Counting Best Practices in Counting - System Scale · Parts counting can be influenced by a...
Transcript of Counting Best Practices in Counting - System Scale · Parts counting can be influenced by a...
Coun
ting
When counting thousands of parts every day, accuracy is key. Mistakes can be costly and translate in overfilling costs, unstable production processes, waste and a dam-aged reputation. Piece counting with scales is a simple and fast way to determine numbers of parts in receiving, warehousing, production or shipping. However, count-ing accurately requires a thorough counting solution.
Contents
1 Parts weights and deviation
2 The right counting scale system
3 Counting resolution vs. internal resolution
4 Benefits of scale calibration
5 The environment
6 What does “accuracy” mean for you?
7 Good Weighing Practice™ for Counting
This includes: •Anefficientcountingprocessforyouroperators•Adequatecountingscales•Operatortrainingand•Aplantomaintaintheoperationalreliabilityand accuracy of the scales.
What influences counting accuracy?Parts counting can be influenced by a multitude offactors.However,amongthemainimpactsarethe:•Partsweightsanditsdeviation•Theaccuracyofthecountingscales (counting resolution) •Theenvironment
Let’s take a closer look on each of those factors.
Best Practices in CountingHowtoAchieveAccurateCountingResults
2 METTLER TOLEDO - White Paper - Counting © 2012 Mettler-Toledo AG
Coun
ting
Yourcountingsystemshouldbespecifiedaccordingthecriticalpartsyouhavetocount.Therearecriti-calcomponentstoeverycountingprocess,whichincludecountingpartsthatareverylightand/orpartsthathavethegreatestdeviationinpieceweight.Eachparthasacertaindeviationthatcanbemeasuredand calculated with the standard deviation. For high-precisionparts,thestandarddeviationoftheaver-agepieceweight(APW)isabout0.5%.ThatmeansthatapartwithAPWof1.5gramshasadeviationof0.0225grams.Practicalexperienceshowsthatstan-darddeviationsvaryfrom0.5–1.5%.Therealsoarepartswithahigherstandarddeviation,suchassomeplastic-moldedparts.
Whatistheimpactoftheaveragepieceweightanditsdeviation on the counting accuracy? In summary, the higher the standard deviation, the higher the resulting counting error. In addition, the smaller the average pieceweight,thehigherthecountingresolutionofyourreferenceorsamplescaleneedstobetoachieveresults in a defined accuracy range. Therefore, when specifyinganewcountingsystem,askyoursupplierto take those two factors into account.
1 Parts Weights and Deviation
Tostartcountingwithascale,theaveragepieceweight first needs to be determined. Industrial count-ingscalescanstoretheaveragepieceweightinitsmemory.Todothis,firstweightensamplepartsandpressthesample10(orreference10)key.Nowthescalewillstoretheaveragepieceweighttoitsinternalmemory, a crucial key to achieving accurate counting results. Making a mistake here translates to big errors throughoutthecountingprocess.
Here are some key considerations when determining averagepieceweight:
1.Thesamplepartsyouuseneedtoberepresentativeofthepartsyouwanttocount.Foreachnewbatch,anewaveragepieceweightshouldbedetermineddueto changes in raw materials or machine settings.
2.Thenumberofsamplepiecesimpactsthecountingaccuracy.If,forexample,yourpartshaveahighstan-dard deviation, you can cut the counting error in half by increasingthenumberofsamplepartsfrom10to30.
3. The counting scale used to determine the average pieceweightneedstohavetheappropriatecountingresolutiontoaccuratelymeasurethesampleweight.Thiscanimplythatatwo-scalecountingsystemisneededwithahigh-resolutionsample(reference)scale connected to the counting (bulk) scale where theactualcountingtakesplace.
2 The Right Counting Scale System
3 METTLER TOLEDO - White Paper - Counting © 2012 Mettler-Toledo AG
Coun
ting
Notonlyisitimportanttoselecttherightequipment,butinstallingitcorrectlyandgettingoperatorstrainedisparamounttoputtinginplaceamaintenanceandcalibrationplan.Eventhoughindustrialscalesaredesigned to withstand harsh manufacturing environ-ments,theymustbeperiodicallytestedandmain-tained.Properscalecalibrationisespeciallyimportant
whenoperatingatwo-scalesystem.Ifthesampleandcountingscalearenotperiodicallycalibrated,chancesare the counting results are wrong. Qualified calibra-tion and maintenance makes sure your measuring deviceoperatesreliablyanddeliversaccurateresultsthroughout its lifetime.
4 Benefits of Scale Calibration
Howaccurateascalecandeterminethesampleweight is determined by its counting resolution. To achieveahighcountingresolutionthequalityoftheweighingelectronicintermsoflownoise,adequateintegrationandproperfilteringisofmajorimportance.
The counting resolution should not be mistaken with the so called “internal resolution” which has hardly any influence on the counting accuracy of a scale.
3 Counting Resolution vs. Internal Resolution
Ambientconditionsalsoinfluencecountingaccuracy.Toachieveanoptimumresult,theenvironmentmustbeasfreefromvibrationsaspossible.Forexample,drafts caused by fans or air conditioning systems mustbeprevented,asshoulddirectsunlightandfluctuationsintemperature.Thescaleitselfshouldbe
alignedhorizontally,especiallyhigh-resolutionscales.In each case, correct installation, user training and the scalescapabilityoffilteringnoisehaveapositiveef-fect on the counting result.
5 The Environment
Whatareyourprocesstolerances?Thisisanimpor-tantquestionthatneedstobeansweredduringtheevaluationofacountingsolution.Accuracyisnotthesame for everyone. To select the right counting scale,
it’skeytoknowifadeviationof+/-1%(e.g.+/-1partsof100parts)isacceptableorifitneedstobehigher.
6 What Does “Accuracy” Mean for You?
Coun
ting
BasedontheprinciplesoftheglobalWeighingStan-dard - Good Weighing Practice™ (GWP®)-METTLERTOLEDOhelpscustomerstodeterminetherightcount-ingsolutionforanyprocessrequirement.
With GWP®RecommendationforCounting*,youcanbe sure that:
Evaluation•Yourcountingprocessisevaluatedbydetermining theaveragepieceweightsanddeviationsofthe criticalpartsandyourprocesstolerances
Selection•Therightscalesandbalancesareselectedbased onyourrequirementsandtheoptimalsizeofsample (reference)piecesisspecified
Installation•Successfulinstallationandusertrainingis performed
Calibration•Scalesandbalancesaremaintainedandcalibrated regularlytopreserveaccuracyandtogeneratethe necessary documents for audits
Routine Operation•Traininghasbeenconductedensuringgood operation
7 Good Weighing Practice™ for Counting
Get more information on GWP®RecommendationforCounting* www.mt.com/gwp-rec-counting
Mettler-Toledo AG CH-8606GreifenseeSwitzerlandPhone +41 44 944 22 11Fax +41449443060
Subjecttotechnicalchanges©01/2013Mettler-ToledoAGMarCom Industrial
GWP® is the only science-based global standard for efficient lifecycle management of weighing systems,applicabletoallkindsofweighing systemsofanymanufacturer.Ithelpsyouto
•choosetherightbalanceorscale•calibrateandoperateyourweighing equipmentwithsecurity•complywithcurrentquality,compliance, laboratory and manufacturing standards
www.mt.com/GWP
*availableinselectedcountries