8/19/2019 Dallas' Response to Exxxotica Lawsuit

1/60

 Hoco`hm`ts― Tospl`so tl Zime`tecc―s Kltel` clr m Zroieke`mry E`nu`gtel` m`h Dreoc  

464:7/?:232= Zmbo | e

E@ XFO _@EXOH WXMXOW HEWXTEGX GL_TX

CLT XFO @LTXFOT@ HEWXTEGX LC XOVMW

HMIIMW HESEWEL@

XFTOO OVZL OSO@XW, I.I.G. §

§Zime`tecc § 

§v. §  GM @L> 7>=3-gv-::?=7-H 

§

GEXU LC HMIIMW, ot mi § §

Hoco`hm`ts § 

HOCO@HM@XW― TOWZL@WO XL ZIME@XECC―W KLXEL@

CLT M ZTOIEKE@MTU E@N_@GXEL@ M@H DTEOC 

GLKO @LR Hoco`hm`ts= m`h ceio tfes Tospl`so tl Zime`tecc―s Kltel` clr m Zroieke`mry

E`nu`gtel` m`h Dreoc. Xfo Glurt sfluih ho`y Zime`tecc―s kltel` clr tfo romsl`s stmtoh doilw>

E.

W_KKMTU 

Crmuh, greko m`h dromgf lc gl`trmgt mro m cow lc tfo km`y iobetekmto, `l`hesgreke`mtlry

romsl`s wfegf nustecy tfo Gety―s hogesel` m`h ostmdiesf tfmt Zime`tecc―s roquost clr e`nu`gtevo roieoc

sfluih do ho`eoh. E` mhhetel` tl Oxxxltegm―s ’u`giom` fm`hs‛ progiuhe`b ets o`tetioko`t tl

e`nu`gtevo roieoc, tfo Gety―s romsl`mdio teko, pimgo m`h km``or robuimtel`s prlveho m

gl`stetutel`mi nustecegmtel` clr tfo Gety―s Tosliutel`.

=

 GEXU LC HMIIMW, XOVMW, M.G. BL@M^IO^, slioiy e` fes lccegemi  gmpmgety ms Gety Km`mbor, TL@ AE@B, slioiye` fes lccegemi gmpmgety ms Oxogutevo Herogtlr lc tfo Hopmrtko`t lc Gl`vo`tel` m`h Ovo`t Worvegos, KEAO

 TMRIE@BW, e` fes lccegemi gmpmgety ms Kmylr lc tfo Gety lc Hmiims, GMWOU XFLKMW, e` fes lccegemi gmpmgety ms m

kokdor lc tfo Gety Glu`gei lc tfo Gety lc Hmiims, GMTLIU@ AE@B MT@LIH, e` for lccegemi gmpmgety ms m kokdor

lc tfo Gety Glu`gei lc tfo Gety lc Hmiims, TEGAOU H. GMIIMFM@, e` fes lccegemi gmpmgety ms m kokdor lc tfo Gety

Glu`gei lc tfo Gety lc Hmiims, XECCE@@E M. UL_@B, e` for lccegemi gmpmgety ms m kokdor lc tfo Gety Glu`gei lc tfo

Gety lc Hmiims, OTEA REIWL@, e` fes lccegemi gmpmgety ms m kokdor lc tfo Gety Glu`gei lc tfo Gety lc Hmiims, D.

 MHMK KgBL_BF, e` fes lccegemi gmpmgety ms m kokdor lc tfo Gety Glu`gei lc tfo Gety lc Hmiims, m`h NO@@ECOT

WXM_DMGF BMXOW, e` for lccegemi gmpmgety ms m kokdor lc tfo Gety Glu`gei lc tfo Gety lc Hmiims  

Gmso 7>=3-gv-::?=7-H Hlguko`t 4: Ceioh :7/4?/=3 Zmbo = lc 3: ZmboEH 8?:

8/19/2019 Dallas' Response to Exxxotica Lawsuit

2/60

 Hoco`hm`ts― Tospl`so tl Zime`tecc―s Kltel` clr m Zroieke`mry E`nu`gtel` m`h Dreoc  

464:7/?:232= Zmbo | ee

EE.

XMDIO LC GL@XO@XW 

E. W_KKMTU ...................................................................................................................................... E 

EE. XMDIO LC GL@XO@XW ................................................................................................................... EE 

EEE. XMDIO LC M_XFLTEXEOW ............................................................................................................. S 

ES. DMGABTL_@H .............................................................................................................................= 

M.  Oxxxltegm Cmgts ........................................................................................................=  

=.  Kr. Fm`hy―s Toproso`tmtel`s tl tfo Gety Mdlut Oxxxltegm ........................= 

4.  Kr. Fm`hy―s Cmiso Toproso`tmtel`s tl tfo Gety Mdlut OxxxltegmXoxms, IIG ..................................................................................................7 

7. 

Oxxxltegm Selimtoh Ets Mbrooko`t ...............................................................? 

8. 

Oxxxltegm Selimtoh Wtmto Imw .....................................................................2 

?. 

Oxxxltegm Selimtoh Hmiims Gety Glho Gfmptor 8=M, tfo WoxumiiyLreo`toh Duse`oss Lrhe`m`go .......................................................................6 

3.  Xfo Gety Heh @lt Glkket tl Zrlveho m Gl`trmgt clr Oxxxltegm e`4:=3............................................................................................................=7  

2.  Xfo Gety Glu`gei Mpprlvos tfo Tosliutel` ...............................................=8  

D. 

Xfo Hmiims Woxumiiy Lreo`toh Duse`oss Lrhe`m`go ...............................................=? 

6.  Xfo O`mgtko`t lc tfo Lrhe`m`go ...............................................................=? 

5. 

Xfo Iobesimtevo E`to`t lc tfo Lrhe`m`go ....................................................=? 

=:. 

Xfo Hmiims Gety Glu`gei―s Iobesimtevo Ce`he`bs lc Cmgt e` Wupplrtlc tfo Hmiims WLD Lrhe`m`go .....................................................................=2 

==.  Xfo Hmiims Gety Glu`gei―s Iobesimtevo Ce`he`bs lc Cmgt Tobmrhe`btfo Iego`se`b lc WLDs ...............................................................................=2 

=4.   @l Oxokptel` Oxests clr m Xokplrmry Woxumiiy Lreo`toh Duse`oss .........=6 

S. MTB_KO@XW M@H M_XFLTEXEOW.................................................................................................=6  

M.  Xfo Hlgtre`o lc Gl`stetutel`mi Mvlehm`go. ...........................................................=6 

D.  Zroieke`mry E`nu`gtel` Wtm`hmrh ............................................................................=5 

G. 

Zime`tecc Gm``lt Giomriy Ostmdiesf M Wudstm`temi Ieaoiefllh lc Wuggoss l`tfo Korets. ..............................................................................................................4=

 

=.  Zime`tecc―s _`giom` Fm`hs Zrogiuhos Ets O`tetioko`t tl OquetmdioToieoc. .........................................................................................................4=  

m.  Zime`tecc Wfluih @lt Ldtme` Oquetmdio Toieoc Dogmuso EtKmho Crmuhuio`t Kesroproso`tmtel`s tl tfo Gety. ......................... 44

 

 d.  Zime`tecc Wfluih @lt Ldtme` Oquetmdio Toieoc Dogmuso Et

Gmso 7>=3-gv-::?=7-H Hlguko`t 4: Ceioh :7/4?/=3 Zmbo 4 lc 3: ZmboEH 8?=

8/19/2019 Dallas' Response to Exxxotica Lawsuit

3/60

 Hoco`hm`ts― Tospl`so tl Zime`tecc―s Kltel` clr m Zroieke`mry E`nu`gtel` m`h Dreoc  

464:7/?:232= Zmbo | eee

Topomtohiy Miilwoh Greke`mi Mgtevety tl Lggur mtOxxxltegm ...................................................................................... 48 

(=)  Selimtel`s lc Wtmto Imw ........................................................ 48 

(4)  Selimtel`s lc Hmiims Lrhe`m`gos ........................................... 4? 

g. 

Zime`tecc Wfluih @lt Ldtme` Oquetmdio Toieoc Dogmuso EtSelimtoh Ets Mbrooko`t Retf tfo Gety. ......................................... 4?

 

4. 

Oxxxltegm es M Woxumiiy Lreo`toh Duse`oss _`hor Gfmptor 8=Mm`h Cmeis tl Glkpiy Retf Xfmt Lrhe`m`go. ...............................................42 

m.  Oxxxltegm es M Glkkorgemi O`torpreso, tfo ZrekmryDuse`oss lc Rfegf es tfo Lccore`b lc Worvegos m`h tfoOxfedete`b lc Etoks E`to`hoh tl Zrlveho WoxumiBrmtecegmtel`. ................................................................................. 42 

 d.  Oxxxltegm Hlos @lt Glkpiy wetf Gfmptor 8=M m`hZrlhugos Wogl`hmry Occogts tfmt Gfmptor 8=M es Hoseb`oh

tl Zrovo`t. ..................................................................................... 45 

g.  Gfmptor 8=M es gl`stetutel`mi........................................................ 7= 

(=) 

Gfmptor 8=M es @mrrlwiy Xmeilroh tl Worvo M Wudstm`temiBlvor`ko`t E`torost...................................................................... 74 

(4)  Gfmptor 8=M Iomvos Lpo` Mhoqumto Mitor`mtevo Mvo`uos lcGlkku`egmtel`. ............................................................................ 76 

(7)  Oxxxltegm―s Mutflreteos mro E`mpplseto Dogmuso Oxxxltegm esM Woxumiiy Lreo`toh Duse`oss Wudnogt tl M Xeko, Zimgo, m`hKm``or Lrhe`m`go. ....................................................................... 8: 

h. 

M`y E`nury Oxxxltegm Wuccoroh crlk tfo Tosliutel` es @ltTohrossmdio Dogmuso Gfmptor 8=M E`hopo`ho`tiy Zrovo`tsOxxxltegm―s Woxumiiy Lr eo`toh Duse`oss mt tfo Gl`vo`tel`Go`tor. ........................................................................................... 8= 

7.  Oxxxltegm―s Cerst Mko`hko`t Gimek Cmeis. ...............................................84 

m.  Xfo Zudieg Clruk Essuo. ............................................................... 87 

 d.  Oxxxltegm―s Cmgemi Mttmga l` tfo Gety―s Tosliutel` Cmeis. ........... 87 

g.  Oxxxltegm Gm``lt Zrlvo E`to`tel`mi Seowple`tHesgreke`mtel`............................................................................... 88 

(=) 

Xfo Gety―s Tosliutel`. .......................................................... 88 

(4)  Oxxxltegm―s Nuhegemi Mhkessel`s _`horke`o Et Gimek lcSeowple`t Hesgreke`mtel`. ............................................................ 88 

(7)  Oxxxltegm―s Seowple`t es @lt Giomr. .................................... 8? 

h.  Oxxxltegm Gm``lt Zrlvo Zrelr Tostrme`t. ...................................... 82 

H.  Oxxxltegm Gm``lt Giomriy Ostmdiesf tfmt Xforo es M Wudstm`temi Xfromt tfmt

Gmso 7>=3-gv-::?=7-H Hlguko`t 4: Ceioh :7/4?/=3 Zmbo 7 lc 3: ZmboEH 8?4

8/19/2019 Dallas' Response to Exxxotica Lawsuit

4/60

 Hoco`hm`ts― Tospl`so tl Zime`tecc―s Kltel` clr m Zroieke`mry E`nu`gtel` m`h Dreoc  

464:7/?:232= Zmbo | ev

Erropmrmdio Fmrk Reii Tosuit ec tfo E`nu`gtel` es @lt Brm`toh. ............................82 

O.  Oxxxltegm Gm``lt Giomriy Ostmdiesf Xfmt tfo Xfromto`oh E`nury Lutwoebfstfo Xfromto`oh Fmrk tl tfo Gety. ...........................................................................86 

C.  Oxxxltegm Gm``lt Giomriy Ostmdiesf Xfmt m Zroieke`mry E`nu`gtel` Reii @lt Hessorvo tfo Zudieg E`torost. ...........................................................................?: 

SE. GL@GI_WEL@ .............................................................................................................................?: 

Gmso 7>=3-gv-::?=7-H Hlguko`t 4: Ceioh :7/4?/=3 Zmbo 8 lc 3: ZmboEH 8?7

8/19/2019 Dallas' Response to Exxxotica Lawsuit

5/60

 Hoco`hm`ts― Tospl`so tl Zime`tecc―s Kltel` clr m Zroieke`mry E`nu`gtel` m`h Dreoc  

464:7/?:232= Zmbo | v

EEE.

XMDIO LC M_XFLTEXEOW 

_.W. Gl`stetutel` 

_.W. GL@WX. mko`h. E. ...................................................................................................... =6, 8=, 87

_.W. GL@WX. mko`h. V .................................................................................................................. 43

_.W. GL@WX. mrt. E, §=:, gi.= .......................................................................................................... 4?

Gmsos 

7? Dmr m`h Breiio, IIG v. Gety lc Wm` M`tl`el, 587 C. Wupp. 4h 2:3 (R.H. Xox.4:=7) ................................................................................................................................. 86, ?:

 Mgko Tocrebormtel` Wuppieos, E`g. v. Mgko Tocrebormtel` lc Dmtl` Tlubo, E`g.,53= C.Wupp. 573 (O.H. Im. =553) ............................................................................................ 85

 Mhhorioy v. Cilrehm, 76? _.W. 75 (=533) ...................................................................................... 43

 Msfgrlct v. mi-Aehh , =7= W.Gt. 4:28 (4:==) .................................................................................. =5 Dmdy Hliis Xlpioss Wmill`s, E`g. v. Gety lc Hmiims, ==8 C.Wupp.4h ?7= (@.H. Xox.

4:::), mcc―h. 45? C.7h 82= (?tf Ger. 4::4) ...................................................................... pmssek

 Dmeioy v. Wtm`clrh , @l. 7>== ‗ gv ‗ :::8: ‗  @DD ‗ WWM, 4:=4 RI ?35:4: (@.H.Kess. 4:=4) ............................................................................................................................. 85

 Dmr`os v. Bio` Xfomtro, E`g., ?:= _.W. ?3: (=55=) ...................................................................... 77

 DBFM, IIG v. _`evorsmi Gety, 78: C.7h 45? (?tf Ger. 4::7) ...................................................... 77

 D^MZW, E`g. v. Gety lc Km`amtl, 436 C.7h 3:7 (6tf Ger. 4::=) .............................................. 72, 76

Gmkrotm v. Broo`o, =7= W.Gt. 4:4: (4:==) .................................................................................. =5

Ge`ovesel` Glrp. v. Gety lc Durdm`a , 28? C.4h ?3: (5tf Ger. =568) ............................................. 8:

Gety lc Oreo v. Zmp―s M.K., ?45 _.W. 422 (4:::) .......................................................................... 74

Gety lc Iettiotl` v. ^.N. Bects H-8, I.I.G ., ?8= _.W. 228 (4::8) ................................................... 8=

Gety lc Ils M`boios v. Mimkohm Dllas, E`g., ?7? _.W. 84? (4::4) ......................................... 74, 77

Gety lc To`tl` v. Zimyteko Xfomtros, E`g., 82? _.W. 8= (=563).............................................. pmssek

Gluttm v. Wtmto, 76? W.R.7h 38= (Xox. Mpp. ‘ Oi Zmsl 4:=4, `l pot.) ..................................... 6, 78

Glx Gmdio Glkk―`s, E`g. v. _`etoh Wtmtos, 554 C.4h ==26 (==tf Ger. =557) ............................... 43

 Hmves v. Coh. Oiogtel` Glkk―`, ??8 _.W. 248 (4::6) ................................................................. 8= Hmytl`m Brm`h, E`g. v. Gety lc Hmytl`m Domgf, 85: C.7h 63: (==tf Ger. 4::2) .................... 7=, 77

 Ho``es Koim`gl`, E`g. v. Gety lc @ow Lriom`s, 2:7 C.7h 434 (?tf Ger. 4:=4) ............................ 4:

 HIW, E`g. v. Gety lc Gfmttm`llbm, =:2 C.7h 8:7 (3tf Ger. =552) .................................................. 7:

 Hukms v. Gety lc Hmiims, 386 C. Wupp. =:3= (@.H. Xox. =563) .................................. =?, =3, =2, 8?

 Ohwmrh N. HoDmrtlil Glrp. v. @.I.T.D., 837 _.W. =82 (=567) ..................................................... =5

Gmso 7>=3-gv-::?=7-H Hlguko`t 4: Ceioh :7/4?/=3 Zmbo ? lc 3: ZmboEH 8?8

8/19/2019 Dallas' Response to Exxxotica Lawsuit

6/60

 Hoco`hm`ts― Tospl`so tl Zime`tecc―s Kltel` clr m Zroieke`mry E`nu`gtel` m`h Dreoc  

464:7/?:232= Zmbo | ve

 Cm`tmsy Tm`gf, E`g. v. Gety lc Mrie`btl`, 8?5 C.7h ?83 (?tf Ger. 4::3) .................... 7:, 74, 77, 73

 Cmu`tiorly v. Iuk, 4=: _.W. 47: (=5:6) ...................................................................................... 85

 Ciotgfor v. Zoga , =: _.W. (3 Grm`gf) 62 (=6=:) ........................................................................... 4?

 Clstor v. Gety lc Oi Zmsl, 753 W.R.7h 488 (Xox. Mpp.-Oi Zmsl 4:=7) ......................................... 7=

 CR/ZDW, E`g. v. Gety lc Hmiims, 857 _.W. 4=? (=55:) ................................................................... =?

 CR/ZDW, E`g. v. Gety lc Hmiims, 672 C.4h =456 (?tf Ger. =566) ................................................... =?

BXO Gmrh Worvegos v. MX&X Glrp., @l. 7>53-GS-=52:-H, =552 RI 282=4 (@.H.Xox. =552) ............................................................................................................................... 86

 Fmmso v. Bimz`or , 34 W.R.7h 25? (Xox. 4::=) ............................................................................. 47

 Fmrresl` v. Roiis Cmrbl Dm`a, @.M., Gmuso @l. 7>=7 ‗ GS ‗ 8364 ‗ H, 4:=? RI=385:35 (@.H. Xox. 4:=?) (Cetzwmtor, N.)............................................................................... 43

 Fomitfple`t, Ith., v. Otfox Glrp., 427 C.Wupp.4h 6=2 (R.H. Xox. 4::=) .................................... 4=

 Feii v. Glilrmhl, ?7: _.W. 2:7 (4:::) ......................................................................................... 83 Flhbo v. Zre`go, 27: C.Wupp. 282 (@.H. Xox. =55:) ................................................................... =5

 Fliim`h Mk. E`s. Gl. v. Wuggossel` lc Tly, 222 C.4h 554 (?tf Ger. =56?) ................................... 4:

 Fliies v. Iy`gf, =4= C. Wupp. 7h 3=2 (@.H. Xox. 4:=?) ............................................................... 84

 E` ro Dmso Flihe`bs, IIG , @l. 7>== ‗ GS ‗ 7?7= ‗ H, 4:=? RI =6:6?73 (@.H. Xox.4:=?) (Cetzwmtor, N.) .......................................................................................................... 44, 47

 E`t―i Wlg―y clr Aresf`m Gl`sgelus`oss v. Wfrmhor , 83= C. Wupp. 2=8 (@.H. Xox.=526) ....................................................................................................................................... 87

 Etmiem` Glwdly Zmrt`ors, Ith. v. Zruho`temi E`s. Gl. lc Mk., 78= W.R.7h 747(Xox. 4:==) .............................................................................................................................. 47

 Nmgasl` Rlko`―s Fomitf Lrbm`ezmtel` v. Gurreor , 23: C.7h 886 (?tf Ger. 4:=8) ...................... 4:

 Nl`os v. Dusf, =44 C. Wupp. 4h 2=7 (@.H. Xox. 4:::) .................................................................. 4:

 Nl`os v. Aoiiy, 3== Coh. Mppx. 445 (?tf Ger. 4:=?) ..................................................................... 43

 Nustego v. Flsokm``, 22= C.7h 46? (?tf Ger. 4:=8) ..................................................................... 84

 AF Luthllr, I.I.G. v. Gimy Glu`ty, 864 C.7h =455 (==tf Ger. 4::2) ......................................... 84

 Imaoim`h Ilu`bo v. Gety lc Nmgasl`, Kess., 527 C.4h =4?? (?tf Ger. =554) ................................. 75

 Iilyh Glrp., Ieketoh v. Xm``or , 8:2 _.W. ??= (=524) .................................................................. 43

 Iunm` v. Hoco`hors lc Reihieco, ?:8 _.W. ??? (=554) ................................................................... 84

 Iy`b v. @lrtfwost E`hem` Gokotory Zrltogtevo Mss―`, 86? _.W. 875 (=566) ......................... =6, =5

 Kess. Zlwor & Iebft Gl. v. _`etoh Bms Zepo Ie`o Gl., 23: C.4h 3=6 (?tf Ger.=56?) ....................................................................................................................................... 4:

 Ketgfoii Drls. Ceik Brlup v. Ge`okm Mhuit Xfomtor , 3:8 C.7h 6?4 (?tf Ger. =525) ................... 4=

Gmso 7>=3-gv-::?=7-H Hlguko`t 4: Ceioh :7/4?/=3 Zmbo 3 lc 3: ZmboEH 8??

8/19/2019 Dallas' Response to Exxxotica Lawsuit

7/60

 Hoco`hm`ts― Tospl`so tl Zime`tecc―s Kltel` clr m Zroieke`mry E`nu`gtel` m`h Dreoc  

464:7/?:232= Zmbo | vee

 KNNB Tostmurm`t, IIG v. Flrry Glu`ty, == C. Wupp. 7h ?8= (H.W.G. 4:=8) .............................. 8:

 @.R. O`torpresos, E`g. v. Gety lc Flustl`, 7?4 C.7h =34 (?tf Ger. 4::7) ............................... 77, 75

 @mt―i Coh―` lc tfo Die`h lc Xox., E`g. v. Mddltt, 382 C.7h 4:4 (?tf Ger. 4:==)............................. 8=

 @XT Duiiel` Brlup, IIG v. Iedorty Kotmis Brlup, IIG , @l. 7>=7 ‗ GS ‗ 758? ‗ H,

4:=7 RI ?3723:= (@.H. Xox. 4:=7) ...................................................................................... 4:

Lrtflciox, E`g. v. XforklXoa, E`g., 567 C. Wupp. 4h 633 (@.H. Xox. 4:=7) ................................. 43

 Zomrsl` v. Gmiimfm`, ??? _.W. 447 (4::5) ................................................................................... =5

 Zooa-M-Dll Ilu`bo lc Drmho`tl`, E`g. v. Km`mtoo Glu`ty, 37: C.7h =783 (==tfGer. 4:==) ................................................................................................................................ 7=

 Zim``oh Zmro`tfllh Mss―` lc Fehmibl Glu`ty Xox., E`g. v. Wuofs, 354 C.7h 787(?tf Ger. 4:=4) ......................................................................................................................... 4:

 Zrogesel` E`struko`t Kcb. Gl. v. Mutl. Kme`t. Kmgf. Gl., 748 _.W. 6:3 (=58?) ........................ 4=

 Zrlpreotlrs lc Gfmrios Tevor Drehbo v. Zrlpreotlrs lc Rmrro` Drehbo, 73 _.W. (==Zot.) 84: (=672) ...................................................................................................................... 4?

 Toegfio v. Flwmrhs, =74 W.Gt. 4:66 (4:=4) ................................................................................. =5

 Tos`ega v. Wtmto, ?28 W.R.4h ??6 (Xox. Grek. Mpp. QZm`oi Lp.[ =526) ................................... 6, 78

WHN, E`g. v. Gety lc Flustl`, 672 C.4h =436 (?tf Ger. =566) ........................................................ 73

Wlutfomstor` Zrlkltel`s, Ith. v. Gl`rmh , 84: _.W. ?83 (=52?) .................................................. 8:

Wtoe`dmgf v. Wtmto, 525 W.R.4h 673 (Xox.Mpp.-Muste` =556, pot. roc―h) .................................. 6, 78

Xfroo Mcceiemtoh Xredos lc Ct. Dortflih Tosorvmtel` v. Rlih O`be`oore`b, Z.G.,832 _.W. =76 (=568) ................................................................................................................ =5

XA―s Sehol, E`g. v. Ho`tl` Glu`ty, 48 C.7h 2:? (?tf Ger. 4::8) ................................................. 73

_.W. v. Klrbm`ceoih , ?:= C.7h 8?7 (?tf Ger. 4::2) ....................................................................... 44

_`etoh Wtmtos v. Zimydly O`tk―t Brlup, E`g., ?45 _.W. 6:7 (4:::) ............................................. 8:

Sorkl`t Mbo`gy lc @mturmi Tos. v. _.W. ox roi. Wtovo`s, ?45 _.W. 23? (4:::) ............................ 84

Rmrh v. Tlga Mbme`st Tmgesk, 85= _.W. 26= (=565) ........................................................ 73, 76, 83

Rfeto v. Gmriugge, 634 C.4h =4:5 (?tf Ger. =565) ........................................................................ 4:

Reiiemks v. Wtmto, @l. :?-:7-386-GT, 4::8 RI 5?4:8 (Xox. Mpp. ‘ Hmiims 4::8,`l pot.) (kok. lp. `lt hoseb`mtoh clr pudiegmtel`) ............................................................. 6, 78

Re`tor v. @mturmi Tos. Hoc. Glu`gei , ??? _.W. 2 (4::6) ........................................................ 7=, 8:

Rllhmii v. Gety lc Oi Zmsl, 85 C.7h ==4: (?tf Ger. =55?) ............................................................ 75

Rlrih Reho Sehol lc Rmsfe`btl`, E`g. v. Gety lc Wplam`o, 736 C.7h ==63 (5tf Ger.4::8) ....................................................................................................................................... 74

Ulu`b v. Mkoregm` Ke`e Xfomtros, E`g., 842 _.W. ?: (=523) ....................................................... 82

Wtmtutos 

Gmso 7>=3-gv-::?=7-H Hlguko`t 4: Ceioh :7/4?/=3 Zmbo 2 lc 3: ZmboEH 8?3

8/19/2019 Dallas' Response to Exxxotica Lawsuit

8/60

 Hoco`hm`ts― Tospl`so tl Zime`tecc―s Kltel` clr m Zroieke`mry E`nu`gtel` m`h Dreoc  

464:7/?:232= Zmbo | veee

XOV. D_W. & GLK. GLHO § 42.:= 47

XOV. D_W. LTB. GLHO § 5.::= 48

XOV. D_W. LTB. GLHO § 5.::8 48

XOV. D_W. LTB. GLHO § 5.::? 48

XOV. D_W. LTB. GLHO § 5.:?4 48

XOVMW ZO@MI GLHO § 4=.:= 6, 78

XOVMW ZO@MI GLHO § 4=.:2 6, 78

Ku`egepmi Lrhe`m`gos 

GFMZXOT 8=M ......................................................................................................................... pmssek

Tosliutel` =3:7:6 ................................................................................................................. pmssek

Tuios 

COH. T. GES. Z. 3? 4:

COH. T. GES. Z. 5 48

Dllas/Zorelhegmi Kmtoremis 

DIMGA 'W IMR HEGXEL@MTU (=:tf oh. 4:=8) (ZTELT TOWXTME@X) ........................................... 82

Kmrte` F. Tohesf, Xfo Zrlpor Tlio lc tfo Zrelr Tostrme`t Hlgtre`o e` Cerst Mko`hko`t Xfolry, 2: Sm. I. Tov. ?7 (=568) ....................................................................... 82

Gmso 7>=3-gv-::?=7-H Hlguko`t 4: Ceioh :7/4?/=3 Zmbo 6 lc 3: ZmboEH 8?2

8/19/2019 Dallas' Response to Exxxotica Lawsuit

9/60

 Hoco`hm`ts― Tospl`so tl Zime`tecc―s Kltel` clr m Zroieke`mry E`nu`gtel` m`h Dreoc  

464:7/?:232= Zmbo | =

ES.

DMGABTL_@H 

M.  Oxxxltegm Cmgts

=.  Kr. Fm`hy―s Toproso`tmtel`s tl tfo Gety Mdlut Oxxxltegm

=.= Hure`b tfo spre`b lc 4:=8, Kr. Noccroy Fm`hy kmho e`quereos mdlut iomse`b tfo

Gl`vo`tel` Go`tor. Zime`tecc―s Mpp. 88.4  Kr. Fm`hy prlvehoh Oream Dl`hy, tfo Gl`vo`tel`

Go`tor―s Wmios Gllrhe`mtlr, wetf e`clrkmtel` mdlut Oxxxltegms e` ltfor geteos m`h wetf fes

’Lpormte`b Toqueroko`ts clr Mhuit O`tortme`ko`t Lreo`toh Ovo`ts‛ (’Lpormte`b

Toqueroko`ts‛). Hs. Mpp. 5?-53, ³ 71 =::-=:=1 Zime`tecc―s Mpp. =?-=3, ³ ?1 Zime`tecc―s Mpp. ?:-

?4. Ks. Dl`hy sfmroh tfoso glkku`egmtel`s wetf ltfor kokdors lc tfo Gl`vo`tel` Go`tor

stmcc, e`giuhe`b tfo Gl`vo`tel` Go`tor―s Mssestm`t Herogtlr, Nlf` Nlf`sl`. Hs. Mpp. 88, ³ 81 ?7-

?51 ==7-=43.

=.7 Kr. Fm`hy roproso`toh tl tfo Gl`vo`tel` Go`tor tfmt Oxxxltegm, ’es m bmtfore`b

 pimgo lc mii tfe`bs oxlteg, orlteg, so`sumi m`h soxy. Oxxxltegm comturos m sflw cillr wetf mii lc

tfo imtost prlhugts m`h sorvegos gmtore`b tl tfo Mhuit Iecostyio Glkku`ety m`h `ebftiy plst-ovo`t

 pmrteos mt ilgmi `ebftgiuds.‛ Hs. Mpp. =:7. Kr. Fm̀ hy okpfmsezoh tfmt mt Oxxxltegm, ’Qt[foro es

`l ievo `uhety lr iowh mgts, dut rmtfor m` upsgmio bmtfore`b lc prlhugts m`h sorvegos gmtore`b tl

tfo mhuit iecostyio.‛ Fo oxpime`oh tfmt Oxxxltegm flihs m cuii o`tortme`ko`t stmbo l` tfo sflw

cillr, comtur e`b cmsfel` sflws, kuseg m`h ltfor ievo porclrkm`gos.‛ Hs. Mpp. ?7-?51 56-=:?.

=.8 Kr. Fm`hy eho`teceoh kmios, mbo =6-7? ms Oxxxltegm―s tmrbot hoklbrmpfeg,

mgglu`te`b clr mpprlxekmtoiy 75 porgo`t lc mii mtto`hoos. Hs. Mpp. ?31 =:8.

=.? Kr. Fm`hy misl tlih tfo Gl`vo`tel` Go`tor tfmt, ’OVVVLXEGM es `lt ylur

‖typegmi― ovo`t m`h tforoclro gm``lt do tromtoh ms sugf.‛ Hs. Mpp. ?21 =:?.

4 Hoco`hm`ts fmvo ceioh ldnogtel`s tl slko lc Zime`tecc―s oveho`go. Hat. =6. Hoco`hm`ts― ldnogtel`s mro e`glrplrmtohe`tl tfes rospl`so ms ec cuiiy sot clrtf foroe`.

Gmso 7>=3-gv-::?=7-H Hlguko`t 4: Ceioh :7/4?/=3 Zmbo 5 lc 3: ZmboEH 8?6

8/19/2019 Dallas' Response to Exxxotica Lawsuit

10/60

 Hoco`hm`ts― Tospl`so tl Zime`tecc―s Kltel` clr m Zroieke`mry E`nu`gtel` m`h Dreoc  

464:7/?:232= Zmbo | 4

=.3 Kr. Fm`hy roproso`toh tfmt Oxxxltegm ’miwmys mdehoQs[ dy‛ spogeceoh ’Lpormte`b

Toqueroko`ts,‛ wfegf fo prlvehoh tl Gl`vo`tel` Go`tor stmcc. Hs. Mpp. 88, ³?1 ?7-?51 =:3-==4.

=.2 Kr. Fm`hy roproso`toh tfmt mii pmtrl`s m`h porsl``oi mt Oxxxltegm mro prlfedetoh

crlk ’tfo hespimy lc ioss tfm` glkpiotoiy m`h lpmquoiy glvoroh bo`etmis, pudeg robel`, m`us lr

cokmio dromsts doilw m ple`t ekkohemtoiy mdlvo tfo tlp lc tfo mrolims.‛  Kr. Fm`hy misl mssuroh

stmcc tfmt ’Qs[oxumi mgteveteos mro prlfedetoh‛ m`h stmtoh tfmt tflso ’e`giuho tfo cl`hie`b lr ltfor

orlteg tlugfe`b lc bo`etmis, pudeg robel`, duttlgas, m`us lr cokmio dromsts.‛  Hs. Mpp. ?61 ===.

=.6 Kr. Fm`hy misl roproso`toh tfmt fo m`h/lr fes mcceiemtos wluih> (=) prlveho ovo`t

sogurety porsl``oi tl kl`etlr glkpiem`go wetf tfo torks m`h gl`hetel`s lc tfo mbrooko`t1 (4)

 plst seb`s mt tfo o`trm`go hllrs lc tfo iomsoh oxfedet spmgo prlfedete`b u`imwcui gl`hugt1 (7)

e`suro tfmt ’mii oxfedetlrs, mtto`hoos, iossoo stmcc, m`h m`y ltfor e`vetoos m`h buosts lc iossoo sfmii

glkpiy wetf mii mppiegmdio imws wetf rospogt tl mgteveteos m`h kmtoremis e`seho tfo iomsoh

 prokesos1 (8) e`clrk omgf m`h ovory oxfedetlr, e` wrete`b, lc tfo Lpormte`b Toqueroko`ts m`h

e`glrplrmto tfo oxmgt im`bumbo e`tl mii oxfedetlr mbrooko`ts1 (?) ldtme` wretto`

mga`lwiohboko`t lc tfo Lpormte`b Toqueroko`ts crlk mii oxfedetlrs1 (3) suporveso tfo sflw m`h

oxfedetlr gl`hugt mt mii tekos1 m`h (2) ekkohemtoiy onogt tfo oxfedetlr―s porsl``oi lr m`y e`vetoo

lr buost lc tfo oxfedetlr gl`tredute`b tl tfo velimtel` lc tfo Lpormte`b Toqueroko`ts m`h

ekkohemtoiy gilso m`y sugf oxfedet. Hs. Mpp. ?6-?51 ===-==4. Mhhetel`miiy, Kr. Fm`hy

roproso`toh tfmt `l mhuit lr ldsgo`o kmtoremis wluih do vesedio crlk m`y pudieg rebft lc wmy m`h

tfmt `l l`o u`hor =6 yomrs lc mbo wluih do mhkettoh. Hs. Mpp. ?61 ===.

=.5 Gl`vo`tel` Go`tor stmcc roveowoh Kr. Fm`hy―s prlplsoh Lpormte`b Toqueroko`ts

wetf Gety porsl``oi, e`giuhe`b porsl``oi crlk tfo Hmiims Zliego Hopmrtko`t, m`h oxpime`oh tfmt

tfo Lpormte`b Toqueroko`ts rociogtoh wfmt Kr. Fm`hy wms prlplse`b tl hl m`h flw fo wms

Gmso 7>=3-gv-::?=7-H Hlguko`t 4: Ceioh :7/4?/=3 Zmbo =: lc 3: ZmboEH 8?5

8/19/2019 Dallas' Response to Exxxotica Lawsuit

11/60

 Hoco`hm`ts― Tospl`so tl Zime`tecc―s Kltel` clr m Zroieke`mry E`nu`gtel` m`h Dreoc  

464:7/?:232= Zmbo | 7

 prlplse`b tl lpormto Oxxxltegm Hmiims. Hs. Mpp. 88, ³ ?. Kr. Fm`hy―s Lpormte`b Toqueroko`ts

woro ekplrtm`t e` tfo Gl`vo`tel` Go`tor stmcc―s hesgussel`s gl`gor`e`b Oxxxltegm. Xfo

Gl`vo`tel` Go`tor―s Mssestm`t Herogtlr, Kr. Nlf`sl`, ltfor Gl`vo`tel` Go`tor stmcc, m`h Gety

 porsl``oi u`horstllh tfmt Oxxxltegm wluih cliilw tfoso Lpormte`b Toqueroko`ts. Hs. Mpp. 8?,

 ³ 31 3:-37.

=.=: Mhhetel`miiy, dy seb`e`b tfo Gl`vo`tel` Go`tor―s stm`hmrh gl`trmgt, Kr. Fm`hy

mbrooh tfmt ’ovory okpilyor, mbo`t, m`h porkettoh o`trm`t gl``ogtoh wetf tfo purplso clr wfegf

tfo Zrokesos mro ro`toh, sfmii mdeho dy, gl`clrk tl, m`h glkpiy wetf mii imws lc tfo _`etoh

Wtmtos, tfo Wtmto lc Xoxms, m`h mii lrhe`m`gos lc tfo Gety lc Hmiims.‛ Zime`tecc―s Mpp. =:8  ³ 461

Zime`tecc―s Mpp. =6-=5, ³ ==.

=.== E` imto Nuiy m`h omriy Mubust lc 4:=?, roproso`tmtevos crlk tfo Gl`vo`tel`

Go`tor, tfo Gety Mttlr`oy―s lccego, m`h tfo Hmiims Zliego Hopmrtko`t pmrtegepmtoh e` m gl`coro`go

gmii m`h m sopmrmto koote`b wetf Kr. Fm`hy. Hs. Mpp. 8?, ³ 21 =?2, ³ 3. L`o purplso lc tfo

gl`coro`go gmii m`h koote`b wms tl mhhross tfo po`mi glho prlvesel`s roiovm`t tl Oxxxltegm

Hmiims. Kr. Fm`hy mbrooh tl mppiy fes hoce`etel` m`h prlfedetel` lc soxumi mgteveteos tl

 porclrkm`gos lggurre`b mt Oxxxltegm Hmiims, e`giuhe`b m`y pimy, kltel` pegturo, hm`go lr ltfor

oxfedetel` porclrkoh doclro m` muheo`go. Hs. Mpp. 8?, ³ 21 3:-6=1 =?2, ³ 3. Xfo ce`mi e`-porsl`

 pro-gl`coro`go koote`b tlla pimgo l` Mubust ?, 4:=?. Kr. Fm`hy mbrooh tl mdeho dy tfo ruios

fo hesgussoh wetf tfo Gety. Hs. Mpp. 8?, ³ 2. Kr. Fm`hy mhkets tfmt fo mbrooh tfmt ’soxumi

mgteveteos wluih do prlfedetoh m`h `l Zo`mi Glho lcco`sos sugf ms ldsgo`ety, pudieg iowh`oss,

otg. wluih do porkettoh.‛ Hat. = mt =:, ³ 2. 

4.  Kr. Fm`hy―s Cmiso Toproso`tmtel`s tl tfo Gety Mdlut Oxxxltegm Xoxms, IIG

4.= E` fes glkku`egmtel`s wetf Gl`vo`tel` Go`tor stmcc hure`b tfo spre`b m`h

sukkor lc 4:=8, Kr. Fm`hy eho`teceoh sovormi duse`oss o`teteos purplrtohiy e`vlivoh wetf

Gmso 7>=3-gv-::?=7-H Hlguko`t 4: Ceioh :7/4?/=3 Zmbo == lc 3: ZmboEH 83:

8/19/2019 Dallas' Response to Exxxotica Lawsuit

12/60

 Hoco`hm`ts― Tospl`so tl Zime`tecc―s Kltel` clr m Zroieke`mry E`nu`gtel` m`h Dreoc  

464:7/?:232= Zmbo | 8

Oxxxltegm Hmiims, e`giuhe`b Xfroo Oxpl Ovo`ts, Oxltegm Xoxms IIG, m`h Oxltegm Hmiims IIG.

Hs. Mpp. =42-=46.

4.4 L` Mubust ==, 4:=8, Gl`vo`tel` Go`tor stmcc so`t Kr. Fm`hy m prlplsoh gl`trmgt

clr fes prlplsoh iomso lc tfo Gl`vo`tel` Go`tor clr Oxxxltegm Hmiims. Hs. Mpp. 62-66, ³³ 7-81

=45-=84. Xfes prlplsoh gl`trmgt iestoh ’Xfroo Oxpl Ovo`ts‛ ms tfo usor lc tfo Gl`vo`tel`

Go`tor. Hs. Mpp. =45-=84.

4.7 E` rospl`so, l` Mubust =4, 4:=8, Kr. Fm`hy so`t Ks. Dl`hy m` okmei e` wfegf fo

mga`lwiohboh rogoept lc tfo prlplsoh gl`trmgt m`h è wfegf fo oxpime`oh tfmt ’Qw[o hoce`etoiy

`ooh tfo gl`trmgt wretto` tl Oxltegm Xoxms, IIG…iobmiiy Oxltegm Xoxms, IIG es tfo glkpm`y

gl`trmgte`b tfo spmgo.‛  Hs. Mpp. =87-=83. Xfo Gl`vo`tel` Go`tor roessuoh tfo prlplsoh

gl`trmgt wetf tfes gfm`bo. Hs. Mpp. 66, ³ 31 =87.

4.8 L` Nm`umry 5, 4:=?, Kr. Fm`hy seb`oh m gl`trmgt wetf tfo Gl`vo`tel` Go`tor l`

 dofmic lc Oxltegm Xoxms, IIG. Zime`tecc―s Mpp. =:=-=:6. Xfes gl`trmgt prlvehoh tfmt `ltegos clr

tfo _sor, Oxltegm Xoxms, IIG, woro tl do so`t tl Kr. Fm`hy mt m` mhhross e` Zfeimhoipfem,

Zo``syivm`em. Zime`tecc―s Mpp. =:?. 

4.? L` Nuiy 7:, 4:=?, Kr. Fm`hy prlvehoh Gl`vo`tel` Go`tor stmcc wetf m Gortecegmto

lc Iemdeiety E`surm`go portme`e`b tl tfo Gl`vo`tel` Go`tor m`h ieste`b tfo e`suroh ms Xfroo Oxpl

Ovo`ts IIG & Oxltegm Hmiims IIG hdm Oxltegm Xoxms. Hs. Mpp. 66, ³ ?1 5:1 soo misl, Hs. Mpp.

=82-=85. M` mhhross e` Muste`, Xoxms wms prlvehoh clr tfo o`teteos wfegf purplrtoh tl do hle`b

 duse`oss ms Oxltegm Xoxms. Hs. Mpp. 5:.

4.3 E` cmgt, flwovor, Oxltegm Xoxms, IIG hlos `lt oxest. Xfo Glkkl`womitf lc

Zo``syivm`em fms `l roglrh lc m`y o`tety dy tfo `mko lc Oxltegm Xoxms, IIG. Hs. Mpp. 38=-384,

 ³ 81 388. Xfo Wogrotmry lc Wtmto lc Xoxms fms `l roglrh lc m`y o`tety dy tfo `mko lc Oxltegm

Gmso 7>=3-gv-::?=7-H Hlguko`t 4: Ceioh :7/4?/=3 Zmbo =4 lc 3: ZmboEH 83=

8/19/2019 Dallas' Response to Exxxotica Lawsuit

13/60

 Hoco`hm`ts― Tospl`so tl Zime`tecc―s Kltel` clr m Zroieke`mry E`nu`gtel` m`h Dreoc  

464:7/?:232= Zmbo | ?

Xoxms, IIG. Hs. Mpp. 384, ³ ?1 38?. Xfo Wogrotmry lc Wtmto lc Hoimwmro fms `l roglrh lc m`y

o`tety dy tfo `mko lc Oxltegm Xoxms, IIG. Hs. Mpp. 384, ³ 3. M somrgf lc mii stmtos rotur`oh `l

roglrhs clr Oxltegm Xoxms, IIG m`ywforo è tfo _`etoh Wtmtos. Hs. Mpp. 384, ³ 2. Mhhetel`miiy,

`l cegtetelus `mko gortecegmto lr ltfor roglrhs clr Oxltegm Xoxms IIG lr Oxltegm Xoxms mro l` ceio

e` Xrmves Glu`ty, Xoxms, lr è Hmiims Glu`ty, Xoxms. Hs. Mpp. 384, ³ 6-51 383-385.

7.  Oxxxltegm Selimtoh Ets Mbrooko`t

7.= Mitflubf Kr. Fm`hy fmh roproso`toh tfmt mii Oxxxltegm Hmiims pmtrl`s m`h

 porsl``oi wluih do prlfedetoh crlk ’tfo hespimy lc ioss tfm` glkpiotoiy m`h lpmquoiy glvoroh

bo`etmis, pudeg robel`, m`us lr cokmio dromsts doilw m ple`t ekkohemtoiy mdlvo tfo tlp lc tfo

mrolims‛  (Hs. Mpp. ===), e` cmgt, km`y wlko` mt Oxxxltegm Hmiims wlro l`iy pmsteos lr tmpo

glvore`b tfoer `eppios m`h mrolims m`h ltforweso oxplsoh tfoer dromsts. Hs. Mpp. = QCeios =-8, 2-

=:, =4-=?, =2, 4:, 4?, 45[71 4-=21 82-?= Q³³ ==, =7-=?, =6-4:, 44, 48, 42, 45[1 348 Q³ 2[1 34: Q³

5[1 342 Q³ 2[1 37: Q³ 2[1 378 Q³ 2[1 376 Q³ 2[.

7.4 Mitflubf Kr. Fm`hy fmh roproso`toh tfmt soxumi mgteveteos, e`giuhe`b ’tfo

cl`hie`b lr ltfor orlteg tlugfe`b lc bo`etmis, pudeg robel`, duttlgas, m`us lr cokmio dromsts,‛

woro prlfedetoh mt Oxxxltegm Hmiims (Hs. Mpp. ===), e` cmgt, sugf soxumi mgteveteos tlla pimgo mt

Oxxxltegm Hmiims, m`h woro ldsorvoh m`h roglrhoh. Hs. Mpp. = QCeios =-8, 2, ==, =3, 4:, 46[1 86-

?= Q³³ =7-=?, =6, 4=, 47, 46[.

7.7 Mitflubf Kr. Fm`hy fmh roproso`toh tfmt `l mhuit lr ldsgo`o kmtoremis wluih do

vesedio crlk m`y pudieg rebft lc wmy (Hs. Mpp. ===), e` cmgt, fo heh `lt mrrm`bo clr hrmpos lr

sgroo`s tl do plsetel`oh sl ms tl dilga tfo veow lc tfo oxfedet spmgo crlk tfo ilddy wfo` tfo

o`trm`go m`h oxet hllrs tl tfo oxfedet spmgo woro lpo` tl porket polpio tl pmss tfrlubf. E`stomh,

wfo` tfoso hllrs woro lpo` tl porket pmssmbo, e`hevehumis e` tfo ilddy lc tfo Gl`vo`tel` Go`tor

7 Hoco`hm`ts fmvo ceioh m kltel` clr iomvo tl ceio mhuit-lreo`toh oveho`temry kmtoremis u`hor somi.

Gmso 7>=3-gv-::?=7-H Hlguko`t 4: Ceioh :7/4?/=3 Zmbo =7 lc 3: ZmboEH 834

8/19/2019 Dallas' Response to Exxxotica Lawsuit

14/60

 Hoco`hm`ts― Tospl`so tl Zime`tecc―s Kltel` clr m Zroieke`mry E`nu`gtel` m`h Dreoc  

464:7/?:232= Zmbo | 3

gluih ldsorvo m vmreoty lc dlltfs wfegf woro setumtoh `omr tfoso hllrs, m`h gluih ldsorvo mhuit

kmtoremi sugf ms, clr e`stm`go, plio hm`ge`b porclrkoh l` m pimtclrk vesedio tfrlubf tfoso hllrs.

Hs. Mpp. 83-82 Q³ 5[1 = QCeio =5, :>8:-:>8?[1 641 37: Q³ 3[1 378 Q³ 3[1 376 Q³ 3[. Xfo dlltfs

wfegf woro vesedio crlk tfo ilddy wfo` tfo o`try m`h oxet hllrs woro lpo` tl porket o`try m`h

oxet e`giuhoh IM Herogt Klhois, Wekpiy Orlteg Vtrms, Gfmturdmto,8  Mrrm`boko`tCe`hors.glk,

KyCrooGmks.glk m`h, plssediy, Gieps8Wmio.glk. Hs. Mpp. 4?1 83-82 Q³ 5[1 641 34: Q³ 8[. Xfo

Gfmturdmto dlltf e`giuhoh ievo klhois womre`b pmsteos m`h b-stre`bs. Hs. Mpp. = QCeio 2[1 431 ?:

Q³48[. Xfo KyCrooGmks.glk dlltf e`giuhoh wlko` womre`b `ltfe`b klro tfm` pmsteos lr tmpo

l` tfoer `eppios m`h mrolims m`h/lr womre`b b-stre`bs lr sekeimr mttero wfegf oxplsoh tfoer

 duttlgas, m`h wms tfo ilgmtel` wforo slko soxumi mgteveteos m`h pudieg iowh`oss tlla pimgo. Hs.

Mpp. = QCeio 7, :>:=-:>:7 m`h :>4=-:>4?1 Ceio 45[.

7.8 Mitflubf Kr. Fm`hy fmh roproso`toh tfmt fo wluih do gfogae`b eho`tecegmtel` m`h

tfmt `l l`o u`hor tfo mbo lc =6 wluih do mhkettoh tl Oxxxltegm Hmiims, m`h mitflubf, hmys prelr

tl Oxxxltegm Hmiims, HZH stmtoh, ’wo gm``lt stross o`lubf flw vebeim`t ylu kust do l` tfes,‛

(Hs. Mpp. ===1 Hs. Mpp. 3=), e` cmgt, polpio woro mhkettoh tl Oxxxltegm Hmiims wetflut fmve`b

tfoer eho`tecegmtel` gfogaoh, e`giuhe`b mt iomst l`o ylu`b-illae`b wlkm` è for two`teos. Hs.

Mpp. 345-37: Q³ 8[1 377-378 Q³ 8[1 372-376 Q³ 8[. Wlko mtto`hoos lc Oxxxltegm Hmiims smw m

ylu`b wlkm` e` tfo oxfedet spmgo wfl heh ̀ lt mppomr tl do =6 yomrs lih Hs. Mpp. 37: Q³ 5[1 378

Q³ 5[1 376 Q³ 5[.

7.? Mitflubf Kr. Fm`hy fmh prlkesoh tl plst seb`s mt tfo o`trm`go hllrs lc tfo

iomsoh oxfedet spmgo prlfedete`b u`imwcui gl`hugt (Hs. Mpp. ===), Gl`vo`tel` Go`tor stmcc m`h

Oxxxltegm mtto`hoos smw `l sugf seb`s. Hs. Mpp. 82 Q³ =:[1 37: Q³ ?[1 378 Q³ ?[1 376 Q³ ?[.

8  Gfmturdmto hoce`os ’gfmturdmto‛  ms ’tfo mgt lc kmsturdmte`b wfeio gfmtte`b l`ie`o.‛fttps>//twettor.glk/gfmturdmto=3-gv-::?=7-H Hlguko`t 4: Ceioh :7/4?/=3 Zmbo =8 lc 3: ZmboEH 837

https://twitter.com/chaturbate?lang=enhttps://twitter.com/chaturbate?lang=enhttps://twitter.com/chaturbate?lang=en

8/19/2019 Dallas' Response to Exxxotica Lawsuit

15/60

 Hoco`hm`ts― Tospl`so tl Zime`tecc―s Kltel` clr m Zroieke`mry E`nu`gtel` m`h Dreoc  

464:7/?:232= Zmbo | 2

7.3 Mitflubf Kr. Fm`hy fmh roproso`toh tfmt fo wluih kl`etlr glkpiem`go wetf tfo

torks m`h gl`hetel`s lc tfo mbrooko`t m`h suporveso tfo sflw m`h oxfedetlr gl`hugt mt mii tekos,

(Hs. Mpp. ==4), e` cmgt, kuitepio heccoro`t velimtel`s lc tfo Lpormte`b Toqueroko`ts lggurroh.

Wuprm ³³ 7.=-7.?.

8.  Oxxxltegm Selimtoh Wtmto Imw

8.= Mitflubf Kr. Fm`hy fmh mbrooh tfmt ’ovory okpilyor, mbo`t, m`h porkettoh

o`trm`t gl``ogtoh wetf tfo purplso clr wfegf tfo Zrokesos mro ro`toh, sfmii mdeho dy, gl`clrk tl,

m`h glkpiy wetf mii imws lc tfo _`etoh Wtmtos, tfo Wtmto lc Xoxms, m`h mii lrhe`m`gos lc tfo Gety

lc Hmiims‛ (Zime`tecc―s Mpp. =:8, ³ 461 Zime`tecc―s Mpp. =6-=5, ³ ==) m`h tfmt fo wluih e`suro tfmt

’mii oxfedetlrs, mtto`hoos, Iossoo stmcc, m`h m`y ltfor e`vetoos m`h buosts lc Iossoo sfmii glkpiy

wetf mii mppiegmdio imws wetf rospogt tl mgteveteos m`h kmtoremis e`seho tfo iomsoh prokesos

(Zime`tecc―s Mpp. =:8 ³ 46), m`h mitflubf Kr. Fm`hy mhkets tfmt fo mbrooh tfmt ’`l Zo`mi Glho

lcco`sos sugf ms…pudieg iowh`oss…wluih do porkettoh‛ (Hat. = mt =:, ³ 2), e` cmgt, tfo Gety

`lw? fms oveho`go lc kuitepio velimtel`s lc imw wfegf tlla pimgo hure`b Oxxxltegm Hmiims. Hs.

Mpp. = QCeio =, :>?8-=>:81 Ceio 4, :>?:-=>=:1 Ceio 7, :>:=-:>:7 m`h :>4=-:>4?1 Ceio 8 :>8?-:>?2 m`h

=>=?-=>4:[1 86 Q³³ =7-=?[1 =?8 Q³ 8[1 =?6 Q³ 5[1 =52 Q³³ 8-?[1 =55-4:8.

8.4 Hospeto Kr. Fm`hy―s e`etemi roproso`tmtel` tfmt fes Oxxxltegm ovo`ts e`giuho `l

iowh mgts (Hs. Mpp. ?7-?51 56-=:?), vehol clltmbo crlk Oxxxltegm Hmiims hokl`strmtos tfmt

gl`hugt wfegf e`vlivoh cl`hie`b m`h tlugfe`b lc dromsts m`h sekuimtel` lc soxumi e`torglurso dy

?

 Zime`tecc ―s mssortel`s tfmt Oxxxltegm Hmiims ’bmvo reso tl `l eiiobmi gl`hugt‛ (Hat. = mt ?) m`h tfmt, ’Qe[` rospl`so tlGlu`gei Kokdor Ae`bstl`―s quostel`e`b, tfo Gfeoc lc Zliego mccerkoh tfmt `l greke`mi mgtevety fmh doo` o`bmboh e`mt tfo oxpl‛ (Hat. =: mt 6) mro `lt supplrtoh dy tfo oveho`go m`h lvorstmto tfo mgtumi m`swors Gfeoc Drlw` bmvohure`b tfo Codrumry =:, 4:=3 Gety Glu`gei sossel`. Kr. Ae`bstl` msaoh `mrrlw quostel`s gl g̀or`e`b l`iy wfotforu`horglvor vego lccegors mt Oxxxltegm roplrtoh m`y greke`mi mgtevety m`h wfotfor HZH wms mwmro lc m`y e`gromso e`greko tfmt es roimtoh tl Oxxxltegm. Hs. Mpp. 84 QCeio 4, 42>?:-45>77[. Gfeoc Drlw` heh `lt stmto tfmt `l eiiobmigl`hugt lr greke`mi mgtevety tlla pimgo mt Oxxxltegm. Xfo tfroo u`horglvor vego lccegors wfl mtto`hoh OxxxltegmHmiims heh sl l`iy clr m ieketoh teko, `l klro tfm` m` flur m`h m fmic l` l`o hmy m`h twl flurs l` m`ltfor hmy,hure`b wfegf teko tfoy heh `lt ldsorvo greke`mi mgtevety. Hs. Mpp. 3=5-34= Q³³ 7, =:[1 343-342 Q³³ 7, 6[1 347 Q³ 7[.Flwovor, tfes hlos `lt kom` tfmt `l eiiobmi gl`hugt lr greke`mi mgtevety tlla pimgo mt Oxxxltegm Hmiims.

Gmso 7>=3-gv-::?=7-H Hlguko`t 4: Ceioh :7/4?/=3 Zmbo =? lc 3: ZmboEH 838

8/19/2019 Dallas' Response to Exxxotica Lawsuit

16/60

 Hoco`hm`ts― Tospl`so tl Zime`tecc―s Kltel` clr m Zroieke`mry E`nu`gtel` m`h Dreoc  

464:7/?:232= Zmbo | 6

lrmi slhlky heh lggur mt Oxxxltegm Hmiims. Hs. Mpp. = QCeio =, :>?8-=>:81 Ceio 4, :>?:-=>=:1 Ceio

7, :>:=-:>:7, :>4=-:>4?1 Ceio 8, :>8?-:>?2, =>=?-=>4:[1 34:-34= Q³ =:[1 342 Q³ 6[. _`hor Xoxms

imw, tfo gl`hugt wfegf wms gmpturoh l` tfoso veholtmpos gl`stetutos mgts lc pudieg iowh`oss.3 

Hs. Mpp. = QCeio =, :>?8-=>:81 Ceio 4, :>?:-=>=:1 Ceio 7, :>:=-:>:7 m`h :>4=-:>4?1 Ceio 8, :>8?-

:>?2 m`h =>=?-=>4:[1 =?8 Q³ 8[1 =?6 Q³ 5[1 =52 Q³ ?[.

8.7 Mhhetel`miiy, m pmtrl` lc Oxxxltegm Hmiims wms mrrostoh clr mssmuit e` tfo

Gl`vo`tel` Go`tor wfo` fo pu`gfoh m prltostlr e` tfo cmgo. Hs. Mpp. =52, ³ 81 =55-4:4.

M`ltfor pmtrl` lc Oxxxltegm Hmiims wms essuoh m` mrrost l` m wmrrm`t mctor fo wms e`vlivoh e` m

hesturdm`go mt tfo Gl`vo`tel` Go`tor m`h wms clu`h tl fmvo m` lutstm`he`b wmrrm`t. Hs. Mpp.

=52, ³ 81 =55-4:4.

8.8 L` tfo wooao`h tfmt Oxxltegm Hmiims tlla pimgo, Mubust 2-5, 4:=?, tfo vego

sogtel` lc tfo HZH gl`hugtoh m` lpormtel` hoseb`oh tl tmrbot tfo hokm`h seho lc fukm`

trmccegae`b e` tfo Gety lc Hmiims dy tmrbote`b tfo ’Nlf`s‛ wfl slieget prlstetutel` lcc tfo e`tor`ot,

spogecegmiiy tfrlubf tfo wodseto dmgapmbo.glk. Xfes lpormtel` e`vlivoh tfo HZH plste`b twl

mhs l` tfo dmgapmbo.glk wodseto hoseb`oh tl mttrmgt ’Nlf`s‛ wfl sooa tl pmy clr soxumi

o`glu`tors wetf ylu`b lr u`hormbo cokmios. Dltf lc tfo HZH―s  mhs kmho rocoro`go tl

’Oxxltegm‛ lr ’Oxxxltegm.‛  Xfes lpormtel` rosuitoh e` `e`o mrrosts lc ’Nlf`s‛ wfl rospl`hoh tl

tfo HZH―s dmgapmbo.glk mhs. Hs. Mpp. 7?-8=1 =?3-=3:, ³³ 7-?, =:-=41 =34-=5?.

?.  Oxxxltegm Selimtoh Hmiims Gety Glho Gfmptor 8=M, tfo Woxumiiy Lreo`toh

Duse`oss Lrhe`m`go

3 _`hor XOVMW ZO@MI GLHO (’XZG‛) Wog. 4=.:=(4), ’soxumi gl`tmgt‛ kom`s ’m`y tlugfe`b lc tfo m`us, dromst, lrm`y pmrt lc tfo bo`etmis lc m`ltfor porsl` wetf e`to`t tl mrluso lr brmtecy tfo soxumi hosero lc m`y porsl`.‛ _`horXZG Wog. 4=.:2, m porsl` glkkets tfo lcco`so lc pudieg iowh`oss ec fo lr sfo ’a`lwe`biy o`bmbos e` m`y lc tfocliilwe`b mgts e` m pudieg pimgo… (7) Qm`[ mgt lc soxumi gl`tmgt.‛ ’‖Woxumi gl`tmgt― `ooh `lt do ciosf -l`-ciosf dutkmy lggur hospeto tfo oxesto`go lc m giltf lr ltfor dmrreor wfegf provo`ts lr ekpohos ciosf-l`-ciosf gl`tmgt. WooWtoe`dmgf v. Wtmto, 525 W.R.4h 673, 676 ‗ 8: (Xox. Mpp.-Muste` =556, pot. roc―h)  (e`tor`mi getmtel`s lkettoh).‛Gluttm v. Wtmto, 76? W.R.7h 38=, 3?7 (Xox. Mpp. ‘ Oi Zmsl 4:=4, `l pot.)1  soo misl Reiiemks v. Wtmto, @l. :?-:7-386-GT, 4::8 RI 5?4:8 (Xox. Mpp. ‘ Hmiims 4::8, `l pot.) (kok. lp. `lt hoseb`mtoh clr pudiegmtel`)1 Tos`ega v.Wtmto, ?28 W.R.4h ??6 (Xox. Grek. Mpp. QZm`oi Lp.[ =526).

Gmso 7>=3-gv-::?=7-H Hlguko`t 4: Ceioh :7/4?/=3 Zmbo =3 lc 3: ZmboEH 83?

8/19/2019 Dallas' Response to Exxxotica Lawsuit

17/60

 Hoco`hm`ts― Tospl`so tl Zime`tecc―s Kltel` clr m Zroieke`mry E`nu`gtel` m`h Dreoc  

464:7/?:232= Zmbo | 5

?.= Mitflubf Kr. Fm`hy fmh mbrooh tfmt ’ovory okpilyor, mbo`t, m`h porkettoh

o`trm`t gl``ogtoh wetf tfo purplso clr wfegf tfo Zrokesos mro ro`toh, sfmii mdeho dy, gl`clrk tl,

m`h glkpiy wetf mii imws lc tfo _`etoh Wtmtos, tfo Wtmto lc Xoxms, m`h mii lrhe`m`gos lc tfo Gety

lc Hmiims‛ (Zime`tecc―s Mpp. =:8, ³ 461 Zime`tecc―s Mpp. =6-=5, ³ ==), e` cmgt, Oxxxltegm Hmiims

velimtoh Gety lrhe`m`gos roimte`b tl soxumiiy lreo`toh duse`ossos.

?.4 Xfo roglrh sflws tfmt Oxxxltegm―s prekmry duse`oss es tfo lccore`b lc sorvegos

m`h tfo hespimy lc etoks e`to`hoh tl prlveho soxumi stekuimtel` tl ets gustlkors. Xfrlubflut

Oxxxltegm, wlko` ropomtohiy hespimyoh spogeceoh m`mtlkegmi mroms, e`giuhe`b dromsts m`h

 duttlgas. Hs. Mpp. = QCeios =, 4, 7, 8, 5, =4, =2, 44, 47, 48, 46, 45[1 soo misl Hs. Mpp. 7, 8, ?, 3, 6,

5, =:, ==, =4, =7, =?, =2 (pegturos). Xfes ievo `uhety, ms hoce`oh e` § 8=M-4(48), wms m gl`te`ulus

comturo lc Oxxxltegm, prlvehe`b soxumi stekuimtel` m`h soxumi brmtecegmtel` tl Oxxxltegm

gustlkors.

?.7 Oxxxltegm―s `uho wlko` misl prlvehoh soxumi stekuimtel` m`h soxumi

brmtecegmtel` tl Oxxxltegm gustlkors dy o`bmbe`b e` spogeceoh soxumi mgteveteos. Dltf tfo mttero lc

tfo o`tortme`ors m`h tfo gl`hugt e` wfegf tfoy o`bmboh es e`hesgor`edio crlk tfo typegmi gl`hugt

mt mhuit gmdmrots m`h `uho klhoi stuhels.

?.8 Clr oxmkpio, `uho wlko` mt Oxxxltegm cl`hioh, ruddoh, m`h aessoh l`o m`ltfor―s

 dmro dromsts m`h duttlgas. Hs. Mpp. = QCeio =[. Xfoy sekuimtoh o`bmbe`b e` lrmi sox tlbotfor. Hs.

Mpp. = QCeio 7, :>::-:>:7[. Wovormi klhois mppomroh `uho wetfe` tfo ’KyCrooGmks.glk‛ mrom,

wforo tfoy ’porclrkoh‛ ievo clr veowe`b pmtrl`s. KyCrooGmks.glk wms tfo ’proso`te`b

spl`slr‛ ropomtohiy prlkltoh e` Oxxxltegm―s 4:=? prlbrmk kmtoremis, m`h et lggupeoh m imrbo

mrom. Hs. Mpp. =2, =6, 44, 47 (prlbrmk glvor, pp. 4-7, =:, =4). KyCrooGmks.glk es m

 plr`lbrmpfeg wodseto tfmt deiis etsoic ms ’Xfo #= Mhuit Rodgmk Glkku`ety‛ (soo

Gmso 7>=3-gv-::?=7-H Hlguko`t 4: Ceioh :7/4?/=3 Zmbo =2 lc 3: ZmboEH 833

8/19/2019 Dallas' Response to Exxxotica Lawsuit

18/60

 Hoco`hm`ts― Tospl`so tl Zime`tecc―s Kltel` clr m Zroieke`mry E`nu`gtel` m`h Dreoc  

464:7/?:232= Zmbo | =:

www.kycroogmks.glk), wforo usors pmy tl ’gfmt‛ wetf wlko` wfl o`bmbo e` soxumi mgtevety

vem wodgmk. Clr oxmkpio, l`o wlkm` wetf oxplsoh dromsts m`h tmpo l` for `eppios put m imrbo

sekuimtoh po`es e` for klutf m`h sekuimtoh porclrke`b lrmi sox. Hs. Mpp. = QCeio 45, :>78-:>?6[.

Klhois crlk www.Gfmturdmto.glk, m sekeimr wodgmk glkpm`y, lggupeoh m`ltfor mrom. Hs.

Mpp. 4? (prlbrmk).

?.? L` stmbo wetf sglros lc pmtrl`s wmtgfe`b, m `uho wlkm` ’kmsturdmtoh‛ m dlttio

tfmt wms kmho tl illa ieao m dimga, lvor-sezoh po`es wetf m sgrltuk mt l`o o`h, m`h tfo` squertoh

wfeppoh gromk l`tl for dmro dromsts (wetf m tmpo ’V‛ glvore`b for `eppios). Hs. Mpp. = QCeio 4[.

Wfo tfo` strmhhioh m pmtrl` tfmt wms somtoh e` m gfmer l` tfo stmbo, m`h sfo ruddoh m`h dlu`goh

for dmro dromsts e` tfo km`―s cmgo u`tei tfo wfeppoh gromk wms bl`o. Eh.

?.3 Mctor tfmt, tfo `uho wlkm` smt e` tfo gfmer, squertoh wfeppoh gromk l` for pudeg

robel`, rmesoh for coot, spromh for iobs e` tfo mer, m`h tfrust mdlut e` tfo gfmer wfeio tfo kmio

gustlkor (l` fes fm`hs m`h a`oos) put fes klutf e`tl for grltgf, ovo`tumiiy glke`b up wetf m

cmgo cuii lc wfeppoh gromk. Xfo wlkm` tfo` tur`oh mrlu`h e` tfo gfmer, squertoh wfeppoh gromk

l`tl tfo tlp lc for dmro duttlgas, m`h fmh tfo pmtrl` rud fes cmgo e` et. Hs. Mpp. = QCeio 8[.

?.2 Hure`b m`ltfor mgtevety, m wlkm` e` m sfoor lutcet ‘ tfmt oxplsoh for duttlgas ‘ 

fmh for dmro duttlgas cl`hioh, spm`aoh, m`h wfeppoh wfeio l` tfo kme` stmbo wetf m imrbo brlup

lc pmtrl`s wmtgfe`b. Hs. Mpp. = QCeio 46[.

?.6 L`o lc Oxxxltegm―s go`trmi comturos wms m twl-`ebft ’Ks. Oxxxltegm

Glkpotetel`‛ l` tfo kme` stmbo, wforo wlko` hespimye`b spogeceoh m`mtlkegmi mroms (duttlgas

m`h dromsts) o`bmboh e` ievo o`tortme`ko`t clr m imrbo grlwh lc gustlkors. Hs. Mpp. = QCeio 2,

:>::-=>=2, 7>::-5>7:1 soo misl Ceio 4:[. Rlko` o`bmboh e` soxumi hm`ge`b sugf ms tworae`b m`h

fukpe`b, m`h spogeceoh soxumi mgteveteos sugf ms ’orlteg tlugfe`b lc fukm` bo`etmis, pudeg

Gmso 7>=3-gv-::?=7-H Hlguko`t 4: Ceioh :7/4?/=3 Zmbo =6 lc 3: ZmboEH 832

8/19/2019 Dallas' Response to Exxxotica Lawsuit

19/60

 Hoco`hm`ts― Tospl`so tl Zime`tecc―s Kltel` clr m Zroieke`mry E`nu`gtel` m`h Dreoc  

464:7/?:232= Zmbo | ==

robel`, duttlgas … Qm`h[ dromsts.‛ § 8=M-4(78)1 Hs. Mpp. = QCeio 4:, 4>::-4>:61 4>4:-4>4?1 7>4:-

7>7:1 8>8?-8>?7[.

?.5 E` tfo ce`mis, m wlkm` wetf cuiiy oxplsoh duttlgas ’grlwh-surcoh‛ l` tfo

muheo`go, wfegf iot km`y pmtrl`s bot ’m fm`hcui lc mss‛ (por tfo m``lu`gor) ms tfoy tlugfoh for

 dmro duttlgas m`h pmssoh for mrlu`h mdlvo tfoer fomhs. Hs. Mpp. = QCeio 4:, 47>=?-48>:71 Ceio 2,

6>4:-5>7:, =:>=:-=:>84[.

?.=: Hure`b m stmbo porclrkm`go clur wlko` oxplsoh tfoer duttlgas wfeio porclrke`b

ievo o`tortme`ko`t. Xfoy tlugfoh omgf ltfor―s dmro duttlgas wfeio tworae`b m`h rudde`b tfoer

 poiveg/pudeg robel` m`h duttlgas mbme`st l`o m`ltfor. Xfo wlko` misl brmddoh tfoer lw`

 duttlgas m`h dromsts wfeio porclrke`b sekuimtoh sox mgts m`h ruddoh t-sferts dotwoo` tfoer iobs

l`tl tfoer vmbe`ms. Wlko lc tfo wlko` sekuimtoh soxumi e`torglurso dy fukpe`b tfo cillr ms ec

tfoy woro l` tlp lc m`ltfor porsl`, wfeio oxplse`b tfoer dmro duttlgas tl tfo grlwh. Hs. Mpp. =

QCeio ==, ::>74-?>771 2>=?-2>45[.

?.== Mt m`ltfor dlltf, plr`lbrmpfy stmr ’Wmrm Nmy‛ slih soxumiiy oxpieget etoks m`h

 puiioh hlw` for hross, oxplse`b for dromsts. Wfo plsoh e` tfes stmto lc `uhety wetf kuitepio kmio

gustlkors, prosse`b for dmro dromst mbme`st tfo gustlkors― gfosts. Hs. Mpp. = QCeios 5, =:[. 

?.=4 Wovormi `uho wlko` misl plsoh e` soxumi plsetel`s wetf kmio gustlkors. Hs.

Mpp. = QCeio 6, =>??-4>46[. E` l`o mrom, m wlkm` e` m B-stre`b m`h ’hross‛ (wetf flrezl`tmi siets

oxplse`b for duttlgas m`h dromsts) wluih e`vort for dlhy mbme`st m somtoh gustlkor―s tlrsl m`h

spromh for iobs, wfegf put for dmro duttlgas m`h glvoroh vmbe`mi mrom rebft u`hor tfo gustlkor―s

klutf m`h tl`buo. Hs. Mpp. = QCeios =4, =7[1 soo misl eh . QCeios =8, =? (smko wlkm` giekde`b

lvor somtoh gustlkor―s fomh m`h strmhhie`b fek, putte`b dmro duttlgas m`h glvoroh pudeg robel`

mrom `omr gustlkor―s cmgo)[. 

Gmso 7>=3-gv-::?=7-H Hlguko`t 4: Ceioh :7/4?/=3 Zmbo =5 lc 3: ZmboEH 836

8/19/2019 Dallas' Response to Exxxotica Lawsuit

20/60

 Hoco`hm`ts― Tospl`so tl Zime`tecc―s Kltel` clr m Zroieke`mry E`nu`gtel` m`h Dreoc  

464:7/?:232= Zmbo | =4

?.=7 Mt yot m`ltfor dlltf, m wlkm` oxplse`b for duttlgas plsoh e` m a`ooie`b plsetel`

wetf for klutf lpo` mt m pmtrl`―s grltgf, m`h tfo` plsoh e` m do`t -lvor plsetel` ms tflubf sfo

woro lccore`b for m`us clr soxumi po`otrmtel`. Hs. Mpp. = QCeio 4=[. Km`y ltfor sekeimr soxumi

 plsos woro roglrhoh. Hs. Mpp. = QCeio 6, =>4?-=>7? (sekuimte`b kmsturdmtel`)1 4>:?-4>=8 (lrmi

sox plso)1 Ceio =3, =>=:-=>4: (tfroo-wmy m`mi m`h lrmi sox plsetel`)1 Ceio =6, :>4:-:>76 (m`mi sox

 plsetel`)[.

?.=8 Xfes typo lc gl`hugt mt Oxxxltegm ovo`ts es `lt u`usumi. E` l`o vehol, mt m IM

Herogt Klhois dlltf, m wlkm` e` m B-stre`b smt l` m pmtrl`―s imp m`h iot fek kmsturdmto for dy

rudde`b for glvoroh vmbe`mi mrom wetf fes fm`h ms sfo byrmtoh l` fes imps. Wovormi pmtrl`s,

e`giuhe`b l`o wetf m` Oxxxltegm SEZ dmb (ieao tflso gmrreoh dy Hmiims SEZ pmtrl`s), illaoh l`

wfeio tfes bo`etmi stekuimtel` wms lggurre`b. Hs. Mpp. = QCeio 43[.

?.=? Oxxxltegm misl comturoh sovormi dlltfs hohegmtoh tl soxumi stekuimtel` tfrlubf

’vesumi roproso`tmtel`s‛ tfmt ’hopegt lr hosgredo ‖spogeceoh soxumi mgteveteos― lr ‖spogeceoh

m`mtlkegmi mroms―‛‘m`h/lr tfo smio lr ro`tmi lc ’e`struko`ts, hovegos, lr pmrmpfor`miem tfmt mro

hoseb`oh clr uso e` gl``ogtel` wetf ‖spogeceoh soxumi mgteveteos.―‛ § 8=M-4(7). Xfes es m

il`bstm`he`b comturo lc Oxxxltegm, ms m` omrieor prlkltel`mi vehol febfiebfts sox tlys m`h

 plr`lbrmpfeg HSHs, okpfmseze`b tfo lpplrtu`ety tl ’$ Ldtme` Kmssevo $ L`-Weto $ Gmsf Wmios

$.‛ Hs. Mpp. = QCeio ?, :>8?-=>:8[.

?.=3 Clr oxmkpio, Oxxxltegm fms sovormi dlltfs soiie`b soxumiiy oxpieget kohem

kmtoremis. Hs. Mpp. = QCeio 5, :>:6-:>=: (ieste`b HSHs clr $=:, 6x=: pegturos clr $=:, plstors clr

$=?, m`h ’XLZIOWW‛ pfltl wetf Wmrm Nmy clr $4:)1 Ceio =: (soiie`b soxumiiy oxpieget pegturos m`h

HSHs)1 Ceio 4? mt ::>?8-::>?5 (lccore`b plr`lbrmpfeg HSHs)1 eh . mt =>=?-=>47 (soiie`b `uho

gmio`hmrs)[.

Gmso 7>=3-gv-::?=7-H Hlguko`t 4: Ceioh :7/4?/=3 Zmbo 4: lc 3: ZmboEH 835

8/19/2019 Dallas' Response to Exxxotica Lawsuit

21/60

 Hoco`hm`ts― Tospl`so tl Zime`tecc―s Kltel` clr m Zroieke`mry E`nu`gtel` m`h Dreoc  

464:7/?:232= Zmbo | =7

?.=2 Wekeimriy, Gieps8Wmio.glk lggupeoh mrom 2:? mt Oxxxltegm. (Hs. Mpp. 4?,

 prlbrmk.) Gieps8Wmio.glk lccors m vmst gliiogtel` lc plr`lbrmpfeg vehols gmtoblrezoh dy vmrelus

cotesfos, m`h et deiis etsoic ms ’Xfo #= Hlw`ilmhmdio Sehol Giep Weto l` tfo Rod.‛

(www.gieps8smio.glk). Misl comturoh mt Oxxxltegm woro m ietm`y lc hovegos hoseb`oh clr uso e`

gl``ogtel` wetf spogeceoh soxumi mgteveteos, e`giuhe`b sekuimtoh po`esos m`h vedrmtlrs. Hs. Mpp. =

QCeio 6, :>?8-=>=6 (’Mhuits @ooh Xlys Xll‛)[.

?.=6 Oxxxltegm―s soxumi hovego lccore`bs misl comturoh DHWK (Dl`hmbo, Hesgepie`o,

Wmhesk, m`h Kmslgfesk) hovegos e`to`hoh tl prlveho soxumi stekuimtel`, e`giuhe`b wfeps m`h

 pmhhios. Hs. Mpp. 46, 45, 7: (Oxxxltegm―s sflw prlbrmk, mhvortese`b So`us, tfo ’_itekmto Kmio

Kmsturdmtel` Wystok,‛ Xfo Wtlgarllk Hu`bol` Oxporeo`go (www.stlgarllk.glk), m`h Ae`a

Cur`eturo clr DHWK)1 soo misl Hs. Mpp. = QCeio 6, 4>8:-7>=8 (sflwe`b rostrme`ts, pmhhios, sox

swe`bs, m`h HSHs)[. Xfoso hovegos m`h etoks mro lc tfo ae`h glkkl`iy slih e` Hmiims-mrom

mhuit dllastlros.

3.  Xfo Gety Heh @lt Glkket tl Zrlveho m Gl`trmgt clr Oxxxltegm e` 4:=3

3.= Mctor Oxxxltegm Hmiims o`hoh, Kr. Fm`hy oxprossoh fes hosero tl rotur` tl tfo

Gl`vo`tel` Go`tor è 4:=3. Hs. Mpp. ?=, ³ 7:.

3.4 L` Mubust 48, 4:=?, Kr. Fm`hy so`t tfo Gl`vo`tel` Go`tor m clrkmi roquost clr

hmtos clr 4:=3. Hs. Mpp. =?=-=?4. E` tfes roquost, Kr. Fm`hy heh `lt eho`tecy m`y duse`oss

o`tety l` wflso dofmic fo roquostoh hmtos.  Eh .

3.7 Gl`vo`tel` Go`tor stmcc prlvehoh Kr. Fm`hy wetf sovormi to`tmtevo hmtos clr m

 plssedio 4:=3 sflw, dut Kr. Nlf`sl` e`clrkoh Kr. Fm`hy tfmt tfo Gl`vo`tel` Go`tor fmh

sovormi stops tl pursuo doclro tfoy gluih essuo m prlplsoh gl`trmgt clr 4:=3. Zime`tecc―s Mpp.

=221 =6:1 =6=. Kr. Fm`hy e`hegmtoh tfmt fes procorroh hmtos e` 4:=3 woro Kmy 4:-44, m`h fo

msaoh tl do po`geioh e` clr tflso hmtos. Hs. Mpp. ?=, ³ 7:1 67-63.

Gmso 7>=3-gv-::?=7-H Hlguko`t 4: Ceioh :7/4?/=3 Zmbo 4= lc 3: ZmboEH 82:

8/19/2019 Dallas' Response to Exxxotica Lawsuit

22/60

 Hoco`hm`ts― Tospl`so tl Zime`tecc―s Kltel` clr m Zroieke`mry E`nu`gtel` m`h Dreoc  

464:7/?:232= Zmbo | =8

3.8 @l prlplsoh gl`trmgt wms ovor essuoh clr hmtos e` 4:=3. Hs. Mpp. ?=, ³ 7=.

2.  Xfo Gety Glu`gei Mpprlvos tfo Tosliutel`

2.= Mt tfo Codrumry =:, 4:=3 Gety Glu`gei koote`b, kokdors lc tfo Gety Glu`gei

oxpime`oh tfmt Oxxxltegm es m soxumiiy lreo`toh duse`oss ms hoce`oh e` Gfmptor 8=M, m`h

o`glurmboh tfo Gety Glu`gei tl mpprlvo tfo rosliutel` hesmiilwe`b Oxxxltegm mt tfo Gl`vo`tel`

Go`tor, wfegf es e` gilso prlxekety tl roseho`gos, pudieg pmras, m`h m gfurgf. E` mhlpte`b tfo

rosliutel`, m kmnlrety lc tfo Glu`gei seb`mioh tfoer mbrooko`t.

2.4 Kmylr Tmwie`bs― pudieg stmtoko`ts e`hegmto tfmt Gfmptor 8=M mppieos tl

Oxxxltegm. Fo oxpime`oh tfmt Oxxxltegm ’es m duse`oss tfmt pmrtegepmtos è tfo glkkorgo lc sox,

 pime` m`h sekpio,‛ m`h tfmt tfo Gety―s Glho mhhrossos soxumiiy lreo`toh duse`ossos> ’Ro a`lw

flw tl hl soxumiiy lreo`toh duse`ossos e` tfes gety.‛ Hs. Mpp. 84 QCeio 4, ?>46-?>751 =4>=7[.

2.7 Glu`gei Kokdor KgBlubf, mppiye`b tfo im`bumbo lc Gfmptor 8=M, oxpiegetiy

gl`giuhoh tfmt et mppieos tl Oxxxltegm. ’Ms wo illa mt tfo WLD lrhe`m`go, E tfe`a et es mdsliutoiy

giomr tfmt tfes pmrteguimr duse`oss‛ es glvoroh. Hs. Mpp. 84 QCeio 4, =8>?2-=?>=:[. Fo spogecegmiiy

okpfmsezoh tfo im`bumbo mt tfo o`h lc tfo ’soxumiiy lreo`toh duse`oss‛ hoce`etel` e` § 8=M-

4(7=)>

’lr ltfor glkkorgemi o`torpreso tfo prekmry duse`oss lc wfegf es tfo lccore`b lc msorvego lr tfo soiie`b, ro`te`b, lr oxfedete`b lc hovegos lr m`y ltfor etoks e`to`hohtl prlveho soxumi stekuimtel` lr soxumi brmtecegmtel` tl tfo gustlkor.‛ Ec ylu illamt tfo vehols crlk imst yomr―s Hmiims ovo`t, ylu soo oxmgtiy tfes typo lc dofmvelr . Esoo `l mrbuko`t tfmt tfes es `lt m soxumiiy lreo`toh duse`oss lrhe`m`go lurlrhe`m`go.

Hs. Mpp. 84 QCeio 4, =?>4:-=?>?=[.

2.8 Xfo Gety Glu`gei vltoh tl mpprlvo Tosliutel` =3:7:6, wfegf ’herogts tfo Gety

Km`mbor tl `lt o`tor e`tl m gl`trmgt wetf Xfroo Oxpl Ovo`ts, IIG clr tfo iomso lc tfo Hmiims

Gl`vo`tel` Go`tor.‛ Hs. Mpp. 84 QCeio 4, =>:=-=>:4>73[1 Hat. = mt 43.

Gmso 7>=3-gv-::?=7-H Hlguko`t 4: Ceioh :7/4?/=3 Zmbo 44 lc 3: ZmboEH 82=

8/19/2019 Dallas' Response to Exxxotica Lawsuit

23/60

 Hoco`hm`ts― Tospl`so tl Zime`tecc―s Kltel` clr m Zroieke`mry E`nu`gtel` m`h Dreoc  

464:7/?:232= Zmbo | =?

D.  Xfo Hmiims Woxumiiy Lreo`toh Duse`oss Lrhe`m`go

6.  Xfo O`mgtko`t lc tfo Lrhe`m`go

6.= L` Nu`o =4, =563, tfo Hmiims Gety Mttlr`oy proso`toh m prlplsoh lrhe`m`go

robuimte`b soxumiiy lreo`toh duse`ossos tl tfo Hmiims Gety Zim` Glkkessel`.  Hukms v. Gety lc

 Hmiims, 386 C. Wupp. =:3=, =:38 (@.H. Xox. =563). Xfo Gety Mttlr`oy lc Hmiims mt tfmt teko wms

Ks. M`miosieo Ku`gy. Hs. Mpp. 355, ³ 4. Xfo Glkkessel` gl`sehoroh stuheos gmrreoh lut dy mt

iomst tfroo ltfor geteos  ‗  Muste`, E`hem`mplies m`h Ils M`boios.  Hukms, 386 C. Wupp. mt =:38.

Cuii glpeos lc tfoso stuheos mro mttmgfoh mt Hs. Mpp. 274-524. Xfo Glkkessel` misl fomrh

tostekl`y m`h vltoh u`m`eklusiy tl roglkko`h mhlptel` lc tfo prlplsoh lrhe`m`go.  Hukms,

386 C. Wupp. mt =:38.

6.4 L` Nu`o =6, =563, tfo prlplsoh lrhe`m`go wo`t doclro tfo Hmiims Gety Glu`gei.

 Eh . Mctor fomre`b tfo pudieg glkko`t  ‗   u`m`eklusiy e` cmvlr lc tfo lrhe`m`go  ‗   tfo Gety

Glu`gei mhlptoh tfo prlplsoh lrhe`m`go dy m u`m`eklus vlto.  Eh . M gorteceoh glpy lc tfmt

lrhe`m`go, Lrhe`m`go @l. =5=53, gm` do clu`h mt Hs. Mpp. 3?:-322. Dltf tfo Zim` Glkkessel`

m`h tfo Gety Glu`gei mpprlvoh tfo lrhe`m`go dy m u`m`eklus vlto.  Hukms, 386 C. Wupp. mt

=:38. Xfo Gety o`mgtoh tfo WLD lrhe`m`go pursum`t tl ets flko ruio mutflrety.

6.7 Xfo lrebe`mi WLD lrhe`m`go wms ekkohemtoiy gfmiio`boh e` glurt, m`h, mctor

vmrelus mko`hko`ts tl ets iego`se`b prlvesel`s, fms doo` clu`h tl do gl`stetutel`miiy slu`h.

 Hukms v. Gety lc Hmiims, 386 C. Wupp. =:3= (@.H. Xox. =563) mccerkoh dy  CR/ZDW, E`g. v. Gety

lc Hmiims, 672 C.4h =456 (?tf Ger. =566)1 mccerkoh e` pmrt, rovorsoh e` pmrt, vmgmtoh e` pmrt, m`h

rokm`hoh dy CR/ZDW, E`g. v. Gety lc Hmiims, 857 _.W. 4=? (=55:)1 Hs. Mpp. 355-2::, ³ 81 Dmdy

 Hliis Xlpioss Wmill`s, E`g. v. Gety lc Hmiims, ==8 C. Wupp. 4h ?7= (@.H. Xox. 4:::), mcc―h. 45?

C.7h 82= (?tf Ger. 4::4).

5.  Xfo Iobesimtevo E`to`t lc tfo Lrhe`m`go

Gmso 7>=3-gv-::?=7-H Hlguko`t 4: Ceioh :7/4?/=3 Zmbo 47 lc 3: ZmboEH 824

8/19/2019 Dallas' Response to Exxxotica Lawsuit

24/60

 Hoco`hm`ts― Tospl`so tl Zime`tecc―s Kltel` clr m Zroieke`mry E`nu`gtel` m`h Dreoc  

464:7/?:232= Zmbo | =3

5.= E`  Hukms, Nuhbo Dugfkoyor gl`hugtoh m hotmeioh roveow lc tfo Gety―s WLD

lrhe`m`go m`h gl`giuhoh tfmt tfo e`to`t lc dltf tfo Glkkessel` m`h tfo Gety Glu`gei e` mhlpte`b

tfo lrhe`m`go wms ’trm`spmro`tiy giomr.‛  Hukms, 386 C. Wupp. mt =:38. Fo clu`h tfmt tfo Gety―s

lrhe`m`go wms mhlptoh clr tfo gl`to`t-`outrmi purplso lc gl`trliie`b tfo `obmtevo sogl`hmry

occogts lc soxumiiy lreo`toh duse`ossos.  Eh . mt =:33.2 

5.4 Nuhbo Dugfkoyor curtfor `ltoh tfmt omgf lc tfo tfroo stuheos wfegf woro

gl`sehoroh dy dltf tfo Zim` Glkkessel` m`h tfo Gety Glu`gei (Muste`, E`hem`mplies m`h Ils

M`boios) gmko tl tfo gl`giusel` tfmt soxumiiy lreo`toh duse`ossos woro msslgemtoh wetf rese`b

`oebfdlrfllh greko rmtos m`h hrlppe`b `oebfdlrfllh prlporty vmiuos.  Eh . Fo curtfor `ltoh tfmt

ltfor stuheos, dltf tflso oxpiegetiy roieoh l` dy tfo hrmctors m`h tflso `lt usoh, gmko tl sekeimr

gl`giusel`s. (rocorre`b tl stuheos crlk Flustl`, Domukl`t, Mkmreiil, Zflo`ex, Ims Sobms m`h

Womttio).  Eh . Cuii glpeos lc tfo Flustl`, Domukl`t, Mkmreiil, m`h Zflo`ex stuheos mro mttmgfoh

mt Hs. Mpp. 527-=:?4.

5.7 Nuhbo Dugfkoyor stmtoh ’klst ekplrtm`tiy, tfo stuhy porclrkoh lc m sogtel` lc

Hmiims…hotorke`oh tfmt greko e` m` mrom hlke`mtoh dy soxumiiy lreo`toh duse`oss wms 5 :

 porgo`t febfor tfm` e` tfo Gety ms m wflio.  Eh .

5.8 Nuhbo Dugfkoyor `ltoh tfmt dltf tfo Zim` Glkkessel` m`h tfo Gety Glu`gei

stmtoh tfmt tfoy woro gl`gor`oh `lt wetf tfo gl`to`t lc tfo spoogf msslgemtoh wetf soxumiiy

lreo`toh duse`ossos, dut wetf tfo greko, urdm` diebft, m`h piukkote`b prlporty vmiuos tfmt

e`ovetmdiy soezo tfo `oebfdlrfllhs wforo sugf duse`ossos ilgmto.  Hukms, 386 C. Wupp. mt =:3?.

Fo spogecegmiiy qultoh Zime`tecc―s iomh glu`soi, Kr. Midrebft, wfl wms mt tfmt teko m kokdor lc

tfo Zim` Glkkessel`, wfl stmtoh ’et es`―t tfo prlhugt etsoic tfmt wo―ro mttokpte`b tl mhhross foro,

2 Nuhbo Dugfkoyor clu`h tfmt tfo giomr e`to`t lc tfo hrmctor lc tfo lrhe`m`go, Ks. Ku`gy, wms gl`stetutel`mi.  Eh . mt=:3?, c`. =:.

Gmso 7>=3-gv-::?=7-H Hlguko`t 4: Ceioh :7/4?/=3 Zmbo 48 lc 3: ZmboEH 827

8/19/2019 Dallas' Response to Exxxotica Lawsuit

25/60

 Hoco`hm`ts― Tospl`so tl Zime`tecc―s Kltel` clr m Zroieke`mry E`nu`gtel` m`h Dreoc  

464:7/?:232= Zmbo | =2

 dut rmtfor et―s tfo prldioks tfmt mro gmusoh dy m gortme` typo lc duse`oss‛ m`h ’tfo gl`to`t fms

mdsliutoiy `ltfe`b tl hl wetf et.‛  Hukms, mt cllt`lto 6.6  Nuhbo Dugfkoyor gl`giuhoh tfmt tfo

e`to`t lc tfo Gety e` pmsse`b tfo WLD lrhe`m`go ’wms slioiy tl gl`trli tfo sogl`hmry occogts lc

soxumiiy lreo`toh spoogf l` tfo `oebfdlrfllhs ets purvoylrs e`fmdet, rmtfor tfm` tl oieke`mto tfo

spoogf etsoic.‛  Eh . mt =:33. Osso`temiiy, Nuhbo Dugfkoyor gl`giuhoh tfmt tfo Gety stmtoko`t lc

 purplso m`h e`to`t wms klro tfm` koro wlrhs ‗  fo clu`h tfmt et wms truo.5 

=:.  Xfo Hmiims Gety Glu`gei―s Iobesimtevo Ce`he`bs lc Cmgt e` Wupplrt lc tfo

Hmiims WLD Lrhe`m`go

5.= Xfo Hmiims Gety Glu`gei, dmsoh l` ets iobesimtevo roglrh e`giuhe`b stuheos m`h

tostekl`y, kmho iobesimtevo ce`he`bs lc cmgt wetf robmrh tl soxumiiy lreo`toh ostmdiesfko`ts. Xfo

Glu`gei clu`h tfmt et fmh flko ruio mutflrety tl iego`so duse`ossos m`h tl o`clrgo mii lrhe`m`gos

`ogossmry tl prltogt fomitf, ieco, m`h prlporty. Et clu`h tfmt iobetekmto romsl`s oxest tl robuimto

soxumiiy lreo`toh duse`ossos. Hs. Mpp. 3?:-3?3.

==.  Xfo Hmiims Gety Glu`gei―s Iobesimtevo Ce`he`bs lc Cmgt Tobmrhe`b tfo

Iego`se`b lc WLDs

==. = Xfo Hmiims Gety Glu`gei misl clu`h tfmt, ’et es e` tfo e`torost lc tfo pudieg smcoty

m`h woicmro tl prlfedet porsl`s gl`vegtoh lc gortme` grekos crlk o`bmbe`b e` tfo lggupmtel` lc

lpormte`b m soxumiiy lreo`toh duse`oss.‛ Hs. Mpp. 3?8.

6 Ms m rosuit lc fes prelr tostekl`y, Kr. Midrebft es u`equoiy u`mdio tl subbost tfmt tfo Gety―s e`to`t tlwmrh soxumiiylreo`toh duse`oss e`vlivos e`to`tel`mi gl`to`t-dmsoh hesgreke`mtel`.5 ’GFMZXOT 8=M. WOV_MIIU LTEO@XOH D_WE@OWWOW

Wog. 8=M-=. Z_TZLWO M@H E@XO@X(m) Et es tfo purplso lc tfes gfmptor tl robuimto soxumiiy lreo`toh duse`ossos tl prlklto tfo fomitf,

smcoty, klrmis, m`h bo`ormi woicmro lc tfo getezo`s lc tfo gety, m`h tl ostmdiesf romsl`mdio m`h u`eclrk robuimtel`s tl provo`t tfo gl`te`uoh gl`go`trmtel` lc soxumiiy lreo`toh duse`ossos wetfe` tfo gety. Xfo prlvesel`s lc tfes gfmptorfmvo `oetfor tfo purplso `lr occogt lc ekplse`b m ieketmtel` lr rostregtel` l` tfo gl`to`t lc m`y glkku`egmtevokmtoremis, e`giuhe`b soxumiiy lreo`toh kmtoremis. Wekeimriy, et es `lt tfo e`to`t `lr occogt lc tfes Gfmptor tl rostregt lrho`y mggoss dy mhuits tl soxumiiy lreo`toh kmtoremis prltogtoh dy tfo Cerst Mko`hko`t, lr tl ho`y mggoss dy tfohestredutlrs m`h oxfedetlrs lc soxumiiy lreo`toh o`tortme`ko`t tl tfoer e`to`hoh kmraot.

(d) Et es tfo e`to`t lc tfo gety glu`gei tfmt tfo ilgmtel`mi robuimtel`s lc Wogtel` 8=M-=7 lc tfes gfmptormro prlkuibmtoh pursum`t tl Mrtegio 4724w, Tovesoh Gevei Wtmtutos lc Xoxms, ms tfoy mppiy tl `uho klhoi stuhelsm`h soxumi o`glu`tor go`tors l`iy. Et es tfo e`to`t lc tfo gety glu`gei tfmt mii ltfor prlvesel`s lc tfes gfmptor mro prlkuibmtoh pursum`t tl tfo Hmiims Gety Gfmrtor m`h Mrtegio ==2?, Tovesoh Gevei Wtmtutos lc Xoxms.

Gmso 7>=3-gv-::?=7-H Hlguko`t 4: Ceioh :7/4?/=3 Zmbo 4? lc 3: ZmboEH 828

8/19/2019 Dallas' Response to Exxxotica Lawsuit

26/60

 Hoco`hm`ts― Tospl`so tl Zime`tecc―s Kltel` clr m Zroieke`mry E`nu`gtel` m`h Dreoc  

464:7/?:232= Zmbo | =6

=4.  @l Oxokptel` Oxests clr m Xokplrmry Woxumiiy Lreo`toh Duse`oss

=4.= Xfo WLD lrhe`m`go hlos `lt `lw, m`h `ovor fms, e`giuhoh m`y oxokptel` clr m

glkkorgemi o`torpreso tfmt koots tfo soxumiiy lreo`toh duse`oss hoce`etel`, dut lpormtos mt m

ilgmtel` clr l`iy m sflrt porelh lc teko. Rfo` tfo WLD lrhe`m`go wms o`mgtoh, et wms `ovor

gl`tokpimtoh tfmt tfo WLD lrhe`m`go wluih `lt mppiy tl m ’tokplrmry soxumiiy lreo`toh

 duse`oss uso,‛ wfegf es `lt m hoce`oh tork e` tfo Gety―s Glho. E` cmgt, sugf m` e`torprotmtel`

wluih fmvo u`horke`oh tfo e`to`t m`h occogt lc tfo lrhe`m`go, dy o`mdie`b WLDs mt m`y ilgmtel`

wetflut robuimtel`, sl il`b ms m` lpormtlr gluih hokl`strmto tfmt tfo uso wms ’tokplrmry.‛ Hs.

Mpp. 355 QM. Ku`gy Mcct. ³ 7[.

S.

MTB_KO@XW M@H M_XFLTEXEOW 

Zime`tecc fms ieketoh tfo dmses l` wfegf fo sooas m proieke`mry e`nu`gtel` tl tfo `mrrlw,

m`h kestmao`, mssortel` tfmt tfo Gety―s mgtel` e` pmsse`b Tosliutel` =3:7:6  gl`stetutos m prelr

rostrme`t e` velimtel` lc tfo Cerst Mko`hko`t.=:  Flwovor, huo tl Zime`tecc―s lw` gl`hugt e`

gl``ogtel` wetf Oxxxltegm, tfo Glurt `ooh `lt, m`h sfluih `lt, romgf Zime`tecc―s ieketoh

gl`stetutel`mi quostel`. Dogmuso tfo Gety fms iobetekmto, `l`hesgreke`mtlry romsl`s clr gfllse`b

`lt tl o`bmbo e` curtfor glkkorgo wetf Zime`tecc, tfo Glurt sfluih ho`y Zime`tecc―s kltel` clr

 proieke`mry e`nu`gtel`.

M.  Xfo Hlgtre`o lc Gl`stetutel`mi Mvlehm`go.

’M cu`hmko`tmi m`h il`bstm`he`b pre`gepio lc nuhegemi rostrme`t roqueros tfmt glurts mvleh

romgfe`b gl`stetutel`mi quostel`s e` mhvm`go lc tfo `ogossety lc hogehe`b tfok.‛  Iy`b v.

 @lrtfwost E`hem` Gokotory Zrltogtevo Mss―`, 86? _.W. 875, 88?-883 (=566), gete`b Xfroo

=:  Mitflubf tfo Zime`tecc―s dreoc ko`tel`s essuos wfegf mro doyl`h tfo sglpo lc tfo kltel`, sugf ms veowple`thesgreke`mtel`, tflso ltfor essuos mro `lt prlporiy doclro tfo Glurt m`h fmvo doo` wmevoh clr purplsos lc Zime`tecc―skltel`. Flwovor, lut lc m` mdu`hm`go lc gmutel`, m`h wetflut wmeve`b tfoer gl`to`tel` tfmt tflso mhhetel`mi essuosfmvo doo` wmevoh, Hoco`hm`ts weii mhhross tflso ltfor essuos.

Gmso 7>=3-gv-::?=7-H Hlguko`t 4: Ceioh :7/4?/=3 Zmbo 43 lc 3: ZmboEH 82?

8/19/2019 Dallas' Response to Exxxotica Lawsuit

27/60

 Hoco`hm`ts― Tospl`so tl Zime`tecc―s Kltel` clr m Zroieke`mry E`nu`gtel` m`h Dreoc  

464:7/?:232= Zmbo | =5

 Mcceiemtoh Xredos lc Ct. Dortflih Tosorvmtel` v. Rlih O`be`oore`b, Z.G., 832 _.W. =76, =?2 ‗ =?6

(=568)1 soo misl Zomrsl` v. Gmiimfm`, ??? _.W. 447, 48= (4::5) (Et es weso nuhegemi glu`soi ’‖`lt

tl pmss l` quostel`s lc gl`stetutel`miety...u`ioss sugf mhnuhegmtel` es u`mvlehmdio.――‛ (getmtel`s

lkettoh))1 Toegfio v. Flwmrhs, =74 W.Gt. 4:66, 4:57 (4:=4), gete`b Zomrsl`, Gmkrotm v. Broo`o,

=7= W.Gt. 4:4:, 4:7: ‗ 4:7= (4:==), m`h  Msfgrlct v. mi-Aehh , =7= W.Gt. 4:28, 4:6: (4:==). Ec m

gmso gm` do hogehoh l` `l`-gl`stetutel`mi brlu`hs glurts sfluih hl sl m`h sfluih mvleh tfo

gl`stetutel`mi quostel`.  Iy`b , 86? _.W. mt 88?-8831 soo misl, Flhbo v. Zre`go, 27: C. Wupp. 282,

285 (@.H. Xox. =55:) gete`b Iy`b  m`h Ohwmrh N. HoDmrtlil Glrp. v. @.I.T.D., 837 _.W. =82, =?6

(=567). 

E` tfes gmso, Zime`tecc es e` `l plsetel` tl ldtme` tfo oxtrmlrhe`mry oquetmdio roieoc fo sooas

 dogmuso fo kmho ropomtoh, seb`ecegm`t kesroproso`tmtel`s tl tfo Gety e` gl`nu`gtel` wetf

Oxxxltegm Hmiims wfegf tlla pimgo e` tfo Gety―s Gl`vo`tel` Go`tor e` 4:=?. Ms weii do

oxpime`oh e` bromtor hotmei doilw, Zime`tecc crmuhuio`tiy kesroproso`toh tfo stmtus lc tfo miioboh

 duse`oss o`tety l` wflso dofmic fo seb`oh m gl`trmgt tl iomso tfo Gl`vo`tel` Go`tor. Curtfor,

mctor roproso`te`b tfmt Oxxxltegm heh `lt e`vlivo iowh dofmvelr m`h tfmt fo wluih e`suro tfmt mii

oxfedetlrs m`h mtto`hoos wluih glkpiy wetf mii mppiegmdio imws, fo e` cmgt porkettoh fes

oxfedetlrs m`h mtto`hoos tl o`bmbo e` kuitepio e`stm`gos lc pudieg iowh`oss. Ce`miiy, Zime`tecc

o`bmboh e` kuitepio velimtel`s lc tfo torks lc fes mbrooko`t wetf tfo Gety.

Xfoso romsl`s e`hopo`ho`tiy, m`h tlbotfor,  nustecy tfo Gety―s hogesel`  `lt tl seb` m

sogl`h gl`trmgt clr Oxxxltegm. Mitflubf, lut lc m` mdu`hm`go lc gmutel`, tfo Gety weii mhhross

gl`stetutel`mi imw quostel`s, Hoco`hm`ts urbo tfo Glurt tl cliilw tfo woii-ostmdiesfoh ruio lc

gl`stetutel`mi mvlehm`go m`h hogie`o tl hogeho tfo gl`stetutel`mi essuo rmesoh dy Zime`tecc.

D.  Zroieke`mry E`nu`gtel` Wtm`hmrh

Gmso 7>=3-gv-::?=7-H Hlguko`t 4: Ceioh :7/4?/=3 Zmbo 42 lc 3: ZmboEH 823

8/19/2019 Dallas' Response to Exxxotica Lawsuit

28/60

 Hoco`hm`ts― Tospl`so tl Zime`tecc―s Kltel` clr m Zroieke`mry E`nu`gtel` m`h Dreoc  

464:7/?:232= Zmbo | 4:

M proieke`mry e`nu`gtel` es m` oxtrmlrhe`mry rokohy tfmt sfluih `lt do brm`toh u`ioss tfo

klvm`t fms giomriy gmrreoh tfo durho` lc porsumsel` l` mii clur roqueroko`ts.  Ho``es Koim`gl`,

 E`g. v. Gety lc @ow Lriom`s, 2:7 C.7h 434, 436 (?tf Ger. 4:=4) (gete`b  Zim``oh Zmro`tfllh Mss―`

lc Fehmibl Glu`ty Xox., E`g. v. Wuofs, 354 C.7h 787, 786 (?tf Ger. 4:=4)). Xfo roqueroko`ts clr

m proieke`mry e`nu`gtel` mro ms cliilws>

=. M sudstm`temi ieaoiefllh tfmt pime`tecc weii provmei l` tfo korets1

4. M sudstm`temi tfromt tfmt pime`tecc weii succor erropmrmdio e`nury ec tfo e`nu`gtel` es`lt brm`toh1

7. Xfmt tfo tfromt m`h e`nury tl pime`tecc lutwoebfs tfo tfromt m`h fmrk tfo e`nu`gtel`

kmy hl tl tfo hoco`hm`t1 m`h

8. Xfmt brm`te`b tfo proieke`mry e`nu`gtel` weii `lt hessorvo tfo pudieg e`torost.

COH. T.  GES. Z. 3?1  Nmgasl` Rlko`―s Fomitf Lrbm`ezmtel` v. Gurreor , 23: C.7h 886, 8?4 (?tf

Ger. 4:=8) (getmtel` lkettoh)1 soo misl Ho``es Koim`gl`, E`g., 2:7 C.7h mt 436. M pime`tecc wfl

gm``lt provmei l` m`y l`o lc tfo roqueroko`ts es `lt o`tetioh tl e`nu`gtevo roieoc. Woo COH. T. GES. 

Z.  3?.  ’M proieke`mry e`nu`gtel` ‖es  m` oxtrmlrhe`mry m`h hrmsteg rokohy, `lt tl do brm`toh

rlute`oiy, dut l`iy wfo` tfo klvm`t, dy m giomr sflwe`b, gmrreos tfo durho` lc porsumsel`.―‛

 @XT Duiiel` Brlup, IIG v. Iedorty Kotmis Brlup, IIG , @l. 7>=7 ‗ GS ‗ 758? ‗ H, 4:=7 RI

?3723:= *4 (@.H. Xox. 4:=7) qulte`b Nl`os v. Dusf, =44 C. Wupp. 4h 2=7, 2=6 (@.H. Xox. 4:::)

qulte`b Rfeto v. Gmriugge, 634 C.4h =4:5, =4== (?tf Ger. =565)1  Fliim`h Mk. E`s. Gl. v.

Wuggossel` lc Tly, 222 C.4h 554, 552 (?tf Ger. =56?)).  ’Xfo hogesel` tl brm`t m proieke`mry

e`nu`gtel` es tl do tromtoh ms tfo oxgoptel` rmtfor tfm` tfo ruio.‛  Kess. Zlwor & Iebft Gl. v.

_`etoh Bms Zepo Ie`o Gl., 23: C.4h 3=6 (?tf Ger. =56?)1  @XT Duiiel` Brlup, @l. 7>=7 ‗ GS ‗ 

758? ‗ H, 4:=7 RI ?3723:= mt *4, gete`b  Kess. Zlwor & Iebft Gl., 23: C.4h mt 34= (getmtel`s

lkettoh).

Gmso 7>=3-gv-::?=7-H Hlguko`t 4: Ceioh :7/4?/=3 Zmbo 46 lc 3: ZmboEH 822

8/19/2019 Dallas' Response to Exxxotica Lawsuit

29/60

 Hoco`hm`ts― Tospl`so tl Zime`tecc―s Kltel` clr m Zroieke`mry E`nu`gtel` m`h Dreoc  

464:7/?:232= Zmbo | 4=

G.  Zime`tecc Gm``lt Giomriy Ostmdiesf M Wudstm`temi Ieaoiefllh lc Wuggoss l` tfo

Korets.

Zime`tecc gm``lt giomriy ostmdiesf m sudstm`temi ieaoiefllh lc suggoss l` tfo korets lc fes

`mrrlw gimek dogmuso kuitepio, glkpoiie`b, iobetekmto `l`hesgreke`mtlry romsl`s supplrt tfo

Gety―s hogesel`. Xfo Gety fms bllh-cmetf, imwcui, gl`stetutel`mi romsl`s tl oxorgeso ets croohlk tl

hogie`o tl o`tor e`tl m sogl`h gl`trmgt wetf Zime`tecc. Xfoso romsl`s e`giuho crmuh, grekos, dromgf

lc gl`trmgt, m`h velimtel`s lc tfo Gety―s lrhe`m`go. Mhhetel`miiy, Zime`tecc gm``lt giomriy

ostmdiesf m sudstm`temi ieaoiefllh lc suggoss l` tfo korets lc fes gl`stetutel`mi gimek dogmuso tfo

Gety heh `lt o`bmbo e` m prelr rostrme`t lr veowple`t hesgreke`mtel`.

=. 

Zime`tecc ―s _`giom` Fm`hs Zrogiuhos Ets O`tetioko`t tl Oquetmdio Toieoc .

’Xfo hlgtre`o lc u`giom` fm`hs ‖gilsos tfo hllrs lc m glurt lc oquety tl l`o tme`toh wetf

e`oquetmdio`oss lr dmh cmetf roimtevo tl tfo kmttor e` wfegf fo sooas roieoc.―‛  Fomitfple`t, Ith., v.

 Otfox Glrp., 427 C. Wupp. 4h 6=2, 682 (R.H. Xox. 4::=), qulte`b Zrogesel` E`struko`t Kcb. Gl.

v. Mutl. Kme`t. Kmgf. Gl., 748 _.W. 6:3, 6=8 (=58?). ’‖M`y weiicui mgt gl`gor`e`b tfo gmuso lc

mgtel` wfegf rebftcuiiy gm` do smeh tl trm`sbross oquetmdio stm`hmrhs lc gl`hugt es succegeo`t

gmuso― clr tfo glurt tl e`vlao tfo hlgtre`o.‛  Fomitfple`t , 427 C. Wupp. 4h mt 682, qulte`b

 Zrogesel` E`struko`t Kcb., 748 _.W. mt 6=?. ’Xfo wrl`bcui mgts upl` wfegf tfo gimek  lc

u`giom` fm`hs es prokesoh kust ‖e` slko komsuro mccogt tfo oquetmdio roimtel`s dotwoo` tfo

 pmrteos e` rospogt lc slkotfe`b drlubft doclro tfo glurt lc mhnuhegmtel`.―‛   Fomitfple`t , 427 C.

Wupp. 4h mt 682, qulte`b Ketgfoii Drls. Ceik Brlup v. Ge`okm Mhuit Xfomtor , 3:8 C.7h 6?4, 637

(?tf Ger. =525). Mppieoh tl proieke`mry e`nu`gtel`s, tfo hlgtre`o lc u`giom` fm`hs ’mcclrhs tfo

oquety glurt drlmh hesgrotel` e` ronogte`b m` u`giom` ietebm`t―s gimeks.‛  Fomitfple`t , 427 C.

Wupp. 4h mt 686.

Gmso 7>=3-gv-::?=7-H Hlguko`t 4: Ceioh :7/4?/=3 Zmbo 45 lc 3: ZmboEH 826

8/19/2019 Dallas' Response to Exxxotica Lawsuit

30/60

8/19/2019 Dallas' Response to Exxxotica Lawsuit

31/60

 Hoco`hm`ts― Tospl`so tl Zime`tecc―s Kltel` clr m Zroieke`mry E`nu`gtel` m`h Dreoc  

464:7/?:232= Zmbo | 47

XOV. D_W. & GLK. GLHO § 42.:=1 E` ro Dmso Flihe`bs, IIG , @l. 7>== ‗ GS ‗ 7?7= ‗ H, 4:=? RI

=6:6?73 mt *8.

Crmuhuio`t e`hugoko`t es m typo lc glkkl`-imw crmuh mrese`b e` tfo gl`toxt lc m gl`trmgt,

m`h tfo oxesto`go lc m gl`trmgt es `ogossmry tl ostmdiesf m gimek.  E` ro Dmso Flihe`bs, IIG , @l.

7>== ‗ GS ‗ 7?7= ‗ H, 4:=? RI =6:6?73 mt *8, gete`b Fmmso v. Bimz`or , 34 W.R.7h 25?, 256 (Xox.

4::=). Xfo oioko`ts lc tfes typo lc crmuh e`giuho ’(=) tfmt tfo spomaor kmho m kmtoremi

kesroproso`tmtel` (4) tfmt fo a`ow wms cmiso wfo` fo kmho et lr tfmt fo kmho rogaiossiy wetflut

m`y a`lwiohbo lc ets trutf m`h ms m plsetevo mssortel` (7) wetf tfo e`to`t tfmt tfo ltfor pmrty mgt

upl` et m`h (8) tfmt tfo ltfor pmrty mgtoh e` roiem`go l` tfo kesroproso`tmtel` m`h (?) succoroh

e`nury tforody.‛  E` ro Dmso Flihe`bs, IIG , @l. 7>== ‗ GS ‗ 7?7= ‗ H, 4:=? RI =6:6?73 mt *8,

gete`b Etmiem` Glwdly Zmrt`ors, Ith. v. Zruho`temi E`s. Gl. lc Mk., 78= W.R.7h 747, 772 (Xox.

4:==). ’M roproso`tmtel` es kmtoremi ec ‖m romsl`mdio porsl` wluih mttmgf ekplrtm`go tl Qet[ m`h

wluih do e`hugoh tl mgt l` tfo e`clrkmtel` e` hotorke`e`b fes gflego lc mgtel`s e` tfo trm`smgtel`

e` quostel`.―‛ Eh ., gete`b Etmiem` Glwdly, 78= W.R.7h mt 772 (getmtel` lkettoh).

Zime`tecc glkkettoh dltf stmtutlry crmuh m`h crmuhuio`t e`hugoko`t wfo`, mctor rogoeve`b

tfo Gl`vo`tel` Go`tor―s prlplsoh gl`trmgt clr Zime`tecc―s 4:=? iomso clr Oxxxltegm, wfegf iestoh

’Xfroo Oxpl Ovo`ts‛ ms tfo usor lc tfo Gl`vo`tel` Go`tor, Kr. Fm`hy oxpime`oh tfmt ’Qw[o

hoce`etoiy `ooh tfo gl`trmgt wretto` tl Oxltegm Xoxms, IIG…iobmiiy Oxltegm Xoxms, IIG es tfo

glkpm`y gl`trmgte`b tfo spmgo‛ mitflubf Oxltegm Xoxms IIG heh `lt mgtumiiy oxest. Hs. Mpp.

=87-=831 suprm mt ³ 4.7. Ms Fm`hy foih feksoic lut tl do m ’Herogtlr‛ lc Oxltegm Xoxms, IIG,

fo fmh porsl`mi a`lwiohbo tfmt tfo o`tety heh `lt oxest. Zime`tecc―s Mpp. =:=-=:6. Zime`tecc

ldvelusiy e`to`hoh tfmt tfo Gety roiy l` ets roproso`tmtel` mdlut Oxltegm Xoxms, IIG e` o`tore`b

e`tl m gl`trmgt clr tfo iomso lc tfo Gl`vo`tel` Go`tor, m`h tfo Gety heh e` cmgt roiy l` Zime`tecc―s 

Gmso 7>=3-gv-::?=7-H Hlguko`t 4: Ceioh :7/4?/=3 Zmbo 7= lc 3: ZmboEH 86:

8/19/2019 Dallas' Response to Exxxotica Lawsuit

32/60

 Hoco`hm`ts― Tospl`so tl Zime`tecc―s Kltel` clr m Zroieke`mry E`nu`gtel` m`h Dreoc  

464:7/?:232= Zmbo | 48

crmuhuio`t roproso`tmtel` wfo` et mggoptoh m`h glu`torseb`oh tfo Gl`vo`tel` Go`tor iomso

gl`trmgt wfegf Zime`tecc fmh seb`oh l` dofmic lc tfo `l`-oxesto`t Oxltegm Xoxms, IIG.  Eh . Xfo

Gety wms e`nuroh ms m rosuit lc tfo kesroproso`tmtel` dogmuso et miilwoh m` ovo`t tl tmao pimgo e`

tfo Gl`vo`tel` Go`tor dmsoh l` tfo seb`mturo lc m purplrtoh glrplrmto o`tety tfmt hlos `lt

oxest.== 

Ec Oxltegm Xoxms, IIG fmh oxestoh, et wms roqueroh dy imw tl robestor etsoic e` Xoxms e`

lrhor tl trm̀ smgt duse`oss e` 4:=?. XOV.  D_W.  LTB.  GLHO  §§ 5.::=, 5.::8, 5.::?.=4  Oxltegm

Xoxms, IIG wms `lt robestoroh e` Xoxms, lr m`ywforo oiso e` tfo _`etoh Wtmtos. Wuprm mt 4.3.

d. 

Zime`tecc Wfluih @lt Ldtme` Oquetmdio Toieoc Dogmuso Et TopomtohiyMiilwoh Greke`mi Mgtevety tl Lggur mt Oxxxltegm

(=)  Selimtel`s lc Wtmto Imw

Mitflubf Zime`tecc fmh mbrooh tl o`suro tfmt tfo oxfedetlrs m`h mtto`hoos lc Oxxxltegm

wluih glkpiy wetf mii stmto imws, (Zime`tecc―s Mpp. =:8, ³ 461 Zime`tecc―s Mpp. =6-=5, ³ ==1 Hs.

Mpp. ===) m`h mitflubf Zime`tecc mhkets tfmt fo mbrooh tfmt ’`l Zo`mi Glho lcco`sos sugf

ms…pudieg iowh`oss…wluih do porkettoh‛ (Hat. = mt =:, ³ 2), e` cmgt, kuitepio velimtel`s lc imw,

e`giuhe`b kuitepio roglrhoh e`stm`gos lc pudieg iowh`oss dy Oxxxltegm oxfedetlrs, tlla pimgo

hure`b Oxxxltegm Hmiims. Wuprm mt ³³ 8.=-8.71 Hs. Mpp. = QCeio =, :>?8-=>:81 Ceio 4, :>?:-=>=:1

Ceio 7, :>:=-:>:7 m`h :>4=-:>4?1 Ceio 8 :>8?-:>?2 m`h =>=?-=>4:[1 Hs. Mpp. =?8, Q³ 8[1 =?6, Q³ 5[1

=52, Q³³ 8-?[1 =55-4:81 86, Q³³ =7-=?[.

Mhhetel`miiy, twl mrrosts woro kmho mt Oxxxltegm, e`giuhe`b l`o wfegf gfmrboh m pmtrl`

lc Oxxxltegm wetf mssmuit e` tfo Gl`vo`tel` Go`tor wfo` fo pu`gfoh m prltostlr e` tfo cmgo.

Wuprm mt ³ 8.71 Hs. Mpp. =52, ³ 81 =55-4:4.=7 

== Retf tfo hotmei prlvehoh foroe`, Hoco`hm`ts fmvo glkpieoh wetf tfo roqueroko`ts lc COH. T. GES. Z. 5(d).=4 M ieketoh iemdeiety glkpm`y tfmt trm`smgts duse`oss e` Xoxms wetflut cerst robestore`b etsoic wetf tfo Wogrotmry lcWtmto kmy doglko tfo sudnogt lc gevei po`miteos.  Eh . mt § 5.:?4.

Gmso 7>=3-gv-::?=7-H Hlguko`t 4: Ceioh :7/4?/=3 Zmbo 74 lc 3: ZmboEH 86=

8/19/2019 Dallas' Response to Exxxotica Lawsuit

33/60

 Hoco`hm`ts― Tospl`so tl Zime`tecc―s Kltel` clr m Zroieke`mry E`nu`gtel` m`h Dreoc  

464:7/?:232= Zmbo | 4?

(4)  Selimtel`s lc Hmiims Lrhe`m`gos

Mitflubf Kr. Fm`hy fmh mbrooh tfmt ’ovory okpilyor, mbo`t, m`h porkettoh o`trm`t

gl``ogtoh wetf tfo purplso clr wfegf tfo Zrokesos mro ro`toh, sfmii mdeho dy, gl`clrk tl, m`h

glkpiy wetf mii imws lc tfo _`etoh Wtmtos, tfo Wtmto lc Xoxms, m`h mii lrhe`m`gos lc tfo Gety lc

Hmiims‛ (Zime`tecc―s Mpp. p. =:8 QOxxxltegm Gl`trmgt ³ 46[1 Zime`tecc―s Mpp. pp. =6 -=5 QN. Fm`hy

Hogi. ³ ==[), e` cmgt, Oxxxltegm Hmiims velimtoh Gety lrhe`m`gos roimte`b tl soxumiiy lreo`toh

 duse`ossos. Woo pmrmbrmpfs ?.=-?.=6, mdlvo, clr m tflrlubf oxpim`mtel` lc Oxxxltegm―s velimtel`s

lc Hmiims― WLD lrhe`m`go. 

g.  Zime`tecc Wfluih @lt Ldtme` Oquetmdio Toieoc Dogmuso Et Selimtoh Ets

Mbrooko`t Retf tfo Gety.

Zime`tecc lccoroh `ukorlus, spogeceg roproso`tmtel`s mdlut tfo gl`hugt et wluih `lt porket

mt Oxxxltegm, m`h tfo Gety roieoh l` tfoso roproso`tmtel`s, dut Zime`tecc velimtoh km`y lc tfoso

torks lc ets mbrooko`t wetf tfo Gety. E` iebft lc Zime`tecc―s cmeiuro tl mdeho dy tfo torks lc ets

 provelus gl`trmgt wetf tfo Gety, tfo Glurt sfluih `lt lrhor tfo Gety tl o`tor e`tl m `ow gl`trmgt

wetf Zime`tecc.

Xfo Gety―s rebft tl gl`trmgtumi iedorty es ms cu`hmko`tmi ms Zime`tecc ―s gimek tl oxprossevo

iedorty. Roii doclro tfo Cerst m`h Clurtoo`tf Mko`hko`ts, tfo Gl`stetutel` soguroh gl`trmgtumi

rebfts mbmè st stmto e`cre`boko`t. _.W. GL@WX. mrt. E, §=:, gi.=. Xfes prltogtel` sfeoihoh `lt l`iy

 prevmto dut misl blvor`ko`tmi gl`trmgts.  Ciotgfor v. Zoga , =: _.W. (3 Grm`gf) 62 (=6=:). Ms tfo

Wuproko Glurt `ltoh e` mhnuhegmte`b tfes Gl`trmgts Gimuso, ’wo kust `lt clrbot tfmt tfo

glkku`ety misl fmvo rebfts, m`h tfmt tfo fmppe`oss m`h woii doe`b lc ovory getezo` hopo`hs l`

tfoer cmetfcui prosorvmtel`.‛  Zrlpreotlrs lc Gfmrios Tevor Drehbo v. Zrlpreotlrs lc Rmrro`

 Drehbo, 73 _.W. (== Zot.) 84:, ?86 (=672). Rfeio tfo iottor lc tfo Gl`trmgts Gimuso rostregts stmto

=7 Mhhetel`miiy, l` tfo wooao`h lc Oxxxltegm, `e`o mrrosts woro kmho lc ’Nlf`s‛ wfl rospl`hoh tl mhs pimgoh dytfo HZH l` tfo dmgapmbo.glk wodseto. Wuprm mt ³ 8.8. Xfoso mhs rocoro g̀oh ’Oxxxltegm‛ lr ’Oxxltegm.‛  Eh .

Gmso 7>=3-gv-::?=7-H Hlguko`t 4: Ceioh :7/4?/=3 Zmbo 77 lc 3: ZmboEH 864

8/19/2019 Dallas' Response to Exxxotica Lawsuit

34/60

 Hoco`hm`ts― Tospl`so tl Zime`tecc―s Kltel` clr m Zroieke`mry E`nu`gtel` m`h Dreoc  

464:7/?:232= Zmbo | 43

blvor`ko`ts l`iy, (Woo Glx Gmdio Glkk―`s, E`g. v. _`etoh Wtmtos, 554 C.4h ==26, ==64 (==tf

Ger. =557)) ets speret, ms woii ms tfo iottor lc tfo Xo`tf Mko`hko`t, keietmto mbme`st m`y cohormi

 nuhegemi hogesel` glkpoiie`b tfo Gety tl o`tor m gl`trmgt.

Xfo _`etoh Wtmtos Gl`stetutel` hlos `lt clrdeh m Gety crlk gl`trliie`b tfo uso lc ets lw`

 prlporty clr ets lw` imwcui `l`hesgreke`mtlry purplso.  Mhhorioy v. Cilrehm, 76? _.W. 75, 82-86

(=533)1 Iilyh Glrp., Ieketoh v. Xm``or , 8:2 _.W. ??=, ?36 (=524), gete`b Mhhoriy1 Nl`os v. Aoiiy,

3== Coh. Mppx. 445, 47= (?tf Ger. 4:=?), gete`b  Mhhoriy. Xfo Glurt sfluih hocor tl tfo Gety―s

 nuhbko`t robmrhe`b ets hogesel`s mdlut o`tore`b e`tl gl`trmgts. Et es l`o tfe`b tl hogimro tfmt tfo

rosliutel` es u`o`clrgomdio1 et es queto m`ltfor tfe`b tl clrgo tfo Gety tl o`tor e`tl m `ow gl`trmgt

wetf Zime`tecc, wflso prlkesos fmvo prlvo` tl do u`roiemdio.

E` Xoxms tfo oioko`ts lc m gimek clr dromgf lc gl`trmgt mro> (=) tfo oxesto`go lc m vmieh

gl`trmgt1 (4) tfo gimekm`t―s porclrkm`go lc huteos u`hor tfo gl`trmgt1 (7) tfo rospl`ho`t―s dromgf

lc tfo gl`trmgt, m`h (8) hmkmbos rosuite`b crlk tfo dromgf.  Fmrresl` v. Roiis Cmrbl Dm`a, @.M.,

Gmuso @l. 7>=7 ‗ GS ‗ 8364 ‗ H, 4:=? RI =385:35 *8 (@.H. Xox. 4:=?), qulte`b Lrtflciox, E`g. v.

XforklXoa, E`g., 567 C. Wupp. 4h 633, 624 (@.H. Xox. 4:=7) (getmtel` m`h e`tor`mi qultmtel`

kmras lkettoh).

Xfo Gety provelusiy o`toroh e`tl m gl`trmgt portme`e`b tl Oxxxltegm, m`h Zime`tecc mhkets

tl fmve`b prlkesoh tfo Gety tfmt Oxxxltegm wluih `lt porket oxfedetlrs lr pmtrl`s tl o`bmbo e`

’soxumi mgteveteos,‛ hoce`oh tl e`giuho cl`hie`b lr ltfor orlteg tlugfe`b lc duttlgas lr cokmio

 dromsts. Hs. Mpp. =:31 ===1 Zime`tecc―s Mpp. =6-=5, ³³ ==-=41 =:=-=:61 Hat. = mt =:, ³2. Zime`tecc

 prlkesoh tfo Gety tfmt Oxxxltegm wluih `lt porket oxfedetlrs lr pmtrl`s tl hespimy cokmio

 dromsts doilw m ple`t ekkohemtoiy mdlvo tfo tlp lc tfo mrolims. Hs. Mpp. ===. Zime`tecc

 prlkesoh tfo Gety tfmt `l mhuit lr ldsgo`o kmtoremis wluih do vesedio crlk m`y pudieg rebft lc

Gmso 7>=3-gv-::?=7-H Hlguko`t 4: Ceioh :7/4?/=3 Zmbo 78 lc 3: ZmboEH 867

8/19/2019 Dallas' Response to Exxxotica Lawsuit

35/60

 Hoco`hm`ts― Tospl`so tl Zime`tecc―s Kltel` clr m Zroieke`mry E`nu`gtel` m`h Dreoc  

464:7/?:232= Zmbo | 42

wmy.  Eh . Zime`tecc prlkesoh tfmt fo wluih kl`etlr glkpiem`go wetf tfo torks m`h gl`hetel`s lc

tfo mbrooko`t m`h suporveso tfo sflw m`h oxfedetlr gl`hugt mt mii tekos. Hs. Mpp. ===-==4. Fo

heh `lt ievo up tl m`y lc tfoso prlkesos. Wuprm mt ³³ 7.=-7.3.

E`stomh, oxfedetlrs m`h pmtrl`s o`bmboh e` ’soxumi mgteveteos‛ m`h mppomroh e` m stmto lc

`uhety tfmt velimtoh Zime`tecc―s mbrooko`t wetf tfo Gety, mhuit kmtoremi wms vesedio crlk tfo

Gl`vo`tel` Go`tor ilddy, m`h Zime`tecc heh `lt kl`etlr glkpiem`go wetf tfo torks m`h gl`hetel`s

lc tfo mbrooko`t m`h suporveso tfo sflw m`h oxfedetlr gl`hugt mt mii tekos. Wuprm mt ³³ 7.=-7.3.

Xfoso dromgfos lc Zime`tecc―s huteos tl tfo Gety hmkmboh tfo Gety dy porkette`b velimtel`s lc stmto

m`h ilgmi imws l` Gety lw`oh prlporty. Xfo Glurt sfluih `lt lrhor tfo Gety tl o`tor e`tl m