D3.1.x Lise Meitner: The battle for ultimate truth · 2019. 3. 1. · D3.1 CREATIONS Demonstrators...
Transcript of D3.1.x Lise Meitner: The battle for ultimate truth · 2019. 3. 1. · D3.1 CREATIONS Demonstrators...
D3.1 CREATIONS Demonstrators
CREATIONS has received funding from the European Commission
HORIZON2020 Programme
Page1of21
D3.1.x Lise Meitner: The battle for ultimate truth
Project
Reference:
H2020-SEAC-2014-2015/H2020-
SEAC-2014-1 , 665917
Author:
Hermione Ruck
Keene
Code: D 3.1.x Contributors:
Dr Kerry
Chappell
Dr Lindsay
Hetherington
Rae Hoole
Heather Wren
Version &
Date:
Approved by:
D3.1 CREATIONS Demonstrators
CREATIONS has received funding from the European Commission
HORIZON2020 Programme
Page2of21
Table of Contents
1 Introduction / Demonstrator Identity................................................................................. 3
1.1 Subject Domain ...................................................................................................... 3
1.2 Type of Activity ...................................................................................................... 3
1.3 Duration ................................................................................................................ 3
1.4 Setting (formal / informal learning) .......................................................................... 3
1.5 Effective Learning Environment................................................................................ 3
2 Rational of the Activity / Educational Approach .................................................................. 4
2.1 Challenge............................................................................................................... 4
2.2 Added Value .......................................................................................................... 4
3 Learning Objectives ......................................................................................................... 6
3.1 Domain specific objectives ....................................................................................... 6
3.2 General skills objectives .......................................................................................... 6
4 Demonstrator characteristics and Needs of Students .......................................................... 7
4.1 Aim of the demonstrator ......................................................................................... 7
4.2 Student needs addressed ........................................................................................ 7
5 Learning Activities & Effective Learning Environments ........................................................ 8
6 Additional Information ................................................................................................... 15
7 Assessment ................................................................................................................... 19
8 Possible Extension ......................................................................................................... 20
9 References .................................................................................................................... 21
D3.1 CREATIONS Demonstrators
CREATIONS has received funding from the European Commission
HORIZON2020 Programme
Page3of21
1 Introduction / Demonstrator Identity
1.1 Subject Domain
Nuclear fission in Physics, Standard form in Mathematics
1.2 Type of Activity
Local activity
Educational Activities based on Creativity- enriched Inquiry Based Approaches (school based).
1.3 Duration
1 day Masterclass with preparatory Skype with CERN
1.4 Setting (formal / informal learning)
Informal learning
1.5 Effective Learning Environment
• Arts-based
• Dialogic Space / argumentation
• Communication of scientific ideas to audience
D3.1 CREATIONS Demonstrators
CREATIONS has received funding from the European Commission
HORIZON2020 Programme
Page4of21
2 Rationale of the Activity / Educational Approach
2.1 Challenge
Pupils are regularly challenged to relate the discovery process in Science to more abstract scientific contexts
they are required to learn. In particular, elements that are perceived as ‘dry’ and requiring practice need to
be brought to life and grounded to make them more accessible to a wide range of pupils.
In this masterclass, a relatively unknown historical figure (in this case Lise Meitner, overlooked for the Nobel
prize for her work on nuclear fission with Otto Hahn, perhaps due to her gender and Jewish heritage), their
background and work in science are brought to life by a creative learning company (Links to a Life,
http://www.linkstoalife.com/ who would be happy to work with those interested to develop similar days with
the work of other historical figures in science) during the central part of the day. The rest of the day consists
of facilitated workshops relating the curriculum scientific content, facilitated by teachers and /or science
educators. Please note that the Lise Meitner Day was created and developed by Links to a Life, and the play
and teaching materials are copywright to Vince Miles (play) and John Teasdale (workshop materials). This
project has been subsequently adapted to form this Creations project masterclass/demonstrator; future
activities along the same lines would need to develop new theatrical/drama responses to the lives of
significant scientists with the appropriate links to the curriculum. The masterclass fosters links to current
research and innovation in the form of engaging with CERN’s schools programme via Skype.
The following text describes the specific Links to a Life event which has been placed at the centre of this
particular version of a drama/science activity day (please note that this text is © Links to a Life and should
not be reproduced in its current form)
‘Bringing wider public attention to Lise Meitner’s role in the discovery of ‘nuclear fission’, her humanity and
her lasting impact on the modern world, Links to a Life, a creative learning company, has created a day-
long programme for secondary schools including an hour-long piece of theatre at the centre with associated
workshop games, hands on calculations and debate. The day is designed to inspire a passion like hers for
Physics. Links to a Life sheds light on the dramatic and at times life threatening events of her life alongside
an exploration into the Maths and Physics she grappled with in order to arrive at the theoretical explanation
of the splitting of the uranium atom. The performance exposes audiences to her life, her associates
(Boltzmann, Planck, Rutherford and Chadwick), the Maths behind her discovery and its historical context.’
2.2 Added Value
This demonstrator adds value to pupils’ curricular learning in physics and maths by encouraging them to
link the curriculum to historical discoveries and to current cutting edge science, thus situating and grounding
the abstract concepts they are learning. Workshops for both pupils and attending teachers will draw on the
pedagogical approaches suggested by the CREATIONS Features; teachers will be given the opportunity to
explore the Features in their own dedicated workshop, as well as seeing them in action during facilitated
workshops for pupils. Use of pedagogical methods informed by the Features will enable pupils to link their
D3.1 CREATIONS Demonstrators
CREATIONS has received funding from the European Commission
HORIZON2020 Programme
Page5of21
learning in Science and Maths to the real life application of these theoretical approaches, as well as learning
about an individual behind their development.
D3.1 CREATIONS Demonstrators
CREATIONS has received funding from the European Commission
HORIZON2020 Programme
Page6of21
3 Learning Objectives
3.1 Domain specific objectives
Aims
• to inspire more young girls to want to pursue Physics to ‘A level’ and to see it as a viable and attractive option at Higher Education
• to raise public awareness, interest and engagement with contemporary physics, especially amongst girls
• Inspire and enthuse audiences, especially those not previously interested in physics. • Develop the science communication skills of individuals, particularly physicists. • to stimulate an interest in Maths and Physics, especially amongst girls • with professional actors, through an episodic drama, to tell the story of Lise Meitner (1878 –
1968) • to introduce the Maths Meitner used to explain nuclear fission • to develop students’ understanding of nuclear fission, radioactivity and sub-atomic particles • to work in partnership with different sectors to see the programme roll out to a wider and
geographically spread audience
3.2 General skills objectives
Please describe the skills that will be developed according to your demonstrator. As an example,
see below:
In the context of the Meitner Day Masterclass, students’ general skills objectives are:
• Active participation in the negotiation of scientific concepts
• Develop creative and critical skills
• Understanding of scientific concepts and phenomena
• Understanding the process of development of scientific concepts as an interactive process, brought to life
through drama.
• Develop spirit of cooperation and teamwork
• Understand to some extent how drama as an artform works to illuminate ideas and emotions
D3.1 CREATIONS Demonstrators
CREATIONS has received funding from the European Commission
HORIZON2020 Programme
Page7of21
4 Demonstrator characteristics and Needs of Students
4.1 Aim of the demonstrator
The demonstrator’s main aim is to link scientific theory and practice to the dramatized real life experiences of a
scientist who made a significant contribution to the development and application of these theories. The opportunity
to engage with the scientific and autobiographical content through drama– brings the theory to life by linking it to
individuals and their social/historical context. The follow-up workshops engage creatively and dialogically with the
scientific material in more detail, with connections to the dramatic presentation maintained by scientific facilitators
during the follow-up workshops.
The project is aimed at students between 13 and 18 years old and takes a ‘vertical learning’ approach, by including
students from different year groups who can support and challenge one another in terms of applying existing scientific
knowledge. The project is facilitated by actors and teachers/scientists together, and can be developed in cooperation
with researchers and/or scientists from a range of different settings, in collaboration with theatre companies and/or
school drama departments.
4.2 Student needs addressed
Students will be supported in understanding abstract concepts by seeing how they are situated in
the development of science from history through to the present day, in order to engage them with
science differently.
D3.1 CREATIONS Demonstrators
CREATIONS has received funding from the European Commission
HORIZON2020 Programme
Page8of21
5 Learning Activities & Effective Learning Environments
D3.1 CREATIONS Demonstrators
CREATIONS has received funding from the European Commission
HORIZON2020 Programme
Page9of21
Please note that this aspect of the demonstrator has been
completed relating to a specific version, created by the creative
learning company ‘Links to a Life and adapted for the CREATIONs
project masterclass. However, it could be adapted to relate the
curriculum to the life work of any scientist brought to life through
drama.
Science topic: Nuclear Fission
(Relevance to national curriculum) GCSE and A-level physics
related to atomic structure, bonding and radioactivity
Class information
Year Group: Mixed Year 9-13
Age range: 13-18, but the inclusion of older participants is advised in
order to facilitate the learning
Sex: both
Pupil Ability: The approach is designed to help pupils access and engage
with an abstract topic in physics and maths, so although challenging it is
designed to facilitate engagement of all pupils.
Materials and Resources
What do you need? (eg.printed questionnaires, teleconference, etc.) Creations project toolkit materials (e.g. wheels, honeycombs) ; a workbook relevant to the topic ; a drama. A space suitable for drama about science (e.g. a spacious laboratory) with a ‘backstage’ area is required and a classroom. Capacity to teleconference with a relevant research setting.
Prior pupil knowledge
No prior knowledge is required about the historical figure central to the scientific concept. Otherwise, some prior knowledge might be helpful dependent on the central figure
of the day. In this case, knowledge of a basic model of atomic structure is helpful.
D3.1 CREATIONS Demonstrators
CREATIONS has received funding from the European Commission
HORIZON2020 Programme
Page10of21
Individual session project objectives (What do you want pupils to know and understand by the end of the lesson?)
During this scenario, students will develop an understanding of nuclear fission and standard form in Mathematics. They will be able to link this learning to the development
of scientific knowledge and understanding of the atom and sub-atomic particles over time.
Assessment
Pupils’ workbooks; responses to
questions
Differentiation
How can the activities be adapted to the needs of
individual pupils?
‘Vertical’ groups to facilitate peer support for
younger pupils or those who find accessing the
concepts more challenging.
Key Concepts and Terminology
Science terminology:
Nuclear fission, radioactivity, sub-atomic particles, standard
form
Arts terminology:
Exploring characterisation, illuminating human narratives,
empathetic understanding, understanding drama
techniques through ‘close-up’ encounters with the actor’s
craft, physical learning
D3.1 CREATIONS Demonstrators
CREATIONS has received funding from the European Commission
HORIZON2020 Programme
Page11of21
Session Objectives:
During this scenario, students will engage with a researcher studying science at the cutting edge relevant to the historical figure’s work, as a preparatory Q&A session (e.g. CERN’s Virtual
Visits). During the masterclass, they will engage in activities to learn about nuclear fission and standard form developed by ‘linkstoalife’, supported by some of the ‘creations’ toolkit and
features to develop engaging pedagogical approaches. The centrepoint of the day is a drama about the life of Lise Meitner, produced by a creative learning company ‘linkstoalife’. Following
the drama, the learning will be consolidated by a Plenary session in which pupils ask and answer questions about the key topic. This is a fun and active (and competitive) game which
consolidates the learning before we move to the debate around issues raised from her story.
Learning activities in terms of CREATIONS Approach
IBSE Activity Interaction with CREATIONs Features Student Teacher Potential
arts activity
Phase 1:
QUESTION: students
investigate a scientifically
oriented question
Students pose, select, or are given a scientifically oriented
question to investigate. Balance and navigation through dialogue
aids teachers and students in creatively navigating educational
tensions, including between open and structured approaches to
IBSE. Questions may arise through dialogue between students’
scientific knowledge and the scientific knowledge of professional
scientists and science educators, or through dialogue with
different ways of knowledge inspired by interdisciplinarity and
personal, embodied learning. Ethics and trusteeship is an
Students engage with questions relating to the Physics and Maths behind nuclear fission through question posing in taught sessions and
interaction with the drama activity.
Provides initial questions and factual responses to consolidate/give new knowledge in
order to further students’ ability to apply existing Physics/Maths knowledge
Investigation of the Physics/Maths content through links to the
biographical and dramatic content.
D3.1 CREATIONS Demonstrators
CREATIONS has received funding from the European Commission
HORIZON2020 Programme
Page12of21
important consideration in experimental design and collaborative
work, as well as in the initial choice of question.
Phase 2:
EVIDENCE: students give
priority to evidence
Students determine or are guided to evidence/data, which may
come from individual, collaborative and communal activity such
as practical work, or from sources such as data from professional
scientific activity or from other contexts. Risk, immersion and play
is crucial in empowering pupils to generate, question and discuss
evidence.
Students engage with the CERN data prior to the Masterclass via a Virtual Visit.
Facilitate virtual visit and follow-up activities including ‘Happy families’ card game to revisit factual content in a playful manner.
Students could create own happy families fact cards; possibilities of artistic representations of data encountered via CERN virtual visit.
Phase 3:
ANALYSE: students
analyse evidence
Students analyse evidence, using dialogue with each other and
the teacher to support their developing understanding.
Students engage with a range of evidence relating to the discovery
of nuclear fission, including source material from the scientists involved.
Provide resources in terms of physical data and
factual knowledge to support dialogue and engagement with evidence.
Possibilities for students to create own
drama activities in response to aspects of the scientific processes under exploration.
Phase 4:
EXPLAIN: students
formulate an explanation
based on evidence
Students use evidence they have generated and analysed to
consider possibilities for explanations that are original to them.
They use argumentation and dialogue to decide on the relative
merits of the explanations they formulate, playing with ideas.
Students apply mathematical knowledge to calculate energy released during
fission reaction, working in mixed age groups and in dialogue with teachers.
Provide support for mathematical tasks and facilitate dialogue to enable
constructive discussion and experimentation with knowledge.
D3.1 CREATIONS Demonstrators
CREATIONS has received funding from the European Commission
HORIZON2020 Programme
Page13of21
Phase 5:
CONNECT: students
connect explanations to
scientific knowledge
Students connect their explanations with scientific knowledge,
using different ways of thinking and knowing (‘knowing that’,
‘knowing how’, and ‘knowing this’) to relate their ideas to both
disciplinary knowledge and to interdisciplinary knowledge to
understand the origin of their ideas and reflect on the strength of
their evidence and explanations in relation to the original
question.
Students apply mathematical knowledge to calculate energy released during fission reaction, working in mixed age groups and in dialogue with teachers.
Provide support for mathematical tasks and facilitate dialogue to enable constructive discussion and experimentation with knowledge.
Phase 6:
COMMUNICATE:
students communicate and
justify explanation
Communication of possibilities, ideas and justifications through
dialogue with other students, with science educators, and with
professional scientists offer students the chance to test their new
thinking and experience and be immersed in a key part of the
scientific process. Such communication is crucial to an ethical
approach to working scientifically.
Students participate in a ‘relay’ game to respond to questions about Meitner, her life, the science and the moral dilemmas and possible future advantages/ disadvantages of the Nuclear technology resulting from Meitner’s discovery including Nuclear power and atomic weapons. Students are given a question per group to discuss amongst themselves. Students present their views to the session as a whole.
Facilitate responses and moderate responses as necessary.
Possibility of discussing questions ‘in role’ as scientists
D3.1 CREATIONS Demonstrators
CREATIONS has received funding from the European Commission
HORIZON2020 Programme
Page14of21
Phase 7:
REFLECT: students reflect
on the inquiry process and
their learning
Individual, collaborative and community-based reflective activity
for change both consolidates learning and enables students and
teachers to balance educational tensions such as that between
open-ended inquiry learning and the curriculum and assessment
requirements of education.
Students participate in a ‘relay’ game to respond to questions about Meitner, her life, the science and the moral dilemmas and possible future advantages/ disadvantages of the Nuclear technology resulting from Meitner’s discovery including Nuclear power and atomic weapons. Students are given a question per group to discuss amongst themselves. Students
present their views to the session as a whole.
Facilitate responses and moderate responses as necessary.
Possibility of discussing questions ‘in role’ as scientists
D3.1 CREATIONS Demonstrators
CREATIONS has received funding from the European Commission
HORIZON2020 Programme
Page15of21
6 Additional Information
D3.1 CREATIONS Demonstrators
CREATIONS has received funding from the European Commission
HORIZON2020 Programme
Page16of21
Images from the play, staged in the science labs:
D3.1 CREATIONS Demonstrators
CREATIONS has received funding from the European Commission
HORIZON2020 Programme
Page17of21
D3.1 CREATIONS Demonstrators
CREATIONS has received funding from the European Commission
HORIZON2020 Programme
Page18of21
D3.1 CREATIONS Demonstrators
CREATIONS has received funding from the European Commission
HORIZON2020 Programme
Page19of21
7 Assessment
Pre- and post-test questionnaires will be administered to all students participating in the
Masterclass; pre-test will be administered at least two weeks before the activity, and post-test at
the end of the day. Teachers will complete the post-test questionnaire at the end of the day.
Qualitative data will be collected in the form of observations, photographs and interviews with
both students (group) and teachers (individual); teacher follow-up interviews will take place after
the event to provide further insight into the impact of the activities.
D3.1 CREATIONS Demonstrators
CREATIONS has received funding from the European Commission
HORIZON2020 Programme
Page20of21
8 Possible Extension
The activities outlined above could be used to develop similar activities related to other historical
figures in Science, with a particular focus on mis- or under-represented individuals and/or groups.
Links to a Life are happy to enter into discussion with European partners regarding development
of similar drama/workshop masterclasses linked to significant figures throughout the history of
Science. Similar techniques could also be used to engage with living or imagined scientific figures;
for example, students could create dramatic representations of the types of scientists that they
might envision themselves becoming, or scientific innovations that they would like to lead. This
type of activity would also encourage students to consider the limitations or barriers that might be
placed in their way – whether social, moral, economic or intellectual – and how they might
overcome them, linking to the CREATIONS feature of ethics and trusteeship and developing the
idea of resilience in a scientific context.
D3.1 CREATIONS Demonstrators
CREATIONS has received funding from the European Commission
HORIZON2020 Programme
Page21of21
9 References