Deep Learning for Image Analysis · 5/13/2020 · The Secret Sauce: Pretrained Networks • A...
Transcript of Deep Learning for Image Analysis · 5/13/2020 · The Secret Sauce: Pretrained Networks • A...
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved.
Welcome to Deep Learning for Image Analysis
Benjamin WilhelmDavid Kolb
Going live at:
Berlin 5:00 PM (CEST) New York City 11:00 AM (EDT)Austin 10:00 AM (CDT) London 4:00 PM (GMT)
2© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved.
Before we start…
• Please use the Q&A section to post your questions.
• Upvote for your favorite questions.
• Session is recorded and will be available on YouTube.
3© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved.
Before we start…
• Please use the Q&A section to post your questions.
• Upvote for your favourite questions.
• Session is recorded and will be available on YouTube.
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 4
Outline
• Motivation
• Fundamentals
• Image Classification
– Cats & Dogs Classification in KNIME
• Semantic Segmentation
– Natural Image Segmentation in KNIME
• Image Captioning
– Image Captioning in KNIME
5© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved.
Motivation
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 6
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017
Erro
r in
%
Year
Winners of the ImageNet Challenge
Deep Learning
Why Deep Learning?
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 7
Why Deep Learning?
Sergios Karagiannakoshttps://sergioskar.github.io/Semantic_Segmentation/
Bearman and Donghttp://www.catherinedong.com/pdfs/231n-paper.pdf
Isola et al.http://openaccess.thecvf.com/content_cvpr_2017/papers/Isola_Image-To-Image_Translation_With_CVPR_2017_paper.pdf
Purnasai Gudikandulahttps://medium.com/@purnasaigudikandula/artistic-neural-style-transfer-with-pytorch-1543e08cc38f
Silver et al.https://doi.org/10.1038/nature24270
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 8
History of Deep Learning
1943
Neural Nets McCulloch & Pitt
1958
PerceptronRosenblatt
1960
Adaline
Widrow & Hoff
1969XOR Problem
Minsky & Papert
1974Backpropagation
Werbos
1980Neocognitron
(CNN)Fukushima
1986Multi-layered
Perceptron (Backpropagation)Rumelhart, Hinton
& Williams
1990LeNetLecun
2012AlexNet
Krizhevsky
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 9
Interest in Deep Learning according to Google Trends
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 10
What has changed?
Image Source:https://www.nvidia.com/content/dam/en-zz/es_em/Solutions/Data-Center/tesla-v100/[email protected]
Image Source:https://medium.com/syncedreview/sensetime-trains-imagenet-alexnet-in-record-1-5-minutes-e944ab049b2c
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 11
Deep Learning Software
https://developer.nvidia.com/caffe2
https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Datei:Pytorch_logo.png
https://danilobzdok.de/links/theano-deeplearning-package/
https://raw.githubusercontent.com/dmlc/dmlc.github.io/master/img/logo-m/mxnet2.png
https://geekflare.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/05/MicrosoftCNTKlogo.png
https://chainer.org/images/chainer_icon_red.png
https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/2/2d/Tensorflow_logo.svg
https://miro.medium.com/max/368/1*u2t2N3lu8sH1CSsSrP_UyQ.png
https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/c/c0/ONNX_logo_main.png
https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/c/c9/Keras_Logo.jpg
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 12
Deep Learning Software in KNIME
https://developer.nvidia.com/caffe2
https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Datei:Pytorch_logo.png
https://danilobzdok.de/links/theano-deeplearning-package/
https://raw.githubusercontent.com/dmlc/dmlc.github.io/master/img/logo-m/mxnet2.png
https://geekflare.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/05/MicrosoftCNTKlogo.png
https://chainer.org/images/chainer_icon_red.png
https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/2/2d/Tensorflow_logo.svg
https://miro.medium.com/max/368/1*u2t2N3lu8sH1CSsSrP_UyQ.png
https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/c/c0/ONNX_logo_main.png
https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/c/c9/Keras_Logo.jpg
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 13
KNIME Keras Integration
14© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved.
Fundamentals
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 15
Recap: Machine Learning
• Learning programs from data
• Supervised Learning– Input: Data points with labels
– Output: Model that maps from data points to labels
– Examples: Classification, regression
• Unsupervised Learning– Input: Data points without labels
– Output: Model that captures structure of data
– Examples: Clustering, dimensionality reduction
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 16
Examples of Supervised Learning
Images → Class labels
Credit history → Credit score
Customer data → Churn probability
Low resolution image → High resolution image
Cell image → Segmentation
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 17
The Multilayer Perceptron
Input Hidden Output
Neuron
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 18
A Single Neuron
𝑤1
𝑤2
𝑤3
𝜎 𝑏 +
𝑖
𝑤𝑖𝑥𝑖
𝑥1
𝑥2
𝑥3
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 19
Activation Functions
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 20
Forward Propagation
𝑥
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 21
Forward Propagation
𝑥 ℎ(𝑥)
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 22
Forward Propagation
𝑥 ℎ(𝑥) 𝑜(ℎ 𝑥 )
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 23
Modelling Probabilities
• Classification tasks require to output probabilities
• Properties of a probability distribution
– All values are non-negative
– All values sum up to 1
• Binary classification: Sigmoid
• Multi-class classification: Softmax
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 24
Forward Propagation
𝑥 ℎ(𝑥) 𝑜(ℎ 𝑥 ) Correct?
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 25
Loss Functions
• Evaluate how far model outputs are from the true label
• Task dependent
– Binary classification: Binary cross entropy
– Multi-class classification: Categorical cross entropy
– Regression: Mean squared/absolute error
• Must be differentiable
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 26
Gradient Descent
Gradient
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 27
Gradient Descent
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 28
Gradient Descent
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 29
Backpropagation
• All parts of a deep learning model are differentiable
• Backpropagation uses the chain rule to calculate the gradient of the loss with respect to all weights
• Modern deep learning software performs this automagically
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 30
Forward Propagation
𝑥 ℎ(𝑥) 𝑜(ℎ 𝑥 ) 𝑙𝑜𝑠𝑠 = 𝑙 𝑜 ℎ 𝑥
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 31
Backpropagation
𝑙′ 𝑥 = 𝑜′ ℎ 𝑥 ℎ′(𝑥)
Information Flow
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 32
Stochastic Gradient Descent
• Calculating the gradient on the full dataset is time-consuming
• Stochastic Gradient Descent: Evaluate on single data point
• Mini-batch Gradient Descent: Evaluate on a small set of data points
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 33
Momentum
• Averages past gradients
• Equivalent of a ball rolling down a slope (acceleration)
• Can help to
– Reduce fluctuation
– Speed-up progress in direction with small but consistent gradients
– Escape local minima
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 34
Adaptive Learning Rate
• The learning rate controls how large the steps taken by gradient descent are
• Not all parameters may require the same learning rate
• Solution: Adapt the learning rate based on the variance of the gradient
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 35
Different Gradient Descent Optimizers
Optimizer Momentum Adaptive Learning Rates
SGD ✗ ✗
SGD + Momentum ✔ ✗
Adagrad ✗ ✔
Adadelta ✗ ✔
RMSProp ✗ ✔
Adam ✔ ✔
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 36
The True Goal: Generalization
• Overfitting: Model overfits noise of the training set
• Low loss on training data but high loss on unseen data
• Remedy– Decrease model capacity
– Use Data Augmentation
– RegularizationImage Source:https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/1/19/Overfitting.svg
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 37
Old-school Regularization
• Add regularization term to loss that penalizes large parameters
• 𝐿2-Regularization (weight decay)
– Prefers solutions with small weights
• 𝐿1-Regularization
– Prefers solution with sparse weights (most weights are 0)
• Elastic net
– Combination of 𝐿1- and 𝐿2-Regularization
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 38
Dropout
• During training: Randomly drop some neurons
• During inference:Scale neuron activations by drop rate
• Prevents the network to rely too much on individual features
39© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved.
Image Classification
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 40
What is Image Classification?
Task:Decide to which class an image belongs to
Example:Cat or Dog?
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 41
Image Classification with Deep Learning
Input Output
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 42
Image Input for Deep Learning
255 250 100 113 117
248 223 89 105 101
227 65 233 95 91
89 6 65 89 186
70 211 100 78 111
Image Source: https://cdn.pixabay.com/photo/2017/09/12/21/17/dog-2743705_960_720.jpg
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 43
Image Classification with Deep Learning
Input
Output
255 250 100 113 117
248 223 89 105 101
227 65 233 95 91
89 6 65 89 186
70 211 100 78 111
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 44
Image Classification Output
Class Probabilities
Cat Dog
0% 100%
Cat Dog
100% 0%
One-hot vector
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 45
Image Classification with Deep Learning
Input
255 250 100 113 117
248 223 89 105 101
227 65 233 95 91
89 6 65 89 186
70 211 100 78 111
Cat Dog
14% 86%
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 46
Image Classification with Deep Learning
Input
255 250 100 113 117
248 223 89 105 101
227 65 233 95 91
89 6 65 89 186
70 211 100 78 111
Cat Dog
14% 86%
Feature Extraction & Information Aggregation
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 47
Feature Extraction using Convolution
1 2 3
-4 7 4
2 -5 1
Kernel
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 50
Kernel Example
-1 0 1
-2 0 2
-1 0 1
* =
Sobel Y
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 51
Convolutional Layer
• Filter weights are trainable parameters
• Many filters to extract different kinds of features
Image Source: https://datascience.stackexchange.com/a/67324
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 52
Pooling: Aggregating Spatial Information
1 2 8 2
7 4 6 1
8 5 6 9
5 3 1 0
7 8
8 9
3.5 4.25
5.25 4
Max Pooling
Average Pooling
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 53
CNN for Image Classification
Cat
Dog
Image Source: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/6/63/Typical_cnn.png
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 54
Data Augmentation
• Idea: Create more data using ground truth preserving transformations
• Examples
– Mirroring
– Rotation
– Translation
– Zooming
– Color transformations
– Blur
– NoiseImage Source: https://cdn.pixabay.com/photo/2017/09/12/21/17/dog-2743705_960_720.jpg
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 55
The Secret Sauce: Pretrained Networks
• A trained network can be used as initialization for a network solving a different/related task
• Fine-tuning: The other task is similar– Example: A network trained for classification on Imagenet is fine-
tuned to discriminate between images of cats and dogs
• Transfer-learning: The other tasks differs greatly– Example: A network trained for classification on Imagenet is used to
initialize the backbone of a semantic segmentation network
• Feature extraction: The network is only used to extract features
56© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved.
1. Example:Cats & Dogs Classification in KNIME
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 57
Cats & Dogs Data
https://www.kaggle.com/c/dogs-vs-cats/overview
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 58
Cats & Dogs Classification in KNIME
1. Image preprocessing and augmentation
2. Train a simple CNN from scratch
3. Fine-tune a pretrained model
Three Workflows:
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 59
1. Image Preprocessing and Augmentation
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 60
1. Image Preprocessing and Augmentation
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 61
1. Image Preprocessing and Augmentation
Input:
3200 examples
Output:
64000 augmented examples
(80/20) split
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 62
1. Image Preprocessing and Augmentation
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 63
2. Train a Simple CNN
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 65
2. Train a Simple CNN
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 66
Create One-hot Vector
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 67
2. Train a Simple CNN
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 71
2. Train a Simple CNN
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 72
Format Network Output
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 73
Score
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 74
3. Fine-tune a Pretrained Model
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 75
How to Fine-tune a Model?
Basic Recipe (of many):
1. Choose existing architecture, pretrained on a similar task
2. Adapt network head to new task (e.g. number of neurons)
3. Re-train new head only (maybe also some other layers)
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 76
Prepare pretrained ResNet50 Model
ResNet50 Only train the
new network head
Add new head
ResNet50: https://arxiv.org/abs/1512.03385
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 77
3. Fine-tune a Pretrained Model
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 78
Score
79© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved.
Semantic Segmentation
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 80
Semantic Segmentation
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 82
Before: Classification
Image Source: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/6/63/Typical_cnn.png
We have: One classification per imageWe need: One classification per pixel
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 83
Simple Approach: Sliding Window
Monkey
Tree
Fence
Problem: Inefficient
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 84
Another Approach: Only Convolutional Layers
Image Source: http://cs231n.stanford.edu/slides/2017/cs231n_2017_lecture11.pdf
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 85
Better: Encoder-Decoder
Image Source: http://cs231n.stanford.edu/slides/2017/cs231n_2017_lecture11.pdf
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 86
Upsampling? Transpose Convolution
Image Source: https://medium.com/apache-mxnet/transposed-convolutions-explained-with-ms-excel-52d13030c7e8
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 87
U-Net
Ronneberger et al.https://arxiv.org/pdf/1505.04597.pdf
88© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved.
2. Example:Natural Image Segmentation in KNIME
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 89
Workflow Demo
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 90
Workflow Demo
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 91
Workflow Demo
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 92
Workflow Demo
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 93
Workflow Demo
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 94
Workflow Demo
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 95
Workflow Demo
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 96
Workflow Demo
97© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved.
Image Captioning
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 98
What is Image Captioning?
Task:Describe the contents of an image
Example Captions:• A fancy desert on a plate
with a twisted orange.• A plate has a dessert and
orange slices on it.• some iice crean sitting next
to some orange slices …
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 99
Image Captioning with Deep Learning
`A fancy desert on a plate with a twisted orange.`
Does this work?
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 100
Problem Formulation
Problem:
• Length of caption to predict unknown (we need a fixed output dimension for the output layer)
Simple Approach (of many):
• Iterative approach predicting word by word
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 101
Image Captioning with Deep Learning
Image
Next Word in Caption
Partial Caption
One neuron for each possible word, each
word is a `class`
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 102
Iterative Approach Example
Input1: Image Input2: Partial Caption Output: Target Word
*image1* startseq A
*image1* startseq, A fancy
*image1* startseq, A, fancy desert
*image1* startseq, A, fancy, desert on
…
*image1* …, with, a, twisted, orange, . endseq
`A fancy desert on a plate with a twisted orange.`
Special tokens marking start and end of sentence
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 103
Network Inputs
Input1:
255 250 100 113 117
248 223 89 105 101
227 65 233 95 91
89 6 65 89 186
70 211 100 78 111
Input2:startseq, A, fancy, desert ?
Replace words with vocabulary indices
12, 452, 1120, 38
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 104
Network Output
Output: fancy […, 0, 0, 1, 0, …]
Convert vocabulary index of target word to one-hot vector
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 105
How to do Prediction?
Using same iterative approach:
• Predict first word using image and start token (startseq)
• Predict next words using image and partial caption from the previous prediction iteration
• Repeat until endseq is predicted
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 106
Reduce Complexity
Use Help ➜ Transfer Learning:
• Image Input: Use pretrained image features (InceptionV3)
• Text Input: Use pretrained embedding vectors (GLOVE)
Approach: Pre-calculate InceptionV3 image- and GLOVE
embedding-features
• Make captions simpler using textprocessing
InceptionV3 : https://arxiv.org/abs/1512.00567, GLOVE: https://nlp.stanford.edu/projects/glove/
107© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved.
3. Example:Image Captioning in KNIME
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 108
COCO Data
Large image datasets for many different tasks, e.g. image captioning
Five captions per image:• A hot dog bun filled with macaroni salad.• A hot dog bun has macaroni and cheese in it.• A hotdog bun filled with noodles on a plate with fries.• Mac and cheese sub with some fries on the side. • A nice meal sitting on top of a plate.
We are using a randomly sampled subset containing ≈ 8000 images.
Dataset: http://cocodataset.org/#home
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 109
Image Captioning in KNIME
1. Caption preprocessing
2. Pre-calculate image features
3. Pre-calculate GLOVE embedding vectors
4. Model Training
5. Prediction
Five Workflows:
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 110
1. Caption Preprocessing
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 111
1. Caption Preprocessing
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 112
Clean Captions
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 113
1. Caption Preprocessing
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 114
1. Caption Preprocessing
1830 unique wordsvs. ≈ 10000 before cleaning
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 115
2. Pre-calculate Image Features
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 116
2. Pre-calculate Image Features
Extract features of last dense layer (length 2048)
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 117
2. Pre-calculate Image Features
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 118
3. Pre-calculate GLOVE Embedding Vectors
GLOVE is a type of Word Embedding
What are Word Embeddings?:
• Map a word (or vocabulary index) to some position in an n-dimensional space, the position (relative to other words) encodes the semantics of the word
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 119
GLOVE Embedding Vectors Intuition
Nearest Neighbors to ‘frog’:(in terms of distance on the GLOVE vectors)
Image Source: https://nlp.stanford.edu/projects/glove/
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 120
3. Pre-calculate GLOVE Embedding Vectors
Several versions with different length vectors, we choose the 200-dimensional ones here
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 121
3. Pre-calculate GLOVE Embedding Vectors
Look-up word vector for every vocabulary entry and save it in a Python dictionary
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 122
4. Model Training
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 123
Word/Vocab Mapping
…
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 124
4. Model Training
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 125
Create Training Data
29
Padded with zeros to create equal length vectors (29)
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 126
4. Model Training
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 127
Caption Network
Input1: Image Vector
Input2: Word Indices
Shape: [2048]
Shape: [29]
Maps word indices to GLOVE vectors using our pre-calculated dictionary
Shape: [1831]
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 128
Caption Network
Input1: Image Vector
Input2: Word Indices
Shape: [2048]
Shape: [29]
Shape: [1831]
1831 softmax vector (1800 vocabulary size + ‘0’ padding)
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 129
4. Model Training
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 130
Training
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 131
Training
Creates one-hot vector from indices
Caution: Indices must not get out of range of the output shape!
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 132
4. Model Training
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 133
5. Prediction
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 134
Prepare Test Data
startseq:1176
29
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 135
5. Prediction
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 136
Iterative Prediction
1. Start with startseq token
2. Predict next token
3. If predicted token == endseq, exclude example from next iteration
4. Else, go to 2.
5. Repeat until all examples have been excluded
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 137
Iterative Prediction
endseq:348
Trained Model
Test Data
Predict next token
If predicted token == endseq, route
example to output
Loop output
Data for next iteration,stop loop if empty
Else
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 138
5. Prediction
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 139
Caption Results
© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved. 140
Caption Results
141© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved.
Questions?
142© 2020 KNIME AG. All Rights Reserved.
The End –thank you for joining this webinar.