Conventional AINS are toxic - UCLouvain · Conventional AINS are toxic ... FARM2227 2004-2005 2 ......

72
2004-2005 FARM2227 1 Why do need Cox-2 inhibitors ? Conventional AINS are toxic ...

Transcript of Conventional AINS are toxic - UCLouvain · Conventional AINS are toxic ... FARM2227 2004-2005 2 ......

Page 1: Conventional AINS are toxic - UCLouvain · Conventional AINS are toxic ... FARM2227 2004-2005 2 ... FARM2227 2004-2005 23 Effect of IL-1 and dexamethasone on human fibroblast COX

2004-2005FARM2227 1

Why do need Cox-2 inhibitors ?

Conventional AINS are toxic ...

Page 2: Conventional AINS are toxic - UCLouvain · Conventional AINS are toxic ... FARM2227 2004-2005 2 ... FARM2227 2004-2005 23 Effect of IL-1 and dexamethasone on human fibroblast COX

2004-2005FARM2227 2

Adverse Effects of common NSAIDs

Upper Upper -- GIGI➨➨ DyspepsiaDyspepsia➨➨ ErosionsErosions➨➨ AnaemiaAnaemia -- GI bleedingGI bleeding➨➨ Ulcers Ulcers -- bleeds/perforationsbleeds/perforations

RenalRenal➨➨ Renal dysfunctionRenal dysfunction➨➨ Renal failure Renal failure -- acute/chronicacute/chronic➨➨ Blood pressureBlood pressure➨➨ Heart failureHeart failure

AntiAnti--platelet effectsplatelet effectsContributes to blood lossContributes to blood loss

Page 3: Conventional AINS are toxic - UCLouvain · Conventional AINS are toxic ... FARM2227 2004-2005 2 ... FARM2227 2004-2005 23 Effect of IL-1 and dexamethasone on human fibroblast COX

2004-2005FARM2227 3

NSAIDs toxicity

GI GI intolerability*

GIGI MucosalMucosal Damage / Damage / Complicationsintolerability* Complications

endoscopiculcers [3]

perforation orhaemorrhage [4] Death [5]

30302520

% 1510

101.75 0.2

0

* * Range 20-50% based on - withdrawals for GI symptoms1

- community surveys for GI symptoms2

1.1. KiffKiff et al,et al, EurEur JJ RheumatolRheumatol, 1994; 2. , 1994; 2. HardoHardo et al,et al, BJCPBJCP, 1993; 3. Graham, 1993; 3. Graham DYDY et al, Am Jet al, Am J GastroenterolGastroenterol 1988; 1988; 4.4. SilversteinSilverstein et al, Ann et al, Ann Int MedInt Med, 1995; 5. Blower et al, Aliment, 1995; 5. Blower et al, Aliment PharmacolPharmacol, 1997, 1997

Page 4: Conventional AINS are toxic - UCLouvain · Conventional AINS are toxic ... FARM2227 2004-2005 2 ... FARM2227 2004-2005 23 Effect of IL-1 and dexamethasone on human fibroblast COX

2004-2005FARM2227 4

NSAID Ulcers and Ulcer Complications

• Endoscopic ulcer point prevalence: 10-30%

• Ulcer complications: 2-4% per year

• Most (>80%) hospitalizations for GI bleed occur without previous symptoms

• Inhibition of prostaglandin synthesis is principal mechanism for GI damage

• Use of antacids or H2 antagonists do not preventNSAID induced gastric ulcers

Singh G et al. Singh G et al. Am JAm J MedMed 1998;105(1B):31S1998;105(1B):31S--8S.8S.GeisGeis GS et al. GS et al. JJ RheumatolRheumatol 1991;18:111991;18:11--14.14.

Page 5: Conventional AINS are toxic - UCLouvain · Conventional AINS are toxic ... FARM2227 2004-2005 2 ... FARM2227 2004-2005 23 Effect of IL-1 and dexamethasone on human fibroblast COX

2004-2005FARM2227 5

GI mortality associated with typicalNSAIDs vs other causes in US (1of 2)

Fries et al. Am J Med. 1991;91:213–222;Wilson, Crouch. Science. 1987;236:267–270.Fries et al. Am J Med. 1991;91:213–222;Wilson, Crouch. Science. 1987;236:267–270.

Annual risk of death (%)Annual risk of death (%)

0.20.20.10.10.00.0 0.40.40.30.3

Cigarette smokingCigarette smokingCigarette smoking

CancerCancerCancer

NSAID useNSAIDNSAID useuse

Motor vehicle accidentMotor vehicle accidentMotor vehicle accident

Home accidentHome accidentHome accident

Airplane crash (frequent flyer)Airplane crash (frequent flyer)Airplane crash (frequent flyer)

Page 6: Conventional AINS are toxic - UCLouvain · Conventional AINS are toxic ... FARM2227 2004-2005 2 ... FARM2227 2004-2005 23 Effect of IL-1 and dexamethasone on human fibroblast COX

2004-2005FARM2227 6

GI mortality associated with typicalNSAIDs vs other causes in US (2 of 2)

Ventura et al. Monthly Vital Statistics Report. 1997;46(1suppl 2).

Fries et al. Am J Med. 1991;91:213–222.

Ventura et al.Ventura et al. Monthly Vital Statistics ReportMonthly Vital Statistics Report. . 1997;46(1997;46(1suppl1suppl 2). 2).

Fries et al. Fries et al. Am JAm J MedMed. 1991;91:213. 1991;91:213––222.222.

No. deaths (thousands / year)No. deaths (thousands / year)No. deaths (thousands / year)

Alzheimer’s diseaseAlzheimer’s diseaseAlzheimer’s disease

Ovarian cancerOvarian cancerOvarian cancer

NSAIDs (GI)NSAIDsNSAIDs (GI)(GI)

MelanomaMelanomaMelanoma

AsthmaAsthmaAsthma

Cervical cancerCervical cancerCervical cancer

151515101010000 252525202020555

Page 7: Conventional AINS are toxic - UCLouvain · Conventional AINS are toxic ... FARM2227 2004-2005 2 ... FARM2227 2004-2005 23 Effect of IL-1 and dexamethasone on human fibroblast COX

2004-2005FARM2227 7

Deaths attributed to anti-rheumatic medication(series of 1666 patients with RA)

47

30

11

2 2 1 1 00

10

20

30

40

50

Total Steroids Sulphasalazine Chloroquine

NSAIDs Methotrexate Azothiaprine Gold

Myllykangas-Luosujarvi, J Rheum, 1995, 22, 2214-7

Page 8: Conventional AINS are toxic - UCLouvain · Conventional AINS are toxic ... FARM2227 2004-2005 2 ... FARM2227 2004-2005 23 Effect of IL-1 and dexamethasone on human fibroblast COX

2004-2005FARM2227 8

Most patients are asymptomatic prior to a serious NSAID-associated GI event ...

Bleeding, perforation, and gastric outlet obstructionBleeding, perforation, and gastric outlet obstruction

WithoutsymptomsWithoutsymptoms

42%58%58%

N = 141N = 141 N = 1,921N = 1,921

Armstrong &Blower.Gut. 1987;28:527–532.Armstrong &Blower.

Gut. 1987;28:527–532.Singh et al.

Arch Intern Med.1996;156:1530-1536.

Singh et al.Arch Intern Med.

1996;156:1530-1536.

WithsymptomsWithsymptoms

81%81%19%

Page 9: Conventional AINS are toxic - UCLouvain · Conventional AINS are toxic ... FARM2227 2004-2005 2 ... FARM2227 2004-2005 23 Effect of IL-1 and dexamethasone on human fibroblast COX

2004-2005FARM2227 9

*NSAIDs - Relative Risk of GI Complications

None 1Ibuprofen 2.1 (0.6 - 7.1)Diclofenac 2.7 (1.5 - 4.8)Other NSAID (n=16) 2.9 (1.4 - 6.3)Ketoprofen 3.2 (0.9 - 11.9)Naproxen 4.3 (1.6 - 11.2)Tenoxicam 4.3 (1.9 - 9.7)Nimesulide 4.4 (2.5 - 7.7)Indomethacin 5.5 (1.6 - 18.9)Piroxicam 9.5 (6.5 - 13.8)Ketorolac 24.7 (9.6 - 63.5)

DrugDrug Relative Risk Relative Risk (95% C.I.)(95% C.I.)

* Rodriguez et al, Arch Intern Med, 1998, 158, 33-39

Page 10: Conventional AINS are toxic - UCLouvain · Conventional AINS are toxic ... FARM2227 2004-2005 2 ... FARM2227 2004-2005 23 Effect of IL-1 and dexamethasone on human fibroblast COX

2004-2005FARM2227 10

Upper GI complications in Europe

• 1000 people are hospitalised every day for upper GI bleeds in Europe (~400 million population)

• In 400 of these 1000 patients the bleed (or perforation) will be directly attributable toNSAIDs

• 100 (10%) of these 1000 will die from their complications

Calculated from :Blower AL et al, Aliment Pharmacol Ther, 1997, 11, 283-291MacDonald T et al, BMJ, 1997, 315, 1333-1337

Page 11: Conventional AINS are toxic - UCLouvain · Conventional AINS are toxic ... FARM2227 2004-2005 2 ... FARM2227 2004-2005 23 Effect of IL-1 and dexamethasone on human fibroblast COX

2004-2005FARM2227 11

This is why ...

““ Toxicity is the major reason for not Toxicity is the major reason for not recommending the use ofrecommending the use of NSAIDsNSAIDs as as firstfirst--line therapy for patients with OA of line therapy for patients with OA of the hip …..”the hip …..”

OsteoOsteo--arthritis hip, Management Guidelinesarthritis hip, Management GuidelinesHochbergHochberg et al, 1995, Arthritis & Rheumatismet al, 1995, Arthritis & Rheumatism

Page 12: Conventional AINS are toxic - UCLouvain · Conventional AINS are toxic ... FARM2227 2004-2005 2 ... FARM2227 2004-2005 23 Effect of IL-1 and dexamethasone on human fibroblast COX

2004-2005FARM2227 12

Towards new medications ...

Discovery of cyclooxygenase-2 andof cyclooxygenase-2 specific inhibitors

Page 13: Conventional AINS are toxic - UCLouvain · Conventional AINS are toxic ... FARM2227 2004-2005 2 ... FARM2227 2004-2005 23 Effect of IL-1 and dexamethasone on human fibroblast COX

2004-2005FARM2227 13

Role of cyclooxygenase

Arachidonic Acid

Prostaglandins

X

Inflammation and Pain

Support Renal and Platelet Function Protect

Gastric Mucosa

{NSAIDs:

Cyclooxygenase Anti-inflammatoryAnalgesicGastrointestinal ToxicityRenal Toxicity

Shorrock CJ et al. Am J Med 1988;84 (Suppl):25-34.

Page 14: Conventional AINS are toxic - UCLouvain · Conventional AINS are toxic ... FARM2227 2004-2005 2 ... FARM2227 2004-2005 23 Effect of IL-1 and dexamethasone on human fibroblast COX

2004-2005FARM2227 14

The Discovery of the role of cyclooxygenase

• 1898 … aspirin introduced

• 1950s … corticosteroids introduced» anti-inflammatory» significant side effects

• 1960s … NSAIDs introduced• 1971 … mode of action of NSAIDs explained on

basis of COX inhibition (Vane)» platelet activity induced by COX» inhibited by aspirin and other NSAIDs

Page 15: Conventional AINS are toxic - UCLouvain · Conventional AINS are toxic ... FARM2227 2004-2005 2 ... FARM2227 2004-2005 23 Effect of IL-1 and dexamethasone on human fibroblast COX

2004-2005FARM2227 15

Conversion of arachidonic acid to prostaglandins

COOH Arachidonic Acid

2 O2 Cyclooxygenase

PGG2

Cyclooxygenase

OO

COOH

OOHOOHHydroperoxidaseHydroperoxidase2 e-

OO

COOH

OHOH

PGH2 prostanoids• prostaglandins• thromboxans

Page 16: Conventional AINS are toxic - UCLouvain · Conventional AINS are toxic ... FARM2227 2004-2005 2 ... FARM2227 2004-2005 23 Effect of IL-1 and dexamethasone on human fibroblast COX

2004-2005FARM2227 16

Mapping of the cyclooxygenase active site

Page 17: Conventional AINS are toxic - UCLouvain · Conventional AINS are toxic ... FARM2227 2004-2005 2 ... FARM2227 2004-2005 23 Effect of IL-1 and dexamethasone on human fibroblast COX

2004-2005FARM2227 17

Mapping of the cyclooxygenase active site

tyrosine 385 tyrosine 385

COX-1 Active Site occupied by flurbiprofen

argininearginine 120120

Picot, Loll and Garavito: Nature 1994; 367:243.

Page 18: Conventional AINS are toxic - UCLouvain · Conventional AINS are toxic ... FARM2227 2004-2005 2 ... FARM2227 2004-2005 23 Effect of IL-1 and dexamethasone on human fibroblast COX

2004-2005FARM2227 18

All conventional NSAIDs have a similar mechanism of action ...

Kurumbail RG et al. Nature 1996;384:644-8.

ArginineArginine at 120at 120

tyrosine at 385tyrosine at 385

Hydrophobicchannel

hemeheme

+

CC--OO

OHOH

OO

salicylic acidsalicylic acid

CC --OOOHOH

OO

CC --OOOHOH

OO

Page 19: Conventional AINS are toxic - UCLouvain · Conventional AINS are toxic ... FARM2227 2004-2005 2 ... FARM2227 2004-2005 23 Effect of IL-1 and dexamethasone on human fibroblast COX

2004-2005FARM2227 19

All conventional NSAIDs have a similar mechanism of action ...

Kurumbail RG et al. Nature 1996;384:644-8.

ArginineArginine at 120at 120

tyrosine at 385tyrosine at 385

Hydrophobicchannel

hemeheme

+

O-O - C - CH2

NH

Cl

Cl

Diclofenac

NH

Cl

Cl

O

-O -C -CH2

NH

Cl

Cl

O -O -C -CH2

Page 20: Conventional AINS are toxic - UCLouvain · Conventional AINS are toxic ... FARM2227 2004-2005 2 ... FARM2227 2004-2005 23 Effect of IL-1 and dexamethasone on human fibroblast COX

2004-2005FARM2227 20

All conventional NSAIDs have a similar mechanism of action ...

Kurumbail RG et al. Nature 1996;384:644-8.

ArginineArginine at 120at 120

tyrosine at 385tyrosine at 385

Hydrophobicchannel

hemeheme

+

NN

00 00

SS

OO --CONHCONH

SSNN

CHCH33

TenoxicamTenoxicam

NN00

00

SS

OO --

CONH

CONH

SSNN

CHCH

33

NN00

00

SSOO --

CONH

CONH

SSNN

CHCH

33

Page 21: Conventional AINS are toxic - UCLouvain · Conventional AINS are toxic ... FARM2227 2004-2005 2 ... FARM2227 2004-2005 23 Effect of IL-1 and dexamethasone on human fibroblast COX

2004-2005FARM2227 21

Similarities of structures ...

NN

CHCH33SS

NNNN HH

CHCH33

OO

CC

SS

OOOO

OO--

meloxicammeloxicamibuprofenibuprofen

CHCH33

CHCH CC OO--

OO

NNNN HH

CHCH33

OO

CC

SS

OOOO

OO--

piroxicampiroxicamnaproxennaproxen

OO

CHCH33

CHCH CC OO--

OO

CHCH33

Page 22: Conventional AINS are toxic - UCLouvain · Conventional AINS are toxic ... FARM2227 2004-2005 2 ... FARM2227 2004-2005 23 Effect of IL-1 and dexamethasone on human fibroblast COX

2004-2005FARM2227 22

Discovery of two forms of cyclooxygenase

• 1989 ... IL-1 induces COX activity in fibroblasts 1

• 1990 … the inducible COX activity is inhibited by steroids 2

steroids had no effect on basal cyclooxygenase activity

• 1991 … the inducible cycloxygenase (COX-2)is cloned 3– 60% identical to COX-1– certain important amino acid differences– cytokine induced and regulated by glucocorticoids

1 : Raz et al, PNAS, 1989, 86, 1657-16612 : Fu et al, J Biol Chem, 1990, 265. 16737-403 : Xie et al, 1991, PNAS, 88, 2692-6

Page 23: Conventional AINS are toxic - UCLouvain · Conventional AINS are toxic ... FARM2227 2004-2005 2 ... FARM2227 2004-2005 23 Effect of IL-1 and dexamethasone on human fibroblast COX

2004-2005FARM2227 23

Effect of IL-1 and dexamethasoneon human fibroblast COX activity

1600

1200

800

400

0ControlControl ILIL--11 ILIL--1 +1 + DexDex

CO

X A

ctiv

ityC

OX

Act

ivity

Fibroblasts

• +/- IL-1• +/- Dex• −> 8 hr−> AA

Raz et al, PNAS, 86,1657-1661

Page 24: Conventional AINS are toxic - UCLouvain · Conventional AINS are toxic ... FARM2227 2004-2005 2 ... FARM2227 2004-2005 23 Effect of IL-1 and dexamethasone on human fibroblast COX

2004-2005FARM2227 24

COX-2: a new anti-inflammatory drug target

ArachidonicArachidonic AcidAcid

StomachStomachIntestineIntestineKidneyKidneyPlateletPlatelet

Inflammatory SiteInflammatory Site•• MacrophagesMacrophages•• SynoviocytesSynoviocytes•• Endothelial cells Endothelial cells

COXCOX--22(inducible)(inducible)

COXCOX--11(constitutive)(constitutive) •• BrainBrain

•• KidneyKidney•• Female U/G tractFemale U/G tract

((––))

conventionalconventionalNSAIDsNSAIDs

GlucocorticoidsGlucocorticoids(block(block mRNAmRNAexpression)expression)((––))

Page 25: Conventional AINS are toxic - UCLouvain · Conventional AINS are toxic ... FARM2227 2004-2005 2 ... FARM2227 2004-2005 23 Effect of IL-1 and dexamethasone on human fibroblast COX

2004-2005FARM2227 25

Biochemical comparisons of the Cox-1 and Cox-2

COX-1 and COX-2 are membrane-bound proteins that reside, aftersynthesis and transport, primarily in the endoplasmic reticulum. Although the genes for COX-1 and COX-2 are clearly different the proteins actually share 60% homology at the amino acid level; both catalyze from arachidonic acid the formation of prostaglandin (PG) G2 followed by PGH2via a peroxidase function, have a similar molecular mass of 70 kDa, and are identical in length. Studies of the tertiary structures of COX-1 and COX-2 have demonstrated that the amino acid conformation for the substratebinding sites and catalytic regions are almost identical. However, there are important differences in these regions, particularly the exchanges of Ile in COX-1 for Val in COX-2 at positions 434 and 523. These substitutions result in a larger and more flexible substrate channel in COX-2 than in COX-1 and in the inhibitor binding site in COX-2, being 25% larger than that in COX-1.

Warner TD, Mitchell JA. Cyclooxygenases: new forms, new inhibitors, and lessons from the clinic. FASEB J. 2004 May;18(7):790-804.

Page 26: Conventional AINS are toxic - UCLouvain · Conventional AINS are toxic ... FARM2227 2004-2005 2 ... FARM2227 2004-2005 23 Effect of IL-1 and dexamethasone on human fibroblast COX

2004-2005FARM2227 26

Structures of COX-1 and COX-2

COX-2COX-1

tyrosine at 385tyrosine at 385

hydrophobicchannel

hemeheme

argininearginine at 120at 120+

hydrophobicchannel

argininearginine at 120at 120+

tyrosine at 385tyrosine at 385

hydrophilic“side pocket”

Kurumbail RG et al. Nature 1996;384:644-8.

Page 27: Conventional AINS are toxic - UCLouvain · Conventional AINS are toxic ... FARM2227 2004-2005 2 ... FARM2227 2004-2005 23 Effect of IL-1 and dexamethasone on human fibroblast COX

2004-2005FARM2227 27

Conventional NSAIDs inhibit both COX-1 and COX-2

COX-2

Kurumbail RG et al. Nature 1996;384:644-8.

COX-1

tyrosine at 385tyrosine at 385

hemeheme

argininearginine at 120at 120+

argininearginine at 120at 120+

tyrosine at 385tyrosine at 385

binding to Arg 120through carboxyalate is enough...

Page 28: Conventional AINS are toxic - UCLouvain · Conventional AINS are toxic ... FARM2227 2004-2005 2 ... FARM2227 2004-2005 23 Effect of IL-1 and dexamethasone on human fibroblast COX

2004-2005FARM2227 28

Chemistry and Activity

This is where all begins...

Page 29: Conventional AINS are toxic - UCLouvain · Conventional AINS are toxic ... FARM2227 2004-2005 2 ... FARM2227 2004-2005 23 Effect of IL-1 and dexamethasone on human fibroblast COX

2004-2005FARM2227 29

Pharmacochemistry of the COX-2 inhibitors

O

CH3

CF3N

N

SONH2

CelecoxibCelecoxib

CHCH22CHCH22 CC

OO

CHCH33

HH33COCO

NabumetoneNabumetone

O

OS

H3C

OONHNH

NONO22

NimesulideNimesulide

hydrophilichydrophilicgroupgroup

O

O

RofecoxibRofecoxib

O

OS

H3C

Page 30: Conventional AINS are toxic - UCLouvain · Conventional AINS are toxic ... FARM2227 2004-2005 2 ... FARM2227 2004-2005 23 Effect of IL-1 and dexamethasone on human fibroblast COX

2004-2005FARM2227 30

Pharmacochemical determinants in “coxibs”

Occupies thecyclooxygenase

hydrophobic channel

NH2S

O

O

NN

CF3

CH3

Fits into COX-2 hydrophilic side pocket

hydrophilic grouphydrophilic group

hydrophobic group

Page 31: Conventional AINS are toxic - UCLouvain · Conventional AINS are toxic ... FARM2227 2004-2005 2 ... FARM2227 2004-2005 23 Effect of IL-1 and dexamethasone on human fibroblast COX

2004-2005FARM2227 31

Fitting “coxibs” in cyclooxygenases ...

NH2S

O

O

NN

CF3

CH3

NH2

SO

O

NN

3

CH3

CF

Page 32: Conventional AINS are toxic - UCLouvain · Conventional AINS are toxic ... FARM2227 2004-2005 2 ... FARM2227 2004-2005 23 Effect of IL-1 and dexamethasone on human fibroblast COX

2004-2005FARM2227 32

Structures of COX-1 and COX-2 with celecoxib

Cox-1

leucine

Cox-2 valine

hydrophobicgroup

hydrophilicgroup

tyrosine 385tyrosine 385

argininearginine 120120

Page 33: Conventional AINS are toxic - UCLouvain · Conventional AINS are toxic ... FARM2227 2004-2005 2 ... FARM2227 2004-2005 23 Effect of IL-1 and dexamethasone on human fibroblast COX

2004-2005FARM2227 33

Why do “coxibs” bind so tightly to cycoloxygenase-2 ?

the polar the polar sulphonamidesulphonamide side chain tightly bind to hydrophilic “side pocket”side chain tightly bind to hydrophilic “side pocket”

Kurumbail RGKurumbail RG et al. et al. NatureNature 1996;384:6441996;384:644--8.8.

argininearginine at 120at 120+

tyrosine at 385tyrosine at 385

Arg 513 and Hist 90 - forms hydrogen bonds with oxygen insulphonamideside chain

+

+

Page 34: Conventional AINS are toxic - UCLouvain · Conventional AINS are toxic ... FARM2227 2004-2005 2 ... FARM2227 2004-2005 23 Effect of IL-1 and dexamethasone on human fibroblast COX

2004-2005FARM2227 34

Binding of the slide chain to Arg 513 and His 90

polar sulfonamide

Arg 513

His 90

Page 35: Conventional AINS are toxic - UCLouvain · Conventional AINS are toxic ... FARM2227 2004-2005 2 ... FARM2227 2004-2005 23 Effect of IL-1 and dexamethasone on human fibroblast COX

2004-2005FARM2227 35

Why do “coxibs” fail to inhibit cyclooxygenase-1 ?

COX-1

tyrosine at 385tyrosine at 385

hemeheme

argininearginine at 120at 120+

Can’t get in …and doesn’t bind

very well

Kurumbail RGKurumbail RG et al. et al. NatureNature 1996;384:6441996;384:644--8.8.

Page 36: Conventional AINS are toxic - UCLouvain · Conventional AINS are toxic ... FARM2227 2004-2005 2 ... FARM2227 2004-2005 23 Effect of IL-1 and dexamethasone on human fibroblast COX

2004-2005FARM2227 36

Cox-1 vs Cox-2 ...

flurbiprofene in Cox-1 celecoxib in Cox-1

Picot, Loll and Garavito

Nature 1994; 367:243.

Kurumbail et al. Nature 1996;384:644-8.

Page 37: Conventional AINS are toxic - UCLouvain · Conventional AINS are toxic ... FARM2227 2004-2005 2 ... FARM2227 2004-2005 23 Effect of IL-1 and dexamethasone on human fibroblast COX

2004-2005FARM2227 37

Selectivity and specificity of Cox-inhibitors (Lipsky et al, Editorial, J. Rheumatol, 1998, 25, 2298-2303)

Levels 1 & 2, Selectivity1. Enzymatic or biochemical

- in vitro COX-1/COX- 2 ratio2. Biological and pharmacologic

- ex-vivo cell assays

Level 3, Clinical specificity3. At fully efficacious therapeutic concentration

• No inhibition of COX-1 mediated platelet function• No clinically relevant COX-1 inhibitory effect on GI tract= COX-2 SPECIFIC INHIBITION (CSI)

Page 38: Conventional AINS are toxic - UCLouvain · Conventional AINS are toxic ... FARM2227 2004-2005 2 ... FARM2227 2004-2005 23 Effect of IL-1 and dexamethasone on human fibroblast COX

2004-2005FARM2227 38

Categories of COX Inhibitors

1. COX-1 specific Low dose aspirin2. COX non-specific All current NSAIDs3. COX-2 preferential* Agent with some anti-

inflammatory or analgesic activities at a dose that inhibits COX-2 but causes no significant inhibition of COX-1

4. COX-2 specific Agent which at maximal therapeutic dosing causes no clinically meaningful inhibition of COX-1

Page 39: Conventional AINS are toxic - UCLouvain · Conventional AINS are toxic ... FARM2227 2004-2005 2 ... FARM2227 2004-2005 23 Effect of IL-1 and dexamethasone on human fibroblast COX

2004-2005FARM2227 39

Specificity of Celecoxib in vivo

JJJ

J

JJ

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

0 0.1 1 10 100 500

Dose (mg/kg p.o.)

Gastric PG (COX-1)

J Inflammatory PG (COX-2)

PG(%

Con

trol

)

Smith CJ,Smith CJ, PNASPNAS, 1998, 95, 13313, 1998, 95, 13313--1818

Page 40: Conventional AINS are toxic - UCLouvain · Conventional AINS are toxic ... FARM2227 2004-2005 2 ... FARM2227 2004-2005 23 Effect of IL-1 and dexamethasone on human fibroblast COX

2004-2005FARM2227 40

Selective cyclooxygenase inhibitors

NN

CF3

O

Cl

NN

CF3

SH2N

O

O

SC-560 celecoxibIC50 COX-1 0.009 15(µM) COX-2 6.3 0.04

Smith CJ,Smith CJ, PNASPNAS, 1998, 95, 13313, 1998, 95, 13313--1818

Page 41: Conventional AINS are toxic - UCLouvain · Conventional AINS are toxic ... FARM2227 2004-2005 2 ... FARM2227 2004-2005 23 Effect of IL-1 and dexamethasone on human fibroblast COX

2004-2005FARM2227 41

In vivo Specificity of SC-560

SC-560 (mg/kg)

BB

B

BB

B B

J

J

JJ

J

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

0.01 0.1 1 10 100

B Gastric Mucosa (COX-1)J Air Pouch (COX-2)

0

PGE 2

(% c

ontr

ol)

Smith CJ, PNAS, 1998, 95, 13313-18

Page 42: Conventional AINS are toxic - UCLouvain · Conventional AINS are toxic ... FARM2227 2004-2005 2 ... FARM2227 2004-2005 23 Effect of IL-1 and dexamethasone on human fibroblast COX

2004-2005FARM2227 42

Model for COX-1 and COX-2 derived prostaglandinsin inflammation and pain

PGEPGE22

COXCOX--11

COXCOX--22

InflammatoryInflammatoryStimulusStimulus

InflammationInflammation

PGEPGE22

PGsPGs

PainPain

PERIPHERALPERIPHERAL CENTRALCENTRAL

Smith CJ, PNAS, 1998, 95, 13313-18

Page 43: Conventional AINS are toxic - UCLouvain · Conventional AINS are toxic ... FARM2227 2004-2005 2 ... FARM2227 2004-2005 23 Effect of IL-1 and dexamethasone on human fibroblast COX

2004-2005FARM2227 43

Pharmacokinetics

This is where people start sleeping..

Page 44: Conventional AINS are toxic - UCLouvain · Conventional AINS are toxic ... FARM2227 2004-2005 2 ... FARM2227 2004-2005 23 Effect of IL-1 and dexamethasone on human fibroblast COX

2004-2005FARM2227 44

Pharmacokinetics of celecoxib

• Absorption

• 75% bioavailable (versus oral solution)

• food enhances bioavailability by 7-20%

• antacids reduce bioavailability by ~25%

• Distribution

• 97% bound to plasma proteins

• Protein binding is concentration independent

• 3% unbound with linear kinetic profile

Page 45: Conventional AINS are toxic - UCLouvain · Conventional AINS are toxic ... FARM2227 2004-2005 2 ... FARM2227 2004-2005 23 Effect of IL-1 and dexamethasone on human fibroblast COX

2004-2005FARM2227 45

Potential drug interactions ...

• Drugs that are Metabolized by the Cytochrome P450 2C9 Pathway

– S-Warfarin– tolbutamide– phenytoin– glyburide

• Potential Protein Binding Displacement

– warfarin– phenytoin– glyburide

• Drugs Eliminated by the Kidneys

– methotrexate– lithium

• Drugs that are Metabolized by the Cytochrome P450 2D6 Pathway– paroxetine– dextromethorphan

Page 46: Conventional AINS are toxic - UCLouvain · Conventional AINS are toxic ... FARM2227 2004-2005 2 ... FARM2227 2004-2005 23 Effect of IL-1 and dexamethasone on human fibroblast COX

2004-2005FARM2227 46

Actual results of drug interaction studies

Interactions observed :

• lithium (17% increase AUCand Cmax)

• fluconazole (2x increase celecoxib AUC and Cmax byCYP 2C9 inhibition)

• paroxetine anddextromethorphan(moderate increases of PKvalues)

No interactions with :

• methotrexate• glyburide• warfarin• phenytoin• tolbutamide• ketoconazole

Karim A et al. Arthritis & Rheum 1998;41(9) Suppl:1698A.Data on File: Searle (Studies 017, 038, 039, 040, 050, 051,117)

Page 47: Conventional AINS are toxic - UCLouvain · Conventional AINS are toxic ... FARM2227 2004-2005 2 ... FARM2227 2004-2005 23 Effect of IL-1 and dexamethasone on human fibroblast COX

2004-2005FARM2227 47

Celecoxib platelet effects

• no alteration of aggregation or bleeding time [Lack of COX-1 inhibition] at 6 x the therapeutic dose

• Anaemia, ecchymoses were reduced oncelecoxib vs NSAIDs (comparison with naproxen)

Page 48: Conventional AINS are toxic - UCLouvain · Conventional AINS are toxic ... FARM2227 2004-2005 2 ... FARM2227 2004-2005 23 Effect of IL-1 and dexamethasone on human fibroblast COX

2004-2005FARM2227 48

Clinical efficacy ?

Page 49: Conventional AINS are toxic - UCLouvain · Conventional AINS are toxic ... FARM2227 2004-2005 2 ... FARM2227 2004-2005 23 Effect of IL-1 and dexamethasone on human fibroblast COX

2004-2005FARM2227 49

Pain Measure Questionnaire of the American Pain Society (APS)

1. Have you experienced any pain in the last 24 h? (yes or no)

2. How much pain are you having right now? (0–10)3. Indicate the worst pain you have had in the past

24 h. (0–10)4. Indicate the average level of pain you have had in

the past 24 h. (0–10)5. Indicate how pain has interfered with you in:

(7 daily activities; each scored 0–10)

Page 50: Conventional AINS are toxic - UCLouvain · Conventional AINS are toxic ... FARM2227 2004-2005 2 ... FARM2227 2004-2005 23 Effect of IL-1 and dexamethasone on human fibroblast COX

2004-2005FARM2227 50

Patient’s assessment of average arthritis pain in last 24h

OA Knee Trial: Celecoxib vs NaproxenDayDay

Placebo

Celecoxib100 mg BIDCelecoxib200 mg BIDNaproxen500 mg BID

Placebo

Celecoxib100 mg BIDCelecoxib200 mg BIDNaproxen500 mg BID

00 11 22 33 44 55 66 77

**

**

Mea

n ch

ange

inA

PSpa

in m

easu

refr

om b

asel

ine

Mea

n ch

ange

inA

PSpa

in m

easu

refr

om b

asel

ine

-2.0-2.0

-1.5-1.5

-1.0-1.0

-0.5-0.5

0.00.0** ** **

****

n = 795n = 795*P < 0.05 vs all treatments (except naproxen at Day 1 and celecoxib 100 mg at Day 2)*P < 0.05 vs all treatments (except naproxen at Day 1 and celecoxib 100 mg at Day 2)

Data on file : Searle Study 020

Page 51: Conventional AINS are toxic - UCLouvain · Conventional AINS are toxic ... FARM2227 2004-2005 2 ... FARM2227 2004-2005 23 Effect of IL-1 and dexamethasone on human fibroblast COX

2004-2005FARM2227 51

Celecoxib vs Diclofenac in OA

Patient’s Assessment of Pain

Mea

n VA

S (m

m)

70Placebo (n=200)

60 Celecoxib 100 mg 2x/d (n=199)Diclofenac 50 mg 3x/d (n=199)

50

40

30

200 2 4 6

Weeks

Page 52: Conventional AINS are toxic - UCLouvain · Conventional AINS are toxic ... FARM2227 2004-2005 2 ... FARM2227 2004-2005 23 Effect of IL-1 and dexamethasone on human fibroblast COX

2004-2005FARM2227 52

Efficacy of celecoxib 200 mg once a day (qd) in OA

15

Scor

e :

Cha

nge

from

Bas

elin

e

Searle Study 060

Placebo (n=231)Celecoxib 200 mg qd (n=222)Celecoxib 100 mg 2x/d (n=231)

10

5

0Pain Stiffness Function Composite

Page 53: Conventional AINS are toxic - UCLouvain · Conventional AINS are toxic ... FARM2227 2004-2005 2 ... FARM2227 2004-2005 23 Effect of IL-1 and dexamethasone on human fibroblast COX

2004-2005FARM2227 53

Celecoxib Efficacy in RA - Combined Results from 2 Studies (n = 400 per treatment group)

Duration of Morning StiffnessDuration of Morning Stiffness

120

180

240

300

360

0 6 12Week

Mea

n D

urat

ion

(min

)

Data on file :Data on file :SearleSearleStudies 022, 023Studies 022, 023

Tender / Painful Joint CountTender / Painful Joint Count

15

20

25

30

0 6 12Week

MeanScore

Patient’s Global AssessmentPatient’s Global Assessment

MeanScore

PlaceboPlacebo

CelecoxibCelecoxib100 mg 2x/d 200 mg 2x/d400 mg 2x/d

Naproxen500 mg 2x/d

Patient's Global Assessment

2.5

3.0

3.5

4.0

0 6 12Week

Mea

n sc

ore

0 6 1240

50

60

70

Week

Mea

n sc

ore

(mm

)

Patient’s Assessment of Pain (VAS)Patient’s Assessment of Pain (VAS)

2

2

2

2

Page 54: Conventional AINS are toxic - UCLouvain · Conventional AINS are toxic ... FARM2227 2004-2005 2 ... FARM2227 2004-2005 23 Effect of IL-1 and dexamethasone on human fibroblast COX

2004-2005FARM2227 54

Number of tender / painful joints 6 Months International Study in RA

Weeks

10

20

30

0

Mea

n N

o. o

f Joi

nts

0 4 12 248 16 20

JJ Celecoxib 200 mg 2x/d (n=326)Diclofenac SR 75 mg 3x/d (n=329)PP

J

JJ J J J J

P

PP P P P P

Data on File : Searle Study 041Emery P et al, Lancet, 1999,2106-2111

Page 55: Conventional AINS are toxic - UCLouvain · Conventional AINS are toxic ... FARM2227 2004-2005 2 ... FARM2227 2004-2005 23 Effect of IL-1 and dexamethasone on human fibroblast COX

2004-2005FARM2227 55

Toxicity ??

Page 56: Conventional AINS are toxic - UCLouvain · Conventional AINS are toxic ... FARM2227 2004-2005 2 ... FARM2227 2004-2005 23 Effect of IL-1 and dexamethasone on human fibroblast COX

2004-2005FARM2227 56

Gastrointestinal Safety and TolerabilityCelecoxib vs NSAIDs

• Gastroduodenal ulceration- 6 endoscopy studies in >4000 individuals

• Clinically significant upper GI events- 4004 patient-years exposure data (All treatments)

• Changes in haemoglobin

• GI Symptoms } >11,000 patients with OA >11,000 patients with OA or or RARA in 14 Phase II / III in 14 Phase II / III

Page 57: Conventional AINS are toxic - UCLouvain · Conventional AINS are toxic ... FARM2227 2004-2005 2 ... FARM2227 2004-2005 23 Effect of IL-1 and dexamethasone on human fibroblast COX

2004-2005FARM2227 57

Incidence of gastroduodenal ulcers - week 12Celecoxib - Phase III RA and OA UGI Safety Trials

* Significantly different from all other treatments; P < 0.001

**

00

55

1010

1515

2020

% P

atie

nts

with

Ulc

er%

Pat

ient

s w

ith U

lcer

PlaceboPlacebo

(n=205)(n=205)

Celecoxib Celecoxib 5050 mg BIDmg BID

(n=164)(n=164)

Celecoxib Celecoxib 100100 mg BIDmg BID

(n=303)(n=303)

CelecoxibCelecoxib200200 mg BIDmg BID

(n=295)(n=295)

CelecoxibCelecoxib400400 mg BIDmg BID

(n=130)(n=130)

NaproxenNaproxen500500 mg BIDmg BID

(n=283)(n=283)

3030

2525

SearleSearle (Studies 021 & 022)(Studies 021 & 022)

Page 58: Conventional AINS are toxic - UCLouvain · Conventional AINS are toxic ... FARM2227 2004-2005 2 ... FARM2227 2004-2005 23 Effect of IL-1 and dexamethasone on human fibroblast COX

2004-2005FARM2227 58

Incidence of erosions / ulcers in patients with OA

75

**

**

75 Placebo (n=247)

00

2525

5050

GastricGastric

Patie

nts

with

Pa

tient

s w

ith

Eros

ions

/Ulc

ers

(%)

Eros

ions

/Ulc

ers

(%)

Celecoxib 50 mg 2x/d (n=258)Celecoxib 100 mg 2x/d (n=239)Celecoxib 200 mg 2x/d (n=237)Naproxen 500 mg 2x/d (n=233)

DuodenalDuodenal* Significantly different from all other treatments; * Significantly different from all other treatments; PP < 0.001< 0.001

SearleSearle Study 021Study 021

Page 59: Conventional AINS are toxic - UCLouvain · Conventional AINS are toxic ... FARM2227 2004-2005 2 ... FARM2227 2004-2005 23 Effect of IL-1 and dexamethasone on human fibroblast COX

2004-2005FARM2227 59

Incidence of Erosions / Ulcers in Patients with RA

7575 Placebo (n=231)Celecoxib 100 mg (n=240)**Celecoxib 200 mg (n=235)

GastricGastric

Patie

nts

with

Er

osio

ns/U

lcer

s (%

)

Celecoxib 400 mg (n=217)

DuodenalDuodenal

* Significantly different from all other treatments; * Significantly different from all other treatments; PP < 0.001< 0.001

**

Naproxen 500 mg (n=225)

0

25

50

SearleSearle Study 022Study 022

Page 60: Conventional AINS are toxic - UCLouvain · Conventional AINS are toxic ... FARM2227 2004-2005 2 ... FARM2227 2004-2005 23 Effect of IL-1 and dexamethasone on human fibroblast COX

2004-2005FARM2227 60

Cumulative Incidence of Gastric Ulcers

50

Goldstein et al., Reduced incidence of gastroduodenal ulcers with celecoxib, a novel cyclooxygenase-2 inhibitor, compared to naproxen in patients with arthritis. Am J Gastroenterol. 2001 Apr;96(4):1019-27.

**

00

1010

2020

3030

4040

50Pa

tient

s w

ith U

lcer

(%)

Patie

nts

with

Ulc

er (%

)CelecoxibCelecoxib 200 mg200 mgNaproxenNaproxen 500 mg500 mg

** 76/20476/204

**62/22362/223

* * PP < 0.001< 0.00140/24640/246

00--44 00--88 00--1212

WeeksWeeks

8/2498/249 10/23410/234 13/20513/205

Page 61: Conventional AINS are toxic - UCLouvain · Conventional AINS are toxic ... FARM2227 2004-2005 2 ... FARM2227 2004-2005 23 Effect of IL-1 and dexamethasone on human fibroblast COX

2004-2005FARM2227 61

Celecoxib vs Diclofenac plus omeprazole

Page 62: Conventional AINS are toxic - UCLouvain · Conventional AINS are toxic ... FARM2227 2004-2005 2 ... FARM2227 2004-2005 23 Effect of IL-1 and dexamethasone on human fibroblast COX

2004-2005FARM2227 62

Celecoxib vs Diclofenac plus omeprazole

ABSTRACTBackground Current guidelines recommend that patients at risk for ulcer disease who require treatment for arthritis receive nonsteroidal antiinflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) that are selective for cyclooxygenase-2 or the combination of a nonselective NSAID with a proton-pump inhibitor. We assessed whether celecoxib would be similar to diclofenac plus omeprazole in reducing the risk of recurrent ulcer bleeding in patients at high risk for bleeding.

Methods We studied patients who used NSAIDs for arthritis and who presented with ulcer bleeding. After their ulcers had healed, we randomly assigned patients who were negative for Helicobacter pylori to receive either 200 mg of celecoxib twice daily plus daily placebo or 75 mg of diclofenac twice daily plus 20 mg of omeprazole daily for six months. The end point was recurrent ulcer bleeding.

Results In the intention-to-treat analysis, which included 287 patients (144 receiving celecoxib and 143 receiving diclofenac plus omeprazole), recurrent ulcer bleeding occurred in 7 patients receiving celecoxib and 9 receiving diclofenac plus omeprazole. The probability of recurrent bleeding during the six-month period was 4.9 percent (95 percent confidence interval, 3.1 to 6.7) for patients who received celecoxib and 6.4 percent (95 percent confidence interval, 4.3 to 8.4) for patients who received diclofenac plus omeprazole (difference, –1.5 percentage points; 95 percent confidence interval for the difference, –6.8 to3.8). Renal adverse events, including hypertension, peripheral edema, and renal failure, occurred in 24.3 percent of the patients receiving celecoxib and 30.8 percent of those receiving diclofenac plus omeprazole.

Conclusions Among patients with a recent history of ulcer bleeding, treatment with celecoxib was as effective as treatment with diclofenac plus omeprazole, with respect to the prevention of recurrent bleeding. Renal toxic effects are common in high-risk patients receiving celecoxib or diclofenac plus omeprazole.

Page 63: Conventional AINS are toxic - UCLouvain · Conventional AINS are toxic ... FARM2227 2004-2005 2 ... FARM2227 2004-2005 23 Effect of IL-1 and dexamethasone on human fibroblast COX

2004-2005FARM2227 63

Localization of COX-1 and COX-2 in the kidneys

+=COX-1 present+=COX-2 present

Dog Rat Monkey Man

Renal Vasculature(Arteries, Arterioles, Veins)

++

+ ++

++

Glomerulus+ +

Macula Densa

Interstitium ++

+ +

Thick Ascending Loop

Collecting Ducts + + + + + + + + + +

(+++) = expression with volume

+ (+++) + (+++) (-)

+

+ (+++) + (+++)

Khan KN et al. Toxicol Pathol 1998;26(1):137-42.depletion

Page 64: Conventional AINS are toxic - UCLouvain · Conventional AINS are toxic ... FARM2227 2004-2005 2 ... FARM2227 2004-2005 23 Effect of IL-1 and dexamethasone on human fibroblast COX

2004-2005FARM2227 64

Present views on adverse-effects of Cox-1 / Cox-2 inhibitors

Coventional NSAID

Specific Cox-2inhibitors

Cox-1inhibition

Cox-2inhibition

Upper GI tract

Impairment of mucosal

defense

ulcer

Asthmatic lung

Increased leucotrienes production

Broncho-constriction

Platelets

Decreased TxA2

production

bleeding

Decreased GFR

Increased Na reabsption

BloodvesselsKidney

Decreased PgI2

production

OedemaHypertension

Renal insufficiency

Thrombosis

Modified from : Warner TD, Mitchell JA. Cyclooxygenases: new forms, new inhibitors, and lessons from the clinic. FASEB J. 2004 May;18(7):790-804.

Page 65: Conventional AINS are toxic - UCLouvain · Conventional AINS are toxic ... FARM2227 2004-2005 2 ... FARM2227 2004-2005 23 Effect of IL-1 and dexamethasone on human fibroblast COX

2004-2005FARM2227 65

The hypertension story starting in 2001 ...

Page 66: Conventional AINS are toxic - UCLouvain · Conventional AINS are toxic ... FARM2227 2004-2005 2 ... FARM2227 2004-2005 23 Effect of IL-1 and dexamethasone on human fibroblast COX

2004-2005FARM2227 66

The hypertension story reviewed in 2004...

Page 67: Conventional AINS are toxic - UCLouvain · Conventional AINS are toxic ... FARM2227 2004-2005 2 ... FARM2227 2004-2005 23 Effect of IL-1 and dexamethasone on human fibroblast COX

2004-2005FARM2227 67

The hypertension story ... ending on Sept. 30th, 2004

http://www.merck.com/

Page 68: Conventional AINS are toxic - UCLouvain · Conventional AINS are toxic ... FARM2227 2004-2005 2 ... FARM2227 2004-2005 23 Effect of IL-1 and dexamethasone on human fibroblast COX

2004-2005FARM2227 68

The hypertension story ... ending on Sept. 30th, 2004

http://www.merck.com/newsroom/press_releases/product/2004_0930.html

Page 69: Conventional AINS are toxic - UCLouvain · Conventional AINS are toxic ... FARM2227 2004-2005 2 ... FARM2227 2004-2005 23 Effect of IL-1 and dexamethasone on human fibroblast COX

2004-2005FARM2227 69

And the other coxibs…

S

O

O

C

N

O

CH3

OH3C

parecoxib

The Searle's series …

S

O

O

H2N

N

O

CH3

valdecoxib

S

O

O

H2N

NN

CF3

H3C celecoxib

Page 70: Conventional AINS are toxic - UCLouvain · Conventional AINS are toxic ... FARM2227 2004-2005 2 ... FARM2227 2004-2005 23 Effect of IL-1 and dexamethasone on human fibroblast COX

2004-2005FARM2227 70

And the other coxibs…

parecoxib

The MSD series …

etoricoxibrofexocib

S

O

O

H3C

H3C

O

O

S

O

O

H3C

N

H3C

N

Cl

The Novartis little boy…

H2C

NH

-OOC

H3C

Cl

F

lumiracoxib

Current evidence points to a marginal, if any, gain of safety compared with the first generation of COX-2 inhibitors. However, trials with the new COX-2 inhibitors offer the chance to address these open questions of highly selective COX-2 inhibition; that is, thrombogenic risk, sodium and water retention, and interference with tissue repair, in particular, healing of mucosal damage. Drom: Stichtenoth DO, Frolich JC. Drugs. 2003;63(1):33-45. The second generation of COX-2 inhibitors: what advantages do the newest offer?

Page 71: Conventional AINS are toxic - UCLouvain · Conventional AINS are toxic ... FARM2227 2004-2005 2 ... FARM2227 2004-2005 23 Effect of IL-1 and dexamethasone on human fibroblast COX

2004-2005FARM2227 71

Lumiracoxib gastrointestinal safety

Kivitz, A. J., Nayiager, S., Schimansky, T., Gimona, A., Thurston, H. J. & Hawkey, C.Reduced incidence of gastroduodenal ulcers associated with lumiracoxib compared with ibuprofen in patients with rheumatoid arthritis.Alimentary Pharmacology & Therapeutics 19 (11), 1189-1198, 2004.doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2036.2004.01956.x

Cumulative incidence of gastroduodenal ulcers 3 and 5 mm at study end (week 13) by treatment group.

Page 72: Conventional AINS are toxic - UCLouvain · Conventional AINS are toxic ... FARM2227 2004-2005 2 ... FARM2227 2004-2005 23 Effect of IL-1 and dexamethasone on human fibroblast COX

2004-2005FARM2227 72

Lumiracoxib gastrointestinal safety

Kivitz, A. J., Nayiager, S., Schimansky, T., Gimona, A., Thurston, H. J. & Hawkey, C.Reduced incidence of gastroduodenal ulcers associated with lumiracoxib compared with ibuprofen in patients with rheumatoid arthritis.Alimentary Pharmacology & Therapeutics 19 (11), 1189-1198, 2004.doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2036.2004.01956.x

Relative risk from developing gastroduodenal ulcers 3 mm in diameter.