Dark Matter and Dark Energy -...

36
Dark Matter and Dark Energy L. Van Waerbeke Triumf Saturday lectures Nov 2009

Transcript of Dark Matter and Dark Energy -...

Page 1: Dark Matter and Dark Energy - admin.triumf.caadmin.triumf.ca/docs/seminars/Sem3102343965-79538-1.Sem20091… · of dark matter and dark energy This is an embarrassing result that

Dark Matter and Dark Energy

L. Van Waerbeke

Triumf Saturday lectures Nov 2009

Page 2: Dark Matter and Dark Energy - admin.triumf.caadmin.triumf.ca/docs/seminars/Sem3102343965-79538-1.Sem20091… · of dark matter and dark energy This is an embarrassing result that

What is cosmology? Literally “the study of the Universe”Or an attempt to understand the world we live in, in itsglobality

-understand the nature of the Universe-its past-its future

-its meaning (ancient civilizations, philosophy, religion,…)

Page 3: Dark Matter and Dark Energy - admin.triumf.caadmin.triumf.ca/docs/seminars/Sem3102343965-79538-1.Sem20091… · of dark matter and dark energy This is an embarrassing result that

Azteccosmology

Page 4: Dark Matter and Dark Energy - admin.triumf.caadmin.triumf.ca/docs/seminars/Sem3102343965-79538-1.Sem20091… · of dark matter and dark energy This is an embarrassing result that

What is modern cosmology?

-it is a –very young- science, based on observations

-it makes a deep connection between the large and the small,That is a real revolution

-we have definitely lost our central position!

Page 5: Dark Matter and Dark Energy - admin.triumf.caadmin.triumf.ca/docs/seminars/Sem3102343965-79538-1.Sem20091… · of dark matter and dark energy This is an embarrassing result that

1927: Edwin Hubble discovered the expansion of the Universe!1927: Edwin Hubble discovered the expansion of the Universe! founded the idea of a founded the idea of a Big BangBig Bang

Page 6: Dark Matter and Dark Energy - admin.triumf.caadmin.triumf.ca/docs/seminars/Sem3102343965-79538-1.Sem20091… · of dark matter and dark energy This is an embarrassing result that

The Universe is expanding

Page 7: Dark Matter and Dark Energy - admin.triumf.caadmin.triumf.ca/docs/seminars/Sem3102343965-79538-1.Sem20091… · of dark matter and dark energy This is an embarrassing result that

Different possible fates for the Universe

Matter dominated

“Anti” gravity? Or cosmological constant

Ω Λ

Page 8: Dark Matter and Dark Energy - admin.triumf.caadmin.triumf.ca/docs/seminars/Sem3102343965-79538-1.Sem20091… · of dark matter and dark energy This is an embarrassing result that

Ω

Λ ?

Page 9: Dark Matter and Dark Energy - admin.triumf.caadmin.triumf.ca/docs/seminars/Sem3102343965-79538-1.Sem20091… · of dark matter and dark energy This is an embarrassing result that

Ω

Λ ACCELERATINGEXPANSION

DECCELERATINGEXPANSION

Page 10: Dark Matter and Dark Energy - admin.triumf.caadmin.triumf.ca/docs/seminars/Sem3102343965-79538-1.Sem20091… · of dark matter and dark energy This is an embarrassing result that

Early Universe was

SmallDenseHotOpaque

Universe today is

BigLow densityColdTransparent

Page 11: Dark Matter and Dark Energy - admin.triumf.caadmin.triumf.ca/docs/seminars/Sem3102343965-79538-1.Sem20091… · of dark matter and dark energy This is an embarrassing result that

Cosmic Microwave Background:

A picture of the early Universetells us how “big” things were at thattime.

Page 12: Dark Matter and Dark Energy - admin.triumf.caadmin.triumf.ca/docs/seminars/Sem3102343965-79538-1.Sem20091… · of dark matter and dark energy This is an embarrassing result that
Page 13: Dark Matter and Dark Energy - admin.triumf.caadmin.triumf.ca/docs/seminars/Sem3102343965-79538-1.Sem20091… · of dark matter and dark energy This is an embarrassing result that

Ω

Λ

Page 14: Dark Matter and Dark Energy - admin.triumf.caadmin.triumf.ca/docs/seminars/Sem3102343965-79538-1.Sem20091… · of dark matter and dark energy This is an embarrassing result that
Page 15: Dark Matter and Dark Energy - admin.triumf.caadmin.triumf.ca/docs/seminars/Sem3102343965-79538-1.Sem20091… · of dark matter and dark energy This is an embarrassing result that

SDSS

Galaxy distribution

Large Scale Structures

Page 16: Dark Matter and Dark Energy - admin.triumf.caadmin.triumf.ca/docs/seminars/Sem3102343965-79538-1.Sem20091… · of dark matter and dark energy This is an embarrassing result that
Page 17: Dark Matter and Dark Energy - admin.triumf.caadmin.triumf.ca/docs/seminars/Sem3102343965-79538-1.Sem20091… · of dark matter and dark energy This is an embarrassing result that

Ω

Λ

Page 18: Dark Matter and Dark Energy - admin.triumf.caadmin.triumf.ca/docs/seminars/Sem3102343965-79538-1.Sem20091… · of dark matter and dark energy This is an embarrassing result that

Cosmological candles…

DistanceA

ppar

ent l

umin

osity

Standard candle

Page 19: Dark Matter and Dark Energy - admin.triumf.caadmin.triumf.ca/docs/seminars/Sem3102343965-79538-1.Sem20091… · of dark matter and dark energy This is an embarrassing result that
Page 20: Dark Matter and Dark Energy - admin.triumf.caadmin.triumf.ca/docs/seminars/Sem3102343965-79538-1.Sem20091… · of dark matter and dark energy This is an embarrassing result that

Supernovae of type Ia are “standard candles”

Page 21: Dark Matter and Dark Energy - admin.triumf.caadmin.triumf.ca/docs/seminars/Sem3102343965-79538-1.Sem20091… · of dark matter and dark energy This is an embarrassing result that

Ω

Λ

Page 22: Dark Matter and Dark Energy - admin.triumf.caadmin.triumf.ca/docs/seminars/Sem3102343965-79538-1.Sem20091… · of dark matter and dark energy This is an embarrassing result that

The expansion of the Universeis accelerating

So…what?

We don’t understandWe don’t understandthe physics behind it!the physics behind it!

Page 23: Dark Matter and Dark Energy - admin.triumf.caadmin.triumf.ca/docs/seminars/Sem3102343965-79538-1.Sem20091… · of dark matter and dark energy This is an embarrassing result that

Ω

Λ

This is where we “should” be!

Page 24: Dark Matter and Dark Energy - admin.triumf.caadmin.triumf.ca/docs/seminars/Sem3102343965-79538-1.Sem20091… · of dark matter and dark energy This is an embarrassing result that

Do we have a problem?

> 95% of the Universe content is of unknown nature!> 95% of the Universe content is of unknown nature!

Page 25: Dark Matter and Dark Energy - admin.triumf.caadmin.triumf.ca/docs/seminars/Sem3102343965-79538-1.Sem20091… · of dark matter and dark energy This is an embarrassing result that

What is DARK MATTER?

Cornelia ParkerCold Dark Matter: An Exploded View, 1991

Page 26: Dark Matter and Dark Energy - admin.triumf.caadmin.triumf.ca/docs/seminars/Sem3102343965-79538-1.Sem20091… · of dark matter and dark energy This is an embarrassing result that

What it is not:

-normal matter e.g. planets, gas, dust, proto-stars

What it could be

-new type massive particle yet to beDiscovered

-modified gravity

Page 27: Dark Matter and Dark Energy - admin.triumf.caadmin.triumf.ca/docs/seminars/Sem3102343965-79538-1.Sem20091… · of dark matter and dark energy This is an embarrassing result that

What it is not:

-normal matter e.g. planets, gas, dust, proto-stars

What it could be

-new type massive particle yet to beDiscovered

-modified gravity

Page 28: Dark Matter and Dark Energy - admin.triumf.caadmin.triumf.ca/docs/seminars/Sem3102343965-79538-1.Sem20091… · of dark matter and dark energy This is an embarrassing result that
Page 29: Dark Matter and Dark Energy - admin.triumf.caadmin.triumf.ca/docs/seminars/Sem3102343965-79538-1.Sem20091… · of dark matter and dark energy This is an embarrassing result that

What it is not:

-normal matter e.g. planets, gas, dust, proto-stars

What it could be

-new type massive particle yet to beDiscovered

-modified gravity

Page 30: Dark Matter and Dark Energy - admin.triumf.caadmin.triumf.ca/docs/seminars/Sem3102343965-79538-1.Sem20091… · of dark matter and dark energy This is an embarrassing result that
Page 31: Dark Matter and Dark Energy - admin.triumf.caadmin.triumf.ca/docs/seminars/Sem3102343965-79538-1.Sem20091… · of dark matter and dark energy This is an embarrassing result that

Launched in June 2008

Page 32: Dark Matter and Dark Energy - admin.triumf.caadmin.triumf.ca/docs/seminars/Sem3102343965-79538-1.Sem20091… · of dark matter and dark energy This is an embarrassing result that

What it is not:

-normal matter e.g. planets, gas, dust, proto-stars

What it could be

-new type massive particle yet to beDiscovered

-modified gravity

Page 33: Dark Matter and Dark Energy - admin.triumf.caadmin.triumf.ca/docs/seminars/Sem3102343965-79538-1.Sem20091… · of dark matter and dark energy This is an embarrassing result that

Space-time could be wrapped at small scale with many more dimensions than 4!

Page 34: Dark Matter and Dark Energy - admin.triumf.caadmin.triumf.ca/docs/seminars/Sem3102343965-79538-1.Sem20091… · of dark matter and dark energy This is an embarrassing result that

What is DARK ENERGY?

?

Page 35: Dark Matter and Dark Energy - admin.triumf.caadmin.triumf.ca/docs/seminars/Sem3102343965-79538-1.Sem20091… · of dark matter and dark energy This is an embarrassing result that

Dark Energy is a complete mystery but we know that:

-it has negative pressure (equation of state is completely unlike anything else)

-it is small but not zero (theory predicts it is either zero or incredibly large)

>100 distinct candidates

Page 36: Dark Matter and Dark Energy - admin.triumf.caadmin.triumf.ca/docs/seminars/Sem3102343965-79538-1.Sem20091… · of dark matter and dark energy This is an embarrassing result that

SUMMARY

Many independent observations now confirm the existenceof dark matter and dark energy

This is an embarrassing result that we don’t understand 95%of the Universe!

Everything indicates that their physical nature is linked withFundamental physics yet to be discovered

Research agencies across the world (e.g. DoE in the US) aredesigning new generation of detectors capable of probing

the physics of DM and DE

The fact the DM and DE have been detected does notnecessarily mean they are real (e.g. epicycles?)