Copyright 2008 Society of Photo Optical Instrumentation ...3472, ,9 43 8 / 8.:880/ 3 80.9 43 349 07...

10
Copyright 2008 Society of Photo Optical Instrumentation Engineers. One print or electronic copy may be made for personal use only. Systematic reproduction and distribution, duplication of any material in this paper for a fee or for commercial purposes, or modification of the content of the paper are prohibited. Terrance E. Boult, Walter J. Scheirer and Robert Woodworth, “FAAD: Face at a Distance,” Biometric Technology for Human Identification V, B.V.K. Vijaya Kumar, S. Prabhakar, Arun A. Ross, Proc. SPIE 6944, 694402 (2008) http://dx.doi.org/10.1117/12.781497

Transcript of Copyright 2008 Society of Photo Optical Instrumentation ...3472, ,9 43 8 / 8.:880/ 3 80.9 43 349 07...

Page 1: Copyright 2008 Society of Photo Optical Instrumentation ...3472, ,9 43 8 / 8.:880/ 3 80.9 43 349 07 25479,39 88:0 8 9 0 . 4 .0 -09 003

Copyright 2008 Society of Photo Optical Instrumentation Engineers. One print or electronic copy may be made for personal use only. Systematic reproduction and distribution, duplication of any material in this paper for a fee or for commercial purposes, or modification of the content of the paper are prohibited. Terrance E. Boult, Walter J. Scheirer and Robert Woodworth, “FAAD: Face at a Distance,” Biometric Technology for Human Identification V, B.V.K. Vijaya Kumar, S. Prabhakar, Arun A. Ross, Proc. SPIE 6944, 694402 (2008) http://dx.doi.org/10.1117/12.781497

Page 2: Copyright 2008 Society of Photo Optical Instrumentation ...3472, ,9 43 8 / 8.:880/ 3 80.9 43 349 07 25479,39 88:0 8 9 0 . 4 .0 -09 003

,.0989,3.0%077,3.04:9,907$.0707,3/#44/479&3;078941447,/4,9447,/4$5738,3/$0.:7.83.

$%#%%0 88:08 41 ,553 1,., 70.43943 ,9 831.,39 /89,3.08 ,70 34397;, ,3/ 41903 8:-90 %8 5,507

8:22,708 0,7841 01147943,.0,9,/89,3.0. 147:8 8 1,72470 9,3, 1,/ :7011479 89,790/:3/07 90#!:2,3 /0391.,943,9 ,89,3.0 5747,2 1 , 90 5747,22078 :3/07 43 , 10 41 900114798/0243897,90/ 1,.0 70.43943,970,907 9,319,3/43 430 0,/-74:9 89:/0/ 1,.070.43943,9/89,3.0870,9079,3209078%488:0807005.9 89:/0/ %01789,8,9248507.80,907..,3,;0,20,8:7,-025,.9,99080/89,3.08%080.43/,70,,880384788:083.:/37084:94310/41;0,3//3,2.7,30 %85,50789,7989,/8.:8843,3/842041708:983803847870,90/88:083.:/37084:943 '/3,2.7,30,3/933472,,9439903/8.:880890!4940,/90.36:0/0;0450/94,3,09025,.9410,9072,3,3/,9248507.8,920/:2/89,3.08%05,5075708039805072039,708:988439029,9438410893889028,9831.,39/89,3.0,3/:3/07343/0,0,907.43/9438,3/57080398842070,8438147900,5071472,3.0903/89,/8.:8843414:7$$%1,:70570/.943174282,798:71,.09047,3/#,3/4208,5574,.08.42-30/39490#88902,3/4902574;0/

$$ #$$&$ #02,350450/8.:881,.0,9,/89,3.0,3/:8097,/943,%$950.,207,8,3,.9:,,55.,943,894

/0./04902,0841908:-0.9413907089-0,.6:70/198,.44507,9;08:-0.99032,3,88:259438.,3-02,/0:9147,343.44507,9;08:-0.99070,14.:841908.03,742:89-014.:80/43,.4054390,/447475,9,070908:-0.9.,3-0050.90/94,550,7 %088902/083072:89.438/079010/41;0 7084:943 ,3/ 93 88:0803 .4483 .425430398 8:22,7 41 0110.9;0 ' 147 /1107039 8038477084:94388 843 3:70,3/%,-047 4 9 8.03,74884207080,7.078,;0/8.:880/:83 9072,8038478(-:90.438/079077084:9430307,94482,940;03.438/07;0389,3/,7/.,207,8,8574;/0, '94482,948074:8.438/07147,.6:73343.44507,9;08:-0.98,9,.405439889028/0830782:89 .438/07 90 7084:943 .4.0 0,7 ,8 9 25,.98 574.0883 706:7020398 038 .4.08 ,3/ 93706:7020398

:70$038477084:9438,3/900110.9;0 '1471,.070.43943,9,.405439%070/,70,8070900,/2:89-0147901,.094-0:8,-0,88:23,3459289.501,.050!#0202-0790:8,-070/,70,2:89,84,..4:39147;,7,943838:-0.909,3/9:8,20,508038478574-,-,232:2147:8,-07084:9438%02,043901,7798,32,017422:83,22103843,244308839

9,897009,2524390019%0.7.0890,:942,9.,/090.90/1,.0

&8,-0

&8,-0

Page 3: Copyright 2008 Society of Photo Optical Instrumentation ...3472, ,9 43 8 / 8.:880/ 3 80.9 43 349 07 25479,39 88:0 8 9 0 . 4 .0 -09 003

.79., 803847 88:0 89,9 41 93 ,3/ 80384780389;9 3 ,55.,9438070 4507,943 8706:70/ 0;03 9 ,//0/:23,943 8420 950 412,0 390381.,943 8300/0/ 89:/ 4197,/943,3903810725,.983473 90 '88:08.,3-0 14:3/ 3 ( 3 4:7 4347 0 ,84 90890/390381078 -:9 14:3/ 9085,9, 7084:943 488 174290390381078%.42-30/99882, '9574;/0/,8944293

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

$038477084:943 &8,-0803508 40543980319 40/09;,7,943 H3 H3 H3 H3,43,803508 ,43,.74883920 80. 80. 80. 80.'079.,147,7/.74883920

80. 80. 80. 80.%,-0&8,-0#084:94380,3/92093 '03 '82,2:2809,9459289.,.,3-0:80/1471,.070.4394343807;,9;00892,9084:/-0

,1908089208843

:70,250841492,073472,0/ 0198,30,2502,01742(%080.43/.4:23848906:343472,,94317429,95,5079097/.4:238439089,3/,7/$&3472,,943,550/94902,08,3/9014:79.4:2384390$0.:7.8/:, &%3472,,943%079.4:2388424700,2508

.425,7843841$&3472,,943,3/$0.:7.8/:, &%3472,,943

$&$9,3/,7/472,,943

$0.:7.8:,& 3472,,943

#,2,08

6:34472,0/

$&

472,0/

$0.:7.8472,0/

Page 4: Copyright 2008 Society of Photo Optical Instrumentation ...3472, ,9 43 8 / 8.:880/ 3 80.9 43 349 07 25479,39 88:0 8 9 0 . 4 .0 -09 003

3472,,943 8 /8.:880/380.943

3490725479,3988:08 90 .4.0 -09003743,3/17,208:99073. 3 9:73 /0503/8 4390 038 ,3/ 89,-,943 743 8:9907 0;03 ,924/07,90 8:9907 8500/8,481479024943939017,2094-0.420,042097./89479437,9079,3:89,-:70-:78,574-02042097./89479438,;0,30;032470/7,2,9. 25,.943 :70 848 708:989,.,207,43, 9754/ 843 90 9508 41042097./894794389,9.,34..:7$42039070893708:98,//70883/0-:773,70.438/070/3 (08420419480,5574,.2,,559490-:773904:/349,//70889088:084190042097./89479438.,34..:73,//9439,9475708:208.43889039-:773./4083494..:7147;-7,943-:7437438:99078

! % $% $!#$%#;03,1907902,08,70,.6:70/90,92485070,3/0,90725,.98.,3-0.79.,147$9:/39028

, .,030 ,8 9 8,7/ 94 .40.9 034:/,9,:3/07 ;,73 .43/9438 %4 ,//7088 980 /0830/, 850.,0/05072039,809:50.,!4940,/%005072039,809:5419039,54940,/8843-0490,2502,08 43 90 79 %8 54940,/ /,9, 8 :36:0 3 9,9 9 8 , 0343 809 41 2,08 #% 9,9 070/85,0/ 43 , 850., ,3/ 903 702,0/ 1742,55742,90 19 ,3/ 19 0 ,70 .:77039 25020393,3490754940,/809:5,92:.70,907/89,3.0899080/89,3.080300/0/,43 '038147.0:80/!4032244203808 147 22.,207,894:39,/,59078,3/!,3,843.! .,207,8 %02,730,87084:9439 %$,3/,850.,,397010.9;0.4,9347/85,90#%1,.02,080708.,0/:5 147/85,8 430.,3800 1742 900,250843 9079.,70, 1742 908,208:-0.9 90#% /,9, ,8 , 7,30 41 39075:5 /89,3.08 54808 ,3/ .4397,898 %8 702,324/0 ,48 90 88902 94.43974548093,3/8:-0.9884,894574;/0907050,9,-9300/0/9484,90900110.94143/89,3.02,3,3/0,907 8430.,380090.40.943574/:.0/2,088:11.039147/0391.,943-:999095084188:08048841.4397,89,3/;,7,94383809,94304:/050.93,70,89.43/89,3.0.40.9430507203980703 :80/ ,.09 ' 90 .42207., 1,.070.43943 88902 1742 /039 %8 ,4792 ,8 430 41 90 9455071472078390,943,,.0#0.43943;03/4790898(

:70 2,3843.0,32,0-:7,3//89479430110.980397,704317422,0,92

!4940,/5072039,$09:5

19

19

:70!4940,/05072039,809:543019,3/8,25054940,/2,08439079

Page 5: Copyright 2008 Society of Photo Optical Instrumentation ...3472, ,9 43 8 / 8.:880/ 3 80.9 43 349 07 25479,39 88:0 8 9 0 . 4 .0 -09 003

%854940,//,9,809808:90/9484204190 88:08 94 -003.4:39070/ 3:83-42097.8 147:3.44507,9;08:-0.9838:7;0,3.0;/04 3041 90 2489 .439740/ ;,7,9438 8 ,9 0 .,8012,9.3 90 574-0 ,3/ 90 ,07 ,70 -,80/43 90 8,20 2,0 0.059 9,9 90 574-0 ,8 -0038:-0.9 94 90 /89,39 702,3 574.088 ,3/ 900,907 47 39, 90893 0 :80/ , .,207, ,9,55742,90 19 ,3/ 90 7,3430 8012,9.35071472,3.0,84;07 84390702,3574.088 ,3/ ,70 349 , 831.,39 88:0 0903 24;0/ 94 90 20/:2 7,30 54940,/.40.943800307, 7,30,.574-0 809.82,0892,08410,.8:-0.90;07 23:098 9 .40.9438 4;07 24398 %0708:93%41 54940,//,9,,8 3.:/0/ 390 #! $ ,3/ 8:-8098 41 90 /,9, ,70,;,,-0 1742 90 ,:9478 9 2,08 5078:-0.90.,3:8090##90.36:0(940892,9089,3/,7/ 077478 ,3/ 89,989., .431/03.0 4:77,583.:/08:.07747-,78

%0 947,58 3 1:70 84 90 25,.9 41/1107039 0,907 .43/9438 43 1,.0 70.43943%080 0 2489 41 90 708:98 0 84 ,70.:2:,9;02,9..:7;08907747-,78%0.:7;0848 90 70.43943 7,90 43 90 ;079., ,8 ,3/907,3:80/ 94/0./0.4770.970.4394343 9047439, ,8 #,3 70.43943 20,38 90507843,893 90 945 8.4708 41 90 889028%4 938 84:/ -0 ,55,7039 1742 9080 7,58789443,97,370.43943470;037,3 411 90 801 889028 ,70 825 349 8:11.039 1479080 7,308 0;03 :3/07 90 -089 41 0,907.43/9438,3//0,548005708843%080,708012,9.3 050720398 $0.43/ 90 1,7 .,207, ,9,55742,90 19 ,8 2:. 2470 831.,3925,.90/ - 90 ;,7,9438 3 0,907 %0 -0890,907 7,3 70.43943 ,9 19 ,8 0 9 8349 84070-:93.70,833/0;032470 831.,39 25,.90/ 90 88902 3 5,79-0.,:80,990807,3080;03,82,/010.9434190.,207,.,:808831.,39-:7,3/2,9,0901,.04:94190803847810/41;09908043 '038080300/0/ 4:8389,93.70,803/4,/3%0807,58,70.425:90/4;0724709,32,08,3/990.439748419054940,/.40.9438034902,08,70/039.,9:890;,7,9438,70349,791,.98413/;/:,07747854804705708843.,308%090.36:0841(2574;0/5071472,3.08934989,989.,831.,393,705,79-0.,:8090/43 9,//7088-:747042097./894794343.4397,.9,3//3,2.7,30

3,//94394;,7,9438/:0944-;4:80,9070110.984:7050720398,84840/9,99070070;,7,9438/:09492041/,%007747-,7147907,588843439001924895439411:708.43889039380147901:7,5 %080/110703.08,7089,989.,831.,39 490 9,9 94 70/:.0 90 25,.9415480,3/ 93;,7,943890802,08,70:83900,.98,202,04390/85,,839070.43943/,9,-,80 9043;,7,9438-0900390574-0,3/90,07,709480.,:80/-902,388902#0.,9,93/4478,919905071472,3.0439895041/,9,830,750710.9;03998;0789743.43897,3908009,9,91943,.0,7,3/43//,147#,370.43943905071472,3.0414304190-089.42207.,,479288-04 9 ,3/890

:70.:7;08147;,74:80,907809938

Page 6: Copyright 2008 Society of Photo Optical Instrumentation ...3472, ,9 43 8 / 8.:880/ 3 80.9 43 349 07 25479,39 88:0 8 9 0 . 4 .0 -09 003

-04 70.439437,900;03038,39080,70,;07,0/4;07:3/70/84197,892,0850797,84988349,8,253,791,.9

1789:08829-09,99025,.9807043907,2,06:,9 00,230/;,74:820,8:708411,.,2,0 6:,9 ,3/ 94 4:7 8:75780 2,3 41 90 077478 ,/ 3493 94 /4 9 :2,3 507.0;0/ 47 ,4792.,20,8:70/2,06:,9:7084884200,2508419070.439437,30070902,003/0/:503574-08,7084790/-2,9.8.470147,.40.943412,081742,8,202,005072039#,3,3/2,06:,93988090703;0780.4770,90/

:77080,7.8094119413/90.,:8084198:3050.90/54475071472,3.01907.438/07,-03;089,9430549080/ 9054475071472,3.0,8/:0 3 ,705,79 9407747 34.,,94341 90008 3 (057080390/,3,3,88 41 98 9047 %4 /0139;0 84 90 .,:800 ,//0/ 70897,9432,707893 4:7 54940,/ /,9, 94,4:8 94 97,381472 90473,00 .447/3,908 94574;/0004.,9438 390.,59:70/ 2,08%07,58,-4;0849070.439435071472,3.0907747-,781479041190801,.09,47928,3/03:80147.0/,.0994:80 90 .4770.9 00 5489438 %0 708:98 43 -49 .,207,8 070 89,989., 831.,39 ,3/ 03 90 008 ,70.4770.90/905071472,3.0-491,7,3/30,7.,207,8,7082,7%080708:98,7041.4:780459289.-0.,:8090/,9,147.4770.9438,791.,.,-7,94354398,3/80.43/9888012,9.39908,202,0,8574-08,3/,07849030,750710.970.43943894-0050.90/

9825479,399434909,990004.,9438-03/8.:880/,70349:89,6:08943410703902,090008,550,7-:949,954894370,90/94070984:/-03902,0 39044/6:,92,0841 1:7090.4770.90/00548943 8349 3 902//041 9000 9248507. 9:7-:03.0,3/03830110.9 .,3/89479 90 1,.02,0949054399,994475745079088902300/894:80,/11070390054894314798.447/3,9088902,3/3472,,943 574.0/:708 ,341 90 .425:90/ 00 4.,9438070 ;8- 411 90 00 ,3/ 90,;07,0 /110703.0-0900390.425:90/,3/,.09008,8508

3.43.:8430,907,3/,92485070,;00110.989,9831.,3925,.99088902,8/0243897,90/399.439740/050720398 %025,.98749/89,3.0,3/8349:89,6:089434148841.4397,8947-:773-:9,8441042097./89479438

$$% &## $ #% $&#% # 47343.44507,9;08:-0.98,9,/89,3.00300/8420, 94/09072300390 2,08,7044/,3/03

90,705447990889020;090825089,55.,94341570/.94383,33907,.9;04743308890207010.,3570/.91,:7090302982570,.6:70,302,0,3/97,,3#,9079,3,5:70-3,7434490570/.943.,3-0:8094/0907230098147,902547,1:84324/:0%8,8,34-;4:8/70.9,55.,9433-42097.8147:3.44507,9;08:-0.983;/04 489.42207.,889028,;08420;07825014724198950411,:70 570/.943 0 90 /43 9 0;03 -49079 70.43943 :3088 90 1,.0 /090.94324/:0 7054798 , 1,.0 98:11.039 .431/03.0 0 ,;0 3974/:.0/ , 2470 54071: ,5574,. :83 90 82,79 8.4708 9,9 089 ,1907 ,

:70',7,94384;0792041/, :70#0.43943#,3147;,74:86:,92,08

,0

Page 7: Copyright 2008 Society of Photo Optical Instrumentation ...3472, ,9 43 8 / 8.:880/ 3 80.9 43 349 07 25479,39 88:0 8 9 0 . 4 .0 -09 003

4!70.59,9433/

,.090 4.,,943425:90/0 4.,943

549039,2,9. %0 -,8./0,89,9908,50419082,79 8.4708 ;00/ ,8,.:7;0478:71,.0574;/08,//0/31472,943,-4:990:36:03088 41 90 2,9.,3/ 90 574-,-9 418:..088 41 90 4;07,2,9.3574.088

0 90 0307,9047 8:0898 9,9 8,50,3,88 84:/ 570/.91,:70 90 /09,8 41 908,508 ,3/ 907 549039,147 570/.943 ,70 ,84 ,1:3.943 41 90 /,9, 85,.00.,:80 41 90 3,9:70 41-42097.85,.089082,798:71,.041903.439,3810,9:708,92:9508.,08.,:80/-2,9.398:-.:890784170,90//,9,02:9508,25081742908,203/;/:,4;0792017421,2202-07847174250450382,7/0247,5.545:,9438,929-050,0/3,43480889020709039078:-0.9;,7,9438,7082,.425,70/ 94 397,8:-0.9 ;,7,9438 29 -0 1,9 3 , 88902 9 831.,39 39078:-0.9 ;,7,9438 ,3/ , ,70545:,943 %080 ;,7,9438,70 1:3.9438 41 90 :3/073 545:,943 90 -42097. ,47928,3/ 90 .40.94388902%:83$$%90889020,73890,557457,908,5031472,943147,5,79.:,788902389,,9430-00;0,343300,733,47922,-0902489,557457,90147214713,/054203940;0739,47:80411300,733,3/2470.,701:05072039,943

02:9803847829 -0 :80/ 3 8420 ,55.,9438 90 4,8 41 90 # 88902 0307, -089,3/,430478308038478890289:80-0:83$$%1471:8431742,830803847.42-33/1107039,47928 ,3/ 5079:7-,9438 41 90 473, /,9, 0 ,;0 -003 05473 94 /1107039 ,47928 94 2502039$$% 430 -,80/ 43/,44893 ( ,3/ 430 -,80/ 432:9,07 30:7,3098 :83,;009 10,9:708 ( /,-44893 -:/8 , 89743 .,88107 17422:950 74:3/8 41 8250 .42-3,9438 41 0, .,881078 3 08803.0 90,738 974:,34330,7232,943 90 897:.9:7,.42-3,9438 410, .,881078 9,9 -089 ,..4:39 147 9097,33/,9,9,4814790011.039/090723,94341.10,9:7082,9907147,5,79.:,7/,9,809

%8$$%:83/,-4489,8-003,550/ 94570/.93 1,:70841 90,.0% 1,.070.43943,4792-/039,3/90890/43-4983909.,3/3,9:7,;,7,943832,08%00,2504390798481,:70570/.943 7,908 147 -49 90 97,33 ,3/ 9089 8098 147 2,08.40.90/ :3/07 70, 0,907 .43/9438 %080 2,08 0709,03,919,3/19.2,01,.,70.439431,72470.,033 %0 97,3390893 147 98 :80/ 2,0885906:, 9,7,90-04 9088902,889.4770.9 570/.93 2470 9,3 41 90 70.43943 889021,:708 147 430 41 90 0,/3 .42207., 1,.070.43943889028 47 1:843 43 10/ /,9, 90 7,904:/ -06:900110.9;03093430,4792;078:8,34907 1,1,80 ,,72 20,38 9,3574.0883 ,34907 2,0 1742 90;/04806:03.0,894:/9248970249070.4394341:3.44507,9;08:-0.98903,30;03071,80,,727,90.,3-0 9407,90/ 47,288/090.9437,9041 0 9088902.4770.9 570/.90/ 41 , 70.43943 1,:7080 ,;0 ,1,80 ,,72 7,90 41 43 3 8:22,7 90/,-44893,5574,. 94 13/3 , 1,:70 570/.943 .,88107 0,738 9010,9:7084125479,3.0;076:.,3/90708:93.,881078,708:9,-014770,9204507,943

:70 ,:70570/.9435071472,3.0147$$%:83/,-4489%0890/43

!4940,/2,08

:70..:7,.9,:94/090.90/008,3/9.425:90/.4770.90/008

4!70.59,9433/!

,.090 4.,,943425:90/0 4.,943

0,7.,207, ,7.,207,

Page 8: Copyright 2008 Society of Photo Optical Instrumentation ...3472, ,9 43 8 / 8.:880/ 3 80.9 43 349 07 25479,39 88:0 8 9 0 . 4 .0 -09 003

%080.43/,5574,.0,;0-003/0;0453:808,-,.5745,,94330:7,3099,;00910,9:70817429082,798:71,.0 0 -701 8:22,70 90 ,5574,. /09,8 .,3 -014:3/3 (%85,79.:,7,5574,.,8/0;0450/94,//7088,5,79.:,7,412574;3,-42097.88902:831,:70570/.94394570/.903,88902,80941,,3/1845079:7-3035:9574507908948001-09907708:98.4:/-04-9,30/4909,9980,2508,850.,.,8041-42097.1:843070901:843893908,2024/,97424:7,3,884343/89,3.02,080349,990

0013/07830;03900,/3.42207.,889028419030703,/06:,9035,79-0.,:8041,9248507./89479438 ( $4,8 90 1789 ,55.,943 41 90 1,:70 570/.943 9047 0,//70880/ 90 574-02 41 /0./3 03 , 1,.0 2,0 ,80941,,3/1840.438/070/2:9505079:7-,94384190 ,88:20/ 00 4.,9438 ,3/ 90890/ 90 30 4.,9438 147549039,1,:70%0,4792,8 90890/43 9054940,//,9,8098:83

94 /1107039 ,47928 430 41 90 0,/3 90 .42207.,574/:.98,3/ ,825020390/- (%01:70439079 848 90 4;07, 2574;02039 .42-33 90.42207.,88902990$$%5079:7-,94384:7/1107039920841/,974:4:990243941,070:80/14798,3,88%0708:98,70843,;07,0/4;072:950/,874:50/-92041/,%007747-,7884 89,989., .431/03.0490 9,9 3 98 809 41 050720398077478 3 00 4.,,943 .420 1742 94 84:7.08 90 004.,,94307747/:094/07,/,943419035:92,0,8,708:941,9248507.0110.98,3/90004.,,94307747/:0945488-00,308808390.42207.,004.,,943,4792%40907004.,,943077478.0,7,3:33436:,39940;07 9 805490/6:900110.9;0070 94 2574;04;07,.,881.,943 9 8.0,7 9,9 902574;02039807089,9.,831.,392574;020398147 07082,7390 7,30

% !$ $#0.039 47 - 7 4:9 /0;0450/ 90 .43.059 41 494508 70;4.,-0 -42097.-,80/ 94038 9,9 57490.9 9057;,. 41 90 473, :807 574;/0 147 2,3 82:9,304:8 ;,7,9438 9,9 .,3349 -0 30/ 470 831.,3940;070,70:83494508 1,.08147985740.9-0.,:809097,3814723/:.08,74-:89/89,3.082,792097.147 :80 3 2,9.3 3 03.4/0/ 85,.0 %8 74-:89 /89,3.0 97,381472 ,8 -003 843 94 831.,39 2574;05071472,3.0,3/8050.90/94-00;032470831.,3903:80/3/11.:9809938(02,31,.0,47928,;0-003/0;0450/,190713/310,9:7082489,;0:80/, /89,3.020,8:7047,

89247074-:8914728:.,8,,,34-848309420,8:70/89,3.0-09003574-0,3/,07%08095084120,8:708,;090/8,/;,39,09,9,1010,9:708-03831.,39411.,3,;0,/7,2,9.25,.9439070.439437,90 %0 97,381472,3/2,9.3:80/ 147-494508 -,8., 70/:.0 90503,9 147-03944 1,7 1742 905,79.:,710,9:7094,.4389,39 %:810,9:7089,9,70831.,39307747,;0,.4389,39,3/03.070,970/:.0/25,.9%8.,3-0;0725479,3930889,3/0,80993147.90#889028-03/0830/-0.,:809544793,3/343.44507,9;08:-0.983/;/:,10,9:708,702470094,;0,342,4:820,8:7020398

!&%% % % %## #%0,-4;0970090.34408,70-03.42-30/9,3,3/! .425:93.47094147290.4704190

#88902147,.0989,3.0-4./,7,288433:70%0! 03,3.0/88902/408901,.013/33,7/,700.,:8041909388:08.0-02,310/-90:804190089,799,850.,933472,,943/08.7-0/380.943%0.470:808905079:7-,943,5574,.,2:95480,075:82:950,4792894;,7,9438419049450,5574,.9,$$%-,80/570/.9431:8390 5079:7-,9438 94,..4:39 147 437,30 ,9248507.8,3/ 5480 88:08 41 343.44507,9;0 8:-0.98 $$% 8 ,84-03:80/147902547,1:843,80//3(0,;0,70,//0;0450/,1,.0/090.943,3/4.,,94374:9309,9 8 8:9,-0 147! 2502039,943 ,553 98 94 02-0//0/889028,7/,70 3.:/3 90 1472, 10/

:70#,3/4208!071472,3.02574;02039843,0,/3.42207.,,4792

Page 9: Copyright 2008 Society of Photo Optical Instrumentation ...3472, ,9 43 8 / 8.:880/ 3 80.9 43 349 07 25479,39 88:0 8 9 0 . 4 .0 -09 003

5439 ,3,88 8 :3/07, ,3/ 9,9 1: 10/5439,47929.0 -0 /43 90 1472, 90893 %0702,33 .425430398 089 ,3/ ,70 -03 54790/ 94 90 ! 03;7432039 . :3/074 0330073 ,3/574949509089339010/949,0908890294%# 325479,396:08943841.4:780409850714728&31479:3,90340893/,9,8098;0708:90/147

5745075071472,3.090893419834;0,5574,.,3/,.40.9438-03/0830/147$573%4574;/0,34;07,/0,41985071472,3.09090.36:08,;0-00390890/432:9500343/,9,8098%,-0848708:98419070;4.,-049450843#%/,9,8098%4/0243897,90900307,941902574;02039894-04-9,30/-:83 494508 ,3/ # 0 0903/0/ ,47928 3.:/0/ 3 90 447,/4 $9,90 &3;0789 $& ,.0/0391.,943;,:,943$8902'07843 ( 3 5,79.:,7 0 /0;0450/49450 ;078438 1742 90 -,8030!-,80/ 1,.070.4394388902:832:950 2097.8 1742 907 -,80/1,.0 70.43943 ,47928 ,3/ 1742 90,89. :3. 7,5 ,9.07 8 8 0;/039 ,553 90 70;4.,-097,381472894.43;079!394,-49450,4792 ;07 831.,39 2574;0/ 985071472,3.084147 ,3/ 0 90 -089 41 90 473, #% 88433909,-0.42207.,,47928,;0.4393:0/942574;083.09,9/,9047 .425,7843 90 089 7054790/8.470 147 ,3 .42207., ,4792 43:5 8 84 90 74:5 ,8 ,80110.9;0 ,8 ,3 343 .42207.,,4792 ,3/ 90 3/;/:, -49450,47928 070 -09907 %0 3/;/:,494508 50714720/ -09907 -:9 706:70

:70 ;07,#,7.90.9:70147,.0989,3.0

4792,9,809 :5 :5 ,1- ,1. ,9.0/8.4708 432,9.0/ ! /,$419 !70/.9;0 #%$% 3/;/:,!49450 ,.0 74:5#4-:89!49450 ,.0 494508 ,.0 74:5#4-:89 49450 ,.0 3/;/:, 49450 ,.0 :92,0#! :92,0# ! $0.:7.8472,0

%,-0#,3#0.43943#,90843#%8:-8098

Page 10: Copyright 2008 Society of Photo Optical Instrumentation ...3472, ,9 43 8 / 8.:880/ 3 80.9 43 349 07 25479,39 88:0 8 9 0 . 4 .0 -09 003

2:9502,0841,33/;/:,14703742039%05071472,3.041 ,88:507479490!,3/ -,80/,47928-:990.489,3/897:.9:70419,9,47922,09:3,..059,-01474:770,92088902%013,74419,-0848905071472,3.0,314790!,4792:891742:839030$0.:7.8472,,9433974/:.0/3$0.943 9 2574;0/ 3903893472,,9435071472,3.0,8831.,39 3.70,80/43:5,3/982,75071472,3.043:5-:9,89488415071472,3.04349090,07,890!9025,9084190894.,0799089,3/,7/3472,,943,3/9,92,,;0.,:80/90488415071472,3.043,3/:5%09,-0,848489,9902:92,0#,5574,.25020390/314,935439147903/;/:,494508;078438 9 90 30 3472,,943 ,3/ 5079:7-,9438 :83 0907 ! 47 ,430 ,.0;0 70.43943,..:7,.4398/,9, %8 70.439437,9082584890/,9,8098,7094482,1470110.9;0908934198,4792%08939,707/,9,80988050.90/,19079010/5439;078434190#889028.425090%080.43//,9,8090:80/14790893890!480:23,943,3/5708843!/,9,8091742& 748809,

( 0700 .438/070/ 43 90 93 ,3/ :23,943349 90 5480 47 057088438 %0 5071472,3.0 147 90:92,0 # ,47928 ,8 ,,3 70.43943 -:9 ! 43 ,8 8:-0.98 84 0 9 84874-:893088 94 93 90 ,07 80 8 89 6:90 82, 3 .425,7843 0;03 9 90 2574;0/ :, &%3472,,9439089,3/,7/!,3/ ,4792843,.0;0 ,3/ 7,370.4394370850.9;0

&$ $%8 5,507 70;00/ 4:7 47 43 2,47 88:08 147 ,.0 ,9 , 89,3.0 3.:/3 803847 88:08 ,3/

0,907,9248507.8 9 70;00/ 90 !4940,/ .43.059 ,3/ 708:98 147 88902,9. 0;,:,943 41 ,9248507. ,3/0,907 0110.98 %8 5,507 840/ 90.36:08 9,9 03 .42-30/ ,//70880/ 9080 88:08 ,3/ 3974/:.0/ 90# ,7.90.9:70 147 0110.9;0 %0 .43.:843 8 343.44507,9;0 1,.0,9,/89,3.0 0850., 3 498,.,033574-029,92:89-0,//70880/,9,0;070;0419088902/0833.:/3908038479003808,3/90,479299088902570/.9398435071472,3.0

##$( $4.438 411 ,3/ :3/-07 2,0 390381.,943 147 4 9 ,.0 #0.43943

478454342097.8:303.42-3,9439'!#( % '40843%4:9 ,7/307#44/479#43843,3/013 $0.:79$8902

!$ 447 ,207, 9 3907, :2,3 #0.43943 $! 010380 $2548:2 $038478 ,3/422,3/43974422:3.,9438,3/39003.0 %0.34408147420,3/$0.:79,3/420,3/010380'57

( 420 $ 0;07/0 # %007, ,3/ 7,507 %0 $& 1,.0 /0391.,943 0;,:,94388902985:7548010,9:708,3/897:.9:70'$

( !58! 74907!.0,8#,.-:73%,-,88,3/430 ,.0#0.43943'03/47%089#'%%0.3.,#05479$%# $%

( # .0,8 %4:9 11.039 0;,:,943 41 .,881.,943 ,3/ 70.43943 889028 431 43425:907'843,3/!,99073#0.43943'!#55:30

( $ ,7,82,3,3/$ ,,7 4397,89#08947,943410,90707,/0/2,08 %7,38,.943843!,990733,88,3/,.3039003.0!'44:30

( %!#45,,3/%4:9%008,;0942097.8094/8,3/55.,943847845070055

( ,4 ,3/ % 4:9 !70/.93 42097. $8902 ,:70 4310703.0 43 425:9,943,39003.0147420,3/$0.:79,3/!07843,$,190,7.

( %!#45,,3/%4:9,881.,9433,3.02039;,42097.!,99073!079:7-,943!#4310703.043:/4,3/'/04-,80/!07843:9039.,943'!:

( %4:9 #4-:89/89,3.020,8:7081471,.070.439438:55479370;4.,-0-42097.94038 43143,.0,3/ 089:7057

( 0 ' #,208 : %077 4:9 3 ,330 #0,-9 0,8:70 %7,33 147 :9,207, ,.0#0.43943 47845439055.,94341425:907'8430-

($4.438$0307%072,,.0#0.439433,3 507,943,$.03,74'!# ( ,4-/ ,,$.2/,3/-/,31.,943,3/ 4389,3.0,.0#0.43943

,9,-,80.6:8943;,:,943,3/3,3.020393!74.42097.8438479:2431