Descartes Felsefesinde Kuşkudan Bilgiye Geçiş ve Zihnin ... · ally, it would break off the...

17
Beytulhikme An International Journal of Philosophy, Volume 2, Issue 2, December 2012 BEYTULHIKME An International Journal of Philosophy ______________________________________________________________________ Yurtsuz ______________________________________________________________________ si, Fen 49100, [email protected] ______________________________________________________________________ a- tekhne- nin poiesise u- l- e- a- fe ile bunun so- n- Anahtar Kelimeler: t- .

Transcript of Descartes Felsefesinde Kuşkudan Bilgiye Geçiş ve Zihnin ... · ally, it would break off the...

Page 1: Descartes Felsefesinde Kuşkudan Bilgiye Geçiş ve Zihnin ... · ally, it would break off the relationship between technology and Being. The break off connection of Being and begining

Beytulhikme An International Journal of Philosophy, Volume 2, Issue 2, December 2012

BE

YT

UL

HI

KM

E

An

I

nt

er

na

ti

on

al

J

ou

rn

al

o

f

Ph

il

os

op

hy

______________________________________________________________________

Yurtsuz ______________________________________________________________________

si, Fen 49100,

[email protected]

______________________________________________________________________

a-

tekhne-

nin poiesise u-

l-

e-

a-

fe ile bunun so-

n-

Anahtar Kelimeler: t-

.

Page 2: Descartes Felsefesinde Kuşkudan Bilgiye Geçiş ve Zihnin ... · ally, it would break off the relationship between technology and Being. The break off connection of Being and begining

Beytulhikme An International Journal of Philosophy, Volume 2, Issue 2, December 2012

36

BE

YT

UL

HI

KM

E

An

I

nt

er

na

ti

on

al

J

ou

rn

al

o

f

Ph

il

os

op

hy

______________________________________________________________________

Problem of Homelessness of Human Being in the Context of Technology in Heidegger ______________________________________________________________________

Res. Assist. Arts and Sciences, Department of

Philosophy49100, [email protected]

______________________________________________________________________

Abstract: In this paper, I focused on an examination of the relationship

between the critic of technology and homelesness of human being as a

technology and causality that is basis of modern science. Later, it is asser-

ted that the essence of technology is not instrumental, which has been

used for the definition of technology today. This thought is based on the

concept of tekhne which was used by Heidegger. Heidegger says that tekh-

ne belongs to poiesis that means bringing - forth and is something poietic.

In this context, technology is losed its meaning and reduced the its mea-

ning only instrumental. Hence, it doesnt mean bringing forth. Eventu-

ally, it would break off the relationship between technology and Being.

The break off connection of Being and begining of metaphysical thinking

would become our main references the understanding of subject centered

philosophy that is the background of modern technology and result in

homelessness of human being as a problem.

Keywords: Technology,metaphysics, enframing, being, homelessness, cal-

culative thinking.

Page 3: Descartes Felsefesinde Kuşkudan Bilgiye Geçiş ve Zihnin ... · ally, it would break off the relationship between technology and Being. The break off connection of Being and begining

Beytulhikme An International Journal of Philosophy, Volume 2, Issue 2, December 2012

37 Hei-

deggerHeidegger

BE

YT

UL

HI

KM

E

An

I

nt

er

na

ti

on

al

J

ou

rn

al

o

f

Ph

il

os

op

hy

t

n-

a-

t-

jik

m-

i-

genel

o-

e-

epis-

temesi

i-

nin birle -bilim var

Page 4: Descartes Felsefesinde Kuşkudan Bilgiye Geçiş ve Zihnin ... · ally, it would break off the relationship between technology and Being. The break off connection of Being and begining

Beytulhikme An International Journal of Philosophy, Volume 2, Issue 2, December 2012

38

BE

YT

UL

HI

KM

E

An

I

nt

er

na

ti

on

al

J

ou

rn

al

o

f

Ph

il

os

op

hy

e-

-

tehlikeli durumu & Wrathall, 2005: 182). Metafizik

z-

1.

idegger

a-

r-

g-

i-

i-

n-

Page 5: Descartes Felsefesinde Kuşkudan Bilgiye Geçiş ve Zihnin ... · ally, it would break off the relationship between technology and Being. The break off connection of Being and begining

Beytulhikme An International Journal of Philosophy, Volume 2, Issue 2, December 2012

39 Hei-

deggerHeidegger

BE

YT

UL

HI

KM

E

An

I

nt

er

na

ti

on

al

J

ou

rn

al

o

f

Ph

il

os

op

hy

1 Tek-

k

k-

g-

: a) Teknoloji,

noloji mo-

dern tekno (Carino, 2009:

i-

n-

d

sorgula

a-

i

a-

arak ele alabiliriz (Heidegger, 1998: 10-

n-

a-

i-

eidegger, 1998: 12).

v-

1 -

(vorhanden) bir

-bulunan (vorhanden)

m-

de yar 1962: 15, 98)

Page 6: Descartes Felsefesinde Kuşkudan Bilgiye Geçiş ve Zihnin ... · ally, it would break off the relationship between technology and Being. The break off connection of Being and begining

Beytulhikme An International Journal of Philosophy, Volume 2, Issue 2, December 2012

40

BE

YT

UL

HI

KM

E

An

I

nt

er

na

ti

on

al

J

ou

rn

al

o

f

Ph

il

os

op

hy

elerinde

n-

e-

hin mad

i-

o-

n-

(Heidegger, 1998: 12).

i-

a-

e-

e-

i-

p-

n-

a-

ilgisi yoktur. Bizlerin neden, causa aition, bir

Page 7: Descartes Felsefesinde Kuşkudan Bilgiye Geçiş ve Zihnin ... · ally, it would break off the relationship between technology and Being. The break off connection of Being and begining

Beytulhikme An International Journal of Philosophy, Volume 2, Issue 2, December 2012

41 Hei-

deggerHeidegger

BE

YT

UL

HI

KM

E

An

I

nt

er

na

ti

on

al

J

ou

rn

al

o

f

Ph

il

os

op

hy

aition bize

causa neden

aition olarak nedeni yani

eh

a-

i-

hayetinde ise ku causa

efficency n-

r (Heidegger,

1998: 13-1

irilmelidir.

r-

a-

poiesis r-

physis physis

poiesis physis a-

physis

poiesis

getirmedir Heidegger r-

alethia veritas bizim

Page 8: Descartes Felsefesinde Kuşkudan Bilgiye Geçiş ve Zihnin ... · ally, it would break off the relationship between technology and Being. The break off connection of Being and begining

Beytulhikme An International Journal of Philosophy, Volume 2, Issue 2, December 2012

42

BE

YT

UL

HI

KM

E

An

I

nt

er

na

ti

on

al

J

ou

rn

al

o

f

Ph

il

os

op

hy

ise -16). Nihay

t-

-nedensellik-

t-

a-

n-

Aition h-

alethia

gelmesidir. Alethia

alethia a-

tahlil edebiliriz.

a-

k-

Page 9: Descartes Felsefesinde Kuşkudan Bilgiye Geçiş ve Zihnin ... · ally, it would break off the relationship between technology and Being. The break off connection of Being and begining

Beytulhikme An International Journal of Philosophy, Volume 2, Issue 2, December 2012

43 Hei-

deggerHeidegger

BE

YT

UL

HI

KM

E

An

I

nt

er

na

ti

on

al

J

ou

rn

al

o

f

Ph

il

os

op

hy

n-

cadan gelme techneye

zam

Heidegger tekhnenin poiesise

tekhne

episteme ile

tekhne nin bir aleteuein

Tekhne, kendi

e

r-

-

poiesis

g

Page 10: Descartes Felsefesinde Kuşkudan Bilgiye Geçiş ve Zihnin ... · ally, it would break off the relationship between technology and Being. The break off connection of Being and begining

Beytulhikme An International Journal of Philosophy, Volume 2, Issue 2, December 2012

44

BE

YT

UL

HI

KM

E

An

I

nt

er

na

ti

on

al

J

ou

rn

al

o

f

Ph

il

os

op

hy

olarak Ren neh

a

santralin neh

r

e

r-

e

(Heidegger, 1998: 20-22).

n-

- (Bestand) diyor. Buradan hare-

dim olma-

(ge-stellt) veya

2.

Heidegger y-

m-

u-

Page 11: Descartes Felsefesinde Kuşkudan Bilgiye Geçiş ve Zihnin ... · ally, it would break off the relationship between technology and Being. The break off connection of Being and begining

Beytulhikme An International Journal of Philosophy, Volume 2, Issue 2, December 2012

45 Hei-

deggerHeidegger

BE

YT

UL

HI

KM

E

An

I

nt

er

na

ti

on

al

J

ou

rn

al

o

f

Ph

il

os

op

hy

olarak

l-

e

u-

u-

a-

- a-

Page 12: Descartes Felsefesinde Kuşkudan Bilgiye Geçiş ve Zihnin ... · ally, it would break off the relationship between technology and Being. The break off connection of Being and begining

Beytulhikme An International Journal of Philosophy, Volume 2, Issue 2, December 2012

46

BE

YT

UL

HI

KM

E

An

I

nt

er

na

ti

on

al

J

ou

rn

al

o

f

Ph

il

os

op

hy

u-

Oysaki

n-

:

(1998: 51-52).

gizleyen metafiziksel

a-

k-

ikincisine Var-

-

ndirge-

i-

219-220). Varl

i-

e-

t-

l-

n-

Page 13: Descartes Felsefesinde Kuşkudan Bilgiye Geçiş ve Zihnin ... · ally, it would break off the relationship between technology and Being. The break off connection of Being and begining

Beytulhikme An International Journal of Philosophy, Volume 2, Issue 2, December 2012

47 Hei-

deggerHeidegger

BE

YT

UL

HI

KM

E

An

I

nt

er

na

ti

on

al

J

ou

rn

al

o

f

Ph

il

os

op

hy

-

e-

leme e-

Dasein

n-

a-

z-

i-

tedir(Aslan,

e-

mektedir. Nitekim poiesis

Page 14: Descartes Felsefesinde Kuşkudan Bilgiye Geçiş ve Zihnin ... · ally, it would break off the relationship between technology and Being. The break off connection of Being and begining

Beytulhikme An International Journal of Philosophy, Volume 2, Issue 2, December 2012

48

BE

YT

UL

HI

KM

E

An

I

nt

er

na

ti

on

al

J

ou

rn

al

o

f

Ph

il

os

op

hy

yaliz

bede

de bir tekn

r-

e-

a-

da tutamaz (Carino, 2009: 493).

i-

erinde mo-

t-

y

r (Gauthier, 2004: 116- i-

k-

Page 15: Descartes Felsefesinde Kuşkudan Bilgiye Geçiş ve Zihnin ... · ally, it would break off the relationship between technology and Being. The break off connection of Being and begining

Beytulhikme An International Journal of Philosophy, Volume 2, Issue 2, December 2012

49 Hei-

deggerHeidegger

BE

YT

UL

HI

KM

E

An

I

nt

er

na

ti

on

al

J

ou

rn

al

o

f

Ph

il

os

op

hy

n-

cedir (Gauthier, 2004: 116-121).

r-

k

Teknoloji, gerek insan gereks

p-

k-

o-

i-

n-

e-

Dasein olmaktan

i-

i-

a-

e-

mesi ise

Page 16: Descartes Felsefesinde Kuşkudan Bilgiye Geçiş ve Zihnin ... · ally, it would break off the relationship between technology and Being. The break off connection of Being and begining

Beytulhikme An International Journal of Philosophy, Volume 2, Issue 2, December 2012

50

BE

YT

UL

HI

KM

E

An

I

nt

er

na

ti

on

al

J

ou

rn

al

o

f

Ph

il

os

op

hy

y-

-

ve

eticisi

z-

r-

Kaynaklar

Aslan, H. (2006). 43, 5-13.

Botha, C.F. (2003). Heidegger, Technology and Ecology. South African Journal of

Philosophy, 22(2), 157-73.

Carino, J.V. (2009). Heidegger and the Danger of Modern Technology. Philippini-

ana Sacra, 132, 491-504.

Bursa: Asa Kitabevi.

Dreyfus, H.L. & Wrathall, M.A. (ed.) (2005). A Companion to Heidegger. Massachus-

sets: Blackwell Publishing.

Heidegger, M. (1962). Being and Time (trans. J. Macquarrie & E. Robinson). New

York: Harper & Row.

Heidegger, M. (1998). n-

Heidegger, M. (2008). p.

Page 17: Descartes Felsefesinde Kuşkudan Bilgiye Geçiş ve Zihnin ... · ally, it would break off the relationship between technology and Being. The break off connection of Being and begining

Beytulhikme An International Journal of Philosophy, Volume 2, Issue 2, December 2012

51 Hei-

deggerHeidegger

BE

YT

UL

HI

KM

E

An

I

nt

er

na

ti

on

al

J

ou

rn

al

o

f

Ph

il

os

op

hy

. Bursa: Asa Kitabevi.

Gauthier, D.J. (2000). Martin Heidegger, Emmanuel Levinas, and the Politics of Dwel-

ling. PhD. Thesis. Louisiana: Graduate Faculty of the Louisiana State Uni-

versity and Agriculture and Mechanical College.

. Bur-

Zitzelsberger, H.M. (2004). Concerning Technology: Thinking with Heidegger.

Nursing Philosophy, 5, 242-50.