Critical Steps for Real-Time PCR Analysis: Tips and Solutions to Achieve Efficient and Precise Gene...
-
Upload
qiagen -
Category
Healthcare
-
view
701 -
download
0
Transcript of Critical Steps for Real-Time PCR Analysis: Tips and Solutions to Achieve Efficient and Precise Gene...
Sample to Insight
1
Critical Steps for Real-Time PCR AnalysisTips and solutions to achieve efficient and precise gene expression results
Lily Xuanyan Xu – Global Market Manager QIAGEN
1
Sample to Insight
2
Legal disclaimer
QIAGEN products shown here are intended for molecular biology applications. These products are not intended for the diagnosis, prevention or treatment of a disease.
For up-to-date licensing information and product-specific disclaimers, see the respective QIAGEN kit handbook or user manual. QIAGEN kit handbooks and user manuals are available at www.QIAGEN.com or can be requested from QIAGEN Technical Services or your local distributor.
Sample to Insight
3
Agenda
Gene expression workflows
1.1 Advantages of real-time PCR
Critical steps for real-time PCR analysis
2.1 Stabilization of RNA in-sample
2.2 RNA isolation
2.3 cDNA synthesis
QIAGEN gene expression workflow solutions
Questions
1
2
3
4
Sample to Insight
4
Agenda
Gene expression workflows
1.1 Advantages of real-time PCR
Critical steps for real-time PCR analysis
2.1 Stabilization of RNA in-sample
2.2 RNA isolation
2.3 cDNA synthesis
QIAGEN gene expression workflow solutions
Questions
1
2
3
4
Sample to Insight
5
Gene expression profiling
Understanding biological pathways and cellular systemGene expression is regulated at different levels• Transcriptional
• Post-transcriptional
• Translational
• Post-translational
Available experiment methods• Real-time PCR
• Northern blotting
• DNA microarray
• Next-Gen sequencing
Overview of gene expression profiling
Sample to Insight
6
Gene expression profiling
Understanding biological pathways and cellular system.Gene expression is regulated at different levels:• Transcriptional
• Post-transcriptional
• Translational
• Post-translational
Available experiment methods:• Real-time PCR
◦ Sensitive
◦ Quantitative
◦ Reliable
• Northern blotting
• DNA microarray
• Next-Gen sequencing
Overview of gene expression profiling
Sample to Insight
7
Basic gene expression workflow using real-time PCR
RNA quality (purity and integrity) plays a critical role in the accuracy, reproducibility and relevance of downstream analysis.
Sample to Insight
8
Challenges in gene expression workflows
• DNase contamination
• Salt carry-over
• Phenol carry-over
• gDNA contamination
• Complex samples
• Low yield
• Extraction techniques
• RNase contamination
• Improper storage
• RNA degradation
• Sample handling
• Low abundance transcripts
• Large transcripts
• High GC content
• Secondary structure
• Introducing bias
• Low yield
• gDNA removal
• IC controls
• Pipetting errors
• Room temperature setup
• Primer design
• Sensitivity
• Restrictions due to the cyclers
• Calibration and maintenance efforts
Sample to Insight
9
Agenda
Gene expression workflows
1.1 Advantages of real-time PCR
Critical steps for real-time PCR analysis
2.1 Stabilization of RNA in-sample
2.2 RNA isolation
2.3 cDNA synthesis
QIAGEN gene expression workflow solutions
Questions
1
2
3
4
Sample to Insight
10
Agenda
Gene expression workflows
1.1 Advantages of real-time PCR
Critical steps for real-time PCR analysis
2.1 Stabilization of RNA in-sample
2.2 RNA isolation
2.3 cDNA synthesis
QIAGEN gene expression workflow solutions
Questions
1
2
3
4
Sample to Insight
11
Sample collection and stabilization
Changes in mRNA levels following sample harvesting
Sample to Insight
12
Effect of stabilization
Purification of RNA without degradation
Sample to Insight
13
Principles of RNA stabilization
What do we want to achieve?
• Prevent induction of new RNA transcription
• Avoid regulated turnover of mRNA
• Impede unspecific degradation of RNA – either enzymatically (due to release of nucleases
from specific cell types or compartments) or chemically (pH, temperature, etc. dependent)
Approaches:
• Agents that bind directly to nucleic acids
• Agents that lyse cells
• Agents that inhibit, denature and / or precipitate nucleases (and proteins in general)
Sample to Insight
14
Requirements for stabilization of blood and tissue samples
Blood contains only individual cells but has a high protein content:• Diffusion rates of the stabilizing agent are not problematic
• Agents that precipitate or cross-link proteins are detrimental
• In principle, blood volume is not limited (container is limited)
• One-step stabilization technology is required
Tissue contains connected cells:• Diffusion rates of the stabilizing agent are critical
• Thickness of the tissue sample is limited
• Multi-step technology applicable as tissue pieces are transferrable
• Protein precipitation or cross-linking is not an issue
14Practical Hints for Real-Time PCR
QIAGEN offers a variety of stabilization reagents for several different sample types: blood, tissue, cells, bone marrow, bacteria, saliva etc.
Sample to Insight
15
Agenda
Gene expression workflows
1.1 Advantages of real-time PCR
Critical steps for real-time PCR analysis
2.1 Stabilization of RNA in-sample
2.2 RNA isolation
2.3 cDNA synthesis
QIAGEN gene expression workflow solutions
Questions
1
2
3
4
Sample to Insight
16
Agenda
Gene expression workflows
1.1 Advantages of real-time PCR
Critical steps for real-time PCR analysis
2.1 Stabilization of RNA in-sample
2.2 RNA isolation
2.3 cDNA synthesis
QIAGEN gene expression workflow solutions
Questions
1
2
3
4
Sample to Insight
17
Sample disruption and homogenization
Disruption and homogenization: two distinct steps.Disruption: complete disruption of tissue structure, cell walls and plasma membranes of cells is required to release all the RNA contained in the sample. • Different samples require different methods to achieve complete disruption.
• Incomplete disruption results in significantly reduced yields.
Homogenization: Homogenization is necessary to reduce the viscosity of the cell lysates produced by disruption. Homogenization shears the high-molecular-weight genomic DNA and other high-molecular-weight cellular components to create a homogeneous lysate. • Incomplete homogenization results in inefficient binding of RNA and therefore significantly
reduced yields.
Efficient disruption and homogenization - an absolute requirement
Sample to Insight
18
Manual disruption and homogenization
Classic Method
Step 1: Freeze the sample in liquid nitrogen
Step 2: Grind tissue into a powder using a mortar and pestle• Approach works well but it is not consistent
Step 3: Resuspend powdered sample in chaotropic lysis buffer• Genomic DNA is still high molecular weight and will add viscosity to
the sample that can clog spin filters
Step 4: Shear with needle and syringe, improving the efficiency of gDNA removal from columns• Care needed to prevent foaming but still be effective
Sample to Insight
19
Simultaneous Disruption and Homogenization
TissueRuptor• One sample / run
• Disposable probes
• Rotor-stator
TissueLyser LT• Up to 12 samples in parallel
• Bead mill
TissueLyser II• Up to 48 or 192 samples
in parallel
• Bead mill
Mechanical disruption and homogenization
Human / animal tissuePlant tissue
Human / animal tissuePlant tissueBacteriaYeast
Human / animal tissuePlant tissueBacteriaYeast
Sample to Insight
20
Effective tissue disruption
Various rat tissues were disrupted using the TissueLyser LT or TissueLyser II
RNA was purified from 20 mg samples on the QIAcube using the RNeasy Fibrous Tissue Mini Kit (skin, heart, and lung) or RNeasy Lipid Tissue Mini Kit (brain).
Sample to Insight
21
Comparison of RNA yields with different homogenization methods
QIAshredder – fast and simple homogenization of cell lysates
Sample to Insight
mRNA enrichment
mRNA enrichment
Selective exclusion of RNA < 200 nt
mRNA
rRNA > 200 nt
tRNA, snRNA, miRNA < 200 nt
Practical Hints for Real-Time PCR 22
Sample to Insight
Choosing the right RNA purification product / protocol
Is the RNA purification procedure appropriate for the amount of starting material?• Overloading usually results in lower purity, lower yields
• With small samples, it is important to use an efficient RNA purification method
RNA purification from large samples: • Provides a pool of RNA that can be used for multiple experiments
• May be required to get sufficient amounts of RNA from samples that have low RNA content
• High binding capacity – usually also implies higher dead volume
Practical Hints for Real-Time PCR 23
Sample to Insight
24
Special consideration: Difficult-to-lyse tissues
Cells
Yeast
Some tissues• Liver• Spleen• Kidney
Lysis: Phenol-free lysis buffer
Fatty Tissues• Brain• Skin • Adipose tissues – e.g. breast
Lysis: Phenol / guanidine reagent
Fibrous Tissues• Muscle• Heart• Trachea• Lung
Lysis: Proteinase K or phenol / guanidine reagent
Easy to lyse Difficult to lyse
Some tissues require stronger lysis conditions
Sample to Insight
25
Special consideration: Fibrous tissue
Isolating RNA from heart, muscle and other fibrous tissue:
• Contractile proteins, connective tissue and collagen, which can all interfere with the isolation process
• Sample needs to be treated with a protease or phenol containing lysis reagents
• Proper conditions that do not degrade RNA, such as with an RNase-free proteinase K digest (RNeasy Fibrous Tissue Kit)
Sample to Insight
Precipitation vs. spin columns
Precipitation Spin columns
Cheap, no kits required, scalable Higher material cost
More handling, longer incubation times Fast, easy to use
Often several rounds of precipitation required for decent purity High purity
Risk to lose RNA pellet, especially with small samples
Special formats for different sample types and sizes, including very small samples
More room for error; inaccurate pipetting between phases can cause phenol carryover
Consistent, no phenol carry-over
26
Sample to Insight
27
Special consideration: FFPE samples
• Remove and fix tissue as quickly as possible• Use tissue samples no more than 5 mm thick and do
not over-fix (max 24 hours)• Use high-quality reagents for paraffin embedding,
without additives• Avoid sample staining, if possible• Store FFPE samples appropriately
Note: RNA remains intact for up to a year when stored at 4ºC
• Use an appropriate deparaffinization step• Have a crosslink-reversal step during RNA isolation
Minimize the effects of FFPE storage on RNA transcripts
Complete FFPE guide: Critical factors for molecular analysis of FFPE samples
Sample to Insight
FFPE sample – challenges
Formaldehyde fixation results in:• Protein-protein cross-linking• Protein-nucleic acid cross-linking• Nucleic acid-nucleic acid cross-linking
Paraffin embedding means:• Extended incubation at >60°C results in nucleic acid fragmentation• Deparaffination is required prior to nucleic acid preparation
• Harsh lysis conditions are required to break up tissue• Fragmentation of nucleic acids• Remaining formaldehyde modifications on nucleic acids interfere with enzymatic assays
(reverse transcription, PCR)
Practical Hints for Real-Time PCR 28
Sample to Insight
Heat incubation
Heat incubation in proteinase K digestion buffer helps to break formaldehyde crosslinks• Shorter PK digest possible (15 min)
• Better yield
• Better substrate for PCR
Limited by RNA stability: Longer incubation / higher temperature will remove more formaldehyde modifications, but will also result in more RNA fragmentation.
(1 section, 10 µm per prep; brain samples are from a different experiment)
Practical Hints for Real-Time PCR 30
Sample to Insight
Recovery of all usable RNA
Small RNA fragments efficiently recovered with RNeasy FFPE
Practical Hints for Real-Time PCR 31
RNA purified from 6-month-old FFPE rat liver using the RNeasy FFPE Kit or a kit from Supplier R was analyzed on the Agilent 2100® bioanalyzer
Sample to Insight
RNA from FFPE sections: quality / integrity
Quality of RNA from FFPE samples is compromised due to fragmentation (heat + buffer conditions)
Formaldehyde crosslink / modification of RNA
For cDNA synthesis and PCR:• Avoid oligo-dT priming (better: random or gene-specific priming)
• Choose short amplicons (<500 nt, if possible)
18
S
28
S
Flu
or
es
ce
nc
e
Time (seconds)
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
19 24 29 34 39 44 49 54 59 64 69
Flu
or
es
ce
nc
e
Time (seconds)
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
19 24 29 34 39 44 49 54 59 64 69
Fresh FFPE sample ~6 mo. old FFPE samplePCR control
128 208404
668
Practical Hints for Real-Time PCR 32
Sample to Insight
33
Special consideration: RNA from human blood samples
• Very small amounts of RNA
• RNA integrity – presence of RNases
• Cellular RNA or exosomal RNA
• Contaminants must be removed – anticoagulants heparin and EDTA, and naturally occurring enzyme inhibitors, all of which can interfere with downstream RNA analysis
PaxGene webinar and exosomes webinar available
Some challenges of human blood samples:
Sample to Insight
34
Special consideration: Plant material
Things to consider:
• Plant metabolites are difficult to remove
• Healthy young tissues recommendedo RNA yields often higher since young
tissue generally contains more cells and fewer metabolites than the same amount of older tissue
• Many “home-made” protocols RNA isolation recommend growing plants in darkness for 1 to 2 days before harvesting to prevent high levels of plant metabolite accumulation
Sample to Insight
Dedicated kits could solve the problem
Sample to Insight
Special consideration: RNA from bacteria and viruses
Bacterial RNA
• Bacterial mRNA has no 5’ cap and rarely has a poly-A tail
• mRNA isolation by hybrid capture is impossible
• The RNeasy Protect Bacteria Kit is makes bacterial gene expression studies possible
Viral RNA When purifying viral RNA and DNA from plasma and serum,
a major challenge is to concentrate the nucleic acids, as they may be extremely diluted in a large sample volume
QIAamp Kits allow purification of viral nucleic acids from starting volumes as high as 5 ml
Sample to Insight
Back to Basics: RNA Isolation 37
Removal of genomic DNA contamination
Why is removing gDNA so important?
Trace amounts of gDNA in an RNA sample can compromise the accuracy of sensitive applications such as real-time RT-PCR.
Both RNA and DNA targets may be amplified, leading to unreliable quantification of the intended RNA target.
Sample to Insight
Back to Basics: RNA Isolation 38
Removal of genomic DNA contamination
Eliminate genomic DNA contamination either during RNA purification or just prior to cDNA synthesis.
DNase digestion:• On-column, during isolation (DNA already bound to column)
• After RNA isolation, prior to cDNA synthesis
Non-enzymatic removal (columns or reagents).
Design primers to avoid coamplification of DNA targets.
QIAGEN solutions:• DNase digestion (with or without DNase Booster)• gDNA Eliminator Column – RNeasy Plus Kits• gDNA Eliminator Solution – RNeasy Plus Universal Kit
o The gDNA Eliminator Solution is a novel, non-enzymatic solution that reduces gDNA contamination of the aqueous phase. It does not contain DNase
Sample to Insight
microRNAs - micromanagers of gene expression
Characteristic of microRNAs:• Naturally occurring, endogenous small RNA
• A mature miRNA is approximately 22 nt long
• Regulate at least 1/3 of the protein encoding genes
• > 500 microRNAs in human
• Mediate post-transcriptional gene silencing either by translational repression or target mRNA degradation
• A typical human cell harbors 1,000–200,000 miRNAs in patterns unique to particular cell types
• One miRNA might bind 100 or more target mRNAs
• A single mRNA might have target sites for several different miRNAs
• http://microrna.sanger.ac.uk
Fine-tuning of gene expression:• Cell fate
• Differentiation
• Morphogenesis
• Development
• Many aspects of physiology
Practical Hints for Real-Time PCR 39
Sample to Insight
Biogenesis of microRNA
1. Transcribed by RNA polymerase II as pri-miRNAs.
2. In the nucleus, pri-miRNAs are processed to ~70 nt hairpin-like pre-miRNAs by DROSHA.
3. Pre-miRNAs are then exported from the nucleus by Exportin 5.
4. In the cytosol pre-miRNAs are processed to mature miRNAs by Dicer.
5. These miRNAs are incorporated into the RNA-induced silencing complex (RISC).
6. miRNAs with imperfect base pairing to the target mRNA• Lead to translational repression and/or mRNA
degradation
Cytosol
Practical Hints for Real-Time PCR 40
Sample to Insight
RIBOSOME
miRNA – how it works
3`5` AAAAAmRNA
RISC-like complex 5`P3`OH
5`P3`OH
3`UTR3`UTR Seed Region match
27
miRNA is incorporated in RISC and binds to a 7–9 nucleotide region in the 3´untranslated region of the mRNA (= 3´UTR seed region).This binding prevents the ribosome from translation of the GOI.→ The protein is down regulated.
Practical Hints for Real-Time PCR 41
Sample to Insight
miRNAs will likely enter the clinic as biomarkers and diagnostics
Most applications are expected to be in oncology because many miRNAs affect the cell cycle.
• Half of all human miRNAs discovered so far are expressed abnormally in at least one cancer
• Some miRNA profiles are specific to one cancer, others are common to many cancers
Regardless of whether the change in expression is causal or a downstream effect, miRNA profiling is helping discover new
markers for human disease classification.
Practical Hints for Real-Time PCR 42
Sample to Insight
Back to Basics: RNA Isolation 43
miRNA isolation technologies
Cells / Tissue – miRNeasy MiniFNB – miRNeasy MicroFFPE – miRNeasy FFPEBlood – miRNeasy Serum/PlasmaSerum / Plasma – miRNeasy Serum /
Plasma
miRNeasy – efficient purification of miRNA from different starting materials
Highly pure RNA without phenol carryover
Sample to Insight
Efficient copurification from wide array of tissues
Practical Hints for Real-Time PCR 44
Sample to Insight
45
Agenda
Gene expression workflows
1.1 Advantages of real-time PCR
Critical steps for real-time PCR analysis
2.1 Stabilization of RNA in-sample
2.2 RNA isolation
2.3 cDNA synthesis
QIAGEN gene expression workflow solutions
Questions
1
2
3
4
Sample to Insight
46
Agenda
Gene expression workflows
1.1 Advantages of real-time PCR
Critical steps for real-time PCR analysis
2.1 Stabilization of RNA in-sample
2.2 RNA isolation
2.3 cDNA synthesis
QIAGEN gene expression workflow solutions
Questions
1
2
3
4
Sample to Insight
47
Critical factors for an efficient reverse trancription step
Reverse transcription enzyme efficiency is influenced by:
• Quality / quantity of the RNA starting materialo Phenol contaminationo Alcohol contaminationo Salt contaminationo Protein inhibitors
• Affinity to the RNA to avoid secondary structure effects• Choice of priming method
o Random priming vs. oligo-dT priming vs. gene-specific priming
• Genomic DNA contamination• Conditions for one-step vs. two-step RT-PCR• Sequences near the 5‘ end affect the cDNA yield• Use of internal controls is critical
Sample to Insight
48
Effects of complex secondary structure on RT-PCR
Sample to Insight
49
Eliminating genomic DNA contamination
Sample to Insight
50
Improved methods for cDNA synthesis
• QuantiNova Reverse Transcriptase◦ Highly efficient transcription for sensitive detection even of low abundance targets◦ Use of a wide range of RNA amounts (10 pg–5 μg)◦ High affinity for RNA – leads to high sensitivity◦ Up-scaling option for larger input volumes (up to double volume) ◦ Successful use even for difficult templates◦ Plus RNase inhibitor
• gDNA removal buffer◦ Efficient removal of gDNA (> 1000 fold reduction) is integrated in the protocol
• RT-Primer Mix◦ Optimized mix of oligo-dT and random primers
• Internal control◦ Optional use of internal control included to monitor cDNA synthesis efficiency
Sample to Insight
QuantiNova Reverse Transcription Kit – protocol
• With unique Internal Control RNA• With gDNA removal
Fast and convenient protocol:1. RNA (potentially contaminated with gDNA)
◦ Add gDNA Removal Buffer (incl. RNase Inhibitor)◦ Optionally spike in Internal Control RNA◦ 2 min 45°C
2. Synthesize cDNA◦ Add 5 µl RT-Master Mix ◦ 3 min 25°C, 10 min 45°C, 5 min 85°C cDNA (incl. IC cDNA, if
applicable) ◦ Stable storable, colorable with QN Yellow Template Dye
3. Stop reaction (95°C, 3 min) get cDNA without gDNA contamination!!!
cDNA synthesis procedure in only 20 minutes
Practical Hints for Real-Time PCR 51
Sample to Insight
QuantiNova Reverse Transcription Kit – Internal Control
QuantiNova IC reliably indicates inhibition or failure of RT or qPCR reaction.
It is a synthetic RNA that can be optionally used to monitor succesful RT.
Different amounts of SDS spiked into the PCR reaction. The IC indicated inhibition by delayed CT values.Reliable in-process monitoring of RT and qPCR performance.
Practical Hints for Real-Time PCR 52
Sample to Insight
QuantiNova Reverse Transcription Kit – gDNA removal
Efficient, optional gDNA removal prevents CT shifts caused by DNA contamination.
Precise mRNA quantification even if exon spanning primers cannot be used
10 ng gDNA in PCR reaction as positive control
100 & 10 ng gDNA spiked in without gDNA removal in RT-rxn
NTC
100 & 10 ng gDNA spiked in with gDNA removal
Practical Hints for Real-Time PCR 53
Sample to Insight
Effect of primer choice
Amplicon – 3‘ end: 2 kb
(mix or oligo-dT)
(N)x Oligo-dT+(N)x
Oligo-dT
Amplicon – 3‘ end: 6 kb
(mix or oligo-dT)
Oligo-dT
Oligo-dT+(N)x
(N)x
^ 10 kb transcript (amplicon 2kb and 6kb away from 3´ end)
54
Sample to Insight
• High sensitivity due to novel enzyme
• Synthesize cDNA and remove genomic DNA in 20 minutes
• Integrated genomic DNA removal step
• Reverse transcription from all regions due to primer mix (5’ region)
• Internal control
Improved methods for cDNA synthesis
55
Sample to Insight
56
Agenda
Gene expression workflows
1.1 Advantages of real-time PCR
Critical steps for real-time PCR analysis
2.1 Stabilization of RNA in-sample
2.2 RNA isolation
2.3 cDNA synthesis
QIAGEN gene expression workflow solutions
Questions
1
2
3
4
Sample to Insight
57
Agenda
Gene expression workflows
1.1 Advantages of real-time PCR
Critical steps for real-time PCR analysis
2.1 Stabilization of RNA in-sample
2.2 RNA isolation
2.3 cDNA synthesis
QIAGEN gene expression workflow solutions
Questions
1
2
3
4
Sample to Insight
58
Challenges in gene expression workflows
• DNase contamination
• Salt carry-over
• Phenol carry-over
• gDNA contamination
• Complex samples
• Low yield
• Extraction techniques
• RNase contamination
• Improper storage
• RNA degradation
• Sample handling
• Low abundance transcripts
• Large transcripts
• High GC content
• Secondary structure
• Introducing bias
• Low yield
• gDNA removal
• IC controls
• Pipetting errors
• Room temperature setup
• Primer design
• Sensitivity
• Restrictions due to the cyclers
• Calibration and maintenance efforts
RNA quality (purity and integrity) plays a critical role in the accuracy, reproducibility and relevance of downstream analysis.
Sample to Insight
59
QIAGEN solutions
Sample to Insight
60
Useful resources
• Gene expression workflow solutions: www.qiagen.com/gene-expression-workflow
• Review: RNA integrity and the effect on the real-time qRT-PCR performanceFleige S. Phaffl MW. Mol Aspects Med. 2006 Apr-Jun;27(2-3):126-39. Epub 2006 Feb 15. DOI: 10.1016/j.mam.2005.12.003
• RNA resource centre: https://www.qiagen.com/qdm/rna/resources
• Blogs on PCR solutions:http://biomarkerinsights.qiagen.com/category/pcr-solutions/
• Real-time PCR and RT-PCR on GeneQuantification.info:http://www.gene-quantification.com/real-time.html
• Troubleshooting guide:https://www.qiagen.com/support/troubleshooting/
Sample to Insight
61
Agenda
Gene expression workflows
1.1 Advantages of real-time PCR
Critical steps for real-time PCR analysis
2.1 Stabilization of RNA in-sample
2.2 RNA isolation
2.3 cDNA synthesis
QIAGEN gene expression workflow solutions
Questions
1
2
3
4
Sample to Insight
62
Agenda
Gene expression workflows
1.1 Advantages of real-time PCR
Critical steps for real-time PCR analysis
2.1 Stabilization of RNA in-sample
2.2 RNA isolation
2.3 cDNA synthesis
QIAGEN gene expression workflow solutions
Questions
1
2
3
4
Sample to Insight
63
Thank you for attending today’s webinar!
Contact QIAGEN Technical ServiceCall: 1-800-426-8157 for US
Call: +49 2103-29-12400 for EU
Email: [email protected]@[email protected]
Lily Xu Xuanyan, [email protected]
Questions?
Thank you for attending