University of California, Los Angeles

Digital Scholarship and Digital Libraries: Past,Present, and Future

Digital Scholarship and Digital Libraries: !Past, Present, and Future"

Christine L. Borgman!Professor and Presidential Chair in Information Studies!University of California, Los Angeles!

Keynote Presentation!17th International Conference on Theory and Practice of Digital Libraries!Valletta, Malta, September 22-26, 2013!

!"#$%&'&()#*'+*,-*%#".+)%+/",)*0",+#&//1%)#*2&%+

3&4(/*%5+67+875+9:"'.&%5+;75+<)4=.5+875+>&$%.&%5+?75+@&",)%("45+@7+?75+8)%%5+A7+675+B+CD*'*E5+97+FGHHIJ7+!"#$%&'()*+%,&('()*'(*$-%*.%$/"&0%1*2"&314*5-%*678%&3%,&('()*9::"&$;('$7*,(1*6-,33%()%<*K*2&%*'+C#)"%#"+L&1%,*2&%7+$MNOPPQQQ7%.R7(&-PN1:')#*2&%.PN1:S.1//7T.NU&,.S="EV%.RHIGHW+

+X/*("O+>)'')*%+Y*'').+*%,+?&E+Z"*+

G+

=')'$,3*#>-"3,&#-':+"%#&/N*..".+0$"+0&&'.5+."4-)#".5+*%,+)%R4*.041#014"+0$*0+.1NN&40+4"."*4#$+)%+*%E+*%,+*''+["',.+&R+.01,E7++

K""')"+@4&".5+\Z+]14&N"*%+6&//)..)&%O+

•  !&+#&''"#05+#14*0"5+N4"."4-"+*%,+/*="+*-*)'*:'"+"-"4^)%#4"*.)%(+*/&1%0.+&R+.#)"%2[#+,*0*5+%"Q+0EN".+&R+)%R4*.041#014".+Q)''+:"+%"",",7+!$"+N&0"%2*'+:"%"[0.+*4"+"%&4/&1.+:10+0$"+.*/"+).+041"+R&4+0$"+#&.0.7+Y"+0$"4"R&4"+%"",+0&+'*E+0$"+4)($0+R&1%,*2&%.+*%,+0$"+.&&%"4+Q"+.0*40+0$"+:"M"47++

_+

Y&&,5+>75+9%,"4..&%5+!75+3*#$"/5+975+3".05+675+`"%&-*5+L75+8&N"D5+<7+?75+B+;1,.&%5+?7+87+FGHaHJ7+?'1'()*$-%*/,@%4*A"/*B;&":%*>,(*),'(*C&"D*$-%*&'#'()*E1%*"C*#>'%(EF>*1,$,7+L)%*'+4"N&40+&R+0$"+;)($+8"-"'+]bN"40+`4&1N+&%+C#)"%2[#+<*0*7+?"04)"-",+R4&/+$MNOPP#&4,).7"14&N*7"1PRNcP)#0P"^)%R4*.041#014"P,&#.P$'(^.,)^4"N&407N,R+

+

dN"%+*##"..+N&')#)".+•  ]14&N"*%+e%)&%+

–  ]14&N"*%+dN"%+<*0*+6$*''"%("+–  Z&')#E+?]6&//"%,*2&%.+R&4+dN"%+9##"..+0&+?"."*4#$+<*0*+)%+]14&N"+–  ?),)%(+0$"+Q*-"O+;&Q+]14&N"+#*%+(*)%+R4&/+0$"+4).)%(+2,"+&R+.#)"%2[#+,*0*+–  dN"%9X?]+

•  ?"."*4#$+6&1%#)'.+&R+0$"+e@+–  dN"%+*##"..+N1:').$)%(+4"f1)4"/"%0.+–  Z4&-).)&%.+R&4+*##"..+0&+,*0*+

•  Y"''#&/"+!41.0+–  dN"%+*##"..+N1:').$)%(+–  <*0*+.$*4)%(+4"f1)4"/"%0.+

•  K*2&%*'+C#)"%#"+L&1%,*2&%+–  <*0*+.$*4)%(+4"f1)4"/"%0.+–  <*0*+/*%*("/"%0+N'*%.+

•  e7C7+L","4*'+N&')#E^GHag+–  dN"%+*##"..+0&+N1:')#*2&%.+–  dN"%+*##"..+0&+,*0*+

h+

3)(+<*0*5+8)M'"+<*0*5+K&+<*0*O+C#$&'*4.$)N+)%+0$"+K"0Q&4=",+Y&4',+

•  C"#2&%+XO+<*0*+*%,+C#$&'*4.$)N++–  6$+aO+3)(+C#$&'*4.$)N5+8)M'"+C#$&'*4.$)N+++–  6$+GO+<*0*^X%0"%.)-"+C#$&'*4.$)N++–  6$+gO+Y$*0+*4"+<*0*U+++

•  C"#2&%+XXO+!$"+<)-"4.)0E+&R+<*0*O+6*."+C01,)".+–  6$+WO+C#)"%#"O+9.04&%&/E5+C"%.&4^%"0Q&4=",+.#)"%#"+–  6$+_O+C&#)*'+C#)"%#"O+C14-"E.PC&#)*'+K"0Q&4=.i+j1*')0*2-"+.01,)".+–  6$+hO+;1/*%)2".O+<)()0*'+#&''"#2&%.i+31,,$).0+.01,)".++

•  C"#2&%+XXX+<*0*+Z&')#E+*%,+Z4*#2#"+++–  6$+cO+C1NN'EO+?"'"*.)%(+*%,+C$*4)%(+<*0*++–  6$+IO+<"/*%,O+?"1.)%(+*%,+?"N14N&.)%(+<*0*+–  6$+kO+64",)05+9M4):12&%5+*%,+<).#&-"4E++–  6$+aHO+X%0&+0$"+L1014"O+Y$*0+0&+@""N+

c+

!$"&4)".+*%,+0$"/".+

a7  dN"%+.#$&'*4.$)N+).+0$"+%&4/++

G7  L&4/*'+*%,+)%R&4/*'+.#$&'*4'E+#&//1%)#*2&%+*4"+#&%-"4()%(+

g7  <*0*+N4*#2#".+*4"+'&#*'++W7  dN"%+*##"..+0&+,*0*+).+*+N*4*,)(/+.$)l++

I+

a7+dN"%+.#$&'*4.$)N+).+0$"+%&4/+

$MNOPPQQQ7*%.N7&4(PmP/",)*PX/*(".P*%.P"bN'&4"P&%')%"^"b$):)0.P.0&4)".PN$)'&.&N$)#*'^04*%.*#2&%.^-aS_aH7*.$b+ k+

34)#=.+)%+0$"+Q*''B+

34)#=+)%.#4):",+Q)0$+0$"+C104*+&%+<"N"%,"%0+d4)()%*2&%+G"&,0-:;&*1'#$&'>$H*3,$%*I$-*>%($;&7*J*%,&37*K$-*>%($;&7*L=<*L#-D"3%,(*M;#%;D+

aH+

dN"%+*##"..+N1:').$)%(+

aa+

dN"%+,).."/)%*2&%+

aG+

dN"%+,*0*+*%,+&N"%+&%0&'&()".+

ag+

dN"%+,*0*+#&''*:&4*2&%.+

aW+

A)#4&+,).04):12&%+&R+4"."*4#$+&:T"#0.+

a_+

dN"%+*##"..+*n01,".+

•  3"("0.+4)(&14+•  Z4"-"%0.+R4*1,+•  CN"",.+0$"+N*#"+&R+4"."*4#$+•  3"("0.+R4""+4),"4.+•  ?).=.+/).1."+*%,+*%,+/).)%0"4N4"0*2&%+•  \)&'*0".+0$"+#&%[,"%2*')0E+&R+$1/*%+.1:T"#0.+•  ?*).".+#&%o)#0.+:"0Q""%+N&')#)".+&R+1%)-"4.)2".5+R1%,"4.5+N1:').$"4.5+*%,+4"."*4#$+N*40%"4.+

•  X+,&%p0+,&+,*0*+

ah+

G7+L&4/*'+*%,+)%R&4/*'+.#$&'*4'E+#&//1%)#*2&%+*4"+#&%-"4()%(+

ac+`*4-"E5+Y7+<75+q+`4)r0$5+37+67+FakhWJ7+C#)"%2[#+)%R&4/*2&%+"b#$*%("+)%+N.E#$&'&(E7+N>'%(>%5+OPK5+ah__sah_k7+L)(14"+4",4*Q%+:E+>767+Y*'').+R&4+3&4(/*%5+67+87+FGHHcJ7+N>-"3,&#-':*'(*$-%*=')'$,3*L)%4*Q(C"&D,E"(H*Q(C&,#$&;>$;&%H*,(1*$-%*Q($%&(%$7+6*/:4),("5+A9O+AX!+Z4"..7+

`*4-"E5+Y7+<75+q+`4)r0$5+37+67+FakhWJ7+C#)"%2[#+)%R&4/*2&%+"b#$*%("+)%+N.E#$&'&(E7+N>'%(>%5+OPK5+ah__sah_k7+L)(14"+4",4*Q%+:E+>767+Y*'').+R&4+3&4(/*%5+67+87+FGHHcJ7+N>-"3,&#-':*'(*$-%*=')'$,3*L)%4*Q(C"&D,E"(H*Q(C&,#$&;>$;&%H*,(1*$-%*Q($%&(%$7+6*/:4),("5+A9O+AX!+Z4"..7+

64",)0+R&4+R&4/*'+.#$&'*4'E+#&//1%)#*2&%+

•  j1*')0E+&R+#&%0"%0+•  6)0*2&%.+0&+*42#'"+•  6)0*2&%.+0&+T&14%*'+•  ?"-)"Q.+&R+:&&=.+•  <"4)-",+/"04)#.+

–  X/N*#0+R*#0&4.+

– ;^)%,"b+

aI+

64",)0+R&4+)%R&4/*'+.#$&'*4'E+#&//1%)#*2&%+

!!

Pepe, A., Mayernik, M. S., Borgman, C. L. & Van de Sompel, H. (2010). From Artifacts to Aggregations: Modeling Scientific Life Cycles on the Semantic Web. Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology, 61(3): 567–582."

http://www.itadvicex.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/05/blogs-5.jpg!

http://datalib.ed.ac.uk/GRAPHICS/blue_data.gif!

http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-bJ29MM_7Nuk/UBzpOz2JXPI/AAAAAAAAAfA/vDpCD2dW0iE/s1600/GS_Code_Example.png

64",)0+R&4+)%R&4/*'+.#$&'*4'E+#&//1%)#*2&%+

•  9'0/"04)#.+–  <&Q%'&*,.+&R+*42#'".5+N4"N4)%0.5+:&&=.B+–  !Q""0.+*%,+4"0Q""0.+*:&10+N"4.&%5+N1:.5+"0#7+–  `4*%0.+4"#")-",+–  3'&(+N&.0.+–  6)0*2&%.+0&+,*0*+–  6)0*2&%.+0&+.&lQ*4"+–  ]bN"4)/"%0*'+,".)(%.+–  !*'=.+–  C'),".+–  L)(14".+–  !*:'".+–  B7+

64",)0+R&4+)%R&4/*'+.#$&'*4'E+#&//1%)#*2&%+

Pepe, A., Mayernik, M. S., Borgman, C. L. & Van de Sompel, H. (2010). From Artifacts to Aggregations: Modeling Scientific Life Cycles on the Semantic Web. Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology, 61(3): 567–582."

Ga+

<*0*+6)0*2&%+*%,+9M4):12&%+

GG+

e$')45+Z7+L7+F],7J7+FGHaGJ7+!"&*LR&'8;E"(*JJ*=%@%3":'()*=,$,*LR&'8;E"(*,(1*6'$,E"(*S&,>E>%#*,(1*N$,(1,&1#4*

N;DD,&7*"C*,(*Q($%&(,E"(,3*2"&0#-":7+Y*.$)%(0&%5+<767O+!$"+K*2&%*'+9#*,"/)".+Z4"..7+?"04)"-",+R4&/+$MNOPPQQQ7%*N7",1P#*0*'&(7N$NU4"#&4,S),Vag_hW+

+<*0*+C#)"%#"+>&14%*'5+\&'1/"+aG5+ag+C"N0"/:"4+GHag+

g7+<*0*+N4*#2#".+*4"+'&#*'+

3)(+,*0*O+\&'1/"5+\*4)"0E5+\"'&#)0E+

Gg+

GW+

8&%(+0*)'+&R+,*0*+\&'1/

"+&R+,*0*+

K1/:"4+&R+4"."*4#$"4.+

C'),"O+!$"+X%.2010"+R&4+]/N&Q"4)%(+8&%(+!*)'+?"."*4#$+G_+

http://www.census.gov/population/cen2000/map02.gif"

Y$*0+*4"+,*0*U+

ncl.ucar.edu"http://onlineqda.hud.ac.uk/Intro_QDA/Examples_of_Qualitative_Data.php"

Marie Curie’s notebook aip.org"

hudsonalpha.org"

K9C9+9.04&%&/E+Z)#014"+&R+0$"+<*E+

Gh+

?*%("+&R+,*0*+N4*#2#".+

X%,1.04)*'+/"0$&,.+ 942.*%*'+/"0$&,.+

Gc+

GI+

29!

C"%.&4+%"0Q&4=",+.#)"%#"+

Slide by Jason Fisher, UC-Merced gH+

NIMS!transect!velocity distribution!nitrate distribution!

C"%.&4+%"0Q&4=+,*0*"

C&#)*'+.#)"%#"+,*0*+

$MNOPP,..7N4)%#"0&%7",1P)/*(".P(..7()R+ gG+

;1/*%)2".+,*0*+

34)#=+)%.#4):",+Q)0$+0$"+C104*+&%+<"N"%,"%0+d4)()%*2&%+G"&,0-:;&*1'#$&'>$H*3,$%*I$-*>%($;&7*J*%,&37*K$-*>%($;&7*L=<*L#-D"3%,(*M;#%;D+

t*##$"n5+C7+FGHH_J7+X%+Z4*)."+&R+0$"+8)($0O+9+64)2#*'+CE%&N2#+],)2&%+Q)0$+*%+9%%&0*0",+!4*%.'*2&%+&R+6$*N0"4.+a^g+&R+<$*4/*4*=.*p.+`1*%(+D*%+T)%(5+3")%(+0$"+]*4')".0+6$)%"."+!4*%.'*2&%+&R+0$"+8*4("4+Z4*T%*N*4*/)0*7+!&=E&5+>*N*%O+!$"+X%0"4%*2&%*'+?"."*4#$+X%.2010"+R&4+9,-*%#",+31,,$&'&(E5+C&=*+e%)-"4.)0E7+?"04)"-",+R4&/+$MNOPP)4)*:7.&=*7*#7TNP&4#PZ1:')#*2&%.P3ZZ3P)%,"bS3ZZ37$0/'+

+

gg+

C'),"O+9'E..*+`&&,/*%5+;*4-*4,+

W7+dN"%+*##"..+0&+,*0*+).+*+N*4*,)(/+.$)l++

gW+

!$"+6&%1%,41/+&R+C$*4)%(+?"."*4#$+<*0*+

QC*$-%*&%/,&1#*"C*$-%*1,$,*1%3;)%*,&%*$"*8%*&%,:%1H*$-%(*

&%#%,&>-%&#*/-"*:&"1;>%*$-"#%*1,$,*D;#$*#-,&%*$-%DH*

,(1*1"*#"*'(*#;>-*,*/,7*$-,$*$-%*1,$,*,&%*'($%&:&%$,83%*

,(1*&%;#,83%*87*"$-%&#<T*

$MNOPPQQQ70D*%).7&4(P0D*%).:'&(P*4#$)-".P)/*(".PN1.$^N1''^0$1/:7TN(+

u3&4(/*%5+6787+FGHaGJ7++!$"+6&%1%,41/+&R+C$*4)%(+?"."*4#$+<*0*<**U";&(,3*"C*$-%*LD%&'>,(*N">'%$7*"C*

Q(C"&D,E"(*N>'%(>%*,(1*5%>-("3")75+hgFhJOaH_ksaHcI+g_+

?"."*4#$+N4*#2#".+

•  `&*'+).+N1:')#*2&%.+0$*0+4"N&40+0$"+4"."*4#$+•  `&*'+).+,*0*+0$*0+*4"+4"1.*:'"+:E+&0$"4.+

C'),"O+9'E..*+`&&,/*%5+;*4-*4,+gh+

X%,1.04)*'+/"0$&,.+ 942.*%*'+/"0$&,.+

?"N')#*2&%+ X%0"4N4"0*2&%+

<*0*+N4*#2#".+*%,+4"1.*:)')0E+

gc+

•  ?"1."+:E+)%-".2(*0&4+•  ?"1."+:E+#&''*:&4*0&4.+•  ?"1."+:E+#&''"*(1".+•  ?"1."+:E+1%*r')*0",+&0$"4.+•  ?"1."+*0+'*0"4+2/".+

– A&%0$.+–  v"*4.+– <"#*,".+–  6"%014)".+

$MNOPP#$*%,4*7$*4-*4,7",1PN$&0&PGHagP="N'"4P="N'"4S_G_7TN(+

<"(4"".+&R+4"1."+

gI+

<*0*+4"1."+).+,)r#1'0+•  X,"%2RE+•  ?"04)"-"+•  dN"%+•  ?"*,+•  X%0"4N4"0+•  ]-*'1*0"+•  6&/N10"+1N&%+•  ?"N')#*0"+•  6&/:)%"+•  <".#4):"+•  9%%&0*0"+•  8)#"%."P4)($0.+•  Z4&-"%*%#"+•  !41.0+•  9M4):12&%B+

gk+

Y*'').5+>7+675+?&'*%,&5+]75+q+3&4(/*%5+67+87+FGHagJ7+XR+Y"+C$*4"+<*0*5+Y)''+9%E&%"+e."+!$"/U+<*0*+C$*4)%(+*%,+?"1."+)%+0$"+8&%(+!*)'+&R+C#)"%#"+*%,+!"#$%&'&(E7+S+"N*9.B5+VFcJ5+"hcggG7+,&)OaH7agcaPT&14%*'7N&%"7HHhcggG+

+

$MNOPPQQQ7)/R7&4(P"b0"4%*'PN1:.PlPR*%,,P:*.)#.P)/*(".P.1NN,"/S#$07TN(+

C1NN'E+V+#&%2%1)0E5+041.0+

<"/*%,+V+)%-".0/"%05+4).=+

WH+

X%R4*.041#014"+*%,+)%#"%2-".+•  @%&Q'",("+)%R4*.041#014"+)%-".0/"%0.+

–  <*0*+*4#$)-".+–  !&&'.5+."4-)#".5+.1NN&40+–  <*0*+#14*2&%+Q&4=R&4#"+–  <*0*+/*%*("/"%0+04*)%)%(+–  <)()0*'+'):4*4)".+

•  9')(%/"%0+&R+)%#"%2-".+–  <*0*+4"'"*."+–  <*0*+4"1."+–  Z1:').$)%(+–  `4*%0.+*%,+R1%,)%(+–  64",)0+*%,+N4&/&2&%+

$MNOPPG7:N7:'&(.N&07#&/P^RDXvwkDN#eeP!H=91`IgL`XP999999999@(P$(*&0Dg]^^9P.ahHHP)%R4*.041#014"7TN(+ Wa+

aH+C)/N'"+?1'".+R&4+0$"+6*4"+*%,+L"",)%(+&R+C#)"%2[#+<*0*u+

a7  8&-"+E&14+,*0*5+*%,+'"0+&0$"4.+'&-"+)0+0&&7+

G7  C$*4"+E&14+,*0*+&%')%"5+Q)0$+*+N"4/*%"%0+),"%2["47++

g7  6&%,1#0+.#)"%#"+Q)0$+,*0*+4"1."+)%+/)%,7++

W7  Z1:').$+Q&4=o&Q+*.+#&%0"b0++

_7  8)%=+E&14+,*0*+0&+E&14+N1:')#*2&%.+*.+"*4'E+*.+N&..):'"7++

h7  Z1:').$+E&14+#&,"+F"-"%+0$"+./*''+:)0.J7+++

c7  C*E+$&Q+E&1+Q*%0+0&+("0+#4",)0+R&4+E&14+,*0*+F*%,+.&lQ*4"J7++

I7  L&.0"4+*%,+1."+,*0*+4"N&.)0&4)".7++

k7  ?"Q*4,+#&''"*(1".+Q$&+.$*4"+0$")4+,*0*+N4&N"4'E7++

aH7  ;"'N+".0*:').$+x<*0*+C#)"%#"y+*%,+x<*0*+C#)"%2.0.y+*.+-)0*'7++

TG""1D,(H*L<W*S%:%H*L<W*X3">0%&H*L<W*X"&)D,(H*6<+<H*%$*,3H*Y'(*&%@'%/ZH*S+9N*6"D:;$,E"(,3*X'"3")7+ WG+

!$"&4)".+*%,+0$"/".+

a7  dN"%+.#$&'*4.$)N+).+0$"+%&4/++

G7  L&4/*'+*%,+)%R&4/*'+.#$&'*4'E+#&//1%)#*2&%+*4"+#&%-"4()%(+

g7  <*0*+N4*#2#".+*4"+'&#*'++W7  dN"%+*##"..+0&+,*0*+).+*+N*4*,)(/+.$)l++

Wg+

6&%#'1.)&%.O+Y$*0+0&+@""N+

a7  dN"%+.#$&'*4.$)N+).+0$"+%&4/+–  Z1:')#*2&%.+–  <*0*O+#&,"5+,&#1/"%0*2&%5+N4&-"%*%#"++–  8)%=.+:"0Q""%+4"."*4#$+&:T"#0.+

G7  L&4/*'+*%,+)%R&4/*'+.#$&'*4'E+#&//1%)#*2&%+*4"+#&%-"4()%(+

–  L)b",+4"."*4#$+&:T"#0.+–  <E%*/)#+4"."*4#$+&:T"#0.+–  6&%0"b0+*%,+4"'*2&%.$)N.+

WW+

6&%#'1.)&%.O+Y$*0+0&+@""N+

g7  <*0*+N4*#2#".+*4"+'&#*'+–  X%,1.04)*'+N4&#"..".O+,*0*+*4#$)-".+

–  942.*%*'+N4&#"..".O+&4N$*%",+,*0*++

W7  dN"%+*##"..+0&+,*0*+).+*+N*4*,)(/+.$)l+–  6&%,1#0+4"."*4#$+Q)0$+4"1."+)%+/)%,+

–  C0*40+s+%&0+"%,+s+Q)0$+,)()0*'+'):4*4E+."4-)#".+

W_+

Acknowledgements""  UCLA Data Practices team !

"  Rebekah Cummings, Peter Darch, David Fearon, Ariel Hernandez, Matthew Mayernik, Alberto Pepe, Ashley Sands, Katie Shilton, Sharon Traweek, Jillian Wallis, Laura Wynholds, Kan Zhang !

"  Research funding!

"  National Science Foundation!

"  Alfred P. Sloan Foundation!

"  Microsoft External Research!

"  University of Oxford!

"  Balliol College!

"  Oliver Smithies Fellowship!

"  Oxford Internet Institute!

"  Oxford eResearch Center!

"  Bodleian Library!