Design of an automated system for a removable...

34
Design of an automated system for a removable decay pipe window for LBNF Salvatore Alberto Buccellato Final Presentation 23 rd September 2016

Transcript of Design of an automated system for a removable...

Page 1: Design of an automated system for a removable …eddata.fnal.gov/lasso/summerstudents/papers/2016/...LBNF! Salvatore Alberto Buccellato| Design of an automated system for a removable

Design of an automated system for a removable decay pipe window for LBNF!Salvatore Alberto Buccellato!Final Presentation!23rd September 2016!!

Page 2: Design of an automated system for a removable …eddata.fnal.gov/lasso/summerstudents/papers/2016/...LBNF! Salvatore Alberto Buccellato| Design of an automated system for a removable

LBNF!

9/22/2016!Salvatore Alberto Buccellato| Design of an automated system for a removable decay pipe window for LBNF!

2!

Long-Baseline Neutrino Facility!

Sending neutrinos on a 800 mi (1,300 km) journey

Page 3: Design of an automated system for a removable …eddata.fnal.gov/lasso/summerstudents/papers/2016/...LBNF! Salvatore Alberto Buccellato| Design of an automated system for a removable

Project Specification!

9/22/2016!3!

•  Decay Pipe at a Positive Helium pressure 5 psig (0.34 bar)!

!•  Operation 2.3 MW!!•  Window diameter of

1.5 meter!!•  Window should be

curved and include a center section of beryllium!

!•  Remotely

Removable!

Salvatore Alberto Buccellato| Design of an automated system for a removable decay pipe window for LBNF!

Page 4: Design of an automated system for a removable …eddata.fnal.gov/lasso/summerstudents/papers/2016/...LBNF! Salvatore Alberto Buccellato| Design of an automated system for a removable

•  Highly radioactive environment: human access is not possible;!

•  Beam-on dose rates preclude use of an elastomeric seal;!

•  Remote positioning and tightening;!

•  Permissible Seal Leak rate less 0.01 Std.cc/sec!

4! 9/22/2016!Salvatore Alberto Buccellato| Design of an automated system for a removable decay pipe window for LBNF!

Page 5: Design of an automated system for a removable …eddata.fnal.gov/lasso/summerstudents/papers/2016/...LBNF! Salvatore Alberto Buccellato| Design of an automated system for a removable

5!

Seal system!

Helicoflex®  Seal  

9/22/2016!Salvatore Alberto Buccellato| Design of an automated system for a removable decay pipe window for LBNF!

Page 6: Design of an automated system for a removable …eddata.fnal.gov/lasso/summerstudents/papers/2016/...LBNF! Salvatore Alberto Buccellato| Design of an automated system for a removable

Seal System Performance and loading!

•  Metal Seals achieve leak rates on the order of 10-6 Std cc Helium / second.!–  This is better than the 0.01 cc/sec requirement.!!

•  Requires high load applied to seal:!–  1542 pounds per linear inch!–  Total compression on seal is about 286,000 pounds (1.27 MN)!

•  For comparison, the loading due to the 5 psig internal pressure is about 13,000 pounds!

6! 9/22/2016!Salvatore Alberto Buccellato| Design of an automated system for a removable decay pipe window for LBNF!

Page 7: Design of an automated system for a removable …eddata.fnal.gov/lasso/summerstudents/papers/2016/...LBNF! Salvatore Alberto Buccellato| Design of an automated system for a removable

7!

Previous Solutions!

Autoclave  with  rota4ng  ring  

9/22/2016!Salvatore Alberto Buccellato| Design of an automated system for a removable decay pipe window for LBNF!

Pressured  slabs  

Page 8: Design of an automated system for a removable …eddata.fnal.gov/lasso/summerstudents/papers/2016/...LBNF! Salvatore Alberto Buccellato| Design of an automated system for a removable

8!

New Solution!

There  wasn’t  enough  pressure  on  the  seal    Use  of  a  flange  

9/22/2016!Salvatore Alberto Buccellato| Design of an automated system for a removable decay pipe window for LBNF!

Page 9: Design of an automated system for a removable …eddata.fnal.gov/lasso/summerstudents/papers/2016/...LBNF! Salvatore Alberto Buccellato| Design of an automated system for a removable

9!

Flange Choice!

Corrosion  problems:  use  of  steel  is  not  possible    Two  solu4ons:  Titanium,  Stainless  Steel    We  choose  Titanium  HEX  HEAD  M12    Safety  Factor:  4.5  

9/22/2016!Salvatore Alberto Buccellato| Design of an automated system for a removable decay pipe window for LBNF!

Page 10: Design of an automated system for a removable …eddata.fnal.gov/lasso/summerstudents/papers/2016/...LBNF! Salvatore Alberto Buccellato| Design of an automated system for a removable

10!

Flange Calculation!Bolt  parameters  

Bolt  type              M12  PL  Strength              792MPa  Stress  Area                  92,1  mm2  

𝐹𝑖=𝑘×𝑆𝑝×𝐴𝑡  

𝑘=0.9  

𝑇=0.2×𝐹𝑖×𝑑=176𝑁𝑚  

𝑇=129  𝑙𝑏𝑠  𝑓𝑡  

𝐹𝑟=𝑌2×𝐷×𝜋=1,27×106  N    

𝑛= 𝐹𝑟/𝐹𝑖 ∗𝜂=80  

𝜂=4.5  

9/22/2016!Salvatore Alberto Buccellato| Design of an automated system for a removable decay pipe window for LBNF!

Page 11: Design of an automated system for a removable …eddata.fnal.gov/lasso/summerstudents/papers/2016/...LBNF! Salvatore Alberto Buccellato| Design of an automated system for a removable

9/23/16!Presenter | Presentation Title!11!

Two possible solutions!

Tailored  Design    Commercial  Robot    We  chose  to  have  a  conceptual  design  of  both  the  solu4ons  in  order  to  understand  which  can  be  beUer  for  our  purposes.  

Page 12: Design of an automated system for a removable …eddata.fnal.gov/lasso/summerstudents/papers/2016/...LBNF! Salvatore Alberto Buccellato| Design of an automated system for a removable

9/23/16!Presenter | Presentation Title!12!

Tailored Design!

Page 13: Design of an automated system for a removable …eddata.fnal.gov/lasso/summerstudents/papers/2016/...LBNF! Salvatore Alberto Buccellato| Design of an automated system for a removable

13!

Replacement system requirements!

Major  problem:  space    Cartesian  robot  not  possible    2  Degrees  of  Freedom  needed    We  can  use  steel  and  aluminum  

9/22/2016!Salvatore Alberto Buccellato| Design of an automated system for a removable decay pipe window for LBNF!

Page 14: Design of an automated system for a removable …eddata.fnal.gov/lasso/summerstudents/papers/2016/...LBNF! Salvatore Alberto Buccellato| Design of an automated system for a removable

14!

Replacement system design!

•  Rota4onal  +  Prisma4c  Joint  

•  Curve  Profile  •  Hydraulic  Bolt  Tightener  •  Socket  Head  Bolts    

9/22/2016!Salvatore Alberto Buccellato| Design of an automated system for a removable decay pipe window for LBNF!

Page 15: Design of an automated system for a removable …eddata.fnal.gov/lasso/summerstudents/papers/2016/...LBNF! Salvatore Alberto Buccellato| Design of an automated system for a removable

15!

Saving space!

LynxDrive  20C  with  Harmonic  Drive  Technology      Linear  Actuator  with  Parallel  Motor    

9/22/2016!Salvatore Alberto Buccellato| Design of an automated system for a removable decay pipe window for LBNF!

Page 16: Design of an automated system for a removable …eddata.fnal.gov/lasso/summerstudents/papers/2016/...LBNF! Salvatore Alberto Buccellato| Design of an automated system for a removable

16!

Reducing Torque!

Aluminum  hollow  body    2  suppor4ng  pins  on  bolt  4ghtener  

9/22/2016!Salvatore Alberto Buccellato| Design of an automated system for a removable decay pipe window for LBNF!

Page 17: Design of an automated system for a removable …eddata.fnal.gov/lasso/summerstudents/papers/2016/...LBNF! Salvatore Alberto Buccellato| Design of an automated system for a removable

9/23/16!Presenter | Presentation Title!17!

Commercial Robot!

Page 18: Design of an automated system for a removable …eddata.fnal.gov/lasso/summerstudents/papers/2016/...LBNF! Salvatore Alberto Buccellato| Design of an automated system for a removable

9/23/16!Presenter | Presentation Title!18!

What do we need!

Buying  a  Commercial  Robot,  we  want  it  to  be:    •  Light  •  Versa4le  •  With  high  payload-­‐weight  

ra4o  

Page 19: Design of an automated system for a removable …eddata.fnal.gov/lasso/summerstudents/papers/2016/...LBNF! Salvatore Alberto Buccellato| Design of an automated system for a removable

9/23/16!Presenter | Presentation Title!19!

Our Choice!

Page 20: Design of an automated system for a removable …eddata.fnal.gov/lasso/summerstudents/papers/2016/...LBNF! Salvatore Alberto Buccellato| Design of an automated system for a removable

9/23/16!Presenter | Presentation Title!20!

Pros and Cons: Commercial vs Tailored Designed!

+    No  need  for    adaptability  

+  Developed  in  Lab  +  Op4mized  for  this  

 task    -­‐  Need  for  tes4ng  -­‐  Costs  -­‐  More  human  

resources  required  -­‐  Cannot  be  reused  

for  other  applica4ons  

 

+    Versa4le  (can  be    reused)  

+  Already  tested  +  Cheaper  +  Fewer  human  

 resources  needed    -­‐  Not  Op4mized  -­‐  Need  to  adapt  to  

the  task    

Page 21: Design of an automated system for a removable …eddata.fnal.gov/lasso/summerstudents/papers/2016/...LBNF! Salvatore Alberto Buccellato| Design of an automated system for a removable

9/23/16!Presenter | Presentation Title!21!

Our Choice!

Commercial Robot!

Page 22: Design of an automated system for a removable …eddata.fnal.gov/lasso/summerstudents/papers/2016/...LBNF! Salvatore Alberto Buccellato| Design of an automated system for a removable

9/23/16!Presenter | Presentation Title!22!

Impact Wrench - Requirements!

Weight  <  5kg    Small  (less  than  30  cm)    Max  Torque  >  176  Nm    Remotely  Controllable  Torque  

Page 23: Design of an automated system for a removable …eddata.fnal.gov/lasso/summerstudents/papers/2016/...LBNF! Salvatore Alberto Buccellato| Design of an automated system for a removable

9/23/16!Presenter | Presentation Title!23!

Impact Wrench – Our Choice!

Page 24: Design of an automated system for a removable …eddata.fnal.gov/lasso/summerstudents/papers/2016/...LBNF! Salvatore Alberto Buccellato| Design of an automated system for a removable

9/23/16!Presenter | Presentation Title!24!

Impact Wrench - Automation!

The  impact  wrench  is  meant  to  be  manual    We  have  to  find  a  way  to  automa4ze  it:    •  BuUon  holder  

•  Stepper  motor  switch  

•  Pressure  regula4on    

Page 25: Design of an automated system for a removable …eddata.fnal.gov/lasso/summerstudents/papers/2016/...LBNF! Salvatore Alberto Buccellato| Design of an automated system for a removable

9/23/16!Presenter | Presentation Title!25!

Impact Wrench and Robot Link!

Discharge  the  torque:  two  suppor4ng  pins    Modeled  star4ng  from  the  impact  wrench  rear  

cover    

Switch  flanged  

Page 26: Design of an automated system for a removable …eddata.fnal.gov/lasso/summerstudents/papers/2016/...LBNF! Salvatore Alberto Buccellato| Design of an automated system for a removable

9/23/16!Presenter | Presentation Title!26!

Window Replacement System!

Window  s4ll  ac4vated  when  removed    Need  for  a  radia4on  shield    Steel  shield  5  cm  thick  

Page 27: Design of an automated system for a removable …eddata.fnal.gov/lasso/summerstudents/papers/2016/...LBNF! Salvatore Alberto Buccellato| Design of an automated system for a removable

9/23/16!Presenter | Presentation Title!27!

Window Replacement System!

Wheel-­‐mounted  system    Two  blocks  come  inside  the  window  and  clock  in  order  to  carry  it    Everything  is  moved  with  threaded  rods  

Page 28: Design of an automated system for a removable …eddata.fnal.gov/lasso/summerstudents/papers/2016/...LBNF! Salvatore Alberto Buccellato| Design of an automated system for a removable

9/23/16!Presenter | Presentation Title!28!

AirLock!

We  want  not  to  lose  all  the  Helium    Installa4on  of  an  AirLock    Opened  just  at  beginning  and  ending  of  the  opera4on  

Page 29: Design of an automated system for a removable …eddata.fnal.gov/lasso/summerstudents/papers/2016/...LBNF! Salvatore Alberto Buccellato| Design of an automated system for a removable

9/23/16!Presenter | Presentation Title!29!

Full Design!

Page 30: Design of an automated system for a removable …eddata.fnal.gov/lasso/summerstudents/papers/2016/...LBNF! Salvatore Alberto Buccellato| Design of an automated system for a removable

9/23/16!Presenter | Presentation Title!30!

Full Design!

Page 31: Design of an automated system for a removable …eddata.fnal.gov/lasso/summerstudents/papers/2016/...LBNF! Salvatore Alberto Buccellato| Design of an automated system for a removable

9/23/16!Presenter | Presentation Title!31!

Full Design!

Page 32: Design of an automated system for a removable …eddata.fnal.gov/lasso/summerstudents/papers/2016/...LBNF! Salvatore Alberto Buccellato| Design of an automated system for a removable

9/23/16!Presenter | Presentation Title!32!

Full Design!

Page 33: Design of an automated system for a removable …eddata.fnal.gov/lasso/summerstudents/papers/2016/...LBNF! Salvatore Alberto Buccellato| Design of an automated system for a removable

9/23/16!Presenter | Presentation Title!33!

Further Steps!

Simula4ons  and  sizing;    Development  of  a  control  system  based  on  vision;    Purchase  of  Robot  and  Impact  Wrench;    Tes4ng.  

Page 34: Design of an automated system for a removable …eddata.fnal.gov/lasso/summerstudents/papers/2016/...LBNF! Salvatore Alberto Buccellato| Design of an automated system for a removable

34!

Thanks  for  your  aUen4on  

9/22/2016!Salvatore Alberto Buccellato| Design of an automated system for a removable decay pipe window for LBNF!