Control_Theory_Unit_1_31_October_2012.docx
-
Upload
thota-sri-k-haritha -
Category
Documents
-
view
220 -
download
0
Transcript of Control_Theory_Unit_1_31_October_2012.docx
-
7/27/2019 Control_Theory_Unit_1_31_October_2012.docx
1/23
CONTROL THEORYAPPLICATION TO FLIGHT CONTROL SYSTEMS
B. Tech., Aeronautical Engineering
Fourth Year, First Semester
JNTUH
2009-2013 to 2012-2016
UNIT I
CONTROL SYSTEMSMODELING,
PERFORMANCE TIME, FREQUENCY AND S-DOMAIN DESCRIPTION
Note:
This unit is repeated four times citing examples from two text books Kuo and two editions of Ogata, three
different prints -2000, 2005, 2007.
Depending on the book you follow, you can choose the particular part, but cross references have been
inevitable.
Letter refers to Author, first number refers to Section and the next number refers to page no.
(The number occasionally refers to Example no.)
YYechout, S&LStevens & Lewis, O3- OgataThird edition,
O4(5)OgataFourth edition, 2005, O4(7)OgataFourth edition, 2007
NNelson KuoB.C. Kuo[More details at the end]
Part1 of 4.
For the students who are primarily referring to B.C. Kuo:
Dynamic systems, principal constituents, input, output, process: Kuo Sec 4-3, pp138-145,
S1-1-2, pp 2-8,
Block diagram representation: S 1-1-3, 1-1-4, 1-2, 1-2-1, 1-2-2 pp 9-13
Inputs
control input, noise: S1-2-4, 1-2-4, pp 14-15Also read Section 1-3, 1-3-1,1-3-2 pp16-19
Discrete data system on page 17 pertains to Digital control system.
[Read S 3-11, pp 106-117 before reading digital systems in Unit VIII]
Tracking Performance: Section 10-5O3, pp 686
Sensitivity:- - Sensitivity of the gain of the overall system is defined in Sec 1-2-3, pp 13-14
-
7/27/2019 Control_Theory_Unit_1_31_October_2012.docx
2/23
Function of control as regulation (hold), tracking (command)
[See notes of Unit V, reproduced below]
Autopilotspurpose, functioning Y - 9.2 - 444
Inputsfour cases are discussed.Holdkeeping the output constant,
commandinput, (Command here may be interpreted as a particular value)
trackfollow a given input profile
Pitch altitude hold - Y9.2.1446
Altitude hold - flying at a constant height Y9.2.2447
Bank angle holdkeeping roll angle constant Y9.2.3449
Heading holdmaintaining a constant yaw and the required bank angleY 9.2.4450
[The above topics are given from page 327 onwards in S&L]
Velocity holdS&Lpage 334-335
The Mach-hold autopilot is chiefly used on commercial passenger jets during climb and
descent. During a climb the throttles may be set at a fairly high power lever, and feedback of
Mach number to the elevator will be used to achieve a constant Mach climb(Ex 4.6-3 on
page 335 of S&L)Figure on page 335 of Ref S&L or fig 9.25 on page 448 of Y may be
modified to show velocity hold Block Diagram, by replacing h by v. Aircraft Transfer
function may be replaced by a general TF and sensor is for measuring v.
Aircraft Transfer functions are given in Block diagrams given in Ref Y.
Maneuver autopilotY9.2444n is load factor coming on aircraft during manoeuvre.
Pitch rate feedbackY Ex 9.5page 459
Block diagrams of Control Systems: S3-3-1, pp 84 -88
Gain formula: S 3-9, pp99-100.
Compare with Rules for Block diagram algebra in Ogata Section 3-3, page 68.
Control in every day life, pervasiveness of control in nature, engineering and societal
system, the importance of study of control system etc. - Examples in initial pages of all
control system books refer to these.
Robust control: S10-10, pp778-779Robustness is insensitivity to external disturbance and
parameter variation. Also, insensitivity to noise.
Modelling of dynamical systems by differential equations: See spring-mass system etc.,
on page 16 (of the first set) of Notes of Prof. G.V.S.S. Sastry, Wg. Cdr. (Rtd.).
KuoSection 4, pp 134- 160. Ex 4-4, pp151-154, explains spring-mass model. Ex 4-6,
pp155-158, explains a two-spring system.
Stochastic control: See Page 8 (of the second set) of Notes of Prof. G.V.S.S. Sastry, Wg.
Cdr. (Rtd.).
-
7/27/2019 Control_Theory_Unit_1_31_October_2012.docx
3/23
Linear time-invariant systems and linear time-varying systems:
[See Ogata, S3-1, pp 58-59 of O3.]
A differential equation is linear if the coefficients are constants or functions only of the
independent variable. If the coefficients are constants, then they are time-invariant. A morerigorous definition is given below. Dynamic systems that are composed of linear time-
invariant lumped-parameter components may be described by linear time-invariant (constant
coefficient) differential equations. Such systems are called linear time-invariant (or linear
constant-coefficient) systems.
Systems that are represented by differential equations whose coefficients are functions of
time are called linear time-varying systems.
Linear and non-linear systems:
In linear systems, the coefficients of derivatives like
are constants or functions
only of the independent variable. Also, functions like sin or cos would not be present.
Non-linear differential equations are those whose solutions do not obey the law of
superposition.
Definition: A linear system is a system which has the property that if:
(a) an input x1(t) produces an output y1(t), and
(b) an input x2(t) produces an output y2(t), then
(c) an input c1 x1(t) + c2 x2(t) produces an output c1 y1(t) + c2 y2(t) for all pairs of inputs x1(t)
and x2(t) and all pairs of constants c1 and c2.
First order, Second order and higher order systems:
Second order differential equation is of the form
,
while first order differential equation is of the form
See Ogata, S4-2, pp 136-139 of O3.
Second order system: Earlier referred - KuoSection 4, pp 134-160. S4-4, pp151-15,
explaining spring-mass model, and Ex 4-6, pp155-158, explaining a two spring systemare
second order systems.Higher order systemsUnit 6, 7you study nth order systems. The differential equation
contains the terms like. See Eq 3-3, p 79. KuoSection 2-3, pp25-28.
SISOSingle input single output systems
MIMOMultiple input multiple output systemsS 3-2-3, p81referred to as multi-
variable system. Fig 3-5 - Block diagram on p87.
-
7/27/2019 Control_Theory_Unit_1_31_October_2012.docx
4/23
Linearization of non-linear systemsCertain approximations have to be made to make the
coefficients constants at for a limited interval.
Time-invariant linear systemsThe differential equation is linear and the coefficients are
constants and not functions of the independent variable or time.
Control System performancetime domain description output response to control
inputs: As referred to earlier, KuoSection 4, pp 134- 160. Ex 4-4, pp151-154, explains
spring-mass model. The displacement as a function of time is given. Analysis without
referring to Laplace Transforms is given in OgataEx 3-2, pp73-74. Here it is solved in
state-space model. In the class it was solved as a solution of the second order differential
equation. All of these are examples of time domain description, where system variables are
obtained as functions of time, when acted on by an external force. The external force may be
impulse, step or ramp (or any other function).
Characteristic parameters, relation to system parametersexplained in the examples shown
aboveSee the response curve given on page 29 of the first set of notes given by Prof. Sastry
overshoot, steady state error, time constant, rise time, tmax etc.
See Kuo S7-4, pp385-389.
Indicial functions:
The time response in lift and moment to step changes in angle of attack and pitch rate are
termed indicial functions. [NACA R 1188, by Murray Tobak].
Transient Response of a second order system: Kuo, S7-5 pp387-388
Review Fourier transformsSee your old notes of Mathematics.
Laplace Transforms: Kuo S2-4, 2-4-2 pp28-30.
Application to differential equations: [] () () [
]
() ()()
[
] () ()() , where, ()
() See tables in Ogata or any other text book.
Laplace Transform: Kuo S2-6, pp 41-43
Transfer function: Kuo, S3-2, S3.3 pp78-88
Terminology on page 85
GH is loop transfer function. Ogata and many others call it Open-loop transfer function
OLTF
M is used only by some authors. is CLTFclosed loop transfer function.Read Kuo, S3-10-1, 3-10-2, 3-10-3, pp 102-105 to arrive at state and output equations
mentioned in Unit VI.
Kuo - Section 3-11 for Digital system of Unit VIII.
-
7/27/2019 Control_Theory_Unit_1_31_October_2012.docx
5/23
Poles and zeros are defined in Kuo S2-2-4, 2-2-5, pp24-25. See Ex 2-6 on page 38.
Characteristic equation: Kuo S3-2-2, page 80. 1+GH =0 is the characteristic equation of a
closed loop control system with negative feedback.
Kuo, S3-2-2, page 80: The characteristic equation of a linear system is defined as the equation
obtained by setting the denominator polynomial of the transfer function to zero.
Frequency and damping ratio of dominant poles: The lowest frequency pole is called
the dominant pole because it dominates the effect of all of the higher frequency poles [from
Wikipedia]
Relation of transfer function to impulse response: I guess this means system response for
impulse input.
Measures of Performance (MOP): measures derived from the dimensional parameters (bothphysical and structural) and measure attributes of system behavior. MOPs quantify the set of
selected parameters. Examples include sensor detection probability, sensor probability of
false alarm, and probability of correct identification.
Measures of Effectiveness (MOE): measure of how a system performs its functions within its
environment. An MOE is generally an aggregation of MOPs. Examples include
survivability, probability of raid annihilation, and weapon system effectiveness.
[Download from InternetEstablishing System Measures of Effectiveness by John M.
Green.]
Partial Fraction decomposition of transfer function: Kuo S 2-5, pp 34-37
Frequency domain description:
Kuo, Appendix A, pp864-
Eq A-1 Magnitude of G(j) and phase of G(j) are defined. Please note this is not G(s), but
the specific case, where the real part is zero.
Polar plotA plot of the magnitude versus phase in the polar coordinates, as varies fro m
zero to infinity.Bode plotA plot of the magnitude in decibels |()| versus in semi-logcoordinates
Section A1Polar plot, Section A2 Bode Plot.
The polar plot is often called Nyquist Plot.
Polar plot is for any G. Nyquist plot is for GH, [loop transfer function or OLTF]
Frequency Transfer function: I suspect it refers to G(j)
Corner frequencies, resonant frequencies, peak gainPlease study Bode plots.Resonant frequency is the frequency at which the peak resonance M, (Mr),
-
7/27/2019 Control_Theory_Unit_1_31_October_2012.docx
6/23
occurs. [Kuo, S9-1-2, p 544.] Some books use Mp as the symbol.
The resonant frequency is the frequency at which the magnitude ofM(j) is the highest.
In general the Mrshould be between 1.1 and 1.5.
Characteristics of a system are stability, bandwidth, overall gain, disturbance andsensitivity.
Bandwidth: Bandwidth BW is the frequency at which |()| drops to 70.7 percent or 3 dBdown from its zero-frequency value. {Kuo}
In general, the bandwidth of a control system gives an indication of the transient response
properties in the time domain. Kuo, p544.
The frequency range , in which the magnitude of the closed loop does not dropminus3dB is called the bandwidth of the system. {Ogata}. The bandwidth indicates the
frequency where the gain starts to fall off from its low-frequency value. Thus, the bandwidth
indicates how well the system will track an input sinusoid. The rise time and the bandwidth
are inversely proportional to each other.
Another definition: BW is that range of frequencies of the input over which the system will
respond satisfactorily.
Second order system is dealt with in Kuo, S 9-2, pp544- 549.
First order system is given in Ogata S 4-2, pp136-139 of O3.
END OF Part 1.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.--.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.--.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.--.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-..-.-.-.-.-.-.--.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-
Part 2 of 4.
For students who are primarily referring to Ogata, Third Edition:
Dynamic systems, principal constituents, input, output, process: SeeOgata, S1-2, pp 2-6
of Third edition [O(3)].
Block diagram representation: Ogata S3-3, pp63-67 of O3Rules for block diagram algebrapage 68 of O3
Inputscontrol input, noise: Control input is r(t) and R(s), NoiseBlock diagrams in
Ogata, Section 10-3, pp 680-681 and 684-685 of O3 have noise as additional input N(s). This
is usually measurement error of the output (referred to as sensor error).
Discrete data system on {page 17 of Kuo} pertains to Digital control system.
[Read Kuo. S 3-11, pp 106-117 before reading digital systems in Unit VIII]
Tracking Performance: Ogata, Section 10-5see page 686 and then page 685 of O3
-
7/27/2019 Control_Theory_Unit_1_31_October_2012.docx
7/23
()(), where Y(s) and R(s) are output and input respectively. Tracking error is thedifference between the desired output and achieved output. To keep it small, must be close to unity over a wide range of frequency.
Sensitivity: (i) - Sensitivity of the gain of the overall system is defined in Kuo, Sec 1-2-3,pp 13-14
Ogata Section 10-5pp 686-687 of O3
(ii) Sddegree of disturbance rejection
(iii) Sensitivity to modeling errors
Function of control as regulation (hold), tracking (command)
[See notes of Unit V, reproduced below]
Autopilotspurpose, functioning Y - 9.2 - 444
Inputsfour cases are discussed.
Holdkeeping the output constant,
commandinput, (Command here may be interpreted as a particular value)
trackfollow a given input profile
Pitch altitude hold - Y9.2.1446
Altitude hold - flying at a constant height Y9.2.2447
Bank angle holdkeeping roll angle constant Y9.2.3449Heading holdmaintaining a constant yaw and the required bank angleY 9.2.4450
[The above topics are given from page 327 onwards in S&L]
Velocity holdS&Lpage 334-335
The Mach-hold autopilot is chiefly used on commercial passenger jets during climb and
descent. During a climb the throttles may be set at a fairly high power lever, and feedback of
Mach number to the elevator will be used to achieve a constant Mach climb (Ex 4.6-3 on
page 335 of S&L)Figure on page 335 of Ref S&L or fig 9.25 on page 448 of Y may be
modified to show velocity hold Block Diagram, by replacing h by v. Aircraft Transfer
function may be replaced by a general TF and sensor is for measuring v.
Aircraft Transfer functions are given in Block diagrams given in Ref Y.
Maneuver autopilotY9.2444n is load factor coming on aircraft during manoeuvre.
Pitch rate feedbackY Ex 9.5page 459
Block diagrams of Control Systems: Ogata, Examples 3-1, 3-2, pp 69-70 and pp73-75 of
O3. [These are in addition to those cited earlier.]
Control in every day life, pervasiveness of control in nature, engineering and societal
system, the importance of study of control system etc. - Examples in initial pages of all
control system books refer to these.
-
7/27/2019 Control_Theory_Unit_1_31_October_2012.docx
8/23
Robust control: Ogata, S10-5, pp 685-686 of O3Robustness is insensitivity to external
disturbance and parameter variation. Also, insensitivity to noise.
Modelling of dynamical systems by differential equations: See spring-mass system etc.,
on page 16 (of the first set) of Notes of Prof. G.V.S.S. Sastry, Wg. Cdr. (Rtd.).
Ogata, Ex 3-2, pp 73-74 of O3explains spring-mass model. Example in the sub-section
Mechanical System, pp 83-85 of O3 explains a slightly different model, where the spring-
mass system is on a cart.
If you can read the electrical examples in the next few pages, it is good. But, before that read
page 67 of O3, procedures for drawing block diagrams.
Stochastic control: See Page 8 (of the second set) of Notes of Prof. G.V.S.S. Sastry, Wg.
Cdr. (Rtd.).
Linear time-invariant systems and linear time-varying systems:
Ogata, Section 3-1, pp 58-59 of O3.
A differential equation is linear if the coefficients are constants or functions only of the
independent variable. It is time-invariant, if the independent variable is time and the
coefficients are constant. A more rigorous definition for a linear system is given below.
Dynamic systems that are composed of linear time-invariant lumped-parameter components
may be described by linear time-invariant (constant coefficient) differential equations. Such
systems are called linear time-invariant (or linear constant-coefficient) systems.Systems that are represented by differential equations whose coefficients are functions of
time are called linear time-varying systems.
In linear systems, the coefficients of derivatives like
are constants or functions
only of the independent variable. Also, functions like sin or cos would not be present.
Non-linear differential equations are those whose solutions do not obey the law of
superposition.
Definition: A linear system is a system which has the property that if:
(a) an input x1(t) produces an output y1(t), and
(b) an input x2(t) produces an output y2(t), then(c) an input c1 x1(t) + c2 x2(t) produces an output c1 y1(t) + c2 y2(t) for all pairs of inputs x1(t)
and x2(t) and all pairs of constants c1 and c2.
First order, Second order and higher order systems:
Second order differential equation is of the form
,
while first order differential equation is of the form
See Ogata, S4-2, page 136-139 of O3.
-
7/27/2019 Control_Theory_Unit_1_31_October_2012.docx
9/23
Second order system: Earlier referred example explaining spring-mass model is a second
order system.
Higher order systemsUnit 6, 7you study nth order systems. The differential equation
contains the terms like. See Eq 3-3, p 79. KuoSection 2-3, pp25-28.
See Ogata, S4-3, pp 150-154 of O3. If you can study Section 4-3, pp 141-150 of O3, it willbe helpful.
SISOSingle input single output systems
MIMOMultiple input multiple output systemsKuo, S 3-2-3, p81referred to as multi-
variable system. Kuo, Fig 3-5 - Block diagram on p87. Ogata, Section 3-4, page 70 of O3.
Linearization of non-linear systemsCertain approximations have to be made to make the
coefficients constants at for a limited interval. Ogata, S3-10, pp 100-102 of O3.
Time-invariant linear systemsThe differential equation is linear and the coefficients are
constants and not functions of the independent variable, time.
Control System performancetime domain description output response to control
inputs: As referred to earlier, KuoSection 4, pp 134- 160. Ex 4-4, pp151-154, explains
spring-mass model. The displacement as a function of time is given.
Analysis without referring to Laplace Transforms is given in OgataEx 3-2, pp73-74 of O3.
Here it is solved in state-space model. In the class it was solved as a solution of the second
order differential equation. All of these are examples of time domain description, where
system variables are obtained as functions of time, when acted on by an external force. The
external force may be impulse, step or ramp (or any other function).
Characteristic parameters, relation to system parametersexplained in the examples referred
to aboveSee the response curve given on page 29 of the first set of notes given by Prof.
G.V.S.S. Sastryovershoot, steady state error, time constant, rise time, tmax etc.
Also, see S4-3, Sub-section Definitions of transient response specifications, page 150 of
O3.
Indicial function:The time response in lift and moment to step changes in angle of attack and pitch rate are
termed indicial functions. [NACA R 1188, by Murray Tobak].
Transient Response of a second order system: Ogata, Section 4-3, page 150 of O3.
Review Fourier transformsSee your old notes of Mathematics.
Laplace Transforms: Application to differential equations: [] () ()
[ ] () ()()
-
7/27/2019 Control_Theory_Unit_1_31_October_2012.docx
10/23
[
] () ()() , where, ()
()
See tables in Ogata or any other text book.
Laplace Transform: Ogata, S 2-3, pp 17- 23 of O3.
Transfer function: S3-2, S3-3, page 60 and pp 65-66 of O3
Terminology is given clearly by Kuo, S3-3-1, page 85
GH is loop transfer function. Ogata and many others call it Open-loop transfer function
OLTF
M is used only by some authors. is CLTFclosed loop transfer function.Read Kuo, S3-10-1, 3-10-2, 3-10-3, pp 102-105 to arrive at state and output equations
mentioned in Unit VI.
Kuo - Section 3-11 for Digital system of Unit VIII.
Poles and zeros: Ogata, S2-2, page 16 of O3Rigorous definition is given in the text.
[Hint: Roots of the numerator equated to zero are zeros, and roots of the denominator equated
to zero are poles, but definition in the text has to be used.]
Characteristic equation: The equation 1+GH =0 is the characteristic equation of a closed
loop control system with negative feedback.
In the state-space system, | | is the characteristic polynomial of G(s). See Ogata, S3-4, at theend of the Sub-section Correlation between transfer function and state-space equations, page 75 of
O3.
Kuo, S3-2-2, page 80: The characteristic equation of a linear system is defined as the equationobtained by setting the denominator polynomial of the transfer function to zero.
Frequency and damping ratio of dominant poles: The lowest frequency pole is called
the dominant pole because it dominates the effect of all of the higher frequency poles [from
Wikipedia]
Relation of transfer function to impulse response: I guess this means system response for
impulse input.
Measures of Performance (MOP): measures derived from the dimensional parameters (bothphysical and structural) and measure attributes of system behavior. MOPs quantify the set of
selected parameters. Examples include sensor detection probability, sensor probability of
false alarm, and probability of correct identification.
Measures of Effectiveness (MOE): measure of how a system performs its functions within its
environment. An MOE is generally an aggregation of MOPs. Examples include
survivability, probability of raid annihilation, and weapon system effectiveness.
[Download from InternetEstablishing System Measures of Effectiveness by John M.
Green.]
-
7/27/2019 Control_Theory_Unit_1_31_October_2012.docx
11/23
Partial Fraction decomposition of transfer function: Ogata, S2-5, pp37-38 of O3.
Frequency domain description:
Ogata, S8-1, Subsection - Steady state output to sinusoidal inputs (Pp 471-472 of O3:Magnitude of G(j) is given as amplitude ratio, and phase of G(j) is defined as the phase
shift of the output sinusoid with respect to the input sinusoid. Please note this is not G(s), but
the specific case, where the real part is zero. Some call this simply angle of G(j).
Polar plotA plot of the magnitude versus phase in the polar coordinates, as varies from
zero to infinity. Ogata, S8-4, pp 504-505 of O3.
Bode plotA plot of the magnitude in decibels |()| versus in semi-logcoordinates. Bode diagrams are explained in Ogata, S8-2, pp 473-483 of O3. The General
procedure for plotting Bode diagrams is given at the end of the section, pp 483-484 of O3.
Bodepronounced Bodee, Boday (and as per internet, Bodah, probably in his mother
tongue.]
The polar plot is often called Nyquist Plot.
Polar plot is for any G. Nyquist plot is for GH, [loop transfer function or OLTF]
Frequency Transfer function: I suspect it refers to G(j)
Corner frequencies, resonant frequencies, peak gainPlease study Bode plots.Resonant frequency is the frequency at which the peak resonance M, (Mr),
occurs. [Kuo, S9-1-2, p 544. Ogata, S8-2, page 483 of O3] Some books use Mp as the
symbol.
The resonant frequency is the frequency at which the magnitude ofM(j) is the highest.
In general the Mrshould be between 1.1 and 1.5.
Characteristics of a system are stability, bandwidth, overall gain, disturbance and
sensitivity.
Bandwidth: Bandwidth BW is the frequency at which |()| drops to 70.7 percent or 3 dBdown from its zero-frequency value. {Kuo}
In general, the bandwidth of a control system gives an indication of the transient response
properties in the time domain. [See Kuo, p 544, Ogata, S8-9, pp 554-555 of O3]
The frequency range , in which the magnitude of the closed loop does not dropminus3dB is called the bandwidth of the system. {Ogata}. The bandwidth indicates the
frequency where the gain starts to fall off from its low-frequency value. Thus, the bandwidth
indicates how well the system will track an input sinusoid. The rise time and the bandwidth
are inversely proportional to each other.
-
7/27/2019 Control_Theory_Unit_1_31_October_2012.docx
12/23
Another definition: BW is that range of frequencies of the input over which the system will
respond satisfactorily.
Second order system is dealt with in Ogata S 4-2, pp136-139 of O3.
First order system is given in Ogata, S4-3, pp 150-154 of O3.
End of Part 2.
-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.--.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.--.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.--.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-..-.-.-.-.-.-.--.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-
Part 3 of 4.
For students who are primarily referring to Ogata, Fourth Edition printed
in 2005 [O4(5)]:
Dynamic systems, principal constituents, input, output, process: Ogata, S1-2, pp 2-6 of
O4(5).
Block diagram representation: Ogata S3-3, pp 58-63 of O4(5)
Rules for block diagram algebrapage 68 of O3 {not seen in O4(5)}
Inputscontrol input, noise: Control input is r(t) and R(s), NoiseBlock diagrams in
Ogata, Section 10-4, pp 701-705 of O4(5) have noise as additional input N(s). This is usually
measurement error of the output (referred to as sensor error).
Discrete data system on {page 17 of Kuo} pertains to Digital control system.
[Read Kuo. S 3-11, pp 106-117 before reading digital systems in Unit VIII]
Tracking Performance: Ogata, Section 10-5see page 686 and then S10-4, page 685 of O3
{I could not see the relevant part in O4}
()(), where Y(s) and R(s) are output and input respectively. Tracking error is thedifference between the desired output and achieved output. To keep it small, must be close to unity over a wide range of frequency.
Sensitivity: (i)
- Sensitivity of the gain of the overall system is defined in Kuo, Sec 1-2-3,pp 13-14
Ogata Section 10-5pp 686-687 of O3
(ii) Sddegree of disturbance rejection
(iii) Sensitivity to modeling errors
Function of control as regulation (hold), tracking (command)
[See notes of Unit V, reproduced below]
Autopilots
purpose, functioning Y - 9.2 - 444
-
7/27/2019 Control_Theory_Unit_1_31_October_2012.docx
13/23
Inputsfour cases are discussed.
Holdkeeping the output constant,
commandinput, (Command here may be interpreted as a particular value)
trackfollow a given input profile
Pitch altitude hold - Y9.2.1446Altitude hold - flying at a constant height Y9.2.2447
Bank angle holdkeeping roll angle constant Y9.2.3449
Heading holdmaintaining a constant yaw and the required bank angleY 9.2.4450
[The above topics are given from page 327 onwards in S&L]
Velocity holdS&Lpage 334-335
The Mach-hold autopilot is chiefly used on commercial passenger jets during climb and
descent. During a climb the throttles may be set at a fairly high power lever, and feedback of
Mach number to the elevator will be used to achieve a constant Mach climb (Ex 4.6 -3 on
page 335 of S&L)Figure on page 335 of Ref S&L or fig 9.25 on page 448 of Y may be
modified to show velocity hold Block Diagram, by replacing h by v. Aircraft Transfer
function may be replaced by a general TF and sensor is for measuring v.
Aircraft Transfer functions are given in Block diagrams given in Ref Y.
Maneuver autopilotY9.2444n is load factor coming on aircraft during manoeuvre.
Pitch rate feedbackY Ex 9.5page 459
Block diagrams of Control Systems: Ogata, Examples 3-2, 3-3, pp 69-70 and pp73-75 of
O4(5). [These are in addition to those cited earlier.]
Control in every day life, pervasiveness of control in nature, engineering and societalsystem, the importance of study of control system etc. - Examples in initial pages of all
control system books refer to these.
Robust control: Ogata, S10-5, pp 685-686 of O3Robustness is insensitivity to external
disturbance and parameter variation. Also, insensitivity to noise.
[Please see Ogata, Third Edition]
Modelling of dynamical systems by differential equations: See spring-mass system etc.,
on page 16 (of the first set) of Notes of Prof. G.V.S.S. Sastry, Wg. Cdr. (Rtd.).
Ogata, Ex 3-3, pp 73-74 of O4(5) explains spring-mass model. Example in the sub-section
Mechanical Systems, Ex. 3-8 pp 81-82 of O4(5) explains a slightly different model, where
the spring-mass` system is on a cart.
If you can read the electrical examples in the next few pages, it is good. But, before that read
page 67 of O3, procedures for drawing block diagrams.
Stochastic control: See Page 8 (of the second set) of Notes of Prof. G.V.S.S. Sastry, Wg.
Cdr. (Rtd.).
Linear time-invariant systems and linear time-varying systems:
-
7/27/2019 Control_Theory_Unit_1_31_October_2012.docx
14/23
Ogata, Section 3-1, page 54 of O4(5).
A differential equation is linear if the coefficients are constants or functions only of the
independent variable. It is time-invariant, if the independent variable is time and the
coefficients are constant. A more rigorous definition for a linear system is given below.Dynamic systems that are composed of linear time-invariant lumped-parameter components
may be described by linear time-invariant (constant coefficient) differential equations. Such
systems are called linear time-invariant (or linear constant-coefficient) systems.
Systems that are represented by differential equations whose coefficients are functions of
time are called linear time-varying systems.
In linear systems, the coefficients of derivatives like
are constants or functions
only of the independent variable. Also, functions like sin or cos would not be present.
Non-linear differential equations are those whose solutions do not obey the law of
superposition.Definition: A linear system is a system which has the property that if:
(a) an input x1(t) produces an output y1(t), and
(b) an input x2(t) produces an output y2(t), then
(c) an input c1 x1(t) + c2 x2(t) produces an output c1 y1(t) + c2 y2(t) for all pairs of inputs x1(t)
and x2(t) and all pairs of constants c1 and c2.
First order, Second order and higher order systems:
Second order differential equation is of the form
,
while first order differential equation is of the form See Ogata, S5-2, page 221-224 of O4(5).
Second order system: Earlier referred example explaining spring-mass model is a second
order system.
Higher order systemsUnit 6, 7you study nth order systems. The differential equation
contains the terms like. See Eq 3-3, p 79. KuoSection 2-3, pp25-28.
See Ogata, S5-3, pp 230-231 of O4(5). If you can study Section 5-3, pp224-230 of O4(5), it
will be helpful.
SISOSingle input single output systems
MIMOMultiple input multiple output systemsKuo, S 3-2-3, p81referred to as multi-
variable system. Kuo, Fig 3-5 - Block diagram on p87. Ogata, Section 3-4, page 70, O4(5).
Linearization of non-linear systemsCertain approximations have to be made to make the
coefficients constants at for a limited interval. Ogata, S3-10, pp 112-114 of O4(5).
Time-invariant linear systemsThe differential equation is linear and the coefficients are
constants and not functions of the independent variable, time.
-
7/27/2019 Control_Theory_Unit_1_31_October_2012.docx
15/23
Control System performancetime domain description output response to control
inputs: As referred to earlier, KuoSection 4, pp 134- 160. Ex 4-4, pp151-154, explains
spring-mass model. The displacement as a function of time is given.
Analysis without referring to Laplace Transforms is given in OgataEx 3-3, pp73-74 of
O4(5). Here it is solved in state-space model. In the class it was solved as a solution of thesecond order differential equation. All of these are examples of time domain description,
where system variables are obtained as functions of time, when acted on by an external force.
The external force may be impulse, step or ramp (or any other function).
Characteristic parameters, relation to system parametersexplained in the examples referred
to aboveSee the response curve given on page 29 of the first set of notes given by Prof.
G.V.S.S. Sastryovershoot, steady state error, time constant, rise time, tmax etc.
Also, see S5-3, Sub-section Definitions of transient response specifications, pp 229-231 of
O4(5).
Indicial function:
The time response in lift and moment to step changes in angle of attack and pitch rate are
termed indicial functions. [NACA R 1188, by Murray Tobak].
Transient Response of a second order system: Ogata, Section 5-3, page 230 of O4(5).
Review Fourier transformsSee your old notes of Mathematics.
Laplace Transforms: Application to differential equations: [] () () [
]
() ()()
[
] () ()() , where, ()
()
See tables in Ogata or any other text book.
Laplace Transform: Ogata, S 2-3, pp 13-20 of O4(5).
Transfer function: S3-2, S3-3, page 55 and pp 59-60 of O4(5).
Terminology is given clearly by Kuo, S3-3-1, page 85
GH is loop transfer function. Ogata and many others call it Open-loop transfer function
OLTF
M is used only by some authors. is CLTFclosed loop transfer function.Read Kuo, S3-10-1, 3-10-2, 3-10-3, pp 102-105 to arrive at state and output equations
mentioned in Unit VI.
Kuo - Section 3-11 for Digital system of Unit VIII.
Poles and zeros: Ogata, S2-2, page 12 of O4(5). Rigorous definition is given in the text.
[Hint: Roots of the numerator equated to zero are zeros, and roots of the denominator equated
to zero are poles, but definition in the text has to be used.]
-
7/27/2019 Control_Theory_Unit_1_31_October_2012.docx
16/23
Characteristic equation: The equation 1+GH =0 is the characteristic equation of a closed
loop control system with negative feedback.
In the state-space system, | | is the characteristic polynomial of G(s). See Ogata, S3-4, at theend of the Sub-section Correlation between transfer function and state-space equations, page 75 of
O4(5).
Kuo, S3-2-2, page 80: The characteristic equation of a linear system is defined as the equation
obtained by setting the denominator polynomial of the transfer function to zero.
Frequency and damping ratio of dominant poles: The lowest frequency pole is called
the dominant pole because it dominates the effect of all of the higher frequency poles [from
Wikipedia]
Relation of transfer function to impulse response: I guess this means system response for
impulse input.
Measures of Performance (MOP): measures derived from the dimensional parameters (both
physical and structural) and measure attributes of system behavior. MOPs quantify the set of
selected parameters. Examples include sensor detection probability, sensor probability of
false alarm, and probability of correct identification.
Measures of Effectiveness (MOE): measure of how a system performs its functions within its
environment. An MOE is generally an aggregation of MOPs. Examples include
survivability, probability of raid annihilation, and weapon system effectiveness.
[Download from InternetEstablishing System Measures of Effectiveness by John M.
Green.]
Partial Fraction decomposition of transfer function: Ogata, S2-5, pp 36-37 of O4(5).
Frequency domain description:
Ogata, S8-1, SubsectionObtaining steady state output to sinusoidal inputs [pp 493-494 of
O4(5)]:
Magnitude of G(j) is given as amplitude ratio, and phase of G(j) is defined as the phase
shift of the output sinusoid with respect to the input sinusoid. Please note this is not G(s), butthe specific case, where the real part is zero. Some call this simply angle of G(j).
Polar plotA plot of the magnitude versus phase in the polar coordinates, as varies from
zero to infinity. Ogata, S8-4, pp 523-526 of O4(5).
Bode plotA plot of the magnitude in decibels |()| versus in semi-logcoordinates. Bode diagrams are explained in Ogata, S8-2, pp 497-507 of O4(5). The General
procedure for plotting Bode diagrams is given at the end of the section, page 507 of O4(5).
[Bodepronounced Bodee, Boday (and as per internet, Bodah, probably in his mother
tongue.]
-
7/27/2019 Control_Theory_Unit_1_31_October_2012.docx
17/23
The polar plot is often called Nyquist Plot.
Polar plot is for any G. Nyquist plot is for GH, [loop transfer function or OLTF]
Frequency Transfer function: I suspect it refers to G(j)
Corner frequencies, resonant frequencies, peak gainPlease study Bode plots.
Resonant frequency is the frequency at which the peak resonance M, (Mr),
occurs. [Kuo, S9-1-2, p 544. Ogata, S8-2, page 507 of O4(5)] Some books use Mp as the
symbol.
The resonant frequency is the frequency at which the magnitude ofM(j) is the highest.
In general the Mrshould be between 1.1 and 1.5.
Characteristics of a system are stability, bandwidth, overall gain, disturbance and
sensitivity.
Bandwidth: Bandwidth BW is the frequency at which |()| drops to 70.7 percent or 3 dBdown from its zero-frequency value. {Kuo}
In general, the bandwidth of a control system gives an indication of the transient response
properties in the time domain. [See Kuo, p544, Ogata, S8-9, pp 572-573 of O4(5).]
The frequency range , in which the magnitude of the closed loop does not dropminus3dB is called the bandwidth of the system. {Ogata}. The bandwidth indicates the
frequency where the gain starts to fall off from its low-frequency value. Thus, the bandwidth
indicates how well the system will track an input sinusoid. The rise time and the bandwidthare inversely proportional to each other.
Another definition: BW is that range of frequencies of the input over which the system will
respond satisfactorily.
Second order system is dealt with in Ogata S 5-3, pp 224-233 of O4(5).
First order system is given in Ogata, S5-2, pp 221-224 of O4(5).
End of Part 3.
-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.--.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.--.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.--.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-..-.-.-.-.-.-.--.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-
Part 4 of 4.
For students who are primarily referring to Ogata, Fourth Edition printed
in 2007 [O4(7)]:
Dynamic systems, principal constituents, input, output, process: Ogata, S1-2, pp 14-18 of
O4(7).Block diagram representation: Ogata S3-3, pp 70-75 of O4(7).
-
7/27/2019 Control_Theory_Unit_1_31_October_2012.docx
18/23
Rules for block diagram algebrapage 68 of O3 {not seen in O4(5) or O4(7)}
Inputscontrol input, noise: Control input is r(t) and R(s), NoiseBlock diagrams in
Ogata, Section 10-4, pp 713-717 of O4(7) have noise as additional input N(s). This is usually
measurement error of the output (referred to as sensor error).
Discrete data system on {page 17 of Kuo} pertains to Digital control system.
[Read Kuo. S 3-11, pp 106-117 before reading digital systems in Unit VIII]
Tracking Performance: Ogata, Section 10-5see page 686 and then S10-4, page 685 of O3
{I could not see the relevant part in O4}
()(), where Y(s) and R(s) are output and input respectively. Tracking error is thedifference between the desired output and achieved output. To keep it small, must be close to unity over a wide range of frequency.
Sensitivity: (i) - Sensitivity of the gain of the overall system is defined in Kuo, Sec 1-2-3,pp 13-14
Ogata Section 10-5pp 686-687 of O3
(ii) Sddegree of disturbance rejection
(iii) Sensitivity to modeling errors
[Please see Kuo and Ogata, Third Edition]
Function of control as regulation (hold), tracking (command)
[See notes of Unit V, reproduced below]
Autopilotspurpose, functioning Y - 9.2 - 444
Inputsfour cases are discussed.
Holdkeeping the output constant,
commandinput, (Command here may be interpreted as a particular value)
trackfollow a given input profile
Pitch altitude hold - Y9.2.1446
Altitude hold - flying at a constant height Y9.2.2447
Bank angle holdkeeping roll angle constant Y9.2.3449
Heading holdmaintaining a constant yaw and the required bank angleY 9.2.4450
[The above topics are given from page 327 onwards in S&L]
Velocity holdS&Lpage 334-335
The Mach-hold autopilot is chiefly used on commercial passenger jets during climb and
descent. During a climb the throttles may be set at a fairly high power lever, and feedback of
Mach number to the elevator will be used to achieve a constant Mach climb (Ex 4.6 -3 on
page 335 of S&L)Figure on page 335 of Ref S&L or fig 9.25 on page 448 of Y may be
modified to show velocity hold Block Diagram, by replacing h by v. Aircraft Transfer
function may be replaced by a general TF and sensor is for measuring v.Aircraft Transfer functions are given in Block diagrams given in Ref Y.
-
7/27/2019 Control_Theory_Unit_1_31_October_2012.docx
19/23
Maneuver autopilotY9.2444n is load factor coming on aircraft during manoeuvre.
Pitch rate feedbackY Ex 9.5page 459
Block diagrams of Control Systems: Ogata, Examples 3-2, 3-3, pp 81-82 and pp 85-86 of
O4(7). [These are in addition to those cited earlier.]
Control in every day life, pervasiveness of control in nature, engineering and societal
system, the importance of study of control system etc. - Examples in initial pages of all
control system books refer to these.
Robust control: Ogata, S10-5, pp 685-686 of O3Robustness is insensitivity to external
disturbance and parameter variation. Also, insensitivity to noise.
[Please see Ogata, Third Edition]
Modelling of dynamical systems by differential equations: See spring-mass system etc.,
on page 16 (of the first set) of Notes of Prof. G.V.S.S. Sastry, Wg. Cdr. (Rtd.).
Ogata, Ex 3-3, pp 85-86 of O4(5) explains spring-mass model. Example in the sub-section
Mechanical Systems, Ex. 3-8 pp 93-94 of O4(7) explains a slightly different model, where
the spring-mass` system is on a cart.
If you can read the electrical examples in the next few pages, it is good. But, before that read
page 67 of O3, procedures for drawing block diagrams.
Stochastic control: See Page 8 (of the second set) of Notes of Prof. G.V.S.S. Sastry, Wg.Cdr. (Rtd.).
Linear time-invariant systems and linear time-varying systems:
Ogata, Section 3-1, page 56 of O4(7).
A differential equation is linear if the coefficients are constants or functions only of the
independent variable. It is time-invariant, if the independent variable is time and the
coefficients are constant. A more rigorous definition for a linear system is given below.
Dynamic systems that are composed of linear time-invariant lumped-parameter components
may be described by linear time-invariant (constant coefficient) differential equations. Such
systems are called linear time-invariant (or linear constant-coefficient) systems.
Systems that are represented by differential equations whose coefficients are functions of
time are called linear time-varying systems.
In linear systems, the coefficients of derivatives like
are constants or functions
only of the independent variable. Also, functions like sin or cos would not be present.
Non-linear differential equations are those whose solutions do not obey the law of
superposition.
Definition: A linear system is a system which has the property that if:(a) an input x1(t) produces an output y1(t), and
-
7/27/2019 Control_Theory_Unit_1_31_October_2012.docx
20/23
(b) an input x2(t) produces an output y2(t), then
(c) an input c1 x1(t) + c2 x2(t) produces an output c1 y1(t) + c2 y2(t) for all pairs of inputs x1(t)
and x2(t) and all pairs of constants c1 and c2.
First order, Second order and higher order systems:Second order differential equation is of the form
,
while first order differential equation is of the form
See Ogata, S5-2, page 233-236 of O4(7).
Second order system: Earlier referred example explaining spring-mass model is a second
order system.
Higher order systemsUnit 6, 7you study nth order systems. The differential equation
contains the terms like
. See Eq 3-3, p 79. KuoSection 2-3, pp25-28.
See Ogata, S5-3, pp 242-243 of O4(7). If you can study Section 5-3, pp 236-241 of O4(7), it
will be helpful.
SISOSingle input single output systems
MIMOMultiple input multiple output systemsKuo, S 3-2-3, p81referred to as multi-
variable system. Kuo, Fig 3-5 - Block diagram on p87. Ogata, Section 3-4, page 82, O4(7).
Linearization of non-linear systemsCertain approximations have to be made to make the
coefficients constants at for a limited interval. Ogata, S3-10, pp 124-126 of O4(7). .
Time-invariant linear systemsThe differential equation is linear and the coefficients are
constants and not functions of the independent variable, time.
Control System performancetime domain description output response to control
inputs: As referred to earlier, KuoSection 4, pp 134- 160. Ex 4-4, pp151-154, explains
spring-mass model. The displacement as a function of time is given.
Analysis without referring to Laplace Transforms is given in OgataEx 3-3, pp 85-86 of
O4(7). Here it is solved in state-space model. In the class it was solved as a solution of the
second order differential equation. All of these are examples of time domain description,where system variables are obtained as functions of time, when acted on by an external force.
The external force may be impulse, step or ramp (or any other function).
Characteristic parameters, relation to system parametersexplained in the examples referred
to aboveSee the response curve given on page 29 of the first set of notes given by Prof.
G.V.S.S. Sastryovershoot, steady state error, time constant, rise time, tmax etc.
Also, see S5-3, Sub-section Definitions of transient response specifications, pp 241-243 of
O4(7).
Indicial function:
-
7/27/2019 Control_Theory_Unit_1_31_October_2012.docx
21/23
The time response in lift and moment to step changes in angle of attack and pitch rate are
termed indicial functions. [NACA R 1188, by Murray Tobak].
Transient Response of a second order system: Ogata, Section 5-3, page 240 of O4(7).
Review Fourier transformsSee your old notes of Mathematics.
Laplace Transforms: Application to differential equations: [] () () [
]
() ()()
[
] () ()() , where, ()
()
See tables in Ogata or any other text book.
Laplace Transform: Ogata, S 2-3, pp 25-30 of O4(7).
Transfer function: S3-2, S3-3, page 67 and page 72 of O4(7).
Terminology is given clearly by Kuo, S3-3-1, page 85
GH is loop transfer function. Ogata and many others call it Open-loop transfer function
OLTF
M is used only by some authors. is CLTFclosed loop transfer function.Read Kuo, S3-10-1, 3-10-2, 3-10-3, pp 102-105 to arrive at state and output equations
mentioned in Unit VI.
Kuo - Section 3-11 for Digital system of Unit VIII.
Poles and zeros: Ogata, S2-2, page 24 of O4(7). Rigorous definition is given in the text.
[Hint: Roots of the numerator equated to zero are zeros, and roots of the denominator equated
to zero are poles, but definition in the text has to be used.]
Characteristic equation: The equation 1+GH =0 is the characteristic equation of a closed
loop control system with negative feedback.
In the state-space system, | | is the characteristic polynomial of G(s). See Ogata, S3-4, at theend of the Sub-section Correlation between transfer function and state-space equations, page 87 of
O4(7).
Kuo, S3-2-2, page 80: The characteristic equation of a linear system is defined as the equation
obtained by setting the denominator polynomial of the transfer function to zero.
Frequency and damping ratio of dominant poles: The lowest frequency pole is called
the dominant pole because it dominates the effect of all of the higher frequency poles [from
Wikipedia]
Relation of transfer function to impulse response: I guess this means system response for
impulse input.
Measures of Performance (MOP): measures derived from the dimensional parameters (both
-
7/27/2019 Control_Theory_Unit_1_31_October_2012.docx
22/23
physical and structural) and measure attributes of system behavior. MOPs quantify the set of
selected parameters. Examples include sensor detection probability, sensor probability of
false alarm, and probability of correct identification.
Measures of Effectiveness (MOE): measure of how a system performs its functions within itsenvironment. An MOE is generally an aggregation of MOPs. Examples include
survivability, probability of raid annihilation, and weapon system effectiveness.
[Download from InternetEstablishing System Measures of Effectiveness by John M.
Green.]
Partial Fraction decomposition of transfer function: Ogata, S2-5, pp 44-45 of O4(7).
Frequency domain description:
Ogata, S8-1, SubsectionObtaining steady state output to sinusoidal inputs [pp 505-506 of
O4(7)]:
Magnitude of G(j) is given as amplitude ratio, and phase of G(j) is defined as the phase
shift of the output sinusoid with respect to the input sinusoid. Please note this is not G(s), but
the specific case, where the real part is zero. Some call this simply angle of G(j).
Polar plotA plot of the magnitude versus phase in the polar coordinates, as varies from
zero to infinity. Ogata, S8-4, pp 535-538 of O4(7).
Bode plotA plot of the magnitude in decibels |()| versus in semi-logcoordinates. Bode diagrams are explained in Ogata, S8-2, pp 509-519 of O4(7). The Generalprocedure for plotting Bode diagrams is given at the end of the section, page 519 of O4(7).
[Bodepronounced Bodee, Boday (and as per internet, Bodah, probably in his mother
tongue.]
The polar plot is often called Nyquist Plot.
Polar plot is for any G. Nyquist plot is for GH, [loop transfer function or OLTF]
Frequency Transfer function: I suspect it refers to G(j)
Corner frequencies, resonant frequencies, peak gainPlease study Bode plots.
Resonant frequency is the frequency at which the peak resonance M, (Mr),
occurs. [Kuo, S9-1-2, p 544. Ogata, S8-2, page 519 of O4(7)] Some books use Mp as the
symbol.
The resonant frequency is the frequency at which the magnitude ofM(j) is the highest.
In general the Mrshould be between 1.1 and 1.5.
Characteristics of a system are stability, bandwidth, overall gain, disturbance and
sensitivity.
-
7/27/2019 Control_Theory_Unit_1_31_October_2012.docx
23/23
Bandwidth: Bandwidth BW is the frequency at which |()| drops to 70.7 percent or 3 dBdown from its zero-frequency value. {Kuo}
In general, the bandwidth of a control system gives an indication of the transient response
properties in the time domain. [See Kuo, p544, Ogata, S8-9, pp 584-585 of O4(7).]
The frequency range , in which the magnitude of the closed loop does not dropminus3dB is called the bandwidth of the system. {Ogata}. The bandwidth indicates thefrequency where the gain starts to fall off from its low-frequency value. Thus, the bandwidth
indicates how well the system will track an input sinusoid. The rise time and the bandwidth
are inversely proportional to each other.
Another definition: BW is that range of frequencies of the input over which the system will
respond satisfactorily.
Second order system is dealt with in Ogata S 5-3, pp 236-245 of O4(7).
First order system is given in Ogata, S5-2, pp 233-236 of O4(7).
End of Part 4.
-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.--.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.--.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.--.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-..-.-.-.-.-.-.--.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-
References:-
1. YYechout, Morris, Bossert and Hallgren, Introduction to Aircraft Flight Mechanics:
Performance, Static Stability, Dynamic Stability, and Classical Feedback Control, 2003.
2. S&LStevens & Lewis, Aircraft Control and Simulation, 2003.
3. O3Ogata, Modern Control Engineering, Fourth Edition, Second Impression, 2000.
4. O4(5) Ogata, Modern Control Engineering, Fourth Edition, Second Impression, 2005.
5. O4(7) Ogata, Modern Control Engineering, Fourth Edition, Second Impression, 2007.
6. NNelson, Flight Stability and Automatic Control, 2011.
7. KuoB.C. Kuo, Automatic Control Systems, 2003.