Descent with Modification

Theme:• Evolutionary change is based on the

interactions between populations & their environment which results in adaptations (inherited characteristics) to increase fitness

Evolution = change over time in the genetic composition of a population

Charles Darwin (1809-1882)

•English naturalist•1831: joined the HMS Beagle

for a 5-year research voyage around the world (stopped at: Galapagos Islands)

•1859 – published Origin of Species

•Influenced by Lamarck, Hutton & Lyell, Malthus

Darwin’s Theory of Natural Selection:1. Populations produce more offspring than

can possibly survive.2. Individuals in a population vary extensively

from each other, mostly due to inheritance.3. Struggle to survive: individuals whose

inherited characteristics best fit to environment leave more offspring than less fit.

4. Unequal ability of individuals to survive and reproduce leads to gradual change in pop, with favorable characteristics accumulating over generations.

•Populations evolve, not individuals.•Fitness is determined by the environment.

In summary:Natural Selection = differential success in

reproductionProduct of natural selection = adaptations

of populations to environment

Therefore, if humans can create substantial change over short time, nature can over long time.

Natural Selection Artificial Selection

•Nature decides •“Man” decides

•Works on individual •Selective breeding

•Inbreeding occurs

•i.e. beaks •i.e. dalmations

Evidence for Evolution1. Biogeography

▫ Geographic distribution of a species▫ Geographic, reproductive isolation

2. Fossil Record – transitional forms3. Comparative Anatomy

1. Homologous structures2. Vestigial structures

4. Embryonic Development5. Molecular Biology

▫ DNA, proteins

Gill pouches

Post-anal tail

Chicken embryo

Human embryo

•Darwin’s could not explain how inherited variations are maintained in populations - not “trait blending”

•A few years after Darwin’s “Origin of Species”, Gregor Mendel proposed his hypothesis of inheritance:Parents pass on discrete heritable units

(genes) that retain their identities in offspring

•Frequencies of alleles & genotypes in a population’s gene pool remain constant from generation to generation unless acted upon by agents other than sexual recombination (gene shuffling in meiosis)

•Equilibrium = allele and genotype frequencies remain constant

Allele Frequencies:•Gene with 2 alleles : p, q

p = frequency of allele “A ” in a population

q = frequency of allele “a” in a population Note:

1 – p = q1 – q = p

Genotype Frequencies:•3 genotypes (AA, Aa, aa)

p2 = AA2pq = Aaq2 = aa

1. Extremely large population size (no genetic drift).

2. No gene flow (isolation from other populations).

3. No mutations.4. Random mating (no sexual selection).5. No natural selection.

•If any of the Hardy-Weinberg conditions are not met microevolution occurs

•Microevolution = generation to generation change in a population’s allele frequencies

1. Mutations – changes in DNA Point mutations Gene duplication

Mutation will alter or create

new alleles in a population.

2. Sexual Recombination▫ Rearrange alleles into fresh combinations

every generation

3. Natural selection

Douglas fir trees only release their seeds during fires. Fire rarely occurs in the river bottom of this valley.

4. Genetic drift: a change in a population’s allele frequencies due to chance bottleneck and founder effect

A. Bottleneck Effect – genetic drift due to drastic reduction in population size▫ Certain alleles may be over/under

represented

Northern elephant seals hunted nearly to extinction in

California

B. Founder effect – few individuals become isolated from larger population certain alleles over/under represented

Polydactyly in Amish population

5. Gene flow – genetic exchange due to migration of fertile individuals i.e. wind storm blows pollen to another field Reduces differences between populations Gain/lose alleles

Natural selection can alter frequency distribution of heritable traits in 3 ways:

1.Directional selection2.Disruptive (diversifying) selection3.Stabilizing selection

Directional Selection: eg. beak sizes of birds during wet/dry seasons in Galapagos

Diversifying Selection: eg. small beaks for small seeds; large beaks for large seeds

Stabilizing Selection: eg. average human birth weight

Preserving Genetic Variation•Diploidy: inherit 2 alleles

Recessive alleles less favorable Heterozygote protection

•Heterozyote Advantage: People hybrid for sickle cell anemia protected

against malaria.

•Sexual selection for mating success▫Intra (within same sex) – competition for

mate▫Inter (out) – mate choice

Darwinian Fitness : ability to survive AND reproduce AND pass on alleles to offspring

Sexual selection may lead to pronounced secondary differences between the sexes

• Remember:▫Individuals are selected▫Populations evolve

• Terms:▫Population = localized group belonging to

same species▫Species = members of a population that can

interbreed and produce fertile viable offspring▫Gene pool = total combo of genes in a

population at any one time▫Fixed population = all members are

homozygous for trait (usually not the case)

Speciation = origin of species

•Microevolution: changes within a single gene pool

•Macroevolution: evolutionary change above the species level▫cumulative effects of speciation over long

periods of time

Similarity between different species.

Anagenesis Cladogenesis

Anagenesis (“new” “race”)

• Phyletic evolution• A single species

gradually changes into a different species

• No original group left• Evolution in single

direction

Cladogenesis (“branch” “race”)

• Branching evolution• One species stays same, but

small portion leaves and changes to another species

• Gene pool splits• Original + new groups• Increase in diversity/# of

species

Two Patterns of Evolutionary Change

•Proposed by Ernst Mayr (1942)•Species = population or group of

populations whose members have the potential to interbreed in nature and produce viable, fertile offspring▫Reproductively compatible

•Reproductive isolation = barriers that prevent members of 2 species from producing viable, fertile hybrids

Prezygotic Barriers:▫Impede

mating/fertilizationTypes:

▫Habitat isolation▫Temporal isolation▫Behavioral isolation▫Mechanical isolation▫Gametic isolation

Postzygotic Barriers:▫Prevent hybrid zygote

from developing into viable adult

Types:▫Reduced hybrid

viability▫Reduced hybrid

fertility▫Hybrid breakdown

Prezygotic barriers impede mating or hinder fertilization if mating does occur

Postzygotic barriers prevent a hybrid zygote fromdeveloping into a viable, fertile adult

REDUCED HYBRIDVIABILITY

REDUCED HYBRIDFERTILITY

HYBRID BREAKDOWN

HABITAT ISOLATION TEMPORAL ISOLATION BEHAVIORAL ISOLATION MECHANICAL ISOLATION GAMETIC ISOLATION

Reducedhybrid

viability

FertilizationViable,fertile

offspring

Reducedhybridfertility

Hybridbreakdown

Matingattempt

Gameticisolation

Fertilization

Mechanicalisolation

Behavioralisolation

Temporalisolation

Habitatisolation

Individualsof

differentspecies

Types of Reproductive Barriers

Other definitions of species:

•Morphological – by body shape, size, and other structural features

•Paleontological – fossil record•Ecological – niche/role in community

•Phylogenetic – unique genetic history, branch on tree of life

Allopatric speciation Sympatric speciation

Two main modes of speciation

Two main modes of speciation:Allopatric Speciation

“other” “homeland”

Geographically isolated

Evolves by natural selection & genetic drift

Eg. Galapagos finches

Sympatric Speciation

“same” “homeland”

Overlapping populations within home range

Subset of population isolated from parent pop. change due to:

• chromosomal changes• nonrandom mating• habitat differentiation

Eg. polyploidy in plants (oats, cotton, potatoes, wheat)

•Emergence of numerous species from a common ancestor introduced into new environment

•Occurs when: A few organisms make way to new, distant

areas (allopatric speciation) Environmental change extinctions

new niches for survivors•Eg. Hawaiian archepelago

Founding

Parents

When 2 splintered groups rejoin geographically:

Possibilities:1. Still one species2. Two distinct species (no

interbreeding)3. Hybrid zone

Gradualism• Darwin• Slow, constant

change• Less likely

Punctuated Equilibium• Eldridge & Gould• Long period of minor

change are interrupted by short bursts of significant change

• More likely

Tempo of Evolution

• Independent development of similar features between 2 unrelated species

•Similar environments•Analogous structures•Eg. wings on bees & wings on birds

REMEMBER!!•Dear King Philip Came Over For Good Spaghetti•Dear King Philip Crossed Over Five Great Seas•Dear King Philip Came Over From Germany Stoned•Your own???

Drosophila

Lanc

elet

Fish

Amph

ibia

nBird

Human

RatM

ouse

• Phylogeny = evolutionary history of a species or group of species

Phylogram: the length of a branch reflects the number of changes that have taken place in a particular DNA sequence in that lineage

• Cladogram: diagram of evolutionary relationship of organisms▫Shared characteristics due to common

ancestry▫Uses parsimony – simplest explanation, fewest

DNA base changes for tree (“keep it simple”)

LE 25-11b

Turtle Leopard

Hair

Amniotic egg

Four walking legs

Hinged jaws

Vertebral column

Salamander

Tuna

Lamprey

Lancelet (outgroup)

Cladogram

Comparison of Structures

Homology Analogy

• Results from:▫ Adaptive radiation▫ Common ancestor▫ Similar origin

• Different functions• Eg. wing of bat, human

arm, dolphin flipper

• Results from:▫ Convergent evolution▫ Different ancestors▫ Different origin

• Similar functions• Eg. wings of bird, wings of

insect

Remember:•Adaptive radiation – emergence of many species from common ancestor•Convergent evolution – unrelated species independently evolve similarities when adapting to similar environments

Major events during each Era• Precambrian: microscopic fossils (stromatolites)

▫Photosynthesis, atmospheric O2▫Eukaryotes (endosymbiont theory)

• Paleozoic: Cambrian Explosion▫Plants invade land, many animals appear▫Permian Extinction (-96% species)

• Mesozoic: “Age of Reptiles”, dinosaur, plants▫Formation of Pangaea supercontinent▫Cretaceous Extinction – asteroid off Mexico’s coast

• Cenozoic: primates

Note: All end with major extinction & start with adaptive radiation

Land plants

Animals

Paleozoic

Meso-

zoic

Ceno-zoic

Origin of solarsystem andEarth

41

2 3Multicellulareukaryotes

Single-celledeukaryotes

Prokaryotes

Atmosphericoxygen

ProterozoicEon

ArchaeanEon

Humans

Billions of years ago

Evolution of Plants

•Non-Vascular (liverworts, hornworts, mosses) Seedless Vascular (ferns) Seed Vascular (gymnosperms, angiosperms)

•Mosses: Gametophytes = dominant form•Ferns: 1st with vascular tissue (xylem,

phloem▫wet environment (fertilization in water)▫Sporophyte = dominant form

•Gymnosperms: “naked” seeds on cones▫Conifers

•Angiosperms: flowering plants

Evolution of Animals – Body Plan

Evolution of Animals – Body Cavities

Evolution of Animals – Development

Evolution of Animals

Evolution of Animals•Porifera (sponge)•Cnidarian (jellyfish, hydra)•Flatworms (planaria)•Mollusc

▫Gastropod (snail), bivalve (clams), cephalopod (octopus)

•Annelid (earthworm)•Arthropods (insects, crustaceans)•Echinoderms (“spiny skin” = starfish, sea

urchins)•Chordates (vertebrates)

Chordate Characteristics

Phylogeny of living chordates