DOCTORAL THESIS SUMMARY - USTfshl.ust.edu.al/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/quka.pdfcorrect poor posture...

38
REPUBLIC OF ALBANIA SPORTS UNIVERSITY OF TIRANA FACULTY OF MOVEMENT SCIENCES THIRD LEVEL OF DOCTORAL STUDIES DOCTORAL THESIS SUMMARY FIELD OF THE STUDY: SPORT SCIENCE TOPIC: POSTURAL DEVELOPMENT AND POSTURAL IMPROVEMENTS IN CHILDREN AGED 10-13 YEARS Doctoral Student: Scientific Supervisor: MSc. Najada Quka (Shore) Prof.Dr. Dhimitraq Stratobёrdha TIRANA, 2017

Transcript of DOCTORAL THESIS SUMMARY - USTfshl.ust.edu.al/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/quka.pdfcorrect poor posture...

Page 1: DOCTORAL THESIS SUMMARY - USTfshl.ust.edu.al/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/quka.pdfcorrect poor posture in children during Physical Education Class, but unfortunately, it is still unclear

REPUBLIC OF ALBANIA

SPORTS UNIVERSITY OF TIRANA

FACULTY OF MOVEMENT SCIENCES

THIRD LEVEL OF DOCTORAL STUDIES

DOCTORAL THESIS SUMMARY FIELD OF THE STUDY: SPORT SCIENCE

TOPIC:

POSTURAL DEVELOPMENT AND POSTURAL

IMPROVEMENTS IN CHILDREN AGED 10-13 YEARS

Doctoral Student: Scientific Supervisor:

MSc. Najada Quka (Shore) Prof.Dr. Dhimitraq Stratobёrdha

TIRANA, 2017

Page 2: DOCTORAL THESIS SUMMARY - USTfshl.ust.edu.al/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/quka.pdfcorrect poor posture in children during Physical Education Class, but unfortunately, it is still unclear

Postural deviation and postural improvements in children aged 10-13 years

Najada Quka (Shore) 1

ABSTRACT

Postural deviation and postural improvements in children aged 10-13 years.

Posture because of modernization and drastic changes in lifestyle appears to be deviated from the

sagittal axis causing and raising various concerns and issues. Aim: This study aims to identify the

prevalence of postural deviations in children aged 10-13 years, in Tirana and to evaluate the

impact of an intervention program in the correction of postural deviation in children.

Methodology: In order to identify the prevalence of postural deviations we selected 308 subjects

aged 10-13 years and for assessing the impact of Intervention Program were selected 67 children

aged 10-11 years. (Control group = 33; Experimental group = 34). To review the contemporary

international literature we used different research software such as Jab Ref, Pub Med, Google

Scholar, Inspire, Medline and Sport Discuss. In order to perform the testing of subjects we used 1)

Leonardo Mechanograph® GRFP and 2) Posture Screen Mobile®-PSM (iPod) and Postural

Analysis Grid Chart. The statistical processing of the gathered data was carried out through SPSS

20.0 analyses program using mainly Descriptive Analysis, Paired-Sample Test (T-test) and

Multifunctional Linear Regression.

Results: Postural deviations are widespread among children aged 10-13 years at a worrying level

because only 7.8% of the 308 subjects were diagnosed with normal posture. In the anterior plane

11.03% of subjects are diagnosed with scoliosis while in the posterior plane the spread of scoliosis

is diagnosed at the level of 90.25%. Results show that kyphoses are detected in 3.57% and lordoses

in 6.49 % of the subjects. In addition to that, results showed that the prevalence of Scoliosis by

gender in the anterior plane is 12.7% in boys and 9.3% in girls, while in the posterior plane are

92% in girls and 88.5% in boys. In the lateral plane kyphoses resulted in 1.3% of the girls and

5.7% of the boys, while lordosis was recorded in 7.3% of the girls and 5.7% of the boys. The

Paired-Sample Test showed that (T-Test) the difference of mean values between two measures

(M1-M2) is significant for p<0.05 in the experimental group (n = 34) both in the Anterior/Posterior

and Lateral plan. While, the results obtained from Multifunctional linear regression analysis of

linear regression resulted in a meaningful relationship between Posture in Total and Balance "EQ-

Equilibrium" (developed in 8 variants, 4 standing positions with open and closed eyes).

I

Page 3: DOCTORAL THESIS SUMMARY - USTfshl.ust.edu.al/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/quka.pdfcorrect poor posture in children during Physical Education Class, but unfortunately, it is still unclear

Postural deviation and postural improvements in children aged 10-13 years

Najada Quka (Shore) 2

Conclusions and Recommendations: Based on the results of our study we conclude that postural

deviations are evident in children aged 10-13 years. Scoliosis is the most common posture

deviation which has affected both genders. Specifically, at the anterior plane boys are recoded to

be more affected by scoliosis while in the posterior plane it appears to be higher in girls. It is

obvious that children posture is affected even by Kyphoses which is more prevalent in boys and

Lordoses which unlike the first one appears more in girls. Another important conclusion of our

study is the effectiveness of our physical exercise program to improve postural behaviors and

balance ability. On these bases, we recommend that parents, teachers and even children should be

more informed about posture and the problems that a poor posture can cause as well as on the

factors that could adversely affect its normal development. The implementation of such physical

exercises in the Physical Education Curriculum is very important as the education of postural

behavior improves the body shape as well as facilitates the execution of motor performance.

Keywords: Posture, children, 10-13 years old, postural deviations, correction of postural

deviations, physical exercises.

I

Page 4: DOCTORAL THESIS SUMMARY - USTfshl.ust.edu.al/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/quka.pdfcorrect poor posture in children during Physical Education Class, but unfortunately, it is still unclear

Postural deviation and postural improvements in children aged 10-13 years

Najada Quka (Shore) 3

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Abstract .......................................................................................................................................................... I

Table of contents ............................................................................................................................................ II

Introduction ................................................................................................................................................... 1

1. Description of the situation ...................................................................................................................... 1

2. The purpose, hypotheses and significance of the study ........................................................................... 2

CHAPTER I

LITERATURE REVIEW

1.1 Posture ................................................................................................................................................... 3

1.1.1 Posture as a concept ................................................................................................................... 3

1.1.2 Postural development in different life stages ........................................................................... 4

1.1.3 The most common postural deviations in children ................................................................... 5

1.1.4 The diagnosis of "postural deviations" ...................................................................................... 6

1.2 Risk factors of poor posture .................................................................................................................. 7

1.2.1 Lifestyle .................................................................................................................................... 7

1.2.2 Lack of physical activity and obesity ....................................................................................... 8

1.3 Prevalence of postural deviations in children aged 10-13 years .......................................................... 9

1.4 The importance of good posture .......................................................................................................... 10

1.5 Correction of postural deviation in children ....................................................................................... 11

CHAPTER II

METHODOLOGY

2.1 Literature review ................................................................................................................................. 12

2.2 Selection of study subjects .................................................................................................................. 12

2.3 Tests and Measuring Instruments ........................................................................................................ 12

2.4 Statistical Analyzes ............................................................................................................................. 13

2.5 Intervention program ........................................................................................................................... 14

CHAPTER III

RESULTS ................................................................................................................................................... 15

CHAPTER IV

DISCUSSION ............................................................................................................................................ 25

CHAPTER V

CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS .................................................................................. 28

BIBLIOGRAPHY ...................................................................................................................................... 31

II

Page 5: DOCTORAL THESIS SUMMARY - USTfshl.ust.edu.al/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/quka.pdfcorrect poor posture in children during Physical Education Class, but unfortunately, it is still unclear

Postural deviation and postural improvements in children aged 10-13 years

Najada Quka (Shore) 1

INTRODUCTION

1. Description of the situation

Posture is precisely the issue that attracted our attention to be studied and analyzed, stimulated not

only by the nature of this phenomenon that children are increasingly facing nowadays but

especially by its negative health consequences if the correction of postural deviation is not

performed in time. As a result of technology evolution, it is noticed that new generation of modern

society is increasingly facing with postural problems because changes that this evolution has

caused in their lives have influenced significantly their posture. Because of the alarming

prevalence, postural deviations become the most common research issue by different scientists

who considered it as one of the critical problems of the 21-th

century that had conquered young

generation. The human body is changing throughout life, but the greatest challenges are recorded

during puberty when posture as a result of the dynamic changes appears to be more flexible. In

addition to that posture can easily be modified even from negative factors such as: standing for

hours in front of computers or video games, the way they seat in class, how they do homework,

heavy school bags or ways of holding the bag, using urban transport, unhealthy food, low level of

physical activity or wearing uncomfortable shoes. The degree of postural deviations from sagittal

axis may deteriorate more if these negative factors influence continuously and for a long time. So

we emphasize that being aware of "negative factors" or "health problems" that postural deviations

can cause over time, have a special importance to challenge this phenomenon. There are

evidenced that most of the postural deviation are caused by "lack of information” about posture.

The correction of postural deviations is another important thing to challenge postural deviation. It

must be performed before that growth process is completed because it is more efficient and easier

to improve posture displacement. This is why is very important that diagnosis must be performed

as soon as possible in our children live. (Cosma et al, 2015) The most common of postural

deviations in children are scoliosis, lordoses and kyphoses which unfortunately appear to

increasingly concern young generation. This alarming prevalence of postural deviations in

children, evidenced by various international authors, attracted our attention investigating it even in

Albania.

Page 6: DOCTORAL THESIS SUMMARY - USTfshl.ust.edu.al/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/quka.pdfcorrect poor posture in children during Physical Education Class, but unfortunately, it is still unclear

Postural deviation and postural improvements in children aged 10-13 years

Najada Quka (Shore) 2

There are many research articles that directly investigated about the intervention programs to

correct poor posture in children during Physical Education Class, but unfortunately, it is still

unclear that which can be the most effective physical exercise program to correct poor postural

habits. Despite that “strengthening and stretching postural muscles” is the aim that guided all of

those who studied about the correction of postural deviation via physical exercises. After a detailed

analyze of training programs used by contemporary international researchers for correcting

postural deviations during Physical Education Class we decided to apply a combination of

isometric and stretching exercises. Isometric exercises were chosen by us because of the fact that

those are not only one of strength training methods but also because children seem to be more

confident to perform them. Isometric exercises are characterized by an unchangeable motor

scheme where the movement is easily available and understandable for kids. (Bomba & Haff,

2009, Markola et al., 2016)

2. The purpose, hypotheses and significance of the study

The main purpose of our study is to determine the prevalence of postural deviation in children

aged 10-13 years and to identify the impact of the intervention program to correct the postural

deviation in children aged 10-11 years.

Hypotheses of our study are:

H1: Do children aged 10-13 years are affected from postural deviations?

H2 Does the selected intervention program have any effect in correcting postural deviations?

Significance of the study

Identification of postural deviations such as scoliosis, lordosis and kyphoses is not totally unknown

in our country but the uniqueness of this study is the implementation of intervention program

"during Physical Education class" to correct postural deviations. Hoping that the results,

conclusions and recommendations of our study will help not only those who study this field but

also beyond, because through it, we highlight which of postural deviations are most common in

Albanian children aged 10-13 years and how to manage or correct this phenomenon in order to

improve our children’s quality of life through exercise.

Page 7: DOCTORAL THESIS SUMMARY - USTfshl.ust.edu.al/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/quka.pdfcorrect poor posture in children during Physical Education Class, but unfortunately, it is still unclear

Postural deviation and postural improvements in children aged 10-13 years

Najada Quka (Shore) 3

CHAPTER I:

LITERATURE REVIEW

1.1 POSTURE

1.1.1 Posture as a concept

The way how posture is considered by the scientific researchers is quite diverse. Anatomists and

the scientist of Kinesiology had seen posture as an aesthetic problem considering it as "human

body's ability to maintain static and dynamic balance in relation to the force of gravity." (Loots,

1999; Kendall et al., 2005) "Posture" is considered also as a motor habit in a certain morphological

and functional background considering it as an indicator of the mechanical efficiency of the kinetic

condition and muscle balance or neuromuscular coordination. (Latalski et al., 2013)

By many researchers, the ability to keep the body straight during dynamic and static movements is

considered as a relative relationship between the different parts of the body in order to keep it

upright. (Bloomfield et al., 1994; Norris, 2000; Kendall et al., 2005; Penha et al., 2005) Also, good

posture is analyzed in another perspective considering it as a necessity to easily execute different

motor tasks. (Grissaffi, 2007., Gluckman, 1995)

According to Motow -Czyż and Ningthoujam "posture" is the reflection of the individual well-

being, activity, and personality. (Motow –Czyz et al., 2014; Ningthuajam, 2014)

While from Kratenova posture is considered as a behavior that is performed mechanically which

can easily be modified and affected by various actions or habits. (Kratenova et al., 2007)

According to Bloomfield and Norris having a "good posture" means to have a muscle balance,

which is necessary to protect the supporting structures of the body against injury or progressive

deformation. (Bloomfield et al., 1994; Norris, 2000) The necessity of good posture is analyzed also

in the relationship with emotional aspects considering it "outside mirror of emotional feelings".

(Feldenkrais, 1985; Lafond et al., 2007)

Page 8: DOCTORAL THESIS SUMMARY - USTfshl.ust.edu.al/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/quka.pdfcorrect poor posture in children during Physical Education Class, but unfortunately, it is still unclear

Postural deviation and postural improvements in children aged 10-13 years

Najada Quka (Shore) 4

1.1.2 Postural development in different life stage.

Postural development process seems to be associated with some specific physiological changes

which are considered part of development and growth process. In this case, these must be

considered normal changes until these do not persist throughout life.

Infants: The declinations of the spine that can be observed since birth are called the “first

curvature” and they appear in the thoracic and sacral area. Infant’s spine continues to maintain this

shape until they begin to develop other concave curvature. After three months of life, new postures

shape appears to baby’s posture because a convex curvature starts to develop. (Magee, 2002;

Dickson, 2004)

Children: “Flat Foot” symptoms seem to be normal at 10-18 months when he begins to learn how

to walk, but if this foot shape continues to be even after it must be considered as a postural

distortion. In this period “curved legs” appear to be also part of their postural development. But

this postural misalignment can be considered normal until the age of 2 years when “walking’ start

to be a confident motor movement. (Magee, 2002)

Pre-school age: Lumbar Hyperlordosis is a normal postural shape at ages 2-6 years because

during this life stage an imbalance occurs between abdominal muscle and hip flexor muscle. It

should be noted that the rate of lumbar lordoses must be reduced year after year. (Magee, 2002;

Kendall et al., 2005)

School age: In this age is observed the presence of thoracic kyphoses (rounded shoulders) which is

normal until the age of 8 years, but it becomes a problem if it persists in another life stage.

(Kendall et al., 2005) In this period boy’s postural shape is characterized by longer upper and

lower extremities, wide shoulders, narrowed pelvis and larger sized body compared with girls. For

this reason, boys seem to be more likely to have such postural deviations then girls. (Magee, 2002)

Page 9: DOCTORAL THESIS SUMMARY - USTfshl.ust.edu.al/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/quka.pdfcorrect poor posture in children during Physical Education Class, but unfortunately, it is still unclear

Postural deviation and postural improvements in children aged 10-13 years

Najada Quka (Shore) 5

1.1.3 The most common postural deviations in children

To restore a new balance in accordance with rapid and progressive changes that occur during

puberty, our body performs compensatory actions which often become the reason for the

emergence of postural deviations. The most common postural deviations that occur in children are

scoliosis, lordosis and kyphoses. (Latalski et al, 2013)

Scoliosis is the distortion or lateral bending of the spine (left or right). The period of adolescence is

the most likely period to be affected by this shape of the spine. Scoliosis is classified into

Functional (acquired); Structural (inherited) and Idiopathic (without cause). (Dickson, 1994;

Loveless, 1999; Magee, 2002; Brox, 2003)

Kyphoses has considered the excessive curvature of the spine in the thoracic area observed in the

lateral plane. (Arnheim & Prentice, 2000; Strieker et al., 2002; Kendall et al., 2005) There are

three categories of kyphoses: postural kyphoses, congenital kyphoses "genetic" and juvenile

kyphoses. (Krugh & Keysor, 1996; Arneihem & Prentice, 2000; Strieker, 2002; Kendall et al.,

2005)

Lordosis is defined the excessive curvature of the spine in the lumbar area observed in the lateral

plane. This spine distortion occurs more at the obese people and pregnant women. (Kendall et al.,

2005); Magee, 2002)

Page 10: DOCTORAL THESIS SUMMARY - USTfshl.ust.edu.al/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/quka.pdfcorrect poor posture in children during Physical Education Class, but unfortunately, it is still unclear

Postural deviation and postural improvements in children aged 10-13 years

Najada Quka (Shore) 6

1.1.4 The diagnosis of "postural deviations"

The methods used by various researchers to diagnose postural deviations are different and they are

classified into objective (ex: Posture Screen Mobile) and subjective methods (ex. Visual

Observation). (Niekerk, 2008) Subjective methods, contrary to objective methods, are identified

for low statistical accuracy because they depend on the professional ability to observe and to

interpret the data. While objective methods are identified for statistical reliability and validity.

(Niekerk, 2008; Elisabeth et al., 2010)

Postural Analysis Grid Chart and Plumb Line Test is one of the most economical methods

which can be used easily even by Physical Education Teacher. Also, this method is identified even

for its statistical accuracy in both the anterior, posterior and lateral plane. (Minno et al., 2013,

Ningthoujam, 2014)

Bueno and Rech used a subjective method such as "visual observation" to investigate the

prevalence of postural deviations in children. (Bueno & Rech, 2013) Even why this visual

observation is a very economical method there are higher possibilities to mistake violating the

accuracy of the data obtained from it. (Badaro et al., 2015)

"X-Ray" is one of many objective methods quite sophisticated and with high statistical reliability

which is used by Hershkovich but he clearly expressed that this examination wasn’t possible by

everyone because of its expensive cost. (Hershkovich et al., 2013)

Posture Screen Mobile is another objective method which is recently widely applied, mentioning

here Rosell and Cosma who used it not only for postural deviation diagnose but also to identify the

impact of the intervention program to correct postural deviations in children. (Rosell et al., 2010;

Cosma et al., 2015)

Page 11: DOCTORAL THESIS SUMMARY - USTfshl.ust.edu.al/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/quka.pdfcorrect poor posture in children during Physical Education Class, but unfortunately, it is still unclear

Postural deviation and postural improvements in children aged 10-13 years

Najada Quka (Shore) 7

1.2 RISK FACTORS OF POOR POSTURE

1.2.1 Lifestyle

Our daily life habits changed a lot as consequence of modernization process which has

significantly modified posture shape of human being. Because of that poor posture become one of

the most studied issues by many scientific researchers and the phenomenon that dramatically

diffusion among young generation. (Motow -Czyz et al., 2014; Brianezi et al., 2011)

These last two decades is identified that young generation is frequently attracted by the use of

electronic devices (eg: Mobile, iPad, video game act) which is identified to affect the upright

standing that professionally is called "Posture" causing mostly head forward symptoms. (Tremblay

& Willms, 2000; Banfield, 2000; Misra et al., 2012)

This evidence is revealed even by Kratenova who emphasized that children who were spending 14

hours a week watching television or playing video games had the highest probability of poor

posture occurrence. (Kratenova et al., 2007)

Furthermore, it is observed that a significant relationship exists between body weight and lordosis;

how to do homework and kyphoses, sitting position or the way they hold school bag and scoliosis

or the use of uncomfortable shoes and hallux valgus occurrence. (Minoo et al., 2013)

Even why these uncomfortable shoes can affect the appearance of plantar flat-footed, knock knee

or bow legs it is highlighted that the range of these displacements is not a worrying problem.

(Ningthoujam, 2014)

Page 12: DOCTORAL THESIS SUMMARY - USTfshl.ust.edu.al/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/quka.pdfcorrect poor posture in children during Physical Education Class, but unfortunately, it is still unclear

Postural deviation and postural improvements in children aged 10-13 years

Najada Quka (Shore) 8

1.2.2 Lack of physical activity and obesity

Urban transportation is one of the numerous facilities created by modernization process in our

life but the widely use of this is noticed to affects children’s physical activity level which is closely

correlated to postural deviations. (Saunders et al., 1995; Sallis, 2000; Banfield, 2000; Misra et al.,

2012)

Excessive body weight (overweight or obesity) is another risk factor that may induce postural

changes which come out as consequence of compensatory actions that human body produce in

order to restore the lost balance or to maintain it. (Kussuki et al., 2007; Rosell et al., 2010)

Despite that, it is emphasized that “excessive body weight" is not a key risk factor of poor posture

but it increases the probability of their occurrence and can influence the aggravation of existed

postural deviation. (Silva et al., 2011)

Another risk factor that affects children’s postural shape is school bag especially its weight and

how it is holding by them. (Milardovic et al., 2014) Studies have shown that school bag should not

exceed 15% of children’s body weight otherwise, it can alter posture shape forcing head to come

forward. (Hong & Cheung, 2003; Misra et al., 2012; Balamurugan et al., 2014)

Postural behavior scan is affected even by emotional feelings which are related to the fact that

posture is the reflection of how we feel inside considering it as the mirror of our inside feelings.

(Loots et al., 2001)

Page 13: DOCTORAL THESIS SUMMARY - USTfshl.ust.edu.al/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/quka.pdfcorrect poor posture in children during Physical Education Class, but unfortunately, it is still unclear

Postural deviation and postural improvements in children aged 10-13 years

Najada Quka (Shore) 9

1.3 PREVALENCE OF POSTURAL DEVIATIONS IN CHILDREN

AGED 10-13 YEARS

Evidence shows a different prevalence of postural deviations in children and it is evident that "this

phenomenon" has dramatically increased especially these last two decades and mostly in children.

(Balamurugan, 2014)

Scoliosis has been one of the most postural deviations studied because the youth asymmetry body

was the most frequent symptoms recorded in those years. From the study of Kane and Moe

scoliosis resulted at 0.13% and according to them girls were more affected by this deviation than

boys (1.5: 1). (Kane and Moe, 1970)

There is another study that analyzed postural deviations and they discovered that the prevalence of

scoliosis is 4.3% in girls and 1.2% in boys. (Willner & Uden, 1982) Karachalios provided that

1.18% of subjects have scoliosis and there isn’t any difference between girls and boys so they were

identified in the ratio 1:1 regarding scoliosis occurrence. (Karachalios et al., 1999)

This unnoticed gender difference resulted also at Protic-Gava study who emphasized that although

girls were identified with the incorrect posture more than boys, the difference between them was

not significant. The results of his study show that 58.2% of children aged 10-13 years were

diagnosed with lordosis and 32.8% with kyphoses. (Protic-Gava et al., 2011)

There is evidence that lordosis is the most popular postural deviation in school age children which

occur at 45% of them while scoliosis was diagnosed in 7%. (Rulon & Gale, 1987)

While Stroebel reported another prevalence of postural deviations in children and respectively

lordosis at 70% of subjects while rounded shoulders at 57% of them. (Stroebel, 2002)

Different prevalence values of postural deviation are seen at Kratenova’s study that identified

scoliosis in 50% of subjects, lordosis in 32% of them and kyphoses in 31%. (Kratenova et al.,

2007)

Bueno and Rech in their study highlighted that the most common postural deviation is scoliosis

and the age 8-12 years is identified as the "critical" age for hyperlordosis but not favorable for

dorsal kyphoses. Postural deviations identified in this study are scoliosis at 33.2% of subjects,

lumbar hyperlordosis at 27.9% of them and dorsal kyphoses at 16.6%. (Bueno & Rech, 2013)

Page 14: DOCTORAL THESIS SUMMARY - USTfshl.ust.edu.al/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/quka.pdfcorrect poor posture in children during Physical Education Class, but unfortunately, it is still unclear

Postural deviation and postural improvements in children aged 10-13 years

Najada Quka (Shore) 10

Sedrez reported this prevalence such as 50.8 % with kyphoses, 47.4% with scoliosis and 32.2%

with lordosis. (Sedrez et al., 2015)

While from another study is reported that 48.61% of 144 children aged 10-13 years were

diagnosed with scoliosis, 32.63% with lordosis and 30.55% with kyphoses. (Quka & Kaçurri,

2016)

1.4 THE IMPORTANCE OF GOOD POSTURE

Good Posture Education and Correcting Postural Deviations in children are very important for

their wellbeing because the pain that postural displacement produce is uncomfortable affecting the

quality of children's daily movement. (Stroebel, 2002)

There are several health concerns that children may face especially if their posture displacement is

not corrected in time and affects their posture shape for a long time such as insufficient circulation

in the brain (forward head); breathing difficulties (kyphoses), malfunction of heart (kyphoses and

scoliosis, both of them); stomach inflammation or nausea (rounded shoulders reducing space

between sternum and pubic bone). (Wiggins & Victoria, 1931: Loveless, 1999; Dickson, 2004)

Page 15: DOCTORAL THESIS SUMMARY - USTfshl.ust.edu.al/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/quka.pdfcorrect poor posture in children during Physical Education Class, but unfortunately, it is still unclear

Postural deviation and postural improvements in children aged 10-13 years

Najada Quka (Shore) 11

1.5 CORRECTION OF POSTURAL DEVIATION IN CHILDREN

During the literature review, it was observed that a variety of exercises are used by different

authors to correct postural deviation but all of them were guided by the same aim to "strength and

stretching" postural muscles. Because of numerous exercises, the most effective intervention

program in correcting postural displacements continues to be unidentified. (Auxter et al., 1996;

Brianezi et al., 2011; Quka, 2015)

Pilates was one of many intervention programs used to correct posture deviations and resulted that

these exercises can improve not only postural behaviors but even equilibrium. (Cordeiro et al.,

2014; Deutschmann et al., 2014)

In addition to that Misra studied the impact of isometric exercises and stretching in posture

deviation and it was revealed that this kind of exercises has significantly improved postural

behavior in children. (Misra et al., 2012)

While Oliver used only 4 isometric exercises during first 5 minutes of Physical Education Class

and he highlighted the importance of strengthening postural muscles to keep a correct posture.

(Oliver, 2010; Grissaffi, 2007)

Byun used basic exercises of Taekwondo to correct postural deviations and he shows the positive

effects of these exercises on postural behaviors improvement. (Byun et al., 2014)

The important role of physical exercises in correcting postural deviations is analyzed even by

Cosma who implemented a corrective gymnastic program composed of isometric and dynamic

exercises. The importance of these exercises to improve children’s postural behaviors was clearly

highlighted in her study. (Cosma et al., 2015)

Page 16: DOCTORAL THESIS SUMMARY - USTfshl.ust.edu.al/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/quka.pdfcorrect poor posture in children during Physical Education Class, but unfortunately, it is still unclear

Postural deviation and postural improvements in children aged 10-13 years

Najada Quka (Shore) 12

CHAPTER II:

METHODOLOGY

2.1 LITERATURE REVIEW

For the literature review, we used an extensive scientific literature collected by various research

sectors such as JabRef research, PubMed, Google Scholar, Inspire, Medline, Sports Discuss

act. We were focused more on those research articles that had directly investigated the prevalence

of postural deviation in children and their correction during Physical Education Class.

2.2 SELECTION OF STUDY SUBJECTS

In our study participated 308 children aged 10 -13 years who were randomly selected in public

schools of Tirana respectively from the secondary school “Naim Frashëri” and the primary school

"Gustav Myjer".

Postural deviations diagnosis was conducted on a contingent of 308 children aged 10-13 years (n

= 151 girls, n = 157 boys) while the impact of intervention program was analyzed at 67 subjects

who were randomly selected and divided into two groups. So in the experimental group (N = 34,

16 boys & 18 girls), who participated regularly in the intervention program for 12 weeks, 2

times/week, and in the control group (n = 33, 16 boys & 17 girls) who were not part of this

experiment but they continued their daily routine.

2.3 TESTS DHE MEASURING INSTRUMENTS

In order to perform the testing of subjects we used: 1) Posture test using Postural Analysis Grid

Chart and Posture Screen Mobile® (PSM), and 2) Balance test using Leonardo

Mechanography® (GRFP) located in the biomechanics lab at the Sports University of Tirana.

Page 17: DOCTORAL THESIS SUMMARY - USTfshl.ust.edu.al/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/quka.pdfcorrect poor posture in children during Physical Education Class, but unfortunately, it is still unclear

Postural deviation and postural improvements in children aged 10-13 years

Najada Quka (Shore) 13

1) Posture Test: IPAD “Posture Screen Mobile®”& Postural Analysis Grid Chart.

IPAD is the instrument that we used to photograph 308 children, 4 times each, in anterior/

posterior and lateral plan (left and right) and after that, we transferred them to Posture Screen

Mobile® to analyze their postural shape. This new application is revealed in 2010 by Dr. Joe

Ferrantelli, an orthopedic graduated in Life University. Children were photographed near to

Postural Analysis Grid Chart and to provide an appropriate postural assessment, children were

told to be lightly wearing so boys only with shorts (over the knees) while girls with topless and

shorts too.

2) Balance Test: Leonardo Mechanography® (GRFP)

This test is used to evaluate balance at 67 children aged 10-11 years. The balance test was

conducted in 4 different positions, with eyes open and eyes closed, so in 8 variants and

respectively in Romberg Test (eyes open, eyes closed –RomEO/EC) Semi Tandem Test (eyes

open, eyes closed-SemTan EO/EC), Tandem Test (eyes open, eyes closed-TanEO/EC) and 1 leg

Test (eyes open, closed eyes-1L_EC/EO).

2.4 STATISTICAL ANALYZE

To analyze the collected data statistically, we used "IBM SPSS Statistics 20" by different

analytical techniques such as Descriptive Analyse, Paired Simple Test "T-Test" and

Multifunctional Linear Regression.

In this statistical analyze we used several variables such as angulation of posture displacement (in

total) (Anterior & Posterior plan) to identify scoliosis and averaged lateral angulation of

"shoulder"/"hip-pelvis" displacement (left & right) to identify kyphoses and lordosis. These

variables were used to determine also the impact of the intervention program on improving

postural parameters, while for the assessment of balance we analyzed EQ- Equilibrium, obtained

from 8 variants of Balance Test.

Page 18: DOCTORAL THESIS SUMMARY - USTfshl.ust.edu.al/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/quka.pdfcorrect poor posture in children during Physical Education Class, but unfortunately, it is still unclear

Postural deviation and postural improvements in children aged 10-13 years

Najada Quka (Shore) 14

2.5 INTERVENTION PROGRAM

Many of intervention programs used were based on strengthening and stretching muscles in order

to reduce muscle imbalance induced by different external or internal factors. (Hrysomallis &

Goodman, 2001; Annamaria et al., 2003; Misra et al., 2012; Oliver, 2010; Cordeiro et al., 2014;

Cosma et al., 2015)

One of many intervention programs to correct postural deviations is the program of Oliver and

Misra who were focused on isometric and stretching exercises implementing them differentlly.

(Oliver et al., 2010; Misra et al., 2012)

It is very important to emphasize that these two studies are our main referees regarding the

intervention program but it was differently planned including also a variety of postural education

games during the preparation phase of Physical Education Class. Our intervention program is

composed of 6 isometric exercises (20 second each, 2 repetitions, 1:1) and 6 stretching exercises.

Our study lasted almost 6 months (October 2015/March 2016) including here 12 weeks of

intervention program (December 2015 February 2016), previous tests “Posture and Balance Test”

(October-November 2015) for 308 subjects and final tests for 67 subjects (March 2016).

To implement this intervention program during physical education class, 2 times a week, we were

allowed to freely use the gym of primary school "Gustav Myjer". Each session lasted 45 minutes.

After 12-weeks of experimentation period, both two (2) groups underwent immediately to final

tests to assess posture and balance.

Page 19: DOCTORAL THESIS SUMMARY - USTfshl.ust.edu.al/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/quka.pdfcorrect poor posture in children during Physical Education Class, but unfortunately, it is still unclear

Postural deviation and postural improvements in children aged 10-13 years

Najada Quka (Shore) 15

CHAPTER III: RESULTS

Participants in our study

Age Gender Frequency

N

Percent

%

10.00

N=77

Girls

Boys

43

34

55.8

44.2

11.00

N=86

Girls

Boys

39

47

45.3

54.7

12.00

N=104

Girls

Boys

48

56

46.2

53.8

13.00

N=41

Girls

Boys

21

20

51.2

48.8

Girls = 151 / Boys 157

Table 1. Participants by gender and age.

Table 1 shows that from 308 participants there are 49.03 % girls and 50.97 % boys and their mean

age is 11.5 years old.

SCOLIOSIS - Anterior Plan

SCOLIOSIS BY AGE

BY AGE & GENDER Frequency Percent Frequency Percent

N % N %

Girls Normal Posture 40 93.00 71 92.20

Age 10 N = 43 Light Scoliosis 3 7.00

N = 77 Boys Normal Posture 31 91.20

6 7.80 N = 34 Light Scoliosis 3 8.80

Girls Normal Posture 38 97.40 79 91.90

Age 11 N = 39 Light Scoliosis 1 2.60

N = 86 Boys Normal Posture 41 87.20

7 8.10 N = 47 Light Scoliosis 6 12.80

Girls Normal Posture 41 85.40 91 87.50

Age 12 N = 48 Light Scoliosis 7 14.60

N = 104 Boys Normal Posture 50 89.30

13 12.50 N = 56 Light Scoliosis 6 10.70

Girls Normal Posture 18 85.70 33 80.50

Age 13 N = 21 Light Scoliosis 3 14.30

N = 41 Boys Normal Posture 15 75.00

8 19.50 N = 20 Light Scoliosis 5 25.00

Table 2. Prevalence of scoliosis in children by age & gender, measured from the

Anterior Plan.

Page 20: DOCTORAL THESIS SUMMARY - USTfshl.ust.edu.al/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/quka.pdfcorrect poor posture in children during Physical Education Class, but unfortunately, it is still unclear

Postural deviation and postural improvements in children aged 10-13 years

Najada Quka (Shore) 16

Graph 1. Prevalence of scoliosis by gender, measured from the Anterior Plan.

Table 2 shows that children aged 13 years (19.5%) are more affected by light scoliosis. Also, it is

shown that 11.03% are affected by light scoliosis. In Graph 1 it is noted that light scoliosis is

manifested more in boys (12.7%) than girls (9.3%).

Descriptive Statistics

By gender

Gender Age Min Max Mean Std Min Max Mean Std

10 0.00 15.50 4.8453 3.2895

0.0 15.50 5.4361 3.2384 Girls 11 0.00 12.20 5.0718 2.6433

N = 151 12 0.00 14.70 6.1458 3.1451

13 0.00 15.00 5.7000 4.1370

10 0.00 11.20 4.8176 2.9368

0.0 18.10 5.8185 3.5487 Boys 11 0.00 12.70 5.2426 3.5932

N = 157 12 0.00 15.50 6.2143 3.5294

13 2.80 18.10 7.7650 3.7465

Table 3. Descriptive data of Scoliosis by age and gender, measured from the Anterior plan.

Table 3 shows that the posture of boys (5.81850) seem to be more displaced (aggravated scoliosis)

than girls (5.43610) which unfortunately appears to become more emphasized through years. Mean

values of posture displacement are recorded to be higher in boys of 13 years old (7.76500) and in

girls of 12 years old (6.14580).

Girls Boys

90,70% 87,30%

9,30% 12,70%

Scoliosis by Gender

Normal Posture Light Scoliosis

Page 21: DOCTORAL THESIS SUMMARY - USTfshl.ust.edu.al/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/quka.pdfcorrect poor posture in children during Physical Education Class, but unfortunately, it is still unclear

Postural deviation and postural improvements in children aged 10-13 years

Najada Quka (Shore) 17

SCOLIOSIS - Posterior Plan

Graph 2. Scoliosis by age, measured from the Posterior Plan.

Graph 3. Prevalence of scoliosis by gender, measured from the Posterior Plan.

As it is shown in Graph 2, the prevalence of scoliosis result about 90.25%, where 53.89% are

diagnosed with light scoliosis (10-20 degrees) and 36.36% with average scoliosis (20- 40 degrees).

Girls Boys

7,90% 11,50%

51% 56,70%

41% 31,80%

Scoliosis by Gender

Normal Posture Light Scoliosis Average Scoliosis

Age 10 Age 11 Age 12 Age 13

9,10% 15,10%

5,80% 9,80%

58,40% 53,50% 52,90%

48,80%

32,50% 31,40%

41,30% 41,50%

Scoliosis by Age.

Normal Posture Light Scoliosis Average Scoliosis

Page 22: DOCTORAL THESIS SUMMARY - USTfshl.ust.edu.al/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/quka.pdfcorrect poor posture in children during Physical Education Class, but unfortunately, it is still unclear

Postural deviation and postural improvements in children aged 10-13 years

Najada Quka (Shore) 18

The results show that children aged 12 years (94.2%) are more affected by this postural deviation.

(Graph 2) Also, it is shown that girls (92%) seem to be more affected by scoliosis than boys

(88.5%). (Graph 3)

Descriptive Statistics

By gender

Gender Age Min Max Mean Std Min Max Mean Std

10 8.70 29.80 17.7721 5.7120

2.9 36.70 18.7874 6.2082 Girls 11 2.90 30.90 18.1564 6.5670

N = 151 12 4.50 33.80 19.9688 6.2744

13 9.70 36.70 19.3381 6.2792

10 6.10 32.00 17.2912 6.2011

1.0 36.80 17.6039 7.1782 Boys 11 1.02 36.80 16.0323 7.5766

N = 157 12 3.30 35.80 18.0732 6.8250

13 8.60 35.90 20.5150 8.1611

Table 4. Descriptive data of Scoliosis by age and gender, measured from the Posterior plan.

At Table 4 it is noted that the mean value of posture displacement (in total) is higher among girls

aged 12 years (19.96880) and boys aged 13 years (20.5150

o) and according to gender scoliosis is

noted to be more aggravated in girls than in boys (girls = 18.7870; boys = 17.604

0).

KYPHOSES – Lateral Plan

Graph 4. Kyphoses by age, measured from the Lateral Plan.

Age 10 Age 11 Age 12 Age 13

94,80% 97,70% 95,20% 100,00%

5,20% 2,30% 4,80% 0,00%

Kyphoses by Age

Normal Posture Light Kyphoses

Page 23: DOCTORAL THESIS SUMMARY - USTfshl.ust.edu.al/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/quka.pdfcorrect poor posture in children during Physical Education Class, but unfortunately, it is still unclear

Postural deviation and postural improvements in children aged 10-13 years

Najada Quka (Shore) 19

Graph 5. Prevalence of kyphoses by gender, measured from the Lateral Plan.

Graph 4 shows that light kyphoses (10-20 degrees) are more prevalent in children aged 10 years

and in Graph 5 it is clearly shown that boys (5.7%) are more affected by kyphoses than girls

(1.3%). These results show that the prevalence of kyphoses is about 3.57 %.

Descriptive Statistics

By gender

Gender Age Min Max Mean Std Min Max Mean Std

10 -2.30 10.57 4.1144 2.4128

-2.69 10.57 3.0960 2.3230 Girls 11 -1.90 6.65 2.9754 1.9689

N = 151 12 -1.46 6.54 2.4623 1.9596

13 -2.69 7.58 2.6829 2.9078

10 -1.44 9.21 3.5232 2.7445

-2.13 10.22 3.8400 2.6665 Boys 11 -2.13 9.55 4.0828 2.8812

N = 157 12 -1.75 10.22 3.9105 2.7257

13 -0.06 7.29 3.6105 1.8157

Table 5. Descriptive data of kyphoses by age and gender, measured from the Lateral Plan.

As it is shown in Table 5 the mean value of averaged lateral angulation of "shoulder"

displacement (left & right) is recorded to be higher among girls at the age of 10 years (4.11440)

and among boys at the age of 11 years (4.08280). According to gender, results show that kyphoses

are more aggravated among boys (3.840) than girls (3.096

0).

Girls

Boys

98,70%

94,30%

1,30%

5,70%

Kyphoses by Gender

Normal Posture Light Kyphoses

Page 24: DOCTORAL THESIS SUMMARY - USTfshl.ust.edu.al/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/quka.pdfcorrect poor posture in children during Physical Education Class, but unfortunately, it is still unclear

Postural deviation and postural improvements in children aged 10-13 years

Najada Quka (Shore) 20

LORDOSIS - Lateral Plan

LORDOSIS BY AGE

BY AGE & GENDER Frequency Percent Frequency Percent

N % N %

Girls Normal Posture 41 95.30

72 93.50

10 years old N = 43 Light Lordosis 2 4.70

N = 77 Boys Normal Posture 31 91.20 5 6.50

N = 34 Light Lordosis 3 8.80

Girls Normal Posture 34 87.20 76 88.40

11 years old N = 39 Light Lordosis 5 12.80

N = 86 Boys Normal Posture 42 89.40 10 11.60

N = 47 Light Lordosis 5 10.60

Girls Normal Posture 46 95.80 101 97.10

12 years old N = 48 Light Lordosis 2 4.20

N = 104 Boys Normal Posture 55 98.20 3 2.90

N = 56 Light Lordosis 1 1.80

Girls Normal Posture 19 90.50 39 95.10

13 years old N = 21 Light Lordosis 2 9.50

N = 41 Boys Normal Posture 20 100.00 2 4.90

N = 20 Light Lordosis 0 0.00

Table 6. Prevalence of lordosis by age & gender, measured from the Lateral Plan.

Graph 6. Prevalence of lordosis by gender, measured from the Lateral Plan.

Girls Boys

92,70% 94,30%

7,30% 5,70%

Lordosis by Gender

Normal Posture Light Lordosis

Page 25: DOCTORAL THESIS SUMMARY - USTfshl.ust.edu.al/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/quka.pdfcorrect poor posture in children during Physical Education Class, but unfortunately, it is still unclear

Postural deviation and postural improvements in children aged 10-13 years

Najada Quka (Shore) 21

From Table 6 it is noticed that 6.49% of children are affected by lordosis which is more prevalent

among children aged 11 years (11.6%).

In Graph 6 it is clearly shown that girls (7.3%) are more affected by lordosis than boys (5.7%).

Descriptive Statistics

By gender

Gender Age Min Max Mean Std Min Max Mean Std

10 -16.35 1.57 -4.4105 3.4245

-16.35 1.66 -3.7250 3.6697 Girls 11 -13.03 3.25 -4.0238 4.1350

N = 151 12 -10.84 5.15 -2.9458 2.9762

13 -9.22 10.66 -3.5476 4.5162

10 -12.72 5.00 -3.5953 4.2864

-12.72 5.94 -2.9617 3.7013 Boys 11 -11.05 4.27 -2.9466 4.0898

N = 157 12 -11.69 5.94 -2.5459 3.3888

13 -6.64 1.77 -3.0845 2.3639

Table 7. Descriptive data of lordosis by age and gender, measured from the Lateral Plan.

*Negative values show the presence of lordosis. (>- 10 0)

Table 7 shows that the averaged lateral angulation of hip-pelvis displacement (left & right) is

higher among children aged 10 years while according to gender it is shown that lordosis appears

more aggravated among girls (-3.72500) than boys (-2.9617

0).

Page 26: DOCTORAL THESIS SUMMARY - USTfshl.ust.edu.al/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/quka.pdfcorrect poor posture in children during Physical Education Class, but unfortunately, it is still unclear

Postural deviation and postural improvements in children aged 10-13 years

Najada Quka (Shore) 22

BY AGE

POSTURAL

DEVIATION N %

BY GENDER Age 10 = 77 Age 11 = 86 Age 12 = 104 Age 13 = 41

N % N % N % N % N %

N = 308

Normal

Posture 24 7.80

11

Girls 7.30

6 7.80 10 11.60 6 5.80 2 4.90 13

Boys 8.30

1 postural

deviation 230 74.70

116

Girls 76.80

60 78.00 62 72.10 77 74.00 31 75.60 114

Boys 72.60

2 postural

deviations 50 16.20

22

Girls 14.60

9 11.70 12 14.00 21 20.02 8 19.50 28

Boys 17.80

3 postural

deviations 4 1.30

2

Girls 1.30

2 2.60 2 2.30 - - - - 2

Boys 1.30

Table 8. Postural deviations according to gender and age.

From Table 8 we noticed that only 7.8% of children are diagnosed with normal posture while

74.7 % are identified with at least one postural deviation, 16.2 % with two postural deviations

and 1.3 % of them with three postural deviations. Furthermore, results show us that girls are more

affected than boys.

Paired Simple Test Screen Mobile Scoliosis Anterior/Posterior View

Posture Displacement Paired Differences t

Sig.(2-

tailed)

In total Mean Std.

St.

Error 95%

Control Group Deviation Mean Lower Upper

Anterior T1 - T2 5.22 2.84 0.76 1.15 9.53 3.21 .226*

Posterior T1 - T2 16.18 4.27 1.67 2.97 26.34 4.53 .159*

Experimental Group

Anterior T1 - T2 3.72 1.08 0.48 0.15 7.36 6.72 .002*

Posterior T1 - T2 12.28 3.69 1.12 2.61 18.26 7.88 .001*

*p<0.05

Table 9. The difference of mean values between two measures (T1-T2) for the control and

experimental group measured from the Anterior & Posterior Plan.

Page 27: DOCTORAL THESIS SUMMARY - USTfshl.ust.edu.al/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/quka.pdfcorrect poor posture in children during Physical Education Class, but unfortunately, it is still unclear

Postural deviation and postural improvements in children aged 10-13 years

Najada Quka (Shore) 23

Table 10. The difference of mean values between two measures (T1-T2) for the control and

experimental group measured from the Lateral Plan.

Table 11. The difference of mean values between two measures (T1-T2) for the control and

experimental group measured from the Lateral Plan.

In Table 9, 10 and 11 it is noticed that the difference of mean values between two measures (T1-

T2) did not result significantly for p<0.05 for the control group, while for the experimental group

this difference seems to be significant in the Anterior, Posterior and Lateral Plan.

Paired Simple Test Screen Mobile Kyphoses Lateral View

Lateral Plan

Paired

Differences t

Sig.(2-

tailed)

Mean Std.

St.

Error 95%

Control Group Deviation Mean Lower Upper

Shoulder shift T1 - T2 4.77 0.85 0.079 -3.22 13.39 4.12 .108*

Experimental Group

Shoulder shift T1 - T2 3.47 0.72 0.046 -2.66 10.58 8.80 .001*

*p<0.05

Paired Simple Test Screen Mobile Lordosis Lateral View

Lateral Plan

Paired

Differences t

Sig.(2-

tailed)

Mean Std.

St.

Error 95%

Control Group Deviation Mean Lower Upper

Hip back T1 - T2 3.81 0.87 0.068 -14.49 4.61 3.63 .254*

Experimental Group

Hip back T1 - T2 3.58 0.84 0.061 -14.31 3.56 5.13 .002*

*p<0.05

Page 28: DOCTORAL THESIS SUMMARY - USTfshl.ust.edu.al/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/quka.pdfcorrect poor posture in children during Physical Education Class, but unfortunately, it is still unclear

Postural deviation and postural improvements in children aged 10-13 years

Najada Quka (Shore) 24

Multifunctional Linear Regression

Subjects

(n=67) P Coefficient

Age 10

1Leg Test / Posture <0.01 0.487

Romberg Test/ posture <0.05 0.218

Age 11

1Leg Test / Posture <0.01 0.469

Romberg Test/ posture <0.05 0.216

Table 12. Multifunctional correlation between 1 Leg and Romberg test with Posture in total

(Anterior/Posterior/Lateral).

Multifunctional Linear Regression

Subjects

(n=67) P

Coefficient

Age 10

SemiTan Test / Posture <0.01 0.288

Tan Test / Posture <0.01 0.487

Age 11

SemiTan Test / Posture <0.01 0.282

Tan Test / Posture <0.01 0.459

Table 13. Multifunctional correlation between SemiTan and Tan test with Posture in total

(Anterior/Posterior/Lateral).

The results obtained in Table 12 and 13 show that the relationship between Balance (1 Leg,

Romberg, SemiTandem, Tandem) and Posture in total (anterior/posterior/lateral) is significant for

p <0.05.

Page 29: DOCTORAL THESIS SUMMARY - USTfshl.ust.edu.al/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/quka.pdfcorrect poor posture in children during Physical Education Class, but unfortunately, it is still unclear

Postural deviation and postural improvements in children aged 10-13 years

Najada Quka (Shore) 25

CHAPTER IV:

DISCUSSION

The reason why our study is focused on children aged 10-13 years to investigate postural

deviations and their correction through physical exercises is because of the fact that children

posture can easily be influenced and modified by different factors causing a postural displacement.

(Kratenova et al., 2007) This decision was also influenced by the fact that postural deviations can

easily be corrected through exercises specifically when the diagnosis and its correction is

performed before that the growth process is completed. (Brianezi et al., 2011; Latalski et al., 2013;

Gordeiro, 2014; Cosma et al, 2015)

Our results showed that only 7.8% of children had normal posture which means that postural

deviations achieved a concerning widespread among children aged 10-13 years. It was also noted

that 74.7% of them were affected by at least one postural deviation, 16.2% resulted to be affected

by 2 postural deviations, and only 1.3% of them manifested three postural deviations. This

alarming prevalence is detected also in the study of Balamurugan who states that the prevalence of

postural deviations which has increased recently unfortunately achieved an epidemic value.

(Balamurugan, 2014)

From the results of our study was also observed that the most common postural deviation in

children is scoliosis which was detected in 11.03% from the anterior plan and 90.25% in the

posterior plan, while lordosis and kyphoses were detected respectively at 6.49% and 3.57% of

children.

These results run alongside the contemporary studies which emphasized that scoliosis is the most

common postural deviation. (Bueno & Rech, 2013; Kratenova et al., 2007) The contrary is

declared from Sedrez who indicates that kyphoses are the postural deviation that mostly occurs

among children; while Stroebel and Rulon & Gale detected that the postural deviation that children

had been mostly affected is lordosis. (Sedrez et al., 2015; Stroebel, 2002; Rulon & Gale, 1987)

For our study, it is important to emphasize that the diversity of results that are recorded regarding

the prevalence of postural deviations in children, compared with the reference authors, is logical as

long as various diagnostic methods are performed. (Bueno & Rech 2013, Purenovic, 2007)

Page 30: DOCTORAL THESIS SUMMARY - USTfshl.ust.edu.al/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/quka.pdfcorrect poor posture in children during Physical Education Class, but unfortunately, it is still unclear

Postural deviation and postural improvements in children aged 10-13 years

Najada Quka (Shore) 26

According to gender, our results showed that boys (12.7%) are more affected by scoliosis than

girls (9.3%) but this evidence is different from the results of the international studies. Kane & Moe

and Willner & Eden declare that girls are more affected by scoliosis while Karachalios had

detected that girls and boys are equally affected by scoliosis. (Kane & Moe, 1970; Willner-Uden,

1982; Karachalios et al, 1999)

While the results obtained from posterior plan has presented a higher level of scoliosis where

90.25% of the children (n = 278) were diagnosed with scoliosis, by whom 53.89% (n = 166) were

identified with light scoliosis (10- 20 degrees) and 36.36% (n = 112) with average scoliosis (20-40

degrees). Regarding the prevalence of scoliosis (light and average) according to age, the results

showed that children aged 12 years (94.2%) are more affected by this postural deviation. Unlikely

to anterior plan, the results of posterior plan indicated that girls (92%) are more affected by

scoliosis (light and average) than boys (88.5%). This our evidence goes alongside to international

literature selected as the referee in our study. (Kane & Moe, 1970; Willner-Uden, 1982)

Furthermore, our results show that kyphoses (3.57%) has also affected children aged 10-13 years

and to be more precise from 308 subjects only 11 of them were detected with kyphoses. Referring

to international studies, the prevalence of kyphoses is differently presented such as Bueno & Rech

who declare 16.6 % of subjects with kyphoses, while Sedrez in 50.8% of subjects, Protic-Gava in

32.8 % of subjects, Kratenova in 31% of subjects and Stroebel in 57% of subjects. (Bueno &

Rech, 2013., Sedrez et al., 2015; Protic-Gava et al., 2011; Kratenova et al., 2007; Stroebel, 2002)

Regarding the prevalence of kyphoses according to gender results show that boys (5.7%) are more

affected by this deviation than girls (1.3%). The same evidence is seen in the study of Bueno and

Rech who reported exactly that girls are less predisposed to be affected by kyphoses compare to

boys. (Bueno & Rech, 2013)

Lordosis is another postural deviation that affected children aged 10-13 years which is detected in

6.49 % of subjects. If we refer to international studies lordosis were detected in 27.9% by Bueno

& Rech, in 32.2% by Sedrez, in 58.2% from Protic-Gava, in 32% from Kratenova and in 70% by

Stroebel. (Bueno & Rech, 2013; Sedrez et al., 2015; Protic-Gava et al., 2011; Kratenova et al.,

2007; Stroebel, 2002) Regarding the prevalence of lordosis according to gender, the results of our

study indicate that girls (7.3%) are more affected by lordosis than boys (5.7%).

Page 31: DOCTORAL THESIS SUMMARY - USTfshl.ust.edu.al/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/quka.pdfcorrect poor posture in children during Physical Education Class, but unfortunately, it is still unclear

Postural deviation and postural improvements in children aged 10-13 years

Najada Quka (Shore) 27

Our intervention program that took place in children aged 10-11 years during Physical Education

Class was conducted by isometric and stretching exercises combined also with the variety of

games that educate good posture behaviors. Through these exercises, we aimed to “strengthening

and stretching” postural muscles influencing on restoring muscle balance which is in accordance

with what international literature declare. Grissaffi was one of them who emphasized that

strengthening postural muscles can influence to have a good posture and to successfully cope with

everyday life activity but also this may reduce the possibilities to be injured. (Grissaffi, 2007)

From the results of Paired Sample Test, it is shown that the angle of postural displacement in

total and the angle of averaged lateral shoulders or hip-pelvis displacement have changed in both

groups (control and experimental group) but it resulted in being significant only for the

experimental group. (p <0.05) These results clearly show that our intervention program has

significant influence in correcting postural deviations because our results detected this

significant impact on four postural parameters that we analyzed. These results go alongside the

literature which stated that physical exercises are important for postural deviations correction.

(Cordeiro et al., 2014; Deutschmann et al., 2014; Misra et al., 2012; Annamaria et al., 2014; Oliver

et al., 2010; Byun et al., 2014; Cosma et al., 2015)

Multifunctional Linear Regression was used to identify the correlation between 8 variants of

Balance Test performing (EQ -Equilibrium variable) and Posture in total (Anterior/Posterior and

Lateral). By using this statistical analyze we realized that every change in postural parameters (in

total) were evidently reflected on balance ability. The results showed that these correlations are

significant at p<0.05 and respectively p<0.01 between Posture Test-1 Leg, SemiTandem and

Tandem Tests and p <0.05 between Posture – Romberg Test.

These results are in accordance with foreign evidence such as Cordeiro’s who clearly emphasized

the importance of postural correction exercises to improve not only postural behaviors but also

balance. His results show that these exercises improved the plantar surface support of children and

the distribution of gravity force within the supportive surface. (Cordeiro et al., 2014)

Page 32: DOCTORAL THESIS SUMMARY - USTfshl.ust.edu.al/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/quka.pdfcorrect poor posture in children during Physical Education Class, but unfortunately, it is still unclear

Postural deviation and postural improvements in children aged 10-13 years

Najada Quka (Shore) 28

CHAPTER V:

CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS

Regarding the prevalence of postural deviations among children age 10-13 years that was also our

first hypothesis (H1) which is confirmed, we concluded that:

Postural deviations such as scoliosis, lordosis and kyphoses are identified among

children aged 10-13 years detecting that only 7.8% of them showed normal posture.

Scoliosis is the most prevalent postural deviation detected among children which are

diagnosed at 11.03% from the anterior plan and 90.25% from the posterior plan.

Lordosis is diagnosed at 6.49% of them.

Kyphosis is diagnosed at 3.57% of them.

The prevalence of Scoliosis measured from Anterior Plan.

11.03% of children are diagnosed with Scoliosis.

Boys (12.7%) are more affected by scoliosis than girls (9.3%).

The prevalence of Scoliosis measured from Posterior Plan.

90.25% of children aged 10-13 years are diagnosed with Scoliosis.

53.89% are diagnosed with light scoliosis and 36.36% with average scoliosis.

Girls (92%) are more affected by scoliosis than boys (88.5%).

The prevalence of Kyphoses.

3.57% of children are diagnosed with Kyphoses.

Boys (5.7%) are more affected by kyphoses than girls (1.3%).

The prevalence of Lordosis.

6.49 % of children aged 10-13 years are diagnosed with Lordosis.

Girls (7.3 %) are more affected by lordosis than boys (5.7 %).

Page 33: DOCTORAL THESIS SUMMARY - USTfshl.ust.edu.al/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/quka.pdfcorrect poor posture in children during Physical Education Class, but unfortunately, it is still unclear

Postural deviation and postural improvements in children aged 10-13 years

Najada Quka (Shore) 29

Regarding the impact of the intervention program in correcting postural deviations among

children that were also our second hypothesis (H2) which is confirmed, we concluded that:

Our intervention program is effective in improving the angle of postural displacement (in

total) in Anterior/Posterior plan (scoliosis) and the angle of averaged lateral "shoulder"

and "hip-pelvis" displacement (left & right) in the Lateral plan (kyphoses & lordosis).

Paired Sample T-Test results show that for the experimental group the difference of mean

values between two measures (T1-T2) is significant for p<0.05 in both Anterior/Posterior

and Lateral plan.

In conclusion, we can say that our intervention program is effective in correcting postural

deviations because of its significant impact on all postural parameters that we analyzed.

While regarding the analysis of Multifunctional Linear Regression between Posture in total and

Balance, we concluded that:

Changes occurred in posture parameters are reflected in a significant value on the ability

to maintain balance and particularly in EQ-Equilibrium variable.

Page 34: DOCTORAL THESIS SUMMARY - USTfshl.ust.edu.al/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/quka.pdfcorrect poor posture in children during Physical Education Class, but unfortunately, it is still unclear

Postural deviation and postural improvements in children aged 10-13 years

Najada Quka (Shore) 30

Based on these conclusions we recommend as follows:

Parents should be aware of postural development of their children and for this, we

recommend periodical examination by specialist, especially during puberty when because

of morphological and functional changes, but not only (external and internal factors), bad

postural behaviors can be produced;

Physical Education Teachers are recommended to pay more attention to good postural

education in school children because physical exercises can be more effective in correcting

postural deviations if postural problems are identified at the time;

We recommend that strengthening and stretching exercises are very important to become

part of Physical Education Program because this kind of exercises can improve postural

behaviors and balance ability too;

Further studies are necessary to be handled about postural deviations among children. So

we recommend that even why investigating intervention programs is one of many research

issues to be highlighting the preventive methods should be our focus;

Postural development since it is a multifactorial phenomenon requires the commitment of

many actors such as parents, teachers, children, who can influence the progress of their

negative impact. But this can be successfully achieved if they are aware of posture in

general and postural deviations in particular.

Page 35: DOCTORAL THESIS SUMMARY - USTfshl.ust.edu.al/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/quka.pdfcorrect poor posture in children during Physical Education Class, but unfortunately, it is still unclear

Postural deviation and postural improvements in children aged 10-13 years

Najada Quka (Shore) 31

BIBLIOGRAPHY:

1. Arnhetm D.D., Prentice W.E. (2000). Principles of athletic training; 10th

edition. Singapore:

McGraw-Hill. Pg. 868.

2. Annamaria S., Tóth J., Makszin I., Gardi Zs., Feszthammer A., Darabosné T.I., Steinhausz

V.T., Szabó K. T., Varga P. (2003). Primary prevention program of the Hungarian Spine

Society II – Controlled prospective study of short-term efficacy. Clinic Neuroscience. 58/5-

6/:177-182.

3. Annamaria S., Lazáry Á., Feszthammer A., Darabosné I.T., Steinhausz V.T., Boja S.,

Szilágyi Á., Varga P. (2014). Application of special exercises in physical education to

develop, automatize and maintain the biomechanically correct posture. Clinic

Neuroscience. 92:11-19.

4. Auxter D., Pyfer J., Huettig C., Pfyer J. (1996). Book of McGraw-Hill, 8 th

Edition,

Principles and methods of adapted physical education and recreation. Pg.517-67.

5. Brox J.I. (2003). Spine. (In Kjaer M., Krogsgaard M., Magnusson P., Engebretsen L., Roos

H., Takala T., Woo S.L.Y. eds. 2004: Textbook of sports medicine: basic science and

clinical aspects of sports injury).

6. Bueno R. C., Rech R.R. (2013). Postural deviations of students in Southern Brazil.Rev Paul

Pediatric. 31(2):237-42.

7. Byun S., Changkyoo A., Minho K., Han D.(2014). The Effects of an Exercise Program

Consisting of Taekwondo Basic Movements on Posture Correction.J. Phys. Ther. Sci.26:

1585–1588.

8. Badaro A.F.V., Nichele L.F.I and Turra P. (2015). Student body posture in Brazilian

studies. Fisioter Pesq. 22(2); 197-204.

9. Bloomfield J., Ackland T.R., Elliott B.C. (1994). Applied anatomy and biomechanics in

sport. Melbourne: Blackwell Scientific Publications. Pg.374.

10. Balamurugan J. (2014). School bags and musculoskeletal pain among elementary school

children in Chennai City. International journal of medical science and clinical Invention.

Vol. 1, issue 6, Pg. 302-309.

11. Banfield M.A. (2000). The posture theory: some additional considerations. 11th

ed.

Modbury, Australia: Pg.1004.

12. Brianezi L., Cajazeiro D.C., Maifrino L.B.M. (2011). Prevalence of postural deviations in

the school of education and professional practice of physical education. Journal of

Morphol.Sci.Vol.28, No.1, Pg.35-36.

13. Bomba T.O., Haff G.G. (2009). Human Kinetics.5 th

edition. Periodization. Theory and

Methodology of training. ISBN 13: 9780736074834. Pg. 269.

14. Chan G., Chen C.H. (2009). Musculoskeletal effects of obesity. Current Opinion in

Pediatrics.Vol. 21, Pg. 65–70.

15. Cordeiro T.L., Duarte A., Collucci A., Frade M. (2014). Baropodometer as a Clinical Tool

for Evaluating and Following Treatment of Postural Deviations - A Case Report. J Spine.

3: 175.

16. Cosma G., Ilinca I., Rusu L., Nanu C., Burileanu A. (2015). Physical exercise and its role

in a corecct postural alignment. Physical Education, Sport and Kinetotherapy Journal. Vol.

9 No. 1. Pg. 39.

Page 36: DOCTORAL THESIS SUMMARY - USTfshl.ust.edu.al/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/quka.pdfcorrect poor posture in children during Physical Education Class, but unfortunately, it is still unclear

Postural deviation and postural improvements in children aged 10-13 years

Najada Quka (Shore) 32

17. Dickson R.A. (2004). Spinal deformity - basic principles. Current Orthopaedics.18:411-

425.

18. Deutschmann M., Parfant H., Holzer M., Ebner G., Ivanic M., Svehlik A., Weiglein.

(2014). New media supported child-oriented Pilates as the intervention to stabilize posture

and to correct postural defects on pupils aged 10–12. Proceedings of Measuring

Behavior.www.measuringbehavior.org

19. Elisabeth A.G., Ferreira M.D., Edison P.M., Thomaz N.B., Amelia P.M. (2010). Postural

Assessment Software (PAS/SAPO): Validation and reliability. Journal List Clinics.

Vol.65/7. Pg. 675- 681. 2010.

20. Feldenkrais M. (1985). The Potent Self. A guide to spontaneity. London: Harper & Row

Publishers. Pg. 240.

21. Grissaffi D. (2007). Posture and core conditioning. BOOK. Pg. 1-42.

22. Gluckman M.S. (1995). "DPDC, Muscle Balance and Functional Development". Muscle

Balance and Functional Development Article. http://www.dpdc-mbl.com/MBDFAi-tl.htm

23. Hrysomallis C., Goodman C. (2001). A review of resistance exercise and posture

realignment. Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research. Nr.15 (3), Pg. 385-390.

24. Hong Y., Cheung, C. (2003). Gait and posture responses to backpack load during level

walking in children.Gait& Posture. Vol. 17, Pg. 28–33.

25. Hershkovich O., Friedlander A., Gordon B., Arzi H., Derazne E., Tzur D., Shamiss A.,

Afek A. (2013). Association between body mass index, body height, and the prevalence of

spinal deformities.Spine J.doi: 10.1016/j.

26. Kendall F.P., Mccreary E.K., Provance P.G., Rodgers M.M., Romani W.A. (2005).

Muscles testing and function, with posture and pain. 5th Edition. Baltimore: Williams

&Wilkins. Pg.480.

27. Karachalios T., Sofianos J., Roidis N., Sapkas G., Korres D., Nikolopoulos K. (1999). Ten-

year follow-up evaluation of a school-screening program for scoliosis: is the forward-

bending test and accurate diagnostic criterion for the screening of scoliosis? Spine.

24(22):2318-2324.

28. Krugh R.C., Keysor J.J. (1996). Skeletal malalignments of the lower quarter: correlated and

compensatory motions and postures. Journal of Orthopaedic and Sports Physical Therapy,

23(2): 164-170.

29. Kane W.J., Moe J.H. (1970): A scoliosis prevalence survey in Minnesota. Clinical

Orthopaedics.69(1):216-218

30. Kratěnová J., Žejglicová K., Malý M., Filipová V. (2007). Prevalence and Risk Factors of

Poor Posture in School Children in the Czech Republic. Journal of School Health Volume

77, Issue 3, Pg 131–137.

31. Kussuki M.O.M., João S.M.A., Cunha A.C.P. (2007). Postural characterization of obese

children spine between 7 and 10 years old. Fisioterapia em Movimento, Curitiba, V. 20,

No. 1, Pg. 77-84.

32. Lafond D., Descarreaux M., Normand M.C., Harrison D.E. (2007). Postural development

in school children: a cross-sectional study. Chiropractic & Osteopathy, 15:1 doi:

10.1186/1746-1340-15-1.

33. Loveless M.D. (1999). Pediatric spinal deformity. Jacksonville Medicine, 6:227-229.

34. Loots M. (1999). A multi-variate approach to posture. University of Pretoria. (Thesis -

PhD.) 348 p.

Page 37: DOCTORAL THESIS SUMMARY - USTfshl.ust.edu.al/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/quka.pdfcorrect poor posture in children during Physical Education Class, but unfortunately, it is still unclear

Postural deviation and postural improvements in children aged 10-13 years

Najada Quka (Shore) 33

35. Latalski M., Bylina J., Fatyga M., Repko M., Filipovic M., Jarosz M.J., Borowicz K.B.,

Matuszewski L., Trzpis T. (2013). Risk factors of postural defects in children at school

age. Annals of Agricultural and Environmental Medicine. Vol. 20, No 3, Pg. 583–587.

36. Loots M., Loots J.M., Steyn B.J.M. (2001). An investigation into essential aspects of

posture in primary school boys and male senior executives. South African Journal for

Research in Sport, Physical Education and Recreation. 23 (l):37-49.

37. Magee D.J. (2002). Orthopedic physical assessment. 4th edition. Philadelphia: Saunders.

1020 P-

38. Minoo D., Nasser B., Mahmood Sh. (2013). Prevalence and causes of postural deformities

in the upper and lower extremities among 9-18 years old school female in Golestan

province. European Journal of Experimental Biology. Vol. 3, No. 6, Pg. 115-121.

39. Motow-Czyż M., Orczyk A., Marek Orczyk. (201)4. Postural defects correction in the

process of physical education and sport. Physical Activity Review. Vol. 2. Pg.31-36

40. Milardović M., Paušić J., Kuzmanić B. (2014). Differences in body posture and balance in

children of Classroom teaching attending and not attending extended stay. Research in

Physical Education, Sport and Health. Vol. 3, No. 2, Pg. 135-140

41. Misra A., Nigam M., Alagesan J. (2012). Effect of exercises in cervical postural deviation

due to backpack in school children.International journal of current Research. Vol. 4, Issue.

08, Pg. 146-149.

42. Niekerk V.S.M., Louw Q., Vaughan C., Grimmer-Somers K., Schreve K. (2008).

Photographic measurement of upper-body sitting posture of high school students: a

reliability and validity study. BMC Musculoskelet. Vol. 9; Pg.113.

43. Markola L., Bardhyl M., Markola B., Quka N. (2016). Libër. Edukim Lëvizor.

44. Norris C.M. (2000). Back stability. Champaign, 111. Human Kinetics. Pg. 272.

45. NingthoujamR. (2014). Postural deformities in lower extremities among school children.

International Journal of Physical Education, Health & Sports Sciences. Vol. 3, issue. 01.

46. Oliver G.D., Heather R., Blair A., Christopher P., Dougherty D.O. (2010). Implementation

of a Core Stability Program for Elementary School Children. Sports Health Care. Vol. 2

No. 6

47. Protic-Gava B., Scepanovic T., Jevtic N., Kadovic. (2011). The frequency of postural

Disorders in sagittal Plane of younger-aged school children. APES. 2:151-156. UDC:

796:616.711-007.5-084.

48. Purenović T. (2007). Review of national and international research Studies in postural

deformities: The period from 2000 to 2007. Physical education and sport. Vol. 5, No 2, Pg.

139 – 152.

49. Penha P.J., Joao S.M.A., Casarotto R.A., Amino C.J., Penteado D.C. (2005). Postural

assessment of girls between 7 and 10 years of age. Clinics, 60(1):9-16.

50. Quka N., Kaçurri A. (2016). A Cross-sectional study on postural deviations among

Albanian children aged 10–13 years old. 10th

European Conference on Education and

Applied Psychology. Section 11. Physical Education. Proceedings .Vienna. Pg: 92-99.

51. Quka N. (2015). Intervention programs used regarding postural deviations among

children.European Journal of education and applied psychology. Scientific journal.

“Section 7. Physical education.” Austria, Vienna. Volume. 4. pg: 48-51

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC382503/pdf/canmedaj00106-0057.pdf

52. Rulon S., Francis A., Bryce G.R. (1987). Musculoskeletal deviation. Phys Ther. 67:1221-

1225.

Page 38: DOCTORAL THESIS SUMMARY - USTfshl.ust.edu.al/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/quka.pdfcorrect poor posture in children during Physical Education Class, but unfortunately, it is still unclear

Postural deviation and postural improvements in children aged 10-13 years

Najada Quka (Shore) 34

53. Rosell A. A., Fregonesi C. E. T. P., Camargo M. R., Mantovani A. M., Purga M. O., Freitas

I. F., Ferreira D. M. A., and Faria C. R. F. (2010). Prepubescents and pubescents

overweight postural characterization. Brazilian Journal of Biomotricity. Vol. 4, No. 2, Pg.

104-114.

54. Stroebel S. (2002). The prevalence of postural deformities among children age 11 to 13

years in some Western Cape Schools. Stellenbosch: University of Stellenbosch.

(Dissertation - PhD.) 130 p.

55. Saunders H.D., Saunders R., Kraus S.L., Woerman A. (1995). Evaluation, treatment and

prevention of musculoskeletal disorders. 3rd ed. Chaska: Saunders Group. 396 p.

56. Silva L.R., Rodacki A.L.F., Brandalize M., Lopes M.F.A., Bento P.C.B., Leite N. (2011).

Postural changes in obese and non-obese children and adolescents. DOI: 10.5007/1980-

0037.

57. Sallis J.F. (2000). Overcoming inactivity in young people. Physician and Sports

Medicine.28 (10):31-32.

58. Strieker L., Brjggs A., GreigA. (2002). The effect of individually adjusted workstations on

upper quadrant posture and muscle activity in school children. Work, 18:239-248.

59. Sedrez J.A., Zaniratti M.I.R., Noll M., Medeiros F.S., Candotti C.T. (2015). Risk factors

associated with structural postural changes in the spinal column of children and

adolescents. Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Sul (UFRGS), Porto Alegre, RS,

Brazil. Rev Paul Pediatr.Vol. 33(1): pg. 72–81

60. Tremblay M.S., Willms J.D. (2000). Secular trends in the body mass index of Canadian

children. Canadian Medical Association Journal. 163(11):1429-1433.

61. Willner S., Uden A. (1982). A Prospective prevalence study of scoliosis in Southern

Sweden. Acta Orthopaedica Scandinavica.53:233-237.

62. Wiggins R.M.D.C.M., Victoria B.C. (1931). Posture in children. The Canadian Medical

Association Journal. Pg. 820-825.