Dictatorship: Religious and Military

8/18/2019 Dictatorship: Religious and Military

1/31

Annexure-I

UNIVERSITY OF PETROLEUM & ENERGY STUDIESCOLLEGE OF LEGAL STUDIES

BA.,LLB(HONS.) ENERGY LAWS ,SEMESTER II

ACADEMIC YEAR: 2014 -15 SESSION: J ANUARY-M AY

PROJECT

ON

DICTATORSHIP: A COMPARATIVE STUDY BETWEEN RELIGIOUS AND MILITARY

FOR

P!"#"$%! S$"en$e - II

LLBG112'

Un(er #)e Su*er+","n S%. B%/u0 10C0

TO BE FILLED BY THE STUDENT'

NAME: ANI1ET CHATTERJEE

SAP NO: 233345676

ROLL NO: 83

1


2/31

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

I WOULD LIKE TO THANK MY ESTEEMED TEACHER MR. SAMBABU

K.C. FOR GIVING ME THIS OPPURTUNITY TO DO THIS ILLUMINATING

PROJECT FROM WHICH I GLEANED MUCH LEARNING.

2


3/31

TOPIC PAGE

INTRODUCTION

RELIGIOUS DICTATORSHIP

DICTATORSHIP IN IRAN

DICTATORSHIP IN SAUDI ARABIA

MILITARY DICTATORSHIPDICTATORSHIP IN FIJI

DICTATORSHIP IN BURMA

COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS

CONCLUSION

BIBLIOGRAPHY

3

7

8

11

14

16

18

1

6

7

3


4/31

INTRODUCTION

W! "#$! #%% &!!' ("! )#*( ("#( *!+(#,' *-'(+,!& ,' -+ /-&(0-!+' 2-+% #+!

-$!+'! -+ +'5 # &,'%! !'(,( -+ # &,'%! /!+&-'. P-%,(,*#% #("-+,( ,&

0-'-/-%,! ("#( /!+&-' -+ !'(,( #' ("! /-2!+ ,& !9!+*,&! ("+-" $#+,-&

0!*"#',&0& (- :!!/ ("! +%! -) ("#( !'(,( -+ /!+&-'; &(+-' #' '*-'(!&(!.

T",& ,& :'-2' #& DICTATORSHIP.

D,*(#(-+&",/ *#' #%&- ! *#%%! #& #("-+,(#+,#',&01; 2"!+! ("! +,"(& -) ("! 0#&&!&

#+! *+!. T"! +!%#(,-' -) /%,* #' /+,$#(! !"#$,-+ -) ("! *,(,!'& -) ("#(

/#+(,*%#+ &(#(! ,& ,' )-+*!. P-%,(,*#% /+-/##'# ,& (,%,! (- !'-'*! #%(!+'#(!

-$!+',' &&(!0& #' #%&- *+ ("! &/,+,( -) '#(,-'#%,&0.

T"! 0-&( !'!+#% (!+0 ,& !&/-(,&0; 2",*" ,& # )-+0 -) -$!+'0!'( 2",*" # &,'%!

!'(,( +%!& 2,(" #&-%(! /-2!+. T"! !'(,( 0# ! #' ,',$,#%; #& ,' # #(-*+#*;

-+ ,( 0# ! # +-/; #& ,' #' -%,#+*".

D,*(#(-+&",/ *#' ! (+#*! #*: (- ("! 0!,!$#% (,0!&. I' M!,!$#% E+-/!; ("!

C"+*" "!% &2# -$!+ #%% (",'&; 2"!("!+ ("! #,% +'',' -) C#("-%,*

-$!+'0!'(& -+ ("! /%,* %,)! -) /!-/%!. P+-0,'!'( S*,!'(,&(& 2!+! +#'!

"!+!(,*& #' !9*-00',*#(!. F+!!-0 -) &/!!*" 2#& #''!. A' #' %,!%-&

,(!0& ##,'&( ("! *"+*" 0!#'( '!#+ !#(". A /+-0,'!'( !9#0/%! *#' ! ("!

+#',' -) *!+(#,' )!0#%! ,',$,#%& #& 2,(*"!&. T"! 2-% ! +'! (- ("!

&(#:!. T",& 2#& # *%!#+ $,-%#(,-' -) "0#' +,"(&; ( ("#( 2#& 2"#( T"! C"+*"

, ,' ("-&! (,0!&.

1 denotes any po!t!"a syste# t$at "on"ent%ates po&e% !n t$e $ands o' a eade% o% a

s#a e!te t$at !s not "onst!tt!onay %espons!e to t$e ody o' t$e peope.

2 !nst!tt!ona a"t o' %e!*!os "ens%e sed to dep%!+e, sspend, o% !#!t

#e#e%s$!p !n a %e!*!os "o##n!ty o% to %est%!"t "e%ta!n %!*$ts &!t$!n !t, !n

pa%t!"a% %e"ept!on o' t$e sa"%a#ents.


5/31


6/31

M,%,(#+ ,*(#(-+&",/ *#' ! )-' ,' 0-&( A)+,*#' *-'(+,!& '#0!% E=#(-+,#%

G,'!#; ,0#2!; C"#; E(",-/,# #' -("!+&. S-0! !9#0/%! -) &,'%! /#+(

&(#(!& #+! C",'#; N-+(" K-+!# #' -("!+&.

R!%,,-& D,*(#(-+&",/& #+! '-( &- !#&,% ,')!++!. B(; I+#' #' S#, A+#,# *#' ! +!#&-'#%! !9#0/%!& -) +!%,,-& ,*(#(-+&",/&.

U'!+ # ,*(#(-+&",/; ("! /-/%#*! !*-0!& #)+#, (- &/!#: -( -+ #&: )-+ "!%/ )+-0

("!,+ -$!+'0!'(; #& #((+#*(,' ("! #((!'(,-' -) # (+#'( ,& !'!+#%% # $!+ # ,!#.

S- +-:!' (",'& - '+!/#,+!; *+,0!& #+! '-( +!/-+(!; /!-/%! ?&( &))!+ ("+-"

("! &"-+(#!& #' #&+,(,!& -) %,)! '!+ #' '*#+,' -+ "-&(,%! +!,0!.

T"! #/#(" #' "-/!%!&&'!&& ("#( &!( ,' +!&%( ,' # %-2 ,+("+#(! #' !$!'(#%

!*-'-0,* -2'(+'& #& ("!+! #+! )!2!+ 2-+:!+& (- ),%% ?-&; &,'*! #/#("!(,* /!-/%!

"#$! )!2 -+ '- :,&; #' !*#,' 0-+,' *-'(+,!& &!%-0 #((+#*( ,00,+#'(

2-+:!+&. L,)! ,& '-( 2-+(" %,$,'; !*-0!& # (#*,( #+!!0!'( ("+-"-( ("!

*-'(+. R-0#',# '!+ C!#&!&*6 ,& #' !9#0/%! -) # ,*(#(-+&",/ 2"!+! #'','

,+(" *-'(+-% 2#& -'! (- )-+*! R-0#',#'& (- "#$! %#+! )#0,%,!& !&/,(! ("!,+

/-$!+(. T"& -+/"#'#!& ,' C!#&!&*& R-0#',# !*#0! )%% -) 0#%'-+,&"!

:,& 2"-&! /#+!'(& "# ##'-'! ("!0.

A& ("! -$!+#%% /%,* &,':& 0-+! /+-)-' ,'(- "#+&",/ #' "-/!%!&&'!&&; (2-

/-(!'(,#% -(*-0!& !0!+! +!&,&(#'*! #' 2#+. S**!&&)% +!!%%,-' 2,%% (#:! *#+!

-) ("! =,*: ,&&! !$#*#(,' ("! (+#'(; "-2!$!+ ("! #,(#(-+& 2,%% '!! (- !

2#(*")% :!!/,' ,' 0,' ("#( ("!,+ &&(,((,-' -$!+'0!'( !' / !,' #& $,%!

#' ,'"0#'! #& ("! /#&( -'!. W#+ #' ("! &&!=!'( !)!#( 0# &/#+! ("!

6$e Ed!to%s o' En"y"oped!a B%!tann!"a, $icolae %ea"&esc" (a""essed on 1t$ Ap%!, 2015),$ttp&&&.%!tann!"a."o#EB"$e"/edtop!"10072N!"oae-8eases".


7/31

/-/%#*! ,) !'-" &+$,$! #' ("! !'!0 0,'& !'-" (- "!%/ +!0#:! #'

#&&-*,#(! 2,(" ("! /+!$,-& ,*(#(-+&",/. T"! 0-&( ,+! -(*-0! ,0#,'#%! ,& ("#(

("! ,*(#(-+&",/ 2,%% 2,' ("! 2#+ #' &?#(! -+ 0+!+ -)) ("! /-/%#*! -) ("!

#$!++ '#(,-'; !9/#',' "0#' !'+,' #' (+!#*"!+7.

RELIGIOUS DICTATORSHIPS

R!%,,-& -$!+'0!'(& ,& # 0#',)!&(#(,-' -) -$!+'0!'( ,' 2",*" ("! 0,',&(+"#$! &2# -$!+ # -0#,' #' #("-+,( #++#'!0!'( ,& !,("!+ #0,',&(!+!

#("-+,(,!& $,!2! #& *!%!&(,#%% ,!; -+ ,& *-0/%,#'( 2,(" ("! +!%#(,-' -) #

&/!*,),* +!%,,-'.

T"!&! -$!+'0!'(& #+! :'-2' #& THEOCRACIES.

T"! +!#% /+-%!0 2,(" ("!-*+#* ,& '-( ("#( ,( ,& +!%,,-&. T"! +!#% /+-%!0 ,& ("#(

,( !9*%!& +!%,,-& /%+#%,&0. T"#( ,& 2"!' ,( (!'& (- - (-2#+& # ,*(#(-+&",/.

T"! ("!-*+#* 0&( &//+!&& #%% "!+!&; !$!' (- ("! !9(!+0,'#(,-' -) ("! "!+!(,*.

W"!' ("! /-%,* -) /+,),*#(,-' )#,%&; ("! ("!-*+#* )#,%&. I( 0# (#:! (,0!; #& ,( ,

)-+ R-0#' P##',&0 #' ,(& &**!&&-+; 0!,!$#% C#("-%,*,&0; ( )#,% ,( 0&( ,)

/%+#%,&0 ,& #%%-2! (- (#:! +--(.8

T"#( ,& ("! -'% 2# ("! ,*(#(-+&",/ *#' 2-+:. T"! *-0/%!(! ',),*#(,-' -) -'!

*-'(+ '!+ # +!%,,-'.

7 Se S!+an, 'hat are the negatie conse"ences of dictatorship* (. 20, 201),$ttp&&&.9o%a."o#W$at-a%e-ne*at!+e-"onse9en"es-o'-d!"tato%s$!p

: Ed ;a%%, +he real prolem ith theocracy (an. 1, 2015),$ttp&&&.%ant!'estye."o#2015011t$e-%ea-p%oe#-&!t$-t$eo"%a"y.

7


8/31

T"!+! ,& %,((%! %,:!%,"-- -) ("!-*+#* !$!%-/,' )+-0 W!&(!+' *%(+!. W!&(!+'

*%(& -) )#,(" ,'*%,'! (-2#+ ("! &-*,-!*-'-0,* +#("!+ ("#' ("!,&(,*. T"! !&(

*#',#(! )-+ ("!-*+#* ,& I&%#0.

A%% ("!-*+#*,!& %#*: -'! *-'&/,*-& !%!0!'( -) )+!! &-*,!(,!& ("#( ,&; )+!!-0 -)!9/+!&&,-'. E$!' # /+->&*,!'*! +%,' *%!+ 0&( :!!/ ("! *!'&-+& #*(,$!; %!&( #

'!2 ,&*-$!+ *#%% &-0! -0# ,'(- =!&(,-'. U'!+ # ("!-*+#*; ("! ),+&( /+,-+,(

,& &/,+,(#% "!!0-'; '-( !*#&! #' -'! +!%,,-' "#& -( !$!+(",' +,"(; (

!*#&! ("! /-2!+ &(+*(+! !/!'& -' ,(. I) ("! )#,(" )#%%&; ("! +%,' *,+*%! )#%%&.

E*-'-0,* )+!!-0 ,& #'-("!+ *#&#%(.

DICTATORSHIP IN IRAN

I+#' ,& # +!%,,-&% #&! (-(#%,(#+,#' ,*(#(-+&",/. T"!+! #+! '- *"!*:& #'

#%#'*!&; '- !%!*(,-'&; #' '- C-'&(,((,-' ("! !$!' *%#,0 (- )-%%-2. T"! #((,(!&

#' -/,',-'& -) +!%,,-& %!#!+& ,' I+#' 0#((!+. T"!,+ 2",0& #' 2,&"!& #+!; 0-&(

-)(!'; ("! &/+!0! %#2 -) ("! %#'.

T"!+! #+! )!2 %!#!+& ,' ("! 2-+% 0-+! ,0/-+(#'( (- *++!'( 2-+% #))#,+& ( %!&&

'!+&(-- ("#' A#(-%%#" K"#0!'!,; ("! &/+!0! %!#!+ -) I+#'. T"! 0-&(

/-2!+)% ,',$,#% ,' #' #(-*+#(,* &(#(! '- !*,&,-'& *#' ! (#:!' 2,("-( ",&

*-'&!'( #' 2"-&! 0#,' ,'(!+!&( ,& (- !'&+! ",& -2' &+$,$#% #' ("! I&%#0,*

S(#(!5&.1<

H-2!$!+; /+#*(,*#%% &/!#:,'; I+#'& '!%!*(! )-'#(,-'&; (- ! &/!*,),* ("!

,'*-0/#+#%! /,-'!!+ #' 1>0#' G#+,#' C-'*,%; 2,!% 0*" 0-+! /-2!+ ("#'

*"-&! -+#',#(,-'& %,:! ("! #0,',&(+#(,-' #' /#+%,#0!'(. T"! G#+,#' C-'*,%


9/31

"#& ("! /-2!+ (- $!( #%% /-&&,,%,( )-+ -/!' -)),*! #' !9*%! #' 2"- #+! '-(

!&(!!0! &)),*,!'(% )#,(")% (- ("! /+!!0,'!'( /,-'!!+.

K"#0!'!, -!& '-( "#$! ("! 2!%%>:'-2' -%&(!+; *"#+0 #' +!%,,-& *#/#,%,(,!&

("#( K"-0!,', !%,"(! ,'; "-2!$!+ ",& *#/#*,( (- &(# -( -) ("! &/-(%,"( #!(- ",& /-%,(,*#% &(+!'(" #& -) '-( %-' #-. H! "#& +!%,#% &//-+(! /+-+!&&,$!&

-$!+ +!)-+0!+&. H,& /,*(+! #& ("! *-'&,!+#%! #%#'*!+ "#& !!' !','!% (!&(!

("! !#(! *-'(+-%%! 0!,#.

H! #,(,-'#%% "#& &**!&&)% *-'(+-% -$!+ I+#'& &!*-' 0-&( ,'(!'&!

!&(#%,&"0!'(; ("! 1>/#+( G#+,#' C-'*,%; 2",*" "#& ("! /-2!+ (- $!(-

,&*+!(,-'#+ "-/!)%& #' $!(- /#+%,#0!'(#+ *"-,*!&. K"#0!'!, &!%!*(& # %#+!

/-+(,-' -) ,(& ,',$,#%&; #' ,' #,(,-' ("! %!#% -&& 2"- !%!#(!& ("! -("!+ #

%#+! /-+(,-' -). T"! I+#',#' !*-'-0 ,& !'!+#%% &(#(!>*-'(+-%%!; #' K"#0!'!,

"#& ("! 0-&( /-2!+ -$!+ "-2 ("! '#(,-'& -,% ,'*-0! ,& &/!'(.

D+,' I+#'5& J'!


10/31

A**-+,' (- R!/-+(!+& 2,("-( B-+!+&13; 4< %-!+& #' ?-+'#%,&(& 2!+! ,'

/+,&-' #( ("! (,0! -) 2+,(,'. K"-0!', 2#+'! !)-+! ("! !%!*(,-'& ("#( ("!

!%!*(,-'& 2-% '-( ! )+!! #' ("! ?-+'#%,&(& &"-% '-( (+ (- /-+(+# ,( %,:! ("#(.

O' O*(-!+ 8;


11/31

%,:!2,&! :!!/ S'',& )+-0 ,%,' 0-&=!& ,' T!"+#' #' ,+!*(,'

&!/#+#(! E, /!(,(,-'& (- G-. G-$!+'0!'( )-*&,' -) S),&; !&/!*,#%%

,',$,#%& )+-0 ("! N!0#(-%%#", G-'##, -+#',#(,-'; /+-*!!!

'##(!. I' J%; /+-+!&&,$! *-+(& ,' T!"+#' #' S",+# &!'(!'*!

,',$,#%& )+-0 ("! N!0#(-%%#", G-'##,1@ -+#',#(,-' (- (!+0& -) -'! (-1


12/31

("! #0,',&(+#(,-' #' -("!+ (+#'=,% !9!+*,&!& 2,(" (!++-+,&0. T"! -$!+'0!'(

*%,//! -2' -' -'%,'! #*(,$,&0 #' &*#+! #*(,$,&(& #' +!%#(,$!& 2"- +!/-+(!

"0#' +,"(& ,')+,'!0!'(. V,*(,0,#(,-' -) ("! S",# 0,'-+,( &(#! +#0/#'(

&-0! S",# #*(,$,&(& 2!+! &!'(!'*! (- !#(" #' &*-+!& -( %-' ?#,% (!+0&16.

T-+0!'( -) /+,&-'!+& 2#& #%%!!% +!%#+ *-+(& &!'(!'*! %,(,#'(& -' ("!

/+!0,&! -) (-+0!'( *-++/(! #0,&&,-'& #' &!'(!'*! -("!+& (- %#&",'. L#,!&

*-')+-'(! &!+!#(,-' ,' %#2 #' "-'!; #' 2!+! !),*,!'(% !'&+! ##,'&(

&!9#% #' -("!+ $,*,-&'!&& ,' &/,(! -) #'-("!+ %#2 *+,0,'#%,,' #+!&&,$!

!"#$,-+ #( "-0!. T"! -$!+'0!'(17 :!/( #' &00#+,% +!0-$! # %#+! '0!+

-) -(&,! $#+#'(&; ,$,' #*: &-0! (- '#(,-'& 2"!+! ("! 2!+! #( #'!+ -)

!','! "0#' +,"(& 0,&&!&. T"! /-2!+& 0#! )#+ +!#*",' (,%,#(,-' -) *#/,(#% /',&"0!'( #' *-0/%!(! 0#' -/!' !9!*(,-'&.

T"! -$!+'0!'( +!0#,'! ,'(-%!+#'( -) ,&&!'( #' +!/+!&&! ,(& *+,(,*&; ,'*%,'

%-!+& #' -("!+ -'%,'! *-00!'(#(-+&; /-%,(,*#% #' 2-0!'5& +,"(& #*(,$,&(&;0!0!+& -) ("! S",5# 0,'-+,(; #' "0#' +,"(& #*(,$,&(& #' !)!'!+&. T"!

-$!+'0!'( *-'(,'! (- #' ?!& )+-0 &,' &-*,#% 0!,# )-+ #' /+/-&!.

1 La&%en"e Ca+!dson, +he >SA S"pports A anatical ictatorship In Sa"di Araia (an. 23, 2015), $ttpt$e#!enn!#%epo%t."o#201501t$e-sa-sppo%ts-a-

'anat!"a-d!"tato%s$!p-!n-sad!-a%a!a.

17 Ca+!d Batty, Secret cinema gently s"erts Sa"di Araia?s p"ritanism,

8ROWCO?8E (O"t. 17, 2012), $ttp"%o&d+o!"e.o%*%!*$ts-+!oat!ons-!n-sad!-

a%a!a.

12


13/31

I' M#; # *-+( ,' J!#" &!'(!'*! %-!+ R#,) B##2,18 (- 1< !#+& ,' /+,&-'

#' # )%-,' -) 1;N-#,("#' #' A%+#"0#' #%>

R0#," (- /+,&-' (!+0& -) / (- !,"( !#+& (- ! )-%%-2! #'& -' (+#$!%

#+-# #)(!+ *-'$,*(,' ("!0 -) ,0/,',' /%,* -+!+ &,' T2,((!+ (-

*+,(,*,! ("! M,',&(+ -) J&(,*!. T"! *-+( #%&- #''! ("!0 ,'!),',(!% )+-0

&,' #' 0!,# -(%!(& ,'*%,' &-*,#% 0!,#.

T"! -$!+'0!'( , '-( /!+0,( ("! !9,&(!'*! -) /-%,(,*#% /#+(,!&; (+#! ',-'& #'

,'!/!'!'( "0#' +,"(& +-/&; #' ,( #++!&(!; /+-&!*(! #' ,0/+,&-'! ("-&!

2"- &!( / -+ /#+(,*,/#(! ,' '%,*!'&! -+#',#(,-'&.

A%% /%,* #("!+,'&; ,'*%,' !0-'&(+#(,-'&; +!0#,'! /+-",,(! '!+ #'

-+!+ ,&&! ("! I'(!+,-+ M,',&(+ ,'


14/31

I',$,#%& )+-0 ("! S",# 0,'-+,(


15/31

#//#+!'(% &(#! !'!0,*; '-(2,("&(#',' #' #0,',&(+#(,-' 0,')%'!&&

+,',' *+! /+-/!%%! / ,' )#*(,-'#%; #' # '-'/#+(,' #("!+,' ("#( *#' ,$! +!#: ,',(,#(,$! ,' (,0!&

-) (+0-,%; )+("!+0-+! "#$! # (!'!'* (- !/,*( +!%#+ *,(,!' %!,&%#(-+& #&

!!'!+#(! #' ,'!))!*(#%. B #' ; ("!' ##,'; 0,%,(#+ #0,',&(+#(,-'& *#'

+!%#+% ! $!+ ),!+*!; &(#,' ,' )-+*! )-+ %-' &(+!(*"!& -) (,0! #' &0,((,'

'0!+-& "0#' +,"(& $,-%#(,-'&.

. W! *#' !9(!'&,$!% +!*-',! (2- &-+(& "!+!. I' ("! ),+&( /%#*!; ("!+! ,& ("!

0,%,(#+>?'(# &-+( ,' 2"-0 ("! ,'*-0/#+#%! &(+#(! 0#:,' -+#' ,& # ?'(# -+

*"#0!+ -) -)),*!+& ,+!*(,' ("! ("+!! #0,',&(+#(,-'& #+0! )-+*!; '#$#% )-+*!

#' ("! )%,' *-+/&. T"! 0,%,(#+ ?'(# '-+0#%% !&,'#(!& # +!%#+ *,(,!'

23 a 'o%# o' *o+e%n#ent $eaded y #!!ta%y "$!e's.?t !s not t$e sa#e as a #!!ta%y

d!"tato%s$!p o% #!!ta%y >nta &$e%e t$e #!!ta%ys po!t!"a po&e% !s not en'o%"ed o%

e+en sppo%ted y ot$e% a&s.

2 A *%op o' #!!ta%y o"e%s %!n* a "ont%y a'te% se!D!n* po&e%.

15


16/31

+!# (- #0,',&(!+ '!+ ,(& /-2!+. P#+(,!& #' %#20#:,' -,!& #+! &0-("!+!

-+ !%&! ?&( # &-%,(#+ #("-+,( /#+( ,& #%%-2!. R!%#+% #("!+,'& #'

#&&!0%,!& #+! -&(!'&,%! #' &&!+$,!'( #'*,!'( +#+,( -) ("! 0,%,(#+ -)),*,#%. T"!

0,%,(#+; #& &/-:!' (- ,(& &!',-+ -)),*!+&; /%#& ("! '#0,* #' /+!!0,'!'( /#+(

,' &(+#(! 0#:,' ,' ("! 0,%,(#+ ?'(# &-+( -) #0,',&(+#(,-'.

A%&-;

T"!+! ,& ("! /+!&,!'(,#% &-+( ,' 2",*" ("! 0,%,(#+ #&&0! # &(!# /#+( #& -//-&!

(- #' ,'$!'(,$! -+ '#0,* /#+(. H!+!; ("! 0,',&(+ ,& )+#0! (- # +!#( !9(!'( -+

!'(,+!% )+-0 +!%#+ *,(,!'+ #& -//-&! (- 0,%,(#+ &(#)). I' #,+!; )-+ !9#0/%!;

("! #+0! )-+*!& /#+( ,& &//-+(,$! -) ("! /+!&,!'(@.

25 A>ay Rat$o%e, 1eaning and feat"res of military dictatorship (a""essed on 17 Ap%!, 2015),$ttp&&&.p%ese%+ea%t!"es."o#2012031020:*et-"o#pete-!n'o%#at!on-on-t$e-#ean!n*-and-'eat%es-o'- #!!ta%y-%e*!#es.$t#.

1

http://www.preservearticles.com/2012031026068/get-complete-information-on-the-meaning-and-features-of-http://www.preservearticles.com/2012031026068/get-complete-information-on-the-meaning-and-features-of-http://www.preservearticles.com/2012031026068/get-complete-information-on-the-meaning-and-features-of-http://www.preservearticles.com/2012031026068/get-complete-information-on-the-meaning-and-features-of-


17/31

MILIATARY DICTATORSHIP IN FIJI

S,'*! D!*!0!+


18/31

#*(,$,&(& #' "0#' +,"(& !)!'!+&. P+!&,!'(,#% !*+!!& /!+/!(#(! ,0/',(

+#'(,' ,00',( )-+ &!*+,( )-+*! /!+&-''!%7.

C!'&-+&",/ ,& #%,$! #' 2!%%; 2,(" I')-+0#(,-' M,',&(+ -)),*!+&; -)(!'

#**-0/#',! &-%,!+&; -/!+#(,' ,'&,! ("! *-'(+& '!2&+--0& &,'*! %#&(A/+,%. C!'&-+& "#$! '-2 +#'*"! -( (- %-*: %-& *+,(,*#% -) ("! -$!+'0!'(.

M!#'2",%!; ("! /!'#%( )-+ &!,(,-' "#& '!#+% (+,/%! '!+ ("! C+,0!& D!*+!!

$ needs to confront i5i?s a"se of asic h"man rights (;e. 11, 2010),$ttp&&&.t$ea*e."o#.a!t-p%on-needs-to-"on'%ont-F>!s-ase-o'-as!"-$#an-%!*$ts-20100210-nsa&.$t#

2: S$!+a!n! =a%#a%, ights A"se contin"es in i5i ( Ap%! . 201)$ttp&&&.$%&.o%*ne&s20100:%!*$ts-ases-"ont!ne-F>!.

1:


19/31

-)),*!+& ,' ("! #((-+'! !'!+#%& *"#0!+&. H!+! ##,'; "! !9!+*,&! #&-%(!

*-'(+-% ,' !(!+0,',' F,?,& /-%,(,*#% /#(".

A *-0,'#(,-' -) +#*-',#' %#2&; # /#((!+' -) ,'(,0,#(,-' #' "#+#&&0!'( -)

("-&! 2"- #+! *+,(,*#% -) ("! -$!+'0!'(; #& 2!%% #& +!/-+(& -) (-+(+! ("!&!*+,( )-+*!&; "#$! *+!#(! # *%,0#(! -) )!#+ ,' F,?,; , R/!+( A-((; A0'!&(

I'(!+'#(,-'#%5& D!/( A&,#>P#*,),* D,+!*(-+ .

F-%%-2,' !%!*(,-'& -' 17 S!/(!0!+; /#+( &(#(! %! ("! B+0# S-*,#%,&( P+-+#00! P#+(31.

2A#nesty ?nte%nat!ona, i5i: @ainimarama m"st end climate of fear (A*. , 201),$ttps&&&.a#nesty.o%*ena%t!"esne&s2010:F>!-a!n!#a%a#a-#st-end-"!#ate-'ea%.

30 See aso, reedom "nder threat in i5i, ANES6Y ?N6ERNA6?ONAL (a""essed on 20t$ ap%!,2015), $ttp&&&.a#nesty.o%*.nDo%-&o%/pa"!F"F>!

31 a%"o Bnte, @"rmas +ransition to isciplined emocracyB: Adication or

Instit"tionaliCation of 1ilitary "le* ( A*st 2011 ), a+a!ae at $ttp&&&.*!*a-

$a#%*.deensyste#Fesp!"at!ons&p1774ente.pd'

1


20/31

T"! *-'&(,((,-' 2#& #+-#(!; #%% -//-&,(,-' #*(,$,&(& /( !",' #+& #' #'

#((!0/( (- -+#',&! 2#& &!$!+!% +!/+!&&!. T"! #+0 (--: -$!+ #%% &(#(! )'*(,-'&;

*-'(+-%%,' #%% #&/!*(& -) /-%,(,*#%; !*-'-0,* #' &-*,#% %,)! ,' ("! *-'(+. L#+!>

&*#%! /+-(!&(& ##,'&( 0,%,(#+ +%! +-:! -( ,' 188 ,' ("! *!'(+#% /#+( -) ("!

*-'(+. A)(!+ # %-- *+#*:-2' -' /+->!0-*+#* !0-'&(+#(,-'&; ("! +!,0!-+#',&! !'!+#% !%!*(,-'& ,' 1&(#',' )!#+ -) )-+!,' ,'(!+$!'(,-'3.

T"! &!*-' &-+*! -) 0,%,(#+ /-2!+ ,& ("! ",&(-+,*#%% 2!#: '#(+! -) *,$,% &-*,!(.

I' #,(,-' (- #%% ("!&! ",&(-+,*#%%>+,$!' )#*(-+&; 0,%,(#+ ,*(#(-+&",/ "#&

!'!),(! )+-0 B+0#5& #'*,!'( (+#,(,-' -) /-%,(,*#% !)!+!'*!. M#' &*"-%#+& &!!

(",& #& &(!00,'; #( %!#&( ,' /#+(; )+-0 ("! B",&( !%,!) ("#( /-%,(,*#% /-2!+ -+

,'!! #' -("!+ )-+0 -) /!+&-'#% &**!&& ,& # ,+!*( *-'&!=!'*! -) 0!+,( #,'!,' /+!$,-& %,$!&. I( ,& # )-+0 -) 0!+,(-*+#* 2"!+! :#+0,* 0!+,( ,& ,'"!+,(!5

("+-" +!,'*#+'#(,-'.

T"! ),+&( !'!+#% !%!*(,-' ,' < !#+& 2#& "!% ,'


21/31

I( 2#& -*-((! ("! 0#,' -//-&,(,-' +-/; A' S#' S K,& N#(,-'#%

L!#! )-+ D!0-*+#* NLD > 2",*" "# 2-' # %#'&%,! $,*(-+ ,' ("! /+!$,-&

0%(,>/#+( !%!*(,-' ,' 1< ( 2#& '-( #%%-2! (- -$!+'.

A '-0,'#%% *,$,%,#' -$!+'0!'( %! P+!&,!'( T"!,' S!,' > 2"- &!+$! #& #!'!+#% #' ("!' /+,0! 0,',&(!+ '!+ ("! ?'(# > 2#& ,'&(#%%! ,' M#+*" ,'(!+,-+; !)!'&! #'

-+!+ #))#,+& > 0&( ! "!% &!+$,' !'!+#%&.

T"! ?-:! ,' B+0# ,& ("#( T"#' S"2! "#& (+#'&)!++! /-2!+ )+-0 ",& +,"(

"#' (- ",& %!)(; , A' #2; !,(-+ -) T"! I++#2#; #' -'%,'! 0##,'!

/%,&"! B+0!&! !9,%!& ,' T"#,%#'. H! &(,%% -!& (- ",& -)),*! !$!+ #. H!

,& &(,%% ("! %(,0#(! #("-+,(.34

A**-+,' (- # H0#' R,"(& W#(*" +!/-+(3@;

A+0! *-')%,*( !(2!!' ("! B+0!&! -$!+'0!'( #' ("! K#*",' I'!/!'!'*!

A+0 KIA *-'(,'! ,' K#*",' S(#(! ,' ("! '-+("; 2"!+! (!'& -) ("-'& -)

*,$,%,#'& +!0#,' ,&/%#*!. T"! -$!+'0!'( "#& !))!*(,$!% !',! "0#',(#+,#'

#, (- ("! ,&/%#*! K#*",' *,$,%,#'& ,' KIA (!++,(-+. I' *-')%,*( #+!#& ,' K#*",'

#' S"#' S(#(!&; ("! B+0!&! 0,%,(#+ *#++,! -( !9(+#?,*,#% :,%%,'&; &!9#%

$,-%!'*!; (-+(+!; )-+*! %#-+; #' !%,!+#(! #((#*:& -' *,$,%,#' #+!#&; #%% 2",*"

*-'(,'! 2,(" ,0/',(. C!#&!),+! #+!!0!'(& ,' !("',* *-')%,*( #+!#& -) !#&(!+'

B+0# +!0#,' (!'-&.

3 Roe%t Ho%n, Is @"rma?s Strongman eally etiring* (Ap%. 11, 2012),$ttp"ontent.t!#e."o#t!#e&o%da%t!"e0,:5,2070,00.$t#

35 Wo%d Repo%t 2013B%#a, HAN R?GH6S WA68H (2013), aailale at$ttp&&&.$%&.o%*&o%d-%epo%t2013"ont%y-"$apte%s%#aJpa*eK1

21


22/31

F-+0!+ 0,%,(#+ !'!+#%& "-% 0-&( &!',-+ 0,',&(!+,#% /-+()-%,-& #' &!+$,'

!'!+#%& #+! *-'&(,((,-'#%% #+#'(!! ("! /-&(& -) 0,',&(!+& -) !)!'&!; "-0!

#))#,+&; #' -+!+ #))#,+& &!*+,(. M#' )-+0!+ 0,%,(#+ -)),*!+& "-% ,0/-+(#'( /-&,(,-'& ,' ("! +%,' 0,%,(#+>#*:! U',-' S-%,#+,( #' D!$!%-/0!'( P#+(.

I'(!+'#%% ,&/%#*! K#*",' &2!%%! (- #' !&(,0#(! R-",'# #' #'(,>M&%,0

#**-'(& -) ("! !$!'(&; )!%,' ,&*+,0,'#(,-' #' "#(! &/!!*" ,' /+,'( 0!,# #'

-'%,'! #*+-&& ("! *-'(+37.

COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS

T"! )-%%-2,' ,& # *-0/#+#(,$! #'#%&,& -) ("! +!%,,-& #' 0,%,(#+ ,*(#(-+&",/&

,'$-%$,' ("! *#&! &(,!& I+#'; S#, A+#,#; F,?, #' B+0#

3 Id!

37 See also, 6o#


23/31

FORMATION OF THE DICTATORSHIP

M,%,(#+ ,*(#(-+&",/& #+! 0-&(% # +!&%( -) # C-/ (#(; 2",*" ,& ("!

-$!+("+-2,' -) ("! *++!'( -$!+'0!'(. I) 2! ,')!+ )+-0 /+!$,-&% 0!'(,-'!

#(#; 2! *#' &!! ("#( ("! ,*(#(-+&",/& ,' -(" F,?, #' B+0# 2!+! +!&%( -) C-/

(#(&. F,?, 2#& ("! +!&%( -) # *-/ "!#! ("! C-00--+! F+#': B#,',0#+#0#

2",%! B+0# "# ("! #+0 +!$-%( ##,'&( ("! !0-*+#(,* &(#(! ,' 16. G!'!+#%

T"#' S"2! &/!#+"!#,' (",& #' *+!#(,' # -'!>/#+( &(#(! '!+ ("! +%! -)

B+0# S-*,#%,&( P+-+#00! P#+(.

I' ("! +!%,,-& ,*(#(-+&",/&; 2! *#' &!! ("#( ("! *#&! ,& '-( ("! !. I' S#,

A+#,#; A%%#" ,' A%#, A% #&*!'! ("! ("+-'! #)(!+ ("! !#(" -) ",& "#%)> +-("!+; K,' F#"#. I( 2#& "! 2"- &(#+(! ("! ,*(#(-+&",/.

I' ("! *#&! -) I+#'; A#(-%%#" R"-%%#" K"-0!,', 2#& ("! -'! 2"- &(#+(! ("!

,*(#(-+&",/. A' "! (+#'&)!++! ",& +!,'& (- ("! *#/#%! &**!&&-+; A%, K"#0!'!,.

USE OF FORCE

T"! &! -) ,%%!#% )-+*! ,& +#0/#'( #0-' ("! )-+ ,*(#(-+&",/&.

• Fiji38> A0'!&( +!/-+(& &; S!*+,( )-+*!& ,' F,?, "#$! !*-0!

,'*+!#&,'% 0!'#*,' (-2#+& /!-/%! 2"- -//-&! ("! +!,0!; ,'*%,'

?-+'#%,&(& #' "0#' +,"(& !)!'!+&. F,?, ,& '-2 *#"( ,' # -2'2#+

&/,+#% -) "0#' +,"(& $,-%#(,-'& #' +!/+!&&,-'. O'% *-'*!+(!

,'(!+'#(,-'#% /+!&&+! *#' +!#: (",& **%!. A %,(#' -) +!/+!&&,$! (#*(,*&

&! ("! ,'(!+,0 0,%,(#+ -$!+'0!'( (- &(,)%! #' /+-(!&(& #' ,'(,0,#(!

,(& *+,(,*&. T"!&! ,'*%! !#(,'&; #+,(+#+ #++!&(& #' !(!'(,-'; "#+#&&0!'(

-) "0#' +,"(& !)!'!+&; #' &!$!+! %,0,(#(,-'& -' ("! )'#0!'(#% +,"(&(- )+!!-0 -) !9/+!&&,-'; -/,',-'; #' #&&-*,#(,-'3.

3: S"pra at n.2:

3 H#an R!*$ts !oat!on !n ;!>!, ANES6Y ?N6ERNA6?ONAL (sep. :, 2012),$ttp&&&.s"oop."o.nDsto%!es=O00S000:.$t#

23


24/31

• Iran40> I+#',#' #("-+,(,!& +!%#+% &?!*( /+,&-'!+& !&/!*,#%% ("-&!

*-'$,*(! -' /-%,(,*#%%>0-(,$#(! *"#+!&; (- #&! #' !/+,$! ("!0 -)

'!*!&+ 0!,*#% (+!#(0!'(. S!*+,( )-+*!& !/+,$! H-&&!,' R-'#",; #

+,"(& #*(,$,&( #' %-!+; #' -//-&,(,-' %!#!+& M-$, #' K#++-,;)+-0 +!*!,$,' ("! +!%#+ *"!*:>/& -*(-+& "# +!*-00!'! )-+ &!+,-&

0!,*#% *-',(,-'&. A("-+,(,!& !9!*(! #( %!#&( 16 /!-/%! ,' P#:,&(#' -+!+. D-!'& -) -("!+& #+! -'

!#(" +-2 )-+ (!++-+,&0>+!%#(! *"#+!& )-%%-2,' /-%,(,*#%%>0-(,$#(!

/+-&!*(,-'& #' ')#,+ (+,#%&. S"#+,# %#2 ,& #%&- ,0/%!0!'(! 2",*" 0#:!&"0#' +,"(& $,-%#(,-' 0-+! ,' '0!+.

• Burma41> H'+!& -) /!-/%!; ,'*%,' *",%+!'; 2!+! #+,(+#+,% !(#,'!;

"!% ,' ,'*-00',*#- !(!'(,-'; #' &?!*(! (- *+!%; ,'"0#' #'

!+#,' (+!#(0!'( ,' /%#*!& -) !(!'(,-' 2,("-( #**!&& (- #//+-/+,#(! -+

#!=#(! 0!,*#% *#+!. T"!+! *-'(,'! (- ! &-0! +!/-+(& -) (-+(+! #'

-("!+ ,%%>(+!#(0!'(; -**#&,-'#%% %!#,' (- !#(" ,' *&(-.

F-+ !9#0/%!;

M- M,'( S2! ,! ,' # /-%,*! &(#(,-' ,' Y#'-' ,' J% #)(!+ "! 2#&

#**&! -) ,'$-%$!0!'( ,' # 0+!+. H,& - &"-2! &,'& -) (-+(+!.

T"!+! 2#& '- *-0/+!"!'&,$! #' ,'!/!'!'( 0!*"#',&0 (- ,'$!&(,#(!

/-&&,%! 2#+ *+,0!& #' *+,0!& ##,'&( "0#',(; %!#$,' $,*(,0& #' ("!,+

0 Wo%d Repo%t 201, HAN R?GH6S WA68H (a""essed at 1t$

Ap%!, 2015), aailale athttp://!hr!org/orld-report/2067/co"ntry-chapters/iran*pageE6

1 Anna Repo%t 2013, yan#a%, ANES6Y ?nte%nat!ona (ay. 23, 201), aailale at $ttp&&&.a#nestysa.o%*%esea%"$%epo%tsanna-%epo%t-#yan#a%-2013Jpa*eK3

2


25/31

+!%#(,$!& 2,(" ,'#!=#(! #**!&& (- 0!#&+!& -) (+("; ?&(,*! #' +!/#+#(,-'&.

M#' -) ("-&! ,'$-%$! ,' +#$! "0#' +,"(& $,-%#(,-'& "# '-( !!'

+-"( (- ?&(,*!.

•

Saudi Arabia

42

- S!*+,( #("-+,(,!& *#++,! -( #+,(+#+ #++!&(& #'*-'(,'! (- "-% !(#,'!!& 2,("-( *"#+! -+ (+,#% )-+ %-' /!+,-&; 2,("

&*-+!& -) /!-/%! "!% )-+ 0-+! ("#' &,9 0-'("& 2,("-( !,' +!)!++! (- #

*-0/!(!'( *-+(; ,' +!#*" -) ("! *-'(+5& C-! -) C+,0,'#% P+-*!+!&.

D!(#,'!!& 2!+! )+!=!'(% "!% ,'*-00',*#- +,' ,'(!++-#(,-' #'

!',! #**!&& (- %#2!+&; ,' $,-%#(,-' -) ,'(!+'#(,-'#% )#,+ (+,#% &(#'#+&.

T-+(+! #' -("!+ ,%%>(+!#(0!'( +!0#,'! *-00-' #' 2,!&/+!#; #**-+,'

(- )-+0!+ !(#,'!!&; (+,#% !)!'#'(& #' -("!+&; #' 2!+! &! 2,("

,0/',(. I' # '0!+ -) *#&!&; *-+(& *-'$,*(! !)!'#'(& &-%!% -' ("!

#&,& -) /+!>(+,#% *-')!&&,-'& 2,("-( ,'$!&(,#(,' ("!,+ *%#,0& ("#( ("!&!

*-')!&&,-'& "# !!' !9(+#*(! '!+ (-+(+!; ,' &-0! *#&!& &!'(!'*,' ("!

!)!'#'(& (- !#(".

CONTROLLED MEDIA

Fiji- I'


26/31

+!/%,&"! )+-0 # N!2 !#%#' '!2&/#/!+ ,' N-$!0!+ !, ;REECO O; 6HE =RESS (a""essed on 21st Ap%!, 2015),$ttps'%eedo#$ose.o%*%epo%t'%eedo#-p%ess2013F>!M.6-IyG99/o

5 s"pra at n.0

2


27/31

• Saudi Arabia46> "! -$!+'0!'( +!0#,'! ,'(-%!+#'( -) ,&&!'( #' +!/+!&&!

,(& *+,(,*&; ,'*%,' %-!+& #' -("!+ -'%,'! *-00!'(#(-+&; /-%,(,*#% #'

2-0!'5& +,"(& #*(,$,&(&; 0!0!+& -) ("! S",5# 0,'-+,(; #' "0#' +,"(&

#*(,$,&(& #' !)!'!+&. T"! -$!+'0!'( *-'(,'! (- #' ?!& )+-0 &,'&-*,#% 0!,# )-+ #' /+/-&!.

I' M#;


28/31

CONCLUSION

A)(!+ # &**!&&)% *-0/#+#(,$! #'#%&,&; 2! ),' ("#( ("! !%!0!'(& -)

,*(#(-+&",/; ("#( ,&; ("! &,0,%#+ /-,'(& #+! /+!&!'( ,' -(" +!%,,-& #'0,%,(#+ ,*(#(-+&",/&. A%("-" ("! )-+0#(,-' #' ("! ,!-%-,!& 0#

,))!+ ,' *-0/#+,&-'; ("! !))!*( ("! ,*(#(-+&",/ "#& -' ("! *-00-'

/!-/%! ,& ')-+('#(!%; =,(! &,0,%#+.

S!$!+! "0#' +,"(& $,-%#(,-'&; &//+!&&,-' -) ("! /!-/%! #'

,&*+,0,'#(,-' (-2#+& ("! 0,'-+,( &-*,!(,!& #+! &-0! -) ("! #+(& ("#(

",( ("! ! (#+!(. T"! &//+!&&,-' -) /!-/%! ("+-" #' #("-+,(#(,$!

+%! ,' *#&! -) 0,%,(#+ ,*(#(-+&",/ -+ # *#&! -) /+-0%#(,-' -) #+!%,,-& %#2 S"#+,#; )-+ !9#0/%! ,' *#&! -) # +!%,,-& ,*(#(-+&",/.

S,0,%#+ #+,(+#+ #++!&(& #' !(!'(,-'& 2,("-( #' "-/! -) # )#,+ (+,#%

&!!0 (- ! ("! *"#''!%,' )#*(-+ !(2!!' #%% ("! ,*(#(-+&",/&.

T"! !#(" *-'( "#& +,&!' =,(! # %-( #' ,( ,& -'% ,' ("! "#'& -) ("!

,'(!+'#(,-'#% *-00',( (- (#:! &(+,*( #*(,-' ##,'&( ("!&! "-++,),* #*(&.

A2#+!'!&& &"-% ! &/+!# &- ("#( ("! /!-/%! -) ("! 2-+% *#' ',(!

("!,+ $-,*!& ,'(- # 0*" &(+-'!+ -'! (- /+-(!&( ##,'&( ("! !(!&(#%!

#*(& -'! ("! /!-/%! 2"- %,:! (- #*( G-. F,?, #' B+0# &!!0& (- !

!$-%$,' ,'(- # !0-*+#*. B( %; ("! ! *#''-( ! , )-+ ("!

+!%,,-& ,*(#(-+&",/& 2"!+! ("! !9(+!0,&( ("!-*+#(& &!!0 (- "#$!

!'(+!'*"! ("!0&!%$!& !!/ 2,(",' ("! /-2!+ &(+*(+! -) ("! *-'(+.

2:


29/31


30/31

&slamic journalists urged to ree all detained journalists and activists,

REPORTERS WITHOUT BORDERS A/+. 1,*(#(-+&",/>,'>,>#+#,#.

D#$, B#((; Secret cinema gentl% subverts Saudi Arabia;s !uritanism;

CROWDVOICE O*(. 17; $,-%#(,-'&>,'>,>

#+#,#.

(ai ##2,>("!>,>

#+#,#'>%-!+>&!'(!'*!>(->1!#(">/!'#%(>

1'-+(">

#)+,*#,>#+#,#+!/-+(>,>#+#,#.

B##' P!+!-; n being Shia &n Saudi Arabia #**!&&! -' 7 M#+.;


31/31

A?# R#("-+!; -eaning and eatures o militar% dictatorshi! #**!&&! -' 17 A/+,%;

0!#','>#'>)!#(+!&>-)>+!,0!&."(0%.

S",$#%,', P#+0#+; (ights Abuse continues in iji = A/+,% . *"#/(!+&+0#/#!1.

W-+% R!/-+(

Dictatorship: Religious and Military

Documents

Transcript of Dictatorship: Religious and Military