CORRELATION OF MIDDLE AND UPPER DEVONIAN SHALES IN …€¦ · Marcellus-producing regions of...

48
Correlation of Middle and Upper Devonian shales in the Marcellus-producing regions of Pennsylvania John A. Harper 1 , Robin V. Anthony 2 , Kristin M. Carter 2 , Katherine W. Schmid 2 , Brian J. Dunst 2 , Michele L. Cooney 3 1 PA DCNR, Bureau of Topographic & Geologic Survey (ret.) 2 PA DCNR, Bureau of Topographic & Geologic Survey 3 AECOM 1

Transcript of CORRELATION OF MIDDLE AND UPPER DEVONIAN SHALES IN …€¦ · Marcellus-producing regions of...

Page 1: CORRELATION OF MIDDLE AND UPPER DEVONIAN SHALES IN …€¦ · Marcellus-producing regions of Pennsylvania John A. Harper1, Robin V. Anthony2, Kristin M. Carter2, Katherine W. Schmid2,

Correlation of Middle and Upper Devonian shales in the

Marcellus-producing regions of Pennsylvania

John A. Harper1, Robin V. Anthony2, Kristin M. Carter2,

Katherine W. Schmid2, Brian J. Dunst2, Michele L. Cooney3

1PA DCNR, Bureau of Topographic & Geologic Survey (ret.)2PA DCNR, Bureau of Topographic & Geologic Survey

3AECOM

1

Page 2: CORRELATION OF MIDDLE AND UPPER DEVONIAN SHALES IN …€¦ · Marcellus-producing regions of Pennsylvania John A. Harper1, Robin V. Anthony2, Kristin M. Carter2, Katherine W. Schmid2,

Introduction and Purpose• Introduce MRCSP regional

characterization efforts• Present a cursory history of shale

geology in the Appalachian basin• Explain current interpretive methods

as applied to Pennsylvania data• Provide current lithostratigraphic

correlations

2

Page 3: CORRELATION OF MIDDLE AND UPPER DEVONIAN SHALES IN …€¦ · Marcellus-producing regions of Pennsylvania John A. Harper1, Robin V. Anthony2, Kristin M. Carter2, Katherine W. Schmid2,

Midwest Regional Carbon Sequestration Partnership

3

• What is it?• Three phases• Current regional characterization work• Support for CCUS

Carbon Capture Utilization & Storage

• EOR/EGREnhanced Oil/Gas Recovery

Page 4: CORRELATION OF MIDDLE AND UPPER DEVONIAN SHALES IN …€¦ · Marcellus-producing regions of Pennsylvania John A. Harper1, Robin V. Anthony2, Kristin M. Carter2, Katherine W. Schmid2,

Appalachian Basin Shale Work

4

• Eastern Gas Shales Project (EGSP) –correlation based on GR, “Marcellus facies” vs. Marcellus Formation

• Modern Marcellus shale play (2004) –thousands of wells with modern geophysical logs

• Technology and data availability give rise to improved lithostratigraphic interpretations

Page 5: CORRELATION OF MIDDLE AND UPPER DEVONIAN SHALES IN …€¦ · Marcellus-producing regions of Pennsylvania John A. Harper1, Robin V. Anthony2, Kristin M. Carter2, Katherine W. Schmid2,

EGSP Approach

Page 6: CORRELATION OF MIDDLE AND UPPER DEVONIAN SHALES IN …€¦ · Marcellus-producing regions of Pennsylvania John A. Harper1, Robin V. Anthony2, Kristin M. Carter2, Katherine W. Schmid2,

Modern C

orrelation Log

Page 7: CORRELATION OF MIDDLE AND UPPER DEVONIAN SHALES IN …€¦ · Marcellus-producing regions of Pennsylvania John A. Harper1, Robin V. Anthony2, Kristin M. Carter2, Katherine W. Schmid2,

Methods

7

• Regional mapping using geophysical log control for ~3,500 wells in 41 Pennsylvania counties

• Geologic cross sections using New York terminology

• Integration of regional structural controls• Resolution of correlations to

formation and/or member level

Page 8: CORRELATION OF MIDDLE AND UPPER DEVONIAN SHALES IN …€¦ · Marcellus-producing regions of Pennsylvania John A. Harper1, Robin V. Anthony2, Kristin M. Carter2, Katherine W. Schmid2,

Carter, 2007

• Rhinestreet• Middlesex• Geneseo-Burket• Marcellus

Stratigraphic Correlation Diagram

Page 9: CORRELATION OF MIDDLE AND UPPER DEVONIAN SHALES IN …€¦ · Marcellus-producing regions of Pennsylvania John A. Harper1, Robin V. Anthony2, Kristin M. Carter2, Katherine W. Schmid2,

Devonian shale lithostratigraphy

Page 10: CORRELATION OF MIDDLE AND UPPER DEVONIAN SHALES IN …€¦ · Marcellus-producing regions of Pennsylvania John A. Harper1, Robin V. Anthony2, Kristin M. Carter2, Katherine W. Schmid2,

Cross Section Location Map

Page 11: CORRELATION OF MIDDLE AND UPPER DEVONIAN SHALES IN …€¦ · Marcellus-producing regions of Pennsylvania John A. Harper1, Robin V. Anthony2, Kristin M. Carter2, Katherine W. Schmid2,

Cross Section Location Map

Page 12: CORRELATION OF MIDDLE AND UPPER DEVONIAN SHALES IN …€¦ · Marcellus-producing regions of Pennsylvania John A. Harper1, Robin V. Anthony2, Kristin M. Carter2, Katherine W. Schmid2,

NE-SW Cross Section (Basin Strike)

Page 13: CORRELATION OF MIDDLE AND UPPER DEVONIAN SHALES IN …€¦ · Marcellus-producing regions of Pennsylvania John A. Harper1, Robin V. Anthony2, Kristin M. Carter2, Katherine W. Schmid2,

W-E Cross Section (Basin Dip)

Page 14: CORRELATION OF MIDDLE AND UPPER DEVONIAN SHALES IN …€¦ · Marcellus-producing regions of Pennsylvania John A. Harper1, Robin V. Anthony2, Kristin M. Carter2, Katherine W. Schmid2,

Marcellus Shale

14

Page 15: CORRELATION OF MIDDLE AND UPPER DEVONIAN SHALES IN …€¦ · Marcellus-producing regions of Pennsylvania John A. Harper1, Robin V. Anthony2, Kristin M. Carter2, Katherine W. Schmid2,

Marcellus Structure Map

Page 16: CORRELATION OF MIDDLE AND UPPER DEVONIAN SHALES IN …€¦ · Marcellus-producing regions of Pennsylvania John A. Harper1, Robin V. Anthony2, Kristin M. Carter2, Katherine W. Schmid2,

Major Lineaments

Page 17: CORRELATION OF MIDDLE AND UPPER DEVONIAN SHALES IN …€¦ · Marcellus-producing regions of Pennsylvania John A. Harper1, Robin V. Anthony2, Kristin M. Carter2, Katherine W. Schmid2,

Marcellus Structure Mapwith Lineaments

Page 18: CORRELATION OF MIDDLE AND UPPER DEVONIAN SHALES IN …€¦ · Marcellus-producing regions of Pennsylvania John A. Harper1, Robin V. Anthony2, Kristin M. Carter2, Katherine W. Schmid2,

MarcellusCross-section Inset 1 along E-E’

Page 19: CORRELATION OF MIDDLE AND UPPER DEVONIAN SHALES IN …€¦ · Marcellus-producing regions of Pennsylvania John A. Harper1, Robin V. Anthony2, Kristin M. Carter2, Katherine W. Schmid2,

MarcellusCross-section Inset 1 along E-E’

Page 20: CORRELATION OF MIDDLE AND UPPER DEVONIAN SHALES IN …€¦ · Marcellus-producing regions of Pennsylvania John A. Harper1, Robin V. Anthony2, Kristin M. Carter2, Katherine W. Schmid2,

MarcellusCross-section Inset 1 along E-E’

Page 21: CORRELATION OF MIDDLE AND UPPER DEVONIAN SHALES IN …€¦ · Marcellus-producing regions of Pennsylvania John A. Harper1, Robin V. Anthony2, Kristin M. Carter2, Katherine W. Schmid2,

MarcellusCross-section Inset 1 along E-E’

Page 22: CORRELATION OF MIDDLE AND UPPER DEVONIAN SHALES IN …€¦ · Marcellus-producing regions of Pennsylvania John A. Harper1, Robin V. Anthony2, Kristin M. Carter2, Katherine W. Schmid2,

MarcellusCross-section inset 2 along D-D’

Page 23: CORRELATION OF MIDDLE AND UPPER DEVONIAN SHALES IN …€¦ · Marcellus-producing regions of Pennsylvania John A. Harper1, Robin V. Anthony2, Kristin M. Carter2, Katherine W. Schmid2,

MarcellusCross-section inset 2 along D-D’

Page 24: CORRELATION OF MIDDLE AND UPPER DEVONIAN SHALES IN …€¦ · Marcellus-producing regions of Pennsylvania John A. Harper1, Robin V. Anthony2, Kristin M. Carter2, Katherine W. Schmid2,

MarcellusCross-section inset 2 along D-D’

Page 25: CORRELATION OF MIDDLE AND UPPER DEVONIAN SHALES IN …€¦ · Marcellus-producing regions of Pennsylvania John A. Harper1, Robin V. Anthony2, Kristin M. Carter2, Katherine W. Schmid2,

MarcellusCross-section inset 2 along D-D’

Page 26: CORRELATION OF MIDDLE AND UPPER DEVONIAN SHALES IN …€¦ · Marcellus-producing regions of Pennsylvania John A. Harper1, Robin V. Anthony2, Kristin M. Carter2, Katherine W. Schmid2,

Geneseo and Burket Shales

26

Page 27: CORRELATION OF MIDDLE AND UPPER DEVONIAN SHALES IN …€¦ · Marcellus-producing regions of Pennsylvania John A. Harper1, Robin V. Anthony2, Kristin M. Carter2, Katherine W. Schmid2,

Measured Depth to Top of Geneseo / Burket

Page 28: CORRELATION OF MIDDLE AND UPPER DEVONIAN SHALES IN …€¦ · Marcellus-producing regions of Pennsylvania John A. Harper1, Robin V. Anthony2, Kristin M. Carter2, Katherine W. Schmid2,

Geneseo / BurketMajor Lineaments

Page 29: CORRELATION OF MIDDLE AND UPPER DEVONIAN SHALES IN …€¦ · Marcellus-producing regions of Pennsylvania John A. Harper1, Robin V. Anthony2, Kristin M. Carter2, Katherine W. Schmid2,

Geneseo / Burket MD Lineaments

Page 30: CORRELATION OF MIDDLE AND UPPER DEVONIAN SHALES IN …€¦ · Marcellus-producing regions of Pennsylvania John A. Harper1, Robin V. Anthony2, Kristin M. Carter2, Katherine W. Schmid2,

Geneseo / BurketCross-section inset 1 along E-E’

Page 31: CORRELATION OF MIDDLE AND UPPER DEVONIAN SHALES IN …€¦ · Marcellus-producing regions of Pennsylvania John A. Harper1, Robin V. Anthony2, Kristin M. Carter2, Katherine W. Schmid2,

Geneseo / BurketCross-section inset 1 along E-E’

Page 32: CORRELATION OF MIDDLE AND UPPER DEVONIAN SHALES IN …€¦ · Marcellus-producing regions of Pennsylvania John A. Harper1, Robin V. Anthony2, Kristin M. Carter2, Katherine W. Schmid2,

Geneseo / BurketCross-section Inset 1 along E-E’

Page 33: CORRELATION OF MIDDLE AND UPPER DEVONIAN SHALES IN …€¦ · Marcellus-producing regions of Pennsylvania John A. Harper1, Robin V. Anthony2, Kristin M. Carter2, Katherine W. Schmid2,

Geneseo / BurketCross-section inset 2 along C-C’’

Page 34: CORRELATION OF MIDDLE AND UPPER DEVONIAN SHALES IN …€¦ · Marcellus-producing regions of Pennsylvania John A. Harper1, Robin V. Anthony2, Kristin M. Carter2, Katherine W. Schmid2,

Geneseo / BurketCross-section inset 2 along C-C’’

Page 35: CORRELATION OF MIDDLE AND UPPER DEVONIAN SHALES IN …€¦ · Marcellus-producing regions of Pennsylvania John A. Harper1, Robin V. Anthony2, Kristin M. Carter2, Katherine W. Schmid2,

Geneseo / BurketCross-section

inset 2 along C-C’’

Page 36: CORRELATION OF MIDDLE AND UPPER DEVONIAN SHALES IN …€¦ · Marcellus-producing regions of Pennsylvania John A. Harper1, Robin V. Anthony2, Kristin M. Carter2, Katherine W. Schmid2,

Rhinestreet Shale

36

Page 37: CORRELATION OF MIDDLE AND UPPER DEVONIAN SHALES IN …€¦ · Marcellus-producing regions of Pennsylvania John A. Harper1, Robin V. Anthony2, Kristin M. Carter2, Katherine W. Schmid2,

Measured Depth to Top of Rhinestreet Shale

Page 38: CORRELATION OF MIDDLE AND UPPER DEVONIAN SHALES IN …€¦ · Marcellus-producing regions of Pennsylvania John A. Harper1, Robin V. Anthony2, Kristin M. Carter2, Katherine W. Schmid2,

Rhinestreet Shale Major Lineaments

Page 39: CORRELATION OF MIDDLE AND UPPER DEVONIAN SHALES IN …€¦ · Marcellus-producing regions of Pennsylvania John A. Harper1, Robin V. Anthony2, Kristin M. Carter2, Katherine W. Schmid2,

Rhinestreet Shale MDLineaments

Page 40: CORRELATION OF MIDDLE AND UPPER DEVONIAN SHALES IN …€¦ · Marcellus-producing regions of Pennsylvania John A. Harper1, Robin V. Anthony2, Kristin M. Carter2, Katherine W. Schmid2,

Rhinestreet Shale Cross-section inset D – D’

Page 41: CORRELATION OF MIDDLE AND UPPER DEVONIAN SHALES IN …€¦ · Marcellus-producing regions of Pennsylvania John A. Harper1, Robin V. Anthony2, Kristin M. Carter2, Katherine W. Schmid2,

Rhinestreet Shale Cross-section inset D – D’

Page 42: CORRELATION OF MIDDLE AND UPPER DEVONIAN SHALES IN …€¦ · Marcellus-producing regions of Pennsylvania John A. Harper1, Robin V. Anthony2, Kristin M. Carter2, Katherine W. Schmid2,

Rhinestreet / Upper Devonian shales Cross-section Inset 1 along D-D’

Page 43: CORRELATION OF MIDDLE AND UPPER DEVONIAN SHALES IN …€¦ · Marcellus-producing regions of Pennsylvania John A. Harper1, Robin V. Anthony2, Kristin M. Carter2, Katherine W. Schmid2,

Rhinestreet / Upper Devonian shales Cross-section Inset 1 along D-D’

Page 44: CORRELATION OF MIDDLE AND UPPER DEVONIAN SHALES IN …€¦ · Marcellus-producing regions of Pennsylvania John A. Harper1, Robin V. Anthony2, Kristin M. Carter2, Katherine W. Schmid2,

Rhinestreet Shale Cross-section inset C – C’

Page 45: CORRELATION OF MIDDLE AND UPPER DEVONIAN SHALES IN …€¦ · Marcellus-producing regions of Pennsylvania John A. Harper1, Robin V. Anthony2, Kristin M. Carter2, Katherine W. Schmid2,

Rhinestreet Shale Cross-section inset C – C’

Page 46: CORRELATION OF MIDDLE AND UPPER DEVONIAN SHALES IN …€¦ · Marcellus-producing regions of Pennsylvania John A. Harper1, Robin V. Anthony2, Kristin M. Carter2, Katherine W. Schmid2,

RhinestreetUpper Devonian shalesCross-section inset 2

along C-C’• Extending cross-

section eastward into northern tier.

• Lineaments influence deposition, pinch-outs and TOC.

Page 47: CORRELATION OF MIDDLE AND UPPER DEVONIAN SHALES IN …€¦ · Marcellus-producing regions of Pennsylvania John A. Harper1, Robin V. Anthony2, Kristin M. Carter2, Katherine W. Schmid2,

Key Points

47

• Builds on decades of shale research in PA

• ~3,500 wells in 41 counties

• Revised shale lithology based on modern log suite (GR/Neutron/Density)

• Revising structure and isopach maps• Lineaments control deposition,

influence TOC and diagenesis

Page 48: CORRELATION OF MIDDLE AND UPPER DEVONIAN SHALES IN …€¦ · Marcellus-producing regions of Pennsylvania John A. Harper1, Robin V. Anthony2, Kristin M. Carter2, Katherine W. Schmid2,

Please visit the MRCSP website to download our work:

http://www.mrcsp.org/regional-validation

Robin AnthonyPennsylvania Geological Survey

(412) [email protected]

48