dJs'alliiMi - INTOSAI...^ J. - i^jS^i ajili i^liJi AJJJI Uifci Jp^li oVLaJVl ^^ Ifu OUl /j.CJVUJVi I...

34
dJs'alliiMi January 2009

Transcript of dJs'alliiMi - INTOSAI...^ J. - i^jS^i ajili i^liJi AJJJI Uifci Jp^li oVLaJVl ^^ Ifu OUl /j.CJVUJVi I...

Page 1: dJs'alliiMi - INTOSAI...^ J. - i^jS^i ajili i^liJi AJJJI Uifci Jp^li oVLaJVl ^^ Ifu OUl /j.CJVUJVi I i,s^^lji-lj l-W-i JIAAI a-> oUJl^lj frlfjUl ^ J-^ijJb ^jJ tij^Sl JIAAI iT^i 0(

dJs'alliiMi

January 2009

Page 2: dJs'alliiMi - INTOSAI...^ J. - i^jS^i ajili i^liJi AJJJI Uifci Jp^li oVLaJVl ^^ Ifu OUl /j.CJVUJVi I i,s^^lji-lj l-W-i JIAAI a-> oUJl^lj frlfjUl ^ J-^ijJb ^jJ tij^Sl JIAAI iT^i 0(

OUjs^l

\ jij«Jiur

0 t-i^Hi^y

A ^ ^ ^ 1 JJUj ^ OjUJl

^r t^ujj i^ j j ^ aiiU-n.i«Ji v*A-i

W aa!t.^jwVHW"l J p • I j ^ f

t . (^UjsJ^l Jas-la

Y ^ fc^L-jril a AJJ S j i l ^ OlSjO^

r \ Y . . ^ flP ( tSl-js))fl (i»la^t

j _ w j j r v j S ^ ' yn i i<UjU y j ^ i 11*1 j J j

J_rijJl, ( j tJ-^J«J.« (J-<jibjtl—!i> JJP

U U l ^ i ( igwVi j Jja'j i j V J j ^ ' j » i j ^ > i j

c - . / J i j .VUjdl" 1(11 J V.JI J j j i f^ IJjjJi

C f wil - ( Uja>^ V j l l UJ^I jiMl J l -U^l

*lj^l j ;_ t f j .U / jO-1 Itlijll U ^ ' j ^ ' ' ' y r !

j ( J O J - * * J - J J I i - ^ L ^ J ^ ,^1 j l ^V l j

j_k ) (lA_g<rj a j jyJv j ^ ^ j Ij,^ o - f u i

. UUW j( l«Ut

»gVlj J - * * ! jjjViJlj 0*IISH( Ojj j^l (T-«-ji J

jjjUi (,ji^ J! uuji cc-Hj <"*! Jl r^ Jl :, bli oijJi J *

US Govemment Accountability

omce. Room 7S14,441G Street ,

NW, Washington , O.C, 20548,

USA, ( Phone :202-512-4707;

Facsimile: 202-512-4021, Email :

intosaiioumal(%gao.gov).

J l i 'iliiLt 0^ ( W ' l ' 31 1 UJ^I ^IJAX^"^ i j luj

aUrf s—iij«. j^w J l (^ Uj^ juw-( j<ii

(,,.^lj^l sJ-^ JkJ j j ( Uil lUl l J p IjlijU

^ L ^ . jliid J l jl£t<jlj JAilrli «^'^^i =l ijA

£*iji J j ^ J r *^ i j( (lii»jii J># >i » J i ^ ^ 1 ^

J l (1 *1211 j M Hj i\i» i l t t j \ i UUl-l L K U ^

.lU't (j j J j ] l^\iA i i jU i^\jif UL<t JjUd

^ J itUJI tjkli i j j^Vi CP* ( > 11*1 £,jyj

i ah-a jL-opl 4 ii/i'^-i—l J i ' i ^ ( l t »t^l

.^j.Jj> u^l j i j j i j .(jJlSl l i l J * ^ L)j> ii^UjaJj

j l httpr/Zlntosai i ourna], org

i-J^k jumit j http://www.intosai.org

.spel^gao.gov : . ^

(^Jll C6.-Ubi ^ j j i J IL^I o - jU* U j j i ^ j ^ j

l_a r ( i tal j lLJl l Oi r - l»U j : ^ ^ ^ ! i j - l l flj!-t

jiaat j « (;>Uk;&* j . t j l j . i j b ^ l O l f j : ^ i j JT^JJJ

: l jb ] l o i j u l l i j S j tU i i u^U!.!

Anbar Management Services,

Wembley , England , and

University Microfilms

Intemational, Ann Arbor ,

Michigan, USA.

\ iOfJl ( f n J * l

: J O ^ ' V

I—Jl oV-l# !.£* ^r^j . JJLK Jtjyr

L u f i f U ^ l j l i i j jL - iy^

(^jJ .Ol».lAi oijfriJ JjS> j J l . i^lf Ij(U

i ^ V »j«ii -iVVji' ifUli v*ijl i v w ' jj'»jJ i:*^

( J ^ ' J I lA^ii CJVU jll) £1^ uM C&L»

<i.Si/^' >J^' -^ Wi> j^i^ Joy

: X J ^ ' t W j - ^ ^

( I A J * ^ ! >-i«il oWjl') £ t iL . v r UJ

(Ulf) f\(Jl y l j l l (r»^

(Jjl .,^U>j^l) J* J, JiV-

(}^jl - jL-li) jilSU itVi*!

(Wj i CJl-) U(1-JJIS:JI i»wi jjViSi

CUL-t) 4f lujjjVU t-iJ* iJi*Vi

O'oj*> >o>* 'J>w-i ij(Ji*

(U«ili> i^jii^U l4l*!i ^ l * ' ' !

(Z^ ' l l l Unlll Oli1|_ l) ( ^ V > ^jSi-l ll»\_ll U *

: ' j " y

:^fUjiiyJ j J ,U i J j ' i *Utfl

.fUli Jf i_;i, cijrijt (fJ J ' ^ j ^ jjjJji

ifUi JTIJI' ( H ^ <fi*li £ri>i i „ w j ) .rtJ^

^rJjJ j ' ( is-nJ' 'VA>'v>^

i;*\Ji y i j l i iiijij ^ j , * ^ > ( . l.u(

^ J uSi viuli .^(jjihJi 1^ J l JiUt

fUi ^t-^ij ii-*J* •:'Wtf laS^ t j ^ j . j j y ukoy;-

. ^ ( t i ^ ,>i.jn v<fli. r* i erijii. 4 l/r J.!

1,^1 iifrAii Vu**

iJjT JjA- Urijli v C .i«r'>i jU* . J - J P J ' ^1 jT Jj(

y>(j o i j f .CJV-\*I I - < * U-^J ' ( ^ . » I >IJO

j*> o u w i S * ^ j . j J ' i l j f Jio'

•Ul ifUll ^ I j l l j v>lj^l > i^ij J>^

lojf .o!.^'j iwijli J* < fX'i^ fi'j''

bUi iLoJji i^jjl) ifUH ^ijLi i.jju_li J-

Wli l*jJi VJJ*'-*-' ' (^1 Jiji:(ij l«-ijl' ^—fi

> i j lS j . ^ V > V l Jl+J-i y ^ j .11,,:^! jjr^sDj* *d i rol

j jU>> i^JjU > S i i \4* t . fUli ^ i j . \ 1 j ^ j f j r - j , ^ -

,ui\(LJ.l U£< ^ ^ j , , : ^ \ „ i - yti>j«.ili i y r > .

^ j j l J l^f l

.JM-IJ-JJ ^^jSl (^JSIV LIU-IJII J*X. .Ji j I jJl .i-jiJi

1 U p l ^ j j l v iS l i i fUl jJT-ijLij v l ' j l i ' j« H

( j j u l i l ^ U l

.^Ull ( r i l j l l vJU ' Jj 'JjJ kSi

l.£o*Sl iJMdl iLJljIjJl ilnUl » tU i l ( U *

iiiiips//wwWolmto§gin|ffiMiniiisiL®irg l u j j ^ T ^*i^'

Page 3: dJs'alliiMi - INTOSAI...^ J. - i^jS^i ajili i^liJi AJJJI Uifci Jp^li oVLaJVl ^^ Ifu OUl /j.CJVUJVi I i,s^^lji-lj l-W-i JIAAI a-> oUJl^lj frlfjUl ^ J-^ijJb ^jJ tij^Sl JIAAI iT^i 0(

\. . =\ ^u. - h^/J-i i,i0.i ijiiji Vj-^i il^i

^ / j S^b-_pl O'iUaJl i j ^ l j i ^ ' i

Y . . n IP J-iU I J J ^ J ^ H \ jl^^l J iUi l

f ^

jL_Si*il J i L U j ( O b J * U j ^ l j i dJ l ^j^iJtJ ^ j tOVUnl U I L H CJJLASPI

aalis—j! Ol j j i - l JiLJ) i^b-jail j U i ^Ui ( ^ Lp ( i i j J l J iT jU i i l j (Ol jcHj

jC j_ j . j ci^UjsJ^ i,:^;ljS^Vl ikjH j * dJllll JJLiI Jsfi^ J U^j j t(^r*jbl

j - ^ Jj*^l fljiai-! ^^ U-UJl fli* CJlTj .dVJCll J J ^ ^ J l (^L-*JSJ^1

C i j ] l J Lii i l j Ajll J>^jJl jS^. ct^Ujsi^ JJSJJ J l i i j JuJ j L t f l JLw?

j l (:JVUtfVl U - l ^ J y ^ 'iS'jijXA laS^Jlji-l J l a;!-l»- ^ c<iiii ^ J .t---Ull

j u ULT jS3j t^Ujsll J>-l3 JaJii ^ t JbflJVl j j f t f j frU^j i i - o - j Sui* 5lii

- Y * . V j j J j i^ - Li^ial l , ^ 1 l-^t i i l i -Uj -Lts^ j^ ' ftlTjiJij i^b-jJl

CJL - l i l LiQi<^ J U l UJ j \ j t j .t^ujsii uvuflji A,:^jijs--v j * p a j

Sj_ i i l i.; lljsr J—lUJj .^fU—jsJ^ 5_JU1I i i b^ l Jan'n- uT ^t t i b j l -u j l

5 j ^ * ^ ' 0* ^ 'k^b- jJ^U ^ 1 U*^^ l J ^ l CJifiyJ? eOijj! ol:rb=^*ii j

frUa_ptj .luapt 0 ^ of aik^ J ^ a^Ul (j UUSl uaji;T!iiiT ^ 1 ILiliJi l^iil

OjL-U Sbt j j _ t ttfJ-Ji (JLJil J Lli jU ^ S l j l^i- l ^ j i j^^^ l J-»Jl i i j *

j U - ^ l j ( ^ ^ I j i - i V i JaJflAJl j jXaj H^ I ^ I ) ^ ^ y ^ \ ^v^ a j iV ' j ^s^^-J^'l

.iiatl OIA J U J ttfJl (OA>ai OliVjU h \ i j l J ^ ^ i

•^M Jl J.**ll i } i j ^ - ^ (>btj l JUaJVI j i - ^ J ^ i ^ i J ^ l JUa Uirij

Jj'l -*Jl ( J U P j l i JV i j tiUiig- .lit oLuit OJ.J^J i5.^ii J L ^ I L:jtj3(j JJU»J

J4 ctW>l s-^jJUilj ( i ;Ui t j UaAl ftLiipt J l J ' U j l flJU J i j l i ^ j j i ^U*^ !

> ^ M »

Ji j ^ i i U i T

Page 4: dJs'alliiMi - INTOSAI...^ J. - i^jS^i ajili i^liJi AJJJI Uifci Jp^li oVLaJVl ^^ Ifu OUl /j.CJVUJVi I i,s^^lji-lj l-W-i JIAAI a-> oUJl^lj frlfjUl ^ J-^ijJb ^jJ tij^Sl JIAAI iT^i 0(

^ J . - i ^ jS^ i ajili i^liJi A J J J I Uifci

Jp^li oVLaJVl ^ ^ I f u OUl / j i .CJVUJVI i ,s^^l j i - l j l -W-i J I A A I a ->

o U J l ^ l j frlfjUl ^ J-^ijJb ^ j J t i j ^S l J I A A I i T ^ i 0( j i ^ J t^b-j=il

.i^Uj=il ^ j b t

: ^ i ^ l j l oVUtfVi c ^ ^ l - i * t

.IwUil jL t fV l J ' U j JrjU- J * 0*-^ tf JS-* ^ l*kJ.I frUapt iijA* Siljj •

. ^ ^ LJJUSJI j i j j j j (Uk l l (.UapT (i^i •

: ^ i ^ j l ^ I OVU:JV1 j i j t f JI-LAT

.t^(jll Si l l j JjiJt J ^ L U i^jSl^l i« r l j l i c^UUs»l J i •

. i^Ujsi i j t i^Jji l laUi I j ^ H i S j f i j iJlSl. jejia •

.iTjlJil oUkiLi j^( Uai t^L-jsi|j (ijlJjJ l^i Sj^flr*^! ^b'tji j ^ •

JA** UUJ.1 ObUsAVlj leUaill Jff-^y (>) : J ^ ^ j * t-ilJJ»Sl oJU Jai^ ^JLuj

(J-^r*9ii^i obrlrfw-*^! cJ jkJi ( f ) (frijyl-i i J i j i l (Y) il^'Uipt ^ ^;UJsi!

1^1—-Jlil j p jLiai i l J ^ Jtfi J5' I JUJ ] LrUll flj^rSU iiUall i*,5]l OiO^ ( i )

jo lJ l Jla UJ O b J J U ^ ^ J (j JfcUsll SiUj (^UjsJl jj«J cJ_^ (*iUItj .JS^

J ^ J U J J ^ l j J l j ( j j f J r l J j l a . J ( I S S A I ) i j l i j i i laWl i j ^SU i J j J l

t^Ujsil OjSii ^ ( diiJU i f l^^j .tf j ^ S l i^wll J l j t * ^ l j fU-^^i j ; u - j ^ j ^

i^^JiJ hiit._i iij.j-t^-S' l^>i»j jSS't Usit ^ - t f ^ ; ^ j i a^ i j ^ l * ^ h\l£ ,kdi

.V jSl^ l i i i j r i j l (|i i^ \ bUuil ^ J Ai 3 j u u j

t^UjsJl oVLaJl i,:^;lji-il J*c y>ai Jj*^l ^b-irVl J d/jiSi

jjj>u!t aus*

Page 5: dJs'alliiMi - INTOSAI...^ J. - i^jS^i ajili i^liJi AJJJI Uifci Jp^li oVLaJVl ^^ Ifu OUl /j.CJVUJVi I i,s^^lji-lj l-W-i JIAAI a-> oUJl^lj frlfjUl ^ J-^ijJb ^jJ tij^Sl JIAAI iT^i 0(

Y.. <! JJU - 1 ^ ^ \ ioiai a^ujj Vj-^i l i^ i

( t . . A j U > - l ( JjSl l_^U»rl J V O' UaJ t IBS^IIJI-' JU* ^ J l i / ^J i J^^ t J P jaJl j | j

l<=li U)V j ^ l J j - i -^J J_*P 3k»=- JA*!I a y c * * j uT . v5U» tf J*«Jt tf*^' j l l tiUi J*ij

( L-P J f j > ^ Jl# jT ^ j j» j * J p j / ja l t J p a j j l (iJflJt (Jij .Y . \ . ftp ( (> i j^ l tfU-jSj^

.£_j*j . j i ( Uiat ^ t j i j ^ u i j xkijSi j i j t f j

i -a j o u : ^ ! » j ^ tj 'iiSTiiiit V j ^ ^ t i«r t j i V^t' £_> j« J U l Uji ojiif^i (Y * * ^w a ^ t j j

(V j i i i «iwiiij (OUiij (W*^t J U l (I'lpj-rfj (lii j i it i j l i j i l t ^ i i j ^ S i (>• v ' j i k . j . J , U i i j

(JUl a i j ! LV j Ai^j j j -^.J^J^' ' ^ Jtf-o^ J 4 - ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ' ^ J ^ ' -.r' J ' J ^ ' ^ ^ J ^ J

J—, at II I«aUi^i diA j i j j LJJ-. (iiili J p SJ'APJ .^ j^ j i t l i * JJ*' iJ# i*Wt aju^t J J J J J ^

(#ujdj c*iv» (>• j ^ j WJ^*' J**!' ' .^i*j**j - H ' *J'.> ^^-J^ u^^ ' J ^ ' ' J^^* " ' cf '^ '^^'

.^j j»j l i IJU JjW alijjf ^ ^ ajiijU VJi i j ^S t ^ i i } Ojtwli (il ijfto*

Ciii^-t aUUt Ol i jMjIt J l JjrfjJl iljlSlI L!«rlj!.l J * J^Jt ^ J«rj ajL^Ul o-SU^t j i j«Jj

^^UP jLja^Hi ai^-ij (HUUij iJiJ^ 0\i\ai iOPti j U l aIji ^ ( ^ 1 J l ^ i j - j f f i i l i * j-!»>»

( ^ j - ^ J l Lp—^ (^trtijsll (:JIS^ (lit«isi* ( ^ ^ .^J ( j i i^J ilaiat j l i j Illi HI- .(^Lijxil "(-<}' y

l ^ U^jJti a„»i3 (^ttt^jt liUOf J (^iaiij jsry aWj JS^ VJ l ( J^rja-j .i^jiJ'ili ^ y J * j ^ i j

J *jt Jij taiJUait oLdsiJjJ iSjW s-iii J * JUt aiji ^L^S ^ aaijii cJj .au cjii leUaitj

.\Jl9^J. a ^ i ^ (liUw«l« JlJpt l ^ L j k i j (iJualt o t i i ^ U j d l Ol;v> ^ J t L J U I I

Sl^l l ^ ^ o (>jWl CJIJJI

i J - I J * oWUi Olaiu]

l l J jU l U * i j 4 ? ^ lalj>^l m i * !

il*-

J*e ol*j*#

> * ( i j t

CJl*J*#

w y ' i H ' ^ L . J : J <

ym >Bt ijor jt J lyiAiij iWjii erijii y^ i . .

l « r V J .ol*il) UUjlv t f ' -^ ' i i i y>u- . t U i ; 1Y t . , ^ j ( I S S A I ) i j^jH l .m * j » r ^ j j J i j l ^ i :gi»j*!l

• T i . ^ j i m - i , ^ J j j i i j i ,J i i j j i f jtJiJij .a j i l pJiiSi

li^jLJ-i) oyjSii Lw'jii U * n t . yij ( issAi ) i j i j i qJ' JJK^ IJJAS' j i^ i ^a fuJi a*>j:i

I j u u ^ l U-U-i f U t j L ljJl l U l i 01ia»j i^ljJl ^ Ikai Iw rV (1 i^f J ^ ' 1 ^ * * t * ^ ' i / ^ ' y j ' ( lA- ' ^^ ' j

. i iui i i j i j ^ i J

ifLjiSl ^ L J L C I p l VJd OLlj b u i isViji f j i , < T i > ,>ij ( I S S A I ) l < l l / l .m iji>r'*i j j J l ' j l .Jl:Jl^^l

luj—cl ajiii pjijiii cjij* lil \4 JLH (jlj tu<i <y ^-ji (ijSj b i;\^ fiiJi ikiii J ym a<tfr>>> (.>u*i tiii i^v-

•.^/^ UP ai.1 fJAu tJjl-Jl ym jOlill iU*l > V ^ J

Ifj_jij .ym jyiifi JUP) J ^;J]I JP ;,4\JI *tjjji< a^jii ^wi g_njii i^ j juJi >IAI yu»yi J IJKJ' •

i ^ - Ju i ^ > J U - , f t- jdl ^ lU l l !;.< J , ^ hi- \J\ 4>m Cil4{>Jjl > t f ( M U UrUil l i O l imrljll Oi»l>t-! *

i L j j i j L i cj\y i j ,J__^ljjl oljliSjsVij i^ULl j^lj-Bj .*ijJJl j iilJlifW-^i j«JJ CJU*PJ <i«rijll

.JljI^l iSj i i JJlSJj

. J>.>^l l O l ^ l j ^ l ( j i ^ l <i:>lj!-l^11 j ^ o U ^ lU^l^l . n U ^ ^ U j i l la l l

; JUl J «rijfi o i j i *jy a ^ y i i ; miUi :jjVi J J i i .t/i •jus :oi i j i ' littp!//DSC.riQ8revisionen.dk/fas

j l _ ^ l <(.LtW '^A.pt) r . . I t f i jJJ i j j jJ l j > l i i ( 4 i t l ^ i:jJ,et) T i . l*?ivJi JjAii j U l i l W j * JWI

.(^it-V OJ^I) r r < Iwri j*!! iJjJli jlc^i .(wtlr^ i^J^I) T^a l*;t-ijU] J j J i

.IJlLl ^ l j 2 i l J * ( - | ^ j i j j i \ t I k ^ j l l ^ I j l l a j j u - : J i j J i

J . X i ^ - ^ i » . ? ^ - j ^ ^ l ( i » - ( Y < • j i W r . . X . . A j t j ! r l r . ) ( - > J J ^ j i i . :an;-i

t o . JiA*Ji

lmp://www.issniiirp/niadi3f733.1011VlSSAl 1 10 E E. ip draft pdf J j - l J ' j U ^ l y^'iaJl tWjUl

(l'J|._..-!.J!.. )j

• s a g

. j ^U jJ I (jj1}jl a^OsdJl (lJUa^JJ.1 LJIAJ l ; ^

j i j ^ i u r

Page 6: dJs'alliiMi - INTOSAI...^ J. - i^jS^i ajili i^liJi AJJJI Uifci Jp^li oVLaJVl ^^ Ifu OUl /j.CJVUJVi I i,s^^lji-lj l-W-i JIAAI a-> oUJl^lj frlfjUl ^ J-^ijJb ^jJ tij^Sl JIAAI iT^i 0(

Y.. 1 jj>, - a^jS^i ajui a<UjD gjoi i ib^i

ftUiP^l j>iW J j ^ i t • * Jij i l t 9J^ j j ^ ^ ^ \ aiji) J4^ l^ssr^^ J

.4..4J ^>^ j l l J ftUP^I Ol>L.aj ^Ull lijk ^j->j£ iLAslt ZkkAll ikJjSl

.j-fcji i i j i l L*uH JiJA^i 0 ^ uUsli t^y-^i j;U,i (j W O j j ^ j

UJUll JA Oijl *£_j*jll IOA OtJ^ ( W j ^ ) a,^lja-Vl aiail-1 ( ^ ftlj^t > l

^ l U l O^^LAT*^! h ^ ^Ikj U«a *^j ^iS^yi\ CJ^U:n ia:!i 1jS..* UaJTiJl

: j H \ 'i^jj^f^^k *^^js>? 1 * ^ ' ^^*^^ J^ -^ l tfTji t OUjUl j ; ^ Oijl

[email protected]

H.,^iur

Page 7: dJs'alliiMi - INTOSAI...^ J. - i^jS^i ajili i^liJi AJJJI Uifci Jp^li oVLaJVl ^^ Ifu OUl /j.CJVUJVi I i,s^^lji-lj l-W-i JIAAI a-> oUJl^lj frlfjUl ^ J-^ijJb ^jJ tij^Sl JIAAI iT^i 0(

Y.. n JiLo - i s A ^ \ ajai a^ii^ i^}^\ ai^i

^ ' ^'U:*ir. u^-^W*-.. ;/ ' ..>'« ''^p*''.> -' - - "> •

I i^i

CJL—- ( iup i jJ i J j i ^ fcr*s^ Jcft*^ ' ^ - ^

aa,..Ut Cmil 11 .Y»* A j ^ j ] ( LyJuij]

iA^ Ig^jl CJU 4 ^ I j l l jeJ^ 1 . ^ ji ftg r

j i J U i VU ^^^iT 'Sjf^^i =lJj i (,*j • ^ T

L-ilapt f- -fi h TJ .Sjb^lj i^b«slt Jj;LiJ

J j - w j J J J l dJUJl lAjC J \ ^UJ.1 i « r y

. ^ is : ) i i , * j i

i2J_Mall Ol—jVjll ( (j««99r »JgUl C--JA

(^jL-t a^Vj ^ i ^ y V - l * l i>W>3£ JUP^I

JUkP^ l j V l l l J jL*pSfl Sjlil i^ > - ^ * l l j

IY % * r j i L j t^ . j j 4 ^ U ( a*.ir j ^ V J J l

(^1—^jJl 3.-ai«il 9jdL-t^ ^;;wi f j U j ^ CJlJ

J U I J .t^L—^jjtS3l UoJi >vO*" Jirtirt-wioC

O I J J J U I 5jb)j ( Uufl-Tj ,A-aJ J cXjLA

V - - P CJljOdll J ^ ^ U j { SjfOA CJlf J

jofc , ^ ) l i v-o^i ^Uji OJUJJ a ^ y i

( ^ I j : — . V I VwS j l iJt- ( IjJaP l4 i r f> j

a W-1 iia—pj $ c-Tji—& (tfl -jjiSiU

.UkUl a,i».,;ij:u-Vi

j i j L ^ ( i i i j u r j u ^ j (iitUi (^ijLJ-i

f ^ \ Jlj—•'ifl <J j ^ (^-^ jA9ii L>UJ

jj>lj-frSl i^ v»j-J> t r " ^ ^ • * « '

(J^- j j j Ojr J * J^k J ^ i J^ aij

flp w l y j *-Jlj* '•••At* Jp ,yiiJ t^Jl

OB—It ^ ^ JlJj .Y *»A JiU J loJjiT

'• '*»' (J 2—tr^l 4—Jla*- i * ^ Jo-'JJi

otji- C-. l^ br (^Uli ^ijltj ^\ji

i£>\ (CJjll ( i l l i JM>-J .JjJl ^.UL* t

a_ierijltj 3lt\ 11 CiJJ- 4 \JJij ijji

. ^ n ^ r aj - ( a_^uit a«r i jU JiJir

^-SSJ: jLt fVi i/Tji tCjUjUll J * Ojjl

: Ul1 cfr ' j l l j L J I J I I

: !^Jj^y\ - ^ t Anne [email protected] govae,

Maureen MulIiganCojaudge n.irlgov.ie

http://audgen.gov.ie.

I j j j j j

flp ^ l j * j U l j * " ^ ^ i Ojsr" Cl*

.Y a » A J i U . J lOJjjj i i j j ^ i - ^ j J J

J_-*P ( fL-# j yjJli v ^ t f ( ^ l i O jJ l j

^ HIA ^Ip Ju ^Ui ^ I j l i j ^ t j ^ i v ^ .

> ^ ^ O j : r

ot J j U Ail" : J l i ^ u OjJi 0 ^ a*ij

t f L U I ^ t j l l j LjJljll t-aC U l i j l jjsji-t

V i j J i u-—i#) ^'^Ji^ Jii '^ j ^ ^ f ^ j f j

t) fUi v-flJt t i i ^ ^ y (^p ( iUj i ( i^

.'JiUji*^i V l i ' Sjia^i

VUA ^y oSTsll J l i j j ^ I j j i v ^ i i^^>.

3^4^*^ J ^ \ j Jilt t'aSi (>p o U j U t

frUSi j : r j *

Page 8: dJs'alliiMi - INTOSAI...^ J. - i^jS^i ajili i^liJi AJJJI Uifci Jp^li oVLaJVl ^^ Ifu OUl /j.CJVUJVi I i,s^^lji-lj l-W-i JIAAI a-> oUJl^lj frlfjUl ^ J-^ijJb ^jJ tij^Sl JIAAI iT^i 0(

T.. 1 ^b -1^^\ ajui li^ji VjJi ^\

ik-I a«jj[ jbJi ftijj a ^ i -^w aijj U»*J o u - i ^ i a ><* ,^JJ-JI ^y* i j > - j

:a^j Jlj—.(ijbl iiii—i lUll (i'li oCjUli C-fjU. cY « . A j ! Y » < V ^ SJMII ^

(I^IOAT Jk U J ^ a«U]l Vl^l ^^U* U^ ^ * L P > - ^ ' •^—a^ l««!tX-vM*j (OlPjjU.t iOPUl J j J l ^UjJl ( , ^ . . ^ 90^1

YiipUil Cil^Jrl Jk UJ .lil -jU (^ Vj-^'j ^JJJ^' lyUjLjl 3—ftfji-l Ct—sU V^jU^' ha:\ji

a—uii (iijUJ-i iiik gwtf of (;;S . u i / • iiijUi aiarijli 4 ou*i^i a*SU lijLti-j a_ia:Sii a—._jii *sej (^Jij (iifttJij

i iVJi akUi aiftU^ ( ^ aftsli ^ Vui jiTT yi/jV a ^ v i^j^' ^ M ^ L U itiU- 01,^^" £*"JJJI J*=< - ^ ^ i ^ ' j * ^

?fU]| JUJ^I ^ Lrl^j U-lJ-t jST I ^ L i i ' M ^ J^f t>- JLUyt . LJU a—«rly 3ji?=-j C J L ^ J

y-tya i_<l8jU L^l iy^^ JJi J^ • .^Jl Jl OIJULI ItHjil l>!l ij^Sll y jfji^

vaiftUli a^P ( UL^L*. i u * ^ jLarti ^^JJ (OUjUi QA Oijl .Vj-iJi 2,*.JJ 3iXiS3i aiiTjli AJJSJ VU

l.uJt oiiLJ-i Ol%U alilll (i ljlai-i ( / u • :VijSjt 1 oUl^i j ! ir»9^ ^u^i Cwsii (g UjJi JtA^

JUl oUjur ^:)UV ajlijll i ut Jj^r^ij -^jj^^V' - ^ i -t ** ' f ' cr'-^' ^

?aJftUlt iiji ct-^ ( jjJtiJij lit i-»iii-i [email protected] v-iSor JUaiVi tirj (OUjUli j * .1;^

ViUt :ai.LUL] (:fe.Vj ct^ir ajjii ^ L J J ^^^^w.ac- :cjjj)fi ^ ^jli . ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ j ^ , ^ , ^^^

I f - .1 X, .-. t . , li. t ,t I I. rada.gov.ua/achamber/contr . . .x,„, , „ ol/en/mdex ,. U^ .

^ j j ^ f) aJftU.1 a c i ^ j ((4< fi^i ((HI [email protected]

fr-^j* 4*^j j *«^^ ' jif'-'s'' j t *^^M 3a«di 2£CLil

J a—.uJi oiil U hk ^ijU aa^i jf y ^ t&-*^ * ^

j ^ - JUVl a^f i i j^ jo " j , . ^ / ^ ^ ^ o l i L J - t aJe ( ^ ^ * / ^ 5^-^

OUA-4 J—UJ 5J—'iir t3jl» - *iJji*jS^i t tl I tl

. O U J U J J I J OlisJJua* Oiij * l«Jt ^^U*-l cr -TJ- V V- ' C

. L ^ , ^ > 1 1 0 l . a i " c J j i i O t O j a i « o ^ ' > ' ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ' ^ > ' ' ^ ^ ^ - ^ ^ ^ ^ j . j S ^ ^ ^ j ^ ^ J fli

( ^ j . jS J i j ; uuJ iovu^ i i J , j ^ l ^ . i j jV«I.^u^ta . .^ai j j j . f jUi ji^ .,^., ^,Uj (y./jt ^ oui^i

0K^jU:u3^ia^uSi:..a.L^j/j=i>j ^ : ^ ' ^ 3 ^ ' ^ ' ^ ' « ^ i ^ ' - ^ - ^ ^ ^ ( U - j j ^ .LUI/J<^ J . ^ . ^ t

:i.Ul, 0 4 1 ^ 1 - > ^ ^ ^ ' 3 - ^ ' ^ ^ ^ ' ^ ^ i i ' j ^ . . ^ ^Li; 5/ i> i ^ j , ( M y j

: ^ j ( C , . l , l U i - ^ a « U ^ . U ^ j ^ ^ J ' ^ ^ ' ^ V L ^ ' ^ W ^ U ^ , ^ . 5 / a i u J - L ^ j . j . Y . a A

a u ^ i j ^ ^ ^ , j ^ i - j ^ ^ , . - - ^ c ^ I ^ ^ ^ y ^ ' ^ ' ^ ^ J ^ - ^ i j j j t ^ t ^ ^ o u ^ i i ^

,.1^...,. WJ .fl** JS^ a,i^r^j ai*l-Jij Oi^Jii ^ ^ Ij^ foaj igi/jT 4 alii

o w u ^ i a ^ ; . u J i - ^ U J i ' . i > i . -^<^''^J-»J'-'i*5ai,j£iit^o/jmi uoiJijjJi^jjovJiar[.a^iji .

^y>. , i j i , f ta^ ia^^j / j J i , a .u i t ^ ^ ^ c ? * s * e - j t o i k ^ j > a o j ^ ^ o u - i i . ^ ^ A^ ^ i l ^ ^ j ,

.^U3Ui^itfja^^jUir- *>* ^»^J'*^^>^ ^'*J*^^'£«# , , . j ja«rijUJ-^j4^^(yijfjt uUi j ^a j ^ , -v ' j - ^»L«OjUJ , . ' ^ ^ ^ fi^ Jl ^ ^ ^ ^ ' r -^ '^ 'J ' W 5 j ^ ^ j a j . i p a ^ . j . o w U p

^ju«i, j ; u J i ^ w ^ ^ U . j ^ ^ i ^ ^ ' ^ ^ ' ' '^ "-^ ' ^ ' ^ ^ ' • ^ > ' = ' .Jii^i olkLU Jlll .^uii awrijii

^uSi wu

Page 9: dJs'alliiMi - INTOSAI...^ J. - i^jS^i ajili i^liJi AJJJI Uifci Jp^li oVLaJVl ^^ Ifu OUl /j.CJVUJVi I i,s^^lji-lj l-W-i JIAAI a-> oUJl^lj frlfjUl ^ J-^ijJb ^jJ tij^Sl JIAAI iT^i 0(

Y.. 1 y.Uj - a^jS^i yu i iiiijU V j J i iL^i

^^jVUfj JJP jlOA fl J* Ui-tj (cVlS sJl

l._,S^ «««* oli l j i l JHI£J (^I j i j

ij«ilv

OS Msl a—.jS l js_P Oli.bJl 5jtil ( i )

OUUI a lrlMj (Vl«^lj VeA^I 3»li^l

iiiA.u]ij v i^ i

a—.J£MJ a_;ui ova»di ;UrUl A J ^ (O)

;L-iljJ U»-V (JijUl tf Jl ^ V t jM '

oi j i j i^ i j ai jsi! o t i j jU i OK J:>iss=-vi

• V j ^ l ^ » ^ ' S ^ ^ ' J O ^ ^^^ C*)

•tsjiS' M»j liLjd ob.

, aJfrL-Ul s—=51 ^ l i J V i ij4A-l j* i-A-j

(l^.u-^ j jU* ^ Y.»S f iP J ^ V»j^i

>L^i«ll OLli V j ^ l iU^Ul v ^ ^IJ^

2 b 1 o- /l l ^ fWa- t j / j J a-fljjll

(jiu-ft^ i—i>jp OjSJ jT t j ^ oVj^ Jl

.ijl i^l t j - j (ftOata-iVl ftj-J (Jla»-Vlj

>•• Kc JU-.rtl ,j-P:ji ((iJUjUl J* o jl

:a^js:i-i ai»Lj.i

spel(@^ao.gov :cJj=J-Vl^£ijll

www.gao.gov

l ^ ^ \ aSfrUi\ c ^

dOiJet d j b ^ a lUaJ jl

Jl (:yiiik>!- aiLjJii fUJi sJijli j j b j i j j r

ajiA i OM^J i i ^ V* j ^ i ai&iJi (-•J^

JA-.J cX-jfj . ^ 1 aj l i . JjJ aJiOA-l

^j-aj ^ j - j j j?ij-S^i aii^ Jl autf

;^ a^ j^ i al iUi i^Xi J^ j ^ aapuli

(faUflii j j ^ j - £ l \ JU-ftpt JjJbr iiopi

JljA^t OlA-j (OliUaPVl OUr Jl dUifj

.a^^j^i aj LJi fc^ ^isit

1.1 ^» tj__j (Vl2s)* l ^ j l l J4? »a

cjjsj-ii ^ J . Jjf i3%i a jS: -! aJ*Ui

c^ j . ^ ovif si*:!! j* i igiUsiVi il9-jJ3

:>1)

.(www.gao.gov/traiisition_2009

a_ijiUi a^jX^i »iUi ^sS^ f UAs^itj

iJL-ciali i£h tjj—^' je^ J**^'j V—'jl'

^•i—&i ilfijSA V j ^ IjUi iiiiii Xjatyli

^ i ajb^ij (OUl,—iij (j^ijjt uui

.V ja^ i i * ^ i <^iji

: ^ a^- j fUJl iu- Jl f.U^ ^ j l l

^ i » uuAi sJksi ^1 auii t-uidii (^)

i%Ul j ^ \ OUjaU 5j«Ul i i l j l l j

ll^S^lijJ

(fi^li Jfi jy Ji Wjlt oiiJ^Jt (Y)

^^ auiTj YA 4 ^ijJlj (VijJij

(Jeii^^St o-^iTjit

Q» jjJS a—tfij i:5-> j^ Vj—5i u (f)

:j-_i a . ,.-<ll o i j i - l (jip aUP-iUj

a_J^i j (OUU jjsrj (Uitj (lo ijT

iLJjjJl Oi.L_^ ( if js t O^ufj 3A>«3ii

ot J—So: ( 1 aoatiaUl oUjUll asfenjl

Jfi JUl J aitijiJ v«]i sj^Vi apuj

.a>U!l oUUJ-t OlJr Vui jiTl j ^

i-i»i;ll J M aijj OJAJW j£jll -lifjj

tfiLUl Jf i j / j j t j (ljil?- jbJl ftjj

US' .aj.icUi;ii ijdfi j^ij 9u> auX;

- j-j*-T tu^ aiu^ JS/ Oaitj iJu oir

Uj-aPlj .ah', ill VUJ^I UiOMsIlj

V y MI«A]I ^ ^ j J p 4 Oj^juii

i-LUii J aljli J" C^ J-^ J ^ C:»Ji

JJJIAII a#-UI .L2i Uku iJUj .fWl

j_ij«ii ua-^t Ji (CJjd^i ^ijA Jfi

ai4_^ i^iii a—iisS ij J O ^ - ^ -i^uii

OlSU^ j_4 apj;U« JA^ flJlAs^lj

a^jii jauJt-t oT JA liflsii oVUJM

^ j * ^^^ a_?-u aefcHji aijjJi tijb

:jUJi frljj a ^ i 0 ^ cJjsiVl http://www.odi.org.uk/r^o urces/projects/reports/2008 /D6/public-sector-accountability-

effectiveness-accounts-eommittees.pdf. a_u- a^u i oUwJ aiuut ouiaS tj

.UiiJi Jfi \M UuJ u a tufi c^gm-i

JUu-Tlfl ^^-PTjt ( OUjUl ^ 4ijlj

^jUl c--^;^U ^j.^-Jj^ J^M

: Su Msll a , <loH< a «ri_^

-.yjjjsSiili ajjJi

[email protected] si.gov.uk

www.nao.org.uk

fr^Sl jcry

Page 10: dJs'alliiMi - INTOSAI...^ J. - i^jS^i ajili i^liJi AJJJI Uifci Jp^li oVLaJVl ^^ Ifu OUl /j.CJVUJVi I i,s^^lji-lj l-W-i JIAAI a-> oUJl^lj frlfjUl ^ J-^ijJb ^jJ tij^Sl JIAAI iT^i 0(

a*3rt>i J**i jftJb 1 j , ^ fi:Ap^i j ; u j ^ j jUJ i

lAifl ; } (LJ1 fUJi I j l l ,< 13 C ^ :ilapl

^Ji^ J^ - ^ ^ 1 Ol{UJ"t lu^ ^ j W \ ^ i !)UP ^JjJ iiUfljll v = ^ ^ ^ *M

j t X - t g_Uwl CrfUJjr Oitf j t (»Uaft*lII JjJ S - jijfisll U j4 y.JJl iJl;!iJl j *

J—A j j i - ^ i ^ o i ^ j j j i j iu;^ OjgiiijJt .aisli^ dii.J t:) tiwr jL* CJWUP

Jl (tUjiJl ftLjif aidC 4 i i j^^J\ J«fi (*iiii 2 J .IPjeMl X)^* ^^Iji! cJjJl

Oi VJ ,,»Ayij*l( ^:J^^I JJL-J i j i * cJVjl 13| U»>fl>-j tf!)^^! JJUjj f.Uaft*!ll

(Ur jf i^ l j Sftiji fy; V Oi iw^ljli j i j ^ <^ ^«A9- i{lijU i>Ji S j^^ i J j j j ci(

j L _ ^ j - ^ 1 j * J i 4>» ii«i t ^ oiLjJi ^ a^ i J i > ^ i Jili- aV j a^-jj 4ifj

.(•i dUUj J 4 J f ^ ^ \ j ; u j Jjcf ^^ *iJiJi j , ^ J jUt j j ^ \ M j ^ J^*i^

M'iiii^\i j - U l l djd f!Apyi J l U j ^ plTyi. IflljU IsUl Sj ;?- ! ^ ^^ ^ .

jjJ__i (OP J P ju t l j l l >U()[ a , ^ j 5Li ^ ^ ^ l J IU j 0^ tdiJi J) aiU'^Il*

j>-^*;!aj (hrt—Jl fSpyij .(»ru< SBAUJ Jlja 4 4S/U.J a(ii_^ ^ V i jt^i-i

aJfrU—• j—tjrf J l t^-aji fljj-4 (JUJ iCfy^cdi v ' j i i * i ^ i^f^^ -J**^' i^i^i-'

.l.UJt Jlj^Vt »jlij L t ^ J y i i i J i 5iiij ;J l fJl JaUall i j j tiiOfliJl i k U i

tjl^^«_--li Jfl r ^ j 1 1(II_;U (^Vl j^A-l of OU-i» l ib^ . (JajIaAaJl jS(i( ^ j

!>Up)f1 JJUjI Jjissr ouy<M i l^ l i iKc u r .p!Ap l J iU j J \x^ % ^ ^ j

J J — ^ t OliTj O j ^ JJi tf i jTj 5«f Ijll liUaJ ^ l i ^ i IjijiJ JJiJ Jf j ^ . (^1

tfJipVi ji^A-i Jja a* t 551A3 j ^ j i i tfja-^ ^ j j f - i J > - j .a-ui ajdi o U

V—nSl). UJL j l l i j ^ l j J«Jl{ fU£A*)Il j«; ;^ j .LiUlt iUftUll OU^ 4 ^l i j l i

C^Us^j .U.A-J1 Ol^ 3—r^l l^ti^lj ^ U l o l jjLlj ^Ull iilP C)i( ^ j ^ l

;,_P aJfU.1 jy j ^ jjTf OU-aJ a^-lAl j l jJ^l i flaiJl QA tUljJaJl j ^ b Cftifc' l

.:ft j«ii cxh4\ J ^ j>» fiJi t j i i ^ i

^ J H f'iU^I J ;U j J l a«rljll gJlai alb-i ^y OS'Ul Oiy t ^ l j tV l a-U j , ^ j I

j-H^jitf * uu !jj3 J«rijlt ^ u ^ j jy .c^%jU\ UL^ i Jbti ^d > w o* J ^ ' ^ ^ " " ^ ^^^ ^ ^ • ^

15; lillll a/ui i fli* of js^ ,a jSCi.i oOUi 4 o^jJi ^ i j y u u i j ajtuii ^'**^' ^^ * ^ ^ ^ " ^ t

. JiO^j Je.w Oji i^^^lj icrijli aiUj Jii OiP ilia *«?^J-^^ - ^ ^ ^ ^ ' ^ ^

O U ^ OJIJUKJIJ Ojicrljll (•LJ JjOi of j ^ (c i i j« l l j l u^j*A)l v ^ J ''""^^'' ^"^-^^ " ^ - ^ t "

f U j ^ i ,^i^j . f^^ i j j u j ^ j*i«!i tj a^ i oiji^li a ^ j ( f^^ i ji'Uj -0"^ i^ '-^-J* '

.^^>i J;uj ^ JUiil jjiUJJ 3^uSi oij^ii OJOJI ajbli

aa*v- * i ^ j .iijV^i V?^ l i OlT li l {.Uj>*il a.i>J ^^IPSI jl«Jt-i J * P v^f-

A

^!sUVl,pl-, vO,UJl

Page 11: dJs'alliiMi - INTOSAI...^ J. - i^jS^i ajili i^liJi AJJJI Uifci Jp^li oVLaJVl ^^ Ifu OUl /j.CJVUJVi I i,s^^lji-lj l-W-i JIAAI a-> oUJl^lj frlfjUl ^ J-^ijJb ^jJ tij^Sl JIAAI iT^i 0(

r . ' ^ j,b - i ^ ^ s Vil a(iljJ ajjJi aifci

.a_yU!.^i a^^Si o l i jj*50 - ^ \ p j 4 j - ^MVI aliTj Jijai a ^ i j i i j

i^jk^ (^1 / u K j f t j i j i^Vij t jO^(j i i j t j i i j c^uit i l j l a r iJijAjsr j ; u . •

M j ^ ^ \ \ ^ \ Jlal^ O i l j j t l i tU l SijAjsr O i l j U i r tj**il IfclP

I . ^ Jaibsj j f ^ j u j ^ ^09- ^ 1 i^jjUai^ jf t%<Jjb* . ^ ta^ilp j ^ ^ < lJb-f •

MS^\ V^' <ll OJSJ U P uJlki jA

/ OjwflT III! / i\J&\ AijNj of u ^ U J . « ^ iJjbj : ^ r i j i ^ hr\>- Jar^ CJUJIJW •

frljij i U ^ \ plif ^ ^ ( • ^ I j i(iil_^l( PIIA^W U ^ j t i ^ i f QC- O j ^ U l l

- j y ^ t t>« j * ^ tjplp fj«J> aip j t t ^

.(ffjaAA j j * f ^ ^ j f cjUi l j J ^ l ia,.ifl9tiJl jJfj (jj^*s!Ji

^ tjj.j27 t^ j - i^ j ' ( ^ - ^ y > . u t / J 4 ^ o U j U l sJU :y^|l CJ\^ o U j U l l •

.iSj^^^ OUMl jf l«j^l ftbtj tuJlj^lj tayJl h4

a_-iurijli( f P)!! j ; u j ^ t ^ f^yi j ; u j ^ aJui o u ^ tUf (^JJJAJI y

j l ^ l ^ IJ^ i f ^ * f \ J ; U j ^ aJlai 0 \ t ^ »UJj . gibfffiS ^ \ ^ J l ^ U j ^ j 7 j

.(irAP l JJUj ^ o l j ^ l ^ ajlsJl Cfil l ( ^ J! i*^jii c«^Si

u^jJur j M j i |i*-lJ l<^jii J ^ ^ ^ 3 ^ 1 r '^ O y f j ilftJ-i^ C«9*l:J-<»fi=i* '

.J»^UK?S-I Jl# J J>-UJ ^ l j « Jp uJJbUJ

., tofcUJ a^ui oiiisCii ( ^ (^Jjiil i j i i i UJU p\^i -.aijjiii •

. u j i i U ^ i J j i .-jXioii*

t^J—^fj a«rtjll ^fUl V ^ t / j i ^ j ^ j ^ ^ ^ of i^ t ^ :<UP I JOMST U 2ijM •

.<lL{ J U l V I Qf- OjgiM^I cilja9->> (<^ ^ - b v t U i j j t f ^ l i l - j i j ^ ^

. 0 ^ O ^ l i * j ^ ^ ^ of J.J ^ oUjJbu jUa^ O j ^ of : ^ l "

.4 C J J ^ lc fjs)l t J ^ UJoP iMj^jI-l *

OjTjJ—i *!( ,»i^ u r . f ^ ^ l J J U j ^ J^Uail tl VO-W 5ilP Cfi(«r»> t JJ ^

.SO^lj Ul{ ^ O M S I I J ( (f^^UP ^ j a C ^^\ OUjiwail jiAJSj t AP Jl J J U j U\25

joSUu)- IjTjUi of k ^ J l laWl S j ^ ^ l (^WIJ Oya^ci j^iJl Oj«r'jJ.' la^s * ' ^ j

.f!)^P^I J J U j

^ U J - l j f U l os^UaiJl f-^U^l J ; U j J a U (OUL^l ^ J t * ^ J T J ^ j Vjf

U\^ tOlfliU-lj ( ^ U l l j tOlaS-jijiS^l QA iu- l j U > J-OJ U S J .a^UJ OJSJJ

f^^JI JJUj^OjUsIl

Page 12: dJs'alliiMi - INTOSAI...^ J. - i^jS^i ajili i^liJi AJJJI Uifci Jp^li oVLaJVl ^^ Ifu OUl /j.CJVUJVi I i,s^^lji-lj l-W-i JIAAI a-> oUJl^lj frlfjUl ^ J-^ijJb ^jJ tij^Sl JIAAI iT^i 0(

Y . . <\ JJI^ - V j ^ ^ y ^ l il^jJJ JaSj-J* l i * ^

U aisS?- J * Jj.«»JJ J^ l ja* Ja*-iP C-^ ( ^ .5^1 j Jbi l ^ j Jifi *

iJU« i l a i ^ j j i I f k ^ f t^ .oiO^I a^jUll OgPlj ^ ^ I j (^.jyll O^^v^ l {^-^J

.Ojsi^uaJl I f * ^ of < ^ ^ ^ 1 iljLJS OPIJI OUJJLIJ ^ I j i

OUjIi jjJU ^^, " j ^ »wf v ^ ' ,^4^ u ^^^1 J;u j loAA (^J jurji (gu

.ai^js ft^jf VJ** * t ^ OjijiJbJl Utf- H} .Ola»-la=iSlj j^s^^J ,jflL«^l O l^ l j f

JA (diiJUj .^U\# j f OiJLi j \^\( dia.^ JjW jSo: i j ^ % \ i - i y fjail 0\r l i l

.d4 a ii f ji,?^Si JUi^ cJjii Juo (• i

, JUA oL- . jU l J* aUU a ^ Jl (^jjiJl J j^ j i l 0^1 Oj^i-*^! ^B^W :!S)U

aSl,_ji ^ a -b. atUjil Ji-H\ j^ i - i j ^ aitUi -IAP I j j u j JPAO^ .CJ^I^I

^^ a#-uSl ( l iU jU i ^ ^ Jj-aJ-l ^JIP ^^^jii Ojai>»«flJl O j ^ Of J i ^ .CJjai*il

j i j L M a ^ l f : l l a i l ^ l i j ; ^ i . " k ^ j ' ^ j A d l i J OlT lit tCJjsJ^l Je- i U i j *

. j ^ cJj ^ ^ f (J ^ j l l * f4*^j v ^ ta*flrijli

oijiO^j ^ ftU( i3_pji a^b i^r / ^un ^UaiU arjUii f^u^i j ^ u j tUjij

Uai f j ^ ^ ^ j^j?"^ c«>«-*i* uoiSj S f ^ ^ l JJU j [i^jb. of d ^ j .a«*i3i

.aJaiu a jSJ-i Oji^i agW OJSJ of j ^ . tOiljJi ^

J ; U j j&nfj anJjjaS3)!l p!Ap)I' J i U j ajllji: o U j ^ l ^jH tOloUl Ja*t ( :L«bt

a-^jS:j-i j-ijj u" f!>UVi JiL-j ^^ to*iJ-i SJA Ji* ^ .5a;ijli apj^i fM*f^

liUJJ i>^j .u^\ j**J a,^i jU^i ^ oUjUi uj^p. ^:^o ("aijiuji i^\i\

ol j - J j : u r .a^jS^^iafliiii. j J ^ of o^. .yi^i j^iuu a ^ i ^!AP^I j ; u j o!>

.a^waJi oiy jll Js- o\^M jT a*uli Q!jar^J.i jij\is j* hj^. j-^

jy»-U?lj JU-»pf J j J - J f J j j y i Js> UjOi j y f^sU^I J ; U j 5jl ^ : U i U

J ; U ^ j a.-MT (jl^SU O j ^ U ^ Cfta-'W-Jl ^ 1 ^ Of i^^^j -tlfia^W^'j OUV- t l

Z-^ \ * i * J>Pji^ W Ojij*t ^i^iilj .(^Agjpj a^j4^ ( U ^ ^>. U\* Ifrj;!- f'l^P^l

.Sjflil (^ £_jjl liifc ( 0 / j U i JUiJi J U J ^ l j f!>Uyi J jUjJ

iV^ j l j i j l j l l ^^Usil ; ^ U JAJ (Jif i j l j f i , j t r i I j U i of j f i i ^ i g_liuil f^Ap^l

^ j r 4 l . j U a^fij) ^ iSLJl ^jajf . Jj?«il aPj-, ^ ^JO-MII ^y Oiji. 0\i«lj:i\

. ^ \ i - l j fWl oi*^Ml J - f-S^^I J J U J

.Cftsiw-^a-Jl anjfft ( 1 ^ of Lajf c-^ (f!l^p^l j 3 U j ^ ^;:^Jl ( t--*jJ c ^ r l i l

Oi;aiM^I ^ j (a«il>- I j * ^ of a^lijU ^ S l jl^J^I i il O J A U I J O/d^dl ^ l : ^ :

f ^ ^ l JiUj/wOjUaJl

Page 13: dJs'alliiMi - INTOSAI...^ J. - i^jS^i ajili i^liJi AJJJI Uifci Jp^li oVLaJVl ^^ Ifu OUl /j.CJVUJVi I i,s^^lji-lj l-W-i JIAAI a-> oUJl^lj frlfjUl ^ J-^ijJb ^jJ tij^Sl JIAAI iT^i 0(

1 yM - a^^jS^t a iat attiji] a Jj Jt ai^t

. o U j i S J - ^ J ,v^QiM.^l Agibf j C : j .(^lj;>is.«(l * ^ j ^ AIJJKWI J j i i f O U l ^ l j

j - J ^ J i * (S^Ul j f a a UJl liUiilt J f i Ojai^b^t »Vja jTy. :0j..-UJ-1 •

j t i^^ -^ \^ if^-fl 'k.b jL^«pf J j « ^ .jjm-* Ojjfl*. i/if1 «-*:jjA 4; sj; : O J M A ^ I *

•tAi^J ^>^^ jy^^ t H " "^AiJ • J j-"^ ' i*^ i y ^ ^ Ojikife UL^fj t^^Uarl

j ' j ^ j ' Jijip c J j JU aitiiLi j i L ^ i ^ 3.L^ Ojsi9b4ll f-*iIjA AAMi :Oj«ilkll *

a-a5il J I P i } j ^ \ i Oj*jalij i*^jJl fljs>-1j taijul^ O j j ^ j . i .U i i uP (>-*

.lilijU JfiH\ j l 4 ^ gJaU frllA^t lj»»r-fli Of j C j l J-J .a^Si^l

ol OjOiji *Sl j ^ j f Jail a ^ I j i ^ oli jej*^^ (Itfffi wiil t's J* jt^-J. :0jia2ll •

. a i ^ j a«ij-j j * . d i J ^ 0 JWJIT? I.l .aiai^i j * U j^ ijTjOi (I ^ f ^s^ | ^ | j ^

OJSJ U gi i ^ I j tfrlj l Jili. ,:eai»wJl t^^ji ^A U 5alP :OjiUll jl O j ^ l •

Jj.A-J-1 ci Oj^jij la^oiii s-ijj a,LiiS i a ^ i Ojiji^^^ u Ji^j . J j i ^ Sj i*

.ajUicii j j*Si J U. Oj jS^j aj.jUj ^ ^

OjiJii i9>i .aplil oUi^ j (OjU.,0 a:iial aAjlT ai,M^ <S' OJUJH U SAIPJ :0j9ito£ t *

.iiUaJl J l l j U ^ Ji l OjljS^i U SilPj C i4 j } \ \ l ^ \ ^ U ^ ^ Ul,9-f dUij c ^ ^ l

f!>^>l J J U J aa^^ujljs^lj a -L^ ^ j

a-.i^ ^ j j .a iijU jfiHs 'j^\ tfi j o rjj ,1 li) ps-f jJUj! a-.^- t ^ j ^

2--i>ji u r .f^Ap i JJUj ^ JiiUJi a^u ' i l olfrij:r^ij t aM-l p^f^ J^^ j

a kfe)! a^f jp uint *i-»- i *- 4 CJ-USBJJ .p^^\ JiUj ^ OU AP i-tfi a ^

«>*jasj of ( ^ .( -APJI j ; u j ^ o i i ^ Aai-Jij a tfjii jsHs •j4f^ a^^^i

a_^^^i aokAaii Jl j r .UJJ (ft^irj a«kL« ci^ij^ s a s ^ aiuui JLIJ

.a-jTjrf j l av ji>Si OJSJ IIJUP ^ iMijfij aiiU» OJSJJ taa^- ij ai*uJi

j i j i l L-frii L-c (f jL-P i j ju j t j u r i i jp ajjiUi i-iijUi i -^ ol j ^ . ur

.a{tijU ^ S i ji4«t-v a*iJi o i i ^ i •,.7<* o U j i ^ j

jf a-^jS^i ou.iig.ri iUajt Ji* (Sjjta i oipjujvjLi a^gjt JLOS of j i ^ , ur

.a_^ j ^ , a !Ap i a-.gji Oj«, jiJUi } i ouu-i» JL5JJ ( 'g«^ 3i>*!ii

(O l j -P i j oU*U»r l ^ Jj.U=li ^jsall j ^ j l l jVt^lj ovij^r^l i-l^ of vJi.j

(J-J j l s -tii' cJjJtj a^jjj jJl f5Uyi JJUj O l j i l j Spfi'jS J J U J Ol jVj j

• f j.;pjLl J J_f\ ilT^a. j f (Ifiae-J i^^^"^ C&Wj 1*^^ aiiljlt »J la. ii' ' d-^l

(as:—-UL* a^^i a, ij%Mii ^ j ^ ajUi ojk^i o\ ta^^i 11. 1 ii^j OAJ

.{i!)U-pyi JJUj ^ i^ OlA?-Sl jubJ (aj\;!tt-'Kl i y j 4 j (JfJl ( ^ 3y i ! l j

aia^ J^ J* Sio^ a«iP o\i^ JiAjbl j^ul aiyrfj a^^^i a^s^iju^^i ^ j

j»:Ap t j j U j ^ O j u J i

Page 14: dJs'alliiMi - INTOSAI...^ J. - i^jS^i ajili i^liJi AJJJI Uifci Jp^li oVLaJVl ^^ Ifu OUl /j.CJVUJVi I i,s^^lji-lj l-W-i JIAAI a-> oUJl^lj frlfjUl ^ J-^ijJb ^jJ tij^Sl JIAAI iT^i 0(

Y.. =1 j,b - a^jS^\ ajiii ajljjil ajjjii u^\

of ou-.^j (ajlijll jfiH\ j ^ J«uii j jJi iupu* jik If;* j»>jAiij .aJ^ v*^i

a^UjU ^ S i j u ^ ^uuij ( jiai ijjti aiU. o ^ pfi i JLAJ ^ ouyji

. vjiiaii j ^ i J p a^^i ajuu jpi-j aii!!LL-.vii .•aji i jj*Vi M 2^^i aas jfljiu-i ^ j JLP ^ j

siiUaii J* apj*# jta^jJ Jp j / jJ i •

f |^VL3l j (|»iUUsAlj ( ^ \ ; fV^ l M-^J LS»WJ1^ aUuisll i-il^t^l OiJl^ •

taiurijli oWjj j ^isj J* aa-iuf JJUj atiff •

(Oltlj:rl iu£i 4 u^ l j f ^ ^ g^Uji iikse 2-i»j •

t iA^ ^ U j ( ^ Ji^o^ •

itfjj^^l oNl-jartl Ci\^i£ a i ^ l JiiJ/ •

.i^jfijA i j j ^ t^s asiji? og •

:f!)U5l JIUj J) ^ U j JUjl

.f^^i jn^j Jl dsiuj jUji JLP a*ai oijiain j * iop ui c^sj

JJU—J tj j - ^ a jft jp a^uf oujk. ^ fj i .f^^ii JA-,J aiyw Ji is^ * ^jf

juSif £_-;» (gu .ougli sopiij; OIPJJ?jli / vuilij iji j j^ij i:6ai»wJij f^^ i

Siwrljll V^ ^ ,fusA% IjtJar Ul jla (^1 a«rijii ^^1.^1 j»j:r gJ^j .^^j 6y

ouih/1 111 «^-g-Jj (ak..^ a*) f.i«u.<ii .au oii ut (Sj* i^iuii ^ijii ^uj^ c^

0 « ^ O U j U l jlA7 J f i M \ ^ (liitf .liUaill U i ^ j ) a ^ l ^ l j hor i jJ i V^^onil l iXiXii

apj^ afcip-1 ^ j i j t Jp jf a ijiji"! ^ ijJi ( Oj^jii Ojio^ii j l fUli ^ i j i i j ^

Olj—Pi J—(5l . ( , _ ^ (l*Jb- j t 0 ^ 1 J* j ^ l jalU 5alP d l l i O j ^ (Jiai^udJl j * i j b *

LAI* UJI .UMUI j i j^ ftUjjl aA«jK;li ig«*uSi oUjUi CASSS jf j^^ a:, O\PU;>-*J

O j - ^ j i l O j3>U^ l j t f U l ^ I j l l ^ s ^ j .affMiUt o U j U . c4dJ c& i ' ' ^ ' ^ oUj iU*

Ua-dt (*l:Sd: .,»iijg»i og- is i i f i j o i a ^ i (CJLSS) J j ^ i j je j j^ i Ji a ^ j l i Jft-j l i

.a«rijli ^^yj s-JlS^ 4 f^^i J^^j (^Vjif «;*JJ

S !& J—S^J -fi^ '^•i^ Jl »giV1 CJU fSP^I JJUj] tf jUta-1 Jji.^ jCj* .UP ^,

O U U s r JioP Ua f d ^ . .a*Ubj l ^ J ^ J I U j Jg^ j j J (MJI9-SI ftiA J U J * ialis.M'^l

fWi ^ i j i i \A\ j ^ i j j ^ j . j ^w> j£ j * J* a ^ j JJl 4^ Jy ^ f i ^T JiL-j ^ ai'\^i

•aii-'jii J p a^li^^ t ^ ^ i j ^ j jtyf-y o O j i - j t

j L _ ^ lj.ip OJSJ of (^jjj-ftii J * t r J T ^ J ' ' J * ^ J <^ jS'Jj t Jj5)l l ^ ^ j

oijs^uteii Jp Jj-sJi jefuj j ^ \ j M 4 ^^jii ijjjs; ol jSlfi .aiiijU JP^^I

.aju ijLi JUPI UiJL9- ur a jLUi

IT

P jUVl , u u 1 ^ 0 .bull

Page 15: dJs'alliiMi - INTOSAI...^ J. - i^jS^i ajili i^liJi AJJJI Uifci Jp^li oVLaJVl ^^ Ifu OUl /j.CJVUJVi I i,s^^lji-lj l-W-i JIAAI a-> oUJl^lj frlfjUl ^ J-^ijJb ^jJ tij^Sl JIAAI iT^i 0(

Y.. - Jib - a^jT^i aJiii a^ujl a j j j i ai^i

tf Uijji^ jiS' ajiAU-i hij^\ \fu^\

SjiMslI CJli^jU y jS^t al»Udt v=S^ '^i-A 0^1 <:; ^ ^-il^l

a-^^1 (c^ujjif) a uii jij*Si J P atiiji guii sj *w a^jiSi a*kii OOAP

jfj-aTl W Jl^ r J - J SjsiJi frUt ( lAj i l -ujitf^ tVjjsiji t r ^ J i^^ ' i*l*Jl

U j . , ^ . ^ ^ t a-uli a«iij^i VtAijil ojmr i j fUii ^ t j i v = ^ •Jusi^i . t»» A

a - j t u i a_^iiji g; j i SjfirSij ^aij^iSj^if aituJi aiJjJ gu)i Sj sr* ! j * i j i j

i..j^\^\ a-HisjJ iai«ii i j4^^ i j ' ^ j ^ ^ ^ ^ 1 ^ ^ j ^ ^ * 3j«^^ij (a«Ujiiv

aTjLtii J j j i cif f- j . ^ i j » j l / J iififjUi* aij i 0 % J* jsri oL i j f .ajujjJii

( l U ^ tOj^USi l t(/-Ujjjt tUl>-a! t>-l* l i / j j i tow 'U*Jl i*:ij^f tjIlji-1

a-HUj^ t j i j -«!r i j ' j * <t? * ^ y *^^^ ' J> - j l ' ^ i j i l 2 4 j j ^ tjjw^Si (^IjJi

tLUlil tWIsr tOjiVJt-l tgjaJ) iVj^l taaJlja-Vt \ ^ ij-A« ta^ljijfi.Jl JAJJS3I

iLU\:^jj* (J l -J t^J^^ (^;iJ^A* ( l ^ t1j|_^ t jTj .^ t g : / (jUai g ^ tUl^

tJU i -^1 (Vs-Ji^j j^jX j U JAJIjj fl-Uj( tgijjiJi iWa-U <Ja-*j>» <Oj*it

iiOifrjI t^;Jjj i j ; ry ^g i j j *Olij-Ji i\^,Ji\ o ja r (Je_jJi t O i ^ i j ^ £j«-V'

cf- o ^ i t«j'jj LftJi—• Ojjiijij f J j ^ i Jr- .*,?j(g»jj 'gj-'j t3j«ii a^uii

(js^ui c&o iji - *> ai i «JU (i^ujjf a ^ Sjig. (i^Ujs;^ iiuii aiuVt

.aiisi^ a^u a iji ouk.;*j

ttfUjjiSU ^ i i iU-l iflUJi i ^ l t^ OjTjum

i/ J^^ C^*^' '^'^ ^J^ ' ^ - -^ *i - ^ S - 'J JWiwVl J i ^ i j 3jijilj (U.jj;^j()

j i ^ J_* - J p tJS aa»J-l frJL^ i j ^ \ (f ^ j l l iJU oli i j i jil jSijSU X ^ l ^ I j

tf UjjiSu J i S a iU-i i*wi aadjt-i

Page 16: dJs'alliiMi - INTOSAI...^ J. - i^jS^i ajili i^liJi AJJJI Uifci Jp^li oVLaJVl ^^ Ifu OUl /j.CJVUJVi I i,s^^lji-lj l-W-i JIAAI a-> oUJl^lj frlfjUl ^ J-^ijJb ^jJ tij^Sl JIAAI iT^i 0(

r . . 1 jdb - a».jS^i aniai a^uj) asIjoJi ai^i

Oi-l J«ij=Ilj ' Juai U i j j j lSjj l ailil" i J i U l gSijif o j y r ^ j i j ^ j(U

aijjoiJi^ sopii" a iifi, OjSl»-i oisli IJU ot 4 j-Mi j p a a ^ i iji>ii J^P ."u.*f

".gSi f SjUi aiUjj i>)i sj^Sii arj=.x.

i4-_:iVj a_9^i ttfi-jjiVi trs^jj j ' j i (/J o j ^ f u)t ^ i j i (^^ji Jijij j>Pj

A.—" j ^ j •'ij j ' i jx J j - ^ ' ' j ^ > ' j ^ y 4 C ^ ^ ' r*'-** <iJ ^ - > ^ ' ^-**J^^

i j u c (AsiVj a'jsi 6 * ^ tf UjjJ^I O l j i i l j i iU j W j i i i ^ J J f i i j i j i l i ^ j (

afaiUi ^ j sW* i tA*> cii tjsrja* ^^^ <y iS^j^H a*uii aju*:i\ j i i -.ilii

dL-Jl ^ ^ j -< 4BJ1 JSJSIJ .JjUll ^ U ^ l jklkJl iUsPtj ( fUj j iS aB;!iflJly-.Vl

tJuli i ^ i Jp aflrtUi a*jSL*-ij ia,s ;ijwVi akiH jjjiaj ^ J 1 a ui ^^jiVi

. jjup aii\i-i ao»Jri aiUK-*i wSijil o>ar a*jS j

^Olj j ^ j j -gJl a^Sj Sjai J ^ kjf^J^^ OUJisJl Jjai; ( t*9t*> " W ' "-^j^'j

J ^L> ttfU-j j iSt (j AJl-^Ul \jiJLiJ j I j i ^ i OjS3 aiUJJ J P V I } ^ f ^ 5j»>

V* i [f f» *g* i - ^ JtfUjjit Uji gr*j ^ij^ oxij .a^ui i i i^ i oi jUi

a—aPUi-l U i j ^ tj if j?!-f ail i j ' ^ ^ t l **^ u*-^^ tt^L-jjiV W j ( i-»*" Ait

(*^' >.j«if Jp UJ?- i i i ^ ifWi g_iiuJi ,j aifUiij aiUjii otSCfi ij a/uULj

Jl JxUi Sjig. JtJ (a^^Vi lAftii u i c j^ i ^ t usif jSJj tu^jii

JJ—?«ill J^L-!^ J* a^UllI Jfli^j j i ja$j ijfijH^ j ^ j t j i i l l 5Jb- j * uiatowil

J Y • U ^L_P (^1—-jSjj ot Lttif j jt*a,*jJ V J l j ip t j " .a,SijiSl SjUll ^ U i

.a iijiVi 3j^i J -Uu t Ujsi] jCj* Jjf O j ^ (Wi j l s^>^ 'rji-JUj;^

aUif tt^^jT-^^ljJj:? iS^y Cwai- .aoiUIrl ^ U J J P OJJPJIII OjJjbull ^ ^

j j - j j .dg*—sii (j t • • V jj*iji ^^.>sii Jp *i^t (^ujsjy i*u)i a uVi

C-Jj^ jm ^L—<j5JJ a^ 5jig» of *i^Uji:it XgA^ djig. jif t^jji ^Jiys:\Jk

ur toijoiii i i \Siji g j i ij^V) dapUw* Jj sr josii j * \^pj^ S g^v j i

(/li i i jT.r ^jiJLJj . r . 1 . -T . . A 5 j - j i l i LtfUjjif aikd aUi* iiitis- *:«

{hj-Jj (f!sip)fi j ju j i aiJjJ i»uii Sj4*rVi ^ a^l J-i Si t uJi (.uii ^ i j i j

jiiJi) j l j i l l g_U/> J p jirtdi f Ap l JJUj ^ Jui jSLii J*iii! SiOrf ob-ljdl

.(iOJl liA J * ^ jjP 4iiJl»- _^ut J p JUll

3» l t>p t^o*^ M>^ ^ijjfJt- a^ j i i ajij?*ii fU)i i---ii i i j l i i* j j o u j ^i^o^j

j r i j ( Ull ^ I j l i,.aSl*j LAjit OJ;?: ajdl Sjljj JO flOosUl oVUaTilj j jUJ i

^ 1 oifrUiii UPUJ .fUii i j i i i 'i s i Jfi isJ^ vt s^ <^ijji-^i «>u of

fij;s-ij Jigii ( AiisJi jij«j Jp {lUii i j i i j a_jai Sjijj jy aui 4 J J ^ ^

if ujjiSO j . ^ aiiU-1 a*u]i a,^!

Page 17: dJs'alliiMi - INTOSAI...^ J. - i^jS^i ajili i^liJi AJJJI Uifci Jp^li oVLaJVl ^^ Ifu OUl /j.CJVUJVi I i,s^^lji-lj l-W-i JIAAI a-> oUJl^lj frlfjUl ^ J-^ijJb ^jJ tij^Sl JIAAI iT^i 0(

Y.. ^ ^>. - a -jSLJ-i ajai ^^ji a ijaii ai ti

sjjy aiJUjj anjfiy ^jTj (a«j9ij oiiujij i ^ Sjiii om^j tifw j r j^ijiJ

.(i ua* j ^

rt^Ujjif JUPI

Ijw ii»jj ajaj;i akwl JP tSUjjiS i/i-iail tr^' jij^ i^t^^J iT^J!^ J^J^

.jai

jl»_?^ ^--i Y * • V f1__P ij i/JLttiait ^ 1 OiUJ l i S ^ j / i l^ l jS^Vl aiai-l •

a-JaaS- ^—J9j ij if Ujj i t OJLPUJI a , « ^ t/4j^^' ^ * i>* J4.J**« *>*^ i/jUa-»l

if;? jji- aub>- T»> > ip aku oiijijf oir i/jUwVi js^i ja?-j .a9:!.Bj!js-.i

2_- . OjUJi ct-*^ cai.UJl ajuSi Olj^l PW :^jt J1 } H c J j ij (/JLaiJl ^;Jl l

otjjujii ftL-^j i»uapSi aiiijii gull i j ^ ^ i t^\ oijiili »U! ia Mli oi Jei

,jUU ^ aiiU-1 a ^ i J arjUii ijijii C J J ^ .^^JS iJuJi i j ^ ^ i r -^p

a*uJt aiuSii ^ j i i ^J l jijc J p oiiij«r * n u) a^^ijuVi ak^i JUIPI

i j j .OUML.KU.1 OiXU aiU-* ^ J-.UJ1 JUiXMil ^Usrl ' ^ CJitj i t fUjjiS

. t fUjj iS j^uMi flkJi J f i o ^ a i J J p ajijii c i i i j ij-oiw c^>tf

tfUjjil ai# jij^ ^ j , j ^ tJ aiiljl jp*:ji ji Ji-i jji :auuJi tsujjit ai:f •

.a«Ujiiij igtjtS\j aijaisjyii i ^ j j i i s ^ a,M>iuJi aiukJi j * U u ot (ai*uJi

l / V j ^ O j ^ t(g^U flP ^ I j * ) dg^JUir UjaJ ^ g j ; ^ ^Oi :tfUjjif jijliJ •

tfU—jjit a k s ^ t j P jijliJ t(^^jJ flP ^ \ y ) ij^i' Sjilij i(Ojiiflr ftp ^ l y )

ia^-Ujiiii aituii aiUji guii 8jf;r* ij taejaiSj ii aituii aiiijU gwi 5j^50

.jijsii Jfi a^jJii aifcuii aiUjiJ guii ij^H^j

afluii oUjjsjli t^'jj*

a«rly : J» ^ ' y 33^ J y U J J P i S ^ j j H j ^ ajiU-i a*Uil l ^ \ o*kJ

UsUil Sj^srSl j j3 j 4Ji*^l frUpSli Ji»Ua»-Vlj cu^jJailj tSjIi^l (a*uli a?w^i

oUwJu i ^ j a-iip ouJbr (j £ >i»y j r j ^ y ^j .iUJii a ^ i ^ ij aiiljU

J—• UAji^j 1,-^^jii *iij7.ji ij a ^ i j a^i liUaiii oLii ajijii oVji^j

l ^ a - , i j i^gSiU j i j j i ^ air-jjil ^ i j J J <JJ9A1I OjJa*»sll j U a J -JPjy^^

JAL^-^I ^ ^ _ * ^ I ^ u - t i j ^ y ^ \ jUjf 4iA>t oy*- a*uii oiiUJ-1 oiA-

a_»Ull a—aftU-l ox»aPlj . j i jUUl oyurljl - 4**? tjiji j i ^ J j t ^ j '0*r ' j*iJ

.anwi ^ i j l i *i* jr*A- og<»y ^^uait t ii i iijil ojar oilUri

tf y-1 JUptj dJbr «.Us l (OIMS)!

a-,MJei oiiijj .J-4Aj»- i/JL Aj (jJLf a ,^ ! o.,9«aJi (a*uit jup^t aubr J ^

tf ujjiSu jU' aiiU-i a-uit a itj i

Page 18: dJs'alliiMi - INTOSAI...^ J. - i^jS^i ajili i^liJi AJJJI Uifci Jp^li oVLaJVl ^^ Ifu OUl /j.CJVUJVi I i,s^^lji-lj l-W-i JIAAI a-> oUJl^lj frlfjUl ^ J-^ijJb ^jJ tij^Sl JIAAI iT^i 0(

Y.. 1 Jib- ~ a jS i aj\ii aiUji a j j j i aia i

,/jgiail jJ^iuJl Ojyi-^l pUiP^lj .Isiijit ^jar Jl a-iUjil JlisJl Jfi f^^^l*

U j j t (^^Jl ^isll U^l ) OjiW I { raJjU JjSl UUl) j\jl i^s o / -.fjfc

iOiiy^ij tLuWjy (j aiiiji gull sj^^i ijijii ii.,Aji ur .(^uii c(^%

jlfJrl *l/tf i^j .i/Jlaiail ^_r^li y l jJj g^lsr Jl fUAJ jU Ojj^lSlIlj J U U l j

ij JASMO-* jy\ij iauui tfUjjii ai# jij4 ^ j ojg^v j ^ ij aiiijii jp*ii

JU.J jUijA-i J* js:i aill J) ogu^i oiji^i ^A^^J .(/J,iaii ^ i ( a*a i

Olj1j_511 U ^ j j*-li U/j j ( 0: ,Pj . j y j U r j ^ j gjaJi ^ i j ^ l j * l/jL^li

. g / j ( O j ^ l ^ t j tWlsijj* IfftPOa-ij

J^U>- tf UjjiSU ja i ^ j l l ji?j«wl oi i^iaiail j ^ l of 4 t««*jJ V-il j j i j

jijij iUspi Jp 1*1*11 aa*Jt-i oiiij .(juj i aj u* j p jiijj ^ji't \ r g u ri

jj_Jp ttfUjjif 5 ^ U l J^jA jll?l ^ j l i/JLaiisIl jJanJl ^ j l \ ^OiJj JiftKrlJI

Olj-U-iJl ftUl aJrj Sjblj aalU aJr frUJl J p Uoit aB*Jf Oii^Jj .ajuaj J*Jl

.agMM-jll

.OjiUr ij t * M flip ij cf UjjiS yt^ ajiiil a*uli a,M4-i JinaMij

4juplj ^.jit ojJe fuil ^ijli JJi J* ac / aigi. o/jUii j i j ^yjli Jijt

WsAiti lAjit ojar aim j * cJii Jfi <Jj^ij ti^rjUi uiij-si lyia. j riJi

gj.lj—(J I JB—-j*j c ^ ^ ^ \ fiii tf ill (-iiOJji jli ij a - t a*lil f Jf jP

jPj—p j _ ^ ijijU ajjiil CJH I lyjii v ^ l t j .aiSaAii ij>\i a^ a^^jj

j ^ ^ j U l l ciflJall IPJ ((ils^l Ji?- Jil ftj;^rj .LAjil cjjrfl j J l j J Jjai ^

Oj U tiil-*-Jl lAjil uysr ^ ^ j a*lli y * ci ^ y J i ^ j i ^ j ^ U P aiiU

,yj j_jJl i iJUi tj L-c t t^Ujj i^ jJ;^ h_i\k\ a*Uil a9»*: 1 J P O U J U * ^IsJj

iOU-ijUi J* Oijlj .http://afreosaiasseinbly.coin :t5lp tJijj^ij

:tf UjjiS a*Ull aiU li JUflT I j ^ j i

+218 21 444 06 30,444 81 71 . ^ l i

: y j y ^ ! -^.ji

[email protected], afrosai@libyansai,iy.org

^^

tfUjjiSO fXfi aiiU-i i«uii a njui

Page 19: dJs'alliiMi - INTOSAI...^ J. - i^jS^i ajili i^liJi AJJJI Uifci Jp^li oVLaJVl ^^ Ifu OUl /j.CJVUJVi I i,s^^lji-lj l-W-i JIAAI a-> oUJl^lj frlfjUl ^ J-^ijJb ^jJ tij^Sl JIAAI iT^i 0(

r-'^ JiLi- a,»jS i aaiitt aitiji ajjoli ai i

iimmmt^^miimmm^KitfKmmmmi!^^

i/Ujsi)! ^jn^iju>i*i\ Jajbi^t SjiXi i f^ j j^ t j u ^ riiupj

i^ljil ij tfli*il sJU ij IjsST AjJUi t^^ y j i\a\^ J * lOr fU cUl:r JUlTil

i / j _ ^ 4 ^ 1 OUjUJJ y t U l jiOall OjA Sla -I JaAa. Ol c juflll j * 4jt a^jAl

j _ r Jr^ij aikiii o\ (iiili Jp 5jr)Uj .aiiwsJi t3>ii j * j i ^ ul i^vy

i iUjV Uiyu J ^ y J* jSUsi (i U c jU;r AJ t / J *Vji^' * ^ ' c K ^ J > ^ '

• W l isrW (A JiJJl

^ u i i ^ a^uSi o u U i J f i i^Ujai^ a„s ;ija.*Vi aW-i J* Ulsll c>aAl ^ ^

I-U jlfcl (j og^,rly-i^t t5-l»-lj .a>*;rU i^Ujail cjjiffr i^l OjUdlj tarjUli j

OJlPj U r j .JUil Oaiuall J f i O^ UTSU a^^^ lja-ilj i - g - jijIaJ j y t ioi l

aiji ot i lv- ayUll lift tj o^^UflT I jP d .U-1 i j l cal l J * j>* i l i i J i (j

Jjt jAiili O.UP - U SjJaP OjTt (^1 - O ' I IUJSI aa;^;lja-*l! t^Ujsil J*P

a—jr jaii) r •. A jwUy ij u usri

oU-*jU« tf—^ Jj.dMJii 1 ^y j i j ^ t

.(i^uarij j*Ji aiji jp a u»i

a.;!«aJlji_M.l J-_*P L J j i C—?-JBII OIJ

j U ^ i - u=A':Ai ijiA 9Jii o i ^ u ^ i

^ y - e j / j « l f ^ i K * £->^r J^ ^ ^

.^ j l i -1 (luil ftljl (^IP (/Ujsll 0*:(Ltfl

ia_i j-4y«ii aur tj j ^ i j^iji JPJ

^g-lfi J*Jl aiji 0*-jall taiifcl J* iOJl

j i ^j—-fiJS OJ—Ti ot ttfJLoiall ^^Ji l

u-fcai o L j ^ i ftjjj tj a,*jSJ-i aj«rijii ajrAia-i a^t y r • • ^ fui aijij^i

a»/t j i y j i^Ull jlx« J p ^>Jffjl' l i * a*kd1 ftUopf j_;iiLi - J' J .iig-*Siij

w

ijS^lj-^*^! i^\ Jf, tiyi>\

Page 20: dJs'alliiMi - INTOSAI...^ J. - i^jS^i ajili i^liJi AJJJI Uifci Jp^li oVLaJVl ^^ Ifu OUl /j.CJVUJVi I i,s^^lji-lj l-W-i JIAAI a-> oUJl^lj frlfjUl ^ J-^ijJb ^jJ tij^Sl JIAAI iT^i 0(

Y.. »i Jjb - i9*jS^i laJvi i liiijU a,JjJi ai^i

t a^ j jUl o\.- i.ijJ3 Ua-^l 4>-S^j (a«Ml PUAPS a ^ l i Jaii j ^ 3 ^

|J_A aj!)Us_--Vl JP aitSlllj f^\ J p ( Slw j r ^ t j .flP *:rji jjf-^lj

jju!-i_;-Ji a isis—.rii a -^ t jP aij i oU ju* |C^ Uit iji ^ ^ ^ J J « uit

i, ^—i»ili ^ ^ J \ ij ^afrgoi iUgJ Ol o i r ^ 1 - O*^UJVI ai - o^nur^i

j ^ ii/Ujdi ij o*iUJ^i a^ui OUAI .fljb^ij ajuii i^Ujsii hk Ji ifwiij

i-_i\iji u-aUJi i j^^s JA M '-ijSM c i j ^ a«kM aii>i uoi ^ i Ji ^u^

a—Jji a *liT* U?- (/Ujail J«r ij a,^j!l ^ U l l J^\ y Jur^l .PUIP^I

.i«=riy

Ctfilj—ii J—sic .a„-fcfeill ^jW-j Jss-li aijdll J^jsi aii> Jajwtll ^\3ai ^

ic^j^Si aiUji guii 3j^Si a^u i ai tj (COAJ i ^ ^ j a^iiji guii sj^Si

jt ta, .ft iU J.,->b tfA\ ;Jl>Si J* U ^ jl ( J ^ l j j i j (JAJI o\Pj*if jl

^J-lfi Uil fltJl lift AAa-»i of JSJ: . ^ J ^ \ |IUil Jl ol.y*ll J i l Ot jSic

(h-^ Ot js:c (iUUi Jl aiu^iij. js:r ajtdi ^ui ij jt ^ > i u^jui

-iifl** M li J^W J ^ 0*^1- 1 ^U tSJU f' l

J—:> ti Jl.tf T*all ^>-P aijiUl OUlaSllI Cii4^ ih^LfLl\ fliaJ pUJl tj S j l a ^

^^ij a«Mi ^ji^ JA OIPU^IJ (i^ijA£.rii jSlc Ul juaT^i ^'yij f-i^^y^l

.^ia^KU

(? , ^ 1 JUaJVt Olyi i a*;il i;,(U»j t ^ i _ ^ l ctfjs^ j P i j ^ tf jliil plkp^j

;Jlail j ^ l J p l^jbi- j i M \ J>-li flO^ UM^ UJi^^

a jS: ! ajilt aiii^ ajjJt aL t •

a^ijJi ouU-ij o i y jll •

cjyj^t asui Jfi aiiiji u*ii sj^Vi ^ i j * •

i:uij=i » aSUi J p a ft yi oMi ^ l y •

a i kUi ougiij Ijin /\\i o iy jll •

a*uii 01JJ.U1 •

a.^1 a , ^ i t3tjj*ii ij iMfi* \j o^uii •

•i^jj^'i\ JijJi j ; u j j oiiiiiiH •

U^ i\^jy- W jS^j aJoAt j>-b .kii ^ (lOjT a«.f. Juoji sul l i aid i

a-j-uli o i j_u i t 2 _ ^ ^ (UP t > OJSJ ot Uit ^ \ JA j T i j .a iifcli a^wij

iCJyi)!l a—SC^ ^ I j * a t Oil JSI .O'jlUaJ^I ^pr h>'£ JLP a^bt-j tttfji^Sl

aa:SaJlji * l alajH J p plj^f

Page 21: dJs'alliiMi - INTOSAI...^ J. - i^jS^i ajili i^liJi AJJJI Uifci Jp^li oVLaJVl ^^ Ifu OUl /j.CJVUJVi I i,s^^lji-lj l-W-i JIAAI a-> oUJl^lj frlfjUl ^ J-^ijJb ^jJ tij^Sl JIAAI iT^i 0(

Y.. 1 ^b - aa*jSli.i ajm aiUji ajjJiii ai i

ag—-J J-a—it a^ijJi ouju-ij o i y j i i OJSJ of og>-* i j * jssr j j JSJ:J

a -JnM Jj> li a.ip!A* X^ yjjs^*^' • J^^ cP'-JJ * ^^^ f .dlsiUj J^js!

frUapSi J* (•Aji j o&«!-ijii ajpjJ ui£ a^u a i i a ^ i t5ijj* » tj o*iaij

.LUP Jp jvjyiJl

:aarjl^l O^Uif^t J t-l J* aaJ l aiilyUl OUill oVUtfV lUUJl 5>Jt ^jsiJj

a nij Ji oitii / ouiljji •

a^jS^i*

jjf*A-lj pf i^ i JJUJ •

aiUjl •U:P\^\ oifjui •

alilll o i ^ i •

C ^ J l ftUiP*^l •

aS^.jjJl oUiaAl •

a^Uij a ^ ^ i awrijlt oi r •

a^i j i a«rijii oitA •

^i3H ^\^ \ j ^ Lftwrijlij a^i ogu^i •

^ . * j iUaM r j l^ aiii^ti..ll oUiil ^ \ aei^jJJl o i ^ l OJSJ of jyaffUl j ^

ij _^_kJl OiP jUP'il tj cfy»-l ^ t > t ailiji g j l 3j^*il ^ ot JMi ti i i i

o L - ^ l O J _ S J ot jS^. ijlilt J a ^ t ^ .U JUnU a:?-;?* o^ry i^f i'lfJt-t

a-^t j.jtrf a^ai o i ^ i ^L,^J toujUii JUM*:! IJI^ h ^ aiiiji aju>\ i

cf U—jsll «-UL-pt ^- - ra^ aij«11 c^ja.^ ^ j ! a> j^ i ^ I j J l Jijfi t j O O P U U I

.t^lal tf ja-j:

( J U P a -^ jS^ l ai«j-1jll Sijsr ( H ^ l j JxjiifliJl Sjgr O*^UJ*^1 J - . ^ ot jSlc

LTltUtfli .iijisil t a^*^ <^^y)l ^J4^ ^jA^ i^J i>^ 4 JlPUJj c J l P t liaJ

Oj^^-iij ailSC* jjtfj (i^f^t Sillj jlyil c^JUJ aa*jSU-1 aiuct^l OUUaAl J&J

f->Il 8j^*^l J* j r J p ^Ull g^jyj ((/Uj;ilj ailiJJ g j l 5j^*il tf iIji

.(/UjsJij aiijji

3j_ aA-i a s aiij:—-Vl ay-i jijkr 4 f ^ i JP L-^ru cajuti j * ji^ii i P tj

iUUli 4_jii j-rijw aiuUi JjSi j^jj^i of ^jjt .t o n JlY . U J* Syiil

.AjLtj OL^ Jfi Jj.a^ Sjs^J Sj^

t astnipgrechnxangshof .gv.at :^^1 ^jlli ^ JU^l ij iijS *i

a—y-1 ,i j'r^ a gur.u jJuii JP OUJ** «iJap) jf j>sti tj (-^y o.:r lit

.t/UjslV hpiL^^J^^^

l^y^ij^^i ila^\ Jfi ^\j^\

Page 22: dJs'alliiMi - INTOSAI...^ J. - i^jS^i ajili i^liJi AJJJI Uifci Jp^li oVLaJVl ^^ Ifu OUl /j.CJVUJVi I i,s^^lji-lj l-W-i JIAAI a-> oUJl^lj frlfjUl ^ J-^ijJb ^jJ tij^Sl JIAAI iT^i 0(

Y.. ' ^b, - a^jS^i ajm aiiiji a j j j i aL i

UJijJjBfi' ( JLil tf Jsiail ^ ^ 1 ^Usrl

> r ^ ^ j i t U U l i tUai t j i^L-jaiJ J w ^ l j j * l i l l c f JUail ^ 1 f_Ua?-l JLiP

5j—j^rSl t5*i^ a^i / ^ 1 tUpf , ^ j i i£_U»rVI J ^ j . Y . • A j u j y > £ j

Sijijit ^jiisii t J j u - aj.uii iJjjLii j j J aiU»uLri!>u so^ ajisC aiii^ guii

t3j_J frUJlj if Jail U-O-l jiT^I liUaiil J*JI OlP_^ j Jrt l l f } j j OlsiJll J*

L T ^ ' i j ^ J Sji*^* •^yi l i ;^j . J ^ l cfUJSJ^U ^ 1 ^ ^iJj. J i i>k^ J*P

i /Uj^l (JULftt cf Jlaial' t r ^^ frUapl f Ji iOj;«-ljt t^i ^;*Jljijt j j y j t c5«Mai\

.OlPjA^I cjlajtf 5JW Jp I j iyJj

t>tuu ^_*af J* aiJji gJi Sj^^i ftUjj J* u - C^-UBI* cr^ ' *iApt

S J U J *P J j i j (J*Ji olPj*:?j o M i Ojlsc Oj^iiy ^ 1 ^ \ - (/UjsJl

Jl aiuu^^ii .a—lUi UUill j * apj^^ oUi J i ^ i jjiosiij a^uli j * ouji

aiU^U a i j U l jijliall JUaPlj (jUfcl (lia-tl c JlJlA^l j P 0 ^ 1 p U j j j * j i j l iJ

.aL i oJUj (i/Ujsii a ^ 3jig.j (ituii

i^iLijt Jp aiiO^ oug , j . i 9^ tSjb^ij ajilt a u ^ ^ ^4^ a*u[ JJ

J—*p j j i j la^iii i' Jt-i J* Jiytfii ty a-tfbt j i j i i j (lOij ta^m aui jtsu-

O U ^ I ^ ; ^ Ji_^l f j ^ ai> ^ j i j j i i j i jisj. (lOij .^lj=^*!/l -kja^l

5j*u_ai ^Uji ^ y ^ j^ \ i \ oiiusi Jl j*iJi aiji jyw jP Jjiyj iarfi\ii

.aili_^ g j l 5j4:r^l (^J

i l iU-ri j / j (,^ljaM.^l JagkAall JAP tJiji Uit ^_ tji t^ill t j j b jJ V ^ l f ^ j

( jU l j Jj ^ ^ \ oli i\it IjijiJ ( i /Ujd^ ^ l ja- .> I l JajbiJl 5jiJ^ t O j y - l

a_<«?.iy (lU^t J* ^jii a^iu-i 2,p^\j^'i\ ay-i v:^i»«! J*P aiji a^y js

L-«r (/L-MIJ:EII iJlJlAfj ta i j j j i l ^ Jt£M* (Jb^bull ^ j J p .l4U«>^ ala^l

jiat jybj Of Ju»-i J* ^ j i J f i laki-i cuo^ tj ^ U J aaiin aijiH tj O l;?-

.ajHj i JIUASI J * OS-IJ j r ( pju ^1 ^ i j J i j akwVi

l*Ult aJUVl JUpt Jp IjijiJ ti/Ujai^ fUil j ^ ^ l i j j ^ c i i j j r j j s r j l f J j j

. Y«* V f^ dg..>Sil i j OiP (/iil t ^ ' ^ l j ^ U l t ^ i ^ l ^ ^ 1 ^U»rl ^

o lp j—i^y a^ j J l ftUp^U a^k*^ a--iy aiu^l o i i i ( Y * * A ip Jiijt t j

. j U l l i i 2j!k^ («Uit jlail) J j J i ^ > (jHl ^ I j l l .filiJl y j j i

^JUiat t f is idl ,j..,L>i*lil ^Uufl j^T i j OUbJil OUOiOj l J U l is f i j ^ i^^ii

l^ljLlj aAail (^1 J U l t ) - ^ f Jll UT .,^J:Ull U^akijt oUi OUg (l>J^t

Y.

Ji.1 ^

Cf U-j^^uU*^

cfUj=iVl J ^ b

Page 23: dJs'alliiMi - INTOSAI...^ J. - i^jS^i ajili i^liJi AJJJI Uifci Jp^li oVLaJVl ^^ Ifu OUl /j.CJVUJVi I i,s^^lji-lj l-W-i JIAAI a-> oUJl^lj frlfjUl ^ J-^ijJb ^jJ tij^Sl JIAAI iT^i 0(

Y.. ^ ^.b - a^js:j-i ajui aiJji a j j j i ai^i

pl aJVli -uljallj 4JUU»s-l jP I j i y i i \ ^ j \ o ja r Sil^ii iTnHJl gUll i j ^ ^

i j . ^ ^ j ^Usri J j t ai«i .lAjit ^ y r 4 j i j ^ ^ cfUjSj^l J ^ J U P I J *

t a ^ j i i a^j l i oijAjll t ^ i JU l tjiji foij . Y • • j - j i * tj laiij*! ^ j ^

4_*ikjj itfuuu^a^i J f i aaiijii c J j JUPI JP IjijSj ' ^ ^ J J ^ ^ " ^ * * ^

• T * « ^ t)^j{l J o^^ J cM l 4PU»r* -LijtHj . JU l Jak i-j 4UPJ (J^toil

cU<Tii.il o1!li-i Q * J ^ 4 J t ^ ^ ' 3i»- ^ J^ U y ' >-^'-^^' iJt- t W j P' J

jUaJl .OLJ^UI ftUjj j i j l iJ J U l olPjftj^j 0 : li1 J*P i j J J* SiOrf j i jUi

.JUl o\p_^j Jyl i fliA J*p Jp oUjUli J* Oijl www.intosai.org

3.-9-b* i Lutis j 1 ^Us:ri oi»iyi j*is^ a^ifJi a^^i iiuii ajuSi ^

.(jJj-UU a^-^aljil oljlyll Jl jam oUit ^^asUj i dlli Oj-at tj .Ujl

L-Ajii ^j^- •li'v- s?"^' liirfj-ijJi cii-»jSJ^ a^-^jli ^b^ijli ,r^i AJU- •

Oji—M.tj iiaiijil vyA- fUli ^ijli i(^^t*«*y tr-^ "^^^ ili. Y O . fiP

ji^i i^lji) aiUjU guii 3j^5AJ iJijiiij M* :a9ii3ii ^ijii JP tjwvi jp

j^i-i \4.«.tji j_^i) a*iaUi a^ij 2^\ a«rijl.ij tcVAjil '^y^. ^^J^ J^^^

.(CftUii aiiijii J P S I

J—ftP aU j i ;JL I U i l i Ull OliiUodll A;rly ^ t a^rj^t WUaiii ail;!u^lj •

flju* • j - ju i i oiiVjlii ajlijii JPVI ji4Jri t/ij i -->>-j .aj uii a iai a*j^

i / j y i ' j <k^J^ WWl 3j4ar* l j j i j MjH\ og- f Js* l iU i JjUsw ^^\ cal j i l l

.SiViUl

CJ—^ t>iljj ti/Lrijai^ a j l J l j ao^rjl i O V U J V I -JI-IAI J f i ^ 1 ^ I j •

,^-Jp*l!l jl^A-l aj^Uwl a^^f" Y • • *\ fUi i/Uj:3l ^ j i » j * OjSli oli Vj=J'

.' dg.».<iij W o u ^ i i^jii ur aiiijU :(/UjalJ a Ull 2i\A% JUT^I jyrji t OUyjill j * Oijl

[email protected]: ;^jjs^^i Mj^

www.intosai.org : OJJSJ I ^ y

ojuisli oit*:ijlij itiiji^\ aifriUi L;^ JA ^\ji Ciji jfi\ss

obVjiii a(i*jS i aiftUii I.UU J* r^iji Oji Jipiij

.a_,sCij* i a*jS^i ^ uiP r i , ^ 1 ot .Ui soMaii

c«. Ull J* J^Ut i j t l ^Ar flP J* ftlOsil Oji J*P

. j jo i i Ju7*^i c ^ . a^jSl^i aiftUii CUJ: aiis4i

jkJblj 4 ^ ^ ( i * ^ ^ Y tf UJSJI ^Jaa tj JlPUj

a jQiT ojig* Sjbi j_;U^ u,.rij* ij.iap oirj (a.«. u]i

Y

tf Ujsi^il J^ l i

Page 24: dJs'alliiMi - INTOSAI...^ J. - i^jS^i ajili i^liJi AJJJI Uifci Jp^li oVLaJVl ^^ Ifu OUl /j.CJVUJVi I i,s^^lji-lj l-W-i JIAAI a-> oUJl^lj frlfjUl ^ J-^ijJb ^jJ tij^Sl JIAAI iT^i 0(

Y.. 1 Jjb - aj jS; i ajdi aiiijU g j j i ai i

^ t 5y!-Sl ajj^l ( j j , ^ \ siA j i j ^ ^ j i \ ^ ^ \ ^ \ f i hA lOirj .i/Ujail

JA—Aj i/!s;'j^^i h^si i i/Ujsii j*p aiji J a -jSIi-i aiftUli < ^ j j i

ft^jUi J* OiUi Jjit j .a«*jS i aiftUli c,.^. afljjl oii%iii jiO* ...••tf *

t ^ i aUuiii a dJiiUij a^i oiirAJi OUH i/Ujsii ^ tj j u i j ^ j ^ t

.aJaJl C IJAI Jsi^ Uj9j

[email protected] : ^ - ^ y j ^aU^l j i j ^ ^ j "Oji" y - . j j i J i j y U ^

.ddrach49@conicastnet :"Oji" ^yj

a^ui amrtjt otdUj^ a^Pjiii h^\

JjVl £_U-<»sr*rfl (Y • . A j i j - ^ r t i j t(/jjS3l ^j^sisllj a«rlj l j M J U a - l

^—I ,^-U £_UarVi J OjTjUii tjiij .ajUi ai«riji obUij^j ajjiil aa ji

obujkjl j a : ! j^uii a^ ii a^ijtt oguJi au^uj j>yi a«up oijrju

a*S> uijAui O j - j .ajai a*!riji obu&j^ j . a u i (»JUij ija^ aiur jii

ajai a«rijii ob i i j ^ a^Pjiii a.u!ait j^uari tY.« H j i j i l tj a^jjjVi j * r i j i i

j i j - ^ f ij / ^ - . - ^ i a-(iljU t^Si j i ^ i u,j«-^ J ^ j i j . J ^ ^ j ' sJ

. ^ J i r - ^ ij ajai a*rijLi oiiu.j^ a Pjiii aa aii g_u»ri CY . . ^

pljsi"\ o lPU»rl

ol jTj-^ J* a p ^ a^g^ ^\ff^ agidt aji;rijii obUj^ a^pjiii ai aii ^

ftijs—i-l t3ji ty t} '^^ J ^ V^^ j •3iirti/' tf* »iji^ Jj i i.La A.riii oUjUli

J* apj*if Jp j/jsil JAP jt-»t 3J1 ftijiflS- au^j aiiijf ijy wu ta^iin'^i

.ou ui.1 oijri*

Y« * A j i ^ i j U tj ta^^Uil jk£:i>lj i j l ^ \ ^ \ lAaAA\ fttji^l aIji iUtoiri

( V. 01 V • • piijt ajcfijU ajjjji jsiuui oujui i o i j r i * ^ j j ^ ^ j i

(J i j - J i j ijur j j j aiiijii g j i i j ^ ^ \ JA ^ij^^ 4^ J^IAJ .VY . J t V^ .

.A^MJI o\i*JjItj

£—-^j^ i^j4^y—^ tj ^ * * jiW ^ a.x'iUi a .n ix- di ^i j i- i aiji CJto39 lJ

toY. t a> . i d O f l l j t a v l j U anljoll jaWil oU jU l l o i j T i * ^ j j ^

ftij)->-i-_i\ijU gU ia j ^S i J * f r i j >a*g -a l Ia^^^ J j U j . a i . (©r.

.5u»J(l o i i l l j l l j t j u^ l j tlJjTj (JijijJi J j J

ya i aiB iji o b u i j ^ aa jiJi ajs iii ( ^

J U iiUU UMil tfjirl t f ! - j^. (•oiJ jufl^ i Y . • A Oiyf- tj ^ ^ j J l i b j l CftP

YY

tf Ujsi^l J^l i

Page 25: dJs'alliiMi - INTOSAI...^ J. - i^jS^i ajili i^liJi AJJJI Uifci Jp^li oVLaJVl ^^ Ifu OUl /j.CJVUJVi I i,s^^lji-lj l-W-i JIAAI a-> oUJl^lj frlfjUl ^ J-^ijJb ^jJ tij^Sl JIAAI iT^i 0(

Y.. ^ j£b - a jSCJ i a iai aiiijU a^ijJi aL r

( PoJl (caiJ ai^fji ^ jA oU«isll aiAj .a Hil a«r)jll obUj) l a^Pjill aa iii

o b U j ^ i^ j ls aa iJi ^ y J f i a?-\a* jijisii JA asku OjSc-» .dUJi j» Jili

.Y. .^ fip jjijfijajma*urijii

OUjU i l O^jfJui OJlilJ j ^ j J \ JjJJr\

I u ou jU i i o i j r i * Jff jfi c*\yii ajiaii ^^j'y^* c*^ " ^ ^ o^a«; iii^^if

a-_itfjil 1^1 5j^rrVl ^ ^ ! t ^ j .4141 fliA J* Y » . A ji jsrt iOP i j l4iplyl

.a^U:1 ^\^ U^ •ij cob^l Js-jy Jp j , ^

S - i J i i ! ^ • • ^ jiljJ* Cr* :u>yJ* M :a*^J^ l.A.,«iai pfjj^t aSji

J—*p iii l i i j u.) ajai f l j i i l apj«^ a«riy - n • • a«rijU j j j i jgJ.i •

( j i j ^ ' ^ Oi«-'y

a^ijiii ajurijii aisfcji i j i a.-iiji - n > • ams-ijji J j j i jgJ.i •

t i i y M l t • • ^ yJji^ ty :,ji»yJl Syi :1MUUH i^^a^it ft(j«»-t aSji

^yij SU ajai f l j i i l JP J i U l ^ i j i i j i j£s-w** ajufijU j j J i jgili •

a*uli

j iaUi ^ i j i j i j f i tj t^fjlt Jp ct%ju - V • 0 a«^ijU J j J i jg»li •

j*t J f i u /y I o l j i i j j*t Jp a/tall o i y i - V • n a«rljJl J jJ i jg.li •

cM-* fff *>' jtJ^ <J i y- o r b

a iai ,»ii>5iij fiij*iii aii\k.- aijiiii ouyuii - v^ * a«rij*u J j ^ i j ^ ' ^ •

a;jiili

Cjurjj ajU ^ I j l ^ jJUj tj cfjstf ouy * * - VY • awrlyiJ Jj-iJi jg>ii •

t i l 1 • % ^ J J U J J ^ ^ - { ^y -^^ M - ^ ^ ^ ^ a-A-,flA=l\ ft\ji^\ 3S^

Y • • H j_ ,Ja^ l

ajBrijii cjiiP - ar • ajwriyii JjJiii jg*ii •

Sjujfj ou-uiy i y * U* a«rljll oM! aiit - o. ^ a«riyiJ Jj'li i jgJ-i •

ajui f l j i i l J Sijk^ o i { U ^

aB»-\s!i*!Ji SJUPJSI - a iosi'Si awrijli oifcuji - © ^ . a«rijUi j j j i i i j U i •

l ^ Olfrlyr^l " OY • a v l y i i J j ^ l jgJ-l •

a^i^ oijiOi; ^l i lc (a^i^i oi j iui; awrij* - oi>. aiurijU j j j i jgdt •

.ak^jii ou-ui)ft j aiiuit a«^i

Yr

tf Ujsj^i J > b

Page 26: dJs'alliiMi - INTOSAI...^ J. - i^jS^i ajili i^liJi AJJJI Uifci Jp^li oVLaJVl ^^ Ifu OUl /j.CJVUJVi I i,s^^lji-lj l-W-i JIAAI a-> oUJl^lj frlfjUl ^ J-^ijJb ^jJ tij^Sl JIAAI iT^i 0(

Y.. <! j,b - a -jSli-i ajm aiiijU ajjji ai ti

lajai a«rijii oiiL&j a Pjiii a tJii ajuli JUJ^I ^ J ^ touji«ii j * Oiji

projectsecretariat@rik$revisionen.se: i^^j^'j^ M^^

http://psc.rigsrevisionen.dk/fas : Ujaf)Ii J s ^jli

J^AIJU ij L ^ i jciiLUi aJ- jP aii^i a jiii aisrJJi aii L^j IJLT C ^

^-u»j akjut ij arjuiij a^iji (S) -. a Pjiii aa ui yijij jt«4j CY • • v

i l—^^ ^lall ^Uil ^Ikiil a ^ l i a j j j l jtiUll j ^ ^ , ^Ull ^Ikill a^l^ jtiU*

a-ji;-t aLsu^t JP i ujai) tup^ aijji jijUj iiopi (Y) i^ftf-uu jj.iJi

fj^uui JJJOI i\ *>u laii uii ^ikili a^u ajjji juuii akk^ij

.a iijU guii 3j * i Jit u^ Jjuii ^ijsj oUjULi Jig J , ^ (r)

ftU_p^l ^ ^ l4*#»«Jj (Y O • -Y . . A SjaiU JAP aia* a^g^i S-^ C^U

ce^ J W jH^' ^ t*** ' tj *^ ' cj^ 'jJ-' ^ j -li*^ J^ J>Axil

ftUa—p^i oLjrg»-i a—y-i tj a,r-BJjii oiii^i ,yiij jjUj. Y • • A jiyrt j

u-»r .JJil—Ul i j J Uwi a tj uii ikiii jp jijUJij a^ut oujUi

Y *«^-Y * «A i-isii tj S - U P ^ a^wu. a^tji frljarl a^-jsill J U l ala>- c^jdll

.a^l i t j^U* oLli'i

OjljjT I. [ JUTill ^ j i a^Pjill a.u>Jit siA JAP Ob. OUjU* J s J j « a ^

.(^Oi^l fiUll ^ I j l l c.TiCi i^Ull ^ I j l l ^ U * cj^

[email protected] : ; j>^Vi OijJi

www.oag-bvg.gc.ca : oijsiV* c*'* C?J^

ij^ljJLill frb auU

. I A ^ I » U P S c&SAf* 0 9 j ^ OljOill ftLj i^UjsIl aJt- OjXpt

a^-^jiitj aij^^i ouiiif jyXjjk iUji laiiijU gji sj ^Si ij oij.uii ^4

a—a ^ j * Jp cUjsi t asi^ Jp Ai* aaijjsSii ^ ^Uj .aoig-Siij a ijiJij

j - ^ j .http://cbc.courdescomptes.ma ij oijAiii ^ul ( j=il

a—<io,jl i^jUi awriji v ^ Juriti tjijl? JP apj^ ^ J P J J ^ I

. ([email protected]) 3jLn3li

ujjkj aiu- aiiijii gji ij^Hs I^JU«U ot jS^ i a ^ i iiij^i uUij

iU-Aj^l iJ—4j .UljOl ^y UbiUil ^Is^ ^^\ l^^^y^^ii oljkS-1 J^Mj a^Aljll

: Jp /jij ji^l jl il^O^^ii Ji/ ^Uji t^t ftUt UlPly (^tf a,^j CJH^

i jiibjli o l j l ^ jijkr •

Yi

.cUciSl U-ii

Page 27: dJs'alliiMi - INTOSAI...^ J. - i^jS^i ajili i^liJi AJJJI Uifci Jp^li oVLaJVl ^^ Ifu OUl /j.CJVUJVi I i,s^^lji-lj l-W-i JIAAI a-> oUJl^lj frlfjUl ^ J-^ijJb ^jJ tij^Sl JIAAI iT^i 0(

Y •. Jib - a,»jS i ajiii aiiijii ajjoii ai i

i^jli oUi>-j ailijl! JfiHi j l^l i y j jiyJ •

.aiui i^ji:!- oiTijA ftUi J ^ J* aiiijU JPVI j A-i J*P JJIJ Siio •

^ fUp tf Ujsll ftUjapf !k£Jj cUJlAs^ i U j ^ l aijji OljOill ftUj (^Uyi a.;J j y S j

( 0 > ^ L ^ a—uiJll frUhptj .ty»ll)llj (^—rijll t f j U l J p oUJull J B ^ <ulJUi^l

.ouiuii »iA j g ^ tj 3jLPUui (j Usiiii JLP

ftbU t^L—jdl 3_U. j jJ i t^ i i jU i a«rljU! t ^ j i l s ^ l 2J»j ((ilii J l a iu^ l i j

t j c—ijsiyi as;^,ji, JJUP ^ U A . OIJJ—afl tl—^ ^ l * s U J J J U I liift .oljJiiJi

oijjkili ftUi alajjf Jfi. a\AjS*JS Uai* JJLA* y j twww.cbcdirectory.org

Jlijll aij«c a*s4ii aiiijU g*li i j ^ ^ \ ^juj .aiiijU g*iii i j^Hi ^Bi C-TJSAI j i

c- i *^ ' jM*-4 JusVi Jp tfySi aiiijii guii o^^Sii cf J oijjisli \n oijcp JP

.8jAg t ^ i aiiijii

loijoiii frU,! ( Ujsji au Ji Jursi ^^jj toUjUii j * Oiji

[email protected]: ^jj^^i -to i

www.courdescomptes.ma ; uyV' cj' c?^'

i u y ^ i J f i t^Ujsji OjW iiif

3J—ft* ^yU^ * Y • . V jjU tj cf JLii aill j l l J P S I j^Jrl ^ilfct J i (t^Ujsil OjW 3lil

tj l^lJlAs—**:! fcUa-^^1 a—(lljil UtfUtl 3 j ^ ^ a -U* j tt^Ujs}! ^»5^ 3jiJL»*

JLHijij (t3flUjj (a lS b j ^ Oli>ae ^ i J l Jjui J \ - 31iVl . a ^ u i o v u ^ ^ i

3jli l j t O ^ U - J l j t OjUl i^Ujd^ jijJ - Jafl?- j * 3 Ol j i f j (bUj iJ j (t^jj:S3l

- J t ^ l i:r'i*1 f iSy^

( J U P iiA—Jsl j t WWW.illtOSaictOOl.org J l t-—aii (SlaSl aia J l J j ^ j U j

^JULP C^..-^ ( J y j L j i J«?!t.M.u a ^ i ^ J p .(^Uj£ii ^ j l a,-^jli a^iUi i ^V j l l i

Ol—JTj (:ft*Jb«Ul ftWf jia« j t ftlijy . j U l a j T j fUAUl |»-ril Jb^il c^j iwUl

jf [email protected] :^jli—i JuiNi (/b.jsii ^UPS CM '•JJP

[email protected]

OjWil Slit ^

(a^fi-jll j j U - l (^Ujall (iJUii) J * U j » ^ ^Isi ((^Ujsil OJUJ Slit ^^^JJLu^ SJiPUi

^Ijll oLti (PDFs J*JSJ ur tyy ^ r ^/jjJl (•JaJ .5liW Jyjlil a^^ Jfi

(Cj-Ssii *i^j j-^)i i OijJi (a»UjJi a»*iUi 4 O*HJIJ Jyj^ii J^^^ ^ :a, yi

ta—iJiijJi ^j-jsi\ (Cjy^i oljfij* (ifjsii ouo^ toLsiUi ( jUi jruf (^mij

aui J* <r—i jij i^u-^i a^i ouys...* (jaiJ-i oiji i tj auij* (f J IAUI uiij*?

.fJbvUl OlPlJki^

: t f i i l aitfjU J P V I 3^A-li J U J V I J ^ J * t oUjULl j * Jbjl

[email protected] *[email protected] ; jjjsS^V' -Vjil'

w^ww.cag.gov.in : c j y ^ i J f i ^ j \

YO

cfUy^d J^ii

Page 28: dJs'alliiMi - INTOSAI...^ J. - i^jS^i ajili i^liJi AJJJI Uifci Jp^li oVLaJVl ^^ Ifu OUl /j.CJVUJVi I i,s^^lji-lj l-W-i JIAAI a-> oUJl^lj frlfjUl ^ J-^ijJb ^jJ tij^Sl JIAAI iT^i 0(

Y • • ^ Jib - a^jSJ-i ajil\ aitfjU aLSjJI ii^s

a^UjJ a^jSi oij.i»jii JAP apjA)

_MiiaIi t i iriyi J y v ^ y a^jli agJ jli OIJAJJ] t^uyi JAP apj^^ oUjf

j _ U i a—pj*f O J U P J .^jjii i\ 'Jli o g - u a*SU i^lyj tsii^^i j jiP

aiUyi g<Jl aj^sr^l Ojy»U-t ^UiP^I Ji*j . j i ^ y tj Y » « A jiU tj J j^ l ^Ua-Nl

(ijjji (Ou^ij (dg.J^i tgijia] (igi; (ce-oii (Ou^ijir tgikii (iijCiJi tjj i j *

j—i Oj«.^ij* jja^ u r . i j-<^j tiuiLi tgijTjf (Sjuai oiiitjii ti/UjL- (g-jj

!>/. QVI;* J—P Ojiti diiirj (giJj*j (ixT (j^jj'jg tg^jS aiiijU i>Ji Sj^Vi

fl—kllj (Og-%^1 C-±Jjlj .JjjJl iiUllj ta^lj t^iUuiVI OjUatl l^^icxr^ji

.^Us^'ii 4 l ^ aai jll i:ucj Y • • A JAP alwtj (^^1 J l

o u g U i jji.i -T (.—Pi't ^ a,.. jli a Jsjli OIJAJAU t^uyi JAP apjAj a *

4 a,-.UjJi a-U'jii ^^j>P j > j jijBS ( Uj=jij aiiijU gji i ^ ^ a>j)i

cf J Jbr JiJ \ J » i i cJjij (>fcjJi jiV-»Jl J*- a^Uar-ilj a-^lj aiiUsilll o- l l

:aelisli a f ijs.ri' i JijubVi JUl apj«^

jriU-t .jUiP Ju^jTJ-i akij* i ajuij a iiT tj a iijU jp*ii ';^i^\ jji ^ i •

. a^ j l i a>jli o i y jll

o i y jllj a^ji i aflJpjii oiy^li fij sia-iij jejloj jij^ 4 j j Ji t^uyj jjs j pi •

.a>jli Jji

\* \ ^ ( jUii J* liJip gu- a,rUjii aa:l?jli oijjsjji t^uyi JAP apj*# J y j

J ouU>tj oiiiUJ*:!! a:ai J a^ j i i a>jli o i j ^ j j i sjg^i ou^ul i j p ijSi •

i(tfjj^i aiiijU jp*ii j i ^ i : jUi ) aijj.1 Jfi aji5ii

jtgA-i :t>Ui) a^-gjli a Jsjli oiy*jli fUWo-ij jijki tj Vj«jJi ^ J ^ ^ yijia-i •

t(Wi^ (jaill jil J P S I

oioii ij ftii^i awriy jijiaij a^ j i i a^jii oiy^jii ^ JUjj i^i^ tj SJIPUII •

((j^jjli i i ^^ aiiijii J P V I 31^1 :t>ui) ai4Ui j j J i akiij

oUi-ijl! a—ilijU (JUPVI j l ^ i :tjUl) a,-gjli i^j l i oiyjAil i i j - . ^ j •

.(ijuai

aa aijli a jibyi oij—s.jjl ,/Ujdi j ^ i f i j ^ f\jafi\ ,yju (diii Jl aiu^iij

.a—(U^J (^iUdlVl OjliJi aAk;*j i^UjsJl t:j i ^liill 1 / 1 A J f i C J > % ^ ijs^/iij

a^aJsjIl Olj—AjJI (#Ujril JAP apj*jf ^ OjUsIl JJJW Jf i ^ AliJl SjTJL* jTjjj

fjL-5iii ^t_^ JL-^ tj a—aUij i^iuU"^! OjUsii a*kd JUil ^jjiiij a„*;jii

•y^uar*:)!

-uaiijll (ii i^uyl I Y • * A j ^ ^ j 4 JiP t^ili i^Uy^ i^VJl jJa^i Ussr* ij

ji-jiiisli 1/XA JtiJ a„Uj)i a>jli oijAjUl (^uyi JAP apjAif ala-uf jiyi J p

cfU^'5il>b

Page 29: dJs'alliiMi - INTOSAI...^ J. - i^jS^i ajili i^liJi AJJJI Uifci Jp^li oVLaJVl ^^ Ifu OUl /j.CJVUJVi I i,s^^lji-lj l-W-i JIAAI a-> oUJl^lj frlfjUl ^ J-^ijJb ^jJ tij^Sl JIAAI iT^i 0(

Y . . •\ Jjb - ^ J ^ s aaiai aiiijii a^ijaii aLfci

. a ^ l j i^iUaiJ'ill OjUall a«kuj i^Ujsil Cfti

J* Sjsiii J?^ a ^ j i i aaitjii OIJAJJJ (^UJ=JI JAP apj jfe yiiii ^usr*!ji Jiiii^j

.OiS^Jt Y . . ^ Jijil Yr JlY^

i u U ^ ou - . i ^ i a sUc a^rji^i o\l%li Sjiiij JUJ^ I ^ y , t oujWi j * Oijl

[email protected]: i^jj^'j^ -LJJI

http://intosai4kni.org : cjy^fi Jfi ^jli

JjVl APUBTV *^^JJJV1 JAP t3iji ilJlPl

jC jU i J!)U>- 0U3V1J C i j j l l a^fl-oAli Jij*"^! aiiTijl i^b<jjjSii JAP j i j i ^ t

ali.iipijl J U l i5iji t ^ t J l j . t • • A jsi j i tj ( iJJy i ^ / i / 4 I^LAJJJ^ ^ U l

aijjuUij i^>t^\ ^jijS3i U i y awriy J ^ ^ ^"^'' aijUi a^pyli apj«jti jupf

4:9,11 a«riji i^Ujjj^i JAP apj*# J* f*y c j i r J i j (aiUi ouiaJi j s ftUiiij

.Y•*^ f ip i i *

Vj_ptj . c i - ^ i j ifdul ^ J l t j U i a!jil LUj g i / j f og-ut aASU CASJI

.JUl aiji ^ OjUJi 4 ^ j jP oiiyf O L ^ J aiiijJJ Jpf gj j f i j i ^ j ^ a->

(1—SU^ ' t ; - J j ^ (OUMjit (g,*jl JjJLl a>lijll g j l 3j^Sl : ^ J*lS3li frUipSlj

j j j L - r j ,^—jjii ii^*^ij ( i ^ j i (UjJj* tgiji^ (Ou>i3ir (iJLUit (j^i tiijuii

( ^ ^ jU i (lUiW^ ^ U j U iU«ii 5y - r ^ ' (»* Oj^ijiij .a^ijjjSi ji«rijli a*s:*fi

a—aUali iL-ij*ii a«fiyj ai^uui t^Uj^i JAP apj*# ^j^^jj a / i i jU i a jj AJrij

.OjljSili

-Y * • ^ 3j_uu J—Ul abss-j ouuwt*:ii g i / j * ^ afiijU J P S I J^A-I ^ J JJJ

j>5ij J U l aiji u i i 3 J l akJU^ij ,yijisSl i i ^ j ^ j ^^ i i jWjIi a i * cJSLi .Y * n .

^ j U > A - W i j ao-ap jj5ll J . t^iJl ( JU l aijil JjSl ^Uar-il J ^ l ^ aiilj l l

. ( j i a / i j Y» *^

:g i j r j f o g - l ^ 1*S^. JU3*!H ^ j i ( oUjUl l J* Jlijl

[email protected]: jjsS^yi OijJi

: c j y ^ l j p ^ j l l

w\vw.ac-rada.gov.ua/achamber/control/en/index tUj^jr^ ^ijil J j - ^ a«r'ji ^ y i i i jiy=" J ^ c^j='i

aUjJJi a—«fijAi! i i j a ju i jijSsii lac-j y y tY *»A jij=rt ai# (j 31*^ jT i u r

^ u U l jC j U l J%t. Y » • A jaiji i j g^ j -u^jJ (?j JrfjJ>iJ s-l Jil J j u U a i U l

J _ A P apj4if JAP J * ftj;;ir a«r1jll a Up Ojsr J j . IJJ j i t J J T I J T tj c^UjjjSU

(ifjijS3i U i y awriy J a.d.AAJi aijUi a^yli apj«: i (a:a,ii aM -ijl t^Uj^jSi

.a«Ui ou.iiJi J f i frUiiij aijji^ij a9«L i

YV

t fUjs i^ l Jflt-li

Page 30: dJs'alliiMi - INTOSAI...^ J. - i^jS^i ajili i^liJi AJJJI Uifci Jp^li oVLaJVl ^^ Ifu OUl /j.CJVUJVi I i,s^^lji-lj l-W-i JIAAI a-> oUJl^lj frlfjUl ^ J-^ijJb ^jJ tij^Sl JIAAI iT^i 0(

Y.. - ^.b - a^jS^i a,iiii aiiijU a j j j i aiifei

' ^jjJ' ^^1" ^^'^ji ^^j-^j-' ^giil 'gi/j^ ajlijii gji »jfrSi a«rijii j ijju

UUi sy-^*^! ajwrijii J ,**u ur JaijjjSi ui«rijli AASUJ (a/iijUi a-jj^i

J-i. jjjii gi/jt tj og-i^i USU c-.iij (lUyj su^ai oii^jlt j . ^ i^^j}

.iA^riji

J ^ y j j ^ frijil J J - L U a iUi a«rijJl iJjU.i jijisli J f i ^ j J i tj OjTjUii

Y • • A jffiji i j IJLljJ tj l^Ujj j*i l ^ U t jCjll tj

-»*«—U ^JJJ^' J J ^ L U I J J J J U I ^ i JU OjUsli (>) g^ii u« i Jj«ri>i ,*^j

Oli aui i i ou^i—lii aujjjsj Jaijijju *ijii j j j L ^ ^u j^ > ^ n V fiP tj a ^ i j

a;—- a—ijjji auiiJ) J,rijijuj ak^ j^iuj U j tj g i / j f otti_;*ri (Y) J (aui i

fliiJ Jl j*jdt ^ U i J i j ^ j StJ^ ^ frUi of J l Ojiwr'jli y i ^ - ( dJi ^ j . Y . . •

J _ U l ^ I S J Oil I (i i i i Jl aiU^^li .aJfiy j f i o l j u - V j * jiTf t t u .J g,; j*T

. l i i l i j JA^EJ ( j k i l asi a;rjUj VjSt otjiJiiJi o j j l ^

Oj-jurij i i f J U ( ^ I tLi Jupf J* t-i^^ii OU-;»j uT JaijijuiJ cf j l * J P J»U*J1

(jaiji j^j^j ttj_ii jjjL.# tj a-?Ui aijkili oujJ-ij ( g i / j f a*jS^ j i ogpy

ogj:-—« 4 jkJi Siipi og^ j j i ciff-j .JaJjijs-iJ tijii JJJU^ J j ^ U i ^ j

J—i ugi»!Jtj t i j l ^ l j i^jlt J j - ^ l J * SjlaUlj ' ""J** 5ijsr j * uTtJlj ( J j ^ l

.>lAi l

: g i / j t o g - i ' a*s^ Juj^t ^ j ^ » ou jU i JA JUJI

[email protected] : i^jj^^T -^-J^

•' ^ J^T J * £»>' ww\v.ac-rada.gov.ua/achamber/control/en/index

YA

,fuy)|t J^b

Page 31: dJs'alliiMi - INTOSAI...^ J. - i^jS^i ajili i^liJi AJJJI Uifci Jp^li oVLaJVl ^^ Ifu OUl /j.CJVUJVi I i,s^^lji-lj l-W-i JIAAI a-> oUJl^lj frlfjUl ^ J-^ijJb ^jJ tij^Sl JIAAI iT^i 0(

Y.. " Jjb - a -jS i aaiiii aiiijii ajjJi ai i

:a^jiii{ aituit jjjLii cf ujji^ij i Ujsji a ^ ijig. cic jJ-i so-^ ^^j i

j - ^ auu aijsr auj^^ ^^^ Jj i^ t^^jjSij t^ujsii a ^ Sjig* otOi

.|H^)|U.i v^jJUll ij ^jflifl-ftAi JA 3.iiJLr ap^^ a , U t^j>tll VHIJ>U ^ ^ j i

ij O J U S P (Olj^ll j aisl t ) ^ ''- JJJ (I&^J^-^^ a ^ j ^ 3 j j i y Jj^l (1JJJ-I

j_apj .2:*UjJi 4 tiftrjuii jga i f ia^jjii aiA tj . Y . . A jyaiy tj JuUi

t ^ J J *^ i j j ' ^ l i l y j^ljiBUri*:! Y • • A j>A-i i t j ji!t»iil t j (Kr*-flJ SilPi g^Us^l

t j o i j J - U i frUi o i j i g i t j t t ^ j Jpy i CftTjUii jSCc ^^1 o i j j i i l i ftU^J ^ i y

^^^^ ogiai ^u t a«^ 3jd JAP aji>jj j ^ jjSii j * j .aiiijii g j i f^j^t

tf uj.riS[ij ( Ujsii a ^ 3jig Sij^i ouj9 Uji

gu aj^f aOP ot Y *»V IP ij t^Uj^Sl 4 ^ ^ ^ ^^^ cj\9r^^^ ^ t ^ JA^I

A-i-;9j UJU .aw^ljll 3ij:r OlUff * ^ j i y ; j * a,i£U Ot jSCc ailaAl tj a{lijii

Oyj-Uil t^lji f-iJ tY • • A ^/jU tj 5iji-l OUj? c-asr ^ j j ^ j a^MiljJl i l j l l

.aikit tj aij £M aiiijii gu 3j^t i j i ^ j * j j i j i oij^t ouj? JAP aj jj

C *ll iY . • A ^jJaUt i j gyki* tj OiPy-l i-^ ^ - ^ c5 ' J*«J' 3Ji.jj Jr) >

a—iijj JL_«ij .5iji-l OUU t ^ j ^ y l j «w l (.Ij^r)! i»la^ ^ - ^ j it-J^k JjiJl

I flilll U j ^ l J 3ijJb-l OUU 3JJ1J OUIJ<CMI igiiu J j l <U*ll dj^gi J U l

cf j?s- i j j i it J* fr:5Ujii Jfi ouij«w*:ii aJU ii-Q-ftp ( ^ ^ cJj i j j jaiiijU

(j g-^Uj-u' 4 j— j!»1 J j ^ l 8ilp^ g_U»rt i j Jj i l l Oiuartj .arjuit

OjrjUUl JOP ur .arjaJj.1 aarfjU' g/^f j!»ljiia--1 jf cV- T * • A jiJy

.aUf aiiijU guit ,iij^t oi;rg»-i ^ ^ \ssi ic 3ijJ i ouj? j j i jj-^

cf Urijij ij i/i-'j i aaAj Sjig> oijjuii »Ui oi g -i |»U7 ^Uji

ou^g^-i ^UjJ agf Ji aA i tf UjiijSij i Ujsii a^ Sjig. CJUJ

i oJ-i jjs- .(Ui i J aiiijii jpt vj^ j.ifi agjuil 4CJiir i iii oijjiiii ftg

tj OUP ij caiJjii guii 3j4;r* i ty ^* apj« Ui j^ i 3iiPt ^uuri cji Ji

J i j j a*rljl a^jl olrg^'I i l ^ J j i i ^Usr'Sl liA c j^ l j .Y • • A jiyTt

guii (»ij4^t j r tj o j i-f (^i a»-Mrijii oiirg»-*ii (wi^ OI^UP JP OUJU.

oi*u- tg-»UjJi tiA J * ^ j * j . Y * • A jiAS-ri tj JU l ajujj ani a^ i ajiijU

3j4srSi oi joi a^Ajjj j t i U i OjUsU a;Sle i j i ( j j ^ i j i^ujaii a,^ ojig.

.OljJLiit ftLi y% Uai Ul^^g^l ^ ^*^k k^J^ U«Il

Y'

6 J J \ ) A

{ J ^ .A-i]

»J J a_i

f i - « ^ ] yJc i k J U U J-«kC ^ (Ial j j k J j U

j j l J-o g _ - . l j _ J j

i f 1——MljJ-j) ^ J „ \ ".

1 j j - U l ( J U - U £ V j I * * ' " ' 0 J J 1 ; •" t y

I i' I iJ.S I J-aj tf t . .• J "' '• I

C>J J i^—Jk J

L ;> . . * • •

S j J t - *J-- , > ^ 4 • - ' '

: ( U j > j _ j y i a_s_Ui_j

www.ldl.no

tf Ujsii igt^ ojig. cjihjd-

Page 32: dJs'alliiMi - INTOSAI...^ J. - i^jS^i ajili i^liJi AJJJI Uifci Jp^li oVLaJVl ^^ Ifu OUl /j.CJVUJVi I i,s^^lji-lj l-W-i JIAAI a-> oUJl^lj frlfjUl ^ J-^ijJb ^jJ tij^Sl JIAAI iT^i 0(

^ Jjb - a jSLn aaiui aiiiji! aaijji aiafci

t^jjdl ^Htjia! tf Uj.ritj cfl-dj^l a^Ai? 3jigi ^ JjaJU ^Jjs^l CX^ ^^jt

frUj)! iij&^ ^«tfUF Ujj tfUjiiritj cff-oj i a,^ Sjigi otOi iY • * A fip (j

jU^*ili ajup J* ftifj*iti JUi .aikii tj v^jUi j jjfl,fl-*ci.\ JA Oiju*- ^ u

>3i^ > A JA irju.* rv jsii caij-a^i ai^ji tj CJJSJJI aSu j u ,j«iij

|ijni/lTl ^ U f r 3J. JAP aJbjj J Arj! IfiTJ cf U ) ^ f tj li^Xfb** aill j i l J p t

Oljjl isll ^ g s i .Y » « A j w J y j jijsTf t j tfUa^ ti^yU cJ O l j j J l jijiaJj

o^jUUi OIJJLJ jijfaj Jl JUl a^jj cJui (tf U'jsJl a iLj Sjigi tj s^Si

j i jUaJj (wwi-Jj tOljOill frUi . Uni aiUjU g j l ( l i jK^ oUrg»-l (HjisI

s.L^ ^ij—(;ii> gSfj ijuslii ^ ^ cfigi bu.-i arjUii j u aAjuii o i j j j i

^ J J * ^ (^' j C?*^^ " 5J. iUjsiVl tsi* J A P s-i>W ai;^j* J ^ .OljOill

o l j j i ilJL_P^ o \P_^ ^ j t J l Ojr jUi l j | U tOi j jJ i j i j i t f j ,»ff»-ai JAP

^—j»jj iaiiijii gull 3j^*i!i (j tijjuii *UP*III jijiaj - j ^ j j ^y ot^ a rfjaj

t j o y i l J l calfl-jll aiA J l j t .aiJjii gull S j ^^ l tj aaAaii l^^ \ j ;^ \ ak?

tY •»^ JiU ij . ^ j j ^ i ^ y ij a fUi j ^ J* Ojrjiill ojUf (j A«.<i aiU

. ^ U t r 3Ul ^jajlirrfl o g i i i l J A P ajtijj tj O j r j U i l ^ ar»ia..i

i^UjaJl ^ft£^ ^ JUTl I l j (^Ujsll a ^ 3 j ig .

i j i JuU j ,^1 a^ l il lJU-SlI Jp jijUJ lyOlj (^Uja)] a,*^ ojigi j i i j ja^

JjaJtUi £^U-*ar' l t(*-^J*^ V y r ) i^Ut j j i^ ^ ^ ' ^ ' i ***- ' :5jj?^^' j * ^ * ^ '

i ^Uj : !^ a«i l juUll a : ^ aa gSTjall hsfll\ ^Uar\ i(OUJ) ( UjsJ)U ti^Uil

a,Uri t(Vj<^i) if^yi'^ oijUi fi-Ui a.u^ll asf^jaii a.u9iii ^usri i(t:tUi)

^u-fturi c(UUt) i^Ujiii o*ilLATt JAP apjA^ i(g*jijr) j^*ij^ a*uli

c-iijUl hk f^Usrl tcfl--yt jjj# £,Ua;r' i(UUl) t^U-jsJ^ t^isiJl ^jJj^i

^jjj^l iL_^^ ailljU Jp^l 314^.1* i}La3*i\ hk g^Uarl ((OU.»rii) ,^>i

l i ^ ^Usfi iaij^^ii aikuli cf 1-jji^ t^i *l^JUtfIl £_U»ri ^(•^jy'^j)

a—PjA:!Ui , , ^ ^ 1 S^J^ I aJr g_Us!-lj t (Iniijit i~iy^) ti^'jJJl O l P j j U l

.(Oij*iii) (^UjiijSi a^jJi

t^Ujstl a,«j Sjig: JUa7*i|l

ci l—.rijsll l ^ 3jigi oUiA^ J* i U l lift i j OjJf J l v i - ^ i ty <if ^ ^

li^Ujsil a ftd ej ig: jLtfVI ^ J J

[email protected] : yjj=S3^i jiijJi

www.idi.no : Ujsj^i Js ^J\

cf Ujsii aaA.j 3jig ctiiijJ'

Page 33: dJs'alliiMi - INTOSAI...^ J. - i^jS^i ajili i^liJi AJJJI Uifci Jp^li oVLaJVl ^^ Ifu OUl /j.CJVUJVi I i,s^^lji-lj l-W-i JIAAI a-> oUJl^lj frlfjUl ^ J-^ijJb ^jJ tij^Sl JIAAI iT^i 0(

i-z-r ..'-"f r. ^ 1 Jib - a jSCJ-i asiai aitfjii a^jJi uti

t • vA J ^ ^ ^ ^

u-J^

U i ^ ( i W e y ^ ^ ' t ' ^ ^ ' :^ - 0

( ^ J J - B J ((IJUUI-IJ J jU l t I S

JL;it

a_ui JUl apj-rf ^u»ri n - ^

(3—(tijU L U ^ 3 j f r ^ u n y t j

i . M f ' ^ j ^

J—*e a _ * j * # £ ^ 1 — ^ 1 » ^ - 1V

(^dU-J* i l HM h-t l j (a.a:4U-t

J.1 .11 ^^\ LSU , iCl j » Uj

^ j j l t j t i * i i ( j C - j . i ^ i i - t j

-yji aJ^Ut J*P ifijAJ^ ^i^sft lUb-'j J j i i

( i ^ j t jC i j ak,jjlt ai jUJ a«rijLij

. k j /

J>**> ^ - y i i/.Lii,in!i^^1.1*1 : ^ ^ - > n

y i o * f ' ^ j ^

j i ' j i * ,^_-.^Ojy^uuj jUi :>r- n

L-.JI (L^ (Lfuy]/ij^i

Jil*

j'.y^^

y. P a«—-tilt iiUli a,U-i :>» - i

if'^yrijt liiJr^JaJ ij'^*ij^

k. ;t,XA ( i U i l f a<iiri>< otALftjy

Ji^•

a«rV J** >*>** t ** ' :Y'\-Yo j U <a».jjt ( i j^t

I'J J_^j*Jt 3__UJi ^t__tf:rl rlto-IJ J j i i

(3 BIHI a «rljl' otit ijy

.^jjt^^J

•a«rlj» J f i i f i j ^ £^Urt tUs-"!} J j i i

j U ( l ^ j j l t i O U ^ I t^j) j:SJ

otyjLi j*P ap_j*# £^u»ri Yr - Y ^

c U ' 'O i^ <V-«ijl i J r t j l l

ViiaJtjwl J * * JiJ* ^ U ; r l : t i - ^ J j i i

. U U t (list ( i ^ u y i o l i u i t

Js^Ji

a^JlS:;* J * * lPj*# ^1*Brt : l i -V j j i <

(LJjlTl^r (AU i i j Jl j*Vi J U

U^jJJ l

»ui_pt SOPUU aia_-jS'j ((^Ujsj^ o*tfUdSi a,3^js.-i j ,^J ^^jit jjoJrt lift j U i : j i j ^ i t j ^ j ai»jMi*

l^Ur tjl^Ullj i^Uyi jpSS. o g - U j Otdb-f abUi SAUII aUt aJU Cic-j .JaUjll Jjlii^l f } r ^ j h^pvl i^uy i

.aiiaiJi ^1^1 oipusrij (a^ jUt ogUbi j (Otyjli OIA Ji*

. j t i U i i I—»jijj J l aai ii cjipuasr'ii JA Uji^j aosijjuli (OijjJi j>* 0*0*112^4i ot ^ _ "i a^jjJii a?-Ut (_,.,-

.au i l J * * apj*# jSli fUii ct-^ii j-oJi (OUjUi j . j ^ j l j

r>

Y * • ^ flP i j t^UjslNt i jlo^-f

Page 34: dJs'alliiMi - INTOSAI...^ J. - i^jS^i ajili i^liJi AJJJI Uifci Jp^li oVLaJVl ^^ Ifu OUl /j.CJVUJVi I i,s^^lji-lj l-W-i JIAAI a-> oUJl^lj frlfjUl ^ J-^ijJb ^jJ tij^Sl JIAAI iT^i 0(

TOSAI

^ ;

. ' /

> •/sn AiNoaac jsai^Aa

l?l-8ilAI00a ovo

y3 i i i i ^ invd 9='^10S 5^'^lDO 5=AlOd S2='^103 9=' 1DV ^9^0-66^J