Data Activism: Leveraging Advocates to Improve Public Transit · 1967 2009 2016 2019 • Wide...

45
Data Activism: Leveraging Advocates to Improve Public Transit November 13, 2019

Transcript of Data Activism: Leveraging Advocates to Improve Public Transit · 1967 2009 2016 2019 • Wide...

Page 1: Data Activism: Leveraging Advocates to Improve Public Transit · 1967 2009 2016 2019 • Wide sidewalks • Separated bike lane • 40 buses/hr … in mixed traffic. ... Origin Destination

Data Activism: Leveraging Advocates to Improve Public

Transit

November 13, 2019

Page 2: Data Activism: Leveraging Advocates to Improve Public Transit · 1967 2009 2016 2019 • Wide sidewalks • Separated bike lane • 40 buses/hr … in mixed traffic. ... Origin Destination

Matthew DickensSenior Policy Analyst,

APTA

Moderator

Page 3: Data Activism: Leveraging Advocates to Improve Public Transit · 1967 2009 2016 2019 • Wide sidewalks • Separated bike lane • 40 buses/hr … in mixed traffic. ... Origin Destination

Leveraging Advocates to Improve Public Transit

• Transit Advocates Organizing in Cities Across the Country

• Publicly-Available Data Increasing Scope of Their Work

• They Want Transit to Succeed, Even If Sometimes Critical

• Agencies Have Opportunity to Activate These Groups

TITLE OF PRESENTATION I 3

Page 4: Data Activism: Leveraging Advocates to Improve Public Transit · 1967 2009 2016 2019 • Wide sidewalks • Separated bike lane • 40 buses/hr … in mixed traffic. ... Origin Destination

Matthew DickensSenior Policy Analyst,

APTA

Moderator

Page 5: Data Activism: Leveraging Advocates to Improve Public Transit · 1967 2009 2016 2019 • Wide sidewalks • Separated bike lane • 40 buses/hr … in mixed traffic. ... Origin Destination

Today’s Presenters

Ari OfsevitBoard

Member,TransitMatters

Jim AloisiBoard

Member,TransitMatters

Joe AielloChairman, MBTA

Fiscal and

Management

Control Board,

Boston, MA

Monica Tibbits-NuttVice Chair, MBTA

Fiscal and

Management

Control Board,

Boston, MA

Page 6: Data Activism: Leveraging Advocates to Improve Public Transit · 1967 2009 2016 2019 • Wide sidewalks • Separated bike lane • 40 buses/hr … in mixed traffic. ... Origin Destination

What to Expect

• Topic overview

• Industry Presentations

• Panel Member Dialogue

• Audience Q&A and discussions

• Wrap up

TITLE OF PRESENTATION I 6

Page 7: Data Activism: Leveraging Advocates to Improve Public Transit · 1967 2009 2016 2019 • Wide sidewalks • Separated bike lane • 40 buses/hr … in mixed traffic. ... Origin Destination

Asking Audience Questions

To submit a question or comment to the

moderator during the session or during the

Q&A, please type it into the Question box on

your screen and then click on the send arrow

located at the bottom of the box.

Page 8: Data Activism: Leveraging Advocates to Improve Public Transit · 1967 2009 2016 2019 • Wide sidewalks • Separated bike lane • 40 buses/hr … in mixed traffic. ... Origin Destination

Ari OfsevitBoard Member,

Transit Matters

Boston, MA

Session Presenter

Page 9: Data Activism: Leveraging Advocates to Improve Public Transit · 1967 2009 2016 2019 • Wide sidewalks • Separated bike lane • 40 buses/hr … in mixed traffic. ... Origin Destination

1967 2009 2016 2019

Page 10: Data Activism: Leveraging Advocates to Improve Public Transit · 1967 2009 2016 2019 • Wide sidewalks • Separated bike lane • 40 buses/hr … in mixed traffic. ... Origin Destination

• Wide sidewalks• Separated bike lane• 40 buses/hr … in mixed traffic

Page 11: Data Activism: Leveraging Advocates to Improve Public Transit · 1967 2009 2016 2019 • Wide sidewalks • Separated bike lane • 40 buses/hr … in mixed traffic. ... Origin Destination
Page 12: Data Activism: Leveraging Advocates to Improve Public Transit · 1967 2009 2016 2019 • Wide sidewalks • Separated bike lane • 40 buses/hr … in mixed traffic. ... Origin Destination
Page 13: Data Activism: Leveraging Advocates to Improve Public Transit · 1967 2009 2016 2019 • Wide sidewalks • Separated bike lane • 40 buses/hr … in mixed traffic. ... Origin Destination
Page 14: Data Activism: Leveraging Advocates to Improve Public Transit · 1967 2009 2016 2019 • Wide sidewalks • Separated bike lane • 40 buses/hr … in mixed traffic. ... Origin Destination

Matthew DickensSenior Policy Analyst,

APTA

Moderator-Presenter Conversations

Ari OfsevitBoard Member,

Transit Matters

Boston, MA

Page 15: Data Activism: Leveraging Advocates to Improve Public Transit · 1967 2009 2016 2019 • Wide sidewalks • Separated bike lane • 40 buses/hr … in mixed traffic. ... Origin Destination

Jim AloisiBoard Member,

Transit Matters

Boston, MA

Session Presenter

Page 16: Data Activism: Leveraging Advocates to Improve Public Transit · 1967 2009 2016 2019 • Wide sidewalks • Separated bike lane • 40 buses/hr … in mixed traffic. ... Origin Destination
Page 17: Data Activism: Leveraging Advocates to Improve Public Transit · 1967 2009 2016 2019 • Wide sidewalks • Separated bike lane • 40 buses/hr … in mixed traffic. ... Origin Destination

17

Overview of ProposalEarly Morning and NightBus

Original Transit Matters Proposal

Page 18: Data Activism: Leveraging Advocates to Improve Public Transit · 1967 2009 2016 2019 • Wide sidewalks • Separated bike lane • 40 buses/hr … in mixed traffic. ... Origin Destination

Early Morning

18

Origin Destination Patterns

2k -3k trips

3k - 4k trips

3k - 4k trips

5k - 6k trips

6k - 7k trips

7k - 8k trips

> 8k trips

Source: MBTA O-D Transfer Model, October 3-October 30, 2015

Late Night

Page 19: Data Activism: Leveraging Advocates to Improve Public Transit · 1967 2009 2016 2019 • Wide sidewalks • Separated bike lane • 40 buses/hr … in mixed traffic. ... Origin Destination

• The MBTA has early morning bus service between 4-5 am1

• The existing service is not planned or marketed as a network

• There is crowding on first trips of the day in the 4-5 am hour and in the 5-6 am hour.

• This proposal is to create a Early Morning network that would serve existing demand and serve additional riders

• The Early Morning service would be marketed as its own network

19

1 Most routes go only outbound for their first trip before 5. A few “collector” routes start between 3- 4 am.

Existing MBTA Early Morning Service

Page 20: Data Activism: Leveraging Advocates to Improve Public Transit · 1967 2009 2016 2019 • Wide sidewalks • Separated bike lane • 40 buses/hr … in mixed traffic. ... Origin Destination

NightBusDemand for Overnight service

An intercept survey conducted by the MBTA, provide evidence of some demand for overnight service.The map indicates demand by home zip code of respondents who:

-already ride the MBTA,

-already travel overnight,-indicate they are likely to use

an overnight T service

In the highest zip code 16% of respondents fit this criteria; however, we don’t know if they all want to travel to similar locations.

Draft for Discussion & Policy Purposes Only 20

Page 21: Data Activism: Leveraging Advocates to Improve Public Transit · 1967 2009 2016 2019 • Wide sidewalks • Separated bike lane • 40 buses/hr … in mixed traffic. ... Origin Destination

REGIONAL RAILA 21st CENTURY BUSINESS MODEL FOR INTERCITY RAIL SERVICE

Page 22: Data Activism: Leveraging Advocates to Improve Public Transit · 1967 2009 2016 2019 • Wide sidewalks • Separated bike lane • 40 buses/hr … in mixed traffic. ... Origin Destination
Page 23: Data Activism: Leveraging Advocates to Improve Public Transit · 1967 2009 2016 2019 • Wide sidewalks • Separated bike lane • 40 buses/hr … in mixed traffic. ... Origin Destination

Commuter Rail costs “way too much money for way

too little ridership.”We agree. There is a practical, cost-effective & proven solution to this.

Page 24: Data Activism: Leveraging Advocates to Improve Public Transit · 1967 2009 2016 2019 • Wide sidewalks • Separated bike lane • 40 buses/hr … in mixed traffic. ... Origin Destination
Page 25: Data Activism: Leveraging Advocates to Improve Public Transit · 1967 2009 2016 2019 • Wide sidewalks • Separated bike lane • 40 buses/hr … in mixed traffic. ... Origin Destination

Transition to Regional Rail An Incremental Approach

Begin with rationalizing fates

Move on to completing electrification and High-Level Platforms

Page 26: Data Activism: Leveraging Advocates to Improve Public Transit · 1967 2009 2016 2019 • Wide sidewalks • Separated bike lane • 40 buses/hr … in mixed traffic. ... Origin Destination
Page 27: Data Activism: Leveraging Advocates to Improve Public Transit · 1967 2009 2016 2019 • Wide sidewalks • Separated bike lane • 40 buses/hr … in mixed traffic. ... Origin Destination

Matthew DickensSenior Policy Analyst,

APTA

Moderator-Presenter Conversations

Jim AloisiBoard Member,

Transit Matters

Boston, MA

Page 28: Data Activism: Leveraging Advocates to Improve Public Transit · 1967 2009 2016 2019 • Wide sidewalks • Separated bike lane • 40 buses/hr … in mixed traffic. ... Origin Destination

Joe Aiello

Chairman, MBTA Fiscal and

Management Control Board,

Boston, MA

Session Presenter

Page 29: Data Activism: Leveraging Advocates to Improve Public Transit · 1967 2009 2016 2019 • Wide sidewalks • Separated bike lane • 40 buses/hr … in mixed traffic. ... Origin Destination

The Creation of the FMCB

• Winter 2015

• Special Panel Report

• The Board

TITLE OF PRESENTATION I 29

Page 30: Data Activism: Leveraging Advocates to Improve Public Transit · 1967 2009 2016 2019 • Wide sidewalks • Separated bike lane • 40 buses/hr … in mixed traffic. ... Origin Destination

What We Found

• SGR Backlog

• Customers?

• Human Capital Crisis

TITLE OF PRESENTATION I 30

Page 31: Data Activism: Leveraging Advocates to Improve Public Transit · 1967 2009 2016 2019 • Wide sidewalks • Separated bike lane • 40 buses/hr … in mixed traffic. ... Origin Destination

What the FMCB Set Out to Do

• Customer Centricity

• Financial Discipline

• Accelerated Capital Investment

• Strategic Plan

TITLE OF PRESENTATION I 31

Page 32: Data Activism: Leveraging Advocates to Improve Public Transit · 1967 2009 2016 2019 • Wide sidewalks • Separated bike lane • 40 buses/hr … in mixed traffic. ... Origin Destination

The Value of the Outsider

• Expertise in All the Wrong Places

• Breaking Eggs

• Failure is An Option (Within Limitations)

TITLE OF PRESENTATION I 32

Page 33: Data Activism: Leveraging Advocates to Improve Public Transit · 1967 2009 2016 2019 • Wide sidewalks • Separated bike lane • 40 buses/hr … in mixed traffic. ... Origin Destination

Matthew DickensSenior Policy Analyst,

APTA

Moderator-Presenter Conversations

Joe AielloChairman, MBTA Fiscal and

Management Control Board,

Boston, MA

Page 34: Data Activism: Leveraging Advocates to Improve Public Transit · 1967 2009 2016 2019 • Wide sidewalks • Separated bike lane • 40 buses/hr … in mixed traffic. ... Origin Destination

Monica Tibbits-Nutt

Vice Chair, MBTA Fiscal and

Management Control Board,

Boston, MA

Session Presenter

Page 35: Data Activism: Leveraging Advocates to Improve Public Transit · 1967 2009 2016 2019 • Wide sidewalks • Separated bike lane • 40 buses/hr … in mixed traffic. ... Origin Destination
Page 36: Data Activism: Leveraging Advocates to Improve Public Transit · 1967 2009 2016 2019 • Wide sidewalks • Separated bike lane • 40 buses/hr … in mixed traffic. ... Origin Destination
Page 37: Data Activism: Leveraging Advocates to Improve Public Transit · 1967 2009 2016 2019 • Wide sidewalks • Separated bike lane • 40 buses/hr … in mixed traffic. ... Origin Destination
Page 38: Data Activism: Leveraging Advocates to Improve Public Transit · 1967 2009 2016 2019 • Wide sidewalks • Separated bike lane • 40 buses/hr … in mixed traffic. ... Origin Destination
Page 39: Data Activism: Leveraging Advocates to Improve Public Transit · 1967 2009 2016 2019 • Wide sidewalks • Separated bike lane • 40 buses/hr … in mixed traffic. ... Origin Destination
Page 40: Data Activism: Leveraging Advocates to Improve Public Transit · 1967 2009 2016 2019 • Wide sidewalks • Separated bike lane • 40 buses/hr … in mixed traffic. ... Origin Destination
Page 41: Data Activism: Leveraging Advocates to Improve Public Transit · 1967 2009 2016 2019 • Wide sidewalks • Separated bike lane • 40 buses/hr … in mixed traffic. ... Origin Destination

Matthew DickensSenior Policy Analyst,

APTA

Moderator-Presenter Conversations

Monica Tibbits-NuttVice Chair, MBTA Fiscal and

Management Control Board,

Boston, MA

Page 42: Data Activism: Leveraging Advocates to Improve Public Transit · 1967 2009 2016 2019 • Wide sidewalks • Separated bike lane • 40 buses/hr … in mixed traffic. ... Origin Destination

Q&A With Today’s Moderator and Speakers

Ari OfsevitBoard

Member,Transit

Matters

Jim AloisiBoard

Member,Transit

Matters

Joe AielloChairman, MBTA

Fiscal and

Management

Control Board,

Boston, MA

Monica Tibbits-NuttVice Chair, MBTA

Fiscal and

Management

Control Board,

Boston, MA

Page 43: Data Activism: Leveraging Advocates to Improve Public Transit · 1967 2009 2016 2019 • Wide sidewalks • Separated bike lane • 40 buses/hr … in mixed traffic. ... Origin Destination

Asking Audience Questions

To submit a question or comment to the

moderator during the session or during the

Q&A, please type it into the Question box on

your screen and then click on the send arrow

located at the bottom of the box.

Page 44: Data Activism: Leveraging Advocates to Improve Public Transit · 1967 2009 2016 2019 • Wide sidewalks • Separated bike lane • 40 buses/hr … in mixed traffic. ... Origin Destination

Q&A With Today’s Moderator and Speakers

Ari OfsevitBoard

Member,Transit

Matters

Jim AloisiBoard

Member,Transit

Matters

Joe AielloChairman, MBTA

Fiscal and

Management

Control Board,

Boston, MA

Monica Tibbits-NuttVice Chair, MBTA

Fiscal and

Management

Control Board,

Boston, MA

Page 45: Data Activism: Leveraging Advocates to Improve Public Transit · 1967 2009 2016 2019 • Wide sidewalks • Separated bike lane • 40 buses/hr … in mixed traffic. ... Origin Destination

Data Activism: Leveraging Advocates to Improve Public

Transit

November 13, 2019