Dr. Beverly A. Cigler, Ph.D. Professor of Public Policy and Administration Penn State Harrisburg The...

19
Dr. Beverly A. Cigler, Ph.D. Professor of Public Policy and Administration Penn State Harrisburg The South Central Assembly Regional Summit York, Pa. June 13, 2012 LOCAL GOVERNMENT/ MUNICIPAL SERVICES PANEL

Transcript of Dr. Beverly A. Cigler, Ph.D. Professor of Public Policy and Administration Penn State Harrisburg The...

Page 1: Dr. Beverly A. Cigler, Ph.D. Professor of Public Policy and Administration Penn State Harrisburg The South Central Assembly Regional Summit York, Pa. June.

Dr. Beverly A. Cigler, Ph.D.Professor of Public Policy and Administration

Penn State Harrisburg

The South Central Assembly Regional Summit

York, Pa.June 13, 2012

LOCAL GOVERNMENT/MUNICIPAL SERVICES

PANEL

Page 2: Dr. Beverly A. Cigler, Ph.D. Professor of Public Policy and Administration Penn State Harrisburg The South Central Assembly Regional Summit York, Pa. June.

Our vocabulary is optimistic: we talk about the business “cycle,” “recovery,” and “prosperity, all implying a return to the status quo or the “normal”

IS THERE A NEW NORMAL?

Page 3: Dr. Beverly A. Cigler, Ph.D. Professor of Public Policy and Administration Penn State Harrisburg The South Central Assembly Regional Summit York, Pa. June.

Will likely be different and with slower growth

Requires new ways of thinking and operating

More interaction and collaboration

Reducing duplication via consolidation of functions

Elimination or reduction in programs and services of marginal benefit

BUT, THE ‘NEW NORMAL’

Page 4: Dr. Beverly A. Cigler, Ph.D. Professor of Public Policy and Administration Penn State Harrisburg The South Central Assembly Regional Summit York, Pa. June.

Streamlined internal processes Public-private relationships Shared services (intermunicipal,

municipal-county; with authorities; with schools)

Declining or flat revenues: sales, property, income taxes; fees; state payments; federal/state grant opportunities; impact fees--EVERYTHING

THE ‘NEW NORMAL

Page 5: Dr. Beverly A. Cigler, Ph.D. Professor of Public Policy and Administration Penn State Harrisburg The South Central Assembly Regional Summit York, Pa. June.

Assumes changed operations and structures

Need to clear away old assumptions to get to new ideas

Not doing more with less but doing less with less

THE ‘NEW NORMAL’

Page 6: Dr. Beverly A. Cigler, Ph.D. Professor of Public Policy and Administration Penn State Harrisburg The South Central Assembly Regional Summit York, Pa. June.

THE CHALLENGE

RECONCILING INCREASING

DEMANDS WITH LAGGING

RESOURCES

Page 7: Dr. Beverly A. Cigler, Ph.D. Professor of Public Policy and Administration Penn State Harrisburg The South Central Assembly Regional Summit York, Pa. June.

TODAY’S PROBLEMS

ARE NOT “TEMPORARY’’WON’T LIKELY BE SOLVED EASILY

WON’T LIKELY BE SOLVED THROUGH TRADITIONAL APPROACHES

Page 8: Dr. Beverly A. Cigler, Ph.D. Professor of Public Policy and Administration Penn State Harrisburg The South Central Assembly Regional Summit York, Pa. June.

MUNICIPALITIES FACE THE NEED TO

REALIGN SERVICE DELIVERY MAKE BETTER USE OF EXISTING

TECHNOLOGY DEVELOP NEW TECHNOLOGIES CENTRALIZE INFORMATION

TECHNOLOGIES DEVELOP SHARED FACILITIES AND

VENTURES PERFORM SHARED SERVICE DELIVERY AND FIND OTHER WAYS TO IMPROVE

EFFICIENCY

Page 9: Dr. Beverly A. Cigler, Ph.D. Professor of Public Policy and Administration Penn State Harrisburg The South Central Assembly Regional Summit York, Pa. June.

TO DO THIS…

THINK, PLAN, MANAGE AND ACT STRATEGICALLY

THE “HOW TO” IS AVAILABLE—ABOUT 3 DOZEN ALTERNATIVE SERVICE DELIVERY OPTIONS

Page 10: Dr. Beverly A. Cigler, Ph.D. Professor of Public Policy and Administration Penn State Harrisburg The South Central Assembly Regional Summit York, Pa. June.

A PLAN FOR SERVICE DELIVERY INVOLVES

SYSTEMATIC AWARENESS OF OPPORTUNITIES

DEVELOPING A NEW VISION FOR STEERING THE MUNICIPALITY TOWARD INNOVATION

ENCOURAGING SHARED SERVICES AND FACILITIES

Page 11: Dr. Beverly A. Cigler, Ph.D. Professor of Public Policy and Administration Penn State Harrisburg The South Central Assembly Regional Summit York, Pa. June.

A PLAN FOR SERVICE DELIVERY INVOLVES

ADJUSTING THE WORKPLACE CULTURE AND WORKFORCE ITSELF TOWARD ELIMINATING BARRIERS TO INNOVATION AND TOWARD CREATING INCENTIVES TO PROMOTE INNOVATION

ACTIVELY SEEKING CITIZEN ENGAGEMENT THAT HELPS SHAPE PLANS AND EXPECTED OUTCOMES

Page 12: Dr. Beverly A. Cigler, Ph.D. Professor of Public Policy and Administration Penn State Harrisburg The South Central Assembly Regional Summit York, Pa. June.

AREAS RIPE FOR SHARED SERVICES

INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY

PROVISION OF INFORMATION AND REPORTING

PROCUREMENT AND FOOD SERVICE FACILITIES AND REAL PROPERTY

MANAGEMENT

Page 13: Dr. Beverly A. Cigler, Ph.D. Professor of Public Policy and Administration Penn State Harrisburg The South Central Assembly Regional Summit York, Pa. June.

AREAS RIPE FOR SHARED SERVICES

FLEET AND DISPATCH ACTIVITIES

FINANCE, HUMAN RESOURCES AND ADMINISTRATION

SERVICES SUCH AS PARKS AND LIBRARIES, AMONG OTHERS

Page 14: Dr. Beverly A. Cigler, Ph.D. Professor of Public Policy and Administration Penn State Harrisburg The South Central Assembly Regional Summit York, Pa. June.

LESSONS FROM PA AND NATIONAL RESEARCH

BARRIERS TO USE OF ALTERNATIVE SERVICE DELIVERY TOOLS

CHARACTERISTICS OF THE SERVICE SHOULD DETERMINE THE MODE OF DELIVERY

Page 15: Dr. Beverly A. Cigler, Ph.D. Professor of Public Policy and Administration Penn State Harrisburg The South Central Assembly Regional Summit York, Pa. June.

LESSONS…FINDINGS ON MUNICIPAL SIZE AND

EFFICIENCY

FINDINGS ON CAPITAL OR INFRASTRUCTURE INTENSIVE VS. LABOR INTENSIVE SERVICES

FINDINGS ON MUNICIPAL CONSOLIDATION OR MERGERS AND EFFICIENCY AND ECONOMIC COMPETITIVENESS

Page 16: Dr. Beverly A. Cigler, Ph.D. Professor of Public Policy and Administration Penn State Harrisburg The South Central Assembly Regional Summit York, Pa. June.

LESSONS… FINDINGS ON FUNCTIONAL

CONSOLIDATIONS AND EFFICIENCY—MIXED

EFFICIENCY VS. EFFECTIVESNESS VS. OTHER VALUES

MEASURING PERFORMANCE, BENCHMARKING, DATA-BASED REVIEWS

Page 17: Dr. Beverly A. Cigler, Ph.D. Professor of Public Policy and Administration Penn State Harrisburg The South Central Assembly Regional Summit York, Pa. June.

LESSONS…

PRODUCTION VS. FINANCING VS. DELIVERY

EXAMPLES FROM PUBLIC WORKS AND PUBLIC SAFETY

Page 18: Dr. Beverly A. Cigler, Ph.D. Professor of Public Policy and Administration Penn State Harrisburg The South Central Assembly Regional Summit York, Pa. June.

BEST PRACTICES?

COUNTIES WITH MUNICIPAL FUNCTIONS, LAKEWOOD PLAN, URBAN COUNTIES

MANY SHARED SERVICES

SOME FUNCTIONAL CONSOLIDATIONS

Page 19: Dr. Beverly A. Cigler, Ph.D. Professor of Public Policy and Administration Penn State Harrisburg The South Central Assembly Regional Summit York, Pa. June.

ENDINGS

QUESTIONS AND COMMENTS?

Contact:Bev [email protected]