Countering Violent Extremism: How Can Behavior Analysis Help? · 4/15/13 3 Boston Marathon Bombings...

34
Countering Violent Extremism: How Can Behavior Analysis Help? Sarah Casella Jones, Ph.D., BCBA-D, LBA The Chicago School for Professional Psychology – Washington, D.C. Campus Virginia Association for Behavior Analysis Conference 2017 Richmond, VA

Transcript of Countering Violent Extremism: How Can Behavior Analysis Help? · 4/15/13 3 Boston Marathon Bombings...

Page 1: Countering Violent Extremism: How Can Behavior Analysis Help? · 4/15/13 3 Boston Marathon Bombings 1253 Boston, MA USA Bombing 3 183 9/16/13 4 Navy Yard Shooting 154 Washington,

CounteringViolentExtremism:HowCanBehaviorAnalysisHelp?

SarahCasellaJones,Ph.D.,BCBA-D,LBATheChicagoSchoolforProfessionalPsychology– Washington,D.C.Campus

VirginiaAssociationforBehaviorAnalysisConference2017Richmond,VA

Page 2: Countering Violent Extremism: How Can Behavior Analysis Help? · 4/15/13 3 Boston Marathon Bombings 1253 Boston, MA USA Bombing 3 183 9/16/13 4 Navy Yard Shooting 154 Washington,

2

Page 3: Countering Violent Extremism: How Can Behavior Analysis Help? · 4/15/13 3 Boston Marathon Bombings 1253 Boston, MA USA Bombing 3 183 9/16/13 4 Navy Yard Shooting 154 Washington,
Page 4: Countering Violent Extremism: How Can Behavior Analysis Help? · 4/15/13 3 Boston Marathon Bombings 1253 Boston, MA USA Bombing 3 183 9/16/13 4 Navy Yard Shooting 154 Washington,
Page 5: Countering Violent Extremism: How Can Behavior Analysis Help? · 4/15/13 3 Boston Marathon Bombings 1253 Boston, MA USA Bombing 3 183 9/16/13 4 Navy Yard Shooting 154 Washington,
Page 6: Countering Violent Extremism: How Can Behavior Analysis Help? · 4/15/13 3 Boston Marathon Bombings 1253 Boston, MA USA Bombing 3 183 9/16/13 4 Navy Yard Shooting 154 Washington,
Page 7: Countering Violent Extremism: How Can Behavior Analysis Help? · 4/15/13 3 Boston Marathon Bombings 1253 Boston, MA USA Bombing 3 183 9/16/13 4 Navy Yard Shooting 154 Washington,

DataScienceProcess

RawData

Collected

DataareProcessed

CleanDataset

DataProduct

ExploratoryData

Analysis

Models&Algorithms

CommunicateVisualizeReport

MakeDecision

RealWorldEvents

Whatdataneedstoberecorded/collected?

-email-webpages-surveys-medicalrecords

HumanobservationsBiologyFinanceInternetMedicineSports

Page 8: Countering Violent Extremism: How Can Behavior Analysis Help? · 4/15/13 3 Boston Marathon Bombings 1253 Boston, MA USA Bombing 3 183 9/16/13 4 Navy Yard Shooting 154 Washington,

DataScienceProcess

RawData

Collected

DataareProcessed

CleanDataset

DataProduct

ExploratoryData

Analysis

Models&Algorithms

CommunicateVisualizeReport

MakeDecision

RealWorldEvents

Whatdataneedstoberecorded/collected?

-email-webpages-surveys-medicalrecords

HumanobservationsBiologyFinanceInternetMedicineSports

Page 9: Countering Violent Extremism: How Can Behavior Analysis Help? · 4/15/13 3 Boston Marathon Bombings 1253 Boston, MA USA Bombing 3 183 9/16/13 4 Navy Yard Shooting 154 Washington,

“Aspecificsignatureofacrimethatisoftenprevalentastheoffender(s)progressinthecriminalprocess”(Douglas&Munn,1992)

Page 10: Countering Violent Extremism: How Can Behavior Analysis Help? · 4/15/13 3 Boston Marathon Bombings 1253 Boston, MA USA Bombing 3 183 9/16/13 4 Navy Yard Shooting 154 Washington,

“UniformedCrimeReport:Crimescategorizedonthebasisoftheirseriousness,frequencyofoccurrence,pervasivenessinallgeographicareasofthecountry,andlikelihoodofbeingreported tolawenforcement.”

Burglary

Page 11: Countering Violent Extremism: How Can Behavior Analysis Help? · 4/15/13 3 Boston Marathon Bombings 1253 Boston, MA USA Bombing 3 183 9/16/13 4 Navy Yard Shooting 154 Washington,

Participants

•Cross-trainedswornofficers•OperationsDivision•3mainshifts:•Day:0700-1900•Night:1900-0700•Power:1500-0300

Page 12: Countering Violent Extremism: How Can Behavior Analysis Help? · 4/15/13 3 Boston Marathon Bombings 1253 Boston, MA USA Bombing 3 183 9/16/13 4 Navy Yard Shooting 154 Washington,

DataScienceProcess

RawData

Collected

DataareProcessed

CleanDataset

DataProduct

ExploratoryData

Analysis

Models&Algorithms

CommunicateVisualizeReport

MakeDecision

RealWorldEvents

Whatdataneedstoberecorded/collected?

-email-webpages-surveys-medicalrecords

HumanobservationsBiologyFinanceInternetMedicineSports

Page 13: Countering Violent Extremism: How Can Behavior Analysis Help? · 4/15/13 3 Boston Marathon Bombings 1253 Boston, MA USA Bombing 3 183 9/16/13 4 Navy Yard Shooting 154 Washington,

Measures• Primary:• MOFormCompletion

• Quality:• CompletenessofMOsection• DiscrepancybetweennarrativeandMOsection

Page 14: Countering Violent Extremism: How Can Behavior Analysis Help? · 4/15/13 3 Boston Marathon Bombings 1253 Boston, MA USA Bombing 3 183 9/16/13 4 Navy Yard Shooting 154 Washington,
Page 15: Countering Violent Extremism: How Can Behavior Analysis Help? · 4/15/13 3 Boston Marathon Bombings 1253 Boston, MA USA Bombing 3 183 9/16/13 4 Navy Yard Shooting 154 Washington,
Page 16: Countering Violent Extremism: How Can Behavior Analysis Help? · 4/15/13 3 Boston Marathon Bombings 1253 Boston, MA USA Bombing 3 183 9/16/13 4 Navy Yard Shooting 154 Washington,
Page 17: Countering Violent Extremism: How Can Behavior Analysis Help? · 4/15/13 3 Boston Marathon Bombings 1253 Boston, MA USA Bombing 3 183 9/16/13 4 Navy Yard Shooting 154 Washington,
Page 18: Countering Violent Extremism: How Can Behavior Analysis Help? · 4/15/13 3 Boston Marathon Bombings 1253 Boston, MA USA Bombing 3 183 9/16/13 4 Navy Yard Shooting 154 Washington,

DataScienceProcess

RawData

Collected

DataareProcessed

CleanDataset

DataProduct

ExploratoryData

Analysis

Models&Algorithms

CommunicateVisualizeReport

MakeDecision

RealWorldEvents

Whatdataneedstoberecorded/collected?

-email-webpages-surveys-medicalrecords

HumanobservationsBiologyFinanceInternetMedicineSports

Page 19: Countering Violent Extremism: How Can Behavior Analysis Help? · 4/15/13 3 Boston Marathon Bombings 1253 Boston, MA USA Bombing 3 183 9/16/13 4 Navy Yard Shooting 154 Washington,

TaskClarification&PSOGroupFeedback

PSOGroupFeedback+Sgt.GroupFeedbackonReportRejection

Page 20: Countering Violent Extremism: How Can Behavior Analysis Help? · 4/15/13 3 Boston Marathon Bombings 1253 Boston, MA USA Bombing 3 183 9/16/13 4 Navy Yard Shooting 154 Washington,
Page 21: Countering Violent Extremism: How Can Behavior Analysis Help? · 4/15/13 3 Boston Marathon Bombings 1253 Boston, MA USA Bombing 3 183 9/16/13 4 Navy Yard Shooting 154 Washington,
Page 22: Countering Violent Extremism: How Can Behavior Analysis Help? · 4/15/13 3 Boston Marathon Bombings 1253 Boston, MA USA Bombing 3 183 9/16/13 4 Navy Yard Shooting 154 Washington,

DataScienceProcess

RawData

Collected

DataareProcessed

CleanDataset

DataProduct

ExploratoryData

Analysis

Models&Algorithms

CommunicateVisualizeReport

MakeDecision

RealWorldEvents

Whatdataneedstoberecorded/collected?

-email-webpages-surveys-medicalrecords

HumanobservationsBiologyFinanceInternetMedicineSports

Page 23: Countering Violent Extremism: How Can Behavior Analysis Help? · 4/15/13 3 Boston Marathon Bombings 1253 Boston, MA USA Bombing 3 183 9/16/13 4 Navy Yard Shooting 154 Washington,
Page 24: Countering Violent Extremism: How Can Behavior Analysis Help? · 4/15/13 3 Boston Marathon Bombings 1253 Boston, MA USA Bombing 3 183 9/16/13 4 Navy Yard Shooting 154 Washington,

0123456789

101112131415

Monday Tuesday Wednesday Thursday Friday Saturday Sunday

Num

ber o

f Occ

urre

nces

Day Occurred

Copper Thefts-04/20/2011-12-06/2011Common Day

0123456789

101112131415

000-300 300-600 600-900 900-1200 1200-1500 1500-1800 1800-2100 2100-000

Num

ber o

f Occ

urre

nces

Hour Occurred

Copper Thefts-04/20/2011-12-06/2011Common Time

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

000-300 600-900 1200-1500 1800-2100

Num

ber o

f Occ

urre

nces

HourOccurred

Copper: Common Days & Times

Monday-Times

Tuesday-Times

Wednesday-Times

Page 25: Countering Violent Extremism: How Can Behavior Analysis Help? · 4/15/13 3 Boston Marathon Bombings 1253 Boston, MA USA Bombing 3 183 9/16/13 4 Navy Yard Shooting 154 Washington,
Page 26: Countering Violent Extremism: How Can Behavior Analysis Help? · 4/15/13 3 Boston Marathon Bombings 1253 Boston, MA USA Bombing 3 183 9/16/13 4 Navy Yard Shooting 154 Washington,

Collect&AnalyzeData

Date Timeline Event DifferenceBetweenEventsLocation Country Type Deaths Injuries6/1/09 1 LittleRockRecrutingShoting 0 LittleRock,AR USA Shooting 1 111/9/09 2 Ft.HoodAttack 161 Killeen,TX USA Shooting 13 334/15/13 3 BostonMarathonBombings 1253 Boston,MA USA Bombing 3 1839/16/13 4 NavyYardShooting 154 Washington,DC USA Shooting 13 810/23/14 5 NYSubwayAttack-Hatchet 402 NYCity,NY USA HandWeapon 0 511/13/15 6 SeriesofComplexAttacks 386 Paris,France France Complex 137 36812/2/15 7 SanBernardinoCoupleAttacks 19 SanBernandino,CA USA Shooting 14 221/7/16 8 ParisPolicestationattack 36 Paris,France France HandWeapon 1 03/25/16 9 BelgiumAirport&Metroattaks 78 Belgium Belgium Bombing 35 3406/12/16 10 PulseNightclubShooting 79 Orlando,FL USA Shooting 49 536/28/16 11 AtaturkAirportAttack 16 Ataturk,Turkey Turkey Complex 45 2307/14/16 12 Truckdrivenintocrowd 16 Nice,France France Vehicle 86 43411/28/16 13 OhioStateAttack 137 Columbus,OH USA Vehicle 0 1112/19/16 14 BerlinChristmasMarketAttack 21 Berlin,Germany German Vehicle 12 56

Page 27: Countering Violent Extremism: How Can Behavior Analysis Help? · 4/15/13 3 Boston Marathon Bombings 1253 Boston, MA USA Bombing 3 183 9/16/13 4 Navy Yard Shooting 154 Washington,

0

2

4

6

8

10

Shooting Bombing HandWeapon Complex Vehicle

Num

bero

fEvents

AttackType

CategoriesofEventTypes

0

200

400

600

800

1000

1200

1400

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14

Num

bero

fDaysB

etweenEven

ts

Events

DifferenceinDays

Page 28: Countering Violent Extremism: How Can Behavior Analysis Help? · 4/15/13 3 Boston Marathon Bombings 1253 Boston, MA USA Bombing 3 183 9/16/13 4 Navy Yard Shooting 154 Washington,
Page 29: Countering Violent Extremism: How Can Behavior Analysis Help? · 4/15/13 3 Boston Marathon Bombings 1253 Boston, MA USA Bombing 3 183 9/16/13 4 Navy Yard Shooting 154 Washington,
Page 30: Countering Violent Extremism: How Can Behavior Analysis Help? · 4/15/13 3 Boston Marathon Bombings 1253 Boston, MA USA Bombing 3 183 9/16/13 4 Navy Yard Shooting 154 Washington,
Page 31: Countering Violent Extremism: How Can Behavior Analysis Help? · 4/15/13 3 Boston Marathon Bombings 1253 Boston, MA USA Bombing 3 183 9/16/13 4 Navy Yard Shooting 154 Washington,
Page 32: Countering Violent Extremism: How Can Behavior Analysis Help? · 4/15/13 3 Boston Marathon Bombings 1253 Boston, MA USA Bombing 3 183 9/16/13 4 Navy Yard Shooting 154 Washington,

BehaviorallyInfusedDataScience

• Defensive:• HelpanalystswithpossiblebehavioralindicatorsforIndicators&Warnings/ModusOperanditoanevent

• Whatdidtheenvironmentlooklike?(Characteristicsrelatedtoevent)

• Havesimilaritiesbeenseeninthepast?(Behavioral?)• Whendiditoccur?(Timeseriesanalysis)• Wherediditoccur?(Spatialanalysis)

• Offensive:• Countermeasures:

• Anythingthateffectivelynegatesorreducesanadversary’sabilitytoexploitourvulnerabilities.

32

Page 33: Countering Violent Extremism: How Can Behavior Analysis Help? · 4/15/13 3 Boston Marathon Bombings 1253 Boston, MA USA Bombing 3 183 9/16/13 4 Navy Yard Shooting 154 Washington,
Page 34: Countering Violent Extremism: How Can Behavior Analysis Help? · 4/15/13 3 Boston Marathon Bombings 1253 Boston, MA USA Bombing 3 183 9/16/13 4 Navy Yard Shooting 154 Washington,

QUESTIONSorCOMMENTS?

SARAHCASELLAJONES,PHD,BCBA-D,[email protected]

34


MASCAL Lessons Learned from Baghdad to Boston · Discuss and review lessons learned from the Boston Marathon bombings Review personal and event preparedness for a potential MASCAL

MASCAL Lessons Learned from Baghdad to Boston · Discuss and review lessons learned from the Boston Marathon bombings Review personal and event preparedness for a potential MASCAL

The Boston Bombings. April 15, 2013 Two Bombs, at Boston Marathon Two suspects, One shot down, One charged Dzhokhar and Tamerlan Tsarnaev are.

The Boston Bombings. April 15, 2013 Two Bombs, at Boston Marathon Two suspects, One shot down, One charged Dzhokhar and Tamerlan Tsarnaev are.

LESSONS LEARNED FROM THE BOSTON MARATHON BOMBINGS ...

LESSONS LEARNED FROM THE BOSTON MARATHON BOMBINGS ...

Resource and Recovery Guide...victims of the Boston Marathon bombings. The injured, their families and the families of the deceased are asked to register with One Fund Boston so they

Resource and Recovery Guide...victims of the Boston Marathon bombings. The injured, their families and the families of the deceased are asked to register with One Fund Boston so they

After Boston Bombings 3 Friends Removed Backpack From Tsarnaev's Dorm FBI

After Boston Bombings 3 Friends Removed Backpack From Tsarnaev's Dorm FBI

Bombings 3 h

Bombings 3 h

Kue Boston Marathon Presentation no video Annual Meeting... · 1/7/2014 1 Prehospital Response to the Marathon Bombings: Boston, MA DavidHirsch,MD,MPH,FACEP EMSMedicalDirector Capital

Kue Boston Marathon Presentation no video Annual Meeting... · 1/7/2014 1 Prehospital Response to the Marathon Bombings: Boston, MA DavidHirsch,MD,MPH,FACEP EMSMedicalDirector Capital

The Boston Marathon Bombings - Firestorm · Firestorm® | The Boston Marathon Bombings The Boston Marathon Bombings A PP R O A C H E S T O P E R S O N A L S A F E T Y I N A C R I

The Boston Marathon Bombings - Firestorm · Firestorm® | The Boston Marathon Bombings The Boston Marathon Bombings A PP R O A C H E S T O P E R S O N A L S A F E T Y I N A C R I

The City as Subject- The Media and Constitutive Rhetoric in President Obama’s “You Will Run Again” Speech after The Boston Marathon Bombings

The City as Subject- The Media and Constitutive Rhetoric in President Obama’s “You Will Run Again” Speech after The Boston Marathon Bombings

The 2013 Boston Marathon Bombings

The 2013 Boston Marathon Bombings

Bali Bombings Memorial

Bali Bombings Memorial

Boston Bar Association...Boston bombings and its highest praise for each person who assisted those who were injured on that fateful day. Further, we recognize the citizens of Boston

Boston Bar Association...Boston bombings and its highest praise for each person who assisted those who were injured on that fateful day. Further, we recognize the citizens of Boston

Boston Bombings: A Surgical View of Lessons Learned From ... · Boston Bombings: A Surgical View of Lessons Learned From Combat Casualty Care and the Applicability to Boston’s Terrorist

Boston Bombings: A Surgical View of Lessons Learned From ... · Boston Bombings: A Surgical View of Lessons Learned From Combat Casualty Care and the Applicability to Boston’s Terrorist

Column Seidentity SCtion CienCteitleS A Case Study of …biometrics.cse.msu.edu/Publications/Face/KlontzJain_IEEEComputer… · Recognition: The Boston Marathon Bombings Suspects

Column Seidentity SCtion CienCteitleS A Case Study of …biometrics.cse.msu.edu/Publications/Face/KlontzJain_IEEEComputer… · Recognition: The Boston Marathon Bombings Suspects

Observations on CFR.org Website Traffic Surge Due to Chechnya Terrorism Scare and the Boston Marathon Bombings

Observations on CFR.org Website Traffic Surge Due to Chechnya Terrorism Scare and the Boston Marathon Bombings

Live blog: Bombings at the Boston Marathon · Live blog: Bombings at the Boston Marathon 1:14:11 PM] April 15, 2013 at 2:58 PM

Live blog: Bombings at the Boston Marathon · Live blog: Bombings at the Boston Marathon 1:14:11 PM] April 15, 2013 at 2:58 PM

1253 Greek Authors

1253 Greek Authors

How have the Boston Marathon bombings aff ected your ... · the Boston Marathon bombings], my mom said, ‘I don’t think it would be a good idea.’ It’s a going to be a large

How have the Boston Marathon bombings aff ected your ... · the Boston Marathon bombings], my mom said, ‘I don’t think it would be a good idea.’ It’s a going to be a large

Baghdad to Boston (or Austin?): Translating Military ...€¦ · Boston Marathon Bombings. Transit Police Shootings 2013: Officer Richard Donahue

Baghdad to Boston (or Austin?): Translating Military ...€¦ · Boston Marathon Bombings. Transit Police Shootings 2013: Officer Richard Donahue

Boston Bombings Mother of Boston Bombing Suspects Arrested Last

Boston Bombings Mother of Boston Bombing Suspects Arrested Last