Clicker quesons for discussion in CIRTL€¦ · Clicker quesons for discussion in CIRTL ... Eric...

17
Clicker ques,ons for discussion in CIRTL 1. Using images 2. Conceptual examples based on student difficul,es 3. Surveys 4. Reasoning behind the answer is what we’re looking for

Transcript of Clicker quesons for discussion in CIRTL€¦ · Clicker quesons for discussion in CIRTL ... Eric...

Page 1: Clicker quesons for discussion in CIRTL€¦ · Clicker quesons for discussion in CIRTL ... Eric Mazur, “Peer ... Kate Dollard, Northampton HS (based on a queson by Chevy Seney

Clickerques,onsfordiscussioninCIRTL

1.  Usingimages2.  Conceptualexamplesbasedon

studentdifficul,es3.  Surveys

4.  Reasoningbehindtheansweriswhatwe’relookingfor

Page 2: Clicker quesons for discussion in CIRTL€¦ · Clicker quesons for discussion in CIRTL ... Eric Mazur, “Peer ... Kate Dollard, Northampton HS (based on a queson by Chevy Seney

Group1

Whatisacommonorunifyingthemeinthissetofques,ons?(YoumaylistmorethanonebutIhavejustoneinmind)

Page 3: Clicker quesons for discussion in CIRTL€¦ · Clicker quesons for discussion in CIRTL ... Eric Mazur, “Peer ... Kate Dollard, Northampton HS (based on a queson by Chevy Seney

3

YoulooktotheeasternhorizonastheMoonisrisinganddiscoverthatitisinthenewmoonphase.LaterthatsamedaywhenthemoonisseRng,whichofthemoonphasesshownbelowwouldtheMoonhavelookedlike?

CenterforAstronomyEduca,on,EdPrather

Page 4: Clicker quesons for discussion in CIRTL€¦ · Clicker quesons for discussion in CIRTL ... Eric Mazur, “Peer ... Kate Dollard, Northampton HS (based on a queson by Chevy Seney

4

The pie graph shows the energy of the Skater, where could she be on the track?

Consider…1.  Mechanics2.  Depth3.  Goals

A

B

CD

E PE

KE

KathyPerkins,CUBoulder

Page 5: Clicker quesons for discussion in CIRTL€¦ · Clicker quesons for discussion in CIRTL ... Eric Mazur, “Peer ... Kate Dollard, Northampton HS (based on a queson by Chevy Seney

5BillGerace,UMassAmherst

Thediagramsbelowshowtwouniformlychargedspheres.Thechargeontherightsphereis3,mesaslargeasthechargeonthele[sphere.Whichforcediagrambestrepresentsthemagnitudesanddirec,onsoftheelectricforcesonthetwospheres?

A. D.

B. E.

C.

Page 6: Clicker quesons for discussion in CIRTL€¦ · Clicker quesons for discussion in CIRTL ... Eric Mazur, “Peer ... Kate Dollard, Northampton HS (based on a queson by Chevy Seney

Group2

Whatisacommonorunifyingthemeinthissetofques,ons?(YoumaylistmorethanonebutIhavejustoneinmind)

Page 7: Clicker quesons for discussion in CIRTL€¦ · Clicker quesons for discussion in CIRTL ... Eric Mazur, “Peer ... Kate Dollard, Northampton HS (based on a queson by Chevy Seney

Showstudentsademonstra/onthatalightbulbwilllightwhenacurrentisrunthroughaweakacidsolu/on.Iftheacidsolu,onisincreasedto100%strength,whatwillhappentothebrightnessofthelightbulb?

A.  BrighterB.  DimmerC.  CompletelydarkD.  Don’tknow

Originunknown 7

Page 8: Clicker quesons for discussion in CIRTL€¦ · Clicker quesons for discussion in CIRTL ... Eric Mazur, “Peer ... Kate Dollard, Northampton HS (based on a queson by Chevy Seney

8

Asmallacornover,mecangrowintoahugeoaktree.Thetreecanweighmanytons.Wheredoesmostofthemasscomefromasthetreegrows?

A) MineralsinthesoilB) Organicma`erinthesoilC) GasesintheairD) Sunlight

APrivateUniverse;AnnenbergMedia

Page 9: Clicker quesons for discussion in CIRTL€¦ · Clicker quesons for discussion in CIRTL ... Eric Mazur, “Peer ... Kate Dollard, Northampton HS (based on a queson by Chevy Seney

9

You’re on a cart, initially at rest, throwing balls at a partition that is rigidly mounted on the front of the cart. If the balls bounce straight back, as in the figure, then is the cart put in motion?

A.  Yes, left B.  Yes, right C.  No D.  Don’t know

EricMazur,“PeerInstruc,on”

Page 10: Clicker quesons for discussion in CIRTL€¦ · Clicker quesons for discussion in CIRTL ... Eric Mazur, “Peer ... Kate Dollard, Northampton HS (based on a queson by Chevy Seney

Group3

Whatisacommonorunifyingthemeinthissetofques,ons?(YoumaylistmorethanonebutIhavejustoneinmind)

Page 11: Clicker quesons for discussion in CIRTL€¦ · Clicker quesons for discussion in CIRTL ... Eric Mazur, “Peer ... Kate Dollard, Northampton HS (based on a queson by Chevy Seney

11

Ifyouwerewalkingdownaroadandpassedapieceoftrash,wouldyoupickitup?

A.  YesB.  NoC.  Itdepends

vaguelyrecollectedfromaques,ondescribedbyKateDollard,NorthamptonHS

Page 12: Clicker quesons for discussion in CIRTL€¦ · Clicker quesons for discussion in CIRTL ... Eric Mazur, “Peer ... Kate Dollard, Northampton HS (based on a queson by Chevy Seney

Whichofthefollowingareyouleastcomfortableusingtosolveproblems?

A.  Kinema,csB.  Newton’sLawsC.  Work‐EnergyTheorem

D.  Momentum‐ImpulseTheorem

E.  AngularMomentum‐AngularImpulseTheorem

12IanBea`y,UMassAmherst

Page 13: Clicker quesons for discussion in CIRTL€¦ · Clicker quesons for discussion in CIRTL ... Eric Mazur, “Peer ... Kate Dollard, Northampton HS (based on a queson by Chevy Seney

Oneofyouwillberandomlyselectedtobeawinner!Pickone:

A.  Youcanreceive$1.00(cash)rightnowB.  Youcanreceive$1.05(cash)duringthenext

mee,ngofthisclass

13FromDrJamesIIIath`p://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CnnP0uCqD4k

Results:66%ofclasstook$1now(but33%if$1onnexttolastdayofclass

insteadoflastdayofclass)

Page 14: Clicker quesons for discussion in CIRTL€¦ · Clicker quesons for discussion in CIRTL ... Eric Mazur, “Peer ... Kate Dollard, Northampton HS (based on a queson by Chevy Seney

Group4

Whatisacommonorunifyingthemeinthissetofques,ons?(YoumaylistmorethanonebutIhavejustoneinmind)

Thisoneisabittrickier.Hint:Whatdotheanswerchoiceshaveincommon?Whatdotheyrequirestudentstodo?

Page 15: Clicker quesons for discussion in CIRTL€¦ · Clicker quesons for discussion in CIRTL ... Eric Mazur, “Peer ... Kate Dollard, Northampton HS (based on a queson by Chevy Seney

15KateDollard,NorthamptonHS(basedonaques,onbyChevySeneyofFron,erRegionalSchool)

Ifyoucouldhaveonlyonesystemle[,whichwoulditbe?

1.  Circulatory2. Nervous3.  Endocrine4.  Immune5. Diges,ve6.  Respiratory7.  Excretory8. Muscle/Skeletal

Page 16: Clicker quesons for discussion in CIRTL€¦ · Clicker quesons for discussion in CIRTL ... Eric Mazur, “Peer ... Kate Dollard, Northampton HS (based on a queson by Chevy Seney

16CathyWanat,NorthamptonHighSchool

Pickthetwogroupsthatwouldhavethebiggesteffectonwaterqualityina

watershed.

Page 17: Clicker quesons for discussion in CIRTL€¦ · Clicker quesons for discussion in CIRTL ... Eric Mazur, “Peer ... Kate Dollard, Northampton HS (based on a queson by Chevy Seney

CathyWanat,NorthamptonHighSchool

Inthisfoodchain,wouldyouexpecttohavemoreowlsormorefrogsandwhy?