COPE: Today and tomorrow Pearson... · COPE: Today and tomorrow Promoting integrity in research and...

16
COPE: Today and tomorrow Promoting integrity in research and its publication Chris Graf, Geri Pearson, Co-Vice Chairs, COPE Disclosure: CG works for Wiley and benefits from the company’s commercial success. CG receives no form of compensation from COPE for his voluntary role with COPE. GP has nothing to disclose.

Transcript of COPE: Today and tomorrow Pearson... · COPE: Today and tomorrow Promoting integrity in research and...

Page 1: COPE: Today and tomorrow Pearson... · COPE: Today and tomorrow Promoting integrity in research and its publication Chris Graf, Geri Pearson, Co-Vice Chairs, COPE Disclosure: CG works

COPE: Today and tomorrow Promoting integrity in research and its publicationChris Graf, Geri Pearson, Co-Vice Chairs, COPEDisclosure: CG works for Wiley and benefits from the company’s commercial success. CG receives no form of compensation from COPE for his voluntary role with COPE. GP has nothing to disclose.

Page 2: COPE: Today and tomorrow Pearson... · COPE: Today and tomorrow Promoting integrity in research and its publication Chris Graf, Geri Pearson, Co-Vice Chairs, COPE Disclosure: CG works

publicationethics.org

COPE today

Page 3: COPE: Today and tomorrow Pearson... · COPE: Today and tomorrow Promoting integrity in research and its publication Chris Graf, Geri Pearson, Co-Vice Chairs, COPE Disclosure: CG works

publicationethics.org

An enormous amount of great work• 11,000+ members in 103 countries

(Algeria to Zimbabwe)• International and diverse• All research and scholarly work

COPE today: Let’s pause and reflect

Page 4: COPE: Today and tomorrow Pearson... · COPE: Today and tomorrow Promoting integrity in research and its publication Chris Graf, Geri Pearson, Co-Vice Chairs, COPE Disclosure: CG works

MembershipChair: Michael Wise

Applies standardsAll are servedInternational

Cross-disciplinary

Page 5: COPE: Today and tomorrow Pearson... · COPE: Today and tomorrow Promoting integrity in research and its publication Chris Graf, Geri Pearson, Co-Vice Chairs, COPE Disclosure: CG works

EducationChair: Elizabeth Moylan

Flowcharts (18x10)Guidelines

Discussion documentsCases

Statements

Page 6: COPE: Today and tomorrow Pearson... · COPE: Today and tomorrow Promoting integrity in research and its publication Chris Graf, Geri Pearson, Co-Vice Chairs, COPE Disclosure: CG works

Outreach and Events

Chair: Mirjam Curno

Education, supportSeminarsForums

Workshops

Page 7: COPE: Today and tomorrow Pearson... · COPE: Today and tomorrow Promoting integrity in research and its publication Chris Graf, Geri Pearson, Co-Vice Chairs, COPE Disclosure: CG works

ComplaintsChair: Tara Hoke

New approachFacilitate resolution Does not adjudicate

Page 8: COPE: Today and tomorrow Pearson... · COPE: Today and tomorrow Promoting integrity in research and its publication Chris Graf, Geri Pearson, Co-Vice Chairs, COPE Disclosure: CG works

ResearchChair: Adrian Ziderman

Members The wider community

Understand needsPlan accordingly

Page 9: COPE: Today and tomorrow Pearson... · COPE: Today and tomorrow Promoting integrity in research and its publication Chris Graf, Geri Pearson, Co-Vice Chairs, COPE Disclosure: CG works

NominationsChair: Zoë Mullan

CouncilDiverseGlobal

ExperiencedGrowing

Page 10: COPE: Today and tomorrow Pearson... · COPE: Today and tomorrow Promoting integrity in research and its publication Chris Graf, Geri Pearson, Co-Vice Chairs, COPE Disclosure: CG works

Often behind the scenes

FinanceChair: Deborah Poff

StrategyChair: Ginny Barbour

COPE’s future

COPE teamLead by Natalie Ridgeway

Linda GoughSarah GillmoreIratxe Puebla

Dominic MitchellCynthia Clerk

Cathy Whiteley(Thank you all!)

GovernanceSecretary: Charon

Pierson

Page 11: COPE: Today and tomorrow Pearson... · COPE: Today and tomorrow Promoting integrity in research and its publication Chris Graf, Geri Pearson, Co-Vice Chairs, COPE Disclosure: CG works

publicationethics.org

COPE tomorrow

Page 12: COPE: Today and tomorrow Pearson... · COPE: Today and tomorrow Promoting integrity in research and its publication Chris Graf, Geri Pearson, Co-Vice Chairs, COPE Disclosure: CG works

Today’s problems tell us about COPE tomorrow

Irene Hames, at 7th International Congress on Peer Review, 8–10 September 2013, Chicago, USA

http://bit.ly/2qAD5Be

Page 13: COPE: Today and tomorrow Pearson... · COPE: Today and tomorrow Promoting integrity in research and its publication Chris Graf, Geri Pearson, Co-Vice Chairs, COPE Disclosure: CG works

• Research is now a regular job for many– yet basic training often neglects ethics

• Research is global, yet managed locally

• Easier to manipulate text, figures, review– with few accepted standards

• Publishing, and research, is changing fast

Contributing issues: It’s complex

The wicked problem threatening academic research http://bit.ly/2q9FH7Y

Page 14: COPE: Today and tomorrow Pearson... · COPE: Today and tomorrow Promoting integrity in research and its publication Chris Graf, Geri Pearson, Co-Vice Chairs, COPE Disclosure: CG works

publicationethics.org

Underlying problems: incentives

Page 15: COPE: Today and tomorrow Pearson... · COPE: Today and tomorrow Promoting integrity in research and its publication Chris Graf, Geri Pearson, Co-Vice Chairs, COPE Disclosure: CG works

We need a culture of responsibility for the integrity of the literature… it’s not just the

job of editorsGinny Barbour, COPE Chair, 2015 ’’‘‘

Today’s problems tell us about COPE tomorrow

Page 16: COPE: Today and tomorrow Pearson... · COPE: Today and tomorrow Promoting integrity in research and its publication Chris Graf, Geri Pearson, Co-Vice Chairs, COPE Disclosure: CG works

publicationethics.org

COPE tomorrowDiversity + collaboration

• Institutional members (a pilot now)• Diverse geographies, disciplines

A road we need totravel together