DEALING WITH CRUISE TERMINAL DEALS AND AGREEMENT …
Transcript of DEALING WITH CRUISE TERMINAL DEALS AND AGREEMENT …
© B&A Copyright
02.12.19
PRESENTATION TO:
PORT ADMINISTRATION AND LEGAL ISSUES SEMINAR
STRUCTURING LEASE PROVISIONS
DEALING WITH CRUISE TERMINAL DEALS AND
LEASE AGREEMENT IMPACTS ON STRATEGIC VISION PLANNING
© B&A Copyright
MASTER PLANNING EXPERIENCE
• PORT OF GALVESTON MASTER PLAN (ON-GOING)
• PORT EVERGLADES STRATEGIC MASTER PLAN (ON-GOING)
• PORT MIAMI STRATEGIC PLANS (2008, 2012, 2017)
• PORT CANAVERAL CRUISE MASTER PLAN 2014
• PORT CANAVERAL STRATEGIC MASTER PLAN (2017)
• PORT TAMPA BAY CHANNELSIDE MASTER PLAN (2015)
• JAXPORT MASTER PLAN (2013)
• SINGAPORE MARINA BAY MASTER PLAN (2017)
• PORT OF SEATTLE PIER 66 MULTI-USE CRUISE FACILITY & MASTER PLAN (2017)
• PORT OF SAN DIEGO - GENERAL PLANNING AND FINANCIAL FEASIBILITY (2004-PRESENT)
© B&A Copyright
WORLDWIDE CRUISE PASSENGERS
0
5,000
10,000
15,000
20,000
25,000
30,000
Pa
sse
ng
ers
('0
00
)
Asia Europe North America
© B&A Copyright
0
5
10
15
20
25
Ne
w b
uild
ve
sse
ls
Vessels Delivered Vessels On Order
CRUISE VESSEL DELIVERIES AND ORDERS
267 vessels
111 vessels
250,761 berths
20 LNG
© B&A Copyright
AVG. PAX PER SHIP BY YEAR OF CONSTRUCTION, 1999 – 2019
1,427
1,782
1,464
1,833
2,098
2,0772,200
2,703
2,7142,845
3,4563,379
3,298
2,713
3,319
3,596
3,5483,656
3,782
4,1604,350
0
500
1,000
1,500
2,000
2,500
3,000
3,500
4,000
4,500
5,000P
ass
en
ge
rs
© B&A Copyright
GLOBAL FORECAST
50,188,12054,274,800
58,430,061
10,000,000
20,000,000
30,000,000
40,000,000
50,000,000
60,000,000
70,000,000
Pa
sse
ng
ers
Low Medium High
© B&A Copyright
MIAMI / RCCL TERMINAL A – CRUISE LINE INVESTMENT ON LAND LEASE
• GROUND LEASE (20 YEARS PLUS 4 10-YEAR EXTENSIONS) 60 YEARS
• FINANCE, DESIGN, BUILD, OPERATE, MAINTAIN
• MUST KEEP 20% OWNERSHIP IN DEVELOPMENT COMPANY
© B&A Copyright
SEATTLE PIER 66 – NCL – 50-50 PARTNERSHIP WITH PORT
• LEASE (PORT MAINTAINS OWNERSHIP) 15 YEARS PLUS 5• NCL EXCHANGING THROUGHPUT GUARANTEE FOR INVESTMENT
• SPLIT $30-MILLION IN FACILITY UPGRADES FOR BLISS PLUS
© B&A Copyright
PORT EVERGLADES TERMINALS
2, 4, 18, 19, 21, 26
FUNDED DIRECTLY BY THE COUNTY
WITH MAXIMUM REVENUE / PAX
THROUGHOUT GUARANTEES
• CARNIVAL CORP
– CARNIVAL
– PRINCESS
– HOLLAND AMERICA
– P&O CRUISES
– COSTA CRUISES
– CUNARD
• RCCL– CELEBRITY
– RCI
© B&A Copyright
PEV 25 – CELEBRITY – GUARANTEE TO SUPPORT INVESTMENT BY COUNTY
• COUNTY - $100-MILLION INVESTMENT
• DUE TO TIMELINE – RCCL BID CONTRACTOR / PM • 20-YEAR TERM WITH THROUGHPUT REVENUE GUARANTEE
© B&A Copyright
2018
CANAVERAL T3 - CARNIVAL
• COUNTY - $150-MILLION INVESTMENT
• 25-YEAR PRIMARY TERM WITH FOUR ADDITIONAL FIVE-YEAR RENEWAL OPTIONS
• MINIMUM ANNUAL GUARANTEE FROM $7 MILLION TO $14.5 MILLION PER ANNUM
© B&A Copyright
MIAMI / NCL B – COMPLEX DEAL
• COUNTY - $100-MILLION INVESTMENT (DESIGN, FINANCE, BUILD AND MAINTAIN) • 1.3 MILLION NCL MAG PLUS OTHER INCENTIVES
• $24 MILLION IN GROSS REVENUES FROM 2018 PER ANNUM
© B&A Copyright
COMBINATIONS
OWNERSHIP INVESTMENT OPERATIONS
PORT PORT PORT PORT
CRUISE LINE V1 PORT CRUISE LINE CRUISE LINE
CRUISE LINE V2 PORT CRUISE LINE OPERATOR
OPERATOR PORT OPERATOR OPERATOR
DEVELOPER PRIVATE ENTITY PRIVATE ENTITY OPERATOR
© B&A Copyright
CRUISE LINE LEANINGS
• SOME CRUISE LINES ARE LEANING TOWARD “CONTROLLING THEIR OWN DESTINY”
BY BUILDING AND OPERATING THEIR TERMINALS
• OTHERS DO NOT DO SUCH A DEAL AS THEY WANT TO PAY MARKET RATES
• OTHERS DO NOT LEAN TO INVEST, BUT ARE ACTIVELY TRYING TO TIE DOWN BERTHS
• OTHERS WANT TO TIE DOWN BERTHS, BUT USE CONSTRUCTION DEBT TO FINANCE
IMPROVEMENTS
© B&A Copyright
THIRD PARTY OPERATOR STATE-OF-THE-INDUSTRY
• MOST TERMINAL OPERATORS ARE RELUCTANT TO TAKE BIG RISKS AND WOULD
MOST LIKELY DEMAND MINIMUMS
• A NEW TYPE OF TERMINAL OPERATING COMPANY IS EVOLVING THAT HAS AN
APPETITE FOR RISK AND UNDERWRITING
– SOME OPERATORS ARE LOOKING TO MAKE MONEY BY VERTICALLY INTEGRATING THE
BUSINESS MODEL (NO FIXED FORMULA, BUT WILL TRY TO ROLL IN AS MUCH AS IT CAN UNDER
ITS UMBRELLA)
• THE MORE RISK THE OPERATOR TAKES THE LESS REVENUE THE PORT WILL RECEIVE
• THE MORE RISK INVOLVED THE LOWER NUMBER OF BIDDERS
– FIRMS THAT MIGHT OFFER THE LOWEST COST MIGHT BE DISCOURAGED FROM BIDDING
© B&A Copyright
PUBLIC POLICY
• IS IT A SINGULAR ASSET OF THE COMMUNITY?
• WATERFRONT IS VIEWED BY MANY AS SOMETHING TO BE HELD IN THE PUBLIC TRUST
– PUBLIC ACCESS AND WATERFRONT INTEGRATION
• ARE THE PRIVATE AND PUBLIC SECTOR GOALS ALIGNED?– PRIVATE – PROFIT
– PUBLIC – ECONOMIC IMPACT
• HOW DO THE CUSTOMERS (LINES) REACT?
• CONSIDER THE LONG-TERM IMPACTS
© B&A Copyright
STRATEGIC MASTER PLANNING
• LOOKS OUT OVER A 20 TO 30-YEAR HORIZON TO ACHIEVE A VISION
• WITHIN THAT TIMEFRAME PROJECTS ARE DEVELOPED TO ACHIEVE THE VISION
– IMPLEMENTATION IS DONE OVER TIME
– BASED ON A SET OF PRINCIPLES – ROI, ECONOMIC IMPACTS, JOBS
– DRIVEN BY THE MARKET – CARGO, CRUISE, COMMERCIAL
© B&A Copyright
CHANNELSIDE WATERFRONT
MARINA DISTRICT CENTRAL WATERFRONT PARK DISTRICT CRUISE DISTRICT
© B&A Copyright
PORT EVERGLADES MASTER VISION PLAN GUIDING PRINCIPLES
– INCREASE EFFICIENCY
• INCREASE CAPACITY AND MINIMIZE TRUCK TRIPS/COSTS THROUGH OPERATIONAL IMPROVEMENTS
• CONSOLIDATE SIMILAR OPERATIONS/OPERATORS TO ACHIEVE HIGHER LAND USE / THROUGHPUT
• SEPARATE MODES OF TRANSPORTATION TO MINIMIZE TRUCK AND NON-TRUCK TRAFFIC
– PRESERVE FLEXIBILITY
• MEET FUTURE DEMAND WITHOUT PRECLUDING CHANGES IN MARKET CONDITIONS
• RECOGNIZE BERTHS ARE THE PRIMARY ASSET OF THE PORT
– UPLANDS SHOULD BE CONFIGURED TO SUPPORT BERTH UTILIZATION
• TECHNOLOGY WILL DRIVE FUTURE OPERATIONS IN UNEXPECTED WAYS
– FACILITATE INTEGRATION
• WITHIN THE PORT
• BETWEEN THE PORT AND SURROUNDING AREA
• ACROSS THE BROADER SUPPLY CHAIN
Fire Station
(5 acres)
Containers
(259 acres)
Cruise
(60 acres, incl. parking)
Logistics
(8 acres)
Vacant
(19 Acres)
Mixed Cargo/Ro-Ro
(46 acres)
Cruise
(21 acres, incl. parking)
Private
(Petroleum)
Dry Bulk
(13 acres)
Private
(Commercial)
CVB/County
Commercial
(3 acres)
Logistics
(5 acres)
FPL - Private
Private (Miscellaneous)
Vacant
(13 acres)
Wetland/Vacant/FPL Transmission Lines
FEC ICTF (43 acres)
Future PEV
ILC
(16 acres)
Private
(Commercial)
Private (Miscellaneous)
Conservation Area
PORT EVERGLADES TODAY
Logistics
(26 acres)
Vacant
(4 acres)
Wetland
(10 acres)
Cruise
(5 acres)
Commercial
(14 acres)
Commercial
(3 acres)
Eller
Dr
McIntosh Loop RdEisenhower Blvd
SE
17
thS
t
Containers (20 acres)
Containers
(22 acres)
Private Commercial
(12 acres)
Logistics
(7 acres)
Liquid Bulk
(23 acres)
Spoils
(6 acres)
Private
(Commercial )
Maintenance
(5 acres)
Dry Bulk
(5 acres)Break-bulk
(3 acres)
Sp
an
gle
r B
lvd
/SR
84
© B&A Copyright
ACHIEVING THE VISION…
• TO ACHIEVE THE VISION…– THERE MUST BE AN ALIGNMENT OF PLANNING & BUSINESS PRACTICES
– PORTS & USERS NEED TO UNDERSTAND THE FUTURE VISION
• TIMING OF CHANGES (SUCH AS SOUTHPORT TURNING NOTCH) AND IMPACTS ON
OPERATIONS
• MODIFICATIONS / TERMINATION OF AGREEMENTS TO REACH THE VISION
– BY EXAMPLE…
» PROVIDING EXTENSIONS
» MODIFYING LAND USE
» FINANCIAL TERMS