Designing Mixed-Species Native Tree Reforestation Trial in ... · Spiraeopsis philippinensis Elm....

28
Designing Mixed-Species Native Tree Reforestation Trial in the Philippines Mariya Chechina US Fulbright Scholar 2018-2019 [email protected] February 27, 2019

Transcript of Designing Mixed-Species Native Tree Reforestation Trial in ... · Spiraeopsis philippinensis Elm....

Page 1: Designing Mixed-Species Native Tree Reforestation Trial in ... · Spiraeopsis philippinensis Elm. Trema orientalis Ternstroemia spec.2 Vernonia arborea Ham. Garcinia binucao Garcinia

Designing Mixed-Species Native Tree Reforestation Trial in the Philippines

Mariya Chechina

US Fulbright Scholar 2018-2019

[email protected]

February 27, 2019

Page 2: Designing Mixed-Species Native Tree Reforestation Trial in ... · Spiraeopsis philippinensis Elm. Trema orientalis Ternstroemia spec.2 Vernonia arborea Ham. Garcinia binucao Garcinia

Source: ESSC 1999 2

Deforestation in the Philippines

Page 3: Designing Mixed-Species Native Tree Reforestation Trial in ... · Spiraeopsis philippinensis Elm. Trema orientalis Ternstroemia spec.2 Vernonia arborea Ham. Garcinia binucao Garcinia

National Greening Program (NGP)

3DENR 2011

Page 4: Designing Mixed-Species Native Tree Reforestation Trial in ... · Spiraeopsis philippinensis Elm. Trema orientalis Ternstroemia spec.2 Vernonia arborea Ham. Garcinia binucao Garcinia

Management issues

4

Native forests Plantations of exotics

Lack of silvicultural knowledge & seeds

Show low survival and growth in trials

Limited data about site-tree matching

Available seed banks

Fast growing

Data on propagation and planting

VS.

Page 5: Designing Mixed-Species Native Tree Reforestation Trial in ... · Spiraeopsis philippinensis Elm. Trema orientalis Ternstroemia spec.2 Vernonia arborea Ham. Garcinia binucao Garcinia

5

Research Objective

To establish mixed-species native tree trials for biodiversity and forest conservation

based on ecological data

Native forests

Page 6: Designing Mixed-Species Native Tree Reforestation Trial in ... · Spiraeopsis philippinensis Elm. Trema orientalis Ternstroemia spec.2 Vernonia arborea Ham. Garcinia binucao Garcinia

Long Term Ecological Plots

6Source: Chechina and Hamann 2015

Page 7: Designing Mixed-Species Native Tree Reforestation Trial in ... · Spiraeopsis philippinensis Elm. Trema orientalis Ternstroemia spec.2 Vernonia arborea Ham. Garcinia binucao Garcinia

Forest plots

7

Early-successional Plot (A):25 yrs oldMid-Successional Plot (B): 50 yrs oldLate-Successional Plot (C): 100 yrs old

Plot A Plot B Plot C

Page 8: Designing Mixed-Species Native Tree Reforestation Trial in ... · Spiraeopsis philippinensis Elm. Trema orientalis Ternstroemia spec.2 Vernonia arborea Ham. Garcinia binucao Garcinia

Ecological data collection5 X 5 Meter Sub Plots and xy Location Diameter at Breast Height (DBH)

Crown Position Local Tree Name Permanent Tags

8

Page 9: Designing Mixed-Species Native Tree Reforestation Trial in ... · Spiraeopsis philippinensis Elm. Trema orientalis Ternstroemia spec.2 Vernonia arborea Ham. Garcinia binucao Garcinia

Native species traits

9

Frequency

Growth rates

Basal Areas

Seed size

Number of trees in each species in each plot

Total area of all trees in a species in each plot

Difference in DBH of each species in each plot

Derived from Hamann et al. 1999

Source: Chechina and Hamann 2015

Page 10: Designing Mixed-Species Native Tree Reforestation Trial in ... · Spiraeopsis philippinensis Elm. Trema orientalis Ternstroemia spec.2 Vernonia arborea Ham. Garcinia binucao Garcinia

Frequency (F) and Basal Area (BA) are Indicators of Succession

10

Early successional: High F and BA in young forest

Mid Successional: High F and BA in mid-growth forest

Late Successional: High F and BA in old growth forest

Source: Chechina and Hamann 2015

NMDS

Page 11: Designing Mixed-Species Native Tree Reforestation Trial in ... · Spiraeopsis philippinensis Elm. Trema orientalis Ternstroemia spec.2 Vernonia arborea Ham. Garcinia binucao Garcinia

Growth Rates (GR) of Native Species

11

Early successional: High GR of trees recruited in gaps of old forest

Late Successional: High GR of trees recruited in young forest

Source: Chechina and Hamann 2015

Page 12: Designing Mixed-Species Native Tree Reforestation Trial in ... · Spiraeopsis philippinensis Elm. Trema orientalis Ternstroemia spec.2 Vernonia arborea Ham. Garcinia binucao Garcinia

Identified Succession of Native Species 62 classified of 118 identified

• 20 early successional species

• 22 mid successional species

• 20 late successional species

12Source: Chechina and Hamann 2015

Alphitonia excelsa

Ficus congesta

Ficus irisana

Ficus spp1.

Ficus spp2.

Ficus spp. 3

Ficus spp. 5

Ficus spp. 6Ficus variegata

Lithocarpus spp

Litsea tomentosa

Mallotus spp.

Neonauclea calycina

Palaquium spp.

Shorea contorta

Schefflera octophyllum

Spiraeopsis philippinensis Elm.

Trema orientalis

Ternstroemia spec.2

Vernonia arborea Ham.

Garcinia binucao

Garcinia brevirostris

Garcinia spp.1

Garcinia spp2

Syzygium gracile

Syzygium sp. 67

Bischhofia javanica

Dillenia philippinensis

Dillenia reifferscheidia

Ficus benjamina

Ficus chrysolepis

Ficus sepiegata

Ficus spp. 4

Ficus spp. 8

Turpinia ovalifolia Elm.

Canarium villosum.

Litsea quercoides Elm.

Myrica esculenta Buch.-Ham.

Platea excelsa (Heine) Sleum.

Prunus fragrans (Elm.) Kalkm.

Siphonodon celastrineus Griff.

Symplocus ophirensis Clarke

Arthrocarpus heterophyllus

Acer niveum

Agathis philippinesis

Actinodaphne spec.

Cinnamomum mercadoi

Elaeocarpus cumingii

Elaeocarpus sp.

Macaranga bicolor

Memexylon brachybotris

Memexylon cumingii

Memxylon sp2

Palaquium luzoniensis

Pometia pinnata

Pouteria sp.

Symplocus ahernii

Shorea almon

Syzygium garciae

Shorea polysperma

Ternstroemia megacarpa

Weinmania camiguinensis

Page 13: Designing Mixed-Species Native Tree Reforestation Trial in ... · Spiraeopsis philippinensis Elm. Trema orientalis Ternstroemia spec.2 Vernonia arborea Ham. Garcinia binucao Garcinia

Social Preference of Native Trees

13

47 respondents

List of tree species and their uses

Source: Chechina and Hamann 2015

Page 14: Designing Mixed-Species Native Tree Reforestation Trial in ... · Spiraeopsis philippinensis Elm. Trema orientalis Ternstroemia spec.2 Vernonia arborea Ham. Garcinia binucao Garcinia

Preference of Native Trees (N=35/71)

14

Rank = number of respondents + number of uses

Almaciga

Nato-w

Danlugan

Odling-w

Odling-r

Kaningag

Panobul

Tangile

Katmon

Bagosantol

Source: Chechina and Hamann 2015

Page 15: Designing Mixed-Species Native Tree Reforestation Trial in ... · Spiraeopsis philippinensis Elm. Trema orientalis Ternstroemia spec.2 Vernonia arborea Ham. Garcinia binucao Garcinia

Preference of Native Trees (N=35)

15

Rank = number of respondents + number of uses

Almaciga

Nato-w

Danlugan

Odling-w

Odling-r

Kaningag

Panobul

Tangile

Katmon

Bagosantol

Page 16: Designing Mixed-Species Native Tree Reforestation Trial in ... · Spiraeopsis philippinensis Elm. Trema orientalis Ternstroemia spec.2 Vernonia arborea Ham. Garcinia binucao Garcinia

16

r = - 0.51

Source: Chechina and Hamann 2015

Ecologic and socioeconomic preferenceT

ree s

uccessio

n

Late

Earl

y

Page 17: Designing Mixed-Species Native Tree Reforestation Trial in ... · Spiraeopsis philippinensis Elm. Trema orientalis Ternstroemia spec.2 Vernonia arborea Ham. Garcinia binucao Garcinia

17Source: Chechina and Hamann 2015

Ecologic and socioeconomic preferenceT

ree s

uccessio

n

Late

Earl

y

Page 18: Designing Mixed-Species Native Tree Reforestation Trial in ... · Spiraeopsis philippinensis Elm. Trema orientalis Ternstroemia spec.2 Vernonia arborea Ham. Garcinia binucao Garcinia

Ecologic and socioeconomic preference

18

Shorea contorta

Hig

h (

earl

y)Lo

w (

late

)

Source: Chechina and Hamann 2015

Tre

e s

uccessio

n

Late

Earl

y

Page 19: Designing Mixed-Species Native Tree Reforestation Trial in ... · Spiraeopsis philippinensis Elm. Trema orientalis Ternstroemia spec.2 Vernonia arborea Ham. Garcinia binucao Garcinia

Synthesis of Native Species Plantations

19

Page 20: Designing Mixed-Species Native Tree Reforestation Trial in ... · Spiraeopsis philippinensis Elm. Trema orientalis Ternstroemia spec.2 Vernonia arborea Ham. Garcinia binucao Garcinia

Spatial Association of Tree Species

20

10 20 30 40 50

020

4060

80

PlotC Species Distribution

X Position

Y P

ositi

on

Growth rates versus

competition index (USC

work)

Neighborhood modeling

(Lasky et al. 2014)

Page 21: Designing Mixed-Species Native Tree Reforestation Trial in ... · Spiraeopsis philippinensis Elm. Trema orientalis Ternstroemia spec.2 Vernonia arborea Ham. Garcinia binucao Garcinia

Experimental Trial Design

21

Experiment 1: Randomized block design in shade vs. no shade

Experiment 2: Combinations chosen by spatial association in shade vs. no shade

Page 22: Designing Mixed-Species Native Tree Reforestation Trial in ... · Spiraeopsis philippinensis Elm. Trema orientalis Ternstroemia spec.2 Vernonia arborea Ham. Garcinia binucao Garcinia

Trial Site Assessment: Inside Protected Forest Land

22

Cogon grass and Caliandra shrub

Located on poor acidic soils

Page 23: Designing Mixed-Species Native Tree Reforestation Trial in ... · Spiraeopsis philippinensis Elm. Trema orientalis Ternstroemia spec.2 Vernonia arborea Ham. Garcinia binucao Garcinia

Wildling Collection

23

Ficus irisana

Page 24: Designing Mixed-Species Native Tree Reforestation Trial in ... · Spiraeopsis philippinensis Elm. Trema orientalis Ternstroemia spec.2 Vernonia arborea Ham. Garcinia binucao Garcinia

Wildling Collection

24

Parashorea melaanoan

Page 25: Designing Mixed-Species Native Tree Reforestation Trial in ... · Spiraeopsis philippinensis Elm. Trema orientalis Ternstroemia spec.2 Vernonia arborea Ham. Garcinia binucao Garcinia

Nursery Establishment

25Source: Gregorio et al. 2010

Target: ~40 native

species (including

20 early

successional)

Page 26: Designing Mixed-Species Native Tree Reforestation Trial in ... · Spiraeopsis philippinensis Elm. Trema orientalis Ternstroemia spec.2 Vernonia arborea Ham. Garcinia binucao Garcinia

Monitoring of Plantations

26

Growth, survival &

base diameter

Leaf

number

Rate of

photosynthesis

Source: Gregorio et al. 2012

Page 27: Designing Mixed-Species Native Tree Reforestation Trial in ... · Spiraeopsis philippinensis Elm. Trema orientalis Ternstroemia spec.2 Vernonia arborea Ham. Garcinia binucao Garcinia

Project Green Light

27

Endorsement of DENR of Bacolod City

Endorsement of Municipal Environment and

Natural Resource Office of Silay City

MOA with Silay City Water Association

Research Gratuitous Permit from Protected Areas

Management Board of Bacolod

SCWA

PAMB

Page 28: Designing Mixed-Species Native Tree Reforestation Trial in ... · Spiraeopsis philippinensis Elm. Trema orientalis Ternstroemia spec.2 Vernonia arborea Ham. Garcinia binucao Garcinia

Acknowledgements

28

Dr. Andreas Hamann, U of A

Cristia Ledesma, ENRO of Silay City

David Castor, NFEFI

North Negros Forest Guards of Silay City

Maria Lourdes Severino Conlu

Yannick Neveux, GIS and Wildlife Specialist

[email protected]