D iscussion Paper Series U Tokyo IInstitute of Social Science Panel Survey · 2018. 9. 20. · g þ...
Transcript of D iscussion Paper Series U Tokyo IInstitute of Social Science Panel Survey · 2018. 9. 20. · g þ...
UUniversity of Tokyo
IInstitute of Social Science
PPanel Survey
Discussion Paper Series
��������� ������ ����
�������!�"�"��"�
���E��CBD��F'()*!&G?=>A
������@��
#99729254 24 91. '+6+4.8. (2/. $5:78. )+4.3 *:7;.<8 /57 91. &201 8,1553 07+-:+9.8"
#4 #4+3<828 5/ 91. %+,9578 5/ 91. #99729254
�� �� F ������H������G
Yasufumi Yamaguchi
September 2018
No.107
���������
INSTITUTE OF SOCIAL SCIENCE UNIVERSITY OF TOKYO
1
Ú�u�ģ�Ĩ�ğĭ±ȚȘȣųÝȜȥȎȄȇȗ ȖȁȏȅȔȍȠȦȝȨȚȨȍȢȨȐ No. 107 2018� 9Ò
������������JLPS-H�������� ����
�Tƺ ôVȪÚ�u�u�ƧȮË×�ř¼Ő�ȫ
�ËǧË×ģ�ǥLjǍǺƸÞċǧƖƈƚµȧȆȟȢȀ�¯ǾáŦǒǠDžnj�ǡȬƸJʼnǾƠÕ
ĕljǞ�ÕĕǥƑƇǒȬƸÞh�ÎȮJâ¡OÇǥûǝǠtnjǧ¬mǾ¤ǠDžǺǀÚuģğȧƸ
JȚȘȣųÝȪJLPS-HȫǁǨurÓČǛǢŤLJǺƾǒljǒǤNJǸȬYųÝǥǨİ 2óǡǧuşçæ×ōŕǢǘǻǥ�ǝǠċǓdžǺșȂȀȏǧcƵNJDŽǹȬǣǧǷdžǤ�«ǥ$¸ǒǚōŕNJǣǧĪ�
ċǓǠDžǺǧljǾ³ÂǒǠLjnj¨ŝNJDŽǺƾ ×ĬǡǨ JLPS-HȖȨȒǥǞDžǠȬİ 2ó�ÈǬǧ©ŶȬİ 2ó�ƥWóǧdIJȬİ 13ó
ǰǡǧ1ódIJLjǷǫİ 2 óōŕ¡ǧ¥õdIJǧǘǻǙǻǥǞDžǠȬ«9ǵ6ƊƸÞǧȡȦȇȮī9ǤǣȬİ 1 óǡ¤Ǹǻǚ�«ǥǷǺ+ǹǾ7ÛǒǚƾáŦǧļÜȬƻİ 2 ó�ƥǧWóǧȖȨȒǥǨäǦy«Ȭă�ǧě±hÞǧ6ƊʼnȬƖ�Þ6ƊʼnȬƸJ¡Ɩ�ʼnȬƸ 3 ίŃ��ʼnǧdIJNJ�njPÍǑǻǠDžǺǏǢȬƼ1ódIJʼnǧȖȨȒǥǨy«Ȭă�ǧě±hÞ6ƊʼnȬ
Ƹ 3ίŃ���ʼnǧdIJNJ�njPÍǑǻǠDžǺǏǢNJ7ljǝǚƾ
ƺ ×ğĭǨƽË×�ř¼Ő�Ĩ�ğĭƁś?ƞlėğĭȪSȫȪ18103003ƽ22223005ȫƽË×�ř¼Ő�Ĩ�ğĭƁś?ƞlėğĭȪCȫȪ25381122ȫƽË×�ř¼Ő�Ĩ�ğĭƁś?ƞlėğĭȪBȫȪ16H03778ȫƽx���ƞȧß��ģȀȃȗȑȨȍȦȈƽLċA-Ĩ�ğĭƁś?ƞƽÚ�u�ģ�Ĩ�ğĭ±ğĭƂƞƽLjǷǫË×�ř¼Ő�Ĩ�ğĭƁś?ƞȪă9ğĭ`x
@ƁȫǥǷǺğĭ¯Üǧ�ƛǡDŽǺƾȚȘȣųÝȖȨȒǧ:ČǥDŽǚǝǠǨģ�Ĩ�ğĭ±ȚȘ
ȣųÝ�Đ}`�ǧũUǾ¤ǚƾ
2
2
ƺ 1990 ��ǧƠÕ�ñǢǘǻǥ�džģ�r�ǧǤljǡȬ�ÞǢ��ǧƤ%«ȬǢnjǥƸÞJâ¡ǥǣǧǷdžǥƖƈǾƚµǒȬŎƊǧȆȟȢȀǾĴDžǠDžnjǧljǨuNjǤrżǾƗǎǠNjǚȪBrinton 2008Ȳ2008Ȭ×č 2005ȫƾǘǧ�ǡȬƸÞċNJǣǧǷdžǥƖƈ®ŷǾ�¯ǒǠƖƈƚµǾŘDžȬ�Ŋǒǚ¡ǥǣǧǷdžǥȆȟȢȀǾ�¯ǒǠǶnjǧljǥǞDžǠǨȬľĿĕǤųÝǾƔǓǚ³ÂNJï
dzǸǻǺǷdžǥǤǝǚƾ ǀÚuģğȧƸJȚȘȣųÝȪJLPS-HȫǁǨǏǧǷdžǤŝŴǧ�ǥȬǀ�Jʼnǧ®ŷǢŘDǁǢǘ
ǻǾ;ÁǢǒǚǀJâ¡ǧœ��ǧD[ǁǢDždžǀ2 Ǟǧ�đǧƣǧǷǹƠÕĕƽŁXĕǤƤƕ«Ǿ]dzǠ½LJǁǺǏǢǾĘĕǥŨťȧ�ÈǑǻǚȬƸÞh�ÎǾƄÿǢǒǚȚȘȣųÝǡDŽǺȪĞčł
Ŗ 2006ȱ5ȫƾ ǏǧųÝǨ 2004�ǥƢ|ǑǻȬ2018� 8ÒĈhǡİ 14óǰǡ�ÈǑǻǠDžǺƾ�Ë×ǡǨ
�ǥƶǾŞǤDžǮǣƠÕĕljǞ�Õĕǥ�ÈǑǻǠDžǺƸJʼnǧȚȘȣųÝǡDŽǺȬ�ƸÞų
Ýǵ'źʼnųÝǴ�ÈǒǠLjǹtnjǧ¬mNJ¤ǸǻǺȬ�ĵgǧƸJʼnųÝǡDŽǺ NELS ǢǧíƋǾªƳǥŅDžǠųÝĥNJŨťǑǻǠDžǺȬǢDžǝǚăŒǾ¹ǜȬǘǧȖȨȒǾČDžǠtnjǧ7Û
NJǤǑǻǠNjǚȪĞčłŖ 2006Ȭ�ŗł 2017Ǥǣȫƾ ǒljǒǤNJǸȬJLPS-HǥǨ7ÛǾŘdž�ǡáŦǔǭNjuNjǤŲƵNJDŽǺƾǘǻǨİ 1óljǸİ
2 óǥljǍǠƯ�ǥuşçǤæ×ōŕNJċǓǠDžǺǏǢǡDŽǺƾİ 1 óǡǨ 7,563 ȉȨȏǧdIJNJ¤ǸǻǠDžǺNJȬİ 2óǡǨǘǻNJ 482ȉȨȏǰǡú�ǒȬİ 3ó�ƥǴäǦ 500ȉȨȏ;¡ǡÀĩǒǠDžǺǧǡDŽǺƾ æ×ōŕǧcƵǨȚȘȣųÝ�őǥDZǸǻǺǴǧǡDŽǹȬă�ǧ)�ă«ǾÓǔǺ�ǥ+ǝǠ
æ×ōŕNJċǓǠǒǰdžǏǢǡȬȖȨȒǥ��ǧșȂȀȏǾċDZ6ǒǠǒǰdžǏǢNJºÃǑǻǠDžǺ
ȪWooldridge 2001Ȭj× 2006ȫƾJLPS-HǥǞDžǠǴ�ƐǧƔǹuşçǤ8Õæ×ōŕNJċǓǠDžǺ��ȬǘǻNJă�ǧ�ǥ+ǺǏǢǥǷǺșȂȀȏNJċǓǠǒǰǝǠDžǺUŌ«NJƸDžƾ Ǵǒ7Ûǧƪǥ�ǔǺìƫfNJDŽnjǰǡǀȚȘȣųÝǥľĿǒǠdIJǒǠnjǻǺǷdžǤ�ǁǡDŽ
ǻǩȬ�ƐǧșȂȀȏǨĀŠǒǠǷDžljǴǒǻǤDžƾ�ƪȬdIJǾľĿǒǠnjǻǺȪLjǘǸnjĜưĘ
Ǥȫ�ǥLjDžǠǴƸJ¡ǧƖƈƚµǵȆȟȢȀ�¯ǥŲƵǾ¶LJǠDžǺȬǢDžǝǚǷdžǤĝŞǾĢ
ǔǏǢǨƝŝǛǢDžLJǺƾǒljǒǴǒË×ģ�1 ȬDŽǺDžǨ�ǤnjǢǴİ 1 ó�ÈÎǥ�ǒǚìƫfǾňLJǺǧǡDŽǻǩȬȖȨȒǥǣǧǷdžǤ+ǹNJŞǸǻǺǧljǾ³Âǒǚ�ǡ7ÛļÜǾŸŵ
ǔǺǏǢNJïdzǸǻǺǏǢǥǤǺƾ ×ĬǡǨ JLPS-H ǥǞDžǠȬ)�ă«ǥǷǝǠȬōŕǾǨǓdzǢǔǺdIJ,[ǥǣǧǷdžǤƘ
DžNJDZǸǻǺǧljǾáŦǔǺƾǴǒă�ǧ)�ă«ǥLjDžǠæ×ōŕNJċǓǵǔDžǢDždžǷdžǤ,
[NJÌǸljǥǤǻǩȬJLPS-H ǾČDžǚ7ÛļÜǥǞDžǠȬǘǧǷdžǤȖȨȒǧă¦Ǿ;ÁǥŸ
ŵǔǺǏǢNJUŌǥǤǺƾǰǚȬȃȄȂȕȁȦȈǵèüǧ�0ǤǣǧĽť²òǾČDžǚșȂȀȏśê
ǾŸŵǔǺǏǢNJǡNjǺǷdžǥǤǺƾ ��ǡǨȬǰǕË×ǧȚȘȣųÝǥLjǍǺæ×ōŕǥǞDžǠǧ/ŘğĭǾÆĉǒȬ×Ĭǧ®
ŇǾĠůǔǺƾéǥȪȯȫ8ÕōŕNJǣǧǷdžǥċǓǠDžǺǧljȬȪȰȫdIJ,[Ǣ)�ă«ǧƣǥƤ
ƕǨŞǸǻǺǧljȬǧ 2Ǟǧ7ÛǾƔǓǠȬJLPS-HǥLjǍǺæ×ōŕǧ,[ǾÌǸljǥǔǺƾÑ¡ǥǘǻǸǾƉǰLJǠȬJLPS-H ǧ7ÛȬǪDžǠǨƸÞh�ÎǾƄÿǢǔǺȚȘȣųÝ�őǥǞDžǠŸŵǾŘdžƾǤLjȬ;ƐǧǷdžǥ JLPS-H Ǩİ 14 óǰǡ�ÈǑǻǠDžǺNJȬ×ĬǡǨİ 13
3
óǰǡČDžǺǏǢǢǔǺƾ -
/ƐǧǷdžǥȬæ×ōŕǢǘǻǥ�ǝǠċǓǺșȂȀȏǧcƵǨȚȘȣųÝ�őǥ3ÓǑǻǠ
DžǺŲƵǡDŽǹȬg4scǽǕtnjǧáŦNJƝǦǸǻǠNjǚȪ�þ 2012ȫƾ Ë×ǧȚȘȣųÝǥǞDžǠǨȬj×Ȫ2006ȫNJžfò��ťĻøğĭ±NJ�ÈǔǺǀ÷Ɓċ
õǥƤǔǺȚȘȣųÝ JPSCǁǥǞDžǠȬ�ƌȪ2014ȫNJË×�Éģ���NJ�Èǒǚǀ1g�ÉųÝȚȘȣȏȒȖȁNFRJ-08PanalǁǥǞDžǠáŦǾŘǝǠDžǺƾ ǸǨǘǻǙǻǧȚȘȣȧȖȨȒǥǞDžǠȬ�Ŭ��ǥLjǍǺdIJǧÓĀǾ;��ųÝǧdIJ,[ǡüǒȬǣǧǷdžǤ)�
ă«ǥ+ǝǠōŕNJċǓǠDžǺljǾĢǔǏǢǡȖȨȒǧșȂȀȏǾĢǒǚƾǘǧ�ǡȬōŕǧü
ĠćǧƓÅǡ7ÛǾƝDZ�ǍǺ Inverse Probability Weighting òǥǷǺșȂȀȏśêǧUŌ«ǾĢbǒǠDžǺƾ
JLPS-H ǧ{zųÝǢDžLJǺǀÚuģğȧœ�ȚȘȣųÝȪJLPS-YȫǁLjǷǫǀÚuģğȧq�ȚȘȣųÝȪJLPS-MȫǁǥǞDžǠǴčƍȪ2012ȫNJæ×ōŕǥƤǔǺ7ÛǾŘǝǠLjǹȬď«ǵœ��Ȭ�Ɔǒ�ʼnǤǣǡæ×ōŕNJċǓǵǔDžǏǢǾÌǸljǥǒǠDžǺƾ ǴǝǢǴȬJLPS-HǧǷdžǤƸÞh�ÎǾƄÿǢǔǺȚȘȣųÝǨȬǏǻǸNJ�ŻǢǒǚ¯�ǧȚ
ȘȣųÝǢǨōŕǾċDz)�ă«ǥƘDžNJŞǸǻǺUŌ«NJDŽǺƾǚǢLJǩ¯�ȚȘȣǡǨųÝ
Ƣ|�;ǧ6Ù�ǢǤǺƸJ¡ǧƖƈǨȬƭ�ǵċõĊoǧrGǾƔǓǠİ 2 ó�ƥǧōŕǥ�ƱǔǺŝrÅǛǢňLJǸǻǺƾ ǒljǒǤNJǸȬƸÞh�ÎǾƄÿǢǔǺȚȘȣųÝǨË×ǡǴDžnjǞlj�ÈǑǻǠDžǺǴǧǧȬ
ǣǧǷdžǤ)�ă«ǥ+ǝǠæ×ōŕNJċǓǠDžǺǧljǥǞDžǠǧáŦǨǮǢǿǣǤnjȬljǼdžǓ
Ǡ �Ȫ2008Ȭ2009ȫNJDŽǺǧDZǡDŽǺƾ �Ȫ2008Ȭ2009ȫNJáŦǧ�ŻǢǒǚǧǨȬÚ�u�Äŋ�ğĭĨƸÞÄŋğĭ�NJ�ÈǒǚǀĈ�ƸÞċǧċõǢ®ŷǥƤǔǺųÝǁLjǷǫJâ
¡ǧƑƇųÝȪİ 2óȫǡDŽǺƾ �Ȫ2008ȫǨİ 2óųÝǬǧ©ŶȮ·\Ȭ �Ȫ2009ȫǨİ 2óǬǧdIJǧÓĀǥǞDžǠȬ
ųÝ�Żʼnǧ�«ȧ®ŷǢǧƤƕǾŞǠDžǺƾ ǧ7ÛǥlǟnjǢȬď«ȬĦĮ�Þ6ƊʼnǨİ2óųÝǾ·\ǒİ 2óǥdIJǒǤDžȬǢDždžǷdžǥ 2Ǟǧ7Ûǡ3ƔǔǺ,[NJŞǸǻǺNJȬ��iǵģ�ĕŇEȧƀ�ǧŎšǤǣǨİ 2óųÝǬǧ©ŶȮ·\ǥ�ƱǔǺ�ÇǡȬİ 2óǥdIJǔǺljǣdžljǥǨ�ƱNJDZǸǻǤDžƾİ2óųÝǬǧK=Ǿ©ŶǔǺljǣdžljǢ�ƪǥİ2óǥdIJǔǺljǣdžljȬǏǻǸ�ʼnǾş�ǔǺŝeǨ3ƔǔǺƛ7NJDŽǺ�ÇǡȬljǤǸǕǒǴ�ſǒ
ǠDžǺŪǡǨǤDžǢDždžǏǢǥǤǺƾ �Ȫ2008Ȭ2009ȫǾƉǰLJǠȬ×ĬǡǴİ 2óųÝǬǧ©ŶȮ·\Ȭİ 2óǬǧdIJǧÓĀ
ǢųÝ�Żʼnǧ)�ă«ǧƤƕǾáŦǔǺƾJLPS-H ǥǨİ 3 ó�ƥǴ�hǔǺǚdzȬǘǻǸǴ]dzǠ)�ă«ǢǧƤƕǾĠůǒǠǶnjƾǘǧƪȬōŕȒȂȞȦȈǐǢǧ)�ă«ǢǧƤƕǧƘDž
ǥĒ®ǒǤNJǸáŦǾƖdzǺƾ 4 1
4
JLPS-H ǧİ 1 óǨ 2004 � 1ȳ3 Òǥ�ÈǑǻǚ1ƾĤw�ěȧĞ�ěȧ�kěȧħčěǧ 4ěƽť 162ÞǥųÝǾ$ƴǒƽ107ÞǧƸÞljǸK=SŶǧƏIJǾSǍǠDžǺƾ�ƪǥųÝĥǾdQǡNjǚǧǨ 101ÞǡȬdQĥÅǨ 7,563ĥǡDŽǺ2ƾİ 2ó�ƥǥǞDžǠǨȬİ 1óǧųÝĥǥLjDžǠ�Żʼnǥę¿$ƴǒȬ©ŶǔǺnXǥǨųÝĥǧƜƒ/�±Ǿŧ0ǒǠǴǸdž��Ǣ
ǤǝǠDžǺƾ İ 2 ó�ƥǥǞDžǠ©ŶNJDŽǝǚǧǨ 2,036ZǡDŽǝǚNJȬ2005 � 11 Òȳ2006 � 1 Òǥ
Ɯƒǡ�ÈǑǻǚİ 2óǧdQĥÅǨ 501ĥǡDŽǹȬǏǧdžǜİ 1óǧdIJNJDŽǺǴǧǨ 482 ȉȨȏǢǤǝǠDžǺƾ İ 3 ó�ƥǨƜƒò3ǥǷǝǠLjLjǷǘ 1 �LjNjǥ�ÈǑǻȬt�ǧrDǾńǹƏǒǤNJǸǴȬ
äǦ 500ȳ600ȉȨȏ;¡ǡÀĩǒǠDžǺȪŚ 1ȫƾƠÕǥûǝǠľĿǑǻǠDžǺųÝǡDŽǺǚdzȬ��ōŕǒǠǴȬǘǧ¡ǧųÝǡ¥õǔǺȉȨȏNJ��ÅŞǸǻǺǧǴă¦ǡDŽǺƾ
Ś 1ƺ ƸJȚȘȣųÝǧdQĄñȪİ 2ó�ƥǧdQćǧ7ìǨƒ�Åȫ
.5
(1)ƺ lġ7Û ǣǧëƩǡǣǧǷdžǤæ×ōŕNJċǓǠDžǺǧljǧ1 ĕǤ,[Ǿ³ÂǒǠLjnjǚdzǥȬǰǕǨ
1 ųÝǧŭĹǥǞDžǠǨĞčłŖȪ2006ȫǧİ 1įǵ�ŗłȪ2017ȫǧ�įǾMāǑǻǚDžƾ 2 ǏǧǚdzȬİ 1óȖȨȒÎÿǡÊǥȬ�8�ǒǠDžǚìƫfljǸǨ+ǹNJċǓǠDžǺUŌ«NJDŽǺƾǚǛǒȬǏǻǥǞDžǠǨě9ǵƸÞ9ǧdQćǧƘDžǾíƋǔǺǏǢǨǡNjǠǴȬ)��«
ǧ¬mNJǤDžǚdzǥǣǧǷdžǤ)��«ǥǷǺ+ǹNJċǓǺǧljǾĠůǔǺǏǢǨǡNjǤDžƾ×Ĭ
ǧĘĕǨDŽnjǰǡȚȘȣųÝǥLjǍǺİ2ó�ƥǧōŕǧ7ÛǥDŽǺǚdzȬ�8ǧ�ìƫfljǸǧİ 1óÎÿǡǧ+ǹǥǞDžǠǨŸŵǖǕ9ĬǥŹǺƾ 3 ųÝ�ŻʼnǥƜƒǡdIJ$ƴȧųÝĥǾƒ�ǔǺNJȬİ 3ó�ƥǡǨȬdIJÇòǢǒǠųÝĥǬǧŧ0ȧƏƒǥ>LJǠȬWebǡǧ0=ȧÁ6ǴUŌǡDŽǺƾ
��� ����� ��� ��
�1� 2004�1� 17-18� 7,563 69.1%�2� 2004�10� 18-19� 501 24.6%�3� 2005�10� 19-20� 670 33.3%�4� 2006�10� 20-21� 547 27.8%�5� 2008�10� 22-23� 530 27.6%�6� 2009�10� 23-24� 465 25.0%�7� 2010�10� 24-25� 516 29.4%�8� 2011�10� 25-26� 506 29.4%�9� 2012�10� 26-27� 514 30.7%�10� 2013�10� 27-28� 484 29.8%�11� 2014�10� 28-29� 465 29.6%�12� 2015�10� 29-30� 463 30.0%�13� 2016�10� 30-31� 451 30.2%�14� 2017�10� 31-32� 490 33.5%
5
l×�«Ȫ«9Ȭ6ƊƸÞȡȦȇȮī9ȬƸ 3 ÎÞ4¯Ńȫǧ<XNJWóǡǣǧǷdžǥrGǒǠDžǺǧljǾĠůǒǠLjnjƾ
Ś 2ƺ WóǥLjǍǺ«9Ȭ6ƊƸÞȡȦȇȮī9ȬƸ 3ÎÞ4¯Ńǧ7�
Ś 2 ǾŞǺǢȬǵǨǹİ 1óljǸİ 2óǥljǍǠǧuşçǤæ×ōŕǥƪǒȬl×�«ǧ7�
NJuNjnjrDǒǠDžǺǏǢNJ7ljǺƾ«9ǡǨď«<XNJķ 6ȩú�ǒȬ6ƊƸÞȡȦȇȮī9ǨƖƈtåÞȬ�ơƸÞȧ�Ĩǧ<XNJú�ǒǠƖ�Þǧ<XNJuNjnjp>ǒǠDžǺƾǰǚȬƸ 3ÎÞ4¯ŃǨ���ǧ<XNJp>ǒȬ���NJú�ǒǠDžǺƾ ǴǝǢǴȬȋȦȜȣȋȂȐNJ�ǑnjǤǝǚǏǢǴDŽǝǠȬİ 2 ó�ƥǥǴl×�«ǧ7�NJǘǻǤ
ǹǥrGǒǠDžǺǏǢNJĠůǡNjǺƾ (2) K=·\ƽİ 2óōŕƽ1dIJƽǘǒǠ¥õǔǺǧǨűlj ǴǝǢǴȬ«9ǢƸÞȡȦȇȮī9Ȭ¯ŃǧƣǥǴƤƕNJŞǸǻǺǏǢǾňLJǻǩȬŜÅǧ�«ŝ
eǢdIJ,[ǧƣǧƤƕǨYÎǥáŦǔǺ¨ŝNJDŽǺƾǘǏǡȬǏǧijǡǨdIJ,[Ǿ£�rÅ
ǢǒǚDžnjǞljǧ�ƲȥȎȏȕȁȔȇd�7ÛǾŘDžȬǘǻǸǧƣǧƤƕǾáŦǔǺƾ Ñ8ǥŘdžǧǨȬİ 1óljǸİ 2óǥljǍǠǧæ×ōŕǧáŦǡDŽǺƾǏǧțȄȨȐǡǨȬ�İ
2 ó�ƥǧȚȘȣųÝǬǧM>ǥ©ŶǔǺǧljȬ�İ 2 óǧųÝĥǥdIJǒƏƒǔǺljȬǢDždž2ǞǧōŕȒȂȞȦȈNJDŽǹȬ2ijǡţǻǚǷdžǥȬǘǻǙǻǧş�ŝeNJĔǤǝǠDžǺUŌ«NJDŽǺƾǘǻǙǻǥǞDžǠȬİ 1 ódIJʼnǾ7Û�ŻǢǒǚ�ƲȥȎȏȕȁȔȇd�7ÛǾŘDžȬÀ�ļÜǾŚ 3ǥĢǒǚƾ ǏǻǾŞǺǢȬ�ȚȘȣ©ŶǢ�İ 2ódIJǧǘǻǙǻǥNǯǔ�Ʊǧ,[NJ�ŏǒǠDžǺ)
�ă«Ǣ�Ʊǧ,[NJǵǵĔǤǺ)�ă«NJDŽǺǏǢNJ7ljǺƾ�kěǵĞ�ěǡǨħčěǥ
íǭǠȬȚȘȣųÝǬǧM>ǥ©ŶǒȬ�ƪİ 2óǥdIJǒǵǔDž,[ǥDŽǺƾĤw�ěǨİ 2ódIJǥ�ǒǠǨĽťĕǥÓ®ǥǤǝǠDžǤDžNJȬǏǻǨæýŰ�NJȚȘȣ©ŶǥíǭǠuNj
�� � ��������
� !����
� � � ���
�1� 7,563 48.7 51.1 41.1 38.4 20.5 33.1 31.7 33.1 2.1�2� 482 42.7 57.3 54.8 29.9 15.4 41.5 31.1 23.0 4.4�3� 645 38.3 61.7 51.8 30.5 17.7 41.6 29.6 24.6 4.2�4� 526 38.8 61.2 54.6 27.6 17.9 41.0 29.6 25.1 4.4�5� 509 39.5 60.5 49.3 32.4 18.3 37.9 31.9 25.9 4.3�6� 449 38.8 61.3 47.0 35.0 18.0 40.9 30.5 24.5 4.1�7� 498 40.2 59.8 48.0 32.3 19.7 34.9 31.8 29.5 3.9�8� 487 36.8 63.2 46.0 34.3 19.7 38.1 30.6 27.3 4.0�9� 496 38.7 61.3 45.2 35.7 19.2 35.6 30.4 30.2 3.9�10� 468 36.8 63.3 48.3 32.9 18.8 34.7 32.2 29.3 3.7�11� 451 34.2 65.9 48.1 34.4 17.5 35.9 31.2 29.3 3.7�12� 448 34.6 65.4 48.4 33.5 18.1 36.9 30.7 28.7 3.7�13� 435 35.9 64.1 47.8 32.4 19.8 35.6 32.2 28.4 3.8��1���� ����0.25���������
� �!����"� !3������
6
DžǚdzǡDŽǹȬ%ÅǧÀ�*ǨȚȘȣ©Ŷǥ�ǔǺǴǧǢuNjnjrǽǸǤDžƾǰǚȬƸJ¡�ÔȮ
�ƖƈNJƖ�ǵÖ�ǛǢ�ŊǥíǭǠȚȘȣųÝǥ©ŶǒǵǔnjȬİ 2 óǥǴdIJǒǠnjǻǺ,[ǥDŽǺǏǢNJ7ljǺƾ �ÇȬ�ÞȡȦȇǨ�ơƸÞȧ�Ĩǧċ¢ǛǢƖƈtåÞǧċ¢ǥíǭǠȚȘȣųÝǬǧd
IJǥ©ŶǒǠnjǻǺ,[ǥDŽǺNJȬ�ƪǥİ 2 óǥdIJǒǠnjǻǺĠćǨƖƈtåÞǢĽťĕǥÓ®Ǥ�NJǤDžƾDzǒǼİ 2 óǥdIJǒǠnjǻǺǧǨȬȚȘȣųÝǬǧ©ŶǥǨƖƈtåÞǧċ¢ǢƘDžNJŞǸǻǤljǝǚƖ�Þǧċ¢ǡDŽǺƾǰǚȬĀdIJʼnǾƨǍǩȚȘȣųÝǬǧ©Ŷ,
[ǥ¯ŃǥǷǺƘDžǨŞǸǻǤDžǧǥ�ǒȬ�ƪǥǨǷǹ¯ŃNJƸljǝǚ�Ǯǣİ 2 óųÝǥdIJǒǠnjǻǺ,[ǥDŽǺƾ>LJǠȬȚȘȣųÝǬǧ©Ŷǥ�ǒǠǨŽǧ%ÅǾĢǒǠDžǚy«ȓȞ
ȨNJİ 2óǬǧdIJǥǨ 10ȩîýǤNJǸÓ®ǥêǧ,[ǾĢǒǠLjǹȬy«Ǩď«ǥíǭǠİ2óǥdIJǒǠnjǻǺ,[ǥDŽǺǏǢNJ7ljǝǚƾ
Ś 3ƺ ȚȘȣųÝǬǧ©ŶȬİ 2óǧdIJÓĀǾ£�rÅǢǒǚ �ƲȥȎȏȕȁȔȇd�7Û
ǡǨȬǘǧ¡ǧųÝǥ�ǔǺdIJ,[ǴȬYåǥ)�ă«ǥǷǝǠĔǤǝǠDžǺǧǛǼdžljƾļ
ÜǨĚēǔǺNJȬİ 3 óȳİ 13 óǧWóǬǧdIJÓĀǥ�ǔǺ)�ă«ǧ�Ʊǧ,[ǨȬĽťĕÓ®«ǧÓĀǵ%ÅǧuNjǑNJ�ƛrGǔǺǏǢǨDŽǝǠǴȬuNjǤƘDžǨŞǸǻǤDžƾǏǻ
Ǩİ 1 óljǸİ 2 óǬǧ�ƥǥLjǍǺōŕNJņǾ´DžǠuNjnjȬİ 2 ó�ƥǡdIJʼnǥt�ǧrDNJDŽǝǠǴȬİ 1ódIJʼnǢíǭǚ+ǹÇǥǘǻǮǣ�ƱǒǤDžǚdzǛǢňLJǸǻǺƾ
)$�.
Exp(B) B S.E. Exp(B) B S.E.+�L�7O;+8�CM
��+ 0.926 -0.077 (0.054) 1.213 0.193† (0.099)J2-�<L�7O@:<M
�!�< 1.256 0.228** (0.080) 1.399 0.336* (0.142)�>%< 1.621 0.483*** (0.071) 1.328 0.284* (0.132)�?�%< 1.230 0.207* (0.093) 1.245 0.219 (0.161)B15/'KL�7O174M�184 0.905 -0.099 (0.074) 1.006 0.006 (0.136)�194��8�C 1.056 0.054 (0.207) 1.313 0.272 (0.353)�2��L�7OHG�32M
H�2 1.044 0.043 (0.065) 1.542 0.433*** (0.116) "IJ2"I�A 1.374 0.318*** (0.076) 1.207 0.188 (0.150)J�(&0N� HGL�7O#EM
��=� 1.617 0.480*** (0.083) 2.049 0.717*** (0.170) "I�2 1.549 0.438*** (0.087) 2.074 0.730*** (0.178) 1 ���8�C 1.285 0.251† (0.130) 1.843 0.612* (0.250)2�,DL�7O �M
��� 1.084 0.081 (0.065) 1.302 0.264* (0.111)��� 1.014 0.014 (0.066) 0.727 -0.319* (0.128)�8�C 0.216 -1.534*** (0.350) 0.401 -0.915 (0.592)�9 0.194 -1.639*** (0.114) 0.021 -3.857*** (0.226)6Mn=7,563, ***p<0.000 **p<0.001 *p<0.05 †p<0.1
���*F B25�C
7
ǢǨDžLJȬİ 2ó�ƥǔǭǠǧųÝǥdIJǒǠnjǻǚȉȨȏǨ 90�ǢƯ�ǥ�ǤDžƾWóǡdIJʼnNJ�ǒǕǞ0ǻÐǽǹǤNJǸȬ500 ȉȨȏ;¡ǧdQÅǾŀ¹ǡNjǠDžǺǏǢǥǤǺƾİ 1 óljǸľĿǒǠdIJǾĿǍǠDžǺdIJʼnǨǣǧǷdžǤ�ƿǤǧǛǼdžljƾǰǚȬİ 2óǡȋȦȜȣljǸ��ōŕǒǤNJǸǴȬ¡ǧųÝǡ¥õǔǺdIJʼnǨǣǧǷdžǤ�ƿǛǼdžljƾ Ś 4ǥĢǒǚǧǨȬİ 1óljǸİ 13óǰǡ1ǠdIJǔǺǧǨǣǧǷdžǤ�ƿljǾ7ÛǒǚļÜ
ǡDŽǺƾ1ǠdIJǒǚȉȨȏNJ 90�Ǣ�ǤnjȬæýŰ�NJuNjnjǤǝǠDžǺǚdzǥWąĮrÅǧ%ÅNJÓ®ǥǤǹǥnjnjǤǝǠDžǺǴǧǧȬDžnjǞljǧrÅNJĽťĕǥÓ®ǢǤǝǠDžǺƾ İ 2 ódIJǧÓĀǥLjǍǺ,[ǢYåǥȬy«Ǩď«ǷǹǴ1ǠǧųÝǥdIJǒǵǔnjȬ�k
ěȧĞ�ěȪȧ10ȩîýǡǨĤw�ěȫǧƸÞ6ƊʼnǨħčěǧnXǥíǭǠ1ǠǧųÝǥdIJǒǵǔDžƾƸ 3ÎǧÞ4¯ŃNJ��ȧĀdIJǛǝǚċ¢Ǩ1ųÝdIJʼnǡǨǤDž,[ǥDŽǺƾĀdIJǨǔǭljǸnjǀ1dIJʼnǁǡǤDžǚdzǥ��ǢǰǢdzǚNJȬ��ǢĀdIJǡǰǢdzǠǴYåǥ
ǀ��ǁNJÓ®ǢǤǺǚdzȬ¯Ń��Ǜǝǚ�NJ1ųÝdIJʼnǥǤǹǥnjDžǧǛǢDžLJǺƾİ 1óÎ�ƹȬ�ÞȡȦȇȬƸJ¡�ÔȮ�ƖƈǨȬ%ÅǨuNjDžǴǧǧæýŰ�NJuNjDžǚdzljĽť
ĕǥÓ®ǥǨǤǝǠDžǤDžƾ Ś 4ƺ İ 1óȳİ 13ó1dIJʼnljǘǻ�sljǾ£�rÅǢǒǚ�ƲȥȎȏȕȁȔȇd�7Û
İ 2óōŕljǸǧ¥õǢ)�ă«ƣǧƤƕǾŞǚǧNJŚ 5ǡDŽǺƾ¥õʼnǨ 646ȉȨȏǡDŽǝ
ǚƾǏǻǾDZǺǢȬǵǨǹİ 2 óǬǧdIJǵ1dIJǢYåǥȬ10ȩîýǡǨDŽǺNJy«Ǩď«ǥ
Exp(B) B S.E.$�C�/F3$�0�;D
��$ 1.155 0.144† (0.086)A*&�4C�/F824D
���4 1.254 0.226† (0.126)�6 4 1.480 0.392*** (0.112)�7� 4 1.264 0.235 (0.146):1-'"BC�/F17,D�18, 0.864 -0.147 (0.112)�19, ��0�; 0.646 -0.437 (0.379)�*���C�/F?>�+*D
?�* 1.008 0.008 (0.101) �@A*��@�9 1.362 0.309* (0.121)A�#!(E��?>C�/F�=D
���5� 1.565 0.448** (0.139) �@�* 1.557 0.443** (0.140) )������0�; 1.492 0.400* (0.201)*�%<C�/F�D
��� 0.969 -0.031 (0.104)�� 1.099 0.095 (0.101)�0�; 0.177 -1.733* (0.719)�1 0.050 -2.987*** (0.182).Dn=7,563, ***p<0.000 **p<0.001 *p<0.05 †p<0.1
8
íǭǠ¥õǒǵǔnjȬ�kěȪ10ȩîýȫȧĞ�ěǧƸÞ6ƊʼnǨħčěǧnXǥíǭǠ¥õǒǵǔDžǏǢNJ7ljǺƾ>LJǠȬ�ŊʼnǨǘǻ�sǥíǭǠ¥õǒǥnjDžǢDžLJǺƾǰǚȬƸ 3ÎǧÞ4¯ŃNJĀdIJǡDŽǝǚnXǨ¥õǒǥnjDžǢDždž,[NJDŽǺƾ
Ś 5ƺ İ 2óōŕljǸǧ¥õǾ£�rÅǢǒǚ�ƲȥȎȏȕȁȔȇd�7Û
×ĬǡǨȬJLPS-H NJ¶LJǺcƵǢǒǠȚȘȣųÝljǸǧæ×ōŕǾRǹ�ǎȬ8ÕōŕǢǘ
ǧ¡ǧdIJ,[Ȫ1dIJȬ¥õȫNJǣǧǷdžǤ)�ă«Ǿ¹ǞȉȨȏǥLjDžǠċǓǵǔDžǧljǾá
Ŧǒǚƾ 7ÛǧļÜljǸȬJLPS-H ǧİ 2 ó�ƥǧȖȨȒǥǨȬ«9ǵƸÞ±hěȬ�ÞȡȦȇȬƸJ
¡ƖƈȬƸ 3 ÎǧÞ4¯Ńıǧ�«ǥǷǝǠ+ǹNJċǓǠDžǺǏǢNJ7ljǝǚƾy«ǵƖ�ÞJâċȬ¯Ń��Ǜǝǚ�ǧdIJNJǷǹ�njPÍǑǻǚȖȨȒǛǢDždžǏǢǡDŽǺƾ ǏǻǾƉǰLJǺǢȬJLPS-Hǧİ 2ó�ƥǾ]dzǚ7ÛǥǞDžǠ��ǧǏǢǾºÃǡNjǺƾ ǰǕİ 2ó�ƥǧWóǾ7ÛǔǺƪǥǨȬWóǡt�ƘDžǨDŽǺǴǧǧȬǘǧȖȨȒNJųÝƢ
|Îǥ�ǑǻǚìƫfǷǹǴy«Ȭ�kěȧĞ�ěȪȧĤw�ěȫ±hÞ6ƊʼnȬƖ�Þ6ƊʼnȬ
ƸJ¡Ɩ�ʼn�ȬƸ 3 ίŃ���ǥ+ǝǚǴǧǡDŽǺǏǢǾůŷǒǠLjnj¨ŝNJDŽǺƾǏǻǨİ1óǢȖȨȒǾĸǟǍǠ7ÛǔǺƪǴYåǡDŽǺƾ ǰǚȬİ 1óljǸİ 13óǾ1Ǡ"ČǔǺnXǥǨȬy«Ȭ�kěȧĞ�ěȧĤw�ě±hÞ6
Exp(B) B S.E.$�C�/F3$�0�;D
��$ 2.012 0.692** (0.234)A*&�4C�/F824D
���4 2.408 0.878* (0.377)�6 4 2.384 0.876* (0.361)�7� 4 2.069 0.727† (0.424):1-'"BC�/F17,D�18, 1.172 0.164 (0.327)�19, ��0�; 2.332 0.859 (0.646)�*���C�/F?>�+*D
?�* 1.155 0.147 (0.252) �@A*��@�9 0.716 -0.333 (0.420)A�#!(E��?>C�/F�=D
���5� 1.696 0.509 (0.390) �@�* 0.928 -0.083 (0.438) )������0�; 1.753 0.576 (0.543)*�%<C�/F�D
��� 1.053 0.097 (0.239)���0�; 0.484 -0.778* (0.311)�1 0.003 -5.879*** (0.609).Dn=7,563, ***p<0.000 **p<0.001 *p<0.05 †p<0.1
9
ƊʼnȬƸ 3 ίŃ����ǥ+ǝǚǴǧǡDŽǺǏǢǾůŷǔǺ¨ŝNJDŽǺǢDžLJǺƾǤLjȬ1óǡǨǤDžǴǧǧ 3ó��Ǿ:ČǔǺnXǥǞDžǠǨȬ×ĬǡǨ7ÛǾŘǝǠDžǤDžǴǧǧYåǥă�ǧ�ǥ+ǝǚȖȨȒǢǤǝǠǒǰdžUŌ«NJƸDžƾǘǧǚdzȬǣǧǷdžǤ+ǹNJŞǸǻǺǧljǾĠ
ůǒǠljǸ7ÛǾŘdžǏǢNJïdzǸǻǺƾ ȖȨȒǥ+ǹNJDZǸǻǺƪǧ�©ǢǒǠǥňLJǸǻǺǧǨ��ǧ 2ǞǡDŽǺƾ 1 ǞǨȬȖȨȒǧ+ǹǾ;ÁǢǒǠcƵŨ�ǵŸŵȬļŵǧÁĢǾŘdžǏǢǡDŽǺƾǚǢLJǩİ 1
óljǸİ 13óǰǡ1ǠǾ"ČǔǺnXǥȬy«ǥ+ǹNJDZǸǻǺǚdzǥy«ǥƦ�ǒǠ7ÛǾŘǝǚǹȬy«NJtDžȖȨȒǾ.ǥǒǚ7ÛļÜǡDŽǺǏǢǾÌĢǒǚǹǔǺǏǢNJǡNjǺǛǼdžƾy«
ǧľĿȋȦȜȣǾ��Ġ'ǡNjǺǏǢǨ JLPS-H ȖȨȒǧuNjǤ:ÿǡDŽǺƾy«ǧȡȂțȊȨȏǨď«ǥíǭǠtåǡDŽǹȬtåǤȆȟȢȀǾȚȘȣȧȖȨȒǡáŦǡNjǺǏǢǧ®ŇǨuNjDžǢŤ
LJǺƾ Ǵdž 1 ǞǨȬĽť²òǾČDžǠȖȨȒǧ+ǹǾśêǒǠǒǰdžǏǢǡDŽǺƾǏǧ 20 �ǮǣǧƣǥȬ
ȚȘȣųÝǥLjǍǺæ×ōŕǢǘǻǥ�ǝǠċǓǺșȂȀȏǥǞDžǠǨŸŵNJƖdzǸǻǠLjǹȬ
Inverse Probability WeightingòǾǨǓdzǢǒǠȬǘǧǷdžǤșȂȀȏǾśêǔǺĽť²òNJÁĢǑǻǠDžǺȪWooldridge 2002Ȭj× 2006ȫƾǏǧǷdžǤĽť²òǧƙČ#Ǩ¯�ǧȚȘȣųÝNJ�§ǡDŽǹȬƸÞh�ÎǾƄÿǢǔǺǷdžǤȚȘȣųÝǥ�ǔǺBÜǨÌǸljǡǨǤDžǴǧǧȬ
"ČǾáŦǔǺ!iǨH7ǥDŽǺǛǼdžƾ Ñ¡ǥ×ĬǧƦđǾ»ǎǠLjnjƾ×ĬǡǨİ 1 óǡŢ�Ǒǻǚ)�ă«Ǣǘǧ¡ǧųÝǬǧ
©ŶȧdIJ,[ǧƤƕǾáŦǒǠNjǚNJȬǘǻ�sǧ)�ƣǧĔƃ«ǥlǟnjæ×ōŕǥǞDž
ǠǨáŦǡNjǠDžǤDž4ƾǘǧǚdzȬǚǢLJǩƭ�ǵ�Ŋ/Ȭ)�ǧ«àȬ6ƊƩ�ǤǣNJdIJ,
[ǥ�ƱǒǠDžǺljǣdžljǨ7ljǝǠDžǤDžƾǘǧ®^ǡȬ�ǥƐǭǚōŕǬǧ�©ǥǴƦđNJ
DŽǺǢDžLJǺƾǏǧǷdžǤƦđǾƉǰLJǞǞ7ÛǵŸŵǾŘǝǠDžnj~FNJïdzǸǻǺǛǼdžƾ 3
Brinton, Mary C., 2008, Lost in Transition: Youth, Work, and Instability in
Postindustrial Japan, Massachusetts: Cambridge University Press. ȪȲĆčÓVĖ(ȧðØIħŪȬ2008ȬǂvǽǻǚnǾ¾ǒǠ―ȥȏȗȎȄȘȤȨȍȠȦǧģ��―ǃNTT6Ăȫ
×čĎĶȬ2005ȬǂœʼnǢ��―ǀ�ÞĻĎǧ�ŊǁǾƅLJǠǃÚ�u�6Ă�ȭ �2�Ȭ2008ȬǀȚȘȣųÝǥ�ǔǺK=·\ʼnǧ,[―ƸÞċǾ�ŻǢǒǚųÝȖȨȒǾǴǢǥ―ǁǂĮÄu�u�Ƨģ��ğĭĨ�mǃ15: 81-94.
�2�Ȭ2009ȬǀȚȘȣųÝǥLjǍǺ8ÕōŕȋȦȜȣǧ,[―ƸÞċǾ�ŻǢǒǚȚȘȣųÝȖȨȒǾǴǢǥ―ǁǂĮÄu�u�Ƨģ��ğĭĨ�mǃ16: 21-33.
ĞčöłŖȬ2006ȬǂƸÞċǧƖƈƚµǢ®ŷr�ǃȬÚ�u�ģ�Ĩ�ğĭ±ȭ �ƌaȬ2014ȬǀNFRJ-08Panel ǥLjǍǺȃȄȂȗǥǷǺōŕǬǧ�5ǁǂ�Éģ��ğĭǃ26
4 �ǥİ2ó�ƥǡ¬mǾ¤ǸǻǚǢǒǠǴȬ500;¡ǧãdzǠƦǸǻǚȉȨȏǥǞDžǠ¬mNJDŽǹȬİ 1ó�8ǧȋȦȜȣǧdžǜ 7000��ǧȉȨȏǥǞDžǠ¬mNJǤDžǏǢǥǤǺƾǘǧǚdzȬǢnjǥ8ÕōŕǾüǔǺƪǥǘǧ¬mǾČDžǺǏǢǨ�UŌǥƎDžƾ
10
(2): 169-178. �þùȬ2012ȬǀǤǗȚȘȣȧȖȨȒǾ7ÛǔǺǧNJ¨ŝǤǧlj―ȚȘȣȧȖȨȒ7Ûǧă«ǧĺ�―ǁǂĉŵǢÇòǃ27 (1): 23-40.
j×_ƮȬ2006ȬǀȋȦȜȣōŕǥƤǔǺ7Û――ǂ÷ƁċõǥƤǔǺȚȘȣųÝǃǾČDžǚōŕǧş�ŝeǢÀťșȂȀȏǧáūǁǂË×A-ğĭƬŮǃ551: 55-70.
�ŗƷłȬ2017Ȭǂà�ǧƕƟǢœʼn 3ƺ ȡȂțȖȌȂȦǢ�ÔǃCŔÏ°ȭ čƍ&�Ȭ2012ȬǀÚuģğȧœ�q�ȚȘȣųÝǁǧæ×ōŕǥƤǔǺ7Û: ōŕ;�ǧ¬mǾČDžǚŝe7ÛǁǂÚ�u�ģ�Ĩ�ğĭ± ȚȘȣųÝȜȥȎȄȇȗƺ ȖȁȏȅȔȍȠȦȝȨȚȨȍȢȨȐƺ No. 56ǃȬÚ�u�ģ�Ĩ�ğĭ±.
Wooldridge, Jeffrey M., 2001, Econometric Analysis of Cross Section and Panel Data, Massachusetts: The MIT Press.
Wooldridge, Jeffrey M., 2002, “Inverse probability weighted M-estimators for sample selection, attrition, and stratification” Portuguese Economic Journal, 1 (2): 117-139.
�����������"���#������ �
S 2006 2009 2010 2014 C 2013
2016 2015 2017 A 2015 2018B 2016 2020 2018 2024
2004 2006
2006
2008
�����������"���#���� ������ $�%�%�!%��� �
http://csrda.iss.u-tokyo.ac.jp/panel/