Constitutional LawPolitical Law (Constitutional Law) – Article   XVIII

ARTICLE XVIII – TRANSITORY PROVISIONS

 Effectivity of the 1987 Constitution

The 1987 Constitution took effect immediately upon its ratification.

According to the SC, this took place on February 2, 1987, which was

the day the people cast their votes ratifying the Constitution.Military bases agreements

1)      Renewals of military bases agreements must be through a strict treaty.

2)      Ratification of the agreement in a plebiscite is necessary only when

Congress so requires.

3)      Section 25 of Article XVIII allows possible local deployment of only

AMERICAN forces.

 

ARTICLE XVII- AMENDMENTS OR REVISIONS

 

Definitions:

1) Amendment:  an alteration of one or a few specific provisions of the

Constitution.  Its main purpose is to improve specific provisions of the

Constitution.  The changes brought about by amendments will not affect the

other provisions of the Constitution.

2) Revision:  An examination of the entire Constitution to determine how

and to what extent it should be altered.  A revision implies substantive

change, affecting the Constitution as a whole.

Constituent power v. Legislative power

1)      Constituent power is the power to formulate a Constitution or to

propose amendments to or revisions of the Constitution and to ratify such

1

proposal. Legislative power is the power to pass, repeal or amend or ordinary

laws or statutes (as opposed to organic law).

2)      Constituent power is exercised by Congress (by special

constitutional conferment), by a Constitutional Convention or Commission,

by the people through initiative and referendum, and ultimately by sovereign

electorate, whereas legislative power is an ordinary power of Congress

and of the people, also through initiative and referendum.

3)      The exercise of constituent power does not need the approval of the

Chief Executive, whereas the exercise of legislative power ordinarily

needs the approval of the Chief Executive, except when done by people

through initiative and referendum.

Three (3) steps necessary to give effect to amendments and

revisions:

1) Proposal of amendments or revisions by the proper constituent assembly;

2) Submission of the proposed amendments or revisions; and

3) Ratification

Proposal of amendments:

Amendments may be proposed by:

A. Congress, acting as a constituent assembly, by a 3/4 vote of all

its members.

The power of Congress to propose amendments is NOT part of its

ordinary legislative power.

The only reason Congress can exercise such power is that the

Constitution has granted it such power.

B. Constitutional Convention:

1) How a Constitutional Convention may be called

2

a). Congress may call a ConCon by a 2/3 vote of all its members; or

b). By a majority vote of all its members, Congress may submit to the

electorate the question of whether to call a ConCon or not.

2) Choice of which constituent assembly (either Congress or ConCon) should

initiate amendments and revisions is left to the discretion of Congress.  In

other words, it is a political question.

3) BUT:  The manner of calling a ConCon is subject to judicial review,

because the Constitution has provided for vote requirements.

4) If Congress, acting as a constituent assembly, calls for a ConCon but does

not provide the details for the calling of such ConCon, Congress – exercising

its ordinary legislative power – may supply such details.  But in so doing,

Congress (as legislature) should not transgress the resolution of Congress

acting as a constituent assemble.

5) Congress, as a constituent assembly and the ConCon have no power to

appropriate money for their expenses.  Money may be spent from the

treasury only to pursuant to an appropriation made by law.

C. People’s Initiative

1) Petition to propose such amendments must be signed be at least 12% of

ALL registered voters.

2) Every legislative district represented by at least 3% of the registered

voters therein.

3) Limitation:

It cannot be exercised oftener than once every 5 years.

3

Note:

1)      While the substance of the proposals made by each type of constituent

assembly is not subject to judicial review, the manner the proposals are

made is subject to judicial review.

2)      Since these constituent assemblies owe their existence to the

Constitution, the courts may determine whether the assembly has acted in

accordance with the Constitution.

3)      Examples of justiciable issues:

a)      Whether a proposal was approved by the required number of votes in

Congress (acting as a constituent assembly).

b)      Whether the approved proposals were properly submitted to the

people for ratification.

Proposal of Revisions

1)      By Congress, upon a vote of 3/4 of its members

2)      By a constitutional convention

Ratification

1)      Amendments and revisions proposed by Congress and/or by a

ConCon:

a)      Valid when ratified by a MAJORITY of votes cast in a plebiscite.

b)      Plebiscite is held not earlier than 60 days nor later than 90 days from

the approval of such amendments or revisions.

2)      Amendments proposed by the people via initiative:   

4

a)      Valid when ratified by a MAJORITY of votes cast in a plebiscite.

b)      Plebiscite is held not earlier than 60 days nor later than 90 days after

the certification by COMELEC of the petition’s sufficiency

3)      Requisites of a valid ratification:

a)      Held in a plebiscite conducted under the election law;

b)      Supervised by the COMELEC; and

c)      Where only franchised voters (registered) voters take part.

4)      Issues regarding ratification:

a)      The Constitution does not require that amendments and revisions be

submitted to the people in a special election. Thus, they may be submitted

for ratification simultaneously with a general election.

b)      The determination of the conditions under which proposed

amendments/revisions are submitted to the people falls within the legislative

sphere. That Congress could have done better does not make the steps

taken unconstitutional.

c)      All the proposed amendments/revisions made by the constituent

assemblies must be submitted for ratification in one single plebiscite. There

cannot be a piece-meal ratification of amendments/revisions.

d)      Presidential proclamation is NOT required for effectivity of

amendments/revisions, UNLESS the proposed amendments/revisions so

provide.

 

ARTICLE XVI – GENERAL PROVISIONS

5

 

Sections 1-2. Symbols of Nationality

1) Flag

Red, white, and blue.

With a sun and 3 stars

The design may be changed by constitutional amendment.

2) Congress may, by law, adopt a new:

(a) Name for the country,

(b) National anthem, or

(c) National seal.

Note: Law will take effect upon ratification by the people in a NATIONAL

REFERENDUM.

Section 3.  State Immunity

Suability of State

1) The State cannot be sued without its consent.

2) When considered a suit against the State

a).  The Republic is sued by name;

b).  Suits against an un-incorporated government agency;

c).  Suit is against a government official, but is such that ultimate liability

shall devolve on the government

6

i.  When a public officer acts in bad faith, or beyond the scope of his

authority, he can be held personally liable for damages.

ii.  BUT:  If he acted pursuant to his official duties, without malice,

negligence, or bad faith, they are not personally liable, and the suit is really

one against the State.

3) This rule applies not only in favor of the Philippines but also in favor of

foreign states.

4) The rule likewise prohibits a person from filing for interpleader, with the

State as one of the defendants being compelled to interplead.

Consent to be sued

A. Express consent:

1). The law expressly grants the authority to sue the State or any of its

agencies.

2). Examples:

a). A law creating a government body expressly providing that such body

“may sue or be sued.”

b). Art. 2180 of the Civil Code, which creates liability against the State when

it acts through a special agent.

B. Implied consent:

1). The State enters into a private contract.

a). The contract must be entered into by the proper officer and within the

scope of his authority.

7

b). UNLESS:  The contract is merely incidental to the performance of a

governmental function.

2). The State enters into an operation that is essentially a business

operation.

a). UNLESS:  The operation is incidental to the performance of a

governmental        function (e.g. arrastre services)

b). Thus, when the State conducts business operations through a GOCC, the

latter can generally be sued, even if its charter contains no express “sue or

be sued” clause.

3). Suit against an incorporated government agency.

a) This is because they generally conduct propriety business operations and

have charters which grant them a separate juridical personality.

4). The State files suit against a private party.

UNLESS:  The suit is entered into only to resist a claim.

Garnishment of government funds:

1) GENERAL RULE:  NO.  Whether the money is deposited by way of general

or special deposit, they remain government funds and are not subject to

garnishment.

2) EXCEPTION:  A law or ordinance has been enacted appropriating a specific

amount to pay a valid government obligation, then the money can be

garnished.

Consent to be sued is not equivalent to consent to liability:

8

1) The Fact that the State consented to being sued does not mean that the

State will ultimately be held liable.

2) Even if the case is decided against the State, an award cannot be satisfied

by writs of execution or garnishment against public funds.  Reason:  No

money shall be paid out of the public treasury unless pursuant to an

appropriation made by law.

Section 4.  THE ARMED FORCES OF THE PHILIPPINES

Composition:

A citizen armed force

Prohibitions and disqualifications:

1) Military men cannot engage, directly or indirectly, in any partisan political

activity, except to vote.

2) Members of the AFP in active service cannot be appointed to a civilian

position in the government, including GOCCs or their subsidiaries.

The Chief of Staff:

1) Tour of duty: Not exceed to three years

2) EXCEPTION:  In times of war or other national emergency as declared by

Congress, the President may extend such tour of duty.

 

ARTICLE XIV – EDUCATION, SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY,

ARTS, CULTURE, AND SPORTS

 

9

Education

Goals of the State:

The State shall promote and protect:

1) The right to quality education at all levels;

2) The right to affordable and accessible education; and

3) Education that is relevant to the needs of people and society.

Right to Education and Academic Freedom

The right to education must be read in conjunction with the academic

freedom of schools to require “fair, reasonable, and equitable admission

requirements.”

Power to Dismiss Students

1) Schools have the power to dismiss students, after due process, for

disciplinary reasons.

2)  Acts committed outside the school may also be a ground for disciplinary

action if:

a) It involves violations of school policies connected to school-sponsored

activities; or

b) The misconduct affects the student’s status, or the good name or

reputation of the school.

Regulation of Right to Education

The right to education in particular fields may be regulated by the State in

the exercise of its police power, e.g. the State may limit the right to enter

medical school by requiring the applicants to take the NMAT.

10

Free Education

1) The State shall maintain a system of free education in:

a) Elementary level, and

b) High school level.

2) Elementary education is compulsory for all children of school age.

However, this is a moral rather than a legal compulsion.

Educational Institutions

I. Filipinization

A. Ownership:

1). Filipino citizens, or

2). Corporations incorporated in RP and 60% Filipino-owned.

EXCEPT: Schools established by religious groups and mission boards.

3). Congress may increase Filipino equity requirements in ALL educational

institutions.

B. Control and Administration:

1). Must be vested in Filipino citizens

2). Refers to line positions, such as President, Dean, Principal, and Trustees

3). Faculty members may be foreigners.

C.  Student Population:

1). GENERAL RULE: Cannot establish school exclusively for aliens. Aliens can

only comprise up to 1/3 of total enrollment.

11

2). EXCEPTIONS: Schools established for foreign diplomatic personnel and

their dependents, and unless otherwise provided for by law for other foreign

temporary residents.

II. Tax Exemptions

A. Non-stock, non-profit educational institutions:

1) All revenues and assets actually, directly and exclusively used for

educational purposes are exempt from taxes and duties.

2) This is self-executory

    B. Proprietary educational institutions, including cooperatives:

1) Entitled to exemptions as may be provided by law, including restrictions

on dividends and re-investment

2) Requires an enabling statute

3) Grants, endowments, donations and contributions actually, directly and

exclusively used for educational purposes are exempt from taxes, subject to

conditions prescribed by law.

III. Academic Freedom

A. Educational Institutions

Schools have the freedom to determine:

1) Who may teach,

2) What may be taught,

3) How it shall be taught, and

4) Who may be admitted to study.

12

      B. Faculty members

1) Full freedom in research and in the publication of the results, subject to

the adequate performance of their other academic duties.

2) Freedom in the classroom in discussing their subjects, but they should be

careful not to introduce into their teaching controversial matter which has no

relation to their subjects.

3) When faculty members speak or write in their capacity as citizens, then

they are free from institutional censorship or discipline.

     C. Students

They have the right to enjoy in school the guarantees of the Bill of Rights.

    D. Limitations

1) Dominant police power of the State

2) Social interest of the community

    E. Budgetary Priority:

1). Education must be assigned the highest budgetary priority.

2). BUT: This command is not absolute.  Congress is free to determine what

should be given budgetary priority in order to enable it to respond to the

imperatives of national interest and for the attainment of other state policies

or objectives.

Religious Education in Public Schools:

Religion may be taught in public schools subject to the following requisites:

13

1) Express written option by parents and guardians;

2) Taught within regular class hours;

3) Instructors are designated and approved by the proper religious

authorities; and

4) WITHOUT ADDITIONAL COST TO THE GOVERNMENT.

Section 6. Language

1) National language: Filipino

2) Official Languages: Filipino, and unless otherwise provided by law, English.

3) Regional languages are auxiliary to the official languages.

4 (Spanish and Arabic are promoted only on an optional and voluntary basis.

 

ARTICLE XIII – SOCIAL JUSTICE AND HUMAN RIGHTS

Social Justice

1)   Social justice in the Constitution is principally the embodiment of the

principle that those who have less in life should have more in law.

2)   The 1987 Constitution advances beyond what was in previous

Constitutions in that it seeks not only economic social justice but also

political social justice.

Principal activities in order to achieve social justice

1)   Creation of more economic opportunities and more wealth; and

14

2)   Closer regulation of the acquisition, ownership, use and disposition of

property in order to achieve a more equitable distribution of wealth and

political power.

Labor

Section 3 of Article XIII elaborates on the provision in Article II by

specifying who are protected by the Constitution, what rights are

guaranteed, and what positive measures the state should take in order

to enhance the welfare of labor.Right to organize and to hold peaceful concerted activities

Ø The right to organize is given to all kinds of workers BOTH in the

PRIVATE and PUBLIC sectors.

Ø The workers have a right to hold peaceful concerted activities except

the right to strike, which is subject to limitation by law.Right to participate in the decision making process of employers

The workers have the right to participate on matters affecting their rights

and benefits, “as may be provided by law”.  This participation can be through

1)               collective bargaining agreements,

2)               grievance machineries,

3)               voluntary modes of settling disputes, and

4)               conciliation proceedings mediated by government.

Agrarian Reform

Goals:

Agrarian reform must aim at

1)  efficient production,

15

2)  a more equitable distribution of land which recognizes the right of

farmers and regular farmworkers who are landless to own the land they till,

and

3)  a just share of other or seasonal farmworkers in the fruits of the land.

CARL as an exercise of police power and power of eminent domain

To the extent that the law prescribes retention limits for landowners,

there is an exercise of police power. But where it becomes necessary to

deprive owners of their land in excess of the maximum allowed there is

compensable taking and therefore the exercise of eminent domain.

Reach of agrarian reform

It extends not only to private agricultural lands, but also to “other

natural resources,” even including the use and enjoyment of

“communal marine and fishing resources” and “offshore fishing

grounds”.

The Commission on Human Rights

Composition:

1)   Chairman; and

2)   4 members

Qualifications:

1)   Natural-born citizens of the Philippines;

2)   Majority of the Commission must be members of the Philippine Bar;

3)  Term of office, other qualifications and disabilities shall be provided by

law;

4)  The appointment of the CHR members is NOT subject to CA confirmation;

and16

5)  The CHR is not of the same level as the COMELEC, CSC, or COA.

Powers:

1)  Investigate all forms of human rights violations involving civil or political

rights

A. Violations may be committed by public officers or by civilians or rebels.

B. CHR cannot investigate violations of social rights.

C. CHR has NO adjudicatory powers over cases involving human rights

violations.

D. They cannot investigate cases where no rights are violated.

E. Example: There is no right to occupy government land, i.e. squat thereon.

Therefore, eviction therefrom is NOT a human rights violation.

2)  Adopt operational guidelines and rules of procedure.

3)  Cite for contempt for violations of its rules, in accordance with the Rules

of Court.

4) Provide appropriate legal measures for the protection of the human rights

of all persons, within the Philippines, as well as Filipinos residing abroad, and

provide for preventive measures and legal aid services to the

underprivileged whose human rights have been violated or need protection.

A. CHR can initiate court proceedings on behalf of victims of human rights

violations.

B. They can recommend the prosecution of human rights violators, but it

cannot itself prosecute these cases.

17

C. BUT: The CHR cannot issue restraining orders or injunctions against

alleged human rights violators. These must be obtained from the regular

courts.

5)  Exercise visitorial powers over jails, prisons and other detention facilities.

6) Establish continuing programs for research, education and information in

order to enhance respect for the primacy of human rights.

7)  Recommend to Congress effective measures to promote human rights

and to provide compensation to victims of human rights violations or their

families.

8)  Monitor compliance by the government with international treaty

obligations on human rights.

9) Grant immunity from prosecution to any person whose testimony or

whose possession of documents or other evidence is necessary or

convenient to determine the truth in any CHR investigation.

10) Request assistance from any department, bureau, office, or agency in

the performance of its functions.

11)  Appoint its officers and employers in accordance with law.

12)  Perform such other functions and duties as may be provided for by law

 

ARTICLE XII – NATIONAL ECONOMY AND PATRIMONY

 

Sec. 1.  GOALS OF THE NATIONAL ECONOMY

Three-fold goal:

1.  More equitable distribution of opportunities, income and wealth;

18

2.  Sustained increase in the amount of goods and services produced by the

nation for the benefit of the people; and

3.  Expanding productivity, as the key to raising the quality of life for all.

The State shall promote industrialization and full employment

1.  It should be based on sound agricultural development and agrarian

reform

2.  It should be through industries that make full and efficient use of human

and natural resources.  Industries should also be competitive in both

domestic and foreign markets.

Protection of Filipino enterprises

The State shall protect Filipino enterprises against unfair foreign competition

and trade practices.

Role of Private Enterprises

Private enterprises, including corporations, cooperatives, and similar

collective organizations, shall be encouraged to broaden the base of their

ownership

Section 2. REGALIAN DOCTRINE

Distinction between Imperium and Dominium.

1.  Imperium

Government authority possessed by the State which is appropriately

embraced in sovereignty.

2.  Dominium

1. The capacity of the State to own and acquire property.

19

2. It refers to lands held by the government in a proprietary character:

can provide for the exploitation and use of lands and other natural

resources.

Scope:

The following are owned by the State:

1.  Lands of the public domain:

Waters

Minerals, coals, petroleum, and other mineral oils;

All sources of potential energy;

Fisheries;

Forests or timber;

Wildlife;

Flora and fauna; and

Other natural resources.

Alienation of Natural Resources

1.  General Rule:  All natural resources CANNOT be alienated

2.  Exception:  Agricultural lands

Exploration, Development and Utilization of Natural Resources

1.  Shall be under the full control and supervision of the State

2.  Means

20

A.  The state may DIRECTLY UNDERTAKE such activities

B. The state may enter into CO-PRODUCTION, JOINT VENTURE OR

PRODUCTION-SHARING arrangements with

1. Filipino citizen or

2. Corporation or association at least 60% of whose capital is owned by

such citizens

3.  Limitations:

A.  Period:  It should not exceed 25 years, renewable for not more than 25

years

B.  Under terms and conditions as may be provided by law.

4. In case of water rights/water supply/fisheries/industrial uses other than the

development of water power

The beneficial use may be the measure and limit of the grant.

Small-scale Utilization of Natural Resources

1. Congress may, by law, authorize small-scale utilization of natural

resources by Filipino citizens

2. Congress may also authorize cooperative fish farming with priority given

to subsistence fishermen and fishworkers in the rivers, lakes, bays and

lagoons.

Large-Scale Exploration, Development and Utilization of

Minerals/Petroleum/Other Mineral Oils

1.  The President may enter into agreements with foreign owned

corporations involving technical or financial assistance for large-scale 21

exploration etc. of minerals, petroleum, and other mineral oils.  These

agreements should be in accordance with the general terms and conditions

provided by law.

2.  They should be based on the real contributions to economic growth and

general welfare of the country.

3.  In the agreements, the State should promote the development and use of

local scientific and technical resources.

4.  The President should notify Congress of every contract under this

provision within 30 days from its execution.

5.  Management and service contracts are not allowed under this rule.

Protection of Marine Wealth

1.  The State shall protect its marine wealth in its

Archipelagic waters

Territorial sea &

EEZ

2.  The State shall reserve its use and enjoyment exclusively to Filipino

citizens.

Section 3.  LANDS OF THE PUBLIC DOMAIN ARE CLASSIFIED INTO

1.  Agricultural

2.  Forest/timber

3.  Mineral lands &

22

4.  National Parks

Note:

1.  Classification of public lands is an exclusive prerogative of the Executive

Department through the Office of the President, upon recommendation by

the DENR.

2.  Classification is descriptive of the legal nature of the land and NOT what it

looks like.  Thus, the fact that forest land is denuded does not mean it is no

longer forest land.

Alienable lands of public domain

1.  Only agricultural lands are alienable.

2.  Agricultural lands may be further classified by law according to the uses

to which they may be devoted.

Limitations regarding Alienable Lands of the Public Domain

1.  For private corporations or associations

A.  They can only hold alienable lands of the public domain BY LEASE

            B.  Period:  Cannot exceed 25 years, renewable for not more than 25

years

C.  Area:  Lease cannot exceed 1,000 hectares

Note:  A  corporation sole is treated like other private corporations for the

purpose of acquiring public lands.

2.  For Filipino citizens

A.  Can lease up to 500 hectares

23

B.   Can ACQUIRE not more than 12 hectares by purchase, homestead or

grant.

Taking into account the requirements of conservation, ecology and

development, and subject to the requirements of agrarian reform, Congress

shall determine by law the size of the lands of the public domain which may

be acquired, developed, held or lease and the conditions therefore.

Means by Which Lands of the Public Domain Become Private Land

1.  Acquired from government by purchase or grant;

2.  Uninterrupted possession by the occupant and his predecessors-in-

interest since time immemorial; and

3.  Open, exclusive, and undisputed possession of ALIENABLE (agricultural)

public land for a period of 30 years.

A.  Upon completion of the requisite period, the land becomes private

property ipso jure without need of any judicial or other sanction.

B.  Here, in possession since time immemorial, presumption is that the land

was never part of public domain.

C.  In computing 30 years, start from when land was converted to alienable

land, not when it was still forest land

D.  Presumption is that land belongs to the State.

Section 4.  Congress shall, as soon as possible, determine by law,

the specific limits of forest lands and national parks, marking clearly

their boundaries on the ground.  Thereafter, such forest lands and

national parks shall be conserved and may not be increased or

24

diminished, EXCEPT by law.  Congress shall provide measures to

prohibit logging in

1. a.      Endangered forest and

2. b.      Watershed areas for such period as it may determine.

Section 5.  ANCESTRAL LANDS

Protection of Indigenous Cultural Communities

1.  The State protects the rights of indigenous cultural communities to their

ancestral lands

A.  Subject to Constitutional provisions

B.  Subject to national development policies and programs

2.  In determining ownership and extent of ancestral domain, Congress may

use customary laws on property rights and relations.

3.  “ANCESTRAL DOMAIN”

A.  It refers to lands which are considered as pertaining to a cultural region

B.  This includes lands not yet occupied, such as deep forests.

Section 7.  PRIVATE LANDS

General rule

1.  Private lands CAN only be transferred or conveyed to:

A.  Filipino citizens

B. Corporations or associations incorporated in the Philippines, at least 60%

of whose capital is owned by Filipino citizens

2.  Exceptions

25

A.  In intestate succession, where an alien heir of a Filipino is the transferee

of private land.

B.  A natural born citizen of the Philippines who has lost his Philippine

citizenship may be a transferee of PRIVATE ALND, subject to limitation

provided by law.  Hence, land can be used only for residential purposes.  In

this case, he only acquires derivative title.

C.  Foreign states may acquire land but only for embassy and staff residence

purposes.

3.  Filipino citizenship is only required at the time the land is acquired.  Thus,

loss of citizenship after acquiring the land does not deprive ownership.

4.  Restriction against aliens only applies to acquisition of ownership. 

Therefore:

A.  Aliens may be lessees or usufructuaries of private lands

B.  Aliens may be mortgages of land, as long as they do not obtain

possession thereof and do not bid in the foreclosure sale.

5.  Land tenure is not indispensable to the free exercise of religious

profession and worship.  A religious corporation controlled by non-Filipinos

cannot acquire and own land, even for religious purposes.

Remedies to recover private lands from disqualified aliens:

1.  Escheat proceedings

2.  Action for reversion under the Public Land Act

3.  An action by the former Filipino owner to recover the land

26

A.  The former pari delicto principle has been abandoned

B.  Alien still has the title (didn’t pass it on to one who is qualified)

Section 10.  NATIONAL ECONOMY AND PATRIMONY/INVESTMENTS

Power of Congress

1.  Congress, upon the recommendation of NEDA, can reserve to Filipino

citizens or to corporations or associations at least 60% of whose capital is

owned by such citizens, or such higher percentage as Congress may

prescribe, certain areas of investment.  This may be done when the national

interest dictates.

2.  Congress shall also enact measures to encourage the formation and

operation of enterprises whose capital is wholly owned by Filipinos.

National Economy and Patrimony

In the grant of rights, privileges and concessions covering the national

economy and patrimony, the State shall give preference to QUALIFIED

Filipinos.

Section 11.  FRANCHISES FOR PUBLIC UTILITIES

Power to grant:

1.  Congress may directly grant a legislative franchise; or

2. Power to grant franchises may be delegated to appropriate regulatory

agencies and/or LGU’s

Public utility

1.  In order to be considered as a public utility, and thus subject to this

provision, the undertaking must involve dealing directly with the public.

27

2.  Thus, a Build-Operate-Transfer grantee is NOT a public utility.  The BOT

grantee merely constructs the utility, and it leases the same to the

government.  It is the government which operates the public utility

(operation separate from ownership).

To whom granted:

1.  Filipino citizens or

2.  Corporations or associations incorporated in the Philippines and at least

60% of the capital is owned by Filipino citizens.

Terms and conditions:

1.  Duration:  Not more than 50 years

2.  Franchise is NOT exclusive in character

3.  Franchise is granted under the condition that it is subject to amendment,

alteration, or repeal by Congress when the common good so requires.

Participation of Foreign Investors

1. The participation of foreign investors in the governing body of any public

utility enterprise shall be limited to their proportionate share in its capital.

2.  Foreigners cannot be appointed as the executive and managing officers

because these positions are reserved for Filipino citizens.

Section 16.  FORMATION/ORGANIZATION/REGULATION OF CORPORATIONS

1.  Private corporations

Congress can only provide for the formation, etc of private corporations

through a general law.

28

2.  GOCC’s

They may be created by:

a. Special charters in the interest of the common good and subject to the

test of  economic viability.

b. By incorporation under the general corporation law.

Sections 18-19.  SPECIAL ECONOMIC POWERS OF THE GOVERNMENT

1.  Temporary takeover or direction of operations:

A.  Conditions

i.  National emergency and

ii.  When the public interest requires

B.  May be used against privately owned public utilities or businesses

affected with public interest.

C.  Duration of the takeover:  period of emergency

D.  Takeover is subject to reasonable terms and conditions

E.  No need for just compensation because it is only temporary.

2.  Nationalization of vital industries:

A.  Exercised in the interest of national welfare or defense

B.  Involves either:

i.  Establishment and operation of vital industries; or

29

ii. Transfer to public ownership, upon payment of just compensation, public

utilities and other private enterprises to be operated by the government.

Section 19.  MONOPOLIES

1.  The Constitution does NOT prohibit the existence of monopolies.

2. The State may either regulate or prohibit monopolies, when public interest

so requires.

3.  Combinations in restraint of trade or unfair competition are prohibited.

Filipino citizenship or equity requirements:

 

ACTIVITY REQUIREMENTS                                             CITIZENSHIP

AND/OR EQUITY

Exploitation of natural resources                     1.  Filipino citizens; or

2. Corporations incorporated in RP, with 60% Filipino ownership

 

Operation of Public Utilities                              1.  Filipino citizens; or

2. Corporations incorporated in RP, with 60% Filipino ownership

 

Acquisition of alienable lands of the public domain

1.  Filipino citizens;

2. Corporations incorporated in RP, with 60% Filipino ownership;

30

3.  Former natural-born citizens of RP, as transferees, with certain legal

restrictions; and

4.  Alien heirs as transferees in case of intestate succession.

 

Practice of ALL Professions                            Filipino citizens only (natural

persons)

*Congress may, by law, otherwise prescribe

 

Mass Media                                                             1.  Filipino citizens; or

2. Corporations incorporated in RP, and 100% Filipino owned

 

Advertising                                                            1.  Filipino citizens; or

2. Corporations incorporated in RP, and 70% Filipino owned.

 

Educational institution                                     1.  Filipino citizens; or

2. Corporations incorporated in RP, with 60% Filipino ownership

EXCEPT:  Schools established by religious groups and mission boards.

*Congress may, by law, increase Filipino equity requirements for ALL

educational institutions.

 

31

Other economic activities                                Congress may, by law, reserve

to Filipino citizens or to corporations 60% Filipino owned (or even higher)

certain investment areas.

 

ARTICLE XI: ACCOUNTABILITY OF PUBLIC OFFICERS

 

Section 1: PUBLIC OFFICE AS A PUBLIC TRUST

Public officers and employees must at all times be accountable to

the people, serve them with utmost responsibility, integrity, loyalty

and efficiency, act with patriotism and justice and lead modest lives.

 

Section 2: IMPEACHMENT/REMOVAL FROM OFFICE

Impeachment: (as means of removal from office)

1.  Who may be impeached:

– President

– VP

– SC Justices

– Constitutional Commission members

– Ombudsman

2.  Grounds

– Culpable violation of the Constitution

– treason

– bribery

32

– graft and corruption

– other high crimes or

– betrayal of public trust

Note: It is an exclusive list.  Congress cannot, by law, add to the list

of impeachable offenses.

1. These officers cannot be charged in court with offenses that have

removal from office as penalty.

2. The President cannot be charged with murder.

3. A SC Justice cannot be disbarred because this would disqualify him

from his position.

4. BUT AFTER an official has been impeached, he can be charged with the

appropriate offense.

5. Resignation by an impeachable official does not place him beyond the

reach of impeachment proceedings; he can still be impeached

All Other Public Officers and Employees

1.  They may be removed from office as provided by law

2.  BUT: NOT by impeachment

Section 3: PROCEDURE FOR IMPEACHMENT

Exclusive Power of House of Representatives

The House of Representatives has exclusive power to INITIATE all cases of

impeachment.

Procedure:

1.  Filling of verified complaint

1. Can be filed by:

1. Any member of the House of Representatives or

33

2. Any citizen upon a resolution of endorsement by any Member of the

House or

3. By at least 1/3 of all the Members of the House of Representatives

2.)  Inclusion of complaint in the order of business with 10 session days

3.)  Referral to proper Committee within 3 session days thereafter

4.)   Submission of Committee report to the House together with

corresponding resolution

1. There should be a hearing

2. There should be a majority vote of the members

3. The report should be submitted within 60 days from referral, after

hearing, and by a majority vote of ALL its members.

5.)  Calendaring of resolution for consideration by the House

Should be done within 10 session days from receipt thereof

6.)   Vote of at least 1/3 of all Members of the House necessary to:

1. Affirm a favorable resolution with the Articles of Impeachment of the

Committee or

2. To override its contrary resolution

Note: If the verified complaint or resolution of impeachment was filed by at

least 1/3 of all the Members of the House, it shall constitute the Articles of

Impeachment.  Trial in the Senate shall proceed.

7.)        Trial in the Senate

1. Senate has the sole power to try and decide all cases of impeachment

2. For this purpose, the Senators shall be under oath or affirmation

34

3. When the President of the Philippines is on trial, the CJ of the Supreme

Court presides.  However, he/she will not vote.

8.)          Judgment of Conviction

This requires the concurrence of 2/3 of all the Members of the Senate

9.)          Effect of the Impeachment

1. Removal from office of the official concerned

2. Disqualification to hold any office under the Republic of the Philippines

3. Officer still liable to prosecution, trial, and punishment if the

impeachable offense committed also constitutes a felony or crime.

Section 4: SANDIGANBAYAN

Sandiganbayan = the anti-graft court

Sections 5-6, 8-14:  OFFICE OF THE OMBUDSMAN

Composition:

1.)                Ombudsman/Tanodbayan

2.)                Overall deputy

3.)                At least one Deputy each for Luzon, Visayas and Mindanao

4.)                Deputy for military establishment may be appointed

Qualifications: (Ombudsman and his deputies)

1.)    Natural born citizen of the Philippines

2.)    At least 40 years old at time of appointment

3.)    Of recognized probity and independence

4.)    Member of the Philippine bar

35

5.)    Must not have been candidate for any elective office in the immediately

preceding election

6.)    For Ombudsman: He must have been for ten years or more

1. A judge or

2. Engage in the practice of law in the Philippines

Disqualifications/Prohibitions (under Article IX, Section 2)

1.)    Cannot hold any other office or employment during his tenure

2.)    Cannot engage in the practice of any profession or in the active

management or control of any business which may be affected by the

functions of his office

3.)    Cannot be financially interested, directly or indirectly, in any contract

with or in any franchise or privilege granted by the Government, any of its

subdivisions, agencies or instrumentalities, including GOCCs or their

subsidiaries.

Appointment

1.  Of Ombudsman and deputies

1. By the president from a list of at least 6 nominees prepared by the

Judicial and Bar Council. Vacancies will be filled from a list of 3

nominees

2. Appointments do NOT require confirmation

3. All vacancies shall be filled within 3 months after they occur.

2.  Of other officials and employees of the Office of the Ombudsman

1. By the Ombudsman

2. In accordance with Civil Service Law

Term: (Ombudsman and deputies)

1.  7 years with reappointment

36

2.  They are NOT qualified to run for any office in the election immediately

succeeding their cessation from office

Rank/Salaries:

1.  The Ombudsman has the rank of Chairman of a Constitutional

Commission

2.  The Members have the rank of members of a Constitutional Commission

3.  Their salaries cannot be decreased during their term of office.

Powers, Functions and Duties of the Office of the Ombudsman

1.  Investigate on its own, or on complaint by any person, any act or

omission of any public official, employee, office or agency, when such act or

omission appears to be illegal, unjust, improper, or inefficient.

1. The SC held that the power to investigate and prosecute cases

involving public officers and employees has been transferred to the

Ombudsman.

2. The Ombudsman may always delegate his power to investigate.

3. The power to investigate includes the power to impose preventive

suspension.

4. This preventive suspension is not a penalty.

5. “INVESTIGATE” does not mean preliminary investigation.

6. The complaint need not be drawn up in the usual form.

7. The “ILLEGAL” act or omission need not be in connection with the

duties of the public officer or employee concerned.

8. ANY illegal act may be investigated by the Ombudsman.  In this regard,

the Ombudsman’s jurisdiction is CONCURRENT with that of the regular

prosecutors.

37

2.  Direct, upon complaint or at its own instance, any public official or

employee of the government, or any subdivision, agency or instrumentality

thereof, as well as of any government-owned or controlled corporation with

original charter, to perform and expedite any act of duty required by law, or

to stop, prevent, and correct any abuse or impropriety in the performance of

duties.

1. The Ombudsman has PERSUASIVE POWER, and may require that

proper legal steps are taken by the officers concerned.

2. The public official or employee must be employed in:

(I).       The Government

(II).      Any subdivision, agency, or instrumentality thereof; or

(III).     GOCC’s with original charters

1. The SC has held that the SP may prosecute before the Sandiganbayan

judges accused of graft and corruption, even if they are under the

Supreme Court.

3.)  Direct the officer concerned to take the appropriate action against a

public official or employee at fault, and recommend his removal, suspension,

demotion, fine, censure, or prosecution, and ensure compliance therewith.

1. The Ombudsman does NOT himself prosecute cases against public

officers or employees.

2. Final say to prosecute still rests in the executive department.

3. The Ombudsman or Tanodbayan may use mandamus to compel the

fiscal to prosecute.

4.)  Direct the officer concerned, in any appropriate case, and subject to such

limitations as may be provided by law to furnish it with copies of documents

38

relating to contracts or transactions entered into by his office involving the

disbursement or use of public funds of properties, and report any irregularity

to COA for appropriate action.

5.) Request any government agency for assistance and information

necessary in the discharge of its responsibilities, and to examine, if

necessary, pertinent records and documents.

6.) Public matters covered by its investigation when circumstances so

warrant and with due process.

7.) Determine the cause of inefficiency, red tape, mismanagement, fraud and

corruption in the government and make recommendations for their

elimination and the observance of high standards of ethics and efficiency

8.) Promulgate its rules of procedure and exercise such other powers or

perform such functions or duties as may be provided by law.

Note: The Office of the Ombudsman also has the duty to act promptly on

complaints filed in any form or manner against public officials or employees

of the government, or any subdivision, agency or instrumentality including

GOCCs and their subsidiaries.  In appropriate cases, it should notify the

complainants of the action taken and the result thereof.

Fiscal Autonomy

The Office of the Ombudsman enjoys fiscal autonomy.  Its approved annual

appropriations should be automatically and regularly released.

Section 7:  OFFICE OF THE SPECIAL PROCECUTOR

1. Under the 1987 Constitution, the existing Tanodbayan became the Office

of the Special Prosecutor

39

2. Powers

1. It will continue to function and exercise its powers as now or hereafter

may be provided by law

2. Exception: Powers conferred on the Office of the Ombudsman

3. The Office of the Special Prosecutor is subordinate to and acts under the

orders of the Ombudsman

Note: According to Jack, the SC was wrong because the ConCom

intended that the SP was to prosecute anti-graft cases.

 

Section 15: RECOVERY OF ILL-GOTTEN WEALTH

Prescription, Laches, Estoppel

1.)    The right of the State to recover properties unlawfully acquired by

public officials and employees from them or from their nominees or

transferees shall NOT be barred by prescription, laches or estoppel.

2.) Their right to prosecute criminally these officials and employees may

prescribe.

Section 16: PROHIBITION ON CERTAIN FINANCIAL TRANSACTIONS

Coverage:

This prohibition applies to:

1.)    President

2.)    Vice-President

3.)    Members of the Cabinet

40

4.)    Members of Congress

5.)    Members of Supreme Court

6.)    Members of Constitutional Commissions

7.)    Ombudsman

8.)    Any firm or entity in which they have controlling interest

When prohibition applies:

Prohibition applies during their TENURE.

Scope of prohibition:

1.)    The above mentioned officials cannot obtain, directly or indirectly for

BUSINESS PURPOSES:

1. Loans

2. Guarantees

3. Other forms of financial accommodation

From:

1. Government owned or controlled banks; or

2. Government owned or controlled financial institutions.

2.)    If the loan, etc, is NOT for business purpose, e.g. a housing loan, the

prohibition does not apply.

Section 17: Statements of assets, liabilities and net worth

When submitted:

41

Public officer and employee shall submit a declaration under oath of his

assets, liabilities and net worth upon assumption of office and as often as

required under the law.

When declaration shall be disclosed to the public:

These declarations shall be disclosed to the public in a manner provided by

law in the case of:

1.)    President

2.)    Vice-President

3.)    Members of the Cabinet

4.)    Members of Congress

5.)    Justices of the Supreme Court

6.)    Members of Constitutional Commissions

7.)    Other constitutional offices

8.)    Officers of the armed forces with general or flag rank

Section 18: Allegiance of public officers and employees

Allegiance to the State and to the Constitution

Change in Citizenship/Immigrant Status

1.)    Incumbent public officers and employees who seek either:

1. Change his citizenship; or

2. Acquire immigrant status in another country

Shall be dealt with by law.

42

2.)    If Philippine citizenship is one of the qualifications to the office, the loss

of such citizenship means the loss of the office by the incumbent.

3.)    The Election Code provides the rules with respect to non-incumbents,

i.e. persons running for elective offices.

1. The Code provides that permanent residents of or immigrant to a

foreign country cannot file certificates of candidacy unless they

expressly waive their status as such

This renunciation must be some other than, and prior to, the filling of the

certificate of candidacy.

 

ARTICLE X: LOCAL GOVERNMENT

 

Section 1.  TERRITORIAL/POLITICAL SUBDIVISIONS OF THE REPUBLIC

OF THE PHILIPPINES ARE THE:

Composition:

1)      Provinces

2)      Cities;

3)      Municipalities; and

4)      Barangays

There shall be Autonomous regions in:

1)      Muslim Mindanao, and

2)      Cordileras [At present, it is only the Cordilera ADMINISTRATIVE region]

43

Note:    1) A third autonomous regions would require a constiutional

amendment.

2) These political subdivisions, created by the Constitution cannot be

replaced by AMENDMENT, and not by law.

3) While Congress can abolish or eradicate individual units, it cannot abolish

an entire class of LGU’s

Section 2.  Local Autonomy

1)      All political subdivisions shall enjoy local autonomy

2)      This does not mean that the LGU’s are completely free from the central

government.

1. Judiciary may still pass on LGU actions

2. President may exercise disciplinary power over LGU officials.

Sec. 3. Congress shall enact a local government code which shall

provide for a more responsive and accountable local government

structure instituted through a system of decentralization with

effective mechanisms of recall, initiative, and referendum, allocate

among the different local government units their powers,

responsibilities, and resources, and provide for the qualifications,

election, appointment and removal, term, salaries, powers and

functions and duties of local officials, and all other matters relating

to the organization and operation of the local units.

 

Section 4.  PRESIDENTIAL SUPERVISION OF LGUS

Supervision of President

44

1)      The President exercises general supervision over all LGUs

2)      The President exercises DIRECT supervision over

1. Provinces

2. Autonomous regions and

3. Independent cities.

3)      This power is limited to ensuring that lower officers exercise their

functions in accordance with law.

4)      The president cannot substitute his judgment for that of an LGU official

unless the latter is acting contrary to law.

5)      The President may, however, impose administrative sanctions against

LGU officials, such as suspension for 120 days, and may even remove them

from their posts, in accordance with law.

6)      Provinces exercise direct supervision over component cities and

municipalities.

7)      Cities and municipalities exercise direct supervision over component

barangays.

Section 5.  EACH LOCAL GOVERNMENT SHALL HAVE THE POWER TO

CREATE OWN SOURCES OF REVENUE/LEVY TAXES, FEES AND

CHARGES ETC.

Limitations on Power

1)      It is subject to such guidelines and limitations as Congress may

provide.  See Local Government Code for examples.

2)      The guidelines set by Congress should be consistent with the basic

policy of local autonomy.

45

Accrual of taxes, fees, charges

The taxes, fees and charges shall accrue exclusively to the local

governments.

Section 6. LGUs SHALL HAVE A JUST SHARE IN NATIONAL TAXES, AS DETERMINED BY LAW, WHICH SHALL BE AUTOMATICALLY RELEASED TO THEM

Internal Revenue Allotment (IRA)

1)      Share of LGUs in national taxes is limited to the internal revenue taxes.

2)      The share of each LGU should be released, without need of any further

action, directly to the provincial, city, municipal or barangay treasurer. 

Release is made on a quarterly basis within 5 days after the end of each

quarter.

3)      The share of each LGU should not be subject to any lien or holdback

that may be imposed by the national government for whatever purpose.

4)      Each LGU should appropriate in its annual budget at least 20% of its

annual IRA for development projects.

5)      Adjustments in IRA

1. Ground:  Unmanageable public section deficit

2. President can make the necessary adjustments in the IRA upon the

recommendation of the following:

1. Department of Finance Secretary

2. DILG Secretary

3. DBM Secretary

6)      IRA considered for purposes of conversion from one political

subdivision to the next.  (Alvarez v. Guingona)

Section 7.  SHARE OF LGUS IN NATIONAL WEALTH

46

Share of LGUs in national wealth

1)      LGUs are entitled to an equitable share in the proceeds of the

utilization and development of the national wealth within their respective

areas in the manner provided by law.

2)      This includes share the same with the inhabitants by way of direct

benefits.

Under the LGC

1)      LGUs have a share of 40% of the gross collection derived by the

national government from the preceding fiscal year from

1. Mining taxes

2. Royalties

3. Forestry and fishery charges

4. Other taxes, fees and charges

5. Share in any co-production, joint venture or production sharing

agreement in the utilization and development of the national wealth

w/in their territorial jurisdictionSec. 8.  TERM OF OFFICE

Term of Office

Elective local officials, now including barangay officials have a term of 3

years.

Limitations:

1)      No elective official shall serve for more than 3 consecutive terms

2)      Voluntary renunciation of office for any length of time shall not be

considered as an interruption in the continuity of his service for the full term

for which he was elected.

Sec. 9.  SECTORAL REPRESENTATION IN LGUS47

Legislative bodies of the local governments shall have Sectoral

Representation (under the LGC) as may be provided by law

There should be representatives from:

1)      The women’s sector

2)      The workers

3)      Third sector (can choose from any of the following)

A)    Urban poor

B)     Indigenous cultural communities

C)     Disabled persons

D)    Any other sector as may be determined by the sanggunian

Election of Sector Representatives

Sec. 10. Creation, abolition and division of LGU’s

1)      Requisites

1. Compliance with the requirements of the Local Government Code; and

2. Approved by a majority of the votes cast in a plebiscite held in the

political units DIRECTLY affected.

2)      Thus, a province is supposed to be divided into 2 separate provinces,

plebiscite will include voters of the ENTIRE province, and not just the area to

comprise the new province.

3)      LGC requirements relate to matters such as population, revenue, and

area requirements.

Sec. 11.  Metropolitan political subdivisions

Creation:

48

1)      Congress may create special metropolitan political subdivisions by law.

2)      It is subject to a plebiscite

Jurisdiction of Metropolitan authority

It is limited to basic services requiring coordination.

Basic Autonomy of Component Cities and Municipalities

1)      The component cities and municipalities retain their basic autonomy

2)      They shall be entitled to their own local executive and legislative

assemblies.

Sec. 12.  CITIES

Classification of Cities:

1)      Highly urbanized (as determined by law)

2)      Component cities (cities still under provincial control); and

3)      Independent component cities (non-highly urbanized cities whose

voters are prohibited by thecity charter from voting in provincial elections)

Independence from the Province

1)      Highly urbanized cities and independent component cities are

independent of the province.

2)      Component cities whose charter contain no such prohibition are still

under the control of the province and its voters may still vote for elective

provincial officials.

Section 13.  Coordination among LGUS

Consolidation and Coordination of Efforts, Services and Resources

49

1)      It is optional on the part of LGUs as shown by the use of the word

“may”

2)      It can be done for purposes commonly beneficial to them in accordance

with the law.

Under LGC (Section 33)

1)      Consolidation and coordination may be done through appropriate

ordinances.

2)      A public hearing should be conducted and the approval of the

sanggunian obtained.

3)      An LGU can:

1. Contribute funds, real estate, equipment and other kinds of property

2. Appoint/assign personnel under such terms and conditions as may be

agreed upon by the participating LGUs through Memoranda of

Agreement.Section 14.  REGIONAL DEVELOPMENT COUNCILS

Who can provide for RDC

The President shall provide for RDC or other similar bodies composed of:

Composition

1)      Local government officials

2)      Regional heads of departments and other government offices

3)      Representatives of NGOS within the regions

For Purpose of

1)      Administrative decentralization

50

2)      To strengthen local autonomy

3)      To accelerate the economic and social growth and development of the

units in the region

Section 15.  AUTONOMOUS REGIONS

Where:

1)      Muslim Mindanao

2)      Cordillera region

Factors:

1)      Historical heritage

2)      Cultural heritage

3)      Economic and social structures,

4)      Other relevant characteristics within:

1. The framework of the consititution

2. National sovereignty

3. Territorial integrity.

Creation:

1)      Provided by law.

2)      EFFECTIVITY of such creation occurs only when it is approved by a

majority of the votes cast in a plebiscite held among the constituent units.

3)      Only those Provinces, Cities, and Geographical Areas voting favorably

in such plebiscite shall form part of the autonomous region.

51

4)      If only 1 province approved the law, NO AUTONOMOUS REGION

created, since the constitution requires more than one province to constitute

one (like what happened in the Cordillera plebiscite)

5)      The question of which LGU’s shall constitute an autonomous region is

one which is exclusively for Congress to decide.

Section 16.  GENERAL SUPERVISION OVER AUTONOMOUS REGIONS

By Whom:

The President

Purpose:

To ensure that the laws are faithfully executed.

Sec. 17.  All powers, functions and responsibilities not granted by

this Constitution or by law to the autonomous region shall be vested

in the National Government.

Examples:        1) Foreign relations,

2) National defense and Security

3) Monetary Affairs

Section 20.  LEGISLATIVE POWERS

The Organic Act of Autonomous Region shall provide for legislative

powers over:

1)      Administrative organization;

2)      Creation of sources of revenues;

3)      Ancestral domain and natural resources

52

4)      Personal, family and property relations

5)      Regional, urban, and rural planning development;

6)      Economic, social, and tourism development;

7)      Educational policies;

8)      Preservation and development of the cultural heritage; and

9)      Such other matters as may be authorized by law for the promotion of

the general welfare of the people of the region.

Limitations:

1)      Subject to the provisions of the Constitution and national laws

2)      To be exercised within its territorial jurisdiction

Section 21.  PRESERVATION OF PEACE AND ORDER/DEFENSE AND SECURITY

Peace and Order

It shall be the responsibility of the local police agencies.

Defense and Security

It shall be the responsibility of the national government.

 

Reference:

Political Law (Constitutional Law) Reviewer & Memory Aid

Ateneo Central Bar Operations 2001

Louie, Carrie, Evelyn, Thel, Gem, Ronald

 

ARTICLE IX – THE CONSTITUTIONAL COMMISSIONS53

Section 1.   Constitutional Commissions

Independent Constitutional Commissions:

1) Civil Service Commission (CSC)

2) Commission on Elections (COMELEC)

3) Commission on Audit (COA)

Why Independent?

They perform vital functions of government.  Their integrity is protected by

the fact that they:

1) Are constitutionally created (Sec. 1)

2) Have independent powers of appointment (Sec. 4)

3) Each Commission may promulgate its own procedural rules (Sec. 6)

4) Fiscal autonomy (Sec. 5)

5) Salaries may not be diminished during their office (Sec. 3)

6) Commissioners have a fixed term

7) Commissioners are removable by impeachment only.

Section 2.  DISQUALIFICATIONS

Disqualifications:

Members cannot, during their tenure:

1) Hold any other office or employment;

2) Engage in the practice of any profession;

54

3) Engage in the active management or control of any business, which, in

any   way, may be affected by the functions of their office; and

4) Be financially interested, direct or indirect, in any contract, franchise,

privilege granted by the government, any of its subdivisions, agencies,

instrumentalities, including GOCC’s and their subsidiaries.

Note:  The Ombudsman and his deputies are subject to the same

qualifications.

 Section 3.  SALARIES

Salaries

1) Salaries are fixed by law and shall not be decreased during their TENURE.

2) Decreases in salaries only affect those members appointed AFTER

increase.

3) Incumbent members do not lose any salary.

4) Increases take effect IMMEDIATELY.

Section 6.  RULES OF PROCEDURE

Procedures:

1) Rules:  The Commissions may promulgate its own rules EN BANC.

2) Limitation:  It shall not:

a) Diminish,

b) Increase, or

c) Modify substantive rights.

3) Power of SC

55

a). The SC may not, under Art. VIII Sec. 5(5), exercise the power to

disapprove rules of “special courts and quasi-judicial  bodies.”

b). In proceedings before the Commissions, the rules of the Commission

prevail.

c). In proceedings before a court, the Rules of Court prevail.

d). The SC may, however, in appropriate cases, exercise JUDICIAL REVIEW

Section 7.  DECISION MAKING/APPEAL

Decision-Making:

1) Each commission shall decide matter or cases by a majority vote of all the

members within 60 days from submission.

COMELEC may sit en banc or in 2 divisions.

Election cases, including pre-proclamation controversies are decided in

division, with motions for reconsideration filed to the COMELEC en banc.

The SC has held that a majority decision decided by a division of the

COMELEC is a valid decision.

2) As COLLEGIAL BODIES, each commission must act as one, and no one

member can decide a case for the entire commission.  (i.e.  The Chairman

cannot ratify a decision which would otherwise have been void).

Appeals:

1) Decisions, orders or rulings of the COMELEC/COA may be brought on

certiorari to  the SC under Rule 65.

2) Decisions, orders or ruling of the CSC should be appealed to the CA under

Rule 43.

56

Enforcement:

It has been held that the CSC can issue a writ of execution to enforce

judgments which are final.THE CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION

Section 1.  COMPOSITION/QUALIFICATIONS/TERM

Composition:

1) Chairman

2) Commissioners – 2 commissioners

Qualifications:

1) Natural-born citizens of the Philippines;

2) At least 35 years old at the time of their appointments;

3) With proven capacity for public administration; and

4) NOT candidates for any elective position in the elections immediately

preceding their appointment.

5) Appointees by the President to the CSC need Commission on

Appointments (CA) confirmation

Term:

1) Chairman -7 years; Commissioner1 – 5 yrs; Commissioner2 – 3 yrs

2) Limitation:  single term only, no reappointment

3) Appointment to vacancy: only for unexpired term of predecessor

4) No temporary appointments, or appointments in acting capacity.

Section 2.   Scope:

57

The Civil Service embraces all:

A.  branches,

B.  subdivisions,

C.  instrumentalities,

D.  agencies of the government,

E.  including GOCCs with original charters.

1.”With Original Charter” means that the GOCC was created by special

law/by Congress

2. If incorporated under the Corporation Code, it does not fall within the Civil

Service, and is not subject to the CSC jurisdiction.

3. Even if once government-controlled, then becomes privatized, ceases to

fall under CSC.

4. Jurisdiction is determined as of the time of filing the complaint.

Appointments to civil service shall be:

A. Competitive positions

According to merit and fitness to be determined by competitive

examinations, as far as practicable except to positions which are policy-

determining, primarily confidential, or highly technical.

B. Non-competitive positions

1). No need for competitive examinations.

2). 3 kinds

a) Policy-determining –           formulate a method of action for the gov’t

58

b) Primarily confidential –      more than ordinary confidence; close intimacy

insures freedom of intercourse without betrayals of personal trust…

c) Highly technical     –           requires technical skill to a superior degree.

C. The TEST to determine whether non/competitive is the Nature of

the responsibilities, NOT the administrative or legislative

description given to it.

D. Both types of positions are entitled to security of tenure. They

only differ in the MANNER in which they are filled.

E. Who may be appointed:

1). RULE:  Whoever fulfills all the qualifications prescribed by law for a

particular position may be appointed therein.

2). The CSC cannot disapprove an appointment just because another person

is better qualified, as long as the appointee is himself qualified.

3). The CSC CANNOT add qualifications other than those provided by law.

F. Next-In-Rank Rule

While a person next in rank is entitled to preferential consideration, it

does not follow that only he, and no one else, can be appointed.  Such

person has no vested right to the position and the appointing authority

is not bound to appoint the person next in rank.

Tenure (Classification of Positions)

Career Service Non-Career Service

1. Entrance based on merit and fitness to be determined as far as practicable by competitive examinations or based on highly technical qualifications.

1. Entrance on bases OTHER than usual tests of merit and fitness.

59

2. Entitled to security of tenure

1. Tenure limited to:

a)      Period specified by law,

b)      Coterminous with the

appointing authority or subject

to his pleasure, or

c)      Limited to the duration of

a particular project for which

purpose the employment was

made.

3. With opportunity for advancement to higher career positions.

Security of Tenure:

1) Officers or employees of the Civil Service cannot be removed or

suspended EXCEPT for cause provided by law. It guarantees both procedural

and substantive due process.

2) For “LEGAL CAUSE” – Cause is:

a). related to and affects the administration of office, and

b). must be substantial (directly affects the rights & interests of the public)

3) Security of tenure for Non-competitive positions

a). Primarily confidential officers and employees hold office only for so long

as confidence in them remains.

60

b). If there is GENUINE loss of confidence, there is no removal, but the

expiration of the term of office

c). Non-career service officers and employees do not enjoy security of

tenure.

d). Political appointees in the foreign service possess tenure coterminous

with  that of the appointing authority or subject to his pleasure.

4) One must be VALIDLY APPOINTED to enjoy security of tenure. Thus, one

who is not  appointed by the proper appointing authority does not acquire

security of tenure.

Abolition of Office

To be valid, abolition must be made:

(a) In good faith;  (good faith is presumed)

(b) Not for political or personal reasons; and

(c) Not in violation of law

Temporary employees are covered by the following rules:

1). Not protected by security of tenure – can be removed anytime even

without cause

2). If they are separated, this is considered an expiration of his term.

3). BUT:  They can only be removed by the one who appointed them.

4). Entitled only to such protection as may be provided by law.

No officer or employee in the Civil Service shall engage in any

electioneering or in partisan political activity

61

1) Cannot solicit votes in favor of a particular candidate.

2) Cannot give campaign contributions or distribute campaign materials.

3) BUT:  Allowed to express views on political issues, and to mention the

names of the candidates whom he supports.

4) Prohibition does not apply to department secretaries

Right to organize

The right to organize does NOT include the right to strike

Sections 6-7.  DISQUALIFICATION

Disqualifications

1) Losing candidates in any election

a). Cannot be appointed to any office in the government or GOCC’s or their

subsidiaries.

b). Period of disqualification: One (1) year after such election.

2) Elective officials

a). Not eligible for appointment or designation ANY CAPACITY to ANY PUBLIC

OFFICE or position during their tenure.

b). EXCEPTION:  May hold ex officio positions.

Examples:

The Vice President may be appointed Cabinet member

Congressman may sit in the Judicial and Bar Council

c). To be eligible to hold any other office, the elected official must first resign

his office

62

d). Even Congress cannot, by law, authorize the appointment of an elective

official.

3). Appointive officials

a). Cannot hold any other office or employment in the government, any

subdivision, agency, instrumentality, including GOCC’s and their subsidiaries.

b). EXCEPTION:  Unless otherwise allowed by law, or by the primary functions

of his position.

c). This exception DOES NOT APPLY to Cabinet members, and those officers

mentioned in Art. VII, Sec. 13.  They are governed by the stricter prohibitions

contained therein.

Section 8. COMPENSATION

1) Prohibitions:  applies to elected or appointed officers and

employees                     

Cannot receive:

A. Additional   –  an extra reward given for the same office i.e. bonus

B. Double  –  when an officer is given 2 sets of compensation for 2 different

offices held concurrently by 1 officer

C. Indirect Compensation

2) EXCEPTION:  Unless specifically authorized by law

A. “SPECIFICALLY AUTHORIZED” means a specific authority particularly

directed to the             officer or employee concerned.

B. BUT: per diems and allowances given as REIMBURSEMENT for expenses

actually incurred are not prohibited

63

3) Cannot accept any present, emolument, office, title of any kind from

foreign governments UNLESS with the consent of Congress.

4) Pensions and gratuities are NOT considered as additional, double, or

indirect compensation.

THE COMMISSION ON ELECTIONS

Section 1.  COMPOSITION/QUALIFICATIONS/TERM

Composition: (7)

1) Chairman and

2) Commissioners (6)

Qualifications:

1) Natural-born citizens of the Philippines;

2) At least 35 years old at the time of appointment

3) Holders of college degrees; and

4) Not candidates for any elective position in the immediately preceding

elections.

5) Majority of the Commission, including the Chairman must be:

a). Members of the Philippines Bar

b). Engaged in the practice of law for at least 10 years: “any activity in or out

of court, which requires the application of law, legal procedure, knowledge,

training and experience.”

6) Appointments subject to CA approval

64

Term:

1) Chairman -7 yrs; 3 Members – 7 yrs; 2 Members – 5 yrs; 1 Member – 3 yrs.

2) LIMITATION:  Single term only: no reappointment allowed

3) Appointment to a vacancy: only for unexpired portion of predecessor’s

term

4) No temporary appointments, or appointments in acting capacity

a). Thus, the President cannot designate an incumbent commissioner as

acting Chairman.

b). The choice of temporary chairman falls under the COMELEC’s discretion.

Section 2. POWERS AND FUNCTIONS

Powers:

1) Enforce and administer all laws and regulations relative to the conduct of

an election, plebiscite, initiative, referendum, and recall.

(a)    Ex: COMELEC can enjoin construction of public works within 45 days of

an election.

1)      Exercise:

A. Exclusive original jurisdiction over all contests relating to the elections,

returns, and qualifications of all elective

1. Regional,

2. Provincial, and

3. City officials

65

B. Appellate jurisdiction over all contests involving:

1. Elective municipal officials decided by trial courts of general jurisdiction

2. Elective barangay officials decided by trial courts of limited jurisdiction.

C. Decisions, final orders, or rulings of the Commission on election contests

involving elective municipal and barangay offices shall be final, executory,

and not appealable.

Exception: Appealable to the SC on questions of law.

1. Contempt powers

1. COMELEC can exercise this power only in relation to its adjudicatory or

quasi-judicial functions.  It CANNOT exercise this in connection with its purely

executive or ministerial functions.

2. If it is a pre-proclamation controversy, the COMELEC exercises quasi-

judicial/administrative powers.

3. Its jurisdiction over ‘contests’ (after proclamation), is in exercise of its

judicial functions.

E. The COMELEC may issue writs of certiorari, prohibition and mandamus in

exercise of its appellate jurisdiction.  This is not an inherent power.

3) Decide, except those involving the right to vote, all questions affecting

elections, including determination of the number and location of polling

places, appointment of election officials and inspectors, and registration of

voters.

Note: Questions involving the right to vote fall within the jurisdiction of the

ordinary courts.

66

4) Deputize, with the concurrence of the President, law enforcement

agencies and instrumentalities of the Government, including the Armed

Forces of the Philippines, for the exclusive purpose of ensuring free, orderly,

honest, peaceful, and credible elections.

a). This power is NOT limited to the election period.

b). Applies to both criminal and administrative cases.

5) Registration of political parties, organizations, or coalitions/accreditation

of citizens’ arms of the Commission on Elections.

a). The political parties etc. must present their platform or program of

government.

b). There should be sufficient publication

c). Groups which cannot be registered:

i. Religious denominations/sects

ii. Groups which seek to achieve their goals through violence or unlawful

means

iii. Groups which refuse to uphold and adhere to the Constitution

iv. Groups which are supported by any foreign government.

d). BUT:  Political parties with religious affiliation or which derive their

principles from religious beliefs are registerable.

e). Financial contributions from foreign governments and their agencies to

political parties, organizations, coalitions, or candidates related to elections

constitute interference in national affairs.  If accepted, it is an additional

67

ground for the cancellation of their registration with the Commission, in

addition to other penalties that may be prescribed by law.

1)    File, upon a verified complaint, or on its own initiative, petitions in court

for inclusion of exclusion of voters; investigate and, where appropriate,

prosecute cases of violations of election laws, including acts or omissions

constituting elections frauds, offenses and malpractices.

1. COMELEC has exclusive jurisdiction to investigate and prosecute cases

for violations of election laws.

2. COMELEC can deputize prosecutors for this purpose.  The actions of

the prosecutors are the actions of the COMELEC

3. Preliminary investigation conducted by COMELEC is valid.

2)    Recommend to the Congress effective measures to minimize election

spending, including limitation of places where propaganda materials shall be

posted, and to prevent and penalize all forms of election frauds, offenses,

malpractices, and nuisance candidacies.

3)    Recommend to the President the removal of any officer or employee it

has deputized, or the imposition of any other disciplinary action, for violation

or disregard or, or disobedience to its directive, order, or decision.

4)    Submit to the President and the congress a comprehensive report on the

conduct of each election, plebiscite, initiative, referendum, or recall.

Section 3.  RULES OF PROCEDURE/DECISION-MAKING

Rules of Procedure

1)    COMELEC can sit en banc or in two divisions

2)    It has the power to promulgate its own rules of procedure in order to

expedite disposition of election cases, including pre-election controversies.

68

Decision-Making

1) Election cases should be heard and decided in division. Provided that,

2) Motions for reconsideration of decisions should be decided by COMELEC

en banc.

3) ”Decisions” mean resolutions on substantive issues.

2)    If a division dismisses a case for failure of counsel to appear, the Motion

for Reconsideration here may be heard by the division.

3)    EXCEPTION: COMELEC en banc may directly assume jurisdiction over a

petition to correct manifest errors in the tallying of results by Board of

Canvassers.

Section 4.  SUPERVISION/REGULATION OF FANCHISES / PERMITS / GRANTS /

SPECIAL PRIVILEGES / CONCESSIONS

Regulation of franchises

A. What can COMELEC supervise or regulate

1). The enjoyment or utilization of all franchises or permits for the operation

of transportation and other public utilities, media of communication or

information.

2). Grants, special privileges or concessions granted by the Government or

any subdivision, agency or instrumentality thereof, including any GOCC or its

subsidiary

B. When can COMELEC exercise this power

 1). During the election period

69

a). Under Article XI, Section 9, the election period commences 90 days

before

the day of the election and ends 30 days thereafter.

b). In special cases, COMELEC can fix a period.

2). Applies not just to elections but also to plebiscites and referenda.

3). Plebiscite: Submission of constitutional amendments or important

legislative measures to the people ratification

4). Referendum:  power of the electorate to approve or reject legislation

through an election called for that purpose.

COMELEC and the MEDIA

1). COMELEC cannot compel print media to donate free space to the

COMELEC.  It may, however, compel it to provide space after paying just

compensation.

2). Power of COMELEC is over franchises and permits, NOT individuals. For

example, COMELEC may not regulate media practitioners, for this would

violate the freedom of expression.

Section 5.  No pardon, amnesty, parole, or suspension of sentence for

violation of election laws, rules, and regulations shall be granted by the

President without the favorable recommendation of the Commission.

Section 6

Definition of Political Party

organized group of persons pursuing the same political ideals in a

government and includes its branches, and divisions

Importance of registration of a political party

70

1)    Registration confers juridical personality on the party.

2)    It informs the public of the party’s existence and ideals.

3)    It identifies the party and its officers for purposes of regulation by the

COMELEC.

Section 7.  No votes cast in favor of a political party, organization, or

coalition shall be valid, except for those registered under the party-list

system as provided in this Constitution.

Prohibition on block-voting

1) General rule: Block voting NOT allowed

2) EXCEPTION: those registered under the party-list system

Section 8.  PARTY LIST SYSTEM

No Right to be Represented in Various Boards

Political parties, organizations, or coalitions registered under the party-

list system shall NOT be represented in the following:

1). Voters’ registrations boards,

2). Boards of election inspectors,

3). Boards of canvassers, or

4). Other similar bodies.

Poll Watchers

Political parties, etc. are entitled to appoint poll watchers in

accordance with law.

Section 10.  Bona fide candidates for any public office shall be free

from any form of harassment and discrimination.

71

This section does not give candidates immunity from suit.

Discrimination includes unequal treatment in the availment of media

facilities.

Section 11.  FUNDING

How provided

1)    Funds certified by the COMELEC as necessary to defray the expenses for

holding regular and special elections, plebiscites, initiative, referenda and

recalls, shall provided in the regular or special appropriations.

2)    Funds should be certified by the COMELEC as necessary.

Release of funds

Once approved, funds should be released automatically upon

certification by the Chairman of COMELEC.

THE COMMISSION ON AUDIT

Section 1.  COMPOSITION/QUALIFICATIONS

Composition:

1)    Chairman, and

2)    Commissioners (2).

Qualifications:

1)    Natural-born citizens of the Philippines

2)    At least 36 years old at the time of their appointment;

3)    Either:

a). CPA’s with at least 10 years auditing experience; or

b). Members of Phil. Bar with 10 years of practice.

72

4)    Members cannot all belong to the same profession.

5)    Subject to confirmation of the CA.

6)    Must not have been candidates for any elective position in the elections

immediately preceding their appointment.

Term:

1)    Chairman -7 yrs; Commissioner1 -5yrs; Commissioner – 2 -3 yrs.

2)    LIMITATION: – Single terms only; no re-appointment allowed

3)    Appointments to any vacancy shall only be for the unexpired portion of

predecessor’s term.

Section 2.  POWERS

1)    Examine, audit, and settle accounts pertaining to:

1. Revenue and receipts of funds or property; or

2. Expenditures and uses of funds or property

Owned or held in trust by, or pertain to:

1. The Government;

2. Any of its subdivisions, agencies or instrumentalities;

3. Including GOCC’s with original charters.

2)    Conduct post-audit with respect to the following:

1. Constitutional bodies, commissions, and offices granted fiscal

autonomy;

2. Autonomous state colleges and universities;

3. GOCC’s and their subsidiaries incorporated under the Corporation

Code.

73

4. None-governmental entities receiving subsidies or equity, directly or

indirectly, from or through the government, which are required by law

of the granting of institution to submit to such audit.

3)    If COA finds internal control system of audited agencies as inadequate,

COA may adopt measures, including temporary or special pre-audit, as may

be necessary.

4)    Keep the general accounts of the government, preserving vouchers and

other supporting papers pertaining thereto.

5)    Exclusive authority to define the scope of COA’s audit and examination

and to establish the techniques and methods required therefor.

6)    Promulgate accounting and auditing rules and regulations.

1. Including those for the prevention or disallowance of irregular,

unnecessary, excessive, extravagant, or unconscionable expenditures

or uses of government funds and properties.

2. Failure to comply with these rules can be a ground for disapproving the

payment of a proposed expenditure.

Note:

1)    The functions of COA can be classified as:

1. Examine and audit all forms of government revenues;

2. Examine and audit all forms of gov’t expenditures

3. Settle gov’t accounts

4. Promulgate accounting and auditing rules (including those for the

prevention of irregular…expenditures.

5. To decide administrative cases involving expenditures of public funds.

2)    COA can settle only LIQUIDATED ACCOUNTS or those accounts which

may be adjusted simply by arithmetic process.

74

3)    COA has authority not just over accountable officers but also over other

officers who perform functions related to accounting such as verification of

evaluations and computation of fees collectible, and the adoption of internal

rules of control.

4)    COA does not have the power to fix the amount of an unfixed or

undetermined debt.

5)    Where the following requirements are complied with, it becomes the

ministerial duty of the COA to approve and pass in audit vouchers for

payment:

1. There is a law appropriating funds for a particular purpose;

2. There is a contract, made by the proper officer, entered into in

conformity with the above-mentioned law;

3. The goods or services covered by such contract have been delivered or

rendered in pursuance to such contract, as attested by the proper

officer; and

4. Payment has been authorized by officials of the corresponding

department or bureau. 

6)    Prosecutors may still review accounts already settled and approved by

COA for the purpose of determining possible criminal liability.  This is

because COA’s interest in such accounts is merely administrative.

7)      COA has the power to determine the meaning of ‘public bidding’ and

what constitutes failure when regulations require public bidding for the sale

of government property.

Section 3.  No law shall be passed exempting any entity of the

Government or its subsidiary in any guise whatever, or any

75

investment of public funds, from the jurisdiction of the Commission

on Audit.

 

ARTICLE VIII. THE JUDICIAL DEPARTMENT

 

Sec. 1.  JUDICIAL POWER

Scope:

1. Judicial power is the authority to settle justiciable controversies or

disputes involving rights that are enforceable and demandable before the

courts of justice or the redress of wrongs for violations of such rights.

2.  Vested in the Supreme Court and such lower courts as may be

established by law.

3. Since the courts are given ‘judicial power’ and nothing more, courts may

neither attempt to assume or be compelled to perform non-judicial

functions.  They may not be charged with administrative functions except

when reasonably incidental to the fulfillment of their duties.

4.  In order that courts may exercise this power, there must exist the

following:

1. An actual controversy with legally demandable and enforceable rights;

2. Involving real parties in interest;

3. The exercise of such power will bind the parties by virtue of the court’s

application of existing laws.

76

5.  Judicial power cannot be exercised in vacuum.  Without any laws from

which rights arise and which are violated, there can be no recourse to the

courts.

6.  The courts cannot be asked for advisory opinions.

7.  Judicial power includes:

1. The duty of the courts to settle actual controversies involving rights

which are legally demandable and enforceable; and

1. To determine whether or not there has been a grave abuse of

discretion amounting to lack or excess of jurisdiction on the part of any

branch or instrumentality of the government.

Political Questions:

1.  A ‘political question’ is one the resolution of which has been vested by the

Constitution exclusively in either the people, in the exercise of their

sovereign capacity, or in which full discretionary authority has been

delegated to a co-equal branch of the Government.

2.  Thus, while courts can determine questions of legality with respect to

governmental action, they cannot review government policy and the wisdom

thereof, for these questions have been vested by the Constitution in the

Executive and Legislative Departments.

Sec. 2.  ROLES OF CONGRESS

1.  Defining enforceable and demandable rights and prescribing remedies for

violations of such rights; and

2.  Determining the court with jurisdiction to hear and decide controversies

or disputes arising from legal rights.

77

3.  Thus, Congress has the power to define, prescribe and apportion the

jurisdiction of various courts.

1. BUT, Congress cannot deprive the Supreme Court of its jurisdiction

over cases provided for in the Constitution.

2. Creation and abolition of courts:

1. The power to create courts implies the power to abolish and even

re-organize courts.

2. BUT this power cannot be exercised in a manner which would

undermine the security of tenure of the judiciary.

3. If the abolition/re-organization is done in good faith and not for

political or personal reasons, then it is VALID.  (same rule applies

for civil servants)

Sec. 3.  FISCAL AUTONOMY

1. The entire judiciary shall enjoy fiscal autonomy.

2. Annual appropriations for the judiciary cannot be reduced below the

amount appropriated for the previous year.

3. Once approved, appropriations shall be automatically and regularly

released.

Secs. 4-7; 12 JUDICIARY

Composition of the Supreme Court:

1. Chief Justice and

2. 14 Associate Justices

Note:  Members of the Supreme Court and of other courts established by law

shall not be designated to any agency performing quasi-judicial or

administrative functions.

Qualifications of members of the SC:

1.  Natural born citizen of the Philippines

2.  At least 40 years old78

3.  At least 15 years of experience as a judge or in the practice of law in the

Philippines

4.  Person of proven competence, integrity, probity and independence.

Qualifications of members of lower collegiate courts (CA, CTA,

Sandiganbayan)

1.  Natural born citizen of the Philippines

2.  Member of the Philippine bar

3.  Possesses other qualifications prescribed by Congress

4.  Person of proven competence, integrity, probity and independence.

Qualifications of judges of lower non-collegiate courts:

1.  Citizen of the Philippines (may be a naturalized citizen)

2.  Member of the Philippine Bar

3.  Possesses other qualifications prescribed by Congress

4.  Person of proven competence, integrity, probity and independence.

Section 8.  JUDICIAL AND BAR COUNCIL

1.  The Judicial and Bar Council is under the supervision of the SC.

A.  Is under the supervision of the Supreme Court and is composed of:

1. Chief Justice, as ex-officio chairman

2. Secretary of Justice, as an ex-officio member

3. Representative of Congress, as an ex-officio member

4. Representative of the Integrated Bar

79

5. A professor of law

6. A retired member of the SC; and

7. Private sector representative

Note:  The last four re the regular members of the JBC.  Regular members

are appointed by the President with CA approval.  Regular members serve

for 4 years, with staggered terms.

B.  Functions of JBC

1. Principal function:  recommend appointees to the Judiciary

2. Exercise such other functions as the SC may assign to it.

C.  Appointments to the Judiciary  

1. President shall appoint from a list of at least 3 nominees for each

vacancy, as prepared by the JBC.

2. No CA confirmation is needed for appointments to the Judiciary.

3. Vacancies in SC should be filled within 90 days from the occurrence of

the vacancy.

4. Vacancies in lower courts should be filled within 90 days from

submission to the President of the JBC list.

Sec. 10.  SALARIES

1.  Salaries of SC Justices and judges of lower courts shall be fixed by law.

2.  Cannot be decreased during their continuance in office, but can be

increased.

3.  Members of the Judiciary are NOT exempt from payment of income tax.

Sec. 11.  TENURE/DISCIPLINARY POWERS OF SC

1.  Members of the SC and judges of the lower courts hold office during good

behavior until

a.  The age of 70 years old; or

80

b.  They become incapacitated to discharge their duties.

2.  Disciplinary action against judges of lower courts:

a.  Only the SC en banc has jurisdiction to discipline or dismiss judges of

lower courts.

b.  Disciplinary action/dismissal:  Majority vote of SC Justices who took part in

the deliberations and voted therein.

3.  Removal of SC Justices:

a.  Only by IMPEACHMENT.

b.  Cannot be disbarred while they hold office.

Secs. 4-6, 13.  THE SUPREME COURT

Hearing of cases:

1. En banc; or

2. Divisions of 3, 5, or 7.

Cases required to be heard en banc:

1.  All cases involving constitutionality of a/an:

a.  Treaty

b.  International or executive agreement or

c.  Law.

2.  All cases required to be heard en banc under the Rules of Court:

a.  Appeals from Sandiganbayan; and

b.  From the Constitutional Commissions

81

3.  All cases involving the constitutionality, application or operation of

a.  Presidential decrees

b.  Proclamations

c.  Orders

d.  Instructions

e.  Ordinances; and

f.   Other regulations.

4.  Cases heard by a division where required majority of 3 was not obtained.

5.  Cases where SC modifies or reverses a doctrine or principle of law laid

down by the SC en banc or by a division.

6.  Administrative cases to discipline or dismiss judges of lower courts; and

7.  Election contests for President and Vice-President.

Cases heard by division

1.  Must be decided with the concurrence of a majority of the members who

took part in the deliberations and voted thereon.

2.  Majority vote in a division should be at least 3 members.

Powers of the SC

1.  SC has ORIGINAL jurisdiction over

a.  Cases affecting ambassadors, other public ministers and consuls.

Note:  This refers to foreign ambassadors, etc., stationed in the Philippines.82

b.  Petitions for certiorari, prohibiton, mandamus, quo warranto, and habeas

corpus.

2.  SC has APPELLATE jurisdiction over final judgments and orders in the

following:

a.  All cases involving the constitutionality or validity of any

1. treaty

2. international or executive agreement

3. law

4. presidential decree

5. proclamation

6. order

7. instruction

8. ordinance, or

9. regulation;

b.  All cases involving the legality of any

1. tax

2. impost

3. assessment or

4. toll or

5. any penalty imposed in relation thereto;

c.  All cases in which the jurisdiction of any lower court is in issue

d. Criminal cases where the penalty imposed is reclusion perpetua or higher;

and

e.  All cases where ONLY errors or questions of law are involved.

83

3.  Temporarily assign lower court judges to other stations in the public

interest.

Note:  Temporary assignment shall not exceed 6 months without the consent

of the judge concerned.

4.  Order a change of venue or place of trial to avoid a miscarriage of justice.

5.  Promulgate rules concerning:

a.  The protection and enforcement of constitutional rights;

b.  Pleading, practice and procedure in all courts;

c.  Admission to the practice of law;

d.  The Integrated Bar; and

e.  Legal assistance to the underprivileged.

Limitations on Rule Making Power

a. It should provide a simplified and inexpensive procedure for the speedy

disposition of cases.

b.  It should be uniform for all courts of the same grade.

c.  It should not diminish, increase, or modify substantive rights.

6.  Appoint ALL officials and employees of the Judiciary, in accordance with

Civil Service Law.

7. Exercise administrative supervision over ALL courts and the personnel

thereof.

Decisions of the Supreme Court:

84

1. Reached in consultation before being assigned to a member for the writing

of the opinion.

2. A certification to this effect must be signed by the Chief Justice and

attached to the record of the case and served upon the parties.

3. Members of the SC who took no part, or who dissented or abstained must

state the reasons therefore.

Note:  This procedure shall also be observed by all lower collegiate courts

(CA, CTA, and theSandiganbayan).

JUDICIAL REVIEW

Definition

1.  Judicial Review is the power of the SC to declare a law, treaty,

ordinance etc. unconstitutional.

2.    Lower courts may also exercise the power of judicial review, subject to

the appellate jurisdiction of the SC.

3.   Only SC decisions are precedent, and thus, only SC decisions are binding

on all.

Requisites                                            Code:   [A R S Co R]

1.  An ACTUAL CASE calling for the exercise of judicial power

2.  The question involved must be RIPE FOR ADJUDICATION, i.e. the

government act must have had an adverse effect on the person challenging

it.

3.  The person challenging the governmental act must have ‘STANDING’, i.e.

a personal and substantial interest in the case such that he has sustained, or

will sustain, direct injury as a result of its enforcement.

4.  The question of Constitutionality must be raised in the first instance, or at

the earliest opportunity.

85

5.  Resolution of the issue of constitutionality is unavoidable or is the very lis

mota.

Effect of a declaration of unconstitutionality:

1.  Prior to the declaration that a particular law is unconstitutional, it is

considered as an ‘operative fact’ which at that time had to be complied with.

2.  Thus, vested rights may have been acquired under such law before it was

declared unconstitutional.

3. These rights are not prejudiced by the subsequent declaration that the law

is unconstitutional.

Sec. 14.  DECISIONS

1.  Decisions MUST state clearly and distinctly the facts and the law on which

it is based.

2.  Refusal to give due course to petitions for review and motions for

reconsideration must state the legal basis for such refusal.

3.  Memorandum decisions, where the appellate court adopts the findings of

fact and law of the lower court, are allowed as long as the decision adopted

by reference is attached to the Memorandum for easy reference.

4.  These rules only apply to courts.  They do not apply to quasi-judicial or

administrative bodies nor to military tribunals.

86

Courtesy of Ms. Magz

http://en.gravatar.com/lawphilreviewer

 

87