CRM in the New World of Lending - CUNA Councils · 2015-03-08 · 8 Lending CRM Definitions of CRM...
Transcript of CRM in the New World of Lending - CUNA Councils · 2015-03-08 · 8 Lending CRM Definitions of CRM...
PRESENTED TO:
crnrstone.com gonzobanker.com480.423.2030
PRESENTED BY:
November 3, 2014
CRM in the New World of Lending
Terence Roche - Principal
CUNA Lending Council
1
Lending CRM
62.8%60.5% 60.0%
62.4%
73.2%70.2% 69.5%
72.8%
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
70%
80%
90%
100%
2010 2011 2012 2013
Loans to Assets
Loans to Shares
Source: NCUA
The Struggle For Organic Loan Growth in Credit Unions
2
Lending CRMWe Grew Up On A Traditional Formula
Traditional Media Marketing
Drives the face-to-face closing
And the cross-sell
3
Lending CRMBut The Rules Are Changing
Mobile and Social Search
Multi-Channel Fulfillment
New World of Engagement
4
Lending CRMBoom! It’s Game On for Lending
5
Lending CRMLending Disrupters are Showing the Future of CRM and Sales
Mortgage Lending
Impact: Interest Income, Origination Fees, Loan Growth, Cross-Selling Opportunities.
The loan offer is integrated into the
research and buying decision.
One Click…
Source: Trulia.com
6
Lending CRMLending Disrupters
Business Lending
• CircleUp is a crowd funding platform that connects accredited investors with innovative entrepreneurs that have solid business models in the consumer and retail space.
• Funding stories on their website range from 550k to 2.5MM
Consumer Lending
• Lending Club, an online peer-to-peer lending community, has funded nearly 3 billion in loans since its inception 5 years ago.
• Quoted from their website: “We bring you a more efficient model. By allowing our members to directly invest in and borrow from each other, we avoid the cost and complexity of the banking system and pass the savings on to you. Both sides can win: better rates to borrowers and better returns to investors. It's that simple.”
Impact: Interest Income, Loan Growth, Cross-Selling Opportunities.
Impact: Interest Income, Loan Growth, Cross-Selling Opportunities
New players want to disrupt lending
intermediation.
7
Lending CRM
Customers Buy The Channel Experience Not Products ● Customers are focused on channels as this is the way
they interact with their financial institution● In this channel centric (and increasingly mobile)
relationship, it’s time to re-think organizational alignment and focus on capabilities per channel rather than products
Experience is Getting Short Shrift in Banking
8
Lending CRMDefinitions of CRM
8
“It’s simply a tool that should help our RMs manage relationships more efficiently and effectively.”
CRM
“CRM is a well defined set of strategies to ensure effective growth or retention of profitable business and consumer relationships.”
“Megadatabase of information accessible to the line for customer service and business development use.”
“An understanding of our profitable customer base as it relates to current wallet share across all subs, in-process product/service discussions and their association with other entities/relationships.”
“A means of providing information to relationship managers to understand all aspects of their client relationships by combining/aggregating accounts by relationship, providing calling history on their clients by any credit union personnel, calculating and showing profitability, and providing sales tracking and business development opportunities.”
“CRM is a set of methodologies and predefined business practices related to management of the customer relationships in this enterprise.”
9
Lending CRMKey CRM Components
Data Analytics / Segmentation
Prospecting
Campaign Management
Sales Referrals/Tracking
Case Management
Contact History
360 Member View
10
Lending CRM
● Data warehouse infrastructure, support
● The ability to capture and assimilate data from various sources
– Core
– MCIF
– Third party demographic data
– SEG related and provided data
– Channel specific solutions
– Staff production and activity management solutions
– Profitability and other ancillary systems
● The ability to maintain data history
● The ability to perform statistical analysis on the data
Key CRM Components
Data Analytics / Segmentation
Prospecting
Campaign Management
Sales Referrals/Tracking
Case Management
Contact History
360 Member View
● Most Credit Unions have data scattered in different databases. The ability to draw all of this into a single reporting source is difficult. Vendors have not helped solve this.
● Best practice: Single data repository that norms up different data sources, formats
11
Lending CRMKey CRM Components
● The ability to track new prospects through a sales cycle
– Initial contact
– Offer/presentation
– Follow-up
– Close
● Documents and supporting information is accessible with 1 click
● There is tracking but often in a stand-alone tool such as Salesforce
● Often, new prospect tracking is not integrated with campaigns
● The need foe this is heavier in business and mortgage lending (Originators)
● Best practice: – Tracking and reporting the movement from initial
contact to close phases via workflow– Integration with the decisioning system– Cross-sell integrated into workflow, processing
Data Analytics / Segmentation
Prospecting
Campaign Management
Sales Referrals/Tracking
Case Management
Contact History
360 Member View
12
Lending CRM
● The ability to create specific offers and present them to members and non-members through any channel
● The ability to assign follow-up to an employee or team
● The ability to track results by campaign, member, employee
● The ability to analyze ROI on the campaign
Key CRM Components
Data Analytics / Segmentation
Prospecting
Campaign Management
Sales Referrals/Tracking
Case Management
Contact History
360 Member View
13
Lending CRMKey CRM Components
● Current systems do a good job at using member information to create targeted campaigns
● Ability to present the offer through any channel -branch employee, CC agent, mobile, Internet banking -is mixed
● Best practices:– Very flexible campaign selection criteria– Targeted Campaigns with follow-up assigned– All channels show most recent offer, decision
(mobile is a channel)– Method of offer (mailing, e-mail) can be viewed– Hard tracking of approvals that turn into fundings– Offers that were refused, denials are displayed
● The next big things– Loan offer integrated with research, buying
decision– Social marketing– Mobile offers
Data Analytics / Segmentation
Prospecting
Campaign Management
Sales Referrals/Tracking
Case Management
Contact History
360 Member View
14
Lending CRMNavy Federal Credit Union Make Social Media Count
Engaged members by asking them to submit positive, personal messages about the CU, with the chance to win CU products.
Further engaged members by giving them a chance to vote on winners.
“4 million members, 4 million stories”
15
Lending CRMNavy Federal
Targeted friends of their existing Facebook fans who also fit into military segment.
With social media engagement way up, Navy FCU incorporated auto and other promotional offers into social flow.
Integrate the PR/social part of social media with “soft” efforts that drive business production.
16
Lending CRMNavy Federal Credit Union
Navy’s use of social media as part of the “4 million” campaign has been written about in The Financial Brand and Facebook used the campaign as a standout success story.
The campaign drove in hard dollars:• $90 million in new deposits• 5,400 auto refinance loans (equating to $96 million)
Relative to Navy’s $33 billion in loans and $37 billion in deposits at that time (Q3 2012), that translates to:
• 0.24% increase in deposits• 0.29% increase in loans
Navy also acquired 60k new members and increased Facebook fans by 500% (today over 1 million).
17
Lending CRMKey CRM Components
● Prospect, opportunity tracking with the ability to upload any information tracked to fulfillment systems when a sale is made
– Both from campaigns and individual leads● Employee-level tracking of sales opportunities,
offers made, success ratio● Assignment of referrals to the right resource
with feedback provided to the referring employee
● Fast creation of information to sales leaders for feedback, coaching
● Tracking and reporting of incentives, payments
● Most Credit Unions have some form of tracking sales referrals, but it can involve different systems in the CU and CUSO’s
● Referrals create a task for the recipient, but can often be on a stand-alone “to do” list
● Best practices:– Clear referral goals by business group (not just branches!)– Rigorous tracking and reporting of referral follow-ups– Daily tools for supervisors/coaches to use to manage
●
Data Analytics / Segmentation
Prospecting
Campaign Management
Sales Referrals/Tracking
Case Management
Contact History
360 Member View
18
Lending CRMKey CRM Components
● Tracking of specific encounters with members that involved:
– Specific issues or questions that require notes, comments
– Escalation and resolution
– Follow-up to offers or campaigns
● Follow-up events
Data Analytics / Segmentation
Prospecting
Campaign Management
Sales Referrals/Tracking
Case Management
Contact History
360 Member View
● This is largely used for servicing loan, not origination
● Call center systems are usually the ones used by the rest of the CU
● Best practice: – Ability to identify a loan opportunity during a
member encounter and pass to the referral system with case notes
– Campaigns, offers integrated into the case management system inquiry
19
Lending CRMKey CRM Components
● A complete list of all member “touches” with the Credit Union
– Manually tracked by an employee
– Service transactions (branch, call center)
– Self-service transactions (ATM, Internet banking log-in)
– Payments transactions
– Mobile
● Again. largely used for servicing● Most CU’s do put the prospecting/sales
notes in the origination system, not the servicing contact history system
● Best Practices:– Integrated sales and servicing
touches in one system– Integration of campaigns into the
contact history system with one click to see supporting documentation, offers
Data Analytics / Segmentation
Prospecting
Campaign Management
Sales Referrals/Tracking
Case Management
Contact History
360 Member View
20
Lending CRMKey CRM Components
● Prospect, opportunity tracking with the ability to upload any information tracked to fulfillment systems when a sale is made
● Employee-level tracking of sales opportunities, offers made, success ratio
● Fast creation of information to sales leaders for feedback, coaching
● Tracking and reporting of incentives, payments
Best practices:● Non-owner relationships displayed (guarantor)● Total loans outstanding displayed● One click to see offers accepted and refused
Data Analytics / Segmentation
Prospecting
Campaign Management
Sales Referrals/Tracking
Case Management
Contact History
360 Member View
21
Lending CRMSolution Considerations
Integrated Solutions:Solonis CoreTrac
Sedona Sugar
Kiva Argo
360 View
Core Vendors
Integrated Solutions:Solonis CoreTrac
Sedona Sugar
Kiva Argo
360 View
Core Vendors
Point Solutions:
Harte Hankes
Alliant CRM Systems, TX
Raddon
Marquis
Point Solutions:
Harte Hankes
Alliant CRM Systems, TX
Raddon
Marquis
Toolsets:Oracle
Siebel
SAP
Microsoft Dynamics
Salesforce.com
Toolsets:Oracle
Siebel
SAP
Microsoft Dynamics
Salesforce.com
Internally developed:
Various tools - .net, Java, Sharepoint
Internally developed:
Various tools - .net, Java, Sharepoint
22
CRM Lending
● Does everybody use the same CRM system?
– Insurance, investment, other CUSO’s?
● How do we balance the better functionality of some point systems against the better integration of a single system?
– “The business lending group just bought Salesforce!.........”
● Do we have our “CRM nomenclature” right?
– What is a unique product, service to measure?
● What is our big, first “overweight” goal?
– Sales tracking
– Referrals
– Service events and member encounter tracking
Key CRM System Questions
23
Lending CRM
● Cross-channel marketing and fulfillment and a very strong Mobile Experience
● …meets the next gen CRM Data Mashup and analytics
● …meets the Social Media marketing of upstarts● …meets the Amazon-like fulfillment and support
process● …and is managed by passionate sales leaders with
specific goals and accountability
How Do We Build the Winning Lending Formula With Our Resources?