Decentralized Coordination and Information Sharing …...Early Warning and Response? 5 Gap between...

14
1 Decentralized Coordination and Information Sharing in Flood Early Warning and Response

Transcript of Decentralized Coordination and Information Sharing …...Early Warning and Response? 5 Gap between...

Page 1: Decentralized Coordination and Information Sharing …...Early Warning and Response? 5 Gap between Warning and Response Based on Comes (2016) 6 Gas Station Explosion. Accra, 2015 •150

1

Decentralized Coordination

and Information Sharing in

Flood Early Warning and

Response

Page 2: Decentralized Coordination and Information Sharing …...Early Warning and Response? 5 Gap between Warning and Response Based on Comes (2016) 6 Gas Station Explosion. Accra, 2015 •150

2

Users: Community Response

Page 3: Decentralized Coordination and Information Sharing …...Early Warning and Response? 5 Gap between Warning and Response Based on Comes (2016) 6 Gas Station Explosion. Accra, 2015 •150

3

Community Disaster Response

Risks:

• Lack of Coordination

• Safety and Security

• Accountability, Privacy

• Malevolent Actions…

Regardless Risks, Community Response will occur

Page 4: Decentralized Coordination and Information Sharing …...Early Warning and Response? 5 Gap between Warning and Response Based on Comes (2016) 6 Gas Station Explosion. Accra, 2015 •150

4

Previous Research

Previous research:

• EV-CREW

• COBACORE

Can Be:

• Among Communities e.g. Cajun navy

• Across hierarchical scales e.g. Mud Army

Focus on Recovery. Early Warning and Response?

Page 5: Decentralized Coordination and Information Sharing …...Early Warning and Response? 5 Gap between Warning and Response Based on Comes (2016) 6 Gas Station Explosion. Accra, 2015 •150

5

Gap between Warning and Response

Based on Comes (2016)

Page 6: Decentralized Coordination and Information Sharing …...Early Warning and Response? 5 Gap between Warning and Response Based on Comes (2016) 6 Gas Station Explosion. Accra, 2015 •150

6

Gas Station Explosion. Accra, 2015

• 150 casualties• Shelter in unsafe location

Is a warning enough? What info is Relevant?

Page 7: Decentralized Coordination and Information Sharing …...Early Warning and Response? 5 Gap between Warning and Response Based on Comes (2016) 6 Gas Station Explosion. Accra, 2015 •150

7

Early Warning Systems

Information Relevance:

• Warning / Expected Consequences

Information Sharing:

• Towards Communities

• Local info for Professional Responders?

• Info for Coordination of Actions?

• What else is needed to take action?

Coordination Structures

• Among Communities e.g. Cajun Navy

• Across hierarchies e.g. Mud Army

Collaborative?

How to Design Collaborative Early Warning Systems?

Page 8: Decentralized Coordination and Information Sharing …...Early Warning and Response? 5 Gap between Warning and Response Based on Comes (2016) 6 Gas Station Explosion. Accra, 2015 •150

8

Building a “Safe” Testing Environment

• Build App and

Wait for the Flood?

• Build an App and

Simulate:

• How many?

• At which scale?

• Modelling Complex Adaptive Systems

• Top-down: untested approaches?

• Bottom-up: new approaches.

Use Bottom-Up / Agent Based Modelling

Page 9: Decentralized Coordination and Information Sharing …...Early Warning and Response? 5 Gap between Warning and Response Based on Comes (2016) 6 Gas Station Explosion. Accra, 2015 •150

9

Agent Based Model Components

Information Sharing & Relevance

• Mode: Face to face or Remotely

• From whom to whom

Coordination Structures

• In peer groups

• Between communities and institutions

Flood Propagation model

• Lead Time

• Information VS Flood Propagation

• Generation of incidents

• Verification of protection efforts

Page 10: Decentralized Coordination and Information Sharing …...Early Warning and Response? 5 Gap between Warning and Response Based on Comes (2016) 6 Gas Station Explosion. Accra, 2015 •150

10

Expected Results

• Shopping List of Information

• How to get Info Flowing

• How to Coordinate with Communities

Design Guidelines for Collaborative EWS

Page 11: Decentralized Coordination and Information Sharing …...Early Warning and Response? 5 Gap between Warning and Response Based on Comes (2016) 6 Gas Station Explosion. Accra, 2015 •150

11

Thank you!

Vittorio NespecaDelft University of Technology

[email protected]

Page 12: Decentralized Coordination and Information Sharing …...Early Warning and Response? 5 Gap between Warning and Response Based on Comes (2016) 6 Gas Station Explosion. Accra, 2015 •150

12

Research Objectives

Design Principles for Collaborative EWS to improve Resilience through Information Sharing and Decentralized Coordination

RO1: Information relevance framework

RO2: Measurement of information sharing and coordination performance

RO3: Evaluate and characterize information sharing and reporting approaches

RO4: Evaluate and characterize different coordination structures

Page 13: Decentralized Coordination and Information Sharing …...Early Warning and Response? 5 Gap between Warning and Response Based on Comes (2016) 6 Gas Station Explosion. Accra, 2015 •150

13

Platform for Communities

13

Page 14: Decentralized Coordination and Information Sharing …...Early Warning and Response? 5 Gap between Warning and Response Based on Comes (2016) 6 Gas Station Explosion. Accra, 2015 •150

14

Applications for Citizens and

Institutions

14