis loss of teeth amp dental caries along with depression had a significant association
with sex age amp educational status of the study subjects43
21
Review of literature
A study done by Khadervali Nagoor et al (2014) on the health status of elderly
population in an urban area of Kadapa revealed that out of the 200 elderly persons studied
Visual problem due to cataract and refractive errors were present in 72 of the study
subjects followed by pain in joints in 595 gastrointestinal problems in 46 and dental
problems in 44 Other morbidities were hypertension in 42 genitourinary problems in
25 dermatological problems in 235 and psychological problems in 1644
A study done by Kakkar R et al (2013) on morbidity profile among geriatric population
in District Dehradun revealed that the working geriatric group was healthy as compared to
those who were retired Hypertension was the commonest morbidity among all age groups
In the age group of 60-70 years the following morbidities were seen hypertension (306)
followed by diabetes (153) arthritis (14) CVS morbidities (14) cataract (96) and
BPH (83) Among 71-80 years age group Hypertension (287) followed by arthritis
(167) cataract (157) Diabetes (111) BPH (111) and CVS morbidities (93)45
In a study done by Bhawalkar JS et al (2013) on morbidity profile among geriatric
population in an urban area of Pune it was found that Musculoskeletal disorder was the
most common (4331) followed by eye problems (3722) and hypertension (137)It
was seen that 43 elderly population had some health problem but only 8 visited the
health facilities Among them 6 visited private practitioners and only 18 went to
municipal hospitals It was found that only 2322 elderly were taking any medications and
the most commonly used drug was anti-inflammatory drugs 2323 followed by
antihypertensive drugs 136746
22
Review of literature
A study conducted by Deepak Sharma et al (2013) on morbidity pattern and health-
seeking behavior of aged population residing in Shimla revealed that the following
morbidities were present in the study subjects hypertension was the commonest (56)
followed by Musculoskeletal problems (535) Dental problems (27) cataract (23)
anemia (15) and acid peptic disease (175) 658 of the subjects were seeking
treatment for their health problems Majority of the older people preferred allopathic
medicine (812) followed by Ayurvedic medicines (113) and homeopathic medicine
(73) for their health problems Most of the older persons preferred going to a
CHCGovernment hospital for treatment for their illness There was considerable use of
over-the-counter drug by125 of the people 47
A study done by JP Singh et al (2013) on Geriatric morbidity profile in an urban slum of
Nagpur central India revealed that the most common morbidity identified in the study
population was anemia (9650) followed by hypertension (345) arthritis (3225)
cataract (21) and diabetes (1775) More than 2 morbidities were present in 325 of
the study subjects followed by four morbidities in 3125 and two morbidities in 23548
A study conducted by RP Thakur et al (2013) on the health problems of the elderly in
central India revealed that among the elderly residing in the urban areas 384 of the urban
elderly had both dental problems and arthritis followed by anemia in 348 hypertension in
266 cataract in 252 and diabetes mellitus in 157 The prevalence of self-reported
depression was 672 among the urban female elderly when compared to 397 among the
urban females49
23
Review of literature
A study done by Mrinal Ranjan Srivastav et al (2013) on Morbidity Status and its
Social determinants among elderly population of Lucknow revealed that the most common
morbidity among the urban population was eye problems which affected 516 males and
67 females followed by CVS problems in 363 males and 395 females and GIT
problems in 315males and 382 females50
A study done by Shraddha K et al (2012) on morbidity pattern among elderly in urban
population of Mysore revealed that out of the 526 study subjects 486 suffered from the
disease of the eye and adnexa followed by 384 who suffered from endocrine and
metabolic disorders 331 suffered from the disease of the circulatory system 323 had
disease of the oral cavity and salivary glands and 302 had disease of the musculoskeletal
system 51
A study done by Vimala Thomas et al (2012) on morbidity profile and health seeking
behaviour of the elderly in urban slums of Hyderabad revealed that hypertension was the
most common morbidity in 469 followed by Arthritis in 302 Diabetes in 265
respiratory problems in 243 and Cataract in 21 For out-patient treatment 472 visited
private sectors 303 Government facility 25 RMP and 06 AYUSH clinics For in-
patient treatment 198 visited private institutions 16 visited Government institutions
while 642 did not visit either52
24
Review of literature
A study done by Soe Moe et al (2012) on health seeking behaviour of elderly in
Myanmar revealed that 35 of the male elderly perceived that they were having good
health status whereas 229 of them perceived having a poor health status 343 of female
elderly perceived that they were having good health status while 24 of them perceived
having a poor health About 49 of the elderly went to rural health center for treatment
followed by 33 who went to private practitioners 15 visited hospitals and 3 went to
more than one place for treatment53
A study done by Dharamvir Ranjan Bharati et al (2011) in Puducherry revealed that in
the urban areas about 707 of the study subjects had anemia followed by 537 who had
visual impairment and hypertension and 532 suffered from diabetes mellitus It was seen
that On univariate analysis the risk of diabetes mellitus was significantly higher among
elderly from urban areas than that among elderly from rural areas and significantly lower
risk in elderly from below poverty line than in those belonging to normal (not below poverty
line)54
A study done by Rajashree Bhat et al (2011) on the morbidity pattern among the elderly
population in Ahmedabad revealed that most common morbidity of elderly was the
problems of loco-motor system (486) followed by vision (427) and hypertension
(344) In this study only 37 of elderly had psychosocial problems55
A study done by Krishnamachari Srinivasan et al (2010) in an urban area of Bangalore
revealed that 494 subjects had hypertension 323 had diabetes 281 had arthritis
279 suffered from Genitourinary and cardiovascular disease It was observed that about
25
Review of literature
49 of the respondents made less than three physician visits and 13 were hospitalized for
health related problems during the past one year 56
A study done by Kajal Srivastava et al (2010) on the morbidity pattern of the elderly in
urban Agra revealed that 9529 of the elderly were morbid in the slum areas The most
common morbidity which was seen among the elderly people residing in urban slums was
anemia which was seen in 3843 followed by cataract in 298 arthritis in 2431 and
hearing impairments in 2157The system wise distribution of the morbidity pattern
showed the most common systemic involvement was visual disorders 5216 followed by
musculoskeletal system 4784 and the gastrointestinal system 4314 The number of
morbidities was found to be increasing with age and this association with age was
statistically significant57
A study done by Abdullah Ladha et al (2009) on the health seeking behaviour of elderly
population in a poor-urban community of Karachi Pakistan revealed that 164 of the
elderly people were Diabetic and 301 had Hypertension The Common symptoms that
prompted elderly of to seek health care were fever (612) generalized body aches (434)
and cough (404) About 614 responders reported factors which deterred them from
seeking health care out of which 62 reported financial constraint as the commonest factor
Deterrence from seeking health care was associated with illiteracy and living alone58
26
Methodology METHODOLOGY
The study was conducted in the urban field practice area of JJM Medical college
Davangere The city of Davangere is situated in the central part of Karnataka state
265 km north of the state capital Bengaluru along the national highway number 4
Figure 5 Maps showing the location of Davangere district and the area where the
UHTC is located
27
Methodology
Figure 6 Map showing the Urban field practice area of JJM medical college
28
Methodology
Table 3 List of areas covered under the UHTC of JJM Medical
College Davangere
Areas covered Total population Bethur road 1374 Hedge nagar 1213 Mehboob nagar 3042 Mustafa nagar A 2093 B D layout A 1084 Mustafa nagar B 1127 Mahavir nagar 930 Muddabovi colony 1094 Maganhalli 1221 Tippu nagar 968 B D layout B 1717 Batti layout 1080
STUDY AREA The study was conducted in the urban field practice area of JJM
Medical College Davangere which consists of 12 areas with a total population of
16943
STUDY DESIGN Cross sectional study
STUDY POPULATION Persons aged 60 years and above
Total Population Covered 16943
29
Methodology
INCLUSION CRITERIA subjects aged 60 years and above living in the study area
for more than one year duration
EXCLUSION CRITERIA Subjects who we r e no t w i l l i ng t o pa r t i c ipa t e i n
t he s t udy
STUDY PERIOD 1 year from 1st December 2015 to 30th November 2016
SAMPLE SIZE As quoted by Manmohan Gupta et al 35 in the studies done in various
parts of India the prevalence of morbidity in the geriatric population ranges from 31-80
Considering the prevalence of morbidity to be about 50 in the geriatric population at 95
confidence level and allowable error of 10 and a non -response rate of 10 sample size
was calculated to be 440 using the formula
n=4pq L2
n= sample size
4= factor to achieve 95 level of confidence
p= prevalence of morbidities ie 50
q= 100- p ie 100-50 = 50
L= permissible error in the estimate of ldquoprdquo (10 of p)
n = 4 x 50 x 50 = 400
5 x 5
After calculating a non-response rate of 10 a sample size of 440 was calculated
30
Methodology
A community based cross sectional study was conducted in the urban field practice
area of JJM Medical College Davangere The Urban field practice area has a total
population of 16943 and there are 12 areas in urban field practice area of JJM Medical
College Davangere
The Study was conducted by probability proportionate sampling The sample size for each
area was derived from the formula
1198991 =119875119900119901119906119897119886119905119894119900119899 119894119899 119890119886119888ℎ 119886119903119890119886
119879119900119905119886119897 119875119900119901119906119897119886119905119894119900119899119883 119878119886119898119901119897119890 119878119894119911119890
Example 1st area has a population of 1374 so
1198991 =1374
16943119883 440 = 36
Therefore 36 elderly subjects were selected by house to house visit from 1st area Same
procedure was applied for other areas until the desired sample size of 440 was reached
MATERIALS USED FOR DATA COLLECTION
The following tools were used for data collection
Semi-structured predesigned and pre-tested questionnaire
Portable bathroom weighing machine
Stretch- resistant measuring tape
Mercury Sphygmomanometer
Others - stethoscope torch tuning fork knee hammer
ICD-10 for system wise classification of disease59
31
Methodology METHOD OF COLLECTION OF DATA After establishing rapport with the family
and explaining the data collection procedure in the local language an informed verbal
consent was obtained from each individual and data was collected using a
Predesigned semi structured questionnaire by Interview method The questionnaire
comprised of the following information socio-demographic data of the study subjects
information regarding the morbidity pattern and health seeking behaviour If there were
more than one elderly subjects in the same household then all were included
The study subjects were asked about any ho illness (communicable or non-
communicable) which they were suffering from Upon a positive response the subjects were
further asked to specify the type(s) and duration of morbidities that they were suffering
from eg heart disease diabetes gastrointestinal diseases respiratory disease etc Some
were unable to understand or answer questions due to illness In such cases help was sought
from the family members Based on the self-reported symptoms information from
hospital records and clinical examination the prevalence of different morbidities among the
study subjects was assessed The Information about the health seeking behaviour was
sought by asking the study subjects about their visits to a health facility in case of an illness
and also the type of health facility visited ( Government private or quacks )
DATA ENTRY AND ANALYSIS Data was entered and analyzed using MS Excel and
Open Epi Info version 2260 Both descriptive and inferential statistics were used Subjectrsquos
baseline characteristics were presented as frequencies and percentages Categorical
variables between the groups were compared using Chi square test and Fisherrsquos exact
test Fisherrsquos exact test was used when more than 20 cells had expected value lt 5 and any
one of the cells had expected value lt 1 All statistical analysis was carried out at 5 level
of significance and p value lt005 was considered as significant
32
Methodology ETHICAL CLEARANCE
Ethical clearance was obtained before conducting the study from the Ethical Committee of
JJM Medical college Davangere [ANNEXURE III] During the study verbal
informed consent was taken from the study subjects Assurance was given that the
confidentiality concerning their information will be maintained
Clinical Examination included
(a) General physical examination
(b) Anthropometric measurements like height and weight
(c) Systemic examination
(d) Measurement of Blood pressure
(e) Eye examination by torch and Snellenrsquos (E chart)61
(f) Hearing assessment by Rinnersquos test Webberlsquos and Absolute bone conduction
test using tuning fork 62
Parameters used in our study
Height Height was measured with a standard non-stretchable measuring tape to the
nearest 01 cm in standing position (without footwear standing upright with the
back against the wall heels together and eyes directed forward)
33
Methodology Weight Weight was measured with minimal clothing and respecting the modesty of the
individual without footwear using a calibrated standard bathroom weighing scale to the
nearest 05 kg
Body Mass Index (BMI) Using weight (in Kg) and height (in meter2) BMI was calculated by applying the formula
Body Mass Index= Weight (kg) Height (m2)
The BMI cut off values for Asians as recommended by the WHO was used in our study
Table 4 WHO Categorization of Body Mass index (BMI) for Asians 63
Measurement of Blood pressure Procedure Blood pressure was measured in the left arm in a sitting posture with the subject in a
relaxed state Standardized mercury sphygmomanometer with adult size cuff was used
The first appearance of (phase 1 of Korotkoff sounds) sound was used to define
Systolic Blood Pressure (SBP) The disappearance of sound (phase 5) was used to
define Diastolic Blood Pressure (DBP) Two readings were taken five minutes apart and
the average of the two readings was taken as the final blood pressure reading A person
was considered to be a hypertensive if he she was already diagnosed case of
hypertension and or on treatment or with a current SBP of ge 140 mm Hg or DBP ge 90 mm
Hg (JNC VII criteria)64
BODY MASS INDEX INFERENCE
lt 185 underweight
185 to 229 kg m2 Normal
23 to 249 kg m2 Overweight
ge 25 kg m2 Obese
34
Methodology
Table 5 JNC VII Classification of Blood pressure 65
BP Classification Systolic Blood Pressure Diastolic Blood Pressure
Normal lt120 lt 80
Pre Hypertension 120 ndash 139 or 80 ndash 89 Stage 1 Hypertension 140 ndash 159 or 90 ndash 99 Stage 2 Hypertension ge 160 or ge 100
Anaemia was detected by pallor of conjunctiva tongue and nails and was confirmed by
doing haemoglobin estimation using sahlirsquos hemogobinometer66
The cut off for the diagnosis of anaemia was done based on WHO classification67
Diabetes - self reported cases of diabetes were considered as diabetics for the study
STUDY VARIABLES
1 AGE - subjects aged 60 years and above were taken up for the study Age was
recorded to the nearest complete years as stated by the respondent
2 GENDER Both males and females were taken up for the study
3 EDUCATIONAL STATUS 68
i Illiterate -A person who could not read or write
ii Primary School - studied up to 4th standard
iii Higher primary- studied between 5th and 7th standard
iv Secondary school -studied between 8th and 10th standard v Intermediate- studied between 11th or 12 th standard or diploma
vi Graduate - obtained graduate degree
vii Post Graduate- obtained post graduate degree
35
Methodology
4 OCCUPATION STATUS69
i Unskilled worker
Labourer domestic servants casual worker peon sweeper porter washer-man others
(vegetable vendor)
ii Semi-skilled worker
Factory worker agriculture laborers shoemaker potters others (security guard shop
helper canteen helper
iii Skilled
Artisan clerk foreman supervisor carpenter tailor mechanic electrician railway guard
painter modeler smiths baker driver shop assistant petty trader constable soldier
linesman pointsman potter barber others (tinkering printer receptionist salesman
welder cook mason postman plumber agarbatti worker)
iv semi-professional
Teacher pharmacist social worker owner of a small business farmer others (computer
programmer Govt employee nurse)
V Professional
Doctor engineer principal lawyer Military officer senior executive business
proprietor writer scientist large employer director university professor police
officer others (horse rider)
(vi) Unemployed Presently not working retired homemakers
36
Methodology 5 SOCIO ECONOMIC STATUS
Table 6 Socio-economic status (SES)- As per modified BG Prasad Classification70
5 TYPE OF FAMILY 71
Joint Family ndash It is type of family grouping in which a number of married couples and
their children live together in the same household All the men are related by blood
and women of household are their wives unmarried girls and widows of family kinsmen
Nuclear Family - It consist of married couple and their children while they are still
regarded as dependents
Three generation family - It is a family where representatives of three generation are
living together Young married couples continue to stay with their parents and have
their own children as well
Socio-economic
status
Prasadrsquos classification
1961(Per capita income in
Rupees per month)
Modified BG Prasad classification-
updated for May 2016 ((per
capita income in Rupees per
month)
I 100 and above 6261 and above
II 50-99 3099-6260
III 30-49 1835-3098
IV 15-29 949-1834
V Below 15 lt948
37
SAMPLE SIZE ESTIMATION
SAMPLE SIZE As quoted by Manmohan Gupta et al 35 in the studies done in various
parts of India the prevalence of morbidity in the geriatric population ranges from 31-80
Considering the prevalence of morbidity to be about 50 in the geriatric population at 95
confidence level and allowable error of 10 and a non -response rate of 10 sample size
was calculated to be 440 using the formula
n=4pq L2
n= sample size
4= factor to achieve 95 level of confidence
p= prevalence of morbidities ie 50
q= 100- p ie 100-50 = 50
L= permissible error in the estimate of ldquoprdquo (10 of p)
n = 4 x 50 x 50 = 400
5 x 5
After calculating a non-response rate of 10 a sample size of 440 was calculated
A community based cross sectional study was conducted in the urban field practice area of
JJM Medical College Davangere The Urban field practice area has a total population of
16943 and there are 12 areas in urban field practice area of JJM Medical College
Davangere
The Study was conducted by probability proportionate sampling The sample size for each area
was derived from the formula
1198991 =119875119900119901119906119897119886119905119894119900119899 119894119899 119890119886119888ℎ 119886119903119890119886
119879119900119905119886119897 119875119900119901119906119897119886119905119894119900119899119883 119878119886119898119901119897119890 119878119894119911119890
Example 1st area has a population of 1374 so
1198991 =1374
16943119883 440 = 36
Therefore 36 elderly subjects were selected by house to house visit from 1st area Same
procedure was applied for other areas until the desired sample size of 440 was reached
Results
RESULTS
The results are presented under the following headings
I Socio-demographic characteristics of study subjects
II Prevalence of morbidities among the study subjects
III Details of health seeking behavior of the study subjects
38
Results
ISocio-demographic characteristics of the study subjects
Table 7 Age and sex wise distribution of the study subjects
Figure 7 Age and sex wise distribution of the study subjects
In the present study Out of 440 study subjects majority 162(368) were in the age group
of 60-64 Years followed by 109 (247) in the age group of 65-69 Years 99 (225) were
in the age group of 70-74 Years and 35 (8) were more than or equal to 80 years of age
Majority of the subjects were males 260 (59) and 180 (41) were females The mean age
of the study population was 6745 plusmn 655 Years
354 254 262
88 42
389
239 172
67 133
0102030405060708090
100
60-64 65-69 70-74 75-79 ge80
Perc
enta
ge
Age in years
Males
Females
Age group (in years)
Males Females Total
Percentage () Frequency
(n=260) Percentage ()
Frequency (n=180)
Percentage ()
60-64 92 354 70 389 162 368
65-69 66 254 43 239 109 247
70-74 68 262 31 172 99 225
75-79 23 88 12 67 35 80
ge80 11 42 24 133 35 80
Total 260 100 180 100 440 100
39
Results
Table 8 Distribution of the study subjects based on religion
Religion Frequency (n=440) Percentage ()
Hindu 188 427
Muslim 252 573
Total 440 100
Figure 8 Distribution of the study subjects based on religion
In the present study it was found that the majority of the study subject belonged to Muslim
religion 252 (573) followed by Hindus 188 (427)
0102030405060708090
100
Hindu Muslim
427
573
Perc
enta
ge
Religion of the study subjects
40
Results
Table 9 Distribution of the study subjects based on Educational status
Education Frequency (n=440) Percentage ()
Illiterate 231 525
Primary school 121 275
Higher primary 38 86
Secondary School 30 68
Intermediate 6 14
Graduate 14 32
Total 440 100
Figure 9 Distribution of the study subjects based on Educational status
In the present study it was found that the Majority of the study subjects were illiterate
231(525) 121(275) had completed education up to primary school 30(68) had
completed education up to secondary school and only 14(32) were graduates
525
275
86 68
14 32
0102030405060708090
100
Perc
enta
ge
Educational status of study subjects
41
Results Table 10 Distribution of the study subjects based on occupation
Occupation Frequency (n=440) Percentage ()
Semi-professional 2 05
Skilled worker 45 102
Semi-skilled worker 68 155
Unskilled worker 100 227
Unemployed 225 511
Total 440 100
Figure 10 Distribution of study subjects based on their occupation
In our study it was found that the majority of the study subjects 225 (511) were
unemployed followed by 100 (227) who were unskilled workers 68 (155) were semi-
skilled workers and 45 (102) were skilled workers
0102030405060708090
100
05 102 155 227
511
Perc
enta
ge
Occupation of the study subjects
42
Results Table 11 Distribution of the study subjects based on socio-economic status (Modified
BG Prasad classification 2016)
Figure 11 Distribution of the study subjects based on their socio-economic status
In our study majority of the subjects 215 (49) belonged to Class IV Socioeconomic status
followed by 115 (26) who belonged to class III and 56 (13) who belonged to class II
SES (according to Modified BG Prasad Classification 2016)
Class II 13
Class III 26
Class IV 49
Class V 12
Socio-economic status Frequency (n=440) Percentage ()
Class I 0 0
Class II 56 13
Class III 115 26
Class IV 215 49
Class V 54 12
Total 440 100
43
Results
Table 12 Distribution of the study subjects based on their marital status
Marital status Frequency (n=440) Percentage ()
Unmarried 2 05
Married 323 734
Widowwidower 115 261
Total 440 100
Figure 12 Distribution of the study subjects based on their marital status
In our study it was found that majority of the study subjects 323(734) were married
followed by 115(261) who were widowed and only 2 (05) were unmarried
0102030405060708090
100
Unmarried married Widowwidower
05
734
261 Perc
enta
ge
44
Results
Table 13 Distribution of the study subjects based on the type of family
Type of family Frequency (n=440) Percentage ()
Nuclear family 163 37
Joint family 93 21
Three generation family 184 42
Total 440 100
Figure 13 Distribution of the study subjects based on the type of family
In the present study it was found that majority of the study subjects 184 (42) lived in a
three generation family followed by 163 (37) who lived in a nuclear family and 93(21)
who lived in a Joint family
Nuclear family 37
Joint family 21
Three generation
family 42
45
Results
II Prevalence of morbidities among the study subjects
Figure 14 Distribution of the study subjects based on the BMI
In the present study it was found that out of 440 study subjects 198 (45) had a normal
BMI followed by 132 (30) who were overweight 66 (15) were obese and only 44
(10) were underweight
under weight 10
Normal 45
Overweight 30
Obese 15
46
Results
Table 14 Distribution of morbidity pattern of the study subjects based on ICD 10
classification of diseases
System involved ICD 10
Males (n=260)
Females (n=180)
Total (n=440)
No No No
Diseases of musculoskeletal system (M00 ndash M99)
184 707 130 722 314 714
Diseases of the eye and adnexa (H00 ndash H59)
139 534 80 444 219 497
Diseases of oral cavityamp salivary glands (K00 ndash K14)
90 346 64 355 154 35
Endocrine nutritional amp metabolic diseases (E00 ndash
E90)
70 269 75 417 145 329
Diseases of circulatory system (I00 ndash I99)
64 246 73 405 137 311
Diseases of respiratory system(J00 ndash J99)
64 246 37 206 101 23
Diseases of digestive system (K00 ndash K93)
57 219 30 166 87 198
Diseases of skin amp subcutaneous tissue (L00 ndash
L99)
38 146 20 111 58 132
Diseases of the ear and mastoid process (H60 ndashH95)
39 15 18 10 57 13
Diseases of genitourinary system (N00 ndash N99)
22 85 7 39 29 66
Diseases of nervous system (G00 ndash G99)
6 23 5 28 11 25
Note Total number could not be given as many subjects had multiple disorders
47
Results
Figure 15 Distribution of morbidity pattern of the study subjects based on ICD 10
classification of diseases
In the present study it was found that the majority of the subjects 314 (714) suffered
from the disorders of the musculoskeletal system followed by 219 (497) who suffered
from the disease of the eye and adnexa154 (35) suffered from the disease of the oral
cavity 145 (329) suffered from endocrine nutritional and metabolic disorders137
(311) suffered from the disease of the circulatory system 101 (229) suffered from the
disease of the respiratory system 87(198) suffered from the disease of the digestive
system 58 (132) suffered from disease of the skin 57 (13) suffered from the disease of
the ear 29 (66) suffered from the disease of the genitourinary system and only 11( 25 )
suffered from the disease of the nervous system
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
714
497
35 329 311 229
198 132 13 66
25
perc
enta
ge
48
Results
Table 15 Distribution of the study subjects based on morbidity of the musculoskeletal
system
Musculoskeletal
Disease
Males
(n=260)
Females
(n=180)
Total
(n= 440)
Statistical
Value
Knee joint pain
52 (20)
30 (167)
82 (186)
X2 = 0779
df = 1
p=03773
Back ache
30 (115)
35 (194)
65 (148) X2 = 528
df = 1
p = 0021
Joint pain (other than
knee joint pain)
52(20)
35(194)
87(198)
X2 =00206
df=1
p =0885
Non-specific aches
and pain
50(192)
30(167)
80(182)
X2=0470
df=1
p = 0492
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses
In the present study it was found that the most common morbidity of musculoskeletal
system was pain of the joints (other than the knee joint) found in 87 (198) of the subjects
followed by knee joint pain in 82 ( 186) and non-specific pains and aches were found in
80 (182) of the subjects It was found that back ache was more common in females
35(194) compared to males 30 (115) and this difference was found to be statistically
significant
49
Results
Table 16 Distribution of the study subjects based on morbidity of the eye and adnexa
Diseases of the
eye and
adnexa
Males
(n=260)
Females
(n=180)
Total
(n= 440)
Statistical
value
Cataract
112(43)
60(333)
172(391)
X2 = 4241
df=1
p = 0039
Refractive error
20(77)
14(78)
34(77)
X2= 0001
df=1
p = 0973
Others (conjunctivitis
pterygium glaucoma etc)
7(27)
6(33)
13(29)
X2=0152
df=1
p = 0696
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses
In the present study it was found that the most common morbidity of the eye was cataract
found in 172 (391) of the subjects It was more common in males 112 (43) compared to
females 60 (333) and this difference was found to be statistically significant The other
morbidities present were refractive error found in 34 (77) subjects and others which
includes conjunctivitis pterygium glaucoma etc found in 13 (29 ) subjects
50
Results
Table 17 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the oral cavity
Diseases of the
oral cavity
Males
(n =260 )
Females
(n =180 )
Total
(n = 440)
Statistical
value
Stained teeth
22 (84)
18 (10)
40 (91)
X2 =0304
df=1
p = 0581
Missing teeth
40 (154)
38 (211)
78 (177)
X2= 239
df= 1
p=0122
Caries
28 (108)
8 (44)
36 (82)
X2= 566
df= 1
p=0017
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses
In the present study it was found that the most common morbidity of the oral cavity was
missing teeth found in 78 (177 ) of the subjects followed by stained teeth found in 40
(91) of the subjects and dental caries in 36 (82) of the subjects Dental caries were
more common in males 28 (108) compared to females 8(44) and this difference was
found to be statistically significant
51
Results
Table 18 Distribution of study subjects based on endocrine nutritional and metabolic
disorders
Disorders Males
(n =260 )
Females
(n =180)
Total
(n = 440)
Statistical value
Diabetes mellitus
45 (173)
37 (206)
82 (186)
X2 = 0739
df= 1
p = 0389
Anemia
24 (92)
35 (194)
59 (134)
X2= 955
df = 1
p = 0001
Thyroid disorders
1(04)
3 (17)
4 (09)
p= 0309
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
The present study revealed that the most common disorder of the endocrine system was
diabetes mellitus found in 82 (186) of the subjects followed by the nutritional disorder of
anemia found in 59 (134) of the subjects It was seen that anemia was more common
among females 35 (194) compared to males 24 (92) This difference was found to be
statistically significant Disorders of the thyroid gland were found in 4 (09) of the subjects
being more common in females 3(17) compared to males 1 (04)
52
Results
Table 19 Distribution of the study subject based on disease of the circulatory system
Diseases of
circulatory
system
Males
(n=260 )
Females
(n =180)
Total
(n = 440)
Statistical
value
Hypertension
62 (238)
71 (394)
133 (302)
X2= 1227
df= 1
p = 0000
CAD MI
Arrhythmias
2 (08)
2 (11)
4 (09)
p =100
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
In our study it was found that the most common disease of the circulatory system was
hypertension which was found in 133 (302 ) of the subjects it was more common in
females 71 (394) compared to males 62 (239) and this difference was found to be
statistically significant The other disorders of the circulatory system were CAD MI
arrhythmias which were found only in 4 (09) of the study subjects
53
Results
Table 20 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the respiratory system
Disorders of
Respiratory
System
Males
(n=260)
Females
(n=180)
Total
(n=440)
Statistical
value
Bronchial asthma
3 (12)
3 (17)
6 (14)
p =0692
URTI
45 (173)
27 (15)
72 (164)
X2= 0413
df = 1
p = 0520
Acute Bronchitis
12 (46)
7 (39)
19 (43)
X2= 0135
df = 1
p = 0712
Pulmonary TB
4 (15)
0(00)
4 (09)
p =0148
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
Our study revealed that the most common disease of the respiratory system was URTI
(upper respiratory tract infection) found in 72 (164) subjects followed by acute bronchitis
in 19 (43 ) bronchial asthma in 6 (14) and pulmonary TB in only in 4 (09 ) subjects
Pulmonary TB was found in 4 (15) of the males whereas no females had TB however
this difference was not found to be statistically significant
54
Results
Table 21 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the digestive system
Disorders of
Gastrointestinal
system
Males
(n = 260)
Females
(n = 180)
Total
(n = 440)
Statistical value
Constipation
21(8)
6 (33)
27(61)
X2 =4155
df =1
p =0041
Gastritis
24 (92)
18 (10)
42(95)
X2= 0072
df = 1
p =0787
Bleeding per
rectum 3(12) 2(11) 5(11)
p =100
Others (Pain
abdomen
anorexia
indigestion)
9(35)
4 (22)
13 (3)
X2=0569
df =1
p=0450
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
Our study revealed that the most common disorder of the gastrointestinal system was
gastritis found in 42 (95) subjects followed by constipation in 27 ( 61) others which
include pain abdomen anorexia indigestion was found in 13 (3) and bleeding per rectum
was seen in 5 (11) It was seen that constipation was more common among males 21(8)
compared to females 6 (33) which was found to be statistically significant
55
Results
Table 22 Distribution the study subjects based on disease of the Skin and
subcutaneous tissue
Disorders of skin and
subcutaneous tissue
Males ( n = 260)
Females (n = 180)
Total (n = 440)
Statistical
value
Itching
19(73)
2(11)
21(48)
X2 =896
df=1
p = 0002
Scaling 6 (23)
3 (17)
9 (2)
p =0743
Pigmentation
5(19)
4 (22)
9 (2)
p =100
Dryness
8 (31)
11 (61)
19(43)
X2= 237
df = 1
p = 0123 Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
In the present study it was found that the most common disease of the skin was itching
which was present in 21 (48) of the study subjects followed by dryness in 19 (43) and 9
(2) of the subjects had scaling and pigmentation It was seen that itching was more
common among males 19 (73) compared to females 2 (11) and this difference was
found to be statistically significant
56
Results
Table 23 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the ear
Disease of the ear
Males
(n= 260)
Females
(n = 180)
Total
(n = 440) Statistical value
Hearing impairment
33 (126)
16 (89)
49 (111)
X2 =155
df =1
p =0212
Ear discharge
3 (12)
1 (06)
4(09)
p =0647
Tinnitus
3 (12)
1 (06)
4 (09)
p =0647
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
In the present study it was observed that hearing impairment was the most common
morbidity of the ear found in 49 (111) of the subjects though it was more common
among males 33 (126) compared to females 16 (89) the difference was not found to be
statistically significant The other disorders which affected the ear were ear discharge and
tinnitus both present in 4 (09) of the subjects
57
Results
Table 24 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the genitourinary
system
Disorders of
genitourinary system
Male
(n = 260)
Female
(n = 180)
Total
(n=440)
Statistical value
Burning micturition
2 (077)
2 (11)
4 (09)
p=100
Increased frequency of
micturition
20(77) 5(28) 25(57)
X2= 4794
df =1
p =0028 Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
In our study it was observed that the most common morbidity affecting the genitourinary
system was increased frequency of micturition in 25 (57) of the subjects followed by
burning micturition in 4 (09) of the study subjects Increased frequency of micturition was
more common among males 20 (77) compared to females 5 (28) and this difference
was found to be statistically significant
58
Results
Table 25 Distribution of the study subjects based on diseases of the Nervous system
Disease of the
nervous system Males
(n = 260)
Females
(n = 180)
Total
(n = 440)
p value
Memory loss
2 (77)
2 (11)
4 (09)
100
Stroke
2 (77)
0 (00)
2 (05)
0515
Neuritis
2 (77)
3 (17)
5 (11)
0652
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
Our study revealed that the most common disorder of the nervous system was neuritis seen
in 5 (11) of the subjects followed by memory loss in 4 (09) and stroke in 2 (05 ) of
the subjects It was observed that 2 (0 77) of males had suffered a stroke whereas none of
the females had suffered from stroke however this difference was not found to be
statistically significant
59
Results
Table 26 Association between morbidity pattern of the study subjects and their age
group
System involved 60-69Yrs
(n = 271)
70-79Yrs
(n = 134)
gt 80Yrs
(n = 35)
Total
( n = 440)
Statistical
value
Musculoskeletal
System
195 (72)
94 (70)
25 (710)
314 (714) X2= 0143
df = 2 p = 0930
Eye amp adnexa
125 (461)
69 (515)
25 (714)
219 (497) X2= 8166
df = 2 p = 0016
Oral cavity amp salivary gland
56 (207)
68 (507)
30 (857)
154 (350) X2= 7865
df = 2 p lt 00001
Endocrine nutritional amp
metabolic diseases
91 (335)
47 (35)
7 (200)
145 (329) X2= 297
df = 2 p = 0225
Circulatory
system
87 (321)
40 (298)
10 (285)
137 (311) X2= 0328
df = 2 p = 0848
Respiratory
system
64 (236)
31 (231)
6 (171)
101 (23) X2= 0738
df = 2 p = 0691
Digestive system
52 (191)
28 (210)
7 (200)
87 (191) X2= 0166
df = 2 p = 0 920
Skin and subcutaneous
tissue
43 (159)
13 (97)
2 (57)
58 (132) X2= 4831
df = 2 p = 0089
Ear amp mastoid process
27 (99)
20 (149)
10 (285)
57 (13) X2= 1018
d= 2 p = 0006
Genitourinary
system
20 (74)
8 (59)
1 (29)
29 (66) X2= 1151
df = 2 p = 0562
Nervous system
5 (18)
4 (29)
2 (57)
11 (25)
p = 0418
Figure in parenthesis indicates percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
60
Results
Table 26 shows the association between the morbidity pattern and age group of the study
subjects It is observed that the disease of the eye and adnexa increase with increasing age
and are more common in individuals above 80 years of age (714) compared to
individuals in the age group of 60-69 years (461) and 70-79 years (515) This
difference was found to be statistically significant The disease of the oral cavity were also
more common in the subjects aged 80 years and above (857) compared to individuals in
the age group of 70-79 years (507) and 60-69 years (207) this difference was also
found to be statistically significant Significant association was also found between
increasing age and disease of the ear 285 subjects aged 80 years and above suffered from
disease of the ear followed by 149 in the age group of 60-69 years and 99 in the age
group of 60-69 years
61
Results Table 27 Association between morbidity pattern of the study subjects and their
occupation
System involved Employed (n=215)
Unemployed (n=225)
Total (n=440)
Statistical value
Musculoskeletal
system
171 (795) 143 (635) 314 (714) X2 =1374 df=1
p=00002
Eye and adnexa 108 (502) 111(493) 219(497) X2= 0035 df=1
p= 0850
Oral cavityamp
salivary glands
76 (353) 78 (347) 154 (35) X2=0022 df=1
p=0880
Endocrine
nutritional amp
metabolic
disease
75 (348) 70 (311) 145 (329) X2=0708 df=1
p=0400
circulatory
system
58 (269) 79 (351) 137 (311) X2=3393 df=1
p=0065
Respiratory
system
49 (227) 52 (231) 101 (23) X2=0006 df=1
p=09363
Digestive system 45 (21) 42 (187) 87 (198) X2=0125 df=1
p=0723
Skin
subcutaneous
tissue
38 (176) 20 (88) 58 (132) X2=741 df=1
p=0006
Ear and mastoid
process
31 (144) 26 (115) 57 (13) X2=0799 df=1
p=0371
Genitourinary
system
16 (74) 13 (57) 29 (66) X2=0494 df=1
p=0481
Nervous system
2 (093) 9 (4) 11 (25) X2=425 df=1
p=0039 Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses
62
Results
Table 27 shows the association between the morbidity pattern and occupation of the study
subjects It was observed that musculoskeletal disorders were more common among the
subjects who are employed (795) compared to those who are not employed (635) and
this difference was found to be statistically significant A significant association was also
seen between the disorders of the skin and subcutaneous tissue 176 subjects who are
employed suffered from the disease of the skin and subcutaneous tissue compared to 88
who were unemployed The diseases of the nervous system were more common among
those who were unemployed (4) compared to those who were employed (093) this
difference was also found to be statistically significant
63
Results Table 28 Association between morbidity pattern of the study subjects and their
religion
System involved Hindu
(n=188)
Muslim
(n=252)
Total
(n=440)
Statistical value
Musculoskeletal system 138 (73) 176 (698) 314 (714)
X2=0668 df=1
p=0413
Eye and adnexa 100 (531) 119 (472) 219 (497) X2=1535 df=1
p= 0215
Oral cavityamp salivary glands 73 (388) 81 (321) 154 (35)
X2=211 df=1
p=0145
Endocrine nutritional amp metabolic diseases
53 (2819) 92 (365) 145 (329) X2=3371 df=1
p=0066
circulatory system 58 (269) 79 (351) 137 (311)
X2=3393 df=1
p=0065
Respiratory system
33 (176) 68 (269) 101 (229)
X2=5415 df= 1
p=0019
Digestive system 27 (144) 60 (238) 87 (198) X2=6059 df=1
p=0013
Skin subcutaneous tissue
31 (164) 27 (107) 58 (132) X2=3138 df=1
p=00765
Ear and mastoid process
28 (149) 29 (115) 57 (129) X2=1095 df=1
p=0297
Genitourinary system
16 (85) 13 (52) 29 (66) X2=1965 df=1
p=0161
Nervous system
4 (21) 7 (28) 11(25) p=0764
Figure in parenthesis indicates percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
64
Results
Table 28 shows the association between the morbidity pattern of the study subjects and their
religion In our study it was observed that the disorders of the digestive system were more
common among Muslims (238) compared to Hindus (144) this difference was found
to be statistically significant Also the disorders of the respiratory system were more
common among Muslims (269) compared to Hindus (176) This difference was also
found to be statistically significant Some of the diseases were more common among Hindus
which include the disease of the eye and adnexa (531) oral cavity (388) ear (149)
skin and subcutaneous tissue (164) and genitourinary system (85) but it was not found
to be statistically significant
65
Results
III HEATLTH SEEKING BEHAVIOR OF THE STUDY SUBJECTS
Figure16 Distribution of the study subjects based on the visit to health facility in case
of an illness
In our study it was found that that out of 440 study subjects 395(898) visited a health
facility in case of an illness whereas 45(102) did not visit any health facility in case of an
illness
898
102
health facility visitednot visited
66
Results
Table 29 Reasons cited by the study subjects for not seeking healthcare in case of an
illness
In the present study it was found that the most common reason stated by the 45 study
subjects for not seeking health care in case of an illness was that it was a mil 20 (444)
followed by lack of money stated by12 (267) the other reasons stated were no one to
accompany 7 (156) and lack of faith in health care 6 (133)
Reasons cited for not
seeking health care
Frequency (n=45)
Percentage ()
Mild discomfort 20 444
Lack of money 12 267
Lack of faith in
healthcare
6 133
No one to accompany 7 156
Total 45 100
67
Results
Table 30 Distribution of the study subjects based on the type of health facility visited
It was observed that out of 395 subjects who visited health care facility in case of an illness
229(58) Visited government hospitals 160 (405) visited private practitioners hospitals
and 6 (15) visited quacks More number of males (622) visited government hospitals
compared to females (513)
Type of health facility visited
Males
(n=241)
Females
(n=154)
Total
(n=395)
No No No
Government hospital 150 622 79 513 229 58
Private practitionershospitals 87 361 73 474 160 405
Quacks 4 17 2 13 6 15
Total 241 100 154 100 395 100
68
Results
Table 31 Association between gender and health seeking behaviour of the study
subjects
Whether visited
health facility
in case of illness
Sex
Total
n ()
p value Male
n ()
Female
n ()
Yes 241 (927) 154 (856) 395 (898) 00151
No 19 (106) 26 (144) 45 (102)
Total 260 (59) 180 (41) 440 (100)
x2=5901 df =1
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
It was observed that more number of males visited a health care facility in case of an illness
241(927) whereas only 154(856) females visited a health facility in case of an illness
This difference was found to be statistically significant
69
Results
Table 32 Association between educational status and health seeking
behaviour of the study subjects
Whether visited Health facility in case of illness
p value
Educational status(n) Yes () No ()
0000
Illiterate (231) 194 (84) 37 (16)
Primary school (121) 115 (95) 6 (49)
Higher primary (38) 37 (974) 1 (26)
Secondary school (30) 29 (967) 1 (33)
Intermediate (6) 6 (100) 0(00)
Graduate (14) 14 (100) 0(00)
Total(440) 395 (898) 45(102)
Fisherrsquos exact test
In the present study it was found that 84 of the study subjects who were illiterate visited a
health facility in case of an illness whereas 16 did not visit a health facility in case of an
illness 967 of the subjects with education up to secondary school visited the health
facility and 100 of the subjects who studied up to intermediate and with a graduate degree
visited the health facility in case of an illness This difference was found to be statistically
significant
70
Results
Table 33 Distribution of study subjects according to frequency of visits to a health care facility
Frequency of visits to a health care facility
Frequency
(n=395)
Percentage
Once a month 207 524
Once in 3 months 99 251
Once in 6 months 79 20
Once in a year 10 25
Total 395 100
In the present study it was found that out of 395 study subjects who visited a health care
facility in case of an illness 207 (524) visited a health facility every month followed by
99 (251) who visited once in 3 months 79(20) once in 6 months and 10 25 visited
the health facility once in a year
71
Discussion
DISCUSSION
I Socio-demographic characteristics
Our study was done in the urban field practice area of JJM Medical College Davangere
among 440 geriatric subjects our study aimed at assessing the morbidity pattern and health
seeking behaviour of the geriatric population in the study area
In the present study Out of 440 study subjects majority 162(368) were in the age
group of 60-64 Years followed by 109 (247) in the age group of 65-69 Years 99 (225)
in the age group of 70-74 Years and 8 were more than or equal to 80 years of age [Table
7] This was similar to a study conducted by Prakash Boraingaiah et al 72 in which majority
of the elderly (346) belongs to age group 60-64 years followed by age group 75 years and
above (259)
In our study it was also seen that 59 of the study subjects were males and 41 were
females This was similar to a study conducted by Mohan Gupta et al 35 where 573
subjects were males and 427were females Our findings were contrary to a study
conducted by Md Alam Naushad et al 28 where 598 subjects were females and 402
were males
In the present study it was found that the majority of the study subject belonged to
Muslim religion 252 (573) followed by Hindus 188 (427) there were no study subjects
who belonged to other religions like Christian Jain Sikhs etc [Table 8] similar findings
were seen in a study conducted by Mrinal Ranjan Srivastav et al 50 in which 52 of the
subjects were Muslims
72
Discussion
In the present study it was found that the Majority of the study subjects were illiterate
525 whereas 275 had completed education up to primary school 82 had completed
education up to secondary school and only 32 were graduates [Table 9] These findings
were similar to a study done by Shraddha K et al 51in which 504 of the study subjects
were illiterate
In our study it was found that the majority of the study subjects 511 were unemployed
followed by 227 who were unskilled workers 155 were semi-skilled workers and
about 105 were skilled workers [Table 10] These findings were similar to a study done
by Rajat Das Gupta et al27 al in which 481 of the study subjects were not working
In our study majority of the subjects 49 belonged to Class IV Socioeconomic status
followed by 26 who belonged to class III and 13 who belonged to class II (according to
Modified BG Prasad Classification 2016) [Table 11] Similar findings were found in a study
conducted by Sribas Goswami and Manjari Sahai 29 in which majority of the study subjects
belonged to class IV socio economic status
In our study it was found that the majority of the study subjects 734 were married
followed by 261 who were widowed and only 05 were unmarried [Table 12] These
findings were similar to a study done by L subedhi and RB Sah 40 in which 663 of the
subjects were married 322 were widowed and 07 were unmarried
In the present study it was found that majority of the study subjects 42 lived in a three
generation family followed by 37 who lived in a nuclear family and 21 who lived in a
Joint family [Table 13] These findings were similar to a study done by Swapnil Jain et al 26
in which the majority (47) of the study subjects lived in a three generation family
73
Discussion
II Prevalence of morbidities among the study subjects
In the present study it was found that majority of the subjects 45 had a normal BMI
followed by 30 who were overweight about 15 were obese and only10 were
underweight [Figure 14] Similar findings were reported in a study conducted by Khadervali
Nagoor et al 44 in which 49 subjects had a normal BMI In a study done by Vimala
Thomas et al 52 272 of the subjects were obese which was higher than the present study
In the present study it was found that the majority of the subjects suffered from the
disorders of the musculoskeletal system (714) eye and adnexa (497) oral cavity
(311) respiratory system (229) digestive system (198)disease of the skin
(132)ear(13)genitourinary system (66) nervous system (25) [Table14] Similar
findings were seen in a study done by Rajashree Bhat et al 55 in which most common
morbidity of elderly was the problems of loco-motor system (486) followed by vision
(427) CVS disorders (344) respiratory system (202) and disease of ear (179)In
this study though the prevalence of loco-motor system disorders (486) was highest
compared to other disorders it was lesser compared to our study (714) In a study done by
L subedhi and RB Sah 40 it was found that 44 had eye problems 43 had gastrointestinal
problems 33 had CVS problems and 23 had ENT problems In this study the prevalence
of gastrointestinal disorders was much higher compared to our study
In the present study joint pain (including the knee joint) was most common disorder of the
musculoskeletal system seen in 40 of the males compared to 384 in females [Table 15]
whereas in a study done by Swapnil Jain et al 26 it was found that 472 males and 528
females suffered from joint pains This could be attributed to the fact that in our study
majority of the study subjects were males
74
Discussion
In the present study it was found that the most common morbidity of the eye was cataract
found in 39 of the subjects It was more common in males 43 compared to females
333 [ Table 16]These findings were similar to a study done by Shraddha K et al 51 in
which the overall prevalence of cataract was 302 of which 42 males and 358
females had cataract
In the present study it was found that the most common morbidity of the oral cavity was
missing teeth found in 177 of the subjects [Table 17] it was similar to the findings of a
study conducted by JP Singh et al 48 in which 1475 subjects were edentulous
The present study revealed that the most common disorder of the endocrine system was
diabetes mellitus found in 186 of the subjects followed by the nutritional disorder of
anemia found in 134 of the subjects It was seen that anemia was more common among
females 194 compared to males 92 [Table 18] Kakkar R et al 45 reported similar
findings with prevalence of diabetes mellitus as 153 In a study done by Deepak Sharma
et al 47 anemia was present in 15 of the subjects 97 males and 21 females were
anemic which was similar to our study
In our study it was found that the most common disease of the circulatory system was
hypertension which was found in 302 of the subjects it was more common in females
394 compared to males 239 and this difference was found to be statistically significant
[Table 19] A study by L Subedhi and RB Sah 40 reported that the prevalence of
hypertension was more among females (333) compared to males (30) which was
statistically significant
75
Discussion
In our study the most common morbidity of the respiratory system was upper respiratory
tract infection (163) [Table20] it was similar to the study done by Leena Rahul
Salunke33 where it was reported to be 196
In our study the most common disorder of the digestive system was gastritis (95)
[Table 21] similar to the findings of JP Singh et al 48 (35) contrary to this L subedhi
and RB Sah 40 reported a high prevalence of gastritis (39) This difference could be
attributed to the difference in the interpretation of symptoms for the diagnosis of gastritis
In our study the most common disorder of the skin was itching (48) [ Table 22] which
was similar to the findings reported by JP Singh et al 48 in which 225 subjects suffered
from itching
In our study the most common disorder of the ear was impaired hearing (111) [Table
23] similar to a study by Vandana Nikumb et al 38 in which 106 subjects suffered from
hearing impairment
In our study it was observed that the most common morbidity affecting the
genitourinary system was increased frequency of micturition (57) [Table 24]
L subedhi and RB Sah40 found in their study that 143 subjects suffered from increased
frequency of micturition which was higher compared to our study
Our study revealed that 25 subjects suffered from the disorders of the nervous
system [Table 25] similar to a study conducted by Vandana Nikumb et al 38 in which
13 of the Subjects suffered from the disorders of the nervous system whereas in a
study conducted by Shilpa Shaukaiah et al36 it was found that 66 of the subjects
suffered from the disorders of the nervous system which was higher than our study
76
Discussion
It is observed that the disease of the eye and adnexa increased with increasing age and were
more common in individuals above 80 years of age (714) The disease of the oral cavity
were also more common in the subjects aged 80 years and above (857) and 285
subjects aged 80 years and above suffered from disease of the ear A significant association
was found between age and these morbidities [Table 26] Similar results were found in a
study done by Swapnil Jain et al 26 in which cataract hearing impairment and dental
problems were significantly associated with the age of the study subjects
In our study a significant association was found between occupation and the disorders of
the musculoskeletal system skin and the nervous system Disorders of the musculoskeletal
system were more common among employed subjects (795) compared to unemployed
(635) 176 subjects who were employed suffered from the disease of the skin and
subcutaneous tissue compared to 88 who were unemployed Diseases of the nervous
system were more common among those who were unemployed (4) compared to those
who were employed (093) [Table 27]
A study done by Kakkar R et al45 found that there was a significant association between the
employment status and the morbidities of the CVS arthritis and cataract CVS morbidity
was more common among those not working (164) compared to those working (36)
Arthritis was also more common among not working (212) compared to those working
(55) and cataract was also more common among those not working (175) compared to
those working (55)
77
Discussion
In our study it was observed that there was a significant association between religion and
disorders of the digestive system and respiratory system The disorders of the digestive
system were more common among Muslims (238) compared to Hindus (144) Also the
disorders of the respiratory system were more common among Muslims (269) compared
to Hindus (176) [Table 28] In a study conducted by Mrinal Ranjan Srivastav et al 50 it
was found that there was significant association between religion and the morbidities of the
genitourinary system in the urban areas The problems of the genitourinary system were
more common among Hindus (26) compared to Muslims (96)
III HEATLTH SEEKING BEHAVIOR OF THE STUDY SUBJECTS
In our study it was found that that (898) study subjects visited a health facility in case
of an illness whereas 102 did not visit any health facility in case of an illness[Figure 16]
Similar findings were seen in a study conducted by Vimala Thomas et al 52 where it was
found that 716 subjects visited a health facility Contrary to our findings a study
conducted by Bhawalkar JS et al46 showed that only 81 subjects visited a health facility in
case of an illness whereas 919 did not visit any health facility
In the present study it was found that the most common reason stated by study subjects
for not seeking health care in case of an illness was that it was a mild discomfort (444)
followed by lack of money stated by (267) other reasons stated were no one to
accompany (156) and lack of faith in health care (133) [Table 29] In a study
conducted by Deepak Sharma et al 47 it was found that the most common reasons for not
seeking health care were the following disease due to age (496) health services too far
(191) lack of money (6) no body to take to hospital (35)
78
Discussion
It was observed that out of 395 subjects who visited health care facility in case of an illness
58 Visited government hospitals 362 visited private practitioners hospitals and 15
visited quacks [Table 30] similar results were found in a study conducted by Deepak Sharma
et al 47 in which 607 went to Government hospitals 267 consulted private practitioners
and 126 took over the counter drugs In another study conducted by Rajat Das Gupta et al
27 it was found that 33 visited Government hospitals 25 visited private hospitals 6
visited private practitioners
It was observed that more number of males (927) visited a health care facility in case of
an illness whereas only 856 females visited a health facility in case of an illness [Table
31] In a study done by Man Mohan Gupta et al 35 it was found that 672 females and
651 males visited a health facility in case of illness
In the present study it was found that 848 of the study subjects who were illiterate
visited a health facility in case of an illness whereas 152 did not visit a health facility in
case of an illness A significant association was found between educational status and
gender [Table 32] In a study done by Deepak Sharma et al 47 it was found that Gender
literacy income and marital status were not found to be significantly related to health-
seeking behaviour
In the present study it was found that 524 subjects visited a health facility every month
followed by 251 who visited a health facility once in 3 months 20once in 6 months
and 25 visited a health facility once in a year[ Table 33] In a study conducted by Rajat
Das Gupta et al 27 it was found that majority of the subjects (2943) visited a health
facility once a year followed by 2813 who visited a health facility once in three months
79
Conclusion
CONCLUSION
The study revealed that some of the common morbidities among the geriatric subjects were
the disorders of the musculoskeletal system followed by the disease of the eye and adnexa
oral cavity endocrine nutritional and metabolic disorders etc some disorders like cataract
dental caries constipation and increased frequency of micturition were more common
among males whereas disease like anemia and hypertension were more common among
females A significant association was found between some of the morbidities and socio
demographic determinants like age occupation and religion
Any degree of formal schooling was found to be associated with better health seeking
behavior Majority of the subjects visited a Government health facility in case of an illness
and the main reason that was stated for not visiting a health facility was that they suffered
from mild discomfort and did not consider it necessary to visit a health facility
80
Summary
SUMMARY
Our study was done in the urban field practice area of JJM Medical College Davangere
among 440 geriatric subjects our study aimed at assessing the morbidity pattern and health
seeking behaviour of the geriatric population in the study area
The results of our study are as follows
ISocio-demographic characteristics of the study subjects
In the present study 368 subjects were in the age group of 60-64 Years
59 of the subjects were males and 41 were females
573 subjects were Muslims whereas 427 were Hindus
Majority of the subjects were illiterate (525) whereas 275 had completed
education up to primary school
It was found that the majority of the study subjects (511) were unemployed
49 subjects belonged to Class IV Socioeconomic status according to Modified BG
Prasad Classification
734 of the subjects were married
42 of the people lived in a three generation family
II Prevalence of morbidities among the study subjects
Majority of the subjects (45) had a normal BMI followed 30who were
overweight
Majority 714 subjects suffered from the disorders of the musculoskeletal system
followed by 497 who suffered from the disease of the eye and adnexa35
suffered from the disease of the oral cavity 329 suffered from endocrine
nutritional and metabolic disorders and 311 suffered from the disease of the
circulatory system 229 suffered from the disease of the respiratory system198
81
Summary
suffered from the disease of the digestive system132 suffered from disease of the
skin13 suffered from the disease of the ear66 suffered from the disease of the
genitourinary system and 25 suffered from the disease of the nervous system
The most common morbidity of musculoskeletal system was pain of the joints (other
than the knee joint) found in 198 of the subjectsBack ache was more common in
females 231 compared to males 163 and this difference was found to be
statistically significant
cataract found in 39 of the subjects It was more common in males 43 compared
to females 333 and this difference was found to be statistically significant
Missing teeth were found in 177 of the subjects Dental caries were more
common in males 108 compared to females 44 and this difference was found to
be statistically significant
Diabetes mellitus found in 186 of the subjects followed by the nutritional disorder
of anemia found in 134 of the subjects anemia was more common among females
194 compared to males 92 This difference was found to be statistically
significant
Hypertension which was found in 302 of the subjects it was more common in
females 394 compared to males 239 and this difference was found to be
statistically significant
upper respiratory tract infection) found in 163 subjects followed by acute
bronchitis in 43 bronchial asthma in 14 and pulmonary TB in only 09
Gastritis was found in 95 subjects followed by constipation in 61 Among
males (81) had constipation compared to females(03)
Most common disease of the skin was itching which was present in 48 of the
study subjects followed by dryness in 43
82
Summary
Hearing impairment was found in 111 of the subjects
Increased frequency of micturition was found in 57 of the subjects followed by
burning micturition in 09 of the study subjects Increased frequency of
micturition was more among males 77 compared to females in whom it was 28
and this difference was found to be statistically significant
The most common disorder of the nervous system was neuritis seen in 11 of the
subjects followed by memory loss in 09 and stroke in 05 of the subjects
A significant association was found between increasing age and the morbidities of
the eye ear and the oral cavity
Significant association was found between occupation and the disorders of the
musculoskeletal system skin and the nervous system Disorders of the
musculoskeletal system were more common among employed subjects (795)
compared to unemployed (635) 176 subjects who were employed suffered
from the disease of the skin and subcutaneous tissue compared to 88 who were
unemployed Diseases of the nervous system were more common among those who
were unemployed (4) compared to those who were employed (093)
It was observed that the disorders of the digestive system were more common
among Muslims (238) compared to Hindus (144) this difference was found to
be statistically significant Also the disorders of the respiratory system were more
common among Muslims (269) compared to Hindus (176) This difference
was also found to be statistically significant
83
Summary
III HEATLTH SEEKING BEHAVIOR OF THE STUDY SUBJECTS
In our study 898 subjects visited a health facility in case of an illness whereas
102 did not
The most common reason stated by study subjects for not seeking health care in case
of an illness was that it was a mild discomfort (444) followed by lack of money
stated by (267) the other reasons stated were no one to accompany (156) and
lack of faith in health care (133)
It was observed that 58 subjects Visited Government hospitals 362 visited
private practitioners hospitals and 15 visited quacks
Majority of males (927) visited a health care facility in case of an illness whereas
only 856 females visited a health facility in case of an illness This difference was
found to be statistically significant
A significant association was found between the educational status and health
seeking behaviour Majority of the educated subjects visited a health facility in case
of an illness compared to those who were illiterate
It was found that 524 subjects visited a health facility every month followed by
251 who visited a health facility once in 3 months 20once in 6 months and
25 visited a health facility once in a year
84
Limitations
LIMITATIONS
1 Many of the responses were subjective and there were no records to verify them
2 Some of the morbidities were diagnosed only by clinical examination and could not be
confirmed by performing diagnostic tests due to high cost and time constraints
3 This study was done in the urban field practice area which consisted of a closed
community hence the results cannot be generalized to the entire population of the area
85
Recommendations
RECOMMENDATIONS
1 Health education should be given to the geriatric people regarding the common health
problems associated with ageing and preventive care should be provided to the elderly
2 Geriatric clinics should be set up at the primary health care level which provide regular
screening and health check-ups
3 There should also be a provision to provide domiciliary care by specialists qualified in
geriatrics
4 The family members and the care givers of the elderly should be educated about the
common health problems of the elderly and also about the need for regular health check-ups
and emotional support
5 The majority of the geriatric population is out of work force they are suffering from
many morbidities and are totally dependent on others even for their health needs Hence the
Government should increase the pension of the elderly and provide them quality healthcare
free of cost
6 There is also a need for public private partnership to improve the quality of health
services for the geriatric people More number of NGOs should work towards improving the
health and the quality of life of the elderly
86
References
REFERENCES
1 United Nations Department of Economic and Social affairs Population Division
World population ageing 2013 Available from URL
wwwunorgendevelopmentpopulationageingWorldPopulationAgeing2013
[Accessed on 17-7-2016]
2 Khan S and Itrat M Current Issues in Geriatric Health Care in India-A Review J Community Med Health Care 2016 1(1) 1-3
3 United Nations Department of Economic and Social Affairs Population Division
World Population Ageing 2015 ndash Highlights Available from URL
wwwunorgendevelopmentdesapopulationpdfageingWPA2015_Reportpdf
[Accessed on 272017]
4 State of elderly in India 2014 Help age India Available from URL
httpswwwhelpageindiaorgimagespdfstate-elderly-india-2014pdf [Accessed on
1082017]
5 World Health Organization World report on ageing and health 2015Available
from URL wwwwhointageingeventsworld-report-2015-launchen [Accessed on
1272017]
6 National policy for Senior citizens March 2011Ministry of Social Justice and
welfare Govt of India Available from URL
socialjusticenicinwritereaddataUploadFilednpscpdf [Accessed on 482017]
87
References
7 Elderly in India Profile and programmes 2016Govt of India Ministry of statistics
and programme implementation Central Statistics Office Available from URL
wwwmopsigovin [ Accessed on 1442017]
8 Saxena V Kandpal SD Gael D Bansal S Health status of elderly community
based study Indian Journal of Community Health2012 Oct-Dec24(4)269-74
9 Shah T Patel M Shah V Health care seeking behaviour of urban and rural
community in Ahmedabad district Int J Med Sci Public Health20132908-11
10 Sahoo H Mishra NR Health Status Morbidity Pattern and Treatment Seeking
Behaviour among Elderly in India Evidence from 60th round of National Sample
Survey Data Learning community 2011 Dec 2(3) 341-55
11 Park K Parkrsquos Textbook of Preventive and social medicine 24 th ed Jabalpur MS
Banarsidas Bhanot Publishers2017631
12 UNFPA- state of World Population 2011Chapter 1 setting the scene 19-31
Available from URL httpswwwunfpaorgsitesdefaultfilesresource-
pdfUNFPA-Report-Chapter1pd [Accessed on 1082017]
13 Lal S Adarsh Pankaj Textbook of community Medicine 4th ed CBS publishers and
distributors PvtLtd2011732
14 Census of India 2001 Registrar General And Census Commissioner India
Available from URL httpwwwcensusindiagovinCensus[Accessed on
7102015]
15 SRS bulletin October 2012 Registar General of India New Delhi Available from
URL censusindiagovinvital_statisticsSRS_BulletinsSRS_Bulletin-
October_2012[Acessed on 7102015]
88
References
16 Bagchi K Healthy ageing Health and Population-Perspectives and Issues 2000
23(1)11-16
17 Salagre SB The Association of Physicians of India Chapter 177 Health Issues in
Geriatrics Available from URL
wwwapiindiaorgmedicine_update_2013chap177pd [ Accessed on 282017]
18 Ingle GK Nath A Geriatric Health in India Concerns and Solutions Indian Journal
of Community Medicine 2008 33(4)214-18
19 World Health Organization Active Ageing a policy framework 2002 Available
from httpwhqlibdocwhointhq2002who_nmh_nph_028pdf [Accessed on
1062017]
20 Inche Zainal Abidin S Sutan R Shamsuddin K Prevalence and determinants of
appropriate health seeking behaviour among known diabetics Results from a
community-based survey Advances in Epidemiology 2014 Nov 20141-6
21 Begashaw B Tessema F Gesesew HA Health Care Seeking behavior in Southwest
Ethiopia Plos one 2016 Sep 11(9)e0161014
22 MacKian S Health systems development Manchester University of Manchester
2003 A review of health seeking behavior problems and prospects
23 Metta EO Health-seeking behaviour among adults in the context of the
epidemiological transition in Southeastern Tanzania A focus on malaria and
diabetes [Groningen] University of Groningen 2016 228 Available from URL
httpswwwrugnlresearchportalfiles28737720Chapter_7pdf [Accessed on
1272017]
24 Adhikari D Rijal D Factors affecting health seeking behaviour of senior citizens of
Dharan Journal of Nobel Medical College 2015 Sep 4(1)57-63
25 Polisetty S Seepana M Morbidity profile of elderly individuals in urban
Visakhapatnam Int J Community Med Public Health 2017 4(2)2558-63
89
References
26 Jain S Kaware AC Doibale MK Shaikh S Radhey BK Mathurkar MP Morbidity
pattern among geriatric population in urban field practice area of district of
Maharashtra a cross sectional study Int J Community Med Public Health 2016
3(2)523-29
27 Gupta RD Loha A Roy S Morbidity pattern and health-seeking behaviour among
the senior citizens in a selected urban area of Bangladesh A cross-sectional study
South East Asia Journal of Public Health 2016 Jul 5(2)43-49
28 Naushad MA Verma N Bhawnani D Jain M Anand T Umate LV Morbidity
pattern and health seeking behaviour in elderly population of Raipur City
Chhattisgarh India Indian Journal of Community Health2016 Sep 28(3)236-41
29 Goswami S Sahai M A Study of Morbidity Pattern in Elderly Population European
Researcher Series A 2016103(2)119-28
30 Bardhan H Dixit AM Agarwal R Jain PK Gupta S Shukla SK Morbidity profile
of elderly population in Ghaziabad district a cross-sectional study Int J Med Sci
Public Health 2016 5(6)1098-1102
31 Maroof M Ahmad A Khalique N Ansari MA Health problems among the aged A
community based study from urban Aligarh Uttar Pradesh India Int J Community
Med Public Health 2016 Feb 3(4)944-47
32 Shankar G Sidenur B A morbidity study of elderly residing in urban field practice
area of SN medical college Bagalkot National Journal of research in community
medicine 2016 Oct-Dec 4(5) 229-34
90
References
33 Salunkhe LR Socio-demographic profile of old age people living in urban amp urban
slum areas in Maharashtra Karad A comparative study J of Evidence based Med
and Hlthcare 2015 Feb 2(5) 513-21
34 Warbhe P Rupesh W Morbidity profile health seeking behaviour and home
environment survey for adaptive measures in geriatric population-Urban community
study International Journal of Medical Research amp Health Sciences 2015 4(4)778-
82
35 Gupta M Borle AL Chhari N Gupta S Assessment of clinico-socioeconomic
status and health-care support among the elderly people aged older than 60 years in
urban population of Bhopal Central India Int J Med Sci Public Health 2015
4558-64
36 Sahukaiah S Shenoy A Vijayakumar BC An epidemiological study of prevalence
of morbidity patterns among geriatric age group in an urban slum of Mumbai Int J
Med Sci Public Health 2015 Jul 4(7)883-87
37 Shubha Davalagi B Angadi N Mahabalaraju DK Morbidity psycho-social profile
and health seeking behaviour of the elderly population in urban slums of Davangere
City India Int J Res Med Sci 2015 Nov 3(11)3288-91
38 Nikumb V Patankar F Behera A A Study of Morbidity Profile among Geriatric
Population in an Urban Area Sch J App Med Sci 2015 3(3)1365-69
91
References
39 Vishnoi BR Solanki SL Singhal G Meharda B Mishra N Morbidity profile of
elderly in urban slum of Udaipur Rajasthan Int J Oral Health Med Res 2015 May
2(1)9-12
40 Subedi L Sah RB Study of the health status of geriatric age group in Chitwan
district of Nepal Journal of Chitwan Medical College 2015 Mar 5(1)11-17
41 Noor S Krishnababu G Prasad KV Health status of Geriatric population in slums
of Rourkela Young Innovative Journal of Medical and Health Science 2015 May
5(3) 92-94
42 Sarode VM Chronic Diseases Related to Aging and Disease Prevention in Slums in
Mumbai Journal of Aging Science 2014 Jan 2 (1)1-6
43 Barman SK Lata K Ram R Ghosh N Sarker G Shahnawaz K A study of
morbidity profile of geriatric population in an urban community of Kishanganj
Bihar India Global Journal of Medicine and Public Health GJMEDPH 2014 3(1)
1-7
44 Nagoor K Srikanth BA Dudekula R Satna K Comparative study of health status
among slum and non-slum elderly population in Kadapa Region South India
Journal of Evolution of Medical and Dental Sciences 2014 Feb 3(5)1298-308
45 Kakkar R Aggarwal P Kandpal SD Bansal SK An Epidemiological study to assess
morbidity profile among geriatric population in District Dehradun Indian Journal of
Community Health 2013 May 25(1)39-44
46 Bhawalkar JS Dhone AB Jethani S Singru S Jadhav SL Adyanthaya S A study of
morbidity profile among geriatric population in an urban area J Evol Med Dent Sci
2013 Sep 9 36(2)6963-7
92
References
47 Sharma D Mazta SR Parashar A Morbidity pattern and health-seeking behaviour of
aged population residing in Shimla hills of north India A cross-sectional study
Journal of family medicine and primary care 2013 Apr2(2)188
48 Singh JP Singh S Kasturwar NB Hassan A Geriatric morbidity profile in an urban
slum Central India Indian Journal of Community Health 2013 Aug 25(2)164-70
49 Thakur RP Banerjee A Nikumb VB Health Problems among the Elderly A Cross
Sectional Study Annals of medical and health sciences research 2013 3(1)19-25
50 Mrinal RS Beena S Pratibha G Pankaj B Srivastava JP Atul B Morbidity Status
and Its Social Determinants among Elderly Population of Lucknow District India
Sch J App Med Sci 2013 1(6)758-64
51 Shraddha K Prashantha B Prakash B Study on morbidity pattern among elderly in
urban population of Mysore Karnataka India International Journal of Medicine and
Biomedical Research 2012 1(3)215-23
52 Thomas V Lavanya KM Morbidity profile and health seeking behaviour of the
elderly in urban slums of Hyderabad Andhra Pradesh India- A cross sectional study
International Journal of Current Research and Review 2012 Oct 1 4(19)174-80
53 Moe S Tha K Naing DK Htike MM Health seeking behaviour of elderly in
Myanmar International Journal of Collaborative Research on Internal Medicine and
Public Health 2012 4(8)1538-44
93
References
54 Bharati DR Pal R Rekha R Yamuna TV Kar S Radjou AN Ageing in
Puducherry South India An overview of morbidity profile Journal of pharmacy amp
bio allied sciences 2011 Oct 3(4)537
55 Bhatt R Gadhvi MS Sonaliya KN Solanki A Nayak H An epidemiological study
of the morbidity pattern among the elderly population in Ahmedabad Gujarat
National Journal of community medicine 2011 Jul 2(2)233-36
56 Srinivasan Krishnamachari Vaz Mario Thomas Tinku Prevalence of health related
disability among community dwelling urban elderly from middle socioeconomic
strata in Bangaluru India Indian Journal of Medical Research 2010 Apr 131(4)
515-21
57 Srivastava K Gupta SC Kaushal SK Chaturvedi M Morbidity profile of elderly a
cross sectional study of urban Agra Indian Journal of Community Health 2010 Jun
22(1)51-55
58 Ladha A Khan R Malik A Khan S Khan B Khan I et al The health seeking
behaviour of elderly population in a poor-urban community of Karachi Pakistan
Journal of the Pakistan Medical Association2009 Feb 59(2) 89-92
59 WHO ICD-10 version 2010 Geneva World Health Organization Available from
URL appswhointclassificationsicd10browse2010en [Accessed on 772017]
60 OpenEpi22OpenEpi (free) download Windows version Available from URL
enfreedownloadmanagerorgWindows-PCOpenEpi-FREEhtml
61 Tandon R Sinhota Parsonrsquos disease of the eye 22edNew Delhi Elsevier 98-100
62 Dhingra P L Dhingra S Disease of ear nose and throat and head and neck surgery
6th ed New Delhi Elsevier 201422
94
References
63 Aziz N Kallur SD Nirmalan PK Implications of the revised consensus body mass
indices for Asian Indians on clinical obstetric practice Journal of clinical and
diagnostic research 2014 May 8(5)OC01
64 Chobanion AV Bakris GL Black HR The seventh report of the joint national
committee on prevention detection evaluation and treatment of high blood pressure
the JNC 7 report JAMA 2003 2892560-72
65 The Seventh Report of the Joint National Committee on Prevention Detection
Evaluation and Treatment of High Blood Pressure (JNC 7) The GuidelinesUS
Department of Health and Human Services National Heart Lung and Blood
Institute Available at URL
httpswwwnhlbinihgovfilesdocsguidelinesjnc7fullpdf [ Accessed on
1282017]
66 Firkin F Chestman C Penington D Rush B De Gruchyrsquos clinical Hematology in
medical practice 5th edition New Delhi Blackwell science Ltd1989 32-47
67 Report of WHO consultation Nutritional Anaemias Geneva Switzerland World
Health Organization TRS-405 1968 Available from URL
whqlibdocwhointtrsWHO_TRS_405pdf [Accessed on 1282017]
68 National Family Health survey (NFHS-4) 2015-16 India Mumbai IIPS
2016Available from URL httpwwwnfhsindiaorg [Accessed on 4072017]
69 The Minimum Wages Act 1948 Ministry of Labour and Employment Government
of India Available from URL httplabourgovincontentinnerpagewagesphp
[Accessed on 1082017]
70 Khairnar M Wadgave U Shimpi P Updated BG Prasad socioeconomic
classification for 2016 Journal of Indian Association of Public Health Dentistry
2016 Oct 1 14(4)469
95
References
71 Tiwari P Tiwari S Mastering practicals community medicine 1st ed New Delhi
India Wolters Kluwer PvtLtd2013161-67
72 Boralingaiah P Bettappa P Kashyap S Prevalence of Psycho-Social Problems
among Elderly in Urban Population of Mysore City Karnataka India Indian journal
of psychological medicine 2012 Oct 34(4)360
96
PATIENT CONSENT FORM JJM MEDICAL COLLEGE DAVANGERE
DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY MEDICINE I the undersigned hereby give my consent
for investigations carried upon me I am satisfied with the information given about this
Clinical study titled ldquoA STUDY ON THE MORBIDITY PATTERN AND HEALTH
SEEKING BEHAVIOR AMONG THE GERIATRIC POULATION IN THE
URBAN FIELD PRACTICE AREA OF JJM MEDICAL COLLEGE
DAVANGERErdquo ldquoconducted by Dr RUCHI DHAR under the guidance of Dr VIDYA
GS Associate Professor I have been informed and explained the risks involved and I
hereby voluntarily and Unconditionally give my consent without any fear or pressure in
mentally sound and conscious state to participate in this study
DATE PATIENTrsquoS SIGNATURE
eEacuteeEacuteJA ordfEacuteEcirczAgravearingQAtildeAiAgraveAuml ordfAgraveAumlordmAacutelaquozAacutearingregAiAgraveAuml zAacuteordfAgravetUEacutegEacute
ryenAacutemiumlethordfEacuteAumlAmiumlDyensiumlPAgraveordfAgraveAumlAumlaringcurrenn ordfEacuteAumlrsup1poundiuml
ordfEacuteEcirczAgravearingQAtildeAiAgraveAumlvAgraveyenAacutecedilAgraveuEacuteUEacuteMbrvbaragraveUEacute yenAgravevAgraveaelig F PEacutefrac14AgraveUEacute cedilAgraveraquo ordfAgraveiAacutergAgraveAumlordfAgrave poundAacutepoundAgraveAuml CAzAgravegEacute
poundAgravepoundAgraveszlig
ordfEacuteEcirczAgravearingQAtildeAiAgraveAumlvAgraveyenAacutecedilAgraveuEacute ordmAacuteUAgraveAElig plusmnAgravecedilAgraveUcircccedilaQvEacuteigraveUEacuteAzAgraveAuml poundAgravepoundAgraveszligMbrvbaragraveUEacuteAiAgraveAumlpoundAgraveAumlszlig
cedilAgraveAEligasup1gAgraveAumlvEacuteUcircAtildepoundEacute J cedilAgraveOumlr Dyensiuml zAgrave ordfEacuteAEligcopyethrn yenAacutearinglpoundiumleth CAqiuml ordmEacutemacriumlUcirc sup1AtildeQAUiuml copyordmEacuteAtildelaquoAiAgraveAumlgiuml Dyensiuml zAgrave fjAiAgraveiAacutenaeligPiuml yenEacuteAEligAtildeyenAgraveAumlaringmacrEacuteAtildemicroAgravepoundiuml Epoundiuml zAgrave Csectethpoundiuml brvbarAtildemacriumlOslash yenAacuteaeligoumlaringQOumlAtildecediliuml JjAiAgraveAuml Dyensiuml ddordfAgraveAumlAuml ordfEacuteEcirczAgravearingQAtildeAiAgraveAuml ordfAgraveAumlordmAacutelaquozAacutearingregAiAgraveAuml zAacuteordfAgravetUEacutegEacute JAsect sup2AtildeparaethPEacuteAiAgraveAumlrAiAgraveAumldegegrave yenAgravejAtildePEacuteeumlUEacute Mfrac14AgraveyenAgravercedilAgraveAumlordfAgrave ordfEacuteEcirczAgravearinggAacutezAgrave qAacute|| gAgraveAumla zAgravesAgravegAgrave ordfAgraveAumlvAgraveAumlUcirc qAacute|| laquozAacutearing fJcediliumlordfAgraveiAacuteUAgraveethzAgraveplusmnAgraveethPAgravegAacutezAgrave yenEacuteAEligaeligAtildeyensEacutecedilAgravegiuml
EordfAgravegAgraveAuml poundAgravepoundAgraveUEacute F vAgraveyenAacutecedilAgraveuEacuteUEacute Mfrac14AgraveyenAgraveqAgraveAumlordfAgrave ordfAgraveAumlAumlpoundAgraveszlig yenAgraveaeligwAiEacuteAEligAzAgraveAuml
CAplusmnAgraveUAgravefrac14AgravepoundAgraveAumlszlig CxAgraveethordfAacuteUAgraveAumlordfAgraveAvEacute wfrac12sup1gAgraveAumlvAacuteUcircgEacuteDzAgraveYacutejAzAgrave poundAacutepoundAgraveAuml poundAgravepoundAgraveszlig
ordfAgraveAumlpoundAgravecedilAacutegEacute AiAgraveiAacuteordfAgraveAringzEacuteAtilde umlsAgraveAiAgraveAuml ordfAgraveAumlvAgraveAumlUcirc AiAgraveiAacutegAgrave MvAacuteUcircAiAgraveAumllaquoregegravezEacute poundAacutepoundAgraveAuml
vAgraveyenAacutecedilAgraveuEacute aQvEacuteigraveUEacuteAEligfrac14AgraveyenAgraveqAgraveregAuml MbrvbaragraveUEacuteAiAgraveAumlpoundAgraveAumlszlig cedilAgraveAEligasup1gAgraveAumlvEacuteUcircAtildepoundEacute
centpoundAacuteAPAgrave gEacuteAEligAtildeVAi
Annexures
ANNEXURE ndashIII
104
Annexures
PROFORMA
I General information
1 NAME
2 AGE
3 GENDER (a) Male (b) Female
4 MARITAL STATUS (a) Unmarried (b) Married (c) Widow Widower
(d) Divorced separated
5 LIVING ARRANGEMENT (a) with spouse (b) Spouse and children
(c) Children only (d) living alone (e) others
6 RELIGION (a) Hindu (b) Muslim (c) Christian (d) Others
7 ADDRESS
8 EDUCATION (a) illiterate (b) Primary school (c) higher primary
(d) secondary school (e)PUC diploma (e) Graduate (f) Postgraduate
9 OCCUPATION (a) professional (b) semi- professional (c) skilled worker
(d) Semi ndashskilled worker (e) unskilled worker (f) unemployed
10 CONTACT NUMBER
11 TYPE OF FAMILY (a) Joint (b) Nuclear (C) three generation
12 TOTAL NUMBER OF FAMILY MEMBERS
13 TOTAL FAMILY INCOME
14 PER CAPITA FAMILY INCOME
15 SOCIO ECONOMIC STATUS (Modified BG Prasad classification) I IIIIIIVV
16 DIET (a) Vegetarian (b) Mixed
17 Sleep (a) Disturbed if yes reason ______________ (b) Not disturbed
18 Bowel Regular Irregular
19 Bladder Regular Irregular
97
Annexures
20 HABITS (a) betel nut (b) tobacco (c) alcohol (d) smoking (e) others
If any of the habits present Duration (since when) _________
Frequency of consumption day_______
IIAssessment of morbidity based on history
1 Whether suffering from any chronic illness like (a) Type 2 DM (b) Hypertension
(c) Bronchial Asthma (d) TB (e) others
2 Whether suffering from cataract currently (a) Yes (b) No
3 Whether operated for cataract (a) Yes (b) No If Yes duration since operation____
4 MUSCULOSKELETAL SYSTEM
Whether the following symptoms are present
(a) Backache (b) Joint pain (c) restricted joint movements (d) pain in calves
(e) Others_________
5 RESPIRATORY SYSTEM
(a) Productive cough (b) non-productive cough (c) nasal discharge (d) breathlessness (e)
sore throat (f) sneezing
6 CARDIOVASCULAR SYSTEM
(a) Palpitations (b) chest pain (c) breathlessness
7 GASTROINTESTINAL SYSTEM
(a) Pain abdomen (b) lose stools (c) constipation (d) flatulence (e) heart burn
(f) Bleeding per rectum
8 EYE AND ADNEXA
(a) Watering (b) diminution of vision (c) redness
9 EAR
(a) Discharge (b) decreased hearing (c) Tinnitus
10 SKIN
(a) Itching (b) skin eruptions (c) scaling (d) pigmentation
98
Annexures
11 GENITO URINARY SYSTEM
(a) Burning micturition (b) increased frequency of micturition
12 GENERAL SYMPTOMS
(a) Fatigue (b) headache (c) fever
13 ANY OTHER COMPLAINTS (a) burning feet (b) swelling in groin
(c) Memory loss (d) insomnia
III Assessment of health seeking behaviour
1 Do you visit a health facility in case of illness (a) Yes (b) No
If yes how much time do you take to visit a health facility an case of an illness
(a) Within 24 hours (b) 24-48 hours (c) more than 48 hours
2 Which type of health facility do you visit
(a) Govt hospital (b) Private practitioners (c) over the counter drugs (e) quacks
Mention the reason for visiting the particular health facility______________________
3 Whether taking regular treatment after diagnosis ________________
If No mention the reason_______________________
4 Whether following the instructions given by the treating doctor
(a) Yes (b) no
5 cost of treatment per month in case of chronic disease
(a) lt100 (b) 100-200 (c) 200-300 (d) 300 and above
6 Person bearing the cost of treatment
(a) Self (b) spouse (c) son (d) daughter (d) outside help
7 Duration to reach the health facility
(a) less than 3o minutes (b) 30 minutes or more
8 Whether going for regular check -ups (a) Yes (b) No
If Yes duration between the check-ups_______
99
Annexures
9 Whether following self- care practices in case of chronic disease like diabetes and hypertension
(a) Yes (b) No
10 In case of healthy individuals whether getting screening tests done (a) Yes (b) No
11 Whether following any dietary modifications (a) yes (b) No
12 Whether any family member accompanies you to the health facility
If yes who (a) Son (b) daughter (c) spouse (d) others
11 Whether the family supports in following specific diet advised by the doctor
(a) Yes (b) No
12 whether family members help in reminding to take regular medication
(a) Yes (b) No
IV Physical examination
1 Personal hygiene status
S NO COMPONENT CONDITION REMARKS
1 Hair
2 Teeth
3 Bath
4 Clothes
5 Washing hand before
eating food
6 Washing hands with soap
and water after ablution
7 Nails
8 Foot wear
Remarks personal hygiene status Good fair poor
100
Annexures
2 MEASUREMENTS
(a) Weight (in Kg) ______ (b) Height (in cm) _____ (c) BMI ______
(d) Waist circumference______ (e) Hip circumference ___________
(f) Waist hip ratio_________
3 GENERAL PHYSICAL EXAMINATION
Pallor Icterus Cyanosis clubbing lymphadenopathy Oedema
Pulse rate Temp Blood Pressure
Respiratory rate
20 Examination of
Eye Oral cavity Ear
Nose Throat
SYSTEMIC EXAMINATION
Cardiovascular system Respiratory system
Per abdomen Central Nervous system
101
MASTER CHART
Annexures
ANNEXURES
International Classification of Diseases (10th Revision)
I Certain infectious and parasitic diseases (A00-B99)
II Neoplasms (C00-D48)
III Diseases of blood and blood forming organs and certain disorders
involving the immune mechanisms (D50-D89)
IV Endocrine nutritional and metabolic diseases (E00-E90)
V Mental and behavioural disorders (F00-F99)
VI Diseases of the nervous system (G00-G99)
VII Diseases of the eye and adnexa (H00-H59)
VIII Diseases of the ear and mastoid process ( H60-H95)
IX Diseases of the circulatory system (I00-I99)
X Diseases of the respiratory system ( J00-J99)
XI Diseases of the digestive system (K00-K93)
XII Diseases of the skin and subcutaneous tissue ( L00-L99)
XIII Diseases of the musculoskeletal system and connective tissue
(M00-M99)
XIV Diseases of the genitourinary system ( N00-N99)
XV Pregnancy childbirth and purperium (O00-O99)
XVI Certain conditions originating in perinatal period (P00-P96)
XVII Congenital malformations deformations and chromosomal
XVIII (S00-T98)
XIX External causes of morbidity and mortality (V01-Y98)
102
Annexures
XX Injury poisoning and certain other consequences of external causes
(S00-T98)
XXI Factors influencing health status and contact with health services
(Z00-Z99)
XXII Codes for special purpose
103
Annexures
105
Annexures
106
Annexures
107
Annexures
PHOTOS
Picture 1 Showing the investigator interviewing the study subject
Picture 2 Showing the investigator interacting with the study subject
108
Annexures
Picture 3 Showing the investigator recording the Blood pressure of the study subject
Picture 4 Showing the investigator auscultating the study subject
109
Annexures
110
LIST OF TABLES
Table No
Title Page No
1 Percentage share of elderly population (aged 60 years and above) in
total population by sex in India
6
2 Size of elderly population (aged 60+) and their share in total
population in major states of India in 2011
7
3 List of areas covered under the UHTC of JJM Medical College
Davangere
29
4 WHO Categorization of Body Mass index (BMI) for Asians 34
5 JNC VII Classification of Blood pressure 35
6 Socio-economic status (SES)- As per modified BG Prasad
Classification
37
7 Age and sex wise distribution of the study subjects 39
8 Distribution of the study subjects based on religion 40
9 Distribution of the study subjects based on Educational status 41
10 Distribution of the study subjects based on occupation 42
11
Distribution of the study subjects based on socio-economic status
(Modified BG Prasad classification 2016)
43
12 Distribution of the study subjects based on their marital status 44
13 Distribution of the study subjects based on the type of family 45
14 Distribution of morbidity pattern of the study subjects based on ICD
10 classification of diseases
47
xiii
15
Distribution of the study subjects based on morbidity of the
Musculoskeletal system
49
16
Distribution of the study subjects based on morbidity of the eye
and adnexa
50
17 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the oral cavity 51
18
Distribution of study subjects based on endocrine nutritional and
metabolic disorders
52
19 Distribution of the study subject based on disease of the circulatory
system
53
20 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the respiratory
system
54
21
Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the digestive
system
55
22
Distribution the study subjects based on disease of the Skin and
subcutaneous tissue
56
23 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the ear 57
24
Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the
genitourinary system
58
25
Distribution of the study subjects based on diseases of the Nervous
system
59
26 Association between morbidity pattern of the study subjects and
their age group
60
xiv
27
Association between morbidity pattern of the study subjects and
their occupation
62
28
Association between morbidity pattern of the study subjects and
their religion
64
29 Reasons cited by the study subjects for not seeking healthcare in
case of an illness
67
30 Distribution of the study subjects based on the type of health facility
visited
68
31 Association between gender and health care seeking behavior of the
study subjects
69
32 Association between educational status and health care seeking
behaviour of the study subjects
70
33 Distribution of study subjects according to frequency of visits to a
health care facility
71
xv
LIST OF FIGURES
Figure No
Title Page No
1 Proportion of elderly in the Indian population by age groups
1961-2001
6
2 Pathophysiology of health issues in geriatrics 10
3 Predicting health behaviour with social cognition models 13
4 Health belief model components and linkages 15
5 Maps showing the location of Davangere district and the
area where the UHTC is located
27
6 Map showing the Urban field practice area of JJM medical college
28
7 Age and sex wise distribution of the study subjects 39
8 Distribution of the study subjects based on religion 40
9 Distribution of the study subjects based on Educational status 41
10 Distribution of study subjects based on their occupation 42
11
Distribution of study subjects based on their occupation
43
12 Distribution of the study subjects based on their marital status 44
13 Distribution of the study subjects based on the type of family 45
14 Distribution of the study subjects based on the BMI 46
15 Distribution of morbidity pattern of the study subjects based on
ICD 10 classification of diseases
48
16 Distribution of the study subjects based on the visit to health
facility in case of an illness
66
xvi
ABSTRACT Background
According to census 2011 the elderly population aged 60 years and above account for 8
of total population and is projected to rise to 124 by the year 2026 Health status is an
important factor that has a significant impact on quality of life The elderly are one of the
most vulnerable and high risk groups in terms of health status and their health seeking
behaviour is crucial in any society
Objectives
1 To study the morbidity pattern among the geriatric population in the urban field
practice area of JJM Medical college Davangere
2 To assess the health seeking behaviour of the elderly residing in the study area
Methods It was a community based cross sectional study which was conducted in the urban field
practice area of JJM Medical College Davangere The total study subjects were 440
individuals aged 60 years and above Data was collected using a predesigned pre-tested
and semi- structured questionnaire Height weight and blood pressure were measured
and recorded Data was analyzed by using MS Excel and Open-Epi Info software
version 22 Statistical test employed was chi-square and Fishers exact test x
Results and Conclusion
In our study it was found that the majority of the subjects (368) were in the age group
of 60-64 years 525 were illiterate 511 were unemployed and 49 belonged to class
IV socio economic status The study revealed that the some of the common morbidities
among the geriatric subjects were the disorders of the musculoskeletal system (714)
eye and adnexa (497) oral cavity (329) endocrine nutritional and metabolic
disorders (329)etc some disorders like cataract dental caries constipation and
increased frequency of micturition were more common among males whereas disease
like anemia and hypertension were more common among females A significant
association was found between some of the morbidities and socio demographic
determinants like age occupation and religion
Any degree of formal schooling was found to be associated with better health seeking
behavior Majority of the subjects (58) visited a Government health facility in case of
an illness and the main reason that was stated for not visiting a health facility was that
they suffered from mild discomfort (444) and did not consider it necessary to visit a
health facility
Key words Geriatric urban behaviour morbidity
xi
Introduction
INTRODUCTION
ldquoA STUDY ON THE MORBIDITY PATTERN AND HEALTH SEEKING BEHAVIOUR AMONG THE GERIATRIC POPULATION IN THE URBAN FIELD
PRACTICE AREA OF JJM MEDICAL COLLEGE DAVANGERErdquo
All countries of the world are experiencing population ageing Ageing is a result of
decreasing mortality and most importantly declining fertility The global share of older
people (aged 60 years and above) has increased from 92 per cent in 1990 to 117 in
2013 and will continue to grow as a proportion of the world population reaches 211 by
20501
The lsquoNational Policy for Older Personsrsquo was adopted by the Government of India in
January 1999 and it defines a lsquosenior citizenrsquo or lsquoelderlyrsquo as a person who is aged 60 years
or above Ageing is a progressive process associated with declines in structure and
function impaired maintenance and repair systems increased susceptibility to disease and
death2
In 2015 Worldwide there were 901 million people aged 60 years or over It is
projected that their number will grow to 14 billion in 2030 which is the target date for the
SDGs and to 21 billion by 2050 There will be growth in the number of older persons aged
60 years and above between 2015 and 2030 This increase is projected to be especially
significant global phenomenon and virtually every country in the world will experience a
substantial increase including the less developed regions3 The increased life expectancy has
led to challenges in health care management The elderly suffer from various diseases which
include non-communicable disease (NCDs) like diabetes hypertension coronary heart
disease and other disorders like osteoarthritis stroke dementia osteoporosis cancer
1
Introduction enlarged prostate depression and cataract related blindness In the coming years there will
be a phenomenal growth in the population of the elderly while the family size will reduce
The disintegration of the joint family and women moving out of the household has led to the
absence of traditional caregivers for the elderly who are already a vulnerable group4
The most common cause of health problems in the old aged people is chronic diseases
Most of these problems can be prevented or delayed by engaging in healthy behaviours
Even in the advanced years of life physical activity and good nutrition can have
effective benefits on health and well-being Many health problems of old age can be
effectively managed if they are detected early enough5 The National Policy for Older
Persons was announced by the Government of India in the year 1999 The Constitution of
India under Article 41 mandates the well-being of senior citizens ldquoThe state shall
within the limits of its economic capacity and development make effective provision
for securing the right to public assistance in case of old aged peoplerdquo 6
National Council for Older Persons (NCOP) has been reconstituted and renamed as
National Council for Senior Citizens (NCSrC) in order to have a definite structure and also
regional balancing the NCOP advises the Central and State Governments on a broad range
of issues related to welfare of senior citizens and enhancement of their quality of life The
NCSrc meets at least twice a year7 The elderly suffer from multiple medical as well as
psychological problems There has already been some pioneering work on the elderly in
India but a lot more remains to be done There is an urgent need to pay attention
towards the medical and socio-economic problems that are being faced by the elderly
people in India and thus formulate strategies to bring about an improvement in their
quality of life8 The Health seeking behaviour is influenced by various factors which
include the individual self diseases and the availability and accessibility of health
2
services It is important to have knowledge regarding the health seeking behaviour of
individuals for designing health care policies and programmes so that all the possible
difficulties with early diagnosis and effective treatment can be identified and appropriate
interventions can be implemented9 As already stated the elderly are a vulnerable group as
there are psychological as well as physiological changes with increasing age and it is
difficult to cope up with the problems of ageing Some of the most common problems in old
age are cardiovascular problems arthritis respiratory problems blood pressure and so on
Therefore the study of the health status of elderly morbid conditions perceptions about
it is important to note and the health care of the elderly becomes very important since they
are more prone to illness than young people and are also more prone to domestic and other
accidents Their health and treatment seeking behaviour are most important for the
formulation of welfare programmes of the country 10
Hence this study was taken up in the urban field practice area of JJM Medical College
Davangere to assess the morbidity pattern and health seeking behaviour of the geriatric
subjects
3
Objectives
OBJECTIVES
1 To study the morbidity pattern among the geriatric population in the urban field
practice area of JJM Medical college Davangere
2 To assess the health seeking behaviour of the elderly residing in the study area
4
Review of literature
vii
REVIEW OF LITERATURE
1 Definition Geriatrics or clinical gerontology Is the term used for the care of the aged 11 The United Nations uses 60 years and above to refer to older people the same is also used
by demographers However in many developed countries the age of 65 is used as the
reference point for older persons 12
Elderly are classified in to 3 groups 13
Young old Persons in the age group of 60 years to 74 years
Old old Persons in the age group of 75 years to 84 years
Oldest old Persons above the age of 85 yrs
2 Demography of the ageing population in India
The UN defines a country as ldquoAgeingrdquo or ldquoGreying Nationrdquo where the
proportion of people over 60 reaches 7 percent to total population By 2011 India has
exceeded that proportion (80 percent) and is expected to reach 126 percent in 2025
The Indian population has increased from 361 million in 1951 to 1027 billion in 2001
and further to 121 billion in 2011 Simultaneously the number of older people has
increased from 19 million (ie 4 percent of total population) to 77 million and
further to roughly 93 million (ie 75 percent of the total) during the same time
span 14
5
Review of literature
Figure1 proportion of elderly in the Indian population by age groups 1961-2001 14
Table 1 Percentage share of elderly population (aged 60 years and above) in total
population by sex in India 15
Years Male Female Total Rural Urban
1961 55 58 56 58 47
1971 59 60 60 62 50
1981 64 66 65 68 54
1991 67 68 68 71 57
2001 71 78 75 77 67
2011 77 84 80 81 79
2004-05 69 75 72 73 70
2007-08 73 77 75 76 72
6
Review of literature
The rise in population of males was more modest from 55 percent to 71 percent while for
females there had been a steep rise from 58 percent to 78 percent during five decadal
Censuses from 1961 to 2001 In 2011 the elderly population accounted for 80 percent of
total population For males it was marginally lower at 77 percent while for females it was
84 percent According to NSSO surveys the proportion of elderly population in rural areas
was 73 percent during 2004-05 and increased up to 76 percent in 2007-08 While on the
other hand in urban areas the proportion of elderly population rose from 70 percent to 72
percent during the corresponding period It has been observed that the percentage share of
elderly to total population remained higher in rural areas than in urban areas15
Table2 Size of elderly population (aged 60+) and their share in total population in major states of India in 201115
All India and selected major states
Proportion of elderly in total population of State
Male Female Total Andhra Pradesh 83 94 88 Bihar 72 67 70 Gujarat 76 90 83 Haryana 66 76 71 Himachal Pradesh 104 103 104 Karnataka 79 89 84 Kerala 118 133 126 Madhya Pradesh 68 74 71 Maharashtra 88 97 93 Orissa 91 95 93 Punjab 91 100 95 Rajasthan 66 79 72 Tamil Nadu 102 109 105 Uttar Pradesh 66 71 68 West Bengal 82 82 82 All India 77 84 80
7
Review of literature
3 MORBIDITY PATTERN AMONG THE ELDERLY
Physiological Decline and Consequences of increasing age
Ageing i s a process of decline in biological functions affecting most physical
Systems The following systems are affected by ageing
(a) Atrophy of the Taste Buds and Loss of Teeth
With the increasing age the taste buds of the tongue get atrophied and as a result the
preference for food alters significantly There is also a considerable loss of teeth causing
difficulties in chewing food
(b) Changes in the Gastrointestinal Tract
As the age advances the walls of the intestine get atrophied and the motility is
markedly reduced (lazy intestine) The digestive enzymes secreted by the intestine are
also reduced Hence the partly digested food stays in the intestine for a longer period
As a result the common complaint of the elderly person is gas formation (flatulence)
and constipation
(c) Respiratory System
As the age advance there is progressive fibrosis of the lungs leading to reduced
oxygenation of the lungs and breathing difficulties
(d) Kidney and genitourinary System
The kidneys get smaller in size and the power of the kidneys to filter out the unwanted
waste products from the body is diminished The total amount of urine becomes less in
old age and thus the waste products are not adequately excreted from the body
8
Review of literature
(e) Urinary Bladder
Urinary bladder gets smaller in size due to shrinkage and as a result the accumulation
of urine even of a small amount leads to an urge for urination With increase in age
the valve in the bladder which controls the exit of urine from the bladder to urethra
gets atrophied and weak Involuntary leakage of urine occurs in case the bladder is full
or due to increase of pressure on bladder on sneezing or even on laughing a condition
known as urinary incontinence Incontinence is a common complaint of elder females
(f) Heart and Circulatory System
The blood vessels get rigid and quite often the vessel walls become rough with the
deposition of solid matters consisting mostly of cholesterol The heart muscles get weaker
and power to send blood throughout the body through the circulatory system gets less and
less powerful The most dangerous effect on heart is coronary heart disease especially
coronary thrombosis
(g) Muscular system
The muscles in the body get gradually atrophied with ageing and especially those
small muscles which are necessary for quick reflex action The elderly person can quite
be capable of working like a normal person and can undertake activities which require
big muscles of legs and arms But when it comes to quick movement which needs small
muscles for quick reflex movements these functions are impaired causing accidents
like slipping on wet floor of the bathroom
(h) Brain
With ageing the size of the brain gets smaller and the weight also becomes less This
however does not interfere with the function of the brain However in general the brain
cells and its fibers which carry impulses from brain to the system and upwards get
9
Review of literature
degenerated The most glaring manifestation of ageing affecting the brain is
forgetfulness and in simple terms it is inability of brain to recall the past experience
However this is common in all elderly persons
(i ) Bones
The bones become porous and fragile as age advances especially in elderly females This
condition is known as osteoporosis and leads to sustaining of fractures even after a minor
fall16
Figure 2 pathophysiology of health issues in geriatrics17
The common disease that the geriatric population suffers from are type 2 diabetes
coronary heart disease hypertension stroke chronic obstructive pulmonary disease
10
Review of literature
Alzheimerrsquos disease osteoarthritis osteoporosis prostatic hypertrophy cataracts macular
degeneration cancer etc and at the same time they are vulnerable to infections involving
respiratory (including TB) urinary and digestive tract17
In India the elderly people suffer from dual medical problems ie communicable and
nonndash communicable diseases There is also impairment of special sensory functions like
vision and hearing A decline in immunity and age-related physiological changes leads to
an increased burden of communicable diseases in the elderly A report by Indian Council
of Medical Research (ICMR) on the chronic morbidity profile in the elderly states that
hearing impairment is the most common morbidity followed by visual impairment
However different studies show varied results in the morbidity pattern18
Major chronic conditions affecting older people worldwide 19
Cardiovascular diseases (such as coronary heart disease) Diabetes Mellitus
Hypertension Stroke Cancer
Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease
Musculoskeletal conditions (such as arthritis and osteoporosis)
Mental health conditions (mostly dementia and depression)
Blindness and visual impairment
11
Review of literature
Health seeking behaviour
1 Definition
There is no common definition agreed upon by sociologists in any sociology literature
Different definitions may be used in different studies despite referring to the same activity
Sociology and literature assume that health seeking behaviour is influenced by the various
factors which include individual self or the individual diseases present and also the
availability and accessibility of health services Being dependent on these determinants and
their interactions it can be said that health care seeking behaviour is a very complex
outcome of various factors which operate at individual family and community level20
Health Seeking Behavior (HSB) refers to decision or an action taken by an individual to
maintain attain or regain good health and to prevent illness The decisions which are
made encompasses all available health care options like visiting a public or private and
modern or traditional health facility self-medication and use of home remedies or not to
utilize the available health services etc
Determining the health care seeking behavior is very important to provide a need
based health care services to the population Visiting official channels in a formally
recognized health care system has been considered as the desired Health seeking behaviour
Health seeking behavior is influenced by multiple factors including availability quality and
price of services and also social groups health views residences and personal features of the
users Peoplersquos choice of health care differs in socio demographic socio-economic and
cultural compositions and this has an effect on their health seeking behavior Urban dwellers
are generally believed to be open to new ideas and willing to try certain things on a trial and
error basis21
12
Review of literature
Health seeking behaviours two approaches
(a) Health seeking behaviours utilization of the system
This approach focuses on the actions which are taken to rectify perceived ill health and
the type of health care facility which is utilized by the people There is data which
suggests that the people visit more traditional healers and unofficial medical channels
this should be prevented and the emphasis s h o u l d b e on encouraging people to opt
first for the official channels
(b) Health seeking behaviours the process of illness response
This approach considers the factors which enable or prevent people from making
healthy choices either i n their lifestyle behaviours or use of medical care and
treatment22
Figure 3 Predicting health behaviour with social cognition models 22
13
Review of literature
2 Health belief Model of health seeking behaviour
Since lsquoHealth seekingrsquo is a conditioned behaviour any attempt which is made to
encourage people to seek health care definitely requires an understanding of their
motivation for such behaviour Only through a deeper understanding of the intricate
factors shaping behavioural practices can health promotion programmes and or
interventions successfully be introduced into the realities of the peoplersquos lives to bring
about changes in health behaviour
Behaviour change theories and models such as the Health Belief Model (HBM)
Theory of Reasoned Action (TRA) Theory of Planned Behaviour (TPB) and the
Trans theoretical model have been widely applied in public health in an attempt to
explain or predict health seeking behaviours Their use enables identification and
understanding of peoplersquos health-seeking behaviour beyond their knowledge attitudes
and practices
HBM is a health specific behavioural cognitive model This model is based on the
idea that people are more likely to change their behaviour and adhere to treatments
if they have the following perceptions (i) have a perception that they are at risk of
contracting the disease (perceived susceptibility) (ii) perception that the disease
might have an unfavorable outcome (perceived severity) (iii) perceive that the
proposed health behaviour to be both effective and practical (perceived benefits)
(iv) perceive the barriers to adopting the behaviour to be minimal (perceived
barriers)(v) perceive themselves to have the ability of applying and practicing the
specific behaviour proposed (perceived self-efficacy) and (vi) they have the cues
for motivating their actions such as internal cues (pain symptoms past experiences)
or external cues (advice from friends relatives and mass media campaigns) (cues to
14
Review of literature
action) The specificity of the HBM to health has made it suitable for use in
understanding and explaining the behaviour as well as health outcomes and this may also
explain its wider use in public health2 3
Figure 4 Health belief model components and linkages 23
3 Factors influencing health seeking behaviour
The factors affecting the health seeking behaviours are seen in various contexts which
include physical socio-economic cultural and political factors Therefore the utilization of
a health care system whether public or private formal or non- formal may depend on socio-
demographic factors social structures level of education cultural beliefs and practices and
some other factors like gender discrimination status of women economic and political
systems environmental conditions and the disease pattern and health care system itself also
have an impact on the health seeking behaviour24
15
Review of literature
REVIEW OF RELATED STUDIES
A study done by Sanjay Polisetty and Madhavi Seepana (2017) on the morbidity profile
of elderly individuals in urban Visakhapatnam revealed that of the 270 study participants
about 996 suffered from either some form of acute or chronic morbidity More than 70
of individuals suffered from eye problems of which most common problem was cataract
seen in 60 About 304 had difficulties in chewing and 256 had difficulty in hearing
Hypertension was present in 49 of individuals and 742 of Diabetics were also found to
be hypertensive25
A study done by Swapnil Jain et al (2016) on Morbidity pattern among geriatric
population in urban field practice area of a district in Maharashtra revealed 653 suffered
from hearing impairment 62 were anemic 462 had hypertension 423 had joint
pain 41 had dental problems 38 7 had cataract and 318 had chronic bronchitis It
was seen that 81 of the subjects had multiple morbidities 26
A study done by Rajat Das Gupta et al (2016) in an urban area of Bangladesh on Morbidity
pattern and health-seeking behavior among the senior citizens revealed that of the 384 study
participants 968 were suffering from at least one medical problem The commonest was
musculoskeletal problems in 8411 followed by eye problems in 8125 It was found that
all the respondents sought treatment for their health problems 33 respondents went to
Government hospitals to seek medical help 6927 respondents took prescribed
medications and 567 were satisfied with their treatment 27
16
Review of literature
A study done by Md Alam Naushad et al (2016) on Morbidity pattern and health
seeking behavior in elderly population of Raipur City Chhattisgarh revealed that the
prevalence of morbidity among elderly was 9531 Out of total morbid population some
chronic illness was present in 7049 Gastro intestinal system was involved in 8262
followed by eye in 7983 and Cardiovascular system in 5245 It was found that 3552
of the subjects sought treatment from private registered practitioners 28
A study done by Sribas Goswami and Manjari Sahai (2016) in Raipur city on Morbidity
Pattern in elderly Population revealed that out of total study population of 640 elderly
subjects 610 (9531) suffered from some morbidity Prevalence among females was
9892 whereas among males it was 9026 Out of various agencies 3552 subjects
were utilizing private facility followed by 2785 who were utilizing Government agency
2631 visited quacks and 1030 were taking treatment from other source 29
A study done by Harsh Bardhan et al (2016) on the Morbidity profile of elderly population
in Ghaziabad district revealed that in geriatric population 5008 suffered from
musculoskeletal problems 5877 had dental problems and impairment of vision was seen
in 5561 The overall prevalence of diabetes and heart disease were 10 and 122
respectively 236 subjects reported the problem of loneliness and depression
forgetfulness was also reported by 3296 As far as treatment seeking behavior is
concerned approach of elderly is quite different for different morbidities The main source
of treatment for morbidities such as hypertension respiratory urinary GIT-related and
musculoskeletal problems was quacks 30
17
Review of literature
A study done by Mohammad Maharoof et al (2016) on the health problems among
the aged in Urban Aligarh UP revealed that of the 225 study subjects 782 had cataract
followed by depression in 356 refractive error in 276 loco-motor problem in 213
and hearing loss in 138 The prevalence of hearing loss was significantly related to gender
as it was higher among females with 181 compared to males in whom it was 6931
A study done by Gowri Shankar and Bhayalaxmi Sidenur (2016) on morbidity of
elderly residing in an urban area of Bagalkot revealed that the most common morbidity was
Cataract seen in 2875 followed by musculoskeletal problems in 2813 and 2313
were known hypertensive Both diabetes mellitus and hypertension was observed in 10 of
the study subjects32
A study done by Leena Rahul Salunkhe (2015) on socio-demographic profile of old
age people living in urban amp urban slum areas in Maharashtra Karad revealed that 504
and 42 elderly suffered from arthritis in an urban area and a slum respectively Number of
diabetics were higher in urban (14) than urban slum (35) 301 of subjects from urban
area suffered from hypertension compared to 161 from urban slums Upper Respiratory
Infections was more in slum dwellers (196) than people residing in urban area (7) Acid
peptic diseases were found in 168 study subjects in urban area and 154 in slum area 33
In a study done by Warbhe Priyanka A and Warbhe Rupesh (2015) on morbidity
profile health seeking behaviour and home environment survey of the elderly in an urban
slum community it was found that 941 had 1-3 morbidities 41 had 4-6 morbidities
373 gave a history of fall and 314 had history of fracture 136 subjects had been
18
Review of literature
operated for cataract 168 had undergone a procedure for fracture and10 had undergone
a dental procedure 542 went to Urban health center (UHC) and Government hospitals for
treatment and 786 received both allopathic and Ayurvedic treatment34
A study done by Man Mohan Gupta et al (2015) on Assessment of Clinico-
socioeconomic status and health-care support among the elderly people aged older than 60
years in urban population of Bhopal revealed that 353 subjects received treatment for
their morbidities from the Government hospitals whereas 267 from private
clinichospital About 653 study subjects presented with complaints and morbidity The
common morbidities which were found in the subjects were fatigue (487) backache
(353) Obesity (393) and hypertension (247)35
In a study done by Shilpa Shaukaiah et al (2015) on prevalence of morbidity pattern
among geriatric age group in an urban slum of Mumbai it was found that body ache was the
most commonly reported symptom by 290 followed by visual problems in 2318 joint
pain in 2181 indigestion in 2045 and backache in 2045 subjects36
A study done by Shubha Davalagi B et al (2015) on morbidity psycho-social profile and
health seeking behavior of the elderly population in urban slums of Davangere City revealed
that the most common morbidity which was present in the study subjects was
musculoskeletal problems in 46 psychosocial problems were present in 31 and
respiratory problems in 23 Majority of the elderly (56) utilized government
institutions for treatment of chronic disease and 47 for treatment of acute disease The
elderly population had financial constraints and lack of accessibility in seeking health care37
19
Review of literature
A study done by Vandana Nikumb et al ( 2015) on morbidity Profile among Geriatric
Population in an Urban Area of Navi Mumbai revealed that 9312 elderly were morbid and
with increasing age the number of morbidities was found to be increasing In this study it
was found that the most common morbidity was psychosocial problems which include
stress which was present in 594 subjects followed by musculoskeletal problems in
556 and eye problems like diminished vision mostly due to cataract in 463
Hypertension dental problems respiratory problems ENT problems (hearing impairment)
and endocrine disorders like diabetes accounted for 281 219 119 106 and10
respectively38
A study done by Vishnoi BR et al (2015) on Morbidity Profile of Elderly in Urban
Slum of Udaipur Rajasthan revealed that 61 of the study subjects had impaired vision
followed by 25 who had hypertension 1533 suffered from insomnia 1467 had
anemia and 14 suffered from gastrointestinal problems The condition of females was
worse compared to males39
In a study done by L Subedhi and RB Sah (2015) on the health status of geriatric age
group in Chitwan district of Nepal it was found that of the 300 study subjects 44 had
Ophthalmic problems 43 had GIT problems 33 had CVS problems 23 had ENT
problems 1567 had metabolic disorders and 533 had mental disorders The study
highlighted a high prevalence of morbidity and health related problems in the geriatric age
group40
20
Review of literature
A study done by Sofia Noor et al (2015) on health status of geriatric population in slums
of Rourkela revealed that the morbidities among the elderly that were found to be significant
were hypertension decreased visual acuity urinary problems and insomnia Apart from
systemic morbidities 91 of the elderly also complained of fragility which includes
complex physiological deterioration and unexplained weight loss41
In a study conducted by VM Sarode (2014) on Chronic Diseases Related to Ageing and
Disease Prevention in Slums in Mumbai it was found that there were highly significant
disorders among aged women related to Skin lesion and super infection Untreated bacterial
pharyngitis acute rheumatic fever while disorders among aged men were related to
hypertension Illicit drug use diabetes and asthma It was found that 49 of elderly males
and 45 of elderly females had not sought any treatment for their illness Of the people who
had sought treatment 93 elderly males and 92 of elderly females had taken treatment
from Government hospital42
A study conducted by Sanjeev Kumar Barman et al (2014) on morbidity profile of
geriatric population in an urban slum of Kishnganj Bihar revealed that the prevalence of
anemia cataract and hypertension were quite high 6375 6125 and 5063
respectively Loss of income amp occupation along with a feeling of neglect from the family
members were the common problems among the elderly It was also found that morbidities
like arthritis loss of teeth amp dental caries along with depression had a significant association
with sex age amp educational status of the study subjects43
21
Review of literature
A study done by Khadervali Nagoor et al (2014) on the health status of elderly
population in an urban area of Kadapa revealed that out of the 200 elderly persons studied
Visual problem due to cataract and refractive errors were present in 72 of the study
subjects followed by pain in joints in 595 gastrointestinal problems in 46 and dental
problems in 44 Other morbidities were hypertension in 42 genitourinary problems in
25 dermatological problems in 235 and psychological problems in 1644
A study done by Kakkar R et al (2013) on morbidity profile among geriatric population
in District Dehradun revealed that the working geriatric group was healthy as compared to
those who were retired Hypertension was the commonest morbidity among all age groups
In the age group of 60-70 years the following morbidities were seen hypertension (306)
followed by diabetes (153) arthritis (14) CVS morbidities (14) cataract (96) and
BPH (83) Among 71-80 years age group Hypertension (287) followed by arthritis
(167) cataract (157) Diabetes (111) BPH (111) and CVS morbidities (93)45
In a study done by Bhawalkar JS et al (2013) on morbidity profile among geriatric
population in an urban area of Pune it was found that Musculoskeletal disorder was the
most common (4331) followed by eye problems (3722) and hypertension (137)It
was seen that 43 elderly population had some health problem but only 8 visited the
health facilities Among them 6 visited private practitioners and only 18 went to
municipal hospitals It was found that only 2322 elderly were taking any medications and
the most commonly used drug was anti-inflammatory drugs 2323 followed by
antihypertensive drugs 136746
22
Review of literature
A study conducted by Deepak Sharma et al (2013) on morbidity pattern and health-
seeking behavior of aged population residing in Shimla revealed that the following
morbidities were present in the study subjects hypertension was the commonest (56)
followed by Musculoskeletal problems (535) Dental problems (27) cataract (23)
anemia (15) and acid peptic disease (175) 658 of the subjects were seeking
treatment for their health problems Majority of the older people preferred allopathic
medicine (812) followed by Ayurvedic medicines (113) and homeopathic medicine
(73) for their health problems Most of the older persons preferred going to a
CHCGovernment hospital for treatment for their illness There was considerable use of
over-the-counter drug by125 of the people 47
A study done by JP Singh et al (2013) on Geriatric morbidity profile in an urban slum of
Nagpur central India revealed that the most common morbidity identified in the study
population was anemia (9650) followed by hypertension (345) arthritis (3225)
cataract (21) and diabetes (1775) More than 2 morbidities were present in 325 of
the study subjects followed by four morbidities in 3125 and two morbidities in 23548
A study conducted by RP Thakur et al (2013) on the health problems of the elderly in
central India revealed that among the elderly residing in the urban areas 384 of the urban
elderly had both dental problems and arthritis followed by anemia in 348 hypertension in
266 cataract in 252 and diabetes mellitus in 157 The prevalence of self-reported
depression was 672 among the urban female elderly when compared to 397 among the
urban females49
23
Review of literature
A study done by Mrinal Ranjan Srivastav et al (2013) on Morbidity Status and its
Social determinants among elderly population of Lucknow revealed that the most common
morbidity among the urban population was eye problems which affected 516 males and
67 females followed by CVS problems in 363 males and 395 females and GIT
problems in 315males and 382 females50
A study done by Shraddha K et al (2012) on morbidity pattern among elderly in urban
population of Mysore revealed that out of the 526 study subjects 486 suffered from the
disease of the eye and adnexa followed by 384 who suffered from endocrine and
metabolic disorders 331 suffered from the disease of the circulatory system 323 had
disease of the oral cavity and salivary glands and 302 had disease of the musculoskeletal
system 51
A study done by Vimala Thomas et al (2012) on morbidity profile and health seeking
behaviour of the elderly in urban slums of Hyderabad revealed that hypertension was the
most common morbidity in 469 followed by Arthritis in 302 Diabetes in 265
respiratory problems in 243 and Cataract in 21 For out-patient treatment 472 visited
private sectors 303 Government facility 25 RMP and 06 AYUSH clinics For in-
patient treatment 198 visited private institutions 16 visited Government institutions
while 642 did not visit either52
24
Review of literature
A study done by Soe Moe et al (2012) on health seeking behaviour of elderly in
Myanmar revealed that 35 of the male elderly perceived that they were having good
health status whereas 229 of them perceived having a poor health status 343 of female
elderly perceived that they were having good health status while 24 of them perceived
having a poor health About 49 of the elderly went to rural health center for treatment
followed by 33 who went to private practitioners 15 visited hospitals and 3 went to
more than one place for treatment53
A study done by Dharamvir Ranjan Bharati et al (2011) in Puducherry revealed that in
the urban areas about 707 of the study subjects had anemia followed by 537 who had
visual impairment and hypertension and 532 suffered from diabetes mellitus It was seen
that On univariate analysis the risk of diabetes mellitus was significantly higher among
elderly from urban areas than that among elderly from rural areas and significantly lower
risk in elderly from below poverty line than in those belonging to normal (not below poverty
line)54
A study done by Rajashree Bhat et al (2011) on the morbidity pattern among the elderly
population in Ahmedabad revealed that most common morbidity of elderly was the
problems of loco-motor system (486) followed by vision (427) and hypertension
(344) In this study only 37 of elderly had psychosocial problems55
A study done by Krishnamachari Srinivasan et al (2010) in an urban area of Bangalore
revealed that 494 subjects had hypertension 323 had diabetes 281 had arthritis
279 suffered from Genitourinary and cardiovascular disease It was observed that about
25
Review of literature
49 of the respondents made less than three physician visits and 13 were hospitalized for
health related problems during the past one year 56
A study done by Kajal Srivastava et al (2010) on the morbidity pattern of the elderly in
urban Agra revealed that 9529 of the elderly were morbid in the slum areas The most
common morbidity which was seen among the elderly people residing in urban slums was
anemia which was seen in 3843 followed by cataract in 298 arthritis in 2431 and
hearing impairments in 2157The system wise distribution of the morbidity pattern
showed the most common systemic involvement was visual disorders 5216 followed by
musculoskeletal system 4784 and the gastrointestinal system 4314 The number of
morbidities was found to be increasing with age and this association with age was
statistically significant57
A study done by Abdullah Ladha et al (2009) on the health seeking behaviour of elderly
population in a poor-urban community of Karachi Pakistan revealed that 164 of the
elderly people were Diabetic and 301 had Hypertension The Common symptoms that
prompted elderly of to seek health care were fever (612) generalized body aches (434)
and cough (404) About 614 responders reported factors which deterred them from
seeking health care out of which 62 reported financial constraint as the commonest factor
Deterrence from seeking health care was associated with illiteracy and living alone58
26
Methodology METHODOLOGY
The study was conducted in the urban field practice area of JJM Medical college
Davangere The city of Davangere is situated in the central part of Karnataka state
265 km north of the state capital Bengaluru along the national highway number 4
Figure 5 Maps showing the location of Davangere district and the area where the
UHTC is located
27
Methodology
Figure 6 Map showing the Urban field practice area of JJM medical college
28
Methodology
Table 3 List of areas covered under the UHTC of JJM Medical
College Davangere
Areas covered Total population Bethur road 1374 Hedge nagar 1213 Mehboob nagar 3042 Mustafa nagar A 2093 B D layout A 1084 Mustafa nagar B 1127 Mahavir nagar 930 Muddabovi colony 1094 Maganhalli 1221 Tippu nagar 968 B D layout B 1717 Batti layout 1080
STUDY AREA The study was conducted in the urban field practice area of JJM
Medical College Davangere which consists of 12 areas with a total population of
16943
STUDY DESIGN Cross sectional study
STUDY POPULATION Persons aged 60 years and above
Total Population Covered 16943
29
Methodology
INCLUSION CRITERIA subjects aged 60 years and above living in the study area
for more than one year duration
EXCLUSION CRITERIA Subjects who we r e no t w i l l i ng t o pa r t i c ipa t e i n
t he s t udy
STUDY PERIOD 1 year from 1st December 2015 to 30th November 2016
SAMPLE SIZE As quoted by Manmohan Gupta et al 35 in the studies done in various
parts of India the prevalence of morbidity in the geriatric population ranges from 31-80
Considering the prevalence of morbidity to be about 50 in the geriatric population at 95
confidence level and allowable error of 10 and a non -response rate of 10 sample size
was calculated to be 440 using the formula
n=4pq L2
n= sample size
4= factor to achieve 95 level of confidence
p= prevalence of morbidities ie 50
q= 100- p ie 100-50 = 50
L= permissible error in the estimate of ldquoprdquo (10 of p)
n = 4 x 50 x 50 = 400
5 x 5
After calculating a non-response rate of 10 a sample size of 440 was calculated
30
Methodology
A community based cross sectional study was conducted in the urban field practice
area of JJM Medical College Davangere The Urban field practice area has a total
population of 16943 and there are 12 areas in urban field practice area of JJM Medical
College Davangere
The Study was conducted by probability proportionate sampling The sample size for each
area was derived from the formula
1198991 =119875119900119901119906119897119886119905119894119900119899 119894119899 119890119886119888ℎ 119886119903119890119886
119879119900119905119886119897 119875119900119901119906119897119886119905119894119900119899119883 119878119886119898119901119897119890 119878119894119911119890
Example 1st area has a population of 1374 so
1198991 =1374
16943119883 440 = 36
Therefore 36 elderly subjects were selected by house to house visit from 1st area Same
procedure was applied for other areas until the desired sample size of 440 was reached
MATERIALS USED FOR DATA COLLECTION
The following tools were used for data collection
Semi-structured predesigned and pre-tested questionnaire
Portable bathroom weighing machine
Stretch- resistant measuring tape
Mercury Sphygmomanometer
Others - stethoscope torch tuning fork knee hammer
ICD-10 for system wise classification of disease59
31
Methodology METHOD OF COLLECTION OF DATA After establishing rapport with the family
and explaining the data collection procedure in the local language an informed verbal
consent was obtained from each individual and data was collected using a
Predesigned semi structured questionnaire by Interview method The questionnaire
comprised of the following information socio-demographic data of the study subjects
information regarding the morbidity pattern and health seeking behaviour If there were
more than one elderly subjects in the same household then all were included
The study subjects were asked about any ho illness (communicable or non-
communicable) which they were suffering from Upon a positive response the subjects were
further asked to specify the type(s) and duration of morbidities that they were suffering
from eg heart disease diabetes gastrointestinal diseases respiratory disease etc Some
were unable to understand or answer questions due to illness In such cases help was sought
from the family members Based on the self-reported symptoms information from
hospital records and clinical examination the prevalence of different morbidities among the
study subjects was assessed The Information about the health seeking behaviour was
sought by asking the study subjects about their visits to a health facility in case of an illness
and also the type of health facility visited ( Government private or quacks )
DATA ENTRY AND ANALYSIS Data was entered and analyzed using MS Excel and
Open Epi Info version 2260 Both descriptive and inferential statistics were used Subjectrsquos
baseline characteristics were presented as frequencies and percentages Categorical
variables between the groups were compared using Chi square test and Fisherrsquos exact
test Fisherrsquos exact test was used when more than 20 cells had expected value lt 5 and any
one of the cells had expected value lt 1 All statistical analysis was carried out at 5 level
of significance and p value lt005 was considered as significant
32
Methodology ETHICAL CLEARANCE
Ethical clearance was obtained before conducting the study from the Ethical Committee of
JJM Medical college Davangere [ANNEXURE III] During the study verbal
informed consent was taken from the study subjects Assurance was given that the
confidentiality concerning their information will be maintained
Clinical Examination included
(a) General physical examination
(b) Anthropometric measurements like height and weight
(c) Systemic examination
(d) Measurement of Blood pressure
(e) Eye examination by torch and Snellenrsquos (E chart)61
(f) Hearing assessment by Rinnersquos test Webberlsquos and Absolute bone conduction
test using tuning fork 62
Parameters used in our study
Height Height was measured with a standard non-stretchable measuring tape to the
nearest 01 cm in standing position (without footwear standing upright with the
back against the wall heels together and eyes directed forward)
33
Methodology Weight Weight was measured with minimal clothing and respecting the modesty of the
individual without footwear using a calibrated standard bathroom weighing scale to the
nearest 05 kg
Body Mass Index (BMI) Using weight (in Kg) and height (in meter2) BMI was calculated by applying the formula
Body Mass Index= Weight (kg) Height (m2)
The BMI cut off values for Asians as recommended by the WHO was used in our study
Table 4 WHO Categorization of Body Mass index (BMI) for Asians 63
Measurement of Blood pressure Procedure Blood pressure was measured in the left arm in a sitting posture with the subject in a
relaxed state Standardized mercury sphygmomanometer with adult size cuff was used
The first appearance of (phase 1 of Korotkoff sounds) sound was used to define
Systolic Blood Pressure (SBP) The disappearance of sound (phase 5) was used to
define Diastolic Blood Pressure (DBP) Two readings were taken five minutes apart and
the average of the two readings was taken as the final blood pressure reading A person
was considered to be a hypertensive if he she was already diagnosed case of
hypertension and or on treatment or with a current SBP of ge 140 mm Hg or DBP ge 90 mm
Hg (JNC VII criteria)64
BODY MASS INDEX INFERENCE
lt 185 underweight
185 to 229 kg m2 Normal
23 to 249 kg m2 Overweight
ge 25 kg m2 Obese
34
Methodology
Table 5 JNC VII Classification of Blood pressure 65
BP Classification Systolic Blood Pressure Diastolic Blood Pressure
Normal lt120 lt 80
Pre Hypertension 120 ndash 139 or 80 ndash 89 Stage 1 Hypertension 140 ndash 159 or 90 ndash 99 Stage 2 Hypertension ge 160 or ge 100
Anaemia was detected by pallor of conjunctiva tongue and nails and was confirmed by
doing haemoglobin estimation using sahlirsquos hemogobinometer66
The cut off for the diagnosis of anaemia was done based on WHO classification67
Diabetes - self reported cases of diabetes were considered as diabetics for the study
STUDY VARIABLES
1 AGE - subjects aged 60 years and above were taken up for the study Age was
recorded to the nearest complete years as stated by the respondent
2 GENDER Both males and females were taken up for the study
3 EDUCATIONAL STATUS 68
i Illiterate -A person who could not read or write
ii Primary School - studied up to 4th standard
iii Higher primary- studied between 5th and 7th standard
iv Secondary school -studied between 8th and 10th standard v Intermediate- studied between 11th or 12 th standard or diploma
vi Graduate - obtained graduate degree
vii Post Graduate- obtained post graduate degree
35
Methodology
4 OCCUPATION STATUS69
i Unskilled worker
Labourer domestic servants casual worker peon sweeper porter washer-man others
(vegetable vendor)
ii Semi-skilled worker
Factory worker agriculture laborers shoemaker potters others (security guard shop
helper canteen helper
iii Skilled
Artisan clerk foreman supervisor carpenter tailor mechanic electrician railway guard
painter modeler smiths baker driver shop assistant petty trader constable soldier
linesman pointsman potter barber others (tinkering printer receptionist salesman
welder cook mason postman plumber agarbatti worker)
iv semi-professional
Teacher pharmacist social worker owner of a small business farmer others (computer
programmer Govt employee nurse)
V Professional
Doctor engineer principal lawyer Military officer senior executive business
proprietor writer scientist large employer director university professor police
officer others (horse rider)
(vi) Unemployed Presently not working retired homemakers
36
Methodology 5 SOCIO ECONOMIC STATUS
Table 6 Socio-economic status (SES)- As per modified BG Prasad Classification70
5 TYPE OF FAMILY 71
Joint Family ndash It is type of family grouping in which a number of married couples and
their children live together in the same household All the men are related by blood
and women of household are their wives unmarried girls and widows of family kinsmen
Nuclear Family - It consist of married couple and their children while they are still
regarded as dependents
Three generation family - It is a family where representatives of three generation are
living together Young married couples continue to stay with their parents and have
their own children as well
Socio-economic
status
Prasadrsquos classification
1961(Per capita income in
Rupees per month)
Modified BG Prasad classification-
updated for May 2016 ((per
capita income in Rupees per
month)
I 100 and above 6261 and above
II 50-99 3099-6260
III 30-49 1835-3098
IV 15-29 949-1834
V Below 15 lt948
37
SAMPLE SIZE ESTIMATION
SAMPLE SIZE As quoted by Manmohan Gupta et al 35 in the studies done in various
parts of India the prevalence of morbidity in the geriatric population ranges from 31-80
Considering the prevalence of morbidity to be about 50 in the geriatric population at 95
confidence level and allowable error of 10 and a non -response rate of 10 sample size
was calculated to be 440 using the formula
n=4pq L2
n= sample size
4= factor to achieve 95 level of confidence
p= prevalence of morbidities ie 50
q= 100- p ie 100-50 = 50
L= permissible error in the estimate of ldquoprdquo (10 of p)
n = 4 x 50 x 50 = 400
5 x 5
After calculating a non-response rate of 10 a sample size of 440 was calculated
A community based cross sectional study was conducted in the urban field practice area of
JJM Medical College Davangere The Urban field practice area has a total population of
16943 and there are 12 areas in urban field practice area of JJM Medical College
Davangere
The Study was conducted by probability proportionate sampling The sample size for each area
was derived from the formula
1198991 =119875119900119901119906119897119886119905119894119900119899 119894119899 119890119886119888ℎ 119886119903119890119886
119879119900119905119886119897 119875119900119901119906119897119886119905119894119900119899119883 119878119886119898119901119897119890 119878119894119911119890
Example 1st area has a population of 1374 so
1198991 =1374
16943119883 440 = 36
Therefore 36 elderly subjects were selected by house to house visit from 1st area Same
procedure was applied for other areas until the desired sample size of 440 was reached
Results
RESULTS
The results are presented under the following headings
I Socio-demographic characteristics of study subjects
II Prevalence of morbidities among the study subjects
III Details of health seeking behavior of the study subjects
38
Results
ISocio-demographic characteristics of the study subjects
Table 7 Age and sex wise distribution of the study subjects
Figure 7 Age and sex wise distribution of the study subjects
In the present study Out of 440 study subjects majority 162(368) were in the age group
of 60-64 Years followed by 109 (247) in the age group of 65-69 Years 99 (225) were
in the age group of 70-74 Years and 35 (8) were more than or equal to 80 years of age
Majority of the subjects were males 260 (59) and 180 (41) were females The mean age
of the study population was 6745 plusmn 655 Years
354 254 262
88 42
389
239 172
67 133
0102030405060708090
100
60-64 65-69 70-74 75-79 ge80
Perc
enta
ge
Age in years
Males
Females
Age group (in years)
Males Females Total
Percentage () Frequency
(n=260) Percentage ()
Frequency (n=180)
Percentage ()
60-64 92 354 70 389 162 368
65-69 66 254 43 239 109 247
70-74 68 262 31 172 99 225
75-79 23 88 12 67 35 80
ge80 11 42 24 133 35 80
Total 260 100 180 100 440 100
39
Results
Table 8 Distribution of the study subjects based on religion
Religion Frequency (n=440) Percentage ()
Hindu 188 427
Muslim 252 573
Total 440 100
Figure 8 Distribution of the study subjects based on religion
In the present study it was found that the majority of the study subject belonged to Muslim
religion 252 (573) followed by Hindus 188 (427)
0102030405060708090
100
Hindu Muslim
427
573
Perc
enta
ge
Religion of the study subjects
40
Results
Table 9 Distribution of the study subjects based on Educational status
Education Frequency (n=440) Percentage ()
Illiterate 231 525
Primary school 121 275
Higher primary 38 86
Secondary School 30 68
Intermediate 6 14
Graduate 14 32
Total 440 100
Figure 9 Distribution of the study subjects based on Educational status
In the present study it was found that the Majority of the study subjects were illiterate
231(525) 121(275) had completed education up to primary school 30(68) had
completed education up to secondary school and only 14(32) were graduates
525
275
86 68
14 32
0102030405060708090
100
Perc
enta
ge
Educational status of study subjects
41
Results Table 10 Distribution of the study subjects based on occupation
Occupation Frequency (n=440) Percentage ()
Semi-professional 2 05
Skilled worker 45 102
Semi-skilled worker 68 155
Unskilled worker 100 227
Unemployed 225 511
Total 440 100
Figure 10 Distribution of study subjects based on their occupation
In our study it was found that the majority of the study subjects 225 (511) were
unemployed followed by 100 (227) who were unskilled workers 68 (155) were semi-
skilled workers and 45 (102) were skilled workers
0102030405060708090
100
05 102 155 227
511
Perc
enta
ge
Occupation of the study subjects
42
Results Table 11 Distribution of the study subjects based on socio-economic status (Modified
BG Prasad classification 2016)
Figure 11 Distribution of the study subjects based on their socio-economic status
In our study majority of the subjects 215 (49) belonged to Class IV Socioeconomic status
followed by 115 (26) who belonged to class III and 56 (13) who belonged to class II
SES (according to Modified BG Prasad Classification 2016)
Class II 13
Class III 26
Class IV 49
Class V 12
Socio-economic status Frequency (n=440) Percentage ()
Class I 0 0
Class II 56 13
Class III 115 26
Class IV 215 49
Class V 54 12
Total 440 100
43
Results
Table 12 Distribution of the study subjects based on their marital status
Marital status Frequency (n=440) Percentage ()
Unmarried 2 05
Married 323 734
Widowwidower 115 261
Total 440 100
Figure 12 Distribution of the study subjects based on their marital status
In our study it was found that majority of the study subjects 323(734) were married
followed by 115(261) who were widowed and only 2 (05) were unmarried
0102030405060708090
100
Unmarried married Widowwidower
05
734
261 Perc
enta
ge
44
Results
Table 13 Distribution of the study subjects based on the type of family
Type of family Frequency (n=440) Percentage ()
Nuclear family 163 37
Joint family 93 21
Three generation family 184 42
Total 440 100
Figure 13 Distribution of the study subjects based on the type of family
In the present study it was found that majority of the study subjects 184 (42) lived in a
three generation family followed by 163 (37) who lived in a nuclear family and 93(21)
who lived in a Joint family
Nuclear family 37
Joint family 21
Three generation
family 42
45
Results
II Prevalence of morbidities among the study subjects
Figure 14 Distribution of the study subjects based on the BMI
In the present study it was found that out of 440 study subjects 198 (45) had a normal
BMI followed by 132 (30) who were overweight 66 (15) were obese and only 44
(10) were underweight
under weight 10
Normal 45
Overweight 30
Obese 15
46
Results
Table 14 Distribution of morbidity pattern of the study subjects based on ICD 10
classification of diseases
System involved ICD 10
Males (n=260)
Females (n=180)
Total (n=440)
No No No
Diseases of musculoskeletal system (M00 ndash M99)
184 707 130 722 314 714
Diseases of the eye and adnexa (H00 ndash H59)
139 534 80 444 219 497
Diseases of oral cavityamp salivary glands (K00 ndash K14)
90 346 64 355 154 35
Endocrine nutritional amp metabolic diseases (E00 ndash
E90)
70 269 75 417 145 329
Diseases of circulatory system (I00 ndash I99)
64 246 73 405 137 311
Diseases of respiratory system(J00 ndash J99)
64 246 37 206 101 23
Diseases of digestive system (K00 ndash K93)
57 219 30 166 87 198
Diseases of skin amp subcutaneous tissue (L00 ndash
L99)
38 146 20 111 58 132
Diseases of the ear and mastoid process (H60 ndashH95)
39 15 18 10 57 13
Diseases of genitourinary system (N00 ndash N99)
22 85 7 39 29 66
Diseases of nervous system (G00 ndash G99)
6 23 5 28 11 25
Note Total number could not be given as many subjects had multiple disorders
47
Results
Figure 15 Distribution of morbidity pattern of the study subjects based on ICD 10
classification of diseases
In the present study it was found that the majority of the subjects 314 (714) suffered
from the disorders of the musculoskeletal system followed by 219 (497) who suffered
from the disease of the eye and adnexa154 (35) suffered from the disease of the oral
cavity 145 (329) suffered from endocrine nutritional and metabolic disorders137
(311) suffered from the disease of the circulatory system 101 (229) suffered from the
disease of the respiratory system 87(198) suffered from the disease of the digestive
system 58 (132) suffered from disease of the skin 57 (13) suffered from the disease of
the ear 29 (66) suffered from the disease of the genitourinary system and only 11( 25 )
suffered from the disease of the nervous system
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
714
497
35 329 311 229
198 132 13 66
25
perc
enta
ge
48
Results
Table 15 Distribution of the study subjects based on morbidity of the musculoskeletal
system
Musculoskeletal
Disease
Males
(n=260)
Females
(n=180)
Total
(n= 440)
Statistical
Value
Knee joint pain
52 (20)
30 (167)
82 (186)
X2 = 0779
df = 1
p=03773
Back ache
30 (115)
35 (194)
65 (148) X2 = 528
df = 1
p = 0021
Joint pain (other than
knee joint pain)
52(20)
35(194)
87(198)
X2 =00206
df=1
p =0885
Non-specific aches
and pain
50(192)
30(167)
80(182)
X2=0470
df=1
p = 0492
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses
In the present study it was found that the most common morbidity of musculoskeletal
system was pain of the joints (other than the knee joint) found in 87 (198) of the subjects
followed by knee joint pain in 82 ( 186) and non-specific pains and aches were found in
80 (182) of the subjects It was found that back ache was more common in females
35(194) compared to males 30 (115) and this difference was found to be statistically
significant
49
Results
Table 16 Distribution of the study subjects based on morbidity of the eye and adnexa
Diseases of the
eye and
adnexa
Males
(n=260)
Females
(n=180)
Total
(n= 440)
Statistical
value
Cataract
112(43)
60(333)
172(391)
X2 = 4241
df=1
p = 0039
Refractive error
20(77)
14(78)
34(77)
X2= 0001
df=1
p = 0973
Others (conjunctivitis
pterygium glaucoma etc)
7(27)
6(33)
13(29)
X2=0152
df=1
p = 0696
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses
In the present study it was found that the most common morbidity of the eye was cataract
found in 172 (391) of the subjects It was more common in males 112 (43) compared to
females 60 (333) and this difference was found to be statistically significant The other
morbidities present were refractive error found in 34 (77) subjects and others which
includes conjunctivitis pterygium glaucoma etc found in 13 (29 ) subjects
50
Results
Table 17 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the oral cavity
Diseases of the
oral cavity
Males
(n =260 )
Females
(n =180 )
Total
(n = 440)
Statistical
value
Stained teeth
22 (84)
18 (10)
40 (91)
X2 =0304
df=1
p = 0581
Missing teeth
40 (154)
38 (211)
78 (177)
X2= 239
df= 1
p=0122
Caries
28 (108)
8 (44)
36 (82)
X2= 566
df= 1
p=0017
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses
In the present study it was found that the most common morbidity of the oral cavity was
missing teeth found in 78 (177 ) of the subjects followed by stained teeth found in 40
(91) of the subjects and dental caries in 36 (82) of the subjects Dental caries were
more common in males 28 (108) compared to females 8(44) and this difference was
found to be statistically significant
51
Results
Table 18 Distribution of study subjects based on endocrine nutritional and metabolic
disorders
Disorders Males
(n =260 )
Females
(n =180)
Total
(n = 440)
Statistical value
Diabetes mellitus
45 (173)
37 (206)
82 (186)
X2 = 0739
df= 1
p = 0389
Anemia
24 (92)
35 (194)
59 (134)
X2= 955
df = 1
p = 0001
Thyroid disorders
1(04)
3 (17)
4 (09)
p= 0309
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
The present study revealed that the most common disorder of the endocrine system was
diabetes mellitus found in 82 (186) of the subjects followed by the nutritional disorder of
anemia found in 59 (134) of the subjects It was seen that anemia was more common
among females 35 (194) compared to males 24 (92) This difference was found to be
statistically significant Disorders of the thyroid gland were found in 4 (09) of the subjects
being more common in females 3(17) compared to males 1 (04)
52
Results
Table 19 Distribution of the study subject based on disease of the circulatory system
Diseases of
circulatory
system
Males
(n=260 )
Females
(n =180)
Total
(n = 440)
Statistical
value
Hypertension
62 (238)
71 (394)
133 (302)
X2= 1227
df= 1
p = 0000
CAD MI
Arrhythmias
2 (08)
2 (11)
4 (09)
p =100
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
In our study it was found that the most common disease of the circulatory system was
hypertension which was found in 133 (302 ) of the subjects it was more common in
females 71 (394) compared to males 62 (239) and this difference was found to be
statistically significant The other disorders of the circulatory system were CAD MI
arrhythmias which were found only in 4 (09) of the study subjects
53
Results
Table 20 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the respiratory system
Disorders of
Respiratory
System
Males
(n=260)
Females
(n=180)
Total
(n=440)
Statistical
value
Bronchial asthma
3 (12)
3 (17)
6 (14)
p =0692
URTI
45 (173)
27 (15)
72 (164)
X2= 0413
df = 1
p = 0520
Acute Bronchitis
12 (46)
7 (39)
19 (43)
X2= 0135
df = 1
p = 0712
Pulmonary TB
4 (15)
0(00)
4 (09)
p =0148
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
Our study revealed that the most common disease of the respiratory system was URTI
(upper respiratory tract infection) found in 72 (164) subjects followed by acute bronchitis
in 19 (43 ) bronchial asthma in 6 (14) and pulmonary TB in only in 4 (09 ) subjects
Pulmonary TB was found in 4 (15) of the males whereas no females had TB however
this difference was not found to be statistically significant
54
Results
Table 21 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the digestive system
Disorders of
Gastrointestinal
system
Males
(n = 260)
Females
(n = 180)
Total
(n = 440)
Statistical value
Constipation
21(8)
6 (33)
27(61)
X2 =4155
df =1
p =0041
Gastritis
24 (92)
18 (10)
42(95)
X2= 0072
df = 1
p =0787
Bleeding per
rectum 3(12) 2(11) 5(11)
p =100
Others (Pain
abdomen
anorexia
indigestion)
9(35)
4 (22)
13 (3)
X2=0569
df =1
p=0450
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
Our study revealed that the most common disorder of the gastrointestinal system was
gastritis found in 42 (95) subjects followed by constipation in 27 ( 61) others which
include pain abdomen anorexia indigestion was found in 13 (3) and bleeding per rectum
was seen in 5 (11) It was seen that constipation was more common among males 21(8)
compared to females 6 (33) which was found to be statistically significant
55
Results
Table 22 Distribution the study subjects based on disease of the Skin and
subcutaneous tissue
Disorders of skin and
subcutaneous tissue
Males ( n = 260)
Females (n = 180)
Total (n = 440)
Statistical
value
Itching
19(73)
2(11)
21(48)
X2 =896
df=1
p = 0002
Scaling 6 (23)
3 (17)
9 (2)
p =0743
Pigmentation
5(19)
4 (22)
9 (2)
p =100
Dryness
8 (31)
11 (61)
19(43)
X2= 237
df = 1
p = 0123 Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
In the present study it was found that the most common disease of the skin was itching
which was present in 21 (48) of the study subjects followed by dryness in 19 (43) and 9
(2) of the subjects had scaling and pigmentation It was seen that itching was more
common among males 19 (73) compared to females 2 (11) and this difference was
found to be statistically significant
56
Results
Table 23 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the ear
Disease of the ear
Males
(n= 260)
Females
(n = 180)
Total
(n = 440) Statistical value
Hearing impairment
33 (126)
16 (89)
49 (111)
X2 =155
df =1
p =0212
Ear discharge
3 (12)
1 (06)
4(09)
p =0647
Tinnitus
3 (12)
1 (06)
4 (09)
p =0647
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
In the present study it was observed that hearing impairment was the most common
morbidity of the ear found in 49 (111) of the subjects though it was more common
among males 33 (126) compared to females 16 (89) the difference was not found to be
statistically significant The other disorders which affected the ear were ear discharge and
tinnitus both present in 4 (09) of the subjects
57
Results
Table 24 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the genitourinary
system
Disorders of
genitourinary system
Male
(n = 260)
Female
(n = 180)
Total
(n=440)
Statistical value
Burning micturition
2 (077)
2 (11)
4 (09)
p=100
Increased frequency of
micturition
20(77) 5(28) 25(57)
X2= 4794
df =1
p =0028 Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
In our study it was observed that the most common morbidity affecting the genitourinary
system was increased frequency of micturition in 25 (57) of the subjects followed by
burning micturition in 4 (09) of the study subjects Increased frequency of micturition was
more common among males 20 (77) compared to females 5 (28) and this difference
was found to be statistically significant
58
Results
Table 25 Distribution of the study subjects based on diseases of the Nervous system
Disease of the
nervous system Males
(n = 260)
Females
(n = 180)
Total
(n = 440)
p value
Memory loss
2 (77)
2 (11)
4 (09)
100
Stroke
2 (77)
0 (00)
2 (05)
0515
Neuritis
2 (77)
3 (17)
5 (11)
0652
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
Our study revealed that the most common disorder of the nervous system was neuritis seen
in 5 (11) of the subjects followed by memory loss in 4 (09) and stroke in 2 (05 ) of
the subjects It was observed that 2 (0 77) of males had suffered a stroke whereas none of
the females had suffered from stroke however this difference was not found to be
statistically significant
59
Results
Table 26 Association between morbidity pattern of the study subjects and their age
group
System involved 60-69Yrs
(n = 271)
70-79Yrs
(n = 134)
gt 80Yrs
(n = 35)
Total
( n = 440)
Statistical
value
Musculoskeletal
System
195 (72)
94 (70)
25 (710)
314 (714) X2= 0143
df = 2 p = 0930
Eye amp adnexa
125 (461)
69 (515)
25 (714)
219 (497) X2= 8166
df = 2 p = 0016
Oral cavity amp salivary gland
56 (207)
68 (507)
30 (857)
154 (350) X2= 7865
df = 2 p lt 00001
Endocrine nutritional amp
metabolic diseases
91 (335)
47 (35)
7 (200)
145 (329) X2= 297
df = 2 p = 0225
Circulatory
system
87 (321)
40 (298)
10 (285)
137 (311) X2= 0328
df = 2 p = 0848
Respiratory
system
64 (236)
31 (231)
6 (171)
101 (23) X2= 0738
df = 2 p = 0691
Digestive system
52 (191)
28 (210)
7 (200)
87 (191) X2= 0166
df = 2 p = 0 920
Skin and subcutaneous
tissue
43 (159)
13 (97)
2 (57)
58 (132) X2= 4831
df = 2 p = 0089
Ear amp mastoid process
27 (99)
20 (149)
10 (285)
57 (13) X2= 1018
d= 2 p = 0006
Genitourinary
system
20 (74)
8 (59)
1 (29)
29 (66) X2= 1151
df = 2 p = 0562
Nervous system
5 (18)
4 (29)
2 (57)
11 (25)
p = 0418
Figure in parenthesis indicates percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
60
Results
Table 26 shows the association between the morbidity pattern and age group of the study
subjects It is observed that the disease of the eye and adnexa increase with increasing age
and are more common in individuals above 80 years of age (714) compared to
individuals in the age group of 60-69 years (461) and 70-79 years (515) This
difference was found to be statistically significant The disease of the oral cavity were also
more common in the subjects aged 80 years and above (857) compared to individuals in
the age group of 70-79 years (507) and 60-69 years (207) this difference was also
found to be statistically significant Significant association was also found between
increasing age and disease of the ear 285 subjects aged 80 years and above suffered from
disease of the ear followed by 149 in the age group of 60-69 years and 99 in the age
group of 60-69 years
61
Results Table 27 Association between morbidity pattern of the study subjects and their
occupation
System involved Employed (n=215)
Unemployed (n=225)
Total (n=440)
Statistical value
Musculoskeletal
system
171 (795) 143 (635) 314 (714) X2 =1374 df=1
p=00002
Eye and adnexa 108 (502) 111(493) 219(497) X2= 0035 df=1
p= 0850
Oral cavityamp
salivary glands
76 (353) 78 (347) 154 (35) X2=0022 df=1
p=0880
Endocrine
nutritional amp
metabolic
disease
75 (348) 70 (311) 145 (329) X2=0708 df=1
p=0400
circulatory
system
58 (269) 79 (351) 137 (311) X2=3393 df=1
p=0065
Respiratory
system
49 (227) 52 (231) 101 (23) X2=0006 df=1
p=09363
Digestive system 45 (21) 42 (187) 87 (198) X2=0125 df=1
p=0723
Skin
subcutaneous
tissue
38 (176) 20 (88) 58 (132) X2=741 df=1
p=0006
Ear and mastoid
process
31 (144) 26 (115) 57 (13) X2=0799 df=1
p=0371
Genitourinary
system
16 (74) 13 (57) 29 (66) X2=0494 df=1
p=0481
Nervous system
2 (093) 9 (4) 11 (25) X2=425 df=1
p=0039 Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses
62
Results
Table 27 shows the association between the morbidity pattern and occupation of the study
subjects It was observed that musculoskeletal disorders were more common among the
subjects who are employed (795) compared to those who are not employed (635) and
this difference was found to be statistically significant A significant association was also
seen between the disorders of the skin and subcutaneous tissue 176 subjects who are
employed suffered from the disease of the skin and subcutaneous tissue compared to 88
who were unemployed The diseases of the nervous system were more common among
those who were unemployed (4) compared to those who were employed (093) this
difference was also found to be statistically significant
63
Results Table 28 Association between morbidity pattern of the study subjects and their
religion
System involved Hindu
(n=188)
Muslim
(n=252)
Total
(n=440)
Statistical value
Musculoskeletal system 138 (73) 176 (698) 314 (714)
X2=0668 df=1
p=0413
Eye and adnexa 100 (531) 119 (472) 219 (497) X2=1535 df=1
p= 0215
Oral cavityamp salivary glands 73 (388) 81 (321) 154 (35)
X2=211 df=1
p=0145
Endocrine nutritional amp metabolic diseases
53 (2819) 92 (365) 145 (329) X2=3371 df=1
p=0066
circulatory system 58 (269) 79 (351) 137 (311)
X2=3393 df=1
p=0065
Respiratory system
33 (176) 68 (269) 101 (229)
X2=5415 df= 1
p=0019
Digestive system 27 (144) 60 (238) 87 (198) X2=6059 df=1
p=0013
Skin subcutaneous tissue
31 (164) 27 (107) 58 (132) X2=3138 df=1
p=00765
Ear and mastoid process
28 (149) 29 (115) 57 (129) X2=1095 df=1
p=0297
Genitourinary system
16 (85) 13 (52) 29 (66) X2=1965 df=1
p=0161
Nervous system
4 (21) 7 (28) 11(25) p=0764
Figure in parenthesis indicates percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
64
Results
Table 28 shows the association between the morbidity pattern of the study subjects and their
religion In our study it was observed that the disorders of the digestive system were more
common among Muslims (238) compared to Hindus (144) this difference was found
to be statistically significant Also the disorders of the respiratory system were more
common among Muslims (269) compared to Hindus (176) This difference was also
found to be statistically significant Some of the diseases were more common among Hindus
which include the disease of the eye and adnexa (531) oral cavity (388) ear (149)
skin and subcutaneous tissue (164) and genitourinary system (85) but it was not found
to be statistically significant
65
Results
III HEATLTH SEEKING BEHAVIOR OF THE STUDY SUBJECTS
Figure16 Distribution of the study subjects based on the visit to health facility in case
of an illness
In our study it was found that that out of 440 study subjects 395(898) visited a health
facility in case of an illness whereas 45(102) did not visit any health facility in case of an
illness
898
102
health facility visitednot visited
66
Results
Table 29 Reasons cited by the study subjects for not seeking healthcare in case of an
illness
In the present study it was found that the most common reason stated by the 45 study
subjects for not seeking health care in case of an illness was that it was a mil 20 (444)
followed by lack of money stated by12 (267) the other reasons stated were no one to
accompany 7 (156) and lack of faith in health care 6 (133)
Reasons cited for not
seeking health care
Frequency (n=45)
Percentage ()
Mild discomfort 20 444
Lack of money 12 267
Lack of faith in
healthcare
6 133
No one to accompany 7 156
Total 45 100
67
Results
Table 30 Distribution of the study subjects based on the type of health facility visited
It was observed that out of 395 subjects who visited health care facility in case of an illness
229(58) Visited government hospitals 160 (405) visited private practitioners hospitals
and 6 (15) visited quacks More number of males (622) visited government hospitals
compared to females (513)
Type of health facility visited
Males
(n=241)
Females
(n=154)
Total
(n=395)
No No No
Government hospital 150 622 79 513 229 58
Private practitionershospitals 87 361 73 474 160 405
Quacks 4 17 2 13 6 15
Total 241 100 154 100 395 100
68
Results
Table 31 Association between gender and health seeking behaviour of the study
subjects
Whether visited
health facility
in case of illness
Sex
Total
n ()
p value Male
n ()
Female
n ()
Yes 241 (927) 154 (856) 395 (898) 00151
No 19 (106) 26 (144) 45 (102)
Total 260 (59) 180 (41) 440 (100)
x2=5901 df =1
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
It was observed that more number of males visited a health care facility in case of an illness
241(927) whereas only 154(856) females visited a health facility in case of an illness
This difference was found to be statistically significant
69
Results
Table 32 Association between educational status and health seeking
behaviour of the study subjects
Whether visited Health facility in case of illness
p value
Educational status(n) Yes () No ()
0000
Illiterate (231) 194 (84) 37 (16)
Primary school (121) 115 (95) 6 (49)
Higher primary (38) 37 (974) 1 (26)
Secondary school (30) 29 (967) 1 (33)
Intermediate (6) 6 (100) 0(00)
Graduate (14) 14 (100) 0(00)
Total(440) 395 (898) 45(102)
Fisherrsquos exact test
In the present study it was found that 84 of the study subjects who were illiterate visited a
health facility in case of an illness whereas 16 did not visit a health facility in case of an
illness 967 of the subjects with education up to secondary school visited the health
facility and 100 of the subjects who studied up to intermediate and with a graduate degree
visited the health facility in case of an illness This difference was found to be statistically
significant
70
Results
Table 33 Distribution of study subjects according to frequency of visits to a health care facility
Frequency of visits to a health care facility
Frequency
(n=395)
Percentage
Once a month 207 524
Once in 3 months 99 251
Once in 6 months 79 20
Once in a year 10 25
Total 395 100
In the present study it was found that out of 395 study subjects who visited a health care
facility in case of an illness 207 (524) visited a health facility every month followed by
99 (251) who visited once in 3 months 79(20) once in 6 months and 10 25 visited
the health facility once in a year
71
Discussion
DISCUSSION
I Socio-demographic characteristics
Our study was done in the urban field practice area of JJM Medical College Davangere
among 440 geriatric subjects our study aimed at assessing the morbidity pattern and health
seeking behaviour of the geriatric population in the study area
In the present study Out of 440 study subjects majority 162(368) were in the age
group of 60-64 Years followed by 109 (247) in the age group of 65-69 Years 99 (225)
in the age group of 70-74 Years and 8 were more than or equal to 80 years of age [Table
7] This was similar to a study conducted by Prakash Boraingaiah et al 72 in which majority
of the elderly (346) belongs to age group 60-64 years followed by age group 75 years and
above (259)
In our study it was also seen that 59 of the study subjects were males and 41 were
females This was similar to a study conducted by Mohan Gupta et al 35 where 573
subjects were males and 427were females Our findings were contrary to a study
conducted by Md Alam Naushad et al 28 where 598 subjects were females and 402
were males
In the present study it was found that the majority of the study subject belonged to
Muslim religion 252 (573) followed by Hindus 188 (427) there were no study subjects
who belonged to other religions like Christian Jain Sikhs etc [Table 8] similar findings
were seen in a study conducted by Mrinal Ranjan Srivastav et al 50 in which 52 of the
subjects were Muslims
72
Discussion
In the present study it was found that the Majority of the study subjects were illiterate
525 whereas 275 had completed education up to primary school 82 had completed
education up to secondary school and only 32 were graduates [Table 9] These findings
were similar to a study done by Shraddha K et al 51in which 504 of the study subjects
were illiterate
In our study it was found that the majority of the study subjects 511 were unemployed
followed by 227 who were unskilled workers 155 were semi-skilled workers and
about 105 were skilled workers [Table 10] These findings were similar to a study done
by Rajat Das Gupta et al27 al in which 481 of the study subjects were not working
In our study majority of the subjects 49 belonged to Class IV Socioeconomic status
followed by 26 who belonged to class III and 13 who belonged to class II (according to
Modified BG Prasad Classification 2016) [Table 11] Similar findings were found in a study
conducted by Sribas Goswami and Manjari Sahai 29 in which majority of the study subjects
belonged to class IV socio economic status
In our study it was found that the majority of the study subjects 734 were married
followed by 261 who were widowed and only 05 were unmarried [Table 12] These
findings were similar to a study done by L subedhi and RB Sah 40 in which 663 of the
subjects were married 322 were widowed and 07 were unmarried
In the present study it was found that majority of the study subjects 42 lived in a three
generation family followed by 37 who lived in a nuclear family and 21 who lived in a
Joint family [Table 13] These findings were similar to a study done by Swapnil Jain et al 26
in which the majority (47) of the study subjects lived in a three generation family
73
Discussion
II Prevalence of morbidities among the study subjects
In the present study it was found that majority of the subjects 45 had a normal BMI
followed by 30 who were overweight about 15 were obese and only10 were
underweight [Figure 14] Similar findings were reported in a study conducted by Khadervali
Nagoor et al 44 in which 49 subjects had a normal BMI In a study done by Vimala
Thomas et al 52 272 of the subjects were obese which was higher than the present study
In the present study it was found that the majority of the subjects suffered from the
disorders of the musculoskeletal system (714) eye and adnexa (497) oral cavity
(311) respiratory system (229) digestive system (198)disease of the skin
(132)ear(13)genitourinary system (66) nervous system (25) [Table14] Similar
findings were seen in a study done by Rajashree Bhat et al 55 in which most common
morbidity of elderly was the problems of loco-motor system (486) followed by vision
(427) CVS disorders (344) respiratory system (202) and disease of ear (179)In
this study though the prevalence of loco-motor system disorders (486) was highest
compared to other disorders it was lesser compared to our study (714) In a study done by
L subedhi and RB Sah 40 it was found that 44 had eye problems 43 had gastrointestinal
problems 33 had CVS problems and 23 had ENT problems In this study the prevalence
of gastrointestinal disorders was much higher compared to our study
In the present study joint pain (including the knee joint) was most common disorder of the
musculoskeletal system seen in 40 of the males compared to 384 in females [Table 15]
whereas in a study done by Swapnil Jain et al 26 it was found that 472 males and 528
females suffered from joint pains This could be attributed to the fact that in our study
majority of the study subjects were males
74
Discussion
In the present study it was found that the most common morbidity of the eye was cataract
found in 39 of the subjects It was more common in males 43 compared to females
333 [ Table 16]These findings were similar to a study done by Shraddha K et al 51 in
which the overall prevalence of cataract was 302 of which 42 males and 358
females had cataract
In the present study it was found that the most common morbidity of the oral cavity was
missing teeth found in 177 of the subjects [Table 17] it was similar to the findings of a
study conducted by JP Singh et al 48 in which 1475 subjects were edentulous
The present study revealed that the most common disorder of the endocrine system was
diabetes mellitus found in 186 of the subjects followed by the nutritional disorder of
anemia found in 134 of the subjects It was seen that anemia was more common among
females 194 compared to males 92 [Table 18] Kakkar R et al 45 reported similar
findings with prevalence of diabetes mellitus as 153 In a study done by Deepak Sharma
et al 47 anemia was present in 15 of the subjects 97 males and 21 females were
anemic which was similar to our study
In our study it was found that the most common disease of the circulatory system was
hypertension which was found in 302 of the subjects it was more common in females
394 compared to males 239 and this difference was found to be statistically significant
[Table 19] A study by L Subedhi and RB Sah 40 reported that the prevalence of
hypertension was more among females (333) compared to males (30) which was
statistically significant
75
Discussion
In our study the most common morbidity of the respiratory system was upper respiratory
tract infection (163) [Table20] it was similar to the study done by Leena Rahul
Salunke33 where it was reported to be 196
In our study the most common disorder of the digestive system was gastritis (95)
[Table 21] similar to the findings of JP Singh et al 48 (35) contrary to this L subedhi
and RB Sah 40 reported a high prevalence of gastritis (39) This difference could be
attributed to the difference in the interpretation of symptoms for the diagnosis of gastritis
In our study the most common disorder of the skin was itching (48) [ Table 22] which
was similar to the findings reported by JP Singh et al 48 in which 225 subjects suffered
from itching
In our study the most common disorder of the ear was impaired hearing (111) [Table
23] similar to a study by Vandana Nikumb et al 38 in which 106 subjects suffered from
hearing impairment
In our study it was observed that the most common morbidity affecting the
genitourinary system was increased frequency of micturition (57) [Table 24]
L subedhi and RB Sah40 found in their study that 143 subjects suffered from increased
frequency of micturition which was higher compared to our study
Our study revealed that 25 subjects suffered from the disorders of the nervous
system [Table 25] similar to a study conducted by Vandana Nikumb et al 38 in which
13 of the Subjects suffered from the disorders of the nervous system whereas in a
study conducted by Shilpa Shaukaiah et al36 it was found that 66 of the subjects
suffered from the disorders of the nervous system which was higher than our study
76
Discussion
It is observed that the disease of the eye and adnexa increased with increasing age and were
more common in individuals above 80 years of age (714) The disease of the oral cavity
were also more common in the subjects aged 80 years and above (857) and 285
subjects aged 80 years and above suffered from disease of the ear A significant association
was found between age and these morbidities [Table 26] Similar results were found in a
study done by Swapnil Jain et al 26 in which cataract hearing impairment and dental
problems were significantly associated with the age of the study subjects
In our study a significant association was found between occupation and the disorders of
the musculoskeletal system skin and the nervous system Disorders of the musculoskeletal
system were more common among employed subjects (795) compared to unemployed
(635) 176 subjects who were employed suffered from the disease of the skin and
subcutaneous tissue compared to 88 who were unemployed Diseases of the nervous
system were more common among those who were unemployed (4) compared to those
who were employed (093) [Table 27]
A study done by Kakkar R et al45 found that there was a significant association between the
employment status and the morbidities of the CVS arthritis and cataract CVS morbidity
was more common among those not working (164) compared to those working (36)
Arthritis was also more common among not working (212) compared to those working
(55) and cataract was also more common among those not working (175) compared to
those working (55)
77
Discussion
In our study it was observed that there was a significant association between religion and
disorders of the digestive system and respiratory system The disorders of the digestive
system were more common among Muslims (238) compared to Hindus (144) Also the
disorders of the respiratory system were more common among Muslims (269) compared
to Hindus (176) [Table 28] In a study conducted by Mrinal Ranjan Srivastav et al 50 it
was found that there was significant association between religion and the morbidities of the
genitourinary system in the urban areas The problems of the genitourinary system were
more common among Hindus (26) compared to Muslims (96)
III HEATLTH SEEKING BEHAVIOR OF THE STUDY SUBJECTS
In our study it was found that that (898) study subjects visited a health facility in case
of an illness whereas 102 did not visit any health facility in case of an illness[Figure 16]
Similar findings were seen in a study conducted by Vimala Thomas et al 52 where it was
found that 716 subjects visited a health facility Contrary to our findings a study
conducted by Bhawalkar JS et al46 showed that only 81 subjects visited a health facility in
case of an illness whereas 919 did not visit any health facility
In the present study it was found that the most common reason stated by study subjects
for not seeking health care in case of an illness was that it was a mild discomfort (444)
followed by lack of money stated by (267) other reasons stated were no one to
accompany (156) and lack of faith in health care (133) [Table 29] In a study
conducted by Deepak Sharma et al 47 it was found that the most common reasons for not
seeking health care were the following disease due to age (496) health services too far
(191) lack of money (6) no body to take to hospital (35)
78
Discussion
It was observed that out of 395 subjects who visited health care facility in case of an illness
58 Visited government hospitals 362 visited private practitioners hospitals and 15
visited quacks [Table 30] similar results were found in a study conducted by Deepak Sharma
et al 47 in which 607 went to Government hospitals 267 consulted private practitioners
and 126 took over the counter drugs In another study conducted by Rajat Das Gupta et al
27 it was found that 33 visited Government hospitals 25 visited private hospitals 6
visited private practitioners
It was observed that more number of males (927) visited a health care facility in case of
an illness whereas only 856 females visited a health facility in case of an illness [Table
31] In a study done by Man Mohan Gupta et al 35 it was found that 672 females and
651 males visited a health facility in case of illness
In the present study it was found that 848 of the study subjects who were illiterate
visited a health facility in case of an illness whereas 152 did not visit a health facility in
case of an illness A significant association was found between educational status and
gender [Table 32] In a study done by Deepak Sharma et al 47 it was found that Gender
literacy income and marital status were not found to be significantly related to health-
seeking behaviour
In the present study it was found that 524 subjects visited a health facility every month
followed by 251 who visited a health facility once in 3 months 20once in 6 months
and 25 visited a health facility once in a year[ Table 33] In a study conducted by Rajat
Das Gupta et al 27 it was found that majority of the subjects (2943) visited a health
facility once a year followed by 2813 who visited a health facility once in three months
79
Conclusion
CONCLUSION
The study revealed that some of the common morbidities among the geriatric subjects were
the disorders of the musculoskeletal system followed by the disease of the eye and adnexa
oral cavity endocrine nutritional and metabolic disorders etc some disorders like cataract
dental caries constipation and increased frequency of micturition were more common
among males whereas disease like anemia and hypertension were more common among
females A significant association was found between some of the morbidities and socio
demographic determinants like age occupation and religion
Any degree of formal schooling was found to be associated with better health seeking
behavior Majority of the subjects visited a Government health facility in case of an illness
and the main reason that was stated for not visiting a health facility was that they suffered
from mild discomfort and did not consider it necessary to visit a health facility
80
Summary
SUMMARY
Our study was done in the urban field practice area of JJM Medical College Davangere
among 440 geriatric subjects our study aimed at assessing the morbidity pattern and health
seeking behaviour of the geriatric population in the study area
The results of our study are as follows
ISocio-demographic characteristics of the study subjects
In the present study 368 subjects were in the age group of 60-64 Years
59 of the subjects were males and 41 were females
573 subjects were Muslims whereas 427 were Hindus
Majority of the subjects were illiterate (525) whereas 275 had completed
education up to primary school
It was found that the majority of the study subjects (511) were unemployed
49 subjects belonged to Class IV Socioeconomic status according to Modified BG
Prasad Classification
734 of the subjects were married
42 of the people lived in a three generation family
II Prevalence of morbidities among the study subjects
Majority of the subjects (45) had a normal BMI followed 30who were
overweight
Majority 714 subjects suffered from the disorders of the musculoskeletal system
followed by 497 who suffered from the disease of the eye and adnexa35
suffered from the disease of the oral cavity 329 suffered from endocrine
nutritional and metabolic disorders and 311 suffered from the disease of the
circulatory system 229 suffered from the disease of the respiratory system198
81
Summary
suffered from the disease of the digestive system132 suffered from disease of the
skin13 suffered from the disease of the ear66 suffered from the disease of the
genitourinary system and 25 suffered from the disease of the nervous system
The most common morbidity of musculoskeletal system was pain of the joints (other
than the knee joint) found in 198 of the subjectsBack ache was more common in
females 231 compared to males 163 and this difference was found to be
statistically significant
cataract found in 39 of the subjects It was more common in males 43 compared
to females 333 and this difference was found to be statistically significant
Missing teeth were found in 177 of the subjects Dental caries were more
common in males 108 compared to females 44 and this difference was found to
be statistically significant
Diabetes mellitus found in 186 of the subjects followed by the nutritional disorder
of anemia found in 134 of the subjects anemia was more common among females
194 compared to males 92 This difference was found to be statistically
significant
Hypertension which was found in 302 of the subjects it was more common in
females 394 compared to males 239 and this difference was found to be
statistically significant
upper respiratory tract infection) found in 163 subjects followed by acute
bronchitis in 43 bronchial asthma in 14 and pulmonary TB in only 09
Gastritis was found in 95 subjects followed by constipation in 61 Among
males (81) had constipation compared to females(03)
Most common disease of the skin was itching which was present in 48 of the
study subjects followed by dryness in 43
82
Summary
Hearing impairment was found in 111 of the subjects
Increased frequency of micturition was found in 57 of the subjects followed by
burning micturition in 09 of the study subjects Increased frequency of
micturition was more among males 77 compared to females in whom it was 28
and this difference was found to be statistically significant
The most common disorder of the nervous system was neuritis seen in 11 of the
subjects followed by memory loss in 09 and stroke in 05 of the subjects
A significant association was found between increasing age and the morbidities of
the eye ear and the oral cavity
Significant association was found between occupation and the disorders of the
musculoskeletal system skin and the nervous system Disorders of the
musculoskeletal system were more common among employed subjects (795)
compared to unemployed (635) 176 subjects who were employed suffered
from the disease of the skin and subcutaneous tissue compared to 88 who were
unemployed Diseases of the nervous system were more common among those who
were unemployed (4) compared to those who were employed (093)
It was observed that the disorders of the digestive system were more common
among Muslims (238) compared to Hindus (144) this difference was found to
be statistically significant Also the disorders of the respiratory system were more
common among Muslims (269) compared to Hindus (176) This difference
was also found to be statistically significant
83
Summary
III HEATLTH SEEKING BEHAVIOR OF THE STUDY SUBJECTS
In our study 898 subjects visited a health facility in case of an illness whereas
102 did not
The most common reason stated by study subjects for not seeking health care in case
of an illness was that it was a mild discomfort (444) followed by lack of money
stated by (267) the other reasons stated were no one to accompany (156) and
lack of faith in health care (133)
It was observed that 58 subjects Visited Government hospitals 362 visited
private practitioners hospitals and 15 visited quacks
Majority of males (927) visited a health care facility in case of an illness whereas
only 856 females visited a health facility in case of an illness This difference was
found to be statistically significant
A significant association was found between the educational status and health
seeking behaviour Majority of the educated subjects visited a health facility in case
of an illness compared to those who were illiterate
It was found that 524 subjects visited a health facility every month followed by
251 who visited a health facility once in 3 months 20once in 6 months and
25 visited a health facility once in a year
84
Limitations
LIMITATIONS
1 Many of the responses were subjective and there were no records to verify them
2 Some of the morbidities were diagnosed only by clinical examination and could not be
confirmed by performing diagnostic tests due to high cost and time constraints
3 This study was done in the urban field practice area which consisted of a closed
community hence the results cannot be generalized to the entire population of the area
85
Recommendations
RECOMMENDATIONS
1 Health education should be given to the geriatric people regarding the common health
problems associated with ageing and preventive care should be provided to the elderly
2 Geriatric clinics should be set up at the primary health care level which provide regular
screening and health check-ups
3 There should also be a provision to provide domiciliary care by specialists qualified in
geriatrics
4 The family members and the care givers of the elderly should be educated about the
common health problems of the elderly and also about the need for regular health check-ups
and emotional support
5 The majority of the geriatric population is out of work force they are suffering from
many morbidities and are totally dependent on others even for their health needs Hence the
Government should increase the pension of the elderly and provide them quality healthcare
free of cost
6 There is also a need for public private partnership to improve the quality of health
services for the geriatric people More number of NGOs should work towards improving the
health and the quality of life of the elderly
86
References
REFERENCES
1 United Nations Department of Economic and Social affairs Population Division
World population ageing 2013 Available from URL
wwwunorgendevelopmentpopulationageingWorldPopulationAgeing2013
[Accessed on 17-7-2016]
2 Khan S and Itrat M Current Issues in Geriatric Health Care in India-A Review J Community Med Health Care 2016 1(1) 1-3
3 United Nations Department of Economic and Social Affairs Population Division
World Population Ageing 2015 ndash Highlights Available from URL
wwwunorgendevelopmentdesapopulationpdfageingWPA2015_Reportpdf
[Accessed on 272017]
4 State of elderly in India 2014 Help age India Available from URL
httpswwwhelpageindiaorgimagespdfstate-elderly-india-2014pdf [Accessed on
1082017]
5 World Health Organization World report on ageing and health 2015Available
from URL wwwwhointageingeventsworld-report-2015-launchen [Accessed on
1272017]
6 National policy for Senior citizens March 2011Ministry of Social Justice and
welfare Govt of India Available from URL
socialjusticenicinwritereaddataUploadFilednpscpdf [Accessed on 482017]
87
References
7 Elderly in India Profile and programmes 2016Govt of India Ministry of statistics
and programme implementation Central Statistics Office Available from URL
wwwmopsigovin [ Accessed on 1442017]
8 Saxena V Kandpal SD Gael D Bansal S Health status of elderly community
based study Indian Journal of Community Health2012 Oct-Dec24(4)269-74
9 Shah T Patel M Shah V Health care seeking behaviour of urban and rural
community in Ahmedabad district Int J Med Sci Public Health20132908-11
10 Sahoo H Mishra NR Health Status Morbidity Pattern and Treatment Seeking
Behaviour among Elderly in India Evidence from 60th round of National Sample
Survey Data Learning community 2011 Dec 2(3) 341-55
11 Park K Parkrsquos Textbook of Preventive and social medicine 24 th ed Jabalpur MS
Banarsidas Bhanot Publishers2017631
12 UNFPA- state of World Population 2011Chapter 1 setting the scene 19-31
Available from URL httpswwwunfpaorgsitesdefaultfilesresource-
pdfUNFPA-Report-Chapter1pd [Accessed on 1082017]
13 Lal S Adarsh Pankaj Textbook of community Medicine 4th ed CBS publishers and
distributors PvtLtd2011732
14 Census of India 2001 Registrar General And Census Commissioner India
Available from URL httpwwwcensusindiagovinCensus[Accessed on
7102015]
15 SRS bulletin October 2012 Registar General of India New Delhi Available from
URL censusindiagovinvital_statisticsSRS_BulletinsSRS_Bulletin-
October_2012[Acessed on 7102015]
88
References
16 Bagchi K Healthy ageing Health and Population-Perspectives and Issues 2000
23(1)11-16
17 Salagre SB The Association of Physicians of India Chapter 177 Health Issues in
Geriatrics Available from URL
wwwapiindiaorgmedicine_update_2013chap177pd [ Accessed on 282017]
18 Ingle GK Nath A Geriatric Health in India Concerns and Solutions Indian Journal
of Community Medicine 2008 33(4)214-18
19 World Health Organization Active Ageing a policy framework 2002 Available
from httpwhqlibdocwhointhq2002who_nmh_nph_028pdf [Accessed on
1062017]
20 Inche Zainal Abidin S Sutan R Shamsuddin K Prevalence and determinants of
appropriate health seeking behaviour among known diabetics Results from a
community-based survey Advances in Epidemiology 2014 Nov 20141-6
21 Begashaw B Tessema F Gesesew HA Health Care Seeking behavior in Southwest
Ethiopia Plos one 2016 Sep 11(9)e0161014
22 MacKian S Health systems development Manchester University of Manchester
2003 A review of health seeking behavior problems and prospects
23 Metta EO Health-seeking behaviour among adults in the context of the
epidemiological transition in Southeastern Tanzania A focus on malaria and
diabetes [Groningen] University of Groningen 2016 228 Available from URL
httpswwwrugnlresearchportalfiles28737720Chapter_7pdf [Accessed on
1272017]
24 Adhikari D Rijal D Factors affecting health seeking behaviour of senior citizens of
Dharan Journal of Nobel Medical College 2015 Sep 4(1)57-63
25 Polisetty S Seepana M Morbidity profile of elderly individuals in urban
Visakhapatnam Int J Community Med Public Health 2017 4(2)2558-63
89
References
26 Jain S Kaware AC Doibale MK Shaikh S Radhey BK Mathurkar MP Morbidity
pattern among geriatric population in urban field practice area of district of
Maharashtra a cross sectional study Int J Community Med Public Health 2016
3(2)523-29
27 Gupta RD Loha A Roy S Morbidity pattern and health-seeking behaviour among
the senior citizens in a selected urban area of Bangladesh A cross-sectional study
South East Asia Journal of Public Health 2016 Jul 5(2)43-49
28 Naushad MA Verma N Bhawnani D Jain M Anand T Umate LV Morbidity
pattern and health seeking behaviour in elderly population of Raipur City
Chhattisgarh India Indian Journal of Community Health2016 Sep 28(3)236-41
29 Goswami S Sahai M A Study of Morbidity Pattern in Elderly Population European
Researcher Series A 2016103(2)119-28
30 Bardhan H Dixit AM Agarwal R Jain PK Gupta S Shukla SK Morbidity profile
of elderly population in Ghaziabad district a cross-sectional study Int J Med Sci
Public Health 2016 5(6)1098-1102
31 Maroof M Ahmad A Khalique N Ansari MA Health problems among the aged A
community based study from urban Aligarh Uttar Pradesh India Int J Community
Med Public Health 2016 Feb 3(4)944-47
32 Shankar G Sidenur B A morbidity study of elderly residing in urban field practice
area of SN medical college Bagalkot National Journal of research in community
medicine 2016 Oct-Dec 4(5) 229-34
90
References
33 Salunkhe LR Socio-demographic profile of old age people living in urban amp urban
slum areas in Maharashtra Karad A comparative study J of Evidence based Med
and Hlthcare 2015 Feb 2(5) 513-21
34 Warbhe P Rupesh W Morbidity profile health seeking behaviour and home
environment survey for adaptive measures in geriatric population-Urban community
study International Journal of Medical Research amp Health Sciences 2015 4(4)778-
82
35 Gupta M Borle AL Chhari N Gupta S Assessment of clinico-socioeconomic
status and health-care support among the elderly people aged older than 60 years in
urban population of Bhopal Central India Int J Med Sci Public Health 2015
4558-64
36 Sahukaiah S Shenoy A Vijayakumar BC An epidemiological study of prevalence
of morbidity patterns among geriatric age group in an urban slum of Mumbai Int J
Med Sci Public Health 2015 Jul 4(7)883-87
37 Shubha Davalagi B Angadi N Mahabalaraju DK Morbidity psycho-social profile
and health seeking behaviour of the elderly population in urban slums of Davangere
City India Int J Res Med Sci 2015 Nov 3(11)3288-91
38 Nikumb V Patankar F Behera A A Study of Morbidity Profile among Geriatric
Population in an Urban Area Sch J App Med Sci 2015 3(3)1365-69
91
References
39 Vishnoi BR Solanki SL Singhal G Meharda B Mishra N Morbidity profile of
elderly in urban slum of Udaipur Rajasthan Int J Oral Health Med Res 2015 May
2(1)9-12
40 Subedi L Sah RB Study of the health status of geriatric age group in Chitwan
district of Nepal Journal of Chitwan Medical College 2015 Mar 5(1)11-17
41 Noor S Krishnababu G Prasad KV Health status of Geriatric population in slums
of Rourkela Young Innovative Journal of Medical and Health Science 2015 May
5(3) 92-94
42 Sarode VM Chronic Diseases Related to Aging and Disease Prevention in Slums in
Mumbai Journal of Aging Science 2014 Jan 2 (1)1-6
43 Barman SK Lata K Ram R Ghosh N Sarker G Shahnawaz K A study of
morbidity profile of geriatric population in an urban community of Kishanganj
Bihar India Global Journal of Medicine and Public Health GJMEDPH 2014 3(1)
1-7
44 Nagoor K Srikanth BA Dudekula R Satna K Comparative study of health status
among slum and non-slum elderly population in Kadapa Region South India
Journal of Evolution of Medical and Dental Sciences 2014 Feb 3(5)1298-308
45 Kakkar R Aggarwal P Kandpal SD Bansal SK An Epidemiological study to assess
morbidity profile among geriatric population in District Dehradun Indian Journal of
Community Health 2013 May 25(1)39-44
46 Bhawalkar JS Dhone AB Jethani S Singru S Jadhav SL Adyanthaya S A study of
morbidity profile among geriatric population in an urban area J Evol Med Dent Sci
2013 Sep 9 36(2)6963-7
92
References
47 Sharma D Mazta SR Parashar A Morbidity pattern and health-seeking behaviour of
aged population residing in Shimla hills of north India A cross-sectional study
Journal of family medicine and primary care 2013 Apr2(2)188
48 Singh JP Singh S Kasturwar NB Hassan A Geriatric morbidity profile in an urban
slum Central India Indian Journal of Community Health 2013 Aug 25(2)164-70
49 Thakur RP Banerjee A Nikumb VB Health Problems among the Elderly A Cross
Sectional Study Annals of medical and health sciences research 2013 3(1)19-25
50 Mrinal RS Beena S Pratibha G Pankaj B Srivastava JP Atul B Morbidity Status
and Its Social Determinants among Elderly Population of Lucknow District India
Sch J App Med Sci 2013 1(6)758-64
51 Shraddha K Prashantha B Prakash B Study on morbidity pattern among elderly in
urban population of Mysore Karnataka India International Journal of Medicine and
Biomedical Research 2012 1(3)215-23
52 Thomas V Lavanya KM Morbidity profile and health seeking behaviour of the
elderly in urban slums of Hyderabad Andhra Pradesh India- A cross sectional study
International Journal of Current Research and Review 2012 Oct 1 4(19)174-80
53 Moe S Tha K Naing DK Htike MM Health seeking behaviour of elderly in
Myanmar International Journal of Collaborative Research on Internal Medicine and
Public Health 2012 4(8)1538-44
93
References
54 Bharati DR Pal R Rekha R Yamuna TV Kar S Radjou AN Ageing in
Puducherry South India An overview of morbidity profile Journal of pharmacy amp
bio allied sciences 2011 Oct 3(4)537
55 Bhatt R Gadhvi MS Sonaliya KN Solanki A Nayak H An epidemiological study
of the morbidity pattern among the elderly population in Ahmedabad Gujarat
National Journal of community medicine 2011 Jul 2(2)233-36
56 Srinivasan Krishnamachari Vaz Mario Thomas Tinku Prevalence of health related
disability among community dwelling urban elderly from middle socioeconomic
strata in Bangaluru India Indian Journal of Medical Research 2010 Apr 131(4)
515-21
57 Srivastava K Gupta SC Kaushal SK Chaturvedi M Morbidity profile of elderly a
cross sectional study of urban Agra Indian Journal of Community Health 2010 Jun
22(1)51-55
58 Ladha A Khan R Malik A Khan S Khan B Khan I et al The health seeking
behaviour of elderly population in a poor-urban community of Karachi Pakistan
Journal of the Pakistan Medical Association2009 Feb 59(2) 89-92
59 WHO ICD-10 version 2010 Geneva World Health Organization Available from
URL appswhointclassificationsicd10browse2010en [Accessed on 772017]
60 OpenEpi22OpenEpi (free) download Windows version Available from URL
enfreedownloadmanagerorgWindows-PCOpenEpi-FREEhtml
61 Tandon R Sinhota Parsonrsquos disease of the eye 22edNew Delhi Elsevier 98-100
62 Dhingra P L Dhingra S Disease of ear nose and throat and head and neck surgery
6th ed New Delhi Elsevier 201422
94
References
63 Aziz N Kallur SD Nirmalan PK Implications of the revised consensus body mass
indices for Asian Indians on clinical obstetric practice Journal of clinical and
diagnostic research 2014 May 8(5)OC01
64 Chobanion AV Bakris GL Black HR The seventh report of the joint national
committee on prevention detection evaluation and treatment of high blood pressure
the JNC 7 report JAMA 2003 2892560-72
65 The Seventh Report of the Joint National Committee on Prevention Detection
Evaluation and Treatment of High Blood Pressure (JNC 7) The GuidelinesUS
Department of Health and Human Services National Heart Lung and Blood
Institute Available at URL
httpswwwnhlbinihgovfilesdocsguidelinesjnc7fullpdf [ Accessed on
1282017]
66 Firkin F Chestman C Penington D Rush B De Gruchyrsquos clinical Hematology in
medical practice 5th edition New Delhi Blackwell science Ltd1989 32-47
67 Report of WHO consultation Nutritional Anaemias Geneva Switzerland World
Health Organization TRS-405 1968 Available from URL
whqlibdocwhointtrsWHO_TRS_405pdf [Accessed on 1282017]
68 National Family Health survey (NFHS-4) 2015-16 India Mumbai IIPS
2016Available from URL httpwwwnfhsindiaorg [Accessed on 4072017]
69 The Minimum Wages Act 1948 Ministry of Labour and Employment Government
of India Available from URL httplabourgovincontentinnerpagewagesphp
[Accessed on 1082017]
70 Khairnar M Wadgave U Shimpi P Updated BG Prasad socioeconomic
classification for 2016 Journal of Indian Association of Public Health Dentistry
2016 Oct 1 14(4)469
95
References
71 Tiwari P Tiwari S Mastering practicals community medicine 1st ed New Delhi
India Wolters Kluwer PvtLtd2013161-67
72 Boralingaiah P Bettappa P Kashyap S Prevalence of Psycho-Social Problems
among Elderly in Urban Population of Mysore City Karnataka India Indian journal
of psychological medicine 2012 Oct 34(4)360
96
PATIENT CONSENT FORM JJM MEDICAL COLLEGE DAVANGERE
DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY MEDICINE I the undersigned hereby give my consent
for investigations carried upon me I am satisfied with the information given about this
Clinical study titled ldquoA STUDY ON THE MORBIDITY PATTERN AND HEALTH
SEEKING BEHAVIOR AMONG THE GERIATRIC POULATION IN THE
URBAN FIELD PRACTICE AREA OF JJM MEDICAL COLLEGE
DAVANGERErdquo ldquoconducted by Dr RUCHI DHAR under the guidance of Dr VIDYA
GS Associate Professor I have been informed and explained the risks involved and I
hereby voluntarily and Unconditionally give my consent without any fear or pressure in
mentally sound and conscious state to participate in this study
DATE PATIENTrsquoS SIGNATURE
eEacuteeEacuteJA ordfEacuteEcirczAgravearingQAtildeAiAgraveAuml ordfAgraveAumlordmAacutelaquozAacutearingregAiAgraveAuml zAacuteordfAgravetUEacutegEacute
ryenAacutemiumlethordfEacuteAumlAmiumlDyensiumlPAgraveordfAgraveAumlAumlaringcurrenn ordfEacuteAumlrsup1poundiuml
ordfEacuteEcirczAgravearingQAtildeAiAgraveAumlvAgraveyenAacutecedilAgraveuEacuteUEacuteMbrvbaragraveUEacute yenAgravevAgraveaelig F PEacutefrac14AgraveUEacute cedilAgraveraquo ordfAgraveiAacutergAgraveAumlordfAgrave poundAacutepoundAgraveAuml CAzAgravegEacute
poundAgravepoundAgraveszlig
ordfEacuteEcirczAgravearingQAtildeAiAgraveAumlvAgraveyenAacutecedilAgraveuEacute ordmAacuteUAgraveAElig plusmnAgravecedilAgraveUcircccedilaQvEacuteigraveUEacuteAzAgraveAuml poundAgravepoundAgraveszligMbrvbaragraveUEacuteAiAgraveAumlpoundAgraveAumlszlig
cedilAgraveAEligasup1gAgraveAumlvEacuteUcircAtildepoundEacute J cedilAgraveOumlr Dyensiuml zAgrave ordfEacuteAEligcopyethrn yenAacutearinglpoundiumleth CAqiuml ordmEacutemacriumlUcirc sup1AtildeQAUiuml copyordmEacuteAtildelaquoAiAgraveAumlgiuml Dyensiuml zAgrave fjAiAgraveiAacutenaeligPiuml yenEacuteAEligAtildeyenAgraveAumlaringmacrEacuteAtildemicroAgravepoundiuml Epoundiuml zAgrave Csectethpoundiuml brvbarAtildemacriumlOslash yenAacuteaeligoumlaringQOumlAtildecediliuml JjAiAgraveAuml Dyensiuml ddordfAgraveAumlAuml ordfEacuteEcirczAgravearingQAtildeAiAgraveAuml ordfAgraveAumlordmAacutelaquozAacutearingregAiAgraveAuml zAacuteordfAgravetUEacutegEacute JAsect sup2AtildeparaethPEacuteAiAgraveAumlrAiAgraveAumldegegrave yenAgravejAtildePEacuteeumlUEacute Mfrac14AgraveyenAgravercedilAgraveAumlordfAgrave ordfEacuteEcirczAgravearinggAacutezAgrave qAacute|| gAgraveAumla zAgravesAgravegAgrave ordfAgraveAumlvAgraveAumlUcirc qAacute|| laquozAacutearing fJcediliumlordfAgraveiAacuteUAgraveethzAgraveplusmnAgraveethPAgravegAacutezAgrave yenEacuteAEligaeligAtildeyensEacutecedilAgravegiuml
EordfAgravegAgraveAuml poundAgravepoundAgraveUEacute F vAgraveyenAacutecedilAgraveuEacuteUEacute Mfrac14AgraveyenAgraveqAgraveAumlordfAgrave ordfAgraveAumlAumlpoundAgraveszlig yenAgraveaeligwAiEacuteAEligAzAgraveAuml
CAplusmnAgraveUAgravefrac14AgravepoundAgraveAumlszlig CxAgraveethordfAacuteUAgraveAumlordfAgraveAvEacute wfrac12sup1gAgraveAumlvAacuteUcircgEacuteDzAgraveYacutejAzAgrave poundAacutepoundAgraveAuml poundAgravepoundAgraveszlig
ordfAgraveAumlpoundAgravecedilAacutegEacute AiAgraveiAacuteordfAgraveAringzEacuteAtilde umlsAgraveAiAgraveAuml ordfAgraveAumlvAgraveAumlUcirc AiAgraveiAacutegAgrave MvAacuteUcircAiAgraveAumllaquoregegravezEacute poundAacutepoundAgraveAuml
vAgraveyenAacutecedilAgraveuEacute aQvEacuteigraveUEacuteAEligfrac14AgraveyenAgraveqAgraveregAuml MbrvbaragraveUEacuteAiAgraveAumlpoundAgraveAumlszlig cedilAgraveAEligasup1gAgraveAumlvEacuteUcircAtildepoundEacute
centpoundAacuteAPAgrave gEacuteAEligAtildeVAi
Annexures
ANNEXURE ndashIII
104
Annexures
PROFORMA
I General information
1 NAME
2 AGE
3 GENDER (a) Male (b) Female
4 MARITAL STATUS (a) Unmarried (b) Married (c) Widow Widower
(d) Divorced separated
5 LIVING ARRANGEMENT (a) with spouse (b) Spouse and children
(c) Children only (d) living alone (e) others
6 RELIGION (a) Hindu (b) Muslim (c) Christian (d) Others
7 ADDRESS
8 EDUCATION (a) illiterate (b) Primary school (c) higher primary
(d) secondary school (e)PUC diploma (e) Graduate (f) Postgraduate
9 OCCUPATION (a) professional (b) semi- professional (c) skilled worker
(d) Semi ndashskilled worker (e) unskilled worker (f) unemployed
10 CONTACT NUMBER
11 TYPE OF FAMILY (a) Joint (b) Nuclear (C) three generation
12 TOTAL NUMBER OF FAMILY MEMBERS
13 TOTAL FAMILY INCOME
14 PER CAPITA FAMILY INCOME
15 SOCIO ECONOMIC STATUS (Modified BG Prasad classification) I IIIIIIVV
16 DIET (a) Vegetarian (b) Mixed
17 Sleep (a) Disturbed if yes reason ______________ (b) Not disturbed
18 Bowel Regular Irregular
19 Bladder Regular Irregular
97
Annexures
20 HABITS (a) betel nut (b) tobacco (c) alcohol (d) smoking (e) others
If any of the habits present Duration (since when) _________
Frequency of consumption day_______
IIAssessment of morbidity based on history
1 Whether suffering from any chronic illness like (a) Type 2 DM (b) Hypertension
(c) Bronchial Asthma (d) TB (e) others
2 Whether suffering from cataract currently (a) Yes (b) No
3 Whether operated for cataract (a) Yes (b) No If Yes duration since operation____
4 MUSCULOSKELETAL SYSTEM
Whether the following symptoms are present
(a) Backache (b) Joint pain (c) restricted joint movements (d) pain in calves
(e) Others_________
5 RESPIRATORY SYSTEM
(a) Productive cough (b) non-productive cough (c) nasal discharge (d) breathlessness (e)
sore throat (f) sneezing
6 CARDIOVASCULAR SYSTEM
(a) Palpitations (b) chest pain (c) breathlessness
7 GASTROINTESTINAL SYSTEM
(a) Pain abdomen (b) lose stools (c) constipation (d) flatulence (e) heart burn
(f) Bleeding per rectum
8 EYE AND ADNEXA
(a) Watering (b) diminution of vision (c) redness
9 EAR
(a) Discharge (b) decreased hearing (c) Tinnitus
10 SKIN
(a) Itching (b) skin eruptions (c) scaling (d) pigmentation
98
Annexures
11 GENITO URINARY SYSTEM
(a) Burning micturition (b) increased frequency of micturition
12 GENERAL SYMPTOMS
(a) Fatigue (b) headache (c) fever
13 ANY OTHER COMPLAINTS (a) burning feet (b) swelling in groin
(c) Memory loss (d) insomnia
III Assessment of health seeking behaviour
1 Do you visit a health facility in case of illness (a) Yes (b) No
If yes how much time do you take to visit a health facility an case of an illness
(a) Within 24 hours (b) 24-48 hours (c) more than 48 hours
2 Which type of health facility do you visit
(a) Govt hospital (b) Private practitioners (c) over the counter drugs (e) quacks
Mention the reason for visiting the particular health facility______________________
3 Whether taking regular treatment after diagnosis ________________
If No mention the reason_______________________
4 Whether following the instructions given by the treating doctor
(a) Yes (b) no
5 cost of treatment per month in case of chronic disease
(a) lt100 (b) 100-200 (c) 200-300 (d) 300 and above
6 Person bearing the cost of treatment
(a) Self (b) spouse (c) son (d) daughter (d) outside help
7 Duration to reach the health facility
(a) less than 3o minutes (b) 30 minutes or more
8 Whether going for regular check -ups (a) Yes (b) No
If Yes duration between the check-ups_______
99
Annexures
9 Whether following self- care practices in case of chronic disease like diabetes and hypertension
(a) Yes (b) No
10 In case of healthy individuals whether getting screening tests done (a) Yes (b) No
11 Whether following any dietary modifications (a) yes (b) No
12 Whether any family member accompanies you to the health facility
If yes who (a) Son (b) daughter (c) spouse (d) others
11 Whether the family supports in following specific diet advised by the doctor
(a) Yes (b) No
12 whether family members help in reminding to take regular medication
(a) Yes (b) No
IV Physical examination
1 Personal hygiene status
S NO COMPONENT CONDITION REMARKS
1 Hair
2 Teeth
3 Bath
4 Clothes
5 Washing hand before
eating food
6 Washing hands with soap
and water after ablution
7 Nails
8 Foot wear
Remarks personal hygiene status Good fair poor
100
Annexures
2 MEASUREMENTS
(a) Weight (in Kg) ______ (b) Height (in cm) _____ (c) BMI ______
(d) Waist circumference______ (e) Hip circumference ___________
(f) Waist hip ratio_________
3 GENERAL PHYSICAL EXAMINATION
Pallor Icterus Cyanosis clubbing lymphadenopathy Oedema
Pulse rate Temp Blood Pressure
Respiratory rate
20 Examination of
Eye Oral cavity Ear
Nose Throat
SYSTEMIC EXAMINATION
Cardiovascular system Respiratory system
Per abdomen Central Nervous system
101
MASTER CHART
Annexures
ANNEXURES
International Classification of Diseases (10th Revision)
I Certain infectious and parasitic diseases (A00-B99)
II Neoplasms (C00-D48)
III Diseases of blood and blood forming organs and certain disorders
involving the immune mechanisms (D50-D89)
IV Endocrine nutritional and metabolic diseases (E00-E90)
V Mental and behavioural disorders (F00-F99)
VI Diseases of the nervous system (G00-G99)
VII Diseases of the eye and adnexa (H00-H59)
VIII Diseases of the ear and mastoid process ( H60-H95)
IX Diseases of the circulatory system (I00-I99)
X Diseases of the respiratory system ( J00-J99)
XI Diseases of the digestive system (K00-K93)
XII Diseases of the skin and subcutaneous tissue ( L00-L99)
XIII Diseases of the musculoskeletal system and connective tissue
(M00-M99)
XIV Diseases of the genitourinary system ( N00-N99)
XV Pregnancy childbirth and purperium (O00-O99)
XVI Certain conditions originating in perinatal period (P00-P96)
XVII Congenital malformations deformations and chromosomal
XVIII (S00-T98)
XIX External causes of morbidity and mortality (V01-Y98)
102
Annexures
XX Injury poisoning and certain other consequences of external causes
(S00-T98)
XXI Factors influencing health status and contact with health services
(Z00-Z99)
XXII Codes for special purpose
103
Annexures
105
Annexures
106
Annexures
107
Annexures
PHOTOS
Picture 1 Showing the investigator interviewing the study subject
Picture 2 Showing the investigator interacting with the study subject
108
Annexures
Picture 3 Showing the investigator recording the Blood pressure of the study subject
Picture 4 Showing the investigator auscultating the study subject
109
Annexures
110
15
Distribution of the study subjects based on morbidity of the
Musculoskeletal system
49
16
Distribution of the study subjects based on morbidity of the eye
and adnexa
50
17 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the oral cavity 51
18
Distribution of study subjects based on endocrine nutritional and
metabolic disorders
52
19 Distribution of the study subject based on disease of the circulatory
system
53
20 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the respiratory
system
54
21
Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the digestive
system
55
22
Distribution the study subjects based on disease of the Skin and
subcutaneous tissue
56
23 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the ear 57
24
Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the
genitourinary system
58
25
Distribution of the study subjects based on diseases of the Nervous
system
59
26 Association between morbidity pattern of the study subjects and
their age group
60
xiv
27
Association between morbidity pattern of the study subjects and
their occupation
62
28
Association between morbidity pattern of the study subjects and
their religion
64
29 Reasons cited by the study subjects for not seeking healthcare in
case of an illness
67
30 Distribution of the study subjects based on the type of health facility
visited
68
31 Association between gender and health care seeking behavior of the
study subjects
69
32 Association between educational status and health care seeking
behaviour of the study subjects
70
33 Distribution of study subjects according to frequency of visits to a
health care facility
71
xv
LIST OF FIGURES
Figure No
Title Page No
1 Proportion of elderly in the Indian population by age groups
1961-2001
6
2 Pathophysiology of health issues in geriatrics 10
3 Predicting health behaviour with social cognition models 13
4 Health belief model components and linkages 15
5 Maps showing the location of Davangere district and the
area where the UHTC is located
27
6 Map showing the Urban field practice area of JJM medical college
28
7 Age and sex wise distribution of the study subjects 39
8 Distribution of the study subjects based on religion 40
9 Distribution of the study subjects based on Educational status 41
10 Distribution of study subjects based on their occupation 42
11
Distribution of study subjects based on their occupation
43
12 Distribution of the study subjects based on their marital status 44
13 Distribution of the study subjects based on the type of family 45
14 Distribution of the study subjects based on the BMI 46
15 Distribution of morbidity pattern of the study subjects based on
ICD 10 classification of diseases
48
16 Distribution of the study subjects based on the visit to health
facility in case of an illness
66
xvi
ABSTRACT Background
According to census 2011 the elderly population aged 60 years and above account for 8
of total population and is projected to rise to 124 by the year 2026 Health status is an
important factor that has a significant impact on quality of life The elderly are one of the
most vulnerable and high risk groups in terms of health status and their health seeking
behaviour is crucial in any society
Objectives
1 To study the morbidity pattern among the geriatric population in the urban field
practice area of JJM Medical college Davangere
2 To assess the health seeking behaviour of the elderly residing in the study area
Methods It was a community based cross sectional study which was conducted in the urban field
practice area of JJM Medical College Davangere The total study subjects were 440
individuals aged 60 years and above Data was collected using a predesigned pre-tested
and semi- structured questionnaire Height weight and blood pressure were measured
and recorded Data was analyzed by using MS Excel and Open-Epi Info software
version 22 Statistical test employed was chi-square and Fishers exact test x
Results and Conclusion
In our study it was found that the majority of the subjects (368) were in the age group
of 60-64 years 525 were illiterate 511 were unemployed and 49 belonged to class
IV socio economic status The study revealed that the some of the common morbidities
among the geriatric subjects were the disorders of the musculoskeletal system (714)
eye and adnexa (497) oral cavity (329) endocrine nutritional and metabolic
disorders (329)etc some disorders like cataract dental caries constipation and
increased frequency of micturition were more common among males whereas disease
like anemia and hypertension were more common among females A significant
association was found between some of the morbidities and socio demographic
determinants like age occupation and religion
Any degree of formal schooling was found to be associated with better health seeking
behavior Majority of the subjects (58) visited a Government health facility in case of
an illness and the main reason that was stated for not visiting a health facility was that
they suffered from mild discomfort (444) and did not consider it necessary to visit a
health facility
Key words Geriatric urban behaviour morbidity
xi
Introduction
INTRODUCTION
ldquoA STUDY ON THE MORBIDITY PATTERN AND HEALTH SEEKING BEHAVIOUR AMONG THE GERIATRIC POPULATION IN THE URBAN FIELD
PRACTICE AREA OF JJM MEDICAL COLLEGE DAVANGERErdquo
All countries of the world are experiencing population ageing Ageing is a result of
decreasing mortality and most importantly declining fertility The global share of older
people (aged 60 years and above) has increased from 92 per cent in 1990 to 117 in
2013 and will continue to grow as a proportion of the world population reaches 211 by
20501
The lsquoNational Policy for Older Personsrsquo was adopted by the Government of India in
January 1999 and it defines a lsquosenior citizenrsquo or lsquoelderlyrsquo as a person who is aged 60 years
or above Ageing is a progressive process associated with declines in structure and
function impaired maintenance and repair systems increased susceptibility to disease and
death2
In 2015 Worldwide there were 901 million people aged 60 years or over It is
projected that their number will grow to 14 billion in 2030 which is the target date for the
SDGs and to 21 billion by 2050 There will be growth in the number of older persons aged
60 years and above between 2015 and 2030 This increase is projected to be especially
significant global phenomenon and virtually every country in the world will experience a
substantial increase including the less developed regions3 The increased life expectancy has
led to challenges in health care management The elderly suffer from various diseases which
include non-communicable disease (NCDs) like diabetes hypertension coronary heart
disease and other disorders like osteoarthritis stroke dementia osteoporosis cancer
1
Introduction enlarged prostate depression and cataract related blindness In the coming years there will
be a phenomenal growth in the population of the elderly while the family size will reduce
The disintegration of the joint family and women moving out of the household has led to the
absence of traditional caregivers for the elderly who are already a vulnerable group4
The most common cause of health problems in the old aged people is chronic diseases
Most of these problems can be prevented or delayed by engaging in healthy behaviours
Even in the advanced years of life physical activity and good nutrition can have
effective benefits on health and well-being Many health problems of old age can be
effectively managed if they are detected early enough5 The National Policy for Older
Persons was announced by the Government of India in the year 1999 The Constitution of
India under Article 41 mandates the well-being of senior citizens ldquoThe state shall
within the limits of its economic capacity and development make effective provision
for securing the right to public assistance in case of old aged peoplerdquo 6
National Council for Older Persons (NCOP) has been reconstituted and renamed as
National Council for Senior Citizens (NCSrC) in order to have a definite structure and also
regional balancing the NCOP advises the Central and State Governments on a broad range
of issues related to welfare of senior citizens and enhancement of their quality of life The
NCSrc meets at least twice a year7 The elderly suffer from multiple medical as well as
psychological problems There has already been some pioneering work on the elderly in
India but a lot more remains to be done There is an urgent need to pay attention
towards the medical and socio-economic problems that are being faced by the elderly
people in India and thus formulate strategies to bring about an improvement in their
quality of life8 The Health seeking behaviour is influenced by various factors which
include the individual self diseases and the availability and accessibility of health
2
services It is important to have knowledge regarding the health seeking behaviour of
individuals for designing health care policies and programmes so that all the possible
difficulties with early diagnosis and effective treatment can be identified and appropriate
interventions can be implemented9 As already stated the elderly are a vulnerable group as
there are psychological as well as physiological changes with increasing age and it is
difficult to cope up with the problems of ageing Some of the most common problems in old
age are cardiovascular problems arthritis respiratory problems blood pressure and so on
Therefore the study of the health status of elderly morbid conditions perceptions about
it is important to note and the health care of the elderly becomes very important since they
are more prone to illness than young people and are also more prone to domestic and other
accidents Their health and treatment seeking behaviour are most important for the
formulation of welfare programmes of the country 10
Hence this study was taken up in the urban field practice area of JJM Medical College
Davangere to assess the morbidity pattern and health seeking behaviour of the geriatric
subjects
3
Objectives
OBJECTIVES
1 To study the morbidity pattern among the geriatric population in the urban field
practice area of JJM Medical college Davangere
2 To assess the health seeking behaviour of the elderly residing in the study area
4
Review of literature
vii
REVIEW OF LITERATURE
1 Definition Geriatrics or clinical gerontology Is the term used for the care of the aged 11 The United Nations uses 60 years and above to refer to older people the same is also used
by demographers However in many developed countries the age of 65 is used as the
reference point for older persons 12
Elderly are classified in to 3 groups 13
Young old Persons in the age group of 60 years to 74 years
Old old Persons in the age group of 75 years to 84 years
Oldest old Persons above the age of 85 yrs
2 Demography of the ageing population in India
The UN defines a country as ldquoAgeingrdquo or ldquoGreying Nationrdquo where the
proportion of people over 60 reaches 7 percent to total population By 2011 India has
exceeded that proportion (80 percent) and is expected to reach 126 percent in 2025
The Indian population has increased from 361 million in 1951 to 1027 billion in 2001
and further to 121 billion in 2011 Simultaneously the number of older people has
increased from 19 million (ie 4 percent of total population) to 77 million and
further to roughly 93 million (ie 75 percent of the total) during the same time
span 14
5
Review of literature
Figure1 proportion of elderly in the Indian population by age groups 1961-2001 14
Table 1 Percentage share of elderly population (aged 60 years and above) in total
population by sex in India 15
Years Male Female Total Rural Urban
1961 55 58 56 58 47
1971 59 60 60 62 50
1981 64 66 65 68 54
1991 67 68 68 71 57
2001 71 78 75 77 67
2011 77 84 80 81 79
2004-05 69 75 72 73 70
2007-08 73 77 75 76 72
6
Review of literature
The rise in population of males was more modest from 55 percent to 71 percent while for
females there had been a steep rise from 58 percent to 78 percent during five decadal
Censuses from 1961 to 2001 In 2011 the elderly population accounted for 80 percent of
total population For males it was marginally lower at 77 percent while for females it was
84 percent According to NSSO surveys the proportion of elderly population in rural areas
was 73 percent during 2004-05 and increased up to 76 percent in 2007-08 While on the
other hand in urban areas the proportion of elderly population rose from 70 percent to 72
percent during the corresponding period It has been observed that the percentage share of
elderly to total population remained higher in rural areas than in urban areas15
Table2 Size of elderly population (aged 60+) and their share in total population in major states of India in 201115
All India and selected major states
Proportion of elderly in total population of State
Male Female Total Andhra Pradesh 83 94 88 Bihar 72 67 70 Gujarat 76 90 83 Haryana 66 76 71 Himachal Pradesh 104 103 104 Karnataka 79 89 84 Kerala 118 133 126 Madhya Pradesh 68 74 71 Maharashtra 88 97 93 Orissa 91 95 93 Punjab 91 100 95 Rajasthan 66 79 72 Tamil Nadu 102 109 105 Uttar Pradesh 66 71 68 West Bengal 82 82 82 All India 77 84 80
7
Review of literature
3 MORBIDITY PATTERN AMONG THE ELDERLY
Physiological Decline and Consequences of increasing age
Ageing i s a process of decline in biological functions affecting most physical
Systems The following systems are affected by ageing
(a) Atrophy of the Taste Buds and Loss of Teeth
With the increasing age the taste buds of the tongue get atrophied and as a result the
preference for food alters significantly There is also a considerable loss of teeth causing
difficulties in chewing food
(b) Changes in the Gastrointestinal Tract
As the age advances the walls of the intestine get atrophied and the motility is
markedly reduced (lazy intestine) The digestive enzymes secreted by the intestine are
also reduced Hence the partly digested food stays in the intestine for a longer period
As a result the common complaint of the elderly person is gas formation (flatulence)
and constipation
(c) Respiratory System
As the age advance there is progressive fibrosis of the lungs leading to reduced
oxygenation of the lungs and breathing difficulties
(d) Kidney and genitourinary System
The kidneys get smaller in size and the power of the kidneys to filter out the unwanted
waste products from the body is diminished The total amount of urine becomes less in
old age and thus the waste products are not adequately excreted from the body
8
Review of literature
(e) Urinary Bladder
Urinary bladder gets smaller in size due to shrinkage and as a result the accumulation
of urine even of a small amount leads to an urge for urination With increase in age
the valve in the bladder which controls the exit of urine from the bladder to urethra
gets atrophied and weak Involuntary leakage of urine occurs in case the bladder is full
or due to increase of pressure on bladder on sneezing or even on laughing a condition
known as urinary incontinence Incontinence is a common complaint of elder females
(f) Heart and Circulatory System
The blood vessels get rigid and quite often the vessel walls become rough with the
deposition of solid matters consisting mostly of cholesterol The heart muscles get weaker
and power to send blood throughout the body through the circulatory system gets less and
less powerful The most dangerous effect on heart is coronary heart disease especially
coronary thrombosis
(g) Muscular system
The muscles in the body get gradually atrophied with ageing and especially those
small muscles which are necessary for quick reflex action The elderly person can quite
be capable of working like a normal person and can undertake activities which require
big muscles of legs and arms But when it comes to quick movement which needs small
muscles for quick reflex movements these functions are impaired causing accidents
like slipping on wet floor of the bathroom
(h) Brain
With ageing the size of the brain gets smaller and the weight also becomes less This
however does not interfere with the function of the brain However in general the brain
cells and its fibers which carry impulses from brain to the system and upwards get
9
Review of literature
degenerated The most glaring manifestation of ageing affecting the brain is
forgetfulness and in simple terms it is inability of brain to recall the past experience
However this is common in all elderly persons
(i ) Bones
The bones become porous and fragile as age advances especially in elderly females This
condition is known as osteoporosis and leads to sustaining of fractures even after a minor
fall16
Figure 2 pathophysiology of health issues in geriatrics17
The common disease that the geriatric population suffers from are type 2 diabetes
coronary heart disease hypertension stroke chronic obstructive pulmonary disease
10
Review of literature
Alzheimerrsquos disease osteoarthritis osteoporosis prostatic hypertrophy cataracts macular
degeneration cancer etc and at the same time they are vulnerable to infections involving
respiratory (including TB) urinary and digestive tract17
In India the elderly people suffer from dual medical problems ie communicable and
nonndash communicable diseases There is also impairment of special sensory functions like
vision and hearing A decline in immunity and age-related physiological changes leads to
an increased burden of communicable diseases in the elderly A report by Indian Council
of Medical Research (ICMR) on the chronic morbidity profile in the elderly states that
hearing impairment is the most common morbidity followed by visual impairment
However different studies show varied results in the morbidity pattern18
Major chronic conditions affecting older people worldwide 19
Cardiovascular diseases (such as coronary heart disease) Diabetes Mellitus
Hypertension Stroke Cancer
Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease
Musculoskeletal conditions (such as arthritis and osteoporosis)
Mental health conditions (mostly dementia and depression)
Blindness and visual impairment
11
Review of literature
Health seeking behaviour
1 Definition
There is no common definition agreed upon by sociologists in any sociology literature
Different definitions may be used in different studies despite referring to the same activity
Sociology and literature assume that health seeking behaviour is influenced by the various
factors which include individual self or the individual diseases present and also the
availability and accessibility of health services Being dependent on these determinants and
their interactions it can be said that health care seeking behaviour is a very complex
outcome of various factors which operate at individual family and community level20
Health Seeking Behavior (HSB) refers to decision or an action taken by an individual to
maintain attain or regain good health and to prevent illness The decisions which are
made encompasses all available health care options like visiting a public or private and
modern or traditional health facility self-medication and use of home remedies or not to
utilize the available health services etc
Determining the health care seeking behavior is very important to provide a need
based health care services to the population Visiting official channels in a formally
recognized health care system has been considered as the desired Health seeking behaviour
Health seeking behavior is influenced by multiple factors including availability quality and
price of services and also social groups health views residences and personal features of the
users Peoplersquos choice of health care differs in socio demographic socio-economic and
cultural compositions and this has an effect on their health seeking behavior Urban dwellers
are generally believed to be open to new ideas and willing to try certain things on a trial and
error basis21
12
Review of literature
Health seeking behaviours two approaches
(a) Health seeking behaviours utilization of the system
This approach focuses on the actions which are taken to rectify perceived ill health and
the type of health care facility which is utilized by the people There is data which
suggests that the people visit more traditional healers and unofficial medical channels
this should be prevented and the emphasis s h o u l d b e on encouraging people to opt
first for the official channels
(b) Health seeking behaviours the process of illness response
This approach considers the factors which enable or prevent people from making
healthy choices either i n their lifestyle behaviours or use of medical care and
treatment22
Figure 3 Predicting health behaviour with social cognition models 22
13
Review of literature
2 Health belief Model of health seeking behaviour
Since lsquoHealth seekingrsquo is a conditioned behaviour any attempt which is made to
encourage people to seek health care definitely requires an understanding of their
motivation for such behaviour Only through a deeper understanding of the intricate
factors shaping behavioural practices can health promotion programmes and or
interventions successfully be introduced into the realities of the peoplersquos lives to bring
about changes in health behaviour
Behaviour change theories and models such as the Health Belief Model (HBM)
Theory of Reasoned Action (TRA) Theory of Planned Behaviour (TPB) and the
Trans theoretical model have been widely applied in public health in an attempt to
explain or predict health seeking behaviours Their use enables identification and
understanding of peoplersquos health-seeking behaviour beyond their knowledge attitudes
and practices
HBM is a health specific behavioural cognitive model This model is based on the
idea that people are more likely to change their behaviour and adhere to treatments
if they have the following perceptions (i) have a perception that they are at risk of
contracting the disease (perceived susceptibility) (ii) perception that the disease
might have an unfavorable outcome (perceived severity) (iii) perceive that the
proposed health behaviour to be both effective and practical (perceived benefits)
(iv) perceive the barriers to adopting the behaviour to be minimal (perceived
barriers)(v) perceive themselves to have the ability of applying and practicing the
specific behaviour proposed (perceived self-efficacy) and (vi) they have the cues
for motivating their actions such as internal cues (pain symptoms past experiences)
or external cues (advice from friends relatives and mass media campaigns) (cues to
14
Review of literature
action) The specificity of the HBM to health has made it suitable for use in
understanding and explaining the behaviour as well as health outcomes and this may also
explain its wider use in public health2 3
Figure 4 Health belief model components and linkages 23
3 Factors influencing health seeking behaviour
The factors affecting the health seeking behaviours are seen in various contexts which
include physical socio-economic cultural and political factors Therefore the utilization of
a health care system whether public or private formal or non- formal may depend on socio-
demographic factors social structures level of education cultural beliefs and practices and
some other factors like gender discrimination status of women economic and political
systems environmental conditions and the disease pattern and health care system itself also
have an impact on the health seeking behaviour24
15
Review of literature
REVIEW OF RELATED STUDIES
A study done by Sanjay Polisetty and Madhavi Seepana (2017) on the morbidity profile
of elderly individuals in urban Visakhapatnam revealed that of the 270 study participants
about 996 suffered from either some form of acute or chronic morbidity More than 70
of individuals suffered from eye problems of which most common problem was cataract
seen in 60 About 304 had difficulties in chewing and 256 had difficulty in hearing
Hypertension was present in 49 of individuals and 742 of Diabetics were also found to
be hypertensive25
A study done by Swapnil Jain et al (2016) on Morbidity pattern among geriatric
population in urban field practice area of a district in Maharashtra revealed 653 suffered
from hearing impairment 62 were anemic 462 had hypertension 423 had joint
pain 41 had dental problems 38 7 had cataract and 318 had chronic bronchitis It
was seen that 81 of the subjects had multiple morbidities 26
A study done by Rajat Das Gupta et al (2016) in an urban area of Bangladesh on Morbidity
pattern and health-seeking behavior among the senior citizens revealed that of the 384 study
participants 968 were suffering from at least one medical problem The commonest was
musculoskeletal problems in 8411 followed by eye problems in 8125 It was found that
all the respondents sought treatment for their health problems 33 respondents went to
Government hospitals to seek medical help 6927 respondents took prescribed
medications and 567 were satisfied with their treatment 27
16
Review of literature
A study done by Md Alam Naushad et al (2016) on Morbidity pattern and health
seeking behavior in elderly population of Raipur City Chhattisgarh revealed that the
prevalence of morbidity among elderly was 9531 Out of total morbid population some
chronic illness was present in 7049 Gastro intestinal system was involved in 8262
followed by eye in 7983 and Cardiovascular system in 5245 It was found that 3552
of the subjects sought treatment from private registered practitioners 28
A study done by Sribas Goswami and Manjari Sahai (2016) in Raipur city on Morbidity
Pattern in elderly Population revealed that out of total study population of 640 elderly
subjects 610 (9531) suffered from some morbidity Prevalence among females was
9892 whereas among males it was 9026 Out of various agencies 3552 subjects
were utilizing private facility followed by 2785 who were utilizing Government agency
2631 visited quacks and 1030 were taking treatment from other source 29
A study done by Harsh Bardhan et al (2016) on the Morbidity profile of elderly population
in Ghaziabad district revealed that in geriatric population 5008 suffered from
musculoskeletal problems 5877 had dental problems and impairment of vision was seen
in 5561 The overall prevalence of diabetes and heart disease were 10 and 122
respectively 236 subjects reported the problem of loneliness and depression
forgetfulness was also reported by 3296 As far as treatment seeking behavior is
concerned approach of elderly is quite different for different morbidities The main source
of treatment for morbidities such as hypertension respiratory urinary GIT-related and
musculoskeletal problems was quacks 30
17
Review of literature
A study done by Mohammad Maharoof et al (2016) on the health problems among
the aged in Urban Aligarh UP revealed that of the 225 study subjects 782 had cataract
followed by depression in 356 refractive error in 276 loco-motor problem in 213
and hearing loss in 138 The prevalence of hearing loss was significantly related to gender
as it was higher among females with 181 compared to males in whom it was 6931
A study done by Gowri Shankar and Bhayalaxmi Sidenur (2016) on morbidity of
elderly residing in an urban area of Bagalkot revealed that the most common morbidity was
Cataract seen in 2875 followed by musculoskeletal problems in 2813 and 2313
were known hypertensive Both diabetes mellitus and hypertension was observed in 10 of
the study subjects32
A study done by Leena Rahul Salunkhe (2015) on socio-demographic profile of old
age people living in urban amp urban slum areas in Maharashtra Karad revealed that 504
and 42 elderly suffered from arthritis in an urban area and a slum respectively Number of
diabetics were higher in urban (14) than urban slum (35) 301 of subjects from urban
area suffered from hypertension compared to 161 from urban slums Upper Respiratory
Infections was more in slum dwellers (196) than people residing in urban area (7) Acid
peptic diseases were found in 168 study subjects in urban area and 154 in slum area 33
In a study done by Warbhe Priyanka A and Warbhe Rupesh (2015) on morbidity
profile health seeking behaviour and home environment survey of the elderly in an urban
slum community it was found that 941 had 1-3 morbidities 41 had 4-6 morbidities
373 gave a history of fall and 314 had history of fracture 136 subjects had been
18
Review of literature
operated for cataract 168 had undergone a procedure for fracture and10 had undergone
a dental procedure 542 went to Urban health center (UHC) and Government hospitals for
treatment and 786 received both allopathic and Ayurvedic treatment34
A study done by Man Mohan Gupta et al (2015) on Assessment of Clinico-
socioeconomic status and health-care support among the elderly people aged older than 60
years in urban population of Bhopal revealed that 353 subjects received treatment for
their morbidities from the Government hospitals whereas 267 from private
clinichospital About 653 study subjects presented with complaints and morbidity The
common morbidities which were found in the subjects were fatigue (487) backache
(353) Obesity (393) and hypertension (247)35
In a study done by Shilpa Shaukaiah et al (2015) on prevalence of morbidity pattern
among geriatric age group in an urban slum of Mumbai it was found that body ache was the
most commonly reported symptom by 290 followed by visual problems in 2318 joint
pain in 2181 indigestion in 2045 and backache in 2045 subjects36
A study done by Shubha Davalagi B et al (2015) on morbidity psycho-social profile and
health seeking behavior of the elderly population in urban slums of Davangere City revealed
that the most common morbidity which was present in the study subjects was
musculoskeletal problems in 46 psychosocial problems were present in 31 and
respiratory problems in 23 Majority of the elderly (56) utilized government
institutions for treatment of chronic disease and 47 for treatment of acute disease The
elderly population had financial constraints and lack of accessibility in seeking health care37
19
Review of literature
A study done by Vandana Nikumb et al ( 2015) on morbidity Profile among Geriatric
Population in an Urban Area of Navi Mumbai revealed that 9312 elderly were morbid and
with increasing age the number of morbidities was found to be increasing In this study it
was found that the most common morbidity was psychosocial problems which include
stress which was present in 594 subjects followed by musculoskeletal problems in
556 and eye problems like diminished vision mostly due to cataract in 463
Hypertension dental problems respiratory problems ENT problems (hearing impairment)
and endocrine disorders like diabetes accounted for 281 219 119 106 and10
respectively38
A study done by Vishnoi BR et al (2015) on Morbidity Profile of Elderly in Urban
Slum of Udaipur Rajasthan revealed that 61 of the study subjects had impaired vision
followed by 25 who had hypertension 1533 suffered from insomnia 1467 had
anemia and 14 suffered from gastrointestinal problems The condition of females was
worse compared to males39
In a study done by L Subedhi and RB Sah (2015) on the health status of geriatric age
group in Chitwan district of Nepal it was found that of the 300 study subjects 44 had
Ophthalmic problems 43 had GIT problems 33 had CVS problems 23 had ENT
problems 1567 had metabolic disorders and 533 had mental disorders The study
highlighted a high prevalence of morbidity and health related problems in the geriatric age
group40
20
Review of literature
A study done by Sofia Noor et al (2015) on health status of geriatric population in slums
of Rourkela revealed that the morbidities among the elderly that were found to be significant
were hypertension decreased visual acuity urinary problems and insomnia Apart from
systemic morbidities 91 of the elderly also complained of fragility which includes
complex physiological deterioration and unexplained weight loss41
In a study conducted by VM Sarode (2014) on Chronic Diseases Related to Ageing and
Disease Prevention in Slums in Mumbai it was found that there were highly significant
disorders among aged women related to Skin lesion and super infection Untreated bacterial
pharyngitis acute rheumatic fever while disorders among aged men were related to
hypertension Illicit drug use diabetes and asthma It was found that 49 of elderly males
and 45 of elderly females had not sought any treatment for their illness Of the people who
had sought treatment 93 elderly males and 92 of elderly females had taken treatment
from Government hospital42
A study conducted by Sanjeev Kumar Barman et al (2014) on morbidity profile of
geriatric population in an urban slum of Kishnganj Bihar revealed that the prevalence of
anemia cataract and hypertension were quite high 6375 6125 and 5063
respectively Loss of income amp occupation along with a feeling of neglect from the family
members were the common problems among the elderly It was also found that morbidities
like arthritis loss of teeth amp dental caries along with depression had a significant association
with sex age amp educational status of the study subjects43
21
Review of literature
A study done by Khadervali Nagoor et al (2014) on the health status of elderly
population in an urban area of Kadapa revealed that out of the 200 elderly persons studied
Visual problem due to cataract and refractive errors were present in 72 of the study
subjects followed by pain in joints in 595 gastrointestinal problems in 46 and dental
problems in 44 Other morbidities were hypertension in 42 genitourinary problems in
25 dermatological problems in 235 and psychological problems in 1644
A study done by Kakkar R et al (2013) on morbidity profile among geriatric population
in District Dehradun revealed that the working geriatric group was healthy as compared to
those who were retired Hypertension was the commonest morbidity among all age groups
In the age group of 60-70 years the following morbidities were seen hypertension (306)
followed by diabetes (153) arthritis (14) CVS morbidities (14) cataract (96) and
BPH (83) Among 71-80 years age group Hypertension (287) followed by arthritis
(167) cataract (157) Diabetes (111) BPH (111) and CVS morbidities (93)45
In a study done by Bhawalkar JS et al (2013) on morbidity profile among geriatric
population in an urban area of Pune it was found that Musculoskeletal disorder was the
most common (4331) followed by eye problems (3722) and hypertension (137)It
was seen that 43 elderly population had some health problem but only 8 visited the
health facilities Among them 6 visited private practitioners and only 18 went to
municipal hospitals It was found that only 2322 elderly were taking any medications and
the most commonly used drug was anti-inflammatory drugs 2323 followed by
antihypertensive drugs 136746
22
Review of literature
A study conducted by Deepak Sharma et al (2013) on morbidity pattern and health-
seeking behavior of aged population residing in Shimla revealed that the following
morbidities were present in the study subjects hypertension was the commonest (56)
followed by Musculoskeletal problems (535) Dental problems (27) cataract (23)
anemia (15) and acid peptic disease (175) 658 of the subjects were seeking
treatment for their health problems Majority of the older people preferred allopathic
medicine (812) followed by Ayurvedic medicines (113) and homeopathic medicine
(73) for their health problems Most of the older persons preferred going to a
CHCGovernment hospital for treatment for their illness There was considerable use of
over-the-counter drug by125 of the people 47
A study done by JP Singh et al (2013) on Geriatric morbidity profile in an urban slum of
Nagpur central India revealed that the most common morbidity identified in the study
population was anemia (9650) followed by hypertension (345) arthritis (3225)
cataract (21) and diabetes (1775) More than 2 morbidities were present in 325 of
the study subjects followed by four morbidities in 3125 and two morbidities in 23548
A study conducted by RP Thakur et al (2013) on the health problems of the elderly in
central India revealed that among the elderly residing in the urban areas 384 of the urban
elderly had both dental problems and arthritis followed by anemia in 348 hypertension in
266 cataract in 252 and diabetes mellitus in 157 The prevalence of self-reported
depression was 672 among the urban female elderly when compared to 397 among the
urban females49
23
Review of literature
A study done by Mrinal Ranjan Srivastav et al (2013) on Morbidity Status and its
Social determinants among elderly population of Lucknow revealed that the most common
morbidity among the urban population was eye problems which affected 516 males and
67 females followed by CVS problems in 363 males and 395 females and GIT
problems in 315males and 382 females50
A study done by Shraddha K et al (2012) on morbidity pattern among elderly in urban
population of Mysore revealed that out of the 526 study subjects 486 suffered from the
disease of the eye and adnexa followed by 384 who suffered from endocrine and
metabolic disorders 331 suffered from the disease of the circulatory system 323 had
disease of the oral cavity and salivary glands and 302 had disease of the musculoskeletal
system 51
A study done by Vimala Thomas et al (2012) on morbidity profile and health seeking
behaviour of the elderly in urban slums of Hyderabad revealed that hypertension was the
most common morbidity in 469 followed by Arthritis in 302 Diabetes in 265
respiratory problems in 243 and Cataract in 21 For out-patient treatment 472 visited
private sectors 303 Government facility 25 RMP and 06 AYUSH clinics For in-
patient treatment 198 visited private institutions 16 visited Government institutions
while 642 did not visit either52
24
Review of literature
A study done by Soe Moe et al (2012) on health seeking behaviour of elderly in
Myanmar revealed that 35 of the male elderly perceived that they were having good
health status whereas 229 of them perceived having a poor health status 343 of female
elderly perceived that they were having good health status while 24 of them perceived
having a poor health About 49 of the elderly went to rural health center for treatment
followed by 33 who went to private practitioners 15 visited hospitals and 3 went to
more than one place for treatment53
A study done by Dharamvir Ranjan Bharati et al (2011) in Puducherry revealed that in
the urban areas about 707 of the study subjects had anemia followed by 537 who had
visual impairment and hypertension and 532 suffered from diabetes mellitus It was seen
that On univariate analysis the risk of diabetes mellitus was significantly higher among
elderly from urban areas than that among elderly from rural areas and significantly lower
risk in elderly from below poverty line than in those belonging to normal (not below poverty
line)54
A study done by Rajashree Bhat et al (2011) on the morbidity pattern among the elderly
population in Ahmedabad revealed that most common morbidity of elderly was the
problems of loco-motor system (486) followed by vision (427) and hypertension
(344) In this study only 37 of elderly had psychosocial problems55
A study done by Krishnamachari Srinivasan et al (2010) in an urban area of Bangalore
revealed that 494 subjects had hypertension 323 had diabetes 281 had arthritis
279 suffered from Genitourinary and cardiovascular disease It was observed that about
25
Review of literature
49 of the respondents made less than three physician visits and 13 were hospitalized for
health related problems during the past one year 56
A study done by Kajal Srivastava et al (2010) on the morbidity pattern of the elderly in
urban Agra revealed that 9529 of the elderly were morbid in the slum areas The most
common morbidity which was seen among the elderly people residing in urban slums was
anemia which was seen in 3843 followed by cataract in 298 arthritis in 2431 and
hearing impairments in 2157The system wise distribution of the morbidity pattern
showed the most common systemic involvement was visual disorders 5216 followed by
musculoskeletal system 4784 and the gastrointestinal system 4314 The number of
morbidities was found to be increasing with age and this association with age was
statistically significant57
A study done by Abdullah Ladha et al (2009) on the health seeking behaviour of elderly
population in a poor-urban community of Karachi Pakistan revealed that 164 of the
elderly people were Diabetic and 301 had Hypertension The Common symptoms that
prompted elderly of to seek health care were fever (612) generalized body aches (434)
and cough (404) About 614 responders reported factors which deterred them from
seeking health care out of which 62 reported financial constraint as the commonest factor
Deterrence from seeking health care was associated with illiteracy and living alone58
26
Methodology METHODOLOGY
The study was conducted in the urban field practice area of JJM Medical college
Davangere The city of Davangere is situated in the central part of Karnataka state
265 km north of the state capital Bengaluru along the national highway number 4
Figure 5 Maps showing the location of Davangere district and the area where the
UHTC is located
27
Methodology
Figure 6 Map showing the Urban field practice area of JJM medical college
28
Methodology
Table 3 List of areas covered under the UHTC of JJM Medical
College Davangere
Areas covered Total population Bethur road 1374 Hedge nagar 1213 Mehboob nagar 3042 Mustafa nagar A 2093 B D layout A 1084 Mustafa nagar B 1127 Mahavir nagar 930 Muddabovi colony 1094 Maganhalli 1221 Tippu nagar 968 B D layout B 1717 Batti layout 1080
STUDY AREA The study was conducted in the urban field practice area of JJM
Medical College Davangere which consists of 12 areas with a total population of
16943
STUDY DESIGN Cross sectional study
STUDY POPULATION Persons aged 60 years and above
Total Population Covered 16943
29
Methodology
INCLUSION CRITERIA subjects aged 60 years and above living in the study area
for more than one year duration
EXCLUSION CRITERIA Subjects who we r e no t w i l l i ng t o pa r t i c ipa t e i n
t he s t udy
STUDY PERIOD 1 year from 1st December 2015 to 30th November 2016
SAMPLE SIZE As quoted by Manmohan Gupta et al 35 in the studies done in various
parts of India the prevalence of morbidity in the geriatric population ranges from 31-80
Considering the prevalence of morbidity to be about 50 in the geriatric population at 95
confidence level and allowable error of 10 and a non -response rate of 10 sample size
was calculated to be 440 using the formula
n=4pq L2
n= sample size
4= factor to achieve 95 level of confidence
p= prevalence of morbidities ie 50
q= 100- p ie 100-50 = 50
L= permissible error in the estimate of ldquoprdquo (10 of p)
n = 4 x 50 x 50 = 400
5 x 5
After calculating a non-response rate of 10 a sample size of 440 was calculated
30
Methodology
A community based cross sectional study was conducted in the urban field practice
area of JJM Medical College Davangere The Urban field practice area has a total
population of 16943 and there are 12 areas in urban field practice area of JJM Medical
College Davangere
The Study was conducted by probability proportionate sampling The sample size for each
area was derived from the formula
1198991 =119875119900119901119906119897119886119905119894119900119899 119894119899 119890119886119888ℎ 119886119903119890119886
119879119900119905119886119897 119875119900119901119906119897119886119905119894119900119899119883 119878119886119898119901119897119890 119878119894119911119890
Example 1st area has a population of 1374 so
1198991 =1374
16943119883 440 = 36
Therefore 36 elderly subjects were selected by house to house visit from 1st area Same
procedure was applied for other areas until the desired sample size of 440 was reached
MATERIALS USED FOR DATA COLLECTION
The following tools were used for data collection
Semi-structured predesigned and pre-tested questionnaire
Portable bathroom weighing machine
Stretch- resistant measuring tape
Mercury Sphygmomanometer
Others - stethoscope torch tuning fork knee hammer
ICD-10 for system wise classification of disease59
31
Methodology METHOD OF COLLECTION OF DATA After establishing rapport with the family
and explaining the data collection procedure in the local language an informed verbal
consent was obtained from each individual and data was collected using a
Predesigned semi structured questionnaire by Interview method The questionnaire
comprised of the following information socio-demographic data of the study subjects
information regarding the morbidity pattern and health seeking behaviour If there were
more than one elderly subjects in the same household then all were included
The study subjects were asked about any ho illness (communicable or non-
communicable) which they were suffering from Upon a positive response the subjects were
further asked to specify the type(s) and duration of morbidities that they were suffering
from eg heart disease diabetes gastrointestinal diseases respiratory disease etc Some
were unable to understand or answer questions due to illness In such cases help was sought
from the family members Based on the self-reported symptoms information from
hospital records and clinical examination the prevalence of different morbidities among the
study subjects was assessed The Information about the health seeking behaviour was
sought by asking the study subjects about their visits to a health facility in case of an illness
and also the type of health facility visited ( Government private or quacks )
DATA ENTRY AND ANALYSIS Data was entered and analyzed using MS Excel and
Open Epi Info version 2260 Both descriptive and inferential statistics were used Subjectrsquos
baseline characteristics were presented as frequencies and percentages Categorical
variables between the groups were compared using Chi square test and Fisherrsquos exact
test Fisherrsquos exact test was used when more than 20 cells had expected value lt 5 and any
one of the cells had expected value lt 1 All statistical analysis was carried out at 5 level
of significance and p value lt005 was considered as significant
32
Methodology ETHICAL CLEARANCE
Ethical clearance was obtained before conducting the study from the Ethical Committee of
JJM Medical college Davangere [ANNEXURE III] During the study verbal
informed consent was taken from the study subjects Assurance was given that the
confidentiality concerning their information will be maintained
Clinical Examination included
(a) General physical examination
(b) Anthropometric measurements like height and weight
(c) Systemic examination
(d) Measurement of Blood pressure
(e) Eye examination by torch and Snellenrsquos (E chart)61
(f) Hearing assessment by Rinnersquos test Webberlsquos and Absolute bone conduction
test using tuning fork 62
Parameters used in our study
Height Height was measured with a standard non-stretchable measuring tape to the
nearest 01 cm in standing position (without footwear standing upright with the
back against the wall heels together and eyes directed forward)
33
Methodology Weight Weight was measured with minimal clothing and respecting the modesty of the
individual without footwear using a calibrated standard bathroom weighing scale to the
nearest 05 kg
Body Mass Index (BMI) Using weight (in Kg) and height (in meter2) BMI was calculated by applying the formula
Body Mass Index= Weight (kg) Height (m2)
The BMI cut off values for Asians as recommended by the WHO was used in our study
Table 4 WHO Categorization of Body Mass index (BMI) for Asians 63
Measurement of Blood pressure Procedure Blood pressure was measured in the left arm in a sitting posture with the subject in a
relaxed state Standardized mercury sphygmomanometer with adult size cuff was used
The first appearance of (phase 1 of Korotkoff sounds) sound was used to define
Systolic Blood Pressure (SBP) The disappearance of sound (phase 5) was used to
define Diastolic Blood Pressure (DBP) Two readings were taken five minutes apart and
the average of the two readings was taken as the final blood pressure reading A person
was considered to be a hypertensive if he she was already diagnosed case of
hypertension and or on treatment or with a current SBP of ge 140 mm Hg or DBP ge 90 mm
Hg (JNC VII criteria)64
BODY MASS INDEX INFERENCE
lt 185 underweight
185 to 229 kg m2 Normal
23 to 249 kg m2 Overweight
ge 25 kg m2 Obese
34
Methodology
Table 5 JNC VII Classification of Blood pressure 65
BP Classification Systolic Blood Pressure Diastolic Blood Pressure
Normal lt120 lt 80
Pre Hypertension 120 ndash 139 or 80 ndash 89 Stage 1 Hypertension 140 ndash 159 or 90 ndash 99 Stage 2 Hypertension ge 160 or ge 100
Anaemia was detected by pallor of conjunctiva tongue and nails and was confirmed by
doing haemoglobin estimation using sahlirsquos hemogobinometer66
The cut off for the diagnosis of anaemia was done based on WHO classification67
Diabetes - self reported cases of diabetes were considered as diabetics for the study
STUDY VARIABLES
1 AGE - subjects aged 60 years and above were taken up for the study Age was
recorded to the nearest complete years as stated by the respondent
2 GENDER Both males and females were taken up for the study
3 EDUCATIONAL STATUS 68
i Illiterate -A person who could not read or write
ii Primary School - studied up to 4th standard
iii Higher primary- studied between 5th and 7th standard
iv Secondary school -studied between 8th and 10th standard v Intermediate- studied between 11th or 12 th standard or diploma
vi Graduate - obtained graduate degree
vii Post Graduate- obtained post graduate degree
35
Methodology
4 OCCUPATION STATUS69
i Unskilled worker
Labourer domestic servants casual worker peon sweeper porter washer-man others
(vegetable vendor)
ii Semi-skilled worker
Factory worker agriculture laborers shoemaker potters others (security guard shop
helper canteen helper
iii Skilled
Artisan clerk foreman supervisor carpenter tailor mechanic electrician railway guard
painter modeler smiths baker driver shop assistant petty trader constable soldier
linesman pointsman potter barber others (tinkering printer receptionist salesman
welder cook mason postman plumber agarbatti worker)
iv semi-professional
Teacher pharmacist social worker owner of a small business farmer others (computer
programmer Govt employee nurse)
V Professional
Doctor engineer principal lawyer Military officer senior executive business
proprietor writer scientist large employer director university professor police
officer others (horse rider)
(vi) Unemployed Presently not working retired homemakers
36
Methodology 5 SOCIO ECONOMIC STATUS
Table 6 Socio-economic status (SES)- As per modified BG Prasad Classification70
5 TYPE OF FAMILY 71
Joint Family ndash It is type of family grouping in which a number of married couples and
their children live together in the same household All the men are related by blood
and women of household are their wives unmarried girls and widows of family kinsmen
Nuclear Family - It consist of married couple and their children while they are still
regarded as dependents
Three generation family - It is a family where representatives of three generation are
living together Young married couples continue to stay with their parents and have
their own children as well
Socio-economic
status
Prasadrsquos classification
1961(Per capita income in
Rupees per month)
Modified BG Prasad classification-
updated for May 2016 ((per
capita income in Rupees per
month)
I 100 and above 6261 and above
II 50-99 3099-6260
III 30-49 1835-3098
IV 15-29 949-1834
V Below 15 lt948
37
SAMPLE SIZE ESTIMATION
SAMPLE SIZE As quoted by Manmohan Gupta et al 35 in the studies done in various
parts of India the prevalence of morbidity in the geriatric population ranges from 31-80
Considering the prevalence of morbidity to be about 50 in the geriatric population at 95
confidence level and allowable error of 10 and a non -response rate of 10 sample size
was calculated to be 440 using the formula
n=4pq L2
n= sample size
4= factor to achieve 95 level of confidence
p= prevalence of morbidities ie 50
q= 100- p ie 100-50 = 50
L= permissible error in the estimate of ldquoprdquo (10 of p)
n = 4 x 50 x 50 = 400
5 x 5
After calculating a non-response rate of 10 a sample size of 440 was calculated
A community based cross sectional study was conducted in the urban field practice area of
JJM Medical College Davangere The Urban field practice area has a total population of
16943 and there are 12 areas in urban field practice area of JJM Medical College
Davangere
The Study was conducted by probability proportionate sampling The sample size for each area
was derived from the formula
1198991 =119875119900119901119906119897119886119905119894119900119899 119894119899 119890119886119888ℎ 119886119903119890119886
119879119900119905119886119897 119875119900119901119906119897119886119905119894119900119899119883 119878119886119898119901119897119890 119878119894119911119890
Example 1st area has a population of 1374 so
1198991 =1374
16943119883 440 = 36
Therefore 36 elderly subjects were selected by house to house visit from 1st area Same
procedure was applied for other areas until the desired sample size of 440 was reached
Results
RESULTS
The results are presented under the following headings
I Socio-demographic characteristics of study subjects
II Prevalence of morbidities among the study subjects
III Details of health seeking behavior of the study subjects
38
Results
ISocio-demographic characteristics of the study subjects
Table 7 Age and sex wise distribution of the study subjects
Figure 7 Age and sex wise distribution of the study subjects
In the present study Out of 440 study subjects majority 162(368) were in the age group
of 60-64 Years followed by 109 (247) in the age group of 65-69 Years 99 (225) were
in the age group of 70-74 Years and 35 (8) were more than or equal to 80 years of age
Majority of the subjects were males 260 (59) and 180 (41) were females The mean age
of the study population was 6745 plusmn 655 Years
354 254 262
88 42
389
239 172
67 133
0102030405060708090
100
60-64 65-69 70-74 75-79 ge80
Perc
enta
ge
Age in years
Males
Females
Age group (in years)
Males Females Total
Percentage () Frequency
(n=260) Percentage ()
Frequency (n=180)
Percentage ()
60-64 92 354 70 389 162 368
65-69 66 254 43 239 109 247
70-74 68 262 31 172 99 225
75-79 23 88 12 67 35 80
ge80 11 42 24 133 35 80
Total 260 100 180 100 440 100
39
Results
Table 8 Distribution of the study subjects based on religion
Religion Frequency (n=440) Percentage ()
Hindu 188 427
Muslim 252 573
Total 440 100
Figure 8 Distribution of the study subjects based on religion
In the present study it was found that the majority of the study subject belonged to Muslim
religion 252 (573) followed by Hindus 188 (427)
0102030405060708090
100
Hindu Muslim
427
573
Perc
enta
ge
Religion of the study subjects
40
Results
Table 9 Distribution of the study subjects based on Educational status
Education Frequency (n=440) Percentage ()
Illiterate 231 525
Primary school 121 275
Higher primary 38 86
Secondary School 30 68
Intermediate 6 14
Graduate 14 32
Total 440 100
Figure 9 Distribution of the study subjects based on Educational status
In the present study it was found that the Majority of the study subjects were illiterate
231(525) 121(275) had completed education up to primary school 30(68) had
completed education up to secondary school and only 14(32) were graduates
525
275
86 68
14 32
0102030405060708090
100
Perc
enta
ge
Educational status of study subjects
41
Results Table 10 Distribution of the study subjects based on occupation
Occupation Frequency (n=440) Percentage ()
Semi-professional 2 05
Skilled worker 45 102
Semi-skilled worker 68 155
Unskilled worker 100 227
Unemployed 225 511
Total 440 100
Figure 10 Distribution of study subjects based on their occupation
In our study it was found that the majority of the study subjects 225 (511) were
unemployed followed by 100 (227) who were unskilled workers 68 (155) were semi-
skilled workers and 45 (102) were skilled workers
0102030405060708090
100
05 102 155 227
511
Perc
enta
ge
Occupation of the study subjects
42
Results Table 11 Distribution of the study subjects based on socio-economic status (Modified
BG Prasad classification 2016)
Figure 11 Distribution of the study subjects based on their socio-economic status
In our study majority of the subjects 215 (49) belonged to Class IV Socioeconomic status
followed by 115 (26) who belonged to class III and 56 (13) who belonged to class II
SES (according to Modified BG Prasad Classification 2016)
Class II 13
Class III 26
Class IV 49
Class V 12
Socio-economic status Frequency (n=440) Percentage ()
Class I 0 0
Class II 56 13
Class III 115 26
Class IV 215 49
Class V 54 12
Total 440 100
43
Results
Table 12 Distribution of the study subjects based on their marital status
Marital status Frequency (n=440) Percentage ()
Unmarried 2 05
Married 323 734
Widowwidower 115 261
Total 440 100
Figure 12 Distribution of the study subjects based on their marital status
In our study it was found that majority of the study subjects 323(734) were married
followed by 115(261) who were widowed and only 2 (05) were unmarried
0102030405060708090
100
Unmarried married Widowwidower
05
734
261 Perc
enta
ge
44
Results
Table 13 Distribution of the study subjects based on the type of family
Type of family Frequency (n=440) Percentage ()
Nuclear family 163 37
Joint family 93 21
Three generation family 184 42
Total 440 100
Figure 13 Distribution of the study subjects based on the type of family
In the present study it was found that majority of the study subjects 184 (42) lived in a
three generation family followed by 163 (37) who lived in a nuclear family and 93(21)
who lived in a Joint family
Nuclear family 37
Joint family 21
Three generation
family 42
45
Results
II Prevalence of morbidities among the study subjects
Figure 14 Distribution of the study subjects based on the BMI
In the present study it was found that out of 440 study subjects 198 (45) had a normal
BMI followed by 132 (30) who were overweight 66 (15) were obese and only 44
(10) were underweight
under weight 10
Normal 45
Overweight 30
Obese 15
46
Results
Table 14 Distribution of morbidity pattern of the study subjects based on ICD 10
classification of diseases
System involved ICD 10
Males (n=260)
Females (n=180)
Total (n=440)
No No No
Diseases of musculoskeletal system (M00 ndash M99)
184 707 130 722 314 714
Diseases of the eye and adnexa (H00 ndash H59)
139 534 80 444 219 497
Diseases of oral cavityamp salivary glands (K00 ndash K14)
90 346 64 355 154 35
Endocrine nutritional amp metabolic diseases (E00 ndash
E90)
70 269 75 417 145 329
Diseases of circulatory system (I00 ndash I99)
64 246 73 405 137 311
Diseases of respiratory system(J00 ndash J99)
64 246 37 206 101 23
Diseases of digestive system (K00 ndash K93)
57 219 30 166 87 198
Diseases of skin amp subcutaneous tissue (L00 ndash
L99)
38 146 20 111 58 132
Diseases of the ear and mastoid process (H60 ndashH95)
39 15 18 10 57 13
Diseases of genitourinary system (N00 ndash N99)
22 85 7 39 29 66
Diseases of nervous system (G00 ndash G99)
6 23 5 28 11 25
Note Total number could not be given as many subjects had multiple disorders
47
Results
Figure 15 Distribution of morbidity pattern of the study subjects based on ICD 10
classification of diseases
In the present study it was found that the majority of the subjects 314 (714) suffered
from the disorders of the musculoskeletal system followed by 219 (497) who suffered
from the disease of the eye and adnexa154 (35) suffered from the disease of the oral
cavity 145 (329) suffered from endocrine nutritional and metabolic disorders137
(311) suffered from the disease of the circulatory system 101 (229) suffered from the
disease of the respiratory system 87(198) suffered from the disease of the digestive
system 58 (132) suffered from disease of the skin 57 (13) suffered from the disease of
the ear 29 (66) suffered from the disease of the genitourinary system and only 11( 25 )
suffered from the disease of the nervous system
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
714
497
35 329 311 229
198 132 13 66
25
perc
enta
ge
48
Results
Table 15 Distribution of the study subjects based on morbidity of the musculoskeletal
system
Musculoskeletal
Disease
Males
(n=260)
Females
(n=180)
Total
(n= 440)
Statistical
Value
Knee joint pain
52 (20)
30 (167)
82 (186)
X2 = 0779
df = 1
p=03773
Back ache
30 (115)
35 (194)
65 (148) X2 = 528
df = 1
p = 0021
Joint pain (other than
knee joint pain)
52(20)
35(194)
87(198)
X2 =00206
df=1
p =0885
Non-specific aches
and pain
50(192)
30(167)
80(182)
X2=0470
df=1
p = 0492
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses
In the present study it was found that the most common morbidity of musculoskeletal
system was pain of the joints (other than the knee joint) found in 87 (198) of the subjects
followed by knee joint pain in 82 ( 186) and non-specific pains and aches were found in
80 (182) of the subjects It was found that back ache was more common in females
35(194) compared to males 30 (115) and this difference was found to be statistically
significant
49
Results
Table 16 Distribution of the study subjects based on morbidity of the eye and adnexa
Diseases of the
eye and
adnexa
Males
(n=260)
Females
(n=180)
Total
(n= 440)
Statistical
value
Cataract
112(43)
60(333)
172(391)
X2 = 4241
df=1
p = 0039
Refractive error
20(77)
14(78)
34(77)
X2= 0001
df=1
p = 0973
Others (conjunctivitis
pterygium glaucoma etc)
7(27)
6(33)
13(29)
X2=0152
df=1
p = 0696
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses
In the present study it was found that the most common morbidity of the eye was cataract
found in 172 (391) of the subjects It was more common in males 112 (43) compared to
females 60 (333) and this difference was found to be statistically significant The other
morbidities present were refractive error found in 34 (77) subjects and others which
includes conjunctivitis pterygium glaucoma etc found in 13 (29 ) subjects
50
Results
Table 17 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the oral cavity
Diseases of the
oral cavity
Males
(n =260 )
Females
(n =180 )
Total
(n = 440)
Statistical
value
Stained teeth
22 (84)
18 (10)
40 (91)
X2 =0304
df=1
p = 0581
Missing teeth
40 (154)
38 (211)
78 (177)
X2= 239
df= 1
p=0122
Caries
28 (108)
8 (44)
36 (82)
X2= 566
df= 1
p=0017
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses
In the present study it was found that the most common morbidity of the oral cavity was
missing teeth found in 78 (177 ) of the subjects followed by stained teeth found in 40
(91) of the subjects and dental caries in 36 (82) of the subjects Dental caries were
more common in males 28 (108) compared to females 8(44) and this difference was
found to be statistically significant
51
Results
Table 18 Distribution of study subjects based on endocrine nutritional and metabolic
disorders
Disorders Males
(n =260 )
Females
(n =180)
Total
(n = 440)
Statistical value
Diabetes mellitus
45 (173)
37 (206)
82 (186)
X2 = 0739
df= 1
p = 0389
Anemia
24 (92)
35 (194)
59 (134)
X2= 955
df = 1
p = 0001
Thyroid disorders
1(04)
3 (17)
4 (09)
p= 0309
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
The present study revealed that the most common disorder of the endocrine system was
diabetes mellitus found in 82 (186) of the subjects followed by the nutritional disorder of
anemia found in 59 (134) of the subjects It was seen that anemia was more common
among females 35 (194) compared to males 24 (92) This difference was found to be
statistically significant Disorders of the thyroid gland were found in 4 (09) of the subjects
being more common in females 3(17) compared to males 1 (04)
52
Results
Table 19 Distribution of the study subject based on disease of the circulatory system
Diseases of
circulatory
system
Males
(n=260 )
Females
(n =180)
Total
(n = 440)
Statistical
value
Hypertension
62 (238)
71 (394)
133 (302)
X2= 1227
df= 1
p = 0000
CAD MI
Arrhythmias
2 (08)
2 (11)
4 (09)
p =100
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
In our study it was found that the most common disease of the circulatory system was
hypertension which was found in 133 (302 ) of the subjects it was more common in
females 71 (394) compared to males 62 (239) and this difference was found to be
statistically significant The other disorders of the circulatory system were CAD MI
arrhythmias which were found only in 4 (09) of the study subjects
53
Results
Table 20 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the respiratory system
Disorders of
Respiratory
System
Males
(n=260)
Females
(n=180)
Total
(n=440)
Statistical
value
Bronchial asthma
3 (12)
3 (17)
6 (14)
p =0692
URTI
45 (173)
27 (15)
72 (164)
X2= 0413
df = 1
p = 0520
Acute Bronchitis
12 (46)
7 (39)
19 (43)
X2= 0135
df = 1
p = 0712
Pulmonary TB
4 (15)
0(00)
4 (09)
p =0148
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
Our study revealed that the most common disease of the respiratory system was URTI
(upper respiratory tract infection) found in 72 (164) subjects followed by acute bronchitis
in 19 (43 ) bronchial asthma in 6 (14) and pulmonary TB in only in 4 (09 ) subjects
Pulmonary TB was found in 4 (15) of the males whereas no females had TB however
this difference was not found to be statistically significant
54
Results
Table 21 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the digestive system
Disorders of
Gastrointestinal
system
Males
(n = 260)
Females
(n = 180)
Total
(n = 440)
Statistical value
Constipation
21(8)
6 (33)
27(61)
X2 =4155
df =1
p =0041
Gastritis
24 (92)
18 (10)
42(95)
X2= 0072
df = 1
p =0787
Bleeding per
rectum 3(12) 2(11) 5(11)
p =100
Others (Pain
abdomen
anorexia
indigestion)
9(35)
4 (22)
13 (3)
X2=0569
df =1
p=0450
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
Our study revealed that the most common disorder of the gastrointestinal system was
gastritis found in 42 (95) subjects followed by constipation in 27 ( 61) others which
include pain abdomen anorexia indigestion was found in 13 (3) and bleeding per rectum
was seen in 5 (11) It was seen that constipation was more common among males 21(8)
compared to females 6 (33) which was found to be statistically significant
55
Results
Table 22 Distribution the study subjects based on disease of the Skin and
subcutaneous tissue
Disorders of skin and
subcutaneous tissue
Males ( n = 260)
Females (n = 180)
Total (n = 440)
Statistical
value
Itching
19(73)
2(11)
21(48)
X2 =896
df=1
p = 0002
Scaling 6 (23)
3 (17)
9 (2)
p =0743
Pigmentation
5(19)
4 (22)
9 (2)
p =100
Dryness
8 (31)
11 (61)
19(43)
X2= 237
df = 1
p = 0123 Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
In the present study it was found that the most common disease of the skin was itching
which was present in 21 (48) of the study subjects followed by dryness in 19 (43) and 9
(2) of the subjects had scaling and pigmentation It was seen that itching was more
common among males 19 (73) compared to females 2 (11) and this difference was
found to be statistically significant
56
Results
Table 23 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the ear
Disease of the ear
Males
(n= 260)
Females
(n = 180)
Total
(n = 440) Statistical value
Hearing impairment
33 (126)
16 (89)
49 (111)
X2 =155
df =1
p =0212
Ear discharge
3 (12)
1 (06)
4(09)
p =0647
Tinnitus
3 (12)
1 (06)
4 (09)
p =0647
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
In the present study it was observed that hearing impairment was the most common
morbidity of the ear found in 49 (111) of the subjects though it was more common
among males 33 (126) compared to females 16 (89) the difference was not found to be
statistically significant The other disorders which affected the ear were ear discharge and
tinnitus both present in 4 (09) of the subjects
57
Results
Table 24 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the genitourinary
system
Disorders of
genitourinary system
Male
(n = 260)
Female
(n = 180)
Total
(n=440)
Statistical value
Burning micturition
2 (077)
2 (11)
4 (09)
p=100
Increased frequency of
micturition
20(77) 5(28) 25(57)
X2= 4794
df =1
p =0028 Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
In our study it was observed that the most common morbidity affecting the genitourinary
system was increased frequency of micturition in 25 (57) of the subjects followed by
burning micturition in 4 (09) of the study subjects Increased frequency of micturition was
more common among males 20 (77) compared to females 5 (28) and this difference
was found to be statistically significant
58
Results
Table 25 Distribution of the study subjects based on diseases of the Nervous system
Disease of the
nervous system Males
(n = 260)
Females
(n = 180)
Total
(n = 440)
p value
Memory loss
2 (77)
2 (11)
4 (09)
100
Stroke
2 (77)
0 (00)
2 (05)
0515
Neuritis
2 (77)
3 (17)
5 (11)
0652
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
Our study revealed that the most common disorder of the nervous system was neuritis seen
in 5 (11) of the subjects followed by memory loss in 4 (09) and stroke in 2 (05 ) of
the subjects It was observed that 2 (0 77) of males had suffered a stroke whereas none of
the females had suffered from stroke however this difference was not found to be
statistically significant
59
Results
Table 26 Association between morbidity pattern of the study subjects and their age
group
System involved 60-69Yrs
(n = 271)
70-79Yrs
(n = 134)
gt 80Yrs
(n = 35)
Total
( n = 440)
Statistical
value
Musculoskeletal
System
195 (72)
94 (70)
25 (710)
314 (714) X2= 0143
df = 2 p = 0930
Eye amp adnexa
125 (461)
69 (515)
25 (714)
219 (497) X2= 8166
df = 2 p = 0016
Oral cavity amp salivary gland
56 (207)
68 (507)
30 (857)
154 (350) X2= 7865
df = 2 p lt 00001
Endocrine nutritional amp
metabolic diseases
91 (335)
47 (35)
7 (200)
145 (329) X2= 297
df = 2 p = 0225
Circulatory
system
87 (321)
40 (298)
10 (285)
137 (311) X2= 0328
df = 2 p = 0848
Respiratory
system
64 (236)
31 (231)
6 (171)
101 (23) X2= 0738
df = 2 p = 0691
Digestive system
52 (191)
28 (210)
7 (200)
87 (191) X2= 0166
df = 2 p = 0 920
Skin and subcutaneous
tissue
43 (159)
13 (97)
2 (57)
58 (132) X2= 4831
df = 2 p = 0089
Ear amp mastoid process
27 (99)
20 (149)
10 (285)
57 (13) X2= 1018
d= 2 p = 0006
Genitourinary
system
20 (74)
8 (59)
1 (29)
29 (66) X2= 1151
df = 2 p = 0562
Nervous system
5 (18)
4 (29)
2 (57)
11 (25)
p = 0418
Figure in parenthesis indicates percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
60
Results
Table 26 shows the association between the morbidity pattern and age group of the study
subjects It is observed that the disease of the eye and adnexa increase with increasing age
and are more common in individuals above 80 years of age (714) compared to
individuals in the age group of 60-69 years (461) and 70-79 years (515) This
difference was found to be statistically significant The disease of the oral cavity were also
more common in the subjects aged 80 years and above (857) compared to individuals in
the age group of 70-79 years (507) and 60-69 years (207) this difference was also
found to be statistically significant Significant association was also found between
increasing age and disease of the ear 285 subjects aged 80 years and above suffered from
disease of the ear followed by 149 in the age group of 60-69 years and 99 in the age
group of 60-69 years
61
Results Table 27 Association between morbidity pattern of the study subjects and their
occupation
System involved Employed (n=215)
Unemployed (n=225)
Total (n=440)
Statistical value
Musculoskeletal
system
171 (795) 143 (635) 314 (714) X2 =1374 df=1
p=00002
Eye and adnexa 108 (502) 111(493) 219(497) X2= 0035 df=1
p= 0850
Oral cavityamp
salivary glands
76 (353) 78 (347) 154 (35) X2=0022 df=1
p=0880
Endocrine
nutritional amp
metabolic
disease
75 (348) 70 (311) 145 (329) X2=0708 df=1
p=0400
circulatory
system
58 (269) 79 (351) 137 (311) X2=3393 df=1
p=0065
Respiratory
system
49 (227) 52 (231) 101 (23) X2=0006 df=1
p=09363
Digestive system 45 (21) 42 (187) 87 (198) X2=0125 df=1
p=0723
Skin
subcutaneous
tissue
38 (176) 20 (88) 58 (132) X2=741 df=1
p=0006
Ear and mastoid
process
31 (144) 26 (115) 57 (13) X2=0799 df=1
p=0371
Genitourinary
system
16 (74) 13 (57) 29 (66) X2=0494 df=1
p=0481
Nervous system
2 (093) 9 (4) 11 (25) X2=425 df=1
p=0039 Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses
62
Results
Table 27 shows the association between the morbidity pattern and occupation of the study
subjects It was observed that musculoskeletal disorders were more common among the
subjects who are employed (795) compared to those who are not employed (635) and
this difference was found to be statistically significant A significant association was also
seen between the disorders of the skin and subcutaneous tissue 176 subjects who are
employed suffered from the disease of the skin and subcutaneous tissue compared to 88
who were unemployed The diseases of the nervous system were more common among
those who were unemployed (4) compared to those who were employed (093) this
difference was also found to be statistically significant
63
Results Table 28 Association between morbidity pattern of the study subjects and their
religion
System involved Hindu
(n=188)
Muslim
(n=252)
Total
(n=440)
Statistical value
Musculoskeletal system 138 (73) 176 (698) 314 (714)
X2=0668 df=1
p=0413
Eye and adnexa 100 (531) 119 (472) 219 (497) X2=1535 df=1
p= 0215
Oral cavityamp salivary glands 73 (388) 81 (321) 154 (35)
X2=211 df=1
p=0145
Endocrine nutritional amp metabolic diseases
53 (2819) 92 (365) 145 (329) X2=3371 df=1
p=0066
circulatory system 58 (269) 79 (351) 137 (311)
X2=3393 df=1
p=0065
Respiratory system
33 (176) 68 (269) 101 (229)
X2=5415 df= 1
p=0019
Digestive system 27 (144) 60 (238) 87 (198) X2=6059 df=1
p=0013
Skin subcutaneous tissue
31 (164) 27 (107) 58 (132) X2=3138 df=1
p=00765
Ear and mastoid process
28 (149) 29 (115) 57 (129) X2=1095 df=1
p=0297
Genitourinary system
16 (85) 13 (52) 29 (66) X2=1965 df=1
p=0161
Nervous system
4 (21) 7 (28) 11(25) p=0764
Figure in parenthesis indicates percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
64
Results
Table 28 shows the association between the morbidity pattern of the study subjects and their
religion In our study it was observed that the disorders of the digestive system were more
common among Muslims (238) compared to Hindus (144) this difference was found
to be statistically significant Also the disorders of the respiratory system were more
common among Muslims (269) compared to Hindus (176) This difference was also
found to be statistically significant Some of the diseases were more common among Hindus
which include the disease of the eye and adnexa (531) oral cavity (388) ear (149)
skin and subcutaneous tissue (164) and genitourinary system (85) but it was not found
to be statistically significant
65
Results
III HEATLTH SEEKING BEHAVIOR OF THE STUDY SUBJECTS
Figure16 Distribution of the study subjects based on the visit to health facility in case
of an illness
In our study it was found that that out of 440 study subjects 395(898) visited a health
facility in case of an illness whereas 45(102) did not visit any health facility in case of an
illness
898
102
health facility visitednot visited
66
Results
Table 29 Reasons cited by the study subjects for not seeking healthcare in case of an
illness
In the present study it was found that the most common reason stated by the 45 study
subjects for not seeking health care in case of an illness was that it was a mil 20 (444)
followed by lack of money stated by12 (267) the other reasons stated were no one to
accompany 7 (156) and lack of faith in health care 6 (133)
Reasons cited for not
seeking health care
Frequency (n=45)
Percentage ()
Mild discomfort 20 444
Lack of money 12 267
Lack of faith in
healthcare
6 133
No one to accompany 7 156
Total 45 100
67
Results
Table 30 Distribution of the study subjects based on the type of health facility visited
It was observed that out of 395 subjects who visited health care facility in case of an illness
229(58) Visited government hospitals 160 (405) visited private practitioners hospitals
and 6 (15) visited quacks More number of males (622) visited government hospitals
compared to females (513)
Type of health facility visited
Males
(n=241)
Females
(n=154)
Total
(n=395)
No No No
Government hospital 150 622 79 513 229 58
Private practitionershospitals 87 361 73 474 160 405
Quacks 4 17 2 13 6 15
Total 241 100 154 100 395 100
68
Results
Table 31 Association between gender and health seeking behaviour of the study
subjects
Whether visited
health facility
in case of illness
Sex
Total
n ()
p value Male
n ()
Female
n ()
Yes 241 (927) 154 (856) 395 (898) 00151
No 19 (106) 26 (144) 45 (102)
Total 260 (59) 180 (41) 440 (100)
x2=5901 df =1
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
It was observed that more number of males visited a health care facility in case of an illness
241(927) whereas only 154(856) females visited a health facility in case of an illness
This difference was found to be statistically significant
69
Results
Table 32 Association between educational status and health seeking
behaviour of the study subjects
Whether visited Health facility in case of illness
p value
Educational status(n) Yes () No ()
0000
Illiterate (231) 194 (84) 37 (16)
Primary school (121) 115 (95) 6 (49)
Higher primary (38) 37 (974) 1 (26)
Secondary school (30) 29 (967) 1 (33)
Intermediate (6) 6 (100) 0(00)
Graduate (14) 14 (100) 0(00)
Total(440) 395 (898) 45(102)
Fisherrsquos exact test
In the present study it was found that 84 of the study subjects who were illiterate visited a
health facility in case of an illness whereas 16 did not visit a health facility in case of an
illness 967 of the subjects with education up to secondary school visited the health
facility and 100 of the subjects who studied up to intermediate and with a graduate degree
visited the health facility in case of an illness This difference was found to be statistically
significant
70
Results
Table 33 Distribution of study subjects according to frequency of visits to a health care facility
Frequency of visits to a health care facility
Frequency
(n=395)
Percentage
Once a month 207 524
Once in 3 months 99 251
Once in 6 months 79 20
Once in a year 10 25
Total 395 100
In the present study it was found that out of 395 study subjects who visited a health care
facility in case of an illness 207 (524) visited a health facility every month followed by
99 (251) who visited once in 3 months 79(20) once in 6 months and 10 25 visited
the health facility once in a year
71
Discussion
DISCUSSION
I Socio-demographic characteristics
Our study was done in the urban field practice area of JJM Medical College Davangere
among 440 geriatric subjects our study aimed at assessing the morbidity pattern and health
seeking behaviour of the geriatric population in the study area
In the present study Out of 440 study subjects majority 162(368) were in the age
group of 60-64 Years followed by 109 (247) in the age group of 65-69 Years 99 (225)
in the age group of 70-74 Years and 8 were more than or equal to 80 years of age [Table
7] This was similar to a study conducted by Prakash Boraingaiah et al 72 in which majority
of the elderly (346) belongs to age group 60-64 years followed by age group 75 years and
above (259)
In our study it was also seen that 59 of the study subjects were males and 41 were
females This was similar to a study conducted by Mohan Gupta et al 35 where 573
subjects were males and 427were females Our findings were contrary to a study
conducted by Md Alam Naushad et al 28 where 598 subjects were females and 402
were males
In the present study it was found that the majority of the study subject belonged to
Muslim religion 252 (573) followed by Hindus 188 (427) there were no study subjects
who belonged to other religions like Christian Jain Sikhs etc [Table 8] similar findings
were seen in a study conducted by Mrinal Ranjan Srivastav et al 50 in which 52 of the
subjects were Muslims
72
Discussion
In the present study it was found that the Majority of the study subjects were illiterate
525 whereas 275 had completed education up to primary school 82 had completed
education up to secondary school and only 32 were graduates [Table 9] These findings
were similar to a study done by Shraddha K et al 51in which 504 of the study subjects
were illiterate
In our study it was found that the majority of the study subjects 511 were unemployed
followed by 227 who were unskilled workers 155 were semi-skilled workers and
about 105 were skilled workers [Table 10] These findings were similar to a study done
by Rajat Das Gupta et al27 al in which 481 of the study subjects were not working
In our study majority of the subjects 49 belonged to Class IV Socioeconomic status
followed by 26 who belonged to class III and 13 who belonged to class II (according to
Modified BG Prasad Classification 2016) [Table 11] Similar findings were found in a study
conducted by Sribas Goswami and Manjari Sahai 29 in which majority of the study subjects
belonged to class IV socio economic status
In our study it was found that the majority of the study subjects 734 were married
followed by 261 who were widowed and only 05 were unmarried [Table 12] These
findings were similar to a study done by L subedhi and RB Sah 40 in which 663 of the
subjects were married 322 were widowed and 07 were unmarried
In the present study it was found that majority of the study subjects 42 lived in a three
generation family followed by 37 who lived in a nuclear family and 21 who lived in a
Joint family [Table 13] These findings were similar to a study done by Swapnil Jain et al 26
in which the majority (47) of the study subjects lived in a three generation family
73
Discussion
II Prevalence of morbidities among the study subjects
In the present study it was found that majority of the subjects 45 had a normal BMI
followed by 30 who were overweight about 15 were obese and only10 were
underweight [Figure 14] Similar findings were reported in a study conducted by Khadervali
Nagoor et al 44 in which 49 subjects had a normal BMI In a study done by Vimala
Thomas et al 52 272 of the subjects were obese which was higher than the present study
In the present study it was found that the majority of the subjects suffered from the
disorders of the musculoskeletal system (714) eye and adnexa (497) oral cavity
(311) respiratory system (229) digestive system (198)disease of the skin
(132)ear(13)genitourinary system (66) nervous system (25) [Table14] Similar
findings were seen in a study done by Rajashree Bhat et al 55 in which most common
morbidity of elderly was the problems of loco-motor system (486) followed by vision
(427) CVS disorders (344) respiratory system (202) and disease of ear (179)In
this study though the prevalence of loco-motor system disorders (486) was highest
compared to other disorders it was lesser compared to our study (714) In a study done by
L subedhi and RB Sah 40 it was found that 44 had eye problems 43 had gastrointestinal
problems 33 had CVS problems and 23 had ENT problems In this study the prevalence
of gastrointestinal disorders was much higher compared to our study
In the present study joint pain (including the knee joint) was most common disorder of the
musculoskeletal system seen in 40 of the males compared to 384 in females [Table 15]
whereas in a study done by Swapnil Jain et al 26 it was found that 472 males and 528
females suffered from joint pains This could be attributed to the fact that in our study
majority of the study subjects were males
74
Discussion
In the present study it was found that the most common morbidity of the eye was cataract
found in 39 of the subjects It was more common in males 43 compared to females
333 [ Table 16]These findings were similar to a study done by Shraddha K et al 51 in
which the overall prevalence of cataract was 302 of which 42 males and 358
females had cataract
In the present study it was found that the most common morbidity of the oral cavity was
missing teeth found in 177 of the subjects [Table 17] it was similar to the findings of a
study conducted by JP Singh et al 48 in which 1475 subjects were edentulous
The present study revealed that the most common disorder of the endocrine system was
diabetes mellitus found in 186 of the subjects followed by the nutritional disorder of
anemia found in 134 of the subjects It was seen that anemia was more common among
females 194 compared to males 92 [Table 18] Kakkar R et al 45 reported similar
findings with prevalence of diabetes mellitus as 153 In a study done by Deepak Sharma
et al 47 anemia was present in 15 of the subjects 97 males and 21 females were
anemic which was similar to our study
In our study it was found that the most common disease of the circulatory system was
hypertension which was found in 302 of the subjects it was more common in females
394 compared to males 239 and this difference was found to be statistically significant
[Table 19] A study by L Subedhi and RB Sah 40 reported that the prevalence of
hypertension was more among females (333) compared to males (30) which was
statistically significant
75
Discussion
In our study the most common morbidity of the respiratory system was upper respiratory
tract infection (163) [Table20] it was similar to the study done by Leena Rahul
Salunke33 where it was reported to be 196
In our study the most common disorder of the digestive system was gastritis (95)
[Table 21] similar to the findings of JP Singh et al 48 (35) contrary to this L subedhi
and RB Sah 40 reported a high prevalence of gastritis (39) This difference could be
attributed to the difference in the interpretation of symptoms for the diagnosis of gastritis
In our study the most common disorder of the skin was itching (48) [ Table 22] which
was similar to the findings reported by JP Singh et al 48 in which 225 subjects suffered
from itching
In our study the most common disorder of the ear was impaired hearing (111) [Table
23] similar to a study by Vandana Nikumb et al 38 in which 106 subjects suffered from
hearing impairment
In our study it was observed that the most common morbidity affecting the
genitourinary system was increased frequency of micturition (57) [Table 24]
L subedhi and RB Sah40 found in their study that 143 subjects suffered from increased
frequency of micturition which was higher compared to our study
Our study revealed that 25 subjects suffered from the disorders of the nervous
system [Table 25] similar to a study conducted by Vandana Nikumb et al 38 in which
13 of the Subjects suffered from the disorders of the nervous system whereas in a
study conducted by Shilpa Shaukaiah et al36 it was found that 66 of the subjects
suffered from the disorders of the nervous system which was higher than our study
76
Discussion
It is observed that the disease of the eye and adnexa increased with increasing age and were
more common in individuals above 80 years of age (714) The disease of the oral cavity
were also more common in the subjects aged 80 years and above (857) and 285
subjects aged 80 years and above suffered from disease of the ear A significant association
was found between age and these morbidities [Table 26] Similar results were found in a
study done by Swapnil Jain et al 26 in which cataract hearing impairment and dental
problems were significantly associated with the age of the study subjects
In our study a significant association was found between occupation and the disorders of
the musculoskeletal system skin and the nervous system Disorders of the musculoskeletal
system were more common among employed subjects (795) compared to unemployed
(635) 176 subjects who were employed suffered from the disease of the skin and
subcutaneous tissue compared to 88 who were unemployed Diseases of the nervous
system were more common among those who were unemployed (4) compared to those
who were employed (093) [Table 27]
A study done by Kakkar R et al45 found that there was a significant association between the
employment status and the morbidities of the CVS arthritis and cataract CVS morbidity
was more common among those not working (164) compared to those working (36)
Arthritis was also more common among not working (212) compared to those working
(55) and cataract was also more common among those not working (175) compared to
those working (55)
77
Discussion
In our study it was observed that there was a significant association between religion and
disorders of the digestive system and respiratory system The disorders of the digestive
system were more common among Muslims (238) compared to Hindus (144) Also the
disorders of the respiratory system were more common among Muslims (269) compared
to Hindus (176) [Table 28] In a study conducted by Mrinal Ranjan Srivastav et al 50 it
was found that there was significant association between religion and the morbidities of the
genitourinary system in the urban areas The problems of the genitourinary system were
more common among Hindus (26) compared to Muslims (96)
III HEATLTH SEEKING BEHAVIOR OF THE STUDY SUBJECTS
In our study it was found that that (898) study subjects visited a health facility in case
of an illness whereas 102 did not visit any health facility in case of an illness[Figure 16]
Similar findings were seen in a study conducted by Vimala Thomas et al 52 where it was
found that 716 subjects visited a health facility Contrary to our findings a study
conducted by Bhawalkar JS et al46 showed that only 81 subjects visited a health facility in
case of an illness whereas 919 did not visit any health facility
In the present study it was found that the most common reason stated by study subjects
for not seeking health care in case of an illness was that it was a mild discomfort (444)
followed by lack of money stated by (267) other reasons stated were no one to
accompany (156) and lack of faith in health care (133) [Table 29] In a study
conducted by Deepak Sharma et al 47 it was found that the most common reasons for not
seeking health care were the following disease due to age (496) health services too far
(191) lack of money (6) no body to take to hospital (35)
78
Discussion
It was observed that out of 395 subjects who visited health care facility in case of an illness
58 Visited government hospitals 362 visited private practitioners hospitals and 15
visited quacks [Table 30] similar results were found in a study conducted by Deepak Sharma
et al 47 in which 607 went to Government hospitals 267 consulted private practitioners
and 126 took over the counter drugs In another study conducted by Rajat Das Gupta et al
27 it was found that 33 visited Government hospitals 25 visited private hospitals 6
visited private practitioners
It was observed that more number of males (927) visited a health care facility in case of
an illness whereas only 856 females visited a health facility in case of an illness [Table
31] In a study done by Man Mohan Gupta et al 35 it was found that 672 females and
651 males visited a health facility in case of illness
In the present study it was found that 848 of the study subjects who were illiterate
visited a health facility in case of an illness whereas 152 did not visit a health facility in
case of an illness A significant association was found between educational status and
gender [Table 32] In a study done by Deepak Sharma et al 47 it was found that Gender
literacy income and marital status were not found to be significantly related to health-
seeking behaviour
In the present study it was found that 524 subjects visited a health facility every month
followed by 251 who visited a health facility once in 3 months 20once in 6 months
and 25 visited a health facility once in a year[ Table 33] In a study conducted by Rajat
Das Gupta et al 27 it was found that majority of the subjects (2943) visited a health
facility once a year followed by 2813 who visited a health facility once in three months
79
Conclusion
CONCLUSION
The study revealed that some of the common morbidities among the geriatric subjects were
the disorders of the musculoskeletal system followed by the disease of the eye and adnexa
oral cavity endocrine nutritional and metabolic disorders etc some disorders like cataract
dental caries constipation and increased frequency of micturition were more common
among males whereas disease like anemia and hypertension were more common among
females A significant association was found between some of the morbidities and socio
demographic determinants like age occupation and religion
Any degree of formal schooling was found to be associated with better health seeking
behavior Majority of the subjects visited a Government health facility in case of an illness
and the main reason that was stated for not visiting a health facility was that they suffered
from mild discomfort and did not consider it necessary to visit a health facility
80
Summary
SUMMARY
Our study was done in the urban field practice area of JJM Medical College Davangere
among 440 geriatric subjects our study aimed at assessing the morbidity pattern and health
seeking behaviour of the geriatric population in the study area
The results of our study are as follows
ISocio-demographic characteristics of the study subjects
In the present study 368 subjects were in the age group of 60-64 Years
59 of the subjects were males and 41 were females
573 subjects were Muslims whereas 427 were Hindus
Majority of the subjects were illiterate (525) whereas 275 had completed
education up to primary school
It was found that the majority of the study subjects (511) were unemployed
49 subjects belonged to Class IV Socioeconomic status according to Modified BG
Prasad Classification
734 of the subjects were married
42 of the people lived in a three generation family
II Prevalence of morbidities among the study subjects
Majority of the subjects (45) had a normal BMI followed 30who were
overweight
Majority 714 subjects suffered from the disorders of the musculoskeletal system
followed by 497 who suffered from the disease of the eye and adnexa35
suffered from the disease of the oral cavity 329 suffered from endocrine
nutritional and metabolic disorders and 311 suffered from the disease of the
circulatory system 229 suffered from the disease of the respiratory system198
81
Summary
suffered from the disease of the digestive system132 suffered from disease of the
skin13 suffered from the disease of the ear66 suffered from the disease of the
genitourinary system and 25 suffered from the disease of the nervous system
The most common morbidity of musculoskeletal system was pain of the joints (other
than the knee joint) found in 198 of the subjectsBack ache was more common in
females 231 compared to males 163 and this difference was found to be
statistically significant
cataract found in 39 of the subjects It was more common in males 43 compared
to females 333 and this difference was found to be statistically significant
Missing teeth were found in 177 of the subjects Dental caries were more
common in males 108 compared to females 44 and this difference was found to
be statistically significant
Diabetes mellitus found in 186 of the subjects followed by the nutritional disorder
of anemia found in 134 of the subjects anemia was more common among females
194 compared to males 92 This difference was found to be statistically
significant
Hypertension which was found in 302 of the subjects it was more common in
females 394 compared to males 239 and this difference was found to be
statistically significant
upper respiratory tract infection) found in 163 subjects followed by acute
bronchitis in 43 bronchial asthma in 14 and pulmonary TB in only 09
Gastritis was found in 95 subjects followed by constipation in 61 Among
males (81) had constipation compared to females(03)
Most common disease of the skin was itching which was present in 48 of the
study subjects followed by dryness in 43
82
Summary
Hearing impairment was found in 111 of the subjects
Increased frequency of micturition was found in 57 of the subjects followed by
burning micturition in 09 of the study subjects Increased frequency of
micturition was more among males 77 compared to females in whom it was 28
and this difference was found to be statistically significant
The most common disorder of the nervous system was neuritis seen in 11 of the
subjects followed by memory loss in 09 and stroke in 05 of the subjects
A significant association was found between increasing age and the morbidities of
the eye ear and the oral cavity
Significant association was found between occupation and the disorders of the
musculoskeletal system skin and the nervous system Disorders of the
musculoskeletal system were more common among employed subjects (795)
compared to unemployed (635) 176 subjects who were employed suffered
from the disease of the skin and subcutaneous tissue compared to 88 who were
unemployed Diseases of the nervous system were more common among those who
were unemployed (4) compared to those who were employed (093)
It was observed that the disorders of the digestive system were more common
among Muslims (238) compared to Hindus (144) this difference was found to
be statistically significant Also the disorders of the respiratory system were more
common among Muslims (269) compared to Hindus (176) This difference
was also found to be statistically significant
83
Summary
III HEATLTH SEEKING BEHAVIOR OF THE STUDY SUBJECTS
In our study 898 subjects visited a health facility in case of an illness whereas
102 did not
The most common reason stated by study subjects for not seeking health care in case
of an illness was that it was a mild discomfort (444) followed by lack of money
stated by (267) the other reasons stated were no one to accompany (156) and
lack of faith in health care (133)
It was observed that 58 subjects Visited Government hospitals 362 visited
private practitioners hospitals and 15 visited quacks
Majority of males (927) visited a health care facility in case of an illness whereas
only 856 females visited a health facility in case of an illness This difference was
found to be statistically significant
A significant association was found between the educational status and health
seeking behaviour Majority of the educated subjects visited a health facility in case
of an illness compared to those who were illiterate
It was found that 524 subjects visited a health facility every month followed by
251 who visited a health facility once in 3 months 20once in 6 months and
25 visited a health facility once in a year
84
Limitations
LIMITATIONS
1 Many of the responses were subjective and there were no records to verify them
2 Some of the morbidities were diagnosed only by clinical examination and could not be
confirmed by performing diagnostic tests due to high cost and time constraints
3 This study was done in the urban field practice area which consisted of a closed
community hence the results cannot be generalized to the entire population of the area
85
Recommendations
RECOMMENDATIONS
1 Health education should be given to the geriatric people regarding the common health
problems associated with ageing and preventive care should be provided to the elderly
2 Geriatric clinics should be set up at the primary health care level which provide regular
screening and health check-ups
3 There should also be a provision to provide domiciliary care by specialists qualified in
geriatrics
4 The family members and the care givers of the elderly should be educated about the
common health problems of the elderly and also about the need for regular health check-ups
and emotional support
5 The majority of the geriatric population is out of work force they are suffering from
many morbidities and are totally dependent on others even for their health needs Hence the
Government should increase the pension of the elderly and provide them quality healthcare
free of cost
6 There is also a need for public private partnership to improve the quality of health
services for the geriatric people More number of NGOs should work towards improving the
health and the quality of life of the elderly
86
References
REFERENCES
1 United Nations Department of Economic and Social affairs Population Division
World population ageing 2013 Available from URL
wwwunorgendevelopmentpopulationageingWorldPopulationAgeing2013
[Accessed on 17-7-2016]
2 Khan S and Itrat M Current Issues in Geriatric Health Care in India-A Review J Community Med Health Care 2016 1(1) 1-3
3 United Nations Department of Economic and Social Affairs Population Division
World Population Ageing 2015 ndash Highlights Available from URL
wwwunorgendevelopmentdesapopulationpdfageingWPA2015_Reportpdf
[Accessed on 272017]
4 State of elderly in India 2014 Help age India Available from URL
httpswwwhelpageindiaorgimagespdfstate-elderly-india-2014pdf [Accessed on
1082017]
5 World Health Organization World report on ageing and health 2015Available
from URL wwwwhointageingeventsworld-report-2015-launchen [Accessed on
1272017]
6 National policy for Senior citizens March 2011Ministry of Social Justice and
welfare Govt of India Available from URL
socialjusticenicinwritereaddataUploadFilednpscpdf [Accessed on 482017]
87
References
7 Elderly in India Profile and programmes 2016Govt of India Ministry of statistics
and programme implementation Central Statistics Office Available from URL
wwwmopsigovin [ Accessed on 1442017]
8 Saxena V Kandpal SD Gael D Bansal S Health status of elderly community
based study Indian Journal of Community Health2012 Oct-Dec24(4)269-74
9 Shah T Patel M Shah V Health care seeking behaviour of urban and rural
community in Ahmedabad district Int J Med Sci Public Health20132908-11
10 Sahoo H Mishra NR Health Status Morbidity Pattern and Treatment Seeking
Behaviour among Elderly in India Evidence from 60th round of National Sample
Survey Data Learning community 2011 Dec 2(3) 341-55
11 Park K Parkrsquos Textbook of Preventive and social medicine 24 th ed Jabalpur MS
Banarsidas Bhanot Publishers2017631
12 UNFPA- state of World Population 2011Chapter 1 setting the scene 19-31
Available from URL httpswwwunfpaorgsitesdefaultfilesresource-
pdfUNFPA-Report-Chapter1pd [Accessed on 1082017]
13 Lal S Adarsh Pankaj Textbook of community Medicine 4th ed CBS publishers and
distributors PvtLtd2011732
14 Census of India 2001 Registrar General And Census Commissioner India
Available from URL httpwwwcensusindiagovinCensus[Accessed on
7102015]
15 SRS bulletin October 2012 Registar General of India New Delhi Available from
URL censusindiagovinvital_statisticsSRS_BulletinsSRS_Bulletin-
October_2012[Acessed on 7102015]
88
References
16 Bagchi K Healthy ageing Health and Population-Perspectives and Issues 2000
23(1)11-16
17 Salagre SB The Association of Physicians of India Chapter 177 Health Issues in
Geriatrics Available from URL
wwwapiindiaorgmedicine_update_2013chap177pd [ Accessed on 282017]
18 Ingle GK Nath A Geriatric Health in India Concerns and Solutions Indian Journal
of Community Medicine 2008 33(4)214-18
19 World Health Organization Active Ageing a policy framework 2002 Available
from httpwhqlibdocwhointhq2002who_nmh_nph_028pdf [Accessed on
1062017]
20 Inche Zainal Abidin S Sutan R Shamsuddin K Prevalence and determinants of
appropriate health seeking behaviour among known diabetics Results from a
community-based survey Advances in Epidemiology 2014 Nov 20141-6
21 Begashaw B Tessema F Gesesew HA Health Care Seeking behavior in Southwest
Ethiopia Plos one 2016 Sep 11(9)e0161014
22 MacKian S Health systems development Manchester University of Manchester
2003 A review of health seeking behavior problems and prospects
23 Metta EO Health-seeking behaviour among adults in the context of the
epidemiological transition in Southeastern Tanzania A focus on malaria and
diabetes [Groningen] University of Groningen 2016 228 Available from URL
httpswwwrugnlresearchportalfiles28737720Chapter_7pdf [Accessed on
1272017]
24 Adhikari D Rijal D Factors affecting health seeking behaviour of senior citizens of
Dharan Journal of Nobel Medical College 2015 Sep 4(1)57-63
25 Polisetty S Seepana M Morbidity profile of elderly individuals in urban
Visakhapatnam Int J Community Med Public Health 2017 4(2)2558-63
89
References
26 Jain S Kaware AC Doibale MK Shaikh S Radhey BK Mathurkar MP Morbidity
pattern among geriatric population in urban field practice area of district of
Maharashtra a cross sectional study Int J Community Med Public Health 2016
3(2)523-29
27 Gupta RD Loha A Roy S Morbidity pattern and health-seeking behaviour among
the senior citizens in a selected urban area of Bangladesh A cross-sectional study
South East Asia Journal of Public Health 2016 Jul 5(2)43-49
28 Naushad MA Verma N Bhawnani D Jain M Anand T Umate LV Morbidity
pattern and health seeking behaviour in elderly population of Raipur City
Chhattisgarh India Indian Journal of Community Health2016 Sep 28(3)236-41
29 Goswami S Sahai M A Study of Morbidity Pattern in Elderly Population European
Researcher Series A 2016103(2)119-28
30 Bardhan H Dixit AM Agarwal R Jain PK Gupta S Shukla SK Morbidity profile
of elderly population in Ghaziabad district a cross-sectional study Int J Med Sci
Public Health 2016 5(6)1098-1102
31 Maroof M Ahmad A Khalique N Ansari MA Health problems among the aged A
community based study from urban Aligarh Uttar Pradesh India Int J Community
Med Public Health 2016 Feb 3(4)944-47
32 Shankar G Sidenur B A morbidity study of elderly residing in urban field practice
area of SN medical college Bagalkot National Journal of research in community
medicine 2016 Oct-Dec 4(5) 229-34
90
References
33 Salunkhe LR Socio-demographic profile of old age people living in urban amp urban
slum areas in Maharashtra Karad A comparative study J of Evidence based Med
and Hlthcare 2015 Feb 2(5) 513-21
34 Warbhe P Rupesh W Morbidity profile health seeking behaviour and home
environment survey for adaptive measures in geriatric population-Urban community
study International Journal of Medical Research amp Health Sciences 2015 4(4)778-
82
35 Gupta M Borle AL Chhari N Gupta S Assessment of clinico-socioeconomic
status and health-care support among the elderly people aged older than 60 years in
urban population of Bhopal Central India Int J Med Sci Public Health 2015
4558-64
36 Sahukaiah S Shenoy A Vijayakumar BC An epidemiological study of prevalence
of morbidity patterns among geriatric age group in an urban slum of Mumbai Int J
Med Sci Public Health 2015 Jul 4(7)883-87
37 Shubha Davalagi B Angadi N Mahabalaraju DK Morbidity psycho-social profile
and health seeking behaviour of the elderly population in urban slums of Davangere
City India Int J Res Med Sci 2015 Nov 3(11)3288-91
38 Nikumb V Patankar F Behera A A Study of Morbidity Profile among Geriatric
Population in an Urban Area Sch J App Med Sci 2015 3(3)1365-69
91
References
39 Vishnoi BR Solanki SL Singhal G Meharda B Mishra N Morbidity profile of
elderly in urban slum of Udaipur Rajasthan Int J Oral Health Med Res 2015 May
2(1)9-12
40 Subedi L Sah RB Study of the health status of geriatric age group in Chitwan
district of Nepal Journal of Chitwan Medical College 2015 Mar 5(1)11-17
41 Noor S Krishnababu G Prasad KV Health status of Geriatric population in slums
of Rourkela Young Innovative Journal of Medical and Health Science 2015 May
5(3) 92-94
42 Sarode VM Chronic Diseases Related to Aging and Disease Prevention in Slums in
Mumbai Journal of Aging Science 2014 Jan 2 (1)1-6
43 Barman SK Lata K Ram R Ghosh N Sarker G Shahnawaz K A study of
morbidity profile of geriatric population in an urban community of Kishanganj
Bihar India Global Journal of Medicine and Public Health GJMEDPH 2014 3(1)
1-7
44 Nagoor K Srikanth BA Dudekula R Satna K Comparative study of health status
among slum and non-slum elderly population in Kadapa Region South India
Journal of Evolution of Medical and Dental Sciences 2014 Feb 3(5)1298-308
45 Kakkar R Aggarwal P Kandpal SD Bansal SK An Epidemiological study to assess
morbidity profile among geriatric population in District Dehradun Indian Journal of
Community Health 2013 May 25(1)39-44
46 Bhawalkar JS Dhone AB Jethani S Singru S Jadhav SL Adyanthaya S A study of
morbidity profile among geriatric population in an urban area J Evol Med Dent Sci
2013 Sep 9 36(2)6963-7
92
References
47 Sharma D Mazta SR Parashar A Morbidity pattern and health-seeking behaviour of
aged population residing in Shimla hills of north India A cross-sectional study
Journal of family medicine and primary care 2013 Apr2(2)188
48 Singh JP Singh S Kasturwar NB Hassan A Geriatric morbidity profile in an urban
slum Central India Indian Journal of Community Health 2013 Aug 25(2)164-70
49 Thakur RP Banerjee A Nikumb VB Health Problems among the Elderly A Cross
Sectional Study Annals of medical and health sciences research 2013 3(1)19-25
50 Mrinal RS Beena S Pratibha G Pankaj B Srivastava JP Atul B Morbidity Status
and Its Social Determinants among Elderly Population of Lucknow District India
Sch J App Med Sci 2013 1(6)758-64
51 Shraddha K Prashantha B Prakash B Study on morbidity pattern among elderly in
urban population of Mysore Karnataka India International Journal of Medicine and
Biomedical Research 2012 1(3)215-23
52 Thomas V Lavanya KM Morbidity profile and health seeking behaviour of the
elderly in urban slums of Hyderabad Andhra Pradesh India- A cross sectional study
International Journal of Current Research and Review 2012 Oct 1 4(19)174-80
53 Moe S Tha K Naing DK Htike MM Health seeking behaviour of elderly in
Myanmar International Journal of Collaborative Research on Internal Medicine and
Public Health 2012 4(8)1538-44
93
References
54 Bharati DR Pal R Rekha R Yamuna TV Kar S Radjou AN Ageing in
Puducherry South India An overview of morbidity profile Journal of pharmacy amp
bio allied sciences 2011 Oct 3(4)537
55 Bhatt R Gadhvi MS Sonaliya KN Solanki A Nayak H An epidemiological study
of the morbidity pattern among the elderly population in Ahmedabad Gujarat
National Journal of community medicine 2011 Jul 2(2)233-36
56 Srinivasan Krishnamachari Vaz Mario Thomas Tinku Prevalence of health related
disability among community dwelling urban elderly from middle socioeconomic
strata in Bangaluru India Indian Journal of Medical Research 2010 Apr 131(4)
515-21
57 Srivastava K Gupta SC Kaushal SK Chaturvedi M Morbidity profile of elderly a
cross sectional study of urban Agra Indian Journal of Community Health 2010 Jun
22(1)51-55
58 Ladha A Khan R Malik A Khan S Khan B Khan I et al The health seeking
behaviour of elderly population in a poor-urban community of Karachi Pakistan
Journal of the Pakistan Medical Association2009 Feb 59(2) 89-92
59 WHO ICD-10 version 2010 Geneva World Health Organization Available from
URL appswhointclassificationsicd10browse2010en [Accessed on 772017]
60 OpenEpi22OpenEpi (free) download Windows version Available from URL
enfreedownloadmanagerorgWindows-PCOpenEpi-FREEhtml
61 Tandon R Sinhota Parsonrsquos disease of the eye 22edNew Delhi Elsevier 98-100
62 Dhingra P L Dhingra S Disease of ear nose and throat and head and neck surgery
6th ed New Delhi Elsevier 201422
94
References
63 Aziz N Kallur SD Nirmalan PK Implications of the revised consensus body mass
indices for Asian Indians on clinical obstetric practice Journal of clinical and
diagnostic research 2014 May 8(5)OC01
64 Chobanion AV Bakris GL Black HR The seventh report of the joint national
committee on prevention detection evaluation and treatment of high blood pressure
the JNC 7 report JAMA 2003 2892560-72
65 The Seventh Report of the Joint National Committee on Prevention Detection
Evaluation and Treatment of High Blood Pressure (JNC 7) The GuidelinesUS
Department of Health and Human Services National Heart Lung and Blood
Institute Available at URL
httpswwwnhlbinihgovfilesdocsguidelinesjnc7fullpdf [ Accessed on
1282017]
66 Firkin F Chestman C Penington D Rush B De Gruchyrsquos clinical Hematology in
medical practice 5th edition New Delhi Blackwell science Ltd1989 32-47
67 Report of WHO consultation Nutritional Anaemias Geneva Switzerland World
Health Organization TRS-405 1968 Available from URL
whqlibdocwhointtrsWHO_TRS_405pdf [Accessed on 1282017]
68 National Family Health survey (NFHS-4) 2015-16 India Mumbai IIPS
2016Available from URL httpwwwnfhsindiaorg [Accessed on 4072017]
69 The Minimum Wages Act 1948 Ministry of Labour and Employment Government
of India Available from URL httplabourgovincontentinnerpagewagesphp
[Accessed on 1082017]
70 Khairnar M Wadgave U Shimpi P Updated BG Prasad socioeconomic
classification for 2016 Journal of Indian Association of Public Health Dentistry
2016 Oct 1 14(4)469
95
References
71 Tiwari P Tiwari S Mastering practicals community medicine 1st ed New Delhi
India Wolters Kluwer PvtLtd2013161-67
72 Boralingaiah P Bettappa P Kashyap S Prevalence of Psycho-Social Problems
among Elderly in Urban Population of Mysore City Karnataka India Indian journal
of psychological medicine 2012 Oct 34(4)360
96
PATIENT CONSENT FORM JJM MEDICAL COLLEGE DAVANGERE
DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY MEDICINE I the undersigned hereby give my consent
for investigations carried upon me I am satisfied with the information given about this
Clinical study titled ldquoA STUDY ON THE MORBIDITY PATTERN AND HEALTH
SEEKING BEHAVIOR AMONG THE GERIATRIC POULATION IN THE
URBAN FIELD PRACTICE AREA OF JJM MEDICAL COLLEGE
DAVANGERErdquo ldquoconducted by Dr RUCHI DHAR under the guidance of Dr VIDYA
GS Associate Professor I have been informed and explained the risks involved and I
hereby voluntarily and Unconditionally give my consent without any fear or pressure in
mentally sound and conscious state to participate in this study
DATE PATIENTrsquoS SIGNATURE
eEacuteeEacuteJA ordfEacuteEcirczAgravearingQAtildeAiAgraveAuml ordfAgraveAumlordmAacutelaquozAacutearingregAiAgraveAuml zAacuteordfAgravetUEacutegEacute
ryenAacutemiumlethordfEacuteAumlAmiumlDyensiumlPAgraveordfAgraveAumlAumlaringcurrenn ordfEacuteAumlrsup1poundiuml
ordfEacuteEcirczAgravearingQAtildeAiAgraveAumlvAgraveyenAacutecedilAgraveuEacuteUEacuteMbrvbaragraveUEacute yenAgravevAgraveaelig F PEacutefrac14AgraveUEacute cedilAgraveraquo ordfAgraveiAacutergAgraveAumlordfAgrave poundAacutepoundAgraveAuml CAzAgravegEacute
poundAgravepoundAgraveszlig
ordfEacuteEcirczAgravearingQAtildeAiAgraveAumlvAgraveyenAacutecedilAgraveuEacute ordmAacuteUAgraveAElig plusmnAgravecedilAgraveUcircccedilaQvEacuteigraveUEacuteAzAgraveAuml poundAgravepoundAgraveszligMbrvbaragraveUEacuteAiAgraveAumlpoundAgraveAumlszlig
cedilAgraveAEligasup1gAgraveAumlvEacuteUcircAtildepoundEacute J cedilAgraveOumlr Dyensiuml zAgrave ordfEacuteAEligcopyethrn yenAacutearinglpoundiumleth CAqiuml ordmEacutemacriumlUcirc sup1AtildeQAUiuml copyordmEacuteAtildelaquoAiAgraveAumlgiuml Dyensiuml zAgrave fjAiAgraveiAacutenaeligPiuml yenEacuteAEligAtildeyenAgraveAumlaringmacrEacuteAtildemicroAgravepoundiuml Epoundiuml zAgrave Csectethpoundiuml brvbarAtildemacriumlOslash yenAacuteaeligoumlaringQOumlAtildecediliuml JjAiAgraveAuml Dyensiuml ddordfAgraveAumlAuml ordfEacuteEcirczAgravearingQAtildeAiAgraveAuml ordfAgraveAumlordmAacutelaquozAacutearingregAiAgraveAuml zAacuteordfAgravetUEacutegEacute JAsect sup2AtildeparaethPEacuteAiAgraveAumlrAiAgraveAumldegegrave yenAgravejAtildePEacuteeumlUEacute Mfrac14AgraveyenAgravercedilAgraveAumlordfAgrave ordfEacuteEcirczAgravearinggAacutezAgrave qAacute|| gAgraveAumla zAgravesAgravegAgrave ordfAgraveAumlvAgraveAumlUcirc qAacute|| laquozAacutearing fJcediliumlordfAgraveiAacuteUAgraveethzAgraveplusmnAgraveethPAgravegAacutezAgrave yenEacuteAEligaeligAtildeyensEacutecedilAgravegiuml
EordfAgravegAgraveAuml poundAgravepoundAgraveUEacute F vAgraveyenAacutecedilAgraveuEacuteUEacute Mfrac14AgraveyenAgraveqAgraveAumlordfAgrave ordfAgraveAumlAumlpoundAgraveszlig yenAgraveaeligwAiEacuteAEligAzAgraveAuml
CAplusmnAgraveUAgravefrac14AgravepoundAgraveAumlszlig CxAgraveethordfAacuteUAgraveAumlordfAgraveAvEacute wfrac12sup1gAgraveAumlvAacuteUcircgEacuteDzAgraveYacutejAzAgrave poundAacutepoundAgraveAuml poundAgravepoundAgraveszlig
ordfAgraveAumlpoundAgravecedilAacutegEacute AiAgraveiAacuteordfAgraveAringzEacuteAtilde umlsAgraveAiAgraveAuml ordfAgraveAumlvAgraveAumlUcirc AiAgraveiAacutegAgrave MvAacuteUcircAiAgraveAumllaquoregegravezEacute poundAacutepoundAgraveAuml
vAgraveyenAacutecedilAgraveuEacute aQvEacuteigraveUEacuteAEligfrac14AgraveyenAgraveqAgraveregAuml MbrvbaragraveUEacuteAiAgraveAumlpoundAgraveAumlszlig cedilAgraveAEligasup1gAgraveAumlvEacuteUcircAtildepoundEacute
centpoundAacuteAPAgrave gEacuteAEligAtildeVAi
Annexures
ANNEXURE ndashIII
104
Annexures
PROFORMA
I General information
1 NAME
2 AGE
3 GENDER (a) Male (b) Female
4 MARITAL STATUS (a) Unmarried (b) Married (c) Widow Widower
(d) Divorced separated
5 LIVING ARRANGEMENT (a) with spouse (b) Spouse and children
(c) Children only (d) living alone (e) others
6 RELIGION (a) Hindu (b) Muslim (c) Christian (d) Others
7 ADDRESS
8 EDUCATION (a) illiterate (b) Primary school (c) higher primary
(d) secondary school (e)PUC diploma (e) Graduate (f) Postgraduate
9 OCCUPATION (a) professional (b) semi- professional (c) skilled worker
(d) Semi ndashskilled worker (e) unskilled worker (f) unemployed
10 CONTACT NUMBER
11 TYPE OF FAMILY (a) Joint (b) Nuclear (C) three generation
12 TOTAL NUMBER OF FAMILY MEMBERS
13 TOTAL FAMILY INCOME
14 PER CAPITA FAMILY INCOME
15 SOCIO ECONOMIC STATUS (Modified BG Prasad classification) I IIIIIIVV
16 DIET (a) Vegetarian (b) Mixed
17 Sleep (a) Disturbed if yes reason ______________ (b) Not disturbed
18 Bowel Regular Irregular
19 Bladder Regular Irregular
97
Annexures
20 HABITS (a) betel nut (b) tobacco (c) alcohol (d) smoking (e) others
If any of the habits present Duration (since when) _________
Frequency of consumption day_______
IIAssessment of morbidity based on history
1 Whether suffering from any chronic illness like (a) Type 2 DM (b) Hypertension
(c) Bronchial Asthma (d) TB (e) others
2 Whether suffering from cataract currently (a) Yes (b) No
3 Whether operated for cataract (a) Yes (b) No If Yes duration since operation____
4 MUSCULOSKELETAL SYSTEM
Whether the following symptoms are present
(a) Backache (b) Joint pain (c) restricted joint movements (d) pain in calves
(e) Others_________
5 RESPIRATORY SYSTEM
(a) Productive cough (b) non-productive cough (c) nasal discharge (d) breathlessness (e)
sore throat (f) sneezing
6 CARDIOVASCULAR SYSTEM
(a) Palpitations (b) chest pain (c) breathlessness
7 GASTROINTESTINAL SYSTEM
(a) Pain abdomen (b) lose stools (c) constipation (d) flatulence (e) heart burn
(f) Bleeding per rectum
8 EYE AND ADNEXA
(a) Watering (b) diminution of vision (c) redness
9 EAR
(a) Discharge (b) decreased hearing (c) Tinnitus
10 SKIN
(a) Itching (b) skin eruptions (c) scaling (d) pigmentation
98
Annexures
11 GENITO URINARY SYSTEM
(a) Burning micturition (b) increased frequency of micturition
12 GENERAL SYMPTOMS
(a) Fatigue (b) headache (c) fever
13 ANY OTHER COMPLAINTS (a) burning feet (b) swelling in groin
(c) Memory loss (d) insomnia
III Assessment of health seeking behaviour
1 Do you visit a health facility in case of illness (a) Yes (b) No
If yes how much time do you take to visit a health facility an case of an illness
(a) Within 24 hours (b) 24-48 hours (c) more than 48 hours
2 Which type of health facility do you visit
(a) Govt hospital (b) Private practitioners (c) over the counter drugs (e) quacks
Mention the reason for visiting the particular health facility______________________
3 Whether taking regular treatment after diagnosis ________________
If No mention the reason_______________________
4 Whether following the instructions given by the treating doctor
(a) Yes (b) no
5 cost of treatment per month in case of chronic disease
(a) lt100 (b) 100-200 (c) 200-300 (d) 300 and above
6 Person bearing the cost of treatment
(a) Self (b) spouse (c) son (d) daughter (d) outside help
7 Duration to reach the health facility
(a) less than 3o minutes (b) 30 minutes or more
8 Whether going for regular check -ups (a) Yes (b) No
If Yes duration between the check-ups_______
99
Annexures
9 Whether following self- care practices in case of chronic disease like diabetes and hypertension
(a) Yes (b) No
10 In case of healthy individuals whether getting screening tests done (a) Yes (b) No
11 Whether following any dietary modifications (a) yes (b) No
12 Whether any family member accompanies you to the health facility
If yes who (a) Son (b) daughter (c) spouse (d) others
11 Whether the family supports in following specific diet advised by the doctor
(a) Yes (b) No
12 whether family members help in reminding to take regular medication
(a) Yes (b) No
IV Physical examination
1 Personal hygiene status
S NO COMPONENT CONDITION REMARKS
1 Hair
2 Teeth
3 Bath
4 Clothes
5 Washing hand before
eating food
6 Washing hands with soap
and water after ablution
7 Nails
8 Foot wear
Remarks personal hygiene status Good fair poor
100
Annexures
2 MEASUREMENTS
(a) Weight (in Kg) ______ (b) Height (in cm) _____ (c) BMI ______
(d) Waist circumference______ (e) Hip circumference ___________
(f) Waist hip ratio_________
3 GENERAL PHYSICAL EXAMINATION
Pallor Icterus Cyanosis clubbing lymphadenopathy Oedema
Pulse rate Temp Blood Pressure
Respiratory rate
20 Examination of
Eye Oral cavity Ear
Nose Throat
SYSTEMIC EXAMINATION
Cardiovascular system Respiratory system
Per abdomen Central Nervous system
101
MASTER CHART
Annexures
ANNEXURES
International Classification of Diseases (10th Revision)
I Certain infectious and parasitic diseases (A00-B99)
II Neoplasms (C00-D48)
III Diseases of blood and blood forming organs and certain disorders
involving the immune mechanisms (D50-D89)
IV Endocrine nutritional and metabolic diseases (E00-E90)
V Mental and behavioural disorders (F00-F99)
VI Diseases of the nervous system (G00-G99)
VII Diseases of the eye and adnexa (H00-H59)
VIII Diseases of the ear and mastoid process ( H60-H95)
IX Diseases of the circulatory system (I00-I99)
X Diseases of the respiratory system ( J00-J99)
XI Diseases of the digestive system (K00-K93)
XII Diseases of the skin and subcutaneous tissue ( L00-L99)
XIII Diseases of the musculoskeletal system and connective tissue
(M00-M99)
XIV Diseases of the genitourinary system ( N00-N99)
XV Pregnancy childbirth and purperium (O00-O99)
XVI Certain conditions originating in perinatal period (P00-P96)
XVII Congenital malformations deformations and chromosomal
XVIII (S00-T98)
XIX External causes of morbidity and mortality (V01-Y98)
102
Annexures
XX Injury poisoning and certain other consequences of external causes
(S00-T98)
XXI Factors influencing health status and contact with health services
(Z00-Z99)
XXII Codes for special purpose
103
Annexures
105
Annexures
106
Annexures
107
Annexures
PHOTOS
Picture 1 Showing the investigator interviewing the study subject
Picture 2 Showing the investigator interacting with the study subject
108
Annexures
Picture 3 Showing the investigator recording the Blood pressure of the study subject
Picture 4 Showing the investigator auscultating the study subject
109
Annexures
110
27
Association between morbidity pattern of the study subjects and
their occupation
62
28
Association between morbidity pattern of the study subjects and
their religion
64
29 Reasons cited by the study subjects for not seeking healthcare in
case of an illness
67
30 Distribution of the study subjects based on the type of health facility
visited
68
31 Association between gender and health care seeking behavior of the
study subjects
69
32 Association between educational status and health care seeking
behaviour of the study subjects
70
33 Distribution of study subjects according to frequency of visits to a
health care facility
71
xv
LIST OF FIGURES
Figure No
Title Page No
1 Proportion of elderly in the Indian population by age groups
1961-2001
6
2 Pathophysiology of health issues in geriatrics 10
3 Predicting health behaviour with social cognition models 13
4 Health belief model components and linkages 15
5 Maps showing the location of Davangere district and the
area where the UHTC is located
27
6 Map showing the Urban field practice area of JJM medical college
28
7 Age and sex wise distribution of the study subjects 39
8 Distribution of the study subjects based on religion 40
9 Distribution of the study subjects based on Educational status 41
10 Distribution of study subjects based on their occupation 42
11
Distribution of study subjects based on their occupation
43
12 Distribution of the study subjects based on their marital status 44
13 Distribution of the study subjects based on the type of family 45
14 Distribution of the study subjects based on the BMI 46
15 Distribution of morbidity pattern of the study subjects based on
ICD 10 classification of diseases
48
16 Distribution of the study subjects based on the visit to health
facility in case of an illness
66
xvi
ABSTRACT Background
According to census 2011 the elderly population aged 60 years and above account for 8
of total population and is projected to rise to 124 by the year 2026 Health status is an
important factor that has a significant impact on quality of life The elderly are one of the
most vulnerable and high risk groups in terms of health status and their health seeking
behaviour is crucial in any society
Objectives
1 To study the morbidity pattern among the geriatric population in the urban field
practice area of JJM Medical college Davangere
2 To assess the health seeking behaviour of the elderly residing in the study area
Methods It was a community based cross sectional study which was conducted in the urban field
practice area of JJM Medical College Davangere The total study subjects were 440
individuals aged 60 years and above Data was collected using a predesigned pre-tested
and semi- structured questionnaire Height weight and blood pressure were measured
and recorded Data was analyzed by using MS Excel and Open-Epi Info software
version 22 Statistical test employed was chi-square and Fishers exact test x
Results and Conclusion
In our study it was found that the majority of the subjects (368) were in the age group
of 60-64 years 525 were illiterate 511 were unemployed and 49 belonged to class
IV socio economic status The study revealed that the some of the common morbidities
among the geriatric subjects were the disorders of the musculoskeletal system (714)
eye and adnexa (497) oral cavity (329) endocrine nutritional and metabolic
disorders (329)etc some disorders like cataract dental caries constipation and
increased frequency of micturition were more common among males whereas disease
like anemia and hypertension were more common among females A significant
association was found between some of the morbidities and socio demographic
determinants like age occupation and religion
Any degree of formal schooling was found to be associated with better health seeking
behavior Majority of the subjects (58) visited a Government health facility in case of
an illness and the main reason that was stated for not visiting a health facility was that
they suffered from mild discomfort (444) and did not consider it necessary to visit a
health facility
Key words Geriatric urban behaviour morbidity
xi
Introduction
INTRODUCTION
ldquoA STUDY ON THE MORBIDITY PATTERN AND HEALTH SEEKING BEHAVIOUR AMONG THE GERIATRIC POPULATION IN THE URBAN FIELD
PRACTICE AREA OF JJM MEDICAL COLLEGE DAVANGERErdquo
All countries of the world are experiencing population ageing Ageing is a result of
decreasing mortality and most importantly declining fertility The global share of older
people (aged 60 years and above) has increased from 92 per cent in 1990 to 117 in
2013 and will continue to grow as a proportion of the world population reaches 211 by
20501
The lsquoNational Policy for Older Personsrsquo was adopted by the Government of India in
January 1999 and it defines a lsquosenior citizenrsquo or lsquoelderlyrsquo as a person who is aged 60 years
or above Ageing is a progressive process associated with declines in structure and
function impaired maintenance and repair systems increased susceptibility to disease and
death2
In 2015 Worldwide there were 901 million people aged 60 years or over It is
projected that their number will grow to 14 billion in 2030 which is the target date for the
SDGs and to 21 billion by 2050 There will be growth in the number of older persons aged
60 years and above between 2015 and 2030 This increase is projected to be especially
significant global phenomenon and virtually every country in the world will experience a
substantial increase including the less developed regions3 The increased life expectancy has
led to challenges in health care management The elderly suffer from various diseases which
include non-communicable disease (NCDs) like diabetes hypertension coronary heart
disease and other disorders like osteoarthritis stroke dementia osteoporosis cancer
1
Introduction enlarged prostate depression and cataract related blindness In the coming years there will
be a phenomenal growth in the population of the elderly while the family size will reduce
The disintegration of the joint family and women moving out of the household has led to the
absence of traditional caregivers for the elderly who are already a vulnerable group4
The most common cause of health problems in the old aged people is chronic diseases
Most of these problems can be prevented or delayed by engaging in healthy behaviours
Even in the advanced years of life physical activity and good nutrition can have
effective benefits on health and well-being Many health problems of old age can be
effectively managed if they are detected early enough5 The National Policy for Older
Persons was announced by the Government of India in the year 1999 The Constitution of
India under Article 41 mandates the well-being of senior citizens ldquoThe state shall
within the limits of its economic capacity and development make effective provision
for securing the right to public assistance in case of old aged peoplerdquo 6
National Council for Older Persons (NCOP) has been reconstituted and renamed as
National Council for Senior Citizens (NCSrC) in order to have a definite structure and also
regional balancing the NCOP advises the Central and State Governments on a broad range
of issues related to welfare of senior citizens and enhancement of their quality of life The
NCSrc meets at least twice a year7 The elderly suffer from multiple medical as well as
psychological problems There has already been some pioneering work on the elderly in
India but a lot more remains to be done There is an urgent need to pay attention
towards the medical and socio-economic problems that are being faced by the elderly
people in India and thus formulate strategies to bring about an improvement in their
quality of life8 The Health seeking behaviour is influenced by various factors which
include the individual self diseases and the availability and accessibility of health
2
services It is important to have knowledge regarding the health seeking behaviour of
individuals for designing health care policies and programmes so that all the possible
difficulties with early diagnosis and effective treatment can be identified and appropriate
interventions can be implemented9 As already stated the elderly are a vulnerable group as
there are psychological as well as physiological changes with increasing age and it is
difficult to cope up with the problems of ageing Some of the most common problems in old
age are cardiovascular problems arthritis respiratory problems blood pressure and so on
Therefore the study of the health status of elderly morbid conditions perceptions about
it is important to note and the health care of the elderly becomes very important since they
are more prone to illness than young people and are also more prone to domestic and other
accidents Their health and treatment seeking behaviour are most important for the
formulation of welfare programmes of the country 10
Hence this study was taken up in the urban field practice area of JJM Medical College
Davangere to assess the morbidity pattern and health seeking behaviour of the geriatric
subjects
3
Objectives
OBJECTIVES
1 To study the morbidity pattern among the geriatric population in the urban field
practice area of JJM Medical college Davangere
2 To assess the health seeking behaviour of the elderly residing in the study area
4
Review of literature
vii
REVIEW OF LITERATURE
1 Definition Geriatrics or clinical gerontology Is the term used for the care of the aged 11 The United Nations uses 60 years and above to refer to older people the same is also used
by demographers However in many developed countries the age of 65 is used as the
reference point for older persons 12
Elderly are classified in to 3 groups 13
Young old Persons in the age group of 60 years to 74 years
Old old Persons in the age group of 75 years to 84 years
Oldest old Persons above the age of 85 yrs
2 Demography of the ageing population in India
The UN defines a country as ldquoAgeingrdquo or ldquoGreying Nationrdquo where the
proportion of people over 60 reaches 7 percent to total population By 2011 India has
exceeded that proportion (80 percent) and is expected to reach 126 percent in 2025
The Indian population has increased from 361 million in 1951 to 1027 billion in 2001
and further to 121 billion in 2011 Simultaneously the number of older people has
increased from 19 million (ie 4 percent of total population) to 77 million and
further to roughly 93 million (ie 75 percent of the total) during the same time
span 14
5
Review of literature
Figure1 proportion of elderly in the Indian population by age groups 1961-2001 14
Table 1 Percentage share of elderly population (aged 60 years and above) in total
population by sex in India 15
Years Male Female Total Rural Urban
1961 55 58 56 58 47
1971 59 60 60 62 50
1981 64 66 65 68 54
1991 67 68 68 71 57
2001 71 78 75 77 67
2011 77 84 80 81 79
2004-05 69 75 72 73 70
2007-08 73 77 75 76 72
6
Review of literature
The rise in population of males was more modest from 55 percent to 71 percent while for
females there had been a steep rise from 58 percent to 78 percent during five decadal
Censuses from 1961 to 2001 In 2011 the elderly population accounted for 80 percent of
total population For males it was marginally lower at 77 percent while for females it was
84 percent According to NSSO surveys the proportion of elderly population in rural areas
was 73 percent during 2004-05 and increased up to 76 percent in 2007-08 While on the
other hand in urban areas the proportion of elderly population rose from 70 percent to 72
percent during the corresponding period It has been observed that the percentage share of
elderly to total population remained higher in rural areas than in urban areas15
Table2 Size of elderly population (aged 60+) and their share in total population in major states of India in 201115
All India and selected major states
Proportion of elderly in total population of State
Male Female Total Andhra Pradesh 83 94 88 Bihar 72 67 70 Gujarat 76 90 83 Haryana 66 76 71 Himachal Pradesh 104 103 104 Karnataka 79 89 84 Kerala 118 133 126 Madhya Pradesh 68 74 71 Maharashtra 88 97 93 Orissa 91 95 93 Punjab 91 100 95 Rajasthan 66 79 72 Tamil Nadu 102 109 105 Uttar Pradesh 66 71 68 West Bengal 82 82 82 All India 77 84 80
7
Review of literature
3 MORBIDITY PATTERN AMONG THE ELDERLY
Physiological Decline and Consequences of increasing age
Ageing i s a process of decline in biological functions affecting most physical
Systems The following systems are affected by ageing
(a) Atrophy of the Taste Buds and Loss of Teeth
With the increasing age the taste buds of the tongue get atrophied and as a result the
preference for food alters significantly There is also a considerable loss of teeth causing
difficulties in chewing food
(b) Changes in the Gastrointestinal Tract
As the age advances the walls of the intestine get atrophied and the motility is
markedly reduced (lazy intestine) The digestive enzymes secreted by the intestine are
also reduced Hence the partly digested food stays in the intestine for a longer period
As a result the common complaint of the elderly person is gas formation (flatulence)
and constipation
(c) Respiratory System
As the age advance there is progressive fibrosis of the lungs leading to reduced
oxygenation of the lungs and breathing difficulties
(d) Kidney and genitourinary System
The kidneys get smaller in size and the power of the kidneys to filter out the unwanted
waste products from the body is diminished The total amount of urine becomes less in
old age and thus the waste products are not adequately excreted from the body
8
Review of literature
(e) Urinary Bladder
Urinary bladder gets smaller in size due to shrinkage and as a result the accumulation
of urine even of a small amount leads to an urge for urination With increase in age
the valve in the bladder which controls the exit of urine from the bladder to urethra
gets atrophied and weak Involuntary leakage of urine occurs in case the bladder is full
or due to increase of pressure on bladder on sneezing or even on laughing a condition
known as urinary incontinence Incontinence is a common complaint of elder females
(f) Heart and Circulatory System
The blood vessels get rigid and quite often the vessel walls become rough with the
deposition of solid matters consisting mostly of cholesterol The heart muscles get weaker
and power to send blood throughout the body through the circulatory system gets less and
less powerful The most dangerous effect on heart is coronary heart disease especially
coronary thrombosis
(g) Muscular system
The muscles in the body get gradually atrophied with ageing and especially those
small muscles which are necessary for quick reflex action The elderly person can quite
be capable of working like a normal person and can undertake activities which require
big muscles of legs and arms But when it comes to quick movement which needs small
muscles for quick reflex movements these functions are impaired causing accidents
like slipping on wet floor of the bathroom
(h) Brain
With ageing the size of the brain gets smaller and the weight also becomes less This
however does not interfere with the function of the brain However in general the brain
cells and its fibers which carry impulses from brain to the system and upwards get
9
Review of literature
degenerated The most glaring manifestation of ageing affecting the brain is
forgetfulness and in simple terms it is inability of brain to recall the past experience
However this is common in all elderly persons
(i ) Bones
The bones become porous and fragile as age advances especially in elderly females This
condition is known as osteoporosis and leads to sustaining of fractures even after a minor
fall16
Figure 2 pathophysiology of health issues in geriatrics17
The common disease that the geriatric population suffers from are type 2 diabetes
coronary heart disease hypertension stroke chronic obstructive pulmonary disease
10
Review of literature
Alzheimerrsquos disease osteoarthritis osteoporosis prostatic hypertrophy cataracts macular
degeneration cancer etc and at the same time they are vulnerable to infections involving
respiratory (including TB) urinary and digestive tract17
In India the elderly people suffer from dual medical problems ie communicable and
nonndash communicable diseases There is also impairment of special sensory functions like
vision and hearing A decline in immunity and age-related physiological changes leads to
an increased burden of communicable diseases in the elderly A report by Indian Council
of Medical Research (ICMR) on the chronic morbidity profile in the elderly states that
hearing impairment is the most common morbidity followed by visual impairment
However different studies show varied results in the morbidity pattern18
Major chronic conditions affecting older people worldwide 19
Cardiovascular diseases (such as coronary heart disease) Diabetes Mellitus
Hypertension Stroke Cancer
Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease
Musculoskeletal conditions (such as arthritis and osteoporosis)
Mental health conditions (mostly dementia and depression)
Blindness and visual impairment
11
Review of literature
Health seeking behaviour
1 Definition
There is no common definition agreed upon by sociologists in any sociology literature
Different definitions may be used in different studies despite referring to the same activity
Sociology and literature assume that health seeking behaviour is influenced by the various
factors which include individual self or the individual diseases present and also the
availability and accessibility of health services Being dependent on these determinants and
their interactions it can be said that health care seeking behaviour is a very complex
outcome of various factors which operate at individual family and community level20
Health Seeking Behavior (HSB) refers to decision or an action taken by an individual to
maintain attain or regain good health and to prevent illness The decisions which are
made encompasses all available health care options like visiting a public or private and
modern or traditional health facility self-medication and use of home remedies or not to
utilize the available health services etc
Determining the health care seeking behavior is very important to provide a need
based health care services to the population Visiting official channels in a formally
recognized health care system has been considered as the desired Health seeking behaviour
Health seeking behavior is influenced by multiple factors including availability quality and
price of services and also social groups health views residences and personal features of the
users Peoplersquos choice of health care differs in socio demographic socio-economic and
cultural compositions and this has an effect on their health seeking behavior Urban dwellers
are generally believed to be open to new ideas and willing to try certain things on a trial and
error basis21
12
Review of literature
Health seeking behaviours two approaches
(a) Health seeking behaviours utilization of the system
This approach focuses on the actions which are taken to rectify perceived ill health and
the type of health care facility which is utilized by the people There is data which
suggests that the people visit more traditional healers and unofficial medical channels
this should be prevented and the emphasis s h o u l d b e on encouraging people to opt
first for the official channels
(b) Health seeking behaviours the process of illness response
This approach considers the factors which enable or prevent people from making
healthy choices either i n their lifestyle behaviours or use of medical care and
treatment22
Figure 3 Predicting health behaviour with social cognition models 22
13
Review of literature
2 Health belief Model of health seeking behaviour
Since lsquoHealth seekingrsquo is a conditioned behaviour any attempt which is made to
encourage people to seek health care definitely requires an understanding of their
motivation for such behaviour Only through a deeper understanding of the intricate
factors shaping behavioural practices can health promotion programmes and or
interventions successfully be introduced into the realities of the peoplersquos lives to bring
about changes in health behaviour
Behaviour change theories and models such as the Health Belief Model (HBM)
Theory of Reasoned Action (TRA) Theory of Planned Behaviour (TPB) and the
Trans theoretical model have been widely applied in public health in an attempt to
explain or predict health seeking behaviours Their use enables identification and
understanding of peoplersquos health-seeking behaviour beyond their knowledge attitudes
and practices
HBM is a health specific behavioural cognitive model This model is based on the
idea that people are more likely to change their behaviour and adhere to treatments
if they have the following perceptions (i) have a perception that they are at risk of
contracting the disease (perceived susceptibility) (ii) perception that the disease
might have an unfavorable outcome (perceived severity) (iii) perceive that the
proposed health behaviour to be both effective and practical (perceived benefits)
(iv) perceive the barriers to adopting the behaviour to be minimal (perceived
barriers)(v) perceive themselves to have the ability of applying and practicing the
specific behaviour proposed (perceived self-efficacy) and (vi) they have the cues
for motivating their actions such as internal cues (pain symptoms past experiences)
or external cues (advice from friends relatives and mass media campaigns) (cues to
14
Review of literature
action) The specificity of the HBM to health has made it suitable for use in
understanding and explaining the behaviour as well as health outcomes and this may also
explain its wider use in public health2 3
Figure 4 Health belief model components and linkages 23
3 Factors influencing health seeking behaviour
The factors affecting the health seeking behaviours are seen in various contexts which
include physical socio-economic cultural and political factors Therefore the utilization of
a health care system whether public or private formal or non- formal may depend on socio-
demographic factors social structures level of education cultural beliefs and practices and
some other factors like gender discrimination status of women economic and political
systems environmental conditions and the disease pattern and health care system itself also
have an impact on the health seeking behaviour24
15
Review of literature
REVIEW OF RELATED STUDIES
A study done by Sanjay Polisetty and Madhavi Seepana (2017) on the morbidity profile
of elderly individuals in urban Visakhapatnam revealed that of the 270 study participants
about 996 suffered from either some form of acute or chronic morbidity More than 70
of individuals suffered from eye problems of which most common problem was cataract
seen in 60 About 304 had difficulties in chewing and 256 had difficulty in hearing
Hypertension was present in 49 of individuals and 742 of Diabetics were also found to
be hypertensive25
A study done by Swapnil Jain et al (2016) on Morbidity pattern among geriatric
population in urban field practice area of a district in Maharashtra revealed 653 suffered
from hearing impairment 62 were anemic 462 had hypertension 423 had joint
pain 41 had dental problems 38 7 had cataract and 318 had chronic bronchitis It
was seen that 81 of the subjects had multiple morbidities 26
A study done by Rajat Das Gupta et al (2016) in an urban area of Bangladesh on Morbidity
pattern and health-seeking behavior among the senior citizens revealed that of the 384 study
participants 968 were suffering from at least one medical problem The commonest was
musculoskeletal problems in 8411 followed by eye problems in 8125 It was found that
all the respondents sought treatment for their health problems 33 respondents went to
Government hospitals to seek medical help 6927 respondents took prescribed
medications and 567 were satisfied with their treatment 27
16
Review of literature
A study done by Md Alam Naushad et al (2016) on Morbidity pattern and health
seeking behavior in elderly population of Raipur City Chhattisgarh revealed that the
prevalence of morbidity among elderly was 9531 Out of total morbid population some
chronic illness was present in 7049 Gastro intestinal system was involved in 8262
followed by eye in 7983 and Cardiovascular system in 5245 It was found that 3552
of the subjects sought treatment from private registered practitioners 28
A study done by Sribas Goswami and Manjari Sahai (2016) in Raipur city on Morbidity
Pattern in elderly Population revealed that out of total study population of 640 elderly
subjects 610 (9531) suffered from some morbidity Prevalence among females was
9892 whereas among males it was 9026 Out of various agencies 3552 subjects
were utilizing private facility followed by 2785 who were utilizing Government agency
2631 visited quacks and 1030 were taking treatment from other source 29
A study done by Harsh Bardhan et al (2016) on the Morbidity profile of elderly population
in Ghaziabad district revealed that in geriatric population 5008 suffered from
musculoskeletal problems 5877 had dental problems and impairment of vision was seen
in 5561 The overall prevalence of diabetes and heart disease were 10 and 122
respectively 236 subjects reported the problem of loneliness and depression
forgetfulness was also reported by 3296 As far as treatment seeking behavior is
concerned approach of elderly is quite different for different morbidities The main source
of treatment for morbidities such as hypertension respiratory urinary GIT-related and
musculoskeletal problems was quacks 30
17
Review of literature
A study done by Mohammad Maharoof et al (2016) on the health problems among
the aged in Urban Aligarh UP revealed that of the 225 study subjects 782 had cataract
followed by depression in 356 refractive error in 276 loco-motor problem in 213
and hearing loss in 138 The prevalence of hearing loss was significantly related to gender
as it was higher among females with 181 compared to males in whom it was 6931
A study done by Gowri Shankar and Bhayalaxmi Sidenur (2016) on morbidity of
elderly residing in an urban area of Bagalkot revealed that the most common morbidity was
Cataract seen in 2875 followed by musculoskeletal problems in 2813 and 2313
were known hypertensive Both diabetes mellitus and hypertension was observed in 10 of
the study subjects32
A study done by Leena Rahul Salunkhe (2015) on socio-demographic profile of old
age people living in urban amp urban slum areas in Maharashtra Karad revealed that 504
and 42 elderly suffered from arthritis in an urban area and a slum respectively Number of
diabetics were higher in urban (14) than urban slum (35) 301 of subjects from urban
area suffered from hypertension compared to 161 from urban slums Upper Respiratory
Infections was more in slum dwellers (196) than people residing in urban area (7) Acid
peptic diseases were found in 168 study subjects in urban area and 154 in slum area 33
In a study done by Warbhe Priyanka A and Warbhe Rupesh (2015) on morbidity
profile health seeking behaviour and home environment survey of the elderly in an urban
slum community it was found that 941 had 1-3 morbidities 41 had 4-6 morbidities
373 gave a history of fall and 314 had history of fracture 136 subjects had been
18
Review of literature
operated for cataract 168 had undergone a procedure for fracture and10 had undergone
a dental procedure 542 went to Urban health center (UHC) and Government hospitals for
treatment and 786 received both allopathic and Ayurvedic treatment34
A study done by Man Mohan Gupta et al (2015) on Assessment of Clinico-
socioeconomic status and health-care support among the elderly people aged older than 60
years in urban population of Bhopal revealed that 353 subjects received treatment for
their morbidities from the Government hospitals whereas 267 from private
clinichospital About 653 study subjects presented with complaints and morbidity The
common morbidities which were found in the subjects were fatigue (487) backache
(353) Obesity (393) and hypertension (247)35
In a study done by Shilpa Shaukaiah et al (2015) on prevalence of morbidity pattern
among geriatric age group in an urban slum of Mumbai it was found that body ache was the
most commonly reported symptom by 290 followed by visual problems in 2318 joint
pain in 2181 indigestion in 2045 and backache in 2045 subjects36
A study done by Shubha Davalagi B et al (2015) on morbidity psycho-social profile and
health seeking behavior of the elderly population in urban slums of Davangere City revealed
that the most common morbidity which was present in the study subjects was
musculoskeletal problems in 46 psychosocial problems were present in 31 and
respiratory problems in 23 Majority of the elderly (56) utilized government
institutions for treatment of chronic disease and 47 for treatment of acute disease The
elderly population had financial constraints and lack of accessibility in seeking health care37
19
Review of literature
A study done by Vandana Nikumb et al ( 2015) on morbidity Profile among Geriatric
Population in an Urban Area of Navi Mumbai revealed that 9312 elderly were morbid and
with increasing age the number of morbidities was found to be increasing In this study it
was found that the most common morbidity was psychosocial problems which include
stress which was present in 594 subjects followed by musculoskeletal problems in
556 and eye problems like diminished vision mostly due to cataract in 463
Hypertension dental problems respiratory problems ENT problems (hearing impairment)
and endocrine disorders like diabetes accounted for 281 219 119 106 and10
respectively38
A study done by Vishnoi BR et al (2015) on Morbidity Profile of Elderly in Urban
Slum of Udaipur Rajasthan revealed that 61 of the study subjects had impaired vision
followed by 25 who had hypertension 1533 suffered from insomnia 1467 had
anemia and 14 suffered from gastrointestinal problems The condition of females was
worse compared to males39
In a study done by L Subedhi and RB Sah (2015) on the health status of geriatric age
group in Chitwan district of Nepal it was found that of the 300 study subjects 44 had
Ophthalmic problems 43 had GIT problems 33 had CVS problems 23 had ENT
problems 1567 had metabolic disorders and 533 had mental disorders The study
highlighted a high prevalence of morbidity and health related problems in the geriatric age
group40
20
Review of literature
A study done by Sofia Noor et al (2015) on health status of geriatric population in slums
of Rourkela revealed that the morbidities among the elderly that were found to be significant
were hypertension decreased visual acuity urinary problems and insomnia Apart from
systemic morbidities 91 of the elderly also complained of fragility which includes
complex physiological deterioration and unexplained weight loss41
In a study conducted by VM Sarode (2014) on Chronic Diseases Related to Ageing and
Disease Prevention in Slums in Mumbai it was found that there were highly significant
disorders among aged women related to Skin lesion and super infection Untreated bacterial
pharyngitis acute rheumatic fever while disorders among aged men were related to
hypertension Illicit drug use diabetes and asthma It was found that 49 of elderly males
and 45 of elderly females had not sought any treatment for their illness Of the people who
had sought treatment 93 elderly males and 92 of elderly females had taken treatment
from Government hospital42
A study conducted by Sanjeev Kumar Barman et al (2014) on morbidity profile of
geriatric population in an urban slum of Kishnganj Bihar revealed that the prevalence of
anemia cataract and hypertension were quite high 6375 6125 and 5063
respectively Loss of income amp occupation along with a feeling of neglect from the family
members were the common problems among the elderly It was also found that morbidities
like arthritis loss of teeth amp dental caries along with depression had a significant association
with sex age amp educational status of the study subjects43
21
Review of literature
A study done by Khadervali Nagoor et al (2014) on the health status of elderly
population in an urban area of Kadapa revealed that out of the 200 elderly persons studied
Visual problem due to cataract and refractive errors were present in 72 of the study
subjects followed by pain in joints in 595 gastrointestinal problems in 46 and dental
problems in 44 Other morbidities were hypertension in 42 genitourinary problems in
25 dermatological problems in 235 and psychological problems in 1644
A study done by Kakkar R et al (2013) on morbidity profile among geriatric population
in District Dehradun revealed that the working geriatric group was healthy as compared to
those who were retired Hypertension was the commonest morbidity among all age groups
In the age group of 60-70 years the following morbidities were seen hypertension (306)
followed by diabetes (153) arthritis (14) CVS morbidities (14) cataract (96) and
BPH (83) Among 71-80 years age group Hypertension (287) followed by arthritis
(167) cataract (157) Diabetes (111) BPH (111) and CVS morbidities (93)45
In a study done by Bhawalkar JS et al (2013) on morbidity profile among geriatric
population in an urban area of Pune it was found that Musculoskeletal disorder was the
most common (4331) followed by eye problems (3722) and hypertension (137)It
was seen that 43 elderly population had some health problem but only 8 visited the
health facilities Among them 6 visited private practitioners and only 18 went to
municipal hospitals It was found that only 2322 elderly were taking any medications and
the most commonly used drug was anti-inflammatory drugs 2323 followed by
antihypertensive drugs 136746
22
Review of literature
A study conducted by Deepak Sharma et al (2013) on morbidity pattern and health-
seeking behavior of aged population residing in Shimla revealed that the following
morbidities were present in the study subjects hypertension was the commonest (56)
followed by Musculoskeletal problems (535) Dental problems (27) cataract (23)
anemia (15) and acid peptic disease (175) 658 of the subjects were seeking
treatment for their health problems Majority of the older people preferred allopathic
medicine (812) followed by Ayurvedic medicines (113) and homeopathic medicine
(73) for their health problems Most of the older persons preferred going to a
CHCGovernment hospital for treatment for their illness There was considerable use of
over-the-counter drug by125 of the people 47
A study done by JP Singh et al (2013) on Geriatric morbidity profile in an urban slum of
Nagpur central India revealed that the most common morbidity identified in the study
population was anemia (9650) followed by hypertension (345) arthritis (3225)
cataract (21) and diabetes (1775) More than 2 morbidities were present in 325 of
the study subjects followed by four morbidities in 3125 and two morbidities in 23548
A study conducted by RP Thakur et al (2013) on the health problems of the elderly in
central India revealed that among the elderly residing in the urban areas 384 of the urban
elderly had both dental problems and arthritis followed by anemia in 348 hypertension in
266 cataract in 252 and diabetes mellitus in 157 The prevalence of self-reported
depression was 672 among the urban female elderly when compared to 397 among the
urban females49
23
Review of literature
A study done by Mrinal Ranjan Srivastav et al (2013) on Morbidity Status and its
Social determinants among elderly population of Lucknow revealed that the most common
morbidity among the urban population was eye problems which affected 516 males and
67 females followed by CVS problems in 363 males and 395 females and GIT
problems in 315males and 382 females50
A study done by Shraddha K et al (2012) on morbidity pattern among elderly in urban
population of Mysore revealed that out of the 526 study subjects 486 suffered from the
disease of the eye and adnexa followed by 384 who suffered from endocrine and
metabolic disorders 331 suffered from the disease of the circulatory system 323 had
disease of the oral cavity and salivary glands and 302 had disease of the musculoskeletal
system 51
A study done by Vimala Thomas et al (2012) on morbidity profile and health seeking
behaviour of the elderly in urban slums of Hyderabad revealed that hypertension was the
most common morbidity in 469 followed by Arthritis in 302 Diabetes in 265
respiratory problems in 243 and Cataract in 21 For out-patient treatment 472 visited
private sectors 303 Government facility 25 RMP and 06 AYUSH clinics For in-
patient treatment 198 visited private institutions 16 visited Government institutions
while 642 did not visit either52
24
Review of literature
A study done by Soe Moe et al (2012) on health seeking behaviour of elderly in
Myanmar revealed that 35 of the male elderly perceived that they were having good
health status whereas 229 of them perceived having a poor health status 343 of female
elderly perceived that they were having good health status while 24 of them perceived
having a poor health About 49 of the elderly went to rural health center for treatment
followed by 33 who went to private practitioners 15 visited hospitals and 3 went to
more than one place for treatment53
A study done by Dharamvir Ranjan Bharati et al (2011) in Puducherry revealed that in
the urban areas about 707 of the study subjects had anemia followed by 537 who had
visual impairment and hypertension and 532 suffered from diabetes mellitus It was seen
that On univariate analysis the risk of diabetes mellitus was significantly higher among
elderly from urban areas than that among elderly from rural areas and significantly lower
risk in elderly from below poverty line than in those belonging to normal (not below poverty
line)54
A study done by Rajashree Bhat et al (2011) on the morbidity pattern among the elderly
population in Ahmedabad revealed that most common morbidity of elderly was the
problems of loco-motor system (486) followed by vision (427) and hypertension
(344) In this study only 37 of elderly had psychosocial problems55
A study done by Krishnamachari Srinivasan et al (2010) in an urban area of Bangalore
revealed that 494 subjects had hypertension 323 had diabetes 281 had arthritis
279 suffered from Genitourinary and cardiovascular disease It was observed that about
25
Review of literature
49 of the respondents made less than three physician visits and 13 were hospitalized for
health related problems during the past one year 56
A study done by Kajal Srivastava et al (2010) on the morbidity pattern of the elderly in
urban Agra revealed that 9529 of the elderly were morbid in the slum areas The most
common morbidity which was seen among the elderly people residing in urban slums was
anemia which was seen in 3843 followed by cataract in 298 arthritis in 2431 and
hearing impairments in 2157The system wise distribution of the morbidity pattern
showed the most common systemic involvement was visual disorders 5216 followed by
musculoskeletal system 4784 and the gastrointestinal system 4314 The number of
morbidities was found to be increasing with age and this association with age was
statistically significant57
A study done by Abdullah Ladha et al (2009) on the health seeking behaviour of elderly
population in a poor-urban community of Karachi Pakistan revealed that 164 of the
elderly people were Diabetic and 301 had Hypertension The Common symptoms that
prompted elderly of to seek health care were fever (612) generalized body aches (434)
and cough (404) About 614 responders reported factors which deterred them from
seeking health care out of which 62 reported financial constraint as the commonest factor
Deterrence from seeking health care was associated with illiteracy and living alone58
26
Methodology METHODOLOGY
The study was conducted in the urban field practice area of JJM Medical college
Davangere The city of Davangere is situated in the central part of Karnataka state
265 km north of the state capital Bengaluru along the national highway number 4
Figure 5 Maps showing the location of Davangere district and the area where the
UHTC is located
27
Methodology
Figure 6 Map showing the Urban field practice area of JJM medical college
28
Methodology
Table 3 List of areas covered under the UHTC of JJM Medical
College Davangere
Areas covered Total population Bethur road 1374 Hedge nagar 1213 Mehboob nagar 3042 Mustafa nagar A 2093 B D layout A 1084 Mustafa nagar B 1127 Mahavir nagar 930 Muddabovi colony 1094 Maganhalli 1221 Tippu nagar 968 B D layout B 1717 Batti layout 1080
STUDY AREA The study was conducted in the urban field practice area of JJM
Medical College Davangere which consists of 12 areas with a total population of
16943
STUDY DESIGN Cross sectional study
STUDY POPULATION Persons aged 60 years and above
Total Population Covered 16943
29
Methodology
INCLUSION CRITERIA subjects aged 60 years and above living in the study area
for more than one year duration
EXCLUSION CRITERIA Subjects who we r e no t w i l l i ng t o pa r t i c ipa t e i n
t he s t udy
STUDY PERIOD 1 year from 1st December 2015 to 30th November 2016
SAMPLE SIZE As quoted by Manmohan Gupta et al 35 in the studies done in various
parts of India the prevalence of morbidity in the geriatric population ranges from 31-80
Considering the prevalence of morbidity to be about 50 in the geriatric population at 95
confidence level and allowable error of 10 and a non -response rate of 10 sample size
was calculated to be 440 using the formula
n=4pq L2
n= sample size
4= factor to achieve 95 level of confidence
p= prevalence of morbidities ie 50
q= 100- p ie 100-50 = 50
L= permissible error in the estimate of ldquoprdquo (10 of p)
n = 4 x 50 x 50 = 400
5 x 5
After calculating a non-response rate of 10 a sample size of 440 was calculated
30
Methodology
A community based cross sectional study was conducted in the urban field practice
area of JJM Medical College Davangere The Urban field practice area has a total
population of 16943 and there are 12 areas in urban field practice area of JJM Medical
College Davangere
The Study was conducted by probability proportionate sampling The sample size for each
area was derived from the formula
1198991 =119875119900119901119906119897119886119905119894119900119899 119894119899 119890119886119888ℎ 119886119903119890119886
119879119900119905119886119897 119875119900119901119906119897119886119905119894119900119899119883 119878119886119898119901119897119890 119878119894119911119890
Example 1st area has a population of 1374 so
1198991 =1374
16943119883 440 = 36
Therefore 36 elderly subjects were selected by house to house visit from 1st area Same
procedure was applied for other areas until the desired sample size of 440 was reached
MATERIALS USED FOR DATA COLLECTION
The following tools were used for data collection
Semi-structured predesigned and pre-tested questionnaire
Portable bathroom weighing machine
Stretch- resistant measuring tape
Mercury Sphygmomanometer
Others - stethoscope torch tuning fork knee hammer
ICD-10 for system wise classification of disease59
31
Methodology METHOD OF COLLECTION OF DATA After establishing rapport with the family
and explaining the data collection procedure in the local language an informed verbal
consent was obtained from each individual and data was collected using a
Predesigned semi structured questionnaire by Interview method The questionnaire
comprised of the following information socio-demographic data of the study subjects
information regarding the morbidity pattern and health seeking behaviour If there were
more than one elderly subjects in the same household then all were included
The study subjects were asked about any ho illness (communicable or non-
communicable) which they were suffering from Upon a positive response the subjects were
further asked to specify the type(s) and duration of morbidities that they were suffering
from eg heart disease diabetes gastrointestinal diseases respiratory disease etc Some
were unable to understand or answer questions due to illness In such cases help was sought
from the family members Based on the self-reported symptoms information from
hospital records and clinical examination the prevalence of different morbidities among the
study subjects was assessed The Information about the health seeking behaviour was
sought by asking the study subjects about their visits to a health facility in case of an illness
and also the type of health facility visited ( Government private or quacks )
DATA ENTRY AND ANALYSIS Data was entered and analyzed using MS Excel and
Open Epi Info version 2260 Both descriptive and inferential statistics were used Subjectrsquos
baseline characteristics were presented as frequencies and percentages Categorical
variables between the groups were compared using Chi square test and Fisherrsquos exact
test Fisherrsquos exact test was used when more than 20 cells had expected value lt 5 and any
one of the cells had expected value lt 1 All statistical analysis was carried out at 5 level
of significance and p value lt005 was considered as significant
32
Methodology ETHICAL CLEARANCE
Ethical clearance was obtained before conducting the study from the Ethical Committee of
JJM Medical college Davangere [ANNEXURE III] During the study verbal
informed consent was taken from the study subjects Assurance was given that the
confidentiality concerning their information will be maintained
Clinical Examination included
(a) General physical examination
(b) Anthropometric measurements like height and weight
(c) Systemic examination
(d) Measurement of Blood pressure
(e) Eye examination by torch and Snellenrsquos (E chart)61
(f) Hearing assessment by Rinnersquos test Webberlsquos and Absolute bone conduction
test using tuning fork 62
Parameters used in our study
Height Height was measured with a standard non-stretchable measuring tape to the
nearest 01 cm in standing position (without footwear standing upright with the
back against the wall heels together and eyes directed forward)
33
Methodology Weight Weight was measured with minimal clothing and respecting the modesty of the
individual without footwear using a calibrated standard bathroom weighing scale to the
nearest 05 kg
Body Mass Index (BMI) Using weight (in Kg) and height (in meter2) BMI was calculated by applying the formula
Body Mass Index= Weight (kg) Height (m2)
The BMI cut off values for Asians as recommended by the WHO was used in our study
Table 4 WHO Categorization of Body Mass index (BMI) for Asians 63
Measurement of Blood pressure Procedure Blood pressure was measured in the left arm in a sitting posture with the subject in a
relaxed state Standardized mercury sphygmomanometer with adult size cuff was used
The first appearance of (phase 1 of Korotkoff sounds) sound was used to define
Systolic Blood Pressure (SBP) The disappearance of sound (phase 5) was used to
define Diastolic Blood Pressure (DBP) Two readings were taken five minutes apart and
the average of the two readings was taken as the final blood pressure reading A person
was considered to be a hypertensive if he she was already diagnosed case of
hypertension and or on treatment or with a current SBP of ge 140 mm Hg or DBP ge 90 mm
Hg (JNC VII criteria)64
BODY MASS INDEX INFERENCE
lt 185 underweight
185 to 229 kg m2 Normal
23 to 249 kg m2 Overweight
ge 25 kg m2 Obese
34
Methodology
Table 5 JNC VII Classification of Blood pressure 65
BP Classification Systolic Blood Pressure Diastolic Blood Pressure
Normal lt120 lt 80
Pre Hypertension 120 ndash 139 or 80 ndash 89 Stage 1 Hypertension 140 ndash 159 or 90 ndash 99 Stage 2 Hypertension ge 160 or ge 100
Anaemia was detected by pallor of conjunctiva tongue and nails and was confirmed by
doing haemoglobin estimation using sahlirsquos hemogobinometer66
The cut off for the diagnosis of anaemia was done based on WHO classification67
Diabetes - self reported cases of diabetes were considered as diabetics for the study
STUDY VARIABLES
1 AGE - subjects aged 60 years and above were taken up for the study Age was
recorded to the nearest complete years as stated by the respondent
2 GENDER Both males and females were taken up for the study
3 EDUCATIONAL STATUS 68
i Illiterate -A person who could not read or write
ii Primary School - studied up to 4th standard
iii Higher primary- studied between 5th and 7th standard
iv Secondary school -studied between 8th and 10th standard v Intermediate- studied between 11th or 12 th standard or diploma
vi Graduate - obtained graduate degree
vii Post Graduate- obtained post graduate degree
35
Methodology
4 OCCUPATION STATUS69
i Unskilled worker
Labourer domestic servants casual worker peon sweeper porter washer-man others
(vegetable vendor)
ii Semi-skilled worker
Factory worker agriculture laborers shoemaker potters others (security guard shop
helper canteen helper
iii Skilled
Artisan clerk foreman supervisor carpenter tailor mechanic electrician railway guard
painter modeler smiths baker driver shop assistant petty trader constable soldier
linesman pointsman potter barber others (tinkering printer receptionist salesman
welder cook mason postman plumber agarbatti worker)
iv semi-professional
Teacher pharmacist social worker owner of a small business farmer others (computer
programmer Govt employee nurse)
V Professional
Doctor engineer principal lawyer Military officer senior executive business
proprietor writer scientist large employer director university professor police
officer others (horse rider)
(vi) Unemployed Presently not working retired homemakers
36
Methodology 5 SOCIO ECONOMIC STATUS
Table 6 Socio-economic status (SES)- As per modified BG Prasad Classification70
5 TYPE OF FAMILY 71
Joint Family ndash It is type of family grouping in which a number of married couples and
their children live together in the same household All the men are related by blood
and women of household are their wives unmarried girls and widows of family kinsmen
Nuclear Family - It consist of married couple and their children while they are still
regarded as dependents
Three generation family - It is a family where representatives of three generation are
living together Young married couples continue to stay with their parents and have
their own children as well
Socio-economic
status
Prasadrsquos classification
1961(Per capita income in
Rupees per month)
Modified BG Prasad classification-
updated for May 2016 ((per
capita income in Rupees per
month)
I 100 and above 6261 and above
II 50-99 3099-6260
III 30-49 1835-3098
IV 15-29 949-1834
V Below 15 lt948
37
SAMPLE SIZE ESTIMATION
SAMPLE SIZE As quoted by Manmohan Gupta et al 35 in the studies done in various
parts of India the prevalence of morbidity in the geriatric population ranges from 31-80
Considering the prevalence of morbidity to be about 50 in the geriatric population at 95
confidence level and allowable error of 10 and a non -response rate of 10 sample size
was calculated to be 440 using the formula
n=4pq L2
n= sample size
4= factor to achieve 95 level of confidence
p= prevalence of morbidities ie 50
q= 100- p ie 100-50 = 50
L= permissible error in the estimate of ldquoprdquo (10 of p)
n = 4 x 50 x 50 = 400
5 x 5
After calculating a non-response rate of 10 a sample size of 440 was calculated
A community based cross sectional study was conducted in the urban field practice area of
JJM Medical College Davangere The Urban field practice area has a total population of
16943 and there are 12 areas in urban field practice area of JJM Medical College
Davangere
The Study was conducted by probability proportionate sampling The sample size for each area
was derived from the formula
1198991 =119875119900119901119906119897119886119905119894119900119899 119894119899 119890119886119888ℎ 119886119903119890119886
119879119900119905119886119897 119875119900119901119906119897119886119905119894119900119899119883 119878119886119898119901119897119890 119878119894119911119890
Example 1st area has a population of 1374 so
1198991 =1374
16943119883 440 = 36
Therefore 36 elderly subjects were selected by house to house visit from 1st area Same
procedure was applied for other areas until the desired sample size of 440 was reached
Results
RESULTS
The results are presented under the following headings
I Socio-demographic characteristics of study subjects
II Prevalence of morbidities among the study subjects
III Details of health seeking behavior of the study subjects
38
Results
ISocio-demographic characteristics of the study subjects
Table 7 Age and sex wise distribution of the study subjects
Figure 7 Age and sex wise distribution of the study subjects
In the present study Out of 440 study subjects majority 162(368) were in the age group
of 60-64 Years followed by 109 (247) in the age group of 65-69 Years 99 (225) were
in the age group of 70-74 Years and 35 (8) were more than or equal to 80 years of age
Majority of the subjects were males 260 (59) and 180 (41) were females The mean age
of the study population was 6745 plusmn 655 Years
354 254 262
88 42
389
239 172
67 133
0102030405060708090
100
60-64 65-69 70-74 75-79 ge80
Perc
enta
ge
Age in years
Males
Females
Age group (in years)
Males Females Total
Percentage () Frequency
(n=260) Percentage ()
Frequency (n=180)
Percentage ()
60-64 92 354 70 389 162 368
65-69 66 254 43 239 109 247
70-74 68 262 31 172 99 225
75-79 23 88 12 67 35 80
ge80 11 42 24 133 35 80
Total 260 100 180 100 440 100
39
Results
Table 8 Distribution of the study subjects based on religion
Religion Frequency (n=440) Percentage ()
Hindu 188 427
Muslim 252 573
Total 440 100
Figure 8 Distribution of the study subjects based on religion
In the present study it was found that the majority of the study subject belonged to Muslim
religion 252 (573) followed by Hindus 188 (427)
0102030405060708090
100
Hindu Muslim
427
573
Perc
enta
ge
Religion of the study subjects
40
Results
Table 9 Distribution of the study subjects based on Educational status
Education Frequency (n=440) Percentage ()
Illiterate 231 525
Primary school 121 275
Higher primary 38 86
Secondary School 30 68
Intermediate 6 14
Graduate 14 32
Total 440 100
Figure 9 Distribution of the study subjects based on Educational status
In the present study it was found that the Majority of the study subjects were illiterate
231(525) 121(275) had completed education up to primary school 30(68) had
completed education up to secondary school and only 14(32) were graduates
525
275
86 68
14 32
0102030405060708090
100
Perc
enta
ge
Educational status of study subjects
41
Results Table 10 Distribution of the study subjects based on occupation
Occupation Frequency (n=440) Percentage ()
Semi-professional 2 05
Skilled worker 45 102
Semi-skilled worker 68 155
Unskilled worker 100 227
Unemployed 225 511
Total 440 100
Figure 10 Distribution of study subjects based on their occupation
In our study it was found that the majority of the study subjects 225 (511) were
unemployed followed by 100 (227) who were unskilled workers 68 (155) were semi-
skilled workers and 45 (102) were skilled workers
0102030405060708090
100
05 102 155 227
511
Perc
enta
ge
Occupation of the study subjects
42
Results Table 11 Distribution of the study subjects based on socio-economic status (Modified
BG Prasad classification 2016)
Figure 11 Distribution of the study subjects based on their socio-economic status
In our study majority of the subjects 215 (49) belonged to Class IV Socioeconomic status
followed by 115 (26) who belonged to class III and 56 (13) who belonged to class II
SES (according to Modified BG Prasad Classification 2016)
Class II 13
Class III 26
Class IV 49
Class V 12
Socio-economic status Frequency (n=440) Percentage ()
Class I 0 0
Class II 56 13
Class III 115 26
Class IV 215 49
Class V 54 12
Total 440 100
43
Results
Table 12 Distribution of the study subjects based on their marital status
Marital status Frequency (n=440) Percentage ()
Unmarried 2 05
Married 323 734
Widowwidower 115 261
Total 440 100
Figure 12 Distribution of the study subjects based on their marital status
In our study it was found that majority of the study subjects 323(734) were married
followed by 115(261) who were widowed and only 2 (05) were unmarried
0102030405060708090
100
Unmarried married Widowwidower
05
734
261 Perc
enta
ge
44
Results
Table 13 Distribution of the study subjects based on the type of family
Type of family Frequency (n=440) Percentage ()
Nuclear family 163 37
Joint family 93 21
Three generation family 184 42
Total 440 100
Figure 13 Distribution of the study subjects based on the type of family
In the present study it was found that majority of the study subjects 184 (42) lived in a
three generation family followed by 163 (37) who lived in a nuclear family and 93(21)
who lived in a Joint family
Nuclear family 37
Joint family 21
Three generation
family 42
45
Results
II Prevalence of morbidities among the study subjects
Figure 14 Distribution of the study subjects based on the BMI
In the present study it was found that out of 440 study subjects 198 (45) had a normal
BMI followed by 132 (30) who were overweight 66 (15) were obese and only 44
(10) were underweight
under weight 10
Normal 45
Overweight 30
Obese 15
46
Results
Table 14 Distribution of morbidity pattern of the study subjects based on ICD 10
classification of diseases
System involved ICD 10
Males (n=260)
Females (n=180)
Total (n=440)
No No No
Diseases of musculoskeletal system (M00 ndash M99)
184 707 130 722 314 714
Diseases of the eye and adnexa (H00 ndash H59)
139 534 80 444 219 497
Diseases of oral cavityamp salivary glands (K00 ndash K14)
90 346 64 355 154 35
Endocrine nutritional amp metabolic diseases (E00 ndash
E90)
70 269 75 417 145 329
Diseases of circulatory system (I00 ndash I99)
64 246 73 405 137 311
Diseases of respiratory system(J00 ndash J99)
64 246 37 206 101 23
Diseases of digestive system (K00 ndash K93)
57 219 30 166 87 198
Diseases of skin amp subcutaneous tissue (L00 ndash
L99)
38 146 20 111 58 132
Diseases of the ear and mastoid process (H60 ndashH95)
39 15 18 10 57 13
Diseases of genitourinary system (N00 ndash N99)
22 85 7 39 29 66
Diseases of nervous system (G00 ndash G99)
6 23 5 28 11 25
Note Total number could not be given as many subjects had multiple disorders
47
Results
Figure 15 Distribution of morbidity pattern of the study subjects based on ICD 10
classification of diseases
In the present study it was found that the majority of the subjects 314 (714) suffered
from the disorders of the musculoskeletal system followed by 219 (497) who suffered
from the disease of the eye and adnexa154 (35) suffered from the disease of the oral
cavity 145 (329) suffered from endocrine nutritional and metabolic disorders137
(311) suffered from the disease of the circulatory system 101 (229) suffered from the
disease of the respiratory system 87(198) suffered from the disease of the digestive
system 58 (132) suffered from disease of the skin 57 (13) suffered from the disease of
the ear 29 (66) suffered from the disease of the genitourinary system and only 11( 25 )
suffered from the disease of the nervous system
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
714
497
35 329 311 229
198 132 13 66
25
perc
enta
ge
48
Results
Table 15 Distribution of the study subjects based on morbidity of the musculoskeletal
system
Musculoskeletal
Disease
Males
(n=260)
Females
(n=180)
Total
(n= 440)
Statistical
Value
Knee joint pain
52 (20)
30 (167)
82 (186)
X2 = 0779
df = 1
p=03773
Back ache
30 (115)
35 (194)
65 (148) X2 = 528
df = 1
p = 0021
Joint pain (other than
knee joint pain)
52(20)
35(194)
87(198)
X2 =00206
df=1
p =0885
Non-specific aches
and pain
50(192)
30(167)
80(182)
X2=0470
df=1
p = 0492
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses
In the present study it was found that the most common morbidity of musculoskeletal
system was pain of the joints (other than the knee joint) found in 87 (198) of the subjects
followed by knee joint pain in 82 ( 186) and non-specific pains and aches were found in
80 (182) of the subjects It was found that back ache was more common in females
35(194) compared to males 30 (115) and this difference was found to be statistically
significant
49
Results
Table 16 Distribution of the study subjects based on morbidity of the eye and adnexa
Diseases of the
eye and
adnexa
Males
(n=260)
Females
(n=180)
Total
(n= 440)
Statistical
value
Cataract
112(43)
60(333)
172(391)
X2 = 4241
df=1
p = 0039
Refractive error
20(77)
14(78)
34(77)
X2= 0001
df=1
p = 0973
Others (conjunctivitis
pterygium glaucoma etc)
7(27)
6(33)
13(29)
X2=0152
df=1
p = 0696
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses
In the present study it was found that the most common morbidity of the eye was cataract
found in 172 (391) of the subjects It was more common in males 112 (43) compared to
females 60 (333) and this difference was found to be statistically significant The other
morbidities present were refractive error found in 34 (77) subjects and others which
includes conjunctivitis pterygium glaucoma etc found in 13 (29 ) subjects
50
Results
Table 17 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the oral cavity
Diseases of the
oral cavity
Males
(n =260 )
Females
(n =180 )
Total
(n = 440)
Statistical
value
Stained teeth
22 (84)
18 (10)
40 (91)
X2 =0304
df=1
p = 0581
Missing teeth
40 (154)
38 (211)
78 (177)
X2= 239
df= 1
p=0122
Caries
28 (108)
8 (44)
36 (82)
X2= 566
df= 1
p=0017
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses
In the present study it was found that the most common morbidity of the oral cavity was
missing teeth found in 78 (177 ) of the subjects followed by stained teeth found in 40
(91) of the subjects and dental caries in 36 (82) of the subjects Dental caries were
more common in males 28 (108) compared to females 8(44) and this difference was
found to be statistically significant
51
Results
Table 18 Distribution of study subjects based on endocrine nutritional and metabolic
disorders
Disorders Males
(n =260 )
Females
(n =180)
Total
(n = 440)
Statistical value
Diabetes mellitus
45 (173)
37 (206)
82 (186)
X2 = 0739
df= 1
p = 0389
Anemia
24 (92)
35 (194)
59 (134)
X2= 955
df = 1
p = 0001
Thyroid disorders
1(04)
3 (17)
4 (09)
p= 0309
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
The present study revealed that the most common disorder of the endocrine system was
diabetes mellitus found in 82 (186) of the subjects followed by the nutritional disorder of
anemia found in 59 (134) of the subjects It was seen that anemia was more common
among females 35 (194) compared to males 24 (92) This difference was found to be
statistically significant Disorders of the thyroid gland were found in 4 (09) of the subjects
being more common in females 3(17) compared to males 1 (04)
52
Results
Table 19 Distribution of the study subject based on disease of the circulatory system
Diseases of
circulatory
system
Males
(n=260 )
Females
(n =180)
Total
(n = 440)
Statistical
value
Hypertension
62 (238)
71 (394)
133 (302)
X2= 1227
df= 1
p = 0000
CAD MI
Arrhythmias
2 (08)
2 (11)
4 (09)
p =100
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
In our study it was found that the most common disease of the circulatory system was
hypertension which was found in 133 (302 ) of the subjects it was more common in
females 71 (394) compared to males 62 (239) and this difference was found to be
statistically significant The other disorders of the circulatory system were CAD MI
arrhythmias which were found only in 4 (09) of the study subjects
53
Results
Table 20 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the respiratory system
Disorders of
Respiratory
System
Males
(n=260)
Females
(n=180)
Total
(n=440)
Statistical
value
Bronchial asthma
3 (12)
3 (17)
6 (14)
p =0692
URTI
45 (173)
27 (15)
72 (164)
X2= 0413
df = 1
p = 0520
Acute Bronchitis
12 (46)
7 (39)
19 (43)
X2= 0135
df = 1
p = 0712
Pulmonary TB
4 (15)
0(00)
4 (09)
p =0148
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
Our study revealed that the most common disease of the respiratory system was URTI
(upper respiratory tract infection) found in 72 (164) subjects followed by acute bronchitis
in 19 (43 ) bronchial asthma in 6 (14) and pulmonary TB in only in 4 (09 ) subjects
Pulmonary TB was found in 4 (15) of the males whereas no females had TB however
this difference was not found to be statistically significant
54
Results
Table 21 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the digestive system
Disorders of
Gastrointestinal
system
Males
(n = 260)
Females
(n = 180)
Total
(n = 440)
Statistical value
Constipation
21(8)
6 (33)
27(61)
X2 =4155
df =1
p =0041
Gastritis
24 (92)
18 (10)
42(95)
X2= 0072
df = 1
p =0787
Bleeding per
rectum 3(12) 2(11) 5(11)
p =100
Others (Pain
abdomen
anorexia
indigestion)
9(35)
4 (22)
13 (3)
X2=0569
df =1
p=0450
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
Our study revealed that the most common disorder of the gastrointestinal system was
gastritis found in 42 (95) subjects followed by constipation in 27 ( 61) others which
include pain abdomen anorexia indigestion was found in 13 (3) and bleeding per rectum
was seen in 5 (11) It was seen that constipation was more common among males 21(8)
compared to females 6 (33) which was found to be statistically significant
55
Results
Table 22 Distribution the study subjects based on disease of the Skin and
subcutaneous tissue
Disorders of skin and
subcutaneous tissue
Males ( n = 260)
Females (n = 180)
Total (n = 440)
Statistical
value
Itching
19(73)
2(11)
21(48)
X2 =896
df=1
p = 0002
Scaling 6 (23)
3 (17)
9 (2)
p =0743
Pigmentation
5(19)
4 (22)
9 (2)
p =100
Dryness
8 (31)
11 (61)
19(43)
X2= 237
df = 1
p = 0123 Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
In the present study it was found that the most common disease of the skin was itching
which was present in 21 (48) of the study subjects followed by dryness in 19 (43) and 9
(2) of the subjects had scaling and pigmentation It was seen that itching was more
common among males 19 (73) compared to females 2 (11) and this difference was
found to be statistically significant
56
Results
Table 23 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the ear
Disease of the ear
Males
(n= 260)
Females
(n = 180)
Total
(n = 440) Statistical value
Hearing impairment
33 (126)
16 (89)
49 (111)
X2 =155
df =1
p =0212
Ear discharge
3 (12)
1 (06)
4(09)
p =0647
Tinnitus
3 (12)
1 (06)
4 (09)
p =0647
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
In the present study it was observed that hearing impairment was the most common
morbidity of the ear found in 49 (111) of the subjects though it was more common
among males 33 (126) compared to females 16 (89) the difference was not found to be
statistically significant The other disorders which affected the ear were ear discharge and
tinnitus both present in 4 (09) of the subjects
57
Results
Table 24 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the genitourinary
system
Disorders of
genitourinary system
Male
(n = 260)
Female
(n = 180)
Total
(n=440)
Statistical value
Burning micturition
2 (077)
2 (11)
4 (09)
p=100
Increased frequency of
micturition
20(77) 5(28) 25(57)
X2= 4794
df =1
p =0028 Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
In our study it was observed that the most common morbidity affecting the genitourinary
system was increased frequency of micturition in 25 (57) of the subjects followed by
burning micturition in 4 (09) of the study subjects Increased frequency of micturition was
more common among males 20 (77) compared to females 5 (28) and this difference
was found to be statistically significant
58
Results
Table 25 Distribution of the study subjects based on diseases of the Nervous system
Disease of the
nervous system Males
(n = 260)
Females
(n = 180)
Total
(n = 440)
p value
Memory loss
2 (77)
2 (11)
4 (09)
100
Stroke
2 (77)
0 (00)
2 (05)
0515
Neuritis
2 (77)
3 (17)
5 (11)
0652
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
Our study revealed that the most common disorder of the nervous system was neuritis seen
in 5 (11) of the subjects followed by memory loss in 4 (09) and stroke in 2 (05 ) of
the subjects It was observed that 2 (0 77) of males had suffered a stroke whereas none of
the females had suffered from stroke however this difference was not found to be
statistically significant
59
Results
Table 26 Association between morbidity pattern of the study subjects and their age
group
System involved 60-69Yrs
(n = 271)
70-79Yrs
(n = 134)
gt 80Yrs
(n = 35)
Total
( n = 440)
Statistical
value
Musculoskeletal
System
195 (72)
94 (70)
25 (710)
314 (714) X2= 0143
df = 2 p = 0930
Eye amp adnexa
125 (461)
69 (515)
25 (714)
219 (497) X2= 8166
df = 2 p = 0016
Oral cavity amp salivary gland
56 (207)
68 (507)
30 (857)
154 (350) X2= 7865
df = 2 p lt 00001
Endocrine nutritional amp
metabolic diseases
91 (335)
47 (35)
7 (200)
145 (329) X2= 297
df = 2 p = 0225
Circulatory
system
87 (321)
40 (298)
10 (285)
137 (311) X2= 0328
df = 2 p = 0848
Respiratory
system
64 (236)
31 (231)
6 (171)
101 (23) X2= 0738
df = 2 p = 0691
Digestive system
52 (191)
28 (210)
7 (200)
87 (191) X2= 0166
df = 2 p = 0 920
Skin and subcutaneous
tissue
43 (159)
13 (97)
2 (57)
58 (132) X2= 4831
df = 2 p = 0089
Ear amp mastoid process
27 (99)
20 (149)
10 (285)
57 (13) X2= 1018
d= 2 p = 0006
Genitourinary
system
20 (74)
8 (59)
1 (29)
29 (66) X2= 1151
df = 2 p = 0562
Nervous system
5 (18)
4 (29)
2 (57)
11 (25)
p = 0418
Figure in parenthesis indicates percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
60
Results
Table 26 shows the association between the morbidity pattern and age group of the study
subjects It is observed that the disease of the eye and adnexa increase with increasing age
and are more common in individuals above 80 years of age (714) compared to
individuals in the age group of 60-69 years (461) and 70-79 years (515) This
difference was found to be statistically significant The disease of the oral cavity were also
more common in the subjects aged 80 years and above (857) compared to individuals in
the age group of 70-79 years (507) and 60-69 years (207) this difference was also
found to be statistically significant Significant association was also found between
increasing age and disease of the ear 285 subjects aged 80 years and above suffered from
disease of the ear followed by 149 in the age group of 60-69 years and 99 in the age
group of 60-69 years
61
Results Table 27 Association between morbidity pattern of the study subjects and their
occupation
System involved Employed (n=215)
Unemployed (n=225)
Total (n=440)
Statistical value
Musculoskeletal
system
171 (795) 143 (635) 314 (714) X2 =1374 df=1
p=00002
Eye and adnexa 108 (502) 111(493) 219(497) X2= 0035 df=1
p= 0850
Oral cavityamp
salivary glands
76 (353) 78 (347) 154 (35) X2=0022 df=1
p=0880
Endocrine
nutritional amp
metabolic
disease
75 (348) 70 (311) 145 (329) X2=0708 df=1
p=0400
circulatory
system
58 (269) 79 (351) 137 (311) X2=3393 df=1
p=0065
Respiratory
system
49 (227) 52 (231) 101 (23) X2=0006 df=1
p=09363
Digestive system 45 (21) 42 (187) 87 (198) X2=0125 df=1
p=0723
Skin
subcutaneous
tissue
38 (176) 20 (88) 58 (132) X2=741 df=1
p=0006
Ear and mastoid
process
31 (144) 26 (115) 57 (13) X2=0799 df=1
p=0371
Genitourinary
system
16 (74) 13 (57) 29 (66) X2=0494 df=1
p=0481
Nervous system
2 (093) 9 (4) 11 (25) X2=425 df=1
p=0039 Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses
62
Results
Table 27 shows the association between the morbidity pattern and occupation of the study
subjects It was observed that musculoskeletal disorders were more common among the
subjects who are employed (795) compared to those who are not employed (635) and
this difference was found to be statistically significant A significant association was also
seen between the disorders of the skin and subcutaneous tissue 176 subjects who are
employed suffered from the disease of the skin and subcutaneous tissue compared to 88
who were unemployed The diseases of the nervous system were more common among
those who were unemployed (4) compared to those who were employed (093) this
difference was also found to be statistically significant
63
Results Table 28 Association between morbidity pattern of the study subjects and their
religion
System involved Hindu
(n=188)
Muslim
(n=252)
Total
(n=440)
Statistical value
Musculoskeletal system 138 (73) 176 (698) 314 (714)
X2=0668 df=1
p=0413
Eye and adnexa 100 (531) 119 (472) 219 (497) X2=1535 df=1
p= 0215
Oral cavityamp salivary glands 73 (388) 81 (321) 154 (35)
X2=211 df=1
p=0145
Endocrine nutritional amp metabolic diseases
53 (2819) 92 (365) 145 (329) X2=3371 df=1
p=0066
circulatory system 58 (269) 79 (351) 137 (311)
X2=3393 df=1
p=0065
Respiratory system
33 (176) 68 (269) 101 (229)
X2=5415 df= 1
p=0019
Digestive system 27 (144) 60 (238) 87 (198) X2=6059 df=1
p=0013
Skin subcutaneous tissue
31 (164) 27 (107) 58 (132) X2=3138 df=1
p=00765
Ear and mastoid process
28 (149) 29 (115) 57 (129) X2=1095 df=1
p=0297
Genitourinary system
16 (85) 13 (52) 29 (66) X2=1965 df=1
p=0161
Nervous system
4 (21) 7 (28) 11(25) p=0764
Figure in parenthesis indicates percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
64
Results
Table 28 shows the association between the morbidity pattern of the study subjects and their
religion In our study it was observed that the disorders of the digestive system were more
common among Muslims (238) compared to Hindus (144) this difference was found
to be statistically significant Also the disorders of the respiratory system were more
common among Muslims (269) compared to Hindus (176) This difference was also
found to be statistically significant Some of the diseases were more common among Hindus
which include the disease of the eye and adnexa (531) oral cavity (388) ear (149)
skin and subcutaneous tissue (164) and genitourinary system (85) but it was not found
to be statistically significant
65
Results
III HEATLTH SEEKING BEHAVIOR OF THE STUDY SUBJECTS
Figure16 Distribution of the study subjects based on the visit to health facility in case
of an illness
In our study it was found that that out of 440 study subjects 395(898) visited a health
facility in case of an illness whereas 45(102) did not visit any health facility in case of an
illness
898
102
health facility visitednot visited
66
Results
Table 29 Reasons cited by the study subjects for not seeking healthcare in case of an
illness
In the present study it was found that the most common reason stated by the 45 study
subjects for not seeking health care in case of an illness was that it was a mil 20 (444)
followed by lack of money stated by12 (267) the other reasons stated were no one to
accompany 7 (156) and lack of faith in health care 6 (133)
Reasons cited for not
seeking health care
Frequency (n=45)
Percentage ()
Mild discomfort 20 444
Lack of money 12 267
Lack of faith in
healthcare
6 133
No one to accompany 7 156
Total 45 100
67
Results
Table 30 Distribution of the study subjects based on the type of health facility visited
It was observed that out of 395 subjects who visited health care facility in case of an illness
229(58) Visited government hospitals 160 (405) visited private practitioners hospitals
and 6 (15) visited quacks More number of males (622) visited government hospitals
compared to females (513)
Type of health facility visited
Males
(n=241)
Females
(n=154)
Total
(n=395)
No No No
Government hospital 150 622 79 513 229 58
Private practitionershospitals 87 361 73 474 160 405
Quacks 4 17 2 13 6 15
Total 241 100 154 100 395 100
68
Results
Table 31 Association between gender and health seeking behaviour of the study
subjects
Whether visited
health facility
in case of illness
Sex
Total
n ()
p value Male
n ()
Female
n ()
Yes 241 (927) 154 (856) 395 (898) 00151
No 19 (106) 26 (144) 45 (102)
Total 260 (59) 180 (41) 440 (100)
x2=5901 df =1
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
It was observed that more number of males visited a health care facility in case of an illness
241(927) whereas only 154(856) females visited a health facility in case of an illness
This difference was found to be statistically significant
69
Results
Table 32 Association between educational status and health seeking
behaviour of the study subjects
Whether visited Health facility in case of illness
p value
Educational status(n) Yes () No ()
0000
Illiterate (231) 194 (84) 37 (16)
Primary school (121) 115 (95) 6 (49)
Higher primary (38) 37 (974) 1 (26)
Secondary school (30) 29 (967) 1 (33)
Intermediate (6) 6 (100) 0(00)
Graduate (14) 14 (100) 0(00)
Total(440) 395 (898) 45(102)
Fisherrsquos exact test
In the present study it was found that 84 of the study subjects who were illiterate visited a
health facility in case of an illness whereas 16 did not visit a health facility in case of an
illness 967 of the subjects with education up to secondary school visited the health
facility and 100 of the subjects who studied up to intermediate and with a graduate degree
visited the health facility in case of an illness This difference was found to be statistically
significant
70
Results
Table 33 Distribution of study subjects according to frequency of visits to a health care facility
Frequency of visits to a health care facility
Frequency
(n=395)
Percentage
Once a month 207 524
Once in 3 months 99 251
Once in 6 months 79 20
Once in a year 10 25
Total 395 100
In the present study it was found that out of 395 study subjects who visited a health care
facility in case of an illness 207 (524) visited a health facility every month followed by
99 (251) who visited once in 3 months 79(20) once in 6 months and 10 25 visited
the health facility once in a year
71
Discussion
DISCUSSION
I Socio-demographic characteristics
Our study was done in the urban field practice area of JJM Medical College Davangere
among 440 geriatric subjects our study aimed at assessing the morbidity pattern and health
seeking behaviour of the geriatric population in the study area
In the present study Out of 440 study subjects majority 162(368) were in the age
group of 60-64 Years followed by 109 (247) in the age group of 65-69 Years 99 (225)
in the age group of 70-74 Years and 8 were more than or equal to 80 years of age [Table
7] This was similar to a study conducted by Prakash Boraingaiah et al 72 in which majority
of the elderly (346) belongs to age group 60-64 years followed by age group 75 years and
above (259)
In our study it was also seen that 59 of the study subjects were males and 41 were
females This was similar to a study conducted by Mohan Gupta et al 35 where 573
subjects were males and 427were females Our findings were contrary to a study
conducted by Md Alam Naushad et al 28 where 598 subjects were females and 402
were males
In the present study it was found that the majority of the study subject belonged to
Muslim religion 252 (573) followed by Hindus 188 (427) there were no study subjects
who belonged to other religions like Christian Jain Sikhs etc [Table 8] similar findings
were seen in a study conducted by Mrinal Ranjan Srivastav et al 50 in which 52 of the
subjects were Muslims
72
Discussion
In the present study it was found that the Majority of the study subjects were illiterate
525 whereas 275 had completed education up to primary school 82 had completed
education up to secondary school and only 32 were graduates [Table 9] These findings
were similar to a study done by Shraddha K et al 51in which 504 of the study subjects
were illiterate
In our study it was found that the majority of the study subjects 511 were unemployed
followed by 227 who were unskilled workers 155 were semi-skilled workers and
about 105 were skilled workers [Table 10] These findings were similar to a study done
by Rajat Das Gupta et al27 al in which 481 of the study subjects were not working
In our study majority of the subjects 49 belonged to Class IV Socioeconomic status
followed by 26 who belonged to class III and 13 who belonged to class II (according to
Modified BG Prasad Classification 2016) [Table 11] Similar findings were found in a study
conducted by Sribas Goswami and Manjari Sahai 29 in which majority of the study subjects
belonged to class IV socio economic status
In our study it was found that the majority of the study subjects 734 were married
followed by 261 who were widowed and only 05 were unmarried [Table 12] These
findings were similar to a study done by L subedhi and RB Sah 40 in which 663 of the
subjects were married 322 were widowed and 07 were unmarried
In the present study it was found that majority of the study subjects 42 lived in a three
generation family followed by 37 who lived in a nuclear family and 21 who lived in a
Joint family [Table 13] These findings were similar to a study done by Swapnil Jain et al 26
in which the majority (47) of the study subjects lived in a three generation family
73
Discussion
II Prevalence of morbidities among the study subjects
In the present study it was found that majority of the subjects 45 had a normal BMI
followed by 30 who were overweight about 15 were obese and only10 were
underweight [Figure 14] Similar findings were reported in a study conducted by Khadervali
Nagoor et al 44 in which 49 subjects had a normal BMI In a study done by Vimala
Thomas et al 52 272 of the subjects were obese which was higher than the present study
In the present study it was found that the majority of the subjects suffered from the
disorders of the musculoskeletal system (714) eye and adnexa (497) oral cavity
(311) respiratory system (229) digestive system (198)disease of the skin
(132)ear(13)genitourinary system (66) nervous system (25) [Table14] Similar
findings were seen in a study done by Rajashree Bhat et al 55 in which most common
morbidity of elderly was the problems of loco-motor system (486) followed by vision
(427) CVS disorders (344) respiratory system (202) and disease of ear (179)In
this study though the prevalence of loco-motor system disorders (486) was highest
compared to other disorders it was lesser compared to our study (714) In a study done by
L subedhi and RB Sah 40 it was found that 44 had eye problems 43 had gastrointestinal
problems 33 had CVS problems and 23 had ENT problems In this study the prevalence
of gastrointestinal disorders was much higher compared to our study
In the present study joint pain (including the knee joint) was most common disorder of the
musculoskeletal system seen in 40 of the males compared to 384 in females [Table 15]
whereas in a study done by Swapnil Jain et al 26 it was found that 472 males and 528
females suffered from joint pains This could be attributed to the fact that in our study
majority of the study subjects were males
74
Discussion
In the present study it was found that the most common morbidity of the eye was cataract
found in 39 of the subjects It was more common in males 43 compared to females
333 [ Table 16]These findings were similar to a study done by Shraddha K et al 51 in
which the overall prevalence of cataract was 302 of which 42 males and 358
females had cataract
In the present study it was found that the most common morbidity of the oral cavity was
missing teeth found in 177 of the subjects [Table 17] it was similar to the findings of a
study conducted by JP Singh et al 48 in which 1475 subjects were edentulous
The present study revealed that the most common disorder of the endocrine system was
diabetes mellitus found in 186 of the subjects followed by the nutritional disorder of
anemia found in 134 of the subjects It was seen that anemia was more common among
females 194 compared to males 92 [Table 18] Kakkar R et al 45 reported similar
findings with prevalence of diabetes mellitus as 153 In a study done by Deepak Sharma
et al 47 anemia was present in 15 of the subjects 97 males and 21 females were
anemic which was similar to our study
In our study it was found that the most common disease of the circulatory system was
hypertension which was found in 302 of the subjects it was more common in females
394 compared to males 239 and this difference was found to be statistically significant
[Table 19] A study by L Subedhi and RB Sah 40 reported that the prevalence of
hypertension was more among females (333) compared to males (30) which was
statistically significant
75
Discussion
In our study the most common morbidity of the respiratory system was upper respiratory
tract infection (163) [Table20] it was similar to the study done by Leena Rahul
Salunke33 where it was reported to be 196
In our study the most common disorder of the digestive system was gastritis (95)
[Table 21] similar to the findings of JP Singh et al 48 (35) contrary to this L subedhi
and RB Sah 40 reported a high prevalence of gastritis (39) This difference could be
attributed to the difference in the interpretation of symptoms for the diagnosis of gastritis
In our study the most common disorder of the skin was itching (48) [ Table 22] which
was similar to the findings reported by JP Singh et al 48 in which 225 subjects suffered
from itching
In our study the most common disorder of the ear was impaired hearing (111) [Table
23] similar to a study by Vandana Nikumb et al 38 in which 106 subjects suffered from
hearing impairment
In our study it was observed that the most common morbidity affecting the
genitourinary system was increased frequency of micturition (57) [Table 24]
L subedhi and RB Sah40 found in their study that 143 subjects suffered from increased
frequency of micturition which was higher compared to our study
Our study revealed that 25 subjects suffered from the disorders of the nervous
system [Table 25] similar to a study conducted by Vandana Nikumb et al 38 in which
13 of the Subjects suffered from the disorders of the nervous system whereas in a
study conducted by Shilpa Shaukaiah et al36 it was found that 66 of the subjects
suffered from the disorders of the nervous system which was higher than our study
76
Discussion
It is observed that the disease of the eye and adnexa increased with increasing age and were
more common in individuals above 80 years of age (714) The disease of the oral cavity
were also more common in the subjects aged 80 years and above (857) and 285
subjects aged 80 years and above suffered from disease of the ear A significant association
was found between age and these morbidities [Table 26] Similar results were found in a
study done by Swapnil Jain et al 26 in which cataract hearing impairment and dental
problems were significantly associated with the age of the study subjects
In our study a significant association was found between occupation and the disorders of
the musculoskeletal system skin and the nervous system Disorders of the musculoskeletal
system were more common among employed subjects (795) compared to unemployed
(635) 176 subjects who were employed suffered from the disease of the skin and
subcutaneous tissue compared to 88 who were unemployed Diseases of the nervous
system were more common among those who were unemployed (4) compared to those
who were employed (093) [Table 27]
A study done by Kakkar R et al45 found that there was a significant association between the
employment status and the morbidities of the CVS arthritis and cataract CVS morbidity
was more common among those not working (164) compared to those working (36)
Arthritis was also more common among not working (212) compared to those working
(55) and cataract was also more common among those not working (175) compared to
those working (55)
77
Discussion
In our study it was observed that there was a significant association between religion and
disorders of the digestive system and respiratory system The disorders of the digestive
system were more common among Muslims (238) compared to Hindus (144) Also the
disorders of the respiratory system were more common among Muslims (269) compared
to Hindus (176) [Table 28] In a study conducted by Mrinal Ranjan Srivastav et al 50 it
was found that there was significant association between religion and the morbidities of the
genitourinary system in the urban areas The problems of the genitourinary system were
more common among Hindus (26) compared to Muslims (96)
III HEATLTH SEEKING BEHAVIOR OF THE STUDY SUBJECTS
In our study it was found that that (898) study subjects visited a health facility in case
of an illness whereas 102 did not visit any health facility in case of an illness[Figure 16]
Similar findings were seen in a study conducted by Vimala Thomas et al 52 where it was
found that 716 subjects visited a health facility Contrary to our findings a study
conducted by Bhawalkar JS et al46 showed that only 81 subjects visited a health facility in
case of an illness whereas 919 did not visit any health facility
In the present study it was found that the most common reason stated by study subjects
for not seeking health care in case of an illness was that it was a mild discomfort (444)
followed by lack of money stated by (267) other reasons stated were no one to
accompany (156) and lack of faith in health care (133) [Table 29] In a study
conducted by Deepak Sharma et al 47 it was found that the most common reasons for not
seeking health care were the following disease due to age (496) health services too far
(191) lack of money (6) no body to take to hospital (35)
78
Discussion
It was observed that out of 395 subjects who visited health care facility in case of an illness
58 Visited government hospitals 362 visited private practitioners hospitals and 15
visited quacks [Table 30] similar results were found in a study conducted by Deepak Sharma
et al 47 in which 607 went to Government hospitals 267 consulted private practitioners
and 126 took over the counter drugs In another study conducted by Rajat Das Gupta et al
27 it was found that 33 visited Government hospitals 25 visited private hospitals 6
visited private practitioners
It was observed that more number of males (927) visited a health care facility in case of
an illness whereas only 856 females visited a health facility in case of an illness [Table
31] In a study done by Man Mohan Gupta et al 35 it was found that 672 females and
651 males visited a health facility in case of illness
In the present study it was found that 848 of the study subjects who were illiterate
visited a health facility in case of an illness whereas 152 did not visit a health facility in
case of an illness A significant association was found between educational status and
gender [Table 32] In a study done by Deepak Sharma et al 47 it was found that Gender
literacy income and marital status were not found to be significantly related to health-
seeking behaviour
In the present study it was found that 524 subjects visited a health facility every month
followed by 251 who visited a health facility once in 3 months 20once in 6 months
and 25 visited a health facility once in a year[ Table 33] In a study conducted by Rajat
Das Gupta et al 27 it was found that majority of the subjects (2943) visited a health
facility once a year followed by 2813 who visited a health facility once in three months
79
Conclusion
CONCLUSION
The study revealed that some of the common morbidities among the geriatric subjects were
the disorders of the musculoskeletal system followed by the disease of the eye and adnexa
oral cavity endocrine nutritional and metabolic disorders etc some disorders like cataract
dental caries constipation and increased frequency of micturition were more common
among males whereas disease like anemia and hypertension were more common among
females A significant association was found between some of the morbidities and socio
demographic determinants like age occupation and religion
Any degree of formal schooling was found to be associated with better health seeking
behavior Majority of the subjects visited a Government health facility in case of an illness
and the main reason that was stated for not visiting a health facility was that they suffered
from mild discomfort and did not consider it necessary to visit a health facility
80
Summary
SUMMARY
Our study was done in the urban field practice area of JJM Medical College Davangere
among 440 geriatric subjects our study aimed at assessing the morbidity pattern and health
seeking behaviour of the geriatric population in the study area
The results of our study are as follows
ISocio-demographic characteristics of the study subjects
In the present study 368 subjects were in the age group of 60-64 Years
59 of the subjects were males and 41 were females
573 subjects were Muslims whereas 427 were Hindus
Majority of the subjects were illiterate (525) whereas 275 had completed
education up to primary school
It was found that the majority of the study subjects (511) were unemployed
49 subjects belonged to Class IV Socioeconomic status according to Modified BG
Prasad Classification
734 of the subjects were married
42 of the people lived in a three generation family
II Prevalence of morbidities among the study subjects
Majority of the subjects (45) had a normal BMI followed 30who were
overweight
Majority 714 subjects suffered from the disorders of the musculoskeletal system
followed by 497 who suffered from the disease of the eye and adnexa35
suffered from the disease of the oral cavity 329 suffered from endocrine
nutritional and metabolic disorders and 311 suffered from the disease of the
circulatory system 229 suffered from the disease of the respiratory system198
81
Summary
suffered from the disease of the digestive system132 suffered from disease of the
skin13 suffered from the disease of the ear66 suffered from the disease of the
genitourinary system and 25 suffered from the disease of the nervous system
The most common morbidity of musculoskeletal system was pain of the joints (other
than the knee joint) found in 198 of the subjectsBack ache was more common in
females 231 compared to males 163 and this difference was found to be
statistically significant
cataract found in 39 of the subjects It was more common in males 43 compared
to females 333 and this difference was found to be statistically significant
Missing teeth were found in 177 of the subjects Dental caries were more
common in males 108 compared to females 44 and this difference was found to
be statistically significant
Diabetes mellitus found in 186 of the subjects followed by the nutritional disorder
of anemia found in 134 of the subjects anemia was more common among females
194 compared to males 92 This difference was found to be statistically
significant
Hypertension which was found in 302 of the subjects it was more common in
females 394 compared to males 239 and this difference was found to be
statistically significant
upper respiratory tract infection) found in 163 subjects followed by acute
bronchitis in 43 bronchial asthma in 14 and pulmonary TB in only 09
Gastritis was found in 95 subjects followed by constipation in 61 Among
males (81) had constipation compared to females(03)
Most common disease of the skin was itching which was present in 48 of the
study subjects followed by dryness in 43
82
Summary
Hearing impairment was found in 111 of the subjects
Increased frequency of micturition was found in 57 of the subjects followed by
burning micturition in 09 of the study subjects Increased frequency of
micturition was more among males 77 compared to females in whom it was 28
and this difference was found to be statistically significant
The most common disorder of the nervous system was neuritis seen in 11 of the
subjects followed by memory loss in 09 and stroke in 05 of the subjects
A significant association was found between increasing age and the morbidities of
the eye ear and the oral cavity
Significant association was found between occupation and the disorders of the
musculoskeletal system skin and the nervous system Disorders of the
musculoskeletal system were more common among employed subjects (795)
compared to unemployed (635) 176 subjects who were employed suffered
from the disease of the skin and subcutaneous tissue compared to 88 who were
unemployed Diseases of the nervous system were more common among those who
were unemployed (4) compared to those who were employed (093)
It was observed that the disorders of the digestive system were more common
among Muslims (238) compared to Hindus (144) this difference was found to
be statistically significant Also the disorders of the respiratory system were more
common among Muslims (269) compared to Hindus (176) This difference
was also found to be statistically significant
83
Summary
III HEATLTH SEEKING BEHAVIOR OF THE STUDY SUBJECTS
In our study 898 subjects visited a health facility in case of an illness whereas
102 did not
The most common reason stated by study subjects for not seeking health care in case
of an illness was that it was a mild discomfort (444) followed by lack of money
stated by (267) the other reasons stated were no one to accompany (156) and
lack of faith in health care (133)
It was observed that 58 subjects Visited Government hospitals 362 visited
private practitioners hospitals and 15 visited quacks
Majority of males (927) visited a health care facility in case of an illness whereas
only 856 females visited a health facility in case of an illness This difference was
found to be statistically significant
A significant association was found between the educational status and health
seeking behaviour Majority of the educated subjects visited a health facility in case
of an illness compared to those who were illiterate
It was found that 524 subjects visited a health facility every month followed by
251 who visited a health facility once in 3 months 20once in 6 months and
25 visited a health facility once in a year
84
Limitations
LIMITATIONS
1 Many of the responses were subjective and there were no records to verify them
2 Some of the morbidities were diagnosed only by clinical examination and could not be
confirmed by performing diagnostic tests due to high cost and time constraints
3 This study was done in the urban field practice area which consisted of a closed
community hence the results cannot be generalized to the entire population of the area
85
Recommendations
RECOMMENDATIONS
1 Health education should be given to the geriatric people regarding the common health
problems associated with ageing and preventive care should be provided to the elderly
2 Geriatric clinics should be set up at the primary health care level which provide regular
screening and health check-ups
3 There should also be a provision to provide domiciliary care by specialists qualified in
geriatrics
4 The family members and the care givers of the elderly should be educated about the
common health problems of the elderly and also about the need for regular health check-ups
and emotional support
5 The majority of the geriatric population is out of work force they are suffering from
many morbidities and are totally dependent on others even for their health needs Hence the
Government should increase the pension of the elderly and provide them quality healthcare
free of cost
6 There is also a need for public private partnership to improve the quality of health
services for the geriatric people More number of NGOs should work towards improving the
health and the quality of life of the elderly
86
References
REFERENCES
1 United Nations Department of Economic and Social affairs Population Division
World population ageing 2013 Available from URL
wwwunorgendevelopmentpopulationageingWorldPopulationAgeing2013
[Accessed on 17-7-2016]
2 Khan S and Itrat M Current Issues in Geriatric Health Care in India-A Review J Community Med Health Care 2016 1(1) 1-3
3 United Nations Department of Economic and Social Affairs Population Division
World Population Ageing 2015 ndash Highlights Available from URL
wwwunorgendevelopmentdesapopulationpdfageingWPA2015_Reportpdf
[Accessed on 272017]
4 State of elderly in India 2014 Help age India Available from URL
httpswwwhelpageindiaorgimagespdfstate-elderly-india-2014pdf [Accessed on
1082017]
5 World Health Organization World report on ageing and health 2015Available
from URL wwwwhointageingeventsworld-report-2015-launchen [Accessed on
1272017]
6 National policy for Senior citizens March 2011Ministry of Social Justice and
welfare Govt of India Available from URL
socialjusticenicinwritereaddataUploadFilednpscpdf [Accessed on 482017]
87
References
7 Elderly in India Profile and programmes 2016Govt of India Ministry of statistics
and programme implementation Central Statistics Office Available from URL
wwwmopsigovin [ Accessed on 1442017]
8 Saxena V Kandpal SD Gael D Bansal S Health status of elderly community
based study Indian Journal of Community Health2012 Oct-Dec24(4)269-74
9 Shah T Patel M Shah V Health care seeking behaviour of urban and rural
community in Ahmedabad district Int J Med Sci Public Health20132908-11
10 Sahoo H Mishra NR Health Status Morbidity Pattern and Treatment Seeking
Behaviour among Elderly in India Evidence from 60th round of National Sample
Survey Data Learning community 2011 Dec 2(3) 341-55
11 Park K Parkrsquos Textbook of Preventive and social medicine 24 th ed Jabalpur MS
Banarsidas Bhanot Publishers2017631
12 UNFPA- state of World Population 2011Chapter 1 setting the scene 19-31
Available from URL httpswwwunfpaorgsitesdefaultfilesresource-
pdfUNFPA-Report-Chapter1pd [Accessed on 1082017]
13 Lal S Adarsh Pankaj Textbook of community Medicine 4th ed CBS publishers and
distributors PvtLtd2011732
14 Census of India 2001 Registrar General And Census Commissioner India
Available from URL httpwwwcensusindiagovinCensus[Accessed on
7102015]
15 SRS bulletin October 2012 Registar General of India New Delhi Available from
URL censusindiagovinvital_statisticsSRS_BulletinsSRS_Bulletin-
October_2012[Acessed on 7102015]
88
References
16 Bagchi K Healthy ageing Health and Population-Perspectives and Issues 2000
23(1)11-16
17 Salagre SB The Association of Physicians of India Chapter 177 Health Issues in
Geriatrics Available from URL
wwwapiindiaorgmedicine_update_2013chap177pd [ Accessed on 282017]
18 Ingle GK Nath A Geriatric Health in India Concerns and Solutions Indian Journal
of Community Medicine 2008 33(4)214-18
19 World Health Organization Active Ageing a policy framework 2002 Available
from httpwhqlibdocwhointhq2002who_nmh_nph_028pdf [Accessed on
1062017]
20 Inche Zainal Abidin S Sutan R Shamsuddin K Prevalence and determinants of
appropriate health seeking behaviour among known diabetics Results from a
community-based survey Advances in Epidemiology 2014 Nov 20141-6
21 Begashaw B Tessema F Gesesew HA Health Care Seeking behavior in Southwest
Ethiopia Plos one 2016 Sep 11(9)e0161014
22 MacKian S Health systems development Manchester University of Manchester
2003 A review of health seeking behavior problems and prospects
23 Metta EO Health-seeking behaviour among adults in the context of the
epidemiological transition in Southeastern Tanzania A focus on malaria and
diabetes [Groningen] University of Groningen 2016 228 Available from URL
httpswwwrugnlresearchportalfiles28737720Chapter_7pdf [Accessed on
1272017]
24 Adhikari D Rijal D Factors affecting health seeking behaviour of senior citizens of
Dharan Journal of Nobel Medical College 2015 Sep 4(1)57-63
25 Polisetty S Seepana M Morbidity profile of elderly individuals in urban
Visakhapatnam Int J Community Med Public Health 2017 4(2)2558-63
89
References
26 Jain S Kaware AC Doibale MK Shaikh S Radhey BK Mathurkar MP Morbidity
pattern among geriatric population in urban field practice area of district of
Maharashtra a cross sectional study Int J Community Med Public Health 2016
3(2)523-29
27 Gupta RD Loha A Roy S Morbidity pattern and health-seeking behaviour among
the senior citizens in a selected urban area of Bangladesh A cross-sectional study
South East Asia Journal of Public Health 2016 Jul 5(2)43-49
28 Naushad MA Verma N Bhawnani D Jain M Anand T Umate LV Morbidity
pattern and health seeking behaviour in elderly population of Raipur City
Chhattisgarh India Indian Journal of Community Health2016 Sep 28(3)236-41
29 Goswami S Sahai M A Study of Morbidity Pattern in Elderly Population European
Researcher Series A 2016103(2)119-28
30 Bardhan H Dixit AM Agarwal R Jain PK Gupta S Shukla SK Morbidity profile
of elderly population in Ghaziabad district a cross-sectional study Int J Med Sci
Public Health 2016 5(6)1098-1102
31 Maroof M Ahmad A Khalique N Ansari MA Health problems among the aged A
community based study from urban Aligarh Uttar Pradesh India Int J Community
Med Public Health 2016 Feb 3(4)944-47
32 Shankar G Sidenur B A morbidity study of elderly residing in urban field practice
area of SN medical college Bagalkot National Journal of research in community
medicine 2016 Oct-Dec 4(5) 229-34
90
References
33 Salunkhe LR Socio-demographic profile of old age people living in urban amp urban
slum areas in Maharashtra Karad A comparative study J of Evidence based Med
and Hlthcare 2015 Feb 2(5) 513-21
34 Warbhe P Rupesh W Morbidity profile health seeking behaviour and home
environment survey for adaptive measures in geriatric population-Urban community
study International Journal of Medical Research amp Health Sciences 2015 4(4)778-
82
35 Gupta M Borle AL Chhari N Gupta S Assessment of clinico-socioeconomic
status and health-care support among the elderly people aged older than 60 years in
urban population of Bhopal Central India Int J Med Sci Public Health 2015
4558-64
36 Sahukaiah S Shenoy A Vijayakumar BC An epidemiological study of prevalence
of morbidity patterns among geriatric age group in an urban slum of Mumbai Int J
Med Sci Public Health 2015 Jul 4(7)883-87
37 Shubha Davalagi B Angadi N Mahabalaraju DK Morbidity psycho-social profile
and health seeking behaviour of the elderly population in urban slums of Davangere
City India Int J Res Med Sci 2015 Nov 3(11)3288-91
38 Nikumb V Patankar F Behera A A Study of Morbidity Profile among Geriatric
Population in an Urban Area Sch J App Med Sci 2015 3(3)1365-69
91
References
39 Vishnoi BR Solanki SL Singhal G Meharda B Mishra N Morbidity profile of
elderly in urban slum of Udaipur Rajasthan Int J Oral Health Med Res 2015 May
2(1)9-12
40 Subedi L Sah RB Study of the health status of geriatric age group in Chitwan
district of Nepal Journal of Chitwan Medical College 2015 Mar 5(1)11-17
41 Noor S Krishnababu G Prasad KV Health status of Geriatric population in slums
of Rourkela Young Innovative Journal of Medical and Health Science 2015 May
5(3) 92-94
42 Sarode VM Chronic Diseases Related to Aging and Disease Prevention in Slums in
Mumbai Journal of Aging Science 2014 Jan 2 (1)1-6
43 Barman SK Lata K Ram R Ghosh N Sarker G Shahnawaz K A study of
morbidity profile of geriatric population in an urban community of Kishanganj
Bihar India Global Journal of Medicine and Public Health GJMEDPH 2014 3(1)
1-7
44 Nagoor K Srikanth BA Dudekula R Satna K Comparative study of health status
among slum and non-slum elderly population in Kadapa Region South India
Journal of Evolution of Medical and Dental Sciences 2014 Feb 3(5)1298-308
45 Kakkar R Aggarwal P Kandpal SD Bansal SK An Epidemiological study to assess
morbidity profile among geriatric population in District Dehradun Indian Journal of
Community Health 2013 May 25(1)39-44
46 Bhawalkar JS Dhone AB Jethani S Singru S Jadhav SL Adyanthaya S A study of
morbidity profile among geriatric population in an urban area J Evol Med Dent Sci
2013 Sep 9 36(2)6963-7
92
References
47 Sharma D Mazta SR Parashar A Morbidity pattern and health-seeking behaviour of
aged population residing in Shimla hills of north India A cross-sectional study
Journal of family medicine and primary care 2013 Apr2(2)188
48 Singh JP Singh S Kasturwar NB Hassan A Geriatric morbidity profile in an urban
slum Central India Indian Journal of Community Health 2013 Aug 25(2)164-70
49 Thakur RP Banerjee A Nikumb VB Health Problems among the Elderly A Cross
Sectional Study Annals of medical and health sciences research 2013 3(1)19-25
50 Mrinal RS Beena S Pratibha G Pankaj B Srivastava JP Atul B Morbidity Status
and Its Social Determinants among Elderly Population of Lucknow District India
Sch J App Med Sci 2013 1(6)758-64
51 Shraddha K Prashantha B Prakash B Study on morbidity pattern among elderly in
urban population of Mysore Karnataka India International Journal of Medicine and
Biomedical Research 2012 1(3)215-23
52 Thomas V Lavanya KM Morbidity profile and health seeking behaviour of the
elderly in urban slums of Hyderabad Andhra Pradesh India- A cross sectional study
International Journal of Current Research and Review 2012 Oct 1 4(19)174-80
53 Moe S Tha K Naing DK Htike MM Health seeking behaviour of elderly in
Myanmar International Journal of Collaborative Research on Internal Medicine and
Public Health 2012 4(8)1538-44
93
References
54 Bharati DR Pal R Rekha R Yamuna TV Kar S Radjou AN Ageing in
Puducherry South India An overview of morbidity profile Journal of pharmacy amp
bio allied sciences 2011 Oct 3(4)537
55 Bhatt R Gadhvi MS Sonaliya KN Solanki A Nayak H An epidemiological study
of the morbidity pattern among the elderly population in Ahmedabad Gujarat
National Journal of community medicine 2011 Jul 2(2)233-36
56 Srinivasan Krishnamachari Vaz Mario Thomas Tinku Prevalence of health related
disability among community dwelling urban elderly from middle socioeconomic
strata in Bangaluru India Indian Journal of Medical Research 2010 Apr 131(4)
515-21
57 Srivastava K Gupta SC Kaushal SK Chaturvedi M Morbidity profile of elderly a
cross sectional study of urban Agra Indian Journal of Community Health 2010 Jun
22(1)51-55
58 Ladha A Khan R Malik A Khan S Khan B Khan I et al The health seeking
behaviour of elderly population in a poor-urban community of Karachi Pakistan
Journal of the Pakistan Medical Association2009 Feb 59(2) 89-92
59 WHO ICD-10 version 2010 Geneva World Health Organization Available from
URL appswhointclassificationsicd10browse2010en [Accessed on 772017]
60 OpenEpi22OpenEpi (free) download Windows version Available from URL
enfreedownloadmanagerorgWindows-PCOpenEpi-FREEhtml
61 Tandon R Sinhota Parsonrsquos disease of the eye 22edNew Delhi Elsevier 98-100
62 Dhingra P L Dhingra S Disease of ear nose and throat and head and neck surgery
6th ed New Delhi Elsevier 201422
94
References
63 Aziz N Kallur SD Nirmalan PK Implications of the revised consensus body mass
indices for Asian Indians on clinical obstetric practice Journal of clinical and
diagnostic research 2014 May 8(5)OC01
64 Chobanion AV Bakris GL Black HR The seventh report of the joint national
committee on prevention detection evaluation and treatment of high blood pressure
the JNC 7 report JAMA 2003 2892560-72
65 The Seventh Report of the Joint National Committee on Prevention Detection
Evaluation and Treatment of High Blood Pressure (JNC 7) The GuidelinesUS
Department of Health and Human Services National Heart Lung and Blood
Institute Available at URL
httpswwwnhlbinihgovfilesdocsguidelinesjnc7fullpdf [ Accessed on
1282017]
66 Firkin F Chestman C Penington D Rush B De Gruchyrsquos clinical Hematology in
medical practice 5th edition New Delhi Blackwell science Ltd1989 32-47
67 Report of WHO consultation Nutritional Anaemias Geneva Switzerland World
Health Organization TRS-405 1968 Available from URL
whqlibdocwhointtrsWHO_TRS_405pdf [Accessed on 1282017]
68 National Family Health survey (NFHS-4) 2015-16 India Mumbai IIPS
2016Available from URL httpwwwnfhsindiaorg [Accessed on 4072017]
69 The Minimum Wages Act 1948 Ministry of Labour and Employment Government
of India Available from URL httplabourgovincontentinnerpagewagesphp
[Accessed on 1082017]
70 Khairnar M Wadgave U Shimpi P Updated BG Prasad socioeconomic
classification for 2016 Journal of Indian Association of Public Health Dentistry
2016 Oct 1 14(4)469
95
References
71 Tiwari P Tiwari S Mastering practicals community medicine 1st ed New Delhi
India Wolters Kluwer PvtLtd2013161-67
72 Boralingaiah P Bettappa P Kashyap S Prevalence of Psycho-Social Problems
among Elderly in Urban Population of Mysore City Karnataka India Indian journal
of psychological medicine 2012 Oct 34(4)360
96
PATIENT CONSENT FORM JJM MEDICAL COLLEGE DAVANGERE
DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY MEDICINE I the undersigned hereby give my consent
for investigations carried upon me I am satisfied with the information given about this
Clinical study titled ldquoA STUDY ON THE MORBIDITY PATTERN AND HEALTH
SEEKING BEHAVIOR AMONG THE GERIATRIC POULATION IN THE
URBAN FIELD PRACTICE AREA OF JJM MEDICAL COLLEGE
DAVANGERErdquo ldquoconducted by Dr RUCHI DHAR under the guidance of Dr VIDYA
GS Associate Professor I have been informed and explained the risks involved and I
hereby voluntarily and Unconditionally give my consent without any fear or pressure in
mentally sound and conscious state to participate in this study
DATE PATIENTrsquoS SIGNATURE
eEacuteeEacuteJA ordfEacuteEcirczAgravearingQAtildeAiAgraveAuml ordfAgraveAumlordmAacutelaquozAacutearingregAiAgraveAuml zAacuteordfAgravetUEacutegEacute
ryenAacutemiumlethordfEacuteAumlAmiumlDyensiumlPAgraveordfAgraveAumlAumlaringcurrenn ordfEacuteAumlrsup1poundiuml
ordfEacuteEcirczAgravearingQAtildeAiAgraveAumlvAgraveyenAacutecedilAgraveuEacuteUEacuteMbrvbaragraveUEacute yenAgravevAgraveaelig F PEacutefrac14AgraveUEacute cedilAgraveraquo ordfAgraveiAacutergAgraveAumlordfAgrave poundAacutepoundAgraveAuml CAzAgravegEacute
poundAgravepoundAgraveszlig
ordfEacuteEcirczAgravearingQAtildeAiAgraveAumlvAgraveyenAacutecedilAgraveuEacute ordmAacuteUAgraveAElig plusmnAgravecedilAgraveUcircccedilaQvEacuteigraveUEacuteAzAgraveAuml poundAgravepoundAgraveszligMbrvbaragraveUEacuteAiAgraveAumlpoundAgraveAumlszlig
cedilAgraveAEligasup1gAgraveAumlvEacuteUcircAtildepoundEacute J cedilAgraveOumlr Dyensiuml zAgrave ordfEacuteAEligcopyethrn yenAacutearinglpoundiumleth CAqiuml ordmEacutemacriumlUcirc sup1AtildeQAUiuml copyordmEacuteAtildelaquoAiAgraveAumlgiuml Dyensiuml zAgrave fjAiAgraveiAacutenaeligPiuml yenEacuteAEligAtildeyenAgraveAumlaringmacrEacuteAtildemicroAgravepoundiuml Epoundiuml zAgrave Csectethpoundiuml brvbarAtildemacriumlOslash yenAacuteaeligoumlaringQOumlAtildecediliuml JjAiAgraveAuml Dyensiuml ddordfAgraveAumlAuml ordfEacuteEcirczAgravearingQAtildeAiAgraveAuml ordfAgraveAumlordmAacutelaquozAacutearingregAiAgraveAuml zAacuteordfAgravetUEacutegEacute JAsect sup2AtildeparaethPEacuteAiAgraveAumlrAiAgraveAumldegegrave yenAgravejAtildePEacuteeumlUEacute Mfrac14AgraveyenAgravercedilAgraveAumlordfAgrave ordfEacuteEcirczAgravearinggAacutezAgrave qAacute|| gAgraveAumla zAgravesAgravegAgrave ordfAgraveAumlvAgraveAumlUcirc qAacute|| laquozAacutearing fJcediliumlordfAgraveiAacuteUAgraveethzAgraveplusmnAgraveethPAgravegAacutezAgrave yenEacuteAEligaeligAtildeyensEacutecedilAgravegiuml
EordfAgravegAgraveAuml poundAgravepoundAgraveUEacute F vAgraveyenAacutecedilAgraveuEacuteUEacute Mfrac14AgraveyenAgraveqAgraveAumlordfAgrave ordfAgraveAumlAumlpoundAgraveszlig yenAgraveaeligwAiEacuteAEligAzAgraveAuml
CAplusmnAgraveUAgravefrac14AgravepoundAgraveAumlszlig CxAgraveethordfAacuteUAgraveAumlordfAgraveAvEacute wfrac12sup1gAgraveAumlvAacuteUcircgEacuteDzAgraveYacutejAzAgrave poundAacutepoundAgraveAuml poundAgravepoundAgraveszlig
ordfAgraveAumlpoundAgravecedilAacutegEacute AiAgraveiAacuteordfAgraveAringzEacuteAtilde umlsAgraveAiAgraveAuml ordfAgraveAumlvAgraveAumlUcirc AiAgraveiAacutegAgrave MvAacuteUcircAiAgraveAumllaquoregegravezEacute poundAacutepoundAgraveAuml
vAgraveyenAacutecedilAgraveuEacute aQvEacuteigraveUEacuteAEligfrac14AgraveyenAgraveqAgraveregAuml MbrvbaragraveUEacuteAiAgraveAumlpoundAgraveAumlszlig cedilAgraveAEligasup1gAgraveAumlvEacuteUcircAtildepoundEacute
centpoundAacuteAPAgrave gEacuteAEligAtildeVAi
Annexures
ANNEXURE ndashIII
104
Annexures
PROFORMA
I General information
1 NAME
2 AGE
3 GENDER (a) Male (b) Female
4 MARITAL STATUS (a) Unmarried (b) Married (c) Widow Widower
(d) Divorced separated
5 LIVING ARRANGEMENT (a) with spouse (b) Spouse and children
(c) Children only (d) living alone (e) others
6 RELIGION (a) Hindu (b) Muslim (c) Christian (d) Others
7 ADDRESS
8 EDUCATION (a) illiterate (b) Primary school (c) higher primary
(d) secondary school (e)PUC diploma (e) Graduate (f) Postgraduate
9 OCCUPATION (a) professional (b) semi- professional (c) skilled worker
(d) Semi ndashskilled worker (e) unskilled worker (f) unemployed
10 CONTACT NUMBER
11 TYPE OF FAMILY (a) Joint (b) Nuclear (C) three generation
12 TOTAL NUMBER OF FAMILY MEMBERS
13 TOTAL FAMILY INCOME
14 PER CAPITA FAMILY INCOME
15 SOCIO ECONOMIC STATUS (Modified BG Prasad classification) I IIIIIIVV
16 DIET (a) Vegetarian (b) Mixed
17 Sleep (a) Disturbed if yes reason ______________ (b) Not disturbed
18 Bowel Regular Irregular
19 Bladder Regular Irregular
97
Annexures
20 HABITS (a) betel nut (b) tobacco (c) alcohol (d) smoking (e) others
If any of the habits present Duration (since when) _________
Frequency of consumption day_______
IIAssessment of morbidity based on history
1 Whether suffering from any chronic illness like (a) Type 2 DM (b) Hypertension
(c) Bronchial Asthma (d) TB (e) others
2 Whether suffering from cataract currently (a) Yes (b) No
3 Whether operated for cataract (a) Yes (b) No If Yes duration since operation____
4 MUSCULOSKELETAL SYSTEM
Whether the following symptoms are present
(a) Backache (b) Joint pain (c) restricted joint movements (d) pain in calves
(e) Others_________
5 RESPIRATORY SYSTEM
(a) Productive cough (b) non-productive cough (c) nasal discharge (d) breathlessness (e)
sore throat (f) sneezing
6 CARDIOVASCULAR SYSTEM
(a) Palpitations (b) chest pain (c) breathlessness
7 GASTROINTESTINAL SYSTEM
(a) Pain abdomen (b) lose stools (c) constipation (d) flatulence (e) heart burn
(f) Bleeding per rectum
8 EYE AND ADNEXA
(a) Watering (b) diminution of vision (c) redness
9 EAR
(a) Discharge (b) decreased hearing (c) Tinnitus
10 SKIN
(a) Itching (b) skin eruptions (c) scaling (d) pigmentation
98
Annexures
11 GENITO URINARY SYSTEM
(a) Burning micturition (b) increased frequency of micturition
12 GENERAL SYMPTOMS
(a) Fatigue (b) headache (c) fever
13 ANY OTHER COMPLAINTS (a) burning feet (b) swelling in groin
(c) Memory loss (d) insomnia
III Assessment of health seeking behaviour
1 Do you visit a health facility in case of illness (a) Yes (b) No
If yes how much time do you take to visit a health facility an case of an illness
(a) Within 24 hours (b) 24-48 hours (c) more than 48 hours
2 Which type of health facility do you visit
(a) Govt hospital (b) Private practitioners (c) over the counter drugs (e) quacks
Mention the reason for visiting the particular health facility______________________
3 Whether taking regular treatment after diagnosis ________________
If No mention the reason_______________________
4 Whether following the instructions given by the treating doctor
(a) Yes (b) no
5 cost of treatment per month in case of chronic disease
(a) lt100 (b) 100-200 (c) 200-300 (d) 300 and above
6 Person bearing the cost of treatment
(a) Self (b) spouse (c) son (d) daughter (d) outside help
7 Duration to reach the health facility
(a) less than 3o minutes (b) 30 minutes or more
8 Whether going for regular check -ups (a) Yes (b) No
If Yes duration between the check-ups_______
99
Annexures
9 Whether following self- care practices in case of chronic disease like diabetes and hypertension
(a) Yes (b) No
10 In case of healthy individuals whether getting screening tests done (a) Yes (b) No
11 Whether following any dietary modifications (a) yes (b) No
12 Whether any family member accompanies you to the health facility
If yes who (a) Son (b) daughter (c) spouse (d) others
11 Whether the family supports in following specific diet advised by the doctor
(a) Yes (b) No
12 whether family members help in reminding to take regular medication
(a) Yes (b) No
IV Physical examination
1 Personal hygiene status
S NO COMPONENT CONDITION REMARKS
1 Hair
2 Teeth
3 Bath
4 Clothes
5 Washing hand before
eating food
6 Washing hands with soap
and water after ablution
7 Nails
8 Foot wear
Remarks personal hygiene status Good fair poor
100
Annexures
2 MEASUREMENTS
(a) Weight (in Kg) ______ (b) Height (in cm) _____ (c) BMI ______
(d) Waist circumference______ (e) Hip circumference ___________
(f) Waist hip ratio_________
3 GENERAL PHYSICAL EXAMINATION
Pallor Icterus Cyanosis clubbing lymphadenopathy Oedema
Pulse rate Temp Blood Pressure
Respiratory rate
20 Examination of
Eye Oral cavity Ear
Nose Throat
SYSTEMIC EXAMINATION
Cardiovascular system Respiratory system
Per abdomen Central Nervous system
101
MASTER CHART
Annexures
ANNEXURES
International Classification of Diseases (10th Revision)
I Certain infectious and parasitic diseases (A00-B99)
II Neoplasms (C00-D48)
III Diseases of blood and blood forming organs and certain disorders
involving the immune mechanisms (D50-D89)
IV Endocrine nutritional and metabolic diseases (E00-E90)
V Mental and behavioural disorders (F00-F99)
VI Diseases of the nervous system (G00-G99)
VII Diseases of the eye and adnexa (H00-H59)
VIII Diseases of the ear and mastoid process ( H60-H95)
IX Diseases of the circulatory system (I00-I99)
X Diseases of the respiratory system ( J00-J99)
XI Diseases of the digestive system (K00-K93)
XII Diseases of the skin and subcutaneous tissue ( L00-L99)
XIII Diseases of the musculoskeletal system and connective tissue
(M00-M99)
XIV Diseases of the genitourinary system ( N00-N99)
XV Pregnancy childbirth and purperium (O00-O99)
XVI Certain conditions originating in perinatal period (P00-P96)
XVII Congenital malformations deformations and chromosomal
XVIII (S00-T98)
XIX External causes of morbidity and mortality (V01-Y98)
102
Annexures
XX Injury poisoning and certain other consequences of external causes
(S00-T98)
XXI Factors influencing health status and contact with health services
(Z00-Z99)
XXII Codes for special purpose
103
Annexures
105
Annexures
106
Annexures
107
Annexures
PHOTOS
Picture 1 Showing the investigator interviewing the study subject
Picture 2 Showing the investigator interacting with the study subject
108
Annexures
Picture 3 Showing the investigator recording the Blood pressure of the study subject
Picture 4 Showing the investigator auscultating the study subject
109
Annexures
110
LIST OF FIGURES
Figure No
Title Page No
1 Proportion of elderly in the Indian population by age groups
1961-2001
6
2 Pathophysiology of health issues in geriatrics 10
3 Predicting health behaviour with social cognition models 13
4 Health belief model components and linkages 15
5 Maps showing the location of Davangere district and the
area where the UHTC is located
27
6 Map showing the Urban field practice area of JJM medical college
28
7 Age and sex wise distribution of the study subjects 39
8 Distribution of the study subjects based on religion 40
9 Distribution of the study subjects based on Educational status 41
10 Distribution of study subjects based on their occupation 42
11
Distribution of study subjects based on their occupation
43
12 Distribution of the study subjects based on their marital status 44
13 Distribution of the study subjects based on the type of family 45
14 Distribution of the study subjects based on the BMI 46
15 Distribution of morbidity pattern of the study subjects based on
ICD 10 classification of diseases
48
16 Distribution of the study subjects based on the visit to health
facility in case of an illness
66
xvi
ABSTRACT Background
According to census 2011 the elderly population aged 60 years and above account for 8
of total population and is projected to rise to 124 by the year 2026 Health status is an
important factor that has a significant impact on quality of life The elderly are one of the
most vulnerable and high risk groups in terms of health status and their health seeking
behaviour is crucial in any society
Objectives
1 To study the morbidity pattern among the geriatric population in the urban field
practice area of JJM Medical college Davangere
2 To assess the health seeking behaviour of the elderly residing in the study area
Methods It was a community based cross sectional study which was conducted in the urban field
practice area of JJM Medical College Davangere The total study subjects were 440
individuals aged 60 years and above Data was collected using a predesigned pre-tested
and semi- structured questionnaire Height weight and blood pressure were measured
and recorded Data was analyzed by using MS Excel and Open-Epi Info software
version 22 Statistical test employed was chi-square and Fishers exact test x
Results and Conclusion
In our study it was found that the majority of the subjects (368) were in the age group
of 60-64 years 525 were illiterate 511 were unemployed and 49 belonged to class
IV socio economic status The study revealed that the some of the common morbidities
among the geriatric subjects were the disorders of the musculoskeletal system (714)
eye and adnexa (497) oral cavity (329) endocrine nutritional and metabolic
disorders (329)etc some disorders like cataract dental caries constipation and
increased frequency of micturition were more common among males whereas disease
like anemia and hypertension were more common among females A significant
association was found between some of the morbidities and socio demographic
determinants like age occupation and religion
Any degree of formal schooling was found to be associated with better health seeking
behavior Majority of the subjects (58) visited a Government health facility in case of
an illness and the main reason that was stated for not visiting a health facility was that
they suffered from mild discomfort (444) and did not consider it necessary to visit a
health facility
Key words Geriatric urban behaviour morbidity
xi
Introduction
INTRODUCTION
ldquoA STUDY ON THE MORBIDITY PATTERN AND HEALTH SEEKING BEHAVIOUR AMONG THE GERIATRIC POPULATION IN THE URBAN FIELD
PRACTICE AREA OF JJM MEDICAL COLLEGE DAVANGERErdquo
All countries of the world are experiencing population ageing Ageing is a result of
decreasing mortality and most importantly declining fertility The global share of older
people (aged 60 years and above) has increased from 92 per cent in 1990 to 117 in
2013 and will continue to grow as a proportion of the world population reaches 211 by
20501
The lsquoNational Policy for Older Personsrsquo was adopted by the Government of India in
January 1999 and it defines a lsquosenior citizenrsquo or lsquoelderlyrsquo as a person who is aged 60 years
or above Ageing is a progressive process associated with declines in structure and
function impaired maintenance and repair systems increased susceptibility to disease and
death2
In 2015 Worldwide there were 901 million people aged 60 years or over It is
projected that their number will grow to 14 billion in 2030 which is the target date for the
SDGs and to 21 billion by 2050 There will be growth in the number of older persons aged
60 years and above between 2015 and 2030 This increase is projected to be especially
significant global phenomenon and virtually every country in the world will experience a
substantial increase including the less developed regions3 The increased life expectancy has
led to challenges in health care management The elderly suffer from various diseases which
include non-communicable disease (NCDs) like diabetes hypertension coronary heart
disease and other disorders like osteoarthritis stroke dementia osteoporosis cancer
1
Introduction enlarged prostate depression and cataract related blindness In the coming years there will
be a phenomenal growth in the population of the elderly while the family size will reduce
The disintegration of the joint family and women moving out of the household has led to the
absence of traditional caregivers for the elderly who are already a vulnerable group4
The most common cause of health problems in the old aged people is chronic diseases
Most of these problems can be prevented or delayed by engaging in healthy behaviours
Even in the advanced years of life physical activity and good nutrition can have
effective benefits on health and well-being Many health problems of old age can be
effectively managed if they are detected early enough5 The National Policy for Older
Persons was announced by the Government of India in the year 1999 The Constitution of
India under Article 41 mandates the well-being of senior citizens ldquoThe state shall
within the limits of its economic capacity and development make effective provision
for securing the right to public assistance in case of old aged peoplerdquo 6
National Council for Older Persons (NCOP) has been reconstituted and renamed as
National Council for Senior Citizens (NCSrC) in order to have a definite structure and also
regional balancing the NCOP advises the Central and State Governments on a broad range
of issues related to welfare of senior citizens and enhancement of their quality of life The
NCSrc meets at least twice a year7 The elderly suffer from multiple medical as well as
psychological problems There has already been some pioneering work on the elderly in
India but a lot more remains to be done There is an urgent need to pay attention
towards the medical and socio-economic problems that are being faced by the elderly
people in India and thus formulate strategies to bring about an improvement in their
quality of life8 The Health seeking behaviour is influenced by various factors which
include the individual self diseases and the availability and accessibility of health
2
services It is important to have knowledge regarding the health seeking behaviour of
individuals for designing health care policies and programmes so that all the possible
difficulties with early diagnosis and effective treatment can be identified and appropriate
interventions can be implemented9 As already stated the elderly are a vulnerable group as
there are psychological as well as physiological changes with increasing age and it is
difficult to cope up with the problems of ageing Some of the most common problems in old
age are cardiovascular problems arthritis respiratory problems blood pressure and so on
Therefore the study of the health status of elderly morbid conditions perceptions about
it is important to note and the health care of the elderly becomes very important since they
are more prone to illness than young people and are also more prone to domestic and other
accidents Their health and treatment seeking behaviour are most important for the
formulation of welfare programmes of the country 10
Hence this study was taken up in the urban field practice area of JJM Medical College
Davangere to assess the morbidity pattern and health seeking behaviour of the geriatric
subjects
3
Objectives
OBJECTIVES
1 To study the morbidity pattern among the geriatric population in the urban field
practice area of JJM Medical college Davangere
2 To assess the health seeking behaviour of the elderly residing in the study area
4
Review of literature
vii
REVIEW OF LITERATURE
1 Definition Geriatrics or clinical gerontology Is the term used for the care of the aged 11 The United Nations uses 60 years and above to refer to older people the same is also used
by demographers However in many developed countries the age of 65 is used as the
reference point for older persons 12
Elderly are classified in to 3 groups 13
Young old Persons in the age group of 60 years to 74 years
Old old Persons in the age group of 75 years to 84 years
Oldest old Persons above the age of 85 yrs
2 Demography of the ageing population in India
The UN defines a country as ldquoAgeingrdquo or ldquoGreying Nationrdquo where the
proportion of people over 60 reaches 7 percent to total population By 2011 India has
exceeded that proportion (80 percent) and is expected to reach 126 percent in 2025
The Indian population has increased from 361 million in 1951 to 1027 billion in 2001
and further to 121 billion in 2011 Simultaneously the number of older people has
increased from 19 million (ie 4 percent of total population) to 77 million and
further to roughly 93 million (ie 75 percent of the total) during the same time
span 14
5
Review of literature
Figure1 proportion of elderly in the Indian population by age groups 1961-2001 14
Table 1 Percentage share of elderly population (aged 60 years and above) in total
population by sex in India 15
Years Male Female Total Rural Urban
1961 55 58 56 58 47
1971 59 60 60 62 50
1981 64 66 65 68 54
1991 67 68 68 71 57
2001 71 78 75 77 67
2011 77 84 80 81 79
2004-05 69 75 72 73 70
2007-08 73 77 75 76 72
6
Review of literature
The rise in population of males was more modest from 55 percent to 71 percent while for
females there had been a steep rise from 58 percent to 78 percent during five decadal
Censuses from 1961 to 2001 In 2011 the elderly population accounted for 80 percent of
total population For males it was marginally lower at 77 percent while for females it was
84 percent According to NSSO surveys the proportion of elderly population in rural areas
was 73 percent during 2004-05 and increased up to 76 percent in 2007-08 While on the
other hand in urban areas the proportion of elderly population rose from 70 percent to 72
percent during the corresponding period It has been observed that the percentage share of
elderly to total population remained higher in rural areas than in urban areas15
Table2 Size of elderly population (aged 60+) and their share in total population in major states of India in 201115
All India and selected major states
Proportion of elderly in total population of State
Male Female Total Andhra Pradesh 83 94 88 Bihar 72 67 70 Gujarat 76 90 83 Haryana 66 76 71 Himachal Pradesh 104 103 104 Karnataka 79 89 84 Kerala 118 133 126 Madhya Pradesh 68 74 71 Maharashtra 88 97 93 Orissa 91 95 93 Punjab 91 100 95 Rajasthan 66 79 72 Tamil Nadu 102 109 105 Uttar Pradesh 66 71 68 West Bengal 82 82 82 All India 77 84 80
7
Review of literature
3 MORBIDITY PATTERN AMONG THE ELDERLY
Physiological Decline and Consequences of increasing age
Ageing i s a process of decline in biological functions affecting most physical
Systems The following systems are affected by ageing
(a) Atrophy of the Taste Buds and Loss of Teeth
With the increasing age the taste buds of the tongue get atrophied and as a result the
preference for food alters significantly There is also a considerable loss of teeth causing
difficulties in chewing food
(b) Changes in the Gastrointestinal Tract
As the age advances the walls of the intestine get atrophied and the motility is
markedly reduced (lazy intestine) The digestive enzymes secreted by the intestine are
also reduced Hence the partly digested food stays in the intestine for a longer period
As a result the common complaint of the elderly person is gas formation (flatulence)
and constipation
(c) Respiratory System
As the age advance there is progressive fibrosis of the lungs leading to reduced
oxygenation of the lungs and breathing difficulties
(d) Kidney and genitourinary System
The kidneys get smaller in size and the power of the kidneys to filter out the unwanted
waste products from the body is diminished The total amount of urine becomes less in
old age and thus the waste products are not adequately excreted from the body
8
Review of literature
(e) Urinary Bladder
Urinary bladder gets smaller in size due to shrinkage and as a result the accumulation
of urine even of a small amount leads to an urge for urination With increase in age
the valve in the bladder which controls the exit of urine from the bladder to urethra
gets atrophied and weak Involuntary leakage of urine occurs in case the bladder is full
or due to increase of pressure on bladder on sneezing or even on laughing a condition
known as urinary incontinence Incontinence is a common complaint of elder females
(f) Heart and Circulatory System
The blood vessels get rigid and quite often the vessel walls become rough with the
deposition of solid matters consisting mostly of cholesterol The heart muscles get weaker
and power to send blood throughout the body through the circulatory system gets less and
less powerful The most dangerous effect on heart is coronary heart disease especially
coronary thrombosis
(g) Muscular system
The muscles in the body get gradually atrophied with ageing and especially those
small muscles which are necessary for quick reflex action The elderly person can quite
be capable of working like a normal person and can undertake activities which require
big muscles of legs and arms But when it comes to quick movement which needs small
muscles for quick reflex movements these functions are impaired causing accidents
like slipping on wet floor of the bathroom
(h) Brain
With ageing the size of the brain gets smaller and the weight also becomes less This
however does not interfere with the function of the brain However in general the brain
cells and its fibers which carry impulses from brain to the system and upwards get
9
Review of literature
degenerated The most glaring manifestation of ageing affecting the brain is
forgetfulness and in simple terms it is inability of brain to recall the past experience
However this is common in all elderly persons
(i ) Bones
The bones become porous and fragile as age advances especially in elderly females This
condition is known as osteoporosis and leads to sustaining of fractures even after a minor
fall16
Figure 2 pathophysiology of health issues in geriatrics17
The common disease that the geriatric population suffers from are type 2 diabetes
coronary heart disease hypertension stroke chronic obstructive pulmonary disease
10
Review of literature
Alzheimerrsquos disease osteoarthritis osteoporosis prostatic hypertrophy cataracts macular
degeneration cancer etc and at the same time they are vulnerable to infections involving
respiratory (including TB) urinary and digestive tract17
In India the elderly people suffer from dual medical problems ie communicable and
nonndash communicable diseases There is also impairment of special sensory functions like
vision and hearing A decline in immunity and age-related physiological changes leads to
an increased burden of communicable diseases in the elderly A report by Indian Council
of Medical Research (ICMR) on the chronic morbidity profile in the elderly states that
hearing impairment is the most common morbidity followed by visual impairment
However different studies show varied results in the morbidity pattern18
Major chronic conditions affecting older people worldwide 19
Cardiovascular diseases (such as coronary heart disease) Diabetes Mellitus
Hypertension Stroke Cancer
Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease
Musculoskeletal conditions (such as arthritis and osteoporosis)
Mental health conditions (mostly dementia and depression)
Blindness and visual impairment
11
Review of literature
Health seeking behaviour
1 Definition
There is no common definition agreed upon by sociologists in any sociology literature
Different definitions may be used in different studies despite referring to the same activity
Sociology and literature assume that health seeking behaviour is influenced by the various
factors which include individual self or the individual diseases present and also the
availability and accessibility of health services Being dependent on these determinants and
their interactions it can be said that health care seeking behaviour is a very complex
outcome of various factors which operate at individual family and community level20
Health Seeking Behavior (HSB) refers to decision or an action taken by an individual to
maintain attain or regain good health and to prevent illness The decisions which are
made encompasses all available health care options like visiting a public or private and
modern or traditional health facility self-medication and use of home remedies or not to
utilize the available health services etc
Determining the health care seeking behavior is very important to provide a need
based health care services to the population Visiting official channels in a formally
recognized health care system has been considered as the desired Health seeking behaviour
Health seeking behavior is influenced by multiple factors including availability quality and
price of services and also social groups health views residences and personal features of the
users Peoplersquos choice of health care differs in socio demographic socio-economic and
cultural compositions and this has an effect on their health seeking behavior Urban dwellers
are generally believed to be open to new ideas and willing to try certain things on a trial and
error basis21
12
Review of literature
Health seeking behaviours two approaches
(a) Health seeking behaviours utilization of the system
This approach focuses on the actions which are taken to rectify perceived ill health and
the type of health care facility which is utilized by the people There is data which
suggests that the people visit more traditional healers and unofficial medical channels
this should be prevented and the emphasis s h o u l d b e on encouraging people to opt
first for the official channels
(b) Health seeking behaviours the process of illness response
This approach considers the factors which enable or prevent people from making
healthy choices either i n their lifestyle behaviours or use of medical care and
treatment22
Figure 3 Predicting health behaviour with social cognition models 22
13
Review of literature
2 Health belief Model of health seeking behaviour
Since lsquoHealth seekingrsquo is a conditioned behaviour any attempt which is made to
encourage people to seek health care definitely requires an understanding of their
motivation for such behaviour Only through a deeper understanding of the intricate
factors shaping behavioural practices can health promotion programmes and or
interventions successfully be introduced into the realities of the peoplersquos lives to bring
about changes in health behaviour
Behaviour change theories and models such as the Health Belief Model (HBM)
Theory of Reasoned Action (TRA) Theory of Planned Behaviour (TPB) and the
Trans theoretical model have been widely applied in public health in an attempt to
explain or predict health seeking behaviours Their use enables identification and
understanding of peoplersquos health-seeking behaviour beyond their knowledge attitudes
and practices
HBM is a health specific behavioural cognitive model This model is based on the
idea that people are more likely to change their behaviour and adhere to treatments
if they have the following perceptions (i) have a perception that they are at risk of
contracting the disease (perceived susceptibility) (ii) perception that the disease
might have an unfavorable outcome (perceived severity) (iii) perceive that the
proposed health behaviour to be both effective and practical (perceived benefits)
(iv) perceive the barriers to adopting the behaviour to be minimal (perceived
barriers)(v) perceive themselves to have the ability of applying and practicing the
specific behaviour proposed (perceived self-efficacy) and (vi) they have the cues
for motivating their actions such as internal cues (pain symptoms past experiences)
or external cues (advice from friends relatives and mass media campaigns) (cues to
14
Review of literature
action) The specificity of the HBM to health has made it suitable for use in
understanding and explaining the behaviour as well as health outcomes and this may also
explain its wider use in public health2 3
Figure 4 Health belief model components and linkages 23
3 Factors influencing health seeking behaviour
The factors affecting the health seeking behaviours are seen in various contexts which
include physical socio-economic cultural and political factors Therefore the utilization of
a health care system whether public or private formal or non- formal may depend on socio-
demographic factors social structures level of education cultural beliefs and practices and
some other factors like gender discrimination status of women economic and political
systems environmental conditions and the disease pattern and health care system itself also
have an impact on the health seeking behaviour24
15
Review of literature
REVIEW OF RELATED STUDIES
A study done by Sanjay Polisetty and Madhavi Seepana (2017) on the morbidity profile
of elderly individuals in urban Visakhapatnam revealed that of the 270 study participants
about 996 suffered from either some form of acute or chronic morbidity More than 70
of individuals suffered from eye problems of which most common problem was cataract
seen in 60 About 304 had difficulties in chewing and 256 had difficulty in hearing
Hypertension was present in 49 of individuals and 742 of Diabetics were also found to
be hypertensive25
A study done by Swapnil Jain et al (2016) on Morbidity pattern among geriatric
population in urban field practice area of a district in Maharashtra revealed 653 suffered
from hearing impairment 62 were anemic 462 had hypertension 423 had joint
pain 41 had dental problems 38 7 had cataract and 318 had chronic bronchitis It
was seen that 81 of the subjects had multiple morbidities 26
A study done by Rajat Das Gupta et al (2016) in an urban area of Bangladesh on Morbidity
pattern and health-seeking behavior among the senior citizens revealed that of the 384 study
participants 968 were suffering from at least one medical problem The commonest was
musculoskeletal problems in 8411 followed by eye problems in 8125 It was found that
all the respondents sought treatment for their health problems 33 respondents went to
Government hospitals to seek medical help 6927 respondents took prescribed
medications and 567 were satisfied with their treatment 27
16
Review of literature
A study done by Md Alam Naushad et al (2016) on Morbidity pattern and health
seeking behavior in elderly population of Raipur City Chhattisgarh revealed that the
prevalence of morbidity among elderly was 9531 Out of total morbid population some
chronic illness was present in 7049 Gastro intestinal system was involved in 8262
followed by eye in 7983 and Cardiovascular system in 5245 It was found that 3552
of the subjects sought treatment from private registered practitioners 28
A study done by Sribas Goswami and Manjari Sahai (2016) in Raipur city on Morbidity
Pattern in elderly Population revealed that out of total study population of 640 elderly
subjects 610 (9531) suffered from some morbidity Prevalence among females was
9892 whereas among males it was 9026 Out of various agencies 3552 subjects
were utilizing private facility followed by 2785 who were utilizing Government agency
2631 visited quacks and 1030 were taking treatment from other source 29
A study done by Harsh Bardhan et al (2016) on the Morbidity profile of elderly population
in Ghaziabad district revealed that in geriatric population 5008 suffered from
musculoskeletal problems 5877 had dental problems and impairment of vision was seen
in 5561 The overall prevalence of diabetes and heart disease were 10 and 122
respectively 236 subjects reported the problem of loneliness and depression
forgetfulness was also reported by 3296 As far as treatment seeking behavior is
concerned approach of elderly is quite different for different morbidities The main source
of treatment for morbidities such as hypertension respiratory urinary GIT-related and
musculoskeletal problems was quacks 30
17
Review of literature
A study done by Mohammad Maharoof et al (2016) on the health problems among
the aged in Urban Aligarh UP revealed that of the 225 study subjects 782 had cataract
followed by depression in 356 refractive error in 276 loco-motor problem in 213
and hearing loss in 138 The prevalence of hearing loss was significantly related to gender
as it was higher among females with 181 compared to males in whom it was 6931
A study done by Gowri Shankar and Bhayalaxmi Sidenur (2016) on morbidity of
elderly residing in an urban area of Bagalkot revealed that the most common morbidity was
Cataract seen in 2875 followed by musculoskeletal problems in 2813 and 2313
were known hypertensive Both diabetes mellitus and hypertension was observed in 10 of
the study subjects32
A study done by Leena Rahul Salunkhe (2015) on socio-demographic profile of old
age people living in urban amp urban slum areas in Maharashtra Karad revealed that 504
and 42 elderly suffered from arthritis in an urban area and a slum respectively Number of
diabetics were higher in urban (14) than urban slum (35) 301 of subjects from urban
area suffered from hypertension compared to 161 from urban slums Upper Respiratory
Infections was more in slum dwellers (196) than people residing in urban area (7) Acid
peptic diseases were found in 168 study subjects in urban area and 154 in slum area 33
In a study done by Warbhe Priyanka A and Warbhe Rupesh (2015) on morbidity
profile health seeking behaviour and home environment survey of the elderly in an urban
slum community it was found that 941 had 1-3 morbidities 41 had 4-6 morbidities
373 gave a history of fall and 314 had history of fracture 136 subjects had been
18
Review of literature
operated for cataract 168 had undergone a procedure for fracture and10 had undergone
a dental procedure 542 went to Urban health center (UHC) and Government hospitals for
treatment and 786 received both allopathic and Ayurvedic treatment34
A study done by Man Mohan Gupta et al (2015) on Assessment of Clinico-
socioeconomic status and health-care support among the elderly people aged older than 60
years in urban population of Bhopal revealed that 353 subjects received treatment for
their morbidities from the Government hospitals whereas 267 from private
clinichospital About 653 study subjects presented with complaints and morbidity The
common morbidities which were found in the subjects were fatigue (487) backache
(353) Obesity (393) and hypertension (247)35
In a study done by Shilpa Shaukaiah et al (2015) on prevalence of morbidity pattern
among geriatric age group in an urban slum of Mumbai it was found that body ache was the
most commonly reported symptom by 290 followed by visual problems in 2318 joint
pain in 2181 indigestion in 2045 and backache in 2045 subjects36
A study done by Shubha Davalagi B et al (2015) on morbidity psycho-social profile and
health seeking behavior of the elderly population in urban slums of Davangere City revealed
that the most common morbidity which was present in the study subjects was
musculoskeletal problems in 46 psychosocial problems were present in 31 and
respiratory problems in 23 Majority of the elderly (56) utilized government
institutions for treatment of chronic disease and 47 for treatment of acute disease The
elderly population had financial constraints and lack of accessibility in seeking health care37
19
Review of literature
A study done by Vandana Nikumb et al ( 2015) on morbidity Profile among Geriatric
Population in an Urban Area of Navi Mumbai revealed that 9312 elderly were morbid and
with increasing age the number of morbidities was found to be increasing In this study it
was found that the most common morbidity was psychosocial problems which include
stress which was present in 594 subjects followed by musculoskeletal problems in
556 and eye problems like diminished vision mostly due to cataract in 463
Hypertension dental problems respiratory problems ENT problems (hearing impairment)
and endocrine disorders like diabetes accounted for 281 219 119 106 and10
respectively38
A study done by Vishnoi BR et al (2015) on Morbidity Profile of Elderly in Urban
Slum of Udaipur Rajasthan revealed that 61 of the study subjects had impaired vision
followed by 25 who had hypertension 1533 suffered from insomnia 1467 had
anemia and 14 suffered from gastrointestinal problems The condition of females was
worse compared to males39
In a study done by L Subedhi and RB Sah (2015) on the health status of geriatric age
group in Chitwan district of Nepal it was found that of the 300 study subjects 44 had
Ophthalmic problems 43 had GIT problems 33 had CVS problems 23 had ENT
problems 1567 had metabolic disorders and 533 had mental disorders The study
highlighted a high prevalence of morbidity and health related problems in the geriatric age
group40
20
Review of literature
A study done by Sofia Noor et al (2015) on health status of geriatric population in slums
of Rourkela revealed that the morbidities among the elderly that were found to be significant
were hypertension decreased visual acuity urinary problems and insomnia Apart from
systemic morbidities 91 of the elderly also complained of fragility which includes
complex physiological deterioration and unexplained weight loss41
In a study conducted by VM Sarode (2014) on Chronic Diseases Related to Ageing and
Disease Prevention in Slums in Mumbai it was found that there were highly significant
disorders among aged women related to Skin lesion and super infection Untreated bacterial
pharyngitis acute rheumatic fever while disorders among aged men were related to
hypertension Illicit drug use diabetes and asthma It was found that 49 of elderly males
and 45 of elderly females had not sought any treatment for their illness Of the people who
had sought treatment 93 elderly males and 92 of elderly females had taken treatment
from Government hospital42
A study conducted by Sanjeev Kumar Barman et al (2014) on morbidity profile of
geriatric population in an urban slum of Kishnganj Bihar revealed that the prevalence of
anemia cataract and hypertension were quite high 6375 6125 and 5063
respectively Loss of income amp occupation along with a feeling of neglect from the family
members were the common problems among the elderly It was also found that morbidities
like arthritis loss of teeth amp dental caries along with depression had a significant association
with sex age amp educational status of the study subjects43
21
Review of literature
A study done by Khadervali Nagoor et al (2014) on the health status of elderly
population in an urban area of Kadapa revealed that out of the 200 elderly persons studied
Visual problem due to cataract and refractive errors were present in 72 of the study
subjects followed by pain in joints in 595 gastrointestinal problems in 46 and dental
problems in 44 Other morbidities were hypertension in 42 genitourinary problems in
25 dermatological problems in 235 and psychological problems in 1644
A study done by Kakkar R et al (2013) on morbidity profile among geriatric population
in District Dehradun revealed that the working geriatric group was healthy as compared to
those who were retired Hypertension was the commonest morbidity among all age groups
In the age group of 60-70 years the following morbidities were seen hypertension (306)
followed by diabetes (153) arthritis (14) CVS morbidities (14) cataract (96) and
BPH (83) Among 71-80 years age group Hypertension (287) followed by arthritis
(167) cataract (157) Diabetes (111) BPH (111) and CVS morbidities (93)45
In a study done by Bhawalkar JS et al (2013) on morbidity profile among geriatric
population in an urban area of Pune it was found that Musculoskeletal disorder was the
most common (4331) followed by eye problems (3722) and hypertension (137)It
was seen that 43 elderly population had some health problem but only 8 visited the
health facilities Among them 6 visited private practitioners and only 18 went to
municipal hospitals It was found that only 2322 elderly were taking any medications and
the most commonly used drug was anti-inflammatory drugs 2323 followed by
antihypertensive drugs 136746
22
Review of literature
A study conducted by Deepak Sharma et al (2013) on morbidity pattern and health-
seeking behavior of aged population residing in Shimla revealed that the following
morbidities were present in the study subjects hypertension was the commonest (56)
followed by Musculoskeletal problems (535) Dental problems (27) cataract (23)
anemia (15) and acid peptic disease (175) 658 of the subjects were seeking
treatment for their health problems Majority of the older people preferred allopathic
medicine (812) followed by Ayurvedic medicines (113) and homeopathic medicine
(73) for their health problems Most of the older persons preferred going to a
CHCGovernment hospital for treatment for their illness There was considerable use of
over-the-counter drug by125 of the people 47
A study done by JP Singh et al (2013) on Geriatric morbidity profile in an urban slum of
Nagpur central India revealed that the most common morbidity identified in the study
population was anemia (9650) followed by hypertension (345) arthritis (3225)
cataract (21) and diabetes (1775) More than 2 morbidities were present in 325 of
the study subjects followed by four morbidities in 3125 and two morbidities in 23548
A study conducted by RP Thakur et al (2013) on the health problems of the elderly in
central India revealed that among the elderly residing in the urban areas 384 of the urban
elderly had both dental problems and arthritis followed by anemia in 348 hypertension in
266 cataract in 252 and diabetes mellitus in 157 The prevalence of self-reported
depression was 672 among the urban female elderly when compared to 397 among the
urban females49
23
Review of literature
A study done by Mrinal Ranjan Srivastav et al (2013) on Morbidity Status and its
Social determinants among elderly population of Lucknow revealed that the most common
morbidity among the urban population was eye problems which affected 516 males and
67 females followed by CVS problems in 363 males and 395 females and GIT
problems in 315males and 382 females50
A study done by Shraddha K et al (2012) on morbidity pattern among elderly in urban
population of Mysore revealed that out of the 526 study subjects 486 suffered from the
disease of the eye and adnexa followed by 384 who suffered from endocrine and
metabolic disorders 331 suffered from the disease of the circulatory system 323 had
disease of the oral cavity and salivary glands and 302 had disease of the musculoskeletal
system 51
A study done by Vimala Thomas et al (2012) on morbidity profile and health seeking
behaviour of the elderly in urban slums of Hyderabad revealed that hypertension was the
most common morbidity in 469 followed by Arthritis in 302 Diabetes in 265
respiratory problems in 243 and Cataract in 21 For out-patient treatment 472 visited
private sectors 303 Government facility 25 RMP and 06 AYUSH clinics For in-
patient treatment 198 visited private institutions 16 visited Government institutions
while 642 did not visit either52
24
Review of literature
A study done by Soe Moe et al (2012) on health seeking behaviour of elderly in
Myanmar revealed that 35 of the male elderly perceived that they were having good
health status whereas 229 of them perceived having a poor health status 343 of female
elderly perceived that they were having good health status while 24 of them perceived
having a poor health About 49 of the elderly went to rural health center for treatment
followed by 33 who went to private practitioners 15 visited hospitals and 3 went to
more than one place for treatment53
A study done by Dharamvir Ranjan Bharati et al (2011) in Puducherry revealed that in
the urban areas about 707 of the study subjects had anemia followed by 537 who had
visual impairment and hypertension and 532 suffered from diabetes mellitus It was seen
that On univariate analysis the risk of diabetes mellitus was significantly higher among
elderly from urban areas than that among elderly from rural areas and significantly lower
risk in elderly from below poverty line than in those belonging to normal (not below poverty
line)54
A study done by Rajashree Bhat et al (2011) on the morbidity pattern among the elderly
population in Ahmedabad revealed that most common morbidity of elderly was the
problems of loco-motor system (486) followed by vision (427) and hypertension
(344) In this study only 37 of elderly had psychosocial problems55
A study done by Krishnamachari Srinivasan et al (2010) in an urban area of Bangalore
revealed that 494 subjects had hypertension 323 had diabetes 281 had arthritis
279 suffered from Genitourinary and cardiovascular disease It was observed that about
25
Review of literature
49 of the respondents made less than three physician visits and 13 were hospitalized for
health related problems during the past one year 56
A study done by Kajal Srivastava et al (2010) on the morbidity pattern of the elderly in
urban Agra revealed that 9529 of the elderly were morbid in the slum areas The most
common morbidity which was seen among the elderly people residing in urban slums was
anemia which was seen in 3843 followed by cataract in 298 arthritis in 2431 and
hearing impairments in 2157The system wise distribution of the morbidity pattern
showed the most common systemic involvement was visual disorders 5216 followed by
musculoskeletal system 4784 and the gastrointestinal system 4314 The number of
morbidities was found to be increasing with age and this association with age was
statistically significant57
A study done by Abdullah Ladha et al (2009) on the health seeking behaviour of elderly
population in a poor-urban community of Karachi Pakistan revealed that 164 of the
elderly people were Diabetic and 301 had Hypertension The Common symptoms that
prompted elderly of to seek health care were fever (612) generalized body aches (434)
and cough (404) About 614 responders reported factors which deterred them from
seeking health care out of which 62 reported financial constraint as the commonest factor
Deterrence from seeking health care was associated with illiteracy and living alone58
26
Methodology METHODOLOGY
The study was conducted in the urban field practice area of JJM Medical college
Davangere The city of Davangere is situated in the central part of Karnataka state
265 km north of the state capital Bengaluru along the national highway number 4
Figure 5 Maps showing the location of Davangere district and the area where the
UHTC is located
27
Methodology
Figure 6 Map showing the Urban field practice area of JJM medical college
28
Methodology
Table 3 List of areas covered under the UHTC of JJM Medical
College Davangere
Areas covered Total population Bethur road 1374 Hedge nagar 1213 Mehboob nagar 3042 Mustafa nagar A 2093 B D layout A 1084 Mustafa nagar B 1127 Mahavir nagar 930 Muddabovi colony 1094 Maganhalli 1221 Tippu nagar 968 B D layout B 1717 Batti layout 1080
STUDY AREA The study was conducted in the urban field practice area of JJM
Medical College Davangere which consists of 12 areas with a total population of
16943
STUDY DESIGN Cross sectional study
STUDY POPULATION Persons aged 60 years and above
Total Population Covered 16943
29
Methodology
INCLUSION CRITERIA subjects aged 60 years and above living in the study area
for more than one year duration
EXCLUSION CRITERIA Subjects who we r e no t w i l l i ng t o pa r t i c ipa t e i n
t he s t udy
STUDY PERIOD 1 year from 1st December 2015 to 30th November 2016
SAMPLE SIZE As quoted by Manmohan Gupta et al 35 in the studies done in various
parts of India the prevalence of morbidity in the geriatric population ranges from 31-80
Considering the prevalence of morbidity to be about 50 in the geriatric population at 95
confidence level and allowable error of 10 and a non -response rate of 10 sample size
was calculated to be 440 using the formula
n=4pq L2
n= sample size
4= factor to achieve 95 level of confidence
p= prevalence of morbidities ie 50
q= 100- p ie 100-50 = 50
L= permissible error in the estimate of ldquoprdquo (10 of p)
n = 4 x 50 x 50 = 400
5 x 5
After calculating a non-response rate of 10 a sample size of 440 was calculated
30
Methodology
A community based cross sectional study was conducted in the urban field practice
area of JJM Medical College Davangere The Urban field practice area has a total
population of 16943 and there are 12 areas in urban field practice area of JJM Medical
College Davangere
The Study was conducted by probability proportionate sampling The sample size for each
area was derived from the formula
1198991 =119875119900119901119906119897119886119905119894119900119899 119894119899 119890119886119888ℎ 119886119903119890119886
119879119900119905119886119897 119875119900119901119906119897119886119905119894119900119899119883 119878119886119898119901119897119890 119878119894119911119890
Example 1st area has a population of 1374 so
1198991 =1374
16943119883 440 = 36
Therefore 36 elderly subjects were selected by house to house visit from 1st area Same
procedure was applied for other areas until the desired sample size of 440 was reached
MATERIALS USED FOR DATA COLLECTION
The following tools were used for data collection
Semi-structured predesigned and pre-tested questionnaire
Portable bathroom weighing machine
Stretch- resistant measuring tape
Mercury Sphygmomanometer
Others - stethoscope torch tuning fork knee hammer
ICD-10 for system wise classification of disease59
31
Methodology METHOD OF COLLECTION OF DATA After establishing rapport with the family
and explaining the data collection procedure in the local language an informed verbal
consent was obtained from each individual and data was collected using a
Predesigned semi structured questionnaire by Interview method The questionnaire
comprised of the following information socio-demographic data of the study subjects
information regarding the morbidity pattern and health seeking behaviour If there were
more than one elderly subjects in the same household then all were included
The study subjects were asked about any ho illness (communicable or non-
communicable) which they were suffering from Upon a positive response the subjects were
further asked to specify the type(s) and duration of morbidities that they were suffering
from eg heart disease diabetes gastrointestinal diseases respiratory disease etc Some
were unable to understand or answer questions due to illness In such cases help was sought
from the family members Based on the self-reported symptoms information from
hospital records and clinical examination the prevalence of different morbidities among the
study subjects was assessed The Information about the health seeking behaviour was
sought by asking the study subjects about their visits to a health facility in case of an illness
and also the type of health facility visited ( Government private or quacks )
DATA ENTRY AND ANALYSIS Data was entered and analyzed using MS Excel and
Open Epi Info version 2260 Both descriptive and inferential statistics were used Subjectrsquos
baseline characteristics were presented as frequencies and percentages Categorical
variables between the groups were compared using Chi square test and Fisherrsquos exact
test Fisherrsquos exact test was used when more than 20 cells had expected value lt 5 and any
one of the cells had expected value lt 1 All statistical analysis was carried out at 5 level
of significance and p value lt005 was considered as significant
32
Methodology ETHICAL CLEARANCE
Ethical clearance was obtained before conducting the study from the Ethical Committee of
JJM Medical college Davangere [ANNEXURE III] During the study verbal
informed consent was taken from the study subjects Assurance was given that the
confidentiality concerning their information will be maintained
Clinical Examination included
(a) General physical examination
(b) Anthropometric measurements like height and weight
(c) Systemic examination
(d) Measurement of Blood pressure
(e) Eye examination by torch and Snellenrsquos (E chart)61
(f) Hearing assessment by Rinnersquos test Webberlsquos and Absolute bone conduction
test using tuning fork 62
Parameters used in our study
Height Height was measured with a standard non-stretchable measuring tape to the
nearest 01 cm in standing position (without footwear standing upright with the
back against the wall heels together and eyes directed forward)
33
Methodology Weight Weight was measured with minimal clothing and respecting the modesty of the
individual without footwear using a calibrated standard bathroom weighing scale to the
nearest 05 kg
Body Mass Index (BMI) Using weight (in Kg) and height (in meter2) BMI was calculated by applying the formula
Body Mass Index= Weight (kg) Height (m2)
The BMI cut off values for Asians as recommended by the WHO was used in our study
Table 4 WHO Categorization of Body Mass index (BMI) for Asians 63
Measurement of Blood pressure Procedure Blood pressure was measured in the left arm in a sitting posture with the subject in a
relaxed state Standardized mercury sphygmomanometer with adult size cuff was used
The first appearance of (phase 1 of Korotkoff sounds) sound was used to define
Systolic Blood Pressure (SBP) The disappearance of sound (phase 5) was used to
define Diastolic Blood Pressure (DBP) Two readings were taken five minutes apart and
the average of the two readings was taken as the final blood pressure reading A person
was considered to be a hypertensive if he she was already diagnosed case of
hypertension and or on treatment or with a current SBP of ge 140 mm Hg or DBP ge 90 mm
Hg (JNC VII criteria)64
BODY MASS INDEX INFERENCE
lt 185 underweight
185 to 229 kg m2 Normal
23 to 249 kg m2 Overweight
ge 25 kg m2 Obese
34
Methodology
Table 5 JNC VII Classification of Blood pressure 65
BP Classification Systolic Blood Pressure Diastolic Blood Pressure
Normal lt120 lt 80
Pre Hypertension 120 ndash 139 or 80 ndash 89 Stage 1 Hypertension 140 ndash 159 or 90 ndash 99 Stage 2 Hypertension ge 160 or ge 100
Anaemia was detected by pallor of conjunctiva tongue and nails and was confirmed by
doing haemoglobin estimation using sahlirsquos hemogobinometer66
The cut off for the diagnosis of anaemia was done based on WHO classification67
Diabetes - self reported cases of diabetes were considered as diabetics for the study
STUDY VARIABLES
1 AGE - subjects aged 60 years and above were taken up for the study Age was
recorded to the nearest complete years as stated by the respondent
2 GENDER Both males and females were taken up for the study
3 EDUCATIONAL STATUS 68
i Illiterate -A person who could not read or write
ii Primary School - studied up to 4th standard
iii Higher primary- studied between 5th and 7th standard
iv Secondary school -studied between 8th and 10th standard v Intermediate- studied between 11th or 12 th standard or diploma
vi Graduate - obtained graduate degree
vii Post Graduate- obtained post graduate degree
35
Methodology
4 OCCUPATION STATUS69
i Unskilled worker
Labourer domestic servants casual worker peon sweeper porter washer-man others
(vegetable vendor)
ii Semi-skilled worker
Factory worker agriculture laborers shoemaker potters others (security guard shop
helper canteen helper
iii Skilled
Artisan clerk foreman supervisor carpenter tailor mechanic electrician railway guard
painter modeler smiths baker driver shop assistant petty trader constable soldier
linesman pointsman potter barber others (tinkering printer receptionist salesman
welder cook mason postman plumber agarbatti worker)
iv semi-professional
Teacher pharmacist social worker owner of a small business farmer others (computer
programmer Govt employee nurse)
V Professional
Doctor engineer principal lawyer Military officer senior executive business
proprietor writer scientist large employer director university professor police
officer others (horse rider)
(vi) Unemployed Presently not working retired homemakers
36
Methodology 5 SOCIO ECONOMIC STATUS
Table 6 Socio-economic status (SES)- As per modified BG Prasad Classification70
5 TYPE OF FAMILY 71
Joint Family ndash It is type of family grouping in which a number of married couples and
their children live together in the same household All the men are related by blood
and women of household are their wives unmarried girls and widows of family kinsmen
Nuclear Family - It consist of married couple and their children while they are still
regarded as dependents
Three generation family - It is a family where representatives of three generation are
living together Young married couples continue to stay with their parents and have
their own children as well
Socio-economic
status
Prasadrsquos classification
1961(Per capita income in
Rupees per month)
Modified BG Prasad classification-
updated for May 2016 ((per
capita income in Rupees per
month)
I 100 and above 6261 and above
II 50-99 3099-6260
III 30-49 1835-3098
IV 15-29 949-1834
V Below 15 lt948
37
SAMPLE SIZE ESTIMATION
SAMPLE SIZE As quoted by Manmohan Gupta et al 35 in the studies done in various
parts of India the prevalence of morbidity in the geriatric population ranges from 31-80
Considering the prevalence of morbidity to be about 50 in the geriatric population at 95
confidence level and allowable error of 10 and a non -response rate of 10 sample size
was calculated to be 440 using the formula
n=4pq L2
n= sample size
4= factor to achieve 95 level of confidence
p= prevalence of morbidities ie 50
q= 100- p ie 100-50 = 50
L= permissible error in the estimate of ldquoprdquo (10 of p)
n = 4 x 50 x 50 = 400
5 x 5
After calculating a non-response rate of 10 a sample size of 440 was calculated
A community based cross sectional study was conducted in the urban field practice area of
JJM Medical College Davangere The Urban field practice area has a total population of
16943 and there are 12 areas in urban field practice area of JJM Medical College
Davangere
The Study was conducted by probability proportionate sampling The sample size for each area
was derived from the formula
1198991 =119875119900119901119906119897119886119905119894119900119899 119894119899 119890119886119888ℎ 119886119903119890119886
119879119900119905119886119897 119875119900119901119906119897119886119905119894119900119899119883 119878119886119898119901119897119890 119878119894119911119890
Example 1st area has a population of 1374 so
1198991 =1374
16943119883 440 = 36
Therefore 36 elderly subjects were selected by house to house visit from 1st area Same
procedure was applied for other areas until the desired sample size of 440 was reached
Results
RESULTS
The results are presented under the following headings
I Socio-demographic characteristics of study subjects
II Prevalence of morbidities among the study subjects
III Details of health seeking behavior of the study subjects
38
Results
ISocio-demographic characteristics of the study subjects
Table 7 Age and sex wise distribution of the study subjects
Figure 7 Age and sex wise distribution of the study subjects
In the present study Out of 440 study subjects majority 162(368) were in the age group
of 60-64 Years followed by 109 (247) in the age group of 65-69 Years 99 (225) were
in the age group of 70-74 Years and 35 (8) were more than or equal to 80 years of age
Majority of the subjects were males 260 (59) and 180 (41) were females The mean age
of the study population was 6745 plusmn 655 Years
354 254 262
88 42
389
239 172
67 133
0102030405060708090
100
60-64 65-69 70-74 75-79 ge80
Perc
enta
ge
Age in years
Males
Females
Age group (in years)
Males Females Total
Percentage () Frequency
(n=260) Percentage ()
Frequency (n=180)
Percentage ()
60-64 92 354 70 389 162 368
65-69 66 254 43 239 109 247
70-74 68 262 31 172 99 225
75-79 23 88 12 67 35 80
ge80 11 42 24 133 35 80
Total 260 100 180 100 440 100
39
Results
Table 8 Distribution of the study subjects based on religion
Religion Frequency (n=440) Percentage ()
Hindu 188 427
Muslim 252 573
Total 440 100
Figure 8 Distribution of the study subjects based on religion
In the present study it was found that the majority of the study subject belonged to Muslim
religion 252 (573) followed by Hindus 188 (427)
0102030405060708090
100
Hindu Muslim
427
573
Perc
enta
ge
Religion of the study subjects
40
Results
Table 9 Distribution of the study subjects based on Educational status
Education Frequency (n=440) Percentage ()
Illiterate 231 525
Primary school 121 275
Higher primary 38 86
Secondary School 30 68
Intermediate 6 14
Graduate 14 32
Total 440 100
Figure 9 Distribution of the study subjects based on Educational status
In the present study it was found that the Majority of the study subjects were illiterate
231(525) 121(275) had completed education up to primary school 30(68) had
completed education up to secondary school and only 14(32) were graduates
525
275
86 68
14 32
0102030405060708090
100
Perc
enta
ge
Educational status of study subjects
41
Results Table 10 Distribution of the study subjects based on occupation
Occupation Frequency (n=440) Percentage ()
Semi-professional 2 05
Skilled worker 45 102
Semi-skilled worker 68 155
Unskilled worker 100 227
Unemployed 225 511
Total 440 100
Figure 10 Distribution of study subjects based on their occupation
In our study it was found that the majority of the study subjects 225 (511) were
unemployed followed by 100 (227) who were unskilled workers 68 (155) were semi-
skilled workers and 45 (102) were skilled workers
0102030405060708090
100
05 102 155 227
511
Perc
enta
ge
Occupation of the study subjects
42
Results Table 11 Distribution of the study subjects based on socio-economic status (Modified
BG Prasad classification 2016)
Figure 11 Distribution of the study subjects based on their socio-economic status
In our study majority of the subjects 215 (49) belonged to Class IV Socioeconomic status
followed by 115 (26) who belonged to class III and 56 (13) who belonged to class II
SES (according to Modified BG Prasad Classification 2016)
Class II 13
Class III 26
Class IV 49
Class V 12
Socio-economic status Frequency (n=440) Percentage ()
Class I 0 0
Class II 56 13
Class III 115 26
Class IV 215 49
Class V 54 12
Total 440 100
43
Results
Table 12 Distribution of the study subjects based on their marital status
Marital status Frequency (n=440) Percentage ()
Unmarried 2 05
Married 323 734
Widowwidower 115 261
Total 440 100
Figure 12 Distribution of the study subjects based on their marital status
In our study it was found that majority of the study subjects 323(734) were married
followed by 115(261) who were widowed and only 2 (05) were unmarried
0102030405060708090
100
Unmarried married Widowwidower
05
734
261 Perc
enta
ge
44
Results
Table 13 Distribution of the study subjects based on the type of family
Type of family Frequency (n=440) Percentage ()
Nuclear family 163 37
Joint family 93 21
Three generation family 184 42
Total 440 100
Figure 13 Distribution of the study subjects based on the type of family
In the present study it was found that majority of the study subjects 184 (42) lived in a
three generation family followed by 163 (37) who lived in a nuclear family and 93(21)
who lived in a Joint family
Nuclear family 37
Joint family 21
Three generation
family 42
45
Results
II Prevalence of morbidities among the study subjects
Figure 14 Distribution of the study subjects based on the BMI
In the present study it was found that out of 440 study subjects 198 (45) had a normal
BMI followed by 132 (30) who were overweight 66 (15) were obese and only 44
(10) were underweight
under weight 10
Normal 45
Overweight 30
Obese 15
46
Results
Table 14 Distribution of morbidity pattern of the study subjects based on ICD 10
classification of diseases
System involved ICD 10
Males (n=260)
Females (n=180)
Total (n=440)
No No No
Diseases of musculoskeletal system (M00 ndash M99)
184 707 130 722 314 714
Diseases of the eye and adnexa (H00 ndash H59)
139 534 80 444 219 497
Diseases of oral cavityamp salivary glands (K00 ndash K14)
90 346 64 355 154 35
Endocrine nutritional amp metabolic diseases (E00 ndash
E90)
70 269 75 417 145 329
Diseases of circulatory system (I00 ndash I99)
64 246 73 405 137 311
Diseases of respiratory system(J00 ndash J99)
64 246 37 206 101 23
Diseases of digestive system (K00 ndash K93)
57 219 30 166 87 198
Diseases of skin amp subcutaneous tissue (L00 ndash
L99)
38 146 20 111 58 132
Diseases of the ear and mastoid process (H60 ndashH95)
39 15 18 10 57 13
Diseases of genitourinary system (N00 ndash N99)
22 85 7 39 29 66
Diseases of nervous system (G00 ndash G99)
6 23 5 28 11 25
Note Total number could not be given as many subjects had multiple disorders
47
Results
Figure 15 Distribution of morbidity pattern of the study subjects based on ICD 10
classification of diseases
In the present study it was found that the majority of the subjects 314 (714) suffered
from the disorders of the musculoskeletal system followed by 219 (497) who suffered
from the disease of the eye and adnexa154 (35) suffered from the disease of the oral
cavity 145 (329) suffered from endocrine nutritional and metabolic disorders137
(311) suffered from the disease of the circulatory system 101 (229) suffered from the
disease of the respiratory system 87(198) suffered from the disease of the digestive
system 58 (132) suffered from disease of the skin 57 (13) suffered from the disease of
the ear 29 (66) suffered from the disease of the genitourinary system and only 11( 25 )
suffered from the disease of the nervous system
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
714
497
35 329 311 229
198 132 13 66
25
perc
enta
ge
48
Results
Table 15 Distribution of the study subjects based on morbidity of the musculoskeletal
system
Musculoskeletal
Disease
Males
(n=260)
Females
(n=180)
Total
(n= 440)
Statistical
Value
Knee joint pain
52 (20)
30 (167)
82 (186)
X2 = 0779
df = 1
p=03773
Back ache
30 (115)
35 (194)
65 (148) X2 = 528
df = 1
p = 0021
Joint pain (other than
knee joint pain)
52(20)
35(194)
87(198)
X2 =00206
df=1
p =0885
Non-specific aches
and pain
50(192)
30(167)
80(182)
X2=0470
df=1
p = 0492
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses
In the present study it was found that the most common morbidity of musculoskeletal
system was pain of the joints (other than the knee joint) found in 87 (198) of the subjects
followed by knee joint pain in 82 ( 186) and non-specific pains and aches were found in
80 (182) of the subjects It was found that back ache was more common in females
35(194) compared to males 30 (115) and this difference was found to be statistically
significant
49
Results
Table 16 Distribution of the study subjects based on morbidity of the eye and adnexa
Diseases of the
eye and
adnexa
Males
(n=260)
Females
(n=180)
Total
(n= 440)
Statistical
value
Cataract
112(43)
60(333)
172(391)
X2 = 4241
df=1
p = 0039
Refractive error
20(77)
14(78)
34(77)
X2= 0001
df=1
p = 0973
Others (conjunctivitis
pterygium glaucoma etc)
7(27)
6(33)
13(29)
X2=0152
df=1
p = 0696
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses
In the present study it was found that the most common morbidity of the eye was cataract
found in 172 (391) of the subjects It was more common in males 112 (43) compared to
females 60 (333) and this difference was found to be statistically significant The other
morbidities present were refractive error found in 34 (77) subjects and others which
includes conjunctivitis pterygium glaucoma etc found in 13 (29 ) subjects
50
Results
Table 17 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the oral cavity
Diseases of the
oral cavity
Males
(n =260 )
Females
(n =180 )
Total
(n = 440)
Statistical
value
Stained teeth
22 (84)
18 (10)
40 (91)
X2 =0304
df=1
p = 0581
Missing teeth
40 (154)
38 (211)
78 (177)
X2= 239
df= 1
p=0122
Caries
28 (108)
8 (44)
36 (82)
X2= 566
df= 1
p=0017
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses
In the present study it was found that the most common morbidity of the oral cavity was
missing teeth found in 78 (177 ) of the subjects followed by stained teeth found in 40
(91) of the subjects and dental caries in 36 (82) of the subjects Dental caries were
more common in males 28 (108) compared to females 8(44) and this difference was
found to be statistically significant
51
Results
Table 18 Distribution of study subjects based on endocrine nutritional and metabolic
disorders
Disorders Males
(n =260 )
Females
(n =180)
Total
(n = 440)
Statistical value
Diabetes mellitus
45 (173)
37 (206)
82 (186)
X2 = 0739
df= 1
p = 0389
Anemia
24 (92)
35 (194)
59 (134)
X2= 955
df = 1
p = 0001
Thyroid disorders
1(04)
3 (17)
4 (09)
p= 0309
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
The present study revealed that the most common disorder of the endocrine system was
diabetes mellitus found in 82 (186) of the subjects followed by the nutritional disorder of
anemia found in 59 (134) of the subjects It was seen that anemia was more common
among females 35 (194) compared to males 24 (92) This difference was found to be
statistically significant Disorders of the thyroid gland were found in 4 (09) of the subjects
being more common in females 3(17) compared to males 1 (04)
52
Results
Table 19 Distribution of the study subject based on disease of the circulatory system
Diseases of
circulatory
system
Males
(n=260 )
Females
(n =180)
Total
(n = 440)
Statistical
value
Hypertension
62 (238)
71 (394)
133 (302)
X2= 1227
df= 1
p = 0000
CAD MI
Arrhythmias
2 (08)
2 (11)
4 (09)
p =100
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
In our study it was found that the most common disease of the circulatory system was
hypertension which was found in 133 (302 ) of the subjects it was more common in
females 71 (394) compared to males 62 (239) and this difference was found to be
statistically significant The other disorders of the circulatory system were CAD MI
arrhythmias which were found only in 4 (09) of the study subjects
53
Results
Table 20 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the respiratory system
Disorders of
Respiratory
System
Males
(n=260)
Females
(n=180)
Total
(n=440)
Statistical
value
Bronchial asthma
3 (12)
3 (17)
6 (14)
p =0692
URTI
45 (173)
27 (15)
72 (164)
X2= 0413
df = 1
p = 0520
Acute Bronchitis
12 (46)
7 (39)
19 (43)
X2= 0135
df = 1
p = 0712
Pulmonary TB
4 (15)
0(00)
4 (09)
p =0148
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
Our study revealed that the most common disease of the respiratory system was URTI
(upper respiratory tract infection) found in 72 (164) subjects followed by acute bronchitis
in 19 (43 ) bronchial asthma in 6 (14) and pulmonary TB in only in 4 (09 ) subjects
Pulmonary TB was found in 4 (15) of the males whereas no females had TB however
this difference was not found to be statistically significant
54
Results
Table 21 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the digestive system
Disorders of
Gastrointestinal
system
Males
(n = 260)
Females
(n = 180)
Total
(n = 440)
Statistical value
Constipation
21(8)
6 (33)
27(61)
X2 =4155
df =1
p =0041
Gastritis
24 (92)
18 (10)
42(95)
X2= 0072
df = 1
p =0787
Bleeding per
rectum 3(12) 2(11) 5(11)
p =100
Others (Pain
abdomen
anorexia
indigestion)
9(35)
4 (22)
13 (3)
X2=0569
df =1
p=0450
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
Our study revealed that the most common disorder of the gastrointestinal system was
gastritis found in 42 (95) subjects followed by constipation in 27 ( 61) others which
include pain abdomen anorexia indigestion was found in 13 (3) and bleeding per rectum
was seen in 5 (11) It was seen that constipation was more common among males 21(8)
compared to females 6 (33) which was found to be statistically significant
55
Results
Table 22 Distribution the study subjects based on disease of the Skin and
subcutaneous tissue
Disorders of skin and
subcutaneous tissue
Males ( n = 260)
Females (n = 180)
Total (n = 440)
Statistical
value
Itching
19(73)
2(11)
21(48)
X2 =896
df=1
p = 0002
Scaling 6 (23)
3 (17)
9 (2)
p =0743
Pigmentation
5(19)
4 (22)
9 (2)
p =100
Dryness
8 (31)
11 (61)
19(43)
X2= 237
df = 1
p = 0123 Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
In the present study it was found that the most common disease of the skin was itching
which was present in 21 (48) of the study subjects followed by dryness in 19 (43) and 9
(2) of the subjects had scaling and pigmentation It was seen that itching was more
common among males 19 (73) compared to females 2 (11) and this difference was
found to be statistically significant
56
Results
Table 23 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the ear
Disease of the ear
Males
(n= 260)
Females
(n = 180)
Total
(n = 440) Statistical value
Hearing impairment
33 (126)
16 (89)
49 (111)
X2 =155
df =1
p =0212
Ear discharge
3 (12)
1 (06)
4(09)
p =0647
Tinnitus
3 (12)
1 (06)
4 (09)
p =0647
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
In the present study it was observed that hearing impairment was the most common
morbidity of the ear found in 49 (111) of the subjects though it was more common
among males 33 (126) compared to females 16 (89) the difference was not found to be
statistically significant The other disorders which affected the ear were ear discharge and
tinnitus both present in 4 (09) of the subjects
57
Results
Table 24 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the genitourinary
system
Disorders of
genitourinary system
Male
(n = 260)
Female
(n = 180)
Total
(n=440)
Statistical value
Burning micturition
2 (077)
2 (11)
4 (09)
p=100
Increased frequency of
micturition
20(77) 5(28) 25(57)
X2= 4794
df =1
p =0028 Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
In our study it was observed that the most common morbidity affecting the genitourinary
system was increased frequency of micturition in 25 (57) of the subjects followed by
burning micturition in 4 (09) of the study subjects Increased frequency of micturition was
more common among males 20 (77) compared to females 5 (28) and this difference
was found to be statistically significant
58
Results
Table 25 Distribution of the study subjects based on diseases of the Nervous system
Disease of the
nervous system Males
(n = 260)
Females
(n = 180)
Total
(n = 440)
p value
Memory loss
2 (77)
2 (11)
4 (09)
100
Stroke
2 (77)
0 (00)
2 (05)
0515
Neuritis
2 (77)
3 (17)
5 (11)
0652
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
Our study revealed that the most common disorder of the nervous system was neuritis seen
in 5 (11) of the subjects followed by memory loss in 4 (09) and stroke in 2 (05 ) of
the subjects It was observed that 2 (0 77) of males had suffered a stroke whereas none of
the females had suffered from stroke however this difference was not found to be
statistically significant
59
Results
Table 26 Association between morbidity pattern of the study subjects and their age
group
System involved 60-69Yrs
(n = 271)
70-79Yrs
(n = 134)
gt 80Yrs
(n = 35)
Total
( n = 440)
Statistical
value
Musculoskeletal
System
195 (72)
94 (70)
25 (710)
314 (714) X2= 0143
df = 2 p = 0930
Eye amp adnexa
125 (461)
69 (515)
25 (714)
219 (497) X2= 8166
df = 2 p = 0016
Oral cavity amp salivary gland
56 (207)
68 (507)
30 (857)
154 (350) X2= 7865
df = 2 p lt 00001
Endocrine nutritional amp
metabolic diseases
91 (335)
47 (35)
7 (200)
145 (329) X2= 297
df = 2 p = 0225
Circulatory
system
87 (321)
40 (298)
10 (285)
137 (311) X2= 0328
df = 2 p = 0848
Respiratory
system
64 (236)
31 (231)
6 (171)
101 (23) X2= 0738
df = 2 p = 0691
Digestive system
52 (191)
28 (210)
7 (200)
87 (191) X2= 0166
df = 2 p = 0 920
Skin and subcutaneous
tissue
43 (159)
13 (97)
2 (57)
58 (132) X2= 4831
df = 2 p = 0089
Ear amp mastoid process
27 (99)
20 (149)
10 (285)
57 (13) X2= 1018
d= 2 p = 0006
Genitourinary
system
20 (74)
8 (59)
1 (29)
29 (66) X2= 1151
df = 2 p = 0562
Nervous system
5 (18)
4 (29)
2 (57)
11 (25)
p = 0418
Figure in parenthesis indicates percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
60
Results
Table 26 shows the association between the morbidity pattern and age group of the study
subjects It is observed that the disease of the eye and adnexa increase with increasing age
and are more common in individuals above 80 years of age (714) compared to
individuals in the age group of 60-69 years (461) and 70-79 years (515) This
difference was found to be statistically significant The disease of the oral cavity were also
more common in the subjects aged 80 years and above (857) compared to individuals in
the age group of 70-79 years (507) and 60-69 years (207) this difference was also
found to be statistically significant Significant association was also found between
increasing age and disease of the ear 285 subjects aged 80 years and above suffered from
disease of the ear followed by 149 in the age group of 60-69 years and 99 in the age
group of 60-69 years
61
Results Table 27 Association between morbidity pattern of the study subjects and their
occupation
System involved Employed (n=215)
Unemployed (n=225)
Total (n=440)
Statistical value
Musculoskeletal
system
171 (795) 143 (635) 314 (714) X2 =1374 df=1
p=00002
Eye and adnexa 108 (502) 111(493) 219(497) X2= 0035 df=1
p= 0850
Oral cavityamp
salivary glands
76 (353) 78 (347) 154 (35) X2=0022 df=1
p=0880
Endocrine
nutritional amp
metabolic
disease
75 (348) 70 (311) 145 (329) X2=0708 df=1
p=0400
circulatory
system
58 (269) 79 (351) 137 (311) X2=3393 df=1
p=0065
Respiratory
system
49 (227) 52 (231) 101 (23) X2=0006 df=1
p=09363
Digestive system 45 (21) 42 (187) 87 (198) X2=0125 df=1
p=0723
Skin
subcutaneous
tissue
38 (176) 20 (88) 58 (132) X2=741 df=1
p=0006
Ear and mastoid
process
31 (144) 26 (115) 57 (13) X2=0799 df=1
p=0371
Genitourinary
system
16 (74) 13 (57) 29 (66) X2=0494 df=1
p=0481
Nervous system
2 (093) 9 (4) 11 (25) X2=425 df=1
p=0039 Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses
62
Results
Table 27 shows the association between the morbidity pattern and occupation of the study
subjects It was observed that musculoskeletal disorders were more common among the
subjects who are employed (795) compared to those who are not employed (635) and
this difference was found to be statistically significant A significant association was also
seen between the disorders of the skin and subcutaneous tissue 176 subjects who are
employed suffered from the disease of the skin and subcutaneous tissue compared to 88
who were unemployed The diseases of the nervous system were more common among
those who were unemployed (4) compared to those who were employed (093) this
difference was also found to be statistically significant
63
Results Table 28 Association between morbidity pattern of the study subjects and their
religion
System involved Hindu
(n=188)
Muslim
(n=252)
Total
(n=440)
Statistical value
Musculoskeletal system 138 (73) 176 (698) 314 (714)
X2=0668 df=1
p=0413
Eye and adnexa 100 (531) 119 (472) 219 (497) X2=1535 df=1
p= 0215
Oral cavityamp salivary glands 73 (388) 81 (321) 154 (35)
X2=211 df=1
p=0145
Endocrine nutritional amp metabolic diseases
53 (2819) 92 (365) 145 (329) X2=3371 df=1
p=0066
circulatory system 58 (269) 79 (351) 137 (311)
X2=3393 df=1
p=0065
Respiratory system
33 (176) 68 (269) 101 (229)
X2=5415 df= 1
p=0019
Digestive system 27 (144) 60 (238) 87 (198) X2=6059 df=1
p=0013
Skin subcutaneous tissue
31 (164) 27 (107) 58 (132) X2=3138 df=1
p=00765
Ear and mastoid process
28 (149) 29 (115) 57 (129) X2=1095 df=1
p=0297
Genitourinary system
16 (85) 13 (52) 29 (66) X2=1965 df=1
p=0161
Nervous system
4 (21) 7 (28) 11(25) p=0764
Figure in parenthesis indicates percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
64
Results
Table 28 shows the association between the morbidity pattern of the study subjects and their
religion In our study it was observed that the disorders of the digestive system were more
common among Muslims (238) compared to Hindus (144) this difference was found
to be statistically significant Also the disorders of the respiratory system were more
common among Muslims (269) compared to Hindus (176) This difference was also
found to be statistically significant Some of the diseases were more common among Hindus
which include the disease of the eye and adnexa (531) oral cavity (388) ear (149)
skin and subcutaneous tissue (164) and genitourinary system (85) but it was not found
to be statistically significant
65
Results
III HEATLTH SEEKING BEHAVIOR OF THE STUDY SUBJECTS
Figure16 Distribution of the study subjects based on the visit to health facility in case
of an illness
In our study it was found that that out of 440 study subjects 395(898) visited a health
facility in case of an illness whereas 45(102) did not visit any health facility in case of an
illness
898
102
health facility visitednot visited
66
Results
Table 29 Reasons cited by the study subjects for not seeking healthcare in case of an
illness
In the present study it was found that the most common reason stated by the 45 study
subjects for not seeking health care in case of an illness was that it was a mil 20 (444)
followed by lack of money stated by12 (267) the other reasons stated were no one to
accompany 7 (156) and lack of faith in health care 6 (133)
Reasons cited for not
seeking health care
Frequency (n=45)
Percentage ()
Mild discomfort 20 444
Lack of money 12 267
Lack of faith in
healthcare
6 133
No one to accompany 7 156
Total 45 100
67
Results
Table 30 Distribution of the study subjects based on the type of health facility visited
It was observed that out of 395 subjects who visited health care facility in case of an illness
229(58) Visited government hospitals 160 (405) visited private practitioners hospitals
and 6 (15) visited quacks More number of males (622) visited government hospitals
compared to females (513)
Type of health facility visited
Males
(n=241)
Females
(n=154)
Total
(n=395)
No No No
Government hospital 150 622 79 513 229 58
Private practitionershospitals 87 361 73 474 160 405
Quacks 4 17 2 13 6 15
Total 241 100 154 100 395 100
68
Results
Table 31 Association between gender and health seeking behaviour of the study
subjects
Whether visited
health facility
in case of illness
Sex
Total
n ()
p value Male
n ()
Female
n ()
Yes 241 (927) 154 (856) 395 (898) 00151
No 19 (106) 26 (144) 45 (102)
Total 260 (59) 180 (41) 440 (100)
x2=5901 df =1
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
It was observed that more number of males visited a health care facility in case of an illness
241(927) whereas only 154(856) females visited a health facility in case of an illness
This difference was found to be statistically significant
69
Results
Table 32 Association between educational status and health seeking
behaviour of the study subjects
Whether visited Health facility in case of illness
p value
Educational status(n) Yes () No ()
0000
Illiterate (231) 194 (84) 37 (16)
Primary school (121) 115 (95) 6 (49)
Higher primary (38) 37 (974) 1 (26)
Secondary school (30) 29 (967) 1 (33)
Intermediate (6) 6 (100) 0(00)
Graduate (14) 14 (100) 0(00)
Total(440) 395 (898) 45(102)
Fisherrsquos exact test
In the present study it was found that 84 of the study subjects who were illiterate visited a
health facility in case of an illness whereas 16 did not visit a health facility in case of an
illness 967 of the subjects with education up to secondary school visited the health
facility and 100 of the subjects who studied up to intermediate and with a graduate degree
visited the health facility in case of an illness This difference was found to be statistically
significant
70
Results
Table 33 Distribution of study subjects according to frequency of visits to a health care facility
Frequency of visits to a health care facility
Frequency
(n=395)
Percentage
Once a month 207 524
Once in 3 months 99 251
Once in 6 months 79 20
Once in a year 10 25
Total 395 100
In the present study it was found that out of 395 study subjects who visited a health care
facility in case of an illness 207 (524) visited a health facility every month followed by
99 (251) who visited once in 3 months 79(20) once in 6 months and 10 25 visited
the health facility once in a year
71
Discussion
DISCUSSION
I Socio-demographic characteristics
Our study was done in the urban field practice area of JJM Medical College Davangere
among 440 geriatric subjects our study aimed at assessing the morbidity pattern and health
seeking behaviour of the geriatric population in the study area
In the present study Out of 440 study subjects majority 162(368) were in the age
group of 60-64 Years followed by 109 (247) in the age group of 65-69 Years 99 (225)
in the age group of 70-74 Years and 8 were more than or equal to 80 years of age [Table
7] This was similar to a study conducted by Prakash Boraingaiah et al 72 in which majority
of the elderly (346) belongs to age group 60-64 years followed by age group 75 years and
above (259)
In our study it was also seen that 59 of the study subjects were males and 41 were
females This was similar to a study conducted by Mohan Gupta et al 35 where 573
subjects were males and 427were females Our findings were contrary to a study
conducted by Md Alam Naushad et al 28 where 598 subjects were females and 402
were males
In the present study it was found that the majority of the study subject belonged to
Muslim religion 252 (573) followed by Hindus 188 (427) there were no study subjects
who belonged to other religions like Christian Jain Sikhs etc [Table 8] similar findings
were seen in a study conducted by Mrinal Ranjan Srivastav et al 50 in which 52 of the
subjects were Muslims
72
Discussion
In the present study it was found that the Majority of the study subjects were illiterate
525 whereas 275 had completed education up to primary school 82 had completed
education up to secondary school and only 32 were graduates [Table 9] These findings
were similar to a study done by Shraddha K et al 51in which 504 of the study subjects
were illiterate
In our study it was found that the majority of the study subjects 511 were unemployed
followed by 227 who were unskilled workers 155 were semi-skilled workers and
about 105 were skilled workers [Table 10] These findings were similar to a study done
by Rajat Das Gupta et al27 al in which 481 of the study subjects were not working
In our study majority of the subjects 49 belonged to Class IV Socioeconomic status
followed by 26 who belonged to class III and 13 who belonged to class II (according to
Modified BG Prasad Classification 2016) [Table 11] Similar findings were found in a study
conducted by Sribas Goswami and Manjari Sahai 29 in which majority of the study subjects
belonged to class IV socio economic status
In our study it was found that the majority of the study subjects 734 were married
followed by 261 who were widowed and only 05 were unmarried [Table 12] These
findings were similar to a study done by L subedhi and RB Sah 40 in which 663 of the
subjects were married 322 were widowed and 07 were unmarried
In the present study it was found that majority of the study subjects 42 lived in a three
generation family followed by 37 who lived in a nuclear family and 21 who lived in a
Joint family [Table 13] These findings were similar to a study done by Swapnil Jain et al 26
in which the majority (47) of the study subjects lived in a three generation family
73
Discussion
II Prevalence of morbidities among the study subjects
In the present study it was found that majority of the subjects 45 had a normal BMI
followed by 30 who were overweight about 15 were obese and only10 were
underweight [Figure 14] Similar findings were reported in a study conducted by Khadervali
Nagoor et al 44 in which 49 subjects had a normal BMI In a study done by Vimala
Thomas et al 52 272 of the subjects were obese which was higher than the present study
In the present study it was found that the majority of the subjects suffered from the
disorders of the musculoskeletal system (714) eye and adnexa (497) oral cavity
(311) respiratory system (229) digestive system (198)disease of the skin
(132)ear(13)genitourinary system (66) nervous system (25) [Table14] Similar
findings were seen in a study done by Rajashree Bhat et al 55 in which most common
morbidity of elderly was the problems of loco-motor system (486) followed by vision
(427) CVS disorders (344) respiratory system (202) and disease of ear (179)In
this study though the prevalence of loco-motor system disorders (486) was highest
compared to other disorders it was lesser compared to our study (714) In a study done by
L subedhi and RB Sah 40 it was found that 44 had eye problems 43 had gastrointestinal
problems 33 had CVS problems and 23 had ENT problems In this study the prevalence
of gastrointestinal disorders was much higher compared to our study
In the present study joint pain (including the knee joint) was most common disorder of the
musculoskeletal system seen in 40 of the males compared to 384 in females [Table 15]
whereas in a study done by Swapnil Jain et al 26 it was found that 472 males and 528
females suffered from joint pains This could be attributed to the fact that in our study
majority of the study subjects were males
74
Discussion
In the present study it was found that the most common morbidity of the eye was cataract
found in 39 of the subjects It was more common in males 43 compared to females
333 [ Table 16]These findings were similar to a study done by Shraddha K et al 51 in
which the overall prevalence of cataract was 302 of which 42 males and 358
females had cataract
In the present study it was found that the most common morbidity of the oral cavity was
missing teeth found in 177 of the subjects [Table 17] it was similar to the findings of a
study conducted by JP Singh et al 48 in which 1475 subjects were edentulous
The present study revealed that the most common disorder of the endocrine system was
diabetes mellitus found in 186 of the subjects followed by the nutritional disorder of
anemia found in 134 of the subjects It was seen that anemia was more common among
females 194 compared to males 92 [Table 18] Kakkar R et al 45 reported similar
findings with prevalence of diabetes mellitus as 153 In a study done by Deepak Sharma
et al 47 anemia was present in 15 of the subjects 97 males and 21 females were
anemic which was similar to our study
In our study it was found that the most common disease of the circulatory system was
hypertension which was found in 302 of the subjects it was more common in females
394 compared to males 239 and this difference was found to be statistically significant
[Table 19] A study by L Subedhi and RB Sah 40 reported that the prevalence of
hypertension was more among females (333) compared to males (30) which was
statistically significant
75
Discussion
In our study the most common morbidity of the respiratory system was upper respiratory
tract infection (163) [Table20] it was similar to the study done by Leena Rahul
Salunke33 where it was reported to be 196
In our study the most common disorder of the digestive system was gastritis (95)
[Table 21] similar to the findings of JP Singh et al 48 (35) contrary to this L subedhi
and RB Sah 40 reported a high prevalence of gastritis (39) This difference could be
attributed to the difference in the interpretation of symptoms for the diagnosis of gastritis
In our study the most common disorder of the skin was itching (48) [ Table 22] which
was similar to the findings reported by JP Singh et al 48 in which 225 subjects suffered
from itching
In our study the most common disorder of the ear was impaired hearing (111) [Table
23] similar to a study by Vandana Nikumb et al 38 in which 106 subjects suffered from
hearing impairment
In our study it was observed that the most common morbidity affecting the
genitourinary system was increased frequency of micturition (57) [Table 24]
L subedhi and RB Sah40 found in their study that 143 subjects suffered from increased
frequency of micturition which was higher compared to our study
Our study revealed that 25 subjects suffered from the disorders of the nervous
system [Table 25] similar to a study conducted by Vandana Nikumb et al 38 in which
13 of the Subjects suffered from the disorders of the nervous system whereas in a
study conducted by Shilpa Shaukaiah et al36 it was found that 66 of the subjects
suffered from the disorders of the nervous system which was higher than our study
76
Discussion
It is observed that the disease of the eye and adnexa increased with increasing age and were
more common in individuals above 80 years of age (714) The disease of the oral cavity
were also more common in the subjects aged 80 years and above (857) and 285
subjects aged 80 years and above suffered from disease of the ear A significant association
was found between age and these morbidities [Table 26] Similar results were found in a
study done by Swapnil Jain et al 26 in which cataract hearing impairment and dental
problems were significantly associated with the age of the study subjects
In our study a significant association was found between occupation and the disorders of
the musculoskeletal system skin and the nervous system Disorders of the musculoskeletal
system were more common among employed subjects (795) compared to unemployed
(635) 176 subjects who were employed suffered from the disease of the skin and
subcutaneous tissue compared to 88 who were unemployed Diseases of the nervous
system were more common among those who were unemployed (4) compared to those
who were employed (093) [Table 27]
A study done by Kakkar R et al45 found that there was a significant association between the
employment status and the morbidities of the CVS arthritis and cataract CVS morbidity
was more common among those not working (164) compared to those working (36)
Arthritis was also more common among not working (212) compared to those working
(55) and cataract was also more common among those not working (175) compared to
those working (55)
77
Discussion
In our study it was observed that there was a significant association between religion and
disorders of the digestive system and respiratory system The disorders of the digestive
system were more common among Muslims (238) compared to Hindus (144) Also the
disorders of the respiratory system were more common among Muslims (269) compared
to Hindus (176) [Table 28] In a study conducted by Mrinal Ranjan Srivastav et al 50 it
was found that there was significant association between religion and the morbidities of the
genitourinary system in the urban areas The problems of the genitourinary system were
more common among Hindus (26) compared to Muslims (96)
III HEATLTH SEEKING BEHAVIOR OF THE STUDY SUBJECTS
In our study it was found that that (898) study subjects visited a health facility in case
of an illness whereas 102 did not visit any health facility in case of an illness[Figure 16]
Similar findings were seen in a study conducted by Vimala Thomas et al 52 where it was
found that 716 subjects visited a health facility Contrary to our findings a study
conducted by Bhawalkar JS et al46 showed that only 81 subjects visited a health facility in
case of an illness whereas 919 did not visit any health facility
In the present study it was found that the most common reason stated by study subjects
for not seeking health care in case of an illness was that it was a mild discomfort (444)
followed by lack of money stated by (267) other reasons stated were no one to
accompany (156) and lack of faith in health care (133) [Table 29] In a study
conducted by Deepak Sharma et al 47 it was found that the most common reasons for not
seeking health care were the following disease due to age (496) health services too far
(191) lack of money (6) no body to take to hospital (35)
78
Discussion
It was observed that out of 395 subjects who visited health care facility in case of an illness
58 Visited government hospitals 362 visited private practitioners hospitals and 15
visited quacks [Table 30] similar results were found in a study conducted by Deepak Sharma
et al 47 in which 607 went to Government hospitals 267 consulted private practitioners
and 126 took over the counter drugs In another study conducted by Rajat Das Gupta et al
27 it was found that 33 visited Government hospitals 25 visited private hospitals 6
visited private practitioners
It was observed that more number of males (927) visited a health care facility in case of
an illness whereas only 856 females visited a health facility in case of an illness [Table
31] In a study done by Man Mohan Gupta et al 35 it was found that 672 females and
651 males visited a health facility in case of illness
In the present study it was found that 848 of the study subjects who were illiterate
visited a health facility in case of an illness whereas 152 did not visit a health facility in
case of an illness A significant association was found between educational status and
gender [Table 32] In a study done by Deepak Sharma et al 47 it was found that Gender
literacy income and marital status were not found to be significantly related to health-
seeking behaviour
In the present study it was found that 524 subjects visited a health facility every month
followed by 251 who visited a health facility once in 3 months 20once in 6 months
and 25 visited a health facility once in a year[ Table 33] In a study conducted by Rajat
Das Gupta et al 27 it was found that majority of the subjects (2943) visited a health
facility once a year followed by 2813 who visited a health facility once in three months
79
Conclusion
CONCLUSION
The study revealed that some of the common morbidities among the geriatric subjects were
the disorders of the musculoskeletal system followed by the disease of the eye and adnexa
oral cavity endocrine nutritional and metabolic disorders etc some disorders like cataract
dental caries constipation and increased frequency of micturition were more common
among males whereas disease like anemia and hypertension were more common among
females A significant association was found between some of the morbidities and socio
demographic determinants like age occupation and religion
Any degree of formal schooling was found to be associated with better health seeking
behavior Majority of the subjects visited a Government health facility in case of an illness
and the main reason that was stated for not visiting a health facility was that they suffered
from mild discomfort and did not consider it necessary to visit a health facility
80
Summary
SUMMARY
Our study was done in the urban field practice area of JJM Medical College Davangere
among 440 geriatric subjects our study aimed at assessing the morbidity pattern and health
seeking behaviour of the geriatric population in the study area
The results of our study are as follows
ISocio-demographic characteristics of the study subjects
In the present study 368 subjects were in the age group of 60-64 Years
59 of the subjects were males and 41 were females
573 subjects were Muslims whereas 427 were Hindus
Majority of the subjects were illiterate (525) whereas 275 had completed
education up to primary school
It was found that the majority of the study subjects (511) were unemployed
49 subjects belonged to Class IV Socioeconomic status according to Modified BG
Prasad Classification
734 of the subjects were married
42 of the people lived in a three generation family
II Prevalence of morbidities among the study subjects
Majority of the subjects (45) had a normal BMI followed 30who were
overweight
Majority 714 subjects suffered from the disorders of the musculoskeletal system
followed by 497 who suffered from the disease of the eye and adnexa35
suffered from the disease of the oral cavity 329 suffered from endocrine
nutritional and metabolic disorders and 311 suffered from the disease of the
circulatory system 229 suffered from the disease of the respiratory system198
81
Summary
suffered from the disease of the digestive system132 suffered from disease of the
skin13 suffered from the disease of the ear66 suffered from the disease of the
genitourinary system and 25 suffered from the disease of the nervous system
The most common morbidity of musculoskeletal system was pain of the joints (other
than the knee joint) found in 198 of the subjectsBack ache was more common in
females 231 compared to males 163 and this difference was found to be
statistically significant
cataract found in 39 of the subjects It was more common in males 43 compared
to females 333 and this difference was found to be statistically significant
Missing teeth were found in 177 of the subjects Dental caries were more
common in males 108 compared to females 44 and this difference was found to
be statistically significant
Diabetes mellitus found in 186 of the subjects followed by the nutritional disorder
of anemia found in 134 of the subjects anemia was more common among females
194 compared to males 92 This difference was found to be statistically
significant
Hypertension which was found in 302 of the subjects it was more common in
females 394 compared to males 239 and this difference was found to be
statistically significant
upper respiratory tract infection) found in 163 subjects followed by acute
bronchitis in 43 bronchial asthma in 14 and pulmonary TB in only 09
Gastritis was found in 95 subjects followed by constipation in 61 Among
males (81) had constipation compared to females(03)
Most common disease of the skin was itching which was present in 48 of the
study subjects followed by dryness in 43
82
Summary
Hearing impairment was found in 111 of the subjects
Increased frequency of micturition was found in 57 of the subjects followed by
burning micturition in 09 of the study subjects Increased frequency of
micturition was more among males 77 compared to females in whom it was 28
and this difference was found to be statistically significant
The most common disorder of the nervous system was neuritis seen in 11 of the
subjects followed by memory loss in 09 and stroke in 05 of the subjects
A significant association was found between increasing age and the morbidities of
the eye ear and the oral cavity
Significant association was found between occupation and the disorders of the
musculoskeletal system skin and the nervous system Disorders of the
musculoskeletal system were more common among employed subjects (795)
compared to unemployed (635) 176 subjects who were employed suffered
from the disease of the skin and subcutaneous tissue compared to 88 who were
unemployed Diseases of the nervous system were more common among those who
were unemployed (4) compared to those who were employed (093)
It was observed that the disorders of the digestive system were more common
among Muslims (238) compared to Hindus (144) this difference was found to
be statistically significant Also the disorders of the respiratory system were more
common among Muslims (269) compared to Hindus (176) This difference
was also found to be statistically significant
83
Summary
III HEATLTH SEEKING BEHAVIOR OF THE STUDY SUBJECTS
In our study 898 subjects visited a health facility in case of an illness whereas
102 did not
The most common reason stated by study subjects for not seeking health care in case
of an illness was that it was a mild discomfort (444) followed by lack of money
stated by (267) the other reasons stated were no one to accompany (156) and
lack of faith in health care (133)
It was observed that 58 subjects Visited Government hospitals 362 visited
private practitioners hospitals and 15 visited quacks
Majority of males (927) visited a health care facility in case of an illness whereas
only 856 females visited a health facility in case of an illness This difference was
found to be statistically significant
A significant association was found between the educational status and health
seeking behaviour Majority of the educated subjects visited a health facility in case
of an illness compared to those who were illiterate
It was found that 524 subjects visited a health facility every month followed by
251 who visited a health facility once in 3 months 20once in 6 months and
25 visited a health facility once in a year
84
Limitations
LIMITATIONS
1 Many of the responses were subjective and there were no records to verify them
2 Some of the morbidities were diagnosed only by clinical examination and could not be
confirmed by performing diagnostic tests due to high cost and time constraints
3 This study was done in the urban field practice area which consisted of a closed
community hence the results cannot be generalized to the entire population of the area
85
Recommendations
RECOMMENDATIONS
1 Health education should be given to the geriatric people regarding the common health
problems associated with ageing and preventive care should be provided to the elderly
2 Geriatric clinics should be set up at the primary health care level which provide regular
screening and health check-ups
3 There should also be a provision to provide domiciliary care by specialists qualified in
geriatrics
4 The family members and the care givers of the elderly should be educated about the
common health problems of the elderly and also about the need for regular health check-ups
and emotional support
5 The majority of the geriatric population is out of work force they are suffering from
many morbidities and are totally dependent on others even for their health needs Hence the
Government should increase the pension of the elderly and provide them quality healthcare
free of cost
6 There is also a need for public private partnership to improve the quality of health
services for the geriatric people More number of NGOs should work towards improving the
health and the quality of life of the elderly
86
References
REFERENCES
1 United Nations Department of Economic and Social affairs Population Division
World population ageing 2013 Available from URL
wwwunorgendevelopmentpopulationageingWorldPopulationAgeing2013
[Accessed on 17-7-2016]
2 Khan S and Itrat M Current Issues in Geriatric Health Care in India-A Review J Community Med Health Care 2016 1(1) 1-3
3 United Nations Department of Economic and Social Affairs Population Division
World Population Ageing 2015 ndash Highlights Available from URL
wwwunorgendevelopmentdesapopulationpdfageingWPA2015_Reportpdf
[Accessed on 272017]
4 State of elderly in India 2014 Help age India Available from URL
httpswwwhelpageindiaorgimagespdfstate-elderly-india-2014pdf [Accessed on
1082017]
5 World Health Organization World report on ageing and health 2015Available
from URL wwwwhointageingeventsworld-report-2015-launchen [Accessed on
1272017]
6 National policy for Senior citizens March 2011Ministry of Social Justice and
welfare Govt of India Available from URL
socialjusticenicinwritereaddataUploadFilednpscpdf [Accessed on 482017]
87
References
7 Elderly in India Profile and programmes 2016Govt of India Ministry of statistics
and programme implementation Central Statistics Office Available from URL
wwwmopsigovin [ Accessed on 1442017]
8 Saxena V Kandpal SD Gael D Bansal S Health status of elderly community
based study Indian Journal of Community Health2012 Oct-Dec24(4)269-74
9 Shah T Patel M Shah V Health care seeking behaviour of urban and rural
community in Ahmedabad district Int J Med Sci Public Health20132908-11
10 Sahoo H Mishra NR Health Status Morbidity Pattern and Treatment Seeking
Behaviour among Elderly in India Evidence from 60th round of National Sample
Survey Data Learning community 2011 Dec 2(3) 341-55
11 Park K Parkrsquos Textbook of Preventive and social medicine 24 th ed Jabalpur MS
Banarsidas Bhanot Publishers2017631
12 UNFPA- state of World Population 2011Chapter 1 setting the scene 19-31
Available from URL httpswwwunfpaorgsitesdefaultfilesresource-
pdfUNFPA-Report-Chapter1pd [Accessed on 1082017]
13 Lal S Adarsh Pankaj Textbook of community Medicine 4th ed CBS publishers and
distributors PvtLtd2011732
14 Census of India 2001 Registrar General And Census Commissioner India
Available from URL httpwwwcensusindiagovinCensus[Accessed on
7102015]
15 SRS bulletin October 2012 Registar General of India New Delhi Available from
URL censusindiagovinvital_statisticsSRS_BulletinsSRS_Bulletin-
October_2012[Acessed on 7102015]
88
References
16 Bagchi K Healthy ageing Health and Population-Perspectives and Issues 2000
23(1)11-16
17 Salagre SB The Association of Physicians of India Chapter 177 Health Issues in
Geriatrics Available from URL
wwwapiindiaorgmedicine_update_2013chap177pd [ Accessed on 282017]
18 Ingle GK Nath A Geriatric Health in India Concerns and Solutions Indian Journal
of Community Medicine 2008 33(4)214-18
19 World Health Organization Active Ageing a policy framework 2002 Available
from httpwhqlibdocwhointhq2002who_nmh_nph_028pdf [Accessed on
1062017]
20 Inche Zainal Abidin S Sutan R Shamsuddin K Prevalence and determinants of
appropriate health seeking behaviour among known diabetics Results from a
community-based survey Advances in Epidemiology 2014 Nov 20141-6
21 Begashaw B Tessema F Gesesew HA Health Care Seeking behavior in Southwest
Ethiopia Plos one 2016 Sep 11(9)e0161014
22 MacKian S Health systems development Manchester University of Manchester
2003 A review of health seeking behavior problems and prospects
23 Metta EO Health-seeking behaviour among adults in the context of the
epidemiological transition in Southeastern Tanzania A focus on malaria and
diabetes [Groningen] University of Groningen 2016 228 Available from URL
httpswwwrugnlresearchportalfiles28737720Chapter_7pdf [Accessed on
1272017]
24 Adhikari D Rijal D Factors affecting health seeking behaviour of senior citizens of
Dharan Journal of Nobel Medical College 2015 Sep 4(1)57-63
25 Polisetty S Seepana M Morbidity profile of elderly individuals in urban
Visakhapatnam Int J Community Med Public Health 2017 4(2)2558-63
89
References
26 Jain S Kaware AC Doibale MK Shaikh S Radhey BK Mathurkar MP Morbidity
pattern among geriatric population in urban field practice area of district of
Maharashtra a cross sectional study Int J Community Med Public Health 2016
3(2)523-29
27 Gupta RD Loha A Roy S Morbidity pattern and health-seeking behaviour among
the senior citizens in a selected urban area of Bangladesh A cross-sectional study
South East Asia Journal of Public Health 2016 Jul 5(2)43-49
28 Naushad MA Verma N Bhawnani D Jain M Anand T Umate LV Morbidity
pattern and health seeking behaviour in elderly population of Raipur City
Chhattisgarh India Indian Journal of Community Health2016 Sep 28(3)236-41
29 Goswami S Sahai M A Study of Morbidity Pattern in Elderly Population European
Researcher Series A 2016103(2)119-28
30 Bardhan H Dixit AM Agarwal R Jain PK Gupta S Shukla SK Morbidity profile
of elderly population in Ghaziabad district a cross-sectional study Int J Med Sci
Public Health 2016 5(6)1098-1102
31 Maroof M Ahmad A Khalique N Ansari MA Health problems among the aged A
community based study from urban Aligarh Uttar Pradesh India Int J Community
Med Public Health 2016 Feb 3(4)944-47
32 Shankar G Sidenur B A morbidity study of elderly residing in urban field practice
area of SN medical college Bagalkot National Journal of research in community
medicine 2016 Oct-Dec 4(5) 229-34
90
References
33 Salunkhe LR Socio-demographic profile of old age people living in urban amp urban
slum areas in Maharashtra Karad A comparative study J of Evidence based Med
and Hlthcare 2015 Feb 2(5) 513-21
34 Warbhe P Rupesh W Morbidity profile health seeking behaviour and home
environment survey for adaptive measures in geriatric population-Urban community
study International Journal of Medical Research amp Health Sciences 2015 4(4)778-
82
35 Gupta M Borle AL Chhari N Gupta S Assessment of clinico-socioeconomic
status and health-care support among the elderly people aged older than 60 years in
urban population of Bhopal Central India Int J Med Sci Public Health 2015
4558-64
36 Sahukaiah S Shenoy A Vijayakumar BC An epidemiological study of prevalence
of morbidity patterns among geriatric age group in an urban slum of Mumbai Int J
Med Sci Public Health 2015 Jul 4(7)883-87
37 Shubha Davalagi B Angadi N Mahabalaraju DK Morbidity psycho-social profile
and health seeking behaviour of the elderly population in urban slums of Davangere
City India Int J Res Med Sci 2015 Nov 3(11)3288-91
38 Nikumb V Patankar F Behera A A Study of Morbidity Profile among Geriatric
Population in an Urban Area Sch J App Med Sci 2015 3(3)1365-69
91
References
39 Vishnoi BR Solanki SL Singhal G Meharda B Mishra N Morbidity profile of
elderly in urban slum of Udaipur Rajasthan Int J Oral Health Med Res 2015 May
2(1)9-12
40 Subedi L Sah RB Study of the health status of geriatric age group in Chitwan
district of Nepal Journal of Chitwan Medical College 2015 Mar 5(1)11-17
41 Noor S Krishnababu G Prasad KV Health status of Geriatric population in slums
of Rourkela Young Innovative Journal of Medical and Health Science 2015 May
5(3) 92-94
42 Sarode VM Chronic Diseases Related to Aging and Disease Prevention in Slums in
Mumbai Journal of Aging Science 2014 Jan 2 (1)1-6
43 Barman SK Lata K Ram R Ghosh N Sarker G Shahnawaz K A study of
morbidity profile of geriatric population in an urban community of Kishanganj
Bihar India Global Journal of Medicine and Public Health GJMEDPH 2014 3(1)
1-7
44 Nagoor K Srikanth BA Dudekula R Satna K Comparative study of health status
among slum and non-slum elderly population in Kadapa Region South India
Journal of Evolution of Medical and Dental Sciences 2014 Feb 3(5)1298-308
45 Kakkar R Aggarwal P Kandpal SD Bansal SK An Epidemiological study to assess
morbidity profile among geriatric population in District Dehradun Indian Journal of
Community Health 2013 May 25(1)39-44
46 Bhawalkar JS Dhone AB Jethani S Singru S Jadhav SL Adyanthaya S A study of
morbidity profile among geriatric population in an urban area J Evol Med Dent Sci
2013 Sep 9 36(2)6963-7
92
References
47 Sharma D Mazta SR Parashar A Morbidity pattern and health-seeking behaviour of
aged population residing in Shimla hills of north India A cross-sectional study
Journal of family medicine and primary care 2013 Apr2(2)188
48 Singh JP Singh S Kasturwar NB Hassan A Geriatric morbidity profile in an urban
slum Central India Indian Journal of Community Health 2013 Aug 25(2)164-70
49 Thakur RP Banerjee A Nikumb VB Health Problems among the Elderly A Cross
Sectional Study Annals of medical and health sciences research 2013 3(1)19-25
50 Mrinal RS Beena S Pratibha G Pankaj B Srivastava JP Atul B Morbidity Status
and Its Social Determinants among Elderly Population of Lucknow District India
Sch J App Med Sci 2013 1(6)758-64
51 Shraddha K Prashantha B Prakash B Study on morbidity pattern among elderly in
urban population of Mysore Karnataka India International Journal of Medicine and
Biomedical Research 2012 1(3)215-23
52 Thomas V Lavanya KM Morbidity profile and health seeking behaviour of the
elderly in urban slums of Hyderabad Andhra Pradesh India- A cross sectional study
International Journal of Current Research and Review 2012 Oct 1 4(19)174-80
53 Moe S Tha K Naing DK Htike MM Health seeking behaviour of elderly in
Myanmar International Journal of Collaborative Research on Internal Medicine and
Public Health 2012 4(8)1538-44
93
References
54 Bharati DR Pal R Rekha R Yamuna TV Kar S Radjou AN Ageing in
Puducherry South India An overview of morbidity profile Journal of pharmacy amp
bio allied sciences 2011 Oct 3(4)537
55 Bhatt R Gadhvi MS Sonaliya KN Solanki A Nayak H An epidemiological study
of the morbidity pattern among the elderly population in Ahmedabad Gujarat
National Journal of community medicine 2011 Jul 2(2)233-36
56 Srinivasan Krishnamachari Vaz Mario Thomas Tinku Prevalence of health related
disability among community dwelling urban elderly from middle socioeconomic
strata in Bangaluru India Indian Journal of Medical Research 2010 Apr 131(4)
515-21
57 Srivastava K Gupta SC Kaushal SK Chaturvedi M Morbidity profile of elderly a
cross sectional study of urban Agra Indian Journal of Community Health 2010 Jun
22(1)51-55
58 Ladha A Khan R Malik A Khan S Khan B Khan I et al The health seeking
behaviour of elderly population in a poor-urban community of Karachi Pakistan
Journal of the Pakistan Medical Association2009 Feb 59(2) 89-92
59 WHO ICD-10 version 2010 Geneva World Health Organization Available from
URL appswhointclassificationsicd10browse2010en [Accessed on 772017]
60 OpenEpi22OpenEpi (free) download Windows version Available from URL
enfreedownloadmanagerorgWindows-PCOpenEpi-FREEhtml
61 Tandon R Sinhota Parsonrsquos disease of the eye 22edNew Delhi Elsevier 98-100
62 Dhingra P L Dhingra S Disease of ear nose and throat and head and neck surgery
6th ed New Delhi Elsevier 201422
94
References
63 Aziz N Kallur SD Nirmalan PK Implications of the revised consensus body mass
indices for Asian Indians on clinical obstetric practice Journal of clinical and
diagnostic research 2014 May 8(5)OC01
64 Chobanion AV Bakris GL Black HR The seventh report of the joint national
committee on prevention detection evaluation and treatment of high blood pressure
the JNC 7 report JAMA 2003 2892560-72
65 The Seventh Report of the Joint National Committee on Prevention Detection
Evaluation and Treatment of High Blood Pressure (JNC 7) The GuidelinesUS
Department of Health and Human Services National Heart Lung and Blood
Institute Available at URL
httpswwwnhlbinihgovfilesdocsguidelinesjnc7fullpdf [ Accessed on
1282017]
66 Firkin F Chestman C Penington D Rush B De Gruchyrsquos clinical Hematology in
medical practice 5th edition New Delhi Blackwell science Ltd1989 32-47
67 Report of WHO consultation Nutritional Anaemias Geneva Switzerland World
Health Organization TRS-405 1968 Available from URL
whqlibdocwhointtrsWHO_TRS_405pdf [Accessed on 1282017]
68 National Family Health survey (NFHS-4) 2015-16 India Mumbai IIPS
2016Available from URL httpwwwnfhsindiaorg [Accessed on 4072017]
69 The Minimum Wages Act 1948 Ministry of Labour and Employment Government
of India Available from URL httplabourgovincontentinnerpagewagesphp
[Accessed on 1082017]
70 Khairnar M Wadgave U Shimpi P Updated BG Prasad socioeconomic
classification for 2016 Journal of Indian Association of Public Health Dentistry
2016 Oct 1 14(4)469
95
References
71 Tiwari P Tiwari S Mastering practicals community medicine 1st ed New Delhi
India Wolters Kluwer PvtLtd2013161-67
72 Boralingaiah P Bettappa P Kashyap S Prevalence of Psycho-Social Problems
among Elderly in Urban Population of Mysore City Karnataka India Indian journal
of psychological medicine 2012 Oct 34(4)360
96
PATIENT CONSENT FORM JJM MEDICAL COLLEGE DAVANGERE
DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY MEDICINE I the undersigned hereby give my consent
for investigations carried upon me I am satisfied with the information given about this
Clinical study titled ldquoA STUDY ON THE MORBIDITY PATTERN AND HEALTH
SEEKING BEHAVIOR AMONG THE GERIATRIC POULATION IN THE
URBAN FIELD PRACTICE AREA OF JJM MEDICAL COLLEGE
DAVANGERErdquo ldquoconducted by Dr RUCHI DHAR under the guidance of Dr VIDYA
GS Associate Professor I have been informed and explained the risks involved and I
hereby voluntarily and Unconditionally give my consent without any fear or pressure in
mentally sound and conscious state to participate in this study
DATE PATIENTrsquoS SIGNATURE
eEacuteeEacuteJA ordfEacuteEcirczAgravearingQAtildeAiAgraveAuml ordfAgraveAumlordmAacutelaquozAacutearingregAiAgraveAuml zAacuteordfAgravetUEacutegEacute
ryenAacutemiumlethordfEacuteAumlAmiumlDyensiumlPAgraveordfAgraveAumlAumlaringcurrenn ordfEacuteAumlrsup1poundiuml
ordfEacuteEcirczAgravearingQAtildeAiAgraveAumlvAgraveyenAacutecedilAgraveuEacuteUEacuteMbrvbaragraveUEacute yenAgravevAgraveaelig F PEacutefrac14AgraveUEacute cedilAgraveraquo ordfAgraveiAacutergAgraveAumlordfAgrave poundAacutepoundAgraveAuml CAzAgravegEacute
poundAgravepoundAgraveszlig
ordfEacuteEcirczAgravearingQAtildeAiAgraveAumlvAgraveyenAacutecedilAgraveuEacute ordmAacuteUAgraveAElig plusmnAgravecedilAgraveUcircccedilaQvEacuteigraveUEacuteAzAgraveAuml poundAgravepoundAgraveszligMbrvbaragraveUEacuteAiAgraveAumlpoundAgraveAumlszlig
cedilAgraveAEligasup1gAgraveAumlvEacuteUcircAtildepoundEacute J cedilAgraveOumlr Dyensiuml zAgrave ordfEacuteAEligcopyethrn yenAacutearinglpoundiumleth CAqiuml ordmEacutemacriumlUcirc sup1AtildeQAUiuml copyordmEacuteAtildelaquoAiAgraveAumlgiuml Dyensiuml zAgrave fjAiAgraveiAacutenaeligPiuml yenEacuteAEligAtildeyenAgraveAumlaringmacrEacuteAtildemicroAgravepoundiuml Epoundiuml zAgrave Csectethpoundiuml brvbarAtildemacriumlOslash yenAacuteaeligoumlaringQOumlAtildecediliuml JjAiAgraveAuml Dyensiuml ddordfAgraveAumlAuml ordfEacuteEcirczAgravearingQAtildeAiAgraveAuml ordfAgraveAumlordmAacutelaquozAacutearingregAiAgraveAuml zAacuteordfAgravetUEacutegEacute JAsect sup2AtildeparaethPEacuteAiAgraveAumlrAiAgraveAumldegegrave yenAgravejAtildePEacuteeumlUEacute Mfrac14AgraveyenAgravercedilAgraveAumlordfAgrave ordfEacuteEcirczAgravearinggAacutezAgrave qAacute|| gAgraveAumla zAgravesAgravegAgrave ordfAgraveAumlvAgraveAumlUcirc qAacute|| laquozAacutearing fJcediliumlordfAgraveiAacuteUAgraveethzAgraveplusmnAgraveethPAgravegAacutezAgrave yenEacuteAEligaeligAtildeyensEacutecedilAgravegiuml
EordfAgravegAgraveAuml poundAgravepoundAgraveUEacute F vAgraveyenAacutecedilAgraveuEacuteUEacute Mfrac14AgraveyenAgraveqAgraveAumlordfAgrave ordfAgraveAumlAumlpoundAgraveszlig yenAgraveaeligwAiEacuteAEligAzAgraveAuml
CAplusmnAgraveUAgravefrac14AgravepoundAgraveAumlszlig CxAgraveethordfAacuteUAgraveAumlordfAgraveAvEacute wfrac12sup1gAgraveAumlvAacuteUcircgEacuteDzAgraveYacutejAzAgrave poundAacutepoundAgraveAuml poundAgravepoundAgraveszlig
ordfAgraveAumlpoundAgravecedilAacutegEacute AiAgraveiAacuteordfAgraveAringzEacuteAtilde umlsAgraveAiAgraveAuml ordfAgraveAumlvAgraveAumlUcirc AiAgraveiAacutegAgrave MvAacuteUcircAiAgraveAumllaquoregegravezEacute poundAacutepoundAgraveAuml
vAgraveyenAacutecedilAgraveuEacute aQvEacuteigraveUEacuteAEligfrac14AgraveyenAgraveqAgraveregAuml MbrvbaragraveUEacuteAiAgraveAumlpoundAgraveAumlszlig cedilAgraveAEligasup1gAgraveAumlvEacuteUcircAtildepoundEacute
centpoundAacuteAPAgrave gEacuteAEligAtildeVAi
Annexures
ANNEXURE ndashIII
104
Annexures
PROFORMA
I General information
1 NAME
2 AGE
3 GENDER (a) Male (b) Female
4 MARITAL STATUS (a) Unmarried (b) Married (c) Widow Widower
(d) Divorced separated
5 LIVING ARRANGEMENT (a) with spouse (b) Spouse and children
(c) Children only (d) living alone (e) others
6 RELIGION (a) Hindu (b) Muslim (c) Christian (d) Others
7 ADDRESS
8 EDUCATION (a) illiterate (b) Primary school (c) higher primary
(d) secondary school (e)PUC diploma (e) Graduate (f) Postgraduate
9 OCCUPATION (a) professional (b) semi- professional (c) skilled worker
(d) Semi ndashskilled worker (e) unskilled worker (f) unemployed
10 CONTACT NUMBER
11 TYPE OF FAMILY (a) Joint (b) Nuclear (C) three generation
12 TOTAL NUMBER OF FAMILY MEMBERS
13 TOTAL FAMILY INCOME
14 PER CAPITA FAMILY INCOME
15 SOCIO ECONOMIC STATUS (Modified BG Prasad classification) I IIIIIIVV
16 DIET (a) Vegetarian (b) Mixed
17 Sleep (a) Disturbed if yes reason ______________ (b) Not disturbed
18 Bowel Regular Irregular
19 Bladder Regular Irregular
97
Annexures
20 HABITS (a) betel nut (b) tobacco (c) alcohol (d) smoking (e) others
If any of the habits present Duration (since when) _________
Frequency of consumption day_______
IIAssessment of morbidity based on history
1 Whether suffering from any chronic illness like (a) Type 2 DM (b) Hypertension
(c) Bronchial Asthma (d) TB (e) others
2 Whether suffering from cataract currently (a) Yes (b) No
3 Whether operated for cataract (a) Yes (b) No If Yes duration since operation____
4 MUSCULOSKELETAL SYSTEM
Whether the following symptoms are present
(a) Backache (b) Joint pain (c) restricted joint movements (d) pain in calves
(e) Others_________
5 RESPIRATORY SYSTEM
(a) Productive cough (b) non-productive cough (c) nasal discharge (d) breathlessness (e)
sore throat (f) sneezing
6 CARDIOVASCULAR SYSTEM
(a) Palpitations (b) chest pain (c) breathlessness
7 GASTROINTESTINAL SYSTEM
(a) Pain abdomen (b) lose stools (c) constipation (d) flatulence (e) heart burn
(f) Bleeding per rectum
8 EYE AND ADNEXA
(a) Watering (b) diminution of vision (c) redness
9 EAR
(a) Discharge (b) decreased hearing (c) Tinnitus
10 SKIN
(a) Itching (b) skin eruptions (c) scaling (d) pigmentation
98
Annexures
11 GENITO URINARY SYSTEM
(a) Burning micturition (b) increased frequency of micturition
12 GENERAL SYMPTOMS
(a) Fatigue (b) headache (c) fever
13 ANY OTHER COMPLAINTS (a) burning feet (b) swelling in groin
(c) Memory loss (d) insomnia
III Assessment of health seeking behaviour
1 Do you visit a health facility in case of illness (a) Yes (b) No
If yes how much time do you take to visit a health facility an case of an illness
(a) Within 24 hours (b) 24-48 hours (c) more than 48 hours
2 Which type of health facility do you visit
(a) Govt hospital (b) Private practitioners (c) over the counter drugs (e) quacks
Mention the reason for visiting the particular health facility______________________
3 Whether taking regular treatment after diagnosis ________________
If No mention the reason_______________________
4 Whether following the instructions given by the treating doctor
(a) Yes (b) no
5 cost of treatment per month in case of chronic disease
(a) lt100 (b) 100-200 (c) 200-300 (d) 300 and above
6 Person bearing the cost of treatment
(a) Self (b) spouse (c) son (d) daughter (d) outside help
7 Duration to reach the health facility
(a) less than 3o minutes (b) 30 minutes or more
8 Whether going for regular check -ups (a) Yes (b) No
If Yes duration between the check-ups_______
99
Annexures
9 Whether following self- care practices in case of chronic disease like diabetes and hypertension
(a) Yes (b) No
10 In case of healthy individuals whether getting screening tests done (a) Yes (b) No
11 Whether following any dietary modifications (a) yes (b) No
12 Whether any family member accompanies you to the health facility
If yes who (a) Son (b) daughter (c) spouse (d) others
11 Whether the family supports in following specific diet advised by the doctor
(a) Yes (b) No
12 whether family members help in reminding to take regular medication
(a) Yes (b) No
IV Physical examination
1 Personal hygiene status
S NO COMPONENT CONDITION REMARKS
1 Hair
2 Teeth
3 Bath
4 Clothes
5 Washing hand before
eating food
6 Washing hands with soap
and water after ablution
7 Nails
8 Foot wear
Remarks personal hygiene status Good fair poor
100
Annexures
2 MEASUREMENTS
(a) Weight (in Kg) ______ (b) Height (in cm) _____ (c) BMI ______
(d) Waist circumference______ (e) Hip circumference ___________
(f) Waist hip ratio_________
3 GENERAL PHYSICAL EXAMINATION
Pallor Icterus Cyanosis clubbing lymphadenopathy Oedema
Pulse rate Temp Blood Pressure
Respiratory rate
20 Examination of
Eye Oral cavity Ear
Nose Throat
SYSTEMIC EXAMINATION
Cardiovascular system Respiratory system
Per abdomen Central Nervous system
101
MASTER CHART
Annexures
ANNEXURES
International Classification of Diseases (10th Revision)
I Certain infectious and parasitic diseases (A00-B99)
II Neoplasms (C00-D48)
III Diseases of blood and blood forming organs and certain disorders
involving the immune mechanisms (D50-D89)
IV Endocrine nutritional and metabolic diseases (E00-E90)
V Mental and behavioural disorders (F00-F99)
VI Diseases of the nervous system (G00-G99)
VII Diseases of the eye and adnexa (H00-H59)
VIII Diseases of the ear and mastoid process ( H60-H95)
IX Diseases of the circulatory system (I00-I99)
X Diseases of the respiratory system ( J00-J99)
XI Diseases of the digestive system (K00-K93)
XII Diseases of the skin and subcutaneous tissue ( L00-L99)
XIII Diseases of the musculoskeletal system and connective tissue
(M00-M99)
XIV Diseases of the genitourinary system ( N00-N99)
XV Pregnancy childbirth and purperium (O00-O99)
XVI Certain conditions originating in perinatal period (P00-P96)
XVII Congenital malformations deformations and chromosomal
XVIII (S00-T98)
XIX External causes of morbidity and mortality (V01-Y98)
102
Annexures
XX Injury poisoning and certain other consequences of external causes
(S00-T98)
XXI Factors influencing health status and contact with health services
(Z00-Z99)
XXII Codes for special purpose
103
Annexures
105
Annexures
106
Annexures
107
Annexures
PHOTOS
Picture 1 Showing the investigator interviewing the study subject
Picture 2 Showing the investigator interacting with the study subject
108
Annexures
Picture 3 Showing the investigator recording the Blood pressure of the study subject
Picture 4 Showing the investigator auscultating the study subject
109
Annexures
110
ABSTRACT Background
According to census 2011 the elderly population aged 60 years and above account for 8
of total population and is projected to rise to 124 by the year 2026 Health status is an
important factor that has a significant impact on quality of life The elderly are one of the
most vulnerable and high risk groups in terms of health status and their health seeking
behaviour is crucial in any society
Objectives
1 To study the morbidity pattern among the geriatric population in the urban field
practice area of JJM Medical college Davangere
2 To assess the health seeking behaviour of the elderly residing in the study area
Methods It was a community based cross sectional study which was conducted in the urban field
practice area of JJM Medical College Davangere The total study subjects were 440
individuals aged 60 years and above Data was collected using a predesigned pre-tested
and semi- structured questionnaire Height weight and blood pressure were measured
and recorded Data was analyzed by using MS Excel and Open-Epi Info software
version 22 Statistical test employed was chi-square and Fishers exact test x
Results and Conclusion
In our study it was found that the majority of the subjects (368) were in the age group
of 60-64 years 525 were illiterate 511 were unemployed and 49 belonged to class
IV socio economic status The study revealed that the some of the common morbidities
among the geriatric subjects were the disorders of the musculoskeletal system (714)
eye and adnexa (497) oral cavity (329) endocrine nutritional and metabolic
disorders (329)etc some disorders like cataract dental caries constipation and
increased frequency of micturition were more common among males whereas disease
like anemia and hypertension were more common among females A significant
association was found between some of the morbidities and socio demographic
determinants like age occupation and religion
Any degree of formal schooling was found to be associated with better health seeking
behavior Majority of the subjects (58) visited a Government health facility in case of
an illness and the main reason that was stated for not visiting a health facility was that
they suffered from mild discomfort (444) and did not consider it necessary to visit a
health facility
Key words Geriatric urban behaviour morbidity
xi
Introduction
INTRODUCTION
ldquoA STUDY ON THE MORBIDITY PATTERN AND HEALTH SEEKING BEHAVIOUR AMONG THE GERIATRIC POPULATION IN THE URBAN FIELD
PRACTICE AREA OF JJM MEDICAL COLLEGE DAVANGERErdquo
All countries of the world are experiencing population ageing Ageing is a result of
decreasing mortality and most importantly declining fertility The global share of older
people (aged 60 years and above) has increased from 92 per cent in 1990 to 117 in
2013 and will continue to grow as a proportion of the world population reaches 211 by
20501
The lsquoNational Policy for Older Personsrsquo was adopted by the Government of India in
January 1999 and it defines a lsquosenior citizenrsquo or lsquoelderlyrsquo as a person who is aged 60 years
or above Ageing is a progressive process associated with declines in structure and
function impaired maintenance and repair systems increased susceptibility to disease and
death2
In 2015 Worldwide there were 901 million people aged 60 years or over It is
projected that their number will grow to 14 billion in 2030 which is the target date for the
SDGs and to 21 billion by 2050 There will be growth in the number of older persons aged
60 years and above between 2015 and 2030 This increase is projected to be especially
significant global phenomenon and virtually every country in the world will experience a
substantial increase including the less developed regions3 The increased life expectancy has
led to challenges in health care management The elderly suffer from various diseases which
include non-communicable disease (NCDs) like diabetes hypertension coronary heart
disease and other disorders like osteoarthritis stroke dementia osteoporosis cancer
1
Introduction enlarged prostate depression and cataract related blindness In the coming years there will
be a phenomenal growth in the population of the elderly while the family size will reduce
The disintegration of the joint family and women moving out of the household has led to the
absence of traditional caregivers for the elderly who are already a vulnerable group4
The most common cause of health problems in the old aged people is chronic diseases
Most of these problems can be prevented or delayed by engaging in healthy behaviours
Even in the advanced years of life physical activity and good nutrition can have
effective benefits on health and well-being Many health problems of old age can be
effectively managed if they are detected early enough5 The National Policy for Older
Persons was announced by the Government of India in the year 1999 The Constitution of
India under Article 41 mandates the well-being of senior citizens ldquoThe state shall
within the limits of its economic capacity and development make effective provision
for securing the right to public assistance in case of old aged peoplerdquo 6
National Council for Older Persons (NCOP) has been reconstituted and renamed as
National Council for Senior Citizens (NCSrC) in order to have a definite structure and also
regional balancing the NCOP advises the Central and State Governments on a broad range
of issues related to welfare of senior citizens and enhancement of their quality of life The
NCSrc meets at least twice a year7 The elderly suffer from multiple medical as well as
psychological problems There has already been some pioneering work on the elderly in
India but a lot more remains to be done There is an urgent need to pay attention
towards the medical and socio-economic problems that are being faced by the elderly
people in India and thus formulate strategies to bring about an improvement in their
quality of life8 The Health seeking behaviour is influenced by various factors which
include the individual self diseases and the availability and accessibility of health
2
services It is important to have knowledge regarding the health seeking behaviour of
individuals for designing health care policies and programmes so that all the possible
difficulties with early diagnosis and effective treatment can be identified and appropriate
interventions can be implemented9 As already stated the elderly are a vulnerable group as
there are psychological as well as physiological changes with increasing age and it is
difficult to cope up with the problems of ageing Some of the most common problems in old
age are cardiovascular problems arthritis respiratory problems blood pressure and so on
Therefore the study of the health status of elderly morbid conditions perceptions about
it is important to note and the health care of the elderly becomes very important since they
are more prone to illness than young people and are also more prone to domestic and other
accidents Their health and treatment seeking behaviour are most important for the
formulation of welfare programmes of the country 10
Hence this study was taken up in the urban field practice area of JJM Medical College
Davangere to assess the morbidity pattern and health seeking behaviour of the geriatric
subjects
3
Objectives
OBJECTIVES
1 To study the morbidity pattern among the geriatric population in the urban field
practice area of JJM Medical college Davangere
2 To assess the health seeking behaviour of the elderly residing in the study area
4
Review of literature
vii
REVIEW OF LITERATURE
1 Definition Geriatrics or clinical gerontology Is the term used for the care of the aged 11 The United Nations uses 60 years and above to refer to older people the same is also used
by demographers However in many developed countries the age of 65 is used as the
reference point for older persons 12
Elderly are classified in to 3 groups 13
Young old Persons in the age group of 60 years to 74 years
Old old Persons in the age group of 75 years to 84 years
Oldest old Persons above the age of 85 yrs
2 Demography of the ageing population in India
The UN defines a country as ldquoAgeingrdquo or ldquoGreying Nationrdquo where the
proportion of people over 60 reaches 7 percent to total population By 2011 India has
exceeded that proportion (80 percent) and is expected to reach 126 percent in 2025
The Indian population has increased from 361 million in 1951 to 1027 billion in 2001
and further to 121 billion in 2011 Simultaneously the number of older people has
increased from 19 million (ie 4 percent of total population) to 77 million and
further to roughly 93 million (ie 75 percent of the total) during the same time
span 14
5
Review of literature
Figure1 proportion of elderly in the Indian population by age groups 1961-2001 14
Table 1 Percentage share of elderly population (aged 60 years and above) in total
population by sex in India 15
Years Male Female Total Rural Urban
1961 55 58 56 58 47
1971 59 60 60 62 50
1981 64 66 65 68 54
1991 67 68 68 71 57
2001 71 78 75 77 67
2011 77 84 80 81 79
2004-05 69 75 72 73 70
2007-08 73 77 75 76 72
6
Review of literature
The rise in population of males was more modest from 55 percent to 71 percent while for
females there had been a steep rise from 58 percent to 78 percent during five decadal
Censuses from 1961 to 2001 In 2011 the elderly population accounted for 80 percent of
total population For males it was marginally lower at 77 percent while for females it was
84 percent According to NSSO surveys the proportion of elderly population in rural areas
was 73 percent during 2004-05 and increased up to 76 percent in 2007-08 While on the
other hand in urban areas the proportion of elderly population rose from 70 percent to 72
percent during the corresponding period It has been observed that the percentage share of
elderly to total population remained higher in rural areas than in urban areas15
Table2 Size of elderly population (aged 60+) and their share in total population in major states of India in 201115
All India and selected major states
Proportion of elderly in total population of State
Male Female Total Andhra Pradesh 83 94 88 Bihar 72 67 70 Gujarat 76 90 83 Haryana 66 76 71 Himachal Pradesh 104 103 104 Karnataka 79 89 84 Kerala 118 133 126 Madhya Pradesh 68 74 71 Maharashtra 88 97 93 Orissa 91 95 93 Punjab 91 100 95 Rajasthan 66 79 72 Tamil Nadu 102 109 105 Uttar Pradesh 66 71 68 West Bengal 82 82 82 All India 77 84 80
7
Review of literature
3 MORBIDITY PATTERN AMONG THE ELDERLY
Physiological Decline and Consequences of increasing age
Ageing i s a process of decline in biological functions affecting most physical
Systems The following systems are affected by ageing
(a) Atrophy of the Taste Buds and Loss of Teeth
With the increasing age the taste buds of the tongue get atrophied and as a result the
preference for food alters significantly There is also a considerable loss of teeth causing
difficulties in chewing food
(b) Changes in the Gastrointestinal Tract
As the age advances the walls of the intestine get atrophied and the motility is
markedly reduced (lazy intestine) The digestive enzymes secreted by the intestine are
also reduced Hence the partly digested food stays in the intestine for a longer period
As a result the common complaint of the elderly person is gas formation (flatulence)
and constipation
(c) Respiratory System
As the age advance there is progressive fibrosis of the lungs leading to reduced
oxygenation of the lungs and breathing difficulties
(d) Kidney and genitourinary System
The kidneys get smaller in size and the power of the kidneys to filter out the unwanted
waste products from the body is diminished The total amount of urine becomes less in
old age and thus the waste products are not adequately excreted from the body
8
Review of literature
(e) Urinary Bladder
Urinary bladder gets smaller in size due to shrinkage and as a result the accumulation
of urine even of a small amount leads to an urge for urination With increase in age
the valve in the bladder which controls the exit of urine from the bladder to urethra
gets atrophied and weak Involuntary leakage of urine occurs in case the bladder is full
or due to increase of pressure on bladder on sneezing or even on laughing a condition
known as urinary incontinence Incontinence is a common complaint of elder females
(f) Heart and Circulatory System
The blood vessels get rigid and quite often the vessel walls become rough with the
deposition of solid matters consisting mostly of cholesterol The heart muscles get weaker
and power to send blood throughout the body through the circulatory system gets less and
less powerful The most dangerous effect on heart is coronary heart disease especially
coronary thrombosis
(g) Muscular system
The muscles in the body get gradually atrophied with ageing and especially those
small muscles which are necessary for quick reflex action The elderly person can quite
be capable of working like a normal person and can undertake activities which require
big muscles of legs and arms But when it comes to quick movement which needs small
muscles for quick reflex movements these functions are impaired causing accidents
like slipping on wet floor of the bathroom
(h) Brain
With ageing the size of the brain gets smaller and the weight also becomes less This
however does not interfere with the function of the brain However in general the brain
cells and its fibers which carry impulses from brain to the system and upwards get
9
Review of literature
degenerated The most glaring manifestation of ageing affecting the brain is
forgetfulness and in simple terms it is inability of brain to recall the past experience
However this is common in all elderly persons
(i ) Bones
The bones become porous and fragile as age advances especially in elderly females This
condition is known as osteoporosis and leads to sustaining of fractures even after a minor
fall16
Figure 2 pathophysiology of health issues in geriatrics17
The common disease that the geriatric population suffers from are type 2 diabetes
coronary heart disease hypertension stroke chronic obstructive pulmonary disease
10
Review of literature
Alzheimerrsquos disease osteoarthritis osteoporosis prostatic hypertrophy cataracts macular
degeneration cancer etc and at the same time they are vulnerable to infections involving
respiratory (including TB) urinary and digestive tract17
In India the elderly people suffer from dual medical problems ie communicable and
nonndash communicable diseases There is also impairment of special sensory functions like
vision and hearing A decline in immunity and age-related physiological changes leads to
an increased burden of communicable diseases in the elderly A report by Indian Council
of Medical Research (ICMR) on the chronic morbidity profile in the elderly states that
hearing impairment is the most common morbidity followed by visual impairment
However different studies show varied results in the morbidity pattern18
Major chronic conditions affecting older people worldwide 19
Cardiovascular diseases (such as coronary heart disease) Diabetes Mellitus
Hypertension Stroke Cancer
Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease
Musculoskeletal conditions (such as arthritis and osteoporosis)
Mental health conditions (mostly dementia and depression)
Blindness and visual impairment
11
Review of literature
Health seeking behaviour
1 Definition
There is no common definition agreed upon by sociologists in any sociology literature
Different definitions may be used in different studies despite referring to the same activity
Sociology and literature assume that health seeking behaviour is influenced by the various
factors which include individual self or the individual diseases present and also the
availability and accessibility of health services Being dependent on these determinants and
their interactions it can be said that health care seeking behaviour is a very complex
outcome of various factors which operate at individual family and community level20
Health Seeking Behavior (HSB) refers to decision or an action taken by an individual to
maintain attain or regain good health and to prevent illness The decisions which are
made encompasses all available health care options like visiting a public or private and
modern or traditional health facility self-medication and use of home remedies or not to
utilize the available health services etc
Determining the health care seeking behavior is very important to provide a need
based health care services to the population Visiting official channels in a formally
recognized health care system has been considered as the desired Health seeking behaviour
Health seeking behavior is influenced by multiple factors including availability quality and
price of services and also social groups health views residences and personal features of the
users Peoplersquos choice of health care differs in socio demographic socio-economic and
cultural compositions and this has an effect on their health seeking behavior Urban dwellers
are generally believed to be open to new ideas and willing to try certain things on a trial and
error basis21
12
Review of literature
Health seeking behaviours two approaches
(a) Health seeking behaviours utilization of the system
This approach focuses on the actions which are taken to rectify perceived ill health and
the type of health care facility which is utilized by the people There is data which
suggests that the people visit more traditional healers and unofficial medical channels
this should be prevented and the emphasis s h o u l d b e on encouraging people to opt
first for the official channels
(b) Health seeking behaviours the process of illness response
This approach considers the factors which enable or prevent people from making
healthy choices either i n their lifestyle behaviours or use of medical care and
treatment22
Figure 3 Predicting health behaviour with social cognition models 22
13
Review of literature
2 Health belief Model of health seeking behaviour
Since lsquoHealth seekingrsquo is a conditioned behaviour any attempt which is made to
encourage people to seek health care definitely requires an understanding of their
motivation for such behaviour Only through a deeper understanding of the intricate
factors shaping behavioural practices can health promotion programmes and or
interventions successfully be introduced into the realities of the peoplersquos lives to bring
about changes in health behaviour
Behaviour change theories and models such as the Health Belief Model (HBM)
Theory of Reasoned Action (TRA) Theory of Planned Behaviour (TPB) and the
Trans theoretical model have been widely applied in public health in an attempt to
explain or predict health seeking behaviours Their use enables identification and
understanding of peoplersquos health-seeking behaviour beyond their knowledge attitudes
and practices
HBM is a health specific behavioural cognitive model This model is based on the
idea that people are more likely to change their behaviour and adhere to treatments
if they have the following perceptions (i) have a perception that they are at risk of
contracting the disease (perceived susceptibility) (ii) perception that the disease
might have an unfavorable outcome (perceived severity) (iii) perceive that the
proposed health behaviour to be both effective and practical (perceived benefits)
(iv) perceive the barriers to adopting the behaviour to be minimal (perceived
barriers)(v) perceive themselves to have the ability of applying and practicing the
specific behaviour proposed (perceived self-efficacy) and (vi) they have the cues
for motivating their actions such as internal cues (pain symptoms past experiences)
or external cues (advice from friends relatives and mass media campaigns) (cues to
14
Review of literature
action) The specificity of the HBM to health has made it suitable for use in
understanding and explaining the behaviour as well as health outcomes and this may also
explain its wider use in public health2 3
Figure 4 Health belief model components and linkages 23
3 Factors influencing health seeking behaviour
The factors affecting the health seeking behaviours are seen in various contexts which
include physical socio-economic cultural and political factors Therefore the utilization of
a health care system whether public or private formal or non- formal may depend on socio-
demographic factors social structures level of education cultural beliefs and practices and
some other factors like gender discrimination status of women economic and political
systems environmental conditions and the disease pattern and health care system itself also
have an impact on the health seeking behaviour24
15
Review of literature
REVIEW OF RELATED STUDIES
A study done by Sanjay Polisetty and Madhavi Seepana (2017) on the morbidity profile
of elderly individuals in urban Visakhapatnam revealed that of the 270 study participants
about 996 suffered from either some form of acute or chronic morbidity More than 70
of individuals suffered from eye problems of which most common problem was cataract
seen in 60 About 304 had difficulties in chewing and 256 had difficulty in hearing
Hypertension was present in 49 of individuals and 742 of Diabetics were also found to
be hypertensive25
A study done by Swapnil Jain et al (2016) on Morbidity pattern among geriatric
population in urban field practice area of a district in Maharashtra revealed 653 suffered
from hearing impairment 62 were anemic 462 had hypertension 423 had joint
pain 41 had dental problems 38 7 had cataract and 318 had chronic bronchitis It
was seen that 81 of the subjects had multiple morbidities 26
A study done by Rajat Das Gupta et al (2016) in an urban area of Bangladesh on Morbidity
pattern and health-seeking behavior among the senior citizens revealed that of the 384 study
participants 968 were suffering from at least one medical problem The commonest was
musculoskeletal problems in 8411 followed by eye problems in 8125 It was found that
all the respondents sought treatment for their health problems 33 respondents went to
Government hospitals to seek medical help 6927 respondents took prescribed
medications and 567 were satisfied with their treatment 27
16
Review of literature
A study done by Md Alam Naushad et al (2016) on Morbidity pattern and health
seeking behavior in elderly population of Raipur City Chhattisgarh revealed that the
prevalence of morbidity among elderly was 9531 Out of total morbid population some
chronic illness was present in 7049 Gastro intestinal system was involved in 8262
followed by eye in 7983 and Cardiovascular system in 5245 It was found that 3552
of the subjects sought treatment from private registered practitioners 28
A study done by Sribas Goswami and Manjari Sahai (2016) in Raipur city on Morbidity
Pattern in elderly Population revealed that out of total study population of 640 elderly
subjects 610 (9531) suffered from some morbidity Prevalence among females was
9892 whereas among males it was 9026 Out of various agencies 3552 subjects
were utilizing private facility followed by 2785 who were utilizing Government agency
2631 visited quacks and 1030 were taking treatment from other source 29
A study done by Harsh Bardhan et al (2016) on the Morbidity profile of elderly population
in Ghaziabad district revealed that in geriatric population 5008 suffered from
musculoskeletal problems 5877 had dental problems and impairment of vision was seen
in 5561 The overall prevalence of diabetes and heart disease were 10 and 122
respectively 236 subjects reported the problem of loneliness and depression
forgetfulness was also reported by 3296 As far as treatment seeking behavior is
concerned approach of elderly is quite different for different morbidities The main source
of treatment for morbidities such as hypertension respiratory urinary GIT-related and
musculoskeletal problems was quacks 30
17
Review of literature
A study done by Mohammad Maharoof et al (2016) on the health problems among
the aged in Urban Aligarh UP revealed that of the 225 study subjects 782 had cataract
followed by depression in 356 refractive error in 276 loco-motor problem in 213
and hearing loss in 138 The prevalence of hearing loss was significantly related to gender
as it was higher among females with 181 compared to males in whom it was 6931
A study done by Gowri Shankar and Bhayalaxmi Sidenur (2016) on morbidity of
elderly residing in an urban area of Bagalkot revealed that the most common morbidity was
Cataract seen in 2875 followed by musculoskeletal problems in 2813 and 2313
were known hypertensive Both diabetes mellitus and hypertension was observed in 10 of
the study subjects32
A study done by Leena Rahul Salunkhe (2015) on socio-demographic profile of old
age people living in urban amp urban slum areas in Maharashtra Karad revealed that 504
and 42 elderly suffered from arthritis in an urban area and a slum respectively Number of
diabetics were higher in urban (14) than urban slum (35) 301 of subjects from urban
area suffered from hypertension compared to 161 from urban slums Upper Respiratory
Infections was more in slum dwellers (196) than people residing in urban area (7) Acid
peptic diseases were found in 168 study subjects in urban area and 154 in slum area 33
In a study done by Warbhe Priyanka A and Warbhe Rupesh (2015) on morbidity
profile health seeking behaviour and home environment survey of the elderly in an urban
slum community it was found that 941 had 1-3 morbidities 41 had 4-6 morbidities
373 gave a history of fall and 314 had history of fracture 136 subjects had been
18
Review of literature
operated for cataract 168 had undergone a procedure for fracture and10 had undergone
a dental procedure 542 went to Urban health center (UHC) and Government hospitals for
treatment and 786 received both allopathic and Ayurvedic treatment34
A study done by Man Mohan Gupta et al (2015) on Assessment of Clinico-
socioeconomic status and health-care support among the elderly people aged older than 60
years in urban population of Bhopal revealed that 353 subjects received treatment for
their morbidities from the Government hospitals whereas 267 from private
clinichospital About 653 study subjects presented with complaints and morbidity The
common morbidities which were found in the subjects were fatigue (487) backache
(353) Obesity (393) and hypertension (247)35
In a study done by Shilpa Shaukaiah et al (2015) on prevalence of morbidity pattern
among geriatric age group in an urban slum of Mumbai it was found that body ache was the
most commonly reported symptom by 290 followed by visual problems in 2318 joint
pain in 2181 indigestion in 2045 and backache in 2045 subjects36
A study done by Shubha Davalagi B et al (2015) on morbidity psycho-social profile and
health seeking behavior of the elderly population in urban slums of Davangere City revealed
that the most common morbidity which was present in the study subjects was
musculoskeletal problems in 46 psychosocial problems were present in 31 and
respiratory problems in 23 Majority of the elderly (56) utilized government
institutions for treatment of chronic disease and 47 for treatment of acute disease The
elderly population had financial constraints and lack of accessibility in seeking health care37
19
Review of literature
A study done by Vandana Nikumb et al ( 2015) on morbidity Profile among Geriatric
Population in an Urban Area of Navi Mumbai revealed that 9312 elderly were morbid and
with increasing age the number of morbidities was found to be increasing In this study it
was found that the most common morbidity was psychosocial problems which include
stress which was present in 594 subjects followed by musculoskeletal problems in
556 and eye problems like diminished vision mostly due to cataract in 463
Hypertension dental problems respiratory problems ENT problems (hearing impairment)
and endocrine disorders like diabetes accounted for 281 219 119 106 and10
respectively38
A study done by Vishnoi BR et al (2015) on Morbidity Profile of Elderly in Urban
Slum of Udaipur Rajasthan revealed that 61 of the study subjects had impaired vision
followed by 25 who had hypertension 1533 suffered from insomnia 1467 had
anemia and 14 suffered from gastrointestinal problems The condition of females was
worse compared to males39
In a study done by L Subedhi and RB Sah (2015) on the health status of geriatric age
group in Chitwan district of Nepal it was found that of the 300 study subjects 44 had
Ophthalmic problems 43 had GIT problems 33 had CVS problems 23 had ENT
problems 1567 had metabolic disorders and 533 had mental disorders The study
highlighted a high prevalence of morbidity and health related problems in the geriatric age
group40
20
Review of literature
A study done by Sofia Noor et al (2015) on health status of geriatric population in slums
of Rourkela revealed that the morbidities among the elderly that were found to be significant
were hypertension decreased visual acuity urinary problems and insomnia Apart from
systemic morbidities 91 of the elderly also complained of fragility which includes
complex physiological deterioration and unexplained weight loss41
In a study conducted by VM Sarode (2014) on Chronic Diseases Related to Ageing and
Disease Prevention in Slums in Mumbai it was found that there were highly significant
disorders among aged women related to Skin lesion and super infection Untreated bacterial
pharyngitis acute rheumatic fever while disorders among aged men were related to
hypertension Illicit drug use diabetes and asthma It was found that 49 of elderly males
and 45 of elderly females had not sought any treatment for their illness Of the people who
had sought treatment 93 elderly males and 92 of elderly females had taken treatment
from Government hospital42
A study conducted by Sanjeev Kumar Barman et al (2014) on morbidity profile of
geriatric population in an urban slum of Kishnganj Bihar revealed that the prevalence of
anemia cataract and hypertension were quite high 6375 6125 and 5063
respectively Loss of income amp occupation along with a feeling of neglect from the family
members were the common problems among the elderly It was also found that morbidities
like arthritis loss of teeth amp dental caries along with depression had a significant association
with sex age amp educational status of the study subjects43
21
Review of literature
A study done by Khadervali Nagoor et al (2014) on the health status of elderly
population in an urban area of Kadapa revealed that out of the 200 elderly persons studied
Visual problem due to cataract and refractive errors were present in 72 of the study
subjects followed by pain in joints in 595 gastrointestinal problems in 46 and dental
problems in 44 Other morbidities were hypertension in 42 genitourinary problems in
25 dermatological problems in 235 and psychological problems in 1644
A study done by Kakkar R et al (2013) on morbidity profile among geriatric population
in District Dehradun revealed that the working geriatric group was healthy as compared to
those who were retired Hypertension was the commonest morbidity among all age groups
In the age group of 60-70 years the following morbidities were seen hypertension (306)
followed by diabetes (153) arthritis (14) CVS morbidities (14) cataract (96) and
BPH (83) Among 71-80 years age group Hypertension (287) followed by arthritis
(167) cataract (157) Diabetes (111) BPH (111) and CVS morbidities (93)45
In a study done by Bhawalkar JS et al (2013) on morbidity profile among geriatric
population in an urban area of Pune it was found that Musculoskeletal disorder was the
most common (4331) followed by eye problems (3722) and hypertension (137)It
was seen that 43 elderly population had some health problem but only 8 visited the
health facilities Among them 6 visited private practitioners and only 18 went to
municipal hospitals It was found that only 2322 elderly were taking any medications and
the most commonly used drug was anti-inflammatory drugs 2323 followed by
antihypertensive drugs 136746
22
Review of literature
A study conducted by Deepak Sharma et al (2013) on morbidity pattern and health-
seeking behavior of aged population residing in Shimla revealed that the following
morbidities were present in the study subjects hypertension was the commonest (56)
followed by Musculoskeletal problems (535) Dental problems (27) cataract (23)
anemia (15) and acid peptic disease (175) 658 of the subjects were seeking
treatment for their health problems Majority of the older people preferred allopathic
medicine (812) followed by Ayurvedic medicines (113) and homeopathic medicine
(73) for their health problems Most of the older persons preferred going to a
CHCGovernment hospital for treatment for their illness There was considerable use of
over-the-counter drug by125 of the people 47
A study done by JP Singh et al (2013) on Geriatric morbidity profile in an urban slum of
Nagpur central India revealed that the most common morbidity identified in the study
population was anemia (9650) followed by hypertension (345) arthritis (3225)
cataract (21) and diabetes (1775) More than 2 morbidities were present in 325 of
the study subjects followed by four morbidities in 3125 and two morbidities in 23548
A study conducted by RP Thakur et al (2013) on the health problems of the elderly in
central India revealed that among the elderly residing in the urban areas 384 of the urban
elderly had both dental problems and arthritis followed by anemia in 348 hypertension in
266 cataract in 252 and diabetes mellitus in 157 The prevalence of self-reported
depression was 672 among the urban female elderly when compared to 397 among the
urban females49
23
Review of literature
A study done by Mrinal Ranjan Srivastav et al (2013) on Morbidity Status and its
Social determinants among elderly population of Lucknow revealed that the most common
morbidity among the urban population was eye problems which affected 516 males and
67 females followed by CVS problems in 363 males and 395 females and GIT
problems in 315males and 382 females50
A study done by Shraddha K et al (2012) on morbidity pattern among elderly in urban
population of Mysore revealed that out of the 526 study subjects 486 suffered from the
disease of the eye and adnexa followed by 384 who suffered from endocrine and
metabolic disorders 331 suffered from the disease of the circulatory system 323 had
disease of the oral cavity and salivary glands and 302 had disease of the musculoskeletal
system 51
A study done by Vimala Thomas et al (2012) on morbidity profile and health seeking
behaviour of the elderly in urban slums of Hyderabad revealed that hypertension was the
most common morbidity in 469 followed by Arthritis in 302 Diabetes in 265
respiratory problems in 243 and Cataract in 21 For out-patient treatment 472 visited
private sectors 303 Government facility 25 RMP and 06 AYUSH clinics For in-
patient treatment 198 visited private institutions 16 visited Government institutions
while 642 did not visit either52
24
Review of literature
A study done by Soe Moe et al (2012) on health seeking behaviour of elderly in
Myanmar revealed that 35 of the male elderly perceived that they were having good
health status whereas 229 of them perceived having a poor health status 343 of female
elderly perceived that they were having good health status while 24 of them perceived
having a poor health About 49 of the elderly went to rural health center for treatment
followed by 33 who went to private practitioners 15 visited hospitals and 3 went to
more than one place for treatment53
A study done by Dharamvir Ranjan Bharati et al (2011) in Puducherry revealed that in
the urban areas about 707 of the study subjects had anemia followed by 537 who had
visual impairment and hypertension and 532 suffered from diabetes mellitus It was seen
that On univariate analysis the risk of diabetes mellitus was significantly higher among
elderly from urban areas than that among elderly from rural areas and significantly lower
risk in elderly from below poverty line than in those belonging to normal (not below poverty
line)54
A study done by Rajashree Bhat et al (2011) on the morbidity pattern among the elderly
population in Ahmedabad revealed that most common morbidity of elderly was the
problems of loco-motor system (486) followed by vision (427) and hypertension
(344) In this study only 37 of elderly had psychosocial problems55
A study done by Krishnamachari Srinivasan et al (2010) in an urban area of Bangalore
revealed that 494 subjects had hypertension 323 had diabetes 281 had arthritis
279 suffered from Genitourinary and cardiovascular disease It was observed that about
25
Review of literature
49 of the respondents made less than three physician visits and 13 were hospitalized for
health related problems during the past one year 56
A study done by Kajal Srivastava et al (2010) on the morbidity pattern of the elderly in
urban Agra revealed that 9529 of the elderly were morbid in the slum areas The most
common morbidity which was seen among the elderly people residing in urban slums was
anemia which was seen in 3843 followed by cataract in 298 arthritis in 2431 and
hearing impairments in 2157The system wise distribution of the morbidity pattern
showed the most common systemic involvement was visual disorders 5216 followed by
musculoskeletal system 4784 and the gastrointestinal system 4314 The number of
morbidities was found to be increasing with age and this association with age was
statistically significant57
A study done by Abdullah Ladha et al (2009) on the health seeking behaviour of elderly
population in a poor-urban community of Karachi Pakistan revealed that 164 of the
elderly people were Diabetic and 301 had Hypertension The Common symptoms that
prompted elderly of to seek health care were fever (612) generalized body aches (434)
and cough (404) About 614 responders reported factors which deterred them from
seeking health care out of which 62 reported financial constraint as the commonest factor
Deterrence from seeking health care was associated with illiteracy and living alone58
26
Methodology METHODOLOGY
The study was conducted in the urban field practice area of JJM Medical college
Davangere The city of Davangere is situated in the central part of Karnataka state
265 km north of the state capital Bengaluru along the national highway number 4
Figure 5 Maps showing the location of Davangere district and the area where the
UHTC is located
27
Methodology
Figure 6 Map showing the Urban field practice area of JJM medical college
28
Methodology
Table 3 List of areas covered under the UHTC of JJM Medical
College Davangere
Areas covered Total population Bethur road 1374 Hedge nagar 1213 Mehboob nagar 3042 Mustafa nagar A 2093 B D layout A 1084 Mustafa nagar B 1127 Mahavir nagar 930 Muddabovi colony 1094 Maganhalli 1221 Tippu nagar 968 B D layout B 1717 Batti layout 1080
STUDY AREA The study was conducted in the urban field practice area of JJM
Medical College Davangere which consists of 12 areas with a total population of
16943
STUDY DESIGN Cross sectional study
STUDY POPULATION Persons aged 60 years and above
Total Population Covered 16943
29
Methodology
INCLUSION CRITERIA subjects aged 60 years and above living in the study area
for more than one year duration
EXCLUSION CRITERIA Subjects who we r e no t w i l l i ng t o pa r t i c ipa t e i n
t he s t udy
STUDY PERIOD 1 year from 1st December 2015 to 30th November 2016
SAMPLE SIZE As quoted by Manmohan Gupta et al 35 in the studies done in various
parts of India the prevalence of morbidity in the geriatric population ranges from 31-80
Considering the prevalence of morbidity to be about 50 in the geriatric population at 95
confidence level and allowable error of 10 and a non -response rate of 10 sample size
was calculated to be 440 using the formula
n=4pq L2
n= sample size
4= factor to achieve 95 level of confidence
p= prevalence of morbidities ie 50
q= 100- p ie 100-50 = 50
L= permissible error in the estimate of ldquoprdquo (10 of p)
n = 4 x 50 x 50 = 400
5 x 5
After calculating a non-response rate of 10 a sample size of 440 was calculated
30
Methodology
A community based cross sectional study was conducted in the urban field practice
area of JJM Medical College Davangere The Urban field practice area has a total
population of 16943 and there are 12 areas in urban field practice area of JJM Medical
College Davangere
The Study was conducted by probability proportionate sampling The sample size for each
area was derived from the formula
1198991 =119875119900119901119906119897119886119905119894119900119899 119894119899 119890119886119888ℎ 119886119903119890119886
119879119900119905119886119897 119875119900119901119906119897119886119905119894119900119899119883 119878119886119898119901119897119890 119878119894119911119890
Example 1st area has a population of 1374 so
1198991 =1374
16943119883 440 = 36
Therefore 36 elderly subjects were selected by house to house visit from 1st area Same
procedure was applied for other areas until the desired sample size of 440 was reached
MATERIALS USED FOR DATA COLLECTION
The following tools were used for data collection
Semi-structured predesigned and pre-tested questionnaire
Portable bathroom weighing machine
Stretch- resistant measuring tape
Mercury Sphygmomanometer
Others - stethoscope torch tuning fork knee hammer
ICD-10 for system wise classification of disease59
31
Methodology METHOD OF COLLECTION OF DATA After establishing rapport with the family
and explaining the data collection procedure in the local language an informed verbal
consent was obtained from each individual and data was collected using a
Predesigned semi structured questionnaire by Interview method The questionnaire
comprised of the following information socio-demographic data of the study subjects
information regarding the morbidity pattern and health seeking behaviour If there were
more than one elderly subjects in the same household then all were included
The study subjects were asked about any ho illness (communicable or non-
communicable) which they were suffering from Upon a positive response the subjects were
further asked to specify the type(s) and duration of morbidities that they were suffering
from eg heart disease diabetes gastrointestinal diseases respiratory disease etc Some
were unable to understand or answer questions due to illness In such cases help was sought
from the family members Based on the self-reported symptoms information from
hospital records and clinical examination the prevalence of different morbidities among the
study subjects was assessed The Information about the health seeking behaviour was
sought by asking the study subjects about their visits to a health facility in case of an illness
and also the type of health facility visited ( Government private or quacks )
DATA ENTRY AND ANALYSIS Data was entered and analyzed using MS Excel and
Open Epi Info version 2260 Both descriptive and inferential statistics were used Subjectrsquos
baseline characteristics were presented as frequencies and percentages Categorical
variables between the groups were compared using Chi square test and Fisherrsquos exact
test Fisherrsquos exact test was used when more than 20 cells had expected value lt 5 and any
one of the cells had expected value lt 1 All statistical analysis was carried out at 5 level
of significance and p value lt005 was considered as significant
32
Methodology ETHICAL CLEARANCE
Ethical clearance was obtained before conducting the study from the Ethical Committee of
JJM Medical college Davangere [ANNEXURE III] During the study verbal
informed consent was taken from the study subjects Assurance was given that the
confidentiality concerning their information will be maintained
Clinical Examination included
(a) General physical examination
(b) Anthropometric measurements like height and weight
(c) Systemic examination
(d) Measurement of Blood pressure
(e) Eye examination by torch and Snellenrsquos (E chart)61
(f) Hearing assessment by Rinnersquos test Webberlsquos and Absolute bone conduction
test using tuning fork 62
Parameters used in our study
Height Height was measured with a standard non-stretchable measuring tape to the
nearest 01 cm in standing position (without footwear standing upright with the
back against the wall heels together and eyes directed forward)
33
Methodology Weight Weight was measured with minimal clothing and respecting the modesty of the
individual without footwear using a calibrated standard bathroom weighing scale to the
nearest 05 kg
Body Mass Index (BMI) Using weight (in Kg) and height (in meter2) BMI was calculated by applying the formula
Body Mass Index= Weight (kg) Height (m2)
The BMI cut off values for Asians as recommended by the WHO was used in our study
Table 4 WHO Categorization of Body Mass index (BMI) for Asians 63
Measurement of Blood pressure Procedure Blood pressure was measured in the left arm in a sitting posture with the subject in a
relaxed state Standardized mercury sphygmomanometer with adult size cuff was used
The first appearance of (phase 1 of Korotkoff sounds) sound was used to define
Systolic Blood Pressure (SBP) The disappearance of sound (phase 5) was used to
define Diastolic Blood Pressure (DBP) Two readings were taken five minutes apart and
the average of the two readings was taken as the final blood pressure reading A person
was considered to be a hypertensive if he she was already diagnosed case of
hypertension and or on treatment or with a current SBP of ge 140 mm Hg or DBP ge 90 mm
Hg (JNC VII criteria)64
BODY MASS INDEX INFERENCE
lt 185 underweight
185 to 229 kg m2 Normal
23 to 249 kg m2 Overweight
ge 25 kg m2 Obese
34
Methodology
Table 5 JNC VII Classification of Blood pressure 65
BP Classification Systolic Blood Pressure Diastolic Blood Pressure
Normal lt120 lt 80
Pre Hypertension 120 ndash 139 or 80 ndash 89 Stage 1 Hypertension 140 ndash 159 or 90 ndash 99 Stage 2 Hypertension ge 160 or ge 100
Anaemia was detected by pallor of conjunctiva tongue and nails and was confirmed by
doing haemoglobin estimation using sahlirsquos hemogobinometer66
The cut off for the diagnosis of anaemia was done based on WHO classification67
Diabetes - self reported cases of diabetes were considered as diabetics for the study
STUDY VARIABLES
1 AGE - subjects aged 60 years and above were taken up for the study Age was
recorded to the nearest complete years as stated by the respondent
2 GENDER Both males and females were taken up for the study
3 EDUCATIONAL STATUS 68
i Illiterate -A person who could not read or write
ii Primary School - studied up to 4th standard
iii Higher primary- studied between 5th and 7th standard
iv Secondary school -studied between 8th and 10th standard v Intermediate- studied between 11th or 12 th standard or diploma
vi Graduate - obtained graduate degree
vii Post Graduate- obtained post graduate degree
35
Methodology
4 OCCUPATION STATUS69
i Unskilled worker
Labourer domestic servants casual worker peon sweeper porter washer-man others
(vegetable vendor)
ii Semi-skilled worker
Factory worker agriculture laborers shoemaker potters others (security guard shop
helper canteen helper
iii Skilled
Artisan clerk foreman supervisor carpenter tailor mechanic electrician railway guard
painter modeler smiths baker driver shop assistant petty trader constable soldier
linesman pointsman potter barber others (tinkering printer receptionist salesman
welder cook mason postman plumber agarbatti worker)
iv semi-professional
Teacher pharmacist social worker owner of a small business farmer others (computer
programmer Govt employee nurse)
V Professional
Doctor engineer principal lawyer Military officer senior executive business
proprietor writer scientist large employer director university professor police
officer others (horse rider)
(vi) Unemployed Presently not working retired homemakers
36
Methodology 5 SOCIO ECONOMIC STATUS
Table 6 Socio-economic status (SES)- As per modified BG Prasad Classification70
5 TYPE OF FAMILY 71
Joint Family ndash It is type of family grouping in which a number of married couples and
their children live together in the same household All the men are related by blood
and women of household are their wives unmarried girls and widows of family kinsmen
Nuclear Family - It consist of married couple and their children while they are still
regarded as dependents
Three generation family - It is a family where representatives of three generation are
living together Young married couples continue to stay with their parents and have
their own children as well
Socio-economic
status
Prasadrsquos classification
1961(Per capita income in
Rupees per month)
Modified BG Prasad classification-
updated for May 2016 ((per
capita income in Rupees per
month)
I 100 and above 6261 and above
II 50-99 3099-6260
III 30-49 1835-3098
IV 15-29 949-1834
V Below 15 lt948
37
SAMPLE SIZE ESTIMATION
SAMPLE SIZE As quoted by Manmohan Gupta et al 35 in the studies done in various
parts of India the prevalence of morbidity in the geriatric population ranges from 31-80
Considering the prevalence of morbidity to be about 50 in the geriatric population at 95
confidence level and allowable error of 10 and a non -response rate of 10 sample size
was calculated to be 440 using the formula
n=4pq L2
n= sample size
4= factor to achieve 95 level of confidence
p= prevalence of morbidities ie 50
q= 100- p ie 100-50 = 50
L= permissible error in the estimate of ldquoprdquo (10 of p)
n = 4 x 50 x 50 = 400
5 x 5
After calculating a non-response rate of 10 a sample size of 440 was calculated
A community based cross sectional study was conducted in the urban field practice area of
JJM Medical College Davangere The Urban field practice area has a total population of
16943 and there are 12 areas in urban field practice area of JJM Medical College
Davangere
The Study was conducted by probability proportionate sampling The sample size for each area
was derived from the formula
1198991 =119875119900119901119906119897119886119905119894119900119899 119894119899 119890119886119888ℎ 119886119903119890119886
119879119900119905119886119897 119875119900119901119906119897119886119905119894119900119899119883 119878119886119898119901119897119890 119878119894119911119890
Example 1st area has a population of 1374 so
1198991 =1374
16943119883 440 = 36
Therefore 36 elderly subjects were selected by house to house visit from 1st area Same
procedure was applied for other areas until the desired sample size of 440 was reached
Results
RESULTS
The results are presented under the following headings
I Socio-demographic characteristics of study subjects
II Prevalence of morbidities among the study subjects
III Details of health seeking behavior of the study subjects
38
Results
ISocio-demographic characteristics of the study subjects
Table 7 Age and sex wise distribution of the study subjects
Figure 7 Age and sex wise distribution of the study subjects
In the present study Out of 440 study subjects majority 162(368) were in the age group
of 60-64 Years followed by 109 (247) in the age group of 65-69 Years 99 (225) were
in the age group of 70-74 Years and 35 (8) were more than or equal to 80 years of age
Majority of the subjects were males 260 (59) and 180 (41) were females The mean age
of the study population was 6745 plusmn 655 Years
354 254 262
88 42
389
239 172
67 133
0102030405060708090
100
60-64 65-69 70-74 75-79 ge80
Perc
enta
ge
Age in years
Males
Females
Age group (in years)
Males Females Total
Percentage () Frequency
(n=260) Percentage ()
Frequency (n=180)
Percentage ()
60-64 92 354 70 389 162 368
65-69 66 254 43 239 109 247
70-74 68 262 31 172 99 225
75-79 23 88 12 67 35 80
ge80 11 42 24 133 35 80
Total 260 100 180 100 440 100
39
Results
Table 8 Distribution of the study subjects based on religion
Religion Frequency (n=440) Percentage ()
Hindu 188 427
Muslim 252 573
Total 440 100
Figure 8 Distribution of the study subjects based on religion
In the present study it was found that the majority of the study subject belonged to Muslim
religion 252 (573) followed by Hindus 188 (427)
0102030405060708090
100
Hindu Muslim
427
573
Perc
enta
ge
Religion of the study subjects
40
Results
Table 9 Distribution of the study subjects based on Educational status
Education Frequency (n=440) Percentage ()
Illiterate 231 525
Primary school 121 275
Higher primary 38 86
Secondary School 30 68
Intermediate 6 14
Graduate 14 32
Total 440 100
Figure 9 Distribution of the study subjects based on Educational status
In the present study it was found that the Majority of the study subjects were illiterate
231(525) 121(275) had completed education up to primary school 30(68) had
completed education up to secondary school and only 14(32) were graduates
525
275
86 68
14 32
0102030405060708090
100
Perc
enta
ge
Educational status of study subjects
41
Results Table 10 Distribution of the study subjects based on occupation
Occupation Frequency (n=440) Percentage ()
Semi-professional 2 05
Skilled worker 45 102
Semi-skilled worker 68 155
Unskilled worker 100 227
Unemployed 225 511
Total 440 100
Figure 10 Distribution of study subjects based on their occupation
In our study it was found that the majority of the study subjects 225 (511) were
unemployed followed by 100 (227) who were unskilled workers 68 (155) were semi-
skilled workers and 45 (102) were skilled workers
0102030405060708090
100
05 102 155 227
511
Perc
enta
ge
Occupation of the study subjects
42
Results Table 11 Distribution of the study subjects based on socio-economic status (Modified
BG Prasad classification 2016)
Figure 11 Distribution of the study subjects based on their socio-economic status
In our study majority of the subjects 215 (49) belonged to Class IV Socioeconomic status
followed by 115 (26) who belonged to class III and 56 (13) who belonged to class II
SES (according to Modified BG Prasad Classification 2016)
Class II 13
Class III 26
Class IV 49
Class V 12
Socio-economic status Frequency (n=440) Percentage ()
Class I 0 0
Class II 56 13
Class III 115 26
Class IV 215 49
Class V 54 12
Total 440 100
43
Results
Table 12 Distribution of the study subjects based on their marital status
Marital status Frequency (n=440) Percentage ()
Unmarried 2 05
Married 323 734
Widowwidower 115 261
Total 440 100
Figure 12 Distribution of the study subjects based on their marital status
In our study it was found that majority of the study subjects 323(734) were married
followed by 115(261) who were widowed and only 2 (05) were unmarried
0102030405060708090
100
Unmarried married Widowwidower
05
734
261 Perc
enta
ge
44
Results
Table 13 Distribution of the study subjects based on the type of family
Type of family Frequency (n=440) Percentage ()
Nuclear family 163 37
Joint family 93 21
Three generation family 184 42
Total 440 100
Figure 13 Distribution of the study subjects based on the type of family
In the present study it was found that majority of the study subjects 184 (42) lived in a
three generation family followed by 163 (37) who lived in a nuclear family and 93(21)
who lived in a Joint family
Nuclear family 37
Joint family 21
Three generation
family 42
45
Results
II Prevalence of morbidities among the study subjects
Figure 14 Distribution of the study subjects based on the BMI
In the present study it was found that out of 440 study subjects 198 (45) had a normal
BMI followed by 132 (30) who were overweight 66 (15) were obese and only 44
(10) were underweight
under weight 10
Normal 45
Overweight 30
Obese 15
46
Results
Table 14 Distribution of morbidity pattern of the study subjects based on ICD 10
classification of diseases
System involved ICD 10
Males (n=260)
Females (n=180)
Total (n=440)
No No No
Diseases of musculoskeletal system (M00 ndash M99)
184 707 130 722 314 714
Diseases of the eye and adnexa (H00 ndash H59)
139 534 80 444 219 497
Diseases of oral cavityamp salivary glands (K00 ndash K14)
90 346 64 355 154 35
Endocrine nutritional amp metabolic diseases (E00 ndash
E90)
70 269 75 417 145 329
Diseases of circulatory system (I00 ndash I99)
64 246 73 405 137 311
Diseases of respiratory system(J00 ndash J99)
64 246 37 206 101 23
Diseases of digestive system (K00 ndash K93)
57 219 30 166 87 198
Diseases of skin amp subcutaneous tissue (L00 ndash
L99)
38 146 20 111 58 132
Diseases of the ear and mastoid process (H60 ndashH95)
39 15 18 10 57 13
Diseases of genitourinary system (N00 ndash N99)
22 85 7 39 29 66
Diseases of nervous system (G00 ndash G99)
6 23 5 28 11 25
Note Total number could not be given as many subjects had multiple disorders
47
Results
Figure 15 Distribution of morbidity pattern of the study subjects based on ICD 10
classification of diseases
In the present study it was found that the majority of the subjects 314 (714) suffered
from the disorders of the musculoskeletal system followed by 219 (497) who suffered
from the disease of the eye and adnexa154 (35) suffered from the disease of the oral
cavity 145 (329) suffered from endocrine nutritional and metabolic disorders137
(311) suffered from the disease of the circulatory system 101 (229) suffered from the
disease of the respiratory system 87(198) suffered from the disease of the digestive
system 58 (132) suffered from disease of the skin 57 (13) suffered from the disease of
the ear 29 (66) suffered from the disease of the genitourinary system and only 11( 25 )
suffered from the disease of the nervous system
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
714
497
35 329 311 229
198 132 13 66
25
perc
enta
ge
48
Results
Table 15 Distribution of the study subjects based on morbidity of the musculoskeletal
system
Musculoskeletal
Disease
Males
(n=260)
Females
(n=180)
Total
(n= 440)
Statistical
Value
Knee joint pain
52 (20)
30 (167)
82 (186)
X2 = 0779
df = 1
p=03773
Back ache
30 (115)
35 (194)
65 (148) X2 = 528
df = 1
p = 0021
Joint pain (other than
knee joint pain)
52(20)
35(194)
87(198)
X2 =00206
df=1
p =0885
Non-specific aches
and pain
50(192)
30(167)
80(182)
X2=0470
df=1
p = 0492
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses
In the present study it was found that the most common morbidity of musculoskeletal
system was pain of the joints (other than the knee joint) found in 87 (198) of the subjects
followed by knee joint pain in 82 ( 186) and non-specific pains and aches were found in
80 (182) of the subjects It was found that back ache was more common in females
35(194) compared to males 30 (115) and this difference was found to be statistically
significant
49
Results
Table 16 Distribution of the study subjects based on morbidity of the eye and adnexa
Diseases of the
eye and
adnexa
Males
(n=260)
Females
(n=180)
Total
(n= 440)
Statistical
value
Cataract
112(43)
60(333)
172(391)
X2 = 4241
df=1
p = 0039
Refractive error
20(77)
14(78)
34(77)
X2= 0001
df=1
p = 0973
Others (conjunctivitis
pterygium glaucoma etc)
7(27)
6(33)
13(29)
X2=0152
df=1
p = 0696
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses
In the present study it was found that the most common morbidity of the eye was cataract
found in 172 (391) of the subjects It was more common in males 112 (43) compared to
females 60 (333) and this difference was found to be statistically significant The other
morbidities present were refractive error found in 34 (77) subjects and others which
includes conjunctivitis pterygium glaucoma etc found in 13 (29 ) subjects
50
Results
Table 17 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the oral cavity
Diseases of the
oral cavity
Males
(n =260 )
Females
(n =180 )
Total
(n = 440)
Statistical
value
Stained teeth
22 (84)
18 (10)
40 (91)
X2 =0304
df=1
p = 0581
Missing teeth
40 (154)
38 (211)
78 (177)
X2= 239
df= 1
p=0122
Caries
28 (108)
8 (44)
36 (82)
X2= 566
df= 1
p=0017
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses
In the present study it was found that the most common morbidity of the oral cavity was
missing teeth found in 78 (177 ) of the subjects followed by stained teeth found in 40
(91) of the subjects and dental caries in 36 (82) of the subjects Dental caries were
more common in males 28 (108) compared to females 8(44) and this difference was
found to be statistically significant
51
Results
Table 18 Distribution of study subjects based on endocrine nutritional and metabolic
disorders
Disorders Males
(n =260 )
Females
(n =180)
Total
(n = 440)
Statistical value
Diabetes mellitus
45 (173)
37 (206)
82 (186)
X2 = 0739
df= 1
p = 0389
Anemia
24 (92)
35 (194)
59 (134)
X2= 955
df = 1
p = 0001
Thyroid disorders
1(04)
3 (17)
4 (09)
p= 0309
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
The present study revealed that the most common disorder of the endocrine system was
diabetes mellitus found in 82 (186) of the subjects followed by the nutritional disorder of
anemia found in 59 (134) of the subjects It was seen that anemia was more common
among females 35 (194) compared to males 24 (92) This difference was found to be
statistically significant Disorders of the thyroid gland were found in 4 (09) of the subjects
being more common in females 3(17) compared to males 1 (04)
52
Results
Table 19 Distribution of the study subject based on disease of the circulatory system
Diseases of
circulatory
system
Males
(n=260 )
Females
(n =180)
Total
(n = 440)
Statistical
value
Hypertension
62 (238)
71 (394)
133 (302)
X2= 1227
df= 1
p = 0000
CAD MI
Arrhythmias
2 (08)
2 (11)
4 (09)
p =100
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
In our study it was found that the most common disease of the circulatory system was
hypertension which was found in 133 (302 ) of the subjects it was more common in
females 71 (394) compared to males 62 (239) and this difference was found to be
statistically significant The other disorders of the circulatory system were CAD MI
arrhythmias which were found only in 4 (09) of the study subjects
53
Results
Table 20 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the respiratory system
Disorders of
Respiratory
System
Males
(n=260)
Females
(n=180)
Total
(n=440)
Statistical
value
Bronchial asthma
3 (12)
3 (17)
6 (14)
p =0692
URTI
45 (173)
27 (15)
72 (164)
X2= 0413
df = 1
p = 0520
Acute Bronchitis
12 (46)
7 (39)
19 (43)
X2= 0135
df = 1
p = 0712
Pulmonary TB
4 (15)
0(00)
4 (09)
p =0148
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
Our study revealed that the most common disease of the respiratory system was URTI
(upper respiratory tract infection) found in 72 (164) subjects followed by acute bronchitis
in 19 (43 ) bronchial asthma in 6 (14) and pulmonary TB in only in 4 (09 ) subjects
Pulmonary TB was found in 4 (15) of the males whereas no females had TB however
this difference was not found to be statistically significant
54
Results
Table 21 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the digestive system
Disorders of
Gastrointestinal
system
Males
(n = 260)
Females
(n = 180)
Total
(n = 440)
Statistical value
Constipation
21(8)
6 (33)
27(61)
X2 =4155
df =1
p =0041
Gastritis
24 (92)
18 (10)
42(95)
X2= 0072
df = 1
p =0787
Bleeding per
rectum 3(12) 2(11) 5(11)
p =100
Others (Pain
abdomen
anorexia
indigestion)
9(35)
4 (22)
13 (3)
X2=0569
df =1
p=0450
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
Our study revealed that the most common disorder of the gastrointestinal system was
gastritis found in 42 (95) subjects followed by constipation in 27 ( 61) others which
include pain abdomen anorexia indigestion was found in 13 (3) and bleeding per rectum
was seen in 5 (11) It was seen that constipation was more common among males 21(8)
compared to females 6 (33) which was found to be statistically significant
55
Results
Table 22 Distribution the study subjects based on disease of the Skin and
subcutaneous tissue
Disorders of skin and
subcutaneous tissue
Males ( n = 260)
Females (n = 180)
Total (n = 440)
Statistical
value
Itching
19(73)
2(11)
21(48)
X2 =896
df=1
p = 0002
Scaling 6 (23)
3 (17)
9 (2)
p =0743
Pigmentation
5(19)
4 (22)
9 (2)
p =100
Dryness
8 (31)
11 (61)
19(43)
X2= 237
df = 1
p = 0123 Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
In the present study it was found that the most common disease of the skin was itching
which was present in 21 (48) of the study subjects followed by dryness in 19 (43) and 9
(2) of the subjects had scaling and pigmentation It was seen that itching was more
common among males 19 (73) compared to females 2 (11) and this difference was
found to be statistically significant
56
Results
Table 23 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the ear
Disease of the ear
Males
(n= 260)
Females
(n = 180)
Total
(n = 440) Statistical value
Hearing impairment
33 (126)
16 (89)
49 (111)
X2 =155
df =1
p =0212
Ear discharge
3 (12)
1 (06)
4(09)
p =0647
Tinnitus
3 (12)
1 (06)
4 (09)
p =0647
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
In the present study it was observed that hearing impairment was the most common
morbidity of the ear found in 49 (111) of the subjects though it was more common
among males 33 (126) compared to females 16 (89) the difference was not found to be
statistically significant The other disorders which affected the ear were ear discharge and
tinnitus both present in 4 (09) of the subjects
57
Results
Table 24 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the genitourinary
system
Disorders of
genitourinary system
Male
(n = 260)
Female
(n = 180)
Total
(n=440)
Statistical value
Burning micturition
2 (077)
2 (11)
4 (09)
p=100
Increased frequency of
micturition
20(77) 5(28) 25(57)
X2= 4794
df =1
p =0028 Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
In our study it was observed that the most common morbidity affecting the genitourinary
system was increased frequency of micturition in 25 (57) of the subjects followed by
burning micturition in 4 (09) of the study subjects Increased frequency of micturition was
more common among males 20 (77) compared to females 5 (28) and this difference
was found to be statistically significant
58
Results
Table 25 Distribution of the study subjects based on diseases of the Nervous system
Disease of the
nervous system Males
(n = 260)
Females
(n = 180)
Total
(n = 440)
p value
Memory loss
2 (77)
2 (11)
4 (09)
100
Stroke
2 (77)
0 (00)
2 (05)
0515
Neuritis
2 (77)
3 (17)
5 (11)
0652
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
Our study revealed that the most common disorder of the nervous system was neuritis seen
in 5 (11) of the subjects followed by memory loss in 4 (09) and stroke in 2 (05 ) of
the subjects It was observed that 2 (0 77) of males had suffered a stroke whereas none of
the females had suffered from stroke however this difference was not found to be
statistically significant
59
Results
Table 26 Association between morbidity pattern of the study subjects and their age
group
System involved 60-69Yrs
(n = 271)
70-79Yrs
(n = 134)
gt 80Yrs
(n = 35)
Total
( n = 440)
Statistical
value
Musculoskeletal
System
195 (72)
94 (70)
25 (710)
314 (714) X2= 0143
df = 2 p = 0930
Eye amp adnexa
125 (461)
69 (515)
25 (714)
219 (497) X2= 8166
df = 2 p = 0016
Oral cavity amp salivary gland
56 (207)
68 (507)
30 (857)
154 (350) X2= 7865
df = 2 p lt 00001
Endocrine nutritional amp
metabolic diseases
91 (335)
47 (35)
7 (200)
145 (329) X2= 297
df = 2 p = 0225
Circulatory
system
87 (321)
40 (298)
10 (285)
137 (311) X2= 0328
df = 2 p = 0848
Respiratory
system
64 (236)
31 (231)
6 (171)
101 (23) X2= 0738
df = 2 p = 0691
Digestive system
52 (191)
28 (210)
7 (200)
87 (191) X2= 0166
df = 2 p = 0 920
Skin and subcutaneous
tissue
43 (159)
13 (97)
2 (57)
58 (132) X2= 4831
df = 2 p = 0089
Ear amp mastoid process
27 (99)
20 (149)
10 (285)
57 (13) X2= 1018
d= 2 p = 0006
Genitourinary
system
20 (74)
8 (59)
1 (29)
29 (66) X2= 1151
df = 2 p = 0562
Nervous system
5 (18)
4 (29)
2 (57)
11 (25)
p = 0418
Figure in parenthesis indicates percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
60
Results
Table 26 shows the association between the morbidity pattern and age group of the study
subjects It is observed that the disease of the eye and adnexa increase with increasing age
and are more common in individuals above 80 years of age (714) compared to
individuals in the age group of 60-69 years (461) and 70-79 years (515) This
difference was found to be statistically significant The disease of the oral cavity were also
more common in the subjects aged 80 years and above (857) compared to individuals in
the age group of 70-79 years (507) and 60-69 years (207) this difference was also
found to be statistically significant Significant association was also found between
increasing age and disease of the ear 285 subjects aged 80 years and above suffered from
disease of the ear followed by 149 in the age group of 60-69 years and 99 in the age
group of 60-69 years
61
Results Table 27 Association between morbidity pattern of the study subjects and their
occupation
System involved Employed (n=215)
Unemployed (n=225)
Total (n=440)
Statistical value
Musculoskeletal
system
171 (795) 143 (635) 314 (714) X2 =1374 df=1
p=00002
Eye and adnexa 108 (502) 111(493) 219(497) X2= 0035 df=1
p= 0850
Oral cavityamp
salivary glands
76 (353) 78 (347) 154 (35) X2=0022 df=1
p=0880
Endocrine
nutritional amp
metabolic
disease
75 (348) 70 (311) 145 (329) X2=0708 df=1
p=0400
circulatory
system
58 (269) 79 (351) 137 (311) X2=3393 df=1
p=0065
Respiratory
system
49 (227) 52 (231) 101 (23) X2=0006 df=1
p=09363
Digestive system 45 (21) 42 (187) 87 (198) X2=0125 df=1
p=0723
Skin
subcutaneous
tissue
38 (176) 20 (88) 58 (132) X2=741 df=1
p=0006
Ear and mastoid
process
31 (144) 26 (115) 57 (13) X2=0799 df=1
p=0371
Genitourinary
system
16 (74) 13 (57) 29 (66) X2=0494 df=1
p=0481
Nervous system
2 (093) 9 (4) 11 (25) X2=425 df=1
p=0039 Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses
62
Results
Table 27 shows the association between the morbidity pattern and occupation of the study
subjects It was observed that musculoskeletal disorders were more common among the
subjects who are employed (795) compared to those who are not employed (635) and
this difference was found to be statistically significant A significant association was also
seen between the disorders of the skin and subcutaneous tissue 176 subjects who are
employed suffered from the disease of the skin and subcutaneous tissue compared to 88
who were unemployed The diseases of the nervous system were more common among
those who were unemployed (4) compared to those who were employed (093) this
difference was also found to be statistically significant
63
Results Table 28 Association between morbidity pattern of the study subjects and their
religion
System involved Hindu
(n=188)
Muslim
(n=252)
Total
(n=440)
Statistical value
Musculoskeletal system 138 (73) 176 (698) 314 (714)
X2=0668 df=1
p=0413
Eye and adnexa 100 (531) 119 (472) 219 (497) X2=1535 df=1
p= 0215
Oral cavityamp salivary glands 73 (388) 81 (321) 154 (35)
X2=211 df=1
p=0145
Endocrine nutritional amp metabolic diseases
53 (2819) 92 (365) 145 (329) X2=3371 df=1
p=0066
circulatory system 58 (269) 79 (351) 137 (311)
X2=3393 df=1
p=0065
Respiratory system
33 (176) 68 (269) 101 (229)
X2=5415 df= 1
p=0019
Digestive system 27 (144) 60 (238) 87 (198) X2=6059 df=1
p=0013
Skin subcutaneous tissue
31 (164) 27 (107) 58 (132) X2=3138 df=1
p=00765
Ear and mastoid process
28 (149) 29 (115) 57 (129) X2=1095 df=1
p=0297
Genitourinary system
16 (85) 13 (52) 29 (66) X2=1965 df=1
p=0161
Nervous system
4 (21) 7 (28) 11(25) p=0764
Figure in parenthesis indicates percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
64
Results
Table 28 shows the association between the morbidity pattern of the study subjects and their
religion In our study it was observed that the disorders of the digestive system were more
common among Muslims (238) compared to Hindus (144) this difference was found
to be statistically significant Also the disorders of the respiratory system were more
common among Muslims (269) compared to Hindus (176) This difference was also
found to be statistically significant Some of the diseases were more common among Hindus
which include the disease of the eye and adnexa (531) oral cavity (388) ear (149)
skin and subcutaneous tissue (164) and genitourinary system (85) but it was not found
to be statistically significant
65
Results
III HEATLTH SEEKING BEHAVIOR OF THE STUDY SUBJECTS
Figure16 Distribution of the study subjects based on the visit to health facility in case
of an illness
In our study it was found that that out of 440 study subjects 395(898) visited a health
facility in case of an illness whereas 45(102) did not visit any health facility in case of an
illness
898
102
health facility visitednot visited
66
Results
Table 29 Reasons cited by the study subjects for not seeking healthcare in case of an
illness
In the present study it was found that the most common reason stated by the 45 study
subjects for not seeking health care in case of an illness was that it was a mil 20 (444)
followed by lack of money stated by12 (267) the other reasons stated were no one to
accompany 7 (156) and lack of faith in health care 6 (133)
Reasons cited for not
seeking health care
Frequency (n=45)
Percentage ()
Mild discomfort 20 444
Lack of money 12 267
Lack of faith in
healthcare
6 133
No one to accompany 7 156
Total 45 100
67
Results
Table 30 Distribution of the study subjects based on the type of health facility visited
It was observed that out of 395 subjects who visited health care facility in case of an illness
229(58) Visited government hospitals 160 (405) visited private practitioners hospitals
and 6 (15) visited quacks More number of males (622) visited government hospitals
compared to females (513)
Type of health facility visited
Males
(n=241)
Females
(n=154)
Total
(n=395)
No No No
Government hospital 150 622 79 513 229 58
Private practitionershospitals 87 361 73 474 160 405
Quacks 4 17 2 13 6 15
Total 241 100 154 100 395 100
68
Results
Table 31 Association between gender and health seeking behaviour of the study
subjects
Whether visited
health facility
in case of illness
Sex
Total
n ()
p value Male
n ()
Female
n ()
Yes 241 (927) 154 (856) 395 (898) 00151
No 19 (106) 26 (144) 45 (102)
Total 260 (59) 180 (41) 440 (100)
x2=5901 df =1
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
It was observed that more number of males visited a health care facility in case of an illness
241(927) whereas only 154(856) females visited a health facility in case of an illness
This difference was found to be statistically significant
69
Results
Table 32 Association between educational status and health seeking
behaviour of the study subjects
Whether visited Health facility in case of illness
p value
Educational status(n) Yes () No ()
0000
Illiterate (231) 194 (84) 37 (16)
Primary school (121) 115 (95) 6 (49)
Higher primary (38) 37 (974) 1 (26)
Secondary school (30) 29 (967) 1 (33)
Intermediate (6) 6 (100) 0(00)
Graduate (14) 14 (100) 0(00)
Total(440) 395 (898) 45(102)
Fisherrsquos exact test
In the present study it was found that 84 of the study subjects who were illiterate visited a
health facility in case of an illness whereas 16 did not visit a health facility in case of an
illness 967 of the subjects with education up to secondary school visited the health
facility and 100 of the subjects who studied up to intermediate and with a graduate degree
visited the health facility in case of an illness This difference was found to be statistically
significant
70
Results
Table 33 Distribution of study subjects according to frequency of visits to a health care facility
Frequency of visits to a health care facility
Frequency
(n=395)
Percentage
Once a month 207 524
Once in 3 months 99 251
Once in 6 months 79 20
Once in a year 10 25
Total 395 100
In the present study it was found that out of 395 study subjects who visited a health care
facility in case of an illness 207 (524) visited a health facility every month followed by
99 (251) who visited once in 3 months 79(20) once in 6 months and 10 25 visited
the health facility once in a year
71
Discussion
DISCUSSION
I Socio-demographic characteristics
Our study was done in the urban field practice area of JJM Medical College Davangere
among 440 geriatric subjects our study aimed at assessing the morbidity pattern and health
seeking behaviour of the geriatric population in the study area
In the present study Out of 440 study subjects majority 162(368) were in the age
group of 60-64 Years followed by 109 (247) in the age group of 65-69 Years 99 (225)
in the age group of 70-74 Years and 8 were more than or equal to 80 years of age [Table
7] This was similar to a study conducted by Prakash Boraingaiah et al 72 in which majority
of the elderly (346) belongs to age group 60-64 years followed by age group 75 years and
above (259)
In our study it was also seen that 59 of the study subjects were males and 41 were
females This was similar to a study conducted by Mohan Gupta et al 35 where 573
subjects were males and 427were females Our findings were contrary to a study
conducted by Md Alam Naushad et al 28 where 598 subjects were females and 402
were males
In the present study it was found that the majority of the study subject belonged to
Muslim religion 252 (573) followed by Hindus 188 (427) there were no study subjects
who belonged to other religions like Christian Jain Sikhs etc [Table 8] similar findings
were seen in a study conducted by Mrinal Ranjan Srivastav et al 50 in which 52 of the
subjects were Muslims
72
Discussion
In the present study it was found that the Majority of the study subjects were illiterate
525 whereas 275 had completed education up to primary school 82 had completed
education up to secondary school and only 32 were graduates [Table 9] These findings
were similar to a study done by Shraddha K et al 51in which 504 of the study subjects
were illiterate
In our study it was found that the majority of the study subjects 511 were unemployed
followed by 227 who were unskilled workers 155 were semi-skilled workers and
about 105 were skilled workers [Table 10] These findings were similar to a study done
by Rajat Das Gupta et al27 al in which 481 of the study subjects were not working
In our study majority of the subjects 49 belonged to Class IV Socioeconomic status
followed by 26 who belonged to class III and 13 who belonged to class II (according to
Modified BG Prasad Classification 2016) [Table 11] Similar findings were found in a study
conducted by Sribas Goswami and Manjari Sahai 29 in which majority of the study subjects
belonged to class IV socio economic status
In our study it was found that the majority of the study subjects 734 were married
followed by 261 who were widowed and only 05 were unmarried [Table 12] These
findings were similar to a study done by L subedhi and RB Sah 40 in which 663 of the
subjects were married 322 were widowed and 07 were unmarried
In the present study it was found that majority of the study subjects 42 lived in a three
generation family followed by 37 who lived in a nuclear family and 21 who lived in a
Joint family [Table 13] These findings were similar to a study done by Swapnil Jain et al 26
in which the majority (47) of the study subjects lived in a three generation family
73
Discussion
II Prevalence of morbidities among the study subjects
In the present study it was found that majority of the subjects 45 had a normal BMI
followed by 30 who were overweight about 15 were obese and only10 were
underweight [Figure 14] Similar findings were reported in a study conducted by Khadervali
Nagoor et al 44 in which 49 subjects had a normal BMI In a study done by Vimala
Thomas et al 52 272 of the subjects were obese which was higher than the present study
In the present study it was found that the majority of the subjects suffered from the
disorders of the musculoskeletal system (714) eye and adnexa (497) oral cavity
(311) respiratory system (229) digestive system (198)disease of the skin
(132)ear(13)genitourinary system (66) nervous system (25) [Table14] Similar
findings were seen in a study done by Rajashree Bhat et al 55 in which most common
morbidity of elderly was the problems of loco-motor system (486) followed by vision
(427) CVS disorders (344) respiratory system (202) and disease of ear (179)In
this study though the prevalence of loco-motor system disorders (486) was highest
compared to other disorders it was lesser compared to our study (714) In a study done by
L subedhi and RB Sah 40 it was found that 44 had eye problems 43 had gastrointestinal
problems 33 had CVS problems and 23 had ENT problems In this study the prevalence
of gastrointestinal disorders was much higher compared to our study
In the present study joint pain (including the knee joint) was most common disorder of the
musculoskeletal system seen in 40 of the males compared to 384 in females [Table 15]
whereas in a study done by Swapnil Jain et al 26 it was found that 472 males and 528
females suffered from joint pains This could be attributed to the fact that in our study
majority of the study subjects were males
74
Discussion
In the present study it was found that the most common morbidity of the eye was cataract
found in 39 of the subjects It was more common in males 43 compared to females
333 [ Table 16]These findings were similar to a study done by Shraddha K et al 51 in
which the overall prevalence of cataract was 302 of which 42 males and 358
females had cataract
In the present study it was found that the most common morbidity of the oral cavity was
missing teeth found in 177 of the subjects [Table 17] it was similar to the findings of a
study conducted by JP Singh et al 48 in which 1475 subjects were edentulous
The present study revealed that the most common disorder of the endocrine system was
diabetes mellitus found in 186 of the subjects followed by the nutritional disorder of
anemia found in 134 of the subjects It was seen that anemia was more common among
females 194 compared to males 92 [Table 18] Kakkar R et al 45 reported similar
findings with prevalence of diabetes mellitus as 153 In a study done by Deepak Sharma
et al 47 anemia was present in 15 of the subjects 97 males and 21 females were
anemic which was similar to our study
In our study it was found that the most common disease of the circulatory system was
hypertension which was found in 302 of the subjects it was more common in females
394 compared to males 239 and this difference was found to be statistically significant
[Table 19] A study by L Subedhi and RB Sah 40 reported that the prevalence of
hypertension was more among females (333) compared to males (30) which was
statistically significant
75
Discussion
In our study the most common morbidity of the respiratory system was upper respiratory
tract infection (163) [Table20] it was similar to the study done by Leena Rahul
Salunke33 where it was reported to be 196
In our study the most common disorder of the digestive system was gastritis (95)
[Table 21] similar to the findings of JP Singh et al 48 (35) contrary to this L subedhi
and RB Sah 40 reported a high prevalence of gastritis (39) This difference could be
attributed to the difference in the interpretation of symptoms for the diagnosis of gastritis
In our study the most common disorder of the skin was itching (48) [ Table 22] which
was similar to the findings reported by JP Singh et al 48 in which 225 subjects suffered
from itching
In our study the most common disorder of the ear was impaired hearing (111) [Table
23] similar to a study by Vandana Nikumb et al 38 in which 106 subjects suffered from
hearing impairment
In our study it was observed that the most common morbidity affecting the
genitourinary system was increased frequency of micturition (57) [Table 24]
L subedhi and RB Sah40 found in their study that 143 subjects suffered from increased
frequency of micturition which was higher compared to our study
Our study revealed that 25 subjects suffered from the disorders of the nervous
system [Table 25] similar to a study conducted by Vandana Nikumb et al 38 in which
13 of the Subjects suffered from the disorders of the nervous system whereas in a
study conducted by Shilpa Shaukaiah et al36 it was found that 66 of the subjects
suffered from the disorders of the nervous system which was higher than our study
76
Discussion
It is observed that the disease of the eye and adnexa increased with increasing age and were
more common in individuals above 80 years of age (714) The disease of the oral cavity
were also more common in the subjects aged 80 years and above (857) and 285
subjects aged 80 years and above suffered from disease of the ear A significant association
was found between age and these morbidities [Table 26] Similar results were found in a
study done by Swapnil Jain et al 26 in which cataract hearing impairment and dental
problems were significantly associated with the age of the study subjects
In our study a significant association was found between occupation and the disorders of
the musculoskeletal system skin and the nervous system Disorders of the musculoskeletal
system were more common among employed subjects (795) compared to unemployed
(635) 176 subjects who were employed suffered from the disease of the skin and
subcutaneous tissue compared to 88 who were unemployed Diseases of the nervous
system were more common among those who were unemployed (4) compared to those
who were employed (093) [Table 27]
A study done by Kakkar R et al45 found that there was a significant association between the
employment status and the morbidities of the CVS arthritis and cataract CVS morbidity
was more common among those not working (164) compared to those working (36)
Arthritis was also more common among not working (212) compared to those working
(55) and cataract was also more common among those not working (175) compared to
those working (55)
77
Discussion
In our study it was observed that there was a significant association between religion and
disorders of the digestive system and respiratory system The disorders of the digestive
system were more common among Muslims (238) compared to Hindus (144) Also the
disorders of the respiratory system were more common among Muslims (269) compared
to Hindus (176) [Table 28] In a study conducted by Mrinal Ranjan Srivastav et al 50 it
was found that there was significant association between religion and the morbidities of the
genitourinary system in the urban areas The problems of the genitourinary system were
more common among Hindus (26) compared to Muslims (96)
III HEATLTH SEEKING BEHAVIOR OF THE STUDY SUBJECTS
In our study it was found that that (898) study subjects visited a health facility in case
of an illness whereas 102 did not visit any health facility in case of an illness[Figure 16]
Similar findings were seen in a study conducted by Vimala Thomas et al 52 where it was
found that 716 subjects visited a health facility Contrary to our findings a study
conducted by Bhawalkar JS et al46 showed that only 81 subjects visited a health facility in
case of an illness whereas 919 did not visit any health facility
In the present study it was found that the most common reason stated by study subjects
for not seeking health care in case of an illness was that it was a mild discomfort (444)
followed by lack of money stated by (267) other reasons stated were no one to
accompany (156) and lack of faith in health care (133) [Table 29] In a study
conducted by Deepak Sharma et al 47 it was found that the most common reasons for not
seeking health care were the following disease due to age (496) health services too far
(191) lack of money (6) no body to take to hospital (35)
78
Discussion
It was observed that out of 395 subjects who visited health care facility in case of an illness
58 Visited government hospitals 362 visited private practitioners hospitals and 15
visited quacks [Table 30] similar results were found in a study conducted by Deepak Sharma
et al 47 in which 607 went to Government hospitals 267 consulted private practitioners
and 126 took over the counter drugs In another study conducted by Rajat Das Gupta et al
27 it was found that 33 visited Government hospitals 25 visited private hospitals 6
visited private practitioners
It was observed that more number of males (927) visited a health care facility in case of
an illness whereas only 856 females visited a health facility in case of an illness [Table
31] In a study done by Man Mohan Gupta et al 35 it was found that 672 females and
651 males visited a health facility in case of illness
In the present study it was found that 848 of the study subjects who were illiterate
visited a health facility in case of an illness whereas 152 did not visit a health facility in
case of an illness A significant association was found between educational status and
gender [Table 32] In a study done by Deepak Sharma et al 47 it was found that Gender
literacy income and marital status were not found to be significantly related to health-
seeking behaviour
In the present study it was found that 524 subjects visited a health facility every month
followed by 251 who visited a health facility once in 3 months 20once in 6 months
and 25 visited a health facility once in a year[ Table 33] In a study conducted by Rajat
Das Gupta et al 27 it was found that majority of the subjects (2943) visited a health
facility once a year followed by 2813 who visited a health facility once in three months
79
Conclusion
CONCLUSION
The study revealed that some of the common morbidities among the geriatric subjects were
the disorders of the musculoskeletal system followed by the disease of the eye and adnexa
oral cavity endocrine nutritional and metabolic disorders etc some disorders like cataract
dental caries constipation and increased frequency of micturition were more common
among males whereas disease like anemia and hypertension were more common among
females A significant association was found between some of the morbidities and socio
demographic determinants like age occupation and religion
Any degree of formal schooling was found to be associated with better health seeking
behavior Majority of the subjects visited a Government health facility in case of an illness
and the main reason that was stated for not visiting a health facility was that they suffered
from mild discomfort and did not consider it necessary to visit a health facility
80
Summary
SUMMARY
Our study was done in the urban field practice area of JJM Medical College Davangere
among 440 geriatric subjects our study aimed at assessing the morbidity pattern and health
seeking behaviour of the geriatric population in the study area
The results of our study are as follows
ISocio-demographic characteristics of the study subjects
In the present study 368 subjects were in the age group of 60-64 Years
59 of the subjects were males and 41 were females
573 subjects were Muslims whereas 427 were Hindus
Majority of the subjects were illiterate (525) whereas 275 had completed
education up to primary school
It was found that the majority of the study subjects (511) were unemployed
49 subjects belonged to Class IV Socioeconomic status according to Modified BG
Prasad Classification
734 of the subjects were married
42 of the people lived in a three generation family
II Prevalence of morbidities among the study subjects
Majority of the subjects (45) had a normal BMI followed 30who were
overweight
Majority 714 subjects suffered from the disorders of the musculoskeletal system
followed by 497 who suffered from the disease of the eye and adnexa35
suffered from the disease of the oral cavity 329 suffered from endocrine
nutritional and metabolic disorders and 311 suffered from the disease of the
circulatory system 229 suffered from the disease of the respiratory system198
81
Summary
suffered from the disease of the digestive system132 suffered from disease of the
skin13 suffered from the disease of the ear66 suffered from the disease of the
genitourinary system and 25 suffered from the disease of the nervous system
The most common morbidity of musculoskeletal system was pain of the joints (other
than the knee joint) found in 198 of the subjectsBack ache was more common in
females 231 compared to males 163 and this difference was found to be
statistically significant
cataract found in 39 of the subjects It was more common in males 43 compared
to females 333 and this difference was found to be statistically significant
Missing teeth were found in 177 of the subjects Dental caries were more
common in males 108 compared to females 44 and this difference was found to
be statistically significant
Diabetes mellitus found in 186 of the subjects followed by the nutritional disorder
of anemia found in 134 of the subjects anemia was more common among females
194 compared to males 92 This difference was found to be statistically
significant
Hypertension which was found in 302 of the subjects it was more common in
females 394 compared to males 239 and this difference was found to be
statistically significant
upper respiratory tract infection) found in 163 subjects followed by acute
bronchitis in 43 bronchial asthma in 14 and pulmonary TB in only 09
Gastritis was found in 95 subjects followed by constipation in 61 Among
males (81) had constipation compared to females(03)
Most common disease of the skin was itching which was present in 48 of the
study subjects followed by dryness in 43
82
Summary
Hearing impairment was found in 111 of the subjects
Increased frequency of micturition was found in 57 of the subjects followed by
burning micturition in 09 of the study subjects Increased frequency of
micturition was more among males 77 compared to females in whom it was 28
and this difference was found to be statistically significant
The most common disorder of the nervous system was neuritis seen in 11 of the
subjects followed by memory loss in 09 and stroke in 05 of the subjects
A significant association was found between increasing age and the morbidities of
the eye ear and the oral cavity
Significant association was found between occupation and the disorders of the
musculoskeletal system skin and the nervous system Disorders of the
musculoskeletal system were more common among employed subjects (795)
compared to unemployed (635) 176 subjects who were employed suffered
from the disease of the skin and subcutaneous tissue compared to 88 who were
unemployed Diseases of the nervous system were more common among those who
were unemployed (4) compared to those who were employed (093)
It was observed that the disorders of the digestive system were more common
among Muslims (238) compared to Hindus (144) this difference was found to
be statistically significant Also the disorders of the respiratory system were more
common among Muslims (269) compared to Hindus (176) This difference
was also found to be statistically significant
83
Summary
III HEATLTH SEEKING BEHAVIOR OF THE STUDY SUBJECTS
In our study 898 subjects visited a health facility in case of an illness whereas
102 did not
The most common reason stated by study subjects for not seeking health care in case
of an illness was that it was a mild discomfort (444) followed by lack of money
stated by (267) the other reasons stated were no one to accompany (156) and
lack of faith in health care (133)
It was observed that 58 subjects Visited Government hospitals 362 visited
private practitioners hospitals and 15 visited quacks
Majority of males (927) visited a health care facility in case of an illness whereas
only 856 females visited a health facility in case of an illness This difference was
found to be statistically significant
A significant association was found between the educational status and health
seeking behaviour Majority of the educated subjects visited a health facility in case
of an illness compared to those who were illiterate
It was found that 524 subjects visited a health facility every month followed by
251 who visited a health facility once in 3 months 20once in 6 months and
25 visited a health facility once in a year
84
Limitations
LIMITATIONS
1 Many of the responses were subjective and there were no records to verify them
2 Some of the morbidities were diagnosed only by clinical examination and could not be
confirmed by performing diagnostic tests due to high cost and time constraints
3 This study was done in the urban field practice area which consisted of a closed
community hence the results cannot be generalized to the entire population of the area
85
Recommendations
RECOMMENDATIONS
1 Health education should be given to the geriatric people regarding the common health
problems associated with ageing and preventive care should be provided to the elderly
2 Geriatric clinics should be set up at the primary health care level which provide regular
screening and health check-ups
3 There should also be a provision to provide domiciliary care by specialists qualified in
geriatrics
4 The family members and the care givers of the elderly should be educated about the
common health problems of the elderly and also about the need for regular health check-ups
and emotional support
5 The majority of the geriatric population is out of work force they are suffering from
many morbidities and are totally dependent on others even for their health needs Hence the
Government should increase the pension of the elderly and provide them quality healthcare
free of cost
6 There is also a need for public private partnership to improve the quality of health
services for the geriatric people More number of NGOs should work towards improving the
health and the quality of life of the elderly
86
References
REFERENCES
1 United Nations Department of Economic and Social affairs Population Division
World population ageing 2013 Available from URL
wwwunorgendevelopmentpopulationageingWorldPopulationAgeing2013
[Accessed on 17-7-2016]
2 Khan S and Itrat M Current Issues in Geriatric Health Care in India-A Review J Community Med Health Care 2016 1(1) 1-3
3 United Nations Department of Economic and Social Affairs Population Division
World Population Ageing 2015 ndash Highlights Available from URL
wwwunorgendevelopmentdesapopulationpdfageingWPA2015_Reportpdf
[Accessed on 272017]
4 State of elderly in India 2014 Help age India Available from URL
httpswwwhelpageindiaorgimagespdfstate-elderly-india-2014pdf [Accessed on
1082017]
5 World Health Organization World report on ageing and health 2015Available
from URL wwwwhointageingeventsworld-report-2015-launchen [Accessed on
1272017]
6 National policy for Senior citizens March 2011Ministry of Social Justice and
welfare Govt of India Available from URL
socialjusticenicinwritereaddataUploadFilednpscpdf [Accessed on 482017]
87
References
7 Elderly in India Profile and programmes 2016Govt of India Ministry of statistics
and programme implementation Central Statistics Office Available from URL
wwwmopsigovin [ Accessed on 1442017]
8 Saxena V Kandpal SD Gael D Bansal S Health status of elderly community
based study Indian Journal of Community Health2012 Oct-Dec24(4)269-74
9 Shah T Patel M Shah V Health care seeking behaviour of urban and rural
community in Ahmedabad district Int J Med Sci Public Health20132908-11
10 Sahoo H Mishra NR Health Status Morbidity Pattern and Treatment Seeking
Behaviour among Elderly in India Evidence from 60th round of National Sample
Survey Data Learning community 2011 Dec 2(3) 341-55
11 Park K Parkrsquos Textbook of Preventive and social medicine 24 th ed Jabalpur MS
Banarsidas Bhanot Publishers2017631
12 UNFPA- state of World Population 2011Chapter 1 setting the scene 19-31
Available from URL httpswwwunfpaorgsitesdefaultfilesresource-
pdfUNFPA-Report-Chapter1pd [Accessed on 1082017]
13 Lal S Adarsh Pankaj Textbook of community Medicine 4th ed CBS publishers and
distributors PvtLtd2011732
14 Census of India 2001 Registrar General And Census Commissioner India
Available from URL httpwwwcensusindiagovinCensus[Accessed on
7102015]
15 SRS bulletin October 2012 Registar General of India New Delhi Available from
URL censusindiagovinvital_statisticsSRS_BulletinsSRS_Bulletin-
October_2012[Acessed on 7102015]
88
References
16 Bagchi K Healthy ageing Health and Population-Perspectives and Issues 2000
23(1)11-16
17 Salagre SB The Association of Physicians of India Chapter 177 Health Issues in
Geriatrics Available from URL
wwwapiindiaorgmedicine_update_2013chap177pd [ Accessed on 282017]
18 Ingle GK Nath A Geriatric Health in India Concerns and Solutions Indian Journal
of Community Medicine 2008 33(4)214-18
19 World Health Organization Active Ageing a policy framework 2002 Available
from httpwhqlibdocwhointhq2002who_nmh_nph_028pdf [Accessed on
1062017]
20 Inche Zainal Abidin S Sutan R Shamsuddin K Prevalence and determinants of
appropriate health seeking behaviour among known diabetics Results from a
community-based survey Advances in Epidemiology 2014 Nov 20141-6
21 Begashaw B Tessema F Gesesew HA Health Care Seeking behavior in Southwest
Ethiopia Plos one 2016 Sep 11(9)e0161014
22 MacKian S Health systems development Manchester University of Manchester
2003 A review of health seeking behavior problems and prospects
23 Metta EO Health-seeking behaviour among adults in the context of the
epidemiological transition in Southeastern Tanzania A focus on malaria and
diabetes [Groningen] University of Groningen 2016 228 Available from URL
httpswwwrugnlresearchportalfiles28737720Chapter_7pdf [Accessed on
1272017]
24 Adhikari D Rijal D Factors affecting health seeking behaviour of senior citizens of
Dharan Journal of Nobel Medical College 2015 Sep 4(1)57-63
25 Polisetty S Seepana M Morbidity profile of elderly individuals in urban
Visakhapatnam Int J Community Med Public Health 2017 4(2)2558-63
89
References
26 Jain S Kaware AC Doibale MK Shaikh S Radhey BK Mathurkar MP Morbidity
pattern among geriatric population in urban field practice area of district of
Maharashtra a cross sectional study Int J Community Med Public Health 2016
3(2)523-29
27 Gupta RD Loha A Roy S Morbidity pattern and health-seeking behaviour among
the senior citizens in a selected urban area of Bangladesh A cross-sectional study
South East Asia Journal of Public Health 2016 Jul 5(2)43-49
28 Naushad MA Verma N Bhawnani D Jain M Anand T Umate LV Morbidity
pattern and health seeking behaviour in elderly population of Raipur City
Chhattisgarh India Indian Journal of Community Health2016 Sep 28(3)236-41
29 Goswami S Sahai M A Study of Morbidity Pattern in Elderly Population European
Researcher Series A 2016103(2)119-28
30 Bardhan H Dixit AM Agarwal R Jain PK Gupta S Shukla SK Morbidity profile
of elderly population in Ghaziabad district a cross-sectional study Int J Med Sci
Public Health 2016 5(6)1098-1102
31 Maroof M Ahmad A Khalique N Ansari MA Health problems among the aged A
community based study from urban Aligarh Uttar Pradesh India Int J Community
Med Public Health 2016 Feb 3(4)944-47
32 Shankar G Sidenur B A morbidity study of elderly residing in urban field practice
area of SN medical college Bagalkot National Journal of research in community
medicine 2016 Oct-Dec 4(5) 229-34
90
References
33 Salunkhe LR Socio-demographic profile of old age people living in urban amp urban
slum areas in Maharashtra Karad A comparative study J of Evidence based Med
and Hlthcare 2015 Feb 2(5) 513-21
34 Warbhe P Rupesh W Morbidity profile health seeking behaviour and home
environment survey for adaptive measures in geriatric population-Urban community
study International Journal of Medical Research amp Health Sciences 2015 4(4)778-
82
35 Gupta M Borle AL Chhari N Gupta S Assessment of clinico-socioeconomic
status and health-care support among the elderly people aged older than 60 years in
urban population of Bhopal Central India Int J Med Sci Public Health 2015
4558-64
36 Sahukaiah S Shenoy A Vijayakumar BC An epidemiological study of prevalence
of morbidity patterns among geriatric age group in an urban slum of Mumbai Int J
Med Sci Public Health 2015 Jul 4(7)883-87
37 Shubha Davalagi B Angadi N Mahabalaraju DK Morbidity psycho-social profile
and health seeking behaviour of the elderly population in urban slums of Davangere
City India Int J Res Med Sci 2015 Nov 3(11)3288-91
38 Nikumb V Patankar F Behera A A Study of Morbidity Profile among Geriatric
Population in an Urban Area Sch J App Med Sci 2015 3(3)1365-69
91
References
39 Vishnoi BR Solanki SL Singhal G Meharda B Mishra N Morbidity profile of
elderly in urban slum of Udaipur Rajasthan Int J Oral Health Med Res 2015 May
2(1)9-12
40 Subedi L Sah RB Study of the health status of geriatric age group in Chitwan
district of Nepal Journal of Chitwan Medical College 2015 Mar 5(1)11-17
41 Noor S Krishnababu G Prasad KV Health status of Geriatric population in slums
of Rourkela Young Innovative Journal of Medical and Health Science 2015 May
5(3) 92-94
42 Sarode VM Chronic Diseases Related to Aging and Disease Prevention in Slums in
Mumbai Journal of Aging Science 2014 Jan 2 (1)1-6
43 Barman SK Lata K Ram R Ghosh N Sarker G Shahnawaz K A study of
morbidity profile of geriatric population in an urban community of Kishanganj
Bihar India Global Journal of Medicine and Public Health GJMEDPH 2014 3(1)
1-7
44 Nagoor K Srikanth BA Dudekula R Satna K Comparative study of health status
among slum and non-slum elderly population in Kadapa Region South India
Journal of Evolution of Medical and Dental Sciences 2014 Feb 3(5)1298-308
45 Kakkar R Aggarwal P Kandpal SD Bansal SK An Epidemiological study to assess
morbidity profile among geriatric population in District Dehradun Indian Journal of
Community Health 2013 May 25(1)39-44
46 Bhawalkar JS Dhone AB Jethani S Singru S Jadhav SL Adyanthaya S A study of
morbidity profile among geriatric population in an urban area J Evol Med Dent Sci
2013 Sep 9 36(2)6963-7
92
References
47 Sharma D Mazta SR Parashar A Morbidity pattern and health-seeking behaviour of
aged population residing in Shimla hills of north India A cross-sectional study
Journal of family medicine and primary care 2013 Apr2(2)188
48 Singh JP Singh S Kasturwar NB Hassan A Geriatric morbidity profile in an urban
slum Central India Indian Journal of Community Health 2013 Aug 25(2)164-70
49 Thakur RP Banerjee A Nikumb VB Health Problems among the Elderly A Cross
Sectional Study Annals of medical and health sciences research 2013 3(1)19-25
50 Mrinal RS Beena S Pratibha G Pankaj B Srivastava JP Atul B Morbidity Status
and Its Social Determinants among Elderly Population of Lucknow District India
Sch J App Med Sci 2013 1(6)758-64
51 Shraddha K Prashantha B Prakash B Study on morbidity pattern among elderly in
urban population of Mysore Karnataka India International Journal of Medicine and
Biomedical Research 2012 1(3)215-23
52 Thomas V Lavanya KM Morbidity profile and health seeking behaviour of the
elderly in urban slums of Hyderabad Andhra Pradesh India- A cross sectional study
International Journal of Current Research and Review 2012 Oct 1 4(19)174-80
53 Moe S Tha K Naing DK Htike MM Health seeking behaviour of elderly in
Myanmar International Journal of Collaborative Research on Internal Medicine and
Public Health 2012 4(8)1538-44
93
References
54 Bharati DR Pal R Rekha R Yamuna TV Kar S Radjou AN Ageing in
Puducherry South India An overview of morbidity profile Journal of pharmacy amp
bio allied sciences 2011 Oct 3(4)537
55 Bhatt R Gadhvi MS Sonaliya KN Solanki A Nayak H An epidemiological study
of the morbidity pattern among the elderly population in Ahmedabad Gujarat
National Journal of community medicine 2011 Jul 2(2)233-36
56 Srinivasan Krishnamachari Vaz Mario Thomas Tinku Prevalence of health related
disability among community dwelling urban elderly from middle socioeconomic
strata in Bangaluru India Indian Journal of Medical Research 2010 Apr 131(4)
515-21
57 Srivastava K Gupta SC Kaushal SK Chaturvedi M Morbidity profile of elderly a
cross sectional study of urban Agra Indian Journal of Community Health 2010 Jun
22(1)51-55
58 Ladha A Khan R Malik A Khan S Khan B Khan I et al The health seeking
behaviour of elderly population in a poor-urban community of Karachi Pakistan
Journal of the Pakistan Medical Association2009 Feb 59(2) 89-92
59 WHO ICD-10 version 2010 Geneva World Health Organization Available from
URL appswhointclassificationsicd10browse2010en [Accessed on 772017]
60 OpenEpi22OpenEpi (free) download Windows version Available from URL
enfreedownloadmanagerorgWindows-PCOpenEpi-FREEhtml
61 Tandon R Sinhota Parsonrsquos disease of the eye 22edNew Delhi Elsevier 98-100
62 Dhingra P L Dhingra S Disease of ear nose and throat and head and neck surgery
6th ed New Delhi Elsevier 201422
94
References
63 Aziz N Kallur SD Nirmalan PK Implications of the revised consensus body mass
indices for Asian Indians on clinical obstetric practice Journal of clinical and
diagnostic research 2014 May 8(5)OC01
64 Chobanion AV Bakris GL Black HR The seventh report of the joint national
committee on prevention detection evaluation and treatment of high blood pressure
the JNC 7 report JAMA 2003 2892560-72
65 The Seventh Report of the Joint National Committee on Prevention Detection
Evaluation and Treatment of High Blood Pressure (JNC 7) The GuidelinesUS
Department of Health and Human Services National Heart Lung and Blood
Institute Available at URL
httpswwwnhlbinihgovfilesdocsguidelinesjnc7fullpdf [ Accessed on
1282017]
66 Firkin F Chestman C Penington D Rush B De Gruchyrsquos clinical Hematology in
medical practice 5th edition New Delhi Blackwell science Ltd1989 32-47
67 Report of WHO consultation Nutritional Anaemias Geneva Switzerland World
Health Organization TRS-405 1968 Available from URL
whqlibdocwhointtrsWHO_TRS_405pdf [Accessed on 1282017]
68 National Family Health survey (NFHS-4) 2015-16 India Mumbai IIPS
2016Available from URL httpwwwnfhsindiaorg [Accessed on 4072017]
69 The Minimum Wages Act 1948 Ministry of Labour and Employment Government
of India Available from URL httplabourgovincontentinnerpagewagesphp
[Accessed on 1082017]
70 Khairnar M Wadgave U Shimpi P Updated BG Prasad socioeconomic
classification for 2016 Journal of Indian Association of Public Health Dentistry
2016 Oct 1 14(4)469
95
References
71 Tiwari P Tiwari S Mastering practicals community medicine 1st ed New Delhi
India Wolters Kluwer PvtLtd2013161-67
72 Boralingaiah P Bettappa P Kashyap S Prevalence of Psycho-Social Problems
among Elderly in Urban Population of Mysore City Karnataka India Indian journal
of psychological medicine 2012 Oct 34(4)360
96
PATIENT CONSENT FORM JJM MEDICAL COLLEGE DAVANGERE
DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY MEDICINE I the undersigned hereby give my consent
for investigations carried upon me I am satisfied with the information given about this
Clinical study titled ldquoA STUDY ON THE MORBIDITY PATTERN AND HEALTH
SEEKING BEHAVIOR AMONG THE GERIATRIC POULATION IN THE
URBAN FIELD PRACTICE AREA OF JJM MEDICAL COLLEGE
DAVANGERErdquo ldquoconducted by Dr RUCHI DHAR under the guidance of Dr VIDYA
GS Associate Professor I have been informed and explained the risks involved and I
hereby voluntarily and Unconditionally give my consent without any fear or pressure in
mentally sound and conscious state to participate in this study
DATE PATIENTrsquoS SIGNATURE
eEacuteeEacuteJA ordfEacuteEcirczAgravearingQAtildeAiAgraveAuml ordfAgraveAumlordmAacutelaquozAacutearingregAiAgraveAuml zAacuteordfAgravetUEacutegEacute
ryenAacutemiumlethordfEacuteAumlAmiumlDyensiumlPAgraveordfAgraveAumlAumlaringcurrenn ordfEacuteAumlrsup1poundiuml
ordfEacuteEcirczAgravearingQAtildeAiAgraveAumlvAgraveyenAacutecedilAgraveuEacuteUEacuteMbrvbaragraveUEacute yenAgravevAgraveaelig F PEacutefrac14AgraveUEacute cedilAgraveraquo ordfAgraveiAacutergAgraveAumlordfAgrave poundAacutepoundAgraveAuml CAzAgravegEacute
poundAgravepoundAgraveszlig
ordfEacuteEcirczAgravearingQAtildeAiAgraveAumlvAgraveyenAacutecedilAgraveuEacute ordmAacuteUAgraveAElig plusmnAgravecedilAgraveUcircccedilaQvEacuteigraveUEacuteAzAgraveAuml poundAgravepoundAgraveszligMbrvbaragraveUEacuteAiAgraveAumlpoundAgraveAumlszlig
cedilAgraveAEligasup1gAgraveAumlvEacuteUcircAtildepoundEacute J cedilAgraveOumlr Dyensiuml zAgrave ordfEacuteAEligcopyethrn yenAacutearinglpoundiumleth CAqiuml ordmEacutemacriumlUcirc sup1AtildeQAUiuml copyordmEacuteAtildelaquoAiAgraveAumlgiuml Dyensiuml zAgrave fjAiAgraveiAacutenaeligPiuml yenEacuteAEligAtildeyenAgraveAumlaringmacrEacuteAtildemicroAgravepoundiuml Epoundiuml zAgrave Csectethpoundiuml brvbarAtildemacriumlOslash yenAacuteaeligoumlaringQOumlAtildecediliuml JjAiAgraveAuml Dyensiuml ddordfAgraveAumlAuml ordfEacuteEcirczAgravearingQAtildeAiAgraveAuml ordfAgraveAumlordmAacutelaquozAacutearingregAiAgraveAuml zAacuteordfAgravetUEacutegEacute JAsect sup2AtildeparaethPEacuteAiAgraveAumlrAiAgraveAumldegegrave yenAgravejAtildePEacuteeumlUEacute Mfrac14AgraveyenAgravercedilAgraveAumlordfAgrave ordfEacuteEcirczAgravearinggAacutezAgrave qAacute|| gAgraveAumla zAgravesAgravegAgrave ordfAgraveAumlvAgraveAumlUcirc qAacute|| laquozAacutearing fJcediliumlordfAgraveiAacuteUAgraveethzAgraveplusmnAgraveethPAgravegAacutezAgrave yenEacuteAEligaeligAtildeyensEacutecedilAgravegiuml
EordfAgravegAgraveAuml poundAgravepoundAgraveUEacute F vAgraveyenAacutecedilAgraveuEacuteUEacute Mfrac14AgraveyenAgraveqAgraveAumlordfAgrave ordfAgraveAumlAumlpoundAgraveszlig yenAgraveaeligwAiEacuteAEligAzAgraveAuml
CAplusmnAgraveUAgravefrac14AgravepoundAgraveAumlszlig CxAgraveethordfAacuteUAgraveAumlordfAgraveAvEacute wfrac12sup1gAgraveAumlvAacuteUcircgEacuteDzAgraveYacutejAzAgrave poundAacutepoundAgraveAuml poundAgravepoundAgraveszlig
ordfAgraveAumlpoundAgravecedilAacutegEacute AiAgraveiAacuteordfAgraveAringzEacuteAtilde umlsAgraveAiAgraveAuml ordfAgraveAumlvAgraveAumlUcirc AiAgraveiAacutegAgrave MvAacuteUcircAiAgraveAumllaquoregegravezEacute poundAacutepoundAgraveAuml
vAgraveyenAacutecedilAgraveuEacute aQvEacuteigraveUEacuteAEligfrac14AgraveyenAgraveqAgraveregAuml MbrvbaragraveUEacuteAiAgraveAumlpoundAgraveAumlszlig cedilAgraveAEligasup1gAgraveAumlvEacuteUcircAtildepoundEacute
centpoundAacuteAPAgrave gEacuteAEligAtildeVAi
Annexures
ANNEXURE ndashIII
104
Annexures
PROFORMA
I General information
1 NAME
2 AGE
3 GENDER (a) Male (b) Female
4 MARITAL STATUS (a) Unmarried (b) Married (c) Widow Widower
(d) Divorced separated
5 LIVING ARRANGEMENT (a) with spouse (b) Spouse and children
(c) Children only (d) living alone (e) others
6 RELIGION (a) Hindu (b) Muslim (c) Christian (d) Others
7 ADDRESS
8 EDUCATION (a) illiterate (b) Primary school (c) higher primary
(d) secondary school (e)PUC diploma (e) Graduate (f) Postgraduate
9 OCCUPATION (a) professional (b) semi- professional (c) skilled worker
(d) Semi ndashskilled worker (e) unskilled worker (f) unemployed
10 CONTACT NUMBER
11 TYPE OF FAMILY (a) Joint (b) Nuclear (C) three generation
12 TOTAL NUMBER OF FAMILY MEMBERS
13 TOTAL FAMILY INCOME
14 PER CAPITA FAMILY INCOME
15 SOCIO ECONOMIC STATUS (Modified BG Prasad classification) I IIIIIIVV
16 DIET (a) Vegetarian (b) Mixed
17 Sleep (a) Disturbed if yes reason ______________ (b) Not disturbed
18 Bowel Regular Irregular
19 Bladder Regular Irregular
97
Annexures
20 HABITS (a) betel nut (b) tobacco (c) alcohol (d) smoking (e) others
If any of the habits present Duration (since when) _________
Frequency of consumption day_______
IIAssessment of morbidity based on history
1 Whether suffering from any chronic illness like (a) Type 2 DM (b) Hypertension
(c) Bronchial Asthma (d) TB (e) others
2 Whether suffering from cataract currently (a) Yes (b) No
3 Whether operated for cataract (a) Yes (b) No If Yes duration since operation____
4 MUSCULOSKELETAL SYSTEM
Whether the following symptoms are present
(a) Backache (b) Joint pain (c) restricted joint movements (d) pain in calves
(e) Others_________
5 RESPIRATORY SYSTEM
(a) Productive cough (b) non-productive cough (c) nasal discharge (d) breathlessness (e)
sore throat (f) sneezing
6 CARDIOVASCULAR SYSTEM
(a) Palpitations (b) chest pain (c) breathlessness
7 GASTROINTESTINAL SYSTEM
(a) Pain abdomen (b) lose stools (c) constipation (d) flatulence (e) heart burn
(f) Bleeding per rectum
8 EYE AND ADNEXA
(a) Watering (b) diminution of vision (c) redness
9 EAR
(a) Discharge (b) decreased hearing (c) Tinnitus
10 SKIN
(a) Itching (b) skin eruptions (c) scaling (d) pigmentation
98
Annexures
11 GENITO URINARY SYSTEM
(a) Burning micturition (b) increased frequency of micturition
12 GENERAL SYMPTOMS
(a) Fatigue (b) headache (c) fever
13 ANY OTHER COMPLAINTS (a) burning feet (b) swelling in groin
(c) Memory loss (d) insomnia
III Assessment of health seeking behaviour
1 Do you visit a health facility in case of illness (a) Yes (b) No
If yes how much time do you take to visit a health facility an case of an illness
(a) Within 24 hours (b) 24-48 hours (c) more than 48 hours
2 Which type of health facility do you visit
(a) Govt hospital (b) Private practitioners (c) over the counter drugs (e) quacks
Mention the reason for visiting the particular health facility______________________
3 Whether taking regular treatment after diagnosis ________________
If No mention the reason_______________________
4 Whether following the instructions given by the treating doctor
(a) Yes (b) no
5 cost of treatment per month in case of chronic disease
(a) lt100 (b) 100-200 (c) 200-300 (d) 300 and above
6 Person bearing the cost of treatment
(a) Self (b) spouse (c) son (d) daughter (d) outside help
7 Duration to reach the health facility
(a) less than 3o minutes (b) 30 minutes or more
8 Whether going for regular check -ups (a) Yes (b) No
If Yes duration between the check-ups_______
99
Annexures
9 Whether following self- care practices in case of chronic disease like diabetes and hypertension
(a) Yes (b) No
10 In case of healthy individuals whether getting screening tests done (a) Yes (b) No
11 Whether following any dietary modifications (a) yes (b) No
12 Whether any family member accompanies you to the health facility
If yes who (a) Son (b) daughter (c) spouse (d) others
11 Whether the family supports in following specific diet advised by the doctor
(a) Yes (b) No
12 whether family members help in reminding to take regular medication
(a) Yes (b) No
IV Physical examination
1 Personal hygiene status
S NO COMPONENT CONDITION REMARKS
1 Hair
2 Teeth
3 Bath
4 Clothes
5 Washing hand before
eating food
6 Washing hands with soap
and water after ablution
7 Nails
8 Foot wear
Remarks personal hygiene status Good fair poor
100
Annexures
2 MEASUREMENTS
(a) Weight (in Kg) ______ (b) Height (in cm) _____ (c) BMI ______
(d) Waist circumference______ (e) Hip circumference ___________
(f) Waist hip ratio_________
3 GENERAL PHYSICAL EXAMINATION
Pallor Icterus Cyanosis clubbing lymphadenopathy Oedema
Pulse rate Temp Blood Pressure
Respiratory rate
20 Examination of
Eye Oral cavity Ear
Nose Throat
SYSTEMIC EXAMINATION
Cardiovascular system Respiratory system
Per abdomen Central Nervous system
101
MASTER CHART
Annexures
ANNEXURES
International Classification of Diseases (10th Revision)
I Certain infectious and parasitic diseases (A00-B99)
II Neoplasms (C00-D48)
III Diseases of blood and blood forming organs and certain disorders
involving the immune mechanisms (D50-D89)
IV Endocrine nutritional and metabolic diseases (E00-E90)
V Mental and behavioural disorders (F00-F99)
VI Diseases of the nervous system (G00-G99)
VII Diseases of the eye and adnexa (H00-H59)
VIII Diseases of the ear and mastoid process ( H60-H95)
IX Diseases of the circulatory system (I00-I99)
X Diseases of the respiratory system ( J00-J99)
XI Diseases of the digestive system (K00-K93)
XII Diseases of the skin and subcutaneous tissue ( L00-L99)
XIII Diseases of the musculoskeletal system and connective tissue
(M00-M99)
XIV Diseases of the genitourinary system ( N00-N99)
XV Pregnancy childbirth and purperium (O00-O99)
XVI Certain conditions originating in perinatal period (P00-P96)
XVII Congenital malformations deformations and chromosomal
XVIII (S00-T98)
XIX External causes of morbidity and mortality (V01-Y98)
102
Annexures
XX Injury poisoning and certain other consequences of external causes
(S00-T98)
XXI Factors influencing health status and contact with health services
(Z00-Z99)
XXII Codes for special purpose
103
Annexures
105
Annexures
106
Annexures
107
Annexures
PHOTOS
Picture 1 Showing the investigator interviewing the study subject
Picture 2 Showing the investigator interacting with the study subject
108
Annexures
Picture 3 Showing the investigator recording the Blood pressure of the study subject
Picture 4 Showing the investigator auscultating the study subject
109
Annexures
110
Results and Conclusion
In our study it was found that the majority of the subjects (368) were in the age group
of 60-64 years 525 were illiterate 511 were unemployed and 49 belonged to class
IV socio economic status The study revealed that the some of the common morbidities
among the geriatric subjects were the disorders of the musculoskeletal system (714)
eye and adnexa (497) oral cavity (329) endocrine nutritional and metabolic
disorders (329)etc some disorders like cataract dental caries constipation and
increased frequency of micturition were more common among males whereas disease
like anemia and hypertension were more common among females A significant
association was found between some of the morbidities and socio demographic
determinants like age occupation and religion
Any degree of formal schooling was found to be associated with better health seeking
behavior Majority of the subjects (58) visited a Government health facility in case of
an illness and the main reason that was stated for not visiting a health facility was that
they suffered from mild discomfort (444) and did not consider it necessary to visit a
health facility
Key words Geriatric urban behaviour morbidity
xi
Introduction
INTRODUCTION
ldquoA STUDY ON THE MORBIDITY PATTERN AND HEALTH SEEKING BEHAVIOUR AMONG THE GERIATRIC POPULATION IN THE URBAN FIELD
PRACTICE AREA OF JJM MEDICAL COLLEGE DAVANGERErdquo
All countries of the world are experiencing population ageing Ageing is a result of
decreasing mortality and most importantly declining fertility The global share of older
people (aged 60 years and above) has increased from 92 per cent in 1990 to 117 in
2013 and will continue to grow as a proportion of the world population reaches 211 by
20501
The lsquoNational Policy for Older Personsrsquo was adopted by the Government of India in
January 1999 and it defines a lsquosenior citizenrsquo or lsquoelderlyrsquo as a person who is aged 60 years
or above Ageing is a progressive process associated with declines in structure and
function impaired maintenance and repair systems increased susceptibility to disease and
death2
In 2015 Worldwide there were 901 million people aged 60 years or over It is
projected that their number will grow to 14 billion in 2030 which is the target date for the
SDGs and to 21 billion by 2050 There will be growth in the number of older persons aged
60 years and above between 2015 and 2030 This increase is projected to be especially
significant global phenomenon and virtually every country in the world will experience a
substantial increase including the less developed regions3 The increased life expectancy has
led to challenges in health care management The elderly suffer from various diseases which
include non-communicable disease (NCDs) like diabetes hypertension coronary heart
disease and other disorders like osteoarthritis stroke dementia osteoporosis cancer
1
Introduction enlarged prostate depression and cataract related blindness In the coming years there will
be a phenomenal growth in the population of the elderly while the family size will reduce
The disintegration of the joint family and women moving out of the household has led to the
absence of traditional caregivers for the elderly who are already a vulnerable group4
The most common cause of health problems in the old aged people is chronic diseases
Most of these problems can be prevented or delayed by engaging in healthy behaviours
Even in the advanced years of life physical activity and good nutrition can have
effective benefits on health and well-being Many health problems of old age can be
effectively managed if they are detected early enough5 The National Policy for Older
Persons was announced by the Government of India in the year 1999 The Constitution of
India under Article 41 mandates the well-being of senior citizens ldquoThe state shall
within the limits of its economic capacity and development make effective provision
for securing the right to public assistance in case of old aged peoplerdquo 6
National Council for Older Persons (NCOP) has been reconstituted and renamed as
National Council for Senior Citizens (NCSrC) in order to have a definite structure and also
regional balancing the NCOP advises the Central and State Governments on a broad range
of issues related to welfare of senior citizens and enhancement of their quality of life The
NCSrc meets at least twice a year7 The elderly suffer from multiple medical as well as
psychological problems There has already been some pioneering work on the elderly in
India but a lot more remains to be done There is an urgent need to pay attention
towards the medical and socio-economic problems that are being faced by the elderly
people in India and thus formulate strategies to bring about an improvement in their
quality of life8 The Health seeking behaviour is influenced by various factors which
include the individual self diseases and the availability and accessibility of health
2
services It is important to have knowledge regarding the health seeking behaviour of
individuals for designing health care policies and programmes so that all the possible
difficulties with early diagnosis and effective treatment can be identified and appropriate
interventions can be implemented9 As already stated the elderly are a vulnerable group as
there are psychological as well as physiological changes with increasing age and it is
difficult to cope up with the problems of ageing Some of the most common problems in old
age are cardiovascular problems arthritis respiratory problems blood pressure and so on
Therefore the study of the health status of elderly morbid conditions perceptions about
it is important to note and the health care of the elderly becomes very important since they
are more prone to illness than young people and are also more prone to domestic and other
accidents Their health and treatment seeking behaviour are most important for the
formulation of welfare programmes of the country 10
Hence this study was taken up in the urban field practice area of JJM Medical College
Davangere to assess the morbidity pattern and health seeking behaviour of the geriatric
subjects
3
Objectives
OBJECTIVES
1 To study the morbidity pattern among the geriatric population in the urban field
practice area of JJM Medical college Davangere
2 To assess the health seeking behaviour of the elderly residing in the study area
4
Review of literature
vii
REVIEW OF LITERATURE
1 Definition Geriatrics or clinical gerontology Is the term used for the care of the aged 11 The United Nations uses 60 years and above to refer to older people the same is also used
by demographers However in many developed countries the age of 65 is used as the
reference point for older persons 12
Elderly are classified in to 3 groups 13
Young old Persons in the age group of 60 years to 74 years
Old old Persons in the age group of 75 years to 84 years
Oldest old Persons above the age of 85 yrs
2 Demography of the ageing population in India
The UN defines a country as ldquoAgeingrdquo or ldquoGreying Nationrdquo where the
proportion of people over 60 reaches 7 percent to total population By 2011 India has
exceeded that proportion (80 percent) and is expected to reach 126 percent in 2025
The Indian population has increased from 361 million in 1951 to 1027 billion in 2001
and further to 121 billion in 2011 Simultaneously the number of older people has
increased from 19 million (ie 4 percent of total population) to 77 million and
further to roughly 93 million (ie 75 percent of the total) during the same time
span 14
5
Review of literature
Figure1 proportion of elderly in the Indian population by age groups 1961-2001 14
Table 1 Percentage share of elderly population (aged 60 years and above) in total
population by sex in India 15
Years Male Female Total Rural Urban
1961 55 58 56 58 47
1971 59 60 60 62 50
1981 64 66 65 68 54
1991 67 68 68 71 57
2001 71 78 75 77 67
2011 77 84 80 81 79
2004-05 69 75 72 73 70
2007-08 73 77 75 76 72
6
Review of literature
The rise in population of males was more modest from 55 percent to 71 percent while for
females there had been a steep rise from 58 percent to 78 percent during five decadal
Censuses from 1961 to 2001 In 2011 the elderly population accounted for 80 percent of
total population For males it was marginally lower at 77 percent while for females it was
84 percent According to NSSO surveys the proportion of elderly population in rural areas
was 73 percent during 2004-05 and increased up to 76 percent in 2007-08 While on the
other hand in urban areas the proportion of elderly population rose from 70 percent to 72
percent during the corresponding period It has been observed that the percentage share of
elderly to total population remained higher in rural areas than in urban areas15
Table2 Size of elderly population (aged 60+) and their share in total population in major states of India in 201115
All India and selected major states
Proportion of elderly in total population of State
Male Female Total Andhra Pradesh 83 94 88 Bihar 72 67 70 Gujarat 76 90 83 Haryana 66 76 71 Himachal Pradesh 104 103 104 Karnataka 79 89 84 Kerala 118 133 126 Madhya Pradesh 68 74 71 Maharashtra 88 97 93 Orissa 91 95 93 Punjab 91 100 95 Rajasthan 66 79 72 Tamil Nadu 102 109 105 Uttar Pradesh 66 71 68 West Bengal 82 82 82 All India 77 84 80
7
Review of literature
3 MORBIDITY PATTERN AMONG THE ELDERLY
Physiological Decline and Consequences of increasing age
Ageing i s a process of decline in biological functions affecting most physical
Systems The following systems are affected by ageing
(a) Atrophy of the Taste Buds and Loss of Teeth
With the increasing age the taste buds of the tongue get atrophied and as a result the
preference for food alters significantly There is also a considerable loss of teeth causing
difficulties in chewing food
(b) Changes in the Gastrointestinal Tract
As the age advances the walls of the intestine get atrophied and the motility is
markedly reduced (lazy intestine) The digestive enzymes secreted by the intestine are
also reduced Hence the partly digested food stays in the intestine for a longer period
As a result the common complaint of the elderly person is gas formation (flatulence)
and constipation
(c) Respiratory System
As the age advance there is progressive fibrosis of the lungs leading to reduced
oxygenation of the lungs and breathing difficulties
(d) Kidney and genitourinary System
The kidneys get smaller in size and the power of the kidneys to filter out the unwanted
waste products from the body is diminished The total amount of urine becomes less in
old age and thus the waste products are not adequately excreted from the body
8
Review of literature
(e) Urinary Bladder
Urinary bladder gets smaller in size due to shrinkage and as a result the accumulation
of urine even of a small amount leads to an urge for urination With increase in age
the valve in the bladder which controls the exit of urine from the bladder to urethra
gets atrophied and weak Involuntary leakage of urine occurs in case the bladder is full
or due to increase of pressure on bladder on sneezing or even on laughing a condition
known as urinary incontinence Incontinence is a common complaint of elder females
(f) Heart and Circulatory System
The blood vessels get rigid and quite often the vessel walls become rough with the
deposition of solid matters consisting mostly of cholesterol The heart muscles get weaker
and power to send blood throughout the body through the circulatory system gets less and
less powerful The most dangerous effect on heart is coronary heart disease especially
coronary thrombosis
(g) Muscular system
The muscles in the body get gradually atrophied with ageing and especially those
small muscles which are necessary for quick reflex action The elderly person can quite
be capable of working like a normal person and can undertake activities which require
big muscles of legs and arms But when it comes to quick movement which needs small
muscles for quick reflex movements these functions are impaired causing accidents
like slipping on wet floor of the bathroom
(h) Brain
With ageing the size of the brain gets smaller and the weight also becomes less This
however does not interfere with the function of the brain However in general the brain
cells and its fibers which carry impulses from brain to the system and upwards get
9
Review of literature
degenerated The most glaring manifestation of ageing affecting the brain is
forgetfulness and in simple terms it is inability of brain to recall the past experience
However this is common in all elderly persons
(i ) Bones
The bones become porous and fragile as age advances especially in elderly females This
condition is known as osteoporosis and leads to sustaining of fractures even after a minor
fall16
Figure 2 pathophysiology of health issues in geriatrics17
The common disease that the geriatric population suffers from are type 2 diabetes
coronary heart disease hypertension stroke chronic obstructive pulmonary disease
10
Review of literature
Alzheimerrsquos disease osteoarthritis osteoporosis prostatic hypertrophy cataracts macular
degeneration cancer etc and at the same time they are vulnerable to infections involving
respiratory (including TB) urinary and digestive tract17
In India the elderly people suffer from dual medical problems ie communicable and
nonndash communicable diseases There is also impairment of special sensory functions like
vision and hearing A decline in immunity and age-related physiological changes leads to
an increased burden of communicable diseases in the elderly A report by Indian Council
of Medical Research (ICMR) on the chronic morbidity profile in the elderly states that
hearing impairment is the most common morbidity followed by visual impairment
However different studies show varied results in the morbidity pattern18
Major chronic conditions affecting older people worldwide 19
Cardiovascular diseases (such as coronary heart disease) Diabetes Mellitus
Hypertension Stroke Cancer
Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease
Musculoskeletal conditions (such as arthritis and osteoporosis)
Mental health conditions (mostly dementia and depression)
Blindness and visual impairment
11
Review of literature
Health seeking behaviour
1 Definition
There is no common definition agreed upon by sociologists in any sociology literature
Different definitions may be used in different studies despite referring to the same activity
Sociology and literature assume that health seeking behaviour is influenced by the various
factors which include individual self or the individual diseases present and also the
availability and accessibility of health services Being dependent on these determinants and
their interactions it can be said that health care seeking behaviour is a very complex
outcome of various factors which operate at individual family and community level20
Health Seeking Behavior (HSB) refers to decision or an action taken by an individual to
maintain attain or regain good health and to prevent illness The decisions which are
made encompasses all available health care options like visiting a public or private and
modern or traditional health facility self-medication and use of home remedies or not to
utilize the available health services etc
Determining the health care seeking behavior is very important to provide a need
based health care services to the population Visiting official channels in a formally
recognized health care system has been considered as the desired Health seeking behaviour
Health seeking behavior is influenced by multiple factors including availability quality and
price of services and also social groups health views residences and personal features of the
users Peoplersquos choice of health care differs in socio demographic socio-economic and
cultural compositions and this has an effect on their health seeking behavior Urban dwellers
are generally believed to be open to new ideas and willing to try certain things on a trial and
error basis21
12
Review of literature
Health seeking behaviours two approaches
(a) Health seeking behaviours utilization of the system
This approach focuses on the actions which are taken to rectify perceived ill health and
the type of health care facility which is utilized by the people There is data which
suggests that the people visit more traditional healers and unofficial medical channels
this should be prevented and the emphasis s h o u l d b e on encouraging people to opt
first for the official channels
(b) Health seeking behaviours the process of illness response
This approach considers the factors which enable or prevent people from making
healthy choices either i n their lifestyle behaviours or use of medical care and
treatment22
Figure 3 Predicting health behaviour with social cognition models 22
13
Review of literature
2 Health belief Model of health seeking behaviour
Since lsquoHealth seekingrsquo is a conditioned behaviour any attempt which is made to
encourage people to seek health care definitely requires an understanding of their
motivation for such behaviour Only through a deeper understanding of the intricate
factors shaping behavioural practices can health promotion programmes and or
interventions successfully be introduced into the realities of the peoplersquos lives to bring
about changes in health behaviour
Behaviour change theories and models such as the Health Belief Model (HBM)
Theory of Reasoned Action (TRA) Theory of Planned Behaviour (TPB) and the
Trans theoretical model have been widely applied in public health in an attempt to
explain or predict health seeking behaviours Their use enables identification and
understanding of peoplersquos health-seeking behaviour beyond their knowledge attitudes
and practices
HBM is a health specific behavioural cognitive model This model is based on the
idea that people are more likely to change their behaviour and adhere to treatments
if they have the following perceptions (i) have a perception that they are at risk of
contracting the disease (perceived susceptibility) (ii) perception that the disease
might have an unfavorable outcome (perceived severity) (iii) perceive that the
proposed health behaviour to be both effective and practical (perceived benefits)
(iv) perceive the barriers to adopting the behaviour to be minimal (perceived
barriers)(v) perceive themselves to have the ability of applying and practicing the
specific behaviour proposed (perceived self-efficacy) and (vi) they have the cues
for motivating their actions such as internal cues (pain symptoms past experiences)
or external cues (advice from friends relatives and mass media campaigns) (cues to
14
Review of literature
action) The specificity of the HBM to health has made it suitable for use in
understanding and explaining the behaviour as well as health outcomes and this may also
explain its wider use in public health2 3
Figure 4 Health belief model components and linkages 23
3 Factors influencing health seeking behaviour
The factors affecting the health seeking behaviours are seen in various contexts which
include physical socio-economic cultural and political factors Therefore the utilization of
a health care system whether public or private formal or non- formal may depend on socio-
demographic factors social structures level of education cultural beliefs and practices and
some other factors like gender discrimination status of women economic and political
systems environmental conditions and the disease pattern and health care system itself also
have an impact on the health seeking behaviour24
15
Review of literature
REVIEW OF RELATED STUDIES
A study done by Sanjay Polisetty and Madhavi Seepana (2017) on the morbidity profile
of elderly individuals in urban Visakhapatnam revealed that of the 270 study participants
about 996 suffered from either some form of acute or chronic morbidity More than 70
of individuals suffered from eye problems of which most common problem was cataract
seen in 60 About 304 had difficulties in chewing and 256 had difficulty in hearing
Hypertension was present in 49 of individuals and 742 of Diabetics were also found to
be hypertensive25
A study done by Swapnil Jain et al (2016) on Morbidity pattern among geriatric
population in urban field practice area of a district in Maharashtra revealed 653 suffered
from hearing impairment 62 were anemic 462 had hypertension 423 had joint
pain 41 had dental problems 38 7 had cataract and 318 had chronic bronchitis It
was seen that 81 of the subjects had multiple morbidities 26
A study done by Rajat Das Gupta et al (2016) in an urban area of Bangladesh on Morbidity
pattern and health-seeking behavior among the senior citizens revealed that of the 384 study
participants 968 were suffering from at least one medical problem The commonest was
musculoskeletal problems in 8411 followed by eye problems in 8125 It was found that
all the respondents sought treatment for their health problems 33 respondents went to
Government hospitals to seek medical help 6927 respondents took prescribed
medications and 567 were satisfied with their treatment 27
16
Review of literature
A study done by Md Alam Naushad et al (2016) on Morbidity pattern and health
seeking behavior in elderly population of Raipur City Chhattisgarh revealed that the
prevalence of morbidity among elderly was 9531 Out of total morbid population some
chronic illness was present in 7049 Gastro intestinal system was involved in 8262
followed by eye in 7983 and Cardiovascular system in 5245 It was found that 3552
of the subjects sought treatment from private registered practitioners 28
A study done by Sribas Goswami and Manjari Sahai (2016) in Raipur city on Morbidity
Pattern in elderly Population revealed that out of total study population of 640 elderly
subjects 610 (9531) suffered from some morbidity Prevalence among females was
9892 whereas among males it was 9026 Out of various agencies 3552 subjects
were utilizing private facility followed by 2785 who were utilizing Government agency
2631 visited quacks and 1030 were taking treatment from other source 29
A study done by Harsh Bardhan et al (2016) on the Morbidity profile of elderly population
in Ghaziabad district revealed that in geriatric population 5008 suffered from
musculoskeletal problems 5877 had dental problems and impairment of vision was seen
in 5561 The overall prevalence of diabetes and heart disease were 10 and 122
respectively 236 subjects reported the problem of loneliness and depression
forgetfulness was also reported by 3296 As far as treatment seeking behavior is
concerned approach of elderly is quite different for different morbidities The main source
of treatment for morbidities such as hypertension respiratory urinary GIT-related and
musculoskeletal problems was quacks 30
17
Review of literature
A study done by Mohammad Maharoof et al (2016) on the health problems among
the aged in Urban Aligarh UP revealed that of the 225 study subjects 782 had cataract
followed by depression in 356 refractive error in 276 loco-motor problem in 213
and hearing loss in 138 The prevalence of hearing loss was significantly related to gender
as it was higher among females with 181 compared to males in whom it was 6931
A study done by Gowri Shankar and Bhayalaxmi Sidenur (2016) on morbidity of
elderly residing in an urban area of Bagalkot revealed that the most common morbidity was
Cataract seen in 2875 followed by musculoskeletal problems in 2813 and 2313
were known hypertensive Both diabetes mellitus and hypertension was observed in 10 of
the study subjects32
A study done by Leena Rahul Salunkhe (2015) on socio-demographic profile of old
age people living in urban amp urban slum areas in Maharashtra Karad revealed that 504
and 42 elderly suffered from arthritis in an urban area and a slum respectively Number of
diabetics were higher in urban (14) than urban slum (35) 301 of subjects from urban
area suffered from hypertension compared to 161 from urban slums Upper Respiratory
Infections was more in slum dwellers (196) than people residing in urban area (7) Acid
peptic diseases were found in 168 study subjects in urban area and 154 in slum area 33
In a study done by Warbhe Priyanka A and Warbhe Rupesh (2015) on morbidity
profile health seeking behaviour and home environment survey of the elderly in an urban
slum community it was found that 941 had 1-3 morbidities 41 had 4-6 morbidities
373 gave a history of fall and 314 had history of fracture 136 subjects had been
18
Review of literature
operated for cataract 168 had undergone a procedure for fracture and10 had undergone
a dental procedure 542 went to Urban health center (UHC) and Government hospitals for
treatment and 786 received both allopathic and Ayurvedic treatment34
A study done by Man Mohan Gupta et al (2015) on Assessment of Clinico-
socioeconomic status and health-care support among the elderly people aged older than 60
years in urban population of Bhopal revealed that 353 subjects received treatment for
their morbidities from the Government hospitals whereas 267 from private
clinichospital About 653 study subjects presented with complaints and morbidity The
common morbidities which were found in the subjects were fatigue (487) backache
(353) Obesity (393) and hypertension (247)35
In a study done by Shilpa Shaukaiah et al (2015) on prevalence of morbidity pattern
among geriatric age group in an urban slum of Mumbai it was found that body ache was the
most commonly reported symptom by 290 followed by visual problems in 2318 joint
pain in 2181 indigestion in 2045 and backache in 2045 subjects36
A study done by Shubha Davalagi B et al (2015) on morbidity psycho-social profile and
health seeking behavior of the elderly population in urban slums of Davangere City revealed
that the most common morbidity which was present in the study subjects was
musculoskeletal problems in 46 psychosocial problems were present in 31 and
respiratory problems in 23 Majority of the elderly (56) utilized government
institutions for treatment of chronic disease and 47 for treatment of acute disease The
elderly population had financial constraints and lack of accessibility in seeking health care37
19
Review of literature
A study done by Vandana Nikumb et al ( 2015) on morbidity Profile among Geriatric
Population in an Urban Area of Navi Mumbai revealed that 9312 elderly were morbid and
with increasing age the number of morbidities was found to be increasing In this study it
was found that the most common morbidity was psychosocial problems which include
stress which was present in 594 subjects followed by musculoskeletal problems in
556 and eye problems like diminished vision mostly due to cataract in 463
Hypertension dental problems respiratory problems ENT problems (hearing impairment)
and endocrine disorders like diabetes accounted for 281 219 119 106 and10
respectively38
A study done by Vishnoi BR et al (2015) on Morbidity Profile of Elderly in Urban
Slum of Udaipur Rajasthan revealed that 61 of the study subjects had impaired vision
followed by 25 who had hypertension 1533 suffered from insomnia 1467 had
anemia and 14 suffered from gastrointestinal problems The condition of females was
worse compared to males39
In a study done by L Subedhi and RB Sah (2015) on the health status of geriatric age
group in Chitwan district of Nepal it was found that of the 300 study subjects 44 had
Ophthalmic problems 43 had GIT problems 33 had CVS problems 23 had ENT
problems 1567 had metabolic disorders and 533 had mental disorders The study
highlighted a high prevalence of morbidity and health related problems in the geriatric age
group40
20
Review of literature
A study done by Sofia Noor et al (2015) on health status of geriatric population in slums
of Rourkela revealed that the morbidities among the elderly that were found to be significant
were hypertension decreased visual acuity urinary problems and insomnia Apart from
systemic morbidities 91 of the elderly also complained of fragility which includes
complex physiological deterioration and unexplained weight loss41
In a study conducted by VM Sarode (2014) on Chronic Diseases Related to Ageing and
Disease Prevention in Slums in Mumbai it was found that there were highly significant
disorders among aged women related to Skin lesion and super infection Untreated bacterial
pharyngitis acute rheumatic fever while disorders among aged men were related to
hypertension Illicit drug use diabetes and asthma It was found that 49 of elderly males
and 45 of elderly females had not sought any treatment for their illness Of the people who
had sought treatment 93 elderly males and 92 of elderly females had taken treatment
from Government hospital42
A study conducted by Sanjeev Kumar Barman et al (2014) on morbidity profile of
geriatric population in an urban slum of Kishnganj Bihar revealed that the prevalence of
anemia cataract and hypertension were quite high 6375 6125 and 5063
respectively Loss of income amp occupation along with a feeling of neglect from the family
members were the common problems among the elderly It was also found that morbidities
like arthritis loss of teeth amp dental caries along with depression had a significant association
with sex age amp educational status of the study subjects43
21
Review of literature
A study done by Khadervali Nagoor et al (2014) on the health status of elderly
population in an urban area of Kadapa revealed that out of the 200 elderly persons studied
Visual problem due to cataract and refractive errors were present in 72 of the study
subjects followed by pain in joints in 595 gastrointestinal problems in 46 and dental
problems in 44 Other morbidities were hypertension in 42 genitourinary problems in
25 dermatological problems in 235 and psychological problems in 1644
A study done by Kakkar R et al (2013) on morbidity profile among geriatric population
in District Dehradun revealed that the working geriatric group was healthy as compared to
those who were retired Hypertension was the commonest morbidity among all age groups
In the age group of 60-70 years the following morbidities were seen hypertension (306)
followed by diabetes (153) arthritis (14) CVS morbidities (14) cataract (96) and
BPH (83) Among 71-80 years age group Hypertension (287) followed by arthritis
(167) cataract (157) Diabetes (111) BPH (111) and CVS morbidities (93)45
In a study done by Bhawalkar JS et al (2013) on morbidity profile among geriatric
population in an urban area of Pune it was found that Musculoskeletal disorder was the
most common (4331) followed by eye problems (3722) and hypertension (137)It
was seen that 43 elderly population had some health problem but only 8 visited the
health facilities Among them 6 visited private practitioners and only 18 went to
municipal hospitals It was found that only 2322 elderly were taking any medications and
the most commonly used drug was anti-inflammatory drugs 2323 followed by
antihypertensive drugs 136746
22
Review of literature
A study conducted by Deepak Sharma et al (2013) on morbidity pattern and health-
seeking behavior of aged population residing in Shimla revealed that the following
morbidities were present in the study subjects hypertension was the commonest (56)
followed by Musculoskeletal problems (535) Dental problems (27) cataract (23)
anemia (15) and acid peptic disease (175) 658 of the subjects were seeking
treatment for their health problems Majority of the older people preferred allopathic
medicine (812) followed by Ayurvedic medicines (113) and homeopathic medicine
(73) for their health problems Most of the older persons preferred going to a
CHCGovernment hospital for treatment for their illness There was considerable use of
over-the-counter drug by125 of the people 47
A study done by JP Singh et al (2013) on Geriatric morbidity profile in an urban slum of
Nagpur central India revealed that the most common morbidity identified in the study
population was anemia (9650) followed by hypertension (345) arthritis (3225)
cataract (21) and diabetes (1775) More than 2 morbidities were present in 325 of
the study subjects followed by four morbidities in 3125 and two morbidities in 23548
A study conducted by RP Thakur et al (2013) on the health problems of the elderly in
central India revealed that among the elderly residing in the urban areas 384 of the urban
elderly had both dental problems and arthritis followed by anemia in 348 hypertension in
266 cataract in 252 and diabetes mellitus in 157 The prevalence of self-reported
depression was 672 among the urban female elderly when compared to 397 among the
urban females49
23
Review of literature
A study done by Mrinal Ranjan Srivastav et al (2013) on Morbidity Status and its
Social determinants among elderly population of Lucknow revealed that the most common
morbidity among the urban population was eye problems which affected 516 males and
67 females followed by CVS problems in 363 males and 395 females and GIT
problems in 315males and 382 females50
A study done by Shraddha K et al (2012) on morbidity pattern among elderly in urban
population of Mysore revealed that out of the 526 study subjects 486 suffered from the
disease of the eye and adnexa followed by 384 who suffered from endocrine and
metabolic disorders 331 suffered from the disease of the circulatory system 323 had
disease of the oral cavity and salivary glands and 302 had disease of the musculoskeletal
system 51
A study done by Vimala Thomas et al (2012) on morbidity profile and health seeking
behaviour of the elderly in urban slums of Hyderabad revealed that hypertension was the
most common morbidity in 469 followed by Arthritis in 302 Diabetes in 265
respiratory problems in 243 and Cataract in 21 For out-patient treatment 472 visited
private sectors 303 Government facility 25 RMP and 06 AYUSH clinics For in-
patient treatment 198 visited private institutions 16 visited Government institutions
while 642 did not visit either52
24
Review of literature
A study done by Soe Moe et al (2012) on health seeking behaviour of elderly in
Myanmar revealed that 35 of the male elderly perceived that they were having good
health status whereas 229 of them perceived having a poor health status 343 of female
elderly perceived that they were having good health status while 24 of them perceived
having a poor health About 49 of the elderly went to rural health center for treatment
followed by 33 who went to private practitioners 15 visited hospitals and 3 went to
more than one place for treatment53
A study done by Dharamvir Ranjan Bharati et al (2011) in Puducherry revealed that in
the urban areas about 707 of the study subjects had anemia followed by 537 who had
visual impairment and hypertension and 532 suffered from diabetes mellitus It was seen
that On univariate analysis the risk of diabetes mellitus was significantly higher among
elderly from urban areas than that among elderly from rural areas and significantly lower
risk in elderly from below poverty line than in those belonging to normal (not below poverty
line)54
A study done by Rajashree Bhat et al (2011) on the morbidity pattern among the elderly
population in Ahmedabad revealed that most common morbidity of elderly was the
problems of loco-motor system (486) followed by vision (427) and hypertension
(344) In this study only 37 of elderly had psychosocial problems55
A study done by Krishnamachari Srinivasan et al (2010) in an urban area of Bangalore
revealed that 494 subjects had hypertension 323 had diabetes 281 had arthritis
279 suffered from Genitourinary and cardiovascular disease It was observed that about
25
Review of literature
49 of the respondents made less than three physician visits and 13 were hospitalized for
health related problems during the past one year 56
A study done by Kajal Srivastava et al (2010) on the morbidity pattern of the elderly in
urban Agra revealed that 9529 of the elderly were morbid in the slum areas The most
common morbidity which was seen among the elderly people residing in urban slums was
anemia which was seen in 3843 followed by cataract in 298 arthritis in 2431 and
hearing impairments in 2157The system wise distribution of the morbidity pattern
showed the most common systemic involvement was visual disorders 5216 followed by
musculoskeletal system 4784 and the gastrointestinal system 4314 The number of
morbidities was found to be increasing with age and this association with age was
statistically significant57
A study done by Abdullah Ladha et al (2009) on the health seeking behaviour of elderly
population in a poor-urban community of Karachi Pakistan revealed that 164 of the
elderly people were Diabetic and 301 had Hypertension The Common symptoms that
prompted elderly of to seek health care were fever (612) generalized body aches (434)
and cough (404) About 614 responders reported factors which deterred them from
seeking health care out of which 62 reported financial constraint as the commonest factor
Deterrence from seeking health care was associated with illiteracy and living alone58
26
Methodology METHODOLOGY
The study was conducted in the urban field practice area of JJM Medical college
Davangere The city of Davangere is situated in the central part of Karnataka state
265 km north of the state capital Bengaluru along the national highway number 4
Figure 5 Maps showing the location of Davangere district and the area where the
UHTC is located
27
Methodology
Figure 6 Map showing the Urban field practice area of JJM medical college
28
Methodology
Table 3 List of areas covered under the UHTC of JJM Medical
College Davangere
Areas covered Total population Bethur road 1374 Hedge nagar 1213 Mehboob nagar 3042 Mustafa nagar A 2093 B D layout A 1084 Mustafa nagar B 1127 Mahavir nagar 930 Muddabovi colony 1094 Maganhalli 1221 Tippu nagar 968 B D layout B 1717 Batti layout 1080
STUDY AREA The study was conducted in the urban field practice area of JJM
Medical College Davangere which consists of 12 areas with a total population of
16943
STUDY DESIGN Cross sectional study
STUDY POPULATION Persons aged 60 years and above
Total Population Covered 16943
29
Methodology
INCLUSION CRITERIA subjects aged 60 years and above living in the study area
for more than one year duration
EXCLUSION CRITERIA Subjects who we r e no t w i l l i ng t o pa r t i c ipa t e i n
t he s t udy
STUDY PERIOD 1 year from 1st December 2015 to 30th November 2016
SAMPLE SIZE As quoted by Manmohan Gupta et al 35 in the studies done in various
parts of India the prevalence of morbidity in the geriatric population ranges from 31-80
Considering the prevalence of morbidity to be about 50 in the geriatric population at 95
confidence level and allowable error of 10 and a non -response rate of 10 sample size
was calculated to be 440 using the formula
n=4pq L2
n= sample size
4= factor to achieve 95 level of confidence
p= prevalence of morbidities ie 50
q= 100- p ie 100-50 = 50
L= permissible error in the estimate of ldquoprdquo (10 of p)
n = 4 x 50 x 50 = 400
5 x 5
After calculating a non-response rate of 10 a sample size of 440 was calculated
30
Methodology
A community based cross sectional study was conducted in the urban field practice
area of JJM Medical College Davangere The Urban field practice area has a total
population of 16943 and there are 12 areas in urban field practice area of JJM Medical
College Davangere
The Study was conducted by probability proportionate sampling The sample size for each
area was derived from the formula
1198991 =119875119900119901119906119897119886119905119894119900119899 119894119899 119890119886119888ℎ 119886119903119890119886
119879119900119905119886119897 119875119900119901119906119897119886119905119894119900119899119883 119878119886119898119901119897119890 119878119894119911119890
Example 1st area has a population of 1374 so
1198991 =1374
16943119883 440 = 36
Therefore 36 elderly subjects were selected by house to house visit from 1st area Same
procedure was applied for other areas until the desired sample size of 440 was reached
MATERIALS USED FOR DATA COLLECTION
The following tools were used for data collection
Semi-structured predesigned and pre-tested questionnaire
Portable bathroom weighing machine
Stretch- resistant measuring tape
Mercury Sphygmomanometer
Others - stethoscope torch tuning fork knee hammer
ICD-10 for system wise classification of disease59
31
Methodology METHOD OF COLLECTION OF DATA After establishing rapport with the family
and explaining the data collection procedure in the local language an informed verbal
consent was obtained from each individual and data was collected using a
Predesigned semi structured questionnaire by Interview method The questionnaire
comprised of the following information socio-demographic data of the study subjects
information regarding the morbidity pattern and health seeking behaviour If there were
more than one elderly subjects in the same household then all were included
The study subjects were asked about any ho illness (communicable or non-
communicable) which they were suffering from Upon a positive response the subjects were
further asked to specify the type(s) and duration of morbidities that they were suffering
from eg heart disease diabetes gastrointestinal diseases respiratory disease etc Some
were unable to understand or answer questions due to illness In such cases help was sought
from the family members Based on the self-reported symptoms information from
hospital records and clinical examination the prevalence of different morbidities among the
study subjects was assessed The Information about the health seeking behaviour was
sought by asking the study subjects about their visits to a health facility in case of an illness
and also the type of health facility visited ( Government private or quacks )
DATA ENTRY AND ANALYSIS Data was entered and analyzed using MS Excel and
Open Epi Info version 2260 Both descriptive and inferential statistics were used Subjectrsquos
baseline characteristics were presented as frequencies and percentages Categorical
variables between the groups were compared using Chi square test and Fisherrsquos exact
test Fisherrsquos exact test was used when more than 20 cells had expected value lt 5 and any
one of the cells had expected value lt 1 All statistical analysis was carried out at 5 level
of significance and p value lt005 was considered as significant
32
Methodology ETHICAL CLEARANCE
Ethical clearance was obtained before conducting the study from the Ethical Committee of
JJM Medical college Davangere [ANNEXURE III] During the study verbal
informed consent was taken from the study subjects Assurance was given that the
confidentiality concerning their information will be maintained
Clinical Examination included
(a) General physical examination
(b) Anthropometric measurements like height and weight
(c) Systemic examination
(d) Measurement of Blood pressure
(e) Eye examination by torch and Snellenrsquos (E chart)61
(f) Hearing assessment by Rinnersquos test Webberlsquos and Absolute bone conduction
test using tuning fork 62
Parameters used in our study
Height Height was measured with a standard non-stretchable measuring tape to the
nearest 01 cm in standing position (without footwear standing upright with the
back against the wall heels together and eyes directed forward)
33
Methodology Weight Weight was measured with minimal clothing and respecting the modesty of the
individual without footwear using a calibrated standard bathroom weighing scale to the
nearest 05 kg
Body Mass Index (BMI) Using weight (in Kg) and height (in meter2) BMI was calculated by applying the formula
Body Mass Index= Weight (kg) Height (m2)
The BMI cut off values for Asians as recommended by the WHO was used in our study
Table 4 WHO Categorization of Body Mass index (BMI) for Asians 63
Measurement of Blood pressure Procedure Blood pressure was measured in the left arm in a sitting posture with the subject in a
relaxed state Standardized mercury sphygmomanometer with adult size cuff was used
The first appearance of (phase 1 of Korotkoff sounds) sound was used to define
Systolic Blood Pressure (SBP) The disappearance of sound (phase 5) was used to
define Diastolic Blood Pressure (DBP) Two readings were taken five minutes apart and
the average of the two readings was taken as the final blood pressure reading A person
was considered to be a hypertensive if he she was already diagnosed case of
hypertension and or on treatment or with a current SBP of ge 140 mm Hg or DBP ge 90 mm
Hg (JNC VII criteria)64
BODY MASS INDEX INFERENCE
lt 185 underweight
185 to 229 kg m2 Normal
23 to 249 kg m2 Overweight
ge 25 kg m2 Obese
34
Methodology
Table 5 JNC VII Classification of Blood pressure 65
BP Classification Systolic Blood Pressure Diastolic Blood Pressure
Normal lt120 lt 80
Pre Hypertension 120 ndash 139 or 80 ndash 89 Stage 1 Hypertension 140 ndash 159 or 90 ndash 99 Stage 2 Hypertension ge 160 or ge 100
Anaemia was detected by pallor of conjunctiva tongue and nails and was confirmed by
doing haemoglobin estimation using sahlirsquos hemogobinometer66
The cut off for the diagnosis of anaemia was done based on WHO classification67
Diabetes - self reported cases of diabetes were considered as diabetics for the study
STUDY VARIABLES
1 AGE - subjects aged 60 years and above were taken up for the study Age was
recorded to the nearest complete years as stated by the respondent
2 GENDER Both males and females were taken up for the study
3 EDUCATIONAL STATUS 68
i Illiterate -A person who could not read or write
ii Primary School - studied up to 4th standard
iii Higher primary- studied between 5th and 7th standard
iv Secondary school -studied between 8th and 10th standard v Intermediate- studied between 11th or 12 th standard or diploma
vi Graduate - obtained graduate degree
vii Post Graduate- obtained post graduate degree
35
Methodology
4 OCCUPATION STATUS69
i Unskilled worker
Labourer domestic servants casual worker peon sweeper porter washer-man others
(vegetable vendor)
ii Semi-skilled worker
Factory worker agriculture laborers shoemaker potters others (security guard shop
helper canteen helper
iii Skilled
Artisan clerk foreman supervisor carpenter tailor mechanic electrician railway guard
painter modeler smiths baker driver shop assistant petty trader constable soldier
linesman pointsman potter barber others (tinkering printer receptionist salesman
welder cook mason postman plumber agarbatti worker)
iv semi-professional
Teacher pharmacist social worker owner of a small business farmer others (computer
programmer Govt employee nurse)
V Professional
Doctor engineer principal lawyer Military officer senior executive business
proprietor writer scientist large employer director university professor police
officer others (horse rider)
(vi) Unemployed Presently not working retired homemakers
36
Methodology 5 SOCIO ECONOMIC STATUS
Table 6 Socio-economic status (SES)- As per modified BG Prasad Classification70
5 TYPE OF FAMILY 71
Joint Family ndash It is type of family grouping in which a number of married couples and
their children live together in the same household All the men are related by blood
and women of household are their wives unmarried girls and widows of family kinsmen
Nuclear Family - It consist of married couple and their children while they are still
regarded as dependents
Three generation family - It is a family where representatives of three generation are
living together Young married couples continue to stay with their parents and have
their own children as well
Socio-economic
status
Prasadrsquos classification
1961(Per capita income in
Rupees per month)
Modified BG Prasad classification-
updated for May 2016 ((per
capita income in Rupees per
month)
I 100 and above 6261 and above
II 50-99 3099-6260
III 30-49 1835-3098
IV 15-29 949-1834
V Below 15 lt948
37
SAMPLE SIZE ESTIMATION
SAMPLE SIZE As quoted by Manmohan Gupta et al 35 in the studies done in various
parts of India the prevalence of morbidity in the geriatric population ranges from 31-80
Considering the prevalence of morbidity to be about 50 in the geriatric population at 95
confidence level and allowable error of 10 and a non -response rate of 10 sample size
was calculated to be 440 using the formula
n=4pq L2
n= sample size
4= factor to achieve 95 level of confidence
p= prevalence of morbidities ie 50
q= 100- p ie 100-50 = 50
L= permissible error in the estimate of ldquoprdquo (10 of p)
n = 4 x 50 x 50 = 400
5 x 5
After calculating a non-response rate of 10 a sample size of 440 was calculated
A community based cross sectional study was conducted in the urban field practice area of
JJM Medical College Davangere The Urban field practice area has a total population of
16943 and there are 12 areas in urban field practice area of JJM Medical College
Davangere
The Study was conducted by probability proportionate sampling The sample size for each area
was derived from the formula
1198991 =119875119900119901119906119897119886119905119894119900119899 119894119899 119890119886119888ℎ 119886119903119890119886
119879119900119905119886119897 119875119900119901119906119897119886119905119894119900119899119883 119878119886119898119901119897119890 119878119894119911119890
Example 1st area has a population of 1374 so
1198991 =1374
16943119883 440 = 36
Therefore 36 elderly subjects were selected by house to house visit from 1st area Same
procedure was applied for other areas until the desired sample size of 440 was reached
Results
RESULTS
The results are presented under the following headings
I Socio-demographic characteristics of study subjects
II Prevalence of morbidities among the study subjects
III Details of health seeking behavior of the study subjects
38
Results
ISocio-demographic characteristics of the study subjects
Table 7 Age and sex wise distribution of the study subjects
Figure 7 Age and sex wise distribution of the study subjects
In the present study Out of 440 study subjects majority 162(368) were in the age group
of 60-64 Years followed by 109 (247) in the age group of 65-69 Years 99 (225) were
in the age group of 70-74 Years and 35 (8) were more than or equal to 80 years of age
Majority of the subjects were males 260 (59) and 180 (41) were females The mean age
of the study population was 6745 plusmn 655 Years
354 254 262
88 42
389
239 172
67 133
0102030405060708090
100
60-64 65-69 70-74 75-79 ge80
Perc
enta
ge
Age in years
Males
Females
Age group (in years)
Males Females Total
Percentage () Frequency
(n=260) Percentage ()
Frequency (n=180)
Percentage ()
60-64 92 354 70 389 162 368
65-69 66 254 43 239 109 247
70-74 68 262 31 172 99 225
75-79 23 88 12 67 35 80
ge80 11 42 24 133 35 80
Total 260 100 180 100 440 100
39
Results
Table 8 Distribution of the study subjects based on religion
Religion Frequency (n=440) Percentage ()
Hindu 188 427
Muslim 252 573
Total 440 100
Figure 8 Distribution of the study subjects based on religion
In the present study it was found that the majority of the study subject belonged to Muslim
religion 252 (573) followed by Hindus 188 (427)
0102030405060708090
100
Hindu Muslim
427
573
Perc
enta
ge
Religion of the study subjects
40
Results
Table 9 Distribution of the study subjects based on Educational status
Education Frequency (n=440) Percentage ()
Illiterate 231 525
Primary school 121 275
Higher primary 38 86
Secondary School 30 68
Intermediate 6 14
Graduate 14 32
Total 440 100
Figure 9 Distribution of the study subjects based on Educational status
In the present study it was found that the Majority of the study subjects were illiterate
231(525) 121(275) had completed education up to primary school 30(68) had
completed education up to secondary school and only 14(32) were graduates
525
275
86 68
14 32
0102030405060708090
100
Perc
enta
ge
Educational status of study subjects
41
Results Table 10 Distribution of the study subjects based on occupation
Occupation Frequency (n=440) Percentage ()
Semi-professional 2 05
Skilled worker 45 102
Semi-skilled worker 68 155
Unskilled worker 100 227
Unemployed 225 511
Total 440 100
Figure 10 Distribution of study subjects based on their occupation
In our study it was found that the majority of the study subjects 225 (511) were
unemployed followed by 100 (227) who were unskilled workers 68 (155) were semi-
skilled workers and 45 (102) were skilled workers
0102030405060708090
100
05 102 155 227
511
Perc
enta
ge
Occupation of the study subjects
42
Results Table 11 Distribution of the study subjects based on socio-economic status (Modified
BG Prasad classification 2016)
Figure 11 Distribution of the study subjects based on their socio-economic status
In our study majority of the subjects 215 (49) belonged to Class IV Socioeconomic status
followed by 115 (26) who belonged to class III and 56 (13) who belonged to class II
SES (according to Modified BG Prasad Classification 2016)
Class II 13
Class III 26
Class IV 49
Class V 12
Socio-economic status Frequency (n=440) Percentage ()
Class I 0 0
Class II 56 13
Class III 115 26
Class IV 215 49
Class V 54 12
Total 440 100
43
Results
Table 12 Distribution of the study subjects based on their marital status
Marital status Frequency (n=440) Percentage ()
Unmarried 2 05
Married 323 734
Widowwidower 115 261
Total 440 100
Figure 12 Distribution of the study subjects based on their marital status
In our study it was found that majority of the study subjects 323(734) were married
followed by 115(261) who were widowed and only 2 (05) were unmarried
0102030405060708090
100
Unmarried married Widowwidower
05
734
261 Perc
enta
ge
44
Results
Table 13 Distribution of the study subjects based on the type of family
Type of family Frequency (n=440) Percentage ()
Nuclear family 163 37
Joint family 93 21
Three generation family 184 42
Total 440 100
Figure 13 Distribution of the study subjects based on the type of family
In the present study it was found that majority of the study subjects 184 (42) lived in a
three generation family followed by 163 (37) who lived in a nuclear family and 93(21)
who lived in a Joint family
Nuclear family 37
Joint family 21
Three generation
family 42
45
Results
II Prevalence of morbidities among the study subjects
Figure 14 Distribution of the study subjects based on the BMI
In the present study it was found that out of 440 study subjects 198 (45) had a normal
BMI followed by 132 (30) who were overweight 66 (15) were obese and only 44
(10) were underweight
under weight 10
Normal 45
Overweight 30
Obese 15
46
Results
Table 14 Distribution of morbidity pattern of the study subjects based on ICD 10
classification of diseases
System involved ICD 10
Males (n=260)
Females (n=180)
Total (n=440)
No No No
Diseases of musculoskeletal system (M00 ndash M99)
184 707 130 722 314 714
Diseases of the eye and adnexa (H00 ndash H59)
139 534 80 444 219 497
Diseases of oral cavityamp salivary glands (K00 ndash K14)
90 346 64 355 154 35
Endocrine nutritional amp metabolic diseases (E00 ndash
E90)
70 269 75 417 145 329
Diseases of circulatory system (I00 ndash I99)
64 246 73 405 137 311
Diseases of respiratory system(J00 ndash J99)
64 246 37 206 101 23
Diseases of digestive system (K00 ndash K93)
57 219 30 166 87 198
Diseases of skin amp subcutaneous tissue (L00 ndash
L99)
38 146 20 111 58 132
Diseases of the ear and mastoid process (H60 ndashH95)
39 15 18 10 57 13
Diseases of genitourinary system (N00 ndash N99)
22 85 7 39 29 66
Diseases of nervous system (G00 ndash G99)
6 23 5 28 11 25
Note Total number could not be given as many subjects had multiple disorders
47
Results
Figure 15 Distribution of morbidity pattern of the study subjects based on ICD 10
classification of diseases
In the present study it was found that the majority of the subjects 314 (714) suffered
from the disorders of the musculoskeletal system followed by 219 (497) who suffered
from the disease of the eye and adnexa154 (35) suffered from the disease of the oral
cavity 145 (329) suffered from endocrine nutritional and metabolic disorders137
(311) suffered from the disease of the circulatory system 101 (229) suffered from the
disease of the respiratory system 87(198) suffered from the disease of the digestive
system 58 (132) suffered from disease of the skin 57 (13) suffered from the disease of
the ear 29 (66) suffered from the disease of the genitourinary system and only 11( 25 )
suffered from the disease of the nervous system
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
714
497
35 329 311 229
198 132 13 66
25
perc
enta
ge
48
Results
Table 15 Distribution of the study subjects based on morbidity of the musculoskeletal
system
Musculoskeletal
Disease
Males
(n=260)
Females
(n=180)
Total
(n= 440)
Statistical
Value
Knee joint pain
52 (20)
30 (167)
82 (186)
X2 = 0779
df = 1
p=03773
Back ache
30 (115)
35 (194)
65 (148) X2 = 528
df = 1
p = 0021
Joint pain (other than
knee joint pain)
52(20)
35(194)
87(198)
X2 =00206
df=1
p =0885
Non-specific aches
and pain
50(192)
30(167)
80(182)
X2=0470
df=1
p = 0492
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses
In the present study it was found that the most common morbidity of musculoskeletal
system was pain of the joints (other than the knee joint) found in 87 (198) of the subjects
followed by knee joint pain in 82 ( 186) and non-specific pains and aches were found in
80 (182) of the subjects It was found that back ache was more common in females
35(194) compared to males 30 (115) and this difference was found to be statistically
significant
49
Results
Table 16 Distribution of the study subjects based on morbidity of the eye and adnexa
Diseases of the
eye and
adnexa
Males
(n=260)
Females
(n=180)
Total
(n= 440)
Statistical
value
Cataract
112(43)
60(333)
172(391)
X2 = 4241
df=1
p = 0039
Refractive error
20(77)
14(78)
34(77)
X2= 0001
df=1
p = 0973
Others (conjunctivitis
pterygium glaucoma etc)
7(27)
6(33)
13(29)
X2=0152
df=1
p = 0696
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses
In the present study it was found that the most common morbidity of the eye was cataract
found in 172 (391) of the subjects It was more common in males 112 (43) compared to
females 60 (333) and this difference was found to be statistically significant The other
morbidities present were refractive error found in 34 (77) subjects and others which
includes conjunctivitis pterygium glaucoma etc found in 13 (29 ) subjects
50
Results
Table 17 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the oral cavity
Diseases of the
oral cavity
Males
(n =260 )
Females
(n =180 )
Total
(n = 440)
Statistical
value
Stained teeth
22 (84)
18 (10)
40 (91)
X2 =0304
df=1
p = 0581
Missing teeth
40 (154)
38 (211)
78 (177)
X2= 239
df= 1
p=0122
Caries
28 (108)
8 (44)
36 (82)
X2= 566
df= 1
p=0017
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses
In the present study it was found that the most common morbidity of the oral cavity was
missing teeth found in 78 (177 ) of the subjects followed by stained teeth found in 40
(91) of the subjects and dental caries in 36 (82) of the subjects Dental caries were
more common in males 28 (108) compared to females 8(44) and this difference was
found to be statistically significant
51
Results
Table 18 Distribution of study subjects based on endocrine nutritional and metabolic
disorders
Disorders Males
(n =260 )
Females
(n =180)
Total
(n = 440)
Statistical value
Diabetes mellitus
45 (173)
37 (206)
82 (186)
X2 = 0739
df= 1
p = 0389
Anemia
24 (92)
35 (194)
59 (134)
X2= 955
df = 1
p = 0001
Thyroid disorders
1(04)
3 (17)
4 (09)
p= 0309
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
The present study revealed that the most common disorder of the endocrine system was
diabetes mellitus found in 82 (186) of the subjects followed by the nutritional disorder of
anemia found in 59 (134) of the subjects It was seen that anemia was more common
among females 35 (194) compared to males 24 (92) This difference was found to be
statistically significant Disorders of the thyroid gland were found in 4 (09) of the subjects
being more common in females 3(17) compared to males 1 (04)
52
Results
Table 19 Distribution of the study subject based on disease of the circulatory system
Diseases of
circulatory
system
Males
(n=260 )
Females
(n =180)
Total
(n = 440)
Statistical
value
Hypertension
62 (238)
71 (394)
133 (302)
X2= 1227
df= 1
p = 0000
CAD MI
Arrhythmias
2 (08)
2 (11)
4 (09)
p =100
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
In our study it was found that the most common disease of the circulatory system was
hypertension which was found in 133 (302 ) of the subjects it was more common in
females 71 (394) compared to males 62 (239) and this difference was found to be
statistically significant The other disorders of the circulatory system were CAD MI
arrhythmias which were found only in 4 (09) of the study subjects
53
Results
Table 20 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the respiratory system
Disorders of
Respiratory
System
Males
(n=260)
Females
(n=180)
Total
(n=440)
Statistical
value
Bronchial asthma
3 (12)
3 (17)
6 (14)
p =0692
URTI
45 (173)
27 (15)
72 (164)
X2= 0413
df = 1
p = 0520
Acute Bronchitis
12 (46)
7 (39)
19 (43)
X2= 0135
df = 1
p = 0712
Pulmonary TB
4 (15)
0(00)
4 (09)
p =0148
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
Our study revealed that the most common disease of the respiratory system was URTI
(upper respiratory tract infection) found in 72 (164) subjects followed by acute bronchitis
in 19 (43 ) bronchial asthma in 6 (14) and pulmonary TB in only in 4 (09 ) subjects
Pulmonary TB was found in 4 (15) of the males whereas no females had TB however
this difference was not found to be statistically significant
54
Results
Table 21 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the digestive system
Disorders of
Gastrointestinal
system
Males
(n = 260)
Females
(n = 180)
Total
(n = 440)
Statistical value
Constipation
21(8)
6 (33)
27(61)
X2 =4155
df =1
p =0041
Gastritis
24 (92)
18 (10)
42(95)
X2= 0072
df = 1
p =0787
Bleeding per
rectum 3(12) 2(11) 5(11)
p =100
Others (Pain
abdomen
anorexia
indigestion)
9(35)
4 (22)
13 (3)
X2=0569
df =1
p=0450
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
Our study revealed that the most common disorder of the gastrointestinal system was
gastritis found in 42 (95) subjects followed by constipation in 27 ( 61) others which
include pain abdomen anorexia indigestion was found in 13 (3) and bleeding per rectum
was seen in 5 (11) It was seen that constipation was more common among males 21(8)
compared to females 6 (33) which was found to be statistically significant
55
Results
Table 22 Distribution the study subjects based on disease of the Skin and
subcutaneous tissue
Disorders of skin and
subcutaneous tissue
Males ( n = 260)
Females (n = 180)
Total (n = 440)
Statistical
value
Itching
19(73)
2(11)
21(48)
X2 =896
df=1
p = 0002
Scaling 6 (23)
3 (17)
9 (2)
p =0743
Pigmentation
5(19)
4 (22)
9 (2)
p =100
Dryness
8 (31)
11 (61)
19(43)
X2= 237
df = 1
p = 0123 Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
In the present study it was found that the most common disease of the skin was itching
which was present in 21 (48) of the study subjects followed by dryness in 19 (43) and 9
(2) of the subjects had scaling and pigmentation It was seen that itching was more
common among males 19 (73) compared to females 2 (11) and this difference was
found to be statistically significant
56
Results
Table 23 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the ear
Disease of the ear
Males
(n= 260)
Females
(n = 180)
Total
(n = 440) Statistical value
Hearing impairment
33 (126)
16 (89)
49 (111)
X2 =155
df =1
p =0212
Ear discharge
3 (12)
1 (06)
4(09)
p =0647
Tinnitus
3 (12)
1 (06)
4 (09)
p =0647
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
In the present study it was observed that hearing impairment was the most common
morbidity of the ear found in 49 (111) of the subjects though it was more common
among males 33 (126) compared to females 16 (89) the difference was not found to be
statistically significant The other disorders which affected the ear were ear discharge and
tinnitus both present in 4 (09) of the subjects
57
Results
Table 24 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the genitourinary
system
Disorders of
genitourinary system
Male
(n = 260)
Female
(n = 180)
Total
(n=440)
Statistical value
Burning micturition
2 (077)
2 (11)
4 (09)
p=100
Increased frequency of
micturition
20(77) 5(28) 25(57)
X2= 4794
df =1
p =0028 Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
In our study it was observed that the most common morbidity affecting the genitourinary
system was increased frequency of micturition in 25 (57) of the subjects followed by
burning micturition in 4 (09) of the study subjects Increased frequency of micturition was
more common among males 20 (77) compared to females 5 (28) and this difference
was found to be statistically significant
58
Results
Table 25 Distribution of the study subjects based on diseases of the Nervous system
Disease of the
nervous system Males
(n = 260)
Females
(n = 180)
Total
(n = 440)
p value
Memory loss
2 (77)
2 (11)
4 (09)
100
Stroke
2 (77)
0 (00)
2 (05)
0515
Neuritis
2 (77)
3 (17)
5 (11)
0652
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
Our study revealed that the most common disorder of the nervous system was neuritis seen
in 5 (11) of the subjects followed by memory loss in 4 (09) and stroke in 2 (05 ) of
the subjects It was observed that 2 (0 77) of males had suffered a stroke whereas none of
the females had suffered from stroke however this difference was not found to be
statistically significant
59
Results
Table 26 Association between morbidity pattern of the study subjects and their age
group
System involved 60-69Yrs
(n = 271)
70-79Yrs
(n = 134)
gt 80Yrs
(n = 35)
Total
( n = 440)
Statistical
value
Musculoskeletal
System
195 (72)
94 (70)
25 (710)
314 (714) X2= 0143
df = 2 p = 0930
Eye amp adnexa
125 (461)
69 (515)
25 (714)
219 (497) X2= 8166
df = 2 p = 0016
Oral cavity amp salivary gland
56 (207)
68 (507)
30 (857)
154 (350) X2= 7865
df = 2 p lt 00001
Endocrine nutritional amp
metabolic diseases
91 (335)
47 (35)
7 (200)
145 (329) X2= 297
df = 2 p = 0225
Circulatory
system
87 (321)
40 (298)
10 (285)
137 (311) X2= 0328
df = 2 p = 0848
Respiratory
system
64 (236)
31 (231)
6 (171)
101 (23) X2= 0738
df = 2 p = 0691
Digestive system
52 (191)
28 (210)
7 (200)
87 (191) X2= 0166
df = 2 p = 0 920
Skin and subcutaneous
tissue
43 (159)
13 (97)
2 (57)
58 (132) X2= 4831
df = 2 p = 0089
Ear amp mastoid process
27 (99)
20 (149)
10 (285)
57 (13) X2= 1018
d= 2 p = 0006
Genitourinary
system
20 (74)
8 (59)
1 (29)
29 (66) X2= 1151
df = 2 p = 0562
Nervous system
5 (18)
4 (29)
2 (57)
11 (25)
p = 0418
Figure in parenthesis indicates percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
60
Results
Table 26 shows the association between the morbidity pattern and age group of the study
subjects It is observed that the disease of the eye and adnexa increase with increasing age
and are more common in individuals above 80 years of age (714) compared to
individuals in the age group of 60-69 years (461) and 70-79 years (515) This
difference was found to be statistically significant The disease of the oral cavity were also
more common in the subjects aged 80 years and above (857) compared to individuals in
the age group of 70-79 years (507) and 60-69 years (207) this difference was also
found to be statistically significant Significant association was also found between
increasing age and disease of the ear 285 subjects aged 80 years and above suffered from
disease of the ear followed by 149 in the age group of 60-69 years and 99 in the age
group of 60-69 years
61
Results Table 27 Association between morbidity pattern of the study subjects and their
occupation
System involved Employed (n=215)
Unemployed (n=225)
Total (n=440)
Statistical value
Musculoskeletal
system
171 (795) 143 (635) 314 (714) X2 =1374 df=1
p=00002
Eye and adnexa 108 (502) 111(493) 219(497) X2= 0035 df=1
p= 0850
Oral cavityamp
salivary glands
76 (353) 78 (347) 154 (35) X2=0022 df=1
p=0880
Endocrine
nutritional amp
metabolic
disease
75 (348) 70 (311) 145 (329) X2=0708 df=1
p=0400
circulatory
system
58 (269) 79 (351) 137 (311) X2=3393 df=1
p=0065
Respiratory
system
49 (227) 52 (231) 101 (23) X2=0006 df=1
p=09363
Digestive system 45 (21) 42 (187) 87 (198) X2=0125 df=1
p=0723
Skin
subcutaneous
tissue
38 (176) 20 (88) 58 (132) X2=741 df=1
p=0006
Ear and mastoid
process
31 (144) 26 (115) 57 (13) X2=0799 df=1
p=0371
Genitourinary
system
16 (74) 13 (57) 29 (66) X2=0494 df=1
p=0481
Nervous system
2 (093) 9 (4) 11 (25) X2=425 df=1
p=0039 Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses
62
Results
Table 27 shows the association between the morbidity pattern and occupation of the study
subjects It was observed that musculoskeletal disorders were more common among the
subjects who are employed (795) compared to those who are not employed (635) and
this difference was found to be statistically significant A significant association was also
seen between the disorders of the skin and subcutaneous tissue 176 subjects who are
employed suffered from the disease of the skin and subcutaneous tissue compared to 88
who were unemployed The diseases of the nervous system were more common among
those who were unemployed (4) compared to those who were employed (093) this
difference was also found to be statistically significant
63
Results Table 28 Association between morbidity pattern of the study subjects and their
religion
System involved Hindu
(n=188)
Muslim
(n=252)
Total
(n=440)
Statistical value
Musculoskeletal system 138 (73) 176 (698) 314 (714)
X2=0668 df=1
p=0413
Eye and adnexa 100 (531) 119 (472) 219 (497) X2=1535 df=1
p= 0215
Oral cavityamp salivary glands 73 (388) 81 (321) 154 (35)
X2=211 df=1
p=0145
Endocrine nutritional amp metabolic diseases
53 (2819) 92 (365) 145 (329) X2=3371 df=1
p=0066
circulatory system 58 (269) 79 (351) 137 (311)
X2=3393 df=1
p=0065
Respiratory system
33 (176) 68 (269) 101 (229)
X2=5415 df= 1
p=0019
Digestive system 27 (144) 60 (238) 87 (198) X2=6059 df=1
p=0013
Skin subcutaneous tissue
31 (164) 27 (107) 58 (132) X2=3138 df=1
p=00765
Ear and mastoid process
28 (149) 29 (115) 57 (129) X2=1095 df=1
p=0297
Genitourinary system
16 (85) 13 (52) 29 (66) X2=1965 df=1
p=0161
Nervous system
4 (21) 7 (28) 11(25) p=0764
Figure in parenthesis indicates percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
64
Results
Table 28 shows the association between the morbidity pattern of the study subjects and their
religion In our study it was observed that the disorders of the digestive system were more
common among Muslims (238) compared to Hindus (144) this difference was found
to be statistically significant Also the disorders of the respiratory system were more
common among Muslims (269) compared to Hindus (176) This difference was also
found to be statistically significant Some of the diseases were more common among Hindus
which include the disease of the eye and adnexa (531) oral cavity (388) ear (149)
skin and subcutaneous tissue (164) and genitourinary system (85) but it was not found
to be statistically significant
65
Results
III HEATLTH SEEKING BEHAVIOR OF THE STUDY SUBJECTS
Figure16 Distribution of the study subjects based on the visit to health facility in case
of an illness
In our study it was found that that out of 440 study subjects 395(898) visited a health
facility in case of an illness whereas 45(102) did not visit any health facility in case of an
illness
898
102
health facility visitednot visited
66
Results
Table 29 Reasons cited by the study subjects for not seeking healthcare in case of an
illness
In the present study it was found that the most common reason stated by the 45 study
subjects for not seeking health care in case of an illness was that it was a mil 20 (444)
followed by lack of money stated by12 (267) the other reasons stated were no one to
accompany 7 (156) and lack of faith in health care 6 (133)
Reasons cited for not
seeking health care
Frequency (n=45)
Percentage ()
Mild discomfort 20 444
Lack of money 12 267
Lack of faith in
healthcare
6 133
No one to accompany 7 156
Total 45 100
67
Results
Table 30 Distribution of the study subjects based on the type of health facility visited
It was observed that out of 395 subjects who visited health care facility in case of an illness
229(58) Visited government hospitals 160 (405) visited private practitioners hospitals
and 6 (15) visited quacks More number of males (622) visited government hospitals
compared to females (513)
Type of health facility visited
Males
(n=241)
Females
(n=154)
Total
(n=395)
No No No
Government hospital 150 622 79 513 229 58
Private practitionershospitals 87 361 73 474 160 405
Quacks 4 17 2 13 6 15
Total 241 100 154 100 395 100
68
Results
Table 31 Association between gender and health seeking behaviour of the study
subjects
Whether visited
health facility
in case of illness
Sex
Total
n ()
p value Male
n ()
Female
n ()
Yes 241 (927) 154 (856) 395 (898) 00151
No 19 (106) 26 (144) 45 (102)
Total 260 (59) 180 (41) 440 (100)
x2=5901 df =1
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
It was observed that more number of males visited a health care facility in case of an illness
241(927) whereas only 154(856) females visited a health facility in case of an illness
This difference was found to be statistically significant
69
Results
Table 32 Association between educational status and health seeking
behaviour of the study subjects
Whether visited Health facility in case of illness
p value
Educational status(n) Yes () No ()
0000
Illiterate (231) 194 (84) 37 (16)
Primary school (121) 115 (95) 6 (49)
Higher primary (38) 37 (974) 1 (26)
Secondary school (30) 29 (967) 1 (33)
Intermediate (6) 6 (100) 0(00)
Graduate (14) 14 (100) 0(00)
Total(440) 395 (898) 45(102)
Fisherrsquos exact test
In the present study it was found that 84 of the study subjects who were illiterate visited a
health facility in case of an illness whereas 16 did not visit a health facility in case of an
illness 967 of the subjects with education up to secondary school visited the health
facility and 100 of the subjects who studied up to intermediate and with a graduate degree
visited the health facility in case of an illness This difference was found to be statistically
significant
70
Results
Table 33 Distribution of study subjects according to frequency of visits to a health care facility
Frequency of visits to a health care facility
Frequency
(n=395)
Percentage
Once a month 207 524
Once in 3 months 99 251
Once in 6 months 79 20
Once in a year 10 25
Total 395 100
In the present study it was found that out of 395 study subjects who visited a health care
facility in case of an illness 207 (524) visited a health facility every month followed by
99 (251) who visited once in 3 months 79(20) once in 6 months and 10 25 visited
the health facility once in a year
71
Discussion
DISCUSSION
I Socio-demographic characteristics
Our study was done in the urban field practice area of JJM Medical College Davangere
among 440 geriatric subjects our study aimed at assessing the morbidity pattern and health
seeking behaviour of the geriatric population in the study area
In the present study Out of 440 study subjects majority 162(368) were in the age
group of 60-64 Years followed by 109 (247) in the age group of 65-69 Years 99 (225)
in the age group of 70-74 Years and 8 were more than or equal to 80 years of age [Table
7] This was similar to a study conducted by Prakash Boraingaiah et al 72 in which majority
of the elderly (346) belongs to age group 60-64 years followed by age group 75 years and
above (259)
In our study it was also seen that 59 of the study subjects were males and 41 were
females This was similar to a study conducted by Mohan Gupta et al 35 where 573
subjects were males and 427were females Our findings were contrary to a study
conducted by Md Alam Naushad et al 28 where 598 subjects were females and 402
were males
In the present study it was found that the majority of the study subject belonged to
Muslim religion 252 (573) followed by Hindus 188 (427) there were no study subjects
who belonged to other religions like Christian Jain Sikhs etc [Table 8] similar findings
were seen in a study conducted by Mrinal Ranjan Srivastav et al 50 in which 52 of the
subjects were Muslims
72
Discussion
In the present study it was found that the Majority of the study subjects were illiterate
525 whereas 275 had completed education up to primary school 82 had completed
education up to secondary school and only 32 were graduates [Table 9] These findings
were similar to a study done by Shraddha K et al 51in which 504 of the study subjects
were illiterate
In our study it was found that the majority of the study subjects 511 were unemployed
followed by 227 who were unskilled workers 155 were semi-skilled workers and
about 105 were skilled workers [Table 10] These findings were similar to a study done
by Rajat Das Gupta et al27 al in which 481 of the study subjects were not working
In our study majority of the subjects 49 belonged to Class IV Socioeconomic status
followed by 26 who belonged to class III and 13 who belonged to class II (according to
Modified BG Prasad Classification 2016) [Table 11] Similar findings were found in a study
conducted by Sribas Goswami and Manjari Sahai 29 in which majority of the study subjects
belonged to class IV socio economic status
In our study it was found that the majority of the study subjects 734 were married
followed by 261 who were widowed and only 05 were unmarried [Table 12] These
findings were similar to a study done by L subedhi and RB Sah 40 in which 663 of the
subjects were married 322 were widowed and 07 were unmarried
In the present study it was found that majority of the study subjects 42 lived in a three
generation family followed by 37 who lived in a nuclear family and 21 who lived in a
Joint family [Table 13] These findings were similar to a study done by Swapnil Jain et al 26
in which the majority (47) of the study subjects lived in a three generation family
73
Discussion
II Prevalence of morbidities among the study subjects
In the present study it was found that majority of the subjects 45 had a normal BMI
followed by 30 who were overweight about 15 were obese and only10 were
underweight [Figure 14] Similar findings were reported in a study conducted by Khadervali
Nagoor et al 44 in which 49 subjects had a normal BMI In a study done by Vimala
Thomas et al 52 272 of the subjects were obese which was higher than the present study
In the present study it was found that the majority of the subjects suffered from the
disorders of the musculoskeletal system (714) eye and adnexa (497) oral cavity
(311) respiratory system (229) digestive system (198)disease of the skin
(132)ear(13)genitourinary system (66) nervous system (25) [Table14] Similar
findings were seen in a study done by Rajashree Bhat et al 55 in which most common
morbidity of elderly was the problems of loco-motor system (486) followed by vision
(427) CVS disorders (344) respiratory system (202) and disease of ear (179)In
this study though the prevalence of loco-motor system disorders (486) was highest
compared to other disorders it was lesser compared to our study (714) In a study done by
L subedhi and RB Sah 40 it was found that 44 had eye problems 43 had gastrointestinal
problems 33 had CVS problems and 23 had ENT problems In this study the prevalence
of gastrointestinal disorders was much higher compared to our study
In the present study joint pain (including the knee joint) was most common disorder of the
musculoskeletal system seen in 40 of the males compared to 384 in females [Table 15]
whereas in a study done by Swapnil Jain et al 26 it was found that 472 males and 528
females suffered from joint pains This could be attributed to the fact that in our study
majority of the study subjects were males
74
Discussion
In the present study it was found that the most common morbidity of the eye was cataract
found in 39 of the subjects It was more common in males 43 compared to females
333 [ Table 16]These findings were similar to a study done by Shraddha K et al 51 in
which the overall prevalence of cataract was 302 of which 42 males and 358
females had cataract
In the present study it was found that the most common morbidity of the oral cavity was
missing teeth found in 177 of the subjects [Table 17] it was similar to the findings of a
study conducted by JP Singh et al 48 in which 1475 subjects were edentulous
The present study revealed that the most common disorder of the endocrine system was
diabetes mellitus found in 186 of the subjects followed by the nutritional disorder of
anemia found in 134 of the subjects It was seen that anemia was more common among
females 194 compared to males 92 [Table 18] Kakkar R et al 45 reported similar
findings with prevalence of diabetes mellitus as 153 In a study done by Deepak Sharma
et al 47 anemia was present in 15 of the subjects 97 males and 21 females were
anemic which was similar to our study
In our study it was found that the most common disease of the circulatory system was
hypertension which was found in 302 of the subjects it was more common in females
394 compared to males 239 and this difference was found to be statistically significant
[Table 19] A study by L Subedhi and RB Sah 40 reported that the prevalence of
hypertension was more among females (333) compared to males (30) which was
statistically significant
75
Discussion
In our study the most common morbidity of the respiratory system was upper respiratory
tract infection (163) [Table20] it was similar to the study done by Leena Rahul
Salunke33 where it was reported to be 196
In our study the most common disorder of the digestive system was gastritis (95)
[Table 21] similar to the findings of JP Singh et al 48 (35) contrary to this L subedhi
and RB Sah 40 reported a high prevalence of gastritis (39) This difference could be
attributed to the difference in the interpretation of symptoms for the diagnosis of gastritis
In our study the most common disorder of the skin was itching (48) [ Table 22] which
was similar to the findings reported by JP Singh et al 48 in which 225 subjects suffered
from itching
In our study the most common disorder of the ear was impaired hearing (111) [Table
23] similar to a study by Vandana Nikumb et al 38 in which 106 subjects suffered from
hearing impairment
In our study it was observed that the most common morbidity affecting the
genitourinary system was increased frequency of micturition (57) [Table 24]
L subedhi and RB Sah40 found in their study that 143 subjects suffered from increased
frequency of micturition which was higher compared to our study
Our study revealed that 25 subjects suffered from the disorders of the nervous
system [Table 25] similar to a study conducted by Vandana Nikumb et al 38 in which
13 of the Subjects suffered from the disorders of the nervous system whereas in a
study conducted by Shilpa Shaukaiah et al36 it was found that 66 of the subjects
suffered from the disorders of the nervous system which was higher than our study
76
Discussion
It is observed that the disease of the eye and adnexa increased with increasing age and were
more common in individuals above 80 years of age (714) The disease of the oral cavity
were also more common in the subjects aged 80 years and above (857) and 285
subjects aged 80 years and above suffered from disease of the ear A significant association
was found between age and these morbidities [Table 26] Similar results were found in a
study done by Swapnil Jain et al 26 in which cataract hearing impairment and dental
problems were significantly associated with the age of the study subjects
In our study a significant association was found between occupation and the disorders of
the musculoskeletal system skin and the nervous system Disorders of the musculoskeletal
system were more common among employed subjects (795) compared to unemployed
(635) 176 subjects who were employed suffered from the disease of the skin and
subcutaneous tissue compared to 88 who were unemployed Diseases of the nervous
system were more common among those who were unemployed (4) compared to those
who were employed (093) [Table 27]
A study done by Kakkar R et al45 found that there was a significant association between the
employment status and the morbidities of the CVS arthritis and cataract CVS morbidity
was more common among those not working (164) compared to those working (36)
Arthritis was also more common among not working (212) compared to those working
(55) and cataract was also more common among those not working (175) compared to
those working (55)
77
Discussion
In our study it was observed that there was a significant association between religion and
disorders of the digestive system and respiratory system The disorders of the digestive
system were more common among Muslims (238) compared to Hindus (144) Also the
disorders of the respiratory system were more common among Muslims (269) compared
to Hindus (176) [Table 28] In a study conducted by Mrinal Ranjan Srivastav et al 50 it
was found that there was significant association between religion and the morbidities of the
genitourinary system in the urban areas The problems of the genitourinary system were
more common among Hindus (26) compared to Muslims (96)
III HEATLTH SEEKING BEHAVIOR OF THE STUDY SUBJECTS
In our study it was found that that (898) study subjects visited a health facility in case
of an illness whereas 102 did not visit any health facility in case of an illness[Figure 16]
Similar findings were seen in a study conducted by Vimala Thomas et al 52 where it was
found that 716 subjects visited a health facility Contrary to our findings a study
conducted by Bhawalkar JS et al46 showed that only 81 subjects visited a health facility in
case of an illness whereas 919 did not visit any health facility
In the present study it was found that the most common reason stated by study subjects
for not seeking health care in case of an illness was that it was a mild discomfort (444)
followed by lack of money stated by (267) other reasons stated were no one to
accompany (156) and lack of faith in health care (133) [Table 29] In a study
conducted by Deepak Sharma et al 47 it was found that the most common reasons for not
seeking health care were the following disease due to age (496) health services too far
(191) lack of money (6) no body to take to hospital (35)
78
Discussion
It was observed that out of 395 subjects who visited health care facility in case of an illness
58 Visited government hospitals 362 visited private practitioners hospitals and 15
visited quacks [Table 30] similar results were found in a study conducted by Deepak Sharma
et al 47 in which 607 went to Government hospitals 267 consulted private practitioners
and 126 took over the counter drugs In another study conducted by Rajat Das Gupta et al
27 it was found that 33 visited Government hospitals 25 visited private hospitals 6
visited private practitioners
It was observed that more number of males (927) visited a health care facility in case of
an illness whereas only 856 females visited a health facility in case of an illness [Table
31] In a study done by Man Mohan Gupta et al 35 it was found that 672 females and
651 males visited a health facility in case of illness
In the present study it was found that 848 of the study subjects who were illiterate
visited a health facility in case of an illness whereas 152 did not visit a health facility in
case of an illness A significant association was found between educational status and
gender [Table 32] In a study done by Deepak Sharma et al 47 it was found that Gender
literacy income and marital status were not found to be significantly related to health-
seeking behaviour
In the present study it was found that 524 subjects visited a health facility every month
followed by 251 who visited a health facility once in 3 months 20once in 6 months
and 25 visited a health facility once in a year[ Table 33] In a study conducted by Rajat
Das Gupta et al 27 it was found that majority of the subjects (2943) visited a health
facility once a year followed by 2813 who visited a health facility once in three months
79
Conclusion
CONCLUSION
The study revealed that some of the common morbidities among the geriatric subjects were
the disorders of the musculoskeletal system followed by the disease of the eye and adnexa
oral cavity endocrine nutritional and metabolic disorders etc some disorders like cataract
dental caries constipation and increased frequency of micturition were more common
among males whereas disease like anemia and hypertension were more common among
females A significant association was found between some of the morbidities and socio
demographic determinants like age occupation and religion
Any degree of formal schooling was found to be associated with better health seeking
behavior Majority of the subjects visited a Government health facility in case of an illness
and the main reason that was stated for not visiting a health facility was that they suffered
from mild discomfort and did not consider it necessary to visit a health facility
80
Summary
SUMMARY
Our study was done in the urban field practice area of JJM Medical College Davangere
among 440 geriatric subjects our study aimed at assessing the morbidity pattern and health
seeking behaviour of the geriatric population in the study area
The results of our study are as follows
ISocio-demographic characteristics of the study subjects
In the present study 368 subjects were in the age group of 60-64 Years
59 of the subjects were males and 41 were females
573 subjects were Muslims whereas 427 were Hindus
Majority of the subjects were illiterate (525) whereas 275 had completed
education up to primary school
It was found that the majority of the study subjects (511) were unemployed
49 subjects belonged to Class IV Socioeconomic status according to Modified BG
Prasad Classification
734 of the subjects were married
42 of the people lived in a three generation family
II Prevalence of morbidities among the study subjects
Majority of the subjects (45) had a normal BMI followed 30who were
overweight
Majority 714 subjects suffered from the disorders of the musculoskeletal system
followed by 497 who suffered from the disease of the eye and adnexa35
suffered from the disease of the oral cavity 329 suffered from endocrine
nutritional and metabolic disorders and 311 suffered from the disease of the
circulatory system 229 suffered from the disease of the respiratory system198
81
Summary
suffered from the disease of the digestive system132 suffered from disease of the
skin13 suffered from the disease of the ear66 suffered from the disease of the
genitourinary system and 25 suffered from the disease of the nervous system
The most common morbidity of musculoskeletal system was pain of the joints (other
than the knee joint) found in 198 of the subjectsBack ache was more common in
females 231 compared to males 163 and this difference was found to be
statistically significant
cataract found in 39 of the subjects It was more common in males 43 compared
to females 333 and this difference was found to be statistically significant
Missing teeth were found in 177 of the subjects Dental caries were more
common in males 108 compared to females 44 and this difference was found to
be statistically significant
Diabetes mellitus found in 186 of the subjects followed by the nutritional disorder
of anemia found in 134 of the subjects anemia was more common among females
194 compared to males 92 This difference was found to be statistically
significant
Hypertension which was found in 302 of the subjects it was more common in
females 394 compared to males 239 and this difference was found to be
statistically significant
upper respiratory tract infection) found in 163 subjects followed by acute
bronchitis in 43 bronchial asthma in 14 and pulmonary TB in only 09
Gastritis was found in 95 subjects followed by constipation in 61 Among
males (81) had constipation compared to females(03)
Most common disease of the skin was itching which was present in 48 of the
study subjects followed by dryness in 43
82
Summary
Hearing impairment was found in 111 of the subjects
Increased frequency of micturition was found in 57 of the subjects followed by
burning micturition in 09 of the study subjects Increased frequency of
micturition was more among males 77 compared to females in whom it was 28
and this difference was found to be statistically significant
The most common disorder of the nervous system was neuritis seen in 11 of the
subjects followed by memory loss in 09 and stroke in 05 of the subjects
A significant association was found between increasing age and the morbidities of
the eye ear and the oral cavity
Significant association was found between occupation and the disorders of the
musculoskeletal system skin and the nervous system Disorders of the
musculoskeletal system were more common among employed subjects (795)
compared to unemployed (635) 176 subjects who were employed suffered
from the disease of the skin and subcutaneous tissue compared to 88 who were
unemployed Diseases of the nervous system were more common among those who
were unemployed (4) compared to those who were employed (093)
It was observed that the disorders of the digestive system were more common
among Muslims (238) compared to Hindus (144) this difference was found to
be statistically significant Also the disorders of the respiratory system were more
common among Muslims (269) compared to Hindus (176) This difference
was also found to be statistically significant
83
Summary
III HEATLTH SEEKING BEHAVIOR OF THE STUDY SUBJECTS
In our study 898 subjects visited a health facility in case of an illness whereas
102 did not
The most common reason stated by study subjects for not seeking health care in case
of an illness was that it was a mild discomfort (444) followed by lack of money
stated by (267) the other reasons stated were no one to accompany (156) and
lack of faith in health care (133)
It was observed that 58 subjects Visited Government hospitals 362 visited
private practitioners hospitals and 15 visited quacks
Majority of males (927) visited a health care facility in case of an illness whereas
only 856 females visited a health facility in case of an illness This difference was
found to be statistically significant
A significant association was found between the educational status and health
seeking behaviour Majority of the educated subjects visited a health facility in case
of an illness compared to those who were illiterate
It was found that 524 subjects visited a health facility every month followed by
251 who visited a health facility once in 3 months 20once in 6 months and
25 visited a health facility once in a year
84
Limitations
LIMITATIONS
1 Many of the responses were subjective and there were no records to verify them
2 Some of the morbidities were diagnosed only by clinical examination and could not be
confirmed by performing diagnostic tests due to high cost and time constraints
3 This study was done in the urban field practice area which consisted of a closed
community hence the results cannot be generalized to the entire population of the area
85
Recommendations
RECOMMENDATIONS
1 Health education should be given to the geriatric people regarding the common health
problems associated with ageing and preventive care should be provided to the elderly
2 Geriatric clinics should be set up at the primary health care level which provide regular
screening and health check-ups
3 There should also be a provision to provide domiciliary care by specialists qualified in
geriatrics
4 The family members and the care givers of the elderly should be educated about the
common health problems of the elderly and also about the need for regular health check-ups
and emotional support
5 The majority of the geriatric population is out of work force they are suffering from
many morbidities and are totally dependent on others even for their health needs Hence the
Government should increase the pension of the elderly and provide them quality healthcare
free of cost
6 There is also a need for public private partnership to improve the quality of health
services for the geriatric people More number of NGOs should work towards improving the
health and the quality of life of the elderly
86
References
REFERENCES
1 United Nations Department of Economic and Social affairs Population Division
World population ageing 2013 Available from URL
wwwunorgendevelopmentpopulationageingWorldPopulationAgeing2013
[Accessed on 17-7-2016]
2 Khan S and Itrat M Current Issues in Geriatric Health Care in India-A Review J Community Med Health Care 2016 1(1) 1-3
3 United Nations Department of Economic and Social Affairs Population Division
World Population Ageing 2015 ndash Highlights Available from URL
wwwunorgendevelopmentdesapopulationpdfageingWPA2015_Reportpdf
[Accessed on 272017]
4 State of elderly in India 2014 Help age India Available from URL
httpswwwhelpageindiaorgimagespdfstate-elderly-india-2014pdf [Accessed on
1082017]
5 World Health Organization World report on ageing and health 2015Available
from URL wwwwhointageingeventsworld-report-2015-launchen [Accessed on
1272017]
6 National policy for Senior citizens March 2011Ministry of Social Justice and
welfare Govt of India Available from URL
socialjusticenicinwritereaddataUploadFilednpscpdf [Accessed on 482017]
87
References
7 Elderly in India Profile and programmes 2016Govt of India Ministry of statistics
and programme implementation Central Statistics Office Available from URL
wwwmopsigovin [ Accessed on 1442017]
8 Saxena V Kandpal SD Gael D Bansal S Health status of elderly community
based study Indian Journal of Community Health2012 Oct-Dec24(4)269-74
9 Shah T Patel M Shah V Health care seeking behaviour of urban and rural
community in Ahmedabad district Int J Med Sci Public Health20132908-11
10 Sahoo H Mishra NR Health Status Morbidity Pattern and Treatment Seeking
Behaviour among Elderly in India Evidence from 60th round of National Sample
Survey Data Learning community 2011 Dec 2(3) 341-55
11 Park K Parkrsquos Textbook of Preventive and social medicine 24 th ed Jabalpur MS
Banarsidas Bhanot Publishers2017631
12 UNFPA- state of World Population 2011Chapter 1 setting the scene 19-31
Available from URL httpswwwunfpaorgsitesdefaultfilesresource-
pdfUNFPA-Report-Chapter1pd [Accessed on 1082017]
13 Lal S Adarsh Pankaj Textbook of community Medicine 4th ed CBS publishers and
distributors PvtLtd2011732
14 Census of India 2001 Registrar General And Census Commissioner India
Available from URL httpwwwcensusindiagovinCensus[Accessed on
7102015]
15 SRS bulletin October 2012 Registar General of India New Delhi Available from
URL censusindiagovinvital_statisticsSRS_BulletinsSRS_Bulletin-
October_2012[Acessed on 7102015]
88
References
16 Bagchi K Healthy ageing Health and Population-Perspectives and Issues 2000
23(1)11-16
17 Salagre SB The Association of Physicians of India Chapter 177 Health Issues in
Geriatrics Available from URL
wwwapiindiaorgmedicine_update_2013chap177pd [ Accessed on 282017]
18 Ingle GK Nath A Geriatric Health in India Concerns and Solutions Indian Journal
of Community Medicine 2008 33(4)214-18
19 World Health Organization Active Ageing a policy framework 2002 Available
from httpwhqlibdocwhointhq2002who_nmh_nph_028pdf [Accessed on
1062017]
20 Inche Zainal Abidin S Sutan R Shamsuddin K Prevalence and determinants of
appropriate health seeking behaviour among known diabetics Results from a
community-based survey Advances in Epidemiology 2014 Nov 20141-6
21 Begashaw B Tessema F Gesesew HA Health Care Seeking behavior in Southwest
Ethiopia Plos one 2016 Sep 11(9)e0161014
22 MacKian S Health systems development Manchester University of Manchester
2003 A review of health seeking behavior problems and prospects
23 Metta EO Health-seeking behaviour among adults in the context of the
epidemiological transition in Southeastern Tanzania A focus on malaria and
diabetes [Groningen] University of Groningen 2016 228 Available from URL
httpswwwrugnlresearchportalfiles28737720Chapter_7pdf [Accessed on
1272017]
24 Adhikari D Rijal D Factors affecting health seeking behaviour of senior citizens of
Dharan Journal of Nobel Medical College 2015 Sep 4(1)57-63
25 Polisetty S Seepana M Morbidity profile of elderly individuals in urban
Visakhapatnam Int J Community Med Public Health 2017 4(2)2558-63
89
References
26 Jain S Kaware AC Doibale MK Shaikh S Radhey BK Mathurkar MP Morbidity
pattern among geriatric population in urban field practice area of district of
Maharashtra a cross sectional study Int J Community Med Public Health 2016
3(2)523-29
27 Gupta RD Loha A Roy S Morbidity pattern and health-seeking behaviour among
the senior citizens in a selected urban area of Bangladesh A cross-sectional study
South East Asia Journal of Public Health 2016 Jul 5(2)43-49
28 Naushad MA Verma N Bhawnani D Jain M Anand T Umate LV Morbidity
pattern and health seeking behaviour in elderly population of Raipur City
Chhattisgarh India Indian Journal of Community Health2016 Sep 28(3)236-41
29 Goswami S Sahai M A Study of Morbidity Pattern in Elderly Population European
Researcher Series A 2016103(2)119-28
30 Bardhan H Dixit AM Agarwal R Jain PK Gupta S Shukla SK Morbidity profile
of elderly population in Ghaziabad district a cross-sectional study Int J Med Sci
Public Health 2016 5(6)1098-1102
31 Maroof M Ahmad A Khalique N Ansari MA Health problems among the aged A
community based study from urban Aligarh Uttar Pradesh India Int J Community
Med Public Health 2016 Feb 3(4)944-47
32 Shankar G Sidenur B A morbidity study of elderly residing in urban field practice
area of SN medical college Bagalkot National Journal of research in community
medicine 2016 Oct-Dec 4(5) 229-34
90
References
33 Salunkhe LR Socio-demographic profile of old age people living in urban amp urban
slum areas in Maharashtra Karad A comparative study J of Evidence based Med
and Hlthcare 2015 Feb 2(5) 513-21
34 Warbhe P Rupesh W Morbidity profile health seeking behaviour and home
environment survey for adaptive measures in geriatric population-Urban community
study International Journal of Medical Research amp Health Sciences 2015 4(4)778-
82
35 Gupta M Borle AL Chhari N Gupta S Assessment of clinico-socioeconomic
status and health-care support among the elderly people aged older than 60 years in
urban population of Bhopal Central India Int J Med Sci Public Health 2015
4558-64
36 Sahukaiah S Shenoy A Vijayakumar BC An epidemiological study of prevalence
of morbidity patterns among geriatric age group in an urban slum of Mumbai Int J
Med Sci Public Health 2015 Jul 4(7)883-87
37 Shubha Davalagi B Angadi N Mahabalaraju DK Morbidity psycho-social profile
and health seeking behaviour of the elderly population in urban slums of Davangere
City India Int J Res Med Sci 2015 Nov 3(11)3288-91
38 Nikumb V Patankar F Behera A A Study of Morbidity Profile among Geriatric
Population in an Urban Area Sch J App Med Sci 2015 3(3)1365-69
91
References
39 Vishnoi BR Solanki SL Singhal G Meharda B Mishra N Morbidity profile of
elderly in urban slum of Udaipur Rajasthan Int J Oral Health Med Res 2015 May
2(1)9-12
40 Subedi L Sah RB Study of the health status of geriatric age group in Chitwan
district of Nepal Journal of Chitwan Medical College 2015 Mar 5(1)11-17
41 Noor S Krishnababu G Prasad KV Health status of Geriatric population in slums
of Rourkela Young Innovative Journal of Medical and Health Science 2015 May
5(3) 92-94
42 Sarode VM Chronic Diseases Related to Aging and Disease Prevention in Slums in
Mumbai Journal of Aging Science 2014 Jan 2 (1)1-6
43 Barman SK Lata K Ram R Ghosh N Sarker G Shahnawaz K A study of
morbidity profile of geriatric population in an urban community of Kishanganj
Bihar India Global Journal of Medicine and Public Health GJMEDPH 2014 3(1)
1-7
44 Nagoor K Srikanth BA Dudekula R Satna K Comparative study of health status
among slum and non-slum elderly population in Kadapa Region South India
Journal of Evolution of Medical and Dental Sciences 2014 Feb 3(5)1298-308
45 Kakkar R Aggarwal P Kandpal SD Bansal SK An Epidemiological study to assess
morbidity profile among geriatric population in District Dehradun Indian Journal of
Community Health 2013 May 25(1)39-44
46 Bhawalkar JS Dhone AB Jethani S Singru S Jadhav SL Adyanthaya S A study of
morbidity profile among geriatric population in an urban area J Evol Med Dent Sci
2013 Sep 9 36(2)6963-7
92
References
47 Sharma D Mazta SR Parashar A Morbidity pattern and health-seeking behaviour of
aged population residing in Shimla hills of north India A cross-sectional study
Journal of family medicine and primary care 2013 Apr2(2)188
48 Singh JP Singh S Kasturwar NB Hassan A Geriatric morbidity profile in an urban
slum Central India Indian Journal of Community Health 2013 Aug 25(2)164-70
49 Thakur RP Banerjee A Nikumb VB Health Problems among the Elderly A Cross
Sectional Study Annals of medical and health sciences research 2013 3(1)19-25
50 Mrinal RS Beena S Pratibha G Pankaj B Srivastava JP Atul B Morbidity Status
and Its Social Determinants among Elderly Population of Lucknow District India
Sch J App Med Sci 2013 1(6)758-64
51 Shraddha K Prashantha B Prakash B Study on morbidity pattern among elderly in
urban population of Mysore Karnataka India International Journal of Medicine and
Biomedical Research 2012 1(3)215-23
52 Thomas V Lavanya KM Morbidity profile and health seeking behaviour of the
elderly in urban slums of Hyderabad Andhra Pradesh India- A cross sectional study
International Journal of Current Research and Review 2012 Oct 1 4(19)174-80
53 Moe S Tha K Naing DK Htike MM Health seeking behaviour of elderly in
Myanmar International Journal of Collaborative Research on Internal Medicine and
Public Health 2012 4(8)1538-44
93
References
54 Bharati DR Pal R Rekha R Yamuna TV Kar S Radjou AN Ageing in
Puducherry South India An overview of morbidity profile Journal of pharmacy amp
bio allied sciences 2011 Oct 3(4)537
55 Bhatt R Gadhvi MS Sonaliya KN Solanki A Nayak H An epidemiological study
of the morbidity pattern among the elderly population in Ahmedabad Gujarat
National Journal of community medicine 2011 Jul 2(2)233-36
56 Srinivasan Krishnamachari Vaz Mario Thomas Tinku Prevalence of health related
disability among community dwelling urban elderly from middle socioeconomic
strata in Bangaluru India Indian Journal of Medical Research 2010 Apr 131(4)
515-21
57 Srivastava K Gupta SC Kaushal SK Chaturvedi M Morbidity profile of elderly a
cross sectional study of urban Agra Indian Journal of Community Health 2010 Jun
22(1)51-55
58 Ladha A Khan R Malik A Khan S Khan B Khan I et al The health seeking
behaviour of elderly population in a poor-urban community of Karachi Pakistan
Journal of the Pakistan Medical Association2009 Feb 59(2) 89-92
59 WHO ICD-10 version 2010 Geneva World Health Organization Available from
URL appswhointclassificationsicd10browse2010en [Accessed on 772017]
60 OpenEpi22OpenEpi (free) download Windows version Available from URL
enfreedownloadmanagerorgWindows-PCOpenEpi-FREEhtml
61 Tandon R Sinhota Parsonrsquos disease of the eye 22edNew Delhi Elsevier 98-100
62 Dhingra P L Dhingra S Disease of ear nose and throat and head and neck surgery
6th ed New Delhi Elsevier 201422
94
References
63 Aziz N Kallur SD Nirmalan PK Implications of the revised consensus body mass
indices for Asian Indians on clinical obstetric practice Journal of clinical and
diagnostic research 2014 May 8(5)OC01
64 Chobanion AV Bakris GL Black HR The seventh report of the joint national
committee on prevention detection evaluation and treatment of high blood pressure
the JNC 7 report JAMA 2003 2892560-72
65 The Seventh Report of the Joint National Committee on Prevention Detection
Evaluation and Treatment of High Blood Pressure (JNC 7) The GuidelinesUS
Department of Health and Human Services National Heart Lung and Blood
Institute Available at URL
httpswwwnhlbinihgovfilesdocsguidelinesjnc7fullpdf [ Accessed on
1282017]
66 Firkin F Chestman C Penington D Rush B De Gruchyrsquos clinical Hematology in
medical practice 5th edition New Delhi Blackwell science Ltd1989 32-47
67 Report of WHO consultation Nutritional Anaemias Geneva Switzerland World
Health Organization TRS-405 1968 Available from URL
whqlibdocwhointtrsWHO_TRS_405pdf [Accessed on 1282017]
68 National Family Health survey (NFHS-4) 2015-16 India Mumbai IIPS
2016Available from URL httpwwwnfhsindiaorg [Accessed on 4072017]
69 The Minimum Wages Act 1948 Ministry of Labour and Employment Government
of India Available from URL httplabourgovincontentinnerpagewagesphp
[Accessed on 1082017]
70 Khairnar M Wadgave U Shimpi P Updated BG Prasad socioeconomic
classification for 2016 Journal of Indian Association of Public Health Dentistry
2016 Oct 1 14(4)469
95
References
71 Tiwari P Tiwari S Mastering practicals community medicine 1st ed New Delhi
India Wolters Kluwer PvtLtd2013161-67
72 Boralingaiah P Bettappa P Kashyap S Prevalence of Psycho-Social Problems
among Elderly in Urban Population of Mysore City Karnataka India Indian journal
of psychological medicine 2012 Oct 34(4)360
96
PATIENT CONSENT FORM JJM MEDICAL COLLEGE DAVANGERE
DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY MEDICINE I the undersigned hereby give my consent
for investigations carried upon me I am satisfied with the information given about this
Clinical study titled ldquoA STUDY ON THE MORBIDITY PATTERN AND HEALTH
SEEKING BEHAVIOR AMONG THE GERIATRIC POULATION IN THE
URBAN FIELD PRACTICE AREA OF JJM MEDICAL COLLEGE
DAVANGERErdquo ldquoconducted by Dr RUCHI DHAR under the guidance of Dr VIDYA
GS Associate Professor I have been informed and explained the risks involved and I
hereby voluntarily and Unconditionally give my consent without any fear or pressure in
mentally sound and conscious state to participate in this study
DATE PATIENTrsquoS SIGNATURE
eEacuteeEacuteJA ordfEacuteEcirczAgravearingQAtildeAiAgraveAuml ordfAgraveAumlordmAacutelaquozAacutearingregAiAgraveAuml zAacuteordfAgravetUEacutegEacute
ryenAacutemiumlethordfEacuteAumlAmiumlDyensiumlPAgraveordfAgraveAumlAumlaringcurrenn ordfEacuteAumlrsup1poundiuml
ordfEacuteEcirczAgravearingQAtildeAiAgraveAumlvAgraveyenAacutecedilAgraveuEacuteUEacuteMbrvbaragraveUEacute yenAgravevAgraveaelig F PEacutefrac14AgraveUEacute cedilAgraveraquo ordfAgraveiAacutergAgraveAumlordfAgrave poundAacutepoundAgraveAuml CAzAgravegEacute
poundAgravepoundAgraveszlig
ordfEacuteEcirczAgravearingQAtildeAiAgraveAumlvAgraveyenAacutecedilAgraveuEacute ordmAacuteUAgraveAElig plusmnAgravecedilAgraveUcircccedilaQvEacuteigraveUEacuteAzAgraveAuml poundAgravepoundAgraveszligMbrvbaragraveUEacuteAiAgraveAumlpoundAgraveAumlszlig
cedilAgraveAEligasup1gAgraveAumlvEacuteUcircAtildepoundEacute J cedilAgraveOumlr Dyensiuml zAgrave ordfEacuteAEligcopyethrn yenAacutearinglpoundiumleth CAqiuml ordmEacutemacriumlUcirc sup1AtildeQAUiuml copyordmEacuteAtildelaquoAiAgraveAumlgiuml Dyensiuml zAgrave fjAiAgraveiAacutenaeligPiuml yenEacuteAEligAtildeyenAgraveAumlaringmacrEacuteAtildemicroAgravepoundiuml Epoundiuml zAgrave Csectethpoundiuml brvbarAtildemacriumlOslash yenAacuteaeligoumlaringQOumlAtildecediliuml JjAiAgraveAuml Dyensiuml ddordfAgraveAumlAuml ordfEacuteEcirczAgravearingQAtildeAiAgraveAuml ordfAgraveAumlordmAacutelaquozAacutearingregAiAgraveAuml zAacuteordfAgravetUEacutegEacute JAsect sup2AtildeparaethPEacuteAiAgraveAumlrAiAgraveAumldegegrave yenAgravejAtildePEacuteeumlUEacute Mfrac14AgraveyenAgravercedilAgraveAumlordfAgrave ordfEacuteEcirczAgravearinggAacutezAgrave qAacute|| gAgraveAumla zAgravesAgravegAgrave ordfAgraveAumlvAgraveAumlUcirc qAacute|| laquozAacutearing fJcediliumlordfAgraveiAacuteUAgraveethzAgraveplusmnAgraveethPAgravegAacutezAgrave yenEacuteAEligaeligAtildeyensEacutecedilAgravegiuml
EordfAgravegAgraveAuml poundAgravepoundAgraveUEacute F vAgraveyenAacutecedilAgraveuEacuteUEacute Mfrac14AgraveyenAgraveqAgraveAumlordfAgrave ordfAgraveAumlAumlpoundAgraveszlig yenAgraveaeligwAiEacuteAEligAzAgraveAuml
CAplusmnAgraveUAgravefrac14AgravepoundAgraveAumlszlig CxAgraveethordfAacuteUAgraveAumlordfAgraveAvEacute wfrac12sup1gAgraveAumlvAacuteUcircgEacuteDzAgraveYacutejAzAgrave poundAacutepoundAgraveAuml poundAgravepoundAgraveszlig
ordfAgraveAumlpoundAgravecedilAacutegEacute AiAgraveiAacuteordfAgraveAringzEacuteAtilde umlsAgraveAiAgraveAuml ordfAgraveAumlvAgraveAumlUcirc AiAgraveiAacutegAgrave MvAacuteUcircAiAgraveAumllaquoregegravezEacute poundAacutepoundAgraveAuml
vAgraveyenAacutecedilAgraveuEacute aQvEacuteigraveUEacuteAEligfrac14AgraveyenAgraveqAgraveregAuml MbrvbaragraveUEacuteAiAgraveAumlpoundAgraveAumlszlig cedilAgraveAEligasup1gAgraveAumlvEacuteUcircAtildepoundEacute
centpoundAacuteAPAgrave gEacuteAEligAtildeVAi
Annexures
ANNEXURE ndashIII
104
Annexures
PROFORMA
I General information
1 NAME
2 AGE
3 GENDER (a) Male (b) Female
4 MARITAL STATUS (a) Unmarried (b) Married (c) Widow Widower
(d) Divorced separated
5 LIVING ARRANGEMENT (a) with spouse (b) Spouse and children
(c) Children only (d) living alone (e) others
6 RELIGION (a) Hindu (b) Muslim (c) Christian (d) Others
7 ADDRESS
8 EDUCATION (a) illiterate (b) Primary school (c) higher primary
(d) secondary school (e)PUC diploma (e) Graduate (f) Postgraduate
9 OCCUPATION (a) professional (b) semi- professional (c) skilled worker
(d) Semi ndashskilled worker (e) unskilled worker (f) unemployed
10 CONTACT NUMBER
11 TYPE OF FAMILY (a) Joint (b) Nuclear (C) three generation
12 TOTAL NUMBER OF FAMILY MEMBERS
13 TOTAL FAMILY INCOME
14 PER CAPITA FAMILY INCOME
15 SOCIO ECONOMIC STATUS (Modified BG Prasad classification) I IIIIIIVV
16 DIET (a) Vegetarian (b) Mixed
17 Sleep (a) Disturbed if yes reason ______________ (b) Not disturbed
18 Bowel Regular Irregular
19 Bladder Regular Irregular
97
Annexures
20 HABITS (a) betel nut (b) tobacco (c) alcohol (d) smoking (e) others
If any of the habits present Duration (since when) _________
Frequency of consumption day_______
IIAssessment of morbidity based on history
1 Whether suffering from any chronic illness like (a) Type 2 DM (b) Hypertension
(c) Bronchial Asthma (d) TB (e) others
2 Whether suffering from cataract currently (a) Yes (b) No
3 Whether operated for cataract (a) Yes (b) No If Yes duration since operation____
4 MUSCULOSKELETAL SYSTEM
Whether the following symptoms are present
(a) Backache (b) Joint pain (c) restricted joint movements (d) pain in calves
(e) Others_________
5 RESPIRATORY SYSTEM
(a) Productive cough (b) non-productive cough (c) nasal discharge (d) breathlessness (e)
sore throat (f) sneezing
6 CARDIOVASCULAR SYSTEM
(a) Palpitations (b) chest pain (c) breathlessness
7 GASTROINTESTINAL SYSTEM
(a) Pain abdomen (b) lose stools (c) constipation (d) flatulence (e) heart burn
(f) Bleeding per rectum
8 EYE AND ADNEXA
(a) Watering (b) diminution of vision (c) redness
9 EAR
(a) Discharge (b) decreased hearing (c) Tinnitus
10 SKIN
(a) Itching (b) skin eruptions (c) scaling (d) pigmentation
98
Annexures
11 GENITO URINARY SYSTEM
(a) Burning micturition (b) increased frequency of micturition
12 GENERAL SYMPTOMS
(a) Fatigue (b) headache (c) fever
13 ANY OTHER COMPLAINTS (a) burning feet (b) swelling in groin
(c) Memory loss (d) insomnia
III Assessment of health seeking behaviour
1 Do you visit a health facility in case of illness (a) Yes (b) No
If yes how much time do you take to visit a health facility an case of an illness
(a) Within 24 hours (b) 24-48 hours (c) more than 48 hours
2 Which type of health facility do you visit
(a) Govt hospital (b) Private practitioners (c) over the counter drugs (e) quacks
Mention the reason for visiting the particular health facility______________________
3 Whether taking regular treatment after diagnosis ________________
If No mention the reason_______________________
4 Whether following the instructions given by the treating doctor
(a) Yes (b) no
5 cost of treatment per month in case of chronic disease
(a) lt100 (b) 100-200 (c) 200-300 (d) 300 and above
6 Person bearing the cost of treatment
(a) Self (b) spouse (c) son (d) daughter (d) outside help
7 Duration to reach the health facility
(a) less than 3o minutes (b) 30 minutes or more
8 Whether going for regular check -ups (a) Yes (b) No
If Yes duration between the check-ups_______
99
Annexures
9 Whether following self- care practices in case of chronic disease like diabetes and hypertension
(a) Yes (b) No
10 In case of healthy individuals whether getting screening tests done (a) Yes (b) No
11 Whether following any dietary modifications (a) yes (b) No
12 Whether any family member accompanies you to the health facility
If yes who (a) Son (b) daughter (c) spouse (d) others
11 Whether the family supports in following specific diet advised by the doctor
(a) Yes (b) No
12 whether family members help in reminding to take regular medication
(a) Yes (b) No
IV Physical examination
1 Personal hygiene status
S NO COMPONENT CONDITION REMARKS
1 Hair
2 Teeth
3 Bath
4 Clothes
5 Washing hand before
eating food
6 Washing hands with soap
and water after ablution
7 Nails
8 Foot wear
Remarks personal hygiene status Good fair poor
100
Annexures
2 MEASUREMENTS
(a) Weight (in Kg) ______ (b) Height (in cm) _____ (c) BMI ______
(d) Waist circumference______ (e) Hip circumference ___________
(f) Waist hip ratio_________
3 GENERAL PHYSICAL EXAMINATION
Pallor Icterus Cyanosis clubbing lymphadenopathy Oedema
Pulse rate Temp Blood Pressure
Respiratory rate
20 Examination of
Eye Oral cavity Ear
Nose Throat
SYSTEMIC EXAMINATION
Cardiovascular system Respiratory system
Per abdomen Central Nervous system
101
MASTER CHART
Annexures
ANNEXURES
International Classification of Diseases (10th Revision)
I Certain infectious and parasitic diseases (A00-B99)
II Neoplasms (C00-D48)
III Diseases of blood and blood forming organs and certain disorders
involving the immune mechanisms (D50-D89)
IV Endocrine nutritional and metabolic diseases (E00-E90)
V Mental and behavioural disorders (F00-F99)
VI Diseases of the nervous system (G00-G99)
VII Diseases of the eye and adnexa (H00-H59)
VIII Diseases of the ear and mastoid process ( H60-H95)
IX Diseases of the circulatory system (I00-I99)
X Diseases of the respiratory system ( J00-J99)
XI Diseases of the digestive system (K00-K93)
XII Diseases of the skin and subcutaneous tissue ( L00-L99)
XIII Diseases of the musculoskeletal system and connective tissue
(M00-M99)
XIV Diseases of the genitourinary system ( N00-N99)
XV Pregnancy childbirth and purperium (O00-O99)
XVI Certain conditions originating in perinatal period (P00-P96)
XVII Congenital malformations deformations and chromosomal
XVIII (S00-T98)
XIX External causes of morbidity and mortality (V01-Y98)
102
Annexures
XX Injury poisoning and certain other consequences of external causes
(S00-T98)
XXI Factors influencing health status and contact with health services
(Z00-Z99)
XXII Codes for special purpose
103
Annexures
105
Annexures
106
Annexures
107
Annexures
PHOTOS
Picture 1 Showing the investigator interviewing the study subject
Picture 2 Showing the investigator interacting with the study subject
108
Annexures
Picture 3 Showing the investigator recording the Blood pressure of the study subject
Picture 4 Showing the investigator auscultating the study subject
109
Annexures
110
Introduction
INTRODUCTION
ldquoA STUDY ON THE MORBIDITY PATTERN AND HEALTH SEEKING BEHAVIOUR AMONG THE GERIATRIC POPULATION IN THE URBAN FIELD
PRACTICE AREA OF JJM MEDICAL COLLEGE DAVANGERErdquo
All countries of the world are experiencing population ageing Ageing is a result of
decreasing mortality and most importantly declining fertility The global share of older
people (aged 60 years and above) has increased from 92 per cent in 1990 to 117 in
2013 and will continue to grow as a proportion of the world population reaches 211 by
20501
The lsquoNational Policy for Older Personsrsquo was adopted by the Government of India in
January 1999 and it defines a lsquosenior citizenrsquo or lsquoelderlyrsquo as a person who is aged 60 years
or above Ageing is a progressive process associated with declines in structure and
function impaired maintenance and repair systems increased susceptibility to disease and
death2
In 2015 Worldwide there were 901 million people aged 60 years or over It is
projected that their number will grow to 14 billion in 2030 which is the target date for the
SDGs and to 21 billion by 2050 There will be growth in the number of older persons aged
60 years and above between 2015 and 2030 This increase is projected to be especially
significant global phenomenon and virtually every country in the world will experience a
substantial increase including the less developed regions3 The increased life expectancy has
led to challenges in health care management The elderly suffer from various diseases which
include non-communicable disease (NCDs) like diabetes hypertension coronary heart
disease and other disorders like osteoarthritis stroke dementia osteoporosis cancer
1
Introduction enlarged prostate depression and cataract related blindness In the coming years there will
be a phenomenal growth in the population of the elderly while the family size will reduce
The disintegration of the joint family and women moving out of the household has led to the
absence of traditional caregivers for the elderly who are already a vulnerable group4
The most common cause of health problems in the old aged people is chronic diseases
Most of these problems can be prevented or delayed by engaging in healthy behaviours
Even in the advanced years of life physical activity and good nutrition can have
effective benefits on health and well-being Many health problems of old age can be
effectively managed if they are detected early enough5 The National Policy for Older
Persons was announced by the Government of India in the year 1999 The Constitution of
India under Article 41 mandates the well-being of senior citizens ldquoThe state shall
within the limits of its economic capacity and development make effective provision
for securing the right to public assistance in case of old aged peoplerdquo 6
National Council for Older Persons (NCOP) has been reconstituted and renamed as
National Council for Senior Citizens (NCSrC) in order to have a definite structure and also
regional balancing the NCOP advises the Central and State Governments on a broad range
of issues related to welfare of senior citizens and enhancement of their quality of life The
NCSrc meets at least twice a year7 The elderly suffer from multiple medical as well as
psychological problems There has already been some pioneering work on the elderly in
India but a lot more remains to be done There is an urgent need to pay attention
towards the medical and socio-economic problems that are being faced by the elderly
people in India and thus formulate strategies to bring about an improvement in their
quality of life8 The Health seeking behaviour is influenced by various factors which
include the individual self diseases and the availability and accessibility of health
2
services It is important to have knowledge regarding the health seeking behaviour of
individuals for designing health care policies and programmes so that all the possible
difficulties with early diagnosis and effective treatment can be identified and appropriate
interventions can be implemented9 As already stated the elderly are a vulnerable group as
there are psychological as well as physiological changes with increasing age and it is
difficult to cope up with the problems of ageing Some of the most common problems in old
age are cardiovascular problems arthritis respiratory problems blood pressure and so on
Therefore the study of the health status of elderly morbid conditions perceptions about
it is important to note and the health care of the elderly becomes very important since they
are more prone to illness than young people and are also more prone to domestic and other
accidents Their health and treatment seeking behaviour are most important for the
formulation of welfare programmes of the country 10
Hence this study was taken up in the urban field practice area of JJM Medical College
Davangere to assess the morbidity pattern and health seeking behaviour of the geriatric
subjects
3
Objectives
OBJECTIVES
1 To study the morbidity pattern among the geriatric population in the urban field
practice area of JJM Medical college Davangere
2 To assess the health seeking behaviour of the elderly residing in the study area
4
Review of literature
vii
REVIEW OF LITERATURE
1 Definition Geriatrics or clinical gerontology Is the term used for the care of the aged 11 The United Nations uses 60 years and above to refer to older people the same is also used
by demographers However in many developed countries the age of 65 is used as the
reference point for older persons 12
Elderly are classified in to 3 groups 13
Young old Persons in the age group of 60 years to 74 years
Old old Persons in the age group of 75 years to 84 years
Oldest old Persons above the age of 85 yrs
2 Demography of the ageing population in India
The UN defines a country as ldquoAgeingrdquo or ldquoGreying Nationrdquo where the
proportion of people over 60 reaches 7 percent to total population By 2011 India has
exceeded that proportion (80 percent) and is expected to reach 126 percent in 2025
The Indian population has increased from 361 million in 1951 to 1027 billion in 2001
and further to 121 billion in 2011 Simultaneously the number of older people has
increased from 19 million (ie 4 percent of total population) to 77 million and
further to roughly 93 million (ie 75 percent of the total) during the same time
span 14
5
Review of literature
Figure1 proportion of elderly in the Indian population by age groups 1961-2001 14
Table 1 Percentage share of elderly population (aged 60 years and above) in total
population by sex in India 15
Years Male Female Total Rural Urban
1961 55 58 56 58 47
1971 59 60 60 62 50
1981 64 66 65 68 54
1991 67 68 68 71 57
2001 71 78 75 77 67
2011 77 84 80 81 79
2004-05 69 75 72 73 70
2007-08 73 77 75 76 72
6
Review of literature
The rise in population of males was more modest from 55 percent to 71 percent while for
females there had been a steep rise from 58 percent to 78 percent during five decadal
Censuses from 1961 to 2001 In 2011 the elderly population accounted for 80 percent of
total population For males it was marginally lower at 77 percent while for females it was
84 percent According to NSSO surveys the proportion of elderly population in rural areas
was 73 percent during 2004-05 and increased up to 76 percent in 2007-08 While on the
other hand in urban areas the proportion of elderly population rose from 70 percent to 72
percent during the corresponding period It has been observed that the percentage share of
elderly to total population remained higher in rural areas than in urban areas15
Table2 Size of elderly population (aged 60+) and their share in total population in major states of India in 201115
All India and selected major states
Proportion of elderly in total population of State
Male Female Total Andhra Pradesh 83 94 88 Bihar 72 67 70 Gujarat 76 90 83 Haryana 66 76 71 Himachal Pradesh 104 103 104 Karnataka 79 89 84 Kerala 118 133 126 Madhya Pradesh 68 74 71 Maharashtra 88 97 93 Orissa 91 95 93 Punjab 91 100 95 Rajasthan 66 79 72 Tamil Nadu 102 109 105 Uttar Pradesh 66 71 68 West Bengal 82 82 82 All India 77 84 80
7
Review of literature
3 MORBIDITY PATTERN AMONG THE ELDERLY
Physiological Decline and Consequences of increasing age
Ageing i s a process of decline in biological functions affecting most physical
Systems The following systems are affected by ageing
(a) Atrophy of the Taste Buds and Loss of Teeth
With the increasing age the taste buds of the tongue get atrophied and as a result the
preference for food alters significantly There is also a considerable loss of teeth causing
difficulties in chewing food
(b) Changes in the Gastrointestinal Tract
As the age advances the walls of the intestine get atrophied and the motility is
markedly reduced (lazy intestine) The digestive enzymes secreted by the intestine are
also reduced Hence the partly digested food stays in the intestine for a longer period
As a result the common complaint of the elderly person is gas formation (flatulence)
and constipation
(c) Respiratory System
As the age advance there is progressive fibrosis of the lungs leading to reduced
oxygenation of the lungs and breathing difficulties
(d) Kidney and genitourinary System
The kidneys get smaller in size and the power of the kidneys to filter out the unwanted
waste products from the body is diminished The total amount of urine becomes less in
old age and thus the waste products are not adequately excreted from the body
8
Review of literature
(e) Urinary Bladder
Urinary bladder gets smaller in size due to shrinkage and as a result the accumulation
of urine even of a small amount leads to an urge for urination With increase in age
the valve in the bladder which controls the exit of urine from the bladder to urethra
gets atrophied and weak Involuntary leakage of urine occurs in case the bladder is full
or due to increase of pressure on bladder on sneezing or even on laughing a condition
known as urinary incontinence Incontinence is a common complaint of elder females
(f) Heart and Circulatory System
The blood vessels get rigid and quite often the vessel walls become rough with the
deposition of solid matters consisting mostly of cholesterol The heart muscles get weaker
and power to send blood throughout the body through the circulatory system gets less and
less powerful The most dangerous effect on heart is coronary heart disease especially
coronary thrombosis
(g) Muscular system
The muscles in the body get gradually atrophied with ageing and especially those
small muscles which are necessary for quick reflex action The elderly person can quite
be capable of working like a normal person and can undertake activities which require
big muscles of legs and arms But when it comes to quick movement which needs small
muscles for quick reflex movements these functions are impaired causing accidents
like slipping on wet floor of the bathroom
(h) Brain
With ageing the size of the brain gets smaller and the weight also becomes less This
however does not interfere with the function of the brain However in general the brain
cells and its fibers which carry impulses from brain to the system and upwards get
9
Review of literature
degenerated The most glaring manifestation of ageing affecting the brain is
forgetfulness and in simple terms it is inability of brain to recall the past experience
However this is common in all elderly persons
(i ) Bones
The bones become porous and fragile as age advances especially in elderly females This
condition is known as osteoporosis and leads to sustaining of fractures even after a minor
fall16
Figure 2 pathophysiology of health issues in geriatrics17
The common disease that the geriatric population suffers from are type 2 diabetes
coronary heart disease hypertension stroke chronic obstructive pulmonary disease
10
Review of literature
Alzheimerrsquos disease osteoarthritis osteoporosis prostatic hypertrophy cataracts macular
degeneration cancer etc and at the same time they are vulnerable to infections involving
respiratory (including TB) urinary and digestive tract17
In India the elderly people suffer from dual medical problems ie communicable and
nonndash communicable diseases There is also impairment of special sensory functions like
vision and hearing A decline in immunity and age-related physiological changes leads to
an increased burden of communicable diseases in the elderly A report by Indian Council
of Medical Research (ICMR) on the chronic morbidity profile in the elderly states that
hearing impairment is the most common morbidity followed by visual impairment
However different studies show varied results in the morbidity pattern18
Major chronic conditions affecting older people worldwide 19
Cardiovascular diseases (such as coronary heart disease) Diabetes Mellitus
Hypertension Stroke Cancer
Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease
Musculoskeletal conditions (such as arthritis and osteoporosis)
Mental health conditions (mostly dementia and depression)
Blindness and visual impairment
11
Review of literature
Health seeking behaviour
1 Definition
There is no common definition agreed upon by sociologists in any sociology literature
Different definitions may be used in different studies despite referring to the same activity
Sociology and literature assume that health seeking behaviour is influenced by the various
factors which include individual self or the individual diseases present and also the
availability and accessibility of health services Being dependent on these determinants and
their interactions it can be said that health care seeking behaviour is a very complex
outcome of various factors which operate at individual family and community level20
Health Seeking Behavior (HSB) refers to decision or an action taken by an individual to
maintain attain or regain good health and to prevent illness The decisions which are
made encompasses all available health care options like visiting a public or private and
modern or traditional health facility self-medication and use of home remedies or not to
utilize the available health services etc
Determining the health care seeking behavior is very important to provide a need
based health care services to the population Visiting official channels in a formally
recognized health care system has been considered as the desired Health seeking behaviour
Health seeking behavior is influenced by multiple factors including availability quality and
price of services and also social groups health views residences and personal features of the
users Peoplersquos choice of health care differs in socio demographic socio-economic and
cultural compositions and this has an effect on their health seeking behavior Urban dwellers
are generally believed to be open to new ideas and willing to try certain things on a trial and
error basis21
12
Review of literature
Health seeking behaviours two approaches
(a) Health seeking behaviours utilization of the system
This approach focuses on the actions which are taken to rectify perceived ill health and
the type of health care facility which is utilized by the people There is data which
suggests that the people visit more traditional healers and unofficial medical channels
this should be prevented and the emphasis s h o u l d b e on encouraging people to opt
first for the official channels
(b) Health seeking behaviours the process of illness response
This approach considers the factors which enable or prevent people from making
healthy choices either i n their lifestyle behaviours or use of medical care and
treatment22
Figure 3 Predicting health behaviour with social cognition models 22
13
Review of literature
2 Health belief Model of health seeking behaviour
Since lsquoHealth seekingrsquo is a conditioned behaviour any attempt which is made to
encourage people to seek health care definitely requires an understanding of their
motivation for such behaviour Only through a deeper understanding of the intricate
factors shaping behavioural practices can health promotion programmes and or
interventions successfully be introduced into the realities of the peoplersquos lives to bring
about changes in health behaviour
Behaviour change theories and models such as the Health Belief Model (HBM)
Theory of Reasoned Action (TRA) Theory of Planned Behaviour (TPB) and the
Trans theoretical model have been widely applied in public health in an attempt to
explain or predict health seeking behaviours Their use enables identification and
understanding of peoplersquos health-seeking behaviour beyond their knowledge attitudes
and practices
HBM is a health specific behavioural cognitive model This model is based on the
idea that people are more likely to change their behaviour and adhere to treatments
if they have the following perceptions (i) have a perception that they are at risk of
contracting the disease (perceived susceptibility) (ii) perception that the disease
might have an unfavorable outcome (perceived severity) (iii) perceive that the
proposed health behaviour to be both effective and practical (perceived benefits)
(iv) perceive the barriers to adopting the behaviour to be minimal (perceived
barriers)(v) perceive themselves to have the ability of applying and practicing the
specific behaviour proposed (perceived self-efficacy) and (vi) they have the cues
for motivating their actions such as internal cues (pain symptoms past experiences)
or external cues (advice from friends relatives and mass media campaigns) (cues to
14
Review of literature
action) The specificity of the HBM to health has made it suitable for use in
understanding and explaining the behaviour as well as health outcomes and this may also
explain its wider use in public health2 3
Figure 4 Health belief model components and linkages 23
3 Factors influencing health seeking behaviour
The factors affecting the health seeking behaviours are seen in various contexts which
include physical socio-economic cultural and political factors Therefore the utilization of
a health care system whether public or private formal or non- formal may depend on socio-
demographic factors social structures level of education cultural beliefs and practices and
some other factors like gender discrimination status of women economic and political
systems environmental conditions and the disease pattern and health care system itself also
have an impact on the health seeking behaviour24
15
Review of literature
REVIEW OF RELATED STUDIES
A study done by Sanjay Polisetty and Madhavi Seepana (2017) on the morbidity profile
of elderly individuals in urban Visakhapatnam revealed that of the 270 study participants
about 996 suffered from either some form of acute or chronic morbidity More than 70
of individuals suffered from eye problems of which most common problem was cataract
seen in 60 About 304 had difficulties in chewing and 256 had difficulty in hearing
Hypertension was present in 49 of individuals and 742 of Diabetics were also found to
be hypertensive25
A study done by Swapnil Jain et al (2016) on Morbidity pattern among geriatric
population in urban field practice area of a district in Maharashtra revealed 653 suffered
from hearing impairment 62 were anemic 462 had hypertension 423 had joint
pain 41 had dental problems 38 7 had cataract and 318 had chronic bronchitis It
was seen that 81 of the subjects had multiple morbidities 26
A study done by Rajat Das Gupta et al (2016) in an urban area of Bangladesh on Morbidity
pattern and health-seeking behavior among the senior citizens revealed that of the 384 study
participants 968 were suffering from at least one medical problem The commonest was
musculoskeletal problems in 8411 followed by eye problems in 8125 It was found that
all the respondents sought treatment for their health problems 33 respondents went to
Government hospitals to seek medical help 6927 respondents took prescribed
medications and 567 were satisfied with their treatment 27
16
Review of literature
A study done by Md Alam Naushad et al (2016) on Morbidity pattern and health
seeking behavior in elderly population of Raipur City Chhattisgarh revealed that the
prevalence of morbidity among elderly was 9531 Out of total morbid population some
chronic illness was present in 7049 Gastro intestinal system was involved in 8262
followed by eye in 7983 and Cardiovascular system in 5245 It was found that 3552
of the subjects sought treatment from private registered practitioners 28
A study done by Sribas Goswami and Manjari Sahai (2016) in Raipur city on Morbidity
Pattern in elderly Population revealed that out of total study population of 640 elderly
subjects 610 (9531) suffered from some morbidity Prevalence among females was
9892 whereas among males it was 9026 Out of various agencies 3552 subjects
were utilizing private facility followed by 2785 who were utilizing Government agency
2631 visited quacks and 1030 were taking treatment from other source 29
A study done by Harsh Bardhan et al (2016) on the Morbidity profile of elderly population
in Ghaziabad district revealed that in geriatric population 5008 suffered from
musculoskeletal problems 5877 had dental problems and impairment of vision was seen
in 5561 The overall prevalence of diabetes and heart disease were 10 and 122
respectively 236 subjects reported the problem of loneliness and depression
forgetfulness was also reported by 3296 As far as treatment seeking behavior is
concerned approach of elderly is quite different for different morbidities The main source
of treatment for morbidities such as hypertension respiratory urinary GIT-related and
musculoskeletal problems was quacks 30
17
Review of literature
A study done by Mohammad Maharoof et al (2016) on the health problems among
the aged in Urban Aligarh UP revealed that of the 225 study subjects 782 had cataract
followed by depression in 356 refractive error in 276 loco-motor problem in 213
and hearing loss in 138 The prevalence of hearing loss was significantly related to gender
as it was higher among females with 181 compared to males in whom it was 6931
A study done by Gowri Shankar and Bhayalaxmi Sidenur (2016) on morbidity of
elderly residing in an urban area of Bagalkot revealed that the most common morbidity was
Cataract seen in 2875 followed by musculoskeletal problems in 2813 and 2313
were known hypertensive Both diabetes mellitus and hypertension was observed in 10 of
the study subjects32
A study done by Leena Rahul Salunkhe (2015) on socio-demographic profile of old
age people living in urban amp urban slum areas in Maharashtra Karad revealed that 504
and 42 elderly suffered from arthritis in an urban area and a slum respectively Number of
diabetics were higher in urban (14) than urban slum (35) 301 of subjects from urban
area suffered from hypertension compared to 161 from urban slums Upper Respiratory
Infections was more in slum dwellers (196) than people residing in urban area (7) Acid
peptic diseases were found in 168 study subjects in urban area and 154 in slum area 33
In a study done by Warbhe Priyanka A and Warbhe Rupesh (2015) on morbidity
profile health seeking behaviour and home environment survey of the elderly in an urban
slum community it was found that 941 had 1-3 morbidities 41 had 4-6 morbidities
373 gave a history of fall and 314 had history of fracture 136 subjects had been
18
Review of literature
operated for cataract 168 had undergone a procedure for fracture and10 had undergone
a dental procedure 542 went to Urban health center (UHC) and Government hospitals for
treatment and 786 received both allopathic and Ayurvedic treatment34
A study done by Man Mohan Gupta et al (2015) on Assessment of Clinico-
socioeconomic status and health-care support among the elderly people aged older than 60
years in urban population of Bhopal revealed that 353 subjects received treatment for
their morbidities from the Government hospitals whereas 267 from private
clinichospital About 653 study subjects presented with complaints and morbidity The
common morbidities which were found in the subjects were fatigue (487) backache
(353) Obesity (393) and hypertension (247)35
In a study done by Shilpa Shaukaiah et al (2015) on prevalence of morbidity pattern
among geriatric age group in an urban slum of Mumbai it was found that body ache was the
most commonly reported symptom by 290 followed by visual problems in 2318 joint
pain in 2181 indigestion in 2045 and backache in 2045 subjects36
A study done by Shubha Davalagi B et al (2015) on morbidity psycho-social profile and
health seeking behavior of the elderly population in urban slums of Davangere City revealed
that the most common morbidity which was present in the study subjects was
musculoskeletal problems in 46 psychosocial problems were present in 31 and
respiratory problems in 23 Majority of the elderly (56) utilized government
institutions for treatment of chronic disease and 47 for treatment of acute disease The
elderly population had financial constraints and lack of accessibility in seeking health care37
19
Review of literature
A study done by Vandana Nikumb et al ( 2015) on morbidity Profile among Geriatric
Population in an Urban Area of Navi Mumbai revealed that 9312 elderly were morbid and
with increasing age the number of morbidities was found to be increasing In this study it
was found that the most common morbidity was psychosocial problems which include
stress which was present in 594 subjects followed by musculoskeletal problems in
556 and eye problems like diminished vision mostly due to cataract in 463
Hypertension dental problems respiratory problems ENT problems (hearing impairment)
and endocrine disorders like diabetes accounted for 281 219 119 106 and10
respectively38
A study done by Vishnoi BR et al (2015) on Morbidity Profile of Elderly in Urban
Slum of Udaipur Rajasthan revealed that 61 of the study subjects had impaired vision
followed by 25 who had hypertension 1533 suffered from insomnia 1467 had
anemia and 14 suffered from gastrointestinal problems The condition of females was
worse compared to males39
In a study done by L Subedhi and RB Sah (2015) on the health status of geriatric age
group in Chitwan district of Nepal it was found that of the 300 study subjects 44 had
Ophthalmic problems 43 had GIT problems 33 had CVS problems 23 had ENT
problems 1567 had metabolic disorders and 533 had mental disorders The study
highlighted a high prevalence of morbidity and health related problems in the geriatric age
group40
20
Review of literature
A study done by Sofia Noor et al (2015) on health status of geriatric population in slums
of Rourkela revealed that the morbidities among the elderly that were found to be significant
were hypertension decreased visual acuity urinary problems and insomnia Apart from
systemic morbidities 91 of the elderly also complained of fragility which includes
complex physiological deterioration and unexplained weight loss41
In a study conducted by VM Sarode (2014) on Chronic Diseases Related to Ageing and
Disease Prevention in Slums in Mumbai it was found that there were highly significant
disorders among aged women related to Skin lesion and super infection Untreated bacterial
pharyngitis acute rheumatic fever while disorders among aged men were related to
hypertension Illicit drug use diabetes and asthma It was found that 49 of elderly males
and 45 of elderly females had not sought any treatment for their illness Of the people who
had sought treatment 93 elderly males and 92 of elderly females had taken treatment
from Government hospital42
A study conducted by Sanjeev Kumar Barman et al (2014) on morbidity profile of
geriatric population in an urban slum of Kishnganj Bihar revealed that the prevalence of
anemia cataract and hypertension were quite high 6375 6125 and 5063
respectively Loss of income amp occupation along with a feeling of neglect from the family
members were the common problems among the elderly It was also found that morbidities
like arthritis loss of teeth amp dental caries along with depression had a significant association
with sex age amp educational status of the study subjects43
21
Review of literature
A study done by Khadervali Nagoor et al (2014) on the health status of elderly
population in an urban area of Kadapa revealed that out of the 200 elderly persons studied
Visual problem due to cataract and refractive errors were present in 72 of the study
subjects followed by pain in joints in 595 gastrointestinal problems in 46 and dental
problems in 44 Other morbidities were hypertension in 42 genitourinary problems in
25 dermatological problems in 235 and psychological problems in 1644
A study done by Kakkar R et al (2013) on morbidity profile among geriatric population
in District Dehradun revealed that the working geriatric group was healthy as compared to
those who were retired Hypertension was the commonest morbidity among all age groups
In the age group of 60-70 years the following morbidities were seen hypertension (306)
followed by diabetes (153) arthritis (14) CVS morbidities (14) cataract (96) and
BPH (83) Among 71-80 years age group Hypertension (287) followed by arthritis
(167) cataract (157) Diabetes (111) BPH (111) and CVS morbidities (93)45
In a study done by Bhawalkar JS et al (2013) on morbidity profile among geriatric
population in an urban area of Pune it was found that Musculoskeletal disorder was the
most common (4331) followed by eye problems (3722) and hypertension (137)It
was seen that 43 elderly population had some health problem but only 8 visited the
health facilities Among them 6 visited private practitioners and only 18 went to
municipal hospitals It was found that only 2322 elderly were taking any medications and
the most commonly used drug was anti-inflammatory drugs 2323 followed by
antihypertensive drugs 136746
22
Review of literature
A study conducted by Deepak Sharma et al (2013) on morbidity pattern and health-
seeking behavior of aged population residing in Shimla revealed that the following
morbidities were present in the study subjects hypertension was the commonest (56)
followed by Musculoskeletal problems (535) Dental problems (27) cataract (23)
anemia (15) and acid peptic disease (175) 658 of the subjects were seeking
treatment for their health problems Majority of the older people preferred allopathic
medicine (812) followed by Ayurvedic medicines (113) and homeopathic medicine
(73) for their health problems Most of the older persons preferred going to a
CHCGovernment hospital for treatment for their illness There was considerable use of
over-the-counter drug by125 of the people 47
A study done by JP Singh et al (2013) on Geriatric morbidity profile in an urban slum of
Nagpur central India revealed that the most common morbidity identified in the study
population was anemia (9650) followed by hypertension (345) arthritis (3225)
cataract (21) and diabetes (1775) More than 2 morbidities were present in 325 of
the study subjects followed by four morbidities in 3125 and two morbidities in 23548
A study conducted by RP Thakur et al (2013) on the health problems of the elderly in
central India revealed that among the elderly residing in the urban areas 384 of the urban
elderly had both dental problems and arthritis followed by anemia in 348 hypertension in
266 cataract in 252 and diabetes mellitus in 157 The prevalence of self-reported
depression was 672 among the urban female elderly when compared to 397 among the
urban females49
23
Review of literature
A study done by Mrinal Ranjan Srivastav et al (2013) on Morbidity Status and its
Social determinants among elderly population of Lucknow revealed that the most common
morbidity among the urban population was eye problems which affected 516 males and
67 females followed by CVS problems in 363 males and 395 females and GIT
problems in 315males and 382 females50
A study done by Shraddha K et al (2012) on morbidity pattern among elderly in urban
population of Mysore revealed that out of the 526 study subjects 486 suffered from the
disease of the eye and adnexa followed by 384 who suffered from endocrine and
metabolic disorders 331 suffered from the disease of the circulatory system 323 had
disease of the oral cavity and salivary glands and 302 had disease of the musculoskeletal
system 51
A study done by Vimala Thomas et al (2012) on morbidity profile and health seeking
behaviour of the elderly in urban slums of Hyderabad revealed that hypertension was the
most common morbidity in 469 followed by Arthritis in 302 Diabetes in 265
respiratory problems in 243 and Cataract in 21 For out-patient treatment 472 visited
private sectors 303 Government facility 25 RMP and 06 AYUSH clinics For in-
patient treatment 198 visited private institutions 16 visited Government institutions
while 642 did not visit either52
24
Review of literature
A study done by Soe Moe et al (2012) on health seeking behaviour of elderly in
Myanmar revealed that 35 of the male elderly perceived that they were having good
health status whereas 229 of them perceived having a poor health status 343 of female
elderly perceived that they were having good health status while 24 of them perceived
having a poor health About 49 of the elderly went to rural health center for treatment
followed by 33 who went to private practitioners 15 visited hospitals and 3 went to
more than one place for treatment53
A study done by Dharamvir Ranjan Bharati et al (2011) in Puducherry revealed that in
the urban areas about 707 of the study subjects had anemia followed by 537 who had
visual impairment and hypertension and 532 suffered from diabetes mellitus It was seen
that On univariate analysis the risk of diabetes mellitus was significantly higher among
elderly from urban areas than that among elderly from rural areas and significantly lower
risk in elderly from below poverty line than in those belonging to normal (not below poverty
line)54
A study done by Rajashree Bhat et al (2011) on the morbidity pattern among the elderly
population in Ahmedabad revealed that most common morbidity of elderly was the
problems of loco-motor system (486) followed by vision (427) and hypertension
(344) In this study only 37 of elderly had psychosocial problems55
A study done by Krishnamachari Srinivasan et al (2010) in an urban area of Bangalore
revealed that 494 subjects had hypertension 323 had diabetes 281 had arthritis
279 suffered from Genitourinary and cardiovascular disease It was observed that about
25
Review of literature
49 of the respondents made less than three physician visits and 13 were hospitalized for
health related problems during the past one year 56
A study done by Kajal Srivastava et al (2010) on the morbidity pattern of the elderly in
urban Agra revealed that 9529 of the elderly were morbid in the slum areas The most
common morbidity which was seen among the elderly people residing in urban slums was
anemia which was seen in 3843 followed by cataract in 298 arthritis in 2431 and
hearing impairments in 2157The system wise distribution of the morbidity pattern
showed the most common systemic involvement was visual disorders 5216 followed by
musculoskeletal system 4784 and the gastrointestinal system 4314 The number of
morbidities was found to be increasing with age and this association with age was
statistically significant57
A study done by Abdullah Ladha et al (2009) on the health seeking behaviour of elderly
population in a poor-urban community of Karachi Pakistan revealed that 164 of the
elderly people were Diabetic and 301 had Hypertension The Common symptoms that
prompted elderly of to seek health care were fever (612) generalized body aches (434)
and cough (404) About 614 responders reported factors which deterred them from
seeking health care out of which 62 reported financial constraint as the commonest factor
Deterrence from seeking health care was associated with illiteracy and living alone58
26
Methodology METHODOLOGY
The study was conducted in the urban field practice area of JJM Medical college
Davangere The city of Davangere is situated in the central part of Karnataka state
265 km north of the state capital Bengaluru along the national highway number 4
Figure 5 Maps showing the location of Davangere district and the area where the
UHTC is located
27
Methodology
Figure 6 Map showing the Urban field practice area of JJM medical college
28
Methodology
Table 3 List of areas covered under the UHTC of JJM Medical
College Davangere
Areas covered Total population Bethur road 1374 Hedge nagar 1213 Mehboob nagar 3042 Mustafa nagar A 2093 B D layout A 1084 Mustafa nagar B 1127 Mahavir nagar 930 Muddabovi colony 1094 Maganhalli 1221 Tippu nagar 968 B D layout B 1717 Batti layout 1080
STUDY AREA The study was conducted in the urban field practice area of JJM
Medical College Davangere which consists of 12 areas with a total population of
16943
STUDY DESIGN Cross sectional study
STUDY POPULATION Persons aged 60 years and above
Total Population Covered 16943
29
Methodology
INCLUSION CRITERIA subjects aged 60 years and above living in the study area
for more than one year duration
EXCLUSION CRITERIA Subjects who we r e no t w i l l i ng t o pa r t i c ipa t e i n
t he s t udy
STUDY PERIOD 1 year from 1st December 2015 to 30th November 2016
SAMPLE SIZE As quoted by Manmohan Gupta et al 35 in the studies done in various
parts of India the prevalence of morbidity in the geriatric population ranges from 31-80
Considering the prevalence of morbidity to be about 50 in the geriatric population at 95
confidence level and allowable error of 10 and a non -response rate of 10 sample size
was calculated to be 440 using the formula
n=4pq L2
n= sample size
4= factor to achieve 95 level of confidence
p= prevalence of morbidities ie 50
q= 100- p ie 100-50 = 50
L= permissible error in the estimate of ldquoprdquo (10 of p)
n = 4 x 50 x 50 = 400
5 x 5
After calculating a non-response rate of 10 a sample size of 440 was calculated
30
Methodology
A community based cross sectional study was conducted in the urban field practice
area of JJM Medical College Davangere The Urban field practice area has a total
population of 16943 and there are 12 areas in urban field practice area of JJM Medical
College Davangere
The Study was conducted by probability proportionate sampling The sample size for each
area was derived from the formula
1198991 =119875119900119901119906119897119886119905119894119900119899 119894119899 119890119886119888ℎ 119886119903119890119886
119879119900119905119886119897 119875119900119901119906119897119886119905119894119900119899119883 119878119886119898119901119897119890 119878119894119911119890
Example 1st area has a population of 1374 so
1198991 =1374
16943119883 440 = 36
Therefore 36 elderly subjects were selected by house to house visit from 1st area Same
procedure was applied for other areas until the desired sample size of 440 was reached
MATERIALS USED FOR DATA COLLECTION
The following tools were used for data collection
Semi-structured predesigned and pre-tested questionnaire
Portable bathroom weighing machine
Stretch- resistant measuring tape
Mercury Sphygmomanometer
Others - stethoscope torch tuning fork knee hammer
ICD-10 for system wise classification of disease59
31
Methodology METHOD OF COLLECTION OF DATA After establishing rapport with the family
and explaining the data collection procedure in the local language an informed verbal
consent was obtained from each individual and data was collected using a
Predesigned semi structured questionnaire by Interview method The questionnaire
comprised of the following information socio-demographic data of the study subjects
information regarding the morbidity pattern and health seeking behaviour If there were
more than one elderly subjects in the same household then all were included
The study subjects were asked about any ho illness (communicable or non-
communicable) which they were suffering from Upon a positive response the subjects were
further asked to specify the type(s) and duration of morbidities that they were suffering
from eg heart disease diabetes gastrointestinal diseases respiratory disease etc Some
were unable to understand or answer questions due to illness In such cases help was sought
from the family members Based on the self-reported symptoms information from
hospital records and clinical examination the prevalence of different morbidities among the
study subjects was assessed The Information about the health seeking behaviour was
sought by asking the study subjects about their visits to a health facility in case of an illness
and also the type of health facility visited ( Government private or quacks )
DATA ENTRY AND ANALYSIS Data was entered and analyzed using MS Excel and
Open Epi Info version 2260 Both descriptive and inferential statistics were used Subjectrsquos
baseline characteristics were presented as frequencies and percentages Categorical
variables between the groups were compared using Chi square test and Fisherrsquos exact
test Fisherrsquos exact test was used when more than 20 cells had expected value lt 5 and any
one of the cells had expected value lt 1 All statistical analysis was carried out at 5 level
of significance and p value lt005 was considered as significant
32
Methodology ETHICAL CLEARANCE
Ethical clearance was obtained before conducting the study from the Ethical Committee of
JJM Medical college Davangere [ANNEXURE III] During the study verbal
informed consent was taken from the study subjects Assurance was given that the
confidentiality concerning their information will be maintained
Clinical Examination included
(a) General physical examination
(b) Anthropometric measurements like height and weight
(c) Systemic examination
(d) Measurement of Blood pressure
(e) Eye examination by torch and Snellenrsquos (E chart)61
(f) Hearing assessment by Rinnersquos test Webberlsquos and Absolute bone conduction
test using tuning fork 62
Parameters used in our study
Height Height was measured with a standard non-stretchable measuring tape to the
nearest 01 cm in standing position (without footwear standing upright with the
back against the wall heels together and eyes directed forward)
33
Methodology Weight Weight was measured with minimal clothing and respecting the modesty of the
individual without footwear using a calibrated standard bathroom weighing scale to the
nearest 05 kg
Body Mass Index (BMI) Using weight (in Kg) and height (in meter2) BMI was calculated by applying the formula
Body Mass Index= Weight (kg) Height (m2)
The BMI cut off values for Asians as recommended by the WHO was used in our study
Table 4 WHO Categorization of Body Mass index (BMI) for Asians 63
Measurement of Blood pressure Procedure Blood pressure was measured in the left arm in a sitting posture with the subject in a
relaxed state Standardized mercury sphygmomanometer with adult size cuff was used
The first appearance of (phase 1 of Korotkoff sounds) sound was used to define
Systolic Blood Pressure (SBP) The disappearance of sound (phase 5) was used to
define Diastolic Blood Pressure (DBP) Two readings were taken five minutes apart and
the average of the two readings was taken as the final blood pressure reading A person
was considered to be a hypertensive if he she was already diagnosed case of
hypertension and or on treatment or with a current SBP of ge 140 mm Hg or DBP ge 90 mm
Hg (JNC VII criteria)64
BODY MASS INDEX INFERENCE
lt 185 underweight
185 to 229 kg m2 Normal
23 to 249 kg m2 Overweight
ge 25 kg m2 Obese
34
Methodology
Table 5 JNC VII Classification of Blood pressure 65
BP Classification Systolic Blood Pressure Diastolic Blood Pressure
Normal lt120 lt 80
Pre Hypertension 120 ndash 139 or 80 ndash 89 Stage 1 Hypertension 140 ndash 159 or 90 ndash 99 Stage 2 Hypertension ge 160 or ge 100
Anaemia was detected by pallor of conjunctiva tongue and nails and was confirmed by
doing haemoglobin estimation using sahlirsquos hemogobinometer66
The cut off for the diagnosis of anaemia was done based on WHO classification67
Diabetes - self reported cases of diabetes were considered as diabetics for the study
STUDY VARIABLES
1 AGE - subjects aged 60 years and above were taken up for the study Age was
recorded to the nearest complete years as stated by the respondent
2 GENDER Both males and females were taken up for the study
3 EDUCATIONAL STATUS 68
i Illiterate -A person who could not read or write
ii Primary School - studied up to 4th standard
iii Higher primary- studied between 5th and 7th standard
iv Secondary school -studied between 8th and 10th standard v Intermediate- studied between 11th or 12 th standard or diploma
vi Graduate - obtained graduate degree
vii Post Graduate- obtained post graduate degree
35
Methodology
4 OCCUPATION STATUS69
i Unskilled worker
Labourer domestic servants casual worker peon sweeper porter washer-man others
(vegetable vendor)
ii Semi-skilled worker
Factory worker agriculture laborers shoemaker potters others (security guard shop
helper canteen helper
iii Skilled
Artisan clerk foreman supervisor carpenter tailor mechanic electrician railway guard
painter modeler smiths baker driver shop assistant petty trader constable soldier
linesman pointsman potter barber others (tinkering printer receptionist salesman
welder cook mason postman plumber agarbatti worker)
iv semi-professional
Teacher pharmacist social worker owner of a small business farmer others (computer
programmer Govt employee nurse)
V Professional
Doctor engineer principal lawyer Military officer senior executive business
proprietor writer scientist large employer director university professor police
officer others (horse rider)
(vi) Unemployed Presently not working retired homemakers
36
Methodology 5 SOCIO ECONOMIC STATUS
Table 6 Socio-economic status (SES)- As per modified BG Prasad Classification70
5 TYPE OF FAMILY 71
Joint Family ndash It is type of family grouping in which a number of married couples and
their children live together in the same household All the men are related by blood
and women of household are their wives unmarried girls and widows of family kinsmen
Nuclear Family - It consist of married couple and their children while they are still
regarded as dependents
Three generation family - It is a family where representatives of three generation are
living together Young married couples continue to stay with their parents and have
their own children as well
Socio-economic
status
Prasadrsquos classification
1961(Per capita income in
Rupees per month)
Modified BG Prasad classification-
updated for May 2016 ((per
capita income in Rupees per
month)
I 100 and above 6261 and above
II 50-99 3099-6260
III 30-49 1835-3098
IV 15-29 949-1834
V Below 15 lt948
37
SAMPLE SIZE ESTIMATION
SAMPLE SIZE As quoted by Manmohan Gupta et al 35 in the studies done in various
parts of India the prevalence of morbidity in the geriatric population ranges from 31-80
Considering the prevalence of morbidity to be about 50 in the geriatric population at 95
confidence level and allowable error of 10 and a non -response rate of 10 sample size
was calculated to be 440 using the formula
n=4pq L2
n= sample size
4= factor to achieve 95 level of confidence
p= prevalence of morbidities ie 50
q= 100- p ie 100-50 = 50
L= permissible error in the estimate of ldquoprdquo (10 of p)
n = 4 x 50 x 50 = 400
5 x 5
After calculating a non-response rate of 10 a sample size of 440 was calculated
A community based cross sectional study was conducted in the urban field practice area of
JJM Medical College Davangere The Urban field practice area has a total population of
16943 and there are 12 areas in urban field practice area of JJM Medical College
Davangere
The Study was conducted by probability proportionate sampling The sample size for each area
was derived from the formula
1198991 =119875119900119901119906119897119886119905119894119900119899 119894119899 119890119886119888ℎ 119886119903119890119886
119879119900119905119886119897 119875119900119901119906119897119886119905119894119900119899119883 119878119886119898119901119897119890 119878119894119911119890
Example 1st area has a population of 1374 so
1198991 =1374
16943119883 440 = 36
Therefore 36 elderly subjects were selected by house to house visit from 1st area Same
procedure was applied for other areas until the desired sample size of 440 was reached
Results
RESULTS
The results are presented under the following headings
I Socio-demographic characteristics of study subjects
II Prevalence of morbidities among the study subjects
III Details of health seeking behavior of the study subjects
38
Results
ISocio-demographic characteristics of the study subjects
Table 7 Age and sex wise distribution of the study subjects
Figure 7 Age and sex wise distribution of the study subjects
In the present study Out of 440 study subjects majority 162(368) were in the age group
of 60-64 Years followed by 109 (247) in the age group of 65-69 Years 99 (225) were
in the age group of 70-74 Years and 35 (8) were more than or equal to 80 years of age
Majority of the subjects were males 260 (59) and 180 (41) were females The mean age
of the study population was 6745 plusmn 655 Years
354 254 262
88 42
389
239 172
67 133
0102030405060708090
100
60-64 65-69 70-74 75-79 ge80
Perc
enta
ge
Age in years
Males
Females
Age group (in years)
Males Females Total
Percentage () Frequency
(n=260) Percentage ()
Frequency (n=180)
Percentage ()
60-64 92 354 70 389 162 368
65-69 66 254 43 239 109 247
70-74 68 262 31 172 99 225
75-79 23 88 12 67 35 80
ge80 11 42 24 133 35 80
Total 260 100 180 100 440 100
39
Results
Table 8 Distribution of the study subjects based on religion
Religion Frequency (n=440) Percentage ()
Hindu 188 427
Muslim 252 573
Total 440 100
Figure 8 Distribution of the study subjects based on religion
In the present study it was found that the majority of the study subject belonged to Muslim
religion 252 (573) followed by Hindus 188 (427)
0102030405060708090
100
Hindu Muslim
427
573
Perc
enta
ge
Religion of the study subjects
40
Results
Table 9 Distribution of the study subjects based on Educational status
Education Frequency (n=440) Percentage ()
Illiterate 231 525
Primary school 121 275
Higher primary 38 86
Secondary School 30 68
Intermediate 6 14
Graduate 14 32
Total 440 100
Figure 9 Distribution of the study subjects based on Educational status
In the present study it was found that the Majority of the study subjects were illiterate
231(525) 121(275) had completed education up to primary school 30(68) had
completed education up to secondary school and only 14(32) were graduates
525
275
86 68
14 32
0102030405060708090
100
Perc
enta
ge
Educational status of study subjects
41
Results Table 10 Distribution of the study subjects based on occupation
Occupation Frequency (n=440) Percentage ()
Semi-professional 2 05
Skilled worker 45 102
Semi-skilled worker 68 155
Unskilled worker 100 227
Unemployed 225 511
Total 440 100
Figure 10 Distribution of study subjects based on their occupation
In our study it was found that the majority of the study subjects 225 (511) were
unemployed followed by 100 (227) who were unskilled workers 68 (155) were semi-
skilled workers and 45 (102) were skilled workers
0102030405060708090
100
05 102 155 227
511
Perc
enta
ge
Occupation of the study subjects
42
Results Table 11 Distribution of the study subjects based on socio-economic status (Modified
BG Prasad classification 2016)
Figure 11 Distribution of the study subjects based on their socio-economic status
In our study majority of the subjects 215 (49) belonged to Class IV Socioeconomic status
followed by 115 (26) who belonged to class III and 56 (13) who belonged to class II
SES (according to Modified BG Prasad Classification 2016)
Class II 13
Class III 26
Class IV 49
Class V 12
Socio-economic status Frequency (n=440) Percentage ()
Class I 0 0
Class II 56 13
Class III 115 26
Class IV 215 49
Class V 54 12
Total 440 100
43
Results
Table 12 Distribution of the study subjects based on their marital status
Marital status Frequency (n=440) Percentage ()
Unmarried 2 05
Married 323 734
Widowwidower 115 261
Total 440 100
Figure 12 Distribution of the study subjects based on their marital status
In our study it was found that majority of the study subjects 323(734) were married
followed by 115(261) who were widowed and only 2 (05) were unmarried
0102030405060708090
100
Unmarried married Widowwidower
05
734
261 Perc
enta
ge
44
Results
Table 13 Distribution of the study subjects based on the type of family
Type of family Frequency (n=440) Percentage ()
Nuclear family 163 37
Joint family 93 21
Three generation family 184 42
Total 440 100
Figure 13 Distribution of the study subjects based on the type of family
In the present study it was found that majority of the study subjects 184 (42) lived in a
three generation family followed by 163 (37) who lived in a nuclear family and 93(21)
who lived in a Joint family
Nuclear family 37
Joint family 21
Three generation
family 42
45
Results
II Prevalence of morbidities among the study subjects
Figure 14 Distribution of the study subjects based on the BMI
In the present study it was found that out of 440 study subjects 198 (45) had a normal
BMI followed by 132 (30) who were overweight 66 (15) were obese and only 44
(10) were underweight
under weight 10
Normal 45
Overweight 30
Obese 15
46
Results
Table 14 Distribution of morbidity pattern of the study subjects based on ICD 10
classification of diseases
System involved ICD 10
Males (n=260)
Females (n=180)
Total (n=440)
No No No
Diseases of musculoskeletal system (M00 ndash M99)
184 707 130 722 314 714
Diseases of the eye and adnexa (H00 ndash H59)
139 534 80 444 219 497
Diseases of oral cavityamp salivary glands (K00 ndash K14)
90 346 64 355 154 35
Endocrine nutritional amp metabolic diseases (E00 ndash
E90)
70 269 75 417 145 329
Diseases of circulatory system (I00 ndash I99)
64 246 73 405 137 311
Diseases of respiratory system(J00 ndash J99)
64 246 37 206 101 23
Diseases of digestive system (K00 ndash K93)
57 219 30 166 87 198
Diseases of skin amp subcutaneous tissue (L00 ndash
L99)
38 146 20 111 58 132
Diseases of the ear and mastoid process (H60 ndashH95)
39 15 18 10 57 13
Diseases of genitourinary system (N00 ndash N99)
22 85 7 39 29 66
Diseases of nervous system (G00 ndash G99)
6 23 5 28 11 25
Note Total number could not be given as many subjects had multiple disorders
47
Results
Figure 15 Distribution of morbidity pattern of the study subjects based on ICD 10
classification of diseases
In the present study it was found that the majority of the subjects 314 (714) suffered
from the disorders of the musculoskeletal system followed by 219 (497) who suffered
from the disease of the eye and adnexa154 (35) suffered from the disease of the oral
cavity 145 (329) suffered from endocrine nutritional and metabolic disorders137
(311) suffered from the disease of the circulatory system 101 (229) suffered from the
disease of the respiratory system 87(198) suffered from the disease of the digestive
system 58 (132) suffered from disease of the skin 57 (13) suffered from the disease of
the ear 29 (66) suffered from the disease of the genitourinary system and only 11( 25 )
suffered from the disease of the nervous system
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
714
497
35 329 311 229
198 132 13 66
25
perc
enta
ge
48
Results
Table 15 Distribution of the study subjects based on morbidity of the musculoskeletal
system
Musculoskeletal
Disease
Males
(n=260)
Females
(n=180)
Total
(n= 440)
Statistical
Value
Knee joint pain
52 (20)
30 (167)
82 (186)
X2 = 0779
df = 1
p=03773
Back ache
30 (115)
35 (194)
65 (148) X2 = 528
df = 1
p = 0021
Joint pain (other than
knee joint pain)
52(20)
35(194)
87(198)
X2 =00206
df=1
p =0885
Non-specific aches
and pain
50(192)
30(167)
80(182)
X2=0470
df=1
p = 0492
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses
In the present study it was found that the most common morbidity of musculoskeletal
system was pain of the joints (other than the knee joint) found in 87 (198) of the subjects
followed by knee joint pain in 82 ( 186) and non-specific pains and aches were found in
80 (182) of the subjects It was found that back ache was more common in females
35(194) compared to males 30 (115) and this difference was found to be statistically
significant
49
Results
Table 16 Distribution of the study subjects based on morbidity of the eye and adnexa
Diseases of the
eye and
adnexa
Males
(n=260)
Females
(n=180)
Total
(n= 440)
Statistical
value
Cataract
112(43)
60(333)
172(391)
X2 = 4241
df=1
p = 0039
Refractive error
20(77)
14(78)
34(77)
X2= 0001
df=1
p = 0973
Others (conjunctivitis
pterygium glaucoma etc)
7(27)
6(33)
13(29)
X2=0152
df=1
p = 0696
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses
In the present study it was found that the most common morbidity of the eye was cataract
found in 172 (391) of the subjects It was more common in males 112 (43) compared to
females 60 (333) and this difference was found to be statistically significant The other
morbidities present were refractive error found in 34 (77) subjects and others which
includes conjunctivitis pterygium glaucoma etc found in 13 (29 ) subjects
50
Results
Table 17 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the oral cavity
Diseases of the
oral cavity
Males
(n =260 )
Females
(n =180 )
Total
(n = 440)
Statistical
value
Stained teeth
22 (84)
18 (10)
40 (91)
X2 =0304
df=1
p = 0581
Missing teeth
40 (154)
38 (211)
78 (177)
X2= 239
df= 1
p=0122
Caries
28 (108)
8 (44)
36 (82)
X2= 566
df= 1
p=0017
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses
In the present study it was found that the most common morbidity of the oral cavity was
missing teeth found in 78 (177 ) of the subjects followed by stained teeth found in 40
(91) of the subjects and dental caries in 36 (82) of the subjects Dental caries were
more common in males 28 (108) compared to females 8(44) and this difference was
found to be statistically significant
51
Results
Table 18 Distribution of study subjects based on endocrine nutritional and metabolic
disorders
Disorders Males
(n =260 )
Females
(n =180)
Total
(n = 440)
Statistical value
Diabetes mellitus
45 (173)
37 (206)
82 (186)
X2 = 0739
df= 1
p = 0389
Anemia
24 (92)
35 (194)
59 (134)
X2= 955
df = 1
p = 0001
Thyroid disorders
1(04)
3 (17)
4 (09)
p= 0309
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
The present study revealed that the most common disorder of the endocrine system was
diabetes mellitus found in 82 (186) of the subjects followed by the nutritional disorder of
anemia found in 59 (134) of the subjects It was seen that anemia was more common
among females 35 (194) compared to males 24 (92) This difference was found to be
statistically significant Disorders of the thyroid gland were found in 4 (09) of the subjects
being more common in females 3(17) compared to males 1 (04)
52
Results
Table 19 Distribution of the study subject based on disease of the circulatory system
Diseases of
circulatory
system
Males
(n=260 )
Females
(n =180)
Total
(n = 440)
Statistical
value
Hypertension
62 (238)
71 (394)
133 (302)
X2= 1227
df= 1
p = 0000
CAD MI
Arrhythmias
2 (08)
2 (11)
4 (09)
p =100
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
In our study it was found that the most common disease of the circulatory system was
hypertension which was found in 133 (302 ) of the subjects it was more common in
females 71 (394) compared to males 62 (239) and this difference was found to be
statistically significant The other disorders of the circulatory system were CAD MI
arrhythmias which were found only in 4 (09) of the study subjects
53
Results
Table 20 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the respiratory system
Disorders of
Respiratory
System
Males
(n=260)
Females
(n=180)
Total
(n=440)
Statistical
value
Bronchial asthma
3 (12)
3 (17)
6 (14)
p =0692
URTI
45 (173)
27 (15)
72 (164)
X2= 0413
df = 1
p = 0520
Acute Bronchitis
12 (46)
7 (39)
19 (43)
X2= 0135
df = 1
p = 0712
Pulmonary TB
4 (15)
0(00)
4 (09)
p =0148
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
Our study revealed that the most common disease of the respiratory system was URTI
(upper respiratory tract infection) found in 72 (164) subjects followed by acute bronchitis
in 19 (43 ) bronchial asthma in 6 (14) and pulmonary TB in only in 4 (09 ) subjects
Pulmonary TB was found in 4 (15) of the males whereas no females had TB however
this difference was not found to be statistically significant
54
Results
Table 21 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the digestive system
Disorders of
Gastrointestinal
system
Males
(n = 260)
Females
(n = 180)
Total
(n = 440)
Statistical value
Constipation
21(8)
6 (33)
27(61)
X2 =4155
df =1
p =0041
Gastritis
24 (92)
18 (10)
42(95)
X2= 0072
df = 1
p =0787
Bleeding per
rectum 3(12) 2(11) 5(11)
p =100
Others (Pain
abdomen
anorexia
indigestion)
9(35)
4 (22)
13 (3)
X2=0569
df =1
p=0450
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
Our study revealed that the most common disorder of the gastrointestinal system was
gastritis found in 42 (95) subjects followed by constipation in 27 ( 61) others which
include pain abdomen anorexia indigestion was found in 13 (3) and bleeding per rectum
was seen in 5 (11) It was seen that constipation was more common among males 21(8)
compared to females 6 (33) which was found to be statistically significant
55
Results
Table 22 Distribution the study subjects based on disease of the Skin and
subcutaneous tissue
Disorders of skin and
subcutaneous tissue
Males ( n = 260)
Females (n = 180)
Total (n = 440)
Statistical
value
Itching
19(73)
2(11)
21(48)
X2 =896
df=1
p = 0002
Scaling 6 (23)
3 (17)
9 (2)
p =0743
Pigmentation
5(19)
4 (22)
9 (2)
p =100
Dryness
8 (31)
11 (61)
19(43)
X2= 237
df = 1
p = 0123 Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
In the present study it was found that the most common disease of the skin was itching
which was present in 21 (48) of the study subjects followed by dryness in 19 (43) and 9
(2) of the subjects had scaling and pigmentation It was seen that itching was more
common among males 19 (73) compared to females 2 (11) and this difference was
found to be statistically significant
56
Results
Table 23 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the ear
Disease of the ear
Males
(n= 260)
Females
(n = 180)
Total
(n = 440) Statistical value
Hearing impairment
33 (126)
16 (89)
49 (111)
X2 =155
df =1
p =0212
Ear discharge
3 (12)
1 (06)
4(09)
p =0647
Tinnitus
3 (12)
1 (06)
4 (09)
p =0647
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
In the present study it was observed that hearing impairment was the most common
morbidity of the ear found in 49 (111) of the subjects though it was more common
among males 33 (126) compared to females 16 (89) the difference was not found to be
statistically significant The other disorders which affected the ear were ear discharge and
tinnitus both present in 4 (09) of the subjects
57
Results
Table 24 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the genitourinary
system
Disorders of
genitourinary system
Male
(n = 260)
Female
(n = 180)
Total
(n=440)
Statistical value
Burning micturition
2 (077)
2 (11)
4 (09)
p=100
Increased frequency of
micturition
20(77) 5(28) 25(57)
X2= 4794
df =1
p =0028 Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
In our study it was observed that the most common morbidity affecting the genitourinary
system was increased frequency of micturition in 25 (57) of the subjects followed by
burning micturition in 4 (09) of the study subjects Increased frequency of micturition was
more common among males 20 (77) compared to females 5 (28) and this difference
was found to be statistically significant
58
Results
Table 25 Distribution of the study subjects based on diseases of the Nervous system
Disease of the
nervous system Males
(n = 260)
Females
(n = 180)
Total
(n = 440)
p value
Memory loss
2 (77)
2 (11)
4 (09)
100
Stroke
2 (77)
0 (00)
2 (05)
0515
Neuritis
2 (77)
3 (17)
5 (11)
0652
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
Our study revealed that the most common disorder of the nervous system was neuritis seen
in 5 (11) of the subjects followed by memory loss in 4 (09) and stroke in 2 (05 ) of
the subjects It was observed that 2 (0 77) of males had suffered a stroke whereas none of
the females had suffered from stroke however this difference was not found to be
statistically significant
59
Results
Table 26 Association between morbidity pattern of the study subjects and their age
group
System involved 60-69Yrs
(n = 271)
70-79Yrs
(n = 134)
gt 80Yrs
(n = 35)
Total
( n = 440)
Statistical
value
Musculoskeletal
System
195 (72)
94 (70)
25 (710)
314 (714) X2= 0143
df = 2 p = 0930
Eye amp adnexa
125 (461)
69 (515)
25 (714)
219 (497) X2= 8166
df = 2 p = 0016
Oral cavity amp salivary gland
56 (207)
68 (507)
30 (857)
154 (350) X2= 7865
df = 2 p lt 00001
Endocrine nutritional amp
metabolic diseases
91 (335)
47 (35)
7 (200)
145 (329) X2= 297
df = 2 p = 0225
Circulatory
system
87 (321)
40 (298)
10 (285)
137 (311) X2= 0328
df = 2 p = 0848
Respiratory
system
64 (236)
31 (231)
6 (171)
101 (23) X2= 0738
df = 2 p = 0691
Digestive system
52 (191)
28 (210)
7 (200)
87 (191) X2= 0166
df = 2 p = 0 920
Skin and subcutaneous
tissue
43 (159)
13 (97)
2 (57)
58 (132) X2= 4831
df = 2 p = 0089
Ear amp mastoid process
27 (99)
20 (149)
10 (285)
57 (13) X2= 1018
d= 2 p = 0006
Genitourinary
system
20 (74)
8 (59)
1 (29)
29 (66) X2= 1151
df = 2 p = 0562
Nervous system
5 (18)
4 (29)
2 (57)
11 (25)
p = 0418
Figure in parenthesis indicates percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
60
Results
Table 26 shows the association between the morbidity pattern and age group of the study
subjects It is observed that the disease of the eye and adnexa increase with increasing age
and are more common in individuals above 80 years of age (714) compared to
individuals in the age group of 60-69 years (461) and 70-79 years (515) This
difference was found to be statistically significant The disease of the oral cavity were also
more common in the subjects aged 80 years and above (857) compared to individuals in
the age group of 70-79 years (507) and 60-69 years (207) this difference was also
found to be statistically significant Significant association was also found between
increasing age and disease of the ear 285 subjects aged 80 years and above suffered from
disease of the ear followed by 149 in the age group of 60-69 years and 99 in the age
group of 60-69 years
61
Results Table 27 Association between morbidity pattern of the study subjects and their
occupation
System involved Employed (n=215)
Unemployed (n=225)
Total (n=440)
Statistical value
Musculoskeletal
system
171 (795) 143 (635) 314 (714) X2 =1374 df=1
p=00002
Eye and adnexa 108 (502) 111(493) 219(497) X2= 0035 df=1
p= 0850
Oral cavityamp
salivary glands
76 (353) 78 (347) 154 (35) X2=0022 df=1
p=0880
Endocrine
nutritional amp
metabolic
disease
75 (348) 70 (311) 145 (329) X2=0708 df=1
p=0400
circulatory
system
58 (269) 79 (351) 137 (311) X2=3393 df=1
p=0065
Respiratory
system
49 (227) 52 (231) 101 (23) X2=0006 df=1
p=09363
Digestive system 45 (21) 42 (187) 87 (198) X2=0125 df=1
p=0723
Skin
subcutaneous
tissue
38 (176) 20 (88) 58 (132) X2=741 df=1
p=0006
Ear and mastoid
process
31 (144) 26 (115) 57 (13) X2=0799 df=1
p=0371
Genitourinary
system
16 (74) 13 (57) 29 (66) X2=0494 df=1
p=0481
Nervous system
2 (093) 9 (4) 11 (25) X2=425 df=1
p=0039 Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses
62
Results
Table 27 shows the association between the morbidity pattern and occupation of the study
subjects It was observed that musculoskeletal disorders were more common among the
subjects who are employed (795) compared to those who are not employed (635) and
this difference was found to be statistically significant A significant association was also
seen between the disorders of the skin and subcutaneous tissue 176 subjects who are
employed suffered from the disease of the skin and subcutaneous tissue compared to 88
who were unemployed The diseases of the nervous system were more common among
those who were unemployed (4) compared to those who were employed (093) this
difference was also found to be statistically significant
63
Results Table 28 Association between morbidity pattern of the study subjects and their
religion
System involved Hindu
(n=188)
Muslim
(n=252)
Total
(n=440)
Statistical value
Musculoskeletal system 138 (73) 176 (698) 314 (714)
X2=0668 df=1
p=0413
Eye and adnexa 100 (531) 119 (472) 219 (497) X2=1535 df=1
p= 0215
Oral cavityamp salivary glands 73 (388) 81 (321) 154 (35)
X2=211 df=1
p=0145
Endocrine nutritional amp metabolic diseases
53 (2819) 92 (365) 145 (329) X2=3371 df=1
p=0066
circulatory system 58 (269) 79 (351) 137 (311)
X2=3393 df=1
p=0065
Respiratory system
33 (176) 68 (269) 101 (229)
X2=5415 df= 1
p=0019
Digestive system 27 (144) 60 (238) 87 (198) X2=6059 df=1
p=0013
Skin subcutaneous tissue
31 (164) 27 (107) 58 (132) X2=3138 df=1
p=00765
Ear and mastoid process
28 (149) 29 (115) 57 (129) X2=1095 df=1
p=0297
Genitourinary system
16 (85) 13 (52) 29 (66) X2=1965 df=1
p=0161
Nervous system
4 (21) 7 (28) 11(25) p=0764
Figure in parenthesis indicates percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
64
Results
Table 28 shows the association between the morbidity pattern of the study subjects and their
religion In our study it was observed that the disorders of the digestive system were more
common among Muslims (238) compared to Hindus (144) this difference was found
to be statistically significant Also the disorders of the respiratory system were more
common among Muslims (269) compared to Hindus (176) This difference was also
found to be statistically significant Some of the diseases were more common among Hindus
which include the disease of the eye and adnexa (531) oral cavity (388) ear (149)
skin and subcutaneous tissue (164) and genitourinary system (85) but it was not found
to be statistically significant
65
Results
III HEATLTH SEEKING BEHAVIOR OF THE STUDY SUBJECTS
Figure16 Distribution of the study subjects based on the visit to health facility in case
of an illness
In our study it was found that that out of 440 study subjects 395(898) visited a health
facility in case of an illness whereas 45(102) did not visit any health facility in case of an
illness
898
102
health facility visitednot visited
66
Results
Table 29 Reasons cited by the study subjects for not seeking healthcare in case of an
illness
In the present study it was found that the most common reason stated by the 45 study
subjects for not seeking health care in case of an illness was that it was a mil 20 (444)
followed by lack of money stated by12 (267) the other reasons stated were no one to
accompany 7 (156) and lack of faith in health care 6 (133)
Reasons cited for not
seeking health care
Frequency (n=45)
Percentage ()
Mild discomfort 20 444
Lack of money 12 267
Lack of faith in
healthcare
6 133
No one to accompany 7 156
Total 45 100
67
Results
Table 30 Distribution of the study subjects based on the type of health facility visited
It was observed that out of 395 subjects who visited health care facility in case of an illness
229(58) Visited government hospitals 160 (405) visited private practitioners hospitals
and 6 (15) visited quacks More number of males (622) visited government hospitals
compared to females (513)
Type of health facility visited
Males
(n=241)
Females
(n=154)
Total
(n=395)
No No No
Government hospital 150 622 79 513 229 58
Private practitionershospitals 87 361 73 474 160 405
Quacks 4 17 2 13 6 15
Total 241 100 154 100 395 100
68
Results
Table 31 Association between gender and health seeking behaviour of the study
subjects
Whether visited
health facility
in case of illness
Sex
Total
n ()
p value Male
n ()
Female
n ()
Yes 241 (927) 154 (856) 395 (898) 00151
No 19 (106) 26 (144) 45 (102)
Total 260 (59) 180 (41) 440 (100)
x2=5901 df =1
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
It was observed that more number of males visited a health care facility in case of an illness
241(927) whereas only 154(856) females visited a health facility in case of an illness
This difference was found to be statistically significant
69
Results
Table 32 Association between educational status and health seeking
behaviour of the study subjects
Whether visited Health facility in case of illness
p value
Educational status(n) Yes () No ()
0000
Illiterate (231) 194 (84) 37 (16)
Primary school (121) 115 (95) 6 (49)
Higher primary (38) 37 (974) 1 (26)
Secondary school (30) 29 (967) 1 (33)
Intermediate (6) 6 (100) 0(00)
Graduate (14) 14 (100) 0(00)
Total(440) 395 (898) 45(102)
Fisherrsquos exact test
In the present study it was found that 84 of the study subjects who were illiterate visited a
health facility in case of an illness whereas 16 did not visit a health facility in case of an
illness 967 of the subjects with education up to secondary school visited the health
facility and 100 of the subjects who studied up to intermediate and with a graduate degree
visited the health facility in case of an illness This difference was found to be statistically
significant
70
Results
Table 33 Distribution of study subjects according to frequency of visits to a health care facility
Frequency of visits to a health care facility
Frequency
(n=395)
Percentage
Once a month 207 524
Once in 3 months 99 251
Once in 6 months 79 20
Once in a year 10 25
Total 395 100
In the present study it was found that out of 395 study subjects who visited a health care
facility in case of an illness 207 (524) visited a health facility every month followed by
99 (251) who visited once in 3 months 79(20) once in 6 months and 10 25 visited
the health facility once in a year
71
Discussion
DISCUSSION
I Socio-demographic characteristics
Our study was done in the urban field practice area of JJM Medical College Davangere
among 440 geriatric subjects our study aimed at assessing the morbidity pattern and health
seeking behaviour of the geriatric population in the study area
In the present study Out of 440 study subjects majority 162(368) were in the age
group of 60-64 Years followed by 109 (247) in the age group of 65-69 Years 99 (225)
in the age group of 70-74 Years and 8 were more than or equal to 80 years of age [Table
7] This was similar to a study conducted by Prakash Boraingaiah et al 72 in which majority
of the elderly (346) belongs to age group 60-64 years followed by age group 75 years and
above (259)
In our study it was also seen that 59 of the study subjects were males and 41 were
females This was similar to a study conducted by Mohan Gupta et al 35 where 573
subjects were males and 427were females Our findings were contrary to a study
conducted by Md Alam Naushad et al 28 where 598 subjects were females and 402
were males
In the present study it was found that the majority of the study subject belonged to
Muslim religion 252 (573) followed by Hindus 188 (427) there were no study subjects
who belonged to other religions like Christian Jain Sikhs etc [Table 8] similar findings
were seen in a study conducted by Mrinal Ranjan Srivastav et al 50 in which 52 of the
subjects were Muslims
72
Discussion
In the present study it was found that the Majority of the study subjects were illiterate
525 whereas 275 had completed education up to primary school 82 had completed
education up to secondary school and only 32 were graduates [Table 9] These findings
were similar to a study done by Shraddha K et al 51in which 504 of the study subjects
were illiterate
In our study it was found that the majority of the study subjects 511 were unemployed
followed by 227 who were unskilled workers 155 were semi-skilled workers and
about 105 were skilled workers [Table 10] These findings were similar to a study done
by Rajat Das Gupta et al27 al in which 481 of the study subjects were not working
In our study majority of the subjects 49 belonged to Class IV Socioeconomic status
followed by 26 who belonged to class III and 13 who belonged to class II (according to
Modified BG Prasad Classification 2016) [Table 11] Similar findings were found in a study
conducted by Sribas Goswami and Manjari Sahai 29 in which majority of the study subjects
belonged to class IV socio economic status
In our study it was found that the majority of the study subjects 734 were married
followed by 261 who were widowed and only 05 were unmarried [Table 12] These
findings were similar to a study done by L subedhi and RB Sah 40 in which 663 of the
subjects were married 322 were widowed and 07 were unmarried
In the present study it was found that majority of the study subjects 42 lived in a three
generation family followed by 37 who lived in a nuclear family and 21 who lived in a
Joint family [Table 13] These findings were similar to a study done by Swapnil Jain et al 26
in which the majority (47) of the study subjects lived in a three generation family
73
Discussion
II Prevalence of morbidities among the study subjects
In the present study it was found that majority of the subjects 45 had a normal BMI
followed by 30 who were overweight about 15 were obese and only10 were
underweight [Figure 14] Similar findings were reported in a study conducted by Khadervali
Nagoor et al 44 in which 49 subjects had a normal BMI In a study done by Vimala
Thomas et al 52 272 of the subjects were obese which was higher than the present study
In the present study it was found that the majority of the subjects suffered from the
disorders of the musculoskeletal system (714) eye and adnexa (497) oral cavity
(311) respiratory system (229) digestive system (198)disease of the skin
(132)ear(13)genitourinary system (66) nervous system (25) [Table14] Similar
findings were seen in a study done by Rajashree Bhat et al 55 in which most common
morbidity of elderly was the problems of loco-motor system (486) followed by vision
(427) CVS disorders (344) respiratory system (202) and disease of ear (179)In
this study though the prevalence of loco-motor system disorders (486) was highest
compared to other disorders it was lesser compared to our study (714) In a study done by
L subedhi and RB Sah 40 it was found that 44 had eye problems 43 had gastrointestinal
problems 33 had CVS problems and 23 had ENT problems In this study the prevalence
of gastrointestinal disorders was much higher compared to our study
In the present study joint pain (including the knee joint) was most common disorder of the
musculoskeletal system seen in 40 of the males compared to 384 in females [Table 15]
whereas in a study done by Swapnil Jain et al 26 it was found that 472 males and 528
females suffered from joint pains This could be attributed to the fact that in our study
majority of the study subjects were males
74
Discussion
In the present study it was found that the most common morbidity of the eye was cataract
found in 39 of the subjects It was more common in males 43 compared to females
333 [ Table 16]These findings were similar to a study done by Shraddha K et al 51 in
which the overall prevalence of cataract was 302 of which 42 males and 358
females had cataract
In the present study it was found that the most common morbidity of the oral cavity was
missing teeth found in 177 of the subjects [Table 17] it was similar to the findings of a
study conducted by JP Singh et al 48 in which 1475 subjects were edentulous
The present study revealed that the most common disorder of the endocrine system was
diabetes mellitus found in 186 of the subjects followed by the nutritional disorder of
anemia found in 134 of the subjects It was seen that anemia was more common among
females 194 compared to males 92 [Table 18] Kakkar R et al 45 reported similar
findings with prevalence of diabetes mellitus as 153 In a study done by Deepak Sharma
et al 47 anemia was present in 15 of the subjects 97 males and 21 females were
anemic which was similar to our study
In our study it was found that the most common disease of the circulatory system was
hypertension which was found in 302 of the subjects it was more common in females
394 compared to males 239 and this difference was found to be statistically significant
[Table 19] A study by L Subedhi and RB Sah 40 reported that the prevalence of
hypertension was more among females (333) compared to males (30) which was
statistically significant
75
Discussion
In our study the most common morbidity of the respiratory system was upper respiratory
tract infection (163) [Table20] it was similar to the study done by Leena Rahul
Salunke33 where it was reported to be 196
In our study the most common disorder of the digestive system was gastritis (95)
[Table 21] similar to the findings of JP Singh et al 48 (35) contrary to this L subedhi
and RB Sah 40 reported a high prevalence of gastritis (39) This difference could be
attributed to the difference in the interpretation of symptoms for the diagnosis of gastritis
In our study the most common disorder of the skin was itching (48) [ Table 22] which
was similar to the findings reported by JP Singh et al 48 in which 225 subjects suffered
from itching
In our study the most common disorder of the ear was impaired hearing (111) [Table
23] similar to a study by Vandana Nikumb et al 38 in which 106 subjects suffered from
hearing impairment
In our study it was observed that the most common morbidity affecting the
genitourinary system was increased frequency of micturition (57) [Table 24]
L subedhi and RB Sah40 found in their study that 143 subjects suffered from increased
frequency of micturition which was higher compared to our study
Our study revealed that 25 subjects suffered from the disorders of the nervous
system [Table 25] similar to a study conducted by Vandana Nikumb et al 38 in which
13 of the Subjects suffered from the disorders of the nervous system whereas in a
study conducted by Shilpa Shaukaiah et al36 it was found that 66 of the subjects
suffered from the disorders of the nervous system which was higher than our study
76
Discussion
It is observed that the disease of the eye and adnexa increased with increasing age and were
more common in individuals above 80 years of age (714) The disease of the oral cavity
were also more common in the subjects aged 80 years and above (857) and 285
subjects aged 80 years and above suffered from disease of the ear A significant association
was found between age and these morbidities [Table 26] Similar results were found in a
study done by Swapnil Jain et al 26 in which cataract hearing impairment and dental
problems were significantly associated with the age of the study subjects
In our study a significant association was found between occupation and the disorders of
the musculoskeletal system skin and the nervous system Disorders of the musculoskeletal
system were more common among employed subjects (795) compared to unemployed
(635) 176 subjects who were employed suffered from the disease of the skin and
subcutaneous tissue compared to 88 who were unemployed Diseases of the nervous
system were more common among those who were unemployed (4) compared to those
who were employed (093) [Table 27]
A study done by Kakkar R et al45 found that there was a significant association between the
employment status and the morbidities of the CVS arthritis and cataract CVS morbidity
was more common among those not working (164) compared to those working (36)
Arthritis was also more common among not working (212) compared to those working
(55) and cataract was also more common among those not working (175) compared to
those working (55)
77
Discussion
In our study it was observed that there was a significant association between religion and
disorders of the digestive system and respiratory system The disorders of the digestive
system were more common among Muslims (238) compared to Hindus (144) Also the
disorders of the respiratory system were more common among Muslims (269) compared
to Hindus (176) [Table 28] In a study conducted by Mrinal Ranjan Srivastav et al 50 it
was found that there was significant association between religion and the morbidities of the
genitourinary system in the urban areas The problems of the genitourinary system were
more common among Hindus (26) compared to Muslims (96)
III HEATLTH SEEKING BEHAVIOR OF THE STUDY SUBJECTS
In our study it was found that that (898) study subjects visited a health facility in case
of an illness whereas 102 did not visit any health facility in case of an illness[Figure 16]
Similar findings were seen in a study conducted by Vimala Thomas et al 52 where it was
found that 716 subjects visited a health facility Contrary to our findings a study
conducted by Bhawalkar JS et al46 showed that only 81 subjects visited a health facility in
case of an illness whereas 919 did not visit any health facility
In the present study it was found that the most common reason stated by study subjects
for not seeking health care in case of an illness was that it was a mild discomfort (444)
followed by lack of money stated by (267) other reasons stated were no one to
accompany (156) and lack of faith in health care (133) [Table 29] In a study
conducted by Deepak Sharma et al 47 it was found that the most common reasons for not
seeking health care were the following disease due to age (496) health services too far
(191) lack of money (6) no body to take to hospital (35)
78
Discussion
It was observed that out of 395 subjects who visited health care facility in case of an illness
58 Visited government hospitals 362 visited private practitioners hospitals and 15
visited quacks [Table 30] similar results were found in a study conducted by Deepak Sharma
et al 47 in which 607 went to Government hospitals 267 consulted private practitioners
and 126 took over the counter drugs In another study conducted by Rajat Das Gupta et al
27 it was found that 33 visited Government hospitals 25 visited private hospitals 6
visited private practitioners
It was observed that more number of males (927) visited a health care facility in case of
an illness whereas only 856 females visited a health facility in case of an illness [Table
31] In a study done by Man Mohan Gupta et al 35 it was found that 672 females and
651 males visited a health facility in case of illness
In the present study it was found that 848 of the study subjects who were illiterate
visited a health facility in case of an illness whereas 152 did not visit a health facility in
case of an illness A significant association was found between educational status and
gender [Table 32] In a study done by Deepak Sharma et al 47 it was found that Gender
literacy income and marital status were not found to be significantly related to health-
seeking behaviour
In the present study it was found that 524 subjects visited a health facility every month
followed by 251 who visited a health facility once in 3 months 20once in 6 months
and 25 visited a health facility once in a year[ Table 33] In a study conducted by Rajat
Das Gupta et al 27 it was found that majority of the subjects (2943) visited a health
facility once a year followed by 2813 who visited a health facility once in three months
79
Conclusion
CONCLUSION
The study revealed that some of the common morbidities among the geriatric subjects were
the disorders of the musculoskeletal system followed by the disease of the eye and adnexa
oral cavity endocrine nutritional and metabolic disorders etc some disorders like cataract
dental caries constipation and increased frequency of micturition were more common
among males whereas disease like anemia and hypertension were more common among
females A significant association was found between some of the morbidities and socio
demographic determinants like age occupation and religion
Any degree of formal schooling was found to be associated with better health seeking
behavior Majority of the subjects visited a Government health facility in case of an illness
and the main reason that was stated for not visiting a health facility was that they suffered
from mild discomfort and did not consider it necessary to visit a health facility
80
Summary
SUMMARY
Our study was done in the urban field practice area of JJM Medical College Davangere
among 440 geriatric subjects our study aimed at assessing the morbidity pattern and health
seeking behaviour of the geriatric population in the study area
The results of our study are as follows
ISocio-demographic characteristics of the study subjects
In the present study 368 subjects were in the age group of 60-64 Years
59 of the subjects were males and 41 were females
573 subjects were Muslims whereas 427 were Hindus
Majority of the subjects were illiterate (525) whereas 275 had completed
education up to primary school
It was found that the majority of the study subjects (511) were unemployed
49 subjects belonged to Class IV Socioeconomic status according to Modified BG
Prasad Classification
734 of the subjects were married
42 of the people lived in a three generation family
II Prevalence of morbidities among the study subjects
Majority of the subjects (45) had a normal BMI followed 30who were
overweight
Majority 714 subjects suffered from the disorders of the musculoskeletal system
followed by 497 who suffered from the disease of the eye and adnexa35
suffered from the disease of the oral cavity 329 suffered from endocrine
nutritional and metabolic disorders and 311 suffered from the disease of the
circulatory system 229 suffered from the disease of the respiratory system198
81
Summary
suffered from the disease of the digestive system132 suffered from disease of the
skin13 suffered from the disease of the ear66 suffered from the disease of the
genitourinary system and 25 suffered from the disease of the nervous system
The most common morbidity of musculoskeletal system was pain of the joints (other
than the knee joint) found in 198 of the subjectsBack ache was more common in
females 231 compared to males 163 and this difference was found to be
statistically significant
cataract found in 39 of the subjects It was more common in males 43 compared
to females 333 and this difference was found to be statistically significant
Missing teeth were found in 177 of the subjects Dental caries were more
common in males 108 compared to females 44 and this difference was found to
be statistically significant
Diabetes mellitus found in 186 of the subjects followed by the nutritional disorder
of anemia found in 134 of the subjects anemia was more common among females
194 compared to males 92 This difference was found to be statistically
significant
Hypertension which was found in 302 of the subjects it was more common in
females 394 compared to males 239 and this difference was found to be
statistically significant
upper respiratory tract infection) found in 163 subjects followed by acute
bronchitis in 43 bronchial asthma in 14 and pulmonary TB in only 09
Gastritis was found in 95 subjects followed by constipation in 61 Among
males (81) had constipation compared to females(03)
Most common disease of the skin was itching which was present in 48 of the
study subjects followed by dryness in 43
82
Summary
Hearing impairment was found in 111 of the subjects
Increased frequency of micturition was found in 57 of the subjects followed by
burning micturition in 09 of the study subjects Increased frequency of
micturition was more among males 77 compared to females in whom it was 28
and this difference was found to be statistically significant
The most common disorder of the nervous system was neuritis seen in 11 of the
subjects followed by memory loss in 09 and stroke in 05 of the subjects
A significant association was found between increasing age and the morbidities of
the eye ear and the oral cavity
Significant association was found between occupation and the disorders of the
musculoskeletal system skin and the nervous system Disorders of the
musculoskeletal system were more common among employed subjects (795)
compared to unemployed (635) 176 subjects who were employed suffered
from the disease of the skin and subcutaneous tissue compared to 88 who were
unemployed Diseases of the nervous system were more common among those who
were unemployed (4) compared to those who were employed (093)
It was observed that the disorders of the digestive system were more common
among Muslims (238) compared to Hindus (144) this difference was found to
be statistically significant Also the disorders of the respiratory system were more
common among Muslims (269) compared to Hindus (176) This difference
was also found to be statistically significant
83
Summary
III HEATLTH SEEKING BEHAVIOR OF THE STUDY SUBJECTS
In our study 898 subjects visited a health facility in case of an illness whereas
102 did not
The most common reason stated by study subjects for not seeking health care in case
of an illness was that it was a mild discomfort (444) followed by lack of money
stated by (267) the other reasons stated were no one to accompany (156) and
lack of faith in health care (133)
It was observed that 58 subjects Visited Government hospitals 362 visited
private practitioners hospitals and 15 visited quacks
Majority of males (927) visited a health care facility in case of an illness whereas
only 856 females visited a health facility in case of an illness This difference was
found to be statistically significant
A significant association was found between the educational status and health
seeking behaviour Majority of the educated subjects visited a health facility in case
of an illness compared to those who were illiterate
It was found that 524 subjects visited a health facility every month followed by
251 who visited a health facility once in 3 months 20once in 6 months and
25 visited a health facility once in a year
84
Limitations
LIMITATIONS
1 Many of the responses were subjective and there were no records to verify them
2 Some of the morbidities were diagnosed only by clinical examination and could not be
confirmed by performing diagnostic tests due to high cost and time constraints
3 This study was done in the urban field practice area which consisted of a closed
community hence the results cannot be generalized to the entire population of the area
85
Recommendations
RECOMMENDATIONS
1 Health education should be given to the geriatric people regarding the common health
problems associated with ageing and preventive care should be provided to the elderly
2 Geriatric clinics should be set up at the primary health care level which provide regular
screening and health check-ups
3 There should also be a provision to provide domiciliary care by specialists qualified in
geriatrics
4 The family members and the care givers of the elderly should be educated about the
common health problems of the elderly and also about the need for regular health check-ups
and emotional support
5 The majority of the geriatric population is out of work force they are suffering from
many morbidities and are totally dependent on others even for their health needs Hence the
Government should increase the pension of the elderly and provide them quality healthcare
free of cost
6 There is also a need for public private partnership to improve the quality of health
services for the geriatric people More number of NGOs should work towards improving the
health and the quality of life of the elderly
86
References
REFERENCES
1 United Nations Department of Economic and Social affairs Population Division
World population ageing 2013 Available from URL
wwwunorgendevelopmentpopulationageingWorldPopulationAgeing2013
[Accessed on 17-7-2016]
2 Khan S and Itrat M Current Issues in Geriatric Health Care in India-A Review J Community Med Health Care 2016 1(1) 1-3
3 United Nations Department of Economic and Social Affairs Population Division
World Population Ageing 2015 ndash Highlights Available from URL
wwwunorgendevelopmentdesapopulationpdfageingWPA2015_Reportpdf
[Accessed on 272017]
4 State of elderly in India 2014 Help age India Available from URL
httpswwwhelpageindiaorgimagespdfstate-elderly-india-2014pdf [Accessed on
1082017]
5 World Health Organization World report on ageing and health 2015Available
from URL wwwwhointageingeventsworld-report-2015-launchen [Accessed on
1272017]
6 National policy for Senior citizens March 2011Ministry of Social Justice and
welfare Govt of India Available from URL
socialjusticenicinwritereaddataUploadFilednpscpdf [Accessed on 482017]
87
References
7 Elderly in India Profile and programmes 2016Govt of India Ministry of statistics
and programme implementation Central Statistics Office Available from URL
wwwmopsigovin [ Accessed on 1442017]
8 Saxena V Kandpal SD Gael D Bansal S Health status of elderly community
based study Indian Journal of Community Health2012 Oct-Dec24(4)269-74
9 Shah T Patel M Shah V Health care seeking behaviour of urban and rural
community in Ahmedabad district Int J Med Sci Public Health20132908-11
10 Sahoo H Mishra NR Health Status Morbidity Pattern and Treatment Seeking
Behaviour among Elderly in India Evidence from 60th round of National Sample
Survey Data Learning community 2011 Dec 2(3) 341-55
11 Park K Parkrsquos Textbook of Preventive and social medicine 24 th ed Jabalpur MS
Banarsidas Bhanot Publishers2017631
12 UNFPA- state of World Population 2011Chapter 1 setting the scene 19-31
Available from URL httpswwwunfpaorgsitesdefaultfilesresource-
pdfUNFPA-Report-Chapter1pd [Accessed on 1082017]
13 Lal S Adarsh Pankaj Textbook of community Medicine 4th ed CBS publishers and
distributors PvtLtd2011732
14 Census of India 2001 Registrar General And Census Commissioner India
Available from URL httpwwwcensusindiagovinCensus[Accessed on
7102015]
15 SRS bulletin October 2012 Registar General of India New Delhi Available from
URL censusindiagovinvital_statisticsSRS_BulletinsSRS_Bulletin-
October_2012[Acessed on 7102015]
88
References
16 Bagchi K Healthy ageing Health and Population-Perspectives and Issues 2000
23(1)11-16
17 Salagre SB The Association of Physicians of India Chapter 177 Health Issues in
Geriatrics Available from URL
wwwapiindiaorgmedicine_update_2013chap177pd [ Accessed on 282017]
18 Ingle GK Nath A Geriatric Health in India Concerns and Solutions Indian Journal
of Community Medicine 2008 33(4)214-18
19 World Health Organization Active Ageing a policy framework 2002 Available
from httpwhqlibdocwhointhq2002who_nmh_nph_028pdf [Accessed on
1062017]
20 Inche Zainal Abidin S Sutan R Shamsuddin K Prevalence and determinants of
appropriate health seeking behaviour among known diabetics Results from a
community-based survey Advances in Epidemiology 2014 Nov 20141-6
21 Begashaw B Tessema F Gesesew HA Health Care Seeking behavior in Southwest
Ethiopia Plos one 2016 Sep 11(9)e0161014
22 MacKian S Health systems development Manchester University of Manchester
2003 A review of health seeking behavior problems and prospects
23 Metta EO Health-seeking behaviour among adults in the context of the
epidemiological transition in Southeastern Tanzania A focus on malaria and
diabetes [Groningen] University of Groningen 2016 228 Available from URL
httpswwwrugnlresearchportalfiles28737720Chapter_7pdf [Accessed on
1272017]
24 Adhikari D Rijal D Factors affecting health seeking behaviour of senior citizens of
Dharan Journal of Nobel Medical College 2015 Sep 4(1)57-63
25 Polisetty S Seepana M Morbidity profile of elderly individuals in urban
Visakhapatnam Int J Community Med Public Health 2017 4(2)2558-63
89
References
26 Jain S Kaware AC Doibale MK Shaikh S Radhey BK Mathurkar MP Morbidity
pattern among geriatric population in urban field practice area of district of
Maharashtra a cross sectional study Int J Community Med Public Health 2016
3(2)523-29
27 Gupta RD Loha A Roy S Morbidity pattern and health-seeking behaviour among
the senior citizens in a selected urban area of Bangladesh A cross-sectional study
South East Asia Journal of Public Health 2016 Jul 5(2)43-49
28 Naushad MA Verma N Bhawnani D Jain M Anand T Umate LV Morbidity
pattern and health seeking behaviour in elderly population of Raipur City
Chhattisgarh India Indian Journal of Community Health2016 Sep 28(3)236-41
29 Goswami S Sahai M A Study of Morbidity Pattern in Elderly Population European
Researcher Series A 2016103(2)119-28
30 Bardhan H Dixit AM Agarwal R Jain PK Gupta S Shukla SK Morbidity profile
of elderly population in Ghaziabad district a cross-sectional study Int J Med Sci
Public Health 2016 5(6)1098-1102
31 Maroof M Ahmad A Khalique N Ansari MA Health problems among the aged A
community based study from urban Aligarh Uttar Pradesh India Int J Community
Med Public Health 2016 Feb 3(4)944-47
32 Shankar G Sidenur B A morbidity study of elderly residing in urban field practice
area of SN medical college Bagalkot National Journal of research in community
medicine 2016 Oct-Dec 4(5) 229-34
90
References
33 Salunkhe LR Socio-demographic profile of old age people living in urban amp urban
slum areas in Maharashtra Karad A comparative study J of Evidence based Med
and Hlthcare 2015 Feb 2(5) 513-21
34 Warbhe P Rupesh W Morbidity profile health seeking behaviour and home
environment survey for adaptive measures in geriatric population-Urban community
study International Journal of Medical Research amp Health Sciences 2015 4(4)778-
82
35 Gupta M Borle AL Chhari N Gupta S Assessment of clinico-socioeconomic
status and health-care support among the elderly people aged older than 60 years in
urban population of Bhopal Central India Int J Med Sci Public Health 2015
4558-64
36 Sahukaiah S Shenoy A Vijayakumar BC An epidemiological study of prevalence
of morbidity patterns among geriatric age group in an urban slum of Mumbai Int J
Med Sci Public Health 2015 Jul 4(7)883-87
37 Shubha Davalagi B Angadi N Mahabalaraju DK Morbidity psycho-social profile
and health seeking behaviour of the elderly population in urban slums of Davangere
City India Int J Res Med Sci 2015 Nov 3(11)3288-91
38 Nikumb V Patankar F Behera A A Study of Morbidity Profile among Geriatric
Population in an Urban Area Sch J App Med Sci 2015 3(3)1365-69
91
References
39 Vishnoi BR Solanki SL Singhal G Meharda B Mishra N Morbidity profile of
elderly in urban slum of Udaipur Rajasthan Int J Oral Health Med Res 2015 May
2(1)9-12
40 Subedi L Sah RB Study of the health status of geriatric age group in Chitwan
district of Nepal Journal of Chitwan Medical College 2015 Mar 5(1)11-17
41 Noor S Krishnababu G Prasad KV Health status of Geriatric population in slums
of Rourkela Young Innovative Journal of Medical and Health Science 2015 May
5(3) 92-94
42 Sarode VM Chronic Diseases Related to Aging and Disease Prevention in Slums in
Mumbai Journal of Aging Science 2014 Jan 2 (1)1-6
43 Barman SK Lata K Ram R Ghosh N Sarker G Shahnawaz K A study of
morbidity profile of geriatric population in an urban community of Kishanganj
Bihar India Global Journal of Medicine and Public Health GJMEDPH 2014 3(1)
1-7
44 Nagoor K Srikanth BA Dudekula R Satna K Comparative study of health status
among slum and non-slum elderly population in Kadapa Region South India
Journal of Evolution of Medical and Dental Sciences 2014 Feb 3(5)1298-308
45 Kakkar R Aggarwal P Kandpal SD Bansal SK An Epidemiological study to assess
morbidity profile among geriatric population in District Dehradun Indian Journal of
Community Health 2013 May 25(1)39-44
46 Bhawalkar JS Dhone AB Jethani S Singru S Jadhav SL Adyanthaya S A study of
morbidity profile among geriatric population in an urban area J Evol Med Dent Sci
2013 Sep 9 36(2)6963-7
92
References
47 Sharma D Mazta SR Parashar A Morbidity pattern and health-seeking behaviour of
aged population residing in Shimla hills of north India A cross-sectional study
Journal of family medicine and primary care 2013 Apr2(2)188
48 Singh JP Singh S Kasturwar NB Hassan A Geriatric morbidity profile in an urban
slum Central India Indian Journal of Community Health 2013 Aug 25(2)164-70
49 Thakur RP Banerjee A Nikumb VB Health Problems among the Elderly A Cross
Sectional Study Annals of medical and health sciences research 2013 3(1)19-25
50 Mrinal RS Beena S Pratibha G Pankaj B Srivastava JP Atul B Morbidity Status
and Its Social Determinants among Elderly Population of Lucknow District India
Sch J App Med Sci 2013 1(6)758-64
51 Shraddha K Prashantha B Prakash B Study on morbidity pattern among elderly in
urban population of Mysore Karnataka India International Journal of Medicine and
Biomedical Research 2012 1(3)215-23
52 Thomas V Lavanya KM Morbidity profile and health seeking behaviour of the
elderly in urban slums of Hyderabad Andhra Pradesh India- A cross sectional study
International Journal of Current Research and Review 2012 Oct 1 4(19)174-80
53 Moe S Tha K Naing DK Htike MM Health seeking behaviour of elderly in
Myanmar International Journal of Collaborative Research on Internal Medicine and
Public Health 2012 4(8)1538-44
93
References
54 Bharati DR Pal R Rekha R Yamuna TV Kar S Radjou AN Ageing in
Puducherry South India An overview of morbidity profile Journal of pharmacy amp
bio allied sciences 2011 Oct 3(4)537
55 Bhatt R Gadhvi MS Sonaliya KN Solanki A Nayak H An epidemiological study
of the morbidity pattern among the elderly population in Ahmedabad Gujarat
National Journal of community medicine 2011 Jul 2(2)233-36
56 Srinivasan Krishnamachari Vaz Mario Thomas Tinku Prevalence of health related
disability among community dwelling urban elderly from middle socioeconomic
strata in Bangaluru India Indian Journal of Medical Research 2010 Apr 131(4)
515-21
57 Srivastava K Gupta SC Kaushal SK Chaturvedi M Morbidity profile of elderly a
cross sectional study of urban Agra Indian Journal of Community Health 2010 Jun
22(1)51-55
58 Ladha A Khan R Malik A Khan S Khan B Khan I et al The health seeking
behaviour of elderly population in a poor-urban community of Karachi Pakistan
Journal of the Pakistan Medical Association2009 Feb 59(2) 89-92
59 WHO ICD-10 version 2010 Geneva World Health Organization Available from
URL appswhointclassificationsicd10browse2010en [Accessed on 772017]
60 OpenEpi22OpenEpi (free) download Windows version Available from URL
enfreedownloadmanagerorgWindows-PCOpenEpi-FREEhtml
61 Tandon R Sinhota Parsonrsquos disease of the eye 22edNew Delhi Elsevier 98-100
62 Dhingra P L Dhingra S Disease of ear nose and throat and head and neck surgery
6th ed New Delhi Elsevier 201422
94
References
63 Aziz N Kallur SD Nirmalan PK Implications of the revised consensus body mass
indices for Asian Indians on clinical obstetric practice Journal of clinical and
diagnostic research 2014 May 8(5)OC01
64 Chobanion AV Bakris GL Black HR The seventh report of the joint national
committee on prevention detection evaluation and treatment of high blood pressure
the JNC 7 report JAMA 2003 2892560-72
65 The Seventh Report of the Joint National Committee on Prevention Detection
Evaluation and Treatment of High Blood Pressure (JNC 7) The GuidelinesUS
Department of Health and Human Services National Heart Lung and Blood
Institute Available at URL
httpswwwnhlbinihgovfilesdocsguidelinesjnc7fullpdf [ Accessed on
1282017]
66 Firkin F Chestman C Penington D Rush B De Gruchyrsquos clinical Hematology in
medical practice 5th edition New Delhi Blackwell science Ltd1989 32-47
67 Report of WHO consultation Nutritional Anaemias Geneva Switzerland World
Health Organization TRS-405 1968 Available from URL
whqlibdocwhointtrsWHO_TRS_405pdf [Accessed on 1282017]
68 National Family Health survey (NFHS-4) 2015-16 India Mumbai IIPS
2016Available from URL httpwwwnfhsindiaorg [Accessed on 4072017]
69 The Minimum Wages Act 1948 Ministry of Labour and Employment Government
of India Available from URL httplabourgovincontentinnerpagewagesphp
[Accessed on 1082017]
70 Khairnar M Wadgave U Shimpi P Updated BG Prasad socioeconomic
classification for 2016 Journal of Indian Association of Public Health Dentistry
2016 Oct 1 14(4)469
95
References
71 Tiwari P Tiwari S Mastering practicals community medicine 1st ed New Delhi
India Wolters Kluwer PvtLtd2013161-67
72 Boralingaiah P Bettappa P Kashyap S Prevalence of Psycho-Social Problems
among Elderly in Urban Population of Mysore City Karnataka India Indian journal
of psychological medicine 2012 Oct 34(4)360
96
PATIENT CONSENT FORM JJM MEDICAL COLLEGE DAVANGERE
DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY MEDICINE I the undersigned hereby give my consent
for investigations carried upon me I am satisfied with the information given about this
Clinical study titled ldquoA STUDY ON THE MORBIDITY PATTERN AND HEALTH
SEEKING BEHAVIOR AMONG THE GERIATRIC POULATION IN THE
URBAN FIELD PRACTICE AREA OF JJM MEDICAL COLLEGE
DAVANGERErdquo ldquoconducted by Dr RUCHI DHAR under the guidance of Dr VIDYA
GS Associate Professor I have been informed and explained the risks involved and I
hereby voluntarily and Unconditionally give my consent without any fear or pressure in
mentally sound and conscious state to participate in this study
DATE PATIENTrsquoS SIGNATURE
eEacuteeEacuteJA ordfEacuteEcirczAgravearingQAtildeAiAgraveAuml ordfAgraveAumlordmAacutelaquozAacutearingregAiAgraveAuml zAacuteordfAgravetUEacutegEacute
ryenAacutemiumlethordfEacuteAumlAmiumlDyensiumlPAgraveordfAgraveAumlAumlaringcurrenn ordfEacuteAumlrsup1poundiuml
ordfEacuteEcirczAgravearingQAtildeAiAgraveAumlvAgraveyenAacutecedilAgraveuEacuteUEacuteMbrvbaragraveUEacute yenAgravevAgraveaelig F PEacutefrac14AgraveUEacute cedilAgraveraquo ordfAgraveiAacutergAgraveAumlordfAgrave poundAacutepoundAgraveAuml CAzAgravegEacute
poundAgravepoundAgraveszlig
ordfEacuteEcirczAgravearingQAtildeAiAgraveAumlvAgraveyenAacutecedilAgraveuEacute ordmAacuteUAgraveAElig plusmnAgravecedilAgraveUcircccedilaQvEacuteigraveUEacuteAzAgraveAuml poundAgravepoundAgraveszligMbrvbaragraveUEacuteAiAgraveAumlpoundAgraveAumlszlig
cedilAgraveAEligasup1gAgraveAumlvEacuteUcircAtildepoundEacute J cedilAgraveOumlr Dyensiuml zAgrave ordfEacuteAEligcopyethrn yenAacutearinglpoundiumleth CAqiuml ordmEacutemacriumlUcirc sup1AtildeQAUiuml copyordmEacuteAtildelaquoAiAgraveAumlgiuml Dyensiuml zAgrave fjAiAgraveiAacutenaeligPiuml yenEacuteAEligAtildeyenAgraveAumlaringmacrEacuteAtildemicroAgravepoundiuml Epoundiuml zAgrave Csectethpoundiuml brvbarAtildemacriumlOslash yenAacuteaeligoumlaringQOumlAtildecediliuml JjAiAgraveAuml Dyensiuml ddordfAgraveAumlAuml ordfEacuteEcirczAgravearingQAtildeAiAgraveAuml ordfAgraveAumlordmAacutelaquozAacutearingregAiAgraveAuml zAacuteordfAgravetUEacutegEacute JAsect sup2AtildeparaethPEacuteAiAgraveAumlrAiAgraveAumldegegrave yenAgravejAtildePEacuteeumlUEacute Mfrac14AgraveyenAgravercedilAgraveAumlordfAgrave ordfEacuteEcirczAgravearinggAacutezAgrave qAacute|| gAgraveAumla zAgravesAgravegAgrave ordfAgraveAumlvAgraveAumlUcirc qAacute|| laquozAacutearing fJcediliumlordfAgraveiAacuteUAgraveethzAgraveplusmnAgraveethPAgravegAacutezAgrave yenEacuteAEligaeligAtildeyensEacutecedilAgravegiuml
EordfAgravegAgraveAuml poundAgravepoundAgraveUEacute F vAgraveyenAacutecedilAgraveuEacuteUEacute Mfrac14AgraveyenAgraveqAgraveAumlordfAgrave ordfAgraveAumlAumlpoundAgraveszlig yenAgraveaeligwAiEacuteAEligAzAgraveAuml
CAplusmnAgraveUAgravefrac14AgravepoundAgraveAumlszlig CxAgraveethordfAacuteUAgraveAumlordfAgraveAvEacute wfrac12sup1gAgraveAumlvAacuteUcircgEacuteDzAgraveYacutejAzAgrave poundAacutepoundAgraveAuml poundAgravepoundAgraveszlig
ordfAgraveAumlpoundAgravecedilAacutegEacute AiAgraveiAacuteordfAgraveAringzEacuteAtilde umlsAgraveAiAgraveAuml ordfAgraveAumlvAgraveAumlUcirc AiAgraveiAacutegAgrave MvAacuteUcircAiAgraveAumllaquoregegravezEacute poundAacutepoundAgraveAuml
vAgraveyenAacutecedilAgraveuEacute aQvEacuteigraveUEacuteAEligfrac14AgraveyenAgraveqAgraveregAuml MbrvbaragraveUEacuteAiAgraveAumlpoundAgraveAumlszlig cedilAgraveAEligasup1gAgraveAumlvEacuteUcircAtildepoundEacute
centpoundAacuteAPAgrave gEacuteAEligAtildeVAi
Annexures
ANNEXURE ndashIII
104
Annexures
PROFORMA
I General information
1 NAME
2 AGE
3 GENDER (a) Male (b) Female
4 MARITAL STATUS (a) Unmarried (b) Married (c) Widow Widower
(d) Divorced separated
5 LIVING ARRANGEMENT (a) with spouse (b) Spouse and children
(c) Children only (d) living alone (e) others
6 RELIGION (a) Hindu (b) Muslim (c) Christian (d) Others
7 ADDRESS
8 EDUCATION (a) illiterate (b) Primary school (c) higher primary
(d) secondary school (e)PUC diploma (e) Graduate (f) Postgraduate
9 OCCUPATION (a) professional (b) semi- professional (c) skilled worker
(d) Semi ndashskilled worker (e) unskilled worker (f) unemployed
10 CONTACT NUMBER
11 TYPE OF FAMILY (a) Joint (b) Nuclear (C) three generation
12 TOTAL NUMBER OF FAMILY MEMBERS
13 TOTAL FAMILY INCOME
14 PER CAPITA FAMILY INCOME
15 SOCIO ECONOMIC STATUS (Modified BG Prasad classification) I IIIIIIVV
16 DIET (a) Vegetarian (b) Mixed
17 Sleep (a) Disturbed if yes reason ______________ (b) Not disturbed
18 Bowel Regular Irregular
19 Bladder Regular Irregular
97
Annexures
20 HABITS (a) betel nut (b) tobacco (c) alcohol (d) smoking (e) others
If any of the habits present Duration (since when) _________
Frequency of consumption day_______
IIAssessment of morbidity based on history
1 Whether suffering from any chronic illness like (a) Type 2 DM (b) Hypertension
(c) Bronchial Asthma (d) TB (e) others
2 Whether suffering from cataract currently (a) Yes (b) No
3 Whether operated for cataract (a) Yes (b) No If Yes duration since operation____
4 MUSCULOSKELETAL SYSTEM
Whether the following symptoms are present
(a) Backache (b) Joint pain (c) restricted joint movements (d) pain in calves
(e) Others_________
5 RESPIRATORY SYSTEM
(a) Productive cough (b) non-productive cough (c) nasal discharge (d) breathlessness (e)
sore throat (f) sneezing
6 CARDIOVASCULAR SYSTEM
(a) Palpitations (b) chest pain (c) breathlessness
7 GASTROINTESTINAL SYSTEM
(a) Pain abdomen (b) lose stools (c) constipation (d) flatulence (e) heart burn
(f) Bleeding per rectum
8 EYE AND ADNEXA
(a) Watering (b) diminution of vision (c) redness
9 EAR
(a) Discharge (b) decreased hearing (c) Tinnitus
10 SKIN
(a) Itching (b) skin eruptions (c) scaling (d) pigmentation
98
Annexures
11 GENITO URINARY SYSTEM
(a) Burning micturition (b) increased frequency of micturition
12 GENERAL SYMPTOMS
(a) Fatigue (b) headache (c) fever
13 ANY OTHER COMPLAINTS (a) burning feet (b) swelling in groin
(c) Memory loss (d) insomnia
III Assessment of health seeking behaviour
1 Do you visit a health facility in case of illness (a) Yes (b) No
If yes how much time do you take to visit a health facility an case of an illness
(a) Within 24 hours (b) 24-48 hours (c) more than 48 hours
2 Which type of health facility do you visit
(a) Govt hospital (b) Private practitioners (c) over the counter drugs (e) quacks
Mention the reason for visiting the particular health facility______________________
3 Whether taking regular treatment after diagnosis ________________
If No mention the reason_______________________
4 Whether following the instructions given by the treating doctor
(a) Yes (b) no
5 cost of treatment per month in case of chronic disease
(a) lt100 (b) 100-200 (c) 200-300 (d) 300 and above
6 Person bearing the cost of treatment
(a) Self (b) spouse (c) son (d) daughter (d) outside help
7 Duration to reach the health facility
(a) less than 3o minutes (b) 30 minutes or more
8 Whether going for regular check -ups (a) Yes (b) No
If Yes duration between the check-ups_______
99
Annexures
9 Whether following self- care practices in case of chronic disease like diabetes and hypertension
(a) Yes (b) No
10 In case of healthy individuals whether getting screening tests done (a) Yes (b) No
11 Whether following any dietary modifications (a) yes (b) No
12 Whether any family member accompanies you to the health facility
If yes who (a) Son (b) daughter (c) spouse (d) others
11 Whether the family supports in following specific diet advised by the doctor
(a) Yes (b) No
12 whether family members help in reminding to take regular medication
(a) Yes (b) No
IV Physical examination
1 Personal hygiene status
S NO COMPONENT CONDITION REMARKS
1 Hair
2 Teeth
3 Bath
4 Clothes
5 Washing hand before
eating food
6 Washing hands with soap
and water after ablution
7 Nails
8 Foot wear
Remarks personal hygiene status Good fair poor
100
Annexures
2 MEASUREMENTS
(a) Weight (in Kg) ______ (b) Height (in cm) _____ (c) BMI ______
(d) Waist circumference______ (e) Hip circumference ___________
(f) Waist hip ratio_________
3 GENERAL PHYSICAL EXAMINATION
Pallor Icterus Cyanosis clubbing lymphadenopathy Oedema
Pulse rate Temp Blood Pressure
Respiratory rate
20 Examination of
Eye Oral cavity Ear
Nose Throat
SYSTEMIC EXAMINATION
Cardiovascular system Respiratory system
Per abdomen Central Nervous system
101
MASTER CHART
Annexures
ANNEXURES
International Classification of Diseases (10th Revision)
I Certain infectious and parasitic diseases (A00-B99)
II Neoplasms (C00-D48)
III Diseases of blood and blood forming organs and certain disorders
involving the immune mechanisms (D50-D89)
IV Endocrine nutritional and metabolic diseases (E00-E90)
V Mental and behavioural disorders (F00-F99)
VI Diseases of the nervous system (G00-G99)
VII Diseases of the eye and adnexa (H00-H59)
VIII Diseases of the ear and mastoid process ( H60-H95)
IX Diseases of the circulatory system (I00-I99)
X Diseases of the respiratory system ( J00-J99)
XI Diseases of the digestive system (K00-K93)
XII Diseases of the skin and subcutaneous tissue ( L00-L99)
XIII Diseases of the musculoskeletal system and connective tissue
(M00-M99)
XIV Diseases of the genitourinary system ( N00-N99)
XV Pregnancy childbirth and purperium (O00-O99)
XVI Certain conditions originating in perinatal period (P00-P96)
XVII Congenital malformations deformations and chromosomal
XVIII (S00-T98)
XIX External causes of morbidity and mortality (V01-Y98)
102
Annexures
XX Injury poisoning and certain other consequences of external causes
(S00-T98)
XXI Factors influencing health status and contact with health services
(Z00-Z99)
XXII Codes for special purpose
103
Annexures
105
Annexures
106
Annexures
107
Annexures
PHOTOS
Picture 1 Showing the investigator interviewing the study subject
Picture 2 Showing the investigator interacting with the study subject
108
Annexures
Picture 3 Showing the investigator recording the Blood pressure of the study subject
Picture 4 Showing the investigator auscultating the study subject
109
Annexures
110
Introduction enlarged prostate depression and cataract related blindness In the coming years there will
be a phenomenal growth in the population of the elderly while the family size will reduce
The disintegration of the joint family and women moving out of the household has led to the
absence of traditional caregivers for the elderly who are already a vulnerable group4
The most common cause of health problems in the old aged people is chronic diseases
Most of these problems can be prevented or delayed by engaging in healthy behaviours
Even in the advanced years of life physical activity and good nutrition can have
effective benefits on health and well-being Many health problems of old age can be
effectively managed if they are detected early enough5 The National Policy for Older
Persons was announced by the Government of India in the year 1999 The Constitution of
India under Article 41 mandates the well-being of senior citizens ldquoThe state shall
within the limits of its economic capacity and development make effective provision
for securing the right to public assistance in case of old aged peoplerdquo 6
National Council for Older Persons (NCOP) has been reconstituted and renamed as
National Council for Senior Citizens (NCSrC) in order to have a definite structure and also
regional balancing the NCOP advises the Central and State Governments on a broad range
of issues related to welfare of senior citizens and enhancement of their quality of life The
NCSrc meets at least twice a year7 The elderly suffer from multiple medical as well as
psychological problems There has already been some pioneering work on the elderly in
India but a lot more remains to be done There is an urgent need to pay attention
towards the medical and socio-economic problems that are being faced by the elderly
people in India and thus formulate strategies to bring about an improvement in their
quality of life8 The Health seeking behaviour is influenced by various factors which
include the individual self diseases and the availability and accessibility of health
2
services It is important to have knowledge regarding the health seeking behaviour of
individuals for designing health care policies and programmes so that all the possible
difficulties with early diagnosis and effective treatment can be identified and appropriate
interventions can be implemented9 As already stated the elderly are a vulnerable group as
there are psychological as well as physiological changes with increasing age and it is
difficult to cope up with the problems of ageing Some of the most common problems in old
age are cardiovascular problems arthritis respiratory problems blood pressure and so on
Therefore the study of the health status of elderly morbid conditions perceptions about
it is important to note and the health care of the elderly becomes very important since they
are more prone to illness than young people and are also more prone to domestic and other
accidents Their health and treatment seeking behaviour are most important for the
formulation of welfare programmes of the country 10
Hence this study was taken up in the urban field practice area of JJM Medical College
Davangere to assess the morbidity pattern and health seeking behaviour of the geriatric
subjects
3
Objectives
OBJECTIVES
1 To study the morbidity pattern among the geriatric population in the urban field
practice area of JJM Medical college Davangere
2 To assess the health seeking behaviour of the elderly residing in the study area
4
Review of literature
vii
REVIEW OF LITERATURE
1 Definition Geriatrics or clinical gerontology Is the term used for the care of the aged 11 The United Nations uses 60 years and above to refer to older people the same is also used
by demographers However in many developed countries the age of 65 is used as the
reference point for older persons 12
Elderly are classified in to 3 groups 13
Young old Persons in the age group of 60 years to 74 years
Old old Persons in the age group of 75 years to 84 years
Oldest old Persons above the age of 85 yrs
2 Demography of the ageing population in India
The UN defines a country as ldquoAgeingrdquo or ldquoGreying Nationrdquo where the
proportion of people over 60 reaches 7 percent to total population By 2011 India has
exceeded that proportion (80 percent) and is expected to reach 126 percent in 2025
The Indian population has increased from 361 million in 1951 to 1027 billion in 2001
and further to 121 billion in 2011 Simultaneously the number of older people has
increased from 19 million (ie 4 percent of total population) to 77 million and
further to roughly 93 million (ie 75 percent of the total) during the same time
span 14
5
Review of literature
Figure1 proportion of elderly in the Indian population by age groups 1961-2001 14
Table 1 Percentage share of elderly population (aged 60 years and above) in total
population by sex in India 15
Years Male Female Total Rural Urban
1961 55 58 56 58 47
1971 59 60 60 62 50
1981 64 66 65 68 54
1991 67 68 68 71 57
2001 71 78 75 77 67
2011 77 84 80 81 79
2004-05 69 75 72 73 70
2007-08 73 77 75 76 72
6
Review of literature
The rise in population of males was more modest from 55 percent to 71 percent while for
females there had been a steep rise from 58 percent to 78 percent during five decadal
Censuses from 1961 to 2001 In 2011 the elderly population accounted for 80 percent of
total population For males it was marginally lower at 77 percent while for females it was
84 percent According to NSSO surveys the proportion of elderly population in rural areas
was 73 percent during 2004-05 and increased up to 76 percent in 2007-08 While on the
other hand in urban areas the proportion of elderly population rose from 70 percent to 72
percent during the corresponding period It has been observed that the percentage share of
elderly to total population remained higher in rural areas than in urban areas15
Table2 Size of elderly population (aged 60+) and their share in total population in major states of India in 201115
All India and selected major states
Proportion of elderly in total population of State
Male Female Total Andhra Pradesh 83 94 88 Bihar 72 67 70 Gujarat 76 90 83 Haryana 66 76 71 Himachal Pradesh 104 103 104 Karnataka 79 89 84 Kerala 118 133 126 Madhya Pradesh 68 74 71 Maharashtra 88 97 93 Orissa 91 95 93 Punjab 91 100 95 Rajasthan 66 79 72 Tamil Nadu 102 109 105 Uttar Pradesh 66 71 68 West Bengal 82 82 82 All India 77 84 80
7
Review of literature
3 MORBIDITY PATTERN AMONG THE ELDERLY
Physiological Decline and Consequences of increasing age
Ageing i s a process of decline in biological functions affecting most physical
Systems The following systems are affected by ageing
(a) Atrophy of the Taste Buds and Loss of Teeth
With the increasing age the taste buds of the tongue get atrophied and as a result the
preference for food alters significantly There is also a considerable loss of teeth causing
difficulties in chewing food
(b) Changes in the Gastrointestinal Tract
As the age advances the walls of the intestine get atrophied and the motility is
markedly reduced (lazy intestine) The digestive enzymes secreted by the intestine are
also reduced Hence the partly digested food stays in the intestine for a longer period
As a result the common complaint of the elderly person is gas formation (flatulence)
and constipation
(c) Respiratory System
As the age advance there is progressive fibrosis of the lungs leading to reduced
oxygenation of the lungs and breathing difficulties
(d) Kidney and genitourinary System
The kidneys get smaller in size and the power of the kidneys to filter out the unwanted
waste products from the body is diminished The total amount of urine becomes less in
old age and thus the waste products are not adequately excreted from the body
8
Review of literature
(e) Urinary Bladder
Urinary bladder gets smaller in size due to shrinkage and as a result the accumulation
of urine even of a small amount leads to an urge for urination With increase in age
the valve in the bladder which controls the exit of urine from the bladder to urethra
gets atrophied and weak Involuntary leakage of urine occurs in case the bladder is full
or due to increase of pressure on bladder on sneezing or even on laughing a condition
known as urinary incontinence Incontinence is a common complaint of elder females
(f) Heart and Circulatory System
The blood vessels get rigid and quite often the vessel walls become rough with the
deposition of solid matters consisting mostly of cholesterol The heart muscles get weaker
and power to send blood throughout the body through the circulatory system gets less and
less powerful The most dangerous effect on heart is coronary heart disease especially
coronary thrombosis
(g) Muscular system
The muscles in the body get gradually atrophied with ageing and especially those
small muscles which are necessary for quick reflex action The elderly person can quite
be capable of working like a normal person and can undertake activities which require
big muscles of legs and arms But when it comes to quick movement which needs small
muscles for quick reflex movements these functions are impaired causing accidents
like slipping on wet floor of the bathroom
(h) Brain
With ageing the size of the brain gets smaller and the weight also becomes less This
however does not interfere with the function of the brain However in general the brain
cells and its fibers which carry impulses from brain to the system and upwards get
9
Review of literature
degenerated The most glaring manifestation of ageing affecting the brain is
forgetfulness and in simple terms it is inability of brain to recall the past experience
However this is common in all elderly persons
(i ) Bones
The bones become porous and fragile as age advances especially in elderly females This
condition is known as osteoporosis and leads to sustaining of fractures even after a minor
fall16
Figure 2 pathophysiology of health issues in geriatrics17
The common disease that the geriatric population suffers from are type 2 diabetes
coronary heart disease hypertension stroke chronic obstructive pulmonary disease
10
Review of literature
Alzheimerrsquos disease osteoarthritis osteoporosis prostatic hypertrophy cataracts macular
degeneration cancer etc and at the same time they are vulnerable to infections involving
respiratory (including TB) urinary and digestive tract17
In India the elderly people suffer from dual medical problems ie communicable and
nonndash communicable diseases There is also impairment of special sensory functions like
vision and hearing A decline in immunity and age-related physiological changes leads to
an increased burden of communicable diseases in the elderly A report by Indian Council
of Medical Research (ICMR) on the chronic morbidity profile in the elderly states that
hearing impairment is the most common morbidity followed by visual impairment
However different studies show varied results in the morbidity pattern18
Major chronic conditions affecting older people worldwide 19
Cardiovascular diseases (such as coronary heart disease) Diabetes Mellitus
Hypertension Stroke Cancer
Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease
Musculoskeletal conditions (such as arthritis and osteoporosis)
Mental health conditions (mostly dementia and depression)
Blindness and visual impairment
11
Review of literature
Health seeking behaviour
1 Definition
There is no common definition agreed upon by sociologists in any sociology literature
Different definitions may be used in different studies despite referring to the same activity
Sociology and literature assume that health seeking behaviour is influenced by the various
factors which include individual self or the individual diseases present and also the
availability and accessibility of health services Being dependent on these determinants and
their interactions it can be said that health care seeking behaviour is a very complex
outcome of various factors which operate at individual family and community level20
Health Seeking Behavior (HSB) refers to decision or an action taken by an individual to
maintain attain or regain good health and to prevent illness The decisions which are
made encompasses all available health care options like visiting a public or private and
modern or traditional health facility self-medication and use of home remedies or not to
utilize the available health services etc
Determining the health care seeking behavior is very important to provide a need
based health care services to the population Visiting official channels in a formally
recognized health care system has been considered as the desired Health seeking behaviour
Health seeking behavior is influenced by multiple factors including availability quality and
price of services and also social groups health views residences and personal features of the
users Peoplersquos choice of health care differs in socio demographic socio-economic and
cultural compositions and this has an effect on their health seeking behavior Urban dwellers
are generally believed to be open to new ideas and willing to try certain things on a trial and
error basis21
12
Review of literature
Health seeking behaviours two approaches
(a) Health seeking behaviours utilization of the system
This approach focuses on the actions which are taken to rectify perceived ill health and
the type of health care facility which is utilized by the people There is data which
suggests that the people visit more traditional healers and unofficial medical channels
this should be prevented and the emphasis s h o u l d b e on encouraging people to opt
first for the official channels
(b) Health seeking behaviours the process of illness response
This approach considers the factors which enable or prevent people from making
healthy choices either i n their lifestyle behaviours or use of medical care and
treatment22
Figure 3 Predicting health behaviour with social cognition models 22
13
Review of literature
2 Health belief Model of health seeking behaviour
Since lsquoHealth seekingrsquo is a conditioned behaviour any attempt which is made to
encourage people to seek health care definitely requires an understanding of their
motivation for such behaviour Only through a deeper understanding of the intricate
factors shaping behavioural practices can health promotion programmes and or
interventions successfully be introduced into the realities of the peoplersquos lives to bring
about changes in health behaviour
Behaviour change theories and models such as the Health Belief Model (HBM)
Theory of Reasoned Action (TRA) Theory of Planned Behaviour (TPB) and the
Trans theoretical model have been widely applied in public health in an attempt to
explain or predict health seeking behaviours Their use enables identification and
understanding of peoplersquos health-seeking behaviour beyond their knowledge attitudes
and practices
HBM is a health specific behavioural cognitive model This model is based on the
idea that people are more likely to change their behaviour and adhere to treatments
if they have the following perceptions (i) have a perception that they are at risk of
contracting the disease (perceived susceptibility) (ii) perception that the disease
might have an unfavorable outcome (perceived severity) (iii) perceive that the
proposed health behaviour to be both effective and practical (perceived benefits)
(iv) perceive the barriers to adopting the behaviour to be minimal (perceived
barriers)(v) perceive themselves to have the ability of applying and practicing the
specific behaviour proposed (perceived self-efficacy) and (vi) they have the cues
for motivating their actions such as internal cues (pain symptoms past experiences)
or external cues (advice from friends relatives and mass media campaigns) (cues to
14
Review of literature
action) The specificity of the HBM to health has made it suitable for use in
understanding and explaining the behaviour as well as health outcomes and this may also
explain its wider use in public health2 3
Figure 4 Health belief model components and linkages 23
3 Factors influencing health seeking behaviour
The factors affecting the health seeking behaviours are seen in various contexts which
include physical socio-economic cultural and political factors Therefore the utilization of
a health care system whether public or private formal or non- formal may depend on socio-
demographic factors social structures level of education cultural beliefs and practices and
some other factors like gender discrimination status of women economic and political
systems environmental conditions and the disease pattern and health care system itself also
have an impact on the health seeking behaviour24
15
Review of literature
REVIEW OF RELATED STUDIES
A study done by Sanjay Polisetty and Madhavi Seepana (2017) on the morbidity profile
of elderly individuals in urban Visakhapatnam revealed that of the 270 study participants
about 996 suffered from either some form of acute or chronic morbidity More than 70
of individuals suffered from eye problems of which most common problem was cataract
seen in 60 About 304 had difficulties in chewing and 256 had difficulty in hearing
Hypertension was present in 49 of individuals and 742 of Diabetics were also found to
be hypertensive25
A study done by Swapnil Jain et al (2016) on Morbidity pattern among geriatric
population in urban field practice area of a district in Maharashtra revealed 653 suffered
from hearing impairment 62 were anemic 462 had hypertension 423 had joint
pain 41 had dental problems 38 7 had cataract and 318 had chronic bronchitis It
was seen that 81 of the subjects had multiple morbidities 26
A study done by Rajat Das Gupta et al (2016) in an urban area of Bangladesh on Morbidity
pattern and health-seeking behavior among the senior citizens revealed that of the 384 study
participants 968 were suffering from at least one medical problem The commonest was
musculoskeletal problems in 8411 followed by eye problems in 8125 It was found that
all the respondents sought treatment for their health problems 33 respondents went to
Government hospitals to seek medical help 6927 respondents took prescribed
medications and 567 were satisfied with their treatment 27
16
Review of literature
A study done by Md Alam Naushad et al (2016) on Morbidity pattern and health
seeking behavior in elderly population of Raipur City Chhattisgarh revealed that the
prevalence of morbidity among elderly was 9531 Out of total morbid population some
chronic illness was present in 7049 Gastro intestinal system was involved in 8262
followed by eye in 7983 and Cardiovascular system in 5245 It was found that 3552
of the subjects sought treatment from private registered practitioners 28
A study done by Sribas Goswami and Manjari Sahai (2016) in Raipur city on Morbidity
Pattern in elderly Population revealed that out of total study population of 640 elderly
subjects 610 (9531) suffered from some morbidity Prevalence among females was
9892 whereas among males it was 9026 Out of various agencies 3552 subjects
were utilizing private facility followed by 2785 who were utilizing Government agency
2631 visited quacks and 1030 were taking treatment from other source 29
A study done by Harsh Bardhan et al (2016) on the Morbidity profile of elderly population
in Ghaziabad district revealed that in geriatric population 5008 suffered from
musculoskeletal problems 5877 had dental problems and impairment of vision was seen
in 5561 The overall prevalence of diabetes and heart disease were 10 and 122
respectively 236 subjects reported the problem of loneliness and depression
forgetfulness was also reported by 3296 As far as treatment seeking behavior is
concerned approach of elderly is quite different for different morbidities The main source
of treatment for morbidities such as hypertension respiratory urinary GIT-related and
musculoskeletal problems was quacks 30
17
Review of literature
A study done by Mohammad Maharoof et al (2016) on the health problems among
the aged in Urban Aligarh UP revealed that of the 225 study subjects 782 had cataract
followed by depression in 356 refractive error in 276 loco-motor problem in 213
and hearing loss in 138 The prevalence of hearing loss was significantly related to gender
as it was higher among females with 181 compared to males in whom it was 6931
A study done by Gowri Shankar and Bhayalaxmi Sidenur (2016) on morbidity of
elderly residing in an urban area of Bagalkot revealed that the most common morbidity was
Cataract seen in 2875 followed by musculoskeletal problems in 2813 and 2313
were known hypertensive Both diabetes mellitus and hypertension was observed in 10 of
the study subjects32
A study done by Leena Rahul Salunkhe (2015) on socio-demographic profile of old
age people living in urban amp urban slum areas in Maharashtra Karad revealed that 504
and 42 elderly suffered from arthritis in an urban area and a slum respectively Number of
diabetics were higher in urban (14) than urban slum (35) 301 of subjects from urban
area suffered from hypertension compared to 161 from urban slums Upper Respiratory
Infections was more in slum dwellers (196) than people residing in urban area (7) Acid
peptic diseases were found in 168 study subjects in urban area and 154 in slum area 33
In a study done by Warbhe Priyanka A and Warbhe Rupesh (2015) on morbidity
profile health seeking behaviour and home environment survey of the elderly in an urban
slum community it was found that 941 had 1-3 morbidities 41 had 4-6 morbidities
373 gave a history of fall and 314 had history of fracture 136 subjects had been
18
Review of literature
operated for cataract 168 had undergone a procedure for fracture and10 had undergone
a dental procedure 542 went to Urban health center (UHC) and Government hospitals for
treatment and 786 received both allopathic and Ayurvedic treatment34
A study done by Man Mohan Gupta et al (2015) on Assessment of Clinico-
socioeconomic status and health-care support among the elderly people aged older than 60
years in urban population of Bhopal revealed that 353 subjects received treatment for
their morbidities from the Government hospitals whereas 267 from private
clinichospital About 653 study subjects presented with complaints and morbidity The
common morbidities which were found in the subjects were fatigue (487) backache
(353) Obesity (393) and hypertension (247)35
In a study done by Shilpa Shaukaiah et al (2015) on prevalence of morbidity pattern
among geriatric age group in an urban slum of Mumbai it was found that body ache was the
most commonly reported symptom by 290 followed by visual problems in 2318 joint
pain in 2181 indigestion in 2045 and backache in 2045 subjects36
A study done by Shubha Davalagi B et al (2015) on morbidity psycho-social profile and
health seeking behavior of the elderly population in urban slums of Davangere City revealed
that the most common morbidity which was present in the study subjects was
musculoskeletal problems in 46 psychosocial problems were present in 31 and
respiratory problems in 23 Majority of the elderly (56) utilized government
institutions for treatment of chronic disease and 47 for treatment of acute disease The
elderly population had financial constraints and lack of accessibility in seeking health care37
19
Review of literature
A study done by Vandana Nikumb et al ( 2015) on morbidity Profile among Geriatric
Population in an Urban Area of Navi Mumbai revealed that 9312 elderly were morbid and
with increasing age the number of morbidities was found to be increasing In this study it
was found that the most common morbidity was psychosocial problems which include
stress which was present in 594 subjects followed by musculoskeletal problems in
556 and eye problems like diminished vision mostly due to cataract in 463
Hypertension dental problems respiratory problems ENT problems (hearing impairment)
and endocrine disorders like diabetes accounted for 281 219 119 106 and10
respectively38
A study done by Vishnoi BR et al (2015) on Morbidity Profile of Elderly in Urban
Slum of Udaipur Rajasthan revealed that 61 of the study subjects had impaired vision
followed by 25 who had hypertension 1533 suffered from insomnia 1467 had
anemia and 14 suffered from gastrointestinal problems The condition of females was
worse compared to males39
In a study done by L Subedhi and RB Sah (2015) on the health status of geriatric age
group in Chitwan district of Nepal it was found that of the 300 study subjects 44 had
Ophthalmic problems 43 had GIT problems 33 had CVS problems 23 had ENT
problems 1567 had metabolic disorders and 533 had mental disorders The study
highlighted a high prevalence of morbidity and health related problems in the geriatric age
group40
20
Review of literature
A study done by Sofia Noor et al (2015) on health status of geriatric population in slums
of Rourkela revealed that the morbidities among the elderly that were found to be significant
were hypertension decreased visual acuity urinary problems and insomnia Apart from
systemic morbidities 91 of the elderly also complained of fragility which includes
complex physiological deterioration and unexplained weight loss41
In a study conducted by VM Sarode (2014) on Chronic Diseases Related to Ageing and
Disease Prevention in Slums in Mumbai it was found that there were highly significant
disorders among aged women related to Skin lesion and super infection Untreated bacterial
pharyngitis acute rheumatic fever while disorders among aged men were related to
hypertension Illicit drug use diabetes and asthma It was found that 49 of elderly males
and 45 of elderly females had not sought any treatment for their illness Of the people who
had sought treatment 93 elderly males and 92 of elderly females had taken treatment
from Government hospital42
A study conducted by Sanjeev Kumar Barman et al (2014) on morbidity profile of
geriatric population in an urban slum of Kishnganj Bihar revealed that the prevalence of
anemia cataract and hypertension were quite high 6375 6125 and 5063
respectively Loss of income amp occupation along with a feeling of neglect from the family
members were the common problems among the elderly It was also found that morbidities
like arthritis loss of teeth amp dental caries along with depression had a significant association
with sex age amp educational status of the study subjects43
21
Review of literature
A study done by Khadervali Nagoor et al (2014) on the health status of elderly
population in an urban area of Kadapa revealed that out of the 200 elderly persons studied
Visual problem due to cataract and refractive errors were present in 72 of the study
subjects followed by pain in joints in 595 gastrointestinal problems in 46 and dental
problems in 44 Other morbidities were hypertension in 42 genitourinary problems in
25 dermatological problems in 235 and psychological problems in 1644
A study done by Kakkar R et al (2013) on morbidity profile among geriatric population
in District Dehradun revealed that the working geriatric group was healthy as compared to
those who were retired Hypertension was the commonest morbidity among all age groups
In the age group of 60-70 years the following morbidities were seen hypertension (306)
followed by diabetes (153) arthritis (14) CVS morbidities (14) cataract (96) and
BPH (83) Among 71-80 years age group Hypertension (287) followed by arthritis
(167) cataract (157) Diabetes (111) BPH (111) and CVS morbidities (93)45
In a study done by Bhawalkar JS et al (2013) on morbidity profile among geriatric
population in an urban area of Pune it was found that Musculoskeletal disorder was the
most common (4331) followed by eye problems (3722) and hypertension (137)It
was seen that 43 elderly population had some health problem but only 8 visited the
health facilities Among them 6 visited private practitioners and only 18 went to
municipal hospitals It was found that only 2322 elderly were taking any medications and
the most commonly used drug was anti-inflammatory drugs 2323 followed by
antihypertensive drugs 136746
22
Review of literature
A study conducted by Deepak Sharma et al (2013) on morbidity pattern and health-
seeking behavior of aged population residing in Shimla revealed that the following
morbidities were present in the study subjects hypertension was the commonest (56)
followed by Musculoskeletal problems (535) Dental problems (27) cataract (23)
anemia (15) and acid peptic disease (175) 658 of the subjects were seeking
treatment for their health problems Majority of the older people preferred allopathic
medicine (812) followed by Ayurvedic medicines (113) and homeopathic medicine
(73) for their health problems Most of the older persons preferred going to a
CHCGovernment hospital for treatment for their illness There was considerable use of
over-the-counter drug by125 of the people 47
A study done by JP Singh et al (2013) on Geriatric morbidity profile in an urban slum of
Nagpur central India revealed that the most common morbidity identified in the study
population was anemia (9650) followed by hypertension (345) arthritis (3225)
cataract (21) and diabetes (1775) More than 2 morbidities were present in 325 of
the study subjects followed by four morbidities in 3125 and two morbidities in 23548
A study conducted by RP Thakur et al (2013) on the health problems of the elderly in
central India revealed that among the elderly residing in the urban areas 384 of the urban
elderly had both dental problems and arthritis followed by anemia in 348 hypertension in
266 cataract in 252 and diabetes mellitus in 157 The prevalence of self-reported
depression was 672 among the urban female elderly when compared to 397 among the
urban females49
23
Review of literature
A study done by Mrinal Ranjan Srivastav et al (2013) on Morbidity Status and its
Social determinants among elderly population of Lucknow revealed that the most common
morbidity among the urban population was eye problems which affected 516 males and
67 females followed by CVS problems in 363 males and 395 females and GIT
problems in 315males and 382 females50
A study done by Shraddha K et al (2012) on morbidity pattern among elderly in urban
population of Mysore revealed that out of the 526 study subjects 486 suffered from the
disease of the eye and adnexa followed by 384 who suffered from endocrine and
metabolic disorders 331 suffered from the disease of the circulatory system 323 had
disease of the oral cavity and salivary glands and 302 had disease of the musculoskeletal
system 51
A study done by Vimala Thomas et al (2012) on morbidity profile and health seeking
behaviour of the elderly in urban slums of Hyderabad revealed that hypertension was the
most common morbidity in 469 followed by Arthritis in 302 Diabetes in 265
respiratory problems in 243 and Cataract in 21 For out-patient treatment 472 visited
private sectors 303 Government facility 25 RMP and 06 AYUSH clinics For in-
patient treatment 198 visited private institutions 16 visited Government institutions
while 642 did not visit either52
24
Review of literature
A study done by Soe Moe et al (2012) on health seeking behaviour of elderly in
Myanmar revealed that 35 of the male elderly perceived that they were having good
health status whereas 229 of them perceived having a poor health status 343 of female
elderly perceived that they were having good health status while 24 of them perceived
having a poor health About 49 of the elderly went to rural health center for treatment
followed by 33 who went to private practitioners 15 visited hospitals and 3 went to
more than one place for treatment53
A study done by Dharamvir Ranjan Bharati et al (2011) in Puducherry revealed that in
the urban areas about 707 of the study subjects had anemia followed by 537 who had
visual impairment and hypertension and 532 suffered from diabetes mellitus It was seen
that On univariate analysis the risk of diabetes mellitus was significantly higher among
elderly from urban areas than that among elderly from rural areas and significantly lower
risk in elderly from below poverty line than in those belonging to normal (not below poverty
line)54
A study done by Rajashree Bhat et al (2011) on the morbidity pattern among the elderly
population in Ahmedabad revealed that most common morbidity of elderly was the
problems of loco-motor system (486) followed by vision (427) and hypertension
(344) In this study only 37 of elderly had psychosocial problems55
A study done by Krishnamachari Srinivasan et al (2010) in an urban area of Bangalore
revealed that 494 subjects had hypertension 323 had diabetes 281 had arthritis
279 suffered from Genitourinary and cardiovascular disease It was observed that about
25
Review of literature
49 of the respondents made less than three physician visits and 13 were hospitalized for
health related problems during the past one year 56
A study done by Kajal Srivastava et al (2010) on the morbidity pattern of the elderly in
urban Agra revealed that 9529 of the elderly were morbid in the slum areas The most
common morbidity which was seen among the elderly people residing in urban slums was
anemia which was seen in 3843 followed by cataract in 298 arthritis in 2431 and
hearing impairments in 2157The system wise distribution of the morbidity pattern
showed the most common systemic involvement was visual disorders 5216 followed by
musculoskeletal system 4784 and the gastrointestinal system 4314 The number of
morbidities was found to be increasing with age and this association with age was
statistically significant57
A study done by Abdullah Ladha et al (2009) on the health seeking behaviour of elderly
population in a poor-urban community of Karachi Pakistan revealed that 164 of the
elderly people were Diabetic and 301 had Hypertension The Common symptoms that
prompted elderly of to seek health care were fever (612) generalized body aches (434)
and cough (404) About 614 responders reported factors which deterred them from
seeking health care out of which 62 reported financial constraint as the commonest factor
Deterrence from seeking health care was associated with illiteracy and living alone58
26
Methodology METHODOLOGY
The study was conducted in the urban field practice area of JJM Medical college
Davangere The city of Davangere is situated in the central part of Karnataka state
265 km north of the state capital Bengaluru along the national highway number 4
Figure 5 Maps showing the location of Davangere district and the area where the
UHTC is located
27
Methodology
Figure 6 Map showing the Urban field practice area of JJM medical college
28
Methodology
Table 3 List of areas covered under the UHTC of JJM Medical
College Davangere
Areas covered Total population Bethur road 1374 Hedge nagar 1213 Mehboob nagar 3042 Mustafa nagar A 2093 B D layout A 1084 Mustafa nagar B 1127 Mahavir nagar 930 Muddabovi colony 1094 Maganhalli 1221 Tippu nagar 968 B D layout B 1717 Batti layout 1080
STUDY AREA The study was conducted in the urban field practice area of JJM
Medical College Davangere which consists of 12 areas with a total population of
16943
STUDY DESIGN Cross sectional study
STUDY POPULATION Persons aged 60 years and above
Total Population Covered 16943
29
Methodology
INCLUSION CRITERIA subjects aged 60 years and above living in the study area
for more than one year duration
EXCLUSION CRITERIA Subjects who we r e no t w i l l i ng t o pa r t i c ipa t e i n
t he s t udy
STUDY PERIOD 1 year from 1st December 2015 to 30th November 2016
SAMPLE SIZE As quoted by Manmohan Gupta et al 35 in the studies done in various
parts of India the prevalence of morbidity in the geriatric population ranges from 31-80
Considering the prevalence of morbidity to be about 50 in the geriatric population at 95
confidence level and allowable error of 10 and a non -response rate of 10 sample size
was calculated to be 440 using the formula
n=4pq L2
n= sample size
4= factor to achieve 95 level of confidence
p= prevalence of morbidities ie 50
q= 100- p ie 100-50 = 50
L= permissible error in the estimate of ldquoprdquo (10 of p)
n = 4 x 50 x 50 = 400
5 x 5
After calculating a non-response rate of 10 a sample size of 440 was calculated
30
Methodology
A community based cross sectional study was conducted in the urban field practice
area of JJM Medical College Davangere The Urban field practice area has a total
population of 16943 and there are 12 areas in urban field practice area of JJM Medical
College Davangere
The Study was conducted by probability proportionate sampling The sample size for each
area was derived from the formula
1198991 =119875119900119901119906119897119886119905119894119900119899 119894119899 119890119886119888ℎ 119886119903119890119886
119879119900119905119886119897 119875119900119901119906119897119886119905119894119900119899119883 119878119886119898119901119897119890 119878119894119911119890
Example 1st area has a population of 1374 so
1198991 =1374
16943119883 440 = 36
Therefore 36 elderly subjects were selected by house to house visit from 1st area Same
procedure was applied for other areas until the desired sample size of 440 was reached
MATERIALS USED FOR DATA COLLECTION
The following tools were used for data collection
Semi-structured predesigned and pre-tested questionnaire
Portable bathroom weighing machine
Stretch- resistant measuring tape
Mercury Sphygmomanometer
Others - stethoscope torch tuning fork knee hammer
ICD-10 for system wise classification of disease59
31
Methodology METHOD OF COLLECTION OF DATA After establishing rapport with the family
and explaining the data collection procedure in the local language an informed verbal
consent was obtained from each individual and data was collected using a
Predesigned semi structured questionnaire by Interview method The questionnaire
comprised of the following information socio-demographic data of the study subjects
information regarding the morbidity pattern and health seeking behaviour If there were
more than one elderly subjects in the same household then all were included
The study subjects were asked about any ho illness (communicable or non-
communicable) which they were suffering from Upon a positive response the subjects were
further asked to specify the type(s) and duration of morbidities that they were suffering
from eg heart disease diabetes gastrointestinal diseases respiratory disease etc Some
were unable to understand or answer questions due to illness In such cases help was sought
from the family members Based on the self-reported symptoms information from
hospital records and clinical examination the prevalence of different morbidities among the
study subjects was assessed The Information about the health seeking behaviour was
sought by asking the study subjects about their visits to a health facility in case of an illness
and also the type of health facility visited ( Government private or quacks )
DATA ENTRY AND ANALYSIS Data was entered and analyzed using MS Excel and
Open Epi Info version 2260 Both descriptive and inferential statistics were used Subjectrsquos
baseline characteristics were presented as frequencies and percentages Categorical
variables between the groups were compared using Chi square test and Fisherrsquos exact
test Fisherrsquos exact test was used when more than 20 cells had expected value lt 5 and any
one of the cells had expected value lt 1 All statistical analysis was carried out at 5 level
of significance and p value lt005 was considered as significant
32
Methodology ETHICAL CLEARANCE
Ethical clearance was obtained before conducting the study from the Ethical Committee of
JJM Medical college Davangere [ANNEXURE III] During the study verbal
informed consent was taken from the study subjects Assurance was given that the
confidentiality concerning their information will be maintained
Clinical Examination included
(a) General physical examination
(b) Anthropometric measurements like height and weight
(c) Systemic examination
(d) Measurement of Blood pressure
(e) Eye examination by torch and Snellenrsquos (E chart)61
(f) Hearing assessment by Rinnersquos test Webberlsquos and Absolute bone conduction
test using tuning fork 62
Parameters used in our study
Height Height was measured with a standard non-stretchable measuring tape to the
nearest 01 cm in standing position (without footwear standing upright with the
back against the wall heels together and eyes directed forward)
33
Methodology Weight Weight was measured with minimal clothing and respecting the modesty of the
individual without footwear using a calibrated standard bathroom weighing scale to the
nearest 05 kg
Body Mass Index (BMI) Using weight (in Kg) and height (in meter2) BMI was calculated by applying the formula
Body Mass Index= Weight (kg) Height (m2)
The BMI cut off values for Asians as recommended by the WHO was used in our study
Table 4 WHO Categorization of Body Mass index (BMI) for Asians 63
Measurement of Blood pressure Procedure Blood pressure was measured in the left arm in a sitting posture with the subject in a
relaxed state Standardized mercury sphygmomanometer with adult size cuff was used
The first appearance of (phase 1 of Korotkoff sounds) sound was used to define
Systolic Blood Pressure (SBP) The disappearance of sound (phase 5) was used to
define Diastolic Blood Pressure (DBP) Two readings were taken five minutes apart and
the average of the two readings was taken as the final blood pressure reading A person
was considered to be a hypertensive if he she was already diagnosed case of
hypertension and or on treatment or with a current SBP of ge 140 mm Hg or DBP ge 90 mm
Hg (JNC VII criteria)64
BODY MASS INDEX INFERENCE
lt 185 underweight
185 to 229 kg m2 Normal
23 to 249 kg m2 Overweight
ge 25 kg m2 Obese
34
Methodology
Table 5 JNC VII Classification of Blood pressure 65
BP Classification Systolic Blood Pressure Diastolic Blood Pressure
Normal lt120 lt 80
Pre Hypertension 120 ndash 139 or 80 ndash 89 Stage 1 Hypertension 140 ndash 159 or 90 ndash 99 Stage 2 Hypertension ge 160 or ge 100
Anaemia was detected by pallor of conjunctiva tongue and nails and was confirmed by
doing haemoglobin estimation using sahlirsquos hemogobinometer66
The cut off for the diagnosis of anaemia was done based on WHO classification67
Diabetes - self reported cases of diabetes were considered as diabetics for the study
STUDY VARIABLES
1 AGE - subjects aged 60 years and above were taken up for the study Age was
recorded to the nearest complete years as stated by the respondent
2 GENDER Both males and females were taken up for the study
3 EDUCATIONAL STATUS 68
i Illiterate -A person who could not read or write
ii Primary School - studied up to 4th standard
iii Higher primary- studied between 5th and 7th standard
iv Secondary school -studied between 8th and 10th standard v Intermediate- studied between 11th or 12 th standard or diploma
vi Graduate - obtained graduate degree
vii Post Graduate- obtained post graduate degree
35
Methodology
4 OCCUPATION STATUS69
i Unskilled worker
Labourer domestic servants casual worker peon sweeper porter washer-man others
(vegetable vendor)
ii Semi-skilled worker
Factory worker agriculture laborers shoemaker potters others (security guard shop
helper canteen helper
iii Skilled
Artisan clerk foreman supervisor carpenter tailor mechanic electrician railway guard
painter modeler smiths baker driver shop assistant petty trader constable soldier
linesman pointsman potter barber others (tinkering printer receptionist salesman
welder cook mason postman plumber agarbatti worker)
iv semi-professional
Teacher pharmacist social worker owner of a small business farmer others (computer
programmer Govt employee nurse)
V Professional
Doctor engineer principal lawyer Military officer senior executive business
proprietor writer scientist large employer director university professor police
officer others (horse rider)
(vi) Unemployed Presently not working retired homemakers
36
Methodology 5 SOCIO ECONOMIC STATUS
Table 6 Socio-economic status (SES)- As per modified BG Prasad Classification70
5 TYPE OF FAMILY 71
Joint Family ndash It is type of family grouping in which a number of married couples and
their children live together in the same household All the men are related by blood
and women of household are their wives unmarried girls and widows of family kinsmen
Nuclear Family - It consist of married couple and their children while they are still
regarded as dependents
Three generation family - It is a family where representatives of three generation are
living together Young married couples continue to stay with their parents and have
their own children as well
Socio-economic
status
Prasadrsquos classification
1961(Per capita income in
Rupees per month)
Modified BG Prasad classification-
updated for May 2016 ((per
capita income in Rupees per
month)
I 100 and above 6261 and above
II 50-99 3099-6260
III 30-49 1835-3098
IV 15-29 949-1834
V Below 15 lt948
37
SAMPLE SIZE ESTIMATION
SAMPLE SIZE As quoted by Manmohan Gupta et al 35 in the studies done in various
parts of India the prevalence of morbidity in the geriatric population ranges from 31-80
Considering the prevalence of morbidity to be about 50 in the geriatric population at 95
confidence level and allowable error of 10 and a non -response rate of 10 sample size
was calculated to be 440 using the formula
n=4pq L2
n= sample size
4= factor to achieve 95 level of confidence
p= prevalence of morbidities ie 50
q= 100- p ie 100-50 = 50
L= permissible error in the estimate of ldquoprdquo (10 of p)
n = 4 x 50 x 50 = 400
5 x 5
After calculating a non-response rate of 10 a sample size of 440 was calculated
A community based cross sectional study was conducted in the urban field practice area of
JJM Medical College Davangere The Urban field practice area has a total population of
16943 and there are 12 areas in urban field practice area of JJM Medical College
Davangere
The Study was conducted by probability proportionate sampling The sample size for each area
was derived from the formula
1198991 =119875119900119901119906119897119886119905119894119900119899 119894119899 119890119886119888ℎ 119886119903119890119886
119879119900119905119886119897 119875119900119901119906119897119886119905119894119900119899119883 119878119886119898119901119897119890 119878119894119911119890
Example 1st area has a population of 1374 so
1198991 =1374
16943119883 440 = 36
Therefore 36 elderly subjects were selected by house to house visit from 1st area Same
procedure was applied for other areas until the desired sample size of 440 was reached
Results
RESULTS
The results are presented under the following headings
I Socio-demographic characteristics of study subjects
II Prevalence of morbidities among the study subjects
III Details of health seeking behavior of the study subjects
38
Results
ISocio-demographic characteristics of the study subjects
Table 7 Age and sex wise distribution of the study subjects
Figure 7 Age and sex wise distribution of the study subjects
In the present study Out of 440 study subjects majority 162(368) were in the age group
of 60-64 Years followed by 109 (247) in the age group of 65-69 Years 99 (225) were
in the age group of 70-74 Years and 35 (8) were more than or equal to 80 years of age
Majority of the subjects were males 260 (59) and 180 (41) were females The mean age
of the study population was 6745 plusmn 655 Years
354 254 262
88 42
389
239 172
67 133
0102030405060708090
100
60-64 65-69 70-74 75-79 ge80
Perc
enta
ge
Age in years
Males
Females
Age group (in years)
Males Females Total
Percentage () Frequency
(n=260) Percentage ()
Frequency (n=180)
Percentage ()
60-64 92 354 70 389 162 368
65-69 66 254 43 239 109 247
70-74 68 262 31 172 99 225
75-79 23 88 12 67 35 80
ge80 11 42 24 133 35 80
Total 260 100 180 100 440 100
39
Results
Table 8 Distribution of the study subjects based on religion
Religion Frequency (n=440) Percentage ()
Hindu 188 427
Muslim 252 573
Total 440 100
Figure 8 Distribution of the study subjects based on religion
In the present study it was found that the majority of the study subject belonged to Muslim
religion 252 (573) followed by Hindus 188 (427)
0102030405060708090
100
Hindu Muslim
427
573
Perc
enta
ge
Religion of the study subjects
40
Results
Table 9 Distribution of the study subjects based on Educational status
Education Frequency (n=440) Percentage ()
Illiterate 231 525
Primary school 121 275
Higher primary 38 86
Secondary School 30 68
Intermediate 6 14
Graduate 14 32
Total 440 100
Figure 9 Distribution of the study subjects based on Educational status
In the present study it was found that the Majority of the study subjects were illiterate
231(525) 121(275) had completed education up to primary school 30(68) had
completed education up to secondary school and only 14(32) were graduates
525
275
86 68
14 32
0102030405060708090
100
Perc
enta
ge
Educational status of study subjects
41
Results Table 10 Distribution of the study subjects based on occupation
Occupation Frequency (n=440) Percentage ()
Semi-professional 2 05
Skilled worker 45 102
Semi-skilled worker 68 155
Unskilled worker 100 227
Unemployed 225 511
Total 440 100
Figure 10 Distribution of study subjects based on their occupation
In our study it was found that the majority of the study subjects 225 (511) were
unemployed followed by 100 (227) who were unskilled workers 68 (155) were semi-
skilled workers and 45 (102) were skilled workers
0102030405060708090
100
05 102 155 227
511
Perc
enta
ge
Occupation of the study subjects
42
Results Table 11 Distribution of the study subjects based on socio-economic status (Modified
BG Prasad classification 2016)
Figure 11 Distribution of the study subjects based on their socio-economic status
In our study majority of the subjects 215 (49) belonged to Class IV Socioeconomic status
followed by 115 (26) who belonged to class III and 56 (13) who belonged to class II
SES (according to Modified BG Prasad Classification 2016)
Class II 13
Class III 26
Class IV 49
Class V 12
Socio-economic status Frequency (n=440) Percentage ()
Class I 0 0
Class II 56 13
Class III 115 26
Class IV 215 49
Class V 54 12
Total 440 100
43
Results
Table 12 Distribution of the study subjects based on their marital status
Marital status Frequency (n=440) Percentage ()
Unmarried 2 05
Married 323 734
Widowwidower 115 261
Total 440 100
Figure 12 Distribution of the study subjects based on their marital status
In our study it was found that majority of the study subjects 323(734) were married
followed by 115(261) who were widowed and only 2 (05) were unmarried
0102030405060708090
100
Unmarried married Widowwidower
05
734
261 Perc
enta
ge
44
Results
Table 13 Distribution of the study subjects based on the type of family
Type of family Frequency (n=440) Percentage ()
Nuclear family 163 37
Joint family 93 21
Three generation family 184 42
Total 440 100
Figure 13 Distribution of the study subjects based on the type of family
In the present study it was found that majority of the study subjects 184 (42) lived in a
three generation family followed by 163 (37) who lived in a nuclear family and 93(21)
who lived in a Joint family
Nuclear family 37
Joint family 21
Three generation
family 42
45
Results
II Prevalence of morbidities among the study subjects
Figure 14 Distribution of the study subjects based on the BMI
In the present study it was found that out of 440 study subjects 198 (45) had a normal
BMI followed by 132 (30) who were overweight 66 (15) were obese and only 44
(10) were underweight
under weight 10
Normal 45
Overweight 30
Obese 15
46
Results
Table 14 Distribution of morbidity pattern of the study subjects based on ICD 10
classification of diseases
System involved ICD 10
Males (n=260)
Females (n=180)
Total (n=440)
No No No
Diseases of musculoskeletal system (M00 ndash M99)
184 707 130 722 314 714
Diseases of the eye and adnexa (H00 ndash H59)
139 534 80 444 219 497
Diseases of oral cavityamp salivary glands (K00 ndash K14)
90 346 64 355 154 35
Endocrine nutritional amp metabolic diseases (E00 ndash
E90)
70 269 75 417 145 329
Diseases of circulatory system (I00 ndash I99)
64 246 73 405 137 311
Diseases of respiratory system(J00 ndash J99)
64 246 37 206 101 23
Diseases of digestive system (K00 ndash K93)
57 219 30 166 87 198
Diseases of skin amp subcutaneous tissue (L00 ndash
L99)
38 146 20 111 58 132
Diseases of the ear and mastoid process (H60 ndashH95)
39 15 18 10 57 13
Diseases of genitourinary system (N00 ndash N99)
22 85 7 39 29 66
Diseases of nervous system (G00 ndash G99)
6 23 5 28 11 25
Note Total number could not be given as many subjects had multiple disorders
47
Results
Figure 15 Distribution of morbidity pattern of the study subjects based on ICD 10
classification of diseases
In the present study it was found that the majority of the subjects 314 (714) suffered
from the disorders of the musculoskeletal system followed by 219 (497) who suffered
from the disease of the eye and adnexa154 (35) suffered from the disease of the oral
cavity 145 (329) suffered from endocrine nutritional and metabolic disorders137
(311) suffered from the disease of the circulatory system 101 (229) suffered from the
disease of the respiratory system 87(198) suffered from the disease of the digestive
system 58 (132) suffered from disease of the skin 57 (13) suffered from the disease of
the ear 29 (66) suffered from the disease of the genitourinary system and only 11( 25 )
suffered from the disease of the nervous system
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
714
497
35 329 311 229
198 132 13 66
25
perc
enta
ge
48
Results
Table 15 Distribution of the study subjects based on morbidity of the musculoskeletal
system
Musculoskeletal
Disease
Males
(n=260)
Females
(n=180)
Total
(n= 440)
Statistical
Value
Knee joint pain
52 (20)
30 (167)
82 (186)
X2 = 0779
df = 1
p=03773
Back ache
30 (115)
35 (194)
65 (148) X2 = 528
df = 1
p = 0021
Joint pain (other than
knee joint pain)
52(20)
35(194)
87(198)
X2 =00206
df=1
p =0885
Non-specific aches
and pain
50(192)
30(167)
80(182)
X2=0470
df=1
p = 0492
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses
In the present study it was found that the most common morbidity of musculoskeletal
system was pain of the joints (other than the knee joint) found in 87 (198) of the subjects
followed by knee joint pain in 82 ( 186) and non-specific pains and aches were found in
80 (182) of the subjects It was found that back ache was more common in females
35(194) compared to males 30 (115) and this difference was found to be statistically
significant
49
Results
Table 16 Distribution of the study subjects based on morbidity of the eye and adnexa
Diseases of the
eye and
adnexa
Males
(n=260)
Females
(n=180)
Total
(n= 440)
Statistical
value
Cataract
112(43)
60(333)
172(391)
X2 = 4241
df=1
p = 0039
Refractive error
20(77)
14(78)
34(77)
X2= 0001
df=1
p = 0973
Others (conjunctivitis
pterygium glaucoma etc)
7(27)
6(33)
13(29)
X2=0152
df=1
p = 0696
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses
In the present study it was found that the most common morbidity of the eye was cataract
found in 172 (391) of the subjects It was more common in males 112 (43) compared to
females 60 (333) and this difference was found to be statistically significant The other
morbidities present were refractive error found in 34 (77) subjects and others which
includes conjunctivitis pterygium glaucoma etc found in 13 (29 ) subjects
50
Results
Table 17 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the oral cavity
Diseases of the
oral cavity
Males
(n =260 )
Females
(n =180 )
Total
(n = 440)
Statistical
value
Stained teeth
22 (84)
18 (10)
40 (91)
X2 =0304
df=1
p = 0581
Missing teeth
40 (154)
38 (211)
78 (177)
X2= 239
df= 1
p=0122
Caries
28 (108)
8 (44)
36 (82)
X2= 566
df= 1
p=0017
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses
In the present study it was found that the most common morbidity of the oral cavity was
missing teeth found in 78 (177 ) of the subjects followed by stained teeth found in 40
(91) of the subjects and dental caries in 36 (82) of the subjects Dental caries were
more common in males 28 (108) compared to females 8(44) and this difference was
found to be statistically significant
51
Results
Table 18 Distribution of study subjects based on endocrine nutritional and metabolic
disorders
Disorders Males
(n =260 )
Females
(n =180)
Total
(n = 440)
Statistical value
Diabetes mellitus
45 (173)
37 (206)
82 (186)
X2 = 0739
df= 1
p = 0389
Anemia
24 (92)
35 (194)
59 (134)
X2= 955
df = 1
p = 0001
Thyroid disorders
1(04)
3 (17)
4 (09)
p= 0309
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
The present study revealed that the most common disorder of the endocrine system was
diabetes mellitus found in 82 (186) of the subjects followed by the nutritional disorder of
anemia found in 59 (134) of the subjects It was seen that anemia was more common
among females 35 (194) compared to males 24 (92) This difference was found to be
statistically significant Disorders of the thyroid gland were found in 4 (09) of the subjects
being more common in females 3(17) compared to males 1 (04)
52
Results
Table 19 Distribution of the study subject based on disease of the circulatory system
Diseases of
circulatory
system
Males
(n=260 )
Females
(n =180)
Total
(n = 440)
Statistical
value
Hypertension
62 (238)
71 (394)
133 (302)
X2= 1227
df= 1
p = 0000
CAD MI
Arrhythmias
2 (08)
2 (11)
4 (09)
p =100
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
In our study it was found that the most common disease of the circulatory system was
hypertension which was found in 133 (302 ) of the subjects it was more common in
females 71 (394) compared to males 62 (239) and this difference was found to be
statistically significant The other disorders of the circulatory system were CAD MI
arrhythmias which were found only in 4 (09) of the study subjects
53
Results
Table 20 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the respiratory system
Disorders of
Respiratory
System
Males
(n=260)
Females
(n=180)
Total
(n=440)
Statistical
value
Bronchial asthma
3 (12)
3 (17)
6 (14)
p =0692
URTI
45 (173)
27 (15)
72 (164)
X2= 0413
df = 1
p = 0520
Acute Bronchitis
12 (46)
7 (39)
19 (43)
X2= 0135
df = 1
p = 0712
Pulmonary TB
4 (15)
0(00)
4 (09)
p =0148
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
Our study revealed that the most common disease of the respiratory system was URTI
(upper respiratory tract infection) found in 72 (164) subjects followed by acute bronchitis
in 19 (43 ) bronchial asthma in 6 (14) and pulmonary TB in only in 4 (09 ) subjects
Pulmonary TB was found in 4 (15) of the males whereas no females had TB however
this difference was not found to be statistically significant
54
Results
Table 21 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the digestive system
Disorders of
Gastrointestinal
system
Males
(n = 260)
Females
(n = 180)
Total
(n = 440)
Statistical value
Constipation
21(8)
6 (33)
27(61)
X2 =4155
df =1
p =0041
Gastritis
24 (92)
18 (10)
42(95)
X2= 0072
df = 1
p =0787
Bleeding per
rectum 3(12) 2(11) 5(11)
p =100
Others (Pain
abdomen
anorexia
indigestion)
9(35)
4 (22)
13 (3)
X2=0569
df =1
p=0450
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
Our study revealed that the most common disorder of the gastrointestinal system was
gastritis found in 42 (95) subjects followed by constipation in 27 ( 61) others which
include pain abdomen anorexia indigestion was found in 13 (3) and bleeding per rectum
was seen in 5 (11) It was seen that constipation was more common among males 21(8)
compared to females 6 (33) which was found to be statistically significant
55
Results
Table 22 Distribution the study subjects based on disease of the Skin and
subcutaneous tissue
Disorders of skin and
subcutaneous tissue
Males ( n = 260)
Females (n = 180)
Total (n = 440)
Statistical
value
Itching
19(73)
2(11)
21(48)
X2 =896
df=1
p = 0002
Scaling 6 (23)
3 (17)
9 (2)
p =0743
Pigmentation
5(19)
4 (22)
9 (2)
p =100
Dryness
8 (31)
11 (61)
19(43)
X2= 237
df = 1
p = 0123 Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
In the present study it was found that the most common disease of the skin was itching
which was present in 21 (48) of the study subjects followed by dryness in 19 (43) and 9
(2) of the subjects had scaling and pigmentation It was seen that itching was more
common among males 19 (73) compared to females 2 (11) and this difference was
found to be statistically significant
56
Results
Table 23 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the ear
Disease of the ear
Males
(n= 260)
Females
(n = 180)
Total
(n = 440) Statistical value
Hearing impairment
33 (126)
16 (89)
49 (111)
X2 =155
df =1
p =0212
Ear discharge
3 (12)
1 (06)
4(09)
p =0647
Tinnitus
3 (12)
1 (06)
4 (09)
p =0647
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
In the present study it was observed that hearing impairment was the most common
morbidity of the ear found in 49 (111) of the subjects though it was more common
among males 33 (126) compared to females 16 (89) the difference was not found to be
statistically significant The other disorders which affected the ear were ear discharge and
tinnitus both present in 4 (09) of the subjects
57
Results
Table 24 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the genitourinary
system
Disorders of
genitourinary system
Male
(n = 260)
Female
(n = 180)
Total
(n=440)
Statistical value
Burning micturition
2 (077)
2 (11)
4 (09)
p=100
Increased frequency of
micturition
20(77) 5(28) 25(57)
X2= 4794
df =1
p =0028 Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
In our study it was observed that the most common morbidity affecting the genitourinary
system was increased frequency of micturition in 25 (57) of the subjects followed by
burning micturition in 4 (09) of the study subjects Increased frequency of micturition was
more common among males 20 (77) compared to females 5 (28) and this difference
was found to be statistically significant
58
Results
Table 25 Distribution of the study subjects based on diseases of the Nervous system
Disease of the
nervous system Males
(n = 260)
Females
(n = 180)
Total
(n = 440)
p value
Memory loss
2 (77)
2 (11)
4 (09)
100
Stroke
2 (77)
0 (00)
2 (05)
0515
Neuritis
2 (77)
3 (17)
5 (11)
0652
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
Our study revealed that the most common disorder of the nervous system was neuritis seen
in 5 (11) of the subjects followed by memory loss in 4 (09) and stroke in 2 (05 ) of
the subjects It was observed that 2 (0 77) of males had suffered a stroke whereas none of
the females had suffered from stroke however this difference was not found to be
statistically significant
59
Results
Table 26 Association between morbidity pattern of the study subjects and their age
group
System involved 60-69Yrs
(n = 271)
70-79Yrs
(n = 134)
gt 80Yrs
(n = 35)
Total
( n = 440)
Statistical
value
Musculoskeletal
System
195 (72)
94 (70)
25 (710)
314 (714) X2= 0143
df = 2 p = 0930
Eye amp adnexa
125 (461)
69 (515)
25 (714)
219 (497) X2= 8166
df = 2 p = 0016
Oral cavity amp salivary gland
56 (207)
68 (507)
30 (857)
154 (350) X2= 7865
df = 2 p lt 00001
Endocrine nutritional amp
metabolic diseases
91 (335)
47 (35)
7 (200)
145 (329) X2= 297
df = 2 p = 0225
Circulatory
system
87 (321)
40 (298)
10 (285)
137 (311) X2= 0328
df = 2 p = 0848
Respiratory
system
64 (236)
31 (231)
6 (171)
101 (23) X2= 0738
df = 2 p = 0691
Digestive system
52 (191)
28 (210)
7 (200)
87 (191) X2= 0166
df = 2 p = 0 920
Skin and subcutaneous
tissue
43 (159)
13 (97)
2 (57)
58 (132) X2= 4831
df = 2 p = 0089
Ear amp mastoid process
27 (99)
20 (149)
10 (285)
57 (13) X2= 1018
d= 2 p = 0006
Genitourinary
system
20 (74)
8 (59)
1 (29)
29 (66) X2= 1151
df = 2 p = 0562
Nervous system
5 (18)
4 (29)
2 (57)
11 (25)
p = 0418
Figure in parenthesis indicates percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
60
Results
Table 26 shows the association between the morbidity pattern and age group of the study
subjects It is observed that the disease of the eye and adnexa increase with increasing age
and are more common in individuals above 80 years of age (714) compared to
individuals in the age group of 60-69 years (461) and 70-79 years (515) This
difference was found to be statistically significant The disease of the oral cavity were also
more common in the subjects aged 80 years and above (857) compared to individuals in
the age group of 70-79 years (507) and 60-69 years (207) this difference was also
found to be statistically significant Significant association was also found between
increasing age and disease of the ear 285 subjects aged 80 years and above suffered from
disease of the ear followed by 149 in the age group of 60-69 years and 99 in the age
group of 60-69 years
61
Results Table 27 Association between morbidity pattern of the study subjects and their
occupation
System involved Employed (n=215)
Unemployed (n=225)
Total (n=440)
Statistical value
Musculoskeletal
system
171 (795) 143 (635) 314 (714) X2 =1374 df=1
p=00002
Eye and adnexa 108 (502) 111(493) 219(497) X2= 0035 df=1
p= 0850
Oral cavityamp
salivary glands
76 (353) 78 (347) 154 (35) X2=0022 df=1
p=0880
Endocrine
nutritional amp
metabolic
disease
75 (348) 70 (311) 145 (329) X2=0708 df=1
p=0400
circulatory
system
58 (269) 79 (351) 137 (311) X2=3393 df=1
p=0065
Respiratory
system
49 (227) 52 (231) 101 (23) X2=0006 df=1
p=09363
Digestive system 45 (21) 42 (187) 87 (198) X2=0125 df=1
p=0723
Skin
subcutaneous
tissue
38 (176) 20 (88) 58 (132) X2=741 df=1
p=0006
Ear and mastoid
process
31 (144) 26 (115) 57 (13) X2=0799 df=1
p=0371
Genitourinary
system
16 (74) 13 (57) 29 (66) X2=0494 df=1
p=0481
Nervous system
2 (093) 9 (4) 11 (25) X2=425 df=1
p=0039 Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses
62
Results
Table 27 shows the association between the morbidity pattern and occupation of the study
subjects It was observed that musculoskeletal disorders were more common among the
subjects who are employed (795) compared to those who are not employed (635) and
this difference was found to be statistically significant A significant association was also
seen between the disorders of the skin and subcutaneous tissue 176 subjects who are
employed suffered from the disease of the skin and subcutaneous tissue compared to 88
who were unemployed The diseases of the nervous system were more common among
those who were unemployed (4) compared to those who were employed (093) this
difference was also found to be statistically significant
63
Results Table 28 Association between morbidity pattern of the study subjects and their
religion
System involved Hindu
(n=188)
Muslim
(n=252)
Total
(n=440)
Statistical value
Musculoskeletal system 138 (73) 176 (698) 314 (714)
X2=0668 df=1
p=0413
Eye and adnexa 100 (531) 119 (472) 219 (497) X2=1535 df=1
p= 0215
Oral cavityamp salivary glands 73 (388) 81 (321) 154 (35)
X2=211 df=1
p=0145
Endocrine nutritional amp metabolic diseases
53 (2819) 92 (365) 145 (329) X2=3371 df=1
p=0066
circulatory system 58 (269) 79 (351) 137 (311)
X2=3393 df=1
p=0065
Respiratory system
33 (176) 68 (269) 101 (229)
X2=5415 df= 1
p=0019
Digestive system 27 (144) 60 (238) 87 (198) X2=6059 df=1
p=0013
Skin subcutaneous tissue
31 (164) 27 (107) 58 (132) X2=3138 df=1
p=00765
Ear and mastoid process
28 (149) 29 (115) 57 (129) X2=1095 df=1
p=0297
Genitourinary system
16 (85) 13 (52) 29 (66) X2=1965 df=1
p=0161
Nervous system
4 (21) 7 (28) 11(25) p=0764
Figure in parenthesis indicates percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
64
Results
Table 28 shows the association between the morbidity pattern of the study subjects and their
religion In our study it was observed that the disorders of the digestive system were more
common among Muslims (238) compared to Hindus (144) this difference was found
to be statistically significant Also the disorders of the respiratory system were more
common among Muslims (269) compared to Hindus (176) This difference was also
found to be statistically significant Some of the diseases were more common among Hindus
which include the disease of the eye and adnexa (531) oral cavity (388) ear (149)
skin and subcutaneous tissue (164) and genitourinary system (85) but it was not found
to be statistically significant
65
Results
III HEATLTH SEEKING BEHAVIOR OF THE STUDY SUBJECTS
Figure16 Distribution of the study subjects based on the visit to health facility in case
of an illness
In our study it was found that that out of 440 study subjects 395(898) visited a health
facility in case of an illness whereas 45(102) did not visit any health facility in case of an
illness
898
102
health facility visitednot visited
66
Results
Table 29 Reasons cited by the study subjects for not seeking healthcare in case of an
illness
In the present study it was found that the most common reason stated by the 45 study
subjects for not seeking health care in case of an illness was that it was a mil 20 (444)
followed by lack of money stated by12 (267) the other reasons stated were no one to
accompany 7 (156) and lack of faith in health care 6 (133)
Reasons cited for not
seeking health care
Frequency (n=45)
Percentage ()
Mild discomfort 20 444
Lack of money 12 267
Lack of faith in
healthcare
6 133
No one to accompany 7 156
Total 45 100
67
Results
Table 30 Distribution of the study subjects based on the type of health facility visited
It was observed that out of 395 subjects who visited health care facility in case of an illness
229(58) Visited government hospitals 160 (405) visited private practitioners hospitals
and 6 (15) visited quacks More number of males (622) visited government hospitals
compared to females (513)
Type of health facility visited
Males
(n=241)
Females
(n=154)
Total
(n=395)
No No No
Government hospital 150 622 79 513 229 58
Private practitionershospitals 87 361 73 474 160 405
Quacks 4 17 2 13 6 15
Total 241 100 154 100 395 100
68
Results
Table 31 Association between gender and health seeking behaviour of the study
subjects
Whether visited
health facility
in case of illness
Sex
Total
n ()
p value Male
n ()
Female
n ()
Yes 241 (927) 154 (856) 395 (898) 00151
No 19 (106) 26 (144) 45 (102)
Total 260 (59) 180 (41) 440 (100)
x2=5901 df =1
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
It was observed that more number of males visited a health care facility in case of an illness
241(927) whereas only 154(856) females visited a health facility in case of an illness
This difference was found to be statistically significant
69
Results
Table 32 Association between educational status and health seeking
behaviour of the study subjects
Whether visited Health facility in case of illness
p value
Educational status(n) Yes () No ()
0000
Illiterate (231) 194 (84) 37 (16)
Primary school (121) 115 (95) 6 (49)
Higher primary (38) 37 (974) 1 (26)
Secondary school (30) 29 (967) 1 (33)
Intermediate (6) 6 (100) 0(00)
Graduate (14) 14 (100) 0(00)
Total(440) 395 (898) 45(102)
Fisherrsquos exact test
In the present study it was found that 84 of the study subjects who were illiterate visited a
health facility in case of an illness whereas 16 did not visit a health facility in case of an
illness 967 of the subjects with education up to secondary school visited the health
facility and 100 of the subjects who studied up to intermediate and with a graduate degree
visited the health facility in case of an illness This difference was found to be statistically
significant
70
Results
Table 33 Distribution of study subjects according to frequency of visits to a health care facility
Frequency of visits to a health care facility
Frequency
(n=395)
Percentage
Once a month 207 524
Once in 3 months 99 251
Once in 6 months 79 20
Once in a year 10 25
Total 395 100
In the present study it was found that out of 395 study subjects who visited a health care
facility in case of an illness 207 (524) visited a health facility every month followed by
99 (251) who visited once in 3 months 79(20) once in 6 months and 10 25 visited
the health facility once in a year
71
Discussion
DISCUSSION
I Socio-demographic characteristics
Our study was done in the urban field practice area of JJM Medical College Davangere
among 440 geriatric subjects our study aimed at assessing the morbidity pattern and health
seeking behaviour of the geriatric population in the study area
In the present study Out of 440 study subjects majority 162(368) were in the age
group of 60-64 Years followed by 109 (247) in the age group of 65-69 Years 99 (225)
in the age group of 70-74 Years and 8 were more than or equal to 80 years of age [Table
7] This was similar to a study conducted by Prakash Boraingaiah et al 72 in which majority
of the elderly (346) belongs to age group 60-64 years followed by age group 75 years and
above (259)
In our study it was also seen that 59 of the study subjects were males and 41 were
females This was similar to a study conducted by Mohan Gupta et al 35 where 573
subjects were males and 427were females Our findings were contrary to a study
conducted by Md Alam Naushad et al 28 where 598 subjects were females and 402
were males
In the present study it was found that the majority of the study subject belonged to
Muslim religion 252 (573) followed by Hindus 188 (427) there were no study subjects
who belonged to other religions like Christian Jain Sikhs etc [Table 8] similar findings
were seen in a study conducted by Mrinal Ranjan Srivastav et al 50 in which 52 of the
subjects were Muslims
72
Discussion
In the present study it was found that the Majority of the study subjects were illiterate
525 whereas 275 had completed education up to primary school 82 had completed
education up to secondary school and only 32 were graduates [Table 9] These findings
were similar to a study done by Shraddha K et al 51in which 504 of the study subjects
were illiterate
In our study it was found that the majority of the study subjects 511 were unemployed
followed by 227 who were unskilled workers 155 were semi-skilled workers and
about 105 were skilled workers [Table 10] These findings were similar to a study done
by Rajat Das Gupta et al27 al in which 481 of the study subjects were not working
In our study majority of the subjects 49 belonged to Class IV Socioeconomic status
followed by 26 who belonged to class III and 13 who belonged to class II (according to
Modified BG Prasad Classification 2016) [Table 11] Similar findings were found in a study
conducted by Sribas Goswami and Manjari Sahai 29 in which majority of the study subjects
belonged to class IV socio economic status
In our study it was found that the majority of the study subjects 734 were married
followed by 261 who were widowed and only 05 were unmarried [Table 12] These
findings were similar to a study done by L subedhi and RB Sah 40 in which 663 of the
subjects were married 322 were widowed and 07 were unmarried
In the present study it was found that majority of the study subjects 42 lived in a three
generation family followed by 37 who lived in a nuclear family and 21 who lived in a
Joint family [Table 13] These findings were similar to a study done by Swapnil Jain et al 26
in which the majority (47) of the study subjects lived in a three generation family
73
Discussion
II Prevalence of morbidities among the study subjects
In the present study it was found that majority of the subjects 45 had a normal BMI
followed by 30 who were overweight about 15 were obese and only10 were
underweight [Figure 14] Similar findings were reported in a study conducted by Khadervali
Nagoor et al 44 in which 49 subjects had a normal BMI In a study done by Vimala
Thomas et al 52 272 of the subjects were obese which was higher than the present study
In the present study it was found that the majority of the subjects suffered from the
disorders of the musculoskeletal system (714) eye and adnexa (497) oral cavity
(311) respiratory system (229) digestive system (198)disease of the skin
(132)ear(13)genitourinary system (66) nervous system (25) [Table14] Similar
findings were seen in a study done by Rajashree Bhat et al 55 in which most common
morbidity of elderly was the problems of loco-motor system (486) followed by vision
(427) CVS disorders (344) respiratory system (202) and disease of ear (179)In
this study though the prevalence of loco-motor system disorders (486) was highest
compared to other disorders it was lesser compared to our study (714) In a study done by
L subedhi and RB Sah 40 it was found that 44 had eye problems 43 had gastrointestinal
problems 33 had CVS problems and 23 had ENT problems In this study the prevalence
of gastrointestinal disorders was much higher compared to our study
In the present study joint pain (including the knee joint) was most common disorder of the
musculoskeletal system seen in 40 of the males compared to 384 in females [Table 15]
whereas in a study done by Swapnil Jain et al 26 it was found that 472 males and 528
females suffered from joint pains This could be attributed to the fact that in our study
majority of the study subjects were males
74
Discussion
In the present study it was found that the most common morbidity of the eye was cataract
found in 39 of the subjects It was more common in males 43 compared to females
333 [ Table 16]These findings were similar to a study done by Shraddha K et al 51 in
which the overall prevalence of cataract was 302 of which 42 males and 358
females had cataract
In the present study it was found that the most common morbidity of the oral cavity was
missing teeth found in 177 of the subjects [Table 17] it was similar to the findings of a
study conducted by JP Singh et al 48 in which 1475 subjects were edentulous
The present study revealed that the most common disorder of the endocrine system was
diabetes mellitus found in 186 of the subjects followed by the nutritional disorder of
anemia found in 134 of the subjects It was seen that anemia was more common among
females 194 compared to males 92 [Table 18] Kakkar R et al 45 reported similar
findings with prevalence of diabetes mellitus as 153 In a study done by Deepak Sharma
et al 47 anemia was present in 15 of the subjects 97 males and 21 females were
anemic which was similar to our study
In our study it was found that the most common disease of the circulatory system was
hypertension which was found in 302 of the subjects it was more common in females
394 compared to males 239 and this difference was found to be statistically significant
[Table 19] A study by L Subedhi and RB Sah 40 reported that the prevalence of
hypertension was more among females (333) compared to males (30) which was
statistically significant
75
Discussion
In our study the most common morbidity of the respiratory system was upper respiratory
tract infection (163) [Table20] it was similar to the study done by Leena Rahul
Salunke33 where it was reported to be 196
In our study the most common disorder of the digestive system was gastritis (95)
[Table 21] similar to the findings of JP Singh et al 48 (35) contrary to this L subedhi
and RB Sah 40 reported a high prevalence of gastritis (39) This difference could be
attributed to the difference in the interpretation of symptoms for the diagnosis of gastritis
In our study the most common disorder of the skin was itching (48) [ Table 22] which
was similar to the findings reported by JP Singh et al 48 in which 225 subjects suffered
from itching
In our study the most common disorder of the ear was impaired hearing (111) [Table
23] similar to a study by Vandana Nikumb et al 38 in which 106 subjects suffered from
hearing impairment
In our study it was observed that the most common morbidity affecting the
genitourinary system was increased frequency of micturition (57) [Table 24]
L subedhi and RB Sah40 found in their study that 143 subjects suffered from increased
frequency of micturition which was higher compared to our study
Our study revealed that 25 subjects suffered from the disorders of the nervous
system [Table 25] similar to a study conducted by Vandana Nikumb et al 38 in which
13 of the Subjects suffered from the disorders of the nervous system whereas in a
study conducted by Shilpa Shaukaiah et al36 it was found that 66 of the subjects
suffered from the disorders of the nervous system which was higher than our study
76
Discussion
It is observed that the disease of the eye and adnexa increased with increasing age and were
more common in individuals above 80 years of age (714) The disease of the oral cavity
were also more common in the subjects aged 80 years and above (857) and 285
subjects aged 80 years and above suffered from disease of the ear A significant association
was found between age and these morbidities [Table 26] Similar results were found in a
study done by Swapnil Jain et al 26 in which cataract hearing impairment and dental
problems were significantly associated with the age of the study subjects
In our study a significant association was found between occupation and the disorders of
the musculoskeletal system skin and the nervous system Disorders of the musculoskeletal
system were more common among employed subjects (795) compared to unemployed
(635) 176 subjects who were employed suffered from the disease of the skin and
subcutaneous tissue compared to 88 who were unemployed Diseases of the nervous
system were more common among those who were unemployed (4) compared to those
who were employed (093) [Table 27]
A study done by Kakkar R et al45 found that there was a significant association between the
employment status and the morbidities of the CVS arthritis and cataract CVS morbidity
was more common among those not working (164) compared to those working (36)
Arthritis was also more common among not working (212) compared to those working
(55) and cataract was also more common among those not working (175) compared to
those working (55)
77
Discussion
In our study it was observed that there was a significant association between religion and
disorders of the digestive system and respiratory system The disorders of the digestive
system were more common among Muslims (238) compared to Hindus (144) Also the
disorders of the respiratory system were more common among Muslims (269) compared
to Hindus (176) [Table 28] In a study conducted by Mrinal Ranjan Srivastav et al 50 it
was found that there was significant association between religion and the morbidities of the
genitourinary system in the urban areas The problems of the genitourinary system were
more common among Hindus (26) compared to Muslims (96)
III HEATLTH SEEKING BEHAVIOR OF THE STUDY SUBJECTS
In our study it was found that that (898) study subjects visited a health facility in case
of an illness whereas 102 did not visit any health facility in case of an illness[Figure 16]
Similar findings were seen in a study conducted by Vimala Thomas et al 52 where it was
found that 716 subjects visited a health facility Contrary to our findings a study
conducted by Bhawalkar JS et al46 showed that only 81 subjects visited a health facility in
case of an illness whereas 919 did not visit any health facility
In the present study it was found that the most common reason stated by study subjects
for not seeking health care in case of an illness was that it was a mild discomfort (444)
followed by lack of money stated by (267) other reasons stated were no one to
accompany (156) and lack of faith in health care (133) [Table 29] In a study
conducted by Deepak Sharma et al 47 it was found that the most common reasons for not
seeking health care were the following disease due to age (496) health services too far
(191) lack of money (6) no body to take to hospital (35)
78
Discussion
It was observed that out of 395 subjects who visited health care facility in case of an illness
58 Visited government hospitals 362 visited private practitioners hospitals and 15
visited quacks [Table 30] similar results were found in a study conducted by Deepak Sharma
et al 47 in which 607 went to Government hospitals 267 consulted private practitioners
and 126 took over the counter drugs In another study conducted by Rajat Das Gupta et al
27 it was found that 33 visited Government hospitals 25 visited private hospitals 6
visited private practitioners
It was observed that more number of males (927) visited a health care facility in case of
an illness whereas only 856 females visited a health facility in case of an illness [Table
31] In a study done by Man Mohan Gupta et al 35 it was found that 672 females and
651 males visited a health facility in case of illness
In the present study it was found that 848 of the study subjects who were illiterate
visited a health facility in case of an illness whereas 152 did not visit a health facility in
case of an illness A significant association was found between educational status and
gender [Table 32] In a study done by Deepak Sharma et al 47 it was found that Gender
literacy income and marital status were not found to be significantly related to health-
seeking behaviour
In the present study it was found that 524 subjects visited a health facility every month
followed by 251 who visited a health facility once in 3 months 20once in 6 months
and 25 visited a health facility once in a year[ Table 33] In a study conducted by Rajat
Das Gupta et al 27 it was found that majority of the subjects (2943) visited a health
facility once a year followed by 2813 who visited a health facility once in three months
79
Conclusion
CONCLUSION
The study revealed that some of the common morbidities among the geriatric subjects were
the disorders of the musculoskeletal system followed by the disease of the eye and adnexa
oral cavity endocrine nutritional and metabolic disorders etc some disorders like cataract
dental caries constipation and increased frequency of micturition were more common
among males whereas disease like anemia and hypertension were more common among
females A significant association was found between some of the morbidities and socio
demographic determinants like age occupation and religion
Any degree of formal schooling was found to be associated with better health seeking
behavior Majority of the subjects visited a Government health facility in case of an illness
and the main reason that was stated for not visiting a health facility was that they suffered
from mild discomfort and did not consider it necessary to visit a health facility
80
Summary
SUMMARY
Our study was done in the urban field practice area of JJM Medical College Davangere
among 440 geriatric subjects our study aimed at assessing the morbidity pattern and health
seeking behaviour of the geriatric population in the study area
The results of our study are as follows
ISocio-demographic characteristics of the study subjects
In the present study 368 subjects were in the age group of 60-64 Years
59 of the subjects were males and 41 were females
573 subjects were Muslims whereas 427 were Hindus
Majority of the subjects were illiterate (525) whereas 275 had completed
education up to primary school
It was found that the majority of the study subjects (511) were unemployed
49 subjects belonged to Class IV Socioeconomic status according to Modified BG
Prasad Classification
734 of the subjects were married
42 of the people lived in a three generation family
II Prevalence of morbidities among the study subjects
Majority of the subjects (45) had a normal BMI followed 30who were
overweight
Majority 714 subjects suffered from the disorders of the musculoskeletal system
followed by 497 who suffered from the disease of the eye and adnexa35
suffered from the disease of the oral cavity 329 suffered from endocrine
nutritional and metabolic disorders and 311 suffered from the disease of the
circulatory system 229 suffered from the disease of the respiratory system198
81
Summary
suffered from the disease of the digestive system132 suffered from disease of the
skin13 suffered from the disease of the ear66 suffered from the disease of the
genitourinary system and 25 suffered from the disease of the nervous system
The most common morbidity of musculoskeletal system was pain of the joints (other
than the knee joint) found in 198 of the subjectsBack ache was more common in
females 231 compared to males 163 and this difference was found to be
statistically significant
cataract found in 39 of the subjects It was more common in males 43 compared
to females 333 and this difference was found to be statistically significant
Missing teeth were found in 177 of the subjects Dental caries were more
common in males 108 compared to females 44 and this difference was found to
be statistically significant
Diabetes mellitus found in 186 of the subjects followed by the nutritional disorder
of anemia found in 134 of the subjects anemia was more common among females
194 compared to males 92 This difference was found to be statistically
significant
Hypertension which was found in 302 of the subjects it was more common in
females 394 compared to males 239 and this difference was found to be
statistically significant
upper respiratory tract infection) found in 163 subjects followed by acute
bronchitis in 43 bronchial asthma in 14 and pulmonary TB in only 09
Gastritis was found in 95 subjects followed by constipation in 61 Among
males (81) had constipation compared to females(03)
Most common disease of the skin was itching which was present in 48 of the
study subjects followed by dryness in 43
82
Summary
Hearing impairment was found in 111 of the subjects
Increased frequency of micturition was found in 57 of the subjects followed by
burning micturition in 09 of the study subjects Increased frequency of
micturition was more among males 77 compared to females in whom it was 28
and this difference was found to be statistically significant
The most common disorder of the nervous system was neuritis seen in 11 of the
subjects followed by memory loss in 09 and stroke in 05 of the subjects
A significant association was found between increasing age and the morbidities of
the eye ear and the oral cavity
Significant association was found between occupation and the disorders of the
musculoskeletal system skin and the nervous system Disorders of the
musculoskeletal system were more common among employed subjects (795)
compared to unemployed (635) 176 subjects who were employed suffered
from the disease of the skin and subcutaneous tissue compared to 88 who were
unemployed Diseases of the nervous system were more common among those who
were unemployed (4) compared to those who were employed (093)
It was observed that the disorders of the digestive system were more common
among Muslims (238) compared to Hindus (144) this difference was found to
be statistically significant Also the disorders of the respiratory system were more
common among Muslims (269) compared to Hindus (176) This difference
was also found to be statistically significant
83
Summary
III HEATLTH SEEKING BEHAVIOR OF THE STUDY SUBJECTS
In our study 898 subjects visited a health facility in case of an illness whereas
102 did not
The most common reason stated by study subjects for not seeking health care in case
of an illness was that it was a mild discomfort (444) followed by lack of money
stated by (267) the other reasons stated were no one to accompany (156) and
lack of faith in health care (133)
It was observed that 58 subjects Visited Government hospitals 362 visited
private practitioners hospitals and 15 visited quacks
Majority of males (927) visited a health care facility in case of an illness whereas
only 856 females visited a health facility in case of an illness This difference was
found to be statistically significant
A significant association was found between the educational status and health
seeking behaviour Majority of the educated subjects visited a health facility in case
of an illness compared to those who were illiterate
It was found that 524 subjects visited a health facility every month followed by
251 who visited a health facility once in 3 months 20once in 6 months and
25 visited a health facility once in a year
84
Limitations
LIMITATIONS
1 Many of the responses were subjective and there were no records to verify them
2 Some of the morbidities were diagnosed only by clinical examination and could not be
confirmed by performing diagnostic tests due to high cost and time constraints
3 This study was done in the urban field practice area which consisted of a closed
community hence the results cannot be generalized to the entire population of the area
85
Recommendations
RECOMMENDATIONS
1 Health education should be given to the geriatric people regarding the common health
problems associated with ageing and preventive care should be provided to the elderly
2 Geriatric clinics should be set up at the primary health care level which provide regular
screening and health check-ups
3 There should also be a provision to provide domiciliary care by specialists qualified in
geriatrics
4 The family members and the care givers of the elderly should be educated about the
common health problems of the elderly and also about the need for regular health check-ups
and emotional support
5 The majority of the geriatric population is out of work force they are suffering from
many morbidities and are totally dependent on others even for their health needs Hence the
Government should increase the pension of the elderly and provide them quality healthcare
free of cost
6 There is also a need for public private partnership to improve the quality of health
services for the geriatric people More number of NGOs should work towards improving the
health and the quality of life of the elderly
86
References
REFERENCES
1 United Nations Department of Economic and Social affairs Population Division
World population ageing 2013 Available from URL
wwwunorgendevelopmentpopulationageingWorldPopulationAgeing2013
[Accessed on 17-7-2016]
2 Khan S and Itrat M Current Issues in Geriatric Health Care in India-A Review J Community Med Health Care 2016 1(1) 1-3
3 United Nations Department of Economic and Social Affairs Population Division
World Population Ageing 2015 ndash Highlights Available from URL
wwwunorgendevelopmentdesapopulationpdfageingWPA2015_Reportpdf
[Accessed on 272017]
4 State of elderly in India 2014 Help age India Available from URL
httpswwwhelpageindiaorgimagespdfstate-elderly-india-2014pdf [Accessed on
1082017]
5 World Health Organization World report on ageing and health 2015Available
from URL wwwwhointageingeventsworld-report-2015-launchen [Accessed on
1272017]
6 National policy for Senior citizens March 2011Ministry of Social Justice and
welfare Govt of India Available from URL
socialjusticenicinwritereaddataUploadFilednpscpdf [Accessed on 482017]
87
References
7 Elderly in India Profile and programmes 2016Govt of India Ministry of statistics
and programme implementation Central Statistics Office Available from URL
wwwmopsigovin [ Accessed on 1442017]
8 Saxena V Kandpal SD Gael D Bansal S Health status of elderly community
based study Indian Journal of Community Health2012 Oct-Dec24(4)269-74
9 Shah T Patel M Shah V Health care seeking behaviour of urban and rural
community in Ahmedabad district Int J Med Sci Public Health20132908-11
10 Sahoo H Mishra NR Health Status Morbidity Pattern and Treatment Seeking
Behaviour among Elderly in India Evidence from 60th round of National Sample
Survey Data Learning community 2011 Dec 2(3) 341-55
11 Park K Parkrsquos Textbook of Preventive and social medicine 24 th ed Jabalpur MS
Banarsidas Bhanot Publishers2017631
12 UNFPA- state of World Population 2011Chapter 1 setting the scene 19-31
Available from URL httpswwwunfpaorgsitesdefaultfilesresource-
pdfUNFPA-Report-Chapter1pd [Accessed on 1082017]
13 Lal S Adarsh Pankaj Textbook of community Medicine 4th ed CBS publishers and
distributors PvtLtd2011732
14 Census of India 2001 Registrar General And Census Commissioner India
Available from URL httpwwwcensusindiagovinCensus[Accessed on
7102015]
15 SRS bulletin October 2012 Registar General of India New Delhi Available from
URL censusindiagovinvital_statisticsSRS_BulletinsSRS_Bulletin-
October_2012[Acessed on 7102015]
88
References
16 Bagchi K Healthy ageing Health and Population-Perspectives and Issues 2000
23(1)11-16
17 Salagre SB The Association of Physicians of India Chapter 177 Health Issues in
Geriatrics Available from URL
wwwapiindiaorgmedicine_update_2013chap177pd [ Accessed on 282017]
18 Ingle GK Nath A Geriatric Health in India Concerns and Solutions Indian Journal
of Community Medicine 2008 33(4)214-18
19 World Health Organization Active Ageing a policy framework 2002 Available
from httpwhqlibdocwhointhq2002who_nmh_nph_028pdf [Accessed on
1062017]
20 Inche Zainal Abidin S Sutan R Shamsuddin K Prevalence and determinants of
appropriate health seeking behaviour among known diabetics Results from a
community-based survey Advances in Epidemiology 2014 Nov 20141-6
21 Begashaw B Tessema F Gesesew HA Health Care Seeking behavior in Southwest
Ethiopia Plos one 2016 Sep 11(9)e0161014
22 MacKian S Health systems development Manchester University of Manchester
2003 A review of health seeking behavior problems and prospects
23 Metta EO Health-seeking behaviour among adults in the context of the
epidemiological transition in Southeastern Tanzania A focus on malaria and
diabetes [Groningen] University of Groningen 2016 228 Available from URL
httpswwwrugnlresearchportalfiles28737720Chapter_7pdf [Accessed on
1272017]
24 Adhikari D Rijal D Factors affecting health seeking behaviour of senior citizens of
Dharan Journal of Nobel Medical College 2015 Sep 4(1)57-63
25 Polisetty S Seepana M Morbidity profile of elderly individuals in urban
Visakhapatnam Int J Community Med Public Health 2017 4(2)2558-63
89
References
26 Jain S Kaware AC Doibale MK Shaikh S Radhey BK Mathurkar MP Morbidity
pattern among geriatric population in urban field practice area of district of
Maharashtra a cross sectional study Int J Community Med Public Health 2016
3(2)523-29
27 Gupta RD Loha A Roy S Morbidity pattern and health-seeking behaviour among
the senior citizens in a selected urban area of Bangladesh A cross-sectional study
South East Asia Journal of Public Health 2016 Jul 5(2)43-49
28 Naushad MA Verma N Bhawnani D Jain M Anand T Umate LV Morbidity
pattern and health seeking behaviour in elderly population of Raipur City
Chhattisgarh India Indian Journal of Community Health2016 Sep 28(3)236-41
29 Goswami S Sahai M A Study of Morbidity Pattern in Elderly Population European
Researcher Series A 2016103(2)119-28
30 Bardhan H Dixit AM Agarwal R Jain PK Gupta S Shukla SK Morbidity profile
of elderly population in Ghaziabad district a cross-sectional study Int J Med Sci
Public Health 2016 5(6)1098-1102
31 Maroof M Ahmad A Khalique N Ansari MA Health problems among the aged A
community based study from urban Aligarh Uttar Pradesh India Int J Community
Med Public Health 2016 Feb 3(4)944-47
32 Shankar G Sidenur B A morbidity study of elderly residing in urban field practice
area of SN medical college Bagalkot National Journal of research in community
medicine 2016 Oct-Dec 4(5) 229-34
90
References
33 Salunkhe LR Socio-demographic profile of old age people living in urban amp urban
slum areas in Maharashtra Karad A comparative study J of Evidence based Med
and Hlthcare 2015 Feb 2(5) 513-21
34 Warbhe P Rupesh W Morbidity profile health seeking behaviour and home
environment survey for adaptive measures in geriatric population-Urban community
study International Journal of Medical Research amp Health Sciences 2015 4(4)778-
82
35 Gupta M Borle AL Chhari N Gupta S Assessment of clinico-socioeconomic
status and health-care support among the elderly people aged older than 60 years in
urban population of Bhopal Central India Int J Med Sci Public Health 2015
4558-64
36 Sahukaiah S Shenoy A Vijayakumar BC An epidemiological study of prevalence
of morbidity patterns among geriatric age group in an urban slum of Mumbai Int J
Med Sci Public Health 2015 Jul 4(7)883-87
37 Shubha Davalagi B Angadi N Mahabalaraju DK Morbidity psycho-social profile
and health seeking behaviour of the elderly population in urban slums of Davangere
City India Int J Res Med Sci 2015 Nov 3(11)3288-91
38 Nikumb V Patankar F Behera A A Study of Morbidity Profile among Geriatric
Population in an Urban Area Sch J App Med Sci 2015 3(3)1365-69
91
References
39 Vishnoi BR Solanki SL Singhal G Meharda B Mishra N Morbidity profile of
elderly in urban slum of Udaipur Rajasthan Int J Oral Health Med Res 2015 May
2(1)9-12
40 Subedi L Sah RB Study of the health status of geriatric age group in Chitwan
district of Nepal Journal of Chitwan Medical College 2015 Mar 5(1)11-17
41 Noor S Krishnababu G Prasad KV Health status of Geriatric population in slums
of Rourkela Young Innovative Journal of Medical and Health Science 2015 May
5(3) 92-94
42 Sarode VM Chronic Diseases Related to Aging and Disease Prevention in Slums in
Mumbai Journal of Aging Science 2014 Jan 2 (1)1-6
43 Barman SK Lata K Ram R Ghosh N Sarker G Shahnawaz K A study of
morbidity profile of geriatric population in an urban community of Kishanganj
Bihar India Global Journal of Medicine and Public Health GJMEDPH 2014 3(1)
1-7
44 Nagoor K Srikanth BA Dudekula R Satna K Comparative study of health status
among slum and non-slum elderly population in Kadapa Region South India
Journal of Evolution of Medical and Dental Sciences 2014 Feb 3(5)1298-308
45 Kakkar R Aggarwal P Kandpal SD Bansal SK An Epidemiological study to assess
morbidity profile among geriatric population in District Dehradun Indian Journal of
Community Health 2013 May 25(1)39-44
46 Bhawalkar JS Dhone AB Jethani S Singru S Jadhav SL Adyanthaya S A study of
morbidity profile among geriatric population in an urban area J Evol Med Dent Sci
2013 Sep 9 36(2)6963-7
92
References
47 Sharma D Mazta SR Parashar A Morbidity pattern and health-seeking behaviour of
aged population residing in Shimla hills of north India A cross-sectional study
Journal of family medicine and primary care 2013 Apr2(2)188
48 Singh JP Singh S Kasturwar NB Hassan A Geriatric morbidity profile in an urban
slum Central India Indian Journal of Community Health 2013 Aug 25(2)164-70
49 Thakur RP Banerjee A Nikumb VB Health Problems among the Elderly A Cross
Sectional Study Annals of medical and health sciences research 2013 3(1)19-25
50 Mrinal RS Beena S Pratibha G Pankaj B Srivastava JP Atul B Morbidity Status
and Its Social Determinants among Elderly Population of Lucknow District India
Sch J App Med Sci 2013 1(6)758-64
51 Shraddha K Prashantha B Prakash B Study on morbidity pattern among elderly in
urban population of Mysore Karnataka India International Journal of Medicine and
Biomedical Research 2012 1(3)215-23
52 Thomas V Lavanya KM Morbidity profile and health seeking behaviour of the
elderly in urban slums of Hyderabad Andhra Pradesh India- A cross sectional study
International Journal of Current Research and Review 2012 Oct 1 4(19)174-80
53 Moe S Tha K Naing DK Htike MM Health seeking behaviour of elderly in
Myanmar International Journal of Collaborative Research on Internal Medicine and
Public Health 2012 4(8)1538-44
93
References
54 Bharati DR Pal R Rekha R Yamuna TV Kar S Radjou AN Ageing in
Puducherry South India An overview of morbidity profile Journal of pharmacy amp
bio allied sciences 2011 Oct 3(4)537
55 Bhatt R Gadhvi MS Sonaliya KN Solanki A Nayak H An epidemiological study
of the morbidity pattern among the elderly population in Ahmedabad Gujarat
National Journal of community medicine 2011 Jul 2(2)233-36
56 Srinivasan Krishnamachari Vaz Mario Thomas Tinku Prevalence of health related
disability among community dwelling urban elderly from middle socioeconomic
strata in Bangaluru India Indian Journal of Medical Research 2010 Apr 131(4)
515-21
57 Srivastava K Gupta SC Kaushal SK Chaturvedi M Morbidity profile of elderly a
cross sectional study of urban Agra Indian Journal of Community Health 2010 Jun
22(1)51-55
58 Ladha A Khan R Malik A Khan S Khan B Khan I et al The health seeking
behaviour of elderly population in a poor-urban community of Karachi Pakistan
Journal of the Pakistan Medical Association2009 Feb 59(2) 89-92
59 WHO ICD-10 version 2010 Geneva World Health Organization Available from
URL appswhointclassificationsicd10browse2010en [Accessed on 772017]
60 OpenEpi22OpenEpi (free) download Windows version Available from URL
enfreedownloadmanagerorgWindows-PCOpenEpi-FREEhtml
61 Tandon R Sinhota Parsonrsquos disease of the eye 22edNew Delhi Elsevier 98-100
62 Dhingra P L Dhingra S Disease of ear nose and throat and head and neck surgery
6th ed New Delhi Elsevier 201422
94
References
63 Aziz N Kallur SD Nirmalan PK Implications of the revised consensus body mass
indices for Asian Indians on clinical obstetric practice Journal of clinical and
diagnostic research 2014 May 8(5)OC01
64 Chobanion AV Bakris GL Black HR The seventh report of the joint national
committee on prevention detection evaluation and treatment of high blood pressure
the JNC 7 report JAMA 2003 2892560-72
65 The Seventh Report of the Joint National Committee on Prevention Detection
Evaluation and Treatment of High Blood Pressure (JNC 7) The GuidelinesUS
Department of Health and Human Services National Heart Lung and Blood
Institute Available at URL
httpswwwnhlbinihgovfilesdocsguidelinesjnc7fullpdf [ Accessed on
1282017]
66 Firkin F Chestman C Penington D Rush B De Gruchyrsquos clinical Hematology in
medical practice 5th edition New Delhi Blackwell science Ltd1989 32-47
67 Report of WHO consultation Nutritional Anaemias Geneva Switzerland World
Health Organization TRS-405 1968 Available from URL
whqlibdocwhointtrsWHO_TRS_405pdf [Accessed on 1282017]
68 National Family Health survey (NFHS-4) 2015-16 India Mumbai IIPS
2016Available from URL httpwwwnfhsindiaorg [Accessed on 4072017]
69 The Minimum Wages Act 1948 Ministry of Labour and Employment Government
of India Available from URL httplabourgovincontentinnerpagewagesphp
[Accessed on 1082017]
70 Khairnar M Wadgave U Shimpi P Updated BG Prasad socioeconomic
classification for 2016 Journal of Indian Association of Public Health Dentistry
2016 Oct 1 14(4)469
95
References
71 Tiwari P Tiwari S Mastering practicals community medicine 1st ed New Delhi
India Wolters Kluwer PvtLtd2013161-67
72 Boralingaiah P Bettappa P Kashyap S Prevalence of Psycho-Social Problems
among Elderly in Urban Population of Mysore City Karnataka India Indian journal
of psychological medicine 2012 Oct 34(4)360
96
PATIENT CONSENT FORM JJM MEDICAL COLLEGE DAVANGERE
DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY MEDICINE I the undersigned hereby give my consent
for investigations carried upon me I am satisfied with the information given about this
Clinical study titled ldquoA STUDY ON THE MORBIDITY PATTERN AND HEALTH
SEEKING BEHAVIOR AMONG THE GERIATRIC POULATION IN THE
URBAN FIELD PRACTICE AREA OF JJM MEDICAL COLLEGE
DAVANGERErdquo ldquoconducted by Dr RUCHI DHAR under the guidance of Dr VIDYA
GS Associate Professor I have been informed and explained the risks involved and I
hereby voluntarily and Unconditionally give my consent without any fear or pressure in
mentally sound and conscious state to participate in this study
DATE PATIENTrsquoS SIGNATURE
eEacuteeEacuteJA ordfEacuteEcirczAgravearingQAtildeAiAgraveAuml ordfAgraveAumlordmAacutelaquozAacutearingregAiAgraveAuml zAacuteordfAgravetUEacutegEacute
ryenAacutemiumlethordfEacuteAumlAmiumlDyensiumlPAgraveordfAgraveAumlAumlaringcurrenn ordfEacuteAumlrsup1poundiuml
ordfEacuteEcirczAgravearingQAtildeAiAgraveAumlvAgraveyenAacutecedilAgraveuEacuteUEacuteMbrvbaragraveUEacute yenAgravevAgraveaelig F PEacutefrac14AgraveUEacute cedilAgraveraquo ordfAgraveiAacutergAgraveAumlordfAgrave poundAacutepoundAgraveAuml CAzAgravegEacute
poundAgravepoundAgraveszlig
ordfEacuteEcirczAgravearingQAtildeAiAgraveAumlvAgraveyenAacutecedilAgraveuEacute ordmAacuteUAgraveAElig plusmnAgravecedilAgraveUcircccedilaQvEacuteigraveUEacuteAzAgraveAuml poundAgravepoundAgraveszligMbrvbaragraveUEacuteAiAgraveAumlpoundAgraveAumlszlig
cedilAgraveAEligasup1gAgraveAumlvEacuteUcircAtildepoundEacute J cedilAgraveOumlr Dyensiuml zAgrave ordfEacuteAEligcopyethrn yenAacutearinglpoundiumleth CAqiuml ordmEacutemacriumlUcirc sup1AtildeQAUiuml copyordmEacuteAtildelaquoAiAgraveAumlgiuml Dyensiuml zAgrave fjAiAgraveiAacutenaeligPiuml yenEacuteAEligAtildeyenAgraveAumlaringmacrEacuteAtildemicroAgravepoundiuml Epoundiuml zAgrave Csectethpoundiuml brvbarAtildemacriumlOslash yenAacuteaeligoumlaringQOumlAtildecediliuml JjAiAgraveAuml Dyensiuml ddordfAgraveAumlAuml ordfEacuteEcirczAgravearingQAtildeAiAgraveAuml ordfAgraveAumlordmAacutelaquozAacutearingregAiAgraveAuml zAacuteordfAgravetUEacutegEacute JAsect sup2AtildeparaethPEacuteAiAgraveAumlrAiAgraveAumldegegrave yenAgravejAtildePEacuteeumlUEacute Mfrac14AgraveyenAgravercedilAgraveAumlordfAgrave ordfEacuteEcirczAgravearinggAacutezAgrave qAacute|| gAgraveAumla zAgravesAgravegAgrave ordfAgraveAumlvAgraveAumlUcirc qAacute|| laquozAacutearing fJcediliumlordfAgraveiAacuteUAgraveethzAgraveplusmnAgraveethPAgravegAacutezAgrave yenEacuteAEligaeligAtildeyensEacutecedilAgravegiuml
EordfAgravegAgraveAuml poundAgravepoundAgraveUEacute F vAgraveyenAacutecedilAgraveuEacuteUEacute Mfrac14AgraveyenAgraveqAgraveAumlordfAgrave ordfAgraveAumlAumlpoundAgraveszlig yenAgraveaeligwAiEacuteAEligAzAgraveAuml
CAplusmnAgraveUAgravefrac14AgravepoundAgraveAumlszlig CxAgraveethordfAacuteUAgraveAumlordfAgraveAvEacute wfrac12sup1gAgraveAumlvAacuteUcircgEacuteDzAgraveYacutejAzAgrave poundAacutepoundAgraveAuml poundAgravepoundAgraveszlig
ordfAgraveAumlpoundAgravecedilAacutegEacute AiAgraveiAacuteordfAgraveAringzEacuteAtilde umlsAgraveAiAgraveAuml ordfAgraveAumlvAgraveAumlUcirc AiAgraveiAacutegAgrave MvAacuteUcircAiAgraveAumllaquoregegravezEacute poundAacutepoundAgraveAuml
vAgraveyenAacutecedilAgraveuEacute aQvEacuteigraveUEacuteAEligfrac14AgraveyenAgraveqAgraveregAuml MbrvbaragraveUEacuteAiAgraveAumlpoundAgraveAumlszlig cedilAgraveAEligasup1gAgraveAumlvEacuteUcircAtildepoundEacute
centpoundAacuteAPAgrave gEacuteAEligAtildeVAi
Annexures
ANNEXURE ndashIII
104
Annexures
PROFORMA
I General information
1 NAME
2 AGE
3 GENDER (a) Male (b) Female
4 MARITAL STATUS (a) Unmarried (b) Married (c) Widow Widower
(d) Divorced separated
5 LIVING ARRANGEMENT (a) with spouse (b) Spouse and children
(c) Children only (d) living alone (e) others
6 RELIGION (a) Hindu (b) Muslim (c) Christian (d) Others
7 ADDRESS
8 EDUCATION (a) illiterate (b) Primary school (c) higher primary
(d) secondary school (e)PUC diploma (e) Graduate (f) Postgraduate
9 OCCUPATION (a) professional (b) semi- professional (c) skilled worker
(d) Semi ndashskilled worker (e) unskilled worker (f) unemployed
10 CONTACT NUMBER
11 TYPE OF FAMILY (a) Joint (b) Nuclear (C) three generation
12 TOTAL NUMBER OF FAMILY MEMBERS
13 TOTAL FAMILY INCOME
14 PER CAPITA FAMILY INCOME
15 SOCIO ECONOMIC STATUS (Modified BG Prasad classification) I IIIIIIVV
16 DIET (a) Vegetarian (b) Mixed
17 Sleep (a) Disturbed if yes reason ______________ (b) Not disturbed
18 Bowel Regular Irregular
19 Bladder Regular Irregular
97
Annexures
20 HABITS (a) betel nut (b) tobacco (c) alcohol (d) smoking (e) others
If any of the habits present Duration (since when) _________
Frequency of consumption day_______
IIAssessment of morbidity based on history
1 Whether suffering from any chronic illness like (a) Type 2 DM (b) Hypertension
(c) Bronchial Asthma (d) TB (e) others
2 Whether suffering from cataract currently (a) Yes (b) No
3 Whether operated for cataract (a) Yes (b) No If Yes duration since operation____
4 MUSCULOSKELETAL SYSTEM
Whether the following symptoms are present
(a) Backache (b) Joint pain (c) restricted joint movements (d) pain in calves
(e) Others_________
5 RESPIRATORY SYSTEM
(a) Productive cough (b) non-productive cough (c) nasal discharge (d) breathlessness (e)
sore throat (f) sneezing
6 CARDIOVASCULAR SYSTEM
(a) Palpitations (b) chest pain (c) breathlessness
7 GASTROINTESTINAL SYSTEM
(a) Pain abdomen (b) lose stools (c) constipation (d) flatulence (e) heart burn
(f) Bleeding per rectum
8 EYE AND ADNEXA
(a) Watering (b) diminution of vision (c) redness
9 EAR
(a) Discharge (b) decreased hearing (c) Tinnitus
10 SKIN
(a) Itching (b) skin eruptions (c) scaling (d) pigmentation
98
Annexures
11 GENITO URINARY SYSTEM
(a) Burning micturition (b) increased frequency of micturition
12 GENERAL SYMPTOMS
(a) Fatigue (b) headache (c) fever
13 ANY OTHER COMPLAINTS (a) burning feet (b) swelling in groin
(c) Memory loss (d) insomnia
III Assessment of health seeking behaviour
1 Do you visit a health facility in case of illness (a) Yes (b) No
If yes how much time do you take to visit a health facility an case of an illness
(a) Within 24 hours (b) 24-48 hours (c) more than 48 hours
2 Which type of health facility do you visit
(a) Govt hospital (b) Private practitioners (c) over the counter drugs (e) quacks
Mention the reason for visiting the particular health facility______________________
3 Whether taking regular treatment after diagnosis ________________
If No mention the reason_______________________
4 Whether following the instructions given by the treating doctor
(a) Yes (b) no
5 cost of treatment per month in case of chronic disease
(a) lt100 (b) 100-200 (c) 200-300 (d) 300 and above
6 Person bearing the cost of treatment
(a) Self (b) spouse (c) son (d) daughter (d) outside help
7 Duration to reach the health facility
(a) less than 3o minutes (b) 30 minutes or more
8 Whether going for regular check -ups (a) Yes (b) No
If Yes duration between the check-ups_______
99
Annexures
9 Whether following self- care practices in case of chronic disease like diabetes and hypertension
(a) Yes (b) No
10 In case of healthy individuals whether getting screening tests done (a) Yes (b) No
11 Whether following any dietary modifications (a) yes (b) No
12 Whether any family member accompanies you to the health facility
If yes who (a) Son (b) daughter (c) spouse (d) others
11 Whether the family supports in following specific diet advised by the doctor
(a) Yes (b) No
12 whether family members help in reminding to take regular medication
(a) Yes (b) No
IV Physical examination
1 Personal hygiene status
S NO COMPONENT CONDITION REMARKS
1 Hair
2 Teeth
3 Bath
4 Clothes
5 Washing hand before
eating food
6 Washing hands with soap
and water after ablution
7 Nails
8 Foot wear
Remarks personal hygiene status Good fair poor
100
Annexures
2 MEASUREMENTS
(a) Weight (in Kg) ______ (b) Height (in cm) _____ (c) BMI ______
(d) Waist circumference______ (e) Hip circumference ___________
(f) Waist hip ratio_________
3 GENERAL PHYSICAL EXAMINATION
Pallor Icterus Cyanosis clubbing lymphadenopathy Oedema
Pulse rate Temp Blood Pressure
Respiratory rate
20 Examination of
Eye Oral cavity Ear
Nose Throat
SYSTEMIC EXAMINATION
Cardiovascular system Respiratory system
Per abdomen Central Nervous system
101
MASTER CHART
Annexures
ANNEXURES
International Classification of Diseases (10th Revision)
I Certain infectious and parasitic diseases (A00-B99)
II Neoplasms (C00-D48)
III Diseases of blood and blood forming organs and certain disorders
involving the immune mechanisms (D50-D89)
IV Endocrine nutritional and metabolic diseases (E00-E90)
V Mental and behavioural disorders (F00-F99)
VI Diseases of the nervous system (G00-G99)
VII Diseases of the eye and adnexa (H00-H59)
VIII Diseases of the ear and mastoid process ( H60-H95)
IX Diseases of the circulatory system (I00-I99)
X Diseases of the respiratory system ( J00-J99)
XI Diseases of the digestive system (K00-K93)
XII Diseases of the skin and subcutaneous tissue ( L00-L99)
XIII Diseases of the musculoskeletal system and connective tissue
(M00-M99)
XIV Diseases of the genitourinary system ( N00-N99)
XV Pregnancy childbirth and purperium (O00-O99)
XVI Certain conditions originating in perinatal period (P00-P96)
XVII Congenital malformations deformations and chromosomal
XVIII (S00-T98)
XIX External causes of morbidity and mortality (V01-Y98)
102
Annexures
XX Injury poisoning and certain other consequences of external causes
(S00-T98)
XXI Factors influencing health status and contact with health services
(Z00-Z99)
XXII Codes for special purpose
103
Annexures
105
Annexures
106
Annexures
107
Annexures
PHOTOS
Picture 1 Showing the investigator interviewing the study subject
Picture 2 Showing the investigator interacting with the study subject
108
Annexures
Picture 3 Showing the investigator recording the Blood pressure of the study subject
Picture 4 Showing the investigator auscultating the study subject
109
Annexures
110
services It is important to have knowledge regarding the health seeking behaviour of
individuals for designing health care policies and programmes so that all the possible
difficulties with early diagnosis and effective treatment can be identified and appropriate
interventions can be implemented9 As already stated the elderly are a vulnerable group as
there are psychological as well as physiological changes with increasing age and it is
difficult to cope up with the problems of ageing Some of the most common problems in old
age are cardiovascular problems arthritis respiratory problems blood pressure and so on
Therefore the study of the health status of elderly morbid conditions perceptions about
it is important to note and the health care of the elderly becomes very important since they
are more prone to illness than young people and are also more prone to domestic and other
accidents Their health and treatment seeking behaviour are most important for the
formulation of welfare programmes of the country 10
Hence this study was taken up in the urban field practice area of JJM Medical College
Davangere to assess the morbidity pattern and health seeking behaviour of the geriatric
subjects
3
Objectives
OBJECTIVES
1 To study the morbidity pattern among the geriatric population in the urban field
practice area of JJM Medical college Davangere
2 To assess the health seeking behaviour of the elderly residing in the study area
4
Review of literature
vii
REVIEW OF LITERATURE
1 Definition Geriatrics or clinical gerontology Is the term used for the care of the aged 11 The United Nations uses 60 years and above to refer to older people the same is also used
by demographers However in many developed countries the age of 65 is used as the
reference point for older persons 12
Elderly are classified in to 3 groups 13
Young old Persons in the age group of 60 years to 74 years
Old old Persons in the age group of 75 years to 84 years
Oldest old Persons above the age of 85 yrs
2 Demography of the ageing population in India
The UN defines a country as ldquoAgeingrdquo or ldquoGreying Nationrdquo where the
proportion of people over 60 reaches 7 percent to total population By 2011 India has
exceeded that proportion (80 percent) and is expected to reach 126 percent in 2025
The Indian population has increased from 361 million in 1951 to 1027 billion in 2001
and further to 121 billion in 2011 Simultaneously the number of older people has
increased from 19 million (ie 4 percent of total population) to 77 million and
further to roughly 93 million (ie 75 percent of the total) during the same time
span 14
5
Review of literature
Figure1 proportion of elderly in the Indian population by age groups 1961-2001 14
Table 1 Percentage share of elderly population (aged 60 years and above) in total
population by sex in India 15
Years Male Female Total Rural Urban
1961 55 58 56 58 47
1971 59 60 60 62 50
1981 64 66 65 68 54
1991 67 68 68 71 57
2001 71 78 75 77 67
2011 77 84 80 81 79
2004-05 69 75 72 73 70
2007-08 73 77 75 76 72
6
Review of literature
The rise in population of males was more modest from 55 percent to 71 percent while for
females there had been a steep rise from 58 percent to 78 percent during five decadal
Censuses from 1961 to 2001 In 2011 the elderly population accounted for 80 percent of
total population For males it was marginally lower at 77 percent while for females it was
84 percent According to NSSO surveys the proportion of elderly population in rural areas
was 73 percent during 2004-05 and increased up to 76 percent in 2007-08 While on the
other hand in urban areas the proportion of elderly population rose from 70 percent to 72
percent during the corresponding period It has been observed that the percentage share of
elderly to total population remained higher in rural areas than in urban areas15
Table2 Size of elderly population (aged 60+) and their share in total population in major states of India in 201115
All India and selected major states
Proportion of elderly in total population of State
Male Female Total Andhra Pradesh 83 94 88 Bihar 72 67 70 Gujarat 76 90 83 Haryana 66 76 71 Himachal Pradesh 104 103 104 Karnataka 79 89 84 Kerala 118 133 126 Madhya Pradesh 68 74 71 Maharashtra 88 97 93 Orissa 91 95 93 Punjab 91 100 95 Rajasthan 66 79 72 Tamil Nadu 102 109 105 Uttar Pradesh 66 71 68 West Bengal 82 82 82 All India 77 84 80
7
Review of literature
3 MORBIDITY PATTERN AMONG THE ELDERLY
Physiological Decline and Consequences of increasing age
Ageing i s a process of decline in biological functions affecting most physical
Systems The following systems are affected by ageing
(a) Atrophy of the Taste Buds and Loss of Teeth
With the increasing age the taste buds of the tongue get atrophied and as a result the
preference for food alters significantly There is also a considerable loss of teeth causing
difficulties in chewing food
(b) Changes in the Gastrointestinal Tract
As the age advances the walls of the intestine get atrophied and the motility is
markedly reduced (lazy intestine) The digestive enzymes secreted by the intestine are
also reduced Hence the partly digested food stays in the intestine for a longer period
As a result the common complaint of the elderly person is gas formation (flatulence)
and constipation
(c) Respiratory System
As the age advance there is progressive fibrosis of the lungs leading to reduced
oxygenation of the lungs and breathing difficulties
(d) Kidney and genitourinary System
The kidneys get smaller in size and the power of the kidneys to filter out the unwanted
waste products from the body is diminished The total amount of urine becomes less in
old age and thus the waste products are not adequately excreted from the body
8
Review of literature
(e) Urinary Bladder
Urinary bladder gets smaller in size due to shrinkage and as a result the accumulation
of urine even of a small amount leads to an urge for urination With increase in age
the valve in the bladder which controls the exit of urine from the bladder to urethra
gets atrophied and weak Involuntary leakage of urine occurs in case the bladder is full
or due to increase of pressure on bladder on sneezing or even on laughing a condition
known as urinary incontinence Incontinence is a common complaint of elder females
(f) Heart and Circulatory System
The blood vessels get rigid and quite often the vessel walls become rough with the
deposition of solid matters consisting mostly of cholesterol The heart muscles get weaker
and power to send blood throughout the body through the circulatory system gets less and
less powerful The most dangerous effect on heart is coronary heart disease especially
coronary thrombosis
(g) Muscular system
The muscles in the body get gradually atrophied with ageing and especially those
small muscles which are necessary for quick reflex action The elderly person can quite
be capable of working like a normal person and can undertake activities which require
big muscles of legs and arms But when it comes to quick movement which needs small
muscles for quick reflex movements these functions are impaired causing accidents
like slipping on wet floor of the bathroom
(h) Brain
With ageing the size of the brain gets smaller and the weight also becomes less This
however does not interfere with the function of the brain However in general the brain
cells and its fibers which carry impulses from brain to the system and upwards get
9
Review of literature
degenerated The most glaring manifestation of ageing affecting the brain is
forgetfulness and in simple terms it is inability of brain to recall the past experience
However this is common in all elderly persons
(i ) Bones
The bones become porous and fragile as age advances especially in elderly females This
condition is known as osteoporosis and leads to sustaining of fractures even after a minor
fall16
Figure 2 pathophysiology of health issues in geriatrics17
The common disease that the geriatric population suffers from are type 2 diabetes
coronary heart disease hypertension stroke chronic obstructive pulmonary disease
10
Review of literature
Alzheimerrsquos disease osteoarthritis osteoporosis prostatic hypertrophy cataracts macular
degeneration cancer etc and at the same time they are vulnerable to infections involving
respiratory (including TB) urinary and digestive tract17
In India the elderly people suffer from dual medical problems ie communicable and
nonndash communicable diseases There is also impairment of special sensory functions like
vision and hearing A decline in immunity and age-related physiological changes leads to
an increased burden of communicable diseases in the elderly A report by Indian Council
of Medical Research (ICMR) on the chronic morbidity profile in the elderly states that
hearing impairment is the most common morbidity followed by visual impairment
However different studies show varied results in the morbidity pattern18
Major chronic conditions affecting older people worldwide 19
Cardiovascular diseases (such as coronary heart disease) Diabetes Mellitus
Hypertension Stroke Cancer
Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease
Musculoskeletal conditions (such as arthritis and osteoporosis)
Mental health conditions (mostly dementia and depression)
Blindness and visual impairment
11
Review of literature
Health seeking behaviour
1 Definition
There is no common definition agreed upon by sociologists in any sociology literature
Different definitions may be used in different studies despite referring to the same activity
Sociology and literature assume that health seeking behaviour is influenced by the various
factors which include individual self or the individual diseases present and also the
availability and accessibility of health services Being dependent on these determinants and
their interactions it can be said that health care seeking behaviour is a very complex
outcome of various factors which operate at individual family and community level20
Health Seeking Behavior (HSB) refers to decision or an action taken by an individual to
maintain attain or regain good health and to prevent illness The decisions which are
made encompasses all available health care options like visiting a public or private and
modern or traditional health facility self-medication and use of home remedies or not to
utilize the available health services etc
Determining the health care seeking behavior is very important to provide a need
based health care services to the population Visiting official channels in a formally
recognized health care system has been considered as the desired Health seeking behaviour
Health seeking behavior is influenced by multiple factors including availability quality and
price of services and also social groups health views residences and personal features of the
users Peoplersquos choice of health care differs in socio demographic socio-economic and
cultural compositions and this has an effect on their health seeking behavior Urban dwellers
are generally believed to be open to new ideas and willing to try certain things on a trial and
error basis21
12
Review of literature
Health seeking behaviours two approaches
(a) Health seeking behaviours utilization of the system
This approach focuses on the actions which are taken to rectify perceived ill health and
the type of health care facility which is utilized by the people There is data which
suggests that the people visit more traditional healers and unofficial medical channels
this should be prevented and the emphasis s h o u l d b e on encouraging people to opt
first for the official channels
(b) Health seeking behaviours the process of illness response
This approach considers the factors which enable or prevent people from making
healthy choices either i n their lifestyle behaviours or use of medical care and
treatment22
Figure 3 Predicting health behaviour with social cognition models 22
13
Review of literature
2 Health belief Model of health seeking behaviour
Since lsquoHealth seekingrsquo is a conditioned behaviour any attempt which is made to
encourage people to seek health care definitely requires an understanding of their
motivation for such behaviour Only through a deeper understanding of the intricate
factors shaping behavioural practices can health promotion programmes and or
interventions successfully be introduced into the realities of the peoplersquos lives to bring
about changes in health behaviour
Behaviour change theories and models such as the Health Belief Model (HBM)
Theory of Reasoned Action (TRA) Theory of Planned Behaviour (TPB) and the
Trans theoretical model have been widely applied in public health in an attempt to
explain or predict health seeking behaviours Their use enables identification and
understanding of peoplersquos health-seeking behaviour beyond their knowledge attitudes
and practices
HBM is a health specific behavioural cognitive model This model is based on the
idea that people are more likely to change their behaviour and adhere to treatments
if they have the following perceptions (i) have a perception that they are at risk of
contracting the disease (perceived susceptibility) (ii) perception that the disease
might have an unfavorable outcome (perceived severity) (iii) perceive that the
proposed health behaviour to be both effective and practical (perceived benefits)
(iv) perceive the barriers to adopting the behaviour to be minimal (perceived
barriers)(v) perceive themselves to have the ability of applying and practicing the
specific behaviour proposed (perceived self-efficacy) and (vi) they have the cues
for motivating their actions such as internal cues (pain symptoms past experiences)
or external cues (advice from friends relatives and mass media campaigns) (cues to
14
Review of literature
action) The specificity of the HBM to health has made it suitable for use in
understanding and explaining the behaviour as well as health outcomes and this may also
explain its wider use in public health2 3
Figure 4 Health belief model components and linkages 23
3 Factors influencing health seeking behaviour
The factors affecting the health seeking behaviours are seen in various contexts which
include physical socio-economic cultural and political factors Therefore the utilization of
a health care system whether public or private formal or non- formal may depend on socio-
demographic factors social structures level of education cultural beliefs and practices and
some other factors like gender discrimination status of women economic and political
systems environmental conditions and the disease pattern and health care system itself also
have an impact on the health seeking behaviour24
15
Review of literature
REVIEW OF RELATED STUDIES
A study done by Sanjay Polisetty and Madhavi Seepana (2017) on the morbidity profile
of elderly individuals in urban Visakhapatnam revealed that of the 270 study participants
about 996 suffered from either some form of acute or chronic morbidity More than 70
of individuals suffered from eye problems of which most common problem was cataract
seen in 60 About 304 had difficulties in chewing and 256 had difficulty in hearing
Hypertension was present in 49 of individuals and 742 of Diabetics were also found to
be hypertensive25
A study done by Swapnil Jain et al (2016) on Morbidity pattern among geriatric
population in urban field practice area of a district in Maharashtra revealed 653 suffered
from hearing impairment 62 were anemic 462 had hypertension 423 had joint
pain 41 had dental problems 38 7 had cataract and 318 had chronic bronchitis It
was seen that 81 of the subjects had multiple morbidities 26
A study done by Rajat Das Gupta et al (2016) in an urban area of Bangladesh on Morbidity
pattern and health-seeking behavior among the senior citizens revealed that of the 384 study
participants 968 were suffering from at least one medical problem The commonest was
musculoskeletal problems in 8411 followed by eye problems in 8125 It was found that
all the respondents sought treatment for their health problems 33 respondents went to
Government hospitals to seek medical help 6927 respondents took prescribed
medications and 567 were satisfied with their treatment 27
16
Review of literature
A study done by Md Alam Naushad et al (2016) on Morbidity pattern and health
seeking behavior in elderly population of Raipur City Chhattisgarh revealed that the
prevalence of morbidity among elderly was 9531 Out of total morbid population some
chronic illness was present in 7049 Gastro intestinal system was involved in 8262
followed by eye in 7983 and Cardiovascular system in 5245 It was found that 3552
of the subjects sought treatment from private registered practitioners 28
A study done by Sribas Goswami and Manjari Sahai (2016) in Raipur city on Morbidity
Pattern in elderly Population revealed that out of total study population of 640 elderly
subjects 610 (9531) suffered from some morbidity Prevalence among females was
9892 whereas among males it was 9026 Out of various agencies 3552 subjects
were utilizing private facility followed by 2785 who were utilizing Government agency
2631 visited quacks and 1030 were taking treatment from other source 29
A study done by Harsh Bardhan et al (2016) on the Morbidity profile of elderly population
in Ghaziabad district revealed that in geriatric population 5008 suffered from
musculoskeletal problems 5877 had dental problems and impairment of vision was seen
in 5561 The overall prevalence of diabetes and heart disease were 10 and 122
respectively 236 subjects reported the problem of loneliness and depression
forgetfulness was also reported by 3296 As far as treatment seeking behavior is
concerned approach of elderly is quite different for different morbidities The main source
of treatment for morbidities such as hypertension respiratory urinary GIT-related and
musculoskeletal problems was quacks 30
17
Review of literature
A study done by Mohammad Maharoof et al (2016) on the health problems among
the aged in Urban Aligarh UP revealed that of the 225 study subjects 782 had cataract
followed by depression in 356 refractive error in 276 loco-motor problem in 213
and hearing loss in 138 The prevalence of hearing loss was significantly related to gender
as it was higher among females with 181 compared to males in whom it was 6931
A study done by Gowri Shankar and Bhayalaxmi Sidenur (2016) on morbidity of
elderly residing in an urban area of Bagalkot revealed that the most common morbidity was
Cataract seen in 2875 followed by musculoskeletal problems in 2813 and 2313
were known hypertensive Both diabetes mellitus and hypertension was observed in 10 of
the study subjects32
A study done by Leena Rahul Salunkhe (2015) on socio-demographic profile of old
age people living in urban amp urban slum areas in Maharashtra Karad revealed that 504
and 42 elderly suffered from arthritis in an urban area and a slum respectively Number of
diabetics were higher in urban (14) than urban slum (35) 301 of subjects from urban
area suffered from hypertension compared to 161 from urban slums Upper Respiratory
Infections was more in slum dwellers (196) than people residing in urban area (7) Acid
peptic diseases were found in 168 study subjects in urban area and 154 in slum area 33
In a study done by Warbhe Priyanka A and Warbhe Rupesh (2015) on morbidity
profile health seeking behaviour and home environment survey of the elderly in an urban
slum community it was found that 941 had 1-3 morbidities 41 had 4-6 morbidities
373 gave a history of fall and 314 had history of fracture 136 subjects had been
18
Review of literature
operated for cataract 168 had undergone a procedure for fracture and10 had undergone
a dental procedure 542 went to Urban health center (UHC) and Government hospitals for
treatment and 786 received both allopathic and Ayurvedic treatment34
A study done by Man Mohan Gupta et al (2015) on Assessment of Clinico-
socioeconomic status and health-care support among the elderly people aged older than 60
years in urban population of Bhopal revealed that 353 subjects received treatment for
their morbidities from the Government hospitals whereas 267 from private
clinichospital About 653 study subjects presented with complaints and morbidity The
common morbidities which were found in the subjects were fatigue (487) backache
(353) Obesity (393) and hypertension (247)35
In a study done by Shilpa Shaukaiah et al (2015) on prevalence of morbidity pattern
among geriatric age group in an urban slum of Mumbai it was found that body ache was the
most commonly reported symptom by 290 followed by visual problems in 2318 joint
pain in 2181 indigestion in 2045 and backache in 2045 subjects36
A study done by Shubha Davalagi B et al (2015) on morbidity psycho-social profile and
health seeking behavior of the elderly population in urban slums of Davangere City revealed
that the most common morbidity which was present in the study subjects was
musculoskeletal problems in 46 psychosocial problems were present in 31 and
respiratory problems in 23 Majority of the elderly (56) utilized government
institutions for treatment of chronic disease and 47 for treatment of acute disease The
elderly population had financial constraints and lack of accessibility in seeking health care37
19
Review of literature
A study done by Vandana Nikumb et al ( 2015) on morbidity Profile among Geriatric
Population in an Urban Area of Navi Mumbai revealed that 9312 elderly were morbid and
with increasing age the number of morbidities was found to be increasing In this study it
was found that the most common morbidity was psychosocial problems which include
stress which was present in 594 subjects followed by musculoskeletal problems in
556 and eye problems like diminished vision mostly due to cataract in 463
Hypertension dental problems respiratory problems ENT problems (hearing impairment)
and endocrine disorders like diabetes accounted for 281 219 119 106 and10
respectively38
A study done by Vishnoi BR et al (2015) on Morbidity Profile of Elderly in Urban
Slum of Udaipur Rajasthan revealed that 61 of the study subjects had impaired vision
followed by 25 who had hypertension 1533 suffered from insomnia 1467 had
anemia and 14 suffered from gastrointestinal problems The condition of females was
worse compared to males39
In a study done by L Subedhi and RB Sah (2015) on the health status of geriatric age
group in Chitwan district of Nepal it was found that of the 300 study subjects 44 had
Ophthalmic problems 43 had GIT problems 33 had CVS problems 23 had ENT
problems 1567 had metabolic disorders and 533 had mental disorders The study
highlighted a high prevalence of morbidity and health related problems in the geriatric age
group40
20
Review of literature
A study done by Sofia Noor et al (2015) on health status of geriatric population in slums
of Rourkela revealed that the morbidities among the elderly that were found to be significant
were hypertension decreased visual acuity urinary problems and insomnia Apart from
systemic morbidities 91 of the elderly also complained of fragility which includes
complex physiological deterioration and unexplained weight loss41
In a study conducted by VM Sarode (2014) on Chronic Diseases Related to Ageing and
Disease Prevention in Slums in Mumbai it was found that there were highly significant
disorders among aged women related to Skin lesion and super infection Untreated bacterial
pharyngitis acute rheumatic fever while disorders among aged men were related to
hypertension Illicit drug use diabetes and asthma It was found that 49 of elderly males
and 45 of elderly females had not sought any treatment for their illness Of the people who
had sought treatment 93 elderly males and 92 of elderly females had taken treatment
from Government hospital42
A study conducted by Sanjeev Kumar Barman et al (2014) on morbidity profile of
geriatric population in an urban slum of Kishnganj Bihar revealed that the prevalence of
anemia cataract and hypertension were quite high 6375 6125 and 5063
respectively Loss of income amp occupation along with a feeling of neglect from the family
members were the common problems among the elderly It was also found that morbidities
like arthritis loss of teeth amp dental caries along with depression had a significant association
with sex age amp educational status of the study subjects43
21
Review of literature
A study done by Khadervali Nagoor et al (2014) on the health status of elderly
population in an urban area of Kadapa revealed that out of the 200 elderly persons studied
Visual problem due to cataract and refractive errors were present in 72 of the study
subjects followed by pain in joints in 595 gastrointestinal problems in 46 and dental
problems in 44 Other morbidities were hypertension in 42 genitourinary problems in
25 dermatological problems in 235 and psychological problems in 1644
A study done by Kakkar R et al (2013) on morbidity profile among geriatric population
in District Dehradun revealed that the working geriatric group was healthy as compared to
those who were retired Hypertension was the commonest morbidity among all age groups
In the age group of 60-70 years the following morbidities were seen hypertension (306)
followed by diabetes (153) arthritis (14) CVS morbidities (14) cataract (96) and
BPH (83) Among 71-80 years age group Hypertension (287) followed by arthritis
(167) cataract (157) Diabetes (111) BPH (111) and CVS morbidities (93)45
In a study done by Bhawalkar JS et al (2013) on morbidity profile among geriatric
population in an urban area of Pune it was found that Musculoskeletal disorder was the
most common (4331) followed by eye problems (3722) and hypertension (137)It
was seen that 43 elderly population had some health problem but only 8 visited the
health facilities Among them 6 visited private practitioners and only 18 went to
municipal hospitals It was found that only 2322 elderly were taking any medications and
the most commonly used drug was anti-inflammatory drugs 2323 followed by
antihypertensive drugs 136746
22
Review of literature
A study conducted by Deepak Sharma et al (2013) on morbidity pattern and health-
seeking behavior of aged population residing in Shimla revealed that the following
morbidities were present in the study subjects hypertension was the commonest (56)
followed by Musculoskeletal problems (535) Dental problems (27) cataract (23)
anemia (15) and acid peptic disease (175) 658 of the subjects were seeking
treatment for their health problems Majority of the older people preferred allopathic
medicine (812) followed by Ayurvedic medicines (113) and homeopathic medicine
(73) for their health problems Most of the older persons preferred going to a
CHCGovernment hospital for treatment for their illness There was considerable use of
over-the-counter drug by125 of the people 47
A study done by JP Singh et al (2013) on Geriatric morbidity profile in an urban slum of
Nagpur central India revealed that the most common morbidity identified in the study
population was anemia (9650) followed by hypertension (345) arthritis (3225)
cataract (21) and diabetes (1775) More than 2 morbidities were present in 325 of
the study subjects followed by four morbidities in 3125 and two morbidities in 23548
A study conducted by RP Thakur et al (2013) on the health problems of the elderly in
central India revealed that among the elderly residing in the urban areas 384 of the urban
elderly had both dental problems and arthritis followed by anemia in 348 hypertension in
266 cataract in 252 and diabetes mellitus in 157 The prevalence of self-reported
depression was 672 among the urban female elderly when compared to 397 among the
urban females49
23
Review of literature
A study done by Mrinal Ranjan Srivastav et al (2013) on Morbidity Status and its
Social determinants among elderly population of Lucknow revealed that the most common
morbidity among the urban population was eye problems which affected 516 males and
67 females followed by CVS problems in 363 males and 395 females and GIT
problems in 315males and 382 females50
A study done by Shraddha K et al (2012) on morbidity pattern among elderly in urban
population of Mysore revealed that out of the 526 study subjects 486 suffered from the
disease of the eye and adnexa followed by 384 who suffered from endocrine and
metabolic disorders 331 suffered from the disease of the circulatory system 323 had
disease of the oral cavity and salivary glands and 302 had disease of the musculoskeletal
system 51
A study done by Vimala Thomas et al (2012) on morbidity profile and health seeking
behaviour of the elderly in urban slums of Hyderabad revealed that hypertension was the
most common morbidity in 469 followed by Arthritis in 302 Diabetes in 265
respiratory problems in 243 and Cataract in 21 For out-patient treatment 472 visited
private sectors 303 Government facility 25 RMP and 06 AYUSH clinics For in-
patient treatment 198 visited private institutions 16 visited Government institutions
while 642 did not visit either52
24
Review of literature
A study done by Soe Moe et al (2012) on health seeking behaviour of elderly in
Myanmar revealed that 35 of the male elderly perceived that they were having good
health status whereas 229 of them perceived having a poor health status 343 of female
elderly perceived that they were having good health status while 24 of them perceived
having a poor health About 49 of the elderly went to rural health center for treatment
followed by 33 who went to private practitioners 15 visited hospitals and 3 went to
more than one place for treatment53
A study done by Dharamvir Ranjan Bharati et al (2011) in Puducherry revealed that in
the urban areas about 707 of the study subjects had anemia followed by 537 who had
visual impairment and hypertension and 532 suffered from diabetes mellitus It was seen
that On univariate analysis the risk of diabetes mellitus was significantly higher among
elderly from urban areas than that among elderly from rural areas and significantly lower
risk in elderly from below poverty line than in those belonging to normal (not below poverty
line)54
A study done by Rajashree Bhat et al (2011) on the morbidity pattern among the elderly
population in Ahmedabad revealed that most common morbidity of elderly was the
problems of loco-motor system (486) followed by vision (427) and hypertension
(344) In this study only 37 of elderly had psychosocial problems55
A study done by Krishnamachari Srinivasan et al (2010) in an urban area of Bangalore
revealed that 494 subjects had hypertension 323 had diabetes 281 had arthritis
279 suffered from Genitourinary and cardiovascular disease It was observed that about
25
Review of literature
49 of the respondents made less than three physician visits and 13 were hospitalized for
health related problems during the past one year 56
A study done by Kajal Srivastava et al (2010) on the morbidity pattern of the elderly in
urban Agra revealed that 9529 of the elderly were morbid in the slum areas The most
common morbidity which was seen among the elderly people residing in urban slums was
anemia which was seen in 3843 followed by cataract in 298 arthritis in 2431 and
hearing impairments in 2157The system wise distribution of the morbidity pattern
showed the most common systemic involvement was visual disorders 5216 followed by
musculoskeletal system 4784 and the gastrointestinal system 4314 The number of
morbidities was found to be increasing with age and this association with age was
statistically significant57
A study done by Abdullah Ladha et al (2009) on the health seeking behaviour of elderly
population in a poor-urban community of Karachi Pakistan revealed that 164 of the
elderly people were Diabetic and 301 had Hypertension The Common symptoms that
prompted elderly of to seek health care were fever (612) generalized body aches (434)
and cough (404) About 614 responders reported factors which deterred them from
seeking health care out of which 62 reported financial constraint as the commonest factor
Deterrence from seeking health care was associated with illiteracy and living alone58
26
Methodology METHODOLOGY
The study was conducted in the urban field practice area of JJM Medical college
Davangere The city of Davangere is situated in the central part of Karnataka state
265 km north of the state capital Bengaluru along the national highway number 4
Figure 5 Maps showing the location of Davangere district and the area where the
UHTC is located
27
Methodology
Figure 6 Map showing the Urban field practice area of JJM medical college
28
Methodology
Table 3 List of areas covered under the UHTC of JJM Medical
College Davangere
Areas covered Total population Bethur road 1374 Hedge nagar 1213 Mehboob nagar 3042 Mustafa nagar A 2093 B D layout A 1084 Mustafa nagar B 1127 Mahavir nagar 930 Muddabovi colony 1094 Maganhalli 1221 Tippu nagar 968 B D layout B 1717 Batti layout 1080
STUDY AREA The study was conducted in the urban field practice area of JJM
Medical College Davangere which consists of 12 areas with a total population of
16943
STUDY DESIGN Cross sectional study
STUDY POPULATION Persons aged 60 years and above
Total Population Covered 16943
29
Methodology
INCLUSION CRITERIA subjects aged 60 years and above living in the study area
for more than one year duration
EXCLUSION CRITERIA Subjects who we r e no t w i l l i ng t o pa r t i c ipa t e i n
t he s t udy
STUDY PERIOD 1 year from 1st December 2015 to 30th November 2016
SAMPLE SIZE As quoted by Manmohan Gupta et al 35 in the studies done in various
parts of India the prevalence of morbidity in the geriatric population ranges from 31-80
Considering the prevalence of morbidity to be about 50 in the geriatric population at 95
confidence level and allowable error of 10 and a non -response rate of 10 sample size
was calculated to be 440 using the formula
n=4pq L2
n= sample size
4= factor to achieve 95 level of confidence
p= prevalence of morbidities ie 50
q= 100- p ie 100-50 = 50
L= permissible error in the estimate of ldquoprdquo (10 of p)
n = 4 x 50 x 50 = 400
5 x 5
After calculating a non-response rate of 10 a sample size of 440 was calculated
30
Methodology
A community based cross sectional study was conducted in the urban field practice
area of JJM Medical College Davangere The Urban field practice area has a total
population of 16943 and there are 12 areas in urban field practice area of JJM Medical
College Davangere
The Study was conducted by probability proportionate sampling The sample size for each
area was derived from the formula
1198991 =119875119900119901119906119897119886119905119894119900119899 119894119899 119890119886119888ℎ 119886119903119890119886
119879119900119905119886119897 119875119900119901119906119897119886119905119894119900119899119883 119878119886119898119901119897119890 119878119894119911119890
Example 1st area has a population of 1374 so
1198991 =1374
16943119883 440 = 36
Therefore 36 elderly subjects were selected by house to house visit from 1st area Same
procedure was applied for other areas until the desired sample size of 440 was reached
MATERIALS USED FOR DATA COLLECTION
The following tools were used for data collection
Semi-structured predesigned and pre-tested questionnaire
Portable bathroom weighing machine
Stretch- resistant measuring tape
Mercury Sphygmomanometer
Others - stethoscope torch tuning fork knee hammer
ICD-10 for system wise classification of disease59
31
Methodology METHOD OF COLLECTION OF DATA After establishing rapport with the family
and explaining the data collection procedure in the local language an informed verbal
consent was obtained from each individual and data was collected using a
Predesigned semi structured questionnaire by Interview method The questionnaire
comprised of the following information socio-demographic data of the study subjects
information regarding the morbidity pattern and health seeking behaviour If there were
more than one elderly subjects in the same household then all were included
The study subjects were asked about any ho illness (communicable or non-
communicable) which they were suffering from Upon a positive response the subjects were
further asked to specify the type(s) and duration of morbidities that they were suffering
from eg heart disease diabetes gastrointestinal diseases respiratory disease etc Some
were unable to understand or answer questions due to illness In such cases help was sought
from the family members Based on the self-reported symptoms information from
hospital records and clinical examination the prevalence of different morbidities among the
study subjects was assessed The Information about the health seeking behaviour was
sought by asking the study subjects about their visits to a health facility in case of an illness
and also the type of health facility visited ( Government private or quacks )
DATA ENTRY AND ANALYSIS Data was entered and analyzed using MS Excel and
Open Epi Info version 2260 Both descriptive and inferential statistics were used Subjectrsquos
baseline characteristics were presented as frequencies and percentages Categorical
variables between the groups were compared using Chi square test and Fisherrsquos exact
test Fisherrsquos exact test was used when more than 20 cells had expected value lt 5 and any
one of the cells had expected value lt 1 All statistical analysis was carried out at 5 level
of significance and p value lt005 was considered as significant
32
Methodology ETHICAL CLEARANCE
Ethical clearance was obtained before conducting the study from the Ethical Committee of
JJM Medical college Davangere [ANNEXURE III] During the study verbal
informed consent was taken from the study subjects Assurance was given that the
confidentiality concerning their information will be maintained
Clinical Examination included
(a) General physical examination
(b) Anthropometric measurements like height and weight
(c) Systemic examination
(d) Measurement of Blood pressure
(e) Eye examination by torch and Snellenrsquos (E chart)61
(f) Hearing assessment by Rinnersquos test Webberlsquos and Absolute bone conduction
test using tuning fork 62
Parameters used in our study
Height Height was measured with a standard non-stretchable measuring tape to the
nearest 01 cm in standing position (without footwear standing upright with the
back against the wall heels together and eyes directed forward)
33
Methodology Weight Weight was measured with minimal clothing and respecting the modesty of the
individual without footwear using a calibrated standard bathroom weighing scale to the
nearest 05 kg
Body Mass Index (BMI) Using weight (in Kg) and height (in meter2) BMI was calculated by applying the formula
Body Mass Index= Weight (kg) Height (m2)
The BMI cut off values for Asians as recommended by the WHO was used in our study
Table 4 WHO Categorization of Body Mass index (BMI) for Asians 63
Measurement of Blood pressure Procedure Blood pressure was measured in the left arm in a sitting posture with the subject in a
relaxed state Standardized mercury sphygmomanometer with adult size cuff was used
The first appearance of (phase 1 of Korotkoff sounds) sound was used to define
Systolic Blood Pressure (SBP) The disappearance of sound (phase 5) was used to
define Diastolic Blood Pressure (DBP) Two readings were taken five minutes apart and
the average of the two readings was taken as the final blood pressure reading A person
was considered to be a hypertensive if he she was already diagnosed case of
hypertension and or on treatment or with a current SBP of ge 140 mm Hg or DBP ge 90 mm
Hg (JNC VII criteria)64
BODY MASS INDEX INFERENCE
lt 185 underweight
185 to 229 kg m2 Normal
23 to 249 kg m2 Overweight
ge 25 kg m2 Obese
34
Methodology
Table 5 JNC VII Classification of Blood pressure 65
BP Classification Systolic Blood Pressure Diastolic Blood Pressure
Normal lt120 lt 80
Pre Hypertension 120 ndash 139 or 80 ndash 89 Stage 1 Hypertension 140 ndash 159 or 90 ndash 99 Stage 2 Hypertension ge 160 or ge 100
Anaemia was detected by pallor of conjunctiva tongue and nails and was confirmed by
doing haemoglobin estimation using sahlirsquos hemogobinometer66
The cut off for the diagnosis of anaemia was done based on WHO classification67
Diabetes - self reported cases of diabetes were considered as diabetics for the study
STUDY VARIABLES
1 AGE - subjects aged 60 years and above were taken up for the study Age was
recorded to the nearest complete years as stated by the respondent
2 GENDER Both males and females were taken up for the study
3 EDUCATIONAL STATUS 68
i Illiterate -A person who could not read or write
ii Primary School - studied up to 4th standard
iii Higher primary- studied between 5th and 7th standard
iv Secondary school -studied between 8th and 10th standard v Intermediate- studied between 11th or 12 th standard or diploma
vi Graduate - obtained graduate degree
vii Post Graduate- obtained post graduate degree
35
Methodology
4 OCCUPATION STATUS69
i Unskilled worker
Labourer domestic servants casual worker peon sweeper porter washer-man others
(vegetable vendor)
ii Semi-skilled worker
Factory worker agriculture laborers shoemaker potters others (security guard shop
helper canteen helper
iii Skilled
Artisan clerk foreman supervisor carpenter tailor mechanic electrician railway guard
painter modeler smiths baker driver shop assistant petty trader constable soldier
linesman pointsman potter barber others (tinkering printer receptionist salesman
welder cook mason postman plumber agarbatti worker)
iv semi-professional
Teacher pharmacist social worker owner of a small business farmer others (computer
programmer Govt employee nurse)
V Professional
Doctor engineer principal lawyer Military officer senior executive business
proprietor writer scientist large employer director university professor police
officer others (horse rider)
(vi) Unemployed Presently not working retired homemakers
36
Methodology 5 SOCIO ECONOMIC STATUS
Table 6 Socio-economic status (SES)- As per modified BG Prasad Classification70
5 TYPE OF FAMILY 71
Joint Family ndash It is type of family grouping in which a number of married couples and
their children live together in the same household All the men are related by blood
and women of household are their wives unmarried girls and widows of family kinsmen
Nuclear Family - It consist of married couple and their children while they are still
regarded as dependents
Three generation family - It is a family where representatives of three generation are
living together Young married couples continue to stay with their parents and have
their own children as well
Socio-economic
status
Prasadrsquos classification
1961(Per capita income in
Rupees per month)
Modified BG Prasad classification-
updated for May 2016 ((per
capita income in Rupees per
month)
I 100 and above 6261 and above
II 50-99 3099-6260
III 30-49 1835-3098
IV 15-29 949-1834
V Below 15 lt948
37
SAMPLE SIZE ESTIMATION
SAMPLE SIZE As quoted by Manmohan Gupta et al 35 in the studies done in various
parts of India the prevalence of morbidity in the geriatric population ranges from 31-80
Considering the prevalence of morbidity to be about 50 in the geriatric population at 95
confidence level and allowable error of 10 and a non -response rate of 10 sample size
was calculated to be 440 using the formula
n=4pq L2
n= sample size
4= factor to achieve 95 level of confidence
p= prevalence of morbidities ie 50
q= 100- p ie 100-50 = 50
L= permissible error in the estimate of ldquoprdquo (10 of p)
n = 4 x 50 x 50 = 400
5 x 5
After calculating a non-response rate of 10 a sample size of 440 was calculated
A community based cross sectional study was conducted in the urban field practice area of
JJM Medical College Davangere The Urban field practice area has a total population of
16943 and there are 12 areas in urban field practice area of JJM Medical College
Davangere
The Study was conducted by probability proportionate sampling The sample size for each area
was derived from the formula
1198991 =119875119900119901119906119897119886119905119894119900119899 119894119899 119890119886119888ℎ 119886119903119890119886
119879119900119905119886119897 119875119900119901119906119897119886119905119894119900119899119883 119878119886119898119901119897119890 119878119894119911119890
Example 1st area has a population of 1374 so
1198991 =1374
16943119883 440 = 36
Therefore 36 elderly subjects were selected by house to house visit from 1st area Same
procedure was applied for other areas until the desired sample size of 440 was reached
Results
RESULTS
The results are presented under the following headings
I Socio-demographic characteristics of study subjects
II Prevalence of morbidities among the study subjects
III Details of health seeking behavior of the study subjects
38
Results
ISocio-demographic characteristics of the study subjects
Table 7 Age and sex wise distribution of the study subjects
Figure 7 Age and sex wise distribution of the study subjects
In the present study Out of 440 study subjects majority 162(368) were in the age group
of 60-64 Years followed by 109 (247) in the age group of 65-69 Years 99 (225) were
in the age group of 70-74 Years and 35 (8) were more than or equal to 80 years of age
Majority of the subjects were males 260 (59) and 180 (41) were females The mean age
of the study population was 6745 plusmn 655 Years
354 254 262
88 42
389
239 172
67 133
0102030405060708090
100
60-64 65-69 70-74 75-79 ge80
Perc
enta
ge
Age in years
Males
Females
Age group (in years)
Males Females Total
Percentage () Frequency
(n=260) Percentage ()
Frequency (n=180)
Percentage ()
60-64 92 354 70 389 162 368
65-69 66 254 43 239 109 247
70-74 68 262 31 172 99 225
75-79 23 88 12 67 35 80
ge80 11 42 24 133 35 80
Total 260 100 180 100 440 100
39
Results
Table 8 Distribution of the study subjects based on religion
Religion Frequency (n=440) Percentage ()
Hindu 188 427
Muslim 252 573
Total 440 100
Figure 8 Distribution of the study subjects based on religion
In the present study it was found that the majority of the study subject belonged to Muslim
religion 252 (573) followed by Hindus 188 (427)
0102030405060708090
100
Hindu Muslim
427
573
Perc
enta
ge
Religion of the study subjects
40
Results
Table 9 Distribution of the study subjects based on Educational status
Education Frequency (n=440) Percentage ()
Illiterate 231 525
Primary school 121 275
Higher primary 38 86
Secondary School 30 68
Intermediate 6 14
Graduate 14 32
Total 440 100
Figure 9 Distribution of the study subjects based on Educational status
In the present study it was found that the Majority of the study subjects were illiterate
231(525) 121(275) had completed education up to primary school 30(68) had
completed education up to secondary school and only 14(32) were graduates
525
275
86 68
14 32
0102030405060708090
100
Perc
enta
ge
Educational status of study subjects
41
Results Table 10 Distribution of the study subjects based on occupation
Occupation Frequency (n=440) Percentage ()
Semi-professional 2 05
Skilled worker 45 102
Semi-skilled worker 68 155
Unskilled worker 100 227
Unemployed 225 511
Total 440 100
Figure 10 Distribution of study subjects based on their occupation
In our study it was found that the majority of the study subjects 225 (511) were
unemployed followed by 100 (227) who were unskilled workers 68 (155) were semi-
skilled workers and 45 (102) were skilled workers
0102030405060708090
100
05 102 155 227
511
Perc
enta
ge
Occupation of the study subjects
42
Results Table 11 Distribution of the study subjects based on socio-economic status (Modified
BG Prasad classification 2016)
Figure 11 Distribution of the study subjects based on their socio-economic status
In our study majority of the subjects 215 (49) belonged to Class IV Socioeconomic status
followed by 115 (26) who belonged to class III and 56 (13) who belonged to class II
SES (according to Modified BG Prasad Classification 2016)
Class II 13
Class III 26
Class IV 49
Class V 12
Socio-economic status Frequency (n=440) Percentage ()
Class I 0 0
Class II 56 13
Class III 115 26
Class IV 215 49
Class V 54 12
Total 440 100
43
Results
Table 12 Distribution of the study subjects based on their marital status
Marital status Frequency (n=440) Percentage ()
Unmarried 2 05
Married 323 734
Widowwidower 115 261
Total 440 100
Figure 12 Distribution of the study subjects based on their marital status
In our study it was found that majority of the study subjects 323(734) were married
followed by 115(261) who were widowed and only 2 (05) were unmarried
0102030405060708090
100
Unmarried married Widowwidower
05
734
261 Perc
enta
ge
44
Results
Table 13 Distribution of the study subjects based on the type of family
Type of family Frequency (n=440) Percentage ()
Nuclear family 163 37
Joint family 93 21
Three generation family 184 42
Total 440 100
Figure 13 Distribution of the study subjects based on the type of family
In the present study it was found that majority of the study subjects 184 (42) lived in a
three generation family followed by 163 (37) who lived in a nuclear family and 93(21)
who lived in a Joint family
Nuclear family 37
Joint family 21
Three generation
family 42
45
Results
II Prevalence of morbidities among the study subjects
Figure 14 Distribution of the study subjects based on the BMI
In the present study it was found that out of 440 study subjects 198 (45) had a normal
BMI followed by 132 (30) who were overweight 66 (15) were obese and only 44
(10) were underweight
under weight 10
Normal 45
Overweight 30
Obese 15
46
Results
Table 14 Distribution of morbidity pattern of the study subjects based on ICD 10
classification of diseases
System involved ICD 10
Males (n=260)
Females (n=180)
Total (n=440)
No No No
Diseases of musculoskeletal system (M00 ndash M99)
184 707 130 722 314 714
Diseases of the eye and adnexa (H00 ndash H59)
139 534 80 444 219 497
Diseases of oral cavityamp salivary glands (K00 ndash K14)
90 346 64 355 154 35
Endocrine nutritional amp metabolic diseases (E00 ndash
E90)
70 269 75 417 145 329
Diseases of circulatory system (I00 ndash I99)
64 246 73 405 137 311
Diseases of respiratory system(J00 ndash J99)
64 246 37 206 101 23
Diseases of digestive system (K00 ndash K93)
57 219 30 166 87 198
Diseases of skin amp subcutaneous tissue (L00 ndash
L99)
38 146 20 111 58 132
Diseases of the ear and mastoid process (H60 ndashH95)
39 15 18 10 57 13
Diseases of genitourinary system (N00 ndash N99)
22 85 7 39 29 66
Diseases of nervous system (G00 ndash G99)
6 23 5 28 11 25
Note Total number could not be given as many subjects had multiple disorders
47
Results
Figure 15 Distribution of morbidity pattern of the study subjects based on ICD 10
classification of diseases
In the present study it was found that the majority of the subjects 314 (714) suffered
from the disorders of the musculoskeletal system followed by 219 (497) who suffered
from the disease of the eye and adnexa154 (35) suffered from the disease of the oral
cavity 145 (329) suffered from endocrine nutritional and metabolic disorders137
(311) suffered from the disease of the circulatory system 101 (229) suffered from the
disease of the respiratory system 87(198) suffered from the disease of the digestive
system 58 (132) suffered from disease of the skin 57 (13) suffered from the disease of
the ear 29 (66) suffered from the disease of the genitourinary system and only 11( 25 )
suffered from the disease of the nervous system
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
714
497
35 329 311 229
198 132 13 66
25
perc
enta
ge
48
Results
Table 15 Distribution of the study subjects based on morbidity of the musculoskeletal
system
Musculoskeletal
Disease
Males
(n=260)
Females
(n=180)
Total
(n= 440)
Statistical
Value
Knee joint pain
52 (20)
30 (167)
82 (186)
X2 = 0779
df = 1
p=03773
Back ache
30 (115)
35 (194)
65 (148) X2 = 528
df = 1
p = 0021
Joint pain (other than
knee joint pain)
52(20)
35(194)
87(198)
X2 =00206
df=1
p =0885
Non-specific aches
and pain
50(192)
30(167)
80(182)
X2=0470
df=1
p = 0492
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses
In the present study it was found that the most common morbidity of musculoskeletal
system was pain of the joints (other than the knee joint) found in 87 (198) of the subjects
followed by knee joint pain in 82 ( 186) and non-specific pains and aches were found in
80 (182) of the subjects It was found that back ache was more common in females
35(194) compared to males 30 (115) and this difference was found to be statistically
significant
49
Results
Table 16 Distribution of the study subjects based on morbidity of the eye and adnexa
Diseases of the
eye and
adnexa
Males
(n=260)
Females
(n=180)
Total
(n= 440)
Statistical
value
Cataract
112(43)
60(333)
172(391)
X2 = 4241
df=1
p = 0039
Refractive error
20(77)
14(78)
34(77)
X2= 0001
df=1
p = 0973
Others (conjunctivitis
pterygium glaucoma etc)
7(27)
6(33)
13(29)
X2=0152
df=1
p = 0696
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses
In the present study it was found that the most common morbidity of the eye was cataract
found in 172 (391) of the subjects It was more common in males 112 (43) compared to
females 60 (333) and this difference was found to be statistically significant The other
morbidities present were refractive error found in 34 (77) subjects and others which
includes conjunctivitis pterygium glaucoma etc found in 13 (29 ) subjects
50
Results
Table 17 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the oral cavity
Diseases of the
oral cavity
Males
(n =260 )
Females
(n =180 )
Total
(n = 440)
Statistical
value
Stained teeth
22 (84)
18 (10)
40 (91)
X2 =0304
df=1
p = 0581
Missing teeth
40 (154)
38 (211)
78 (177)
X2= 239
df= 1
p=0122
Caries
28 (108)
8 (44)
36 (82)
X2= 566
df= 1
p=0017
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses
In the present study it was found that the most common morbidity of the oral cavity was
missing teeth found in 78 (177 ) of the subjects followed by stained teeth found in 40
(91) of the subjects and dental caries in 36 (82) of the subjects Dental caries were
more common in males 28 (108) compared to females 8(44) and this difference was
found to be statistically significant
51
Results
Table 18 Distribution of study subjects based on endocrine nutritional and metabolic
disorders
Disorders Males
(n =260 )
Females
(n =180)
Total
(n = 440)
Statistical value
Diabetes mellitus
45 (173)
37 (206)
82 (186)
X2 = 0739
df= 1
p = 0389
Anemia
24 (92)
35 (194)
59 (134)
X2= 955
df = 1
p = 0001
Thyroid disorders
1(04)
3 (17)
4 (09)
p= 0309
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
The present study revealed that the most common disorder of the endocrine system was
diabetes mellitus found in 82 (186) of the subjects followed by the nutritional disorder of
anemia found in 59 (134) of the subjects It was seen that anemia was more common
among females 35 (194) compared to males 24 (92) This difference was found to be
statistically significant Disorders of the thyroid gland were found in 4 (09) of the subjects
being more common in females 3(17) compared to males 1 (04)
52
Results
Table 19 Distribution of the study subject based on disease of the circulatory system
Diseases of
circulatory
system
Males
(n=260 )
Females
(n =180)
Total
(n = 440)
Statistical
value
Hypertension
62 (238)
71 (394)
133 (302)
X2= 1227
df= 1
p = 0000
CAD MI
Arrhythmias
2 (08)
2 (11)
4 (09)
p =100
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
In our study it was found that the most common disease of the circulatory system was
hypertension which was found in 133 (302 ) of the subjects it was more common in
females 71 (394) compared to males 62 (239) and this difference was found to be
statistically significant The other disorders of the circulatory system were CAD MI
arrhythmias which were found only in 4 (09) of the study subjects
53
Results
Table 20 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the respiratory system
Disorders of
Respiratory
System
Males
(n=260)
Females
(n=180)
Total
(n=440)
Statistical
value
Bronchial asthma
3 (12)
3 (17)
6 (14)
p =0692
URTI
45 (173)
27 (15)
72 (164)
X2= 0413
df = 1
p = 0520
Acute Bronchitis
12 (46)
7 (39)
19 (43)
X2= 0135
df = 1
p = 0712
Pulmonary TB
4 (15)
0(00)
4 (09)
p =0148
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
Our study revealed that the most common disease of the respiratory system was URTI
(upper respiratory tract infection) found in 72 (164) subjects followed by acute bronchitis
in 19 (43 ) bronchial asthma in 6 (14) and pulmonary TB in only in 4 (09 ) subjects
Pulmonary TB was found in 4 (15) of the males whereas no females had TB however
this difference was not found to be statistically significant
54
Results
Table 21 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the digestive system
Disorders of
Gastrointestinal
system
Males
(n = 260)
Females
(n = 180)
Total
(n = 440)
Statistical value
Constipation
21(8)
6 (33)
27(61)
X2 =4155
df =1
p =0041
Gastritis
24 (92)
18 (10)
42(95)
X2= 0072
df = 1
p =0787
Bleeding per
rectum 3(12) 2(11) 5(11)
p =100
Others (Pain
abdomen
anorexia
indigestion)
9(35)
4 (22)
13 (3)
X2=0569
df =1
p=0450
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
Our study revealed that the most common disorder of the gastrointestinal system was
gastritis found in 42 (95) subjects followed by constipation in 27 ( 61) others which
include pain abdomen anorexia indigestion was found in 13 (3) and bleeding per rectum
was seen in 5 (11) It was seen that constipation was more common among males 21(8)
compared to females 6 (33) which was found to be statistically significant
55
Results
Table 22 Distribution the study subjects based on disease of the Skin and
subcutaneous tissue
Disorders of skin and
subcutaneous tissue
Males ( n = 260)
Females (n = 180)
Total (n = 440)
Statistical
value
Itching
19(73)
2(11)
21(48)
X2 =896
df=1
p = 0002
Scaling 6 (23)
3 (17)
9 (2)
p =0743
Pigmentation
5(19)
4 (22)
9 (2)
p =100
Dryness
8 (31)
11 (61)
19(43)
X2= 237
df = 1
p = 0123 Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
In the present study it was found that the most common disease of the skin was itching
which was present in 21 (48) of the study subjects followed by dryness in 19 (43) and 9
(2) of the subjects had scaling and pigmentation It was seen that itching was more
common among males 19 (73) compared to females 2 (11) and this difference was
found to be statistically significant
56
Results
Table 23 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the ear
Disease of the ear
Males
(n= 260)
Females
(n = 180)
Total
(n = 440) Statistical value
Hearing impairment
33 (126)
16 (89)
49 (111)
X2 =155
df =1
p =0212
Ear discharge
3 (12)
1 (06)
4(09)
p =0647
Tinnitus
3 (12)
1 (06)
4 (09)
p =0647
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
In the present study it was observed that hearing impairment was the most common
morbidity of the ear found in 49 (111) of the subjects though it was more common
among males 33 (126) compared to females 16 (89) the difference was not found to be
statistically significant The other disorders which affected the ear were ear discharge and
tinnitus both present in 4 (09) of the subjects
57
Results
Table 24 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the genitourinary
system
Disorders of
genitourinary system
Male
(n = 260)
Female
(n = 180)
Total
(n=440)
Statistical value
Burning micturition
2 (077)
2 (11)
4 (09)
p=100
Increased frequency of
micturition
20(77) 5(28) 25(57)
X2= 4794
df =1
p =0028 Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
In our study it was observed that the most common morbidity affecting the genitourinary
system was increased frequency of micturition in 25 (57) of the subjects followed by
burning micturition in 4 (09) of the study subjects Increased frequency of micturition was
more common among males 20 (77) compared to females 5 (28) and this difference
was found to be statistically significant
58
Results
Table 25 Distribution of the study subjects based on diseases of the Nervous system
Disease of the
nervous system Males
(n = 260)
Females
(n = 180)
Total
(n = 440)
p value
Memory loss
2 (77)
2 (11)
4 (09)
100
Stroke
2 (77)
0 (00)
2 (05)
0515
Neuritis
2 (77)
3 (17)
5 (11)
0652
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
Our study revealed that the most common disorder of the nervous system was neuritis seen
in 5 (11) of the subjects followed by memory loss in 4 (09) and stroke in 2 (05 ) of
the subjects It was observed that 2 (0 77) of males had suffered a stroke whereas none of
the females had suffered from stroke however this difference was not found to be
statistically significant
59
Results
Table 26 Association between morbidity pattern of the study subjects and their age
group
System involved 60-69Yrs
(n = 271)
70-79Yrs
(n = 134)
gt 80Yrs
(n = 35)
Total
( n = 440)
Statistical
value
Musculoskeletal
System
195 (72)
94 (70)
25 (710)
314 (714) X2= 0143
df = 2 p = 0930
Eye amp adnexa
125 (461)
69 (515)
25 (714)
219 (497) X2= 8166
df = 2 p = 0016
Oral cavity amp salivary gland
56 (207)
68 (507)
30 (857)
154 (350) X2= 7865
df = 2 p lt 00001
Endocrine nutritional amp
metabolic diseases
91 (335)
47 (35)
7 (200)
145 (329) X2= 297
df = 2 p = 0225
Circulatory
system
87 (321)
40 (298)
10 (285)
137 (311) X2= 0328
df = 2 p = 0848
Respiratory
system
64 (236)
31 (231)
6 (171)
101 (23) X2= 0738
df = 2 p = 0691
Digestive system
52 (191)
28 (210)
7 (200)
87 (191) X2= 0166
df = 2 p = 0 920
Skin and subcutaneous
tissue
43 (159)
13 (97)
2 (57)
58 (132) X2= 4831
df = 2 p = 0089
Ear amp mastoid process
27 (99)
20 (149)
10 (285)
57 (13) X2= 1018
d= 2 p = 0006
Genitourinary
system
20 (74)
8 (59)
1 (29)
29 (66) X2= 1151
df = 2 p = 0562
Nervous system
5 (18)
4 (29)
2 (57)
11 (25)
p = 0418
Figure in parenthesis indicates percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
60
Results
Table 26 shows the association between the morbidity pattern and age group of the study
subjects It is observed that the disease of the eye and adnexa increase with increasing age
and are more common in individuals above 80 years of age (714) compared to
individuals in the age group of 60-69 years (461) and 70-79 years (515) This
difference was found to be statistically significant The disease of the oral cavity were also
more common in the subjects aged 80 years and above (857) compared to individuals in
the age group of 70-79 years (507) and 60-69 years (207) this difference was also
found to be statistically significant Significant association was also found between
increasing age and disease of the ear 285 subjects aged 80 years and above suffered from
disease of the ear followed by 149 in the age group of 60-69 years and 99 in the age
group of 60-69 years
61
Results Table 27 Association between morbidity pattern of the study subjects and their
occupation
System involved Employed (n=215)
Unemployed (n=225)
Total (n=440)
Statistical value
Musculoskeletal
system
171 (795) 143 (635) 314 (714) X2 =1374 df=1
p=00002
Eye and adnexa 108 (502) 111(493) 219(497) X2= 0035 df=1
p= 0850
Oral cavityamp
salivary glands
76 (353) 78 (347) 154 (35) X2=0022 df=1
p=0880
Endocrine
nutritional amp
metabolic
disease
75 (348) 70 (311) 145 (329) X2=0708 df=1
p=0400
circulatory
system
58 (269) 79 (351) 137 (311) X2=3393 df=1
p=0065
Respiratory
system
49 (227) 52 (231) 101 (23) X2=0006 df=1
p=09363
Digestive system 45 (21) 42 (187) 87 (198) X2=0125 df=1
p=0723
Skin
subcutaneous
tissue
38 (176) 20 (88) 58 (132) X2=741 df=1
p=0006
Ear and mastoid
process
31 (144) 26 (115) 57 (13) X2=0799 df=1
p=0371
Genitourinary
system
16 (74) 13 (57) 29 (66) X2=0494 df=1
p=0481
Nervous system
2 (093) 9 (4) 11 (25) X2=425 df=1
p=0039 Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses
62
Results
Table 27 shows the association between the morbidity pattern and occupation of the study
subjects It was observed that musculoskeletal disorders were more common among the
subjects who are employed (795) compared to those who are not employed (635) and
this difference was found to be statistically significant A significant association was also
seen between the disorders of the skin and subcutaneous tissue 176 subjects who are
employed suffered from the disease of the skin and subcutaneous tissue compared to 88
who were unemployed The diseases of the nervous system were more common among
those who were unemployed (4) compared to those who were employed (093) this
difference was also found to be statistically significant
63
Results Table 28 Association between morbidity pattern of the study subjects and their
religion
System involved Hindu
(n=188)
Muslim
(n=252)
Total
(n=440)
Statistical value
Musculoskeletal system 138 (73) 176 (698) 314 (714)
X2=0668 df=1
p=0413
Eye and adnexa 100 (531) 119 (472) 219 (497) X2=1535 df=1
p= 0215
Oral cavityamp salivary glands 73 (388) 81 (321) 154 (35)
X2=211 df=1
p=0145
Endocrine nutritional amp metabolic diseases
53 (2819) 92 (365) 145 (329) X2=3371 df=1
p=0066
circulatory system 58 (269) 79 (351) 137 (311)
X2=3393 df=1
p=0065
Respiratory system
33 (176) 68 (269) 101 (229)
X2=5415 df= 1
p=0019
Digestive system 27 (144) 60 (238) 87 (198) X2=6059 df=1
p=0013
Skin subcutaneous tissue
31 (164) 27 (107) 58 (132) X2=3138 df=1
p=00765
Ear and mastoid process
28 (149) 29 (115) 57 (129) X2=1095 df=1
p=0297
Genitourinary system
16 (85) 13 (52) 29 (66) X2=1965 df=1
p=0161
Nervous system
4 (21) 7 (28) 11(25) p=0764
Figure in parenthesis indicates percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
64
Results
Table 28 shows the association between the morbidity pattern of the study subjects and their
religion In our study it was observed that the disorders of the digestive system were more
common among Muslims (238) compared to Hindus (144) this difference was found
to be statistically significant Also the disorders of the respiratory system were more
common among Muslims (269) compared to Hindus (176) This difference was also
found to be statistically significant Some of the diseases were more common among Hindus
which include the disease of the eye and adnexa (531) oral cavity (388) ear (149)
skin and subcutaneous tissue (164) and genitourinary system (85) but it was not found
to be statistically significant
65
Results
III HEATLTH SEEKING BEHAVIOR OF THE STUDY SUBJECTS
Figure16 Distribution of the study subjects based on the visit to health facility in case
of an illness
In our study it was found that that out of 440 study subjects 395(898) visited a health
facility in case of an illness whereas 45(102) did not visit any health facility in case of an
illness
898
102
health facility visitednot visited
66
Results
Table 29 Reasons cited by the study subjects for not seeking healthcare in case of an
illness
In the present study it was found that the most common reason stated by the 45 study
subjects for not seeking health care in case of an illness was that it was a mil 20 (444)
followed by lack of money stated by12 (267) the other reasons stated were no one to
accompany 7 (156) and lack of faith in health care 6 (133)
Reasons cited for not
seeking health care
Frequency (n=45)
Percentage ()
Mild discomfort 20 444
Lack of money 12 267
Lack of faith in
healthcare
6 133
No one to accompany 7 156
Total 45 100
67
Results
Table 30 Distribution of the study subjects based on the type of health facility visited
It was observed that out of 395 subjects who visited health care facility in case of an illness
229(58) Visited government hospitals 160 (405) visited private practitioners hospitals
and 6 (15) visited quacks More number of males (622) visited government hospitals
compared to females (513)
Type of health facility visited
Males
(n=241)
Females
(n=154)
Total
(n=395)
No No No
Government hospital 150 622 79 513 229 58
Private practitionershospitals 87 361 73 474 160 405
Quacks 4 17 2 13 6 15
Total 241 100 154 100 395 100
68
Results
Table 31 Association between gender and health seeking behaviour of the study
subjects
Whether visited
health facility
in case of illness
Sex
Total
n ()
p value Male
n ()
Female
n ()
Yes 241 (927) 154 (856) 395 (898) 00151
No 19 (106) 26 (144) 45 (102)
Total 260 (59) 180 (41) 440 (100)
x2=5901 df =1
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
It was observed that more number of males visited a health care facility in case of an illness
241(927) whereas only 154(856) females visited a health facility in case of an illness
This difference was found to be statistically significant
69
Results
Table 32 Association between educational status and health seeking
behaviour of the study subjects
Whether visited Health facility in case of illness
p value
Educational status(n) Yes () No ()
0000
Illiterate (231) 194 (84) 37 (16)
Primary school (121) 115 (95) 6 (49)
Higher primary (38) 37 (974) 1 (26)
Secondary school (30) 29 (967) 1 (33)
Intermediate (6) 6 (100) 0(00)
Graduate (14) 14 (100) 0(00)
Total(440) 395 (898) 45(102)
Fisherrsquos exact test
In the present study it was found that 84 of the study subjects who were illiterate visited a
health facility in case of an illness whereas 16 did not visit a health facility in case of an
illness 967 of the subjects with education up to secondary school visited the health
facility and 100 of the subjects who studied up to intermediate and with a graduate degree
visited the health facility in case of an illness This difference was found to be statistically
significant
70
Results
Table 33 Distribution of study subjects according to frequency of visits to a health care facility
Frequency of visits to a health care facility
Frequency
(n=395)
Percentage
Once a month 207 524
Once in 3 months 99 251
Once in 6 months 79 20
Once in a year 10 25
Total 395 100
In the present study it was found that out of 395 study subjects who visited a health care
facility in case of an illness 207 (524) visited a health facility every month followed by
99 (251) who visited once in 3 months 79(20) once in 6 months and 10 25 visited
the health facility once in a year
71
Discussion
DISCUSSION
I Socio-demographic characteristics
Our study was done in the urban field practice area of JJM Medical College Davangere
among 440 geriatric subjects our study aimed at assessing the morbidity pattern and health
seeking behaviour of the geriatric population in the study area
In the present study Out of 440 study subjects majority 162(368) were in the age
group of 60-64 Years followed by 109 (247) in the age group of 65-69 Years 99 (225)
in the age group of 70-74 Years and 8 were more than or equal to 80 years of age [Table
7] This was similar to a study conducted by Prakash Boraingaiah et al 72 in which majority
of the elderly (346) belongs to age group 60-64 years followed by age group 75 years and
above (259)
In our study it was also seen that 59 of the study subjects were males and 41 were
females This was similar to a study conducted by Mohan Gupta et al 35 where 573
subjects were males and 427were females Our findings were contrary to a study
conducted by Md Alam Naushad et al 28 where 598 subjects were females and 402
were males
In the present study it was found that the majority of the study subject belonged to
Muslim religion 252 (573) followed by Hindus 188 (427) there were no study subjects
who belonged to other religions like Christian Jain Sikhs etc [Table 8] similar findings
were seen in a study conducted by Mrinal Ranjan Srivastav et al 50 in which 52 of the
subjects were Muslims
72
Discussion
In the present study it was found that the Majority of the study subjects were illiterate
525 whereas 275 had completed education up to primary school 82 had completed
education up to secondary school and only 32 were graduates [Table 9] These findings
were similar to a study done by Shraddha K et al 51in which 504 of the study subjects
were illiterate
In our study it was found that the majority of the study subjects 511 were unemployed
followed by 227 who were unskilled workers 155 were semi-skilled workers and
about 105 were skilled workers [Table 10] These findings were similar to a study done
by Rajat Das Gupta et al27 al in which 481 of the study subjects were not working
In our study majority of the subjects 49 belonged to Class IV Socioeconomic status
followed by 26 who belonged to class III and 13 who belonged to class II (according to
Modified BG Prasad Classification 2016) [Table 11] Similar findings were found in a study
conducted by Sribas Goswami and Manjari Sahai 29 in which majority of the study subjects
belonged to class IV socio economic status
In our study it was found that the majority of the study subjects 734 were married
followed by 261 who were widowed and only 05 were unmarried [Table 12] These
findings were similar to a study done by L subedhi and RB Sah 40 in which 663 of the
subjects were married 322 were widowed and 07 were unmarried
In the present study it was found that majority of the study subjects 42 lived in a three
generation family followed by 37 who lived in a nuclear family and 21 who lived in a
Joint family [Table 13] These findings were similar to a study done by Swapnil Jain et al 26
in which the majority (47) of the study subjects lived in a three generation family
73
Discussion
II Prevalence of morbidities among the study subjects
In the present study it was found that majority of the subjects 45 had a normal BMI
followed by 30 who were overweight about 15 were obese and only10 were
underweight [Figure 14] Similar findings were reported in a study conducted by Khadervali
Nagoor et al 44 in which 49 subjects had a normal BMI In a study done by Vimala
Thomas et al 52 272 of the subjects were obese which was higher than the present study
In the present study it was found that the majority of the subjects suffered from the
disorders of the musculoskeletal system (714) eye and adnexa (497) oral cavity
(311) respiratory system (229) digestive system (198)disease of the skin
(132)ear(13)genitourinary system (66) nervous system (25) [Table14] Similar
findings were seen in a study done by Rajashree Bhat et al 55 in which most common
morbidity of elderly was the problems of loco-motor system (486) followed by vision
(427) CVS disorders (344) respiratory system (202) and disease of ear (179)In
this study though the prevalence of loco-motor system disorders (486) was highest
compared to other disorders it was lesser compared to our study (714) In a study done by
L subedhi and RB Sah 40 it was found that 44 had eye problems 43 had gastrointestinal
problems 33 had CVS problems and 23 had ENT problems In this study the prevalence
of gastrointestinal disorders was much higher compared to our study
In the present study joint pain (including the knee joint) was most common disorder of the
musculoskeletal system seen in 40 of the males compared to 384 in females [Table 15]
whereas in a study done by Swapnil Jain et al 26 it was found that 472 males and 528
females suffered from joint pains This could be attributed to the fact that in our study
majority of the study subjects were males
74
Discussion
In the present study it was found that the most common morbidity of the eye was cataract
found in 39 of the subjects It was more common in males 43 compared to females
333 [ Table 16]These findings were similar to a study done by Shraddha K et al 51 in
which the overall prevalence of cataract was 302 of which 42 males and 358
females had cataract
In the present study it was found that the most common morbidity of the oral cavity was
missing teeth found in 177 of the subjects [Table 17] it was similar to the findings of a
study conducted by JP Singh et al 48 in which 1475 subjects were edentulous
The present study revealed that the most common disorder of the endocrine system was
diabetes mellitus found in 186 of the subjects followed by the nutritional disorder of
anemia found in 134 of the subjects It was seen that anemia was more common among
females 194 compared to males 92 [Table 18] Kakkar R et al 45 reported similar
findings with prevalence of diabetes mellitus as 153 In a study done by Deepak Sharma
et al 47 anemia was present in 15 of the subjects 97 males and 21 females were
anemic which was similar to our study
In our study it was found that the most common disease of the circulatory system was
hypertension which was found in 302 of the subjects it was more common in females
394 compared to males 239 and this difference was found to be statistically significant
[Table 19] A study by L Subedhi and RB Sah 40 reported that the prevalence of
hypertension was more among females (333) compared to males (30) which was
statistically significant
75
Discussion
In our study the most common morbidity of the respiratory system was upper respiratory
tract infection (163) [Table20] it was similar to the study done by Leena Rahul
Salunke33 where it was reported to be 196
In our study the most common disorder of the digestive system was gastritis (95)
[Table 21] similar to the findings of JP Singh et al 48 (35) contrary to this L subedhi
and RB Sah 40 reported a high prevalence of gastritis (39) This difference could be
attributed to the difference in the interpretation of symptoms for the diagnosis of gastritis
In our study the most common disorder of the skin was itching (48) [ Table 22] which
was similar to the findings reported by JP Singh et al 48 in which 225 subjects suffered
from itching
In our study the most common disorder of the ear was impaired hearing (111) [Table
23] similar to a study by Vandana Nikumb et al 38 in which 106 subjects suffered from
hearing impairment
In our study it was observed that the most common morbidity affecting the
genitourinary system was increased frequency of micturition (57) [Table 24]
L subedhi and RB Sah40 found in their study that 143 subjects suffered from increased
frequency of micturition which was higher compared to our study
Our study revealed that 25 subjects suffered from the disorders of the nervous
system [Table 25] similar to a study conducted by Vandana Nikumb et al 38 in which
13 of the Subjects suffered from the disorders of the nervous system whereas in a
study conducted by Shilpa Shaukaiah et al36 it was found that 66 of the subjects
suffered from the disorders of the nervous system which was higher than our study
76
Discussion
It is observed that the disease of the eye and adnexa increased with increasing age and were
more common in individuals above 80 years of age (714) The disease of the oral cavity
were also more common in the subjects aged 80 years and above (857) and 285
subjects aged 80 years and above suffered from disease of the ear A significant association
was found between age and these morbidities [Table 26] Similar results were found in a
study done by Swapnil Jain et al 26 in which cataract hearing impairment and dental
problems were significantly associated with the age of the study subjects
In our study a significant association was found between occupation and the disorders of
the musculoskeletal system skin and the nervous system Disorders of the musculoskeletal
system were more common among employed subjects (795) compared to unemployed
(635) 176 subjects who were employed suffered from the disease of the skin and
subcutaneous tissue compared to 88 who were unemployed Diseases of the nervous
system were more common among those who were unemployed (4) compared to those
who were employed (093) [Table 27]
A study done by Kakkar R et al45 found that there was a significant association between the
employment status and the morbidities of the CVS arthritis and cataract CVS morbidity
was more common among those not working (164) compared to those working (36)
Arthritis was also more common among not working (212) compared to those working
(55) and cataract was also more common among those not working (175) compared to
those working (55)
77
Discussion
In our study it was observed that there was a significant association between religion and
disorders of the digestive system and respiratory system The disorders of the digestive
system were more common among Muslims (238) compared to Hindus (144) Also the
disorders of the respiratory system were more common among Muslims (269) compared
to Hindus (176) [Table 28] In a study conducted by Mrinal Ranjan Srivastav et al 50 it
was found that there was significant association between religion and the morbidities of the
genitourinary system in the urban areas The problems of the genitourinary system were
more common among Hindus (26) compared to Muslims (96)
III HEATLTH SEEKING BEHAVIOR OF THE STUDY SUBJECTS
In our study it was found that that (898) study subjects visited a health facility in case
of an illness whereas 102 did not visit any health facility in case of an illness[Figure 16]
Similar findings were seen in a study conducted by Vimala Thomas et al 52 where it was
found that 716 subjects visited a health facility Contrary to our findings a study
conducted by Bhawalkar JS et al46 showed that only 81 subjects visited a health facility in
case of an illness whereas 919 did not visit any health facility
In the present study it was found that the most common reason stated by study subjects
for not seeking health care in case of an illness was that it was a mild discomfort (444)
followed by lack of money stated by (267) other reasons stated were no one to
accompany (156) and lack of faith in health care (133) [Table 29] In a study
conducted by Deepak Sharma et al 47 it was found that the most common reasons for not
seeking health care were the following disease due to age (496) health services too far
(191) lack of money (6) no body to take to hospital (35)
78
Discussion
It was observed that out of 395 subjects who visited health care facility in case of an illness
58 Visited government hospitals 362 visited private practitioners hospitals and 15
visited quacks [Table 30] similar results were found in a study conducted by Deepak Sharma
et al 47 in which 607 went to Government hospitals 267 consulted private practitioners
and 126 took over the counter drugs In another study conducted by Rajat Das Gupta et al
27 it was found that 33 visited Government hospitals 25 visited private hospitals 6
visited private practitioners
It was observed that more number of males (927) visited a health care facility in case of
an illness whereas only 856 females visited a health facility in case of an illness [Table
31] In a study done by Man Mohan Gupta et al 35 it was found that 672 females and
651 males visited a health facility in case of illness
In the present study it was found that 848 of the study subjects who were illiterate
visited a health facility in case of an illness whereas 152 did not visit a health facility in
case of an illness A significant association was found between educational status and
gender [Table 32] In a study done by Deepak Sharma et al 47 it was found that Gender
literacy income and marital status were not found to be significantly related to health-
seeking behaviour
In the present study it was found that 524 subjects visited a health facility every month
followed by 251 who visited a health facility once in 3 months 20once in 6 months
and 25 visited a health facility once in a year[ Table 33] In a study conducted by Rajat
Das Gupta et al 27 it was found that majority of the subjects (2943) visited a health
facility once a year followed by 2813 who visited a health facility once in three months
79
Conclusion
CONCLUSION
The study revealed that some of the common morbidities among the geriatric subjects were
the disorders of the musculoskeletal system followed by the disease of the eye and adnexa
oral cavity endocrine nutritional and metabolic disorders etc some disorders like cataract
dental caries constipation and increased frequency of micturition were more common
among males whereas disease like anemia and hypertension were more common among
females A significant association was found between some of the morbidities and socio
demographic determinants like age occupation and religion
Any degree of formal schooling was found to be associated with better health seeking
behavior Majority of the subjects visited a Government health facility in case of an illness
and the main reason that was stated for not visiting a health facility was that they suffered
from mild discomfort and did not consider it necessary to visit a health facility
80
Summary
SUMMARY
Our study was done in the urban field practice area of JJM Medical College Davangere
among 440 geriatric subjects our study aimed at assessing the morbidity pattern and health
seeking behaviour of the geriatric population in the study area
The results of our study are as follows
ISocio-demographic characteristics of the study subjects
In the present study 368 subjects were in the age group of 60-64 Years
59 of the subjects were males and 41 were females
573 subjects were Muslims whereas 427 were Hindus
Majority of the subjects were illiterate (525) whereas 275 had completed
education up to primary school
It was found that the majority of the study subjects (511) were unemployed
49 subjects belonged to Class IV Socioeconomic status according to Modified BG
Prasad Classification
734 of the subjects were married
42 of the people lived in a three generation family
II Prevalence of morbidities among the study subjects
Majority of the subjects (45) had a normal BMI followed 30who were
overweight
Majority 714 subjects suffered from the disorders of the musculoskeletal system
followed by 497 who suffered from the disease of the eye and adnexa35
suffered from the disease of the oral cavity 329 suffered from endocrine
nutritional and metabolic disorders and 311 suffered from the disease of the
circulatory system 229 suffered from the disease of the respiratory system198
81
Summary
suffered from the disease of the digestive system132 suffered from disease of the
skin13 suffered from the disease of the ear66 suffered from the disease of the
genitourinary system and 25 suffered from the disease of the nervous system
The most common morbidity of musculoskeletal system was pain of the joints (other
than the knee joint) found in 198 of the subjectsBack ache was more common in
females 231 compared to males 163 and this difference was found to be
statistically significant
cataract found in 39 of the subjects It was more common in males 43 compared
to females 333 and this difference was found to be statistically significant
Missing teeth were found in 177 of the subjects Dental caries were more
common in males 108 compared to females 44 and this difference was found to
be statistically significant
Diabetes mellitus found in 186 of the subjects followed by the nutritional disorder
of anemia found in 134 of the subjects anemia was more common among females
194 compared to males 92 This difference was found to be statistically
significant
Hypertension which was found in 302 of the subjects it was more common in
females 394 compared to males 239 and this difference was found to be
statistically significant
upper respiratory tract infection) found in 163 subjects followed by acute
bronchitis in 43 bronchial asthma in 14 and pulmonary TB in only 09
Gastritis was found in 95 subjects followed by constipation in 61 Among
males (81) had constipation compared to females(03)
Most common disease of the skin was itching which was present in 48 of the
study subjects followed by dryness in 43
82
Summary
Hearing impairment was found in 111 of the subjects
Increased frequency of micturition was found in 57 of the subjects followed by
burning micturition in 09 of the study subjects Increased frequency of
micturition was more among males 77 compared to females in whom it was 28
and this difference was found to be statistically significant
The most common disorder of the nervous system was neuritis seen in 11 of the
subjects followed by memory loss in 09 and stroke in 05 of the subjects
A significant association was found between increasing age and the morbidities of
the eye ear and the oral cavity
Significant association was found between occupation and the disorders of the
musculoskeletal system skin and the nervous system Disorders of the
musculoskeletal system were more common among employed subjects (795)
compared to unemployed (635) 176 subjects who were employed suffered
from the disease of the skin and subcutaneous tissue compared to 88 who were
unemployed Diseases of the nervous system were more common among those who
were unemployed (4) compared to those who were employed (093)
It was observed that the disorders of the digestive system were more common
among Muslims (238) compared to Hindus (144) this difference was found to
be statistically significant Also the disorders of the respiratory system were more
common among Muslims (269) compared to Hindus (176) This difference
was also found to be statistically significant
83
Summary
III HEATLTH SEEKING BEHAVIOR OF THE STUDY SUBJECTS
In our study 898 subjects visited a health facility in case of an illness whereas
102 did not
The most common reason stated by study subjects for not seeking health care in case
of an illness was that it was a mild discomfort (444) followed by lack of money
stated by (267) the other reasons stated were no one to accompany (156) and
lack of faith in health care (133)
It was observed that 58 subjects Visited Government hospitals 362 visited
private practitioners hospitals and 15 visited quacks
Majority of males (927) visited a health care facility in case of an illness whereas
only 856 females visited a health facility in case of an illness This difference was
found to be statistically significant
A significant association was found between the educational status and health
seeking behaviour Majority of the educated subjects visited a health facility in case
of an illness compared to those who were illiterate
It was found that 524 subjects visited a health facility every month followed by
251 who visited a health facility once in 3 months 20once in 6 months and
25 visited a health facility once in a year
84
Limitations
LIMITATIONS
1 Many of the responses were subjective and there were no records to verify them
2 Some of the morbidities were diagnosed only by clinical examination and could not be
confirmed by performing diagnostic tests due to high cost and time constraints
3 This study was done in the urban field practice area which consisted of a closed
community hence the results cannot be generalized to the entire population of the area
85
Recommendations
RECOMMENDATIONS
1 Health education should be given to the geriatric people regarding the common health
problems associated with ageing and preventive care should be provided to the elderly
2 Geriatric clinics should be set up at the primary health care level which provide regular
screening and health check-ups
3 There should also be a provision to provide domiciliary care by specialists qualified in
geriatrics
4 The family members and the care givers of the elderly should be educated about the
common health problems of the elderly and also about the need for regular health check-ups
and emotional support
5 The majority of the geriatric population is out of work force they are suffering from
many morbidities and are totally dependent on others even for their health needs Hence the
Government should increase the pension of the elderly and provide them quality healthcare
free of cost
6 There is also a need for public private partnership to improve the quality of health
services for the geriatric people More number of NGOs should work towards improving the
health and the quality of life of the elderly
86
References
REFERENCES
1 United Nations Department of Economic and Social affairs Population Division
World population ageing 2013 Available from URL
wwwunorgendevelopmentpopulationageingWorldPopulationAgeing2013
[Accessed on 17-7-2016]
2 Khan S and Itrat M Current Issues in Geriatric Health Care in India-A Review J Community Med Health Care 2016 1(1) 1-3
3 United Nations Department of Economic and Social Affairs Population Division
World Population Ageing 2015 ndash Highlights Available from URL
wwwunorgendevelopmentdesapopulationpdfageingWPA2015_Reportpdf
[Accessed on 272017]
4 State of elderly in India 2014 Help age India Available from URL
httpswwwhelpageindiaorgimagespdfstate-elderly-india-2014pdf [Accessed on
1082017]
5 World Health Organization World report on ageing and health 2015Available
from URL wwwwhointageingeventsworld-report-2015-launchen [Accessed on
1272017]
6 National policy for Senior citizens March 2011Ministry of Social Justice and
welfare Govt of India Available from URL
socialjusticenicinwritereaddataUploadFilednpscpdf [Accessed on 482017]
87
References
7 Elderly in India Profile and programmes 2016Govt of India Ministry of statistics
and programme implementation Central Statistics Office Available from URL
wwwmopsigovin [ Accessed on 1442017]
8 Saxena V Kandpal SD Gael D Bansal S Health status of elderly community
based study Indian Journal of Community Health2012 Oct-Dec24(4)269-74
9 Shah T Patel M Shah V Health care seeking behaviour of urban and rural
community in Ahmedabad district Int J Med Sci Public Health20132908-11
10 Sahoo H Mishra NR Health Status Morbidity Pattern and Treatment Seeking
Behaviour among Elderly in India Evidence from 60th round of National Sample
Survey Data Learning community 2011 Dec 2(3) 341-55
11 Park K Parkrsquos Textbook of Preventive and social medicine 24 th ed Jabalpur MS
Banarsidas Bhanot Publishers2017631
12 UNFPA- state of World Population 2011Chapter 1 setting the scene 19-31
Available from URL httpswwwunfpaorgsitesdefaultfilesresource-
pdfUNFPA-Report-Chapter1pd [Accessed on 1082017]
13 Lal S Adarsh Pankaj Textbook of community Medicine 4th ed CBS publishers and
distributors PvtLtd2011732
14 Census of India 2001 Registrar General And Census Commissioner India
Available from URL httpwwwcensusindiagovinCensus[Accessed on
7102015]
15 SRS bulletin October 2012 Registar General of India New Delhi Available from
URL censusindiagovinvital_statisticsSRS_BulletinsSRS_Bulletin-
October_2012[Acessed on 7102015]
88
References
16 Bagchi K Healthy ageing Health and Population-Perspectives and Issues 2000
23(1)11-16
17 Salagre SB The Association of Physicians of India Chapter 177 Health Issues in
Geriatrics Available from URL
wwwapiindiaorgmedicine_update_2013chap177pd [ Accessed on 282017]
18 Ingle GK Nath A Geriatric Health in India Concerns and Solutions Indian Journal
of Community Medicine 2008 33(4)214-18
19 World Health Organization Active Ageing a policy framework 2002 Available
from httpwhqlibdocwhointhq2002who_nmh_nph_028pdf [Accessed on
1062017]
20 Inche Zainal Abidin S Sutan R Shamsuddin K Prevalence and determinants of
appropriate health seeking behaviour among known diabetics Results from a
community-based survey Advances in Epidemiology 2014 Nov 20141-6
21 Begashaw B Tessema F Gesesew HA Health Care Seeking behavior in Southwest
Ethiopia Plos one 2016 Sep 11(9)e0161014
22 MacKian S Health systems development Manchester University of Manchester
2003 A review of health seeking behavior problems and prospects
23 Metta EO Health-seeking behaviour among adults in the context of the
epidemiological transition in Southeastern Tanzania A focus on malaria and
diabetes [Groningen] University of Groningen 2016 228 Available from URL
httpswwwrugnlresearchportalfiles28737720Chapter_7pdf [Accessed on
1272017]
24 Adhikari D Rijal D Factors affecting health seeking behaviour of senior citizens of
Dharan Journal of Nobel Medical College 2015 Sep 4(1)57-63
25 Polisetty S Seepana M Morbidity profile of elderly individuals in urban
Visakhapatnam Int J Community Med Public Health 2017 4(2)2558-63
89
References
26 Jain S Kaware AC Doibale MK Shaikh S Radhey BK Mathurkar MP Morbidity
pattern among geriatric population in urban field practice area of district of
Maharashtra a cross sectional study Int J Community Med Public Health 2016
3(2)523-29
27 Gupta RD Loha A Roy S Morbidity pattern and health-seeking behaviour among
the senior citizens in a selected urban area of Bangladesh A cross-sectional study
South East Asia Journal of Public Health 2016 Jul 5(2)43-49
28 Naushad MA Verma N Bhawnani D Jain M Anand T Umate LV Morbidity
pattern and health seeking behaviour in elderly population of Raipur City
Chhattisgarh India Indian Journal of Community Health2016 Sep 28(3)236-41
29 Goswami S Sahai M A Study of Morbidity Pattern in Elderly Population European
Researcher Series A 2016103(2)119-28
30 Bardhan H Dixit AM Agarwal R Jain PK Gupta S Shukla SK Morbidity profile
of elderly population in Ghaziabad district a cross-sectional study Int J Med Sci
Public Health 2016 5(6)1098-1102
31 Maroof M Ahmad A Khalique N Ansari MA Health problems among the aged A
community based study from urban Aligarh Uttar Pradesh India Int J Community
Med Public Health 2016 Feb 3(4)944-47
32 Shankar G Sidenur B A morbidity study of elderly residing in urban field practice
area of SN medical college Bagalkot National Journal of research in community
medicine 2016 Oct-Dec 4(5) 229-34
90
References
33 Salunkhe LR Socio-demographic profile of old age people living in urban amp urban
slum areas in Maharashtra Karad A comparative study J of Evidence based Med
and Hlthcare 2015 Feb 2(5) 513-21
34 Warbhe P Rupesh W Morbidity profile health seeking behaviour and home
environment survey for adaptive measures in geriatric population-Urban community
study International Journal of Medical Research amp Health Sciences 2015 4(4)778-
82
35 Gupta M Borle AL Chhari N Gupta S Assessment of clinico-socioeconomic
status and health-care support among the elderly people aged older than 60 years in
urban population of Bhopal Central India Int J Med Sci Public Health 2015
4558-64
36 Sahukaiah S Shenoy A Vijayakumar BC An epidemiological study of prevalence
of morbidity patterns among geriatric age group in an urban slum of Mumbai Int J
Med Sci Public Health 2015 Jul 4(7)883-87
37 Shubha Davalagi B Angadi N Mahabalaraju DK Morbidity psycho-social profile
and health seeking behaviour of the elderly population in urban slums of Davangere
City India Int J Res Med Sci 2015 Nov 3(11)3288-91
38 Nikumb V Patankar F Behera A A Study of Morbidity Profile among Geriatric
Population in an Urban Area Sch J App Med Sci 2015 3(3)1365-69
91
References
39 Vishnoi BR Solanki SL Singhal G Meharda B Mishra N Morbidity profile of
elderly in urban slum of Udaipur Rajasthan Int J Oral Health Med Res 2015 May
2(1)9-12
40 Subedi L Sah RB Study of the health status of geriatric age group in Chitwan
district of Nepal Journal of Chitwan Medical College 2015 Mar 5(1)11-17
41 Noor S Krishnababu G Prasad KV Health status of Geriatric population in slums
of Rourkela Young Innovative Journal of Medical and Health Science 2015 May
5(3) 92-94
42 Sarode VM Chronic Diseases Related to Aging and Disease Prevention in Slums in
Mumbai Journal of Aging Science 2014 Jan 2 (1)1-6
43 Barman SK Lata K Ram R Ghosh N Sarker G Shahnawaz K A study of
morbidity profile of geriatric population in an urban community of Kishanganj
Bihar India Global Journal of Medicine and Public Health GJMEDPH 2014 3(1)
1-7
44 Nagoor K Srikanth BA Dudekula R Satna K Comparative study of health status
among slum and non-slum elderly population in Kadapa Region South India
Journal of Evolution of Medical and Dental Sciences 2014 Feb 3(5)1298-308
45 Kakkar R Aggarwal P Kandpal SD Bansal SK An Epidemiological study to assess
morbidity profile among geriatric population in District Dehradun Indian Journal of
Community Health 2013 May 25(1)39-44
46 Bhawalkar JS Dhone AB Jethani S Singru S Jadhav SL Adyanthaya S A study of
morbidity profile among geriatric population in an urban area J Evol Med Dent Sci
2013 Sep 9 36(2)6963-7
92
References
47 Sharma D Mazta SR Parashar A Morbidity pattern and health-seeking behaviour of
aged population residing in Shimla hills of north India A cross-sectional study
Journal of family medicine and primary care 2013 Apr2(2)188
48 Singh JP Singh S Kasturwar NB Hassan A Geriatric morbidity profile in an urban
slum Central India Indian Journal of Community Health 2013 Aug 25(2)164-70
49 Thakur RP Banerjee A Nikumb VB Health Problems among the Elderly A Cross
Sectional Study Annals of medical and health sciences research 2013 3(1)19-25
50 Mrinal RS Beena S Pratibha G Pankaj B Srivastava JP Atul B Morbidity Status
and Its Social Determinants among Elderly Population of Lucknow District India
Sch J App Med Sci 2013 1(6)758-64
51 Shraddha K Prashantha B Prakash B Study on morbidity pattern among elderly in
urban population of Mysore Karnataka India International Journal of Medicine and
Biomedical Research 2012 1(3)215-23
52 Thomas V Lavanya KM Morbidity profile and health seeking behaviour of the
elderly in urban slums of Hyderabad Andhra Pradesh India- A cross sectional study
International Journal of Current Research and Review 2012 Oct 1 4(19)174-80
53 Moe S Tha K Naing DK Htike MM Health seeking behaviour of elderly in
Myanmar International Journal of Collaborative Research on Internal Medicine and
Public Health 2012 4(8)1538-44
93
References
54 Bharati DR Pal R Rekha R Yamuna TV Kar S Radjou AN Ageing in
Puducherry South India An overview of morbidity profile Journal of pharmacy amp
bio allied sciences 2011 Oct 3(4)537
55 Bhatt R Gadhvi MS Sonaliya KN Solanki A Nayak H An epidemiological study
of the morbidity pattern among the elderly population in Ahmedabad Gujarat
National Journal of community medicine 2011 Jul 2(2)233-36
56 Srinivasan Krishnamachari Vaz Mario Thomas Tinku Prevalence of health related
disability among community dwelling urban elderly from middle socioeconomic
strata in Bangaluru India Indian Journal of Medical Research 2010 Apr 131(4)
515-21
57 Srivastava K Gupta SC Kaushal SK Chaturvedi M Morbidity profile of elderly a
cross sectional study of urban Agra Indian Journal of Community Health 2010 Jun
22(1)51-55
58 Ladha A Khan R Malik A Khan S Khan B Khan I et al The health seeking
behaviour of elderly population in a poor-urban community of Karachi Pakistan
Journal of the Pakistan Medical Association2009 Feb 59(2) 89-92
59 WHO ICD-10 version 2010 Geneva World Health Organization Available from
URL appswhointclassificationsicd10browse2010en [Accessed on 772017]
60 OpenEpi22OpenEpi (free) download Windows version Available from URL
enfreedownloadmanagerorgWindows-PCOpenEpi-FREEhtml
61 Tandon R Sinhota Parsonrsquos disease of the eye 22edNew Delhi Elsevier 98-100
62 Dhingra P L Dhingra S Disease of ear nose and throat and head and neck surgery
6th ed New Delhi Elsevier 201422
94
References
63 Aziz N Kallur SD Nirmalan PK Implications of the revised consensus body mass
indices for Asian Indians on clinical obstetric practice Journal of clinical and
diagnostic research 2014 May 8(5)OC01
64 Chobanion AV Bakris GL Black HR The seventh report of the joint national
committee on prevention detection evaluation and treatment of high blood pressure
the JNC 7 report JAMA 2003 2892560-72
65 The Seventh Report of the Joint National Committee on Prevention Detection
Evaluation and Treatment of High Blood Pressure (JNC 7) The GuidelinesUS
Department of Health and Human Services National Heart Lung and Blood
Institute Available at URL
httpswwwnhlbinihgovfilesdocsguidelinesjnc7fullpdf [ Accessed on
1282017]
66 Firkin F Chestman C Penington D Rush B De Gruchyrsquos clinical Hematology in
medical practice 5th edition New Delhi Blackwell science Ltd1989 32-47
67 Report of WHO consultation Nutritional Anaemias Geneva Switzerland World
Health Organization TRS-405 1968 Available from URL
whqlibdocwhointtrsWHO_TRS_405pdf [Accessed on 1282017]
68 National Family Health survey (NFHS-4) 2015-16 India Mumbai IIPS
2016Available from URL httpwwwnfhsindiaorg [Accessed on 4072017]
69 The Minimum Wages Act 1948 Ministry of Labour and Employment Government
of India Available from URL httplabourgovincontentinnerpagewagesphp
[Accessed on 1082017]
70 Khairnar M Wadgave U Shimpi P Updated BG Prasad socioeconomic
classification for 2016 Journal of Indian Association of Public Health Dentistry
2016 Oct 1 14(4)469
95
References
71 Tiwari P Tiwari S Mastering practicals community medicine 1st ed New Delhi
India Wolters Kluwer PvtLtd2013161-67
72 Boralingaiah P Bettappa P Kashyap S Prevalence of Psycho-Social Problems
among Elderly in Urban Population of Mysore City Karnataka India Indian journal
of psychological medicine 2012 Oct 34(4)360
96
PATIENT CONSENT FORM JJM MEDICAL COLLEGE DAVANGERE
DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY MEDICINE I the undersigned hereby give my consent
for investigations carried upon me I am satisfied with the information given about this
Clinical study titled ldquoA STUDY ON THE MORBIDITY PATTERN AND HEALTH
SEEKING BEHAVIOR AMONG THE GERIATRIC POULATION IN THE
URBAN FIELD PRACTICE AREA OF JJM MEDICAL COLLEGE
DAVANGERErdquo ldquoconducted by Dr RUCHI DHAR under the guidance of Dr VIDYA
GS Associate Professor I have been informed and explained the risks involved and I
hereby voluntarily and Unconditionally give my consent without any fear or pressure in
mentally sound and conscious state to participate in this study
DATE PATIENTrsquoS SIGNATURE
eEacuteeEacuteJA ordfEacuteEcirczAgravearingQAtildeAiAgraveAuml ordfAgraveAumlordmAacutelaquozAacutearingregAiAgraveAuml zAacuteordfAgravetUEacutegEacute
ryenAacutemiumlethordfEacuteAumlAmiumlDyensiumlPAgraveordfAgraveAumlAumlaringcurrenn ordfEacuteAumlrsup1poundiuml
ordfEacuteEcirczAgravearingQAtildeAiAgraveAumlvAgraveyenAacutecedilAgraveuEacuteUEacuteMbrvbaragraveUEacute yenAgravevAgraveaelig F PEacutefrac14AgraveUEacute cedilAgraveraquo ordfAgraveiAacutergAgraveAumlordfAgrave poundAacutepoundAgraveAuml CAzAgravegEacute
poundAgravepoundAgraveszlig
ordfEacuteEcirczAgravearingQAtildeAiAgraveAumlvAgraveyenAacutecedilAgraveuEacute ordmAacuteUAgraveAElig plusmnAgravecedilAgraveUcircccedilaQvEacuteigraveUEacuteAzAgraveAuml poundAgravepoundAgraveszligMbrvbaragraveUEacuteAiAgraveAumlpoundAgraveAumlszlig
cedilAgraveAEligasup1gAgraveAumlvEacuteUcircAtildepoundEacute J cedilAgraveOumlr Dyensiuml zAgrave ordfEacuteAEligcopyethrn yenAacutearinglpoundiumleth CAqiuml ordmEacutemacriumlUcirc sup1AtildeQAUiuml copyordmEacuteAtildelaquoAiAgraveAumlgiuml Dyensiuml zAgrave fjAiAgraveiAacutenaeligPiuml yenEacuteAEligAtildeyenAgraveAumlaringmacrEacuteAtildemicroAgravepoundiuml Epoundiuml zAgrave Csectethpoundiuml brvbarAtildemacriumlOslash yenAacuteaeligoumlaringQOumlAtildecediliuml JjAiAgraveAuml Dyensiuml ddordfAgraveAumlAuml ordfEacuteEcirczAgravearingQAtildeAiAgraveAuml ordfAgraveAumlordmAacutelaquozAacutearingregAiAgraveAuml zAacuteordfAgravetUEacutegEacute JAsect sup2AtildeparaethPEacuteAiAgraveAumlrAiAgraveAumldegegrave yenAgravejAtildePEacuteeumlUEacute Mfrac14AgraveyenAgravercedilAgraveAumlordfAgrave ordfEacuteEcirczAgravearinggAacutezAgrave qAacute|| gAgraveAumla zAgravesAgravegAgrave ordfAgraveAumlvAgraveAumlUcirc qAacute|| laquozAacutearing fJcediliumlordfAgraveiAacuteUAgraveethzAgraveplusmnAgraveethPAgravegAacutezAgrave yenEacuteAEligaeligAtildeyensEacutecedilAgravegiuml
EordfAgravegAgraveAuml poundAgravepoundAgraveUEacute F vAgraveyenAacutecedilAgraveuEacuteUEacute Mfrac14AgraveyenAgraveqAgraveAumlordfAgrave ordfAgraveAumlAumlpoundAgraveszlig yenAgraveaeligwAiEacuteAEligAzAgraveAuml
CAplusmnAgraveUAgravefrac14AgravepoundAgraveAumlszlig CxAgraveethordfAacuteUAgraveAumlordfAgraveAvEacute wfrac12sup1gAgraveAumlvAacuteUcircgEacuteDzAgraveYacutejAzAgrave poundAacutepoundAgraveAuml poundAgravepoundAgraveszlig
ordfAgraveAumlpoundAgravecedilAacutegEacute AiAgraveiAacuteordfAgraveAringzEacuteAtilde umlsAgraveAiAgraveAuml ordfAgraveAumlvAgraveAumlUcirc AiAgraveiAacutegAgrave MvAacuteUcircAiAgraveAumllaquoregegravezEacute poundAacutepoundAgraveAuml
vAgraveyenAacutecedilAgraveuEacute aQvEacuteigraveUEacuteAEligfrac14AgraveyenAgraveqAgraveregAuml MbrvbaragraveUEacuteAiAgraveAumlpoundAgraveAumlszlig cedilAgraveAEligasup1gAgraveAumlvEacuteUcircAtildepoundEacute
centpoundAacuteAPAgrave gEacuteAEligAtildeVAi
Annexures
ANNEXURE ndashIII
104
Annexures
PROFORMA
I General information
1 NAME
2 AGE
3 GENDER (a) Male (b) Female
4 MARITAL STATUS (a) Unmarried (b) Married (c) Widow Widower
(d) Divorced separated
5 LIVING ARRANGEMENT (a) with spouse (b) Spouse and children
(c) Children only (d) living alone (e) others
6 RELIGION (a) Hindu (b) Muslim (c) Christian (d) Others
7 ADDRESS
8 EDUCATION (a) illiterate (b) Primary school (c) higher primary
(d) secondary school (e)PUC diploma (e) Graduate (f) Postgraduate
9 OCCUPATION (a) professional (b) semi- professional (c) skilled worker
(d) Semi ndashskilled worker (e) unskilled worker (f) unemployed
10 CONTACT NUMBER
11 TYPE OF FAMILY (a) Joint (b) Nuclear (C) three generation
12 TOTAL NUMBER OF FAMILY MEMBERS
13 TOTAL FAMILY INCOME
14 PER CAPITA FAMILY INCOME
15 SOCIO ECONOMIC STATUS (Modified BG Prasad classification) I IIIIIIVV
16 DIET (a) Vegetarian (b) Mixed
17 Sleep (a) Disturbed if yes reason ______________ (b) Not disturbed
18 Bowel Regular Irregular
19 Bladder Regular Irregular
97
Annexures
20 HABITS (a) betel nut (b) tobacco (c) alcohol (d) smoking (e) others
If any of the habits present Duration (since when) _________
Frequency of consumption day_______
IIAssessment of morbidity based on history
1 Whether suffering from any chronic illness like (a) Type 2 DM (b) Hypertension
(c) Bronchial Asthma (d) TB (e) others
2 Whether suffering from cataract currently (a) Yes (b) No
3 Whether operated for cataract (a) Yes (b) No If Yes duration since operation____
4 MUSCULOSKELETAL SYSTEM
Whether the following symptoms are present
(a) Backache (b) Joint pain (c) restricted joint movements (d) pain in calves
(e) Others_________
5 RESPIRATORY SYSTEM
(a) Productive cough (b) non-productive cough (c) nasal discharge (d) breathlessness (e)
sore throat (f) sneezing
6 CARDIOVASCULAR SYSTEM
(a) Palpitations (b) chest pain (c) breathlessness
7 GASTROINTESTINAL SYSTEM
(a) Pain abdomen (b) lose stools (c) constipation (d) flatulence (e) heart burn
(f) Bleeding per rectum
8 EYE AND ADNEXA
(a) Watering (b) diminution of vision (c) redness
9 EAR
(a) Discharge (b) decreased hearing (c) Tinnitus
10 SKIN
(a) Itching (b) skin eruptions (c) scaling (d) pigmentation
98
Annexures
11 GENITO URINARY SYSTEM
(a) Burning micturition (b) increased frequency of micturition
12 GENERAL SYMPTOMS
(a) Fatigue (b) headache (c) fever
13 ANY OTHER COMPLAINTS (a) burning feet (b) swelling in groin
(c) Memory loss (d) insomnia
III Assessment of health seeking behaviour
1 Do you visit a health facility in case of illness (a) Yes (b) No
If yes how much time do you take to visit a health facility an case of an illness
(a) Within 24 hours (b) 24-48 hours (c) more than 48 hours
2 Which type of health facility do you visit
(a) Govt hospital (b) Private practitioners (c) over the counter drugs (e) quacks
Mention the reason for visiting the particular health facility______________________
3 Whether taking regular treatment after diagnosis ________________
If No mention the reason_______________________
4 Whether following the instructions given by the treating doctor
(a) Yes (b) no
5 cost of treatment per month in case of chronic disease
(a) lt100 (b) 100-200 (c) 200-300 (d) 300 and above
6 Person bearing the cost of treatment
(a) Self (b) spouse (c) son (d) daughter (d) outside help
7 Duration to reach the health facility
(a) less than 3o minutes (b) 30 minutes or more
8 Whether going for regular check -ups (a) Yes (b) No
If Yes duration between the check-ups_______
99
Annexures
9 Whether following self- care practices in case of chronic disease like diabetes and hypertension
(a) Yes (b) No
10 In case of healthy individuals whether getting screening tests done (a) Yes (b) No
11 Whether following any dietary modifications (a) yes (b) No
12 Whether any family member accompanies you to the health facility
If yes who (a) Son (b) daughter (c) spouse (d) others
11 Whether the family supports in following specific diet advised by the doctor
(a) Yes (b) No
12 whether family members help in reminding to take regular medication
(a) Yes (b) No
IV Physical examination
1 Personal hygiene status
S NO COMPONENT CONDITION REMARKS
1 Hair
2 Teeth
3 Bath
4 Clothes
5 Washing hand before
eating food
6 Washing hands with soap
and water after ablution
7 Nails
8 Foot wear
Remarks personal hygiene status Good fair poor
100
Annexures
2 MEASUREMENTS
(a) Weight (in Kg) ______ (b) Height (in cm) _____ (c) BMI ______
(d) Waist circumference______ (e) Hip circumference ___________
(f) Waist hip ratio_________
3 GENERAL PHYSICAL EXAMINATION
Pallor Icterus Cyanosis clubbing lymphadenopathy Oedema
Pulse rate Temp Blood Pressure
Respiratory rate
20 Examination of
Eye Oral cavity Ear
Nose Throat
SYSTEMIC EXAMINATION
Cardiovascular system Respiratory system
Per abdomen Central Nervous system
101
MASTER CHART
Annexures
ANNEXURES
International Classification of Diseases (10th Revision)
I Certain infectious and parasitic diseases (A00-B99)
II Neoplasms (C00-D48)
III Diseases of blood and blood forming organs and certain disorders
involving the immune mechanisms (D50-D89)
IV Endocrine nutritional and metabolic diseases (E00-E90)
V Mental and behavioural disorders (F00-F99)
VI Diseases of the nervous system (G00-G99)
VII Diseases of the eye and adnexa (H00-H59)
VIII Diseases of the ear and mastoid process ( H60-H95)
IX Diseases of the circulatory system (I00-I99)
X Diseases of the respiratory system ( J00-J99)
XI Diseases of the digestive system (K00-K93)
XII Diseases of the skin and subcutaneous tissue ( L00-L99)
XIII Diseases of the musculoskeletal system and connective tissue
(M00-M99)
XIV Diseases of the genitourinary system ( N00-N99)
XV Pregnancy childbirth and purperium (O00-O99)
XVI Certain conditions originating in perinatal period (P00-P96)
XVII Congenital malformations deformations and chromosomal
XVIII (S00-T98)
XIX External causes of morbidity and mortality (V01-Y98)
102
Annexures
XX Injury poisoning and certain other consequences of external causes
(S00-T98)
XXI Factors influencing health status and contact with health services
(Z00-Z99)
XXII Codes for special purpose
103
Annexures
105
Annexures
106
Annexures
107
Annexures
PHOTOS
Picture 1 Showing the investigator interviewing the study subject
Picture 2 Showing the investigator interacting with the study subject
108
Annexures
Picture 3 Showing the investigator recording the Blood pressure of the study subject
Picture 4 Showing the investigator auscultating the study subject
109
Annexures
110
Objectives
OBJECTIVES
1 To study the morbidity pattern among the geriatric population in the urban field
practice area of JJM Medical college Davangere
2 To assess the health seeking behaviour of the elderly residing in the study area
4
Review of literature
vii
REVIEW OF LITERATURE
1 Definition Geriatrics or clinical gerontology Is the term used for the care of the aged 11 The United Nations uses 60 years and above to refer to older people the same is also used
by demographers However in many developed countries the age of 65 is used as the
reference point for older persons 12
Elderly are classified in to 3 groups 13
Young old Persons in the age group of 60 years to 74 years
Old old Persons in the age group of 75 years to 84 years
Oldest old Persons above the age of 85 yrs
2 Demography of the ageing population in India
The UN defines a country as ldquoAgeingrdquo or ldquoGreying Nationrdquo where the
proportion of people over 60 reaches 7 percent to total population By 2011 India has
exceeded that proportion (80 percent) and is expected to reach 126 percent in 2025
The Indian population has increased from 361 million in 1951 to 1027 billion in 2001
and further to 121 billion in 2011 Simultaneously the number of older people has
increased from 19 million (ie 4 percent of total population) to 77 million and
further to roughly 93 million (ie 75 percent of the total) during the same time
span 14
5
Review of literature
Figure1 proportion of elderly in the Indian population by age groups 1961-2001 14
Table 1 Percentage share of elderly population (aged 60 years and above) in total
population by sex in India 15
Years Male Female Total Rural Urban
1961 55 58 56 58 47
1971 59 60 60 62 50
1981 64 66 65 68 54
1991 67 68 68 71 57
2001 71 78 75 77 67
2011 77 84 80 81 79
2004-05 69 75 72 73 70
2007-08 73 77 75 76 72
6
Review of literature
The rise in population of males was more modest from 55 percent to 71 percent while for
females there had been a steep rise from 58 percent to 78 percent during five decadal
Censuses from 1961 to 2001 In 2011 the elderly population accounted for 80 percent of
total population For males it was marginally lower at 77 percent while for females it was
84 percent According to NSSO surveys the proportion of elderly population in rural areas
was 73 percent during 2004-05 and increased up to 76 percent in 2007-08 While on the
other hand in urban areas the proportion of elderly population rose from 70 percent to 72
percent during the corresponding period It has been observed that the percentage share of
elderly to total population remained higher in rural areas than in urban areas15
Table2 Size of elderly population (aged 60+) and their share in total population in major states of India in 201115
All India and selected major states
Proportion of elderly in total population of State
Male Female Total Andhra Pradesh 83 94 88 Bihar 72 67 70 Gujarat 76 90 83 Haryana 66 76 71 Himachal Pradesh 104 103 104 Karnataka 79 89 84 Kerala 118 133 126 Madhya Pradesh 68 74 71 Maharashtra 88 97 93 Orissa 91 95 93 Punjab 91 100 95 Rajasthan 66 79 72 Tamil Nadu 102 109 105 Uttar Pradesh 66 71 68 West Bengal 82 82 82 All India 77 84 80
7
Review of literature
3 MORBIDITY PATTERN AMONG THE ELDERLY
Physiological Decline and Consequences of increasing age
Ageing i s a process of decline in biological functions affecting most physical
Systems The following systems are affected by ageing
(a) Atrophy of the Taste Buds and Loss of Teeth
With the increasing age the taste buds of the tongue get atrophied and as a result the
preference for food alters significantly There is also a considerable loss of teeth causing
difficulties in chewing food
(b) Changes in the Gastrointestinal Tract
As the age advances the walls of the intestine get atrophied and the motility is
markedly reduced (lazy intestine) The digestive enzymes secreted by the intestine are
also reduced Hence the partly digested food stays in the intestine for a longer period
As a result the common complaint of the elderly person is gas formation (flatulence)
and constipation
(c) Respiratory System
As the age advance there is progressive fibrosis of the lungs leading to reduced
oxygenation of the lungs and breathing difficulties
(d) Kidney and genitourinary System
The kidneys get smaller in size and the power of the kidneys to filter out the unwanted
waste products from the body is diminished The total amount of urine becomes less in
old age and thus the waste products are not adequately excreted from the body
8
Review of literature
(e) Urinary Bladder
Urinary bladder gets smaller in size due to shrinkage and as a result the accumulation
of urine even of a small amount leads to an urge for urination With increase in age
the valve in the bladder which controls the exit of urine from the bladder to urethra
gets atrophied and weak Involuntary leakage of urine occurs in case the bladder is full
or due to increase of pressure on bladder on sneezing or even on laughing a condition
known as urinary incontinence Incontinence is a common complaint of elder females
(f) Heart and Circulatory System
The blood vessels get rigid and quite often the vessel walls become rough with the
deposition of solid matters consisting mostly of cholesterol The heart muscles get weaker
and power to send blood throughout the body through the circulatory system gets less and
less powerful The most dangerous effect on heart is coronary heart disease especially
coronary thrombosis
(g) Muscular system
The muscles in the body get gradually atrophied with ageing and especially those
small muscles which are necessary for quick reflex action The elderly person can quite
be capable of working like a normal person and can undertake activities which require
big muscles of legs and arms But when it comes to quick movement which needs small
muscles for quick reflex movements these functions are impaired causing accidents
like slipping on wet floor of the bathroom
(h) Brain
With ageing the size of the brain gets smaller and the weight also becomes less This
however does not interfere with the function of the brain However in general the brain
cells and its fibers which carry impulses from brain to the system and upwards get
9
Review of literature
degenerated The most glaring manifestation of ageing affecting the brain is
forgetfulness and in simple terms it is inability of brain to recall the past experience
However this is common in all elderly persons
(i ) Bones
The bones become porous and fragile as age advances especially in elderly females This
condition is known as osteoporosis and leads to sustaining of fractures even after a minor
fall16
Figure 2 pathophysiology of health issues in geriatrics17
The common disease that the geriatric population suffers from are type 2 diabetes
coronary heart disease hypertension stroke chronic obstructive pulmonary disease
10
Review of literature
Alzheimerrsquos disease osteoarthritis osteoporosis prostatic hypertrophy cataracts macular
degeneration cancer etc and at the same time they are vulnerable to infections involving
respiratory (including TB) urinary and digestive tract17
In India the elderly people suffer from dual medical problems ie communicable and
nonndash communicable diseases There is also impairment of special sensory functions like
vision and hearing A decline in immunity and age-related physiological changes leads to
an increased burden of communicable diseases in the elderly A report by Indian Council
of Medical Research (ICMR) on the chronic morbidity profile in the elderly states that
hearing impairment is the most common morbidity followed by visual impairment
However different studies show varied results in the morbidity pattern18
Major chronic conditions affecting older people worldwide 19
Cardiovascular diseases (such as coronary heart disease) Diabetes Mellitus
Hypertension Stroke Cancer
Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease
Musculoskeletal conditions (such as arthritis and osteoporosis)
Mental health conditions (mostly dementia and depression)
Blindness and visual impairment
11
Review of literature
Health seeking behaviour
1 Definition
There is no common definition agreed upon by sociologists in any sociology literature
Different definitions may be used in different studies despite referring to the same activity
Sociology and literature assume that health seeking behaviour is influenced by the various
factors which include individual self or the individual diseases present and also the
availability and accessibility of health services Being dependent on these determinants and
their interactions it can be said that health care seeking behaviour is a very complex
outcome of various factors which operate at individual family and community level20
Health Seeking Behavior (HSB) refers to decision or an action taken by an individual to
maintain attain or regain good health and to prevent illness The decisions which are
made encompasses all available health care options like visiting a public or private and
modern or traditional health facility self-medication and use of home remedies or not to
utilize the available health services etc
Determining the health care seeking behavior is very important to provide a need
based health care services to the population Visiting official channels in a formally
recognized health care system has been considered as the desired Health seeking behaviour
Health seeking behavior is influenced by multiple factors including availability quality and
price of services and also social groups health views residences and personal features of the
users Peoplersquos choice of health care differs in socio demographic socio-economic and
cultural compositions and this has an effect on their health seeking behavior Urban dwellers
are generally believed to be open to new ideas and willing to try certain things on a trial and
error basis21
12
Review of literature
Health seeking behaviours two approaches
(a) Health seeking behaviours utilization of the system
This approach focuses on the actions which are taken to rectify perceived ill health and
the type of health care facility which is utilized by the people There is data which
suggests that the people visit more traditional healers and unofficial medical channels
this should be prevented and the emphasis s h o u l d b e on encouraging people to opt
first for the official channels
(b) Health seeking behaviours the process of illness response
This approach considers the factors which enable or prevent people from making
healthy choices either i n their lifestyle behaviours or use of medical care and
treatment22
Figure 3 Predicting health behaviour with social cognition models 22
13
Review of literature
2 Health belief Model of health seeking behaviour
Since lsquoHealth seekingrsquo is a conditioned behaviour any attempt which is made to
encourage people to seek health care definitely requires an understanding of their
motivation for such behaviour Only through a deeper understanding of the intricate
factors shaping behavioural practices can health promotion programmes and or
interventions successfully be introduced into the realities of the peoplersquos lives to bring
about changes in health behaviour
Behaviour change theories and models such as the Health Belief Model (HBM)
Theory of Reasoned Action (TRA) Theory of Planned Behaviour (TPB) and the
Trans theoretical model have been widely applied in public health in an attempt to
explain or predict health seeking behaviours Their use enables identification and
understanding of peoplersquos health-seeking behaviour beyond their knowledge attitudes
and practices
HBM is a health specific behavioural cognitive model This model is based on the
idea that people are more likely to change their behaviour and adhere to treatments
if they have the following perceptions (i) have a perception that they are at risk of
contracting the disease (perceived susceptibility) (ii) perception that the disease
might have an unfavorable outcome (perceived severity) (iii) perceive that the
proposed health behaviour to be both effective and practical (perceived benefits)
(iv) perceive the barriers to adopting the behaviour to be minimal (perceived
barriers)(v) perceive themselves to have the ability of applying and practicing the
specific behaviour proposed (perceived self-efficacy) and (vi) they have the cues
for motivating their actions such as internal cues (pain symptoms past experiences)
or external cues (advice from friends relatives and mass media campaigns) (cues to
14
Review of literature
action) The specificity of the HBM to health has made it suitable for use in
understanding and explaining the behaviour as well as health outcomes and this may also
explain its wider use in public health2 3
Figure 4 Health belief model components and linkages 23
3 Factors influencing health seeking behaviour
The factors affecting the health seeking behaviours are seen in various contexts which
include physical socio-economic cultural and political factors Therefore the utilization of
a health care system whether public or private formal or non- formal may depend on socio-
demographic factors social structures level of education cultural beliefs and practices and
some other factors like gender discrimination status of women economic and political
systems environmental conditions and the disease pattern and health care system itself also
have an impact on the health seeking behaviour24
15
Review of literature
REVIEW OF RELATED STUDIES
A study done by Sanjay Polisetty and Madhavi Seepana (2017) on the morbidity profile
of elderly individuals in urban Visakhapatnam revealed that of the 270 study participants
about 996 suffered from either some form of acute or chronic morbidity More than 70
of individuals suffered from eye problems of which most common problem was cataract
seen in 60 About 304 had difficulties in chewing and 256 had difficulty in hearing
Hypertension was present in 49 of individuals and 742 of Diabetics were also found to
be hypertensive25
A study done by Swapnil Jain et al (2016) on Morbidity pattern among geriatric
population in urban field practice area of a district in Maharashtra revealed 653 suffered
from hearing impairment 62 were anemic 462 had hypertension 423 had joint
pain 41 had dental problems 38 7 had cataract and 318 had chronic bronchitis It
was seen that 81 of the subjects had multiple morbidities 26
A study done by Rajat Das Gupta et al (2016) in an urban area of Bangladesh on Morbidity
pattern and health-seeking behavior among the senior citizens revealed that of the 384 study
participants 968 were suffering from at least one medical problem The commonest was
musculoskeletal problems in 8411 followed by eye problems in 8125 It was found that
all the respondents sought treatment for their health problems 33 respondents went to
Government hospitals to seek medical help 6927 respondents took prescribed
medications and 567 were satisfied with their treatment 27
16
Review of literature
A study done by Md Alam Naushad et al (2016) on Morbidity pattern and health
seeking behavior in elderly population of Raipur City Chhattisgarh revealed that the
prevalence of morbidity among elderly was 9531 Out of total morbid population some
chronic illness was present in 7049 Gastro intestinal system was involved in 8262
followed by eye in 7983 and Cardiovascular system in 5245 It was found that 3552
of the subjects sought treatment from private registered practitioners 28
A study done by Sribas Goswami and Manjari Sahai (2016) in Raipur city on Morbidity
Pattern in elderly Population revealed that out of total study population of 640 elderly
subjects 610 (9531) suffered from some morbidity Prevalence among females was
9892 whereas among males it was 9026 Out of various agencies 3552 subjects
were utilizing private facility followed by 2785 who were utilizing Government agency
2631 visited quacks and 1030 were taking treatment from other source 29
A study done by Harsh Bardhan et al (2016) on the Morbidity profile of elderly population
in Ghaziabad district revealed that in geriatric population 5008 suffered from
musculoskeletal problems 5877 had dental problems and impairment of vision was seen
in 5561 The overall prevalence of diabetes and heart disease were 10 and 122
respectively 236 subjects reported the problem of loneliness and depression
forgetfulness was also reported by 3296 As far as treatment seeking behavior is
concerned approach of elderly is quite different for different morbidities The main source
of treatment for morbidities such as hypertension respiratory urinary GIT-related and
musculoskeletal problems was quacks 30
17
Review of literature
A study done by Mohammad Maharoof et al (2016) on the health problems among
the aged in Urban Aligarh UP revealed that of the 225 study subjects 782 had cataract
followed by depression in 356 refractive error in 276 loco-motor problem in 213
and hearing loss in 138 The prevalence of hearing loss was significantly related to gender
as it was higher among females with 181 compared to males in whom it was 6931
A study done by Gowri Shankar and Bhayalaxmi Sidenur (2016) on morbidity of
elderly residing in an urban area of Bagalkot revealed that the most common morbidity was
Cataract seen in 2875 followed by musculoskeletal problems in 2813 and 2313
were known hypertensive Both diabetes mellitus and hypertension was observed in 10 of
the study subjects32
A study done by Leena Rahul Salunkhe (2015) on socio-demographic profile of old
age people living in urban amp urban slum areas in Maharashtra Karad revealed that 504
and 42 elderly suffered from arthritis in an urban area and a slum respectively Number of
diabetics were higher in urban (14) than urban slum (35) 301 of subjects from urban
area suffered from hypertension compared to 161 from urban slums Upper Respiratory
Infections was more in slum dwellers (196) than people residing in urban area (7) Acid
peptic diseases were found in 168 study subjects in urban area and 154 in slum area 33
In a study done by Warbhe Priyanka A and Warbhe Rupesh (2015) on morbidity
profile health seeking behaviour and home environment survey of the elderly in an urban
slum community it was found that 941 had 1-3 morbidities 41 had 4-6 morbidities
373 gave a history of fall and 314 had history of fracture 136 subjects had been
18
Review of literature
operated for cataract 168 had undergone a procedure for fracture and10 had undergone
a dental procedure 542 went to Urban health center (UHC) and Government hospitals for
treatment and 786 received both allopathic and Ayurvedic treatment34
A study done by Man Mohan Gupta et al (2015) on Assessment of Clinico-
socioeconomic status and health-care support among the elderly people aged older than 60
years in urban population of Bhopal revealed that 353 subjects received treatment for
their morbidities from the Government hospitals whereas 267 from private
clinichospital About 653 study subjects presented with complaints and morbidity The
common morbidities which were found in the subjects were fatigue (487) backache
(353) Obesity (393) and hypertension (247)35
In a study done by Shilpa Shaukaiah et al (2015) on prevalence of morbidity pattern
among geriatric age group in an urban slum of Mumbai it was found that body ache was the
most commonly reported symptom by 290 followed by visual problems in 2318 joint
pain in 2181 indigestion in 2045 and backache in 2045 subjects36
A study done by Shubha Davalagi B et al (2015) on morbidity psycho-social profile and
health seeking behavior of the elderly population in urban slums of Davangere City revealed
that the most common morbidity which was present in the study subjects was
musculoskeletal problems in 46 psychosocial problems were present in 31 and
respiratory problems in 23 Majority of the elderly (56) utilized government
institutions for treatment of chronic disease and 47 for treatment of acute disease The
elderly population had financial constraints and lack of accessibility in seeking health care37
19
Review of literature
A study done by Vandana Nikumb et al ( 2015) on morbidity Profile among Geriatric
Population in an Urban Area of Navi Mumbai revealed that 9312 elderly were morbid and
with increasing age the number of morbidities was found to be increasing In this study it
was found that the most common morbidity was psychosocial problems which include
stress which was present in 594 subjects followed by musculoskeletal problems in
556 and eye problems like diminished vision mostly due to cataract in 463
Hypertension dental problems respiratory problems ENT problems (hearing impairment)
and endocrine disorders like diabetes accounted for 281 219 119 106 and10
respectively38
A study done by Vishnoi BR et al (2015) on Morbidity Profile of Elderly in Urban
Slum of Udaipur Rajasthan revealed that 61 of the study subjects had impaired vision
followed by 25 who had hypertension 1533 suffered from insomnia 1467 had
anemia and 14 suffered from gastrointestinal problems The condition of females was
worse compared to males39
In a study done by L Subedhi and RB Sah (2015) on the health status of geriatric age
group in Chitwan district of Nepal it was found that of the 300 study subjects 44 had
Ophthalmic problems 43 had GIT problems 33 had CVS problems 23 had ENT
problems 1567 had metabolic disorders and 533 had mental disorders The study
highlighted a high prevalence of morbidity and health related problems in the geriatric age
group40
20
Review of literature
A study done by Sofia Noor et al (2015) on health status of geriatric population in slums
of Rourkela revealed that the morbidities among the elderly that were found to be significant
were hypertension decreased visual acuity urinary problems and insomnia Apart from
systemic morbidities 91 of the elderly also complained of fragility which includes
complex physiological deterioration and unexplained weight loss41
In a study conducted by VM Sarode (2014) on Chronic Diseases Related to Ageing and
Disease Prevention in Slums in Mumbai it was found that there were highly significant
disorders among aged women related to Skin lesion and super infection Untreated bacterial
pharyngitis acute rheumatic fever while disorders among aged men were related to
hypertension Illicit drug use diabetes and asthma It was found that 49 of elderly males
and 45 of elderly females had not sought any treatment for their illness Of the people who
had sought treatment 93 elderly males and 92 of elderly females had taken treatment
from Government hospital42
A study conducted by Sanjeev Kumar Barman et al (2014) on morbidity profile of
geriatric population in an urban slum of Kishnganj Bihar revealed that the prevalence of
anemia cataract and hypertension were quite high 6375 6125 and 5063
respectively Loss of income amp occupation along with a feeling of neglect from the family
members were the common problems among the elderly It was also found that morbidities
like arthritis loss of teeth amp dental caries along with depression had a significant association
with sex age amp educational status of the study subjects43
21
Review of literature
A study done by Khadervali Nagoor et al (2014) on the health status of elderly
population in an urban area of Kadapa revealed that out of the 200 elderly persons studied
Visual problem due to cataract and refractive errors were present in 72 of the study
subjects followed by pain in joints in 595 gastrointestinal problems in 46 and dental
problems in 44 Other morbidities were hypertension in 42 genitourinary problems in
25 dermatological problems in 235 and psychological problems in 1644
A study done by Kakkar R et al (2013) on morbidity profile among geriatric population
in District Dehradun revealed that the working geriatric group was healthy as compared to
those who were retired Hypertension was the commonest morbidity among all age groups
In the age group of 60-70 years the following morbidities were seen hypertension (306)
followed by diabetes (153) arthritis (14) CVS morbidities (14) cataract (96) and
BPH (83) Among 71-80 years age group Hypertension (287) followed by arthritis
(167) cataract (157) Diabetes (111) BPH (111) and CVS morbidities (93)45
In a study done by Bhawalkar JS et al (2013) on morbidity profile among geriatric
population in an urban area of Pune it was found that Musculoskeletal disorder was the
most common (4331) followed by eye problems (3722) and hypertension (137)It
was seen that 43 elderly population had some health problem but only 8 visited the
health facilities Among them 6 visited private practitioners and only 18 went to
municipal hospitals It was found that only 2322 elderly were taking any medications and
the most commonly used drug was anti-inflammatory drugs 2323 followed by
antihypertensive drugs 136746
22
Review of literature
A study conducted by Deepak Sharma et al (2013) on morbidity pattern and health-
seeking behavior of aged population residing in Shimla revealed that the following
morbidities were present in the study subjects hypertension was the commonest (56)
followed by Musculoskeletal problems (535) Dental problems (27) cataract (23)
anemia (15) and acid peptic disease (175) 658 of the subjects were seeking
treatment for their health problems Majority of the older people preferred allopathic
medicine (812) followed by Ayurvedic medicines (113) and homeopathic medicine
(73) for their health problems Most of the older persons preferred going to a
CHCGovernment hospital for treatment for their illness There was considerable use of
over-the-counter drug by125 of the people 47
A study done by JP Singh et al (2013) on Geriatric morbidity profile in an urban slum of
Nagpur central India revealed that the most common morbidity identified in the study
population was anemia (9650) followed by hypertension (345) arthritis (3225)
cataract (21) and diabetes (1775) More than 2 morbidities were present in 325 of
the study subjects followed by four morbidities in 3125 and two morbidities in 23548
A study conducted by RP Thakur et al (2013) on the health problems of the elderly in
central India revealed that among the elderly residing in the urban areas 384 of the urban
elderly had both dental problems and arthritis followed by anemia in 348 hypertension in
266 cataract in 252 and diabetes mellitus in 157 The prevalence of self-reported
depression was 672 among the urban female elderly when compared to 397 among the
urban females49
23
Review of literature
A study done by Mrinal Ranjan Srivastav et al (2013) on Morbidity Status and its
Social determinants among elderly population of Lucknow revealed that the most common
morbidity among the urban population was eye problems which affected 516 males and
67 females followed by CVS problems in 363 males and 395 females and GIT
problems in 315males and 382 females50
A study done by Shraddha K et al (2012) on morbidity pattern among elderly in urban
population of Mysore revealed that out of the 526 study subjects 486 suffered from the
disease of the eye and adnexa followed by 384 who suffered from endocrine and
metabolic disorders 331 suffered from the disease of the circulatory system 323 had
disease of the oral cavity and salivary glands and 302 had disease of the musculoskeletal
system 51
A study done by Vimala Thomas et al (2012) on morbidity profile and health seeking
behaviour of the elderly in urban slums of Hyderabad revealed that hypertension was the
most common morbidity in 469 followed by Arthritis in 302 Diabetes in 265
respiratory problems in 243 and Cataract in 21 For out-patient treatment 472 visited
private sectors 303 Government facility 25 RMP and 06 AYUSH clinics For in-
patient treatment 198 visited private institutions 16 visited Government institutions
while 642 did not visit either52
24
Review of literature
A study done by Soe Moe et al (2012) on health seeking behaviour of elderly in
Myanmar revealed that 35 of the male elderly perceived that they were having good
health status whereas 229 of them perceived having a poor health status 343 of female
elderly perceived that they were having good health status while 24 of them perceived
having a poor health About 49 of the elderly went to rural health center for treatment
followed by 33 who went to private practitioners 15 visited hospitals and 3 went to
more than one place for treatment53
A study done by Dharamvir Ranjan Bharati et al (2011) in Puducherry revealed that in
the urban areas about 707 of the study subjects had anemia followed by 537 who had
visual impairment and hypertension and 532 suffered from diabetes mellitus It was seen
that On univariate analysis the risk of diabetes mellitus was significantly higher among
elderly from urban areas than that among elderly from rural areas and significantly lower
risk in elderly from below poverty line than in those belonging to normal (not below poverty
line)54
A study done by Rajashree Bhat et al (2011) on the morbidity pattern among the elderly
population in Ahmedabad revealed that most common morbidity of elderly was the
problems of loco-motor system (486) followed by vision (427) and hypertension
(344) In this study only 37 of elderly had psychosocial problems55
A study done by Krishnamachari Srinivasan et al (2010) in an urban area of Bangalore
revealed that 494 subjects had hypertension 323 had diabetes 281 had arthritis
279 suffered from Genitourinary and cardiovascular disease It was observed that about
25
Review of literature
49 of the respondents made less than three physician visits and 13 were hospitalized for
health related problems during the past one year 56
A study done by Kajal Srivastava et al (2010) on the morbidity pattern of the elderly in
urban Agra revealed that 9529 of the elderly were morbid in the slum areas The most
common morbidity which was seen among the elderly people residing in urban slums was
anemia which was seen in 3843 followed by cataract in 298 arthritis in 2431 and
hearing impairments in 2157The system wise distribution of the morbidity pattern
showed the most common systemic involvement was visual disorders 5216 followed by
musculoskeletal system 4784 and the gastrointestinal system 4314 The number of
morbidities was found to be increasing with age and this association with age was
statistically significant57
A study done by Abdullah Ladha et al (2009) on the health seeking behaviour of elderly
population in a poor-urban community of Karachi Pakistan revealed that 164 of the
elderly people were Diabetic and 301 had Hypertension The Common symptoms that
prompted elderly of to seek health care were fever (612) generalized body aches (434)
and cough (404) About 614 responders reported factors which deterred them from
seeking health care out of which 62 reported financial constraint as the commonest factor
Deterrence from seeking health care was associated with illiteracy and living alone58
26
Methodology METHODOLOGY
The study was conducted in the urban field practice area of JJM Medical college
Davangere The city of Davangere is situated in the central part of Karnataka state
265 km north of the state capital Bengaluru along the national highway number 4
Figure 5 Maps showing the location of Davangere district and the area where the
UHTC is located
27
Methodology
Figure 6 Map showing the Urban field practice area of JJM medical college
28
Methodology
Table 3 List of areas covered under the UHTC of JJM Medical
College Davangere
Areas covered Total population Bethur road 1374 Hedge nagar 1213 Mehboob nagar 3042 Mustafa nagar A 2093 B D layout A 1084 Mustafa nagar B 1127 Mahavir nagar 930 Muddabovi colony 1094 Maganhalli 1221 Tippu nagar 968 B D layout B 1717 Batti layout 1080
STUDY AREA The study was conducted in the urban field practice area of JJM
Medical College Davangere which consists of 12 areas with a total population of
16943
STUDY DESIGN Cross sectional study
STUDY POPULATION Persons aged 60 years and above
Total Population Covered 16943
29
Methodology
INCLUSION CRITERIA subjects aged 60 years and above living in the study area
for more than one year duration
EXCLUSION CRITERIA Subjects who we r e no t w i l l i ng t o pa r t i c ipa t e i n
t he s t udy
STUDY PERIOD 1 year from 1st December 2015 to 30th November 2016
SAMPLE SIZE As quoted by Manmohan Gupta et al 35 in the studies done in various
parts of India the prevalence of morbidity in the geriatric population ranges from 31-80
Considering the prevalence of morbidity to be about 50 in the geriatric population at 95
confidence level and allowable error of 10 and a non -response rate of 10 sample size
was calculated to be 440 using the formula
n=4pq L2
n= sample size
4= factor to achieve 95 level of confidence
p= prevalence of morbidities ie 50
q= 100- p ie 100-50 = 50
L= permissible error in the estimate of ldquoprdquo (10 of p)
n = 4 x 50 x 50 = 400
5 x 5
After calculating a non-response rate of 10 a sample size of 440 was calculated
30
Methodology
A community based cross sectional study was conducted in the urban field practice
area of JJM Medical College Davangere The Urban field practice area has a total
population of 16943 and there are 12 areas in urban field practice area of JJM Medical
College Davangere
The Study was conducted by probability proportionate sampling The sample size for each
area was derived from the formula
1198991 =119875119900119901119906119897119886119905119894119900119899 119894119899 119890119886119888ℎ 119886119903119890119886
119879119900119905119886119897 119875119900119901119906119897119886119905119894119900119899119883 119878119886119898119901119897119890 119878119894119911119890
Example 1st area has a population of 1374 so
1198991 =1374
16943119883 440 = 36
Therefore 36 elderly subjects were selected by house to house visit from 1st area Same
procedure was applied for other areas until the desired sample size of 440 was reached
MATERIALS USED FOR DATA COLLECTION
The following tools were used for data collection
Semi-structured predesigned and pre-tested questionnaire
Portable bathroom weighing machine
Stretch- resistant measuring tape
Mercury Sphygmomanometer
Others - stethoscope torch tuning fork knee hammer
ICD-10 for system wise classification of disease59
31
Methodology METHOD OF COLLECTION OF DATA After establishing rapport with the family
and explaining the data collection procedure in the local language an informed verbal
consent was obtained from each individual and data was collected using a
Predesigned semi structured questionnaire by Interview method The questionnaire
comprised of the following information socio-demographic data of the study subjects
information regarding the morbidity pattern and health seeking behaviour If there were
more than one elderly subjects in the same household then all were included
The study subjects were asked about any ho illness (communicable or non-
communicable) which they were suffering from Upon a positive response the subjects were
further asked to specify the type(s) and duration of morbidities that they were suffering
from eg heart disease diabetes gastrointestinal diseases respiratory disease etc Some
were unable to understand or answer questions due to illness In such cases help was sought
from the family members Based on the self-reported symptoms information from
hospital records and clinical examination the prevalence of different morbidities among the
study subjects was assessed The Information about the health seeking behaviour was
sought by asking the study subjects about their visits to a health facility in case of an illness
and also the type of health facility visited ( Government private or quacks )
DATA ENTRY AND ANALYSIS Data was entered and analyzed using MS Excel and
Open Epi Info version 2260 Both descriptive and inferential statistics were used Subjectrsquos
baseline characteristics were presented as frequencies and percentages Categorical
variables between the groups were compared using Chi square test and Fisherrsquos exact
test Fisherrsquos exact test was used when more than 20 cells had expected value lt 5 and any
one of the cells had expected value lt 1 All statistical analysis was carried out at 5 level
of significance and p value lt005 was considered as significant
32
Methodology ETHICAL CLEARANCE
Ethical clearance was obtained before conducting the study from the Ethical Committee of
JJM Medical college Davangere [ANNEXURE III] During the study verbal
informed consent was taken from the study subjects Assurance was given that the
confidentiality concerning their information will be maintained
Clinical Examination included
(a) General physical examination
(b) Anthropometric measurements like height and weight
(c) Systemic examination
(d) Measurement of Blood pressure
(e) Eye examination by torch and Snellenrsquos (E chart)61
(f) Hearing assessment by Rinnersquos test Webberlsquos and Absolute bone conduction
test using tuning fork 62
Parameters used in our study
Height Height was measured with a standard non-stretchable measuring tape to the
nearest 01 cm in standing position (without footwear standing upright with the
back against the wall heels together and eyes directed forward)
33
Methodology Weight Weight was measured with minimal clothing and respecting the modesty of the
individual without footwear using a calibrated standard bathroom weighing scale to the
nearest 05 kg
Body Mass Index (BMI) Using weight (in Kg) and height (in meter2) BMI was calculated by applying the formula
Body Mass Index= Weight (kg) Height (m2)
The BMI cut off values for Asians as recommended by the WHO was used in our study
Table 4 WHO Categorization of Body Mass index (BMI) for Asians 63
Measurement of Blood pressure Procedure Blood pressure was measured in the left arm in a sitting posture with the subject in a
relaxed state Standardized mercury sphygmomanometer with adult size cuff was used
The first appearance of (phase 1 of Korotkoff sounds) sound was used to define
Systolic Blood Pressure (SBP) The disappearance of sound (phase 5) was used to
define Diastolic Blood Pressure (DBP) Two readings were taken five minutes apart and
the average of the two readings was taken as the final blood pressure reading A person
was considered to be a hypertensive if he she was already diagnosed case of
hypertension and or on treatment or with a current SBP of ge 140 mm Hg or DBP ge 90 mm
Hg (JNC VII criteria)64
BODY MASS INDEX INFERENCE
lt 185 underweight
185 to 229 kg m2 Normal
23 to 249 kg m2 Overweight
ge 25 kg m2 Obese
34
Methodology
Table 5 JNC VII Classification of Blood pressure 65
BP Classification Systolic Blood Pressure Diastolic Blood Pressure
Normal lt120 lt 80
Pre Hypertension 120 ndash 139 or 80 ndash 89 Stage 1 Hypertension 140 ndash 159 or 90 ndash 99 Stage 2 Hypertension ge 160 or ge 100
Anaemia was detected by pallor of conjunctiva tongue and nails and was confirmed by
doing haemoglobin estimation using sahlirsquos hemogobinometer66
The cut off for the diagnosis of anaemia was done based on WHO classification67
Diabetes - self reported cases of diabetes were considered as diabetics for the study
STUDY VARIABLES
1 AGE - subjects aged 60 years and above were taken up for the study Age was
recorded to the nearest complete years as stated by the respondent
2 GENDER Both males and females were taken up for the study
3 EDUCATIONAL STATUS 68
i Illiterate -A person who could not read or write
ii Primary School - studied up to 4th standard
iii Higher primary- studied between 5th and 7th standard
iv Secondary school -studied between 8th and 10th standard v Intermediate- studied between 11th or 12 th standard or diploma
vi Graduate - obtained graduate degree
vii Post Graduate- obtained post graduate degree
35
Methodology
4 OCCUPATION STATUS69
i Unskilled worker
Labourer domestic servants casual worker peon sweeper porter washer-man others
(vegetable vendor)
ii Semi-skilled worker
Factory worker agriculture laborers shoemaker potters others (security guard shop
helper canteen helper
iii Skilled
Artisan clerk foreman supervisor carpenter tailor mechanic electrician railway guard
painter modeler smiths baker driver shop assistant petty trader constable soldier
linesman pointsman potter barber others (tinkering printer receptionist salesman
welder cook mason postman plumber agarbatti worker)
iv semi-professional
Teacher pharmacist social worker owner of a small business farmer others (computer
programmer Govt employee nurse)
V Professional
Doctor engineer principal lawyer Military officer senior executive business
proprietor writer scientist large employer director university professor police
officer others (horse rider)
(vi) Unemployed Presently not working retired homemakers
36
Methodology 5 SOCIO ECONOMIC STATUS
Table 6 Socio-economic status (SES)- As per modified BG Prasad Classification70
5 TYPE OF FAMILY 71
Joint Family ndash It is type of family grouping in which a number of married couples and
their children live together in the same household All the men are related by blood
and women of household are their wives unmarried girls and widows of family kinsmen
Nuclear Family - It consist of married couple and their children while they are still
regarded as dependents
Three generation family - It is a family where representatives of three generation are
living together Young married couples continue to stay with their parents and have
their own children as well
Socio-economic
status
Prasadrsquos classification
1961(Per capita income in
Rupees per month)
Modified BG Prasad classification-
updated for May 2016 ((per
capita income in Rupees per
month)
I 100 and above 6261 and above
II 50-99 3099-6260
III 30-49 1835-3098
IV 15-29 949-1834
V Below 15 lt948
37
SAMPLE SIZE ESTIMATION
SAMPLE SIZE As quoted by Manmohan Gupta et al 35 in the studies done in various
parts of India the prevalence of morbidity in the geriatric population ranges from 31-80
Considering the prevalence of morbidity to be about 50 in the geriatric population at 95
confidence level and allowable error of 10 and a non -response rate of 10 sample size
was calculated to be 440 using the formula
n=4pq L2
n= sample size
4= factor to achieve 95 level of confidence
p= prevalence of morbidities ie 50
q= 100- p ie 100-50 = 50
L= permissible error in the estimate of ldquoprdquo (10 of p)
n = 4 x 50 x 50 = 400
5 x 5
After calculating a non-response rate of 10 a sample size of 440 was calculated
A community based cross sectional study was conducted in the urban field practice area of
JJM Medical College Davangere The Urban field practice area has a total population of
16943 and there are 12 areas in urban field practice area of JJM Medical College
Davangere
The Study was conducted by probability proportionate sampling The sample size for each area
was derived from the formula
1198991 =119875119900119901119906119897119886119905119894119900119899 119894119899 119890119886119888ℎ 119886119903119890119886
119879119900119905119886119897 119875119900119901119906119897119886119905119894119900119899119883 119878119886119898119901119897119890 119878119894119911119890
Example 1st area has a population of 1374 so
1198991 =1374
16943119883 440 = 36
Therefore 36 elderly subjects were selected by house to house visit from 1st area Same
procedure was applied for other areas until the desired sample size of 440 was reached
Results
RESULTS
The results are presented under the following headings
I Socio-demographic characteristics of study subjects
II Prevalence of morbidities among the study subjects
III Details of health seeking behavior of the study subjects
38
Results
ISocio-demographic characteristics of the study subjects
Table 7 Age and sex wise distribution of the study subjects
Figure 7 Age and sex wise distribution of the study subjects
In the present study Out of 440 study subjects majority 162(368) were in the age group
of 60-64 Years followed by 109 (247) in the age group of 65-69 Years 99 (225) were
in the age group of 70-74 Years and 35 (8) were more than or equal to 80 years of age
Majority of the subjects were males 260 (59) and 180 (41) were females The mean age
of the study population was 6745 plusmn 655 Years
354 254 262
88 42
389
239 172
67 133
0102030405060708090
100
60-64 65-69 70-74 75-79 ge80
Perc
enta
ge
Age in years
Males
Females
Age group (in years)
Males Females Total
Percentage () Frequency
(n=260) Percentage ()
Frequency (n=180)
Percentage ()
60-64 92 354 70 389 162 368
65-69 66 254 43 239 109 247
70-74 68 262 31 172 99 225
75-79 23 88 12 67 35 80
ge80 11 42 24 133 35 80
Total 260 100 180 100 440 100
39
Results
Table 8 Distribution of the study subjects based on religion
Religion Frequency (n=440) Percentage ()
Hindu 188 427
Muslim 252 573
Total 440 100
Figure 8 Distribution of the study subjects based on religion
In the present study it was found that the majority of the study subject belonged to Muslim
religion 252 (573) followed by Hindus 188 (427)
0102030405060708090
100
Hindu Muslim
427
573
Perc
enta
ge
Religion of the study subjects
40
Results
Table 9 Distribution of the study subjects based on Educational status
Education Frequency (n=440) Percentage ()
Illiterate 231 525
Primary school 121 275
Higher primary 38 86
Secondary School 30 68
Intermediate 6 14
Graduate 14 32
Total 440 100
Figure 9 Distribution of the study subjects based on Educational status
In the present study it was found that the Majority of the study subjects were illiterate
231(525) 121(275) had completed education up to primary school 30(68) had
completed education up to secondary school and only 14(32) were graduates
525
275
86 68
14 32
0102030405060708090
100
Perc
enta
ge
Educational status of study subjects
41
Results Table 10 Distribution of the study subjects based on occupation
Occupation Frequency (n=440) Percentage ()
Semi-professional 2 05
Skilled worker 45 102
Semi-skilled worker 68 155
Unskilled worker 100 227
Unemployed 225 511
Total 440 100
Figure 10 Distribution of study subjects based on their occupation
In our study it was found that the majority of the study subjects 225 (511) were
unemployed followed by 100 (227) who were unskilled workers 68 (155) were semi-
skilled workers and 45 (102) were skilled workers
0102030405060708090
100
05 102 155 227
511
Perc
enta
ge
Occupation of the study subjects
42
Results Table 11 Distribution of the study subjects based on socio-economic status (Modified
BG Prasad classification 2016)
Figure 11 Distribution of the study subjects based on their socio-economic status
In our study majority of the subjects 215 (49) belonged to Class IV Socioeconomic status
followed by 115 (26) who belonged to class III and 56 (13) who belonged to class II
SES (according to Modified BG Prasad Classification 2016)
Class II 13
Class III 26
Class IV 49
Class V 12
Socio-economic status Frequency (n=440) Percentage ()
Class I 0 0
Class II 56 13
Class III 115 26
Class IV 215 49
Class V 54 12
Total 440 100
43
Results
Table 12 Distribution of the study subjects based on their marital status
Marital status Frequency (n=440) Percentage ()
Unmarried 2 05
Married 323 734
Widowwidower 115 261
Total 440 100
Figure 12 Distribution of the study subjects based on their marital status
In our study it was found that majority of the study subjects 323(734) were married
followed by 115(261) who were widowed and only 2 (05) were unmarried
0102030405060708090
100
Unmarried married Widowwidower
05
734
261 Perc
enta
ge
44
Results
Table 13 Distribution of the study subjects based on the type of family
Type of family Frequency (n=440) Percentage ()
Nuclear family 163 37
Joint family 93 21
Three generation family 184 42
Total 440 100
Figure 13 Distribution of the study subjects based on the type of family
In the present study it was found that majority of the study subjects 184 (42) lived in a
three generation family followed by 163 (37) who lived in a nuclear family and 93(21)
who lived in a Joint family
Nuclear family 37
Joint family 21
Three generation
family 42
45
Results
II Prevalence of morbidities among the study subjects
Figure 14 Distribution of the study subjects based on the BMI
In the present study it was found that out of 440 study subjects 198 (45) had a normal
BMI followed by 132 (30) who were overweight 66 (15) were obese and only 44
(10) were underweight
under weight 10
Normal 45
Overweight 30
Obese 15
46
Results
Table 14 Distribution of morbidity pattern of the study subjects based on ICD 10
classification of diseases
System involved ICD 10
Males (n=260)
Females (n=180)
Total (n=440)
No No No
Diseases of musculoskeletal system (M00 ndash M99)
184 707 130 722 314 714
Diseases of the eye and adnexa (H00 ndash H59)
139 534 80 444 219 497
Diseases of oral cavityamp salivary glands (K00 ndash K14)
90 346 64 355 154 35
Endocrine nutritional amp metabolic diseases (E00 ndash
E90)
70 269 75 417 145 329
Diseases of circulatory system (I00 ndash I99)
64 246 73 405 137 311
Diseases of respiratory system(J00 ndash J99)
64 246 37 206 101 23
Diseases of digestive system (K00 ndash K93)
57 219 30 166 87 198
Diseases of skin amp subcutaneous tissue (L00 ndash
L99)
38 146 20 111 58 132
Diseases of the ear and mastoid process (H60 ndashH95)
39 15 18 10 57 13
Diseases of genitourinary system (N00 ndash N99)
22 85 7 39 29 66
Diseases of nervous system (G00 ndash G99)
6 23 5 28 11 25
Note Total number could not be given as many subjects had multiple disorders
47
Results
Figure 15 Distribution of morbidity pattern of the study subjects based on ICD 10
classification of diseases
In the present study it was found that the majority of the subjects 314 (714) suffered
from the disorders of the musculoskeletal system followed by 219 (497) who suffered
from the disease of the eye and adnexa154 (35) suffered from the disease of the oral
cavity 145 (329) suffered from endocrine nutritional and metabolic disorders137
(311) suffered from the disease of the circulatory system 101 (229) suffered from the
disease of the respiratory system 87(198) suffered from the disease of the digestive
system 58 (132) suffered from disease of the skin 57 (13) suffered from the disease of
the ear 29 (66) suffered from the disease of the genitourinary system and only 11( 25 )
suffered from the disease of the nervous system
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
714
497
35 329 311 229
198 132 13 66
25
perc
enta
ge
48
Results
Table 15 Distribution of the study subjects based on morbidity of the musculoskeletal
system
Musculoskeletal
Disease
Males
(n=260)
Females
(n=180)
Total
(n= 440)
Statistical
Value
Knee joint pain
52 (20)
30 (167)
82 (186)
X2 = 0779
df = 1
p=03773
Back ache
30 (115)
35 (194)
65 (148) X2 = 528
df = 1
p = 0021
Joint pain (other than
knee joint pain)
52(20)
35(194)
87(198)
X2 =00206
df=1
p =0885
Non-specific aches
and pain
50(192)
30(167)
80(182)
X2=0470
df=1
p = 0492
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses
In the present study it was found that the most common morbidity of musculoskeletal
system was pain of the joints (other than the knee joint) found in 87 (198) of the subjects
followed by knee joint pain in 82 ( 186) and non-specific pains and aches were found in
80 (182) of the subjects It was found that back ache was more common in females
35(194) compared to males 30 (115) and this difference was found to be statistically
significant
49
Results
Table 16 Distribution of the study subjects based on morbidity of the eye and adnexa
Diseases of the
eye and
adnexa
Males
(n=260)
Females
(n=180)
Total
(n= 440)
Statistical
value
Cataract
112(43)
60(333)
172(391)
X2 = 4241
df=1
p = 0039
Refractive error
20(77)
14(78)
34(77)
X2= 0001
df=1
p = 0973
Others (conjunctivitis
pterygium glaucoma etc)
7(27)
6(33)
13(29)
X2=0152
df=1
p = 0696
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses
In the present study it was found that the most common morbidity of the eye was cataract
found in 172 (391) of the subjects It was more common in males 112 (43) compared to
females 60 (333) and this difference was found to be statistically significant The other
morbidities present were refractive error found in 34 (77) subjects and others which
includes conjunctivitis pterygium glaucoma etc found in 13 (29 ) subjects
50
Results
Table 17 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the oral cavity
Diseases of the
oral cavity
Males
(n =260 )
Females
(n =180 )
Total
(n = 440)
Statistical
value
Stained teeth
22 (84)
18 (10)
40 (91)
X2 =0304
df=1
p = 0581
Missing teeth
40 (154)
38 (211)
78 (177)
X2= 239
df= 1
p=0122
Caries
28 (108)
8 (44)
36 (82)
X2= 566
df= 1
p=0017
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses
In the present study it was found that the most common morbidity of the oral cavity was
missing teeth found in 78 (177 ) of the subjects followed by stained teeth found in 40
(91) of the subjects and dental caries in 36 (82) of the subjects Dental caries were
more common in males 28 (108) compared to females 8(44) and this difference was
found to be statistically significant
51
Results
Table 18 Distribution of study subjects based on endocrine nutritional and metabolic
disorders
Disorders Males
(n =260 )
Females
(n =180)
Total
(n = 440)
Statistical value
Diabetes mellitus
45 (173)
37 (206)
82 (186)
X2 = 0739
df= 1
p = 0389
Anemia
24 (92)
35 (194)
59 (134)
X2= 955
df = 1
p = 0001
Thyroid disorders
1(04)
3 (17)
4 (09)
p= 0309
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
The present study revealed that the most common disorder of the endocrine system was
diabetes mellitus found in 82 (186) of the subjects followed by the nutritional disorder of
anemia found in 59 (134) of the subjects It was seen that anemia was more common
among females 35 (194) compared to males 24 (92) This difference was found to be
statistically significant Disorders of the thyroid gland were found in 4 (09) of the subjects
being more common in females 3(17) compared to males 1 (04)
52
Results
Table 19 Distribution of the study subject based on disease of the circulatory system
Diseases of
circulatory
system
Males
(n=260 )
Females
(n =180)
Total
(n = 440)
Statistical
value
Hypertension
62 (238)
71 (394)
133 (302)
X2= 1227
df= 1
p = 0000
CAD MI
Arrhythmias
2 (08)
2 (11)
4 (09)
p =100
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
In our study it was found that the most common disease of the circulatory system was
hypertension which was found in 133 (302 ) of the subjects it was more common in
females 71 (394) compared to males 62 (239) and this difference was found to be
statistically significant The other disorders of the circulatory system were CAD MI
arrhythmias which were found only in 4 (09) of the study subjects
53
Results
Table 20 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the respiratory system
Disorders of
Respiratory
System
Males
(n=260)
Females
(n=180)
Total
(n=440)
Statistical
value
Bronchial asthma
3 (12)
3 (17)
6 (14)
p =0692
URTI
45 (173)
27 (15)
72 (164)
X2= 0413
df = 1
p = 0520
Acute Bronchitis
12 (46)
7 (39)
19 (43)
X2= 0135
df = 1
p = 0712
Pulmonary TB
4 (15)
0(00)
4 (09)
p =0148
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
Our study revealed that the most common disease of the respiratory system was URTI
(upper respiratory tract infection) found in 72 (164) subjects followed by acute bronchitis
in 19 (43 ) bronchial asthma in 6 (14) and pulmonary TB in only in 4 (09 ) subjects
Pulmonary TB was found in 4 (15) of the males whereas no females had TB however
this difference was not found to be statistically significant
54
Results
Table 21 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the digestive system
Disorders of
Gastrointestinal
system
Males
(n = 260)
Females
(n = 180)
Total
(n = 440)
Statistical value
Constipation
21(8)
6 (33)
27(61)
X2 =4155
df =1
p =0041
Gastritis
24 (92)
18 (10)
42(95)
X2= 0072
df = 1
p =0787
Bleeding per
rectum 3(12) 2(11) 5(11)
p =100
Others (Pain
abdomen
anorexia
indigestion)
9(35)
4 (22)
13 (3)
X2=0569
df =1
p=0450
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
Our study revealed that the most common disorder of the gastrointestinal system was
gastritis found in 42 (95) subjects followed by constipation in 27 ( 61) others which
include pain abdomen anorexia indigestion was found in 13 (3) and bleeding per rectum
was seen in 5 (11) It was seen that constipation was more common among males 21(8)
compared to females 6 (33) which was found to be statistically significant
55
Results
Table 22 Distribution the study subjects based on disease of the Skin and
subcutaneous tissue
Disorders of skin and
subcutaneous tissue
Males ( n = 260)
Females (n = 180)
Total (n = 440)
Statistical
value
Itching
19(73)
2(11)
21(48)
X2 =896
df=1
p = 0002
Scaling 6 (23)
3 (17)
9 (2)
p =0743
Pigmentation
5(19)
4 (22)
9 (2)
p =100
Dryness
8 (31)
11 (61)
19(43)
X2= 237
df = 1
p = 0123 Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
In the present study it was found that the most common disease of the skin was itching
which was present in 21 (48) of the study subjects followed by dryness in 19 (43) and 9
(2) of the subjects had scaling and pigmentation It was seen that itching was more
common among males 19 (73) compared to females 2 (11) and this difference was
found to be statistically significant
56
Results
Table 23 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the ear
Disease of the ear
Males
(n= 260)
Females
(n = 180)
Total
(n = 440) Statistical value
Hearing impairment
33 (126)
16 (89)
49 (111)
X2 =155
df =1
p =0212
Ear discharge
3 (12)
1 (06)
4(09)
p =0647
Tinnitus
3 (12)
1 (06)
4 (09)
p =0647
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
In the present study it was observed that hearing impairment was the most common
morbidity of the ear found in 49 (111) of the subjects though it was more common
among males 33 (126) compared to females 16 (89) the difference was not found to be
statistically significant The other disorders which affected the ear were ear discharge and
tinnitus both present in 4 (09) of the subjects
57
Results
Table 24 Distribution of the study subjects based on disease of the genitourinary
system
Disorders of
genitourinary system
Male
(n = 260)
Female
(n = 180)
Total
(n=440)
Statistical value
Burning micturition
2 (077)
2 (11)
4 (09)
p=100
Increased frequency of
micturition
20(77) 5(28) 25(57)
X2= 4794
df =1
p =0028 Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
In our study it was observed that the most common morbidity affecting the genitourinary
system was increased frequency of micturition in 25 (57) of the subjects followed by
burning micturition in 4 (09) of the study subjects Increased frequency of micturition was
more common among males 20 (77) compared to females 5 (28) and this difference
was found to be statistically significant
58
Results
Table 25 Distribution of the study subjects based on diseases of the Nervous system
Disease of the
nervous system Males
(n = 260)
Females
(n = 180)
Total
(n = 440)
p value
Memory loss
2 (77)
2 (11)
4 (09)
100
Stroke
2 (77)
0 (00)
2 (05)
0515
Neuritis
2 (77)
3 (17)
5 (11)
0652
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
Our study revealed that the most common disorder of the nervous system was neuritis seen
in 5 (11) of the subjects followed by memory loss in 4 (09) and stroke in 2 (05 ) of
the subjects It was observed that 2 (0 77) of males had suffered a stroke whereas none of
the females had suffered from stroke however this difference was not found to be
statistically significant
59
Results
Table 26 Association between morbidity pattern of the study subjects and their age
group
System involved 60-69Yrs
(n = 271)
70-79Yrs
(n = 134)
gt 80Yrs
(n = 35)
Total
( n = 440)
Statistical
value
Musculoskeletal
System
195 (72)
94 (70)
25 (710)
314 (714) X2= 0143
df = 2 p = 0930
Eye amp adnexa
125 (461)
69 (515)
25 (714)
219 (497) X2= 8166
df = 2 p = 0016
Oral cavity amp salivary gland
56 (207)
68 (507)
30 (857)
154 (350) X2= 7865
df = 2 p lt 00001
Endocrine nutritional amp
metabolic diseases
91 (335)
47 (35)
7 (200)
145 (329) X2= 297
df = 2 p = 0225
Circulatory
system
87 (321)
40 (298)
10 (285)
137 (311) X2= 0328
df = 2 p = 0848
Respiratory
system
64 (236)
31 (231)
6 (171)
101 (23) X2= 0738
df = 2 p = 0691
Digestive system
52 (191)
28 (210)
7 (200)
87 (191) X2= 0166
df = 2 p = 0 920
Skin and subcutaneous
tissue
43 (159)
13 (97)
2 (57)
58 (132) X2= 4831
df = 2 p = 0089
Ear amp mastoid process
27 (99)
20 (149)
10 (285)
57 (13) X2= 1018
d= 2 p = 0006
Genitourinary
system
20 (74)
8 (59)
1 (29)
29 (66) X2= 1151
df = 2 p = 0562
Nervous system
5 (18)
4 (29)
2 (57)
11 (25)
p = 0418
Figure in parenthesis indicates percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
60
Results
Table 26 shows the association between the morbidity pattern and age group of the study
subjects It is observed that the disease of the eye and adnexa increase with increasing age
and are more common in individuals above 80 years of age (714) compared to
individuals in the age group of 60-69 years (461) and 70-79 years (515) This
difference was found to be statistically significant The disease of the oral cavity were also
more common in the subjects aged 80 years and above (857) compared to individuals in
the age group of 70-79 years (507) and 60-69 years (207) this difference was also
found to be statistically significant Significant association was also found between
increasing age and disease of the ear 285 subjects aged 80 years and above suffered from
disease of the ear followed by 149 in the age group of 60-69 years and 99 in the age
group of 60-69 years
61
Results Table 27 Association between morbidity pattern of the study subjects and their
occupation
System involved Employed (n=215)
Unemployed (n=225)
Total (n=440)
Statistical value
Musculoskeletal
system
171 (795) 143 (635) 314 (714) X2 =1374 df=1
p=00002
Eye and adnexa 108 (502) 111(493) 219(497) X2= 0035 df=1
p= 0850
Oral cavityamp
salivary glands
76 (353) 78 (347) 154 (35) X2=0022 df=1
p=0880
Endocrine
nutritional amp
metabolic
disease
75 (348) 70 (311) 145 (329) X2=0708 df=1
p=0400
circulatory
system
58 (269) 79 (351) 137 (311) X2=3393 df=1
p=0065
Respiratory
system
49 (227) 52 (231) 101 (23) X2=0006 df=1
p=09363
Digestive system 45 (21) 42 (187) 87 (198) X2=0125 df=1
p=0723
Skin
subcutaneous
tissue
38 (176) 20 (88) 58 (132) X2=741 df=1
p=0006
Ear and mastoid
process
31 (144) 26 (115) 57 (13) X2=0799 df=1
p=0371
Genitourinary
system
16 (74) 13 (57) 29 (66) X2=0494 df=1
p=0481
Nervous system
2 (093) 9 (4) 11 (25) X2=425 df=1
p=0039 Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
Multiple responses
62
Results
Table 27 shows the association between the morbidity pattern and occupation of the study
subjects It was observed that musculoskeletal disorders were more common among the
subjects who are employed (795) compared to those who are not employed (635) and
this difference was found to be statistically significant A significant association was also
seen between the disorders of the skin and subcutaneous tissue 176 subjects who are
employed suffered from the disease of the skin and subcutaneous tissue compared to 88
who were unemployed The diseases of the nervous system were more common among
those who were unemployed (4) compared to those who were employed (093) this
difference was also found to be statistically significant
63
Results Table 28 Association between morbidity pattern of the study subjects and their
religion
System involved Hindu
(n=188)
Muslim
(n=252)
Total
(n=440)
Statistical value
Musculoskeletal system 138 (73) 176 (698) 314 (714)
X2=0668 df=1
p=0413
Eye and adnexa 100 (531) 119 (472) 219 (497) X2=1535 df=1
p= 0215
Oral cavityamp salivary glands 73 (388) 81 (321) 154 (35)
X2=211 df=1
p=0145
Endocrine nutritional amp metabolic diseases
53 (2819) 92 (365) 145 (329) X2=3371 df=1
p=0066
circulatory system 58 (269) 79 (351) 137 (311)
X2=3393 df=1
p=0065
Respiratory system
33 (176) 68 (269) 101 (229)
X2=5415 df= 1
p=0019
Digestive system 27 (144) 60 (238) 87 (198) X2=6059 df=1
p=0013
Skin subcutaneous tissue
31 (164) 27 (107) 58 (132) X2=3138 df=1
p=00765
Ear and mastoid process
28 (149) 29 (115) 57 (129) X2=1095 df=1
p=0297
Genitourinary system
16 (85) 13 (52) 29 (66) X2=1965 df=1
p=0161
Nervous system
4 (21) 7 (28) 11(25) p=0764
Figure in parenthesis indicates percentage
Multiple responses Fisherrsquos exact test
64
Results
Table 28 shows the association between the morbidity pattern of the study subjects and their
religion In our study it was observed that the disorders of the digestive system were more
common among Muslims (238) compared to Hindus (144) this difference was found
to be statistically significant Also the disorders of the respiratory system were more
common among Muslims (269) compared to Hindus (176) This difference was also
found to be statistically significant Some of the diseases were more common among Hindus
which include the disease of the eye and adnexa (531) oral cavity (388) ear (149)
skin and subcutaneous tissue (164) and genitourinary system (85) but it was not found
to be statistically significant
65
Results
III HEATLTH SEEKING BEHAVIOR OF THE STUDY SUBJECTS
Figure16 Distribution of the study subjects based on the visit to health facility in case
of an illness
In our study it was found that that out of 440 study subjects 395(898) visited a health
facility in case of an illness whereas 45(102) did not visit any health facility in case of an
illness
898
102
health facility visitednot visited
66
Results
Table 29 Reasons cited by the study subjects for not seeking healthcare in case of an
illness
In the present study it was found that the most common reason stated by the 45 study
subjects for not seeking health care in case of an illness was that it was a mil 20 (444)
followed by lack of money stated by12 (267) the other reasons stated were no one to
accompany 7 (156) and lack of faith in health care 6 (133)
Reasons cited for not
seeking health care
Frequency (n=45)
Percentage ()
Mild discomfort 20 444
Lack of money 12 267
Lack of faith in
healthcare
6 133
No one to accompany 7 156
Total 45 100
67
Results
Table 30 Distribution of the study subjects based on the type of health facility visited
It was observed that out of 395 subjects who visited health care facility in case of an illness
229(58) Visited government hospitals 160 (405) visited private practitioners hospitals
and 6 (15) visited quacks More number of males (622) visited government hospitals
compared to females (513)
Type of health facility visited
Males
(n=241)
Females
(n=154)
Total
(n=395)
No No No
Government hospital 150 622 79 513 229 58
Private practitionershospitals 87 361 73 474 160 405
Quacks 4 17 2 13 6 15
Total 241 100 154 100 395 100
68
Results
Table 31 Association between gender and health seeking behaviour of the study
subjects
Whether visited
health facility
in case of illness
Sex
Total
n ()
p value Male
n ()
Female
n ()
Yes 241 (927) 154 (856) 395 (898) 00151
No 19 (106) 26 (144) 45 (102)
Total 260 (59) 180 (41) 440 (100)
x2=5901 df =1
Figures in parenthesis indicate percentage
It was observed that more number of males visited a health care facility in case of an illness
241(927) whereas only 154(856) females visited a health facility in case of an illness
This difference was found to be statistically significant
69
Results
Table 32 Association between educational status and health seeking
behaviour of the study subjects
Whether visited Health facility in case of illness
p value
Educational status(n) Yes () No ()
0000
Illiterate (231) 194 (84) 37 (16)
Primary school (121) 115 (95) 6 (49)
Higher primary (38) 37 (974) 1 (26)
Secondary school (30) 29 (967) 1 (33)
Intermediate (6) 6 (100) 0(00)
Graduate (14) 14 (100) 0(00)
Total(440) 395 (898) 45(102)
Fisherrsquos exact test
In the present study it was found that 84 of the study subjects who were illiterate visited a
health facility in case of an illness whereas 16 did not visit a health facility in case of an
illness 967 of the subjects with education up to secondary school visited the health
facility and 100 of the subjects who studied up to intermediate and with a graduate degree
visited the health facility in case of an illness This difference was found to be statistically
significant
70
Results
Table 33 Distribution of study subjects according to frequency of visits to a health care facility
Frequency of visits to a health care facility
Frequency
(n=395)
Percentage
Once a month 207 524
Once in 3 months 99 251
Once in 6 months 79 20
Once in a year 10 25
Total 395 100
In the present study it was found that out of 395 study subjects who visited a health care
facility in case of an illness 207 (524) visited a health facility every month followed by
99 (251) who visited once in 3 months 79(20) once in 6 months and 10 25 visited
the health facility once in a year
71
Discussion
DISCUSSION
I Socio-demographic characteristics
Our study was done in the urban field practice area of JJM Medical College Davangere
among 440 geriatric subjects our study aimed at assessing the morbidity pattern and health
seeking behaviour of the geriatric population in the study area
In the present study Out of 440 study subjects majority 162(368) were in the age
group of 60-64 Years followed by 109 (247) in the age group of 65-69 Years 99 (225)
in the age group of 70-74 Years and 8 were more than or equal to 80 years of age [Table
7] This was similar to a study conducted by Prakash Boraingaiah et al 72 in which majority
of the elderly (346) belongs to age group 60-64 years followed by age group 75 years and
above (259)
In our study it was also seen that 59 of the study subjects were males and 41 were
females This was similar to a study conducted by Mohan Gupta et al 35 where 573
subjects were males and 427were females Our findings were contrary to a study
conducted by Md Alam Naushad et al 28 where 598 subjects were females and 402
were males
In the present study it was found that the majority of the study subject belonged to
Muslim religion 252 (573) followed by Hindus 188 (427) there were no study subjects
who belonged to other religions like Christian Jain Sikhs etc [Table 8] similar findings
were seen in a study conducted by Mrinal Ranjan Srivastav et al 50 in which 52 of the
subjects were Muslims
72
Discussion
In the present study it was found that the Majority of the study subjects were illiterate
525 whereas 275 had completed education up to primary school 82 had completed
education up to secondary school and only 32 were graduates [Table 9] These findings
were similar to a study done by Shraddha K et al 51in which 504 of the study subjects
were illiterate
In our study it was found that the majority of the study subjects 511 were unemployed
followed by 227 who were unskilled workers 155 were semi-skilled workers and
about 105 were skilled workers [Table 10] These findings were similar to a study done
by Rajat Das Gupta et al27 al in which 481 of the study subjects were not working
In our study majority of the subjects 49 belonged to Class IV Socioeconomic status
followed by 26 who belonged to class III and 13 who belonged to class II (according to
Modified BG Prasad Classification 2016) [Table 11] Similar findings were found in a study
conducted by Sribas Goswami and Manjari Sahai 29 in which majority of the study subjects
belonged to class IV socio economic status
In our study it was found that the majority of the study subjects 734 were married
followed by 261 who were widowed and only 05 were unmarried [Table 12] These
findings were similar to a study done by L subedhi and RB Sah 40 in which 663 of the
subjects were married 322 were widowed and 07 were unmarried
In the present study it was found that majority of the study subjects 42 lived in a three
generation family followed by 37 who lived in a nuclear family and 21 who lived in a
Joint family [Table 13] These findings were similar to a study done by Swapnil Jain et al 26
in which the majority (47) of the study subjects lived in a three generation family
73
Discussion
II Prevalence of morbidities among the study subjects
In the present study it was found that majority of the subjects 45 had a normal BMI
followed by 30 who were overweight about 15 were obese and only10 were
underweight [Figure 14] Similar findings were reported in a study conducted by Khadervali
Nagoor et al 44 in which 49 subjects had a normal BMI In a study done by Vimala
Thomas et al 52 272 of the subjects were obese which was higher than the present study
In the present study it was found that the majority of the subjects suffered from the
disorders of the musculoskeletal system (714) eye and adnexa (497) oral cavity
(311) respiratory system (229) digestive system (198)disease of the skin
(132)ear(13)genitourinary system (66) nervous system (25) [Table14] Similar
findings were seen in a study done by Rajashree Bhat et al 55 in which most common
morbidity of elderly was the problems of loco-motor system (486) followed by vision
(427) CVS disorders (344) respiratory system (202) and disease of ear (179)In
this study though the prevalence of loco-motor system disorders (486) was highest
compared to other disorders it was lesser compared to our study (714) In a study done by
L subedhi and RB Sah 40 it was found that 44 had eye problems 43 had gastrointestinal
problems 33 had CVS problems and 23 had ENT problems In this study the prevalence
of gastrointestinal disorders was much higher compared to our study
In the present study joint pain (including the knee joint) was most common disorder of the
musculoskeletal system seen in 40 of the males compared to 384 in females [Table 15]
whereas in a study done by Swapnil Jain et al 26 it was found that 472 males and 528
females suffered from joint pains This could be attributed to the fact that in our study
majority of the study subjects were males
74
Discussion
In the present study it was found that the most common morbidity of the eye was cataract
found in 39 of the subjects It was more common in males 43 compared to females
333 [ Table 16]These findings were similar to a study done by Shraddha K et al 51 in
which the overall prevalence of cataract was 302 of which 42 males and 358
females had cataract
In the present study it was found that the most common morbidity of the oral cavity was
missing teeth found in 177 of the subjects [Table 17] it was similar to the findings of a
study conducted by JP Singh et al 48 in which 1475 subjects were edentulous
The present study revealed that the most common disorder of the endocrine system was
diabetes mellitus found in 186 of the subjects followed by the nutritional disorder of
anemia found in 134 of the subjects It was seen that anemia was more common among
females 194 compared to males 92 [Table 18] Kakkar R et al 45 reported similar
findings with prevalence of diabetes mellitus as 153 In a study done by Deepak Sharma
et al 47 anemia was present in 15 of the subjects 97 males and 21 females were
anemic which was similar to our study
In our study it was found that the most common disease of the circulatory system was
hypertension which was found in 302 of the subjects it was more common in females
394 compared to males 239 and this difference was found to be statistically significant
[Table 19] A study by L Subedhi and RB Sah 40 reported that the prevalence of
hypertension was more among females (333) compared to males (30) which was
statistically significant
75
Discussion
In our study the most common morbidity of the respiratory system was upper respiratory
tract infection (163) [Table20] it was similar to the study done by Leena Rahul
Salunke33 where it was reported to be 196
In our study the most common disorder of the digestive system was gastritis (95)
[Table 21] similar to the findings of JP Singh et al 48 (35) contrary to this L subedhi
and RB Sah 40 reported a high prevalence of gastritis (39) This difference could be
attributed to the difference in the interpretation of symptoms for the diagnosis of gastritis
In our study the most common disorder of the skin was itching (48) [ Table 22] which
was similar to the findings reported by JP Singh et al 48 in which 225 subjects suffered
from itching
In our study the most common disorder of the ear was impaired hearing (111) [Table
23] similar to a study by Vandana Nikumb et al 38 in which 106 subjects suffered from
hearing impairment
In our study it was observed that the most common morbidity affecting the
genitourinary system was increased frequency of micturition (57) [Table 24]
L subedhi and RB Sah40 found in their study that 143 subjects suffered from increased
frequency of micturition which was higher compared to our study
Our study revealed that 25 subjects suffered from the disorders of the nervous
system [Table 25] similar to a study conducted by Vandana Nikumb et al 38 in which
13 of the Subjects suffered from the disorders of the nervous system whereas in a
study conducted by Shilpa Shaukaiah et al36 it was found that 66 of the subjects
suffered from the disorders of the nervous system which was higher than our study
76
Discussion
It is observed that the disease of the eye and adnexa increased with increasing age and were
more common in individuals above 80 years of age (714) The disease of the oral cavity
were also more common in the subjects aged 80 years and above (857) and 285
subjects aged 80 years and above suffered from disease of the ear A significant association
was found between age and these morbidities [Table 26] Similar results were found in a
study done by Swapnil Jain et al 26 in which cataract hearing impairment and dental
problems were significantly associated with the age of the study subjects
In our study a significant association was found between occupation and the disorders of
the musculoskeletal system skin and the nervous system Disorders of the musculoskeletal
system were more common among employed subjects (795) compared to unemployed
(635) 176 subjects who were employed suffered from the disease of the skin and
subcutaneous tissue compared to 88 who were unemployed Diseases of the nervous
system were more common among those who were unemployed (4) compared to those
who were employed (093) [Table 27]
A study done by Kakkar R et al45 found that there was a significant association between the
employment status and the morbidities of the CVS arthritis and cataract CVS morbidity
was more common among those not working (164) compared to those working (36)
Arthritis was also more common among not working (212) compared to those working
(55) and cataract was also more common among those not working (175) compared to
those working (55)
77
Discussion
In our study it was observed that there was a significant association between religion and
disorders of the digestive system and respiratory system The disorders of the digestive
system were more common among Muslims (238) compared to Hindus (144) Also the
disorders of the respiratory system were more common among Muslims (269) compared
to Hindus (176) [Table 28] In a study conducted by Mrinal Ranjan Srivastav et al 50 it
was found that there was significant association between religion and the morbidities of the
genitourinary system in the urban areas The problems of the genitourinary system were
more common among Hindus (26) compared to Muslims (96)
III HEATLTH SEEKING BEHAVIOR OF THE STUDY SUBJECTS
In our study it was found that that (898) study subjects visited a health facility in case
of an illness whereas 102 did not visit any health facility in case of an illness[Figure 16]
Similar findings were seen in a study conducted by Vimala Thomas et al 52 where it was
found that 716 subjects visited a health facility Contrary to our findings a study
conducted by Bhawalkar JS et al46 showed that only 81 subjects visited a health facility in
case of an illness whereas 919 did not visit any health facility
In the present study it was found that the most common reason stated by study subjects
for not seeking health care in case of an illness was that it was a mild discomfort (444)
followed by lack of money stated by (267) other reasons stated were no one to
accompany (156) and lack of faith in health care (133) [Table 29] In a study
conducted by Deepak Sharma et al 47 it was found that the most common reasons for not
seeking health care were the following disease due to age (496) health services too far
(191) lack of money (6) no body to take to hospital (35)
78
Discussion
It was observed that out of 395 subjects who visited health care facility in case of an illness
58 Visited government hospitals 362 visited private practitioners hospitals and 15
visited quacks [Table 30] similar results were found in a study conducted by Deepak Sharma
et al 47 in which 607 went to Government hospitals 267 consulted private practitioners
and 126 took over the counter drugs In another study conducted by Rajat Das Gupta et al
27 it was found that 33 visited Government hospitals 25 visited private hospitals 6
visited private practitioners
It was observed that more number of males (927) visited a health care facility in case of
an illness whereas only 856 females visited a health facility in case of an illness [Table
31] In a study done by Man Mohan Gupta et al 35 it was found that 672 females and
651 males visited a health facility in case of illness
In the present study it was found that 848 of the study subjects who were illiterate
visited a health facility in case of an illness whereas 152 did not visit a health facility in
case of an illness A significant association was found between educational status and
gender [Table 32] In a study done by Deepak Sharma et al 47 it was found that Gender
literacy income and marital status were not found to be significantly related to health-
seeking behaviour
In the present study it was found that 524 subjects visited a health facility every month
followed by 251 who visited a health facility once in 3 months 20once in 6 months
and 25 visited a health facility once in a year[ Table 33] In a study conducted by Rajat
Das Gupta et al 27 it was found that majority of the subjects (2943) visited a health
facility once a year followed by 2813 who visited a health facility once in three months
79
Conclusion
CONCLUSION
The study revealed that some of the common morbidities among the geriatric subjects were
the disorders of the musculoskeletal system followed by the disease of the eye and adnexa
oral cavity endocrine nutritional and metabolic disorders etc some disorders like cataract
dental caries constipation and increased frequency of micturition were more common
among males whereas disease like anemia and hypertension were more common among
females A significant association was found between some of the morbidities and socio
demographic determinants like age occupation and religion
Any degree of formal schooling was found to be associated with better health seeking
behavior Majority of the subjects visited a Government health facility in case of an illness
and the main reason that was stated for not visiting a health facility was that they suffered
from mild discomfort and did not consider it necessary to visit a health facility
80
Summary
SUMMARY
Our study was done in the urban field practice area of JJM Medical College Davangere
among 440 geriatric subjects our study aimed at assessing the morbidity pattern and health
seeking behaviour of the geriatric population in the study area
The results of our study are as follows
ISocio-demographic characteristics of the study subjects
In the present study 368 subjects were in the age group of 60-64 Years
59 of the subjects were males and 41 were females
573 subjects were Muslims whereas 427 were Hindus
Majority of the subjects were illiterate (525) whereas 275 had completed
education up to primary school
It was found that the majority of the study subjects (511) were unemployed
49 subjects belonged to Class IV Socioeconomic status according to Modified BG
Prasad Classification
734 of the subjects were married
42 of the people lived in a three generation family
II Prevalence of morbidities among the study subjects
Majority of the subjects (45) had a normal BMI followed 30who were
overweight
Majority 714 subjects suffered from the disorders of the musculoskeletal system
followed by 497 who suffered from the disease of the eye and adnexa35
suffered from the disease of the oral cavity 329 suffered from endocrine
nutritional and metabolic disorders and 311 suffered from the disease of the
circulatory system 229 suffered from the disease of the respiratory system198
81
Summary
suffered from the disease of the digestive system132 suffered from disease of the
skin13 suffered from the disease of the ear66 suffered from the disease of the
genitourinary system and 25 suffered from the disease of the nervous system
The most common morbidity of musculoskeletal system was pain of the joints (other
than the knee joint) found in 198 of the subjectsBack ache was more common in
females 231 compared to males 163 and this difference was found to be
statistically significant
cataract found in 39 of the subjects It was more common in males 43 compared
to females 333 and this difference was found to be statistically significant
Missing teeth were found in 177 of the subjects Dental caries were more
common in males 108 compared to females 44 and this difference was found to
be statistically significant
Diabetes mellitus found in 186 of the subjects followed by the nutritional disorder
of anemia found in 134 of the subjects anemia was more common among females
194 compared to males 92 This difference was found to be statistically
significant
Hypertension which was found in 302 of the subjects it was more common in
females 394 compared to males 239 and this difference was found to be
statistically significant
upper respiratory tract infection) found in 163 subjects followed by acute
bronchitis in 43 bronchial asthma in 14 and pulmonary TB in only 09
Gastritis was found in 95 subjects followed by constipation in 61 Among
males (81) had constipation compared to females(03)
Most common disease of the skin was itching which was present in 48 of the
study subjects followed by dryness in 43
82
Summary
Hearing impairment was found in 111 of the subjects
Increased frequency of micturition was found in 57 of the subjects followed by
burning micturition in 09 of the study subjects Increased frequency of
micturition was more among males 77 compared to females in whom it was 28
and this difference was found to be statistically significant
The most common disorder of the nervous system was neuritis seen in 11 of the
subjects followed by memory loss in 09 and stroke in 05 of the subjects
A significant association was found between increasing age and the morbidities of
the eye ear and the oral cavity
Significant association was found between occupation and the disorders of the
musculoskeletal system skin and the nervous system Disorders of the
musculoskeletal system were more common among employed subjects (795)
compared to unemployed (635) 176 subjects who were employed suffered
from the disease of the skin and subcutaneous tissue compared to 88 who were
unemployed Diseases of the nervous system were more common among those who
were unemployed (4) compared to those who were employed (093)
It was observed that the disorders of the digestive system were more common
among Muslims (238) compared to Hindus (144) this difference was found to
be statistically significant Also the disorders of the respiratory system were more
common among Muslims (269) compared to Hindus (176) This difference
was also found to be statistically significant
83
Summary
III HEATLTH SEEKING BEHAVIOR OF THE STUDY SUBJECTS
In our study 898 subjects visited a health facility in case of an illness whereas
102 did not
The most common reason stated by study subjects for not seeking health care in case
of an illness was that it was a mild discomfort (444) followed by lack of money
stated by (267) the other reasons stated were no one to accompany (156) and
lack of faith in health care (133)
It was observed that 58 subjects Visited Government hospitals 362 visited
private practitioners hospitals and 15 visited quacks
Majority of males (927) visited a health care facility in case of an illness whereas
only 856 females visited a health facility in case of an illness This difference was
found to be statistically significant
A significant association was found between the educational status and health
seeking behaviour Majority of the educated subjects visited a health facility in case
of an illness compared to those who were illiterate
It was found that 524 subjects visited a health facility every month followed by
251 who visited a health facility once in 3 months 20once in 6 months and
25 visited a health facility once in a year
84
Limitations
LIMITATIONS
1 Many of the responses were subjective and there were no records to verify them
2 Some of the morbidities were diagnosed only by clinical examination and could not be
confirmed by performing diagnostic tests due to high cost and time constraints
3 This study was done in the urban field practice area which consisted of a closed
community hence the results cannot be generalized to the entire population of the area
85
Recommendations
RECOMMENDATIONS
1 Health education should be given to the geriatric people regarding the common health
problems associated with ageing and preventive care should be provided to the elderly
2 Geriatric clinics should be set up at the primary health care level which provide regular
screening and health check-ups
3 There should also be a provision to provide domiciliary care by specialists qualified in
geriatrics
4 The family members and the care givers of the elderly should be educated about the
common health problems of the elderly and also about the need for regular health check-ups
and emotional support
5 The majority of the geriatric population is out of work force they are suffering from
many morbidities and are totally dependent on others even for their health needs Hence the
Government should increase the pension of the elderly and provide them quality healthcare
free of cost
6 There is also a need for public private partnership to improve the quality of health
services for the geriatric people More number of NGOs should work towards improving the
health and the quality of life of the elderly
86
References
REFERENCES
1 United Nations Department of Economic and Social affairs Population Division
World population ageing 2013 Available from URL
wwwunorgendevelopmentpopulationageingWorldPopulationAgeing2013
[Accessed on 17-7-2016]
2 Khan S and Itrat M Current Issues in Geriatric Health Care in India-A Review J Community Med Health Care 2016 1(1) 1-3
3 United Nations Department of Economic and Social Affairs Population Division
World Population Ageing 2015 ndash Highlights Available from URL
wwwunorgendevelopmentdesapopulationpdfageingWPA2015_Reportpdf
[Accessed on 272017]
4 State of elderly in India 2014 Help age India Available from URL
httpswwwhelpageindiaorgimagespdfstate-elderly-india-2014pdf [Accessed on
1082017]
5 World Health Organization World report on ageing and health 2015Available
from URL wwwwhointageingeventsworld-report-2015-launchen [Accessed on
1272017]
6 National policy for Senior citizens March 2011Ministry of Social Justice and
welfare Govt of India Available from URL
socialjusticenicinwritereaddataUploadFilednpscpdf [Accessed on 482017]
87
References
7 Elderly in India Profile and programmes 2016Govt of India Ministry of statistics
and programme implementation Central Statistics Office Available from URL
wwwmopsigovin [ Accessed on 1442017]
8 Saxena V Kandpal SD Gael D Bansal S Health status of elderly community
based study Indian Journal of Community Health2012 Oct-Dec24(4)269-74
9 Shah T Patel M Shah V Health care seeking behaviour of urban and rural
community in Ahmedabad district Int J Med Sci Public Health20132908-11
10 Sahoo H Mishra NR Health Status Morbidity Pattern and Treatment Seeking
Behaviour among Elderly in India Evidence from 60th round of National Sample
Survey Data Learning community 2011 Dec 2(3) 341-55
11 Park K Parkrsquos Textbook of Preventive and social medicine 24 th ed Jabalpur MS
Banarsidas Bhanot Publishers2017631
12 UNFPA- state of World Population 2011Chapter 1 setting the scene 19-31
Available from URL httpswwwunfpaorgsitesdefaultfilesresource-
pdfUNFPA-Report-Chapter1pd [Accessed on 1082017]
13 Lal S Adarsh Pankaj Textbook of community Medicine 4th ed CBS publishers and
distributors PvtLtd2011732
14 Census of India 2001 Registrar General And Census Commissioner India
Available from URL httpwwwcensusindiagovinCensus[Accessed on
7102015]
15 SRS bulletin October 2012 Registar General of India New Delhi Available from
URL censusindiagovinvital_statisticsSRS_BulletinsSRS_Bulletin-
October_2012[Acessed on 7102015]
88
References
16 Bagchi K Healthy ageing Health and Population-Perspectives and Issues 2000
23(1)11-16
17 Salagre SB The Association of Physicians of India Chapter 177 Health Issues in
Geriatrics Available from URL
wwwapiindiaorgmedicine_update_2013chap177pd [ Accessed on 282017]
18 Ingle GK Nath A Geriatric Health in India Concerns and Solutions Indian Journal
of Community Medicine 2008 33(4)214-18
19 World Health Organization Active Ageing a policy framework 2002 Available
from httpwhqlibdocwhointhq2002who_nmh_nph_028pdf [Accessed on
1062017]
20 Inche Zainal Abidin S Sutan R Shamsuddin K Prevalence and determinants of
appropriate health seeking behaviour among known diabetics Results from a
community-based survey Advances in Epidemiology 2014 Nov 20141-6
21 Begashaw B Tessema F Gesesew HA Health Care Seeking behavior in Southwest
Ethiopia Plos one 2016 Sep 11(9)e0161014
22 MacKian S Health systems development Manchester University of Manchester
2003 A review of health seeking behavior problems and prospects
23 Metta EO Health-seeking behaviour among adults in the context of the
epidemiological transition in Southeastern Tanzania A focus on malaria and
diabetes [Groningen] University of Groningen 2016 228 Available from URL
httpswwwrugnlresearchportalfiles28737720Chapter_7pdf [Accessed on
1272017]
24 Adhikari D Rijal D Factors affecting health seeking behaviour of senior citizens of
Dharan Journal of Nobel Medical College 2015 Sep 4(1)57-63
25 Polisetty S Seepana M Morbidity profile of elderly individuals in urban
Visakhapatnam Int J Community Med Public Health 2017 4(2)2558-63
89
References
26 Jain S Kaware AC Doibale MK Shaikh S Radhey BK Mathurkar MP Morbidity
pattern among geriatric population in urban field practice area of district of
Maharashtra a cross sectional study Int J Community Med Public Health 2016
3(2)523-29
27 Gupta RD Loha A Roy S Morbidity pattern and health-seeking behaviour among
the senior citizens in a selected urban area of Bangladesh A cross-sectional study
South East Asia Journal of Public Health 2016 Jul 5(2)43-49
28 Naushad MA Verma N Bhawnani D Jain M Anand T Umate LV Morbidity
pattern and health seeking behaviour in elderly population of Raipur City
Chhattisgarh India Indian Journal of Community Health2016 Sep 28(3)236-41
29 Goswami S Sahai M A Study of Morbidity Pattern in Elderly Population European
Researcher Series A 2016103(2)119-28
30 Bardhan H Dixit AM Agarwal R Jain PK Gupta S Shukla SK Morbidity profile
of elderly population in Ghaziabad district a cross-sectional study Int J Med Sci
Public Health 2016 5(6)1098-1102
31 Maroof M Ahmad A Khalique N Ansari MA Health problems among the aged A
community based study from urban Aligarh Uttar Pradesh India Int J Community
Med Public Health 2016 Feb 3(4)944-47
32 Shankar G Sidenur B A morbidity study of elderly residing in urban field practice
area of SN medical college Bagalkot National Journal of research in community
medicine 2016 Oct-Dec 4(5) 229-34
90
References
33 Salunkhe LR Socio-demographic profile of old age people living in urban amp urban
slum areas in Maharashtra Karad A comparative study J of Evidence based Med
and Hlthcare 2015 Feb 2(5) 513-21
34 Warbhe P Rupesh W Morbidity profile health seeking behaviour and home
environment survey for adaptive measures in geriatric population-Urban community
study International Journal of Medical Research amp Health Sciences 2015 4(4)778-
82
35 Gupta M Borle AL Chhari N Gupta S Assessment of clinico-socioeconomic
status and health-care support among the elderly people aged older than 60 years in
urban population of Bhopal Central India Int J Med Sci Public Health 2015
4558-64
36 Sahukaiah S Shenoy A Vijayakumar BC An epidemiological study of prevalence
of morbidity patterns among geriatric age group in an urban slum of Mumbai Int J
Med Sci Public Health 2015 Jul 4(7)883-87
37 Shubha Davalagi B Angadi N Mahabalaraju DK Morbidity psycho-social profile
and health seeking behaviour of the elderly population in urban slums of Davangere
City India Int J Res Med Sci 2015 Nov 3(11)3288-91
38 Nikumb V Patankar F Behera A A Study of Morbidity Profile among Geriatric
Population in an Urban Area Sch J App Med Sci 2015 3(3)1365-69
91
References
39 Vishnoi BR Solanki SL Singhal G Meharda B Mishra N Morbidity profile of
elderly in urban slum of Udaipur Rajasthan Int J Oral Health Med Res 2015 May
2(1)9-12
40 Subedi L Sah RB Study of the health status of geriatric age group in Chitwan
district of Nepal Journal of Chitwan Medical College 2015 Mar 5(1)11-17
41 Noor S Krishnababu G Prasad KV Health status of Geriatric population in slums
of Rourkela Young Innovative Journal of Medical and Health Science 2015 May
5(3) 92-94
42 Sarode VM Chronic Diseases Related to Aging and Disease Prevention in Slums in
Mumbai Journal of Aging Science 2014 Jan 2 (1)1-6
43 Barman SK Lata K Ram R Ghosh N Sarker G Shahnawaz K A study of
morbidity profile of geriatric population in an urban community of Kishanganj
Bihar India Global Journal of Medicine and Public Health GJMEDPH 2014 3(1)
1-7
44 Nagoor K Srikanth BA Dudekula R Satna K Comparative study of health status
among slum and non-slum elderly population in Kadapa Region South India
Journal of Evolution of Medical and Dental Sciences 2014 Feb 3(5)1298-308
45 Kakkar R Aggarwal P Kandpal SD Bansal SK An Epidemiological study to assess
morbidity profile among geriatric population in District Dehradun Indian Journal of
Community Health 2013 May 25(1)39-44
46 Bhawalkar JS Dhone AB Jethani S Singru S Jadhav SL Adyanthaya S A study of
morbidity profile among geriatric population in an urban area J Evol Med Dent Sci
2013 Sep 9 36(2)6963-7
92
References
47 Sharma D Mazta SR Parashar A Morbidity pattern and health-seeking behaviour of
aged population residing in Shimla hills of north India A cross-sectional study
Journal of family medicine and primary care 2013 Apr2(2)188
48 Singh JP Singh S Kasturwar NB Hassan A Geriatric morbidity profile in an urban
slum Central India Indian Journal of Community Health 2013 Aug 25(2)164-70
49 Thakur RP Banerjee A Nikumb VB Health Problems among the Elderly A Cross
Sectional Study Annals of medical and health sciences research 2013 3(1)19-25
50 Mrinal RS Beena S Pratibha G Pankaj B Srivastava JP Atul B Morbidity Status
and Its Social Determinants among Elderly Population of Lucknow District India
Sch J App Med Sci 2013 1(6)758-64
51 Shraddha K Prashantha B Prakash B Study on morbidity pattern among elderly in
urban population of Mysore Karnataka India International Journal of Medicine and
Biomedical Research 2012 1(3)215-23
52 Thomas V Lavanya KM Morbidity profile and health seeking behaviour of the
elderly in urban slums of Hyderabad Andhra Pradesh India- A cross sectional study
International Journal of Current Research and Review 2012 Oct 1 4(19)174-80
53 Moe S Tha K Naing DK Htike MM Health seeking behaviour of elderly in
Myanmar International Journal of Collaborative Research on Internal Medicine and
Public Health 2012 4(8)1538-44
93
References
54 Bharati DR Pal R Rekha R Yamuna TV Kar S Radjou AN Ageing in
Puducherry South India An overview of morbidity profile Journal of pharmacy amp
bio allied sciences 2011 Oct 3(4)537
55 Bhatt R Gadhvi MS Sonaliya KN Solanki A Nayak H An epidemiological study
of the morbidity pattern among the elderly population in Ahmedabad Gujarat
National Journal of community medicine 2011 Jul 2(2)233-36
56 Srinivasan Krishnamachari Vaz Mario Thomas Tinku Prevalence of health related
disability among community dwelling urban elderly from middle socioeconomic
strata in Bangaluru India Indian Journal of Medical Research 2010 Apr 131(4)
515-21
57 Srivastava K Gupta SC Kaushal SK Chaturvedi M Morbidity profile of elderly a
cross sectional study of urban Agra Indian Journal of Community Health 2010 Jun
22(1)51-55
58 Ladha A Khan R Malik A Khan S Khan B Khan I et al The health seeking
behaviour of elderly population in a poor-urban community of Karachi Pakistan
Journal of the Pakistan Medical Association2009 Feb 59(2) 89-92
59 WHO ICD-10 version 2010 Geneva World Health Organization Available from
URL appswhointclassificationsicd10browse2010en [Accessed on 772017]
60 OpenEpi22OpenEpi (free) download Windows version Available from URL
enfreedownloadmanagerorgWindows-PCOpenEpi-FREEhtml
61 Tandon R Sinhota Parsonrsquos disease of the eye 22edNew Delhi Elsevier 98-100
62 Dhingra P L Dhingra S Disease of ear nose and throat and head and neck surgery
6th ed New Delhi Elsevier 201422
94
References
63 Aziz N Kallur SD Nirmalan PK Implications of the revised consensus body mass
indices for Asian Indians on clinical obstetric practice Journal of clinical and
diagnostic research 2014 May 8(5)OC01
64 Chobanion AV Bakris GL Black HR The seventh report of the joint national
committee on prevention detection evaluation and treatment of high blood pressure
the JNC 7 report JAMA 2003 2892560-72
65 The Seventh Report of the Joint National Committee on Prevention Detection
Evaluation and Treatment of High Blood Pressure (JNC 7) The GuidelinesUS
Department of Health and Human Services National Heart Lung and Blood
Institute Available at URL
httpswwwnhlbinihgovfilesdocsguidelinesjnc7fullpdf [ Accessed on
1282017]
66 Firkin F Chestman C Penington D Rush B De Gruchyrsquos clinical Hematology in
medical practice 5th edition New Delhi Blackwell science Ltd1989 32-47
67 Report of WHO consultation Nutritional Anaemias Geneva Switzerland World
Health Organization TRS-405 1968 Available from URL
whqlibdocwhointtrsWHO_TRS_405pdf [Accessed on 1282017]
68 National Family Health survey (NFHS-4) 2015-16 India Mumbai IIPS
2016Available from URL httpwwwnfhsindiaorg [Accessed on 4072017]
69 The Minimum Wages Act 1948 Ministry of Labour and Employment Government
of India Available from URL httplabourgovincontentinnerpagewagesphp
[Accessed on 1082017]
70 Khairnar M Wadgave U Shimpi P Updated BG Prasad socioeconomic
classification for 2016 Journal of Indian Association of Public Health Dentistry
2016 Oct 1 14(4)469
95
References
71 Tiwari P Tiwari S Mastering practicals community medicine 1st ed New Delhi
India Wolters Kluwer PvtLtd2013161-67
72 Boralingaiah P Bettappa P Kashyap S Prevalence of Psycho-Social Problems
among Elderly in Urban Population of Mysore City Karnataka India Indian journal
of psychological medicine 2012 Oct 34(4)360
96
PATIENT CONSENT FORM JJM MEDICAL COLLEGE DAVANGERE
DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY MEDICINE I the undersigned hereby give my consent
for investigations carried upon me I am satisfied with the information given about this
Clinical study titled ldquoA STUDY ON THE MORBIDITY PATTERN AND HEALTH
SEEKING BEHAVIOR AMONG THE GERIATRIC POULATION IN THE
URBAN FIELD PRACTICE AREA OF JJM MEDICAL COLLEGE
DAVANGERErdquo ldquoconducted by Dr RUCHI DHAR under the guidance of Dr VIDYA
GS Associate Professor I have been informed and explained the risks involved and I
hereby voluntarily and Unconditionally give my consent without any fear or pressure in
mentally sound and conscious state to participate in this study
DATE PATIENTrsquoS SIGNATURE
eEacuteeEacuteJA ordfEacuteEcirczAgravearingQAtildeAiAgraveAuml ordfAgraveAumlordmAacutelaquozAacutearingregAiAgraveAuml zAacuteordfAgravetUEacutegEacute
ryenAacutemiumlethordfEacuteAumlAmiumlDyensiumlPAgraveordfAgraveAumlAumlaringcurrenn ordfEacuteAumlrsup1poundiuml
ordfEacuteEcirczAgravearingQAtildeAiAgraveAumlvAgraveyenAacutecedilAgraveuEacuteUEacuteMbrvbaragraveUEacute yenAgravevAgraveaelig F PEacutefrac14AgraveUEacute cedilAgraveraquo ordfAgraveiAacutergAgraveAumlordfAgrave poundAacutepoundAgraveAuml CAzAgravegEacute
poundAgravepoundAgraveszlig
ordfEacuteEcirczAgravearingQAtildeAiAgraveAumlvAgraveyenAacutecedilAgraveuEacute ordmAacuteUAgraveAElig plusmnAgravecedilAgraveUcircccedilaQvEacuteigraveUEacuteAzAgraveAuml poundAgravepoundAgraveszligMbrvbaragraveUEacuteAiAgraveAumlpoundAgraveAumlszlig
cedilAgraveAEligasup1gAgraveAumlvEacuteUcircAtildepoundEacute J cedilAgraveOumlr Dyensiuml zAgrave ordfEacuteAEligcopyethrn yenAacutearinglpoundiumleth CAqiuml ordmEacutemacriumlUcirc sup1AtildeQAUiuml copyordmEacuteAtildelaquoAiAgraveAumlgiuml Dyensiuml zAgrave fjAiAgraveiAacutenaeligPiuml yenEacuteAEligAtildeyenAgraveAumlaringmacrEacuteAtildemicroAgravepoundiuml Epoundiuml zAgrave Csectethpoundiuml brvbarAtildemacriumlOslash yenAacuteaeligoumlaringQOumlAtildecediliuml JjAiAgraveAuml Dyensiuml ddordfAgraveAumlAuml ordfEacuteEcirczAgravearingQAtildeAiAgraveAuml ordfAgraveAumlordmAacutelaquozAacutearingregAiAgraveAuml zAacuteordfAgravetUEacutegEacute JAsect sup2AtildeparaethPEacuteAiAgraveAumlrAiAgraveAumldegegrave yenAgravejAtildePEacuteeumlUEacute Mfrac14AgraveyenAgravercedilAgraveAumlordfAgrave ordfEacuteEcirczAgravearinggAacutezAgrave qAacute|| gAgraveAumla zAgravesAgravegAgrave ordfAgraveAumlvAgraveAumlUcirc qAacute|| laquozAacutearing fJcediliumlordfAgraveiAacuteUAgraveethzAgraveplusmnAgraveethPAgravegAacutezAgrave yenEacuteAEligaeligAtildeyensEacutecedilAgravegiuml
EordfAgravegAgraveAuml poundAgravepoundAgraveUEacute F vAgraveyenAacutecedilAgraveuEacuteUEacute Mfrac14AgraveyenAgraveqAgraveAumlordfAgrave ordfAgraveAumlAumlpoundAgraveszlig yenAgraveaeligwAiEacuteAEligAzAgraveAuml
CAplusmnAgraveUAgravefrac14AgravepoundAgraveAumlszlig CxAgraveethordfAacuteUAgraveAumlordfAgraveAvEacute wfrac12sup1gAgraveAumlvAacuteUcircgEacuteDzAgraveYacutejAzAgrave poundAacutepoundAgraveAuml poundAgravepoundAgraveszlig
ordfAgraveAumlpoundAgravecedilAacutegEacute AiAgraveiAacuteordfAgraveAringzEacuteAtilde umlsAgraveAiAgraveAuml ordfAgraveAumlvAgraveAumlUcirc AiAgraveiAacutegAgrave MvAacuteUcircAiAgraveAumllaquoregegravezEacute poundAacutepoundAgraveAuml
vAgraveyenAacutecedilAgraveuEacute aQvEacuteigraveUEacuteAEligfrac14AgraveyenAgraveqAgraveregAuml MbrvbaragraveUEacuteAiAgraveAumlpoundAgraveAumlszlig cedilAgraveAEligasup1gAgraveAumlvEacuteUcircAtildepoundEacute
centpoundAacuteAPAgrave gEacuteAEligAtildeVAi
Annexures
ANNEXURE ndashIII
104
Annexures
PROFORMA
I General information
1 NAME
2 AGE
3 GENDER (a) Male (b) Female
4 MARITAL STATUS (a) Unmarried (b) Married (c) Widow Widower
(d) Divorced separated
5 LIVING ARRANGEMENT (a) with spouse (b) Spouse and children
(c) Children only (d) living alone (e) others
6 RELIGION (a) Hindu (b) Muslim (c) Christian (d) Others
7 ADDRESS
8 EDUCATION (a) illiterate (b) Primary school (c) higher primary
(d) secondary school (e)PUC diploma (e) Graduate (f) Postgraduate
9 OCCUPATION (a) professional (b) semi- professional (c) skilled worker
(d) Semi ndashskilled worker (e) unskilled worker (f) unemployed
10 CONTACT NUMBER
11 TYPE OF FAMILY (a) Joint (b) Nuclear (C) three generation
12 TOTAL NUMBER OF FAMILY MEMBERS
13 TOTAL FAMILY INCOME
14 PER CAPITA FAMILY INCOME
15 SOCIO ECONOMIC STATUS (Modified BG Prasad classification) I IIIIIIVV
16 DIET (a) Vegetarian (b) Mixed
17 Sleep (a) Disturbed if yes reason ______________ (b) Not disturbed
18 Bowel Regular Irregular
19 Bladder Regular Irregular
97
Annexures
20 HABITS (a) betel nut (b) tobacco (c) alcohol (d) smoking (e) others
If any of the habits present Duration (since when) _________
Frequency of consumption day_______
IIAssessment of morbidity based on history
1 Whether suffering from any chronic illness like (a) Type 2 DM (b) Hypertension
(c) Bronchial Asthma (d) TB (e) others
2 Whether suffering from cataract currently (a) Yes (b) No
3 Whether operated for cataract (a) Yes (b) No If Yes duration since operation____
4 MUSCULOSKELETAL SYSTEM
Whether the following symptoms are present
(a) Backache (b) Joint pain (c) restricted joint movements (d) pain in calves
(e) Others_________
5 RESPIRATORY SYSTEM
(a) Productive cough (b) non-productive cough (c) nasal discharge (d) breathlessness (e)
sore throat (f) sneezing
6 CARDIOVASCULAR SYSTEM
(a) Palpitations (b) chest pain (c) breathlessness
7 GASTROINTESTINAL SYSTEM
(a) Pain abdomen (b) lose stools (c) constipation (d) flatulence (e) heart burn
(f) Bleeding per rectum
8 EYE AND ADNEXA
(a) Watering (b) diminution of vision (c) redness
9 EAR
(a) Discharge (b) decreased hearing (c) Tinnitus
10 SKIN
(a) Itching (b) skin eruptions (c) scaling (d) pigmentation
98
Annexures
11 GENITO URINARY SYSTEM
(a) Burning micturition (b) increased frequency of micturition
12 GENERAL SYMPTOMS
(a) Fatigue (b) headache (c) fever
13 ANY OTHER COMPLAINTS (a) burning feet (b) swelling in groin
(c) Memory loss (d) insomnia
III Assessment of health seeking behaviour
1 Do you visit a health facility in case of illness (a) Yes (b) No
If yes how much time do you take to visit a health facility an case of an illness
(a) Within 24 hours (b) 24-48 hours (c) more than 48 hours
2 Which type of health facility do you visit
(a) Govt hospital (b) Private practitioners (c) over the counter drugs (e) quacks
Mention the reason for visiting the particular health facility______________________
3 Whether taking regular treatment after diagnosis ________________
If No mention the reason_______________________
4 Whether following the instructions given by the treating doctor
(a) Yes (b) no
5 cost of treatment per month in case of chronic disease
(a) lt100 (b) 100-200 (c) 200-300 (d) 300 and above
6 Person bearing the cost of treatment
(a) Self (b) spouse (c) son (d) daughter (d) outside help
7 Duration to reach the health facility
(a) less than 3o minutes (b) 30 minutes or more
8 Whether going for regular check -ups (a) Yes (b) No
If Yes duration between the check-ups_______
99
Annexures
9 Whether following self- care practices in case of chronic disease like diabetes and hypertension
(a) Yes (b) No
10 In case of healthy individuals whether getting screening tests done (a) Yes (b) No
11 Whether following any dietary modifications (a) yes (b) No
12 Whether any family member accompanies you to the health facility
If yes who (a) Son (b) daughter (c) spouse (d) others
11 Whether the family supports in following specific diet advised by the doctor
(a) Yes (b) No
12 whether family members help in reminding to take regular medication
(a) Yes (b) No
IV Physical examination
1 Personal hygiene status
S NO COMPONENT CONDITION REMARKS
1 Hair
2 Teeth
3 Bath
4 Clothes
5 Washing hand before
eating food
6 Washing hands with soap
and water after ablution
7 Nails
8 Foot wear
Remarks personal hygiene status Good fair poor
100
Annexures
2 MEASUREMENTS
(a) Weight (in Kg) ______ (b) Height (in cm) _____ (c) BMI ______
(d) Waist circumference______ (e) Hip circumference ___________
(f) Waist hip ratio_________
3 GENERAL PHYSICAL EXAMINATION
Pallor Icterus Cyanosis clubbing lymphadenopathy Oedema
Pulse rate Temp Blood Pressure
Respiratory rate
20 Examination of
Eye Oral cavity Ear
Nose Throat
SYSTEMIC EXAMINATION
Cardiovascular system Respiratory system
Per abdomen Central Nervous system
101
MASTER CHART
Annexures
ANNEXURES
International Classification of Diseases (10th Revision)
I Certain infectious and parasitic diseases (A00-B99)
II Neoplasms (C00-D48)
III Diseases of blood and blood forming organs and certain disorders
involving the immune mechanisms (D50-D89)
IV Endocrine nutritional and metabolic diseases (E00-E90)
V Mental and behavioural disorders (F00-F99)
VI Diseases of the nervous system (G00-G99)
VII Diseases of the eye and adnexa (H00-H59)
VIII Diseases of the ear and mastoid process ( H60-H95)
IX Diseases of the circulatory system (I00-I99)
X Diseases of the respiratory system ( J00-J99)
XI Diseases of the digestive system (K00-K93)
XII Diseases of the skin and subcutaneous tissue ( L00-L99)
XIII Diseases of the musculoskeletal system and connective tissue
(M00-M99)
XIV Diseases of the genitourinary system ( N00-N99)
XV Pregnancy childbirth and purperium (O00-O99)
XVI Certain conditions originating in perinatal period (P00-P96)
XVII Congenital malformations deformations and chromosomal
XVIII (S00-T98)
XIX External causes of morbidity and mortality (V01-Y98)
102
Annexures
XX Injury poisoning and certain other consequences of external causes
(S00-T98)
XXI Factors influencing health status and contact with health services
(Z00-Z99)
XXII Codes for special purpose
103
Annexures
105
Annexures
106
Annexures
107
Annexures
PHOTOS
Picture 1 Showing the investigator interviewing the study subject
Picture 2 Showing the investigator interacting with the study subject
108
Annexures
Picture 3 Showing the investigator recording the Blood pressure of the study subject
Picture 4 Showing the investigator auscultating the study subject
109
Annexures
110