Collins v. Smith (1978)

8/13/2019 Collins v. Smith (1978)

1/25

Page 1

8/13/2019 Collins v. Smith (1978)

2/25

Page 2578 F.2d 1197, *; 1978 U.S. App. LEXIS 11072, **;

3 Media L. Rep. 2490

1 ! 1 "#$UME%&

FRANK COLLIN and the NATIONAL SOCIALIST PARTY OFAMERICA, Plaintiffs-Appellees, v. ALERT SMIT!, P"esident #f the

$illa%e #f S&ie, Illin#is' (O!N N. MAT)ER, (R., $illa%e Mana%e" #f

the $illa%e #f S&ie, Illin#is' !AR$EY SC!*ART), C#"p#"ati#n

C#+nsel #f the $illa%e #f S&ie, Illin#is' and the $ILLAE OF

SKOKIE, ILLINOIS, a M+niipal C#"p#"ati#n, efendants-Appellants

N#s. /0-1201, /0-1203

4NITE STATES CO4RT OF APPEALS FOR T!E SE$ENT!

CIRC4IT

3/0 F.5d 116/' 16/0 4.S. App. LE7IS 118/5' 2 Media L. Rep. 5968

Ap"il 19, 16/0, A"%+ed

Ma: 55, 16/0

ISPOSITION; AFFIRME".

CASE S4MMARY;

PROCE4RAL POST4RE; Appe''a(), a +i''age, i) peide(), a(d )-e, g-) e+ie/ ! a dge()e()eed a U(i)ed S)a)e di)i) ), /-i- i(+a'ida)ed Sie, I''., 6i''age #di(a(e %. 775%994,

a pe-e(i+e pei) )e ! a'' paade p'i ae'ie ! e )-a( 50 pe(. Appe''ee, a%ai p'i)ia' gp, app'ied ! a pei) ) -'d a de()a)i( i( !() ! )-e +i''age -a''. &-e +i''agede(ied )-e pei).

O$ER$IE*; Appe''ee, a %ai p'i)ia' gp, p'a((ed ) a- i( !() ! appe''a() +i''age +i''age -a''.Appe''a() )ai(ed a pe'ii(a i(()i(. A!)e )-e ) e!ed ) )a )-e i(()i( pe(di(g appea',)-e U(i)ed S)a)e Spee $) deed a )a. :/e+e, )-e i(()i( /a ee()' e+eed.Appe''a() e(a)ed )-ee di(a(e ) p-ii) )-e de()a)i(. A!)e appe''ee app'ia)i( ! a pei)/a de(ied, )-e ) e+ie/ed )-e e+ide(e a(d ga()ed appe''ee e'ie!. #( appea', )-e ) -ad )de)ei(e /-e)-e )-e Fi) Ae(de() p)e)ed appe''ee a)i+i). &-e ) -e'd )-e Fi) Ae(de()ea() )-a) g+e(e() -ad ( p/e ) e)i) e

8/13/2019 Collins v. Smith (1978)

3/25


3 Media L. Rep. 2490-'a), ))ea(e, /eai(g, ii(a' 'ie', ppei(

Le?isNe?is@R !eadn#tes

Constitutional Law > Bill of Rights > Fundamental Freedoms > Freedom of Assembly

Constitutional Law > Bill of Rights > Fundamental Freedoms > Freedom of Speech > Commercial

Speech > Boycotts & Piceting

!ransportation Law > Carrier "uties & Liabilities > Contraband

=:%1> A')-g- a-i(g, paadi(g, a(d pie)i(g, eae )-e i(+'+e (d) ip'ia)i(g ig(i!ia()i()ee) i( ai()ai(i(g p'i de, ae 'e p)e)ed )-a( pe pee-, )-e ae ((e)-e'e e) )ig(i!ia() Fi) Ae(de() p)e)i(. I(deed, a( de' a(d peae!' de()a)i(, /i)- p'aad, i()-e +ii(i) ! a ea) ! g+e(e(), i a( e Fundamental Freedoms > Freedom of Speech > Fighting #ords

=:%3> A (+i)i( ! 'e )-a( /d )-a) a) 'ea) )e(d ) i(i)e a( iedia)e ea- ! )-e peae a(()e )i!ied.

Constitutional Law > Bill of Rights > Fundamental Freedoms > Freedom of Speech > "efamation >

$eneral %eriew

Constitutional Law > Bill of Rights > Fundamental Freedoms > Freedom of Speech > Fighting #ordsConstitutional Law > Bill of Rights > Fundamental Freedoms > Freedom of Speech > %bscenity

=:%4> &-ee ae e)ai( /e''de!i(ed a(d (a/' 'ii)ed 'ae ! pee-, )-e pe+e()i( a(dp(i-e() ! /-i- -a+e (e+e ee( )-g-) ) aie a( $()i))i(a' p'e. &-ee i('de )-e 'e/da(d e(e, )-e p!a(e, )-e 'ie', a(d )-e i(')i(g ?!ig-)i(g? /d. S- ))ea(e ae (ee()ia' pa) ! a( e Bill of Rights > Fundamental Freedoms > Freedom of Speech > Scope of

Freedom=:%@> I) i pe!e)' 'ea )-a) a )a)e a( () ae ii(a' )-e peae!' e

8/13/2019 Collins v. Smith (1978)

4/25


3 Media L. Rep. 2490!!e(i+e pee-, ) (' /-e( )-e peae i()de ( )-e pi+a ! )-e -e, a ap)i+e adie(ea(() pa)ia'' a+id e Bill of Rights > Fundamental Freedoms > Freedom of Speech > Scope ofFreedom

=:%8> &-e ai'i) ! g+e(e(), ((a() /i)- )-e U(i)ed S)a)e $()i))i(, ) -) !! die'e' ) p)e) )-e ! -eai(g i) i depe(de() p( a -/i(g )-a) )a()ia' pi+a i()ee) aeei(g i(+aded i( a( ee()ia'' i()'ea'e a((e. A( ade +ie/ ! )-i a)-i) /'d e!!e)i+e'ep/e a ai) ) i'e(e diide() ip' a a a))e ! pe(a' pedi'e)i(.

Constitutional Law > Bill of Rights > Fundamental Freedoms > 'udicial & Legislatie Restraints >

Prior Restraint

=:%9> &-e pep)i( agai() pi e)ai() i -ea+ie a(d )-e degee ! p)e)i( ade )-a( )-a)agai() 'ii) ( e

8/13/2019 Collins v. Smith (1978)

5/25


3 Media L. Rep. 2490)a,National Socialist Party of America v. Village of Skokie, 432 U.S. 43, 53 L. Ed. 2d 9@, 97 S. $). 2205C1977D. &-e i(()i( /a ee()' e+eed !i) i( pa), Village of Skokie v. National Socialist Partyof America, 51 I''. App. 3d 279, 3@@ %.E.2d 347, 9 I''. "e. 90 C1977D, a(d )-e( i( i) e()ie), id.,@9 I''. 2d @05, 373 %.E.2d 21, 14 I''. "e. 890, 3 Media L. Rep. 1704 C1978D. #( Ma 2, 1977, )-e 6i''agee(a)ed )-ee di(a(e ) p-ii) de()a)i( - a )-e (e $''i( a(d %SPA -ad )-ea)e(ed. 3&-i'a/i) ee de'aa) a(d i(()i+e e'ie! agai() e(!ee() ! )-e di(a(e.

3 &-e di)i) ) -eei( !(d a a a))e ! 'egi'a)i+e i()e() )-a) )-e di(a(e i( e)i( /ee deig(ed ) +e %aia-e. &-e appe''a() d () a))a )-e !i(di(g.

6i''age #di(a(e %. 775%994 C-eei(a!)e deig(a)ed, ! (+e(ie(e ! e!ee(e, a 994D i ape-e(i+e pei) )e ! a'' paade p'i ae'ie ! e )-a( 50 pe(. 4I) eiepei) app'ia() ) )ai( G300,000 i( p'i 'iai'i) i(a(e a(d G50,000 i( ppe) daagei(a(e.Id., HH 2754, 275@CD. #(e ! )-e peeii)e ! a pei) i a !i(di(g )-e apppia)eC!!iia'D )-a) )-e ae'

/i'' () p)a ii(a'i), depa+i) 'a ! +i)e i(, i(i)e +i'e(e, -a)ed, ae -)i'i) )/ada pe( gp ! pe( ea( ! e!ee(e ) e'igi, aia', e)-(i, (a)i(a' egi(a' a!!i'ia)i(.

Id., H 275@CD. A()-e i a !i(di(g )-a) )-e pei) a)i+i) /i'' () e (d)ed ?! a( ('a/!'ppe,? id., H 275@CiD. %(e ! )-i di(a(e app'ie ) a)i+i)ie ! )-e 6i''age i)e'! ! ag+e(e()a' age(, id., H 2751, a(d a( p+ii( ! )-e di(a(e a e /ai+ed (a(i(e() ! )-e ad ! &)ee ! )-e 6i''age, id., H 27@4. & paade ae'e /i)-) a pei) i aie, p(i-a'e !i(e ! G5 ) G500.Id., H 27@5.

4 Se)i( 2752 ! )-e di(a(e eie app'ia)i( ! a pei) a) 'ea) 30 da e!e )-e pped paade. Lie e)-e p+ii( ! 994, i) i () -a''e(ged -ee. e ae i(!ed )-a) appe''ee egi)eed 'e))e ! Api' 11, 1978, -a+e

app'ied ! a pei) ) de()a)e ( B(e 25, 1978.

6i''age #di(a(e %. 775%995 C995D p-ii)

)-e diei(a)i( ! a( a)eia' /i)-i( )-e 6i''age ! Sie /-i- p)e a(d i(i)e -a)ed agai()pe( ea( ! )-ei ae, (a)i(a' igi(, e'igi(, a(d i i()e(ded ) d

. . . .

Id., H 2843.1. ?"iei(a)i( ! a)eia'? i('de p'ia)i( dip'a di)i)i( ! p)e, ig(, -a(di'', /i)i(g a(d p'i dip'a !ai(g a(d ')-i(g ! 'i ig(i!ia(e.

Id., H 2843.2. 6i'a)i( i a ie p(i-a'e !i(e ! p ) G500, ipi(e() ! p ) i< ()-.

Id., H 28.43.4. 6i''age #di(a(e %. 775%99@ C99@D p-ii) p'i de()a)i( ee !p'i)ia' pa)ie /-i'e /eai(g ?i'i)a)'e? (i!, H 28.42.1, a(d +i'a)i( i p(i-a'e a i( 995.

$''i( a(d %SPA app'ied ! a pei) ) a- ( B' 4, 1977, /-i- /a de(ied ( )-e g(d )-eapp'ia)i( di'ed a( i()e()i( ) +i'a)e 99@. &-e 6i''age appae()' app'ie 994 H 275@CiD )-a) a(i()e()i( ) +i'a)e 995 99@ e)a'i-e a( ?('a/!' ppe? ! )-e a- ae'. &-e pei)app'ia)i( )a)ed )-a) )-e a- /'d 'a) a) a -a'! -, a(d /'d i(+'+e 30 ) 50 de()a)/eai(g (i! i('di(g /a)ia a(d ai(g a pa) a((e /i)- a /a)ia a(d p'aad /i)-)a)ee() )-ee( - a ?-i)e Fee Spee-,? ?Fee Spee- ! )-e -i)e Ma(,? a(d ?Fee Spee- !-i)e Aeia.? A i(g'e !i'e ide/a' a- )-a) /'d () dip) )a!!i /a pped, /i)-) pee-e

8/13/2019 Collins v. Smith (1978)

6/25

Page @578 F.2d 1197, *; 1978 U.S. App. LEXIS 11072, **;

3 Media L. Rep. 2490 )-e di)i)i( ! -a(di'' 'i)ea)e. 5$(e' ! )-e 6i''age ad+ie )-a) )-e 6i''age de ()ai()ai( )-a) $''i( a(d %SPA /i'' e-a+e )-e )-a( a deied i( )-e pei) Capp'ia)i(D.

5 A e(e/ed pei) app'ia)i( ! B(e 25, 1978, /a e() ) )-e 6i''age ( Api' 11, 1978, a(d ()ai( ii'a ei)a)i(.

&-e di)i) ), a!)e (idei(g ea(da, e

8/13/2019 Collins v. Smith (1978)

7/25


3 Media L. Rep. 2490&-ee a)i+i)ie i(+'+e )-e ?g(a)e ig-)? ! !ee pee- a(d !ee ae'. See Thomas v. Collins, 323U.S. 51@, 530, 89 L. Ed. 430, @5 S. $). 315 C1945D. ?&-e /eai(g ! a( aa(d ! )-e ppe !e A+e a'' e'e, )-e Fi) Ae(de() ea( )-a) g+e(e() -a ( p/e ) e)i) e C1971D; Street v. Ne# /ork, 394 U.S. 57@, =22 L. Ed. 2d 572, 89 S. $). 1354> C19@9D;Ne# /ork TimesCo. v. Sllivan, 37@ U.S. 254, 2@970, =11 L. Ed. 2d @8@, 84 S. $). 710> C19@4D, a(d ae i)ed; NAACP v. $tton,371 U.S. 415, 445, =9 L. Ed. 2d 405, 83 S. $). 328> C19@3D; 0ood v. 'eorgia, 370 U.S. 375, 388389, =8 L. Ed. 2d

8/13/2019 Collins v. Smith (1978)

8/25


3 Media L. Rep. 24905@9, 82 S. $). 13@4> C19@2D; Terminiello v. Chicago, 337 U.S. 1, 4, =93 L. Ed. 1131, @9 S. $). 894> C1949D;De

1onge v. +regon, 299 U.S. 353, 3@5, =81 L. Ed. 278, 57 S. $). 255> C1937D. & pei) )-e ()i(ed i'di(g ! p'i)i a(d ')e, a(d ) ae e'!!'!i''e() ! ea- i(di+ida', pep'e ae gaa()eed )-e ig-) )e

8/13/2019 Collins v. Smith (1978)

9/25


3 Media L. Rep. 2490p-ii)i( ! appe''ee de()a)i(. A')-g- )-a) deii( /a i( a pi e)ai() ()e

8/13/2019 Collins v. Smith (1978)

10/25


3 Media L. Rep. 2490I( pi(i($eaharnaisde () pp) di(a(e 995, ! )/ i(depe(de() ea(. Fi), )-ea)i(a'e ! )-a) deii( )( i)e p'ai(' ( )-e )(g )e(de( ! )-e p-ii)ed ))ea(e ) ae+i'e(e a(d dide. &-e I''i(i Spee $) -ad 'ii)ed )-e )a))e app'ia)i(, a )-e U(i)edS)a)e Spee $) ()ed.

Id. a) 254. &-e 'a))e $) a' pi()ed ) )-a) )-e )e(de( ) i(de ea-

! )-e peae /a )-e )adi)i(a' )i!ia)i( ! )-e ii(a' 'ie' 'a/ /-i- -ad a'/a ee( )-g-) ) ei(e ! )-e Fi) Ae(de(). Id. A!)e )a)i(g )-e ie C/-e)-e I''i(i 'd e

13 I) ea ()i(g )-a) /e ae note+ie/i(g -ee a 'a/ /-i- p-ii) a)i( deig(ed ) ipede )-e ea' e

8/13/2019 Collins v. Smith (1978)

11/25


3 Media L. Rep. 2490i(i)e +i'e(e )-a) )i!ied ii(a' 'ie' 'a/. e d () ead i) a e)a'i-i(g a( a')e(a)i+e g(d ! deii(.

15 e a' ()e )-a) /e -a+e !(d ()-i(g i( Spee $) pi(i( a!)e$eaharnais) pp) )-i i()epe)a)i(.

I(deed, i( )-Ne# /ork Times Co. v. Sllivan, 37@ U.S. 254, 2@8, 11 L. Ed. 2d @8@, 84 S. $). 710 C19@4D; a(d 'arrison v.&oisiana, 379 U.S. @4, 70, 13 L. Ed. 2d 125, 85 S. $). 209 C19@4D, )-e $) ie! e!ee(e )$eaharnais)ea)ed i) a aae i(+'+i(g a 'ie'i-d ! +i'e(e.

&-e Eig-)- $ii), Tollett v. *nited States, 485 F.2d 1087, 1094 (.14 C8)- $i. 1973D, a(d Bdge ig-) !)-e "i)i) ! $'ia $ii),Anti5Defamation &eage of $,nai $,rith v. -ederal CommnicationsCommission, 131 U.S. App. ".$. 14@, 403 F.2d 1@9, 174 (.5 C19@8D C(i(g pi(i(D, cert. denied, 394U.S. 930, 22 L. Ed. 2d 459, 89 S. $). 1190 C19@9D, -a+e e I)i pe!e)' 'ea )-a) a )a)e a( () ?ae ii(a' )-e peae!' e

8/13/2019 Collins v. Smith (1978)

12/25

8/13/2019 Collins v. Smith (1978)

13/25


3 Media L. Rep. 2490pei) ! )-e a- a () e de(ied ( )-e ai ! a()iipa)ed +i'a)i( )-ee!. See994 H 275@CiD, )ed a+e. e )( ) )-e e)i( ! /-e)-e )-e ii'a p+ii( i') i() 994, H 275@CD, a( e )-e ai ! a pei) de(ia'.

&-e a(/e ea'' !''/ /i)- e+e( gea)e )e(g)- ! ('i( ( 995. eae 994 H 275@CDgi+e ) 6i''age ?!!iia' )-e p/e ) de( e ! a ! i( ad+a(e ! a)a' e

8/13/2019 Collins v. Smith (1978)

14/25


3 Media L. Rep. 2490#( )-e )-e -a(d, /e d () (eed ) de)ei(e (/ )-a) ( i(a(e eiee() 'd e iped i(a( i)a(e, /-i- /'d e a 'e e)i(, i( +ie/. &-e pee() ae de () eie ) ea- ) ) deide )-i ie ( a ad ai. Appe''ee /i'' eei+e a'' )-e e'ie! )-e -a+e ee)eda(d ) /-i- )-e ae e()i)'ed ( ei)-e g(d. Adi(g', /e aep) )-e 6i''age (ei( )-a) )-ei(a(e eiee() a(() e app'ied -ee, 21/-i- i p'ai(' a(da)ed )-e ed a(d )-epe)i(e() ae 'a/, a(d a!!i )-e dge() a i) ea ( HH 2754 a(d 275@CD ( )-a) ai.

21 &-e die() ip'ia)i( )-a) /e g-) ) /ai) ) ee e

8/13/2019 Collins v. Smith (1978)

15/25


3 Media L. Rep. 2490Co% v. Ne# 2ampshire, 312 U.S. 5@9, 85 L. Ed. 1049, @1 S. $). 7@2 C1941D, i a' i(appi)e, )-eae i) i(+'+ed pei) !ee ae!'' deig(ed (' ) -e'p )-e )/( i( e)i( de!a a)a' )i(ed i( paade, a(d eae )-ee /a, i( )-e i)a(e ! )-a) ae, ( ai ) ae )-e )a))e?/'d e app'ied a ) pe+e() peae!' pie)i(g. . . .?

Id. a) 578.

e )-i( )-e ip'ia)i( i( Bdge Spe-e pi(i( )-a) )-e di)i) ) a(d )-i ) -a+e e(gaged i(a( (ee' ?-? ) dge() i /i)-) pp). &-e ae /a e!e )-e di)i) ) ! +e i

Collins v. Smith (1978)

Documents

Transcript of Collins v. Smith (1978)