Cooperative Autonomous Driving and Interaction with Vulnerable...

47
9 th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation for Intelligent Vehicles. Vancouver, Canada, 24 th Sept. 2017 Cooperative Autonomous Driving and Interaction with Vulnerable Road Users Miguel Ángel Sotelo [email protected] Full Professor University of Alcalá (UAH) SPAIN 9th Workshop on PPNIV – Keynote

Transcript of Cooperative Autonomous Driving and Interaction with Vulnerable...

Page 1: Cooperative Autonomous Driving and Interaction with Vulnerable …ppniv17.irccyn.ec-nantes.fr/session2/Sotelo/presentation.pdf · 9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation

9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation for Intelligent Vehicles. Vancouver, Canada, 24th Sept. 2017

Cooperative Autonomous Driving and Interaction with Vulnerable Road Users

Miguel Ángel Sotelo

[email protected] Full Professor

University of Alcalá (UAH)SPAIN

9th Workshop on PPNIV – Keynote

Page 2: Cooperative Autonomous Driving and Interaction with Vulnerable …ppniv17.irccyn.ec-nantes.fr/session2/Sotelo/presentation.pdf · 9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation

9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation for Intelligent Vehicles. Vancouver, Canada, 24th Sept. 2017 2

u Motivation

u Autonomous Cooperative Driving

u GCDC Results

u Interaction with VRUs

u Conclusions and Future Work

Content

Page 3: Cooperative Autonomous Driving and Interaction with Vulnerable …ppniv17.irccyn.ec-nantes.fr/session2/Sotelo/presentation.pdf · 9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation

9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation for Intelligent Vehicles. Vancouver, Canada, 24th Sept. 2017 3

• Despite the great development in the past years, thereare still some major limitations in AutonomousDriving:

Motivation

Legal frameworkLegal frameworkLegal framework

NavigationNavigationNavigation ReliabilityReliabilityReliability

EfficiencyEfficiencyEfficiency Social AcceptanceSocial AcceptanceSocial Acceptance

Page 4: Cooperative Autonomous Driving and Interaction with Vulnerable …ppniv17.irccyn.ec-nantes.fr/session2/Sotelo/presentation.pdf · 9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation

9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation for Intelligent Vehicles. Vancouver, Canada, 24th Sept. 2017 4

• Navigation:- Enriched maps are needed (2 Gb/Km).

- International Consortia: BMW, Daimler, Audi (HERE).

- Online data acquisition and map building.

Limitations of Autonomous Vehicles

Page 5: Cooperative Autonomous Driving and Interaction with Vulnerable …ppniv17.irccyn.ec-nantes.fr/session2/Sotelo/presentation.pdf · 9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation

9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation for Intelligent Vehicles. Vancouver, Canada, 24th Sept. 2017 5

• Reliability:- Improvement in sensorial capabilities (adverse weather).

- Development of Cooperative Systems.

• Efficiency:- Human-like decision making and maneuvering.

- Emulation of human driving by means of prediction ofintentions of other traffic agents, such as pedestrians andother vehicles.

- There is a need for enhanced cooperation andinteraction capabilities.

Limitations of Autonomous Vehicles

Page 6: Cooperative Autonomous Driving and Interaction with Vulnerable …ppniv17.irccyn.ec-nantes.fr/session2/Sotelo/presentation.pdf · 9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation

9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation for Intelligent Vehicles. Vancouver, Canada, 24th Sept. 2017 6

u Motivation

u Autonomous Cooperative Driving

u GCDC Results

u Interaction with VRUs

u Conclusions and Future Work

Content

Page 7: Cooperative Autonomous Driving and Interaction with Vulnerable …ppniv17.irccyn.ec-nantes.fr/session2/Sotelo/presentation.pdf · 9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation

9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation for Intelligent Vehicles. Vancouver, Canada, 24th Sept. 2017 7

• Techniques:- Cooperation with other vehicles (autonomously or manually

driven) and with the infrastructure.

- Cooperation with VRUs (Vulnerable Road Users) byprediction their intentions and trajectories.

Autonomous Cooperative Driving

• Limitations:- Strong dependency on penetration rate.

• Goal:- Increase reliability and efficiency of autonomous vehicles.

Page 8: Cooperative Autonomous Driving and Interaction with Vulnerable …ppniv17.irccyn.ec-nantes.fr/session2/Sotelo/presentation.pdf · 9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation

9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation for Intelligent Vehicles. Vancouver, Canada, 24th Sept. 2017 8

• GCDC 2016 (three tests):- Platooning + Merging.

- Management of T-intersections.

- Management of emergency vehicles.

• Initiatives:- European Commission: funding of research projects on

Cooperative Systems and Autonomous Driving (FP7 andH2020).

- Grand Cooperative Driving Challenge (GCDC):International Competition on Autonomous CooperativeDriving in Helmond (The Netherlands) in 2011 and 2016.

Autonomous Cooperative Driving

Page 9: Cooperative Autonomous Driving and Interaction with Vulnerable …ppniv17.irccyn.ec-nantes.fr/session2/Sotelo/presentation.pdf · 9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation

9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation for Intelligent Vehicles. Vancouver, Canada, 24th Sept. 2017 9

• GCDC 2016: Platooning + Merging

Autonomous Cooperative Driving

Page 10: Cooperative Autonomous Driving and Interaction with Vulnerable …ppniv17.irccyn.ec-nantes.fr/session2/Sotelo/presentation.pdf · 9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation

9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation for Intelligent Vehicles. Vancouver, Canada, 24th Sept. 2017 10

• GCDC 2016: Management of T intersections

Autonomous Cooperative Driving

Page 11: Cooperative Autonomous Driving and Interaction with Vulnerable …ppniv17.irccyn.ec-nantes.fr/session2/Sotelo/presentation.pdf · 9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation

9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation for Intelligent Vehicles. Vancouver, Canada, 24th Sept. 2017 11

• GCDC 2016: Management of emergency vehicles

Autonomous Cooperative Driving

Page 12: Cooperative Autonomous Driving and Interaction with Vulnerable …ppniv17.irccyn.ec-nantes.fr/session2/Sotelo/presentation.pdf · 9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation

9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation for Intelligent Vehicles. Vancouver, Canada, 24th Sept. 2017 12

• DRIVERTIVE – General Architecture

Autonomous Cooperative Driving

Page 13: Cooperative Autonomous Driving and Interaction with Vulnerable …ppniv17.irccyn.ec-nantes.fr/session2/Sotelo/presentation.pdf · 9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation

9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation for Intelligent Vehicles. Vancouver, Canada, 24th Sept. 2017 13

• Data Fusion - Localization Example

Autonomous Cooperative Driving

Page 14: Cooperative Autonomous Driving and Interaction with Vulnerable …ppniv17.irccyn.ec-nantes.fr/session2/Sotelo/presentation.pdf · 9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation

9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation for Intelligent Vehicles. Vancouver, Canada, 24th Sept. 2017 14

• Communications System (ITS G5 V2V standard)

Messages types

• CAM (Cooperative Awareness Message): position, geometry andvehicles dynamics.

• DENM (Decentralized Environmental Notification Message):asynchronous messages from infrastructure o from other vehicles (e.g.emergency vehicles approaching).

• iCLCM (iGame Cooperative Lane Change Message): messages forinteraction protocol in different scenarios.

Autonomous Cooperative Driving

Page 15: Cooperative Autonomous Driving and Interaction with Vulnerable …ppniv17.irccyn.ec-nantes.fr/session2/Sotelo/presentation.pdf · 9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation

9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation for Intelligent Vehicles. Vancouver, Canada, 24th Sept. 2017 15

• Scenario 1: Platooning + Merging

Autonomous Cooperative Driving

Page 16: Cooperative Autonomous Driving and Interaction with Vulnerable …ppniv17.irccyn.ec-nantes.fr/session2/Sotelo/presentation.pdf · 9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation

9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation for Intelligent Vehicles. Vancouver, Canada, 24th Sept. 2017 16

• Scenario 1:

Platooning + Merging

Behavior on the leftlane is different fromthat on the right lane

Autonomous Cooperative Driving

Page 17: Cooperative Autonomous Driving and Interaction with Vulnerable …ppniv17.irccyn.ec-nantes.fr/session2/Sotelo/presentation.pdf · 9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation

9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation for Intelligent Vehicles. Vancouver, Canada, 24th Sept. 2017 17

• Scenario 2: Management of T-intersections

Autonomous Cooperative Driving

Page 18: Cooperative Autonomous Driving and Interaction with Vulnerable …ppniv17.irccyn.ec-nantes.fr/session2/Sotelo/presentation.pdf · 9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation

9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation for Intelligent Vehicles. Vancouver, Canada, 24th Sept. 2017 18

• Scenario 2:

T-Intersections

A safety distance mustbe kept at all times w.r.tthe preceding vehicle

Autonomous Cooperative Driving

Page 19: Cooperative Autonomous Driving and Interaction with Vulnerable …ppniv17.irccyn.ec-nantes.fr/session2/Sotelo/presentation.pdf · 9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation

9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation for Intelligent Vehicles. Vancouver, Canada, 24th Sept. 2017 19

Analysis of the communication channel (CCDF –Complementary Cumulative Distribution Function)

Autonomous Cooperative Driving

Page 20: Cooperative Autonomous Driving and Interaction with Vulnerable …ppniv17.irccyn.ec-nantes.fr/session2/Sotelo/presentation.pdf · 9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation

9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation for Intelligent Vehicles. Vancouver, Canada, 24th Sept. 2017 20

Mean and Variance of UD (Car)

Autonomous Cooperative Driving

Page 21: Cooperative Autonomous Driving and Interaction with Vulnerable …ppniv17.irccyn.ec-nantes.fr/session2/Sotelo/presentation.pdf · 9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation

9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation for Intelligent Vehicles. Vancouver, Canada, 24th Sept. 2017 21

Mean and Variance of UD (Truck)

Autonomous Cooperative Driving

Page 22: Cooperative Autonomous Driving and Interaction with Vulnerable …ppniv17.irccyn.ec-nantes.fr/session2/Sotelo/presentation.pdf · 9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation

9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation for Intelligent Vehicles. Vancouver, Canada, 24th Sept. 2017 22

Analysis of the communication channel

- For some vehicles, the probability of large delays issignificant (>10%).

- The UD degrades with distance.

- Occlusions have a strong effect on delays:

- Trucks are less occluded given that theirantennas are located at a height of 3 meters.

- Other findings: DCC in a highly congested channel is making some of the vehicles get stuck in Restrictive state and are not able to regularly access the channel.

- CAM and DENM in GCDC at 25 Hz.

Autonomous Cooperative Driving

Page 23: Cooperative Autonomous Driving and Interaction with Vulnerable …ppniv17.irccyn.ec-nantes.fr/session2/Sotelo/presentation.pdf · 9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation

9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation for Intelligent Vehicles. Vancouver, Canada, 24th Sept. 2017 23

Effect of UD on Emergency Braking during CACC

Autonomous Cooperative Driving

- There is a probability between 0.01 – 0.001 ofcollision with the leading vehicle is onlycommunications are used for CACC in a fleet of morethan 4 vehicles.

- The channel load is responsible for lowreliability.

- An additional sensor is needed (radar).

Page 24: Cooperative Autonomous Driving and Interaction with Vulnerable …ppniv17.irccyn.ec-nantes.fr/session2/Sotelo/presentation.pdf · 9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation

9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation for Intelligent Vehicles. Vancouver, Canada, 24th Sept. 2017 24

u Motivation

u Autonomous Cooperative Driving

u GCDC Results

u Interaction with VRUs

u Conclusions and Future Work

Content

Page 25: Cooperative Autonomous Driving and Interaction with Vulnerable …ppniv17.irccyn.ec-nantes.fr/session2/Sotelo/presentation.pdf · 9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation

9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation for Intelligent Vehicles. Vancouver, Canada, 24th Sept. 2017 25

• DRIVERTIVE – University of Alcalá’s team- Autonomous Cooperative Vehicle (Velodyne, Radar, 3D Vision, Laser,

DGPS, CANBus, Communications, fully automated)

Autonomous Cooperative Driving

Page 26: Cooperative Autonomous Driving and Interaction with Vulnerable …ppniv17.irccyn.ec-nantes.fr/session2/Sotelo/presentation.pdf · 9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation

9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation for Intelligent Vehicles. Vancouver, Canada, 24th Sept. 2017 26

DRIVERTIVE at GCDC 2016

GCDC Results

Page 27: Cooperative Autonomous Driving and Interaction with Vulnerable …ppniv17.irccyn.ec-nantes.fr/session2/Sotelo/presentation.pdf · 9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation

9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation for Intelligent Vehicles. Vancouver, Canada, 24th Sept. 2017 27

DRIVERTIVE – Winner of the Prize to the Best Team withFull Automation in GCDC 2016

GCDC Results

Page 28: Cooperative Autonomous Driving and Interaction with Vulnerable …ppniv17.irccyn.ec-nantes.fr/session2/Sotelo/presentation.pdf · 9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation

9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation for Intelligent Vehicles. Vancouver, Canada, 24th Sept. 2017 28

GCDC 2016

GCDC Results

Page 29: Cooperative Autonomous Driving and Interaction with Vulnerable …ppniv17.irccyn.ec-nantes.fr/session2/Sotelo/presentation.pdf · 9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation

9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation for Intelligent Vehicles. Vancouver, Canada, 24th Sept. 2017 29

u Motivation

u Autonomous Cooperative Driving

u GCDC Results

u Interaction with VRUs

u Conclusions and Future Work

Content

Page 30: Cooperative Autonomous Driving and Interaction with Vulnerable …ppniv17.irccyn.ec-nantes.fr/session2/Sotelo/presentation.pdf · 9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation

9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation for Intelligent Vehicles. Vancouver, Canada, 24th Sept. 2017 30

Motivation

Page 31: Cooperative Autonomous Driving and Interaction with Vulnerable …ppniv17.irccyn.ec-nantes.fr/session2/Sotelo/presentation.pdf · 9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation

9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation for Intelligent Vehicles. Vancouver, Canada, 24th Sept. 2017 31

Motivation

• Pedestrian Path Prediction in the Automotive:– Further improvement in state-of-the-art ADAS by meansof action classification

– Walking, Stopping, Starting, Bending-in

– Improvement of accuracy in 30-50 cm:

– Difference between effective and non-effectiveintervention in emergency braking systems

– Initiation of emergency braking 0.16 s in advance canpotentially reduce severity of accidents injuries by 50%

– Early recognition of pedestrians stopping actions canprovide more accurate last-second active interventions

Strong gains are expected in the performance and reliability of active

pedestrian protection systems

Strong gains are expected in the performance and reliability of active

pedestrian protection systems

Strong gains are expected in the performance and reliability of active

pedestrian protection systems

Page 32: Cooperative Autonomous Driving and Interaction with Vulnerable …ppniv17.irccyn.ec-nantes.fr/session2/Sotelo/presentation.pdf · 9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation

9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation for Intelligent Vehicles. Vancouver, Canada, 24th Sept. 2017 32

Proposed Approach

Global Scheme

Off-line Motion Capture System

Recovery of 3D pose and position

Lateral predicted position

On-line

Probabilistic Training

Knowledge of Pedestrians dynamics

Stereo Cameras

Transformation to latent space +

prediction

Geometric processing

3D Pedestrian Pose

Estimation

Page 33: Cooperative Autonomous Driving and Interaction with Vulnerable …ppniv17.irccyn.ec-nantes.fr/session2/Sotelo/presentation.pdf · 9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation

9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation for Intelligent Vehicles. Vancouver, Canada, 24th Sept. 2017 33

Pedestrian Pose Measurement

Pedestrian Skeleton considered in this research

Page 34: Cooperative Autonomous Driving and Interaction with Vulnerable …ppniv17.irccyn.ec-nantes.fr/session2/Sotelo/presentation.pdf · 9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation

9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation for Intelligent Vehicles. Vancouver, Canada, 24th Sept. 2017 34

Pedestrian Pose Measurement

Method for Joints Extraction - Example

Page 35: Cooperative Autonomous Driving and Interaction with Vulnerable …ppniv17.irccyn.ec-nantes.fr/session2/Sotelo/presentation.pdf · 9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation

9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation for Intelligent Vehicles. Vancouver, Canada, 24th Sept. 2017 35

Pedestrian Pose Measurement

Method for Joints Extraction – Results

Page 36: Cooperative Autonomous Driving and Interaction with Vulnerable …ppniv17.irccyn.ec-nantes.fr/session2/Sotelo/presentation.pdf · 9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation

9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation for Intelligent Vehicles. Vancouver, Canada, 24th Sept. 2017 36

Pedestrian Pose Measurement

Body parts detection using Deep Learning

Page 37: Cooperative Autonomous Driving and Interaction with Vulnerable …ppniv17.irccyn.ec-nantes.fr/session2/Sotelo/presentation.pdf · 9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation

9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation for Intelligent Vehicles. Vancouver, Canada, 24th Sept. 2017 37

General Method - Overview

Page 38: Cooperative Autonomous Driving and Interaction with Vulnerable …ppniv17.irccyn.ec-nantes.fr/session2/Sotelo/presentation.pdf · 9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation

9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation for Intelligent Vehicles. Vancouver, Canada, 24th Sept. 2017 38

Activity Recognition - Example

Page 39: Cooperative Autonomous Driving and Interaction with Vulnerable …ppniv17.irccyn.ec-nantes.fr/session2/Sotelo/presentation.pdf · 9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation

9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation for Intelligent Vehicles. Vancouver, Canada, 24th Sept. 2017 39

Experimental Results

Detection Delay - Summary

Page 40: Cooperative Autonomous Driving and Interaction with Vulnerable …ppniv17.irccyn.ec-nantes.fr/session2/Sotelo/presentation.pdf · 9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation

9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation for Intelligent Vehicles. Vancouver, Canada, 24th Sept. 2017 40

Experimental Results

Probabilistic Action Classification

Page 41: Cooperative Autonomous Driving and Interaction with Vulnerable …ppniv17.irccyn.ec-nantes.fr/session2/Sotelo/presentation.pdf · 9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation

9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation for Intelligent Vehicles. Vancouver, Canada, 24th Sept. 2017 41

Experimental Results

Probabilistic Action Classification

Page 42: Cooperative Autonomous Driving and Interaction with Vulnerable …ppniv17.irccyn.ec-nantes.fr/session2/Sotelo/presentation.pdf · 9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation

9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation for Intelligent Vehicles. Vancouver, Canada, 24th Sept. 2017 42

Experimental Results

Video sequence showing prediction results

Page 43: Cooperative Autonomous Driving and Interaction with Vulnerable …ppniv17.irccyn.ec-nantes.fr/session2/Sotelo/presentation.pdf · 9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation

9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation for Intelligent Vehicles. Vancouver, Canada, 24th Sept. 2017 43

Intelligent Interface with VRUs

GRAIL – GReen Assistant Interfacing Light

Page 44: Cooperative Autonomous Driving and Interaction with Vulnerable …ppniv17.irccyn.ec-nantes.fr/session2/Sotelo/presentation.pdf · 9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation

9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation for Intelligent Vehicles. Vancouver, Canada, 24th Sept. 2017 44

Intelligent Interface with VRUs

GRAIL – GReen Assistant Interfacing Light

Page 45: Cooperative Autonomous Driving and Interaction with Vulnerable …ppniv17.irccyn.ec-nantes.fr/session2/Sotelo/presentation.pdf · 9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation

9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation for Intelligent Vehicles. Vancouver, Canada, 24th Sept. 2017 45

u Motivation

u Autonomous Cooperative Driving

u GCDC Results

u Interaction with VRUs

u Conclusions and Future Work

Content

Page 46: Cooperative Autonomous Driving and Interaction with Vulnerable …ppniv17.irccyn.ec-nantes.fr/session2/Sotelo/presentation.pdf · 9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation

9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation for Intelligent Vehicles. Vancouver, Canada, 24th Sept. 2017

Conclusions and Future Work

Conclusions- Autonomous Cooperative Systems will pave the way to the massive

and robust deployment of self-driving cars.

- The V2V communication link is still a weakness that needs further attention from the scientific community in order to provide real-time and robust communication capability among large fleets of vehicles.

- Anticipating the intentions of other traffic participants, such as VRUs and vehicles, is essential for mimicking human drivers behavior.

Future Work- Enhancement of V2V communication channel for large fleets of

vehicles (antenna placement, frequency of data, etc.).

- Context-based action prediction using Probabilistic Graphical Models (Bayesian Networks) is under development for VRUs and vehicles.

- Gaze direction, group behavior.

Page 47: Cooperative Autonomous Driving and Interaction with Vulnerable …ppniv17.irccyn.ec-nantes.fr/session2/Sotelo/presentation.pdf · 9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation

9th Workshop on Planning, Perception, and Navigation for Intelligent Vehicles. Vancouver, Canada, 24th Sept. 2017

Cooperative Autonomous Driving and Interaction with Vulnerable Road Users

Thanks for your kind attention!

Miguel Ángel Sotelo

[email protected] Full Professor

University of Alcalá (UAH)SPAIN

9th Workshop on PPNIV – Keynote