Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
description
Transcript of Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 1/95
!"# %&'(#'() &* ("+) ,&%-.#'( /0# 10&(#%(#, 23 4565 )(/(# (0/,# )#%0#( 7/8)9 *#,#0/7 %&130+:"( /', 1/(#'( 7/8) /', +'(#0'/;&'/7 %&130+:"( /', 1/(#'( 7/8)5
!"# %&'(#'() &* ("+) ,&%-.#'( /0# )-2<#%( (& 10&(#%;&' -',#0 4565 =/(#'( >117+%/;&') ?&5 @ABCDE9CCAF D@BDCG9H@GF D@BHAI9JHCF D@BHKK9JKDF D@BKAH9DA@F
D@BKE@9IEIF D@BKEE9GDGF D@BKEG9HI@F D@BKEH9GCGF D@BKDK9@KEF D@BKCE9EEIF D@BKHH9ACAF D@B KKI9EE@F D@BKKE9JCDF D@BKKE9C@GF D@BKKE9CI@F DIBJJ@9@ICF
@EBIKH9CIAF DIBJ@G9EA@F DIBJ@K9KHC /', L'(#0'/;&'/7 =M! =/(#'( >117+%/;&' ?&5 =M! 46@ABGI@GK5 >'&'&)9 N3'/.+% >'&'3.+(39 M&!9
N3'/.+% N#OL,#';P#09 NNLN /', N& ?&( Q#.#.2#0 /0# (0/,#./0R) &* >'&'&) L'%5
Controlled Data Fusion andAnti-Discrimination Benefits of
Anonos Dynamic Anonymity!""!!!!" !""!"""! !""!"""" "!"""! !""!"""" !"""!!""
July 2014
S@
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 2/95
I T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
!"#"#$ &'"()*+ !"#"')*,' %/' "#71 (&U
• -)./#01 12*$3"4 56$*"1$$ )#718$ 23 +.10&V+': 10&P() B 1-01&)# 8"+7# )+.-7(/'#&-)73
#'"/'%+': 10+V/%3 /', 1#0)&'/7+W/;&' +#).(/17 ,# &# 9#, :/(+; (../#(+<1$
*"+#"$*$,1", =*,< +6//1", 56$*"1$$ )#718$F
• &18*01/ *))17*(,1 51"1>,$ =*,<#6, /1?6*/*"4 )#7*>+(3#"$ (& #X+);': 2-)+'#)) /',
(#%"'&7&:3 10/%;%#) =<*81 $1/0*"4 ($ ( .8(@#/) A#/ A6,6/1 *""#0(3#"F
• B#6",1/ "14(301 *).8*+(3#"$ #A 1"<("+17 5*4 7(,( /1C*71"3>+(3#" +(.(5*8*31$
)+'%# #)(/27+)".#'( &* ("# Y!M =0+V/%3 Y0/.#8&0R +' IJ@IF
• D1+#"+*81 (..(/1", ,1"$*#"$ 2#(8##' ("# Y!M =0+V/%3 Y0/.#8&0R /', ("# 0#%#'(
Z"+(# [&-)# =&,#)(/ /', =M>6! 0#1&0()F
• !77/1$$ 6"("$=1/17 ?61$3#"$ +' ("# Z"+(# [&-)# =&,#)(/ /', =M>6! 0#1&0()F
•
D1+#"+*81 7*E1/1"+1$ 51,=11" FGHG ("7 IF ./*0(+' ./(+3+1$ /', )(0#':("#' 4565 \ ]46/*# [/02&0 10&:0/.5
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 3/95
A T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
$%&'( )* +),-(,-.
/%0123)4,5 ), 6)4,5(3 )* 7,),). 8,09 :%2(
89
8,-3)540;), -) 7,),). <=,%>?0 7,),=>?-=@<(A?5(,;B0%;), C?-D)4- <(AE%'4%;), F
889 7 +),-3)''(5 <%-% 64.?), :'%= ?, 6?E( 70-. G
8889 HE(3E?(C )* 7,),). <=,%>?0 7,),=>?-= "I
8J9 HE(3E?(C )* 7,),). +?30'( )* $34.- K+)$L MIJ9 7,),). <=,%>?0 7,),=>?-= E.9 N-%;0 7,),=>?-= OM
7PP(,5?Q 7 R 8>P3)E(5 :43P).( %,5 :(3.),%'?S%;), FT
7PP(,5?Q / R 7PP'?0%;),. )* <=,%>?0 7,),=>?-= GU
7PP(,5?Q + R /%0123)4,5 ), 7,),). 6)4,5(3. II
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 4/95
E T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
-G -",/#76+3#" ,# !"#"#$ &'"()*+ !"#"')*,'J
&1C*71"3>+(3#" =*,<#6, &1C0(86(3#"
Q/("#0 ("/' <-)( *&%-)+': &' 10&V+,+': )(/;% /'&'3.+(3 *&0 / ,/(/
)-2<#%( /) / 8"&7#9 >'&'&) &'"()*+ !"#"')*,' +) ,#)+:'#, (&
10&V+,# ,3'/.+% /'&'3.+(3 *&0 ,+)%0#(#U
•
!+30*31$
• F$1$ /',
• B#).#"1",$ &* ,/(/
!"#0#23 /77#V+/;': ,+)%0+.+'/;&' &* ,/(/ )-2<#%() /', #'/27+':%&'(0&77#, ,/(/ *-)+&' ("0&-:" 1&)+;V# 2+: ,/(/ /'/73;%)5
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 5/95
G T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
7+$ 8@V) 7,),=>?-=
7+$ 88@N-%;0 7,),=>?-=
7+$ 888@N03%>&'(5 7,),=>?-=
7+$ 8J@7,),). <=,%>?0 7,),=>?-=
7+$ JW%32( N0%'( <=,%>?0 7,),=>?-= C?-D 64.?),
--G ! B#",/#8817 &(,( K6$*#" L8(' *" K*01 !+,$
M&'(0&77#, N/(/ Y-)+&' =7/3 \ =/:# @ &* @A
&-HBM!-NID " #$%& '()*+, %& -./ %-/0-101 *& *- 02*3()0 .4 /$0 5-.-.& %-60-7.- *& * 8$.)0 " %/ %& %-/0-101 *& * &%3()0
02*3()0 .4 1%90:0-;0& <0/800- -.-=02%&/0-/> &/*7;> *-1 &;:*3<)01 *-.-+3%/+> .- /$0 .-0 $*-1? *-1 @+-*3%; 5-.-+3%/+A8%/$ 5-.-.&B> *-1 /$0 <0-0C/& .4 )*:D0 &;*)0 @+-*3%; 5-.-+3%/+ 8%/$ 4E&%.-> .- /$0 ./$0: $*-1> 8%/$ /$0 *11%7.- .4
.F%-0 %-4.:3*7.- <0%-D %-(E/ %-/. * &+&/03G H$%)0 5-.-.& ;.E)1 <0 %3()030-/01 %- * &%3%)*: 3*--0:> /$%& '()*+, .-)+
&$.8& * (*:7*) *(()%;*7.- .4 @+-*3%; 5-.-+3%/+G
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 6/95
D T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
• I3*D%-0 * ;*: 1:%60& /$:.ED$ /$:00 /:*J; )%D$/&> 0*;$
.4 8$%;$ $*& *- *E/.3*7; )%;0-&0 ()*/0 :0*1%-D A5KLMB
;*30:*G #$0 ;*: /$0- /E:-& * ;.:-0: *-1 (*:N& %- *D*:*D0 ).;*/01 */ OPQ H$0:0 R/:00/G
• I- /$%& ()*+> /$0 403*)0 1:%60: :0(:0&0-/& * 1*/* &E<S0;/
*-1 /$0 (.)%;0 .J;0: :0(:0&0-/& * ;.:(.:*/0 T
D.60:-30-/*) *E/$.:%/+ CDE:0G
!"# *&77&8+': ^17/3_ 0#10#)#'() / "31&("#;%/79 1)#-,& 0#/7O8&07,
1/0/77#7 &* "&8 >'&'&) N3'/.+% >'&'3.+(3 +) -'+`-# %&.1/0#, (& &("#0
/'&'3.+W/;&' 10/%;%#) /', "&8 +( )-11&0() +#",/#8817 7(,( A6$*#"a5
a !"# b/3 IJ@E 4565 =0#)+,#'(c) M&-'%+7 &* >,V+)&0) &' 6%+#'%# /', !#%"'&7&:3 d=M>6!e 0#1&0( #';(7#, U%D @*/* *-1 L:%6*;+V 5
#0;$-.).D%;*) L0:&(0;760 @*/* )(/(#) ("/( ^,/(/ *-)+&' &%%-0) 8"#' ,/(/ *0&. ,+f#0#'( )&-0%#) /0# 20&-:"( +'(& %&'(/%( /', '#8 */%()
#.#0:#5_ 6## "g1UBB88858"+(#"&-)#5:&VB)+(#)B,#*/-7(BP7#)B.+%0&)+(#)B&)(1B=M>6!B1%/)(h2+:h,/(/h/',h10+V/%3hOh./3hIJ@E51,*
M&'(0&77#, N/(/ Y-)+&' =7/3 \ =/:# I &* @A
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 7/95
C T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
7+8ATFX
7+8ATFX
7+8ATFX7+8ATFXF"G
YD(3( N-9
7+$ 8@
V) 7,),=>?-=
Z" N=.-(> [,)C.@$4(.5%= \ O@"F :]
W?0(,.( P'%-( 7+8ATFX ?.
3(2?.-(3(5 -) ^9 ^%=
ZM N=.-(> [,)C.@
$4(.5%= \ O@"X :]
W?0(,.( P'%-( 7+8ATFX ?.
3(2?.-(3(5 -) ^9 ^%=
ZO N=.-(> [,)C.@
$4(.5%= \ O@M! :]
W?0(,.( P'%-( 7+8ATFX ?.
3(2?.-(3(5 -) ^9 ^%=
ZF N=.-(> [,)C.@
<]J 3(0)35. .D)C ^9 ^%=
3(.?5(,0( ?. ')0%-(5 %-
F"G YD(3( N-3((-
M&'(0&77#, N/(/ Y-)+&' =7/3 \ =/:# A &* @A
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 8/95H T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
7+$ 8 +43-%?, A 9# (O1)., (, ("#"')*,' +) /'/7&:&-) (& ("# )-2<#%( %/0 "/V+': +() &8' 7+%#')# 17/(#)&' )-%" ("/( ("# +,#';(3 &* ("# %/09 ("# %/0c) ,0+V#0 /', ("# /,,0#)) &* ("# 0#)+,#'%# &* ("# ,0+V#0 /0#
R'&8' /) )&&' /) +( ,0+V#) ("0- ("# P0)( (0/i% 7+:"( 8+(" >j=Q %/1/2+7+;#)F ("# ;.# ("/( ("# %/0 :&#)
("0&-:" #/%" &* ("# ("0## (0/i% 7+:"() 8&-7, /7)& 2# 0#%&0,#,5
M&'(0&77#, N/(/ Y-)+&' =7/3 \ =/:# E &* @A
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 9/95K T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
_$`AUXM
_$`AUXM
_$`AUXM _$`AUXMF"G
YD(3( N-9
7+$ 88@
N-%;0 7,),=>?-=
Z" N=.-(> [,)C.@$4(.5%= \ O@"F :]
W?0(,.( P'%-( _$`AUXM
a,3(2?.-(3(5
ZM N=.-(> [,)C.@$4(.5%= \ O@"X :]
W?0(,.( P'%-( _$`AUXM
a,3(2?.-(3(5
ZO N=.-(> [,)C.@$4(.5%= \ O@M! :]
W?0(,.( P'%-( _$`AUXM
a,3(2?.-(3(59 Y?-D O
P)?,-. )* -3?%,24'%;),
5(-(0-(5b P)'?0( %3(
%'(3-(5 -) '))1 *)3 0%3
C?-D 4,3(2?.-(3(5 '?0(,.(
P'%-( _$`AUXM
ZF cQ-3?,.?0 cE?5(,0(@
$D( P)'?0( )d0(3 ,)-(. -D%- % 0%3 C?-D '?0(,.( P'%-( _$`AUXM P%31. ?, %
2%3%2( ')0%-(5 %- F"G YD(3( N-3((-e P3)P(3-= 3(0)35. .D)C D)4.( ?.
-D( 3(.?5(,0( )* ^9 ^%=
8, %, %f(>P--) 3(>%?,
%,),=>)4.b
-D( 53?E(3 P4-.
4,3(2?.-(3(5
g54>>=h
'?0(,.( P'%-(.
), D(3 0%3
M&'(0&77#, N/(/ Y-)+&' =7/3 \ =/:# G &* @A
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 10/95@J T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
#1 Tuesday / 3:14 PM
License plate
XTQ-672 is
unregistered
#2 Tuesday / 3:17 PM
License plate
XTQ-672 is
unregistered
#3 Tuesday / 3:20 PM
License plate
XTQ-672 is
unregistered
4
C
a
r
w
i
t
h
X
T
Q
-
6
7
2
u
n
r
e
g
i
s
t
e
r
e
d
p
l
a
t
e
s
p
a
r
k
e
d
a
t
r
e
s
i
d
e
n
c
e
l
o
c
a
t
e
d
a
t
4
1
5
Where
S
t
r
e
e
t
b
e
l
o
n
g
i
ng to J.
J
a
y
7+$ 88 +43-%?, \ H,(3+ ("#"')*,' +) /'/7&:&-) (& 1-k': l,-..3c 7+%#')# 17/(#) &' ("# )-2<#%( %/05 Z"+7#
("# +,#';(3 &* ("# %/0 8&-7, '&( 2# R'&8' /( ("# ;.# +( ,0&V# ("0- ("# P0)( d)#%&', /', ("+0,e (0/i% 7+:"( +(
8&-7, 2# R'&8' ("/( ("# )/.# %/0 8#'( ("0&-:" #/%" &* ("# ("0## (0/i% 7+:"() /', ("# ;.# +( ,0&V# ("0-
#/%" 7+:"( 8&-7, /7)& 2# 0#%&0,#,5 >( 7#/)( /) #/073 /) IJJJ9 #X1#0() 7+R# j/(/'3/ 68##'#39 %-00#'( M"+#*
!#%"'&7&:+)( /( ("# 4565 Y#,#0/7 !0/,# M&..+))+&'9 '&(#, +' "#0 M/0'#:+# b#77&' 4'+V#0)+(3 1/1#0 #';(7#,
R%3()0 @03.D:*($%;& WX0- I10-74+ L0.()0 Y-%ZE0)+ ("# 8#/R'#)) &* )(/;% +,#';P#0) (& 10&V+,# #f#%;V#
/'&'3.+(35 b&0# 0#%#'(739 m/.#) !-0&8 '&(#, +' "+) IJ@A 2&&R #';(7#, #$0 @*%)+ [.EV \.8 /$0 ]08
5160:7&%-D I-1E&/:+ I& @0C-%-D [.E: I10-7/+ *-1 [.E: H.:/$ ("/( ("+) +) 1/0;%-7/073 ("# %/)# ^8"#' P0.)
+'(#0.+g#'(73 /,, &n+'# +'*&0./;&' (& ("# &'7+'# ,/(/ /', ("#' )+.173 )(0+1 ("# '/.# /', /,,0#)) (&
./R# +( l/'&'3.&-)5c5_
M&'(0&77#, N/(/ Y-)+&' =7/3 \ =/:# D &* @A
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 11/95@@ T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
:W]AUFT
_7FAX"$
7iVAH8<TjjAX"MF"G
YD(3( N-9
7+$ 888@
N03%>&'(5 7,),=>?-=
Z" N=.-(> [,)C.@$4(.5%= \ O@"F :]
W?0(,.( P'%-( :W]AUFT
a,3(2?.-(3(5
ZM N=.-(> [,)C.@$4(.5%= \ O@"X :]
W?0(,.( P'%-( _7FAX"$
a,3(2?.-(3(5
ZO N=.-(> [,)C.@
$4(.5%= \ O@M! :]
W?0(,.( P'%-( TjjAX"M
a,3(2?.-(3(59
ZF cQ-3?,.?0 cE?5(,0(@
YD?'( -D( P)'?0( )d0(3 >%= ,)-( -D%- % 0%3 C?-D '?0(,.( P'%-( 7iVAH8< P%31. ?,
% 2%3%2( ')0%-(5 %- F"G YD(3( N-3((-b -D(3( ?. ,) 3(%.), -) 0D(01 P3)P(3-=
3(0)35. .?,0( ,) %'(3- C%. 3%?.(59
8, %, %f(>P- -)
3(>%?,
%,),=>)4.b -D(
53?E(3 P4-. *)43
5?k(3(,-
4,3(2?.-(3(5
g54>>=h '?0(,.(
P'%-(. ), D(3
0%3b
.433(P;;)4.'=
.C?-0D?,2 -D(>
&(*)3( (%0D
'?2D-
%,5 &(*)3(P%31?,2
M&'(0&77#, N/(/ Y-)+&' =7/3 \ =/:# C &* @A
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 12/95@I T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
7+$ 888 +43-%?, \ ]f&0() /( ^$+/()5817 ("#"')*,' _ 7+R# %V,/WW7#5%&.9 0#,'&+)#5&0:B/,'/-)#/. /',
(&010&<#%(5&0: 10&V+,# / 7#V#7 &* /'&'3.+(3 *&0 ,/(/ )-2<#%()9 2-( /( ("# %&)( &* 7&)) &* 1#0)&'/7+W#,
&f#0+':) ./,# 1&))+27# 23 &':&+': /,V/'%#) +' (#%"'&7&:3 d#5:59 ("# L'(#0'#( &* !"+':) dL&!e9 1#0)&'/7+W#,
.#,+%+'#9 #(%5e /', 1&(#';/7 7&)) &* )&%+/7 /%%&-'(/2+7+(35
Y&0 #X/.17#9 / m-'# @J9 IJ@E 1&)( &' *0##,&.O(&O;'R#05%&. "+:"7+:"(#, ("# 0+)# &* / 1&7+;%/7 /', #("+%/7
("#&03 &* &2*-)%/;&' /) ^o/ )(0/(#:3 *&0 +',+V+,-/7)9 :0&-1) &0 %&..-'+;#) (& "+,#F (& 10&(#%(("#.)#7V#)F (& 10&(#)( &0 #'/%( %+V+7 ,+)&2#,+#'%#9 #)1#%+/773 +' ("# %&'(#X( &* .&'+(&0+':9 /::0#:/(#,
/'/73)+)9 /', 10&P7+':o(& ./R# 7+*# / 7+g7# 2+( "/0,#0 *&0 ("# 1&8#0) ("/( 2# /', (& 10&(#)( ("# )-0V#+77/'%#
0#:+.#555/',o(& )+:'/7 (& ("#+0 1##0) ("/( ("#3 /0# %&')%+#';&-) %+;W#') 8"& 8+77 '&( /%%#1( ("# )(/(-)
`-&5_
#1
Tuesday/3:14 PM
License plate
PLM-649 is
unregistered
4
T
u
e
s
d
a
y
L
i
c
e
n
s
e
P
l
a
t
e
A
H
N
-
O
I
D
#3 Tuesday/3:20 PM
License plate
9ZZ-712 is
unregistered
#2 Tuesday/3:17 PM
License plate
XA4-71T is
unregistered
M&'(0&77#, N/(/ Y-)+&' =7/3 \ =/:# H &* @A
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 13/95@A T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
:W]AUFT
_7FAX"$
7iVAH8<TjjAX"MF"G
YD(3( N-9
7+$ 8J@
7,),). <=,%>?0 7,),=>?-=
Z" N=.-(> [,)C.@$4(.5%= \ O@"F :]
W?0(,.( P'%-( :W]AUFT
a,3(2?.-(3(5
ZM N=.-(> [,)C.@$4(.5%= \ O@"X :]
W?0(,.( P'%-( _7FAX"$
a,3(2?.-(3(5
ZO N=.-(> [,)C.@
$4(.5%= \ O@M! :]
W?0(,.( P'%-( TjjAX"M
a,3(2?.-(3(59
$) P3)E?5(
0),-3)''(5
<=,%>?0
7,),=>?-=b %
-34.-(5 P%3-= \
P3)Q= P'%0(.
*)43 5?k(3(,-
g54>>=h '?0(,.(
P'%-(. ), -D(
53?E(3h. 0%3b
.C?-0D?,2 -D(>
&(*)3( (%0D '?2D-
%,5 &(*)3(
P%31?,29
Y?-D?, -D( +)$b
-D( 5%-(. %,5
;>(. *)3 (%0D
4.( )* %
g54>>=h?5(,;B(3 %3(
,)-(5 *)3 4.(
%4-D)3?S(5 &=
-D( 5%-% .4&l(0-9
ZF cQ-3?,.?0 cE?5(,0(@
YD?'( -D( P)'?0( )d0(3 >%= ,)-( -D%- % 0%3 C?-D '?0(,.( P'%-( 7iVAH8< P%31.
?, % 2%3%2( ')0%-(5 %- F"G YD(3( N-3((-b -D(3( ?. ,) 3(%.), -) 0D(01 P3)P(3-=
3(0)35. .?,0( ,) %'(3- C%. 3%?.(59
M&'(0&77#, N/(/ Y-)+&' =7/3 \ =/:# K &* @A
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 14/95
@E T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
7+$ 8J +43-%?, K:%3- "L \ p-()+,# ("# M&! 8+(" &'"()*+ !"#"')*,' 9 ("# +,#';(3 &* ("# %/0 +) '&(
R'&8' /( ("# ;.# +( ,0+V#) ("0&-:" /'3 (0/i% 7+:"(F +( +) '&( R'&8' ("/( ("# )/.# %/0 8#'( ("0&-:" ("#
("0## 7+:"()F /', 8"+7# ("# ;.#) ("/( / )##.+':73 ,+f#0#'( %/0 ,0&V# ("0- #/%" 7+:"( 8&-7, 2# 0#%&0,#,9
("#)# ,+f#0#'( ;.#) 8&-7, '&( 2# /))&%+/(#, 8+(" / )+':7# %/05 !"# -)# &* %"/':+': 7+%#')# 17/(#) "/)
("# 10/%;%/7 #f#%( &* ./R+': +( 7&&R 7+R# ("# /%( &* ,0+V+': ("0- #/%" (0/i% 7+:"( +) '&( /))&%+/(#, 8+("#/%" &("#0 &0 8+(" / )+':7# %/05 L' /,,+;&'9 +* )&.#&'# 8#0# (& '&(# ("/( ("# )-2<#%( %/0 ,0&V# +'(& ("#
:/0/:#9 ("#0# +) '& 8/3 (& %&00#7/(# ("# &8'#0 &* ("# 10+V/(# 0#)+,#'%# (& /'3 &* ("# &("#0 &2)#0V#,
%/0) B 7+%#')# 17/(#) )+'%# ("#3 8&-7, #/%" "/V# "/, / -'+`-# +,#';*3+': 7+%#')# 17/(# /))&%+/(#, 8+("
("#.5
H4-.?5( +)$
#1 Tuesday/3:14 PM
License plate
PLM-649 is
unregistered
4
T
u
e
s
d
a
y
L
i
c
e
n
s
e
P
l
a
t
e
A
H
N
-
O
I
D
#3
Tuesday/3:20 PM
License plate
9ZZ-712 is
unregistered
#2 Tuesday/3:17 PM
License plate
XA4-71T is
unregistered
M&'(0&77#, N/(/ Y-)+&' =7/3 \ =/:# @J &* @A
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 15/95
@G T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
7+$ 8J +43-%?, K:%3- ML \ L')+,# ("# M&! 8+(" &'"()*+ !"#"')*,' > %&'(0&77#, ,/(/ *-)+&' +) ./,#
1&))+27# 23 10&V+,+': /'&'3.+(3 *&0 &(,(9 -71"3,' d&* N/(/ 6-2<#%( B M&'(0&77#0e /', B#",12, d#5:59
;.#9 17/%#9 1-01&)#e 23 &2*-)%/;': %&''#%;&') 2#(8##' /', /.&': ("# *&0#:&+':5 !"# M&! 0#(/+')
R'&87#,:# &* 8"/( ,3'/.+%/773 %"/':+': +,#';*3+': 7+%#')# 17/(#) 8#0# /))&%+/(#, 8+(" ("# )-2<#%( %/0
/( #/%" ;.#9 17/%# /', 1-01&)#5 !"+) +'*&0./;&' 8&-7, 2# /V/+7/27# *&0 -)#) /110&V#, 23 ("# -)#0 /',
"#0 (0-)(#, 1/0(3 B 10&X39 8"+%" %&-7, +'%7-,# /%%#)) (& +'*&0./;&' 23 /-("&0+(3 P:-0#) -',#0
#)(/27+)"#, 7#:/7 10/%;%#) ("/( +'%7-,# /,#`-/(# )/*#:-/0,) (& 10&(#%( ("# 0+:"() &* ("# ,/(/ )-2<#%(5
#2 Tuesday/3:17 PM
License plate
XA4-71T
#1 Tuesday/3:14 PM
License plate
PLM-649
#3
Tuesday/3:20 PM
License plate
9ZZ-712
4
T
u
e
s
d
a
y
L
i
c
e
n
s
e
P
l
a
t
e
A
H
N
-
O
I
D
J. J
a
y
4
1
5
Where
S
t
r
e
e
t
8,.?5( +)$
M&'(0&77#, N/(/ Y-)+&' =7/3 \ =/:# @@ &* @A
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 16/95
@D T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
7+$ J@
W%32( N0%'( <=,%>?0
7,),=>?-= \ 64.?),
M&'(0&77#, N/(/ Y-)+&' =7/3 \ =/:# @I &* @A
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 17/95
@C T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
7+$ J +43-%?, \ 8+(" &'"()*+ !"#"')*,' 9 (8& 10+'%+17# 2#'#P() /0+)# 8+(" +'%0#/)#, )%/7#U
• I"<("+17 ("#"')*,' ,-# (& :0#/(#0 '-.2#0) &* ,/(/ B )-2<#%() B /%;&')F /',
•
-)./#017 #..#/,6"*31$ *&0 ,/(/ /'/73;%) /', %&'(0&77#, ,/(/ *-)+&'5
>'&'&) &'"()*+ !"#"')*,' #'/27#) ,/(/ )-2<#%() (& 2#'#P( *0&. &':&+': (#%"'&7&:+%/7
/,V/'%#.#'() d#5:59 ("# L'(#0'#( &* !"+':) dL&!e9 1#0)&'/7+W#, .#,+%+'#9 #(%5e 8+("&-( "/V+': (&
0#7+'`-+)" 10+V/%39 )#%-0+(3 &0 %&'(0&75 :<*$ *$ 7#"1 5'
P*Q ($$*4"*"4 6"*?61 7'"()*+(88' +<("4*"4 *71"3>1/$ ,# 7(,( R $65S1+,$ R (+3#"$T
P**Q /1,(*"*"4 *"A#/)(3#" /14(/7*"4 ($$#+*(3#" #A *71"3>1/$ =*,< 7(,(R $65S1+,$ R (+3#"$T ("7
P***Q ./#0*7*"4 7(,( $65S1+,$ =*,< 71,1/)*"*$3+ +#",/#8 #01/ =<# <($ (++1$$ ,# R 6$1 #A
($$#+*(3#" *"A#/)(3#"5
N3'/.+% >'&'3.+(39 /) )-11&0(#, 23 ("# >'&'&) B*/+81 #A :/6$, PB#:Q9 #'/27#) +#",/#8817 7(,(
A6$*#" 23 10&V+,+': %&'(0&77#, /'&'3.+(3 *&0 &(,( T -71"3,' d&* N/(/ 6-2<#%( B M&'(0&77#0e /',
B#",12, d#5:59 ;.#9 1-01&)#9 17/%#e 5' #5A6$+(3"4 +#""1+3#"$ 51,=11" ("7 ()#"4 ,<1
A#/14#*"4T #'/27+': ("#U
•
4',&+': &0 0#V#0)/7 &* #+("#0 0+:"() :0/'(#, &0 /%%#)) (& ,/(/F /',
• Q#<-V#'/;&' &* ,/(/ (& )-11&0( /,,+;&'/7 )#%&',/03 -)#) 8+("&-( V+&7/;': 10&.+)#) (&
,/(/ )-2<#%()5
M&'(0&77#, N/(/ Y-)+&' =7/3 \ =/:# @A &* @A
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 18/95
@H T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
---G U01/0*1= #A !"#"#$ &'"()*+ !"#"')*,'
79 N?>P'( +),0(P-
VG W()1 B<("41/ $D%- :%=. *)3 8-.('*
+9 ]?,?>%' +D%,2(. -) cQ?.;,2 :3%0;0(.
<9 +),.?.-(,- C?-D W(2?.'%;E( \ m(24'%-)3= `)%'.
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 19/95
@K T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
79 N?>P'( +),0(P-
!8& 7&':O)(/',+': 10+'%+17#) *&0 )-%%#))*-7 =0+V/%3 ]'"/'%+': !#%"'&7&:+#) 10&V+,#
("/(U
•
!"# ,#)+:' &* / )3)(#. )"&-7, 2# )+.17# /', '&( 0#`-+0# )#%0#%3F %&.10&.+)#&* / )3)(#. )"&-7, .+'+.+W# +'%&'V#'+#'%# (& 1/0;%+1/'()5
d[(301D)k.h :3?,0?P'( R "IIOe
•
L( )"&-7, 2# /))-.#, ("/( q("# #'#.3 R'&8) ("# )3)(#.5_
dND%,,),h. ]%Q?> R "TF!.e
b&0# 0#%#'(739 +'(#0'/;&'/7 )#%-0+(3 #X1#0( r0-%# 6%"'#+#0 "/) #.1"/)+W#, ("# '##, *&0=0+V/%3 ]'"/'%+': !#%"'&7&:+#) (& ^*/+7 8#77_ 8"#' ("#3 */+7 V#0)-) *&%-)+': &'73 &'
10#V#';': ./7+%+&-) +'%-0)+&')5
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 20/95
IJ T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
/9 W()1 B<("41/ $D%- :%=. *)3 8-.('*
X1 518*101 &'"()*+ !"#"')*,' +(" ,6/" +6//1", 56$*"1$$ )#718$ #" ,<1*/ <1(7$ 5' 1"(58*"4
*)./#017 ./#>,$ R .6/.#$1 A#/ +#).("*1$ =<*81 $*)68,("1#6$8' 1"<("+*"4 ./*0(+' ("7
.1/$#"(8*Y(3#"G
+)>P%,?(.U L' ("# %&'(#X( &* #7#%(0&'+% %&..#0%# B /,V#0;)+':9 ("# 0#/)&' N3'/.+% >'&'3.+(3 8&0R) +) ("/(
%&.1/'+#) ,& '&( /%(-/773 %/0# 8$. 3&- /0#F ("#3 %/0# 8$*/ 3&- /0# ? $.8 3&- 2#"/V#F /', 8$0- 3&- 2#"/V#
("/( 8/35 !"# .&0# /%%-0/(# ("#+0 (/0:#;': +) /', ("# 7#)) 8/)(#*-79 ("# .&0# 7+R#73 /' /'&'3.&-) %&')-.#0
8+77 0#)1&', */V&0/273 (& / 1#0)&'/7+W#, &f#0+':5 N3'/.+% >'&'3.+(3 ("-) &2V+/(#) ("# '##, *&0 %&.1/'+#) (&
*&77&8 ,/(/ )-2<#%() /0&-', ("# ,+:+(/7 8&07, (03+': (& 1#0)-/,# ("#. (& 2-3 10&,-%() B )#0V+%#) ("/( ("#3 ./3
'&( 0#/773 '##, &0 8/'(5 N3'/.+% >'&'3.+(3 /77&8) *&0 .&0# 10&P(/27# ^./(%"+':_ &* )#77#0) /', +'(#0#)(#,%-)(&.#0)5
M-00#'(739 ("# 2#)( %&.1/'+#) %/' ,& +) (& ^)#:.#'(_ 1&(#';/7 %-)(&.#0) 23 -)+': ,#.&:0/1"+%) /', )(/;);%)
2-( ("#3 "/V# '& +,#/ &* ("# /%(-/7 +'(#0#)( &* )#:.#'( .#.2#0)5 N3'/.+% >'&'3.+(3 +.10&V#) -1&'
:#'#0/7+W#, ,#.&:0/1"+%) /', )(/;);%) 23 10&V+,+': +',+V+,-/7+W#, #X10#))+&') B7#V#7) &* #X10#))+&' &* +'(#0#)(
*0&. .#.2#0) &* )#:.#'() 8"& /0# <*4<8' ?6(8*>17 ./#$.1+,$5
L' ("# %&'(#X( &* "#/7("%/0#9 N3'/.+% >'&'3.+(3 ./R#) +( 1&))+27# *&0 +'*&0./;&' %&.+': *0&. ,+)1/0/(#
%7+'+%)9 1"3)+%+/' &i%#)9 "&)1+(/7) /', #X&:#'&-) )&-0%#) (& 2# .#/'+':*-773 %&.2+'#, ("#0#23 #'/27+': ("#
2#)( 1&))+27# "#/7("%/0# /', &-(%&.#)5 r#)( &* /779 +( %/' ,& ("+) +' / .&0# 10+V/(# /', )#%-0# ./''#0 (&
*/%+7+(/(# 2#g#0 0#)#/0%" /', /,, (& ("# .&.#'(-. *&0 1#0)&'/7+W#, .#,+%+'#5
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 21/95
I@ T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
<%-% N4&l(0-.@ !"# -)# &* 2+: ,/(/ .+'+': d+'%7-,+': 2&0'O,+:+(/7 /', 2&0'O/'/7&: ,/(/ /', ("# 10&,-%() &*
,/(/ *-)+&' /', /'/73)+)e9 %&-17#, 8+(" )&%+/7 .#,+/ /', &("#0 1-0%"/)#, ,/(/9 "/) #X17&,#,5 s#(9 ("+)
./))+V#73 7/0:#0 V&7-.# &* /'/73W#, ,/(/ "/) */+7#, (& ,#7+V#0 &' +() *-77 10&.+)# &* +.10&V+': 1#&17#t) 7+V#)5
^.$- @G L.10&/*> /$0 &0-%.: H$%/0 \.E&0 *16%&0: *-1 ;$%04 *E/$.: .4 /$0 _*+ `aPO H$%/0
\.E&0 M0(.:/ 0-7/)01 U%D @*/*V R0%b%-D W((.:/E-%70&> L:0&0:6%-D c*)E0&> &*%1 %- *-
%-/0:6%08 /$*/ L:0&%10-/ W<*3* 8*& &E:(:%&01 1E:%-D $%& :06%08 .4 /$0 ]GRG5Gd& *;76%70&
/$*/V
'e,<1 $()1 ,1+<"#8#4*1$ (/1 "#, #"8' 6$17 5' ,<1 *",188*41"+1 +#))6"*,'T 56, A(/
)#/1 5/#(78' *" ,<1 .658*+ ("7 ./*0(,1 $.<1/1$ 51+(6$1 ,<1/1 *$ $# )6+< +#881+3#"G,
]%= "b M!"F V(C n)31 $?>(. %3;0'( (,;-'(5 B(88 A#/ M*)*,$ #" X15 &(,( #A B6$,#)1/$
!"# *-',/.#'(/7 )&-0%#) &* ("# 10&27#. /0# +'/%%-0/(# /', +')-i%+#'(73 10#%+)# ,/(/5 L',+V+,-/7) ./3 2#
,#'+#, )#0V+%#)9 10&,-%() /', #X1#0+#'%#) 8"#' ,/(/ +) 80&':5 ]V#' 8&0)#9 8"#' %#0(/+' )##.+':73 2#'+:'
,/(/ +) +'/%%-0/(# /', ("#' %&.2+'#, 8+(" &("#0 ,/(/ d#V#' +* /%%-0/(#e )+:'+P%/'( "/0. %/' 2# ,&'# (&
+''&%#'( +',+V+,-/7) d#5:59 .+),+/:'&)+) &* 7+*#O("0#/(#'+': "#/7(" %&',+;&')9 */7)# /00#)(9 ,#'+/7 &*
.&0(:/:# &0 &("#0 %0#,+(e5 L'/%%-0/(# ,/(/ ("-) %/' "/V# / .#(/)(/)+W+': #f#%(9 1&(#';/773 1&+)&'+': :&&,
+'*&0./;&' /2&-( /' +',+V+,-/79 /',B&0 )3.1(&.)5
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 22/95
II T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
H$%)0 <%D 1*/* (:0&0-/& -08 ;$*))0-D0&> %/ *)&. (:0&0-/& %330-&0 .((.:/E-%70& /.
%3(:.60 )%60&> /$0 Y-%/01 R/*/0& %& (0:$*(& <0f0: &E%/01 /. )0*1 /$%& ;.-60:&*7.- /$*-
*-+ ./$0: -*7.- .- 0*:/$G U6/ *""#0(301 $.*/*,T ,1+<"#8#4*+(8 ;"#=C<#=T ("7 711.
+#))*,)1", ,# 0(861$ #A ./*0(+'T A(*/"1$$T "#"C7*$+/*)*"(3#"T ("7 $18AC
71,1/)*"(3#" =*88 <18. 6$ <(/"1$$ ,<1 51"1>,$ #A ,<1 5*4 7(,( /10#863#" ("7
1"+#6/(41 ,<1 A/11 Z#= #A *"A#/)(3#" =<*81 =#/;*"4 =*,< #6/ *",1/"(3#"(8
.(/,"1/$ ,# ./#,1+, .1/$#"(8 ./*0(+' G
]%= M!"F YD?-( i)4.( m(P)3- (,;-'(5 V*4 &(,(J H1*Y*"4 U..#/,6"*31$T L/1$1/0*"4 [(861$
L' ("# %&'(#X( &* #7#%(0&'+% %&..#0%# B /,V#0;)+':9 ,/(/ )-2<#%() &'73 8/'( (& )## :0)06*-/ &f#0+':)F
("# .&0# %::0)06*-/ &f#0+':) ("#3 0#%#+V#9 ("# )0&& )%N0)+ ("#3 /0# (& 2-3 )&.#("+': *0&. ("# %&.1/'3
./R+': ("# &f#0+':5 Z+(" N3'/.+% >'&'3.+(39 ,/(/ )-2<#%() %/' 0#./+' ,3'/.+%/773 /'&'3.&-) /',
)"/0# +'*&0./;&' +' / %&'(0&77#, ./''#09 #'/27+': ("#. (& 0#%#+V# +'*&0./;&' /', /,V#0;)#.#'()
(0-73 1#0)&'/7+W#, *&0 ("#.9 8"+7# 10&(#%;': ("#. *0&. '#:7+:#'( /', '#*/0+&-) .+)-)# &* ("#+0 ,/(/5
L' ("# %&'(#X( &* "#/7("%/0#9 )"&0(%&.+':) +' %-00#'( )#%-0+(3 /', 10+V/%3 /110&/%"#) .#/' ("/( .&)(
)3)(#.) *&%-) 10+./0+73 &' 10#V#';': ("# -',#)+0/27# 2/, 0#)-7( &* ./R+': ,/(/ /V/+7/27# (&
-'+'(#',#, 1/0;#) 8"& .+:"( +.10&1#073 -)# ,/(/5 M&'V#0)#739 N3'/.+% >'&'3.+(3 #'/27#) ,/(/ (&
2# -)#, *&0 ("# 2#)( +',+V+,-/7 1-01&)# &* +.10&V+': "#/7("%/0# *&0 )-2<#%() ,#)%0+2#, 23 ("# ,/(/ /',*&0 ("# 2#)( )&%+#(/7 1-01&)# &* /))&%+/;': ,/(/ 0#7/(#, (& / )-2<#%( 8+(" &("#0 )-2<#%() 1&))#))+':
)+.+7/0 /g0+2-(#) /', B &0 )3.1(&.)5
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 23/95
IA T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
+9 ]?,?>%' +D%,2(. -) cQ?.;,2 :3%0;0(.
&'"()*+ !"#"')*,' 718*01/$ *))17*(,1 51"1>,$ =*,<#6, )#7*>+(3#" ,# 12*$3"4
56$*"1$$ ("7 ,1+<"#8#4' ./(+3+1$G
Z+(" ("# -)# &* ,3'/.+%/773 %"/':#/27#9 (#.1&0/773 7+.+(#,9 -'+`-#9 /', 0#O/))+:'/27#&'"()*+ &1C-71"3>1/$ d&&-&$e9 %-00#'( )3)(#.) /', 10&%#))#) d#5:59 8#2 20&8)#0) /',
,/(/ /'/73;% #':+'#)e ,& '&( 0#%&:'+W# 0#7/;&')"+1) 2#(8##' /', /.&': @%&*&&.;%*/01
/', B &0 M0()*;01 ,/(/ #7#.#'() d/) .&0# *-773 ,#)%0+2#, "#0#+'e5 !"#3 %/' 10&%#))
+'*&0./;&' -)+': #X+);': %/1/2+7+;#) 8+("&-( %0#/;': +'*#0#'%#)9 %&00#7/;&')9 10&P7#) &0
%&'%7-)+&') 12+1., ($ 12./1$$8' (6,<#/*Y17 5' 7(,( $65S1+,$ ("7 ,/6$,17 .(/31$ R ./#2*1$
0*( ,<1 !"#"#$ B*/+81 #A :/6$, PB#:Q d/) .&0# *-773 ,#)%0+2#, "#0#+'e5>,,+;&'/7 )+:'+P%/'( 2#'#P() 8&-7, /0+)# *0&. '#8 2-)+'#)) /', (#%"'&7&:3 10/%;%#)
("/( 7#V#0/:# )1#%+P% /g0+2-(#) /', %/1/2+7+;#) &* N3'/.+% >'&'3.+(39 2-( /77 )-%"
.&,+P%/;&') 8&-7, 2# #V/7-/(#, &' ("# 2/)+) &* ("#+0 0#(-0' &' +'V#)(.#'(5 Z# 2#7+#V#
N3'/.+% >'&'3.+(3 %/' )#0V# /) / 17/u&0. *&0 +''&V/;&'5
N3'/.+% >'&'3.+(3 %/' 2# +.17#.#'(#, &' / %#'(0/7+W#, &0 *#,#0/(#, .&,#7 (& 0#v#%(
,#)+0#, 0#7/;&')"+1) 2#(8##' ,/(/ )-2<#%() /', /110&10+/(# (0-)(#, 1/0;#) B 10&X+#)5
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 24/95
IE T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
<9 +),.?.-(,- C?-D W(2?.'%;E( \ m(24'%-)3= `)%'.
N3'/.+% >'&'3.+(3 */%+7+(/(#) %&.17+/'%# 8+(" Y!M 10+'%+17#) +'+;/773 *&0./7+W#, +' b/0%" IJ@I +'
L:./0;7-D g.-&E30: L:%6*;+ %- *- h:* .4 M*(%1 g$*-D0V M0;.330-1*7.-& 4.: UE&%-0&&0& *-1
L.)%;+3*N0:&5 M/1/2+7+;#) &* N3'/.+% >'&'3.+(3 %/' "#71 #')-0# ("/(U
•
&(,( *$ "#, \/1($#"(58' 8*";17 ,# ( $.1+*>+ +#"$6)1/T +#).6,1/T #/ #,<1/ 710*+1] &0• N/(/ %&77#%;&'9 -)# /', 0#(#';&' 1&7+%+#) /0# %&')+)(#'( 8+(" Y!M 2#)( 10/%;%#) *&0 L/*0(+' 5'
&1$*4"T H*).8*>17 B#"$6)1/ B<#*+1 ("7 :/("$.(/1"+'G
&# 9#, :/(+; /110&/%"#) (& 10&(#%;': 10+V/%3 /0# 7#)) %&')+)(#'( 8+(" %-00#'( #%&'&.+% .&,#7) ("/'
&# 9#, D1)1)51/ /110&/%"#) ./,# 1&))+27# 23 N3'/.+% >'&'3.+(35
N3'/.+% >'&'3.+(3 10#)#'() / .#%"/'+). (& "#71 +.17#.#'( ("# %&'%#1( &* / N(4"( B(/,( A#/ 7(,(
/) 1&1-7/0+W#, 23 r0-%# 6%"'#+#09 ("# +'(#0'/;&'/773 0#'&8'#, )#%-0+(3 (#%"'&7&:+)( /', /-("&09 23
1$,(58*$<*"4 ("7 1"A#/+*"4 7*E1/1", .(/31$^ /*4<,$ ("7 #58*4(3#"$ =*,< /1$.1+, ,# 7(,( *" ( )#/1
5(8("+17 )(""1/G
L' /,,+;&'9 N3'/.+% >'&'3.+(3 %/' #'/27# / )113"4 #A ,<1 )*"7$ +' )(/0R %&'(0/)( (& (/R#O+(O&0O
7#/V#O+(9 1-01&0(#, ^'&;%# /', %&')#'(_ %7+%R80/1 /00/':#.#'() ("/( "/V# 7&)( %0#,+2+7+(3 \ )& .-%"
)& ("/( ("# b/3 IJ@E 4565 =0#)+,#'(c) M&-'%+7 &* >,V+)&0) &' 6%+#'%# /', !#%"'&7&:3 d=M>6!e 0#1&0(
#';(7#, U%D @*/* *-1 L:%6*;+V 5 #0;$-.).D%;*) L0:&(0;760 %/77) %-00#'( %7+%R80/1 '&;%# /', %&')#'(
/00/':#.#'() / )(/;1, A(*86/15
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 25/95
IG T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
M!"M 6$+ +),.4>(3 :3?E%0= 63%>(C)31 m(P)3-
L/#,1+3"4 B#"$6)1/ L/*0(+' *" (" I/( #A D(.*7 B<("41J D1+#))1"7(3#"$ A#/ V6$*"1$$1$
("7 L#8*+')(;1/$5 !"# Y!M Y0/.#8&0R9 +'+;/773 *&0./7+W#, +' IJ@I9 ,&#) '&( /1173 +* /
%&.1/'3t) ,/(/ +) '&( q0#/)&'/273 7+'R#, (& / )1#%+P% %&')-.#09 %&.1-(#09 &0 &("#0,#V+%#_ 23 .#/') &*U
• > %&.1/'3 (/R+': 0#/)&'/27# .#/)-0#) (& #')-0# ("/( ,/(/ +) ,#O+,#';P#,F
• !"# %&.1/'3 1-27+%73 %&..+k': (& -)# ,/(/ +' / ,#O+,#';P#, */)"+&' /', '&(
/g#.1;': (& 0#O+,#';*3 ("# ,/(/F /',
•
!"# %&.1/'3 %&'(0/%(-/773 10&"+2+;': &("#0 #';;#) 8+(" 8"&. +( )"/0#) ,#O+,#';P#, ,/(/ *0&. 0#O+,#';*3+': ("/( ,/(/5
L' ("# %&'(#X( &* %&.173+': 8+(" ("# Y0/.#8&0R9 ("# 0#1&0( "+:"7+:"(#, ("# *&77&8+': 2#)(
10/%;%#)U
• L/*0(+' 5' &1$*4"
• H*).8*>17 B#"$6)1/ B<#*+1
•
:/("$.(/1"+'
L' /,,+;&' (& 2#)( 10/%;%#)9 ("# 0#1&0( "+:"7+:"() j#:+)7/;V# Q#%&..#',/;&') +'%7-,+':
)1#%+P%/773 N& ?&( !0/%R5
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 26/95
ID T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
• H1*Y*"4 U..#/,6"*31$
•
r+: ,/(/ )/V#) 7+V#)• r+: ,/(/ ./R#) ("# #%&'&.3 8&0R 2#g#0
• r+: ,/(/ )/V#) (/X1/3#0 ,&77/0)
• L/1$1/0*"4 [(861$
• r/7/'%+': 1&8#0 2#(8##' :&V#0'.#'( /', %+;W#') 8+(" 2+: ,/(/ (&&7)
• Q#V#7/;&' &* 6#')+;V# =#0)&'/7 L'*&0./;&'
•
L#$*301 _7(,( A6$*#"] 01/$6$ "14(301 _)#$(*+ 1E1+,] 8"#0# 1#0)&'/7+'*&0./;&' %/' 2# ,#0+V#, *0&. ,/(/ )#() 8+("&-( =LL
• =&(#';/7 ,+)%0+.+'/(&03 -)#) &* 2+: ,/(/ /'/73;%)
• L#8*+' D1+#))1"7(3#"$
• >,V/'%# M&')-.#0 =0+V/%3 r+77 &* Q+:"()
• =/)) ?/;&'/7 N/(/ r0#/%" j#:+)7/;&'
•
]X(#', =0+V/%3 =0&(#%;&') (& '&'O4565 =#0)&')
• ]')-0# N/(/ M&77#%(#, &' 6(-,#'() +) -)#, *&0 ],-%/;&'/7 =-01&)#)
• ]X1/', !#%"'+%/7 ]X1#0;)# (& 6(&1 N+)%0+.+'/;&'
• >.#', ("# ]7#%(0&'+% M&..-'+%/;&') =0+V/%3 >%(
]%= M!"F YD?-( i)4.( m(P)3- A /?2 <%-%@ N(?S?,2 HPP)3-4,?;(.b
:3(.(3E?,2 J%'4(.
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 27/95
IC T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
• w-#);&') #f#%;V#'#)) &* ^'&;%# /', %"&+%#_
• M-00#'( 10/%;%# %0#/(#) /' -'#V#' 17/3+': P#7, 2#(8##' -)#0) /', %&.1/'+#)
0#)-7;': +' _( ;*"7 #A )(/;1, A(*86/1]
• L/#.#$1$ .(/(7*4) $<*` *0&. 10+V/%3 10&(#%;&' 2/)#, &' %&77#%;&' &* ,/(/ ,#
A/()1=#/; 5($17 #" 6$1$ #A 7(,( (& "#71U
• >%%&-'( *&0 -)# &* 2&(" ^2&0' /'/7&:_ /', ^2&0' ,+:+(/7_ .#(/ ,/(/
• >,,0#)) 7&&.+': +))-# ("/( +'*&0./;&' %&77#%(#, -',#0 &'# 10#(#X( (&,/3 ./3
./R# '#8 +'*#0#'%#) 1&))+27# (&.&00&8 \ ^,/(/ *-)+&'_
• D1+#4"*Y1$ /#81 #A L/*0(+' I"<("+*"4 :1+<"#8#4*1$ *" ./#,1+3"4 ./*0(+'
• N+)%0#,+() #i%/%3 &* )&.# #.#0:+': \ /', #)(/27+)"#, \ (#%"'&7&:+#) *&0
10&(#%;': 10+V/%3 :+V#' ("# 0#/7+;#) /', %/1/2+7+;#) &* r+: N/(/
• ?&(#) ("/( (#%"'+%/7 )&7-;&') %/''&( 10&V+,# /,#`-/(# 10&(#%;&' 8+("&-( 0-7#)
/', 0#:-7/;&') (& #'%&-0/:# ("#+0 ,#V#7&1.#'( /', -)#• >,V&%/(#) *&0 4565 (& (/R# ("# 7#/,9 +'(#0'/;&'/773 /', ,&.#);%/7739 +' /,&1;':
1&7+%+#) (& $3)68(,1 6$1 #A ./(+3+(8 L/*0(+' I"<("+*"4 :1+<"#8#4*1$
• Z/0') 1&7+%+#) )"&-7, *&%-) &' +'(#',#, &-(%&.#) '&( 1/0;%-7/0 )&7-;&')
]%= M!"F :3(.?5(,;%' +)4,0?' )* 75E?.)3. ), N0?(,0( %,5
$(0D,)')2= K:+7N$L m(P)3-
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 28/95
IH T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
-[G U01/0*1= #A !"#"#$ B*/+81 #A :/6$, PB#:Q
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 29/95
IK T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
$D( 7,),). +?30'( )* $34.- K+)$L >%,%2(. 5%-% 4.(
&= oa.(3.p ?, %00)35%,0( C?-D P(3>?..?),. K:cm]NL
>%,%2(5 &= -34.-(5 P%3;(. \ P3)Q?(.9
^4)#0)_ ./3 2#U
• N/(/ )-2<#%() 8"& /0# ("# )-2<#%( &* ("# ,/(/ +' `-#);&' d#5:59 -)#0)9 %&')-.#0)9 1/;#'()9#(%5 8+(" 0#)1#%( (& ("#+0 &8' ,/(/ \ *&0 1-01&)#) "#0#&*9 ^H65S1+, F$1/$_eF /', B &0
•
!"+0, 1/0;#) 8"& /0# '&( ("# )-2<#%( &* ("# ,/(/ +' `-#);&' d#5:59 V#',&0)9
.#0%"/'()9 "#/7("%/0# 10&V+,#0)9 #(%5 \ *&0 1-01&)#) "#0#&*9 ^:<*/7 L(/,' F$1/$_ e5
Z"#' ,/(/ +) +'1-( 23 / ,/(/ )-2<#%( (& 8"&. ,/(/ 1#0(/+') d/ ^6-2<#%( 4)#0_e9 ("# 6-2<#%( 4)#0
./3 #)(/27+)" %-)(&.+W#, 10+V/%3 1&7+%3 1#0.+))+&') *&0 -)# &* ("#+0 ,/(/ 23 .#/') &* 10#O)#(
1&7+%+#) d#5:59 x&7,B6+7V#0Br0&'W#e ("/( (0/')7/(# +'(& P'#O:0/+'#, ,3'/.+% 1#0.+))+&') &0
/7(#0'/;V#73 ./3 )#7#%( / ^M-)(&._ &1;&' (& )1#%+*3 .&0# ,#(/+7#, ,3'/.+% 1/0/.#(#0)5
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 30/95
AJ T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
:cm]. 3('%-( -) %'')C%&'( )P(3%;),. .40D
%. CD%- 5%-% 0%, &( 4.(5 &= CD)>b *)3
CD%- P43P).(b CD%- ;>( P(3?)5b (-09
=]Qb6 ./3 /7)& )1#%+*3 ,#)+0#, /'&'3.+W/;&' 7#V#7) )-%" /) 8"#' B 8"#0# B "&8 (& -)#
NNLN) *&0 &*$($$#+*(3#" /', B &0 D1.8(+1)1", d/) .&0# *-773 ,#)%0+2#, "#0#+'e +' ("#
%&'(#X( &* 10&V+,+': /'&'3.+(3 *&0 ("# +,#';(3 /', B &0 /%;V+;#) &* / ,/(/ )-2<#%(9 8"#' (&
-)# &("#0 =0+V/%3 ]'"/'%+': !#%"'+`-#) +' %&''#%;&' 8+("9 &0 +' 7+#- &*9 NNLN)9 8"#' (&
10&V+,# +,#';*3+': +'*&0./;&' (& */%+7+(/(# (0/')/%;&')9 #(%5
Z"#' ,/(/ +) +'1-( 23 )&.#&'# &("#0 ("/' ("# ,/(/ )-2<#%( (& 8"&. ,/(/ 1#0(/+') d/ ^!"+0,
=/0(3 4)#0_e9 ("# !"+0, =/0(3 4)#0 %/' #)(/27+)" =]Qb) ("/( 1"(581 7(,( 6$1 R (++1$$ *"
+#).8*("+1 =*,< (..8*+(581 +#/.#/(,1T 814*$8(301 ("7 R #/ /1468(,#/' 7(,( 6$1 R ./*0(+'
/1?6*/1)1",$G
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 31/95
A@ T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
• <(0)4P'?,2 +),-(Q- \ 71+#6.8*"4 +#",12, A/#) 7(,( 8+("
0#)1#%( (& ("+0, 1/0;#) #X(#0'/7 (& ("# )3)(#. 5' 6$*"4
&&-&$ ,<(, +(""#, 51 ,/(+;17 12,1/"(88' 2-( 8"+%" /0#
)#%-0#73 (0/%R#,9 )(&0#, /', ./'/:#, 8+("+' ("# B#: 5
•
<?.%..)0?%;), \ #'/27+': ,/(/ ("/( &("#08+)# 0#V#/7)10+V/(# +'*&0./;&' (& 2# $1.(/(,17 *",# 0*$*58' 6"/18(,17
$65+#).#"1",$ \ #/%" &* 8"+%" %/' 2# .(*/17 =*,< ( &&-&
)& ("/( /'3&'# +'(#0%#1;': )-2%&.1&'#'() ,&#) '&( R'&8 ("#+0 %&'(#X( &0 .#/'+':5
• m(A%..)0?%;), \ /2+7+(3 (& _$3,+<] ,#41,<1/ $11)*"48' 6"/18(,17 7(,( 23 0#(/+'+': +'*&0./;&'
0#:/0,+': 0#7/;&')"+1) 2#(8##' /', /.&': NNLN) 8+("+' ("# B#: 5
•
m(P'%0(>(,- \ /2+7+(3 (& /1.8(+1 10+V/(# +'*&0./;&' 8+(" ,3'/.+%/773 %"/':+': NNLN) 8"+7# 0#(/+'+':
R'&87#,:# /) (& V/7-# ("/( #/%" NNLN 0#10#)#'() )& /) (& /101(8 )*"*)6)9 +* /'39 +'*&0./;&'
1#0(/+'+': (& /18(3#"$<*.$ ("7R#/ +#",12, 51,=11" ("7 ()#"4 7(,( 181)1",$5
• N('(0;), \ #'/27+': ,/(/ )-2<#%() &0 (0-)(#, 1/0;#) B 10&X+#) (& /10*1= 7(,( *" (44/14(,17
7(,( ./#>81$ d8"+%" +'%7-,#) &2)#0V/;&'/7 ,/(/ /', #X17+%+( ,/(/e (& $181+, 7(,( "11717 ,# $6..#/, (
$.1+*>+ (+3#"T (+30*,' #/ .6/.#$1G
• $3%01?,2 \ /2+7+(3 (& (0/%R ,3'/.+%/773 %"/':+': /', 0#O/))+:'/27# NNLN) +' &0,#0 (& d/e /1C($$#+*(,1
("#. (&:#("#0 +' ("# %/)# &* @%&*&&.;%*7.- /', d2e R'&8 ("#+0 +#",12, R )1("*"4 +' ("# %/)# &*
M0()*;030-/ 5
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 32/95
AI T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
N-%;0 7,),=>?-= +) &'#O,+.#')+&'/7 +' ("/( +( 10&V+,#) /'&'3.+(3 *&0 ,/(
&'73 d8"+%" ./3 2# 0#O+,#';P#, 8+("&-( ("# N/(/ 6-2<#%(c) 1#0.+))+&'e5
<=,%>?0 7,),=>?-= +) .-7;O,+.#')+&'/7 +' ("/( +( 10&V+,#) %&'(0&77#,
/'&'3.+(3 *&0U
• N/(/
• L,#';(3 d&* N/(/ 6-2<#%( B M&'(0&77#0e
• M&'(#X(• !+.#
•
=-01&)#
• =7/%#
• p("#0
r3 &2*-)%/;': %&''#%;&') 2#(8##' /', /.&': ("# *&0#:&+':9 +#",/#8817
7(,( A6$*#" +) ./,# 1&))+27# #'/27+': ("#U
• 4',&+': &0 0#V#0)/7 &* #+("#0 0+:"() :0/'(#, &0 /%%#)) (& ,/(/F /',
•
Q#<-V#'/;&' &* ,/(/ (& )-11&0( /,,+;&'/7 )#%&',/03 -)#) 8+("&-
V+&7/;': 10&.+)#) (& ,/(/ )-2<#%()5
[G !"#"#$ &'"()*+ !"#"')*,' 0$G H,(3+ !"#"')*,'
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 33/95
AA T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
a L( )"&-7, 2# '&(#, ("/( ("#)# ,+f#0#'( /'&'3.+(3 (#%"'+`-#) /0# '&( .-(-/773 #X%7-)+V# /', ("/(
,#1#',+': &' ("# */%() /', %+0%-.)(/'%#) &* #/%" )+(-/;&'9 / .+X(-0# &* ("#)# (#%"'+`-#) ./3 10&,-%#
("# 2#)( 10+V/%39 )#%-0+(3 /', %&'(0&75
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 34/95
AE T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
N3'/.+% =0+V/%3 +) /%"+#V#, 23 -)+': +,#';P#0) %/77#, <=,%>?0 <(A85(,;B(3. d<<8<.e5 NNLN)
$1.(/(,1 7(,( A/#) +#",12, 2#%/-)# #X(#0'/7 (& ("# M&! ("#0# +) '& ,+)%#0'/27# 0#7/;&')"+1
2#(8##' &(,(9 -71"3,' dN/(/ 6-2<#%( B M&'(0&77#0e &0 B#",12, d#5:59 ;.#9 1-01&)# &0 17/%#e
/))&%+/(#, 8+(" ,+f#0#'( NNLN)5 L'(#0'/7 (& ("# M&!9 0#7/;&')"+1 +'*&0./;&' +) )(*",(*"17 A#/
6$1 ($ (6,<#/*Y17 5' 7(,( $65S1+,$ ("7 ,/6$,17 .(/31$ R ./#2*1$5
Y&0 #X/.17#9 +' ("# /2&V# ^17/3_ &' )7+,# @I9 /( [email protected] NNLNa aLMNCbcde +) -)#,9 /( AU@C 1.
NNLN af!cCgh: i +) -)#,9 /', /( AUIJ NNLN adiiCghje +) -)#,5 ]X(#0'/7 (& ("# M&!9 ("#0# +) '&
/11/0#'( 0#7/;&')"+1 2#(8##' /', /.&': ("#)# NNLN)F +'(#0'/7 (& ("# M&!9 ("#)# NNLN) /0#
/))&%+/(#, /) *&77&8)U aLMNCbcde af!cCgh:e a!diiCghje k lG l(' G
!"# /))+:'.#'(9 /117+%/;&'9 #X1+0/;&' /', 1&(#';/7 0#%3%7+': &* ,3'/.+%/773 %"/':#/27#9(#.1&0/773 7+.+(#,9 -'+`-#9 /', 0#O/))+:'/27# NNLN) ./3 &%%-0 +' /'3 &* ("# *&77&8+':9 &0 +' /'3
%&.2+'/;&' &* ("# *&77&8+':9 8/3)U
a ]X/.17# NNLN) /0# 10&V+,#,
*&0 +77-)(0/;V# 1-01&)#) &'73F
/%(-/7 NNLN) ./3 "/V#
%&')+,#0/273 .&0# %"/0/%(#0)
/', 2# %&')+,#0/273 .&0#
%&.17#X5
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 35/95
AG T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
<?.%..)0?%;), %,5 <<8<.
• N+)/))&%+/(#, ,/(/ #7#.#'() ,& '&( 0#V#/7 %&'(#X(5 Y&0 #X/.17#9 +( +) -'%7#/09 8+("&-(
/,,+;&'/7 +'*&0./;&'9 +* ("# 7#g#0) ^._ ^/_ ^)_ ^#_ /', ^(_ /0# +'(#',#, (& 0#10#)#'(
^.#/()_ ^)(#/._ ^(#/.)_ ^(/.#)_ &0 ^./(#)_ &0 8"#("#0 ("# 8&0,) ^N&#_ ^[/8R_^6-)/'_ /', ^m&"'_ /0# +'(#',#, (& 0#10#)#'( ^m&"' N&#_ ^N&# [/8R_ &0 ^6-)/'
[/8R5_
• L'%0#/)+': ("# '-.2#0 &* ,+)/))&%+/(#, ,/(/ #7#.#'() +' / ,/(/ )#( +'%0#/)#) ("#
,+i%-7(3 &* ,+)%#0'+': %&'(#X(5
• N3'/.+% >'&'3.+(3 -)#) <<8<. ("/( "/V# '& +'"#0#'( .#/'+': /', "/V# '&
10#,+%(/27# &0 ,#0+V/;V# 0#7/;&')"+1) (& ,/(/ #7#.#'()F +* +'(#0%#1(#,9 ("# NNLN)9 +'
/', &* ("#.)#7V#)9 ,& '&( 0#V#/7 +'*&0./;&'5• NNLN) /0# ("#' /))&%+/(#, 8+(" ,+)/))&%+/(#, ,/(/ #7#.#'() /) )(/(#, /2&V#5
• 6#%-0# ,/(/2/)#) )(&0# +'*&0./;&' 0#v#%;': +'(#',#, /))&%+/;&') 2#(8##' NNLN)
/', ,+)/))&%+/(#, ,/(/ #7#.#'()5
• ^y#3)_ /0# ("#' -)#, (& %&..-'+%/(# +'(#',#, 0#7/;&')"+1) 2#(8##' /', /.&':
NNLN) -)#, *&0 &*$($$#+*(3#" 1-01&)#) ("#0#23 0#O/))&%+/;': 10#V+&-)73 ,+)/))&%+/(#,
,/(/ #7#.#'()5 L' ("# %&'(#X( &* @%&*&&.;%*7.-9 8# %/77 ("#)# R#3) ^7..)0?%;), [(=._&0 ^7[.5_ Y&0 )#%-0+(3 1-01&)#)9 NNLN) /', >y) ./3 2# )#'( )#1/0/(#73 ^&-( &* 2/',_
*0&. &'# /'&("#05
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 36/95
AD T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
<?.%..)0?%;), %,5 <<8<. A;.-7-E01B
• L'*&0./;&' %&'(/+'#, +' >y) ./3 2# &2*-)%/(#, /( ("# ;.# &* %&..-'+%/;&' 23
=0+V/%3 ]'"/'%+': !#%"'+`-#) )-%" /) #'%031;':9 (&R#'+W+':9 #7+,+': &0 &("#08+)# /', B
&0 23 +'(0&,-%+': /,,+;&'/7 7/3#0) &* /2)(0/%;&' 23 0#17/%+': >y) 8+(" )#%&',O7#V#7 &0
'O7#V#7 NNLN)5
L' %031(&:0/1"39 (0/')1&)+;&' %+1"#0) )"+z -'+() &* 17/+'(#X( /%%&0,+': (& / 0#:-7/0 )3)(#. )&
("/( %+1"#0(#X( %&');(-(#) / 1#0.-(/;&' &* ("# 17/+'(#X( d+5#59 / 2+<#%;V# *-'%;&' +) -)#, (&
0#&0,#0 ("# 17/+'(#X( +'(& %+1"#0(#X( /', /' +'V#0)# *-'%;&' +) -)#, (& ,#%031( ("# %+1"#0(#X(
2/%R +'(& 17/+'(#X(e5
&*$($$#+*(3#" ,+f#0) *0&. (0/')1&)+;&' %+1"#0) +' / '-.2#0 &* 8/3)9 +'%7-,+':U
• !0/')1&)+;&' %+1"#0) /0# ./("#./;%/7 *-'%;&') %&')+);': &* / )#0+#) &* 8#77O,#P'#, )(#1)
*&77&8#, /) / 10&%#,-0#9 8"#0#/) NNLN) -)#, *&0 @%&*&&.;%*7.- "/V# '& +'"#0#'( .#/'+':
/', '& 10#,+%(/27# &0 ,#0+V/;V# 0#7/;&')"+1) (& ,+)/))&%+/(#, ,/(/F /',
•
!0/')1&)+;&' %+1"#0) 0#&0,#0 ,/(/ +'(& / 10#,+%(/27# )(0-%(-0# &0 1/g#0'9 8"#0#/) ("#1-01&)# &* NNLN) -)#, *&0 @%&*&&.;%*7.- +) (& &2V+/(# ("# 0#`-+0#.#'( *&0 -)+': 10#,+%(/27#
)(0-%(-0#) &0 1/g#0')5
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 37/95
AC T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
m(P'%0(>(,- %,5 <<8<.
• M0()*;030-/ %&')+)() &* -)+': NNLN) (& *-773 0#17/%# ,/(/ #7#.#'() ("/( 8&-7, &("#08+)#
0#V#/7 &(,(9 -71"3,' d&* N/(/ 6-2<#%( B M&'(0&77#0e &0 B#",12, d#5:59 ;.#9 1-01&)#9 17/%#e5
!"+) +) +' %&'(0/)( (& /))&%+/;': NNLN) 8+(" ,+)/))&%+/(#, ,/(/ #7#.#'() /) +) ("# %/)#
8+(" @%&*&&.;%*7.-5• 6+.+7/0 (& @%&*&&.;%*7.-9 NNLN) -)#, *&0 M0()*;030-/ 1-01&)#) "/V# '& +'"#0#'(
.#/'+': /', '& 10#,+%(/27# &0 ,#0+V/;V# 0#7/;&')"+1) (& 0#17/%#, ,/(/ )& ("/( +*
+'(#0%#1(#, ("# NNLN)9 +' /', &* ("#.)#7V#)9 ,& '&( 0#V#/7 +'*&0./;&'5
• 6#%-0# ,/(/2/)#) )(&0# +'*&0./;&' 0#V#/7+': ("# V/7-# &* ,/(/ #7#.#'() 0#17/%#, 23
NNLN)5
•
^y#3)_ /0# -)#, (& %&..-'+%/(# ("# V/7-# &* ,/(/ #7#.#'() ("/( "/V# 2##' 0#17/%#, 23NNLN)5 L' ("# %&'(#X( &* M0()*;030-/ 9 8# %/77 ("#)# R#3) ^D1.8(+1)1", [(=._ &0 ^m[.5_
Y&0 )#%-0+(3 1-01&)#)9 NNLN) /', Qy) ./3 2# )#'( )#1/0/(#73 ^&-( &* 2/',_ *0&. &'#
/'&("#05
• L'*&0./;&' %&'(/+'#, +' Qy) ./3 2# &2*-)%/(#, /( ("# ;.# &* %&..-'+%/;&' 23 =0+V/%3
]'"/'%+': !#%"'+`-#) )-%" /) #'%031;':9 (&R#'+W+':9 #7+,+': &0 &("#08+)# /', B &0 23
+'(0&,-%+': /,,+;&'/7 7/3#0) &* /2)(0/%;&' 23 0#17/%+': Qy) 8+(" )#%&',O7#V#7 &0 'O7#V#7
NNLN)5
• M0()*;030-/ %/' %&')+)( &* ^J%'4( D1.8(+1)1", _ /', B &0 ^64.?), D1.8(+1)1", _ \ ("#
,+f#0#'%# 1#0(/+'+': (& ;.+': /', +'(#'( &* /))&%+/(#, ,/(/ %&..-'+%/;&')5
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 38/95
AH T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
m(P'%0(>(,- %,5 <<8<. A;.-7-E01B
• J%'4( D1.8(+1)1", 0#*#0) (& )+(-/;&') 8"#0# NNLN) /', ("# Qy) '#%#))/03 (&
,+)%#0' ("# V/7-# &* ,/(/ #7#.#'() 0#17/%#, 23 NNLN) /0# %&..-'+%/(#, &' /
0#7/;V#73 %&'(#.1&0/'#&-) 2/)+) 8+(" ("# +'(#'( &* &2*-)%/;': ("# V/7-# &* ,/(/
#7#.#'() 0#17/%#, 23 ("# NNLN) (& /'3&'# 8"& ,&#) '&( "/V# /%%#)) (& Qy)5
• 64.?), D1.8(+1)1", 0#*#0) (& )+(-/;&') 8"#0# NNLN) /', ("# Qy) '#%#))/03 (&
,+)%#0' ("# V/7-# &* ,/(/ #7#.#'() 0#17/%#, 23 ("# NNLN) /0# %&..-'+%/(#, /(
,+f#0#'( 1&+'() +' ;.# ("#0#23 #'/27+': ("# V/7-# &* ("# ,/(/ #7#.#'() 0#17/%#, 23
("# NNLN) (& 2# 8+(""#7,9 %"/':#, &0 -1,/(#,5
• !"+) #'/27#) +#",/#8817 7(,( A6$*#" 23 10&V+,+': %&'(0&77#, /'&'3.+(3 *&0
&(,(9 -71"3,' d&* N/(/ 6-2<#%( B M&'(0&77#0e9 /', B#",12, d#5:59 ;.#9 1-01&)#9
17/%#e 23 &2*-)%/;': %&''#%;&') 2#(8##' /', /.&': ("# *&0#:&+':9 #'/27+':
("#U
• 4',&+': &0 0#V#0)/7 &* #+("#0 0+:"() :0/'(#, &0 /%%#)) (& ,/(/F /',
• Q#<-V#'/;&' &* ,/(/ (& )-11&0( /,,+;&'/7 )#%&',/03 -)#) 8+("&-(
V+&7/;': 10&.+)#) (& ,/(/ )-2<#%()5
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 39/95
AK T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
m(P'%0(>(,- %,5 <<8<. A;.-7-E01B
L' %031(&:0/1"39 )-2);(-;&' %+1"#0) 0#17/%# -'+() &* 17/+'(#X( 8+(" %+1"#0(#X( /%%&0,+':
(& / 0#:-7/0 )3)(#.F / 0#%#+V#0 ,#%+1"#0) ("# %+1"#0(#X( 23 1#0*&0.+': /' +'V#0)#
)-2);(-;&' -)+': / %+1"#05 6-2);(-;&' %+1"#0) /0# /7:&0+(".) %&')+);': &* / )#0+#) &*
8#77O,#P'#, )(#1) *&77&8#, /) / 10&%#,-0#5
D1.8(+1)1", ,+f#0) *0&. )-2);(-;&' %+1"#0) +' / '-.2#0 &* 8/3)9 +'%7-,+': ("# */%(
("/( NNLN) "/V# '& +'"#0#'( .#/'+': /', '& 10#,+%(/27# &0 ,#0+V/;V# 0#7/;&')"+1 (&
0#17/%#, ,/(/5
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 40/95
EJ T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 41/95
E@ T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 42/95
EI T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
&*$($$#+*(3#" W(E(' <(-(3>?,%;), K<W<L #'(/+7) ./("#./;%/7 /'/73)+) &* ("#
-'+`-#'#)) &* / ,/(/ #7#.#'( (& /))#)) ("# 7#V#7 &* @%&*&&.;%*7.- 0#`-+0#, (& 0#,-%# ("#10&2/2+7+(3 &* +,#';P%/;&' &0 0#O/))&%+/;&' 23 /,V#0)/0+#) 8+("&-( 10&1#0 1#0.+))+&'5
NjN V/7-#) ./3 2# -)#, /) *".6, (& ,#(#0.+'# ("# 0#7#V/'( 7#V#7 &* @%&*&&.;%*7.- B
M0()*;030-/ /110&10+/(# *&0 ,+f#0#'( (31#) &* ,/(/ #7#.#'()5
7,),=>?-= ](%.43(>(,- N0)3(. K7]NL %&00#7/(# (& ./("#./;%/773 ,#0+V#, 7#V#7) &*
%#0(/+'(3 1#0(/+'+': (& ("# 7+R#7+"&&, ("/( 1#0)&'/773 )#')+;V# /', B &0 +,#';*3+':
+'*&0./;&' ./3 2# ,+)%#0'+27# 23 ("+0, 1/0;#)5
>b6 V/7-#) ./3 2# -)#, (& #V/7-/(# ("# #6,.6, *0&. @%&*&&.;%*7.- B M0()*;030-/
/%;V+;#) (& ,#(#0.+'# ("# 7#V#7 B (31# &* %&')#'( 0#`-+0#, 2#*&0# ,/(/ %/' 2# -)#,5
<?.%..)0?%;), W(E(' <(-(3>?,%;), \ 7,),=>?-= ](%.43(>(,- N0)3(.
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 43/95
EA T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
N-(P Z" \ N/(/ /g0+2-(#) /0# #V/7-/(#, (& /))#)) @%&*&&.;%*7.- j#V#7 N#(#0.+'/;&') dNjN)e \
+5#59 ,/(/ #7#.#'() /0# /'/73W#, (& ,#(#0.+'# ("# 1&(#';/7 7+R#7+"&&, &* ,+0#%(73 &0 +',+0#%(73
0#V#/7+': 1#0)&'/79 )#')+;V#9 +,#';*3+': &0 &("#0 +'*&0./;&' 8+(" 0#:/0, (& 8"+%" /'&'3.+(310&(#%;&' +) ,#)+0#,5
N-(P ZI \ r/)#, +' 1/0( &' NjN)9 ,/(/ #7#.#'() /0# ,3'/.+%/773 /'&'3.+W#, 23 .#/') &*
@%&*&&.;%*7.-5 L' /,,+;&'9 ,/(/ #7#.#'() ./3 /7)& -',#0:& M0()*;030-/G
N-(P ZA \ > %/7%-7/;&' +) 1#0*&0.#, 23 .#/') &* / ./("#./;%/7 *-'%;&' B /7:&0+(". d#5:59 ("#./("#./;%/7 *-'%;&' B /7:&0+(". 0#v#%(#, +' Y+:-0# @ 2#7&8e (& %/7%-7/(# /' >'&'3.+(3
b#/)-0#.#'( 6%&0# d>b6e ("/( %&00#7/(#) (& ("# 7+R#7+"&&, ("/( ("# +,#';(3 &* ("# ,/(/ )-2<#%(
(& 8"+%" )/+, ,/(/ /g0+2-(#) 1#0(/+' ./3 2# ,+)%#0'+27# 23 ("+0, 1/0;#) /z#0 @%&*&&.;%*7.- B
M0()*;030-/ 8+(" NNLN)5
N-(P ZE \ !"# )%&0#B0/;': %/7%-7/(#, +' 6(#1 {A /2&V# ./3 2# -)#, (& )1#%+*3 ("# 7#V#7 &*
%&')#'( B +'V&7V#.#'( 0#`-+0#, 23 ("# ,/(/ )-2<#%( (& 8"+%" ("# /'&'3.+W#, ,/(/ /g0+2-(#)1#0(/+' V#0)-) 8"/( 7#V#7 &* ,+)%0#;&' B -)# / ("+0, 1/0(3 ./3 #X#0%+)# 8+(" 0#:/0, (& ("#
/'&'3.+W#, ,/(/ /g0+2-(#) 8+("&-( 0#`-+0+': %&')#'( B +'V&7V#.#'( 23 ("# ,/(/ )-2<#%( )-%" /)
("# #X/.17# >b6 -)/:# 0#v#%(#, +' Y+:-0# I 2#7&85
<?.%..)0?%;), W(E(' <(-(3>?,%;), \ 7,),=>?-= ](%.43(>(,- N0)3(.
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 44/95
EE T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
&*$($$#+*(3#" W(E(' <(-(3>?,%;), K<W<L +'V&7V#) ,#(#0.+'+': ("# -'+`-#'#)) &* / ,/(/#7#.#'( &0 #V#' &* %&.1&'#'( 1+#%#) &* / ,/(/ #7#.#'( 23 *0#`-#'%3 &* &%%-00#'%#9
/.&': &("#0 ,#(#0.+'/;&') /', %&.1&'#'( #X/.+'/;&')5
Y&0 +')(/'%# \ / "+:"73 1&1-7/0 '/.# 7+R# b/g ./3 '&( '##, (& 2# %-( -1 *-0("#05
[&8#V#09 -'+`-# '/.#) d1&))+273 #X%7-,+': '/.#) 7+R# N#'V#09 8"+%" +) /7)& /117+%/27#
(& ("# %+(3e 8&-7, '##, (& 2# %-( -1 +'(& "+:"#0 *0#`-#'%3 7#g#0 %&.2+'/;&') (& 0#.&V#
("# 7+R#7+"&&, &* 0#O+,#';P%/;&' +' (0/')+( &0 -';7 1#0.+))+&') /0# :+V#' &0 0#%#+V#,5
<?.%..)0?%;), W(E(' <(-(3>?,%;),q
m&*$($$#+*(3#" M1018 &1,1/)*"(3#" 12().81$ (/1 A#/ *886$,/(3#" .6/.#$1$ #"8'
6?243(
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 45/95
EG T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
7,),=>?-= ](%.43(>(,- N0)3(.q
m :<1$1 !"#"')*,' N1($6/1)1", H+#/1 12().81$ (/1 A#/ *886$,/(3#" .6/.#$1$ #"8'
6?243(
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 46/95
ED T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
7,),=>?-= ](%.43(>(,- N0)3(.q
m :<1$1 !"#"')*,' N1($6/1)1", H+#/1 12().81$ (/1 A#/ *886$,/(3#" .6/.#$1$ #"8'
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 47/95
EC T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
Z# 2#7+#V# ("/( 23 8&0R+': (&:#("#09 8# %/' 0#%&'%+7# )##.+':73 %&'v+%;': +'(#0#)() &*
:&V#0'.#'()9 %&01&0/;&') /', +',+V+,-/7) 8+(" 0#:/0, (& ,+:+(/7 10+V/%39 )#%-0+(3 /',
%&'(0&7 23 7#V#0/:+': ("# /2+7+(3 &* &'"()*+ !"#"')*,' (&U
•
-)./#01 12*$3"4 56$*"1$$ )#718$ 23 +.10&V+': 10&P() B 1-01&)# 8"+7# )+.-7(/'#&-)73#'"/'%+': 10+V/%3 /', 1#0)&'/7+W/;&' +#).(/17 ,# &# 9#, :/(+; (../#(+<1$
*"+#"$*$,1", =*,< +6//1", 56$*"1$$ )#718$F
• &18*01/ *))17*(,1 51"1>,$ =*,<#6, /1?6*/*"4 )#7*>+(3#"$ (& #X+);': 2-)+'#)) /',
(#%"'&7&:3 10/%;%#) =<*81 $1/0*"4 ($ ( .8(@#/) A#/ A6,6/1 *""#0(3#"F
• B#6",1/ "14(301 *).8*+(3#"$ #A 1"<("+17 5*4 7(,( /1C*71"3>+(3#" +(.(5*8*31$
)+'%# #)(/27+)".#'( &* ("# Y!M =0+V/%3 Y0/.#8&0R +' IJ@IF
• D1+#"+*81 (..(/1", ,1"$*#"$ 2#(8##' ("# Y!M =0+V/%3 Y0/.#8&0R /', ("# 0#%#'(
Z"+(# [&-)# =&,#)(/ /', =M>6! 0#1&0()F
•
!77/1$$ 6"("$=1/17 ?61$3#"$ +' ("# Z"+(# [&-)# =&,#)(/ /', =M>6! 0#1&0()F
• D1+#"+*81 7*E1/1"+1$ 51,=11" FGHG ("7 IF ./*0(+' ./(+3+1$ /', )(0#':("#' 4565 \ ]4
6/*# [/02&0 10&:0/.5
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 48/95
EH T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
6)3 >)3( ?,*)3>%;),b P'(%.( 0),-%0-@
`%3= W%6(E(3
:/03|/'&'&)5%&.
dAJAe HIAOH@@@
$(5 ]=(3.),
(#,|/'&'&)5%&.
dI@Ie DGHO@JHJ
!..1"7*+1$ K#88#= :<*$ L(41
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 49/95
EK T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
7PP(,5?Q 7
8>P3)E(5 :43P).( %,5 :(3.),%'?S%;),
=/:#) EK O GG
:<1 A#88#=*"4 $8*71$ ./#0*71 ( 4/(.<*+(8 #01/0*1= #A =('$ ,<(, &'"()*+ !"#"')*,' +(" <18.
*)./#01 L6/.#$1 ("7 L1/$#"(8*Y(3#" 5' ,/("$A#/)*"4 (..8*+(3#"$T $'$,1)$T .8(@#/)$T
1+#))1/+1 $*,1$ ("7 48#5(8 "1,=#/;$ 6$*"4 $,(3+ ("#"')*,' *",# #"1$ 6$*"4 7'"()*+(88'+#",/#88(581 ("#"')*,'T ./#,1+3"4 7(,( $65S1+,$^ ./*0(+'T $1+6/*,' ("7 +#",/#8 A(/ 51O1/ ("7
*" ( )#/1 /1810(", )(""1/ ,<(" 51A#/1 =<*81 )(;*"4 .#$$*581 "1= <1(8,<+(/1T )(/;13"4T
181+,/#"*+ +#))1/+1 ("7 #,<1/ #5S1+301$G
7PP(,5?Q 7 R 8>P3)E(5 :43P).( %,5 :(3.),%'?S%;),
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 50/95
GJ T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
7PP(,5?Q 7 8>P3)E(5 :43P).( %,5 :(3.),%'?S%;),>11#',+X > \ =/:# @ &* D
7PP(,5?Q 7 R 8>P3)E(5 :43P).( %,5 :(3.),%'?S%;),
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 51/95
G@ T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
7PP(,5?Q 7 8>P3)E(5 :43P).( %,5 :(3.),%'?S%;),>11#',+X > \ =/:# I &* D
7PP(,5?Q 7 R 8>P3)E(5 :43P).( %,5 :(3.),%'?S%;),
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 52/95
GI T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
PP P P>11#',+X > \ =/:# A &* D
7PP(,5?Q 7 R 8>P3)E(5 :43P).( %,5 :(3.),%'?S%;),
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 53/95
GA T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
PP P P>11#',+X > \ =/:# E &* D
7PP(,5?Q 7 R 8>P3)E(5 :43P).( %,5 :(3.),%'?S%;),
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 54/95
GE T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
PP P P>11#',+X > \ =/:# G &* D
7PP(,5?Q 7 R 8>P3)E(5 :43P).( %,5 :(3.),%'?S%;),
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 55/95
GG T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
a!"# /2&V# +',+%/(#, '/.#)9 (0/,#./0R) /',B&0 ,&./+' '/.#) /0# ("# 10&1#0(3 &* ("#+0 0#)1#%;V# &8'#0)5 >'&'&) L'%5 ./R#) '& %7/+. &* 0+:"() (&9 &0 /i7+/;&' 8+("9 )/+, ./0R) &0 &8'#0)5
PP P P>11#',+X > \ =/:# D &* D
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 56/95
GD T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
7PP(,5?Q /
N('(0- 7PP'?0%;),. )* <=,%>?0 7,),=>?-=
=/:#) GD O HC
!"# +,#/;&' ("/( "/) #V&7V#, +'(& N3'/.+% >'&'3.+(39 ("# M+0%7# &* !0-)( dM&!e /', &("#0
#7#.#'() &* >'&'&)9 2#:/' +' IJ@I \ =188 51A#/1 ,<1 jnho H"#=71" /1018(3#"$ R :(/41,
7(,( 5/1(+< ("7 ,<1 jnhc !:p: 7(,( 5/1(+< R H"(.+<(, K:B $1O81)1", R IF B#6/, #A l6$3+1 qD*4<, ,# 51 K#/4#O1"^ 71+*$*#" (4(*"$, W##481G
>( P0)(9 20/+')(&0.+': )#))+&') +'V&7V#, ("# *&-',#0) &* >'&'&)9 !#, b3#0)&' /', x/03
j/Y#V#09 2-( 7/(#0 #X1/',#, (& +'%7-,# ,+)%-))+&') 8+(" %7&)# %&'P,/'() /2&-( 8/3) 8#
%&-7, /%"+#V# l73?.-)-'(r. `)'5(, ](%,c C ( 71$*/(581 )*7781 51,=11" ,=# 12,/1)1$T #"1
#A 12+1$$ ("7 ,<1 #,<1/ #A 71>+*1"+' O 23 .#/') &* / 0#V&7-;&'/03 /110&/%" (& ,/(/
10+V/%3 -;7+W+': ,3'/.+%/773 %0#/(#,9 %"/':+': /', -'+`-#73 0#O/))+:'/27# (&R#') dNNLN)e(& %0#/(# )#%-0# ,/(/ 0#7/;&')"+1) ("/( %&-7, '&( 2# ,+)%#0'#, 23 -'/-("&0+W#, 1/0;#)5
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 57/95
GC T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
>) ;.# "/) 1/))#,9 ("# >'&'&) l0+': &* (0-)(#, /,V+)&0)c "/) :0&8' (& +'%7-,# '-.#0&-)
#':+'##0)9 8"+(# "/( "/%R#0)9 10&*#))+&'/7 /,V+)&0)9 #V/':#7+)( V&7-'(##0)9 1/+, %&')-7(/'()9
Y&0(-'# GJ %&01&0/;&' M"+#* =0+V/%3 pi%#0)9 10+V/%3 /', )#%-0+(3 #X1#0()9 7#:+)7/(&0)9
0#:-7/(&0) /', &("#0) l,#,+%/(#, (& ("# %/-)#5c
:<1 12().81$ *"+86717 *" !..1"7*2 V +#)1 A/#) ( 0(/*1,' #A ,<1 (5#01 $#6/+1$ ("7 /6" (=*71 4()6, #A $65S1+, )(O1/T +#).812*,'T 71,(*8 ("7 $+#.1 ("7 (/1 ./1$1",17 <1/1 =*,<
,<1 <#.1 #A 41"1/(3"4 (77*3#"(8 *71($ A#/ .#,1"3(8 (..8*+(3#"$ A#/T ("7 7*$+6$$*#"$
(5#6, ,<1 .#,1"3(8 #AT &'"()*+ !"#"')*,'G
^?#X( )(#1)_ *&0 >'&'&)9 N3'/.+% >'&'3.+(39 N& ?&( Q#.#.2#0 /', ("# M+0%7# &* !0-)(
dM&!e ,#1#',9 +' 1/0(9 &' 0#)-7() &* ("#)# ,+)%-))+&') 0#:/0,+': ("# .#0+()9 #X(#')+2+7+(3 /',
/2+7+(3 &* N3'/.+% >'&'3.+(3 (& "#71 %&,+*3 / 20&/,O2/)#, %&')#')-) /', )&7-;&' *&0/%"+#V+': ,#)+0#, 7#:+)7/;V# /', 0#:-7/(&03 &2<#%;V#) &' %&..#0%+/773 2#'#P%+/7 (#0.) *&0
/77 ./0R#( 1/0;%+1/'() \ 8"+7# )+:'+P%/'(73 #'"/'%+': +',+V+,-/7 10+V/%39 )#%-0+(3 /',
%&'(0&75
Z# 2#7+#V# ("/( 23 8&0R+': (&:#("#09 8# %/' 0#%&'%+7# ("# )##.+':73 %&'v+%;': +'(#0#)() &*
:&V#0'.#'()9 %&01&0/;&') /', +',+V+,-/7) 8+(" 0#:/0, (& ,+:+(/7 10+V/%39 )#%-0+(3 /',
%&'(0&75 =7#/)# )#', /'3 /,,+;&'/7 +,#/) *&0 1&(#';/7 /117+%/;&') &* N3'/.+% >'&'3.+(3 (&+,#/;&'|/'&'&)5%&.5
C :<("; '#6r
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 58/95
GH T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
Z" V),Ai8:77 ](5?0%' :3%0;0( 7PP'?0%;),
ZM i8:77 /3?,2 n)43 HC, <(E?0( K/nH<L 7PP'?0%;),
ZO i(%'-D0%3( :)3-%' 7PP'?0%;),
ZF Y(%3%&'( i(%'-D0%3( 7PP'?0%;),
ZG Y?3('(.. +%33?(3 \ VN7 700(.. -) 8,*)3>%;),
ZU 8)$ R 8,-(3,(- )* $D?,2.
ZX 7,%'=.?. )* :)-(,;%' +4.-)>(3 /%.(ZI m(%'A$?>( +4.-)>?S%;),
ZT i?2D'= :(3?.D%&'( `))5. 7PP'?0%;),
Z"! ])&?'( <(E?0(. %,5 W)0%;), N(3E?0(.
Z"" c>(32(,0= ]%,%2(>(,- N=.-(>.
Z"M 6%>?'= c540%;),%' m?2D-. %,5 :3?E%0= 70- Z"O +D?'53(,r. H,'?,( :3?E%0= :3)-(0;), 70-
Z"F ca <%-% :3)-(0;), <?3(0;E( "TTG\FU\c+
N('(0- 7PP'?0%;),. )* <=,%>?0 7,),=>?-=
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 59/95
GK T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
!"# *&77&8+': D )7+,#) )"&8 "&8 >'&'&) ./3 "#71 ,#(#0.+'# ("# /110&10+/(#
7&%/;&' *&0 )#0V+%#) +' ,+f#0#'( '#+:"2&0"&&,) 8+("&-( 0#V#/7+': +'*&0./;&'10&(#%(#, 23 ("# a9N9 i(%'-D 8,.43%,0( :)3-%&?'?-= %,5 700)4,-%&?'?-= 70- Ki8:77L
23 )#1/0/;': %&'(#X( *0&. ,/(/ \ +5#59 ,/(/ #7#.#'() /0# +,#';P#,9 )#1/0/(#, /',
^(/::#,_ +' / ./''#0 ("/( ,&#) '&( 0#V#/7 %&'(#X( &0 0#7/;&')"+1) 2#(8##' ,/(/
#7#.#'() 8+("&-( /%%#)) (& )#%-0# ,+0#%(&0+#) ./+'(/+'#, 23 ("# )3)(#.5
!"+) "31&("#;%/7 #X/.17# +'V&7V#) / P%;&'/7 .#,+%/7 10/%;%#9 -)+': NNLN) (&#V/7-/(# *&-0 */%+7+;#) #)(/27+)"#, &V#0 ("# 3#/0) +' ,+f#0#'( 7&%/;&') \ #/%"
&f#0+': / ,+f#0#'( .#,+%/7 10&%#,-0#5 Q#*#0#'%#) (& )(#1) +' ("# "31&("#;%/7
#X/.17# 0#*#0 (& )(#1) &' ("# ,+/:0/. &' ("# *&77&8+': 1/:#5
Z" V),Ai8:77 ](5?0%' :3%0;0( 7PP'?0%;),]X/.17# =/:# @ &* D
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 60/95
DJ T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
Z" V),Ai8:77 ](5?0%' :3%0;0( 7PP'?0%;),]X/.17# =/:# I &* D
dN#(/+7#, ]X17/'/;&' 10&V+,#, &' *&77&8+': 1/:#)e
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 61/95
D@ T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
>( m(*(3(,0( " ("# &8'#0) &* ("# .#,+%/7 10/%;%# 0#`-#)( (& P', &-( 8"#("#0 .#,+%/7
10&%#,-0#) /0# 2#+': &f#0#, +' ("# 7&%/;&') .&)( %&'V#'+#'( *&0 ("# ./<&0+(3 &* ("#+01/;#'()5
m(*(3(,0( M )"&8) ("/( #/%" &* ("# .#,+%/7 */%+7+;#) )(&0#) .#,+%/7 0#%&0,) +' /'
+',+V+,-/7 N/(/ 6(&0# d+' ("+) #X/.17#9 #/%" N/(/ 6(&0# )(&0#) ,/(/ +' / ,+f#0#'(
*&0./(e5
m(*(3(,0( O )"&8) ("/( ("# ,/(/ *0&. #/%" &* ("# N/(/ 6(&0#) +) 10&%#))#, 23 / N/(/L.1&0(#0 (& %&'V#0( ,+f#0#'( ,/(/ *&0./() +'(& / %/'&'+%/7 ,/(/ .&,#75
>( m(*(3(,0( F ("# =&7+%3 >-("&0+(3 /117+#) / 1&7+%3 (& )#1/0/(# %&'(#X( *0&. ,/(/ \ +5#59
,/(/ #7#.#'() /0# +,#';P#,9 )#1/0/(#, /', ^(/::#,_ +' / ./''#0 ("/( ,&#) '&( 0#V#/7
.#/'+': &0 0#7/;&')"+1) 2#(8##' ,/(/ #7#.#'() 8+("&-( /%%#)) (& ,+0#%(&0+#) ("/( 8+77
2# ./+'(/+'#, )#%-0#73 23 ("# )3)(#.5 L' ("+) #X/.17#9 +'*&0./;&' 0#`-+0#, *&0 ("#
,#)+0#, /'/73)+) 8+77 %&')+)( &*U d+e 1/;#'( '/.#F d++e 10&%#,-0#d)e 1#0*&0.#,F d+++e */%+7+(38"#0# #/%" 10&%#,-0# 8/) 1#0*&0.#,F /', d+Ve */%+7+(3 %7&)#)( (& #/%" 1/;#'(c)
0#)+,#'%#5
Z" V),Ai8:77 ](5?0%' :3%0;0( 7PP'?0%;),]X/.17# =/:# A &* D
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 62/95
DI T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
>( m(*(3(,0( G ("# ?&0./7+W/;&' ]':+'# -)#) ("# 10+V/%3 1&7+%3 0#%#+V#, *0&. ("#
=&7+%3 >-("&0+(3 (&U
+5 Q#17/%# #/%" 1/;#'( '/.# 8+(" / -'+`-# NNLNF
++5 Q#17/%# #/%" .#,+%/7 10&%#,-0# +'V&7V#, 8+(" / -'+`-# NNLN )& ("# )/.#
10&%#,-0# *&0 ,+f#0#'( 1/;#'() +) 0#*#00#, (& 23 ("# )/.# NNLNF
+++5 Q#17/%# ("# */%+7+(3 8"#0# #/%" 10&%#,-0# 8/) 1#0*&0.#, *&0 #/%" )1#%+P% 1/;#'(
8+(" / -'+`-# NNLN )& ("# )/.# */%+7+(3 *&0 ,+f#0#'( 1/;#'() +) 0#*#00#, (& 23 ("#
)/.# NNLNF /',+V5 Q#17/%# ("# */%+7+(3 %7&)#)( (& #/%" 1/;#'(c) 0#)+,#'%# 8+(" / -'+`-# NNLN )& ("#
)/.# */%+7+(3 *&0 ,+f#0#'( 1/;#'() +) 0#*#00#, (& 23 ("# )/.# NNLN5
L( )"&-7, 2# '&(#, ("/( /( ("+) 1&+'( ("# 0#7/;&')"+1 2#(8##' ,+f#0#'( ,/(/ #7#.#'()
d'&8 0#10#)#'(#, 23 NNLN)e +) #V+,#'( 2-( ("#0# +) '& +'*&0./;&' 0#v#%;': ("#
+,#';(3 &* 1/;#'()9 10&%#,-0#) &0 */%+7+;#) ,-# (& ("# 0#17/%#.#'( &* ("+) +'*&0./;&'8+(" NNLN)5
Z" V),Ai8:77 ](5?0%' :3%0;0( 7PP'?0%;),]X/.17# =/:# E &* D
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 63/95
DA T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
>( m(*(3(,0( U lM0()*;030-/ y#3)c d+5#59 R#3) ("/( +,#';*3 ("# 0#7/;&')"+1 2#(8##'
#/%" &'# &0 .&0# ,/(/ #7#.#'(9 +'%7-,+': ("# V/7-# &* ("# ,/(/ #7#.#'(d)e9 /', ("#NNLN -)#, (& 0#17/%# ("# &'# &0 .&0# ,/(/ #7#.#'(e /0# %0#/(#, ("/( %&'(/+'
+'*&0./;&' '#%#))/03 (& 0#O+,#';*3 1/;#'()9 10&%#,-0#) /', */%+7+;#)5 M0()*;030-/
y#3) /0# 0#(/+'#, +' / )#%-0# )3)(#. ,+0#%(&035
m(*(3(,0( X )"&8) ("/( ("# ?&0./7+W/;&' ]':+'#9 /%;': /) / =&7+%3 =0&(#%(#, N/(/
=0&X39 ,+)/))&%+/(#) #/%" NNLN /))&%+/(#, 8+(" / 1/;#'( '/.#9 10&%#,-0# &0 */%+7+(3
)-%" ("/( ("# 0#7/;&')"+1 2#(8##' ,+f#0#'( ,/(/ #7#.#'() +) '& 7&':#0 #V+,#'( d+5#59
8+("+' ("# ("# )3)(#.9 ,/(/ #7#.#'() /0# '& 7&':#0 0#v#%(#, +' 0#7/;&')"+1 (& &'#
/'&("#0e5 !"# ?&0./7+W/;&' ]':+'# %0#/(#) l 5&&.;%*7.- y#3)c d+5#59 R#3) ("# ,#P'# ("#
0#7/;&')"+1 2#(8##' ,+f#0#'( NNLN)e ("/( %&'(/+' ("# +'*&0./;&' '#%#))/03 (& 0#O
/))&%+/(# 1/;#'()9 10&%#,-0#) /', */%+7+;#) %&00#%(735 5&&.;%*7.- y#3) /0# 0#(/+'#, +'
/ )#%-0# )3)(#. ,+0#%(&035
>( m(*(3(,0( I ("# N/(/ ]X1&0(#0 )#',) ("# ,+)/))&%+/(#, NNLN) /', 5&&.;%*7.- y#3)
(& ("# N/(/ 4)/:# 63)(#.5
Z" V),Ai8:77 ](5?0%' :3%0;0( 7PP'?0%;),]X/.17# =/:# G &* D
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 64/95
DE T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
>( m(*(3(,0( T ("# N/(/ 4)/:# 63)(#. )#',) (& ("# +'(#',#, 0#%+1+#'( ("# NNLN) /',
5&&.;%*7.- y#3) '#%#))/03 (& 0#O/))&%+/(# NNLN) d*&0 )#%-0+(3 1-01&)#)9 ("# NNLN) /',
5&&.;%*7.- y#3) /0# )#'( )#1/0/(#73 ^&-( &* 2/',_ *0&. &'# /'&("#0e5 !"# +'(#',#,
0#%+1+#'( &'73 R'&8) ("/( ("# NNLN) 0#10#)#'(U
+5
L,#';P#0) 8"+%" /0# '&( )"&8' (& %&00#7/(# (& 1/;#'( '/.#)F
++5 >%;V+;#) 8"+%" /0# '&( )"&8' (& %&00#7/(# (& .#,+%/7 10&%#,-0#)F
+++5 j&%/;&') M/(#:&03 @ 8"+%" /0# '&( )"&8' (& %&00#7/(# (& ("# */%+7+(3 8"#0# #/%"
10&%#,-0# 8/) 1#0*&0.#,F /',+V5 j&%/;&') M/(#:&03 I 8"+%" /0# '&( )"&8' (& %&00#7/(# (& ("# */%+7+(3 %7&)#)( (& #/%"
1/;#'(c) 0#)+,#'%#5
Z+(" ("# /2&V# #'-.#0/(#, ,/(/9 ("# 0#%+1+#'( +) /27# (& 1#0*&0. ("# '#%#))/03
/'/73)#)5 !"# 0#%+1+#'( ,&#) '&( 0#`-+0#9 /', +) '&( 10&V+,#,9 /'3 *-0("#0 %&'(#X( /2&-(
("# ,/(/5 !"# 0#)-7() &* ("# /'/73)+) /0# )#'( (& ("# .#,+%/7 10/%;%# &8'#0) (& +'(#010#(("# 0#)-7() (& ,#(#0.+'# 8"#("#0 10&%#,-0#) 1#0*&0.#, /( ,+f#0#'( */%+7+;#) )"&-7, 2#
0#7&%/(#, (& 2#g#0 0#v#%( ("# 7&%/;&' &* ("# ./<&0+(3 &* ("#+0 1/;#'()5
Z" V),Ai8:77 ](5?0%' :3%0;0( 7PP'?0%;),]X/.17# =/:# D &* D
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 65/95
DG T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
ZM i8:77 /3?,2 n)43 HC, <(E?0( K/nH<L 7PP'?0%;),]X/.17# =/:# @ &* D
!"# *&77&8+': D )7+,#) )"&8 "&8 >'&'&) ./3 "#71 #'/27# ("# 1&1-7/0 -)# &* r0+':
s&-0 p8' N#V+%# drspNe 10/%;%#) +' "#/7("%/0# 8"+7# )/*#:-/0,+': 1/;#'( 0#%&0,)5
!"+) #X/.17# &* / 10&1&)#, -)# &* N3'/.+% >'&'3.+(3 )"&8) "&8 [#/7(" M/0#
=0&V+,#0) d[M=)e %/' R##1 / %&13 &* ]7#%(0&'+% [#/7("%/0# Q#%&0,) d][Qe ,/(/ *&0
("#+0 1/;#'() &' / rspN /( 8&0R9 8+(" ("# -'+`-# +,#';P#0) 0#.&V#, *&0 1/;#'(
'/.#9 .#,+%/7 "+)(&039 ,+/:'&)+)9 /', (0#/(.#'( +'*&0./;&' /', 0#17/%#, 8+("
NNLN)5 L* ("#0# +) / ("#z &* ("# ,#V+%#9 &'73 ("# NNLN) /0# 0#10#)#'(#, &' ("#
%7+'+%+/' rspN5 !"+) 8&-7, 10#V#'( ("# /%%+,#'(/7 #X1&)-0# &* )#%-0# 1/;#'( ,/(/ +'
("# #V#'( &* / ("#z &* ("# rspN +(#.5 L' /,,+;&' (& ("# NNLN) '&( 0#V#/7+': ("#
-'+`-# +,#';P#0) *&0 1/;#'( '/.#9 .#,+%/7 "+)(&039 ,+/:'&)+)9 /', (0#/(.#'(
+'*&0./;&'9 ("# NNLN) /77&8 *&0 0#V#0)/7 &* /%%#)) 0+:"() /) 8#77 /) 0#17/%#.#'( &*
("# V/7-#) /))&%+/(#, 8+(" ("# NNLN)5
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 66/95
DD T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
ZM i8:77 /3?,2 n)43 HC, <(E?0( K/nH<L 7PP'?0%;),]X/.17# =/:# I &* D
dN#(/+7#, ]X17/'/;&' 10&V+,#, &' *&77&8+': 1/:#)e
K L
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 67/95
DC T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
ZM i8:77 /3?,2 n)43 HC, <(E?0( K/nH<L 7PP'?0%;),]X/.17# =/:# A &* D
>( m(*(3(,0( " [&)1+(/7 2/)#, 0#)+,#'( ,&8'7&/,) ("# ,/3c) 1/;#'( 7+)( (& "+)
7/1(&1 B 1"&'# )& ("/( "# %/' P'+)" "+) B "#0 '&(#) *0&. "&.#5
m(*(3(,0( M )"&8) ("/( #/%" &* ("# .#,+%/7 */%+7+;#) )(&0#) .#,+%/7 0#%&0,) +' /'
+',+V+,-/7 N/(/ 6(&0# d+' ("+) #X/.17#9 #/%" N/(/ 6(&0# )(&0#) ,/(/ +' / ,+f#0#'(
*&0./(e5
m(*(3(,0( O )"&8) ("/( ("# ,/(/ *0&. #/%" &* ("# N/(/ 6(&0#) +) 10&%#))#, 23 /
N/(/ L.1&0(#0 (& %&'V#0( ,+f#0#'( ,/(/ *&0./() +'(& / %/'&'+%/7 ,/(/ .&,#75
>( m(*(3(,0( F ("# =&7+%3 >-("&0+(3 /117+#) / 1&7+%3 (& )#1/0/(# %&'(#X( *0&. ,/(/
\ +5#59 ,/(/ #7#.#'() /0# +,#';P#,9 )#1/0/(#, /', ^(/::#,_ +' / ./''#0 ("/( ,&#)
'&( 0#V#/7 .#/'+': &0 0#7/;&')"+1) 2#(8##' ,/(/ #7#.#'() 8+("&-( /%%#)) (&
,+0#%(&0+#) ("/( 8+77 2# ./+'(/+'#, )#%-0#73 23 ("# )3)(#.5 L' ("+) #X/.17#9
+'*&0./;&' 0#`-+0#, *&0 ("# ,#)+0#, /'/73)+) 8+77 %&')+)( &*U d+e 1/;#'( '/.#F d++e,+/:'&)+)F d+++e .#,+%/7 "+)(&03F /', d+Ve 10#)%0+1;&' +'*&0./;&'5
K L '
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 68/95
DH T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
ZM i8:77 /3?,2 n)43 HC, <(E?0( K/nH<L 7PP'?0%;),]X/.17# =/:# E &* D
>( m(*(3(,0( G ("# ?&0./7+W/;&' ]':+'# -)#) ("# 10+V/%3 1&7+%3 0#%#+V#, *0&. ("#
=&7+%3 >-("&0+(3 (&U
+5 Q#17/%# #/%" 1/;#'( '/.# 8+(" / -'+`-# NNLNF
++5 Q#17/%# #/%" .#,+%/7 ,+/:'&)+) 8+(" / -'+`-# NNLN )& ("# )/.# ,+/:'&)+) *&0
,+f#0#'( 1/;#'() +) 0#*#00#, (& 23 ("# )/.# NNLNF
+++5 Q#17/%# %&.1&'#'() &* ("# .#,+%/7 "+)(&03 *&0 #/%" 1/;#'( 8+(" -'+`-#
NNLN) )& ("# )/.# #7#.#'() &* .#,+%/7 "+)(&03 *&0 ,+f#0#'( 1/;#'() +)
0#*#00#, (& 23 ("# )/.# NNLN)F /',
+V5 Q#17/%# 10#)%0+1;&' +'*&0./;&' 8+(" -'+`-# NNLN) )& ("# )/.# 10#)%0+1;&')
*&0 ,+f#0#'( 1/;#'() /0# 0#*#00#, (& 23 ("# )/.# NNLN)5
L( )"&-7, 2# '&(#, ("/( /( ("+) 1&+'( ("# 0#7/;&')"+1 2#(8##' ,+f#0#'( ,/(/
#7#.#'() d'&8 0#10#)#'(#, 23 NNLN)e +) #V+,#'( 2-( ("#0# +) '& +'*&0./;&'
0#v#%;': ("# +,#';(3 &* 1/;#'()9 ,+/:'&)+)9 .#,+%/7 "+)(&03 &0 10#)%0+1;&' ,-# (&("# 0#17/%#.#'( &* ("+) +'*&0./;&' 8+(" NNLN)5
M ? H ? K H L '? ;
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 69/95
DK T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
ZM i8:77 /3?,2 n)43 HC, <(E?0( K/nH<L 7PP'?0%;),]X/.17# =/:# G &* D
>( m(*(3(,0( U lM0()*;030-/ y#3)c d+5#59 R#3) ("/( +,#';*3 ("# 0#7/;&')"+1
2#(8##' #/%" &'# &0 .&0# ,/(/ #7#.#'()9 +'%7-,+': ("# V/7-# &* ("# ,/(/#7#.#'(d)e9 /', ("# NNLN -)#, (& 0#17/%# ("# &'# &0 .&0# ,/(/ #7#.#'()e /0#
%0#/(#, ("/( %&'(/+' +'*&0./;&' '#%#))/03 (& 0#O+,#';*3 1/;#'()9 ,+/:'&)+)9
.#,+%/7 "+)(&039 /', 10#)%0+1;&' +'*&0./;&'5 M0()*;030-/ y#3) /0# 0#(/+'#, +' /
)#%-0# )3)(#. ,+0#%(&035
m(*(3(,0( X )"&8) ("/( ("# ?&0./7+W/;&' ]':+'#9 /%;': /) / =&7+%3 =0&(#%(#,
N/(/ =0&X39 ,+)/))&%+/(#) #/%" NNLN /))&%+/(#, 8+(" / 1/;#'( '/.#9 .#,+%/7
"+)(&03 &0 ,+/:'&)+) )-%" ("/( ("# 0#7/;&')"+1 2#(8##' ,+f#0#'( ,/(/ #7#.#'() +)
'& 7&':#0 #V+,#'( d+5#59 8+("+' ("# )3)(#.9 ,/(/ #7#.#'() /0# '& 7&':#0 0#v#%(#, +'
0#7/;&')"+1 (& &'# /'&("#0e5 !"# ?&0./7+W/;&' ]':+'# %0#/(#) l 5&&.;%*7.-
y#3)c d+5#59 R#3) ("# ,#P'# ("# 0#7/;&')"+1 2#(8##' ,+f#0#'( NNLN)e ("/( %&'(/+'
("# +'*&0./;&' '#%#))/03 (& 0#O/))&%+/(# 1/;#'()9 10&%#,-0#) /', */%+7+;#)
%&00#%(735 5&&.;%*7.- y#3) /0# 0#(/+'#, +' / )#%-0# )3)(#. ,+0#%(&035
ZM i8:77 / ? n H < ? K/nH<L 7 '? ;
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 70/95
CJ T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
ZM i8:77 /3?,2 n)43 HC, <(E?0( K/nH<L 7PP'?0%;),]X/.17# =/:# D &* D
>( m(*(3(,0( I ("# N/(/ ]X1&0(#0 )#',) ("# ,+)/))&%+/(#, NNLN) /', 5&&.;%*7.-
y#3) (& ("# N/(/ 4)/:# 63)(#.5
>( m(*(3(,0( T ("# N/(/ 4)/:# 63)(#. )#',) (& ("# +'(#',#, 0#%+1+#'( ("# NNLN)
/', 5&&.;%*7.- y#3) '#%#))/03 (& 0#O/))&%+/(# NNLN) d*&0 )#%-0+(3 1-01&)#)9 ("#
NNLN) /', 5&&.;%*7.- y#3) /0# )#'( )#1/0/(#73 ^&-( &* 2/',_ *0&. &'# /'&("#0e5
!"# +'(#',#, 0#%+1+#'( &'73 R'&8) ("/( ("# NNLN) 0#10#)#'(U
+5
L,#';P#0) 8"+%" /0# '&( )"&8' (& %&00#7/(# (& 1/;#'( '/.#)F
++5 !#0.+'&7&:3 8"+%" +) '&( )"&8' (& %&00#7/(# (& ,+/:'&)+) &0 (0#/(.#'(F
+++5
p0,#0 )#() 8"+%" /0# '&( )"&8' (& %&00#7/(# (& ("# 1/;#'( %"/0(F /',
+V5 b#,+%/;&' -1,/(#) 8"+%" /0# '&( )"&8' (& %&00#7/(# (& ("# 10#)%0+1;&' ,/(/5
ZO i '-D : - ' 7 '? ;
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 71/95
C@ T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
• N3'/.+% >'&'3.+(3 %&-7, "#71 +' ("# *&77&8+': )%#'/0+&U
•
> )&z8/0# V#',&0 10&V+,#) / 1&0(/7 *&0 / 8+,# V/0+#(3 &* %7+'+%) (& -)# 8"+%"/77&8) 1/;#'() (& /%%#)) ("#+0 &8' .#,+%/7 0#%&0,)5
• 6&z8/0# /77&8) *&0 .-7;17# .#.2#0) &* / */.+73 B :0&-1 B -'+( &* V/0+&-)
/:#) (& /%%#)) #/%" &("#0)c 1/;#'( /', .#,+%/7 0#%&0,) /) ,#(#0.+'#, 8+("
,3'/.+% 1#0.+))+&'+':5
• Z"#' / .#.2#0 &* / :0&-1 7#/V#) ("# -'+(9 ("# Y-)+&' M0()*;030-/
%/1/2+7+;#) &* >'&'&) %&-7, 2# 7#V#0/:#, (& %&.17#(#73 d/', `-+%R73e
10#V#'( *-0("#0 /%%#)) (& .#,+%/7 ,/(/ *&0 ("&)# 7#z +' ("# -'+(5
• Y&0 #X/.17#9 +* / %&-17# ,+V&0%#) /', ("# 8+*# +) :+V#' %-)(&,3 &*
%"+7,0#'9 )"# ./3 8/'( (& %-( &f /%%#)) 23 "#0 "-)2/', (& "#0 /', "#0
%"+7,0#'c) .#,+%/7 ,/(/5
ZO i(%'-D0%3( :)3-%' 7PP'?0%;),]X/.17# =/:# @ &* @
ZF Y &' i '-D 7 '? ;
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 72/95
CI T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
• N3'/.+% >'&'3.+(3 %&-7, "#71 +' ("# *&77&8+': )%#'/0+&U
•
!"# ,/(/ *0&. 8#/0/27# P('#)) ,#V+%#) d#5:59 Y+(2+()e +) 2#+': 0#`-#)(#, (& 2# -)#, 230#)#/0%"#0) 8+("+' 7/0:# (#/%"+': "&)1+(/7)5
• N/(/ +) :/("#0#, 23 +',+V+,-/7)c 8#/0/27# ,#V+%#)9 /', %&'(/+' / 7/0:# /.&-'( &* ("#+0 1#0)&'/7
+'*&0./;&' )-%" /) '/.#9 2+0(",/3 B /:#9 /,,0#))9 "#+:"(9 8#+:"(9 #(%5
•
!"# @%&*&&.;%*7.-9 S/7-# M0()*;030-/ /', Y-)+&' M0()*;030-/ %/1/2+7+;#) &* >'&'&) %&-7,
2# 7#V#0/:#, )& ("/(U• Q#)#/0%" "&)1+(/7) %&-7, %&77#%( ("# ,/(/ /', /'/73W# +( (& ,#(#0.+'# "&8 V/0+&-) 7#V#7)
&* 1"3)+%/7 /%;V+;#) +.1/%( ("# )(-,3 :0&-1 8"+%" %/' ("#' 2# -)#, +' 0#:/0, (&
+',+V+,-/7) 2/)#, -1&' :#',#09 /:#9 8#+:"(9 7&%/;&'9 #(%5F /',
•
Q#)#/0%" "&)1+(/7) %&-7, %&.2+'# ("# ,/(/ 8+(" )&.# &* ("# /))&%+/(#, ,/(/ )-2<#%()c
.#,+%/7 ,/(/ d8+("&-( R'&8+': ("# +,#';(3 &* ("# ,/(/ )-2<#%() ,-# (& / %&.2+'/;&' &*
*-0("#0 @%&*&&.;%*7.-9 S/7-# M0()*;030-/ /', Y-)+&' M0()*;030-/B (& )## "&8 +( ./3+.1/%( ,+)#/)#)9 +77'#))#)9 %"0&'+% %&',+;&') d#5:59 %"0&'+% &2)(0-%;V# 1-7.&'/03 ,+)#/)#
O Mp=Ne5
ZF Y(%3%&'( i(%'-D0%3( 7PP'?0%;),]X/.17# =/:# @ &* @
ZG Y? ' + ? \ VN7 7 - 8 * ;
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 73/95
CA T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
ZG Y?3('(.. +%33?(3 \ VN7 700(.. -) 8,*)3>%;),]X/.17# =/:# @ &* E
!"# *&77&8+': E )7+,#) )"&8 "&8 >'&'&) ./3 "#71 (& 2/7/'%# )/*#:-/0,) *&0
1#0)&'/7 10+V/%3 /', 7#:+;./(# +'(#0#)() &* :&V#0'.#'( /:#'%+#) d7+R# ("# ?6>e (&/'/73W# +'*&0./;&' /', +'V#);:/(# )-)1+%+&-) )+(-/;&')5
L' ("+) %/)#9 N3'/.+% >'&'3.+(3 %&-7, 2# +.17#.#'(#, 23 / 8+0#7#)) %/00+#0 /',
NNLN) %&-7, ,3'/.+%/773 ./)R %#0(/+' P#7,) +' %/77 ,#(/+7 0#%&0,) (& #'/27# ?6>
.&,#7+': *&0 )-)1+%+&-) 2#"/V+&0 8"+7# 10&(#%;': -)#0 10+V/%35 r/)#, &'
.&,#7+': 0#)-7()9 ("# ?6> %&-7, )#%-0# / 8/00/'( *&0 ("# R#3) (& 10&V+,# )&.# &0
/77 &* ("# ./)R#, ,/(/5
ZG Y? ' + ? \ VN7 7 - 8 * ;
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 74/95
CE T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
ZG Y?3('(.. +%33?(3 \ VN7 700(.. -) 8,*)3>%;),]X/.17# =/:# I &* E
• +433(,-'=b %/77 ,#(/+7 0#%&0,) 10&V+,# / 8#/7(" &* +'*&0./;&' *&0 ?6> /';O(#00&0+)(#f&0() \ )"&8' /) / )+.17+P#, #X/.17# /2&V#
•
!"# %"/77#':# +) 10&V+,+': /%%#)) (& #'&-:" +'*&0./;&' *&0 #f#%;V# ?6> ,/(/.&,#7+': 8"+7# 10&(#%;': -)#0 10+V/%35
• N3'/.+%/773 %"/':+': NNLN) #.17&3#, 23 / %/00+#0 %&-7, (0/')*&0. )&.# ,/(/ 2-(7#/V# &("#0 ,/(/ +' ("# &1#' ("#0#23 10&V+,+': / 2/7/'%# &* P0)( 7#V#7 +'*&0./;&' *&0.&,#7+': /', 10+V/%3 10&(#%;&'5
ZG Y?3('(.. +%33?(3 \ VN7 700(.. -) 8,*)3>%;),
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 75/95
CG T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
ZG Y?3('(.. +%33?(3 \ VN7 700(.. -) 8,*)3>%;),]X/.17# =/:# A &* E
• Y?-D 5=,%>?0 %,),=>?-=b ?6> .&,#7+': %&-7, &%%-0 8"+7#
10&(#%;': 10+V/%35• L* ("# .&,#7+': 0#)-7() .##( ("# )(/',/0, *&0 ("# +))-/'%# &* /
8/00/'(9 ("# %/00+#0 8&-7, 10&V+,# ("# >))&%+/;&' y#3) d>y)e /', B
&0 Q#17/%#.#'( y#3) dQy)e /) &0,#0#, +' ("# 8/00/'(5
• =&)( ,#7+V#03 &* ("# NNLN R#3) /', / ,#(#0.+'/;&' ("/( ("# -)#0 +)
'&( -',#0 )-)1+%+&'9 ("# %/00+#0 %&-7, %"/':# ("# NNLN) *&0 ("#
0#%&0,) +' `-#);&'9 0#(-0'+': ("# -)#0 (& /'&'3.&-) )(/(-)5
ZG Y?3('(.. +%33?(3 \ VN7 700(.. -) 8,*)3>%;),
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 76/95
CD T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
ZG Y?3('(.. +%33?(3 \ VN7 700(.. -) 8,*)3>%;),]X/.17# =/:# E &* E
ZU 8)$ 8,-(3,(- )* $D?,2.
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 77/95
CC T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
ZU 8)$ R 8,-(3,(- )* $D?,2.]X/.17# =/:# @ &* G
M&')-.#0 /,&1;&' &* L&! )#0V+%#) ./3 )-f#0 *0&. ("# 7/%R &* 1#0%#+V#,
10+V/%3U
• x/0('#0 10#,+%() 23 IJIJ9 ("#0# 8+77 2# IDr %&''#%(#, ,#V+%#) /0&-',
("# 8&07, %&.1/0#, (& C5Ar )./0(1"&'#)9 (/27#() /', =M) %&.2+'#,5
• GK} &* 46 +'(#0'#( -)#0) R'&8 ("/( )./0( ,#V+%#) %/' %&77#%(
+'*&0./;&' /2&-( ("#+0 1#0)&'/7 /%;V+;#) /', HC} /0# Mp?M]Q?]N
>rp4! ![] !s=] &* +'*&0./;&' %&77#%(#, ("0&-:" )./0( ,#V+%#)d!Q46!#e5
• :<*$ +#"+1/" ,/("$8(,1$ *",# *"76$,/' 7*$,/6$, =<1/1 #"8' jjs A118
,<(, ,<1 51"1>,$ #A $)(/, 710*+1$ #6,=1*4< ./*0(+' +#"+1/"$G
ZU 8)$ 8,-(3,(- )* $D?,2.
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 78/95
CH T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
ZU 8)$ R 8,-(3,(- )* $D?,2.]X/.17# =/:# I &* G
Z"&. /0# 8# %&.*&0(/27# )"/0+': 1#0)&'/7 ,/(/ 8+(" (&,/3 *0&. )./0( ,#V+%#)~
$maN$
F!s i(%'-D :3)*(..?),%'.
UOs NP)4.(\ N?2,?B0%,- H-D(3
F"s +').( 63?(,5.
O!s :)'?0(
MIs 8,.43%,0( +)>P%,?(.
MUs /)..
MMs N4P(3>%31(-.
M!s c,(32= +)>P%,?(.
"Fs 75 +)>P%,?(.
"Fs `)E(3,>(,-
L1)&) bpQL &' 2#"/7* &* !Q46!#9 dY#20-/03 IJ@Ee
ZU 8)$ 8,-(3,(- )* $D?,2.
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 79/95
CK T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
ZU 8)$ R 8,-(3,(- )* $D?,2.]X/.17# =/:# A &* G
8,.43%,0( 8)$ a.( +%.(
r#' ,0+V#) / )1&0() %/0 /', "/) 2##' -)+':U
•
> *0## )./0(1"&'# /11 /', r7-#(&&(" #'/27#, prNj+'R d/ ,#V+%# /-(& )"&1) -)# (& ,+/:'&)# 3&-0 %/0e 8"+%":+V#) "+. +'*&0./;&' 7+R# 0#/7O;.# *##,2/%R &' ,0+V+':9 /V#0/:# )1##,9 (0+1 7&:)9 /%%#)) (& V#"+%7#
,+/:'&);%) 8"#' ("#0# +) / 10&27#.9 :/) )(/;&' 10+%#) 2/)#, &' 7&%/;&'9 #(%5F /',
•
> ,/)"2&/0, %/.#0/ (& 0#%&0, "+) %/0c) 1#0*&0./'%# "/',7+': ,-0+': )&.# &* "+) ,0+V#) O 8"+%" "# 1&)() (&
"+) s&-!-2# /%%&-'( O 8"+%" /7)& 7&:) 7&%/;&' /', ,0+V+': )1##, +' ("# V+,#&c) .#(/,/(/5
Q#%#'(73 "+) +')-0/'%# 10#.+-.) )(/0(#, (& 0+)# ,#)1+(# ("# */%( ("/( "# "/) '&( "/, /' /%%+,#'( &0 ;%R#(5
r#'c) )./0(1"&'# /117+%/;&' 10&V+,#0 )#77) ,/(/ (& +')-0/'%# %&.1/'+#) /) 1/0( &* ("#+0 2-)+'#)) .&,#75 !"+)
,/(/ 1&0(0/3) r#' /) /' /::0#))+V# ,0+V#0 +' ("# #3#) &* "+) +')-0/'%# 10&V+,#0 /', /7)& )"&8) "# "/) 2##'
*0#`-#';': /0#/) &* ("# %+(3 ,-0+': ("# 8##R#', 8+(" "+:" %/0 ("#z 0/(#)5 !"# +')-0/'%# %&.1/'3 /7)& 0#:-7/073
)%/') -)#0 :#'#0/(#, %&'(#'( *0&. ("# 8#2 7&&R+': *&0 /::0#))+V# ,0+V+': 2#"/V+&0)F -)+': ("#+0 ^r+: N/(/_ /))#()
("#3 /0# /27# (& %&00#7/(# ("# .#(/,/(/ *0&. ("# V+,#& 8+(" ("# +'*&0./;&' ("#3 "/V# 0#%#+V#, *0&. "+)
)./0(1"&'# /117+%/;&'5 !"+) "/) "#71#, ("#. 2-+7, / %&'(#X(-/7 10&P7# *&0 r#' ("/( +' (-0' ./,# ("# +')-0/'%#
%&.1/'3 0/+)# r#'c) 10#.+-.)5 N&+': )& "#71) ("# +')-0/'%# %&.1/'3 2#g#0 %&'(0&7 10#.+-.) *&0 7#))O
/::0#))+V# ,0+V#0) 8"+7# /7)& +'%0#/)+': 10&P() *&0 ("# %&.1/'35
ZU 8)$ R 8,-(3,(- )* $D?,2.
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 80/95
HJ T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
ZU 8)$ R 8,-(3,(- )* $D?,2.]X/.17# =/:# E &* G
[(= %,5 <%-%+)33('%;), <?3(0-)3=
7 , ) , ) . + ) $ c , 2 ? , (
d N # % & - 1 7 # ) M & ' ( # X ( - ) + ' : N N L N c ) e
=0+V/%3 6#0V+%# r-0#/- b&,#7
/4.?,(.. m4'(. %,5
N(043?-= :)'?0=
N-(P Z"A 85(,;B%&'( <%-%K8,P4-L
N-(P ZMA &*$($$#+*(3#" %,5
D1.8(+1)1",KH4-P4-L
N-(P ZOA :(3>%,(,- 7..?2,>(,-@ or-)+'#)) Q-7#)_ :&V#0' ("/( ("# NNLNc) "/V# 2#%&.# 1#0./'#'(73 /))+:'#, (& ("/( ,/(/ &-(1-( +')(/'%# 8"#' 0#7#/)#, (&
#X(#0'/7 1/0;#)5
<%-% N(- 700)4,- Z V%>( `:N W)0%;), NP((5 K]:iL $3?P <3?E(3 N0)3( J(D?0'( $=P( J(D?0'( n(%3 J(D?0'( <?%2,).;0.
{@ @AEDCK r#' !0-)(3 AEAIGE?5JHGAGIEZ CG DGB@JJ rbZ GAG+ IJ@A x0##'
{I @AEDCK r#' !0-)(3 A@J@JE?5JHCIKA@Z HJ EGB@JJ rbZ GAG+ IJ@A s#77&8
6./0(M/0
M7&-,
6#0V+%#
N/(/>=L
b/'/:#.#'(
N/(/ >=L
<%-% N(- 700)4,- Z V%>( `:N W)0%;), NP((5 K]:iL $3?P <3?E(3 N0)3( J(D?0'( $=P( J(D?0'( n(%3 J(D?0'( <?%2,).;0.
{@ =@•I}A AAEExxm dx@[Ge >7/2/./ CG DGB@JJ rbZ GAG+ IJ@A x0##'
{I pE€~C{ KKCCmmx dx@[Ge >7/2/./ HJ EGB@JJ rbZ GAG+ IJ@A s#77&8
8)$ &*$($$#+*(3#" %,5
D1.8(+1)1",
ZU 8)$ R 8,-(3,(- )* $D?,2.
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 81/95
H@ T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
ZU 8)$ R 8,-(3,(- )* $D?,2.]X/.17# =/:# G &* G
L' ("+) /117+%/;&' &* N3'/.+% >'&'3.+(39 @%&*&&.;%*7.- /', M0()*;030-/ 8+("NNLNc) #')-0#U
• r#' %/''&( 2# 1#0)&'/773 +,#';P#, 23 ("# ,/(/ "# +) (0/').+k': 2/%R (& ("#
%7&-, )#0V+%# 10&V+,#0F
• !"# %7&-, )#0V+%# 10&V+,#0 +) /27# (& %&';'-# 8+(" ("#+0 2-)+'#)) .&,#7 /', )#77
-)#*-7 ,/(/ (& +')-0/'%# %&.1/'+#)F /',
•
!"# +')-0/'%# %&.1/'3 +) );77 /27# (& /::0#:/(# V+/27# 0#:+&'/7 ,/(/ (& ./R#
2-)+'#)) ,#%+)+&')9 2-( -'/27# (& (/0:#( /', ,+)%0+.+'/(# /:/+')( )1#%+P% -)#0)
("0&-:" / %&'(#X(-/7 10&P7#5
ZX 7,%'=.?. )* :)-(,;%' +4.-)>(3 /%.(
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 82/95
HI T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
ZX 7,%'=.?. )* :)-(,;%' +4.-)>(3 /%.(]X/.17# =/:# @ &* @
• L' 0#(-0' *&0 )1#%+/7 &f#0) &0 &("#0 %&'%#))+&') &f#0#, 23 10&10+#(&0)9 N3'/.+%
>'&'3.+(3 ,/(/ )-2<#%() %&-7, #7#%( (& "/V# +'*&0./;&' %&'%#0'+': ("#. )"/0#, 8+("
10&10+#(&0) +' /' %,),=>)4. *%.D?), 8"#' ("#3 #'(#0 &0 /0# 8+("+' / 10#)%0+2#,,+)(/'%# d#5:59 @ .+7#9 @JJJ *##(9 IJ *##(9 &0 &("#0 ,+)(/'%# ,#1#',+': -1&' ("#
+.17#.#'(/;&'e *0&. / )(&0# 23 .#/') &* ,3'/.+%/773 %"/':+': /', 0#O/))+:'/27#
NNLN) 0/("#0 ("/' /' /,V#0;)+': +,#';P#0 +' .&2+7# 1"&'#)5
• L' ("+) ./''#09 10&10+#(&0)BV#',&0) %&-7, "/V# / "+:"73 /%%-0/(# /::0#:/(#, V+#8 &*
("#+0 1&(#';/7 %-)(&.#0 2/)# \ +' (#0.) &* /:#9 :#',#09 +'%&.#9 #(%5 :#'#0/773 /) 8#77/) /( ,+f#0#'( ;.#) &* ("# ,/3 B ,/3) &* ("# 8##R ("/( %&-7, "#71 ("#. .&0# #f#%;V#73
,#(#0.+'# ,#)+0#, +'V#'(&03 /', &("#0 )/7#) /%;V+;#)5
• N3'/.+% >'&'3.+(3 ,/(/ )-2<#%() 8&-7, 2#'#P( *0&. )1#%+/7 /00/':#.#'() C?-D)4-
(E(3 D%E?,2 -) 3(E(%' -D(?3 P(3.),%' ?,*)3>%;), (& 10&10+#(&0) d8"& 8&-7, )+.173
R'&8 ("/( / ,/(/ )-2<#%( 8/) / N3'/.+% >'&'3.+(3 )-2)%0+2#0 2-( 8&-7, '&( R'&8
8"/( )1#%+P% +'*&0./;&' (& /))&%+/(# 8+(" ("# 1/0;%-7/0 ,/(/ )-2<#%(e5
ZI m(%'A$?>( +4.-)>?S%;),
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 83/95
HA T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
ZI m(%'A$?>( +4.-)>?S%;),]X/.17# =/:# @ &* @
L'*&0./;&' 0#:/0,+': N3'/.+% >'&'3.+(3O#'/27#, +'*&0./;&' *0&. .-7;17# ,/(/
)-2<#%() %&-7, 2# -)#, (& %-)(&.+W# -)#0 #X1#0+#'%# B &11&0(-'+(3 /( 7&%/;&') 8"#0#
N3'/.+% >'&'3.+(3 ,/(/ )-2)%0+2#0) :/("#0 8+("&-( 0#`-+0+': ("/( 1#0)&'/7 +,#';*3+':+'*&0./;&' 2# 0#V#/7#, \ _'#6 7#"^, <(01 ,# ;"#= =<# - () ,# ./#0*71 )1 =*,< (
.1/$#"(8*Y17 12.1/*1"+1G] Y&0 #X/.17#U
• L' )(&0#) 8"#0# V+,#& )%0##') /0# 17/%#, ("0&-:" ("# )(&0#9 ("# )(&0# %&-7, R'&8 +' 0#/7
;.# 8"#' ("#3 "/V# / 7/0:# 10&1&0;&'/7 %-)(&.#0 2/)# &* / )1#%+P% :#',#09 /:#9
+'%&.# 7#V#79 #(%5 /', %&-7, 17/3 V+,#&) (/0:#(#, (& )-%" ,#.&:0/1"+% /', %"/':# ("#
V+,#&) 17/3+': /) ("# %&.1&)+;&' &* )"&11#0) %"/':#) ("0&-:"&-( ("# ,/3 8+("&-("/V+': (& R'&8 ("# /%(-/7 +,#';(3 &* ("# N3'/.+% >'&'3.+(3 )-2)%0+2#0) \ &'73
0#7#V/'( ,#.&:0/1"+% +'*&0./;&' '##, 2# )"/0#, &' / ,3'/.+%/773 /'&'3.&-) 2/)+)
23 .#/') &* NNLN)5
•
>( / %&'%#0( 23 / 2/', ("/( 17/3) %&-'(03 8#)(#0' /', :&)1#7 .-)+%9 ("# 2/', %&-7,
,#(#0.+'# ("/( ("# ./<&0+(3 &* N3'/.+% >'&'3.+(3 )-2)%0+2#0) /g#',+': ("# %&'%#0(
10#*#00#, :&)1#7 .-)+% /', /,<-)( ("#+0 )&': )#7#%;&' *&0 ("# %&'%#0( /%%&0,+':738+("&-( "/V+': (& R'&8 ("# /%(-/7 +,#';(3 &* ("# N3'/.+% >'&'3.+(3 )-2)%0+2#0) \ &'73
0#7#V/'( ,#.&:0/1"+% +'*&0./;&' '##, 2# )"/0#, &' / ,3'/.+%/773 /'&'3.&-) 2/)+)
23 .#/') &* NNLN)5
ZT i?2D'= :(3?.D%&'( `))5. 7PP'?0%;),
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 84/95
HE T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
ZT i?2D'= :(3?.D%&'( ̀ ))5. 7PP'?0%;),]X/.17# =/:# @ &* @
• >' +',+V+,-/7 N3'/.+% >'&'3.+(3 -)#0 8+(" /' #)(/27+)"#, 1/g#0' &0 10#*#0#'%# *&0
2-3+': "+:"73 1#0+)"/27# *0#)"O%-( v&8#0)9 *&&,)(-f) &0 &("#0 +(#.) ("/( 7&)# ("#+0
-)#*-7'#)) /', V/7-# +* '&( -;7+W#, 8+("+' / )"&0( 1#0+&, &* ;.# %&-7, #7#%( (& "/V# /'
/7#0( )#'( (& 10&10+#(&0) &* )(&0#) 8"+%" )#77 )-%" +(#.) 8"#' ("# -)#0 #'(#0)9 &0 +)
8+("+' / 10#)%0+2#, ,+)(/'%# *0&.9 ("# )(&0#5
• !"# /7#0( 8&-7, '&;*3 ("# )(&0#) ("/( / "+:"73 `-/7+P#, 10&)1#%;V# %-)(&.#0 d+5#59
)&.#&'# 8+(" ("# /2+7+(3 (& 1/3 /', /' #)(/27+)"#, "+)(&03 &* ./R+': )+.+7/0 1-0%"/)#)e
+) 8+("+' /' /%;&'/27# ,+)(/'%# &* ("#+0 )(&0# \ / 10#0#`-+)+(# *&0 %&')-../;':
(0/')/%;&') :+V#' ("# 1#0+)"/27# '/(-0# &* ("# )-2<#%( +'V#'(&035
• Z+("&-( "/V+': (& R'&8 ("# +,#';(3 &* ("# 10&)1#%;V# %-)(&.#09 ("# 10&10+#(&0 %&-7,
)#', ("# -)#0 V+/ N3'/.+% >'&'3.+(3 '&;P%/;&' / )1#%+/7 -'1-27+%+W#, &f#0 *&0 ("#
+(#.d)e5 L* ("# N3'/.+% >'&'3.+(3 -)#0 P',) ("# )1#%+/7 &f#0 )-i%+#'(73 /g0/%;V#9 ("#3
%/' &* ("#+0 &8' V&7+;&' :& (& ("# %&-'(#0 /', %&')-../(# ("# )/7#5 >7(#0'/;V#739 ("#
N3'/.+% >'&'3.+(3 -)#0 %&-7, %"&&)# (& ./R# / %&-'(#0O&f#0 &0 +:'&0# ("# )1#%+/7&f#0 8+("&-( #V#0 +,#';*3+': "+.)#7* &0 "#0)#7* (& ("# 10&10+#(&05
Z"! ])&?'( <(E?0(. %,5 W)0%;), N(3E?0(.
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 85/95
HG T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
> N3'/.+% >'&'3.+(3 10+V/%3 %7+#'( ./3 2# -)#, &' / .&2+7# ,#V+%# (& )("(41 /1(8C3)1 ;"#=81741 #A
8#+(3#"T (+30*,'T ("7 R #/ 51<(0*#/ #A ,<1 .<#"1 ("7 *,$ #="1/ t ,<1 &(,( H65S1+, 5 !"# 1"&'# ./3 /7)&
(0/').+(9 0#%#+V# /', 10&%#)) +'*&0./;&' *0&. &("#0 ,#V+%#) /', +'*&0./;&' )&-0%#) +( +'(#0/%() 8+("
/-(&./;%/773 &0 V+/ ("# N/(/ 6-2<#%(c) /%;V+(35 4)# &* NNLN) ./'/:#, 23 10+V/%3 1&7+%+#) #)(/27+)"#, 23 ("#N/(/ 6-2<#%( B !0-)(#, =/0(3 )+:'+P%/'(73 0#,-%# ("# 7+R#7+"&&, &* ,/(/ 10&P7+': 8+("&-( 1#0.+))+&' /) 8#77 /)
("# .+)-)# &* ,/(/9 +'%7-,+': ,+)%0+.+'/;&'9 ("#z9 #(%5
>) .&2+7# /11) +'(#0/%( 8+(" ("# 1"&'#9 NNLN) #'/27# ("# N/(/ 6-2<#%( &0 !0-)(#, =/0(3 (& %&'(0&7 2&(" ("#
;.+': /', 7#V#7 &* 1/0;%+1/;&' +' 7&%/;&' /', ;.# )#')+;V# 0#`-#)() *0&. /11)9 /) 8#77 /) ("# ,#:0## (&
8"+%" +'*&0./;&' +) )"/0#, 8+(" ("+0, 1/0;#) +' /' /'&'3.&-) 0/("#0 ("/' 1#0)&'/773 +,#';P/27# ./''#0 23
-;7+W+': +'(#:0/(#, N+)/))&%+/;&' j#V#7 N#(#0.+'/;&' /'/73)+) /', >'&'3.+(3 b#/)-0#.#'( 6%&0#) 2#*&0#
+'*&0./;&' +) )#'( &-(5 Y&0 #X/.17#9 / .&2+7# 17/u&0. 10&V+,#09 )#0V+': /) / !0-)(#, =/0(39 ./3U
• !0/').+( 1#0*&0./'%# ,/(/ (& / .&2+7# ,#V+%# ./'-*/%(-0#0 =*,<#6, /101(8*"4 ,<1 *71"3,' #A ,<1 710*+1
#/ ,<1 *71"3,' #/ 8#+(3#" #A ,<1 &(,( H65S1+, 9 23 -)+': ,3'/.+%/773 %"/':+': NNLN)F
• =0&V+,# / .&2+7# /117+%/;&' ,#V#7&1#0 8+(" :#&7&%/;&' ,/(/ '#%#))/03 *&0 / ,#V+%# (& 7/-'%" B -)# / ./1
/117+%/;&' =*,<#6, /101(8*"4 ,<1 *71"3,' #A ,<1 710*+1 #/ &(,( H65S1+, 9 23 -)+': ,3'/.+%/773 %"/':+':
NNLN) /', / Q#17/%#.#'( y#3 dQye (& %&..-'+%/(# 7&%/;&' +'*&0./;&'F
•
6#', /' #.#0:#'%3 K@@ &1#0/(&0 8+(" 8#+(3#" ("7 *71"3,' *"A#/)(3#" A#/ ( 710*+1
("7 ,<1 &(,( H65S1+, 6$1/ 9 23 -)+': ,3'/.+%/773 %"/':+': NNLN) /', Q#17/%#.#'(
y#3) dQy)e (& %&..-'+%/(# 7&%/;&' /', +,#';(3 +'*&0./;&'5
Z"! ])&?'( <(E?0(. %,5 W)0%;), N(3E?0(.]X/.17# =/:# @ &* @
Z"" c>(32(,0= ]%,%2(>(,- N=.-(>.
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 86/95
HD T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
].#0:#'%3 ./'/:#.#'( )3)(#.) )-11&0(#, 23 N3'/.+% >'&'3.+(3 10&(&%&7) %&-7,U
• j#( #.#0:#'%3 1#0)&''#7 R'&8U
• 8"& +) 8"#0#
*-1
• 8+(" 8"/(
• b#,+%/79 /%%#)) /', *-'%;&'/7 '##,)
•
?-.2#0 &* */.+73 .#.2#0)• =#( /', 7+V#)(&%R +'*&0./;&'
• ](%5
• &'73 8"#' ("# #.#0:#'%3 1#0)&''#7 "/V# '##, (& R'&8 )1#%+P% +'*&0./;&' +' 0#)1&')#
(& )1#%+P% #.#0:#'%3 )+(-/;&')F
• 23 -)# #.#0:#'%3 ./'/:#.#'( )3)(#.) #`-+11#, 8+(" #.#0:#'%3 7#V#7 /%;V/;&' &*
0#`-+0#, +'*&0./;&' ("0&-:" <<8<.5
]))#';/7739 ,+f#0#'( +'*&0./;&' %&-7, 2# /%;V/(#, /( ,+f#0#'( 7#V#7) &* #.#0:#'%3 &0 +'
,+f#0#'( (31#) &* )+(-/;&') 23 7#V#0/:+': )%/7/27# /', #X(#')+27# NNLNO#'/27#, %&'(#'(5
Z"" c>(32(,0= ]%,%2(>(,- N=.-(>.]X/.17# =/:# @ &* @
Z"M -D3)42D "F@ 6cm:7 \ +H::7 \ ca <%-% <?3(0;E(
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 87/95
HC T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
@I5 N3'/.+% >'&'3.+(3 %&-7, "#71 #'/27# )%"&&7) (& )"/0# &'73 '#%#))/03 +'*&0./;&' 8+("
("+0, 1/0;#) +' /%%&0,/'%# 8+(" ("# a9N9 6%>?'= c540%;),%' m?2D-. %,5 :3?E%0= 70- K6cm:7L 23
-)+': NNLN)9 N+)/))&%+/;&' y#3) /', B&0 Q#17/%#.#'( y#3)5
@A5 N3'/.+% >'&'3.+(3 %&-7, "#71 1/0#'() (& #X#0%+)# %&'(0&7 &V#0 ("# (31# &* ,/(/ 0#V#/7#, 23
("#+0 %"+7,0#' (& 8#2)+(#) +' /%%&0,/'%# 8+(" ("# a9N9 +D?'53(,r. H,'?,( :3?E%0= :3)-(0;), 70-
K+H::7L 23 -)+': NNLN)9 N+)/))&%+/;&' y#3) /', B&0 Q#17/%#.#'( y#3)5
@E5 N3'/.+% >'&'3.+(3 %&-7, "#71 ,/(/ %&'(0&77#0) +' %&.173+': 8+(" >0;%7# D d0#`-+0#.#'()
*&0 */+0'#))9 7/8*-7'#))9 '#%#))+(39 10&1&0;&'/7+(3 /', ,/(/ `-/7+(3e /', >0;%7# Cd*e d0#`-+0#.#'()
*&0 2/7/'%+': &* 7#:+;./(# +'(#0#)() &* ("# %&'(0&77#0 /:/+')( ("# *-',/.#'(/7 0+:"() &* ("# ,/(/
)-2<#%(e -',#0 IF &(,( L/#,1+3#" &*/1+301 hdduRcbRIB 23 -)+': NNLN)9 N+)/))&%+/;&' y#3)
/', B&0 Q#17/%#.#'( y#3)5
Z"M -D3)42D "F@ 6cm:7 \ +H::7 \ ca <%-% <?3(0;E(]X/.17# =/:# @ &* @
7PP(,5?Q +
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 88/95
HH T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
7PP(,5?Q +
/%0123)4,5 ), 7,),). 6)4,5(3.
=/:#) HH O KE
!#, b3#0)&' /', x/03 j/Y#V#0 "/V# 2##' 8&0R+': (&:#("#0 /) 2-)+'#)) 1/0('#0) )+'%#
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 89/95
HK T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
!#, b3#0)&' /', x/03 j/Y#V#0 "/V# 2##' 8&0R+': (&:#("#0 /) 2-)+'#)) 1/0('#0) )+'%#
IJJ@5 L' IJJA9 ("#3 %/.# -1 8+(" /' +'V#';&' ("/( %"/':#, ("# :7&2/7 P'/'%+/7
)#0V+%#) +',-)(039 ,<1' *",/#76+17 ,/("$A#/)(301 /1(8C3)1 ,/("$.(/1"+' ("7 +#",/#8
*",# ( )(/;1, P,<1 48#5(8 >"("+*(8 )(/;1,$Q =<1/1 7(,( #5$+6/*,' <(7 511" 0*1=17 ($
( "1+1$$(/' /1?6*/1)1",G
6+'%# #.20/%+': #7#%(0&'+% ./0R#( /%%#)) +' ("# KJ)9 ("# P'/'%+/7 +',-)(03 "/, 2#7+#V#,
("/( '&("+': &("#0 ("/' 0#/7 ;.# &2)%-0+(3 8/) 1&))+27# ,-# (& ("# *&77&8+': */%(&0)U
• !"&-)/',) &* (0/,#0) )+.-7(/'#&-)73 )-2.+( &0,#0)F
• p0,#0) /0# )-2.+g#, -)+': '-.#0&-) ,+)1/0/(# (0/,+': )3)(#.) /', 17/u&0.) \
#/%" 8+(" ,+f#0#'( 0#%&0, 7/3&-()9 P7# *&0./()9 #(%5F• p0,#0) /0# 10&%#))#, 23 / .30+/, &* +'(#0.#,+/0+#) )-%" /) 20&R#0)9 ,#/7#0) /',
%7#/0+': P0.) \ #/%" 8+(" +',+V+,-/7 1&7+%+#)9 10&%#,-0#) /', 8/3) &* ,&+':
2-)+'#))F
• p0,#0) %/' 2# 20&R#' -1 +'(& )-2O&0,#0) /', B &0 %&.2+'#, 8+(" &("#0 &0,#0) (&
%0#/(# )-1#0O&0,#0)F
•
p0,#0) %/' 2# )-2.+g#, (& &'# &0 .&0# &* / '-.2#0 &* 7+`-+,+(3 ,#);'/;&') *&0
*-7P77.#'(5
L ( (" P + 7 + , ( + , 2 + 7 , + ("
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 90/95
KJ T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
L' )&.# 0#)1#%()9 ("# P'/'%+/7 +',-)(03 8/) 1#0%#+V#, /) 2#+': /'/7&:&-) ,-0+': ("#
(0/,+': ,/3 (& / 2+: 2&87 &* )1/:"#k '&&,7#)5 !"# 10#V/+7+': ("#&03 8/) ("/( &'73 &' ("#
,/3 +..#,+/(#73 *&77&8+': / :+V#' (0/,+': ,/3 d(0/,# ,/(# 17-) &'# ,/3 &0 !@e %&-7,
,/(/ *&0 ("/( ,/39 %&.+': *0&. '-.#0&-) ,+f#0#'( (0/,+': )3)(#.)9 +'(#0.#,+/0+#) /',
7+`-+,+(3 ,#);'/;&')9 2# %&'V#0(#, +'(& / %&..&' *&0./(9 %&.2+'#, /', 0#v#%(#, +' /'#X%#7 )10#/,)"##(5 :<1 /6""*"4 S#;1 =($ ,<(, /*$; )("(41/$ =#687 $<#= 6. *" ,<1
)#/"*"4T 41, ,<1*/ +6. #A +#E11T $*, 7#=" (, ,<1*/ 71$; ("7 _=*"+1] ($ ,<1' Z*..17
,</#64< 12+18 $./1(7$<11,$ $<#=*"4 ,<1 /1$68,$ #A ,/(7*"4 (+30*,' A#/ ,<1 ./10*#6$ 7('G
L' IJJA9 !#, /', x/039 8&0R+': 8+(" &("#0) /( ("#+0 %&.1/'3 6$cV9 *"01",17 ( $*).81
56, 1814(", (../#(+< ,<(, )(71 /1(8C3)1 >"("+*(8 /*$; )("(41)1", ( /1(8*,' 5 !"#+0
+'V#';&' 7#V#0/:#, ("# */%( ("/( 8"+7# ("#0# /0# (#') &* ("&-)/',) &* (0/,+': )3)(#.)
)-2.+k': &0,#0)9 #/%" &* 8"+%" ./3 2# 10&%#))#, 23 &'# &0 .&0# &* "-',0#,) &*
+'(#0.#,+/0+#)9 )#1/0/(#, /', B &0 %&.2+'#, 8+(" &("#0 &0,#0)9 /', -7;./(#73 )-2.+g#,
(& &'# &0 .&0# 7+`-+,+(3 ,#);'/;&')9 /77 )-%" &0,#0) /0# #'%&,#, +' %&..&' 2+'/03
*&0./() -)+': @) /', J)5 !"+) 2/)# 7#V#7 #'%&,+': /', ,#%&,+': &* +'*&0./;&' /( / 2+'/037#V#7 ./,# ("# Y!]? +'V#';&' 1&))+27#5
!"# Y!]? +'V#';&' /::0#:/(#, #'%&,#, ,/(/ *0&. ("# 1#/R &* ("# P'/'%+/7
; + * ; +, " 7+ +,+ , ; ; 7 , ,+f
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 91/95
K@ T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
(0/')/%;&' +'*&0./;&' 130/.+, \ ("# 7+`-+,+(3 ,#);'/;&') \ (0/')7/(#, ,+f#0#'%#)
+' P7# *&0./() (& :#'#0/(# / %&..&' '&0./7+W#, *&0./(9 /', /'/73W#, ("#
'&0./7+W#, #'%&,#, ,/(/ (& ,#(#%( +,#';P#0) )#'( +' / V/0+#(3 &* ,+f#0#'( 8/3) \ /77
+' 0#/7O;.#5 Z+(" ("+) /110&/%"9 Y!]? )"&8#, +( 8/) 1&))+27# ,# ,/("$)*, ,# .(/31$
*" /1(8C3)1 #"8' ,<#$1 7(,( 181)1",$ =<*+< ,<1' <(01 ( /*4<, ,# $11T (, ,<(, .#*", *"
3)1 =<1" ,<1' >/$, <(01 ,<1 /*4<, ("7 R #/ "117 ,# $11 *, 5 r#*&0# Y!]?9 ("+) "/,
'#V#0 2##' ,&'# /%0&)) ,+)1/0/(# )3)(#.)9 2#(8##' /', /.&': ,+f#0#'( ("+0, 1/0(3
+'(#0.#,+/0+#) /', 7+`-+,+(3 ,#);'/;&')5
!#, /', x/03 )1#'( )#V#0/7 3#/0) .##;': 8+(" 0#:-7/(&0)9 7#:+)7/(&0)9 /', +',-)(03
("&-:"( 7#/,#0)5 !"#3 8&-7, )"&8 /' Y!]? %&.1-(#0 )%0##' /', )/39 ^!"+) +) ("#
P'/'%+/7 ./0R#() +' 0#/7O;.#5 Z# %/' )"&8 3&- / (0/,#0c) +'(#0#)( /%0&)) .-7;17#
+'(#0.#,+/0+#)9 .-7;17# )3)(#.)5 Z# %/' )"&8 3&- / 2/'Rc) +'(#0#)( /%0&)) .-7;17#
(0/,#0)9 [1/' 7*E1/1", 0*1=$ +(" 51 +/1(,17 5' q$8*+*"4 ("7 7*+*"4^ 1"+#717 7(,( *"
/1(8 3)1 ($ *, /18(,1$ ,# >"("+*(8 $1/0*+1$G] Z+("+' (8& .&'(") /z#0 0#%#+V+': ("#
+'+;/7 1/(#'( &' ("#+0 +'V#';&' +' p%(&2#0 IJ@J9 ?>6N>w pb‚ 2&-:"( Y!]? /', "/)'&8 ,#17&3#, ("#+0 1/(#'(#, (#%"'&7&:3 /0&-', ("# :7&2#5
]X%#01( *0&. '&.+'/;&' &* Y!]? *&0 ("# IJJK ?/;&'/7 b#,/7 &* !#%"'&7&:3 /',
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 92/95
KI T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
]X%#01( *0&. '&.+'/;&' &* Y!]? *&0 ("# IJJK ?/;&'/7 b#,/7 &* !#%"'&7&:3 /',
L''&V/;&' d?b!Le9 ("# 4'+(#, 6(/(#)c "+:"#)( "&'&0 *&0 (#%"'&7&:+%/7 /%"+#V#.#'(9
2#)(&8#, 23 ("# =0#)+,#'( &' >.#0+%/t) 7#/,+': +''&V/(&0)U
_X1 518*101 K:I9^$ (+<*101)1",$ (/1 10*71"+1 #A ,<1 +#).("'^$
*""#0(301 81(71/$<*. /18(,17 ,# 71018#.)1", #A >"("+*(8 $1+6/*31$
/*$; )("(41)1", ,1+<"#8#4'G H6++1$$A68 71018#.)1", ("7
71.8#')1", #A $6+< ,1+<"#8#4*1$ *$ *).#/,(", ,# #6/ "(3#"^$
+#"3"617 1+#"#)*+ =188C51*"4T ./#$.1/*,' ("7 *"71.1"71"+1G]
>''#g# j5 ?/W/0#("9 M&..+))+&'#0
4565 6#%-0+;#) /', ]X%"/':# M&..+))+&'
IJJG (& IJJH
Y!]?c) +'(#0/%;&') 8+(" ("# ("# 4565 6#%-0+;#) /', ]X%"/':# M&..+))+&' 0#:/0,+': Q+)R
b/'/:#.#'( M&'(0&7) *&0 r0&R#0) &0 N#/7#0) 8+(" b/0R#( >%%#)) *&0 10&(#%;&' &*
P'/'%+/7 ./0R#() 8/) )& +')(0-.#'(/7 ("/( Y!]? 8/) %+(#, PV# ;.#) +' P'/7 6]M Q-7#@G%AOG d@C MYQ =/0( IEJ9 Q#7#/)# ?&5 AEODAIE@e /( *&&('&(#) @K9 H@9 HI9 HA /', II@5
>) ?>6N>w pb‚ #X#%-;V#) !#, /', x/03 '#X( )&-:"( (& %"/':# ("# .+',)#( &* ("#
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 93/95
KA T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
>) ?>6N>w pb‚ #X#%-;V#)9 !#, /', x/03 '#X( )&-:"( (& %"/':# ("# .+',)#( &* ("#
P'/'%+/7 +',-)(03 0#:/0,+': ("# -)# &* %7&-, %&.1-;': *&0 )(&0+': )#')+;V# P'/'%+/7
+'*&0./;&'5 !"#3 %&'%#+V#, &* / ^P'/'%+/7 2+: ,/(/ %7&-,_ /', .#( 8+(" >./W&'
Z#2 6#0V+%#) d>Z6e #':+'##0) /', #X#%-;V#) (& "#71 (-0' ("#+0 %&'%#1( +'(& /
0#/7+(35 !#,9 x/03 /', ("#+0 (#/. 8&0R#, %7&)#73 8+(" >Z6 (& 71018#. ( "1= =(' #A$1+6/*"4 7(,( 0*( +8#67 +#).63"4 ,<(, +#).8*17 =*,< $,/*+, >"("+*(8 *"76$,/'
/1?6*/1)1",$ ,<(, 7(,( +(""#, 51 )#7*>17G !"#3 8&0R#, &' / <&+'( 1/(#'( 2#(8##'
?>6N>w /', >Z6 *&0 ("#+0 '#8 /110&/%" (& )(&0+': P'/'%+/7 ,/(/ +' ("# %7&-, /',
-7;./(#73 7/-'%"#, ("# )#0V+%# /) Q#:-7/(&03 Q#%&0,) Q#(#';&' &0 QA /V/+7/27#
*0&. YL?wjp4N9 / )-2)+,+/03 &* ?>6N>w pb‚5
!#, /', x/03 0#/7+W#, 8"/( ("#3 *&-', +'(0+:-+': /( Y!]? /', YL?wjp4N 8/) ("/(
("#3 2&(" +'V&7V#, %&.17#X9 "+:"73 *0/:.#'(#, 0#:-7/(#, )+(-/;&')5 !"#)#
)+(-/;&')9 +'V&7V+': )##.+':73 %&'v+%;': :&/7) /', &2<#%;V#) &* 0#:-7/(&0)9
7#:+)7/(&0) /', ./0R#( 1/0;%+1/'()9 #'/27#, !#, /', x/03 (& /1173 / -'+`-#
/110&/%" (& /1+#"+*8*"4 $*,6(3#"$ =*,< *""#0(301 (..8*+(3#"$ #A ,1+<"#8#4' G
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 94/95
KE T IJ@E >'&'&) L'%5 8885/'&'&)5%&.
?&8 8+(" >'&'&)9 b3#0)&' /', j/Y#V#0 /0# 10&1&)+': / (0/')*&0./;V# )&7-;&' (&
("# &11&)+(# 10&27#. ("/( Y!]? )&7V#,U ./#0*7*"4 /1(8C3)1 3)1T .8(+1 ("7
.6/.#$1C5($17 #5A6$+(3#" ("7 _+#",/#8817 7(,( A6$*#"] A#/ ( )(/;1, P48#5(8 7(,(
*"A#/)(3#"Q =<1/1 7(,( ,/("$.(/1"+' *$ ,#7(' 0*1=17 ($ ( /1?6*/1)1", 5
b&)( 1-0V#3&0) &* ,/(/ +' (&,/3c) ^#7#%(0&'+% &2)#0V/;&'/7 8&07,_ %7/+. ("#3 '##,
0#/7O;.# (0/')1/0#'%3 +'(& ,/(/ )-2<#%()c /%;V+;#) \ #5:59 8"& ("#3 /0# 23 .#/') &*
)(/;% +,#';P#0)9 8"/( ("#3 ,& 23 .#/') %&&R+#) &0 &("#0 )(/;% +,#';P#0)9 #(%5 \ (&
)-11&0( / V+/27# /', 0&2-)( #%&'&.+% .&,#75 !#, /', x/03 2#7+#V# ("+) +) 8"3 N&O
?&(O!0/%R +'+;/;V#) "/V# */+7#, (& :/+' 8+,# )10#/, /%%#1(/'%# \ ("#3 /0#+'%&')+)(#'( 8+(" ("# %-00#'( #%&'&.+% .&,#75
[&8#V#09 !#, /', x/03 2#7+#V# ("/( 23 )8/3+': ("# %-00#'( ,#*/-7( .+',)#( *0&. &'#
0#`-+0+': 0#/7O;.# (0/')1/0#'%3 (& &'# #'/27+': 0#/7O;.# %&'(0&77#, ;.#9 1-01&)#9
/', 17/%# 2/)#, &2)%-0+(39 (" 101" )#/1 0*5/(", ("7 /#56$, 1+#"#)*+ )#718 *$
.#$$*581 5' )1("$ #A ,<1 !"#"#$ 1"+#7*"4 R 71+#7*"4 $'$,1) t &'"()*+ !"#"')*,'G
7/18/2019 Controlled Data Fusion and Anti-Discrimination Benefits of Anonos Dynamic Anonymity
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/controlled-data-fusion-and-anti-discrimination-benefits-of-anonos-dynamic-anonymity 95/95
6)3 >)3( ?,*)3>%;),b P'(%.( 0),-%0-@
`%3= W%6(E(3 $(5 ]=(3.),
:/03|/'&'&)5%&. (#,|/'&'&)5%&.
dAJAe HIAOH@@@ dI@Ie DGHO@JHJ