CONSTANT EFFORT COMPUTATION AS A DETERMINANT OF MOTOR BEHAVIOR

19
CONSTANT EFFORT COMPUTATION CONSTANT EFFORT COMPUTATION AS A DETERMINANT OF MOTOR AS A DETERMINANT OF MOTOR BEHAVIOR BEHAVIOR Emmanuel Guigon, Pierre Baraduc, Michel Emmanuel Guigon, Pierre Baraduc, Michel Desmurget Desmurget INSERM U483, UPMC, Paris, France INSERM U483, UPMC, Paris, France INSERM U534, « Space and Action », Bron, France INSERM U534, « Space and Action », Bron, France

TAGS:

description

CONSTANT EFFORT COMPUTATION AS A DETERMINANT OF MOTOR BEHAVIOR. Emmanuel Guigon, Pierre Baraduc, Michel Desmurget INSERM U483, UPMC, Paris, France INSERM U534, « Space and Action », Bron, France. Amplitude (cm). MOTOR BEHAVIOR: CONSTRAINED. AMPLITUDE / VELOCITY AMPLITUDE / DURATION. - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Transcript of CONSTANT EFFORT COMPUTATION AS A DETERMINANT OF MOTOR BEHAVIOR

Page 1: CONSTANT EFFORT COMPUTATION AS A DETERMINANT OF MOTOR BEHAVIOR

CONSTANT EFFORT COMPUTATIONCONSTANT EFFORT COMPUTATIONAS A DETERMINANT OF MOTOR AS A DETERMINANT OF MOTOR

BEHAVIORBEHAVIOR

Emmanuel Guigon, Pierre Baraduc, Michel DesmurgetEmmanuel Guigon, Pierre Baraduc, Michel DesmurgetINSERM U483, UPMC, Paris, FranceINSERM U483, UPMC, Paris, France

INSERM U534, « Space and Action », Bron, FranceINSERM U534, « Space and Action », Bron, France

Page 2: CONSTANT EFFORT COMPUTATION AS A DETERMINANT OF MOTOR BEHAVIOR

MOTOR BEHAVIOR: CONSTRAINEDMOTOR BEHAVIOR: CONSTRAINED

AMPLITUDE / VELOCITYAMPLITUDE / DURATION

Gordon et al. (1994)

Amplitude (cm)

Page 3: CONSTANT EFFORT COMPUTATION AS A DETERMINANT OF MOTOR BEHAVIOR

MOTOR BEHAVIOR: CONSTRAINEDMOTOR BEHAVIOR: CONSTRAINED

KINEMATICINVARIANCE

Gordon et al. (1994)

Page 4: CONSTANT EFFORT COMPUTATION AS A DETERMINANT OF MOTOR BEHAVIOR

MOTOR BEHAVIOR: CONSTRAINEDMOTOR BEHAVIOR: CONSTRAINED

CONSTRAINTS ACROSS DIRECTIONS

Gordon et al. (1994)

Page 5: CONSTANT EFFORT COMPUTATION AS A DETERMINANT OF MOTOR BEHAVIOR

MOTOR BEHAVIOR: CONSTRAINEDMOTOR BEHAVIOR: CONSTRAINED

SPEED VS ACCURACY

Fitts (1954)Jeannerod (1988)

W = 2 inW = 1W = 0.5W = 0.25

*

Page 6: CONSTANT EFFORT COMPUTATION AS A DETERMINANT OF MOTOR BEHAVIOR

MOTOR BEHAVIOR: FLEXIBLEMOTOR BEHAVIOR: FLEXIBLE

INDEPENDENT CONTROLOF KINEMATICS AND

ACCURACY

Gribble et al. (2003)

Page 7: CONSTANT EFFORT COMPUTATION AS A DETERMINANT OF MOTOR BEHAVIOR

KNOWN PRINCIPLESKNOWN PRINCIPLESAmplitude/duration OCOC (Harris&Wolpert 1998)

Kinematic invariance OCOC (Flash&Hogan 1985 - Harris&Wolpert 1998)

Across directions ? (but see Todorov 1998)

Speed/accuracyOFC + SEN (Hoff&Arbib 1993) or SDNSDN (Todorov 2003)OC + SDN (Harris&Wolpert 1998)

Kinematics/accuracy ?

Trajectory OC (Uno et al. 1989) - EPT (Gribble et al. 1998)

EMG OC (Dornay et al. 1996) - EPT (Flanagan et al. 1990)

Online correctionOFC (Hoff&Arbib 1993 - Todorov&Jordan 2002)EPT (Flanagan et al. 1993)

Redundancy SOFC (Todorov&Jordan 2002)

Central command ? (but see Todorov 2000)

OCOC: optimal control - OFCOFC: optimal feedback control - SOFCSOFC: stochastic OFCEPTEPT: equilibrium-point theory - SDNSDN: signal-dependent noise - SENSEN: state-estimation noise

Page 8: CONSTANT EFFORT COMPUTATION AS A DETERMINANT OF MOTOR BEHAVIOR

CURRENT PRINCIPLESCURRENT PRINCIPLES

• Optimal feedback controlOptimal feedback controlConstraints: to reach the goal (zero-error)Objective (cost): to minimize the controls (effort)

• Constant effortConstant effortFor given instructions, all movements areperformed with the same effort

• CocontractionCocontraction as an independent parameter

• State-estimation noiseState-estimation noiseInaccuracy in estimation of position and velocityIncreases with velocityDecreases with cocontraction (fusimotor control)

Page 9: CONSTANT EFFORT COMPUTATION AS A DETERMINANT OF MOTOR BEHAVIOR

Muscles as force generator.No force/length effects.No force/velocity effects.No stretch reflex.No biarticular muscles.

No static forces.No viscosity.Same formulation for OFC.Solved numerically (Bryson 1999).

OPTIMAL CONTROL PROBLEMOPTIMAL CONTROL PROBLEM

Page 10: CONSTANT EFFORT COMPUTATION AS A DETERMINANT OF MOTOR BEHAVIOR

KINEMATICSKINEMATICS

Page 11: CONSTANT EFFORT COMPUTATION AS A DETERMINANT OF MOTOR BEHAVIOR

EMGsEMGs

SHOULDER ELBOW

Page 12: CONSTANT EFFORT COMPUTATION AS A DETERMINANT OF MOTOR BEHAVIOR

AMPLITUDE / DURATIONAMPLITUDE / DURATION

Page 13: CONSTANT EFFORT COMPUTATION AS A DETERMINANT OF MOTOR BEHAVIOR

KINEMATIC INVARIANCEKINEMATIC INVARIANCE

Also holds for changesin inertial load.

Page 14: CONSTANT EFFORT COMPUTATION AS A DETERMINANT OF MOTOR BEHAVIOR

DIRECTIONAL VARIATIONSDIRECTIONAL VARIATIONS

Page 15: CONSTANT EFFORT COMPUTATION AS A DETERMINANT OF MOTOR BEHAVIOR

KINEMATICS & ACCURACYKINEMATICS & ACCURACY

- OFCOFC + SENSEN- Estimation of endpoint position: linear forward model- Gaussian noise on velocity- Variability: determinant of terminal covariance matrix

SHOULDER

ELBOW

- Same amplitude- Same duration- Similar kinematics- Different accuracy

Page 16: CONSTANT EFFORT COMPUTATION AS A DETERMINANT OF MOTOR BEHAVIOR

WHAT ARE THE CONTROLS?WHAT ARE THE CONTROLS?

Sergio&Kalaska (1998)

SHOULDER FLEXOR CONTROL

Page 17: CONSTANT EFFORT COMPUTATION AS A DETERMINANT OF MOTOR BEHAVIOR

DIRECTIONAL TUNINGDIRECTIONAL TUNING

Sergio&Kalaska (1998)

FLEXOR EXTENSOR

SH

OU

LD

ER

EL

BO

W

Page 18: CONSTANT EFFORT COMPUTATION AS A DETERMINANT OF MOTOR BEHAVIOR

SUMMARYSUMMARY

• Known principles OPTIMAL FEEDBACK CONTROLOPTIMAL FEEDBACK CONTROLSTATE-ESTIMATION NOISESTATE-ESTIMATION NOISE

TrajectoryEMGSpeed/accuracyCentral command

• New principles CONSTANT EFFORTCONSTANT EFFORTCOCONTRACTIONCOCONTRACTION

Amplitude/durationKinematic invarianceConstraints across directionsKinematics/accuracy

Page 19: CONSTANT EFFORT COMPUTATION AS A DETERMINANT OF MOTOR BEHAVIOR

DISCUSSIONDISCUSSION

• Kinematic invarianceWithout desired trajectory.

• Constant effortMovements are selected not byminimizing a cost, but by choosinga cost level

• Limitations / Extensions- Static forces- Limitations of force control (Ostry&Feldman

2003)- Accuracy/stability: viscoelastic properties- Adaptation to force fields and inertial loads


Input Description 2-1 · $DET determinant full CI for MCSCF ALDECI:DETINP $CIDET determinant full CI ALDECI:DETINP $GEN determinant general CI for MCSCF ALGNCI:GCIINP $CIGEN determinant

Input Description 2-1 · $DET determinant full CI for MCSCF ALDECI:DETINP $CIDET determinant full CI ALDECI:DETINP $GEN determinant general CI for MCSCF ALGNCI:GCIINP $CIGEN determinant

Parallelizing the Hamiltonian Computation in DQMC ...Che-Rung Lee (cherung@cs.nthu.edu.tw) Parallel Checkerboard Method AsHES 2012 1 / 31. Outline 1 Determinant quantum Monte Carlo

Parallelizing the Hamiltonian Computation in DQMC ...Che-Rung Lee ([email protected]) Parallel Checkerboard Method AsHES 2012 1 / 31. Outline 1 Determinant quantum Monte Carlo

Social Determinant and NCD

Social Determinant and NCD

Determining the Determinant

Determining the Determinant

Matrix Operations: Determinant

Matrix Operations: Determinant

Job satisfaction and determinant factors among … · Job satisfaction and determinant factors among midwives ... (95%CI:(0.001–0.45 ... Job satisfaction and determinant factors

Job satisfaction and determinant factors among … · Job satisfaction and determinant factors among midwives ... (95%CI:(0.001–0.45 ... Job satisfaction and determinant factors

Determinant of Attitude

Determinant of Attitude

Determinant Dpp

Determinant Dpp

Determinant Brand Extension

Determinant Brand Extension

Design Bill Determinant Standard and Convention · 3. Bill Determinant Attribute Convention 8 3.1 Common Bill Determinant Attribute 8 3.2 Charge Group Specific Bill Determinant Attributes

Design Bill Determinant Standard and Convention · 3. Bill Determinant Attribute Convention 8 3.1 Common Bill Determinant Attribute 8 3.2 Charge Group Specific Bill Determinant Attributes

Beylkin Determinant

Beylkin Determinant

Context-Dependent Network Agents Specific technology goals of funded effort: distributed computation and control applications of synchronized sampling.

Context-Dependent Network Agents Specific technology goals of funded effort: distributed computation and control applications of synchronized sampling.

MATA33 Determinant notes, mostly stolen from Prof Eric ... ongoing/lecture portions... · MATA33 Determinant notes, mostly stolen from Prof Eric Moore Definition: determinant (i)

MATA33 Determinant notes, mostly stolen from Prof Eric ... ongoing/lecture portions... · MATA33 Determinant notes, mostly stolen from Prof Eric Moore Definition: determinant (i)

Numerical Analysis - khu.ac.krcvlab.khu.ac.kr/NALecture10.pdf · 2015. 10. 12. · Determinant by Gauss Elim. •Determinant calculation is expensive with large system •Determinant

Numerical Analysis - khu.ac.krcvlab.khu.ac.kr/NALecture10.pdf · 2015. 10. 12. · Determinant by Gauss Elim. •Determinant calculation is expensive with large system •Determinant

Determinant of Microcredit Repayment.pdf

Determinant of Microcredit Repayment.pdf

Behavioral determinant

Behavioral determinant

Interesting Determinant Formulas

Interesting Determinant Formulas

Earning the right to indulge: Effort as a determinant of customer

Earning the right to indulge: Effort as a determinant of customer

Determinant: §3.1 The Determinant of a Matrix

Determinant: §3.1 The Determinant of a Matrix

1 Chapter 6 – Determinant Outline 6.1 Introduction to Determinants 6.2 Properties of the Determinant 6.3 Geometrical Interpretations of the Determinant;

1 Chapter 6 – Determinant Outline 6.1 Introduction to Determinants 6.2 Properties of the Determinant 6.3 Geometrical Interpretations of the Determinant;