Dark Matter Complementarity in the …...Dark Matter Complementarity in the phenomenological MSSM...
Transcript of Dark Matter Complementarity in the …...Dark Matter Complementarity in the phenomenological MSSM...
![Page 1: Dark Matter Complementarity in the …...Dark Matter Complementarity in the phenomenological MSSM Ahmed Ismail ANL/UIC Dark Matter at the LHC September 21, 2013 1305.6921, 1307.8444](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060509/5f247d4ce36503219361809a/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Dark Matter Complementarity in the phenomenological MSSM
Ahmed IsmailANL/UIC
Dark Matter at the LHCSeptember 21, 2013
1305.6921, 1307.8444with Matthew Cahill-Rowley, Randy Cotta, Alex Drlica-Wagner, Stefan Funk, JoAnne Hewett, Tom Rizzo, and Matthew Wood
![Page 2: Dark Matter Complementarity in the …...Dark Matter Complementarity in the phenomenological MSSM Ahmed Ismail ANL/UIC Dark Matter at the LHC September 21, 2013 1305.6921, 1307.8444](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060509/5f247d4ce36503219361809a/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
2
Complementarity in SUSY
Standard neutralino dark matter in the MSSM with R-parity is a flexible tool, despite not encompassing other interesting scenarios
Motivates study of how well different approaches at DM experiments and colliders work together to see SUSY
Simplified frameworks often used to estimate sensitivity, but useful to consider more complete models too, especially to solve other problems at the same time
![Page 3: Dark Matter Complementarity in the …...Dark Matter Complementarity in the phenomenological MSSM Ahmed Ismail ANL/UIC Dark Matter at the LHC September 21, 2013 1305.6921, 1307.8444](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060509/5f247d4ce36503219361809a/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
3
Complementarity in SUSY
Goal: study a set of full, realistic MSSM spectra with neutralino LSPs, remaining agnostic about SUSY breaking
Do not require LSP to saturate relic density Sparticle masses are scanned up to 4 TeV,
giving LSPs from 40 GeV to ~2 TeV Study models at the LHC as well as current
and future experiments searching for dark matter – direct detection, neutrino telescopes, indirect detection
![Page 4: Dark Matter Complementarity in the …...Dark Matter Complementarity in the phenomenological MSSM Ahmed Ismail ANL/UIC Dark Matter at the LHC September 21, 2013 1305.6921, 1307.8444](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060509/5f247d4ce36503219361809a/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
4
The phenomenological MSSM
The full MSSM has 105 new free parameters, many of which are strongly constrained
Impose minimal flavor violation, diagonal sparticle mass matrices with degenerate first two generations, CP conservation
Generated random points in resulting 19-dim. space passing precision EW, flavor, DM constraints
Produced set of ~2.2 x 105 consistent models in late 2011
![Page 5: Dark Matter Complementarity in the …...Dark Matter Complementarity in the phenomenological MSSM Ahmed Ismail ANL/UIC Dark Matter at the LHC September 21, 2013 1305.6921, 1307.8444](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060509/5f247d4ce36503219361809a/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
5
Neutralino LSP relic density
log10
Ωh2
Num
ber
of m
odel
s
Impose WMAP as upper bound only
![Page 6: Dark Matter Complementarity in the …...Dark Matter Complementarity in the phenomenological MSSM Ahmed Ismail ANL/UIC Dark Matter at the LHC September 21, 2013 1305.6921, 1307.8444](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060509/5f247d4ce36503219361809a/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
6
Neutralino LSP relic density
Bino annihilation through Z/h funnel
Bino coannihilationWell-tempered neutralino
Other annihilations
1.7 TeV wino
1 TeV Higgsino
![Page 7: Dark Matter Complementarity in the …...Dark Matter Complementarity in the phenomenological MSSM Ahmed Ismail ANL/UIC Dark Matter at the LHC September 21, 2013 1305.6921, 1307.8444](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060509/5f247d4ce36503219361809a/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
7
Direct detection
XENON1T (LUX + ZEPLIN) can exclude 23% (38%) of modelsCOUPP500 can exclude 2% through SD detection
XENON1T (2017)
LZ (6M kg-days)
XENON100 (2011)XENON100 (2012)
R = Ω/ΩWMAP
![Page 8: Dark Matter Complementarity in the …...Dark Matter Complementarity in the phenomenological MSSM Ahmed Ismail ANL/UIC Dark Matter at the LHC September 21, 2013 1305.6921, 1307.8444](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060509/5f247d4ce36503219361809a/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
8
IceCube
LSP capture in the sun and subsequent annihilation produces high energy neutrinos
Calculate ν flux for each model, because annihilations go to different final states
Also need to check capture-annihilation equilibrium; 48% of our models do not have these processes balanced in the sun, typically giving a low ν flux!
See 1105.1199 for more details
![Page 9: Dark Matter Complementarity in the …...Dark Matter Complementarity in the phenomenological MSSM Ahmed Ismail ANL/UIC Dark Matter at the LHC September 21, 2013 1305.6921, 1307.8444](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060509/5f247d4ce36503219361809a/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
9
IceCube
Fraction excluded by IceCube
R ×
σS
D,p (
pb)
LSP mass (GeV)
COUPP500
1.2% of models will be excluded by 5 years of IceCube dataOnly sensitive to bino-Higgsino mixtures!
Pure eigenstate LSPs survive due to poor capture or annihilation
R = Ω/ΩWMAP
![Page 10: Dark Matter Complementarity in the …...Dark Matter Complementarity in the phenomenological MSSM Ahmed Ismail ANL/UIC Dark Matter at the LHC September 21, 2013 1305.6921, 1307.8444](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060509/5f247d4ce36503219361809a/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
Indirect detection
The LSP annihilates to some mixture of the standard decay modes bb, WW, ττ, as well as others
Calculate γ ray spectrum from annihilations for each model separately
Fermi LAT two year dwarf analysis (1111.2604) + 10x improvement (0.1%)
CTA with US contribution with 500 hours of exposure to galactic center SR (19%)
![Page 11: Dark Matter Complementarity in the …...Dark Matter Complementarity in the phenomenological MSSM Ahmed Ismail ANL/UIC Dark Matter at the LHC September 21, 2013 1305.6921, 1307.8444](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060509/5f247d4ce36503219361809a/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
11
Indirect detection
Fraction excluded by CTA
Ann
ihila
tion
cros
s se
ctio
n (c
m3 /s
)
LSP mass (GeV)
Fermi limits
Fermi better at lower masses, CTA dominates for heavy LSPHeavy coannihilating binos have very low annihilation cross
sections, and won't be excluded by CTA (or LHC!)
![Page 12: Dark Matter Complementarity in the …...Dark Matter Complementarity in the phenomenological MSSM Ahmed Ismail ANL/UIC Dark Matter at the LHC September 21, 2013 1305.6921, 1307.8444](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060509/5f247d4ce36503219361809a/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
12
LHC searches
Generate SUSY events for each model with PYTHIA/Prospino/PGS; codes modified!
Input relevant MET-based SUSY searches up to March 2013, generally following ATLAS
Non-MET searches also included Mono-X not implemented, but much less
important than jets+MET for complete spectra LHC is more powerful than in minimal DM
frameworks due to plethora of new colored particles
![Page 13: Dark Matter Complementarity in the …...Dark Matter Complementarity in the phenomenological MSSM Ahmed Ismail ANL/UIC Dark Matter at the LHC September 21, 2013 1305.6921, 1307.8444](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060509/5f247d4ce36503219361809a/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
LHC
Strong production and phase space between LCP and LSP mattersLSP mass (GeV)
Ligh
test
col
ored
spa
rtic
le m
ass
(GeV
)
Simplified model limitsATLAS-CONF-2012-109
![Page 14: Dark Matter Complementarity in the …...Dark Matter Complementarity in the phenomenological MSSM Ahmed Ismail ANL/UIC Dark Matter at the LHC September 21, 2013 1305.6921, 1307.8444](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060509/5f247d4ce36503219361809a/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
14
Search complementarity
Direct and indirect detection probe distinct regions!
DD = XENON1T + COUPP500ID = Fermi + CTA
39%27%8%
11%15%R = Ω/Ω
WMAP
![Page 15: Dark Matter Complementarity in the …...Dark Matter Complementarity in the phenomenological MSSM Ahmed Ismail ANL/UIC Dark Matter at the LHC September 21, 2013 1305.6921, 1307.8444](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060509/5f247d4ce36503219361809a/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
15
14 TeV LHC projection
ATLAS (and CMS) can probe unseen models at 14 TeV
DD = XENON1T + COUPP500ID = Fermi + CTA
+ 14 TeV jets + MET
R = Ω/ΩWMAP
PRELIMINARY
![Page 16: Dark Matter Complementarity in the …...Dark Matter Complementarity in the phenomenological MSSM Ahmed Ismail ANL/UIC Dark Matter at the LHC September 21, 2013 1305.6921, 1307.8444](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060509/5f247d4ce36503219361809a/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
16
Search complementarity
LHC, CTA, and XENON1T act orthogonally and exclude many models
XENON1T
R = Ω/ΩWMAP
![Page 17: Dark Matter Complementarity in the …...Dark Matter Complementarity in the phenomenological MSSM Ahmed Ismail ANL/UIC Dark Matter at the LHC September 21, 2013 1305.6921, 1307.8444](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060509/5f247d4ce36503219361809a/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
17
14 TeV LHC projection
Again, 14 TeV jets + MET can significantly increase coverage
XENON1T
R = Ω/ΩWMAP
PRELIMINARY
![Page 18: Dark Matter Complementarity in the …...Dark Matter Complementarity in the phenomenological MSSM Ahmed Ismail ANL/UIC Dark Matter at the LHC September 21, 2013 1305.6921, 1307.8444](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060509/5f247d4ce36503219361809a/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
18
So what's left of this?
Bino annihilation through Z/h funnel
Bino coannihilationWell-tempered neutralino
Other annihilations
1.7 TeV wino
1 TeV Higgsino
![Page 19: Dark Matter Complementarity in the …...Dark Matter Complementarity in the phenomenological MSSM Ahmed Ismail ANL/UIC Dark Matter at the LHC September 21, 2013 1305.6921, 1307.8444](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060509/5f247d4ce36503219361809a/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
19
After LHC Run I + current/future DM
Bino annihilation through Z/h funnel
Bino coannihilationWell-tempered neutralino
Other annihilations
1.7 TeV wino
1 TeV Higgsino
![Page 20: Dark Matter Complementarity in the …...Dark Matter Complementarity in the phenomenological MSSM Ahmed Ismail ANL/UIC Dark Matter at the LHC September 21, 2013 1305.6921, 1307.8444](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060509/5f247d4ce36503219361809a/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
20
Lessons learned
The LHC can fill in many of the holes in coverage left by dark matter experiments, especially in complete theories with numerous new colored states
If DM searches are fruitless, remaining pMSSM points that do have right relic density have (co)annihilating bino LSPs, to be probed by 14 TeV LHC
Spin-independent direct detection, CTA, and the LHC are expected to be the most powerful searches for the pMSSM in the near future
![Page 21: Dark Matter Complementarity in the …...Dark Matter Complementarity in the phenomenological MSSM Ahmed Ismail ANL/UIC Dark Matter at the LHC September 21, 2013 1305.6921, 1307.8444](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060509/5f247d4ce36503219361809a/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
21
Backup
![Page 22: Dark Matter Complementarity in the …...Dark Matter Complementarity in the phenomenological MSSM Ahmed Ismail ANL/UIC Dark Matter at the LHC September 21, 2013 1305.6921, 1307.8444](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060509/5f247d4ce36503219361809a/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
22
The phenomenological MSSM 19 free parameters of the phenomenological
MSSM
M1, M
2, M
3, , tan , M
A, q
1,3, u
1,3, d
1,3, l
1,3, e
1,3,
At,b,τ
Generate random points in this parameter space, and test vs. experimental constraints
Surviving points go into model set, which is then tested against incoming and future dataMatthew Cahill-Rowley, JoAnne Hewett, Stefan Höche, AI, Tom Rizzo, 1206.4321
![Page 23: Dark Matter Complementarity in the …...Dark Matter Complementarity in the phenomenological MSSM Ahmed Ismail ANL/UIC Dark Matter at the LHC September 21, 2013 1305.6921, 1307.8444](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060509/5f247d4ce36503219361809a/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
23
Model set generation 50 GeV ≤ |M
1| ≤ 4 TeV
100 GeV ≤ |M2, μ| ≤ 4 TeV
400 GeV ≤ M3 ≤ 4 TeV
1 ≤ tan β ≤ 60
100 GeV ≤ MA, l, e ≤ 4 TeV
400 GeV ≤ q1, u
1, d
1 ≤ 4 TeV
200 GeV ≤ q3, u
3, d
3 ≤ 4 TeV
|At,b,τ
| ≤ 4 TeV
Generate spectra for 3 × 106 points in 19 dimensional parameter space, requiring lightest neutralino to be LSP
Spectra are generated with SOFTSUSY and SuSpect, and tossed if there are problems (tachyons, color/charge breaking minima, unbounded scalar potentials) or the generators disagree significantly
Decay tables are calculated with modified versions of SDECAY, HDECAY, MadGraph, and CalcHEP
![Page 24: Dark Matter Complementarity in the …...Dark Matter Complementarity in the phenomenological MSSM Ahmed Ismail ANL/UIC Dark Matter at the LHC September 21, 2013 1305.6921, 1307.8444](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060509/5f247d4ce36503219361809a/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
24
Model set generation
Impose WMAP7 as upper bound on thermal relic density of lightest neutralino, and check against DM direct detection constraints
Precision EW constraints: g – 2, invisible width of Z, ∆ρ
Flavor constraints: b → sγ, Bs → µµ, B → τν
Require all charged sparticles > 100 GeV
Apply LHC stable particle, Φ → ττ constraints as of 12/2011
2 × 105 models left; computationally demanding!
![Page 25: Dark Matter Complementarity in the …...Dark Matter Complementarity in the phenomenological MSSM Ahmed Ismail ANL/UIC Dark Matter at the LHC September 21, 2013 1305.6921, 1307.8444](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060509/5f247d4ce36503219361809a/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
25
Indirect detection
Two year LAT analysis doesn't exclude any models
Fermi LAT
Our extrapolation(0.1%)
log(
σv)
(cm
3 /s)
Boost = <σv>UL
/ <σv>total
![Page 26: Dark Matter Complementarity in the …...Dark Matter Complementarity in the phenomenological MSSM Ahmed Ismail ANL/UIC Dark Matter at the LHC September 21, 2013 1305.6921, 1307.8444](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060509/5f247d4ce36503219361809a/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
26
Indirect detection
CTA is sensitive to 19% of models!
CTA
Boost = <σv>UL
/ <σv>total
![Page 27: Dark Matter Complementarity in the …...Dark Matter Complementarity in the phenomenological MSSM Ahmed Ismail ANL/UIC Dark Matter at the LHC September 21, 2013 1305.6921, 1307.8444](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060509/5f247d4ce36503219361809a/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
An aside: the Higgs mass
This model set was generated before the Higgs discovery
20% of our models have the lighter CP-even Higgs weighing 126 ± 3 GeV (1206.5800)
Generally, an MSSM Higgs this heavy requires either heavy stops or large stop mixing
The LHC results for the subset of our models with a Higgs near 126 GeV are very similar to those for the full model set (1211.1981)
All other results are completely unaffected
![Page 28: Dark Matter Complementarity in the …...Dark Matter Complementarity in the phenomenological MSSM Ahmed Ismail ANL/UIC Dark Matter at the LHC September 21, 2013 1305.6921, 1307.8444](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060509/5f247d4ce36503219361809a/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
28
LHC searches
Higgs (GeV)
Num
ber
of m
odel
s
Neutralino LSP
Overall LHC search efficiency nearly completely independent of Higgs mass!
![Page 29: Dark Matter Complementarity in the …...Dark Matter Complementarity in the phenomenological MSSM Ahmed Ismail ANL/UIC Dark Matter at the LHC September 21, 2013 1305.6921, 1307.8444](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060509/5f247d4ce36503219361809a/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
29
Search complementarity
IceCube won't see any new models beyond 1T direct detection....
DD = XENON1T + COUPP500
77%0%
22%1%
R = Ω/ΩWMAP