Dhabhol Power Project
-
Upload
ans4friends -
Category
Documents
-
view
221 -
download
0
Transcript of Dhabhol Power Project
-
8/7/2019 Dhabhol Power Project
1/15
Company
LOGO
The Dabhol Power ProjectCase Analysis
In the name of Allah the most
Merciful & Beneficent
-
8/7/2019 Dhabhol Power Project
2/15
A ProTeam Presentation
Dr. Sikandar Khan
Ans Ali Ashraf
Muhamasd Waqas Khan
Ali Ashiq Kirmani
to
Mazhar JavedJunaid Ilyas
Inam Ul Haq
Salman Ahmad
by
Mehvish Ishtiaq
-
8/7/2019 Dhabhol Power Project
3/15
Feasibility Study
(Is the idea prima facie promising?)
(Y
ES)
(Was the project worthwhile?)
(YES)
(Generation of ideas)
(Initial screening)
-
8/7/2019 Dhabhol Power Project
4/15
Introduction
Dabhol power company was promoted in March 1993.100% foreign owned private company incorporated in India.By Enron corp USA, Bechtel Enterprises Inc. USA (constructing the plant),
and General Electric Co. USA (selling turbines).The power generated by the plant will be sold to Maharashtra State Electricity
Board (MSEB).
The cost was estimated at US$ 2.8 billionThe project is 2184 MWProject was initiated in 1992 and took
nine years to commence operation.The plant closed in June 2001 due to a
payment and contract dispute between the
Maharashtra state government and owners.The new elected government led to renegotiation of tariff rates that reduced
the profitability of the private firm.However, when a new govt was reelected, the condition of the pre-existing
agreement was revised, resulting in the private sector consortium Dabhol
power corporation DPC) stopping the project.
-
8/7/2019 Dhabhol Power Project
5/15
Shareholding Pattern
50%
10%
-
8/7/2019 Dhabhol Power Project
6/15
Timeline of the Project
(G.O.M, Enron, Bechtel, GE signMOU)
(PPA signed)
(Phase 1 begins, change of govt.
in Mah; project scrapped)
(renegotiation;
construction
of
phase1
resumes)
(pha
se1becomes
opera
tion
al)
(MSEB
begins
todefault)(Enron files for bankruptcy;DPC shuts down)
(Indian receivers tookcontrol of DPC)
Re-named Ratnagiri gas andpower /Started Oprations
2010 Running at 1850MW/B.E/14% ROI
-
8/7/2019 Dhabhol Power Project
7/15
Details of the Power Plant
Total capacity 2,015 MWOriginally estimated cost of the plant - $ 2.8 billion
-
8/7/2019 Dhabhol Power Project
8/15
PPA Details
Agreement for 20 years.
Implemented on BOO basis(Build, Own, Operate).
MSEB guaranteed to buy
90% of power produced.
MSEB to receive 30% of the DPC profitsannually.
MSEB to bear any increase in fuel price.
-
8/7/2019 Dhabhol Power Project
9/15
Reasons for Non-Performance
By early 2002, Enron was variously termed radioactive,contaminated.
Maharashtra ordered the project to be halted because oflack of transparency, alleged padded costs andenvironmental hazards. But by then Enron had invested$300 million.
The congress government in Maharashtra was defeated inthe state polls in March 1995 and the new govt. of BJPand Shiv Sena came into power.
A committee led by deputychief minister recommended
scrapping of the project on
Aug 3, 1995.
-
8/7/2019 Dhabhol Power Project
10/15
Other Reasons for Closure
Failure of GOI it refused to commit the resources tosolve the problems raised through the projects failure.
Failure of GOM govt. of Maharashtra was the sole
purchaser of power under PPA anda 15% equity holder in the project.
It utterly failed to participate
in the long workout efforts.
-
8/7/2019 Dhabhol Power Project
11/15
Controversies
Lack of competitive bidding (transparent procurementmethod)
No EIA (environmental impact assessment) wascarried out.
One-sided MOU signed in favor of DPC (Worldbank).
-
8/7/2019 Dhabhol Power Project
12/15
WORLD BANK TURNED DOWN FINANCING(when sought by central govt.)
It felt that the project was not economically viable. Project did not satisfy the test of least cost power. It was too large for the power demands of
Maharashtra.
Power tariffs higher than comparedto other independent powerprojects in the country.
Agreement was treated as
confidential.
-
8/7/2019 Dhabhol Power Project
13/15
Dabhol Today
Current generation 1,850 MW at almost full capacity.
5% power will go to Goa, Daman and Diu after full capacity(1940MW)is achieved
Gas agreement with Reliance from KG Basin for 8.5mmcmd of gas
Selling price Rs. 4.34/unit almost double than other 4000MW plant atlest than Rs. 2 a unit.
2009-2010 year of breakeven, Started earning ROI of 14%
Looking forward for expansion of 2000MW in couple of years
Looking forward for the commencement of LNG terminal in 2011
-
8/7/2019 Dhabhol Power Project
14/15
Findings
Based on the analysis, the appropriate return toequity holders should not be much greater thanthe cost of foreign debt given the PPA and thecounter guarantee by Government of India.
Payments by MSEB as perthe PPA has been guaranteed
by Govt. of Maharashtra and
counter guaranteed by Govt.
of India.Premium for equity appears excessive.
-
8/7/2019 Dhabhol Power Project
15/15
Thanks