8/13/2019 De roy v. CA-article 4

1/2

!"#$%&'( *+ ,-" .-'&'##'/"0

!"#$%&% ()"$*

12/'&2

345!6 6575859:

+,$, -., /012/ 3456478 9:; 2://?@ #, A% $)B 45C D>$+>=>) $@&)!; #",','*/";0

()"$* )< @##%@=! 45C =">! E%$-@=; !$,; +=%->@ E%$-@=; =">!

E%$-@=; 3$,; F%>$! )< &@$>!!@ E%$-@=; 54GHI8; +=>(%$>@ A%=@ ($"?

E%$-@= 45C =">! E%$-@=; !$,; ;"0#*/?"/,0>

$ % ! ) = " * > ) -

()$*%!;!"#3-'0 0#"('2& ('='& 2(,'*/ +*; (";,'*;2;' 0""@0 ,* ?"(&2;" /$&& 2/? =*'? ,A* BCD

;"0*&$,'*/0 *+ ,-" 8#"('2& E';0, 6'='0'*/ *+ ,-" F*$;, *+ G##"2&0 '/ ,-" (20" *+

H$'0 I";/2&< 8;>< ", 2&> => E"&'02 .";?*02 6" !*J< ", 2&>< FGKL>!> F7 :*> MNCOP>

3-" +';0, ;"0*&$,'*/ #;*Q$&R2,"? */ SM 8"#,"Q%"; TUON ?"/'"? #",','*/";0V

Q*,'*/ +*; "W,"/0'*/ *+ ,'Q" ,* +'&" 2 Q*,'*/ +*; ;"(*/0'?";2,'*/ 2/? ?';"(,"?"/,;J *+ X$?RQ"/, 0'/(" ,-" ?"('0'*/ '/ 02'? (20" -2? %"(*Q" +'/2&Y 2/? ,-"

0"(*/? !"0*&$,'*/ ?2,"? CN 9(,*%"; TUON ?"/'"? #",','*/";0V Q*,'*/ +*;

;"(*/0'?";2,'*/ +*; -2='/R %""/ +'&"? *$, *+ ,'Q">

G, ,-" *$,0",< ,-'0 F*$;, (*$&? -2=" ?"/'"? ,-" #",','*/ *$,;'R-, +*; /*, %"'/R

=";'+'"? 20 ;"Z$';"? %J !$&" P[ 0"(,'*/ T *+ ,-" !$&"0 *+ F*$;,> 4*A"=";< "="/

'+ ,-" '/0,2/, #",','*/ ?'? /*, 0$++"; +;*Q ,-'0 ?"+"(,< ,-'0 F*$;,< */ #;*("?$;2&

2/? 0$%0,2/,'=" R;*$/?0< A*$&? 0,'&& ;"0*&=" ,* ?"/J ',>

3-" +2(,0 *+ ,-" (20" 2;" $/?'0#$,"?> 3-" +';"A2&& *+ 2 %$;/"?K*$, %$'&?'/R

*A/"? %J #",','*/";0 (*&&2#0"? 2/? ?"0,;*J"? ,-" ,2'&*;'/R 0-*# *(($#'"? %J

,-" +2Q'&J *+ #;'=2," ;"0#*/?"/,0< ;"0$&,'/R '/ '/X$;'"0 ,* #;'=2," ;"0#*/?"/,0

2/? ,-" ?"2,- *+ 12;'002 I";/2&< 2 ?2$R-,";> .;'=2," ;"0#*/?"/,0 -2? %""/

A2;/"? %J #",','*/";0 ,* =2(2," ,-"'; 0-*# '/ ='"A *+ ',0 #;*W'Q',J ,* ,-"

A"2@"/"? A2&& %$, ,-" +*;Q"; +2'&"? ,* ?* 0*> 9/ ,-" %20'0 *+ ,-" +*;"R*'/R

+2(,0< ,-" !"R'*/2& 3;'2& F*$;,> E';0, \$?'('2& !"R'*/< I;2/(- ]]]7555< #;"0'?"?

%J ,-" 4*/> G/,*/'* 1> I"&"/< ;"/?";"? X$?RQ"/, +'/?'/R #",','*/";0 R$'&,J *+

R;*00 /"R&'R"/(" 2/? 2A2;?'/R ?2Q2R"0 ,* #;'=2," ;"0#*/?"/,0> 9/ 2##"2& .",','*/";0 +'&"?,-"'; Q*,'*/ +*; ;"(*/0'?";2,'*/ */ 8"#,"Q%"; C^< TUON %$, ,-'0 A20 ?"/'"?

'/ ,-" !"0*&$,'*/ *+ 9(,*%"; CN< TUON>

3-'0 F*$;, +'/?0 ,-2, ,-" F*$;, *+ G##"2&0 ?'? /*, (*QQ', 2 R;2=" 2%$0" *+

?'0(;",'*/ A-"/ ', ?"/'"? #",','*/";0V Q*,'*/ +*; "W,"/0'*/ *+ ,'Q" ,* +'&" 2

Q*,'*/ +*; ;"(*/0'?";2,'*/< ?';"(,"? "/,;J *+ X$?RQ"/, 2/? ?"/'"? ,-"';

Q*,'*/ +*; ;"(*/0'?";2,'*/> 5, (*;;"(,&J 2##&'"? ,-" ;$&" &2'? ?*A/

'/ !"#"$%&"' )*+,-.-/','0 1*23 43 5".67*< _L>!> :*> NMOU[< G$R$0, [< TUO[ B2, #> CTCD8"2'"9"*" 43 :,27*; :.,2/"$

A"2"&" 43 1*+,-9,;/"+, @..,$$"+, !> :*> N^OC^< 8"#,> T[< TUOP

8/13/2019 De roy v. CA-article 4

2/2

8'/(" #",','*/";0 -";"'/ +'&"? ,-"'; Q*,'*/ +*; "W,"/0'*/ */

E"%;$2;J CN< TUOP< ', '0 0,'&& A',-'/ ,-" R;2(" #";'*?< A-'(-

"W#';"? */ \$/" SM< TUOP< 2/? Q2J 0,'&& %" 2&&*A"?>

3-'0 R;2(" #";'*? A20 2&0* 2##&'"? '/ B/''/7* 43 1*+,-9,;/"+, @..,$$"+,

!> :*> NSPPU< 9(,*%"; CO< TUOP< T^[ 8F!G SMPa>a5/ ,-" '/0,2/, (20"< -*A"=";< #",','*/";0V Q*,'*/ +*; "W,"/0'*/ *+ ,'Q" A20

+'&"? */ 8"#,"Q%"; U< TUON< Q*;" ,-2/ 2 J"2; 2+,"; ,-" "W#';2,'*/ *+ ,-" R;2("

#";'*? */ \$/" SM< TUOP> 4"/("< ', '0 /* &*/R"; A',-'/ ,-" (*=";2R" *+ ,-"

R;2(" #";'*?> F*/0'?";'/R ,-" &"/R,- *+ ,'Q" +;*Q ,-" "W#';2,'*/ *+ ,-" R;2("

#";'*? ,* ,-" #;*Q$&R2,'*/ *+ ,-" ?"('0'*/ *+ ,-" F*$;, *+ G##"2&0 */ G$R$0,

C[< TUON< #",','*/";0 (2//*, 0""@ ;"+$R" '/ ,-" 'R/*;2/(" *+ ,-"'; (*$/0"&

;"R2;?'/R 02'? ;$&" +*; ,-"'; +2'&$;" ,* +'&" 2 Q*,'*/ +*; ;"(*/0'?";2,'*/ A',-'/

,-" ;"R&"Q"/,2;J #";'*?>

.",','*/";0 (*/,"/? ,-2, ,-" ;$&" "/$/('2,"? '/ ,-" !"#"$%&"'(20" 0-*$&? /*,

%" Q2?" ,* 2##&J ,* ,-" (20" 2, %2; *A'/R ,* ,-" /*/K#$%&'(2,'*/ *+

,-" !"#"$%&"'?"('0'*/ '/ ,-" 9++'('2& L2b",," 20 *+ ,-" ,'Q" ,-" 0$%X"(,

?"('0'*/ *+ ,-" F*$;, *+ G##"2&0 A20 #;*Q$&R2,"?> F*/,;2;J ,* #",','*/";0V

='"A< ,-";" '0 /* &2A ;"Z$';'/R ,-" #$%&'(2,'*/ *+ 8$#;"Q" F*$;, ?"('0'*/0 '/,-" 9++'('2& L2b",," %"+*;" ,-"J (2/ %" %'/?'/R 2/? 20 2 (*/?','*/ ,* ,-"';%"(*Q'/R "++"(,'="> 5, '0 ,-" %*$/?"/ ?$,J *+ (*$/0"& 20 &2AJ"; '/ 2(,'=" &2A

#;2(,'(" ,* @""# 2%;"20, *+ ?"('0'*/0 *+ ,-" 8$#;"Q" F*$;, #2;,'($&2;&J A-";"

'00$"0 -2=" %""/ (&2;'+'"?< (*/0'0,"/,&J ;"',";2,"?< 2/? #$%&'0-"? '/ ,-"

2?=2/(" ;"#*;,0 *+ 8$#;"Q" F*$;, ?"('0'*/0 BL> !> 0D 2/? '/ 0$(- #$%&'(2,'*/0

20 ,-" 8$#;"Q" F*$;, !"#*;,0 G//*,2,"? B8F!GD 2/? &2A X*$;/2&0>3-'0 F*$;, &'@"A'0" +'/?0 ,-2, ,-" F*$;, *+ G##"2&0 (*QQ',,"? /* R;2=" 2%$0"

*+ ?'0(;",'*/ '/ 2++';Q'/R ,-" ,;'2& (*$;,V0 ?"('0'*/ -*&?'/R #",','*/"; &'2%&"

$/?"; G;,'(&" CTUM *+ ,-" F'='& F*?"< A-'(- #;*='?"0 ,-2, c,-" #;*#;'",*; *+ 2

%$'&?'/R *; 0,;$(,$;" '0 ;"0#*/0'%&" +*; ,-" ?2Q2R" ;"0$&,'/R +;*Q ',0 ,*,2& *;

#2;,'2& (*&&2#0"< '+ ', 0-*$&? %" ?$" ,* ,-" &2(@ *+ /"("002;J ;"#2';0>

:*; A20 ,-";" ";;*; '/ ;"X"(,'/R #",','*/";0 2;R$Q"/, ,-2, #;'=2,"

;"0#*/?"/,0 -2? ,-" c&20, (&"2; (-2/("c ,* 2=*'? ,-" 2(('?"/, '+ */&J ,-"J

-""?"? ,-"> A2;/'/R ,* =2(2," ,-" ,2'&*;'/R 0-*# 2/? < ,-";"+*;"< #",','*/";0

#;'*; /"R&'R"/(" 0-*$&? %" ?'0;"R2;?"?< 0'/(" ,-" ?*(,;'/" *+ c&20, (&"2;

(-2/("