COVID-19 AND AFFORDABLE HOUSING IN CALIFORNIA: LENDERS …€¦ · Mark Rasmussen, California...

15
COVID-19 AND AFFORDABLE HOUSING IN CALIFORNIA: LENDERS AND INVESTORS RESPOND Thank you to our co-sponsors!

Transcript of COVID-19 AND AFFORDABLE HOUSING IN CALIFORNIA: LENDERS …€¦ · Mark Rasmussen, California...

Page 1: COVID-19 AND AFFORDABLE HOUSING IN CALIFORNIA: LENDERS …€¦ · Mark Rasmussen, California Community Reinvestment Corporation Sindy Spivak, Bank of America Tim McCann, Wells Fargo

COVID-19 AND AFFORDABLE HOUSING IN CALIFORNIA: LENDERS AND INVESTORS RESPOND

Thank you to our co-sponsors!

Page 2: COVID-19 AND AFFORDABLE HOUSING IN CALIFORNIA: LENDERS …€¦ · Mark Rasmussen, California Community Reinvestment Corporation Sindy Spivak, Bank of America Tim McCann, Wells Fargo

NPH & California Housing Partnership | 2

Housekeeping

• Audio and video for all attendees are disabled.

• We are not recording this session.

• We are collecting audience questions only through the Q&A chat box.

• Dial-in participants do not have access to the Q&A chat box.

• Make sure your Zoom name displays your name and employer.

Page 3: COVID-19 AND AFFORDABLE HOUSING IN CALIFORNIA: LENDERS …€¦ · Mark Rasmussen, California Community Reinvestment Corporation Sindy Spivak, Bank of America Tim McCann, Wells Fargo

INTRODUCTIONAmie Fishman, Non-Profit Housing Association of Northern CaliforniaMatt Schwartz, California Housing Partnership

Page 4: COVID-19 AND AFFORDABLE HOUSING IN CALIFORNIA: LENDERS …€¦ · Mark Rasmussen, California Community Reinvestment Corporation Sindy Spivak, Bank of America Tim McCann, Wells Fargo

NPH & California Housing Partnership | 4

Agenda• Topic 1: In Operations

• How investors and lenders are working with affordable housing providers to address rental income shortfalls for developments in operation.

• Discussion• Q&A

• Topic 2: In Development• How investors and lenders are working with developers to address closing,

construction and lease-up delays for projects in development• Discussion• Q&A

• Topic 3: The Market• How lenders and investors are approaching new investments in pending affordable

housing developments • Discussion• Q&A

• General Q&A

Page 5: COVID-19 AND AFFORDABLE HOUSING IN CALIFORNIA: LENDERS …€¦ · Mark Rasmussen, California Community Reinvestment Corporation Sindy Spivak, Bank of America Tim McCann, Wells Fargo

NPH & California Housing Partnership | 5

Panelists

• Bank of America: Sindy Spivak • California Community Reinvestment Corporation: Mark Rasmussen • Chase Bank: Cécile Chalifour • Enterprise: Philip Porter • Housing Trust Silicon Valley: Kevin Zwick • Merritt Community Capital Corporation: Ari Beliak • National Equity Fund: Todd Fabian • PGIM Real Estate: Kenji Tamaoki• Red Stone Equity Partners, LLC: Matt Grosz • US Bank: Lisa Gutierrez & Vihar Sheth • Wells Fargo: John Kauh & Tim McCann

Page 6: COVID-19 AND AFFORDABLE HOUSING IN CALIFORNIA: LENDERS …€¦ · Mark Rasmussen, California Community Reinvestment Corporation Sindy Spivak, Bank of America Tim McCann, Wells Fargo

TOPIC 1: IN OPERATIONSHow investors and lenders are working with affordable housing providers to address rental income shortfalls for developments in operation

MODERATORS: Darnell Williams, Eden Housing

Lauren Maddock, California Housing Partnership

Page 7: COVID-19 AND AFFORDABLE HOUSING IN CALIFORNIA: LENDERS …€¦ · Mark Rasmussen, California Community Reinvestment Corporation Sindy Spivak, Bank of America Tim McCann, Wells Fargo

NPH & California Housing Partnership | 7

Topic 1: In Operations

• Rental Income and Portfolio Trends• Solutions to Operational Shortfalls• Relief for Residents and Support for Property Staff

PANELISTS:Cécile Chalifour, Chase BankKenji Tamaoki, PGIM Real Estate Lisa Gutierrez, US BankMark Rasmussen, California Community Reinvestment CorporationSindy Spivak, Bank of AmericaTim McCann, Wells FargoTodd Fabian, National Equity Fund

MODERATORS: Darnell Williams, Eden Housing

Lauren Maddock, California Housing Partnership

Page 8: COVID-19 AND AFFORDABLE HOUSING IN CALIFORNIA: LENDERS …€¦ · Mark Rasmussen, California Community Reinvestment Corporation Sindy Spivak, Bank of America Tim McCann, Wells Fargo

TOPIC 2: IN DEVELOPMENTHow investors and lenders are working with developers to address closing, construction and lease-up delays for projects in development

MODERATORS: Kim McKay, BRIDGE Housing

Nicole Norori, California Housing Partnership

Page 9: COVID-19 AND AFFORDABLE HOUSING IN CALIFORNIA: LENDERS …€¦ · Mark Rasmussen, California Community Reinvestment Corporation Sindy Spivak, Bank of America Tim McCann, Wells Fargo

NPH & California Housing Partnership | 9

Topic 2: In Development

• How to Close a Deal in the Time of COVID• Managing Construction Delays - Budgets, Schedules, and

Risk...Oh My!• Delays and Cost Impacts in Lease-Up/Conversion

PANELISTS:Ari Beliak, Merritt Community Capital CorporationJohn Kauh, Wells FargoLisa Gutierrez, US BankMark Rasmussen, California Community Reinvestment CorporationMatt Grosz, Red Stone Equity Partners, LLC

MODERATORS: Kim McKay, BRIDGE Housing

Nicole Norori, California Housing Partnership

Page 10: COVID-19 AND AFFORDABLE HOUSING IN CALIFORNIA: LENDERS …€¦ · Mark Rasmussen, California Community Reinvestment Corporation Sindy Spivak, Bank of America Tim McCann, Wells Fargo

TOPIC 3: THE MARKETHow lenders and investors are approaching new investments in pending affordable housing developments

MODERATORS: Richard Mandel, California Housing Partnership

Claire Parisa, California Housing Partnership

Page 11: COVID-19 AND AFFORDABLE HOUSING IN CALIFORNIA: LENDERS …€¦ · Mark Rasmussen, California Community Reinvestment Corporation Sindy Spivak, Bank of America Tim McCann, Wells Fargo

NPH & California Housing Partnership | 11

Topic 3: The Market

• Equity Appetite and Pricing• Debt Appetite and Pricing• Lender & Investor Underwriting• CDFI Perspective

PANELISTS: Cécile Chalifour, Chase BankJohn Kauh, Wells FargoKenji Tamaoki, PGIM Real Estate Kevin Zwick, Housing Trust Silicon ValleyPhilip Porter, EnterpriseSindy Spivak, Bank of AmericaVihar Sheth, US Bank MODERATORS:

Richard Mandel, California Housing PartnershipClaire Parisa, California Housing Partnership

Page 12: COVID-19 AND AFFORDABLE HOUSING IN CALIFORNIA: LENDERS …€¦ · Mark Rasmussen, California Community Reinvestment Corporation Sindy Spivak, Bank of America Tim McCann, Wells Fargo

Q&APlease type your questions using the Q&A chat box. Speakers will be responding live.

Page 13: COVID-19 AND AFFORDABLE HOUSING IN CALIFORNIA: LENDERS …€¦ · Mark Rasmussen, California Community Reinvestment Corporation Sindy Spivak, Bank of America Tim McCann, Wells Fargo

NPH & California Housing Partnership | 13

Audience Q&A

TOPIC 1: IN OPERATIONS TOPIC 2: IN DEVELOPMENT TOPIC 3: THE MARKET

• Cécile Chalifour, Chase Bank

• Kenji Tamaoki, PGIM Real Estate

• Lisa Gutierrez, US Bank

• Mark Rasmussen, California Community Reinvestment Corporation

• Sindy Spivak, Bank of America

• Tim McCann, Wells Fargo

• Todd Fabian, National Equity Fund

• Ari Beliak, Merritt Community Capital Corporation

• John Kauh, Wells Fargo

• Lisa Gutierrez, US Bank

• Mark Rasmussen, California Community Reinvestment Corporation

• Matt Grosz, Red Stone Equity Partners, LLC

• Cécile Chalifour, Chase Bank

• John Kauh, Wells Fargo

• Kenji Tamaoki, PGIM Real Estate

• Kevin Zwick, Housing Trust Silicon Valley

• Philip Porter, Enterprise

• Sindy Spivak, Bank of America

• Vihar Sheth, US Bank

• Darnell Williams, Eden Housing

• Lauren Maddock, California Housing Partnership

• Kim McKay, BRIDGE Housing

• Nicole Norori, California Housing Partnership

• Richard Mandel, California Housing Partnership

• Claire Parisa, California Housing Partnership

Please type your questions using the Q&A chat box. Speakers will be responding live.

Page 14: COVID-19 AND AFFORDABLE HOUSING IN CALIFORNIA: LENDERS …€¦ · Mark Rasmussen, California Community Reinvestment Corporation Sindy Spivak, Bank of America Tim McCann, Wells Fargo

NPH & California Housing Partnership | 14

Contacts at the Partnership & NPH

California Housing Partnership (chpc.net)

• Matt Schwarz, President & CEO [email protected]

• Richard Mandel, Director of Financial Consulting [email protected]

• Claire Parisa, Senior Housing Finance Consultant [email protected]

Non-Profit Housing Association of Northern California(nonprofithousing.org)

• Amie Fishman, Executive Director [email protected]

• Estephanie Sunga, Senior Program & Events Manager [email protected]

Page 15: COVID-19 AND AFFORDABLE HOUSING IN CALIFORNIA: LENDERS …€¦ · Mark Rasmussen, California Community Reinvestment Corporation Sindy Spivak, Bank of America Tim McCann, Wells Fargo

FINAL REMARKSMatt Schwartz, California Housing Partnership