Commentary_Pitcja
-
Upload
pitcha-sakmangkorn -
Category
Documents
-
view
18 -
download
0
Transcript of Commentary_Pitcja
Commentary # 2
“Coca Cola and Schwarzkopf’s Advertising for Muslim Market”
By
Pitcha Sakmangkorn
Multi-cultural Marketing Communications
Dr. M. Schiller
April 4, 2015
The world consists of many diverse markets that are different from aspect to aspect,
such as culture, belief, and trend. To success in reaching one specific market, the company cannot
apply the same approach into every market. To get people, showing that the brand “understands”
you by conveying effective communication, is needed.
Two print ads above belong to the Coca Cola Company that were launched in the
mid 2014 regarding to one of the most important festival of Muslims, “Ramadan”. The ads and the
campaign attempted to reach Muslims who believe and follow the rule of holy Quran-Sharif and
Ramadan during one-month period of fasting that was June 29th- July 27th 2014. Fasting during
Ramadan is one of the Five Pillars of Islam; in other words, five primary obligations or pillars of
faith that each Muslim must fulfill in his or her lifetime (The five pillars of Isam, 2015). The ads
relevant themselves with Muslims by connecting the brand with their cultural beliefs and Islamic
religion in which it brings emotional appeal of consumers to the ads. This is related to value appeal
for devout/spiritual people who are traditional, respectful, modest, and obedient whom they have
strong underlying beliefs about priorities in their lives and morality. Also, the ads portray an appeal
of psychological needs; the need to eat and drink. It implies that Coca Cola is a drink for you after
you break the fast.
As we can see from the ads, the brand uses the moon and Arabic alphabets in the
visuals. This is related to Islam religion, specifically Ramadan as mentioned. Ramadan is a month
that Muslims all over the world will “fast” or abstain from food, drink, and other physical needs
such as sexual activities, including evil actions, thoughts, and words, from dawn until sunset. The
underlying assumption of this tradition is for Muslims to purify the soul from impurities, practice
self-sacrifice/restraint, have time to re-focus attention on the worship of God (El-Ashi, A., Fasting
in Islam). They communicate by using the moon in ad visual that refers to a new moon sighting,
marking the start of the ninth month in the Islamic calendar, in other words, Ramadan begins
(Ramadan starts in United States, 1995). Another visual appears Arabic alphabets shaping to be
Coca Cola bottle. It can be implied as a refreshing bottle that Muslims can enjoy drinking once they
break the fast.
These two ads are well executed since they show that the brand is “one of them”,
they value what Muslims value, they believe what Muslims believe, and they want to be part of
important thing in their lives. Muslims value religion so much and prioritize it, therefore if the
brand shows that they value and understand Islamic religion, consumers are likely to trust the brand
and recognize the brand easily. Consequently, the brand can embed in consumers’ brain for long,
which results in brand loyalty, and eventually the brand can make the high volume of sales from the
product being advertised.
By mid-2014, the German hair care brand Schwarzkopf that is under giant consumer-goods
maker like Henkel AG & Company launched the ads and the campaign to please hidden market of
Muslim women who have veiled hair (Schlusse, D., 2014).
The ad visuals show the product images and the Muslim models wearing “Hijab”, a veil
that covers the head and chest, which is daily worn by Muslim women beyond the age of
adolescence. This kind of attire is a symbol of modesty and privacy. Muslims are taught to believe
that women’s physical beauty is not something to be commoditized or to be shown in public sphere,
especially to men. Wearing it also means to show respect to their God and to show that they obey and
recognize the immense wisdom behind his commandment (Why do Muslim women veil themselves,
2011).
The Glorious Qur’an, Islamic bible says “Say to the believing women that they should lower
their gaze and guard their modesty; and that they should not display their beauty and ornaments
except what must ordinarily appear thereof; that they should draw their veils over their bosoms and
not display their beauty except to their husbands…” (Al-Qur'an 24:30-31)
Hair is considered part of a woman’s physical attractiveness. Therefore, for Muslim women,
hair covering is an essential thing to do to express their sincere and modesty of attire. Also, hijab is
not merely about covering the beauty but it is a sign for Muslims to restrain behavior, manners,
speech and appearance in public (Why do Muslim women veil themselves, 2011).
Now we know that all Muslim women have to wear it. One thing we can assume is not all of
them will be pleased wearing it, especially new generation who tends to care more about their
physical appearance and materials. One possible problem of Muslim women is if they suffocate their
hair under hijab all day, their hair will be stinky, has split ends, and the scalp will be itchy. The brand
acts like they understand these problems by claiming that the shampoo can refresh hair, more
importantly they act like they understand the need of the women to follow the path of Islamic. It
looks like they were trying to “help female Muslim out” to have pleasant feeling with hair while they
still can maintain their value of religion at the same time.
The appeal shown in the ads is “need for aesthetic sensations”, by using beautiful models
and the sea background that give us a sense of beauty and relaxation. This gives an idea that the
product will help fulfill the need of having beautiful hair even its under the veil.
Again these ads connect to cultural belief and Islamic religion. They show that they are
helpful and be the answer that solves irritated issues in their minds. Therefore these ads are well
executed.
However, to make the ads more effective, I would suggest Schwarzkopf to connect to female
Muslims more in terms of the ad visuals. These two ads just simply show the product images and the
models without the real and powerful stories behind them. For example, the visuals should include a
woman in the veil surrounded by people in an outdoor area. She smiles and laughs happily showing
the confidence that the shampoo itself gives her happiness. Or it could be a woman in the veil
standing elegantly with the blurred background of prominent Islamic sacred/holy place.
Reference
Fasting in Islam. Retrieved from http://www.eden.rutgers.edu/~muslims/fasting.htm
Hijab. Retrieved from http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hijab
Quran. Retrieved from http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quran
Ramadan. Retreieved from http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ramadan
Ramadan starts in United States. Retrieved from http://www.timeanddate.com/holidays/us/ramadan-begins
Shampoo Jihad: Major Companies Marketing Shampoo for “Veiled [Muslim] Women”; HAMAS Ad
Campaign Comin’ Soon. Retrieved from http://www.debbieschlussel.com/71592/absurd-sad-companies-
marketing-shampoo-for-veiled-muslim-women/
The five pillars of Islam. Retrieved from http://www.saudiembassy.net/about/country-
information/Islam/five_pillars_of_Islam.aspx
Why do Muslim women veil themselves?. Retrieved from http://www.whyislam.org/faqs/islam-and-gender-
issues/why-do-muslim-women-veil-themselves/