Digital Video Planetary Imaging with a Dobsonian Telescope · 7 Film Camera - late 1800s to ~1980s...
Transcript of Digital Video Planetary Imaging with a Dobsonian Telescope · 7 Film Camera - late 1800s to ~1980s...
Digital Video Planetary Imaging
with a Dobsonian Telescope
WOLAS 10-6-2012 © Martin Lewis Nov. 2015 1 Martin Lewis (www.Skyinspector.co.uk)
2
Planetary Imaging
© Martin Lewis Nov. 2015
• Methods of Recording Planetary Details
• Lucky Imaging of Planets with Digital Video Cameras- Overview
• Video Planetary Imaging with a Dobsonian Telescope?
• Progressive Refinement of Imaging Methods
3
Recording Planetary Surface Detail- Methods
© Martin Lewis Nov. 2015
4
Recording Planetary Surface Detail – Methods
• Sketching at the Eyepiece
• Film camera
• CCD camera
• Digital camera
• Digital Video imaging
© Martin Lewis Nov. 2015
5
Sketching at the Eyepiece - 1600’s to present
• Low tech, low cost
• Able to make the most of fleeting moments of good seeing to pick out fine detail
• Brain is able to effectively average out some of the movement effects of a turbulent atmosphere
© Martin Lewis Nov. 2015
Giovanni Cassini 1677 Sketch of Jupiter
6
Sketching at the Eyepiece - 1600’s to present
Jupiter 9/6/93, 10” Dob. ML
• Can be difficult to quickly record fine details accurately before planetary rotation becomes significant especially for Jupiter
• High levels of skill needed to make quick and accurate drawings of planets – can take years to develop this skill
• Prone to subjectivity and suggestion - Martian canals
7
Film Camera - late 1800’s to ~1980’s
• Less subjective than sketching
• But generally, can see much more by eye at eyepiece than can record on film
• Small image size at prime focus and scattering of light in film causes loss of contrast unless use eyepiece projection or barlow to enlarge image then longer image exposures cause blurring
© Martin Lewis Nov. 2015
AA Common 1867; 1st known photo of a planet showing surface details
8
Film Camera - late 1800’s to ~1980’s
• Dimness esp. due to enlargement, necessitates exposures of several seconds making method prone to blurring by movement of atmosphere and placing big demands on tracking accuracy.
• Have to estimate position of best focus - lot of luck required
Pic du Midi 1m scope 1988
© Martin Lewis Nov. 2015
200” Hale telescope
9
CCD Imaging - 1980’s to ~2000
• CCD are like reusable electronic film
• No emulsion scattering issues and higher sensitivity compared to film which allows short exposures at reasonable image scale – so reducing blurring by atmosphere
• Can take many more individual images than with film and reject most- with this method one can readily home-in on the position of best focus
• Electronic image so easier to carry out imaging processing techniques that allow image enhancement and methods like stacking of individual images
• Electronic medium allows easy distribution of images
• CCD cameras relatively expensive
© Martin Lewis Nov. 2015
10
Digital Camera - 1990’s to present
• Similar to CCD imaging with similar advantage but much cheaper than CCDs now- no need for cooled chip of CCD as exposures so short
• Quick to see results and so quick to home-in on focus
• Recent camera developments allow live view and video imaging at high fps
© Martin Lewis Nov. 2015
11
Digital Video Imaging - ~2000 to present
• Has the potential to pull out significantly more detail than any other method
• No other method comes close to video imaging in terms of accuracy and detail
……. and still evolving with better cameras and processing methods coming along all the time!
© Martin Lewis Nov. 2015
12 © Martin Lewis Nov. 2015 © Damian Peach
13
Digital Video Imaging – Introduction
© Martin Lewis Nov. 2015
14
Digital Video Imaging – Introduction
• Low-cost uncooled CCD digital video camera (webcam) used to take thousands of separate frames of planet which are combined to make one final combined image
• Not just the recording method. The whole process relies on the combination of video camera AND special processing software.
The venerable and once very popular Philips Toucam webcam with its colour Sony 098 chip ready for action!
© Martin Lewis Nov. 2015
15
Digital Video Imaging – Introduction
• Video imaging method uses software to;
• Align separate frames
• Put frames in quality order
• Reject worst frames
• Stack the best frames to produce an averaged and low-noise image where atmospheric disturbances is averaged out
• Stacked average image can then be image-processed revealing detail which was initially hidden
© Martin Lewis Nov. 2015
16
Digital Video Imaging - Advantages
• Video camera fairly low cost and key processing software is free!
• Relatively simple to get started
• Good results possible with fairly minimal learning but great capacity to take further
• Best planetary imagers need to develop skills in a wide range of different disciplines and this makes it really challenging and interesting;
• optics
• video processing
• still image processing
• mechanics
• thermal management
• weather/atmosphere
© Martin Lewis Nov. 2015
17
Digital Video Imaging - Overview of Method
© Martin Lewis Nov. 2015
18
Digital Video Imaging Overview – Min. Equipment
laptop
Firewire/USB/Ethernet
connection for high data
transfer rate
Video
camera Filter wheel (for
mono camera)
Barlow or
Powermate
Motorised
Focusser
Plus •1.25” to camera adaptor •IR/UV filter
Tracking Mount
TELESCOPE
19
Digital Video Imaging Overview - Lucky Imaging
Overview of the Lucky Imaging process
• What a real planetary video looks like
• Unprocessed Video of Mars (red filter) from 26th Jan 2010.
• 2000 frame video
• See how the brain picks out the fleeting details
© Martin Lewis Nov. 2015
20 © Martin Lewis Nov. 2015
21
Lucky Imaging – Quality Sorting
Best red frame out of whole avi of 2000 frames
-not as good as ‘mentally filtered’ impression!
© Martin Lewis Nov. 2015
Lucky Imaging – Quality Sort
Best of 2000 frames
Worst of 2000 frames
1201st Worst Frame
Align and Stack this Range
• Registax or AutoStakkert!2 sorts the frames of the video in quality order
• Pick the best 1200 out of 2000 total frames
1200th Worst Frame
Reject this Range
23
Lucky Imaging – Align and Stack
Best of 2000 frames Worst of 1200 stack
Stack of 1200 frames
© Martin Lewis Nov. 2015
• Align and Stack best 1200 frames
Aligned Stack of 1200 best frames. -Noise reduced -Atmospheric turbulence averaged out
24
Lucky Imaging – Wavelet Processing
Stacked image wavelet processed in Registax (Red)
Stack of 1200 best frames.
© Martin Lewis Nov. 2015
25
Lucky Imaging – Colour Images
Taken through Blue filter
–quality sorted/aligned/stacked image wavelet processed
Taken through Red filter
–quality sorted/aligned/stacked image wavelet processed
Taken through Green filter
–quality sorted/aligned/stacked image wavelet processed
© Martin Lewis Nov. 2015
26
Video Imaging – RGB Colour Method
© Martin Lewis Nov. 2015
27
Video Imaging – Two Methods of Getting Colour
• Traditionally Monochrome video cameras with changeable colour filters in front produced superior results;
• Superior dyes in dedicated filters with more controlled band-pass
• 3x as many pixels for each colour so better resolution
• More light per colour per frame so less noise
• Colour video cameras with colour filters incorporated into the chip are simpler and much quicker and now much improved
Colour Camera Mono Camera + RGB filters 1/3/2012
28
Video Imaging with a Dobsonian though??
© Martin Lewis Nov. 2015
29
The Dobsonian Design
•To help popularise astronomy, John Dobson, a Californian monk, invented a simple low cost alt-azimuth mount for a Newtonian reflector to allow the largest aperture to be built for the lowest cost •The ‘Sidewalk Astronomers’ took the scopes around the streets of San Francisco at night showing people the heavens
30
Dobsonian Design
The mount revolutionised astronomy and made large aperture scopes much more affordable •Very stable alt-az mount •Undriven •Push-To follow with no tracking
31
Dobsonian Variants
Traditional solid tube
Truss tube
BIG!
Small
Ultra-light
Original
32
222mm Dobsonian ‘Mr. Orb Inspector’
© Martin Lewis Nov. 2015
33
Video Imaging with a Dobsonian
• The frame to frame alignment capability of Registax and AS2 means that there is not the requirement to keep the planet absolutely stationary in the field during recording of the video
• Planet’s image just needs to be somewhere in the field
• But a Dobsonian telescope has no drive capability at all so image will drift out in a few seconds won’t it ??
© Martin Lewis Nov. 2015
34
Video Imaging with a Dobsonian – Drift Method
Drift Method (May 2005)
• Allow planet to drift through field and record video as drifts from one side of field to other side
• Reposition scope to start and repeat drifts until have a few hundred frames
• Process videos in Registax as a set
• Drift video 22th June 2005
© Martin Lewis Nov. 2015
35 © Martin Lewis Nov. 2015
36
Video Imaging with a Dobsonian – Drift Method
Jupiter using drift method June 2005 with colour Toucam
© Martin Lewis Nov. 2015
37
Video Imaging with a Dobsonian – Drift Method
• Very simple method to get you going on any undriven scope
• Field drift approx. 15” per second
• Short exposures of <1/30 sec give <0.5arcsecs of smear
• Small image size otherwise get too few frames per drift
• Need to work quickly to minimise rotation of planet (esp. Jupiter)
• No compensation for field rotation
© Martin Lewis Nov. 2015
38
Video Imaging with a Dob. – Eq. Platform Method
• Drift method can only take you so far
• Image scale is low
• Noisy images as too few frames
• In Autumn 2005 decided to improve my imaging by designing and making an equatorial platform
• With my Dobsonian mounted on this platform it should allow me to track the planet
• Targeted the 2005/2006 apparition of Mars for completion of equatorial platform
© Martin Lewis Nov. 2015
39 © Martin Lewis Nov. 2015
39
40
Video Imaging with a Dob. – Eq. Platform Method
• Platform has a virtual rotational axis which has to be carefully aligned with the earth’s axis – it must point at the Celestial Pole
• Anything placed on the driven platform follows the rotation of the sky
• Very stable as bearing surfaces so far apart and very low
• Retains the easy alt-az scope movement that is so appealing with a Dobsonian scope but with the benefits of tracking
© Martin Lewis Nov. 2015
41
Equatorial Platforms – Simples
Lat=52°
•Large Cone with base angle = 2x latitude
© Martin Lewis Nov. 2015
42
Equatorial Platforms – Simples
•On ground with axis at latitude angle
© Martin Lewis Nov. 2015
43
Equatorial Platforms – Simples
•Constrain with rollers on brackets on each side so cone can only rotate about axis
© Martin Lewis Nov. 2015
44
Equatorial Platforms – Simples
•Point axis at celestial pole and rotate with sidereal period to match stars
© Martin Lewis Nov. 2015
45
Equatorial Platforms – Simples
•Cut off parallel with ground and fill scoop shape to make a flat and level platform
•Anything placed on platform will follow the stars
© Martin Lewis Nov. 2015
46
Commercial Equatorial Platforms
• Tom Osypowski, California, US, www.equatorialplatforms.com @ $1000+
© Martin Lewis Nov. 2015
47 © Martin Lewis Nov. 2015
48 © Martin Lewis Nov. 2015 48
49
Video Imaging with a Dob. – Eq. Platform Method
Mars 18th Nov 2005
First images of Mars with scope on Eq. Platform
with Toucam Colour camera
© Martin Lewis Nov. 2015
50
Video Imaging with a Dob. – Eq. Platform Method
Equatorial Platform 11th May 2006 Drift Method 22nd June 2005
• More frames in given time so lower noise
• More frames and larger images scale so more detail visible
© Martin Lewis Nov. 2015
51
Refinement of the Imaging Method
© Martin Lewis Nov. 2015
52
• Color video cameras simpler to use and quicker to get results
• But B&W (mono) video cameras with changeable colour filters in front produced superior results
• Superior dyes in dedicated filters
• 3x as many pixels for each colour
• More light per colour per frame
• Mono-rechipped Toucam bought in early 2006
© Martin Lewis Nov. 2015
Further Improvements to Method – From Colour to Mono
53
Further Improvements to Method – From Colour to Mono
Eq. Platform and Mono-rechipped Toucam (610nm filter)
Eq. Platform and Standard Colour Toucam
Both 17th Feb. 2006
© Martin Lewis Nov. 2015
54
Further Improvements – Addressing Vibration
• Improvements made to eq. platform motor vibration (2009)
© Martin Lewis Nov. 2015
55
Further Improvements to Methods – Vibration
• Very low motor vibration is a key characteristic of any tracking mount when video imaging planets. Much less important than tracking accuracy
• Normally won’t even notice vibration Visually or Deep Sky work but when need resolutions of <0.5” for high resolution planetary imaging the impact can be large
• Should certainly be no vibration felt in body of scope and very little by motor
© Martin Lewis Nov. 2015
• Detection presence of vibration problems by ‘star dance’ method
56
Further Improvements to Methods – Vibration
Tapped eyepiece at high power - no vibration
Tapped eyepiece at high power – vibration present
© Martin Lewis Nov. 2015
57
Further Improvements to Methods – Vibration
• Stepper motor replaced with turntable synchronous motor driven under-voltage
• Introduced worm and wheel into gearing path to improve mechanical isolation
• Motor is spring isolated
• New design of low power synchronous motor drive electronics designed by work colleague (Steve Markham)
© Martin Lewis Nov. 2015
58 4th May 2010 Edge-on Saturn after improvements to platform vibration
59
Further Improvements to Methods – Sensitivity
• Increasing the image surface brightness allows one to push forward in a number of ways to improve image resolution;
• Larger image size without excessive reduction in surface brightness
• Faster frame rate without being limited by exposure time. More frames = less noise and better averaging
• Less shot noise
• To improve image brightness
• Get a larger scope - also improves inherent resolution ££££
• Get a more sensitive camera - Sony 618 chip has twice the sensitivity of previous popular chips
© Martin Lewis Nov. 2015
60 21st Sept 2010
Jupiter with 618 chipped Imaging Source camera showing detail in Ganymede
© Martin Lewis Nov. 2015 60
61
Saturn 10th April 2011
© Martin Lewis Nov. 2015 61
62
Further Improvements to Methods – Image Scale
• Improved sensitivity allows improved image scale
• f35.7 = 7.9m fl & f22.3 = 5.0m fl
© Martin Lewis Nov. 2015
63
Further Improvements to Methods – Use of ADC
• Prismatic effects of atmosphere especially at low altitude means a positional offset for R, G and B
© Martin Lewis Nov. 2015
64
Further Improvements to Methods – Use of ADC
• Registax can realign the separate R,G &B channels BUT
• When the dispersion is bad then you get vertical smearing within each colour band
Polaris (alt 52°) showing dispersion effects
65
Further Improvements to Methods – ADC
• Severity of dispersion effects depends on object altitude, wavelength and the width of filter bandpass
• Colour filters reduce dispersion effects but are significant in blue for all planet altitudes from UK (<60°)
Ju
pite
r 20
15
© Jean-Pierre Prost
Sa
turn
20
15
0.4” resolution limit
66
Further Improvements to Methods – Use of ADC
• Atmospheric Dispersion Corrector (ADC) to correct for prismatic effects of atmosphere by applying opposite dispersion to that caused by atmosphere
Astro Systems Holland
© Martin Lewis Nov. 2015
Pierro Astro ZWO
67
Further Improvements to Methods – ADC
© Martin Lewis Nov. 2015
68 © Martin Lewis Nov. 2015
69
Further Improvements to Methods – ADC
Jupiter & Callisto 13th Jan 2012
Jupiter 22nd Nov. 2011
Smallest features ~0.4” across (image scale=0.18pix/arc sec)
© Martin Lewis Nov. 2015
70
Further Improvements to Methods – ADC
© Martin Lewis Nov. 2015
71
Mars 2012 Albedo Maps
© Martin Lewis Nov. 2015
72
Mars –Opposition, Winter 2007/2008
© Martin Lewis Nov. 2015
Winjupos to unwrap globes and form map
73
Mars –Winter/Spring 2010
© Martin Lewis Nov. 2015
74
Mars –Winter/Spring 2010 (top) v Spring 2012 (bottom)
© Martin Lewis Nov. 2015
26th Jan 2010 14.1” after vibration fixed
24th Mar 2010 13.1” with 618 chip & ADC & Pipp
Mars –Spring 2012
75 © Martin Lewis Nov. 2015
76
Mars – Spring 2012
© Martin Lewis Nov. 2015
77
Mars –Spring 2012
© Martin Lewis Nov. 2015
78 © Martin Lewis Nov. 2015
79
Further Improvements to Methods – Winjupos Derotation
Winjupos is a multipurpose Swiss Army knife for planetary imaging. Originally designed to map the movements of Jupiter’s cloud belts the program can now do all sorts of other useful things; •Ephemeris for planets and their moons with graphical representation •Creation of planetary maps by unwrapping globe •Creation of rotational videos based on standard or created maps •Derotation of videos •Derotation of RGB images
© Martin Lewis Nov. 2015
80
Further Improvements to Methods – Winjupos Derotation
Derotation feature is especially useful for Jupiter. Rotational period is so short that to prevent blurring of the image all videos need to be gathered within about 2mins. Derotation feature allows you to extend the time window enormously
© Martin Lewis Nov. 2015
81
Further Improvements to Methods – Winjupos Derotation
•R 1min 3600 frames at 60fps •G 1min 3600 frames at 60fps •B 1min 1800 frames at 30fps •R 1min 3600 frames at 60fps •G 1min 3600 frames at 60fps •B 1min 1800 frames at 30fps •R 1min 3600 frames at 60fps •G 1min 3600 frames at 60fps •B 1min 1800 frames at 30fps •Process each video to create R, G or B images •Combine all Reds using image derotate •Combine all Greens using image derotate •Combine all Blues using image derotate •Finally Combine R, G & B with RGB derotate
© Martin Lewis Nov. 2015
82
Further Improvements to Methods – Winjupos Derotation
© Martin Lewis Nov. 2015
83 © Martin Lewis Nov. 2015
© Max Alexander
22nd June 2005 17th Dec 2012
Same 8 ¾” Telescope!
Drift Method with Toucam Eq. Platform (vibration reduced), Sony 618
chip camera, ADC, + Winjupos derotate
85
Where Then?
© Martin Lewis Nov. 2015
In early 2013 decided that had reached the limits of my 222mm scope but not the limits of my ambition! I needed a bigger planetary scope!
86
Where Then?
© Martin Lewis Nov. 2015
In early 2013 decided that had reached the limits of my 222mm scope but not the limits of my ambition! I needed a bigger planetary scope! Fortunately I had one.....
87
Fossil Light 444mm Dobsonian
© Martin Lewis Nov. 2015
88
18” on equatorial platform- 1st try on 9th Jan 2013
89
18” on equatorial platform- 1st used 9th Jan. 2013
90
2013 season
© Martin Lewis Nov. 2015
•Jan. 2013 was right at end of 2012/2013 Jupiter apparition 2012/2013 •Saturn that year I used my trusty 222mm Dobsonian and a newer, faster higher sensitivity colour CMOS based camera that had been recently launched by ZWO in China •Even though colour camera it gave great images when used with the ADC -even for Saturn at 27°
91
2013
© Martin Lewis Nov. 2015
92
2014
93
2014
© Martin Lewis Nov. 2015
•Decided to use 18” as much as possible on Jupiter and Mars in 2014 •Colour versus mono comparisons kept defying received wisdom that you get the best colour images using a mono camera and filters
ASI120MC (colour) ASI120MM (mono + RGB filters)
94
2014
© Martin Lewis Nov. 2015
ZWO ASI120MC colour camera gave great images & much less trouble than mono RGB
ASI120MM (mono + RGB filters)
95
2014
© Martin Lewis Nov. 2015
•With the good results on Jupiter with the 18” + colour camera + ADC combo I decided to use this combination for Mars apparition in 2014
15th April 2014 15th May 2014
96
2014
© Martin Lewis Nov. 2015
•Saturn was still better with the 222mm scope but the lower altitude was making imaging it difficult
Best of 2014 (23° alt.) Best of 2013 (27° alt.)
2014
•After Saturn had gone from the evening skies there would be a long break until Jupiter came round
•Took the opportunity to get Es Reid to improve the figure on my mirror –removing ~1/6 wave of overcorrection •Did a lot of work on improving the thermal management of the scope as well as big improvements to the mirror edge support which I think was causing issues with low alt. planets like Saturn.
98
2015
2015
•Jupiter with new larger format colour ASI camera with larger pixels (ASI174MC)
Jupiter and Ganymede 14th April Jupiter 23rd April
2015
•Colour camera versus mono RGB again!
ASI174MC colour ASI174MM mono RGB
2015
•Also experimented with better barlows including a lovely 2.7x APM barlow which was better corrected than my 3x TV and 2.5x and 5x Powermates •Doubled-up, two 2.7x APM cells together give 6x magnification
2015
•Also experimented with IR imaging using a new Astronomiks 642nm filter
2015
•Methane filter (890nm 10nm bandpass) from ZWO on Jupiter well past its best
2015
•ASI174MM did well in UV and IR on Venus
105 © Martin Lewis Nov. 2015
2015
•Venus in UV and IR in 2015
106 © Martin Lewis Nov. 2015
9th July
13th May 3rd June 23rd June
30th July
2015
•The ASI174 when combined with the refigured mirror and improved mirror support gave my best ever Saturn image at an altitude of only 20°!
2015
•Another new camera from ZWO was the highly sensitive and ultra low noise ASI224 colour camera which is very sensitive in the IR
108 © Martin Lewis Nov. 2015
2016?
•Venus best at end of year •Mars close, but very low at opposition at alt. 16° •Make the most of Jupiter 44° alt. at opposition •Saturn very low at opposition at alt. 18°
109 © Martin Lewis Nov. 2015
Planetary Imaging of DSOs?
•An exciting new possibility with the ASI224MC is to use thousands of short exposure photos and high gain to take shots of DSOs using planetary imaging align and stack techniques
110 © Martin Lewis Nov. 2015 ASI124MC 360 frames at 0.25secs exp. 2min total
111