89/22/16 16:45:36 280-388-1380 ->

Chri5topher H, Mcy,er, ldaho S,tate Bar No. 4461 MichaeJ P. Lawrencey Jdaho .Stat~ Bar, No. 7288 OtVENS. PURS1,UY u.r 601 w_. Bannock St. J>.O: Box 2720 Boise, Idaho 8·3701-2720 Telephone: 208 .. 388-1200 Facsimile: 208-388-1300 www.iiv~nspunl'ey.com chdsmeyer@givenspursley.com mpl@givcnspursley :cQm Attijmejis/01· Sri.h Wate1' Idaho Inc.

288?362121 Giuens Pursely LLP Page 882

District vOurt • ~HBA Fifth Judlclal District

In Re: Administrative Appeals County of Twin Falls • State of Idaho

SEP 2 2 2016

JN THE D1$TRIL"T COURT OF THE FOURTH JUDICIAL DISTRIC'l'

OF:TIIE ·~7 ATE ·OF ·JD AHO, IN AND .FOR THE COUNTY OF ADA

BALLENTYNE.DJTCRCOMPANY; BOJSE VAl~LBY lRRlOATJON DITCH COMPANY; CANYON COUNTY -WATER.COMPANY~· mJREKAWATEi{ COMPANY~ FARMER:s· CO-OP~R.A'fIVE.DUCii COMP.<\,NY,. MIDDLETON MILL DITCH COMPANY~ MIDDLETON.IRRIGATION ASSOCIATION~ INC.; NAMPA:& MERJDlAN IRRIGATION DISTRICT; NEW .DRY CREEK DITCH COMPANY; PIONEER DITCH COMPANY; P~ON~ER:IRR10ATION DJ_STRlCT; SETTLERS IRRIGATION DISTRICT;. S0lJ'f1-I BOISE WATER COMPANY! and THURMAN MILL DITCH COMPANY~ . . .

~cti~i~~e~, vs.

BOISE PRO.lECT BOARD OF CONTROLt and NEW YORK IRRIGATION DISTRICT ~ . . t

Peti tione1<s, vs.

IDAHO DEPARTMENT OF WATER RE.<sOUR.CES; and GARY SPACK:MAN, in his capacity as the.Director of the.Idaho Department of Water Resources;

Res onden.ts,

PE'tl'flON FOR ·REHl:AkTl'ilC · :i6,i,v.12iss9~J . . .. . . . .

C',ase No. CV-WA-201S-21376 (Consoli.dated Ada C.ou.nty. ·case No. CV-WA·20JS .. 2I39J)

PETITION FOR REHltARJNG

89/22/16 16:45:49 28B-3BB-1380

and

SUEZ. WATER IDAHO INC. 1

lntervc.nor.

->

IN THE MATIER 6'FACCOUNTING FOR DISTRIBUTION OF' WATERTO TiiE FEDERAL QN .. $TREAM RESERVOIRS IN WATER .DlSJRICT 63

2087362121 Giuens Pursely LLP Page BB3

Intervenor. Suez. ·Wa.ter ld.aho Inc:, ("Suez"), by imd. through its counsel of record and

pursuant. t.o Idaho· Rule .of Ci vH P1'()cedure 8:4 t-tnd Idaho AppeJiat~ Rule-42;_1 here~y peliti~ns to

this_ G_o"rt .for 1:ehcilr1ng :1:~garding the. Mtm()rr;,,;tdi~~ i)Qcf.rion and O~dtr ~led in this proceeding

on Septem her· J J ·2(H 6 .

.As requh'Qd by .. rdal'tc) Appe11ate ·Rule .42(c)1 .S.ue~·witt fi1c: J ·tnetrt¢randwn in ~upl){)rt of

this ,Pijtition withh1 .t4 day~ of the: filing date. ~fthis:P~tti0.n. S~lQt'a supportin_g mem:0t't\ndum

wHf iocus·pri_1:,.uu·1.ly on-th~ . .a~C6unH~:Pl'Oc~ur9~1 pertahi111g·t.() '•un~Cc.x.>\mted for s_tor~ge~: and> jn

particular, the,right to:·"t~ river''' refill thatSuez.alleges ·is hiheren.t in every·on .. str.~$11 ~tQrage . , , ' ,• ' . .

dgh.t and compe:lle<l'by Idiulo1-s· Prier Appropriation Doctfine .-and. the con8titutlonai .mar1date· for

maximum ~T~e. Suez does nQt .request oral argument ..

1 Ruic 84 of !he Idaho Rule! of CM I Procedure Sl .. tes thJt "any proc~dure {Of judlcJal review not specified or eo\/Ored by'these·rulos n1ust be jn 11~Q~rd.mee with ·th¢--i.ppr11pl'ititc: rut~ .<>t tl\c Idahi) A~llatc Ruic~ to the o>ftent 11ot contrnry to1h~s .l'Olo 84." t .R.C.P, 84.(r). While R:ol~ ·_84- recrignim.thll1'"'a petition for l'ehearing'~ .may b·c filed after judgm·e11tis entered in a jiJdieial review 'j)J'ocec~ir,g, (.R.CJ'. '84(t). it ·do.es not apeclfy tbo-nppUcab~ proc~dtim: Thifs, lli~ protedural ~i'ovisfon11 Jn ld~h'o A~llate Rule 42 tC8nrdfng: t,etiti<>ns 'for rehearing ·apply in tliis j'ldioinl fevi~w·µrqeeeding. I.R.C.P. 84(r). · ··

•,' . ' ,• . ' . . '

Pt:h'f¥<1N FOR JU:1U:ARING l~-u·u 126593%_-1 ·

Page2 of4

89/22/16 16:46:82 288-388-1388 -> 211)7362121 Giuens Pursely LLP Page 804

Respectfully submitted this 22st day of September, 2016.

GIVENS PURSLEY U,P

By ~ ·P.C-----.___ Michael P, Lawrence Attorneys for Suez Warer /d(lho inc,

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

I hereby certify that 011 this 22nd day of September, 2016, I caused to be filed 11nd served true and correct copies of the foregoing document to the person(s) listed below by the method indicated:

DOCUMENT FILED: Clerk of the District Court SN.A.KE R1VHR BASIN ADJUD1CATION

253 Third Avenue North Twjn FaJJs, ID 83301-6l31

.Mailing address: P.O. Box 2707 Twin Falls, tD 8330~-2707 ddelnney@idcourts.net

D

~ 0

U.S. Mail Hand Delivered Overnight Mau '.Facsimile: 208~736·2121 E-mail

CHECK Jc'OR FILING FEE PROVIDED WI1'H COPY OF J>OCUMENT: Ada County Courthouse Fourth Juaicial District Court 200 W Front St Boise, ID 83702

Pl!.'l'l'l'ION FOR lh'JfJo.:i\lUNG 30•1 ~·l/ l 26~9396_ 11

D

~ D

U.S. Mail Hand Delivered Overnight Mail Facsimile: 208~736-2121 E-mail

Pagc3 of4

119/22/16 16:•U,:tB 288-388-1388 -> 28El73&2121 Giuens Pursely LLP Pagr.: 885

DOCUMENT SERVED:

Daniel V. Steenson S. Bryce Fanis Andl'ew Waldera SA W1'001li LAW 0f PICES1 Pl.l-C 110 l W River St, Ste 11 0 Boise, ID 83 702

Mailing address: P.O. Box 7985 Boise~ ID 83707 dan@sawtoothlaw.com bryce@sawtoothJaw.com 4\ndy@sawtoothlaw.com

Albert P. Barker Shelley M. Davis BARKRR ROSHOLT & SIMPSON LJ.P 1010 W Jefferson St, Ste 102 Boise, ID 83702

Mailing address: P.O. Box 2139 Boise, ID 83701·2139 apb@idahowaters.com smd@idahowuters.com

Chas. F. McDevitt P.O. Box 1543 Boise, ID 83701 chas@mcdevitt.org

Garri.ck B.axter Deputy Atrom·ey General IDAHO 0HPAR™ENT OF W ATP.R. RESOURCES 322 E Front St Boise, ID 83702

Mailing a.ddres$: P.O. Box 83720 Boise, JD 83720.()098 garrick. baxter@id\\T.idaho.gov

Pt:'J'JTION FOR Rt:HF.hlUNG :,0, f 51/ 12&S9396,. 4

U.S. Mail Hand Del.ivercd Overnight Mail Facsimile: 208-629M7559 Effmail

U.S. Mail Hand Delivered Overnight Mail Facsimile: 208·344-6034 £..mail

U. S. Mail Hand Delivered Overnight Meil Facsimile; F, .. mail

U.S. Mail Hand Delivered Overnight Mail Facsimile: 208-287M6700 E~mail

~ e C-----____ Michael P. Lawrence

Page 4 of4