COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for...

180
February 2007

Transcript of COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for...

Page 1: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

February 2007

Research Institute for Higher EducationHIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY

ISBN978-4-902808-27-8

COE Publication Series No. 25

A Study of Research Policy,Research Training, and Mobility

in the Academic Community

February 2007

Page 2: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

���������� �������

������������

���������� ����

���������� ���

Page 3: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

COE ���������� �

� ���������� ������������������ Research Institute for

Higher Education���� RIHE������� !"#$��������� ���%

�&�1972 ' 5 ()�*+)!"#$"��,-./0��12)34���5678)9:

��;<����=>?@"����"ABCD���<E*F��G HI�'J�

KL:M%NO)��PQ�1���RS"����)KTUVW�XG��Y��G

&��Z[%\' 2002')�]^ 30_'�`a:)b���G

c d"ef"')�56g�7" 21hi COEjklmn"o5g�pq)�r��> ���

"jkstuvw21hix����yz{n|}�~2������������>��& 113

����o5& 20 ��"��"�������*F��G d"d������"�1)

�����%YG ���"��"M%�����Y��%�:��  ���"D¡¢�£¤

¥)¦�%���� ��§¨����"©ª%�«¬­�"��)��*F��Gd���d

F�%"O®�¯°"±²³&´µ*FG�%��¶')§G·�¸¹KL�YGº»&¼§F

G�%��O)�½Ud�%�����£¾)�¿À"K*�ÁÂ�:ÃÄ%���� dF�

����&�Å"�Æ�Ç*FG¾ÈÉ+ÊË�Ì�:)b·G¯=�%�ÍÎÏ"ÐÑÒ

Ó��lÔÕ)Öa+F�×Ø�}ÉFGÙÚÒÛÜÒÝÞ"ß�àa����� �G&·��

wáo"â)ã·Gäo�%�:�"åæUçè�%d"9�UCé�ê¨ëì�����)�

dF�íC)*+U:îk�{ïð�ñ"ÝÞ�òó��ôõ"�1)�r��ö"÷ø�Où

�Gr�úû��r:�dü%����

c >jkstuv��ý-)þ���G����:Gì)�5 '�)§G·�����"%

�&���2)� FD�SD"����yz{n"~2���yz{n"~2�����

�� ó�~2��U�",-�M�)�������z"|}���¢"�óU�",-

)K�2)���d��������� *+)�óX�¸�2)¬RS�����ó

X����:d�)9·������"��v��u"�ó)ºì�=� �)9:!"#

�ݻ2)$%�:d�)������ !���!"�&����d"9�U�'% COE

y��(�$%�:d�)rG���G !"f2��ý���� ���" COE jklm

n�D)�����%r:PQ"O®�*+)��ì:d��!"¬RS�"�,)9·�

��v��u"�ó�NO)���:d�)EÉF�r��

c >-.)9·�h)/�!*F:$%#&�¬RS"����¢���9������)

D�"�:ÎÏ"oØ)0KU12�:3¼�45�:d�&%YF6�7S"89%����

�G���v��u"�ö"�1"Gì)�:¢";[É+<�U=Ö>�=?»�ß��

�d�&%Y��G+�d"@Ur¦A%� BC9ü�Ï�DrE�@���

2003' 3(

c c c c c c c c c c c c c c c c c c c c 21hi COEjklmn

c c c c c c c c c c c c c c c c c c c c c c c c ������c �>c �

Page 4: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

����

� � COE ����������� �������������� �������

��������� !"#$%�&'(� 21)* COE+,-. �/0�12�'3

���421)*56789:;<=�>?"#$%�&@(������ ��AB(C

D���EF(GH�CI#I�JK�LMNOBPQR���MS(�T#A$UVW

X���YU(MN���(Z[�MS�\](K�^_`Yabcd��ef(GH

gDL���&h(��(Z"#��ijkJl0��Y�������\]�mn

op(q�AB�rsEZ(q�It(6u�vw�xy[�t(z{"#I����"

%vw|}�9kAB~89(CI#����������vwAB��(CD���

����k(�Uz{"#I������XL(&�(AB����;k[�8�AB

��OEZAB8���7������ef(�����(&�(������[�AB�

����Y8������ ¡¢£¤O�¥¦§¨£ ¡¢£¤�Z©(3I#����

� &ª��421)*56789:�«¬­;<=(Z"#®¯AB:��°]���±

²(³´��µ�¶�·¸(��YI�¹´J���[��º�Jo»¼��tLn¼

��µn¼��tL³´�½��("%¾�`��«�¿³´��YÀ�ÁÂ(Ã'[�­

µ�ÄÅÆ(����������Y³´����Ç]�ÈÉIU3t��JK�/0�

H&'(³´Jm�`[�������Y��e&@( IT ÊËYÌX����(¦

ÍΤ¾�(�gI%ÏÐÑÒ�Î��µ�¶��������"%³´��(CI#Ó�

���ABJIt��f^�Ó����ÔX�;<X��tÕÖ���Y������& 1

×(CI#�Jo�ØÙ�Ús(Û%AB«¬­;<�+,Ü��ABYMNÝÞ��Y�

Z©tLßeàáâ>�ãä"#åæ](K�çè·¸�ãé[��& 2×(CI#AB8

����](;k�Y[�B�(CD��ê�dë[��Y(�T#AB³�¬;<·¸�

ìí[��

&î�(CI#AB���MSYvwjkÆïY"#�AB~89�ðeñ��ò³��

�(ABMS 1990 óô�õ�;ö÷Ê(�T#A$Uø`"%�ùÒ�úûü�¨£ú

ýþ�Í�Ð�MS(�T#�o�ABYMN�Z©A$Uø`"'f�AB��Oa

b�Ù(CI#��`��m`«funding­X��Y�(�f�� �-,��

¤`O³´� �����(�T#opï���J'�Y�"U�T#$%�AB89�Ç]

yíJ0�X��'fAB����Ç]ê��]�À���®[��)������k�

J��L�#I��������"%�Ö�MNOBPQRÝÞ��AB���MSG��

��!#I�����& 3×(CI#AB(CD���"�#2���$5Yfê��

ÓJ>?X�������XL(& 4×(CI#AB����%I}���vwjkY

U(|}���i9k�%�AB~89(3I#ÀÝ"%I�AB;ö÷Ê�õ�AB~�ø

&Yd'ï(CD�B(�¹í·¸�A$�ÈÉ()tX�������o*](+Á[�

Page 5: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

B(�Ç]yíJ12�'3Y���

&,�(CI#�Jo��������k[�AB������(3I#ì-[���

Jo�AB��B.O/�0`(CI#$��#���J1I�����YÀ��#$%�

K�%���k�2K����(�T#34X�#$%���(���56�`åæJ7ã

YX�#I������� ������AB8�ABEZAB8���XL(¦8

�+�Ð����(3I#9�"#$%«���9���­�K"#K�Lv:���

;R](<=_>Æ_?@��� v:AB��� 2Y�eAB������

��CD_O¦û���Ð�_K�(E�"%FGYK�;kHI7(�T#A$U��X

�#I�J��«�������­���"%���YK���]0K(�T#�Jo�A

B8�������kLM(NO�ûÎ�Ð�P"#I�����"B#]Qn�YK�

o*]ABJ#���Y�����«���34��­������ �>Æ_��êY1

2(3I#ìí[�'fRS�v:�ê(3I#TU"%�& 5×��������Y"

#�Jo�v:MS�o*]�VHtLWLt("%�& 6����9����'3Y"

#�Jo�AB8����X� 60 ó��Y�Z["K�ï���JÓ���( ¶"%t

�ìí"%�XL(& 7 ×��Jo���AB 17 \(GH�]eK�EZY"#�X�

����� ¶�^�"%�_\.«¢Ðü��¦8Ð-­EZ(�T#A$U`OJ¹�

L��a�Y�T%�®¯(CD��Jo�AB8�����A�Nb�'3o*`(���

& 8×(CI#�Jo�Sov8�Ye�D�A�cdI�P[�ov8�(GH�e#

Ó����ABúB�úd'(CI#o*`Jf"It�ì-[�YY2(K�jk·¸�

gh"%��Jo�i��a9[���$��#ÕÖ��a�JjL�%�&,����(

& 9×Y"#ÍkÐl�#2Jðeñ��#I���Jo�ÍkÐl�MS��AB;ö÷

ÊYMm]úMS]�0nJA$UO��a�JjL�%�MN�e2opEZO�EZ��

�l�OB�q�r¨£�JMS�ks(A$Utu"#I��Y$��#ÕÖvI�

���&w�(CI#������[�0KY"#�AB����OFG_�>?(G

H�e#�����ø�Ov:MS(�T#8������úûÎ�ÐY¡¢£¤�ìí[

��YU(&10×(CI#xy�^÷z(�T#����YFG_�{3�Ö�|Ö[��

K"#& 11 ×(CI#�Jo�AB8�}R�)ôs�¥¦§¨£ú¡¢£¤�ì-[�

YY2(;ö÷Ê(�T#��CD_��AB�X���¥¦§¨£ú¡¢£¤JÓ���

(ø`"%�t��Iø`"�tT%�t�ìí[��

� ������� ��~��12(3I#��](���]��]�VH�

��](o*H��VH��e���JL�Jo������ �dë"%�xy���

�0�]�g��á���"%2�2��J����� �}R��:�¿�����

���I%JD���I����>Æ_v:(Z"# COE ������ 414AB~8

9(Z"# COE������ 3ÍkÐl�#2(Z"# COE������ 22���

X�%I�o*]�v:(Z"#COE������ 5AB8������(Z"#COE

������ 15���X�%I��%AB~89(Z"#XL(&@���J�X��a

Page 6: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

�����XL( COE +,-. }R������X�%I���L�k�J�Jo�B

�OAB����ô`O;ö÷Ê(��#��S��q����

��Y�T%J��������� ����¼�(Z�T#�U�f�����Y��

���I#I��0� B¡/�BP¢Õ�(��£M]������ô�i���¤¥

ABB¦§¨©hª«H��l��d�ת(���¬­O����®T#I%J$v

U¯°±"�!%I��%���;R]( ![�(e%T#����� ��;k�2

Y�eeÜÐÎ��C²7�³X�IJ�U�´�����f�Y´�8��M. µ8ж

¤�Ò΢Ð8�C. ý�ù�8�(·U¸¹�±"�!%I�XL( COE������

f�Omº»â"#I%JI%f�(¼ó������I%���L�f�����J�D

���³�k��½!��Y¾¿F��T%�³"#¯°±"�!��&����

� �

� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ����� ���l�� � À'ÁÂÃ

Page 7: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

�� � ��

������� ·············································································����� ������

���� 21������ ������������

� 1 � ���������������� ······················· ���� 1�

� 2 � ���� !������ � ······································�� �"� #$���%&�

���� ������ �������

� 3 � �'()�� !���*+,- ····························����.� /0 27

� 4 � ��123����4567� ··································����"� #$ 43

���� ���������������

� 5 � 89:;<=>�4?@ABC� ·······························� ���� 61

� 6 � DE���2FGH�IJ ······································� ���� 73

� 7 � *+��GHK�LMNO:·····································� ���� 109

� 8 � P.���2QGH�RSTUVR42F;VWK�XU�

················� Y� Z[\���� ��%]&�

� 9 � P.�^_`ab()Uc�7dKefU� ················� ���� 149

���� ����������������

� 10 � ��ghijKklmn\opqr� ·······················� ���� ��%s&�

� 11 ��2F�ntuvwq\opqr

·············� xy� z0\���� ��%{s�

Page 8: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

���

21���������� �������

Page 9: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� ����

� 1�� ������� ��������

���� ��∗

� ��������� ������������������21 !"#$%&'(�

)*+�,�-1990./012345�67*845�9�:;23*8<45�,�-

=>�<�*845�2?<@� A<BC@DEF�G��@HIJK,��LM�NO

FG�-

�P�QR@DSOT�=U���VWXYZX[)\]^�:;_`��abcdH

IJe,�-23fghijkl23mno�pfqro�s3o�tu�vwo�xy<zr�

{|}~��X���23����<���G�;��������t��G�T_`��a

bcd*845e,�K�=]^���z�<���K2����:FG����S��e

��@��-

U�����>�67jknowledge-based societyud��e,�-ab�� ¡¢e���

>�67�G������K£���FG�K���eS���>�67¤¥¦§�=��

�¨©ª��NOFG�-��>�67¤¥�«¬­�67®¯¤¥��°y67�±y

67,�G�²³67�G�;¤¥e,��-°y67>´<µ¶�·¸e,¹�±y67

=��º��:F»¼�½¾¿e,�-���«:F��>�67>´<µ¶�º��:F

���¶gÀÁ���Ke��e,��-ÂM�z��G���EO�Ã�ÄÁ�Å:G*8

45�­�TÆM�ÇÈ:;��EO�GÉ@�*845�G�ÊËe«g­���KÌÍe,

�-

�D�UÎ�vwo���>�67o�Ï�FÐÑ<eÒÓ<�HIJ�I@�FG����

AÔÕËÖ�:F×����-�Kk 18 ØnÙÚÛ\]^�:;23ÜÝËÖK��

�Þß��FG�K�>�<�� AÒÓ<9à�á��âã�ËÖ�:Fäå���æ�e

,�-:;K�F�çè�k#$%&aé��Æê­�����‘Glonacal’�S�ë;��ì

íîïeðñ����,�-

� Ëò#$%&ó@�;9à���:;��ô��®¯<��Kõö:Fó¹�=2��

®÷:;9àøe2345Kè�:FG��E�æ�e,��-�P�:F���:;��>

�67�G�67®¯<�]^\ùú:�KD�xy<zrû�{|üýþ������X[)

û�vwû\��O�KD���673jsociology of knowledgeu��3673jsociology of

scienceu�D������jgoverning knowledgeu�m\�­�-�Kk���m

�Ï�23*845 ���GF��íîï\��:��Kk 21 !"#$%&'(�

)�§�<�*+ �\ð�:Fï;G-

���������� 37� ��������� 21��������� !"�#$%&2006'�()

������*+,-./01�2-182�3456789∗

()������*+,-./01��:�

Page 10: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� ����

� =��y���:F��Ëò*84501�óÁ�23�=%& �î��*+��

67®¯�:F��>�67\�¹Ù�:F�ab�23��óÏ�vw�G@��67<

�\�¹�����Ï�F2345�§����@����eúû\� <�ðñ­��©

!��B.�Z��23�"�#ùíîï��ë;�67®¯�:F��>�67\45¯�

�­�$¹%ïúû\&�­�-=��Ï�F���>�67�óÁ��Kk23fghi

'(@D)*­��+, �-./ý[)\01­�úû<íîï\2�:;G-=��í

îï\Õ:F��Kk��kl23�pl23,�G�sl23�*+�+,j45u �

3�<45\67<�B8@D�1­�úû<��\9:2;:�=�D§�< �ÌÍ

J\<=­�-

���������� ������

� LM�>?23#$%& ���@~��U 29 A �BC7_23�*+cj2001

. 11 Du�óGF�_23î�Eú\t��*+­�@c\ûF;K�=øe���e

GHúûIA\ÃJ:; 1)-;�OT�J. Y~Kü.�þ�_39øLMcjcenter of

learningu����Kk#$%& �/Ê<�NZ-.)���:FOP:; 2)-:@:�

���e�Ëòè�:FG�23 Aá��âãoËÖ��1:���G-QR�Ï�T�

39øLM�� S�17 !.TX(�18 !UV@DWZ~(�19 !øX@D�

.Y�D� 20 !U�Z2[01��{¸X|\]kd��¯:;-��D�¯]^�

��k3^\_O�ë;�67'(�)*+Kç�:�=�`�:F39øLM��¯

:;-

��ea�­æ�U�8��3^\_O�67<bcK�.Y01��*±>��:F2

3'(�)d8o��;���,�-19 !01���e8�óGF23�/���<rf

gQ�nhij*+��FG�G-�.Y�WZ~(�te2k<� �l*mK&���;K

23���F/��gQ�:F,n:FG�G-

U��� 20 !{¸X|\]k01�Z/\o�æ�39øLMKHò:�G-{¸X

|\]k#$%&'(�)�óGF�npq@DEF� A��@�;�r"'(�)Kst

:Fó¹�39øLM��¯:�G���{¸X|\]k#$%&'(�)K Auüã�

:Fvw:F�FG�-�k#$%&'(�)45�óGFá��âão:; A>xuü

ãKy\z@{�������-Y~=ü.�þ�úûe��ë;�23*+�|}:F39

øLM��¯­��G���K���~�\���-á��âã�#$%&'(�)K�k

�óGF*+��;��s­�T�39øLM�ë;�NZ-.)\��:;çèk�8�

23���­�ÌÍJK#G@�:��G-

� �;�M.��}23�&�������23gQ�#$%&'(�)¦�&��>�

<�v�íîï�:F2����ÁF�; 3)-���3� �M;��Ï�F�����E�

�;��S��FG�-:@:�KD�ab�z�<�vw9:�óÏ���>�6701

Page 11: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� ����

�*845øe&�����,�Ëò A<�2345���23�&���e��´

�1:���G�����FG�-=E����Q23è3�\>x�:;�����,

�-��Ï����&��>x����23è3��=#$%&'(�)e,�-23

è3��#$%&'(�)�G�23¦~67Ã���GF��o:FG����@D�¦

~<e@�X�{����\�y���:FG��SO�-:;K�F����þN�óÁ�2

3�&�����â��ão��@D��â��ã�{�@(d�./����K�ïD�

F�;K�*845!/�óÁ�è3�\�OFá��âã�è�­� A2345\�1e

��G-Ëò� A23*845�è3�#����@@�D��©FÏ��HIJ�I

@�Fè�:FG�-23*845��23gQè3�0  ~®¡K¢£:FG��E�

æ�e,��-

¤{�{�k#$%&�&\�¥:F��øk�&�¦X��@D�(dÚ§��&\

E{FG�K�����óGF�3�0j�*845è¨KÑG� ©­�n�ª���G-

©ª�«k#$%&�&�­��F��*845Â��3�Ϲè3�K�@�;K�*8

45��óGF�3�è3�\��@�¬­:;-3 |kÔÕËÖ��è3�®Yã��

\�OFá��âã�*845Kè�:FG����,�-����¯Â��}��e��

1K�@�G-=������ ~<��¹Ù�G��}��e��3���23a�<

¿3�fghi'(@D)*­�45-./ý[)(G\01­����°±e,��G�

²8\¦³:FG�-

� �8�*845��óGF>�<íîï�:FÏ�������B. �Z��úûe,�

4)-�Z�����Ï�T�23�"�#ùíîï��ab�vw�23gQÎM��G:

�´µ¶�Ï�âW·�gQ�Ï�Fks���-Q�k¶�k�¸¹\º»:FG�K���

�þN#$%& �Me,� D. ¼Z}~jBraunu�F. ¸X¦jMerrienu�I. �þ�V.

jMcNayu�H. ½{�jBoeru$���Z��úû\¾¿��k¶¦#$%&'(�)®

À\Á¹Â�FG�-�;{¸X|\]k D. ü�ãjDilluD�23�abQR\Â�F

G�����:;�Z��úûíîïK>´���Fó¹��Kk#$%& �M6�

K�íîïøe �\&��{FG� 5)-�úû��23î�*8k�¸¹\ÌÍ�

�D:���H�23®¯��\\�ab�vw�23gQ�G�#$%&\Á¹Ã����

�B8@Dúûo\�ï�-��:; 3@�����íîï��¹�Áab�vwQR�Q

­�ûÄ�23*845\0Å­�je�ÆÇv�<��íîï\2�:F�;���4�

FÃJ����e��@�� 6)-:@:����íîï�óGF��;�OTab�23�

e®¯�"�#ù ��a�<QR�óGFe,�F�Ëò*845Ï���`��ab

�:Fz�<�®¯���>�67d*8<®¯��Z���Ï�F�È<�º���FG

�@�;�LM� ©­�-�G���ÂMab�23QR�óGFøÉCÊ�MH�Ê

,�G�67Ë67��ÌË67�Z�~{¸X|67�th"<�0Å��ïD���

�ÍÎ�Ïa<�Ð:�@�2��ab@D`��abd*845<������tSw

��FG�Ge,�-=úû<ÑÒ�y�:F 1990 ./01� ���23xy<

Page 12: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� ����

zr\øÓ�:; ��4o:FÔ� 7)-23ÏÕ6ªo�G�23z�<®5��� 1980

./23�abQRû�óGF1D@�²�:;�\ÑÖ­��ye,�;�×O�-Ø

H�ÆM��>�67d®¯�_���®¯cU 6Ù 5ReÁ¹Â�FG�K�=�eQ

Ús:;d8<Ð:��23¦��9:�Is<���û��t��Fó¹�2��67<

�Û¹�:F��>�67�ms��FG�G-=��QúûK#$%&'(�)¦�Ü

��FG�@D�Ø�D�G-jê`��ab�}�23Ïa<®5�{Ï���>�67

�}�23û�{Ï���:;67®¯<�¹Ù��íîï��ms��F��@�;e,

�-

� 0jûÄ\��O�Ëò23*845HIJ�úû<Ð:\ðñ­����=d8<

Ð:�G��@NOD��-=øe������U���21 !23�óÁ�ab�2

3QR�Q­�ûÄ��t�ÝtÞ����23�ß�Ï�Fàá���æ�@��G�

>�<Ð:K���Fõ�e,���Kú0���-=��©!� 21 !23�óGF%&

�âã\äÁ��ß@j%&«ÖM�%&å� �æçu�G�Ð:��èé:���

FG�-21 !øê���23%&�*ë��;�kq%&�:Fß�K{�@(e��v�<

®Yã��e¶gÀÁD���'(�G-21 !ìí<�23�ø$Æ%&è3�îs�

���Ä°±e,�K�Ëòø$%&��� 90%®Yã��ev�o���ÌÍJ�ïq<

��ðs:���G- �gQ�23��ñ67�xy� �l�Mò$�'óôõ\Õ:F

23K�<øÓ@����:F�xy�Mò�67\�<��3ö^<�X��­�øÓ<æç

\G�=�o�!/K�í­�ÌÍJ�#G-

� =��Q÷:FU�9:��°y67�±y67=:F��>�67�G�2��67®¯

�,�F����23KtÏ��67<øù�Ï�F�R��FG�@�G�673<Ð:

e,�-��>�67�óGF��º��:F�3ö^<���úM�»¼�/��z�>

�<*8\ûü­�-=�ÄÁ��Ëò2345Kýþ<�k¶z�ÒÓª'\�­���

��=��\9���ý����FG�-*845¾� 23Z~�~á�0ÂÏ��

ä�*���<�=�e�������k�<�23Z~�~á�á��âãvw�óÁ��

�z�<�·~��(�øeë;�.~�X�'~\��:FG� 8)-

� 1990./Æ�01���:;��@D#$%&HIJ�:F�vwo���67�Q÷

J@D_{|üýþ������X[)cjAcademic Capitalismuû��,�G�_·á���

¼�����X[)cjCognitive CapitalismuûK&��� �FG� 9)-;�OT�S. (��

��jSlaughteru& L. ®(X�jLeslieu� S. (����& G. ��ü(jRhoadesu��Â

M/Ê���e,��-��D�G���z��vwå8@D��>�67�óÁ�xy

<zr�l�;23�\*+:;�e,�-���«:F�I. ¼®.�X�jBleiklieu& M.

�~ãjHenkelu$����#$%& �M�¿¾e����y>Gå8@D23�

\<=­�K�ÆM R. �(�.|�jHostakeru& A. â¼jVabu$K&�:;_·á���

¼�����X[)cjCognitive Capitalismuû�=��e,� 10)-QD���\���y

>Gå8@D23���QR\��­�8�óGF���F�N����e,�-

Page 13: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� ����

� ��:;lw@Dy>�23\*+­�;������Q­��3K�����Ä��-#$

%&'(�)���z�3@D{����T@¹e�����î�û���a�3�D��j

ê:;Ï�����673��3673å8@D�­�ý�K,� 11)-��>�67���

z�<��e,��3ö^ï�#������,�K���*+�}� 21 !23�

*+�ºË�G-

������������������ !"#$%&'()*+�

� jê:;Ï����Z����23�"�#ù@����:Fab�vw�gQj23uÎ

M\ms:Fó¹�=��´µ¶@����"�#ù\ÐO�-��>�6723û\&�

­�w\��=�:;67®¯<��\��Díîï�tÏ��¶gÀÁ�æ�@�G�ú

û<Ð:K,�-����GF�Æe ê­����:;G-�

� =Â����� 3@���j�G:� 4@���uíîïøe�2345�"�#

ù �\!":ðñ­���Ký�e,��-�Z���=�"�#ù �\23_®¯c

�_�\cB8@DûF�K���"�#ù�a�<�z�< �\}�Fó¹�@�ö#

e,�-jê:;Ï���Z���k�¸¹íîï\2�:;K��úû�k¦®À �

������KkÏ��kl�pl�sl�pfqr$6ª�fghi�ö#�«abQR

�,�4$J\��O�T��úû��D��&�{���KÌÍe,�-�`û$¹%ï

úû���:;�Kk]^\��OF��e,�-G���{Ï��Kk#$%&'(�

)�óGF�@���¦�@����ea�<Ê¿�Ï�%Á&�KG�=��"�#ù\Ç

È�{FG�-©F@���¦�;�OTab@���e�����·�"Kö#o:FG�-

���øÉab«MHab�'e� ‘Glocal’jGlobal+Localu@D�D� ‘Glonacal’

jGlobal+National+Localu,�G�‘Nalocal’jNational+Localu�G��ìK£�����k

e39<��íîï�aé<B8�:F&���FG� 12)-�������eS��·���(

)�#ùK�~�:F*���-

� +�<��Kk\��Á�FïÏ�-�Ù�U�@���ab�S�F��lmbk7

¾e��ab¦,�b~�3(�Ø()�øÉab�MHab�¿QR�t�6ª�Ê¿�

-.KHò­�-b~�3(��:F� /Ä7¡¢�0D:F�� aéo\ðñ­�-

ab�()#ù\zFk7elmo:�=m1\23:FÍÎoK4����=�5�

23gQ�¢£\6O�-=�Kab�"�#ù7@DE;2345e,�-��:;�"�

#ù ����Kkw\����FÇÈ:@�ö#e,�-= �� M. }��â�-.

úûK˧\Ϲ�1­�@�:��G 13)-;�OT�b~�3(�«:F�ô8'9j23�

ab4�~=�5:B7�ÏÕ($u��k";<�G�á��âão2Ë=�\>?@�

:F��"\ÐO�-b~�3(�b~�3(eab4�~�23�«:F�;<aé�AB

:�KD�ë;�ÍÎ�����'(�)�*+\Õ:F�ô8'9�«­��DC¶J

D�\ÛDG�ë;�íîï�óGF��DÊ¿àá��&\<=­�-

Page 14: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� ����

� ØH�23�abj�()�MH���\*Eu�b~�3(F?aéG��©#�]G

�q¯�G�{~�â®~��Lú<ª'\�:�KD��39�Ì=��\>?@�23

45j;�OTmnou�G�ë;�íîïj45uøe«ab�«67�G�ô8'9�

�\H�Iú�J¨��KéjJ�u­�-����Kke�[Âkl�pljLl�vlu�

slMç¹�ae���QR�óGFklMH����pl23øÉabQR�NG-

:@:'e�pfqr�î\�xy�t A��\E�Gfghi6ªo�Æ��[Â�

.Yuüã�O�:;PQ23�[Æ{¸X|uüã�:Fë"23�R<Æ��ÛF�

;ã��K#$%&A�óÁ�FpM�ô8 �\Ϲö#�:FG� 14)-SÆ�TU"Kð

ñ������:;ab����·#ù�ÇÈ­�;���Kk�ë;�� Nalocalaé�

GlonacalaéK�������Ä��-

� ��:;ë;��abjøÉ�MH�b~�3(�VÕ(óÏ�Ø()�Ï�Fý�:��W

Xe��Gu�����G�=\Y¹;�"�o�vwo�G�'Z[­�íîïøe�2

37�39�Ì\�\­�23��\]^�úû<]B:�KD'9�ô8­�-ab�"

KN��vw�"�G�k"67�óGF��39û�23û�O�:Fab�ô8:;¹�

w\�Ï�F�_`�Gû�ab�te«c­�w\�,��-:@:��KkÏ���ab

�"K���F�G67�«c­����2��de\Èf:�GI¹Àge��G-

� :@����"@���#ù �K­æF©FÏ��¢£¿\�23�6O����´NO

D��G- �V\23�ö\23�µ�23�h."23�i�23�kl23�pl23�

sl23�pfqr23� �23�´µ23�%j23�©Fsl23e��[Â�ë"ùk

��#�,l��m"��*845�sl23�,�G�ëf��;sl23�i2@Dh2

��+,��;sl23�Ï�F��"@���¢£¿�n�e,�-��>�67�óGF

39�K23�+,�*+�tÏ��¢£­�@�ÇÈ:;��K]^�,���\��O

�Á�T�D�Ge,��-

� G���{Ï���:;23@����"�#ùíîï��ab�{Ï�23gQ�{Ï�

�"�#ù­�;�ã���Hm� �\á�FG����,�-���ab�23�����

ºopsgQ\¦ò<�"�o:Fó¹�Ä@D�=�@�����@���¦e-.K*F

�-���«:Fvw�ïB�Ðq"\�\­�T­��t��Ð;�ºopsgQ�

"�\+�<�he�lI:�G-z�<�>�,l,ð�673<�SqeSGrO�T�

vw<ÒÓøe67<ÜÝ�stK�����23Hl>�,ðKzr<�ÏÕ<�å

8@Dps��������-�ñ��uvvwe,ð�_vw���vw�wÁc�S�

��Ï���q<�vwe�vwdx$�>x\fs­����Ï�F�Ä�e��ÐKÌ

Íe�,B�x$�g7���~(K�����ý�K,�-23�23fg>xj{�®ü�

��'~u\�X{­�T23gQvw�x$��Ðe��K�=,ð�vw�Ï�Fp

s���-

� �Z��K@����23#ù ��óGF_®¯c��¹�Á_�\c\������

:;����#$%&'(�)ï�*8gÍ<�yz\Â2�:;23ûe,���\��:

Page 15: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� ���

FG�-;�OTab��¡¢�taé�:;K�F�"�#ù;��÷m"o�ÍÎ

oa�< �\Õ:F23gQ\�"�#ù:�45­�-vw@����vw �\Õ:F

zr,ð\ûü­�-�D�23gQ�23���O�:;ºops �\Õ:F�D\#ù

­�-

� e��jê:;�ûd8e,���67�G�45������:;�Z��õ 3@�

��jab�vw�23gQu�"óÏ�#ù�tÏ��QR\�¹��e,��@-�

Kkª{#|67�}� 18 ØnÙÚÛ�2345¯��:F�G¢£\w¨­67®¯

��e,�-©ª����>�67�í� 21 !23��*+�+,�2��¢£\w

¨­����(G�G-;Ä���D67®¯�}������=���ºops��"�

#ù ��gÍ\lI­��e�,¹O��23�*+��+,~��:F��­�-a

b�23óÏ�vw����:;67®¯d«¬\îï%E���Ï�F�=�5��"�

#ù �\��­�-:;K�F���D67®¯\_��>�67c�:F�"�#ù@�

���:F¶gÀÁ�����ÌÍe�,�:���e�,�-��>�67�@�����2

3�ab�«:F�"�#ùgÍ\á;�Ge,�-:;K�F�_��c�_67c�_a

bc�_23c\©��¶gÀÁ������"@���e,�_abc�_23c���"�

#ùgÍ\I:�G67®¯\©�eûF�����¹��"@���ºops ��=��

¢£<���­�67®¯�'(�'óQR�D�¶gÀÁ\��-:@��67®¯�«

­��@����"�#ùk¶<'(��Kkfghi�Ï��"�#ù �'(\¸

¹­���K�ÌÍ���-jê:;Ï���_ab��¡¢�taé�:;K�F�"�#

ù;��÷m"o�ÍÎoa�< �\Õ:F23gQ\�":�KD�45\�è­

�cw\_¡¢�taé�:;K�Fc\_67®¯�:F��>�67c�/�e��-

­���_ab��67®¯�:F��>�67d«¬aé�:;K�F�"�#ù;�

�÷m"o�ÍÎoa�< �\Õ:F23gQ\�":�KD�45\�è­�c��

���-

� ��:;_67®¯�:F��>�67c���"@���e,�_abcT@¹@�_2

3gQc�_vwc@����óGF��©ª�¶gÀÁD��-­���_67®¯�:F

��>�67c�ÎM@����«:F�©ª�¢£���Ù�:F��­�e,�-

,���-./0123��45����$6789���:;�

� 0jðñ@D�Ëò23*845�óÁ�%& �î��*+��67®¯�:F�

�>�67�¹Ù@D23�"45z���<��íîï\Ús­����Ï�F���

�e�Kk��>�67d�¬­�2345\«Ö��=Ã�\¡�o­����Ï�F

ð�­���KÌÍe,�-�Ï��9���Ï�F���e��>�67d�23Á

¹îïH\1D@�­������{~���º���\Õ:F��*+�}�23®À

�-./ý[)\01­�ÌÍJ\��-��:;�÷��úûo�§�< �\ÕFF�

����b~�3( 21 ! COE ��áZ)����e,�_21 !"#$%&'(�

Page 16: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� ���

)*+��<��cøÓ�����Kt��eÌÍe,��@-�

� 'U���;�9���:F��Kkfghi@DE;67®¯�:F��>�67

¢£�Ï��"�#ùã���fghi�Ï�F'(­��y��\lFF§�­���KÌ

Íe,��-;�OT�2004.�0Âkl23!/����>�67d45�����a

bjb~�3(u/Ä7¡¢�x�:;45jm"ou���D�ÍÎo��;aé��"�

�F2345K����ÌÍJ�\G��Ëòkl23mn=��¸¹:F#Ge,��

15)-���kl23!/��vw@D#ù�Ï�F23gQ�DK��>�67d«¬;

��45\îè­��\G��@�;�î�e��K�mno�Ï�F��>�67dvw<

«¬\abjb~�3(u�"�Ï�e���gQ�De��­��\G��Ì��Ê��

2:;���o���Ä��-�����jê:;Ï���abøe��()��óGFG�

G��a�<¿3K��:�ab�GOt��WXe����aé�����-���«:Fs

l23�ab@D���"�Ï�F#ù����\G�kljmnu23Ϲ�6��GK�

vw@D��<�¢£\Õ:F#ù����\GKϹ2�G-=��©!�23gQ��

��>�67@D¢£���«­�ºops�Ì��kljmnu23Ϲsl23HK

��@�#GÄ��-:@����>�67d«¬�abzÌ45Ϲvw«¬45H

K��@���e,��-�D�!��<�E;w\�kl23mn�kl23!/Ϲ��2

3gQ�� ©�ºops�Ï�F��>�67d#ù�\GK6G�©!��vw�®

(�~(:F��®5­�ÌÍJ�#GÄ��-=ø��,�F�pl23�pfqr23�

ϹÇÈ:;ö#��" �K*F�-ÂMpl23��ab@�������Gabjb~

�3(u�GabjMH���u��õ�"�#ù �K*F�-��K�G�Ô�jê

:;‘Nalocal’�#ù �e,�-3�pl23�Ïa<��Gab��m<���Gab

�"\äÁ�­GÄ��-ØH�ÆMfghie�pl23�:F�Gab�Gab�

"��sl23�:Fvw<�¢£\���<�äÁ�-

� �D��23>�<�gÍe,�%& ��Q:F��%&� �e�fghi'(�Ï�

F��"ã���}�.�ÀÁ����-kl23�sl23�¸¹:F ��IK#���

2�ÍÎ��\Õ:Fab�"\äÁ�­G-���«:Fsl23�3*d{|}~�

�X��@D%&� ¡�IK�G;��vw��[\-.®���G¢:;23�|X�£

Z)45K4����­G-pl23�óGF�MH���eàá���;�Mòxy�Mò

¤qº�\G¢:;�"�\G�#����-

� 0j�67<®¯�:F��>�67��j67<¥¿u\=�5� 3@���d¢£

��:F$¹%E���Ï�F��Kkfghi'(�Ï���>�67d23�+,

��*+!���¢£¿$\§�e����<��íîïK2����T\����Ke��-

���íîï��EN(0�z����h¦:FG�K���<�������®¡�!

��K'«<�¶gÀÁD�����,��-��:;�Kk#$%&�óÁ������K

k�§23,¹l��fghi@DÌí:Fó¹������Ï�%&� ��67���

(w�¨úJrò¹H�23gQg@�;���¬FFn�e,�j» 1\�0��;Gu-

Page 17: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� ����

< �� 0123��= !���>?@ABCDEFG<�

���� ������ ������������������� !"#��

$%&�'()*+'�,�-./0�12�345�6)789��� !����$%*:.;��� <������=>�?@AB��CDEFG;)�3�

� .TX(e� A<�B8@Dï�T���øÉCÊ<e�abÃ�¿��G�.����

K��KkϹ��@�´µ¶�Ï�âþW·�gQ�©§:FG� 16)-23�ab��,�

F�âþW·�gQK23��� �ª���óGFõ��gÍ\`;:FG�-234

5��:F�ø�«âþW·�gQK#ùgQ���FG���Kª���G�S��FG�-�

�Kkw\�øÉCÊ<�ab@D��<��gQd¾�@Á��\G�kl23w\��

@�#G-�H�{¸X|\]k�óGF�Ï�S������MH�Ê"Kè�:FG�-

;<=>

?@AB

CDEFG��

CDH��

CIH��

CJH��

CJHKL��

CIH�3

CDEFG��

MN=>

?@AB

CJHKL��

CDH��

CJH��

;<=>

�����

C�����

����

C�� ��

�����

?@=>������

Page 18: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� �����

÷¬abK23\øÉCÊ<�·~���ã­��\G��Kkw\�¸¹:F��@��G-

� G���{Ï�Ëòk�²­\E����çè�k2345�á��âão\]^�{¸

X|<�vwoKt§�è�:��,�-�k®i<�bo<�'(K,��{Ï�ab�

@DvwË���­����F�235ë�ab@D23gQ9e§¯����\G�#

���-=�`�vwÒÓ�§o:�RgQK45\X��­�-D. X�(�~�=�\°

�"�èjsnake-like processionu�±=:;-{¸X|Ï��Öï�vwEúe2345

��23@D#$%&Aï��²w­�-X�(�~�°~¶�³OF�2345�ô:F

�è­��õ23jÂ`u�øõ23�Îõ23jÆ`u¯�\Ep�ÊË:;-=�`�

23�ab�76�t"�<gQ�¦F��ï�D��23'ó�K<´:\����Ï�

F©Fhi\,DÔ�23Ká�Ï����jIsomorphism ��u��Q�µ­� 17)-Ëò

��>�67�óGF��.)Zá�`��!�<����FÑGA¶e=©�oËÖ�î

�­�ÌÍJK,�-G���:F�õ������ab�"@Dvw�"d'W������

�F23*845,`��`��Kvw�óÁ�����D����G���e,��-6ª

�®¡�bcøevw�����e��gQK©FÏ����>�67d45\�ï;�

:F����`�p:F©�e�,¹·��gQ�Ï�F��G«���,¹·�-�

H�����������IJK�L�:M$��0123N>?@ANOPQR�

� �

� ��>�67\*,­�����ª¸��GF��ùú:Fó�ý�K,�Ä��-���

���Q:F�¹�h¸�¦À��he��-ÂM�Q:F�²³o67�í\_OFG� IT

67\ðñ­�TÀg�ú0���-²³¹���K{/�á@Dü��ãd®5����,�-

ü��ã����e{/�á�'(:F 2èm Ae,�-·~�£���W~�WWî

ï\�{�Ï�F­æFK&����-²³67&�\_O��� 2èm Ae,�-

���Ï�F���º{o��¶»o�¼½o�¢�oKÌÍ���-Ä@D�=���:; IT

5±���\¹¾�­�23%&Hm�hi���ò¹H\2��®5­������-�

� �H�ÆM��¦À�Q­��3<ª¸����3673eûÄ��;h¸�«¿À��

3H�«§���MÁT½~[Du��«u��Ã�ü�'�X~«�Z~(ü�'�X~«

.~��ü�'�X~�23û�Q÷:FûÄ���23�«67��3�«%&��%j�«

´µ�« ���t�t�6ª���h"ûK,� 18)-,�G� EÁ½.Ä�K&�:;Ï���

��\�Å�gÍ�:Fe8�¬���\�%&K�h��; 19)-u��ê¸���¬�

o�9:0p��ã��ü�'�X~o��D��xyobc�'W��{���*±H¸

��Q÷­�-��:;��hi®À�ò¹HK2345�G@��QR\�¹��@�=

V�K��>�67�óÁ� 21 "!23�,¹l�\h,­������-0¾e����

>�67d���}�23�j�u*+�=§� �ÌÍJ��GFjê:;��\�

�:���+�<� �Ð:��GF!":FïÏ�-�

Page 19: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� �����

����������� ���

� ��>�67K UI�=}�tÏ��®o:FG�@�=��\Ê­�S���K�23=

�Mò=�fgmn=\*�Äu��Â"@D¬��3ö^"�çÆ�3"�u��ÃdG��

@23�®��FG�;Ä��-23fghi�h"jV\�ö\�µ�$� RÇ|�V

T��hÈu�t\�¹Ù�:F�ab�"�vw�"��R23=}�tÏ��QR\�

¹��@Éëf23�GH23�h2o23�tðñe��-©ª��3~=}�tÏ�

�®o:;@Éëf3~�GH3~�h2o:;3~=}�Ê�­�ý�K,��-3¶=}

®o��GF�G��@ç� �K,¹���>�67ûú��RZË\*ï�KD&

���F�;Ï�ÄK�3¶=}�«­�fghi�ab�"�vw�"¢£¿IÌ�Q­

�ð��Í",� ����e,� 20)-ab�"�Ï�F3¶�ÌoK 1991.�§¯��;

��e� 29 h�94. 250 h�97. 348 h�2000. 444 h�2004. 554 h�e�

2:FG�KtÏ��ûúe RoK���FG�e,��@-� �

���������������������������

� h2oËÖ�pl23�¹�Ásl23fghie���t����Fó¹�kl23��

��t�G-kli2� 4."23�ÎÏ���he�\��;-1996.��� 598Ð,�;

i2K 2003.��� 525Ðe���� 125Ði2Kh2o:; 21)-���� 125Ðh

2o��GF�=�<!��<�äåjï�u�23�3~�3�j´au\Ñå<�äå:

Fó�ý�K,��-���vw�"�ÒÓ�sl23h2o���>�67�,�F�ÔG

H3��+,�C��.��HIJï���Õn<*,�|X�£Z)�%&Hm�Ö

û�µ¶×�$jp�u\tÏ��ØÙ4Ú:FG�@��D�Ûvw#ù�Ï�sl23

4î,ð\ä���sB©Ò�� ¡�$!����e�¹�45vw��\1D@�

­�ý�K,��-�

���� !"��#$��%&'(�

� �jê:;Ï�����>�67�h¸�¦À<�B8@D�­���Ke��-(1)�(2)

�����GF���¦À�Q��;Ð:e,�-²³ö^5±�¦À�h¸ÜH�Q��

e�%&Ð��%&Hm�Öyûb�3ݪ¸�õ��.~N��\6O�-kl23jm

nu�ab�"K���¤Î�Þ9��\ý��­�-:@�=¤Î�Þ¢�K£ß��

�@t�@�ô8�`�Ï�Fûü���-¤Î�Þ��'�e� 2.�2k<���¡.

0j��\�­�-sl23�ÍÎqe"à�,��45dg¯J�C�FG�-:

@� 18ØnÙÚÛ�sl23ÜÝ�2��¢£\w¨­e�N`23\6�áO�s3

*�â¹aé� �Ϲ�%&�4o:FØ23�ç�:FÁ¹îEãIK,��-����

vw#ùKØ@����¸¹:FgÍ­��'(�G-�

Page 20: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� �����

�)�*+,-./012���1234�

� �Kk ���kl23mnä�<23�slV\23\øL�îè��F�FG�K�

��:; �23� �l� �@~�� �gÍ���+,�QR�Q­�#å\î��

np�zr$®Yãe§�o­�ý�K,�-æD�%&45ã���«0<��"�#ù

K�����'(�G-fghi�Ï�@����"�#ù�%&� ��e����e,��-

p�<��¤ç23çÆ�3ö^ �@~���¤è23éêë� �l$ì9#å�§�<

�Ký�e,��- ��ab�"�#ù¢£\��äÁ�-���>í ��¬� ��

�� �6ª<�[îKfghi��"hi�G@��QR\�¹��@��­�ý�K,

��-�

� �

�5�%6*�78*�9:*���;�<�=>?�

� ���Q:F¦À<�%j��´µ��e8���he�����­e�Sw:;-���´

µ��23QR����e3ïÐ�®Yãe§¯��F�;-2000./01�m��zr�ð

3�%¡�t´µ¡23ñB8e23*mK&���F�FG�-Ôëf23ñ�<!

��<�äåjï�u�Õ+,�C��.��HIJ\��jï�u�Ûn<*,�|X�£

Z)jp�u��t�Q:Fjêíîïe��­���Ke��-�

�@�ABC�D>�EFD GH�#�I<�=>?J���KLMN�

� ��>�67á�23d��.~�X�'~���3ö^<���z��QRe

,�-�3ö^K¯í»¼<�º��/��Fòó<�*±J\#��º�<�æç\`;­-

23�3����23�67QR�G�Ô�36÷ôQR\2��®h­�-�3ö^õ

8õò�ab�z�A[î���Q÷­�- �ºéõ�� TLOÏ��23î��23%

öæç�tK2��®o­�Ä��-�

��

�O���%PQRS��34STU��D>�VWXYDZ[��12�

23%övw �Ë��ò¹H��GF�LM÷:;������e,�>?23#

$%& ���@~��COE �'X�[ 15ø3�23%Bvw�Nù S�Ëò�úí

ùûj2005.u\�0��;G 22)-��e��>�67�¹Ù@D���CÍ",���

��:F��Ôpübý���Ï�X�ã��þH�çÆõòpüõò�tK��ÌÍe

,�-ÕçÆõòî��óÁ�X�ã��+�<����Ûh2osl23�*+þH�

�����>�67B8@DGHj¦~unë��gjoF��u�ëj ~uX�ã��

�t�tÏ�������@Í"����G-�

� �

�\��/���./�]^_�

� ��>�67�óGF�����+,K37¯I�6ª�¢£\6O�-���+,�

}�F37�+,Kè�­�e,��-��u��ÃKè�­��­�T�=��¦À�

Page 21: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� �����

¬F;37K�,��������-;�OT�%&�CeSOT�{t�\���ã�ú0:

Ï��­������¬FF�3�{t�37cK�,����©!��ØHe23î�ø�

_{t�3~cK*+��������-3�3^7Ä3^��j37u¯I\!��<�

��673<���­����Ï�F���D§�KÌÍ����-�H���67è�­

����F�23�%Bd ����aé<���<��KõB���ãI�ð��G-v

wo�Ï�F��ÒÓJKÅ:���Tî��=67<�«cÚg\Fþ£�­�-�»��

H¸@Dvwod��:;�Kk#$%&'(�)�tÏ��vwod"�o\è�FG

���:FG�@§�­�ý�K,�-=Hmû���:F�;�OT3�#$%&3

*,B���3�23ýþ'~J\��­��'���Ce,�-�Kk#$%&4

5K設��¸�:F��23*845�SÆ 21 !23�j�u*+�tÏ���

­eP�eG�@�î��nëq@D�­���KÌÍe,�-���eÏC:FG�3�#

$%&3737B=j1997�2000�2002�2004.�=u�ÆÇë�\2:F���

�'(�G-�

� 0j�_��67�óÁ�#$%&'(�)*+c��GF��<�úû&���GF¤

ê:;-&�:;$¹%ïúû\��:;��úû�§��G�G��§� ��Ï�Fð��

��ý�K,��-�;�=ð��`�Ï�F�D�$¹%ïúû\��o­�ý�K,�-

��e&�:;$¹%ïúû��íîï�,��e���e,�F6�²8\áOFG�-

�Kk#$%&�Ëò�@�F�@�;�t*845��,�F23>�=�KM

�®¯:F�FG�-23,¹l��þîï��"ò¹H��K5ë­�-=��@(K

���e, :;±y67@Dë;���>�67�G�&�øe�2�§�K���FG

�e,�-�Ï��!/#$%& ��óGF��;ë;�B8@D��íîï\ý�

�­�-

STU5VWXYZ�

1)� �C���j2002u_23î�Eú\t��*+­�@ù= Sh�úíhùcø23

î��*+� U 29 Aj2001 .�u �BC7¼½û#$%& ��ý 71 ��>?2

3#$%& ���@~���25-30�-

2)� J. Y~=ü.�þ�j1974uj��3���C�Ù�uø�3673û���-

J. Y~=ü.�þ�j1982uj����uø39b�E��:F !��23û�.

�ã"#7-

3)� M. ��}j1976uj�C�Ù�$6%<&�uø#3®6723�¦X��@D�(dû

¤ç23"#7-

4)� B. �Z��j1994ujI�Ù�uø#$%&'(�)�23î�¸¹673û¤'�-

5) � Braun, D. & Merrien, F.-X. j 1999uTowards a New Model of Governance for

Page 22: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� �����

Universities ?: A Comparative View, Jessica Kingsley.

6)� �Kk#$%& �Møe���:;ab�vwQR\����úû<�Ê�:F�

; �M/Ê�é{Ë(j¤ç23ue,��-

7)� B. �Z��'y)��GF��0¾\�0��;G-

� � - Clark, B. R. (1998) Creating Entrepreneurial Universities: Organizational Pathways of

Transformation, IAU Press Pergamon.

� � - Clark, B. R (2000) ‘Collegial Entrepreneurism in Proactive Universities: Lesson from

Europe’, Change, 2, pp.10-19

� � - Clark, B. R (2001) ‘The Entrepreneurial University: New Foundations for Collegality,

Autonomy, and Achievement’, Higher Education Management (OECD), 13(2), pp.9-24.

- Clark, B. R. (2002) ‘University Transformation: Primary Pathways to University

Autonomy and Achievement’, in Steven Brint (ed), The Future of the City of Intellect:

The Changing American University, Stanford University Press, pp.322-342

� � - Clark, B. R (2004) Sustaining Change in Universities: Continuities in case studies and

concepts, Society for Research into Higher Education & Open University Press.

8)� The Times Higher Supplement : World University Rankings 2005 - the best guide to the

world’s top universities. *.Ϲ 2.��eZ~�~áK§¯��FG�- AZ~�

~á23 200¶øe�{¸X|\]k����þN�{�{�k23K¶gÀÁD�FG

�-� 2.�ÄÁe�®¯K2�GK�Ím �{¸X|23¡Kª������þ

N�k�{�{�W�(�ZX{23K+,:FG�-3�e�¤2�ç2�¤çØ2�

2-2�=./2�¤è2�>2�è0T2�122�3<24���FG�-;Ä:�

Ã�£¹H�Ð:K,¹�6 Ã��­æF23%& �*±Je����.~WZ<

�Ã�K*��FG�-=;����K2�GÃ�Kï�<�·8\5:j6FG�;�

º �23Kj¶�7G%�eG�-

9)� - Slaughter, S. & Leslie, L. L. (1997) Academic Capitalism: Politics, Policies, and

Entrepreneurial University, John Hopkins University Press.

� � - Slaughter, S. & Rhoades, G. (2004) Academic Capitalism and New Economy: Market,

State and Higher Education, John Hopkins University Press.

10)� Bleiklie, I. & Henkel, M. (2005) Governing Knowledge: A Study of Continuity and

Change in Higher Education, a Festschrift in Honour of Maurice Kogan, Springer.

11)� Stefhr, N. & Grundmann, R. (2005) Knowledge: Critical Concept in Philosophy, 5 ,

Leading Academic Publishers.

12)� - Margarison, S. & Rhoades, G. (2002) ‘Beyond National States, Markets, and Systems

of Higher Education: A Glonacal Agency Heuristic’, Higher Education, 43(3), Kluwer

Academic Publishers, pp. 281-309.

� � - Vidovich, L. (2004) ‘Global-national-local Dynamics in Policy Processes: A Case of

Page 23: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� �����

‘Quality’ Policy in Higher Education’, British Journal of Sociology of Education, 25(3),

pp. 341-354.

� � - Marginson, S. (2004) ‘Competition and Markets in Higher Education: A ‘Glonacal’

Analysis’, Policy Futures in Education, 2, pp. 175-244.

� � - Lee, J-K. (2004) ‘Globalization and Higher Education: A South Korean Perspective’,

Globalization, 4(1). http://globalization.icaap.org/content/v4.1/lee.html

� � � � � �; 2005.�{¸X|#$%&37jASHEu30A27jW�ZüãW�{vue��Ê

��FG�-

13)� M. }��â�j8?9�uj1954uøÊ¿�_�ûï­�ý:-

� � M. }��â�j ;<�=�uj1962uø_�673Â�Ãûeb6-

14)� pfqr23�Q­�ab�MH����Mò67�xy$�ö#�ô8��" ���

#>?n+@j2004uøpfqr23flp²û¤'�� ï 255 ��\�0��;G-�

¹�Á�23gQú¥�%& ����|X�£Z)�¨úzrhi�%¡Bnp�t

�" ��Í"�G-

15)� ACB<�b~�3(�óÁ�45��lmoe,¹�aé��ÍÎoe,��Í",�s

Ë\:FG�-;Ä�aé��GF�ÍÎo�G�CËsËe�°±�8K,��LM�

©­�jU 2A3ø#$%&WD�Z)EU 33A �BC7�>?23#$%& ��

�@~��� 2005. 11D 7-93u

16)� ��:;3 ¸¹�Q:F��;�OT�F�ã{j2005u_#$%&ø·�ü�V�

'~ûhiù.TX(�3�¸¹hiùcø23ûCûU 35C�>?23#$%&

���@~���207-227��\�0��;G-

17)� D. X�(�~jëGÕH�IJ�K�L:6��uj1961uø23%&û�%&673d

�ïûï­�ý:�35-63�-�

18)� M. T½~[j`M'�N�uj1997uøË/67��e8ùu��û���@ùûOÚ

Z.¼ZX�-�

E. ½.Ä�jI�Ù�uj1996uø23%ö¡�±�(|Z'þ��NûPQ23"#

~-� �

19)� Stefhr, N. & Grundmann, R. (2005) Ibid. �

20)� RS�Ùj2003u_3ï3¶�T¼­�´a�Cë;�=}ãIcø3¶ �ûU

17��23���3¶ö6g*�109-126�-�

8øËUj2005u_3¶T¼�Q­�´a�C=}VWcIDE 9D��62-68�-�

21)� �¡XeE�i2Ë�Yj2004uøBetweenû5D�jNo.204uø4C���®~�­�

i2ûè {��7-10�-�

22)� �C����.%�Z�[\>9j2005uø3�23%Bvw�Nù S�Ëò�úíùû

COE �'X�[ 15�>?23#$%& ���@~��-�

Page 24: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� 17��

� 2 �� ������� ��

��� ��∗�

�����������

������������� ��������������������� !��"

#$�%&'()*���+���,�-.)��/0-12�03�()4+���,�-.)

5676���/0'89�����:;<����=�5>���#?���+�@��A

��BCD'�E5>)*+�@��/0�����=��F'()��G$<����+�

A����F'HIJ5>����KE�F'()*�

�����L���MN�O.P'Q()*�L�RSTUVW��X����Y>)*�L

���Z[���\@�]�^_ ab-�)--Q�����^_@cdef-�;<Y>)*

���ghi�+�'Q��'Q�j>)4k�l'����mno����ghi�Zp.)4�

� ��bq-$<�+�-�������03��B. WrsW�tA� uvwxy'z

{.)k-'X)4B. WrsW�:)-�tA� uvwx��| 1�}.:�����-b

q-~� 2��h#��mn#��;<~)*| 1�����bq&'(��� �����t

A� /0�}.*+� XYZ���>'()*�������L������'()*A�B�

C�D ����������������<��+�'����Z��� ��.)���"

�$�bq'()*X+��Y+��Z+���' A�L�� ��.)���"�$<�;

�bq A��-~�k-��)*�$<k��-�� 2�����.)-k��+���

\`�]`���'()*�6��+� X-�L D��.)-k� X+� D�\���]

@����'()*�

�� ���������������

� � � � �������� X�

� � � � �� Y�

� � � � �� Z�

� � � � �

������������ � � � � � A�������� � ���B ������������C��������������D

� �� ��� �� �� �� �� �� �

5<����/�-$<��5 �����n>)*��� ¡�/���+�A���/0

'HIJ5>���"?��¢KE$£¤�¥.)F'()* ¦���k'KE5>���

����� ������ �

��

��

Page 25: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� 18��

�����§¨'�©�+�A'�� @ª�'����M«�Hm5>)* ¬����­�

�®�F�+�¯H�ª�[�F'Q()* °��£¤�¥�±²�³'´sµ¶s·s�¸

¹�?�$���­º»�¼½�F-Q���¤¾&¿�¡\-Q�;<~)*5n� À��

��­�ÁÂ�Ã;���ÄÅ�ÆÇ�È�)k-Q()*�

k�:������+�-12ÉÊZ�bq'(��+�A�˨)� �����ÌÍ/0

�¡�'()-~�)*+������HÎ�����Ï2��F'(���H@��ÐÑ��

G.)���ÒÓ`ª�[�F'()��G$<������­º»�Ô�˨)ÒÓ`ÕÖ�

×Ø�ÙÚ()*�

��������� !"�#�$%&'�����()*�+,�

���#���L�ÛÜ[�Ù����'()*ÝÞ�Bßàá%âãäå�B��%&æçè

é1996êë�ìÐãæçè-íîï�ðñ5>��ß� 1,503%&�����òª�]�¿�%&

� 580�ó�)*k������Ô%&@+�A���ôõ�ö÷���%&�øù�ú5~�100

�ûü�%&A�ý~� 541%&�þ_êÉ{�ý©- 537�����~<���Z�����

þ_ê���<I)-�E 1�:���)*�

Emn�~©�m�k-�I�>)46����mn(;���� 42' 1996êY�100

�ì����ä&� 7.8%�ó�)�.��~* ¦��8©������ÐÏÐmn 1950ê

6'�_�5><~)* ¬��1980ê ì�Q���� ���������`����'9

8©���^_5><Ë���������~<~)4�

- �� ����.���/+0�

� 1919 �� 1920�44� 1945�49� 1950�59� 1960�69� 1970�79� 1980�89� 1990�96�

����� 1 5 6 17 17 10 9 1

��� 3 5 7 16 6 8 19 2

�� 2 2 4 17 14 13 27 8

���� 0 3 3 4 8 6 14 2

��� 0 1 1 13 5 6 12 4

���� 4 2 11 12 18 11 7 0

����� 0 2 3 8 3 7 5 0

������� 3 0 11 13 6 11 9 4

������� 0 10 6 10 14 13 27 6

��� 13 30 52 110 91 85 129 27

�Ë�ËË:�+��K�ì������) 1919 ê�+� 8�ì��þ_5>����j

�m 13'(����cd���.)-���:���)*�

����1884��������1916��ÝÞ v!r"µ���1919��1�����1918��

ÝÞ#$���1898��ÝÞ|%&ß��1892��'���1889��'�����1908��()�

Page 26: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� 19��

��1909��ÝÞ*)���1895��ÝÞ+,���1913��å­���1887��å-.���1897�*�

k�/0>�o)-�1�$Q.�<���Y��Z��2+øù�����-�;<~

)3'��~*4$��56�+������J7��³�-.)ö÷���89�Q�Q��

��:;��³�-.)Q�Q8~*�òª�¿'����6'�����Y ��<='

�������>��H6><~�~*k���þ_5>������:��8>�89�?

�Q�()������ÝÞ��@��B��uvwx�89�:)-*�n>)*�

{A�2B� 30êÔ��+��C+§¨'(;�*19DE�Fj����Gå+�  2

HI�Gå+�-$<þ_5>��Ï��äå��H6>�m-~�-�J�©-Q�òª

�]��FK��'��~*+��ì����ÝÞ�+�'Þ9���L���=�$���

�L#�/��M.)+��9�N�<J9�On><~�*�����HÎ5>���@£¤

��¥������Õ����������-~��P��ª�bq�<|������)1�

8�J�m;�*�-��>��;<Qö÷���bq-�)1Q8(;�*�

+��ìÐ�+�mnRSB��CT�UV�WG+�C�-XY�ò�+�C�Z;+��

[><+\@c)]�G+�^_`-ab�j��c9+�&Û-�)*de����fg

h+X©�;<X�-i�:�4�

Y �:������Þ9��H6>)����Ð��'()4�Ð��)-��>6'�

Z¿³�'(;�Tjk�+\�c)]��+���ò¿�\þ_5>�æK+�-$<lm

5>�*c9�+�mn���L#5>):��no��;<�,�<���-~�bq�1

�8H6>)�'()*�Ð��;<�p�89�+��:)���L#q5>�äå�

��1�8H6>��'()*CT�UVì��rGå+���,�rs�+�@Màt�+

��æK+�-$<Þ9��lm5>�+�¯uvw²/��q��RS 30 êxmn'(

)-~�:�*�

�Ð��;<��89þ_5>)�y�¡���k�:��+��ÛÜ�z{�|}�"?

'()*ä&-$<�ÝÞ��Lä&'�Þ9�����þ_��Ð��;<mn~X�-~�

:�*����~©�m�!�+�'����³�-.)ö÷������@���n><~

���ÐÏÐ��>��&-$<�()~��>-���äå�������þ_5>�*

1950ê ��)-����Z��-�!������þ_5>���Z[��.)*Y �

�B��uvwx��k�k��#5>�-i�:�4�

1����+,23'����45�

��� ��8����Z��Q;<J�$�������Z[��$~*Y��� �

-~�cd�?��B��%&��úøù�Q����)- 200���)-�j>)*ÝÞ�Ë

~<��� �03�����H�����2�L���>�[©�ÝÞ� ��� 1941�RS

16�ê�H6>��±��~*$m$�Ð� 50 êÔ�˨)� �03�����0����

�©�XQ�()*

Page 27: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� 20��

��������

� 6���Ð�˨)� 03���`����_�no�Z���}$��E 2'()*ä

&� 10ê��'o)-�1950ê 2Q8© 24.5%�ó�<~)*Y�!�������8

©��k���H6><~)*��Ð�1960�1970ê � 14%²Ü'��.)�1980ê

�19.5%�- 1990ê �6êÔ' 14.5%����0����'()*2�����������

����\'�f�)�Z[�"?'()*����I��Z�����`å-� ¿��Ä`

��¿���`�.¿��>��]� '�� ¡& ¿'()*

- �� 6789:�;<��(=>�+,0�

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

���� -1949 1950 1960 1970 1980 1990

� � � (��) -59 -69 -79 -89 -95 �---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

1.�� 6 (2) 2 0 0 0 0 8

2.������ 1 (1) 5 2 2 3 3 16

3.������ 0 (0) 0 1 0 4 3 8

4.������ 0 (0) 2 1 1 1 3 8

5.����� 4 (2) 3 0 3 0 2 12

6.������ 0 (0) 0 2 3 6 2 14

7. !� � � 2 (2) 4 2 1 5 1 16

8."#� 2 (1) 0 1 2 1 2 8

9.$%� 0 (0) 1 1 1 0 0 3

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

10.�&� 0 (0) 4 3 2 3 0 12

11.�'(� 1 (0) 2 3 0 1 1 8

12.)�&� 1 (1) 1 2 4 0 0 8

13.*�� 1 (1) 2 0 0 1 1 5

14.!(� 1 (0) 3 1 2 0 1 8

15.+,� 0 (0) 1 0 1 2 0 4

16.-./� 1 (1) 5 1 1 3 1 12

17.0,12� 1 (0) 4 2 0 1 1 9

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

3� � � 21(11) 39 22 23 31 23 159

(%) 13.2 24.5 13.8 14.5 19.5 14.5 100%

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- �

ä&-$<��Ðmn 1960 ê B6'����Y�!������H6>��'

(����ÐY6'��1960ê ��H$�����5n���Z�����Z[$<~)

�'()-i�:�*

� � �¡¢'��1950ê ������e-_£5>�*k����0¤�³å°å�UV

Ë:¥0C�� ����ÝÞ� ���Ì\-$<_�5>�*¦'`��¿'��1941ê�

_�5>�ÝÞ� '�� 1956êì����g.)-ö��� '��_�5>�1957

ê��� ���_�5>)*k�W����ÝÞ� ��mnZ[.)�'H6>�-5>

<~)*�Ë�1960ê�Ð��§Ô� ¨���� 2�����1970ê ì���©�� �

��_�5>)*

� ��`å-� �Z���1960 ê ��1961 ê���� �����&-$< 1965 ê�Ý

Þ��� ���ª.)*1980ê ��G«å��������¬ò[@å-� �0.)�

�98©H6>��1990ê �­;<Q�Z[�¡®-�¯'~)*

Page 28: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� 21��

� �Ä`��¿��1950ê а�0¤� �Ä��-� ����_�5>�Ð�1966ê

�ÝÞ� �Ä���1970ê�ÝÞ� .��_�5>�±Ý�!���²;�*��Ð�

1990ê �­��ÝÞ�³� ���ÝÞ� ÄÅ���ÝÞ� ÛÜ��_�5>¡®-8

>[�¯'~)*

� �ª`ª�¿'���Ð^© 1948ê�ÝÞ� ª����1954ê�ÝÞª�� ��_�

5>�Ð�|%&�Z��ý~<�>�����e[��~*k�Ô�1979ê�ÝÞH´� �

��1994ê�ÝÞµ�Qª���_�5>�²Ü'()*

� � ��`�.¿'��¶·¸`¹º� 03Ë:¥:;5603������^© 1950

ê �_�5>�*1966ê���ÝÞ� ��mnZ»¼�.)�'ÝÞ� �.��_�5

>)�k>��&-$< 1983ê��ÝÞH�56���1990ê��ÝÞ½¾¶¿rx��

H6>)*� Z�03�����1970ê mn 1980ê �m¨<�Z�\¿À�+�`�\

�!�ÁÂF-$<H6><©)*�Ë����)~¦'�?�ÝÞ¹º� ��-ÝÞ¶·¸

� ��� 1994ê�KÃ$�ÝÞ¶·¸`¹º� ��-�;�*1980ê Ämn 1990ê

�m¨<ÝÞ�Å���� IÆ`¼½���ÝÞ��������98©���H6><~

)*

� � ��`�Ç� ¿����� �¿:�Q¦')©�ÝÞ����-ÝÞbÈ����

���� 1927ê�H6><~)*ÝÞ� �������Ð� 1952ê����7%&H6>

��Y 4,000���.+X�����;<~)*

� É#� ¿'��{A+��H6>�¦'�)~��`���()�2+øù�ÝÞ 

��� 1948ê�H6>�*��ÐQJ$����$<~)*

� É#� -��.>��tA� ¿���9�J�~*tA� ���Êf����\'�j

><~)*

� �]� �Z�����Ô�8>8`¬Ë8��ÌÍ�� �Z�:�QcC'()*6��

�¢h#��+�A����³��Q���Î�¢³��Q�-~������G«+�

� `ú�Î`³�tÎ-�>�5n����]`]I��>�§Ô� ¨�%&-d5>):

��Q�Q()*�$<6��ÏÐ���>��{A+���Î�¢�����Ñ��.):

��¦'�)~Q�Q()*þ_�&�8>8Q�$~*

������� ���

����� ���������������

� +��_�-ö>����_��Q~©�m�ÒSÓ()*¡���Êf��mn��Z[

Ô�6���Z»¼�Ô�'()*������Z[ÕXÖ��)FK8~-�j>)*�

Ë�Êf������`���×K$<äå����_�.)Øsv@Ùå����ÝÞÌ\

-$<���_�.)ØsvQk>���)k-'X:�*

� ~6¡���Êf��-�Ú03�_�5>)�^_Ô�'()*kk�Q5676���õ

Ô��5>)*���@�\`�]�ö÷H�³�-.)�����&-.)Q��]���

Page 29: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� 22��

Û�Üö��Ýsx�&��;�Q��ÝÞ�B�Þ�ÝÞ� +�ß�@�ß+�Ô%&�

\�@����&��;�Q��IFEL ��àá�@����&��;�Q���()*

5n�6��()� ��Mâ�I�-$<"#5>�§Ô%&���_�$���Ùå�%

&@Äã_��Íä.)FKQ()*

�����������������

� _���å�¦'�H#�Óæçv�:)õÔ[-��������!�)�����h#¢

�ßõ�����Ë:¥ª���×ØmnZõ'X)*�>��8©�FK�8ß8>�cd�

�>èé5><~)*+X© 2��Z[����L�bq�()*E 3���ê��}$<

~)*

- 1� ���8&�?�

��

��

������ VS �����Specialities, Research Areas�

��� !"#$% VS &'%

()*+ VS,-*+"��.���/ VS012

34*+�5�6789�VS0:*+(;5�6789)

�<�=>%?@A(4B)"CDE=�EFG��E��H

IJ�� !"��� VS��KLMNO VSPQ

 ¡���L��'()*k>�5n��3��Z¨n>)*6��� 1����@����

ª�����ÒÀ���LZ��Disciplines��:)����%&'()m�()~��LZ�

���<�()�ë���wsì��³� �½¾¶¿rx����� ��.)����%&

'()m�í�'()*�� 2���î�L���Z[�ÜK~'()*ïð���L�G«-

.)m��ëZ����Z[$�Z�@���G«�Oë.)m'()*�� 3��ñòóôm

bÈóôm'(��bÈóôõ~-ö;A�M«­8©÷�.):���)45n���� 4

��øø�Sùúæûs�óômüm'()*��ý~��·rRSx@���.���Lþ�

¬�n�����Z[��y-�)*

� Z[� ¦�����¢h#�³�-.)bqh�'()*�� 1����¢h#����ø

�()*�¢äå�ø��()~�å-�ø����¯'~)m��ë���Oë5><~

)m�6����+���Oë5>��+���¢@ö÷H�!&-.)m���'í�5>)*

5n���� 2-$<�+�A����³�����ñòóô�'()m��Î�¢��� M

â­!&-�;<~)���bÈóô�'()m��()*�¢h#���8-$<�J7

+����Q��)k-'X:�*5n����bq�K�[��()*��S"��s

ì����mnJ�$<øù�+.)-�/0D����«��lm�ø�� �[��

de�K�[�I���-~�cd��.):���)*9���øù��)-��<%&m

n�$<ª%.�@á%.���.�[$<�©*

Page 30: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� 23��

�������� !"� #$%

� ��@�����_£�Ê�6;�©É�'� Q�H��H6>)4$m$���H�-$<

�>e�ª�����@�z{()*

&"�'(�)�

� ��������-$<�6����-�6©ª��������e[()*å-[�£¤

[��,�-.)ª�h��e[��� ����^$~��wþ�w$�*å-[�����

��Ùå�� ÛÜ����-�6n��Q;-�N��¬ò[� @å-!"�mmj)��

�¬ò[Ô� ���¬ò[#U¿$Øsu%"���ÝÞå-� ��A��HIJ$�*1970

ê ì��£¤[����ÝÞ� Z���� uvwx£¤���r CAI ����ÝÞ� £

¤���]�� �����H¯§*

*+,-.�/0

� ò�ÄÅ��6��á56���a&�-�� �ÆÇ�È��*����@k'� Q��

<��ÐH6>�^$~�]`]IA��.(^$~���þ_-�;�*1980ê ì�'��

a&�)~^$©H6>�H�]�K§]-~;�^$~�]��^$~��Lþ�HIJ$�

H�]� ���ÝÞK§� ���ÝÞ��� ������]0×�^$~���H¯§*

k>���ÎYF��¢�$s*�Qb�)Q�'Q(;��+�'�¢L#�+j)���

�-;<Q��:]I�� �1����á$�¨>��n�~��'(;�mn�+�-�Î

��¢�,X-¯§��H6>��'()*6��� :¢./.�a�-~�ò�ÄÅQ�

ÝÞ�³� ��H6>)��-Q�;�-~�:�*

1���23���456789:8;9<8=>�

� � ���\�Q����Z[�0/()*��Z[��1�����L'�Gb'X�~

��Lþ�2F��()*

� �Ðm���Ô�M3]���1�$m;�*� '`�4���³�-.)ÒÀ�� �

-�¬�;����.�5È.)�����:�6�8�()�����þ_$�*1950ê ��

��27'()*

� 5n��1950ê ì���Sùúæûs�G�@� �IÆ�ý~����Z[�8�$�

$�k-Qo9��~*ö,G«���.)�F@Sùúæûs�¬�)���e�_�5

>�*

� 1980ê ����>:>������\�Q�Z[�;$on>):���;�*Ùå�Æ

Ç�<¨<�¦'��'��ª�'���ª��'Q =�>ÓæsÝ��^$~�.y5È

5>q��*��Z[����G«�|+'Q()*�-�¬�)��G«���.)k-��

?�ú¾@T¾wAs�!B.)2QC���.'()*k�$<±D������)k-�

�m;�:��ws�5>):���)*

Page 31: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� 24��

?�@A����,BCD�EFG�

� +�¯� �|+�-Q�~�+�¯H�$©��$���"?��¢9Q��$<~)*

$m$�Êf�����D�ðñyò9��ºG����>����$<~�~*EF����

���E�F��©��;G��©)F��©)k-Q�^$~�����H>��y-�;<

~)-�j>)*

@���AB�C�D��EC�D��FGH&I�JK�

��G«Ë:¥���.�8>'(����Z�'Q89���H6><~)4k�:��n

o���òª�]�'�IJmQ$>�~*

� ú5���'�h#¢Ô'K1�ÞyL'X)-~�M¾Vµ()*����Lþ0�

�ÜM.)J9��'�1Ü�N~O~Þy'X)*

� $m$��k'�£¤�ÜM��������¢�On>)*���¢���Qö,:���

�0��?;<~)Q�~)mQ�>�~������fX©�n>�~k-Q(��

)*ú5���'�@PsT���-ÕÖ�QO@()*|%&'Q­5>)m��mRj

$~*5n��¡������-;<��89�ú����­.)1�(���ÛÌJ�æS

�Ú¶'X�~*ä&-$<������-;<Q������-;<Q�øù�ÁÂ�T<'

X�~ùM¾Vµ()*

U+�����/���%����sVÛ[�4*h#¢�8>8�+.)������

���'�Þy�O�)k-de�W$©���ä¢�$s*�üX�©ü�.k-�YW�

�)*

� ��U+[$h#¢�9��$���wsìQ8>��>��Êf����\�����

����(;<>e����%H6>)*�>:>����%�'��»~�������

.)k-'X�Z[�\��È�)k-Q'X)�S"]@^ ½_V@�*���%�'��

K1�#U¿$Øsu%"Ê�'�½`ÜM5>�6�8+X~*����� ?���

����\�$<Qn~�~-~�t��ab�M$<~)*ú5���`�������:�

�$s*�ü�$<©>)§¨'�©�Üö&�community�-$<�fcQT<'X)*�

���������� ?������!Õmn\�5>�~-~�ºG�dec�õ©?

�:���>��S"]@^`½_V@:�QQ;-��sì����þ_$:�-.)'

(��*

� �L���Z[�Gb$����bq¨���N-$<����Z]��M.)+øù���

8~4�L������e��'�8>8�f¯'~)*bq�y���)-k��:>��()

²Ü� g8�M.)���h@m�"¥�~�bq����e��ij�Gb'X)�K.

Weick, 1976�*

� �����Z]���cd�¬�;<~<Q�(�mQ°�¼�$�������:��bq

&'()*Z]��Û�kl$�Z]���'��mJ$���+��no�E\��¨�$�

Page 32: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� 25��

³��¼ �@PsT�p�.)Q�Q()*���bqÛ�6­.)k-�:;<�+øù

���'()�Qmmjn��ú5����M¾Vµ�T<'X)Ê�8�+.)*�L��

�Z;&�����������O[5���� �[�!".)*$m$������k��

[��q�o<r�o���st��ï$<~)*+øù'(��n�úøù�u5�M.)¨

�b�n>)4

LMN�OP

Clark, B. R. (1983) The Higher Education System, University of California Press. �MÞl3

�1994�ãtA� uvwxèCvw*�

Weick, K. (1976) ‘The Educational Organizations as Loosely Coupled Systems’,

Administrative Science Quarterly, 21 (March).

xØyzH`p�{|� �1991��ã� ���è�ÏÐ�ã� ���è  58,  4}*

+~¡�1992���~J.66��ã� ���è����� ÝÞ� ��À�ê'��  59, 

3}*

����`³���1991��ÝÞ� ��ú'�ã� ���è  58,  4}*

ÝÞ[��â�1978�ãÝÞ�[��ê'�[�-[�Z;��IèC�[�ö�*

ÝÞ�B�Þ�1994�ã��¤��å�˨)�B%&�YnèÝÞ�Bßàá%*

ÝÞ�Bßàá%â�1996�ãäå�B��%&æçè1996êÜë�+�����ê*

�yu��1995�ã+���L���ª��èC�&Jëª*

�yu��2000�ã�òª�]��³�-.)�L���Z[-���h�-/��0.)ª�

����èò\�]���Û��#?¤�%�XY+�+�¯� ���]*

�yu�`���{�1996��� ������Z[����¸¹�0.)��mn�ÝÞ�

��  55�+�����*

�yu��2004����-�@����¡`�� âã+�¯�aÐè�à¡�21 DE�+�`

tA� �*�)�  4,��Cvw*

Page 33: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

���

���������������

Page 34: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� �����

� 3�� �������� �����

��� ��∗

���������

��������

� ����������� �������������������� !��"#�$

��%&'()*+,-.�&/01�2&/-34506� 7��18�9:;�<=>

?@9:+,�AB-����C+,/A.����D�E?4,%&FAGHIB�?4+JK

��L4IIF-���4MFALBNB�OP����"#�QR;�?4+J�D�ES

T�JU�D.�VWXYZ�[.�\�V]��>�DK�,��^_`ab4���4MF

A�c�d��YZ�ef��J��,g�h�ij�k�le�7U��m4no�pq�7

U;�4�g�h�+JK7DrstE�

� uv�%&�,w.x4yz?{|;��0]}]4��~�+J��L�+,�f����

������U�L���7����71�����0��QR��L4������.��

;��D+��C4��>%&D��������4tE-i�k4��"#����40

]�}]4�k����-U��J�������� 10 �^�3��K��*��7%&'

(4��"#��Y ¡~�9;��¢£¤4MFA?LB�¥AF�-K�¦U�V]4�

�"#4i�k�§VWYZ¨§©ªM«¨¬�[�4�­���0]}]+,§�_®

{ �§%¬¯n �§�°£¤¨-3±²³-��"#�QR;�?4�[��

� D�´����,µ&¶·�c¸¹4º»�¼½D;�µ&¶·¾¿4À�ÁU�%&�ÂB

�����0]}])*+,-.V]~��?Ã.tE�-K������L4[.,µ��

-34��Ä���³��YÅ+J�)*��'(X��>Æ��DK�,��ÇÈ4u�4É

ÊËÌD��� 7%&ÍÎ>�DK�,%&4ÏeÐ�ÑK7U��"#4"ÒÓ�Ô��Õ

�7U;�fÖD������4×Ø,LBÙÚ�%�-ÛÜD-K������

���� �������������

� �,�� 3Ý��7U���C4%&�¦*���Y 4¡~��>Þ�4�¢�£¤��

������2002���K7ßÝ£¤D 2005���K7àÝ£¤FA�� 14tE-���¡

~4�¢DL4áâ�~FK7 1)�£¤,�wC4%&ãäåæç�è�%&�M«�éê)'

ëXì'ëí 15,000 ��­î��K7?4+�Ýï>_,í 2,500 �+J��L4£¤�¦�

����ðßÝ£¤, 1999�ÓFA 2002�Ó�àÝ£¤, 2004�Óñ4òó�ô����õ

�7��àÝ£¤+,V]4òó³-'(+�^öab÷�0]+, 4ø5 öab�}]+, 1

ùabú4�����K�¦U�F�ûü4>Dýü4>D+,�10þ�û4���J���F

?L4��,ßÝ£¤�����àÝ£¤4v��%����D�´FA�Y ¡~4�Mâ4

���������� ������

Page 35: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� �����

��J��D�»+���

� ?KD?��4£¤+,­î>�'ëì'ë+JU��F?��"#�"�D©�B���

4%&�M«�éê+J�D�´FA�9:>4� tU?�½�_������F?�B

-��LB�?FF�A�V]�?���[.4����¡~IB����D�~FK7� 7

LBD�����-����+��"#�����0]4'(?�=_���D?��B7��

D��ÕIB����*+J��

� D�´+���%&?�½���CwÚ+,�%&,34çÓ4�����ô��L4���

,3�FA����4+J´EF�LB���f�FU,�8��¸ �!��"����§µ

&¶·��£¤#$¨�J��LB�%��7&#,!�4µ&¶·'(�)K���4+��

B������ 15 �^4*�+,�-4.+Õ�7?4�Ñ 1 +J���B�t�D�/u

�+,D?�%&��ô;����4�0,%�.12����D�/3�+,+4%�-�4

D���+c+,,C����56FA�����478��-��D�~F��+c498,�

56FA�����4wÚ�:½�78� 2003�£¤+, 50i�;k<+J�4�­��,C

498, 68 i�;k<+J��uv�%&ÙA�ô�;����478,+c4v�=>³�

%���L40?,@FA0?4u��,�,C+,BC564D�E��LBNB4�FÉG

k��7��[04����%&�G�;�D�E§%&�H*¬¨4���¡~É�IJ�K

L�����LB��4_M�NO����D�E�D�J���F��P�?0?�J��

�����������������

� LB�Qs��R���ûS4/u4T�;-������0�bUV+�-��WtE�µ

&¶·'(��ô;�UVX�YK�¸V;�D�2003�4����0,�,C4%&� 4Z 7

ù[b+J�4�­��+c4%&+, 3Z 3ù[b+J����\ê+c4%&,[04��

���K���D�E]î�^�)´E�/u�+c4%&4_,,C4 3~4 1çÓ+J�4

������0,,C4 77�?_K���4)FA��B�,@AF4`a���.��D�

QsABtE�

� �F�ïs,bc+J��CR�-�;�98�����,����";���>%&ãd

ðäåæçñ4HZ-3�e��� B�����B,+,fg+J��ah,���C+,%

&'(i��Ì��>+J�4�­���,C+,��%&J��,LB�jk�%&4W�£

¤4­î�-K����D�L��,C+,��>4��"#l4mn4Ó8����Ä�§o

ÌiJUV¨��¸V;�4�­�����C498,p��?qr�LE+,-�FA+J

�����OECDl4#$�R��,:_�ô��oÌiJUV4�-�ss�tE-tu�

-IB���Dõ.����C4%&'(�t���"#���4�¢����,�v�³-

£¤wx�pyD©�B��

� ��C4%&�,�����z�����D�E{,��>4^+?��5º<=>4^+?

t.õFB��7)��%&'(�ÐsB|LB�G}EHZ�Ðs�YK�Ù#³�§���¨

�~Aê+� Eà4�¸£¤�,J��4�z�J���4£¤�34tE���;�F,�

Page 36: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� �����

� �� ������������������������� ����

���������� ������������������� �� !"#$%&� �'(

)*� �+,-./(

0�( 1234&�567889 :;<=>>7 :;�?@A6B234&�5 =>>C :;�?@AD4&E(

�� ���!"�����#$�%&�'()*�

����%�-æh+,-�)´EF��4tE-T?�����ý���É�IJD��4%

&DLB�9;�5º�����k��D��7��

+����!"��,-�./�

������ �!�"�#$��

� %&4�y-�7,�'������������J��7)LBA49:���ü���

�,�%&9:>4^+?I � -Qs�J���,F����%&418 ����7D��

=�4§'�¨��D�D.%&4���§��X'�¨D����74�����¥�S��

����=��½��7V��+,��?§'�X��¨D�ê+�74����õ�74+ 

¡ �¢s74+J´E� 7�4�D,��%4'(4���ü�/u����/3�'�D

�E�D+JK7£¤+?J��

� �%�¥ A����C4'(4¦1û4���ü,�CR³���?��"#�§K���

�D��AB����`_�ß4¨�©ª�4CR£¤�t�D�,C+,%&'(4 4�4E

� 3� +��tU'��¦1û4/u�üDïs���4�­����C+,����%�%

&�a�� 4�4E� 3� +����/u�ü)D���� 2)�?KD?�,C4%&'(�

«ê+'��/u�üDïs��7D,�A-��,C4%&,[¬â�­W�'�M«�Ü®

�����

������

������

������

������

������

������

���� ���� ���� ����

��

��

��

������

�����

������

������

������

������

������

������

������

������

���� ���� ���� ����

��

��

�����

� !" #$

� � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �

� � � � ! " # $ � � �

���*�F�GH =>>I :J(

Page 37: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� �����

;�%&�%á[��D�L��'(468û4¯°X±8���C����¥KF�K��²

ôIB���FA+J´E�

� ��C4'(��'�tU?��"#�³��;4�,0?�J��LB,'(4´µ¶·�

¸D����"#�­îD�7?4�-K���FA+J��¹s|'(�ô4D��º½AB

�4,�&üðäåñ4�F��B +�����7����+J��&�»�¼)IB7¤½

H&·�V�@cJ�F�D�E�D��y-¾¿�jD����%&?[�� 7�uÀ»�

�;tE-Á�³-�Q�§ÂV¨DÃÄÅÆ,� )�^�����Ç��4È4ÝU+?�

7AÉI-&��Ðs� 7%&ãd��ÄÊf��>��&�»l4ËÌ)*+,-.�&

�%�l4���Í�ÎÄ1¹�[.-K�������BA4�D,���ÇÈ���+?±

WÐ�7�D4���³­Ïl4�Ð4Ñ�D©�B��

� §'�,Ò�¨Ì)����,ÊÒ�ÓÌ+J�¨D�E�D,�'(4"#�È4�sv4

 ��t.��7rÔ+J��� U�&ü&·Â»�¼)IB7�V�,�u�4%&D�

EÕÖW�×s��Ø.uÀ�gô;�µ�JU� 7L4�D�J�7½��LBA�,u»

4Ùj�yºIB�FA+J�� 7�Ø�gôÒ�J�FA�L�D%&+,'(�1���

´µ��Ú;�4+,-�)´EF�

������ %&'()*+

� 7)�Ç��%&��4�Û4¸Ü,�%&'(,�Ó4���Ú�ݽ�?KD'��µ�

Þß��+J�D�E�D+J���B�,�.�F4ßà�J��LB,/u����C�á

'�4%ââ4­��ã��[.4&d,Y�4tE-ä¨��Få-�����?D�.'�

)*+,æz�-.-K��7D�E�D+J��D�4£¤���?�[.4&d,'Þ'�

ä¨��Få-çè'�tU,�é6��L�6Ç'��º½�����B,Y�4tE-�

�>D����AB��7'(�DK�9«4­²�J�yê+J�FA�-F-F­ë�ì�

��FD "#�íê�;��+J�D�E¸Ü?�L4tE-yê�ës�7½+J�D;�-

A|�%��­½���+J´E�

� /3��'(,y4M��L7-������î���4+�LB�ï½�F�'��µ�e

B���+J�D�Eßà+J���B,�¸ð4ah?JK�-F-F¾¿�ñì+J���

�ò4ó���.tE-��,�LB�ô�õÌö÷4ø�F�ù4ú���+JB|D?F.�

��4Û³û�����~FU;�ü¥�º½�y�FA,�ý¾4­î�-U;���

ò4ó�������E�������4Û³�þB�fÖ�4W�)�K�� ED�E1

¢����D?ah+J�� 7�§��¨D���,������ +ÍK�?��D��,�

B��?K�A��4ÇÈ4����;�tE-§�^¨|FU+?ñ��D?ý¾4E��,

J��D)´E�

� /���0]4'(,D?F.�V]4'(,��+J�D�Ey4M4��J����"

#�­��,�§«�-�D�K��� D�Eý¾?^��«�-�D���^�J�-A

'���D�E�*+J��Ç�4'(,%&ï4#�4M+�ä����<��ÉGk�?

Page 38: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� ����

ú.9n����>?[.�u ���+J�D?«�-�D�K���D?rs-�D©E

��7�F�F��4'(4M�,�ëÇD'ë�4���F%&��-�>?[FK7Dõ.�

�-3?%&4'(�����D��rED�p�§ëÇ,@��+;F D�Ea�F*��K

�.��3EAy^+,�%&'(4¦1,ëÇ4��_+��D�E�T�J�tE)�

���#$���%&,%-+./�

� �û4¹4tE��y4M+,%&'(4���Ú�J U�.�-�����J�tE+J

���F��%&4���´,�Û4��"#�DK�����y-?4+J��D�þB�,

-A-��LB,�%&4c�D?9���D+J���%&�¦*���"#,�µ&¶·

�Ƕ·Dú�9:�JU����,Í�4�Q�Û4d"�õÌ4û�%�-mn���

��FA+J��

� ��"#,�0]�M«���Ç%&��4���9�tK�?�L4[.�<�B����

7L�+��y-��J��,¶·R����B��7�D?1�+J���F��%&4�

��,P4���9�,-����J��/u��%&�¦*���,�&�%&M��4�

Õ�tK���B�4+,-.���>J��,'ë�M«D;���ÊÌ� 4!��tK�

��B�� 7�Ç�¦*��"��,��-³��+L4����AB���J���B,

ΰÖ#+J��ûÄ�s-��D+J��IA��%&��4�³���9�¦��,�C

$%&J��,5º³yê� �ës�±8³���%&����,�F�[.º½AB��?

�´ê�BA4�ÕIB7��?���'(�7½�,py-�DF?�B-���?KD/�

³Ú��L�� 7�)4*�å4%����?py+JU��BA,%&+����+=-

9�-��

� �4�D,%&4��>�«�,f�¦1������D�E�D+,-��%&�¦*��

�"#,�-.�/0IB7&a4Ù?D �9:�� 7�L4fÖD����Ä�§%&4

Ù1¨��y+J��D,rE +?-��D+,J����F�-�A���,�%&4��

>,�2FA4��¶·ð3ä��4�ñD�E.+�'(�1���4¡~L4PI �

-.+�Ñ�D��4¶·�5*��¦1�����FA+J����4��³YÅ4Ð6,�

^!³78D�E.+�56X�ÇD%&X��>D4+Ó-9Ü9:�.��������B

,%&D�����"#�gk�ú.Ñ28K���«¹+J� 3)�

� /3��%&,%&ã'�L4P�gk��Êf��>¶·>4:;DL4Þ���K��

��D+J����"#�,�<-��>¶·>�py+J������=�4�<-��>X

¶·>����É�IJ�è7-�D�L4C4��"#,��>?��� E���>X¶

·>4Þ�,�%&��4���9+?+��4+,-�FD�E���@»IB����F�

%&�,P4���9�-����J��LB,�A�»4��Û³Xv.XI���B�B-

�Ù?-���C����4Ù?-��DÂg�D]�E�AB7'�:;É�IJ�F��´

µ4Ùj�£¥;�äåGå4&üën�á+JK���BA4���?K��%&,P4�

��9�,-��4�y-�8�<K���4+J���

Page 39: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� �����

0�12 34��56#��78�

���01 23#$4567�#$%89���:;

� ��C4%&,�¥1 19�4HC%&4¯uÛ³ðHC%&Iñ�J�tE�§C$4Jy¨

�ëk�����E�9D��üu�*AB����L4T+,C$5º4 !³-KL4ý�

uFB��7Drs���Pv+HC%&,C$�94M+��°ü�nsAB��7�D�

¥1���4_Û41M�gk��N���7D�´4J���¯D��4§%&4Ù1 �tK

��HC%&�¦*�'(�14Ù¸Ò�������,Ù?-&aD�EOP�Q�IB��

D�?R�K7�LB,S¡%ß��eU�TU�1e�VW1e-3I � -1e�gk�

�X,�7��%�%&ï4M+�-.�/0;�&a4Ù?�Ú�;�9D��%&�¦*

�&a4Ù¸Ò,Ø.��³�GèIB��D�-K7��F?�%ß,HC%&4�¯+JK

7%&Ù1��%�ï4M+;��4%&�Y\�DD-U�&a4Ù?�%&4Ù1�Z[

;���>4_,\]³�Ð6�7�

� &a4Ù?��4Ù¸,�?;�D§î^4_¨³`a���.����4�D�tK

��%&�¦*�'������4�R³X�ô³-yêÔbFAcd;�efÒ�J���F

��%� �,gh%&4ii�j�k�M�%&,l*�<4'�49X&a��49D��

��FA4mn��½� 7��ÓÍ��/�4op-%ââ4M�JK�?�%&,qÇ�4

é6ð¸D��%�Çñ47½4�rés�9D��4�7�%�FK77½?JK��L4'

�X��4ÔbL4?4�,��49«ý¾�I�3[.,� A-FK7�%&�DK�,�

tuûF��-�vg-�w+JK7DrstE�

���<=>?@A�BC�D�EF

�4�D�,�xy%4KL?%���F��%&,�&a46D��zÙ4�7��7;�

D�+�74,�{{4��4ÂB�45¯�­;�ý¾|µ4�°D��4�7�?�ê+

�7FA+?J��,j43%|µ4}~-ó������I � -ý¾³����7DsL

B����³-?4+JK7D��?��v4|µ4Gè�ØAB��D�tK�u»4KLµ

�è��F�bSIBE�L9�JK7�5¯n�ðÙ��ñ?��4N­|µ4{|�@Ú+

�-FK74+���C,Yc¸±Í�+�.DÜ®���?���D4��û�[.4C��

æz����7�tE-��¸±³-Í�X��5º?�Ú���7��

�F��1989�4j�l<BC���¼ ���¸±Úh4%�-�X�ã��LBA�Gè

��D\ê+�7[.4%&�? 7�ÙA4¸±X Ü47½4�¤4[.��K�� K7�

LB�w�K���9¸±Í�µ&¶·4�Q�¤U�D;�äi*¨Â4¸Ü�%�-|µ

�èK��7�äi*¨4u²¸8Úh� ; ;¥AF�-U��J�21y�����4�

,��6�M+J���

'�4~�+?�Y�4tE-§V��¨­§+'Ö¨�§Ù��¨­§���Xf��¨�

D�EtE-��4­L�+,-.���'����4§Ù?â��¨90�w%&ï���

�AB�tE��/�4������Y�+JB|��4­L4§�¨4�Î���.�ê+�

Page 40: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� �����

7,�4§'�z¨D§�Çz¨�§V��¨D§Í��E¨-3Ô�4��4 ��ÛL�¼

½�L4Ñ�§�g�¨D§ï�¨,����0���.�9¸±Í�4Qs�'�5º'

�"#�8e;��F3EF��K��q�.­L;�tE�-K7�%&?Y�-A%&50

%&Ù1-34tE-51³�D�A��|�|ah�-K��74+J��� à,���

�0���.��YÅ�34tE�K/;�4F�-3Í�ah��½�%&ah4¡��áb

��AB�D�´+J��§%&Ù1tU���¨D�EST4Ø�U,� I�%&4��O

P4áâ�Õ;?4+J���

���GHIJK*L�M$NO

� y%¢£4¤Ñ,�gx¥�C^��7-��9:�!��7��4M+�F��µ&¶·D

r!-9:�JK7¦1¶·tU?Í��QÍ���µû47½4�Ƕ·D49:�9r

â�7 4)��47½�µ&¶·4§��Ø�U�µ&¶·4¨D-��"����E%&4�7

�©¶·IB�tE�-K��7�1990�w�ªK��F��4§x¥�C¨,�§µ&¶·,

Í��Q4lkjk¨DQs,k½�Í�4CR��µû4ðTFA�%&�¦*���"#

4"Òâ47½�py-tu�«U¼½7�

��C+,�80�w�¬�%&4��OP�J U�?­®�7�D4N�FA�u�³�,�

¯°�"��47½4iko±²n�%³D4�²�JK7��90�w�¬�ªK��,UP

4CÛD´£�J�g�F4tE����"#D�ÇXÍ�D49:�Ú�vµU�ÑAB7�

�"��Fëô��F,xD�����B���?�%&l4��ËY�Ð0;��D�E{,�

F��-.� ��D�-��

�F��LB,F��4tE�¶��w�IB�u·òá¡~�t���YÅ+,-.� 7

D¸¹��º³�¡~IB�'�»(+,-��µ��¾¿£²��w�IB�tE��%&

¥4�J��,��>FA4Íê�����q�-�¤�Í�Æx�¡~IB����J��,

���(ð+c&·¾¿��x��(-3ñ4tE�§��³��Y ¨���"#4M«�~

�:½��J�4��»+J��

IA���4�D����,�1995���(L.+µ&¶·�c.��L���.4¼»��

�� 1996��,/u½4µ&¶·�c¸¹��2001�FA,/3½4µ&¶·�c¸¹��I

A� 2006 �FA,/�½µ&¶·�c¸¹�º»IB�"�*IB����D�J�� 7�

4^��Vµ&��½%&�¦*�&·��4OP²n�¾��¿EV��D��Àµµ&�Á

µ&�rZµ&-3��Ƕ·�R��µ&¶·4¾¿�¾��è�µ&¶·E��C4�5

ï4uOD��4�E�8�tK�uÚD-U� 7µ&¶·��,�8µ&¶·���*

�4�äÌIB��Ö�L4¯��^âIB����D?���OPïÃ47½�%�-­µ

D-K����D,�4�D+J��

�P�#$�QRST�UV���WX

1998 ���IB7%&���ïͧ21 y�4%&ÅDà�4ïvº����¨42hD�

Page 41: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� ����

�¼(AB���§��³OP4M+ÆÒ�Æ.%&¨D�Eo��Ç,���4%&�«UÈ

.OPáâDLBl4­ëº�E .r�=��������´��½��D%&����"F

;�D�tK���á'�É�IJwÚD��tU[.4��4�É�ës��D�+��4+

J��

� �4tE-ðTFA�%&4��´�àuÓ²0��WtE�%&4�7,�T�ÊE�D�

J�FA�L4�T4Ò�� �Qs�W���T4M�,���4˵�tK�¥AF�IB

L��LB�̱IB��7?4�J����|§{�¨4�TD+?�\��?4+J���

B�­������, ) )�Í�-*B|-A-�ah�JU�L4�Í47½¥AF��

-*B|-A-��T�_[.{|;���B����tK�¥AF�;��D�%&4u�4

�7+J���L4tE-�T,§=�¨4�T+J�� 7��T,L4×ØÙÚ��Î�J

�§�"¨³-?4FA�L4�T��K���ah��Í;�7½4§ëô¨³-?4 +�

´�´J���4§{�¨ø§=� �§�"¨ø§ëô¨43�4���EDÑ 2�J�tE-

Ï�4î��ÐAB��LBNB4î��J�Ñb�� B7S���L4î��9:;�%&

4�7+J��

� ¹s|�/ 3î�;-��§{� X§�"¨+Ò³AB7D�´�J�§çè'� �§'Þ'

� �§�TÚ]¢Ó¨,��Û�DK�?KD?ÔÕW4ú�%&4�7�;-��ß 2>,%

&4'�4�L���>,%&4���Õ������B�­ë;�%&4Ö#D��,�&�

'�D%&ã'��J���&�'�,%ß4gh�¶HC%&�u�4Ö�ÌD;�§l*�

<¬&�'�¨+JU�%&ã,��>Þ��¸Û³D;�§&·��¬%&ã¨+J��

� 7)���4/ 3î�4�´,���4�áâ�tK�%�-KL�5*����&·��×

+rs|��B +4tE-Ø,4�����5b�ÙÚ;�tE-���� U{�4���

²0;��D��T�u.4+,-.���CFA�=�4�T�9������±²³��Û

;��D�;-��Ø,�­C4%&�Ü��L4�7��7;�D�º½AB�tE�-K�

�7�ÑM4§&·��¬%&ã¨��/ 3î�FA/ 4î�� 7�K�üu�*AB���

4,�L4�D�������V]4��~�+,�=)�§��¨D§�^¨4Òx��~¥

-?4�[�D©E��yzÜj+rs|§��¨D,§=�¨4?4�¥AF�;� Ò;�

+J��D�þB�,-A-��

� IA��Y�FA4¯°&·��¬4�"���6s����D4!T��T�7ëôXR�

��Û³³�"��4ÝÞ�Ø�U��J���4tE-���­��py-��Ö#D��

,�������;k���� Òjßå<-3�´�´J��F���,C4�á'���

>+J�Òjà�Xáiá�'ë,�1990��§Organized Research Unit¨D�E ��â�

����ã�³-&�Ö#D4 ��^£�7����C�¦��?�à�4��"#,i��

©k<-&�X%&ãÖ#+,-.����X;k�X Òjßå<4tE-Â#³-��Ö

#��T�u����B�tE�-�)´E�.�â���BA4áâ4µ�D-�4F3EF�

à�|A.L4Í����U7�?4+J� 5)�

Page 42: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� �����

+� ���9:;#<=>?@�

�������( ( ( (

0�� � � � 5K��LM6� � � 5K��NOD4&E� � �

A������B)*CD�E ������!"��,-�

� ����9;�CR�Ü��ä�-;�D���C�¦*�%&4���34tE-üu�*

�J�4F�t.~F��Ñ 3 ,����4Ù$�ô78ð%ñ+J��� U56�56�9

���Çz�ÙA4����D�EtE-YÅ4ÂB��56FA%&l�J��,�ÇzFA

%&l-3;å��×s7YÅ��ÄwÚ4YÅ4ÂB4M+34.A�478�:½���

4F�Õ������B���D�+c,Ù$�ô78�?KD?�.�LBNB4;å��

ÙAå�)YÅ�ÙA�EçÓ�%á���D�Õ�����

Ñ 4,�CwÚ4���4M+�%&��ô;����478+J��+c,o±k���i

æ�äi*¨-34¸yCD�ê+��478�CR³���%áç����rED��Çz+

4��"#�"�+J��D�Õ�����Ñ 5,�%&4��YÅ4E��56FAØ7YÅ

478+J��+c,�4Ñ�FA���U�èC�i�±lÌD�ê+ÇýüÊÌ� �é;

�� 7�Ñ 64�ÇzFAØ7YÅ478+?�ÇýüÊÌ� +J��

�� ��� �

�� �

�� �

���������

�����

!"#�$��

%&�'#�$��

�(#��

)

���

*+,-.'

����

�/��

012345

���� 678��

9::;<

=>:;<

Page 43: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� �����

� �û4Ï�4�ÜFA���U�+c4���4¢£,�CR³���DF-U�4-?4+

J��D�~F��¹s|�Ñ 3+,;å�^4ê7U¢£�^��D�Ñ 4Ñ 5+,56

FA%&l4���ËY��-��D�Ñ 6+,�&4B$¢£�ú��D�Õ�����?�

´ê�+c4�����L4?4� ���ah�¹s|���D��¸û;��Å04¨ë

k<4¦v��L%&�[��D-3�DC4�����D4c¯�-�ì��-341&

?J���F�¹s|�CL%&.�â4��4M+�%&456FA4Ù¸XÙ·�º½AB

���tE)��CR³�,Ç?56®{Ó4ç�%&É�IJ�;+�+c�èK���4+

,-�FD©�B��

0� ����FG��HI�J�� � � � � � � A� ��������HI�

���PQRST(=>>7T(UVWXY(Z[X\Y[\(]Y^X[W_`abc(

(

(

(

(

Page 44: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� �����

� � K� ������LMCD�HI� � � � � � N� ������OPQCD�HI�

� �

K���R&�ST#TU�VW�

�����YZ�,���Y[�\]^_

� ��C4%&4��YÅ,�,CD,4-U�¶��w�IB�tE-òá¡~�ì�t��

���¸+JK7��µ&¶·�c¸¹4?D+­W��J���OP4ïÃq�"º�gk��

���µ���Û45º³���ð21 y� COE ÒʱJ-3ñ�IA�,�^FA4YÅ

-3���Ä���³YÅ4ëli<�%�.-U��J��%&ã&dí��å��>�­

;�Í�³Gî����?��¬4áâ��AB�tE�-K������ 7�LBA4YÅ

�¡~;�7½��3ä��4���½�I � -¶·���B����

Page 45: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� �����

� �4tE-M+���C4&·��"#�­;�YÅïHÉ�IJ������-.D?ð³

�,�Y�����¡��ïÃq��ÑAB�tE�-K7DrstE��F�-�A��BD

,­ñ³�������4��Y ð��"¯�ò4óè50��<���Gî�r�^Y

 -3ñ����,� ) )�`~-T��AB�4+,-�F�L����4���DP4

��Y D4B#Ò4ôI����"#4­Q�¡�.õ(���4+,-�F�J��,�ö

³DIB�hÓ����YÅ4÷û"ô�øê+��4+,-�F�

�û4tE-ah�T���D����4��ÊÌ� +,�ò� 12�ÓFA 14�Ó�F*

�µ���Ø�§��YÅ4ïHD����D49:����4£¤��¨��"�7ð/ 1ù

4S�úññ�

���`abcaVd-�ef��Y[

� £¤��4�ç+�ò� 14� 3û�wC4 4�h%&4'ë�ì'ëí 15,000��­î��

¢£¤��K7�L4Ñ�4 y,½4gU+J��/u��£¤­î>�� 2�J�tE-I

� -��Y 4E��@���Ó4��?4D��ST����FD�E�D+J���+

¥AF-tE���V���-34V]D�0&�O&-340]D+,�F-U��4-�

�D�~F��� U�V]+,����������^����u.>�²½�[��D�Ñ

(X»�­;���Ó����D-34�ü�J�4�­���0]+,����^���

D�ê+�¸ýXìfXí��åX%&ãd-34Gî��>�­;���Ç�²½�%���

D+J�� 7���"¯¯n4pyÓ?�0]�¦��,V]tU?�Ö����

� +� ��R&�ST!XY��Z[#�\]�

��������� ������������������� �� !"#$%&� �'()*� �+,-./(

���������� ������������������������ !" #$ %$ &$ '( )�*

��+, -./. 01/0 02/3 .4/5 .4/. 64/7 03/589��: 60/2 6-/0 6./6 60/. 64/5 .2/- 6-/2;<��: 0/3 0/3 -/2 -/3 4/2 7/- -/6=>?: 3/7 4/- 6/7 ./6 ./2 2/- 5/2@=?: 7/7 66/7 0/7 ./1 ./6 2/- 1/-��ABCA -/0 ./5 3/. 3/2 -/3 -/2 3/7��DE 2/7 2/4 5/0 1/4 1/5 -/2 4/-FGHI 62/4 1/0 ./5 2/7 2/1 6/0 ./1JK��L 5/5 1/6 .6/. .0/3 .6/- .5/2 66/6MNAOPQ 6/6 2/4 5/2 4/. 3/1 62/. 6/.RSAOPQ ./. ./0 -/- 3/3 -/3 5/6 ./0� 622/2 622/2 622/2 622/2 622/2 622/2 622/2

�T���:�UV���WX��YZ���� !" #$ %$ &$ '( )�*

[\]UV 36/0 32/. -3/2 -4/7 -4/- 35/3 4-/2V^�]UV 1/7 62/2 61/6 ../3 .5/. .1/. 6-/2UV_`� -/2 62/2 6./0 62/7 7/5 4/4 7/6abcd ../7 61/1 6-/1 66/1 66/3 3/5 -/5)�* 7/3 5/. 4/- 3/3 -/2 2/2 3/7efg 0/5 ./7 ./0 ./4 ./. 2/1 0/3� 622/2 622/2 622/2 622/2 622/2 622/2 622/2

Page 46: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� �����

� /3���|4��Y ¢£�áA-�98�����4Ðþ������34tE-KL�

Y�;?4F�õ�7D�´���B4~�+?�����¹������?Ð6;�Dïs�

����>�u�[���V]+,����,áA-�D¥K�ïs���>�0]����F

-UÛL��� U,����tU?���^�®{;�tE-i 4��"#D��<XÖ

ôX¨©�[.��-*B|�UL7-�tE-��"#D+,�Ù�D1&�4-�D�E�

�4��ÊÌ� +f÷����ahST��H*�tE-�����,����4+,-�

)´EF�

����gV#hid-����j

� /����û4Ýï4����~��tU� 7~�Ô4��>^+��ô;����40�

%�-�4�J�D�E�D+J��ò� 10�ÓFA 13�Ó +4 4�^4�£¤­î>4ò

ó���¦t2ò� 16 �4òó���40,�cÌ4� 1 4tE�-K��������[.

pyD;�~�Dp��?LED?rs-�~�D41&4��¥AF+,-�F�

� 7 7 ����P��§Ô�'�¨4 2004� 2û 22+�+�§���Ðs�����\A¨

D�E¿ÎJ�È�r�(��¦AB�� I�����Ø7U�4«P+J������þA

gDrE�?U,�-���Ðs��*������8E)*4�<Öô�IA�,�^�

��>�ns-�D�gKF.4�����½�*��D�-U,�-�FD«¡����4

,�3EA�)*+,-�A������4��²ô^!Í�48e-3,L4�Í47½

�÷û-u´D©�B���5º<=>%&4<F �JK�,�IA�÷û-fL��Qs

���+J´E�

N�^_����!"��:;�

21y��T��4eU �J��|�DC4%&CL���-3�³���9�¦*�&·

���M«D;���R�4É�IJð�B�§µ&É�IJ¨D�\�ñ,�%�-á��

�s����y%¢£4��yzÍ�4áâ4M+�1990�w��D.��µ&¶·DÍ�"

#D49:�tUr!�-U�µ&¶·&·��4�yÒ�L4����";�%&á4�

7�DC56�ÞÛ�¼½������C+?�1996�Ó���µ&¶·�c¸¹�º»���

|/ 3�¸¹4­4ý���4~�45º4�"�ÑAB���D�´+J���

���klmn %89�op

�4tE-»��­ë���OECD�CSTPðµ&¶·5º�(�ñ+,�2000� 3û��µ

&É�IJ�9;�ä��FåXÊÌ� �¯*��1) �³;å�4���9ð%&¦t2L

4P4�³���9ñ�¦*���"#4��H*�2) YÅïH4ïð��³YÅ4Ð%�¶

·�?D�.�T¡~-3ñ�¦t2 3) ���r4Þ�DK/D�E��4æh�9����R

³F�çè³-�°FA�M³�����5º³��ÎJ����Ø��D�Û³�����ú

Page 47: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� ����

½��7� 7��D�����DC�­;�äk��<£¤Cx�������ð��C

?L4­îC4u�ñ4�F��"���9;���åÉGF ð2001� 10û��Òñ���

YÅ�9;���åÉGF ð2002� 5ûõÌ*kñ����r�9;���åÉGF ð2003

� 6ûÒ��ñ-3�çè$��s�4"�-&#�U?��B��7��

�,�BA4����ä��FåXÊÌ� 2�/D��=�FAú6���7��2003��

ªK��ÊÌ� 4wxÑ�4Ǥ#$(���IB7���+,�L4#$(§µ&É�IJ

4²Î�L4æhD­ëðGoverning the Science System – Challenges and Responsesñ¨4Ô

b��B���OECD6�C�¦*��4ah�9;���1&¦t2%&�¦*���É�I

J4��v�����¦�7���

� ��c4��-K7ä��FåXÊÌ� 4?D?D4#$(,�18���7�cVDL4

éV( 4c�IA�+c,C-3DCx4�í�<�6s7F-U%�4?4+J��cV�

¦��,�µ&É�IJ�¦*�Ç�4áâD5º­ë��§µ&É�IJ4ï��D5º­ë¨

Dh��6�DC4fgÒ4ah��T�-�A ð������

���qrs�tu45�vw

L�+,�§L4µ&É�IJ�,�á;��D4=µ�Ð%������� D����4

=µ4���,���"#wÀ�­;�!»³-YÅïnD�E��B +�yDQsAB��

75ºæh�×s��7-á4#��JU��47½§µ&É�IJ4²Îð��+,

Governance D�Eô"�q�AB����ñ D�E�Y�����tUØ��g�4?D��

��"#4��H*��³���èl4YÅ¡~����94²ÎL��¦*���"#�t

��Td��Í��/���FA4yêl4­ë-3�I � -5ºÍ»�ç�:�ah��

DC�¦��«Uû(AB�����D�~#������

� L4R��4#$(�^£�����D,�Y�tU?[¬-°$9:>4yº�­ë;��

D+J��µ&>��4�I��56�6s���ÇzuÀ������%&-3+4��

"#�­;��tU±²³-°$9:>�-U��J���B�­ë������94¥+?�

��YÅ�K/;�)*+,-.�LBNB4��ÛÜ��º���B7�r�ïH;�D�E

�FÉGk�N�;��py-Ù·Òð��<ô��ñ�K/;�pyÒ�Ð������

uv564¸-�8,�§L4C$�è�³��Td�´µ�/è+��tE����ËY�7

YÅ�tUûX³���B�tE�;��D+J�� D#$(,��������,�����

L��Í��%&;�?4+J���D4Qs�Ø U�56,µ&É�IJ4²Î�J7K��

tU��¸±�FK���� 7��ÇzuÀ����4¥FA?�I � -yº�µ&

É�IJ�­��-IB��J��µ&É�IJ4²Î,��4tE-I � -°$9:>4

���M+��B-*B|-A-�4+J���4'U,���C�¦��?�CL%&4.�

â��³��YÅ4Ð6��AB�tE-»�4áâ�fg;�?4�J�tE�©s���

Page 48: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� ���

�����WX�xyz{|}~)�����

OECD6�DC,���C��½���û���7ïæh�­����5ÚhXÖ#4ï�

���*47½45º�ç4ï��³���9�³��"#l4YÅïni¨�ÇJ4ï�

L���4���³Y 4K/�����py-tu�­½��J���

7)��LBDD?��y-�D,���"#4/�è�Ò4ah+J���B,��û��

�7tE-á4=µ� U�tU[¬Ò�?K7°$9:>l4­ë��ûÒ�è7g�7½

�?py-�D+J���j©�4���iåÌ�YÅïn9«ÝÞ4o�-áâFAµ&É

�IJ��U�µ&É�IJ4!»Ò����4C�4Û\�óè�������³Y 4ó

è�?�½�py�J��� U,�I � -yê�­;�Ó±k��py-4+J���

� ?KD?�5º­ë4�g�L4û�4Ó8�,�µ&É�IJ����4L4CzÙ4Ò

��t�DD�´�%���D.��5ºÍ»4¯��M4çÓ����94Ù¸Ò4çÓ,�

DC�¦��%�.4-K����D�~FK��7�C�tK�,��BA4ï,�(­¸

±+�F���Ø-���P4C�¦��,�tUsc³-ï�Ñ2�.?4�[�)´E�

L4�Î+��4#$(,�DC��»45ºÏv)�*�H*�4+,-.�DC�¦*�Í

��ÙÚ;�MFA�@AF4úQ&#�L�FA���;�D�+��D�ET+��±J�

?4+J�DQsABtE��

� ��C�¦��,�µ&¶·�c¸¹4­4M+�§µ&É�IJ¨������=4ï

DïÃ�ÑAB��7� 7��á'�ïD�EðTFA,�%&hÓ4+µâ¼h,¡D

¶·hÓ48e�CL%&4.�â-3��B 7sc³-ï�ÑABtED�����OECD

4�4#$(���IB��D����9:>,��C4µ&¶·X&·��4u-4�Q�Ñ

�DD?�����IJD��4%&4 ; ;4q�����˵��.���?4+

J���

`ab�

1)� /c0u£¤§&·��É�IJ4ï47½4Y ¡~¦t2���rÞ��9;�§£

¤�� ðµ&���pìÅñ��

2)� ÷c1%§&·��4ïÃ�9;�£¤�� 1991�Ø2%&%&'���;k��úñ��

3)� �i�ÌXª3kÇ,���I��4é»�J7K���B +4tE�%&4��>�Ù

?��EtE-��¢¬ðÖ�� 1ñ�6s����,��³��Ç�%&4��>4��

I���KL�ns�tE-&�4Ö�� 25�d B���×+4%&D��D49:�á

â�6�K����D���������

4)� 2001� 9û 11+4,C��[�IÒ1e�d���yz4¦1³9Ü9:�^ U��J

U��B�µ&¶·�?}~-KL�ns�����

5)� Roger Geiger, 1990,”Organized Research Units – Their Role in the Development of

University Research,” Journal of Higher Education, Vol.61, No.1, pp.1-19

Page 49: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� ����

`cdefb�

OECD (1998) University Research in Transition.

OECD (2003) Governance of Public Research: Toward Better Practices.

÷c1X/c0u%ð2003ñ7%&ï4�|8�Û9�

%:;ð1999ñ7%&ï� 1945ø19998÷<=�

�i�ÌXª3kÇðÉ>Ûu?@ñð1997ñ7�w��D�4!£AÖ���D,@F8BÃ�

/c0uð2002ñ7%&4¢£µUD%&8jä��'����

/c0uð2003ñ7%&4¢£µUD%&APart28jä��'����

/c0uð2006ñ7�T��D%&ÍÎ8jä��'����

Page 50: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� �����

� 4 �� ������� ����

��� ��

���������� ��

��������� ��������������������� !�"#�$%

��"&'(�)�*+�,-��./01�2345!�678(9:;<+�=>

?@AB���C6DEB��#F ��B�G>�4HI��� 7��J,B��K�

�LMN���OP�<QRST'(� <�UV�WXY6B�:Z[<��\��

�\�] 7+^1�_`<a\� �b�Qc�B�:�����1�de�fg4hi6

jk<l!X(�67m?������1�defg4hi6jk���<���no'(

�67'X����pq �rC:st(6u�:�c�. v=>?wxyz�WXY6B

�:{|1����?��J,�<l!X(�67��8����}~�jk����:W

)��������C6;<+������,-��.�����no ]c�.�67

���� �1988 V 12 ����������\�K��4�B��������

������C6����Z>j���������O>V���������\����

h����� ¡�¢£���¤¥�¦§1¨�©����¤¥ª�«1¬­�%i6

R����4s. 79 1996 V�®�¯°'( ±�f²D³´µ�})�Q¶�±�f²

%·�¸<¹ºX(�»¼½¾¿½ÀÁÂÃÄÅÆPDÇ�ª¬�©ÈÉ�ÊË�������u

�<�(X( 7

1991V�ÌÍ�Î�B<BÏ\����2001V�9:�+Ð��K� Ñ�Ò+

��wÐ��y�Ó©��B<BÏ\4Ô � 7��Õ��:u����±4Ö�ª

¬� v'X� �����4u ��×Ð��uØ3'( 7

8�}~���"Ù\ÚÛ�ÜÔ �Ý´RÞ�ußà��(�6v�B±�áâ�ãD³

äåæçèé�Ý´Rê�}) 1990V��ë����ì\�K�àí��8~7

9î�����43c��R �1992V� 233ã:W. <�2000V� 346ã�2002

V� 376ã�2005V� 396ã��¨ï� 71992VzX 2002V9:� 10V�� 1.6ð

��)���ñ�R �1992VzX 2002V� 10V��O���ò�����u 2ð�ó�

�. 7

8�ÜÔ�������u�uôa�ì\�] 7���ñ�õ¿ÁŽ Qö\� 7

��÷ø�ùú4û6������5!6Õ�üý��þ�<¨ï� 7��������

��:����ñ��q�<�9.�67

� ��OP����uQö\��)����1òf²1Z>�����þ�<�i6��u

���O���OP��K� ���[ò��ò Å�¼Z>����<ô¨��67'X

�����1òf²1Z>�����~���ò��F��þ�<�i6*���±���

Page 51: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� �����

��?�f²���þ�<¨ï��678(9:����OP��*�1�������X(

] ��ò��F���6� OP�� 4�� 1����.�67

�2���RuUVôa�¨ï��6v�����R �1980V��ë��ä�¨ï��

67���������RÆ� 1Ç �1970�80V�� ��?���� :ô¨�� <�

1990V�� �6��!Ú4"cy�Ó©�� :ô¨��671999V���Qc�##�

���������R�5!6�����þ� 50%4$%� 78(9:��R<Qz.

���M�: ¨ï �rXz:W6<��j�±�ò��±�ò���©�8(9:��

����&'<():W6�'(] � ���ôa�����<¨ï��67

� �

� �� ��������������� !"��

� � 1975 1980 1985 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002

��� 9 13 16 133 147 162 217 256 295 335 369 461

��� 27 19 30 123 174 181 229 308 362 383 432 525

��� 354 457 497 811 908 995 1,163 1,242 1,319 1,343 1,376 1,415

��� 456 523 480 1,613 1,925 2,143 2,350 2,684 2,680 2,791 2,934 2,985

�� 136 193 237 509 587 641 694 745 776 819 886 900

�� 671 1,071 1,703 2,735 2,886 3,175 3,372 3,580 3,613 3,836 3,914 4,136

� � 4 3 4 4 2 7 11 11 11

��� 2 8 5 24 32 32 37 64 90 85 101 129

��� 12 16 12 24 29 29 34 41 46

�� 6 36 239 301 371 453 524 599 683 743 744

���������������

��� 1,655 2,290 3,004 6,203 6,979 7,716 8,543 9,434 9,770 10,320 10,807 11,352

��� 70 67 81 175 198 198 215 242 240 266 299 278

��� 53 54 86 178 184 207 191 198 201 227 224 226

��� 322 365 363 324 335 320 318 300 260 243 226 236

��� 530 663 924 1,396 1,372 1,268 1,230 1,250 1,120 1,173 1,021 936

�� 249 334 460 503 521 402 400 355 371 422 362 358

�� 1,700 2,466 3,024 4,122 3,896 3,625 3,736 3,511 3,212 3,217 3,048 2,717

� � 1 2 2 1 2 1 6 6 2

��� 13 26 18 52 53 64 47 65 51 42 64 62

��� 2 2 5 3 4 9 9 4 8

�� 4 18 88 90 114 116 109 122 151 122 139

�������������

��� 2,397 3,979 4,974 6,841 6,653 6,205 6,257 6,036 5,587 5,756 5,376 4,962

��� 79 80 97 308 345 360 432 498 535 601 668 739

��� 80 73 116 301 358 388 420 506 563 610 656 751

��� 676 822 860 1,135 1,243 1,315 1,481 1,542 1,579 1,586 1,602 1,651

��� 986 1,186 1,404 3,009 3,297 3,411 3,580 3,934 3,800 3,964 3,955 3,921

�� 385 527 697 1,012 1,108 1,043 1,094 1,100 1,147 1241 1,248 1,258

�� 2,371 3,537 4,727 6,857 6,782 6,800 7,108 7,091 6,825 7,053 6,962 6,853

� � 5 5 6 5 4 8 17 17 13

��� 15 34 23 76 85 96 84 129 141 127 165 191

��� 14 18 17 27 33 38 43 45 54

�� 10 54 327 391 485 569 633 721 834 865 883

������

��� 4,592 6,269 7,978 13,040 13,632 13,921 14,800 15,470 15,357 16,076 16,183 16,314

����������� ��������������������� �� !"#$% ���& �� '"#$()*+,��

8�}~��©�� :u��������b�H��24&'i6�<*+�,-��)

KKW678�8�4./�z��������01O>V�42�b�� ó:OPi

6��34<ó5��671 V�ó26� ��34 �1992 V� 36.3%zX 2002 V�

41.0%��.�6701O>V� ����Æ7nÇ3 V:W6<�b�n�489���

Page 52: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� �����

��4&'i6}~��. ���}~7

UV����«��:<���;���.]t!"#��<��.�6<�8(

�����K�u=ö:W67+^1�*Ti6��pq4>�i6 !� ��(X�H?

1�@�Ë4��i6�������ò���«�A14�:i68� �B³�m7��²p

q�s�4]cCDi6�<:W67ô¨� ��°F4¬E'F6 !��������

<ôG�H\i6��~�IuñºKKW67���� ���JK1���: �c�LN

1���<M#��.�6v

#�$%&'(�#)*+,-&./01�2�

����<ª���2��R<ô¨��6�b���������N1 ©�}~��

�X(�)����� ©�}~�OP<Q�'(���ñ ©�}~���ñp4R)�

©�}~�S�4è]�©�}~��å'(�6�rT~z7������C6��UV?

���ñ���ñp� ©�}~�()��<<W t.�6�rT~z7'X� ���

�������«4�:òXYòZ[�Yc !� \<l!X(6�z7

COE]Ä^À_��������2���%i6���]Ä`ÿ½: �;+�����

4hi6ia���±4bI�� ������%i6��±9äå���}c�����

�ñ4bI�� ���ñ��dò��pq�%i6äå�4­e��'X��Ý´�fg�

hi��j4s��B³�����������klÁ�������2��å��C6«

��:������Z[�K��m� 7

9î�2K�«�näå 2003V 6o7��s. 7����4YK;+�����±9 920

p�b��������%i6��±9äå�4qr� 7hst���R 470 p�th

4 51.1%:W. 78(�=�������7n���ñ4bI�i6���ñ��dò

��pq�%i6äå��äåu�qr4��±9�vw� 7x��±� ��NòLN�}

c��±�¤¥�yº 3BzX 40B9:�R�äåu4=z� 78,024B�qr�b�h

st��R 2,656p:�th4 33.1%:W. 72K�äå�th4 � 2�{��67

�j�W . ���� 4�N�LN�|}N��^N� 4K��~� 7���� �

�*):W67

�� N�j�±����±�������²��c��~��R� �9 <6�

L� N�L��M������c��~��R� �9 <6�

|}N�|������c��~��R� �9 <6�

�^N���^ò��Õ���}c��N��LN��|}N���R�9 <6�

9 �t�������4 3 K���]��C v�2��R�±���¸��Q�Rò�

¶4D1��~4s����<Q��������������~� 7

Page 53: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� �����

���«�näå�ï���B±�á�â�ãD³äåé���ñRg��Å��j�â

��f��'(�6�2��R4�j� 7'X�����H�����'( �

2002 V� 1 V����'( �2S�;4��òäå��S����S��9'�©4äå

����� ���m� v

� #� �������

���� ��������

��� �������� ����� � !(%) ��� ����� � !(%)

� � 261 170 65.1 4,205 1,576 37.5

� � 77 37 48.1 680 175 25.7

� � 582 259 44.5 3,139 898 28.6

��� 920 470�

51.1 8,024 � 2,656* 33.1

��-./012 &3--4 5 678��

3���45�678&���9:�

����������

�����N1 ���Ø3D1  4 ¡��������� ��¢� �K����

���£Ð���pq4s��¤ ��Õ������1�>[���i6�M#����

��g��c��D¥��6¦z��e4�~8�4N1�i6��¤°'(�6v� ��±9

�b��x��±�����7n<Ô ��6§þ�K�¨© 7���������K�

��~ª~��t�� � t��;L� 96.6%����F����< 75.4%����Z>j

����< 64.6%��.� 7����7n<������«:W6��íe��� �y

�Ó©;F¬S<��7�z��­ 4 �� 1 ��<����F�����K�®°1t�4

{��68� ¯N'(67

8(4��� ��°6���N: ����F����83.7%��<��~ª~��t��

�6<�LN?|}N: ����F����})u���Z>j����4±²i6�<Q

�78�}~��LN?|}N: ���ûX( }~������³��F���«���

~�´ µ(KKW)�¶�T�·�=>?���g4u¸! Qö����4��i6«�

¹�X(�67

�������ºnÆO���Ç: ����Z>j����4»°i6�<¼½1�Qc��

9?O��� ���Z>j����«��¹�X(6}~��.�67

� 3� ;<=>?78���45�6�� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � 9:;<=<>"?@

�� �� ��� ��� ��

�������� 83.6 69.2 73.0 68.2 75.4

�� ���� 97.1 97.7 96.8 91.3 96.6

!"#$%���� 53.9 74.4 74.7 51.2 64.6

Page 54: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� �"���

� �������

����7n<����F4¸! �¾�������«��¹�X(6�i(¿���

� ©�}~�¹�X(�6�rT~z7«����� ��� �ÀÁ:W68�4:ßi

6u�:W6��b����~ª~� 10.0%����� Ö��� ��e4hi6����

X(6a]:W6� 30.4%��z. 7¶�T����S� ���� ����,-�

]cÂÃ� ���Ô4{� u�:W6�� 47.6%����S� Äcuâ*Å4ÆXié

}~����Ô4{� u�:W6�� 64.3%��<»°� 7������ �£Ð�

*jº��������«4:ßi6u�:W6�� 84.3%��<»°� 7

8(X�ÜÔ})���� �u ?ñÇ4zC9�!óÈ ��É�b���'(6u

�:u��(49�!WÈ �!�?�Ê�����'(6u�: ��8�<ßXz:W67

¶�T���� ������ËÌõÍ�ü,Ù����\Xz�Î'�d°4' S�4 �

z�ÏÐ� 8�4u.�hg���1������«4:ßi6u��:W6���}~7

� @� ���ABCDEF� ���������

� �� ��� ��� ��� ��

��&'()�*+�,-./012345607�./0� 10.5 6.6 13.4 11.5 10.0

��&'(89:*+��;3<60 =>?@A0BC./0� 32.7 29.1 28.9 29.4 30.4

����'()�*+��D�EF=�CGHIJK���L3MJK7�./0� 47.1 51.1 45.8 44.0 47.6

����'(NGO7PQR3S@6TUVW���L3MJK7�./0� 58.1 67.4 71.9 62.0 64.3

��&'(X JKQ%Y��� 2JO�Z[345607�./0� 88.4 85.4 74.2 86.5 84.3

@���45GH&�IJK��LMNO+PQR�

������������������� !"#$%&�

������<¨����i6�<¨i6�K(�x�<��i6�2�«?A1�

=«�u�<��.c67W6��:��'(6����Õ���:��'(6����

«<]c¬�.�6�<Ñ9�c��8� �£ß:W6v

�8:���±9�b������7n�ÒõËÓÀ_�����A1�%i6£ÔÕÖ4

�uX. 7£Ô���±�ÒõËÓÀ_�£�<��i6����A1<�Õ��3a

©�}~�ÕÖi6z4¨© �8T��î(�K�u�t��� 7þº7��<�y×=

gr�ª~����� 7

� S� ���JKT�LUV5WX?YZ[D\�� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � 9?@�

�� �� ��� ��� ��

\\U)]^ 29.9 34.3 34.4 36.7 32.8

��_.``aWbO:0 49.4 53.0 51.6 49.0 51.0

�CGaWbO:0 20.7 12.7 14.0 14.3 16.2

�z������A1 ��:W6��¬�.�6���X(�6Æ� 5Ç7�����

A1 ���:©���¬�.�9iz���~«�����}�=g���� � ;L

Page 55: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� �#���

� 3þ��:W. <����:??¬�.�6�ª~���� � ­ 5þu�)]��

�:z�)¬�.�6�ª~���� �4ï�6��;L� 3�� 2��×67�

�������«?A1�¬«� ���� �� �N<Øu]�7�( ��N:

ÙÀÚ�_<�RW)��Û��������\<È( ��:W6z�K���O<Î'

�zX:WT~7�

� �'(��)*+,������

��±9�£Ô���� ��C6B³�����A14�ÍÜõÒ��Ýõ¼�¾�Þ�Â

Àß¼� 4Ò+�3à�uX. 7��ÜÔ�*á4{F¿�á�¿�ÍÜõÒ�3ài6�

B³��2 ��N: A1<���ÕÖ'(�6��b��|}N: �B³})uÍÜ

õÒ��2��<A1<���ÕÖ'(�67�

� � 1 ��B³��<���zX�B³��<â��4ã� Rê4 3 K���� �K�

�{��678(})�LN: �B³��2 äå 4 Ò+�=g:W6�íe'(�67

�z���N: �B³ ÍÜõÒ})u��<�æÅÄçÙ 3Ò+})uâ��ÕÖ'(�

67è��|}N: �B³���� ©�+})uâ��ÕÖ'(�678( ����H

:u�B³�|����é�4Éê.�6rT~77ë� 6��2S��4ìÆ'( �7

^ �� ���+PQR�

���

���

���

���

���

���

��

��

��

��

��

��

��

��

��

��

��

��

��

��

��

��

��

��

��

��

��

�����

������ ��

S���45�_`�&;<ab�

���-�./�

����������� ������ ����� ���������������

���� !�"#$%&'!(�� ����������)*���+,-./���01

Page 56: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� �$���

2�31���&����4./��561����78��9:;��<�&'=/>?����

� ��������@A��BC-.��/(DEFG�H1&��)*�-./I�J#�(K

LMNO��� ��������PQR=/���S��&TU�V�WX/�=/��Y

SZ[ !\]�^!/XYS_`�Z[IaG�bc !/XYa�=/def#g\&'=/(

�Bhi3G�����&�jklmn�"#op�q.��/(K

K

� ���012�3456�

UV���ª<ícH���ñ��q\<�9.�67�������zX����

9:*î�=*��b�i6ïż<Qz. <�2003V�â�ãD³äåæçèé�}6

��ðñ��·�üý� O���;L: 29.1%�����: 32.6%45!�67

��ñäå��Å�4T��������º��ò4�j� ÜÔ4� 6�{i7���

��ñ�óR�ó��<�=*��:W6v��Àß¿<â�y©�=*��<Qc�Àß

¿<��y©Õ�zX���] �<Q�7��� �� ��N:�Bô��:��õ

q<Q�7óR<=*�:W6<�O�����Õ�zX��� �< 30%42��67

LN: ���zX��9:ia=*���< 7þ���67��: O��Ù:Õ�

zX���] �< 19.9%u�6��b����: ��������õq�] �<

Q�7|}N:u�=*�< 7 þ42��6v��: =*��� 60%�öb1�

�c�����:���c6�<öb1�Q�Æ23.8%Ç<���: �=*��<Q�7�

� c� ���Ade��_�Lfb��?

��� ��� �����

c� d� e� �� c� d� e� �� c� d� e� ��

6BO]Q��� 49.2 55.1 51.5 51.1 69.9 74.5 76.5 72.8 60.0 70.6 83.1 72.6

f�g�h=ij� 33.6 29.6 30.1 31.6 19.9 12.8 9.2 15.3 13.8 9.6 5.5 9.1

��g�h=ij� 8.6 6.1 8.7 8.2 8.4 9.4 11.1 9.3 23.8 17.6 10.0 16.3

fk�lm.ij� 8.6 9.2 9.7 9.1 1.8 3.4 3.2 2.6 2.5 2.2 1.4 1.9

��ABCD"�E"F"GH���IJK%LM0"NO�PQ"RS��(TUV��

K

�7���89��:9.�

�����º��ò�÷� ��ñ���pq�uøù4���67��õq4�ø�

� ��S��%i6���Jú�n<ûc�6üý<ûX( 79 �O����^�õq

� �ñ ���G>S����������õq� �ñ O�S���%þ�<�96üý

<ûX( 7

�ñ����Å��¯°�Î � �}.¬�.�6v;L: �UV�F�ö��±Ó

r�< 6þUc45!�6<��N: ��£�£ý:±Ór�<6óR45!�679 �

;L: �� �UV�F<'O�i6�����*B�:W68�<Q�<��N: �U

V�F<'O�i6����� ¬�. �Å��4±��u 4þUc�678�}~���N

��ñ ����Å��Ø°zX�j1ò£1:W6��b��LNò|}N: ��ñ

Page 57: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� �%���

��������*B4��S�������A=���*B4@.�6v�����

�ñ ���S��%i6�Ã��?äåò­ø�Qc���4þ]���,��1£pq�u

��4 .�67��Õ��N��ñ �>?��·������ü��Qc���4 .

�67|}N?�N: ÍÁ��½�����<Q�<�LN: ÍÁ��½ ��7�

+���:���,���ø� �LN�|}N��^N��ñ: 8þ�ó�6<��N:

5þ�u� ��7�²S��ÏÐ�K� �LN�|}N��^N��ñ: 4þ�ó<

+^1ò;+1������S�ÏÐ��ø<W6<��N�ñ: +^1ò;+1�����

�S�ÏÐ �c��g��#�S�4ÏÐ� �ø�< 5þUc��.�67�

;L���UV�F���UV�bi6�E� ��:���u���9 ��Nr

<������ ��þ� t��� 85%��45!�67�

c���gh�

��S���u�4ia�� �K�° 8��W6j ��:WT~v­^�Ë�

�.°6��S�����S��9'�S��L��©(4�.u���}.�cy©¬

�.�6v�����W)z �j�ò��ò£�±�: ¬�.�)����Ô���,

-u]c¬�.�67�2S�u¼��Á<¬�.�6� ��� !:W67

��S�� ��}� 3 �~�,-<W)�~:W6v * ����QR��²S�4D�

�� �è]�T'( 9�#S�rCzX�6��]���S�Æ�N�Q�Ç:W67

 � �<N�¬�6�R��² �S�4D��� �è]�T'( 3à1��#S���

#S��D��. @�S�Æ<N�¬�6�R��² �S�Ç�}cì�S�zX�6��

]���S�ÆLN�Q�Ç:W67 ! �����² �S���u�4�2S�Æ#S�Ç

���8(�ì�S�<"�X(�6��]���S�:W6Æ|�ò���Q�Ç7

�����;<=>?���=@ABC�

'�­^���S� ©�}~�u�z���±9<ØU��� #$1������S�

�K���uX. 7� 7 �{��6}~���N: 8 þ�ó<B³ê:èz(�400

Þ%&Tn'(:)* 535+�H�ê: 500+�9':W678(�b��LN�|}N: �

B³ê�,ê�©·+ê�34 ó-:W67LN�%&�9' )* 293+�H�ê: 200+

��N�ó���:W6<�|}N: .!�c�)*: 94+�H�ê: 40+��.�67

� i� j���kelm%?45��ghno�

�� �� ��� ��� ��

no^�p�o 13.9 46.1 48.3 38.9 34.5%

���qrso(%)

tuo 86.1 53.9 51.7 61.1 65.5%

vw�xy(z)

(400{vwr|}~)

���

���

535

500

293

200

94

40

458

350

354z

250�

Page 58: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� �&���

� �DE�������;<FG�

���:)� 14 V����'( ���2 381 �:W. 78�~�H�����

'(� 364/���S��K��ji67364�H���ü0'( 1èg4��S��

� 2ü� � 5/:W. 7��|��������: �S��y�Ó© �����@

�'( S��3]4)45º ,:6�'(� 78(X�K� �88: Ý´1��

j stî�³&�Ø7:���mi6v

��;<=>�

IL�4"c�N: S��7R 77º7�Qc�0189u]z. 7M���� 6

7º7�3à1�7R<Q�7L� ­ 57���ò����� ­ 47:W67IL� 7R

<�c�y�ө�S� 3o4 7:��'(�67���S����7R ����})

u 17�óQz. 7

� 2 �B³ê:èz( ��S��9'Æ400Þ%&Tn'(Ç4{��67

�N��������Î�ò���: �)* 500+�ó�9':W67í��² ­ 440

+�LNÆL��M����Ç 300o400+�IL��|}N: 200+���.�67©

���� :u�S��9' .!Qö:�9�S�uW(¿��S�uW67����H�

L�: bIR<�z. !01894(ü����v9 �S����9' )*­ 700

+:�����})u 300+Ucu9c�.�67�

^ #� pqrUs\te��ghuv�

�&WW XYZ[\]^�

�������

������������

�������

��

��

��

��

��

��

��

��

��

��

��

��

��

��

��

���

����

�HI�JKLMN<OP�

� M��������: S��H����R<Qc�)* 60 �ó:W. 7����²:u

­ 50:W. 78(�b��IL��Î�ò����|}N ����R<��7 r��

���Î�ò��� 0189<]c����R<Q�S�uW(¿��<;c��S�uW

67��������S������ ���R�9<��7�

Page 59: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� �'���

��S��Ø7�:;'( ãTòì��ÃR ��NÆ�������Î�ò���Ç��

���²: )* 120³�ó:W. 78(�b��LNÆM��L�Ç�|}NÆ���ò

���|����Ç ãTòì��ÃR<�z. 7�����S������ ãTòì�

�ÃR� 9<�z. 7

��S��ãTòì��Ã��C6B³ê�Ã�,ê�©��Ã�R4äa �8T�IL�

4"��N: �ãTòì��Ã�H�B³ê��Ã<Qz. 78(�b��LN�|}

N��² �,ê�©��Ã<Qz. 7���S���})u�����y~<�,ê�©�

�Ã<Qc�B³ê��Ã<��7�

�7��Q;<RSTUVWX?Y���;<Z[X�

ó�Æ2Ç��j:�j��z. |���������S���<�K�=E��8~v

>?N���S��y�Ó© ���2@lS��}cì�S���<'(��#S����ì�

S���B�zX�.�67#S� ��2�@�< *1���.�6,���² ��

3]4):W6«���è]�T��S�:W6«�<W67>?|�: �º�<Q�v7��

«��è]�T��#S��7��R/��@�S��<"�X(�6v@�S��y�Ó© �

,���² �S��3]4):��2�@�< *1���.�6u�<Q�v8(X�@�

S�4D���è]�T��#S�<ÏÐ'(�6�:W67#S�<�A��² �S�

�3]4):WT~�è]�T�:WT~���î(�«�:u�Ø7�R/��ì�S��<

"�X(�6v8(X ,ê��²S�:W68�uW6<�>?|��«��B³ê�Bá�

��S�:W68�<Q�v�(X�;< *1�:W6� �X��v

'������Qö�4./���2S�����#S��9' ���� �}.C

+�]c¬�.�67�N��2S� �#S�rCzX�)�#S��7R<Qc�100

D�ó�9�S���.�67�( ���?��#g�6EÏÐ� �²S�4D�Ö

�ïÐOF'(è]�T'(�67�( ��N�Qc��2&'�<�2&'9:9�V

R4GC� 8��]�%H:WT~7

bÆ1��>?N�|����: �����² �S���u�4�2S�Æ#S�Ç�i

6u�<Qz. v#S� �Î'�pÞ: 2 I :J4'(�6�© 1 DW )�KæL

Q�<��² �S�:W6zX�RD�9':W67 r��|}N��� �LN�}~

��R�@�S�4D��è]�T'( ��]�#S�uW67

L�����M������������©LN� ��2S��Qc �è]�T��#S

��7�ì�S�<"�X(�6u�<Qc�#S� MÅ]Ä: A40R�D�9'��6v

i�45��wxyz{|}~�&���wx��o�

���01��\]^_`abcU�

��±9<ØU��� #$1������&'��� � 8�{��67�N ·+N

��Æy�Ó©<O�ñÇ�þ�<�c�&'��VPu 35Q���7�BG>7 11V���

Page 60: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� �����

��7n���7 5 Vó4�6����S���Å�4��� 6�7 V�u�67LN�|}

N �B³j<¼½1:�&'��VP 30 Q��:�����Æ7nÇ���7�)*­ 3

Vó:���4&'��67�N�LNò|}N: &'�M#�VR 2ðU�÷�<W6v�

� �� j���kelm%?45��wxy�

�� �� ��� ��� ��

tu�� 70.3 86.5 94.4 82.9 82.3%�� ���

p�� 29.7 13.5 5.6 17.1 17.7%

�� ���h�������(���) 35.2 29.6 29.9 32.4 31.8��(30)

������g����� 5.6 3.3 3.6 3.6 4.2��(3)

���$���� 11.1 6.7 6.6 8.9 8.3��(6)

)����3�[�=��JO��� 6.7 5.3 4.1 6.2 5.6��(5)

� �01��\]deX�

í��01O>V��Æ*+ 3 V�|�R|N 4 VÇ:�����&'�Sg��K��

��±9���ñ�O°4T�û v� 94°6���ñ ©�� :u��U�i(¿Sg�

<ØuQz. v�z����±9�O° � ��]�9<W. v|}N: ����Sg�

�t�� �< 60%4ót.� <�LN��^N: �U�i(¿Sg�<ØuQc��N

: �()�<ØuQz. v«�n�t�� �ñ �§��ñ:�8(zX�24&'i6j

:W6zX��2&'�K�VÑ1WX<Y!X(�6zu�(��v8(�b����±

9�t� �9V��ø�DZ� [\�]^ÜÔ�_�}~v�

� �� �K�����U45��wx�

� ��� ��� ���� ���� ���

� ���x� �� �� ���x� �� �� ���x �� �� ���x �� �� ���x� �� ��

����� 9.8 9.9 42.5 29.1 60.4 37.8 20.0 16.0 31.3 25.0

������ 41.0 59.9 56.0 62.0 35.4 57.8 60.0 67.9 46.4 60.9

��� 49.1 30.1 1.5 8.9 4.2 4.4 20.0 16.0 22.3 14.1

� ��� �K�����U���wx���?���;<=u&�_�����QR�

��� ��� �����

���x ��� ���x� ���� ���x� ���

������=��W���L3�_�= 612� 71.5 86.4 85.2 90.5 87.2 90.2

¡��¢��£x:K¤¥¦=h_£��012� 38.8 60.5 8.3 45.5 9.5 50.5

§��¢����¨©ª£«6¬012� 45.6 49.8 33.6 36.1 29.1 40.9

­���® �Y®¯°3±K6�=h_£��012� 43.0 61.0 58.5 60.2 24.4 51.4

²���&�©ª£³´W12� 23.1 43.8 4.3 30.6 5.9 32.3

µ���X¶����·¸£³´W12� 43.9 55.5 32.5 44.3 31.0 48.1

¹���hº�»¼��½£¾¿*./012� 57.3 44.5 56.7 45.9 36.5 40.3

À�f�������2QÁJO:W:12� 30.1 37.0 39.2 40.0 25.8 32.0

Â���&���ÃÄÅ��ÆÇ£È:12� 45.5 40.9 62.9 47.3 51.2 47.2

�É���X¶�ÊË£¾¿*./012� 66.0 69.3 75.4 69.1 71.4 65.8

���ÌÍÎÏÐ3JWÑAÒW@W:12� 38.0 44,4 28.1 25.0 35.7 41.9

Page 61: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� �����

: ��`�01O>V��:������&'<)���rT~zv� 10�}(¿�;L�

� ��S�6��M#����Ô4n���üi8����£�£ý��L<a��:W68��

<ØuQ�v�N�LN: ��S�2ü�º2¡�4� i����<zz68����B���

D¥1�d<a��:W68��<Q�7�N: ��2S�<9� !ÏÐ���<zz68

���LN�|}N: ����&'�N0b��Oc<��8���©<;ÈX(�6v��

�N: �Qc��ñ<���2S�<9� !ÏÐ���<zz68��4;È�6v

����45�_0�&7A�YZ[D��GH�

�ñ��«�bi6ÕÖ ���±9�}6ÕÖ})u�ñ£ýÆ��NÇ�}6£ÔÕÖ

��<»°1:W67;L��ÕÖ d���_�}~v��·+ê4ècòeig����

1de�����7n�ñ���;L1�«���. ��:ÕÖ<â�Æ� 11Çv

����:���pq�Øu§Ð.�66E��� ��NLN�u�O�S�� !��

����B���������O�����>���B���G>���:W6Æ� 12Ç78(

���:��ã9:�,ê��d���ã9:��d���B�������ò*����<Q

�7�

� ��� ��45�6�_0�A)[Z����&�y���

�:_`>a:b#>"?�

��� ��� �����

���x ��� ���x ��� ���x� ���

1.p�o(Ó?Òno)3ÔÕ12 26.9 36.8 36.8 34.9 29.7 27.4

2.p�o(Ó?Òno)3ÖG12 7.6 12.7 6.6 11.7 11.0 7.7

3.p�o(Ó?Òno)3×612 6.5 14.6 4.4 9.1 7.7 5.1

4.��ØÊÙtuoÚ 29.6 40.8 20.6 27.9 15.4 24.4

5.!"*+�Û; 33.9 23.1 40.0 22.0 34.4 13.2

6.���Û; 18.6 24.9 11.0 23.7 12.1 16.0

7.ÜÝÊ 25.7 33.8 32.1 33.9 25.3 21.3

8.��������2JO����Z[ 25.0 24.0 28.6 20.4 26.4 16.8

� �

� �#� ��45`���GH ����o��_ ������

�?�

�� �� ��� ��� ��

1.f����K¤��� 95.3 94.0 66.4 93.4� 89.6

2.f�hº�Þ$ 88.4 69.5 51.5 73.0� 72.1

3.���ß�àáâã 62.4 58.1 37.8 57.4� 54.7

4.��hº��$�� 66.2 78.3 55.0 66.0� 69.5

5.��hº�!"�ä 80.5 83.1 83.0 80.2� 82.2

6.��hº�no��½ 50.0 46.1 47.2 51.9� 47.7

7.��hº��påj 35.6 33.7 35.7 35.4� 34.7

8.��hº����äkQæ�ä 61.2 57.5 59.5 66.3� 59.6

9.��ß�àáâã 44.6 46.7 43.4 47.2� 45.4

10.«çè.�no��½ 59.4 62.9 68.5 61.7� 63.0

11.«çè.��½ 52.2 67.1 54.2 62.3� 59.8

Page 62: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� �����

����45�_��_a�

t���~�B³�²fg�����FÆDCÇ�hT'(�6� �tîz� 5%�:W.

7� �� LN<Øu�z. 7hTi ��zXW6�� jk'(68�� ���

.!)%:W67�(:u�­ 4þ��ñ �PD? DC��U�i(¿hT'(6����

� 7�

� 9 �t��W. �����ñ�­ 3�� 1<�b�lÅmß^òÍn¼�ß½ÆTAÇ4@

ð��)�6Eu¸!6�­ 3�� 2< TA��ø�:W. 7��t��� 2þ�<�b

õ ÅmòÍn¼�ß½ÆRAÇ4@ð��)��ø� 3þ��:W. 7�

� ��������ñ�o��h��pü�ùú4??qr�ëaû}~v� 13�{��6

}~��t�4' �����ñ;L�o��h� ­ 21st�pü 17stu:W. 7�

z���( �ñ����}.z�)¬�.�6v

9î�h�4Ø3���û6��+Ð20s5vt�@Ð18st�wÐ22stx��wÐ +@

Ð�3a2stzX4st���c�.�6vh���� �+Ð O�ñ<Qc¸9(�

68�4./���Báy��zy{�ÆO�ñÇ�<Qc�@Ð �B³�,��y���

<�wÐ �|zX�}~��ÍÁ��½�����LzX�y���<Q�7��� �� �

�N ��Báy��zy{�ÆO�ñÇ�<Qc�LN �|zX�}~��B³�²fg�

�y��Æ��Ç�<Qc�ÍÁ��½� ��7|}N �ÍÁ��½�<^r.Q�7

Õ��pü �Ø3��� �+Ð ���ò��¸�<??�c�wÐ ��>fò�Q��

��*¸ò*�¸�<��v��� �� ��N �O�¸��|}N ��>fò�Q����

*¸ò*�¸���¸����ò��¸��©Qc��N:pü<Q�v

� �3� ��45�_�`&��� ¡y� ������ � � � � �cd3ef�

·é ê !"*+ê� ���

� � � �� �� ��� ���

������ 24.2 22.1 18.2 29.3 20.7 26.7 23.9 22.5

������ 55.5 50.8 36.3 68.1 44.1 17.3 152.7 32.8

��� 35.5 32.5 39.2 40.2 34.8 34.6 36.7 41.4

������� !� 54.8 56.2 63.9 50.2 53.8 62.2 39.5 59.1

�� "#$���%!&'()� 8.6 12.0 10.0 2.1 2.9 14.8 5.6 0.0

*+,-���� !� 5.0 4.3 2.6 6.9 7.1 4.3 4.4 3.5

./0� !1�%!&2 3)� 10.7 13.2 5.5 7.2 12.3 11.8 6.6 9.9

4�5� 15.0 14.2 4.2 18.9 15.8 15.6 13.0 14.3

ë

g

67� 209.2 205.2 179.8 222.8 191.4 187.2 282.4 184.1

89:;<=!� 38.1 30.8 35.0 51.8 35.8 36.9 42.8 38.8

> ?� 9.1 8.8 7.9 9.8 14.0 5.9 8.8 10.5

@A?;AB?� 13.3 11.9 11.0 16.3 14.3 10.8 17.3 12.1

C?� 34.9 36.0 28.3 34.3 29.7 33.0 46.5 30.3

DE;FG?� 43.2 44.8 29.4 43.2 38.7 39.3 57.2 40.0

HI;J3?� 5.2 5.3 5.5 5.1 4.7 4.4 7.8 4.3

KL;MN?� 14.1 13.8 11.5 15.3 11.4 13.0 20.0 12.9

4�5�O?� 14.5 15.0 9.2 14.8 13.9 13.1 19.4 9.3

ì

 

67� 172.5 166.5 137.7 190.9 162.4 156.5 220.2 158.1

PQRS� 1,843 1,100 133 610 509 815 409 112

Page 63: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� �����

wÐ<+Ð�3ah�òpü�u2stº7Æ­10%Ç��� ��>f�÷�4./��

6�ªt(67��� �� �LN ­øg:Q���4./�zÍÁ��½ �c��

t.h�4B³�,�?B³�²fg��y��?y{��]cv���6v|}N�

��ñ ���g:�|�����}pq:ñ´4Ð�6�<Qc�B³�,��y��

4uX.�uh�;L�5!6þ� â�v

�����ñ� �L1� �BòO�zX¼½kŽ���� �<Q�<�O�ñ?��

juQ�7����h��pü43ài6����ù-� ]�÷�<W6v

��Ý1�ñ�i�t���BòO�zX¼½kŽ���� B³j�ñ �h� ­18s

t:����� �y��<­10st�ÍÁ��½<4s2vt�|zX��R)<3s2vt:W.

7Õ����j�ñ �h�31st:����� �°Zh�13st�ÍÁ��½10st:W.

7���t���25.8%<6E�Z>�ø4Y.� 7��j�ñ �����ñ�4��1

u5!�6v

Ø7��O�ñ �h��;L)* ­15str<�+¸O�ñ�w¸O�ñ: 9<W)�

+¸O�ñ 19st�B³j��Ý1�ñ�=gr<�w¸O�ñ 13st�6stuâz.

Æ�14Ç7w¸O�ñ�h���� ����L��BázX�y��g4�F5.7st�Í

Á��½<­3st�|zX�}~<1.4st��:W. 78�}~�â�h��uzztXî�

+¸O�ñ �t�cu�¶�>fò�Q�4�t©¿�X��7u.�u��>fò�Q�

­2s5vt�B³j�ñ})u1sty©â¶��.�6� ��>f����34�C

�6zX:WT~7�z���(�uzztXî�h�<��ó��>f�@<W68���

t�F ��*¸ô*�¸��¸���ò��¸�©;�pü4�)K!�64'��8���

67+¸O�ñ�w¸O�ñ���ùú��9 �W9)�u]��_�}~7

��@� ¢�_�����+£ ¤£�� � � � � � �cdef�

ë� g� ì�  �

�í �í �í �í

î�@�ïð� 0.9 14.4 Þ$ñkòóô� 2.4 24.7

ÌÍÎÏÐ� 5.2 31.4 f�í� 9.7 8.0

¸#� 0.0 4.7 õöíkö÷í� 14.0 9.4

tuänø�ù�ô� 0.0 0.6 úí� 40.4 29.8

tu�ûüýøù�ôÙþ>Ú� 0.0 1.1 ��k��í� 48.3 34.9

�_���@�ù�ô� 0.0 33.4 ��k�í� 8.9 4.8

��ù�ô�ù�ôÙ ��Ú� 180.3 23.7 ��k��í� 9.1 3.7

)��� 2.5 18.1 )��t�í� 20.1 11.6

�� 188.9 127.5 �� 153.0 126.8

������¥-¦§&�¨©ª«¬­®

����QfA_`gR�

��� �Qö���ò��±��¤?�s�©�})�Qc���±:�2S���å

¬�.�6v;-�äå: �(X�;�9: ßXz�i68�<:]�z. <�*�1�

Page 64: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� �"���

�2�å�]Ä�¼ ���� 3:{i}~�j£�å�³�å� 2I�:st(�6}~:

W67p� �?��±�}.¬�6<�88:�~j£�å� ��¢�2:��å:W

)�³�å ��±;L:��å:W6vj£�å�I�:,��4s. )��¢�F��:�

�i6«�uW67� ¡ �½_��Å� ¡:W)�³�å})uj£�å��<qr:

­«1��å?��ó�UV4s.�68�uQ��ªt(6v�

^ 3� 45��¥-z{¯°�

�¢������ Ù��Ö(��Ã�(�¢��k����(�¢����^3® Ú

� � � � � � � � �

������ø·é Ù! ^.!�k"�#$�%3&¸Ú

���� Ù������ø.��60Ú

� � � � � � � � �

�¢���� Ù��Ö('(Ö(��Ã�(�¢��(����()Ý��(�¢����(

Þ$ñòó45Ö^3*+ß® Ú

� � � � � � � � �

à��, Ù�����ø^(u����ø·éÚ

� � � � � � � � � �

�¢��E-ø

����ø=U0�,

Ù!�2����£ .JK�/�0.(���E-2[123Ú

Ù!�2����=U0�,Ú

� � � � � � � � �

�¢4�,& Ù�����ø^.(��56Ö378�9(4�:;Ú

�¢Þ>Ùf<=Ú

� �

�����56

�¢����> � �ø?Ö@2��óA?Ö@=® yA(BC=DyA0

� ���;<hijhkl�

��S�4��'F6� ­�Qc�¼�ç]4 9�C(¿�X��vó��:{� j£

�å�³�å �­ ��ñ��.��24&'i6 !�Ø7�I�:W6v�¢�:st(

6j£�å�8¡¢C69:���ñ j£�å��@�M#�¡�4� ��z�C(¿�

X��v­ ��ñ��.�88�£69:<Øu��4#i6�:W67

���4&'�}~�i6� �*+���S��HIB�4�i���Ô<���;+1�

��g:�å4�C�OPW6×{1������Û:�¤í4�C�z�C(¿�X��v

á�¿��S��*BÆW6� ;BÇ��6##���<����:��,�'(� )�

kÂõÅQ]�²S���������'(�68���©:W67������2&'�

�*+�ê�g�<*°A1:W68�uM¥�'(67���� ���÷4�C�6

�:�"'(6<�S���: ·+ê�÷ø4�C68�uW67

��S�42üi6�º����:���,�4¾[ZC�6��± ­ 3�� 1��c�

65.1%���± ��,�4#������7�z���² ���S���4#����

Page 65: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� �#���

6��± äåbI��±�­ 4�� 3�u�×67��S��*B��6���Ô<���g

��² ���å�����­^���'(�68� ��·� !��}6�å4�C�

68���6v�2&'�º2¡����kÂõÅQ]�² �����*B4��'(�6

� �W6�<��� �2S��«4@�i6 !�*K�ËI��:W6v

�7�fAmn:�

�����S���å¦F��K�¨© 7��å¦F�4Øâ\j:/�i68���.

�9iz��¨© �N�b� ��3j�<ØuQc�í��4j���5j���.�67

��å¦F��H��Õ§¨W6� Õ�¢��F<ìï�9iz��¨© �N: ��}c

W6�51.9%���]©]�32.2%����þ�:Õ§¨òÕ�¢��F<�å�ït.�67�

8(�b����å¦F��H��Õ���F<ìï�9iz��K� ��}cW6�

14.8%���]©]�40.0%��©9)��y�Ó©���< 45.1%45!�67K9)�B³

���: �S���å�Õ���F<ìïi68� W9)��7��S� �*K�

��:�Õ§¨òÕ�¢��F4ï� �å¦F�:�åi6ïż<Q�7�

¤¥��ò��±: �©ª���±ò�¢g�«¬�<'X(68�uW678(X�

�1·B�� �ðñ�¢��å¦F<Ò�Å:]��B��UV?�å4s~rC:�c��

å�]Ä�¼:��NQ§���§þ4uÔ i7�

�z��Τ¥��ô��± �F�­<®c���W6� ��±���1·B��4¯�

�(68� )��v�i(¿�,+�°¿¼�űÁò°^²³±Å�}~��Õ���F4

�å¦F�ï�68�<��X(6v r�8(u­^�­ei6��6�� )µ��C(¿�

X���<<W67S��å� ¶R::]6��u��å�?Ø·÷��ü�i6 !�¸

�?¹º»�«� ¼¸�ËðuM#:W6v9 ��2�å V�½�iHi68�<Qc�Q

���n�Õ���F�E4¾¿F�C(¿�X��7�

mt�äå:�Õ���F4�2�å¦F��¦F�vwi68� �c��·�4vw

i6� �S���Å�<é:W6�z��º��UV4�� �F<Õ��õq� �

©��. «���X(�6�_�}~v�

�o���;<fApqX�rst�

��S� �¿K~=*�� 3�4 j��å¦F�}.�å'(678�~�*j<��

S�4ÏÐ� ��ñ�UV�F:W)��å¦F��#å��67�å¦F� �©ª��

¢?��±��F<�.�68�uW67�å¦F �2ü'( ��S���<4}cLÀ

��6ðñ�����!¿z):W67�

�z��3�4j��å¦FrC:���@F:Áð�ÕÖ<:]6�rT~z7��� ���

���ËÌõÍ�ü,Ù����\Xz�Î'�d°4' S�4 �z�ÏÐ� 8�4

u.�hg���1������«4:ßi6u��:W67�å¦F �S�#Â4�û�

N�º�2ü'( ��S��*þ�ì�S�4�û�'X���,��:�,��<�«Ãy

Page 66: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� �$���

��Ø·�å:���÷������@�W. ��<�àz��6E��s��4 9�

ó:�Û�×{1�ÂÃ4��68�4í!��@�<*jº��������«4£�

�68�4]°��C(¿�X��vtîz 3�4j��å¦F�¬FÄÅ��rT~z7� �

B³�����C6�å� ���S��«4mÃç¿i6Q�Qö�ÜÒÆÇ_<W67

#å?�å¦F�]^4ÈXF�� !�©���±�u�ö-��¤<ØCX(�6v�

 *����S�42üi6�M#�¡�<°!X(�68�:W67á�¿����

�������±: �ÉÊ� ��åF�}6å�<W6;+1�����Øâ 2K�S�Æ�

1W6� Ð�1�Ç4@���z�C(¿�X��7j�±�N: �����7n 3V�

:8�¡�4� i8� C+�)��7LN?|}N���±: ��2S�Æ#S�Ç�H

?4�i�²S�Æ�1W6� Ð�1�Ç<��'(�6 ��¡�4QC�6vi�t��

Òkß½Ëß�ßÞ�hÌ'(�6 �:W68��¤ *°�ó� SCI��ßÙ¿½ÂÍ¿

�ÅÆIFÇ4uK �:W68��IF< 10002��� �:W68��©:W678(X�#

� 2ü'( S��##B�<��Õ������}6�å�}.*°A1�ó:W6�

í!X(�68�4#li6v�( ���S�<��º��t¿�·� !��}6ÕÖ4�

C�68�4OPi6v�

 � ���S���u�:W67��S��H?4�i��<�ÀÁW6�² ���º�

��'(�6��u�������² ����'( S�<�Î��2�@�£ý�}6

×{1�ÂÃ�}6u�:W68�<{'(6M#<W6v#S�<�1S�:W6«� �<

��v�< �#S�<�/:��zuA=��:W6«�:W67A=���«���8:

��2�@��j�×{1ÂÃ��<<W6v ��Ð�1���.� ��u��@�<�

����b�×{1�ÂÃ4��68�4:ß��C(¿�X��v�

��S�<�#S��ì�S�ò%þS��©zX��'(�6� ��@��A=��ó

�×{1�ÂÃ4:ßi6 !:W678(X"Q'( �R�S�����àz��@�<

Ð�1���.�68�4{i8��})��2S����<�àz��@��8(9:��

���Ô�}6u�:W68�<:ß'(6�:W67�

�z���(rC:�<<���À¯i6tC: ��7£�±�?|����: ¤¥�

��mÅ_:A=��<st(�10 p42�6A1��}.ÏÐ'(6S�uW67«��

}. ��2�@� ������]�ÂÃ4� ��u�Ð�1�:��8�uW6v

8�}~�«���2S��@è��A1�;FzXðñS�4�2S��#S�ÆW6� ì

�S�Ç��2üi68�4í!6¤Ïè4"Qi6��±uW67�

 ! �@J�:W67Ø·�åI����S� ��BÐ: 1Ñ���@J'(�r(:

u�(4��i68�<:]67'X����S� �+Ð+��è���Ò'(�ðñ��

è����'(�����'(6vS� ��å�ÓHrC:�c���'( 7:u�·B��

�}6°��6ÕÖ�'X'(6�:W679 ���±���:���f��qr'( �

�S�Ô# ��2<��'( 7��zXJ4@A'(6v�2¤Õ  8¡� ����c

�2��$� �����24��� �] �ðñ����24��� BzX 3����ð

Page 67: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� �%���

ñ����2����·6S���<�#Â�cS��å�ÜÔ�#Â4@�i6u��i6�

�°!X(�6v�

8�}~���2�@��×{1��²1ÂÃ�×Ð� ������g�4:ßi6 !

����±���� �Q�Qö�«�XY�ÜÒÆÇ_<W6v9V��UV�W . UV�

�<�å¦F��#å��68�<Q�<�#å��å¦F<dF��å4s~ !�ÁÅÁ<

6X(�6v� �����}~�d��ÁÅÁ<W. ��u��Ö�u��:W6� _

���vØ·1� ��å¦F��eW6]^�×Ø<l!X(6v�

±²³h´µ�

Berelson, B. (1960) Graduate Education in the United States. McGraw-Hill.

Bowen, W. G. & Rudenstine N. L. (1992) In Pursuit of Ph.D. Princeton University Press.

Clark, B. R. (ed.) (1993) The Research Foundations of Graduate Education. University of

California Press.

Clark, B. R. (1995) Places of Inquiry. Research and Advanced Education in Modern

Universities, University of California Press.

Goodchild, L. F., Green K. E., Katz E. L. & Kluwer R. C. (ed.) (1997) Rethinking the

Dissertation Process: Tackling Personal and Institutional Obstacles (New Directions for

Higher Education, Number 99), Jossey-Bass.

ñÙÚÆ1995Çâ �°ß�l¼½4NUi��O�éÍÁ¿7�

ÛÜÝÞòßQàáâ/Æ1995Çâ�������éãÜ�ü0B7�

H������Æ2005Çâ��������ä+^1�å�W6������æ�ýCäé

�B±�á7

çBÚ�Æ2000ÇâÍÜõÒ���KéÌè�ü0�7�

Page 68: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

���

���� !"������

Page 69: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� �����

� 5�� ������� ����∗�

���� ���

��������� ����� ����������������� �!"#$%

&�'()*+,-.�/���0�123�4+(5"+���6��78�9:;:<=

>�?@AB&CD-E�FG3�HI +&JK:LMN;:OP�� �QRSTUV9

KWX��YZ[\]^�_�B�EB#`a+&'b+C��cd�efPB&CD-ghi

���j�klXcd^ Cm.BnhUo:pAB&',��qrsDth�uv,Dwxy

#nh���z{AB&CD-���j 15 |kh������}~������uvqrsD

. ����&C#����������#��D 1� 2�|k��������q���D_

�h�D- .������h�����12�6��DC����j#�C&�����C

,f�������Y#�,�_Y������� ¡ho¢£LJN:�D¤m�¥0¦§

¨��_Y���#�C&EB©ª«¬+&CD �­C®C-

� �¯h��.Bnh�_Y#���q°±+,}~²³q´ns&����j�kl<JKµ

#��D���q¶·�Dz¸ �¹ºª�¤m�i�h�DO°±�D-E+&EB��_Y

��� ��Y#ª�¤m#��D�O#»C&��Y�p¼i½f&�����¾q¿À+�

��Y�ÁRÂõqÄÅ�+&�',C-E�,f��Æh�.m+,���qÇ5�D,f

#��YÁRÂõ#­È�D ÉÊ#�1997ËÌ�ÍÎAB&',]?ÏqgÐ#�ÑÒ�.

Bnh#Ó[+&',kl#��D}~²³qÔÕ�D-n,�E��¾ Ö�#»C&­È�

D i#�×Ø�� 21 ¥Ù������#��D����kl�Ú#»C&ÛÜY�p¼O

P°±�D-

� i ¤��ÝÞ6��kl<JKµ�klcd<JKµ���6��ß�àá�Àâ�ãY�

.Bnh�äå�æçèé#¤%&ê�D. #�ëìABDí'h���n,�6���OB

,îTKLJïX��Yðñ^�gh�òABDí'h��m-E�2ó#�..h�ôõ��

6��klcd<JKµ�ò�ôõ#ö�q÷ø�D. �h'B�ùCh�D-

���������� ��������

���������� �� �������� ��

� ��Ò�}~�D2ó��6Å� +&������#�C&�ú»�ûZ�ü�OPýþA

B&',-������¹�ûZ�����DJ�:L�Xholy spark^ûZh�D-��Ò�À

�#�s&�y���Y7�Y�� �ª ����(�}~��#���D-}~Ò��

i­sD.m+,���k���t��#C n��C-.BP�k���À�#�s&y

OP��6� ����(�C�������Z#��q�C&CD-

� ¹���ú�ûZ����YÔ��Xsocial rewards^ûZh�D-��YÔ� ���KWo

����������� ������������������� !"#$"%&'()*+,-./

012(����������� �34567820069�:;<=>�16-33?�@ABCD0E

Page 70: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� �����

�C�_Y���#`+&>�J��q� #!"KWo��C�_Y���#`+&�#

£$J�%TL<&T�6'�D��Y<JKµh�D-��#��D��}~�(�3���

¹���ZY�ûZh²�æ» �B�����12Y� �)*zh��m-�¹�ûZ#+

,�%&"��D��Ò���ú�ûZ�6'�+,#OO�P-�FP�./Y�6Å�#¤%

&ýºY#"��D-E�,f./Y��6Å�#0�D��Ò#�1Y�6Å��)20

�D-

� C-B#+&i�QÁ9R���Ò��q34+,5"������}~#¤B�����DJ

�:L�ûZ¤����YÔ6�ûZ�¹7Y#r8AB&CD-��������9�Ê:�

;<#=>�D12?À��n�r@+�C��h������DJ�:L�ûZqr8�D�

#�%,-+O+�����#¤%&�����k�QRSTUV9KW�_�B�123 �

�cd�AYIB<JKµ�]?Ï�CBcdÏD��æ��Ek3�ª����������

D/h�CO#FGY����YÔ�<JKµ�q��#H�IJO������#?@AB&

CD-..h� +&CD����12�kl#��D��� ��K��.m+,���Y

Ô�<JKµ� )23���#�D�h�D-

�������������� !�

��6�#�¤����j12#�¤��DC����jFL#�¤�EiEi�E����

����Y#�mobilityX!�^#¤%&¶·AB�EBP�n,�M #NO�D-

P1#Q�¤m#�ÑÒ�34#¤DR:!R:����S��TUV:U#¤B������

���j�WX�Y!�Z[�����\]^q_( ��-O0.78Z ��Y#i% i�C

����`N:>#ÎDXQÁ9R�1.62Zh�¦�a�T;�3.53�¦��b<Q�0.54 -

+O+�i% cz�p¼��¥:Þ#�&��������55d� �`eY#�40:

OP·Ënh#O�&����fg�D. h��m-, s��QÁ9Rh�30-35h:�!�

G0.31Zh�Ìi�5hj�h!�k�l�+&���65-69h:h�1.15Z#nhl�+&CD-

¹����h�20h:OP60h:nh0.33ZOP0.48ZhW!+&���40Ë/h�-O0.15

Z+O!�+&C�C. #�D-¹7�mn#\f,7oi14R��ghp�#qC&¦�h

�D-

C-B#+&i�rst�ÀG�����h�u¥:qv+&;<?ÀqwO�Dkl<JK

µ�xyAB&C�COPh�D-��������12�z� ·Ë#$m���{�#=|

�D<JKµ#�%&CD-E�,f�QÁ9R NO+&��#}s+, ,~#�_Y��

�����D ­�BD-.BP�����#��D������j�klcd<JKµ�z{

#»��%&CD-���j�kl<JKµ klcd<JKµ ��ÞABDí'{-kl<

JKµ�ý +&Ýkq`� �D��klcd<JKµ��'(3�&H�Ycd ÝkYc

d�ú»��/q8»-E�C-Bi¦�Y#������}~���� �(��D-���

h�kl<JKµ�õôq�C�+�#+&klcd<JKµ��ò#�D Cm Cm��q

��+&CD-

Page 71: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� �����

��� ������������ ��!"#�� � � � ���������

(F -30� 30-35 35-40 40-45 45-50 50-55 55-60 60-65 65�- ����

��

� �� 0.09 0.31 0.53 0.73 0.84 1.00 1.00 1.02 1.15 1.62 38.3

���� - - - - - - - - - 1.77 -

��� 0.11 0.28 0.66 1.00 1.14 1.13 1.17 1.12 1.48 2.00 48.8

���� 0.18 1.00 1.05 1.21 1.88 1.39 1.00 2.00 - 3.53 -

��� - 0.22 0.10 0.16 0.24 0.25 0.29 0.45 0.50 0.54 26.8

������ 0.30 0.49 0.53 0.68 0.73 0.91 0.87 0.87 1.40 1.68 15.7

��� 0.23 0.32 0.52 0.59 0.55 0.62 0.78 - - 1.54 -

���� 0.63 0.93 0.91 0.91 1.22 1.25 1.50 1.04 1.06 2.42 -

� 0.14 0.35 0.54 0.58 0.84 0.96 1.13 1.10 0.96 1.52 19.5

����� 0.29 0.53 0.85 1.05 1.06 1.27 1.34 1.22 - 2.58 -

!" 0.44 0.42 0.38 0.33 0.41 0.41 0.47 0.64 0.81 0.78 54.3

#$ - 0.10 0.11 0.37 0.32 0.43 0.55 0.48 - 0.83 36.1

%& 0.41 0.37 0.55 0.78 1.14 1.39 1.76 2.42 - 2.69 8.3

���'� - 0.56 0.42 0.86 0.90 0.95 0.87 0.76 1.56 1.64 20.8

��� �� ���������������� !"#

$�%&'(��)*+, -./012*3456!%&'(789:;<"#

=�>)?+@A �B CD.!EFG"HI�2�J3)KLM?+@A��N�.!E&'(789.O4

P !"#

�<JKµ#�C&�EBP�<JKµFº�EiEi��}~²³ ª�¤m#���DO

Cm¼#�AÖ���D��..h�n-�kl<JKµ��¼OP���j�����_�

q°±+&�',C-��.Bnh·�+&',���X!�^ �����j��6�X12^

�@3Xallocation^ ��Xselection^���h�D-..h�cz��£Tï��.�@3

���������j����Dcd#¤%&�·ABD Cm. ��9÷ ABD. h

��m-�������� ����Dcd )23h�D. q..h��n-C�+&�'

,C- #­s��cdq$��C!���������YÔ��ûZOP��+&��}~�

(�3#���+�C-��D�'�s�����12z�#¤D����ª������}~

�(�3#���DOªmO�AP�D°Bq*z �D-C-B#�¤�.BP��ºY�°

±��q�f&°±+&�,C-

�rÌ#��Y# ¡+&�&i�¥0����j�¢£9Q¤²�������j¥²<

JKµ���}~H��S¦ÏD�§¨ÏD�kl����#¤%&�'(NO�D-ÑÒ�

R:!R:����S��TU�V:U34#¤%&14R�ç¡����j�¥:/!�q3

4+,-EB#¤B����Y#�,©�����Y��ª�����j�����DóCqQ

��Y!� E�¢£9Q¤²#��D¢£9QR:o#�D-

9Ò�¹�Y#��D������j�!�Z[q�D �����!�Z[�14R��gh

13«�¦�«�b<Q#qC&����¦i�C`N:>#ÎD-�Y�!��!�?@Z[�

0.78h¬­Y#�&¹Zq®%&CD-3¯q°sB��±[Z!��Dki²�(�C�h�

n%,(!�+�Ck�O���³ó#tDh��m-���TU`�h�1699´q`� +&�

Page 72: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� �����

¬­Ëµ51.4h�\]^�5^Ìt�1.5%�4^�1.6%�3^�6.8%�2^�27.3%��\]^�1

^���62.8%q¶fD-!�?@k�0.78h�D��K�#!�+�Ck�60%Ìt#tD-

·��¸Ò�¢£9QR:o#»C&�P1#Q�¤m#���#¤%&ê�D-.�Ph¹

ì+��B��P�C����¥:�!�Z[���¥:�?/#!�+,Z[h��(���

�˵#�ÅC&ºP�»SOP��nh�¼!�Z[�¬­qQ+&CD-+,�%&�¥:

�(�D©ª¬­!�Z[�l½�D¾¿#�D-+O+�¥:�12²ÀG�Ê:�)3q

Á�D�h�¥:/�OC�%T>N`��NO#¤D Â��X9�¥:¤�¸�¥:�!�

Z[��C^�CfPBD-

.�V:U34#¤%&���Y�p¼OP���¢£9Q¤²�¥:/�������ªq

N`Y#ÃÄ�D. �2'h�D-n-�ÅË?XÆÇÈÉ�30h:^gË?XÆ��

9?��45-55hÊ^Ë?X¸?��·Ë?�60h:Ìt^�¥:h34+&�D ���

�����j�¢£9Q¤²��ª��ÅË?�!��ÛA��gË?�!�G�²�AXËÌ

Y�g²^�·Ë?�!��ÛA�#�D-����.���¤q��Y#�D '�f&�ê

h�D. �ÀÓABD-��Y#�&¢£9Q�ÍÎ���1#QÁ9RÎ��ÏPB¤m-E

�¢£9Q>bÐJ�˵qÑJ# Ò+&!�Z[it}+&CD-.�U£>#Ó�D���

Ô£Õ�a:Jï�9Q�Ö×�ªh�D-�2#·Ë?#!�G�fl�C+Øl�D����

�Ì#Ô£ÕX65hÌt^�a�T;X60-65h^�b<QX60hÌt^�Ö×X60hÌt^

�tÏPBD-����2ó#�.�ÀG�ÙÚ#���Û�¤Ü�NO ·ËÏ#¤D�æ�

OP�æ �!�#¤D. �F[h�D-�3#���� ·� �!�G#�C&4+(NO

�D¼�Æ��OP��}5#O�&�Ê?#�D-

Òs��������}5�ÝÞ˵#�ß�Ó� ��ABD45-55h����j�!�G�

9ß ¸ßh© ~ª)3+&C�C-n,40-45h�55-60h �t� i#0.079¸hàth

�D-�� Éá�!�Z[��Cp�hAsgË?�!�Z[�˵# Ò+&t}+&CD-

.�!�G�ÙÚ#���}5Ê?�kl âó�Di���D-Òs���juº#¶fD�

� G�QÁ9R38.8%�Ô£Õ48.8%�b<Q26.8%�JSã:VT15.7%�ä919.5%�a:

Jï�9Q20.8%�p�36.1%�Ö×8.3%�£J�åN20.3%h��#¤%&n�n�h�D��

����54.3% �� G�¥0�¦¢æNq¶fD-�� G���B�Æ��OP��

�}5#�+C����çD��*èh�D-.��� G�³ó �Y!�?@k�N�qé

ê+&�D �ë0.49� ¡YCN���D. �ìCAB,Xíîï� 1996^-�����

� G��C©ª!�G�C�h�D-E�·#iKÂðQ G�ñò\ G�12²ÀG

!�Z[ �N�qef,���� G �N��¦iO%,-+,�%&����#�C&

gË?���Y�!��© ~ªó,����Æ��Ì�¤�i���Û(�O»Up or Out�Ú

�ªkl�ôõf�Ú�H�InB&C�C. �ö÷+&CD-i��~tø+,ÈùÏ�ª

��}~�.yH�����i�����¢£9Q���¤#�'(ú¨+&CD-

Page 73: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� �����

$���� %&��'()*+��,��

���"#$%&'�()*+,-�

û¸�����12#»C&êL^M �<ãQq34+&�D �1960Ë:Ì9�ü��ý

¶3�1980Ë:�þ��qgw +,}~��#¤D12�ob=L3�1990Ë:Ìi����

�#¤D}~��qgw +,12�u�3���4#�%&',-..h�³��D���j

kl�����nD i#�û¸60Ë#+&123 �!"#$C}~���<ãQi��

H ��H hÌ�#t�ê�çf,. �'�f&���C-EB ÉÊ#·�h���jÝ

k¢æN����#»C&34+&�D �¦×����C����'&CD-�n�?@AB

Dí'i�h��C��ÑÒ�EBq����j�c� �~hCD-

�¹#�ÅÇ�S¦�]?Ï#¤Dñò\S��JÔLXpost doctors^�COE}~jq�ç

f�Î>b�ãL裡qgw#K#Ûá3+�}~Ò +&���Y�¢£9Q�J�Ì�#

)�[#�%&����JÔL¸� S®#�/+&CD-������E��Îy��ÏD

�ÍÎ#¤%&�2005Ë���12,000kÌt��JÔL�CD��ºP���Y�L3�IB�

�~P�AB&C�C-�DTU#¤B��, s���������Þ}~j�]?���¸

#�C&�ò\S#�¨AB,Ò�35%# ªn%&CD-n,À3�}~������Þ}~

j�]?��Êhi]?Ïh�Cò\S ��¨��Éá#28%# ªn��3³#i�+&C�

C-]?Ï�¸#n,]?Ï�Jï � Sh��·+,}~�(ª.�O�(��i��C-

¹Z�]?Ïq7o+,}~Ò#�ò\Sq¨ì�D O�KÂðQï�=Lqæ:J#+,

]?Ï������¦»�[Ë/�]?Ï{��]?��Êh�cdh�L§¨ÏqIB�D<

JKµq�f#ìæ�í'h�D-¬²18ËD��ézeh�ðy���#�C&��JÔL

S��>b�ãLï#5��¶���ézeqK��D�·h�D���f�D`a�z{AB&

CD-

�ú#�gË¥:��18hk g#$m��!"#¤D#n��6#�/+&CD-�æ�

�Ek$���ÀTU#¤B��¬­+&60���!"ABD{�m Cm�%�ê&CD-Å

Ç� iO(�gË¥:h�&'�#S_����0# %&iÝk# %&iG(+'_�

h�D-��)*#$m����«+�nh���IB#»C&�C�C��`a�ôõ��A

B&CD���j#»C&�"�¢æN�`a�.Bnh© ~ª,Úh�E�KÜiÔÕAB

&C�C-GNP#i#£$J�«¬#¤D���¿ti�D����,�#¤D�j�#Si-

.#iºP����q/'tÏDz¸#�D�h�D-.m+,#£$J������+&�_

Y���#»��Di�h�C. �F[h��m-

� �#�<ÂQ¥:#i�6��ç»»�D-.Bnh<ÂQ¥:�·Ë?������æ�

��·ËÒ��æ��#!��D. #¤%&u¥:�ghii% iO%,��¦×h��

2007Ë�01�¥:�2S?q3s&�<ÂQ¥:�im¹»��2007Ë_��#��»»�D

XC�4D�2007Ë_������·jÄ 56Ò[�É[��DC�·jÄ���Û(���

��!"��çn�qQ7�D�ª AB,^-�_Y�89��IB i#�<ÂQ¥:�

�ú� Sq�ê�. ��18hk fg?�12#�C&���{:®#��»»�D-�º

Page 74: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� �����

Y#�;<��#��D·Ë¸�= S#»C&°±+&�¤m-2005ËD#��D�j�2S>

ÂS¹?#¤B��uºh98´��j�2S�C+�Âê+&CD-·Ë�j�38´C,��E

�m��ú�S2��n%,�j�13´#ënDXE�m�2´�;<����]��h�D^-

n,��h@A2SÒ�5´���h·Ë9#�æ��#Âê+�¢£9Q�BÀqìI+,�j

�3´h�%,-�¶�·ËÒ�m��ú�S2qìI+,³ó�34%hk#¹kh�D-x�

}~����C��}~��À�}~���]��q_���17´�·ËÒh1´����ú�S

2qìI+&CD#�D�CX;<��� HU-information� No.3^-Ì9�;<����yÀ7

oÒh�( i·Ë¸�S2�ìIAB,����h��yÀ7oÒh�P�ú�S2�ìI�

:®h�D-E�,fO·Ë9#�ú��æ �S2qìI�D¾¿�E(�%&'&CD-u

�Y�¢æNh�B���^�jåXTUÔÕFXðy���^#=>+,ÑÒ�¥:M ��

��#��DTU34h��60h:����j�����.�6Ë/#1�£TïX%^©ª��

+,-¸ø�D¤m#�.�·Ë?�����55d��¾G `eY��¿�#�D i

#�.��¤E1% Cm�� G�<ÂQ¥:�'�f&�+C� qQ7+&CD-

���� !�./01*23�

Ìt�C-B�¥:����ji12Ydk#��APABDÊ:q3s&CD-.�¤m�

����j�c��ÙÚ#��ª�¤m���YÁRÂõ�wC&CD�h��mO�¿

À+&�¤m-P2��.Bnh���HI�}~²³OP���j����qT¿�DJ»�T

¿KqÛ·+&�����Ú .BOPz{ABD L�BD`a#»C&¿À+,-��}~

q(�3�D,f����j������1960Ë:#����j12�AY��/���H�

+&�ÈùÏ kl#M¼��OB,-12h�£To9:VWT`XinbreedingNF^O^�

PQ3��XR�ç��^�H�/h���Æ��ÈÉ�S¦ G�1N1N1�åTïÕÎÈ

ùÏ#¤DïîbKTkl�S��`� AB�EBP�����ñ��� }~+�CFGq

T�+, ­�B,-E�¸�����Ó[qv+&������}~�AYIB�ìI#�k

U/#��DåÏ�'�f&czh�D. �ÀÓAB,-�ºY#���#¤DEÏt�T¿

6'�12�AYVY�/�T¿����#¤DH�Y�/XÈùÏ�ÈùÏV�:ïÁ

TïÏ�ª^klY�/XS¦ ]?ÏWXÏ�ª^�T¿�AP#�YZ[T¿�\]

h'D-

C-B#�¤�¹�����������DÝÞ6����Ö�h��(���12YZ

[^0�¼óY�T¿6'�)23h�D. qQ7+&CD-���������3�Ú�.

�¼���Ò#��Y#ÀÓAB#((�_Z��çf&S¦���+�ÈùÏH����+�

�^��E���qv+&K�ABD. �%,-_¸����q¹`fD,f#��14R

�TUhi��Y#¦iC50%qasD�� GX�� Æ��Ì�� G�14R��¬­�

32.6%�¦��Ö×�8.3%h�Ì��JSã:VT15.7%�£R9J19.1%�p�36.1%�QÁ9

R38.8%�Èù�b�Ô£Õh48.8% �%&CD^qc��í'h���Y#�,����ïî

bKTbklqÆÀ�Dde�Cn{#f|AB&CD ­�g��DnC-

Page 75: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� ����

�$� -.,/������%&01�2345�

GHI�JKLMN OP*QRS5TUN

RVWXYN Z$[N

\]^�_`abcdN

efg�hgiN

jkg�lmi5�niN

op�h*/qDN

r*stN��uv�wxyzN

x9g{|5�}~�������N����uvWXYN

�*stN ����������l��g�uv�����i-.���N

��*stNjkg����g���������� ¡¢Y£N

jkg��ni��¤¥¦����§N

¨©ª«WXYN

��*stN

¬f­®¯�g-.efg`��°�±�°�j²�op³´�/q

D�]µg�¶·�¸�����g¹�¶·�'#º»H�¼½8�

¾¿À­®¯��Á¼½ÃN

o��ÄN

�ÅN

abÆÇN

È�£�`�TUNÉÊËÌÍWXYN

(Î��ÏÅN ÐÑÒÓÔ~��Õ�����À(Î��N 20109N ÐI³´20%Ã

·�h�a�T;�¤m#���j�ñW]jÎ �!"�£R9J�hTKÂðQÏ �!

"�QÁ9R�ñò\S�l��ª�55��h123 ��'�ìCABD-i��~�.m

+,���qfDkl�Ú#i$+&����hi������#��DjkU +&��

��ju7�7�Ykl��m#��ABD*z��D-7�Y�IB��C .�hno�k

UqìI�D. ����{:®h���������#��D�[/���p1#¸qqr�

D. #�D-

6�7!8�9:�;<�=�>?,�@AB���

���456�789:;�<=>�?�

� C-B#+&i1997Ë#ÍÎAB,]?Ï�����s/ðy��`æT¿�YZ[^

0/�ÝkY�ì��NO�`æqÙÚ#�ì��¹tq��Cnn���� +&�����

®�u +&ÝÞ6��ýºY#ìL�·2'�¤m#�Ú3AB,i�h�D. �ÀÓAB

D-

Ì�h��21¥Ù����������#�C&.BOP�kl<JKµ��¿�qQ�¹»

h�D]?Ï��¾#»C&°±+&�¤m-�������]?Ï�Jï�C%,Cª��D

�v¨G��h��mO-2005Ë����ì�[w�åXqxPB&C�C��]?ÏÍÎÞ»

�,1998ËD#���99�Jï#�D�O%,��2001ËD#�147��2,884�Jï�2002ËD

#�196��5,248�Jï yzj[Y#l½+&'&CD-�]�j15|k �B�vaG3.5%

9ËOP�D Øl+&CD-\[Y�²ÀOP��+&2005Ë��h�2|�Jïq{s&

CD2'�i�D-Boston College�QNï|=LXP. G. Altbach^�����Y#���j�

�KTQÁ9R3��X}wèé�~�3^q�s,�����i�K#E��q���f&C

D-

Page 76: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� ����

���@AB?CDEFG�456�

_��.m+,]?ÏÍÎ#��D�6Å�h�D-����Ò�ª�¤m#°s&CDOh

�D-/�C. #]?Ï#��Dcd��æ2#¤%&��DC�Û�¤Ü�i% ­s�6

��ÍÎH��«#¤%&�'(ê�D. {-C�C��cd��³�h&CD C%&i�

­h��C-���Î�hì��¹tq��Cnn�6��F�hÍÎAB,. q°sB�,

Ài�C-E�hz{AB&CDU£>q�·+�Cnnu�#v¨+,���.¶�q²ð3

+�C�ª��#�D. �EY#�ÓAB&ÍÎAB&CD. �²�(�C. {-ÑÒi

.Bnh��}~�YZ[ +&C�C��TU#ül+,��]?Ï#��DTU©ª±

�����³qQ+,7o��C-n-�]?ÏÍÎ��6���æ�����#��æ���

}~#>�£a9KWq�(¾¿�CfPBD-ÍÎ9�ôõh��æ�ÀlÀ�çfï=>%

£Ô���¹�h��ºÚ��j�P�l]��¨�+,¤m{-E�,f�æ��h�]?Ï

ÍÎ9�ôõ#»C&A_+,���n�]?Ï#»C&ôõ+,¤���C-�æ�¤bY#

i�yF��j��:¢T`#¤D�jýºh�nDOP����Dôõ�Èù�«�ÐT

U:��H�h�ÍÎ�²�(�C��·�h�}~�uºh10Ë�·?Ycd�:�� C

m�������~�h�B��(�C� CmÊ:�B�ÍÎ�6i�D-

]?Ï�U£>X��Î}~ÆÇÎ>b�ãLïÎ^�]?�=]�Z[#�+&�2002

ËD�u�TUh[PO#+,XP34^-��Î�]?Ï�8³Ø� ¦�h�D-E�·#�

}~ÆÇÎ2³�>b�ãLïÎÅ�´� ,Y#��}~H��(�3qÀG +,��Î�Í

Î�6h�D-]?Ï�]?Fºi��F�#¤%&�·�D. �2' AB&CD��.B

nhTU��C{�#�����KÜ�ª�¤m�i�h��mO-34�³h��æ�h¦

12Ë#��Di������æ��/�3¯�'�f&C-E�gh¡®��¤C5Ë�]?�

57%q¶fD-Wæ�æ�}w�¨�_�i���Wæ�5Ë 3Ë#3³��æ�135Ë

�Û(��Ò�C-Bi¦�5Ëh�D-

�6� CDEFG�,HIJKL7!8MNO�P7�QR�� �QRST�

(Î ]Î ÖÎ Ä×

ØeQD 82 À5.0Ã 8 À4.7Ã 337 À32.4Ã 427 À15.0Ã

1ºÙ 321 À19.7Ã 51 À30.2Ã 5 À0.5Ã 377 À13.3Ã

2ºÙ 7 À0.4Ã 0 À0.0Ã 6 À0.6Ã 13 À0.5Ã

3ºÙ 0 À0.0Ã 0 À0.0Ã 55 À5.3Ã 55 À1.9Ã

4ºÙ 0 À0.0Ã 0 À0.0Ã 6 À0.6Ã 6 À0.2Ã

5ºÙ 0 À0.0Ã 0 À0.0Ã 44 À4.2Ã 44 À1.5Ã

ÙÀÚxÛÃ 1223 À74.9Ã 110 À65.1Ã 587 À56.4Ã 1920 À67.6Ã

Ä× 1633À100.0à 169À100.0à 1040À100.0à 2842À100.0Ã

Page 77: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� �����

�S� CDEFG�,HIJKL7!8MNO�7!� � � � �QRST�

(Î ]Î ÖÎ Ä×

19 40 À2.4Ã 0 À0.0Ã 183 À17.6Ã 223 À7.8Ã

29 63 À3.9Ã 0 À0.0Ã 28 À2.7Ã 91 À3.2Ã

39 143 À8.8Ã 58 À34.3Ã 600 À57.7Ã 801 À28.2Ã

49 68 À4.2Ã 0 À0.0Ã 16 À1.5Ã 84 À3.0Ã

59 926 À56.7Ã 111 À65.7Ã 213 À20.5Ã 1250 À44.0Ã

69 34 À2.1Ã 0 À0.0Ã 0 À0.0Ã 34 À1.2Ã

79 167 À10.2Ã 0 À0.0Ã 0 À0.0Ã 167 À5.9Ã

89 2 À0.1Ã 0 À0.0Ã 0 À0.0Ã 2 À0.1Ã

109 183 À11.2Ã 0 À0.0Ã 0 À0.0Ã 183 À6.4Ã

129 7 À0.4Ã 0 À0.0Ã 0 À0.0Ã 7 À0.2Ã

Ä× 1633À100.0à 169À100.0à 1040À100.0à 2842À100.0Ã

QÁ9R�%|:KWRNXsabbatical yearN}~¢£^��EiEi12;<OP18¥Ù#

¤:|:Ô���·��OP�kU/'�'�,f#ÍÎ+,���n� ­�BD-E�]?

�¥�t�¦ÒOP7Ë#¹D Cm§?�ÛC-+,�%&�]?Ï�?/ cd�7˧?q

?¨ +&CD-E�%£LN#ó��&����7Ëq�j�©ª�D]?%£LN +�«¬

i%|:KWRN�?/�ßgA�,�u/Y#R=ï�D-���j��hiy��qìI

�D ÉÊ#�­®�,f�ë�q¯�,��ðPh�}~�¼n f +&4F#+,,f,

��D¦"��D-

+O+����h�]?�?/�å¹Yh��(�]?Ï�?/�°±#3¯+&CD-i%

²OABD��=]�2'� Z[#�D-=]�2³��]? Éá���F�#¤%&ì

L�·2'h�D��=]�+ Cm���]?�uº�15%h���=]�Z[�,Ï´ C

m���æh��~ uº�75%×(q¶fD-]?Ïqv¨+&i�L3�© ~ª·Ënh

IBABDOP���S#i�C#v¨�2' Cm. #�D-QÁ9Rh�KÂðQÏ��

D�h���#�¹7#]?Ï�v¨AB�C-����]?Ï#]?�=]#�.�¤m#�

DXôõf^��C���kl��µCi� +&Uo:pAB&',�O�h�(�YZ[^

0X|=¶·:6�^#�C&ôõqÑ�cgDäå��C. i¹¸ �%&C¤m-FP�

L3�klqªm���DO����h�£R9J�QÁ9R�¤b¸:b=�d��¤m#Y

Z[�|=¶·:6��EC��hi�(�|�+&C&i¹º�CfPB&C�C-

�H�IJKL�MN�

.�¤m�¾G#����Pi� Cm¤�.�¤m�¾G#�DOP.E�����]?Ï

���}~#«¬+,O Cm¼#»C&�cdq»g,��E�cd�6��.#�C&

�'(3OBD- ­m¤����¥0��3�AB,�� �%&CD-zPO�«¬q+&

CD ]?ÏqÍÎ+,6�¢æNhZ¼+,]?Ï�ÍÎÒ%£Ô�½³�cd+&CD¹��

]?Ïqv¨AB,�j¢æN�cd�4³Ø�#ënDXP56^-.�ÙÚ#��ÍÎ%£Ô

#������ûZ�#¤%&]?Ï���}~�(�3#¾�D �����Di� W%A

Page 78: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� ����

� � � �T� 7!8����,/��U/VWX7!8HIU/��YZ�QRST�

(N Î ]N Î ÖN Î ÜN P

ÝÄ*Þ 29 À67.4Ã 5 À83.3Ã 22 À64.7Ã 56 À67.5Ã

¥¦�H 38 À82.6à 5 À83.3à 24 À68.6à 67 À77.0Ã

�¤�H 20 À47.6à 4 À80.0à 25 À73.5à 49 À60.5Ã

ßàáâ 13 À30.2Ã 2 À33.3Ã 9 À31.0Ã 24 À30.8Ã

>Åãä 24 À55.8Ã 4 À66.7Ã 18 À56.3Ã 46 À56.8Ã

�=UV.WX.YZ[�\]^_ `6<a4bc !de�"#��# S)fghbc HZi!de456`jk"#

�[� 7!8����,/��\VWX7!8\��YZ� � � � �QRST�

(N Î ]N Î ÖN Î ÜN P

�¤�¥¦��IiÞ�åÞãäDæåç 34 À10.2à 5 À20.8à 4 À5.8à 43 À10.1Ã

�¤�¥¦��IiÞèèãäDæåç 90 À26.9à 9 À37.5Ã19 À27.5à 118 À27.6Ã

¶·Á5éêAci�Qå 106 À31.7Ã 4 À16.7Ã11 À15.9Ã 121 À28.3Ã

ëì*Þ¶·íîæåç�ïðñíîçòó672éç 69 À20.7à 3 À12.5Ã25 À36.2à 97 À22.7Ã

ô�õ 35 À10.5Ã 3 À12.5Ã10 À14.5Ã 48 À11.2Ã

ÄN × 334À100.0Ã24À100.0Ã69À100.0Ã 427À100.0Ã

# �l7m4nopg!�qZ[.�r"#

BD-.B#`+&]?Ïv¨�j¢æNh���(I¿�ûZ#¤Dkl�)�·3#�Àq

8». �ª�cdq�(+,¹¸ °sPBD-

C-B#+&i�¤(­s������]?Ï�Ûá���(­s��Á�Â'ÃY�`a��

���6��]?Ï����Fº#iÄ�+&CD-, s��ÅÆÇ����¤m#�£T�

LﶷLU:Ximpact factor^ Cm�_�¼iÛC������ CmE�OP���cd

kl�@��s�ê�q��A�D����D¹�h��æ}~����DÈôÇP�¤m#�

10Ë�·?Ycd#:¨�DãYh]?ÏqÍÎ+&CD .�i��Xcdq�CnC#+&

1É+,{�#�klcd<JKµ�=�òh�=°qÊË�(AB&CD^�KÜ�K#An

Ình�D-���]?Ï�78Y��¼OP��ÍÎABD�Í���D��EB���}~

�,f#i�P�C+�����jFL# %&)ù�. h�D-¦×���Û�Îõ��Ï

Ð3#¤%&C2�Ñ(�%, Cm�q+'�#Ò(-EB#:�%&CBcd6��EB#

%&:�D¤m{��¹�/Os��Ó�ÔÓqÕÖ�DÊ:���0#i�Em{-�

���]?Ï#�C&i% icz�Ö� �D��cd����q×%&h�D-��Y�p

¼OP�D �QÁ9R#:PABD¤m#�]?Ï KÂðQÏ ���#xyq½sDí'

h��m-����]?Ï�KÂðQ>ï�=LXtenure-truckN�L§¨�Jï^#���D<

JKµ�¹7#ÍÎAB&C�C-n,YZ[^0�6'�+F#wO�C,f#�]?Ï#�

�DJUT;:Ô�]?�=]�cd����q�f#ìæ�D*z���Em{-

Page 79: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� ����

S�]L��^_`abcdefghiA-.jNk+�lm�

�ôY#­%&�21¥Ù���ØqfÌ�����jkl�����CO#�Dí'h��m

O-�������]?����j# %&*-+ik��Ci�h��C-7�Y�kl�

cd�ÙÞ��¹Ú��ªxy�í'¼�ÛC-n,�ÈùÏXchair system^���}~��

�Y�«h���Û�89a¨åó�Ô£ÕY�ð[Ü� +&ÝP(«¬+&',��

_Z���hÈùÏ��Þ3AB,-V�:ïÁTïÏXdepartment system^���)3�f

ß��������127���#�C&��àY���Ö��}~(�#vaYh�D��È

ùÏ��_Y8q��kU¥²�/#�C&nB&CD/i²�(�C-+O+�¹�h�Iá

��8q�AP#�¦`�qcp�D6'�.��D,f#�£To9:VWT`�Ê:â��

`aqT'Og�C-Æ�����qÆ��ÆÇ�t«�S¦qÆ�D-Em+,k/���È

ùÏ#¤%&IBAB&',�h�D-Ô£Õ�9ËÈùÏ �Þ�}~�JïXÏD^ +&

Æ��<JKµqÍÎ+,-����2ó�ã���Æ��äæ+,ç« å³qI¿ABDO

P�à,�S¦�ÈùÏ�%�:ïºÏqÓºA�D�¿#6'�D-C-B#+��i% i

F³Yh�+C������[��Jï[q�m#æg�D. {-zknh+FO3OP�C

��cd¤�i�ç�cd ��m-���#�C&��L§¨#¤%&�í&�k���#�

B,��uS¦#`�D���S¦ G��tè�¤m#55�h�i% iC50%qasD

OP{-�����ª�3îh����·��í&�S¦qó��&�DO#ÛC-, s��

.� Gq3³#�D. #�B��ïîbKTbkl�ìK#Zéh'D-tè�R:!R:�

���S��TU#�Å(ÑÒ�34h�S¦ G ��� ���í&�z¸�ghë0.49

Cmi% iC N�qQ+,-������� G�²�C©ª����C�h�D-�

� Gq�ÏD. #¤%&���ç« cdqfD. �h'���}~�(�3qÇ5h

'D-�+C¾G�#�C&��© ~ª�í&����j����#ê��D. ��_¸�

)2'�Ê:#&Î�D2'��C-EB ÉÊ#�123#�C&�Éç���`#�C&

iÅÇ�S¦ Éá�E�¶�� i�B�Y]����]���åT;SÁTï��Xendowment

professorNë´��^�ìÂí·:<KW>b¶ã=%:XUniversity ProfessorN�Þ��^

�ª¦`3� îqé�D. �h'�C{�m-�æ��Ek3#��DñW]jÎ�ÄH�

�E�¤m�2'�qïf&CD-�¶��¯� +&�üð���´ñò���óô����

DC�üõ���5±}�ªhkl#döqp�Dí(��¶��J:�:��Y�S¦i�h

#÷�+&CD-Ûø���üõÀ�����x����KT>N����^�ª����h

�¶���'��C�æ��h��KoY�klcd<JKµ��òAB&CD-C-B#�¤�

¹7#���j��·+,kl<JKµ�ìæABB��H�Y¢æN#�¤�ÝkY¢æN#

�¤�klcd<JKµ�´·Y#�DOi�B�C-cz�. ��<JKµ�­ù+,��

q�ò�D*z���m-

C-B#+&i���q�çf���kl�Ú�¹7ô +&����123�B��D©ª�

���j�S¦�ÅÇ <ÂQ` hÛá3+�ò\#`�Dñò\��DC�KÂðQ#`�

Page 80: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� ����

DhTKÂðQ�³ó�N`Y#(���S¦�²i�� G����D�h��CO Cm

ûZqÑÒ��s&CD-.�ÙÚ#�[PO#����123#$%&��ú8�FG3�5

¿ABD�O�h�(�QRVû=L>b¶ã=<&T�kU��Y8üqfýDú¨{�#�

kU�Ýkt��'(ÅÇ��L§¨3�ìO�kUq��+,thKÂðQ3�D6'�ú¨

�D- #·Ë9¸�<ÂQ`#�C&����j�ÀC�Y7��Ñ�cg#¤%&·�>b

¶ã=<&TÌt#�'�Ýkt��çD¾¿#�D-.BP��_3î#¤%&lH�ê�D

���¥:#��D123#$mkl�Ú�)3�é�PB�C-i ¤��gË¥:#�C&

i�Y8ü�'ît�·�SnÌt#z��DOP��� }~�å³33�kl�tÞ3 �

 îAP#�yOP�þ=Ô¤TKWT`�2'��nDh��m-

C-B#�¤�#£$J1�<:9T`X#£$J3� Cm�Ài�D^����� Cm�

VWob:h�B'%,�����#E�Êî��DOªmO��_h�D��H� S¦ k

l Cm��wxy����û¸¹Ú+&Uo:pABq�,���������à,��2�S

TÔ +&��q��ò3�D,f����Ko��çh¯��fPB&CD-

nopqrs�

P. G. QNï|=L�4Xíîï·�^X2004^�����Ê:#��D���j�kl�

Ú �� ¡�p¼OP �XCOE}~<9:Ã5^;<����}~p1ÐTU:-

à�v�X1965^��������12�ü��ê�-

gí�X1994^��� QÁ9R������F-

ðy���������Îõ�X2005^kU�j�¼��Ûá3�DÅÇ}~kU�¢£9Q

�J#»C&X2005Ë7�^�-

íîïX1981^���Ò��� ��3�à�v���������}~�X��}~h:

ïNo.49^;<������}~ÐTU:�32-39�-

íîïX1990^������!�}~ �Or@���@3�ÁRÂõ �ü��-

íîïX1996^�!�� º��+�¯�?�¹�4�����S��� ¡�����

ê�y�148-204�-

íîïX2001^����j���� �_Y������� !"#�ü�$�v�

}~¢Vð:��^�j������� Ö� <¼ �ü�7�àÔ��329-353�-

íîïX2005^��j����qÇ�i��zO ]?Ï�KÜTUq�#°sD �

�Between�10-11��XNo.216^�5}Q�14-17�-

íîï%:P&'(;)*+�,X2005^�������j12=° �-��Ø

� �XCOE}~<9:Ã15^;<����}~p1ÐTU:-

íîï%:P&./0¹+!�1X2004^��������j#��Dkl�Ú ]?

ÏTUqgw# �XCOE}~<9:Ã4^;<����}~p1ÐTU:-

Page 81: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� �����

� 6 �� �������� ��

���� ��

� �� 60 �������� ��������� �������� ��� �� �

!�"#$ 1990 �%&'()*+,-./0123456 789:;</.=0�> ?

@��(A:BCDE FG�2�H���� �IJKLMNOH ,PQRSTUVQ>

WXYQ-.0$"Z($[\(]^_�`N!aMN(b�!���cBC$]^WX

deYQf-.0`N:� e$2ghN$����� ijkl1mn�]^]o�pq

rst bu(v+!WX`N2�H�����c����w��xy�z{� m|2}~

��(v+!�J9:�� CeA:�O�"#$3456 ��!���cBC mn��

��3�`N��A:��(�g!$��� ���cBC(�g!��(`N��$�"

#� v�2��(A: O�H��|�d��1���!g:"C$���!g:�9N��

hN$��2:E�L���A: O H(��� v�2 ¡¢(A: O3456(v+

!��L£¤T¥¦§S¨-©ª¦i«Q AI ����a¬���v���!g:­%®¯

(°±$²a2gBC ��$BC"C(³¬�O2g���´(�g!$��� ���c

BC pµT.¶ ·*¸!�� 60 � ¹º��"# �� »HO(9:�¼­(�½¾�

¿À ÁÂ�g

��� ���cBC ÃÄ(ÅÆ �¯��ÇÈ ÉÊË Ì�� ���ÍBCÎ�Ï

ÃÄÎÐ$ 1965�(ÑÒ`N�ÓÉÊ� 1965Ô�hN ÕÖ�×ØÙWÚ$�1984�(Ñ

Ò`N!g:ÛÜ$Ì���Íw ¹Ý1ÃÄÐÓÞßÑÒÔ�2+!g:��h àá12

ÃÄ$���� ���cBC(t9:×ØWÚOH3�`N!g:ÓÉÊ�� 1984Ô×âÙ

OHãh 20� �­äå1WÚ�2+!g:æç$`H( 20�� ×èÙWÚ gégé

2ê�OHZë9:��h â�e�� 60� �ì ¹º1(íÄ9:

hMe�´ î1$��� 60 ���� ���cBC$gO(���O íïWÚ9:M

�(A:ð�� ���cBC$�� 60 �ñ(�a¬�����A:stA:g$���

c�(�g!�ò1(ó!hNH ôõ¢�ög÷�ð�� �ò1(ó��12øù¢$

�¬2g�úðN!û�gMMe$ÃÄ Zü1(ý+!g:���c þ���� ��9

:���cBC(ÅÆ �g!��� 60 �ñ ���cBC �� �½ 3456� OO

ðIOHú��gM ÷ ����!â eð�� �� 60 � � �� ­�

(���2�H�ð�� ���cBC�� v�(���!aO��Ið¯�½ 3456

�Æ �I�(�2�HZ�1(�»9:M�(A:

×â($�h ÷�� 60 �(ð:����wc�(��g!�ð���� �� â�

eA+VQ��.T�Q,Ó�� ��!ÏÔ �� "æ*ep­� WÚ$Zë`N

!g:� �60��g�#gj$Qeíï�� $2ghN�¼­(�VQ��.T�Q

, ���!g:%&(�g!��ò�L���'(�)*� �I�OH+½�×Ø($�

Page 82: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� �����

�� 30 �(,:�!�c_-WÚ./Û(��g!��� ���cBC�h ôõ¢�hN

(t09:���c 12�£3�(�g!�g¬�O 4%25Æ XE��h õ¡ ¹º

9:�Ið¯ 1990 �%&' ��� 3456�(�g!���cBCL���c 12�

£3�$gO(���O Z�9:¼m(�×è($��½ 3456$�678 �9�

�!�78��� AI ����!a!g:��) ôN��!� v�2�� �!g:O�

:1A:g$ü1(;<�� eA:×�($�ð�� =V>�k�BC��!?¢��

�c�@�)�c(ÅÆ A!BCe�DE(FGHNBC 3��!g:ð�� ��

�cBC$� v�(���O ­äå1(H÷��12%I(�g!$J*�÷K(�g

!¹º�!g: eLM�!g®ag

����������� ���

���������� ����

� ����� ­äå1�� N¸:CÝ�gégé2�I��A:��M.f-O E5��P

(QN���ð�� �� ��(�R�!���cBC� t0¢ ;<�!dv��¸

��S 1 (T9��I�ð�� CÝ$����� É�WX� �!UV0i«¦§ 1973 �

%OHV� W�� �X9:â �×ØÙ����OH���V�(g: 1960 �%*e

Y�.f��e������� �X�!g: H( 1960�%OH�� =j�(ZQ��

1975�% W�� �! 1990�%OH 18[)�\]L,-./0�(8���=j��2005

� ��^� 50%_ ;</.=0��(ZQ9:M��!d:��ð�� �� ��`

¿�$�vh 15 �a�eçb�!g:M�(2I�f-O `¿��E5$EcdeA+!�

"Z ��`¿�$�h � �e781fg hi j+!g:M��ðO:MNH XE

�!d:����vhk 1 v�(XEea:eAé�

������������� ������������

� � �

� � �

� � �

� � �

� � �

� � �

� � �

� �

� �

�� � � �� � � �� � � �� � � �� � � �� � �� � �� � �� � �� � � �

� �

� �

� �

� �

� �

� �

����

���

���

Page 83: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� �����

� �� ��������

�� � ���� ��

19451960�� � � ������� �15� ����� �

19601975�� ����� ����� �15�38� !"#��$%&'�

19751990�� (�� �����)�38�37� *"��+,-.�

19902005�� /012� �����3�37�50�

4��5��678�

9:;<�5=>�

(20052020�� ?@��) ABC�DE���50%� =>?@FG5?/H

������������������������

�Kél�M������ ��`¿�m ��($n@ 78o�e12�õ%&�]^p

qÓr�Ôs ]o�`H($����> �t <.u���a¬hi�!g:M�$�vw

(xyea:S 1$M ñ Q�z{��c{�|��^� T�� eA:*}�S

1 OH^� õ¡ ó:���� �� `¿�� ~LO(�rea:`H(Q�ø{(

t�!$ 18[)�L�c hi [¬�¯!g:M��E�`N:�O����o���c{

Ó���c�&��cÔ õ¡$^� LQ�z{ õ¡(t�2¬����â��!���!

g:M��E�`N:M àOH�� [g!��N��1960�% �c�� ��+���

gM�L 1975�1990� ����W��(�g!��� $ö�9:� ��c{$�Z(

���!g:M����ea:�O����1(ó!S 1 ��o�� �c{ ��õ¡O

H$»�2��$»HOe2g e�Rdro��zr �I���õ¡ ó!dv�S 2

� 3 $�Rdro��3�r(ó�c{�st{ õ¡ T�� eA:MNH SOH

��(ð:õ¡(�g!&� v�2�� ��ea:

�*}���1�¡��!����� ^� õ¡$���\�g����o�� st{

$�Z(���!�I�2000�&'��K���2+!g:×â�o×Ø���(�z

���V�Ó1960-1975 �Ô(�vh 400 st��h ��$��g�O�����L

3456�(�g!�I 300! ��o�� st�â� � e���!g:×Ø�*

e(��vh 25st����&'e��� 10st���`N!g:

�×â� É� X��(�g!$��o��� RdOHó!���� J ��3�OH

ó!������J�� ¡@�9N��g}N st����� �V T�!g:

¢×Ø� ���V�(�g!$��J ��S�� st�£�l���`N2g (b�

!��V�(�g!$ J¤§¶. ��S�� d���¬É��`N!g:M��E�

`N:�

¥×è� W��(Q:���V eú¸��J¤§¶. ��������¦§¨�2+!

����st �V ©¸:â � J¤§¶.(�g!$h ^� $��9:� �

â� �V eÉst���`N!g:M��E�`N:

Page 84: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� �����

ª×�� 3456�(Q:��×ØÙ«¬.�.le�ø{�­Æ(®��� \(]°

9:�O�h â e�±�J��² �J¤§¶.L J¤§¶.e�� ���9:

¼m(�J¤§¶.e$��������(_Ý���`N:�¼­(�������

2004��(³r�� à´(��_Ý`N:

&Ç�µ¶�v�(��� �c{($�� õ¡�0õ��a2��$ó�N2g�

�Z(�V�!a�O��· e$RdrS3�rOHóst{($WX�����V

������3456�¸�(��g�� A:M��E�`N

������������ ��

��

��

��

��

��

��

��

���� ���� ���� ���� ���� ��� ��� ��� ��� �����

��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ���

������������

���

���

���

���

���

���

���� ���� ���� ���� ��� ��� ��� ��� ���� ���� ����

���

���

���

��

�����

�����

�����

����� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� ���

Page 85: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� �����

���������������� �!�

� M��stL�c{ ��$�� ���cBC(� v�2hi �H9 eAé�

OMMe$�cBC �ÁLst õ¡$�� ���cBC(� v�2�� �H�

O Ny�g�(��3456�(�g!$´ 5÷!¿¹�g

��"#$%&'�

*}����cBC iª£ õ¡(�g!º"!dv��� ���cBC »�$�¡

¸�É����`¼9:�½ 1948� 2¾WÚe$ 16,600)eA+� ��2004�"#

156,000)e 9¿&Ǽ�ñ �ø� $I 7¿ÀeA:OH�Z$�ø ���&Ç(�c

$����!g:�½Á�� 1945�� à�!�c���¹- 17,994Ü�Â���eA+

�t�!�r�|Ã�rÄÅ�c� 202,623ÜeA+OH��½ £ÆÂ���Ç«0 �

c{(ÈÉ9:ÓÌpqs× 73�.Ð1945�Ô

� M���� ���cBC »�$gégé2Êe �� �H���(�¯:��

�cBC ÑË!¸� iª£$k 2 �IeA:MN(vN��&� v�2�����`

N:

� � �� ������������ �������� !� �

1953 1961 1981 2001

1. ��� 3,841� 29.1 ��� 7,935� 24.8 ��� 11,250� 15.4 ��� 12,596� 11.4

2. ��� 1,938� 14.7 ��� 4,269� 13.4 ��� 6,809� 9.3 ��� 8,378� 7.6

3. ��� 1,039 � 7.9 ��� 1,744� 5.5 �� 3,476� 4.8 (��) 7,604� 6.9

4. ��� 900� � 6.8 ��� 1,612� 5.0 3,363� 4.6 � 4,559� 4.1

5. ��� 69� � 5.7 ��� 1,467� 4.6 �� 3,256� 4.5 �� 4,485� 4.1

6. �� 599 4.5 ��� 1,131� 3.5 �� 2,710� 3.7 �� 4,446� 4.0

7. ��� 570� � 4.3 ��� 965 3.0 �� 2,539� 3.5 �� 4,210� 3.8

8. �� 366� � 2.8 �� 937� 2.9 �� 2,473 3.4 �� 3,840� 3.5

9. ��� 302� � 2.3 ��� 849 � 2.9 (��) 2,056 2.8 �� 3,364� 3.1

10.��� 191� 1.4 (��) 716 � 2.7 � 1,915 2.6 �� 3,296� 3.0

11.�� 164 � 1.2 ��� 691� 2.2 �� 1,852� 2.5 �� 2,791� 2.5

12.��� 160 � 1.2 ��� 680� 2.1 �� 1,585� 2.2 � 2,619� 2.4

13.��� 91 0.7 ��� 512� 1.6 �� 1,530� 2.1 �� 2,034� 1.8

14.��� 87 0.7 ��� 477� 1.5 �� 1,334� 1.8 �� 1,960 1.8

15.��� 83 0.6 ��� 452� 1.4 �� 1,141� 1.6 �� 1,621� 1.5

16.(���76� � 0.6 ��� 436� 1.4 ��� � 783� 1.1 �� 1,442� 1.3

��� � 13,179 31,934 72,899 110,288

����������� ��������������������� � !�"�#�$%&'()*(+,- .//0 �1234�5�6�7� 890: ����� ;�<=>����6-?@A���BC 0/D�EF!6�

Page 86: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� �����

ð�� ��$�� 60� ���M ñ(�*O2`¿����!$ 15�Ìye��

­� �����k 2OHÙ v�2�¡ ÍdÎ:M��ea:92ðK��� 60�

×â� ��X��($Ï� ÐÑ$ 3Ò(®�!�I�Çy 3��eBC Ó{�ÑÔ`N!

g

×Ø ���V�($Ï� ÐÑ$�� âÓ25%Ô(ÕÖ9:�¼­(�Á×��� à´

�����cBC�3�`N)÷:��Çy 5��eBC Ó� Ñ÷:@���(tð+

�c{�h ÒÝ�«jf 10QI9:×è�(�¯: 1980�% �� `¿�W�`N:

­�(2:�BC�ØÙ9:÷O�Ï� iª£� 15%Ú(\]9:�¼­(BC���æ�

×��� à´��Û_1��(v+!�Ü���-¦§�`NxÝBC�3�`NÛ

_1�� à´��xÝ1(äå�`NBC�3�`N!aMNH ��($�� W

�12`¿���hi�!g:M� TÞ�!g:× 4� 3456�(Q:���^� Ç

ßLBC »�(8+!��-¦§�`N!gBC$vIôõ¢ �÷!g+�¸��

Ïà�� iª£$�� 1Ò(ö�9:�¼­(�Çyp�� iª£$g}N�ö�9:

Çy 10��eBC�� 5Ò Ñ÷:�g�Þm2­% á¸:MN$ôõ¢�âã �

÷�-¦§�OH���> ��­% á¸!g:M� T9M��iª£âã àe@

���ÑËzÓ@�e�y Îä���)å@�)�cÔ�×èy(Çß9:���(�Çß

�a¬�÷!g:M�$æî(ç9:MNH$�����ò��g+h�^@9:M�

T�!g:

&Ç���12õ¡ µ¶���qr�� õ¡ �è9:�°±ég�� 60�ñeP

Q§�iª£ ê(Çß`ë�� %k($�ì��Ü��Ïí��îï��ðu2����

HN:Ó@���$ñÝ�eA:��PQ§�iª£ Çß$×âyeA:ÔPQ§$ö��

!g2g��iª£ ö�`ë,0.¨($�Ï��à��òó�2��Q:MN(b�!

PQ§�iª£��(ö�`ë,0.¨($�Ïô��õö��÷��Ïø��âù�2��

Q:MNH ��($�BC xÝ1fgLqr�� Zú2��hi�!g:v�®���

�56(v+!BCâã�\�¬2N�ûK'Lü¯' ý�vI�a¬2Ih�eA:&Ç

%I9N��Ù v�(*�÷HN:92ðK�

�Ï� ÐÑ�� þ�

����cBC ��

¢�@e �yÎäz ¯�

¥ûK'�ü¯' »��

� MNH ��12¡ ��2�H�è�!dv�ð�� ���cBC$�� 60 � ñ(

16�) �Á(»��É���WX�(�g!$Ï��à��Ïà��� 3�� deB

C �Ó{ �Ñ�h ��20�¸�( 5!�8!�9!Ó�@ÑË �� �¬ÔeBC

�Ó{ Ñ÷:v�(2+#��$O�!��dOH ��d âã1�� �Ñ9

"aeA:������{�Ç$O2I���!a!g:�¬(Ï� ÐÑ��$��¬5

Page 87: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� ����

�`N»�� ������g�`¿�Ç��(�g!$@�)�� �g!�BC £�

l�$Ï�ÑËz(v+!�Ñ`NÐÑ��(A+�� 1953 � ­Æ(�g!�I

30%�3)( 1)$Ï�ÑËz�g�M�(2:hN� 1961�($I 25%�4)( 1)$Ï

�ÑËz�1981�($ 15.4%�2001�($ 11.4%�"#e$�hH¬ 10)( 1)�Ï�ÑË

z(��2gMNOH ­%(�g!$�Ï��z$�°�ç�2é�

`H(��� 60 � ñ(���cBC �ò��^@�hN �@e�y Îä�!�

� ���cBC(LQ��c$ 1953� ��e$�� ð}O 76Üe�� 0.6%(��

2O+iª£eú¸� 16yeað÷!°{�eA+�¬( 1981�OH 2001� ñ(

��1(���2001�"#��@e�y Îä�!�� ���cBC(LQ��c$�

vh 7%�7,600 )(®9:20 ��($�hH¬f¦¨(�IÑ:eAé�· �@�)�

� {� 2001�"#�3.0%�4,600)(®�!�I� zÝðë! 10%�10)( 1)$��)

(v:�ò��@�)(v:�ò� ! OH�Z(�ò��!a!g:��) �yÎäz

$"# �|�@�)��(v:���cBC> LQ$×ây�à�)(v+!®�`N!�

I��O�$�Í��+��ÞgM�OH���1($�%���&`N:

� g}N(ëv�ð�� ���cBC BCâã\LBC'u$(|(5�`N!a!g:

ð�� ���cBCxS$�� 60� ñ(�a¬)I*¸HNÏ��à��òó�+��

ðu�iª£ ��2�H�,b{ »-�2�H.y /0�!a�O�· e$Ü��

ì��îï�Ïí�.yLiª£ �Z(Ç�!aûK'eA:'b(ø��÷��âù2

�$,b{$�Z(��`ë2�H��.yLiª£ ��!aM����$Ìr��e

A+I�¹ÝÃÄ��e�âq Û_�Pe1�`N!g:�g�E���ag÷��òó

$ý�»��!a!g:

� ����()�������������

� `!���� ���cBC$ 1990 �&' ��3456(8+!�a¬���!a�

�� 3456 XE9N�k 3 �IeA:��� �(�J� ��(�¯:3456$�

pqr�s 4Å(v:234ñ5LpC %kz à´����678Là8��678

9:;<(��+!�]^S=> [\2_�(vIà8ñz1(^÷HN:234stW

XLBCWX � $að÷!?gqr��st WX$���@�ÇAB2� (1�`N�

�� %$hN£�÷¬2O+��3456(v:��CD(v+!���� EÜe56e

a:��F: GH�LLެ2I�I1���%J`N!g:�( 2004 �� �J��

@)�(8+!���c KL$�4��cdOHD�4��cd(?@�����c )*

#I $pst MN(�g!OP�QR S� �(Zë`N:v�(2+�J¤§¶.

(�g!$x ��c��! �� �¯:�� J¤§¶.(�g!$OP�QR �m(

v+!Zë`N!�I��4��cvI���$�%(CD`N!g:

Page 88: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� ����

�"� #$%&�'()*+,-'(./�

���� ����

�����

�� ������������

���������� !"#$% !&'��()*+,�-�.

/0 !12345678'9:-;8<=>

�? @�A�BCD@�E@<FG&

H H H H IJ�KLMNOPLMNQRS&TUV

H H H H WX�Y�Z�[&,<�-�.

�\]��

^_\]<`% a�8/��bcd�9:-;8<=>&

���N\] \]ef�ghi/jklmn/�oi&

H H H H H H H H \]9:<p���?<qrsr&

�?\] �o/WNTtuvwx<\]�

gh��

��<yz{|}Tg~/��,<��

��45 �[�T ��'��/�5

���� L�A/��A'����T�}�����or@�A&'��/K��'U

V�����/%���&'WX�#1��<J��E�%'@�A��

���� ¡¢�����£¤¥3¦§

¨©��<E�%

ª«¬gh��

���­®`% ¯°����±�TL°��±�T²�³´T²�±�H H

µ¶gh ��*+±�T·¸¹,��gºT�� !�»[¼gº,

;8½J ·¸�¾¿ÀÁÂT·¸�¾���TY%ÁÂ

�� ��bc<ÃÄTÅÆ6ÇT�?`%T�È- !

3456�(�g!$��st��� �����J�� _�����J�� �J��

��q j§P¦¨¬0R2����(�T?ê¼LU-UL@�)�c(t9:@15V�

1997��OH N�� ÅQ(v+!�BC â3�eA:��� ���cBC$�a¬�õ

�!a!g:

� hNH â�1�¡ ��9N�Ù Æ���HN:eAé�92ðK��N�� ÅQ(

v+!�þËWX�(�a2���øG�YjfR§¶.L$Z2� [ZB%� J�� i

<£�Í\(�g!�Ë��Þm���12�£S$j�]^»(2+!a��A:�T?W

Xs8��@LT?ê¼LU78 î�9�J��_8L�ò1`E`H($aªQb.5 c

^OH�dN�ë2�H?¢ ����78> ^Ñ�Ù×(S÷HN:v�(2+!a¢

3456LBC�(8+!�yÎä e^L�ò� ��!VQ��.T�Q,�âqçf`N

:�¡�S÷HN

� g}N(�!���J�� @)�(8+!�J���c$UPQb�¼m�D�4��cd

�gX`N�)* �h��@1(AB�2+MNepst �iíjL��1k\�%J

`N�st ����O2I�¬2+M�$*ZeA:`H( 2005 � 7 ¾�!��@�5

V`N�a� v�(�� �c'((t9:���Oð+�����Q� 2005 ��n(

5V`N:ó��®MN ls(�$�Sm�Í w�ÅQ�no� gðp:q$¯:r'

( ó���Zë`N:�¬()*�w��'( ÷s+!ð�� 3456$qr��st

(ÅÆ�?+!a��A:Ó�P�� 2005ÔtH¬Ù� 2005u2020�$���� ���

�(ZQ9:M�(2:�ö� ÅQ2�(8+!ð�� ����$p��I��J��@

)ñL�J��ñ�`H($��JL J �¸_ÝS���%J`N:AB¢��gÙ�

(�¯:���cBC$h��i±e�a¬�vëw: ä2g®é�

Page 89: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� �����

��0123,4516�789�

���*+,-��

� `!���� ���cBC(�g!��æî`N:"aÅÆ$�Ï��! �!ÏÓVQ�

�.T�Q,ÔeA:£x�¤ ���cBC(�g!yYk�ulÓËn4Âz{|S}~

2� {�t�Ô çf9:*��"#e���e�÷HN!g:���Þg��ÉÊ��$M

µc ��� �Ï"� àá1µc��!�3���ð�� �Ï"�(_-1($G÷!

+½�

� a� v�(���� ½%��$Ï�OHÑ`9:�����c ÑË��$��Ã$�W

g@�)��OH$G*+�ú+!�vg»� 20 �%OH��ÑËze���)÷��

h £�l�$Ï�ÑËz �O������XzeA+`¼­OH»� 26 �*e(�X

`N�)�Í$ 130 Üe�h �K 100 Ü$���XzeA+Ó�P� 1977Ô��ÑË

z$Ï�ÑËz�Og2g­%eA+OH�à�LÏô� �Í�£�l� 100%½¬Ï�Ñ

ËzO@��I �ÍeA+¡¸��»� 36 � Ï�@r �Í�$�22 Üà 21 Ü��

!ÑËzeO�@����XzeA+hN(b�!�â b��eA+à�×� @r

�Í�$ 12Üà 10Ü�Ï�ÑËzej¶¦©�c����XzeA+��Ù��Í Þ

¬� 1�2 â���Ke���� ���cBC���£�l�Ï�Ïe�Ñ`N!g

Ï�ÑËz�O���� �¯!g2g­%($�@�) �X�2g1I�n Ï�ÑËze

���O2gâ �»� 10 � Ïà��`¼­($�@�)��$ 50%(®�!gÓMN

$pqs�WgQN@�) 20%(A:�g�Ô ¼­($IÓ{�@�)��eA+

�O��×�`¼­ »� 20�%&'(¯\(]°9:@�)�c� _-�è�!d:��

1906Ó»� 39Ô�($�Ï×� @�)�c�$ 8.3%Ó$�Í&Ç 187Ü�@�)�c 17Ü�

®���$�¬Ô�¼G¬à×� 2.6%Ó113Ü�3ÜÔ�×���e$ 6.3%Ó300Ü�20ÜÔ�

��� 5V�A+ 1918Ó�V 7Ô�($�¼m(�hN�N 7.92%Ó151Ü�13ÜÔ�3.5%

Ó136 Ü�5 ÜÔ�3.7%Ó595 Ü�23 ÜÔ�`H(�½��� ×���J`N 1939Ó�D

14Ô�($hN�N 1.9%Ó356 Ü�7 ÜÔ�2.9%Ó270 Ü�8 ÜÔ�1.6%Ó1,377 Ü�23 ÜÔ

e�×��� @�)�c� $�ð}O 1.6% {¸:(��}��(ú¸��gÏ×� BC

Ñ� $»��

� e$��� �cõ¡ xS$��O¡¸��1948�� ���c{$ 16,600ÜÓ$Z&

ÇÔeA+� ��2003��e$ 156,000ÜÔeA+ÓÌ�!��WÚ./ÛÐA��Ô

92ðK�M ÓB (I 9¿ ��eA:M ñ��ø ��¿ $I 7¿eA:OH��

ø ���&Ç(���c$����1960�% Y�.f��OH=j��> ?@�m�

1970�%OH 1980�% ��� �!��=j���> ^¿�`H( 1990�%&'$;<

/.=0��> ?@�m(A:M ñ BC�� µ¶9:��1962� ��� ���c

BC(�¯:Ï�ÑËz BCÑÔ $Ó���c��(b9:Ï�ÑËz ÒÝÔ$ 31,934

ÜÓn�&ÇÔ �K 7,935 Ü��� 24.8% Ñ÷!���1(Ï�ÑËz�¡¢eA+

�O��=j��� 1982 �e$Ï�ÑËz$ 15.4%(ö�9:�¼­(��� ���cB

Page 90: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� �����

C$Á×� à´��ÃÄ��(v+!xݸ�(�Ü�`N!a`H(;</.=0�

�(ZQ���A: 2002�"#�Ï� ÑÔ $I 10%½�(*eö���BC �Ü��Þ

m��â��e^`N�� ������(����c$���c�� 1Ò�Ï�ÑËz

�g�M�(2:»��($Ï�ÑËz�BC �q� �Ñ���"# Ï�ÑËz$

12,500)½�eBCe$�°�ç(2+!a��A:�½ v�(Ï�ÑËz����cBC

�Ñ�­%(�"N��h xS$\��

������./0�

p�� �� $�����OhNH$��R1(ó!ÃÄz£��� õ¡L���P

Zú�A:g$É���LÃÄz £�9:��¤ ���(v+!��1($��`N:

�� �!�c_-WÚ./Û$ 3�¸�WÚ`N:M��pqr�s ¥* â���!Â�

�¯HN!g:���!ÑËz _-�¹)`N $ 1977Ó�D 52Ô�OH"#*e �v

h 25�ñeA:

� =j�> `¿��(���� �� ��$ 35¦ à´(±5%&n GH �D��e

x?���ÓB ½�"#�$£�l�¼G�� eA:k 4 ��3�r(�§�!ó:��

O2I ���¨ðN:�J�� �� $�1970�%(���£Æ¼GOLL�÷(x?�

!g:�� J� �D����J��¼meAI�LLö÷(x?�!g:M z(�§

�!�J CÝ$ 1990 �%¯\(�'�!�I��½ 10 �ñ( 15%�bOQ�;</.

=0�> ?@��(�g!xÝ12%J(v:�J� É��hi�!g:92ðK�1990

��($ 39!eA+��2004��($ 80!Ó�K 3!$ 2003��vI�ø©ñ�ªÔ�¿

����M ñ 38 !�É(�J`NM�(2:ÓÌ����â«ÐA��Ô· e$

�J�� ��¤¬��m$��`N:� �É���e$V� £��ñ %9:�!ÑË

ÃÄz ��9:M�$]ABeA:OHVQ��.T�Q,$¯]ëw: ä2g

� :� ;<=>?0123,4516���

�� � I� J !� # *� # "� #1977� 34.7 39.4 39.2 29.3

1980� 36.7 42.0 41.4 31.0

1983� 37.4 42.4 41.2 32.2

1986� 38.3 43.7 41.6 32.9

1989� 38.1 44.1 40.9 32.2

1992� 37.7 44.7 39.4 31.8

1995� 37.5 43.9 35.1 32.7

1998� 36.1 43.0 30.9 31.4

2001� 34.0 42.4 25.7 28.7

� � � � � � � � � � ��GAH�I��JK�LMNOPQR� ��STUVW��6

Ó"Ô�12 34.$"#5

��1($Ø�è �q �g!�9"! ­Ýe�� $ö��!g:Ók 5ÔM àe

³� à´��®¯t� �� �`$°¬�HN:�MéeA:��hNvI`H( 10%

Page 91: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� �����

&Ç �� �÷ 70%½� ��±Q ®+!g: $²³�PeA:M �P$)´��

�DE(1HN!g:�!��WÚ./Û(vN��1950 �A­($²³�q$�J 1 ! 1

�q deAI�"#e��qÜ$Þm��!g:�úðN:� �����2g�µ2�P

e�J�e 2�q(��2g�c{�ð}O 204ÜÓ$Z&ÇÔe�ÃÄz £�BC(ëv�

¶�9:@qBC(ëv�að÷!1�1®OH�ÃÄst�H��ëw: ä2g��hN�

�� �÷!g:D&®é�1970�% ��� ·+�à(A+!��J�� É3¸��

�³�äS�c£�äS¹º»¼r�Lú.ä à´( 19 !��`N��h �K Þ¬$

³r�S³�q 2g²(³r����`N��12�� $LLö����1977�($

51%�83�($ 54%�95�($ 60%�É3¸³r�� �� Çß(v+!h �P�� �

� ��*I�"#$�� 56%�ö���LLnqBC$½D��(�Ê�!g:

� @� �A?0123,4516���� � � � �XY�D�

�� � �� � �� � �� � �1977� 34.7 20.2 21.2 27.7 42.1 44.2

1983� 37.4 20.5 21.4 29.9 42.3 46.7

1989� 38.1 20.7 20.7 29.3 41.7 48.2

1995� 37.5 19.4 19.4 26.8 39.8 45.1

2001� 34.0 16.3 15.8 24.5 35.9 43.1

�� � � � �� � �� � �� � �� � ���1977� 51.3 65.1 37.3 18.3 27.9 13.6

1983� 53.9 55.0 38.1 21.5 29.4 13.6

1989� 57.4 56.3 35.6 20.0 30.0 16.7

1995� 59.5 58.3 35.3 20.9 27.1 20.0

2001� 55.9 68.3 31.4 17.3 23.5 17.0

� � ��GAH�I�Z[R� ��S�VW��6

"������B�C� � � � � � � � � � � � � �

���������� �!����

� ôõ¢ÓmobilityÔ�$���cBC(�¯:pµ ?õ(v+!��`N:?õ�|ôõ

¢ ÝE1(579:÷(����cBC ¾�34L?õ ¿3�(�g!S 4(XE�!

�M�Ó�P�� 1990ÔM SOHE�`N:v�(�?õ$À|2ÙÁe579:M��e

a:�5pe$���1(qrstn ôõ¢���ñ ôõ¢������@BC � ô

õ¢��|�z Øz Aðë�� ôõ¢(�g!57�g×â ôõ¢�$�½�e

ú��v�(�VQ��.T�Q,�g�qrst nqBC ¹Â¢ T9ôõ¢eA+

×Ø ôõ¢�$���ñ?õeAI����cBCÓS 4 e$����cBC@(bu�!�

���cBC nqBC�Ã�!g:��qrst����cBC�@qBC è\34��!

ÄÅ�!g:Ô(�¯:��Æd12ôõ¢ k�!g:×è ôõ¢$�BCñ�92ðK

���cBC�@qBC� ôõ¢eA:×� ôõ¢$ÉÇ%È �g��Fe579:

MMe$×Ø ���cBCnq ôõ¢�92ðK��ñ?õ(�g!Þê1(;<�!dv

Page 92: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� �����

D :� �����EF#$-G�=>� �

\]�%&'^_`899/a���Kb cdefg�hij kl(j� mnopq�rst$8.9 u6-

� k 6$��3�OHóqr��st> �ñbQ?õ ��ñ?õ�Ã�!g:M ?

õ $��3�¸� ��� 1 �ñ(3�c �%�bQ�!aO T�!g:�è;<(

vN���� 30�ñ( U�d ôõ¢ T�!g:M���O:��ñ?õ$��1($�

��cBC �V (v+!��`N:

� H� ;<=>IJKL��MG�����

1968 1971 1974 1977 1980 1983 1986 1989 1992 1995 1998 2001

!#� 3.76 2.40 3.05 2.83 2.63 2.05 1.59 2.40 2.21 2.40 2.53 2.38

*#� 4.69 2.85 2.07 1.57 2.07 1.76 1.38 2.55 2.77 4.07 3.36 4.15

"#� 5.18 3.50 3.19 2.82 2.09 2.01 2.20 3.08 2.92 2.94 2.53 3.64

I� J 4.50 2.99 3.07 2.76 2.33 2.01 1.90 2.78 2.63 2.79 2.58 3.19

\]�%&'^_���Kb cdef�rst6

��GAH�I��JK�LMNOPQR� ��STU�����vwx[�6

89yy �xz {00|}/~� }/ �x[���6-

���cd�������cd=�÷��K���8//

U�d ��($»HO(�� ¯\2���t��!g:�ÉðN:��ôõ¢�Çß�

��$ü1(�a¬µ2:1960�%$���� ����st$Y�.f��OH=j��>

KÊ��?@�(A+!��S�S  g}N ��3�(�g!��� ¯\2»-�@ð

N��=j� Þ¬ ËÌ� $ J¤§¶.eA+M ­���� Þ¬���S»

-`N� J�� ������¬e^`NY�.f��(�g!$�� �Á�Ö`¬�

{�°2g�Mé(¯\(��S»Í`N e���ñ?õ $����� Ç«0(®�

ά 1970 �%�Ó(� ¤§¶. ôõ ��'9:���J�¤§¶.$�É3¸�� �

Page 93: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� �����

�(v+!��ñ?õ$A:â�&Ç ±Q /0�1980�%$5Ï B% Ðñ(A:�

¼­(���^� $��K�2+hN$Ñ��� W�]o�Zë`N�ñe�A+

1980�%�ÓOH×ØÙ«¬.�.=. bo��!�Je$Q��c��SHN�hN(78

�!�c Yjf»-]o�ÅQ`N:â �1990�% ±�J� ²e$�JL��t���

���`N:M�(2:`H(��J��¬( J��$�18[)�¯](8�øaÒI]o

��!���ÓªS��> ßÔ�¤¦f�2+!x^`N!a1995�OH 2003�*e.

(�7!�8!�6!�15!�15!�23!�13!�17!�18! - 122! ������(

ßÔ�!g: eA:M ����9"!e$2g��1990�( 593!A+��$�2003

�($ 523 !(*e]°9:â ���� �$ 372 !OH 544 !*e¯�����J�

�V$���ÓÌ����â«Ð� A��Ô�O��ôõ¢(hi �H9 $�V �

OIe$2¬�ü ��9:��]o�t�9:1990�% ��3456&��â e��¤

ó�����_Ý���¤�1ÕPl56���Ö�ijkl ÅQ�×dHN�· e$ 21

B  COE ¨-,Pl(%k`N:v�2âã12BC1ØÙ�X�`N!aM����

$ 1960 �% ØÙ��%(µ2:h ;<��!�BC ��9:]o ���ôõ¢ �

÷!g:�EÜ`N:

� �O��2007 �($ 18 [)�� 120 �)Ú(ö�9:(�OOðH}�MN*e ��{�

Q��c$�� â eA+æ� ^� ¡Ç��N¬Hg�&ea:Oó��$2g��

����C /�0��Ô1(Ú¯: $MNOHeA:��t�z$�J�� @)�eâ

gÛ� v�2Ü�(2+!g:M�$Ý÷2g��)�](v:°|�Þ78(ZQ9N��

×Ø� 3456 ­%��Z(ß�9: J ��àù�"Z12� (2:�OIe2¬�

��J� _Ý���Oáâ ­%�ß�9:®é�h�2N�à�� ôõ¢$âÜ(�*

I�¾ãÔ äs�2:[Z�åæ�!"çà��$�è1(�¬�¬÷�éw$2O2O

êëeA:à���ë "Z�ì�Ù+!g: eA:BC �V$��ñ?õ ôõ¢

�÷:����àù�g�BC ����íî(�ôõ¢ �÷: eA:����C(�+

!i±A:ôõ¢�$�O�·ï(579:ð%�A:

�������� �!6789�8:;9��

â ��c ôõ¢(�g!$� v�eAé�OS 5 $�1960 �%&' ��zr(ó

str ôõ¢ T�� eA:Ó�P�SñòSóô� 2005ÔMN(vN�Ù v�2

�¡�S÷HN:

����V�Ó1960u1975�Ô($�����gôõ¢�S÷HN:

����Ó1975u1990�Ô($g}N ��3�(�g!�ôõ¢$¯]9:

¢3456�Ó1990u2005�Ô(�g!ôõ¢$çõ9:���V�£� �`e$2g

¥��3�r(ó:���V�(�g!$ J���������(�g!$�J���BC

¦§a�!g:M��°¬E�`N:`H(3456�(�g!$�J�� ôõ¢�

að÷!�g

Page 94: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� �����

D @� ;<N?B�C����

����

����

����

����

����

����

����

�� ��� ��� ��� �� �� �� � �� �� � ����

��������������������

��

��

��

��

�����d� � ��cd=� ×- ���

z������\cd�

� M M�$�����õ¡�að÷!åt��gM� T�!g:¼­(hN$����

ôõ¢$����(8�BC�VÓ,b?õÔ(v+!ôõ¢�§aöM`N!g:M� TÞ

�!g:92ðK�BC�V ��*N�ôõ¢$�*I�h ��·2IeA:�O��

MNH$N��L)*1Ö�(v+!ôõ¢Ó÷ø?õÔ�§aöM`N!g: e$2gM�

TÞ�!�I�MN$ð�� ôõ¢ �a2�� â�(2+!g:ðNðN 2001 �

� ×ùe$N��(v+!?õ��c$ 1,177ÜeAI�MN$��c{ 0.16%(A:

92ðK�N��(v:÷ø?õ$�ñ 0.16%£�ì�Ç�!g:(�*:Ó�P�£O�

2004Ôôõ¢���1øù¢� t�e57`N: $�M Ö� 8�÷ø?õ pú(�

g!eA:N��(v:÷ø?õ�� m�é¬��1øù¢�t0�!g:O�P �� *

¡(;<���ôõ�$e^�!g:��ÃÄ�� [Z��Ç�VQ��.T�Q, ¹Â

$ 1Ò](�*+!�I�N��� 12�£$ð}��û�1e2g�g�vI[Z 12

�£S$j�� ]^»`�hi�!g: eAé�Òc2�H���1øù¢(t�!$g

*®ü�2T.¶�®`N!�H}�æ�íïWÚ ÕÎ9:ð%�Aé�

�"!OPIJQLG�

� 1997�(ÅQ`NN�� ôõ¢> hi$��º9:v�(�æ*e �Méað÷!°

2g��2004� �J�� @)� hi$MNOHeA:°2¬��MN*e 3456�

?õ > hi$� v�2� eAé�Ok 7$�B% �ÆOHó�ñ ��ñ?õ

õ¡ �è�� eA:92ðK�MMeú���ñ?õ �$p�(�¯:p��

·��OH bQ?õz{ A��� ���c{e��ý� eA:��+!�MNH

Page 95: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� �����

ç$pB% 12�£3� T9�¼­(�pB% ôõ¢ k�!g:MN(vN���

� 30 �ñ(�¯:��� ���c 12�£S¤.�$��1($���!g2g92ð

K�×â�$Ã� ÃÄ��OH·��> �a2�'?õ�×Ø�$à��OH��­(¡¯

! þÙ1(�'9:·��> Çß?õ�×è�$�� ��¯�9:�JOH J�> ?

õeA:· ¿�(�g!$M���¡$S÷HN2O+h ��($)*�BC A

I  åæ��a¬hi�!g:M�$»HOeAé�

�O����(óN��� 30 �ñ(��O �õ��S`N:×â($BC »��B%

¸� ?õ ($�%2t0¢�A:1980�% BCW�� pB% ?õ $�öeA+

¡¸��1986 �% ?õ $ 60 [*e g}N B%(�g!�?õ 2% _¸:M�$2

g�����v|h � ?õ � 2% _¸:· e�1970 �% �����V�L 1990

�%&' ��3456�($"çB% ?õ Çß��S`N:

� R� OPIJKLG����� �� � � � � � �XY����

1971 1974 1977 1980 1983 1986 1989 1992 1995 1998 2001

�30K 1.96 1.94 2.17 1.10 1.46 1.14 1.83 1.97 1.67 2.16 2.92

30�35 2.69 2.58 2.56 2.24 2.17 1.90 2.85 2.59 2.89 2.90 3.47

35�40 3.19 3.25 2.46 2.15 1.82 1.82 2.48 2.42 2.68 2.67 3.14

40�45 2.31 2.80 2.13 1.75 1.23 1.25 2.00 2.34 2.62 2.36 2.86

45�50 1.77 2.17 1.76 1.74 1.22 0.98 1.49 1.52 1.84 2.08 2.83

50�55 1.19 1.32 1.16 1.25 1.07 1.07 1.65 1.37 1.34 1.50 2.18

55�60 1.21 1.32 1.31 0.88 0.82 0.66 1.28 1.08 1.20 0.87 1.54

60�65 3.11 2.78 2.77 3.92 3.08 3.57 2.78 2.85

65K� 2.62 2.85 2.98 3.87 3.11 2.71 2.62 2.38

��GAH�I��JK�LMNOPQR� ��STU����������x[�6

89yy �xz {00|}/~�� }/ �x[���6-

cd�������cd=����K���8//

×Ø($��� ?õ �.§$ 1995�*eÕÎ�!a���OH 30[%½Ó(?@�

!a�O��1998�&' pB% ?õ H÷!d:��30[OH 55[%*e pB%

?õ $g}N� 2% _¸!à�� ?õ ��¬2+!g:M ��($ 1990�%&'

�J�BC �V�OIe2¬��º9:v�(��� ���(8�?õ Çß�N¸H

N:��1997�&' N��ÅQ(v:)*]o hi�N¸HN: z g}N�?õ (

�a2hi �Æ�!g:O$��a25ÆeA:��£�;<�!dg

×è($���� ?õ��a¬�õ���A:1989�%OH 90�%½Ó(O¯!���

 J� ��¤���(�� �O¸�Í$��P(v+!åæ9:� 72 [½�*e$

��6> :J�AB2 e��� dgx �J�L � ��¤��%c =0Ý�Í��

!§¬ZA*eA+hN�_-Ç�v¬"N!g:M ­� ��z ?õ $· �

B% hNvI��±Q2 eA:�O��hN&'$�60u65[ÚL 65[&' ?õ�

¯\(�'�M ��($ � �� +��LâqÔ\�J�� ��V�hi�!g

:O��N2g��¤���$ J�� )´�§0.f�ûÇ�I2[Zà´(Î+!%

ð+O��N2g�Ü2�Í$ J î²�($2:��â�12���Í(�+!$i

Page 96: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� �����

<£B%�ë ­%2 eA:

� B%(ëv�MNOH$��2)´$§¬ZA*eA:��BC1�ç�2¯N�ó¡

a�`N2g�O� ��°� ��9: �aBC 5E�¡¢(2:M�®¯$f¯��

2H���hN ��9:÷($��SA �g±Q /09:ð%�A:æ��ð��

Ö�ijkl$��SA QI�dÖ�OHS�st(v:¨-¤jÖ�(�+!%ð:���

���! Ö�±Q�ý®`N2¯N��qr�� ü1®�$/0ea2ghN�¼­(�

æ��@)�(v+!�J������ ��2)*]o ÅQ9:M��AB�2+ e�

M B% )*]o$?@�(Q:ð�� ����56���9:O��O$· )´ �

v�(����®ea:O��OeA:

�<�=>5?@ABC?9����

� ��� ���cBC �� â�$�ÜBCÓSegmental MarketÔ(A:M�$9e(�

��Ó�P�� 1990Ô�J��ÑËz$Rdñ ôõ¢$�g�� J��ÑËz ?õ$

 J���P(1�12�¡�S÷HNMMe$ÑË! �¢$ÎIQN!g2g��Rd

ñ ?õ ��1($�����S����S�2�±�1($��3� �ÆOH�JS�JS

 J p��ñe ôõ¢ ;<9:M�(v+!EÜ9:M��ABeA:k 8$�J���

�J��� J�� p��>� ��OH?õ�!aO �è�� eA:MN(vN

���J��>$�J��OH nqBC ?õ(v+!Þ¬$Ñ÷HN!g:1968�OH 3

�¸�(�� 73.5%�54.8%�64.1%�73.1%�66.5%�65.1%�68.4%�69.2%�66.7%�61.7%�

63.1%�59.3%eA+���6 Ò&Ç$�J��BCne��`N!g:M��E�`N:

â � J��> bQ?õ$�� 30 � ñ(BC��V�M��A+!�· ��3��

�§�!��Þg¡¸���J�> bQ$ 1968�( 577Ü�2001�( 1207Üe�2.1¿

�V (b�!� J�> bQ$ 873ÜOH 2,557Üe��V � 2.9¿e��Á��J�

> bQ ���!g:�O��1980�% ö�V ­%$� Jñ ?õ$�J�OH b

Qz Ó{eA+�� z �$Ù×(+½��2001� ��e$�b�!g:MNH T.

¶$�MN*e��� ���cBC$�J�� à´(¿¹`N:�¡�A+���J �

� a+O¯�� J> ?õ(����S`N���ÁOHó!� J�� BC�Ù×

(»���B%ñ ?õ OHó!�à�� )´§a�a�hN2I(���!g:M� T

Þ�!g:

� k 8 (�g!�æî9"a��â� Æ$��OH ?õeA:��bQ(�g!$ 1995

�%&'(�g!��J��OH �¼m( �bQ(�g!$ 1990 �½�OH J��OH

�hN�N ?õ{�¯��!g:2000�($�½e$�� 23!  J�������

!g:2001 ��( 744 Ü� J��OH 4 �� �(?õ�!g: $M ÷eA:�

J��$���ø�ä(�g!��J��$�J���(v+!��J�> ?õ����!g

:M���� ���"�$�;</.=0���> ?@���13456(v:â­1

2� e$A:(ëv�M ­� ���cBC �a¬��9:�À â�eA:M�(ñæ

Page 97: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� ����

� S� ;<=>TUVWMG���� �XY���

���� 1968 1971 1974 1977 1980 1983 1986 1989 1992 1995 1998 2001

!� " 424 598 527 696 639 524 449 700 661 710 808 716

#� " 35 283 138 57 63 37 39 58 53 64 74 74

$� " 75 119 108 153 180 162 113 125 153 212 218 241

!#% 10 30 16 12 25 19 14 40 40 77 105 89

$� % 7 30 12 21 24 0 17 32 15 22 29 23

&� ' 26 31 21 11 18 48 11 22 31 17 16 20

(� ) 2 12 15 13 34 38 49 31 44

� 577 1091 822 952 961 805 656 1011 991 1151 1281 1207

���� 1968 1971 1974 1977 1980 1983 1986 1989 1992 1995 1998 2001

!� " 40 72 35 28 32 41 37 86 72 127 106 143

#� " 6 16 5 6 6 6 8 3 10 43 15 33

$� " 22 25 19 16 32 11 10 27 37 59 61 73

!#% 23 47 6 6 3 2 0 4 1 18 39 100

$� % 4 6 3 5 9 0 1 10 8 14 14 16

&� ' 1 7 1 1 1 14 0 2 0 12 11 6

(� ) 1 0 0 0 0 12 13 14 10

� 96 173 69 63 83 74 56 132 140 286 260 381

���� 1968 1971 1974 1977 1980 1983 1986 1989 1992 1995 1998 2001

!� " 422 434 485 507 384 416 514 725 694 748 655 760

#� " 50 75 82 75 48 47 54 67 88 97 86 113

$� " 321 510 385 446 302 279 274 485 493 541 592 854

!#% 9 20 7 9 5 11 7 18 21 32 22 25

$� % 55 242 76 104 108 3 115 218 257 278 245 744

&� ' 16 49 13 16 8 106 16 42 35 21 23 30

(� ) 6 13 8 7 23 34 39 25 33

� 873 1330 1048 1163 868 870 987 1578 1622 1756 1648 2559

��GAH�I��JK�LMNOPQR� ��STU����������x[�6

�Z���Z���� � 6

¡¢���£6

g2g*�1990�%$�J� ��(v+!BC�»�`N!a!g:�Ið¯ 1995�

&'$ J� )´BC�±�ea2g�Á(»��!g:

®�k 7 �Mée5Æ��!T`Nv�(��½ B%ñ�Ið¯"ç à�� ôõ

¢ �*I���� ���(v+!�H`N O�N�� )*]o(v+!�H`N

O$��%25ÆeA:k 8$��OH��> ?õ:�að÷!�agM� T�!g

:· e��| WÚ(vN��2001� N�� �NÖ��(v+!øG?õ AB¢

$��¬ó��+!���e 0.16 (��2gÓ�P�S� � 2004ÔM�� z T.¶

OHEÜ�!�k 7 B%ñ ?õ(�g!à�� ?õ ��¬2+!g:��($���

���(v:?õLâã1BC�(v:§a�a  �!O([ghi �H��EÜ`N

:M��ôõ¢$BC �V�â0 3456�A:g$âã12)´§a�a]o â­

12hieA+!�N�� v�2��12)*]o ÅQ(v+!"E12?õ ��!�

H`N� e$2gM��j¶V0 ôõ¢ â�±Q(/09:÷($�#¢�

÷ ,¸w:341��56 ÕÎ�½��2:��hNH$À|2ÙÁe$d 789:®¯

(#Î�9:M�$]AB®"E12ôõ¢ ��(�®9:O$æ� ��]o N¸:Ç

eað÷!�%2�Æ�ú¸:®é�

Page 98: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� ���

:�����-XA�

�����D��EFGHI5�JKLMN

� ���c��MOH�§0.f`N:O$°±A:��eA:hN$¼­(���cBC�

@q� t�¢(t�!�HO �� '%9:®é�)´¶� �ÆOH���cBC�@

q� t�$Ø�  ¡�N¸HN:×â$��¤� t�eAI�×Ø$��BC@� t

�eA:MMe$�*}½z ��¤� tðIOH��¬(;<�!dv��� ��¤

4:î1$ÃÄz )´£�eA+M�$»HOeA:�¬(¬��m����2N�

£�l�ÃÄz £� î1�9:�O��78 ����ê(ÃÄ$�� 2&�'e$2

g��&@ ÃÄst��678(�g!$��9:78 �!��^@9:�¼m(�7

8 ÃÄ78�$(@�!^@9:1990�%(��¤ �y(t9:ó�����¤�$M�

�78 ��(b9:%J�d:M��ea:

��¤ ��$ J��e¯\(e^`N:â �ÃÄ�� à´(��¤ �Æ�LhN(

%ð:qR��^@9:��¤> �Æ��$��vhÙ �À 0�92ðK�)E*�

4� ÃÄr Ç«0(�¬hN�¼­(�c +� ÃÄr +��9:��ÃÄ ,

Ç.R£¦¨ e^9:÷ ,ù -� 9:���m�c .*(v+!��¤�c »

Í S:M v�(â e��¤ »Í�e^`N:�¼­(h �c/Í�£¤OQ¶¬�

k���!%J`N:�O����¤ �c$����cBC ¾�&Ç(»��!g: e

éw¹ ��@(�0÷2¯N�2H2g�O����cBC$��¤ »Í(�¡�!»�

�!$g2g÷���¤ É��z WX�®$â\a|�g� (2Hw: ä2g®é

� k 9 $É���¤���m12z�|3�z 100%��!�h �K ����st> é

wz � �P¸�(��� 40�ñ(,+! 10��a(�è�� eA:MN(vN��

1963 � ��e$�í�q(�g!$h »-� á¸! 71% ���m12zL3�z��

�(Ãw 0÷�O��h � 10�¸�(ó��> Ãwz ÒÝ$¯\(ö���2003

�($ 12%(*e�'�!g:í�q$ 6�� 23w�m��!���m�1��m$â�

����!@ðN�Þ¬$tñ87(éw�MN(b�!���m^�z$�� ÃÄz�

�!�&`N: �â�1eA+��1980 �%($9e(h � $ 20%Ú(*eö��!

gE�ä Ãwz$ 1963�($ 55%ÚeA+��2003�e$ð}O 62%(*eö���

ÃÄ+L�@(Ãw 0÷:[z�°2¬2g

· �)p�P(�g!$AÃOH��> Ãw ÒÝ$ 2 ÒOH 3 ÒÚex?��2003 �

($ 1ÒÚ(ö��!g:â �¼GpräeA:78r��Pe$AÃ$ 20%ÚeA+��

70�%$»-9:� 80�%($ OD���â­1(`ø���80�%�| 90�%(�

g!$ 40%Ú(*eÇß�!g:g}N(�!��prä�P(�¯:@qBC$Erä h

N(�§�!åb1(1�1eA:M�®é�hN�¼­(� �¤§¶.(�g!$�1980

�%(â­1(��9:� �h ��CLOe$A:�â��!»-�!g+M��

E��MNH �P Ãw � ���!g:eAé�

Page 99: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� ����

� Y� Z[\]��^_NTU`�N�ab�cdef�gh� �XY���

-� L M� N 1963� 1973� 1983� 1993� 2003��� O 0.9 0.2 0.5 0.5

P� � 1.2 0.7 0.4 Q�� � 38.1 31.6 25.4 23.3 13.6

�� O 1.3 0.3 0.6 0.4

P� � 3.2 3.3 0.9 R� S�� � 21.1 36.6 25.1 27.6 15.8

�� O 0.3 0.0 0.6 0.0

P� � 4.1 2.3 0.9 T� U�� � 23.0 44.0 36.7 41.4 23.1

�� O 0.4 0.3 1.0 0.3

P� � 0.3 0.4 0.1 <�� � 55.1 21.1 14.6 14.2 6.2

�� O 0.8 0.7 1.0 1.4

P� � 0.3 0.1 0.5 V�� � 71.1 39.4 28.0 26.0 12.3

�� O 0.5 0.0 0.0 0.2

P� � 0.4 0.7 0.0 W�� � 49.1 20.5 8.8 23.9 10.6

�� O 1.7 0.0 0.1 0.0

P� � 0.1 0.0 0.2 X� Y�� � 37.4 25.3 27.7 20.1 14.0

�� O 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0

P� � 0.0 12.5 4.0 Z� ��� � 0.0 14.3 31.3 16.0

�� O 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.6

P� � 5.2 0.0 2.2 [� \�� � 48.4 26.0 27.3 18.2

�� O 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0

P� � 0.0 3.8 0.0 ]� ^�

�� � 0.0 0.0 16.7 0.0 9.4

�� O 0.0 1.1 0.7

P� � 0.0 0.0 0.3 _`a�� � 50.0 26.4 15.2

��GAH�I��JK�LMNOPQR� ��STU����������x[�6

¡¢�¤¥¦§�6

g}N(�!����¤���m Ãw(�g!���cBC Ñ÷:ÒÝ$ 2003 �(��

1(ó! 13.6%*e(ö��!g:�O��h · 86.4%$���cBC@(Ãw 0÷

O�*$DE4wL±z�g�M�(2:��¤ 12*$3�����1($ 5�)

&Ç DE4wL±z�g:�úðN!g:��M��Z��ÃwBC "� 56+!g

:��¤� BC$���cBC(ëv�tñBC(ëv�"#$vIØÙ�!g:�O��

�� 3456�(�¯:��¤ ��L�Æ��qR��23w��¤�ù�07�COE�

âã189ÅQ]o2�$��678> ?@(8+!���cBC(É2�X��B�vI

��2ÃÄB\�A:g$:2���X %J�!g:÷�É���z(�+!$vIa|

�gBC�2+!g:

1980�%�Ó&'�£¤T¥¦§S¨-©ª¦i«Q PkQ£x�¤�L£¤T¥¦§S¨

-Ƕ�£.f���ò1(�(|(^@9:£x�¤(�¯:k<Õ£ÓOn fP¦§Ô

ÕÖ�>Qk<Õ£ÓOn or OfffP¦§ÔLDE4w ����=.;S£ij¶Qf2��

fg ��øG!g:ð��e� 1980 �%�Ó&'�[�\ à´��YjR§S©ª

Page 100: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� ����

-.i¦¨�¨-aª§fd)*2�w� Þm��]û���^@9:

S 6(T9v�(���¤¬��m#�ø$ÃÄz Ä< �¯��Þm2E4LDE4w

Yjf(=�ON�12�£S$j þ>9:M��12�£þ>$��óHN2O+

�¡eA:�O�MNH Yjf Þ¬$DE4weN�� YjfeA:÷�[z ��

1212�£S$j$DE(]^»(2+YjR§ ){$ 1�) _¸:��$ZLÉw

$� Yjf$hN(�¡�!Þ¬2g*�1997� gðp:þ>1N�� ÅQ(8�

2N�c(b9:w�rN��gX $�ðNðN -ùe$��Í 1.7%�$�Í 1.8%�n�

2.9%�$Z 7.9%eA+Ó�P�S� � 2004ÔMMe $Z þ>1N�� gX $ 1

Ò(?2g��a� v�($Z N�$ÞmeAI��O�@�_�(v:N���°2¬

2gv�®g}N(�!��[Z M��Þm��w� £§¤jSYVQf$�DE(

ÞmO�]^»(2+��MN$RVA [ZÃÄz�MN*e�Ê�!a���¼meA

:RVAe$Þm��12�£ £§¤jSYVQf Ì÷�9: ¡e 57�BleA

:ð��)*ijkl$RVA n�$åæ9:�Mé�°2¬2g��[Z(t�!$�h

�C¬2g��(ð���RVA1278��(�Ê9:eAé�M���� ��9: 1

�  @��!�£x�¤ fP¦§ n(v:>Qk<Õ£OHk<Õ£> PVQ »��

9:â �DE4OHE4>12�£ £§¤jSYVQf XE9:ð%�Aé�ÃÄz

£�($�V� ­ñ�D8�½�(`N:®¯(�q)1(�781(�)´ Eè f¯�

¡�2)´ �®9:÷ bo�]AFeA:

D H� ����ij3�klm�

� 8�¨©ª��«¬­�®«¬­�¯�°±²�­­� ª��³´��� �$¨�«¬­�´µ6�

7�$¶���·�¸��°±²�­��§5�¹º»4¼5!6

� .�Kb(½Kb�¶�Kb�(vw(¾�K¿��À�¶��� �Á ÂÃ�$��ª��´µ6

��6

bc9:

��

��

OD�

��

*+,-.

/0123

��

de�fg�hEijk

Page 101: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� ����

g}N(�!��M��3412�� £O([Z�ë ­% ��)(g¬�O BC1

2E��A:×â E�$�½ ��56eAé�¡¸��1980�%�Ó&'���¤ �

�L�a256�åÙg®��¤ �JGH9:÷($4®+noL�rî(=0Ý�Í

��9:ð%�A:hN�¼­(��¤ ýA$D���!$�Í&ÇeAI�n�$â�

($S÷HN2gx �J�� CÝ�BC 5EOHg+!¡�2�c �®9: $vw

e$2g��eIgYjf�AN��ZJ2­Ý =0Ý�Í �®(ôX9:â ���

ÃÄ ZK 0�¡�2$�Í�§a�ON2gv�KL9:ð%�A:h ÷($�+¬

ß�SßÔ`ëI�ÃÄèLZXØÙ(�L�!e�§aª÷:ð%�A:h����¤

)*i©f$O2IV�(,+![Z�cBC ØÙ �H9��¤�J Q���J�`

H(M�­Ó�à �ø�Ñ*eÔ*e {�ñOH 10 �½¬���2¯N�ôX�Yj

f ���[Z Yjf(bXea2g��¤M��(2+!�?õL��(v+!IaYj

f��®ea2¯N���NYjf([Z ¶�ea2g*Z���¤ �� î��!¡�

2)´ �®9:÷(�x ��LÃÄ��eÞ¬ �©��ÅQ`N)÷��56�^�

(�N!�©b� �Þ$�Þ��Ó�P�� 2000Ô×Ø E�$�23w��¤(S÷H

N:v�(�@q78 ZO1�uX12�6OH3�`N:¤�1ÕPl�%J`N:£x

�¤ ¨-©ª¦i«P0Sj§.0 ��$�Q.jxR¦R(v:�´�ÇZ¬sB�!g

:OHeA:23w��¤e$ 3Ò½� 78�Xz �§0.f�SA ò(ð%®�úð

N:@SC������2� �PeÙ|23��¤��J`NN���� £¤T¥¦§S

¨-©ª¦i«QYjf TÙ9:×è E�$âã12BC1ØÙ�X�`N:(�N!�

É�BCe$buÑ�}�U�\d )´�%J`N:V¦RWQk�Q, ­%�[ZBC

TÙ9:×� E�$Ta¶078L¹º»¼78 ß�(v+!�É�g�678�ß�

9:XY ��S�q($2gÉ�g�P�Z\A:�P ��9:÷($���¤e$h

�h�£�]ABeA:·�� "ç ��) §a�¬O���BC@(É2)´ 0÷

:ð%�A:×[ E���!��½ ��e$ ACÓ£R¥¦i«QSU©�jÔ¤Q¶.�

éw¤Q¶.�yVk��(v:6����FDÓ©\¤0k�ST�«-¦¨xQfÔ2�2��

"C ZOL���X�Ö�`N:)´�£�`N!g:"#$]^Ç�I ���V$À÷

h�(2g÷�Òc2�Hh Yjf Þ¬$���[Z )´©ñ(*ð9"a��z Y

jf bXLN�� gX�!_ 1(*X9:�O2gM��[Z��(bu9"¬�

1990�%&'�YjR§S©ª-.i¦¨�� »ÍLj.$.COE2�(%k`N:¨-aª

§fdWX�A:g$�c@WX »Í�e^`NÓÖ`� 2004Ô

���O1�����PQO1RS�JKLMN

� &Ç v�(�É� ���cBC> ÃwÒÝ$Ù×(ö��!ae$�hN(%ð+

!� v�2)´����cBC(�§0.f`N O�è9:ð%�Aé�k 10 $É�

�Xz 3�� (�g!T.¶ XE�� eA:p¤§¶.a+! _-12T.¶$

1983�OHeA:��hN(vN�Ù v�2���¨¸:

Page 102: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� ����

� � � � � � � � � � � �n� ����opghN�#q � � � � � � �XY���

�� � 1968 1971 1974 1977 1980 1983 1986 1989 1992 1995 1998 2001

lm��n 21.3 16.6 13.2 13.7 13.2 12.6 11.0

am��n 10.7 8.3 7.2 6.4 6.1 7.2 6.5

o*p 11.7 7.1 13.1 14.5 20.1 19.5 21.5 18.9 16.7 17.2 16.8 14.3

q� r 9.1 7.2 6.2 7.5 7.9 7.9 10.1 12.0 15.3 24.6 17.9 19.4

l� s 0.4 0.3 0.2 0.2 0.4 0.5 0.8 0.6 1.1

�� m 3.1 2.4 1.6 1.6 2.1 3.1 2.2 2.0 2.0

_`a 38.8 41.7 46.2 44.3 35.9 42.9 45.9

�� � 1968 1971 1974 1977 1980 1983 1986 1989 1992 1995 1998 2001

lm��n 4.9 2.4 3.8 0.7 0.9 0.3 3.5

am��n 19.1 14.7 11.2 11.4 11.9 10.8 8.9

o*p 8.6 8.0 8.1 6.8 10.6 10.6 10.0 10.7 8.5 11.1 11.0 11.9

q� r 11.4 8.4 6.5 8.0 9.5 8.1 8.5 14.7 13.8 16.2 17.4 19.6

l� s 1.7 1.7 1.5 1.6 1.4 1.8 1.2 1.5 2.4

�� m 22.7 18.8 19.8 17.1 17.1 18.5 17.7 16.7 16.6

_`a 34.6 43.7 41.3 45.4 40.9 42.2 37.1

��GAH�I��JK�LMNOPQR� ��STU����������x[�6

¡¢�¤¥¦§�6

×â($�É���z$ 20�ñ(��!�·! É��zê(ö��!�I� z bë!�

�� 34%OH 7.6%>��� â&�*eö��!g: eA:M Æ$k 7 ;< cd¯

!g:×Ø($�=�eOH �X$ 1960�%OH���)÷ 1980�% �.§(�!�h

�Ù×(ö��!a!g:���cBC�»-�2g­�(� ��*I��(»-�(ö�9

:"�$�BC õa�$âH�!g2g��12�X){$�1968�OH 3�¸�(�739Ü�

362�734�967�1,450�1,435�1,640�1,510�1,434�1,534�1,568�

1,468 Ü�2+!g:×è($�tñOH �Xz�Ù×(���¡(A:� �P(�g!

tñ�Xz����!g: O ;<�!d:ð%�A:��h nZ(�g!$`H(�º9:

M�(�g×�($��Lqh · �!rOH �Xz$¸¬°{eAI���BC(�Æ

9hi��a¬2g,b{� 266Ü&�(��2g�O����> �X$qh · �!r

OH �c �X� 15%½� Ñ÷!g:×[($qh ·r �X����(ëv���(ë

v�4 Ò½� ±Qex?�!g:�è �(2+!g:Ì�!�c_-WÚ./ÛÐ$�A�

�� 5¾"#eWÚ`N:h ÷½�� 5¾&' ±wLDE4w �ñ �!�X�

Ãw�Xz$�É���z(�Aë}�WÚ­(�g!$qh ·r ¤kf�.(g*N:h

z �òWÚ T.¶ �è�;<(vN��ð�� ���c$��¤þ2�OH�� Ãw

(é¬*e(,��e 4.95 � 78�X �leg:Ó�P�� 1996Ôh�!×i($���c

É��Xz(�g!µº�!�M�É��Xz$ 1992�&' 3�¸�(�1354Ü�1059Ü�

926 Ü�h�! 2001 �($ 749 Ü*eö��!g:M D&$�� ���(v+!BC�Õ

]�M�(v:�2 É��Xz {($�¼�ñ( 197ÜOH 185ÜeAI�M v�2"

�$�S`N2gÓÌ�!�c_-WÚ./ÛÐA��Ô�! �X$���$ÃÄ��e$2

g e*�$Z �X$A:� �h ç$að÷!°2gÃÄ�� v�2·! �Xz$

���¼m(�a¬]°�!a!g:tñOH �X$���!a!g:���åæ9:Æ$

qh · �!rOH �X���â��!× 1y Ñ÷��2001�(tñ��b�!g:qh

Page 103: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� ����

· �!r�$�!�à´eA:MN$�! Ô\z��X`N: �â�1eA+���

Xø �®9:j@(v:qh ·r ¤kf�.$���¼meA:� � � � �

`!���BC�·BC� t� ó:T.¶��!tñOH �X �q¸�(�è�

�k 11 eA:Ǻ�v�(tñOH �X$Ù×(���¡(A+�O��M kO

Hó:���P(v+!*K*KeA:M��E�`N:,b{e®¯�í��78Ó100 Ü

&ÇÔ .eÞ¬��V e$78�®¯�í� .e�¬�gðp:uXr��P(�g!t

ñ� )*�ô�BleA:M��E�`N:�� 78r�$"Z ]o�kl�!�I�

)´£� ¥ L���]^�ùC� )* ôõ¢ �÷:"aeA:� OECDOH`E`

N $ 1970�%eA+ÓpqsÌ�� 78r�]oÐ1977Ô1990�%OHtñOH

�X�Ù×(����2001�($¯��!g:MNH Þ¬$�e�L��� �PeÞg�

xm`N:��@��¬ayj�MOT��ê]o�L���ø2� à´�9:23w��¤Ó¨

-©ª¦i«P0Sj§.0Ô��h ��É(�J`N:M�OH�L�!��M �P

tñ78� �ô$�%(��9:M�(2é�

� ��� rMIJ�gh���st� !� � � � � � � �XY���

45 67 89 :; �; <; => ?@ AB �� �C DEF �

1974 20 21 23 108 28 129 2 3 6 7 2 349

1977 22 28 28 127 27 241 1 6 9 11 0 500

1980 29 35 27 127 10 321 3 6 5 6 0 569

1983 24 39 20 88 19 363 1 6 5 7 0 580

1986 40 49 23 108 22 491 0 7 8 13 2 774

1989 36 92 38 214 36 520 4 4 9 6 2 961

1992 39 115 52 291 46 725 0 9 13 21 1 1312

1995 46 158 79 365 43 1456 0 8 10 25 7 2197

1998 58 149 67 328 46 985 0 14 9 15 1 1672

2001 83 289 76 359 38 1034 0 15 16 60 25 1995

��GAH�I��JK�·�LMPQR�- ���TUVW��6

���TUVW

� ��BC ôõ¢$À|2ÙÁe;<`N:ð%�A:stn(�¯:VQ��.T�Q,

v�2ü1ôõ¢�AN��?õµc�Þmew�ñ ôõ¢�A:��BC ôõ¢��

!$��ñ ?õ(óHN:ôõ¢�A:`H(Ǻ�v�(��BC�@qBC� ñ

ôõ¢�A:A:g$�º9:v�(aªQb.5OHóü12ôõ¢L@�)�c �@

BC� ôõ¢�Aé��( 2001�$�� ��� hi â­1(ëv[¬�¯!g:

� hz$��?õ :12ôõ¢ vI1�(m�9:�F��!ÉÇ%È 2:{n &½(

¹`�Ó�P�� 2001ÔÉÇ%È ùÑ@$Ó�Xz{åbQz{Ô÷Ó���c{ul

wzÔ×100 eA:92ðK�ôõ¢ vI»�(ÄÅ9:÷(�"ÔxQ/.(b9:É

2xQ/. � ùÑ����cBCnq�@qBC õ¡ '%�{n(v+!Þ

Á12ÙÁ ôõ¢(�g!vIn�2õa ÄÅ9:M��AB�2:

� ¡¸��k 12 e���cBC�� ÉÇ%È H÷!dv��� 30 � õ¡(�g!�

Page 104: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� ����

1960 �%$������¯\(^@�­%eA:1986 � BC������­% 1.5

¿ xQ/.�%�A+�� 30�ñ( U�d ÉÇ%È T9��2001�$ 1960�%

ÉÇ%È çõ9:M�$2g��Ǻ�v�(�2001�$�JS J �� ���

hi oN!$2:*g�½ ÉÇ%È ��zr(;<�!d:���J� ç����

!g:M� TÞ�!g:· �Rdr(;<�!d:����($�� ����hi�!

g:���� ���$�� â­12lwz G`9:�ÉÇ%È($hN£��a2hi

p¸!g2gv�®hN(�2 ÉÇ%È ��%(ö��!g:�¬(�2 hN$ 1980

�%($qº(ö���h ��rIçõ�!2gM��E�`N:M ��($�����

2� 1962�Ó�D 37Ô(`¼��1967�Ó�D 42Ô(â�IX�`N�1971�( 3!�1974

�( 2 !��J`N��1977 �OHÓª� ÕÖ�(Q:*��2BCe$@qBCO

H )´�ô�s�gM�$&½OH��`N!g:Ótu� 1976Ô

� ��� ��������=>kVWkuv�owPxy

1968 1971 1974 1977 1980 1983 1986 1989 1992 1995 1998 2001

I� J 13.6 9.9 9.9 9.7 9.3 8.8 8.8 9.4 9.3 9.3 9.2 10.2

!#� 13.6 8.8 8.9 9.5 9.7 9.0 8.8 9.7 9.3 9.5 9.7 9.5

*#� 13.6 11.1 10.9 10.1 11.4 9.8 9.7 10.6 11.9 12.7 9.9 10.9

"#� 13.7 10.7 10.7 9.8 8.7 8.5 8.6 9.0 8.9 8.7 8.6 10.7

4��� 13.6 9.9 9.9 9.7 9.3 8.8 8.8 9.4 9.3 9.3 9.2 10.2

P� � 14.2 9.5 10.2 9.4 8.3 7.5 8.0 8.7 8.6 7.0 7.0 7.1

�� O 12.3 8.1 6.2 4.5 3.8 3.3 6.0 6.4 6.1 5.8 5.0 7.0

[� t 5.8 3.9 4.0 4.0 3.4 2.9 3.0 4.2 3.9 4.4 4.1 5.2

u[t 6.0 4.7 4.8 4.0 3.7 3.3 2.9 4.7 4.8 5.3 5.2 6.2

v� w 14.3 12.5 11.4 10.2 9.5 8.3 8.5 10.1 10.5 10.3 10.4 13.0

u� x 28.0 21.2 21.1 20.3 20.9 21.0 21.6 20.8 20.8 20.0 20.5 21.8

��GAH�I��JK�LMNOPQR�.//8 �S�·Ä5¼Å\��6-

ÆÇÈÉ���Ê�=�¿��=������K���Ë�=��8//-

� â �w�r(ÉÇ%È ;<�!d:��hNH$w�(v+!�a¬åæ9:M��E�

`N:$Z�g�w�$þËWX�$â�(ó2`N!g2g$Z ÉÇ%È���\�g

1960 �%($ 30.0% ÉÇ%È T9â �hN&'$ 20.0%Úeâ��!�I�BC �

V L��� hi £�l��¯!g2g$Z\$BC hi �¯2ge�â��!ÉÇ

%È�öM+!g:N�� ÅQ� 1997�&'��g�vI 1990�%OHâ��!���

2g92ðK�3�c 2Ò�â��!�%�!g:M�(2:

· �n�w&Ç(�g!ó!dv�n��$�Í��Í g}N w���2®HO2 U

�d ÉÇ%È T9g}N w�� 2001� ��e 1960�% ÉÇ%È (+½�!g

:®�w��ög£�ÉÇ%È$�ag���Í�$�Í hNH$�b9:��A:â

�($$�Í ÉÇ%È$�Í hN Çç:$}eA:���Í\$��(v:3w��a¬

hi�!g:AB¢�A:h ÷O 1980 �% ���cBC����­�(�"ç ?

õ������?õ� ��*+­�(�Í\ ÉÇ%È�$�Í hN Çç+!g:n

�\$�ÍS$�Í�$Z\ àñ��ex?�!g:g}N(�!� 2001 �(2+!�$

�Í\$ 1960 �% ÉÇ%È Çç+!g:��ñ?õLBC �V ®¯OH$�»e

Page 105: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� ����

a2gü12É�g"��öa��A:M� T�!g:MNH$ÉÇ%È {nOH»HO

2v�(�ÉÇ%È$��nqBC hi �¯:�OIe2¬���@qBC� )´�ô�

�a¬hi�!g:M ÆOHó!�3456� )´ �§0.f ôN�Ù×(xv�õ

�!g:M� T�!g:

M M�$k 13 eT�v�(����Peó!��a2ý�S÷HN:?õÃÄe³w

x�P�4]2�e?õ ��¬�ø¼�PLE�t�e?õ �ögM�$9e(¹@ÃÄe

�»`N!g:®¯�P$"C� �ôeôõ¢��g4]äe$$Z\ ��$Z�L;

y s(3w9:ÒÝ�åb1(�gø¼�Pe$xÝ#õ(8�z���ôõ¢ ö¬�!

gÓ�P�� 1990Ô· e�k 11 eT�v�(�®¯�í��78r���Ið¯78

r� �PeBC@ )´�ô�#`��!g:M� ���M���ÆOHk 13 ;

<�!d:�°±ég�XSlwz��(Þg®¯$������2g��78r��í��

ø¼�P2�$@qBC g÷)´ �§0.feÉÇ%È�Çß�!g:4]ä$�Á(

b9:åb123wz Þ`�ç Çß`ë!g:�E�`N:í�ä�78r�ä�ø¼ä

2� 23wäL�òä2��MN*e��BCe¹{`N2O+É2)´ ôN��MN

OH 21 B d ���� 3�¬:M�(2: eAé�M��VQ$§f�9e(g¬

�O �PeøG��A:

� �"� ���������z{|�owPx

�� � ���� ��� � � �� � �� � � �

yz{| 1075 1186 586 1279 250 5100

}~{| 813 826 363 524 91 1017

��{| 1245 913 655 1148 223 5428

��[�| 23098 19665 14764 25895 6412 46059

��[�|��{| 21853 18752 14109 24747 6189 40631

����� 8.64 10.73 6.73 7.29 5.51 15.06

�� � �� � �� � �� � �� � ��� �

yz{| 3 77 338 298 97 10289

}~{| 0 69 274 128 50 4155

��{| 2 114 392 236 43 10399

��[�| 63 1495 8165 4521 1456 151593

��[�|��{| 61 1381 7773 4285 1413 141194

����� 4.92 10.57 7.87 9.94 10.40 10.23

��GAH�I��JK�LMNOPQR�.//8 �S�·Ä5¼Å\��6

@��}~��0�3�5�

���X!���������

£x�¤ ��> ?¢^Ñ ÷w*�`$����� ?¢�"���3v`N!g:#

�ø �K?¢$����m(�g!$9e( 1978�(���¤�m(�g!� 1984�(�Ó

{�2+O�!T¢�Tà1Þ{eA+¨-©ª¦i«P0�PÓ@��¬ayj�³��

Page 106: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� ����

�Ô(�g!�?¢ ^Ñ$��¬�?¢�$ 50%(½�a��A:���?¢^Ñ °2g

í�ä�(�g!�?¢�c �L9÷ `*w*2k\�2`N!g:��g���st

¹WXz 53%$?¢�Ñ÷!g:���Íw> ?¢LQ��1975�( 24%eA+�

��2003�"#($ 41%(*e��¬»��?¢�V� 20%(®������ �.b.

1JC(A:Ô\��(�?¢�V��¸!aaªQb.$�?¢ {1���OIe2¬�

�� ¤�1ÕPl������ nv�øù AI ��wc WXL'(3���� )E

*�(|:9"! �a¬�v`ë��g��O��MM(|:*e($ 1960 �%&�

=V>�k��aªQb.(t9:ýr}Ó*õ oN!$2H2gÓ~.Q���|� 2004Ô

M v�2£x�¤ �� ó:(�¯��� ����(�¯:aªQb.�� 56$Æ

d12�^��g+!vgK2d(��ò1(���c ?¢� ó!��T.¶$LL�

g��PkQ¿�e$���c KL�âqt�9:÷O�?¢� $�Pa0 39.5%�x1

iY 35.6%�;� 32.8%��¬�½784Â�eA+-i£� 26.5%��§1�g�ö��

àÏe$�V��j 23.2%�jOª.TQ 25.8%�UPQb 22.4%�VjPY0 27.6%� 20%Ú

T9â �RVAe$ 16.9%(�*:`H(£a£SUiª£<£xÝe$��9:â 

e�U.jfP�£ 34.8%��� 24.8%��¬�· e�� 13.0%���$ 7.0%�b��e$

�ö� eAI���� 24.1%OH�O¯lN!g:ÓÔ��S�D� 1996ÔM v�2�

ò�� '%�!O�2003 �"#eú¸���J�� @�)�c 717 ÜÓn�&ÇÔ �K

?¢�c$ 132Ü�?¢� $ 18.4%e��)�c �J� 10.3% �a¬Çç+!g: e

A:Ópqr�sW"� 2003Ô�

â �g}N �(�g!��?¢�c(t�!$�”The higher, the fewer”�g�5E�A

:��Lw�2� }~��¬2N�2:£��?¢ 3�� $ö¬2:�g� eA:

â� ��vIÃÄà´ }~ �g��e$?¢$°2¬����m�1��m�¬��m�

Ç PQ§(2:£�?|�ø � $ö�9:w�¸�(ó!��n��$�Í��Í�w

� }~��*:£�?¢ ���c$°2gÇÈ ¹^���e`¸�w� ÜÃLKL$

µ2:� �n� 48.3%�$�Í 43.3%�m�Í 31.8%�`H(�Í(2:� 17.8%�â��

��:ð���Ç«0 åæ$A:��w�ñ ý$�ag��ñ ?õ ;2Qj�T¢

�c�?¢�c�e$�a2Ôý�A:14 ¤�SxÝ�� ��e$T¢� 0.89 çeA:

(b�!�?¢$ 0.69 çe�?¢�T¢ ?õç{ Çç:�$2gð�� ��$T¢

0.53ç(b�!�?¢$ð}O 0.37ç ;2Qj�O�*N!g2gÓ�P�� 1996Ô

� �O��k 14 (XE�v�(�ð��e�Vgîeó:����O ��$A:×â(

$&½$�J��J� J�� .e?¢� $öO+��2000�%OH�J�� ?¢�

$â��^@�2003�($�J�� ?¢� $ 20% _¸×Ø($�� 50� ñ(

?¢� $ 3¿�(2+!g:92ðK�1953�($��?¢� $ 4.8%(��2O+��

2003�($ 15.3%(®�!g:2010�(������� ?¢� 20%$®�AB GH(A

:���J��@)_8 £§i«QS¨PQe$�J� ?¢� 20% ®� îF��!�

I�M ** ��e$h Z"$2O2Oë�g��(A:Ó�J��_8� 2000Ô

Page 107: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� ���

� �:� ;<=>TUuvIJKL�C����� �XY���

1953 1963 1973 1983 1993 2003

!� # 2.8 4.1 4.7 5.2 6.6 10.3

*� # 6.6 7.0 9.2 9.4 11.1 21.9

"� # 9.2 11.7 11.6 11.5 12.6 18.1

[� t 1.9 2.3 2.9 4.0 5.5 9.2

u[t 3.6 4.2 5.8 6.8 9.1 15.2

v� w 7.1 10.1 10.6 10.4 13.2 21.8

u� x 7.1 12.8 14.1 13.8 15.3 22.6

I� J 4.8 7.2 8.2 8.4 9.9 15.3

��GAH�I��J·�NOPQRgÌÍKÎ��g�

- - - - - - - - - - - ÏÐ�� ��K���µ!ÑÒª��Å\��6

� MN*e��`N!av�(�?¢� �g��$?|��L?¢ä���P�Ã`N:

�MéeA:¡¸��k 15(T9v�(�?¢� � 30%&Ç ��Ó?¢�c� 30Ü&�

$�¬Ô$ 2001�"#e 33!A:��h �K�?|�� ÜÃ��g� � 22! {¸

:ÓÁ?|��eA+��²J��� ��¸:Ôh ·$��ä�ø¼ä ���hN�

N 4!�4]ä 2!�@6� 1!eA:· e?¢�c ,b{ Þg����!$�Á �

ag¹Ý��L?|��Ç�HN:¡¸��2002�(�¯:?¢�c Þg�� «jfkQ

$�ðuÂ�� 146ÜÓn�&ÇÔ�Ï�� 132Ü�Ïà?|³� 127Ü���� 126Ü�ò

ó� 108Ü�Ï� 106Ü��t� 101Ü���P�� 97Ü���?|� 94Ü�+� 92Ü�e

A:ÓÌ×�PQ1Q,Ð2002Ô�O��Û_ A:Á×�§Pj ?¢� eó:��ô�

3.6%Ón�&Ç�57ÜÔ�Ïô� 2.3%Ó33ÜÔ�òó� 6.6%�Ï� 4.5%�Ïàí� 1.9%Ó13

ÜÔ�âù 7.2%Ó20 ÜÔ�Ü� 5.8%Ó88 ÜÔ�à� 2.4%Ó64 ÜÔ�ì��3.7%Ó57 ÜÔ�

÷� 7.2%Ó87ÜÔ�õ� 3.1%Ó1998��41ÜÔeA:Ó� $ 1998��?¢�c Z{$

õ� �g! 2002�Ô��$dg� ÃÄ�� ?¢� $�Z(Çß�!g:

�J� ��¤(�¯:¬��m ?|�ø� $��P(v+!��pst ��¤(v+

!��a¬µ2:������e$ 21.3%�¼1��me$ 23.2%eA:Ó£x�¤e$½z

39.9%��z 55.9%Ô?¢�c� 1��CÝ ?|�ø� ç$�¬��me 3.2¿�

1��me 3.5 ¿eA:?¢�c� ���¤?|�ø� Ôý ýr�EÜ���+�?

¢�c Þ¬�X9"aeA:�4-9:M��ABeAé����%2�Æ$��12øù¢

��±�Çe579"aeAé�g*MNH T.¶ 0KÝðë!g2g��g}N(�

!��ÇÈ ��¤ ?|�ø� $��1(ó!?¢� Çß ì�Ç�:T\�2+!g:

M�$ñæg2g?¢� ¹^� â�eA:£x�¤(�g!`¸��Pr(�a¬µ2:

� �2003�4�� ��_-e$ 40% ���!g:

Page 108: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� ����

� � � � � � � � � � �@� �C��y "n���9���� � � � � � �XY���

\]�ÓÔÆÕ����Ö×Ø×Ù�.//: �S6

���OYZ�������

� "# �� DÃ3� `O ÆN�àB ��(@a�¬��h Ñ`ÆOH��$h�h

��ò1eA+P´A:[z$�y 0÷!�.-¦$pxOH��2£0¨j �¸�V

¶�£ �-.<£L=Ç0> î��½B(Q+!��� à´xeA+RVA($

�.-¦$�£x�¤�£a£ C¬OH�����y Îä�»� Ï���J`N�

a�Þ¬ �Wg@�)���Y#�"#e��� 3�ñ(1+!d!��@�ste��

�c �X�ÒÝÓDE4 g�Ô$�VjPY0 65.1%�UPQb 33.7%��� 29.6%�R

VA 25.3%�;� 22.4%�jOª.TQ 21.8%� 2Ò _¸�V��j�U.jf�£�£x�

¤� 13u15%Ú ±Q(A:¼m(�"#�BCe$ 8000�) �ø���e�leg:��

BC ��ø$�;yjY _-(vN��1980�%($ 100�)�1990�( 120�)�2000

�( 160�)Ó4% 50p�Ô(��"#e$ 200�)½�®é��É_-e$�£x�¤

$ 58.6�)�29.3%Ó�ñ5 200�)��!Ô�V��j 24.3�)�12.6%�RVA 22.7�)�

11.6%�©PQj 18.0 �)�9.0%�U.jfP�£ 13.6 �)�6.8%���$ 11.7 �)Ópq

r�s�2004Ô�5.9% {¸:�(���) �@> ��ø$ 1990�%( 2.7�)eA+

� ��2000 �($ 7.6 �)(®9:ÓÌ;yjYp�_-��Ð� 2004Ôð��> �

�ø 10�)-U$®�`N��xÝ1($�à� 66.3%��� 13.2%�Ú� 3.5%�£a£�

90%½� Ñ÷�ü Êe 1998 �($ 91%��y Îä���2002 �($ 69%�ö���

3�z� 3.1%OH 6.0%(¿�9:�g�É2����ø�Ó¹�sW"� 2004Ô

� Ǻ�v�(�»�� ���Í$�Wg@�)�$�Ïà×�(ëv�à�×�(ëv�

�@�� �Xz�½��`N�£�l� 100%½¬�V� ���XzeA+"# ��

���c q�� 3�ñ(�¯:��A:g$ÃÄ ÷ �@�Xzr � $��� I

55.5%eA+Ðgi± ���Xz$�+�°2g���ò�§e$��1eA:VjP

Y0 93.5%�jOª.TQ 74.5%��� 71.8%�UPQb 69.9%�RVA 64.8%��� 61.5%(

��� ��� � � � � � ���

1 ������ 90.2 11 ��L�� 46.2 23 ���#� 39.2

2 ������ 80.0 13 ���� 46.1 24 ���e�6 37.8

3 ��� 73.2 14 ����� 45.0 25 ��b � 37.4

4 ��¡¢� 60.6 15 �£��� 44.0 26 ¤¥��� 37.4

5 �¦§��� 60.0 16 ¤¥�� 43.7 27 ¨©�� 36.4

6 S���� 59.7 17 �£��6� 42.2 28 ª#��� 36.1

7 ���«� 58.3 18 ¬��E­®� 41.2 29 ¯°¬±�� 35.9

8 ²³��� 50.7 19 ´µ�¶� 40.7 30 ¤¥Z�� 34.0

9 !#�� 48.2 20 ¤³·²�6 40.2 31 ¤¥�¸� 31.8

10 ¹º�X»� 46.5 21 �¼��� 40.0 32 ¤¥Z�� 31.1

11 ½¾��� 46.2 22 ¿²��� 39.4 33 ÀÁT�� 30.0

Page 109: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� �����

$��2g�� �Ñ�eA:V��j 52.9%�£x�¤ 42.6%vI$�gÓ�P�� 1996Ô

Ǻ�v�(�ð�� ���cBC(�g!��) �@�y Îäz iª£$Ï�(Î

g!× 3y Ñ÷:*e(�V���hN(�§�!@�) �c�¯QN$�%(dN!g

:

� ð�� �ò�$»� Ã� �g!����· ¿���§�!��ò�OHÎIÒ`N!

að}O 20 �½($�q�� ��J��($�@�)eV� �Í8xQ/.�2+!

g:$�ÍS�Í$â)�g2gr�úðNÓ��i�S(�®�� 1980Ô1982 �(t�

z Bt*õ ©�(v+!q�JÑ$�J ��(�¯:@�)�c NX�(t9:�r-

�@rÓgðp:q��J��@�)�cN�@r�&�q@�)�c@r��Ã9:��M

@�e$n�&Ç�b��2+!g:Ô ���e^`N:M @� �J 3 ��($ 32 Ü

�gX`N�Kél�q@�)�c@r&½(�g!��@�)��2g�$n�� �N

:���c�$r&LeKL`N:)|�Óâ�(q@�)�c@r&@e�X`N:N� 1�

DE4wÔ�1973� ��e��� 150Ü�n�� 307Üg��1983�($hN�N 311

�432��%(���!g:

q@�)�c@r&' @�)�c õ¡$�k 16 �IeA:Ó®��$Z$q@�)

�c@r$gX`N2gÔMN(vN�����(�g!@�)�c$�2001 �"# 4,610

Üe���c 3.0%eA+_-��HNÃ÷! 20����!g:��M ñ( J��J�

�J .e���!g:�¬(�J�(�g!$ 1995�%&'(�g!¯��!g:

� �H� X�������

�XY��$ÚÛÜ���-

b!R[� 1986� 1989� 1992� 1995� 1998� 2001�

!� #351

Â0.7Ã453

Â0.8Ã644

Â1.2Ã1,095

Â1.9Ã1,344

Â2.2Ã1,231

Â2.0Ã

*� #40

Â0.7Ã38

Â0.6Ã67

Â0.9Ã228

Â2.8Ã274

Â2.9Ã328

Â3.1Ã

"� #949

Â1.7Ã1,291

Â2.1Ã1,662

Â2.4Ã2,216

Â3.0Ã2,607

Â3.4Ã3,051

Â3.8Ã

[� t367

Â0.9Ã459

Â1.1Ã579

Â1.2Ã773

Â1.5Ã974

Â1.7Ã1,172

Â2.0Ã

u[t225

Â0.8Ã337

Â1.2Ã520

Â1.7Ã879

Â2.8Ã1,219

Â3.6Ã1,332

Â3.8Ã

v� w665

Â4.5Ã752

Â4.7Ã875

Â5.2Ã1,181

Â6.8Ã1,318

Â7.2Ã1,414

Â7.5Ã

u� x208

Â0.6Ã231

Â0.7Ã395

Â1.1Ã701

Â1.9Ã713

Â1.9Ã685

Â1.8Ã

>� QÂI� JÃ

1,340

Â1.2Ã1,782

Â1.5Ã2,373

Â1.8Ã3,539

Â2.5Ã4,227

Â2.9Ã4610

Â3.0Ã

��GAH�I��JK�LMNOPQR�- ���S�·Ä5¼Å\��6-

89Ý: �Sxz�LM§�6-

Page 110: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� �����

M ��($��J� �ÇyOH8¡�� 38Ü�ôõö� 19Ü��ìB� 15Ü�¢ò²

J� 14Ü�£Z²J���ì^�p 13Ü�Ïà�J� 11Ü�¤¥B��÷¦B��p 10Ü2

���a¬hi�!g:� eú¸���º9:v�(�¦§²J��¨©�J�2��J

É��Þ¬g*N!g:�J�(�g!$¡�2)´ É(0÷:÷($�@BC(î

¡¯w: ä2O+�¼­(��� ­Ý�)pä�ú.ä`H($�òä2� �P�åÙ

ge�J`N÷eAé�8¡��e$@�)�c �®9:÷�ò�© +¬OHÅQ

��)*ijkl�£x�¤ n �9��!�I���ÃÄ(t9:*� ��9:�Í8�

��/V�Qª0eZë`N!g:

� qrst ,b{e$Ç«� 104 ÜÓn�&ÇÔ�J¬­� 70 Ü�t"@6� 64 Ü�à�

60 Ü�Ï� 51 Ü�®�� 51 Ü�îò@6� 48 Ü�Ï�� 46 Ü�Ïô� 45 Ü��ò�¯�

41Ü�+� 41Ü�8¡� 40Ü�òó� 39Ü���� 38Ü�°±�ò� 37Ü�t��²³��

p 34Ü�@]��´��p 30ÜeA+Ó30Ü&Ç�Ì��PQ1Q,Ð2003Ôh ·

�J�e$�õö� 33Ü�îï� 21Ü�ì��÷� 20ÜÓpqr�sW"�2003� 7¾Ôe

A+ �e$§�j;2Qä���@6�ú.ä�� à´( � ¹Ý��L�J��,

b{e$Þ{ Ñ÷:· �qrst @�)�c� e$�20.0%&Ç� 20!eA:��

1($�°±�ò� 84.1%�8¡� 45.5%�îò@6� 41.7%�µ�p�� 38.5%�Ïಶ�

34.5%�J¬­£a£·�#� 31.9%�t"@6� 31.5%��ò�¯�� 28.3%�Ü�¸²r�

27.8%�Ü�¸@�6� 27.2%��ì�@� 25.0%�¦§²J� 24.5%�¹�� 24.1%�Ç«�

23.1%�¨©�J� 22.2%�Ïàî�� 21.4%�V±@6� 20.8%�ô��p�� 20.6%�à�

@�6��ºD�»��p 20.0%eA+Ó� 20.0%&Ç�Ì��PQ1Q,мÇÔÖ�

Á �J� J���Tà1(Þg J�e$°±�ò�LJ¬­£a£·�#� v�(�

�� ijkl�� £x�¤�2g�$�ò�Ó,-./0Sj¶Qb.R�Ô����A

:BC¼ws3ÓWTOÔ$��½��� g�=.¬j ��Χ_� ÖS�ð��

£x�¤����!$����! ��¹ON:M�(2:g}N(ëv� J��(�g!

$)pä�@6ä��òä��eS���ä(v+!Ñ÷HN!g:®¯(��c�OIe2¬

�� �ò�$â\^@9:M��2é��Ið¯�¨-©ª¦i«P0Sj§.0�`N:

�P(�g!$�c �ò��¯\(^@9:eAé�

��AN�M��@�)�c �½xS T� �k 17 eA:MN$�J��Lê¼{

Xst(�¯:n�&Ç @�)�c b���!g:MN(vN��ð�� ��)´ �

ò78(�¯:xS T�!g:��øxS�¼m�à����� £a£ÑË�Þg�Í

\$£x�¤����à�eA:��$�Í\$à�����£x�¤ .�2:@�)�c

($N�� gX9:� ��g¡¸���J CÝ�717Ü �KN�� gX$ 380Ü

53%eAI��J� CÝ�¼m( 276Ü �K 105Ü 38.0%eA:��e 48.8%eA:�|

�è�T.¶e$�ð�� ����c(b9:N��gX $ 2001� 1.9%�2002� 3.4%

�¯��!a!g:� �@�)�c> N��gX$¾@N(�gh ÷($�Í�h

**�Í(ßÔ9:��1H2g��ÃÄÊe$�� à´xeA:£x�¤OHÉ2�Í

Page 111: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� �����

� �R� ����b�X���������������XY����

+� Ä !� � [� t u[t v� w Q

ÅÆf 4 2 0 6

e�hÆÇ 1 4 0 5

� Š2 2 1 5

� ! 31 85 37 153

� ! 25 190 23 238

Ë� Ì 1 5 2 8

ÍÎÍ

_`a 1 13 2 16

ÍÏ�Ç 36 54 20 110

Ð� ÑÇÒ­ 1 11 4 16

ÊÓÑ 1 1 3 5

ÅÔ�e 9 25 5 39

fÅÕ 5 27 2 34

�hÆe 1 11 0 12

ÅÈ�Í 1 2 0 3

ÖhÆ­ 1 3 0 4

×iÍ 3 7 0 10

Ø� ¾

_`a 3 13 3 19

Ö�e�h�Í 7 11 1 19

ÖÙÍBÍBÚ�Î�hÆf 0 4 2 6

Ê� ¤ 1 1 1 3

Í��Ç 1 3 2 6

>� Q 135 474 108 717

\]�GAH�INÞ- .//: � y ß6

\��%(bQ9:AB¢�Ý�ea2g e�,m$êëeA:��{��I�$�Í��Í

(ß^9:�9N���Í\$£x�¤(%ð+!à�����2é����g÷!N¸N��

½g���:1($�Z(£a£ ­%(ZQ9:M�(2:®é�Ó(�®� 2005Ô

� &Ç���OH"#(|:*e 60 � ���cBC �¶�M ñ����cBCOH

���cBC>��p��I��Á1(�ü1(���a¬xv�õ�� 1(�� 60 �

õa ¹�ù9:M�(v+!�ð�� ���cBC$�ò��,-./0�> õa �

Z(^÷!g:M��E�`NhN�¼­(ôõ¢$­%�­% 56(v+!ÜÎ1(�

�`N!g"#$��678ß�(v+!�A:�Pe$���78 ñ )*�ô�â�

�#`��!a!g:����78� �ô�^@�!g:M��E�`NMN*e ð

�� ���cBC$�Ï�g���p�(©�`N��OH���3456 �!ôõ¢

�÷����cBC#¢��e^`N!g:Ó�P�� 1990Ô

g}N(�!��ð�� ����$��� 60 � �¶�!d!�Y�.f�=j�� �

!�"#�;</.=0Ó£§¤jÔ �� ÁÂ�!g:Y�.fOH=j��(O¯!

��`¿�($��J��J� J ���m »-�í�ä )´£�-U� J ����

�|����cBC ¯\(`¿`ë1970�%$�J É3¸����� J�� ���

Page 112: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� �����

���cBC ©¸�O��1980�%($�âb�!��W�]o �e^� $Çßë}�

���cBC$¿ ­% á¸�hN$pµ �F_-(kN!g�¬( 1980 �%�ÓO

H��¤»ÍLhN(0õ9: ODÓU./.R§¶.Ô WX����ø9:v�(2:·

 ����mÇ«0e$�� É�W����1($ÕÎ`N:� �×ØÙ«¬.�.=.

� 1980�%�ÓOHþÙ�T\1(�ø�c ��`ë:(78�!��cYjf�»-�

� 1990�%$�,-./01256 ��(�ð���dN�ë2�H�����Q �h�

ls(���3456]o�j¶.f9:¤�1ÕPl������¤ �Æ��BCDE

ÅQ�£¤OQ¶¬�k� ��(����ÀÆ;Ö��×èzÖ����J��@)���

ÁÕ�+(�KÑ`N:�¼­(����cBC(�+tð:N�� ÅQ2� )*]o(�

·dÂ�MNH$���cBC ü1AI (�a2hi �Æ9M�(2:��M ­��

���cBC(:1(hi �H9 $��� J��¤ ����JL��t��� É�

»-��� ������CD(v: J É���ø�c](8��cÃ]����cBC(

�a2hi �Æ9

� 2000�%(Q:��3456�Ó(QI��J�� _ÝS���L�J��@)��Id

���COE��dâã89L@q89 n ÅQ��707(v:���It� ó����

�¤�Æ��S�Ö��euLerning����� �ÑQ�øÄ��st����]o�`N�"

#�ð�� ,PQRSTUVQ�57`N!g:2000�%($���mÇ«0e ²¶�³

Å��ò��ØÙ�ú.2�¹º1S�ò1­Ý(�g!�� É�»-�Zë`N:â ��

�¤�mÇ«0e$qR�L23w��¤ ÅQ�e^`N:�¬()*Ê(�g!$��J

�� @)�(78�!D�4��cd �(b�`N�`H(nq'(�w�w� ���

�]�1£aªQb('dÂ*N!g:hN�¼­(M��3456$[ZÃÄz w�

Þm� Æ��!aMNH 2000 �% 3456$���cBCLstn )*(xÇI

12hi �Æ9AB¢�A:�� 3456$����'(�)* 56 ��!����

cBC(:1Sü1�� �H�!aM��T.¶ ÇOH�E�`N!a

� g}N(ëv��� 60 � µ¶�!�ð�� ���cBC$�þÙ1(���!a e

$2¬�hN�N ­% ]oL56�é¬0õ�2�H�*`(ÜÎ1(���!aM�

T�!g:ðNðN�XE�­äå12{� �� E�9:M���%eA:M� 4-

�!�agg}N(�!��ð�� 3456 �Ý$����cBCL£¤T¥¦§S¨

-©ª¦i«Q ÙÁ ��`(¶y�!ó:M��að÷!È%eA:"# ×âÙ��5

6$,PQRSTUVQ3¸�g�gvgv�þ��(|é���!g:��*®�v$ó¸!

g2g��£¤T¥¦§S¨-©ª¦i«QÉ�3456à(A+!����cBC$�6�]

^»2­% á¸��A:

� MNOH�� 3456  ¡��!�Ta¶0ú.���678> 56�_�Þ°|78

(8�à8]^Sx ]^ �����ò12��BC(�¯:,-./02WX�q) PV

©=V§0(bu9:OP�øÄ����st��! WX�$f¯!�:M�$ea2gM

àe�â (�¯:�ö�(8��n12��J�� _ÝS�����ò�L,-./0�

Page 113: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� �����

����� BCBC WX$�"# ×âÙvI�+���Á2×ØÙ 3456�ð|®

é�

�ò12�ÆOHð�� ���cBCL)*]o�,-./02õa T�!gM��*

ZeA:Ó�P�� 2004Ô1980 �%�Ó&'�£¤T¥¦§S¨-©ª¦i«Q PkQ£

x�¤�L£¤T¥¦§S¨-Ƕ�£.f���ò1(�(|(^@9:£x�¤(�¯:

k<Õ£ÓOnfP¦§Ô ÕÖ�>Qk<Õ£ÓOn or OfffP¦§ÔL$.f¶V=. ���

�=.;S£ij¶Qf2��fg ��øG!g:MN$��£x�¤�OIe$2g�

V��je$ 1980�%(k<գ�Ӫ`N��UPQbe$ 1990�%(D��cd(?@

�ð��e� 1980�%�Ó&'�[�\ à´��YjR§S©ª-.i¦¨� -aª

§fd)*2�w� Þm��]û���^@9:â �1990�%�Ó($þËWX��ÊN�

N���$G÷!ÅQ`N�¬( 2000 �%($nq'(Lw� w��m�RVAËT0

OH£x�¤ËT0> ÌZ ~»(���að÷!�%2nq'(��! ��ÃÄ'($�

A��ÁÂ�Îah�eA:

hN�¼­(�ð�� ���cBC �¢(�g!��a2���A+�� $�Ï�

$¼ÂeA:�$ú¸2g��hN����Ï1@õ �H�!g:�$UÜea2g��h

�� $ÍÎ2õa �!g4%ÃÄ��(�g!��� LÛ_�3��!g:���

P2� åæ(v+!VQ��.T�Q, õ¡$�|eA+�O���ò12¶ÆOHó

CÝ�ð�� hN$Tà12�`(A:æ����ò1212�£3�L�+12@�)

�c �X(v+!�� $þÙö�9:�,m`N:���ò12BC�Lâã(Ï�!g¬

($�VQ��.T�Q, wª÷]o�]AFeAé���1)´£��VQ��.T�Q

, �`$�ð�� )´£� Û_L�Ð�nq'(�ÃÄj¶V0�é¬tð+!�I�V

Q��.T�Q, çf9:�g�M�$�ð�� ��1¿mn �;<9:M�eA:�

O���.-¦$�ô� à´�����cBC �ÆOHó!��� ���cBC$að

÷!�µeAI��L$PbVl b��ÇÑ� �`��1�� �%¢2�OH)*Êe

É256�%J`N:��1256  ¡��!$,¸w:â���ò�> õa�A:

M�®g}N(�!��ð�� ���cBC(�¯:ôõ¢�56�$]A� t�(A:

M��»HO(2+��æ��ð�� ���cBC �gôõ¢ ®0���`¿9:÷

($����� �V ®�9::O2Ò]1©��,¸w:34156�]AFeA:M��

E�`N20 �� ×�ÙWÚ(�g!$�É�gÙB% ÃÄz(�Në9:�O2g��

h ­�ð�� ���cBC$â�� v�2­% á¸!g:eAé�OÓ

�������

�PÔjÓ1977ÔÌ�� £¤T¥¦§o¨-©ª¦i«QÎ×���(�¯:�Íñ5 3�

�no�ÎÐÓ��ÃÄ>.f× 30ÕÔ÷¦������ÃĤQ¶.

�PÔjÓ2003ÔÌ�� ����ijklÎ�6��4ÎÐÏà��ÑÒ8

Page 114: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� �����

Ô�´S�D�â�Ó1996ÔÌ���Íw �ò�§Ð���ÑÒq

P. G. £0f/¦§��Ó�P�Ö×·ØÔÓ2004ÔÌ3456­%(�¯:���c )*]

oÎ�ò�§ �ÆOHÎÐÓCOEÃÄi�.u 5Ô÷¦������ÃĹ`¤Q¶.

ÙÚÛâÓ1984ÔÌà�×��� Ü�Î×��� Ý�M*ÎÐÜ�¸��ÑÒ8

W. ¤¥Q,jÓ£nÞâSßòàVØÔÓ1972ÔÌ�� ���ÍÐ|áâ

ãä7Ì��wc�ÐÌ����wc�Î��J���ÐÌ����wc�ΠJ���ÐA�

�� LM

�J��_8� T?ê¼LU(t9:å.1Q,,0.¨Ì�J��(�¯:T?ê¼LU x

^9:÷(� ./ÛÐ2000� 5¾ 19�

Ö`~âÓ2004ÔJÃÄz 12�£S$j���$�OKr�»¼7854æiQYaOlÌÃ

Äz 12�£S$jÐ

(�®Ó2005Ôq�� ���ò� ÷ @�)�c NXrÌ��5ñÐ× 35 ñ�÷¦�

�����ÃĹ`¤Q¶.

ÉÊ��Ó1965ÔÌ�� ���ÍBCÎ�Ï ÃÄÎÐÏ#­ÑÒ

ÉÊ����Ó1984ÔÌ���Íw ¹Ý1ÃÄΣ¤T¥¦§S¨-©ª¦i«Q 78�ÎÐ

ÞßÑÒ

tuVÓ1976ÔJ��23�!�� ø�K��78�8�Ì��78�ÃÄÐ× 31ñ

��i�S(�®�Ó1980ÔÌ�� �ò��@�)�cÐ×èp»7

����¹`ÓHEDÔUQPVQijklçSDÓwc8ü¹`ÔÎ~.Q���|è

http://home.hiroshima-u.ac.jp/hed/SD/SD_041203/SD_041203.htmé2005� 1¾ê

pqr�sÌ�!��WÚ./ÛÎ����stÎÐA���Ò

pqr�sÌ�!�c_-WÚ./ÛÐA��

pqr�sÌ������â«ÐA���Ò

pqr�sÌ����â«ÐA���Ò

pqr�sJà8��6789:K2005� 2¾

pqsÌpqs�.ÐA���Ò

pqr�sÓ2000ÔÌ;yjY�ò_-Ð

�òëìÃÄíq���� _-T.¶«.jrÓhttp://www.cc.matsuyama-u.ac.jp/~yamada

� /database/index.htmlÔ

�P�Ö×Ó1990ÔÌ���Í ?õÃÄÎ�Ï©� þ�S�� x¤<ulÎÐÏ~â

�P�Ö×Ó1996Ôqôõ¢�}~rÔ�´S�D�â��Ì���Íw �ò�§Ð���

ÑÒq�148-204î

� � �P�Ö×Ó2000ÔÌ���c �©�(t9:ÃÄÎ�� ��$)´ gO(�§0.f

9:OÎÐÓ����ÃÄïÛ 61ÕÔ÷¦������ÃĹ`¤Q¶.

�P�Ö×Ó2001Ôq���c ôõ¢Î��56$�M*e_<1eA+OÎrIDEÌ"%

����Î�ñz���c ��ÐNo.432Ó2001� 9¾ÕÔ

Page 115: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� �����

�P�Ö×Ó2005Ôq�c ôõ¢ e9� $�OÎN�� Z�WÚ �(N¸:Îr

ÌBetweenÐ10-11¾Õ�^ãR�14-17î

�P�Ö×ç%kèSñò÷ðSóôVñÓ2005ÔÌ�� ���cBC�NÎ"#S��S¾

�ÎÐÓCOEÃÄi�.u 15Ô÷¦������ÃĹ`¤Q¶.

�P�Ö×ç%kèS� ëâSôòóôÓ2004ÔÌð�� ���c(t9:)*]oÎN�

�WÚ à´(ÎÐÓCOEÃÄi�.u 4Ô÷¦������ÃĹ`¤Q¶.

�P�Ö×S� ëâSôòóôÓ2005Ôq���c N��(t9:ÃÄÎ��£QQ.fW

Ú �è à´(ÎrÌ��5ñÐ× 35ñ�÷¦������ÃĹ`¤Q¶.�87-108î

�P�Ö×ç%kèSôòóôS� ëâÓ2005ÔÌð�� ���c(t9:)*]o��N

�� ÅQSZëS�N �è à´(ÎÐÓCOE ÃÄi�.u 14Ô÷¦������ÃÄ

¹`¤Q¶.

Page 116: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� ������

� 7 �� �������� ���

� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �

� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ���� ��

������������ ����������� ����������� !"

�#$���%&��'()*+,-(./0�123�45����678�9�:;�<

�/=�4>?��#@�AB3�CDE!CFGHIJD�K8L<�� !"M�%��

N�OP3������ Q�6R"0�ST�UV?"R8�D�W8R�UV?"R/R

�D�HXY?CRL

����������

����������� ���

Z ��678[\��]^_��1877`aIb 10`c�de��fghW8LM�%�

iI�jkG>1�l%�mnhoW!"pq Xrhst���"R8L<�u\u\�vwx

yz�%{DJx|�iIH}~?�M�%�i��/�(�����h�3���"�CLF

�Eh�����u\� XG�����hW=���u\�<����(�hW!CLIb�p

q�rGR���h\���8 ������%�iI���?"RCLde�fg�&?"

#���H�4K8C��� ����6¡R¢%�H¡�K8FGhW!CL

� 1�£K ���Ib 10a1877c`�de��fgDJIb 30`�e¤¥%��¦g

Eh�dea¥%c��M�%h§s�[\�hW!CL<�fg¨©�ª#@� 50%��

��6¡R¢%�#«hW!CLCG¬­�de��®�¯�©\#$�°'±�hW!CL

°'±�h²³H?�´µ�o°'±�¶·hW!CLF�?C©��®��QOEh¸¹º»

?���®¼�x[Eh´µ���°'±�h½¾?CL^¿���ªÀ��¢%�#«��

�?"6=�RM­����¢%�hW!CLxQ�ÁÂÃ¥%��fg��8Äp 14

`��¢%�#@�Å�Ibu\G�ÆÇÅ��/È��/R��<�ÉÊ�ËÌÍ�d#

@�ÎÏK8C� 1.6%�EhÎÐ?CL

F�FG�©��6R"�¢%�#«� !"M�%��ÑÒ�6ÓÔ�Õ!FGR�ªÀ

�/Ö×HØRhR8FG�ÙÚ��8��<�¢%�#«o��ÎÛ�ÜÝ�K8�Þ!

"�d]ß¼��?Do�àá=���#«�G!"\M!"R!CLyà��� �­�

d^¿uDJIb 26`Eh�â���C��#«� 130ÁhW!C��<��ã 100Á�

äå�æ�OhW!CL

Page 117: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� ������

�� �������������������

�� �� �� �� ���� ��� �� %

1877� � 10�� 11 17 28 56 50.0

1883� � 16�� 26 37 13 76 17.1

1895� � 28�� 79 35 16 130 12.3

1902� � 35�� 202 98 20 320 6.3

1908� � 41�� 364 136 21 521 4.0

1918�����7�� 419 176 23 618 3.7

1926��� ��� 644 392 35 1,071 3.3

1931��� 6�� 705 464 29 1,198 2.5

1935��� 10�� 736 512 26 1,274 2.0

1939��� 14�� 792 585 23 1,400 1.6

����������� ������

�����������

Z Ib 19`�#�ç��è�Þ!"�de��de¥%�G?"éêë7J��Ib 30`

��e¤¥%��¦fDJÄp 14 `�ÁÂÃ¥%��¦f�ì8Eh�dí�îï�íð

ñ�ò��~óôHõ¹%öh�÷�" 7¥%��fê��CLF�u��6R"���

ö¯øùG?"�²úû�üg��8s¶�ýþ���#$����G���*�jk�k

gK8u�hoW8LF�u�������?"de��¼�ÜÝ�� ���¹�

���x©�v\�GÓ0�d�OhW!CLsv\/R?�v\H��"�����

��²«��#$�#$��'()*+,-(.�����üg?��öh�UV}BHK8L

M�%��ß¡�û�ügG�u�ýþ��Ñg�SH�?"��a'()*+,-(.co

����8L?D?�ÁÂÃ¥%�/0�Q^ø�#@*�µ+��ôÙ��ode¥�e

¤¥���?"6=�Q^¥�Ñg��Q�/!"1���C��|û�� 1954 `��h

�'()*+,-(. �!"ªÒh� 21.6%�æE8LR#��?"oR!CÓ¡���8G

�#$���678�9�}B�$/RC����AB3��M�"%Ru\hW!CL

�� ���������

1877� � 10�� �����

1886� � 19�� �������

1897� � 30�� �������

1907� � 40�� ������� �

1910� � 43�� ��������

1910� � 43�� �������

1929��� 04�� �������

1939��� 14�� !"�����

Z ?Do��¶h�%gH�&G?C®��'��(��)*+H�&G?C,-.+�/�#

@0k�C��.+«1�/�iÙ2��è 7`��ç��è�Þ�3�4�5+��

V6� !"�M�%�.+#�ûT�78�G�9:�/�;��Hjk?CLF�?C.+

Page 118: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� ������

#�!"���G!<�M�%=��>?@���?@HjkK8G�u���Q�M�%�

.+#����H�¹ÜAK8FGG/!CLZ Z

��� !����"#$���%&'(�

F�?CBCDJ�M�%��#@�����D�de¥�H�E�F�Q�G¥%

�H�&��<��H�jk��8FG�/8LE�F�Q�.+#��>1�IR"�Kh

�DJ�6R">1?CLFFh��F�Eh�M�%��#@����´,KL�MNO

PQL�R(��W8R�AB3�"K8��HSTK�­�UV��_�WX��8L

Yd�Z[\]

^����'()*+,-(.�jk

_`a�� 8~óô�G7b���C��

c����678²úû��ß¡����*�G�N�OP3

def���ghQ(�+�¢%�#@�¢¯?@/0G�123

if%j³gk�8%&�

lmn?CAB3aopqGorscZ �ߡ�Z �N�tOP3Z

?C�!"��QDJuvEh��� ��F�?C���BCHRD�ÚwK8D�jx

/yzhW!CFG�{�/RLFFh��G=M7x[ 10 Å`���� �9�����

��0� ���?CDH�&�|}?CRLF~h����� � !"�����G

¹�����678���0� ��>1��"�CD|�?"5CRL

R#��?"o�?@���� ����.O+�µ����?@���/0�?@ÈBH�

!����F��8L����� o<�s�hO�Co�hW8L���?@��Òû��

��È � 8��j����� �s�G�?Ro�G/8L������ �NO4���

´����|���DJ�OK8��+�)*L���HjAGK8LF�J�|������

�*´��+�(��� !"�¾��C�+��KL��H�!�vw�%��¾����

CLvw����� ��E=��*��� ��%�aUK���+h+�(°��+�

��*�c�<�DJ +OL���h��%h¡¢H£8!"�CLM�%�y4�%DJ

¤�k�"� ��E!CLF�J����� ����H��k=gãH¥¦K8�4�

5+§é�¦ÙK8GF� ��EG�8FG�h�8hW¨�L

F�?C����� ��h�������SÊ��W=¶�©/º»Hª¬"�C

���F�G6=hW8LK/Mã�

Y�«�9_�g�é��«����

^��ûT�¬�­g®�û���rs������¾��ß¡�û�ÚÒ

Page 119: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� ������

_Üû¯p������g¢¯:;°±�COE� GP°±/0

c%g�²��g*+�+�LN���G�³�Ñ´��tµ¶@�

d,-��«g,-�����

irsûT��¾gÑ·_|rs�E¸¼rs��¾�¹}rs/0

lö¯øùG����ºg#���øù�¬ºk�²úûDJ|øù�

»�O��g¼�±�æ�O�%&�

½<��

Z F�J�����Üû¯p��� ��s¾���H¿=EG�".µ+N�?"R8?�À

#?o������h�8o�ho/RL?D?��Q�M�%���ÁÂ�����êD

�C�ÃHÙÚK8Uh�/º»Hª¬8��hW8LUVh�F�?C�������

HBC������������Ã�IR"7Ä?"5 �L

)��*�#$����+����� � � � � � � � � �

����������

M�%����Q 60`H��?CLF�9�ED/^>��G?"� 15`§éhF�Å

I�u�HÆ7h�8FG��JhÇÈCLK/Mã�Es��¦É�GoÊ��8o�h�|

û�^¿DJ 1975 `Eh�u�hW8LF�u���DDJ�.+#�!"H¬ºk?"|

C/|û���¾��¦É��Cu�hW8L�¤ñËÌ�,-.+�/�«1�/�|û

�G?"�¤ñËÌ�fê��CL<�G�u�|C/.+#�Íx�ά8ȹ%µ3gÏ

�fg��CLйE��� 1960`Ñ1975`�D7"��M�%�.T��k¸HBC��

o3�4�5+H�&�Ï�Å`û��ÒÓ��ÏK8u�hW8L�#@Å��Qs

Ô?"Ï?"R8��F�u�� 1975 `DQ��3g��#@Å�%g�<�H���"

ÕÖ?�<�U×�ؼ�6Ù�ÚK8s¶hW8L�Q�E¸��Û¨K8���1975`Ñ

1990`��9hW8LF�u���4� �¾�¼SÅ�ÎÛ�Üû���#@�Å��ÝÏ

Þ?"R8G�R¬�<�Eh�ÏÞGß?RÇàH£KFGDJF�u�HÜû�GÊ?"R

8LEÅ� 1990 `\���� ��6R"�E�Fáâ+)+��ãäh¾�¼Å�4� �

Ï�å#8L<�Q� 18 æ�ç�ÎÐ�.O+�µ�/�����º»oW!"è�/�Ë

H�WK����� �����CL��:;�¢¯°±��¾� =����é4��8

s¶���Ñj�/�³��¾���#����kê�ÇK8��+�ëµ�+��ìIí®

��?¹NM�8 ��/!"�CL

F�9��#$���Bî�IR"7ÄK8G�F� �/ïîHð5¿8FG�h�8L

K/Mã��Q 60`�Es���d�Z[� 3É�ñ?"6=�Ué 3�h���òÅ�

[ó��"RCLE����d�Z[�Å7�sa25%c�ôèK8G�u��G¥%�H

�&G?C�#$���jk����8��Ué 5�h���ò7H[�8L¢%��"

M!C#@ÅG<�ÉÊ�á�� 10¾=K8L1980`\���^>�Üû��8u��/8

Page 120: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� ������

G���õöK8C�D�d��Q�� 15%÷�ÛÐK8G�u���ÑÒ��¥%�H

�&G?Cø���� !"7b��)OL����Côù���jk��CLø���H

�&G?Côù��`a���C���jk��"�CLF�J�BC����Üû�/^>

���º»?"R8FGH£ú?"R8LEÅ����� ��¾8G�4� UV����

Ú�Þ!"�)OL����"RC��� =AB3H.�"R!CLCG¬­�de��

�Q��ªÒ� 1 É�%VK8G�u��Ué����Q��R#�o%VK8LUé 10

�h��ªÒ� 5ÉH[�8GR�©û/u\Hü¬8LF��AB3G:; H.�C)OL

��DJª%����%u\Hü¬"R8FGH£KLF�?C�Q�:;��h¢%�]ß

¼a¢%h�éH¿ý?C��þ¢%�#@c�E¸é�UVK8GGo��UV H�¹

.�"R8FG�����K8LF�J�ª%�G%&��R!<�4àK8FGH£ú?"R

8L

UU�ªÒ�/BîH��?C��ýþ��BîH7ÄK8G�Y�RL�Q 60 `9h�

(�G�Q�H��UV��C��\����ò�Á�d'����Î/0��

J�8a¢%��ÌÊÒhW8c���(�G�Q��UV�EséhW8L�(��%V?

"R/R���Q�H%V��C.µ+N���d�e��ä/0�¾8LF��Ç?"

�(�G�Q�Go�%V��C.µ+N���dí�îï� �d��s�/0�

¾8LF�J�BC������ôù�ÁÂ�ýþ���Ã/0�º»?"R8 ����

�� � !"��:;�Û?¹/�­�ãø��7ø�Ù� =�¹/=<�hW8L

)� ,-./012345���%&'(

Sectors #$%&

State Control

�'()*+�

���������� �������������������

������� ��!"#$�21%& COE'()*+�GP'(

)*+�� �� ,��-./����0�12���3

�45�6�7845�)(9:;45�<=�>?@AB45

�CD�EF�GH��IJKLF��MNOPEFQR>12

�,S��TUVWXY�Z[\]M^[\]_`a3WbcW/d

Market Control

�,-./01/�

�<=�eT��f�gh'ij�k;9'ij�lmj'ij3W

noWCD�NOPEF3W,S��p�qrst93

��p<=�u/<=�no<=�0�EF<=���

����v<=�wxyW<=Tz{W,|W�}Pp~y

Institution Control

�23456�

�����i��hW��/��/12��f�no���9�k�p~y

���IJ��vW1����/�J���

�CD�Y�� �� ,�����UV���IJ�����3

���,|�[��W�������lW�h���l�orB��3�

��WZ���bc�����/T�� 3�¡¢B���£¤

¥�?¦§�qg�¨�©�sªh«9}¬

�­����#$T��fno���/d�®��¯�v�3��$>°±�

����

Buffer Control

�789:;<=��

�"²�eT�³´�µ�W³´�µ¶·W� �� ,¸W[ ��

¸W¹�º»W¹�¸¼

�½¾�¿12�����¸W³´ÀÁ�f12�ÂW��12��ÃvÄ

�ÂÁ¼

�NOPEF�Y�ÅÆÇÈÉ�ÇÊ�³´�µ¶·ËÌ�®TËÌ

��¸�ÍÎ�ÏÐ�Kw�[Ñ>,S�T>12

�~�ºÒ�¿�ÍËÓhÔ9

Page 121: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� ������

�������� !�"�#$%��

Z Nz���¼0k��ö¯��hW8L��DJy��£?"5 �L� 4 �jx� 13

/�'()*+,-(.È�H£?Co�hW8a�ª%��@��%µg����?�Z ¨

Û` =7Ä?CL�ö�ê����4(5++Hõ¹²«UU��¶#@�UV��ûcLF

Fh���J� 3I�.µ―N�7�?"7Ä?"� �L

6� #$������789:1;<8=����

�� � 1954� 1963� 1974� 1984� 1994� 2003��� � 98.0 96.7 94.3 89.5 83.6 78.0

�� � 86.6 87.5 86.8 84.1 80.1 72.3

>?@� 83.1 79.2 82.3 82.9 72.3 71.1

AB� 75.3 69.7 81.2 78.7 70.1 63.8

�� � 55.1 63.7 64.9 62.4 59.1 51.0

��� 52.4 56.9 55.6 59.0 62.5 55.6

� � 21.6 22.0 29.7 44.6 53.8 44.4

�� � 42.0 42.9 57.2 60.2 61.4 59.6

�� � 52.8 60.4 64.1 65.6 62.9 55.8

CD� 46.6 46.5 54.8 29.5 40.2 40.7

�E� 30.7 42.3 48.3 52.9 58.9 56.1

FG� 58.0 58.8 47.4 50.3 43.4 32.1

H� � 36.8 40.7 37.9 43.1 39.4 38.9

������ ��������� ���� �� !""# ��$%� !""! �� !""# ���

���� ���& �� !""# ����� !""" ����

� Es��%g�G3g���LN�G?"�d�e�Î� !".µ+NhW8L

F� 4 /��H�F� ��x#h�8LK/Mã�1950 `\��R#�o 75%UU�Ñ$

H£?"R8Ld�e�|û�G�R¬��D�û%H<�EE&'?"6=�85%UU

�Ñ$ H£KL�hod� 98%�Ñ$ hö¯���Ñ/]ß¼h=[��"R8L?D?�

F�òv(�9�d 20.0%�e 14.3%� R#�o 12%DQG�R#���oÑ$ H

¤�%V��"R8L<��ê�F� 4/�Ñ$ ��70%÷ 3/�60%÷ 1/Eh%VK8

���ÝG?"�LN 4/�¾8LST��)¬­��LN/�**+��+����W!"

FE�Ñ$ HV�"R¹���ÝG?".R'()*+,-(. H,-?"6=�.��+

/µ��� 2000`\�¾!"V×�(0H1�"R8L

Z E���2=�G¥hW8í�dí�Á�ò�î.µ+NhW8LU½�Es�

.µ+N��?"�F�J�.µ+N�Q^øhW8Ldí�í�Ib 40 `�î�I

b 43`�ò�Á�D/=k�"�Äp 6`G 14`hW8LE 1.µ+N�d�e�%

g.µ+NH�?"�8G�'()*+,-(. �>3H45?"y^6�0.RL�Q�

|û�G?"¬ºk��8Eh�ò�Á���uÒû�9H75��80k�9�97G

�)R�CRL<�J�BC�|û^¿u�'()*+,-(.H45?"R8L

F�J�.µ+N��: 50 `9�6Ù��Ro���+����4à?/�Jo�Ñ$

�UV��"R8LF� 50`9�Á� 23%�ò� 17%oÑ$ HU�"R8Lî� 1980

`\Eh� 13%�í� 60 `\U× 10%DQUV?"6=�uvo 50%�;<H=!"R8L

F�J�.µ+N��.��+/µ����}à�Hü¬"�R#�����o'()*+,-

Page 122: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� �����

(. HV×����"R8LE 1GE 2�.µ+NH�?"ؼ�Çà�hW=����

GR¬0os¶��Ñ$ H%V��"R8�h�/RL<�G�u�ؼ�.µ+Nh� 1950

`\�6Ù��R��.��+/µ��HîD¬"�ؼ�6Ù�ôè?IIW8���Q�

�}H�>8Àx�W¨�L

R#��?"oE 2.µ+N�?@A�ÁhW¨�LF�òv(�dG�Çà�� 20%U

U�Ñ$ HUV��"R8LÁ�ôÙ��dGe��9�W!"��Q�B¹Ø��

~óô�ôé�CÓ�"RCLG¥xQ�u�hW8 1947`��®�¯� 60Á�a²«UUc

48Á�80%�Á¥]ß¼hW!C��'�¯� 58Á� 6Á�10%�Ù�¯� 40Á� 0Á�

0%h���:� 3�¯HÊM�" 149Á� 87Á�58.4%�Á¥�]ß¼hW8L��:Hõ

7­�®�¯U¢�Ë/h0k?C�8��GÓ0R/D!CL

|ûQ� 1954 `����@��HDoGR"�i�¯�]ß/H7Ä?"�"o�²«U

U� 29 ÁhW8��<��ãd]ß¼��16 Á� 55.2%�e]ß¼� 12 Á� 41.4%h�

ؼÊM�" 97%�ñK8L2= 2Á�î��E?�� 1ÁhW8LÑ/]ß¼�R/RLG

)� =�G¥G?"� 1939aÄp 14c`�®�¯GÙ'�¯�'2`�G?"xoQ^

6G?"^¿?�i2`��O�FohW!CL?D?�2004`uv�i�¯#@ 55Á��

ã�Ñ/]ß¼ 21Á�e 11Á�d 10Á�dí�ò� 3Á�<�� 7Áh�Ñ$ �

40%÷EhUV?"R8LÙ�¯�'�¯o|û��¯G?"]^?C��h���u���

GÓ097/�80k�h�/D!CC���'()*+,-(. ��Ù�¯ 4.3%�'�¯

26.1%G%R�áµDJ]^?"R8a�ÁÂÃ� 50 `3�1995cLA¢�/®�¯� 80%

GR�.RÑ$ DJ]^?CFGHõ7­�©¹�¯Gh��Q 50 `9�%RÑ$ HFE

�UV��C�hW8L

E¸��ä� l�s��d'��D�iÙ���,-��D3H-I.µ+N

hW8LF�J�>3�HRDJ<�I�©û/���û%H£?"�CLF�.µ+Nh��

,-.+#��ø�H-Id'Gs�Gh����J���.��+/µ�����H�/

�Jo�Çà�/Ñ$ �BîH£KLK/Mã�d'�ÁÂÃG�û��QsÔ?"Ñ$

H.� 60%DQHx.�uv� 55%DQhKãLR"R8LF��Ç?"s�h� 1954`

DJuvEhs¶��Ñ$ H%V��"R8LK/Mã�F� 50`9�Ñ$ � 58%DJ 32%

G�����hx�V�¤H½�?���� 13 /��h�xoÑ$ �%¹�ö¯��

� 68%��/]ß¼�12��"R8FG�/8LF�BC��sÒ0� �/��MÙ�NO

?"R8�D�YW8��ÇPhW8��F��F~h7ÄK8L

F��Ç?"�äG l��uv�40%DQ��Q��;<�W8L?D?uvEh�Ø

¼��R�D/=û%HS�?"R8LD¼�Dß��T�� ��de#��hW8�#@

0kH�UG?CiÙ2��ø�H<�EE&'?�|û�fgu�SÊ���àM�/

D!CL<��7�#�w���HBCG?" 55%�Ñ$ �.�H£?"RCL1973` 10V

�ä�^¿K8��|�W���� H��"�X��`�#���øùH7Y��8G�

u��?@2��?@'��®��Z[\Ã]`��78HÚ���SÊ����GÈ^?

Page 123: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� �����

Ca�ª%�s_�2004cL|�ù�78h�Ñ/���OH`aK8FG�bchW8

C��1980 `\��Ñ$ � 20%÷�Eh%V?CLuvhoU½�|78h��ÝG?"Ñ

$ �%RLR#��� Ï�9h 25%�Ñ$ �Ð$��� �RD�ÜÝ�MC8o�h

W!CD�F�WdhoÙÚh�8Ls¶� ��Q�|û��� u��ä��Åòv

(yÓ�"�iÙ2�HËÒGK8 l.+�/�.+'��/�®2�+��Ê� !"

SÊ���åß�ZJ�CL<�U×� �Ñ$ ���Q 40%DQ�;<h�}?"R8L

i���2�#����2�#���&Ù��#2#��78hÑ$ �.¹���2ªÒho

6 ÉUU�Ñ$ hW8��iÙ2H�k?"RCÙ���2�Ñ$ �uv�28.0%Eh%

V?"R8LF�Je¸{U¢�²���2�yzfg2���2�%&hi��2h� 10%÷

�;<hW=�Q^��2oj�CªÒ��kÑ$ � 40%Hl=�SÊ���h�xo12

�hW8a�ª%��@��2003cL

R#��?"o�F�J�������Q 60 `�**+��J��.��+/µ����

�H�/�Jo����ÇÎGàB�.µ+Nö�6R"��/EîH�W?"R8GF¨oü

D�¹�J�8��.µ+Nö�ým���6R"%HK8GF¨oW8LF�J��<�I

���!"�êD�Cfêjn��N�ù�����G���\]�º»?"R8�%H/RL

Z UU��Q�Ñ$ �IR"��?CLfêjn��N�ù�!"�%H� !"'()*+

,-(.�Bî��¹op��"R8FG�qr��CLs¶h�«�Úa��«��

�9_�� 1990 `\U×����� ��hé4������¼0k!<� =s:�Úa

?C�oüD���ªÒ���s�%�'()*+,-(.���+��.��+/µ��

�6R"s¾��Ë�ýþ!"�� H�?"L��Ð$?IIW8L<�?C\]��Dh�

Es��s�%����G?"�xo�U��ø��/âL. 4���ÎÛ�<�ÉÊH%

V��"R8FG�Pt�hW8L<?"E���'�¯�ª%�k�Ñ$ �%V?"R8�

oDDMJ#�'�`hxoø��/sIhW8d'�Ñ$ �ÎÛ�UV?"R8L'�`

��Rdí�Á�ò/0o'()*+,-(.H.�8ïî�W8Lu��E¸��?@

2�`�ª%�koüD�%V?"R8o���s��<�UU�ÎÛ�'()*+,-(.

HÐ$���ö¯��H12?"R8LEÅ��G¥G?"�xoQ^�Á���SÊ�

G?"¬]^?C�ä����¼�Ñ·0k�v<�/8�¾�"'()*+,-(.H.�

"R8L<?"Ew��1990`\QòDJuvEh�.��+/µ����S�6R"���

��ä��§sÑ$ HUV��"R8�Hõ7­�'()*+,-(.HÎÛ�Ð$��"

R8��$/¹/RLF�J�%HHO5]?"R8o��xDL

UVh��F�J�BC�IR"©y��|�K8L<��Ê�jx��Pz´µ�-�0

� �/{3H-I��¼D�G¹��é��_DJ|}K8L'()*+,-(.HªÒ��

%V��"R8���ö¯��H12?"R8M7���R!CRs�%�jx����0

� �/�8�12?"R8�D�ö¯���Bî�IR"7Ä?"5 �L<�J�7ÄH�

?"����� 21v(��ÇÎ�sz��¬"¹8�%H/RL

Page 124: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� ������

�&�����'()*�

��+,$�

Z UÇ��G¹�����'()*+,-(.�IR"�G¹�d�e� !"�Î�

âL. 4��Q�20%DQ'()*+,-(.H%V��"R8L��G¥o��� UDE

h�'()*+,-(.H����"�C����� Q�<�JH%V��"�CLF�?C

ªÒG?"���� V�����ö¯��H���]ß¼�12?CFGH£ú?"R8L

~¼�7Ä� �­�13�ªÒ��{#@� 14,686ÁhW!Ca²«UUcL<��ã�13

����]ß¼� 12,460Áh�<���st�]ß¼� 2,226ÁhW!CL13���]

ß¼����ÑÒH 85%Eh=[?"6=�st�]ß¼� 15%�G0E8L

>� ?@A2345#$����+��

IJ� �� �� KL�� MNOP =� Q R� Q� MNOS�

1 ���� 3,033 20.7 1,391 1,642 39.7

2 ���� 1,738 11.8 980 758 18.3

3 ���� 1,065 7.3 733 332 8.0

4 ���� 959 6.5 813 146 3.5

5 ���� 915 6.2 652 263 6.4

6 >?@� 798 5.4 684 114 2.8

7 �� �� 797 5.4 644 153 3.7

8 A� B� 789 5.4 690 99 2.4

9 � �� 661 4.5 457 204 4.9

10 CD�� 556 3.8 458 98 2.4

11 �E�� 515 3.5 313 202 4.9

12 HT�� 479 3.3 417 62 1.5

13 FG�� 155 1.0 91 64 1.5

�� � 12,460 66.8 8,323 4,137 33.2

��'�()�*+,-./�0123456�7�658��

� 5��2003`T���@���ëR"��� 13��]ß�H7Ä?Co�hW8

aC�?����U¢�]ß¼�õ¹cLF�� �­�1 é�de�]ß¼h���#

@ªÒa²«UUc12,460Á��ã 3,033Á��Q�� 20.7%H[�8a�Q� 1��cL2003

`T�M�%��#@���d]߼��Q�� 11.4%hW!CDJ����h��Q 2

���Q�H£?"R8FG�/8LF� 3,033Á�d]ß¼��ã 1,391Áad�Ñ/�

�c�Ë/�d��¶?"6=�2=� 1,642 Áad��/��c�dHõ¹�� 12

�������¶?"R8L��� 13�hË/U¢��¶?"R8#@��13���

ªÒh 4,137����� �������� 39.7%�� 4����������� �

!"#$%&'()*�+,-.(�/01 2 � �23��� �456� 12 �

�7�8(/01�/01 2 � �#9(*�:� 18.3%�;� 8.0%�dí 6.4%�Á

Md' 4.9%�í 3.7%�îï 3.5%� !" 2.8%�Î 2.4%��ä 2.4%�s±� 2.4%�

2.4%��hW8LF��êDJÙÚ��8 ���ª%��#@��G������G

Page 125: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� ������

h��]ß���Q���¹S/8FG�ÙÚ��8LK/Mã�Es��d�Z[\]

�������h���"¹���8Leo 16%÷H£KLE������9��Q�6

Ù��RGR�FGhW8LDJ�ª%���Q�����6Ù�<��0�¹�/R

������]ß/U¢�#@��h��dGeHÊM�"ªÒ� 58.0%��Q 6ÉH=

[K8LE¸��E�G"¾?"�ä� �������Q��Ñ/U¢���"$/R

GR�FG�ÙÚ��8LG¥�ø�H-I6�Ué��������R��FG��/�

�bchW8FGH£ú?"R8L�ä�ª%����Q��DJh£?C ���E 4é�

�R���������h�Ë/U¢�M#D 98 ÁH�=�����/RLF�FG��u

��M�%��#@���������`a�?C�)R�¬�­�~óô�� 87b

���C��H�ÝG?"jk?"R8FGH£ú?"R8LUU�,+5��������

�:;��?�H£KG�u��������ÑÒ�123��97hW8FGH£ú?"R

8L�������ÑÒ�����5'µ�/!"©�"��12��"R8G)¬8Do

?�/RL

���-�

Z E#����G�#�����_hW=�<��U��N�OP3a��c� !"kgK

8L<�C�����g���N�OP3��_DJrs��8L�é�<�R��Yh�N�

OP3�KÈ"h�/R����?CWdG?"7Ä�v<hW8L|û�� 1949aÄp 24c

`�|û�« 1953aÄp 28c`�^¿?CL� 6� �­�1954`�����¿ý\]�G

¥�>3H-I���h� 30%DJ 40%÷����¿ý H£?"R8Ld�e�ò

<��ÑÝ2�`�§2��d'� 45%H�¬"R8LF��Ç?"iÙ2�ø�H-I

��|û�u�SÊ��?C �?@2�`�s��i2`�[�8ÉÊ�.R !"

��<�I� 15%DQh�D¼��Q¸7�shW8L|û��^¿u��ؼ�Ù��RL

B� #$������CDEFG����

�� 1954� 1963� 1974� 1984� 1994� 2003��� � 33.9 73.2 68.2 75.7 78.1 83.6

��� 36.3 73.6 72.9 76.8 75.1 86.0

�� � 45.1 72.0 72.2 72.5 75.9 81.6

� � 38.4 66.7 71.4 83.2 84.3 83.5

�� � 46.9 71.5 75.9 80.9 83.6 87.9

�� � 47.8 74.7 81.0 82.5 83.5 89.7

�� � 40.0 65.7 71.6 78.5 81.5 87.0

CD� 19.4 50.9 57.6 61.7 67.1 78.4

�E� 45.0 75.1 85.1 91.2 88.9 97.7

FG� 16.0 39.5 26.3 31.8 38.7 50.0

H� � 16.6 40.3 62.3 67.0 70.6 79.6

>?@� 15.5 28.7 26.9 33.1 41.5 42.1

AB� 29.3 23.2 35.0 53.0 55.3 59.2

��9:��

Page 126: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� ������

Z uvh�G¥� 7 /�R#�o 80%UU��é�¿ý H�!"R8L1980 `\QòDJ

M�%�����ySDJ�«yS�FE��P�?��CL������¼0k�h

W8C��<��k@hW8#@�¨Ý�é¿ý¼hW8FG�x���8u\G/!"�CL

<�ho�ÝG?"789hÙ��J�8LA¬­�ÑÝ2�`G?@2�`�§2��Çà

�/BîH£?"R8LD¼�d'������h�97.7%Gxo.¹�²«UU 560Á��

����éH-!"R/R�� 13Á���/RL13Á��ãi2` 7Áa1Á�Ò����c�

ÑÝ2�` 6 ÁhW8L¨��6R"��Q ¹DJ��é�#$V4�ÁÂG��"6=�

�&����H-C/Rè#$�ª�h 5Áai2` 3Á�Ù2` 2Ác���#�F�?C�

���à������;<H.�"R8a�ª%��@��2003cL�¶�Q¼�s�� 10

`DEh� 30%÷�EhæE=������h�x%hW!CLF� 10`9� 12%Ï�x.

���H½�K8LF�Ù´�QÇK8FG�?"�¨�h�Ñ$ H%V��8s¶��é

�¿ý �%Ro��x[��δ+)hUV��"R8FGHFFhWX?"6�CRL

� �ä� �|û^¿u�� 10%÷��é¿ý hW!C���Q 60 `9��é¿ý\]

��¥�>1?"R8LUÇ?C ����ä� 1973`�^¿u��Ñ$ � 20%÷�4Ç

�)¬­�/]ß¼� !"gãU�J�C���é� ��E!C¹º»?"R/RLA¬­�

?@'�`�|C�fê��C78�7��1984`���ho 70Á��5LP��ãÑ/]ß

¼�²«UU��s�oR/RLECi2`�Ù2`H¾�K8�&78�oDDMJ#���

�¿ý¼� 67.1%H[�8L�J�#����2/0h��2000 `\�¯G��Þ�¬ºkU

����Q�yS��¨#@��#���&Ù�`/0� 70%÷UU�Ñ$ H=!"R8G�

R�o������¿ýH�¨°6xÂK8/0?"ö¯��Hfê��@����<UU��

?¹?"R8LF�J�!"�Ñ·ÜûH�?"g�=}�!<HêC?"R8a�ª%��

@��2003cL

� M�%��#@���"K8���E 3 F¥�hIJD�/!CFG���#@���

�Q��d�e�ÐR"ð¢��]ß¼�E 3 éH[���i�?@2�h� 1�2 éH

:��0�/!CLM�%��#@��h¢%��é¿ý¼�Esé�/8�o<� ¹/R

�¨�L�������'()*+,-(.Nz�Úw²�9x/sI�%&�hW8LE#�

�é�¿ýyDJ%&��IR"7Ä?"� �LA¬­�� 7�����#@��ãð¢h

���H0�¹JR¿ý?"R8DH7Ä?CLF�� �­ 1954 `���h��da#0

¯c1Á�d'a'�¯c2Á�s�a���¯�?@�¯c2Á� !"a#��¯�)

�¯�Ù'�¯c3 Á�Îai�¯�®�¯c4 Á�ÊM�"Ê¡ 12 ÁhW!CL13 �

h�<�¨u�#@S¡� 5,338hW!CDJ�<�¢] � 0.22%G)�FG�/8a��

�@��1954cL%&�GR��_h�t£�k�"6=��?¨Ibu\�^¿u�¶� �

0%&�?"RCG)¬8LE�F���¤%��h��#��¥¦���°'±��§%�

�¬ð¢æ�K8ã¨��GÓ0/D!CL1963 `\h���¹ 13 �h 28 ÁaªÒ 7,131

Ác�ªÒ� 0.39%�;<hW!Ca�ª%��@��1963cLF�u�� !"� 11 ÁG

ð¢h�éH¿ý?C#@�xo©D!CL1974`\�/8G��hð¢��é¿ý¼�Fo

Page 127: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� ������

GR�FG�/¹/8L<�ho�k� 9,110Á�� 92ÁG�kh 1.01%G 1%÷H ��¹ü

=K8 ��/8L1984`\�/!"s�%�����%&��D/=4>?"¹8L¢%�

éH¿ý?C��ªÒ 10,949 Á� 278 Áh�� DJ�8G 2.53%G�ÏK8LG¹� 1994

`\�¾8G�F�Àh�%&��s:4>?"¹8L12,371Á� 636Áh�5.1%G 5%;<H

�¬"¹8L21v(©©� 2003`uvh� 14,829Á� 913Á� 6.2%hW!Ca�ª%��

@��2003cL

H� #$������I�CDEFGJ����

1954� 1963� 1974� 1984� 1994� 2003��� � 0.0 0.0 0.7 1.3 2.7 5.8

��� 0.0 0.0 0.6 1.4 2.9 7.1

�� � 0.1 0.1 1.2 2.8 6.8 6.9

CD� 0.0 0.0 1.7 5.5 7.5 8.9

�E� 1.4 1.0 2.1 4.4 2.8 4.3

FG� 2.5 2.6 1.5 6.9 15.6 19.0

� � 0.0 0.6 0.6 1.3 3.3 4.6

�� � 0.0 0.4 2.2 3.2 6.0 5.7

�� � 0.0 0.2 0.8 2.7 3.8 2.9

H� � 0.0 0.2 0.4 2.6 4.8 4.8

�� � 0.0 0.2 1.2 1.1 3.3 4.1

>?@� 0.5 1.7 0.7 1.5 5.4 6.6

AB� 0.9 0.2 0.3 1.1 5.3 8.8

��9:��

�J��F�J�����ð¢h�x��é¿ý�ôùþ7ª��� 8�£K�G¹���

*´� 578Áh�'«*� 81Á�P�(� 48Á�°'± 44ÁGй��íå�7hð¢¿ý

¼� 70.7%H=[K8LF��Ç?"� +OL�ôùh�¿ý¼� 197Áh���¹ 23.3%H

[�8LäåhªÒ� 94%H[�8FGH£?"R8LF�J�,+5��N��&ô���

G!"äåhW8FGH£ú?"6=�#�Àh�æ�O��h��&hW8FGG¬ÇàH/

?"R8L

K� #$������LM�NFG��

UV � WX % WX YZ[\ ��[\

]� � ^ 13,842 94.3 13,842 94.3 __�

O`ab 578 3.9�� c

bde 19 0.1

597 4 70.7

fga/ 81 0.6

hi1/ 48 0.3

jfk 44 0.3

lmnop

qrR 24 0.2

197 1.3 23.3

s� � 8 0.05

t� � 10 0.1OuO

qrR 8 0.05

26 0.2 3.1

vwOxO y� � 15 0.1 15 0.1 1.8

qrR 9 0.1 9 0.1 0.1

� 14,686 100 100 100 844

� � � � ���;<,-=>?�@<ABC DBC� EFGH� IJ����

Page 128: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� ������

�¶�M�%�ýþ!"�G�5C%&����/Ù�W8LfêjnDJ�8G�3g

���*���(`��¢%�`�¯���6R"�´,KL��NOPQL�R(�%&

�� ¹DJ4à?"RCLQÇK8 ���¢%�#@�3g�µg��A!"h� �.¹�

ð¢�éo�AK8L2003 `uv�%g������ho�ð¢�é� 15%UU�%&�

�4>?C�¯H�"58G�íh�����2a17.8%�UV§é­®¯��#@ 10ÁUV

�¯G�­®c�%& ]�,-���2a16.7c�díh������2a17.0c�%&i

���2a16.7c��äh�?@'�`a37.7c�u\��u\i��`a21.4c�?@2�

`a18.8c�i��)��`a17.2c�ô°2�`a16.3c�±�²W�`a15.8c�dh�

�����2a41.2c�#����2a15.2c�s�h�%&³��®��2a50.0c���

���2a43.6c�Áh�%&1^��2a21.2c�òh�%&µ�����2a20.0c�

h�?@2���2a22.0c����¯a20.6c�Îh��´Ã]�¯a33.3c��³µ

Ù��2a26.9c����¯a22.4c�����,-���2a18.2c�SÊ���¯a17.8c

�Û¨K8LF�JDJÙÚ��8 ������/0�?@2�`�¢%��i��/0�i

2`6 �%&`�?@'���´���/0�¶Ê�ù�6R"%&���8���kg?"

R8FGH£ú?"R8a�ª%��@��2003cL

ýþ�ªÒDJ�8G�s���ä�Îh 8%UU�ð¢�é�¿ý¼hW=�G

¹�s�h� 19%�ñ?"R8LD·hWX?C ���s�h�'()*+,-(.�

�ÎÛ�%V?CÙ´��Ñ/U¢�ð¢�é¿ý¼�*�µ+�� 8L��G�¢¸�¹�

hW8GR��g�/�ÙDJÚºK�­�R¨R¨/»`¼H�N�OP3��_DJµ��

p|?C�ê��N�OP3�Pt�/Wd�sIhW8ð¢�é�¿ý¼� =.R¢¸�.

R��¼G?"rs���¼J�0�ST�Ñ/]ß¼�G!"\M!CD½bK8Àx�W8L

s�h�Ë/]ß¼��é�¿ý¼�¢]��¾��8�0��"R/RGR���oW8L

<�C��Ë/]ß¼�\M!"ð¢�é¿ý¼� =.¹rs��CGK�­�<��<�/

=�¿�7G/8�¨�L?D?��¶h�ð¢�é¿ý¼�À®Q�<���¾��8�0�

OP3HÀ#?o£?"/R�h�/RDGR��?R��o"Á¼����W8L9x/_��

��*´��é�� �M�%��é�� �<�uv�éêë7��UD�M�%�Gû��

é�éêë7G%H?"��#@��°6G?"�W8R�F�DJÑg?C��¼G?"

5/��8�°6G?"�/��8���/RFGH�"�/8ERL

R#��� ��é�-I�³�7��N�OP3�ÇK8�é�éêë7��8�0k�S

��N�ù� !"%HK8?�ð¢�é�?@�s�o78� !"S/8L'�`�\�C

8d'h��é�¿ý �UV?"R8��ð¢�é¼�*�µ+���M�"%RAoW8L

?D?�ªÒ���"�s�� �/?@2�78��Ah��/��?D�'()*+,-

(.Ħ����öÜ��A/0�/RÅ=�$/¹Goâ�u�678¢¸¹���êG?"

'()*+,-(.�ÎÐ?CGÚºKÈ�hW¨�LF�FG���éÆmh�/¹�M�%

����ÖÇ��C�#@���6R"-I�³��M�"9xhW8L���6R"o�

��`��³`/0h.R��s�h�?@2�`�§2��U��%&³��®��2�

Page 129: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� ������

|f� !"ð¢�é�¿ý¼� 50%GR�t£�%&�/*�µ+��/��"R8Ls�

h�'()*+,-(.�BC���M�%��#@��� ��¹¢¸¹���G?"È5

��CFGH£úK8G�u��Ñ/U¢�G=M7ð¢��é���jk��"R8FGHf

�8L��� U×�.O+�µ�5(�+°HBC��F�?CÉÊ�s�%������

�78�0� �/º»HËQKD���Q�'()*+,-(.�>1H�A�8Uh9x/

�_�/8�¨�L

&�.��-/01+,$�

UÇ?C ���uv�M�%��#@����¹È�?C�t�sI�%&��W!CL

F��#@���%&���8�/ÌÀ�L�?"58G�¢%�#@G���ð¢��

h��é¿ý¼GR�¶î3h7Äv<hW8LD¼�IR"�Kh�DJh)Ë?C?�Q¼

�IR"oD·hÍ�CLFFh�Q¼�NzH�J�7Ä��|}?"5 �L

K/Mã����ð¢h��é¿ý�"?"%&�/�#@���jk��"R8�h�

/R�¨�D�GR�ÎìhW8LF�?C%&�/����yz�/����#@���z

��u�8o�hW8L����ð¢�é¿ý¼�?@2���ho����²���³/0

�.O+�µ�?C,-��ù�6R"ÎÏ?CFG�Kh�WX?CLUÇ������ã

ð¢��h�éH¿ý?C#@�]ß/H7Ä?C���� 9hW8LZ Z

O� CDEFG���P8Q8=�

IJ� z{��� �J|}~X�

1 b�h��xO�� 47

2 �m�mj�� 33

3 /�1h�mj�<pa�� 32

5 �M�1�� 25

6 n1j1�� 21

7 fa�f�<MIT<�m���� 20

10 n�N/�m�� 19

11 f�m��<�f/�1M1�<�1�aou�� 16

14 vo�/h�mj�<�n1�O�<�m/�N/�1�<��f�� 13

��KL�,-M3NO��

��ÏóÁÐh)¬­�17�aXch�$/¹Go 13ÁUU��é¿ý¼����

��¶?"R8LÊM�" 369ÁGR�FG�/8LEsé�´*Pѵ���XGR�FG

�/8��F��X� 2005`uv�10����(��DJ�k��"R8���&��+

�*+/hW8L�û���*�o 13 ��SÊhW8LF� �/�ÃHÇÒK�­�§

=�G?"�Ó+�+°���5(PÑ+°���LNM.µ+NHjkK8L%þh��

Page 130: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� ������

�*´ 13 ��'«*��O(°(�Ô()*Lh��L��PÑ+°� 3 ��P�(� 1

�hÅ7�¸a76.5%c���*´h=[��"R8L)��hR¬­ 95%��%���D

J�éH¿ý?"R8L���.O+�µ)�hW8FG�FFDJoÙÚ��8LM�%�â

hÕ�M��+µHA�G�­�γÖ��«âhÕ��2h�´*����oÓ+�+°

¶·/J#$×oÓ+�+°æ�O� !"[�J�"R8Læ��Ø�/R#@�Ó+�+°

��=�E�8����H�"R8GR� 1�LR#��?"o�[R�������

��#@���6R"�%&��s�G4àK8FG�ÑIhW8G)¬ �L

6�� �#$��"�R!STU�

UU�©û/�_DJM�%������H7Ä?"�CLF�J��êDJ�M�%��

������%ö���dH�&G?CeÚ��C��Hjk?IIo��¶h���é�

x��>�BîH7Ä?"58G�G¹�?@2���ù�6R"ÎÛ�%&��.O+�µ�

?IIW8FG�ÙÚ��CLs¶�DJ�6R"�Q�#@���BîH7Ä?C��<Fh

WX��C ���M�%��#@������ U�AB3amobilitycHFE�.�"

R8LF�?C���B�%&�/�_DJ�"�����N�/OP3�0� ��"

¾?"R8�hW¨�DL

A¬­�Z 1 ��%�ÑÝ2�78�678�N�OP3�"K8WdG?"�iÅG/'

�+�R(Hu`a��ÛÜ?Co�hW8L�iÅ��N�/OP3�Ý�ÌÀ�\��Wd

hW8Lvw�\��/�PQ*+Þß��àá�ihW8DJg�/ÀojÓhR8FGoü

DhW¨�L?D?�2�?@��78�6R"�F�Eh���G?"�N�OP3�g�Ì

À�/'�+�R(�Ý� !"rAK8FG�v<hW8G��8L/'�+�R(�Ý��

�¼ÌÍ�ÜÝ���"&���T� !"�¹NO��8C���N�OP3�gHâü�

45?"R8G�)R�CR��W8ST�qr�v<hW¨�LF��êDJ½bK8GUV

� �/ïî�ü¹��8LEs�����*´�vw��Q 5ÉDQH[�8ÆÇ�/ãé3

H=[K8��F� 10 Å`�9� 10%[¹�Ð$ïî�ü¹��8LE����<��Ç?"

 +OL��%aEUc��gÝGo� 10%[¹��N�OP3HUV��"R8FG�ÙÚ�

�8L����%�°'±�Ýo�8FG/�Jg�6R"ÎÛ�UV?"R8LE¸���M

�%��N�OP3�F� 20`9�sÔ?"UV?"R8Lx[ 10`9���� ��6R"

gÝGo�OP3�UîR"R8LSÒG?"g =oÝ�/OP3�U�!"R8FG��"

¿�8LEÅG?"��h��%G?"�%��N�OP3�����8Lx[ 10 `Å9�

ÎÛ/���� ������_jk�� !"��%��N�OP3�vw��hL�/

ÉÊH[�IIW8FG�ÙÚ��8L�(�0+µ�÷ä�å%/0�h��%�OP3oª

Ò���UVïî�W8LxQ��´æ��Èç�/BîH£?"R8LDò�k¸�Qò�%

VïîH£ú?"R8��G�����*´Ê+%�Bî/1èöh|¬J�8Lx[h�V

×uP�éU�W8G�8È�hW¨�LUU�¦Ù?C ���vw��� �£�� !

Page 131: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� ������

� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �� ������� �����������

�� � �������

UK

JPN

����

FRNC

CHN

ITL

CND

����

GRM

The Trend of Academic Productivity by Countries

����

Share of Articles

Sh

are o

f citatio

ns

0P���Q-�Q-RSTU�� !""� ���

Z

"�%��N�OP3�L��UV?IIW8FG�x[����� GêJ¹�v7�"Á

�W8�hW¨�DLZ

�¶�ýþ�����N�OP3�"?"�RDhW¨�DLvw����*´Ê+%�ý

þ��W8����de�Î�vw��(�(.h0� �/éê�W8�hW¨�

DLZ 2� �­���*´Ê+%�éêK8��ëìí���UéH[�"R8FG�Ù

Ú��8LF��Ç?"�M�%���á�� 30 ���G¥����de�e�dí

�îï�ÁÂÃ�<��3g�î�γÖ�¾!"R8LF�ï�vw�(�(.��

�ËÒ� !"�¹NO��"R8FGoÇÒK8Àx�W¨�L<��'(,L���â�

�ð¶ñx� !"º»Hò78DJhW8LR#��?"oSÊ�/�_DJrs��8Àx

�W8��M�%�����ÁÂH¦ÉK8C������ó���øù��W8R��³�

/�ô¦É��M�"9xhW8FG�)�Eho/RLM�%� 21 v(@�õ��­�&

?"uv�E��èö��nÀ?"R8L�

V �� WXYZ[\:]^_`^[a[b�c5�R!STU����

�0V�WXYZ[Z\Z]�^_`�ab[]XZ[^[b�WX^_`cdZ[_Xe�ab[]Xb]�f[ZdZ[_X�WXg]h�dXg�a_b[di�ab[]Xb]Y�f[ZdZ[_X�WXg]hj�

fkW�l]Y]d`bm�WXbnj�dXg�odZ[_Xdi�ab[]Xb]�p_\XgdZ[_Xe�q[r[Y[_X�_^�ab[]Xb]�l]Y_\`b]Y�aZdZ[YZ[bYn�Ys]b[di�Zdt\idZ[_XYn�a]]�dss]Xg[h�Zdti]��u#�n��������������������������� ������������

2002

2002

1985

1985

USA

E U

Share of articles

Share o

f citations

JPN

U K

The Trend of Academic Productivity by Countries

Page 132: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� �����

V )� defghi2345jY��P8Q8=�

Share of articles by institutions

1.Harvard

2.Tokyo

3.UCLA

4.Michigan

5.Toronto

6.Penn

7.Kyoto

8.Stanford

9.Cambridge

10.Berkley

12.John Hop.

13.Wisconsin

14.Imperial Col.

15. UCS

16.Osaka

17.Tohoku

18.Oxford

19.Yale

20.MIT

21.Chicago

22.Kyushu

23.Nagoya

24.Hokkaido

25.Cal.Tech

26.Soul

27.Tokyo I.T.

28.Singapore

29.Beijing

30.Keio

klm�

1�� �.+#��@yz��÷,-��«�678#�G��g?@2�`H�&�ø]ù

¼gúûüsýaþ³Ö��«�³µÙ��2�âhÕ�M��+µc�]ù��ë¹LZ

knogpm�

�8��a1977c÷���´,KL�MNOPQL�R(�¥%��678#$ÌÍ�jk

G²úû�øa����+�E 30�c l��#���4(5+L

P. G. �µ��L�ºßa�8û����ca2004c���� u\�678�#@����

��%&���_DJ��aCOE�*+ 5c l�.+#���1^4(5+L

Þ8èa1988c��´,KL�M�+J(��3�¼�?@���d¸ L

��>sa1984c�e¤¥%�����¥%�3�DGFE��ÁÂÃ�]�@L

W. ´K(.�a�ö�s��"�è�ca1972c����#$�ì� L

��?���@���ª%��@��%µg�º��ª%��@��3g�º�¨Û

`TH�àL

|���a1965c����#$����������d�\]�LZ

|���ºßa1984c��#$��SÊ�����´,KL��NOPQL�R(�?@���

©�]�L

ÁÂÃ�3ºÌ�@@a1995c�ÁÂÃ� 50`3�L

i¯2�­��/��¥�]ù[�.+#�!"��¨Û`T�H�àL

i¯2�­��/#@�¡¥�]ù[�¨Û`H�àL

0V�<B,-vwxy�

Page 133: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� �����

i¯2�­�ª%Ï��s_�¨Û`T�H�àL

i¯2�­�ª%�s_�¨Û`T�H�àL

i¯2�­���#���@�� 2005` 2VL

i¯2�­a2000c�.Õ��%&�¡�L

�"!"��#÷�#�3�¡,+5á+�øahttp://www.cc.matsuyama-u.ac.jp/~yamada

/database/index.htmlcL

�8û��a1990c��#$�}B�����ÖÇ�pq�Ç7��´����d¸ L

�8û��a2005c÷#@�AB3HéKo��xD�®�û��n¥�H��|¬8�ø

�Between�10-11V��4��°�14-17 $L

�8û��%\�&�'" (�)*è+a2005c����#@��¬|�uv��:�,

���aCOE���*+ 15c l�.+#���1^4(5+L

�8û��%\�&�-.!s�*/01a2004c�M�%��#@�"K8�����®�

û¥�H�&���aCOE���*+ 4c l�.+#���1^4(5+L

�8û��%\�&�*/01�-.!sa2005c�M�%��#@�"K8����2�®

�û��¾����¬®�7ÄH�&���aCOE ���*+ 14c l�.+#���

1^4(5+L

Page 134: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� ������

� 8 �� �������� ���� ���������

�� ��∗

���� �

�����

� ��������� �������������� ������ !"������

���#� $�%&��#� "�'()�*+,�)�*�-!�./�$�%01�'(

)�* +2��3456�789:;��<=>"����������?�@A� ! B

2�!!$�%(C�DE"��1�,�)FG�HIJKL��+MN �,�)�*�O

�PQ�RST�$�O�U�*�VWXYZ[���+ $�%�����C�'(����

���\] ^_��#��`a bcd�_��+�eYX f��_���ghi�j�k�

l�*mnopqrs ��t�2001 uvw�4,610 xyz{|}~�,�)�*��w��%

�ghi�j��h�� ��t����� " 717xy��|}~�,�)�*�^���

���O�)�*� 238xy33.2�~_��+�qrf��_�%���8�XY'(����

*��#�"O�U�*��3�� 1<�$��+���f��%dXdB�Y���dO�

)�* !_����"�+���ef��_B_%���"�kF����*��������

�s��kF�����*��������sy��� � 2003u¡�|¢����*�+£¤~

¥¦d��O�U�*J§¨d�&�S©EBª«JeYX ���+ ¬­BDE�$�%

&�}��®�fY '(�¯°�±��#��²I�O�U�*�³´53+�����µY

��±¶\]?�·¸JKL���+JD¹+d_%

����� ���

������������ �

��Kº ^»�¼c\]"�½¾!�¿��$�%� �UÀ"�'(�������X

YÁ\]�$�%&�ÂÃ"ÄÅ�\] ÆJÇd�&��� �& 20u�ÈÉÊË��1960

uÌ�1980uÌ�2000uÌ �ÍÎB\]�ªÏf�%QÄ�\]�"кÑY �2��

�¶\]�� ^»��*��#��Z[f��_�%�-�UÀ"�ÒÉÓ5ÔÕ+d��,

�)�*\]�$�%��"Ö×Ø �2�Ù�U�*�ÚÛ+d�=�Ü���%+½

��+,�)�*ÝÞß�\]+d�àªd�_�%�¾�UÀ"�� ^»��#��¿��

O������*�á�â ���\]�=�}ãY��_�%Ìä+d�"åæ�����±

\]çè�8�=�Ü���#�é9ê�Êë�ìãY��yÌäíîRïðñ~%&�òó�

Æ"�k'(��� ^»�,�)�*syåæ�����±\]çè�8k��\]Ó8ës�

∗ ������������ � ����

Page 135: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� ������

� 43 ô�1980~+d��+õY��_�%&��X Pö÷J"øõ�á�â\]"ùd_S

}�»��P�á�âXY�*?�³´53úò�\]"�+��B_%

� '(���"�_û_ûB./��#EBü¿Jód�%eý�þÌ��J��P��

�"����^�_,�)�*J�� �2�þÌ��J���%Qþ�\]���\]

��t�'(�\]���'(�*" �g��y�Ú�O��~���ôJ=>d��_

�%dXP��������B���i�Kº�P2+P� �d�_�yкÑ�����ï�

2005~%��d'()�³´53úò ��d��,�)+d��O�U�*"�� "'

(������� ^_�����BJód�X�Ú���%�- "O�U�*�

�XY�������B³´53úòJd�_�X�¬­B Û+Bû�%fY �¾ "'(

���XY��! ��#��²I ^_�á�â��*"O�) "�d�\]#��'(

)�*��<=>"��������#������ �3456�789:;+�ü¿

�2�$%è&J+2�_��� P�'�%'(+(�+���E)* �2�'(����

���"K+f��_���"B_X+_��� ,-._/0�1¨f��%

� (C�"���d2-�,�)�*+��»O���* 3WJ4�����B�ÚKº

������B�<J=>d�5ÌE "����B³´53Júòd��+d�_��XJ�

6KL��%&� �2��'(���������#� �2����� ��d��_�

XJKL���+�78�$�+MN �®��'O9²�ü¿�$�²��'�½�%+½ �

789:;� EU+M:�3ê3�����;�"<7=�$�%&�d2-�P��d\

]",-._%

� KL²ß+d�"�2003u�F����*�J>8& �&�O ?2�_��������

�@���|}�O�)x��*JAB+dS©E�8�JCDdP�JKL��%���

!�w'O�)�$��!PE�����&�JFG��õ "��Y�)H 3èI8ëo

pJ��J¨�$�%_6� d�P���dÚÛW"$���O�)�*�KLd�_��

��MN�14ú«�OPKº�uQ��<��@��<�=>¼y��MN~��RB��SJ

STd��f�U�BVWXY�'(��� Võ�_�O�)�*�ª«JWXd_+Y'

�_�%2003uZ¡F����*�JAB d¬B�["y2002u 4\vw~�1982u� 9

\ 1' ò�d]��^"����� ^»�,�)�*�ÝÞ° ���§Gß_ �2��

Q` aÞf�O�)�*" 1983 u�$�yÖ×Ø� 2005~%2003 u"�bZ 20 cu+_

�dD�u�P$�XY�$�%}�������*�XYCDdO�)�*��8�+'

(����*FG��8�+�����+ �2�������� ^»�O�)�*�<4e

»���fe �GE �'�½�gû�%

�������������

� ]��^"����� ^»�,�)�*�ÝÞ° ���§Gh4ß_"�1982 u 9 \ 1

' ò�dßi�$�%��ßi�ò�"�SR½�jk ���lBmn�òó�$Y��

�$�%]'(������ "�,�)�oÍ����4è$8+B2�_�z�����"

Page 136: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� ������

)P_B_%���+"�pqEr�Js]���±J��+�¤����+d�"���+

<tuB�+�"$��_X_��+vf��"���� 20 Su0��+�$�%�����

f'�����wò* ,�)"�+��_B_NÌg2%x�ÇÆ"�¨y,�)�\]1

��������ÝÞzH 1974u 5\ {�2 2�%|`"� y,�)�}�~G����

\]1�)���zH+d�{õP��$�%1975u 10\�w'Ù���f)���*��

�"gh�� Ad­��J�Dd�]������OÝ�* 3ê3)JaÞ��õ�§Gh

4�ªÏ_J�'%��Mu 12\ "�������������� Ad�]w'Ù��

�f)�������*?�~G��B� ���­��_J�D%fY 1977 u 3 \�'(

���u Ad�]¨y,�)i�1������ ���­��_J�Dd%&�àó���

����"�1979 u 5 \]����� ^_��,�)J��|}�O�*+d�a��

�+J �E �����Z}��¦"+�d_+_���JÇäd%1982u 8\ "]�

�^"����� ^»�,�)�*�ÝÞ° ���§Gh4ß_�ò��Mu 9\ 1'XY

Ïcf���++B2%

� ��ßi�",�)J���z���OÝ��+d�ÝÞ���+�,�)��"����

wò*+d��u� �����+J�õ�_�%dXdB�Y�,�)�� ]Ý�_B��

��J1»�d�����?�}Ý !_�"®��Z� Û+��B������#� +

2��BÚÛWJ d�_�%1982 u 9 \ 1 ' ò�d]��^"����� ^»�,

�)�*�ÝÞ° ���§Gh4ß_�DE"���^"�����° ^_�,�)J��

° ÝÞ���+����++���+ �����° ^»��±��\]�¡bJ¢�+

+P �����#ü¿�¡b ����+�$2%ßi�Ïcf���3 u��! 1986 u

�NW�"����� w�d�_�,�)�*yO��|}~"�32xJS'�&���O

�)�*" 2 xg2%������!"�,�)�* 7 x�O �O�)�*" 3 xg2%

2003u�NW�"���FG�,�)�*"�5403)JS'yz{JE£¤V��*~����

*FG� 3.46�J¥õ��� B2%�g¦B_P���20 u0 ���t§K¨'�+

��X�%

������������

� vw����©`ú«JfX���tO5��� cª½��125«�¬�DÇWXY��

"&P&P�#E�$2%º�$�­1"�<J®õ�789:;(�XY¯FB3Ëé&J

°'�É�53�±98²3¶È³ËÓJD´d%þ5 @2�P�Ú�O���$2µÉ

¶ "789:;�3456�3ê3�·½XYá�d��<J=>d%eý�¸��¹�f

�+PR½�^�_,�)����wd%vw�Pº» 3u¼ �2�Á�P�,�½�

����*J�¾d!y¿¤VJE£~"�É&%ÀË 65.1��Á%è 33.7��ÃÄ 29.6��

µÉ¶ 25.3��Å5 22.4��&Æ�8�è 21.8�+ 2 JÇ'�ÉÈ5&�Á8&ë53�3

456P 13É15�Ê�Ë¥ $�%M: �vw�5Ì�" 8000Í)��â�������_

Page 137: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� �����

���5Ì�á�â"�ÎÏ&Ð�mn ��t�1980uÌ " 100Í)�1990u 120Í)�

2000u 160Í)y¬­ 50(�~ �Ñ%vw�" 200Í)0�gû�%QÄmn�"�34

56" 58.6 Í)�29.3�yÒÓÔ 200 Í)+d�~�ÉÈ5& 24.3 Í)�12.6��µÉ¶ 22.7

Í)�11.6��Õ%è& 18.0Í)�9.0��Á8&ë%53 13.6Í)�6.8��'(" 11.7Í)

yghi�j� 2004~�5.9�JS'�%Ö �'()�×,?�á�â" 1990 uÌ 2.7 Í)

�$2P���2000 u " 7.6 Í) Ø��ykÎÏ&Ðg�mnuØs2004~%���?�

á�â 10 Í)nÙ"Øòf����RE "�O� 66.3��Ù� 13.2��ÊÚ 3.5�+3ê

3� 90�0�J¥õ�Û�#� 1998u " 91���<J=>d��2002u " 69�+Ü¢

d�Ý�1P 3.1�XY 6.0� Þ¨��+_�ÄBÚÛPTâd%

� }�d�� �eý������"^�_,�)�"�¸ßà� ���ßáà� ���

×,á���¾1�0�+f���+�� 100�þ½�â��á��¾1�$2%68ÏÈ8

������#op ��t���� ^»����*�]º» 3u¼ ^»��ã$�_"\

]�õ�×,�¾1_��ä"�FG�å 55.5��$2%æ_2-�á��¾1"P2+¦

B_���#���"çèE�$�%É&%ÀË 93.5��&Æ�8�è 74.5��ÃÄ 71.8��

Á%è 69.9��µÉ¶ 64.8��Ù� 61.5� "�tB_%�Ú�éD��$�ÉÈ5& 52.9��

3456 42.6���"¯_%}�d�� ��������*�� ^_�'()�×,�<

=>1���3"¸� ê_�� 3<J¥õ��� òâd��&� ��d�,�)��*

ë»@�"�ì í��_�%

� �����#�"eý�`�J�_�����î�ï�+��d���#�XY=� f��

%�6X 20u0 "�]'(������ "�,�)�oÍ����4è$8+B2�_

�z�����" )P_B__+ð��y'¯ñò�Ö×Ø�� 1980~%� 1982u �ó1

��ôzH�õö �2�]��^"����� ^»�,�)�*�ÝÞ° ���§Gh4

ß_y_�÷�]�����,�)�*Ý�ß_�|¢],�)�*ß_+£¤������ßi

�"��|}�AB+B2�_�~��¨�øbf��%��ßi�ò� 3 u� " 32 x�ù

Þf�%P�û��],�)�*ß_|0 ^_�P�,�)��B_d"��+út��'(

�*+"Gû����f��)H�y � ],�)�*ß_|,�aÞf��Ý� 1u�¿¤

V�~�1973u�ü@���� 150x���� 307x_��1983u "&�ý� 311x�432

x+�ì ¨�d�_�%

],�)�*ß_|þ�,�)�*�HI"�ä 1����$�ygd�z{"],�)�*

ß_"ùÞf�B_~%�� ��t�F�� ^_�,�)�*"�2001uvw 4,610x��

F�*� 3.0��$2%mn�aY�`õ� 20u�ºd�_�����¼ ��������

���¨�d�_�%+½ ��� ^_�" 1995 uÌ|þ ^_�`¨d�_�%����

"������}<XY���� 38x����� 19x���� 15x����� 14x�

�{�������( 13x�¸ßá�� 11x� ����åæ���( 10xB���½

��d�_�%�A�ä�ð't������� �æ����������B����Ä1�

R½E���_�%��� ^_�"��B)�JÄ ®õ�õ "×,�� DJI»U

�J>BX2+MN �¹1��R�)gU��qUfY "�#UB��Kº��._�1

Page 138: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� ������

� �� �����������������������y�<í�~�

,�)�* 1986 1989 1992 1995 1998 2001

�� �351

(0.7)

453

(0.8)

644

(1.2)

1,095

(1.9)

1,344

(2.2)

1,231

(2.0)

�� �40

(0.7)

38

(0.6)

67

(0.9)

228

(2.8)

274

(2.9)

328

(3.1)

�� �949

(1.7)

1,291

(2.1)

1,662

(2.4)

2,216

(3.0)

2,607

(3.4)

3,051

(3.8)

�� �367

(0.9)

459

(1.1)

579

(1.2)

773

(1.5)

974

(1.7)

1,172

(2.0)

z��225

(0.8)

337

(1.2)

520

(1.7)

879

(2.8)

1,219

(3.6)

1,332

(3.8)

�� �665

(4.5)

752

(4.7)

875

(5.2)

1,181

(6.8)

1,318

(7.2)

1,414

(7.5)

z� {208

(0.6)

231

(0.7)

395

(1.1)

701

(1.9)

713

(1.9)

685

(1.8)

!� n

yç� è~

1,340

(1.2)

1,782

(1.5)

2,373

(1.8)

3,539

(2.5)

4,227

(2.9)

4610

(3.0)

����������� ������� ����������� !"#$%& ��'()� �

)*+,��-�"�

�f�õ�$û�%�����",�)�*J;���õ�#��J�½XY�@d�)

x�&Ô�P3456²�J !+d�^���±\] ���z�Jͨ������GP$

É5è"Ë�ªÏf��_�%

� #G½��$AS�"}%� 104xy��|}~��&'� 70x��(,�� 64x�ß� 60

x�¸� 51 x�)Ð� 51 x�*�,�� 48 x�¸×� 46 x�¸�� 45 x��# +� 41

x��� 41x���� 40x�,-� 39x�'(� 38x�./�#� 37x����01��

( 34x�ß��×2��( 30x�$2y30x|}�k��%è³è3s2003~%&�î��

���"���� 33x�*4� 21x���å� 20xyghi�jo��� 2003u 7\~�

$2%���"Ê5&Å´èU���,���qU�JO� ���5!��¶����$A

S�"RSJ¥õ�%î²�#G½��,�)�*�ä�"�20.0�|}� 20 l�$�%6G

E "�./�#� 84.1����� 45.5��*�,�� 41.7��78g�� 38.5��¸ß09

� 34.5���&'3ê3:ç;� 31.9���(,�� 31.5���# +�� 28.3��x<=>

i� 27.8��x<=,��� 27.2����� 25.0����� 24.5�� 8� 24.1��

}%� 23.1������� 22.2�� ß*�� 21.4��â/,�� 20.8���×lg�� 20.6��

ßá,����?ð�@��( 20.0��$2y�ä 20.0�|}�k��%è³è3sM}~%A

Page 139: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� ������

ÍÎ���������BCE R_%����"./�#�¶�&'3ê3:ç;���� �

����&Ô��GJ3456�B_d"�#�y398$Ë�&�èÂ8µ�~d��P$

�%5ÌDE½wyWTO~"�Qþ���JE£È8F&��[=G�¨JH�d%����

3456��'(l"��+d��l�IX���+ B�%_6� ������� ^_�

")gU�,�U��#U�������U �2�¥õY��_�g» ��*tX��B½

����#�" Jbc���++Bû�%+��»�é9Õ�:�KLË�&Ê8Ë�f��

Kº ^_�"�*��#��`a bc���$û�%

+P$����d,�)�*��M�¢JNd��ä 2�$�%��"����¶OMP

Þ½� ^»���|}�,�)�*JAB+d�_�%�� ��t�������)���

� �� �������������������y�<í)~�

�� R �� x �� � z�� �� � n

Éèµ 4 2 0 6

&5%è6 1 4 0 5

�� É 2 2 1 5

Ù� � 31 85 37 153

O� � 25 190 23 238

Ê� Ú 1 5 2 8

3ê3

&�î 1 13 2 16

3456 36 54 20 110

�� �6L 1 11 4 16

O� )� � 1 1 3 5

ÉÈ5& 9 25 5 39

µÉ¶ 5 27 2 34

Õ%è& 1 11 0 12

�53 1 2 0 3

Á%è 1 3 0 4

9�3 3 7 0 10

�� �

&�î 3 13 3 19

������� 7 11 1 19

Áç3²3�������� 0 4 2 6

O� � ¸ 1 1 1 3

3Õ56 1 3 2 6

!� � n 135 474 108 717

�.�������/� 011& � 2 3"�

Page 140: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� ������

#�� ^»��¢JNd�_�%á�â�¢+M:�O��Ù�°�3ê3D��R_%��

J"3456���O��$���z��J"O����3456��+B�%,�)�*

"Ý��JùÞ���ä�¯_%Q't�����!�717x���Ý���ùÞ" 380x�

53��$�������!�M: 276x��� 105x 38.0��$�%çè� 48.8��$�%

RH�KLd�8��"�����F(S�* A��Ý��ùÞä" 2001 u 1.9��2002

u 3.4�+`¨d��_�P���,�)�*?�Ý��ùÞ"T,� ¯_%&�õ z

���&����� UV��+P�YB_d�\]#�"�Ú�O���$�3456XYÄ

B��JP�ì W@��78XPY¨�B_���JZ"[\�$���S]���z�

���� Ub��+��t���J"3456 Ì�2�O��Q�+Bû�%Ù�PEõ�

Y'�t�þ_^_�©E ";ª 3ê3�NÌ `@���+ B�gû�yÖ×Ø� 2005~%

�!�"#$�����%&'()�

� 2003ußSj�mn�8� ��+�ÊÚJEõO�)��MJa!'( _�O�)"�

46Í 2396)�_� 3)%�b"��½cy1+¿cy1 K»�_�%cy1" 8Í 6,727)�

¿cy1�O ��'()�de1" 5Í 4,714)� y1" 3Í 3,299)�á�" 8Í 7,091

)�f�" 3Í 8,873)�}g" 4Í 1,839)�&�î" 11Í 9,860)+B2�_�%2002u

�ßSjmn�8� ��+�'(�,�)\]1�O �O�)� 35.3�J¥õ�_�%2<�

3<�3456�Ù��f�å 3Þ B2�_�%���*+_��h�§ �������*

"���EB&Ô8�&�¯½�2004 u 4 \XY������*"�����ß)� i_�

�S*��K�B½B2��¥�S*EB�K�$������ d�Pj¨EB�h�$�

�+"c8�+^��$�%fY �vÌ���ÇkJ58µ��i�\]�Q¼ÆJl2�_

��+B�XY�O�)���*�ª«JWX���+"�'( +2�P�O�)���*

+2�P�O� +2�P�¯°�± +2�P��m­B2-Ja2�_�%

� ],�)�*ÝÞß_�ncf���`õ�aÞf�O�)�*�� 1 ô"�1983 u 4 \

Çof�cØâf��$��µ"���ôp��q'�z�� aÞf�%&����

Ubf��¨uÝ���Võ��xr�� B2yÖ×Ø� 2005~%O�)�� ôcf�

�aÞf� 1983uXY®s�opAB+B� 2003u���t�� 20u+_�dD B�u

�P$�+MN �uDf�� 2004u 4\�����ß)���ncf��v0�u�P$�%

����"�ß)���0+ß)�d�XY"�,�)�*��Þ ���$�X��XJo�

�w­P$�õ�&�v0� 2003 u ^»�F����*���8�JKLAB d�»

�$�%

���������� ���

� þÌ'(�xy�BX��,�)���Jë»�_N�"�eý�+�-.5Ì��v��

-Z$2%c8��� �eý`� ^»�¹1N�¸ß����*"�XB��hK",�

Page 141: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� �����

)�$�%|`"],�)�* 28x Ad�'()�*" 19x �zBX2_4�%dXd�

&���.� {A�| }2�_%� P�~!"�1945uXY 1952u ��¥�� ^

»�'(��±�����"®'PB^ê_�_�%�!�yª#"�¬+d�3456~ �

�¥�"�9$8ë�Æ�8µyRobert Ward~�_�]nÙf��ýE��_5�+Þ� ð

�f���� �vÌ�'(��ýE���EÇk"���v��N�������P��$

�%

� ���14ú«XYÁ�+������"�1982 u 9 \ 1 '�]���"����� ^

»�,�)�*�ÝÞ° ^»�§Gh4ß_yßi� 89ô~Ïcf����"����â_¼

ßE �����?�,�)�*�ÝÞ"�õY��_BX2%�BÁ ���ßi�Ïc

f�� 3u$��� 1986u 3\ 1'vw����� w�d�_�,�)�*y��|}~"�

32x����O�)��*"g� 2xdX_BX2%�����"�,�)�*y��|}~

F* 7x����O�)�*"�3x_%����� ^_��¿¤ ¦B_�+��X�%

ä 3 Nd�� �2003 u�F����*� e_�KLd14ú«XY�O�)�

*��8��$�%���8�"���|}g»JAB dõ�z{�¿¤VB�"AB,

+d�_�%2003u�NW�"�������FG+d����|}�O�)�*"�669)J

S'�%�� S]+;8çèë���+���� FG�å 6 $� 59�3�� 397x�

O�)�*�w�d�^��P2+P¯_��3J¥õ�%���� " 4þ½�O�)FG

� 36�9�J¥õ�_� 247 x�w�d�_�%î²������" 25 x�O�)�*�w�

d�_�%fY ���� "�397 x�O�)�*�w�d�_�%141G �lS�$É

3&�$�õ� l$��O�)�*�S"������P2+PR_%!�������

"���R½�,�)�*Jë»�@��_��+��X�%

� � *+,-./01!�����

� � �� � �� ������

� � � �� � �����

�� � � ��� �� �

�� � � �� � �����

�� � �� ���� ������

� '(���FG ^»����*�*y��|}~�O�O�)�*�¥õ�!JZ�d�

Á�+�14ú«G�"�����!�O�)�*"����� 0.565� �zB_�+��X

�%������!�QÜ��*FG� 0.31�dX¥õ�_B_%�����QPR½����

2 Þ��&��P 0.599�dX¥õ�_B_%14ú«G���+��������2� d�

P�;8çèÔ8êE ¦B_��uH¨'�_��I"��YB_%��FG+d��O�)

�*"�0.567�dX¥õ�_B_�+��X�%dXd�,�)�*FGyz{Eõ~+d��

2003u�NW�" 5403)JS'����*FG� 15Í 6,155x� 3.46�J¥õ�_� 6)%­

Page 142: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� ������

�� ���|}��@�J��+B�z{J "�SR½�w���+"uD���$û�%

���!"#$%&'�

� '(���"�xy�<_��¶��EÄd_��B�_û_ûB��XYwòf��_�%

xy¶�m �2�MN��_�$�%Q'tMN�¯_�� wMd�_�O�)�*JWX

d�����õ �(��\]�� ���C�KLd��+M:������\]��+

d�"��×l�¸��¸ß�x<=���ßá����,-�¸��� ��åæ 11 l+

���������� 2 l�!n 13 lJ\]�� K�d%&����J ���+_

��+!�6Ô�58 d���Y�J�Á�Á��yкÑ�����ï� 2005~%

� ä 4"�FG� 669x �d��\]��+&�î����O�)�*�)SJä�P��$

�%\]�� w�d�_�O�)�*"�125x�FG 669x�å 2� 18.7�J¥õ�^��

&�î� ����" 544 x 81.3�J¥õ�_�%!��'(��� Võ�_�O�)� 5

) 1)"\]�� w�d�_��+��X�%

� 2� 34��56./01!�������

� � �� �� ������

����� ���� ��� ��

� ��� ���� ������

�� � � �� ���� �������

fY �\]�� KLd�_� 125x�O�)�*JOPKºG Á�+�=��J�_��

ª �58���*�OPKº"���$�%&� ê½ 2< "�)g� 12�5��|¢���

��" 6�3�� ��Sq�i����"Mø 5�4����" 4�5��âq�" 2�7�+P2

+P¦B_%\]�� _�O�)�*�OPKº+ ��� ^»�O��*�K�+"�M

øX��X�Pd����BY�������XJ.� ^_�Z�d�Á_+t�%

�(�)*+,-.� #$�/�

!z ��@�VWXY��Á�+�AB+B2�_���|} 669x������"�FG

� 3��z��"�83����"�14�+B2�_�%����ä"¿¤ ¦B_P�����

�J��+_2�P�_z��"�8  J¥õ�_�%®��\]�� Võ�_�O�)�

*�OXY����`a ¨����+�Y'Y��%�BÁ �\]�� _�O�)��"�

O�)�*FG� 14�J¥õ�_�%

Page 143: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� ������

¢ 1"�\]�� w�d�_� 125x ���O�)�*uQ�K�JN�P��$�%P

2+PR_�"�35 ¡XY 40 ¡���FG� 39�J¥õ�^���-< R_�"�41 ¡X

Y 45¡����28�J¥õ�^��QP¦B_�"�56¡|}��*���6X 1�dX_B

_%��" 51¡XY 55¡���)PEõ�P 4� �z6�\]�� w�d�_�O�)�

*� 96�"�50 ¡|¢+_��+�¢ed%���*FG+���Jd�Á�P�'(�F

Gçè"�50¡|¢�49.1��51¡|}" 40.9���£1�~"x¤�$�%¬B�["�'

O�üo¤f��" 1978uXY�$��+XY��g 30u�xydXB_�+ $û�%�

���O��*�'( bDd�)"���E ­_5Ì�) ÓOd�_�+t���%

.�ä 5"�\]���ÁJAB+dO�)�*�)S�P��$�%125x��� �¸

���� ¥R½�FG� 30.4� |� 38x�O�)�*�w�d�_�%ê_�� 2<"�

¸ß��+,-���¦���16 x6!�w�d�_�%4 <"����+����� 9 x�

6<�åæ��� 8x�w�d�_�%|¢�7<"�ßá�¸�������¦���6x6!

�$�%P2+PR_¸��� ^»�O�)�* 38 xJKLd�Á�+��ÚKº ^_�

"���U�BCE R_�+�KX2%38x�O 28x�OPKº"���$��¸���

FG� 73.7�J¥õ�_��+ B�%��"�¸���g»�vBB�X��X"��J�õ

�����+ d_%. ¸����O�)�*�uQ+Kº�Ê9&äJ��+�F* 50

¡|¢�$��+�KX2%��"�J2-���X�§ � ¥R_��U�"�¬K½Y

_��*�uQ"�35¡XY 40¡���¼ _��+�KX2%1980uÌ �� §��

§ ^_��'(�â�R½"�i*��ad_�+P´¨f���+�$�%��N��á�

â�R½w�d�_�78XP$�%uQ��AE ­_�"�\]�� w�d�_�O�)

�*FG ^_�P�õY����¸����"+½ ©ª�$�%F�E �O�)�*�K

º+uQ+�@+"���_��ó�$��X���FGJ�d½KLd�Á_+t�%

7 �� !����89:���;

���

���

���

���

��

��

�� �

��� �

�� �

����

�����

�� ��

��45678

Page 144: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� ������

� <� ����=>'!����34?@�

� � )� S� ;8çèë�

�×l��� 5 4.0

¸���� 38 30.4

¸ß��� 16 12.8

x<=��� 2 1.6

ßá��� 6 4.8

���� 9 7.2

����� 9 7.2

åæ��� 8 6.4

,-��� 16 12.8

¸ß�h��� 6 4.8

������ 6 4.8

����� 4 3.2

!� n� 125 100.0

�0�$123-.� ���

� F����*�XYCDf� 669)�O�)�*"�'(����� G����BKº�

\]d�^���â ��KºJ�'�_���$û�X%¢ 2"�O�)�* 669xJOPK

ºG KLdP��$�%3%Õ�Nd�� �F�³>Ë���+�)gU��*� ¥

R½�FG� 38�J¥õ�^��&�."���U�$��� 3<"���i�U�$�%��

¾!�Kºg»�FG� 88.4�J¥õ�_�%!���O�)�*��+��"��¾!�OP

Kº�«¬d�_��+�KX�%&�î�Kº+d�"�����U" 5.1���� 2.3��S

qU 2.0��i� 1.1��âqU 0.7��5!�R 0.5�+_��¥ B2�_�%

���

�����

���

������

����

����

���

���

��

����

����

��

����

��� �

��

���

��

��

���

��

����

����

��45678�

7 �� (A./B1!�����

Page 145: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� ������

¸����KLàó+"��d�_�%¸���+\]��FG�O�)�*�O­Kº+P

��d�Á�+�\]�� Võ�_�O�)�*�OPKº"�=��J�_��ª �58�

��*�OPKº"���$�%&� ê_��� 2<")g� 12.5������" 6.3��S

q�i����"&�ý� 5.4����i��4.5��âq��2.7�+QA�$��+���f�

�%O�)�*�F�çè"�R_� )g�������$�� Ad��\]�� KL�

�O�)�*�O­Kº"�R_� ����)g������$�%��+)g�ÖWdt

X��B½�\]�����i�"�F�çè�"Q�XY 2¥D+B2�_�%

����O�)���*�}< 3Kºy)g������~��*JAB �uQ��<�Q

®�<=>¼����@�w�d�_����14ú«B�JKLd�Á_%� ¢ 3"�)g�

������ 3Kº�O�)�*JuQ�VWXYKLdP��$�%��}< 3Kº"�O

�)�*FG�uQK�"¿¤ þ_P��$�P���¾1"&�ý�§¯�$�%�B���

��Kº�" 41É46¡ü@���i�PM:�41É45¡ü@�)gKº�" 46¡É50¡ü@�

&�ý��°8Ê�$�%çèuQXYð't�eYX ������)g���­½�¾1

��B~�$��+���f��%

� fY ��<�=>±²J³õ�!�)gKº�"��<=>1�FG" 177x��&��

�f�ô" 98 x�FG� 55.4�J¥õ�^����ô" 79 x�FG� 44.6�J¥õ�_�%

)gKº ^»� 44.6�+_���ô�jä"MKº ^»�'(FG�çè��"�X ¯

_+¡Zf��%á�â+d� §��J=>d�_�+Y'Y�����Z[d�Á��%�

�i���!P��<=>1 112x����f� 37x 33���� 75x 67�+��ô=>ä"

XB�¯Ë¥+_'�%dXd�����!"�����<Ja!�*��ä"BCE R_%

f� 5x� 2.8� Ad����" 171x��97.2�J¥õ�_�%����B����� !

_�Q®�<�=>¼�VWXYY�d�Á_+t�%.�ä 6"�}v� 3Kº Ld�_

�O�)�*�Q®�<�=>�J´�dP��$�%�� ��t�)g������¾K

º ^_��'(��<J+2O�)�*"P2+PR½�n 324x��O�+��J�»t

FG� 73.5�J¥õ�_�%KºG ��P�)g�O��=2 41�J�_�������

��YP 80�|}"'(�=>d�_��+�KX�%Q®�<J'(�=>dO��*JK

��

��

��

��

��

��

��

�� ! "# �� $ �� ! �� $ �� ! �� $ �� ! �� $ �� ! �� ! %&

���

��

��45678�

7 � 89./B1�CDEFDG��

Page 146: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� ������

� H� (A�=>'!�����IJKL���

'� � � (� ,� � � ��� �

��\]�� �� ��� ��� ���� O�� ��� &�î�

)g� 51 (24.3) 21 (10.0) 8 (3.8) 44 (21.0) 80 (38.1) 6 (2.9) 210 (100.0)

��� 56 (45.9) 7 (5.7) 5 (4.1) 30 (24.6) 19 (15.6) 5 (4.1) 122 (100.1)

��� 104 (58.4) 43 (24.2) 2 (1.1) 4 (2.2) 24 (13.5) 1 (0.6) 178 (100.0)

!n� 160 (31.4) 71 (13.9) 15 (2.9) 78 (15.3) 123(24.1) 12 (2.4) 510 (100.0)

��45678� � � � � �

Ld�Á�+�¶"���\]��XY=>d!�¯_%dXd�)gKº ^_�"��

��+�����=>d!" 20�Ê�èµd�_�%

� . ä 7"�Q®�< !_�KºG��14ú«G �P��$���QPR_�*S"�

0�d�� )gU�$�%� 2<"���U�$��QP¦B_�"��i�U�$�%�

����)gKº" 191x���FG� 82.3�J¥õ�_�%­�� ���FG+d��Kº

G��)gU+��i�Kº� ¥R_�"������$��+J¢ed%���� "

������hwò")g�h¶���h��AE R½�xy�O���O�g��3ê3t

¶B��iDPR½14f��_�������+"·E ¡Z���%§ ����!"�

R_� ��� 66.9��)g 15.5����i� 15.1�+}<J¥õ�^������+"A¸

E�$�%

� M� ,-N(AO�01!����I�

M� � � N�� �

������ ������� �� �� ���� �����!� n�

)g� 14 (6.0) 22 (9.3) 36 (15.5) 5 (2.2) 191 (82.3) 232 (100.0)

��� 5 (4.0) 14 (11.1) 19 (15.1) 5 (4.0) 102 (81.0) 126 (100.0)

SqU� 6 (50.0) 6 (50.0) 12 (100.0) 0 (0.0) 0 (0.0) 12 (100.0)

��� 6 (85.7) 1 (14.3) 7 (100.0) 0 (0.0) 0 (0.0) 7 (100.0)

��� 65 (35.9) 56 (30.9) 121 (66.9) 8 (4.4) 52 (28.7) 181 (100.0)

âq�� 3 (75.0) 1 (25.0) 4 (100.0) 0 (0.0) 0 (0.0) 4 (100.0)

��� 6 (42.9) 6 (42.9) 12 (85.7) 1 (7.1) 1 (7.1) 14 (100.0)

����� 7 (22.6) 6 (19.4) 13 (41.9) 1 (3.2) 17 (54.8) 31 (100.0)

Kº�

5!�R� 0 (0.0) 0 (0.0) 0 (0.0) 3 (100.0) 0 (0.0) 3 (100.0)

!� � n� 112 (18.4) 112 (18.4) 224 (36.8) 23 (3.8) 363 (59.4) 610 (100.0)

��45678� � � � � �

Page 147: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� ����

�4���%56789�

� '(�����*+d�¶2�_½} �,�)��" ����M�+�2����d�P

ð¹�ÚÛ�D�½�%'()��â+º��+»½ h�iD+\]JO�+��¼&ëJ

�_��¯ZB'(��­®f��%�â¶c½+�2t¾�J¢YB»�tBYB_%P�û

�O�)PQ,�"B_%&���'(�&�8¿B�±\]J¡b��õ �µY"�â�

�á�⫶Q®�<J���=2X�VWXYKLd�Á_+t�%

� ä 8"����*� À?f�'(�O�)���*�D�lJ KLdP�����

����Q®�xJ®'XJNd�_�P��$�%�� ��t�O��Q®�<J=2

�*"�24.6� $� 147x�_��+�KX�%���QP¦B½�13xFG� 2.2�dX

¥õ�_B_% ��73.6� $�437x"�'(�Q®�<J=>d�_�xª�KX2%

fY '(��<=>¼JMN�ÁWXYÁ�+���\]���BCE R_%'(�Q®�

<J=2�"�}�d�� 437)_��&�O 247)���\]����<J=2�^

��56.5�J¥õ�_�%

� P� "#���� QR"#��*+,-�

� � )� S� ;8çèë�

��\]��� 247 41.4

�� ���� 87 14.6

����� 18 3

'� (�

����� 85 14.2

O� � �� 147 24.6

�� � �� 13 2.2

!� � n� 597 100.0

��45678� � �

�:���%$;<=>?�

� O�)���*�=>d�<�³>Ë"��¶f�fY "��+f�U��$�����

��<�³>˱²JfY KLd�Á��%ä 9 N��� �'( ^»�O�)�*��

<=>1 549x������ô=>1" 404x�f��&�" 145x�$2y<e1J�½~%

O�)����*FG����<=>1����73.6���*"��ôJa2�_�%<e1+

��J�_S]�ð't�FG� 669x��� 82.1��O�)���*"�f�|}��<J

a2�_��+ B�%fY 14ú«G =>�<³>ËJZ�d�Á�+�¶"�����

��²��f�|}��<Ja2�_��*�R_P�����g»�Á�+���� _�O

�)�*�S�R_�+�KX�%14ú«G�f�+����äJÁ�P������O�)

�*���ôKj1" 91.9��$�� Ad����� _�O�)�*" 59�dXa2�_

Page 148: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� �����

� S� !�����ITUV *+,-OJKL�

1� 4� ú� «�� �

�� �� �� �� �� ��!� n�

��� 205 (91.9) 19 (90.5) 180 (59.0) 404 (73.6)

�<�f�� 18 (8.1) 2 (9.5) 125 (41.0) 145 (26.4)

!� n� 223 (100.0) 21 (100.0) 305 (100.0) 549 (100.0)

��45678� � � �

B_%59�+_�S]"�d�ܽB_������+���+�&�~�x¤+d�_�%.

�ä 10 Nd�� ���"MNXYÁvw�KL��+�<JN�P��$�%��\

]��+�� ���+J$������ w�d���ôJa!O�)�*" ¥R½�

205 xJ���%\]�����Â=>ä"'()�*��P¯½����\]��+ ���

+�"~"B_%

� �W� !�����IJKL �ITUV�

� � �� � � <�

� � � �� �� � f� ��!� n�

��\]��� 101 �91.0� 10 �9.0� 111 �100.0�

�� ���� 104 �92.7� 8 �7.1� 112 �100.0�

����� 19 �90.5� 2 �9.5� 21 �100.0�

����� 180 �59.0� 125 �41.0� 305 �100.0�

!� � � n� 404 �73.6� 145 �26.4� 549 �100.0�

�@���%ABCD�,�

� 1980uÌ @2�XY�1990uÌ�¬t���¼�'( ¶2�O�)"��½Ã!

�³´53Júòd�_�+ð���%

1�'(�$�§Z�òÄJÅõ�XY�O� Æ��'(�>�¾�)Ç��qJSTd��

O����Çk�- Èû�+ÄÉ��Äd_xhB� «¬J��%

2�'(��Ê �³´53 á�Y6�fY ¯_&Ô8�&J®õ�_��Ëôd��

3456¶789:;B��¾�JD´d�_½%

3�á�B_d�á���}�J�¾d�XY�¶2Ì�O� �'_)�"�ÍÎ Æ2

���%

4��SR½�)"�'( á���'(�â«JÏ�g%

O�)�*"��J®õ�'( _�_��X�®��'( á���X�'(JÐwd��

Page 149: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� �����

�¾�� c½�X�$�_"�Ò� Æ��X"�XB�,-._+�û�$�%&�J�e

�� |2��®�µY"���_��� _��X%���*³´53úòJY'��@�

VWXY��Á_+t�%

� ä 11 "��@�VWXY�O�)���*+��FG+���J��P��$���O�)

�*��!���"FG� 27.1� Ad����FG�����ä"�52.0� Ød�^���

gçèEB+�û��"_2�_B_%&�Ñ#�z����!"���+��Ö�S� B

2�_�%O�)�*�z��"�O�)�*FG� 54.4�J¥õ�_�� Ad��'(��

�FG�z��"�31.2�J¥õ�_�%��"�^_E O�)�*���¼&ë Ubd�

_½78X��FG��ä��¯_�+�ð'�%,�)����*�O "�O�)� ¥R

_�g�����*FG�O����½Y_��m B2�_��XJ��+�����ä"�

O�)�*+��FG��ä"�þ_P��$��+�KX�%dXd�O�)���*"��

�"FG� 0.26��z���"FG� 0.88����"FG� 0.56��O�)�*"�'(��

���|}�*FG� 0.5� ºzB_+_�¿¤ ¦B_P��$��+J�ÒdB»�tB

��_%

� ��� !����XYZ[�

� � � O�)�*� � '(�çè�

�� � �� 161 �27.1� 61,310 �52.0�

z����� 323 �54.4� 36,774 �31.2�

�� � �� 110 �18.4� 19,795 �16.8�

!� � n� 594 �100.0� 117,879 �100.0�

.�ä 12 "�14ú«GXY�O�)�*��@�P��$�%��g»�Á�+���

� _�O�)���"O�)��FG� 14.3� ºzB_� Ad������!"�FG�

82�P¥õ�_�%z���Á�+����+����"��MV�$�P���FG+d��

���� _�O�)�*"���|}��@�O�)�*FG� 65�P¥õ�_�%����

+����+"&�ý��30.8��4.2�dX¥õ�_B_�+��X�%xyE ������

²��,�)�*Jë»@�N�"������6_Ñ�"¶½�������o� ,�)�

*Jë»@�{õ�"�1982 u 9 \ �]��^"����� ^»�,�)�*�Ý

Þ° ���§Gh4ß_JÓ½+d��$�%��E Ô_P�+"_'�ì5«��+�

+d�_����g��ü@�$��+"�#�?�í�JÕÖ�U�J>B_%

Page 150: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� �����

� ��� !����*+,-./01XYZ[�

� � �� �� �� �� �� �� !� n�

�� �� 23 (12.6) 6 (24.0) 132 (34.2) 161 (27.1)

z��� 140 (76.5) 15 (60.0) 168 (43.5) 323 (53.4)

�� �� 20 (10.9) 4 (16.0) 86 (22.3) 110 (18.5)

� � 183 �100.0� 25 �100.0) 386 (100.0) 594 (100.0)

��4569:;<78� � �

.�¢ 4 "�uQXYÁO�)�*FG�P��$�%50 ¡����*"�FG� 87�P

¥õ�^��O�)��*"uH¨'�_�[¦�P$�%�@+uQ+ × Á�Á�+��

�� !_�_�O�)�*"�36 ¡XY�$�%uQü�Á�+ 36 ¡XY 40 ¡��" ¥

¦B½�8x�FG� 5.8��41¡XY 45¡��"�28x� 20.4��46¡XY 50¡��" 44

x� 32.1��51¡XY 55¡��" 18x� 13.1��56¡|}�O�)�*"�39x�FG�

28.5�¥õ�_�%z����!"�35¡��" 9x�FG� 3.1��35¡XY 40¡��" 84

x�FG� 29.4��41¡XY 45¡��"�100x� 35��46¡XY 50¡��" 74x� 25.9��

51¡XY 55¡��" 11x� 3.8�+&�ý�¥õ�_�%

ä 13"��@+uQXYÁÊ9&ä�$�%�@�óB½�+����*�uQ"�50¡

|¢�$��+�KX�%��"%��FG+���P�O�)�*�uQ�­_�+�KX�%

P��+!uDd_�"�z���S"�QPR½�286 xP_�%`a òâd�g»

®�����J��+d��_ �û���+t�����Ò� Ø���\]1P¦B½

BXû�%,�)�*�_6����D��$����J+z{��ä�ÙÆ ¦B_�I $

�%+½ 01���J�¦Bf",�)�Ý��¶���ÚÛ+XX�2�_���"B_X

+ÕÖ��%Pd&��$�BYt��J�`aB¨�"�õB_�+ B�%�#�?�Ä

B��JY'�N� _�_��$û�%

7 2� 89./B1�����

��

���

���

���

���

���

��

��

��35���

36�40 ����

41�45 ����

46�50 ����

51�55 ����

56����

��45678�

Page 151: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� ����

� � � !����XY 89�

� � Ú35¡ 35Ú40¡ 41Ú45¡ 46Ú50¡ 51Ú55¡ 56¡Ú !� n

�� �� 0 (0.0) 8 (5.8) 28 (20.4) 44 (32.1) 18 (13.1) 39 (28.5) 137 (100.0)

z��� 9 (3.1) 84 (29.4) 100 (35.0) 74 (25.9) 11 (3.8) 8 (2.8) 286 (100.0)

�� �� 20 (19.8) 31 (30.7) 31 (30.7) 18 (17.8) 1 (1.0) 0 (0.0) 101 (100.0)

!� n� 29 (5.5) 123 (23.5) 159 (30.3) 136 (26.0) 30 (5.7) 47 (9.0) 524 (100.0)

��456=>:;<78� � � � � �

�E�FGH ��IJ�

� �6�� "�O��*�'(������� �����+ �2��ÚE8ÒE ��

�� ·¸d�_��XJop���+"<7=�$�%�¤i��"�#ü¿é9ê�Êë

�2���R:B\] Û�ÏÛf��78XP$�%)gKº�"O�)�{ ��O�\]

"Ü����$û�d�'(g� !_��ÝXY�Äd_VÞ �2�ÄB'(\]�78

X�IX���$û�%fY ��i��"O�+'(��+���\]PfY kIf���

�B_%�����OP�$�¯°�±\]Kº ^_�"�� 10 u¼���dßà���

´¨f��_� 7)%'(���������#�+"��d\]��ÚEâáX�I}�r

�2-�m­+B�%�*��WXd�* ) )�\]Ô8Ò+ª�¶âgâáJD¡²ã

8&��D¡²ã8&¶����¢�'�äåvxæGJKL���+ �2��O��*��

ÚEâáX !_��NUçE�KºE ��KL���+�78�$�%

� �- "�&��X Pm­B�ó�R�_½!X$�%+'t�'(���wè ^_�

O� ����Þ��i��h�wò¶65³ã%� ^_�O��¶O�g�Jo���+"�

'(�����#�Jo��W�Pm­�$û�%$�_"O��á�â\]"XB�b��_

���'(�\]1éò+_�VWXY��+�'(��#��ÄB8�J���+�78�

$û�%

� �¾ "����*��NUçEKL�º» 20 u�HIJWX��õ ��*��KLJ

î�uÌ��Á�%6GE "�]��^"����� ^»�,�)�*�ÝÞ° ���§G

ß_�Ïcf��XY�]F����*�_XY�8��sêopJc�%ª# 1983 uXYÏ

cf�],�)�*)Þß_J�� �1983uXY 5uëÁ��1988u�1993u�1998u�

2003u������*�J>8& O�)�*�&����ª«opJ��+MN �O�)á

�â�ª«opPc�%&d��3èI8ë ��#)�<�sêop+§ì$�sí1 Éè

�Fã8JªÏ��%x0 ���*�XY�¢+�"îï¶O�U'()�E���_�78

X�ð��B_%

Page 152: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� �����

=\]��

� �����KLJ�d��'(������� ^»��#�� Æ�eYX f��%

|}�ñ�AXY���*�JKLd�Á�+�|¢���B,-._àâ�>Y�%�6�

FGEBò­J��+���|}O�U�*"F����� 669x_��+�¢ed%141

G��b�"����� 247x����� 25x����� 397x�$2%�����FG�

6J¥õ�ê_���� 37�J¥õ�����" 4� +���%dXd�çÊ�8G�ÒÓ

Ô ¥õ�!JóD��+�&�ý����� 0.57������ 0.59������ 0.31��

�+����ä �+��j2~"B½�����ä"^^�&¬K�$2%\]��yôà

���������,-�å�� ¶��¸��~+ ����KL���+�\]�� " 125

xy18.7�~� ��� " 544 xy81.3�~�$2%fY F�*JKL�h¶KºXY�

�+�)g 232x��� 126x���U 181x���U 37x����U 31x�&�î 3x�

$2%��Y+uQ��<�D�l��8�JÊ9&KLd�>Y�8�J�õì�á!�

|¢�¾W ­åd�Á��%

1�O�U�*"�giU�"����� R½��<"O��(��Q®�xJ=>d�^��

uQK�"�iU��P¯Q K�d�_�%���+"�����"giU�iJO� &

�OP�*+d�O��éòf�\]1�5ÊË8ë �2��#��¡bf��_��

+JNöd�_�%

2��iU+½ ��EB�R�O��*"\]�� ^_�÷øf��^��dXPuQK�

"giU��PXB�­½��<J'(�=>d�^��giU+"A¸E '(�\]��

���U á����ôJ=>d���*+d�ùúf��+J2-��%1980uÌX

Y�� §�� ^_�'()�â��i*����û*�d�+�´¨f�����v

B"��Y��++üô��%

3�¼c\] ��t���i�U�'()�*"��JO�+d ����<J=>d��

'(��±\]��� Ad����U�"�*��#�"��U�"B½�O�U�$2%

�giU�"O��¶g�+._�#ü¿�$�%���+"'(�¯°�±��h��i�

65³ã%�°+._�ó�$��+JNöd�_�%

� |}�eYXB�� 21 5«�'(�����#�JZ����!�'O+��ó"�õ

�m­B�ó $������#�+��»O�U�*�ó�"'O +2�����m

­B2-Ja2�½�+t���%�

Page 153: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� �����

^_`�

y1~'¯ñò�Ö×Ø�y1980~k����#�+,�)�*s�¾ge�%�

y2~Ö×Øy1986~]����#�+,�)�*ÝÞß_k��@�+�±�ý�� 14sy1985

uZ~k\]*Ó�s�v��sy��\]Ó8ë 67 ô~åæ�����±\]çè�8�

88þ%

y3~ßSj�8��8ê� http://www.moj.go.jp/

y4~Ö×Øy2005~�'(����#��õ�,�)�*�ÝÞ�k��âÓs� 35Ó�åæ

��¯°�±\]IÇçè�8�29þ%

y5~Robert E. Ward (1968). “Reflections on Allied Occupation and Planned Change in Japan,”

in Robert E. Ward (ed.), Political Development in Modern Japan, Princeton University

Press.

y6~Ö×Øy1968~}À��87þ%

y7~���y2005~�1990u|þ ^»�'( ^»�3ê3¯°�±\]�kI�k��âÓs

� 36Ó�åæ��¯°�±\]IÇçè�8�205þ%

^abCc`�

ɺ��y1977~k'(�36�:Êé9Õ�:�Kè�à��� ^»���ÓÔ�úò+

�Þ��sy��\]Ó8ë 30ô~åæ�����±\]çè�8%

j(C�ö©� y1996~k�������#��s� ��D¡h%

��d���y1993~k���#�?���sÈÉÒËD¡�%

ö÷ �y1997~k���#��\]s� ��D¡h%

�º�oy1988~k36�:Ê�Æ8Òès¸N�%

îRïðñy1987~k���±��#�s� ��D¡h%

���k���*�skF����*��������skF����*�������s|�u

ZJ�¸%

ÄÅ��y1965~k'(�����������\]�s¸;'D¡%

ÄÅ���ªy1984~k������5!E\]�36�:Ê�é9Õ�:�Kè�����s

R�D¡%

Ö×Øy2005~]'(����#��õ�,�)�*�ÝÞ_k��âÓs� 35 Ó�åæ��

¯°�±\]IÇçè�8�293-310 þ%(âg "ª1����������#�+,�)

�*�ÝÞ ���=�ÜÁ+����Ðf��_�%

Oæ��y2004~k215«���sâ¹�%

'¯ñò�Ö×Ø�y1980~k����#�+,�)�*s�¾ge�%

0�Nñy1980~k�#�NÌ+��s�(�%

Page 154: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� �����

ghi�jk�l (opqr��¯°�±½��s|�uZ¡J�¸%

ghi�jk�l�*mnopqr�s|�uJ�¸%

ghi�jkF��� �s|�uZ¡J�¸%

ghi�j�8��8ê� http://www.mext.go.jp/

Ð��ñ\]�]'(�±ymn�8�>8&_yhttp://www.cc.matsuyama-u.ac.jp/~yamada

/database/index.html~yD�íghjkghjuqs|�uZ¡~%

кÑ��y1990~k�����ËH\]���õd�Ï �dK�46²¿��s¸N�%

кÑ��y2000~k���*���� ���\]É'(���")�J_X 5ÊË8ë�

��XÉsy¯°�±\]!� 61ô~åæ��¯°�±\]IÇçè�8%

кÑ��y2001~k���*�¿HX����ý"����"óE�$2X�sIDEkvÌ

�¯°�±�§Óí���*���sNo.432y2001u 9\ô~%

кÑ��yÌä~���å#��ïo$y2005~k'(�������%Y�º»�vw�&_

�syCOE\]�58¿ 15~åæ��¯°�±\]IÇçè�8%

кÑ���'(� �ï)*+y2005~]���*�Ý�� ���\]�F�3èI8ëo

p�KLJO� �_k��âÓs� 35Ó�åæ��¯°�±\]IÇçè�8�87-108

þ%

Page 155: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� ������

� 9 �� ������� ���������

���� ��

�����

� ��������� ������������ ���������� ! "#�

�����$%�&'()$*(+,-�.(/0 �1(23456$%�78�9(�:;

�-<=#�>?@ ���AB-CD EF������$%�GH2I%-JK#�L>

M�NLLO��PQ ���������RS T6U���� ! VW�XY�V5Z[

&'(+,-\7#�NP] �.(2�����$%�^Z-\7#�>?@ �_Z I#

����������$%�`a-bc#�NPd ABef�Qg>U�������$%

"#�$h�ij�k"�lmk"�_ZnZ�$%-op#�NLZ �q��Qr�ABe

f�$*(st(u�vwxy>�����$%�_Z6>�z{-|U�������$%

��ABef�}2q[~���O���Z��[L>-=65 #�N������^Z-�

�����F �����AB�k">U�AB��ef� ���� I�U��[5-CD

( =65 U���U���AB���>��U��2�AB���-z{U�LZ56��

�� VW��AB������$%�����-��N���O��������S ���

_� �-��#�N

������ �������

����AB VW�XY�¡¢ ���\7U�£�>�¤�AB VW�XY�¥B�¦

§6Z[�� 1913 ¨�©ª¤A�«¬�Z[.OMq[N­®¯°�±²�³´OMq[��

_Zµ�¶2·¸56O�2¹�º»¼ U�½¾Q¿O½��À5Á�-Â2�XY IU�Ã

ı²�³Å ��Æ3 ¿�XÇB½ <È�Z[ `É2�NXÇB½�¥Bµ_�FµÊË

�Z[�O�2¹�Ì� 1923 ¨�OÍ[2WZÎ2625q[NÏ�¤�AB>U���ÐÑ

¤A� 1919¨> 1935¨Ò1945¨�ÓÔ¤A� 1925¨�ªÕÖ¤A� 1930¨�©Ð>×Ø~

7ÙAO� 1929¨ �_ZnZXY�¥B-¦ÚU���N

� Q:�AB Û�ÜÝ "U�µ?Þ ��§�Dß(OMq[N¤�AB VW��­�X

Y Û�ÐѤA�ß�¿XY ÛÄ1929-1936ÆOMq[NBà "U�Bá��â���

©ª¤A��­OMq[NXY�ãáä�å7�Z[�� 1932 ¨�L>OMq[N�¬AB�

�­�XY æ�çFO�U5µèé¿OMq[êëìÇ×ØAB æÄ1954¨ÆOMq[N©

ÐABO��íîïÄ1970¨Æ�OÍ[ðÎ2625q[N

� L��� �����F³�>U�������� ! V��XY��ñ��çF�ò�ó

-ô�µõöOMq[N÷ 1 ø#ù¹�1953¨ 4.8%�1963¨ 7.2%�1973¨ 8.2%�1983¨

Page 156: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� ������

8.4%�1993 ¨ 9.9%�2003 ¨ 15.3%O�AB���efF��ú¹]ûü ýq���N�.

(2ò�óOô�µ������þ �§�XY���-ô�µÄ2005¨���1�h��X

?�� ������ 11.6%>�� 32.5%���� 40.9%���y�� 47.0%2�

���5 �Î2������F��OM�N

� �� ���� �������������

1953 1963 1973 1983 1993 2003

�¬AB 2.8 4.1 4.7 5.2 6.6 10.3

�¬AB 6.6 7.0 9.2 9.4 11.1 21.9

�¬AB 9.2 11.7 11.6 11.5 12.6 18.1

�� � � 4.8 7.2 8.2 8.4 9.9 15.3

� �

� �� ����� ��� ����!"#� $%%& '��

��������

��������

����������������������������������

������������������������

�����������

�����������

���

� �� �� �� �� �� ��

� � �

����� ��

���� �� �

����

!� �"

#��$ "

�"�����

%�����

!��� �&

�������

'�����

(������ " �

)����* �

+ ���

,-.

� � � �

$��()*+,-./0��1234567�

� ����$%úef���� X�-��Z��� Õß�> �W�!���"# $%OM

�NAB��efµ?ÞOM ������$%µ?&��2~�O7<#�L>�Ú'5µU

Z2�N_�OM�>#ZÎ�L���2()O�����*-+,U�£�>-��OM.�N

/ �� X��0 Õß�µ�-1¥#�Î5 O2¹�2�~é>?é�3�$% 4p�M

�N�����RS��.(2"# IU������5wó������26�-øU���

5LLO�bc78-��U[�N

Page 157: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

��

������

���

���

��

��

��

��

��

Eq

ua

l R

igh

tP

osit

ive A

cti

on

Gen

der M

ain

str

ea

min

gE

qu

al

Op

po

rtu

nit

yA

ffir

ma

tiv

e A

cti

on

Div

ersit

y

Ma

in P

urp

ose

Eq

ua

l tr

ea

tmen

tC

on

pen

sa

tory

Eq

ua

lity

Gen

der E

qu

ali

tyF

air

trea

tmen

tR

eco

urse E

qu

ali

tyE

qu

ali

ty o

f d

iffe

ren

ces

Un

ited

Sta

tes

Majo

r fo

cu

s

So

urc

es a

nd�

Ag

en

ts

Th

e o

rgan

izati

on

as a

wh

ole

wit

h

all

its

str

uctu

res v

alu

es,

cu

sto

ms,

an

d p

oli

cy p

racti

tices

Leg

isla

tio

n,

man

date

s,

role

s

an

d p

roced

uers

Ad

dre

ssin

g f

orm

al

are

ars

of

dis

cre

pan

cy a

nd

esta

bli

sh

ing

pro

tocol

for

po

sit

ive

dis

cri

min

ati

on

Inte

nti

on

aly

in

org

an

izati

on

al

co

mp

osit

ion

an

d a

tten

tio

n t

o

po

ints

of

access

Acto

rs n

orm

all

y i

nv

olv

ed

in

po

licy

mak

ing(e

.g.n

etw

ork

s),

su

pp

ort

ed

by s

pecia

lized

un

its,

cen

tres,

or

off

ices w

ith

sp

ecif

ic t

ask

s

So

cia

l m

ov

em

en

t,E

xcu

tive

ord

ers

ju

dic

ial

decis

ion

-

mak

ing

Po

licy E

xam

ple

s

Legis

lati

on

form

al

rule

s

an

d p

roced

ure

s

Sp

ecif

ic p

rob

lem

are

a,

wh

ere

in

wom

en

are

un

derr

ep

resen

ted

or

occu

py d

isad

van

tag

ed

po

sit

ion

s

Legis

lati

ve a

uth

ori

ties,

po

licym

ak

ers

Sp

ecia

l u

nit

s,

co

mm

itte

es o

r

off

icers

fo

r eq

ual

op

port

un

itie

s

Eu

ro

pea

n U

nio

n

Inte

rest

gro

up

s,

leg

al

pre

ced

en

t, e

nfo

rcem

en

t

au

tho

riti

es/a

gen

ts

Sta

te i

nte

rest

as i

den

tifi

ed

by t

he

hig

hest

cou

rt,

inte

rests

gro

up

s,

sp

ecif

ic o

rgan

izati

on

al

un

its

19

57

Tre

aty

of

Ro

me,

call

ed

for

eq

ual

pay f

or

men

an

d w

om

en

Eq

ual

Tre

atm

en

t D

irecti

ve o

f 1

97

6,

for

pro

tecti

on

an

d p

osit

ive a

cti

on

for

wo

men

an

d w

om

en

Gen

der-

Main

str

eam

ing

at

the

Un

ivers

ity o

f D

ort

mu

nd

Ap

pli

ed

Scie

nces P

rogra

m,

esta

bli

sh

men

t o

f

peer

revie

w s

yste

m a

nd

refo

rm o

f

eq

uali

ty p

oli

cie

s-1

99

8

Hig

her

Ed

ucati

on

Act

of

19

72

, T

itle

��

no

ex

clu

sio

ns o

n t

he b

asis

of

sex

to

ed

ucati

on

al

pro

gra

ms

or

acti

vit

ies r

eceiv

ing f

ed

era

l

fun

din

g

Un

ivers

ity o

f M

icig

an

Law

Sch

oo

l

ad

mis

sio

ns s

tan

dard

s u

ph

eld

in

Gru

tter

v.B

oll

ing

er,

20

06

Mic

igan

Ball

ot

Tit

le o

f th

e C

ivil

Rig

ht

act

of

19

64

. an

d o

ther

measu

res

en

su

rin

g p

roh

ibit

ion

of

sex

-

based

dis

cri

min

ari

on

��������������� ������������������������������������������������ ���������������������������������������������� ���!��"��������#�$����������� � �����

Page 158: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� ������

� 2 ��EU �������� ��������������������� !"#

$�%&��'�() ��"*+�,"-�$�%�����������./�01"

�234567�89:;<��= >?#@A���B�����%&��C/��EU �

���D"EF"G#HIJ;<�/�KLMNOP���QRS�TU��/�VW���X

Y�$�%&�/ �Z:J[\]^A_���`abcd"ef�"��������gA^

���:J��^A EUhi"j��kl����$�&�f�B�����%j��mn

�op"��O�q�01�r.�str."uvQw�^Axy/�]��z� 3"xy[\

]O{|�/�]�}�op"~�"`abc���qz>����}fr.z��~�}O�

�/���:�01�fF����� "�C/���������#�str.f~�r.�

��^���q���q�>�����#��w��f*+���mn���q�'������

"01�f~�������z��(��������O_'}%/ f=����"op"~

�`abcf������:JhY�Y^�"�C/��d�"��������8���r.

" ¡5r.���'=�~�¢£J����¤¥O¦����&�f7g/ %

� �� ������� ���������

������������������ !�

&�/ xyO§���u��~�"¨��/�©ª�~� 7«O¨��/�xy/ %¬­

®¯�r.�/�"r°O¥ / op�±²³´5��~�µ´�¶9��C����#�·

v¸ Q¸ w � �¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ ¸ �

�q¹�º

Coordination among

Ministries

Reforms: committee reports, legislations

Policy: relaxation of regulation, globalization, marketization

Budget: foundation system and evaluation

Personnel: non-public servants type/treatment/grades

01¹�º

Market Response

Marketization: teaching/research/budget/personnel

(faculties/students/managers)

Academic Marketplace: mobility/personnel affairs/academic

productivity

r.¹�º

Institutional Strategy

Mission/Function/System/Evaluation: teaching, research, social

services

Management: faculty meeting/meeting of the board of trustees,

teaching/management

str.¹�º

Autonomy

Formation of Consensus: Science Council of Japan/Japan

Association of National Universities

and so on.

University Evaluation Organization:

Japan University Accreditation Association/Japan Institution

for Higher Education Evaluation/National Institution for

Academic Degree and University Evaluation

Competitive Fund: Ministry of Education, Japan Society for the

promotion of Science, Foundation

Association: Creation, Interaction and Publication of Knowledge,

Gender Issues

Page 159: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� ������

»J��O¼½¾J^= f�������������j�J¿"»¥O! A/ %!�'

¿�j�!8�"~�r.�'=�*+/ %j"ÀÁ��Â"'�J��:JÃÄÅ­Q�

fÆÇ/���"#$È�^%

¸ 7 ~��./�e�e���Éu~�"������.��Ê¿\]ËÌÍ�ÎÏ�ÐÑÒÓ

"�����ÔÕÊ¿\]�Ö×Ø�{Ù¢Ú�w"xyz� 4}�Ûj"Ü">ÝÞ�Oßà

/�á:âã�ä:JxyOå] %

&�A"uÒ�Ú­Q"æç"èéO������Éu~�"�������.��Ê¿\]

ËÌÍ��./�êë~�ìÞíî��ïðv�w�ñ˹òó^Au~��ôõKö�e =

�ËÌÍ"÷øO�ù�/ %j"¤¥�'�(�á:��ú~fû!ü¢,�#ýþ~�55

�����~�ý~�þ~5�~�÷ø��J^= %���� 2~��Ü~�O��/�� %

Î�Ï�ÐÑÒÓ"�����ÔÕÊ¿\]��./�!m���ú~�ýþ~"ñËáfü¢

ï���ý~�~f&�����þ~��~��¢��~�������ÔÕ�"Ê¿\]

fÏ�ÐÑÒÓ#_� ¿��#���ñË"ïf�������f$�%Ö�×Ø�{Ù¢

Ú�w��./���� 4JAã�� 2���I¿�ú~fû!ü¢�~�ý~�þ~f��

#���������ýþ~��~f�J¢�~fû!�����%����/�!��~��

���"bc����:#�$�f��������#�û!��O�=���%

� "� # $%���&'()*+,-../ 01� � � � � � �

� ��� ��� ��� �����

�����������

�� � 3.5 6.1 9.5 9.0 6.2 5.0

�� � 3.8 5.2 12 11.5 7.1 4.9

�� � 3.2 6.0 11.2 13.4 8.4 5.1

�� � 5.3 10.9 13.4 17.0 10.8 8.3

�� � 4.0 6.7 12.8 8.2 6.6 5.8

�� � 3.3 4.5 4.7 9.2 5.8 3.9

�� � 2.8 5.3 11.9 12.4 7.5 4.6

2 -� 3��&'()*+45�

0

2

4

6

8

10

1990 1992 1994 1996 1998 2000 2002 2004

������

������

12

���

���

Page 160: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� ������

&�/ ¤¥^A7����&�����~�µ´���¬­®¯�r.# 2010õ�#" EU

�"� !" 20%���#$MNf%����mµ´#N|:JÊ¿\]&Ú'f%��� �

!^^eA��ur."�������5� !"��()/�*+f,-���%&"-fÜ

">����EFJÂ"~�`abc�~�¢*+���&È#$�%&�A"ÀÁ�����

������û.�J��#~�����f/���J^= ���&�!�0^!/�J�f�

û~"�0�ur."��ÃÄÅ­Q��$�%ú~5ýþ~"'����1�2�1"�

��R­T"��53�4!��&�JfA����� "���fÆÇ/���^Â�^�

5 í6"�B"7�f8 e=���%¨9�ú~#�5 í6":�B�C;/�� �

���'�0<�Í"=>JÂOI/��������O��/�� z?p@�A¸ 2004}%

j��mn���B�/�"u�C"���R­T5Ê¿\]"D fEF~�"�����

ÔÕBG�HI"JKO¥ /���'�)%���"!�������"$¿h��ÔxL�

'=�� í6"UÒ®�wÒ'f~�¢£J�^A#$�%&�/ Ó­T���B�� "

���R­T�5 í6"�BÞf��EF~�"Ê¿\]O~�¢MN/���&�f�B

�� %O�P�(&�/ ʿ\]O�4�Q���&��'=�ef�f�����d��

ORS#��H�"hTfBg�� %/^/�&�/ KUMN�'��QRS�TU��Ü

h#Vh³´"O+�:J�����WXð�YZ/���'���$���®['2��

" W¨������'��H\�+�(]^Þf~�_�!,-^`J�&�O�B/��¢

aéf$È�%

6789:;�

bLcdz1988}e�Úf­Q@Ï�g�h� ��"i´�hjýkl%

m��@nopqz2004}e ~�íî������h��������"~�OÂ�rc

/ ^hjýkl%

��~�5�Hmst"Q��.��uvw�x�y@y'�Tz2004}e��~�"5�Hm

stOQ��� z"%PÍj%

{~�� í6|}´¸ ~"ï��´z� 52 ���´}ËÌz��j"����_�{

~�"� ½�}zhttp://www.sclib.kyoto-u.ac.jp/ICEO/konnwakai/52kai.pdf}%

��~�µ´z2000}eËÌͺ��~�����5�HmstOQ��� z�j5�Hms

tT���QÓ@w�x�yy'�T%

��I�z1965}eop"~�í�01h��"��hjý��=>%

��I���z1984}e~�í��"EF:��h�Úf­QT�®�­RS�"i´�hj

ü�=>%

�����®���'"���º���q"�ÍJAã������zhttp://froebel.child.edu.

yamaguchi-u.ac.jp/masako/shoukai/shoukai.html}%

Page 161: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� ������

JAICOWS�z1996}e� ���"�° O���j���=>%

~�²³´z1994}���º~�í6" ¡b¢�%

ýþ~�5�Hmst£6´z2002¤2005}e5�Hmst£6´j%

ýþ~� Tohoku University, Committee of the Gender Equality Project (2002-2005). The

Report of the Gender Equality Project.

��q�z2005}e5�Hmsti´¥Íj�p. 208%

ú¦§~�5�Hmst�.��w�x�y@y'�Teú¦§~�����5�HmstOQ

��� z"%Pjz2001@2002}%

ú¦§~�5�Hmst�.��w�x�y@y'�Teú¦§~�����5�HmstËÌ

Íjz2002}%

ú¦§~�5�HmstQ�st£6´5�Hmstóeú¦§~�����5�HmstËÌ

Íjz2003-2005}%

op�±²³´z2000}e� ���"¨©b¢"ª«:¬­����j� 132�E´%

®¯Èq�z1999}e� ���"x°�±$j²³Í´%

?pµ¶q@�A·q�z2004}e�����O����h5�Hmsti´O9¸�� z�

hj¹2Rº=>%

»LA¼½z1990}e~�í�"¾���h��¿À"ÁÂ@Àx"�234hjýkl%

»LA¼½ÃÄ�Å@Æ�êÇ@ÈÉd�z2005}eop"~�í�01ÊËhÌÍ@¸Ç@Î

ÏhjzCOE��R�3 15}êë~�ìÞíî��ïðv�w��p. 113%

Ðníî²³´z1986}e�Ñ,ËÌÍj%

Clark, B. R. (2005). Genetic Entrepreneurialism among American Universities, Higher

Education Forum, 2, 1-17.

Yamanoi, A. (2003) A Study on the System of Fixed-Term Appointments for Faculty

Members: Focusing on the Process from its Introduction to Legislation, Higher Education

Research in Japan, 1, 21-41.

Yamanoi, A. (2005) The Academic Marketplace in Japan: Inbreeding, Grades and

Organization at Research Universities, Higher Education Forum, 2, 93-114.

Yamanoi, A. & Kuzuki, K. (2004). A Study on the Fixed-Term System for Faculty Members:

Focusing on the Analysis of Types, Length of Term and Renewal, Higher Education

Research in Japan, 2, 1-20.

Page 162: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

���

��#$%&� !"������

Page 163: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� ������

� 10�� ������� �������

���� ���

���������� ��������������

��������

���������� ���������������������� �!���

��"#$��%&'(���)*(����"!+,-.� �/��0%12��!3!�

4��5����6(��78�"!964:;�<.= �/>?#$��"�����

�@�7�6����78�@-A����0��"�B-A���CD"EF���GH>

I�!,/J

KL�ME���NO"��0�PQ12EF�3�?�RS��4�������?��

��T��78��?����T"��NO��U,/VW�XYNO"Z[�\]H^+�

#$"����%)*(�_�`ab;�cd>I�U�!�/efghIi�jk���

����l9�,mIn+������4��%_�`aH�,opNO5 +,/qrst

uvT�wp^+�����?��������T�wp�xy����)g�z{��|

}~�4�����g������������PQ>I�� ������"#$���

)H���>I�U�!�/lI?�NO����=������!�"��!�I3!��

lI�?�����M�5 �9/J

lI6���R�%������3�4��|�4���RS��&g3#$�����&

'>I, ������ �7��¡%¢£��!�/l9�,�� �7���¤¥H +

�=#¦ �§ ¨¦ ©ª «¬!� �­®5�V=¯°g��'¬g3 ���5=

�/l�±9�������� ���%²�±9NO(�������¬³�8g�e

f|����)´X�±+�µ¶·¸�%¹3!5 �9/º»�XYNO!�����

�¼½¾¿�#$"���À2Á�%��g!��GH(�ÂÃ� �/ÄÅ� ��

�"������"¨Æ���hÇ��È�ÉÊË"3+,/J

J

���� ������������

lIÌ5�����!�!�3<.Ã�ÍÎ>I�!,/ÏÐ�ÑÒÓ�����chair¡�

Ô#ÕMÖ����×Ø�5 ��ÙÚ%ÛÜ�Ý�Þß(��²9��hÇ��3>I�/

àÏ�����#Õ á#Õ áâ���ãä_�3?åæçè�5 ������Öé�êë

ìí�"EF�����îï�ìíØðÒ]%ñ��,/òÜi����"_�`a�ìíóØ

ôõ%ö÷�,¥'�_�`a�ø�ôùú_�non-tenure¡�mF½�û!±9ü�I���

�3��%ýþ,#Õ�����5�ÙÚ5�!�3���_�`a5�1994Ú�E��5

Ú�sÁSÙÚ�¨�Ú���"!9¬�?�¶���ò� >I,/È�,��_�`

a5��ôùú_�tenure�êëë)��¡|��`ðØ�emeritus���#Õ¡%�����

Page 164: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� ������

�Ú����|ÙÚ��!�=�±�M��S��¿����(���#Õ�RS3+,/

UCLA�û�#$���"�� �3!"�!#Õ�B. Clark¡3²�A. a�ð�"!9#�$

%�����`ðØ#Õ"��80&%'Ü�!Ì3UCLA(%2U�)5*+��!�/�

�"+�=�¼Ö"+�=�#$���Þß½��!�,>I�-�./%=,?(ó

Øôõ3+�!�/M040&1L5ôùú_%2¹��34�±91994Ú�ÙÚ���5

6�,��783#¦�30Ú�3�9Ù�����:Ì�;<½� �/=��)>±Ii�

àÏ5�?@42&5AB�����TUð����60&C�ÙÚ5D¨(�/�S�=?@20Ú

��»¨5U����L�����5�»¨�_�`a±�±È10Ú�3=E!/783�Ö

F%6G"�,ÖéHI��USJ3��5 �/_�`a��Ú�Ì5�mF½�û!Mb�

KÙ½��L3�M����#$���*½H§���!�/���5��N���PQ±+

�mF½%û��HI�PQ>I�l"8%O�I����4��5�¤¥H±�§UP

��,�ÙÚ�Q�HºG�h?I�Mb��4���Ö5��Öé��RH=���?��

l9�,S]�"#�TU%NV(�W��XY5 �/J

5������ ����¨�Z[_a�\]! ^Ò!]�²�±93_` ��ÄL²

�±9ab>I��5 �9�/c)�����%�US)C(Ii�#$���&'d�]

�ef�g� d�]¡")*d�]�_�`ad�]¡� �/���5��12ñh"��

�ij����0��k�B-A��¡±+� ����Rl�H(�/!Ì�È� m%�

Ì�XYH��n¬(Ii���� ���"���#$�����²�±93ñh� ��

5 �9�/È�opg3qDg3d�]%3þ�"(Ii������78�����¡��

����������3²�ÍÎ>I�/ �!� 1970 ÚCr�sQ�5PQ>I,jk�

�t"S��u �v"!+,#$���)*b;� �/VW5��0��w"!+,��0

�#$���)*��= �/!�I·±���6��������6����������

��6�78�3²�±Sö÷�6G">I�/1970ÚC�xyXz��{!�jk��3

²5#$������)*�p�I|�,/���ÖF`!]��� �b�l9�, ���

�µ¶±+��USJ3�/��=�l9�, ���� �b"ÖéHI�EF���<(

�l"�}3S3!/J

KL�y������ ~Ã�sÏg�K1�ÑÒÓd�]%st"�,����? ~�

,/��������¨ÆX��)´±+�R}J3����)´5�#Õ 1�á#Õ 1��

����R!¥'�3�4¡�áâ���R!¥'�R�¡�?X�>I���Ú�5�3���

!�"\]Ñ�=��?I�=����ÖH�1!��4�B9�v�3��#Õ 1�á#

Õ 1��� 1�áâ 5"!9���ò">I,¡���g��7v�uv7�v�¬�v���

v3²�"�²�)´5�#Õ 1�á#Õ3!���� 1�áâ 1 "!9���ÓD5 ��)

´±+�áâ����¥'= �¡/�¿���5=ÑÒÓ%�����%PQ��!���

�"�²��"\]ÑD�¨ÆX�%����#Õö°� 5�%����Å��=}3S3

!/�������ÓD¨ÆóØôõ%�������"Q��êëìí�|Ú�����Öé

�G�EFg�<���á#Õ���[ô�b;5#Õ�i(�"�Ý�����_a

Page 165: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� ������

�\]! ^Ò!]�Academic Cycle¡"�iI�Ú��^Ò!]ºG�§¿��y�J 1965¡/

(3���#Õ"á#Õ�Ú���û�H"�ÚH�^Ò!]ºG�<.�ÍÎ>I,/#Õ�

á#Õ�Ú�^Ò!]ºG�§¿�/#Õ�ÙÚ3�"��À�á#Õ�#Õ3��á#Õ

×Ø���!á#Õ��í>I�/á#Õ=�!�#Õ=�!��"3�/�������5

��?SmF½%��(�±93HI�PQ>I�l3�+,�5�#Õ�ÙÚÌ5��>I�

!�/#Õ=á#Õ=û�H(�/l�±9��ïp�Ú��^Ò!]ºG�U�ÌI�l

"3�/Ï�g3<.�_a�\]! ^Ò!]ºG"!9�3�Ú�<.5�3S����

sÏg3��5 �#$��"����5 �/�� 5�����<¡¢"��£|#$ 5

��§T�_a�\]! ^Ò!]ºG�¤¥�<�I�l"3�/91��<.����

��¦ó§`�%st��!��5�#Õ"á#Õ�¨�(Ii��<g3ØðÒ]|§©½

=^Ò!]H·¸�%¹3!/J

J

������� ������������

��������������ÖF�`!]��b��KL 60 Ú�M���ef""

=�H�,/KL�ª 1��#¦�«f`_�áâ�¬Æ�?�í>I�È�ÌÌÙÚÌ5Þ

ß�,/�¿����5�­Çg33�wF®Ù>I,/_a�\]! ^Ò!]ºG=(5

l�¬Æ5§¿�!�/J

ª 2 �� 1960 ÚCy���0�G�¯ª°±����#¦¤¥�°�(��I���

�0#$%êÜ�AB5E��áâ%²³�,L�´��µ ��´m¶'%²��·[�

����AB¸¹>I��"!9«f`_ØðÒ]�¯ª�4(�±93�/=��)>

5������ Uð����?@Ú�� 42&5 +,/l�Ý�5�_a�\]! ^Ò!]

ºG�#Õ"á#Õ�Ú���<.3��5�á#Õ%y,�í(�¥'�íÚ��º�

U���®Ùg3�l"»�9/#Õ"�Ú��� 15 &AG�¬z">I���¼½3­®

5�����Ú���¾W(�"�sÏg�#Õ�ÙÚ3?3�Ii�#Õ×Ø��¿���

È�ÌÌ5���5U3!/È�,�ÀÁ� ��ÂÚá#Õ"!9ÃÄ=§Å�Æ3!/�

���l9�,_a�\]! ^Ò!]ºG��<g§©½�?h�"�>?ÇÈ3<.%É

UÊl(/��=�˽Ú�� 15 &̱+��Í��5���=ªMÖ����>I�Î5

=3!/J

>?ª 3 �� 1980 ÚCLÏ��5�����5� ���"���#$��������

��?����·Ð�>I� b5�Öé�G=NO>I�1990ÚC�?�Ñ�ÒÓóØôõ

�4�3þ| 1997 Ú�N��HI=PQ>I�/ª 2 �%�Ù�, ���|Öést��

F(�,��ÔÐ�qDg3_a�\]! ^Ò!]ºG=�)g�H��¿��/���

�±+��������ÓD¨ÆX��ÕÖH>I��5�Ú��<.�×���ØÙ(�M

b� b5�Ì,y,3<.�§¿�/1�"���Ú�� 15&Ì�Ú³����=Øð�Û�

ÑH>I3!ÝC3�/��=�ªÜ¯ÝÞ�ß�õ±� 18 &ÖËà|��NOEF�

��áâ|á#Õ�#Õ¨á�âܱ+����������#Õö°�c)Vû�ãäå

Page 166: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� �����

�,�æ´çJ 1996¡/#Õ��RS3�"�Ú��l»��l"3SVËN�%�è5U�

;<½�ûS3�"�Ý���5Ô#ÕÜÖ=é�S3!/ ���±�l9�,Öé��

H�´b5'û�HºG"!9_a�\]! ^Ò!]�§¿�/34�#$��=,?(<

.�±��êH(�/û��3��²��«¬ë��U�ÌI�;<½�ûS3���ìb

#Õ"!9���íî<.3��Æ3!éï=ð�5!�/ª 3����â����«f`

_ñ���H�|��Ý�5 �/×ØÑ!6I�,��Mb5TU6I��?I|����

´b5���0ñB-AòóL"ô�g3�âçèa]ô¦"�My,3Æ�%ñ��|��

Ý�5 �/l�<.�!��¯õ5ö÷øù�l""���ll5�ÍÎ(�:��/J

ª 4 ���2000 ÚC����4�ÖH|ÈIEF(����#$����|¨Æ�hÇ�

�^9Öé���Xú�¬Æ5 �/l�¬Æ��Ì��2001Ú��12sä�NÔ±��

����îï���|�78��û�ÕÖ���Fg3#$����%Ð�(�l"�;<"

3+,/>? 2004 ÚG��4����ÖH"ÈIEF(��ü#$ýþv��)7v±

�NO5�ÄL������|Öé��ô3�U3¤¥%���l"3�/ÈI?�opg

�US)��"���#¦������¦D�PQ"¨Æ�hÇ�5 �/=�����ÖH�

ë)�¨Æ�(�lI?�ME�HI��]�"��PQ>I,�5�3S�¯�|NO�Ý

��Ìþ�,6¾�¦v�ÈI�Iµ¶(���"S�lI�?�=��Ïõ5cd��!�

¼������#$����|_a�\]! ^Ò!]�U3¤¥%Z�(l"3�/º»

�Ò�ß`��¦�Z����"!9 ���±+�Ü?I�!�,��"S ����

NO>I�"(Ii�����Ò�ß`��¦�Z��º�H(�/J

�������� ���� �

2004Ú��ü#$ýþv��)7v!��á#ÕC��#Õ�¨Æ%PQ(���

��Ù�3>I,��#ýJ 2005¡/<.��¨Æ|¨���Ù"#$����"��£5

�/lIÌ5��B#$�ª 58�ª 7�!��á#Õ�¨����#Õ�¨�%á���"

�Ù>I,��È�,�#Õ�¨��«�×Ò����#Õ"��£ �/-���£�

!��#Õ%á��¨��#Õ�?ï4½%£+,�¿¨��!�I(ùU� �/)7v

5�mh'�·�L��4¥4+�NO���?I�l""3+,/L�%��(�"!9

l"������#$������sÏg����"�78�%�í��!���mh���

�����78�wp��������á#Õ"#Õ��£�µ6g5� ���á#Õ

�ï4½��1±�ûS3+�!�"!9º_� ����g=Úí(�/È�,�#Õ�

�g3���Ù���l9�,mh��,>I,/��Üi1��Ø�5�º»�mh�1

��3!"!9����!,±9»��!�I��=-��)�"E���<��!����

���*½H(�/¨Æ��i<.|È�12���½�<.�!�Ìþ>I����: 1�

±93NÔ�b� �/ll5 L3Ã�����"¨Æ"��£5 �9/ÔÐ�����

�1����Ð���J#Õ�á#ÕZ[áâ5 +,��á#Õ¨%6!���ÈIC��

Page 167: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� ������

#Õ%î4�,¨�"��Ù"�,¥'�#$����"�¦ó§`�"��£�N��<�I

�l"3�/�����������������|�78�±�¾W��S�/���"

!9ÔÐ� 1�¦ó§`�@1��@1#Õ#α"!9ÑÒÓDd�]±�=�1�¦ó§`�@

1 �78@1 #¦�Å"!9_�`aDd�]��H�$�!qruv�±�Ë'g»"��

I����l��]�"���^Ò!]½ �/l�±9������¡¢��¦ó§`�¡

"��£½"Þß½����%&��5 �i��53S��§%&��5 ��©ª�'ªs

ä"�� �!�#$��ï(�V��À"���<��!�/lI6����������

����¡¢��¦ó§`�¡"��£½� ���Þß½�^Ò!]��>S����%&�

�5 +�=¨ÆX��?cCgÞß½�3!/Ì,�§%&�����#$§[Z"õ|Ø

!�]5 �/-��ö÷�?¬Ø>I�±9����5Ò�ß`��¦�Z�Þß(��=�

���"!9��ñh �/_�`a5Ò�ß`��¦�Z�)!�¯*+%"��?I�m

pw(l"� ,3����������±���¡¢��¦ó§`�¡|ÖgcC��Þ

ß½ �/�Ì����������")!�¯*�òÜi�Ò�ß`��¦�Z+%��

-Ü�HI¡��]�"3+��<��!��5 �/.Hg3/Ã�?h�=�������

����F½|�ß½� ��¤¥�¬±�Ë��!�/����uv� ?0�1Ý]5Þ

ßg5KÙ�,233���~a���ô˾g5 +,/#$"���µ�(�qg½i

%���!�,��¬zg����"���������4Ã%�Å'�·,ÕÖ5�M�#

$����%X5(�l"�V=�6>I���#$"���µ78(��<%£�»��Õ

Ö3�M���-�%)H>·,b�5èÜ��5 �/_�`ad�]�L��b�%���

�!����¦ó§`��~a9A±+�-�G%:C>·�óØôõ=èÜ?I�/!�I

��= ����NO±+�#$����US�F(�l"�M¶!3!/J

! �� �"�� #�����

�� ���� �

�� �

��

��

�� ����

�� �

��

�� ����

�� �

#$

��

�� �����

�� �

��

��

�� ���� �

�� �

��

��

���������

�������

��� �

�� �

� �

�� �

� �

�� �

� �

�� �

� �

�� �

� �

�� �

Page 168: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� �����

��12sä!���� ���"������"�78���Ù�?;<>I��� 

�7=�-A��#$��3�8g%å�(�,��#$-A�Ð��ª 25 �� 2 ���g3

�òÈ�´�#$���m>���?#¦�µ@�)�"E����p�%������AN

�%»���3�±9BC(�=�"(��"�Ù>I�/ ����opg3�D�EÊ>

I�!3!/l�l"� ����Ù��RH%FG(�=��²9��ÄL�Hw%hI��

L� �9/AN�%»%JK(�,������#$����%Ü�stq�LY½�

&'�ÞM�¾í���"²9����"!9sÏg<.�LN"3�/l9�,q���"�

�*>I,¨Æ�¨�"#$�����NOO�"(Ii�ÈI�,"Ü'�gPn>I,

"��=�ÈI��3���!¿�5 +��Q���NO�3�¹3!/#$���q"a

`«ú"õ��£½������q"��§©��£½�"!9-��<.%#$����"�

�²9Pn&'(���<�I�/���"!9��� ����#$"��%&'(�35M

ÝC%R�,�������S25 +,��lI�?��H�$�!qruv�ÝC�-.

�R!/ª 4�!���_a�\]! ^Ò!]=�7|����µ6gh�±��U3

��5§¿�l"3���mF½�û�IiÙT(�l"=èÜ?I�/9oU��)´

!��z��oU�PQ>I�!�±93��!"Øð�"!9U����Fg3���è

V>I�!�/��!"Øð��WXg�Y±+�Ü?I��5���g3��%êÜ�Z

[>I3S3Ii�È���!"Øð��ÙT(�ë\ ��¤¥�¬�©ªB)�Ë��

!��=�I3!/�lz]��Y&F^��%!�=�Ì��V=~ag3¡¢%Ìþ

��_��Å�È�#Õ×Ø�c)g/´5�â%�`��a�â5ï��p�%ë�5

U�óØôõPQ��!�/>?N��±�Z[���>I�!�/x�!�=xØ�

��Øð�#Õ{"bc+��È�#Õ%��B)>I,©ª5�ô���|áâ%ì+�ÏÖ

���5U�ÝM%������ãä�3%:�/dX�¦e 2,500��9� 2004ÚG� 39�

ÃB)(�"�9/ÈI?�����"���lI�?�fg �b�� 1�5 ����

�0-A|�B-A� �#$��"��a`«ú"õ|�§%&��"���<.�P�/!

�I��=Ö�|¬��sh��¡¢|uv7�|���¾íb~D���¡¢5�²�±9

3�����i>��!��� �!�#$���²9èÜ?I�ùU��<�I±9/#$�

�����)H�±�M��p(�;<½= �»�9/J

¤¥j"g3���Y�WXgB)óØôõ�s5���_ 1Þú�%st"�,?k�Z

[±+�¼���|¼Ö1Ý]5�WX�$H(�/�1�±93Ú����êëìí��

�=+?��hÇ�%·¸�%¹3!/ ������783���%l]Ñm�ô¦�Z(�

óØôõ%PQ(Ii�6no�����=pq�<�rí(�/����¤¥sÉUºG%

tUÊl�¤¥WX�$H(�/�����¼���"��783���%âuSTU(�óØ

ôõ%X5(�l"±+��v 3ÖF�w%²9��(���lI�?�V= L3-.�

M�3�9/�4���ÖH±+�Öé�(�����ºXú>I,/�4�Ö���

Öé��RH±+���Ú��¨Æ"TU�RlH�#¦�#$�����9H�Ô#Õ�Æ

�)H�ÙÚ�Z[ÙÚL�TU�ª 4�!�ÉUÊl>I�_a�\]! §[çä]óx

Page 169: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� ������

�ïp�yÏg3·Ù"�Lz>�l""3�9/lI?�(���-.��E§[eä!�

5H���!�����#¦¤¥���/Ã�?�Üi�lI?�rÀ{|Ô+�opg9

Ù�����%6Gm�(��L� �9/È�,��9Ù��7!��²�±93�

���|Öé�NO�ýp>I�ÈI?�_a�\]! ^Ò!]ºG%§Ê>·�!����

ÈI��Ý�����V= L3}\�M�5 ��<g§©½�Academic Productivity¡"

��£%m�(��L� �/¬Ì"º¥�m�g��%Ú������W~Ð�����op

g3<.Ã"-.�hÜ�S�µ¶3!/J

$%&'()�

�Ï��1981¡���Ö�uv����u/J

P. G.J_]�\]!Ð �æ´ç��´Î¡�2004¡�XYNOÝC����#¦�ÖéH

I���ö÷�/Ã�?���COE��ó`��5¡����û�#$��b~��ð�/J

¨´�Ô�1988¡�_a�\]! S�g���½���uv���z��/J

W. a\�ZØ�� �M ���ÔΡ�1972¡�àÏ���#Õ����/J

y�Ú��1965¡�àÏ���#Õ¤¥��������z�� �/J

y�Ú�Ð�1969¡����l�àÏg3�=����� �/J

y�Ú�Ð �1984¡���#Õ¨��'g���_a�\]! §[çä]óx��uv���

R� �/J

��òM ���M�1996¡�àÏ�������s �� ��/J

�æ¡�1994¡���"_�`auv�¢à�£/J

��7�¤7�¥¦ �¦ýþv�2005¡ÖF�¦v���RlH(��â��ÖF�«f`_

�Ø�!��2005Ú7§¡��2007Ú<."��¨©�cC���#¦��ªÙÚ±�¬

v���v)´!�cCÞM�3âSp�3!«¬� �"ÍÎ>I�!�¡/J

æ´ç���1981¡�7�����"uvH�������#$����ð��7�uv���

��No.49�32-39­/J

æ´ç���1990¡���#Õ�wF�����B��� B)��aù�õ��z��/J

æ´ç���1996¡�wF½"®���Ï� ¯�°MÐ ���#Õ¨���ö÷�s ��

���148-204­/J

æ´ç���2001¡���#¦�mF½"�<g§©½�±²³´ µ¶· �z¸¹ �Ú©

��1Þú��к�¦vÐ���NO�-."XÃ��z�²»yÓu�329-353­/J

æ´ç���2005¡�#¦�mF½%�(=��+��N���mhP¼%sèÜ���

�Between�10-11§½���_Ñ�14-17­/J

æ´ç��¾C¿À Á�� Ã�ÔÄ�2005¡�àÏ���#¦¤¥·è�9Å º» ~

Ð���COE��ó`��15¡����û�#$��b~��ð�/J

æ´ç��¾C¿À ÆÇÈM �µ³É�2004¡�������#¦�(�ÖéHI�N�

�P¼%�����COE��ó`��4¡����û�#$��b~��ð�/J

Page 170: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� ������

� 11 �� ������� �������

��� ��∗

���� ��

����������� �����

� ����� ���������������������� !"#�$%&�

'()*%+�",-./012345� 1978�59 678�9:�;45319787����

��������"�<=>?@(:- 1)�A����(�$%&B"CDEF�GH"

��� I"JK�LMNOPQ&O�R%O����01�FDSTUVW�XYZ(:

�8�[\]^EF�;

� _`a�:�bcd9�e( 40f�g�e( 30f9:DSGH�Ahi9�8cd�R

Fjk"lDE\m��EF�(�no�pqrstuv"$%w9xy/��/�a�8c

d� 60f� 50f�FzQ&o"lDE\m���8�">�;8cd%&�'� 20%

{|"}S-��$^SwwQ&Or�~L^�K�}K9:�345� 19787;8lz"c

d��(%&����01"�|�w��8�">�;

� 8z^S�����^E�45319657�����k����������%����

������[��EF�;^�^�0x��Az^S��(����EFSh�������

k������p�l-�������� ¡¢��£�¤¥¦§¨©�ª«�>¬G­®(¯

°�">DE|±±:�;8�w9%����cd²��³´µ¶ ·³¸"lDE¹$��

S�� ���º�����pD��|>»¼½¾!"J��EF�;

_`a�k�����"¿DEÀEp�1997%#���¨yÁ"Â/�ÃÄ2�F}

Å�yÁ²ÃÆÇ"ÈF�yÁ²�gÉPcÊ�FDSËÁÌ͵�ÎÏ":�pÐK9

>Ñ��e"Ò^Ep<�/�8�(ÓÔ�>DEF�;ÕÖ"JK��×Ø�²mÙÚÛp

ÜwDEF�8�[:}uÝÀ�a����k�"JK�����²�Þ�±±:��F`�;

wS�ßà²áâ����3Japan Research Career Information Network�ãä JREC-IN7

åæ"Èzßà²çƨ"l�èép:DE��������p0xêb��":�3ëì

í� 2005a7;��"�îï�� ��������ÚÛ�ðñ�pF`�bcd²��A

òÑ( 1990%���£óiO3¥ôO7õö÷ø"JFE��cd²"sù���8�

�>DS 2);

� 8lz"�0x���k�������45319657��(>��EFSh���

úû�ü>DSp">DEF�;^�^��� �����������ýþ��S}K9

�>Ñ�îïA���wSü>��9��(VWEF�8�(\]��EF�3ëìí�

������������ �� e-mail: [email protected]

Page 171: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� ������

2005a7;/>}���cd²rsù"lDE�#%&�"8Ð}�8�>Ñ�<yo[��9

|�ÓÔZ�QÑ>���h"�cd9=�e 2kp�^Ñ>F;I¥"l�8z^Sk�

½O�q�9�Q&O01�Fz�� ��������23ëìí� 2005a�15 67�Fz

��[VW�u��Fz9:�;

� A�9��0x���k�����P���' ¾"JFE��� ��������

"îð��ü>���(À���Ð�z�;Ö�9��wv��� ¶�[�FEÕÖ��

�%&��"±FE�����[��^S��:������cd[�_�^Sû�[

Çz8�9�8i"±FE���"^EF|SF;

���������������� !�

� wv�ÕÖ���%&���½O[��^SF;���%&��"��^S Ç

��"��45319657P!í319847¨(����� 3);45319657�"����o ¡

#$%&'3ÕÖ�()*¼� 19567�" ¡#����o�����$+'3ÕÖ�()*¼�

19617[�FE����[tV%#"BO^�A%&��[ 2hi,9�-^EF�;!í

319847��"�.��¢/'301»� 19827[�FE�4523��-/�8�"lDE

÷4 20%,���e¬G½L[���"^EF�;

� 8�� Ç��9�����%&��(��eB�g�e�cÊB9�$%5[6S

GH"7z~L^EF��[û�/�8�9�� ��������ç8[���"/�8

�"9:(:DS;^�^�;/�lz"�0��<M9��=û�(>v^p?è9>F;

/>}���cd²@9���eA¢(g�eBC>DEF��>v^p>�>FSG�

A%&��[HI/�8�(�� ��������ç8[���"/�8�"�>�>Ñ

>DE|EF�9:�;

� 8i"±FE���"/�SG"���J Ç��lz>��� ¶�[�FS�K�

¶L9�¿M(:�SG��_"l�û�"N�O�>F;^�^�Az^S�_"l�û�[

�����!9<P"ýQ/�SG"p�ÕÖ���¢Ï#%&��(7lz"R

~^EF��[��^EJÑ8��óD9:�;A89�889� 3%+�"SÇ���"�

��TU23âVW'3<¥X�Y7[�FE��Z[%&½O\D[HI/�"�7

G�8��/�;

] 1 �����%&���½O[^^Sp9:�;���>��[À���1974 %

_`�30%,9�eZ[%&� 2fO7�g�e�cÊ9� 4fO7�B^EF�;ASG�

�e�g�eZ[%&�� 1974% 13.3f�� 2fO7êwDS�">DEF�;8�[a

b�8#"À���.æ9� 30%,9 0.6f�ßæ9� 0.2f�cd��(À���"Ò^�

eæ9� 3.7f��e�g�e%&�[�|ÑêGEF�;

SÐ^�8 ¶���û��8���:Ñw9���%&��(���"Q&O^EF

�8��A^EAfé��e�g�e%&�(êwDEF��Fz8�9:�;Ö�9��

Page 172: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� ������

" �� ����������� !�

1974 1977 1980 1983 1986 1989 1992 1995 1998 2001 2004

�� 55.3 55.3 55.6 55.9 56.3 56.6 56.8 56.9 57.0 57.1 57.2

��� 42.0 42.2 42.6 43.3 44.1 44.5 44.8 45.0 45.3 45.6 45.9

�� 38.4 37.9 38.6 39.4 40.3 40.8 41.3 41.6 42.0 42.2 42.5

������ 13.3 13.1 13.0 12.6 12.2 12.1 12.0 11.9 11.7 11.5 11.3

�� 53.1 53.0 53.5 54.3 54.7 54.7 54.6 54.5 54.6 54.9 55.2

��� 41.7 41.8 42.2 42.9 43.6 43.8 43.9 43.8 43.8 44.2 44.4

�� 36.6 37.6 38.4 39.3 40.2 40.2 40.7 40.7 41.2 41.7 42.2

������ 11.4 11.2 11.3 11.4 11.1 10.9 10.7 10.7 10.8 10.7 10.8

�� 52.8 53.2 54.0 54.7 55.2 55.3 55.4 55.2 55.4 55.7 56.1

��� 42.5 42.8 43.5 44.1 45.0 45.1 44.8 44.6 44.9 45.5 46.0

�� 38.3 38.8 39.9 40.8 41.9 42.3 41.9 41.6 41.8 41.7 42.2

������ 10.3 10.4 10.5 10.6 10.2 10.2 10.6 10.6 10.5 10.2 10.1

�� 57.1 57.2 57.3 57.3 57.4 57.9 58.3 58.5 58.6 58.5 58.5

��� 42.3 42.5 42.9 43.7 44.5 45.2 45.9 46.5 47.0 47.2 47.4

�� 39.2 38.0 38.6 39.4 40.1 41.0 41.6 42.0 42.4 42.4 42.6

������ 14.8 14.7 14.4 13.6 12.9 12.7 12.4 12.0 11.6 11.3 11.1

��

�"^lz�^EF����cd²@9���%&��9:�SG�8�� ¶�

��*û>û��Ç`>F;/>}���e�g�e�%&���gh�áâ�^EóD9�

:�(�Ö�9i�"j�uak^�l$cdI�,%&���(l-óD> ¶�

�>�;^�^�A��[��� ¶���HI/�8��mn9:�;A89op9��:�

�����cd[�_�^E�l$cdI�,%&��[���"^SF;

#�$%&'(���)�����*+���,�-.&'/01 23*�

45319787���� ����������#.æ�k<�»¼X�q�!9pcd²[

rDEF���2345� 1978�58679VW�ÓÔZ(�|F���^EF�;/>}��#�

s�A89tu[v�>��wxP��EF(/y�EF�SG�$%w9A8"F±zK�k

(�¥û9:�23��7��9:�;A89Ö{9��l"Az^S��(|}9:�z.æ�

�Ãkz������9:� A��[�_�^E~-���;

� cd"±FE���� ���������_���^E�k<X��»¼X����"

wS(����[��Ò1�^S45319787"�F�A�����Â� 9cd[Ò1�/

� 4);A�����Â�cd��19783�� 537%"bcd²���cd²r�~Ç^�2000

%"����¥������¥(TH���4���¥(S�^���� �����®� �

��p"�����"ubzK��S;^�^�Aç8����^Ebcd²"�F��[r

DEF�SG���cd[hq�9�-/�8�(ÓÔ9:�;_@9�"�.��¢/'30

1»��%��7"�`�����¥ô�[�FEû�[ÇFSF;

� �E�] 2"^^EF���A������cd"JK��,%&��9:�;�

%�ÕÖQ¨��[�� 15%����9�`lz�/�L|(À���(�5)����V

�[ 30%��$/�a��e�g�e®��%&�� 15f�Fz8�">�;no®�[

 uE�]9��� 15������%":S� 1960%�1975%�1990%�2005%hi

l$cdI�,%&��[^^EF�;

Page 173: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� ������

" �� + ����,�-.&'4567��)������

��a 50 �

��b 47 � 62 �

��� 54

��d 37 52 �

��e 41 �

��a 51 �

��b 43 58 �

��� 43 � 58 �

��d 40 55

��e 62 �

��a 51 �

��b 38 53

��� 38 53

��d 42 57

��e 46

��a 51 �

��b 39 54 �

��� 44 � 59 �

��d 37 52 �

��e 41 �

��a 49

��b 36 51 �

��� 42 57

��d 50

��e 61 �

��a 60 �

��b 55 �

��� 35 50

��d 60 �

��e 54 �

��f 49 �

��a 58 �

��b 36 51 �

��� 30 45 60

��d 54 �

��a 61

��b 48 63

��� 49

��d 45 60

��e 41

��a 45 � 60 �

��b 39 54 �

��� 57

��d 49

47.53 48.25 47.93 52.28

8.49 8.93 9.71 6.84

2005199019751960

����

�E

�F

�G

�H

�I

�A

�B

�C

�D

���������� �������������������������

���������� � � !������ � "#$%&'()*+,��������

� � � � � � �-. / '� 0�&1()*2-. 3�� 4556 789:;<666 78=:�&1>?���

@AB��

� � � � � � �C����������$D�EFG����������

Page 174: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� ������

wv�����Â�cd��Z[%&R~[ÀEÀ���1960%hi9� 46.94f�1975

%hi9��48.25 f�1990 %hi9� 47.93 f�½O(:w-À��>F"Ò^�2005 %

hi9� 52.28f�����Â�cd��( 1990%_` 15%,9¡¢"Q&O^EF�8�

(}��;o"£¤C� 6)R~[ÀEÀlz;1960 %hi9� 8.73�1975 %hi9� 8.93�

1990%hi9� 9.71�A¥R~"�¦���(z�(`�"Ò^�2005%hi9� 6.84

�8�w9">Ñb�>¥[^^EF�;

8��fé[:}uÝÀ���1990%hiw9�����Â�cd��Z[%&"½O�

À��v�A%&��pC-(:w-À��>�DS"Ò^�2005%hi9��îðl-p

Z[%&(�B^�^�p%&��"pC-(À���8�(}��;

l"�o%&��C-"§¨^EF��©}��(�¢Ï��9:�;]!9��ª

«K^EF�p[#�e2�Az9>Fp[#g�e2:�F�#cÊ2�^E]J^EF�

(�2005%hi ¶�[À���cd F�cd G�Fz 2±cd(�e 2k"lDE��

��EF�8�(}��;�%&[À���cd F9�� e�� f%&�� 5f�c

dG9�� c�� d%&�� 6f�¬GE%&(�F 2k"lDEcd(����EF�

8�(}��;8i"±FEpz­^®^ÑÀ�SG"�A�����Â�cdI%&�

[^^S(] 39:�;

" #� + ����,�-.&'(���8�

1960 1975 1990 2005

��A 3 - 17 11

��B 8 15 18 7

��C 13 15 11 11

��D 12 10 22 11

��E 13 9 - 11

��F 20 - - 5

��G 22 19 - 6

��H 13 14 - 19

��I - 6 8

�� 13.00 13.67 14.80 9.89

���� 6.05 3.67 6.30 4.17

���� ��� <>HIJKLM�-.�N���

� � � � ��45O6 7'-. P�Q���2� R�� S'T'U��G�����

wv�A�����Â�cdI%&�Z[R~[ÀEÀ���1960%hi9� 11.75

f�1975%hi9� 13.67f�1990%hi9� 14.80f��cd�,%&��¯���

":�"Ò^�2005%hi9� 9.89f�°±"A�(êwDEF�;£¤C�"±FE��

�cd%&�Z[[p�"²t^EF�(�8�[À���1960%hi 7.00����2005

%hi9� 4.17��cd,%&�a�±|(b�Ñ>DEF�8�(}��;1975%hi

9� 2005%hi¥[@³� 3.679�:�(�Z[¥��( 13.67�QF8�"ÝÀ�a�1975

%hi9��cd,�%&�(���"�|F�89:�"Ò^�2005%hi9��c

Page 175: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� �����

d,�%&�(���"b�F�89:��F`lz;

8����"��1975 %´1990 %�"�KE 3 ±cd"JFERFcÊB(r����

2000%�"��2cd"JFEg�e�"�e(r�������2005%0x9� 2cd"

JFE/�E�e(µ¶��EF�8�(·¸^EF�;8z^S�� ���º�����¹

ºØ»¶>½¼��"��1990%��' ¾[^E½Â,ª«­®(¾¿^�k�>À

ÁÂ[F�"åÁ/����^EÃĽÔ(A�>-"ÅFEF��ÆÇ/�|9:�z;

8hÁ"�cd CP I"JFE�ÈÉ´µ¶ ·³¸3üqÊ°7"l�µ��¶É(Ç}�

EF�8���pA��RË���3] 2[Ìj7;

8��fé[] 2fé�:}uÝÀ�>�a��cd²rsù_`�A�����Â

�cd9�����"cdI�%&(�B^EF�ÐK9>Ñ�cd[��/��,

%&�pêwDEF�8�(}��;8z^S��"��2k�e�������cd FP

cd GÍx"§¨/�ÐKp9�>Ñ�Aqcd�,%&�p�="êwDE

F�8�(ÎÏ^EF�;�cd²rsù"l��Q&O01�Fz�еÑ��:�cd(

çÒ" 2k�e�������8�l-p����' ¾"úÈ^E½ÂI¤ª«­®(¯

°�">-��Jlz"µ¶¢ÏÓ�Pq�t�oÔ[F�Õ�[v>Flz>¬G��

"ÖDEF���`Õ�[v>F;

^�^����V×Z"±FE�A�\£�pF`��u~v��[] 29ÀSGH��

Á~v��"O�Ø7ÙF�À��>�DS;/>}�����Â�cd[��/��z

����hi9ÚÛ�u[~v^EFSpÜH��1960%9 47.1Ý�1975%9 50.0Ý�

1990%9 42.9Ý�2005%9 50.0Ý9:DS;8lz"�­>Ñ�p0hi9���� ��

������������V×Z�\£�^E�u~v���,"�TU�Â�Z

�z�(`>�DS;^�^�;^Slz"��� ��������£¤[½¼�uEw9

�' ¾¬G­®"ÒÞ^E|EF�(�10 �"JFE^���lz"�13 ����ÚÛ

ß~và��<q�®qáGE$H����9�Z[9 80Ýð�"â^EF�;13 ����

z�.æ 9����ÚÛß~và���ã 78.4Ý���Q 89.7Ýw9ûä^EF�;å��

" A�������ÚÛß~và��1954% 16.6Ý�1963% 40.3Ý�1974% 62.3Ý�

1984% 67.0Ý�1994% 70.6Ý�2003% 79.6Ý9:DS;Az^S�����.Z[��-

^E A��æ¶�9��2005%0x9 50.0Ýç¤� 30è�³Éð�é�[�DEJ-�

�� ���������p�l-��ÈÉ´µ¶ ·³¸páGEÒÞ^>K�a�ê�±

^F¬Gª«"ÒÞ/�8��mn9:�8�[^ë^EF�;

9���:04;<7=>?�@A�

� ��"����[r�/�ì(�� ��������[7ø�íî^EF��"±F

EÀEÀlz;_@�Öp9�F���21ïð COEK�¸»�#21ïðñQ¨������

�ò�À�ÁÂ2���ó�^EçÆ��S#�� ¾"±FE2329:�;8

Page 176: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� ������

89�A23z���X{[Ò1�^S23 ¶�[�F� 7);

� ] 4���X{(�r�EF�^E7lz>i[óô^EF��"±FE���ñ#

³õ��[^^Sp9:�;çÆ��S�³æ¶É9� 8±i[ñ^^�A�ö�"±|

#óô/�2#PPóô/�2#óô^>F2#GH"l-ü>�2 4ÎÏ9÷ø^Ep�DS;

>J����ñ��ùú.��q#$H�� a2�ù²��[ák#$H�� b2��¥)( 2

±_�9û�¥:�#üH�� a2��¥)( 2 ±_�9û�¥>F#üH�� b2�ù²�

�[ý��^S#üH�� c2�û�¥[þ±#�X�� a2�û�¥[þS>F#�X�� b2

7±"û�^EF�;

" 9� ���=>BC 23DE<7F�

����a ����b ����a ����b ����c ����a ����b

�� 98.5% 94.3% 90.3% 80.2% 92.6% 62.5% 73.3%

� � 68.2% 65.2% 60.6% 67.4% 64.8% 87.5% 68.3%

������� 6.1% 11.5% 12.3% 13.2% 10.2% 25.0% 14.7%

������������� 18.2% 27.0% 26.6% 33.1% 27.8% 0.0% 26.5%

����� 83.3% 75.7% 68.4% 49.9% 61.1% 62.5% 34.3%

! 1.5% 1.4% 0.9% 2.2% 1.9% 0.0% 1.5%

"# 51.5% 23.0% 14.4% 11.4% 21.3% 12.5% 14.0%

$% 43.9% 50.4% 43.0% 53.8% 54.6% 50.0% 51.2%

��VW'T�XYZ��[�\]G^_''`a��G�����

8fé[À����� ��������"Ò/�°�[^/\£9:�#q��%

&�»³�2��Fv����ñ"JFEp\^E#���L2P#���L2�#ÚÛ�

u2P#�2Z2l-�óô��EJ�v�#Z#2P#»¼�¶���L2l-�óô����

�":��F`�;>J�#$H�� a2lz>wxQF��9��#���L2P#ÚÛ

�u2�#.ÒZ2(¡¢"óô��EF�"Ò^�#q��%&�»³�2"±FE�

q���ñ��-^SGH"�Aóô���Ò�"ãF; ;lz"�wxQF��O

7k���/�SG��� ����������[íî/�>D(:�Ð(�ç8�^

EAz^S��(�Ò�"�:w-íî��EF>F�Fz8�(z�(`lz;

� p��Ø�8 ¶��0hi"JFE�r�EF�^Eóô/�i9:-�÷4��

��-/�(�>F;wxQF��9��� ����������(�Ò�"�:w-í

î��EF>F�Fz���ê"ÜwDSa�-9>Ñ�÷4�����FEF��p^�

>F;^�^�Az^S�'��ðpw9"ÀS�Q&O01r�еÑ�t[��/�D

�:�F�A�"� [�K�D�>��p^�>F;

G�HI�JK�

� Ö�9��0x���k�����@"JFE��� ��������"îð��ü

>���(À�����Fz��Â�"gz|�wv��� ¶�[�FEÕÖ���

Page 177: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� �����

%&��"±FE�����[��^S��A�����Â�cd[�_�^Sû�[ÇF�

��"��k�"Ò/�r�ì�î"±FE��^S;9D>���^E�_@ 3i(�

����;

� ��"�"���TU23âVW'[�FE�ÕÖ���¢Ï#%&��(7l

z"R~^EF��[û�^Sfé����%&������"Q&O^EJ-�Af

é��e�g�e%&�(êwDEF�8�(���">DS;

� �j"�A�����Â�cd"JK��,%&��[û�^Sfé��cd²rs

ù_`����"cdI�%&(�B^EF�ÐK9>Ñ�cd[��/��,%

&�pêwDEF�8�(���">DS;8z^S����Ak�À��[F�"åÁ/

��:�}�9:��R���;

��"����[r�/�ì(óô^EF�i[û�^Sfé�l"wxQF��O7�

� ����������[íî/�>D(:�"p��}�v�ç8�^EAz^S��(

�Ò�"�:w-íî��EF>Flz"À���;

� _���[�w`���0����¬G���Q&O01�Fz�� �������

���"����EJ-�45�"lDE��(Ç}�EFS�hl-p������[¦^

EF��F`�;/>}���� ��������ÖÀ�>����ëìí32005a7p\

]/�lz"��>�%&��9�>�%&����"lDE���g�>��9:

���P����Z"��(VW�8�":�SG9:�;

� �o!"����P����Z�Fz8���(bcd�S�"�DEJ-�0x�bc

d²[rDEF��¬GE­)9:� 2)�Fz��"ÝÀ�>�a�Az^S���bcd

²[rDEF��¥"�DE��"÷�v�óDô/�|��9:����`>F�p

F��p^�>F;^�^��_�^E~-��S A��lz"�]�|��cd�[r-

>(���ç�bcd�[rDEF��­>��vÍx/�;wS��� ������

�������"cd¹����"�7w�p9�>Ñ��¥¹��P��¹����

9p:�^����"�`�a�MP��¬G¹����9p:�345� 19657;

� éS^E��Q&O01�Fz�� ��������������P����Z"7

lz>·¸[��/9:�z�;wS����V×Z�%&�Â�(\]��EF�(34

5� 1978O�7��Q&O01�Fz�� ����������(���V×Z"7lz

>·¸[��/��Fzip¡¢"*��F��9:�;^�^�8i"±FE�Â�0

hi9�hÁ Ë9:�SG�qÕ[Á/8��^SF;

LMN�

1)� 45319657���$%&B"CDS�� ��������TU[�b¿"ÑF�G

�SG"��#�e�g�e�cÊ%&�[*�%>F^*!�"%"^E����[Z

[/�8�2345� 1965�23467(>D���^EF�;

Page 178: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

� �� ������

2)� bcd²����ð��#�$ñcd[�u�^Sk�����9:-�A¢Ï

�����e 1�g�e�cÊ 1�Fz%&ñ(gÖ9:�;bcd²@9���eè�

É('�>F¿-�g�e�cÊ�BCüL[Ç`>FSG��� ��������(�

��>�;>J��;/�#�� ¾"±FE2323�X{237"l�a�0

x�8�^Ebcd²[��Sp� 12.3Ý�¡¢"­>Ñ�ê�����[(G�

�9�p�Þ^F��`����8�^Ebcd²[��Sp� 7.9Ý��bcd²�ê

�pêb^EFÑ8�()����;

3)� 8O�"p�*+319887��"�.��¢/'301»� 1981�19857[�FE�1981

%hi"JK��.��� �ûì%&��[,|�<Xq�®Xq���

L8[HI/���p"��-��¥�%&��[ 2hi,9�-^�A��

-��¥�%&��.ï)/¨[ÇDEF�;

4)� �0"����FDEp��X��w9áG��AÒ1�¬GE0?>p�>�;A

SGÖ{9���-�1?���o(è�É"±FEF�8�(�$���cd[Ò1�

^S;>J�] 2"^/#cd I2� 1960%hi9�Íx^EF>FSG�1960%û�

Ò1�#cd I2[2Ñ 8cd�/�;

5)� _`a�ëìí32005b7��1945%�� 1960%[#34Á2�1975%w9[#Q��{

Á2�1990%w9[#5²Á2�2005%w9[#�' ¾Á2�û�^EF�;

6)� £¤C����:� ¶��w-!9�6© ¶�(A ¶���Z[¥��7

ø��K7�EF��[]/8�9:�;

7)� �³æ¶É23� 2006 % 3´4 5"�KE�2005 %��"���+'"J9��EF�

����¥��X/�E[Ò1"ÇDS;�X{"Ò/�23?è³õ)� 1,4549:-�

³:à� 29.3Ý9:�;

LOPQRN�

!í;<319847#���e¬G½L� � 1 =� k0L8�½O245ã>?"���e¢

$H���@�� ����K�AB��C³»¼�@'òDt��33´516;

45ã>319657"ÕÖ���e¬G@����@'EFGt�»;

45ã>319787"ÕÖ�M@H�I23J"À��oïM@'ÕÖ6K4L»;

��¢/MǼ?"�.��¢/'�%���01»;

*+=N319887#Ow�ï�,PZ¨@�-��¥��� ��������337@2

"4Q�����¥ðD'� 30�� 2ß�197´2166;

<¥3X�7Y"���TU23âVW'�%��;

ëìíRS32005a7#�³´µ¶ ·³¸ÅÑ`2"ÕÖ���¬GT�@÷4�0x�

Uï@'3COE���µ¶V 1570W��Q¨����XSY³�¶�3´186;

ëìíRS32005b7#��ÕÖ�� ¾����e¬G½O2� 2³Õ!Q¨��AZ¶»

�[� 33³���¼30W��7S]¦\;

Page 179: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

�����

����

���� � � � �� �������������� ������ !

�"� #$� � � � � �� � �%�����&� ��

�'� ()� � � � � � �� �������������� ��

*� +,� � � � � � � �� � �%�����&� #-./01

23� 4)� � � � 56 � ���������� 78

�9:;<=>?@ABCDEFGH��

I��JKLMNOPQI

�COE��JR�S25!

2007�T?19!U 2 V 16W� �X

�� Y� �� �������������

Z739I8512� [��\]�1I2I2

� _ (082)424I6240

http://rihe.hiroshima-u.ac.jp/

abc� defg� �hi�jR�iklmn

Z730I0052� ��\opqrs3I2I30

� _ (082) 244I1110

ISBN978-4-902808-27-8

Page 180: COE Publication Series No. 25 A Study of Research Policy ......February 2007 Research Institute for Higher Education HIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY ISBN978 -4 902808 -27 8 COE Publication Series

February 2007

Research Institute for Higher EducationHIROSHIMA UNIVERSITY

ISBN978-4-902808-27-8

COE Publication Series No. 25

A Study of Research Policy,Research Training, and Mobility

in the Academic Community

February 2007