Coal to Liq Westinghouse Flint ApegAnl Presentn09

download Coal to Liq Westinghouse Flint ApegAnl Presentn09

of 46

Transcript of Coal to Liq Westinghouse Flint ApegAnl Presentn09

  • 7/29/2019 Coal to Liq Westinghouse Flint ApegAnl Presentn09

    1/46

    FOX CREEK COAL TO LIQUIDS PROJECT:GREEN FUELS FOR THE FUTURE

    Presented by:

    en n , . ng., . . - ro ec anager

    APEGGA Professional Development DaysTELUS Convention Centre

    Cal ar Alberta

    Friday April 24, 2009

  • 7/29/2019 Coal to Liq Westinghouse Flint ApegAnl Presentn09

    2/46

  • 7/29/2019 Coal to Liq Westinghouse Flint ApegAnl Presentn09

    3/46

    Inexpert use of data in this presentation

    could be harmful to your companys bottom line,and may shorten an otherwise promising career !

    3

  • 7/29/2019 Coal to Liq Westinghouse Flint ApegAnl Presentn09

    4/46

    Agenda

    Alter NRG Cor orate Overview &

    how the Fox Creek Coal-to-Liquids Projectgot started

    Fox Creek Project Overview

    Focus on Key Environmental Challenges- Carbon and Water Management

    4

  • 7/29/2019 Coal to Liq Westinghouse Flint ApegAnl Presentn09

    5/46

    Who is Alter NRG?

    Alter NRG is a publicly traded (TSX: NRG; OTCQX: ANRGF) Canadian companyrovidin clean ener throu h asification

    Right Assets Industry-leading Westinghouse plasma gasification technologyLarge coal resource (40,000 bbls/d for 50 years)

    Right People

    Experienced management and technical team

    Track record of on-time, on-budget delivery

    Staged growth

    Right Plan

    Strategic partnerships with industry leadersNumerous growth opportunities technology and energy revenues

    Environmental concerns

    Right Time

    Our vision is to be a senior energy producer by becoming the worlds leading supplier

    ncreas ng ong- erm g o a eman or energySpecial financing and tax incentives for clean energy projects

    5

    of plasma gasification technology and developing environmentally sustainable and

    economically viable gasification projects

  • 7/29/2019 Coal to Liq Westinghouse Flint ApegAnl Presentn09

    6/46

    Target Markets

    Large size Strong economic returns

    Competitive advantage

    Waste-To-Energy (WTE)

    nv ronmen a a van age

    onvert ng waste nto c ean energy power an steam an or transportat on ue w e re uc ngharmful air emissions and the need for landfills.

    Power Plant Retrofi t

    Converting coal and biomass into clean syngas prior to combustion, to meet all environmental

    em ss ons s an ar s, an prov e eca es o a ona annu y ncome.Petroleum Coke

    Converting the energy rich by-product of upgrading (petroleum coke) to useable energy such aspower, or liquid fuels.

    6

    Coal-To-Liquids (CTL)

    Converting our large coal asset into high-value liquid fuels like diesel, and naphtha.

  • 7/29/2019 Coal to Liq Westinghouse Flint ApegAnl Presentn09

    7/46

    Gasification 101 continued

    2 2

    Carbon Monoxide & Hydrogen

    . building blocks to many-

    7

  • 7/29/2019 Coal to Liq Westinghouse Flint ApegAnl Presentn09

    8/46

    Gasification 101

    Liquids (e.g. diesel, naphtha)

    8

  • 7/29/2019 Coal to Liq Westinghouse Flint ApegAnl Presentn09

    9/46

    What is Plasma?

    Plasma is a highly ionized gas

    By controlling gas through the plasma torch and with the aid of a magneticfield, energy from the electric arc is transferred to the process gas

    9

  • 7/29/2019 Coal to Liq Westinghouse Flint ApegAnl Presentn09

    10/46

    What is Plasma Gasification?

    What are the advantages of plasma gasification?

    control provides:

    - Ability to gasi fy blended feedstocks includingwaste

    - High-quality syngas-- Better environmental performance

    Energy efficient Plasma Torches use 2% to 5% of the energy input Facili ty Exports 80% of the energy input to clean

    syngas

    Alter NRG owns Westinghouse Plasma Corp. -

    30 years and over $100 million of R&D throughWestinghouse

    Proprietary IP with 22 active patents worldwide Performed hundreds of pilot tests on numerous feedstocks

    10

    s tp p ot ac ty ocate n a son,PA

  • 7/29/2019 Coal to Liq Westinghouse Flint ApegAnl Presentn09

    11/46

    Plasma Technology Milestones

    Industry-leading Technology Worlds 1st Commercial-Scale Plasma Gasifier

    Mihama Mikata operational in 2002Plasma technology used since 1989 by GM, Alcan, etc.- over 500,000 hours of industrial use

    Worlds Largest Plasma Gasifier for WTEAdding Commercial Facilities

    11

    Utashinai operational in 2003Pune being commissioned in 2008-09

  • 7/29/2019 Coal to Liq Westinghouse Flint ApegAnl Presentn09

    12/46

    Our Competitive Advantage

    Our Value: Provide clean energy at low cost ($2 to $4 per MMBtu) from cheap andabundant feedstocks includin waste biomass coal and etroleum coke.

    Environmentally Responsible Plasma gasification can

    reduce CO , NOx, SOx & PM

    Commercially Proven

    Two facilities in commercialoperation for more thanfive years

    and other harmful emissions

    Somerset power plant retrofitwill be the largest renewableenergy project in Mass.

    Commercially operatingplasma torches for ~ 20 years

    Independent third-party tech

    reviews RW Beck, Hatch,AECOM, Juniper, Golder, etc.

    Project size $50 - $300 million

    reduced financingrequirements and quicker

    time to com letion

    Worlds only commercialplasma gasification WTEfacilities processing MSW

    Worlds lar est hazardous

    Multitude of feedstock inputs

    Variety of outputs: syngas,steam, baseload power &liquid fuels

    waste plasma gasificationfacility being commissioned

    World-class plasmagasification pilot facility

    12

    A Scalable & Flexible TechnologyIndustry-leading Technology

  • 7/29/2019 Coal to Liq Westinghouse Flint ApegAnl Presentn09

    13/46

    Fox Creek Coal to Liquids Project

    Location

    Other Western Canada Gasification-based Projects

    The Fox Creek Project Highlights and Economics

    The Environmental Challenges- Carbon Capture & Storage- Managing Water Demand

    13

  • 7/29/2019 Coal to Liq Westinghouse Flint ApegAnl Presentn09

    14/46

    CTL Value PropositionHow Fox Creek Got Started

    Capitalizing on the SpreadBetween Coal and Oil

    High Value Diesel & Naphtha

    Market Opportunity

    CTL via gasification commercial for more than 30 years

    addingvalue

    Value per tonne

    700

    800

    900

    1000

    Crude Oil (WTI)

    Natural Gas (Nymex)

    Coal Bi Sand Bar e

    AddingValue

    Netback over $70/ barrel ( US$80WTI) Enough low cost coal for40,000 bbls/d for 50 years

    Coal Resource Specifically Suited For Gasification 200300

    400

    500

    Close to major light oilfields forCO2 sequestration andto infrastructure, refineries and end markets

    Execution PlanSource: World Coal Institute

    0

    2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008

    since 2008

    Target operation by 2015 2016

    14

    1 tonne coal = 1.5 bbls diesel

  • 7/29/2019 Coal to Liq Westinghouse Flint ApegAnl Presentn09

    15/46

    Polygeneration Options

    Low value added / No local marketSyngas as Clean Fuelm e 2 cap ure po en a

    Synthetic Natural Gas Low value addedVery high CO2 yield vs. market

    owerCO2 capture more costly

    Hydrogen Good value on paper/ merchant market

    Good CO2 capture economics

    Liquid HC Fuels Highest value added outside of pet chemGood CO2 capture economics/EOR area

    Ethanol Under investigation

    15

  • 7/29/2019 Coal to Liq Westinghouse Flint ApegAnl Presentn09

    16/46

    Fox Creek Coal to Liquids Project

    Location of Coal Reserves

    Fox Creek

    Coal Resource

    Grande

    Prairie

    Fox Creek

    Coal Resource

    Grande

    Prairie

    Edmonton

    Calgary

    Edmonton

    Calgary

    56,000 acres

    850 mega-tonnes in place

    468 mega-tonnes resources

    close to existing road, rail &pipeline infrastructure

    close to future EOR sites forconventional oil & gas

    16

  • 7/29/2019 Coal to Liq Westinghouse Flint ApegAnl Presentn09

    17/46

    Other Projects in Western CanadaUsing Gasification

    ar ous o san s p an s heavy bitumen residues to hydrogen, CO2/CCS

    - Coal to hydrogen, CO2 / CCS

    (Belle Plaine, Sask.) Alberta / Sask Pet Coke to power, CO2 / CCS

    17

  • 7/29/2019 Coal to Liq Westinghouse Flint ApegAnl Presentn09

    18/46

    Fox Creek CTL Project Highlights

    Extract coal using established surface mining technology

    Produce diesel fuel and naphtha through gasification andconversion of synthesis gas ( syngas) to liquids

    Capture and store the majority of the CO2 (CCS)

    18

  • 7/29/2019 Coal to Liq Westinghouse Flint ApegAnl Presentn09

    19/46

    Addressing ImportantStrategic Goals for Alberta

    for Alberta Utilization of low rank coal resources in an environmentall

    responsible manner

    Conversion to clean, high-value energy, especially diesel fuel -

    Carbon capture and storage part of the plan

    Extension of conventional oil field life throu h enhanced oil

    recovery (EOR)

    New approaches to water management

    19

  • 7/29/2019 Coal to Liq Westinghouse Flint ApegAnl Presentn09

    20/46

    The Value Chain

    Extraction Transportation/Processing F-T Processing

    Cost to Mine & Process Coal = $43/tonne

    Revenue = $165/tonne

    CO2 Capture and Sale Naphtha

    Approximate Gross Margin =

    Sulphur Free Diesel (>70 cetane)

    20

    Note: Assumptions based on 2015 under the 20,000 bbl case, Cost to process coal include all operating costs and sustaining capital

    $122/tonne

  • 7/29/2019 Coal to Liq Westinghouse Flint ApegAnl Presentn09

    21/46

    Preliminary Project Economics

    Projected Leveraged Rates of Return Using Constant Pricing

    Assumptions: IRR is based on a constant pricing with constant expenses. Leverage is based 50%debt, 7% interest rate.

    21

  • 7/29/2019 Coal to Liq Westinghouse Flint ApegAnl Presentn09

    22/46

    Main Project Metrics

    UltimateInitial Phase

    ,

    Make Up water, t/day*

    ,

    5,000

    ,

    10,000 moredetailslater

    Products, b/dayDiesel

    Naphtha

    16,500

    3,500

    33,000

    7,000

    CO2 , t/daymmscfd

    11,500220

    23,000440

    detailslater

    owern erna

    gen.n erna

    gen.

    22

    a preliminary estimate of best in class performance for CTL plants

  • 7/29/2019 Coal to Liq Westinghouse Flint ApegAnl Presentn09

    23/46

    Surface Coal Mine

    Dragline mininginvolves a series of

    parallel open pits

    5-35 metre overburden

    As mining advances,

    overburden excavated

    is backfilled into thepreviously mined pit

    n ng tec n ques arerelatively conventional

    23

  • 7/29/2019 Coal to Liq Westinghouse Flint ApegAnl Presentn09

    24/46

    Coal Properties, Reserves & Cost

    FOX CREEK PROJECTASSAY OF RUN OF MINE COAL

    Component % Weight

    Carbon 41.59

    -place

    468 mega-tonnesresource at estimated

    y rogen .

    Oxygen 9.70

    Nitrogen 1.05

    $10/tonne cost

    One tonne will convert to

    1.5 barrels of l iquidSulphur 0.32

    Ash 25.00

    Moisture 20.00

    wil l support 40,000 b/dliquids for 50 years

    Total 100.00Heating Value,MJ/kg (btu/#)

    16.2 (6,950)

    24

  • 7/29/2019 Coal to Liq Westinghouse Flint ApegAnl Presentn09

    25/46

    Other Project Elements

    Coal Transportation, Preparation and Storage

    Coal is trucked to a storage area at the coal-to-liquids plant Coal is conditioned for gasification

    operations or land reclamation

    Coal-to-Liquids Plant Coal gasified to syngas mixture of hydrogen and carbon monoxide

    Syngas is processed to form a mixture of hydrocarbons, then

    Steam & Fuel gas by-products used to generate steam/power

    Co-product CO2 captured for EOR or other storage

    25

  • 7/29/2019 Coal to Liq Westinghouse Flint ApegAnl Presentn09

    26/46

    Coal to Liquids Plant

    only main streams shown

    AirAir

    SeparationUnit

    CO2

    to EORincl. all H2S

    Naphtha

    & Diesel

    process water

    Coal from

    Fox Creekmine

    Gasifier

    CO shift &

    Gas cooling

    rawsyngas

    Gas

    cleanup Productupgrading

    Hydrogen sepn.

    Fischer-Tropschs nthesis

    Slag to disposal

    fired heater

    wastesteam

    fuel gasquench water

    make upwater

    steam turbines

    power exportto grid

    internaluse

    FOX CREEKCOAL PROJECT

    LF J an 14,2008

    26

  • 7/29/2019 Coal to Liq Westinghouse Flint ApegAnl Presentn09

    27/46

    Where are we now?

    Partner Selection & Discussion

    Interested in those that bring technology or operating know-how

    Other investors are also being sought

    Commenced May 2008; one year

    2010: Environmental Assessment and Project application

    onsu a on

    Stakeholder Consultation plan in place and already underway

    Pre-Design Basis Work

    Short-listing gasification, gas cleanup and FT technologies Enter into appropriate NDA agreements

    Also use this period to confirm capital costs

    27

    Confirming CO2 and water plans also key

  • 7/29/2019 Coal to Liq Westinghouse Flint ApegAnl Presentn09

    28/46

    Market for Products

    Diesel

    Transportation fuels are increasingly in short supply across North America

    and diesel demand is growing Expected start-up diesel production (13,500 barrels per day) represents

    a ou o curren es ern ana a supp y

    Diesel product is a very high quality (>70 cetane) blending stock, that can be

    used to upgrade lower value stocks (e.g. oil sands products)

    Naphtha

    Used as a diluent to transport heavy crude oil in pipelines

    Diluent is in short su l in Alberta and demand is rowin

    Carbon Dioxide

    Gasification captures 85% of plant CO2 in form suitable for nearby EOR

    28

    t er storage opt ons or a ance o pro uct on vs. eman

  • 7/29/2019 Coal to Liq Westinghouse Flint ApegAnl Presentn09

    29/46

    Project Schedule

    2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013

    Preliminary Disclosure (complete)

    2014 2015

    Terms Of Reference

    Baseline Environmental Work

    EIA / Project ApplicationMinesCoal to Liquids Plant

    Regulatory Process Review

    Approvals issued

    Key Technology/Licensor Review

    Engineering, Construction & Startup

    MinesCoal to Liquids Plant

    29

  • 7/29/2019 Coal to Liq Westinghouse Flint ApegAnl Presentn09

    30/46

    Environmental Opportunities

    Optimizing Water Supply & Net Use

    30

  • 7/29/2019 Coal to Liq Westinghouse Flint ApegAnl Presentn09

    31/46

    31

  • 7/29/2019 Coal to Liq Westinghouse Flint ApegAnl Presentn09

    32/46

    Carbon Dioxide Emissions

    Comparing various sources - kg CO2 / m3 transportation fuelCO only. Other CO E not included except for LNG

    kg/m340 APIcrude 20 APIcrude

    Coker based refinery

    Bitumen RecoveryUpgrading and Refining

    low high

    CTL

    6,000

    5,000 Dilute CO2

    Captureready CO2

    4,000

    LNG

    3,000 ProductionRefiningBy-Products

    32

    , End use

    Sources: T.J.McCann & Associates, LENEF Consulting, NETL, SAE/Argonne Lab - Figures do not include other GHG gases

  • 7/29/2019 Coal to Liq Westinghouse Flint ApegAnl Presentn09

    33/46

  • 7/29/2019 Coal to Liq Westinghouse Flint ApegAnl Presentn09

    34/46

    Carbon Capture & Sequestration

    capacity, Mega-tonnes CO2

    Coal Bed

    Methane

    gas & oilpools

    9,00015,000

    10,000

    2,000 EOR

    aquifers

    sto rage @ 100 M-t/year = 360 years top 240 oil pools

    capacity, Mega-tonne CO2

    2,580

    Source: CERI / T.J.McCann & Associates

    top 350 gas pools

    ,

    cost to sequester

    $

    /tonne

    100

    50

    34

    Source: CERI 0 50 100 M-t/year

  • 7/29/2019 Coal to Liq Westinghouse Flint ApegAnl Presentn09

    35/46

    Sequestration Options Considered

    EOR market 2012 estimated

    at 27,000 t/day for ~20 years

    ,but need alternatives tocover for EOR demandvariations

    eep sa ne aqu ers

    depleted gas reservoirs

    35

    C i F C k d

  • 7/29/2019 Coal to Liq Westinghouse Flint ApegAnl Presentn09

    36/46

    Comparing Fox Creek andDakota - Weyburn

    Make no mistake about i tthe CCS and oil contribution aspects

    Compare with the well known Dakota Gas Plant (ND) - Weyburn (Sask)heavy oil field link

    Coal mined, t/day 18,000 (lignite) 13,500 (sub-bit)

    Dakota - Weyburn Fox Creek - Local Fields

    e y startup

    Liquids Produced, b/day 28,000 (NG-boe) 20,000

    ,

    EOR potential, mmboil 130 550years 10-15 25-30

    36

    CO2 sequestered, Mega-t/year 1.8 4

  • 7/29/2019 Coal to Liq Westinghouse Flint ApegAnl Presentn09

    37/46

    The Water Challenge

    Carbon Capture & Sequestration

    Optimizing Water Supply & Net Use

    37

  • 7/29/2019 Coal to Liq Westinghouse Flint ApegAnl Presentn09

    38/46

    The Water Challenge

    recall this map

    from a

    38

  • 7/29/2019 Coal to Liq Westinghouse Flint ApegAnl Presentn09

    39/46

    Main Factors Driving Water Policy

    A Key Environmental Consideration in Alberta .

    Reliable source of water for process is required, but river 30 miles

    distance/$100 million plus environmental approval headacheswe do not need

    s s e us ness an nanc a ncen ve o ge crea ve

    Optimize water conservation

    maximum recycle & reuse - zero river water critical review of demand vs. acceptable quality maximize air cooling; water for trim control only

    For make up: potential sources of groundwater and surface waterarebeing investigated from mine operations; also investigating use ofbrackish/saline sources

    In shortriver water is a last resort!

    39

    Water management under investigationbut here is a work-in-progress plan!

  • 7/29/2019 Coal to Liq Westinghouse Flint ApegAnl Presentn09

    40/46

    Water Demand Schematic

    Boiler Feed Water180BFW make up 910

    Water flows tonne/day or cubic metre/day

    for 20,000 b/day case

    Gasifier-Shift-Rx

    CO2 recovery

    Amine 320

    Steam (240)Quench Twr 380blowdown 410 HRSG

    blowdown

    deaerator

    Shift-FT

    ma e up

    Quench Twr 380

    make up

    Trim Water Coolin 200

    CW

    Compressor 140

    scrubber drains

    brine

    Slag CoolingQuench 3650

    1970

    Cooler 1080

    200

    ?

    issue: keeping it cool

    Waterin slag Waste Water

    Collection-Treatment

    600

    ow own

    2002080

    40

    1880treated water return

    Mine & Surface Water

    Brackish/Saline Watermake up

  • 7/29/2019 Coal to Liq Westinghouse Flint ApegAnl Presentn09

    41/46

    Analyzing Water Balance Further

    Water flows tonne/day or cubic metre/day

    for 20 000 b/da case

    Real Net Losses

    c ua a e p ows

    Rx Section 700Slag Cooling 3650

    Gasifer-FT-Rx (net) 350Slag Cooling 2570

    BFW Deaerator 180

    a e pCW Make Up 200

    5460

    Brine 80Trim Cooling/W-W 400

    3580

    Sources

    Recycled 1880

    Mine & Surface * 2000Brackish/Saline ** 15805460

    41

    * Not yet confirmed ** Supply virtually unlimitedno contingency included!

    S

  • 7/29/2019 Coal to Liq Westinghouse Flint ApegAnl Presentn09

    42/46

    Matching Needs to Sources

    Water flows tonne/day or cubic metre/day for 20,000 b/day case

    Slag Cooling 3650 Brackish/Saline Water (1580)

    + Plant Recycle and/or Mine water (2100)How much treatment needed ?

    o ow own s reams nee any rea men

    Reactor Section(non steam)

    700 Use balance of Recycle stream (850)

    Exact source will depend on treatment needed

    BFW Make Up 910 Plant Recycle and/or Mine waterExact source will depend on treatment needed

    Cooling WaterMake Up 200 Plant Recycle and/or Mine waterExact source will depend on treatment needed

    42

    we need to get creative and no cooling towers!

  • 7/29/2019 Coal to Liq Westinghouse Flint ApegAnl Presentn09

    43/46

    do we have a water back up plan?

    Id kind of hoped

    be further down the

    list than Plan B !

    43

  • 7/29/2019 Coal to Liq Westinghouse Flint ApegAnl Presentn09

    44/46

    Summary

    An important future-oriented coal opportunity for Alberta

    Key Minister approvals-in-principle: April, 2008

    Consistent with some important Alberta government drivers onAlberta CO2 policy & maximized value added in Alberta

    ,

    Public Disclosure & Proposed Terms of Reference issued:June-October, 2008

    Mine & CTL shows sound economics (>20% ROE)

    Opportunity for project enhancements/redirection with partners

    44

    S

  • 7/29/2019 Coal to Liq Westinghouse Flint ApegAnl Presentn09

    45/46

    Summary

    The environmental challenges in CO2 and water are ont e ront urner or ot t e government an s

    85% of the project CO2 emissions will be captured andseques ere

    We are getting creative to avoid water draw from rivers

    45

  • 7/29/2019 Coal to Liq Westinghouse Flint ApegAnl Presentn09

    46/46

    thank you!

    46