Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence · 2019-10-28 · Creating Safe...

57
Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence School Teams: Strategic Planning for Integrating Promotion, Prevention & Intervention into School Policies and Practices Kevin P. Dwyer, MA, NCSP [email protected]

Transcript of Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence · 2019-10-28 · Creating Safe...

Page 1: Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence · 2019-10-28 · Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence School Teams: Strategic Planning for

CreatingSafeSchoolEnvironments:PreventingSchoolViolence

SchoolTeams:StrategicPlanningforIntegratingPromotion,Prevention&InterventionintoSchoolPoliciesandPractices

KevinP.Dwyer,MA,[email protected]

Page 2: Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence · 2019-10-28 · Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence School Teams: Strategic Planning for

Alaska

Page 3: Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence · 2019-10-28 · Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence School Teams: Strategic Planning for

Objectives• 1.Understandthesciencebehindthepreventionandinterventionparadigm

relatedtosafeschoolclimateandacademicandsocial-emotionalachievement• 2.Understandthecriticalneedforschool-basedleadershipteamstomanageasafe

andsocial-emotionallyhealthyschoolclimate• 3.Understand thestepstobuildingeffectiveschoolandsystemclimateteams• 4.Learnthewaystoaddressthe“how-to”forgainingbuy-in,andselecting

implementablealignedbestpracticesforpromotion,prevention,earlyandintensiveinterventions

• 5.Learnfromactualfield-testedexamplesofhowschoolleadership teamshavebeenformed,operationalized,supportedandsustained;movingfromanidea,todesignofteams,tomanagementandneedsassessmentoveramulti-yearperiodforapplicationinyourschools

• 6.Discussandprovideexamplesofongoingactivities tosupportgoalsandobjectivesresultinginmeasurableoutcomesusingtheLogicModel

• 7.Understandhowtoimplementstepsforsustainability.

Page 4: Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence · 2019-10-28 · Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence School Teams: Strategic Planning for

SCHOOL SECURITY

*Police

* ViolencePrevention

*Drug & AlcoholPrevention Program

Drug Counseling

SCHOOL NURSE

*STD/Pregnancy Prevention

Physical/Health Education

ProbationofficersJuvenile Services

HIGH SCHOOL

Teachers and Staff

AVOIDING THE DYSFUNCTIONAL SCHOOL

“RICH IN SERVICES”

SOCIAL SERVICES

*SSI *Medicaid

*Teen Mother *Pregnancy Counseling Prevention

*Child Abuse/Neglect Prevention

HEALTH SERVICES

*Physical and MentalHealth Services

SCHOOL COUNSELORS

*College *Class Schedule

*Mentors

STUDENT SERVICESSCHOOL PSYCHOLOGISTSCHOOL SOCIAL WORKER

*Special Education

• INTERNAL SCHOOL TEAM COORDINATION• TEACHER TRAINING/CONSULTATION• POSTIVE BEHAVIORAL SUPPORTS• SOCIAL SKILL INSTRUCTION• INSTRUCTIONAL LEARNING SUPPORT• INTEGRATED SERVICE PLANNING & PROBLEM

SOLVING• FAMILY CENTERED SYSTEM• SUPPORT FOR PARENT SKILL & INVOLVEMENT• COLLABORATION

Administration

Alternative Schools

WHAT’S MISSING?

AdaptedfromslidebyofNationalResourceCenterforSafeSchoolsBaseduponDwyer,1992

Page 5: Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence · 2019-10-28 · Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence School Teams: Strategic Planning for

GuidingPrinciples• Complexproblemscanbescientificallyidentifiedand

remediedusingbestpractices.

• Thechangeprocessrequiressustainedsystemandschool-basedleadership&ownership.

• Changerequiresstrategicplansandactionsteps,andtakesmultipleyears.

• Systemsofongoingqualityimprovementwithafocusonneededmodificationsand adherencetofidelityandresults-basedoutcomesneedtobeinplace.

• Examplesofexistinginitiativesyouaredoingandhowyouknowtheyareworking?

Page 6: Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence · 2019-10-28 · Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence School Teams: Strategic Planning for
Page 7: Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence · 2019-10-28 · Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence School Teams: Strategic Planning for

MatrixofSuccessfulPrograms

� ������������������

��� �����

��� �������� �� ��

���������� �� ������� ���

Page 8: Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence · 2019-10-28 · Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence School Teams: Strategic Planning for

SystemsStrategicPlan• Improvecapacitytoplananddeploy• Improvepolicies,proceduresandpractices• Improveschoolclimate• Providesocialemotionallearning&reinforcement *• Providepositivebehavioralpoliciesandpractices*• Developearlywarning&responsesystem• Enhanceschool-agencycollaboration• Enhancefamilyengagement• Providefocusedprofessionaldevelopment• Focusfunding&humanresources• Developqualitystandards&ongoingimprovementmeasures

Page 9: Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence · 2019-10-28 · Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence School Teams: Strategic Planning for

ResponsibilityforFidelitytoGuidingPrinciple

SchoolSystemLeadershipTeamDirectsPrinciples&StrategicPlans

School-basedLeadershipTeamManagestheimplementationoftheinitiatives,&actions – theclimate

policiesandpracticesaspartofschool’splan

Page 10: Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence · 2019-10-28 · Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence School Teams: Strategic Planning for

• Lackofsupportfromsystemleadership• Lackofsystemicapproaches• Lackofmonitoringandaccountability• Weakprofessionaldevelopment• Fragmentation&lackofeffectivecommunicationbetweenandamong

agencies,services,police,familiesandschools• Cultural,structural,andhistoricaldisconnectsbetweenagenciesandschools

andfamilies• Weakimplementationofinnovativeefforts• Failuretosystematizechangeinmostprojects– pilotprogramsnotgoingto

scale• Inconsistencyofservicesacrossschools• Interventionsnorrobustenoughtoaddressmultipleriskfactors

• Otherreasonswhyeffortsfail?

WhyEffortsFail

Page 11: Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence · 2019-10-28 · Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence School Teams: Strategic Planning for

TheParableoftheFishandFishBowl

IstheProblem:• TheFish,• TheWater,or• Both?

Adaptedfrom:BethDoll,UniversityofNebraska

Page 12: Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence · 2019-10-28 · Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence School Teams: Strategic Planning for

ThinkEcologically:WhataretheTheImplicationsofthisforAllPlayers?

• Students• Teachers• Staff• Principles• Superintendents• SEA• Families• Agencies&CBOs

Adaptedfrom:BethDoll,UniversityofNebraska

Page 13: Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence · 2019-10-28 · Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence School Teams: Strategic Planning for

Family & Community

School

IdentifyProtectiveandRiskFactorsat

allLevels

Wheretointervene?

Classroom

Individual student Factors

Page 14: Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence · 2019-10-28 · Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence School Teams: Strategic Planning for

School,FamilyandSocialRisk&Protection

• Highlevelsofprotectiondonoteliminateimpactofhighlevelsofrisk

• Riskandprotectivefactorsoftenaccumulateandalsointeract

• Riskandprotectivefactorshaveimmediateaswellaslonger-termoutcomes

Page 15: Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence · 2019-10-28 · Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence School Teams: Strategic Planning for

StudentLevelRiskFactors

• Chronicillness• Disability• Poorsocialskills• Lowfrustrationtolerance• Lackofempathy• Alienation• Attentionanddisruptive

behaviorproblems• Impulsivity• Unmetmentalhealthneeds• Traumaticstress• Otherstudentriskfactors?

ProtectiveFactors• Cooperative• Effectivesocialskills• Eventemperament• Empathic• Effectivelisteningskills• Eagertolearn• Caring• Tolerant• Respectful• Alert&attentive• Dealseffectivelywithconflict• Dealseffectivelywithfrustration• Otherprotectivefactors?

15

Page 16: Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence · 2019-10-28 · Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence School Teams: Strategic Planning for

SchoolandCommunityLevelRiskFactors

School• Highratesoflowacademic

achievementandacademicfailure

• Bullying• Peerrejection• Poorstudent-teacher

relationships• Poorbehaviormanagement• Gangs• Poorcurriculumandinstruction• Poorfamilyinclusion• Poorculturalawareness&

inclusion

Community• Generationalpoverty• Highunemploymentrate• Scarcityofaffordable

housing• Lackofmental,medicaland

legalservices• Fooddeserts• Discrimination• Neighborhoodviolenceand

crimePairofACEs

16

Page 17: Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence · 2019-10-28 · Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence School Teams: Strategic Planning for
Page 18: Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence · 2019-10-28 · Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence School Teams: Strategic Planning for

StressMatters

Page 19: Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence · 2019-10-28 · Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence School Teams: Strategic Planning for

AnxietyandToxicStress

• Compromisedworkingmemory

• Lessattention• Limitstocreativity

Page 20: Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence · 2019-10-28 · Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence School Teams: Strategic Planning for

• TheImplicationsoftheworkofKimberlySchonert–Reichlandcolleagues– “Stresscontagionintheclassroom?Thelink

betweenclassroomteacherburnoutandmorningcortisolinelementaryschoolstudents”(Oberle &Schonert-Reichel,2016)

• TheImplicationsoftheworkofMarkGreenbergandTrishJennings– Reducedteacherstress->changedteacher

behaviors->changedstudentoutcomes.(Jennings,Minnici,&Yoder,2018)

• “Thebestapproachtosafetyistofixschoolsandsupportchildrenandstaff.”(Osher,Sandler&Kelley,&2001)

TheSolutionisNotAbout“Fixing”Teachersor

Students

Page 21: Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence · 2019-10-28 · Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence School Teams: Strategic Planning for

Connection,Caring&Trust

SocialEmotionalLearning&Support

PositiveBehavioralApproaches&Supports

HighAcademicStandards&LearningSupports

ConditionsforLearning

Page 22: Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence · 2019-10-28 · Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence School Teams: Strategic Planning for

CharacteristicsofStrongSchoolClimate/LeadershipTeams

• Inclusiveyetefficient• Task-driven– Actionplanners&implementers• Connectedtoyourinterventionteam(studentsupportteam)

• Whyuseyourexistingleadershipteam?– Parallelteamisnotasefficient– Parallelteamscanreducevalue– Parallelteamseparatesclimatefromacademicmissionofschool

– Stressonschool’shumanresources&time

Page 23: Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence · 2019-10-28 · Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence School Teams: Strategic Planning for

SchoolClimateTeamMembership(cont.)

• SelectionCriteria– Political– powerbrokers– Administrative– incharge&instructionalleader– Sociallyinclusive– Cultural/ethnicleaders– Functional– Specializedknowledge– schoolpsychologist?

• Howchosen?– Volunteersrequested– Chosenbypeers- elected– Selectedbyadministrator– Selectedbycommunityagency

• OtherIdeasforWhoandHowchosen?

Page 24: Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence · 2019-10-28 · Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence School Teams: Strategic Planning for

SchoolClimateLeadershipTeam

StudentSupport&InterventionTeam

- Principal- Teacherrep- Schoolpsychologist

DevelopaSchoolLeadershipTeamtoImplementSocial/EmotionalClimate

Coreteammembersbuildthebridgeacrossuniversal

&individualinterventionsTeams.

Linkingclimate/leadershipteamtostudentsupportteam

Page 25: Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence · 2019-10-28 · Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence School Teams: Strategic Planning for

SystemicStrategicPlan(cont.)• Implementstrategiesdevelopmentallyover5years• Employ3-tieredapproachtoprevention/intervention• Positivebehavioralapproaches,socialemotional

learningandstudentconnectedness• Buildstructurestosupportchange

– DistrictLevel• Provideappropriateprofessionaldevelopmentandcoachingsupport

• Improveandmonitorskill-setandknowledgeofALL(Paraprofessionals,SROs,Agency&family)

• Targetresourcesthatgotoschools• Utilizestakeholderworkgroupstoselectbestpracticesforallschools

• Monitor,respondtoandsupporttheuseofConditionsforLearningdata

• Identifyasetofprogramsandstrategiesthatthedistrictwilluse

Page 26: Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence · 2019-10-28 · Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence School Teams: Strategic Planning for

EvaluationMethodology• AnalyzeAvailableData

– Reports– Evaluations– ArchivalData– Wholooksatofficereferrals?Attendance?

• Keyinformantinterviews• StakeholderOutreach• Casestudies

– StratifiedRandomSelectionofSchools– StratifiedRandomSelectionofClassestoObserveand

Teachers,Students,Staff,andFamiliestoInterview– ExpertInformants(schoolpsychologist?)– Observations– ExaminationandContextualizationofSchoolArchivalData

Page 27: Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence · 2019-10-28 · Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence School Teams: Strategic Planning for

• Outcomes;• Informationon

differentialeffects;• Cost;• Staffingimplications;• Flexibility;• Compatibility;• Implicationsfor

instructionaltimeand;• Externalsupportneeded

&available.

Intervention Evaluation Criteria

Page 28: Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence · 2019-10-28 · Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence School Teams: Strategic Planning for

EvaluationMethodology(cont.)• ValidationActivities

– StatisticalAnalyses– FocusGroups– students,staff,parents,partners

• EpidemiologicalSurvey:– ConditionsforLearningSurvey– YouthRiskBehaviorSurveillanceSystem

Page 29: Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence · 2019-10-28 · Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence School Teams: Strategic Planning for

WorkatAllThreeLevels

Page§ 29

ProvideIndividualizedIntensive

Supports

InterveneEarly&ProvideFocusedYouthDevelopment

Activities

BuildaSchool-wideFoundation

Providecoordinated,intensive,sustained,culturallycompetent,individualized,child- andfamily- drivenandfocusedservicesandsupportsthataddressneedswhilebuildingassets.

Implementstrategiesandprovidesupportsthataddressriskfactorsandbuildprotectivefactorsforstudentsatriskforsevereacademicorbehavioraldifficulties.

Universalprevention&youthsocialskilldevelopmentapproaches,caringschoolclimate,positive&proactiveapproachtodiscipline,personalizedinstruction,culturalcompetence,&strongfamilyinvolvement.

ACEs&PairofACEs– TraumainformedplansandthePrevention/InterventionModel

Page 30: Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence · 2019-10-28 · Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence School Teams: Strategic Planning for

TraumaInformedACEs• NumberofAdverseChildhoodExperiences(ACEScore)• Women Percent(N=32,539) MenPercent(N=21,245) Total• Percent(N=53,784)• 0 40.0% 41.4% 40.7%• 1 22.4% 24.9% 23.6%• 2 13.4% 13.2% 13.3%• 3 8.0% 8.1% 8.1%• 4ormore16.2% 12.4% 14.3%• Note:Reportsandarticlesthatusedatafromotheryearsand/orother

statesmaycontaindifferentestimates.• Source:CentersforDiseaseControlandPrevention.BehavioralRiskFactor

SurveillanceSystemSurveyACEModuleData,2010.Atlanta,Georgia:U.S.DepartmentofHealthandHumanServices,CentersforDiseaseControlandPrevention;2015.Availablefromhttps://www.cdc.gov/violenceprevention/acestudy.

Page 31: Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence · 2019-10-28 · Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence School Teams: Strategic Planning for

EvidenceforPopulation-BasedPerspectivesonChildren'sBehavioralAdjustmentandNeedsforServiceDeliveryinSchoolsJeanA.BakerMichiganStateUniversity,RandyW.Kamphaus,ArthurM.Home,andAnneP.WinsorTheUniversityofGeorg}aAbstract.Americanschoolchildrenshowtremendousacademicaswellasintra- andinterpersonalbehavioraldifferencesintheclassroom.Currentservicedeliverymodelswithinschoolsmaybe insufficienttomeetthedemandanddiversityofstudents'needs,especiallyinschoolsservingstudentsplacedatriskbyadverselifecircumstances,suchaspoverty.SchoolPsychologyReview,2006,Volume35,No.1,pp.31-46

Page 32: Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence · 2019-10-28 · Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence School Teams: Strategic Planning for

ImpactofClimateonMathAchievement:NationalSurveys

• NAEP(NationalAssessmentofEducationalProgress)

– Atallthreegradelevelsstudentsinschoolsreportinganabove-averageclimatehadhighermeanNAEPmathematicsscalescoresthanstudentsinschoolsreportingaverageorbelow-averageschoolclimateonthesamemeasure.

• NELS(TheNationalEducationLongitudinalStudyof1988)– Adolescentperceptionsofconnectionswithteacherspredictedacademicgrowthinmathematics.

Page§ 32Citations§ 4,5

Page 33: Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence · 2019-10-28 · Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence School Teams: Strategic Planning for

AmericanInstitutesforResearch

–KimberlyKendziora,DavidOsher,LawrenceB.Friedman,LisaHoogstra,AndrewSwanlund,PaulBailey,ClareHalloran,MarkGaribaldi,ManolyaTanyu,AndreaBoyle,MichelleOlivia,andMatthewBurke

• ResultsFromanEvaluationofaDemonstrationProgramtoBuildSystemicSocialandEmotionalLearninginEightLargeUrbanSchoolDistricts( 2015)

Page 34: Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence · 2019-10-28 · Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence School Teams: Strategic Planning for

• MostsuperintendentsaffirmedacommitmenttosustainingandgrowingSELandsaiditwasimportanttotheirgoals.

• SELhasbeenembeddedasapillarinstrategicplans.• SELisincreasinglyalignedwithotherdistrictwideinitiatives.• DistrictleadersreportedthatthefocusonSELwascontributingbothto

teacherqualityandstudents’abilitytodemonstratetheacademicbehaviors(suchasattention-span).

• DistrictleadersreportedthatSELwascontributingtoreductionsinexclusionarydisciplineinsomedistricts.

SelectedQualitativeFindings

34

Page 35: Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence · 2019-10-28 · Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence School Teams: Strategic Planning for

–KimberlyKendziora,DavidOsher,LawrenceB.Friedman,LisaHoogstra,AndrewSwanlund,PaulBailey,ClareHalloran,MarkGaribaldi,ManolyaTanyu,AndreaBoyle,MichelleOlivia,andMatthewBurke

ResultsFromanEvaluationofaDemonstrationProgramtoBuildSystemicSocialandEmotionalLearninginEightLargeUrban

SchoolDistricts

April2015 Copyright©2015AmericanInstitutesforResearch.Allrightsreserved.

Page 36: Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence · 2019-10-28 · Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence School Teams: Strategic Planning for

• Controllingforstudentdemographics,in2013–14:– Anchorage:Higherimplementation↔ fewerdisciplinaryreferrals.

– Cleveland:Higherimplementation↔higherreadingandmathematicsscores,higherGPAs,andfewersuspensions.

– Chicago:Nosignificantassociationswerefound.

– Nashville:Higherimplementation↔higherGPAsandmathematicsscores(butnotreadingscores),higherattendance,andfewersuspensions.However,Algebra1scoresweresignificantlylowerinhigher-implementingschools.

SchoolSELImplementationActivitiesandStudentRecordData

36

Page 37: Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence · 2019-10-28 · Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence School Teams: Strategic Planning for

ProblemDefined

• Objectifytheprobleminmeasurableobservableterms

• Clarifyhowproblemisbarriertoschool’svision– ConditionsforLearning

• Identifytherootcauses• Verifyrootcauseswithdata• Considereffectivenessofpresentinterventions(includingpoliciesandpractices)

Page 38: Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence · 2019-10-28 · Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence School Teams: Strategic Planning for

Actions

• Clearlyconnectedtoproblem’scauses• Utilizeproven“best”practicesthathavebeenshowntoaddressproblem&causes

• Establishstepsrequiredtoenableaction–mayinvolvemultiple“actions”priortofinalaction.

• Includeallstakeholdersinselectingactionsincludingleadershipforneededresources

• Definewhowilldowhat,whenandhow!

Page 39: Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence · 2019-10-28 · Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence School Teams: Strategic Planning for

Createclassroomcommunitiesofferingall

childrenastrongsenseofsafetyandbelonging

• SeeEdutopia,“HowLearningHappens”

• https://www.edutopia.org/how-learning-happens

Page 40: Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence · 2019-10-28 · Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence School Teams: Strategic Planning for

ResearchTraining

ImplementationEvaluationRevisionsFidelityScaling

Communication

Best PracticeImplementation

Training

Practiceimplemented

MeasuredResults

OngoingMonitoring&Evaluation

MeasuredresultsCommunicatesuccess

OngoingMonitoring&Evaluation

ModificationsIdentified

ModifiedTraining

PracticeSustained

KPD 2017Revised

Page 41: Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence · 2019-10-28 · Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence School Teams: Strategic Planning for

LogicModelPROBLEMDEFINED

ACTION OUTPUTS OUTCOMES

StudentbehavioralreferralsareincreasinginallgradesAchievementscoresremainlow

Adopt:- resilientclassroompractices- classmeetings- de-escalationtechniques- planningcenters

#ofteachertrainings-- observationsusingkey-wordscale,- documentationofclassmeetings-Implementationofplanningcenterpracticesasdefined

ReducenumberofreferralsIncreasedstudentattention&instructiontimeIncreasedpositivemeasuresonCFLsurveybystudentsandteachers

VisionImprovedacademicachievement

Page 42: Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence · 2019-10-28 · Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence School Teams: Strategic Planning for

Determineoutputs• Measureproblems/activitiesthatrequireactionplans• Selectionofbestpractices– includeimplementers• Selectionofcriteriaforeachimplementation• Fidelitymeasuresforoutputs:

– #oftrainingsforclassmeetings&trainingevaluatedbasedoncriteria

– #classmeetingsheld;#observed;#evaluatedforfidelity&results&remedies

Ideas??

Page 43: Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence · 2019-10-28 · Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence School Teams: Strategic Planning for

Determineoutcomes

• Defineoutcomemeasuresusingproblemdataanddesiredbenchmarks,goals

• Wheneverpossibleuseexistingdatasets• Outcomesmustbeobjective– observable• Ideas??

Page 44: Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence · 2019-10-28 · Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence School Teams: Strategic Planning for

AddresstheConditionsforLearning inYourActionPlan

Page 45: Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence · 2019-10-28 · Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence School Teams: Strategic Planning for

Connection,Caring&Trust

SocialEmotionalLearning&Support

PositiveBehavioralApproaches&Supports

HighAcademicStandards&LearningSupports

ConditionsforLearning

Page 46: Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence · 2019-10-28 · Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence School Teams: Strategic Planning for

ConnectionCaring&Trust• Trainandresourceclassroom/schoolresiliency• Studentfocusgroups– initialsteps• Classmeetings– canconnecttoSEL• Advisoriesforall&addressacademicguidanceandpersonalbehavioralissues

• Extracurricularactivities– trainingsponsors• NamebadgeswithlargeprintFIRSTnamesforall• Familyliaisonstaff• Trainingallstaffincludingsafety/securitytoberespectful

Page 47: Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence · 2019-10-28 · Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence School Teams: Strategic Planning for

TeachSocialSkills

!FINDINGS!FROM!A!NATIONAL!SURVEY!!

SOCIAL!AND!EMOTIONAL!LEARNING!!�������������� ������������� ��!

Support'for'this'study'provided'by:''The!Atlantic!Philanthropies,!!The!California!Endowment,!The!NoVo!Foundation,!and!The!Raikes!Foundation!

Page 48: Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence · 2019-10-28 · Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence School Teams: Strategic Planning for

CASEL’sTeaching5SELCompetencies

• Selfawareness• Socialawareness• Selfmanagement• Relationshipskills• Responsibledecisionmaking

Page 49: Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence · 2019-10-28 · Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence School Teams: Strategic Planning for

SocialEmotionalLearning• Teachingsocialskillshasbeenshowntoincreaseachievement,

attention&reducebehaviorproblems• StartwithuniversalSELintheprimarygrades– getquickestbuy-in• Usesocialskillsinallschoolenvironments– cafeteria,halls,recess• TrainteacherstoteachSEL(2daystraining)andstafftoreinforce(3-6

hours)&giveprincipal’sinstructionalleadershiproletoensureinstructionhappensasrequiredbySELprogram

• Provideparenteducationandtipsforhome• Includeinlanguagearts,creativewriting,andotheracademic

subjects.

SeeCASEL.org

Page 50: Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence · 2019-10-28 · Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence School Teams: Strategic Planning for

PositiveBehavior• Rewritedisciplinecodeusingpositives• Providestudentsandfamiliesinformationtogethelpforbehavioral

issuesanddisseminateaspartofcodedocument• Establishplanningcenterstoreplacein-schoolsuspensionsothat

studentscanbehelpedtofindnewwaystoaddresstheiracademicfrustrationandbehaviors

• ProvidePDforstafftode-escalateproblemsandidentifyearlywarningsignsofacademicandbehavioralissues

• Trainsecuritystafftoreinforcepositivebehaviors• Establishwellmanagedpeermediationprograms• Utilizestudentsupportteamtoaddressdevelopingandchallenging

studentbehavioralissues• Establishrestorativejusticeresponsetoproblembehaviors• UnderstandandwhenpossibleaddressACEs

Page 51: Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence · 2019-10-28 · Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence School Teams: Strategic Planning for

HighAcademicStandards&LearningSupports

• Designandsupporteffectivehighstandardcurriculumandinstructionforall

• Establishaneffectivestudentsupportteam(SST)withknowledgeablemembers&makereferralprocesseasy– withresourcesatthetable

• Engageallinadoptingaproblemsolving“whatworks”approachtowellidentifiedacademicproblems

• Ensurethatallsupportchallengingacademicstandardsandtheirinstruction– principals

• Supportteachersinusingindividualizedandtargetedneeds-basedinstruction

• SupportandresourceafterschoolandSaturdayinstructionalsupports

• Utilizetechnologytosupportcurriculumandinstruction• MonitorstudentprogressthroughSST

Page 52: Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence · 2019-10-28 · Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence School Teams: Strategic Planning for

LessonsLearned• Planningrequiresinclusivestrongleadershipbeyondtheschool.

• Communicationandtransparencywithstakeholdersisparamount.

• Trainingmustbeongoinginvolvingcoachingandmonitoring.

• Datasystemsmustbeinplace&userfriendly.• Datamustbeusedtoexaminefidelity&outcomes.• Climateteammustbeconnectedtoalllevelsofinterventionservices.

• Allactivitiesmustbealigned&seamless.

Page 53: Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence · 2019-10-28 · Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence School Teams: Strategic Planning for

LogicModelWorksheetPROBLEMDEFINED

ACTION OUTPUTS OUTCOMES

Vision

Whatmightyouworkonandwhoareyouralliesneededtogetstarted– establishinitiatives- monitorandsustainthem?

Page 54: Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence · 2019-10-28 · Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence School Teams: Strategic Planning for

ThreatAssessmentCheckNASPforthreatAssessmentandCrisisResponseEstablishaSystemicBehavioralThreatAssessmentandManagementProcessTheFBI’sBehavioralThreatAssessmentCenter(Ammanetal.2017)hasofferedaneffectiveandsystematicthreatassessment.

See:Reeves&Brock(2017)

Page 55: Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence · 2019-10-28 · Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence School Teams: Strategic Planning for

ReadingsResources:SchoolBehavioralThreatAssessmentandManagementLouvar Reeves,M.A.&Brock,S.E.Contemp SchoolPsychol (2017).https://doi.org/10.1007/s40688-017-0158-6

Resilient Classrooms:Creating healthy environmentsfor learning 2ndEd.B.Doll,K.Brehm&S.Zucker (2014)GuilfordPress.

Safe,Supportive and SuccessfulSchools:Stepby Step.Osher,Dwyer&Jackson(2014)AmericanInstitutes for Research.

NASPAssessingtheSafetyoftheSchoolEnvironmentUsingtheFrameworkforSafeandSuccessfulSchools• Thisassessmentshouldbeutilizedcollaborativelybytheschoolsafetyteamandschooladministrationtoguide

effortsandidentifyneedswithintheuniquecontextofeachschoolcommunity.ConsiderusingthisassessmentandtheattachedresultanalysisandactionplanningtoolinconjunctionwiththePolicyRecommendationsforImplementationtheFrameworkforSafeandSuccessfulSchools. Datafromthisassessmentisnotavalidmethodofcomparingschoolsormeasuringprogress;itisintendedonlytoguidediscussion,planning,goalsetting,anddecisionmaking.

1Cowan,K.C.,Vaillancourt,K.,Rossen,E.,&Pollitt,K.(2013).Aframeworkforsafeandsuccessfulschools[Brief].Bethesda,MD:NationalAssociationofSchoolPsychologists.ImplementingtheFrameworkforSafeandSuccessfulSchools

Page 56: Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence · 2019-10-28 · Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence School Teams: Strategic Planning for

Citations1. Dwyer,K.andOsher,D.(2007)Safeguardingourchildren:Anactionguide.Boston,

Sopris West.2. Osher,D.,Dwyer,K.&Jackson,S.(2004).Safesupportiveandsuccessfulschools:Step

bystep.WashingtonDC,AmericanInstitutesforResearch3. Osher,D.andKendziora (2010).Buildingconditionsforlearning.Chapter6,p.132.In

Doll,Pfohl &Yoon,Eds.Handbookofyouthpreventionscience.NewYork:Routledge.4. Kendziora,K.,et.al.(2015)ResultsFromanEvaluationofaDemonstrationProgramto

BuildSystemicSocialandEmotionalLearninginEightLargeUrbanSchoolDistricts.WashingtonDC:AmericanInstitutesforResearch.

5. Greenberg,E.,Skidmore,D.,&Rhodes,D.(2004,April).Climatesforlearning:mathematicsachievementanditsrelationshiptoschoolwide studentbehavior,schoolwide parentalinvolvement,andschoolmorale.PaperpresentedattheannualmeetingoftheAmericanEducationalResearchersAssociation,SanDiego,CA.

6. Gregory,A.,&Weinstein,R.S.(2004).Connectionandregulationathomeandinschool:Predictinggrowthinachievementforadolescents.JournalofAdolescentResearch,19,405–427.

7. Davidson,R.(2002).Anxietyandaffectivestyle:Roleofprefrontalcortexandamygdala.BiologicalPsychiatry,51(1),68-80.

8. Vygotsky,L.(1978).Mindinsociety.Cambridge,MA:HarvardUniversityPress.

Page 57: Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence · 2019-10-28 · Creating Safe School Environments: Preventing School Violence School Teams: Strategic Planning for

NOVEMBER2018

$ 3 3 .0 0PAPER

$ 6 4 .0 0CLOTH

978-1-68253-262-1

978-1-68253-263-8

288PAGES/INDEXADMINISTRATION

“Osher, Moroney, and Wil l iamson successfully integrate research, practice, and pol icy to help educators develop and implement effective and sustainable models to nurture caring schools that all chi ldren and educators deserve.”

—MARK T. GREENBERG, BENNETT CHAIR OF PREVENTION RESEARCH, PENNSYLVANIA STATE UNIVERSITY

CREATING SAFE, EQUITABLE, ENGAGINGSCHOOLSA Comprehensive, Evidence-Based Approach to Supporting Students

EDITED BY DAVID OSHER, DEBORAH MORONEY, AND SANDRAWILLIAMSON

Creating Safe, Equitable, Engaging Schools br ings toge ther the col lec tive w isdom o f m ore than th i r ty experts f rom a var ie ty o f fie lds to show h o w school leaders can createcommunit ies tha t suppor t the social, emotional, and academicneeds o f all

s tudents. I t offers an essential gu ide fo r m ak ing sense o f

the m yr iad evidence- based frameworks, resources, and too ls available to create a continuous im provem entsystem.

Chapters i l lustrate h o w leaders can leverage the power o f school-based teams to assess the needs o f s tudents in the ir school and select appropr ia te in terventions across a w ide var ie ty o f domains, inc lud ing social and em otiona l learning, trauma, restorative practices, cultura l responsiveness, and s tudent and fam ily engagement. F il led w i threcommendations gleaned from research and ongo ing w ork inevery USstate and terr i tory , Creating Safe, Equitable, Engaging Schools is a cr i t ica l resource fo r unders tanding and adop t ing evidence-based practices and m ak ing p rogram m at ic decis ions to ensure the ideal condit ions fo r learning, g rowth , and development.

DAVID OSHER is v ice pres ident and ins t i tu te fe l low a t Amer ican Institutes fo r Research. DEBORAH MORONEY is a managing d irec tor a t Amer ican Institutes fo r Research and is d i rec tor o f the you th deve lopm ent and suppor t ive learning env ironments prac tice area. SANDRA WILLIAMSON is a v ice pres ident fo r policy, practice, and systems change atAmer ican Institutes fo r Research.

W EB HARVARDEDUCATIONPRESS.ORGPHONE 1.888.437.14371.978.829.2532 (OUTSIDE US)

FAX 1.978.348.1233

EMAIL [email protected] EDUCATION PRESS C /O PSSC4 6 DEVELOPMENTROADFITCHBURG, M A 01420

@HARVARD_ED_PUBFACEBOOK.COM/ HARVARDEDUCATIONPRESSLINKEDIN.COMPINTEREST.COM/HVARDEDPRESS

SAVE 20% when youmention sales code

CSEE18(OFFER EXPIRES

3/27/19)

PLACE YOURORDER

CONTRIBUTORS

Kellie Anderson • Catherine Barbour • Juliette Berg • Ilene Berman • Aaron R. Butler • Vanessa Coleman • Greta Colombi • Kevin Dwyer • Allison Dymnicki • Edward Fergus • Karen Francis • Elizabeth V. Freeman • Allison Gruner Gandhi • Kathleen Guarino • Lynn Holdheide • Stephanie Jackson • Jessica Johnson • Jason Katz • Kimberly Kendziora • R. Jason LaTurner • Fausto Alejandro López • Amy Mart • Robert V. Mayo • Sam Neiman • Jessica Newman • Trina Osher •

Jill Pentimonti • Jeffrey M. Poirier • Frank Rider • Terry Salinger • Manolya Tanyu• Roger P. Weissberg • Lacy Wood • Sara Wraight • Nick

Yoder