Doc.: IEEE 802.15-99/179r1 Submission November 1999 Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.Slide 1 IEEE P802.15...

November 1999

Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.Slide 1

doc.: IEEE 802.15-99/179r1

Submission

IEEE P802.15 Working Group for Wireless Personal Area Networks

Tutorial Overview & LB1 Results

Bluetooth™ Specification v1.0B, a Basis For Standards-Making

10Jan00 to 14Jan00

David Inter-Continental Hotel Tel-Aviv, Israel

November 1999


doc.: IEEE 802.15-99/179r1

Submission

Tutorial Agenda

• Overview of the P802.15.1 v0.6 Draft Standard - Gifford -99/179r0 – Summary of LB1 Results & Sponsor

Balloting Pool Status - Gifford -99/179r0– P802.15.1/D0.6 vs. Bluetooth v1.0 B

Differences - Siep -99/180r0

• Questions & Answers - Siep/Gifford• Closing Remarks - Gifford

November 1999


doc.: IEEE 802.15-99/179r1

Submission

Tutorial Objectives

• The IEEE Working Group for Wireless Personal Area Networks initiated their first Working Group Electronic Letter Ballot during the IEEE 802 November 1999 Plenary. This Conference Tutorial has been prepared to assist the Working Group as well as the potential WPAN Sponsor Ballot Pool attendees on the LB1 Results as well as provide a Summary of the P802.15.1/D0.6 vs. Bluetooth v1.0 B Differences, the source of the technology. Additionally, we will describe how the IEEE P802.15 WPAN technology complements the 802 Family.

• Due to the fast track nature of this standards-making process the January Conference Tutorial will provide the necessary baseline for the up and coming Working Group recirculation LB and Sponsor Ballot voting.

November 1999


doc.: IEEE 802.15-99/179r1

Submission

Takeaway or Careabouts

• LB1 yielded 1013 comments to be resolved against P802.15.1/D0.6– 193 Technical Comments and– 818 Editorial Comments

• LB1 Comment Resolution 10-14Jan00• P802.15.1/D1.0 Recirculation LB on or

before 25Feb00• Draft ready for Sponsor Ballot Mar00

November 1999


doc.: IEEE 802.15-99/179r1

Submission

Bluetooth/IEEE Proposed Timeline

Jul 1999 - Initial Discussion on Proposal submissions Jul 1999 - IEEE initial vote of support to draft 802.15

based on Bluetooth specification Sep 1999 - Overview the draft 802.15.1 based on the

current Bluetooth specification to the time line Nov 1999 - Initial draft ready for WG ballot. Jan 2000 - First Ballot complete, second ballot kicked

off.• Mar 2000 - Draft ready for IEEE sponsor ballot.• Jul 2000• Nov 2000• Dec 2000 - Approval by IEEE Standards Board

November 1999


doc.: IEEE 802.15-99/179r1

Submission

Overview of Key IEEE802 Dates

• Mar 1999 – Project 802.15 Working Group for Wireless Personal Area

Networks (WPAN) was formed

• Jul 1999– P802.15 Task Group 1 was formed

• Nov 1999 Kaua'i, HI– Draft Standard submitted to WG from TG1

• Mar 2000 Albuquerque, NM– Draft ready for Sponsor Ballot or

• Jul 2000 LaJolla, CA– Draft ready for Sponsor Ballot

November 1999


doc.: IEEE 802.15-99/179r1

Submission

How To Get A Copy Of Tutorial Slides

• Softcopy– http://grouper.ieee.org/groups/802/15/pub/

Tutorials.htm– http://grouper.ieee.org/groups/802/15/pub/

2000/Jan00/– Obtain P802.15 Flash Card(s), or look in the

Tuesday P802.15 Server SubDir

• Hardcopy– See Ian Gifford, IEEE P802.15 Meeting

November 1999


doc.: IEEE 802.15-99/179r1

Submission

Tutorial Speakers

• Ian Gifford - IEEE 802.15.1 Chair– [email protected]– Tel: +1 978 442 4650

• Tom Siep - IEEE 802.15.1 TechEditor– [email protected]– Tel: +1 214 480 6786

November 1999


doc.: IEEE 802.15-99/179r1

Submission


TG1 LB1 Report

David Intercontinental Hotel 12, Kaufman St. Tel Aviv Israel

November 1999


doc.: IEEE 802.15-99/179r1

Submission

Contents

• LB1 Summary

• TG1 Ballot Roadmap

• LB1 Background/Flowchart

• LB1 Results– Balloting– Commenting

• Next Steps

November 1999


doc.: IEEE 802.15-99/179r1

Submission

LB1 Summary

• Letter Ballot 1 MOTION: To submit the contents of document IEEE P802-15/D0.6 to Sponsor Ballot [default recirculation ballot].

• Letter Ballot 1 RESULT: Motion failed with 18/15/2 or 43% (P802-15/D0.6)

• Our plan is resolve the LB1 Comments and start a 10 Day recirculation LB of P802-15/D1.0 on 25Feb00 or sooner

November 1999


doc.: IEEE 802.15-99/179r1

Submission

TG1 Ballot Roadmap

1999 20009/99

Today

11/998/99 12/99

WG Balloting

2/00 3/00 4/00 5/00 6/00 7/00 8/00 9/00 10/00 11/00 12/00...10/99

SponsorBalloting

HICA IL NM WA CA TN FLMeetings/Events

WG LetterBallot

#1

WG LetterBallot

#2Sponsor Says IEEE ETSI?

SponsorBallot

#1

SponsorBallot

#2

WGLB#1

TG 1 PlanWGLB#2

WGLB #3Option

TG 1 ActualWGLB#1

WGLB#2

SponsorLB#1

SponsorLB#1

SponsorLB#1

November 1999


doc.: IEEE 802.15-99/179r1

Submission

TG1 Draft Standard Flowchart

S oftw are W ork in g G rou p A ir In te rface W ork in g G rou p

n W ork in g G rou p s

W G C h a irm an

IE E E E d ito ria l W ork in g G rou p

P rog ram M an ag em en t(P M )

B lu e too thS p ec ia l In te res t G rou p

A d viso ry C ore

C oexis ten ce S tu d y G rou p (S G )

H ig h R ate S tu d y G rou p (H R S G )

S tu d y G rou p s

M an ag m en t E n tityL L C S u b layerM A C S u b layerP H Y L ayer

S u b Task G rou p s

Task G rou p 1 (TG 1 )

Task G rou p s

M arke tin g C om m ittee (M C )

C om m ittees

P 8 0 2 .1 5 W G

W G C h a ir

S p on sorIE E E 8 0 2

WG TG1 Timeline Submission -99/148r0 is a MS Project (*.MPP) file thatdescribes, in detail, the WG TG1 Draft Standard Flowchart over time. The

following slides are an abstract of this timeline before and after LB1 extension.

Bluetooth v1.0 A

Bluetooth v1.0 B

November 1999


doc.: IEEE 802.15-99/179r1

Submission

Letter Ballot #1Comment DB

TG1 Draft Standard Flowchart - 1

Draft StandardSubmission

V0.6 (v1.0A)4Nov99


V0.64Nov99

23Dec99

Letter Ballot #1

Letter Ballot #1Comment DB 27Dec99

11Nov99

*Letter Ballot 1Ballot Results & Comment Prep.

{

27Dec99

Source: http://grouper.ieee.org/groups/802/15/pub/1999/Nov99/99148r0P802-15_WG-TG1-Timeline.mpp

*All comments are loaded into the database. Any Bluetooth comments are also loaded.


(v1.0B)1Dec99

November 1999


doc.: IEEE 802.15-99/179r1

Submission

TG1 Draft Standard Flowchart - 2 (cont.)

Letter Ballot #1Comment DB 27Dec9927Dec99

BluetoothSummary Report20Jan00

P802.15 Interim Meeting 10-13Jan00

27Jan00*A collection of all proposed changes to D0.6 and adescription of the Action Items to be completed by

specified individuals by a specified time.

*Technical IssuesSummary Report


updated to V1.0 17Feb00

Letter Ballot #1Comment DB

Source: http://grouper.ieee.org/groups/802/15/pub/1999/Nov99/99148r0P802-15_WG-TG1-Timeline.mpp

November 1999


doc.: IEEE 802.15-99/179r1

Submission

Working Group Balloting Pools

Membership• 42 Voting• 4 Nearly Voting• 11 Aspirant

LB1 closed at 11pm EST, Dec 23, 1999 after running for 43days originally the LB1 was to run 30 days (11Nov99-10Dec99).

42 Voting

30 Days

42 Voting4 Nearly Voting

11 Aspirant= 58 in LB1

43 Days

November 1999


doc.: IEEE 802.15-99/179r1

Submission

11Nov99 the P802.15 Working Group was comprised of 42 voting members:

1 Mr. Houman Alborzi voter2 Mr. Dimitri Alexandrou voter3 Mr. Simon Baatz (Simon) voter4 Mr. Edul Batliwala (Edul) voter5 Mr. Alan Bien (Alan) voter6 Dr. Chatschik Bisdikian voter7 Mr. Dave Carlson (Dave) voter8 Mr. Harshal Chhaya (Harshal) voter9 Mr. Wm. Caldwell Crosswy voter10 Mr. William Cruz (Bill) voter11 Mr. Richard Ditch (Rich) voter12 Mr. Richard Eckard (Dick) voter13 Mr. Kurt Fischer (Kurt) voter14 Mr. Matthias Frank (Matthias) voter15 Mr. Ian Gifford (Ian) voter16 Ms. Nada Golmie (Nada) voter17 Mr. Allen Heberling (Allen) voter18 Mr. Robert Heile (Bob) voter19 Mr. John Paul Jones (John) voter20 Dr. Srinivas Kandala voter21 Dr. Parviz Kermani (Parviz) voter22 Mr. Stuart Kerry (Stuart) voter

23 Mr. Patrick Kinney (Pat) voter24 Mr. Bruce P. Kraemer (Bruce) voter25 Dr. Yunxin Li (Yunxin) voter26 Mr. Daniel R. McGlynn voter27 Mr. Michael D. McInnis (Mike) voter28 Dr. Akira Miura (Akira) voter29 Dr.Thomas Müller (Thomas) voter30 Mr. Peter Murray (Peter) voter31 Mr. Erwin R. Noble (Erwin) voter32 Mr. Mike Paczonay (Mike) voter33 Mr. Arto Palin (Arto) voter34 Dr. Davis Pan (Davis) voter35 Mr. Ivan Reede (Ivan) voter36 Mr. Carlos A. Rios (Carlos) voter37 Mr. Brian E. Roan (Brian) voter38 Mr. Karlheinz Schwarz voter39 Dr. Stephen J. Shellhammer voter40 Mr. Thomas Siep (Tom) voter41 Mr. Nick Stapleton (Nick) voter42 Mr. Steve Torp (Steve) voter43 Dr. Fujio Watanabe (Fujio) voter

= Resignation prior to the LB #1 Start

November 1999


doc.: IEEE 802.15-99/179r1

Submission

11Nov99 the P802.15 Working Group was comprised of 16 non members:

Nearly Voter

43 Mr. David Cypher (Dave) Voter

44 Mr. Rajesh Jarang (Rajesh) Voter

45 Mr. Kevin Marquess (Kevin) Voter

46 Mr. Richard Wilson (Dick) Voter

Aspirant

47 Mr. Richard Alfvin (Rick) Voter

48 Mr. James Allen (Jim) Voter

49 Mr. Thomas Baker (Tom) Voter

50 Dr. Victor Bahl (Vic) Voter

51 Mr. William Bailey (Bill) Voter

52 Mr. Timothy J. Blaney (Tim) Voter

53 Mr. Todor Cooklev (Todor) Voter

54 Mr. Masaki Hoshina (Masaki) Voter

55 Mr. Gary McCoy (Gary) Voter

56 Mr. Anand R. Prasad (Anand) Voter

57 Mr. Matthew Sherman (Mat) Voter

58 Mr. Hirohisa Wakai (Hirohisa) Voter

November 1999


doc.: IEEE 802.15-99/179r1

Submission

LB1 Results - Overview

• 42 Total Voting Members

• 35 Total Votes (18/15/2)

• 7 Total Failed to vote (2 of 7 were incomplete No's)

VOTE CATEGORY NUMBER PERCENTAGEYea 18 43%Nea 15 36%Abstain 2 5%Failed to vote 7 17%Total 42 100%

November 1999


doc.: IEEE 802.15-99/179r1

Submission

LB1 Results - DetailNO LAST NAME STATUS LB1 VOTE

1 Bien Mr. Alan (Alan) voter a2 Pan Dr. Davis (Davis) voter a3 Baatz Mr. Simon (Simon) voter n4 Bisdikian Dr. Chatschik (Chatschik) voter n5 Eckard Mr. Richard (Dick) voter n6 Gifford Mr. Ian (Ian) voter n7 Golmie Ms. Nada (Nada) voter n8 Heberling Mr. Allen (Allen) voter n9 Heile Mr. Robert (Bob) voter n

10 Kinney Mr. Patrick (Pat) voter n11 Kraemer Mr. Bruce P. (Bruce) voter n12 McInnis Mr. Michael D. (Mike) voter n13 Mueller Mr. Thomas voter n14 Palin Mr. Arto (Arto) voter n15 Shellhammer Dr. Stephen J. (Steve) voter n16 Siep Mr. Thomas (Tom) voter n17 Watanabe Dr. Fujio (Fujio) voter n18 McGlynn Mr. Daniel R. voter n-w/o19 Reede Mr. Ivan (Ivan) voter n-w/o20 Alexandrou Mr. Dimitri (Dimitri) voter y21 Batliwala Mr. Edul voter y

22 Crosswy Mr. Wm. Caldwell (Caldwell) voter y23 Ditch Mr. Richard (Rich) voter y24 Fischer Mr. Kurt (Kurt) voter y25 Frank Mr. Matthias (Matthias) voter y26 Jones Mr. John Paul (John) voter y27 Kerry Mr. Stuart (Stuart) voter y28 Miura Dr. Akira (Akira) voter y29 Murray Mr. Peter voter y30 Noble Mr. Erwin R. (Erwin) voter y31 Rios Mr. Carlos A. (Carlos) voter y32 Schwarz Mr. Karlheinz (Karlheinz) voter y33 Torp Mr. Steve (Steve) voter y34 Alborzi Mr. Houman (Houman) voter y/c35 Li Dr. Yunxin (Yunxin) voter y/c36 Paczonay Mr. Mike (Mike) voter y/c37 Stapleton Mr. Nick (Nick) voter y/c38 Carlson Mr. Dave voter f39 Chhaya Mr. Harshal (Harshal) voter f40 Kandala Dr. Srinivas (Srinivas) voter f41 Kermani Dr. Parviz (Parviz) voter f42 Roan Mr. Brian E. (Brian) voter f

a = Abstainn = Do Not Approve (Negative)y = Approve (Affirmative)/c = with Comments w/o = with out Comments y = failed to respond

November 1999


doc.: IEEE 802.15-99/179r1

Submission

Type of comments (e/E/t/T) - LB1 #

TG1 appreciates the work the eighteen (18) Members didin providing these 1013 Comments! 2 not coded.

Minor Editorial Major Editorial Minor Technical Major TechnicalNO LAST NAME LB1 VOTE INITIAL "e" "E" "t" "T" TOTAL

1 Alborzi Mr. Houman (Houman) y/c hxa 39 7 15 1 622 Baatz Mr. Simon (Simon) n smb 0 0 2 5 73 Bisdikian Dr. Chatschik (Chatschik) n ccb 14 22 0 3 394 Eckard Mr. Richard (Dick) n rge 0 17 0 5 225 Gifford Mr. Ian (Ian) n icg 34 4 0 0 386 Golmie Ms. Nada (Nada) n NG 94 48 59 18 2197 Heberling Mr. Allen (Allen) n ADH 68 36 4 12 1208 Heile Mr. Robert (Bob) n rfh 0 1 0 0 19 Kinney Mr. Patrick (Pat) n pwk 0 12 0 7 19

10 Kraemer Mr. Bruce P. (Bruce) n bpk 0 0 0 1 111 Li Dr. Yunxin (Yunxin) y/c yxl 34 208 4 3 24912 McInnis Mr. Michael D. (Mike) n mdm 11 1 0 5 1713 Mueller Mr. Thomas n tm 0 5 8 15 2814 Paczonay Mr. Mike (Mike) y/c mjp 132 0 4 3 13915 Palin Mr. Arto (Arto) n atp 2 0 2 2 616 Shellhammer Dr. Stephen J. (Steve) n Sjs 0 1 0 6 717 Siep Mr. Thomas (Tom) n tms 0 0 0 7 718 Stapleton Mr. Nick (Nick) y/c nms 2 0 0 0 219 Watanabe Dr. Fujio (Fujio) n fxw 24 2 1 1 28

454 364 99 94 1011

November 1999


doc.: IEEE 802.15-99/179r1

Submission

Type of comments (e/E/t/T) - LB1 #/%

1011 Comments• Minor Editorial "e”

– 454 (45%)

• Major Editorial "E”– 364 (36%)

• Minor Technical "t”– 99 (10%)

• Major Technical "T”– 94 (9%)

45%

36%

10%

9%

Minor Editorial

Major Editorial

Minor Technical

Major Technical

454

364

99

94

Minor Editorial

Major Editorial

Minor Technical

Major Technical

November 1999


doc.: IEEE 802.15-99/179r1

Submission


Sponsor Balloting Pool Status

November 1999


doc.: IEEE 802.15-99/179r1

Submission

P802.11

Sponsor Balloting Pool as of 6Jan00

WG Membership• 42 Voting• 4 Nearly Voting• 11 Aspirant

LAN/MAN802.15

48?

P802.1658

1400+9

?

?

?

?

November 1999


doc.: IEEE 802.15-99/179r1

Submission

Sponsor Balloting Pool as of 6Jan00 (cont.)

No Last Name FirstName Company VOTER1 Alborzi Houman University of Maryland 12 Bisdikian Chatschik IBM Research 13 Crosswy William C Compaq Computer Corp. 14 Gifford Ian C M/A-COM, Inc. 15 Heberling Allen Eastman Kodak Co. 16 Heile Robert GTE 17 Kerry Stuart J OK-Brit 18 Kinney Patrick W Intermec Inc. 19 McInnis Michael D The Boeing Co. 110 Alspaugh Matthew D SpectraLink11 Andersson Daniel Celsius Test Systems AB12 Bell Ernest 3Com Corporation13 Belvin Stephen E Raytheon14 Boer Jan Lucent Technologies15 Carter James S IBM Corp16 Currivan Bruce J Broadcom17 Ecclesine Peter CISCO Systems18 Fischer Michael A Intersil Corp.19 Fischer Kurt B Hyper Corp.20 Freedman Avraham InnoWave-ECI Ltd.21 Gaucher Brian P IBM TJ Watson Research22 Gilb James P Motorola23 Godfrey Tim Choice Microsystems24 Hermann Reto J IBM Research25 Izadpanah Hossein HRL Laboratories

26 Kardach Jim Intel27 Khanna Amarpal S Agilent Technologies28 Kiernam Brian G InterDigital Comm Corp.29 Langston J Leland Raytheon30 Marks Roger B NIST31 Noble Erwin Telxon Corp.32 O'Hara Robert Informed Technology, Inc.33 Paine Richard H Boeing34 Pandanda Roger MCS Corp.35 Petry Brian D 3Com36 Ralston Margarete A Wytec Inc.37 Rautenberg Peter Alcatel Cabling Systems38 Rohner Christian IBM Research39 Roy Jaideep Bear Sterns & Co.40 Sanders Ray W CircuitPath41 Schott Wolfgang IBM Research Div.42 Sherman Matthew J AT&T43 Solomon David Fujitsu Network Communications44 Thomas Nicholas A 3Com Corp.45 Turner Edward 3COM46 Tzerefos Polychronis D University of Sheffield47 Valcourt Scott A University of New Hampshire48 Zhang Wei NIST

9

November 1999


doc.: IEEE 802.15-99/179r1

Submission

Next Steps

• More Request to join via e-mails?

• Contact?– 802 Secretary to advertise – P802.11, .16 Chairs to advertise– Liaison Mailing List

• New Link on .15 Web Site?

• Other?

Doc.: IEEE 802.15-99/179r1 Submission November 1999 Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.Slide 1 IEEE P802.15...

Documents

Transcript of Doc.: IEEE 802.15-99/179r1 Submission November 1999 Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.Slide 1 IEEE P802.15...