COMPLIANCE TO AS2941-2013 FIXED FIRE PROTECTION ... · • Sections 3 & 4 – Pumps • Section 8...

21
All slides © Copyright FPA Australia COMPLIANCE TO AS2941-2013 FIXED FIRE PROTECTION INSTALLATIONS – PUMPSET SYSTEMS Ken Kugler – Executive Officer – Standards – Pump Industry Australia Robert Date – Managing Director – Welling & Crossley Tim Ewens – Technical Specialist – Fire – BKB Building Solutions

Transcript of COMPLIANCE TO AS2941-2013 FIXED FIRE PROTECTION ... · • Sections 3 & 4 – Pumps • Section 8...

Page 1: COMPLIANCE TO AS2941-2013 FIXED FIRE PROTECTION ... · • Sections 3 & 4 – Pumps • Section 8 -Electric Motors & Controllers • Section 9 –Diesel Engines & Controllers •

All slides © Copyright FPA Australia

COMPLIANCE TO AS2941-2013FIXED FIRE PROTECTION INSTALLATIONS –PUMPSET SYSTEMS

Ken Kugler – Executive Officer – Standards – Pump Industry Australia

Robert Date – Managing Director – Welling & Crossley

Tim Ewens – Technical Specialist – Fire – BKB Building Solutions

Page 2: COMPLIANCE TO AS2941-2013 FIXED FIRE PROTECTION ... · • Sections 3 & 4 – Pumps • Section 8 -Electric Motors & Controllers • Section 9 –Diesel Engines & Controllers •

All slides © Copyright FPA Australia

WHAT DOES AS2941 SPECIFY?

In General:-• Foreword:

• provides minimum requirements for FIRE pump sets• Based on sound engineering principles, test data and field experience

• Scope:• Totally independent pump set systems• Specific requirements for pumps, drivers, pump controllers and auxiliary

equipment for FIRE pump sets• Requirements for installation and acceptance testing for electrical and

compression-ignition drivers

Page 3: COMPLIANCE TO AS2941-2013 FIXED FIRE PROTECTION ... · • Sections 3 & 4 – Pumps • Section 8 -Electric Motors & Controllers • Section 9 –Diesel Engines & Controllers •

All slides © Copyright FPA Australia

WHAT DOES AS2941 SPECIFY?

Specifically:-• Sections 3 & 4 – Pumps • Section 8 - Electric Motors & Controllers• Section 9 – Diesel Engines & Controllers• Section 3 – Pipework• Section 10 - Shop Testing & Conformance• Appendix D – the Pump House/Room• Appendix F – Performance Test Data, Controller Function Test - Typical

Page 4: COMPLIANCE TO AS2941-2013 FIXED FIRE PROTECTION ... · • Sections 3 & 4 – Pumps • Section 8 -Electric Motors & Controllers • Section 9 –Diesel Engines & Controllers •

All slides © Copyright FPA Australia

WHY DO WE NEED AS2941?

A very good Question!Why do we need any standard?

We need AS2941 so that we can be confident that the fire pump set will do its job effectively in the event that it is required to run to

protect life and property from a fire.

Page 5: COMPLIANCE TO AS2941-2013 FIXED FIRE PROTECTION ... · • Sections 3 & 4 – Pumps • Section 8 -Electric Motors & Controllers • Section 9 –Diesel Engines & Controllers •

All slides © Copyright FPA Australia

WHO IS RESPONSIBLE FOR ENSURING COMPLIANCE WITH AS2941?

Architects:• Section 11 & Appendix D state clearances required around fire

pumps for maintenance and replacementEngineers & Designers:• Section 2 Water Supplies, Section 3 General Requirements, Section 4

Specific Requirements and so onPump Set Manufacturers:• Among other sections, Section 10 Shop testing & Conformance

Page 6: COMPLIANCE TO AS2941-2013 FIXED FIRE PROTECTION ... · • Sections 3 & 4 – Pumps • Section 8 -Electric Motors & Controllers • Section 9 –Diesel Engines & Controllers •

All slides © Copyright FPA Australia

WHO IS RESPONSIBLE FOR ENSURING COMPLIANCE WITH AS2941?

Fire Contractors:• All SectionsCertifiers:• All SectionsBuilders:• All SectionsFacilities Managers:• All Sections

Page 7: COMPLIANCE TO AS2941-2013 FIXED FIRE PROTECTION ... · • Sections 3 & 4 – Pumps • Section 8 -Electric Motors & Controllers • Section 9 –Diesel Engines & Controllers •

All slides © Copyright FPA Australia

WHAT GUARANTEE DO YOU HAVE FOR COMPLIANCE?

Are the words:Certificate of Conformance

“This is to certify that the ABC Pump Company electric fire pump serial number XYZ123 built and tested on factory order 12345/1 complies with the requirements of AS2941-2013”.

Sufficient?

Page 8: COMPLIANCE TO AS2941-2013 FIXED FIRE PROTECTION ... · • Sections 3 & 4 – Pumps • Section 8 -Electric Motors & Controllers • Section 9 –Diesel Engines & Controllers •

All slides © Copyright FPA Australia

WHAT GUARANTEE DO YOU HAVE FOR COMPLIANCE?

Performance to AS2417 Annex A

Annubar line take-off between non-return valve & discharge isolation valve – NOT from common discharge manifold

Page 9: COMPLIANCE TO AS2941-2013 FIXED FIRE PROTECTION ... · • Sections 3 & 4 – Pumps • Section 8 -Electric Motors & Controllers • Section 9 –Diesel Engines & Controllers •

All slides © Copyright FPA Australia

WHAT GUARANTEE DO YOU HAVE FOR COMPLIANCE?

Maximum Absorbed PUMP

power

Page 10: COMPLIANCE TO AS2941-2013 FIXED FIRE PROTECTION ... · • Sections 3 & 4 – Pumps • Section 8 -Electric Motors & Controllers • Section 9 –Diesel Engines & Controllers •

All slides © Copyright FPA Australia

WHAT DOES COMPLIANCE LOOK LIKE?

Page 11: COMPLIANCE TO AS2941-2013 FIXED FIRE PROTECTION ... · • Sections 3 & 4 – Pumps • Section 8 -Electric Motors & Controllers • Section 9 –Diesel Engines & Controllers •

All slides © Copyright FPA Australia

WHAT DOES NON-COMPLIANCE LOOK LIKE?

Page 12: COMPLIANCE TO AS2941-2013 FIXED FIRE PROTECTION ... · • Sections 3 & 4 – Pumps • Section 8 -Electric Motors & Controllers • Section 9 –Diesel Engines & Controllers •

All slides © Copyright FPA Australia

WHAT DOES NON-COMPLIANCE LOOKLIKE?

Page 13: COMPLIANCE TO AS2941-2013 FIXED FIRE PROTECTION ... · • Sections 3 & 4 – Pumps • Section 8 -Electric Motors & Controllers • Section 9 –Diesel Engines & Controllers •

All slides © Copyright FPA Australia

WHAT DOES COMPLIANCE LOOK LIKE?

Electric Panel8.2.4e – is capable of being locked in the ON position (power on)8.2.8 – touch screens shall not be used for primary operation – start, stop & reset8.2.19 – each driver control device and each switch and circuit breaker shall be marked to indicate plainly the name of the manufacturer, model number and applicable electrical rating

Page 14: COMPLIANCE TO AS2941-2013 FIXED FIRE PROTECTION ... · • Sections 3 & 4 – Pumps • Section 8 -Electric Motors & Controllers • Section 9 –Diesel Engines & Controllers •

All slides © Copyright FPA Australia

WHAT DOES COMPLIANCE LOOK LIKE?

Diesel Panel9.3.6.5 – Manual shutdown shall be accomplished by means of a hold-on push button manual stop switch9.4.4 – is capable of being locked in the ON position (power on)9.4.6 – touch screens shall not be used for primary operation – start, stop & reset9.4.21 – similar wording to 8.2.19 regarding labelling.

Page 15: COMPLIANCE TO AS2941-2013 FIXED FIRE PROTECTION ... · • Sections 3 & 4 – Pumps • Section 8 -Electric Motors & Controllers • Section 9 –Diesel Engines & Controllers •

All slides © Copyright FPA Australia

WHAT DOES NON-COMPLIANCE LOOKLIKE?

Power cables must be a minimum of 300mm above the floor

Incorrect gauge installation

No isolation valve

downstream of mains

bypass check valve &

pipework is unsupported placing high

stress on pump

nozzles

Pressure switch loop is unsupported

– no vibration isolation

Page 16: COMPLIANCE TO AS2941-2013 FIXED FIRE PROTECTION ... · • Sections 3 & 4 – Pumps • Section 8 -Electric Motors & Controllers • Section 9 –Diesel Engines & Controllers •

All slides © Copyright FPA Australia

WHAT DOES NON-COMPLIANCE LOOKLIKE?

Both the main cooling line and the bypass cooling line must contain a pressure regulating valve – not

one for both

No check valve downstream of the bypass strainer

Stress on hose – poor manufacture

only

Page 17: COMPLIANCE TO AS2941-2013 FIXED FIRE PROTECTION ... · • Sections 3 & 4 – Pumps • Section 8 -Electric Motors & Controllers • Section 9 –Diesel Engines & Controllers •

All slides © Copyright FPA Australia

A CHECK LIST

In our experience, compliance with the standard is poor!

The possible solution?“Check List?”

Page 18: COMPLIANCE TO AS2941-2013 FIXED FIRE PROTECTION ... · • Sections 3 & 4 – Pumps • Section 8 -Electric Motors & Controllers • Section 9 –Diesel Engines & Controllers •

All slides © Copyright FPA Australia

A CHECK LIST

Page 19: COMPLIANCE TO AS2941-2013 FIXED FIRE PROTECTION ... · • Sections 3 & 4 – Pumps • Section 8 -Electric Motors & Controllers • Section 9 –Diesel Engines & Controllers •

All slides © Copyright FPA Australia

A CHECK LIST

Page 20: COMPLIANCE TO AS2941-2013 FIXED FIRE PROTECTION ... · • Sections 3 & 4 – Pumps • Section 8 -Electric Motors & Controllers • Section 9 –Diesel Engines & Controllers •

All slides © Copyright FPA Australia

A CHECK LIST

Page 21: COMPLIANCE TO AS2941-2013 FIXED FIRE PROTECTION ... · • Sections 3 & 4 – Pumps • Section 8 -Electric Motors & Controllers • Section 9 –Diesel Engines & Controllers •

All slides © Copyright FPA Australia

SUMMING UP - THE ISSUES

Who would complete a check list?We see the document being the responsibility of numerous individuals.Perhaps it should be split or sectioned for the following:

• System Designer• Pumpset Manufacturer• Installation Contractor

• Certifier• Building Surveyor