'DQLHO & *LUDUG 6%1 · 2019-07-20 · bsh home appliances corp. ) ... dq rughu fhuwli\lqj d fodvv...

34
3/$,17,))6¶ 027,21 )25 &/$66 &(57,),&$7,21 &$6( 12 &91& 'DQLHO & *LUDUG 6%1 -RUGDQ (OLDV 6%1 $GDP ( 3RON 6%1 6LPRQ 6 *ULOOH 6%1 *,5$5' 6+$53 //3 &DOLIRUQLD 6WUHHW 6XLWH 6DQ )UDQFLVFR &$ 7HOHSKRQH [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] %HQMDPLQ ) -RKQV pro hac vice $QGUHZ : )HULFK pro hac vice =DFKDU\ 3 %HDWW\ pro hac vice &+,0,&/(6 7,.(//,6 //3 2QH +DYHUIRUG &HQWUH :HVW /DQFDVWHU $YHQXH +DYHUIRUG 3$ 7HOHSKRQH [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] Counsel for Plaintiffs 81,7(' 67$7(6 ',675,&7 &2857 1257+(51 ',675,&7 2) &$/,)251,$ 6$1 -26( ',9,6,21 3$75,&,$ :((.6 $/,&,$ +(/06 %5,$1 0&&/2< DQG $'5,$1 $/&$5$= RQ EHKDOI RI WKHPVHOYHV DQG DOO RWKHUV VLPLODUO\ VLWXDWHG 3ODLQWLIIV Y *22*/( //& 'HIHQGDQW &DVH 1R FY1& 3/$,17,))6¶ 127,&( 2) 027,21 $1' 027,21 )25 &/$66 &(57,),&$7,21 $1' 0(025$1'80 2) /$: ,1 6833257 7+(5(2) 25$/ $5*80(17 5(48(67(' 'DWH 0DUFK 7LPH SP &RXUWURRP WK )ORRU -XGJH +RQ 1DWKDQDHO 0 &RXVLQV 5('$&7(' ),/(' 81'(5 6($/ Case 5:18-cv-00801-NC Document 94 Filed 11/05/18 Page 1 of 34

Transcript of 'DQLHO & *LUDUG 6%1 · 2019-07-20 · bsh home appliances corp. ) ... dq rughu fhuwli\lqj d fodvv...

Page 1: 'DQLHO & *LUDUG 6%1 · 2019-07-20 · bsh home appliances corp. ) ... dq rughu fhuwli\lqj d fodvv ri doo lqglylgxdov lq wkh 8qlwhg 6wdwhv zkr sxufkdvhg iurp *rrjoh ru dq dxwkrul]hg

[email protected] [email protected] [email protected] [email protected]

pro hac vicepro hac vice

pro hac vice

[email protected] [email protected] [email protected]

Counsel for Plaintiffs

Case 5:18-cv-00801-NC Document 94 Filed 11/05/18 Page 1 of 34

Page 2: 'DQLHO & *LUDUG 6%1 · 2019-07-20 · bsh home appliances corp. ) ... dq rughu fhuwli\lqj d fodvv ri doo lqglylgxdov lq wkh 8qlwhg 6wdwhv zkr sxufkdvhg iurp *rrjoh ru dq dxwkrul]hg

Case 5:18-cv-00801-NC Document 94 Filed 11/05/18 Page 2 of 34

Page 3: 'DQLHO & *LUDUG 6%1 · 2019-07-20 · bsh home appliances corp. ) ... dq rughu fhuwli\lqj d fodvv ri doo lqglylgxdov lq wkh 8qlwhg 6wdwhv zkr sxufkdvhg iurp *rrjoh ru dq dxwkrul]hg

Case 5:18-cv-00801-NC Document 94 Filed 11/05/18 Page 3 of 34

Page 4: 'DQLHO & *LUDUG 6%1 · 2019-07-20 · bsh home appliances corp. ) ... dq rughu fhuwli\lqj d fodvv ri doo lqglylgxdov lq wkh 8qlwhg 6wdwhv zkr sxufkdvhg iurp *rrjoh ru dq dxwkrul]hg

Abdeljalil v. Gen. Elec. Capital Corp.

Amchem Prods., Inc. v. Windsor

Amgen Inc. v. Connecticut Ret. Plans & Tr. Funds

Avedisian v. Mercedes-Benz, USA, LLC

Banks v. Nissan N. Am., Inc.

Baranco v. Ford Motor Co.

Beaton v. SpeedyPC Software

Bias v. Wells Fargo & Co.

Brickman v. Fitbit, Inc.

Briseno v. ConAgra Foods, Inc.

Broomfield v. Craft Brew Alliance, Inc.

Cape Flattery Ltd. v. Titan Mar., LLC

Clothesrigger, Inc. v. GTE Corp.

Comcast Corp. v. Behrend

Day v. AT & T Corp.

Case 5:18-cv-00801-NC Document 94 Filed 11/05/18 Page 4 of 34

Page 5: 'DQLHO & *LUDUG 6%1 · 2019-07-20 · bsh home appliances corp. ) ... dq rughu fhuwli\lqj d fodvv ri doo lqglylgxdov lq wkh 8qlwhg 6wdwhv zkr sxufkdvhg iurp *rrjoh ru dq dxwkrul]hg

Ehret v. Uber Techs., Inc.

Falco v. Nissan N. Am. Inc.

Fitzhenry-Russell v. Dr. Pepper Snapple Grp., Inc.

leave to appeal denied

Gaudet v. American Home Shield Corp.

Gold v. Lumber Liquidators, Inc.

Grace v. Apple, Inc.

Guido v. L’Oreal, USA, Inc.

Gutierrez v. Carmax Auto Superstores Cal.

Hadley v. Kellogg Sales Co.

In re Anthem, Inc. Data Breach Litig.

In re Arris Cable Modem Consumer Litig.

In re Cathode Ray Tube (CRT) Antitrust Litig.

rpt. & rec. adopted

In re Intuitive Surgical Sec. Litig.

In re MyFord Touch Consumer Litig.

In re Nexus 6P Prod. Liab. Litig.

Case 5:18-cv-00801-NC Document 94 Filed 11/05/18 Page 5 of 34

Page 6: 'DQLHO & *LUDUG 6%1 · 2019-07-20 · bsh home appliances corp. ) ... dq rughu fhuwli\lqj d fodvv ri doo lqglylgxdov lq wkh 8qlwhg 6wdwhv zkr sxufkdvhg iurp *rrjoh ru dq dxwkrul]hg

In re Online DVD Rental Antitrust Litig.

aff’d

In re Sony Gaming Networks & Customer Data Security Breach Litig.

In re Sony Vaio Computer Notebook Trackpad Litig.

In re Whirlpool Corp. Front-Loading Washer Prods. Liab. Litig.

In re: Apple Inc. Device Performance Litig.

Johnson v. Harley-Davidson Motor Co. Grp., LLC

Just Film, Inc. v. Buono

Knutson v. Schwan’s Home Serv., Inc.

Kumar v. Salov N. Am. Corp

Lilly v. Jamba Juice Co.

Nedlloyd Lines B.V. v. Super. Ct.

Opperman v. Path, Inc.

Outboard Marine Corp. v. Super. Ct.

Phillips Petroleum Co. v. Shutts

Pulaski & Middleman, LLC v. Google, Inc.

Rodriguez v. Hayes

Case 5:18-cv-00801-NC Document 94 Filed 11/05/18 Page 6 of 34

Page 7: 'DQLHO & *LUDUG 6%1 · 2019-07-20 · bsh home appliances corp. ) ... dq rughu fhuwli\lqj d fodvv ri doo lqglylgxdov lq wkh 8qlwhg 6wdwhv zkr sxufkdvhg iurp *rrjoh ru dq dxwkrul]hg

Sloan v. Gen. Motors LLC

order clarified

Staton v. Boeing Co.

Tait v. BSH Home Appliances Corp.

Tait v. BSH Home Appliances Corp.

Torres v. Mercer Canyons Inc.

Tyson Foods, Inc. v. Bouaphakeo

Valentino v. Carter-Wallace, Inc.

Vega v. Jones, Day, Reavis & Pogue

Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. v. Dukes

Walsh v. CorePower Yoga LLC

Washington Mut. Bank, FA v. Super. Ct.

Wolin v. Jaguar Land Rover N. Am., LLC

Wolph v. Acer Am. Corp.

Zinser v. Accufix Research Inst., Inc.

Case 5:18-cv-00801-NC Document 94 Filed 11/05/18 Page 7 of 34

Page 8: 'DQLHO & *LUDUG 6%1 · 2019-07-20 · bsh home appliances corp. ) ... dq rughu fhuwli\lqj d fodvv ri doo lqglylgxdov lq wkh 8qlwhg 6wdwhv zkr sxufkdvhg iurp *rrjoh ru dq dxwkrul]hg

Federal Practice & Procedure

Introducing the “New Handshake” to Expand Remedies and Revive Responsibility in Ecommerce

Consumer Complaints and Public Policy: Validating the “Tip-of-the-Iceberg” Theory

Case 5:18-cv-00801-NC Document 94 Filed 11/05/18 Page 8 of 34

Page 9: 'DQLHO & *LUDUG 6%1 · 2019-07-20 · bsh home appliances corp. ) ... dq rughu fhuwli\lqj d fodvv ri doo lqglylgxdov lq wkh 8qlwhg 6wdwhv zkr sxufkdvhg iurp *rrjoh ru dq dxwkrul]hg

Case 5:18-cv-00801-NC Document 94 Filed 11/05/18 Page 9 of 34

Page 10: 'DQLHO & *LUDUG 6%1 · 2019-07-20 · bsh home appliances corp. ) ... dq rughu fhuwli\lqj d fodvv ri doo lqglylgxdov lq wkh 8qlwhg 6wdwhv zkr sxufkdvhg iurp *rrjoh ru dq dxwkrul]hg

Case 5:18-cv-00801-NC Document 94 Filed 11/05/18 Page 10 of 34

Page 11: 'DQLHO & *LUDUG 6%1 · 2019-07-20 · bsh home appliances corp. ) ... dq rughu fhuwli\lqj d fodvv ri doo lqglylgxdov lq wkh 8qlwhg 6wdwhv zkr sxufkdvhg iurp *rrjoh ru dq dxwkrul]hg

Id

but see

see also infra

Case 5:18-cv-00801-NC Document 94 Filed 11/05/18 Page 11 of 34

Page 12: 'DQLHO & *LUDUG 6%1 · 2019-07-20 · bsh home appliances corp. ) ... dq rughu fhuwli\lqj d fodvv ri doo lqglylgxdov lq wkh 8qlwhg 6wdwhv zkr sxufkdvhg iurp *rrjoh ru dq dxwkrul]hg

see also

E.g.

Case 5:18-cv-00801-NC Document 94 Filed 11/05/18 Page 12 of 34

Page 13: 'DQLHO & *LUDUG 6%1 · 2019-07-20 · bsh home appliances corp. ) ... dq rughu fhuwli\lqj d fodvv ri doo lqglylgxdov lq wkh 8qlwhg 6wdwhv zkr sxufkdvhg iurp *rrjoh ru dq dxwkrul]hg

E.g.

see also

See also

See also

Case 5:18-cv-00801-NC Document 94 Filed 11/05/18 Page 13 of 34

Page 14: 'DQLHO & *LUDUG 6%1 · 2019-07-20 · bsh home appliances corp. ) ... dq rughu fhuwli\lqj d fodvv ri doo lqglylgxdov lq wkh 8qlwhg 6wdwhv zkr sxufkdvhg iurp *rrjoh ru dq dxwkrul]hg

Id

Id.

E.g.

Case 5:18-cv-00801-NC Document 94 Filed 11/05/18 Page 14 of 34

Page 15: 'DQLHO & *LUDUG 6%1 · 2019-07-20 · bsh home appliances corp. ) ... dq rughu fhuwli\lqj d fodvv ri doo lqglylgxdov lq wkh 8qlwhg 6wdwhv zkr sxufkdvhg iurp *rrjoh ru dq dxwkrul]hg

Case 5:18-cv-00801-NC Document 94 Filed 11/05/18 Page 15 of 34

Page 16: 'DQLHO & *LUDUG 6%1 · 2019-07-20 · bsh home appliances corp. ) ... dq rughu fhuwli\lqj d fodvv ri doo lqglylgxdov lq wkh 8qlwhg 6wdwhv zkr sxufkdvhg iurp *rrjoh ru dq dxwkrul]hg

Case 5:18-cv-00801-NC Document 94 Filed 11/05/18 Page 16 of 34

Page 17: 'DQLHO & *LUDUG 6%1 · 2019-07-20 · bsh home appliances corp. ) ... dq rughu fhuwli\lqj d fodvv ri doo lqglylgxdov lq wkh 8qlwhg 6wdwhv zkr sxufkdvhg iurp *rrjoh ru dq dxwkrul]hg

Case 5:18-cv-00801-NC Document 94 Filed 11/05/18 Page 17 of 34

Page 18: 'DQLHO & *LUDUG 6%1 · 2019-07-20 · bsh home appliances corp. ) ... dq rughu fhuwli\lqj d fodvv ri doo lqglylgxdov lq wkh 8qlwhg 6wdwhv zkr sxufkdvhg iurp *rrjoh ru dq dxwkrul]hg

Case 5:18-cv-00801-NC Document 94 Filed 11/05/18 Page 18 of 34

Page 19: 'DQLHO & *LUDUG 6%1 · 2019-07-20 · bsh home appliances corp. ) ... dq rughu fhuwli\lqj d fodvv ri doo lqglylgxdov lq wkh 8qlwhg 6wdwhv zkr sxufkdvhg iurp *rrjoh ru dq dxwkrul]hg

Fitzhenry-Russell v. Dr. Pepper Snapple

Grp., Inc. leave to appeal denied

Kumar v. Salov N. Am. Corp

Lilly v. Jamba Juice Co.

Case 5:18-cv-00801-NC Document 94 Filed 11/05/18 Page 19 of 34

Page 20: 'DQLHO & *LUDUG 6%1 · 2019-07-20 · bsh home appliances corp. ) ... dq rughu fhuwli\lqj d fodvv ri doo lqglylgxdov lq wkh 8qlwhg 6wdwhv zkr sxufkdvhg iurp *rrjoh ru dq dxwkrul]hg

Amgen

Inc. v. Connecticut Ret. Plans & Tr. Funds

See infra

Case 5:18-cv-00801-NC Document 94 Filed 11/05/18 Page 20 of 34

Page 21: 'DQLHO & *LUDUG 6%1 · 2019-07-20 · bsh home appliances corp. ) ... dq rughu fhuwli\lqj d fodvv ri doo lqglylgxdov lq wkh 8qlwhg 6wdwhv zkr sxufkdvhg iurp *rrjoh ru dq dxwkrul]hg

Brickman v. Fitbit, Inc.

Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. v. Dukes

Hanlon v. Chrysler Corp

Walsh v. CorePower Yoga LLC

In re Sony Vaio Computer Notebook Trackpad Litigation

see also Wolph v. Acer

Am. Corp.

E.g.

See,

e.g. Banks v. Nissan N. Am., Inc.

Case 5:18-cv-00801-NC Document 94 Filed 11/05/18 Page 21 of 34

Page 22: 'DQLHO & *LUDUG 6%1 · 2019-07-20 · bsh home appliances corp. ) ... dq rughu fhuwli\lqj d fodvv ri doo lqglylgxdov lq wkh 8qlwhg 6wdwhv zkr sxufkdvhg iurp *rrjoh ru dq dxwkrul]hg

Rodriguez v. Hayes

In re Online DVD Rental Antitrust Litig.

aff’d

See

See, e.g. Falco v. Nissan N. Am. Inc.

Wolin v. Jaguar Land Rover N. Am., LLC

Gold v. Lumber Liquidators, Inc.

Case 5:18-cv-00801-NC Document 94 Filed 11/05/18 Page 22 of 34

Page 23: 'DQLHO & *LUDUG 6%1 · 2019-07-20 · bsh home appliances corp. ) ... dq rughu fhuwli\lqj d fodvv ri doo lqglylgxdov lq wkh 8qlwhg 6wdwhv zkr sxufkdvhg iurp *rrjoh ru dq dxwkrul]hg

Staton v. Boeing Co.

In re Intuitive

Surgical Sec. Litig.

Id.

See

See

Case 5:18-cv-00801-NC Document 94 Filed 11/05/18 Page 23 of 34

Page 24: 'DQLHO & *LUDUG 6%1 · 2019-07-20 · bsh home appliances corp. ) ... dq rughu fhuwli\lqj d fodvv ri doo lqglylgxdov lq wkh 8qlwhg 6wdwhv zkr sxufkdvhg iurp *rrjoh ru dq dxwkrul]hg

Amchem Prods., Inc. v. Windsor see also Tyson

Foods, Inc. v. Bouaphakeo Hanlon

Federal Practice & Procedure

See Phillips Petroleum Co. v. Shutts

Zinser v. Accufix Research Inst., Inc.

Nedlloyd Lines

B.V. v. Superior Court In re: Apple Inc. Device Performance Litig.

Nedlloyd

Id. Washington Mut. Bank, FA v. Super. Ct. see also

Bias v. Wells Fargo & Co.

Case 5:18-cv-00801-NC Document 94 Filed 11/05/18 Page 24 of 34

Page 25: 'DQLHO & *LUDUG 6%1 · 2019-07-20 · bsh home appliances corp. ) ... dq rughu fhuwli\lqj d fodvv ri doo lqglylgxdov lq wkh 8qlwhg 6wdwhv zkr sxufkdvhg iurp *rrjoh ru dq dxwkrul]hg

Bias

Id.

include

Id

Id.

See e.g. Cape Flattery Ltd. v. Titan

Mar., LLC

In re Sony Gaming Networks & Customer Data Security Breach Litigation

Id

See, e.g.

Opperman v. Path, Inc.

In re Nexus 6P Prod. Liab. Litig.

Case 5:18-cv-00801-NC Document 94 Filed 11/05/18 Page 25 of 34

Page 26: 'DQLHO & *LUDUG 6%1 · 2019-07-20 · bsh home appliances corp. ) ... dq rughu fhuwli\lqj d fodvv ri doo lqglylgxdov lq wkh 8qlwhg 6wdwhv zkr sxufkdvhg iurp *rrjoh ru dq dxwkrul]hg

Nedlloyd

Bias

Clothesrigger, Inc. v.

GTE Corp.

See, e.g. Outboard

Marine Corp. v. Super. Ct. Gutierrez v. Carmax Auto Superstores

Cal.

Day v. AT & T Corp.

Case 5:18-cv-00801-NC Document 94 Filed 11/05/18 Page 26 of 34

Page 27: 'DQLHO & *LUDUG 6%1 · 2019-07-20 · bsh home appliances corp. ) ... dq rughu fhuwli\lqj d fodvv ri doo lqglylgxdov lq wkh 8qlwhg 6wdwhv zkr sxufkdvhg iurp *rrjoh ru dq dxwkrul]hg

Baranco v. Ford

Motor Co.

Johnson v. Harley-Davidson Motor Co. Grp.,

LLC

Tait v. BSH Home Appliances Corp.

Google

Vega v. Jones, Day, Reavis & Pogue

see

Fitzhenry-Russell

accord Ehret v. Uber Techs., Inc.

Case 5:18-cv-00801-NC Document 94 Filed 11/05/18 Page 27 of 34

Page 28: 'DQLHO & *LUDUG 6%1 · 2019-07-20 · bsh home appliances corp. ) ... dq rughu fhuwli\lqj d fodvv ri doo lqglylgxdov lq wkh 8qlwhg 6wdwhv zkr sxufkdvhg iurp *rrjoh ru dq dxwkrul]hg

Sloan v. Gen. Motors LLC

order clarified

see In

re Anthem, Inc. Data Breach Litig.

Guido v. L’Oreal, USA, Inc.

Case 5:18-cv-00801-NC Document 94 Filed 11/05/18 Page 28 of 34

Page 29: 'DQLHO & *LUDUG 6%1 · 2019-07-20 · bsh home appliances corp. ) ... dq rughu fhuwli\lqj d fodvv ri doo lqglylgxdov lq wkh 8qlwhg 6wdwhv zkr sxufkdvhg iurp *rrjoh ru dq dxwkrul]hg

Torres v. Mercer Canyons Inc.

Wolin

Gaudet v. American Home Shield Corp.

See, e.g. Abdeljalil v. Gen. Elec. Capital Corp.

Knutson v. Schwan’s Home Serv., Inc.

See Avedisian v. Mercedes-Benz, USA, LLC

Case 5:18-cv-00801-NC Document 94 Filed 11/05/18 Page 29 of 34

Page 30: 'DQLHO & *LUDUG 6%1 · 2019-07-20 · bsh home appliances corp. ) ... dq rughu fhuwli\lqj d fodvv ri doo lqglylgxdov lq wkh 8qlwhg 6wdwhv zkr sxufkdvhg iurp *rrjoh ru dq dxwkrul]hg

Id. see also In re Whirlpool Corp. Front-Loading Washer Prods. Liab.

Litig.

Tait v. BSH Home Appliances Corp.

Wolin In re Whirlpool

cf

Introducing the “New Handshake” to Expand Remedies and Revive Responsibility in

Ecommerce

see generally

Consumer Complaints and Public Policy: Validating the “Tip-of-the-Iceberg” Theory

Case 5:18-cv-00801-NC Document 94 Filed 11/05/18 Page 30 of 34

Page 31: 'DQLHO & *LUDUG 6%1 · 2019-07-20 · bsh home appliances corp. ) ... dq rughu fhuwli\lqj d fodvv ri doo lqglylgxdov lq wkh 8qlwhg 6wdwhv zkr sxufkdvhg iurp *rrjoh ru dq dxwkrul]hg

In re Arris Cable Modem Consumer Litig.,

Beaton v. SpeedyPC Software

Just

Film, Inc. v. Buono

Comcast Corp. v. Behrend see Guido

Broomfield v. Craft Brew Alliance, Inc.

see also In re Arris

Briseno v. ConAgra Foods, Inc.

Comcast

Pulaski

See In re Arris

Case 5:18-cv-00801-NC Document 94 Filed 11/05/18 Page 31 of 34

Page 32: 'DQLHO & *LUDUG 6%1 · 2019-07-20 · bsh home appliances corp. ) ... dq rughu fhuwli\lqj d fodvv ri doo lqglylgxdov lq wkh 8qlwhg 6wdwhv zkr sxufkdvhg iurp *rrjoh ru dq dxwkrul]hg

See e.g. Fitzhenry-Russell Hadley v. Kellogg Sales Co.

In re Arris

In re MyFord Touch Consumer Litig.

See, e.g. Guido

Briseno v. ConAgra

Foods, Inc.

Case 5:18-cv-00801-NC Document 94 Filed 11/05/18 Page 32 of 34

Page 33: 'DQLHO & *LUDUG 6%1 · 2019-07-20 · bsh home appliances corp. ) ... dq rughu fhuwli\lqj d fodvv ri doo lqglylgxdov lq wkh 8qlwhg 6wdwhv zkr sxufkdvhg iurp *rrjoh ru dq dxwkrul]hg

See Briseno In re Cathode Ray

Tube (CRT) Antitrust Litig.

rpt. & rec. adopted Comcast

Grace v. Apple, Inc.

See Valentino v. Carter-Wallace, Inc.,

Mullins v. Premier Nutrition Corp.

Hanlon

Case 5:18-cv-00801-NC Document 94 Filed 11/05/18 Page 33 of 34

Page 34: 'DQLHO & *LUDUG 6%1 · 2019-07-20 · bsh home appliances corp. ) ... dq rughu fhuwli\lqj d fodvv ri doo lqglylgxdov lq wkh 8qlwhg 6wdwhv zkr sxufkdvhg iurp *rrjoh ru dq dxwkrul]hg

Jordan Elias

[email protected] [email protected] [email protected] [email protected]

pro hac vicepro hac vice

pro hac vice

[email protected] [email protected] [email protected]

Counsel for Plaintiffs

Jordan Elias

Case 5:18-cv-00801-NC Document 94 Filed 11/05/18 Page 34 of 34