Decision-making in the WTO: medieval or up-to-date? WTO Public Forum, Geneva, 26 September 2006...

5
Decision-making in the WTO: medieval or up-to-date? WTO Public Forum, Geneva, 26 September 2006 Introductory comments Manfred Elsig HEI/WTI

Transcript of Decision-making in the WTO: medieval or up-to-date? WTO Public Forum, Geneva, 26 September 2006...

Page 1: Decision-making in the WTO: medieval or up-to-date? WTO Public Forum, Geneva, 26 September 2006 Introductory comments Manfred Elsig HEI/WTI.

Decision-making in the WTO: medieval or up-to-date?

WTO Public Forum, Geneva, 26 September 2006

Introductory comments

Manfred ElsigHEI/WTI

Page 2: Decision-making in the WTO: medieval or up-to-date? WTO Public Forum, Geneva, 26 September 2006 Introductory comments Manfred Elsig HEI/WTI.

Objectives

Assessment of the current system of decision-making

Address institutional reform related to decision-making

Bridge academic, diplomatic and NGO debates

Page 3: Decision-making in the WTO: medieval or up-to-date? WTO Public Forum, Geneva, 26 September 2006 Introductory comments Manfred Elsig HEI/WTI.

The WTO as a (legitimate) political system:Some Key Concepts

Transparency

Accountability

Participation Efficiency

Input Legitimacy Output Legitimacy

Page 4: Decision-making in the WTO: medieval or up-to-date? WTO Public Forum, Geneva, 26 September 2006 Introductory comments Manfred Elsig HEI/WTI.

What means “Decision-making“

• Decision-Making in a wider sense (Systemic Issues)

Access to the system (Participation) Output/Public Good (Efficiency) Acceptance (Legitimacy) WTO-Jargon (Transparency) Influence/power (Realpolitik)

• Decision-Making in a narrow sense (Decision Rules)

Formal/Informal QMV/Consensus Single Package / Variable Geometry Negotiation Modalities/Formulas Ministerials From G1 to G149 (decision fora and coalitions) The Role of the Secretariat

Page 5: Decision-making in the WTO: medieval or up-to-date? WTO Public Forum, Geneva, 26 September 2006 Introductory comments Manfred Elsig HEI/WTI.

Decision-making in the WTO: medieval or up-to-date?

• Thanks for your attention!